AB 459: Peace officers: Attorney General: reports.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires each state and local agency that employs peace officers to annually report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by the agencys peace officers, and requires that data to include specified information, including the time, date, and location of the stop, and the reason given to the person stopped at the time of the stop. Existing law also makes all stop data and reports public records.
This bill would revise these provisions to require each state and local agency that employs peace officers to report stop data to the Attorney General, as described above, by March 1, as specified. The bill would require those agencies to report semiannually reporting if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in their submissions, as specified. By imposing new duties on local agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would specify that any stop data reported by a state or local agency in an open text or narrative field only be made available from the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. The bill would also require the Attorney General to provide all state and local agency stop data to public or private entities, as specified, for the study of racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. The bill would make related findings and declarations.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law requires each state and local agency that employs peace officers to annually report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by the agencys peace officers, and requires that data to include specified information, including the time, date, and location of the stop, and the reason given to the person stopped at the time of the stop. Existing law also makes all stop data and reports public records.
This bill would revise these provisions to require each state and local agency that employs peace officers to report stop data to the Attorney General, as described above, by March 1, as specified. The bill would require those agencies to report semiannually reporting if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in their submissions, as specified. By imposing new duties on local agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would specify that any stop data reported by a state or local agency in an open text or narrative field only be made available from the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. The bill would also require the Attorney General to provide all state and local agency stop data to public or private entities, as specified, for the study of racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. The bill would make related findings and declarations.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee or applicant for employment to agree, in writing, to any term or condition that is known by the employer to be illegal. Existing law provides that certain contractual agreements between an employer and employee are against public policy, including specified provisions affecting an employees membership in a labor organization and the protection of state law in employment. Under existing law, enforcement of state labor laws is generally committed to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within the Department of Industrial Relations, under the direction of the Labor Commissioner.This bill would provide that a provision in an agreement between an individual and any other person for the performance of personal or professional services is contrary to public policy and deemed unconscionable if the provision meets specified conditions relating to the use of a digital replica of the voice or likeness of an individual in lieu of the work of the individual or to train a generative artificial intelligence system. The bill would provide that it shall apply retroactively. The bill would require any person who is currently under, or has entered into, an agreement with an individual performing personal or professional services containing such a provision, by February 1, 2024, to notify that individual in writing that the provision is unenforceable.Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee or applicant for employment to agree, in writing, to any term or condition that is known by the employer to be illegal. Existing law provides that certain contractual agreements between an employer and employee are against public policy, including specified provisions affecting an employees membership in a labor organization and the protection of state law in employment. Under existing law, enforcement of state labor laws is generally committed to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within the Department of Industrial Relations, under the direction of the Labor Commissioner.
This bill would provide that a provision in an agreement between an individual and any other person for the performance of personal or professional services is contrary to public policy and deemed unconscionable if the provision meets specified conditions relating to the use of a digital replica of the voice or likeness of an individual in lieu of the work of the individual or to train a generative artificial intelligence system. The bill would provide that it shall apply retroactively. The bill would require any person who is currently under, or has entered into, an agreement with an individual performing personal or professional services containing such a provision, by February 1, 2024, to notify that individual in writing that the provision is unenforceable.
Existing law, the Bronzan-McCorquodale Act, contains provisions governing the operation and financing of community mental health services for persons with mental disorders in every county through locally administered and locally controlled community mental health programs.Existing law, the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA), an initiative measure enacted by the voters as Proposition 63 in the November 2, 2004, statewide general election, establishes the continuously appropriated Mental Health Services Fund to fund various county mental health programs, including prevention and early intervention programs.This bill would require the California Health and Human Services Agency, by July 1, 2026, to establish the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR), consisting of performance indicators, county self-assessments, and county and health plan improvement plans, to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by the agency. The bill would require the agency to convene a workgroup, as specified, to establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted. The bill would require the agency to establish specific process measures and uniform elements for the county and health plan improvement plan updates. The bill would require the agency to report to the Legislature, as specified. By imposing new requirements on counties, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.This bill would require the agency to request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide specific services, including preparing an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes. The bill would require the analysis to be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup on or before July 1, 2026.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.Existing law, the Bronzan-McCorquodale Act, contains provisions governing the operation and financing of community mental health services for persons with mental disorders in every county through locally administered and locally controlled community mental health programs.
Existing law, the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA), an initiative measure enacted by the voters as Proposition 63 in the November 2, 2004, statewide general election, establishes the continuously appropriated Mental Health Services Fund to fund various county mental health programs, including prevention and early intervention programs.
This bill would require the California Health and Human Services Agency, by July 1, 2026, to establish the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR), consisting of performance indicators, county self-assessments, and county and health plan improvement plans, to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by the agency. The bill would require the agency to convene a workgroup, as specified, to establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted. The bill would require the agency to establish specific process measures and uniform elements for the county and health plan improvement plan updates. The bill would require the agency to report to the Legislature, as specified. By imposing new requirements on counties, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the agency to request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide specific services, including preparing an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes. The bill would require the analysis to be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup on or before July 1, 2026.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the Bronzan-McCorquodale Act, contains provisions governing the operation and financing of community mental health services for persons with mental disorders in every county through locally administered and locally controlled community mental health programs. Existing law further provides that, to the extent resources are available, community mental health services should be organized to provide an array of treatment options in specified areas, including, among others, precrisis and crisis services and case management.
This bill, the Behavioral Health Rights Act, would enumerate rights for people seeking or receiving behavioral health care in California, including a persons right to receive recovery-oriented and culturally appropriate care from a licensed, certified, or qualified mental health or substance use professional of their choosing, the right to appropriate housing, and a persons right to be guaranteed the protection of the confidentiality of their relationship with their mental health and substance abuse professional, as specified. The bill would guarantee behavioral health services for Californians, including intensive case management, peer support services, and supportive housing services, provided by their county behavioral health department or public or private health plan, based on specific standards of care.Existing law, the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA), an initiative measure enacted by the voters as Proposition 63 in the November 2, 2004, statewide general election, establishes the continuously appropriated Mental Health Services Fund to fund various county mental health programs, including prevention and early intervention programs.
This bill would require the California Health and Human Services Agency, by July 1, 2026, to establish the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR), consisting of performance indicators, county self-assessments, and county and health plan improvement plans, to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by the agency. The bill would require the agency to convene a workgroup, as specified, to establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted. The bill would require the agency to establish specific process measures and uniform elements for the county and health plan improvement plan updates. The bill would require the agency to report to the Legislature, as specified. By imposing new requirements on counties, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the agency to request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide specific services, including preparing an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes. The bill would require the analysis to be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup on or before July 1, 2026.
The bill would require the agency to establish a risk corridor structure, as specified, that applies to all health payers who provide behavioral health services in California. The bill would require those health payers to spend at least 20% of their provider health payments, to be adjusted annually, on behavioral health services.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
This bill, the Behavioral Health Rights Act, would enumerate rights for people seeking or receiving behavioral health care in California, including a persons right to receive recovery-oriented and culturally appropriate care from a licensed, certified, or qualified mental health or substance use professional of their choosing, the right to appropriate housing, and a persons right to be guaranteed the protection of the confidentiality of their relationship with their mental health and substance abuse professional, as specified. The bill would guarantee behavioral health services for Californians, including intensive case management, peer support services, and supportive housing services, provided by their county behavioral health department or public or private health plan, based on specific standards of care.
Existing law, the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA), an initiative measure enacted by the voters as Proposition 63 in the November 2, 2004, statewide general election, establishes the continuously appropriated Mental Health Services Fund to fund various county mental health programs, including prevention and early intervention programs.
This bill would require the California Health and Human Services Agency, by July 1, 2026, to establish the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR), consisting of performance indicators, county self-assessments, and county and health plan improvement plans, to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by the agency. The bill would require the agency to convene a workgroup, as specified, to establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted. The bill would require the agency to establish specific process measures and uniform elements for the county and health plan improvement plan updates. The bill would require the agency to report to the Legislature, as specified. By imposing new requirements on counties, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the agency to request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide specific services, including preparing an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes. The bill would require the analysis to be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup on or before July 1, 2026.
The bill would require the agency to establish a risk corridor structure, as specified, that applies to all health payers who provide behavioral health services in California. The bill would require those health payers to spend at least 20% of their provider health payments, to be adjusted annually, on behavioral health services.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
This bill would make a technical, nonsubstantive change to those provisions.Existing law, the Bronzan-McCorquodale Act, contains provisions governing the operation and financing of community mental health services for persons with mental disorders in every county through locally administered and locally controlled community mental health programs. Existing law further provides that, to the extent resources are available, community mental health services should be organized to provide an array of treatment options in specified areas, including, among others, precrisis and crisis services and case management.
This bill would make a technical, nonsubstantive change to those provisions.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The data reported under the Racial and Identity Profiling Act of 2015 (Chapter 466 of the Statutes of 2015) provides important information about the state of policing in California.
(b)Despite existing prohibitions that law enforcement agencies shall not include personally identifiable information of individuals stopped or unique identifying information of the officers in their reports, this information continues to be included in open text and narrative fields.
(c)Over 4,500,000 reports were submitted to the Department of Justice in 2022. Unlike the local law enforcement agencies, the Department of Justice is uniquely situated in that it is the repository of all reports statewide, resulting in it maintaining millions of reports. Over the next decade, the Department of Justice is anticipated to receive tens of millions of reports.
(d)The Department of Justice lacks resources to review and redact the millions of reports in its possession to ensure that stopped individuals personally identifiable information or officers unique identifying information is not released to the public.
(e)For similar types of sensitive information, the Legislature has balanced the publics right to know with the risk of disclosure of personally identifiable information by limiting the disclosure of such information from the Department of Justice to the public, while authorizing research, educational, and similar institutions to receive sensitive information to conduct research in support of public policy.
(f)It is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that the full reports, including open text and narrative fields, remain publicly available from the reporting agencies, which are already responsible for reviewing and redacting any personally identifiable information or unique identifying information hat that may have been included in open text and narrative fields before the reports are transmitted to the Department of Justice and released to the public.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature that portions of the reports, specifically, open text and narrative fields that potentially contain personally identifiable information, be available to the public solely from the reporting agencies and not from the Department of Justice.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature that portions of reports, specifically, open text and narrative fields that potentially contain personally identifiable information, be treated like criminal history and similarly sensitive information. It is the intent of the Legislature that such portions maintained by the Department of Justice be made available to stakeholders and researchers, in order for stakeholders and researchers to make recommendations and develop best practices for discussion and implementation of reforms that will improve public safety in California.
SEC. 2.Section 12525.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:12525.5.(a)(1)Each state and local agency that employs peace officers shall preserve and report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by that agencys peace officers. Each agencys final stop reports shall be submitted by March 1 for the preceding calendar year.
(2)If reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agencys submission to the Attorney General, the agency shall submit semiannually for the following calendar year. The Attorney General shall provide notice to the agency by October 1, with the semiannual requirement taking effect as of January 1.
(3)Semiannual agency reports required pursuant to paragraph (2) shall be submitted by September 1 and March 1 of each year. The final reports on all stops conducted from January 1 to June 30 shall be submitted by September 1, and the final reports on all stops conducted from July 1 to December 31 shall be submitted by March 1.
(b)The reporting shall include, at a minimum, the following information for each pedestrian, traffic, or any other type of stop:
(1)The time, date, and location of the stop.
(2)The reason for the stop.
(3)The reason given to the person stopped at the time of the stop.
(4)The result of the stop, such as, no action, warning, citation, property seizure, or arrest.
(5)If a warning or citation was issued, the warning provided or violation cited.
(6)If an arrest was made, the offense charged.
(7)The perceived race or ethnicity, gender, and approximate age of the person stopped, provided that the identification of these characteristics shall be based on the observation and perception of the peace officer making the stop, and the information shall not be requested from the person stopped. For motor vehicle stops, this paragraph only applies to the driver, unless any actions specified under paragraph (8) apply in relation to a passenger, in which case the characteristics specified in this paragraph shall also be reported for that passenger.
(8)Actions taken by the peace officer during the stop, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)Whether the peace officer asked for consent to search the person, and, if so, whether consent was provided.
(B)Whether the peace officer searched the person or any property, and, if so, the basis for the search and the type of contraband or evidence discovered, if any.
(C)Whether the peace officer seized any property and, if so, the type of property that was seized and the basis for seizing the property.
(c)If more than one peace officer performs a stop, only one officer is required to collect and report to the officers agency the information specified under subdivision (b).
(d)(1)State and local law enforcement agencies shall not report the name, address, social security number, or other unique personal identifying information of persons stopped, searched, or subjected to a property seizure, for purposes of this section. Law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that personally identifiable information of the individual stopped or any other information that is exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an open text or narrative field.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, the data reported shall be available to the public, except for the badge number or other unique identifying information of the peace officer involved. Any data reported in an open text or narrative field shall only be made available by the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. However, the
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), the Attorney General shall provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. The
(A)The Attorney General shall not provide data to a public or private entity under this paragraph unless the entity agrees to all of the following:
(i)The entity shall not disclose any personally identifying information of individuals stopped or unique identifying information of the peace officer involved and shall keep that information confidential.
(ii)The entity may only use the data for the purposes for which it was shared.
(iii)The entity shall ensure that any publication of the data is done in a manner to prevent the release of personally identifying information and unique identifying information.
(B)The Attorney General shall issue regulations governing how the data is provided to the public and private entities.
(3)(4)Notwithstanding any other law, the Department of Justice shall not be liable for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section.
(e)Not later than January 1, 2018, the Attorney General, in consultation with stakeholders, including the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (j) of Section 13519.4 of the Penal Code, federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies and community, professional, academic, research, and civil and human rights organizations, shall issue regulations for the collection and reporting of data required under subdivision (b). The regulations shall specify all data to be reported, and provide standards, definitions, and technical specifications to ensure uniform reporting practices across all reporting agencies. To the best extent possible, the regulations should be compatible with any similar federal data collection or reporting program.
(f)Except for the restrictions specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d), all data and reports made pursuant to this section are public records within the meaning of Section 7920.530 and are open to public inspection pursuant to Sections 7922.500 to 7922.545, inclusive, 7923.000, and 7923.005.
(g)(1)For purposes of this section, peace officer, as defined in Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 830) of Title 3 of Part 2 of the Penal Code, is limited to members of the California Highway Patrol, a city or county law enforcement agency, and California state or university educational institutions. Peace officer, as used in this section, does not include probation officers and officers in a custodial setting.
(2)For purposes of this section, stop means any detention by a peace officer of a person, or any peace officer interaction with a person in which the peace officer conducts a search, including a consensual search, of the persons body or property in the persons possession or control.
(h)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which amends Section 12525.5 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to ensure that stopped individuals personally identifiable information and officers unique identifying information is not released to the public, it is necessary to limit access to open text and narrative field stop data reported by state and local agencies to the Attorney General.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The data reported under the Racial and Identity Profiling Act of 2015 (Chapter 466 of the Statutes of 2015) provides important information about the state of policing in California.
(b)Despite existing prohibitions that law enforcement agencies shall not include personally identifiable information of individuals stopped or unique identifying information of the officers in their reports, this information continues to be included in open text and narrative fields.
(c)Over 4,500,000 reports were submitted to the Department of Justice in 2022. Unlike the local law enforcement agencies, the Department of Justice is uniquely situated in that it is the repository of all reports statewide, resulting in it maintaining millions of reports. Over the next decade, the Department of Justice is anticipated to receive tens of millions of reports.
(d)The Department of Justice lacks resources to review and redact the millions of reports in its possession to ensure that stopped individuals personally identifiable information or officers unique identifying information is not released to the public.
(e)For similar types of sensitive information, the Legislature has balanced the publics right to know with the risk of disclosure of personally identifiable information by limiting the disclosure of such information from the Department of Justice to the public, while authorizing research, educational, and similar institutions to receive sensitive information to conduct research in support of public policy.
(f)It is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that the full reports, including open text and narrative fields, remain publicly available from the reporting agencies, which are already responsible for reviewing and redacting any personally identifiable information or unique identifying information hat may have been included in open text and narrative fields before the reports are transmitted to the Department of Justice and released to the public.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature that portions of the reports, specifically, open text and narrative fields that potentially contain personally identifiable information, be available to the public solely from the reporting agencies and not from the Department of Justice.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature that portions of reports, specifically, open text and narrative fields that potentially contain personally identifiable information, be treated like criminal history and similarly sensitive information. It is the intent of the Legislature that such portions maintained by the Department of Justice be made available to stakeholders and researchers, in order for stakeholders and researchers to make recommendations and develop best practices for discussion and implementation of reforms that will improve public safety in California.
SEC. 2.Section 12525.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:12525.5.(a)(1)Each state and local agency that employs peace officers shall annually preserve and report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by that agencys peace officers officers. Each agencys final stop reports shall be submitted by March 1 for the preceding calendar year.
(2)Each agency that employs 1,000 or more peace officers shall begin collecting data on or before July 1, 2018, and shall issue its first round of reports on or before April 1, 2019. Each agency that employs 667 or more but less than 1,000 peace officers shall begin collecting data on or before January 1, 2019, and shall issue its first round of reports on or before April 1, 2020. Each agency that employs 334 or more but less than 667 peace officers shall begin collecting data on or before January 1, 2021, and shall issue its first round of reports on or before April 1, 2022. Each agency that employs 1 or more but less than 334 peace officers shall begin collecting data on or before January 1, 2022, and shall issue its first round of reports on or before April 1, 2023.(2)If reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agencys submission to the Attorney General, the agency shall submit semiannually for the following calendar year. The Attorney General shall provide notice to the agency by October 1, with the semiannual requirement taking effect as of January 1.
(3)Semiannual agency reports required pursuant to paragraph (2) shall be submitted by September 1 and March 1 of each year. The final reports on all stops conducted from January 1 to June 30 shall be submitted by September 1, and the final reports on all stops conducted from July 1 to December 31 shall be submitted by March 1.
(b)The reporting shall include, at a minimum, the following information for each pedestrian, traffic, or any other type of stop:
(1)The time, date, and location of the stop.
(2)The reason for the stop.
(3)The reason given to the person stopped at the time of the stop.
(4)The result of the stop, such as, no action, warning, citation, property seizure, or arrest.
(5)If a warning or citation was issued, the warning provided or violation cited.
(6)If an arrest was made, the offense charged.
(7)The perceived race or ethnicity, gender, and approximate age of the person stopped, provided that the identification of these characteristics shall be based on the observation and perception of the peace officer making the stop, and the information shall not be requested from the person stopped. For motor vehicle stops, this paragraph only applies to the driver, unless any actions specified under paragraph (8) apply in relation to a passenger, in which case the characteristics specified in this paragraph shall also be reported for that passenger.
(8)Actions taken by the peace officer during the stop, including, but not limited to, the following:
(A)Whether the peace officer asked for consent to search the person, and, if so, whether consent was provided.
(B)Whether the peace officer searched the person or any property, and, if so, the basis for the search and the type of contraband or evidence discovered, if any.
(C)Whether the peace officer seized any property and, if so, the type of property that was seized and the basis for seizing the property.
(c)If more than one peace officer performs a stop, only one officer is required to collect and report to the officers agency the information specified under subdivision (b).
(d)(1)State and local law enforcement agencies shall not report the name, address, social security number, or other unique personal identifying information of persons stopped, searched, or subjected to a property seizure, for purposes of this section. Notwithstanding any other law, the data reported shall be available to the public, except for the badge number or other unique identifying information of the peace officer involved. Law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that personally identifiable information of the individual stopped or any other information that is exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an open text or narrative field.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, the data reported shall be available to the public, except for the badge number or other unique identifying information of the peace officer involved. Any data reported in an open text or narrative field shall only be made available by the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. However, the Attorney General shall provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. The Attorney General shall issue regulations governing how the data is provided to the public and private entities.
(3)Notwithstanding any other law, the Department of Justice shall not be liable for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section.
(e)Not later than January 1, 2018, the Attorney General, in consultation with stakeholders, including the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (j) of Section 13519.4 of the Penal Code, federal, state, and local law enforcement agencies and community, professional, academic, research, and civil and human rights organizations, shall issue regulations for the collection and reporting of data required under subdivision (b). The regulations shall specify all data to be reported, and provide standards, definitions, and technical specifications to ensure uniform reporting practices across all reporting agencies. To the best extent possible, the regulations should be compatible with any similar federal data collection or reporting program.
(f)All Except for the restrictions specified in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d), all data and reports made pursuant to this section are public records within the meaning of Section 7920.530 and are open to public inspection pursuant to Sections 7922.500 to 7922.545, inclusive, 7923.000, and 7923.005.
(g)(1)For purposes of this section, peace officer, as defined in Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 830) of Title 3 of Part 2 of the Penal Code, is limited to members of the California Highway Patrol, a city or county law enforcement agency, and California state or university educational institutions. Peace officer, as used in this section, does not include probation officers and officers in a custodial setting.
(2)For purposes of this section, stop means any detention by a peace officer of a person, or any peace officer interaction with a person in which the peace officer conducts a search, including a consensual search, of the persons body or property in the persons possession or control.
(h)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 2 of this act, which amends Section 12525.5 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to ensure that stopped individuals personally identifiable information and officers unique identifying information is not released to the public, it is necessary to limit access to open text and narrative field stop data reported by state and local agencies to the Attorney General.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 927 is added to the Labor Code, to read:927.(a)A provision in an agreement between an individual and any other person for the performance of personal or professional services is contrary to public policy and is deemed unconscionable and subject to Section 1670.5 of the Civil Code if the provision meets all of the following conditions:(1)The provision allows for the creation and use of a digital replica of the individuals voice or likeness in place of work the individual would otherwise have performed in person or allows for the use of the individuals voice and likeness to train a generative artificial intelligence system.(2)The provision does not clearly define and detail all of the proposed uses of the digital replica or the generative artificial intelligence system.(3)The individual was not represented in either of the following manners:(A)Represented by legal counsel who negotiated on behalf of the individual licensing their digital replica rights and the licensing terms exist in a standalone written agreement.(B)Represented by a labor union representing workers who do the proposed work and the terms of their collective bargaining agreement expressly covers uses of digital replicas and generative artificial intelligence systems.(b)This section shall apply retroactively.(c)Any person who is currently under, or has entered into, an agreement with an individual performing personal or professional services containing a provision as described in subdivision (a), by February 1, 2024, shall notify that individual in writing that the provision is unenforceable.(a)A provision in an agreement between an individual and any other person for the performance of personal or professional services is contrary to public policy and is deemed unconscionable and subject to Section 1670.5 of the Civil Code if the provision meets all of the following conditions:
(1)The provision allows for the creation and use of a digital replica of the individuals voice or likeness in place of work the individual would otherwise have performed in person or allows for the use of the individuals voice and likeness to train a generative artificial intelligence system.
(2)The provision does not clearly define and detail all of the proposed uses of the digital replica or the generative artificial intelligence system.
(3)The individual was not represented in either of the following manners:
(A)Represented by legal counsel who negotiated on behalf of the individual licensing their digital replica rights and the licensing terms exist in a standalone written agreement.
(B)Represented by a labor union representing workers who do the proposed work and the terms of their collective bargaining agreement expressly covers uses of digital replicas and generative artificial intelligence systems.
(b)This section shall apply retroactively.
(c)Any person who is currently under, or has entered into, an agreement with an individual performing personal or professional services containing a provision as described in subdivision (a), by February 1, 2024, shall notify that individual in writing that the provision is unenforceable.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as amended in the Assembly, April 13, 2023. (JR11)(a)(1)The California Health and Human Services Agency shall establish, by July 1, 2026, the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR) to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination by the agency of best practices in service delivery. The CBH-OAR shall cover county recipients and shall include the programmatic elements that each county and health plan offers as part of its behavioral health care service array, and shall consist of performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
(2)For purposes of this section, behavioral health services includes mental health and substance use disorder services being provided by or arranged by either of the following:(A)A county behavioral health agency funded through county general funds, 1991 Realignment and 2011 Realignment funds, federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grants, Mental Health Services Act funds, and other sources of local, state, or federal funding dedicated to county behavioral health services.(B)Health plans, including both public and private health plans.(b)(1)(A)(i)On or before October 1, 2024, the agency shall convene a workgroup composed of representatives from all of the following:
(I)The State Department of Health Care Services.
(II)The Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission.
(III)The Department of Managed Health Care.
(IV)The Department of Insurance.
(V)The University of California.
(VI)County behavioral health agencies.
(VII)Health plans.
(VIII)Legislative staff.
(IX)Interested behavioral health advocacy and research organizations.
(X)Consumers.
(XI)Organizations that represent county behavioral health agencies and county boards of supervisors.
(XII)Nonprofit community-based organizations.
(XIII)Researchers.
(XIV)Other entities or individuals that the agency deems necessary.
(ii)The workgroup shall establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted.
(B)The agency shall report annually to the Senate Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services during the budget process with an update on the schedule for, development of, and future changes to, the CBH-OAR.
(2)In establishing the work plan, the workgroup shall, at minimum, do all of the following:
(A)Consider existing performance indicators being measured.
(B)Consider or develop additional, alternative, or additional and alternative performance indicators to be measured.
(C)Develop uniform elements of the county and health plan system needs assessment process and the county and health plan system improvement plans.
(D)Develop timelines for implementation.
(E)Make recommendations for reducing the existing services data reporting burden.
(F)Make recommendations for financial incentives to counties for achievement on performance measures.
(G)Analyze the county and state workload associated with implementation of the requirements of this section.
(3)The workgroup shall develop the uniform elements for the county and health plan system improvement plans required in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2). The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop the uniform elements of the updates to those plans as required pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2).
(4)On or after July 1, 2027, the workgroup may, at the discretion of the agency, be disbanded or incorporated into existing advisory bodies.
(c)(1)The CBH-OAR shall consist of the following three components: performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
(2)(A)(i)The CBH-OAR performance indicators shall include both process and outcome measures. These measures shall be established to provide baseline and ongoing information about how the state, counties, and health plans are performing over time and to inform and guide each county behavioral health agencys and health plans system needs assessment process and system improvement plan.
(ii)Process measures shall include measures of participant engagement, service delivery, and participation. Specific process measures shall be established by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, and may include measures of engagement as shown by improvement in program participation, timeliness of service provision, rates of utilization of program components, and referrals and utilization of services.
(iii)If the University of California enters into the contract described in subdivision (f), outcome measures shall be determined based on the recommendations included in the analysis prepared by the University of California pursuant to subdivision (f).
(B)To the extent permitted by existing state and federal privacy laws, performance indicator data available in existing county and health plan data systems shall be collected by counties and health plans and provided to the agency, and performance indicator data available in existing state agency data systems shall be collected by the agency and provided to the counties and health plans. This data shall be reported in a manner and on a schedule determined by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, but no less frequently than semiannually.
(C)(i)During the first three-year CBH-OAR cycle, performance indicator data reported by each county and health plan shall be used to establish both county and statewide baselines for each performance indicator. The data reported in the first year of the first CBH-OAR cycle shall serve as the county and statewide baselines. After the first review cycle, the agency shall establish standard target thresholds for each performance indicator established by the workgroup.
(ii)The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop a process for resolving disputes regarding the establishment of standard target thresholds pursuant to clause (i).
(D)(i)For subsequent reviews, based upon availability of additional data through data sharing agreements, the agency shall consider whether to establish additional performance indicators to advance the intent of this section.
(ii)Additional performance indicators shall also be subject to the process described in subparagraph (C) and shall include consideration of when data on the additional performance indicators will be available for reporting, if not already available.
(E)If, during subsequent reviews, there is sufficient reason to establish statewide performance standards for one or more outcome measures, the agency may establish those standards for each of the agreed-upon outcome measures.
(3)(A)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process component of the CBH-OAR, as established by the workgroup, shall require county behavioral health agencies and health plans to assess their performance on the established performance indicators, identify the strengths and weaknesses in their current practice and resource deployment, and identify and describe how operational decisions and systemic factors affect program outcomes as described in paragraph (4).
(ii)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be designed to identify areas of best practices for replication and for system improvement and shall guide the development of the county and health plan system improvement plan.
(B)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be completed by the county and health plans, in consultation and collaboration with stakeholders, and submitted to the agency every three years.
(ii)(I)Counties shall convene local stakeholders, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(ia)County behavioral health directors, supervisors, and caseworkers.
(ib)Consumers and family members of consumers.
(ic)Health plans operating in the county.
(id)Hospitals.
(ie)Local educational agencies.
(if)Law enforcement.
(ig)Child welfare agencies.
(ih)County-contracted providers.
(ii)Other county behavioral health agency partners.
(II)To the extent possible and relevant, local stakeholders shall also include representatives from tribal organizations and the local behavioral health board.
(III)Additional specific county behavioral health agency partners shall be determined by the county and may include, but are not limited to, adult education providers, providers of services for survivors of domestic violence, the local housing continuum of care, county human services departments, county drug and alcohol programs, and community-based service providers, as appropriate.
(iii)Health plans shall convene stakeholders, including, but not limited to, providers, hospitals, enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, parents of child enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, and a representative sample of county behavioral health departments from their service area.
(4)(A)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall include the uniform elements established by the workgroup pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(B)(i)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall be completed every three years by the county and health plan.
(ii)A countys system improvement plan shall be approved in public session by the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, and be submitted to the agency. Prior to being presented to the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, for approval, the countys system improvement plan shall be presented to the local behavioral health board or equivalent body. A health plans system improvement plan shall be approved by its board of directors.
(C)(i)A countys system improvement plan shall include a services peer review element, conducted by peer counties, the purpose of which is to provide additional insight, including collaborative training on best practices and technical assistance by peer counties.
(ii)Health plans are not required to participate in a peer review process.
(D)The county behavioral health agency or health plan shall complete an annual progress report on the status of its system improvement plan and shall submit these reports to the agency.
(d)(1)(A)The agency shall receive, review, and, based on its determination of whether the county or health plan system improvement plan meets the required elements, certify as complete all submitted performance indicator data, county and health plans self-assessments, county and health plan system improvement plans, and annual progress reports.
(B)The agency shall identify and promote the replication of best practices in service delivery to achieve the established process and outcome measures.
(C)The agency shall monitor, on an ongoing basis, county performance on the performance indicators developed pursuant to subdivision (c).
(D)The agency may assign the duties outlined in paragraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, to the State Department of Health Care Services, the Department of Managed Health Care, and the Department of Insurance, as appropriate.
(2)The agency shall, on an annual basis, beginning July 1, 2026, submit a report to the Legislature that summarizes county or health plan performance on the established performance indicators during the reporting period, analyzes county performance trends over time, and makes findings and recommendations for common service improvements identified in the county and health plan system assessments and system improvement plans, including information on common statutory, regulatory, or fiscal barriers identified as inhibiting system improvements and recommendations to overcome those barriers.
(3)(A)(i)If the contract is executed pursuant to subdivision (f), the agency shall, in partnership with the University of California, facilitate the provision of technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans that supports the countys or health plans selected areas for improvement as described in its system improvement plan.
(ii)The agency and the University of California shall not be considered peers in the county peer review element, and their role shall be limited to providing technical assistance.
(B)If the agency determines, in the course of its review of county and health plan system improvement plans and annual updates or in the course of its review of regularly submitted performance indicator data, that a county or health plan is consistently failing to meet the performance indicator standard target thresholds established pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the agency shall engage the county or health plan in a process of targeted technical assistance and support to address and resolve the identified shortcomings.
(e)A county shall execute and fulfill components of its system improvement plan that can be accomplished with existing resources.
(f)The agency shall request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide all of the following services:
(1)(A)(i)Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans and provided to the state may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes.
(ii)The analysis shall be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup established pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) on or before July 1, 2026, and shall include recommended life outcome measures and measures of the reduction of the negative outcomes described in subdivision (d) of Section 5840 that address prevention and early intervention strategies for mental illness and measures of employment, educational attainment, program exits and program reentries, adherence to treatment plans, attainment of housing, reduction in contacts with law enforcement, reduction in hospitalizations, and reductions in homelessness.
(B)The analysis required to be delivered to the Legislature pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(2)Create and maintain a dashboard modeled after the California Child Welfare Indicators Project to publicly report the data collected by counties and health plans and to report the status of performance indicators as described in this section.
(3)Consult with the agency to provide technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans as described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (d).
(g)For purposes of this section:
(1)Behavioral health services includes mental health and substance use disorder services being provided by or arranged by either of the following:
(A)A county behavioral health agency funded through county general funds, 1991 Realignment and 2011 Realignment funds, federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration block grants, Mental Health Services Act funds, and other sources of local, state, or federal funding dedicated to county behavioral health services.
(B)Health plans, including both public and private health plans.
(2)Health plan means a health care service plan regulated by the Department of Managed Health Care or a disability insurer regulated by the Department of Insurance.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)The California Health and Human Services Agency shall establish, by July 1, 2026, the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR) to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination by the agency of best practices in service delivery. The CBH-OAR shall cover county recipients and shall include the programmatic elements that each county and health plan offers as part of its behavioral health care service array, and shall consist of performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
(2)For purposes of this section, behavioral health services includes mental health and substance use disorder services being provided by or arranged by either of the following:
(A)A county behavioral health agency funded through county general funds, 1991 Realignment and 2011 Realignment funds, federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grants, Mental Health Services Act funds, and other sources of local, state, or federal funding dedicated to county behavioral health services.
(B)Health plans, including both public and private health plans.
(b)(1)(A)(i)On or before October 1, 2024, the agency shall convene a workgroup composed of representatives from all of the following:
(I)The State Department of Health Care Services.
(II)The Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission.
(III)The Department of Managed Health Care.
(IV)The Department of Insurance.
(V)The University of California.
(VI)County behavioral health agencies.
(VII)Health plans.
(VIII)Legislative staff.
(IX)Interested behavioral health advocacy and research organizations.
(X)Consumers.
(XI)Organizations that represent county behavioral health agencies and county boards of supervisors.
(XII)Nonprofit community-based organizations.
(XIII)Researchers.
(XIV)Other entities or individuals that the agency deems necessary.
(ii)The workgroup shall establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted.
(B)The agency shall report annually to the Senate Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services during the budget process with an update on the schedule for, development of, and future changes to, the CBH-OAR.
(2)In establishing the work plan, the workgroup shall, at minimum, do all of the following:
(A)Consider existing performance indicators being measured.
(B)Consider or develop additional, alternative, or additional and alternative performance indicators to be measured.
(C)Develop uniform elements of the county and health plan system needs assessment process and the county and health plan system improvement plans.
(D)Develop timelines for implementation.
(E)Make recommendations for reducing the existing services data reporting burden.
(F)Make recommendations for financial incentives to counties for achievement on performance measures.
(G)Analyze the county and state workload associated with implementation of the requirements of this section.
(3)The workgroup shall develop the uniform elements for the county and health plan system improvement plans required in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2). The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop the uniform elements of the updates to those plans as required pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2).
(4)On or after July 1, 2027, the workgroup may, at the discretion of the agency, be disbanded or incorporated into existing advisory bodies.
(c)(1)The CBH-OAR shall consist of the following three components: performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
(2)(A)(i)The CBH-OAR performance indicators shall include both process and outcome measures. These measures shall be established to provide baseline and ongoing information about how the state, counties, and health plans are performing over time and to inform and guide each county behavioral health agencys and health plans system needs assessment process and system improvement plan.
(ii)Process measures shall include measures of participant engagement, service delivery, and participation. Specific process measures shall be established by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, and may include measures of engagement as shown by improvement in program participation, timeliness of service provision, rates of utilization of program components, and referrals and utilization of services.
(iii)If the University of California enters into the contract described in subdivision (f), outcome measures shall be determined based on the recommendations included in the analysis prepared by the University of California pursuant to subdivision (f).
(B)To the extent permitted by existing state and federal privacy laws, performance indicator data available in existing county and health plan data systems shall be collected by counties and health plans and provided to the agency, and performance indicator data available in existing state agency data systems shall be collected by the agency and provided to the counties and health plans. This data shall be reported in a manner and on a schedule determined by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, but no less frequently than semiannually.
(C)(i)During the first three-year CBH-OAR cycle, performance indicator data reported by each county and health plan shall be used to establish both county and statewide baselines for each performance indicator. The data reported in the first year of the first CBH-OAR cycle shall serve as the county and statewide baselines. After the first review cycle, the agency shall establish standard target thresholds for each performance indicator established by the workgroup.
(ii)The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop a process for resolving disputes regarding the establishment of standard target thresholds pursuant to clause (i).
(D)(i)For subsequent reviews, based upon availability of additional data through data sharing agreements, the agency shall consider whether to establish additional performance indicators to advance the intent of this section.
(ii)Additional performance indicators shall also be subject to the process described in subparagraph (C) and shall include consideration of when data on the additional performance indicators will be available for reporting, if not already available.
(E)If, during subsequent reviews, there is sufficient reason to establish statewide performance standards for one or more outcome measures, the agency may establish those standards for each of the agreed-upon outcome measures.
(3)(A)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process component of the CBH-OAR, as established by the workgroup, shall require county behavioral health agencies and health plans to assess their performance on the established performance indicators, identify the strengths and weaknesses in their current practice and resource deployment, and identify and describe how operational decisions and systemic factors affect program outcomes as described in paragraph (4).
(ii)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be designed to identify areas of best practices for replication and for system improvement and shall guide the development of the county and health plan system improvement plan.
(B)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be completed by the county and health plans, in consultation and collaboration with stakeholders, and submitted to the agency every three years.
(ii)(I)Counties shall convene local stakeholders, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(ia)County behavioral health directors, supervisors, and caseworkers.
(ib)Consumers and family members of consumers.
(ic)Health plans operating in the county.
(id)Hospitals.
(ie)Local educational agencies.
(if)Law enforcement.
(ig)Child welfare agencies.
(ih)County-contracted providers.
(ii)Other county behavioral health agency partners.
(II)To the extent possible and relevant, local stakeholders shall also include representatives from tribal organizations and the local behavioral health board.
(III)Additional specific county behavioral health agency partners shall be determined by the county and may include, but are not limited to, adult education providers, providers of services for survivors of domestic violence, the local housing continuum of care, county human services departments, county drug and alcohol programs, and community-based service providers, as appropriate.
(iii)Health plans shall convene stakeholders, including, but not limited to, providers, hospitals, enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, parents of child enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, and a representative sample of county behavioral health departments from their service area.
(4)(A)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall include the uniform elements established by the workgroup pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(B)(i)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall be completed every three years by the county and health plan.
(ii)A countys system improvement plan shall be approved in public session by the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, and be submitted to the agency. Prior to being presented to the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, for approval, the countys system improvement plan shall be presented to the local behavioral health board or equivalent body. A health plans system improvement plan shall be approved by its board of directors.
(C)(i)A countys system improvement plan shall include a services peer review element, conducted by peer counties, the purpose of which is to provide additional insight, including collaborative training on best practices and technical assistance by peer counties.
(ii)Health plans are not required to participate in a peer review process.
(D)The county behavioral health agency or health plan shall complete an annual progress report on the status of its system improvement plan and shall submit these reports to the agency.
(d)(1)(A)The agency shall receive, review, and, based on its determination of whether the county or health plan system improvement plan meets the required elements, certify as complete all submitted performance indicator data, county and health plans self-assessments, county and health plan system improvement plans, and annual progress reports.
(B)The agency shall identify and promote the replication of best practices in service delivery to achieve the established process and outcome measures.
(C)The agency shall monitor, on an ongoing basis, county performance on the performance indicators developed pursuant to subdivision (c).
(D)The agency may assign the duties outlined in paragraphs (A) to (C), inclusive, to the State Department of Health Care Services, the Department of Managed Health Care, and the Department of Insurance, as appropriate.
(2)The agency shall, on an annual basis, beginning July 1, 2026, submit a report to the Legislature that summarizes county or health plan performance on the established performance indicators during the reporting period, analyzes county performance trends over time, and makes findings and recommendations for common service improvements identified in the county and health plan system assessments and system improvement plans, including information on common statutory, regulatory, or fiscal barriers identified as inhibiting system improvements and recommendations to overcome those barriers.
(3)(A)(i)If the contract is executed pursuant to subdivision (f), the agency shall, in partnership with the University of California, facilitate the provision of technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans that supports the countys or health plans selected areas for improvement as described in its system improvement plan.
(ii)The agency and the University of California shall not be considered peers in the county peer review element, and their role shall be limited to providing technical assistance.
(B)If the agency determines, in the course of its review of county and health plan system improvement plans and annual updates or in the course of its review of regularly submitted performance indicator data, that a county or health plan is consistently failing to meet the performance indicator standard target thresholds established pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the agency shall engage the county or health plan in a process of targeted technical assistance and support to address and resolve the identified shortcomings.
(e)A county shall execute and fulfill components of its system improvement plan that can be accomplished with existing resources.
(f)The agency shall request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide all of the following services:
(1)(A)(i)Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans and provided to the state may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes.
(ii)The analysis shall be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup established pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) on or before July 1, 2026, and shall include recommended life outcome measures and measures of the reduction of the negative outcomes described in subdivision (d) of Section 5840 that address prevention and early intervention strategies for mental illness and measures of employment, educational attainment, program exits and program reentries, adherence to treatment plans, attainment of housing, reduction in contacts with law enforcement, reduction in hospitalizations, and reductions in homelessness.
(B)The analysis required to be delivered to the Legislature pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(2)Create and maintain a dashboard modeled after the California Child Welfare Indicators Project to publicly report the data collected by counties and health plans and to report the status of performance indicators as described in this section.
(3)Consult with the agency to provide technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans as described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (d).
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:(a)Mental illnesses and substance use disorders do not diminish a persons right to fully participate in all aspects of society, yet many people with mental illnesses and substance use disorders have been precluded from doing so because of a lack of accessible and high-quality health care, services, and supports.(b)Historically, individuals living with mental illness and substance use disorders have been subjected to inhumane treatment, including institutionalization for indefinite periods of time where they were forced to undergo cruel and unusual treatments that were more traumatizing than recuperative.(c)Despite progress to deinstitutionalize our behavioral health system and invest in community behavioral health alternatives, in 2023, the 60th anniversary of the Community Mental Health Act and the 15th anniversary of the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act, federal and state governments have failed to properly invest in a full continuum of behavioral services, resulting in an inaccessible, paternalistic, and discriminatory system of care.(d)While limited entitlements to services have been established for some subpopulations of individuals with mental illnesses and substance use disorders, failure to meaningfully measure the impact of care, enforce these entitlements, and invest the necessary resources in the services has resulted in these limited entitlements rarely being realized.(e)Despite the disease burden for individuals with mental illnesses and substance use disorders being significantly higher on average than for individuals with physical health diagnoses, Medi-Cal and health plans spend significantly less on behavioral health services than physical health services, which results in low penetration rates and poor outcomes.(f)Studies have documented that, due to this lack of accessible care, people with mental illnesses and substance use disorders, as a group, occupy an inferior status in our society and are severely disadvantaged physically, socially, vocationally, economically, and educationally.(g)The states goals are to ensure access to high-quality care, services, and supports is available to individuals with mental illnesses and substance use disorders when they need it and for as long as they need it and to ensure equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living, and economic self-sufficiency for those individuals.(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the following:(1)Provide a clear and comprehensive mandatory minimum set of services that are universally accessible to all Californians in need of behavioral health care.(2)Ensure these minimum services are high quality, culturally competent, equitable, recovery- and resiliency-focused, and have the effect of improving quality of life outcomes for Californians with mental illnesses and substance use disorders.(3)Fulfill the vision of this act to ensure high-quality care for all by collecting and disseminating relevant data, enforcing the provision of these services, and establishing necessary investments into these services.SEC. 2.Chapter 3.7 (commencing with Section 5740) is added to Part 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:3.7.Behavioral Health Rights Act5740.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the Behavioral Health Rights Act.5741.A person seeking or receiving behavioral health care in California has all of the following rights:(a)The right to live in a safe, healthy, and comfortable home that supports an individuals mental health and substance use challenges. This includes, but is not limited to, affordable housing, temporary housing, adult residential facilities, permanent supportive housing, financial assistance to keep an individual in their current home or housing services, or other services needed to obtain or retain housing.(b)(1)The right to be provided information from their purchasing entity, such as an insurer, third-party payer, public purchaser, or county provided service, describing the nature and extent of behavioral health treatment benefits available to the individual.(2)This information shall describe the availability of services, procedures for accessing services, process for complaints, and appeal rights.(3)The information shall be presented clearly in writing with language the individual can understand.(c)The right to receive recovery-oriented and culturally appropriate care from a licensed, certified, or qualified mental health or substance use professional of their choosing.(1)This right allows an individual to be placed in the least restrictive setting possible, regardless of age, physical health, mental health, sexual orientation, and gender identity and expression.(2)To ensure an individual is making an informed decision about appropriate care, this right includes the ability to receive full information on the education and training of the treating professionals, treatment options, the risks and benefits of a particular treatment option, and cost implications of the services provided.(3)If medication is used, the risks and benefits of medication shall be explained in a way a person can understand, including, but not limited to, how the medication may interact with other medications, food, or underlying health conditions.(d)The right to receive benefits for behavioral health treatment on the same basis as any other illness, with the same copayments, lifetime benefits, and catastrophic coverage in insurer, third-party payer, or public purchaser health plans.(e)(1)The right to treatment review processes that are fair and valid and the right to be guaranteed that a review of their behavioral health treatment will involve a professional having the training, credentials, or licensure to provide the treatment in the jurisdiction in which it will be provided.(2)The reviewer shall not have a financial interest in the decision and is subject to the requirements in subdivision (f) on confidentiality.(f)(1)The right to be guaranteed the protection of the confidentiality of their relationship with their mental health and substance abuse professional, except when laws or ethics dictate otherwise.(2)A disclosure to another party shall be time limited and made with the full written, informed consent of the individual to whom the information relates.(3)An individual need not disclose confidential, privileged, or other information other than diagnosis, prognosis, type of treatment, time and length of treatment, and cost.(4)An entity receiving information for the purposes of benefits determination, a public agency receiving information for health care planning, or an organization with a legitimate right to information shall maintain clinical information in confidence with the same rigor and be subject to the same penalties for violation as is the direct provider of care.(5)(A)Information technology shall be used for data transmission, storage, or management only with methodologies that remove individual identifying information and ensure the protection of the individuals privacy.(B)Information shall not be transferred, sold, or otherwise used except as specified in this paragraph.(g)The right to continue receiving mental health treatment when their placement changes, including, but not limited to, when a person is moved to a different county, treatment facility, housing service, or other treatment provider.(h)The right to learn about the methods an individual can use to submit complaints or grievances regarding care by the treating professional or entity to that persons or entitys regulatory board, professional association, or oversight body.(i)(1)The right to hold treating professionals, systems, and entities accountable and liable to the individual for a violation of these rights or injuries caused by gross incompetence or negligence on the part of the professional or treating entity.(2)The treating professional shall advocate for the individual, document necessity of care for the individual, and advise the individual of options if payment authorization is denied.(3)Payers and other third parties may be held accountable and liable to an individual for an injury caused by gross incompetence or negligence or by their clinically unjustified decisions.5742.(a)All Californians in need of behavioral health services are entitled to behavioral health services that shall be provided by their county behavioral health department or public or private health plan based on the generally accepted standards of care described in subdivision (b). These behavioral health services shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:(1)Community-based services including outreach and engagement services.(2)Outpatient and intensive outpatient services, including individual therapy, group therapy, family therapy, and coordinated specialty care.(3)Intensive case management.(4)Peer support services.(5)Intensive home- and community-based services, including wrap-around services, full-service partnerships, and assertive community treatment.(6)Supportive housing services.(7)Supportive employment services.(8)Short-term residential settings, including crisis residential services.(9)Partial hospitalization.(10)Placement in a psychiatric health facility.(11)Inpatient psychiatric hospitalization.(12)Placement in an institute for mental disease.(13)Crisis services, including crisis counseling, mobile crisis teams, and crisis receiving and stabilization services.(14)Placement in a sobering center.(15)Detoxification services.(16)Medically assisted treatment.(b)All Californians in need of behavioral health services are entitled to receive the services provided in subdivision (a) upon determination of medical necessity based on current generally accepted standards of mental health and substance use disorder care, including all of the following:(1)For a primary substance use disorder diagnosis in adolescents and adults, the Treatment Criteria for Addictive, Substance-Related, and Co-Occurring Conditions by the American Society of Addiction Medicine.(2)For a primary mental health diagnosis in adults 19 years of age and older, Level of Care Utilization System by the American Association for Community Psychiatry.(3)For a primary mental health diagnosis in children 6 to 18 years of age, inclusive, the Child and Adolescent Level of Care/Service Intensity Utilization System by the American Association for Community Psychiatry and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.(4)For a primary mental health diagnosis in children five years of age and younger, Early Child Service Intensity Instrument by the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.(5)For an individual without a primary mental health or substance use disorder diagnosis, determination processes consistent with existing requirements in the states Medi-Cal program, including, but not limited to, designated scores on assessment tools based on adverse childhood experiences and the existing No Wrong Door System for access to Medi-Cal behavioral health services.(c)This section does not relieve a county or Medi-Cal-managed health plan of its obligation to provide early and periodic screening, diagnosis, and treatment consistent with the requirements of Subchapter XIX (commencing with Section 1396) of Chapter 7 of Title 42 of the United States Code.(d)(1)This section does not relieve a health plan of its obligation to provide for services otherwise required by Sections 1374.72 and 1374.721 of the Health and Safety Code or Section 10144.52 of the Insurance Code.(2)This section does not conflict with existing requirements of the Medi-Cal programs.(e)This section does not prohibit county behavioral health departments or health plans from providing or arranging for additional behavioral health services.(f)Services guaranteed in this section shall be provided for or arranged in accordance with timely access requirements in Sections 1342.2, 1367.03, and 1367.031 of the Health and Safety Code, Sections 10133.53 and 10133.54 of the Insurance Code, and Section 14197.5743.(a)(1)The California Health and Human Services Agency shall establish, by July 1, 2026, the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR) to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination by the agency of best practices in service delivery. The CBH-OAR shall cover county recipients and shall include the programmatic elements that each county and health plan offers as part of its behavioral health care service array, and shall consist of performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.(2)For purposes of this section, behavioral health services includes mental health and substance use disorder services being provided by or arranged by either of the following:(A)A county behavioral health agency funded through county general funds, 1991 Realignment and 2011 Realignment funds, federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grants, Mental Health Services Act funds, and other sources of local, state, or federal funding dedicated to county behavioral health services.(B)Health plans, including both public and private health plans.(b)(1)(A)(i)On or before October 1, 2024, the agency shall convene a workgroup comprised of representatives from the all of the following:(I)The State Department of Health Care Services.(II)The Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission.(III)The Department of Managed Health Care.(IV)The Department of Insurance.(V)The University of California.(VI)County behavioral health agencies.(VII)Health plans.(VIII)Legislative staff.(IX)Interested behavioral health advocacy and research organizations.(X)Consumers.(XI)Organizations that represent county behavioral health agencies and county boards of supervisors.(XII)Nonprofit community-based organizations.(XIII)Researchers.(XIV)Other entities or individuals that the agency deems necessary.(ii)The workgroup shall establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted.(B)The agency shall report annually to the Senate Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services during the budget process with an update on the schedule for, development of, and future changes to, the CBH-OAR.(2)In establishing the work plan, the workgroup shall, at minimum, do all of the following:(A)Consider existing performance indicators being measured.(B)Consider or develop additional, alternative, or additional and alternative performance indicators to be measured.(C)Develop uniform elements of the county and health plan system needs assessment process and the county and health plan system improvement plans.(D)Develop timelines for implementation.(E)Make recommendations for reducing the existing services data reporting burden.(F)Make recommendations for financial incentives to counties for achievement on performance measures.(G)Analyze the county and state workload associated with implementation of the requirements of this section.(3)The workgroup shall develop the uniform elements for the county and health plan system improvement plans required in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2). The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop the uniform elements of the updates to those plans as required pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2).(4)On or after July 1, 2027, the workgroup may, at the discretion of the agency, be disbanded or incorporated into existing advisory bodies.(c)(1)The CBH-OAR shall consist of the following three components: performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.(2)(A)(i)The CBH-OAR performance indicators shall include both process and outcome measures. These measures shall be established to provide baseline and ongoing information about how the state, counties, and health plans are performing over time and to inform and guide each county behavioral health agencys and health plans system needs assessment process and system improvement plan.(ii)Process measures shall include measures of participant engagement, service delivery, and participation. Specific process measures shall be established by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, and may include measures of engagement as shown by improvement in program participation, timeliness of service provision, rates of utilization of program components, and referrals and utilization of services.(iii)If the University of California enters into the contract described in subdivision (f), outcome measures shall be determined based on the recommendations included in the analysis prepared by the University of California pursuant to subdivision (f).(B)To the extent permitted by existing state and federal privacy laws, performance indicator data available in existing county and health plan data systems shall be collected by counties and health plans and provided to the agency, and performance indicator data available in existing state agency data systems shall be collected by the agency and provided to the counties and health plans. This data shall be reported in a manner and on a schedule determined by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, but no less frequently than semiannually.(C)(i)During the first three-year CBH-OAR cycle, performance indicator data reported by each county and health plan shall be used to establish both county and statewide baselines for each performance indicator. The data reported in the first year of the first CBH-OAR cycle shall serve as the county and statewide baselines. After the first review cycle, the agency shall establish standard target thresholds for each performance indicator established by the workgroup.(ii)The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop a process for resolving disputes regarding the establishment of standard target thresholds pursuant to clause (i).(D)(i)For subsequent reviews, based upon availability of additional data through data sharing agreements, the agency shall consider whether to establish additional performance indicators to advance the intent of this chapter.(ii)Additional performance indicators shall also be subject to the process described in subparagraph (C) and shall include consideration of when data on the additional performance indicators will be available for reporting, if not already available.(E)If, during subsequent reviews, there is sufficient reason to establish statewide performance standards for one or more outcome measures, the agency may establish those standards for each of the agreed-upon outcome measures.(3)(A)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process component of the CBH-OAR, as established by the workgroup, shall require county behavioral health agencies and health plans to assess their performance on the established performance indicators, identify the strengths and weaknesses in their current practice and resource deployment, and identify and describe how operational decisions and systemic factors affect program outcomes as described in paragraph (4).(ii)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be designed to identify areas of best practices for replication and for system improvement and shall guide the development of the county and health plan system improvement plan.(B)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be completed by the county and health plans, in consultation and collaboration with stakeholders, and submitted to the agency every three years.(ii)(I)Counties shall convene local stakeholders, including, but not limited to, all of the following:(ia)County behavioral health directors, supervisors, and caseworkers.(ib)Consumers and family members of consumers.(ic)Health plans operating in the county.(id)Hospitals.(ie)Local educational agencies.(if)Law enforcement.(ig)Child welfare agencies.(ih)County-contracted providers.(ii)Other county behavioral health agency partners.(II)To the extent possible and relevant, local stakeholders shall also include representatives from tribal organizations and the local behavioral health board.(III)Additional specific county behavioral health agency partners shall be determined by the county and may include, but are not limited to, adult education providers, providers of services for survivors of domestic violence, the local housing continuum of care, county human service departments, county drug and alcohol programs, and community-based service providers, as appropriate.(iii)Health plans shall convene stakeholders, including, but not limited to, providers, hospitals, enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, parents of child enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, and a representative sample of county behavioral health departments from their service area.(4)(A)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall include the uniform elements established by the workgroup pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).(B)(i)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall be completed every three years by the county and health plan.(ii)A countys system improvement plan shall be approved in public session by the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, and be submitted to the agency. Prior to being presented to the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, for approval, the countys system improvement plan shall be presented to the local behavioral health board or equivalent body. A health plans system improvement plan shall be approved by its board of directors.(C)(i)A countys system improvement plan shall include a services peer review element, conducted by peer counties, the purpose of which is to provide additional insight, including collaborative training on best practices and technical assistance by peer counties.(ii)Health plans are not required to participate in a peer review process.(D)The county behavioral health agency or health plan shall complete an annual progress report on the status of its system improvement plan and shall submit these reports to the agency.(d)(1)(A)The agency shall receive, review, and, based on its determination of whether the county or health plan system improvement plan meets the required elements, certify as complete all submitted performance indicator data, county and health plans self-assessments, county and health plan system improvement plans, and annual progress reports.(B)The agency shall identify and promote the replication of best practices in service delivery to achieve the established process and outcome measures.(C)The agency shall monitor, on an ongoing basis, county performance on the performance indicators developed pursuant to subdivision (c).(D)The agency may assign the duties outlined in paragraphs (A) through (C), inclusive, to the State Department of Health Care Services, the Department of Managed Health Care, and the Department of Insurance, as appropriate.(2)The agency shall, on an annual basis, beginning July 1, 2026, submit a report to the Legislature that summarizes county or health plan performance on the established performance indicators during the reporting period, analyzes county performance trends over time, and makes findings and recommendations for common service improvements identified in the county and health plan system assessments and system improvement plans, including information on common statutory, regulatory, or fiscal barriers identified as inhibiting system improvements and recommendations to overcome those barriers.(3)(A)(i)If the contract is executed pursuant to subdivision (f), the agency shall, in partnership with the University of California, facilitate the provision of technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans that supports the countys or health plans selected areas for improvement as described in its system improvement plan.(ii)The agency and the University of California shall not be considered peers in the county peer review element, and their role shall be limited to providing technical assistance.(B)If the agency determines, in the course of its review of county and health plan system improvement plans and annual updates or in the course of its review of regularly submitted performance indicator data, that a county or health plan is consistently failing to meet the performance indicator standard target thresholds established pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the agency shall engage the county or health plan in a process of targeted technical assistance and support to address and resolve the identified shortcomings.(e)A county shall execute and fulfill components of its system improvement plan that can be accomplished with existing resources.(f)The agency shall request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide all of the following services:(1)(A)(i)Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans and provided to the state may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes.(ii)The analysis shall be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup established pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) on or before July 1, 2026, and shall include recommended life outcome measures and measures of the reduction of the negative outcomes described in subdivision (d) of Section 5840 that address prevention and early intervention strategies for mental illness and measures of employment, educational attainment, program exits and program reentries, adherence to treatment plans, attainment of housing, reduction in contacts with law enforcement, reduction in hospitalizations, and reductions in homelessness.(B)The analysis required to be delivered to the Legislature pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.(2)Create and maintain a dashboard modeled after the California Child Welfare Indicators Project to publicly report the data collected by counties and health plans and to report the status of performance indicators as described in this section.(3)Consult with the agency to provide technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans as described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (d).5744.(a)Effective no later than July 1, 2026, the California Health and Human Services Agency, in consultation with the Department of Managed Health Care, the State Department of Health Care Services, and the Department of Insurance, shall establish a risk corridor structure applying to all health payers who provide behavioral health services in California. Under this structure, the risk sharing of costs shall include a requirement that these health payers are required to spend at least 20 percent of their provider health payments on behavioral health services.(b)The above percentage of provider health payments on behavioral health services shall be adjusted annually based on an estimate of the prevalence rate of behavioral health conditions among a health payers enrollee population and an estimate of the disease burden as measured by financial cost for this estimated enrollee group.(c)A health payer specified above can meet its spending obligation on behavioral health services under this risk corridor structure in a variety of ways, including provider reimbursement payments, incentive payments intended to improve the quality of behavioral health service delivery, or other innovative investments in the provision of behavioral health services.SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Mental illnesses and substance use disorders do not diminish a persons right to fully participate in all aspects of society, yet many people with mental illnesses and substance use disorders have been precluded from doing so because of a lack of accessible and high-quality health care, services, and supports.
(b)Historically, individuals living with mental illness and substance use disorders have been subjected to inhumane treatment, including institutionalization for indefinite periods of time where they were forced to undergo cruel and unusual treatments that were more traumatizing than recuperative.
(c)Despite progress to deinstitutionalize our behavioral health system and invest in community behavioral health alternatives, in 2023, the 60th anniversary of the Community Mental Health Act and the 15th anniversary of the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act, federal and state governments have failed to properly invest in a full continuum of behavioral services, resulting in an inaccessible, paternalistic, and discriminatory system of care.
(d)While limited entitlements to services have been established for some subpopulations of individuals with mental illnesses and substance use disorders, failure to meaningfully measure the impact of care, enforce these entitlements, and invest the necessary resources in the services has resulted in these limited entitlements rarely being realized.
(e)Despite the disease burden for individuals with mental illnesses and substance use disorders being significantly higher on average than for individuals with physical health diagnoses, Medi-Cal and health plans spend significantly less on behavioral health services than physical health services, which results in low penetration rates and poor outcomes.
(f)Studies have documented that, due to this lack of accessible care, people with mental illnesses and substance use disorders, as a group, occupy an inferior status in our society and are severely disadvantaged physically, socially, vocationally, economically, and educationally.
(g)The states goals are to ensure access to high-quality care, services, and supports is available to individuals with mental illnesses and substance use disorders when they need it and for as long as they need it and to ensure equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living, and economic self-sufficiency for those individuals.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the following:
(1)Provide a clear and comprehensive mandatory minimum set of services that are universally accessible to all Californians in need of behavioral health care.
(2)Ensure these minimum services are high quality, culturally competent, equitable, recovery- and resiliency-focused, and have the effect of improving quality of life outcomes for Californians with mental illnesses and substance use disorders.
(3)Fulfill the vision of this act to ensure high-quality care for all by collecting and disseminating relevant data, enforcing the provision of these services, and establishing necessary investments into these services.
SEC. 2.Chapter 3.7 (commencing with Section 5740) is added to Part 2 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:3.7.Behavioral Health Rights Act5740.This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the Behavioral Health Rights Act.
5741.A person seeking or receiving behavioral health care in California has all of the following rights:
(a)The right to live in a safe, healthy, and comfortable home that supports an individuals mental health and substance use challenges. This includes, but is not limited to, affordable housing, temporary housing, adult residential facilities, permanent supportive housing, financial assistance to keep an individual in their current home or housing services, or other services needed to obtain or retain housing.
(b)(1)The right to be provided information from their purchasing entity, such as an insurer, third-party payer, public purchaser, or county provided service, describing the nature and extent of behavioral health treatment benefits available to the individual.
(2)This information shall describe the availability of services, procedures for accessing services, process for complaints, and appeal rights.
(3)The information shall be presented clearly in writing with language the individual can understand.
(c)The right to receive recovery-oriented and culturally appropriate care from a licensed, certified, or qualified mental health or substance use professional of their choosing.
(1)This right allows an individual to be placed in the least restrictive setting possible, regardless of age, physical health, mental health, sexual orientation, and gender identity and expression.
(2)To ensure an individual is making an informed decision about appropriate care, this right includes the ability to receive full information on the education and training of the treating professionals, treatment options, the risks and benefits of a particular treatment option, and cost implications of the services provided.
(3)If medication is used, the risks and benefits of medication shall be explained in a way a person can understand, including, but not limited to, how the medication may interact with other medications, food, or underlying health conditions.
(d)The right to receive benefits for behavioral health treatment on the same basis as any other illness, with the same copayments, lifetime benefits, and catastrophic coverage in insurer, third-party payer, or public purchaser health plans.
(e)(1)The right to treatment review processes that are fair and valid and the right to be guaranteed that a review of their behavioral health treatment will involve a professional having the training, credentials, or licensure to provide the treatment in the jurisdiction in which it will be provided.
(2)The reviewer shall not have a financial interest in the decision and is subject to the requirements in subdivision (f) on confidentiality.
(f)(1)The right to be guaranteed the protection of the confidentiality of their relationship with their mental health and substance abuse professional, except when laws or ethics dictate otherwise.
(2)A disclosure to another party shall be time limited and made with the full written, informed consent of the individual to whom the information relates.
(3)An individual need not disclose confidential, privileged, or other information other than diagnosis, prognosis, type of treatment, time and length of treatment, and cost.
(4)An entity receiving information for the purposes of benefits determination, a public agency receiving information for health care planning, or an organization with a legitimate right to information shall maintain clinical information in confidence with the same rigor and be subject to the same penalties for violation as is the direct provider of care.
(5)(A)Information technology shall be used for data transmission, storage, or management only with methodologies that remove individual identifying information and ensure the protection of the individuals privacy.
(B)Information shall not be transferred, sold, or otherwise used except as specified in this paragraph.
(g)The right to continue receiving mental health treatment when their placement changes, including, but not limited to, when a person is moved to a different county, treatment facility, housing service, or other treatment provider.
(h)The right to learn about the methods an individual can use to submit complaints or grievances regarding care by the treating professional or entity to that persons or entitys regulatory board, professional association, or oversight body.
(i)(1)The right to hold treating professionals, systems, and entities accountable and liable to the individual for a violation of these rights or injuries caused by gross incompetence or negligence on the part of the professional or treating entity.
(2)The treating professional shall advocate for the individual, document necessity of care for the individual, and advise the individual of options if payment authorization is denied.
(3)Payers and other third parties may be held accountable and liable to an individual for an injury caused by gross incompetence or negligence or by their clinically unjustified decisions.
5742.(a)All Californians in need of behavioral health services are entitled to behavioral health services that shall be provided by their county behavioral health department or public or private health plan based on the generally accepted standards of care described in subdivision (b). These behavioral health services shall include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Community-based services including outreach and engagement services.
(2)Outpatient and intensive outpatient services, including individual therapy, group therapy, family therapy, and coordinated specialty care.
(3)Intensive case management.
(4)Peer support services.
(5)Intensive home- and community-based services, including wrap-around services, full-service partnerships, and assertive community treatment.
(6)Supportive housing services.
(7)Supportive employment services.
(8)Short-term residential settings, including crisis residential services.
(9)Partial hospitalization.
(10)Placement in a psychiatric health facility.
(11)Inpatient psychiatric hospitalization.
(12)Placement in an institute for mental disease.
(13)Crisis services, including crisis counseling, mobile crisis teams, and crisis receiving and stabilization services.
(14)Placement in a sobering center.
(15)Detoxification services.
(16)Medically assisted treatment.
(b)All Californians in need of behavioral health services are entitled to receive the services provided in subdivision (a) upon determination of medical necessity based on current generally accepted standards of mental health and substance use disorder care, including all of the following:
(1)For a primary substance use disorder diagnosis in adolescents and adults, the Treatment Criteria for Addictive, Substance-Related, and Co-Occurring Conditions by the American Society of Addiction Medicine.
(2)For a primary mental health diagnosis in adults 19 years of age and older, Level of Care Utilization System by the American Association for Community Psychiatry.
(3)For a primary mental health diagnosis in children 6 to 18 years of age, inclusive, the Child and Adolescent Level of Care/Service Intensity Utilization System by the American Association for Community Psychiatry and the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.
(4)For a primary mental health diagnosis in children five years of age and younger, Early Child Service Intensity Instrument by the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry.
(5)For an individual without a primary mental health or substance use disorder diagnosis, determination processes consistent with existing requirements in the states Medi-Cal program, including, but not limited to, designated scores on assessment tools based on adverse childhood experiences and the existing No Wrong Door System for access to Medi-Cal behavioral health services.
(c)This section does not relieve a county or Medi-Cal-managed health plan of its obligation to provide early and periodic screening, diagnosis, and treatment consistent with the requirements of Subchapter XIX (commencing with Section 1396) of Chapter 7 of Title 42 of the United States Code.
(d)(1)This section does not relieve a health plan of its obligation to provide for services otherwise required by Sections 1374.72 and 1374.721 of the Health and Safety Code or Section 10144.52 of the Insurance Code.
(2)This section does not conflict with existing requirements of the Medi-Cal programs.
(e)This section does not prohibit county behavioral health departments or health plans from providing or arranging for additional behavioral health services.
(f)Services guaranteed in this section shall be provided for or arranged in accordance with timely access requirements in Sections 1342.2, 1367.03, and 1367.031 of the Health and Safety Code, Sections 10133.53 and 10133.54 of the Insurance Code, and Section 14197.
5743.(a)(1)The California Health and Human Services Agency shall establish, by July 1, 2026, the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR) to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination by the agency of best practices in service delivery. The CBH-OAR shall cover county recipients and shall include the programmatic elements that each county and health plan offers as part of its behavioral health care service array, and shall consist of performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
(2)For purposes of this section, behavioral health services includes mental health and substance use disorder services being provided by or arranged by either of the following:
(A)A county behavioral health agency funded through county general funds, 1991 Realignment and 2011 Realignment funds, federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grants, Mental Health Services Act funds, and other sources of local, state, or federal funding dedicated to county behavioral health services.
(B)Health plans, including both public and private health plans.
(b)(1)(A)(i)On or before October 1, 2024, the agency shall convene a workgroup comprised of representatives from the all of the following:
(I)The State Department of Health Care Services.
(II)The Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission.
(III)The Department of Managed Health Care.
(IV)The Department of Insurance.
(V)The University of California.
(VI)County behavioral health agencies.
(VII)Health plans.
(VIII)Legislative staff.
(IX)Interested behavioral health advocacy and research organizations.
(X)Consumers.
(XI)Organizations that represent county behavioral health agencies and county boards of supervisors.
(XII)Nonprofit community-based organizations.
(XIII)Researchers.
(XIV)Other entities or individuals that the agency deems necessary.
(ii)The workgroup shall establish a workplan by which the CBH-OAR shall be conducted.
(B)The agency shall report annually to the Senate Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services during the budget process with an update on the schedule for, development of, and future changes to, the CBH-OAR.
(2)In establishing the work plan, the workgroup shall, at minimum, do all of the following:
(A)Consider existing performance indicators being measured.
(B)Consider or develop additional, alternative, or additional and alternative performance indicators to be measured.
(C)Develop uniform elements of the county and health plan system needs assessment process and the county and health plan system improvement plans.
(D)Develop timelines for implementation.
(E)Make recommendations for reducing the existing services data reporting burden.
(F)Make recommendations for financial incentives to counties for achievement on performance measures.
(G)Analyze the county and state workload associated with implementation of the requirements of this section.
(3)The workgroup shall develop the uniform elements for the county and health plan system improvement plans required in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2). The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop the uniform elements of the updates to those plans as required pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2).
(4)On or after July 1, 2027, the workgroup may, at the discretion of the agency, be disbanded or incorporated into existing advisory bodies.
(c)(1)The CBH-OAR shall consist of the following three components: performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process, and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
(2)(A)(i)The CBH-OAR performance indicators shall include both process and outcome measures. These measures shall be established to provide baseline and ongoing information about how the state, counties, and health plans are performing over time and to inform and guide each county behavioral health agencys and health plans system needs assessment process and system improvement plan.
(ii)Process measures shall include measures of participant engagement, service delivery, and participation. Specific process measures shall be established by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, and may include measures of engagement as shown by improvement in program participation, timeliness of service provision, rates of utilization of program components, and referrals and utilization of services.
(iii)If the University of California enters into the contract described in subdivision (f), outcome measures shall be determined based on the recommendations included in the analysis prepared by the University of California pursuant to subdivision (f).
(B)To the extent permitted by existing state and federal privacy laws, performance indicator data available in existing county and health plan data systems shall be collected by counties and health plans and provided to the agency, and performance indicator data available in existing state agency data systems shall be collected by the agency and provided to the counties and health plans. This data shall be reported in a manner and on a schedule determined by the agency, in consultation with the workgroup, but no less frequently than semiannually.
(C)(i)During the first three-year CBH-OAR cycle, performance indicator data reported by each county and health plan shall be used to establish both county and statewide baselines for each performance indicator. The data reported in the first year of the first CBH-OAR cycle shall serve as the county and statewide baselines. After the first review cycle, the agency shall establish standard target thresholds for each performance indicator established by the workgroup.
(ii)The agency, in consultation with the workgroup, shall develop a process for resolving disputes regarding the establishment of standard target thresholds pursuant to clause (i).
(D)(i)For subsequent reviews, based upon availability of additional data through data sharing agreements, the agency shall consider whether to establish additional performance indicators to advance the intent of this chapter.
(ii)Additional performance indicators shall also be subject to the process described in subparagraph (C) and shall include consideration of when data on the additional performance indicators will be available for reporting, if not already available.
(E)If, during subsequent reviews, there is sufficient reason to establish statewide performance standards for one or more outcome measures, the agency may establish those standards for each of the agreed-upon outcome measures.
(3)(A)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process component of the CBH-OAR, as established by the workgroup, shall require county behavioral health agencies and health plans to assess their performance on the established performance indicators, identify the strengths and weaknesses in their current practice and resource deployment, and identify and describe how operational decisions and systemic factors affect program outcomes as described in paragraph (4).
(ii)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be designed to identify areas of best practices for replication and for system improvement and shall guide the development of the county and health plan system improvement plan.
(B)(i)The county and health plan system needs assessment process shall be completed by the county and health plans, in consultation and collaboration with stakeholders, and submitted to the agency every three years.
(ii)(I)Counties shall convene local stakeholders, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(ia)County behavioral health directors, supervisors, and caseworkers.
(ib)Consumers and family members of consumers.
(ic)Health plans operating in the county.
(id)Hospitals.
(ie)Local educational agencies.
(if)Law enforcement.
(ig)Child welfare agencies.
(ih)County-contracted providers.
(ii)Other county behavioral health agency partners.
(II)To the extent possible and relevant, local stakeholders shall also include representatives from tribal organizations and the local behavioral health board.
(III)Additional specific county behavioral health agency partners shall be determined by the county and may include, but are not limited to, adult education providers, providers of services for survivors of domestic violence, the local housing continuum of care, county human service departments, county drug and alcohol programs, and community-based service providers, as appropriate.
(iii)Health plans shall convene stakeholders, including, but not limited to, providers, hospitals, enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, parents of child enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, and a representative sample of county behavioral health departments from their service area.
(4)(A)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall include the uniform elements established by the workgroup pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(B)(i)The county and health plan system improvement plan shall be completed every three years by the county and health plan.
(ii)A countys system improvement plan shall be approved in public session by the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, and be submitted to the agency. Prior to being presented to the countys board of supervisors or chief elected official, as applicable, for approval, the countys system improvement plan shall be presented to the local behavioral health board or equivalent body. A health plans system improvement plan shall be approved by its board of directors.
(C)(i)A countys system improvement plan shall include a services peer review element, conducted by peer counties, the purpose of which is to provide additional insight, including collaborative training on best practices and technical assistance by peer counties.
(ii)Health plans are not required to participate in a peer review process.
(D)The county behavioral health agency or health plan shall complete an annual progress report on the status of its system improvement plan and shall submit these reports to the agency.
(d)(1)(A)The agency shall receive, review, and, based on its determination of whether the county or health plan system improvement plan meets the required elements, certify as complete all submitted performance indicator data, county and health plans self-assessments, county and health plan system improvement plans, and annual progress reports.
(B)The agency shall identify and promote the replication of best practices in service delivery to achieve the established process and outcome measures.
(C)The agency shall monitor, on an ongoing basis, county performance on the performance indicators developed pursuant to subdivision (c).
(D)The agency may assign the duties outlined in paragraphs (A) through (C), inclusive, to the State Department of Health Care Services, the Department of Managed Health Care, and the Department of Insurance, as appropriate.
(2)The agency shall, on an annual basis, beginning July 1, 2026, submit a report to the Legislature that summarizes county or health plan performance on the established performance indicators during the reporting period, analyzes county performance trends over time, and makes findings and recommendations for common service improvements identified in the county and health plan system assessments and system improvement plans, including information on common statutory, regulatory, or fiscal barriers identified as inhibiting system improvements and recommendations to overcome those barriers.
(3)(A)(i)If the contract is executed pursuant to subdivision (f), the agency shall, in partnership with the University of California, facilitate the provision of technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans that supports the countys or health plans selected areas for improvement as described in its system improvement plan.
(ii)The agency and the University of California shall not be considered peers in the county peer review element, and their role shall be limited to providing technical assistance.
(B)If the agency determines, in the course of its review of county and health plan system improvement plans and annual updates or in the course of its review of regularly submitted performance indicator data, that a county or health plan is consistently failing to meet the performance indicator standard target thresholds established pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the agency shall engage the county or health plan in a process of targeted technical assistance and support to address and resolve the identified shortcomings.
(e)A county shall execute and fulfill components of its system improvement plan that can be accomplished with existing resources.
(f)The agency shall request the University of California to enter into a contract with the state to provide all of the following services:
(1)(A)(i)Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans and provided to the state may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes.
(ii)The analysis shall be delivered to the agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup established pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) on or before July 1, 2026, and shall include recommended life outcome measures and measures of the reduction of the negative outcomes described in subdivision (d) of Section 5840 that address prevention and early intervention strategies for mental illness and measures of employment, educational attainment, program exits and program reentries, adherence to treatment plans, attainment of housing, reduction in contacts with law enforcement, reduction in hospitalizations, and reductions in homelessness.
(B)The analysis required to be delivered to the Legislature pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(2)Create and maintain a dashboard modeled after the California Child Welfare Indicators Project to publicly report the data collected by counties and health plans and to report the status of performance indicators as described in this section.
(3)Consult with the agency to provide technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans as described in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (d).
5744.(a)Effective no later than July 1, 2026, the California Health and Human Services Agency, in consultation with the Department of Managed Health Care, the State Department of Health Care Services, and the Department of Insurance, shall establish a risk corridor structure applying to all health payers who provide behavioral health services in California. Under this structure, the risk sharing of costs shall include a requirement that these health payers are required to spend at least 20 percent of their provider health payments on behavioral health services.
(b)The above percentage of provider health payments on behavioral health services shall be adjusted annually based on an estimate of the prevalence rate of behavioral health conditions among a health payers enrollee population and an estimate of the disease burden as measured by financial cost for this estimated enrollee group.
(c)A health payer specified above can meet its spending obligation on behavioral health services under this risk corridor structure in a variety of ways, including provider reimbursement payments, incentive payments intended to improve the quality of behavioral health service delivery, or other innovative investments in the provision of behavioral health services.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 5600.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5600.4.Community mental health services should be organized to provide an array of treatment options in the following areas, to the extent resources are available:(a)Precrisis and Crisis Services. Immediate response to individuals in precrisis and crisis and to members of the individuals support system, on a 24-hour, seven-day-a-week basis. Crisis services may be provided offsite through mobile services. The focus of precrisis services is to offer ideas and strategies to improve the persons situation, and help access what is needed to avoid crisis. The focus of crisis services is stabilization and crisis resolution, assessment of precipitating and attending factors, and recommendations for meeting identified needs.(b)Comprehensive Evaluation and Assessment. Includes, but is not limited to, evaluation and assessment of physical and mental health, income support, housing, vocational training and employment, and social support services needs. Evaluation and assessment may be provided offsite through mobile services.(c)Individual Service Plan. Identification of the short- and long-term service needs of the individual, advocating for, and coordinating the provision of these services. The development of the plan should include the participation of the client, family members, friends, and providers of services to the client, as appropriate.(d)Medication Education and Management. Includes, but is not limited to, evaluation of the need for administration of, and education about, the risks and benefits associated with medication. Clients should be provided this information prior to the administration of medications pursuant to state law. To the extent practicable, families and caregivers should also be informed about medications.(e)Case Management. Client-specific services that assist clients in gaining access to needed medical, social, educational, and other services. Case management may be provided offsite through mobile services.(f)Twenty-four Hour Treatment Services. Treatment provided in any of the following: an acute psychiatric hospital, an acute psychiatric unit of a general hospital, a psychiatric health facility, a psychiatric residential treatment facility, an institute for mental disease, a community treatment facility, or community residential treatment programs, including crisis, transitional and long-term programs.(g)Rehabilitation and Support Services. Treatment and rehabilitation services designed to stabilize symptoms, and to develop, improve, and maintain the skills and supports necessary to live in the community. These services may be provided through various modes of services, including, but not limited to, individual and group counseling, day treatment programs, collateral contacts with friends and family, and peer counseling programs. These services may be provided offsite through mobile services.(h)Vocational Rehabilitation. Services that provide a range of vocational services to assist individuals to prepare for, obtain, and maintain employment.(i)Residential Services. Room and board and 24-hour care and supervision.(j)Services for Homeless Persons. Services designed to assist mentally ill persons who are homeless, or at risk of being homeless, to secure housing and financial resources.(k)Group Services. Services to two or more clients at the same time.Community mental health services should be organized to provide an array of treatment options in the following areas, to the extent resources are available:
(a)Precrisis and Crisis Services. Immediate response to individuals in precrisis and crisis and to members of the individuals support system, on a 24-hour, seven-day-a-week basis. Crisis services may be provided offsite through mobile services. The focus of precrisis services is to offer ideas and strategies to improve the persons situation, and help access what is needed to avoid crisis. The focus of crisis services is stabilization and crisis resolution, assessment of precipitating and attending factors, and recommendations for meeting identified needs.
(b)Comprehensive Evaluation and Assessment. Includes, but is not limited to, evaluation and assessment of physical and mental health, income support, housing, vocational training and employment, and social support services needs. Evaluation and assessment may be provided offsite through mobile services.
(c)Individual Service Plan. Identification of the short- and long-term service needs of the individual, advocating for, and coordinating the provision of these services. The development of the plan should include the participation of the client, family members, friends, and providers of services to the client, as appropriate.
(d)Medication Education and Management. Includes, but is not limited to, evaluation of the need for administration of, and education about, the risks and benefits associated with medication. Clients should be provided this information prior to the administration of medications pursuant to state law. To the extent practicable, families and caregivers should also be informed about medications.
(e)Case Management. Client-specific services that assist clients in gaining access to needed medical, social, educational, and other services. Case management may be provided offsite through mobile services.
(f)Twenty-four Hour Treatment Services. Treatment provided in any of the following: an acute psychiatric hospital, an acute psychiatric unit of a general hospital, a psychiatric health facility, a psychiatric residential treatment facility, an institute for mental disease, a community treatment facility, or community residential treatment programs, including crisis, transitional and long-term programs.
(g)Rehabilitation and Support Services. Treatment and rehabilitation services designed to stabilize symptoms, and to develop, improve, and maintain the skills and supports necessary to live in the community. These services may be provided through various modes of services, including, but not limited to, individual and group counseling, day treatment programs, collateral contacts with friends and family, and peer counseling programs. These services may be provided offsite through mobile services.
(h)Vocational Rehabilitation. Services which that provide a range of vocational services to assist individuals to prepare for, obtain, and maintain employment.
(i)Residential Services. Room and board and 24-hour care and supervision.
(j)Services for Homeless Persons. Services designed to assist mentally ill persons who are homeless, or at risk of being homeless, to secure housing and financial resources.
(k)Group Services. Services to two or more clients at the same time.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (July 2). |
| Jun 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 25). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 12, 2024 | Re-referred to Coms. on PUB S. and JUD. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Senate Rules Suspended |
| Jun 27, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 1982.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 18). |
| May 3, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (April 11). |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 7, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 9. |
| Feb 6, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 459 Haney Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Attorney General Rob Bonta | ** Support | |
| California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions | ** Support | |
| California Council Of Community Behavioral Health Agencies | ** Support | |
| California State Sheriffs Association | ** Against | |
| Health Access California | ** Support | |
| The Kennedy Forum | ** Support | |
| The Steinberg Institute | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 459 (Kalra) - Peace officers: Attorney General: reports
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 459 modifies requirements for reporting stop data to the California Department of Justice (DOJ).
Fiscal Impact:
- Significant onetime and ongoing costs (General Fund) to the California Highway Patrol of approximately $3 million dollars annually. CHP submits approximately 2.5 million stops to DOJ annually. CHP notes that this bill will add to workload and financial obligations of the department’s already strained resources.
- CHP estimates approximately $650,000 in IT costs and indicates that the department would constantly need to assess and reassess the IT needs and secure funding for this specific effort, in addition to increasing IT demands.
- CHP indicates that this bill will increase the department’s workload and in order to meet CPRA obligations and manage the increased workload from reviewing and redacting approximately 2.5 million stop data entries. CHP’s Office of Risk Management (ORM) Public Record’s Unit (PRU) processes and discloses CHP’s records under the California Public Records Act (CPRA). This includes reviewing, analyzing, and redacting records to ensure compliance with the law. CHP notes that the ORM’s PRU has experienced an exponential increase in CPRA requests received over the past four years. Currently, the ORM’s PRU only reviews stop data for exempt information in response to CPRA requests. CHP indicates that ORM would require additional staff to meet the requirements of this bill, including 15 AGPAs, three SSM Is, and one SSM II. The estimated costs include salary, benefits, operating/expenses, and IT storage: Year 1 Costs: $2,714,000; Year 2 and ongoing costs: $2,543,000.
- Unknown, significant ongoing costs (General Fund, local funds), in the tens of millions of dollars annually, to local law enforcement agencies for data retention as specified in this bill. To the extent local agency expenditures qualify as a reimbursable state mandate, agencies could claim reimbursement of those costs. Such costs could vary. For context, the Commission on State Mandates’ statewide cost estimate for Crime Statistics Reports for the DOJ reflects eligible reimbursement of over $13.6 million per year for slightly over 50% of local agencies reporting.
Background:
AB 953 (Weber) Chapter 466, Statutes of 2015, also known as the Racial and Identity Profiling Act (RIPA) of 2015, expressly prohibited racial and identity profiling by law enforcement and required local and state law enforcement agencies to annually report vehicle and pedestrian stop data to the DOJ. Generally, all of the data collected and reported by law enforcement agencies to the DOJ are public records for the purpose of the CPRA. Existing law provides that agencies shall not report any personal identifying information (PII) of persons stopped, and specifies that the badge number and other identifying information of peace officers involved in stops is not disclosable. Moreover, existing law expressly states that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that the PII is not transmitted to the DOJ.
According to the DOJ, the data sets on stops received from law enforcement agencies frequently contain errors, incomplete submissions, or PII of individuals stopped or the law enforcement officers making the stops. This often leads to the DOJ being unable to remedy those errors in time for transmittal to the RIPA Board for their annual report or rejecting data access requests due to privacy and liability concerns.
Proposed Law:
- Requires law enforcement agencies to preserve stop data.
- Requires law enforcement agencies to submit their stop data for the preceding calendar year to the DOJ by March 1.
- Provides that, if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agency’s submission to the DOJ, the agency must submit its stop data semiannually the following calendar year.
- Specifies that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that PII and other information exempt from disclosure is not transmitted to the DOJ in a narrative field.
- Provides that stop data reported to the DOJ can only be made available to the public by the reporting law enforcement agency and not the DOJ.
- Provides that that the DOJ is not liable for the disclosure by another entity of PII of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure.
- Requires DOJ to provide all stop data reported, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement.
- States that the DOJ shall not provide data to a public or private entity unless the entity agrees not to disclose PI or individuals and unique identifying information of peace officers, as specified.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 459 (Author:Kalra)
Version: June 10, 2024
Hearing Date: July 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Peace officers: Attorney General: reports
DIGEST
This bill modifies the timeline that law enforcement agencies must comply with when reporting stop data to the California Department of Justice (DOJ), and specifies that data reported in an open text or narrative field is only available under a request made pursuant to the California Public Records Act (CPRA) from the reporting agency and not from DOJ. The bill requires the Attorney General to share the data with entities conducting specified research, and provides that the DOJ is not liable for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In 2015, the Legislature passed AB 953 (Weber, Ch. 466, Stats. of 2015), also known as the Racial and Identity Profiling Act (RIPA) of 2015, which expressly prohibited racial and identity profiling by law enforcement and required law enforcement agencies to annually report vehicle and pedestrian stop data to the DOJ. This bill seeks to address two issues that the DOJ has encountered in trying to enforce RIPA. First, the bill establishes a new reporting timeline that requires each agency’s final stop reports to be submitted by March 1; however, if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agency’s submission, that agency must submit semiannually for the following calendar year. Second, the bill provides that open text fields are still publicly available under the CPRA, but only from the reporting agency, who would be responsible for redacting any personal identifying information that the agency included in any RIPA dataset. The bill is sponsored by the Attorney General, Rob Bonta. The bill is opposed by the California State Sheriffs’ Association. The bill passed the Senate Public Safety Committee on a vote of 4 to 1. This analysis will focus on the issues in the jurisdiction of this Committee, mainly the provision related to public records, privacy concerns surrounding sharing data, and the limitation on liability.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy. (Cal. const. art I. § 1.)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies are required to be open to public scrutiny. (Cal. const. art. I, § 3(b)(1).)
- Requires a statute to be broadly construed if it furthers the people’s right of access, and narrowly construed if it limits the right of access. (Cal. const. art. I, § 3(b)(1).)
- Requires a statute that limits the public’s right of access to be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest. (Cal. const. art. I, § 3(b)(1).)
- Governs the disclosure of information collected and maintained by public agencies pursuant to the CPRA. (Gov. Code §§ 7920.000 et seq.)
- States that, the Legislature, mindful of the right of individuals to privacy, finds and declares that access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Gov. Code § 7921.000.)
- Defines “public records” as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code § 7920.530.)
- Defines “public agency” as any state or local agency. (Gov. Code § 7920.525(a).)
- Provides that all public records are open to inspection at all times during the office hours of a state or local agency and every person has a right to inspect any public record, unless the record is exempt from public disclosure. Any reasonably segregable portion of a record shall be available for inspection by any person requesting the record after deletion of the portions that are exempted by law. (Gov. Code § 7922.525.)
- Some records are prohibited from being disclosed and other records are permissively exempted from being disclosed. (See e.g. Gov. Code §§ 7920.505 & 7922.200.)
- There are several general categories of documents or information that are permissively exempt from disclosure under the CPRA essentially due to the character of the information. The exempt information can be withheld by the public agency with custody of the information, but it also may be disclosed if it is shown that the public’s interest in disclosure outweighs the public’s interest in non-disclosure of the information. (CBS, Inc. v. Block (1986) 42 Cal.3d 646, at 652.).
- Finds and declares that pedestrians, users of public transportation, and vehicular occupants who have been stopped, searched, interrogated, and subjected to a property seizure by a peace officer for no reason other than the color of their skin, national origin, religion, gender identity or expression, housing status, sexual orientation, or mental or physical disability are the victims of discriminatory practices (Pen. Code § 13519.4(d)(4).)
- Establishes the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA), which, among other duties, is required to conduct and consult available, evidence-based research on intentional and implicit biases, and law enforcement stop, search, and seizure tactics. (Pen. Code § 13519.4(j)(3)(D).)
- Prohibits a peace officer from engaging in racial or identity profiling, as defined. (Pen. Code § 13519.4(e),(f).)
- Requires each state and local agency that employs peace officers to annually report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by that agency’s peace officers for the preceding calendar year. (Gov. Code § 12525.5(a)(1).)
- Establishes a timeline for the reporting of stop data by law enforcement agencies to the Attorney General, with larger agencies required to begin reporting by 2018, and progressively smaller agencies required to begin reporting on an annual basis until the smallest agencies are required to report by 2022. (Gov. Code § 12525.5(a)(2).)
- Requires reports on stops submitted to the Attorney General to include, at a minimum, the following information:
- The time, date, and location of the stop.
- The reason for the stop.
- The reason given to the person at the time of the stop.
- The result of the stop, such as: no action, warning, citation, arrest, etc.
- If a warning or citation was issued, the warning provided or the violation cited.
- If an arrest was made, the offense charged.
- The perceived race or ethnicity, gender, and approximate age of the person stopped. For motor vehicle stops, this paragraph only applies to the driver unless the officer took actions with regard to the passenger.
- Actions taken by the peace officer, as specified. (Gov. Code §1 2525.5(b)(1)-(8).)
- Provides that if more than one peace officer performs a stop, only one officer is required to collect and report to the officer’s agency the information specified above. (Gov. Code § 12525.5(c).)
- Prohibits law enforcement agencies from reporting personal identifying information (PII) of the individuals stopped, searched, or subjected to a property seizure, and that all other information in the reports, except for unique identifying information of the officer involved, is available to the public. (Gov. Code § 12525.5(d).)
- Provides that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that PII of the individual stopped or any other information that is exempt from disclosure is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an open text field. (Gov. Code § 12525.5(d).)
- Specifies that all data and reports made pursuant to the above provisions are public records and are open to public inspection pursuant to the CPRA (Gov. Code § 12525.5(e).)
- Defines “stop,” for the purposes of reports sent by law enforcement agencies to the Attorney General, as any detention by a peace officer of a person, or any peace officer interaction with a person in which the peace officer conducts a search, including a consensual search, of the person’s body or property in the person’s possession or control. (Gov. Code § 12525.5(g)(2).)
- Defines “personal identifying information” as any name, address, telephone number, health insurance number, taxpayer identification number, school identification number, state or federal driver's license, or identification number, social security number, place of employment, employee identification number, professional or occupational number, mother's maiden name, demand deposit account number, savings account number, checking account number, PIN (personal identification number) or password, United States Citizenship and Immigration Services-assigned number, government passport number, date of birth, unique biometric data including fingerprint, facial scan identifiers, voiceprint, retina or iris image, or other unique physical representation, unique electronic data including information identification number assigned to the person, address or routing code, telecommunication identifying information or access device, information contained in a birth or death certificate, or credit card number of an individual person, or an equivalent form of identification. (Pen. Code §530.55(b).)
This bill:
- Requires law enforcement agencies, in addition to reporting stop data under existing law, to preserve the data, and requires submittal of their final stop reports to the Attorney General by March 1 for the preceding calendar year.
- Provides that, if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agency’s submission to the Attorney General, the agency must submit semiannually for the following calendar year.
- The Attorney General is required to provide notice to the agency by October 1, with the semiannual requirement taking effect as of January 1.
- Specifies that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that personally identifiable information (PII) of the individual stopped or any other info exempt from disclosure is not transmitted to the Attorney General in a narrative field.
- Requires that any data reported in an open text or narrative field only be made available to the public by the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. However, the Attorney General is required to provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement, and is required to issue regulations governing how the data is provided pursuant to this provision.
- Provides that that the Department of Justice is not liable for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
In 2015, the Legislature passed AB 953 (Weber, Chapter 466), which established the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory (RIPA) Board to eliminate racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. Under existing law, reporting agencies such as local law enforcement and the CHP, are required to annually report data on stops conducted to the DOJ.
Unfortunately, these data sets frequently contain errors, incomplete submissions, or personally identifiable information of individuals stopped or the law enforcement officers making the stops. This often leads to the DOJ being unable to remedy those errors in time for transmittal to the RIPA Board for their annual report or rejecting data access requests due to privacy and liability concerns.
AB 459 would ensure more timely and comprehensive data verification through a performance-based mechanism and improve the availability of RIPA data. Specifically, this bill updates reporting deadlines and makes clarifying changes regarding access to RIPA data open text fields reported by law enforcement.
- Background on RIPA and the need to address public records requests for open text data fields
The Senate Public Safety Committee analysis of this bill provides a useful explanation about RIPA and the issues this bill seeks to remedy:
In 2015, the Legislature passed AB 953 (Weber, Ch. 466, Stats. of 2015), also known as the Racial and Identity Profiling Act (RIPA) of 2015, which expressly prohibited racial and identity profiling by law enforcement and required law enforcement agencies to annually report vehicle and pedestrian stop data to the DOJ. Under AB 953, agencies were required to begin reporting on a staggered timeline, with the largest agencies required to submit their first reports to DOJ by April 1, 2019, and the smallest agencies submitting by April 1, 2023. For the latest RIPA report, published January 1, 2024 and marking the fifth year of RIPA stop data reporting, all 560 law enforcement agencies in California were required to report data. A total of 535 law enforcement agencies in California collected data on 4,575,725 pedestrian and vehicle stops conducted from January 1 to December 31, 2022, and the remaining 25 law enforcement agencies reported zero stops for the 2022 reporting year. Existing law defines “stop” as “any detention by a peace officer of a person, or any peace officer interaction with a person in which the peace officer conducts a search, including a consensual search, of the person’s body or property in the person’s possession or control.”[…]
Generally, all of the data collected and reported by law enforcement agencies to DOJ per the above are deemed to be public records for the purpose of the CPRA and must be made available to the public. […] Specifically, existing law provides that agencies shall not report any personal identifying information (PII) of persons stopped, and specifies that the badge number and other identifying information of peace officers involved in stops is not disclosable. Moreover, existing law expressly states that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that PII is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an “open text” field.
According to the sponsor of the bill, Attorney General Rob Bonta:
[…][F]ollowing the recent completion of the 2023 RIPA data reporting period on April 1, 2024, 14% of reporting agencies submitted data with higher rates of errors or incomplete submissions that could not be remedied in time before transmittal to the RIPA Board for their analysis and annual report. In addition, reporting agencies continue to include PII in open text data fields of the RIPA data set, despite years of training, technical assistance, and partnership from DOJ, which has meant that DOJ cannot release that subset of data to the public without the risk of Californians’ PII being disclosed. […]
AB 459 would also address DOJ’s liability concerns regarding PII disclosure in RIPA’s open text data fields by clarifying that open text fields are still publicly available, but only from the reporting agency via a PRA request, who would then be responsible for redacting PII that they have included in any RIPA dataset. The bill would also establish a process similar to other existing disclosure processes (e.g., criminal history, CURES), where researchers can receive access to these open text data fields, as well as all RIPA data from DOJ, when data security can be assured. In the RIPA Board’s 2024 report alone, more than 4.5 million stops by 535 California law enforcement agencies conducted in 2022 were analyzed.
The California State Sheriffs’ Association writes in opposition to the bill noting:
The bill fails to define the terms “reporting issues” and “unresolved errors” meaning that the criteria that would be used by the AG to determine that an agency must increase the frequency of its reporting is unclear. Further, it is possible that whatever issues the AG decides trigger AB 459’s provisions would not necessarily be resolved by more frequent reporting in the subsequent year.
Additionally, the bill removes responsibility to disclose information made public by statute from the AG’s office and places it solely with the reporting agency. This provision, along with the bill’s other requirements, will likely result in increased costs for, and demand more resources from, local law enforcement agencies.
- Access to public records is a fundamental right
Access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Gov. Cod § 7921.000.) In 2004, the right of public access was enshrined in the California Constitution with the passage of Proposition 59 (Nov. 3, 2004, statewide general election),[1] which amended the California Constitution to specifically protect the right of the public to access and obtain government records: “The people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and therefore . . . the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny.” (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 3 (b)(1).) In 2014, voters approved Proposition 42 (Jun. 3, 2014, statewide direct primary election)[2] to further increase public access to government records by requiring local agencies to comply with the CPRA and the Ralph M. Brown Act[3], and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, as provided. (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 3 (b)(7).)
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless they are exempt from disclosure. (Gov. Cod § 7922.252.) A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business that is prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code § 7920.530.) There are several general categories of documents or information that are permissively exempt from disclosure under the CPRA essentially due to the character of the information. The exempt information can be withheld by the public agency with custody of the information, but it also may be disclosed if it is shown that the public’s interest in disclosure outweighs the public’s interest in non-disclosure of the information. (CBS, Inc. v. Block (1986) 42 Cal.3d 646, at 652.). Additionally, some records are prohibited from disclosure or are specifically stated to not be public records. (see Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).)
California generally recognizes that public access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right.[4] At the same time, the state recognizes that this right must be balanced against the right to privacy.[5] The general right of access to public records may, therefore, be limited when records include personal information. This bill affects access to public records by not allowing a member of the public to access data reported in an open text or narrative field in the possession of the DOJ from the DOJ. The bill instead requires a record request for that data to be made to the law enforcement agency that provided that data to the DOJ. This provision is antithetical to the basic principle of the CPRA that a state agency that is in possession of public records is required to allow the public access to them. The DOJ argues that they cannot provide this data to a requester due to the fact that local law enforcement agencies are including PII in the data sets, and because of the enormous volume of data that the DOJ would have to review for potential redaction of PII before disclosing under the CPRA. They claim that a single year’s worth of open text or narrative field data could involve over 4 million individual stops, and that they simply do not have the resources or man power to review every piece of data individually to redact it for potential PII that was left in by the reporting law enforcement agency. It should be noted, that there were over 500 law enforcement agencies that reported data to the DOJ under RIPA. This means that if someone wanted to get all the data reported to the DOJ, they would have to make 500 plus individual records requests. However, since the DOJ is not releasing this information currently a member of the public who wants this information has to seek it from the reporting law enforcement agency anyways.
- Limitation on liability and privacy concerns on sharing data
The bill requires the Attorney General to provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. Under the bill, the Attorney General must issue regulations governing how the data is provided to the public and private entities. This requirement to share data does not include any guardrails for protecting the information once it is shared with other entities. There is no requirement that the other entities agree to keep the data confidential, only use the data for the purpose for which it was shared, or that the public entities ensure that when the data is reproduced or published it is not done in way that could lead to PII being disclosed. (see Health & Saf. Code § 121022.) There is also no penalty provided for an entity that discloses any PII it receives. (see Health & Saf. Code § 121025.)
As the Attorney General notes in his sponsor letter, there are high incidences of PII being included in the open text or narrative fields and that this is the reason the DOJ is seeking the ability to not have to release this information pursuant to a public record request. Further to this point, the Attorney General is seeking a limitation on liability for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure. If the issue surrounding PII in open text or narrative fields is so severe to warrant changing the fundamental premise of the CPRA, it seems only prudent that strong confidentiality protections be included with the requirement to share RIPA data with public and private entities conducting research.
- Constitutional Considerations
In 2016, the Legislature created and funded the California Firearm Violence Research Center (hereinafter, “the Center”) at the University of California, Davis with the goal of developing research to prevent gun violence and inform public policymaking regarding firearms.[6] In creating the Center, the Legislature also mandated that several state agencies, including the DOJ, provide the Center with data necessary for it to conduct its research. Shortly thereafter, the DOJ began restricting the Center’s access to certain data, citing privacy concerns, and in response, the Legislature passed AB 173 (Committee on Budget, Ch. 253, Stats. of 2021), which reiterated the duty of the DOJ to provide the Center with requested data.
In 2022, a group of gun owners filed lawsuits in both state and federal court challenging AB 173 on several grounds, including that the law violates, or at least chills, their Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms and that it violates privacy and due process protections guaranteed to them by the Fourteenth Amendment. The San Diego Superior Court ruled in October 2022 that the state was prohibited from sharing the plaintiffs’ personal information and granted the plaintiffs’ request for a preliminary injunction. However, in November 2023, the Fourth Appellate Circuit of the California Court of Appeal ruled in an unpublished case that even if the plaintiffs met the threshold inquiries to establish a privacy claim, the trial court did not adequately balance the privacy concerns of the plaintiffs against the legitimate countervailing interest asserted by the Attorney General.[7] While the Second Amendment issue in the case does not apply to this bill, the privacy concerns raised may be similarly implicated by this bill. Though the Attorney General was victorious in the case described above, it is no guarantee that this bill will be immune to a similar constitutional challenge.
- Amendments
The specific amendments to address the concerns about the lack of confidentiality protections surrounding the requirement to share RIPA data with public and private entities conducting research:
Amendment[8]
Section 12525.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:
[…]
(d) (1) State and local law enforcement agencies shall not report the name, address, social security number, or other unique personal identifying information of persons stopped, searched, or subjected to a property seizure, for purposes of this section. Law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that personally identifiable information of the individual stopped or any other information that is exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an open text or narrative field.
(2) Notwithstanding any other law, the data reported shall be available to the public, except for the badge number or other unique identifying information of the peace officer involved. Any data reported in an open text or narrative field shall only be made available by the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. However,
(3) Notwithstanding paragraph (2), the Attorney General shall provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement.
- The Attorney General shall not provide data to a public or private entity under this paragraph unless the entity agrees to all of the following:
- The entity shall not disclose any personally identifying information of individuals stopped or unique identifying information of the peace officer involved and shall keep that information confidential.
- The entity shall only be authorized to use the data for the purposes for which it was shared.
- The entity shall ensure that any publication of the data is done in a manner to prevent the release of personally identifying information and unique identifying information.
(B) The Attorney General shall issue regulations governing how the data is provided to the public and private entities.
(3) (4) Notwithstanding any other law, the Department of Justice shall not be liable for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section.
SUPPORT
Attorney General Rob Bonta
OPPOSITION
California State Sheriff’s Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation: AB 953 (Weber, Ch. 466, Stats. of 2015) see Comment 2), above.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Public Safety (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 79, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 15, Noes 0)
Assembly Health Committee (Ayes 15, Noes 0)
**************
Prop. 59 was placed on the ballot by a unanimous vote of both houses of the Legislature. (SCA 1 (Burton, Ch. 1, Stats. 2004)) ↑
Prop. 42 was placed on the ballot by a unanimous vote of both houses of the Legislature. (SCA 3 (Leno, Ch. 123, Stats. 2013)) ↑
The Ralph M. Brown Act is the open meetings laws that applies to local agencies. (Gov. Code §§ 59450 et. seq.) ↑
Cal. Const., art. I, § 3; Gov. Code, § 7921.000. ↑
Cal. Const., art. I, § 1. ↑
California Penal Code §14230 et. seq. ↑
Barba v. Bonta (2023) WL 7980426(Super. Ct. No. 37-2022- 00003676-CU-CR-CTL) p. 3, available at https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/nonpub/D081194.PDF. ↑
The amendments may also include technical, nonsubstantive changes recommended by the Office of Legislative Counsel. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 459 Hearing Date: June 25, 2024
Author: | Kalra | ||
Version: | June 10, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | AB | ||
Subject: Peace officers: Attorney General: reports
HISTORY
Source: Department of Justice
Prior Legislation: SB 50 (Bradford, 2023), currently on Assembly Inactive File
SB 1389 (Bradford, 2022), died on Senate Inactive File
AB 2773 (Holden, 2022), Ch. 805, Stats. of 2022
AB 953 (Weber, 2015) Ch. 466, Stats. of 2015
AB 2133 (Torrico, 2006), not heard in Assembly Public Safety
SB 1389 (Murray, 2000), held in Senate Appropriations
Support: Unknown
Opposition: California State Sheriffs’ Association
Assembly Floor Vote: N/A
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to modify the timeline that law enforcement agencies must adhere to when reporting stop data to the DOJ and to specify that data reported in an open text or narrative field is only available from the reporting agency and not from DOJ, except as specified.
Existing law provides that the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable seizures and searches may not be violated; and a warrant may not issue except on probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons and things to be seized. (U.S. Const., amend. IV.; Cal. Const., art I, § 13.)
Existing law provides that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny. (Cal. Const., art I, § 3, subd. (b)(1).)
Existing law provides that a statute, court rule, or other authority adopted after the effective date of the above provision that limits the right of access shall be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest. (Cal. Const., art I, § 3, subd. (b)(2).)
Existing law finds and declares that pedestrians, users of public transportation, and vehicular occupants who have been stopped, searched, interrogated, and subjected to a property seizure by a peace officer for no reason other than the color of their skin, national origin, religion, gender identity or expression, housing status, sexual orientation, or mental or physical disability are the victims of discriminatory practices (Penal Code §13519.4(d)(4).)
Existing law creates the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA), which, among other duties, is required to conduct and consult available, evidence-based research on intentional and implicit biases, and law enforcement stop, search, and seizure tactics. (Penal Code §13519.4(j)(3)(D).)
Existing law prohibits a peace officer from engaging in racial or identity profiling, as defined. (Penal Code §13519.4(e),(f).)
Existing law defines “personal identifying information” as any name, address, telephone number, health insurance number, taxpayer identification number, school identification number, state or federal driver's license, or identification number, social security number, place of employment, employee identification number, professional or occupational number, mother's maiden name, demand deposit account number, savings account number, checking account number, PIN (personal identification number) or password, United States Citizenship and Immigration Services-assigned number, government passport number, date of birth, unique biometric data including fingerprint, facial scan identifiers, voiceprint, retina or iris image, or other unique physical representation, unique electronic data including information identification number assigned to the person, address or routing code, telecommunication identifying information or access device, information contained in a birth or death certificate, or credit card number of an individual person, or an equivalent form of identification. (Pen. Code, §530.55, subd. (b).)
Existing law requires each state and local agency that employs peace officers to annually report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by that agency’s peace officers for the preceding calendar year. (Govt. Code §12525.5, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law sets forth a timeline for the reporting of stop data by law enforcement agencies to the Attorney General, with larger agencies required to begin reporting by 2018, and progressively smaller agencies required to begin reporting on an annual basis until the smallest agencies are required to report by 2022. (Govt. Code §12525.5, subd. (a)(2).)
Existing law requires reports on stops submitted to the Attorney General to include, at a minimum, the following information:
- The time, date, and location of the stop.
- The reason for the stop.
- The reason given to the person at the time of the stop.
- The result of the stop, such as: no action, warning, citation, arrest, etc.
- If a warning or citation was issued, the warning provided or the violation cited.
- If an arrest was made, the offense charged.
- The perceived race or ethnicity, gender, and approximate age of the person stopped. For motor vehicle stops, this paragraph only applies to the driver unless the officer took actions with regard to the passenger.
- Actions taken by the peace officer, as specified. (Govt. Code §12525.5(b)(1)-(8).)
Existing law provides that if more than one peace officer performs a stop, only one officer is required to collect and report to the officer’s agency the information specified above. (Govt. Code §12525.5, subd. (c).)
Existing law provides that law enforcement agencies shall not report personal identifying information of the individuals stopped, searched, or subjected to a property seizure, and that all other information in the reports, except for unique identifying information of the officer involved, shall be available to the public. (Govt. Code §12525.5, subd. (d).)
Existing law provides that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that personally identifiable information of the individual stopped or any other information that is exempt from disclosure pursuant to this section is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an open text field. (Govt. Code §12525.5, subd. (d).)
Existing law specifies that all data and reports made pursuant to the above provisions are public records and are open to public inspection pursuant to the California Public Records Act. (Govt. Code §§12525.5(e), 7920.000 et. seq.)
Existing law defines “stop,” for the purposes of reports sent by law enforcement agencies to the Attorney General, as ‘any detention by a peace officer of a person, or any peace officer interaction with a person in which the peace officer conducts a search, including a consensual search, of the person’s body or property in the person’s possession or control.’ (Government Code §12525.5(g)(2).)
This bill provides that in addition to reporting stop data under existing law, law enforcement agencies must preserve said data, and shall submit their final stop reports to the Attorney General by March 1 for the preceding calendar year.
This bill strikes the provision of existing law enacting the staggered reporting timeline.
This bill provides that if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agency’s submission to the Attorney General, the agency shall submit semiannually for the following calendar year. The Attorney General shall provide notice to the agency by October 1, with the semiannual requirement taking effect as of January 1.
This bill provides that semiannual agency reports required per the above shall be submitted by September 1 and March 1 of each year. The final reports on all stops conducted from January 1 to June 30 shall be submitted by September 1, and the final reports on all stops conducted from July 1 to December 31 shall be submitted by March 1.
This bill specifies that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that personally identifiable information of the individual stopped or any other info exempt from disclosure is not transmitted to the Attorney General in a narrative field.
This bill specifies that any data reported in an open text or narrative field shall only be made available by the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General.
This bill provides that despite the provision immediately above, the Attorney General shall provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational, advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement., and shall issue regulations governing how the data is provided pursuant to this provision.
This bill states that the Department of Justice shall not be liable for the disclosure by another entity of personally identifiable information of the individual stopped, unique identifying information of the peace officer, or any other information exempt from disclosure.
This bill sets forth several legislative findings and declarations, including a finding demonstrating the interest protected by the limitations on public access to the writings of public agencies in the bill and the need for protecting that interest.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the Author:
In 2015, the Legislature passed AB 953 (Weber, Chapter 466), which established the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory (RIPA) Board to eliminate racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. Under existing law, reporting agencies such as local law enforcement and the CHP, are required to annually report data on stops conducted to the DOJ.
Unfortunately, these data sets frequently contain errors, incomplete submissions, or personally identifiable information of individuals stopped or the law enforcement officers making the stops. This often leads to the DOJ being unable to remedy those errors in time for transmittal to the RIPA Board for their annual report or rejecting data access requests due to privacy and liability concerns.
AB 459 would ensure more timely and comprehensive data verification through a performance-based mechanism and improve the availability of RIPA data. Specifically, this bill updates reporting deadlines and makes clarifying changes regarding access to RIPA data open text fields reported by law enforcement.
- The Public’s Right to Law Enforcement Records Generally
In 1968, the Legislature passed the California Public Records Act (CPRA), declaring that “access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in the state.”[1] The purpose of the CPRA is to prevent secrecy in government and to contribute significantly to the public understanding of government activities.[2] Under the law, virtually all public records are open to public inspection unless express exempted in statute. However, even if a record is not expressly exempted, an agency may refuse to disclose records if on balance, the interest of nondisclosure outweighs disclosure. Generally, “records should be withheld from disclosure only where the public interest served by not making a record public outweighs the public interest served by the general policy of disclosure.”[3]
In the context of law enforcement agencies, the CPRA expressly and generally “does not require the disclosure of records of complaints to, or investigations conducted by, or records of intelligence information or security procedures of” the DOJ, any state or local law enforcement agency, and other specified agencies.[4] Notwithstanding that general rule, the CPRA requires the disclosure of specified personal identifying information and investigatory records related to 1) any misdemeanor or felony incident, 2) any arrest made by the agency, and 3) any request for service made to the agency and the response to that request.[5]
Records related to peace officers enjoy greater protection under CPRA and in many cases are altogether exempt from disclosure; specific exemptions to the general policy requiring disclosure in the context of peace officer records include 1) records of complaints to, or investigations conducted by any state or local police agency, 2) personnel records, if disclosure would constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy, and 3) records, the disclosure of which is exempted or prohibited pursuant to federal or state law, including records deemed confidential under state law.[6] Recent legislation has vastly expanded the public’s access to previously confidential peace officer personal records, particularly those that fall into specified categories.[7] However, this legislation also required agencies to redact specified personal information, the release of which ““would cause an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy that clearly outweighs the strong public interest in records about possible misconduct,” and information that, if unredacted, would pose a significant danger to the physical safety of the peace officer or another person.[8]
- Racial and Identity Profiling Act (RIPA) Data and Reporting
In 2015, the Legislature passed AB 953 (Weber, Ch. 466, Stats. of 2015), also known as the Racial and Identity Profiling Act (RIPA) of 2015, which expressly prohibited racial and identity profiling by law enforcement and required law enforcement agencies to annually report vehicle and pedestrian stop data to the DOJ. Under AB 953, agencies were required to begin reporting on a staggered timeline, with the largest agencies required to submit their first reports to DOJ by April 1, 2019, and the smallest agencies submitting by April 1, 2023. For the latest RIPA report, published January 1, 2024 and marking the fifth year of RIPA stop data reporting, all 560 law enforcement agencies in California were required to report data. A total of 535 law enforcement agencies in California collected data on 4,575,725 pedestrian and vehicle stops conducted from January 1 to December 31, 2022, and the remaining 25 law enforcement agencies reported zero stops for the 2022 reporting year.[9] Existing law defines “stop” as “any detention by a peace officer of a person, or any peace officer interaction with a person in which the peace officer conducts a search, including a consensual search, of the person’s body or property in the person’s possession or control.”[10]
Under existing law, agencies are required to report, at a minimum, the following information for each pedestrian, traffic, or any other type of stop:
- The time, date, and location of the stop.
- The reason for the stop.
- The reason given to the person stopped at the time of the stop.
- The result of the stop, such as, no action, warning, citation, property seizure, or arrest.
- If a warning or citation was issued, the warning provided or violation cited.
- If an arrest was made, the offense charged.
- The perceived race or ethnicity, gender, and approximate age of the person stopped, as specified.
- Actions taken by the peace officer during the stop, as specified.
Generally, all of the data collected and reported by law enforcement agencies to DOJ per the above are deemed to be public records for the purpose of the CPRA and must be made available to the public. However, as explained further below, existing law proscribes the reporting of personal identifying information pertaining to both the individuals stopped and the officers involved.[11]
- Effect of This Bill
This bill contains two major operative components. The first relates to the timeline that law enforcement agencies must adhere to when reporting data to the DOJ. Existing law, which has not been amended since the first reports began, requires each state and local agency that employs peace officers to “annually report to the Attorney General data on all stops conducted by that agency’s peace officers for the preceding calendar year.” According to the Author, that timeline has proved problematic:
Following the completion of the 2023 Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory (RIPA) date reporting period on April 1, 2024, 14% of RIPA reporting agencies submitted data with errors or incomplete submissions that could not be remedied in time before transmittal to the RIPA Board for their analysis and annual report. Furthermore, in the prior reporting year, an additional 19,186 new stops were submitted after the reporting deadline had passed. […] Currently, approximately 89 percent of reporting agencies (480 of 560) voluntarily submit to DOJ more frequently than annually, but without a consistent statewide standard, a number of the largest reporting agencies only submit annually, and close to the April 1st due date.
Accordingly, this bill establishes a new reporting timeline, requiring each agency’s final stop reports to be submitted by March 1. However, if reporting issues or unresolved errors are identified in an agency’s submission, that agency must submit semiannually for the following calendar year, with reports due by September 1 (covering data from Jan 1 to June 30) and March 1 (covering data from July 1 to December 31) of each year.
The second component of this bill relates to personal identifying information that is often improperly reported to DOJ despite existing requirements that law enforcement agencies ensure that that information is not transmitted to DOJ. Specifically, existing law provides that agencies shall not report any personal identifying information (PII) of persons stopped, and specifies that the badge number and other identifying information of peace officers involved in stops is not disclosable. Moreover, existing law expressly states that law enforcement agencies are solely responsible for ensuring that PII is not transmitted to the Attorney General in an “open text” field. According to the Author, despite these mandates, PII-related reporting problems persist:
Reporting agencies continue to include PII in the open text data fields of the RIPA data set despite training, technical assistance, and partnership with the DOJ. This has led to data being unavailable to the public due to privacy and liability concerns, as well as limited resources for the DOJ to review and redact millions of reports that may contain PII.
This bill clarifies that the reporting agency’s responsibility to prevent the transmittal of PII also extends to “narrative” fields filled out by agency personnel, which allow for more text input than “open text” fields. Additionally, the bill provides that any data reported in an open text or narrative field shall only be made available by the reporting agency and not from the Attorney General. By shifting this responsibility to agencies, the bill will likely redirect public records requests for this specific data from DOJ to the reporting agencies. Given this shift in reporting responsibility, the bill also disclaims DOJ liability for the disclosure of PII and non-disclosable info by another entity (i.e. a reporting agency).
Finally, the bill contains a provision requiring the DOJ to provide all data reported, including open text or narrative fields, to public or private entities for educational advocacy, or research purposes relating to studying racial and identity profiling by law enforcement. As discussed below, this provision resembles a prior bill that permitted the DOJ to share personal information and which was ultimately challenged on constitutional grounds.
- Constitutional Considerations
In 2016, the Legislature created and funded the California Firearm Violence Research Center (hereinafter, “the Center”) at the University of California, Davis with the goal of developing research to prevent gun violence and inform public policymaking regarding firearms.[12] In creating the Center, the Legislature also mandated that several state agencies, including the DOJ, provide the Center with data necessary for it to conduct its research. Shortly thereafter, the DOJ began restricting the Center’s access to certain data citing privacy concerns, and in response, the Legislature passed Assembly Bill 173 (Committee on Budget, Ch. 253, Stats. of 2021), which reiterated the duty of the DOJ to provide the Center with requested data.
In 2022, a group of gun owners filed lawsuits in both state and federal court challenging AB 173 on several grounds, including that the law violates, or at least chills, their Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms and that it violates privacy and due process protections guaranteed to them by the Fourteenth Amendment. The San Diego Superior Court ruled in October 2022 that the state was prohibited from sharing the plaintiffs’ personal information and granted the plaintiffs’ request for a preliminary injunction. However, in November 2023, Fourth Appellate Circuit of the California Court of Appeal ruled that even if the plaintiffs met the threshold inquiries to establish a privacy claim, the trial court did not adequately balance the privacy concerns of the plaintiffs against the legitimate countervailing interest asserted by the Attorney General.[13] While the Second Amendment issue is inapposite, the privacy concerns at play in the case regarding AB 173 may be implicated by this bill as well, and despite the Attorney General’s victory in the case described above, the Committee should be aware that such victory is no guarantee that this bill is entirely safe from constitutional challenge.
- Argument in Support
According to the bill’s sponsor, the Department of Justice:
Following the recent completion of the 2023 RIPA data reporting period on April 1, 2024, 14% of reporting agencies submitted data with higher rates of errors or incomplete submissions that could not be remedied in time before transmittal to the RIPA Board for their analysis and annual report. In addition, reporting agencies continue to include PII in open text data fields of the RIPA data set, despite years of training, technical assistance, and partnership from DOJ, which has meant that DOJ cannot release that subset of data to the public without the risk of Californians’ PII being disclosed.
AB 459 would update Government Code section 12525.5 to increase the statutory reporting frequency for RIPA reporting agencies from annually to twice a year, if a reporting agency fails to report on time or reports with unresolved errors. This bill would also move the annual submission deadline up a month, to March 1st, for all reporting agencies. Combined, both provisions would allow DOJ an opportunity to work with reporting agencies to rectify errors, and help with the preparations necessary for DOJ to support the RIPA Board’s annual work. Additionally, there is precedent for increasing reporting frequencies after years of implementation, with AB 48 (Gonzalez, Statutes of 2021) shifting law enforcement agencies’ duty to report use of force data from annually to monthly, pursuant to AB 71 (Rodriguez, Statutes of 2015).
Last but not least, AB 459 would also address DOJ’s liability concerns regarding PII disclosure in RIPA’s open text data fields by clarifying that open text fields are still publicly available, but only from the reporting agency via a PRA request, who would then be responsible for redacting PII that they have included in any RIPA dataset. The bill would also establish a process similar to other existing disclosure processes (e.g., criminal history, CURES), where researchers can receive access to these open text data fields, as well as all RIPA data from DOJ, when data security can be assured. In the RIPA Board’s 2024 report alone, more than 4.5 million stops by 535 California law enforcement agencies conducted in 2022 were analyzed. This bill will help ensure that the letter and intent of RIPA is fully realized, to strengthen the trust between communities and law enforcement that is necessary for public safety.
- Argument in Opposition
According to the California State Sheriffs Association:
The bill fails to define the terms “reporting issues” and “unresolved errors” meaning that the criteria that would be used by the AG to determine that an agency must increase the frequency of its reporting is unclear. Further, it is possible that whatever issues the AG decides trigger AB 459’s provisions would not necessarily be resolved by more frequent reporting in the subsequent year. Additionally, the bill removes responsibility to disclose information made public by statute from the AG’s office and places it solely with the reporting agency. This provision, along with the bill’s other requirements, will likely result in increased costs for, and demand more resources from, local law enforcement agencies.
-- END –
California Government Code §7921.000 ↑
City of San Jose v. Superior Court (1999) 74 Cal.App.4th 1008, 1016-1017. ↑
Gov. Code, § 7922.000 ↑
Gov. Code § 7923.600 ↑
Gov. Code §§7923.605, 7923.610; 7923.615 ↑
Gov. Code, §§ 7923.600; 7927.700, 7927.705 ↑
SB 1421 (Skinner, Ch. 988, Stats. of 2018) and SB 16 (Skinner, Ch. 402, Stats of 2021); the specific categories are less relevant to this bill and therefore not described here, but can be found at Penal Code § 832.7, subd. (b). ↑
Penal Code §832.7(b)(6). ↑
“Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board Annual Report 2024.” Department of Justice. 1 January 2024, at p. 29. 2024 - RIPA Board - Annual Report - AB 953 - Racial and Identity and Profiling Advisory Board (ca.gov) ↑
Govt. Code §12525.5, subd. (g)(2) ↑
Govt. Code §12525.5, subds. (d), (f). ↑
California Penal Code §14230 et. seq. ↑
Barba v. Bonta (2023), Super. Ct. No. 37-2022- 00003676-CU-CR-CTL, D081194.PDF (ca.gov) ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 459
Author:(Haney)
As Amended Ver:April 13, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the California Health and Human Services Agency (CHHSA) to establish, by July 1, 2026, the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by CHHSA.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
- Mental Health (MH) in California - Systems of Care: Behavioral health disorders are among the most common chronic illnesses that people face, both in the United States and in California. Behavioral health treatment and services within California may be provided to individuals either voluntarily or involuntarily. Most services are received voluntarily within community-based settings. Regardless of whether the services occur in an in-patient (hospitalization) or outpatient (community based) setting (group therapy, counseling, etc.), patients who enter treatment voluntarily are more inclined to experience improvement in their behavioral health condition than those admitted involuntarily. Regardless of whether an individual is receiving behavioral health treatment voluntarily or involuntarily, the delivery systems remain the same. As with physical health, there are three primary delivery and payment systems, private insurance (including Covered California), Medicaid (Medi-Cal within California), and private pay (uninsured).
Under California law, behavioral health services are considered essential health benefits (EHBs) and all health plans are required to provide coverage for behavioral health services, including substance use disorders. Additionally, under both Federal and California law, behavioral health services must be offered in such a way as to achieve parity with medical services, ensuring they are covered under the same terms and conditions as other medical conditions – meaning that behavioral health services must achieve parity with medical conditions in areas such as, but not limited to, network adequacy, geographic (time of travel and distance to treatment) and timely access standards (appointment availability), and financial requirements such as copayments and deductibles.
- Funding Streams for Public Community Mental Health Services: The funding of community mental health services in California is quite complex and involves multiple, distinct funding streams. To further compound this complexity, each of those funding streams may have specific objectives and requirements tied to its use. In a report dated August 21, 2019, entitled an "Overview of Public Community Mental Health Services Funding and the Mental Health Services Act (MHSA)," the Legislative Analyst's Office estimated that in 2017-18, community mental health services funding was approximately $9.8 billion.
Of those funds, approximately $7.9 billion went to county mental health services and $1.9 billion to Medi-Cal Managed Care (MCMC) and fee-for-service. Thus, about 80% of total funding for community mental health services went to county mental health agencies and the remaining 20% of funding is either paid out directly by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) for specific benefits such as psychotropic medications or goes to MCMCs to pay for outpatient therapy for Medi-Cal enrollees (primarily adults) with mild-to-moderate mental illness. With the exception of some MHSA funding within specific allocations of the MHSA (i.e., prevention and early intervention and innovation discussed in detail below) most of these monies support direct patient care.
- MHSA. Proposition 63, the MHSA was passed by voters in November 2004. The MHSA imposes a 1% income tax on personal income in excess of $1 million and creates the 16 member Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission charged with overseeing the implementation of MHSA. The MHSA addresses a broad continuum of prevention, early intervention and service needs as well as providing funding for infrastructure, technology, and training needs for the community mental health system.
The MHSA requires each county mental health department to prepare and submit a three-year plan to DHCS that must be updated each year and approved by DHCS after review and comment by the MHSOAC. In their three-year plans, counties are required to include a list of all programs for which MHSA funding is being requested and that identifies how the funds will be spent and which populations will be served. Counties must submit their plans for approval to the MHSOAC before the counties may spend certain categories of funding including Prevention and Early Intervention and Innovation funds.
- Health Insurance Regulation. In California, regulation and oversight of fully insured employee health benefit plans is split between two state departments, the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) and California Department of Insurance (CDI). The DMHC licenses and regulates the full scope of managed care models, including all health maintenance organizations in California, as well as preferred provider organizations (PPOs), exclusive provider organizations, point-of service products and MCMC plans. DMHC assesses and monitors health plan networks and delivery systems for compliance with the Knox-Keene Act. CDI has jurisdiction under the California Insurance Code over all other types of health insurance, including plans that offer traditional health insurance products, such as indemnity plans, and some PPO plans.
There are essentially three relevant regulatory frameworks for health insurance: state regulation by DMHC, by CDI; and, regulation of self-insured employee health benefit plans by the federal Department of Labor. Each regulator is governed by its own set of laws and consumers are caught in the middle sometimes guessing which laws and appeal rights apply.
- Federal Mental Health Parity. In 1996, the U.S. Congress passed the Mental Health Parity Act (MHPA), which prohibits large group health plans from imposing higher annual or lifetime dollar limits on MH benefits. However, the MHPA did not mandate coverage for MH services and only applied to group health plans that offered MH benefits. The MHPA also did not apply to substance use disorders (SUDs), services limits, limitations on the types of facilities covered, or differences in cost sharing, and plans could have stricter prior authorization requirements for MH services than for other medical services.
- State Mental Health Parity. In 1999, California passed AB 88 (Thompson), Chapter 534, Statutes of 1999, which requires a health plan contract or disability insurance policy to provide coverage for the diagnosis and medically necessary services of serious mental illnesses of a person of any age and of serious emotional disturbances of a child. Benefits must be applied under the same terms and conditions as applied to other medical conditions. AB 88 also requires copayments, deductibles and maximum lifetime benefits to be applied equally to all benefits under the plan.
- Federal Act. In 2008, Congress passed the federal Act to cover some of the gaps in the MHPA. Similar to the MHPA, the Act only applies to large-group health plans. However, the federal Act also included Medicare Advantage plans offered through group health plans, state and local government plans, Medicaid managed care plans, and state Children's Health Insurance Program plans. Unlike the MHPA, the federal Act prohibited differences in services limits, cost-sharing, in-and-out-of-network coverage, and applied to services for SUDs.
The federal Act requires, if health plans include services for MH/SUDs as part of their benefits, to provide those services under the same terms and conditions as other medical services. The federal Act eliminated all differences between MH/SUDs and other medical services as they related to services and visit limits; deductibles; copayments; coinsurance; and, the use of out-of-network providers when a health plan gave this option. Further, federal regulations in 2010 and then the final rule in 2013, prohibited health plans from imposing a financial requirement or services limit restriction that is more restrictive than what are offered for medical and surgical benefits in the same classification. Both DMHC and CDI provide regulatory oversight of federal and California parity laws and are monitoring filings for compliance with these laws.
- The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) and EHBs. The ACA applied the federal Act to issuers in the individual market and qualified health plans offered through a health benefit exchange, including small group products. The ACA also specified coverage of the 10 EHBs, including MH/SUD treatment services. California's EHB statute also specifically states that the federal Act applies to health plans that must comply with EHBs, including products offered off the exchange. The ACA states that coverage of MH/SUD services along with any scope and duration limits imposed on the benefits comply with the federal Act and all rules, regulations, and guidance issued pursuant to the federal Act. According to a 2015 Health Affairs Health Policy Brief, the ACA went beyond the federal Act by mandating coverage instead of requiring parity only if coverage is provided.
- Outcome Measurements and Accountability. As described above, California's behavioral health system is complex, convoluted and more often than not, confusing - not only for those trying to access needed behavioral health services; but for those attempting to assess the system to determine how well the systems works, how the entities are performing and whether behavioral health is improving or worsening in the state. While there are performance contracts between the MCMCs and the counties and DHCS, they often do not address patient outcomes nor measure true performance across a defined set of outcome goals. This bill is attempting to develop that framework for oversight and accountability.
Additionally, Governor Newsom announced in March 2023, his plan to "Modernize California’s Behavioral Health System." Among other major initiatives, the plan calls for greater fiscal accountability and oversight on county spending for behavioral health, greater fiscal transparency through enhanced reporting requirements, the development of specific outcome measurements, not just process measures but those aimed at driving toward meaningful and measurable system change and improved health outcomes. The Governor's plan also calls for greater alignment between Medi-Cal (county provided mental health services whether through a MCMC or a Mental Health Plan and commercial coverage of behavioral health services requiring that DHCS and DMHC work collaboratively to develop a plan for achieving parity between commercial and Medi-Cal mental health and SUD benefits.
According to the Author
California's MH and addiction care systems are broken, leaving thousands left to fend for themselves while facing impossible circumstances with few resources. The system is not focused on outcomes – resulting in needless human suffering, institutionalization, homelessness, incarceration, and death. The author continues, we need measurable goals and accountability to ensure all Californians have access to quality care. This bill will hold MH and addiction care systems accountable by requiring counties and health plans to set treatment goals and requires the state to monitor and publicly report their progress towards those goals. The author concludes this is a critical next step to improving the lives of Californians living with mental illnesses and addiction.
Arguments in Support
The California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions (CALBHB/C), in a support position states that performance measures and outcomes for mental/behavioral health programs are fundamental to making informed decisions. Increased standardization, analysis and communication of performance outcome data will help to ensure effective local and statewide review and implementation of behavioral health programs and services. CALBHB/C concludes that measuring performance related to life outcomes is key to understanding best practices, informing improvement plans, justifying local and statewide implementation and sustaining funding.
Arguments in Support if Amended
The Psychiatric Physicians Alliance of California (PPAC) in a support if amended position states that the need for outcomes and quality data to design behavioral health treatment strategies more effectively is readily apparent with 35,000 individuals with SMI homeless on our streets, another 100,000 receiving MH treatment in jails, and one in three prisoners or 26,000 of 90,000 individuals currently incarcerated. PPAC requests that the CHHSA workgroup provision in this bill be amended to include organizations representing psychiatric physicians who can bring medical expertise to the table. PPAC concludes that the additional of a psychiatric physicians makes sense given the centrality of medications to the SMI population, because people with SMI die on average 26 years earlier than their peers without SMI, often of treatable and preventable health conditions.
Arguments in Opposition
There is no known opposition.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, CHHSA states total costs of implementing this bill are indeterminate, but potentially in the low millions of dollars per year, and some of the bill's activities would likely be delegated to one or more departments, such as DHCS (General Fund (GF)).
The author submitted a request for $29.6 million in the 2023-24 state budget. However, according to the sponsor, the current version of this bill requires only $20 million.
Additionally, costs to the University of California (UC) to establish the structure necessary to fulfill the requested services is estimated to be $2 million to $3 million in the first year, based on the need to consult with experts who can help define necessary data metrics, develop a secure portal for county data, and identify best practices in current data sciences and security measures (non-Proposition 98 GF). UC would also use the funds to retrieve county mental health data in a usable format, create a secure data repository, and set up data exchanges.
Minor and absorbable costs to DMHC and CDI.
If the Commission on State Mandates determines the provisions of this bill are a reimbursable state mandate, the state could be required to pay local health plans costs.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 15-0-0
YES: Wood, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Flora, Vince Fong, Maienschein, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Rodriguez, Santiago, Villapudua, Weber
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-1
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: April 13, 2023
CONSULTANT: Judith Babcock / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000516
Date of Hearing: May 3, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 459
Author:(Haney) – As Amended Ver:April 13, 2023
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 15 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Health and Human Services Agency (Agency) to establish the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR).
Specifically, this bill does the following:
- Requires the Agency to convene a workgroup composed of representatives from specified state departments, the University of California (UC), county behavioral health (BH) agencies, health plans and insurers, Legislative staff, consumers, advocacy and research organizations, and other entities to establish a work plan for conducting the CBH-OAR.
- Requires the Agency to report, annually during the budget process, to the Assembly and Senate Budget Subcommittees on Health Human Services, on the CBH-OAR.
- Requires the CBH-OAR to consist of three components:
- Performance indicators, including specific process and outcome measures, as specified.
- A county and health plan system needs assessment process, which will be designed to identify best practices for replication and areas for system improvement, and to guide the development of the county and health plan system improvement plan. A county BH provider or health plan will consult with specified local stakeholders in developing its needs assessment and submit it to the Agency every three years.
- County and health plan system improvement plans. A county system improvement plan will include a services peer review, conducted by peer counties. The county BH agency or health plan will complete an annual progress report and submit it to the Agency.
- Requires the Agency to review, monitor, and provide technical support for counties and health plans in their efforts to meet the requirements in 3), above, and to identify and promote the replication of best practices.
- Requires the Agency to request UC to enter into a contract with the state to do the following:
- Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of BH services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on specified life outcomes and deliver the analysis to the Agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup on or before July 1, 2026.
- Create and maintain a dashboard modeled after the California Child Welfare Indicators Project to publicly report data collected by counties and health plans, and the status of performance indicators.
- Consult with the Agency to provide technical assistance to county BH agencies and health plans.
- Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of BH services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on specified life outcomes and deliver the analysis to the Agency, the Legislature, and the workgroup on or before July 1, 2026.
- Requires a county to execute and fulfill components of its system improvement plan that can be accomplished with existing resources.
- Defines, for the purposes of this bill, “health plan” as a health care service plan regulated by the Department of Managed Health Care or a disability insurer regulated by the Department of Insurance.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The Agency states total costs of implementing this bill are indeterminate, but potentially in the low millions of dollars per year, and some of the bill’s activities would likely be delegated to one or more departments, such as the Department of Health Care Services (General Fund (GF)).
The author submitted a request for $29.6 million in the 2023-24 state budget. However, according to the sponsor, the current version of this bill requires only $20 million:
Costs to UC to establish the structure necessary to fulfill the requested services is estimated to be $2 million to $3 million in the first year, based on the need to consult with experts who can help define necessary data metrics, develop a secure portal for county data, and identify best practices in current data sciences and security measures (non-Proposition 98 GF). UC would also use the funds to retrieve county mental health data in a usable format, create a secure data repository, and set up data exchanges.
Minor and absorbable costs to the Department of Managed Health Care and the Department of Insurance.
If the Commission on State Mandates determines the provisions of this bill are a reimbursable state mandate, the state could be required to pay local health plans costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
California’s mental health and addiction care systems are broken, leaving thousands in dire straits to fend for themselves while facing impossible circumstances with few resources. The system is not focused on outcomes – resulting in needless human suffering, institutionalization, homelessness, incarceration, and death. We need measurable goals and accountability to ensure all Californians have access to quality care. AB 459 will hold our mental health and addiction care systems accountable by requiring counties and health plans to set treatment goals and requires the state to monitor and publicly report their progress towards those goals. This is a critical next step to improving the lives of Californians living with mental illnesses and addiction.
- Background. California’s BH system is complex and confusing not only for those trying to access care, and those trying to access needed BH services, but also for those attempting to assess the system to determine how well the systems works, how the entities are performing and whether behavioral health is improving or worsening in the state. While there are performance contracts among the Medi-Cal managed care plans, the counties, and the Department of Health Care Services, they often do not address patient outcomes or measure performance across a defined set of outcomes.
In March 2023, Governor Newsom announced his plan to “Modernize California’s Behavioral Health System.” Among other major initiatives, the plan calls for greater fiscal accountability and oversight on county spending for behavioral health, greater fiscal transparency through enhanced reporting requirements, the development of specific outcome measurements, not just process measures but those aimed at driving toward meaningful and measurable system change and improved health outcomes. The Governor’s plan also calls for greater alignment between Medi-Cal (county-provided mental health services through a MCMC or a MHP) and commercial coverage of behavioral health services requiring that DHCS and DMHC work collaboratively to develop a plan for achieving parity between commercial and Medi-Cal mental health and SUD benefits.
- Prior Legislation.
- SB 89 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 24, Statutes of 2017, established CalWORKS Outcomes and Accountability Review (Cal-OAR) to facilitate a local accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county CalWORKs programs and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery.
- AB 686 (Arambula), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, would have required the Agency to establish, by July 1, 2023, the California Community-Based Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBBH-OAR) to facilitate a local accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county BH programs and in the collection and dissemination by the Agency of best practices in service delivery. AB 686 would have required the Agency to convene a work group, similar to the work group in this bill. AB 686 was held in this committee.
- SB 970 (Eggman), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, was similar to this bill, except it addressed a narrower scope of publicly-funded BH activities and excluded health plans. SB 970 died on the Assembly Floor.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 459 (
Author:(Haney) – As Amended Ver:March 23, 2023
SUBJECT: California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review.
SUMMARY: Requires the California Health and Human Services Agency (CHHSA) to establish, by July 1, 2026, the California Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBH-OAR) to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by CHHSA. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires CHHSA to establish, by July 1, 2026, the CBH-OAR to facilitate an accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county and commercial behavioral health services and in the collection and dissemination of best practices in service delivery by CHHSA.
- Requires the CBH-OAR to cover county recipients and include the programmatic elements that each county and health plan offer as part of its behavioral health care service array and to consist of performance indicators, including specific processes and outcome measures, a county and health plan system needs assessment process and a county and health plan system improvement plan.
- Defines for purposes of this bill, “behavioral health services” to include mental health (MH) and substance use disorder (SUD) services being provided by or arranged by either of the following:
- A county behavioral health agency funded through county general funds, 1991 Realignment and 2011 Realignment funds, federal Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration grants, Mental Health Services Act (MHSA) funds, and other sources of local, state, or federal funding dedicated to county behavioral health services; and,
- Health plans, including both public and private health plans.
- Requires CHHSA, on or before October 1, 2024, to convene a workgroup composed of representatives from all of the following:
- The State Department of Health Care Services (DHCS);
- The Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission (MHSOAC);
- The Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC);
- The Department of Insurance (CDI);
- The University of California (UC);
- County behavioral health agencies;
- Health plans;
- Legislative staff;
- Interested behavioral health advocacy and research organizations;
- Consumers;
- Organizations that represent county behavioral health agencies and county boards of supervisors;
- Nonprofit community-based organizations;
- Researchers; and,
- Other entities or individuals CHHSA deems necessary.
- Requires the workgroup to establish a work plan by which the CBH-OAR will be conducted.
- Requires CHHSA to report annually to the Senate Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services and the Assembly Budget Subcommittee on Health and Human Services during the budget process with an update on the schedule for, development of, and future changes to, the CBH-OAR.
- Requires the workgroup when establishing the work plan to, at a minimum, do all of the following:
- Consider existing performance indicators being measured;
- Consider or develop additional, alternative, or additional and alternative performance indicators to be measured;
- Develop uniform elements of the county and health plan system needs assessment process and the county and health plan system improvement plans;
- Develop timelines for implementation;
- Make recommendations for reducing the existing services data reporting burden;
- Make recommendations for financial incentives to counties for achievement on performance measures; and,
- Analyze the county and state workload associated with implementation of the requirements of this bill.
- Requires the workgroup to develop the uniform elements for the county and health plan system improvement plans required in 7) c) above. Requires, CHHSA, in consultation with the workgroup, to develop the uniform elements of the updates to those plans as required in 7) c) above.
- Authorizes, after July 1, 2027, and at the discretion of CHHSA, the workgroup be disbanded or incorporated into existing advisory bodies.
- Requires the CBH-OAR to consist of the following three components:
- Performance Indicators (including specific processes and outcome measures):
- Requires the CBH-OAR performance indicators to include both process and outcome measures. Requires these measures to be established to provide baseline and ongoing information about how the state, counties, and health plans are performing over time and to inform and guide each county behavioral health agency’s and health plan’s system needs assessment process and system improvement plan;
- Requires that process measures include measures of participant engagement, service delivery, and participation. Requires that specific process measures be established by CHHSA, in consultation with the workgroup, and allows those measures to include measures of engagement as shown by improvement in program participation, timeliness of service provision, rates of utilization of program components, and referrals and utilization of services;
- Provides that if the UC enters into the contract described in 19) below, outcome measures to be determined based on the recommendations included in the analysis prepared by the UC as specified in 19) below;
- Permits, to the extent allowed by existing state and federal privacy laws, performance indicator data available in existing county and health plan data systems to be collected by counties and health plans and provided to CHHSA, and performance indicator data available in existing state agency data systems be collected by CHHSA and provided to the counties and health plans. Provides that this data is to be reported in a manner and on a schedule determined by CHHSA, in consultation with the workgroup, but no less frequently than semiannually;
- Requires that during the first three-year CBH-OAR cycle, performance indicator data reported by each county and health plan be used to establish both county and statewide baselines for each performance indicator. Requires that the data reported in the first year of the first CBH-OAR cycle to serve as the county and statewide baselines. Provides that after the first review cycle, CHHSA is to establish standard target thresholds for each performance indicator established by the workgroup;
- Requires CHHSA, in consultation with the workgroup, to develop a process for resolving disputes regarding the establishment of standard target thresholds in v) above;
- Requires that for subsequent reviews, based upon availability of additional data through data sharing agreements, CHHSA consider whether to establish additional performance indicators to advance the intent of this bill;
- Requires additional performance indicators be subject to the process described in v) above and to include consideration of when data on the additional performance indicators will be available for reporting, if not already available; and,
- Permits CHHSA if, during subsequent reviews, there is sufficient reason to establish statewide performance standards for one or more outcome measures, to establish those standards for each of the agreed-upon outcome measures.
- County and health plan system needs assessment process:
- The county and health plan system needs assessment process component of the CBH-OAR, as established by the workgroup to require county behavioral health agencies and health plans to assess their performance on the established performance indicators, identify the strengths and weaknesses in their current practice and resource deployment, and identify and describe how operational decisions and systemic factors affect program outcomes as described in 10) c) i) below;
- Requires that the county and health plan system needs assessment process be designed to identify areas of best practices for replication and for system improvement and to guide the development of the county and health plan system improvement plan;
- Requires the county and health plan system needs assessment process to be completed by the county and health plans, in consultation and collaboration with stakeholders, and submitted to CHHSA every three years;
- Requires counties to convene local stakeholders, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- County behavioral health directors, supervisors, and caseworkers;
- Consumers and family members of consumers;
- Health plans operating in the county;
- Hospitals;
- Local educational agencies;
- Law enforcement;
- Child welfare agencies;
- County-contracted providers;
- Other county behavioral health agency partners;
- To the extent possible and relevant, local stakeholders to also include representatives from tribal organizations and the local behavioral health board; and,
- Additional specific county behavioral health agency partners to be determined by the county and may include, but are not limited to, adult education providers, providers of services for survivors of domestic violence, the local housing continuum of care, county human services departments, county drug and alcohol programs, and community-based service providers, as appropriate; and,
- Requires health plans to convene stakeholders, including, but not limited to, providers, hospitals, enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, parents of child enrollees who are or have received behavioral health services in that system, and a representative sample of county behavioral health departments from their service area.
- The county and health plan system needs assessment process component of the CBH-OAR, as established by the workgroup to require county behavioral health agencies and health plans to assess their performance on the established performance indicators, identify the strengths and weaknesses in their current practice and resource deployment, and identify and describe how operational decisions and systemic factors affect program outcomes as described in 10) c) i) below;
- County and health plan system improvement plan:
- Requires the county and health plan system improvement plan to include the uniform elements established by the workgroup pursuant to subparagraph 7) c) above;
- Requires the county and health plan system improvement plan to be completed every three years by the county and health plan;
- Requires a county’s system improvement plan to be approved in public session by the county’s board of supervisors or chief elected official and be submitted to CHHSA. Prior to being presented to the county’s board of supervisors or chief elected official for approval, the county’s system improvement plan is to be presented to the local behavioral health board or equivalent body. Requires a health plan’s system improvement plan to be approved by its board of directors;
- Requires a county’s system improvement plan to include a services peer review element, conducted by peer counties, the purpose of which is to provide additional insight, including collaborative training on best practices and technical assistance by peer counties. Specifies that health plans are not required to participate in a peer review process; and,
- Requires the county behavioral health agency or health plan to complete an annual progress report on the status of its system improvement plan and to submit these reports to CHHSA.
- Performance Indicators (including specific processes and outcome measures):
- Requires CHHSA to receive, review, and, based on its determination of whether the county or health plan system improvement plan meets the required elements, certify as complete all submitted performance indicator data, county and health plans’ self-assessments, county and health plan system improvement plans, and annual progress reports.
- Requires CHHSA to identify and promote the replication of best practices in service delivery to achieve the established process and outcome measures.
- Requires CHHSA to monitor, on an ongoing basis, county performance on the performance indicators developed 10) a) above.
- Permits CHHSA to assign the duties outlined in 12) to 13) above, inclusive, to DHCS, DMHC, and CDI, as appropriate.
- Requires CHHSA to, on an annual basis, beginning July 1, 2026, submit a report to the Legislature that summarizes county or health plan performance on the established performance indicators during the reporting period, analyzes county performance trends over time and makes findings and recommendations for common service improvements identified in the county and health plan system assessments and system improvement plans, including information on common statutory, regulatory, or fiscal barriers identified as inhibiting system improvements and recommendations to overcome those barriers.
- Requires CHHSA, that if the contract in 19) below is executed, CSHAA is to, in partnership with UC, facilitate the provision of technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans that supports the county’s or health plan’s selected areas for improvement as described in its system improvement plan. Specifies that CHHSA and UC are not to be considered peers in the county peer review element, and their role is limited to providing technical assistance.
- Provides that if CHHSA determines, in the course of its review of county and health plan system improvement plans and annual updates, or in the course of its review of regularly submitted performance indicator data, that a county or health plan is consistently failing to meet the performance indicator standard target thresholds established in 10) a) v) above, the agency is to engage the county or health plan in a process of targeted technical assistance and support to address and resolve the identified shortcomings.
- Requires a county to execute and fulfill components of its system improvement plan that can be accomplished with existing resources.
- Requires CHHSA to request the UC to enter into a contract with the state to provide all of the following services:
- Prepare an analysis of how data pertaining to the provision of behavioral health services and client outcomes collected by the counties and health plans and provided to the state may be used to demonstrate the impact of services on life outcomes;
- Deliver the analysis to CHHSA, the Legislature, and the workgroup established in 4) above on or before July 1, 2026, and to include recommended life outcome measures and measures of the reduction of the following negative outcomes listed in the Prevention and Early Intervention Program that may result from untreated mental illness and that address prevention and early intervention strategies for mental illness and measures of employment, educational attainment, program exits and program reentries, adherence to treatment plans, attainment of housing, reduction in contacts with law enforcement, reduction in hospitalizations, and reductions in homelessness;
- Ensure the analysis required in 10) a) above be submitted in accordance with existing law;
- Create and maintain a dashboard modeled after the California Child Welfare Indicators Project to publicly report the data collected by counties and health plans and to report the status of performance indicators as described in this bill; and,
- Consult with CHHSA to provide technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies and health plans as described in subparagraph 10) b) above.
EXISTING LAW:
- Permits the MHSOAC, working in collaboration with the DHCS, the California Behavioral Health Planning Council (CBHPC), and the County Behavioral Health Directors Association of California (CBHDAC), as specified, to design a joint plan for a coordinated evaluation of client outcomes in the community-based MH system. Requires the CHHSA to lead this comprehensive joint plan effort. [Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC) §5845]
- Requires DHCS and each county to have a performance contract for community MH services, the MHSA, the Projects for Assistance in Transition from Homelessness grant, the Community Mental Health Services Block Grant, and other federal grants or other county MH programs. Requires DHCS to develop the county MH services performance contract, and to provide the three-year performance contract to the county by January 2 of the year the existing performance contract expires. [WIC §5650]
- Requires, in consultation with the CBHDAC, DHCS, MHSOAC, the CBHPC and CHHSA, county behavioral health systems to provide reports and data to meet the information needs of the state as necessary. [WIC §5664]
- Establishes within the State Department of Social Services (DSS), the California CalWORKs Outcomes and Accountability Review (Cal-OAR) (upon which this bill is based) to facilitate a local accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county CalWORKs programs and in the collection and dissemination by DSS of best practices in service delivery. [WIC §11523]
- Establishes the DMHC to regulate health plans under the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975 (Knox-Keene Act) and the CDI to regulate health and other insurance. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1340, et seq., and Insurance Code (INS) §106, et seq.]
- Requires every health plan contract and insurance policy that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage to provide coverage for medically necessary treatment of MH and SUD under the same terms and conditions applied to other medical conditions, as specified. [HSC §1374.72 and INS §10144.5]
- Requires the health plan or insurer, if services for the medically necessary treatment of a MH or SUD are not available in network within the geographic and timely access standards set by law or regulation, to arrange coverage to ensure the delivery of medically necessary out-of-network services and any medically necessary follow-up services that, to the maximum extent possible, meet those geographic and timely access standards. Requires that this includes, but is not limited to, providing services to secure medically necessary out-of-network options that are available to the enrollee within geographic and timely access standards, and requires the enrollee or insured to pay no more than the same cost sharing that would be paid for the same covered services received from an in-network provider. [HSC §1374.72 and INS §10144.5]
- Required DMHC to establish and convene a Health Equity and Quality Committee by March of 2022 for the purpose of recommending health equity and quality measures and benchmark standards for all health plans, with the goal of addressing long-standing health inequities and ensure the equitable delivery of high-quality health care services across all market segments, including the individual, small and large group markets, and the Medi-Cal Managed Care program. Establishes the following Health Equity and Qualify Measure Standards comprised of 12 Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set measures and one Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems measures. [HSC § 1399.870]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, California’s MH and addiction care systems are broken, leaving thousands left to fend for themselves while facing impossible circumstances with few resources. The system is not focused on outcomes – resulting in needless human suffering, institutionalization, homelessness, incarceration, and death. The author continues, we need measurable goals and accountability to ensure all Californians have access to quality care. This bill will hold MH and addiction care systems accountable by requiring counties and health plans to set treatment goals and requires the state to monitor and publicly report their progress towards those goals. The author concludes this is a critical next step to improving the lives of Californians living with mental illnesses and addiction.
- BACKGROUND.
- MH in California - Systems of Care: Behavioral health disorders are among the most common chronic illnesses that people face, both in the United States and in California. Behavioral health treatment and services within California may be provided to individuals either voluntarily or involuntarily. Most services are received voluntarily within community-based settings. Regardless of whether the services occur in an in-patient (hospitalization) or outpatient (community based) setting (group therapy, counseling, etc.), patients who enter treatment voluntarily are more inclined to experience improvement in their behavioral health condition than those admitted involuntarily. Regardless of whether an individual is receiving behavioral health treatment voluntarily or involuntarily, the delivery systems remain the same. As with physical health, there are three primary delivery and payment systems, private insurance (including Covered California), Medicaid (Medi-Cal within California), and private pay (uninsured).
Under California law, behavioral health services are considered essential health benefits (EHBs) and all health plans are required to provide coverage for behavioral health services, including substance use disorders. Additionally, under both Federal and California law, behavioral health services must be offered in such a way as to achieve parity with medical services, ensuring they are covered under the same terms and conditions as other medical conditions – meaning that behavioral health services must achieve parity with medical conditions in areas such as, but not limited to, network adequacy, geographic (time of travel and distance to treatment) and timely access standards (appointment availability), and financial requirements such as copayments and deductibles.- Private Pay: If an individual has private coverage whether through an individual plan purchased by themselves or a group plan through their employer, they have access to behavioral health services. Either the individual or the employer pays premiums directly to the plans. Under private pay insurance, beneficiaries access services in much the same way they would regular medical care. They would seek out a mental health provider either directly or through a referral from their primary care provider. These services may be offered through a behavioral MH provider that contracts with the health plan as part of their provider network or through a specialized mental health plan (MHP) that the primary health care plan has sub-contracted with to provide behavioral health services, (examples of specialized MHPs include Beacon and Managed Health Network). Unlike Medicaid (described below) where care is provided via a two-prong approach based on severity of mental illness, individuals insured under private coverage receive all their behavioral health benefits through their single plan regardless of the severity of their mental illness.
- Medicaid/Medi-Cal: Medicaid is a joint, state, and federal program that operates under both federal and state laws and regulations. Federal Medicaid law sets broad requirements for the program and mandates coverage of some populations and benefits, while inclusion of other populations and benefits are optional for the states. States make the operational and policy decisions to determine who is eligible for enrollment, which services are covered, and how payments are set. In California, the state Medicaid program is Medi-Cal. As the primary payer of MH services, and the program entity responsible for the coverage of nearly one-third of Californians, the MH coverage provided under Medi-Cal is a fundamental component of the state’s MH delivery system. California operates its Medi-Cal MH programs as two separate systems of care - managed care (MCMC) and county special MHPs. MCMC plans provides care to individuals with mild-to-moderate mental illness while the MHPs have responsibility for the serious mentally ill (SMI) and serious emotional disturbance (SED) populations.
MHPs provide a broad range of specialty mental health services (SMHS) to individuals with a level of mental illness classified as SMI. The delivery of SMHS through MHPs is commonly referred to as a “carve-out.” A “carve out” is when services covered by the Medi-Cal program are delivered outside of managed care. MHPs are responsible for providing SMHS to Medi-Cal beneficiaries who meet SMHS medical necessity criteria. SMHS are delivered through 56 county MHPs (Placer and Sierra counties and Yuba and Sutter counties operate two separate dual-county combined MHPs.) Medi-Cal beneficiaries who meet medical necessity criteria for SMHS are entitled to receive medically necessary SMHS from the county MHP, regardless of whether or not they are enrolled in a MCMC plan. Counties are essentially responsible for providing mental health services to children on Medi-Cal, adults on Medi-Cal with SMI, the bulk of programs provided under the MHSA and low-income residents without health insurance coverage (indigent care).
MCMC plans deliver their scope of mental health coverage in different ways and to a population that experiences what is referred to as mild to moderate mental illness. For example, some MCMC plans use a specialized healthcare service plan to administer the mental health benefit, while other plans manage the benefit directly, and one plan contracts with its county behavioral health department.
- MH in California - Systems of Care: Behavioral health disorders are among the most common chronic illnesses that people face, both in the United States and in California. Behavioral health treatment and services within California may be provided to individuals either voluntarily or involuntarily. Most services are received voluntarily within community-based settings. Regardless of whether the services occur in an in-patient (hospitalization) or outpatient (community based) setting (group therapy, counseling, etc.), patients who enter treatment voluntarily are more inclined to experience improvement in their behavioral health condition than those admitted involuntarily. Regardless of whether an individual is receiving behavioral health treatment voluntarily or involuntarily, the delivery systems remain the same. As with physical health, there are three primary delivery and payment systems, private insurance (including Covered California), Medicaid (Medi-Cal within California), and private pay (uninsured).
This two-method delivery system is oftentimes difficult for consumers to maneuver because mental illness is not linear. Individuals may move from a diagnosis of a mild-to-moderate level illness to SMI and back again. For example at any given time, an individual may be managing their illness with the aid of medications and counselling. However, that same individual may also experience a psychotic episode, cease their medication and require hospitalization and as a result, their illness may be reclassified as a SMI. Navigating the two systems to ensure ongoing treatment and care can be burdensome and does not always result in well-coordinated care. Providers within the MCMC and MHP plans may also be different, coordination of treatment may be non-existent and fiscal accountability may or may not be assumed by the appropriate entity.
This lack of fiscal accountability also occurs between private insurance coverage and the county’s responsibility to provide care for SMI patients whether they are a Medi-Cal beneficiary or not. A patient may experience the need for care; the county provides it and then later learns there is private insurance. However, recouping the treatment costs from the private insurer is oftentimes difficult with counties eventually bearing the full cost of treatment for individuals with private coverage.
- Funding Streams for Public Community Mental Health Services: The funding of community mental health services in California is quite complex and involves multiple, distinct funding streams. To further compound this complexity, each of those funding streams may have specific objectives and requirements tied to its use. In a report dated August 21, 2019, entitled an “Overview of Public Community Mental Health Services Funding and the MHSA,” the Legislative Analyst’s Office estimated that in 2017-18, community mental health services funding was approximately $9.8 billion. The source of these funds were provided primarily through the following:
- Federal funds (primarily Medi-Cal) $4.3 billion;
- MHSA $2.0 billion [Now estimated to be nearly $4 billion];
- Local Realignment Revenues $2.7 billion; and,
- State General Fund $0.8 billion.
- Funding Streams for Public Community Mental Health Services: The funding of community mental health services in California is quite complex and involves multiple, distinct funding streams. To further compound this complexity, each of those funding streams may have specific objectives and requirements tied to its use. In a report dated August 21, 2019, entitled an “Overview of Public Community Mental Health Services Funding and the MHSA,” the Legislative Analyst’s Office estimated that in 2017-18, community mental health services funding was approximately $9.8 billion. The source of these funds were provided primarily through the following:
Of those funds, approximately $7.9 billion went to county mental health services and $1.9 billion to MCMC and fee-for-service. Thus, about 80% of total funding for community mental health services went to county mental health agencies and the remaining 20% of funding is either paid out directly by the DHCS for specific benefits such as psychotropic medications or goes to MCMCs to pay for outpatient therapy for Medi-Cal enrollees (primarily adults) with mild-to-moderate mental illness. With the exception of some MHSA funding within specific allocations of the MHSA (i.e., prevention and early intervention and innovation discussed in detail below) most of these monies support direct patient care.
- MHSA. Proposition 63, the MHSA was passed by voters in November 2004. The MHSA imposes a 1% income tax on personal income in excess of $1 million and creates the 16 member MHSOAC charged with overseeing the implementation of MHSA. The MHSA addresses a broad continuum of prevention, early intervention and service needs as well as providing funding for infrastructure, technology, and training needs for the community mental health system.
The MHSA requires each county mental health department to prepare and submit a three-year plan to DHCS that must be updated each year and approved by DHCS after review and comment by the MHSOAC. In their three-year plans, counties are required to include a list of all programs for which MHSA funding is being requested and that identifies how the funds will be spent and which populations will be served.
- Community Services and Supports: Provides direct mental health services to the severely and seriously mentally ill, such as mental health treatment, cost of health care treatment, and housing supports. Regulation requires counties to direct the majority of its Community Services and Supports funds to Full‑Service Partnerships (FSPs). FSPs are county coordinated plans, in collaboration with the client and the family to provide the full spectrum of community services. These services consist of mental health services and supports, such as peer support and crisis intervention services; and non-mental health services and supports, such as food, clothing, housing, and the cost of medical treatment;
- Prevention and Early Intervention: Provides services to mental health clients in order to help prevent mental illness from becoming severe and disabling;
- Innovation: Provides services and approaches that are creative in an effort to address mental health clients’ persistent issues, such as improving services for underserved or unserved populations within the community;
- Capital Facilities and Technological Needs: Creates additional county infrastructure such as additional clinics and facilities and/or development of a technological infrastructure for the mental health system, such as electronic health records for mental health services; and,
- Workforce Education and Training: Provides training for existing county mental health employees, outreach and recruitment to increase employment in the mental health system, and financial incentives to recruit or retain employees within the public mental health system.
Counties must submit their plans for approval to the MHSOAC before the counties may spend certain categories of funding including Prevention and Early Intervention and Innovation funds.
- Health Insurance Regulation. In California, regulation and oversight of fully insured employee health benefit plans is split between two state departments, the DMHC and CDI. The DMHC licenses and regulates the full scope of managed care models, including all health maintenance organizations in California, as well as preferred provider organizations (PPOs), exclusive provider organizations, point-of service products and MCMC plans. DMHC assesses and monitors health plan networks and delivery systems for compliance with the Knox-Keene Act. CDI has jurisdiction under the California Insurance Code over all other types of health insurance, including plans that offer traditional health insurance products, such as indemnity plans, and some PPO plans.
There are essentially three relevant regulatory frameworks for health insurance: state regulation by DMHC, by CDI; and, regulation of self-insured employee health benefit plans by the federal Department of Labor. Each regulator is governed by its own set of laws and consumers are caught in the middle sometimes guessing which laws and appeal rights apply. - Federal Mental Health Parity. In 1996, the U.S. Congress passed the Mental Health Parity Act (MHPA), which prohibits large group health plans from imposing higher annual or lifetime dollar limits on MH benefits. However, the MHPA did not mandate coverage for MH services and only applied to group health plans that offered MH benefits. The MHPA also did not apply to SUDs, services limits, limitations on the types of facilities covered, or differences in cost sharing, and plans could have stricter prior authorization requirements for MH services than for other medical services.
- State Mental Health Parity. In 1999, California passed AB 88 (Thompson), Chapter 534, Statutes of 1999, which requires a health plan contract or disability insurance policy to provide coverage for the diagnosis and medically necessary services of SMIs of a person of any age and of SEDs of a child. Benefits must be applied under the same terms and conditions as applied to other medical conditions. AB 88 also requires copayments, deductibles and maximum lifetime benefits to be applied equally to all benefits under the plan.
- Federal Act. In 2008, Congress passed the federal Act to cover some of the gaps in the MHPA. Similar to the MHPA, the Act only applies to large-group health plans. However, the federal Act also included Medicare Advantage plans offered through group health plans, state and local government plans, Medicaid managed care plans, and state Children’s Health Insurance Program plans. Unlike the MHPA, the federal Act prohibited differences in services limits, cost-sharing, in-and-out-of-network coverage, and applied to services for SUDs.
The federal Act requires, if health plans include services for MH/SUDs as part of their benefits, to provide those services under the same terms and conditions as other medical services. The federal Act eliminated all differences between MH/SUDs and other medical services as they related to services and visit limits; deductibles; copayments; coinsurance; and, the use of out-of-network providers when a health plan gave this option. Further, federal regulations in 2010 and then the final rule in 2013, prohibited health plans from imposing a financial requirement or services limit restriction that is more restrictive than what are offered for medical and surgical benefits in the same classification. Both DMHC and CDI provide regulatory oversight of federal and California parity laws and are monitoring filings for compliance with these laws. - The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) and EHBs. The ACA applied the federal Act to issuers in the individual market and qualified health plans offered through a health benefit exchange, including small group products. The ACA also specified coverage of the 10 EHBs, including MH/SUD treatment services. California’s EHB statute also specifically states that the federal Act applies to health plans that must comply with EHBs, including products offered off the exchange. The ACA states that coverage of MH/SUD services along with any scope and duration limits imposed on the benefits comply with the federal Act and all rules, regulations, and guidance issued pursuant to the federal Act. According to a 2015 Health Affairs Health Policy Brief, the ACA went beyond the federal Act by mandating coverage instead of requiring parity only if coverage is provided.
- Outcome Measurements and Accountability. As described above, California’s behavioral health system is complex, convoluted and more often than not, confusing - not only for those trying to access needed behavioral health services; but for those attempting to assess the system to determine how well the systems works, how the entities are performing and whether behavioral health is improving or worsening in the state. While there are performance contracts between the MCMCs and the counties and DHCS, they often do not address patient outcomes nor measure true performance across a defined set of outcome goals. This bill is attempting to develop that framework for oversight and accountability.
Additionally, Governor Newsom announced in March 2023, his plan to “Modernize California’s Behavioral Health System.” Among other major initiatives, the plan calls for greater fiscal accountability and oversight on county spending for behavioral health, greater fiscal transparency through enhanced reporting requirements, the development of specific outcome measurements, not just process measures but those aimed at driving toward meaningful and measurable system change and improved health outcomes. The Governor’s plan also calls for greater alignment between Medi-Cal (county provided mental health services whether through a MCMC or a MHP) and commercial coverage of behavioral health services requiring that DHCS and DMHC work collaboratively to develop a plan for achieving parity between commercial and Medi-Cal mental health and SUD benefits.
- Health Insurance Regulation. In California, regulation and oversight of fully insured employee health benefit plans is split between two state departments, the DMHC and CDI. The DMHC licenses and regulates the full scope of managed care models, including all health maintenance organizations in California, as well as preferred provider organizations (PPOs), exclusive provider organizations, point-of service products and MCMC plans. DMHC assesses and monitors health plan networks and delivery systems for compliance with the Knox-Keene Act. CDI has jurisdiction under the California Insurance Code over all other types of health insurance, including plans that offer traditional health insurance products, such as indemnity plans, and some PPO plans.
- SUPPORT. The California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions (CALBHB/C), in a support position states that performance measures and outcomes for mental/behavioral health programs are fundamental to making informed decisions. Increased standardization, analysis and communication of performance outcome data will help to ensure effective local and statewide review and implementation of behavioral health programs and services. CALBHB/C concludes that measuring performance related to life outcomes is key to understanding best practices, informing improvement plans, justifying local and statewide implementation and sustaining funding.
The Kennedy Forum, also in support states that recent initiatives such as the California Youth Behavioral Health Initiative, CARE Court, CalAIM and recent legislation have brought much-needed reforms to the behavioral health system of care. In addition, almost $4 billion in new investments have been made in additional behavioral health facilities and housing. It’s now critical that our systems of care are held accountable to ensure the effectiveness of these initiatives. This bill seeks to create a data-informed and community-driven continuous quality improvement framework for California’s public and private mental health and substance use care systems. The Kennedy Forum concludes that this bill requires counties and health plans to set ambitious goals and the state to monitor and publicly report their progress. - SUPPORT IF AMENDED. The Psychiatric Physicians Alliance of California (PPAC) in a support if amended position states that the need for outcomes and quality data to design behavioral health treatment strategies more effectively is readily apparent with 35,000 individuals with SMI homeless on our streets, another 100,000 receiving MH treatment in jails, and one in three prisoners or 26,000 of 90,000 individuals currently incarcerated. PPAC requests that the CHHSA workgroup provision in this bill be amended to include organizations representing psychiatric physicians who can bring medical expertise to the table. PPAC concludes that the additional of a psychiatric physicians makes sense given the centrality of medications to the SMI population, because people with SMI die on average 26 years earlier than their peers without SMI, often of treatable and preventable health conditions.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 686 (Arambula) of 2022 would have required CHHSA to establish, by July 1, 2023, the California Community-Based Behavioral Health Outcomes and Accountability Review (CBBH-OAR) to facilitate a local accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county behavioral health programs and in the collection and dissemination by the agency of best practices in service delivery. AB 686 would have require CHHSA to convene a workgroup to establish a work plan by which the CBBH-OAR would be conducted and to consult on various other components of the CBBH-OAR process. AB 686 died in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 970 (Eggman) of 2022 would have required the CHHSA to establish the California MHSA Outcomes and Accountability Review, with a dedicated workgroup tasked with establishing three specified components to assist county mental health programs in improving MHSA funded programs. SB 970 died on the Assembly Floor.
- SB 89 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 24, Statutes of 2017, established Cal-OAR to facilitate a local accountability system that fosters continuous quality improvement in county CalWORKs programs and in the collection and dissemination by DSS of best practices in service delivery.
- AMENDMENTS. As currently written, this bill references health plans which relates specifically to benefit plans following under the purview of the DMHC. It is the author’s intent that this bill would apply not only to health plans following under DMHC regulation; but also insurance plans which fall under the purview of the CDI. The Committee may want to consider amending the bill to ensure both DMHC regulated health plans and CDI regulated insurance plans are included in this bill.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
The Steinberg Institute (sponsor)
California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions
California Council on Community Behavioral Health Agencies
Health Access California
The Kennedy Forum
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Judith Babcock / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):