AB 593: Hearsay: admissibility of statements.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-07-06
Existing law, known as the hearsay rule, provides that, at a hearing, evidence of a statement that was made other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing and that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated is inadmissible. Existing law also provides exceptions to the hearsay rule to permit the admission of specified kinds of evidence. Existing law provides that evidence of a statement that is offered against a party who has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule, as specified. Existing law would repeal this exception on January 1, 2016.
This bill would delete the January 1, 2016, repeal date for these provisions, thereby extending the hearsay exemption into perpetuity.
Existing law, known as the hearsay rule, provides that, at a hearing, evidence of a statement that was made other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing and that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated is inadmissible. Existing law also provides exceptions to the hearsay rule to permit the admission of specified kinds of evidence. Existing law provides that evidence of a statement that is offered against a party who has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule, as specified. Existing law would repeal this exception on January 1, 2016.
This bill would delete the January 1, 2016, repeal date for these provisions, thereby extending the hearsay exemption into perpetuity.
Existing law, known as the hearsay rule, provides that, at a hearing, evidence of a statement that was made other than by a witness while testifying at the hearing and that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated is inadmissible. Existing law also provides exceptions to the hearsay rule to permit the admission of specified kinds of evidence. Existing law provides that evidence of a statement that is offered against a party who has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule, as specified. Existing law would repeal this exception on January 1, 2016.
This bill would delete the January 1, 2016, repeal date for these provisions, thereby extending the hearsay exemption into perpetuity.
(a)Evidence of a statement is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is offered against a party that has engaged, or aided and abetted, in the wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness.
(b)(1)The party seeking to introduce a statement pursuant to subdivision (a) shall establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the elements of subdivision (a) have been met at a foundational hearing.
(2)The hearsay evidence that is the subject of the foundational hearing is admissible at the foundational hearing. However, a finding that the elements of subdivision (a) have been met shall not be based solely on the unconfronted hearsay statement of the unavailable declarant, and shall be supported by independent corroborative evidence.
(3)The foundational hearing shall be conducted outside the presence of the jury. However, if the hearing is conducted after a jury trial has begun, the judge presiding at the hearing may consider evidence already presented to the jury in deciding whether the elements of subdivision (a) have been met.
(4)In deciding whether or not to admit the statement, the judge may take into account whether it is trustworthy and reliable.
(c)This section shall apply to any civil, criminal, or juvenile case or proceeding initiated or pending as of January 1, 2011.
(a)Evidence of a statement is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is offered against a party that has engaged, or aided and abetted, in the wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness.
(b)(1)The party seeking to introduce a statement pursuant to subdivision (a) shall establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the elements of subdivision (a) have been met at a foundational hearing.
(2)The hearsay evidence that is the subject of the foundational hearing is admissible at the foundational hearing. However, a finding that the elements of subdivision (a) have been met shall not be based solely on the unconfronted hearsay statement of the unavailable declarant, and shall be supported by independent corroborative evidence.
(3)The foundational hearing shall be conducted outside the presence of the jury. However, if the hearing is conducted after a jury trial has begun, the judge presiding at the hearing may consider evidence already presented to the jury in deciding whether the elements of subdivision (a) have been met.
(4)In deciding whether or not to admit the statement, the judge may take into account whether it is trustworthy and reliable.
(c)This section shall apply to any civil, criminal, or juvenile case or proceeding initiated or pending as of January 1, 2011.
(a)Evidence of a statement is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is offered against a party that has engaged, or aided and abetted, in the wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness.
(b)(1)The party seeking to introduce a statement pursuant to subdivision (a) shall establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the elements of subdivision (a) have been met at a foundational hearing.
(2)The hearsay evidence that is the subject of the foundational hearing is admissible at the foundational hearing. However, a finding that the elements of subdivision (a) have been met shall not be based solely on the unconfronted hearsay statement of the unavailable declarant, and shall be supported by independent corroborative evidence.
(3)The foundational hearing shall be conducted outside the presence of the jury. However, if the hearing is conducted after a jury trial has begun, the judge presiding at the hearing may consider evidence already presented to the jury in deciding whether the elements of subdivision (a) have been met.
(4)In deciding whether or not to admit the statement, the judge may take into account whether it is trustworthy and reliable.
(c)This section shall apply to any civil, criminal, or juvenile case or proceeding initiated or pending as of January 1, 2011.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2016, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2016, deletes or extends that date. If this section is repealed, the fact that it is repealed, should it occur, shall not be deemed to give rise to any ground for an appeal or a postverdict challenge based on its use in a criminal or juvenile case or proceeding before January 1, 2016.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 6, 2015 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 55, Statutes of 2015. |
| Jul 6, 2015 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jun 26, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 11 a.m. |
| Jun 23, 2015 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jun 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 1550.). |
| Jun 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 17, 2015 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Jun 10, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 9, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 9). |
| May 7, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 13, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 13, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 885.) |
| Apr 13, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0.) |
| Apr 8, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Apr 7, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 7). |
| Apr 7, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 7). |
| Mar 9, 2015 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 27. |
| Feb 24, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 22, 2015 | Special Consent #3 AB593 Levine | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 9, 2015 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Apr 13, 2015 | AB 593 LEVINE Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 7, 2015 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 593
Page 5
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 593
Introduced: 2/24/15
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/9/15
AYES: Hancock, Anderson, Glazer, Leno, Liu, Monning, Stone
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 4/13/15 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Hearsay: admissibility of statements
SOURCE: California District Attorneys Association
DIGEST: This bill repeals the January 1, 2016 sunset date of the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” hearsay exception.
Existing law:
Defines "unavailable as a witness," for purposes of the Evidence Code, to include a declarant who is:
Exempted or precluded on grounds of privilege from testifying concerning the matter to which his or her statement is relevant;
Disqualified from testifying to the matter;
Dead or unable to attend or testify because of physical or mental illness or infirmity;
Physically absent and the court is unable to compel attendance;
Physically absent even though the proponent has exercised reasonable diligence but has been unable to procure his or her attendance by the court process; or
Persistent in refusing to testify concerning the subject matter of the declarant’s statement despite having been found in contempt for refusal to testify. (Evidence Code § 240 (a).)
Specifies that a declarant is not unavailable as a witness if the declarant's unavailability was procured by the wrongdoing of the proponent of the declarant's out-of-court statement for the purpose of preventing the declarant from attending or testifying. (Evidence Code § 240 (b).)
Defines "hearsay evidence" as a statement made by a declarant, other than a witness while testifying, that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated. Specifies that except as provided by law, hearsay evidence is inadmissible. (Evidence Code § 1200.)
Provides that, in a criminal action, a statement that is otherwise admissible as hearsay evidence under the Evidence Code is inadmissible if its admission would violate the constitutions of either California or the United States. (Evidence Code § 1204.)
Enumerates several "hearsay exceptions" that permit the admission of hearsay statements where the circumstances surrounding the statement create presumptions in favor of its truthfulness, including dying declarations, "excited utterances," statements against interest, statements of mental or physical states and, under specified circumstances, certain prior recorded statements, former testimony, business and official records, and other recorded statements or published writings, as specified. (Evidence Code §§1220 through 1341.)
Provides that, in a criminal proceeding charging a serious felony, a statement made by a declarant is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the declarant is unavailable and there is clear and convincing evidence that the declarant's unavailability was knowingly caused by, aided by, or solicited by the party against whom the statement is offered and the unavailability is the result of the death by homicide or the kidnapping of the declarant. Requires further that the declarant's out-of-court statement was memorialized by a tape recording made by law enforcement or a written statement prepared by a law enforcement official and signed by declarant and notarized prior to the death or kidnapping of the declarant. Specifies the procedure by which the above elements must be proved. (Evidence Code § 1350.)
Provides that, in a criminal prosecution, where the victim is a minor, a statement made by the victim when under the age of 12 describing any act of child abuse or neglect, as specified, is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the court finds certain indicia of reliability and the child either testifies at the proceedings or is unavailable as a witness. Requires the proponent of the statement to provide adverse party with advance notice in order to provide adverse party with a fair opportunity to prepare to meet the statement. (Evidence Code §1360).
Provides that a statement that purports to narrate or describe the infliction or threat of physical injury is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the declarant is unavailable as a witness and the statement was made at the time of infliction or threat; was made in writing and recorded by a physician, nurse, paramedic, or law enforcement official; and was made under circumstances that would indicate its trustworthiness. (Evidence Code § 1370.)
Provides that, in a criminal prosecution for elder and dependent adult abuse, a statement made by the victim is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the victim is unavailable as a witness, the statement was made under circumstances which indicate its trustworthiness, and the victim, at the time of the proceeding or hearing, suffers from the infirmities of advanced age or other form of organic brain damage, or other physical, mental, or emotional dysfunction. (Evidence Code § 1380.)
Provides that evidence of a statement is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is offered against a party that has engaged in, or aided and abetted, in the wrongdoing intended to, and did procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness. (Evidence Code § 1390(a)).
Provides that hearsay evidence, including the hearsay evidence that is the subject of the foundational hearing, is admissible at the foundational hearing. However, a finding that the elements have been met shall not be based solely on the uncomforted hearsay statement of the unavailable declarant and shall be supported by independent corroborative evidence. (Evidence Code § 1390(b)(2)).
Provides that the foundational hearing shall be conducted outside the presence of the jury. However, if the hearing is conducted after a jury trial has begun, the judge presiding at the hearing may consider evidence already presented to the jury in deciding whether the elements are met. (Evidence Code § 1390(b)(3)).
Provides that this hearsay exception it creates sunsets on January 1, 2016. (Evidence Code § 1390(d)).
This bill removes the sunset on this provision.
Background
Under the hearsay rule, an out-of-court statement cannot be admitted if it is offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. This general rule is subject to several hearsay exceptions that have developed over the years, first at common law and then codified into federal and state rules of evidence. The hearsay rule reflects the law's preference for live testimony, which is given under oath, subject to cross-examination, and seen by the jury. The several exceptions to the hearsay rule generally come into play when the witness is not available to testify, but the circumstances of their out-of-court statements somehow suggest the reliability or probable truthfulness of those statements. Some classic examples include the "dying declaration" and "excited utterances," since presumably people do not have the inclination or the time, respectively, to think up a lie under such circumstances. In theory, the circumstances under which the statement was made creates a measure of reliability that serves as an imperfect but necessary substitute for the things that supposedly make in-court statements more reliable, such as an oath and the opportunity to cross-examine.
In 2010, the Legislature created a new hearsay exception providing that evidence of a statement that is offered against a party who has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule. At the time, supporters of the bill argued that this exception was necessary to prevent the “injustice” that occurs when a party is responsible for a person not being able to testify in court and that it is consistent with a federal hearsay exception and exceptions in other states. However, because of concerns raised by the opposition, a sunset was placed in the bill. The author argues that there is no evidence of abuse of this exception and thus the sunset should be removed
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California District Attorneys Association (source)
California Chamber of Commerce
California College and University Police Chiefs Association
California State Sheriffs’ Association
Crime Victims United of California
Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/10/15)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 4/13/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Harper
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
6/10/15 14:32:01
**** END ****
AB 593 (Levine ) Page 5 of 5
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 593 Hearing Date: June 9, 2015
Author: |
Levine |
||
Version: |
February 24, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
MK |
||
Subject: Hearsay: Admissibility of Statements
HISTORY
Source: California District Attorneys Association
Prior Legislation: AB 1723 (Lieu) Chapter 537, Stats. 2010
AB 268 (Calderon) 2007 (Amended to be different subject matter while in Senate Judiciary Committee)
AB 2093 (Karnette) 2006 (Failed Assembly Public Safety)
AB 141 (Cohn), Chapter 116, Stats. 2004
SB 1876 (Solis) - Ch. 261, Stats. 1996
Support: The California Chamber of Commerce; California College and University Police Chiefs; California State Sheriffs’ Association; Crime Victims United of California
Opposition: None known
Assembly Floor Vote: 79 - 0
PURPOSE
This bill repeals the January 1, 2016 sunset date of the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” hearsay exception.
Existing law defines "unavailable as a witness," for purposes of the Evidence Code, to include a declarant who is:
Exempted or precluded on grounds of privilege from testifying concerning the matter to which his or her statement is relevant;
Disqualified from testifying to the matter;
Dead or unable to attend or testify because of physical or mental illness or infirmity;
Physically absent and the court is unable to compel attendance;
Physically absent even though the proponent has exercised reasonable diligence but has been unable to procure his or her attendance by the court process;
Persistent in refusing to testify concerning the subject matter of the delcarant’s statement despite having been found in contempt for refusal to testify (Evidence Code Section 240 (a).)
Existing law specifies that a declarant is not unavailable as a witness if the declarant's unavailability was procured by the wrongdoing of the proponent of the declarant's out-of-court statement for the purpose of preventing the declarant from attending or testifying. (Evidence Code § 240 (b).)
Existing law defines "hearsay evidence" as a statement made by a declarant, other than a witness while testifying, that is offered to prove the truth of the matter stated. Specifies that except as provided by law, hearsay evidence is inadmissible. (Evidence Code § 1200.)
Existing law provides that, in a criminal action, a statement that is otherwise admissible as hearsay evidence under the Evidence Code is inadmissible if its admission would violate the constitutions of either California or the United States. (Evidence Code § 1204.)
Existing law enumerates several "hearsay exceptions" that permit the admission of hearsay statements where the circumstances surrounding the statement create presumptions in favor of its truthfulness, including dying declarations, "excited utterances," statements against interest, statements of mental or physical states and, under specified circumstances, certain prior recorded statements, former testimony, business and official records, and other recorded statements or published writings, as specified. (Evidence Code §§1220 through 1341.)
Existing law provides that, in a criminal proceeding charging a serious felony, a statement made by a declarant is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the declarant is unavailable and there is clear and convincing evidence that the declarant's unavailability was knowingly caused by, aided by, or solicited by the party against whom the statement is offered and the unavailability is the result of the death by homicide or the kidnapping of the declarant. Requires further that the declarant's out-of-court statement was memorialized by a tape recording made by law enforcement or a written statement prepared by a law enforcement official and signed by declarant and notarized prior to the death or kidnapping of the declarant. Specifies the procedure by which the above elements must be proved. (Evidence Code § 1350.)
Existing law provides that, in a criminal prosecution, where the victim is a minor, a statement made by the victim when under the age of 12 describing any act of child abuse or neglect, as specified, is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the court finds certain indicia of reliability and the child either testifies at the proceedings or is unavailable as a witness. Requires the proponent of the statement to provide adverse party with advance notice in order to provide adverse party with a fair opportunity to prepare to meet the statement. (Evidence Code §1360).
Existing law provides that a statement that purports to narrate or describe the infliction or threat of physical injury is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the declarant is unavailable as a witness and the statement was made at the time of infliction or threat; was made in writing and recorded by a physician, nurse, paramedic, or law enforcement official; and was made under circumstances that would indicate its trustworthiness. (Evidence Code § 1370.)
Existing law provides that, in a criminal prosecution for elder and dependent adult abuse, a statement made by the victim is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the victim is unavailable as a witness, the statement was made under circumstances which indicate its trustworthiness, and the victim, at the time of the proceeding or hearing, suffers from the infirmities of advanced age or other form of organic brain damage, or other physical, mental, or emotional dysfunction. (Evidence Code § 1380.)
Existing law provides that evidence of a statement is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is offered against a party that has engaged in, or aided and abetted, in the wrongdoing intended to, and did procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness. (Evidence Code § 1390(a))
Existing law provides that hearsay evidence, including the hearsay evidence that is subject of the foundational hearing, is admissible at the foundational hearing. However, a finding that the elements have been met shall not be based solely on the uncomforted hearsay statement of the unavailable declarant and shall be supported by independent corroborative evidence. (Evidence Code § 1390(b)(2))
Existing law provides that the foundational hearing shall be conducted outside the presence of the jury. However, if the hearing is conducted after a jury trial has begun, the judge presiding at the hearing may consider evidence already presented to the jury in deciding whether the elements are met. (Evidence Code § 1390(b)(3))
Existing law provides that this hearsay exception it creates sunsets on January 1, 2016. (Evidence Code § 1390(d)).
This bill removes the sunset on this provision.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past eight years, this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In February of this year the administration reported that as “of February 11, 2015, 112,993 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.6% of design bed capacity, and 8,828 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. This current population is now below the court-ordered reduction to 137.5% of design bed capacity.”( Defendants’ February 2015 Status Report In Response To February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state now must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
Need for The Bill
According to the author:
AB 593 continues to allow an exception to the hearsay rule in cases where a witness is unavailable to testify, for reasons such an intimidation or death.
In 2010, the Legislature unanimously approved and the Governor signed AB 1723 (Lieu, 2010), which established a “forfeiture by wrongdoing” hearsay exception.. This exception allowed for the introduction of hearsay as evidence if the witness was unavailable due to some wrongdoing on the part of the defendant.
At the time this exception was created, a sunset date was included (January 1, 2016), to allow the Legislature to consider whether the negative consequences predicted by the opponents would actually come to pass. That sunset date is fast approaching, and we are unaware of widespread problems that the forfeiture by wrongdoing exception has created in the last four years.
2. The Hearsay Rule
Under the hearsay rule, an out-of-court statement cannot be admitted if it is offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. This general rule is subject to several hearsay exceptions that have developed over the years, first at common law and then codified into federal and state rules of evidence. The hearsay rule reflects the law's preference for live testimony, which is given under oath, subject to cross-examination, and seen by the jury. The several exceptions to the hearsay rule generally come into play when the witness is not available to testify, but the circumstances of their out-of-court statements somehow suggest the reliability or probable truthfulness of those statements. Some classic examples include the "dying declaration" and "excited utterances," since presumably people do not have the inclination or the time, respectively, to think up a lie under such circumstances. In theory, the circumstances under which the statement was made creates a measure of reliability that serves as an imperfect but necessary substitute for the things that supposedly make in-court statements more reliable, such as an oath and the opportunity to cross-examine.
3. Forfeiture by Wrongdoing Exception
In 2010 the Legislature created a new hearsay exception providing that evidence of a statement that is offered against a party who has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule. At the time supporters of the bill argued that it this exception was necessary prevents the “injustice” that occurs when a party is responsible for a person not being able to testify in court and that it is consistent with a federal hearsay exception and exceptions in other states. However, because of concerns raised by the opposition, a sunset was placed in the bill. The author argues that there is no evidence of abuse of this exception and thus the sunset should be removed. The sponsor, the California District Attorneys Association states:
EC 1390 has proven to be a valuable tool for prosecutors in instances where witnesses or victims have been intimidated or killed in order to prevent them from testifying.
To illustrate the types of cases in which the forfeiture by wrongdoing exception is used, suppose a witness testifies before a grand jury that she ahs seen a gang member commit a drive-by shooting. Without EC 1390, if the gang member then kills, or acquiesces in the killing of, the witness, the witness’ testimony is not admissible in the trial on the drive-by shooting.
Similarly, suppose a woman makes a report to the police that her husband has assaulted her and the husband is then charged with spousal abuse. Without EC 1390, if the husband then successfully intimidates the woman so that she is no longer willing to testify, her out-of-court statements would be inadmissible at trial.
AB 593 is necessary to remove the sunset date on the forfeiture by wrongdoing hearsay exception. This helps prevent the injustice that occurs when a criminal defendant is able to exclude hearsay statements of an unavailable victim or witness, even though the defendant is the very person who is responsible for the victim or witness being unavailable to testify in court.
-- END –
AB 593
Page 4
Date of Hearing: April 7, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
AB 593
(Levine) – As Introduced February 24, 2015
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Hearsay: admissibility of statements
KEY ISSUE: Should California EXTEND THE “FORFEITURE BY WRONGDOING” HEARSAY EXCEPTION INDEFINITELY?
SYNOPSIS
Under the hearsay rule an out-of-court statement cannot be admitted as evidence if introduced to prove the truth of the matter asserted. The hearsay rule reflects the law's preference for live witnesses, who take oaths, are cross-examined, and can be seen by the jury. However, existing law recognizes several hearsay exceptions, which generally apply when the declarant is unavailable to testify as a witness but where the circumstances surrounding the statement create a presumption of reliability. (For example "dying declarations" or spontaneous utterances, etc.) Under the common law, a hearsay exception known as "forfeiture by wrongdoing" permitted statements to be admitted if the declarant was "unavailable as a witness" and the unavailability was due to some wrongdoing on the part of the defendant.
California enacted the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” hearsay exception in 2011, with a four-year sunset. As currently enacted, the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” exception to the hearsay rule permits the introduction of hearsay into evidence, if the party seeking to introduce the statement can establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the other party has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, cause the declarant of the statement to be unavailable as a witness. This bill would delete the sunset which expires at the end of 2015.
According to the author and supporters, this bill is necessary to maintain this hearsay exception, which helps to prevent the injustice that occurs when hearsay statements of an unavailable victim or witness are excluded from evidence, even though the person against whom the statement is offered, is the very person who is responsible for the victim or witness being unavailable to testify in court. The exception has been used in the trial courts without any major problems. There is no known opposition to this bill.
SUMMARY: Extends the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” exception to the hearsay rule indefinitely. Specifically, this bill repeals the January 1, 2016 sunset date of the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” hearsay exception.
EXISTING LAW:
Provides that evidence of a statement is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule if the statement is offered against a party that has engaged, or aided and abetted, in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant as a witness. (Evidence Code Section 1390(a). All further references are to the Evidence Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
Requires the party seeking to introduce a statement to establish the essential elements at a foundational hearing, outside the presence of the jury. (Section 1390(b)(1).)
Permits the use of hearsay evidence, including the contested statement, at the foundational hearing. A finding that a statement is admissible against a wrongdoer may be based on the hearsay statement of the unavailable declarant, but it must also be supported by independent corroborative evidence. (Section 1390(b)(2).)
Provides that this hearsay exception applies to any civil, criminal, or juvenile case initiated or pending as of January 1, 2011. (Section 1390(c).)
Provides that the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” exception will sunset on January 1, 2016, unless a later enacted statute, deletes or extends that date. (Section 1390(d).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Under the hearsay rule an out-of-court statement cannot be admitted as evidence if introduced to prove the truth of the matter asserted. (Section 1200.) The hearsay rule reflects the law's preference for live witnesses, who take oaths, are cross-examined, and can be seen by the jury. However, existing law recognizes several hearsay exceptions, which generally apply when the declarant is unavailable to testify as a witness but where the circumstances surrounding the statement create a presumption of reliability. (For example "dying declarations" or spontaneous utterances, etc.) (Sections 1242 & 1240.) Under the common law, a hearsay exception known as "forfeiture by wrongdoing" permitted statements to be admitted if the declarant was "unavailable as a witness" and the unavailability was due to some wrongdoing on the part of the defendant. (Federal Rule of Evidence Section 804(b)(6).)
The author explains the reason for the bill as follows:
In 2010, the Legislature unanimously approved and the Governor signed AB 1723 (Lieu) Chapter 537, Stats. 2010, which established the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” hearsay exception. This exception allowed for the introduction of hearsay as evidence if the witness is unavailable due to some wrongdoing on the part of the defendant.
At the time this exception was created, the Assembly Judiciary Committee requested that a sunset date be included, to allow the Legislature to consider whether the negative consequences predicted by the opponents would actually come to pass. The sunset date is fast approaching, and we are unaware of any widespread problems that the forfeiture by wrongdoing exception has created in the last four years.
No Evidence That the “Forfeiture by Wrongdoing” Exception Has Been Problematic to the Execution of Justice in California Courts? In 2010, when the Legislature was considering the forfeiture by wrongdoing exception to the hearsay rule, opponents expressed concern about the provision in the bill that permits the use of hearsay, including the contested statement, at the foundational hearing. The opponents also argued that this new exception would unduly expand the use of inherently unreliable hearsay evidence and was more than likely unconstitutional under the Sixth Amendment’s “confrontation clause.” At that time, the author and the sponsor responded to opponents’ concerns by pointing out that hearsay is already permitted at a foundational hearing under the federal Rules. Federal Rules of Evidence section 104(a) states, “the court must decide any preliminary question about whether a witness is qualified, a privilege exists, or evidence is admissible. In so deciding, the court is not bound by evidence rules, except those on privilege.”
The “forfeiture by wrongdoing” exception has been in effect for more than three years, and if there were a problem with its use one would think that it would have manifested itself by this time. Courts have allowed the use of this hearsay exception and there has been no determination, to the knowledge of this Committee, that this exception has been ruled as unconstitutional in any of these cases. The purpose of a sunset provision is to permit the Legislature to revisit the policy and to determine if there have been unwanted or unintended consequences. The Committee has not been provided with any evidence that any such unwanted or unintended consequences have come to pass; thus, the Committee may conclude it is reasonable to remove the sunset.
It should be noted that this exception to the hearsay rule applies in civil and juvenile cases, as well as criminal cases. Therefore, a hearsay statement can be offered against individuals other than criminal defendants.
Court Ruling on the Use of the Forfeiture by Wrongdoing Exception. California courts have ruled on the forfeiture of wrongdoing exception, but there is no published case law demonstrating the court challenging the validity of the exception. When considering the unavailability of a witness, the court found that the exception was properly used, when a witness was threatened by the defendant and was too fearful to appear in court to testify. (See, e.g., People v. Jones (2012), 207 Cal. App. 4th 1392, 1397 (the Court of Appeals held that the defendant’s threatening telephone calls from jail to the witness constituted sufficient wrongdoing to make the witness unavailable, and allowed her out of court statements to be used as testimony under the forfeiture by wrongdoing exception).)
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the sponsor, the California District Attorneys Association (CDAA), “this bill would remove the sunset date from the forfeiture by wrongdoing hearsay exception, which permits the introduction of hearsay into evidence if the party seeking to introduce the statement can establish by a preponderance of the evidence that the other party has engaged or acquiesced in wrongdoing that was intended to, and did, procure the unavailability of the declarant of the hearsay.”
Previous Relevant Legislation: AB 1723 (Lieu) Chapter. 537, Stats. 2010 amended the California Evidence Code to include the “forfeiture by wrongdoing” exception to the hearsay rule.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association (sponsor)
California Chamber of Commerce
California College and University Police Chiefs
California State Sheriffs” Association
Crime Victims United of California
Opposition
None on File
Analysis Prepared by: Khadijah Hargett / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):