AB 3079: In-Home Supportive Services program: undocumented related providers.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-25
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law provides for the county-administered In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS) program, under which qualified aged, blind, and disabled persons are provided with services in order to permit them to remain in their own homes and avoid institutionalization. Existing law establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services, under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. Existing law authorizes certain Medi-Cal recipients to receive waiver personal care services in order to permit them to remain in their own homes. Existing law permits services to be provided under the IHSS program either through the employment of individual providers, a contract between the county and an entity for the provision of services, the creation by the county of a public authority, or a contract between the county and a nonprofit consortium.
This bill would require the department, by March 1, 2025, or when the Case Management Information and Payrolling System (CMIPS) can implement the necessary automation changes, whichever is later, to develop and issue guidance, in consultation with specified entities, to ensure that individuals without satisfactory immigration status, as defined, are able to receive IHSS benefits using a provider of their choice, including a provider who is related to the 5th degree to the recipient, as specified, and who has, or is in the process of obtaining, an individual taxpayer identification number. The bill would require the department, by January 1, 2025, and in consultation with specified stakeholders, to develop recommendations to enable any recipient of services to select a related provider of their choice, as specified.
Existing law requires a county to investigate the background of a person who seeks to become a supportive services provider or is already providing those services, and who is not listed on the registry of a public authority or nonprofit consortium. Existing law requires that investigation to include criminal background checks conducted by the Department of Justice, as prescribed. Existing law requires the county to deny or terminate an individuals request to provide IHSS upon notice from the Department of Justice that the person has a conviction for any specified offense.
This bill would exempt a person who meets the requirements to be a related provider of IHSS, as described above, or who is related to the 5th degree to the IHSS recipient from those criminal background check requirements, but would require the person to attest to any convictions for the specified offenses. The bill would prohibit a person with a conviction for any of those offenses from providing IHSS.
Under existing law, a new applicant to provide in-home supportive services, or a person whose application has been denied on the basis of a conviction and for whom an appeal of that denial is pending, is ineligible to provide or receive payment for providing supportive services for 10 years following a conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, specified felony offenses. Existing law permits a recipient who wishes to employ a provider applicant who has been convicted of one of the specified offenses to submit to the county an individual waiver of the exclusion provided for in those provisions.
This bill would require a person who meets the requirements to be a related provider of IHSS, as described above, or who is related to the 5th degree to the IHSS recipient to attest to any convictions for an offense subject to the 10-year exclusion. The bill would permit a recipient of IHSS who wishes to employ a related provider applicant who has been convicted of an eligible offense to submit to the county an individual waiver of that exclusion.
To the extent that these provisions would increase duties of counties administering the IHSS program, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law provides for the county-administered In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS) program, under which qualified aged, blind, and disabled persons are provided with services in order to permit them to remain in their own homes and avoid institutionalization. Existing law establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services, under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. Existing law authorizes certain Medi-Cal recipients to receive waiver personal care services in order to permit them to remain in their own homes. Existing law permits services to be provided under the IHSS program either through the employment of individual providers, a contract between the county and an entity for the provision of services, the creation by the county of a public authority, or a contract between the county and a nonprofit consortium.
This bill would require the department, by March 1, 2025, or when the Case Management Information and Payrolling System (CMIPS) can implement the necessary automation changes, whichever is later, to develop and issue guidance, in consultation with specified entities, to ensure that individuals without satisfactory immigration status, as defined, are able to receive IHSS benefits using a provider of their choice, including a provider who is related to the 5th degree to the recipient, as specified, and who has, or is in the process of obtaining, an individual taxpayer identification number. The bill would require the department, by January 1, 2025, and in consultation with specified stakeholders, to develop recommendations to enable any recipient of services to select a related provider of their choice, as specified.
Existing law requires a county to investigate the background of a person who seeks to become a supportive services provider or is already providing those services, and who is not listed on the registry of a public authority or nonprofit consortium. Existing law requires that investigation to include criminal background checks conducted by the Department of Justice, as prescribed. Existing law requires the county to deny or terminate an individuals request to provide IHSS upon notice from the Department of Justice that the person has a conviction for any specified offense.
This bill would exempt a person who meets the requirements to be a related provider of IHSS, as described above, from those criminal background check requirements, but would require the person to attest to any convictions for the specified offenses. The bill would prohibit a person with a conviction for any of those offenses from providing IHSS.
Under existing law, a new applicant to provide in-home supportive services, or a person whose application has been denied on the basis of a conviction and for whom an appeal of that denial is pending, is ineligible to provide or receive payment for providing supportive services for 10 years following a conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, specified felony offenses. Existing law permits a recipient who wishes to employ a provider applicant who has been convicted of one of the specified offenses to submit to the county an individual waiver of the exclusion provided for in those provisions.
This bill would require a person who meets the requirements to be a related provider of IHSS, as described above, to attest to any convictions for an offense subject to the 10-year exclusion. The bill would permit a recipient of IHSS who wishes to employ a related provider applicant who has been convicted of an eligible offense to submit to the county an individual waiver of that exclusion.
To the extent that these provisions would increase duties of counties administering the IHSS program, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(a)(1)Effective October 1, 2009, a county shall investigate the background of a person who seeks to become a supportive services provider and who is not listed on the registry of a public authority or nonprofit consortium pursuant to Section 12301.6. This investigation shall include criminal background checks conducted by the Department of Justice pursuant to Section 15660.
(2)(A)A person who meets the criteria specified in subdivision (a) of Section 12305.9 or who is related to the fifth degree to the IHSS recipient shall be exempt from the requirements of this subdivision, but shall attest to any convictions that violate the provisions of Section 12305.81. Any person who attests to a conviction pursuant to Section 12305.81 shall be prohibited from providing in-home supportive services.
(B)For purposes of this section, fifth degree means any person who, by blood, adoption, or marriage, is a spouse, child, grandchild, great-grandchild, parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, great-great-grandparent, sibling, nephew or niece, grandnephew or grandniece, great-grandnephew or great-grandniece, uncle or aunt, great-uncle or great-aunt, great-granduncle or great-grandaunt, first cousin, or first cousin once removed of the IHSS recipient.
(b)No later than July 1, 2010, the county shall complete a criminal background check pursuant to subdivision (a) for a provider who is providing in-home supportive services prior to October 1, 2009, and who is not listed on a public authority or nonprofit consortium registry, as a condition of the providers continued enrollment in the IHSS program. Criminal background checks shall be conducted at the providers expense.
(c)(1)Upon notice from the Department of Justice that a prospective or current provider has been convicted of a criminal offense specified in Section 12305.81, the county shall deny or terminate the applicants request to become a provider of supportive services to any recipient of the In-Home Supportive Services program.
(2)Commencing 90 days after the effective date of the act that adds Section 12305.87, and upon notice from the Department of Justice that an applicant who is subject to the provisions of that section has been convicted of, or incarcerated following conviction for, an offense described in subdivision (b) of that section, the county shall deny the applicants request to become a provider of supportive services to any recipient of in-home supportive services, subject to the individual waiver and exception processes described in that section. An applicant who is denied on the basis of Section 12305.87 shall be informed by the county of the individual waiver and exception processes described in that section.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the county shall provide an individual with a copy of the individuals state-level criminal offender record information search response as provided to the county by the Department of Justice if the individual has been denied eligibility to provide supportive services to any recipient of the In-Home Supportive Services program based on this information. The copy of the state-level criminal offender record information search response shall be included with the individuals notice of denial. Along with the notice of denial, the county shall also provide information in plain language on how an individual may contest the accuracy and completeness of, and refute any erroneous or inaccurate information in, their state-level criminal offender record information search response as provided by the Department of Justice as authorized by Section 11126 of the Penal Code. The state-level criminal offender record information search response shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(4)The department shall develop a written appeal process for the current and prospective providers who are determined ineligible to receive payment for the provision of services under the In-Home Supportive Services program. Notwithstanding any other law, the county shall provide the department with a copy of the state-level criminal offender record information search response as provided to the county by the Department of Justice for any individual who has requested an appeal based upon a denial of eligibility to provide supportive services to any recipient of the In-Home Supportive Services program pursuant to Sections 12305.81 and 12305.87. The state-level criminal offender record information search response shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(d)This section does not prohibit the Department of Justice from assessing a fee pursuant to Section 11105 or 11123 of the Penal Code to cover the cost of furnishing summary criminal history information.
(e)A county authorized to secure a criminal background check clearance pursuant to this section shall accept a clearance for an individual described in subdivision (a) or (b) who has been deemed eligible by another nonprofit consortium, public authority, or county with criminal background check authority pursuant to either Section 12301.6 or this section, to receive payment for providing services pursuant to this article. Existence of a clearance shall be determined by verification through the case management, information, and payrolling system, that another county, nonprofit consortium, or public authority with criminal background check authority pursuant to Section 12301.6 or this section has deemed the current or prospective provider to be eligible to receive payment for providing services pursuant to this article.
(f)The department shall seek federal financial participation, to the extent possible, to cover any costs associated with this section.
SEC. 2.Section 12305.87 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:12305.87.(a)(1)Commencing 90 days following the effective date of the act that adds this section, a person specified in paragraph (2) shall be subject to the criminal conviction exclusions provided for in this section, in addition to the exclusions required under Section 12305.81.
(2)This section shall apply to a person who satisfies either of the following conditions:
(A)The person is a new applicant to provide services under this article.
(B)The person is an applicant to provide services under this article whose application has been denied on the basis of a conviction and for whom an appeal of that denial is pending.
(b)(1)Subject to subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), an applicant subject to this section shall not be eligible to provide or receive payment for providing supportive services for 10 years following a conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, any of the following:
(A)A violent or serious felony, as specified in subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code and subdivision (c) of Section 1192.7 of the Penal Code.
(B)A felony offense for which a person is required to register under subdivision (c) of Section 290 of the Penal Code. For purposes of this paragraph, the 10-year time period specified in this section shall commence with the date of conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, the underlying offense, and not the date of registration.
(C)A felony offense described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) or paragraph (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 10980.
(2)(A)A person who meets the criteria specified in subdivision (a) of Section 12305.9 or who is related to the fifth degree to the IHSS recipient shall attest to any convictions specified in paragraph (1). Notwithstanding paragraph (1), a recipient of services under this article who wishes to employ their related provider who has been convicted of an offense specified in paragraph (1) may submit to the county an individual waiver of the exclusion provided for in this section.
(B)For purposes of this section, fifth degree means any person who, by blood, adoption, or marriage, is a spouse, child, grandchild, great-grandchild, parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, great-great-grandparent, sibling, nephew or niece, grandnephew or grandniece, great-grandnephew or great-grandniece, uncle or aunt, great-uncle or great-aunt, great-granduncle or great-grandaunt, first cousin, or first cousin once removed of the IHSS recipient.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), an application shall not be denied under this section if the applicant has obtained a certificate of rehabilitation under Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 4852.01) of Title 6 of Part 3 of the Penal Code or if the information or accusation against the applicant has been dismissed pursuant to Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a recipient of services under this article who wishes to employ a provider applicant who has been convicted of an offense specified in subdivision (b) may submit to the county an individual waiver of the exclusion provided for in this section. This paragraph shall not be construed to allow a recipient to submit an individual waiver with respect to a conviction or convictions for offenses specified in Section 12305.81.
(2)The county shall notify a recipient who wishes to hire a person who is applying to be a provider and who has been convicted of an offense subject to exclusion under this section of that applicants relevant criminal offense convictions that are covered by subdivision (b). The notice shall include both of the following:
(A)A summary explanation of the exclusions created by subdivision (b), as well as the applicable waiver process described in this subdivision and the process for an applicant to seek a general exception, as described in subdivision (e). This summary explanation shall be developed by the department for use by all counties.
(B)An individual waiver form, which shall also be developed by the department and used by all counties. The waiver form shall include both of the following:
(i)A space for the county to include a reference to any Penal Code sections and corresponding offense names or descriptions that describe the relevant conviction or convictions that are covered by subdivision (b) and that the provider applicant has in their background.
(ii)A statement that the service recipient, or their authorized representative, if applicable, is aware of the applicants conviction or convictions and agrees to waive application of this section and employ the applicant as a provider of services under this article.
(3)To ensure that the initial summary explanation referenced in this subdivision is comprehensible for recipients and provider applicants, the department shall consult with representatives of county welfare departments and advocates for, or representatives of, recipients and providers in developing the summary explanation and offense descriptions.
(4)The individual waiver form shall be signed by the recipient, or by the recipients authorized representative, if applicable, and returned to the county welfare department by mail or in person. Except for a parent, guardian, or person having legal custody of a minor recipient, a conservator of an adult recipient, or a spouse or registered domestic partner of a recipient, a provider applicant shall not sign their own individual waiver form as the recipients authorized representative. The county shall retain the waiver form and a copy of the provider applicants criminal offense record information search response until the date that the convictions that are the subject of the waiver request are no longer within the 10-year period specified in subdivision (b).
(5)An individual waiver submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall entitle a recipient to hire a provider applicant who otherwise meets all applicable enrollment requirements for the In-Home Supportive Services program. A provider hired pursuant to an individual waiver may be employed only by the recipient who requested that waiver, and the waiver shall only be valid with respect to convictions that are specified in that waiver. A new waiver shall be required if the provider is subsequently convicted of an offense to which this section otherwise would apply. A provider who wishes to be listed on a provider registry or to provide supportive services to a recipient who has not requested an individual waiver shall be required to apply for a general exception, as provided for in subdivision (e).
(6)This section does not preclude a provider who is eligible to receive payment for services provided pursuant to an individual waiver under this subdivision from being eligible to receive payment for services provided to one or more additional recipients who obtain waivers pursuant to this same subdivision.
(7)The state and a county shall be immune from any liability resulting from granting an individual waiver under this subdivision.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), an applicant who has been convicted of an offense identified in subdivision (b) may seek from the department a general exception to the exclusion provided for in this section.
(2)Upon receipt of a general exception request, the department shall request a copy of the applicants criminal offender record information search response from the applicable county welfare department, public authority, or nonprofit consortium. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the county, public authority, or nonprofit consortium shall provide a copy of the criminal offender record information search response, as provided to the county, public authority, or nonprofit consortium by the Department of Justice, to the department. The county, public authority, or nonprofit consortium shall provide this information in a manner that protects the confidentiality and privacy of the criminal offender record information search response. The state or federal criminal history record information search response shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(3)The department shall consider the following factors when determining whether to grant a general exception under this subdivision:
(A)The nature and seriousness of the conduct or crime under consideration and its relationship to employment duties and responsibilities.
(B)The persons activities since conviction, including, but not limited to, employment or participation in therapy education, or community service, that would indicate changed behavior.
(C)The number of convictions and the time that has elapsed since the conviction or convictions.
(D)The extent to which the person has complied with any terms of parole, probation, restitution, or any other sanction lawfully imposed against the person.
(E)Any evidence of rehabilitation, including character references, submitted by the person, or by others on the persons behalf.
(F)Employment history and current or former employer recommendations. Additional consideration shall be given to employer recommendations provided by a person who has received or has indicated a desire to receive supportive or personal care services from the applicant, including, but not limited to, those services, specified in Section 12300.
(G)Circumstances surrounding the commission of the offense that would demonstrate the unlikelihood of repetition.
(H)The granting by the Governor of a full and unconditional pardon.
(f)If the department makes a determination to deny an application to provide services pursuant to a request for a general exception, the department shall notify the applicant of this determination by either personal service or registered mail. The notice shall include the following information:
(1)A statement of the departments reasons for the denial that evaluates evidence of rehabilitation submitted by the applicant, if any, and that specifically addresses any evidence submitted relating to the factors in paragraph (3) of subdivision (e).
(2)A copy of the applicants criminal offender record information search response, even if the applicant already has received a copy pursuant to Section 12301.6 or 12305.86. The department shall provide this information in a manner that protects the confidentiality and privacy of the criminal offender record information search response.
(A)The state or federal criminal history record shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(B)The department shall retain a copy of each individuals criminal offender record information search response until the date that the convictions that are the subject of the exception are no longer within the 10-year period specified in subdivision (b), and shall record the date the copy of the response was provided to the individual and the department.
(C)The criminal offender record information search response shall not be made available by the department to any individual other than the provider applicant.
(g)(1)Upon written notification that the department has determined that a request for exception shall be denied, the applicant may request an administrative hearing by submitting a written request to the department within 15 business days of receipt of the written notification. Upon receipt of a written request, the department shall hold an administrative hearing consistent with the procedures specified in Section 100171 of the Health and Safety Code, except where those procedures are inconsistent with this section.
(2)A hearing under this subdivision shall be conducted by a hearing officer or administrative law judge designated by the director. A written decision shall be sent by certified mail to the applicant.
(h)The department shall revise the provider enrollment form developed pursuant to Section 12305.81 to include both of the following:
(1)The text of subdivision (c) of Section 290 of the Penal Code, subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code, subdivision (c) of Section 1192.7 of the Penal Code, and paragraph (2) of subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 10980.
(2)A statement that the provider understands that if they have been convicted, or incarcerated following conviction for, any of the crimes specified in the provisions identified in paragraph (b) in the last 10 years, and has not received a certificate of rehabilitation or had the information or accusation dismissed, as provided in subdivision (c), they shall only be authorized to receive payment for providing in-home supportive services under an individual waiver or general exception as described in this section, and upon meeting all other applicable criteria for enrollment as a provider in the program.
(i)(1)Notwithstanding the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), the department may implement and administer this section through all-county letters or similar instructions from the department until regulations are adopted. The department shall adopt emergency regulations implementing these provisions no later than July 1, 2011. The department may readopt any emergency regulation authorized by this section that is the same as or substantially equivalent to an emergency regulation previously adopted under this section.
(2)The initial adoption of emergency regulations pursuant to this section and one readoption of emergency regulations shall be deemed an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare. Initial emergency regulations and the one readoption of emergency regulations authorized by this section shall be exempt from review by the Office of Administrative Law. The initial emergency regulations and the one readoption of emergency regulations authorized by this section shall be submitted to the Office of Administrative Law for filing with the Secretary of State and each shall remain in effect for no more than 180 days, by which time final regulations may be adopted.
(j)In developing the individual waiver form and all-county letters or information notices or similar instructions, the department shall consult with stakeholders, including, but not limited to, representatives of the county welfare departments, and representatives of consumers and providers. The consultation shall include at least one in-person meeting prior to the finalization of the individual waiver form and all-county letters or information notices or similar instructions.
SEC. 3.Section 12305.9 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:12305.9.(a)No later than March 1, 2025, or when the Case Management Information and Payrolling System (CMIPS) can implement the necessary automation changes, whichever is later, the department shall develop and issue guidance, in consultation with aging and disability advocates, provider representatives, immigration and employment law nonprofit organizations, such as the Center for Immigration Law and Policy at the University of California, Los Angeles, School of Law, and the National Employment Law Project, the California Association of Public Authorities, and the County Welfare Directors Association, to ensure that individuals without satisfactory immigration status, as described by subdivision (a) of Section 14007.8, are afforded access to IHSS program benefits by a provider of their choice, including a person who meets the following criteria:
(1)The person is related to the fifth degree to the IHSS recipient. For purposes of this section, fifth degree means any person who, by blood, adoption, or marriage that marriage, is a spouse, child, grandchild, great-grandchild, parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, great-great-grandparent, sibling, nephew or niece, grandnephew or grandniece, great-grandnephew or great-grandniece, uncle or aunt, great-uncle or great-aunt, great-granduncle or great-grandaunt, first cousin, or first cousin once removed of the IHSS recipient.
(2)(A)The person has obtained, or is in the process of obtaining, an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN).
(B)The guidance issued pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include a process for enrollment of persons as a provider using an ITIN in lieu of a social security number, and a process of enrollment for prospective providers who are in process of obtaining an ITIN.
(3)An individual who is unable to provide a social security number due to immigration status shall be eligible to provide services pursuant to this subdivision if all other requirements pursuant to this chapter are met.
(b)No later than January 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the stakeholders listed in subdivision (a), shall develop recommendations to enable any recipient of services to select a related provider of their choice as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). The provisions of paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) shall apply.
(c)This section does not change the nature of any employment relationship between providers and recipients, the county, public authority, nonprofit consortium, or state.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)Effective October 1, 2009, a county shall investigate the background of a person who seeks to become a supportive services provider and who is not listed on the registry of a public authority or nonprofit consortium pursuant to Section 12301.6. This investigation shall include criminal background checks conducted by the Department of Justice pursuant to Section 15660.
(2)A person who meets the criteria specified in subdivision (a) of Section 12305.9 shall be exempt from the requirements of this subdivision, but shall attest to any convictions that violate the provisions of Section 12305.81. Any person who attests to a conviction pursuant to Section 12305.81 shall be prohibited from providing in-home supportive services.
(b)No later than July 1, 2010, the county shall complete a criminal background check pursuant to subdivision (a) for a provider who is providing in-home supportive services prior to October 1, 2009, and who is not listed on a public authority or nonprofit consortium registry, as a condition of the providers continued enrollment in the IHSS program. Criminal background checks shall be conducted at the providers expense.
(c)(1)Upon notice from the Department of Justice that a prospective or current provider has been convicted of a criminal offense specified in Section 12305.81, the county shall deny or terminate the applicants request to become a provider of supportive services to any recipient of the In-Home Supportive Services program.
(2)Commencing 90 days after the effective date of the act that adds Section 12305.87, and upon notice from the Department of Justice that an applicant who is subject to the provisions of that section has been convicted of, or incarcerated following conviction for, an offense described in subdivision (b) of that section, the county shall deny the applicants request to become a provider of supportive services to any recipient of in-home supportive services, subject to the individual waiver and exception processes described in that section. An applicant who is denied on the basis of Section 12305.87 shall be informed by the county of the individual waiver and exception processes described in that section.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the county shall provide an individual with a copy of his or her the individuals state-level criminal offender record information search response as provided to the county by the Department of Justice if the individual has been denied eligibility to provide supportive services to any recipient of the In-Home Supportive Services program based on this information. The copy of the state-level criminal offender record information search response shall be included with the individuals notice of denial. Along with the notice of denial, the county shall also provide information in plain language on how an individual may contest the accuracy and completeness of, and refute any erroneous or inaccurate information in, his or her their state-level criminal offender record information search response as provided by the Department of Justice as authorized by Section 11126 of the Penal Code. The state-level criminal offender record information search response shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(4)The department shall develop a written appeal process for the current and prospective providers who are determined ineligible to receive payment for the provision of services under the In-Home Supportive Services program. Notwithstanding any other law, the county shall provide the department with a copy of the state-level criminal offender record information search response as provided to the county by the Department of Justice for any individual who has requested an appeal based upon a denial of eligibility to provide supportive services to any recipient of the In-Home Supportive Services program pursuant to Sections 12305.81 and 12305.87. The state-level criminal offender record information search response shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(d)This section shall not be construed to does not prohibit the Department of Justice from assessing a fee pursuant to Section 11105 or 11123 of the Penal Code to cover the cost of furnishing summary criminal history information.
(e)A county authorized to secure a criminal background check clearance pursuant to this section shall accept a clearance for an individual described in subdivision (a) or (b) who has been deemed eligible by another nonprofit consortium, public authority, or county with criminal background check authority pursuant to either Section 12301.6 or this section, to receive payment for providing services pursuant to this article. Existence of a clearance shall be determined by verification through the case management, information, and payrolling system, that another county, nonprofit consortium, or public authority with criminal background check authority pursuant to Section 12301.6 or this section has deemed the current or prospective provider to be eligible to receive payment for providing services pursuant to this article.
(f)The department shall seek federal financial participation, to the extent possible, to cover any costs associated with this section.
SEC. 2.Section 12305.87 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:12305.87.(a)(1)Commencing 90 days following the effective date of the act that adds this section, a person specified in paragraph (2) shall be subject to the criminal conviction exclusions provided for in this section, in addition to the exclusions required under Section 12305.81.
(2)This section shall apply to a person who satisfies either of the following conditions:
(A)He or she The person is a new applicant to provide services under this article.
(B)He or she The person is an applicant to provide services under this article whose application has been denied on the basis of a conviction and for whom an appeal of that denial is pending.
(b)(1)Subject to subdivisions (c), (d), and (e), an applicant subject to this section shall not be eligible to provide or receive payment for providing supportive services for 10 years following a conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, any of the following:
(1)(A)A violent or serious felony, as specified in subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code and subdivision (c) of Section 1192.7 of the Penal Code.
(2)(B)A felony offense for which a person is required to register under subdivision (c) of Section 290 of the Penal Code. For purposes of this paragraph, the 10-year time period specified in this section shall commence with the date of conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, the underlying offense, and not the date of registration.
(3)(C)A felony offense described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) or paragraph (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 10980.
(2)A person who meets the criteria specified in subdivision (a) of Section 12305.9 shall attest to any convictions specified in paragraph (1). Notwithstanding paragraph (1), a recipient of services under this article who wishes to employ their related provider who has been convicted of an offense specified in paragraph (1) may submit to the county an individual waiver of the exclusion provided for in this section.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), an application shall not be denied under this section if the applicant has obtained a certificate of rehabilitation under Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 4852.01) of Title 6 of Part 3 of the Penal Code or if the information or accusation against him or her the applicant has been dismissed pursuant to Section 1203.4 of the Penal Code.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a recipient of services under this article who wishes to employ a provider applicant who has been convicted of an offense specified in subdivision (b) may submit to the county an individual waiver of the exclusion provided for in this section. This paragraph shall not be construed to allow a recipient to submit an individual waiver with respect to a conviction or convictions for offenses specified in Section 12305.81.
(2)The county shall notify a recipient who wishes to hire a person who is applying to be a provider and who has been convicted of an offense subject to exclusion under this section of that applicants relevant criminal offense convictions that are covered by subdivision (b). The notice shall include both of the following:
(A)A summary explanation of the exclusions created by subdivision (b), as well as the applicable waiver process described in this subdivision and the process for an applicant to seek a general exception, as described in subdivision (e). This summary explanation shall be developed by the department for use by all counties.
(B)An individual waiver form, which shall also be developed by the department and used by all counties. The waiver form shall include both of the following:
(i)A space for the county to include a reference to any Penal Code sections and corresponding offense names or descriptions that describe the relevant conviction or convictions that are covered by subdivision (b) and that the provider applicant has in his or her their background.
(ii)A statement that the service recipient, or his or her their authorized representative, if applicable, is aware of the applicants conviction or convictions and agrees to waive application of this section and employ the applicant as a provider of services under this article.
(3)To ensure that the initial summary explanation referenced in this subdivision is comprehensible for recipients and provider applicants, the department shall consult with representatives of county welfare departments and advocates for, or representatives of, recipients and providers in developing the summary explanation and offense descriptions.
(4)The individual waiver form shall be signed by the recipient, or by the recipients authorized representative, if applicable, and returned to the county welfare department by mail or in person. Except for a parent, guardian, or person having legal custody of a minor recipient, a conservator of an adult recipient, or a spouse or registered domestic partner of a recipient, a provider applicant shall not sign his or her their own individual waiver form as the recipients authorized representative. The county shall retain the waiver form and a copy of the provider applicants criminal offense record information search response until the date that the convictions that are the subject of the waiver request are no longer within the 10-year period specified in subdivision (b).
(5)An individual waiver submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall entitle a recipient to hire a provider applicant who otherwise meets all applicable enrollment requirements for the In-Home Supportive Services program. A provider hired pursuant to an individual waiver may be employed only by the recipient who requested that waiver, and the waiver shall only be valid with respect to convictions that are specified in that waiver. A new waiver shall be required if the provider is subsequently convicted of an offense to which this section otherwise would apply. A provider who wishes to be listed on a provider registry or to provide supportive services to a recipient who has not requested an individual waiver shall be required to apply for a general exception, as provided for in subdivision (e).
(6)Nothing in this section shall This section does not preclude a provider who is eligible to receive payment for services provided pursuant to an individual waiver under this subdivision from being eligible to receive payment for services provided to one or more additional recipients who obtain waivers pursuant to this same subdivision.
(7)The state and a county shall be immune from any liability resulting from granting an individual waiver under this subdivision.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), an applicant who has been convicted of an offense identified in subdivision (b) may seek from the department a general exception to the exclusion provided for in this section.
(2)Upon receipt of a general exception request, the department shall request a copy of the applicants criminal offender record information search response from the applicable county welfare department, public authority, or nonprofit consortium. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the county, public authority, or nonprofit consortium shall provide a copy of the criminal offender record information search response, as provided to the county, public authority, or nonprofit consortium by the Department of Justice, to the department. The county, public authority, or nonprofit consortium shall provide this information in a manner that protects the confidentiality and privacy of the criminal offender record information search response. The state or federal criminal history record information search response shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(3)The department shall consider the following factors when determining whether to grant a general exception under this subdivision:
(A)The nature and seriousness of the conduct or crime under consideration and its relationship to employment duties and responsibilities.
(B)The persons activities since conviction, including, but not limited to, employment or participation in therapy education, or community service, that would indicate changed behavior.
(C)The number of convictions and the time that has elapsed since the conviction or convictions.
(D)The extent to which the person has complied with any terms of parole, probation, restitution, or any other sanction lawfully imposed against the person.
(E)Any evidence of rehabilitation, including character references, submitted by the person, or by others on the persons behalf.
(F)Employment history and current or former employer recommendations. Additional consideration shall be given to employer recommendations provided by a person who has received or has indicated a desire to receive supportive or personal care services from the applicant, including, but not limited to, those services, specified in Section 12300.
(G)Circumstances surrounding the commission of the offense that would demonstrate the unlikelihood of repetition.
(H)The granting by the Governor of a full and unconditional pardon.
(f)If the department makes a determination to deny an application to provide services pursuant to a request for a general exception, the department shall notify the applicant of this determination by either personal service or registered mail. The notice shall include the following information:
(1)A statement of the departments reasons for the denial that evaluates evidence of rehabilitation submitted by the applicant, if any, and that specifically addresses any evidence submitted relating to the factors in paragraph (3) of subdivision (e).
(2)A copy of the applicants criminal offender record information search response, even if the applicant already has received a copy pursuant to Section 12301.6 or 12305.86. The department shall provide this information in a manner that protects the confidentiality and privacy of the criminal offender record information search response.
(A)The state or federal criminal history record shall not be modified or altered from its form or content as provided by the Department of Justice.
(B)The department shall retain a copy of each individuals criminal offender record information search response until the date that the convictions that are the subject of the exception are no longer within the 10-year period specified in subdivision (b), and shall record the date the copy of the response was provided to the individual and the department.
(C)The criminal offender record information search response shall not be made available by the department to any individual other than the provider applicant.
(g)(1)Upon written notification that the department has determined that a request for exception shall be denied, the applicant may request an administrative hearing by submitting a written request to the department within 15 business days of receipt of the written notification. Upon receipt of a written request, the department shall hold an administrative hearing consistent with the procedures specified in Section 100171 of the Health and Safety Code, except where those procedures are inconsistent with this section.
(2)A hearing under this subdivision shall be conducted by a hearing officer or administrative law judge designated by the director. A written decision shall be sent by certified mail to the applicant.
(h)The department shall revise the provider enrollment form developed pursuant to Section 12305.81 to include both of the following:
(1)The text of subdivision (c) of Section 290 of the Penal Code, subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code, subdivision (c) of Section 1192.7 of the Penal Code, and paragraph (2) of subdivisions (c) and (g) of Section 10980.
(2)A statement that the provider understands that if he or she has they have been convicted, or incarcerated following conviction for, any of the crimes specified in the provisions identified in paragraph (b) in the last 10 years, and has not received a certificate of rehabilitation or had the information or accusation dismissed, as provided in subdivision (c), he or she they shall only be authorized to receive payment for providing in-home supportive services under an individual waiver or general exception as described in this section, and upon meeting all other applicable criteria for enrollment as a provider in the program.
(i)(1)Notwithstanding the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), the department may implement and administer this section through all-county letters or similar instructions from the department until regulations are adopted. The department shall adopt emergency regulations implementing these provisions no later than July 1, 2011. The department may readopt any emergency regulation authorized by this section that is the same as or substantially equivalent to an emergency regulation previously adopted under this section.
(2)The initial adoption of emergency regulations pursuant to this section and one readoption of emergency regulations shall be deemed an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare. Initial emergency regulations and the one readoption of emergency regulations authorized by this section shall be exempt from review by the Office of Administrative Law. The initial emergency regulations and the one readoption of emergency regulations authorized by this section shall be submitted to the Office of Administrative Law for filing with the Secretary of State and each shall remain in effect for no more than 180 days, by which time final regulations may be adopted.
(j)In developing the individual waiver form and all-county letters or information notices or similar instructions, the department shall consult with stakeholders, including, but not limited to, representatives of the county welfare departments, and representatives of consumers and providers. The consultation shall include at least one in-person meeting prior to the finalization of the individual waiver form and all-county letters or information notices or similar instructions.
SEC. 3.Section 12305.9 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:12305.9.(a)No later than March 1, 2025, or when the Case Management Information and Payrolling System (CMIPS) can implement the necessary automation changes, whichever is later, the department shall develop and issue guidance, in consultation with aging and disability advocates, provider representatives, immigration and employment law nonprofit organizations, such as the Center for Immigration Law and Policy at the University of California, Los Angeles, School of Law, and the National Employment Law Project, the California Association of Public Authorities, and the County Welfare Directors Association, to ensure that individuals without satisfactory immigration status, as described by subdivision (a) of Section 14007.8, are afforded access to IHSS program benefits by a provider of their choice, including a person who meets the following criteria:
(1)The person is related to the fifth degree to the IHSS recipient. For purposes of this section, fifth degree means any person by blood, adoption, or marriage that is a spouse, child, grandchild, great-grandchild, parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, great-great-grandparent, sibling, nephew or niece, grandnephew or grandniece, great-grandnephew or great-grandniece, uncle or aunt, great-uncle or great-aunt, great-granduncle or great-grandaunt, first cousin, or first cousin once removed of the IHSS recipient.
(2)(A) The person has obtained, or is in the process of obtaining, an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN).
(B)The guidance issued pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include a process for enrollment of persons as a provider using an ITIN in lieu of a social security number, and a process of enrollment for prospective providers who are in process of obtaining an ITIN.
(3)An individual who is unable to provide a social security number due to immigration status shall be eligible to provide services pursuant to this subdivision if all other requirements pursuant to this chapter are met.
(b)No later than January 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the stakeholders listed in subdivision (a), shall develop recommendations to enable any recipient of services to select a related provider of their choice as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a). The provisions of paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) shall apply.
(c)This section does not change the nature of any employment relationship between providers and recipients, the county, public authority, nonprofit consortium, or state.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2024 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 5215.) |
| May 15, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 29, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (April 23). |
| Apr 9, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 11, 2024 | Referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Feb 17, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Alzheimer'S Association, State Policy Office | ** Support | |
| alzheimer's greater los angeles | ** Support | |
| alzheimer's orange county | ** Support | |
| Alzheimer'S San Diego | ** Support | |
| California Domestic Workers Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Family Resource Association | ** Support | |
| Caring Across Generations | ** Support | |
| Child Abuse Prevention Center | ** Support | |
| City and County of San Francisco | ** Support | |
| County of Santa Clara | ** Support | |
| Family Caregiver Alliance | ** Support | |
| Justice in Aging | ** Support | |
| Latino Coalition for a Healthy California | ** Support | |
| Vision y Compromiso | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3079
Author:(Ting) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2024
Policy Committee: | Human Services | Vote: | 5 - 1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to develop and issue guidance to ensure undocumented immigrants are afforded access to become in-home supportive services (IHSS) providers for family members of the fifth-degree. Requires these providers be exempt from criminal background checks otherwise required for IHSS providers.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, by March 1, 2025, or when the Case Management Information and Payrolling System (CMIPS) can implement the necessary automation changes, whichever is later, CDSS to develop and issue guidance, in consultation with aging and disability advocates, provider representatives, immigration and employment law nonprofit organizations, to ensure individuals without satisfactory immigration status are afforded access to IHSS program benefits by a provider of their choice, including a person who meets the following criteria:
- The person is related to the fifth degree to the IHSS recipient. For purposes of these provisions, “fifth degree” means any person who is by blood, adoption, or marriage, a spouse, child, grandchild, great-grandchild, parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, great-great-grandparent, sibling, nephew or niece, grandnephew or grandniece, great-grandnephew or great-grandniece, uncle or aunt, great-uncle or great-aunt, great-granduncle or great-grandaunt, first cousin, or first cousin once removed of the IHSS recipient.
- The person has obtained, or is in the process of obtaining, an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN). Requires the guidance described above to include a process for enrolling a person as a provider using an ITIN in lieu of a Social Security number, and a process for enrolling a prospective provider who is in the process of obtaining an ITIN.
- Specifies an individual who is unable to provide a Social Security number due to immigration status is eligible to provide services if all other requirements pursuant to these provisions are met.
- Requires, no later than January 1, 2025, CDSS, in consultation with the stakeholders to develop recommendations to enable any recipient of services to select a related provider of their choice.
- Exempts a person who meets the criteria specified in 1, above, from a criminal background check, but requires the person attest to convictions that prohibit a person from providing IHSS services under existing law. Specifies a person who attests to a prohibited conviction is prohibited from providing IHSS.
- Permits a family member to employ a related provider who meets the criteria specified in 1, above, and who attested to a conviction that would otherwise prohibit the relative from providing IHSS.
FISCAL EFFECT:
CDSS anticipates significant one-time General Fund automation costs, potentially in the millions of dollars to reprogram CMIPS to account for the changes in the provider enrollment requirements.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In 2023, California took the groundbreaking step of expanding Medi-Cal eligibility to include undocumented people. As a result of that expansion, undocumented adults can now receive services through the state’s In Home Supportive Services (IHSS) program. While this is a huge step forward, California must do more to address healthcare inequities and increase access to care. The state needs to take action to address our longstanding home healthcare worker shortage. The vast majority of IHSS recipients rely on a family member or loved one to serve as their IHSS provider; yet, despite the IHSS workforce crisis, undocumented recipients are unable to select an undocumented family member to act as their provider. To help address this provider shortage, [This bill] authorizes undocumented IHSS recipients to select an undocumented family member to serve as their in home provider.
- Background. IHSS. IHSS allows eligible low-income individuals in California who are 65 years of age and older, living with a disability, or blind to access services that enable them to remain in their own homes and avoid premature institutional care. IHSS program providers are paid to assist with personal care services (such as bathing, toileting, and grooming), domestic and related services (meal preparation, housecleaning), paramedical services, and protective supervision. As of February 2023, there were 613,410 IHSS providers in California; 95.5% of providers are a relative, spouse, or parent of the recipient, and 55.6% of providers live in the same residence as the recipient. There are over 593,000 Californians who receive IHSS.
Eligible IHSS recipients must physically reside in the United States, be a California resident, be Medi-Cal qualified, live at home or in a place of their own choosing, which can include a licensed community care facility or long-term care facility, and complete a Health Care Certification form. IHSS is administered through counties. IHSS clients self-direct their care, which allows them to choose and hire their own providers, including friends and family. About 70% of IHSS providers are related to their clients.
IHSS provider applicants must complete an enrollment process, which includes submitting the necessary forms to the county, submitting fingerprint images to the Department of Justice (DOJ) for a criminal background check, and participating in a provider orientation.
In 2021, California expanded Medi-Cal benefits to qualified individuals regardless of immigration status. With this expansion, individuals who are undocumented, over 50 years of age, and otherwise qualified are also newly eligible for IHSS. However, undocumented recipients cannot select an undocumented family member to act as their provider due to immigration status.
The Department of Labor statistics show there are not enough direct care workers to meet population needs. To help address the labor shortage and to allow an undocumented IHSS recipient choose their preferred provider, this bill allows an IHSS recipient to hire an undocumented family-member provider. This bill exempts the provider from the usual background check requirements, but requires the person to attest to prohibited convictions.
Legal Questions. CDSS and the County Welfare Directors Association both assert this bill is not implementable due to the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) which bars employers from hiring undocumented immigrants. On the other hand, legal experts from the UCLA Center for Immigration Law and Policy offered a legal analysis that asserts the United States Supreme Court has upheld in multiple different cases that Congress cannot regulate state governments without clear language of its intentions. IRCA does not mention states which, according to this legal analysis, means IRCA does not apply to state government entities. Their legal analysis was issued to the University of California (UC) Board of Regents to advocate for Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) student’s right to work on campus. Ultimately, the UC Regents in January 2024 rejected the proposal to allow undocumented immigrants to be employed on UC campuses.
- Prior Legislation. AB 133 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021, expanded eligibility for full scope Medi-Cal to individuals who are 50 years of age or older, regardless of citizenship or immigration status, if otherwise eligible.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Alex Lee, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3079 (
Author:Ting) – As Introduced Ver:February 16, 2024
SUBJECT: In-Home Supportive Services program: undocumented related providers
SUMMARY: Requires, the California Department of Social Services (CDSS), to develop and issue guidance to ensure undocumented immigrants are afforded access to become in-home supportive services (IHSS) providers for family members of the fifth-degee. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, no later than March 1, 2025, or when the Case Management Information and Payrolling System can implement the necessary automation changes, whichever is later, CDSS to develop and issue guidance, in consultation with aging and disability advocates, provider representatives, immigration and employment law nonprofit organizations, such as the Center for Immigration Law and Policy at the University of California, Los Angeles, School of Law, and the National Employment Law Project, the California Association of Public Authorities, and the County Welfare Directors Association, to ensure that individuals without satisfactory immigration status, as described in 7) below, are afforded access to IHSS program benefits by a provider of their choice, including a person who meets the following criteria:
- The person is related to the fifth degree to the IHSS recipient. For purposes of these provisions, “fifth degree” means any person by blood, adoption, or marriage that is a spouse, child, grandchild, great-grandchild, parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, great-great-grandparent, sibling, nephew or niece, grandnephew or grandniece, great-grandnephew or great-grandniece, uncle or aunt, great-uncle or great-aunt, great-granduncle or great-grandaunt, first cousin, or first cousin once removed of the IHSS recipient;
- The person has obtained, or is in the process of obtaining, an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN). Requires the guidance as described in 1) to include a process for enrollment of persons as a provider using an ITIN in lieu of a Social Security number, and a process of enrollment for prospective providers who are in the process of obtaining an ITIN.
- Specifies that an individual who is unable to provide a Social Security number due to immigration status is eligible to provide services if all other requirements pursuant to these provisions are met.
- Requires, no later than January 1, 2025, CDSS, in consultation with the stakeholders listed in 1) above, to develop recommendations to enable any recipient of services to select a related provider of their choice.
- Provides that these provisions do not change the nature of any employment relationship between providers and recipients, the county, public authority, nonprofit consortium, or state.
- Establishes that a person who meets the criteria specified in 1) above is exempt from a criminal background check, but shall attest to any convictions that violate the provisions of Welfare and Institutions Code Section 12305.81 as described below in existing law.
- Specifies that any person who attests to a conviction, as specified, is prohibited from providing in-home supportive services.
- Permits a family member to allow a person who meets the criteria specified in 1) above, and who attested to any conviction described in Welfare and Institutions Code Section 12305.81 and that would otherwise qualify for an exclusion.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the IHSS program to provide supportive services to individuals who are aged, blind, or living with disabilities, and who are unable to perform the services themselves or remain safely in their homes without receiving these services. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section [WIC] 12300 § et seq.)
- Defines supportive services as domestic services and services related to domestic services, heavy cleaning, personal care services, accompaniment by a provider when needed during necessary travel to health-related appointments or to alternative resource sites, yard hazard abatement, protective supervision, teaching and demonstration directed at reducing the need for other supportive services, and paramedical services which make it possible for the recipient to establish and maintain an independent living arrangement. Personal care services shall mean all of the following:
- Assistance with ambulation;
- Bathing, oral hygiene, and grooming;
- Dressing;
- Care and assistance with prosthetic devices;
- Bowel, bladder, and menstrual care;
- Repositioning, skin care, range of motion exercises, and transfers;
- Feeding and assurance of adequate fluid intake;
- Respiration; and,
- Assistance with self-administration of medications. (WIC § 12300 (b))
- Restricts parents of children receiving IHSS benefits from being paid unless the provider leaves full-time employment or is prevented from obtaining full-time employment because no other suitable provider is available. (WIC § 12300(e))
- Establishes a workweek as beginning at 12:00 a.m. on Sunday and includes the next consecutive 168 hours, terminating at 11:59 p.m. the following Saturday, and restricts a provider from working more than 66 hours in a week. (WIC § 12300.4)
- Prohibits a person from being eligible to provide or receive payment for providing IHSS services for 10 years following a conviction for, or incarceration following a conviction for, specified abuse of a child, abuse of an elder or dependent adult, or fraud against a government health care or supportive services program. (WIC § 12305.81)
- Requires counties to perform a background check on individuals applying to become IHSS providers, and stipulates circumstances under which individuals shall be excluded from becoming an IHSS provider, as well as circumstances under which such an exclusion might be waived. (WIC §§ 12305.86 -87)
- Requires an individual who is 25 years of age or younger, and who does not have satisfactory immigration status or is unable to establish satisfactory immigration status to be eligible for the full scope of Medi-Cal benefits, if they are otherwise eligible for benefits.
Federal law.
- Prohibits employers from employing undocumented immigrants. (8 United States Code § 1324a.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown, this bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
Background: In-Home Supportive Services Program. Eligible low-income individuals in California who are at least 65 years of age and older, living with a disability, and/or blind to live in the place of their choosing and avoid premature institutional care. IHSS can be used for services such as housecleaning, meal preparation, laundry, grocery shopping, personal care services (such as bowel and bladder care, bathing, grooming, and paramedical services), accompaniment to medical appointments, and protective supervision for the mentally impaired. This saves the state significant money by preventing these individuals from needing a hospital or a long-term care facility.
All eligible IHSS recipients must physically reside in the United States, be a California resident, Medi-Cal qualified, live at home or place of own choosing which can include a licensed community care facility, long-term care facility, and complete a Health Care Certification form. IHSS is administered through counties. IHSS clients self-direct their care, which allows them to choose and hire their own providers, including friends and family. About 70% of IHSS providers are related to their clients.
When an individual is determined eligible for IHSS services by a county social worker, they are authorized for a certain number of hours of care per week. IHSS recipients are responsible for hiring, firing, directing, and supervising their IHSS workers. These responsibilities include some administrative duties, such as scheduling and signing timesheets; however, the state handles payroll. Providers must complete an enrollment process, including submitting fingerprint images for a criminal background check and participating in a provider orientation prior to receiving payment for services.
The population needing to be served by IHSS is increasing and diversifying. According to how the Census Bureau defines baby boomers, the youngest cohort of baby boomers will be turning 66 years of age in 2030. Adding to the pool of potential IHSS recipients, in 2021, California expanded Medi-Cal to qualified individuals regardless of immigration status. With this expansion, individuals with functional impairments who are undocumented and over 50 years of age are also newly eligible for IHSS.
According to a 2020 California State Auditor’s report of the IHSS program: “From January 2015 through December 2019, the number of recipients statewide who lacked care grew on average from 33,000 to more than 40,000 each month.” As a result of California’s aging population, expanded criteria for eligible recipients of IHSS, and the existing caregiving workforce shortage, this issue will continue to worsen the shortage of IHSS workers to provide the necessary care.
Master Plan for Aging. In June 2019, Governor Newsom issued Executive Order N-14-19 that ordered the California Health and Human Services Agency to convene a Master Plan for Aging Stakeholder Committee to establish a 10-year plan with aging services based on data, stakeholder input, and research. The Executive Order also established a Long-Term Services and Supports (LTSS) Subcommittee that was required, by March 2020, to report:
- The growth and sustainability of long-term care programs and their infrastructure, including the IHSS program.
- Access to long-term care, financing for long-term care services, and the quality of long-term care provided in an array of settings.
- The impact of program sustainability and other factors, such as labor supply and retention of the workforce providing long-term services and supports.
- A recommendation to stabilize long-term care, including the IHSS program as a foundational source for implementing the Master Plan whereby our aging population can safely remain in their own homes within their own communities.
Following the Executive Order, the COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a major policymaking pause across many health and human services programs, and for the aging and disabled population particularly. As a result, the report was released in May 2020 and the contents were shaped by the immediate crisis to recipients of long-term care services. The pandemic highlighted the need for in-home options rather than institutional settings like community care facilities.
One of the five objectives offered in the LTSS report was: “Recognizing personal preferences and labor market challenges, the state must: 1) provide maximum support to family caregivers who have additional jobs outside the family caregiving setting through family leave policies, including job protections, that allow unpaid caregivers the flexibility to continue to earn while providing needed family support and; 2) accelerate the growth of the paid workforce to meet increasing demand for LTSS.” The Master Plan for Aging estimates that California will face a caregiver shortage of up to 3.2 million paid direct care workers.
California is the most racially and ethnically diverse state in the nation. By 2030, White, non-Latino Californians over the age of 60 will no longer represent the majority of older adults in California and the majority will identify as Black; Latino/x; Asian, Native Hawaiian, or Pacific Islander; American Indian or Alaska Native; or multiracial. This shift will further necessitate adequate culturally competent and linguistically appropriate services and providers to better reflect the needs of the population they will be serving.
To accomplish the above objective, the LTSS subcommittee recommended ensuring a linguistically and culturally responsive workforce by identifying best practices in cultural responsiveness which could include implicit bias training. As described in the LTSS subcommittee report, person-centered care relies on understanding and accepting everyone’s race, ethnicity, language, culture, faith tradition, sexual orientation, history, lived experience, and preferences.
The Department of Aging regularly offers a variety of training on such cultural inclusivity
As part of the objectives laid out in the LTSS Subcommittee Stakeholder Report, to ensure there is an easy-to-navigate LTSS system that includes home and community-based and residential options statewide, making sure that IHSS recipients receive timely, accurate information that is linguistically and culturally responsive is critical to consistency and accuracy.
Caregiving Workforce. California’s direct care workers are largely women and women of color. National Partnership for Women & Families reports, 89% of paid caregivers are women. Of the 89% of women, 28% are Black, 21% are Hispanic or Latino, and 9% are other which equates to half of the direct care staff.
The Department of Labor statistics show that there are not enough direct care workers to meet population needs due to low wages, meager benefits, and low respect for demanding jobs requiring difficult physical and emotional work. In recent years, California increased hourly wages to help retain and recruit caregivers as well as offer a bonus for working through the difficulty of the pandemic. Each county determines hourly wages, and as of April 2023, the average is $16.52/hour with Santa Clara County offering the highest rate of $19.04/hour. The low wages make the field difficult to recruit, making family caregivers crucial to serving this vulnerable population.
California relies on family caregivers to take care of loved ones who are aging and/or living with disabilities. According to the Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index in 2011, more than 1 in 6 Americans working full-time or part-time report assisting with the care of an elderly or disabled family member, relative, or friend. Family caregivers can be eligible for IHSS funding to supplement of their lost wages due to their caregiving duties. However, undocumented recipients are denied the right to select an undocumented family member to act as their provider due to immigration status. This bill will provide outreach to immigrant communities to encourage IHSS provider enrollment.
Paid caregivers often make it possible for family caregivers to remain in the workforce and provide valuable, loving care. At the same time, their wages are low, their jobs are insecure and they lack access to basic protections like paid family and medical leave and paid sick days to care for their own loved ones and personal health needs. According to an AARP report, Valuing the Invaluable: 2015 Update, the economic value of this work is staggering; family caregiving was recently estimated to be worth $470 billion.
Is This Bill Implementable? CDSS and the County Welfare Directors Association both assert this bill is not implementable due to the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) which bars employers from hiring undocumented immigrants. However, legal experts from the UCLA Center for Immigration Law and Policy have offered a legal analysis of whether undocumented immigrants can be employed by a state entity. Their legal analysis makes the case that the United States Supreme Court has upheld in multiple different cases that Congress cannot regulate state governments without clear language of its intentions. IRCA does not mention states which, according to this legal analysis, means IRCA does not apply to state government entities.
Their legal analysis was issued to the University of California (UC) Board of Regents to advocate for DACA student’s right to work on campus. In the memo sent with the legal analysis, UCLA Center for Immigration Law and Policy writes,
In short, when Congress passed IRCA, Congress did not curtail states’ historic power to determine the employment qualifications of state employees. As a result, IRCA’s prohibition on hiring undocumented persons does not bind state government entities. State entities can lawfully hire undocumented students irrespective of employment authorization status under federal law.
Ultimately, the UC Regents in January 2024 rejected the proposal to allow undocumented immigrants to be employed on UC campuses. At the meeting, the UC president said: “We have concluded that the proposed legal pathway is not viable at this time,” and the proposal is “inadvisable” and “carries significant risk for the institution and for those we serve.” However, “as new information becomes available, we will evaluate that information, and if appropriate, move ahead.”
This bill is applying this legal analysis to justify the legality of permitting undocumented IHSS providers.
Author’s Statement: According to the Author, “In 2023, California took the groundbreaking step of expanding Medi-Cal eligibility to include undocumented people. As a result of that expansion, undocumented adults can now receive services through the state’s In Home Supportive Services (IHSS) program. While this is a huge step forward, California must do more to address healthcare inequities and increase access to care. The state needs to take action to address our longstanding home healthcare worker shortage. The vast majority of IHSS recipients rely on a family member or loved one to serve as their IHSS provider; yet, despite the IHSS workforce crisis, undocumented recipients are unable to select an undocumented family member to act as their provider. To help address this provider shortage, AB 3079 authorizes undocumented IHSS recipients to select an undocumented family member to serve as their in home provider.”
Equity Implications: Californians with Medi-Cal eligibility who demonstrate the need for support services due to age, disability, or blindness are eligible for IHSS. California’s expansion of Medi-Cal ensured that nearly 286,000 undocumented older adults over the age of 50 could benefit from full-scope Medi-Cal services, including IHSS. The state’s shortage of IHSS providers means that many of these newly eligible older adults will not be able to receive the supportive services they need, and are thus deprived of the care necessary to avoid hospitalization, nursing care, and poor health outcomes.
California’s Master Plan for Aging notes that by 2030, the majority of Californians over 60 years old will identify as Black; Latino/x; Asian, Native Hawaiian, or Pacific Islander; American Indian or Alaska Native; or multiracial, necessitating more culturally competent and linguistically appropriate services and providers.
Policy Considerations: This bill makes criminal background check exemptions for undocumented immigrants providing care to their fifth-degree family members, but is silent for other IHSS providers. Criminal background checks were put in place a decade ago to ensure providers were safe to provide care and were not going to abuse their patients or the IHSS payment system. Criminal background checks have posed a barrier to many to becoming providers for family members. As noted above, family caregivers are most common – especially in families of color. However, passing and paying for the criminal background check has been noted as difficult for many. If this Legislature determines that waiving a background check to give care to family members does not pose a significant risk, then this should be true for all IHSS providers who care for family members.
Expanding the IHSS provider pool is sensical given California has also expanded the recipient pool, but creating two separate background check rules is inequitable and inconsistent with the stated purpose of the bill – to allow recipients to choose who gives them care.
Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to extend background check exemptions for fifth-degree family member recipients to all IHSS providers.
Proposed Committee Amendments: The Committee proposes amendments to address policy considerations stated above to do the following:
- Expand the criminal background exemption for all IHSS providers providng care to fifth- degree family members.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 133 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 143, Statutes of 2021, expanded eligibility for full scope Medi-Cal to individuals who are 50 years of age or older, regardless of citizenship or immigration status, if otherwise eligible.
AB 2641 (Patterson) of 2014, would have repealed the provisions that authorize a waiver or exemption from the 10-year exclusion for a person who has committed a serious or violent felony, a felony for which registration as a sex offender is required, or a felony misuse of CalFresh funds. AB 2641 was set for a hearing by this committee but was cancelled at the request of th author..
SB 1104 (Budget and Fiscal Review Committee), Chapter 229, Statutes of 2004, Prohibited an individual convicted in the last ten years of health care fraud, child abuse, or elder abuse from providing IHSS services.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City and County of San Francisco (Sponsor)
Alzheimer's Association State Policy Office
Alzheimer's Greater Los Angeles
Alzheimer's Orange County
Alzheimer's San Diego
California Domestic Workers Coalition
California Family Resource Association
Caring Across Generations
Child Abuse Prevention Center
County of Santa Clara
Family Caregiver Alliance (FCA)
Justice in Aging
Latino Coalition for A Healthy California
Vision Y Compromiso (UNREG)
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Alexandria Smith / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services
Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):