AB 2860: Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico programs.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-14
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-14: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 246, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program. The bill would require the Dental Board of California to, notwithstanding existing requirements to provide specified federal taxpayer information, issue a 3-year nonrenewable permit to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the applicant meets specified conditions.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would authorize the Medical Board of California to issue a limited number of active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program, as specified. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with an approved medical school or an approved residency program, as provided. The bill would also require specified entities to be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements. The bill would impose fees in connection with both programs, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program. The bill would require the Dental Board of California to, notwithstanding existing requirements to provide specified federal taxpayer information, issue a 3-year nonrenewable permit to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the applicant meets specified conditions.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would authorize the Medical Board of California to issue a limited number of active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program, as specified. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with an approved medical school or an approved residency program, as provided. The bill would also require specified entities to be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements. The bill would impose fees in connection with both programs, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program. The bill would require the Dental Board of California to, notwithstanding existing requirements to provide specified federal taxpayer information, issue a 3-year nonrenewable permit to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the applicant meets specified conditions.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would authorize the board Medical Board of California to issue a limited number of active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program, Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program, as specified. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with an approved medical school or an approved residency program, as provided. The bill would also require specified entities to be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements. The bill would impose fees in connection with the program, both programs, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would authorize the board to issue a limited number of active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program, as specified. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with an approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program, as provided. The bill would also require specified entities to be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements. The bill would impose fees in connection with the program, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would authorize the board to issue a limited number of active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program, as specified. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with an approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program, as provided. The bill would also require specified entities to be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements. The bill would impose fees in connection with the program, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would require the Medical Board of California to permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a 3-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the program to extend their license for 3 years on a one-time basis. Commencing January 1, 2025, and every 3 years thereafter, until January 1, 2041, the bill would require the board to permit no more than an additional specified number of physicians from Mexico to participate in the program. authorize the board to issue a limited number of active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program, as specified. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with the University of California at San Francisco, an approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program, as provided. The bill would also require the board to work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the pilot program and worked in the placement of physicians in federally qualified health centers that participated in the pilot program. specified entities to be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements. The bill would impose fees in connection with the program, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would require the Medical Board of California to permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a 3-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the program to extend their license for 3 years on a one-time basis. Commencing January 1, 2025, and every 3 years thereafter, until January 1, 2041, the bill would require the board to permit no more than an additional specified number of physicians from Mexico to participate in the program. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with the University of California at San Francisco, as provided. The bill would also require the board to work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the pilot program and worked in the placement of physicians in federally qualified health centers that participated in the pilot program.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
Existing law, the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, allows up to 30 licensed physicians and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed 3 years, in accordance with certain requirements. Existing law requires the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to provide oversight pursuant to these provisions. Existing law requires appropriate funding to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities before implementation of the pilot program may proceed.
Existing law requires physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program to be enrolled in English as a second language classes, to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month orientation program, and to have satisfactorily completed a 6-month externship at the applicants place of employment, among various other requirements.
This bill would repeal the provisions regarding the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, and would instead establish two bifurcated programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. Within these 2 programs, the bill would generally revise and recast certain requirements pertaining to the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, including deleting the above-described requirement that Mexican physicians participating in the program enroll in adult English as a second language classes. The bill would instead require those physicians to have satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language or the Occupational English Test, as specified. The bill would remove the requirement that the orientation program be 6 months, and would further require the orientation program to include electronic medical records systems utilized by federally qualified health centers and standards for medical chart notations. The bill would also delete the requirement that the physicians participate in a 6-month externship. The bill would further delete provisions requiring an evaluation of the pilot program to be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations, and would make various other related changes to the program.
Commencing January 1, 2025, the bill would require the Medical Board of California to permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a 3-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the program to extend their license for 3 years on a one-time basis. Commencing January 1, 2025, and every 3 years thereafter, until January 1, 2041, the bill would require the board to permit no more than an additional specified number of physicians from Mexico to participate in the program. Under the bill, each additional physician selected for the program would not be eligible to renew their 3-year license.
The bill would require the federally qualified health centers employing physicians pursuant to the program to continue specified peer review protocols and procedures and to work with the University of California at San Francisco, as provided. The bill would also require the board to work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the pilot program and worked in the placement of physicians in federally qualified health centers that participated in the pilot program.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999, only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996, only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English-dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino health care workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce health care disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with health care shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(20)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(21)Latinos were already 19 percent of the states population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the states total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(22)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(23)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a permit only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of dentistry pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of dentistry under the permit in accordance with this section.
(j)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(k)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(l)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(m)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program approved by the board in connection with the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, and that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program may be changed by a committee of at least five chief medical officers at federally qualified health centers employing program licensees to ensure that the orientation program contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)Representatives from California and the UNAM in Mexico that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license, each licensee shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits by the board to ensure compliance. The board may issue a citation and administrative fine against a licensee who fails to comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with a California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or a residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected patient encounters with each licensee per six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. The faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, psychiatry, and obstetrics and gynecology from the California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or the residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. The faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and be accredited by The Joint Commission, National Committee for Quality Assurance, or Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year physicians and surgeons license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license issued pursuant to this program shall be referred to as a Physicians and Surgeons from Mexico License and shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.
(g)(1)(A)Between January 1, 2025, and January 1, 2029, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 155 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 30 of the 155 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2025, and December 31, 2025, except that the board may accept up to 15 applications after December 31, 2025, and before January 1, 2028.
(2)(A)Between January 1, 2029, and January 1, 2033, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 195 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 195 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2029, and December 31, 2029, except that the board may accept up to 19 applications after December 31, 2029, and before January 1, 2032.
(3)(A)Between January 1, 2033, and January 1, 2037, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 225 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2033, and December 31, 2033, except that the board may accept up to 22 applications after December 31, 2033, and before January 1, 2036.
(4)(A)Between January 1, 2037, and January 1, 2041, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 255 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 255 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2037, and December 31, 2037, except that the board may accept up to 25 applications after December 31, 2037, and before January 1, 2040.
(5)(A)Between January 1, 2041, and January 1, 2045, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 275 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 275 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2041, and December 31, 2041, except that the board may accept up to 27 applications after December 31, 2041, and before January 1, 2044.
(6)A physicians eligibility pursuant to this subdivision is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(h)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(i)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
2126.(a)The following fees apply to the licensure of physicians and surgeons authorized by this article:
(1)The application and processing fee shall be the amount specified in subdivision (b) of Section 2435.
(2)The initial license fee shall be one and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (c) of Section 2435.
(3)The fee for the Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System (CURES) shall be three times the annual fee specified under subdivision (a) of Section 208.
(4)The fee for the Steven M. Thompson Physician Corps Loan Repayment Program shall be one-and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 2436.5.
(b)The fees required by this section shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California, except that the fee described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) shall be deposited into the CURES Fund.
(c)Any unencumbered funds collected by the board pursuant to former Section 853 shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999, only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996, only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English-dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino health care workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce health care disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with health care shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(20)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(21)Latinos were already 19 percent of the states population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the states total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(22)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(23)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a permit only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of dentistry pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of dentistry under the permit in accordance with this section.
(j)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(k)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(l)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(m)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program approved by the board in connection with the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, and that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program may be changed by a committee of at least five chief medical officers at federally qualified health centers employing program licensees to ensure that the orientation program contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)Representatives from California and the UNAM in Mexico that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license, each licensee shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits by the board to ensure compliance. The board may issue a citation and administrative fine against a licensee who fails to comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with a California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or a residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected patient encounters with each licensee per six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. The faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, psychiatry, and obstetrics and gynecology from the California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or the residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. The faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and be accredited by The Joint Commission, National Committee for Quality Assurance, or Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year physicians and surgeons license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license issued pursuant to this program shall be referred to as a Physicians and Surgeons from Mexico License and shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.
(g)(1)(A)Between January 1, 2025, and January 1, 2029, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 155 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 30 of the 155 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2025, and December 31, 2025, except that the board may accept up to 15 applications after December 31, 2025, and before January 1, 2028.
(2)(A)Between January 1, 2029, and January 1, 2033, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 195 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 195 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2029, and December 31, 2029, except that the board may accept up to 19 applications after December 31, 2029, and before January 1, 2032.
(3)(A)Between January 1, 2033, and January 1, 2037, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 225 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2033, and December 31, 2033, except that the board may accept up to 22 applications after December 31, 2033, and before January 1, 2036.
(4)(A)Between January 1, 2037, and January 1, 2041, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 255 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 255 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2037, and December 31, 2037, except that the board may accept up to 25 applications after December 31, 2037, and before January 1, 2040.
(5)(A)Between January 1, 2041, and January 1, 2045, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 275 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 275 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2041, and December 31, 2041, except that the board may accept up to 27 applications after December 31, 2041, and before January 1, 2044.
(6)A physicians eligibility pursuant to this subdivision is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(h)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(i)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
2126.(a)The following fees apply to the licensure of physicians and surgeons authorized by this article:
(1)The application and processing fee shall be the amount specified in subdivision (b) of Section 2435.
(2)The initial license fee shall be one and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (c) of Section 2435.
(3)The fee for the Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System (CURES) shall be three times the annual fee specified under subdivision (a) of Section 208.
(4)The fee for the Steven M. Thompson Physician Corps Loan Repayment Program shall be one-and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 2436.5.
(b)The fees required by this section shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California, except that the fee described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) shall be deposited into the CURES Fund.
(c)Any unencumbered funds collected by the board pursuant to former Section 853 shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999, only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996, only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English-dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino healthcare health care workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce healthcare health care disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with healthcare health care shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(20)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(21)Latinos were already 19 percent of the states population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the states total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(22)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(23)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a permit only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of dentistry pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of dentistry under the permit in accordance with this section.
(i)(j)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)(k)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(k)(l)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(l)(m)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program approved by the board in connection with the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, and that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program may be changed by a committee of at least five chief medical officers at federally qualified health centers employing program licensees to ensure that the orientation program contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)Representatives from California and the UNAM in Mexico that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license, each licensee shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits by the board to ensure compliance. The board may issue a citation and administrative fine against a licensee who fails to comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with a California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or a residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected patient encounters with each licensee per six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. The faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, psychiatry, and obstetrics and gynecology from the California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or the residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. The faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and be accredited by The Joint Commission, National Committee for Quality Assurance, or Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year physicians and surgeons license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license issued pursuant to this program shall be referred to as a Physicians and Surgeons from Mexico License and shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.
(f)(g)(1)(A)Between January 1, 2025, and January 1, 2029, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 155 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 30 of the 155 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2025, and December 31, 2025, except that the board may accept up to 15 applications after December 31, 2025, and before January 1, 2028.
(2)(A)Between January 1, 2029, and January 1, 2033, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 195 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 195 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2029, and December 31, 2029, except that the board may accept up to 19 applications after December 31, 2029, and before January 1, 2032.
(3)(A)Between January 1, 2033, and January 1, 2037, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 225 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2033, and December 31, 2033, except that the board may accept up to 22 applications after December 31, 2033, and before January 1, 2036.
(4)(A)Between January 1, 2037, and January 1, 2041, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 255 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 255 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2037, and December 31, 2037, except that the board may accept up to 25 applications after December 31, 2037, and before January 1, 2040.
(5)(A)Between January 1, 2041, and January 1, 2045, the board shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 275 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 275 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2041, and December 31, 2041, except that the board may accept up to 27 applications after December 31, 2041, and before January 1, 2044.
(6)A physicians eligibility pursuant to this subdivision is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(g)(h)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(h)(i)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
2126.(a)The following fees apply to the licensure of physicians and surgeons authorized by this article:
(1)The application and processing fee shall be the amount specified in subdivision (b) of Section 2435.
(2)The initial license fee shall be one and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (c) of Section 2435.
(3)The fee for the Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System (CURES) shall be three times the annual fee specified under subdivision (a) of Section 208.
(4)The fee for the Steven M. Thompson Physician Corps Loan Repayment Program shall be one-and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 2436.5.
(b)The fees required by this section shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California, except that the fee described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) shall be deposited into the CURES Fund.
(c)Any unencumbered funds collected by the board pursuant to former Section 853 shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999, only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996, only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English-dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino healthcare workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce healthcare disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with healthcare shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(20)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(21)Latinos were already 19 percent of the states population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the states total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(22)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(23)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(k)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(l)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program approved by the board in connection with the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, and that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program may be changed by a committee of at least five chief medical officers at federally qualified health centers employing program licensees to ensure that the orientation program contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)Representatives from California and the UNAM in Mexico that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license, each licensee shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits by the board to ensure compliance. The board may assess a civil penalty issue a citation and administrative fine against a licensee who fails to comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with an approved a California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or a medical institution with an approved residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit patient encounters with each licensee per six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. The faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, psychiatry, and obstetrics and gynecology of the approved from the California medical school approved by the board pursuant to Section 2084 or medical institution with an approved the residency program approved by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. The faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and be accredited by The Joint Commission, National Committee for Quality Assurance, or Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year physicians and surgeons license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license issued pursuant to this program shall be referred to as a Physicians and Surgeons from Mexico License and shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)(A)Between January 1, 2025, and January 1, 2029, the board may issue up to a total of 125 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program. shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 155 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 30 of the 125 155 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2025, and December 31, 2025. 2025, except that the board may accept up to 15 applications after December 31, 2025, and before January 1, 2028.
(2)(A)Between January 1, 2029, and January 1, 2033, the board may issue up to a total of 195 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program. shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 195 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 195 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2029, and December 31, 2029. 2029, except that the board may accept up to 19 applications after December 31, 2029, and before January 1, 2032.
(3)(A)Between January 1, 2033, and January 1, 2037, the board may issue up to a total of 225 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program. shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 225 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2033, and December 31, 2033. 2033, except that the board may accept up to 22 applications after December 31, 2033, and before January 1, 2036.
(4)(A)Between January 1, 2037, and January 1, 2041, the board may issue up to a total of 255 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program. shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 255 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 255 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2037, and December 31, 2037. 2037, except that the board may accept up to 25 applications after December 31, 2037, and before January 1, 2040.
(5)(A)Between January 1, 2041, and January 1, 2045, the board may issue up to a total of 275 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program. shall coordinate with the representatives described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) to ensure that no more than 275 program participants have a current and active license at the same time.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 275 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2041, and December 31, 2041. 2041, except that the board may accept up to 27 applications after December 31, 2041, and before January 1, 2044.
(6)A physicians eligibility pursuant to this subdivision is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(g)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(h)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
2126.(a)The following fees apply to the licensure of physicians and surgeons authorized by this article:
(1)The application and processing fee shall be the amount specified in subdivision (b) of Section 2435.
(2)The initial license fee shall be one and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (c) of Section 2435.
(3)The fee for the Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System (CURES) shall be three times the annual fee specified under subdivision (a) of Section 208.
(4)The fee for the Steven M. Thompson Physician Corps Loan Repayment Program shall be one-and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 2436.5.
(b)The fees required by this section shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California, except that the fee described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) shall be deposited into the CURES Fund.
(c)Any unencumbered funds collected by the board pursuant to former Section 853 shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999, only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996, only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English-dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino healthcare workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce healthcare disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with healthcare shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(20)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(21)Latinos were already 19 percent of the states population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the states total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(22)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(23)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(k)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(l)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program approved by the board in connection with the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, and that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program may be changed by a committee of at least five chief medical officers at federally qualified health centers employing program licensees to ensure that the orientation program contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)Representatives from California and the UNAM in Mexico that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license, each licensee shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits by the board to ensure compliance. The board may assess a civil penalty against a licensee who fails to comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with an approved medical school or a medical institution with an approved residency program to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. The faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, psychiatry, and obstetrics and gynecology of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. The faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and be accredited by The Joint Commission, National Committee for Quality Assurance, or Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year physicians and surgeons license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license issued pursuant to this program shall be referred to as a Physicians and Surgeons from Mexico License and shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)(A)Between January 1, 2025, and January 1, 2029, the board may issue up to a total of 125 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 30 of the 125 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2025, and December 31, 2025.
(2)(A)Between January 1, 2029, and January 1, 2033, the board may issue up to a total of 195 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 195 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2029, and December 31, 2029.
(3)(A)Between January 1, 2033, and January 1, 2037, the board may issue up to a total of 225 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2033, and December 31, 2033.
(4)(A)Between January 1, 2037, and January 1, 2041, the board may issue up to a total of 255 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2037, and December 31, 2037.
(5)(A)Between January 1, 2041, and January 1, 2045, the board may issue up to a total of 275 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 275 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2041, and December 31, 2041.
(6)A physicians eligibility pursuant to this subdivision is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(g)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(h)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
2126.(a)The following fees apply to the licensure of physicians and surgeons authorized by this article:
(1)The application and processing fee shall be the amount specified in subdivision (b) of Section 2435.
(2)The initial license fee shall be one and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (c) of Section 2435.
(3)The fee for the Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System (CURES) shall be three times the annual fee specified under subdivision (a) of Section 208.
(4)The fee for the Steven M. Thompson Physician Corps Loan Repayment Program shall be one-and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 2436.5.
(b)The fees required by this section shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California, except that the fee described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) shall be deposited into the CURES Fund.
(c)Any unencumbered funds collected by the board pursuant to former Section 853 shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999 1999, only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996 1996, only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English dominant non-English-dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino healthcare workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce healthcare disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with healthcare shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
(20)TheThe physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(21)(20)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(22)(21)Latinos were already 19 percent of the state's population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the state's total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(23)(22)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(24)(23)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English-speaking English speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign-born. foreign born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(k)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(l)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a nonrenewable three-year physicians and surgeons license to practice medicine to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program approved by the board in connection with the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, and that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program shall be approved by the board may be changed by a committee of at least five chief medical officers at federally qualified health centers employing program licensees to ensure that it the orientation program contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)(i)Representatives from the UNAM in Mexico and a medical school in good standing or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California shall confer to develop a mutually agreed-upon distant learning program for the orientation program required pursuant to subparagraph (B). (ii)The representatives(C)Representatives from California and the UNAM in Mexico that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, and assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements. requirements, selecting appropriate federally qualified health centers throughout California, ensuring compliance with program provisions, developing policy and clinical workshops, monitoring productivity and increased access to medical care, and assessing the necessity of policy and programmatic improvements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their nonrenewable three-year medical physicians and surgeons license, each physician licensee shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits by the board to ensure compliance. The board may assess a civil penalty against a licensee who fails to comply with the requirements of this paragraph.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with the University of California at San Francisco (UCSF) School of Medicine to have UCSF an approved medical school or a medical institution with an approved residency program to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to UCSF the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. UCSF The faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, psychiatry, and obstetrics and gynecology of the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. UCSF The faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of UCSF the approved medical school or medical institution with an approved residency program secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the UCSF secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro-rata pro rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by The Joint Commission or have protocols similar to those required by The Joint Commission. These protocols shall be submitted to the board prior to the hiring of physicians. Commission, National Committee for Quality Assurance, or Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this three-year pilot program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)Any funding necessary for the implementation of the program and oversight functions shall be secured from donations or nonprofit organizations. Implementation of this program shall not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from donations or nonprofit organizations. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from donations and nonprofit organizations. The board shall, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from donations and nonprofit organizations for this program.(8)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year license to practice medicine shall be ______________ dollars ($____). A(7)A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year physicians and surgeons license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The nonrenewable three-year medical physicians and surgeons license issued pursuant to this program shall be referred to as a Physicians and Surgeons from Mexico License and shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a three-year license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to all of the following conditions:(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.(g)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, the board may extend the three-year license period if, before January 30, 2024, the licensee was unable to practice more than 30 consecutive business days due to at least one of the following circumstances:(A)The pregnancy of the licensee.(B)The pregnancy of the married spouse of the licensee.(C)The pregnancy of the domestic partner who is in a civil union with the licensee.(D)Delay caused by the credentialing process of health plans.(E)Delay caused by the visa application and review process by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.(2)For a licensee to be eligible for an extension under this subdivision, both of the following shall be submitted to the board no later than January 30, 2024:(A)A declaration signed by the licensee under penalty of perjury and supporting documentation demonstrating that the licensee meets the requirements of this subdivision.(B)A request for the extension from the chief executive officer of the community health center who employs the licensee.(3)If the board determines that the requirements of this subdivision have been satisfied for a licensee, it may grant a one-time extension for the timeframe in which the licensee was unable to work.(4)An extension granted pursuant to this subdivision shall not extend the license period by more than one year or beyond September 30, 2026, whichever is sooner, and shall be dependent upon the program having sufficient funding appropriated in the annual Budget Act.(h)(1)(A)Commencing January 1, 2025, the board shall permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a three-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the pilot program, as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), to extend their license for three years on a one-time basis.(B)Commencing January 1, 2025, the board shall permit no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico to participate in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists. Each additional physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.(C)Commencing January 1, 2029, the board shall permit no more than 145 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.(D)Commencing January 1, 2033, the board shall permit no more than 175 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.(E)Commencing January 1, 2037, the board shall permit no more than 210 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.(F)Commencing January 1, 2041, the board shall permit no more than 220 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.(f)(1)(A)Between January 1, 2025, and January 1, 2029, the board may issue up to a total of 125 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 30 of the 125 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2025, and December 31, 2025.
(2)(A)Between January 1, 2029, and January 1, 2033, the board may issue up to a total of 195 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 195 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2029, and December 31, 2029.
(3)(A)Between January 1, 2033, and January 1, 2037, the board may issue up to a total of 225 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2033, and December 31, 2033.
(4)(A)Between January 1, 2037, and January 1, 2041, the board may issue up to a total of 255 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 225 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2037, and December 31, 2037.
(5)(A)Between January 1, 2041, and January 1, 2045, the board may issue up to a total of 275 active licenses to eligible applicants to participate in the program.
(B)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), no more than 40 of the 275 licenses may be issued to physicians whose primary area of practice is psychiatry.
(C)During the time period described in subparagraph (A), an applicant shall submit an application to the board between October 1, 2041, and December 31, 2041.
(2)(6)A physicians eligibility pursuant to paragraph (1) this subdivision is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(i)(g)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Costs for administering the program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.(k)(h)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
(l)The board shall work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing all required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the former Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and worked in the placement of physicians in federally qualified health centers that participated in the pilot program.2126.(a)The following fees apply to the licensure of physicians and surgeons authorized by this article:
(1)The application and processing fee shall be the amount specified in subdivision (b) of Section 2435.
(2)The initial license fee shall be one and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (c) of Section 2435.
(3)The fee for the Controlled Substance Utilization Review and Evaluation System (CURES) shall be three times the annual fee specified under subdivision (a) of Section 208.
(4)The fee for the Steven M. Thompson Physician Corps Loan Repayment Program shall be one-and one-half times the amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 2436.5.
(b)The fees required by this section shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California, except that the fee described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) shall be deposited into the CURES Fund.
(c)Any unencumbered funds collected by the board pursuant to former Section 853 shall be deposited into the Contingent Fund of the Medical Board of California.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999 only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996 only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino healthcare workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce healthcare disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with healthcare shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
(20)The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(21)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(22)Latinos were already 19 percent of the state's population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the state's total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(23)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(24)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English-speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign-born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(k)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(l)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year license to practice medicine to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, AC. A.C.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program shall be approved by the board to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)(i)Representatives from the UNAM in Mexico and a medical school in good standing or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California shall confer to develop a mutually agreed-upon distant learning program for the orientation program required pursuant to subparagraph (B).
(ii)The representatives from UNAM that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, and assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their three-year medical license, each physician shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits to ensure compliance.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with the University of California at San Francisco (UCSF) School of Medicine to have UCSF conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter, six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to UCSF in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken the fourth, eighth, and twelfth month every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. UCSF faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, and obstetrics and gynecology shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. UCSF faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the three six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of UCSF secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the UCSF secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro-rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by The Joint Commission or have protocols similar to those required by The Joint Commission. These protocols shall be submitted to the board prior to the hiring of physicians.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this three-year pilot program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico. Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7)Any funding necessary for the implementation of the program and oversight functions shall be secured from donations or nonprofit philanthropic entities. organizations. Implementation of this program shall not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from donations or nonprofit philanthropic entities. organizations. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from donations and nonprofit philanthropic entities. organizations. The board shall, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from donations and nonprofit philanthropic entities organizations for this program.
(8)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year license to practice medicine shall be ______________ dollars ($____). A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The three-year medical license issued pursuant to this program shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a three-year license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to all of the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.
(g)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, the board may extend the three-year license period if, before January 30, 2024, the licensee was unable to practice more than 30 consecutive business days due to at least one of the following circumstances:
(A)The pregnancy of the licensee.
(B)The pregnancy of the married spouse of the licensee.
(C)The pregnancy of the domestic partner who is in a civil union with the licensee.
(D)Delay caused by the credentialing process of health plans.
(E)Delay caused by the visa application and review process by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.
(2)For a licensee to be eligible for an extension under this subdivision, both of the following shall be submitted to the board no later than January 30, 2024:
(A)A declaration signed by the licensee under penalty of perjury and supporting documentation demonstrating that the licensee meets the requirements of this subdivision.
(B)A request for the extension from the chief executive officer of the community health center who employs the licensee.
(3)If the board determines that the requirements of this subdivision have been satisfied for a licensee, it may grant a one-time extension for the timeframe in which the licensee was unable to work.
(4)An extension granted pursuant to this subdivision shall not extend the license period by more than one year or beyond September 30, 2026, whichever is sooner, and shall be dependent upon the program having sufficient funding appropriated in the annual Budget Act.
(h)(1)(A)Commencing January 1, 2025, the board shall permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a three-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the pilot program, as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), to extend their license for three years on a one-time basis.
(B)Commencing January 1, 2025, the board shall permit no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico to participate in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists. Each additional physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(C)Commencing January 1, 2029, the board shall permit no more than 145 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(D)Commencing January 1, 2033, the board shall permit no more than 175 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(E)Commencing January 1, 2037, the board shall permit no more than 210 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(F)Commencing January 1, 2041, the board shall permit no more than 220 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(2)A physicians eligibility pursuant to paragraph (1) is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Costs for administering the program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(k)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
(l)The board shall work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing all required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the former Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and worked in the placement of physicians in federally qualified health centers that participated in the pilot program.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The facts and sources cited in this subdivision describe the physician shortages that existed up to 2001 in California and the United States, including an emphasis on the lack of Latino medical students and licensed physicians in proportion to their population in California. These critical and dangerous shortages led to the creation of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(1)The 2020 United States Census determined the population of California to be over 39 million people with approximately 16 million being Latino.
(2)From July 1990 to July 1999, Californias population increased by approximately 4 million people. Approximately 61 percent of this growth can be attributed to the growth in the Latino population. The Latino population has increased at an average rate of 275,000 persons per year from 1990 to 1999. The Latino population is estimated to have grown in virtually all counties over this period.
(3)The United States General Accounting Office reports that the United States Community Health Centers patients comprise 65 percent ethnic and racial minorities.
(4)Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires any federally funded health facility to ensure persons with limited English proficiency may meaningfully access health care services. Persons with limited English proficiency are often excluded from programs, experience delays or denials of services, or receive care and services based on inaccurate or incomplete information.
(5)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration reports the number of physicians in California grew 17 percent between 1989 and 1998.
(6)The federal Health Resources and Services Administration found in 1998 that only 4 percent of active patient care physicians were Latino.
(7)The Association of American Medical Colleges in 1998 found only 6.8 percent of all graduates from United States medical schools were of an ethnic or racial minority group.
(8)In 1999 only 11 percent of dentists in California were a member of a racial or ethnic minority group with 5 percent being classified as Asian or Pacific Islanders.
(9)In 1996 only 4 percent of dentists in California were Latino.
(10)According to the Institute of Medicine report requested by the United States Congress, research evidence suggests that provider-patient communication is directly linked to patient satisfaction, adherence, and subsequently health outcomes. Thus, when sociocultural differences between the patient and the provider are not appreciated, explored, understood, or communicated in the medical encounter, the result is patient dissatisfaction, poor adherence, poorer health outcomes, and racial and ethnic disparities in health care.
(11)A Commonwealth Fund of New York study found that: (1) one-third of Latinos said they had problems communicating with their doctors with barriers to this poor communication including language, cultural traditions, and sensitivity; (2) communication is essential to quality health care; and (3) inadequate communication can lead to the perception of inhumane health care service delivery.
(12)The Summit on Immigration Needs & Contributions of the Bridging Borders in the Silicon Valley Project found that approximately 50 percent of participants reported that having a provider that speaks their language will improve the quality of health care services they receive.
(13)Only two states in the country have reported cultural competency standards for care.
(14)No states in the country have reported foreign language competencies for physicians or dentists.
(15)According to the Dallas Morning News, many immigrants travel to Mexico to receive health care due to the cultural and language barriers they encounter in the United States health care system. According to the San Jose Mercury News, 65 percent of the membership of the largest medical association in California reported that if they were required to pay for medical interpreters, they would stop seeing patients that required interpretation services.
(16)According to the Journal of the American Medical Association, in 1999, one medical school had a separate course covering cultural diversity, 109 medical schools included cultural diversity content as part of a required course or clerkship, and 84 medical schools included information on cultural beliefs or practices related to death or dying in a required course or clerkship.
(b)The facts and data set forth in this subdivision reflect physician shortages from 2015 onward, as projected through 2034 nationwide, but do not include the shortage of culturally and linguistically competent medical providers in the nation or California, which seriously exacerbates the problems of accessing medical care in non-English dominant communities.
(1)Despite the Latino population comprising approximately 38 percent of the people in California in 2015, the percentage of Latino physicians in California was only 7 percent in 2015.
(2)In 2015, the percentage of Doctor of Osteopathic Medicine graduates in California was 3 percent, physician assistants was 20 percent, nurse practitioners was 9 percent, and registered nurses was 20 percent.
(3)According to data reported in the Physicians Almanac, 7 percent of physicians working in the San Joaquin Valley in 2021 were Latina or Latino, whereas the Latino population in that region was 53 percent.
(4)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the County of Los Angeles accounted for 6 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 49 percent.
(5)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians working in the Inland Empire accounted for 7 percent of the population, whereas the Latino population in that region was 52 percent.
(6)In 2021, Latina and Latino physicians in the Sacramento area accounted for 4 percent, whereas Latinos comprised 22 percent of the population in that region.
(7)The Physicians Almanac reported in 2021 that all of the most populated regions of California where Latinos reside had less than the recommended number of primary care physicians, with only 60 per 100,000 patients.
(8)The region with the highest percentage of doctors who spoke Spanish in 2021 was the Central Coast, with 28 percent, followed by the County of Los Angeles, with 27 percent. There was no detailed information on this data based on Spanish language fluency or knowledge of cultural beliefs and practices related to health care.
(9)Based on a study published in the Journal of Health Affairs, Latino and Hispanic groups are underrepresented in medical professions that require advanced degrees and overrepresented in similar professions that dont require a bachelors or higher degree.
(10)In 2020, the American Community Survey found that, Mexican Americans made up 10.7 percent of the U.S. workforce but just 1.77 percent of U.S. physicians.
(11)According to a recent article in the Washington Post from 2023, Underrepresentation among Latino healthcare workers is a concern because data suggests racially, and ethnically diverse and culturally competent medical providers can help reduce healthcare disparities among minority populations. Minority patients with providers who share their race, ethnicity, or language report receiving better care than when they see providers from different racial or language groups. Studies have shown that providers from minority groups are more likely to work in areas with healthcare shortages, accept Medicaid, and spend more time with patients.
(12)As of November 1, 2023, California has the nations most federally designated Primary Care Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs) with 694, followed by Texas with 436. An HPSA is an area that must have 3,500 in population for one primary care physician.
(13)The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a leading voice in medical academia and research. The AAMC issued a significant study in June 2021 on physician shortages in the United States titled The Complexities of Physician Supply and Demand: Projections from 2019 to 2034.
(14)In this study, the AAMC projects that the United States could see an estimated shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians by 2034, including shortfalls in both primary and specialty care.
(15)The study cites the COVID-19 pandemic as exposing many of the deepest disparities in health and access to health care services and exposed vulnerabilities in the health care system, according to AAMC President and CEO David J. Skorton, MD.
(16)The AAMC projected the following physician shortages by 2034:
(A)Primary Care (e.g., family medicine, general pediatrics, geriatric medicine): between 17,800 and 48,000.
(B)Surgical Specialties (e.g., general surgery, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery): between 15,800 and 30,200.
(C)Medical Specialties (e.g., cardiology, oncology, infectious diseases, pulmonology): between 3,800 and 13,400.
(D)Other Specialties (e.g., anesthesiology, neurology, emergency medicine, addiction medicine): between 10,300 and 35,600.
(17)The President and CEO of the AAMC, David J. Skorton, MD, testified before Congress, stating that the issue of increasing clinician burnout, which the pandemic has intensified, could cause doctors and other health workers to cut back their hours or accelerate their plans for retirement.
(18)Despite Congressional efforts in 2021 to introduce bipartisan legislation to increase medical residencies by 2,000 annually for seven years, the shortages identified by the AAMC will come about.
(19)On the matter of workforce diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI), the AAMC stated in this study as follows:
(20)The physician workforce lacks sufficient diversity and inclusion (i.e., it lacks diversity overall and in positions of leadership and influence). The AAMC has identified addressing this lack as a core strategic priority. Extensive long-term data-collection work is needed, as is extensive and nuanced research about physician workforce diversity and the anti-racist policies that can combat the endemic structural and systemic racism that harms the current physician workforce, damages the nations ability to create a more diverse and inclusive physician workforce, and impedes a diverse population from receiving equitable health care.
(21)In 1980, the United States Census found an unprecedented growth in the Latino community that would continue beyond the decade. The United States census predicted that Latino demographic trends would have Latinos being the largest minority population in the United States during the first decade of the 2000s.
(22)Latinos were already 19 percent of the state's population in California in 1980. From 1980 to 1990, the state's total population grew by 26 percent, but the Latino population increased by 69 percent.
(23)In other words, the need to be more inclusive of Latinos in the health care workforce and the health care needs of Latinos was well known to California policymakers in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and since 2010. However, the academic medical community and health care policymakers made no substantive move to prevent the situation from getting to the point that the AAMC and many other studies on the health care workforce have warned us to take immediate action to resolve this matter.
(24)The AAMC and the majority of all studies on health care workforce shortages have underestimated the impact of physician shortages in the Latino community over the last four decades. They have also underestimated its impact on other communities that are not predominantly English-speaking and are at least first- and, at times, second-generation foreign-born. The lack of culturally and linguistically competent physicians exacerbates and worsens the physician shortages in these communities for generations. Hence, the poor health profile of Latinos and other ethnic and racial populations in California.
(c)Underscoring the lack of preparation, creativity, and commitment to deal with the needs of a culturally and linguistically diverse society, such as California since the 1980s, and the growing physician shortages in the state, the University of California Schools of Medicine and the three private university medical schools at Stanford University, the University of Southern California, and Loma Linda University do not offer any mandatory cultural or foreign language courses to prepare medical students to serve the diverse populations that reside in California. The actions and policies taken by these medical institutions confirm the need for programs such as the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
SEC. 2.Section 853 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.853.(a)The Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created. This program shall allow up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology, and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years, in accordance with this section. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.(b)The Medical Board of California shall issue three-year nonrenewable licenses to practice medicine to licensed Mexican physicians and the Dental Board of California shall issue three-year nonrenewable permits to practice dentistry to licensed Mexican dentists.(c)Physicians from Mexico eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the following:(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C.(2)Prior to leaving Mexico, each physician shall have completed the following requirements:(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Family practitioners who include obstetrics and gynecology in their practice shall also be required to have appropriately documented, as specified by United States standards, 50 live births. Mexican obstetricians and gynecologists shall be fellows in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed a six-month orientation program that addressed medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, and pharmacology differences. This orientation program shall be approved by the Medical Board of California to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.(ii)Additionally, Mexican physicians participating in the program shall be required to be enrolled in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes that focus on both verbal and written subject matter. Each physician participating in the program shall have transcripts sent to the Medical Board of California from the appropriate Mexican university showing enrollment and satisfactory completion of these classes.(C)Representatives from the UNAM in Mexico and a medical school in good standing or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California shall confer to develop a mutually agreed upon distant learning program for the six-month orientation program required pursuant to subparagraph (B).(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their three-year nonrenewable medical license, the Mexican physicians shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain an average of 25 continuing education units per year for a total of 75 units for a full three years of program participation.(4)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), the applicant shall receive a three-year nonrenewable license to work in nonprofit community health centers and shall also be required to participate in a six-month externship at the applicants place of employment. This externship shall be undertaken after the participant has received a license and is able to practice medicine. The externship shall ensure that the participant is complying with the established standards for quality assurance of nonprofit community health centers and medical practices. The externship shall be affiliated with a medical school in good standing in California. Complaints against program participants shall follow the same procedures contained in the Medical Practice Act (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 2000)).(5)After arriving in California, Mexican physicians participating in the program shall be required to be enrolled in adult ESL classes at institutions approved by the Bureau for Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education or accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges. These classes shall focus on verbal and written subject matter to assist a physician in obtaining a level of proficiency in English that is commensurate with the level of English spoken at community clinics where the physician will practice. The community clinic employing a physician shall submit documentation confirming approval of an ESL program to the board for verification. Transcripts of satisfactory completion of the ESL classes shall be submitted to the Medical Board of California as proof of compliance with this provision.(6)(A)Nonprofit community health centers employing Mexican physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations or have protocols similar to those required by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations. These protocols shall be submitted to the Medical Board of California prior to the hiring of Mexican physicians.(B)In addition, after the program participant successfully completes the six-month externship program, a free standing health care organization that has authority to provide medical quality certification, including, but not limited to, health plans, hospitals, and the Integrated Physician Association, is responsible for ensuring and overseeing the compliance of nonprofit community health centers medical quality assurance protocols, conducting site visits when necessary, and developing any additional protocols, surveys, or assessment tools to ensure that quality of care standards through quality assurance protocols are being appropriately followed by physicians participating in the program.(7)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this three-year pilot program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities.(8)The Medical Board of California shall provide oversight review of both the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (l). The board shall consult with the medical schools applying for funding to implement and evaluate this program, executive and medical directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, and hospital administrators who will have these participants practicing in their hospital, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Any funding necessary for the implementation of this program, including the evaluation and oversight functions, shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for this program.(d)(1)Dentists from Mexico eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the following requirements or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):(A)Be graduates from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:(i)A minimum grade point average.(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.(iii)Passage of a general examination.(iv)Passage of an oral interview.(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the Dental Board of California.(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period prior to enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November of 2003 from the Dental Board of California under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the Dental Board of California.(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), dentists participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by the Dental Practice Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1600)).(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation by representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).(8)The Dental Board of California shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (l). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.(e)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.(f)Physicians and dentists from Mexico having met the applicable requirements set forth in subdivisions (c) and (d) shall be placed in a pool of candidates who are eligible to be recruited for employment by nonprofit community health centers in California, including, but not limited to, those located in the Counties of Ventura, Los Angeles, San Bernardino, Imperial, Monterey, San Benito, Sacramento, San Joaquin, Santa Cruz, Yuba, Orange, Colusa, Glenn, Sutter, Kern, Tulare, Fresno, Stanislaus, San Luis Obispo, and San Diego. The Medical Board of California shall ensure that all Mexican physicians participating in this program have satisfactorily met the requirements set forth in subdivision (c) prior to placement at a nonprofit community health center.(g)Nonprofit community health centers in the counties listed in subdivision (f) shall apply to the Medical Board of California and the Dental Board of California to hire eligible applicants who shall then be required to complete a six-month externship that includes working in the nonprofit community health center and a corresponding hospital. Once enrolled in this externship, and upon payment of the required fees, the Medical Board of California shall issue a three-year nonrenewable license to practice medicine and the Dental Board of California shall issue a three-year nonrenewable dental special permit to practice dentistry. For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable license to practice medicine shall be nine hundred dollars ($900) and the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A licensee or permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee or permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable license or permit shall be deemed to be a license or permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs, including managed care organizations and health maintenance organizations.(h)The three-year nonrenewable license or permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the licensees or permitholders address of record, if, in the Medical Board of Californias or Dental Board of Californias sole discretion, it has determined that either:(1)The license or permit was issued by mistake.(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the licensee or permitholder that warrants terminating the license or permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.(i)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the Medical Board of California shall issue a three-year nonrenewable license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Pilot Program pursuant to this section, subject to all of the following conditions:(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the Medical Board of California a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the Medical Board of California determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.(2)The Medical Board of California, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.(j)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, the Medical Board of California may extend the three-year nonrenewable license period if, prior to January 30, 2024, the licensee was unable to practice more than 30 consecutive business days due to at least one of the following circumstances:(A)The pregnancy of the licensee.(B)The pregnancy of the married spouse of the licensee.(C)The pregnancy of the domestic partner who is in a civil union with the licensee.(D)Delay caused by the credentialing process of health plans.(E)Delay caused by the visa application and review process by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.(2)For a licensee to be eligible for an extension under this subdivision, both of the following shall be submitted to the Medical Board of California no later than January 30, 2024:(A)A declaration signed by the licensee under penalty of perjury and supporting documentation demonstrating that the licensee meets the requirements of this subdivision.(B)A request for the extension from the chief executive officer of the community health center who employs the licensee.(3)If the Medical Board of California determines that the requirements of this subdivision have been satisfied for a licensee, it may grant a one-time extension for the timeframe in which the licensee was unable to work.(4)An extension granted pursuant to this subdivision shall not extend the license period by more than one year or beyond September 30, 2026, whichever is sooner, and shall be dependent upon the program having sufficient funding appropriated in the annual Budget Act.(k)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.(l)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted jointly by one medical school and one dental school in California and either UNAM or a foreign dental school approved by the Dental Board of California, in consultation with the Medical Board of California. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:(1)Quality of care provided by doctors and dentists licensed under this pilot program.(2)Adaptability of these licensed practitioners to California medical and dental standards.(3)Impact on working and administrative environment in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.(4)Response and approval by patients.(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.(m)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.(n)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.SEC. 3.Article 2.7 (commencing with Section 1645.4) is added to Chapter 4 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:2.7.Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program1645.4.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Dental Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
(b)The Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program is hereby created.
(c)(1)This program continues the dentist component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)(1)Each dentist from Mexico who is eligible to participate in this program shall comply with the requirements specified in subparagraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, or the requirements contained in paragraph (2):
(A)Be a graduate from the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(B)Meet all criteria required for licensure in Mexico that is required and being applied by the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia), including, but not limited to:
(i)A minimum grade point average.
(ii)A specified English language comprehension and conversational level.
(iii)Passage of a general examination.
(iv)Passage of an oral interview.
(C)Enroll and complete an orientation program that focuses on the following:
(i)Practical issues in pharmacology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ii)Practical issues and diagnosis in oral pathology that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iii)Clinical applications that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(iv)Biomedical sciences that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(v)Clinical history management that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vi)Special patient care that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(vii)Sedation techniques that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(viii)Infection control guidelines that shall be taught by an instructor who is affiliated with a California dental school approved by the board.
(ix)Introduction to health care systems in California.
(x)Introduction to community clinic operations.
(2)(A)Graduate within the three-year period before enrollment in the program, from a foreign dental school that has received provisional approval or certification by November 2003 from the board under the Foreign Dental School Approval Program.
(B)Enroll and satisfactorily complete an orientation program that focuses on the health care system and community clinic operations in California.
(C)Enroll and satisfactorily complete a course taught by an approved foreign dental school on infection control approved by the board.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion to a competency level of the requirements in paragraph (1) or (2), each dentist participating in the program shall be eligible to obtain employment in a nonprofit community health center pursuant to subdivision (f) within the structure of an extramural dental program for a period not to exceed three years.
(4)Dentists participating in the program shall be required to complete the necessary continuing education units required by this chapter.
(5)The program shall accept 30 participating dentists. The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program applicants. If an active program participant leaves the program for any reason, a participating dentist from the alternate list shall be chosen to fill the vacancy. Only active program participants shall be required to complete the orientation program specified in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1).
(6)(A)Additionally, an extramural dental facility may be identified, qualified, and approved by the board as an adjunct to, and an extension of, the clinical and laboratory departments of an approved dental school.
(B)As used in this subdivision, extramural dental facility includes, but is not limited to, any clinical facility linked to an approved dental school for the purposes of monitoring or overseeing the work of a dentist licensed in Mexico participating in this program and that is employed by an approved dental school for instruction in dentistry that exists outside or beyond the walls, boundaries, or precincts of the primary campus of the approved dental school, and in which dental services are rendered. These facilities shall include nonprofit community health centers.
(C)Dental services provided to the public in these facilities shall constitute a part of the dental education program.
(D)Approved dental schools shall register extramural dental facilities with the board. This registration shall be accompanied by information supplied by the dental school pertaining to faculty supervision, scope of treatment to be rendered, arrangements for postoperative care, the name and location of the facility, the date operations shall commence at the facility, and a description of the equipment and facilities available. This information shall be supplemented with a copy of the agreement between the approved dental school and the affiliated institution establishing the contractual relationship. Any change in the information initially provided to the board shall be communicated to the board.
(7)The program shall also include issues dealing with program operations, and shall be developed in consultation with representatives of community clinics, approved dental schools, or the National Autonomous University of Mexico School of Faculty Dentistry (Facultad de Odontologia).
(8)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and the evaluation required pursuant to subdivision (j). The board shall consult with dental schools in California that have applied for funding to implement and evaluate this program and executive and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, as it conducts its oversight responsibilities of this program and evaluation. Implementation of this program may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall report to the Legislature every January during which the program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
(f)Nonprofit community health centers that employ participants shall be responsible for ensuring that participants are enrolled in local English-language instruction programs and that the participants attain English-language fluency at a level that would allow the participants to serve the English-speaking patient population when necessary and have the literacy level to communicate with appropriate hospital staff when necessary.
(g)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year nonrenewable dental permit shall be five hundred forty-eight dollars ($548). A permitholder shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the permitholder employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year nonrenewable permit shall be deemed to be a permit in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs.
(h)The three-year nonrenewable permit shall terminate upon notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the permitholders address of record, if, in the board's sole discretion, it has determined that either:
(1)The permit was issued by mistake.
(2)A complaint has been received by either board against the permitholder that warrants terminating the permit pending an investigation and resolution of the complaint.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical and dental practitioners from Mexico participating in this pilot program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Beginning 12 months after this pilot program has commenced, an evaluation of the program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations. The evaluation shall be conducted by one dental school in California and either the National Autonomous University of Mexico or a foreign dental school approved by board. If the evaluation required pursuant to this section does not begin within 15 months after the pilot project has commenced, the evaluation may be performed by an independent consultant selected by the Director of Consumer Affairs. This evaluation shall include, but not be limited to, the following issues and concerns:
(1)Quality of care provided by dentists under this pilot program.
(2)Adaptability of these practitioners to California dental standards.
(3)Impact on working and administrative environments in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
(4)Response and approval by patients.
(5)Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
(6)Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
(7)Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
(8)Progress reports on available data listed shall be provided to the Legislature on achievable time intervals beginning in the second year of implementation of this pilot program. An interim final report shall be issued three months before termination of this pilot program. A final report shall be submitted to the Legislature at the time of termination of this pilot program on all of the above-described data. The final report shall reflect and include how other initiatives concerning the development of culturally and linguistically competent medical and dental providers within California and the United States are impacting communities in need of these health care providers.
(k)Costs for administering this pilot program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(l)Program applicants shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
SEC. 4.Article 6 (commencing with Section 2125) is added to Chapter 5 of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, to read:6.Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program2125.(a)For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(1)Board means the Medical Board of California.
(2)Program means the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program.
(b)(1)The Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program is hereby created.
(2)The board shall provide oversight review of the implementation of this program and shall approve physician candidates from Mexico for program participation.
(c)(1)This program extends the physician component of the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, as established in former Section 853, which authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology from Mexico to practice medicine in California for a period not to exceed three years.
(2)The program shall also maintain an alternate list of program participants.
(d)The board shall issue a three-year license to practice medicine to each licensed physician from Mexico who meets the criteria set forth in this section.
(e)Each physician from Mexico, to be eligible to participate in this program, shall comply with all of the following:
(1)Be licensed, certified or recertified, and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico. This certification or recertification shall be performed, as appropriate, by the Consejo Mexicano de Ginecologia y Obstetricia, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Medicina Familiar, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Medicina Interna, A.C., the Consejo Mexicano de Certificacion en Pediatria, A.C., or the Consejo Mexicano de Psiquiatria, AC.
(2)Before leaving Mexico, have completed all of the following requirements:
(A)Passed the board review course with a score equivalent to that registered by United States applicants when passing a board review course for the United States certification examination in each of the physicians specialty areas and passed an interview examination developed by the National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) for each specialty area. Each family practitioner who includes obstetrics and gynecology in their practice and shall not perform deliveries in California unless they have performed 50 live birth deliveries, as required by United States standards, confirmed by written documentation by the supervising department chair, hospital administrator, or hospital chief medical officer. Each obstetrician and gynecologist from Mexico shall be a fellow in good standing of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
(B)(i)Satisfactorily completed an orientation program that includes medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. This orientation program shall be approved by the board to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable.
(ii)Satisfactorily completed the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the board.
(C)(i)Representatives from the UNAM in Mexico and a medical school in good standing or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California shall confer to develop a mutually agreed-upon distant learning program for the orientation program required pursuant to subparagraph (B).
(ii)The representatives from UNAM that executed and implemented the provisions of the former Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall be the points of contact involved in securing required documents, recruiting and vetting candidates, and assisting candidates for this program in Mexico to meet all program requirements.
(3)Upon satisfactory completion of the requirements in paragraphs (1) and (2), and after having received their three-year medical license, each physician shall be required to obtain continuing education pursuant to Section 2190. Each physician shall obtain 25 continuing education units per year for three years of program participation, which shall be subject to random audits to ensure compliance.
(4)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with the University of California at San Francisco (UCSF) School of Medicine to have UCSF conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter, and the reviews shall be transmitted to UCSF in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken the fourth, eighth, and twelfth month of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. UCSF faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, and obstetrics and gynecology shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. UCSF faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the three months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of UCSF secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the UCSF secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro-rata basis.
(5)The federally qualified health centers employing physicians in the program shall be required to have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by The Joint Commission or have protocols similar to those required by The Joint Commission. These protocols shall be submitted to the board prior to the hiring of physicians.
(6)Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this three-year pilot program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico.
(7)Any funding necessary for the implementation of the program and oversight functions shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Implementation of this program shall not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. The board shall, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for this program.
(8)For purposes of this program, the fee for a three-year license to practice medicine shall be ______________ dollars ($____). A licensee shall practice only in the nonprofit community health center that offered the licensee employment and the corresponding hospital. This three-year license shall be deemed to be a license in good standing pursuant to the provisions of this chapter for the purpose of participation and reimbursement in all federal, state, and local health programs. These programs shall include the Medicare Program, the fee-for-service and managed care delivery systems of the Medi-Cal program, and private insurance. A physician from Mexico shall not be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in this state program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. The three-year medical license issued pursuant to this program shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the board applies.
(f)(1)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, of Section 30, the board shall issue a three-year license pursuant to this section to an applicant who has not provided an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if the board staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program pursuant to this section, subject to all of the following conditions:
(A)The applicant shall immediately seek both an appropriate three-year visa and the accompanying social security number from the United States government within 14 days of being issued a medical license under this section.
(B)The applicant shall immediately provide to the board a social security number obtained in accordance with subparagraph (A) within 10 days of the federal government issuing the social security card related to the issued visa.
(C)The applicant shall not engage in the practice of medicine pursuant to this section until the board determines that the conditions in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been met.
(2)The board, if it determines that an applicant has met the conditions in paragraph (1), shall notify the applicant that the applicant may engage in the practice of medicine under the license in accordance with this section.
(g)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, the board may extend the three-year license period if, before January 30, 2024, the licensee was unable to practice more than 30 consecutive business days due to at least one of the following circumstances:
(A)The pregnancy of the licensee.
(B)The pregnancy of the married spouse of the licensee.
(C)The pregnancy of the domestic partner who is in a civil union with the licensee.
(D)Delay caused by the credentialing process of health plans.
(E)Delay caused by the visa application and review process by the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.
(2)For a licensee to be eligible for an extension under this subdivision, both of the following shall be submitted to the board no later than January 30, 2024:
(A)A declaration signed by the licensee under penalty of perjury and supporting documentation demonstrating that the licensee meets the requirements of this subdivision.
(B)A request for the extension from the chief executive officer of the community health center who employs the licensee.
(3)If the board determines that the requirements of this subdivision have been satisfied for a licensee, it may grant a one-time extension for the timeframe in which the licensee was unable to work.
(4)An extension granted pursuant to this subdivision shall not extend the license period by more than one year or beyond September 30, 2026, whichever is sooner, and shall be dependent upon the program having sufficient funding appropriated in the annual Budget Act.
(h)(1)(A)Commencing January 1, 2025, the board shall permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a three-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the pilot program, as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), to extend their license for three years on a one-time basis.
(B)Commencing January 1, 2025, the board shall permit no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico to participate in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists. Each additional physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(C)Commencing January 1, 2029, the board shall permit no more than 145 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(D)Commencing January 1, 2033, the board shall permit no more than 175 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(E)Commencing January 1, 2037, the board shall permit no more than 210 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(F)Commencing January 1, 2041, the board shall permit no more than 220 licensed physicians to participate in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists. Each physician selected for the program pursuant to this subparagraph shall not be eligible to renew their three-year license.
(2)A physicians eligibility pursuant to paragraph (1) is subject to the physician complying with all of the requirements set forth in this section.
(i)All applicable employment benefits, salary, and policies provided by nonprofit community health centers to their current employees shall be provided to medical practitioners from Mexico participating in this program. This shall include nonprofit community health centers providing malpractice insurance coverage.
(j)Costs for administering the program shall be secured from philanthropic entities.
(k)Each program applicant shall be responsible for working with the governments of Mexico and the United States in order to obtain the necessary three-year visa required for program participation.
(l)The board shall work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing all required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the former Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and worked in the placement of physicians in federally qualified health centers that participated in the pilot program.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique and immediate need for physicians and dentists in California that have the cultural competency, language fluency, and requisite expertise to treat the large Latino patient population.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 246, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 14, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 5, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 77. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 28 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 13, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 12, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 25, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 18, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (June 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 29, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E. D. |
| May 15, 2024 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E. D. |
| May 2, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 2, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 5077.) |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | From Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (April 17). |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (April 2). |
| Mar 4, 2024 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 27, 2024 | AB 2860 Garcia Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 26, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2860 Garcia et al. By Hurtado | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 10, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2024 | AB 2860 Garcia Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2024 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Alameda Health Consortium | ** Support | |
| AltaMed Health Services | ** Support | |
| Altura Centers For Health | ** Support | |
| Arroyo Vista Family Health Center | ** Support | |
| CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates | ** Support | |
| California Medical Association | ** Support | |
| California Primary Care Association | ** Support | |
| Clinica De Salud Del Valle De Salinas | ** Support | |
| Clinica Monsenor Oscar A. Romero | ** Support | |
| Communicare+OLE | ** Support | |
| Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County | ** Support | |
| Community Health Partnership | ** Support | |
| Community Health Systems, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Comprehensive Community Health Centers | ** Support | |
| CPCA Advocates | ** Support | |
| Dientes Community Dental | ** Support | |
| Eisner Health | ** Support | |
| El Proyecto del Barrio, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Family Health Centers of San Diego | ** Support | |
| Golden Valley Health Centers | ** Support | |
| Gracelight Community Health | ** Support | |
| Health Alliance of Northern California | ** Support | |
| Health and Life Organization | ** Support | |
| Health Center Partners of Southern California | ** Support | |
| Health Net of California | ** Support | |
| Hill Country Community Clinic | ** Support | |
| La Clinica de la Raza | ** Support | |
| Lifelong Medical Care | ** Support | |
| Local Health Plans Of California | ** Support | |
| Medical Board of California | ** Support | |
| National Hispanic Health Foundation | ** Support | |
| Neighborhood Healthcare | ** Support | |
| North Coast Clinics Network | ** Support | |
| Petaluma Health Center | ** Support | |
| Redwoods Rural Health Center | ** Support | |
| SAC Health | ** Support | |
| San Benito Health Foundation | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium | ** Support | |
| Share Our Selves | ** Support | |
| Shasta Community Health Center | ** Support | |
| South Central Family Health Center | ** Support | |
| The Children's Clinic | ** Support | |
| TrueCare | ** Support | |
| Valley Community Healthcare | ** Support | |
| West County Health Centers | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2860
Author:(Garcia)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Reestablishes the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program as the distinct Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and revises various requirements contained within the existing pilot program relating to the temporary state licensure of medical professionals from Mexico.
Senate Amendments
- Establish the fees charged to participants in the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program that are consistent with fees charged to other licensed physicians in California.
- Restructure the calculation of how many licensed physicians from Mexico may be authorized to practice in California in each of the established periods of time.
- Replace language specifying that federally qualified health centers must work with the University of San Francisco to instead require that they work with an unspecified approved medical school or institution.
- Make various additional technical and conforming changes to clarify implementation by the Medical Board of California (MBC).
COMMENTS
Mexico Pilot Program. The concept of allowing physicians from Mexico to temporarily practice in California was purportedly first proposed in 1998 by board members at the Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS), an FQHC in Monterey County. As described in reporting by the CHCF, "the clinic was having a hard time finding enough physicians to work in Salinas, let alone doctors who spoke Spanish and understood the culture." CSVS's chief executive officer worked with a policy consultant to develop and advocate for the proposal, which reportedly received "pushback from some California medical school officials, physicians, and the California Medical Association."
In 2001, Assemblymember Marco A. Firebaugh introduced Assembly Bill 1045, sponsored by the California Hispanic Health Care Association. The bill was amended in May 2002 to reflect language proposed to the Subcommittee of a Task Force on Culturally and Linguistically Competent Physicians and Dentists. By the time AB 1045 was heard by the Senate Committee on Business and Professions in August 2002, it had been amended several additional times but was still formally opposed by the California Medical Association, the California Dental Association, and the Federation of State Medical Boards, all of whom raised concerns that the proposed pilot program could result in undertrained, lower quality health care providers being allowed to practice in California. The committee analysis noted that further amendments were needed to clarify the author's intent and resolve outstanding questions about how the program would be implemented.
Despite the bill's opposition, AB 1045 passed the Legislature and was signed into law by Governor Gray Davis on September 30, 2002. The bill repealed the statute establishing the Subcommittee and established the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. The bill allowed up to 30 physicians and 30 dentists from Mexico to participate in the program for three-year periods—a compromise from the 150 physicians and 100 dentists that were previously proposed. Participants in the pilot program were required to hold a license in good standing in Mexico, pass a board review course, complete a six-month orientation program, and enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. The bill additionally required the MBC and Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight, in consultation with other entities, to provide oversight of these entities and submit reports to the Legislature.
While AB 1045 was enacted in 2002, its vision was not effectuated for over two decades. This substantial delay is attributable to several factors. First, the bill required that the pilot program could only be implemented "if the necessary amount of nonstate resources are obtained" and that "General Fund moneys shall not be used for these programs." Sponsors of the bill would have to secure private philanthropic donations to fund the pilot program. Additionally, the bill required the identification of medical schools and hospitals that would accept foreign physicians, which was reportedly a challenging task.
Supporters of the pilot program ultimately succeeded in overcoming the administrative hurdles to implementing AB 1045. Philanthropic dollars were collected and placed into a Special Deposit Fund to support the MBC's implementation of the bill, with $333,000 from that fund appropriated in the Budget Act of 2020. Similar funding has continued to be appropriated in subsequent budget bills, with an estimated $498,000 in philanthropic funds appropriated in Fiscal Year 2023-24 and $299,000 appropriated in Fiscal Year 2024-25.
Physicians from Mexico finally started serving patients under the pilot program in August 2021, beginning with physicians working at San Benito Health Foundation in August 2021. Additional physicians subsequently began serving patients at CSVS in Monterey County, Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County. From January to November 2023, additional licensed physicians from Mexico began serving patients in the Alta Med Health Corporation in Los Angeles and Orange Counties.
The first annual progress report on the pilot program, submitted to the Legislature by the University of California, Davis in August of 2022, found that many patients had positive experiences with physicians practicing through the pilot program. In particular, patients reportedly had substantially positive experiences communicating with their doctor, and frequently felt welcome. While the overall efficacy of the pilot program was still under review, initial reports appeared positive.
UC Davis submitted its second annual progress report on the pilot program to the Legislature in October of 2023. As stated in the report summary, the goal of the evaluation was to provide recommendations on the pilot program and opine on "whether it should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated." The report summary concluded with a finding that the pilot program "has strong positive feedback from all. Physicians integrated seamlessly, making healthcare more accessible, and increasing patient trust. Staff reported excellent patient care processes and a supportive environment." The report further concluded that physicians in the program "demonstrated a solid understanding of California Medical Standards."
With early assessments of the pilot program producing undeniably positive findings, the original supporters of AB 1045 now believe it is appropriate to revise and expand the program from the version that was negotiated back in 2001. To begin with, the bill would extend the licenses of physicians currently participating in the pilot program by an additional three years. This will allow those physicians who have been successfully evaluated to continue serving patients and compensate for opportunities to serve patients that were lost due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Next, this bill would revise the requirements that physicians from Mexico must meet both prior to coming to California and upon arrival. First, this bill would remove the requirement that participants in the pilot program complete a six-month externship after receiving their license. Additionally, this bill replaces the requirement that the orientation program for physicians be six months with a more general requirement that does not specify a length of time. The bill also adds training on electronic medical records systems and medical record documentation standards to the list of subjects that must be included in that orientation.
Current law also requires physicians from Mexico to enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. This bill would remove that requirement and instead require that participants complete the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the MBC. This bill would then statutorily reestablish the program for physicians from Mexico and change its title to no longer refer to a "pilot program." The newly codified Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program would then gradually expand over the next fifteen years, with increases every four years pursuant to a specified schedule.
This bill would then reestablish the component of the prior pilot program relating to dentists from Mexico as the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. To date, no dentists from Mexico have been able to participate in the pilot program, with supporters of the program prioritizing physicians in the early stages of implementation. The intent of the author and sponsors of this bill is to begin the process of allowing dentists to participate in a recodified pilot program within the Dental Practice Act.
With the above provisions, among other less significant changes, the pilot program will be significantly expanded from its inceptive form under AB 1045. The primary care access crisis has only grown more apparent over the past two decades, with even greater attention afforded to the stark health care inequities in California communities. It can also be argued that there is now less instinctive skepticism of immigrant professionals than there was when AB 1045 was negotiated, particularly given the cultural and linguistic competence that providers from Mexico inherently offer. The Legislature may therefore consider it to now be the appropriate time to expand the pilot program and allow it to fulfill the vision originally conceived by its creators.
According to the Author
"Perhaps the most urgent matter confronting the health care of our state and nation is ensuring that we have an adequate supply of doctors available to serve the diversity of our state and nation's population. The shortage of physicians has only increased since 2000. AB 2860 addresses this serious structural and institutional problem by increasing the number of doctors from Mexico; the previous pilot program, in 2002, allowed them to practice in California. AB 2860 increases physicians from Mexico from 30 to 125 beginning in 2025 and increases medical providers by 30 to 40 every three years until 2041. We will have substantially more culturally, and linguistically competent doctors create access and serve patients in California. This program is the only program of its type and purpose in the nation. UC Davis School of Medicine's 2nd annual evaluation of this program, issued in October 2023, found that the program had '…strong feedback from all, health care is more accessible, patient trust has increased, and Mexican physicians demonstrate a solid understanding of California Medical Standards.'"
Arguments in Support
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS) is co-sponsoring this bill. CSVS writes: "Through our active participation in the Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program, we have witnessed firsthand the profound impact that these dedicated professionals have made in our service areas. From their arrival in CY 2022 to December 2023, our physicians had a total of 81,587 patient visits. In addition to this increase in patient visits, all eleven physicians have proven to be culturally responsive to the needs of our patients. They have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient's treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness."
The advocacy affiliate of the California Primary Care Association (CPCA) is also co-sponsoring this bill, writing: "Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need. As the committee well knows, the physician shortage, particularly in rural and underserved communities, is at a critical point; efforts to bring in highly trained physicians from Mexico to provide care in disenfranchised communities must be prioritized."
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
Pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Berman, Flora, Alanis, Bains, Juan Carrillo, Chen, Dixon, Grayson, Irwin, Jackson, Low, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Pellerin, Sanchez, Soria, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0-5
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon, Megan Dahle, Flora, Low, Mathis
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED
VERSION: August 19, 2024
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0004737
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2860 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2860
Author: Garcia (D), et al.
Amended: 8/19/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 12-0, 6/10/24
AYES: Ashby, Nguyen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Menjivar, Niello, Roth, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Smallwood-Cuevas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/2/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico programs
SOURCE: California Primary Care Association
Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas
DIGEST:
This bill recasts the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Pilot Program) as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act and makes various updates and conforming changes.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/19/24 require the Medical Board of California (MBC) and Dental Board of California (DBC) to issue a license to a Mexico Physicians or Mexico Dentists Program applicants if they otherwise meet eligibility requirements but do not have a taxpayer identification number or social security number and make other conforming changes.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/12/24 make various technical and conforming changes to assist with implementation pursuant to discussions with the Medical Board of California.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Mexico Pilot Program to allow up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology who are certified or recertified and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico, and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for three years according to certain requirements. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 853).
- Specifies that physician program participants, prior to leaving Mexico, must complete a six-month orientation program which addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, and pharmacology differences. Requires National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) and a medical school in good standing, or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California, to confer to develop a mutually agreed upon distant learning program for the six-month orientation. Requires MBC to approve the orientation to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable. (BPC §§ 853(c)(2)(B)(i) and 853 (c)(2)(C)).
- Authorizes physician applicants to receive a three-year nonrenewable license to work in nonprofit community health centers and requires them to participate in a six-month externship at their place of employment. Specifies that the externship commences after licensure, that the externship ensures the participant is complying with the established standards for quality assurance of nonprofit community health centers and medical practices, and that the externship be affiliated with a medical school in good standing in California. Specifies that nonprofit community health centers employing physician program participants must have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (Joint Commission) or have protocols similar to those required by the Joint Commission. Requires protocols to be submitted to MBC prior to the hiring of physicians. (BPC §§ 853 (c)(4) and 853 (c)(6)).
- Requires MBC and the Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight review of program implementation. Requires MBC and DBC to consult with the medical schools and dental schools applying for funding to implement and evaluate this program, executive and medical and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, and for MBC, hospital administrators who will have these participants practicing in their hospital. Requires MBC and DBC to report to the Legislature every January during which the Mexico Pilot Program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. (BPC § 853 (c)(8) and BPC § 853 (d)(8))
- Specifies that any funding necessary for the implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC, including the evaluation and oversight functions, shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Specifies that implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Authorizes MBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities and, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for the Mexico Pilot Program. Authorizes DBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. (Id.)
- Authorizes DBC to grant a license to practice dentistry to an applicant who satisfies certain requirements, including a requirement that satisfactory evidence be provided that the applicant has graduated from a dental school approved either by a national accrediting body approved by the DBC or by CODA, a national accreditor established within the American Dental Association. (BPC § 1634.1)
- Requires applicants for physician and surgeon licensure by MBC, who graduated from a MBC approved international medical school, to complete two years of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (U.S.) or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (Canada) accredited postgraduate training. (BPC § 2096).
This bill:
- Recasts the Mexico Pilot Program as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act.
- Deletes a prescribed length for the orientation program participants in the Mexico Physicians Program must complete prior to coming to California and updates required curriculum to include: medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. Deletes the requirement under current law that the curriculum include pharmacology differences.
- Updates the requirement under current law for physicians in the Mexico Physicians Program to enroll in ESL classes and instead requires individuals to provide documentation to MBC that they scored 85 percent on the Test of English as a Foreign Language or 350 on the Occupational English Test.
- Updates the fee schedule for participants.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Updates authority for participating hospitals to establish criteria necessary to allow Mexico Physician Program participants to have hospital privileges by specifying that they take into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by FQHCs and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
- Specifies that a physician from Mexico cannot be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in the Mexico Physicians Program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. Specifies that a Mexico Physicians Program participant’s license must be referred to as a “Physician’s and Surgeon’s from Mexico License” and must not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that MBC applies.
- Allows the number of physicians eligible to participate in the Mexico Physicians Program to increase by specified increments every four years until 2041, when no more than 275 physicians, including up to 40 psychiatrists, may participate.
- Specifies that MBC and DBC must issue a license to a program applicant without an individual taxpayer identification number or social security number if MBC or DBC staff determines the applicant is otherwise eligible for a license only under the program and meets other specific requirements related to obtaining a visa and social security number.
- Makes various findings and declarations about California’s population, the importance of provider-patient communication, primary care and physician shortages in California, and other related topics.
Background
The Mexico Pilot Program, established by AB 1045 (Firebaugh, Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002), was designed to bring physicians and dentists from Mexico with rural experience, who speak the language, understand the culture, and know how to apply this knowledge in serving the large Latino communities in rural areas who have limited or no access to primary health care services. Proponents of the measure were concerned about addressing primary care physician and dentist shortages while maintaining a high quality of care.
The bill authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for up to three years, and required the individuals to meet certain requirements related to training and education.
AB 1045 tasked MBC with oversight review of both the implementation of the program and an evaluation of the program once it is implemented. The bill specified that any funding necessary for the implementation of the program, including the evaluation and oversight functions, was to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities and further stated that implementation of the program could not move forward unless appropriate funding was secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
Program participants are required to undergo a six-month orientation program approved by MBC that addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices and pharmacology differences.
MBC received the necessary philanthropic funding in 2018 to initiate the program and began taking the necessary steps for implementation. As of April 2019, MBC began accepting applications for the Mexico Pilot Program. MBC received the required funding commitments necessary for program implementation in December 2020. Mexico Pilot Program physicians are authorized to practice in the following MBC-approved community health clinics: Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas in Monterey County; San Benito Health Foundation in San Benito County; Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County and; AltaMed Health Services Corporation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Primary Care Association (co-source)
Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas (co-source)
Alameda Health Consortium
AltaMed Health Services
Altura Centers for Health
Arroyo Vista Family Health Center
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
California Medical Association
Clinica Monseñor Oscar A. Romero
CommuniCare+OLE
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Community Health Partnership
Community Health Systems, Inc.
Comprehensive Community Health Centers
CPCA Advocates
Dientes Community Dental
Eisner Health
El Proyecto Del Barrio, INC.
Family Health Centers of San Diego
Golden Valley Health Centers
Gracelight Community Health
Health Alliance of Northern California
Health and Life Organization (Sacramento Community Clinics)
Health Center Partners of Southern California
Health Net of California
Hill Country Community Clinic
La Clinica De La Raza
Lifelong Medical Care
Local Health Plans of California
National Hispanic Health Foundation
Neighborhood Healthcare
North Coast Clinics Network
Petaluma Health Center
Redwoods Rural Health Center
Sac Health
San Benito Health Foundation
San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium
Share Our Selves
Shasta Community Health Center
South Central Family Health Center
The Children's Clinic
Truecare
Valley Community Healthcare
West County Health Centers
9 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/24)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to AltaMed, “The Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program established under AB 1045 has been instrumental in addressing this shortage by allowing 30 doctors from Mexico to practice medicine in California's federally funded community health centers. Effective December 2023, AltaMed has successfully implemented the Mexico Pilot Program with placement of 7 physicians from Mexico at our clinics. Data shows that from August 2021 to September 2023, 22 of the 30 doctors from Mexico allowed to practice medicine in California under AB 1045 provided 118,498 medical encounters to more than 36,000 patients at four community health centers. Access to comprehensive primary healthcare services has increased significantly in the communities where these doctors are practicing.”
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas notes an increase in patient visits as a result of participation in the Mexico Pilot Program and writes that physicians “have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient’s treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness. The confidence that patients have acquired as a result of this program underscores the importance of the contributions these doctors are making to provide access to medical care for many who have not had this access…without the [Mexico Pilot Program], CSVS would have continued to face significant challenges in meeting the healthcare needs of our community.”
Supporters write that while California must do more to address the physician shortage, this bill takes one approach to temporarily resolve the issue. They argue that this bill seeks to expand the existing program, over 15 years, to bring nearly 1000 physicians to California on one-time, three-year licenses. These physicians would join community health centers and clinics throughout the state to serve populations of need, focusing primarily on migrant farmworker, underserved Latinx and rural communities. Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/2/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Megan Dahle, Flora, Low, Mathis
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
8/20/24 16:11:14
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2860 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2860
Author: Garcia (D), et al.
Amended: 8/12/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 12-0, 6/10/24
AYES: Ashby, Nguyen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Menjivar, Niello, Roth, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Smallwood-Cuevas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/2/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico programs
SOURCE: California Primary Care Association
Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas
DIGEST:
This bill recasts the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Pilot Program) as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act and makes various updates and conforming changes.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/12/24 make various technical and conforming changes to assist with implementation pursuant to discussions with the Medical Board of California.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Mexico Pilot Program to allow up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology who are certified or recertified and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico, and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for three years according to certain requirements. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 853).
- Specifies that physician program participants, prior to leaving Mexico, must complete a six-month orientation program which addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, and pharmacology differences. Requires National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) and a medical school in good standing, or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California, to confer to develop a mutually agreed upon distant learning program for the six-month orientation. Requires MBC to approve the orientation to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable. (BPC §§ 853(c)(2)(B)(i) and 853 (c)(2)(C)).
- Authorizes physician applicants to receive a three-year nonrenewable license to work in nonprofit community health centers and requires them to participate in a six-month externship at their place of employment. Specifies that the externship commences after licensure, that the externship ensures the participant is complying with the established standards for quality assurance of nonprofit community health centers and medical practices, and that the externship be affiliated with a medical school in good standing in California. Specifies that nonprofit community health centers employing physician program participants must have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (Joint Commission) or have protocols similar to those required by the Joint Commission. Requires protocols to be submitted to MBC prior to the hiring of physicians. (BPC §§ 853 (c)(4) and 853 (c)(6)).
- Requires MBC and the Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight review of program implementation. Requires MBC and DBC to consult with the medical schools and dental schools applying for funding to implement and evaluate this program, executive and medical and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, and for MBC, hospital administrators who will have these participants practicing in their hospital. Requires MBC and DBC to report to the Legislature every January during which the Mexico Pilot Program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. (BPC § 853 (c)(8) and BPC § 853 (d)(8))
- Specifies that any funding necessary for the implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC, including the evaluation and oversight functions, shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Specifies that implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Authorizes MBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities and, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for the Mexico Pilot Program. Authorizes DBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. (Id.)
- Authorizes DBC to grant a license to practice dentistry to an applicant who satisfies certain requirements, including a requirement that satisfactory evidence be provided that the applicant has graduated from a dental school approved either by a national accrediting body approved by the DBC or by CODA, a national accreditor established within the American Dental Association. (BPC § 1634.1)
- Requires applicants for physician and surgeon licensure by MBC, who graduated from a MBC approved international medical school, to complete two years of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (U.S.) or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (Canada) accredited postgraduate training. (BPC § 2096).
This bill:
- Recasts the Mexico Pilot Program as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act.
- Deletes a prescribed length for the orientation program participants in the Mexico Physicians Program must complete prior to coming to California and updates required curriculum to include: medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. Deletes the requirement under current law that the curriculum include pharmacology differences.
- Updates the requirement under current law for physicians in the Mexico Physicians Program to enroll in ESL classes and instead requires individuals to provide documentation to MBC that they scored 85 percent on the Test of English as a Foreign Language or 350 on the Occupational English Test.
- Updates the fee schedule for Mexico Physician Program participants.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Updates authority for participating hospitals to establish criteria necessary to allow Mexico Physician Program participants to have hospital privileges by specifying that they take into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by FQHCs and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
- Specifies that a physician from Mexico cannot be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in the Mexico Physicians Program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. Specifies that a Mexico Physicians Program participant’s license must be referred to as a “Physician’s and Surgeon’s from Mexico License” and must not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that MBC applies.
- Allows the number of physicians eligible to participate in the Mexico Physicians Program to increase by specified increments every four years until 2041, when no more than 275 physicians, including up to 40 psychiatrists, may participate.
- Makes various findings and declarations about California’s population, the importance of provider-patient communication, primary care and physician shortages in California, and other related topics.
Background
The Mexico Pilot Program, established by AB 1045 (Firebaugh, Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002), was designed to bring physicians and dentists from Mexico with rural experience, who speak the language, understand the culture, and know how to apply this knowledge in serving the large Latino communities in rural areas who have limited or no access to primary health care services. Proponents of the measure were concerned about addressing primary care physician and dentist shortages while maintaining a high quality of care.
The bill authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for up to three years, and required the individuals to meet certain requirements related to training and education.
AB 1045 tasked MBC with oversight review of both the implementation of the program and an evaluation of the program once it is implemented. The bill specified that any funding necessary for the implementation of the program, including the evaluation and oversight functions, was to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities and further stated that implementation of the program could not move forward unless appropriate funding was secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
Program participants are required to undergo a six-month orientation program approved by MBC that addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices and pharmacology differences.
MBC received the necessary philanthropic funding in 2018 to initiate the program and began taking the necessary steps for implementation. As of April 2019, MBC began accepting applications for the Mexico Pilot Program. MBC received the required funding commitments necessary for program implementation in December 2020. Mexico Pilot Program physicians are authorized to practice in the following MBC-approved community health clinics: Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas in Monterey County; San Benito Health Foundation in San Benito County; Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County and; AltaMed Health Services Corporation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/8/24)
California Primary Care Association (co-source)
Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas (co-source)
Alameda Health Consortium
AltaMed Health Services
Altura Centers for Health
Arroyo Vista Family Health Center
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
California Medical Association
Clinica Monseñor Oscar A. Romero
CommuniCare+OLE
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Community Health Partnership
Community Health Systems, Inc.
Comprehensive Community Health Centers
CPCA Advocates
Dientes Community Dental
Eisner Health
El Proyecto Del Barrio, INC.
Family Health Centers of San Diego
Golden Valley Health Centers
Gracelight Community Health
Health Alliance of Northern California
Health and Life Organization (Sacramento Community Clinics)
Health Center Partners of Southern California
Health Net of California
Hill Country Community Clinic
La Clinica De La Raza
Lifelong Medical Care
Local Health Plans of California
National Hispanic Health Foundation
Neighborhood Healthcare
North Coast Clinics Network
Petaluma Health Center
Redwoods Rural Health Center
Sac Health
San Benito Health Foundation
San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium
Share Our Selves
Shasta Community Health Center
South Central Family Health Center
The Children's Clinic
Truecare
Valley Community Healthcare
West County Health Centers
9 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/8/24)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to AltaMed, “The Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program established under AB 1045 has been instrumental in addressing this shortage by allowing 30 doctors from Mexico to practice medicine in California's federally funded community health centers. Effective December 2023, AltaMed has successfully implemented the Mexico Pilot Program with placement of 7 physicians from Mexico at our clinics. Data shows that from August 2021 to September 2023, 22 of the 30 doctors from Mexico allowed to practice medicine in California under AB 1045 provided 118,498 medical encounters to more than 36,000 patients at four community health centers. Access to comprehensive primary healthcare services has increased significantly in the communities where these doctors are practicing.”
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas notes an increase in patient visits as a result of participation in the Mexico Pilot Program and writes that physicians “have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient’s treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness. The confidence that patients have acquired as a result of this program underscores the importance of the contributions these doctors are making to provide access to medical care for many who have not had this access…without the [Mexico Pilot Program], CSVS would have continued to face significant challenges in meeting the healthcare needs of our community.”
Supporters write that while California must do more to address the physician shortage, this bill takes one approach to temporarily resolve the issue. They argue that this bill seeks to expand the existing program, over 15 years, to bring nearly 1000 physicians to California on one-time, three-year licenses. These physicians would join community health centers and clinics throughout the state to serve populations of need, focusing primarily on migrant farmworker, underserved Latinx and rural communities. Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/2/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Megan Dahle, Flora, Low, Mathis
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
8/14/24 14:03:12
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2860 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2860
Author: Garcia (D), et al.
Amended: 6/18/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 12-0, 6/10/24
AYES: Ashby, Nguyen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Menjivar, Niello, Roth, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Smallwood-Cuevas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/2/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico programs
SOURCE: California Primary Care Association
Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas
DIGEST:
This bill recasts the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Pilot Program) as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act and makes various updates and conforming changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Mexico Pilot Program to allow up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology who are certified or recertified and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico, and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for three years according to certain requirements. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 853).
- Specifies that physician program participants, prior to leaving Mexico, must complete a six-month orientation program which addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, and pharmacology differences. Requires National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) and a medical school in good standing, or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California, to confer to develop a mutually agreed upon distant learning program for the six-month orientation. Requires MBC to approve the orientation to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable. (BPC §§ 853(c)(2)(B)(i) and 853 (c)(2)(C)).
- Authorizes physician applicants to receive a three-year nonrenewable license to work in nonprofit community health centers and requires them to participate in a six-month externship at their place of employment. Specifies that the externship commences after licensure, that the externship ensures the participant is complying with the established standards for quality assurance of nonprofit community health centers and medical practices, and that the externship be affiliated with a medical school in good standing in California. Specifies that nonprofit community health centers employing physician program participants must have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (Joint Commission) or have protocols similar to those required by the Joint Commission. Requires protocols to be submitted to MBC prior to the hiring of physicians. (BPC §§ 853 (c)(4) and 853 (c)(6)).
- Requires MBC and the Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight review of program implementation. Requires MBC and DBC to consult with the medical schools and dental schools applying for funding to implement and evaluate this program, executive and medical and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, and for MBC, hospital administrators who will have these participants practicing in their hospital. Requires MBC and DBC to report to the Legislature every January during which the Mexico Pilot Program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. (BPC § 853 (c)(8) and BPC § 853 (d)(8))
- Specifies that any funding necessary for the implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC, including the evaluation and oversight functions, shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Specifies that implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Authorizes MBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities and, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for the Mexico Pilot Program. Authorizes DBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. (Id.)
- Authorizes DBC to grant a license to practice dentistry to an applicant who satisfies certain requirements, including a requirement that satisfactory evidence be provided that the applicant has graduated from a dental school approved either by a national accrediting body approved by the DBC or by CODA, a national accreditor established within the American Dental Association. (BPC § 1634.1)
- Requires applicants for physician and surgeon licensure by MBC, who graduated from a MBC approved international medical school, to complete two years of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (U.S.) or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (Canada) accredited postgraduate training. (BPC § 2096).
This bill:
- Recasts the Mexico Pilot Program as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act.
- Deletes a prescribed length for the orientation program participants in the Mexico Physicians Program must complete prior to coming to California and updates required curriculum to include: medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. Deletes the requirement under current law that the curriculum include pharmacology differences.
- Updates the requirement under current law for physicians in the Mexico Physicians Program to enroll in ESL classes and instead requires individuals to provide documentation to MBC that they scored 85 percent on the Test of English as a Foreign Language or 350 on the Occupational English Test.
- Updates the fee schedule for Mexico Physician Program participants.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Updates authority for participating hospitals to establish criteria necessary to allow Mexico Physician Program participants to have hospital privileges by specifying that they take into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by FQHCs and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
- Specifies that a physician from Mexico cannot be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in the Mexico Physicians Program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. Specifies that a Mexico Physicians Program participant’s license must be referred to as a “Physician’s and Surgeon’s from Mexico License” and must not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that MBC applies.
- Allows the number of physicians eligible to participate in the Mexico Physicians Program to increase by specified increments every four years until 2041, when no more than 275 physicians, including up to 40 psychiatrists, may participate.
- Makes various findings and declarations about California’s population, the importance of provider-patient communication, primary care and physician shortages in California, and other related topics.
Background
The Mexico Pilot Program, established by AB 1045 (Firebaugh, Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002), was designed to bring physicians and dentists from Mexico with rural experience, who speak the language, understand the culture, and know how to apply this knowledge in serving the large Latino communities in rural areas who have limited or no access to primary health care services. Proponents of the measure were concerned about addressing primary care physician and dentist shortages while maintaining a high quality of care.
The bill authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for up to three years, and required the individuals to meet certain requirements related to training and education.
AB 1045 tasked MBC with oversight review of both the implementation of the program and an evaluation of the program once it is implemented. The bill specified that any funding necessary for the implementation of the program, including the evaluation and oversight functions, was to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities and further stated that implementation of the program could not move forward unless appropriate funding was secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
Program participants are required to undergo a six-month orientation program approved by MBC that addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices and pharmacology differences.
MBC received the necessary philanthropic funding in 2018 to initiate the program and began taking the necessary steps for implementation. As of April 2019, MBC began accepting applications for the Mexico Pilot Program. MBC received the required funding commitments necessary for program implementation in December 2020. Mexico Pilot Program physicians are authorized to practice in the following MBC-approved community health clinics: Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas in Monterey County; San Benito Health Foundation in San Benito County; Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County and; AltaMed Health Services Corporation
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/24/24)
California Primary Care Association (co-source)
Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas (co-source)
Alameda Health Consortium
AltaMed Health Services
Altura Centers for Health
Arroyo Vista Family Health Center
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
California Medical Association
Clinica Monseñor Oscar A. Romero
CommuniCare+OLE
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Community Health Partnership
Community Health Systems, Inc.
Comprehensive Community Health Centers
CPCA Advocates
Dientes Community Dental
Eisner Health
El Proyecto Del Barrio, INC.
Family Health Centers of San Diego
Golden Valley Health Centers
Gracelight Community Health
Health Alliance of Northern California
Health and Life Organization (Sacramento Community Clinics)
Health Center Partners of Southern California
Health Net of California
Hill Country Community Clinic
La Clinica De La Raza
Lifelong Medical Care
Local Health Plans of California
National Hispanic Health Foundation
Neighborhood Healthcare
North Coast Clinics Network
Petaluma Health Center
Redwoods Rural Health Center
Sac Health
San Benito Health Foundation
San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium
Share Our Selves
Shasta Community Health Center
South Central Family Health Center
The Children's Clinic
Truecare
Valley Community Healthcare
West County Health Centers
Nine individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/24/24)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to AltaMed, “The Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program established under AB 1045 has been instrumental in addressing this shortage by allowing 30 doctors from Mexico to practice medicine in California's federally funded community health centers. Effective December 2023, AltaMed has successfully implemented the Mexico Pilot Program with placement of 7 physicians from Mexico at our clinics. Data shows that from August 2021 to September 2023, 22 of the 30 doctors from Mexico allowed to practice medicine in California under AB 1045 provided 118,498 medical encounters to more than 36,000 patients at four community health centers. Access to comprehensive primary healthcare services has increased significantly in the communities where these doctors are practicing.
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas notes an increase in patient visits as a result of participation in the Mexico Pilot Program and writes that physicians “have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient’s treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness. The confidence that patients have acquired as a result of this program underscores the importance of the contributions these doctors are making to provide access to medical care for many who have not had this access…without the [Mexico Pilot Program], CSVS would have continued to face significant challenges in meeting the healthcare needs of our community.”
Supporters write that While California must do more to address the physician shortage, AB 2860 takes one approach to temporarily resolve the issue. The bill seeks to expand the existing program, over 15 years, to bring nearly 1000 physicians to California on one-time, three-year licenses. These physicians would join community health centers and clinics throughout the state to serve populations of need, focusing primarily on migrant farmworker, underserved Latinx and rural communities. Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/2/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Calderon, Megan Dahle, Flora, Low, Mathis
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
6/25/24 13:11:38
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Angelique Ashby, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 10, 2024
Author: | |||
Version: | May 29, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Recasts the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Pilot Program) as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act and makes various updates and conforming changes.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Mexico Pilot Program to allow up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology who are certified or recertified and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico, and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for three years according to certain requirements. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 853).
- Specifies that physician program participants, prior to leaving Mexico, must complete a six-month orientation program which addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, and pharmacology differences. Requires National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) and a medical school in good standing, or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California, to confer to develop a mutually agreed upon distant learning program for the six-month orientation. Requires MBC to approve the orientation to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable. (BPC §§ 853(c)(2)(B)(i) and 853 (c)(2)(C)).
- Authorizes physician applicants to receive a three-year nonrenewable license to work in nonprofit community health centers and requires them to participate in a six-month externship at their place of employment. Specifies that the externship commences after licensure, that the externship ensures the participant is complying with the established standards for quality assurance of nonprofit community health centers and medical practices, and that the externship be affiliated with a medical school in good standing in California. Specifies that nonprofit community health centers employing physician program participants must have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (Joint Commission) or have protocols similar to those required by the Joint Commission. Requires protocols to be submitted to MBC prior to the hiring of physicians. (BPC §§ 853 (c)(4) and 853 (c)(6)).
- Requires MBC and the Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight review of program implementation. Requires MBC and DBC to consult with the medical schools and dental schools applying for funding to implement and evaluate this program, executive and medical and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, and for MBC, hospital administrators who will have these participants practicing in their hospital. Requires MBC and DBC to report to the Legislature every January during which the Mexico Pilot Program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. (BPC § 853 (c)(8) and BPC § 853 (d)(8))
- Specifies that any funding necessary for the implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC, including the evaluation and oversight functions, shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Specifies that implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Authorizes MBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities and, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for the Mexico Pilot Program. Authorizes DBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. (Id.)
- Authorizes DBC to grant a license to practice dentistry to an applicant who satisfies certain requirements, including a requirement that satisfactory evidence be provided that the applicant has graduated from a dental school approved either by a national accrediting body approved by the DBC or by CODA, a national accreditor established within the American Dental Association. (BPC § 1634.1)
- Requires applicants for physician and surgeon licensure by MBC, who graduated from a MBC approved international medical school, to complete two years of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (U.S.) or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (Canada) accredited postgraduate training. (BPC § 2096).
This bill:
- Recasts the Mexico Pilot Program as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act.
- Deletes a prescribed length for the orientation program participants in the Mexico Physicians Program must complete prior to coming to California and updates required curriculum to include: medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. Deletes the requirement under current law that the curriculum include pharmacology differences.
- Updates the requirement under current law for physicians in the Mexico Physicians Program to enroll in ESL classes and instead requires individuals to provide documentation to MBC that they scored 85 percent on the Test of English as a Foreign Language or 350 on the Occupational English Test.
- Updates the fee schedule for Mexico Physician Program participants.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Updates authority for participating hospitals to establish criteria necessary to allow Mexico Physician Program participants to have hospital privileges by specifying that they take into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by FQHCs and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
- Specifies that a physician from Mexico cannot be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in the Mexico Physicians Program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. Specifies that a Mexico Physicians Program participant’s license must be referred to as a “Physician’s and Surgeon’s from Mexico License” and must not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that MBC applies.
- Allows the number of physicians eligible to participate in the Mexico Physicians Program to increase by specified increments every four years until 2041, when no more than 275 physicians, including up to 40 psychiatrists, may participate.
- Makes various findings and declarations about California’s population, the importance of provider-patient communication, primary care and physician shortages in California, and other related topics.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill is keyed fiscal. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, MBC estimates additional licensing workload of approximately 336 hours for the first three fiscal years, at a cost of $100,000. Costs would be offset by application and licensing fees, assuming each licensee pays an application fee of $647 and licensing fee of $1,726.50. DBC does not anticipate a fiscal impact. DBC has not started the Pilot Program as required funding from philanthropic entities to implement the Pilot Program has not yet materialized and DBC does not anticipate implementation of the Dentists Program. The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) estimates absorbable costs for information services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas and the California Primary Care Association. According to the Author, little progress has been made in reducing the physician shortage in the nation and California and educating and training more ethnic and racial minorities at medical schools. Even less progress has been made in preparing medical students to be culturally and linguistically competent. The Author states, "These realities are taking place at a time when Latinos are now the largest population group in the State of California, and the state has become more ethnically and racially diverse than at any other time in its history. The Author notes that this bill builds on the success of the Mexico Pilot Program by removing the “pilot” status and extending the program for 15 years. According to the Author, “This program will place more physicians and culturally and linguistically competent physicians in communities throughout the state that are federally designated Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSA) (less than one primary care doctor for 3,000 patients in rural areas and 3500 in urban centers). We are placing doctors within one year compared to it taking 10 to 15 years to produce one doctor who may or may not want to work in these HPSA communities and is culturally and linguistically competent.”
- Background. The Mexico Pilot Program, established by AB 1045 (Firebaugh, Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002), was designed to bring physicians and dentists from Mexico with rural experience, who speak the language, understand the culture, and know how to apply this knowledge in serving the large Latino communities in rural areas who have limited or no access to primary health care services. Proponents of the measure were concerned about addressing primary care physician and dentist shortages while maintaining a high quality of care.
The bill authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for up to three years, and required the individuals to meet certain requirements related to training and education.
AB 1045 tasked MBC with oversight review of both the implementation of the program and an evaluation of the program once it is implemented. The bill specified that any funding necessary for the implementation of the program, including the evaluation and oversight functions, was to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities and further stated that implementation of the program could not move forward unless appropriate funding was secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
Program participants are required to undergo a six-month orientation program approved by MBC that addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices and pharmacology differences.
MBC received the necessary philanthropic funding in 2018 to initiate the program and began taking the necessary steps for implementation. As of April 2019, MBC began accepting applications for the Mexico Pilot Program. MBC received the required funding commitments necessary for program implementation in December 2020. Mexico Pilot Program physicians are authorized to practice in the following MBC-approved community health clinics: Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas in Monterey County; San Benito Health Foundation in San Benito County; Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County and; AltaMed Health Services Corporation
In August 2022, the Center for Reducing Health Disparities (CRHD) at the University of California, Davis released its first annual progress report of the Mexico Pilot Program. The initial report covers the two FYs of the Mexico Pilot Program’s operations, FY 20/21 and 21/21 and includes baseline data results in three of the requisite categories. Per BPC Section 853 (j), the evaluation must include, but not be limited to:
- Quality of care provided by doctors and dentists licensed under this pilot program.
- Adaptability of these licensed practitioners to California medical and dental standards.
- Impact on working and administrative environment in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
- Response and approval by patients.
- Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
- Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
- Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
Discussions continue between the original sponsors of AB 1045 who remain supportive of the Mexico Pilot Program’s goals, MBC staff, and CRHD representatives about what context and factors for capturing baseline data should be taken into consideration in order to provide an effective evaluation.
- Arguments in Support. According to AltaMed, “Our healthcare professionals have witnessed firsthand the severe shortage of physicians in many areas of California, particularly in underserved communities. This shortage is even more pronounced among Latino physicians and by the lack of cultural and linguistic competency among healthcare providers, which can make it difficult for patients to access the care they need. We know that patients prefer to see physicians of a similar cultural background; and language concordance between physician and patient can decrease communication barriers and increase quality of care. The Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program established under AB 1045 has been instrumental in addressing this shortage by allowing 30 doctors from Mexico to practice medicine in California's federally funded community health centers. Effective December 2023, AltaMed has successfully implemented the Mexico Pilot Program with placement of 7 physicians from Mexico at our clinics. Data shows that from August 2021 to September 2023, 22 of the 30 doctors from Mexico allowed to practice medicine in California under AB 1045 provided 118,498 medical encounters to more than 36,000 patients at four community health centers. Access to comprehensive primary healthcare services has increased significantly in the communities where these doctors are practicing. By the end of the pilot, once all 30 physicians have practiced for three years each, we can anticipate the total number of encounters to be closer to 370,000, addressing a gap in care. As you can see, this innovative model has shown to be successful to date and needs to continue with the expansion of AB 2860, as it responds to the ever-worsening structural and institutional barriers causing doctor shortages, especially with culturally and linguistically competent doctors…This bill is vital in addressing the physician shortage and lack of cultural and linguistic competent physicians.”
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS) notes an increase in patient visits as a result of participation in the Mexico Pilot Program and writes that physicians “have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient’s treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness. The confidence that patients have acquired as a result of this program underscores the importance of the contributions these doctors are making to provide access to medical care for many who have not had this access…without the [Mexico Pilot Program], CSVS would have continued to face significant challenges in meeting the healthcare needs of our community.”
Supporters write that “While California must do more to address the physician shortage, AB 2860 takes one approach to temporarily resolve the issue. The bill seeks to expand the existing program, over 15 years, to bring nearly 1000 physicians to California on one-time, three-year licenses. These physicians would join community health centers and clinics throughout the state to serve populations of need, focusing primarily on migrant farmworker, underserved Latinx and rural communities. Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need.”
- Comments. MBC writes that it “…believes that the [Mexico Pilot Program] has increased access to quality care in the communities where the program licensees are practicing medicine. The first two annual evaluations conducted by UC Davis have shown positive results, therefore, the Board believes that AB 2860 is aligned with its mission to protect consumers and promote access to quality care.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Alameda Health Consortium
AltaMed Health Services
Altura Centers for Health
Arroyo Vista Family Health Center
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
California Medical Association
Clinica De Salud Del Valle De Salinas
Clinica Monseñor Oscar A. Romero
CommuniCare+OLE
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Community Health Partnership
Community Health Systems, Inc.
Comprehensive Community Health Centers
CPCA Advocates
Dientes Community Dental
Eisner Health
El Proyecto Del Barrio, INC.
Family Health Centers of San Diego
Golden Valley Health Centers
Gracelight Community Health
Health Alliance of Northern California
Health and Life Organization (Sacramento Community Clinics)
Health Center Partners of Southern California
Health Net of California
Hill Country Community Clinic
La Clinica De La Raza.
Lifelong Medical Care
Local Health Plans of California
National Hispanic Health Foundation
Neighborhood Healthcare
North Coast Clinics Network
Petaluma Health Center
Redwoods Rural Health Center
Sac Health
San Benito Health Foundation
San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium
Share Our Selves
Shasta Community Health Center
South Central Family Health Center
The Children's Clinic
Truecare
Valley Community Healthcare
West County Health Centers
Nine individuals
Opposition:
None received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Angelique Ashby, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 3, 2024
Author: | |||
Version: | May 29, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Recasts the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Pilot Program) as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act and makes various updates and conforming changes.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Mexico Pilot Program to allow up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology who are certified or recertified and in good standing in their medical specialty in Mexico, and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for three years according to certain requirements. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 853).
- Specifies that physician program participants, prior to leaving Mexico, must complete a six-month orientation program which addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices, and pharmacology differences. Requires National Autonomous University of Mexico (UNAM) and a medical school in good standing, or a facility conducting an approved medical residency training program in California, to confer to develop a mutually agreed upon distant learning program for the six-month orientation. Requires MBC to approve the orientation to ensure that it contains the requisite subject matter and meets appropriate California law and medical standards where applicable. (BPC §§ 853(c)(2)(B)(i) and 853 (c)(2)(C)).
- Authorizes physician applicants to receive a three-year nonrenewable license to work in nonprofit community health centers and requires them to participate in a six-month externship at their place of employment. Specifies that the externship commences after licensure, that the externship ensures the participant is complying with the established standards for quality assurance of nonprofit community health centers and medical practices, and that the externship be affiliated with a medical school in good standing in California. Specifies that nonprofit community health centers employing physician program participants must have medical quality assurance protocols and either be accredited by the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations (Joint Commission) or have protocols similar to those required by the Joint Commission. Requires protocols to be submitted to MBC prior to the hiring of physicians. (BPC §§ 853 (c)(4) and 853 (c)(6)).
- Requires MBC and the Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight review of program implementation. Requires MBC and DBC to consult with the medical schools and dental schools applying for funding to implement and evaluate this program, executive and medical and dental directors of nonprofit community health centers wanting to employ program participants, and for MBC, hospital administrators who will have these participants practicing in their hospital. Requires MBC and DBC to report to the Legislature every January during which the Mexico Pilot Program is operational regarding the status of the program and the ability of the program to secure the funding necessary to carry out its required provisions. (BPC § 853 (c)(8) and BPC § 853 (d)(8))
- Specifies that any funding necessary for the implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC, including the evaluation and oversight functions, shall be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Specifies that implementation of the Mexico Pilot Program by MBC and DBC may not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities. Authorizes MBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities and, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from nonprofit philanthropic entities for the Mexico Pilot Program. Authorizes DBC to accept funds from nonprofit philanthropic entities. (Id.)
- Authorizes DBC to grant a license to practice dentistry to an applicant who satisfies certain requirements, including a requirement that satisfactory evidence be provided that the applicant has graduated from a dental school approved either by a national accrediting body approved by the DBC or by CODA, a national accreditor established within the American Dental Association. (BPC § 1634.1)
- Requires applicants for physician and surgeon licensure by MBC, who graduated from a MBC approved international medical school, to complete two years of Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (U.S.) or Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (Canada) accredited postgraduate training. (BPC § 2096).
This bill:
- Recasts the Mexico Pilot Program as two distinct programs, the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Mexico Physicians Program) in the Medical Practice Act, and the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Mexico Dentists Program) in the Dental Practice Act.
- Deletes a prescribed length for the orientation program participants in the Mexico Physicians Program must complete prior to coming to California and updates required curriculum to include: medication documentation and reconciliation, the electronic medical records system utilized by federally qualified health centers, and standards for medical record documentation to support medical decisionmaking and quality care. Deletes the requirement under current law that the curriculum include pharmacology differences.
- Updates the requirement under current law for physicians in the Mexico Physicians Program to enroll in ESL classes and instead requires individuals to provide documentation to MBC that they scored 85 percent on the Test of English as a Foreign Language or 350 on the Occupational English Test.
- Updates the fee schedule for Mexico Physician Program participants.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Updates authority for participating hospitals to establish criteria necessary to allow Mexico Physician Program participants to have hospital privileges by specifying that they take into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by FQHCs and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
- Specifies that a physician from Mexico cannot be denied credentials by a health plan because the physician is a participant in the Mexico Physicians Program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States. Specifies that a Mexico Physicians Program participant’s license must be referred to as a “Physician’s and Surgeon’s from Mexico License” and must not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that MBC applies.
- Allows the number of physicians eligible to participate in the Mexico Physicians Program to increase by specified increments every four years until 2041, when no more than 275 physicians, including up to 40 psychiatrists, may participate.
- Makes various findings and declarations about California’s population, the importance of provider-patient communication, primary care and physician shortages in California, and other related topics.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill is keyed fiscal. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, MBC estimates additional licensing workload of approximately 336 hours for the first three fiscal years, at a cost of $100,000. Costs would be offset by application and licensing fees, assuming each licensee pays an application fee of $647 and licensing fee of $1,726.50. DBC does not anticipate a fiscal impact. DBC has not started the Pilot Program as required funding from philanthropic entities to implement the Pilot Program has not yet materialized and DBC does not anticipate implementation of the Dentists Program. The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) estimates absorbable costs for information services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas and the California Primary Care Association. According to the Author, little progress has been made in reducing the physician shortage in the nation and California and educating and training more ethnic and racial minorities at medical schools. Even less progress has been made in preparing medical students to be culturally and linguistically competent. The Author states, "These realities are taking place at a time when Latinos are now the largest population group in the State of California, and the state has become more ethnically and racially diverse than at any other time in its history. The Author notes that this bill builds on the success of the Mexico Pilot Program by removing the “pilot” status and extending the program for 15 years. According to the Author, “This program will place more physicians and culturally and linguistically competent physicians in communities throughout the state that are federally designated Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSA) (less than one primary care doctor for 3,000 patients in rural areas and 3500 in urban centers). We are placing doctors within one year compared to it taking 10 to 15 years to produce one doctor who may or may not want to work in these HPSA communities and is culturally and linguistically competent.”
- Background. The Mexico Pilot Program, established by AB 1045 (Firebaugh, Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002), was designed to bring physicians and dentists from Mexico with rural experience, who speak the language, understand the culture, and know how to apply this knowledge in serving the large Latino communities in rural areas who have limited or no access to primary health care services. Proponents of the measure were concerned about addressing primary care physician and dentist shortages while maintaining a high quality of care.
The bill authorized up to 30 licensed physicians specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology and up to 30 licensed dentists from Mexico to practice medicine or dentistry in California for up to three years, and required the individuals to meet certain requirements related to training and education.
AB 1045 tasked MBC with oversight review of both the implementation of the program and an evaluation of the program once it is implemented. The bill specified that any funding necessary for the implementation of the program, including the evaluation and oversight functions, was to be secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities and further stated that implementation of the program could not move forward unless appropriate funding was secured from nonprofit philanthropic entities.
Program participants are required to undergo a six-month orientation program approved by MBC that addresses medical protocol, community clinic history and operations, medical administration, hospital operations and protocol, medical ethics, the California medical delivery system, health maintenance organizations and managed care practices and pharmacology differences.
MBC received the necessary philanthropic funding in 2018 to initiate the program and began taking the necessary steps for implementation. As of April 2019, MBC began accepting applications for the Mexico Pilot Program. MBC received the required funding commitments necessary for program implementation in December 2020. Mexico Pilot Program physicians are authorized to practice in the following MBC-approved community health clinics: Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas in Monterey County; San Benito Health Foundation in San Benito County; Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County and; AltaMed Health Services Corporation
In August 2022, the Center for Reducing Health Disparities (CRHD) at the University of California, Davis released its first annual progress report of the Mexico Pilot Program. The initial report covers the two FYs of the Mexico Pilot Program’s operations, FY 20/21 and 21/21 and includes baseline data results in three of the requisite categories. Per BPC Section 853 (j), the evaluation must include, but not be limited to:
- Quality of care provided by doctors and dentists licensed under this pilot program.
- Adaptability of these licensed practitioners to California medical and dental standards.
- Impact on working and administrative environment in nonprofit community health centers and impact on interpersonal relations with medical licensed counterparts in health centers.
- Response and approval by patients.
- Impact on cultural and linguistic services.
- Increases in medical encounters provided by participating practitioners to limited-English-speaking patient populations and increases in the number of limited-English-speaking patients seeking health care services from nonprofit community health centers.
- Recommendations on whether the program should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.
Discussions continue between the original sponsors of AB 1045 who remain supportive of the Mexico Pilot Program’s goals, MBC staff, and CRHD representatives about what context and factors for capturing baseline data should be taken into consideration in order to provide an effective evaluation.
- Arguments in Support. According to AltaMed, “Our healthcare professionals have witnessed firsthand the severe shortage of physicians in many areas of California, particularly in underserved communities. This shortage is even more pronounced among Latino physicians and by the lack of cultural and linguistic competency among healthcare providers, which can make it difficult for patients to access the care they need. We know that patients prefer to see physicians of a similar cultural background; and language concordance between physician and patient can decrease communication barriers and increase quality of care. The Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program established under AB 1045 has been instrumental in addressing this shortage by allowing 30 doctors from Mexico to practice medicine in California's federally funded community health centers. Effective December 2023, AltaMed has successfully implemented the Mexico Pilot Program with placement of 7 physicians from Mexico at our clinics. Data shows that from August 2021 to September 2023, 22 of the 30 doctors from Mexico allowed to practice medicine in California under AB 1045 provided 118,498 medical encounters to more than 36,000 patients at four community health centers. Access to comprehensive primary healthcare services has increased significantly in the communities where these doctors are practicing. By the end of the pilot, once all 30 physicians have practiced for three years each, we can anticipate the total number of encounters to be closer to 370,000, addressing a gap in care. As you can see, this innovative model has shown to be successful to date and needs to continue with the expansion of AB 2860, as it responds to the ever-worsening structural and institutional barriers causing doctor shortages, especially with culturally and linguistically competent doctors…This bill is vital in addressing the physician shortage and lack of cultural and linguistic competent physicians.”
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS) notes an increase in patient visits as a result of participation in the Mexico Pilot Program and writes that physicians “have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient’s treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness. The confidence that patients have acquired as a result of this program underscores the importance of the contributions these doctors are making to provide access to medical care for many who have not had this access…without the [Mexico Pilot Program], CSVS would have continued to face significant challenges in meeting the healthcare needs of our community.”
Supporters write that “While California must do more to address the physician shortage, AB 2860 takes one approach to temporarily resolve the issue. The bill seeks to expand the existing program, over 15 years, to bring nearly 1000 physicians to California on one-time, three-year licenses. These physicians would join community health centers and clinics throughout the state to serve populations of need, focusing primarily on migrant farmworker, underserved Latinx and rural communities. Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need.”
- Comments. MBC writes that it “…believes that the [Mexico Pilot Program] has increased access to quality care in the communities where the program licensees are practicing medicine. The first two annual evaluations conducted by UC Davis have shown positive results, therefore, the Board believes that AB 2860 is aligned with its mission to protect consumers and promote access to quality care.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Alameda Health Consortium
AltaMed Health Services
Altura Centers for Health
Arroyo Vista Family Health Center
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
California Medical Association
Clinica De Salud Del Valle De Salinas
Clinica Monseñor Oscar A. Romero
CommuniCare+OLE
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Community Health Partnership
Community Health Systems, Inc.
Comprehensive Community Health Centers
CPCA Advocates
Dientes Community Dental
Eisner Health
El Proyecto Del Barrio, INC.
Family Health Centers of San Diego
Golden Valley Health Centers
Gracelight Community Health
Health Alliance of Northern California
Health and Life Organization (Sacramento Community Clinics)
Health Center Partners of Southern California
Hill Country Community Clinic
La Clinica De La Raza.
Lifelong Medical Care
Local Health Plans of California
Neighborhood Healthcare
North Coast Clinics Network
Petaluma Health Center
Redwoods Rural Health Center
Sac Health
San Benito Health Foundation
San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium
Share Our Selves
Shasta Community Health Center
South Central Family Health Center
The Children's Clinic
Truecare
Valley Community Healthcare
West County Health Centers
Opposition:
None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2860
Author:(Garcia)
As Amended Ver:April 3, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Reestablishes the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program as the distinct Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and revises various requirements contained within the existing pilot program relating to the temporary state licensure of medical professionals from Mexico.
Major Provisions
- Repeals the current law establishing the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and replaces it with two new statutes: one establishing a Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the other establishing a Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
- Removes the requirement that physicians and dentists from Mexico complete a six-month externship at their place of employment after receiving a three-year nonrenewable license.
- Changes the existing requirement that physicians under the current program complete a six-month orientation before leaving Mexico with a more general requirement that those physicians complete an approved orientation program of unspecified length, and adds training on electronic medical records systems and medical record documentation standards to the list of subjects that must be included in that orientation.
- Repeals the requirement that physicians from Mexico must enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes and instead requires that participants complete the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85% or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provide written documentation of their completion to the Medical Board of California (MBC).
- Replaces the current fee amount that must be paid to the MBC for a three-year license with a placeholder where the fee amount will be set through future amendments.
- Prohibits a health plan from denying credentials to a physician from Mexico because the physician is a participant in the program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States.
- Provides that the three-year license issued to a physician under the program shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the MBC applies.
- Beginning January 1, 2025, provides that the MBC shall permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a three-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the existing pilot program to extend their license for three years on a one-time basis.
- Gradually increases the number of physicians from Mexico eligible to receive a nonrenewable three-year license from the MBC to practice under the program, with increases occurring every four years until 2041 pursuant to the following schedule:
- Commencing January 1, 2025, no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists (or 125 total physicians from Mexico, including renewed participants).
- Commencing January 1, 2029, no more than 145 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2033, no more than 175 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2037, no more than 210 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2041, no more than 220 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Requires the MBC to work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing all required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the former Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and worked in the placement of physicians in FQHCs that participated in the pilot program.
COMMENTS
Mexico Pilot Program. The concept of allowing physicians from Mexico to temporarily practice in California was purportedly first proposed in 1998 by board members at the Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS), an FQHC in Monterey County. As described in reporting by the CHCF, "the clinic was having a hard time finding enough physicians to work in Salinas, let alone doctors who spoke Spanish and understood the culture." CSVS's chief executive officer worked with a policy consultant to develop and advocate for the proposal, which reportedly received "pushback from some California medical school officials, physicians, and the California Medical Association."
In 2001, Assemblymember Marco A. Firebaugh introduced Assembly Bill 1045 (Firebaugh) Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002, sponsored by the California Hispanic Health Care Association. The bill was amended in May 2002 to reflect language proposed to the Subcommittee of a Task Force on Culturally and Linguistically Competent Physicians and Dentists. By the time AB 1045 was heard by the Senate Committee on Business and Professions in August 2002, it had been amended several additional times but was still formally opposed by the California Medical Association, the California Dental Association, and the Federation of State Medical Boards, all of whom raised concerns that the proposed pilot program could result in undertrained, lower quality health care providers being allowed to practice in California. The committee analysis noted that further amendments were needed to clarify the author's intent and resolve outstanding questions about how the program would be implemented.
Despite the bill's opposition, AB 1045 passed the Legislature and was signed into law by Governor Gray Davis on September 30, 2002. The bill repealed the statute establishing the Subcommittee and established the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. The bill allowed up to 30 physicians and 30 dentists from Mexico to participate in the program for three-year periods—a compromise from the 150 physicians and 100 dentists that were previously proposed. Participants in the pilot program were required to hold a license in good standing in Mexico, pass a board review course, complete a six-month orientation program, and enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. The bill additionally required the MBC and Dental Board of California (DBC) to provide oversight, in consultation with other entities, to provide oversight of these entities and submit reports to the Legislature.
While AB 1045 was enacted in 2002, its vision was not effectuated for over two decades. This substantial delay is attributable to several factors. First, the bill required that the pilot program could only be implemented "if the necessary amount of nonstate resources are obtained" and that "General Fund moneys shall not be used for these programs." Sponsors of the bill would have to secure private philanthropic donations to fund the pilot program. Additionally, the bill required the identification of medical schools and hospitals that would accept foreign physicians, which was reportedly a challenging task.
Supporters of the pilot program ultimately succeeded in overcoming the administrative hurdles to implementing AB 1045. Philanthropic dollars were collected and placed into a Special Deposit Fund to support the MBC's implementation of the bill, with $333,000 from that fund appropriated in the Budget Act of 2020. Similar funding has continued to be appropriated in subsequent budget bills, with an estimated $498,000 in philanthropic funds appropriated in Fiscal Year 2023-24 and $299,000 appropriated in Fiscal Year 2024-25.
Physicians from Mexico finally started serving patients under the pilot program in August 2021, beginning with physicians working at San Benito Health Foundation in August 2021. Additional physicians subsequently began serving patients at CSVS in Monterey County, Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County. From January to November 2023, additional licensed physicians from Mexico began serving patients in the Alta Med Health Corporation in Los Angeles and Orange Counties.
The first annual progress report on the pilot program, submitted to the Legislature by the University of California (UC), Davis in August of 2022, found that many patients had positive experiences with physicians practicing through the pilot program. In particular, patients reportedly had substantially positive experiences communicating with their doctor, and frequently felt welcome. While the overall efficacy of the pilot program was still under review, initial reports appeared positive.
UC Davis submitted its second annual progress report on the pilot program to the Legislature in October of 2023. As stated in the report summary, the goal of the evaluation was to provide recommendations on the pilot program and opine on "whether it should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated." The report summary concluded with a finding that the pilot program "has strong positive feedback from all. Physicians integrated seamlessly, making healthcare more accessible, and increasing patient trust. Staff reported excellent patient care processes and a supportive environment." The report further concluded that physicians in the program "demonstrated a solid understanding of California Medical Standards."
With early assessments of the pilot program producing undeniably positive findings, the original supporters of AB 1045 now believe it is appropriate to revise and expand the program from the version that was negotiated back in 2001. To begin with, the bill would extend the licenses of physicians currently participating in the pilot program by an additional three years. This will allow those physicians who have been successfully evaluated to continue serving patients and compensate for opportunities to serve patients that were lost due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Next, this bill would revise the requirements that physicians from Mexico must meet both prior to coming to California and upon arrival. First, this bill would remove the requirement that participants in the pilot program complete a six-month externship after receiving their license. Additionally, this bill replaces the requirement that the orientation program for physicians be six months with a more general requirement that does not specify a length of time. The bill also adds training on electronic medical records systems and medical record documentation standards to the list of subjects that must be included in that orientation.
Current law also requires physicians from Mexico to enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. This bill would remove that requirement and instead require that participants complete the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the MBC.
This bill would then statutorily reestablish the program for physicians from Mexico and change its title to no longer refer to a "pilot program." The newly codified Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program would then gradually expand over the next fifteen years, with increases every four years pursuant to the following schedule:
- Commencing January 1, 2025, no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists (or 125 total physicians from Mexico, including renewed participants).
- Commencing January 1, 2029, no more than 145 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2033, no more than 175 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2037, no more than 210 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2041, no more than 220 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
This bill would then reestablish the component of the prior pilot program relating to dentists from Mexico as the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. To date, no dentists from Mexico have been able to participate in the pilot program, with supporters of the program prioritizing physicians in the early stages of implementation. The intent of the author and sponsors of this bill is to begin the process of allowing dentists to participate in a recodified pilot program within the Dental Practice Act.
With the above provisions, among other less significant changes, the pilot program will be significantly expanded from its inceptive form under AB 1045. The primary care access crisis has only grown more apparent over the past two decades, with even greater attention afforded to the stark health care inequities in California communities. It can also be argued that there is now less instinctive skepticism of immigrant professionals than there was when AB 1045 was negotiated, particularly given the cultural and linguistic competence that providers from Mexico inherently offer. The Legislature may therefore consider it to now be the appropriate time to expand the pilot program and allow it to fulfill the vision originally conceived by its creators.
According to the Author
"Perhaps the most urgent matter confronting the health care of our state and nation is ensuring that we have an adequate supply of doctors available to serve the diversity of our state and nation's population. The shortage of physicians has only increased since 2000. AB 2860 addresses this serious structural and institutional problem by increasing the number of doctors from Mexico; the previous pilot program, in 2002, allowed them to practice in California. AB 2860 increases physicians from Mexico from 30 to 125 beginning in 2025 and increases medical providers by 30 to 40 every three years until 2041. We will have substantially more culturally, and linguistically competent doctors create access and serve patients in California. This program is the only program of its type and purpose in the nation. UC Davis School of Medicine's 2nd annual evaluation of this program, issued in October 2023, found that the program had '…strong feedback from all, health care is more accessible, patient trust has increased, and Mexican physicians demonstrate a solid understanding of California Medical Standards.'"
Arguments in Support
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS) is co-sponsoring this bill. CSVS writes: "Through our active participation in the Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program, we have witnessed firsthand the profound impact that these dedicated professionals have made in our service areas. From their arrival in CY 2022 to December 2023, our physicians had a total of 81,587 patient visits. In addition to this increase in patient visits, all eleven physicians have proven to be culturally responsive to the needs of our patients. They have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient's treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness."
The advocacy affiliate of the California Primary Care Association (CPCA) is also co-sponsoring this bill, writing: "Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need. As the committee well knows, the physician shortage, particularly in rural and underserved communities, is at a critical point; efforts to bring in highly trained physicians from Mexico to provide care in disenfranchised communities must be prioritized."
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, the MBC estimates additional licensing workload of approximately 336 hours for the first three fiscal years, at a cost of $100,000, offset by application and licensing fees, assuming each licensee pays an application fee of $647 and licensing fee of $1,726.50; no fiscal impact to the DBC.
VOTES
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Berman, Flora, Alanis, Bains, Juan Carrillo, Chen, Dixon, Grayson, Irwin, Jackson, Low, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Pellerin, Sanchez, Soria, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-0
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
UPDATED
VERSION: April 3, 2024
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0002761
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2860
Author:(Garcia) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 18 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill repeals the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Pilot Program) and reestablishes it as two distinct programs – the Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program (Physicians Program) and Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program (Dentists Program) – and revises various requirements relating to the temporary state licensure of medical professionals from Mexico.
Specifically, this bill:
- Repeals the Pilot Program.
- Creates the Dentists Program, continuing the dentist component of the Pilot Program, and requiring the Dental Board of California (DBC) to issue a three-year, nonrenewable permit to practice dentistry to each dentist from Mexico who meets specified criteria.
- Authorizes no more than 30 dentists from Mexico to practice dentistry in California for up to three years.
- Specifies training and education requirements for the Dentists Program.
- Requires DBC to provide oversight review of the implementation and evaluation of the Dentists Program, as specified.
- Sets the fee for a three-year, nonrenewable permit in the Dentists Program at $548.
- Creates the Physicians Program, continuing the physician component of the Pilot Program, and requiring the Medical Board of California (MBC) to issue a three-year license to practice medicine to each physician from Mexico who meets specified criteria.
- Changes the Pilot Program requirement that physicians complete a six-month orientation before leaving Mexico with a more general requirement that those physicians complete an approved orientation program, and requires the orientation to include training on electronic medical records systems and medical record documentation standards.
- Repeals the requirement that physicians from Mexico enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes and instead requires participants to complete the Test of English as a Foreign Language, as specified. Sets other requirements for participating physicians.
- Replaces the current fee amount that must be paid to the MBC for a three-year license with a placeholder for an amount to be set with future amendments.
- Beginning January 1, 2025, authorizes the MBC to allow each of 30 licensed physicians who were issued a three-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the Pilot Program to extend their licenses one time, for three years.
- Allows the number of physicians eligible to participate in the Physicians Program to increase by specified increments every four years until 2041, when no more than 220 physicians, including up to 40 psychiatrists, may participate.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine to conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
FISCAL EFFECT:
MBC estimates additional licensing workload of approximately 336 hours for the first three fiscal years, at a cost of $100,000 (Contingent Fund of the MBC). Costs would be offset by application and licensing fees, assuming each licensee pays an application fee of $647 and licensing fee of $1,726.50.
The Dental Board of California (DBC) does not anticipate a fiscal impact. DBC has not started the Pilot Program as required funding from philanthropic entities to implement the Pilot Program has not yet materialized and DBC does not anticipate implementation of the Dentists Program.
The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) estimates absorbable costs for information services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas and the California Primary Care Association. According to the author:
Perhaps the most urgent matter confronting the health care of our state and nation is ensuring that we have an adequate supply of doctors available to serve the diversity of our state and nation’s population. The shortage of physicians has only increased since 2000. AB 2860 addresses this serious structural and institutional problem by increasing the number of doctors from Mexico; the previous pilot program, in 2002, allowed them to practice in California. AB 2860 increases physicians from Mexico from 30 to 125 beginning in 2025 and increases medical providers by 30 to 40 every three years until 2041. We will have substantially more culturally, and linguistically competent doctors create access and serve patients in California. This program is the only program of its type and purpose in the nation. UC Davis School of Medicine’s 2nd annual evaluation of this program, issued in October 2023, found that the program had “…strong feedback from all, health care is more accessible, patient trust has increased, and Mexican physicians demonstrate a solid understanding of California Medical Standards.
- Background.
Pilot Program. AB 1045 (Firebaugh), Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002, established the Pilot Program because Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS), an FQHC in Monterey County, was having difficulty finding enough physicians to work in Salinas, let alone doctors who spoke Spanish and understood the various cultures in the region. AB 1045 allowed up to 30 physicians and 30 dentists from Mexico to participate for three-year periods. AB 1045 was not implemented for over two decades, largely because the bill stipulated General Fund moneys could not be used and the Pilot Program could be implemented only if the necessary nonstate resources were obtained.
Supporters of the Pilot Program eventually collected philanthropic money to support the MBC’s implementation of the bill, and the Legislature appropriated $333,000 in the Budget Act of 2020. Subsequent budget bills have continued to appropriate funding, with an estimated $498,000 in philanthropic funds appropriated in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24 and $299,000 appropriated in FY 2024-25. Physicians from Mexico finally started serving patients under the Pilot Program in August 2021, beginning with physicians working at San Benito Health Foundation. Additional physicians subsequently began serving patients in counties of Monterey, Tulare, Los Angeles, and Orange.
Pilot Program Evaluation. The MBC contracted with the Center for Reducing Health Disparities at the University of California, Davis to conduct a three-year evaluation of the Program. Interviews of Pilot Program physicians and staff and administrators at the community health centers where the physicians practice suggest they integrate well, improve access to health care, and increase patient trust.
- Related Legislation.
- Assembly Bill 2864 (Garcia) requires the MBC to extend the licenses of physicians participating in the Pilot Program by an additional three years. AB 2864 is pending in this committee.
- AB 1395 (Garcia, Chapter 205, Statutes of 2023) requires the MBC to issue a license to applicants for participation in the Pilot Program who do not currently possess federal documentation but otherwise meet the Pilot Program’s requirements, and authorizes the MBC to extend a Pilot Program participant’s license under certain conditions.
- AB 1396 (Garcia) was substantially similar to AB 1395 and was held in this committee.
- Assembly Bill 2864 (Garcia) requires the MBC to extend the licenses of physicians participating in the Pilot Program by an additional three years. AB 2864 is pending in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Marc Berman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2860
Author:(Garcia) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2024
SUBJECT: Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico programs.
SUMMARY: Reestablishes the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program as the distinct Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and revises various requirements contained within the existing pilot program relating to the temporary state licensure of medical professionals from Mexico.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Medical Board of California (MBC) to administer the Medical Practice Act. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 2000 et seq.)
- Establishes the Dental Board of California (DBC) to administer the Dental Practice Act. (BPC §§ 1600 et seq.)
- Requires all continuing medical education courses to contain curriculum that includes cultural and linguistic competency in the practice of medicine and the understanding of implicit bias. (BPC § 2190.1)
- Establishes a voluntary cultural and linguistic physician competency program operated by local medical societies of the California Medical Association and monitored by the MBC’s Division of Licensing. (BPC § 2198)
- Defines “cultural and linguistic competency” as cultural and linguistic abilities that can be incorporated into therapeutic and medical evaluation and treatment, including direct communication in the patient-client primary language, understanding and applying the roles of culture in health care, and awareness of how health care providers and patients attitudes, values, and beliefs influence and impact professional and patient relations. (BPC § 2198.1)
- Establishes the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program, which allows up to 30 physicians from Mexico specializing in family practice, internal medicine, pediatrics, and obstetrics and gynecology to practice medicine in California. (BPC § 853(a))
- Provides that the MBC shall issue three-year nonrenewable licenses to practice medicine to physicians from Mexico who are eligible to participate in the pilot program. (BPC § 853(b))
- Requires physicians from Mexico to comply with various requirements to participate in the pilot program, including medical education and practice requirements and enrollment in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. (BPC § 853(c))
- Requires dentists from Mexico to comply with various requirements to participate in the pilot program, including dental education and practice requirements. (BPC § 853(d))
- Provides that nonprofit community health centers that employ pilot program participants are responsible for ensuring that participants are taking courses in the English language and obtain a specified level of English fluency. (BPC § 853(e))
- Authorizes the MBC to extend the three-year nonrenewable license period for a physician from Mexico if, prior to January 30, 2024, the licensee was unable to practice more than 30 consecutive business days due to specified circumstances. (BPC § 853(j))
- Provides that an evaluation of the pilot program shall be undertaken with funds provided from philanthropic foundations beginning 12 months after the pilot program has commenced. (BPC § 853(l))
- Requires that all costs for administering the pilot program be secured from philanthropic entities. (BPC § 853(m))
- Provides that the criteria for issuing three-year nonrenewable medical licenses and dental permits under the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program shall not be utilized at any time as the standard for issuing a license to practice medicine or a permit to practice dentistry in California on a permanent basis. (BPC § 854)
THIS BILL:
- Repeals the current law establishing the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and replaces it with two new statutes: one establishing a Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program and the other establishing a Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
- Removes the requirement that physicians and dentists from Mexico complete a six-month externship at their place of employment after receiving a three-year nonrenewable license.
- Changes the existing requirement that physicians under the current program complete a six-month orientation before leaving Mexico with a more general requirement that those physicians complete an approved orientation program of unspecified length, and adds training on electronic medical records systems and medical record documentation standards to the list of subjects that must be included in that orientation.
- Repeals the requirement that physicians from Mexico must enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes and instead requires that participants complete the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provide written documentation of their completion to the MBC.
- Replaces the current fee amount that must be paid to the MBC for a three-year license with a placeholder where the fee amount will be set through future amendments.
- Prohibits a health plan from denying credentials to a physician from Mexico because the physician is a participant in the program and did not receive their medical education and training in the United States.
- Provides that the three-year license issued to a physician under the program shall not include any additional notations beyond the current numerical identifiers that the MBC applies.
- Beginning January 1, 2025, provides that the MBC shall permit each of the no more than 30 licensed physicians who were issued a three-year license to practice medicine pursuant to the existing pilot program to extend their license for three years on a one-time basis.
- Gradually increases the number of physicians from Mexico eligible to receive a nonrenewable three-year license from the MBC to practice under the program, with increases occurring every four years until 2041 pursuant to the following schedule:
- Commencing January 1, 2025, no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists (or 125 total physicians from Mexico, including renewed participants).
- Commencing January 1, 2029, no more than 145 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2033, no more than 175 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2037, no more than 210 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2041, no more than 220 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Requires the federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) that employ physicians from Mexico to continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government and to work with the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter.
- Requires the MBC to work with the community health centers that assisted in recruiting, vetting, and securing all required documents from primary sources in Mexico to participate in the former Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program and worked in the placement of physicians in FQHCs that participated in the pilot program.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Council.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Clinicas de Salud del Valle de Salinas and the California Primary Care Association. According to the author:
“Perhaps the most urgent matter confronting the health care of our state and nation is ensuring that we have an adequate supply of doctors available to serve the diversity of our state and nation’s population. The shortage of physicians has only increased since 2000. AB 2860 addresses this serious structural and institutional problem by increasing the number of doctors from Mexico; the previous pilot program, in 2002, allowed them to practice in California. AB 2860 increases physicians from Mexico from 30 to 125 beginning in 2025 and increases medical providers by 30 to 40 every three years until 2041. We will have substantially more culturally, and linguistically competent doctors create access and serve patients in California. This program is the only program of its type and purpose in the nation. UC Davis School of Medicine’s 2nd annual evaluation of this program, issued in October 2023, found that the program had ‘…strong feedback from all, health care is more accessible, patient trust has increased, and Mexican physicians demonstrate a solid understanding of California Medical Standards.’”
Background.
Health Care Workforce Inequities. There has long been an acknowledged decline in the number of accessible primary care physicians, which has disproportionately impacted communities with concentrated populations of immigrant families and people of color. A recent study found that between 2010 and 2019, the number of primary care physicians in proportion to population remained largely unchanged nationally, and that counties with a high proportion of minorities saw a decline during that period.[1] Additionally, physicians who are accessible to immigrant communities often do not possess the linguistic or cultural competence to appropriately treat all patients. A 2018 study published by the Latino Policy & Politics Initiative at the University of California, Los Angeles found that while nearly 44 percent of the California population speaks a language other than English at home, many of the state’s most commonly spoken languages are underrepresented by the physician workforce.[2]
Research cited by the California Health Care Foundation (CHCF) in its 2021 report “Health Workforce Strategies for California: A Review of the Evidence” found that while 39 percent of Californians identified as Latino/x in 2019, only 14 percent of medical school matriculants and 6 percent of active patient care physicians in California were Latino/x.[3] In February 2024, the Assembly Committee on Health held an informational hearing on diversity in California’s health care workforce. The background paper for the hearing concluded that “it is well-documented that physicians from minority backgrounds are more likely to practice in Health Profession Shortage Areas and to care for minority, Medicaid, and uninsured people than their counterparts.”[4]
Mexico Pilot Program. The concept of allowing physicians from Mexico to temporarily practice in California was purportedly first proposed in 1998 by board members at the Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS), an FQHC in Monterey County. As described in reporting by the CHCF, “the clinic was having a hard time finding enough physicians to work in Salinas, let alone doctors who spoke Spanish and understood the culture.” CSVS’s chief executive officer worked with a policy consultant to develop and advocate for the proposal, which reportedly received “pushback from some California medical school officials, physicians, and the California Medical Association.”[5]
In 2000, the Legislature enacted Assembly Bill 2394 by Assemblymember Marco A. Firebaugh, sponsored by the California Hispanic Healthcare Association. As amended in the Senate, the bill established the Task Force on Culturally and Linguistically Competent Physicians and Dentists. The bill briefly included language that would have created a Doctors and Dentists from Mexico Exchange Pilot Program; however, this language was subsequently removed from the bill. Instead, a Subcommittee of the Task Force, chaired by the Director of Health Services, was charged with examining “the feasibility of establishing a pilot program that would allow Mexican and Caribbean licensed physicians and dentists to practice in nonprofit community health centers in California’s medically underserved areas.”
AB 2394 required the Subcommittee to make its report to the full Task Force by March 1, 2001, and then the full Task Force was required to forward the report to the Legislature, with any additional comments, by April 1, 2001. The achievability of this timeline was questioned by the Senate Committee on Business and Professions; the bill’s committee analysis noted that the Subcommittee was only allotted three months after the effective date of the bill to deliver its report to the Task Force. This due date was considered even more challenging in view of the fact that the sponsor of the bill had indicated a desire that the Subcommittee visit Mexico as part of its study.
In 2001, Assemblymember Firebaugh introduced Assembly Bill 1045, again sponsored by the California Hispanic Health Care Association. The bill initially proposed to simply require that the Subcommittee’s recommendations be incorporated into the Medical Practice Act by statute—despite the fact that those recommendations had not yet been made. As predicted, the Subcommittee’s report had not been accomplished by the dates prescribed in the prior bill. When AB 1045 was first considered by the Assembly Committee on Health, the first meeting of the Subcommittee was scheduled to take place days later on May 10, 2001. Additional amendments to the bill proposed to push out the Subcommittee’s deadline to report to the Task Force until June 15, 2001, with the final report due on August 15, 2001. AB 1045 subsequently stalled following passage to the Senate, remaining pending in the Senate Committee on Business and Professions with multiple hearings postponed over the course of the following year.
In the meantime, the Subcommittee finally met on July 10, 2001. During this meeting, the Subcommittee discussed comments and proposals it had received from seven organizations, including the California Medical Association, the California Dental Association, the Medical Board of California, the California Hispanic Health Care Association, the California Latino Medical Association, the Latino Coalition for a Healthy California, and the chief executive officer of CSVS (the FQHC in Monterey County). The proposal submitted by the California Hispanic Health Care Foundation comprised of language creating a Licensed Doctors and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program that was briefly amended into AB 1045 (and removed just two days later). The draft proposal was subsequently revised based on comments from CSVS.
The Subcommittee compared each proposal in an element matrix and then discussed potential models for a pilot program during its meeting. According to the Subcommittee meeting minutes:
“Although many members agreed on a number of the proposed elements, there was significant disagreement upon the time frame for implementing a pilot project, the temporary or permanent nature of licensure, education requirements for licensure, placements of doctors and dentists who participate in a pilot project, and how to determine cultural linguistic competency.”
After extensive discussion of the different proposals and the areas of disagreement, it was determined that the Subcommittee should disband, with members arguing that “the Subcommittee has come as far as it can with decisions and proposals.” A decision was made to simply forward the element matrix and the various proposals to the full Task Force.
The chairs of the Task Force subsequently submitted the Subcommittee’s report to the Legislature on September 7, 2001. The report’s cover letter noted that while its transmittal fulfilled the Task Force’s commitment to forward the Subcommittee’s report, the contents of the report were still being discussed by the full Task Force and the submission did not constitute adoption of the report or any recommendations by the Task Force. As a result, no conclusive recommendations were ever submitted to the Legislature for consideration, but rather a collection of unresolved discussion topics and conflicting proposals.[6]
Amendments were ultimately made to AB 1045 in May 2002 that reflected the revised language proposed to the Subcommittee by the California Hispanic Health Care Association, the bill’s sponsor. By the time AB 1045 was heard by the Senate Committee on Business and Professions in August 2002, it had been amended several additional times but was still formally opposed by the California Medical Association, the California Dental Association, and the Federation of State Medical Boards, all of whom raised concerns that the proposed pilot program could result in undertrained, lower quality health care providers being allowed to practice in California. The committee analysis noted that further amendments were needed to clarify the author’s intent and resolve outstanding questions about how the program would be implemented.
Despite the bill’s opposition, AB 1045 passed the Legislature and was signed into law by Governor Gray Davis on September 30, 2002. The final amended version of the bill repealed the statute establishing the Subcommittee and established the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. The bill allowed up to 30 physicians and 30 dentists from Mexico to participate in the program for three-year periods—a compromise from the 150 physicians and 100 dentists that were previously proposed. Participants in the pilot program were required to hold a license in good standing in Mexico, pass a board review course, complete a six-month orientation program, and enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. The bill additionally required the MBC and DBC to provide oversight, in consultation with other entities, to provide oversight of these entities and submit reports to the Legislature.
While AB 1045 was enacted in 2002, its vision was not effectuated for over two decades. This substantial delay is attributable to several factors. First, the bill required that the pilot program could only be implemented “if the necessary amount of nonstate resources are obtained” and that “General Fund moneys shall not be used for these programs.” Sponsors of the bill would have to secure private philanthropic donations to fund the pilot program. Additionally, the bill required the identification of medical schools and hospitals that would accept foreign physicians, which was reportedly a challenging task.[7]
Supporters of the pilot program ultimately succeeded in overcoming the administrative hurdles to implementing AB 1045. Philanthropic dollars were collected and placed into a Special Deposit Fund to support the MBC’s implementation of the bill, with $333,000 from that fund appropriated in the Budget Act of 2020. Similar funding has continued to be appropriated in subsequent budget bills, with an estimated $498,000 in philanthropic funds appropriated in Fiscal Year 2023-24 and $299,000 appropriated in Fiscal Year 2024-25.
Physicians from Mexico finally started serving patients under the pilot program in August 2021, beginning with physicians working at San Benito Health Foundation in August 2021. Additional physicians subsequently began serving patients at CSVS in Monterey County, Altura Centers for Health in Tulare County. From January to November 2023, additional physicians from Mexico began serving patients in the Alta Med Health Corporation in Los Angeles and Orange Counties.
Early in the implementation of the pilot program, some barriers were identified in the process through which physicians from Mexico receive approval to participate in the pilot program. As noncitizens, applicants typically would not have an individual taxpayer identification number (ITIN) or social security number (SSN), which is required by all regulatory boards, including the MBC, as a condition of receiving a license. However, applicants typically cannot apply to receive a visa and accompanying SSN without proof that they may legally work in California, which they cannot demonstrate without a license from the MBC. To resolve this issue, Assembly Bill 1395 (Garcia) was signed into law in 2023 to resolve this issue for physicians who had been unable to finalize their participation in the pilot program.
Another issue that was identified was that some physicians from Mexico were unable to practice for significant portions of the three-year period to which their license was limited due to factors outside their control. To address this issue, language was included in Senate Bill 815 (Roth), the MBC’s sunset bill, to authorize an extension of a license when the physician was unable to work due to a delay in the visa application process beyond the established time line by the federal Customs and Immigration Services. The MBC was also authorized to extend a license if the physician was unable to treat patients for more than 30 days due to an ongoing condition, including pregnancy, serious illness, credentialing by health plans, or serious injury. These extensions allowed those physicians from Mexico more time to serve patients under the pilot program.
The first annual progress report on the pilot program, submitted to the Legislature by the University of California, Davis in August of 2022, found that many patients had positive experiences with physicians practicing through the pilot program. In particular, patients reportedly had substantially positive experiences communicating with their doctor, and frequently felt welcome. While the overall efficacy of the pilot program was still under review, initial reports appeared positive.
UC Davis submitted its second annual progress report on the pilot program to the Legislature in October of 2023. As stated in the report summary, the goal of the evaluation was to provide recommendations on the pilot program and opine on “whether it should be continued, expanded, altered, or terminated.” The report summary concluded with a finding that the pilot program “has strong positive feedback from all. Physicians integrated seamlessly, making healthcare more accessible, and increasing patient trust. Staff reported excellent patient care processes and a supportive environment.” The report further concluded that physicians in the program “demonstrated a solid understanding of California Medical Standards.”
With early assessments of the pilot program producing undeniably positive findings, the original supporters of AB 1045 now believe it is appropriate to revise and expand the program from the version that was negotiated back in 2001. To begin with, the bill would extend the licenses of physicians currently participating in the pilot program by an additional three years. This will allow those physicians who have been successfully evaluated to continue serving patients and compensate for opportunities to serve patients that were lost due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Next, this bill would revise the requirements that physicians from Mexico must meet both prior to coming to California and upon arrival. First, this bill would remove the requirement that participants in the pilot program complete a six-month externship after receiving their license. Additionally, this bill replaces the requirement that the orientation program for physicians be six months with a more general requirement that does not specify a length of time. The bill also adds training on electronic medical records systems and medical record documentation standards to the list of subjects that must be included in that orientation.
Current law also requires physicians from Mexico to enroll in adult English-as-a-second-language (ESL) classes. This bill would remove that requirement and instead require that participants complete the Test of English as a Foreign Language by scoring a minimum of 85 percent or the Occupational English Test with a minimum score of 350, and provided written documentation of their completion to the MBC.
This bill would then statutorily reestablish the program for physicians from Mexico and change its title to no longer refer to a “pilot program.” The newly codified Licensed Physicians from Mexico Program would then gradually expand over the next fifteen years, with increases every four years pursuant to the following schedule:
- Commencing January 1, 2025, no more than an additional 95 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 30 psychiatrists (or 125 total physicians from Mexico, including renewed participants).
- Commencing January 1, 2029, no more than 145 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2033, no more than 175 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2037, no more than 210 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
- Commencing January 1, 2041, no more than 220 physicians from Mexico in the program, including up to 40 psychiatrists.
This bill would then reestablish the component of the prior pilot program relating to dentists from Mexico as the Licensed Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program. To date, no dentists from Mexico have been able to participate in the pilot program, with supporters of the program prioritizing physicians in the early stages of implementation. The intent of the author and sponsors of this bill is to begin the process of allowing dentists to participate in a recodified pilot program within the Dental Practice Act.
With the above provisions, among other less significant changes, the pilot program will be significantly expanded from its inceptive form under AB 1045. The primary care access crisis has only grown more apparent over the past two decades, with even greater attention afforded to the stark health care inequities in California communities. It can also be argued that there is now less instinctive skepticism of immigrant professionals than there was when AB 1045 was negotiated, particularly given the cultural and linguistic competence that providers from Mexico inherently offer. The Legislature may therefore consider it to now be the appropriate time to expand the pilot program and allow it to fulfill the vision originally conceived by its creators.
Current Related Legislation.
Assembly Bill 2864 (Garcia) would require the MBC to extend the licenses of physicians participating in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program by an additional three years. This bill is pending in this committee.
Prior Related Legislation.
AB 1395 (Garcia, Chapter 205, Statutes of 2023) requires the MBC to issue a license to applicants for participation in the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program who do not currently possess federal documentation but otherwise meet the pilot program’s requirements, and authorizes the MBC to extend a pilot program participant’s license under certain conditions.
AB 1396 (Garcia) from 2023 was substantially similar to AB 1395. This bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 1045 (Firebaugh, Chapter 1157, Statutes of 2002) established the Licensed Physicians and Dentists from Mexico Pilot Program.
AB 2394 (Firebaugh, Chapter 802, Statutes of 2000) created the Task Force on Culturally and Linguistically Competent Physicians and Dentists and required its subcommittee to examine the feasibility of establishing a pilot program that would allow Mexican and Caribbean licensed physicians and dentists to practice in nonprofit community health centers in California’s medically underserved areas.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas (CSVS) is co-sponsoring this bill. CSVS writes: “Through our active participation in the Doctors from Mexico Pilot Program, we have witnessed firsthand the profound impact that these dedicated professionals have made in our service areas. From their arrival in CY 2022 to December 2023, our physicians had a total of 81,587 patient visits. In addition to this increase in patient visits, all eleven physicians have proven to be culturally responsive to the needs of our patients. They have made our patients feel comfortable with familiar linguistic flourishes, adapting to incorporate traditional healing practices into the patient’s treatment plan, and understanding their culturally specific words or beliefs about illness.”
The advocacy affiliate of the California Primary Care Association (CPCA) is also co-sponsoring this bill, writing: “Many health centers are interested in participating and hosting eligible physicians to bring culturally and linguistically competent physicians to provide care to communities in need. As the committee well knows, the physician shortage, particularly in rural and underserved communities, is at a critical point; efforts to bring in highly trained physicians from Mexico to provide care in disenfranchised communities must be prioritized.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
As the program allowing for physicians from Mexico to serve patients in California clinics is intended to expand, there is a consensus that additional revenue will be needed to sustain the MBC’s oversight and enforcement functions in regards to those temporarily licensed physicians. Stakeholders have therefore agreed that language should be added to the bill establishing fees that would be charged in association with the issuance of the temporary license. While the precise dollar amount needed for this fee has not yet been determined, the author has expressed a commitment to amend the bill to reflect the eventual inclusion of a specific license fee.
AMENDMENTS:
At the request of the author, amend paragraphs 4, 6, and 7 of subdivision (e) in Section 4 of the bill as follows:
(4) The federally qualified health centers employing physicians from Mexico shall continue the peer review protocols and procedures as required by the federal government. The federally qualified health centers shall work with the University of California at San Francisco (UCSF) School of Medicine to have UCSF conduct 10 secondary reviews of randomly selected visit encounters per quarter six-month period, and the reviews shall be transmitted to UCSF in PDF format. The secondary reviews shall be undertaken the fourth, eighth, and twelfth month every six months of each year for the three years that the physicians from Mexico are employed by federally qualified health centers. UCSF faculty reviewers in family medicine, pediatrics, internal medicine, and obstetrics and gynecology shall provide feedback to the federally qualified health centers of the findings of their secondary reviews. UCSF faculty and federally qualified health center chief medical officers shall jointly develop no less than two quality assurance (QA) seminars for all physicians from Mexico to attend during the three six months of secondary reviews conducted. The purpose of UCSF secondary peer reviews shall be to provide feedback on compliance with medical standards, protocols, and procedures required by the federal government and assessed by the monthly or quarterly peer reviews conducted by federally qualified health centers. The associated costs for the UCSF secondary reviews and QA seminars shall be the responsibility of the federally qualified health centers on a pro-rata basis.
…
(6) Participating hospitals shall have the authority to establish criteria necessary to allow individuals participating in this three-year pilot program to be granted hospital privileges in their facilities, taking into consideration the need and concerns for access to patient populations served by federally qualified health centers and attending doctors from Mexico, especially in rural areas that do not have hospitals staffed to provide deliveries of newborns.
(7) Any funding necessary for the implementation of the program and oversight functions shall be secured from donations or nonprofit philanthropic entities organizations. Implementation of this program shall not proceed unless appropriate funding is secured from donations or nonprofit philanthropic entities organizations. Notwithstanding Section 11005 of the Government Code, the board may accept funds from donations and nonprofit philanthropic entities organizations. The board shall, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, expend funds received from donations and nonprofit philanthropic entities organizations for this program.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Primary Care Association (Co-Sponsor)
Clinica De Salud Del Valle De Salinas (Co-Sponsor)
Alameda Health Consortium - San Leandro, CA
AltaMed Health Services
Altura Centers for Health
Arroyo Vista Family Health Center
CaliforniaHealth+ Advocates
CommuniCare+OLE
Community Health Partnership
Comprehensive Community Health Centers
Dientes Community Dental
Eisner Health
El Proyecto Del Barrio
Family Health Centers of San Diego
Golden Valley Health Centers
Gracelight Community Health
Health Alliance of Northern California
Health and Life Organization (Sacramento Community Clinics)
Health Center Partners of Southern California
Lifelong Medical Care
Medical Board of California (If Amended)
North Coast Clinics Network
Petaluma Health Center
Redwoods Rural Health Center
Sac Health
San Benito Health Foundation
San Francisco Community Clinic Consortium
Share Our Selves
Shasta Community Health Center
South Central Family Health Center
The Children’s Clinic (TCC Family Health)
West County Health Centers
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Liu M, Wadhera RK. Primary Care Physician Supply by County-Level Characteristics, 2010-2019. ↑
https://latino.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/The_Patient_Perspective-UCLA-LPPI-Final.pdf ↑
https://www.chcf.org/publication/health-workforce-strategies-california ↑
https://ahea.assembly.ca.gov/media/1665 ↑
https://www.chcf.org/blog/doctors-mexico-treat-farmworkers-rural-california ↑
A copy of the Subcommittee’s report is available for review in the Government Publications section of the California State Library. ↑
Quintanilla, Esther. “In California, doctors from Mexico help fill the need for some patients. ‘As good as any doctor.’” Valley Public Radio, September 28, 2023. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):