AB 2578: Nursing: students in out-of-state nursing programs.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-24
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Nursing Practice Act, establishes the Board of Registered Nursing to license and regulate the practice of nursing. The act prohibits a person from engaging in the practice of nursing without an active license but authorizes a student to render nursing services incidental to the students course of study, as specified.
This bill would additionally authorize a student to render nursing services if the student is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution, as defined, for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting that meets certain criteria, including that the program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education and that the program maintains minimum faculty to student faculty-to-student ratios required of board-approved programs for in-person clinical experiences. The bill would require the student to be supervised in person by a registered nurse licensed by the board while rendering nursing services. The services, as specified, and would require payment to the board of a one-time fee of $100 per student placed in clinical experience in this state.
This bill would prohibit a clinical agency or facility from offering nonacute clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of in-state students enrolled in a board-approved nursing program. The bill would require the program to provide initial and subsequent reports to the board, as specified. The bill would require the initial reports to include, among other things, proof of programmatic accreditation and good standing, with an attestation under penalty of perjury that the program will notify the board within 10 days of any changes in status. By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Nursing Practice Act, establishes the Board of Registered Nursing to license and regulate the practice of nursing. The act prohibits a person from engaging in the practice of nursing without an active license but authorizes a student to render nursing services incidental to the students course of study, as specified.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to those provisions. additionally authorize a student to render nursing services if the student is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution, as defined, for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting that meets certain criteria, including that the program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education and that the program maintains minimum faculty to student ratios required of board-approved programs for in-person clinical experiences. The bill would require the student to be supervised in person by a registered nurse licensed by the board while rendering nursing services. The bill would prohibit a clinical agency or facility from offering clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of in-state students enrolled in a board-approved nursing program.
Existing law, the Nursing Practice Act, establishes the Board of Registered Nursing to license and regulate the practice of nursing. The act prohibits a person from engaging in the practice of nursing without an active license but authorizes a student to render nursing services incidental to the course of study, as specified.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to those provisions.
A student may render nursing services if those services are incidental to the course of study of one of the following:
(a)A student enrolled in a board-approved prelicensure program or school of nursing.
(b)A nurse licensed in another state or country taking a board-approved continuing education course or a postlicensure course.
(c)(1)A student who is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting that meets all of the following criteria:
(A)The program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education.
(B)The board does not otherwise approve the program.
(C)(i)The student placement does not impact any students already assigned to the agency or facility.
(ii)The program shall provide, upon request by the board, a current list of all upcoming California facility clinical placements for students.
(D)The program shall utilize clinical placements only in nonacute care facilities.
(D)(E)The program does not make payments to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical experience placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing.
(E)(F)The program qualifies graduates for licensure under this chapter. chapter, pursuant to board curriculum requirements.
(F)(G)The program maintains minimum faculty to student faculty-to-student ratios required of board-approved programs for in-person clinical experiences.
(G)(H)The program pays a one-time fee of one hundred dollars ($100) to the board for each student under this subdivision who participates in clinical experience placements in the state.
(I)The program meets all applicable Bureau of Private Postsecondary Education regulatory requirements.
(J)The programs California instructors meet the same faculty requirements as required by the board for in-state schools.
(2)A student described by this subdivision shall be supervised in person by a registered nurse licensed by the board pursuant to this chapter while rendering nursing services. services, who shall ensure compliance with this chapter.
(3)A clinical agency or facility shall not offer clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a board-approved nursing program.
(4)The program shall provide initial and subsequent annual reports to the board.
(A)The initial report, which shall be submitted before initial clinical placements occur, shall include all of the following:
(i)Proof of programmatic accreditation with an attestation under penalty of perjury that the program will notify the board within 10 days of any changes in accreditation status.
(ii)Proof that the program is in good standing with its home-state nursing regulatory body with an attestation under penalty of perjury that the program will notify the board within 10 days of any changes in status.
(iii)A schedule of planned clinical placements at California health care facilities for the current year, with accompanying payment of fees, that includes locations, dates, hours, and number of students.
(iv)A list of California clinical instructors who meet the board requirements for in-state school instructors, detailing instructor names and California RN license numbers.
(B)The annual report, which shall be submitted to the board by January 31 of each subsequent year, shall include all of the following:
(i)A clinical placement report detailing the locations, dates, and number of students placed at California health care facilities during the previous calendar year.
(ii)A schedule of planned clinical placements detailing the locations, dates, hours, and number of students scheduled at California health care facilities for the current calendar year.
(iii)Accounting and reconciliation of the fee owed to the board for newly placed students for the previous year, and payment for the newly placed students planned for the current year.
(iv)A list of California clinical instructors who meet the board requirements for in-state school instructors, detailing instructor names and California RN license numbers.
(4)(5)For purposes of this subdivision, out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution has the same meaning as defined in Section 94850.5 of the Education Code.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
A student may render nursing services if those services are incidental to the course of study of one of the following:
(a)A student enrolled in a board-approved prelicensure program or school of nursing.
(b)A nurse licensed in another state or country taking a board-approved continuing education course or a postlicensure course.
(c)(1)A student who is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting that meets all of the following criteria:
(A)The program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education.
(B)The board does not otherwise approve the program.
(C)The student placement does not impact any students already assigned to the agency or facility.
(D)The program does not make payments to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical experience placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing.
(E)The program qualifies graduates for licensure under this chapter.
(F)The program maintains minimum faculty to student ratios required of board-approved programs for in-person clinical experiences.
(G)The program pays a one-time fee of one hundred dollars ($100) to the board for each student under this subdivision who participates in clinical experience placements in the state.
(2)A student described by this subdivision shall be supervised in person by a registered nurse licensed by the board pursuant to this chapter while rendering nursing services.
(3)A clinical agency or facility shall not offer clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a board-approved nursing program.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution has the same meaning as defined in Section 94850.5 of the Education Code.
Nursing services may be rendered by a student when these A student may render nursing services if those services are incidental to the course of study of one of the following:
(a)A student enrolled in a board-approved prelicensure program or school of nursing.
(b)A nurse licensed in another state or country taking a board-approved continuing education course or a postlicensure course.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 1.) (July 1). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E. D. |
| Jun 17, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E. D. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 71. Noes 0. Page 5490.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 1, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (April 16). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2024 | AB 2578 Flora Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Board of Registered Nursing | ** Against | |
| California Association of Colleges of Nursing | ** Against | |
| California Baptist University College of Nursing | ** Against | |
| California Kidney Care Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Against | |
| California Nurses Association | ** Against | |
| California Organization of Associate Degree Nursing Programs | ** Against | |
| Fresenius Medical Care North America | ** Support | |
| GENERATIONS HEALTHCARE | ** Support | |
| Nightingale Education Group | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2578 (Flora) - Nursing: students in out-of-state nursing programs
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 2578 authorizes a student who is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to provide supervised nursing services that are incidental to the course of study for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting if specified criteria are met.
Fiscal Impact:
The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) reports:
- Ongoing annual costs of approximately $745,000 for additional administrative workload. The BRN notes that up to 50 nursing programs across the country and 3,000 additional students may qualify under this bill. The actual number of students and nursing programs will depend on the interest to participate and ability to meet BRN licensure requirements.
- Ongoing annual costs of approximately $431,000 to review prelicensure distance education curriculums.
- Potential revenue increase of $300,000, based on BRN’s estimate of an additional 3,000 students. This bill establishes a fee of $100 for each student who participates in clinical experience placements in the state, to be paid by the out-of-state program. Fee revenue may offset BRN’s additional administrative costs to some extent.
- One-time IT cost of $13,000 to the Office of Information Services, which is anticipated to be absorbed through the redirection of maintenance resources.
Background:
The BRN regulates nurse-licensees in California and is responsible for setting the educational standards for nursing programs, approving new and expanding programs, approving continuing education providers, evaluating and licensing applicants, administering discipline, managing an intervention program for licensees with substance use disorders or mental illness, and providing stakeholder information and outreach. The BRN is a special fund agency that obtains its revenues from licensing, renewal and other fees.
With respect to nursing programs, the BRN has authority to review and approve both new programs in California and oversee enrollment increases and other programmatic changes for existing programs. In general, the BRN’s current school approval process requires institutions seeking approval for a nursing program to first submit a letter of intent with minor details about the name, contact, type, location, and then start date. Next, the proposed program submits a feasibility study, which is a detailed proposal that outlines most aspects of the proposed program, including a description of the overall institution, including history, accreditation status, and other programs. It also includes geographic area, description of program type, information on the applicant pool, description of the subject matter and support areas, including faculty and facilities, budget projections, and availability of clinical placements. Currently, the BRN does not play a role in finding or securing clinical placement slots for any institution. Rather, BRN reviews whether there is sufficient availability as reported by the institution. There are approxinmately159 board-approved nursing programs in California.
The issue of clinical placements for all nursing students remain a constant area of concern for many stakeholders. The lack of clinical facility resources for educational providers affects not only new programs seeking BRN-approval, but also programs that seek to expand and students in those programs who lose their clinical placements when a clinical facility no longer offers clinical space. The availability of student placements for clinical experiences is based on clinical facilities, such as hospitals or clinics willing and able to accommodate, accept, and teach students. While there are no mandatory requirements that any healthcare facility accept students, many willingly accept students because it is necessary for the workforce and can help with recruitment. The facilities must have staff who are qualified to teach and supervise students, and often develop contracts with partner educational programs to outline responsibilities, liability, and expectations. As a result, clinical placements are often difficult to find.
Currently, the BRN is required to review and collect some data about clinical placements. Annually the BRN collects, analyzes and reports information related to the number of clinical placement slots that are available and the location of those clinical placement slots within the state, including but not limited to information concerning the total number of placement slots a clinical facility can accommodate and how many slots the programs will need. The BRN has little to no direct control over the actual availability of placements.
Proposed Law:
- Authorizes a student who is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to provide nursing services that are incidental to the course of study for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting if all of the following criteria are met:
- The program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education.
- The BRN does not otherwise approve the program.
- The student placement does not impact any students already assigned to the agency or facility.
- The program provides, upon request by the BRN, a current list of all upcoming California facility clinical placements for students.
- The program only utilizes clinical placements in nonacute care facilities.
- The program does not make payments to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing.
- The program qualifies graduates for licensure under the California Nursing Practice Act, pursuant to BRN curriculum requirements.
- The program maintains minimum faculty-to-student ratios required of BRN-approved programs for in-person clinical experience.
- The program pays a one-time fee of $100 to the BRN for each student who participates in clinical experience placements in this state.
- The program meets all applicable Bureau for Private Postsecondary (BPPE) regulatory requirements.
- The program’s California instructors meet the same faculty requirements as required by the BRN for in-state schools.
- Requires a student qualified to render nursing services pursuant to the above criteria to be supervised in-person, by a California-licensed RN.
- Prohibits a clinical agency or facility from offering clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a BRN-approved nursing program.
- Requires a program to provide initial and subsequent annual reports to the BRN.
- Requires the initial report to be submitted before initial clinical placements occur to include specified information.
- Requires the annual report to be submitted to the BRN by January 1, annually and include other specified information.
- Defines for purposes of this bill, “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California.
- Makes other technical and clarifying changes.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Angelique Ashby, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: July 1, 2024
Author: | |||
Version: | June 24, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Elissa Silva | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Allows a nursing student enrolled in an out-of-state nursing program to obtain clinical experience in California, if specified conditions are met, limits the type of health care facilities where the student may obtain clinical experience, and requires out-of-state nursing programs to provide initial and annual reports to the BRN.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) to license and regulate registered nurses (RN) and advance practice registered nurses (APRN) and approval of nursing education programs. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2701)
- Defines “an approved school of nursing” or “an approved nursing program” as one that has been approved by the BRN, gives the course of instruction approved by the BRN, covering not fewer than two academic years, is affiliated or conducted in connection with one or more hospitals, and is an institution of higher education which includes but is not limited to, community colleges offering an associate of arts or associate of science degree, baccalaureate degree, or an entry level master’s degree, and is an institution that is not subject to specified provisions of the California Private Postsecondary Education Act, as specified. (BPC § 2786(a)(1))
- Requires an approved school or nursing or nursing program to meet a minimum of 500 direct patient care clinical hours in a BRN-approved clinical setting with a minimum of 30 hours of supervised direct patient, care clinical hours dedicated to each nursing area specified by the BRN. (BPC § 2786(a)(2))
- Requires the BRN to determine by regulation the subjects of instruction to be completed in an approved school of nursing for licensure as a registered nurse (RN) and must include the minimum units of theory and clinical experience and necessary to achieve essential clinical competency at the entry level of the RN. (BPC § 2786(c)(1))
- Restricts the BRN, when considering a request from an approved school of nursing program, which is actively accredited by an institution or programmatic accreditor, to increase enrollment, to consider only the following factors related to the ability to adequately train additional students:
- Adequacy of resources, including but not limited to faculty, facilities, equipment, and supplies;
- Availability of clinical placements;
- Complaints that have been verified by the BRN from students, faculty, or other interested parties;
- Licensing examination pass rates, graduation rates, and retention rates; and
- Any other similar factors specified by the BRN in regulations, except for workforce issues, as specified. (BPC § 2786.2(b)(1)(F))
- Requires the BRN to annually collect, analyze and report information related to the number of clinical placement slots that are available and the location of those clinical placement slots within the state, including but not limited to information concerning the total number of placement slots a clinical facility can accommodate and how many slots the programs that use the facility will need. (BPC § 2786(c)(3)(A))
- Defines “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California. (Education Code (EDC) § 94850.5)
This bill:
- Permits a student who is a resident of the state and enrolled in a prelicensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution for the purpose of gaining clinical experience in a clinical setting that meets all of the following criteria:
- The program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education;
- The board does not otherwise approve the program;
- The student placement does not impact any students already assigned to the agency or facility;
- The program provides, upon request by the BRN, a current list of all upcoming California facility clinical placements for students;
- The program only utilizes clinical placements in nonacute care facilities;
- The program does not make payments to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing;
- The program qualifies graduates for licensure under the California Nursing Practice Act, pursuant to BRN curriculum requirements;
- The program maintains minimum faculty to student rations required of BRN-approved programs for in-person clinical experience;
- The program pays a one-time fee of $100 to the BRN for each student who participates in the clinical experience placement in this state;
- The program meets all applicable Bureau for Private Postsecondary (BPPE) regulatory requirements; and,
- The program’s California instructors meet the same faculty requirements as required by the BRN for in-state schools.
- Requires the student in 1) above to be supervised in-person, by a CA-licensed RN.
- Prohibits a clinical agency or facility from offering clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a BRN-approved nursing program.
- Defines for purposes of this bill, “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California.
- Requires a program to provide initial and subsequent annual reports to the BRN, as specified.
- Requires the initial report in 5) above to be submitted before initial clinical placements occur to include the following:
- Proof of programmatic accreditation with an attestation under penalty of perjury that the program will notify the BRN with 10 days of any changes in accreditation status;
- Proof that the program is in good standing with its home state nursing regulatory body with an attestation under penalty of perjury that the program will notify the BRN within 10 days of any changes in status;
- A schedule of planned clinical placements at California health care facilities for the current year, with accompanying payment of fees, that includes locations, dates, hours, and number of students; and,
- A list of California clinical instructors who meet the BRN requirements for in-state school instructors, detailing instructor names and California RN license numbers.
- Requires the annual report in 5) above to be submitted to the BRN by January 1, annually and include the following;
- A clinical placement report detailing the locatio0ns, dates, and number of students scheduled at California health care facilities for the current calendar year;
- Accounting and reconciliation of the fee owned to the BRN for newly placed students for the previous year, and payment for the newly placed students planned for the current year; and,
- A list of California clinical instructors who meet the BRN requirements for in-state school instructors, detailing instructor names and California RN license numbers.
- Makes other technical and clarifying changes.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations BRN estimates increased workload at a cost of $431,000 ongoing. BRN states it would need to review curriculum to ensure each school meets licensure requirements and estimates there could be up to up to 50 nursing programs across the country that could utilize this new process, and 3,000 additional students in California. BRN would also need to provide technical assistance for students, schools, and hospitals utilizing the new process. The Department of Consumer Affairs’ Office of Information Services estimates absorbable costs of $5,000 for new fee codes and to update enforcement codes in its electronic licensing system.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. Nightingale College is the sponsor of this bill. According to the author, “Current California statutes do not allow California residents enrolled in non-California Board of Registered Nursing (BRN)-approved out-of-state distance nursing education programs to participate in on-ground clinical rotations in the state. The regulatory authority for nursing education is granted to the California Board of Registered Nursing (BRN). Existing law allows nursing students to provide nursing services related to their course of study but only if they are enrolled in a BRN approved program that is located in the State. The BRN does not have the authority to authorize a program approve by a board of nursing in another state to host clinical rotations in the state.
Current law in California does not allow for these students to conduct on the ground clinical rotations in California, forcing students to move each semester away from their job, home and family in California, and find another State and facility to finish their degree.”
- Background.
Board of Registered Nursing. The BRN regulates nurse-licensees in California and is responsible for setting the educational standards for nursing programs, approving new and expanding programs, approving continuing education providers, evaluating and licensing applicants, administering discipline, managing an intervention program for licensees with substance use disorders or mental illness, and providing stakeholder information and outreach. The BRN is a special fund agency that obtains its revenues from licensing, renewal and other fees. With respect to nursing programs, the BRN has authority to review and approve both new programs in California and oversees enrollment increases and other programmatic changes for existing programs. SB 122 (Price, Chapter 789, Statutes of 2012) provided the BRN with oversight and approval of nursing education programs in California and permitted the BRN to charge a fee for nursing program approval. Currently, an application for school approval is $40,000. In addition to the BRN education program approval, a private postsecondary school or program must obtain approval from the Bureau of Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) if it is not accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC) or by a regional accreditor. An out-of-state academic institution providing education to students in California is required to register with the BPPE. This bill would specify in the Nurse Practice Act, that any out-of-state nursing program must meet the regulatory requirements of the BPPE in order for those students to obtain clinical experience in California.
BRN School Approval Process. In general, the BRN’s current process requires institutions seeking approval for a nursing program to first submit a letter of intent with minor details about the name, contact, type, location, and then start date. Next, the proposed program submits a feasibility study, which is a detailed proposal that outlines most aspects of the proposed program, including a description of the overall institution, including history, accreditation status, and other programs. It also includes geographic area, description of program type, information on the applicant pool, description of the subject matter and support areas, including faculty and facilities, budget projections, and availability of clinical placements. Currently, the BRN does not a play role in finding or securing clinical placement slots for any institution, just reviews whether there is sufficient availability as reported by the institution. There are approxinmately159 board-approved nursing programs in California.
Clinical Placements. Nursing programs approved by the BRN must comply with current BRN regulations, which require the program to maintain written objectives for student learning in such facilities and assign students only to facilities that can provide the experience necessary to meet those objectives. Each program must maintain written agreements with facilities that include the following:
- Assurance of the availability and appropriateness of the learning environment in relation to the program's written objectives;
- Provision for orientation of faculty and students;
- A specification of the responsibilities and authority of the facility's staff as related to the program and to the educational experience of the students;
- Assurance that staff is adequate in number and quality to ensure safe and continuous health care services to patients;
- Provisions for continuing communication between the facility and the program; and
- A description of the responsibilities of faculty assigned to the facility utilized by the program.
Additionally, current regulations require when selecting a new clinical agency or facility for student placement, the nursing program must take into consideration the impact that an additional group of students would have on students of other nursing programs already assigned to the agency or facility.
The issue of clinical placements for all nursing students remain a constant area of concern for many stakeholders. The lack of clinical facility resources for educational providers affects not only new programs seeking BRN-approval, but also programs that seek to expand and students in those programs who lose their clinical placements when a clinical facility no longer offers clinical space. The availability of student placements for clinical experiences is based on clinical facilities, such as hospitals or clinics that are willing to accept and teach students and their ability to accommodate students. While there are no mandatory requirements that any healthcare facility accept students, many willingly accept students because it is necessary for the workforce and can help with recruitment. The facilities must have staff who are qualified to teach and supervise students, and often develop contracts with partner educational programs to outline responsibilities, liability, and expectations. As a result, clinical placements are often difficult to find. The lack of clinical placement availability was elevated during the COVID-19 pandemic when clinical facilities closed their doors to students and faculty for a variety of reasons, including staff and patient safety and resource challenges. Although the pandemic has waned, the need for clinical space in healthcare facilities remains.
Currently, the BRN is required to review and collect some data about clinical placements. Annually the BRN collects, analyzes and reports information related to the number of clinical placement slots that are available and the location of those clinical placement slots within the state, including but not limited to information concerning the total number of placement slots a clinical facility can accommodate and how many slots the programs will need. The BRN has little to no direct control over the actual availability of placements. Part of the ongoing issue with clinical placement slots is the fairness in which some academic institutions may find clinical spots at facilities while other cannot. This bill would allow students who reside in California, but attend a non-BRN approved nursing school located outside of the state, an opportunity to obtain clinical placements in California.
Current law, (BPC § 2729), limits nursing services by a student when the services are incidental to the course of study by either a student enrolled in a BRN-approved prelicensure program or school of nursing, or a nurse licensed in another state or country taking a board-approved continuing education course or a post licensure course.
To be eligible for licensure in California, an individual must complete a BRN-approved education program, which must be at least two academic years and affiliated with a clinical facility. Today, California-approved nursing programs are located at various academic institutions throughout California including Community Colleges, the California State University system, the University of California system, and private for profit institutions regulated by the BPPE. All in-state nursing programs are required to meet the BRN’s regulatory requirements for approved nursing programs and curriculum and the BRN must determine the areas of coursework required for each program through regulations. Students who attend out-of-state nursing programs must have their education evaluated for equivalency with state requirements, including clinical experience. Those who do not meet the requirements will be denied or considered deficient and required to complete additional remedial education or training. Because the BRN only approves schools which have sought approval and ensures those programs meet the education and clinical standards under California’s nurse practice act, the BRN does not review schools located outside of California that have not requested board-approval. The BRN does not evaluate whether or not a non-approved school’s program meets the requirements for licensure in California. However, this bill expressly authorizes students from non-California based educational institutions to be eligible for clinical placement opportunities in California as part of their educational program even when BRN approval has not been obtained.
Students who live in California and enroll in non-BRN-approved distance programs likely move or commute to other states during their course of study to obtain the required clinical experience if they wish to immediately qualify for licensure in California upon graduation. This bill seeks to assist those students with a more simplified process to obtain clinical experience.
As currently drafted, this bill creates parameters on which institutions would be eligible to have their students obtain clinical placements in California. Those include: 1) the program has programmatic accreditation, 2) the clinical placement does not impact any current-California students already assigned to a clinical facility, 3) the program does not make any payments to any clinical agency in exchange for a clinical placement slot (which is currently prohibited for an institution in California), 4) the program qualifies graduates for licensure, and 5) the student is supervised by a California licensed RN while rendering RN services.
Recent amendments would limit the types of facilities where students would be eligible to be placed for their clinical training to specify only nonacute care facilities. Those settings could include skilled nursing facilities, clinics, home health agencies, dialysis clinics, to name a few, but not hospitals. For BRN-approved nursing programs, there are no limitations on the type facilities where clinical experience can be acquired; any many programs utilize nonacute settings. To facilitate the availability of placements, some nursing programs and clinical facilities utilize local databases known as regional consortiums to share placement availability and coordinate partnerships. The consortiums vary by region, function, and pricing methodologies. However, participation is voluntary and as a result, the databases are incomplete.
Additionally, this bill would prohibit a facility from offering clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the clinical placement is needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a BRN-approved nursing program. As currently drafted, there are not clear enforcement provisions in this bill. If a program violates any of the prohibitions listed in this bill, it is unclear how it would be enforced, including who violations are reported to. If a California-approved instruction were to violate provisions of the nurse practice act, they are subject to discipline from the BRN.
While the bill requires a $100 per student payment to the BRN for utilization of the clinical placements, it is unlikely the costs associated with the BRN’s review process would be recuperated.
This bill was recently amended to additionally require the distance education programs to provide reports to the BRN. These programs will be required to provide an initial report to the BRN, before any clinical placement occur and subsequent annual reports. The report information aims to provide the BRN with important data about the utilization of clinical placements from distant education students by requiring the schools provide a schedule of planned clinical placement spots and subsequent information about the slots and locations utilized. In addition, the report attempts to provide accounting of students to ensure the appropriate per-student fee is paid appropriately to the BRN.
There is nothing in current law that prohibits any of the schools offering these distance education programs from obtaining BRN approval in California.
- Related Legislation. SB 1042 (Roth of 2024) among various other provisions, would require a defined health facility that offers clinical placement slots, upon the request of an approved school of nursing or an approved program, to meet with representatives of the school or program to discuss the clinical placement needs, among other provisions. (Status: This bill is currently pending the Assembly Committee on Appropriations)
SB 1015 (Cortese of 2024) requires the BRN to study and recommend standards regarding how approved schools of nursing or nursing programs manage or coordinate clinical placements and to annually collect, analyze, and report information related to management of coordination of clinical placements. (Status: this bill is pending in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations)
AB 2015 (Schiavo of 2024) authorizes the BRN to approve an individual to serve as a member, director, or assistant director of faculty of a school of nursing or nursing program. (Status: this bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations)
AB 1292 (Flora of 2023) was substantially similar to this bill. (Status: this bill was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.)
AB 1577 (Low of 2023) would have required hospitals that offer pre-licensure clinical training slots to work in good faith with community college nursing programs to meet their clinical training needs. (Status: This bill is pending in the Senate Health Committee).
AB 2684 (Berman, Chapter 413, Statutes of 2022) made changes to address the lack of clinical placements, including establishing a lower 500 minimum number of clinical experience hours, authorizing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory, prohibiting nursing schools and programs from paying for clinical placements, and requiring the BRN to utilize data from available regional or individual institution databases in collecting information related to the number of clinical placement slots available to nursing students.
AB 2288 (Low, Chapter 282, Statutes of 2020), authorized the director of an approved nursing program, during a state of emergency, to make requests to the BRN for the following: 1) use of a clinical setting without meeting specified requirements; 2) use of preceptorships without having to maintain specified written policies; 3) use of clinical simulation up to 50% for medical-surgical and geriatric courses; 4) use of clinical simulation up to 75% for psychiatric-mental health nursing, obstetrics, and pediatrics courses; and 5) allowing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory.
AB 1015 (Blanca Rubio, Chapter 591, Statutes of 2021) requires the BRN to incorporate regional forecasts into its biennial analyses of the nursing workforce, develop a plan to address regional areas of shortage identified by its nursing workforce forecast, as specified, and annually collect, analyze, and report information related to the number of clinical placement slots that are available and the location of those clinical placement slots within the state.
- Arguments in Support. Nightingale Education Group writes in support and notes, “AB 2578 recognizes that for many California residents, distance nursing education is the best, or only, option for pursuing a nursing degree. By amending the nurse practice act to allow California residents enrolled in accredited distance nursing education programs to participate in clinical rotations at California facilities (conducted by California licensed registered nurses), the Legislature will allow these California residents to complete their online nursing education while simultaneously participating in their required hands-on training in their local communities, providing them much-needed experience and exposure to California healthcare systems and removing the need for costly out-of-state travel. AB2578 assures quality and cooperation from distance nursing education programs by mandating full accreditation by a USDOE recognized nursing education accrediting entity and by requiring programs to work together with California healthcare facilities to determine availability for local clinical rotations.”
Generations Healthcare writes in support and notes, “Generations Healthcare facilities are currently at half capacity for clinical rotations and are eager and ready to host new clinical agreements with opportunities to develop new California nursing talent. In each of our establishments we have constructed a proctorship Graduate training program to nurture this superior talent. This program was designed to help facilitate the immersion and integration of nursing education via virtual hybrid formats to support on-the-ground learning techniques. This stewardship training course cultivates the sought after quality care and sets expectations for these nursing professionals. As an existing employee partner and clinical building in Henderson, NV. Generations Healthcare provides job offers to talent during their clinical rotations with a high success rate of placement, proctorship, and ongoing employment.”
California Kidney Care Alliance writes in support and notes that this bill “…addresses the pressing shortage of healthcare professions, particularly nurses, by expanding the future pool of potential recruits in the state. With an increasing demand for dialysis services due to factors such as aging population and rising rates of chronic diseases, having an adequate workforce is essential to ensure patients receive timely and quality care.”
Fresenius Medical Care North America writes in support and notes, “AB 2578 advances healthcare education and training, ultimately contributing to the overall improvement of healthcare delivery and outcomes in the state. “
- Arguments in Opposition. The Board of Registered Nursing writes in opposition and notes, “There are said to be thousands of students enrolled in the out of state schools exempted by this bill that are living in California and seeking to do clinical placements here. Since the Board does not have authority over healthcare facilities and would not have oversight of the out of state nursing programs, there would be no way to identify if or when clinical displacement of students enrolled in California approved nursing programs is occurring. The Board would also not have any ability to take administrative action, if warranted.”
The California Labor Federation writes, “Direct patient care clinical experience for nursing students is a critical component of nursing education programs, but clinical nursing education slots in California are already limited. While we appreciate the author’s amendments from the previous iteration of this bill, AB 2578 would exacerbate the already limited access to clinical education slots for students in California by allowing out-state distance nursing programs to provide clinical education in the state. It would additionally displace nursing students in community college and state university nursing programs, which have long served as meaningful pathways into the nursing profession for racially, economically, and geographically diverse communities in California.”
The California Nurses Association states, “We are concerned that AB 2578 would undermine the availability of clinical education placements for nursing students of California-approved programs. The availability of clinical education slots in California health care facilities for existing nursing students is already limited.”
The California Association of Colleges of Nursing writes in opposition and notes, “We assert that AB 2578 is the wrong approach and that as an academic community we must work collaboratively side by side with the state and our clinical providers to learn how to expand access to California schools and programs of nursing for a long-term solution, and more importantly, meet California workforce needs. This must be done without legislation that gives up a precious state resource to out-of-state actors who seek to profit from California residents.”
The California Organization of Associate Degree Nursing and the California Baptist University College of Nursing write in opposition and notes, “Although AB 2578 suggests that California residents would be the beneficiaries of graduates of out-of-state entities, the real winner of this measure would be the educational entities who would directly profit from the tuition charged to these Californian students. This current measure takes a misguided step in the wrong direction by providing access to these limited placements to out-of-state educational entities, who have no ties to the state.”
- Policy Issues for Consideration.
Enforcement. Although this bill has limitations on how students enrolled in out-of-state distance education schools would be able to obtain clinical education in California, there is no enforcement mechanism to ensure compliance. If an out-of-state academic institution were to pay a clinical facility for placements, it unclear who would enforce the violation and what the penalty would be. The bill requires a school to pay $100 per student, but there is no mechanism to ensure compliance, other than a proposed self-report. This bill requires schools to provide reports to the BRN however, if those reports are late or not submitted, the BRN has no authority in this bill to take any action or deny student placements in a clinical facility.
Displacement of current students. Clinical experience is the bedrock of nursing education. Although this bill attempts to ensure that current California students are not displaced, this bill does not provide a measurable system to determine if clinical displacement occurs. Today, when considering school approval or program expansion, analysis occurs to the availability of clinical placements and where the program is located. Schools residing outside of California, but accepting distance education students, likely do not investigate or determine whether clinical space is available prior to acceptance. The location of school enrollees at out-of-state schools is not required to be shared with the BRN. As recently amended, this bill would only permit students enrolled in out of state programs to obtain clinical placements in nonacute care settings (facilities that are not hospitals), under the assumption that hospitals are the most clinically impacted. Currently, facilities are not required to report clinical placement information to the BRN, so it would be challenging for the BRN to know if any violation occurs, and nothing would prevent a hospital from permitting a student to obtain clinical education.
BRN-Approval and Cost Recovery. BPC § 2786.5 provides the BRN fee authority to recoup the costs for approving, inspecting and taking appropriate enforcement action against nursing schools and programs who violate the nurse practice act. However, schools located outside of California do not pay a fee to the BRN for any programmatic review. As currently drafted, this bill limits a student enrolled in an out-of-state distance education program from obtaining clinical education in California, unless the distance education nursing program meets the requirements for licensure, under the nurse practice act in California. Because the BRN only approves schools which have sought approval and ensures those programs meet the education and clinical standards under California’s nurse practice act, the BRN does not review schools located outside of California that have not requested board-approval. As currently drafted, this bill would likely require the BRN to do some form of curriculum or education approval of an out-of-state distance education provider to comply with the requirement proposed by this bill that the “program qualifies the student for licensure” under the nurse practice act. This review would likely cost the BRN significant resources and increase the need of Nurse Education Consultants. While this bill requires the school to provide $100 per student, that amount may not be sufficient to cover the BRN’s cost.
Overly Broad. Although this bill is sponsored by one institution, which serves California residents enrolled in an out-of-state program; this bill would be applicable to any distance education-nursing program located outside of California. This could lead to additional clinical impaction issues. Additionally, the recent amendments require any out-of-state distance education provider to report annually and before initial placement of students. However, it is not clear what the BRN is supposed to do with the reported information. If a compliance check is the goal, the bill lacks sufficient enforcement authority for the BRN to take action against an institution for not reporting on time or for violating any of the prohibitions. Additionally, as this bill is applicable to all distant education providers, the BRN could have a significant number of reports to review.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Nightingale Education Group (source)
California Kidney Care Alliance
Fresenius Medical Care North America
Generations Healthcare
Opposition:
Board of Registered Nursing
California Association of Colleges of Nursing
California Baptist University College of Nursing
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Organization of Associate Degree Nursing Programs
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2578
Author:(Flora)
As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Authorizes an unlicensed nursing student who is enrolled in an out-of-state distance education nursing program to provide supervised nursing services that are incidental to the course of study for purposes of gaining clinical experience.
Major Provisions
- Authorize a student who is a resident of this state and enrolled in a pre-licensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to provide nursing services to gain clinical experience in a clinical setting if the following are met:
- The program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education.
- The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) has not otherwise approved the program.
- The student placement does not impact any students already assigned to the agency or facility.
- The program does not make payments to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical experience placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing.
- The program qualifies graduates for licensure under the Nursing Practice Act.
- The program maintains minimum faculty to student ratios required of BRN-approved programs for in-person clinical experiences.
- The program pays a one-time fee of $100 to the BRN for each student who participates in clinical experience placements in the state.
- Require a student providing services under this bill to be supervised by an RN while rendering nursing services.
- Prohibit a clinical agency or facility from offering clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a BRN-approved nursing program.
- Specify that, for purposes of the authorization under this bill, "out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution" means a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California.
COMMENTS
Background. Nursing education generally contains two components, classroom theory and clinical experience. Clinical experience is supervised, hands-on experience providing patient care, providing an opportunity to apply theory to practice. In California, both theory and clinical experience are required for licensure as an RN.
To allow students to gain clinical experience, existing law exempts students from licensing requirements while providing nursing services through a BRN-approved education program. There is no exemption for students enrolled in non-BRN-approved nursing education programs, including students who live in California but attend distance-learning nursing education programs based in other states.
However, students who attend out-of-state programs must have their education evaluated for equivalency with state requirements, including clinical experience. Those who do not meet the requirements will be denied or considered deficient and required to complete additional remedial education or training.
As a result, the in-state students enrolled in non-BRN-approved distance programs must move to other states during their course of study to obtain the required clinical experience if they wish to immediately qualify for licensure in California upon graduation. This bill seeks to avoid requiring those students to move or travel by expanding the license exemption, though specifically limited to students enrolled in non-BRN-approved distance education nursing programs that are also accredited.
BRN. The BRN is a licensing entity within Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) and is responsible for administering and enforcing the Nursing Practice Act, which is the chapter of laws that establishes the BRN and outlines the regulatory framework for the practice, licensing, education and discipline of RNs and advanced practice registered nurses. The BRN is also one of the few licensing boards that actively approve and regulate educational programs that offer the degrees necessary for licensure. In-state programs that offer a course of instruction leading to an RN license must seek approval from the BRN to operate. At the end of fiscal year 2021-22, the BRN reported a total of 152 approved RN programs, including 91 Associate Degree in nursing (ADN) programs, 48 Bachelor of Science in nursing (BSN) programs, and 13 Entry-level Master's (ELM) programs.
Lack of Clinical Placements. During the BRN's 2022 Sunset Review, both this committee and the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee raised, and continue to work on, the issue of the availability of clinical placements for nursing students. The availability of student placements for clinical experiences is based on the willingness of clinical facilities, such as hospitals or clinics, to accept and teach students.
While there are no requirements that clinical facilities accept students, many willingly accept students because it is necessary for the workforce and can help with recruitment. However, the facilities must have staff that is qualified to teach and supervise students. As a result, clinical placements are often difficult to find. Unfortunately, students who are unable to obtain their clinical placements before the end of the term either have to drop out or receive an incomplete. Under either circumstance, the student would have to repeat the course.
This bill may complicate that problem by authorizing nursing students who are enrolled in out-of-state distance education programs to compete for already limited clinical placements. To reduce the chance that a student enrolled in an in-state program is displaced from a clinical placement, this bill contains language previously recommended by this committee requiring clinical facilities to give preference to students enrolled in an in-state program.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 1292 (Flora) of 2023 was substantially similar to this bill. AB 1292 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 1577 (Low) of 2023 would have required hospitals that offer pre-licensure clinical training slots to work in good faith with community college nursing programs to meet their clinical training needs. AB 1577 died pending a hearing in the Senate Health Committee.
AB 2684 (Berman), Chapter 413, Statutes of 2022, which was the BRN's 2022 Sunset Review bill,[1] made several changes to address the lack of clinical placements, including establishing a lower 500 minimum number of clinical experience hours, authorizing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory, prohibiting nursing schools and programs from paying for clinical placements, and requiring the BRN to utilize data from available regional or individual institution databases in collecting information related to the number of clinical placement slots available to nursing students.
AB 2288 (Low), Chapter 282, Statutes of 2020, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, authorized the director of an approved nursing program, during a state of emergency, to make requests to the BRN for the following: 1) the use of a clinical setting without meeting specified requirements; 2) the use of preceptorships without having to maintain specified written policies; 3) the use of clinical simulation up to 50% for medical-surgical and geriatric courses; 4) the use of clinical simulation up to 75% for psychiatric-mental health nursing, obstetrics, and pediatrics courses; and 5) allowing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory.
AB 1015 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 591, Statutes of 2021, required the BRN to incorporate regional forecasts into its biennial analyses of the nursing workforce, develop a plan to address regional areas of shortage identified by its nursing workforce forecast, as specified, and annually collect, analyze, and report information related to the number of clinical placement slots that are available and the location of those clinical placement slots within the state.
According to the Author
"[This bill] recognizes that for some California residents, online distance nursing education is the best option to pursue a nursing degree…. The reality for these students is that they are forced to find another state, where they can move to for a number of weeks, to fulfill on-ground practical components of their education. This has to be done at their own expense, forcing them to take time away from their families and their home, in order to complete their nursing degree. Further, these students develop relationships with these health facilities outside of the State and often results in their leaving the State of California to become a nurse in another State when California needs as many nurses as possible…. Many students choose not to further their education because of limited options in their area. With blended distance education programs, students can enroll in colleges and universities hundreds or thousands of miles from home. Having a strong local nursing workforce is imperative to improving patient care and access across the state and to decreasing the state's healthcare financial burdens. [This bill] provides an immediate, long- lasting, and much desired solution for creating and keeping a strong nursing workforce of local California nurses."
Arguments in Support
Nightingale Education Group (sponsor) writes in support:
Nightingale Education Group is the parent company of Nightingale College, a distance education nursing college headquartered in Salt Lake City, Utah. Nightingale College was established in 2011 and currently serves thousands of pre-licensure nursing students across the country, including over 3,000 California residents.
[This bill] recognizes that for many California residents, distance nursing education is the best, or only, option for pursuing a nursing degree. By amending the nurse practice act to allow California residents enrolled in accredited distance nursing education programs to participate in clinical rotations at California facilities (conducted by California licensed registered nurses), the Legislature will allow these California residents to complete their online nursing education while simultaneously participating in their required hands-on training in their local communities, providing them much-needed experience and exposure to California healthcare systems and removing the need for costly out-of-state travel. [This bill] assures quality and cooperation from distance nursing education programs by mandating full accreditation by a USDOE recognized nursing education accrediting entity and by requiring programs to work together with California healthcare facilities to determine availability for local clinical rotations.
Under the current nursing regulations, the reality for many California residents is that they are forced, while enrolled in distance education programs domiciled outside of California, to fulfill clinical experiential learning requirements in other states, where they are required to relocate for several weeks each semester to fulfill the mandatory on-ground practical components of their education. This creates a costly and cumbersome reality where students must travel at their own expense, leaving their families, homes, and employment, for weeks at a time every semester for the duration of their nursing program. Additionally, during these travel rotations, these students are developing relationships with, and actively being recruited by, healthcare facilities in other states, which often results in the students leaving California after graduation, further adding to California's already drastic nursing shortage.
Arguments in Opposition
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) estimates increased workload, at a cost of $431,000 ongoing (BRN Fund). BRN states it would need to review curriculum to ensure each school meets licensure requirements and estimates there could be up to up to 50 nursing programs across the country that could utilize this new process, and 3,000 additional students in California. BRN would also need to provide technical assistance for students, schools, and hospitals utilizing the new process.
The Department of Consumer Affairs' Office of Information Services estimates absorbable costs of $5,000 for new fee codes and to update enforcement codes in its electronic licensing system.
VOTES
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Berman, Flora, Alanis, Bains, Juan Carrillo, Chen, Dixon, Grayson, Irwin, Jackson, Ward, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Pellerin, Sanchez, Soria, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
UPDATED
VERSION: March 21, 2024
CONSULTANT: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0003005
The sunset review process provides an opportunity for the DCA, the Legislature, the boards, and interested parties and stakeholders to discuss the performance of the boards, and make recommendations for improvements. Each year, the Assembly Business and Professions Committee and the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee hold joint sunset review oversight hearings to review the boards and bureaus. For more information, see the background paper on the BRN's 2022 Sunset Review, accessible at: https://abp.assembly.ca.gov/jointsunsethearings. ↑
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2578
Author:(Flora) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 18 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows a nursing student who is a California resident enrolled in an out-of-state distance education nursing program to render nursing services, under the supervision of a licensed registered nurse, for the purpose of gaining experience in a clinical setting.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) estimates increased workload, at a cost of $431,000 ongoing (BRN Fund). BRN states it would need to review curriculum to ensure each school meets licensure requirements and estimates there could be up to up to 50 nursing programs across the country that could utilize this new process, and 3,000 additional students in California. BRN would also need to provide technical assistance for students, schools, and hospitals utilizing the new process.
The Department of Consumer Affairs’ Office of Information Services estimates absorbable costs of $5,000 for new fee codes and to update enforcement codes in its electronic licensing system.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Nightingale College. According to the author:
For some California residents, online distance nursing education is the best option to pursue a nursing degree…Amending the nurse practice act to allow California residents enrolled in accredited distance nursing education programs to participate in clinical rotations at California facilities conducted by California BRN licensed registered nurses, allows them pursue this online education in California. The distance nursing education programs must be fully accredited by a USDOE recognized accrediting entity, and only if space is available at a California health facility.
The reality for these students today is that they are forced to find another state, where they can move to for a number of weeks, to fulfill on-ground practical components of their education. This has to be done at their own expense, forcing them to take time away from their families and their home, in order to complete their nursing degree. Further, these students develop relationships with these health facilities outside of the State and often results in their leaving the State of California to become a nurse in another State when California needs as many nurses as possible.
- Background. Generally, nursing students are required to obtain clinical experience. Existing law prohibits students from providing nursing services without a registered nurse (RN) license, unless they are providing services incidental to the course of study of a BRN-approved course.
- Related Legislation.
- AB 1292 (Flora) is substantially similar to this bill. AB 1292 was held in this committee.
- AB 1577 (Low) requires a hospital to report to the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), on a quarterly basis, the number of clinical nursing placements filled by the hospital, and requires HCAI to post the information on its website. AB 1577 also requires a community college with students enrolled in a nursing school to notify HCAI of the number of clinical placements the community college will require for the next academic year. AB 1577 was referred to, but not heard in, Senate Health Committee.
- Prior Legislation.
- AB 2684 (Berman), Chapter 413, Statutes of 2022, which was the BRN’s 2022 sunset review bill, made several changes to address the lack of clinical placements, including reducing the minimum number of clinical experience hours to 500, authorizing clinical placements to take place immediately following theory, prohibiting nursing schools and programs from paying for clinical placements, and requiring the BRN to utilize specified data related to the number of clinical placement slots available to nursing students.
- AB 1015 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 591, Statutes of 2021, required the BRN to incorporate regional forecasts into its biennial analyses of the nursing workforce, develop a plan to address regional areas of shortage identified by its nursing workforce forecast, as specified, and annually collect, analyze, and report information related to the availability and location of clinical placement slots.
- AB 2288 (Low), Chapter 282, Statutes of 2020, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, authorized the director of an approved nursing program, during a state of emergency, to make requests to the BRN for the following: (1) the use of a clinical setting without meeting specified requirements; (2) the use of preceptorships without having to maintain specified written policies; (3) the use of clinical simulation for up to 50% for medical-surgical and geriatric courses and up to 75% for psychiatric-mental health nursing, obstetrics, and pediatrics courses; and (4) allowing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Marc Berman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2578
Author:(Flora) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
SUBJECT: Nursing: students in out-of-state nursing programs.
SUMMARY: Authorizes an unlicensed nursing student who is enrolled in an out-of-state distance education nursing program to provide supervised nursing services that are incidental to the course of study for purposes of gaining clinical experience.
EXISTING LAW:
- Regulates the practice of nursing under the Nursing Practice Act. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 2700-2838.4)
- Establishes the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to administer and enforce the Nursing Practice Act until January 1, 2027. (BPC § 2701)
- Prohibits the practice of nursing without holding a license which is in an active status issued under the Nursing Practice Act, except as otherwise provided, and specifies that every licensee may be known as a registered nurse (RN) and use the title “R.N.” (BPC § 2732)
- Requires an applicant for licensure as an RN to complete the education requirements established by the BRN in a program in this state approved by the BRN or in a school of nursing outside of this state which, in the opinion of the BRN, offers an education that meets the BRN’s requirements. (BPC § 2736)
- Defines “an approved school of nursing” or “an approved nursing program” as one that (1) has been approved by the BRN, (2) gives the course of instruction approved by the BRN, covering not less than two academic years, (3) is affiliated or conducted in connection with one or more hospitals, and (4) is an institution of higher education. (BPC § 2786(a))
- Requires the BRN to determine by regulation the required subjects of instruction for licensure as an RN and (1) include the minimum units of theory and clinical experience necessary to achieve essential clinical competency at the entry level of an RN and (2) require all programs to provide clinical instruction in all phases of the educational process, except as specified. (BPC § 2786(c))
- Authorizes a student to render nursing services if those services are incidental to the course of study of one of the following:
- A student enrolled in a BRN-approved pre-licensure program or school of nursing. (BPC § 2729(a))
- A nurse licensed in another state or country taking a BRN-approved continuing education course or a post-licensure course. (BPC § 2729(b))
- Requires a nursing program to obtain approval from the BRN for the use of any agency or facility for clinical experience, and requires the program to take into consideration the impact that an additional group of students would have on students of other nursing programs already assigned to the agency or facility. (California Code of Regulations, Title 16, § 1427)
- Prohibits an institution of higher education or a private postsecondary school of nursing, or an entity affiliated with the institution or school of nursing, from making a payment to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical experience placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing, as specified. (BPC § 2786.4)
- Defines an “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California. (Education Code § 94850.5)
THIS BILL:
- Authorizes a student who is a resident of this state and enrolled in a pre-licensure distance education nursing program based at an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to provide nursing services to gain clinical experience in a clinical setting if the following are met:
- The program is accredited by a programmatic accreditation entity recognized by the United States Department of Education.
- The BRN has not otherwise approved the program.
- The student placement does not impact any students already assigned to the agency or facility.
- The program does not make payments to any clinical agency or facility in exchange for clinical experience placements for students enrolled in a nursing program offered by or affiliated with the institution or private postsecondary school of nursing.
- The program qualifies graduates for licensure under the Nursing Practice Act.
- The program maintains minimum faculty to student ratios required of BRN-approved programs for in-person clinical experiences.
- The program pays a one-time fee of $100 to the BRN for each student who participates in clinical experience placements in the state.
- Requires a student providing services under this bill to be supervised by an RN while rendering nursing services.
- Prohibits a clinical agency or facility from offering clinical experience placements to an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution if the placements are needed to fulfill the clinical experience requirements of an in-state student enrolled in a BRN-approved nursing program.
- Specifies that, for purposes of the authorization under this bill, “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” means a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the Nightingale Education Group. According to the author, “[This bill] recognizes that for some California residents, online distance nursing education is the best option to pursue a nursing degree…. The reality for these students is that they are forced to find another state, where they can move to for a number of weeks, to fulfill on-ground practical components of their education. This has to be done at their own expense, forcing them to take time away from their families and their home, in order to complete their nursing degree. Further, these students develop relationships with these health facilities outside of the State and often results in their leaving the State of California to become a nurse in another State when California needs as many nurses as possible…. Many students choose not to further their education because of limited options in their area. With blended distance education programs, students can enroll in colleges and universities hundreds or thousands of miles from home. Having a strong local nursing workforce is imperative to improving patient care and access across the state and to decreasing the state’s healthcare financial burdens. [This bill] provides an immediate, long- lasting, and much desired solution for creating and keeping a strong nursing workforce of local California nurses.”
Background. Nursing education generally contains two components, classroom theory and clinical experience. Clinical experience is supervised, hands-on experience providing patient care, providing an opportunity to apply theory to practice. In California, both theory and clinical experience are required for licensure as an RN.
To allow students to gain clinical experience, existing law exempts students from licensing requirements while providing nursing services through a BRN-approved education program. There is no exemption for students enrolled in non-BRN-approved nursing education programs, including students who live in California but attend distance-learning nursing education programs based in other states.
However, students who attend out-of-state programs must have their education evaluated for equivalency with state requirements, including clinical experience. Those who do not meet the requirements will be denied or considered deficient and required to complete additional remedial education or training.
As a result, the in-state students enrolled in non-BRN-approved distance programs must move to other states during their course of study to obtain the required clinical experience if they wish to immediately qualify for licensure in California upon graduation. This bill seeks to avoid requiring those students to move or travel by expanding the license exemption, though specifically limited to students enrolled in non-BRN-approved distance education nursing programs that are also accredited.
BRN. The BRN is a licensing entity within DCA and is responsible for administering and enforcing the Nursing Practice Act, which is the chapter of laws that establishes the BRN and outlines the regulatory framework for the practice, licensing, education and discipline of RNs and advanced practice registered nurses. The BRN is also one of the few licensing boards that actively approve and regulate educational programs that offer the degrees necessary for licensure. In-state programs that offer a course of instruction leading to an RN license must seek approval from the BRN to operate. At the end of fiscal year 2021-22, the BRN reported a total of 152 approved RN programs, including 91 Associate Degree in nursing (ADN) programs, 48 Bachelor of Science in nursing (BSN) programs, and 13 Entry-level Master's (ELM) programs.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 1292 (Flora) of 2023 was substantially similar to this bill. AB 1292 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 1577 (Low) of 2023 would have required hospitals that offer pre-licensure clinical training slots to work in good faith with community college nursing programs to meet their clinical training needs. AB 1577 died pending a hearing in the Senate Health Committee.
AB 2684 (Berman), Chapter 413, Statutes of 2022, which was the BRN’s 2022 Sunset Review bill,[1] made several changes to address the lack of clinical placements, including establishing a lower 500 minimum number of clinical experience hours, authorizing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory, prohibiting nursing schools and programs from paying for clinical placements, and requiring the BRN to utilize data from available regional or individual institution databases in collecting information related to the number of clinical placement slots available to nursing students.
AB 2288 (Low), Chapter 282, Statutes of 2020, in response to the COVID-19 pandemic, authorized the director of an approved nursing program, during a state of emergency, to make requests to the BRN for the following: 1) the use of a clinical setting without meeting specified requirements; 2) the use of preceptorships without having to maintain specified written policies; 3) the use of clinical simulation up to 50% for medical-surgical and geriatric courses; 4) the use of clinical simulation up to 75% for psychiatric-mental health nursing, obstetrics, and pediatrics courses; and 5) allowing clinical placements to take place in the academic term immediately following theory.
AB 1015 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 591, Statutes of 2021, required the BRN to incorporate regional forecasts into its biennial analyses of the nursing workforce, develop a plan to address regional areas of shortage identified by its nursing workforce forecast, as specified, and annually collect, analyze, and report information related to the number of clinical placement slots that are available and the location of those clinical placement slots within the state.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Nightingale Education Group (sponsor) writes in support:
Nightingale Education Group is the parent company of Nightingale College, a distance education nursing college headquartered in Salt Lake City, Utah. Nightingale College was established in 2011 and currently serves thousands of pre-licensure nursing students across the country, including over 3,000 California residents.
[This bill] recognizes that for many California residents, distance nursing education is the best, or only, option for pursuing a nursing degree. By amending the nurse practice act to allow California residents enrolled in accredited distance nursing education programs to participate in clinical rotations at California facilities (conducted by California licensed registered nurses), the Legislature will allow these California residents to complete their online nursing education while simultaneously participating in their required hands-on training in their local communities, providing them much-needed experience and exposure to California healthcare systems and removing the need for costly out-of-state travel. [This bill] assures quality and cooperation from distance nursing education programs by mandating full accreditation by a USDOE recognized nursing education accrediting entity and by requiring programs to work together with California healthcare facilities to determine availability for local clinical rotations.
Under the current nursing regulations, the reality for many California residents is that they are forced, while enrolled in distance education programs domiciled outside of California, to fulfill clinical experiential learning requirements in other states, where they are required to relocate for several weeks each semester to fulfill the mandatory on-ground practical components of their education. This creates a costly and cumbersome reality where students must travel at their own expense, leaving their families, homes, and employment, for weeks at a time every semester for the duration of their nursing program. Additionally, during these travel rotations, these students are developing relationships with, and actively being recruited by, healthcare facilities in other states, which often results in the students leaving California after graduation, further adding to California’s already drastic nursing shortage.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file
POLICY ISSUE FOR CONSIDERATION:
Lack of Clinical Placements. During the BRN’s 2022 Sunset Review, both this committee and the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee raised, and continue to work on, the issue of the availability of clinical placements for nursing students. The availability of student placements for clinical experiences is based on the willingness of clinical facilities, such as hospitals or clinics, to accept and teach students.
While there are no requirements that clinical facilities accept students, many willingly accept students because it is necessary for the workforce and can help with recruitment. However, the facilities must have staff that is qualified to teach and supervise students. As a result, clinical placements are often difficult to find. Unfortunately, students who are unable to obtain their clinical placements before the end of the term either have to drop out or receive an incomplete. Under either circumstance, the student would have to repeat the course.
This bill may complicate that problem by authorizing nursing students who are enrolled in out-of-state distance education programs to compete for already limited clinical placements. To reduce the chance that a student enrolled in an in-state program is displaced from a clinical placement, this bill contains language previously recommended by this committee requiring clinical facilities to give preference to students enrolled in an in-state program.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
Nightingale Education Group (sponsor)
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
The sunset review process provides an opportunity for the DCA, the Legislature, the boards, and interested parties and stakeholders to discuss the performance of the boards, and make recommendations for improvements. Each year, the Assembly Business and Professions Committee and the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee hold joint sunset review oversight hearings to review the boards and bureaus. For more information, see the background paper on the BRN’s 2022 Sunset Review, accessible at: https://abp.assembly.ca.gov/jointsunsethearings. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):