AB 3186: Public works: prevailing wages: access to records.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-20
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-05: Referred to Com. on RLS.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires that, except as specified, not less than the general prevailing rate of per diem wages be paid to workers employed on public works and imposes misdemeanor penalties for a willful violation of this requirement. Existing law defines public works, for the purposes of regulating public works contracts, as, among other things, construction, alteration, demolition, installation, or repair work done under contract and paid for, in whole or in part, out of public funds.
Existing law requires the Labor Commissioner to investigate allegations that a contractor or subcontractor violated the law regulating public works projects, including the payment of prevailing wages. Existing law requires each contractor and subcontractor on a public works project to keep accurate payroll records, showing the name, address, social security number, work classification, straight time and overtime hours worked each day and week, and the actual per diem wages paid to each journeyman, apprentice, worker, or other employee employed by the contractor or subcontractor in connection with the public work. Existing law requires any copy of records made available for inspection as copies and furnished upon request to the public or any public agency to be marked or obliterated to prevent disclosure of an individuals name, address, and social security number but specifies that any copy of records made available to a Taft-Hartley trust fund for the purposes of allocating contributions to participants be marked or obliterated only to prevent disclosure of an individuals full social security number, as specified.
This bill would require each contractor and subcontractor performing work on an owner or developer, as defined, undertaking any public works project and any covered entity, as defined for these purposes as a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity, that develops or undertakes such project, to make specified records available upon request to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified. The bill would also apply this requirement to contractors, subcontractors, and covered entities that are developing, undertaking, or performing work on an owner or developer that undertakes a development project for which contractors are required to maintain and verify payroll records, as specified. that includes work subject to the requirements of public works. The bill would subject a contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity, an owner or developer, for failing to comply with the provisions of this act, to a penalty by the commissioner, as specified, and would deposit the penalties into a specified fund. This bill would require the Director of Industrial Relations to adopt rules to govern the release of those records, as specified.
Existing law requires that, except as specified, not less than the general prevailing rate of per diem wages be paid to workers employed on public works and imposes misdemeanor penalties for a willful violation of this requirement. Existing law defines public works, for the purposes of regulating public works contracts, as, among other things, construction, alteration, demolition, installation, or repair work done under contract and paid for, in whole or in part, out of public funds.
Existing law requires the Labor Commissioner to investigate allegations that a contractor or subcontractor violated the law regulating public works projects, including the payment of prevailing wages. Existing law requires each contractor and subcontractor on a public works project to keep accurate payroll records, showing the name, address, social security number, work classification, straight time and overtime hours worked each day and week, and the actual per diem wages paid to each journeyman, apprentice, worker, or other employee employed by the contractor or subcontractor in connection with the public work. Existing law requires any copy of records made available for inspection as copies and furnished upon request to the public or any public agency to be marked or obliterated to prevent disclosure of an individuals name, address, and social security number but specifies that any copy of records made available to a Taft-Hartley trust fund for the purposes of allocating contributions to participants be marked or obliterated only to prevent disclosure of an individuals full social security number, as specified.
This bill would require each contractor and subcontractor performing work on any public works project and any covered entity, as defined for these purposes as a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity, that develops or undertakes such project, to make specified records available upon request to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified. The bill would also apply this requirement to contractors, subcontractors, and covered entities that are developing, undertaking, or performing work on a development project for which contractors are required to maintain and verify payroll records, as specified. The bill would subject a contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity, for failing to comply with the provisions of this act, to a penalty by the commissioner, as specified, and would deposit the penalties into a specified fund. This bill would require the Director of Industrial Relations to adopt rules to govern the release of those records, as specified.
Existing law requires that, except as specified, not less than the general prevailing rate of per diem wages be paid to workers employed on public works and imposes misdemeanor penalties for a willful violation of this requirement. Existing law defines public works, for the purposes of regulating public works contracts, as, among other things, construction, alteration, demolition, installation, or repair work done under contract and paid for, in whole or in part, out of public funds.
Existing law requires the Labor Commissioner to investigate allegations that a contractor or subcontractor violated the law regulating public works projects, including the payment of prevailing wages. Existing law requires each contractor and subcontractor on a public works project to keep accurate payroll records, showing the name, address, social security number, work classification, straight time and overtime hours worked each day and week, and the actual per diem wages paid to each journeyman, apprentice, worker, or other employee employed by the contractor or subcontractor in connection with the public work. Existing law requires any copy of records made available for inspection as copies and furnished upon request to the public or any public agency to be marked or obliterated to prevent disclosure of an individuals name, address, and social security number but specifies that any copy of records made available to a Taft-Hartley trust fund for the purposes of allocating contributions to participants be marked or obliterated only to prevent disclosure of an individuals full social security number, as specified.
This bill would require each contractor and subcontractor performing work on any public works project and any covered entity, as defined for these purposes as a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity, that develops or undertakes such project, to make specified records available upon request to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified. The bill would also apply this requirement to contractors, subcontractors, and covered entities that are developing, undertaking, or performing work on a development project for which contractors are required to maintain and verify payroll records, as specified. The bill would subject a contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity, for failing to comply with the provisions of this act, to a penalty by the commissioner, as specified, and would deposit the penalties into a specified fund. This bill would require the Director of Industrial Relations to adopt rules to govern the release of those records, as specified.
(a)Each contractor and subcontractor performing work on An owner or developer undertaking any public works project subject to the requirements of this chapter, and any covered entity that develops or undertakes any such project, chapter shall make the following records available upon request to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds (29 U.S.C. Sec. 186(c)), and to joint labor-management committees established pursuant to the federal Labor Management Cooperation Act of 1978 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 175a):
(1)Requests for bids and submitted bid documents.(2)(1)Final executed construction contracts.
(3)Records of work performed and workers employed on the project, including, but not limited to, a certified copy of payroll records described in Section 1776.(2)A certified copy of payroll records described in Section 1776 if the owner or developer has possession, custody, or control of these records.
(4)For any contractor or subcontractor(3)If the owner or developer were required to provide an enforceable commitment that a skilled and trained workforce will be used to complete a contract or project, the monthly reports required under Section 2602 of the Public Contract Code.
(b)The requirements of subdivision (a) shall apply to any covered entity that develops or undertakes, and each contractor and subcontractor performing work on, owner or developer that undertakes a development project for which contractors are required by other statutes governing the project to maintain and verify payroll records pursuant to Section 1776, that includes work subject to the requirements of this chapter, regardless of whether the project is in its entirety a public work, as defined in Article 1 (commencing with Section 1720).
(c)(1)Any records of work performed that are made available under this section shall be redacted only to prevent disclosure of any individuals social security number.
(2)The owner or developer may redact pricing information from contracts and subcontracts if that information has not been made public.
(d)Where the requesting department, trust fund, or joint labor-management committee has identified the documents or information sought with specificity, the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity owner or developer shall reasonably assist in identifying responsive records.
(e)(1)A contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity An owner or developer has 10 days in which to comply subsequent to receipt of a written notice requesting the records enumerated in subdivision (a).
(2)In the event that the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity owner or developer fails to comply with a request from a multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust fund or a joint labor-management committee, the fund or committee shall submit a complaint to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within 10 days after compliance was required. The Division of Labor Standards Enforcement shall promptly investigate any complaints.
(3)If the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement determines that the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity owner or developer has failed to provide any records subject to disclosure pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b), or failed to comply with subdivisions (c) to (e), inclusive, the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity owner or developer shall be subject to a penalty by the Labor Commissioner of until strict compliance is effectuated. The penalty shall be one hundred dollars ($100) for each calendar day, or portion thereof, for each worker, until strict compliance is effectuated. effectuated with respect to records described by paragraph (2) of subdivision (a). For records described by paragraphs (1) and (3) of subdivision (a), the penalty shall be five hundred dollars ($500) for each calendar day, or portion thereof, until strict compliance is effectuated. Penalties received pursuant to this paragraph shall be deposited in the State Public Works Enforcement Fund established by Section 1771.3 and shall be used only for the purposes specified in that section.
(4)A contractor is not subject to a penalty assessment pursuant to this section due to the failure of a subcontractor to comply with this section.(5)(4)The director shall adopt rules consistent with the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) and the Information Practices Act of 1977 (Title 1.8 (commencing with Section 1798) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code) governing the release of these records, including the establishment of reasonable fees to be charged for reproducing copies of records required by this section.
(f)For purposes of this section, covered entity means an owner or developer includes a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity. entity but does not include the state or a political subdivision.
(a)Each contractor and subcontractor performing work on any public works project subject to the requirements of this chapter, and any covered entity that develops or undertakes any such project, shall make the following records available upon request to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds (29 U.S.C. Sec. 186(c)), and to joint labor-management committees established pursuant to the federal Labor Management Cooperation Act of 1978 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 175a):
(1)Bid documents.(2)Signed contracts and subcontracts.(1)Requests for bids and submitted bid documents.
(2)Final executed construction contracts.
(3)Records of work performed and workers employed on the project, including, but not limited to, a certified copy of payroll records described in Section 1776.
(4)For any contractor or subcontractor required to provide an enforceable commitment that a skilled and trained workforce will be used to complete a contract or project, the monthly reports required under Section 2602 of the Public Contract Code.
(b)The requirements of subdivision (a) shall apply to any covered entity that develops or undertakes, and each contractor and subcontractor performing work on, a development project for which contractors are required by other statutes governing the project to maintain and verify payroll records pursuant to Section 1776, regardless of whether the project is in its entirety a public work, as defined in Article 1 (commencing with Section 1720).
(c)Any records made available under this section shall be redacted only to prevent disclosure of any individuals social security number.
(d)Where the requesting department, trust fund, or joint labor-management committee has identified the documents or information sought with specificity, the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity shall reasonably assist in identifying responsive records.
(e)(1)A contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity has 10 days in which to comply subsequent to receipt of a written notice requesting the records enumerated in subdivision (a).
(2)In the event that the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity fails to comply with a request from a multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust fund or a joint labor-management committee, the fund or committee shall submit a complaint to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within 10 days after compliance was required. The Division of Labor Standards Enforcement shall promptly investigate any complaints.
(3)If the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement determines that the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity has failed to provide any records subject to disclosure pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b), or failed to comply with subdivisions (c) to (e), inclusive, the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity shall be subject to a penalty by the Labor Commissioner of one hundred dollars ($100) for each calendar day, or portion thereof, for each worker, until strict compliance is effectuated. Penalties received pursuant to this paragraph shall be deposited in the State Public Works Enforcement Fund established by Section 1771.3 and shall be used only for the purposes specified in that section.
(4)A contractor is not subject to a penalty assessment pursuant to this section due to the failure of a subcontractor to comply with this section.
(5)The director shall adopt rules consistent with the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) and the Information Practices Act of 1977 (Title 1.8 (commencing with Section 1798) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code) governing the release of these records, including the establishment of reasonable fees to be charged for reproducing copies of records required by this section.
(f)For purposes of this section, covered entity means a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity.
(a)Each contractor and subcontractor performing work on any public works project subject to the requirements of this chapter, and any covered entity that develops or undertakes any such project, shall make the following records available upon request to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds (29 U.S.C. Sec. 186(c)), and to joint labor-management committees established pursuant to the federal Labor Management Cooperation Act of 1978 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 175a):
(1)Bid documents.
(2)Signed contracts and subcontracts.
(3)Records of work performed and workers employed on the project, including, but not limited to, a certified copy of payroll records described in Section 1776.
(4)For any contractor or subcontractor required to provide an enforceable commitment that a skilled and trained workforce will be used to complete a contract or project, the monthly reports required under Section 2602 of the Public Contract Code.
(b)The requirements of subdivision (a) shall apply to any covered entity that develops or undertakes, and each contractor and subcontractor performing work on, a development project for which contractors are required by other statutes governing the project to maintain and verify payroll records pursuant to Section 1776, regardless of whether the project is in its entirety a public work, as defined in Article 1 (commencing with Section 1720).
(c)Any records made available under this section shall be redacted only to prevent disclosure of any individuals social security number.
(d)Where the requesting department, trust fund, or joint labor-management committee has identified the documents or information sought with specificity, the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity shall reasonably assist in identifying responsive records.
(e)(1)A contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity has 10 days in which to comply subsequent to receipt of a written notice requesting the records enumerated in subdivision (a).
(2)In the event that the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity fails to comply with a request from a multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust fund or a joint labor-management committee, the fund or committee shall submit a complaint to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within 10 days after compliance was required. The Division of Labor Standards Enforcement shall promptly investigate any complaints.
(3)If the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement determines that the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity has failed to provide any records subject to disclosure pursuant to subdivision (a) or (b), or failed to comply with subdivisions (c) to (e), inclusive, the contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity shall be subject to a penalty by the Labor Commissioner of one hundred dollars ($100) for each calendar day, or portion thereof, for each worker, until strict compliance is effectuated. Penalties received pursuant to this paragraph shall be deposited in the State Public Works Enforcement Fund established by Section 1771.3 and shall be used only for the purposes specified in that section.
(4)A contractor is not subject to a penalty assessment pursuant to this section due to the failure of a subcontractor to comply with this section.
(5)The director shall adopt rules consistent with the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code) and the Information Practices Act of 1977 (Title 1.8 (commencing with Section 1798) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code) governing the release of these records, including the establishment of reasonable fees to be charged for reproducing copies of records required by this section.
(f)For purposes of this section, covered entity means a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 61. Noes 0. Page 5549.) |
| May 21, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 20, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 8, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Apr 8, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 11, 2024 | Referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Feb 17, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 22, 2024 | AB 3186 Petrie-Norris Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Associated General Contractors Of California | ** Against | |
| Associated General Contractors-San Diego Chapter | ** Against | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Coalition For Rural Housing | ** Against | |
| California Housing Consortium | ** Against | |
| California Housing Partnership Corporation | ** Against | |
| California Teamsters Public Affairs Council | ** Support | |
| District Council 16 International Union Of Painters And Allied Trades | ** Support | |
| Finishing Contractors Association Of Southern California | ** Support | |
| Housing California | ** Against | |
| Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California | ** Against | |
| Northern California Allied Trades | ** Support | |
| San Diego Housing Federation | ** Against | |
| Southern California Association of Nonprofit Housing | ** Against | |
| Southern California Glass Management Association | ** Support | |
| State Building and Construction Trades Council | ** Support | |
| Western Painting and Coating Contractors Association | ** Support |
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3186
Author:(Petrie-Norris)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires owners and developers undertaking any public works project to make specified records available to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), multi-employer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Requires an owner or developer undertaking any public works project to make the following records available upon request to the DLSE, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified:
- Final executed construction contracts;
- A certified copy of payroll records, as specified, if the owner or developer has possession, custody, or control of these records.
- If the owner or developer were required to provide an enforceable commitment that a skilled and trained workforce will be used to complete a contract or project, the monthly reports required, as specified.
- Applies the requirements of 1), above, to an owner or developer that undertakes a development project that includes work subject to public works law, regardless of whether the project is in its entirety a public work.
- Provides that any records of work performed that are made available under the requirements of 1), above, be redacted only to prevent disclosure of social security numbers, but allows the owner or developer to redact pricing information from contracts and subcontracts if that information has not been made public.
- Requires an owner or developer to reasonably assist in identifying responsive records when the requesting department, trust fund, or joint labor-management committee has identified the documents or information sought with specificity.
- Provides that an owner or developer has 10 days in which to comply with a written request for records enumerated in 1), above, and, in the event that the owner or developer fails to comply with a request from a multi-employer Taft-Hartley trust fund or joint labor-management committee, requires the fund or committee to submit a complaint to DLSE within 10 days after compliance was required, and requires DLSE to promptly investigate any complaints.
- Subjects an owner or developer, for failing to comply with the provisions of this bill, to penalties by the Labor Commissioner (LC), as specified, and would deposit the penalties into a specified fund.
- Requires the Director of Industrial Relations (DIR) to adopt rules to govern the release of those records, as specified.
- Provides that "owner or developer" includes a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity but does not include the state or a political subdivision.
COMMENTS
Public works laws require that, among other things, prevailing wage is paid to workers on publicly-funded projects, as specified. In California, the prevailing wage rate is an hourly rate paid on public works projects that is often set in the terms of a collective bargaining agreement. According to the Department of Industrial Relations, the wage rate relies upon such factors as "the particular craft, classification or type of work within the locality and in the nearest labor market area (if majorities of such workers are paid at a single rate). If there is no single rate paid to a majority, then the single or modal rate being paid to the greater number of workers is prevailing."
Prevailing wage laws are intended to ensure that contractors are not awarded public works contracts by paying low wages and undercutting competitors who provide higher compensation. In this way, these laws create a level playing field by requiring an across-the-board rate for all bidders on publicly-subsidized projects.
To ensure compliance with various pay requirements under public works laws, contractors and subcontractors are required to submit their payroll records to the LC. In addition to the LC's oversight, joint-labor management committees and multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds play a critical role in verifying the accuracy and thoroughness of payroll records, and filing complaints with the LC for suspected violations pertaining to the payment of prevailing wages on public works projects. These payroll records are also available to the public, but must be requested through DLSE or the entity awarding the contract.
Under existing law, certain projects overseen by private entities are subject to public works law if they meet specific criteria. However, private entities are not subject to the California Public Records Act. Because of this, joint labor-management committees and multiemployer Taft-Hartley Trust Funds have had record requests denied on public works projects administered by private entities.
The author provided the following examples to the Committee:
"In San Jose County, the private entity building the PATH Villas on 4th Street, funded in part by the County's Office of Supportive Housing Measure A dollars, failed to respond to requests for project documents, stating that they are not currently required to under the law (because they are not a public entity). This is a $33 million project.
Another privately developed but publicly-funded project that failed to respond to multiple requests for project documents is the Light Tree New Construction Project – a $61.5 million project. Ultimately, the JLMC resorted to seeking state assistance to receive certified payroll records."
This bill would require owners and developers undertaking any public works project, regardless of whether the project is in its entirety a public work, to comply with specific record requests related to the project from joint labor-management committees, multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and the DLSE.
According to the Author
"The California Public Records Act (CPRA) is a fundamental transparency pillar of state and local government, granting the public access to information that enables it to monitor the functioning of its government, including the appropriate and honest use of taxpayer dollars. While exhaustive in nature, the CPRA does not cover private entities that own, undertake, or develop a project funded in whole or in part by public financing. To ensure that workers on these projects are being paid their due wages, are being classified accurately, and are being treated fairly, this measure will extend to private entities a very limited set of accountability measures to ensure compliance with existing state laws."
Arguments in Support
The District Council 16, International Union of Painters and Allied Trades are in support and state, "Often, on construction projects, workers are underpaid and or misclassified and, without oversight, this growing problem will only continue to get bigger. Existing law provides the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and joint labor-management committees with the ability to request documents from contractors when they are using public funds to develop public works projects. It is imperative that the Public Contract Code, the California Labor Code, and prevailing wage requirements are met on every public works project.
It is understood that private entities are just that, private. However, private entities using public funds should also be held to the same standard and accountability as governmental bodies when it comes to producing project documents and information. Private entities currently have no oversight through the California Public Records Act."
Arguments in Opposition
The California Housing Consortium, Housing California, and the California Housing
Partnership are in opposition and state, "We share the author's interest in ensuring compliance with prevailing wage laws. When a private development is subject to prevailing wage requirements, the general contractor has a duty to ensure that both itself and all of the subcontractors comply with the applicable laws. These companies are responsible for submitting prevailing wage reports to the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to demonstrate compliance. The system is on-line, so no paper is produced, and these records can be requested by anyone. If there are problems with submittal of these records, we recommend that public entities retain some percentage of the contract amount until compliance is demonstrated. If there are problems with the public obtaining the records from DIR, we recommend focusing on improving DIR's response capacity.
Since the records already submitted establish whether prevailing wages were paid or not, it is not clear that the additional documentation referenced in the bill is actually necessary to enforce compliance. According to our members and partners, the proposed list of documents in the bill is overly broad and the third-party compliance firms often employed rarely if ever have the breadth and scope of documents that are specified. As a result, the production of records becomes a burdensome and costly task that provides little to no benefit."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs of an unknown amount to DLSE to investigate complaints for non-compliance with records requirements, partially offset by specified penalty revenue (special fund).
Additionally, costs of an unknown amount to DIR to adopt rules for records release consistent with the CPRA, a complex statute with specific exemptions, processes, timelines, and remedies. For example, under the CPRA, a requester whose public records request is denied may file a lawsuit in superior court to compel disclosure of records. Although existing law already requires DIR to adopt such rules governing the release of CPRs by specified entities, it is unclear whether the same rules would apply to the release of records pursuant to this bill.
VOTES
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-0-2
YES: Ortega, Wendy Carrillo, Lee, Ward, Zbur
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, Alanis
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-2-2
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Jim Patterson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: May 16, 2024
CONSULTANT: Erin Hickey / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0003290
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3186
Author:(Petrie-Norris) – As Amended Ver:April 8, 2024
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires a contractor and a covered entity to make specific records regarding a public works project available upon request.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a contractor (and subcontractor) performing work on a public works project, as well as a covered entity developing a public works project, to make specified records available, within 10 days, upon request by the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), multi-employer Taft-Hartley trust funds (THTFs), and joint labor-management committees (JLMCs). Records subject to release include: (a) requests for bids and submitted bid documents, (b) final executed construction contracts, (c) records of work performed and workers employed on the project, including a certified copy of payroll records (CPRs), and (d) if applicable, monthly reports regarding skilled and trained workforce. The only redaction permitted is the worker’s social security number, and these requirements also apply to a project that is not a public work in its entirety, but for which CPRs are required.
- Requires DLSE to promptly investigate a complaint by a THTF or JLMC against a contractor or covered entity for non-compliance with records requirements and imposes a penalty of $100 per day of non-compliance, to be deposited in the State Public Works Enforcement Fund.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) director to adopt rules consistent with the California Public Records Act (CPRA) to govern the release of records, including the establishment of reasonable fees for reproducing records.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs of an unknown, but potentially significant amount, in excess of $150,000, to DLSE to investigate complaints for non-compliance with records requirements, partially offset by specified penalty revenue (special fund).
Additionally, costs of an unknown, but potentially significant, amount to DIR to adopt rules for records release consistent with the CPRA, a complex statute with specific exemptions, processes, timelines, and remedies. For example, under the CPRA, a requester whose public records request is denied may file a lawsuit in superior court to compel disclosure of records. It is unclear whether DIR’s investigation of complaints must meet a similar adjudication threshold.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
While exhaustive in nature, the CPRA does not cover private entities that own, undertake, or develop a project funded in whole or in part by public financing. To ensure that workers on these projects are being paid their due wages, are being classified accurately, and are being treated fairly, this measure will extend to private entities a very limited set of accountability measures to ensure compliance with existing state laws.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is supported by labor organizations, including the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, which argues, “private entities using public funds also should be held to the same standards and accountability as governmental bodies when it comes to producing project documents and information.”
This bill is opposed by contractor associations, as well as a coalition of affordable housing developers led by the California Housing Partnership, which argues, “Since the records already submitted establish whether prevailing wages were paid or not, it is not clear that the additional documentation referenced in the bill is actually necessary to enforce compliance” and, “As a result, the production of records becomes a burdensome and costly task that provides little to no benefit.”
- Background.
CPRA. The CPRA requires documents and records of state and local agencies be open and available for public inspection unless they are exempt from disclosure. Exemptions generally include personnel records, investigative records, drafts, and material made confidential by other state or federal statutes. In addition, CPRA authorizes a record be withheld whenever the public interest in nondisclosure clearly outweighs the public interest in disclosure. Under CPRA, when a state or local agency withholds a record because it is exempt from disclosure, the agency must notify the requester of the reasons for withholding the record. The only remedy available to a requester whose public records request has been denied is to file a lawsuit in superior court to compel disclosure of the records.
Inspection of CPRs. CPRs reflect a company’s accounting of funds paid out on a contract performed for a public works project, detailing the hours worked, wages paid to each employee, and the jobs performed. The primary purpose of a CPR is to provide the contracting agency with a method of oversight to guarantee contractors compensate employees with prevailing wages.
Existing law requires a public works contractor to keep accurate CPRs and make a copy of any CPR available for inspection at the contractor’s principal office by an employee or the employee’s authorized representative. A THTF or JLMC may request, through the body awarding the contract or DLSE, a copy of a CPR with the individual’s social security number redacted. Existing law also requires a public works contractor to furnish CPRs to the Labor Commissioner (also known as DLSE), at least monthly, via DIR’s eCPR system. Accordingly, payroll records with an individual’s name, address and social security number redacted are currently accessible to the public on DIR’s website using its Payroll Search tool.
SB 954 (Archuleta), Chapter 824, Statutes of 2022, required DIR to establish an eCPR database specifically for THTFs and JLMCs, through which these entities can gain easier access to more detailed CPRs than records published on DIR’s website, without having to rely on the awarding body or DLSE to facilitate inspection of a paper copy. The database must be operational by July 1, 2024. AB 587 (R. Rivas), Chapter 806, Statutes of 2023, preserved the right of a THTF or JLMC to inspect a paper CPR copy, despite having access to the eCPR.
This bill allows a THTF or JLMC to directly request CPRs from a contractor, without having to make the request through the awarding entity or DLSE. Additionally, this bill allows a THTF or JLMC to request additional types of records, such as requests for bids and submitted bid documents, from the contractor, as well as from the covered entity developing the public works project. Thus, this bill provides a way for a THTF or JLMC to gain access to additional records from a private entity not subject to disclosure under the CPRA.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Liz Ortega, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3186 (
Author:Petrie-Norris) – As Amended Ver:April 8, 2024
SUBJECT: Public works: prevailing wages: access to records
SUMMARY: Requires contractors and subcontractors on public works projects, as well as covered entities as specified, to make specified records available to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), multi-employer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires each contractor and subcontractor performing work on any public works project and any covered entity, as defined, that develops or undertakes such project, to make the following records available upon request to the DLSE, to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and to joint labor-management committees, as specified:
- Requests for bids and submitted bid documents;
- Final executed construction contracts;
- Records of work performed and workers employed on the project, including a certified copy of payroll records.
- For any contractor or subcontractor required to provide an enforceable commitment that a skilled and trained workforce will be used to complete a contract or project, the monthly reports required, as specified.
- Defines “covered entity” to mean a corporation, limited liability company, partnership, joint venture, or other legal entity.
- Applies the requirements of 1) above to contractors, subcontractors, and covered entities that are developing, undertaking, or performing work on a development project for which contractors are required to maintain and verify payroll records, as specified.
- Provides that any records made available under this requirement be redacted only to prevent disclosure of social security numbers.
- Requires a contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity to reasonably assist in identifying responsive records when the requesting department, trust fund, or joint labor-management committee has identified the documents or information sought with specificity.
- Provides that a contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity has 10 days in which to comply with a written request for records enumerated in 1) above and, in the event that the contractor, subcontractor or covered entity fails to comply with a request from a multi-employer Taft-Hartley trust fund or joint labor-management committee, requires the fund or committee to submit a complaint to DLSE within 10 days after compliance was required, and requires DLSE to promptly investigate any complaints.
- Subjects a contractor, subcontractor, or covered entity, for failing to comply with the provisions of this bill, to a penalty by the Labor Commissioner (LC), as specified, and would deposit the penalties into a specified fund.
- Provides that a contractor is not responsible for a subcontractor’s failure to comply with this bill.
- Requires the Director of Industrial Relations (DIR) to adopt rules to govern the release of those records, as specified.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Defines “public works,” for the purposes of regulating public works contracts, as, among other things, construction, alteration, demolition, installation, or repair work done under contract and paid for, in whole or in part, out of public funds. Labor Code § 1720(a).
- Specifies that, if the state or a political subdivision reimburses a private developer for costs that would normally be borne by the public, or provides directly or indirectly a public subsidy to a private development project that is de minimis in the context of the project, then the project is not subject to existing public works law. Labor Code § 1720(c)(3)(A).
- Defines “de minimis” for purposes of 2) above to mean both less than $600,000 and less than 2 percent of the total project cost. Labor Code § 1720(c)(3)(B)(i).
- Requires that not less than the general prevailing rate of per diem wages be paid to all workers employed on a "public works" project costing over $1,000 dollars and imposes misdemeanor penalties for violation of this requirement. Labor Code §1771.
- Requires contractors and subcontractors, while performing public works, to furnish specified payroll records at least once a month directly to the LC, in an electronic format, in the manner prescribed by the LC, on the department’s internet website. Labor Code, § 1771.4 (a)(3).
- Requires the DIR, by July 1, 2024, to develop and implement an online database, accessible only to multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds and joint-labor management committees, of electronic certified payroll records submitted in compliance with public works requirements. Labor Code, §1771.4 (e).
- Requires each contractor and subcontractor on a public works project to keep accurate payroll records, showing the name, address, social security number, work classification, straight time and overtime hours worked each day and week, and the actual per diem wages paid to each journeyman, apprentice, worker, or other employee employed by the contractor or subcontractor in connection with the public work. Labor Code § 1776(a).
- Requires a certified copy of all payroll records enumerated in 7) above to be made available upon request by the public for inspection or for copies thereof, but requires that such a request be made through either the body awarding the contract or the DLSE. Labor Code § 1776(b)(3).
- Requires any copy of records made available for inspection as copies and furnished upon request to the public or any public agency to be marked or obliterated to prevent disclosure of an individual’s name, address, and social security number but specifies that any copy of records made available to a Taft-Hartley trust fund for the purposes of allocating contributions to participants be marked or obliterated only to prevent disclosure of an individual’s full social security number, as specified. Labor Code § 1776(e).
- EXISTING FEDERAL LAW
Establishes Taft-Hartley trust funds, which are employee pension or welfare benefit trusts jointly administered by equal numbers of representatives of employees and employers, as specified. 29 U.S.C. § 186(c)(5) - (c)(8).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Public works laws require that, among other things, prevailing wage is paid to workers on publicly-funded projects, as specified. In California, the prevailing wage rate is an hourly rate paid on public works projects that is often set in the terms of a collective bargaining agreement. According to the Department of Industrial Relations, the wage rate relies upon such factors as "the particular craft, classification or type of work within the locality and in the nearest labor market area (if majorities of such workers are paid at a single rate). If there is no single rate paid to a majority, then the single or modal rate being paid to the greater number of workers is prevailing."
Prevailing wage laws are intended to ensure that contractors are not awarded public works contracts by paying low wages and undercutting competitors who provide higher compensation. In this way, these laws create a level playing field by requiring an across-the-board rate for all bidders on publicly-subsidized projects.
To ensure compliance with various pay requirements under public works laws, contractors and subcontractors are required to submit their payroll records to the LC. In addition to the LC’s oversight, joint-labor management committees and multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds play a critical role in verifying the accuracy and thoroughness of payroll records, and filing complaints with the LC for suspected violations pertaining to the payment of prevailing wages on public works projects. These payroll records are also available to the public, but must be requested through DLSE or the entity awarding the contract.
Under existing law, certain projects overseen by private entities are subject to public works law if they meet specific criteria. However, private entities are not subject to the California Public Records Act. Because of this, joint labor-management committees and multiemployer Taft-Hartley Trust Funds have had record requests denied on public works projects administered by private entities.
The author provided the following examples to the Committee:
“In San Jose County, the private entity building the PATH Villas on 4th Street, funded in part by the County’s Office of Supportive Housing Measure A dollars, failed to respond to requests for project documents, stating that they are not currently required to under the law (because they are not a public entity). This is a $33 million project.
Another privately developed but publicly-funded project that failed to respond to multiple requests for project documents is the Light Tree New Construction Project – a $61.5 million project. Ultimately, the JLMC resorted to seeking state assistance to receive certified payroll records.”
This bill would require contractors, subcontractors and covered entities, as defined, that have received public funding to complete a public works project, as specified, to comply with specific record requests related to the project from joint labor-management committees, multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and the DLSE.
According to the author, “The California Public Records Act (CPRA) is a fundamental transparency pillar of state and local government, granting the public access to information that enables it to monitor the functioning of its government, including the appropriate and honest use of taxpayer dollars. While exhaustive in nature, the CPRA does not cover private entities that own, undertake, or develop a project funded in whole or in part by public financing. To ensure that workers on these projects are being paid their due wages, are being classified accurately, and are being treated fairly, this measure will extend to private entities a very limited set of accountability measures to ensure compliance with existing state laws.”
Committee Comments
This bill is substantially similar to AB 2439 (Quirk-Silva) of 2024. Committee staff would encourage the two authors to work together to determine a path forward.
Arguments in Support
The District Council 16, International Union of Painters and Allied Trades are in support and state, “Often, on construction projects, workers are underpaid and or misclassified and, without oversight, this growing problem will only continue to get bigger. Existing law provides the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and joint labor-management committees with the ability to request documents from contractors when they are using public funds to develop public works projects. It is imperative that the Public Contract Code, the California Labor Code, and prevailing wage requirements are met on every public works project.
It is understood that private entities are just that, private. However, private entities using public funds should also be held to the same standard and accountability as governmental bodies when it comes to producing project documents and information. Private entities currently have no oversight through the California Public Records Act.”
Arguments in Opposition
The California Housing Consortium, Housing California, and the California Housing
Partnership are in opposition and state, “We share the author’s interest in ensuring compliance with prevailing wage laws. When a private development is subject to prevailing wage requirements, the general contractor has a duty to ensure that both itself and all of the subcontractors comply with the applicable laws. These companies are responsible for submitting prevailing wage reports to the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to demonstrate compliance. The system is on-line, so no paper is produced, and these records can be requested by anyone. If there are problems with submittal of these records, we recommend that public entities retain some percentage of the contract amount until compliance is demonstrated. If there are problems with the public obtaining the records from DIR, we recommend focusing on improving DIR’s response capacity.
Since the records already submitted establish whether prevailing wages were paid or not, it is not clear that the additional documentation referenced in the bill is actually necessary to enforce compliance. According to our members and partners, the proposed list of documents in the bill is overly broad and the third-party compliance firms often employed rarely if ever have the breadth and scope of documents that are specified. As a result, the production of records becomes a burdensome and costly task that provides little to no benefit.”
Prior and Related Legislation
AB 2439 (Quirk-Silva) of 2024 is substantially similar to this bill and would require an owner, a developer, or the agent of an owner or developer, that, among other things, receives public funds from a public agency to perform specified public works projects, to make available specified records to joint labor-management committees, multiemployer Taft-Hartley trust funds, and nonprofits established to ensure compliance within the building and construction trades industry. This bill is set for hearing in this Committee.
AB 587 (Robert Rivas), Chapter 806, Statutes of 2023 required any copy of records requested by, and made available for inspection by or furnished to, a Taft-Hartley trust fund or joint labor-management committee to be on forms provided by the DLSE or contain the same information as the forms provided by DLSE. Additionally, AB 587 clarified that copies of electronic certified payroll records do not satisfy payroll records requests made by Taft-Hartley trust funds and joint labor-management committees.
SB 954 (Archuleta), Chapter 824, Statutes of 2022 required the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to develop and implement an online database of certified payroll records submitted to comply with Public Works requirements.
AB 1023 (Flora), Chapter 326, Statutes of 2021 allowed the Labor Commissioner to impose a penalty on a contractor or subcontractor on a public works project if they fail to furnish payroll records to the Labor Commissioner as required by public works standards.
AB 2744 (Committee on Labor and Employment), Chapter 297, Statutes of 2014 made conforming changes to reflect a merger of duties within the DLSE and more fully integrate enforcement of apprenticeship standards within the enforcement mechanisms already available to address other violations of the requirements for contractors and subcontractors on public works projects under existing law.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
District Council 16, International Union of Painters and Allied Trades
Finishing Contractors Association of Southern California
Northern California Allied Trades
Southern California Glass Management Association
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Western Painting and Coating Contractors Association
Opposition
Associated General Contractors of California
Associated General Contractors-san Diego Chapter
California Coalition for Rural Housing
California Housing Consortium
California Housing Partnership Corporation
Housing California
Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California
San Diego Housing Federation
Southern California Association of Nonprofit Housing
Oppose Unless Amended
California Building Industry Association
Analysis Prepared by: Erin Hickey / L. & E. /
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):