AB 3127: Reporting of crimes: mandated reporters.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-22
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires a health practitioner, as defined, to make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that is either self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, or caused by assaultive or abusive conduct, including elder abuse, sexual assault, or torture. A violation of these provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor.
This bill would remove the requirement that a health practitioner make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by assaultive or abusive conduct. The bill would instead require that a health practitioner make a report when the injury is life threatening or results in death, as specified, or is the result of child abuse or elder or dependent adult abuse. The bill would require the health practitioner to additionally make a report when a person is seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury if the patient requests a report be sent, as specified.
The bill would also require a health practitioner who suspects that a patient has suffered physical injury that is caused by domestic violence, as defined, to provide brief counseling and a referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services, as specified.
This bill would make other conforming changes.
Because a violation of these requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law requires a health practitioner, as defined, to make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that is either self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, or caused by assaultive or abusive conduct, including elder abuse, sexual assault, or torture. A violation of these provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor.
This bill would remove the requirement that a health practitioner make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by assaultive or abusive conduct. The bill would instead require that a health practitioner make a report when the injury is life threatening or results in death, as specified, or is the result of child abuse or elder or dependent adult abuse. The bill would require the health practitioner to additionally make a report when a person is seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury if the patient requests a report be sent, as specified.
The bill would also require a health practitioner who suspects that a patient has suffered physical injury that is caused by domestic violence, as defined, to provide brief counseling and a referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services, as specified.
This bill would make other conforming changes.
Because a violation of these requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law requires a health practitioner, as defined, to make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that is either self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, or caused by assaultive or abusive conduct, including elder abuse, sexual assault, or torture. A violation of these provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor.
This bill would remove the requirement that a health practitioner make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by assaultive or abusive conduct. The bill would instead require that a health practitioner make a report when the injury is life threatening or results in death, or is the result of child abuse or elder or dependent adult abuse. The bill would require the health practitioner to additionally make a report when a person is seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury if the patient requests a report be sent, as specified.
The bill would also require a health practitioner who suspects that a patient has suffered physical injury that is caused by domestic violence, as defined, to provide brief counseling and a referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services, as specified.
This bill would make other conforming changes.
Because a violation of these requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Recognizing that abuse survivors often need to access health care and medical treatment and advocacy services apart from police reporting and criminal legal involvement, this bill limits medical mandatory reporting requirements for adult injuries to only those injuries that are life-threatening without immediate medical treatment and requires health care practitioners to offer patients a connection with advocacy services.
(b)Health care practitioners play a critical role in prevention, identification, and response to violence. Studies show that survivors of abuse want health practitioners to provide survivor-centered, trauma-informed, and nonjudgmental care. Requirements to report all adult violent injuries can result in reduced survivor help seeking, increased danger in some situations, and a reluctance of health practitioners to address abuse. Yet, some patients may want their health practitioner to report abuse because it would be dangerous to do so themselves.
(c)Connecting patients who are surviving abuse to supportive advocacy services can improve their health and safety, decrease potential barriers to care, and promote trust between survivors and health care practitioners and the health care system. Particularly for seriously injured patients seeking care in acute care settings, offering a connection to an in-person advocate is strongly recommended.
(d)This act does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports permitted by subdivisions subdivision (c) or (j) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or at the patients request. Health practitioners must still follow reporting requirements for child abuse, pursuant to Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 11164) of Chapter 2 of Title 1 of Part 4 of the Penal Code, and elder and vulnerable adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. It is the intent of the Legislature to promote partnership between health facilities and domestic and sexual violence advocacy organizations, legal aid, county forensic response teams, family justice centers, and other community-based organizations that address social determinants of health in order to better ensure the safety and wellness of their patients and provide training for health practitioners. California has made strides to enhance health practitioners capacity to address and prevent violence and trauma, including education for practitioners on how to assess for and document abuse as referenced in subdivision (h) of Section 2191 of the Business and Professions Code, Section 2196.5 of the Business and Professions Code, Section 13823.93 of the Penal Code, and Section 1259.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that all health care staff participate in regular training on the health impacts and dynamics of domestic violence, how to assess for danger using validated tool, and how to offer culturally responsive education and support.
SEC. 2.Section 11160 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11160.(a)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department who, in the health practitioners professional capacity or within the scope of the health practitioners employment, provides medical services for a physical condition to a patient whom the health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects is a person described as follows, shall immediately make a report in accordance with subdivision (b):
(1)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury inflicted by the persons own act or inflicted by another where the injury is by means of a firearm.
(2)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury that is life threatening or results in death, caused by the use of nonaccidental violence inflicted by another.
(3)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury resulting from child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165, or elder or dependant dependent adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department shall make a report regarding persons described in subdivision (a) to a local law enforcement agency as follows:
(1)A report by telephone shall be made immediately or as soon as practically possible.
(2)A written report shall be prepared on the standard form developed in compliance with paragraph (4), and adopted by the Office of Emergency Services, or on a form developed and adopted by another state agency that otherwise fulfills the requirements of the standard form. The completed form shall be sent to a local law enforcement agency within two working days of receiving the information regarding the person.
(3)A local law enforcement agency shall be notified and a written report shall be prepared and sent pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) even if the person who suffered the wound or other injuries described in subdivision (a) has expired, regardless of whether or not the wound or other injury was a factor contributing to the death, and even if the evidence of the conduct of the perpetrator of the wound or other injury was discovered during an autopsy.
(4)The report shall include, but shall not be limited to, the following:
(A)The name of the injured person, if known.
(B)The injured persons whereabouts.
(C)The character and extent of the persons injuries.
(D)The identity of any person the injured person alleges inflicted the wound or other injury upon the injured person.
(c)In the circumstance of an adult seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury, if the patient requests a report be sent to law enforcement, health practitioners shall follow the reporting process in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b). Additionally, the medical documentation of injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury shall be conducted and made available to the patient for use as outlined in the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191).
(d)For the purposes of this section, injury does not include any psychological or physical condition brought about solely through the voluntary administration of a narcotic or restricted dangerous drug.
(e)When two or more persons who are required to report are present and jointly have knowledge of a known or suspected instance of violence that is required to be reported pursuant to this section, and when there is an agreement among these persons to report as a team, the team may select by mutual agreement a member of the team to make a report by telephone and a single written report, as required by subdivision (b). The written report shall be signed by the selected member of the reporting team. Any member who has knowledge that the member designated to report has failed to do so shall thereafter make the report.
(f)The reporting duties under this section are individual, except as provided in subdivision (e).
(g)A supervisor or administrator shall not impede or inhibit the reporting duties required under this section and a person making a report pursuant to this section shall not be subject to any sanction for making the report. However, internal procedures to facilitate reporting and apprise supervisors and administrators of reports may be established, except that these procedures shall not be inconsistent with this article. The internal procedures shall not require an employee required to make a report under this article to disclose the employees identity to the employer.
(h)(1)A health practitioner, as described in subdivision (a), who, in the health practitioners professional capacity or within the scope of the health practitioners employment, provides medical services to a patient whom the health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects is experiencing any form of domestic violence, as set forth in Section 124250 of the Health and Safety Code, or sexual violence, as set forth in Sections 243.4 and 261, shall, to the degree that it is medically possible for the individual patient, provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a warm handoff or referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services, as described in Sections 1035.2 and 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, before the end of the patient visit. The health practitioner has met the requirements of this subdivision when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided and warm handoff or referral or other assistance is offered by a member of the health care team at the health facility.
(2)If the health practitioner is providing medical services to the patient in the emergency department of a general acute care hospital, the health practitioner shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a medical evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program as described in Sections 1035.2 and 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
(3)Nothing in this subdivision is intended to conflict with Sections 11161.2 and 680.2, which stipulate that victims receiving forensic medical exams have the right to a qualified social worker, victim advocate, or sexual assault counselor to be present during the examination.
(i)A health practitioner, with the assistance of a social worker or advocate if available, may offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any nonaccidental injury.
(j)Health practitioners who treat a patient for wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse that have not previously been documented in the health practitioners medical record for the patient shall document such wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse in the health practitioners medical record for the patient. If in the health practitioners professional judgment, such documentation would increase danger for the patient, the portions of the medical record containing documentation of the wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse may be marked confidential.
(k)This section does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports to law enforcement at the patients request, or as permitted by HIPAA in Section 164.512(c) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which permits disclosures about victims of abuse, neglect, or domestic violence, if the individual agrees, or pursuant to Section 164.512(j) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which permits disclosures to prevent or limit a serious and imminent threat to a person or the public.
(l)For the purposes of this section, it is the Legislatures intent to avoid duplication of information.
(m)For purposes of this section only, employed by a local government agency includes an employee of an entity under contract with a local government agency to provide medical services.
(n)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Life threatening means an injury likely to result in death without immediate medical or surgical intervention. Life-threatening injuries can include, but are not limited to, injuries from knife, gun, and strangulation that are likely to result in death without immediate medical or surgical intervention.
(2)Referral may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the survivor advocacy organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor advocacy organization, or the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
(3)Warm handoff may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection to an in-person survivor advocate, through a call with a survivor advocate, in-person onsite survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of teleadvocacy. When a telephone call is not possible, the warm handoff may be completed through an email. The patient may decline the warm handoff. Health practitioners are encouraged to offer connection to an in-person advocate where available.
(o)A health practitioner shall not be civilly or criminally liable for any report made or not made pursuant to this section or for any other acts taken or not taken, in relation thereto, or resulting therefrom, in good faith compliance with this section and other applicable state and federal laws.
SEC. 3.Section 11161 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11161.Notwithstanding Section 11160, the following shall apply to every physician or surgeon who has under their charge or care any person described in subdivision (a) of Section 11160:
(a)The physician or surgeon shall make a report in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 11160 to a local law enforcement agency.
(b)It is recommended that any medical records of a person about whom the physician or surgeon is required to report pursuant to subdivision (a) include the following:
(1)Any comments by the injured person regarding past domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700, or regarding the name of any person suspected of inflicting the wound or other physical injury upon the person.
(2)A map of the injured persons body showing and identifying injuries and bruises at the time of the health care.
(3)A copy of the law enforcement reporting form.
(c)(1)The physician or surgeon shall offer a referral to local domestic violence services if the person is suffering or suspected of suffering from domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700.
(2)The physician or surgeon has met the requirements of this subdivision if the referral is offered by a member of the health care team at the health facility.
SEC. 4.Section 11163.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11163.2.(a)In any court proceeding or administrative hearing, neither the physician-patient privilege nor the psychotherapist privilege applies to the information required to be reported pursuant to this article.
(b)The reports required by this article shall be kept confidential by the health facility, clinic, or physicians office that submitted the report, and by local law enforcement agencies, and shall only be disclosed by local law enforcement agencies to those involved in the investigation of the report or the enforcement of a criminal law implicated by a report. In no case shall the person suspected or accused of inflicting the wound or other injury upon the injured person, or the attorney of the suspect accused, be allowed access to the injured persons whereabouts. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to conflict with Section 1054.1 or 1054.2.
(c)For the purposes of this article, reports of suspected child abuse and information contained therein may be disclosed only to persons or agencies with whom investigations of child abuse are coordinated under the regulations promulgated under Section 11174.
(d)The Board of Prison Terms may subpoena reports that are not unfounded and reports that concern only the current incidents upon which parole revocation proceedings are pending against a parolee.
SEC. 5.Section 11163.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11163.3.(a)A county may establish an interagency domestic violence death review team to assist local agencies in identifying and reviewing domestic violence deaths and near deaths, including homicides and suicides, and facilitating communication among the various agencies involved in domestic violence cases. Interagency domestic violence death review teams have been used successfully to ensure that incidents of domestic violence and abuse are recognized and that agency involvement is reviewed to develop recommendations for policies and protocols for community prevention and intervention initiatives to reduce and eradicate the incidence of domestic violence.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, abuse has the meaning set forth in Section 6203 of the Family Code and domestic violence has the meaning set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code.
(2)For purposes of this section, near death means the victim suffered a life-threatening injury, as determined by a licensed physician or licensed nurse, as a result of domestic violence.
(c)A county may develop a protocol that may be used as a guideline to assist coroners and other persons who perform autopsies on domestic violence victims in the identification of domestic violence, in the determination of whether domestic violence contributed to death or whether domestic violence had occurred prior to death, but was not the actual cause of death, and in the proper written reporting procedures for domestic violence, including the designation of the cause and mode of death.
(d)County domestic violence death review teams shall be comprised of, but not limited to, the following:
(1)Experts in the field of forensic pathology.
(2)Medical personnel with expertise in domestic violence abuse.
(3)Coroners and medical examiners.
(4)Criminologists.
(5)District attorneys and city attorneys.
(6)Representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code.
(7)Law enforcement personnel.
(8)Representatives of local agencies that are involved with domestic violence abuse reporting.
(9)County health department staff who deal with domestic violence victims health issues.
(10)Representatives of local child abuse agencies.
(11)Local professional associations of persons described in paragraphs (1) to (10), inclusive.
(e)An oral or written communication or a document shared within or produced by a domestic violence death review team related to a domestic violence death review is confidential and not subject to disclosure or discoverable by a third party. An oral or written communication or a document provided by a third party to a domestic violence death review team, or between a third party and a domestic violence death review team, is confidential and not subject to disclosure or discoverable by a third party. This includes a statement provided by a survivor in a near-death case review. Notwithstanding the foregoing, recommendations of a domestic violence death review team upon the completion of a review may be disclosed at the discretion of a majority of the members of the domestic violence death review team.
(f)Each organization represented on a domestic violence death review team may share with other members of the team information in its possession concerning the victim who is the subject of the review or any person who was in contact with the victim and any other information deemed by the organization to be pertinent to the review. Any information shared by an organization with other members of a team is confidential. This provision shall permit the disclosure to members of the team of any information deemed confidential, privileged, or prohibited from disclosure by any other statute.
(g)Written and oral information may be disclosed to a domestic violence death review team established pursuant to this section. The team may make a request in writing for the information sought and any person with information of the kind described in paragraph (2) may rely on the request in determining whether information may be disclosed to the team.
(1)An individual or agency that has information governed by this subdivision shall not be required to disclose information. The intent of this subdivision is to allow the voluntary disclosure of information by the individual or agency that has the information.
(2)The following information may be disclosed pursuant to this subdivision:
(A)Notwithstanding Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, medical information.
(B)Notwithstanding Section 5328 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, mental health information.
(C)Notwithstanding Section 15633.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, information from elder abuse reports and investigations, except the identity of persons who have made reports, which shall not be disclosed.
(D)Notwithstanding Section 11167.5, information from child abuse reports and investigations, except the identity of persons who have made reports, which shall not be disclosed.
(E)State summary criminal history information, criminal offender record information, and local summary criminal history information, as defined in Sections 11075, 11105, and 13300.
(F)Notwithstanding Section 11163.2, information pertaining to reports by health practitioners of persons suffering from physical injuries inflicted by means of a firearm or abuse, if reported, and information relating to whether a physician referred the person to local domestic violence services as required by Section 11161.
(G)Notwithstanding Section 827 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, information in any juvenile court proceeding.
(H)Information maintained by the Family Court, including information relating to the Family Conciliation Court Law pursuant to Section 1818 of the Family Code, and Mediation of Custody and Visitation Issues pursuant to Section 3177 of the Family Code.
(I)Information provided to probation officers in the course of the performance of their duties, including, but not limited to, the duty to prepare reports pursuant to Section 1203.10, as well as the information on which these reports are based.
(J)Notwithstanding Section 10850 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, records of in-home supportive services, unless disclosure is prohibited by federal law.
(3)The disclosure of written and oral information authorized under this subdivision shall apply notwithstanding Sections 2263, 2918, 4982, and 6068 of the Business and Professions Code, or the lawyer-client privilege protected by Article 3 (commencing with Section 950) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the physician-patient privilege protected by Article 6 (commencing with Section 990) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the psychotherapist-patient privilege protected by Article 7 (commencing with Section 1010) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the sexual assault counselor-victim privilege protected by Article 8.5 (commencing with Section 1035) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the domestic violence counselor-victim privilege protected by Article 8.7 (commencing with Section 1037) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, and the human trafficking caseworker-victim privilege protected by Article 8.8 (commencing with Section 1038) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code.
(4)In near-death cases, representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, shall obtain an individuals informed consent in accordance with all applicable state and federal confidentiality laws, before disclosing confidential information about that individual to another team member as specified in this section. In death review cases, representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations shall only provide client-specific information in accordance with both state and federal confidentiality requirements.
(5)Near-death case reviews shall only occur after any prosecution has concluded.
(6)Near-death survivors shall not be compelled to participate in death review team investigations; their participation is voluntary. In cases of death, the victims family members may be invited to participate, however they shall not be compelled to do so; their participation is voluntary. Members of the death review teams shall be prepared to provide referrals for services to address the unmet needs of survivors and their families when appropriate.
SEC. 6.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Recognizing that abuse survivors often need to access health care and medical treatment and advocacy services apart from police reporting and criminal legal involvement, this bill replaces mandated police reporting by medical professionals with offering connection to survivor services. limits medical mandatory reporting requirements for adult injuries to only those injuries that are life-threatening without immediate medical treatment and requires health care practitioners to offer patients a connection with advocacy services.
(b)Health care providers play a critical role in prevention, identification, and response to violence. However, current law requiring health professionals in California to file reports to law enforcement when treating patients for all suspected violence-related injuries can have a chilling effect of preventing domestic and sexual violence survivors from seeking medical care, decreasing patient autonomy and trust, and resulting in health providers being reluctant to address domestic and sexual violence with their patients.(c)Studies have shown that medical mandatory reporting of adult domestic and sexual violence may increase patient danger and insecurity, whereas being able to openly discuss abuse without fear of police reporting can produce greater health and safety outcomes.(d)Because of the complexity of interpersonal violence and impact of social inequities on safety, people who have experienced violence should be provided survivor-centered support and health care that results in better outcomes for patient safety. Doing so can improve the health and safety of patients already in care, decrease potential barriers to care, and promote trust between survivors and health providers.(b)Health care practitioners play a critical role in prevention, identification, and response to violence. Studies show that survivors of abuse want health practitioners to provide survivor-centered, trauma-informed, and nonjudgmental care. Requirements to report all adult violent injuries can result in reduced survivor help seeking, increased danger in some situations, and a reluctance of health practitioners to address abuse. Yet, some patients may want their health practitioner to report abuse because it would be dangerous to do so themselves.
(c)Connecting patients who are surviving abuse to supportive advocacy services can improve their health and safety, decrease potential barriers to care, and promote trust between survivors and health care practitioners and the health care system. Particularly for seriously injured patients seeking care in acute care settings, offering a connection to an in-person advocate is strongly recommended.
(e)Nothing in this act limits or overrides
(d)This act does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports permitted by subdivisions (c) or (j) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or at the patients request. Providers Health practitioners must still follow reporting requirements for child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165 Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 11164) of Chapter 2 of Title 1 of Part 4 of the Penal Code, and elder and vulnerable adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. It is the intent of the Legislature to promote partnership between health facilities and domestic and sexual violence advocacy organizations, legal aid, county forensic response teams, family justice centers, and other community-based organizations that address social determinants of health in order to better ensure the safety and wellness of their patients and provide training for health practitioners. California has made strides to enhance health practitioners capacity to address and prevent violence and trauma, including education for practitioners on how to assess for and document abuse as referenced in subdivision (h) of Section 2191 of the Business and Professions Code, Section 2196.5 of the Business and Professions Code, Section 13823.93 of the Penal Code, and Section 1259.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(e)It is the intent of the Legislature that all health care staff participate in regular training on the health impacts and dynamics of domestic violence, how to assess for danger using validated tool, and how to offer culturally responsive education and support.
SEC. 2.Section 11160 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11160.(a)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department who, in the health practitioners professional capacity or within the scope of the health practitioners employment, provides medical services for a physical condition to a patient whom the health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects is a person described as follows, shall immediately make a report in accordance with subdivision (b):
(1)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury inflicted by the persons own act or inflicted by another where the injury is by means of a firearm.
(2)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury that is life threatening or results in death, inflicted upon the person by another. caused by the use of nonaccidental violence inflicted by another.
(3)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury resulting from child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165, or elder or dependant adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department shall make a report regarding persons described in subdivision (a) to a local law enforcement agency as follows:
(1)A report by telephone shall be made immediately or as soon as practically possible.
(2)A written report shall be prepared on the standard form developed in compliance with paragraph (4), and adopted by the Office of Emergency Services, or on a form developed and adopted by another state agency that otherwise fulfills the requirements of the standard form. The completed form shall be sent to a local law enforcement agency within two working days of receiving the information regarding the person.
(3)A local law enforcement agency shall be notified and a written report shall be prepared and sent pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) even if the person who suffered the wound or other injury injuries described in subdivision (a) has expired, regardless of whether or not the wound or other injury was a factor contributing to the death, and even if the evidence of the conduct of the perpetrator of the wound or other injury was discovered during an autopsy.
(4)The report shall include, but shall not be limited to, the following:
(A)The name of the injured person, if known.
(B)The injured persons whereabouts.
(C)The character and extent of the persons injuries.
(D)The identity of any person the injured person alleges inflicted the wound or other injury upon the injured person.
(c)In the circumstance of an adult seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury, if the patient requests a report be sent to law enforcement, health practitioners shall follow the reporting process in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b). Additionally, the medical documentation of injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury shall be conducted and made available to the patient for use as outlined in the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191).
(d)For the purposes of this section, injury does not include any psychological or physical condition brought about solely through the voluntary administration of a narcotic or restricted dangerous drug.
(e)When two or more persons who are required to report are present and jointly have knowledge of a known or suspected instance of violence that is required to be reported pursuant to this section, and when there is an agreement among these persons to report as a team, the team may select by mutual agreement a member of the team to make a report by telephone and a single written report, as required by subdivision (b). The written report shall be signed by the selected member of the reporting team. Any member who has knowledge that the member designated to report has failed to do so shall thereafter make the report.
(f)The reporting duties under this section are individual, except as provided in subdivision (e).
(g)A supervisor or administrator shall not impede or inhibit the reporting duties required under this section and a person making a report pursuant to this section shall not be subject to any sanction for making the report. However, internal procedures to facilitate reporting and apprise supervisors and administrators of reports may be established, except that these procedures shall not be inconsistent with this article. The internal procedures shall not require an employee required to make a report under this article to disclose the employees identity to the employer.
(h)(1)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department as described in subdivision (a), who, in the health practitioners professional capacity or within the scope of the health practitioners employment, provides medical services to a patient whom the health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects is experiencing any form of domestic violence, as set forth in Section 124250 of the Health and Safety Code, or sexual violence, as set forth in Sections 243.4 and 261, shall, to the degree that it is medically possible for the individual patient, provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a warm handoff or referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services, as described in Sections 1035.2 and 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, before the end of the patient visit. The health practitioner has met the requirements of this subdivision when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided and warm handoff or referral or other assistance is offered by a member of the health care team at the health facility.
(2)If the health practitioner is providing medical services to the patient in the emergency department of a general acute care hospital, the health practitioner shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a medical evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program as described in Sections 1035.2 and 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
(3)Nothing in this subdivision is intended to conflict with Sections 11161.2 and 680.2, which stipulate that victims receiving forensic medical exams have the right to a qualified social worker, victim advocate, or sexual assault counselor to be present during the examination.
(i)A health practitioner practitioner, with the assistance of a social worker or advocate if available, may offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any nonaccidental injury.
(j)Health practitioners who treat a patient for wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse that have not previously been documented in the health practitioners medical record for the patient shall document such wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse in the health practitioners medical record for the patient. If in the health practitioners professional judgment, such documentation would increase danger for the patient, the portions of the medical record containing documentation of the wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse may be marked confidential.
(k)(1)This section does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports to law enforcement at the patients request, or as permitted by HIPAA in Section 164.512(c) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which permits disclosures about victims of abuse, neglect, or domestic violence, if the individual agrees, or pursuant to Section 164.512(j) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which permits disclosures to prevent or limit a serious and imminent threat to a person or the public.
(2)This section does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports permitted by subdivisions (c) or (j) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or at the patients request. Providers shall follow reporting requirements for child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165 of the Penal Code, and elder and vulnerable adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.(l)For the purposes of this section, it is the Legislatures intent to avoid duplication of information.
(m)For purposes of this section only, employed by a local government agency includes an employee of an entity under contract with a local government agency to provide medical services.
(n)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Life threatening means an injury involving a substantial risk of death, including loss or substantial impairment of the function of a bodily member, organ, or mental faculty that is likely to be permanent, as determined by a licensed health practitioner. likely to result in death without immediate medical or surgical intervention. Life-threatening injuries can include, but are not limited to, injuries from knife, gun, and strangulation that result in a substantial risk of death. are likely to result in death without immediate medical or surgical intervention.
(2)Referral may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the survivor advocacy organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor advocacy organization, or the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
(3)Warm handoff may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection to an in-person survivor advocate, through a call with a survivor advocate, in-person onsite survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of teleadvocacy. When a telephone call is not possible, the warm handoff may be completed through an email. The patient may decline the warm handoff. Health practitioners are encouraged to offer connection to an in-person advocate where available.
(o)A health practitioner shall not be civilly or criminally liable for any report made or not made pursuant to this section or for any other acts taken or not taken, in relation thereto, or resulting therefrom, in good faith compliance with this section and other applicable state and federal laws.
SEC. 3.Section 11161 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11161.Notwithstanding Section 11160, the following shall apply to every physician or surgeon who has under their charge or care any person described in subdivision (a) of Section 11160:
(a)The physician or surgeon shall make a report in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 11160 to a local law enforcement agency.
(b)It is recommended that any medical records of a person about whom the physician or surgeon is required to report pursuant to subdivision (a) include the following:
(1)Any comments by the injured person regarding past domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700, or regarding the name of any person suspected of inflicting the wound or other physical injury upon the person.
(2)A map of the injured persons body showing and identifying injuries and bruises at the time of the health care.
(3)A copy of the law enforcement reporting form.
(c)The physician or surgeon shall offer a referral to local domestic violence services if the person is suffering or suspected of suffering from domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700.
SEC. 4.Section 11163.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11163.2.(a)In any court proceeding or administrative hearing, neither the physician-patient privilege nor the psychotherapist privilege applies to the information required to be reported pursuant to this article.
(b)The reports required by this article shall be kept confidential by the health facility, clinic, or physicians office that submitted the report, and by local law enforcement agencies, and shall only be disclosed by local law enforcement agencies to those involved in the investigation of the report or the enforcement of a criminal law implicated by a report. In no case shall the person suspected or accused of inflicting the wound or other injury upon the injured person, or the attorney of the suspect accused, be allowed access to the injured persons whereabouts. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to conflict with Section 1054.1 or 1054.2.
(c)For the purposes of this article, reports of suspected child abuse and information contained therein may be disclosed only to persons or agencies with whom investigations of child abuse are coordinated under the regulations promulgated under Section 11174.
(d)The Board of Prison Terms may subpoena reports that are not unfounded and reports that concern only the current incidents upon which parole revocation proceedings are pending against a parolee.
SEC. 5.Section 11163.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11163.3.(a)A county may establish an interagency domestic violence death review team to assist local agencies in identifying and reviewing domestic violence deaths and near deaths, including homicides and suicides, and facilitating communication among the various agencies involved in domestic violence cases. Interagency domestic violence death review teams have been used successfully to ensure that incidents of domestic violence and abuse are recognized and that agency involvement is reviewed to develop recommendations for policies and protocols for community prevention and intervention initiatives to reduce and eradicate the incidence of domestic violence.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, abuse has the meaning set forth in Section 6203 of the Family Code and domestic violence has the meaning set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code.
(2)For purposes of this section, near death means the victim suffered a life-threatening injury, as determined by a licensed physician or licensed nurse, as a result of domestic violence.
(c)A county may develop a protocol that may be used as a guideline to assist coroners and other persons who perform autopsies on domestic violence victims in the identification of domestic violence, in the determination of whether domestic violence contributed to death or whether domestic violence had occurred prior to death, but was not the actual cause of death, and in the proper written reporting procedures for domestic violence, including the designation of the cause and mode of death.
(d)County domestic violence death review teams shall be comprised of, but not limited to, the following:
(1)Experts in the field of forensic pathology.
(2)Medical personnel with expertise in domestic violence abuse.
(3)Coroners and medical examiners.
(4)Criminologists.
(5)District attorneys and city attorneys.
(6)Representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code.
(7)Law enforcement personnel.
(8)Representatives of local agencies that are involved with domestic violence abuse reporting.
(9)County health department staff who deal with domestic violence victims health issues.
(10)Representatives of local child abuse agencies.
(11)Local professional associations of persons described in paragraphs (1) to (10), inclusive.
(e)An oral or written communication or a document shared within or produced by a domestic violence death review team related to a domestic violence death review is confidential and not subject to disclosure or discoverable by a third party. An oral or written communication or a document provided by a third party to a domestic violence death review team, or between a third party and a domestic violence death review team, is confidential and not subject to disclosure or discoverable by a third party. This includes a statement provided by a survivor in a near-death case review. Notwithstanding the foregoing, recommendations of a domestic violence death review team upon the completion of a review may be disclosed at the discretion of a majority of the members of the domestic violence death review team.
(f)Each organization represented on a domestic violence death review team may share with other members of the team information in its possession concerning the victim who is the subject of the review or any person who was in contact with the victim and any other information deemed by the organization to be pertinent to the review. Any information shared by an organization with other members of a team is confidential. This provision shall permit the disclosure to members of the team of any information deemed confidential, privileged, or prohibited from disclosure by any other statute.
(g)Written and oral information may be disclosed to a domestic violence death review team established pursuant to this section. The team may make a request in writing for the information sought and any person with information of the kind described in paragraph (2) may rely on the request in determining whether information may be disclosed to the team.
(1)An individual or agency that has information governed by this subdivision shall not be required to disclose information. The intent of this subdivision is to allow the voluntary disclosure of information by the individual or agency that has the information.
(2)The following information may be disclosed pursuant to this subdivision:
(A)Notwithstanding Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, medical information.
(B)Notwithstanding Section 5328 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, mental health information.
(C)Notwithstanding Section 15633.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, information from elder abuse reports and investigations, except the identity of persons who have made reports, which shall not be disclosed.
(D)Notwithstanding Section 11167.5, information from child abuse reports and investigations, except the identity of persons who have made reports, which shall not be disclosed.
(E)State summary criminal history information, criminal offender record information, and local summary criminal history information, as defined in Sections 11075, 11105, and 13300.
(F)Notwithstanding Section 11163.2, information pertaining to reports by health practitioners of persons suffering from physical injuries inflicted by means of a firearm or abuse, if reported, and information relating to whether a physician referred the person to local domestic violence services as required by Section 11161.
(G)Notwithstanding Section 827 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, information in any juvenile court proceeding.
(H)Information maintained by the Family Court, including information relating to the Family Conciliation Court Law pursuant to Section 1818 of the Family Code, and Mediation of Custody and Visitation Issues pursuant to Section 3177 of the Family Code.
(I)Information provided to probation officers in the course of the performance of their duties, including, but not limited to, the duty to prepare reports pursuant to Section 1203.10, as well as the information on which these reports are based.
(J)Notwithstanding Section 10850 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, records of in-home supportive services, unless disclosure is prohibited by federal law.
(3)The disclosure of written and oral information authorized under this subdivision shall apply notwithstanding Sections 2263, 2918, 4982, and 6068 of the Business and Professions Code, or the lawyer-client privilege protected by Article 3 (commencing with Section 950) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the physician-patient privilege protected by Article 6 (commencing with Section 990) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the psychotherapist-patient privilege protected by Article 7 (commencing with Section 1010) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the sexual assault counselor-victim privilege protected by Article 8.5 (commencing with Section 1035) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the domestic violence counselor-victim privilege protected by Article 8.7 (commencing with Section 1037) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, and the human trafficking caseworker-victim privilege protected by Article 8.8 (commencing with Section 1038) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code.
(4)In near-death cases, representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, shall obtain an individuals informed consent in accordance with all applicable state and federal confidentiality laws, before disclosing confidential information about that individual to another team member as specified in this section. In death review cases, representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations shall only provide client-specific information in accordance with both state and federal confidentiality requirements.
(5)Near-death case reviews shall only occur after any prosecution has concluded.
(6)Near-death survivors shall not be compelled to participate in death review team investigations; their participation is voluntary. In cases of death, the victims family members may be invited to participate, however they shall not be compelled to do so; their participation is voluntary. Members of the death review teams shall be prepared to provide referrals for services to address the unmet needs of survivors and their families when appropriate.
SEC. 6.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Recognizing that abuse survivors often need to access health care and medical treatment apart from police reporting and criminal legal involvement, this bill replaces mandated police reporting by medical professionals with offering connection to survivor services.
(b)Health care providers play a critical role in prevention, identification, and response to violence. However, current law requiring health professionals in California to file reports to law enforcement when treating patients for all suspected violence-related injuries can have a chilling effect of preventing domestic and sexual violence survivors from seeking medical care, decreasing patient autonomy and trust, and resulting in health providers being reluctant to address domestic and sexual violence with their patients.
(c)Studies have shown that medical mandatory reporting of adult domestic and sexual violence may increase patient danger and insecurity, whereas being able to openly discuss abuse without fear of police reporting can produce greater health and safety outcomes.
(d)Because of the complexity of interpersonal violence and impact of social inequities on safety, people who have experienced violence should be provided survivor-centered support and health care that results in better outcomes for patient safety. Doing so can improve the health and safety of patients already in care, decrease potential barriers to care, and promote trust between survivors and health providers.
(e)Nothing in this act limits or overrides the ability of a health practitioner to make reports permitted by subdivisions (c) or (j) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or at the patients request. Providers must still follow reporting requirements for child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165 of the Penal Code, and elder and vulnerable adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. It is the intent of the Legislature to promote partnership between health facilities and domestic and sexual violence advocacy organizations, legal aid, county forensic response teams, family justice centers, and other community-based organizations that address social determinants of health in order to better ensure the safety and wellness of their patients and provide training for health practitioners. California has made strides to enhance health practitioners capacity to address and prevent violence and trauma, including education for practitioners on how to assess for and document abuse as referenced in subdivision (h) of Section 2191 of the Business and Professions Code, Section 2196.5 of the Business and Professions Code, Section 13823.93 of the Penal Code, and Section 1259.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
SEC. 2.Section 11160 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11160.(a)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department who, in the health practitioners professional capacity or within the scope of the health practitioners employment, provides medical services for a physical condition to a patient whom the health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects is a person described as follows, shall immediately make a report in accordance with subdivision (b):
(1)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury inflicted by the persons own act or inflicted by another where the injury is by means of a firearm.
(2)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury inflicted upon the person where the injury is the result of assaultive or abusive conduct.(2)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury that is life threatening or results in death, inflicted upon the person by another.
(3)A person suffering from a wound or other physical injury resulting from child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165, or elder or dependant adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(b)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department shall make a report regarding persons described in subdivision (a) to a local law enforcement agency as follows:
(1)A report by telephone shall be made immediately or as soon as practically possible.
(2)A written report shall be prepared on the standard form developed in compliance with paragraph (4), and adopted by the Office of Emergency Services, or on a form developed and adopted by another state agency that otherwise fulfills the requirements of the standard form. The completed form shall be sent to a local law enforcement agency within two working days of receiving the information regarding the person.
(3)A local law enforcement agency shall be notified and a written report shall be prepared and sent pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) even if the person who suffered the wound, other injury, or assaultive or abusive conduct wound or other injury has expired, regardless of whether or not the wound, other injury, or assaultive or abusive conduct wound or other injury was a factor contributing to the death, and even if the evidence of the conduct of the perpetrator of the wound, other injury, or assaultive or abusive conduct wound or other injury was discovered during an autopsy.
(4)The report shall include, but shall not be limited to, the following:
(A)The name of the injured person, if known.
(B)The injured persons whereabouts.
(C)The character and extent of the persons injuries.
(D)The identity of any person the injured person alleges inflicted the wound, other injury, or assaultive or abusive conduct wound or other injury upon the injured person.
(c)In the circumstance of an adult seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury, if the patient requests a report be sent to law enforcement, health practitioners shall follow the reporting process in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b). Additionally, the medical documentation of injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury shall be conducted and made available to the patient for use as outlined in the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) (Public Law 104-191).
(c)(d)For the purposes of this section, injury does not include any psychological or physical condition brought about solely through the voluntary administration of a narcotic or restricted dangerous drug.
(d)For the purposes of this section, assaultive or abusive conduct includes any of the following offenses: (1)Murder, in violation of Section 187. (2)Manslaughter, in violation of Section 192 or 192.5. (3)Mayhem, in violation of Section 203. (4)Aggravated mayhem, in violation of Section 205. (5)Torture, in violation of Section 206. (6)Assault with intent to commit mayhem, rape, sodomy, or oral copulation, in violation of Section 220. (7)Administering controlled substances or anesthetic to aid in commission of a felony, in violation of Section 222. (8)Battery, in violation of Section 242. (9)Sexual battery, in violation of Section 243.4. (10)Incest, in violation of Section 285. (11)Throwing any vitriol, corrosive acid, or caustic chemical with intent to injure or disfigure, in violation of Section 244. (12)Assault with a stun gun or taser, in violation of Section 244.5. (13)Assault with a deadly weapon, firearm, assault weapon, or machinegun, or by means likely to produce great bodily injury, in violation of Section 245. (14)Rape, in violation of Section 261 or former Section 262. (15)Procuring a person to have sex with another person, in violation of Section 266, 266a, 266b, or 266c. (16)Child abuse or endangerment, in violation of Section 273a or 273d. (17)Abuse of spouse or cohabitant, in violation of Section 273.5. (18)Sodomy, in violation of Section 286. (19)Lewd and lascivious acts with a child, in violation of Section 288. (20)Oral copulation, in violation of Section 287 or former Section 288a. (21)Sexual penetration, in violation of Section 289. (22)Elder abuse, in violation of Section 368. (23)An attempt to commit any crime specified in paragraphs (1) to (22), inclusive.(e)When two or more persons who are required to report are present and jointly have knowledge of a known or suspected instance of violence that is required to be reported pursuant to this section, and when there is an agreement among these persons to report as a team, the team may select by mutual agreement a member of the team to make a report by telephone and a single written report, as required by subdivision (b). The written report shall be signed by the selected member of the reporting team. Any member who has knowledge that the member designated to report has failed to do so shall thereafter make the report.
(f)The reporting duties under this section are individual, except as provided in subdivision (e).
(g)A supervisor or administrator shall not impede or inhibit the reporting duties required under this section and a person making a report pursuant to this section shall not be subject to any sanction for making the report. However, internal procedures to facilitate reporting and apprise supervisors and administrators of reports may be established, except that these procedures shall not be inconsistent with this article. The internal procedures shall not require an employee required to make a report under this article to disclose the employees identity to the employer.
(h)(1)A health practitioner, as defined in subdivision (a) of Section 11162.5, employed by a health facility, clinic, physicians office, local or state public health department, local government agency, or a clinic or other type of facility operated by a local or state public health department who, in the health practitioners professional capacity or within the scope of the health practitioners employment, provides medical services to a patient whom the health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects is experiencing any form of domestic violence, as set forth in Section 124250 of the Health and Safety Code, or sexual violence, as set forth in Sections 243.4 and 261, shall, to the degree that it is medically possible for the individual patient, provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a warm handoff or referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services, as described in Sections 1035.2 and 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, before the end of the patient visit. The health practitioner has met the requirements of this subdivision when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided and warm handoff or referral or other assistance is offered by a member of the health care team at the health facility.
(2)If the health practitioner is providing medical services to the patient in the emergency department of a general acute care hospital, the health practitioner shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a medical evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program as described in Sections 1035.2 and 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
(i)A health practitioner may offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any nonaccidental injury.
(j)Health practitioners who treat a patient for wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse that have not previously been documented in the health practitioners medical record for the patient shall document such wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse in the health practitioners medical record for the patient. If in the health practitioners professional judgment, such documentation would increase danger for the patient, the portions of the medical record containing documentation of the wounds, physical injuries, or other signs consistent with abuse may be marked confidential.
(k)(1)This section does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports to law enforcement at the patients request, or as permitted by HIPAA in Section 164.512(c) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which permits disclosures about victims of abuse, neglect, or domestic violence, if the individual agrees, or pursuant to Section 164.512(j) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, which permits disclosures to prevent or limit a serious and imminent threat to a person or the public.
(2)This section does not limit or override the ability of a health practitioner to make reports permitted by subdivisions (c) or (j) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or at the patients request. Providers shall follow reporting requirements for child abuse, pursuant to Section 11165 of the Penal Code, and elder and vulnerable adult abuse, pursuant to Section 15600 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(h)(l)For the purposes of this section, it is the Legislatures intent to avoid duplication of information.
(i)(m)For purposes of this section only, employed by a local government agency includes an employee of an entity under contract with a local government agency to provide medical services.
(n)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Life threatening means an injury involving a substantial risk of death, including loss or substantial impairment of the function of a bodily member, organ, or mental faculty that is likely to be permanent, as determined by a licensed health practitioner. Life-threatening injuries can include, but are not limited to, injuries from knife, gun, and strangulation that result in a substantial risk of death.
(2)Referral may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the survivor advocacy organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor advocacy organization, or the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
(3)Warm handoff may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection through a call with a survivor advocate, in-person onsite survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of teleadvocacy. When a telephone call is not possible, the warm handoff may be completed through an email. The patient may decline the warm handoff.
(o)A health practitioner shall not be civilly or criminally liable for any report made or not made pursuant to this section or for any other acts taken or not taken, in relation thereto, or resulting therefrom, in good faith compliance with this section and other applicable state and federal laws.
SEC. 3.Section 11161 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11161.Notwithstanding Section 11160, the following shall apply to every physician or surgeon who has under his or her their charge or care any person described in subdivision (a) of Section 11160:
(a)The physician or surgeon shall make a report in accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 11160 to a local law enforcement agency.
(b)It is recommended that any medical records of a person about whom the physician or surgeon is required to report pursuant to subdivision (a) include the following:
(1)Any comments by the injured person regarding past domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700, or regarding the name of any person suspected of inflicting the wound, wound or other physical injury, or assaultive or abusive conduct injury upon the person.
(2)A map of the injured persons body showing and identifying injuries and bruises at the time of the health care.
(3)A copy of the law enforcement reporting form.
(c)It is recommended that the The physician or surgeon refer the person shall offer a referral to local domestic violence services if the person is suffering or suspected of suffering from domestic violence, as defined in Section 13700.
SEC. 4.Section 11163.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11163.2.(a)In any court proceeding or administrative hearing, neither the physician-patient privilege nor the psychotherapist privilege applies to the information required to be reported pursuant to this article.
(b)The reports required by this article shall be kept confidential by the health facility, clinic, or physicians office that submitted the report, and by local law enforcement agencies, and shall only be disclosed by local law enforcement agencies to those involved in the investigation of the report or the enforcement of a criminal law implicated by a report. In no case shall the person suspected or accused of inflicting the wound, other injury, or assaultive or abusive conduct wound or other injury upon the injured person or his or her attorney person, or the attorney of the suspect accused, be allowed access to the injured persons whereabouts. Nothing in this subdivision is intended to conflict with Section 1054.1 or 1054.2.
(c)For the purposes of this article, reports of suspected child abuse and information contained therein may be disclosed only to persons or agencies with whom investigations of child abuse are coordinated under the regulations promulgated under Section 11174.
(d)The Board of Prison Terms may subpoena reports that are not unfounded and reports that concern only the current incidents upon which parole revocation proceedings are pending against a parolee.
SEC. 5.Section 11163.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:11163.3.(a)A county may establish an interagency domestic violence death review team to assist local agencies in identifying and reviewing domestic violence deaths and near deaths, including homicides and suicides, and facilitating communication among the various agencies involved in domestic violence cases. Interagency domestic violence death review teams have been used successfully to ensure that incidents of domestic violence and abuse are recognized and that agency involvement is reviewed to develop recommendations for policies and protocols for community prevention and intervention initiatives to reduce and eradicate the incidence of domestic violence.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, abuse has the meaning set forth in Section 6203 of the Family Code and domestic violence has the meaning set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code.
(2)For purposes of this section, near death means the victim suffered a life-threatening injury, as determined by a licensed physician or licensed nurse, as a result of domestic violence.
(c)A county may develop a protocol that may be used as a guideline to assist coroners and other persons who perform autopsies on domestic violence victims in the identification of domestic violence, in the determination of whether domestic violence contributed to death or whether domestic violence had occurred prior to death, but was not the actual cause of death, and in the proper written reporting procedures for domestic violence, including the designation of the cause and mode of death.
(d)County domestic violence death review teams shall be comprised of, but not limited to, the following:
(1)Experts in the field of forensic pathology.
(2)Medical personnel with expertise in domestic violence abuse.
(3)Coroners and medical examiners.
(4)Criminologists.
(5)District attorneys and city attorneys.
(6)Representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code.
(7)Law enforcement personnel.
(8)Representatives of local agencies that are involved with domestic violence abuse reporting.
(9)County health department staff who deal with domestic violence victims health issues.
(10)Representatives of local child abuse agencies.
(11)Local professional associations of persons described in paragraphs (1) to (10), inclusive.
(e)An oral or written communication or a document shared within or produced by a domestic violence death review team related to a domestic violence death review is confidential and not subject to disclosure or discoverable by a third party. An oral or written communication or a document provided by a third party to a domestic violence death review team, or between a third party and a domestic violence death review team, is confidential and not subject to disclosure or discoverable by a third party. This includes a statement provided by a survivor in a near-death case review. Notwithstanding the foregoing, recommendations of a domestic violence death review team upon the completion of a review may be disclosed at the discretion of a majority of the members of the domestic violence death review team.
(f)Each organization represented on a domestic violence death review team may share with other members of the team information in its possession concerning the victim who is the subject of the review or any person who was in contact with the victim and any other information deemed by the organization to be pertinent to the review. Any information shared by an organization with other members of a team is confidential. This provision shall permit the disclosure to members of the team of any information deemed confidential, privileged, or prohibited from disclosure by any other statute.
(g)Written and oral information may be disclosed to a domestic violence death review team established pursuant to this section. The team may make a request in writing for the information sought and any person with information of the kind described in paragraph (2) may rely on the request in determining whether information may be disclosed to the team.
(1)An individual or agency that has information governed by this subdivision shall not be required to disclose information. The intent of this subdivision is to allow the voluntary disclosure of information by the individual or agency that has the information.
(2)The following information may be disclosed pursuant to this subdivision:
(A)Notwithstanding Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, medical information.
(B)Notwithstanding Section 5328 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, mental health information.
(C)Notwithstanding Section 15633.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, information from elder abuse reports and investigations, except the identity of persons who have made reports, which shall not be disclosed.
(D)Notwithstanding Section 11167.5 of the Penal Code, 11167.5, information from child abuse reports and investigations, except the identity of persons who have made reports, which shall not be disclosed.
(E)State summary criminal history information, criminal offender record information, and local summary criminal history information, as defined in Sections 11075, 11105, and 13300 of the Penal Code. 13300.
(F)Notwithstanding Section 11163.2 of the Penal Code, 11163.2, information pertaining to reports by health practitioners of persons suffering from physical injuries inflicted by means of a firearm or of persons suffering physical injury where the injury is a result of assaultive or abusive conduct, or abuse, if reported, and information relating to whether a physician referred the person to local domestic violence services as recommended required by Section 11161 of the Penal Code. 11161.
(G)Notwithstanding Section 827 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, information in any juvenile court proceeding.
(H)Information maintained by the Family Court, including information relating to the Family Conciliation Court Law pursuant to Section 1818 of the Family Code, and Mediation of Custody and Visitation Issues pursuant to Section 3177 of the Family Code.
(I)Information provided to probation officers in the course of the performance of their duties, including, but not limited to, the duty to prepare reports pursuant to Section 1203.10 of the Penal Code, 1203.10, as well as the information on which these reports are based.
(J)Notwithstanding Section 10850 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, records of in-home supportive services, unless disclosure is prohibited by federal law.
(3)The disclosure of written and oral information authorized under this subdivision shall apply notwithstanding Sections 2263, 2918, 4982, and 6068 of the Business and Professions Code, or the lawyer-client privilege protected by Article 3 (commencing with Section 950) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the physician-patient privilege protected by Article 6 (commencing with Section 990) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the psychotherapist-patient privilege protected by Article 7 (commencing with Section 1010) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the sexual assault counselor-victim privilege protected by Article 8.5 (commencing with Section 1035) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, the domestic violence counselor-victim privilege protected by Article 8.7 (commencing with Section 1037) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code, and the human trafficking caseworker-victim privilege protected by Article 8.8 (commencing with Section 1038) of Chapter 4 of Division 8 of the Evidence Code.
(4)In near-death cases, representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, shall obtain an individuals informed consent in accordance with all applicable state and federal confidentiality laws, before disclosing confidential information about that individual to another team member as specified in this section. In death review cases, representatives of domestic violence victim service organizations shall only provide client-specific information in accordance with both state and federal confidentiality requirements.
(5)Near-death case reviews shall only occur after any prosecution has concluded.
(6)Near-death survivors shall not be compelled to participate in death review team investigations; their participation is voluntary. In cases of death, the victims family members may be invited to participate, however they shall not be compelled to do so; their participation is voluntary. Members of the death review teams shall be prepared to provide referrals for services to address the unmet needs of survivors and their families when appropriate.
SEC. 6.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jun 11, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 24, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| May 22, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| May 22, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| May 13, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 13, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 42. Noes 15. Page 5189.) |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 10. Noes 4.) (April 10). |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 1, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 11, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 17, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 24, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 11, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2024 | AB 3127 McKinnor Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Access Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| Aclu California Action | ** Support | |
| Alliance for Boys and Men of Color | ** Support | |
| American Nurses Association/California | ** Support | |
| Arcadia Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Asian Americans for Community Involvement | ** Support | |
| Black Lives Matter Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Burbank Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| California Black Women's Collective Empowerment Institute | ** Support | |
| California Consortium for Urban Indian Health | ** Support | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Against | |
| California for Safety and Justice | ** Support | |
| California Narcotic Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| California Partnership To End Domestic Violence | ** Support | |
| California Reserve Peace Officers Association | ** Against | |
| California Sexual Assault Forensic Examiners Association | ** Against | |
| CLAREMONT POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking | ** Support | |
| Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice | ** Support | |
| Community Solutions | ** Support | |
| Corona Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Culturally Responsive Domestic Violence Network | ** Support | |
| Culver City Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Deputy Sheriffs Association of Monterey County | ** Against | |
| Downtown Women's Center | ** Support | |
| east los angeles women's center | ** Support | |
| Family Violence Appellate Project | ** Support | |
| Freefrom | ** Support | |
| Fullerton Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Futures Without Violence | ** Support | |
| Gray's Trauma-Informed Care Service Corps | ** Support | |
| Healthy Alternatives to Violent Environments | ** Support | |
| Heal Trafficking | ** Support | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Support | |
| Jenesse Center, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles LGBT Center | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles School Police Management Association | ** Against | |
| los angeles school police officers association | ** Against | |
| Lumina Alliance | ** Support | |
| Miracles Counseling Center | ** Support | |
| Murrieta Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Newport Beach Police Association | ** Against | |
| Novato Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Palos Verdes Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Assocation | ** Against | |
| Pomona Police Officers' Association | ** Against | |
| Project Sanctuary, INC. | ** Support | |
| Psychiatric Physicians Alliance of California | ** Support | |
| Public Counsel | ** Support | |
| Resilience Orange County | ** Support | |
| RIVERSIDE POLICE OFFICERS ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Against | |
| San Diego County District Attorney's Office | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Public Defender | ** Support | |
| Santa Ana Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Sheedy Consulting, LLC | ** Support | |
| Sunita Jain Anti-Trafficking Initiative | ** Support | |
| The Collective Healing and Transformation Project | ** Support | |
| UC Irvine School of Law, Domestic Violence Clinic | ** Support | |
| Upland Police Officers Association | ** Against | |
| Victims Empowerment Support Team | ** Support | |
| western center on law & poverty | ** Support | |
| Woman INC | ** Support | |
| Youth Forward | ** Support | |
| Youth Leadership Institute | ** Support | |
| Ywca Golden Gate Silicon Valley | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 3127 (McKinnor) - Reporting of crimes: mandated reporters
Version: May 22, 2024 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: June 24, 2024 | Consultant: Liah Burnley |
Bill Summary:
AB 3127 would narrows the circumstances in which a health practitioner must make a report to law enforcement because they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that was caused by assaultive or abusive conduct.
Fiscal Impact:
Unknown, potentially reimbursable costs (local funds, General Fund), possibly in the hundreds of thousands, to local public health departments local government agencies, and clinics or other types of facilities operated by a local health department to provide brief counseling and education, and offer a warm handoff or referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services. Additional training and policy updates may also be required. General Fund costs will depend on whether this bill imposes a state-mandated local program as determined by the Commission on State Mandates. (See Staff Comments)
Background:
According to the author:
California currently requires health care providers to report injuries sustained to their patients that are either suspected to be, or are the direct result of domestic and sexual violence. This requirement for mandatory reporting in medicine does not require that patients consent to the report, and 83.3% of domestic violence (DV) survivors stated that mandatory reporting made their experience worse or did not improve their situation at all.
Not only does medical mandated reporting put victims at higher risk of their abuse escalating, it also violates basic tenets of medical ethics according to the American Medical Association. Naturally, it is unfair to exclude patients from decisions that affect their health when they have the cognitive ability to advocate for themselves, yet physicians will face liability if they do not report to law enforcement. This may result in providers actively avoiding any discussion of domestic violence or sexual assault, and data show that 59% of emergency department providers in California may not comply with the law if their patient did not want them to make a report.
Although well intended, requiring healthcare providers to report adult patients experiencing violence to law enforcement is not an evidence-based practice: there are no data suggesting that it results in positive outcomes for patient health or safety. Research does demonstrate that mandatory reporting may worsen a survivor’s situation and also deter survivors from disclosing abuse to their provider, or even seeking medical attention for injuries sustained from abuse out of fear of being reported.
Proposed Law:
- Eliminates duty of a health care practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by such conduct, except in specified cases
- Retains a health practitioner’s duty to make a report of injuries to law enforcement in instances where a wound or injury is self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, is life threatening and cause by intentional violence, or involves child abuse, elder abuse, or abuse of a dependent adult
- Provides that in the circumstance of an adult seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury, if the patient requests a report be sent to law enforcement health practitioners shall follow the reporting process and document the injuries.
- Requires a health care practitioner, who in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, knows or reasonably suspects that their patient is experiencing any form of domestic violence or sexual violence, to provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a “warm handoff” or referral to domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services before the end of treatment, to the extent that it is medically possible.
- Provides that the health practitioner shall have met the requirement when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided and warm hand off or referral is offered by a member of the health care team.
- Provides that if the health practitioner is providing medical services to the patient in the emergency department of a hospital, they shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a forensic evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
- Encourages health care practitioners to offer patients direct connection to an in-person domestic or sexual violence advocate or social worker whenever available.
- Provided that to the extent possible, health practitioners shall document all nonaccidental violent injuries and incidents of abuse in the medical record.
- Allows the health practitioner to offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any non-accidental injury.
- Provides that nothing limits or overrides the ability of a health care practitioner to alert law enforcement to an imminent or serious threat to health or safety of an individual or the public, pursuant to the privacy rules of HIPAA.
- Defines “warm handoff” may include but is not limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection through a call with survivor advocate, in-person on site survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of tele-advocacy.
- Provides the patient may decline the “warm hand-off”.
- Provides that “referral” may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the survivor advocacy organization information about how the survivor organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor organization, the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
- Contains findings and declarations.
- Provides that a health practitioner shall not be civilly or criminally liable for acting in compliance with these requirements for any report that is made in good faith compliance with state law.
- Makes conforming cross-references.
Related Legislation:
- AB 1028 (McKinnor), of this legislative session, would have eliminated the duty of a health practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement. AB 1028 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 2790 (Wicks), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have limited the duty of a health practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement to injuries that are self-inflicted or caused by a firearm. AB 2790 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Staff Comments: Advocates of this bill contend that this bill could result in some long-term costs savings associated with streamlining health care providers and law enforcement responses. Currently health practitioners are required to spend time filing reports for all violent injuries both to file reports for all violence, in addition to following their health setting protocols for screening, documentation, and referral outlined by their healthcare setting. This bill could allow health practitioners will be able to spend more time on tailored care for the individual patient, and less time engaged in the two-step reporting process in cases where law enforcement may not be warranted.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 3127 Hearing Date: June 11, 2024
Author: | McKinnor | ||
Version: | May 22, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Reporting of crimes: mandated reporters
HISTORY
Source: Futures Without Violence
Prior Legislation: AB 1028 (McKinnor) held in Senate Appropriations 2023
AB 2790 (Wicks) held in Senate Appropriations 2022
Support: ACLU California Action; American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX; American Nurses Association California; Asian Americans for Community Involvement; Asian Resources, Inc.; California Alliance of Academics and Communities for Public Health Equity (public Health Institute); California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Democratic Party; California Medical Assoc.; Coalition to Abolish Slavery and Trafficking; Collective Healing and Transformation Project; Community Solutions for Children, Families and Individuals; Dignity Health; East Los Angeles Women’s Center; FreeFrom; Initiate Justice; Justice At Last; Lumina Alliance; Ohio Domestic Violence Network; Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California; Public Health Advocates; Smart Justice California, a Project of Tides Advocacy; STAND! For Families Free of Violence; Victims Empowerment Support Team; Western Center on Law & Poverty; Woman Inc.; Youth Forward
Opposition: Alliance for Hope International; California District Attorneys Association; California Emergency Nurses Association; California Sexual Assault Forensic Examiner Association; California Sexual Assault Investigators Association; Enloe Medical Center Sexual Assault Response Team; San Diego County District Attorney’s Office; San Diego Emergency Physicians, INC; Training Institute on Strangulation Prevention
Assembly Floor Vote: 42 - 15
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to eliminate the duty of a health care practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement except in specified circumstances.
Existing law requires a health practitioner, as defined, to make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that is either self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, or caused by assaultive or abusive conduct, as specified. (Penal Code § 11160.)
Existing law punishes the failure of a health care practitioner to submit a mandated report by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding $1,000, or by both. (Penal Code § 11162)
Existing law provides that a health practitioner who makes a report in accordance with these duties shall not incur civil or criminal liability as a result of any report. (Penal Code § 11161.9 (a))
Existing law states that neither the physician-patient privilege nor the psychotherapist patient privilege apply in any court or administrative proceeding with regards to the information required to be reported. (Penal Code § 11163.2)
This bill eliminates duty of a health care practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by such conduct, except in specified cases
This bill retains a health practitioner’s duty to make a report of injuries to law enforcement in instances where a wound or injury is self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, is life threatening and cause by intentional violence, or involves child abuse, elder abuse, or abuse of a dependent adult.
This bill provides that in the circumstance of an adult seeking care for injuries related to domestic, sexual, or any nonaccidental violent injury, if the patient requests a report be sent to law enforcement health practitioners shall follow the reporting process and document the injuries.
This bill requires a health care practitioner, who in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, knows or reasonably suspects that their patient is experiencing any form of domestic violence or sexual violence, to provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a “warm handoff” or referral to domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services before the end of treatment, to the extent that it is medically possible.
This bill provides that the health practitioner shall have met the requirement when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided and warm hand off or referral is offered by a member of the health care team.
This bill provides that if the health practitioner is providing medical services to the patient in the emergency department of a hospital, they shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a forensic evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
This bill encourages health care practitioners to offer patients direct connection to an in-person domestic or sexual violence advocate or social worker whenever available.
This bill provided that to the extent possible, health practitioners shall document all nonaccidental violent injuries and incidents of abuse in the medical record.
This bill allows the health practitioner to offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any non-accidental injury.
This bill provides that nothing limits or overrides the ability of a health care practitioner to alert law enforcement to an imminent or serious threat to health or safety of an individual or the public, pursuant to the privacy rules of HIPAA.
This bill defines “warm handoff” may include but is not limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection through a call with survivor advocate, in-person on site survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of tele-advocacy.
This bill provides the patient may decline the “warm hand-off”.
This bill provides that “referral” may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the survivor advocacy organization information about how the survivor organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor organization, the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
This bill contains findings and declarations.
This bill provides that a health practitioner shall not be civilly or criminally liable for acting in compliance with this section for any report that is made in good faith compliance with state law.
This bill makes conforming cross-references.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
California currently requires health care providers to report injuries sustained to their patients that are either suspected to be, or are the direct result of domestic and sexual violence. This requirement for mandatory reporting in medicine does not require that patients consent to the report, and 83.3% of domestic violence (DV) survivors stated that mandatory reporting made their experience worse or did not improve their situation at all.
Not only does medical mandated reporting put victims at higher risk of their abuse escalating, it also violates basic tenets of medical ethics according to the American Medical Association. Naturally, it is unfair to exclude patients from decisions that affect their health when they have the cognitive ability to advocate for themselves, yet physicians will face liability if they do not report to law enforcement. This may result in providers actively avoiding any discussion of domestic violence or sexual assault, and data show that 59% of emergency department providers in California may not comply with the law if their patient did not want them to make a report.
Although well intended, requiring healthcare providers to report adult patients experiencing violence to law enforcement is not an evidence-based practice: there are no data suggesting that it results in positive outcomes for patient health or safety. Research does demonstrate that mandatory reporting may worsen a survivor’s situation and also deter survivors from disclosing abuse to their provider, or even seeking medical attention for injuries sustained from abuse out of fear of being reported.
2. Duty of Health Care Practitioners to Report Injuries
Penal Code section 11160 requires health care facility or clinic who is suffering from specified injuries to report that fact immediately, by telephone and in writing, to the local law enforcement authorities. The duty to report extends to physicians and surgeons, psychiatrists, psychologists, dentists, medical residents, interns, podiatrists, chiropractors, licensed nurses, dental hygienists, optometrists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, emergency medical technicians, paramedics, and others. The duty to report is triggered when a health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects that the patient is suffering from a wound or other physical injury that is the result of assaultive or abusive conduct caused by another person, or when there is a gunshot wound or injury regardless of whether it self-inflicted or one cause by another person. Health practitioners are required to report if these triggering conditions are met, regardless of patient consent. Failure to make the required report is a misdemeanor.
This bill would eliminate the duty of a health care practitioner to report known or suspected assaultive or abusive conduct subject to exceptions. This bill specifies that there is still a duty to report assaultive conduct caused by intentional violence and which results in life threatening injuries or death, as well child abuse, elder abuse, and abuse of a dependent adult. In addition, this bill specifies that nothing in its provisions limits or overrides the ability of a health care provider to report assaultive or abusive conduct at a patient’s request, or to alert law enforcement to an imminent and serious threat to health or safety of an individual pursuant to HIPPA.
According to the background provided by the author, “[i]n a 2020 survey done by the National Domestic Violence Hotline of survivors who had experienced mandated reporting, 83.3% of survivors stated mandatory reporting made the situation much worse, somewhat worse, or did nothing to improve the DV situation. 27% of callers reported that they did not seek healthcare because of mandatory reporting requirements”. A report by Futures Without Violence, a co-sponsor of this bill, notes with regards to mandated reporting laws:
Most U.S. states have enacted mandatory reporting laws, which require the reporting of specified injuries and wounds, and very few have mandated reporting laws specific to suspected abuse or domestic violence for individuals being treated by a health care professional. Mandatory reporting laws are distinct from elder abuse or vulnerable adult abuse and child abuse reporting laws, in that the individuals to be protected are not limited to a specific group, but pertain to all individuals to whom specific health care professionals provide treatment or medical care, or those who come before the health care facility. The laws vary from state-to-state, but generally fall into four categories: states that require reporting of injuries caused by weapons; states that mandate reporting for injuries caused in violation of criminal laws, as a result of violence, or through non-accidental means; states that specifically address reporting in domestic violence cases; and states that have no general mandatory reporting laws.
(Compendium of State and U.S. Territory Statutes and Policies on Domestic Violence and Health Care, Fourth Ed. 2019 at pp.2-3, available https://www.futureswithoutviolence.org/wp-content/uploads/Compendium-4th-Edition-2019-Final.pdf.)
It should be noted that the duty to report known or suspected child abuse and neglect under the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act, is separate from a health care practitioner’s duty to report injuries generally. (See Penal Code § 11164 et. seq.) This bill does not eliminate the duty of health care practitioners under that Act. Similarly, the duty to report known or suspected abuse of an elder or a dependent adult is also separate from a health care provider’s general duty to report injury. (See Welfare & Inst. Code,§ 15360.) This bill also does not eliminate the duty of health care practitioners under those provisions of law.
3. Prior Legislation
This bill is similar to AB 1028 (McKinnor) 2023 and AB 2790 (Wicks) both of which passed this Committee and were held in Senate Appropriations Committee. This bill is narrower than either of those bills by continuing to require reporting when a would or physical injury is life threatening and caused by the use of nonaccidental violence by another.
4. Argument in Support
In support the California Alliance of Academics and Communities for Public Health Equity support this bill stating, in part:
Domestic and sexual violence have been shown to be associated with increased risk of many health issues, and so health care providers play a critical role in prevention, identification, and response to violence. When providers can have open, trauma-informed conversations with patients about abuse, survivors are four times more likely to access an intervention, such as domestic violence advocacy. Unfortunately, we have seen the ways in which strict medical mandated reporting requirements for all violent injuries have kept survivors from seeking necessary healthcare in the first place, made survivors feel like they could never return to healthcare after they learned of the requirement, or made them feel like they could not share the reason for or extent of certain injuries or health issues with their provider. Not only do these broad requirements create a barrier to healthcare, but medical mandated reporting to law enforcement can result in the escalation of abuse, undue child welfare involvement, survivors themselves being criminalized, exposure to immigration detention or deportation, and more.
According to a study of callers to National Domestic Violence Hotline, 51% of survivors who had experienced mandatory reporting stated that it made their situations much worse, and another 32% stated that it either made things worse or did not help them at all. Although a well-intentioned attempt to ensure domestic and sexual violence is taken seriously as a health issue, there is no research that suggests that medical mandated reporting for violent injuries results in positive safety outcomes for survivors. Survivors in California deserve to be able to access trauma-informed healthcare separately from law enforcement. Domestic and sexual violence advocates are specifically trained to help survivors more safely access the criminal and civil legal systems should they want to.
Because AB 3127 will require health providers to offer a warm hand off and referral to an advocacy organization, advocates will be able to respond before violence escalates. A warm and informed connection to confidential advocacy services will allow survivors to address their various safety needs- from crisis intervention, emergency housing to legal support- in an on-going and trauma-informed way. In a more measured approach than previous versions of this bill, AB 3127 will limit injuries that require a medical mandated report to life threatening
violent injuries and firearm injuries, as well as require that providers in acute care settings offer assistance to violently injured patients in accessing a medical evidentiary exam or reporting to law enforcement, in addition to making offering a connection to anti-violence advocates.
5. Argument in Opposition
California Sexual Assault Forensic Examiner Association opposes this bill stating in part:
The authors describe this bill to replace “reporting with supporting”. But the only requirement is brief counseling and a hotline phone number. The Bill does not provide for IN-PERSON advocacy and given the planned cuts to VOCA funding fewer advocates will be available in the future. In the model of the Sexual Assault Response Team (SART), health care providers work together with law enforcement and advocates to guide patients in crisis through their choices and legal options. Without this “support” patients will be left on their own to engage with systems that they may already feel too overwhelmed or unprepared to navigate without confidential, trauma-informed guidance.
DV health care mandatory reporting developed because of the growing number of domestic violence homicides. 47% of DV homicide victims are seen in a health care setting in the year before they are killed for injuries sustained by the same person that ultimately kills them, and for every 1 completed DV homicide there are 8 attempted homicides and those patients are being seen everyday in EDs across the state. Domestic Violence homicide risk assessment and harm reduction falls squarely in the realm of health care. We need more education and engagement from health care, not less. When the injuries are severe and DV fatality risk high, an advocate alone cannot be expected to provide safety, law enforcement is needed.
-- END –
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3127
Author:(McKinnor)
As Amended Ver:April 1, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Eliminates the duty of a health care practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by such conduct, except in specified cases.
Major Provisions
- Retains a health practitioner's duty to make a report of injuries to law enforcement to instances where a wound or injury is self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, is life threatening and caused by intentional violence, or involves child abuse, elder abuse, or the abuse of a dependent adult.
- Allows reporting of other assaultive or abusive conduct when a patient requests, and in such cases, requires the medical documentation of injuries be made available to the patient.
- Requires a health care practitioner, who in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, knows or reasonably suspects that their patient is experiencing any form of domestic violence or sexual violence, to provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a "warm handoff" or referral to domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services before the end of treatment, to the extent that it is medically possible.
- Encourages health care practitioners to offer patients direct connection to an in-person domestic or sexual violence advocate or social worker whenever available.
- Provides that the health practitioner can satisfy the above requirement when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided by, and warm handoff or referral is offered by, a member of the health care team.
- States that if the patient is being treated in the emergency department of a general acute care hospital, the health practitioner shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a medical evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
- Allows the health practitioner to offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any non-accidental injury.
- Defines "warm handoff" as including but not being limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection through a call with survivor advocate, in-person on site survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of teleadvocacy.
- Provides the patient may decline the "warm hand-off."
- Provides that a "referral" may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor organization, the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
- Provides that nothing limits or overrides the ability of a health care practitioner to alert law enforcement to an imminent or serious threat to health or safety of an individual or the public, pursuant to the privacy rules of the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA).
- Gives health care practitioners immunity from criminal or civil liability arising from any required or authorized report.
- Contains legislative findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
According to the Author
"AB 3127 will ensure survivors can access healthcare services by creating a survivor-centered, trauma-informed approach and limit non-consensual and potentially dangerous referrals to law enforcement. This change will increase access to healthcare and ensure that survivors are provided the agency and information they need to be safe and healthy."
Arguments in Support
According to Futures Without Violence, a co-sponsor of this bill, "California law currently mandates that health professionals, when treating patients who have a physical injury that is known or suspected to have been a result of violence make an immediate report to law enforcement. While medical mandated reporting to law enforcement for firearm wounds or other very serious injuries is common in many states, California is one of only three states that still have such broad and harmful requirements to report explicitly for domestic and sexual violence-related injuries without patient consent. Although this law was a well-intentioned attempt to ensure health care providers take violence and abuse seriously, no research has shown that medical mandatory reporting to law enforcement has positive safety or health outcomes for survivors.
"Domestic and sexual violence can have long term negative health outcomes, so it is crucial that survivors are able to access health care. Though health providers have an important role in addressing violence, some actively avoid discussing domestic and sexual violence out of fear of having to make a report to law enforcement. Mandatory reporting laws have also been shown to keep survivors from seeking care, and when survivors do see a health provider, they often don't feel comfortable bringing up their experiences of violence. This results in unaddressed health issues and missed opportunities to connect survivors to crucial advocacy services.
"Fear of involving law enforcement is a main reason survivors decide not to tell their health provider about domestic violence, or even seek care in the first place. According to a survey by the National Domestic Violence Hotline that documented survivors' experiences with law enforcement, of survivors who chose to involve law enforcement by calling 911, only 20% said they felt safer - 80% said they had no change in safety or felt even less safe. There are many reasons why survivors do not want to involve police: fear of angering their partner and increasing severity of violence, not wanting their partner to be arrested, being arrested for defending themselves, exposing themselves and their families to involvement with child welfare systems, and more. Mandatory reporting laws may also discourage immigrant survivors from seeking health care; research has shown that contact with law enforcement produces a chilling effect in asking for help or fear of reprisal from federal immigration authorities.
"Extensive research has been done on what survivors of domestic and sexual violence want from health care professionals: self-determination and autonomy, validation and compassion, confidentiality and trust, and informed providers who are able to offer resources and health promotion strategies.
"In a more measured approach than previous versions of this bill, AB 3127 will limit injuries that require a medical mandated report to life threatening violent injuries and firearm injuries, in addition to child abuse and elder abuse. With this bill, health providers will be required to offer survivors a warm connection to a trained, confidential advocate who will work with them to address their different safety needs such as emergency safety planning, housing, legal support, counseling, restraining orders, and safer access to the legal system. Health providers will be able to address domestic and sexual violence in a confidential and trusting manner, and ensure access to advocacy services."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the California Sexual Assault Forensic Examiners Association (Cal SAFE), "We agree that PC 11160-1163.6 needs to be amended; however, the proposed language is an over-reach that creates significant unintended consequences. The bill language was developed without consultation or considerations for PC 13823.5-13823.11 which defines the standard of care for the medical treatment of victims of Sexual Assault and gives authority to the California Clinical Forensic Medical Training Center to establish best practices for the care of Sexual Assault patients. Cal SAFE has met with the authors and sponsors in an effort to educate, explain unintended consequences, and propose amended language. We have been unable to come to a timely agreement with the sponsors that will address the health and safety concerns for patients who are victims of Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence together referred to as Interpersonal Violence (IPV). …
"AB1028 was initiated to address the needs of IPV victims who DO NOT WANT to report to law enforcement, however it does not protect victims that DO WANT to make a report to law enforcement. Often the most injured victims, brought to emergency departments WANT and NEED the support of health care and advocacy to make or complete a report to law enforcement. AB 1028, if passed, will eliminate any requirement for health care to assist a victim to report to law enforcement, and instead will require only that health care provider give a victim of IPV a phone number to a DV advocacy agency. In Alameda County, only 4% of domestic violence victims who only received Family Justice Center (FJC) contact information in the emergency room setting ever made contact with the FJC.. In contrast, IN-PERSON advocacy will quantitatively and qualitatively improve survivor outcomes. Direct-to-advocacy (warm-handoff) referrals, unlike traditional referrals, improve survivor's chances of reaching advocacy services (increase to 48% in Alameda County) and also alleviated racial/ethnic disparities in care.
"The OPT IN approach to mandatory reporting that is proposed in this bill asserts that it will guarantee autonomy for victims, but without mandating IN-PERSON advocacy to guide these patients in crisis through their choices and legal options, it will more likely be perceived by the patients as further abandonment, particularly for the patients with the most challenges to navigating systems. Cal SAFE proposes to amend the language to 1) Require IN-PERSON advocacy for those victims at highest risk for DV homicide. 2) Maintain health care mandatory reporting to law enforcement for victims that present for care, in urgent or emergency health care settings seeking care for IPV injury including all forms of serious life threatening injuries, not just gun related injuries.
"Since 2017, sexual assault (SA) victims have had the option of the Non Investigative Report (NIR) created for SA victims who are undecided about making a statement to law enforcement. This allows the victim to have in-person advocacy and medical forensic exam to capture time sensitive evidence, and to postpone making the law enforcement report until which time the patient is ready. The OPT-OUT NIR protocol has been used by 6% of SA victims annually across the state. The NIR solution has been effectively utilized and allows patients time to make a considered decision. A similar NIR report protocol for DV would be an option that will maintain much needed medical/forensic documentation while giving the patient the option to consider reporting to law enforcement.
"50% of all DV homicides are committed with guns. Limiting mandated reporting to gun related injuries, as proposed in AB 1028, will eliminate the mandate for health care to report all other forms of DV regardless of severity. DV health care mandatory reporting was an effort to impact the growing number of domestic violence homicides. Homicide is the leading cause of death for pregnant women in the U.S. and black women are at substantially higher risk of being killed. Kentucky eliminated health care mandatory reporting 5 years ago, and since has seen a 63% increase in DV homicides. A multidisciplinary approach to DV that includes health care, advocacy and law enforcement is homicide prevention. Removing the health care mandated report without providing direct to advocacy (warm hand-off) referrals will result in more DV homicides."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, "Likely no state costs. Possible minor cost savings to the court and counties to the extent this bill narrows an existing misdemeanor and results in fewer convictions and jail terms.
Unknown, potentially absorbable costs to local public health agencies and clinics to provide brief counseling and offer referrals to patients suspected of experiencing domestic or sexual violence. Costs to the General Fund will depend on whether the duties imposed by this bill constitute a reimbursable state mandate, as determined by the Commission on State Mandates."
VOTES
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 5-0-3
YES: McCarty, Reyes, Ting, Wilson, Zbur
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Lackey, Stephanie Nguyen
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 10-4-1
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
ABS, ABST OR NV: Wendy Carrillo
UPDATED
VERSION: April 1, 2024
CONSULTANT: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0002712
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3127
Author:(McKinnor) – As Amended Ver:April 1, 2024
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill narrows the circumstances in which a health practitioner must make a report to law enforcement because they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that was caused by assaultive or abusive conduct.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Likely no state costs. Possible minor cost savings to the court and counties to the extent this bill narrows an existing misdemeanor and results in fewer convictions and jail terms.
Unknown, potentially absorbable costs to local public health agencies and clinics to provide brief counseling and offer referrals to patients suspected of experiencing domestic or sexual violence. Costs to the General Fund will depend on whether the duties imposed by this bill constitute a reimbursable state mandate, as determined by the Commission on State Mandates.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 3127 will ensure survivors can access healthcare services by creating a survivor-centered, trauma-informed approach and limit non-consensual and potentially dangerous referrals to law enforcement. This change will increase access to healthcare and ensure that survivors are provided the agency and information they need to be safe and healthy.
- Background. Existing law requires a health practitioner who treats a person suffering from specified injuries to report that fact immediately to local law enforcement authorities. The duty to report is triggered when a health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects that the patient is suffering from a wound or other physical injury that is the result of assaultive or abusive conduct caused by another person, or when the injury was caused by a firearm. The duty to report extends to many health care professionals including physicians, surgeons, psychiatrists, psychologists, dentists, medical residents, interns, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, emergency medical technicians, and paramedics, among others. A health practitioner is required to report assault or abuse regardless of patient consent. Failure to make the required report is a misdemeanor.
This bill narrows the circumstances in which a health practitioner has a duty to report known or suspected assaultive or abusive conduct. Under the bill, a health practitioner must make a report to law enforcement only if the patient’s injury was caused by a firearm, was life threatening, or resulted in death. The bill defines “life threatening” as an injury likely to result in death without immediate medical or surgical intervention, including injuries from a knife, gun, or strangulation. In practice, this means a health practitioner who suspects a lesser injury was caused by domestic violence will no longer be required to report the injury to law enforcement or face a potential criminal charge. A health practitioner may still make a report to law enforcement based on lesser injuries at the request of a patient.
Whenever a health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects a patient is experiencing domestic or sexual violence, the bill requires the practitioner, to the degree that it is medically possible for the individual patient, to provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a “warm handoff” or referral to local and national domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services. This requirement is satisfied when a member of the health care team provides brief counseling and simply offers a referral to advocacy services. The bill does not eliminate a health practitioner’s duty to report known or suspected child abuse and neglect, or their duty to report known or suspected abuse of an elder or a dependent adult.
- Prior Legislation. AB 1028 (McKinnor), of this legislative session, would have eliminated the duty of a health practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement. AB 1028 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2790 (Wicks), of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, would have limited the duty of a health practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement to injuries that are self-inflicted or caused by a firearm. AB 2790 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
Chief Counsel: Sandy Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3127
Author:(McKinnor) – As Amended Ver:April 1, 2024
SUMMARY:
Eliminates the duty of a health care practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury caused by such conduct, except in specified cases. Specifically, this bill:
- Retains a health practitioner’s duty to make a report of injuries to law enforcement to instances where a wound or injury is self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, is life threatening and caused by intentional violence, or involves child abuse, elder abuse, or the abuse of a dependent adult.
- Allows reporting of other assaultive or abusive conduct when a patient requests, and in such cases, requires the medical documentation of injuries be made available to the patient.
- Requires a health care practitioner, who in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, knows or reasonably suspects that their patient is experiencing any form of domestic violence or sexual violence, to provide brief counseling, education, or other support, and offer a “warm handoff” or referral to domestic violence or sexual violence advocacy services before the end of treatment, to the extent that it is medically possible.
- Encourages health care practitioners to offer patients direct connection to an in-person domestic or sexual violence advocate or social worker whenever available.
- Provides that the health practitioner can satisfy the above requirement when the brief counseling, education, or other support is provided by, and warm handoff or referral is offered by, a member of the health care team.
- States that if the patient is being treated in the emergency department of a general acute care hospital, the health practitioner shall also offer assistance to the patient in accessing a medical evidentiary exam, reporting to law enforcement, and a 24-hour domestic or sexual violence advocacy program, if the patient wants to pursue these options.
- Allows the health practitioner to offer a warm handoff and referral to other available victim services, including, but not limited to, legal aid, community-based organizations, behavioral health, crime victim compensation, forensic evidentiary exams, trauma recovery centers, family justice centers, and law enforcement to patients who are suspected to have suffered any non-accidental injury.
- Defines “warm handoff” as including but not being limited to, the health practitioner establishing direct and live connection through a call with survivor advocate, in-person on site survivor advocate, in-person on-call survivor advocate, or some other form of teleadvocacy.
- Provides the patient may decline the “warm hand-off.”
- Provides that a “referral” may include, but is not limited to, the health practitioner sharing information about how a patient can get in touch with a local or national survivor advocacy organization, information about how the organization could be helpful for the patient, what the patient could expect when contacting the survivor organization, the survivor advocacy organizations contact information.
- Provides that nothing limits or overrides the ability of a health care practitioner to alert law enforcement to an imminent or serious threat to health or safety of an individual or the public, pursuant to the privacy rules of the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPPA).
- Gives health care practitioners immunity from criminal or civil liability arising from any required or authorized report.
- Contains legislative findings and declarations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires a health practitioner, as defined, to make a report to law enforcement when they suspect a patient has suffered physical injury that is either self-inflicted, caused by a firearm, or caused by assaultive or abusive conduct, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 11160.)
- Punishes the failure of a health care practitioner to submit a mandated report by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding $1,000, or by both. (Pen. Code, § 11162.)
- Provides that a health practitioner who makes a report in accordance with these duties shall not incur civil or criminal liability as a result of any report. (Pen. Code, § 11161.9, subd. (a).)
- States that neither the physician-patient privilege nor the psychotherapist patient privilege apply in any court or administrative proceeding with regards to the information required to be reported. (Pen. Code, § 11163.2)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “AB 3127 will ensure survivors can access healthcare services by creating a survivor-centered, trauma-informed approach and limit non-consensual and potentially dangerous referrals to law enforcement. This change will increase access to healthcare and ensure that survivors are provided the agency and information they need to be safe and healthy.”
- Duty of Health Care Practitioners to Report Injuries: Penal Code section 11160 requires a health care practitioner who treats a person brought in to a health care facility or clinic who is suffering from specified injuries to report that fact immediately, by telephone and in writing, to the local law enforcement authorities. The duty to report extends to physicians and surgeons, psychiatrists, psychologists, dentists, medical residents, interns, podiatrists, chiropractors, licensed nurses, dental hygienists, optometrists, marriage and family therapists, clinical social workers, professional clinical counselors, emergency medical technicians, paramedics, and others. The duty to report is triggered when a health practitioner knows or reasonably suspects that the patient is suffering from a wound or other physical injury that is the result of assaultive or abusive conduct caused by another person, or when there is a gunshot wound or injury regardless of whether it is self-inflicted or one caused by another person. Health practitioners are required to report if these triggering conditions are met, regardless of patient consent. Failure to make the required report is a misdemeanor.
This bill would eliminate the duty of a health care practitioner to report known or suspected assaultive or abusive conduct, subject to exceptions. This bill specifies that there is still a duty to report assaultive conduct caused by intentional violence and which results in life threatening injuries or death, as well child abuse, elder abuse, and abuse of a dependent adult. In addition, this bill specifies that nothing in its provisions limits or overrides the ability of a health care provider to report assaultive or abusive conduct at a patient’s request, or to alert law enforcement to an imminent and serious threat to health or safety of an individual pursuant to HIPPA.
A report by Futures Without Violence, a co-sponsor of this bill, notes with regards to mandated reporting laws:
Most U.S. states have enacted mandatory reporting laws, which require the reporting of specified injuries and wounds, and very few have mandated reporting laws specific to suspected abuse or domestic violence for individuals being treated by a health care professional. Mandatory reporting laws are distinct from elder abuse or vulnerable adult abuse and child abuse reporting laws, in that the individuals to be protected are not limited to a specific group, but pertain to all individuals to whom specific health care professionals provide treatment or medical care, or those who come before the health care facility. The laws vary from state-to-state, but generally fall into four categories: states that require reporting of injuries caused by weapons; states that mandate reporting for injuries caused in violation of criminal laws, as a result of violence, or through non-accidental means; states that specifically address reporting in domestic violence cases; and states that have no general mandatory reporting laws.
(Compendium of State and U.S. Territory Statutes and Policies on Domestic Violence and Health Care, Fourth Ed. 2019 at pp.2-3, available at: https://www.futureswithoutviolence.org/wp-content/uploads/Compendium-4th-Edition-2019-Final.pdf.)
A survey of state laws on reporting nationwide shows:
[O]nly two states have laws that specifically require mandated reporting of DV specifically (not just injuries) to law enforcement and that five states have exceptions for reporting injuries due to domestic violence. New Hampshire’s statute excuses a person from reporting if the victim is over 18, has been the victim of a sexual assault offense or abuse (defined in RSA 173-B:1), and objects to the release of any information to law enforcement. However, this exception does not apply if the victim of sexual assault or abuse is also being treated for a gunshot wound or other serious bodily injury. Oklahoma’s statute does not require reporting domestic abuse if the victim is over age 18 and is not incapacitated, unless the victim requests that the report be made orally or in writing. In all cases what is reported to be domestic abuse shall clearly and legibly be documented by the health care provider and any treatment provided. Pennsylvania’s statute states that failure to report such injuries when the act caused bodily injury (defined in § 2301) is not an offense if the victim is an adult; the injury was inflicted by an individual who is the current or former spouse or sexual or intimate partner; has been living as a spouse or who shares biological parenthood; the victim has been informed of the physician’s duty to report and that report cannot be made without the victim’s consent; the victim does not consent to the report; and the victim has been provided with a referral to the appropriate victim service agency. Tennessee’s statute excuses health care practitioners from reporting if the person is 18 years of age or older; objects to the release of any identifying information to law enforcement officials; and is a victim of a sexual assault offense or domestic abuse (defined in § 36-3-601). The exception does not apply and the injuries shall be reported if the injuries incurred by the sexual assault or domestic abuse victim are considered by the treating healthcare professional to be life threatening, or the victim is being treated for injuries inflicted by strangulation, a knife, pistol, gun, or other deadly weapon. Colorado’s statute provides an exception for reporting if the injuries are resulting from domestic violence and if the victim is at least 18 and does not wish the injury to be reported. This exception does not apply if the injury is from a firearm, knife, ice pick, or other sharp object. Compendium of State and U.S. Territory Statutes and Policies on Domestic Violence and Health Care Futures Without Violence Kentucky, North Dakota, and Washington also require that victims of domestic violence be given educational information related to support services. Kentucky’s statute states that professionals (including health professionals) must provide the victim with educational materials on domestic violence support services if the professional has cause to believe the patient has experienced domestic or dating violence. North Dakota’s statute requires that health professionals provide victims with information on support services when a report on domestic or sexual violence has been made. Washington’s statute requires that hospitals inform the patient of resources to ensure their safety if the patient has stated that their bullet, gunshot, or stab wound was the result of domestic violence. (Compendium, supra, at pp. 5-6.)
It should be stressed that the duty to report known or suspected child abuse and neglect under the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act, is separate from a health care practitioner’s duty to report injuries generally. (See Pen. Code, § 11164 et. seq.) This bill does not eliminate the duty of health care practitioners under that Act. Similarly, the duty to report known or suspected abuse of an elder or a dependent adult is also separate from a health care provider’s general duty to report injury. (See Welf. & Inst. Code, § 15360.) This bill also does not eliminate the duty of health care practitioners under those provisions of law. In fact, as noted above, this bill specifies that there is still a duty to report those types of abuse.
- Argument in Support: According to Futures Without Violence, a co-sponsor of this bill, “California law currently mandates that health professionals, when treating patients who have a physical injury that is known or suspected to have been a result of violence make an immediate report to law enforcement. While medical mandated reporting to law enforcement for firearm wounds or other very serious injuries is common in many states, California is one of only three states that still have such broad and harmful requirements to report explicitly for domestic and sexual violence-related injuries without patient consent. Although this law was a well-intentioned attempt to ensure health care providers take violence and abuse seriously, no research has shown that medical mandatory reporting to law enforcement has positive safety or health outcomes for survivors.
“Domestic and sexual violence can have long term negative health outcomes, so it is crucial that survivors are able to access health care. Though health providers have an important role in addressing violence, some actively avoid discussing domestic and sexual violence out of fear of having to make a report to law enforcement. Mandatory reporting laws have also been shown to keep survivors from seeking care, and when survivors do see a health provider, they often don’t feel comfortable bringing up their experiences of violence. This results in unaddressed health issues and missed opportunities to connect survivors to crucial advocacy services.
“Fear of involving law enforcement is a main reason survivors decide not to tell their health provider about domestic violence, or even seek care in the first place. According to a survey by the National Domestic Violence Hotline that documented survivors’ experiences with law enforcement, of survivors who chose to involve law enforcement by calling 911, only 20% said they felt safer - 80% said they had no change in safety or felt even less safe. There are many reasons why survivors do not want to involve police: fear of angering their partner and increasing severity of violence, not wanting their partner to be arrested, being arrested for defending themselves, exposing themselves and their families to involvement with child welfare systems, and more. Mandatory reporting laws may also discourage immigrant survivors from seeking health care; research has shown that contact with law enforcement produces a chilling effect in asking for help or fear of reprisal from federal immigration authorities.
“Extensive research has been done on what survivors of domestic and sexual violence want from health care professionals: self determination and autonomy, validation and compassion, confidentiality and trust, and informed providers who are able to offer resources and health promotion strategies.
“In a more measured approach than previous versions of this bill, AB 3127 will limit injuries that require a medical mandated report to life threatening violent injuries and firearm injuries, in addition to child abuse and elder abuse. With this bill, health providers will be required to offer survivors a warm connection to a trained, confidential advocate who will work with them to address their different safety needs such as emergency safety planning, housing, legal support, counseling, restraining orders, and safer access to the legal system. Health providers will be able to address domestic and sexual violence in a confidential and trusting manner, and ensure access to advocacy services.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to the California Sexual Assault Forensic Examiners Association (Cal SAFE), “We agree that PC 11160-1163.6 needs to be amended; however, the proposed language is an over-reach that creates significant unintended consequences. The bill language was developed without consultation or considerations for PC 13823.5-13823.11 which defines the standard of care for the medical treatment of victims of Sexual Assault and gives authority to the California Clinical Forensic Medical Training Center to establish best practices for the care of Sexual Assault patients. Cal SAFE has met with the authors and sponsors in an effort to educate, explain unintended consequences, and propose amended language. We have been unable to come to a timely agreement with the sponsors that will address the health and safety concerns for patients who are victims of Sexual Assault and Domestic Violence together referred to as Interpersonal Violence (IPV). …
“AB1028 was initiated to address the needs of IPV victims who DO NOT WANT to report to law enforcement, however it does not protect victims that DO WANT to make a report to law enforcement. Often the most injured victims, brought to emergency departments WANT and NEED the support of health care and advocacy to make or complete a report to law enforcement. AB 1028, if passed, will eliminate any requirement for health care to assist a victim to report to law enforcement, and instead will require only that health care provider give a victim of IPV a phone number to a DV advocacy agency. In Alameda County, only 4% of domestic violence victims who only received Family Justice Center (FJC) contact information in the emergency room setting ever made contact with the FJC.. In contrast, IN-PERSON advocacy will quantitatively and qualitatively improve survivor outcomes. Direct-to-advocacy (warm-handoff) referrals, unlike traditional referrals, improve survivor's chances of reaching advocacy services (increase to 48% in Alameda County) and also alleviated racial/ethnic disparities in care.
“The OPT IN approach to mandatory reporting that is proposed in this bill asserts that it will guarantee autonomy for victims, but without mandating IN-PERSON advocacy to guide these patients in crisis through their choices and legal options, it will more likely be perceived by the patients as further abandonment, particularly for the patients with the most challenges to navigating systems. Cal SAFE proposes to amend the language to 1) Require IN-PERSON advocacy for those victims at highest risk for DV homicide. 2) Maintain health care mandatory reporting to law enforcement for victims that present for care, in urgent or emergency health care settings seeking care for IPV injury including all forms of serious life threatening injuries, not just gun related injuries.
“Since 2017, sexual assault (SA) victims have had the option of the Non Investigative Report (NIR) created for SA victims who are undecided about making a statement to law enforcement. This allows the victim to have in-person advocacy and medical forensic exam to capture time sensitive evidence, and to postpone making the law enforcement report until which time the patient is ready. The OPT-OUT NIR protocol has been used by 6% of SA victims annually across the state. The NIR solution has been effectively utilized and allows patients time to make a considered decision. A similar NIR report protocol for DV would be an option that will maintain much needed medical/forensic documentation while giving the patient the option to consider reporting to law enforcement.
“50% of all DV homicides are committed with guns. Limiting mandated reporting to gun related injuries, as proposed in AB 1028, will eliminate the mandate for health care to report all other forms of DV regardless of severity. DV health care mandatory reporting was an effort to impact the growing number of domestic violence homicides. Homicide is the leading cause of death for pregnant women in the U.S. and black women are at substantially higher risk of being killed. Kentucky eliminated health care mandatory reporting 5 years ago, and since has seen a 63% increase in DV homicides. A multidisciplinary approach to DV that includes health care, advocacy and law enforcement is homicide prevention. Removing the health care mandated report without providing direct to advocacy (warm hand-off) referrals will result in more DV homicides.” - Prior Legislation:
- AB 1028 (McKinnor) of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, was similar to this bill. AB 1028 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 2790 (Wicks) of the 2021-2022 Legislative Session, also would have limited the duty of a health care practitioner to report assaultive or abusive conduct to law enforcement to instances in which the wound or injury is self-inflicted or caused by a firearm. AB 2790 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1028 (McKinnor) of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, was similar to this bill. AB 1028 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Access Reproductive Justice
ACLU California Action
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Nurses Association/California
Asian Americans for Community Involvement
Black Lives Matter - Los Angeles
California Black Women's Collective Empowerment Institute
California Consortium for Urban Indian Health
California for Safety and Justice
California Partnership to End Domestic Violence
Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking (CAST)
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice (CURYJ)
Community Solutions
Culturally Responsive Domestic Violence Network
Downtown Women's Center
East Los Angeles Women's Center
Family Violence Appellate Project
Freefrom
Futures Without Violence (UNREG)
Gray's Trauma-informed Care Services Corp
Heal Trafficking
Healthy Alternatives to Violent Environments
Initiate Justice
Jenesse Center, INC.
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, INC.
Los Angeles LGBT Center
Lumina Alliance
Miracles Counseling Center
Project Sanctuary, INC.
Psychiatric Physicians Alliance of California
Public Counsel
Resilience Orange County
San Francisco Public Defender
Sheedy Consulting, LLC
Sunita Jain Anti-trafficking Initiative
The Collective Healing and Transformation Project
UC Irvine School of Law, Domestic Violence Clinic
Victims Empowerment Support Team
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Woman INC
Youth Forward
Youth Leadership Institute
YWCA Golden Gate Silicon Valley
Opposition
Arcadia Police Officers' Association
Burbank Police Officers' Association
California District Attorneys Association
California Narcotic Officers' Association
California Reserve Peace Officers Association
California Sexual Assault Forensic Examiner Association
Claremont Police Officers Association
Corona Police Officers Association
Culver City Police Officers' Association
Deputy Sheriffs' Association of Monterey County
Fullerton Police Officers' Association
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles School Police Management Association
Los Angeles School Police Officers Association
Murrieta Police Officers' Association
Newport Beach Police Association
Novato Police Officers Association
Palos Verdes Police Officers Association
Placer County Deputy Sheriffs' Assocation
Pomona Police Officers' Association
Riverside Police Officers Association
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
San Diego County District Attorney's Office
Santa Ana Police Officers Association
Upland Police Officers Association
Analysis Prepared by:
Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):