AB 2823: Crimes: vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-02-15
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-23: In committee: Hearing postponed by committee.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law prohibits operating a vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, as specified. Under existing law, if a person is convicted of driving under the influence and is granted probation, the period of probation shall be for no less than 3 years and no more than 5 years, unless the maximum prison sentence for the offense is greater than 5 years, in which case the period of probation may be longer.
Existing law prohibits the unlawful killing of a human being, without malice aforethought, while driving under the influence. A violation of this prohibition is punishable either as a misdemeanor or as a felony. Under existing law, if a person is convicted of the unlawful killing of a human being, without malice aforethought, while driving under the influence, and is granted probation, the period of probation shall be no more than one year if the person is convicted of a misdemeanor and two years if the person in convicted of a felony.
This bill would increase the period of probation for a person who is convicted of the unlawful killing of a human being, without malice aforethought, while driving under the influence to be the same as the period of probation for a person who is convicted of driving under the influence.
By increasing the period of probation, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)Gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is the unlawful killing of a human being without malice aforethought, in the driving of a vehicle, where the driving was in violation of Section 23140, 23152, or 23153 of the Vehicle Code, and the killing was either the proximate result of the commission of an unlawful act, not amounting to a felony, and with gross negligence, or the proximate result of the commission of a lawful act that might produce death, in an unlawful manner, and with gross negligence.
(b)Vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is the unlawful killing of a human being without malice aforethought, in the driving of a vehicle, where the driving was in violation of Section 23140, 23152, or 23153 of the Vehicle Code, and the killing was either the proximate result of the commission of an unlawful act, not amounting to a felony, but without gross negligence, or the proximate result of the commission of a lawful act that might produce death, in an unlawful manner, but without gross negligence.
(c)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (d), gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated in violation of subdivision (a) is punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 4, 6, or 10 years.
(2)Vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated in violation of subdivision (b) is punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 for 16 months or two or four years.
(d)A person convicted of violating subdivision (a) who has one or more prior convictions of this section or of paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 192, subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 192.5 of this code, or of violating Section 23152 punishable under Sections 23540, 23542, 23546, 23548, 23550, or 23552 of, or convicted of Section 23153 of, the Vehicle Code, shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for a term of 15 years to life. Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 2930) of Chapter 7 of Title 1 of Part 3 shall apply to reduce the term imposed pursuant to this subdivision.
(e)Notwithstanding Section 1203.1 or 1203a, if a person is convicted of a violation of this section and is granted probation, the period of probation shall be not less than three nor more than five years, provided, however, that if the maximum sentence provided for the offense may exceed five years in the state prison, the period during which the sentence may be suspended and terms of probation enforced may be for a longer period than three years but may not exceed the maximum time for which sentence of imprisonment may be pronounced.
(e)(f)This section shall not be construed as prohibiting or precluding a charge of murder under Section 188 upon facts exhibiting wantonness and a conscious disregard for life to support a finding of implied malice, or upon facts showing malice consistent with the holding of the California Supreme Court in People v. Watson, 30 Cal. 3d 290.
(f)(g)This section shall not be construed as making any homicide in the driving of a vehicle or the operation of a vessel punishable which is not a proximate result of the commission of an unlawful act, not amounting to felony, or of the commission of a lawful act which might produce death, in an unlawful manner.
(g)(h)For the penalties in subdivision (d) to apply, the existence of any fact required under subdivision (d) shall be alleged in the information or indictment and either admitted by the defendant in open court or found to be true by the trier of fact.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 4, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Highway Patrolmen | ** Support | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Support | |
| California Police Chiefs Association | ** Support | |
| California State Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | |
| Peace Officers Research Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Placer County District Attorney's Office | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
Counsel: Liah Burnley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY: Requires the period of probation for vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated to be not less than three years and allows probation to be imposed, in specified cases, for 15 years to life. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, if a person is convicted of vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated or gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and is granted probation, the period of probation shall be not less than three years and not more than five years.
- Allows probation to be imposed for a longer term if the maximum sentence provided for the offense exceeds five years in state prison. In such cases, a period of probation may be imposed up to 15 years to life, the maximum time for which a sentence of imprisonment can be pronounced for gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is the unlawful killing of a human being without malice aforethought, in the driving of a vehicle, where the driving was under the influence of alcohol or drugs, as specified, with gross negligence. (Pen. Code, § 191.5, subd. (a).)
- Provides that gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated as a felony, punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for 4, 6, or 10 years. (Pen. Code, § 191.5, subd. (c)(1).)
- Provides that a person convicted of gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, who has one or more prior specified convictions, shall be punished with a felony by imprisonment in the state prison for a term of 15 years to life. (Pen. Code, § 191.5, subd. (d).)
- Provides that vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is the unlawful killing of a human being without malice aforethought, in the driving of a vehicle, where the driving was under the influence of alcohol or drugs, as specified, but without gross negligence. (Pen. Code, § 191.5, subd. (b).)
- Provides that vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is punishable as a misdemeanor by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year or as a felony by imprisonment in the county jail for 16 months or two or four years. (Pen. Code, § 191.5, subd. (c)(2).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “California law has a major disparity in how the criminal justice system grants probation to those who drive under the influence that results in an injury or death of another person. If you take the life of someone while driving under the influence, you shouldn’t be on probation for less time than a person who didn’t. By aligning the terms of probation, we can ensure the person who took a life can receive much needed services from our probation officers while being responsibly monitored to ensure they don’t recidivate.”
- Probation Terms: Probation is the suspension of a custodial sentence and a conditional release of a defendant into the community. Probation can be “formal” or “informal.” “Formal” probation is under the direction and supervision of a probation officer. As a general proposition, the level of probation supervision will be linked to the level of risk the probationer presents to the community.
Defendants convicted of misdemeanors, and most felonies, are eligible for probation based on the discretion of the court. When considering the imposition of probation, the court evaluates the safety of the public, the nature of the offense the interests of justice, the loss to the victim, and the needs of the defendant. (Pen. Code, § 1202.7.) The court also has broad discretion to impose conditions that foster the defendant’s rehabilitation and protect public safety. (People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1114, 1120.) A valid condition must be reasonably related to the offense and aimed at deterring misconduct in the future. (Id. at 1121.)
Prior to 2021, when a defendant was convicted of a felony, the court could impose a term of probation for up to five years, or no longer than the prison term that can be imposed if the maximum prison term exceeds five years. (Pen. Code, § 1203.1.) In misdemeanor cases, the court could impose a term of probation for up to three years, or no longer than the maximum term of imprisonment if more than three years. (Pen. Code, § 1203a.) AB 1950 (Kamlager), Chapter 328, Statutes of 2020, limited probation to two years for a felony and one year for a misdemeanor.
This bill rolls back these recent reforms made by the Legislature and would require a court to impose probation for a term of no less than three years, and a term of up to 15 years to life, depending on the circumstances of the case. - Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated And Gross Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated: The difference between vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated and gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is the degree of negligence required. Vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated is a lesser crime than gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated. Vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated only requires ordinary negligence, which is the failure to use reasonable care to prevent reasonably foreseeable harm to oneself or someone else. A person is negligent if they do something that a reasonably careful person would not do in the same situation. On the other hand, gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated requires a person to act in a reckless way that creates a high risk of death or great bodily injury. In other words, a person acts with gross negligence when they disregard human life. (Compare CALCRIM NO. 590 [Gross Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated] with CALCRIM No. 591 [Vehicular Manslaughter While Intoxicated].)
To prove that the defendant is guilty of vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, the prosecution must show:
1. The defendant drove under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol;
2. While driving under the influence the defendant also committed an act that might cause death;
3. The defendant committed the act that might cause death with ordinary negligence; and,
4. The defendant’s negligent conduct caused the death of another person. (CALCRIM No. 591.)
To prove that the defendant is guilty of gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, the prosecution must show:
1. The defendant drove under the influence of drugs and/or alcohol;
2. While driving under the influence the defendant also committed an act that might cause death;
3. The defendant committed the act that might cause death with gross negligence; and,
4. The defendant’s grossly negligent conduct caused the death of another person. (CALCRIM No. 590.)
- Increased Penalties Do Not Deter Crime: Unduly long sentences are counterproductive for public safety and contribute to the dynamic of diminishing returns as the incarcerated population expands.[1] Increasingly punitive sentences add little to the deterrent effect of the criminal justice system; and mass incarceration diverts resources from program and policy initiatives that hold the potential for greater impact on public safety.[2]
Research shows that increasing the severity of the punishment does little to deter the crime. According to the National Institute of Justice, laws and policies designed to deter crime by focusing mainly on increasing the severity of punishment are ineffective partly because criminals know little about the sanctions for specific crimes. More severe punishments do not “chasten” individuals convicted of crimes, and prisons may exacerbate recidivism. Studies show that for most individuals convicted of a crime, short to moderate prison sentences may be a deterrent but longer prison terms produce only a limited deterrent effect. In addition, the crime prevention benefit falls far short of the social and economic costs.[3] This is intuitive: most individuals are not even thinking about the risk of being caught, let alone know how much prison time they may face.[4]
An analysis of 116 studies showed that incarceration does not deter people from committing future crimes and, in fact, incarceration can actually make someone more likely to be arrested and commit crimes later (due to heightened barriers to securing employment, identification, housing, and other basic services necessary to successfully reenter society).[5] These findings are consistent with other research from national institutions of renown.[6] - Argument in Support: According to California District Attorneys Association (CDAA), “There is no explanation for why a reduced probationary term is warranted for someone who is convicted of vehicular manslaughter while being under the influence when compared to the probationary term mandated for someone convicted of simply driving under the influence. This is especially true considering the additional restitution obligations that are often imposed as a condition of probation upon a defendant that is convicted of vehicular manslaughter. AB 2823 fixes this inconsistency by ensuring that a person who is convicted of the unlawful killing of a human being, without malice, while driving under the influence is to be granted the same period of probation as a person who is convicted of driving under the influence.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to American Civil Liberties Union California Action, “Probation is an arduous process where even the slightest technical violation or missed meeting can result in a lengthy prison sentence. Expanding that time period will not contribute to greater rehabilitation, but rather, increase disparities. Our research shows that many probation violations result from social and economic disadvantages, including poverty, housing insecurity, problematic drug use, mental health conditions, and racial bias. In most cases, these factors are present in combination. For example, Black and brown people are more likely to be poor and homeless than their white counterparts, and many people with mental health conditions use drugs to cope with their symptoms. Meanwhile, poverty and homelessness can exacerbate mental health conditions. More time on probation means more monthly supervision fees and more time to mess up— which can trigger additional fines and incarceration.
“After a nearly 500 percent increase in the US jail and prison population from 1980 to 2007, and nearly 400 percent rise in probation and parole populations, incarceration and supervision growth is finally slowing. States across the country are gradually reforming laws and policies to reduce their reliance on incarceration. Yet many reforms have failed to tackle the role of probation and parole in perpetuating mass incarceration. Data show that, between 1978 and 2008 the proportion of US state and federal prison admissions that resulted from violations of parole, extended supervision, or “split sentence” probation doubled. In the late seventies, 16 percent of state and federal prison admissions stemmed from such violations; by 2008, that number was 36 percent. This proportion declined sharply in 2011, likely due in large part to California’s “realignment” policy, which, among other things, limited imprisonment for supervision violations—leading to a sizeable reduction in prison admissions for these violations. California cannot afford to backstep on its progress combatting mass incarceration.” - Related Legislation:
- AB 2106 (McCarty) would increase the term of probation for persons convicted of a controlled substance offense. AB 2016 is pending in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 2943 (Zbur) would, among other things, increase the maximum term of probation for shoplifting. AB 2943 is pending in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 2106 (McCarty) would increase the term of probation for persons convicted of a controlled substance offense. AB 2016 is pending in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1067 (Jim Patterson), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have increased the penalties for fleeing the scene of an accident resulting in the death of another person from an alternate felony-misdemeanor with a maximum punishment of four years in state prison, to an alternate felony-misdemeanor having a maximum punishment of six years in the state prison. AB 1607 failed passage in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1551 (Gipson), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have required the California Victim Compensation Board to pay child victims loss of support until they are 18 years old, for gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated, or a hit and run while intoxicated, if the offense caused the death of the child’s parent or guardian AB 1551 failed passage in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 582 (Jim Patterson), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, was the same as AB 1067. AB 582 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1950 (Kamlager), Chapter 328, Statutes of 2020, specifies that a court may not impose a term of probation longer than two years for a felony conviction and one year for a misdemeanor conviction
- AB 195 (Jim Patterson), of the 2019-2020 Legislative Session, as amended in the Senate, was the same AB 1067. AB 195 failed passage in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 2014 (E. Garcia), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have increased the penalty for fleeing the scene of an accident resulting in death or serious bodily injury from two, three, or four years in state prison to two, four, or six years in state prison. The hearing on AB 2014 was canceled in this committee at the request of the author.
- AB 1067 (Jim Patterson), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, would have increased the penalties for fleeing the scene of an accident resulting in the death of another person from an alternate felony-misdemeanor with a maximum punishment of four years in state prison, to an alternate felony-misdemeanor having a maximum punishment of six years in the state prison. AB 1607 failed passage in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California District Attorneys Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC)
Placer County District Attorney's Office
Oppose
ACLU California Action
Analysis Prepared by:
Long-Term Sentences: Time to Reconsider the Scale of Punishment, 87 UMKC L. Rev., 1 (Nov. 5, 2018). ↑
Ibid. ↑
National Institute of Justice, Five Things about Deterrence <https://www.ojp.gov/pdffiles1/nij/247350.pdf> [as of Feb. 15, 2023]. ↑
Long-Term Sentences: Time to Reconsider the Scale of Punishment, 87 UMKC L. Rev., 1 (Nov. 5, 2018) (citations omitted). ↑
Brookings, Retail Theft In US Cities: Separating Fact from Fiction (March 6, 2024). Available at: <https://www.brookings.edu/articles/retail-theft-in-us-cities-separating-fact-from-fiction/>. ↑
National Research Council of the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, The Growth of Incarceration in the United States: Exploring Causes and Consequences, (April 2014) at pp. 130 -150. Available at: <https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1026&context=jj_pubs>. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):