AB 2766: Prisons: parole calculations and inmate release credits.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-16
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Under existing law, criminal offenders sentenced to imprisonment in the state prison are sentenced for either a determinate term or an indeterminate life sentence, and a person sentenced to an indeterminate life sentence is held until release by the Board of Parole Hearings. Under existing law, a person sentenced to a determinate sentence is released after serving the term of their sentence, minus any credits earned, and is required to serve a period of time after release under parole supervision.
Existing constitutional provisions, enacted by Proposition 57 at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election, make an inmate sentenced to state prison for a conviction of a nonviolent felony offense eligible for early parole consideration after completing the full term for their primary offense, as defined.
This bill would provide that Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records pertaining to an inmates release date and their early release credits are public records and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. The bill would require the department, Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, by March 1, 2026, and by March 1 of each year thereafter, to compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits, as specified, and post that report on its internet website.
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for inspection by the public, subject to specified criteria and with specified exceptions. Existing law exempts from disclosure any investigatory or security file compiled by any other state or local police agency, or any investigatory or security files compiled by any other state or local agency for correctional, law enforcement, or licensing purposes.
Under existing law, criminal offenders sentenced to imprisonment in the state prison are sentenced for either a determinate term or an indeterminate life sentence, and a person sentenced to an indeterminate life sentence is held until release by the Board of Parole Hearings. Under existing law, a person sentenced to a determinate sentence is released after serving the term of their sentence, minus any credits earned, and is required to serve a period of time after release under parole supervision.
Existing constitutional provisions, enacted by Proposition 57 at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election, make an inmate sentenced to state prison for a conviction of a nonviolent felony offense eligible for early parole consideration after completing the full term for their primary offense, as defined.
This bill would provide that Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records pertaining to an inmates release date and their early release credits are public records and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. The bill would state that the provisions relative to the California Public Records Act are declaratory of existing law. The bill would require the department, by March 1, 2026, and by March 1 of each year thereafter, to compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits, as specified, and post that report on its internet website.
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for inspection by the public, subject to specified criteria and with specified exceptions. Existing law exempts from disclosure any investigatory or security file compiled by any other state or local police agency, or any investigatory or security files compiled by any other state or local agency for correctional, law enforcement, or licensing purposes.
Under existing law, criminal offenders sentenced to imprisonment in the state prison are sentenced for either a determinate term or an indeterminate life sentence, and a person sentenced to an indeterminate life sentence is held until release by the Board of Parole Hearings. Under existing law, a person sentenced to a determinate sentence is released after serving the term of their sentence, minus any credits earned, and is required to serve a period of time after release under parole supervision.
Existing constitutional provisions, enacted by Proposition 57 at the November 8, 2016, statewide general election, make an inmate sentenced to state prison for a conviction of a nonviolent felony offense eligible for early parole consideration after completing the full term for their primary offense, as defined.
This bill would provide that Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records pertaining to an inmates release date and their early release credits are public records and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. The bill would state that the provisions relative to the California Public Records Act are declaratory of existing law.
By March 1, 2026, and by March 1 of each year thereafter, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. The annual report, which shall be posted on the departments internet website, shall include the following information:
(a)The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.
(b)The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
SECTION 1.Section 7923.611 is added to the Government Code, to read:7923.611.(a)(1)To the extent that disclosure is not prohibited by subdivision (b) or any other provision of the Public Records Act, department records pertaining to an inmates release date and the early release credits earned by an inmate are public records and are subject to disclosure under this division.(2)A disclosure under this section shall be limited to the total number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories:(A)Good behavior.(B)Rehabilitation and education program participation.(C)Pretrial release credits.(b)This section does not allow the disclosure of either of the following:(1)Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191) or the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code).(2)Early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison, as described in Section 2935 of the Penal Code.(c)By March 1, 2026, and by March 1 of each year thereafter, the department shall compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. The annual report, which shall be posted on the departments internet website, shall include the following information:(1)The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.(2)The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.(d)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:(1)Department means the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.(2)In-custody informant has the same meaning as in subdivision (a) of Section 1127a of the Penal Code.(a)(1)To the extent that disclosure is not prohibited by subdivision (b) or any other provision of the Public Records Act, Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation department records pertaining to an inmates release date and what the inmate did to earn any release credits the early release credits earned by an inmate are public records and are subject to disclosure under this division.
(1)(2)A disclosure under this section shall be sufficiently detailed and include the limited to the total number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories:
(A)Good behavior.
(B)Rehabilitation and education program participation.
(C)Pretrial release credits.
(2)A disclosure shall also include the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.(b)This section does not require allow the disclosure of Department either of the following:
(1)Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191). 104-191) or the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code).
(c)(1)This section does not require the disclosure of early(2)Early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison, as described in Section 2935 of the Penal Code.
(c)By March 1, 2026, and by March 1 of each year thereafter, the department shall compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. The annual report, which shall be posted on the departments internet website, shall include the following information:
(1)The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.
(2)The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
(2)(d)As used in this section, in-custody the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Department means the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
(2)In-custody informant has the same meaning as in subdivision (a) of Section 1127a of the Penal Code.
SEC. 2.The addition of Section 7923.611 to the Government Code made by this act does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.(a)To the extent that disclosure is not prohibited by any other provision of the Public Records Act, Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records pertaining to an inmates release date and what the inmate did to earn any release credits are public records and are subject to disclosure under this division.
(1)A disclosure under this section shall be sufficiently detailed and include the number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories:
(A)Good behavior.
(B)Rehabilitation and education program participation.
(C)Pretrial release credits.
(2)A disclosure shall also include the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.
(b)This section does not require the disclosure of Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191).
(c)(1)This section does not require the disclosure of early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison, as described in Section 2935 of the Penal Code.
(2)As used in this section, in-custody informant has the same meaning as in subdivision (a) of Section 1127a of the Penal Code.
SEC. 2.The addition of Section 7923.611 to the Government Code made by this act does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jul 1, 2024 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jun 18, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| May 22, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 21, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 72. Noes 0. Page 5378.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2024 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 2). |
| Mar 19, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (March 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 4, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and JUD. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2024 | AB 2766 Low Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 19, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Arcadia Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Burbank Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Support | |
| California Narcotic Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| California Reserve Peace Officers Association | ** Support | |
| California State Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| CLAREMONT POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Corona Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Culver City Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Deputy Sheriffs Association of Monterey County | ** Support | |
| Fullerton Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Support | |
| League Of California Cities | ** Support | |
| Murrieta Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Neutral as Proposed to be Amended | ** Support | |
| Newport Beach Police Association | ** Support | |
| Novato Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Palos Verdes Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| PLACER COUNTY DEPUTY SHERIFFS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Pomona Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| RIVERSIDE POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Support | |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| San Bernardino County Sheriff'S Department | ** Support | |
| Santa Ana Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Uncommon Law | ** Against | |
| Upland Police Officers Association | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2766 (Low) - Prisons: parole calculations and inmate release credits
Version: May 16, 2024 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: July 1, 2024 | Consultant: Liah Burnley |
Bill Summary:
AB 2766 would require the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to compile an annual report for each facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year.
Fiscal Impact:
CDCR indicates significant one-time costs (General Fund) potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to implement this bill. CDCR notes that each institution is divided into facilities and the level of detail required to be reported under this bill would require CDCR’s Office of Research to establish new reporting protocols that ensure compliance. Additionally, CDCR has broad categories of credits awarded to the incarcerated population for participation and achievement in certain programming opportunities. Ensuring CDCR appropriately captures and reports the level of details required under AB 2766 would result in likely significant one-time costs.
Background:
The California Constitution authorizes CDCR to award credits to incarcerated persons. Section 32 to article I of the California Constitution states, in pertinent part:
The following provisions are hereby added to enhance public safety, improve rehabilitation, and avoid the release of prisoners by federal court order, notwithstanding anything in this article or any other provision of law. […]
Credit Earning: The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall have authority to award credits earned for good behavior and approved rehabilitative or educational achievements. […]
The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall adopt regulations in furtherance of these provisions, and the Secretary of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall certify that these regulations protect and enhance public safety.
Pursuant to CDCR’s Regulations, Good Conduct Credits and other programming credits, such as Rehabilitative Achievement Credits, Milestone Completion Credits, and Educational Merit Credits, apply toward an incarcerated person’s Earliest Possible Release Date for determinate sentences and Minimum Eligible Parole Date for indeterminate sentences.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires CDCR to compile an annual report for each facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. This bill requires the annual report to include the following information:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year; and,
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 2766 Hearing Date: June 18, 2024
Author: | Low | ||
Version: | May 16, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SJ | ||
Subject: Prisons: parole calculations and inmate release credits
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: AB 15 (Dixon), failed in Assembly Public Safety in 2023
SB 288 (Nguyen), failed in Senate Pubic Safety in 2023
SB 359 (Umberg), failed in Assembly Public Safety in 2023
Proposition 57, as approved by the voters on November 8, 2016
Support: California District Attorneys Association; California Police Chiefs Association; League of California Cities
Opposition: None known
Assembly Floor Vote: 72 - 0
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to require the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to compile an annual report for each facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year.
Existing law, as enacted by Proposition 57, provides that any person convicted of a nonviolent felony offense and sentenced to state prison is eligible for parole consideration after completing the full term for his or her primary offense. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 32, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law, as enacted by Proposition 57, provides that CDCR has the authority to award credits earned for good behavior and approved rehabilitative or educational achievements. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 32, subd. (a)(2).)
Existing law requires CDCR to submit a report to the relevant fiscal and policy committees of the Legislature and the Legislative Analyst’s Office whenever the department proposes regulatory changes pursuant to Section 32 of Article I of the California Constitution that would affect inmate credit earning. Requires the report to include both of the following: an explanation of the rationale for each of the proposed changes to credit earning, and an estimate of the impact of the proposed changes to credit earning on the size of inmate and parolee populations. (Pen. Code, § 2936.)
Existing law provides that, in addition to other specified limitations, the only inmate or parolee data which may be released without a valid written authorization from the inmate or parolee to the media or to the public includes that inmate’s or parolee’s: name; age; race and/or ethnicity; birthplace; county of last legal residence; commitment offense; date of admission to CDCR and CDCR number; facility assignments and a general description of behavior; patient health condition given in short and general terms that do not communicate specific medical information about the individual, such as good, fair, serious, critical, treated and released, or undetermined; manner of death as natural, homicide, suicide, accidental, or executed; and, sentencing and release actions, including month and year of current parole eligibility date. (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 15, § 3261.2, subd. (e)(1)-(11).)
This bill requires CDCR to compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year, by March 1, 2026, and by March 1 of each year.
This bill requires the annual report to include the following information:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
This bill requires the annual report to be posted on the department’s website.
COMMENTS
- Need For This Bill
According to the author:
In recent news, we have seen cases of violent, convicted felons who were released early from their prison sentences, and who then went on to commit more violent felony offenses against the public. In many of these cases, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) has refused to disclose information as to how those inmates obtained their early release credits. It is vital to the creation of a fair and just system for all Californians, that we have a transparent criminal justice system.
- Proposition 57
Proposition 57 was approved by the voters in 2016 and changed the rules governing parole and the granting of custody credits to inmates in state prison. Proposition 57 authorized CDCR to award credits earned for good behavior and approved rehabilitative or educational achievements. Prior to the passage of the initiative, the matter of conduct credits earned in prison was governed by statute. (See e.g., Pen. Code, §§ 2933 and 2933.1.)
Proposition 57 added section 32 to article I of the California Constitution which states, in pertinent part:
32. (a) The following provisions are hereby added to enhance public safety, improve rehabilitation, and avoid the release of prisoners by federal court order, notwithstanding anything in this article or any other provision of law….
(2) Credit Earning: The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall have authority to award credits earned for good behavior and approved rehabilitative or educational achievements.
(b) The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall adopt regulations in furtherance of these provisions, and the Secretary of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall certify that these regulations protect and enhance public safety. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 32, emphasis added)
Effective May 1, 2021, the rate of Good Conduct Credits earned for individuals serving time for a violent felony increased to 33.3%. (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 15, § 3043.2, subd. (b)(2).) The rate of Good Conduct Credits earned for nonviolent second and third strikers increased to 50%. (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 15, § 3043.2, subd. (b)(3).) Good Conduct Credits and other programming credits, such as Rehabilitative Achievement Credits, Milestone Completion Credits, and Educational Merit Credits, apply toward an incarcerated person’s Earliest Possible Release Date for determinate sentences and Minimum Eligible Parole Date for indeterminate sentences. (Cal. Code Regs, tit. 15, §§ 3043.2, subd. (b), 3043.3, subd. (c), 3043.4, subd. (b), 3043.5, subd. (b).)
- CDCR’s Credit Calculations
CDCR regulations implementing Proposition 57 have garnered significant interest since the passage of the initiative and been the subject of several legal challenges, including the exclusion of registered sex offenders in the initial proposed regulations and the use of a “paper review” parole consideration process, among others. The regulations received additional attention following the announcement of changes to credit earning in the spring of 2021, and several news outlets ran stories with headlines regarding the significant number of incarcerated individuals who would be eligible for early release as a result. (See Don Thompson, 76,000 California prison inmates could be released earlier with good behavior (May 1, 2021) available at <https://www.latimes.com/world-nation/story/2021-05-01/76-000-california-inmates-now-eligible-for-earlier-releases>.) The department’s credit calculations have been criticized for lacking transparency and being awarded in ways that are inconsistent with the voters’ intent. (Julie Watts, “Secret” Prop. 57 prison credits: Are most felons really “earning” early release? (Oct. 11, 2022) available at <https://www.cbsnews.com/sacramento/news/investigating-prop-57-credits-how-was-sacramento-shooting-suspect-smiley-martin-out-of-prison-early/>.) CDCR maintains that credit earning information is confidential. (Id.)
- Effect of This Bill
This bill requires CDCR to compile an annual report for each facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. This bill requires the annual report to include the following information:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2766
Author:(Low and Dixon)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to compile data and issue a report on the number of incarcerated persons participating in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs and the total number of hours of sentence credits earned by those people.
Major Provisions
- Requires CDCR by March 1, 2026, and by March 1 annually thereafter, to compile an annual report for each CDCR facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year; and to post the annual reports on its internet website.
- Requires the report to include:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year; and,
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by incarcerated people, compiled in categories used by CDCR for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
COMMENTS
Proposition 57: On November 8, 2016, Californians voted on whether to increase rehabilitation services and decrease the state's prison population by approving Proposition 57. Known as The Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act of 2016, Proposition 57 proposed, among other things, to authorize CDCR to award sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education. It required CDCR to pass regulations to that effect. (https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2016/general/en/pdf/complete-vig.pdf.) Voters approved Proposition 57 by a margin of nearly 30 points. (https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_57,_Parole_for_Non-Violent_Criminals_and_Juvenile_Court_Trial_Requirements_(2016).)
As required, CDCR has since issued regulations to effectuate the proposition's purpose. (California Constitution, Article I, Section 32, subdivision (b); 15 California Code of Regulations Section 3043, et seq.) Awarding credits is based on several different eligibilities including Good Conduct, Milestone Completion, Rehabilitative Achievement, Educational Merit, and Extraordinary Conduct. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/proposition57/.)
According to the Author
"In recent news, we have seen cases of violent, convicted felons who were released early from their prison sentences, and who then went on to commit more violent felony offenses against the public. In many of these cases, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) has refused to disclose information as to how those inmates obtained their early release credits. It is vital to the creation of a fair and just system for all Californians, that we have a transparent criminal justice system. AB 2766 will provide that CDCR records pertaining to an inmate's early release date and how they earned their early release credits are available to the public, and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act. AB 2766 will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law, to help Californian's feel safe in their communities and to create just outcomes for all."
Arguments in Support
According to the California District Attorneys Association, "As many victims and justice system stakeholders have been surprised by the release of certain offenders and have expressed concerns about the lack of information when incarcerated individuals are released back into their communities, this bill is one way of addressing those concerns. The public should have a better idea of how the laws they have enacted are working when it comes to the release of offenders so they can decide whether to challenge, support, or seek modification in the laws.
"This bill is a codification of how release of the records should be handled under the current law, with exceptions to disclosure in the current language that protect the most sensitive information, and modifications to further mitigate any harm from the competing concerns can be made if warranted."
Arguments in Opposition
According to Oakland Privacy, "It is a relatively rare occasion for us to find ourselves arguing against more governmental transparency and against a broadening of the California Public Records Act. However the potential safety issues disregarded by AB 2766 are sobering and of great concern. Moreover, it is not clear to us what the public interest in the information actually consists of. The CPRA is not intended to satisfy prurient, sensationalistic interests and in this case, we are unable to identify any other interest. Accordingly, we request that the committee not advance the bill.
"The privacy interests at stake in AB 2766 are similar to those that protect employee data and medical records. In general, rehabilitative efforts can and do encompass personal information including substance issues, mental health and therapy, and educational difficulties. Both employers and health/medical facilities keep such information private for very good reasons. Release of such information has discriminatory aspects and moreover, having such information broadly released serves as a strong disincentive to requesting and receiving needed treatments. The Legislature, for example, has taken legislative action to prevent the sale and sharing of information from mental health applications for exactly this reason.
"In a prison and in the real world that inmates must sometimes grapple with post-release (which includes gangs and former criminal associates) these dangers are multiplied and amplified with physical threats to life and limb if gangs and associates dislike rehabilitative efforts or associate them with snitching to criminal justice authorities. Since one form of credit (the extraordinary conduct credit) in fact involves assisting with safety and security issues in the prison, the perception of snitching may in fact be the reality - with possible consequences awaiting the inmate post-release, which neither CDCR nor the unwitting public records requester is likely to be available to mitigate.
"One of the fundamental precepts of privacy law is consent, which is nowhere mentioned in AB 2766. For good reasons, the Public Records Act does not rely on the consent of government bodies in order to release public information, but inmates are not government bodies and information about their activities in prison can, in some circumstances, not only constitute particularized individual information about one specific person, but also pose unique dangers to them upon release. While we do strip inmates of a number of personal freedoms and rights, the privacy of their medical and psychiatric information has generally not been up for grabs. At a minimum, allowing an inmate to withhold consent for the release of their records would seem to be required for their safety.
"Moreover, the public interest in such information is unclear to us. The bill's author in the 2023 Assembly Public Safety committee analysis states that "more transparencies will help the community feel safe and be assured that CDCR is properly applying the law". While we share an interest in CDCR properly applying the law, the oversight responsibilities for CDCR lie with the state and the Legislature, not with individual members of the public. We don't really see how a list of the particular set of release credits for one or a small group of individuals provides oversight of CDCR's performance, which requires aggregate data. So the likely use of such reports seems limited to one of two purposes"
- Harassing a particular individual after their release, which can only have negative effects regarding recidivism and the ability to re-integrate into non-criminal society
- Gotcha reporting for ex post-facto examinations in the unfortunate incidence of another crime after release. While we would never say there is no public interest in sensationalistic crime reporting, one individual's story, however dramatic it may prove to be, is not in itself a meaningful analysis of rehabilitation programs and shouldn't be substituted for one. There is plenty of aggregated data available for reporters interested in examining how well California's rehabilitative efforts are going.
"Given the potential dangers to newly-released inmates and the lack of news value in individual health and psychiatric information garnered without consent, the balance of equities present are convincingly on the side of treating personal information like it is personal information."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to Assembly Appropriations Committee, "Annual costs (General Fund) to CDCR of an unknown but potentially significant amount to generate and post the facility reports required by the bill. If CDCR needs to update its IT systems to generate the information required for the reports, the department will also incur significant one-time costs."
VOTES
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: McCarty, Alanis, Lackey, Stephanie Nguyen, Reyes, Ting, Wilson, Zbur
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: McKinnor
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 10-0-5
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Bryan, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: May 16, 2024
CONSULTANT: Andrew Ironside / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0003270
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2766
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
Judiciary | 11 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill states that certain information about credits earned by an incarcerated person is disclosable under the Public Records Act (PRA) and requires the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to release an annual report for each CDCR facility that includes information about the number of incarcerated people who participated in specified rehabilitative activities and the total amount of credits earned.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs (General Fund) to CDCR, likely in the millions of dollars or more annually. As described in more detail below, CDCR will need to hire additional staff to respond to PRA requests authorized by this bill, handle related litigation, and complete the facility reports required by the bill. CDCR also reports significant one-time costs, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, for IT system updates to generate some of the information required to be disclosed under the bill.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In recent news, we have seen cases of violent, convicted felons who were released early from their prison sentences, and who then went on to commit more violent felony offenses against the public. In many of these cases, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) has refused to disclose information as to how those inmates obtained their early release credits. It is vital to the creation of a fair and just system for all Californians, that we have a transparent criminal justice system… AB 2766 will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law, to help Californian’s feel safe in their communities and to create just outcomes for all.
- Background. Under existing law, there are a number of credits that may be applied to an incarcerated person’s sentence to reduce the actual amount of time in custody they are required to serve. Some credits are based on an incarcerated person’s good behavior, while others are awarded upon completion of specific rehabilitative programs. The maximum amount of credits an incarcerated person may earn also depends on their conviction offense and when the conviction occurred. In 2016, voters passed Proposition 57, which, in pertinent part, amended the California Constitution to give CDCR authority to award credits for good behavior and approved rehabilitative and education achievements. As stated in Proposition 57, the goal of these credits is “to enhance public safety, improve rehabilitation, and avoid the release of prisoners by federal court order” due to significant prison overcrowding in the state. As required by Proposition 57, CDCR promulgated regulations that allow the department to award a variety of credits, including for good conduct, milestone completion, rehabilitative achievement, educational merit, and extraordinary conduct. In addition to potential rehabilitative benefits, credit earning helps promote a safer environment inside detention facilities by incentivizing incarcerated people to follow the rules, refrain from violence, and participate in self-help programming, vocational training, and education programs.
This bill states that, with specified exceptions, records pertaining to an incarcerated person’s release date and credits they have earned are disclosable public records under the PRA. Under the bill, such a disclosure must be limited to the total number of days of credit for good behavior, rehabilitation and education program participation, and pretrial release credits. The bill does not allow disclosure of CDCR records protected by state and federal medical confidentiality laws or early release credits earned by an in-custody informant. Additionally, the bill requires CDCR to compile, beginning in 2026, an annual report for each CDCR facility that includes information about the number of incarcerated people at the facility who participated in rehabilitative programs and the total amount of credits earned by people incarcerated at the facility.
As described above, both of these provisions will result in significant workload increases to CDCR. There are currently more than 90,000 people incarcerated in CDCR facilities in California. Under the PRA, any member of the public may submit a request for records to CDCR and CDCR is obligated to provide a response within 10 days or defend civil litigation to enforce the request. If PRA requests are submitted for even 5% of CDCR’s population, the department will need additional staffing to handle the resulting 4,500 record requests and funding for any related litigation. CDCR will also incur additional workload costs to compile the required annual reports for each of the department’s prisons, camps, and other facilities.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2766
Author:(Low and Dixon)
As Amended Ver:April 03, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
States that California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) records pertaining to an incarcerated person's release date and the early release credits earned by an incarcerated person are public records subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act (CPRA).
Major Provisions
- States that CDCR records pertaining to an incarcerated person's release date and the early release credits earned by an incarcerated person are public records subject to disclosure under CPRA.
- Requires disclosure to be limited to the total number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories:
- Good behavior;
- Rehabilitation and education program participation; and,
- Pretrial release credits.
- Provides that CDCR is prohibited from disclosing records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA).
- Provides that CDCR is prohibited from disclosing early release credits earned by an in-custody informant, as defined, for providing exception assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison.
- Requires CDCR by March 1, 2026, and by March 1 annually thereafter, to compile an annual report for each CDCR facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year; and to post the annual reports on its internet website.
- Requires the report to include:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year; and,
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by incarcerated people, compiled in categories used by CDCR for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, prerelease programs, and grant programs.
COMMENTS
- Proposition 57: On November 8, 2016, Californians voted on whether to increase rehabilitation services and decrease the state's prison population by approving Proposition 57. Known as The Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act of 2016, Proposition 57 proposed, among other things, to authorize CDCR to award sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education. It required CDCR to pass regulations to that effect. (https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2016/general/en/pdf/complete-vig.pdf.) Voters approved Proposition 57 by a margin of nearly 30 points. (https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_57,_Parole_for_Non-Violent_Criminals_and_Juvenile_Court_Trial_Requirements_(2016).)
- As required, CDCR has since issued regulations to effectuate the proposition's purpose. (Cal. Const., Art. I, Section 32, subd. (b); 15 CCR Section 3043, et seq.) Awarding credits is based on several different eligibilities including Good Conduct, Milestone Completion, Rehabilitative Achievement, Educational Merit, and Extraordinary Conduct. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/proposition57/.)
- Institutional Safety at CDCR Facilities: This bill would make "[CDCR] records pertaining to an inmate's release date and what the inmate did to earn any release credits…subject to disclosure" under CPRA. This bill provides limited exceptions to or restrictions on disclosure. It does not limit who can request an incarcerate person's records. Nor does it exempt from disclosure an incarcerated person's release credit information before that person's release date has been set. Even if the date has been set, an incarcerated person is not immediately released upon receiving that date. In either case, a person could request information on an incarcerated person's rehabilitative efforts and then communicate that information to another incarcerated person within the same institution.
For example, an incarcerated person may receive "up to twelve months of Extraordinary Conduct Credit" for "provid[ing] exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison." (Pen. Code, section 2935; 15 CCR section 3043.6, subd. (a).) Disclosure that an incarcerated person assisted corrections staff may put that person at risk from other incarcerated persons, particularly if the provided information resulted in consequences for other incarcerated persons. Given the ongoing efforts by CDCR to manage security threat groups ("gangs") and other security threats within its institutions, there may be reason for concern that such broad disclosures would threaten institutional safety and the safety of the people in CDCR's care. Similarly, it could also put the individual in immediate risk from persons who are not incarcerated, such as members of rival gangs, once they are released from prison.
This bill would require disclosure of all credits earned except HIPAA-protected records and "early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison." However, exempting disclosure of only the information pertaining to extraordinary conduct credits would result in a discrepancy between the credits earned and the release date, highlighting that the incarcerated person had received credits for conduct exempted from disclosure. The omission of the credits would serve only to highlight that the credits had been earned in service to CDCR.
- A Disincentive to Participate in Rehabilitative Programming: As mentioned above, this bill provides broad disclosure on what an incarcerated person did to earn release credits before that person has been released from CDCR, which may place that person at risk. Moreover, this bill requires disclosure of "the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed." This could require the disclosure of information about rehabilitation credits an incarcerated person earns for participation in self-help and peer support groups, such as Narcotics Anonymous and/or Alcoholics Anonymous among others, or participation programs like CBI-Life Skills. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/rehabilitation/cbi/) Whether such information falls under the bill's HIPAA-exception is unclear, and resolving the issue could require litigation. If earning credits could result in disclosure of an incarcerated person's personal information or might threaten their personal safety, will they be disincentivized to participate in rehabilitative programming?
- Vague Language: This bill provides that "[a] disclosure…shall be sufficiently detailed and include the number of days of credit…," but it does not provide guidance to CDCR on the records, or the portions of records, that would be required to meet that standard. Given that the bill requires that disclosures be both "sufficiently detailed and include the number of days of credit…," disclosure would have to go beyond a cursory calculation of the total credit days an incarcerated person has earned in each category. But what level of detail is "sufficient[]" to comply with this bill's mandate?
- Practical Consideration: According to the author, this bill "will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law." Yet, as previously noted, this bill would not require disclosure of HIPAA-protected records or "early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison." As a result, a report issued by CDCR in response to a CPRA request on how an individual earned release credits while incarcerated would not completely account for credits withheld under one of the exceptions in this bill. Put simply, under this bill the public may not have significantly more clarity about how CDCR awarded an individual credits, even if it knows more personal, potentially embarrassing or stigmatizing, information about the subject of the request.
According to the Author
"In recent news, we have seen cases of violent, convicted felons who were released early from their prison sentences, and who then went on to commit more violent felony offenses against the public. In many of these cases, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) has refused to disclose information as to how those inmates obtained their early release credits. It is vital to the creation of a fair and just system for all Californians, that we have a transparent criminal justice system. AB 2766 will provide that CDCR records pertaining to an inmate's early release date and how they earned their early release credits are available to the public, and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act. AB 2766 will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law, to help Californian's feel safe in their communities and to create just outcomes for all."
Arguments in Support
According to the California District Attorneys Association, "As many victims and justice system stakeholders have been surprised by the release of certain offenders and have expressed concerns about the lack of information when incarcerated individuals are released back into their communities, this bill is one way of addressing those concerns. The public should have a better idea of how the laws they have enacted are working when it comes to the release of offenders so they can decide whether to challenge, support, or seek modification in the laws.
"This bill is a codification of how release of the records should be handled under the current law, with exceptions to disclosure in the current language that protect the most sensitive information, and modifications to further mitigate any harm from the competing concerns can be made if warranted."
Arguments in Opposition
According to Oakland Privacy, "It is a relatively rare occasion for us to find ourselves arguing against more governmental transparency and against a broadening of the California Public Records Act. However the potential safety issues disregarded by AB 2766 are sobering and of great concern. Moreover, it is not clear to us what the public interest in the information actually consists of. The CPRA is not intended to satisfy prurient, sensationalistic interests and in this case, we are unable to identify any other interest. Accordingly, we request that the committee not advance the bill.
"The privacy interests at stake in AB 2766 are similar to those that protect employee data and medical records. In general, rehabilitative efforts can and do encompass personal information including substance issues, mental health and therapy, and educational difficulties. Both employers and health/medical facilities keep such information private for very good reasons. Release of such information has discriminatory aspects and moreover, having such information broadly released serves as a strong disincentive to requesting and receiving needed treatments. The Legislature, for example, has taken legislative action to prevent the sale and sharing of information from mental health applications for exactly this reason.
"In a prison and in the real world that inmates must sometimes grapple with post-release (which includes gangs and former criminal associates) these dangers are multiplied and amplified with physical threats to life and limb if gangs and associates dislike rehabilitative efforts or associate them with snitching to criminal justice authorities. Since one form of credit (the extraordinary conduct credit) in fact involves assisting with safety and security issues in the prison, the perception of snitching may in fact be the reality - with possible consequences awaiting the inmate post-release, which neither CDCR nor the unwitting public records requester is likely to be available to mitigate.
"One of the fundamental precepts of privacy law is consent, which is nowhere mentioned in AB 2766. For good reasons, the Public Records Act does not rely on the consent of government bodies in order to release public information, but inmates are not government bodies and information about their activities in prison can, in some circumstances, not only constitute particularized individual information about one specific person, but also pose unique dangers to them upon release. While we do strip inmates of a number of personal freedoms and rights, the privacy of their medical and psychiatric information has generally not been up for grabs. At a minimum, allowing an inmate to withhold consent for the release of their records would seem to be required for their safety.
"Moreover, the public interest in such information is unclear to us. The bill's author in the 2023 Assembly Public Safety committee analysis states that "more transparencies will help the community feel safe and be assured that CDCR is properly applying the law". While we share an interest in CDCR properly applying the law, the oversight responsibilities for CDCR lie with the state and the Legislature, not with individual members of the public. We don't really see how a list of the particular set of release credits for one or a small group of individuals provides oversight of CDCR's performance, which requires aggregate data. So the likely use of such reports seems limited to one of two purposes"
1) Harassing a particular individual after their release, which can only have negative effects
regarding recidivism and the ability to re-integrate into non-criminal society.
2) Gotcha reporting for ex post-facto examinations in the unfortunate incidence of another crime after release. While we would never say there is no public interest in sensationalistic crime reporting, one individual's story, however dramatic it may prove to be, is not in itself a meaningful analysis of rehabilitation programs and shouldn't be substituted for one. There is plenty of aggregated data available for reporters interested in examining how well California's rehabilitative efforts are going.
"Given the potential dangers to newly-released inmates and the lack of news value in individual health and psychiatric information garnered without consent, the balance of equities present are convincingly on the side of treating personal information like it is personal information."
FISCAL COMMENTS
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: McCarty, Alanis, Lackey, Stephanie Nguyen, Reyes, Ting, Wilson, Zbur
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, Pacheco, Reyes, Sanchez, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: McKinnor
UPDATED
VERSION: April 03, 2024
CONSULTANT: Andrew Ironside / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0002693
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2766
Author:(Low and Dixon) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2024
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Public records: parole calculations and inmate release credits
KEY ISSUES:
- should existng law be clarified so that specified information in the records of the california department of corrections and rehabilitation (CDCR) about inmates, including AN INMATE’S release date and the early release credits earned by the inmate, is required to be disclosed to the public upon request?
- should CDCR be required, by March 1, 2026 and by March 1ST of each year thereafter, to compile an annual report for each facility that awards sentence credits, with data ABOUT INMATE PARTICIPATION IN rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year?
SYNOPSIS
Access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. The people of the state also support providing rehabilitation and educational programs, as well as the early release credits awarded for such programs, to inmates in California prisons. However, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) currently provides the public with very limited information about the programs, and inmate participation in those programs, to the public. CDCR, for example, does not provide the public with information about inmate release dates upon their request.
The bill in print requires disclosure of “the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.” Arguably, this type of information could violate an inmate’s privacy and disincentivized inmate participation in programs that could be embarrassing, thereby undermining the rehabilitative goals of CDCR and Proposition 57. As proposed to be amended, the bill requires the disclosure of information about how inmates earn their early release credits, but on a less granular, invasive, and potentially endangering level. For example, it clarifies that an inmate’s release date and the early release credits earned by the inmate are public records that are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act (CPRA). But it does not require the release of information that arguably would invade the inmate’s privacy and endanger their safety without serving any valid public interest. The amendments are incorporated into the SUMMARY, below, and explained in the analysis.
The bill is supported by a large number of law enforcement groups. It is opposed by UnCommon Law; Oakland Privacy and Initiate Justice, which oppose the bill in print, are neutral on the bill as it is proposed to be amended.
SUMMARY: Clarifies that the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and the early release credits earned by an inmate are public records that are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act (CPRA); and requires CDCR to compile an annual report that summarizes inmate participation in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs at each CDCR facility. Specifically, this bill:
- States that to the extent that disclosure is not prohibited by 3), or any other provision of the CPRA, CDCR’s records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and the early release credits earned by an inmate are public records that are subject to disclosure under CPRA.
- Requires disclosure to be limited to the total number of days of credit that were awarded based on each of the following categories:
- Good behavior;
- Rehabilitation and education program participation; and,
- Pretrial release credits.
- Provides that CDCR shall not disclose either of the following:
- Records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA) or the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code).
- Early release credits earned by an in-custody informant, as defined, for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison.
- Requires, by March 1, 2026 and by March 1st of each year thereafter, CDCR to compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. The annual report, which shall be posted on the department’s internet website, shall include the following information:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, pre-release programs, and grant programs.
- Defines the following terms to have the following meaning:
- “Department” means the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
- “In-custody informant” has the same meaning as in subdivision (a) of Section 1127a of the Penal Code.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business and, therefore, the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny. Specifies that any law or rule that limits the public right of access shall be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation. (California Constitution, art. I, Section 3.)
- Provides that, in enacting the California Public Records Act (CPRA), the Legislature, mindful of the right of individuals to privacy, finds and declares that access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Government Code Section 7921.000. All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Defines “public records” to include any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics and those in the custody of, or maintained by, the Governor’s office means any writing prepared on or after January 6, 1975. (Section 7920.530.)
- Provides that public records are open to inspection at all times during the office hours of a state or local agency and every person has a right to inspect any public record, exempted as otherwise provided; and that any reasonably segregable portion of a record shall be available for inspection by any person requesting the record after deletion of the portions that are exempted by law. (Section 7922.525.)
- Requires a public agency to determine whether it has disclosable public records in its possession within ten days or, in specified “unusual circumstances,” within 14 days of the ten-day period, of its receipt of a request for public records and to promptly notify the person making the request of the determination and the reasons therefor. (Section 7922.535 (a).)
- Requires a public agency to justify withholding any record by demonstrating that the record in question is exempt under express provisions of this division, or that on the facts of the particular case the public interest served by not disclosing the record clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record. (Section 7922.000.)
- Provides that Penal Code sections 11076 and 13202 may operate to exempt criminal offender record information, or portions thereof, from disclosure. (Section 7930.130.)
- Provides that criminal offender record information shall be disseminated, whether directly or through any intermediary, only to such agencies as are, or may subsequently be, authorized access to such records by statutes. (Penal Code Section 11076.)
- Provides that every public agency or bona fide research institution concerned with the prevention or control of crime, the quality of criminal justice, or the custody or correction of offenders may be provided with criminal offender record information, including criminal court records, as required for the performance of its duties, including the conduct of research. (Penal Code Section 13202.)
- Requires CDCR to establish written guidelines for accessibility of records and to make a copy of the guidelines available upon request free of charge to any person requesting them. (Section 7922.635 (a)(6), (b).)
- Provides that an incarcerated person, unless otherwise precluded, is eligible to receive good conduct, rehabilitation, and/or education credits to advance their release date if sentenced to a determinate term or to advance an initial parole hearing date if sentenced to an indeterminate term with the possibility of parole. (Penal Code Sections 2931, 2933, 2933.05; see also 15 CCR 3043.4, et. seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill clarifies that California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and the early release credits earned by an inmate are public records that are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act (CPRA); and requires CDCR to compile an annual report that summarizes inmate participation in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs at each CDCR facility. According to the author:
In recent news, we have seen cases of violent, convicted felons who were released early from their prison sentences, and who then went on to commit more violent felony offenses against the public. In many of these cases, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) has refused to disclose information as to how those inmates obtained their early release credits. It is vital to the creation of a fair and just system for all Californians, that we have a transparent criminal justice system. AB 2766 will provide that CDCR records pertaining to an inmate’s early release date and how they earned their early release credits are available to the public, and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act. AB 2766 will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law, to help Californian’s feel safe in their communities and to create just outcomes for all.
Public Records and Public Access to Such Records. Access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Section 7921.000.) In 2004, the right of public access was enshrined in the California Constitution with the passage of Proposition 59 (Nov. 3, 2004, statewide general election), placed on the ballot by a unanimous vote of both houses of the Legislature. (SCA 1 (Burton, Ch. 1, Stats. 2004), which amended the California Constitution to specifically protect the right of the public to access and obtain government records: “The people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and therefore . . . the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny.” (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 3 (b)(1).) In 2014, voters approved Proposition 42 (Jun. 3, 2014, statewide direct primary election), placed on the ballot by a unanimous vote of both houses of the Legislature, (SCA 3 (Leno, Ch. 123, Stats. 2013), to further increase public access to government records by requiring local agencies to comply with the CPRA and the Ralph M. Brown Act, and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, as provided. (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 3 (b)(7).)
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection at all times during the office hours of a public agency for inspection by the public, unless exempted. (Section 7922.525.) A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Section 7920.530.) The CPRA allows a public agency 10 days or, in specified “unusual circumstances,” within 14 days of the 10-day period to respond to a request for the requested public record, and authorizes the agency to charge a fee for its “direct costs of duplication” of the record. (Sections 7922.530 (a), 7922.535.)
Proposition 57. On November 8, 2016, Californians voted to increase rehabilitation services and decrease the state’s prison population by approving Proposition 57. Known as The Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act of 2016, Proposition 57 proposed, among other things, to authorize CDCR to award sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education. It required CDCR to pass regulations to that effect. Voters approved Proposition 57 by a margin of nearly 30 points. (https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_57,_Parole_for_Non-Violent_Criminals_and_Juvenile_Court_Trial_Requirements_(2016).)
As required, CDCR has since issued regulations to effectuate Proposition 57’s purpose. (Cal. Const., Art. I, § 32, subd. (b); 15 CCR § 3043, et seq.) Awarding credits, pursuant to these regulations, is based on several different eligibilities including Good Conduct, Milestone Completion, Rehabilitative Achievement, Educational Merit, and Extraordinary Conduct. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/proposition57/.)
CDCR also has issued regulations governing the disclosure of information relating to an incarcerated person. Specifically, CDCR regulations state, “[T]he only inmate or parolee data which may be released without a valid written authorization from the inmate or parolee to the media or to the public” includes their name, age, race and/or ethnicity, birthplace, count of last legal residence, commitment offense, date of admission, facility assignment, a general description of behavior, a short and general description of an inmate’s health or manner of death, and the month and year of their release. (15 CCR § 3261.2(e)(1)-(11).)
The bill and author’s proposed amendments. The bill in print would make “[CDCR] records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and what the inmate did to earn any release credits…subject to disclosure” under the CPRA. Specifically, it requires disclosure of “the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.” As the Assembly Committee on Public Safety pointed out in its analysis of the bill, “this could require the disclosure of information about rehabilitation credits an incarcerated person earns for participation in self-help and peer support groups, such as Narcotics Anonymous and/or Alcoholics Anonymous among others, or participation programs like CBI-Life Skills.” Arguably, this type of information could violate an inmate’s privacy and disincentivized inmate participation in programs that could be embarrassing, thereby undermining the rehabilitative goals of CDCR and Proposition 57.
As proposed to be amended, the bill requires the disclosure of information about how inmates earn their early release credits, but on a less granular, invasive, and potentially endangering level. For example, it clarifies that an inmate’s release date and the early release credits earned by the inmate are public records that are subject to disclosure under CPRA. But it does not require the release of information that arguably would invade the inmate’s privacy and endanger their safety without serving any valid public interest. Instead, the bill, as proposed to be amended, requires disclosure to be limited to the total number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories: (1) good behavior; (2) rehabilitation and education program participation; and (3) pretrial release credits. This amendment also appears to resolve an issue raised by the Assembly Committee on Public Safety that release of the total number of credits, but not the credits earned by an inmate as a confidential informant, could allow members of the public (and even other inmates) to determine whether a fellow inmate had earned credits as an informant if there were a discrepancy between those two numbers, which could significantly endanger the safety of that inmate and the safety of other inmates and correctional officers working at the facility.
Whereas the bill in print states that disclosure of health information that is protected by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA) or early release credits earned by an in-custody informant “is not required,” the bill, as proposed to be amended, states that these types of information –the disclosure of which likely would violate federal law (in the case of HIPPA-protected health information) or endanger the safety of the inmate (in the case of in-custody informant information) is prohibited from being disclosed by CDCR.
The bill, as proposed to be amended, also requires CDCR to compile an annual report that summarizes inmate participation in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs at each CDCR facility. This report will provide aggregate data to the public, shedding light on the extent to which Proposition 57 is being implemented in CDCR facilities. Finally, the author’s amendments remove Section 2 of the bill, which states that the bill is declaratory of existing law. At least one provision of the bill—the requirement for CDCR to report aggregate data about inmate participation in rehabilitation programs—is an expansion of existing law. Furthermore, it is unclear whether all other provisions of the bill are merely declaratory of existing law given that they require the public disclosure of more inmate release information than CDCR currently provides to the public.
As proposed to be amended, the bill will read as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 7923.611 is added to the Government Code, to read:
7923.611. (a) To the extent that disclosure is not prohibited by subdivision (b) or any other provision of the Public Records Act, Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and what the inmate did to earn any release the early release credits earned by an inmate are public records and are subject to disclosure under this division.
(1) A disclosure under this section shall be sufficiently detailed and include limited to the total number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories:
(A) Good behavior.
(B) Rehabilitation and education program participation.
(C) Pretrial release credits.
(2) A disclosure shall also include the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.
(b) This section does not require allow the disclosure of either of the following:
(1) Department records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191)or the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code).
(c) (1) This section does not require the disclosure of early
(2) Early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison, as described in Section 2935 of the Penal Code.
(2) (c) By March 1, 2026 and by March 1st of each year thereafter, the department shall compile an annual report for each department facility that awards sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the prior calendar year. The annual report, which shall be posted on the department’s internet website, shall include the following information:
- The number of inmates at the facility who participated in rehabilitation, good behavior, and education programs during the year.
- The total number of hours of sentence credits earned by inmates, compiled in categories used by the department for sentence credits, including for activities in groups, educational programs, career technical education programs, treatment programs, pre-release programs, and grant programs.
(d) As used in this section, the following terms have the following meaning:
(1) “Department” means the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
(2) “In-custody informant” has the same meaning as in subdivision (a) of Section 1127a of the Penal Code.
SEC. 2. The addition of Section 7923.611 to the Government Code made by this act does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
These amendments appear to address most, if not all, of the opposition arguments. For example, Oakland Privacy writes the following about the proposed amendments: “Oakland Privacy is writing to inform the Committee that after review of proposed committee amendments, we are dropping our opposition to the bill and maintaining a neutral position.”
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California State Sheriffs Association writes the following in support of the bill:
California has been a leader in creating a more just criminal justice system. Through the expansion of rehabilitative programs, diversion opportunities, improved training, and various other reforms, our state has shown its commitment to giving offenders a second chance. That said, many victims and justice system stakeholders have been surprised by the release of certain offenders, and many have expressed concerns about the lack of information when incarcerated individuals are released back into their communities.
AB 2766 provides additional transparency in these release proceedings. By making clear this information is subject to disclosure under the PRA, communities and law enforcement will be better informed of offenders’ releases and have a greater understanding of the credits that offenders have received to grant their release.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: UnCommon Law writes that it opposes the bill for the following reasons:
This legislation is misguided. This bill attempts to clarify that records which are already public will be public. Specifically, Prop 57 granted CDCR the authority to set credit earning rates for people who are incarcerated in California State Prisons. This bill clarifies that the release dates, number of credits earned, and programs an individual takes while incarcerated are all public record. This poses privacy concerns given the nature of the meaningful rehabilitation programs that exist and the deep self-work that is often required to complete these programs.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Arcadia Police Officers' Association
Burbank Police Officers' Association
California District Attorneys Association
California Narcotic Officers' Association
California Reserve Peace Officers Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Claremont Police Officers Association
Corona Police Officers Association
Culver City Police Officers' Association
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of Monterey County
Fullerton Police Officers' Association
League of California Cities
Murrieta Police Officers' Association
Newport Beach Police Association
Novato Police Officers Association
Palos Verdes Police Officers Association
Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Association
Pomona Police Officers' Association
Riverside Police Officers Association
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
San Bernardino County Sheriff's Department
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Upland Police Officers Association
Neutral as Proposed to be Amended
Initiate Justice
Oakland Privacy
Opposition
Uncommon Law
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 19, 2024
Counsel: Andrew Ironside
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
States that California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) records pertaining to an inmates release date and what an inmate did to earn release credits are public records subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act (CPRA). Specifically, this bill:
- States that CDCR records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and what the inmate did to earn any release credits are public records subject to disclosure under CPRA.
- Requires disclosure to be sufficiently detailed and include the number of days of credit that were based on each of the following categories:
- Good behavior;
- Rehabilitation and education program participation; and,
- Pretrial release credits.
- Good behavior;
- Requires disclosure to include the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.
- Provides that CDCR is not required to disclose records that are subject to the privacy protections of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA).
- Provides that CDCR is not required to disclose information early release credits earned by an in-custody informant, as defined, for providing exception assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison.
- States that this act does not constitute a change in, but is declaratory of, existing law.
EXISTING LAW:
-
- Provides that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights, including privacy. (Cal. Const., Art. I, § 1.)
- Provides that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny. (Cal. Const., Art. I, § 3, subd. (b)(1).)
- Defines “public records” to include any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business, prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code, § 7920.530.)
- Declares that the Legislature, mindful of the right of individuals to privacy, finds and declares that access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Gov. Code, § 7921.000.)
- Provides that the inalienable right to privacy under the California Constitution may exempt certain records, or portions thereof, from disclosure under the California Public Records Act. (Gov. Code, § 7930.000.)
- Provides that Penal Code sections 11076 and 13202 may operate to exempt criminal offender record information, or portions thereof, from disclosure. (Gov. Code, § 7930.130.)
- Defines “criminal offender record information” as records and data compiled by criminal justice agencies for purposes of identifying criminal offenders and of maintaining as to each such offender a summary of arrests, pretrial proceedings, the nature and disposition of criminal charges, sentencing, incarceration, rehabilitation, and release. (Pen. Code, § 13102.)
- Requires an agency to justify withholding any record by demonstrating that the record in question is exempt under express provisions of CPRA, or that on the facts of a particular case the public interest served by not disclosing the record clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record. (Gov. Code, § 7922.000.)
- Provides for a right of access to criminal offender record information by any person or public agency authorized by law. (Pen. Code, § 13200.)
- Provides that the right of access to criminal offender record information does not authorize access of any person or public agency to such information unless such access is otherwise authorized by law. (Pen. Code, § 13201.)
- Provides that every public agency or bona fide research institution concerned with the prevention or control of crime, the quality of criminal justice, or the custody or correction of offenders may be provided with criminal offender record information, including criminal court records, as required for the performance of its duties, including the conduct of research. (Pen. Code, § 13202.)
- Provides that criminal offender record information shall be disseminated, whether directly or through any intermediary, only to such agencies as are, or may subsequently be, authorized access to such records by statutes. (Pen. Code, § 11076.)
- Requires CDCR to establish written guidelines for accessibility of records, to post those guidelines in a conspicuous public place at CDCR offices, and to make a copy of the guidelines available upon request free of charge to any person requesting them. (Gov. Code, § 6253.4(b)(5).)
- Provides that any person may institute a proceeding for injunctive or declarative relief, or for a writ of mandate, in any court of competent jurisdiction, to enforce that person’s right to inspect or receive a copy of any public record or class of public records. (Gov. Code, § 7923.)
- Requires CDCR to establish written guidelines for accessibility of records. (Gov. Code, § 7922.635, subd. (a)(6).)
- States that any person convicted of a nonviolent felony offense and sentenced to state prison shall be eligible for parole consideration after completing the full term for his or her primary offense. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 32.)
- Provides that CDCR shall have authority to award credits earned for good behavior and approved rehabilitative or educational achievements. (Cal. Const., art. 1, § 32, subd. (a)(2).)
- Provides that an incarcerated person, unless otherwise precluded, is eligible to receive good conduct, rehabilitation, and/or education credits to advance their release date if sentenced to a determinate term or to advance an initial parole hearing date if sentenced to an indeterminate term with the possibility of parole. (Pen. Code, §§ 2931, 2933 & 2933.05; see also 15 CCR § 3043.4, et. seq.)
- Provides that, in addition to other specified limitations, the only incarcerated person or parolee data which may be released without a valid written authorization from the incarcerated person or parolee to the media or to the public includes that person’s:
- Name;
- Age;
- Race and/or ethnicity;
- Birthplace;
- County of last legal residence;
- Commitment offense;
- Date of admission to CDCR and CDCR number;
- Facility assignments and a general description of behavior;
- Patient health condition given in short and general terms that do not communicate specific medical information about the individual, such as good, fair, serious, critical, treated and released, or undetermined;
- Manner of death as natural, homicide, suicide, accidental, or executed; and,
- Sentencing and release actions, including month and year of current parole eligibility date. (15 CCR § 3261.2(e)(1)-(11).)
- Name;
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “In recent news, we have seen cases of violent, convicted felons who were released early from their prison sentences, and who then went on to commit more violent felony offenses against the public. In many of these cases, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) has refused to disclose information as to how those inmates obtained their early release credits. It is vital to the creation of a fair and just system for all Californians, that we have a transparent criminal justice system. AB 2766 will provide that CDCR records pertaining to an inmate’s early release date and how they earned their early release credits are available to the public, and are subject to disclosure under the California Public Records Act. AB 2766 will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law, to help Californian’s feel safe in their communities and to create just outcomes for all.”
- Proposition 57: On November 8, 2016, Californians voted on whether to increase rehabilitation services and decrease the state’s prison population by approving Proposition 57. Known as The Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act of 2016, Proposition 57 proposed, among other things, to authorize CDCR to award sentence credits for rehabilitation, good behavior, and education. It required CDCR to pass regulations to that effect. (https://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2016/general/en/pdf/complete-vig.pdf.) Voters approved Proposition 57 by a margin of nearly 30 points. (https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_57,_Parole_for_Non-Violent_Criminals_and_Juvenile_Court_Trial_Requirements_(2016).)
As required, CDCR has since issued regulations to effectuate the proposition’s purpose. (Cal. Const., Art. I, § 32, subd. (b); 15 CCR § 3043, et seq.) Awarding credits is based on several different eligibilities including Good Conduct, Milestone Completion, Rehabilitative Achievement, Educational Merit, and Extraordinary Conduct. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/proposition57/.) - California Public Records Act (CPRA): The CPRA provides that every person or entity in California has a right to access information concerning the conduct of the people’s business. (Gov. Code, §7921.000; Cal. Const., Art. I, § 3, subd. (b)(1).) Despite the public’s fundamental right to access public records, the California Constitution also provides people have inalienable rights, including the right to pursue and obtain privacy. (Cal. Const., Art. I, § 1.) The CPRA provides that the inalienable right to privacy under California Constitution may exempt certain records, or portions thereof, from disclosure under the Act. (Gov. Code, §7930.000.) It specifically states that Penal Code sections 11076 and 13202 may operate to exempt criminal offender record information, or portions thereof, from disclosure. (Gov. Code, § 7930.130.)
If an agency rejects a public records request, the CPRA requires the agency to justify withholding any record by demonstrating that the record in question is exempt under express provisions of CPRA, or that on the facts of a particular case the public interest served by not disclosing the record clearly outweighs the public interest served by disclosure of the record. (Civ. Code, § 7922.000.) Any person may challenge an agency’s rejection of a CPRA request by instituting proceedings for injunctive or declarative relief, or for a writ of mandate, in any court of competent jurisdiction, to enforce that person’s right to inspect or receive a copy of any public record or class of public records. (Gov. Code, § 7923.)
CDCR has issued regulations governing the disclosure of information relating to an incarcerated person. Specifically, CDCR regulations state, “[T]he only inmate or parolee data which may be released without a valid written authorization from the inmate or parolee to the media or to the public” includes their name, age, race and/or ethnicity, birthplace, count of last legal residence, commitment offense, date of admission, facility assignment, a general description of behavior, a short and general description of an inmate’s health or manner of death, and the month and year of their release. (15 CCR § 3261.2(e)(1)-(11).)
This bill would require CDCR to disclose significantly more information than is likely required under the CPRA, and which, contrary to Section 2 of this bill, appears to be protected. - Institutional Safety at CDCR Facilities: This bill would make “[CDCR] records pertaining to an inmate’s release date and what the inmate did to earn any release credits…subject to disclosure” under CPRA. This bill provides limited exceptions to or restrictions on disclosure. It does not limit who can request an incarcerate person’s records. Nor does it exempt from disclosure an incarcerated person’s release credit information before that person’s release date has been set. Even if the date has been set, an incarcerated person is not immediately released upon receiving that date. In either case, a person could request information on an incarcerated person’s rehabilitative efforts and then communicate that information to another incarcerated person within the same institution.
For example, an incarcerated person may receive “up to twelve months of Extraordinary Conduct Credit” for “provid[ing] exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison.” (Pen. Code, § 2935; 15 CCR § 3043.6, subd. (a).) Disclosure that an incarcerated person assisted corrections staff may put that person at risk from other incarcerated persons, particularly if the provided information resulted in consequences for other incarcerated persons. Given the ongoing efforts by CDCR to manage security threat groups (“gangs”) and other security threats within its institutions, there may be reason for concern that such broad disclosures would threaten institutional safety and the safety of the people in CDCR’s care. Similarly, it could also put the individual in immediate risk from persons who are not incarcerated, such as members of rival gangs, once they are released from prison.
This bill would require disclosure of all credits earned except HIPAA-protected records and “early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison.” However, exempting disclosure of only the information pertaining to extraordinary conduct credits would result in a discrepancy between the credits earned and the release date, highlighting that the incarcerated person had received credits for conduct exempted from disclosure. The omission of the credits would serve only to highlight that the credits had been earned in service to CDCR. - A Disincentive to Participate in Rehabilitative Programming: As mentioned above, this bill provides broad disclosure on what an incarcerated person did to earn release credits before that person has been released from CDCR, which may place that person at risk. Moreover, this bill requires disclosure of “the types of rehabilitative and education programs that the inmate participated in and completed.” This could require the disclosure of information about rehabilitation credits an incarcerated person earns for participation in self-help and peer support groups, such as Narcotics Anonymous and/or Alcoholics Anonymous among others, or participation programs like CBI-Life Skills. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/rehabilitation/cbi/) Whether such information falls under the bill’s HIPAA-exception is unclear, and resolving the issue could require litigation. If earning credits could result in disclosure of an incarcerated person’s personal information or might threaten their personal safety, will they be disincentivized to participate in rehabilitative programming?
- Vague Language: This bill provides that “[a] disclosure…shall be sufficiently detailed and include the number of days of credit…,” but it does not provide guidance to CDCR on the records, or the portions of records, that would be required to meet that standard. Given that the bill requires that disclosures be both “sufficiently detailed and include the number of days of credit…,” disclosure would have to go beyond a cursory calculation of the total credit days an incarcerated person has earned in each category. But what level of detail is “sufficient[]” to comply with this bill’s mandate?
- Practical Consideration: According to the author, this bill “will create more transparencies to ensure that CDCR is properly applying the law.” Yet, as previously noted, this bill would not require disclosure of HIPAA-protected records or “early release credits earned by an in-custody informant for providing exceptional assistance in maintaining the safety and security of a prison.” As a result, a report issued by CDCR in response to a CPRA request on how an individual earned release credits while incarcerated would not completely account for credits withheld under one of the exceptions in this bill. Put simply, under this bill the public may not have significantly more clarity about how CDCR awarded an individual credits, even if it knows more personal, potentially embarrassing or stigmatizing, information about the subject of the request.
- Argument in Support: According to the California District Attorneys Association, “As many victims and justice system stakeholders have been surprised by the release of certain offenders and have expressed concerns about the lack of information when incarcerated individuals are released back into their communities, this bill is one way of addressing those concerns. The public should have a better idea of how the laws they have enacted are working when it comes to the release of offenders so they can decide whether to challenge, support, or seek modification in the laws.
“This bill is a codification of how release of the records should be handled under the current law, with exceptions to disclosure in the current language that protect the most sensitive information, and modifications to further mitigate any harm from the competing concerns can be made if warranted.” - Argument in Opposition: According to Oakland Privacy, “It is a relatively rare occasion for us to find ourselves arguing against more governmental transparency and against a broadening of the California Public Records Act. However the potential safety issues disregarded by AB 2766 are sobering and of great concern. Moreover, it is not clear to us what the public interest in the information actually consists of. The CPRA is not intended to satisfy prurient, sensationalistic interests and in this case, we are unable to identify any other interest. Accordingly, we request that the committee not advance the bill.
“The privacy interests at stake in AB 2766 are similar to those that protect employee data and medical records. In general, rehabilitative efforts can and do encompass personal information including substance issues, mental health and therapy, and educational difficulties. Both employers and health/medical facilities keep such information private for very good reasons. Release of such information has discriminatory aspects and moreover, having such information broadly released serves as a strong disincentive to requesting and receiving needed treatments. The Legislature, for example, has taken legislative action to prevent the sale and sharing of information from mental health applications for exactly this reason.
“In a prison and in the real world that inmates must sometimes grapple with post-release (which includes gangs and former criminal associates) these dangers are multiplied and amplified with physical threats to life and limb if gangs and associates dislike rehabilitative efforts or associate them with snitching to criminal justice authorities. Since one form of credit (the extraordinary conduct credit) in fact involves assisting with safety and security issues in the prison, the perception of snitching may in fact be the reality - with possible consequences awaiting the inmate post-release, which neither CDCR nor the unwitting public records requester is likely to be available to mitigate.
“One of the fundamental precepts of privacy law is consent, which is nowhere mentioned in AB 2766. For good reasons, the Public Records Act does not rely on the consent of government bodies in order to release public information, but inmates are not government bodies and information about their activities in prison can, in some circumstances, not only constitute particularized individual information about one specific person, but also pose unique dangers to them upon release. While we do strip inmates of a number of personal freedoms and rights, the privacy of their medical and psychiatric information has generally not been up for grabs. At a minimum, allowing an inmate to withhold consent for the release of their records would seem to be required for their safety.
“Moreover, the public interest in such information is unclear to us. The bill’s author in the 2023 Assembly Public Safety committee analysis states that “more transparencies will help the community feel safe and be assured that CDCR is properly applying the law”. While we share an interest in CDCR properly applying the law, the oversight responsibilities for CDCR lie with the state and the Legislature, not with individual members of the public. We don’t really see how a list of the particular set of release credits for one or a small group of individuals provides oversight of CDCR’s performance, which requires aggregate data. So the likely use of such reports seems limited to one of two purposes:
1) Harassing a particular individual after their release, which can only have negative effects regarding recidivism and the ability to re-integrate into non-criminal society
2) Gotcha reporting for ex post-facto examinations in the unfortunate incidence of another crime after release. While we would never say there is no public interest in sensationalistic crime reporting, one individual’s story, however dramatic it may prove to be, is not in itself a meaningful analysis of rehabilitation programs and shouldn’t be substituted for one. There is plenty of aggregated data available for reporters interested in examining how well California’s rehabilitative efforts are going.
“Given the potential dangers to newly-released inmates and the lack of news value in individual health and psychiatric information garnered without consent, the balance of equities present are convincingly on the side of treating personal information like it is personal information.”
- Related Legislation:
- AB 1260 (Joe Patterson), would require CDCR to make an initial determination of the minimum eligible parole date for an inmate based on the sentence of the court, any credits awarded, and the good conduct credit rate, as specified. AB 1260 failed passage in this committee and was granted reconsideration. AB 1260 is pending referral in the Senate Rules Committee.
- AB 1898 (Flora), would prohibit a person convicted of specified child pornography offenses, who previously has been convicted of and has served two or more separate prior prison terms for specified offenses, from receiving release credits. AB 1898 will be heard today in this committee.
- AB 2341 (V. Fong), would prohibit the granting of release credits to an inmate serving a sentence for a fentanyl-related offense, as specified. AB 2341 has been pulled by the author.
- AB 1260 (Joe Patterson), would require CDCR to make an initial determination of the minimum eligible parole date for an inmate based on the sentence of the court, any credits awarded, and the good conduct credit rate, as specified. AB 1260 failed passage in this committee and was granted reconsideration. AB 1260 is pending referral in the Senate Rules Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 15 (Dixon), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, was identical to this bill. AB 15 failed passage in this committee.
- SB 288 (J. Nguyen), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill and AB 15 (Dixon). SB 288 failed passage in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- SB 359 (Umberg), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have required CDCR to compile data related to credits awarded to incarcerated persons, as specified, and to submit an annual report to the Legislature on or before January 1, 2025. SB 359 failed passage in this committee.
- SB 345 (Bradford), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required CDCR, among others, to the extent not prohibited by the CPRA, to conspicuously post on their Internet website, in a searchable manner, all current standards, policies, practices, operating procedures, and education and training materials. Governor Brown vetoed SB 345.
- AB 15 (Dixon), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, was identical to this bill. AB 15 failed passage in this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
League of California Cities
Opposition
Initiate Justice
Initiate Justice Action
Oakland Privacy
Uncommon Law
Analysis Prepared by:
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):