AB 2677: Sureties: liability.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-04
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-09-22: Vetoed by Governor.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law authorizes a beneficiary to enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties by civil action. Under existing law, a judgment of liability on a bond, except as specified, is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties, and obligates each of them jointly and severally. Existing law provides that except as specified, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond, and that the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond.
This bill would define aggregate liability, for purposes of the provisions above, to include all liability for damages, costs, and attorneys fees, including any attorneys fees that may be assessed as costs, if recoverable. The bill would define surety for these purposes as a corporate insurer or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in the state.
Existing law authorizes a beneficiary to enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties by civil action. Under existing law, a judgment of liability on a bond, except as specified, is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties, and obligates each of them jointly and severally. Existing law provides that except as specified, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond, and that the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond.
This bill would define aggregate liability, for purposes of the provisions above, to include all liability for damages, costs, and attorneys fees, including any attorneys fees that may be assessed as costs, if recoverable. The bill would provide that unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorneys fees against the surety, a surety is not liable for an award of attorneys fees as costs. The bill would define surety for these purposes as a corporate insurer or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in the state.
Existing law authorizes a beneficiary to enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties by civil action. Under existing law, a judgment of liability on a bond, except as specified, is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties, and obligates each of them jointly and severally. Existing law provides that except as specified, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond, and that the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond.
This bill would define aggregate liability, for purposes of the provisions above, to include all liability for damages, costs, and attorneys fees, if recoverable. The bill would provide that unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorneys fees against the surety, a surety is not liable for an award of attorneys fees as costs.
(a)Notwithstanding any statute other than Section 996.480, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond, including any attorneys fees that may be assessed as costs pursuant to paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) of Section 1033.5 or similar statute, is limited to the amount of the bond. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond.
(b)If a bond is given in an amount greater than the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer pursuant to statute, the liability of the surety on the bond is limited to the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer, unless the amount of the bond has been increased voluntarily or by agreement of the parties to satisfy an objection to the bond made in an action or proceeding.
(c)The liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in any of the following circumstances:
(1)The bond contains a stipulation pursuant to Section 995.520 that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety.
(2)The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond.
(d)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Aggregate liability includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorneys fees, if recoverable.
(2)Surety means an admitted surety insurer as defined in Section 995.120.
(a)Notwithstanding any statute other than Section 996.480, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond bond, including any attorneys fees that may be assessed as costs pursuant to paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) of Section 1033.5 or similar statute, is limited to the amount of the bond. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. Unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorneys fees against the surety under the bond, a surety is not liable for an award of attorneys fees as costs.
(b)If a bond is given in an amount greater than the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer pursuant to statute, the liability of the surety on the bond is limited to the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer, unless the amount of the bond has been increased voluntarily or by agreement of the parties to satisfy an objection to the bond made in an action or proceeding.
(c)The liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in any of the following circumstances:
(1)The bond contains a stipulation pursuant to Section 995.520 that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety.
(2)The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond.
(d)For purposes of this section, aggregate liability includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorneys fees, if recoverable. the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Aggregate liability includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorneys fees, if recoverable.
(2)Surety means an admitted surety insurer as defined in Section 995.120.
(a)Notwithstanding any other statute other than Section 996.480, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. Unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorneys fees against the surety under the bond, a surety is not liable for an award of attorneys fees as costs.
(b)If a bond is given in an amount greater than the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer pursuant to statute, the liability of the surety on the bond is limited to the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer, unless the amount of the bond has been increased voluntarily or by agreement of the parties to satisfy an objection to the bond made in an action or proceeding.
(c)The liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in any of the following circumstances:
(1)The bond contains a stipulation pursuant to Section 995.520 that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety.
(2)The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond.
(d)For purposes of this section, aggregate liability includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorneys fees, if recoverable.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 22, 2024 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2024 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 30, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 34. Noes 3.). |
| Jun 27, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 26, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (June 25). |
| May 17, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 8, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 4995.) |
| Apr 18, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 16, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 16). |
| Apr 8, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 4, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2677 Chen By Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | [06-25-2024] set for [First] hearing: Reconsideration of favorable vote granted | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2024 | AB 2677 Chen Consent Calendar Second Day | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| American Property Casualty Insurance Association | ** Support | |
| American Subcontractors Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Associated Builders And Contractors Of California | ** Support | |
| Associated General Contractors | ** Support | |
| ASSOCIATED GENERAL CONTRACTORS SAN DIEGO CHAPTER | ** Support | |
| Associated Roofing Contractors of Bay Area Counties, Inc. | ** Support | |
| California Builders Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Low-Income Consumer Coalition | ** Against | |
| Civil Justice Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Consumer Federation Of California | ** Against | |
| Consumers For Auto Reliability And Safety | ** Against | |
| Contractors State License Board | ** Support | |
| Elder Law & Advocacy | ** Against | |
| Flasher Barricade Association | ** Support | |
| Masonry Contractors Association of California, Inc. | ** Support | |
| painting & decorating contractors of california inc. | ** Support | |
| Roofing Contractors Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange | ** Support | |
| Southern California Contractors Association | ** Support | |
| Union Roofing Contractors Assn | ** Support | |
| Union Roofing Contractors Association | ** Support | |
| United Contractors | ** Support | |
| Western Electrical Contractors Association Inc. | ** Support |
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 2677
Author:(Chen)
As Enrolled Ver:September 4, 2024
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Clarifies that a license sureties' liability is limited to the penal sum of the bond.
Major Provisions
- Specifies that attorney's fees that may be assessed as costs when authorized by contract, statute, or law are included under the provision that limits the aggregate liability of a surety to the amount of the bond.
- Defines "aggregate liability" to include all liability for damages, costs, or attorney's fees, if recoverable.
- Defines "surety" for purposes of the section as an "admitted surety insurer," as provided by law.
Governor's Veto Message
This bill would cap the aggregate liability of an insurer that issues a surety bond to the amount of the bond.
While I appreciate the author's attempt to reduce the cost of bonds for licensees, California law offers numerous avenues for insurers to limit their liability for attorney fees when faced with meritorious claims. I am concerned that this bill's limitation of attorney fees could have the unintended consequence of preventing all but the most affluent consumers from being able to seek redress if they are harmed.
COMMENTS
Existing law establishes that the aggregate liability of a surety for breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. According to the author, the statute needs to be clarified so that "aggregate liability" of the license surety includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorney's fees.
What is a surety license bond? Generally, a surety is defined as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. A surety license bond refers to a type of bond that certain professionals or businesses are required to obtain as a condition of obtaining or maintaining a license to operate within the state. This bond serves as a form of financial guarantee to ensure compliance with laws and regulations governing the respective industry. If the bonded party fails to meet their obligations, the bond can be used to compensate consumers harmed by the licensee.
Examples of professions or businesses that may be required to obtain a surety license bond in California include:
- Contractors: Under the Contractors' State License Law, contractors are required to obtain a contractor's license bond (California Business and Professions Code Section 7071.6).
- Auto Dealers: California Vehicle Code Section 11710 mandates auto dealers to obtain a motor vehicle dealer bond as a condition of obtaining and maintaining their dealer license.
- Mortgage Brokers and Lenders: Mortgage brokers and lenders must secure a mortgage loan originator bond or mortgage broker bond (California Financial Code Section 50141).
The surety bond amount requirement differs across licensing categories.
Bond requirements ensure professionals get licensed and that consumers have a financial recourse. According to the author, with over 285,000 licensed contractors in California, contractors comprise the largest group of license bond holders. This bill applies to all surety insurers across all professions, but with contractors making up the largest category of licensed professionals who are required to maintain a surety, this analysis will focus on that group, as a recent court decision relating to contractor's license surety bonds was the impetus for this bill. Contractor's license bonds are required for every licensed contractor—no matter how large or small—in the state. License bond sureties typically write them in exchange for a signed indemnity agreement and an annual premium of several hundred dollars, depending on the insurer. In general, the bond premium is the same regardless of the size or experience of the contractor. In this way, even the smallest contractor can afford the bond and the surety's risk (now $25,000) is relatively modest as well. This encourages licensure and therefore regulation by the license board which is designed and intended to protect the public from violations of the license law by licensed contractors.
The legislative intent behind requiring contractor license bonds primarily revolves around safeguarding consumers against financial harm resulting from contractor malpractice or non-compliance with contractual obligations. By imposing bonding requirements, lawmakers sought to provide a financial recourse for consumers in cases of contractor default, abandonment, or substandard workmanship. If contractors have posted a bond that is controlled by state, the Contractors State Licensing Board can access the bond and make the consumer whole. The bond amount has increased over time by statutory changes.
Recent court decision rules that surety's exposure to attorney's fees not capped. A recent California appellate court opinion (Karton v. Ari Design & Construction, Inc. (2021) 61 Cal.App. 5th 734) held that a surety under a contractor license bond was liable for the full amount of a $90,000 attorney fee award entered against the contractor even though the bond limit was only $12,500. More recently, in an unreported February 2024 decision another California appellate court - relying on the precedent set forth in Karton - held that a surety was liable for the full amount of a $264,440 attorney fee award even though the bond limit was only $50,000. (See Gonzalez v. Hudson Ins. Co., No. D080166, 2024 WL 566058 (Cal. Ct. App. Feb. 13, 2024); see also Vehicle Code Section 11710 (setting the surety bond for auto dealers at $50,000).) Prior to Karton, a surety's exposure to attorney's fees was understood to be capped by the penal sum of its bond. According to the author, if this decision is left uncorrected by the Legislature, the effect on licensed businesses will be devastating:
These cases have thrown the once-stable market into turmoil. The second largest writer of contractor license bonds has already left the market. Others may follow. Those remaining will likely have to increase the premium they charge for these bonds, tighten underwriting requirements, and even require collateral. The result has left, or may result in, many contractors without an affordable market to purchase license bonds. When a surety pays on a bond, its bond principal (the contractor) is required to reimburse the surety what it has paid. How many contractors could reimburse their surety company $90,000.00? This would put many of them out of business or file for bankruptcy. If the cost of the bond becomes exorbitant and the specter of reimbursement prohibitive, many contractors will have no choice but to go unlicensed. This will hit small and emerging contractors the hardest.
This view is supported by the legislative history and public policy. A 2020 CSLB report tasked with determining whether to increase the bond limit for contractors from $15,000 to $25,000 raised the policy implications of raising the cap and its effect on the market:
[I]ncreasing the bond amount raises questions about the higher costs of obtaining a contractor license and/or limiting the pool of available contractors by doing so. The "barrier to licensure" concern of increasing the bond would be the increase in the cost of the bond precluding new people from entering the construction field, which not only keeps such individuals from earning a living but may increase the cost of construction services by limiting access to the number of available contractors. The result could be a negative impact to consumers in a manner that outweighs the intended benefit of raising the bond, which is to provide more funds for consumers who are injured by the acts of a contractor.(SB 610(Glazer) License Bond Study, Jan. 21, 2021, available at https://www.cslb.ca.gov/About_Us/Library/Reports.aspx.)
This bill clarifies that the penal cap of the "aggregate liability" of a surety license bond includes attorney's fees and costs. In other words, the amount that can be collected against the surety, including any attorney fees and costs, is capped at the penal limit. In the example of a contractor's license bond, the amount that can be collected against the surety (including any attorney's fees or costs) could not exceed $25,000. The liability of the principal (i.e., the licensee) remains unchanged.
According to the Author
The author writes that while the current state of affairs following the Karton decision is extremely problematic for the principal (i.e., the licensed professional), and the surety company that underwrites the bond – but, ultimately, the real harm will befall California consumer:
Fewer licensed contractors will mean less competition and the higher priced bond cost will be passed along to consumers (especially homeowners). Those homeowners will be tempted to hire unlicensed contractors who can no longer afford or qualify for license bonds. These now-unregulated contractors would pose substantial risks to unsuspecting homeowners (and other consumers) by exposing them to shoddy workmanship, abandonment or even life/safety injury or loss.
Arguments in Support
The American Subcontractors Association of California (ASAC) explain the need for this measure:
The recent California appellate court opinion in Karton v. Ari Design (61 Cal. App. 5th 734) has brought to light an issue regarding the liability of surety bond companies holding licensed contractor bonds. Specifically, the opinion indicated that these companies may be compelled to pay attorney fees for litigating parties in cases where genuinely disputed claims necessitate litigation. Consequently, sureties are beginning to receive these types of claims for attorney fees.
AB 2677 aims to address this issue by defining "aggregate liability" to include all liability for damages, costs, and attorney's fees, if recoverable. Further, the bill provides that unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorney's fees against the surety, a surety is not liable for an award of attorney's fees as costs.
The potential for unlimited attorney's fees payouts poses a significant risk and will likely necessitate higher bond premiums. Additionally, surety companies may opt to restrict the issuance of contractor bonds or even exit the market altogether. AB 2677 is aimed at preserving accessible contractor bonds while upholding consumer protections. Therefore, ASAC fully supports this measure.
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of organizations that represent moderate and low-income consumers, families, and small business owners write in opposition to the bill, arguing that passage of AB 2677 would:
- Harm millions of moderate and low-income Californians victimized by unscrupulous, predatory, and illicit fly-by-night and under-capitalized individuals and entities, by limiting the victims' attorney's fees to the amount of the bond, thereby denying them access to justice.
- Render surety bonds worthless for victims of illegal conduct and fraud committed by entities that are required to obtain a bond, then go out of business or disappear, including: immigration consultants (notarios), auctioneers, credit services, discount buying organizations, dance studios, employment agencies, foreclosure consultants, car dealers, entities that operate autonomous vehicles, health studios, job listing services, sellers of travel, home contractors, and mortgage brokers.
- Perversely reward negligent surety bond companies that fail to exercise due diligence or even minimally responsible underwriting, to ensure that bonded entities are sufficiently capitalized and not likely to engage in fraud.
- Overturn well-established legal precedents that have existed for decades, finding that victims harmed by bonded entities are entitled to be awarded their attorney's fees by the surety, beyond the amount of the bond.
- Allow surety bond companies to evade liability for denying valid and legitimate claims.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None.
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 12-0-0
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez, Waldron
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0-5
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Boerner, Megan Dahle, Gallagher, Hart, Mathis
SENATE FLOOR: 34-3-3
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, McGuire, Newman, Nguyen, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Menjivar, Min, Wahab
ABS, ABST OR NV: Durazo, Limón, Niello
UPDATED
VERSION: September 4, 2024
CONSULTANT: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0005131
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2677 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2677
Author: Chen (R)
Amended: 4/17/24 in Assembly
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 6/25/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Laird, Roth
NOES: Wahab
NO VOTE RECORDED: Durazo, Niello, Stern
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-1, 6/25/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Laird, Niello, Roth
NOES: Wahab
NO VOTE RECORDED: Durazo, Stern
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 4/25/24 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Sureties: liability
SOURCE: Flasher Barricade Association
DIGEST:
This bill specifies that attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs when authorized by contract, statute, or law are included under existing provisions of law that limit the aggregate liability of a surety to the amount of a surety bond issued by that surety.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.470(a).)
- Establishes that, except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. (Ibid.)
- Establishes that the liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in either of the following circumstances:
- The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety, as provided; or
- The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond. (Id. at subd. (c).)
- Provides that partial payment of a claim by a surety is not to be considered satisfaction of the claim and the beneficiary may enforce the liability on the bond. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.480(b).)
- Provides that if the nature and extent of the liability of the principal is established by final judgment of a court and the time for an appeal has expired or, if an appeal is taken, the appeal is finally determined and the judgment is affirmed, then both of the following apply:
- A surety may make payment on a bond without awaiting enforcement of the bond; and
- If the beneficiary makes a claim for payment on a bond given in an action or proceeding after the liability of the principal is so established and the surety fails to make payment, the surety is liable for costs incurred in obtaining a judgment against the surety, including a reasonable attorney’s fee, and interest on the judgment from the date of the claim. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.480 (a).)
- Establishes that the amount of the bond in 4a), above, is reduced to the extent of any payment by the surety in good faith. (Id. at para. (1) of subd. (a).)
- Specifies that payment by a surety of the amount of a bond constitutes a full discharge of all the liability of the surety on the bond. (Code of Civil Proc. § 996.490 (a).)
- Clarifies that a judgment of liability on a bond may be enforced in the same manner and to the same extent as other money judgments. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.495.)
- Establishes that a judgment of liability on a bond is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties and obligates each of them jointly and severally. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.460 (a).)
- Specifies that a beneficiary may enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.410(a).)
- Defines “admitted surety insurer” as a corporate insurer or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in the state, as defined in Section 105 of the Insurance Code. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 995.120(a).)
- Defines “surety” as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. (Civil Code § 2787.)
- Establishes that attorney’s fees, when authorized by contract, statute, or law are allowable as costs. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 1033.5(a)(10).)
- Provides that where a person assumes liability as surety upon a conditional obligation, their liability is commensurate with that of the principal, and they are not entitled to notice of the default of the principal, unless they are unable, by the exercise of reasonable diligence, to acquire information of such default, and the creditor has actual notice thereof. (Civ. Code § 2808.)
This bill:
- Specifies that attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs when authorized by contract, statute, or law are included under the provision that limits the aggregate liability of a surety to the amount of the bond.
- Defines “aggregate liability” to include liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees, if recoverable.
- Defines “surety” to mean an admitted surety insurer as defined in Section 995.120 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (See 10), above.)
Comments
“Surety” means a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. (Civ. Code § 2787.) A surety license bond refers to a type of bond that certain professionals and businesses are required to obtain as a prerequisite to conducting business in this state. If the bonded professional or business is found in violation of the law the bond can be used to compensate clients or consumers of the professional or business. Per the express terms of the surety bond, the principal agrees to indemnify the surety for any amounts paid by the surety on the bond and other costs incurred. The Code of Civil Procedure governs how liability may be enforced on a bond and specifies that a beneficiary may enforce the liability of a bond against both the principal and the surety in a civil action where both the principal and surety are to be joined as parties. (Code of Civ. Proc. §§ 996.410 & 996.430.)
According to the author, contractors comprise the largest group of licensed bond holders in California, with over 285,000 licensed contractors in the state. Generally, the premium for a contractor license bond is the same irrespective of the size or experience of the contractor seeking bondage. The idea behind this structure is that it hopefully encourages licensure and therefore regulation by the CSLB, which was established to protect the public from violations of the Contractors Law.
This bill is being brought in response to the holding in Karton v. Ari Design and Construction (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 734. In Karton, plaintiff sued his contractor (Ari Design and Construction) and was awarded damages, costs of litigation, and $90,000 in attorney’s fees. Wesco Insurance Company was the surety for the contractor, who had a contractor’s bond of $12,500 (which was the statutory dollar amount at the time).[1] The trial court held that Wesco was not liable to the plaintiff for the $90,000 in attorney’s fees as that sum exceed the amount of the surety bond Wesco issued to Ari Design. (Id. at 751.) Karton argued on appeal that Wesco was liable for the $90,000 attorney fees, even though it exceed the amount of the surety bond. The appellate court concurred with Karton’s argument, noting that Section 2808 of the Civil Code makes a surety’s liability commensurate with that of the surety’s principal, the contractor in this case. (Ibid.) The court cited to a prior decision, Pierce v. Western Surety Co. (2012) 207 Cal.App.4th 83 to support its conclusion, noting that the “surety’s obligation to pay costs under Code of Civil Procedure [S]ection 1032 was based on its status as a litigant and was not for breach of the condition of the bond.” (Karton at p. 752 (citing to Pierce at p. 92).) In the Pierce case, the trial court awarded attorney fees to the plaintiff “in an amount not to exceed the remaining balance on the bond.” (Pierce at 82.)
Wesco argued to the court that its ruling was against public policy, stating that public policy “favors low insurance premiums, and that to increase its liability would mean higher insurance rates.” (Ibid.) The court responded that Wesco could have negotiated a settlement for its own liability or used interpleader procedures to deposit the amount of the surety bond with the court, but that Wesco instead decided to avoid liability based on the merits of the case and therefore is not in a position to protest liability for the costs of going to court. (Ibid.) The court further noted that if “a surety decides to fight a lawsuit, it can make itself liable for the costs of that litigation in excess of the face value of its bond” and noted that Wesco had already paid the Kartons $38,768.49 after the trial court proceeding for the sum of the $12,500 bond, post judgment interest, and costs. (Karton at 753.) Wesco’s petition for a rehearing by the appellate court was denied on March 29, 2021, and review by the California Supreme Court was denied on June 23, 2021.
A 2024 unpublished opinion from the California Fourth District Court of Appeal upheld the trial court’s finding that a surety of an auto dealer bond was liable for $264,440 in attorney fees, which was greatly in excess of the value of the $50,000 auto dealer bond issued by Hudson and the underlying damages award of $8,748.28 in compensatory damages and $5,000 in punitive damages. (Gonzalez v. Hudson Insurance Co. (2024) 2024 WL 566058.) The attorney fees were incurred in both arbitration and then the subsequent trial and were awarded to the plaintiff by the court because she prevailed on her claim under the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, which requires that court costs and attorney fees be awarded to a prevailing plaintiff. (§ 1750 et. seq. of the Civil Code.) In this case, the plaintiff was unable to collect from the auto dealer (principal on the bond) as they “disappeared” after they lost in arbitration, and therefore sought to collect from the surety Hudson Insurance. (Id. at 2.)
The author and sponsor state that the two above described cases have “thrown the once-stable [surety bond] market into turmoil” because if sureties cannot rely on the bond amount to limit their aggregate liability, “they will have to reconsider how they underwrite and price such bonds, which is likely to significantly impact licensed contractors in particular.” As evidence to this proposition, they point to the fact that second largest writer of contractor license bonds—Suretec Insurance/Markel Surety—has left the California market. They argue that if this bill is not enacted, premiums for surety bonds will have to increase, tighten their underwriting requirements, and potentially require collateral. They posit that consumers are the ones who will be negatively impacted because: (1) there will be fewer licensed contractors due to the higher cost of bonds; (2) the higher costs of the bonds will be passed on to the consumers; and (3) this will result in more unlicensed contractors being hired, which will pose risks to consumers.
California Appellate Court decisions have held as far back as 1992 that a surety can be liable for an amount in excess of a surety bond. In Harris v. Northwestern National Ins. Co. (1992) 6 Cal.App.4th 1061, the court held that a surety could be liable for court costs in excess of the bond that were incurred for the surety’s “own conduct unsuccessfully litigating respondents' amended complaint and amended cross-complaint” under Sections 1032 and 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Harris at 1067.) The court in Harris noted that three prior California Supreme Court Cases from the late 1800s provided that the judgment in a successful action against a surety on a bond should be against the surety for the full amount that the defendant is liable on the bond and for costs. (People v. Rooney (1886) 29 Cal.643, 644; People v. Love (1864) 25 Cal. 521, 522-23 & 531; Heppe v. Johnson (1887) 73 Cal.265, 266.) Additionally, the court stated that Section 996.470 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which this bill is amending, limits liability up to the amount of the bond for breach on the condition of the bond, not liability imposed by statute. (Harris at 1065.) To further bolster the court’s view, they pointed to Section 996.475 of the Code of Civil procedure, which was enacted in 1984, and provides that “nothing in this chapter is intended to limit the liability of a surety pursuant to any other statute. This section is declaratory of, and not a change in, existing law.”
The court in Harris explained:
To avoid the costs and risks of litigation, appellant could have negotiated settlements of its own liability or used interpleader procedures to deposit the amount of its bond in court. [citations omitted] Here appellant elected to gamble that appellant and its principal, the notary, might avoid liability altogether on the merits. Having lost that gamble, appellant is not in a position to complain about liability for court costs contemplated by Code of Civil Procedure [S]ection 1032.
This bill defines “aggregate liability” as including all liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees, if recoverable. Section 996.470 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as proposed to be amended by this bill, states that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for breaches of the condition of a bond, including any attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs pursuant to paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) of Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure or similar statute, is limited to the amount of the bond. If the definition of aggregate liability includes recoverable costs, then the bond limits recovery to the amount of the bond for costs as well, which would abrogate the holding in Harris, above.
If this bill is enacted, the burden of recouping attorney fees and other costs awarded by the court will fall completely on the consumer or homeowner as the contractor or principal would remain liable for those fees or costs. As the sponsor and support coalition of this bill note in their letter, attorney fees can be substantial—$90,000 in the Karton case—and it is likely that many contractors will be forced into bankruptcy to pay the surety back. They note that if the contractor files for bankruptcy or cannot pay, the surety would have to pay the fees. However, under this bill a contractor or principal is still liable for the fees or costs and the only recourse the homeowner or consumer will have as is to seek judgment against the contractor or principal on the surety bond. If the contractor or principal either goes bankrupt or disappears, as was the situation in the Gonzalez case discussed above, the homeowner or consumer will likely not be able to recoup any of the fees or costs.
The opposition fears that if this bill were to pass, the consumer protection that surety bond requirements are supposed to provide to consumers would be illusory. As the Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety note:
By allowing surety companies to evade potentially having to pay defrauded victims’ attorneys fees when the sureties fail to honor legitimate claims and force victims to litigate in order to prove they were defrauded, and in order to receive any compensation under the bond, AB 2677 would make any protections afforded consumers by the existence of the bond largely illusory.
Only the very wealthy, who can afford to pay for legal counsel out of pocket, would be able to afford to access the bonds, rendering their supposed protections virtually useless for most Californians.
Though the author and sponsor focus largely on contractor license bonds, this bill would affect all surety bonds. There are numerous instances of surety bonds required by statute including, license bonds for auto dealers, mortgage brokers and lenders, notaries, immigration consultants, and cannabis-related businesses (see Veh. Code § 11710; Fin. Code § 50141; Gov. Code § 8213; & 4 C.C.R. Div. 19, § 15002(c)(22).) Additionally, surety bonds can be required to pay employees of a business such as for car washes, which are required to obtain a surety bond of $150,000 to ensure that their employees are paid in accordance with existing law (i.e. tip and wage laws). (see Lab. Code § 2055.) Other surety bonds are required for public works projects that cost greater than $25,000. (Civ. Code § 3247.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/27/24)
Flasher Barricade Association (source)
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated Builders and Contractors of California
Associated General Contractors
Associated General Contractors San Diego Chapter
Associated Roofing Contractors of Bay Area Counties, Inc.
American Subcontractors Association of California
California Builders Alliance
California Building Industry Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Contractors State License Board
Masonry Contractors Association of California, Inc.
Painting & Decorating Contractors of California, Inc.
Roofing Contractors Association of California
Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange
Southern California Contractors Association
Union Roofing Contractors Association
United Contractors
Western Electrical Contractors Association Inc.
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/27/24)
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Consumer Federation of California
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Elder Law & Advocacy
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
The purpose of AB 2677 is to cap the liability of a state-mandated surety bond to the penal sum of the bond. That will ensure that surety license bonds, including contractor and car dealer license bonds, remain affordable and widely available to maintain consumer protections intended by the legislature up to the license bond’s penal sum. For these reasons, it is imperative that AB 2677 be enacted.
The Contractors State License Board writes in support, stating:
An increase in the cost of the license bond is a barrier to licensure for applicants that may not have the financial resources to pay the increased costs. It is further the Board’s understanding that the bill as amended April 17, 2024, ensures the entire amount of a license bond is available for consumers.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Low-Income Consumer Coalition and Consumer Federation of California write in opposition, stating:
The reality is that without the help of an attorney very few people would be able to access those bonds – or even to know of their existence. A bill that precludes the payment of attorneys' fees would essentially shut down consumers' access to surety bonds. We agree that making consumers whole, rather than paying attorneys, must be the first priority. But if there is no realistic prospect for paying attorneys, then consumers won’t get paid either, because the bond proceeds will never be accessed. […]
AB 2677 would make those bonds illusory as a practical matter. It would undermine the purpose of the bonds that are maintained by hundreds of thousands of businesses for the benefit of millions of consumers. Only those few consumers who could afford to pay for a lawyer out of pocket would be able to access the bonds. That is the opposite of what surety bonds were designed for, and it is certainly not what this Legislature had in mind when it required them.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 4/25/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Boerner, Megan Dahle, Gallagher, Hart, Mathis
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
6/27/24 15:38:54
**** END ****
The statutory dollar amount for a contractor license bond was increased to $25,000 as of January 1, 2023. (SB 607 (Min, Ch. 367, Stats. 2021).) ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2677 (Author:Chen)
Version: April 17, 2024
Hearing Date: June 25, 2024
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
AMConsultant:
SUBJECT
Sureties: liability
DIGEST
The bill specifies that attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs when authorized by contract, statute, or law are included under existing provisions of law that limit the aggregate liability of a surety to the amount of a surety bond issued by that surety.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This bill seeks to abrogate the holding in Karton v. Ari Design and Construction (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 734, which held that a surety was liable for attorney fees awarded even though they were greater than the amount of the contractor license bond issued by the surety. This bill would specify that a surety is not liable for costs or attorney fees assessed by a court pursuant to an authorization in a contract, statute, or other law that are greater than the amount of the surety bond. The author and sponsor of this bill argue that this is necessary to ensure that the surety insurance market is not thrown into turmoil, noting that the second largest writer of surety bonds in California has already withdrawn from writing contractor license bonds. The bill is sponsored by Flasher Barricade Association and supported by various organizations, including, among others, those that represent the insurance industry, contractors, and the building industry, and the Contractors State License Board. The bill is opposed by several consumer protection organizations, including the Consumer Federation of California and Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.470(a).)
- Establishes that, except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. (Ibid.)
- If a bond is given in an amount greater than the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer pursuant to statute, the liability of the surety on the bond is limited to the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer, unless the amount of the bond has been increased voluntarily or by agreement of the parties to satisfy an objection to the bond made in an action or proceeding. (Id. at subd. (b).)
- Establishes that, except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. (Ibid.)
- Establishes that the liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in either of the following circumstances:
- the bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety, as provided; or
- the bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond. (Id. at subd. (c).)
- Provides that partial payment of a claim by a surety is not to be considered satisfaction of the claim and the beneficiary may enforce the liability on the bond. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.480(b).)
- Provides that if the nature and extent of the liability of the principal is established by final judgment of a court and the time for an appeal has expired or, if an appeal is taken, the appeal is finally determined and the judgment is affirmed, then both of the following apply:
- a surety may make payment on a bond without awaiting enforcement of the bond; and
- if the beneficiary makes a claim for payment on a bond given in an action or proceeding after the liability of the principal is so established and the surety fails to make payment, the surety is liable for costs incurred in obtaining a judgment against the surety, including a reasonable attorney’s fee, and interest on the judgment from the date of the claim. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.480 (a).)
- Establishes that the amount of the bond in 4a), above, is reduced to the extent of any payment by the surety in good faith. (Id. at para. (1) of subd. (a).)
- Specifies that payment by a surety of the amount of a bond constitutes a full discharge of all the liability of the surety on the bond. (Code of Civil Proc. § 996.490 (a).)
- Clarifies that a judgment of liability on a bond may be enforced in the same manner and to the same extent as other money judgments. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.495.)
- Establishes that a judgment of liability on a bond is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties and obligates each of them jointly and severally. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.460 (a).)
- Specifies that a beneficiary may enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 996.410(a).)
- Defines “admitted surety insurer” as a corporate insurer or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in the state, as defined in Section 105 of the Insurance Code. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 995.120(a).)
- Defines “surety” as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. (Civil Code § 2787.)
- Establishes that attorney’s fees, when authorized by contract, statute, or law are allowable as costs. (Code of Civ. Proc. § 1033.5(a)(10).)
- Provides that where a person assumes liability as surety upon a conditional obligation, their liability is commensurate with that of the principal, and they are not entitled to notice of the default of the principal, unless they are unable, by the exercise of reasonable diligence, to acquire information of such default, and the creditor has actual notice thereof. (Civ. Code § 2808.)
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of contractors under the Contractors State License Law (Contractors Law) by the Contractors State License Board (CSLB). (Bus. and Prof. Code § 7000 et seq.)
- Requires an applicant or licensee to file or have on file with the CLSB a contractor’s bond in the sum of $25,000. (Bus. and Prof. Code § 7071.6(a).)
This bill:
- Specifies that attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs when authorized by contract, statute, or law are included under the provision that limits the aggregate liability of a surety to the amount of the bond.
- Defines “aggregate liability” to include liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees, if recoverable.
- Defines “surety” to mean an admitted surety insurer as defined in Section 995.120 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (See 10), above.)
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
The purpose of AB 2677 is to cap the liability of a state-mandated surety bond to the penal sum of the bond. That will ensure that surety license bonds, including contractor and car dealer license bonds, remain affordable and widely available to maintain consumer protections intended by the legislature up to the license bond’s penal sum. For these reasons, it is imperative that AB 2677 be enacted.
- This bill is brought in response to two recent California Appeals Court Decisions that have found a surety can be liable for attorney fees even if they are in excess of the surety bond
- Surety bonds
“Surety” means a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. (Civ. Code § 2787.) A surety license bond refers to a type of bond that certain professionals and businesses are required to obtain as a prerequisite to conducting business in this state. If the bonded professional or business is found in violation of the law the bond can be used to compensate clients or consumers of the professional or business. Per the express terms of the surety bond, the principal agrees to indemnify the surety for any amounts paid by the surety on the bond and other costs incurred. The Code of Civil Procedure governs how liability may be enforced on a bond and specifies that a beneficiary may enforce the liability of a bond against both the principal and the surety in a civil action where both the principal and surety are to be joined as parties. (Code of Civ. Proc. §§ 996.410 & 996.430.)
- Contractor license bonds
According to the author, contractors comprise the largest group of licensed bond holders in California, with over 285,000 licensed contractors in the state. Generally, the premium for a contractor license bond is the same irrespective of the size or experience of the contractor seeking bondage. The idea behind this structure is that it hopefully encourages licensure and therefore regulation by the CSLB, which was established to protect the public from violations of the Contractors Law.
- Recent California Appeals Court opinions that have held a surety can be liable for attorney fees in an amount in excess of the surety bond
This bill is being brought in response to the holding in Karton v. Ari Design and Construction (2021) 61 Cal.App.5th 734. In Karton, plaintiff sued his contractor (Ari Design and Construction) and was awarded damages, costs of litigation, and $90,000 in attorney’s fees. Wesco Insurance Company was the surety for the contractor, who had a contractor’s bond of $12,500 (which was the statutory dollar amount at the time).[1] The trial court held that Wesco was not liable to the plaintiff for the $90,000 in attorney’s fees as that sum exceed the amount of the surety bond Wesco issued to Ari Design. (Id. at 751.) Karton argued on appeal that Wesco was liable for the $90,000 attorney fees, even though it exceed the amount of the surety bond. The appellate court concurred with Karton’s argument, noting that Section 2808 of the Civil Code makes a surety’s liability commensurate with that of the surety’s principal, the contractor in this case. (Ibid.) The court cited to a prior decision, Pierce v. Western Surety Co. (2012) 207 Cal.App.4th 83 to support its conclusion, noting that the “surety’s obligation to pay costs under Code of Civil Procedure [S]ection 1032 was based on its status as a litigant and was not for breach of the condition of the bond.” (Karton at p. 752 (citing to Pierce at p. 92).) In the Pierce case, the trial court awarded attorney fees to the plaintiff “in an amount not to exceed the remaining balance on the bond.” (Pierce at 82.)
Wesco argued to the court that its ruling was against public policy, stating that public policy “favors low insurance premiums, and that to increase its liability would mean higher insurance rates.” (Ibid.) The court responded that Wesco could have negotiated a settlement for its own liability or used interpleader procedures to deposit the amount of the surety bond with the court, but that Wesco instead decided to avoid liability based on the merits of the case and therefore is not in a position to protest liability for the costs of going to court. (Ibid.) The court further noted that if “a surety decides to fight a lawsuit, it can make itself liable for the costs of that litigation in excess of the face value of its bond” and noted that Wesco had already paid the Kartons $38,768.49 after the trial court proceeding for the sum of the $12,500 bond, post judgment interest, and costs. (Karton at 753.) Wesco’s petition for a rehearing by the appellate court was denied on March 29, 2021, and review by the California Supreme Court was denied on June 23, 2021.
A 2024 unpublished opinion from the California Fourth District Court of Appeal upheld the trial court’s finding that a surety of an auto dealer bond was liable for $264,440 in attorney fees, which was greatly in excess of the value of the $50,000 auto dealer bond issued by Hudson and the underlying damages award of $8,748.28 in compensatory damages and $5,000 in punitive damages. (Gonzalez v. Hudson Insurance Co. (2024) 2024 WL 566058.) The attorney fees were incurred in both arbitration and then the subsequent trial and were awarded to the plaintiff by the court because she prevailed on her claim under the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, which requires that court costs and attorney fees be awarded to a prevailing plaintiff. (§ 1750 et. seq. of the Civil Code.) In this case, the plaintiff was unable to collect from the auto dealer (principal on the bond) as they “disappeared” after they lost in arbitration, and therefore sought to collect from the surety Hudson Insurance. (Id. at 2.)
- Author and sponsors arguments for why this bill is needed
The author and sponsor state that the two above described cases have “thrown the once-stable [surety bond] market into turmoil” because if sureties cannot rely on the bond amount to limit their aggregate liability, “they will have to reconsider how they underwrite and price such bonds, which is likely to significantly impact licensed contractors in particular.” As evidence to this proposition, they point to the fact that second largest writer of contractor license bonds—Suretec Insurance/Markel Surety—has left the California market. They argue that if this bill is not enacted, premiums for surety bonds will have to increase, tighten their underwriting requirements, and potentially require collateral. They posit that consumers are the ones who will be negatively impacted because: (1) there will be fewer licensed contractors due to the higher cost of bonds; (2) the higher costs of the bonds will be passed on to the consumers; and (3) this will result in more unlicensed contractors being hired, which will pose risks to consumers.
- Potential concerns raised by this bill
- Bill likely abrogates other existing court cases
California Appellate Court decisions have held as far back as 1992 that a surety can be liable for an amount in excess of a surety bond. In Harris v. Northwestern National Ins. Co. (1992) 6 Cal.App.4th 1061, the court held that a surety could be liable for court costs in excess of the bond that were incurred for the surety’s “own conduct unsuccessfully litigating respondents' amended complaint and amended cross-complaint” under Sections 1032 and 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Harris at 1067.) The court in Harris noted that three prior California Supreme Court Cases from the late 1800s provided that the judgment in a successful action against a surety on a bond should be against the surety for the full amount that the defendant is liable on the bond and for costs. (People v. Rooney (1886) 29 Cal.643, 644; People v. Love (1864) 25 Cal. 521, 522-23 & 531; Heppe v. Johnson (1887) 73 Cal.265, 266.) Additionally, the court stated that Section 996.470 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which this bill is amending, limits liability up to the amount of the bond for breach on the condition of the bond, not liability imposed by statute. (Harris at 1065.) To further bolster the court’s view, they pointed to Section 996.475 of the Code of Civil procedure, which was enacted in 1984, and provides that “nothing in this chapter is intended to limit the liability of a surety pursuant to any other statute. This section is declaratory of, and not a change in, existing law.”
The court in Harris explained:
To avoid the costs and risks of litigation, appellant could have negotiated settlements of its own liability or used interpleader procedures to deposit the amount of its bond in court. [citations omitted] Here appellant elected to gamble that appellant and its principal, the notary, might avoid liability altogether on the merits. Having lost that gamble, appellant is not in a position to complain about liability for court costs contemplated by Code of Civil Procedure [S]ection 1032.
This bill defines “aggregate liability” as including all liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees, if recoverable. Section 996.470 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as proposed to be amended by this bill, states that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for breaches of the condition of a bond, including any attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs pursuant to paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) of Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure or similar statute, is limited to the amount of the bond. If the definition of aggregate liability includes recoverable costs, then the bond limits recovery to the amount of the bond for costs as well, which would abrogate the holding in Harris, above.
- Burden will be on consumers to recoup attorney’s fees and other costs from principal
If this bill is enacted, the burden of recouping attorney fees and other costs awarded by the court will fall completely on the consumer or homeowner as the contractor or principal would remain liable for those fees or costs. As the sponsor and support coalition of this bill note in their letter, attorney fees can be substantial—$90,000 in the Karton case—and it is likely that many contractors will be forced into bankruptcy to pay the surety back. They note that if the contractor files for bankruptcy or cannot pay, the surety would have to pay the fees. However, under this bill a contractor or principal is still liable for the fees or costs and the only recourse the homeowner or consumer will have as is to seek judgment against the contractor or principal on the surety bond. If the contractor or principal either goes bankrupt or disappears, as was the situation in the Gonzalez case discussed above, the homeowner or consumer will likely not be able to recoup any of the fees or costs.
- Opposition fears this bill will make the security surety bonds are supposed to provide to consumers illusory
The opposition fears that if this bill were to pass, the consumer protection that surety bond requirements are supposed to provide to consumers would be illusory. As the Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety note:
By allowing surety companies to evade potentially having to pay defrauded victims’ attorneys fees when the sureties fail to honor legitimate claims and force victims to litigate in order to prove they were defrauded, and in order to receive any compensation under the bond, AB 2677 would make any protections afforded consumers by the existence of the bond largely illusory.
Only the very wealthy, who can afford to pay for legal counsel out of pocket, would be able to afford to access the bonds, rendering their supposed protections virtually useless for most Californians.
- Bill affects all surety bonds, not just license bonds
Though the author and sponsor focus largely on contractor license bonds, this bill would affect all surety bonds. There are numerous instances of surety bonds required by statute including, license bonds for auto dealers, mortgage brokers and lenders, notaries, immigration consultants, and cannabis-related businesses (see Veh. Code § 11710; Fin. Code § 50141; Gov. Code § 8213; & 4 C.C.R. Div. 19, § 15002(c)(22).) Additionally, surety bonds can be required to pay employees of a business such as for car washes, which are required to obtain a surety bond of $150,000 to ensure that their employees are paid in accordance with existing law (i.e. tip and wage laws). (see Lab. Code § 2055.) Other surety bonds are required for public works projects that cost greater than $25,000. (Civ. Code § 3247.)
- Statements in support
The Contractors State License Board writes in support, stating:
The Contractors State License Board (CSLB) supports Assembly Bill (AB) 2677. This bill would provide that a surety writing a bond is not liable for an award of attorney’s fees (as costs in a civil action) unless a statute requiring a bond expressly authorizes the recovery of them.
The CSLB requires a license bond for every licensed contractor. It is the Board’s understanding that this bill will address concerns about an increase in the costs of bonds that arose after a recent court opinion, Karton v. Ari Design & Construction, 61 Cal.App.5th 734 (2021).
An increase in the cost of the license bond is a barrier to licensure for applicants that may not have the financial resources to pay the increased costs. It is further the Board’s understanding that the bill as amended April 17, 2024, ensures the entire amount of a license bond is available for consumers.
- Statements in opposition
The California Low-Income Consumer Coalition and Consumer Federation of California write in opposition, stating:
There is a reason that California law requires certain types of business to have surety bonds: because the Legislature has found that fly-by-night members of those industries are likely to defraud their customers and then close up shop before consumers can get their money back. Surety bonds perform an essential function: even if the business and its proprietors are gone, the bond remains as a source of funds to make defrauded consumers whole.
The reality is that without the help of an attorney very few people would be able to access those bonds – or even to know of their existence. A bill that precludes the payment of attorneys' fees would essentially shut down consumers' access to surety bonds. We agree that making consumers whole, rather than paying attorneys, must be the first priority. But if there is no realistic prospect for paying attorneys, then consumers won’t get paid either, because the bond proceeds will never be accessed.
A wide array of business enterprises are required by California law to obtain surety bonds in order to protect consumers in the event of the business going under – or disappearing – and leaving its customers with no other recourse. Auctioneers, credit service organizations, dance studios, discount buying organizations, employment agencies, foreclosure consultants, health studios, immigration consultants (notarios), job listing services, sellers of travel, home contractors, auto dealers, mortgage brokers –– all must maintain a surety bond to protect against consumer harm.
AB 2677 would make those bonds illusory as a practical matter. It would undermine the purpose of the bonds that are maintained by hundreds of thousands of businesses for the benefit of millions of consumers. Only those few consumers who could afford to pay for a lawyer out of pocket would be able to access the bonds. That is the opposite of what surety bonds were designed for, and it is certainly not what this Legislature had in mind when it required them.
SUPPORT
Flasher Barricade Association (sponsor)
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated Builders and Contractors of California
Associated General Contractors
Associated General Contractors San Diego Chapter
Associated Roofing Contractors of Bay Area Counties, Inc.
American Subcontractors Association of California
California Builders Alliance
California Building Industry Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Contractors State License Board
Masonry Contractors Association of California, Inc.
Painting & Decorating Contractors of California, Inc.
Roofing Contractors Association of California
Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange
Southern California Contractors Association
Union Roofing Contractors Association
United Contractors
Western Electrical Contractors Association Inc.
OPPOSITION
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Consumer Federation of California
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation: SB 607 (Min, Ch. 367, Stats. 2021), among other things, increased the required limit for a contractor license bond to $25,000.
PRIOR VOTES
Assembly Floor (Ayes 75, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
**************
The statutory dollar amount for a contractor license bond was increased to $25,000 as of January 1, 2023. (SB 607 (Min, Ch. 367, Stats. 2021).) ↑
Date of Hearing: April 16, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2677
Author:(Chen) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2024
PROPOSED CONSENT (As Proposed to be Amended)
SUBJECT: Sureties: liability
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT SURETY LICENSE BONDS REMAIN AFFORDABLE AND WIDELY AVAILABLE AS CONSUMER PROTECTIONS, should the law be clarified so that a license sureties’ liability is limited to the penal sum of the bond?
SYNOPSIS
This measure seeks to clarify the law regarding license sureties’ liability. Many licensed business and professionals are required to maintain surety license bonds as a condition of licensure. This bond serves as a form of financial guarantee to ensure compliance with laws and regulations governing their respective industries, and ensures that consumers are compensated for harm by a licensee. Examples of industries that require bonds as a condition for licensure include motor vehicle dealers, notaries, insurance brokers and collection agencies. With over 285,000 licensed contractors in California, contractors comprise the largest group of license bond holders. Existing law establishes that the aggregate liability of a surety for breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. A recent California appellate court opinion (Karton v. Ari Design & Construction, Inc. (2021) 61 Cal. App. 5th 734) held that a surety under a contractor license bond was liable for the full amount of a $90,000 attorney fee award entered against the contractor even though the bond limit was only $12,500. This decision has thrown the surety market into turmoil. According to the author, the second largest writer of contractor license bonds has already left the market. Others may follow. Those remaining will likely have to increase the premium they charge for these bonds, tighten underwriting requirements, and even require collateral. The author warns that the result has left, or may, result in many contractors without an affordable market to purchase license bonds.
This measure clarifies that license sureties’ liability, including any attorney’s fees or costs, is limited to the penal sum of the bond. The author is proposing amendments to further clarify the intent of the bill. The amendments are incorporated into the SUMMARY, below, and explained in the analysis. This measure is supported by a coalition of construction organizations, including United Contractors, Flasher Barricade Association and the California Builders Alliance. The American Subcontractors Association of California is also in support. There is no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Clarifies that a license sureties’ liability is limited to the penal sum of the bond. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond, including any attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs, as provided, is limited to the amount of the bond.
- Defines “aggregate liability” for purposes of liability of a surety to include all liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees, if recoverable.
- Defines “surety” for purposes of the section as an “admitted surety insurer,” as provided by law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.470 (a).)
- Establishes that, except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. (Ibid.)
- If a bond is given in an amount greater than the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer pursuant to statute, the liability of the surety on the bond is limited to the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer, unless the amount of the bond has been increased voluntarily or by agreement of the parties to satisfy an objection to the bond made in an action or proceeding. (Id. at (b).)
- Establishes that the liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in any of the following circumstances:
- The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety, as provided.
- The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond. (Id. at (c).)
- Provides that partial payment of a claim by a surety is not to be considered satisfaction of the claim and the beneficiary may enforce the liability on the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.480 (b).)
- Establishes that if the nature and extent of the liability of the principal is established by final judgment of a court, including any judgment affirmed on appeal:
- A surety may make payment on a bond without awaiting enforcement of the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.480 (a)(1).)
- If the beneficiary makes a claim for payment on a bond given in an action or proceeding after the liability of the principal is so established and the surety fails to make payment, the surety is liable for costs incurred in obtaining a judgment against the surety, including a reasonable attorney’s fee, and interest on the judgment from the date of the claim. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.480 (a)(2).)
- Establishes that the amount of the bond in 6a) is reduced to the extent of any payment by the surety in good faith. (Id.)
- Provides that payment by a surety of the amount of a bond constitutes a full discharge of all the liability of the surety on the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.490 (a).)
- Clarifies that a judgment of liability on a bond may be enforced in the same manner and to the same extent as other money judgments. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.495.)
- Establishes that, notwithstanding existing law, a judgment of liability on a bond is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties and obligates each of them jointly and severally. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.460 (a).)
- Provides that a beneficiary may enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.410 (a).)
- Defines “admitted surety insurer” as a corporate insurer or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in the state, as provided. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 995.120 (a).)
- Defines “surety” as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. (Civil Code Section 2787.)
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of more than 300,000 contractors under the Contractors State License Law (Contractors Law) by the CSLB within the DCA). The Contractors State License Board (CSLB) is under the direction of the registrar of contractors (Registrar). (Business and Professions Code Section 7000 et seq.)
- Requires the Contractors’ State License Board, before issuing a license, to require that the applicant or licensee file or have on file a contractor’s bond in the sum of $25,000. (Business and Professions Code Section 7071.6 (a).)
- Establishes that attorney’s fees, when authorized by contract, statute, or law are allowable as costs. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1033.5 (a)(10).)
- Defines “admitted surety insurer” a corporate insurer or a reciprocal or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in this state, as provided. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 995.120.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Existing law establishes that the aggregate liability of a surety for breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. According to the author, the statute needs to be clarified so that “aggregate liability” of the license surety includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees.
What is a surety license bond? Generally, a surety is defined as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. A surety license bond refers to a type of bond that certain professionals or businesses are required to obtain as a condition of obtaining or maintaining a license to operate within the state. This bond serves as a form of financial guarantee to ensure compliance with laws and regulations governing the respective industry. If the bonded party fails to meet their obligations, the bond can be used to compensate consumers harmed by the licensee.
Examples of professions or businesses that may be required to obtain a surety license bond in California include:
- Contractors: Under the Contractors' State License Law, contractors are required to obtain a contractor’s license bond (California Business and Professions Code Section 7071.6).
- Auto Dealers: California Vehicle Code Section 11710 mandates auto dealers to obtain a motor vehicle dealer bond as a condition of obtaining and maintaining their dealer license.
- Mortgage Brokers and Lenders: Mortgage brokers and lenders must secure a mortgage loan originator bond or mortgage broker bond (California Financial Code Section 50141).
The surety bond amount requirement differs across licensing categories.
Bond requirements ensure professionals get licensed and that consumers have a financial recourse. According to the author, with over 285,000 licensed contractors in California, contractors comprise the largest group of license bond holders. This bill applies to all surety insurers across all professions, but with contractors making up the largest category of licensed professionals who are required to maintain a surety, this analysis will focus on that group, as a recent court decision relating to contractor’s license surety bonds was the impetus for this bill. Contractor’s license bonds are required for every licensed contractor—no matter how large or small—in the state. License bond sureties typically write them in exchange for a signed indemnity agreement and an annual premium of several hundred dollars, depending on the insurer. In general, the bond premium is the same regardless of the size or experience of the contractor. In this way, even the smallest contractor can afford the bond and the surety's risk (now $25,000) is relatively modest as well. This encourages licensure and therefore regulation by the license board which is designed and intended to protect the public from violations of the license law by licensed contractors.
The legislative intent behind requiring contractor license bonds primarily revolves around safeguarding consumers against financial harm resulting from contractor malpractice or non-compliance with contractual obligations. By imposing bonding requirements, lawmakers sought to provide a financial recourse for consumers in cases of contractor default, abandonment, or substandard workmanship. If contractors have posted a bond that is controlled by state, the Contractors State Licensing Board can access the bond and make the consumer whole. The bond amount has increased over time by statutory changes.
Recent court decision rules that surety’s exposure to attorney’s fee not capped. A recent California appellate court opinion (Karton v. Ari Design & Construction, Inc. (2021) 61 Cal.App. 5th 734) held that a surety under a contractor license bond was liable for the full amount of a $90,000 attorney fee award entered against the contractor even though the bond limit was only $12,500. More recently, in an unreported February 2024 decision another California appellate court - relying on the precedent set forth in Karton - held that a surety was liable for the full amount of a $264,440 attorney fee award even though the bond limit was only $50,000. (See Gonzalez v. Hudson Ins. Co., No. D080166, 2024 WL 566058 (Cal. Ct. App. Feb. 13, 2024); see also Vehicle Code Section 11710 (setting the surety bond for auto dealers at $50,000).) Prior to Karton, a surety’s exposure to attorney’s fees was understood to be capped by the penal sum of its bond. According to the author, if this decision is left uncorrected by the Legislature, the effect on licensed businesses will be devastating:
These cases have thrown the once-stable market into turmoil. The second largest writer of contractor license bonds has already left the market. Others may follow. Those remaining will likely have to increase the premium they charge for these bonds, tighten underwriting requirements, and even require collateral. The result has left, or may result in, many contractors without an affordable market to purchase license bonds. When a surety pays on a bond, its bond principal (the contractor) is required to reimburse the surety what it has paid. How many contractors could reimburse their surety company $90,000.00? This would put many of them out of business or file for bankruptcy. If the cost of the bond becomes exorbitant and the specter of reimbursement prohibitive, many contractors will have no choice but to go unlicensed. This will hit small and emerging contractors the hardest.
This view is supported by the legislative history and public policy. A 2020 CSLB report tasked with determining whether to increase the bond limit for contractors from $15,000 to $25,000 raised the policy implications of raising the cap and its effect on the market:
[I]ncreasing the bond amount raises questions about the higher costs of obtaining a contractor license and/or limiting the pool of available contractors by doing so. The “barrier to licensure” concern of increasing the bond would be the increase in the cost of the bond precluding new people from entering the construction field, which not only keeps such individuals from earning a living but may increase the cost of construction services by limiting access to the number of available contractors. The result could be a negative impact to consumers in a manner that outweighs the intended benefit of raising the bond, which is to provide more funds for consumers who are injured by the acts of a contractor.(SB 610(Glazer) License Bond Study, Jan. 21, 2021, available at https://www.cslb.ca.gov/About_Us/Library/Reports.aspx.)
The author further warns that while the current state of affairs following the Karton decision is extremely problematic for the principal (i.e., the licensed professional), and the surety company that underwrites the bond – but, ultimately, the real harm will befall California consumer:
Fewer licensed contractors will mean less competition and the higher priced bond cost will be passed along to consumers (especially homeowners). Those homeowners will be tempted to hire unlicensed contractors who can no longer afford or qualify for license bonds. These now-unregulated contractors would pose substantial risks to unsuspecting homeowners (and other consumers) by exposing them to shoddy workmanship, abandonment or even life/safety injury or loss.
This bill clarifies that the penal cap of the “aggregate liability” of a surety license bond includes attorney’s fees and costs. In other words, the amount that can be collected against the surety, including any attorney fees and costs, is capped at the penal limit. In the example of a contractor’s license bond, the amount that can be collected against the surety (including any attorney’s fees or costs) could not exceed $25,000. The liability of the principal (i.e., the licensee) remains unchanged.
Author’s amendments. In order to further clarify the intent of the author, the author proposes the following amendments:
996.470. (a) Notwithstanding any statute other than Section 996.480, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond, including any attorney’s fees that may be assessed as costs pursuant to Section 1033.5(a)(1) or similar statute, is limited to the amount of the bond. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. Unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorney’s fees against the surety under the bond, a surety is not liable for an award of attorney’s fees as costs.
…
(e) For purposes of this section, “surety” means “admitted surety insurer” as defined in Section 995.120.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The American Subcontractors Association of California explain the need for this measure:
The recent California appellate court opinion in Karton v. Ari Design (61 Cal. App. 5th 734) has brought to light an issue regarding the liability of surety bond companies holding licensed contractor bonds. Specifically, the opinion indicated that these companies may be compelled to pay attorney fees for litigating parties in cases where genuinely disputed claims necessitate litigation. Consequently, sureties are beginning to receive these types of claims for attorney fees.
AB 2677 aims to address this issue by defining "aggregate liability" to include all liability for damages, costs, and attorney’s fees, if recoverable. Further, the bill provides that unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorney’s fees against the surety, a surety is not liable for an award of attorney’s fees as costs.
The potential for unlimited attorney’s fees payouts poses a significant risk and will likely necessitate higher bond premiums. Additionally, surety companies may opt to restrict the issuance of contractor bonds or even exit the market altogether. AB 2677 is aimed at preserving accessible contractor bonds while upholding consumer protections. Therefore, ASAC fully supports this measure.
A construction industry coalition, including United Contractors, Flasher Barricade Association and the California Builders Alliance, detail the significant impacts of the Karton decision on licensed contractors:
1). Since contractors indemnify the surety company for any and all costs charged against a bond, the contractor will be liable to reimburse the surety for the attorney’s fees.
2). Since attorney’s fees can be substantial (in the Karton case they were $90,000!), it is likely that many contractors will be forced into bankruptcy.
3). If the contractor files for bankruptcy, or cannot pay for whatever the reason, the surety will pay the fees. Because of the risk of exposure to unlimited attorney’s fee payouts due to contractors being unable to pay the costs, the potentially significant costs to the surety will be offset by charging the remaining bondholders (contractors) higher bond premiums.
4). Sureties, knowing they could face unlimited attorney fee payouts, will tighten underwriting standards so that only those contractors with the healthiest balance sheets will be able to qualify for these bonds.
5). Sureties may limit the number of contractor bonds they issue.
6). It prevents contractors from having an opportunity to litigate disputed claims. Why?
Because, to avoid exposure to attorney fees in excess of the bond’s penal sum, sureties will be incentivized to pay the claim rather than allow the contractors to litigate their dispute.
7). Sureties Leaving California Market. One other major driver affecting both surety bond affordability and availability is the fact that surety companies already have and will continue to, exponentially, leave the California market if the California State Legislature and governor do not act. Indeed, the second largest writer of surety bonds in California, Suretec Insurance/Markel Surety, has already withdrawn from writing contractor license bonds in the California surety marketplace, with several other sureties as well currently deliberating whether to withdraw.
8). Finally, any and all increased costs that contractors will be faced with will be passed on to the consumer. This could seriously impact the construction economy, because many projects, due to their increased costs, will be put ‘on hold.’
Then there’s the realization that many of these existing as well as prospective contractors, who will be unable to qualify or afford the increased license bond, will simply work unlicensed. This will mean then that all of the consumers who contract with these individuals will lose even the most basic protection that would be afforded to them by way of the $25,000 license bond.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated General Contractors
Associated General Contractors San Diego Chapter
Associated Roofing Contractors of Bay Area Counties, Inc.
California Builders Alliance
California Building Industry Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Flasher Barricade Association
Masonry Contractors Association of California, Inc.
Roofing Contractors Association of California
Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange
Southern California Contractors Association
Union Roofing Contractors Assn
United Contractors
Western Electrical Contractors Association Inc.
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2677
Author:(Chen) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2024
PROPOSED CONSENT (As Proposed to be Amended)
SUBJECT: Sureties: liability
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT SURETY LICENSE BONDS REMAIN AFFORDABLE AND WIDELY AVAILABLE TO MAINTAIN CONSUMER PROTECTIONS, should the law be clarified that a license sureties’ liability is limited to the penal sum of the bond?
SYNOPSIS
This measure seeks to clarify the law regarding license sureties’ liability. Many licensed business and professionals are required to maintain surety license bonds as a condition of licensure. This bond serves as a form of financial guarantee to ensure compliance with laws and regulations governing their respective industries, and ensures that consumers are compensated for harm by a licensee. Examples of industries that require bonds as a condition for licensure include motor vehicle dealers, notaries, insurance brokers and collection agencies. With over 285,000 licensed contractors in California, contractors comprise the largest group of license bond holders. Existing law establishes that the aggregate liability of a surety for breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. A recent California appellate court opinion (Karton v. Ari Design & Construction, Inc. (2021) 61 Cal. App. 5th 734) held that a surety under a contractor license bond was liable for the full amount of a $90,000 attorney fee award entered against the contractor even though the bond limit was only $12,500. This decision has thrown the surety market into turmoil. According to the author, the second largest writer of contractor license bonds has already left the market. Others may follow. Those remaining will likely have to increase the premium they charge for these bonds, tighten underwriting requirements, and even require collateral. The result has left, or may, result in many contractors without an affordable market to purchase license bonds.
This measure clarifies that license sureties’ liability, including any attorney’s fees or costs, is limited to the penal sum of the bond. In order to further clarify the intent of the bill, the author has made minor amendments. The amendments are incorporated into the SUMMARY, below, and explained in the analysis. This measure is supported by a coalition of construction organizations, including United Contractors, Flasher Barricade Association and the California Builders Alliance. The American Subcontractors Association of California is also in support. There is no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Clarifies that a license sureties’ liability is limited to the penal sum of the bond. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes that unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorney’s fees or costs against the surety under the bond, a surety is not liable for an award of attorney’s fees or costs.
- Defines “aggregate liability” for purposes of liability of a surety to include all liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees, if recoverable.
- Defines “surety” for purposes of the section as an “admitted surety insurer,” as provided by law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.470 (a).)
- Establishes that, except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. (Ibid.)
- If a bond is given in an amount greater than the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer pursuant to statute, the liability of the surety on the bond is limited to the amount required by statute or by order of the court or officer, unless the amount of the bond has been increased voluntarily or by agreement of the parties to satisfy an objection to the bond made in an action or proceeding. (Id. at (b).)
- Establishes that the liability of a surety is limited to the amount stipulated in any of the following circumstances:
- The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a personal surety is limited to the worth of the surety, as provided.
- The bond contains a stipulation that the liability of a surety is an amount less than the amount of the bond pursuant to a statute that provides that the liability of sureties in the aggregate need not exceed the amount of the bond. (Id. at (c).)
- Provides that partial payment of a claim by a surety is not to be considered satisfaction of the claim and the beneficiary may enforce the liability on the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.480 (b).)
- Establishes that if the nature and extent of the liability of the principal is established by final judgment of a court, including any judgment affirmed on appeal:
- A surety may make payment on a bond without awaiting enforcement of the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.480 (a)(1).)
- If the beneficiary makes a claim for payment on a bond given in an action or proceeding after the liability of the principal is so established and the surety fails to make payment, the surety is liable for costs incurred in obtaining a judgment against the surety, including a reasonable attorney’s fee, and interest on the judgment from the date of the claim. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.480 (a)(2).)
- Establishes that the amount of the bond in 6a) is reduced to the extent of any payment by the surety in good faith. (Id.)
- Provides that payment by a surety of the amount of a bond constitutes a full discharge of all the liability of the surety on the bond. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.490 (a).)
- Clarifies that a judgment of liability on a bond may be enforced in the same manner and to the same extent as other money judgments. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.495.)
- Establishes that, notwithstanding existing law, a judgment of liability on a bond is in favor of the beneficiary and against the principal and sureties and obligates each of them jointly and severally. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.460 (a).)
- Provides that a beneficiary may enforce the liability on a bond against both the principal and sureties. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 996.410 (a).)
- Defines “admitted surety insurer” as a corporate insurer or interinsurance exchange to which the Insurance Commissioner has issued a certificate of authority to transact surety insurance in the state, as provided. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 995.120 (a).)
- Defines “surety” as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. (Civil Code Section 2787.)
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of more than 300,000 contractors under the Contractors State License Law (Contractors Law) by the CSLB within the DCA). The Contractors State License Board (CSLB) is under the direction of the registrar of contractors (Registrar). (Business and Professions Code Section 7000 et seq.)
- Requires the Contractors’ State License Board, before issuing a license, to require that the applicant or licensee file or have on file a contractor’s bond in the sum of $25,000. (Business and Professions Code Section 7071.6 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Existing law establishes that the aggregate liability of a surety for breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. According to the author, the statute needs to be clarified so that “aggregate liability” of the license surety includes all liability for damages, costs, or attorney’s fees.
What is a surety license bond? Generally, a surety is defined as a party who guarantees the performance of a contract or the fulfillment of an obligation by another party, known as the principal. A surety license bond refers to a type of bond that certain professionals or businesses are required to obtain as a condition of obtaining or maintaining a license to operate within the state. This bond serves as a form of financial guarantee to ensure compliance with laws and regulations governing the respective industry. If the bonded party fails to meet their obligations, the bond can be used to compensate consumers harmed by the licensee.
Examples of professions or businesses that may be required to obtain a surety license bond in California include:
- Contractors: Under the Contractors' State License Law, contractors are required to obtain a contractor’s license bond (California Business and Professions Code Section 7071.6).
- Auto Dealers: California Vehicle Code Section 11710 mandates auto dealers to obtain a motor vehicle dealer bond as a condition of obtaining and maintaining their dealer license.
- Mortgage Brokers and Lenders: Mortgage brokers and lenders must secure a mortgage loan originator bond or mortgage broker bond (California Financial Code Section 50141).
The surety bond amount requirement differs across licensing categories.
Bond requirements ensure professionals get licensed and that consumers have a financial recourse. According to the author, with over 285,000 licensed contractors in California, contractors comprise the largest group of license bond holders. This bill applies to all surety insurers across all professions, but with contractors making up the largest category of licensed professionals who are required to maintain a surety, this analysis will focus on that group, as a recent court decision relating to contractor’s license surety bonds was the impetus for this bill. Contractor’s license bonds are required for every licensed contractor—no matter how large or small—in the state. License bond sureties typically write them in exchange for a signed indemnity agreement and an annual premium of several hundred dollars, depending on the insurer. In general, the bond premium is the same regardless of the size or experience of the contractor. In this way, even the smallest contractor can afford the bond and the surety's risk (now $25,000) is relatively modest as well. This encourages licensure and therefore regulation by the license board which is designed and intended to protect the public from violations of the license law by licensed contractors.
The legislative intent behind requiring contractor license bonds primarily revolves around safeguarding consumers against financial harm resulting from contractor malpractice or non-compliance with contractual obligations. By imposing bonding requirements, lawmakers sought to provide a financial recourse for consumers in cases of contractor default, abandonment, or substandard workmanship. If contractors have posted a bond that is controlled by state, the Contractors State Licensing Board can access the bond and make the consumer whole. The bond amount has increased over time by statutory changes.
Recent court decision rules that surety’s exposure to attorney’s fee not capped. A recent California appellate court opinion (Karton v. Ari Design & Construction, Inc. (2021) 61 Cal.App. 5th 734) held that a surety under a contractor license bond was liable for the full amount of a $90,000 attorney fee award entered against the contractor even though the bond limit was only $12,500. More recently, in an unreported February 2024 decision another California appellate court - relying on the precedent set forth in Karton - held that a surety was liable for the full amount of a $264,440 attorney fee award even though the bond limit was only $50,000. (See Gonzalez v. Hudson Ins. Co., No. D080166, 2024 WL 566058 (Cal. Ct. App. Feb. 13, 2024); see also Vehicle Code Section 11710 (setting the surety bond for auto dealers at $50,000).) Prior to Karton, a surety’s exposure to attorney’s fees was understood to be capped by the penal sum of its bond. According to the author, if this decision is left uncorrected by the Legislature, the effect on licensed businesses will be devastating:
These cases have thrown the once-stable market into turmoil. The second largest writer of contractor license bonds has already left the market. Others may follow. Those remaining will likely have to increase the premium they charge for these bonds, tighten underwriting requirements, and even require collateral. The result has left, or may result in, many contractors without an affordable market to purchase license bonds. When a surety pays on a bond, its bond principal (the contractor) is required to reimburse the surety what it has paid. How many contractors could reimburse their surety company $90,000.00? This would put many of them out of business or file for bankruptcy. If the cost of the bond becomes exorbitant and the specter of reimbursement prohibitive, many contractors will have no choice but to go unlicensed. This will hit small and emerging contractors the hardest.
This view is supported by the legislative history and public policy. A 2020 CSLB report tasked with determining whether to increase the bond limit for contractors from $15,000 to $25,000 raised the policy implications of raising the cap and its effect on the market:
[I]ncreasing the bond amount raises questions about the higher costs of obtaining a contractor license and/or limiting the pool of available contractors by doing so. The “barrier to licensure” concern of increasing the bond would be the increase in the cost of the bond precluding new people from entering the construction field, which not only keeps such individuals from earning a living but may increase the cost of construction services by limiting access to the number of available contractors. The result could be a negative impact to consumers in a manner that outweighs the intended benefit of raising the bond, which is to provide more funds for consumers who are injured by the acts of a contractor.(SB 610(Glazer) License Bond Study, Jan. 21, 2021, available at https://www.cslb.ca.gov/About_Us/Library/Reports.aspx.)
The author further warns that while the current state of affairs following the Karton decision is extremely problematic for the principal (i.e., the licensed professional), and the surety company that underwrites the bond – but, ultimately, the real harm will befall California consumer:
Fewer licensed contractors will mean less competition and the higher priced bond cost will be passed along to consumers (especially homeowners). Those homeowners will be tempted to hire unlicensed contractors who can no longer afford or qualify for license bonds. These now-unregulated contractors would pose substantial risks to unsuspecting homeowners (and other consumers) by exposing them to shoddy workmanship, abandonment or even life/safety injury or loss.
This bill clarifies that the penal cap of the “aggregate liability” of a surety license bond includes attorney’s fees and costs. In other words, the amount that can be collected against the surety, including any attorney fees and costs, is capped at the penal limit. So in the example of contractor’s license bonds, the amount that can be collected against the surety (including any attorney’s fees or costs) could not exceed $25,000. The liability of the principal (i.e., the licensee) remains unchanged.
Author’s amendments. In order to further clarify the intent of the author, the author proposes the following amendments:
996.470 (a) Notwithstanding any statute other than Section 996.480, the aggregate liability of a surety to all persons for all breaches of the condition of a bond is limited to the amount of the bond. Except as otherwise provided by statute, the liability of the principal is not limited to the amount of the bond. Unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorney’s fees or costs against the surety under the bond, a surety is not liable for an award of attorney’s fees as or costs.
…
(e) For purposes on this section, “surety” means “admitted surety insurer” as defined in Section 995.120.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The American Subcontractors Association of California explain the need for this measure:
The recent California appellate court opinion in Karton v. Ari Design (61 Cal. App. 5th 734) has brought to light an issue regarding the liability of surety bond companies holding licensed contractor bonds. Specifically, the opinion indicated that these companies may be compelled to pay attorney fees for litigating parties in cases where genuinely disputed claims necessitate litigation. Consequently, sureties are beginning to receive these types of claims for attorney fees.
AB 2677 aims to address this issue by defining "aggregate liability" to include all liability for damages, costs, and attorney’s fees, if recoverable. Further, the bill provides that unless a statute requiring a bond at issue affirmatively and expressly authorizes the recovery of attorney’s fees against the surety, a surety is not liable for an award of attorney’s fees as costs.
The potential for unlimited attorney’s fees payouts poses a significant risk and will likely necessitate higher bond premiums. Additionally, surety companies may opt to restrict the issuance of contractor bonds or even exit the market altogether. AB 2677 is aimed at preserving accessible contractor bonds while upholding consumer protections. Therefore, ASAC fully supports this measure.
A construction industry coalition, including United Contractors, Flasher Barricade Association and the California Builders Alliance, detail the significant impacts of the Karton decision on licensed contractors:
1). Since contractors indemnify the surety company for any and all costs charged against a bond, the contractor will be liable to reimburse the surety for the attorney’s fees.
2). Since attorney’s fees can be substantial (in the Karton case they were $90,000!), it is likely that many contractors will be forced into bankruptcy.
3). If the contractor files for bankruptcy, or cannot pay for whatever the reason, the surety will pay the fees. Because of the risk of exposure to unlimited attorney’s fee payouts due to contractors being unable to pay the costs, the potentially significant costs to the surety will be offset by charging the remaining bondholders (contractors) higher bond premiums.
4). Sureties, knowing they could face unlimited attorney fee payouts, will tighten underwriting standards so that only those contractors with the healthiest balance sheets will be able to qualify for these bonds.
5). Sureties may limit the number of contractor bonds they issue.
6). It prevents contractors from having an opportunity to litigate disputed claims. Why?
Because, to avoid exposure to attorney fees in excess of the bond’s penal sum, sureties will be incentivized to pay the claim rather than allow the contractors to litigate their dispute.
7). Sureties Leaving California Market. One other major driver affecting both surety bond affordability and availability is the fact that surety companies already have and will continue to, exponentially, leave the California market if the California State Legislature and governor do not act. Indeed, the second largest writer of surety bonds in California, Suretec Insurance/Markel Surety, has already withdrawn from writing contractor license bonds in the California surety marketplace, with several other sureties as well currently deliberating whether to withdraw.
8). Finally, any and all increased costs that contractors will be faced with will be passed on to the consumer. This could seriously impact the construction economy, because many projects, due to their increased costs, will be put ‘on hold.’
Then there’s the realization that many of these existing as well as prospective contractors, who will be unable to qualify or afford the increased license bond, will simply work unlicensed. This will mean then that all of the consumers who contract with these individuals will lose even the most basic protection that would be afforded to them by way of the $25,000 license bond.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Associated General Contractors
Associated General Contractors San Diego Chapter
Associated Roofing Contractors of Bay Area Counties, Inc.
California Builders Alliance
California Building Industry Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Flasher Barricade Association
Masonry Contractors Association of California, Inc.
Roofing Contractors Association of California
Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange
Southern California Contractors Association
Union Roofing Contractors Assn
United Contractors
Western Electrical Contractors Association Inc.
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
View Older HearingsBill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):