AB 2584: Single-family residential real property: corporate entity: ownership.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-20
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-07-02: In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law provides that real property within the state is governed by the law of this state, except where title is in the United States. Existing law generally regulates the obligations of owners with respect to real property.
This bill would prohibit a business entity, as defined, that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an ownership interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. property, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to bring a civil action for a violation of these provisions, and would require a court in a civil action in which the Attorney General prevails to order specified relief, including that the business entity pay a civil penalty of $100,000 for each violation and that the business entity sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters judgment. The bill would require that these provisions be the exclusive means of enforcement of these provisions. The bill would define various terms for these purposes.
Existing law provides that real property within the state is governed by the law of this state, except where title is in the United States. Existing law generally regulates the obligations of owners with respect to real property.
This bill would prohibit a business entity entity, as defined, that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to bring a civil action for a violation of these provisions, and would require a court in a civil action in which the Attorney General prevails to order specified relief, including that the business entity pay a civil penalty of $100,000 for each violation and that the business entity sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters judgment. The bill would define various terms for these purposes.
Existing law provides that real property within the state is governed by the law of this state, except where title is in the United States. Existing law generally regulates the obligations of owners with respect to real property.
This bill would prohibit a business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to bring a civil action for a violation of these provisions, and would require a court in a civil action in which the Attorney General prevails to order specified relief, including that the business entity pay a civil penalty of $100,000 for each violation and that the business entity sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters judgment. The bill would define various terms for these purposes.
(a)For purposes of this title, the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entitys successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include either of the following:
(A)A nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
(B)A person or entity primarily engaged in the construction of housing, only if the person or entity does not hold a given property longer than five years without applying for building permits for that property. new housing.
(2)Single-family residential property means a single parcel of real property improved with only one detached dwelling unit. unit on it for which a certificate of occupancy has been issued.
(b)A business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties shall not purchase, acquire, or otherwise obtain an ownership interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently lease the property. The seller shall have no liability for a violation of this section.
(c)(1)The Attorney General may bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California for a violation of this section.
(2)If the Attorney General prevails in a civil action brought pursuant to paragraph (1), the court shall order all of the following:
(A)The business entity to pay a civil penalty of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation of this section.
(B)The business entity to sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters the judgment.
(C)Reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(D)Any other relief the court deems appropriate.
(3)This subdivision shall be the exclusive means of enforcing this section.
(a)For purposes of this title, the following definitions apply. apply:
(1)Business entity means any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entitys successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include either of the following: a
(A)A nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
(B)A person or entity primarily engaged in the construction of housing, only if the person or entity does not hold a given property longer than five years without applying for building permits for that property.
(2)Single-family residential property means real property improved with one dwelling unit.
(b)A business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties shall not purchase, acquire, or otherwise obtain an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently lease the property.
(c)(1)The Attorney General may bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California for a violation of this section.
(2)If the Attorney General prevails in a civil action brought pursuant to paragraph (1), the court shall order all of the following:
(A)The business entity to pay a civil penalty of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation of this section.
(B)The business entity to sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters the judgment.
(C)Reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(D)Any other relief the court deems appropriate.
(a)For purposes of this title, the following definitions apply.
(1)Business entity means any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entitys successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include a nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
(2)Single-family residential property means real property improved with one dwelling unit.
(b)A business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties shall not purchase, acquire, or otherwise obtain an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently lease the property.
(c)(1)The Attorney General may bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California for a violation of this section.
(2)If the Attorney General prevails in a civil action brought pursuant to paragraph (1), the court shall order all of the following:
(A)The business entity to pay a civil penalty of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation of this section.
(B)The business entity to sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters the judgment.
(C)Reasonable attorneys fees and costs.
(D)Any other relief the court deems appropriate.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 2, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 20, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 22, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 21, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 48. Noes 11. Page 5430.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| Apr 24, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (April 9). |
| Apr 3, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 4, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 21, 2024 | AB 2584 Lee Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aids Healthcare Foundation | ** Support | |
| Alchemist Community Development Corporation | ** Support | |
| alliance of californians for community empowerment action | ** Support | |
| American Federation Of State, County, And Municipal Employees, Afl-Cio | ** Support | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Against | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Roundtable | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Land Title Association | ** Against | |
| California Mortgage Bankers Association | ** Against | |
| Ceres Community Project | ** Support | |
| CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| Childrens Partnership | ** Support | |
| City of Concord | ** Support | |
| City of San Jose | ** Support | |
| Community Alliance With Family Farmers | ** Support | |
| East Bay Housing Organizations | ** Support | |
| Housing Now! CA Coalition | ** Support | |
| Livable California | ** Support | |
| Long Beach Forward | ** Support | |
| National Rental Home Council | ** Against | |
| Pesticide Action Network | ** Support | |
| Santa Monica Democratic Club | ** Support | |
| Southern California Rental Housing Association | ** Against | |
| Sustainable Agriculture Education | ** Support | |
| Techequity Action | ** Support | |
| Urban Habitat | ** Support |
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2584 (Author:Lee)
Version: June 20, 2024
Hearing Date: July 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ME
SUBJECT
Single-family residential real property: corporate entity: ownership
DIGEST
This bill prohibits a business entity, as defined, that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an ownership interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. If the business entity violates this law then the Attorney General is entitled to bring an action in court. If the Attorney General prevails then the court is required to make the business entity pay $100,000 in civil penalties and the court is required to force the business entity to sell the property to an independent entity, which is not defined, within one year of the date the court enters judgment. The Court must also order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to be paid to the Attorney General and any other relief the court deems appropriate.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under this bill, a business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties is prohibited from purchasing another single-family residential property and leasing the property. The Attorney General can bring an action against a business entity that violates this provision. The court is forced to order a $100,000 civil penalty and to require the business entity to sell their property to an independent entity within one year of the entry of judgment.
This prohibition on the business entity will have negative impacts on the seller of single-family homes who would otherwise receive offers from business entities. This could lead to a lower selling price for the seller of the home. Additionally, a renter who is in a home that was purchased by the business entity may be forced out of their home because the business entity will be forced to sell the property within a year. Moreover, materials submitted to the Committee do not show that these business entities that own 1,000 or more single family residential properties are buying up large amounts of single family residences in California. The materials that were submitted to the Committee show that these business entities accounted for about 2% of home purchasers throughout the United States in the first quarter of 2022. Forcing the sale of properties that can result in the displacement of renters and lowering the selling price of homes can have a detrimental impact on Californians. The Committee has received no evidence that there is a demonstrated problem that justifies the negative impact that this bill would have on renters and sellers that this bill would have.
This bill is author sponsored and supported by some unions, some cities, and affordable housing advocates. The bill is opposed by the California Association of Realtors, California Business Roundtable, California Mortgage Bankers Association, National Rental Home Council, California Apartment Association, and the California Land Title Association.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that all property has an owner, whether that owner is the state and the property is public, or the owner is an individual and the property is private. Provides that the State may also hold property as a private proprietor. (Civ. Code § 669.)
- Provides that any person, regardless of their citizenship status, may take, hold, and dispose of property, real or personal, within this state. (Civ. Code § 670.)
This bill:
- Prohibits a business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an ownership interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property.
- Authorizes the Attorney General to bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California for a violation of the above.
- Requires the court to order all of the following if the Attorney General prevails in a civil action brought pursuant to this bill: order the business entity to pay a $100,000 civil penalty for each violation of this bill; order the business entity to sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters the judgment; order the business entity to pay reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to the Attorney General; and order any other relief the court deems appropriate.
- Provides that 3), above, is the exclusive means of enforcing this bill.
- Specifies that the seller shall have no liability for a violation of this bill.
- Defines the following for purposes of this bill:
- “Business entity” means any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entity’s successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include a nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity; or a person or entity primarily engaged in the construction of new housing.
- “Single-family residential property” means a single parcel of real property improved with only one detached dwelling unit on it for which a certificate of occupancy has been issued.
COMMENTS
- Author statement
According to the author:
Corporations are buying up whole neighborhoods worth of housing inventory. First-time homebuyers are not able to compete with cash offers from these large corporate firms. By outbidding homebuyers and converting properties to rentals, these corporations are taking homeownership opportunities away from hard working Californians and exacerbating the scarcity of single-family homes. This bill will protect Californians’ opportunities for stability and homeownership.
A report by the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University provided to the Committee by the author of this bill clarified the following[1]:
7. Large rental operators own a small share of the single-family rental stock
According to one estimate by Adam Travis tabulating Zillow ZTRAX data for 2018, investors with at least 1,000 properties owned just 2 percent of small rental properties (single-family homes and multifamily structures with 2-4 units), though 12 percent of properties [are] owned by some corporate entity. By comparison, micro investors or mom and pop landlords with 1-2 units owned two-thirds (66 percent) of all small rental properties.
Another report provided to the Committee by the author’s office explained that investors who own 1000 of more units purchased 2% of single family homes nationwide in the first quarter of 2022.[2]
2. The bill can harm the population the author intends to protect
This bill places restrictions on selling houses and includes enforcement mechanisms that will lead to renters being displaced.
a. Places restrictions on sellers selling housing and renting that housing
Under this bill, a business entity, as defined, that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties is prohibited from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an ownership interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. If the business entity violates this law then the Attorney General is entitled to bring an action in court. If the Attorney General prevails then the court is required to make the business entity pay $100,000 in civil penalties and the court is required to force the business entity to sell the property to an independent entity, within one year of the date the court enters judgment. The Court must also order reasonable attorney’s fees and costs to be paid to the Attorney General and any other relief the court deems appropriate. The bill will negatively impact sellers of single family homes that would otherwise have offers from the business entity. Therefore the seller’s property will have less value than it would have without this restriction.
b. Enforcement mechanisms will have unintended consequences on renters
Under this bill, a tenant who lives in a property that was acquired by the business entity in violation of the terms of the bill can end up losing their housing as the business entity will be forced to sell the home to an undefined independent entity. Presumably the author intends this to mean any person or entity that is not a business entity with an interest in more than 1,000 single family homes. When the home is sold, the purchaser may want to move into their property, thus leading to housing instability for the renter of the home. The stated purpose of the bill is to help Californians with housing stability. This bill arguably undermines Californian’s housing stability. The Committee may wish to hold the bill so as not to unintentionally harm California home sellers and renters.
3. Support
In support of the bill, the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO, writes:
Corporate entities’ involvement in the single-family housing market has increased exponentially since the foreclosure crisis that occurred at the beginning of the Great Recession. There were thousands of available homes that had been foreclosed upon and many investment firms saw them as portfolio assets. Fast forward nearly twenty years later and giant investment firms like Blackstone are now the landlord for hundreds of thousands of single-family properties across the United States and California.
This trend has dire consequences for the future of housing in California. According to MetLife Investment Management, corporate investment entities will own 40 percent of all single-family rental units in the country by 2030. When entities like Blackstone, which manages more than $1 trillion of total assets, buy up single-family properties, it prices out Californians like AFSCME members who may be trying to buy their first home or are looking to rent a home. While these entities claim they may let go of some of their current holdings soon because of market forces, current law would not stop them from doing exactly what they did in 2008 again.
AB 2584 aims to provide a solution to this issue by targeting the biggest culprits in the market. The bill targets corporate and other business entities that have an ownership interest in at least 1000 single-family residential properties. Specifically, it would ban these entities from acquiring ownership interests in additional homes if they plan on leasing them to prospective tenants. The bill would vest enforcement authority in the Attorney General’s office and make each violation come at a cost of $100,000.
Livable California, a supporter of the bill, writes that “[s]peculation is a key element causing high housing costs and difficulty for 1st time home buyers in California. Anti-speculation bills are rare. We welcome AB 2584’s attempt to reign in this problem.”
The City of San Jose writes the following in support of the bill:
According to data from the California Association of Realtors, in April 2024, the median sale price for a single-family home in California was $904,210, an 11.4% increase from the previous year and the highest median price in the state’s history. Locally, the median single-family home in Santa Clara County reached $2 million, according to the Santa Clara County Association of Realtors. California’s inventory of for-sale single-family homes has declined in recent years, making it difficult for first-time home buyers to enter the housing market.
As we work to build up our housing supply, resale listings remain stagnant as existing homeowners are reluctant to list their properties given market conditions and high interest rates. This has only deepened the housing affordability crisis as many working families and young people struggle to compete against institutional investors with the means to purchase single-family properties in cash. This bill places much-needed guardrails against this practice, allowing prospective homebuyers to compete under more fair market conditions.
The City of San José supports legislation that makes it easier for first-time homebuyers to enter the market.
Community Alliance with Family Farmers writes the following in support of AB 2584:
The bill clears a path for working-class homebuyers by prohibiting large corporate real estate firms that own more than 1,000 homes from buying additional homes and converting them to rentals. Home prices have soared in the state of California and the median home price has risen to $800,000 in 2024. Only 15% of Californians can afford to buy a home at current costs. With nearly 75 percent of farmers operating on less than $100,000 in gross sales in California accessing a home at such extreme prices would be nearly impossible.
Meanwhile, institutional investors and large real estate firms have gone on a homebuying spree. In 2022, investors purchased 1 in 3 homes that were on the market. In California, large landlords like Invitation Homes own thousands of single-family properties, primarily buying more affordable homes in cheaper markets. This takes away homebuying opportunities from working families like small farmers. By passing AB 2584, the state legislature could even the playing field and stop the corporate buy-out of single-family neighborhoods.
4. Opposition
The California Association of Realtors and California Land Title Association write the following in opposition to AB 2584:
AB 2584 (Lee) seeks to eliminate and prohibit anyone from owning more than 1,000 primary (1-unit) single-family homes. As drafted the measure lacks clarity. Among other things, the bill eliminates the opportunity to purchase homes once an owner reached a specified threshold which, if enacted, could be reduced to lower thresholds of unit ownership, thus restricting individual wealth generation opportunities. Furthermore, enforcement and verification of title will be nearly impossible to achieve creating unresolvable conflicts within the real estate transaction purchase process that could have a variety of unintended consequences to property ownership in California.
The California Apartment Association and California Mortgage Bankers Association write the following in opposition to AB 2584:
[ . . . ] CAA and CMBA continue to oppose AB 2584, your bill that would prohibit a business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently leasing the property. “Business entity” is defined in AB 2584 as any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entity’s successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include a nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
Ownership of single-family homes by “business entities” in California is extremely limited, estimated at 0.15 of 1 percent. Admittedly, there were homes purchased by business entities during the 2007-2008 financial crisis, triggered by a housing bubble in the United States, which led to massive bank foreclosures of homes during that time. Instead of keeping homes boarded up and allowing neighborhoods to decline, banks sold the homes to business entities that maintained them for tenants. Today, however, because of the high cost of homes in California, we do not see investment by “business entities” like we did in the mid 2000’s.
Today business entities are moving away from the single-family home market. It may be a better approach for AB 2584 to focus on requiring these businesses to give tenants in the home the first right to purchase the home when the entity decides to sell. We believe this is a better focus for AB 2584 and may give more tenants the option to become homeowners.
According to information provided to the Committee by the National Rental Home Council, an opponent of this bill:
Single-family rental homes account for nearly 25% of California’s housing market, providing access to quality, affordably priced housing for more than 2 million resident households across the state in neighborhoods with proximity to quality schools, employment centers, and transportation corridors. [ . . . ]
We are concerned about AB 2584 which proposes to target an industry with a modest presence in the California rental housing market. In recent years, many institutional housing investors have been net sellers of single-family rental homes in California. Today, NRHC members own approximately 0.15 of 1% of the approximately 8.5 million single family homes in California – the vast majority of rental housing in California is owned by non-institutional owners (“mom-and-pops”).
AB 2584 seeks to outlaw one class of home buyer from freely entering into a contract with another willing party for a home purchase. Given the scant overall institutional presence in the California single family rental home marketplace, this proposal appears to be legislating against a narrative of institutional ownership, not actual statistics.
Institutional owners of housing are able to bring rental housing products to the market more rapidly than some other potential rental property owners. In a high-cost housing market like California, more supply, and choice within that supply, should be an overriding public policy goal. The marketplace demand for rental housing in California is very strong, with many owners having occupancy rates consistently in excess of 95%. Our member companies bring choice to prospective renters who may wish to have a single-family home, versus a multifamily (or other) housing alternative. The occupancy rates of the single-family rental homes reflect the marketplace demand for these housing choices.
SUPPORT
Alchemist Community Development Corporation
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
Ceres Community Project
Children’s Partnership
CFT, AFT, AFL-CIO
City of Concord
City of San Jose
Community Alliance with Family Farmers
East Bay Housing Organizations
Housing Now! CA Coalition
Livable California
Long Beach Forward
Pesticide Action Network
Santa Monica Democratic Club
Sustainable Agriculture Education
TechEquity Action
Urban Habitat
OPPOSITION
California Association of Realtors
California Apartment Association
California Business Roundtable
California Land Title Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
National Rental Home Council
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 1212 (Skinner, 2024) places restrictions on Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) purchasing housing, as defined, and places restrictions on REITs selling housing, as provided. AB 2584 is currently in this Committee.
AB 2230 (Bennett, 2024) enacts the Residential Housing Unfair Practices Act of 2023, to: (1) bring residential housing within the purview of the Cartwright Act, the Unfair Practices Act, and the Unfair Competition Law to prevent market manipulation of housing prices and supply during the period of the previously declared statewide housing emergency; and (2) ensure that residential housing is developed and managed to be responsive to the needs, demands, and pricing affordable to residents of our state and not to the needs, demands, and pricing desired by nonresident investors or speculators. The bill is currently in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1333 (Ward, 2023) prohibits a developer of residential one to four dwelling units from conducting a bundled sale of real property to an institutional investor. Applies this restriction only to properties for which the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2025. Defines "bundled sale" as the sale of two or more parcels real property containing one to four residential dwelling units, inclusive, in a single transaction. Defines "institutional investor" as an entity that is not a natural person and having portfolios containing more than 1,000 units. This bill is scheduled to be heard in this Committee on the same day as AB 2584.
Prior Legislation: None known.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 48, Noes 11)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 4)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 2)
**************
8 Facts About Investor Activity in the Single-family Rental Market, Alexander Hermann (July 18, 2023) available at: 8 Facts About Investor Activity in the Single-Family Rental Market | Joint Center for Housing Studies (harvard.edu) as of June 20, 2024. ↑
Single-Family Investor Activity Bounces Back in the First Quarter of 2022 (July 7, 2022)Available at: Single-Family Investor Activity Bounces Back in the First Quarter of 2022 | CoreLogic® as of June 20, 2024. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2584
Author:(Lee)
As Amended Ver:April 10, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits business entities that own more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing any additional single-family properties and leasing them out.
Major Provisions
- Defines "business entity" as any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entity's successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include a nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
- Excludes from the definition of "business entity" any of the following:
- A nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
- A person or entity primarily engaged in the construction of housing so long as they do not hold a given property longer than five years without pulling building permits.
- Defines "single-family residential property" as real property improved with one dwelling unit.
- Prohibits a business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently lease the property.
- Authorizes the Attorney General to bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California for a violation of this bill.
- Establishes that if the Attorney General prevails in a civil action, the court must order the following relief:
- Reasonable attorney's fees and costs;
- The business entity to pay a civil penalty of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation;
- The business entity to sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters the judgment; and
- Any other relief the court deems appropriate.
COMMENTS
California is facing a housing crisis. The inventory of available homes—especially of affordable entry-level homes—is severely constrained. In tackling this issue, the Legislature has focused on increasing supply and maintaining home affordability, but with limited success. The decline in homeownership has resulted in a growing population of renters. Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate "buy/build-to-rent" model by prohibiting business entities with large single-family home portfolios from purchasing and renting out property in the state.
In California, the percentage of institutional investors is tiny. According to a March 6, 2024 Roofstock report, business entities that have more than 1,000 homes in their portfolio represented less than 1% of California home purchases in 2023. In other words, even in the absence of legislation, the group that this bill is targeting purchased only 0.8% of all single-family homes sold in the state last year. This represents a slight decrease from the 0.9% of single- family homes they purchased the year prior. Though currently small, the author points to the growing national trend of the corporate build/buy-to-rent single-family home model, the fluctuation in interest rates, and the serious concerns it raises about home affordability and availability—particularly in a market with constrained inventory.
This bill prohibits business entities with an interest in more than 1,000 single-family homes in their portfolio from purchasing and leasing out any additional single-family homes. The prohibition applies to a business entity that owns more than 1,000 units anywhere, as it is intended to target the country's "mega investors" regardless of how many homes they may own in the state. While there is no universally accepted definition of institutional ownership, the 1,000 figure is commonly used to describe the largest investors in the single-family rental market. (See Thomas Malone, The New Normal? Single-Family Investor Activity Remains Steady in Q3, CoreLogic Intelligence (blog), CoreLogic, December 8, 2022, https://www.corelogic.com/intelligence/the-new-normal-single-family-investor-activity-remains-steady-in-q3.)
Thus, if a business entity owns 1,000 homes elsewhere, it is prohibited from purchasing and leasing even one additional home in California. The bill sets a hard cap of 1,000 homes: if a business entity clears a certain number of homes from its portfolio so that it has an interest in fewer than 1,000 homes, it can later purchase and rent out more—up until the 1,000 single-family home cap. Further, the bill's prohibition applies only to buying and leasing; this measure does not limit a business entity, regardless of the number of homes it already owns, from purchasing additional homes, so long as it does not rent them out. It is unclear what the policy rationale is for prohibiting purchase for rent but allowing purchases to just sit vacant or get "flipped" by institutional investors only to be sold at a markup to individual buyers.
This bill's enforcement procedures. Enforcement of this bill's prohibition falls to the Attorney General. It empowers the Attorney General to bring a civil action, imposes a $100,000 civil penalty for each violation (i.e., any additional purchase of a single-family rental in excess of 1,000 by a business entity) and reasonable attorney's fees and costs, and requires the business entity to divest from the property within one year of the date of judgment.
The penalty amount is on the higher end of penalty amounts in law, but penalties in the $100,000 range are not uncommon. Examples of $100,000 penalties include conduct ranging from housing discrimination (Government Code Section 12989.3(f)(3)) to misrepresentations about the flushability of disposable wipes (Public Resources Code Section 49653(b)(1).) One could argue that the civil penalty in combination with the forced sale might run afoul of the Eighth Amendment's prohibition on excessive fines. Furthermore, it is unclear how the forced sale would occur: who would set the price of the listed house? What would happen if the house did not sell?
Additional considerations. As currently written, even if this measure were successful, there is nothing that would stop a business from purchasing 999 homes under one name, and then continuing to buy up additional homes as a different corporate entity. SB 1201 (Durazo), currently pending in the Senate's Banking and Financial Institutions, might help alleviate this concern. SB 1201 requires corporations, limited liability companies (LLCs), and real estate investment trusts to report information about their beneficial owners, as specified, on periodic reports that those business entities are required to file with the Secretary of State and that are made available to the public. That measure, if successful, would help uncover—but not necessarily stop—such gamesmanship from occurring. The definition of "single-family dwelling" also allows for gamesmanship. As drafted, the bill's prohibition applies only to properties that contain a single dwelling unit. So a single-family home that has an "accessory dwelling unit" (which qualifies as a dwelling unit under existing law) would not fall under the purview of this measure. In other words, an institutional investor could add an ADU to the property and evade the bill's "single-family dwelling" prohibition altogether.
According to the Author
Corporations are buying up whole neighborhoods worth of housing inventory. First-time homebuyers are not able to compete with cash offers from these large corporate firms. By outbidding homebuyers and converting properties to rentals, these corporations are taking homeownership opportunities away from hard working Californians and exacerbating the scarcity of single-family homes. This bill will protect Californians' opportunities for stability and homeownership.
Arguments in Support
The Alliance for Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) support this measure:
The bill clears a path for working class homebuyers by prohibiting large corporate real estate firms that own more than 1,000 homes from buying additional homes and converting them to rentals. Home prices have soared in the state of California and the median home price has risen to $800,000 in 2024. Only 15% of Californians can afford to buy a home at current costs.
Meanwhile, institutional investors and large real estate firms have gone on a homebuying spree. In 2022, investors purchased 1 in 3 homes that were on the market. In California, large landlords like Invitation Homes own thousands of single-family properties, primarily buying more affordable homes in cheaper markets. This takes away homebuying opportunities from working families. By passing AB 2584, the state legislature could even the playing field and stop the corporate buy-out of single-family neighborhoods.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Association of Realtors, although strongly supportive of AB 1333 (Ward 2023), which eliminated bundled sales of newly-constructed single-family homes, opposes this measure because it has concerns about its breadth unintended consequences:
AB 2584 (Lee) seeks to eliminate and prohibit anyone from owning more than 1,000 primary (1-unit) single-family homes. As drafted the measure lacks clarity. Among other things, the bill eliminates the opportunity to purchase homes once an owner reached a specified threshold which, if enacted, could be reduced to lower thresholds of unit ownership, thus restricting individual wealth generation opportunities.
The National Rental Home Council opposes this measure:
Single-family rental homes account for nearly 25% of California's housing market, providing access to quality, affordably priced housing for more than 2 million resident households across the state in neighborhoods with proximity to quality schools, employment centers, and transportation corridors. Members of NRHC have demonstrated a steadfast commitment to residents and communities by providing housing that reflects the diverse needs and circumstances of all Californians, both homeowners and renters.
I am concerned about AB 2584 which proposes to target an industry with a modest presence in the California rental housing market. In recent years, many institutional housing investors have been net sellers of single-family rental homes in California. Today, NRHC members own approximately 0.15 of 1% of the approximately 8.5 million single family homes in California – the vast majority of rental housing in California is owned by non-institutional owners ("mom-and-pops"). AB 2584 seeks to outlaw one class of home buyer from freely entering into a contract with another willing party for a home purchase. Given the scant overall institutional presence in the California single family rental home marketplace, this proposal appears to be legislating against a narrative of institutional ownership, not actual statistics.
Institutional owners of housing are able to bring rental housing products to the market more rapidly than some other potential rental property owners. In a high-cost housing market like California, more supply, and choice within that supply, should be an overriding public policy goal. The marketplace demand for rental housing in California is very strong, with many owners having occupancy rates consistently in excess of 95%. Our member companies bring choice to prospective renters who may wish to have a single-family home, versus a multifamily (or other) housing alternative. The occupancy rates of the single-family rental homes reflect the marketplace demand for these housing choices.
The California Chamber of Commerce and the California Building Industry Association both believe that the measure should be further amended:
We appreciate the exemption for "a person or entity primarily engaged in construction". Unfortunately, part of the planned amendments includes a holding period. In doing so, the bill will still prevent homebuilders from producing critically needed housing in the state. In California, it usually takes much longer than 5 years to get property entitled to the point of pulling building permits. Sometimes homebuilders buy land that already has a home on it as we try to get approvals to build even more housing. As proposed, we would be forced to evict the tenants and leave those homes empty to avoid the restrictions of the bill. Our experience has been that leaving homes unoccupied creates a magnet for crime and frequent health and safety calls to the home. Given the current housing crisis, it seems wasteful to leave the property unoccupied.
In addition, in current market conditions it takes much longer than 5 years to sell out of a project. And if we experience a downturn like the Great Recession, it will take a lot longer. Any arbitrary time limit will be counterproductive to the state's housing goals.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis:
- Potential costs (General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ) of an unknown but potentially significant amount if the Attorney General brings civil actions to enforce the prohibition established by this bill. Actual costs will depend on the number of violations and whether the Attorney General decides to file enforcement actions on behalf of the state. If DOJ pursues civil litigation authorized by this bill, it would result in a significant workload increase, likely in excess of $150,000 annually, though costs may be offset by attorney's fees awards if DOJ prevails. If DOJ chooses not to pursue litigation authorized by this bill, DOJ would likely not incur any costs.
- Cost pressures (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to the courts to adjudicate cases authorized by this bill. Actual costs to the courts will depend on the number of cases filed and the amount of court time needed to adjudicate each case. It generally costs approximately $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. If DOJ files two cases and each requires three days of court time to resolve, the resulting workload cost to the courts would be about $48,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The Governor's 2024-25 budget proposes $83.1 million ongoing from the General Fund to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
According to the Legislative Analyst's Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Kalra, Ting, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Reyes
NO: Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Pacheco, Waldron
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-0
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: April 10, 2024
CONSULTANT: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002995
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2584
Author:(Lee) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2024
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 8 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a business entity that owns more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing any additional single-family properties and renting them out. The bill authorizes the Attorney General to enforce this prohibition through civil litigation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Potential costs (General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ) of an unknown but potentially significant amount if the Attorney General brings civil actions to enforce the prohibition established by this bill. Actual costs will depend on the number of violations and whether the Attorney General decides to file enforcement actions on behalf of the state. If DOJ pursues civil litigation authorized by this bill, it would result in a significant workload increase, likely in excess of $150,000 annually, though costs may be offset by attorney’s fees awards if DOJ prevails. If DOJ chooses not to pursue litigation authorized by this bill, DOJ would likely not incur any costs.
- Cost pressures (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to the courts to adjudicate cases authorized by this bill. Actual costs to the courts will depend on the number of cases filed and the amount of court time needed to adjudicate each case. It generally costs approximately $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. If DOJ files two cases and each requires three days of court time to resolve, the resulting workload cost to the courts would be about $48,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. The Governor’s 2024-25 budget proposes $83.1 million ongoing from the General Fund to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Corporations are buying up whole neighborhoods worth of housing inventory. First-time homebuyers are not able to compete with cash offers from these large corporate firms. By outbidding homebuyers and converting properties to rentals, these corporations are taking homeownership opportunities away from hard working Californians and exacerbating the scarcity of single-family homes. This bill will protect Californians’ opportunities for stability and homeownership.
- Background. California is in a serious housing crisis, with record low levels of homes available for purchase in the state. There are many factors that have contributed to the current crisis, but this bill takes aim at institutional investors – generally corporations or other business entities – that purchase hundreds or thousands of single-family homes and rent them out, rendering them unavailable for purchase by prospective individual homeowners.
This bill prohibits a business entity with an ownership interest in more than 1,000 single-family homes in their portfolio from purchasing and renting out any more single-family homes. Under the bill, this prohibition is enforceable by DOJ through civil litigation. As detailed in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, institutional investors own a very small percentage of single-family homes in California, with applicable business entities making up less of 1% of home purchases in the state in 2023. The policy committee analysis also notes some practical challenges in enforcing the bill’s prohibitions – for example, a business entity could easily form multiple related corporate entities to purchase more than 1,000 homes. Regardless, by authorizing DOJ to bring civil enforcement actions, the bill may result in significant costs to the state, with actual costs depending on the number of actions brought and the amount of court time needed to adjudicate them.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2584
Author:(Lee) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2024
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Single-family residential real property: corporate entity: ownership
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD CALIFORNIA PROHIBIT certain business entities that have an interest in more than 1,000 single-family homes from purchasing and leasing any additional single-family homes?
SYNOPSIS
California is facing a housing crisis. The inventory of available homes—especially affordable entry-level homes—in the state is severely constrained. In tackling this issue, the Legislature has focused on increasing supply and maintaining home affordability, but with limited success. The decline in homeownership has resulted in a growing population of renters. As institutional investors acquire a larger number of homes, they may contribute to an increase in property prices, making it more challenging for individual households, especially first-time buyers, to enter the housing market. With their deep pockets, these institutional buyers can often outbid individual homebuyers, driving up prices in the process. This leaves first-time homebuyers struggling to compete in real estate markets where affordability already is a concern.
Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate build or buy to rent model by prohibiting business entities with an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing another single-family residential property and leasing it out. The rise of corporation ownership of single-family homes is limited in this state—the percentage of homes purchased by the “mega investors” this bill targets (i.e., those with more 1,000 single-family homes in their portfolio) was less than 1% of home purchases in 2023. According to the author, by prohibiting mega investors from buying and leasing more single-family homes, it clears a path for first time and working class homebuyers. This measure is supported by the AIDS Healthcare Foundation and the Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE). Opposition includes the California Apartment Association, the National Rental Home Council, and the California Association of Realtors. The California Building Industry Association and the Chamber of Commerce oppose the bill in print. As proposed to be amended, the bill exempts builders if they apply for a building permit within 5 years of purchase. These amendments resolves some, but not all, of their concerns. The amendments are incorporated into the SUMMARY, below, and explained in the analysis.
SUMMARY: Prohibits business entities that own more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing any additional single-family properties and leasing them out. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “business entity” as any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entity’s successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include a nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
- Excludes from the definition of “business entity” any of the following:
- A nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
- A person or entity primarily engaged in the construction of housing so long as they do not hold a given property longer than 5 years without pulling building permits.
- Defines “single-family residential property” as real property improved with one dwelling unit.
- Prohibits a business entity that has an interest in more than 1,000 single-family residential properties from purchasing, acquiring, or otherwise obtaining an interest in another single-family residential property and subsequently lease the property.
- Authorizes the Attorney General to bring a civil action in the name of the people of the State of California for a violation of this bill.
- Establishes that if the Attorney General prevails in a civil action, the court must order the following relief:
- Reasonable attorney’s fees and costs;
- The business entity to pay a civil penalty of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) for each violation;
- The business entity to sell the property to an independent third party within one year of the date that the court enters the judgment; and
- Any other relief the court deems appropriate.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines “business entity” as any organization or enterprise operated for profit, including but not limited to a proprietorship, partnership, firm, business trust, joint venture, syndicate, corporation or association. (Government Code Section 82005.)
- Defines “business entity” as a sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation, association or other group, however organized and whether or not organized to operate at a profit, but does not mean a financial institution organized, chartered, or holding a license or authorization certificate under a law of this state or the United States to make loans or extend credit and subject to supervision by an official or agency of this state or the United States, nor the parent of any such financial institution, nor any subsidiary of any such financial institution or parent. (Civil Code Section 1799 (b).)
- Defines “single-family residential property” as one of the following:
- Real property improved with one to four dwelling units.
- A unit in a residential stock cooperative, condominium, or planned unit development.
- A mobilehome or manufactured home when offered for sale or sold through a real estate license, as provided.
- A qualified ownership interest in real property subject to an agreement providing the owner the right to occupy one to four dwelling units on that property. (Civil Code Section 1670.12 (a)(2).)
- “Dwelling unit” means a structure or the part of a structure that is used as a home, residence, or sleeping place by one person who maintains a household or by two or more persons who maintain a common household. (Civil Code Section 1940 (c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: California is facing a housing crisis. The inventory of available homes—especially of affordable entry-level homes—is severely constrained. In tackling this issue, the Legislature has focused on increasing supply and maintaining home affordability, but with limited success. The decline in homeownership has resulted in a growing population of renters. Recognizing the importance of homeownership for financial stability, this bill seeks to stymie the rise of corporate “buy/build-to-rent” model by prohibiting business entities with large single-family home portfolios from purchasing and renting out property in the state. According to the author:
Corporations are buying up whole neighborhoods worth of housing inventory. First-time homebuyers are not able to compete with cash offers from these large corporate firms. By outbidding homebuyers and converting properties to rentals, these corporations are taking homeownership opportunities away from hard working Californians and exacerbating the scarcity of single-family homes. This bill will protect Californians’ opportunities for stability and homeownership.
The housing affordability crisis. Housing affordability is a primary concern of the California Legislature—and rightfully so. According to the California Association of Realtors’ Traditional Housing Affordability Index (HAI), California hit a peak high affordability index of 56 percent in 2012. Ten years later, however, only 21 percent of California households could afford to purchase the median-priced home $790,020, down from 27 percent at the end of 2021. (California Association of Realtors Housing Affordability Index, Data for the 4th quarter of 2022, available at https://www.car.org/marketdata/data/haitraditional.) A major cause of our housing crisis is the mismatch between the supply of housing and the demand for housing. In 2022, the Statewide Housing Plan adopted by the Housing and Community Development Department (HCD) found that California needs approximately 2.5 million units of housing, including one million units that are affordable to lower income households, in order to address this mismatch. (HCD, California Statewide Housing Plan: A Home for Every Californian (March 2022), available at https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/94729ab1648d43b1811c1698a748c136.) That would require production of over 300,000 units a year, including over 120,000 units a year of housing affordable to lower income households. By contrast, housing production in the past decade has been under 80,000 units per year. (HCD, Addressing a Variety of Housing Challenges, available at https://www.hcd.ca.gov/policy-and-research/addressing-variety-housing-challenges (last accessed Jan. 8, 2024).)
The decline of owner-occupancy rates in California. The lack of affordable housing, likely in combination with other interrelated factors, such as demographic shifts delaying in life-cycle milestones such as marriage and childbearing (or the decision to forego those milestones altogether), has resulted in a decline in home ownership. In 2022, California’s homeownership rate—the percentage of California homes owned by their occupants—stood at 55.3%, one percent higher than the preceding year. (U.S. Census Bureau, Homeownership Rate for California, available at https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CAHOWN.) This rate is down from a high of 60.2 percent in 2006, at the peak of the housing bubble, and represents a trend of decreasing home-ownership since the Great Recession. (Ibid.) The decline was even more stark for younger Californians aged 35–45. For that group, the share who owned a home declined from 49.5 percent to 39.7, almost 10 percentage points from 2000 to 2021. (Shoag, et al., Terner Center for Housing Innovation, U.C. Berkeley, The First Step Is The Hardest: California’s Sliding Homeownership Ladder (May 2023), available at https://ternercenter.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/Homeownership-Ladder-May-2023-Final.pdf.)
While more pronounced in California, this reflects a national trend. According to census data, between 2007 and 2017, the United States added less than 1 million households in owner-occupied homes, but 6.5 million in renter-occupied homes. The national homeownership rate bottomed out at 62.9 percent in 2016, down from a high of 69 percent in 2005. (U.S. Census Bureau, Homeownership Rate in the United States, available at https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N.) The decline in homeownership has resulted in a corresponding increase in rental demand, and a corresponding untenable increase in rental rates. The majority of Californian renters—more than 3 million households—pay more than 30 percent of their income toward rent, and nearly one-third—more than 1.5 million households—pay more than 50 percent of their income toward rent. (https://www.hcd.ca.gov/policy-and-research/addressing-variety-housing-challenges.) Those renting are increasingly looking for single-family residences. An estimated 39 percent of rental housing units in the United States are single-family dwellings. (Real Estate Consulting, Single-Family Rental Housing – Institutional Opportunities (August 9, 2022) available at https://www.rclco.com/publication/prea-quarterly-single-family-rental-housing-institutional-opportunities/.)
The corporate single-family rental makes up a tiny share of rental properties. The overwhelming majority of single-family rentals are owned by smaller landlords. In June 2021, the Urban Land Institute reported that small-scale investors own 97 percent of the nation’s single-family rental inventory, meaning that the share of institutional investors is just three percent. (Congressional Research Service, Single-Family Market Rents and Institutional Investors, October 3, 2022, available at https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF12225.) This report defined “institutional investors” as those owning more than 2,000 units. According to a 2022 report by the National Association of Realtors, institutional buyers—which they defined as companies, corporations, or limited liability companies (LLCs) regardless of the number of units owned—made up 13 percent of the residential sales market in 2021, with the median purchase price of institutional buyers typically 26 percent lower than the states’ median purchase prices. (National Association of Realtors, Impact of Institutional Buyers on Home Sales and Single Family Rentals (May 2022), available at https://www.nar.realtor/sites/default/files/documents/2022-impact-of-institutional-buyers-on-home-sales-and-single-family-rentals-05-12-2022.pdf.)
In California, the percentage of institutional investors is tiny. According to a March 6, 2024 Roofstock report, business entities that have more than 1,000 homes in their portfolio represented less than 1% of California home purchases in 2023. In other words, even in the absence of legislation, the group that this bill is targeting purchased only 0.8% of all single-family homes sold in the state last year. This represents a slight decrease from the 0.9% of single- family homes they purchased the year prior.
Though currently small, the author points to the growing national trend of the corporate build/buy-to-rent single-family home model, the fluctuation in interest rates, and the serious concerns it raises about home affordability and availability—particularly in a market with constrained inventory.
Corporate landlords. Corporate ownership of single-family homes is a newer phenomenon. The increase in institutional investors began during the Great Recession, when housing prices dropped precipitously and credit tightened. (Lambie-Hanson, L. et al., Leaving Households Behind: Institutional Investors and the U.S. Housing Recovery (2019), available at https://www.philadelphiafed.org/-/media/frbp/assets/working-papers/2019/wp19-01.pdf.) During the financial crisis, investors bought foreclosed properties, often at a discount, with institutional buyers joining the usual cash investors. (Francesca Mari, New York Times, A $60 Billion Housing Grab By Wall Street (March 4. 2020), available at New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/04/magazine/wall-street-landlords.html.) Institutional buyers are entities with substantial financial resources, such as real estate investment trusts (REITs), private equity firms, and hedge funds. Unlike individual homebuyers who depend on federally-backed financing to purchase homes, institutional investors can purchase properties with cash. They were thus uniquely situated to purchase large numbers of foreclosed properties that might have not qualified for federally-backed loans. As hundreds of thousands of homes went into foreclosure, the federal government sought to stabilize housing prices by increasing demand for the homes by creating incentives for private investors to make bulk purchases. (Alana Semuels, When Wall Street Is Your Landlord, The Atlantic, (February 13, 2019) available at https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2019/02/single-family-landlords-wall-street/582394/.) Thus, institutional investors’ entry into the market for single-family residences came against the backdrop of staggering foreclosure rates, economic uncertainty, and government incentives.
The rate of investor purchases surged again during the COVID-19 pandemic. In the first quarter of 2022, investor purchases of single- family homes averaged 28 percent per month, compared with 19 percent the previous year: significant increases from the average of 16 percent between 2017 and 2019. (Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, State of the Nation’s Housing (2022), available at https://www.jchs.harvard.edu/state-nations-housing-2022.)
Institutional investors had long avoided the single-family market because of the challenge of managing dispersed properties. (Mari, New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/04/magazine/wall-street-landlords.html.) Digital technologies, including improved data and analytics, however, have transformed the single-family rental market. (Fields, D., Vergerio, UC Berkeley, Corporate landlords and market power: What does the single-family rental boom mean for our housing future? (2022), available at https://escholarship.org/uc/item/07d6445s.) Technology has made both purchasing and managing dispersed rental properties more efficient and profitable. Corporate owners can use digital tools to acquire property quickly and can use other tools to screen applicants, accept payments, manage maintenance requests, and gather data on rental markets.
Within regions across the country, researchers find that large corporate investors buying single-family rentals and rent-to-own units tend to concentrate their purchases at the neighborhood level, primarily in “low income, historically non-white neighborhoods that have suffered from disinvestment, but where gentrification or real estate cycle dynamics predict medium term price increases.” (Raymond, E., et al., Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta., Large corporate buyers of residential rental housing during the COVID19 pandemic in three southeastern metropolitan areas (2022), available at https://bpb-us-w2.wpmucdn.com/sites.gatech.edu/dist/d/2497/files/2022/01/ERaymond-2022-CorporateLandlords_PandemicPurchases.pdf.) In a zero-sum housing environment, where demand far exceeds supply, resulting in higher home prices, corporate winners means individual losers. A large majority of Americans report wanting to own a home and seeing homeownership as the best marker of financial success and security. (Schmidt, G., Homeownership Remains the American Dream, Despite Challenges, (June 2, 2022) The New York Times, available at https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/02/realestate/homeownership-affordability-survey.html.)
Opponents of this bill see the concentration of institutional capital in low-income areas as a societal positive: corporate rentals provide a desired product for those wanting the advantages of single-home living without the burden. They also point to data suggesting that rents of mid-tier single-family rental homes are significantly lower than the mortgage payment of entry level homes in many areas across the state. For example, San Jose and San Francisco represent the top two metro areas in the country where the spread in cost between renting and owning a home with a mortgage is the widest. (Renting Is Usually Cheaper Than Owning, but Not Always — Here’s How They Compare in the Nation’s 50 Largest Metros, Feb. 12, 2024, available at https://www.lendingtree.com/home/mortgage/comparing-rent-vs-owning-a-home-in-nations-largest-metros/).
In addition to depriving individual buyers of the opportunity to purchase homes, the rise of the corporate home ownership poses other problems. Corporate landlords are usually detached from the communities where the rental properties are located, and may be more motivated by profit-maximizing than the average “mom-and-pop” landlord. A 2017 study published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta found that corporate landlords, especially those which are large institutional investors, were far likelier than other owners to evict their tenants. (Raymond, E., et al., FRB Atlanta Community and Economic Development Discussion Paper No. 2016-4, Corporate Landlords, Institutional Investors, and Displacement: Eviction Rates in Singlefamily Rentals (2016), available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=2893552.) In 2018, a Reuters special investigation of Invitation Homes, a creation of private equity giant Blackstone Group LP, found after “interviews with scores of the company’s tenants in neighborhoods across the United States, the picture that emerges isn’t as much one of exceptional service as it is one of leaky pipes, toxic mold, nonfunctioning appliances, and months-long waits for repairs.” (Michelle Conlin, Reuters, Spiders, sewage and a flurry of fees – the other side of renting a house from Wall Street (July 27, 2018), available at https://www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-housing-invitation/.) Earlier this year, Attorney General Bonta announced a $3.7 million settlement with Invitation Homes to resolve allegations that it violated California’s rent cap law. (Liam Dillon, Los Angeles Times, Nation’s largest single-family home landlord to pay $3.7 million in California rent-gouging case (January 8, 2024), available at https://www.latimes.com/homeless-housing/story/2024-01-08/invitation-homes-tenant-rent-gouging-settlement.)
This bill prohibits business entities with an interest in more than 1,000 single-family homes in their portfolio from purchasing and leasing out any additional single-family homes. The prohibition applies to a business entity that owns more than 1,000 units anywhere, as it is intended to target the country’s “mega investors” regardless of how many homes they may own in the state. While there is no universally accepted definition of institutional ownership, the 1,000 figure is commonly used to describe the largest investors in the single-family rental market. (See Thomas Malone, The New Normal? Single-Family Investor Activity Remains Steady in Q3, CoreLogic Intelligence (blog), CoreLogic, December 8, 2022, https://www.corelogic.com/intelligence/the-new-normal-single-family-investor-activity-remains-steady-in-q3.)
Thus, if a business entity owns 1,000 homes elsewhere, it is prohibited from purchasing and leasing even one additional home in California. The bill sets a hard cap of 1,000 homes: if a business entity clears a certain number of homes from its portfolio so that it has an interest in fewer than 1,000 homes, it can later purchase and rent out more—up until the 1,000 single-family home cap.
Further, the bill’s prohibition applies only to buying and leasing; this measure does not limit a business entity, regardless of the number of homes it already owns, from purchasing additional homes, so long as it does not rent them out. It is unclear what the policy rationale is for prohibiting purchase for rent but allowing purchases to just sit vacant or get “flipped” by institutional investors only to be sold at a markup to individual buyers.
The author is proposing amendments to this measure that exempt nonprofit entities and builders who applied for permits within 5 years of purchasing the property from the definition of business entity. These amendments are intended to assuage concerns that this measure might stall housing development. While these amendments address some of the concerns of opposition, the author may wish to further amend the bill to remove the 5-year holding period, based on opposition’s representations that it usually takes longer than five years to obtain permitting and it is inefficient and counter-productive for that property to sit vacant in order to avoid this bill’s prohibition.
This bill’s enforcement procedures. Enforcement of this bill’s prohibition falls to the Attorney General. It empowers the Attorney General to bring a civil action, imposes a $100,000 civil penalty for each violation (i.e., any additional purchase of a single-family rental in excess of 1,000 by a business entity) and reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, and requires the business entity to divest from the property within one year of the date of judgment.
The penalty amount is on the higher end of penalty amounts in law, but penalties in the $100,000 range are not uncommon. Examples of $100,000 penalties include conduct ranging from housing discrimination (Government Code Section 12989.3(f)(3)) to misrepresentations about the flushability of disposable wipes (Public Resources Code Section 49653(b)(1).) One could argue that the civil penalty in combination with the forced sale might run afoul of the Eighth Amendment’s prohibition on excessive fines. Furthermore, it is unclear how the forced sale would occur: who would set the price of the listed house? What would happen if the house did not sell?
Additional considerations. As currently written, even if this measure were successful, there is nothing that would stop a business from purchasing 999 homes under one name, and then continuing to buy up additional homes as a different corporate entity. SB 1201 (Durazo), currently pending in the Senate’s Banking and Financial Institutions, might help alleviate this concern. SB 1201 requires corporations, limited liability companies (LLCs), and real estate investment trusts to report information about their beneficial owners, as specified, on periodic reports that those business entities are required to file with the Secretary of State and that are made available to the public. That measure, if successful, would help uncover—but not necessarily stop—such gamesmanship from occurring.
The definition of “single-family dwelling” also allows for gamesmanship. As drafted, the bill’s prohibition applies only to properties that contain a single dwelling unit. So a single-family home that has an “accessory dwelling unit” (which qualifies as a dwelling unit under existing law) would not fall under the purview of this measure. In other words, an institutional investor could add an ADU to the property and evade the bill’s “single-family dwelling” prohibition altogether.
Author’s amendments. In order to assuage concerns that this measure might adversely affect housing construction in the state, the author proposes the following amendments, exempting certain builders:
945.20. (a) For purposes of this title, the following definitions apply.
(1) “Business entity” means any association, company, firm, partnership, corporation, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, real estate investment trust, or other legal entity, and that entity’s successors, assignees, or affiliates, but does not include either of the following: a nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
(A) A nonprofit corporation or other nonprofit legal entity.
(B) A person or entity primarily engaged in the construction of housing, only if the person or entity does not hold a given property longer than five years without applying for building permits for that property.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Alliance for Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) support this measure:
The bill clears a path for working class homebuyers by prohibiting large corporate real estate firms that own more than 1,000 homes from buying additional homes and converting them to rentals. Home prices have soared in the state of California and the median home price has risen to $800,000 in 2024. Only 15% of Californians can afford to buy a home at current costs.
Meanwhile, institutional investors and large real estate firms have gone on a homebuying spree. In 2022, investors purchased 1 in 3 homes that were on the market. In California, large landlords like Invitation Homes own thousands of single-family properties, primarily buying more affordable homes in cheaper markets. This takes away homebuying opportunities from working families. By passing AB 2584, the state legislature could even the playing field and stop the corporate buy-out of single-family neighborhoods.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Association of Realtors, although strongly supportive of AB 1333 (Ward 2023), which eliminated bundled sales of newly-constructed single-family homes, opposes this measure because it has concerns about its breadth unintended consequences:
AB 2584 (Lee) seeks to eliminate and prohibit anyone from owning more than 1,000 primary (1-unit) single-family homes. As drafted the measure lacks clarity. Among other things, the bill eliminates the opportunity to purchase homes once an owner reached a specified threshold which, if enacted, could be reduced to lower thresholds of unit ownership, thus restricting individual wealth generation opportunities.
The National Rental Home Council opposes this measure:
Single-family rental homes account for nearly 25% of California’s housing market, providing access to quality, affordably priced housing for more than 2 million resident households across the state in neighborhoods with proximity to quality schools, employment centers, and transportation corridors. Members of NRHC have demonstrated a steadfast commitment to residents and communities by providing housing that reflects the diverse needs and circumstances of all Californians, both homeowners and renters.
I am concerned about AB 2584 which proposes to target an industry with a modest presence in the California rental housing market. In recent years, many institutional housing investors have been net sellers of single-family rental homes in California. Today, NRHC members own approximately 0.15 of 1% of the approximately 8.5 million single family homes in California – the vast majority of rental housing in California is owned by non-institutional owners (“mom-and-pops”).
AB 2584 seeks to outlaw one class of home buyer from freely entering into a contract with another willing party for a home purchase. Given the scant overall institutional presence in the California single family rental home marketplace, this proposal appears to be legislating against a narrative of institutional ownership, not actual statistics.
Institutional owners of housing are able to bring rental housing products to the market more rapidly than some other potential rental property owners. In a high-cost housing market like California, more supply, and choice within that supply, should be an overriding public policy goal. The marketplace demand for rental housing in California is very strong, with many owners having occupancy rates consistently in excess of 95%. Our member companies bring choice to prospective renters who may wish to have a single-family home, versus a multifamily (or other) housing alternative. The occupancy rates of the single-family rental homes reflect the marketplace demand for these housing choices.
Institutional owners of housing are able to bring rental housing products to the market more rapidly than some other potential rental property owners. In a high-cost housing market like California, more supply, and choice within that supply, should be an overriding public policy goal. The marketplace demand for rental housing in California is very strong, with many owners having occupancy rates consistently in excess of 95%. Our member companies bring choice to prospective renters who may wish to have a single-family home, versus a multifamily (or other) housing alternative. The occupancy rates of the single-family rental homes reflect the marketplace demand for these housing choices.
The California Chamber of Commerce and the California Building Industry Association both believe that the measure should be further amended:
We appreciate the exemption for “a person or entity primarily engaged in construction”. Unfortunately, part of the planned amendments includes a holding period. In doing so, the bill will still prevent homebuilders from producing critically needed housing in the state. In California, it usually takes much longer than 5 years to get property entitled to the point of pulling building permits. Sometimes homebuilders buy land that already has a home on it as we try to get approvals to build even more housing. As proposed, we would be forced to evict the tenants and leave those homes empty to avoid the restrictions of the bill. Our experience has been that leaving homes unoccupied creates a magnet for crime and frequent health and safety calls to the home. Given the current housing crisis, it seems wasteful to leave the property unoccupied.
In addition, in current market conditions it takes much longer than 5 years to sell out of a project. And if we experience a downturn like the Great Recession, it will take a lot longer. Any arbitrary time limit will be counterproductive to the state’s housing goals.
Related pending state legislation: AB 1212 (Skinner): This bill prohibits an investment entity, as defined, from purchasing or acquiring an interest, as defined, in a single-family dwelling or other dwelling that consists of one or 2 residential units with the state. Status: Pending, Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1333 (Ward): This bill prohibits a developer of residential one to 4 dwelling units, inclusive, from conducting a sale of 2 or more parcels of real property containing one to 4 residential dwelling units in a single transaction to an institutional investor, if the occupancy permit was issued on or after January 1, 2025.
Related pending federal legislation. S.3402 (Merkley): This bill imposes an excise tax on hedge fund taxpayers that own a certain number of single-family residences in excess of a specified amount.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) Action
Opposition
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
National Rental Home Council
Southern California Rental Housing Association
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Business Roundtable
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):