AB 486: Long-term health facilities: citation appeals.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-17
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-17: From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Long-Term Care, Health, Safety, and Security Act of 1973 generally requires the State Department of Public Health to license and regulate long-term health care facilities and to establish an inspection and reporting system to ensure that long-term health care facilities are in compliance with state statutes and regulations. The act divides violations into classes AA, A, and B, depending on the severity and probability of the harm resulting or that could result from the violation.
Under existing law, if a licensee decides to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee is required, within 15 business days of the service of the citation, to inform the director of the licensees intent to adjudicate the validity of the violation in the superior court, and to file that action within 90 days, as specified. Existing law requires a licensee who desires to contest a class B citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through specified department administrative adjudicatory procedures, or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration through the American Arbitration Association.
This bill would delete the civil action provisions for contesting a class AA or A citation, and would make those citation classifications subject to the administrative proceedings applicable for contesting a class B citation. The bill would authorize an administrative law judge to affirm, modify, or dismiss a citation, the class of a citation, or the proposed penalty. The bill would authorize a licensee to seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision. The bill would make related conforming changes and various technical, nonsubstantive changes. Notwithstanding those provisions, the bill would delay application of its changes with respect to contesting class AAand class A citations with respect to the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center as specified, until the earlier of January 1, 2025, 2026, or 30 days after the facility provides documentation to the department regarding its recertification to participate in the federal Medicare and Medicaid programs. Until that time, the bill would authorize the facility to appeal class AA and class A citations to the superior court in the same manner as provided under existing law, as specified. The bill would repeal that authorization on January 1, 2026.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center in the City and County of San Francisco.
The Long-Term Care, Health, Safety, and Security Act of 1973 generally requires the State Department of Public Health to license and regulate long-term health care facilities and to establish an inspection and reporting system to ensure that long-term health care facilities are in compliance with state statutes and regulations. The act divides violations into classes AA, A, and B, depending on the severity and probability of the harm resulting or that could result from the violation.
Under existing law, if a licensee decides to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee is required, within 15 business days of the service of the citation, to inform the director of the licensees intent to adjudicate the validity of the violation in the superior court, and to file that action within 90 days, as specified. Existing law requires a licensee who desires to contest a class B citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through specified department administrative adjudicatory procedures, or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration through the American Arbitration Association.
This bill would delete the civil action provisions for contesting a class AA or A citation, and would make those citation classifications subject to the administrative proceedings applicable for contesting a class B citation. The bill would authorize an administrative law judge to affirm, modify, or dismiss a citation, the class of a citation, or the proposed penalty. The bill would authorize a licensee to seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision. The bill would make related conforming changes and various technical, nonsubstantive changes. Notwithstanding those provisions, the bill would delay application of its changes with respect to contesting class AAand class A citations with respect to the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center as specified, until the earlier of January 1, 2025, or 30 days after the facility provides documentation to the department regarding its recertification to participate in the federal Medicare and Medicaid programs. Until that time, the bill would authorize the facility to appeal class AA and class A citations to the superior court in the same manner as provided under existing law, as specified. The bill would repeal that authorization on January 1, 2026.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center in the City and County of San Francisco.
The Long-Term Care, Health, Safety, and Security Act of 1973 generally requires the State Department of Public Health to license and regulate long-term health care facilities and to establish an inspection and reporting system to ensure that long-term health care facilities are in compliance with state statutes and regulations. The act divides violations into classes AA, A, and B, depending on the severity and probability of the harm resulting or that could result from the violation.
Under existing law, if a licensee decides to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee is required, within 15 business days of the service of the citation, to inform the director of the licensees intent to adjudicate the validity of the violation in the superior court, and to file that action within 90 days, as specified. Existing law requires a licensee who desires to contest a class B citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through specified department administrative adjudicatory procedures, or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration through the American Arbitration Association. Existing law authorizes a licensee that disagrees with the determination of an administrative law judge to seek judicial review.
This bill would delete the civil action provisions for contesting a class AA or A citation under these provisions, citation, and would make those citation classifications subject to the administrative proceedings applicable for contesting a class B citation. The bill would authorize an administrative law judge to affirm, modify, or dismiss a citation, the class of a citation, or the proposed penalty. The bill would authorize a licensee to seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision in the context of a class AA or A citation and would authorize a licensee to elect to submit the decision of an administrative law judge to arbitration for a class B citation. decision. The bill would make related conforming changes and various technical, nonsubstantive changes.
The Long-Term Care, Health, Safety, and Security Act of 1973 generally requires the State Department of Public Health to license and regulate long-term health care facilities and to establish an inspection and reporting system to ensure that long-term health care facilities are in compliance with state statutes and regulations. The act divides violations into classes AA, A, and B, depending on the severity and probability of the harm resulting or that could result from the violation.
The act defines a class A violation as a violation that the department determines presents either (1) imminent danger that death or serious harm to the patients or residents of the long-term health care facility would result therefrom, or (2) substantial probability that death or serious physical harm to patients or residents of the long-term health care facility would result therefrom. The act defines a class AA violation as a class A violation that the department determines to have been a substantial factor in the death of a resident of a long-term health care facility. The act defines a class B violation as a violation that the department determines has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of long-term health care facility patients or residents, other than class AA or A violations. Class B violations are also, unless otherwise determined by the department to be a class A violation, any violation of a patients rights as set forth in specified regulations that is determined by the department to cause, or under circumstances likely to cause, significant humiliation, indignity, anxiety, or other emotional trauma to a patient.Under existing law, if a licensee decides to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee is required, within 15 business days of the service of the citation, to inform the director of the licensees intent to adjudicate the validity of the violation in the superior court, and to file that action within 90 days, as specified. Existing law requires a licensee who desires to contest a class B citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through specified department administrative adjudicatory procedures, or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration through the American Arbitration Association. Existing law authorizes a licensee that disagrees with the determination of an administrative law judge to seek judicial review.
This bill would delete the civil action provisions for contesting a class AA or A citation under these provisions, and would make those citation classifications subject to the administrative proceedings applicable for contesting a class B citation. The bill would authorize an administrative law judge to affirm, modify, or dismiss a citation, the class of a citation, or the proposed penalty. The bill would authorize a licensee to seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision in the context of a class AA or A citation and would authorize a licensee to elect to submit the decision of an administrative law judge to arbitration for a class B citation. The bill would make related conforming changes and various technical, nonsubstantive changes.
The Long-Term Care, Health, Safety, and Security Act of 1973 generally requires the State Department of Public Health to license and regulate long-term health care facilities and to establish an inspection and reporting system to ensure that long-term health care facilities are in compliance with state statutes and regulations.
The act defines a class A violation as a violation that the department determines presents either (1) imminent danger that death or serious harm to the patients or residents of the long-term health care facility would result therefrom, or (2) substantial probability that death or serious physical harm to patients or residents of the long-term health care facility would result therefrom. The act defines a class AA violation as a class A violation that the department determines to have been a substantial factor in the death of a resident of a long-term health care facility. The act defines a class B violation as a violation that the department determines has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of long-term health care facility patients or residents, other than class AA or A violations. Class B violations are also, unless otherwise determined by the department to be a class A violation, any violation of a patients rights as set forth in specified regulations that is determined by the department to cause, or under circumstances likely to cause, significant humiliation, indignity, anxiety, or other emotional trauma to a patient.
Under existing law, if a licensee decides to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee is required, within 15 business days of the service of the citation, to inform the director of the licensees intent to adjudicate the validity of the violation in the superior court, and to file that action within 90 days, as specified. Existing law requires a licensee who desires to contest a class B citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through specified department administrative adjudicatory procedures, or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration through the American Arbitration Association.
This bill would delete the civil action provisions for contesting a class AA or A citation under these provisions, and would make those citation classifications subject to the administrative proceedings applicable for contesting a class B citation. The bill would make related conforming changes and various technical, nonsubstantive changes.
(a)If the licensee desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty therefor, the licensee shall use the processes described in subdivision (b) for class AA or A citations, or subdivision (c) for class B citations.
(b)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171. 131071. The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may seek judicial review of the decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(c)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class B citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171 131071 or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration in accordance with paragraph (2).
The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty. The licensee may choose to have their appeal heard by the administrative law judge or submit the matter to binding arbitration by notifying the director in writing within 15 business days of the service of the citation. The licensee may seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may, in lieu of seeking judicial review of the decision as provided in Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, elect to submit the matter to binding arbitration by filing, within 60 days of its receipt of the decision, a request for arbitration with the American Arbitration Association. The parties shall agree upon an arbitrator designated from the American Arbitration Association in accordance with the associations established rules and procedures. The arbitration hearing shall be set within 45 days of the election to arbitrate, but in no event less than 28 days from the date of selection of an arbitrator. The arbitration hearing may be continued up to 15 additional days if necessary at the arbitrators discretion. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this subdivision, the arbitration hearing shall be conducted in accordance with the American Arbitration Associations established rules and procedures. The arbitrator shall determine whether the licensee violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and whether the citation meets the criteria established in Sections 1423 and 1424. If the arbitrator determines that the licensee has violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and that the class of the citation should be upheld, the proposed assessment of a civil penalty shall be affirmed, subject to the limitations established in Section 1424. The licensee and the department shall each bear its respective portion of the cost of arbitration. A resident, or the residents designated representative, or both, may make an oral or written statement regarding the citation, at any arbitration hearing to which the matter has been submitted.
(d)If an appeal is prosecuted under this section, including an appeal taken in accordance with Section 100171, 131071, the department shall have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the alleged violation did occur, (2) the alleged violation met the criteria for the class of citation alleged, and (3) the assessed penalty was appropriate. The department shall also have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the assessment of a civil penalty should be upheld. If a licensee appeals a contested citation or the assessment of a civil penalty, the civil penalty shall not be due and payable unless and until the appeal is terminated in favor of the department.
(e)In assessing the civil penalty for a violation, all relevant facts shall be considered, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The probability and severity of the risk which the violation presents to the patients or residents mental and physical condition.
(2)The patients or residents medical condition.
(3)The patients or residents mental condition and history of mental disability.
(4)The good faith efforts exercised by the facility to prevent the violation from occurring.
(5)The licensees history of compliance with regulations.
(f)Except as otherwise provided in this subdivision, an assessment of civil penalties for a class A or class B violation shall be trebled and collected for a second and subsequent violation for which a citation of the same class was issued within any 12-month period. Trebling shall occur only if the first citation issued within the 12-month period was issued in the same class, a civil penalty was assessed, and a plan of correction was submitted for the previous same-class violation occurring within the period, without regard to whether the action to enforce the previous citation has become final. However, the increment to the civil penalty required by this subdivision shall not be due and payable unless and until the previous action has terminated in favor of the department.
If the class B citation is issued for a patients rights violation, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 1424, it shall not be trebled unless the department determines the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, security, or welfare of long-term health care facility residents.
(g)The director shall prescribe procedures for the issuance of a notice of violation with respect to violations having only a minimal relationship to safety or health.
(h)Actions brought under this chapter shall be set for hearing by an administrative law judge at the earliest possible date and shall take precedence over all other matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. In addition, actions for class AA and A violations shall take precedence over actions for class B violations. Times for responsive pleading and for hearing the proceeding shall be set by the administrative law judge, pursuant to Section 100171, 131071, with the object of securing a decision as to subject matters at the earliest possible time.
(i)If the citation is dismissed, the department shall take action immediately to ensure that the public records reflect in a prominent manner that the citation was dismissed.
(j)Penalties paid on violations under this chapter shall be applied against the departments accounts to offset any costs incurred by the state pursuant to this chapter. Any costs or penalties assessed pursuant to this chapter shall be paid within 30 days of the date the decision becomes final. If a facility does not comply with this requirement, the department shall withhold any payment under the Medi-Cal program until the debt is satisfied. Payment shall not be withheld if the department determines that it would cause undue hardship to the facility or to patients or residents of the facility.
SEC. 2.Section 1428.3 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1428.3.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 1428, if the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center in the City and County of San Francisco is decertified by the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services as of January 1, 2024, that facility may continue to appeal class A and AA citations to the superior court in accordance with the requirements of subdivision (b) of Section 1428, as amended by Section 5 of Chapter 729 of the Statutes of 2011, until January 1, 2026, or 30 days after the date the licensee provides the State Department of Public Health with documentation that the facility has been recertified to participate in both the federal Medicare and Medicaid programs, whichever occurs first.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution, because of the unique circumstances facing the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center while it focuses on the demands associated with its application for recertification from the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, in addition to continuing its daily operations.
(a)If the licensee desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty therefor, the licensee shall use the processes described in subdivision (b) for class AA or A citations, or subdivision (c) for class B citations.
(b)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171. The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may seek judicial review of the decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(c)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class B citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171 or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration in accordance with paragraph (2).
The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty. The licensee may choose to have their appeal heard by the administrative law judge or submit the matter to binding arbitration by notifying the director in writing within 15 business days of the service of the citation. The licensee may seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may, in lieu of seeking judicial review of the decision as provided in Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, elect to submit the matter to binding arbitration by filing, within 60 days of its receipt of the decision, a request for arbitration with the American Arbitration Association. The parties shall agree upon an arbitrator designated from the American Arbitration Association in accordance with the associations established rules and procedures. The arbitration hearing shall be set within 45 days of the election to arbitrate, but in no event less than 28 days from the date of selection of an arbitrator. The arbitration hearing may be continued up to 15 additional days if necessary at the arbitrators discretion. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this subdivision, the arbitration hearing shall be conducted in accordance with the American Arbitration Associations established rules and procedures. The arbitrator shall determine whether the licensee violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and whether the citation meets the criteria established in Sections 1423 and 1424. If the arbitrator determines that the licensee has violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and that the class of the citation should be upheld, the proposed assessment of a civil penalty shall be affirmed, subject to the limitations established in Section 1424. The licensee and the department shall each bear its respective portion of the cost of arbitration. A resident, or the residents designated representative, or both, may make an oral or written statement regarding the citation, at any arbitration hearing to which the matter has been submitted.
(d)If an appeal is prosecuted under this section, including an appeal taken in accordance with Section 100171, the department shall have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the alleged violation did occur, (2) the alleged violation met the criteria for the class of citation alleged, and (3) the assessed penalty was appropriate. The department shall also have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the assessment of a civil penalty should be upheld. If a licensee appeals a contested citation or the assessment of a civil penalty, the civil penalty shall not be due and payable unless and until the appeal is terminated in favor of the department.
(e)In assessing the civil penalty for a violation, all relevant facts shall be considered, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The probability and severity of the risk which the violation presents to the patients or residents mental and physical condition.
(2)The patients or residents medical condition.
(3)The patients or residents mental condition and history of mental disability.
(4)The good faith efforts exercised by the facility to prevent the violation from occurring.
(5)The licensees history of compliance with regulations.
(f)Except as otherwise provided in this subdivision, an assessment of civil penalties for a class A or class B violation shall be trebled and collected for a second and subsequent violation for which a citation of the same class was issued within any 12-month period. Trebling shall occur only if the first citation issued within the 12-month period was issued in the same class, a civil penalty was assessed, and a plan of correction was submitted for the previous same-class violation occurring within the period, without regard to whether the action to enforce the previous citation has become final. However, the increment to the civil penalty required by this subdivision shall not be due and payable unless and until the previous action has terminated in favor of the department.
If the class B citation is issued for a patients rights violation, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 1424, it shall not be trebled unless the department determines the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, security, or welfare of long-term health care facility residents.
(g)The director shall prescribe procedures for the issuance of a notice of violation with respect to violations having only a minimal relationship to safety or health.
(h)Actions brought under this chapter shall be set for hearing by an administrative law judge at the earliest possible date and shall take precedence over all other matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. In addition, actions for class AA and A violations shall take precedence over actions for class B violations. Times for responsive pleading and for hearing the proceeding shall be set by the administrative law judge, pursuant to Section 100171, with the object of securing a decision as to subject matters at the earliest possible time.
(i)If the citation is dismissed, the department shall take action immediately to ensure that the public records reflect in a prominent manner that the citation was dismissed.
(j)Penalties paid on violations under this chapter shall be applied against the departments accounts to offset any costs incurred by the state pursuant to this chapter. Any costs or penalties assessed pursuant to this chapter shall be paid within 30 days of the date the decision becomes final. If a facility does not comply with this requirement, the state department shall withhold any payment under the Medi-Cal program until the debt is satisfied. Payment shall not be withheld if the department determines that it would cause undue hardship to the facility or to patients or residents of the facility.
SEC. 2.Section 1428.3 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:1428.3.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 1428, if the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center in the City and County of San Francisco is decertified by the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services as of January 1, 2024, that facility may continue to appeal class A and AA citations to the superior court in accordance with the requirements of subdivision (b) of Section 1428, as amended by Section 5 of Chapter 729 of the Statutes of 2011, until January 1, 2026, or 30 days after the date the licensee provides the State Department of Public Health with documentation that the facility has been recertified to participate in both the federal Medicare and Medicaid programs, whichever occurs first.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution, because of the unique circumstances facing the Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center while it focuses on the demands associated with its application for recertification from the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, in addition to continuing its daily operations.
(a)If the licensee desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty therefor, the licensee shall use the processes described in subdivision (b) for class AA or A citations, or subdivision (c) for class B citations.
(b)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171. The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may seek judicial review of the decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(c)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class B citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171 or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration in accordance with paragraph (2).
The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty. The licensee may choose to have their appeal heard by the administrative law judge or submit the matter to binding arbitration by notifying the director in writing within 15 business days of the service of the citation. The licensee may seek judicial review of an administrative law judges decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may may, in lieu of seeking judicial review of the decision as provided in Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, elect to submit the matter to binding arbitration by filing, within 60 days of its receipt of the decision, a request for arbitration with the American Arbitration Association. The parties shall agree upon an arbitrator designated from the American Arbitration Association in accordance with the associations established rules and procedures. The arbitration hearing shall be set within 45 days of the election to arbitrate, but in no event less than 28 days from the date of selection of an arbitrator. The arbitration hearing may be continued up to 15 additional days if necessary at the arbitrators discretion. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this subdivision, the arbitration hearing shall be conducted in accordance with the American Arbitration Associations established rules and procedures. The arbitrator shall determine whether the licensee violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and whether the citation meets the criteria established in Sections 1423 and 1424. If the arbitrator determines that the licensee has violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and that the class of the citation should be upheld, the proposed assessment of a civil penalty shall be affirmed, subject to the limitations established in Section 1424. The licensee and the department shall each bear its respective portion of the cost of arbitration. A resident, or the residents designated representative, or both, may make an oral or written statement regarding the citation, at any arbitration hearing to which the matter has been submitted.
(d)If an appeal is prosecuted under this section, including an appeal taken in accordance with Section 100171, the department shall have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the alleged violation did occur, (2) the alleged violation met the criteria for the class of citation alleged, and (3) the assessed penalty was appropriate. The department shall also have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the assessment of a civil penalty should be upheld. If a licensee appeals a contested citation or the assessment of a civil penalty, the civil penalty shall not be due and payable unless and until the appeal is terminated in favor of the department.
(e)In assessing the civil penalty for a violation, all relevant facts shall be considered, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The probability and severity of the risk which the violation presents to the patients or residents mental and physical condition.
(2)The patients or residents medical condition.
(3)The patients or residents mental condition and history of mental disability.
(4)The good faith efforts exercised by the facility to prevent the violation from occurring.
(5)The licensees history of compliance with regulations.
(f)Except as otherwise provided in this subdivision, an assessment of civil penalties for a class A or class B violation shall be trebled and collected for a second and subsequent violation for which a citation of the same class was issued within any 12-month period. Trebling shall occur only if the first citation issued within the 12-month period was issued in the same class, a civil penalty was assessed, and a plan of correction was submitted for the previous same-class violation occurring within the period, without regard to whether the action to enforce the previous citation has become final. However, the increment to the civil penalty required by this subdivision shall not be due and payable unless and until the previous action has terminated in favor of the department.
If the class B citation is issued for a patients rights violation, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 1424, it shall not be trebled unless the department determines the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, security, or welfare of long-term health care facility residents.
(g)The director shall prescribe procedures for the issuance of a notice of violation with respect to violations having only a minimal relationship to safety or health.
(h)Actions brought under this chapter shall be set for hearing by an administrative law judge at the earliest possible date and shall take precedence over all other matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. In addition, actions for class AA and A violations shall take precedence over actions for class B violations. Times for responsive pleading and for hearing the proceeding shall be set by the administrative law judge, pursuant to Section 100171, with the object of securing a decision as to subject matters at the earliest possible time.
(i)If the citation is dismissed, the department shall take action immediately to ensure that the public records reflect in a prominent manner that the citation was dismissed.
(j)Penalties paid on violations under this chapter shall be applied against the departments accounts to offset any costs incurred by the state pursuant to this chapter. Any costs or penalties assessed pursuant to this chapter shall be paid within 30 days of the date the decision becomes final. If a facility does not comply with this requirement, the state department shall withhold any payment under the Medi-Cal program until the debt is satisfied. Payment shall not be withheld if the department determines that it would cause undue hardship to the facility or to patients or residents of the facility.
(a)If the licensee desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty therefor, the licensee shall use the processes described in subdivision (b) for classes AA, A, or class AA or A citations, or subdivision (c) for class B citations.
(b)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171. The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty.
(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may seek judicial review of the decision pursuant to Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(2)(c)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class B citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171 or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration in accordance with subdivision (c). paragraph (2).
(3)The
The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the level class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty. The licensee may choose to have their appeal heard by the administrative law judge or submit the matter to binding arbitration by notifying the director in writing within 15 business days of the service of the citation.
(c)(2)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may, in lieu of seeking judicial review of the decision as provided in Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, may elect to submit the matter to binding arbitration by filing, within 60 days of its receipt of the decision, a request for arbitration with the American Arbitration Association. The parties shall agree upon an arbitrator designated from the American Arbitration Association in accordance with the associations established rules and procedures. The arbitration hearing shall be set within 45 days of the election to arbitrate, but in no event less than 28 days from the date of selection of an arbitrator. The arbitration hearing may be continued up to 15 additional days if necessary at the arbitrators discretion. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this subdivision, the arbitration hearing shall be conducted in accordance with the American Arbitration Associations established rules and procedures. The arbitrator shall determine whether the licensee violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and whether the citation meets the criteria established in Sections 1423 and 1424. If the arbitrator determines that the licensee has violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and that the class of the citation should be upheld, the proposed assessment of a civil penalty shall be affirmed, subject to the limitations established in Section 1424. The licensee and the department shall each bear its respective portion of the cost of arbitration. A resident, or the residents designated representative, or both, may make an oral or written statement regarding the citation, at any arbitration hearing to which the matter has been submitted.
(d)If an appeal is prosecuted under this section, including an appeal taken in accordance with Section 100171, the department shall have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the alleged violation did occur, (2) the alleged violation met the criteria for the class of citation alleged, and (3) the assessed penalty was appropriate. The department shall also have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the assessment of a civil penalty should be upheld. If a licensee appeals a contested citation or the assessment of a civil penalty, the civil penalty shall not be due and payable unless and until the appeal is terminated in favor of the department.
(e)In assessing the civil penalty for a violation, all relevant facts shall be considered, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The probability and severity of the risk which the violation presents to the patients or residents mental and physical condition.
(2)The patients or residents medical condition.
(3)The patients or residents mental condition and history of mental disability.
(4)The good faith efforts exercised by the facility to prevent the violation from occurring.
(5)The licensees history of compliance with regulations.
(f)Except as otherwise provided in this subdivision, an assessment of civil penalties for a class A or class B violation shall be trebled and collected for a second and subsequent violation for which a citation of the same class was issued within any 12-month period. Trebling shall occur only if the first citation issued within the 12-month period was issued in the same class, a civil penalty was assessed, and a plan of correction was submitted for the previous same-class violation occurring within the period, without regard to whether the action to enforce the previous citation has become final. However, the increment to the civil penalty required by this subdivision shall not be due and payable unless and until the previous action has terminated in favor of the department.
If the class B citation is issued for a patients rights violation, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 1424, it shall not be trebled unless the department determines the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, security, or welfare of long-term health care facility residents.
(g)The director shall prescribe procedures for the issuance of a notice of violation with respect to violations having only a minimal relationship to safety or health.
(h)Actions brought under this chapter shall be set for hearing by an administrative law judge at the earliest possible date and shall take precedence over all other matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. In addition, actions for class AA and A violations shall take precedence over actions for class B violations. Times for responsive pleading and for hearing the proceeding shall be set by the administrative law judge, pursuant to Section 100171, with the object of securing a decision as to subject matters at the earliest possible time.
(i)If the citation is dismissed, the department shall take action immediately to ensure that the public records reflect in a prominent manner that the citation was dismissed.
(j)Penalties paid on violations under this chapter shall be applied against the departments accounts to offset any costs incurred by the state pursuant to this chapter. Any costs or penalties assessed pursuant to this chapter shall be paid within 30 days of the date the decision becomes final. If a facility does not comply with this requirement, the state department shall withhold any payment under the Medi-Cal program until the debt is satisfied. Payment shall not be withheld if the department determines that it would cause undue hardship to the facility or to patients or residents of the facility.
(a)If the licensee desires to contest a citation or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty therefor, the licensee shall use the processes described in subdivisions (b) and (c) subdivision (b) for classes AA, A, or B citations.
(b)If a licensee intends to contest a class AA or a class A citation, the licensee shall inform the director in writing, within 15 business days of the service of the citation of the licensees intent to adjudicate the validity of the citation in the superior court in the county in which the long-term health care facility is located. In order to perfect a judicial appeal of a contested citation, a licensee shall file a civil action in the superior court in the county in which the long-term health care facility is located. The action shall be filed no later than 90 calendar days after a licensee notifies the director that he or she intends to contest the citation, and served not later than 90 days after filing. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a licensee prosecuting a judicial appeal shall file and serve a case management statement pursuant to Rule 212 of the California Rules of Court within six months after the department files its answer in the appeal. Notwithstanding subdivision (d), the court shall dismiss the appeal upon motion of the department if the case management statement is not filed by the licensee within the period specified. The court may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the level of the citation, or the amount of the proposed assessment of the civil penalty.(b)(1)If a licensee desires to contest a class AA or A citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171.
(c)(2)If a licensee desires to contest a class B citation, the licensee shall, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify the director or the directors designee that he or she the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the procedures set forth in Section 100171 or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration in accordance with subdivision (d). (c). The
(3)The administrative law judge may affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation citation, the level of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty. The licensee may choose to have his or her their appeal heard by the administrative law judge or submit the matter to binding arbitration by notifying the director in writing within 15 business days of the service of the citation.
(d)(c)If a licensee is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, the licensee may, in lieu of seeking judicial review of the decision as provided in Section 1094.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, elect to submit the matter to binding arbitration by filing, within 60 days of its receipt of the decision, a request for arbitration with the American Arbitration Association. The parties shall agree upon an arbitrator designated from the American Arbitration Association in accordance with the associations established rules and procedures. The arbitration hearing shall be set within 45 days of the election to arbitrate, but in no event less than 28 days from the date of selection of an arbitrator. The arbitration hearing may be continued up to 15 additional days if necessary at the arbitrators discretion. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this subdivision, the arbitration hearing shall be conducted in accordance with the American Arbitration Associations established rules and procedures. The arbitrator shall determine whether the licensee violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and whether the citation meets the criteria established in Sections 1423 and 1424. If the arbitrator determines that the licensee has violated the regulation or regulations cited by the department, and that the class of the citation should be upheld, the proposed assessment of a civil penalty shall be affirmed, subject to the limitations established in Section 1424. The licensee and the department shall each bear its respective portion of the cost of arbitration. A resident, or his or her the residents designated representative, or both, may make an oral or written statement regarding the citation, at any arbitration hearing to which the matter has been submitted.
(e)(d)If an appeal is prosecuted under this section, including an appeal taken in accordance with Section 100171, the department shall have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the alleged violation did occur, (2) the alleged violation met the criteria for the class of citation alleged, and (3) the assessed penalty was appropriate. The department shall also have the burden of establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the assessment of a civil penalty should be upheld. If a licensee appeals a contested citation or the assessment of a civil penalty, no civil penalty shall the civil penalty shall not be due and payable unless and until the appeal is terminated in favor of the department.
(f)(e)In assessing the civil penalty for a violation, all relevant facts shall be considered, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The probability and severity of the risk which the violation presents to the patients or residents mental and physical condition.
(2)The patients or residents medical condition.
(3)The patients or residents mental condition and his or her history of mental disability.
(4)The good faith efforts exercised by the facility to prevent the violation from occurring.
(5)The licensees history of compliance with regulations.
(g)(f)Except as otherwise provided in this subdivision, an assessment of civil penalties for a class A or class B violation shall be trebled and collected for a second and subsequent violation for which a citation of the same class was issued within any 12-month period. Trebling shall occur only if the first citation issued within the 12-month period was issued in the same class, a civil penalty was assessed, and a plan of correction was submitted for the previous same-class violation occurring within the period, without regard to whether the action to enforce the previous citation has become final. However, the increment to the civil penalty required by this subdivision shall not be due and payable unless and until the previous action has terminated in favor of the department.
If the class B citation is issued for a patients rights violation, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 1424, it shall not be trebled unless the department determines the violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, security, or welfare of long-term health care facility residents.
(h)(g)The director shall prescribe procedures for the issuance of a notice of violation with respect to violations having only a minimal relationship to safety or health.
(i)(h)Actions brought under this chapter shall be set for trial hearing by an administrative law judge at the earliest possible date and shall take precedence on the court calendar over all other cases except matters matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. In addition, actions for class AA and A violations shall take precedence over actions for class B violations. Times for responsive pleading and for hearing the proceeding shall be set by the judge of the court administrative law judge, pursuant to Section 100171, with the object of securing a decision as to subject matters at the earliest possible time.
(j)(i)If the citation is dismissed, the department shall take action immediately to ensure that the public records reflect in a prominent manner that the citation was dismissed.
(k)(j)Penalties paid on violations under this chapter shall be applied against the departments accounts to offset any costs incurred by the state pursuant to this chapter. Any costs or penalties assessed pursuant to this chapter shall be paid within 30 days of the date the decision becomes final. If a facility does not comply with this requirement, the state department shall withhold any payment under the Medi-Cal program until the debt is satisfied. No payment shall Payment shall not be withheld if the department determines that it would cause undue hardship to the facility or to patients or residents of the facility.
(l) The amendments made to subdivisions (a) and (c) of this section by Chapter 84 of the Statutes of 1988, to extend the number of days allowed for the provision of notification to the director, do not affect the right, that is also contained in those amendments, to request judicial relief from these time limits.(m) If a licensee exercises its right to a citation review conference prior to January 1, 2012, the citation review conference and all notices, reviews, and appeals thereof shall be conducted pursuant to this section as it read on December 31, 2011.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 17, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 11, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 3, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 29, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (June 28). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 61. Noes 17. Page 2005.) |
| May 22, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1684.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 3.) (May 18). |
| May 18, 2023 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1580.) |
| May 17, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 3, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 22, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 8, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 10. |
| Feb 7, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 28, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 486 Kalra Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AARP | ** Support | |
| Association Of Regional Center Agencies | ** Support | |
| Attorney General Rob Bonta | ** Support | |
| California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform | ** Support | |
| California Foundation For Independent Living Centers | ** Support | |
| California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association | ** Support | |
| Caring Across Generations | ** Support | |
| Choice in Aging | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Support | |
| Family Caregiver Alliance | ** Support | |
| Hand in Hand: The Domestic Employers Network | ** Support | |
| Justice in Aging | ** Support | |
| Placer Independent Resource Services | ** Support | |
| UDW/AFSCME Local 3930 | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Susan Talamantes Eggman, Chair
BILL NO: AB 486
AUTHOR: | Kalra | ||
VERSION: | May 22, 2023 | ||
HEARING DATE: | June 28, 2023 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Long-term health facilities: citation appeals
SUMMARY:
Repeals the process whereby long-term care facilities can appeal more severe types of citations by filing a civil action in the superior court, and instead subjects these appeals to hearings by an administrative law judge that are currently used for lower level citations.
Existing law:
- Licenses and regulates long-term care (LTC) facilities by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). LTC facilities include skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), intermediate care facilities (ICFs), ICF/developmentally disabled (ICF/DD), ICF/DD-habilitative, ICF/DD-nursing, and congregate living health facilities. [HSC §1250, et seq., and §1418]
- Establishes a civil penalty structure for LTC facilities, categorized into “AA,” “A,” and “B” violations: “A” violations are where CDPH determines that the violation presents either imminent danger of death or serious harm, or a substantial probability that death or serious harm to residents would result; “AA” violations (the most severe) are those that meet the criteria for a class “A” violation that CDPH determines was a direct proximate cause of the death of a resident of an LTC facility; and, “B” violations are those that CDPH determines have a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of LTC facility residents. [HSC §1424]
- Requires the LTC facility licensee, if CDPH meets the burden of proof in 2) above, to have the burden of proving that the licensee did what might reasonably be expected of an LTC, acting under similar circumstances, to comply with the regulation, and if the licensee sustains this burden, requires the citation to be dismissed. [HSC §1424]
- Establishes citation penalty amounts, which have a lower range for ICF/DDs and congregate living health facilities, and a higher range for SNFs and ICFs. The higher penalty range for SNFs and ICFs is as follows:
- “B” violation penalties range from $150 to $3,000;
- “A” violation penalties range from $3,500 to $25,000, or, if an “A” citation involves the death of a resident, from $15,000 to $60,000; and,
- “AA” violation penalties range from $30,000 to $120,000. [HSC §1424.5]
- Requires CDPH, for a second or subsequent “AA” citation of a SNF or ICF within a 24-month period, to commence action to suspend or revoke the facility’s license. [HSC §1424.5(a)(1)]
- Provides for an appeal process for citations as follows:
- For “B” citations, permits the LTC facility to notify CDPH within 15 working days of a citation that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation through the administrative adjudication provisions of the Administrative Procedures Act before an administrative law judge (ALJ), as specified, or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration by the American Arbitration Association, as specified; and,
- For “A” and “AA” citations, requires an LTC facility wishing to contest a citation to notify CDPH within 15 business of receiving the citation, and then to file a civil action in the superior court in the county in which the LTC facility is located. Requires the action to be filed no later than 90 calendar days after notification that the facility intends to contest the citation, and served no later than 90 days after filing. Requires the LTC facility to serve a case management statement, as specified, within six months after the department files its answer in the appeal, and requires the court to dismiss the appeal if the case management statement is not filed by the licensee within the period specified. Permits the court to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation. [HSC §1428(b) and (c)]
- Establish a process to seek a writ of administrative mandate by a state court for the purpose of inquiring into the validity of any final administrative order or decision made as the result of a proceeding in which a hearing is required to be given. Requires the inquiry to extend to whether the respondent has proceeding in excess of jurisdiction, whether there was a fair trial, or whether there was any prejudicial abuse or discretion, such as if the decision is not supported by the findings, or the findings are not supported by the evidence. Permits the court, when it finds there is relevant evidence that could not have been produced or that was improperly excluded at the hearing, to remand the case to be reconsidered in the light of that evidence, or to admit the evidence at the hearing on the writ without remanding the case. [CCP §1094.5]
This bill:
- Revises the manner in which LTC facilities can appeal citations issued by CDPH by repealing a process whereby, in the case of “A” or AA” citations, the licensee files a civil action in the superior court to contest the citation, and instead subjects these appeals to the same administrative adjudication by an administrative law judge that is used for “B” violations.
- Permits an LTC facility, if it is dissatisfied with the decision of the administrative law judge, to seek judicial review of the decision via a writ of administrative mandate in state court.
- Revises provisions of law that required court appeals governing “A” and “AA” citations to take precedence on the court calendar unless specific laws grant matters equal or superior precedence, to instead require hearings by an administrative law judge to take precedence in the same manner. Requires, additionally, that “A” and “AA” violations take precedence over “B” violations.
- Makes other minor clarifying and conforming changes to the provisions of law governing citation appeals for LTC facilities.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to Assembly Appropriations Committee, CDPH estimates the fiscal effect of this bill to range from annual ongoing savings of approximately $500,000 to annual ongoing costs of $1.6 million (Licensing and Certification Fund). On average, CDPH issues 141 AA and A citations and handles 64 appeals per year. Of the appeals, 61 settle before trial, three go to full trial, and one results in an appeal of the superior court decision. CDPH anticipates an increase in the average annual number of appeals to 85 appeals, of which approximately 67% (57 appeals) would settle during the pre-hearing process, 33% (28 appeals) would go to full hearing before an ALJ, and 16% (14 appeals) would go to judicial review. The cost range reflects costs and savings in relation to the current process, depending on whether the Office of the Attorney General (AG) or CDPH’s Office of Legal Services (OLS) would assume responsibility for litigating AA and A citation appeals in the administrative forum. If the AG handles the litigation, CDPH estimates a total net cost of approximately $1.6 million annually ongoing, including three new positions and external services provided by the OAG, an administrative tribunal, and other potential expert contracts. This estimate reflects total new costs of $5.1 million and four positions required to implement this bill, less $3.5 million and one position for activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate.
If CDPH’s attorneys handle the litigation, CDPH estimates a total net savings of approximately $500,000 annually ongoing, including seven new positions and external services provided by litigation contractors. This reflects the total new costs of $3.1 million and eight positions required to implement this bill, less $3.6 million and one position from activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 61 - 17 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 11 - 3 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 11 - 4 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, this bill strengthens oversight of nursing homes. California is an outlier among other states by granting nursing home facilities the right to challenge citations and fines for the most serious violations linked to a resident death or the substantial probability of death in our overburdened court system. This bill moves appeals to an out-of-court administrative hearing in front of an ALJ, who can fairly assess the evidence in a more efficient timeline that will result in a just, cost-effective resolution for all parties. This bill gives relief to our backlogged judicial system, while retaining a facilities’ due process rights to file a writ of mandate for judicial review of an ALJ’s decision. By making this long overdue change, this bill allows our state regulators to more effectively hold negligent facilities accountable so quality care for future residents can be improved.
- Data on appeals of “A” and “AA” citations. According to information provided to the author by CDPH, between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2021, facilities appealed 668 Class AA or A citations out of a total of 1,474 Class AA or A citations issued. Of the 668 appeals, 292 (44%) had no decrease in fine amount or citation level, and in 5 (0.7%) the facility prevailed and the citation was dismissed. Of the remainder, 139 (21%) were downgraded to a lower level of citation, and 341 (51%) had a reduced penalty amount. CDPH stated that these numbers are based on the previous penalty standards, and may change once CDPH has had the opportunity to determine the impacts of AB 323 (Kalra, Chapter 458, Statutes of 2021), which changed the standards effective for violations taking place on or after January 1, 2022.
- Background on Office of Administrative Hearings. The Office of Administrative Hearings (OAH) is a quasi-judicial tribunal that hears administrative disputes. Established by the California Legislature in 1945, OAH provides independent ALJs to conduct hearings for more than 1,500 state and local government agencies. OAH provides both adjudication and alternative dispute resolution services. According to OAH, the ALJs are fully independent of the agencies whose attorneys appear before them, and an ALJ as the same relationship with each party – that of a neutral fact finder. All OAH ALJs are required to have practiced law for at least five years before being appointed, and typically have more than ten years of experience.
The author and sponsor state that the administrative hearing process is what is used for practically all administrative citation appeals, including by the Department of Social Services which licenses residential care facilities for the elderly. Hospitals that are issued “immediate jeopardy” citations by CDPH, which can be up to $75,000 for a first violation and as high as $125,000 for repeated violations, are also limited to the administrative hearing process to contest these citations. - Current administrative hearing process for Class “B” citations. Class B violations are issued by CDPH’s Center for Health Care Quality district offices to facilities along with a notification of appeal rights. The district offices determine the appropriate penalty amount based on the conduct and the facility’s compliance history. The facility can immediately pay the penalty at a reduced cost (65% of the penalty amount), or, the facility has 15 days to appeal and has the choice of binding arbitration or an administrative hearing. The facility sends their appeal to CDPH’s OLS. OLS prepares an accusation (similar to a complaint in civil court) that is served on the facility, along with a notice of defense (similar to an answer in civil court). The facility has 20 days to return the notice of defense. If the facility does not return the notice of defense, CDPH will take a default judgment. If the notice of defense is returned, OLS communicates with the facility or facility counsel on potential settlement options. If settlement efforts are unsuccessful, OLS will request a hearing date from OAH (typically within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defense). OAH assigns an ALJ and sets a hearing date. The parties exchange discovery, which in administrative cases, consists solely of a document exchange, and prepare for hearing. Most B citation matters are resolved through settlement efforts after discovery is exchanged. If a B citation goes to hearing, the ALJ issues a proposed decision (the Administrative Procedure Act requires 30 days, but it is usually longer). At hearing, the Administrative Procedures Act allows for administrative hearsay, which reduces the number of witnesses that need to testify. The ALJ sends the proposed decision to CDPH Public Health Programs team, who advises the Director on the review of the proposed decision. CDPH has 100 days to review the proposed decision and either accept, reject, or amend the decision.
Under the provisions of this bill, facilities with “A” and “AA” citations dissatisfied with the OAH process may file a writ of administrative mandate in a superior court that will review the factual/evidentiary record from the OAH hearing to determine if the process was fair. Unlike an initial judicial proceeding that LTC facilities can appeal to under current law, a writ is limited in scope and less time consuming because there is no discovery process. However, the court in a writ case may permit additional evidence if it is new evidence that, “in the exercise of reasonable diligence, could not have been produced or that was improperly excluded at the hearing.” - State Auditor Report. The State Auditor published a report in May 2018, “Absent Effective State Oversight, Substandard Quality of Care Has Continued.” According to the audit, the state has not adequately addressed ongoing deficiencies related to the quality of care that LTC facilities provide. The report pointed out that between 2006 and 2015, the number of federal deficiencies that CDPH identified at LTCs increased by more than 30%. However, during the same time period, the number of state citations (B, A, and AA citations) decreased by 34%. According to the report, CDPH stated that the burden of proof required for state citations is higher than for federal deficiencies. The audit made several recommendations to the Legislature regarding actions that could be taken to improve the quality of care in LTC facilities, one of which was increasing the amount of state penalties by the amount of inflation. If the Legislature revised existing penalty amounts for inflation, a $100,000 fine, the maximum state penalty amount for a violation resulting in patient death, would increase to $146,000.
- Report by Disability Rights California (DRC). DRC, which is sponsoring this bill, is a private nonprofit corporation that has been designated, pursuant to federal law, as the protection and advocacy agency in California for the rights of persons with disabilities. DRC released a report in January 2017 entitled “Keeping Nursing Home Residents Safe: The State Must Hold Nursing Homes Accountable for Resident Deaths.” According to this report, DRC analyzed hundreds of cases in which CDPH issued lower level citations for deaths (rather than an AA citation) where the conduct of the nursing home staff directly contributed to the residents’ deaths. DRC found that CDPH failed to consistently apply the same citation level when staff misconduct is a direct proximate cause of a resident’s death, and that CDPH appears to lack consistent standards for issuing citations in the case of a resident’s death. According to this report, DRC reviewed citations issued between 2000 and 2014, including 1,744 Class A violations, of which 287 involved patient deaths. DRC concluded that deaths in these facilities were inappropriately classified as Class A violations, even in cases of severe neglect. In this report, DRC recommended that CDPH do the following: consistently issue an AA citation when staff conduct is a direct proximate cause of a resident’s death; apply consistent standards for issuing citations; and, provide greater transparency regarding the facts supporting a finding of inadequate probable cause in the case of resident deaths.
- Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Prior legislation. AB 323 (Kalra, Chapter 458, Statutes of 2021) revised the criteria under which CDPH issues civil penalties against LTC facilities that were found to have caused the death of a resident, so that instead of having to prove the death of a resident was the “direct proximate cause” of a violation by the facility, CDPH would have to prove that the violation was a “substantial factor” in the death of a resident, and defines substantial factor as more than a remote or trivial factor but is not required to be the only cause of harm. Additionally, increases the amount of civil penalties assessed against LTC facilities.
AB 849 (Reyes, Chapter 471, Statutes of 2021) amends the damages that can be sought by a current or former resident or patient of a SNF or ICF for violations of the resident’s or patient’s rights by specifying that the $500 cap on statutory damages is for each violation.
AB 506 (Kalra of 2019) was similar to AB 323 above, but in addition to changing the causation standard from direct proximate cause to substantial factor, it added an additional element to what must be proved by requiring that the facts and circumstances demonstrate that the death was a foreseeable result of the violation. AB 506 was vetoed by the Governor, who stated that “this bill began as a laudable effort to update the standard for determining a facility’s responsibility for the death of a patient or resident. However, I am concerned that the language, in its current form, would create more confusion than clarity and would not help CDPH to enforce the law. I encourage the Legislature and stakeholders to work with CDPH toward a resolution that enables the Department to better hold facilities accountable for causing the death of a patient or resident.”
AB 641 (Feuer, Chapter 729, Statutes of 2011) eliminates the citation review conference process from the citation appeals process for LTC facilities, and allowed fines to be levied from both state and federal agencies when an incident violates both state and federal laws. - Support. DRC is the sponsor of this bill and states that under current law, SNFs in California accused of the most serious violations are given special treatment in the appeals process. If a facility is cited with a Class AA or A citation because of a violation that has resulted in the death or substantial probability of death of a resident, the facility may appeal the citation to a superior court in the county in which the facility is located, which is a singular privilege not available to other types of licensees. DRC notes that it is expensive and time consuming for the state to defend their citations in superior court. SNFs are not required to pay their fines until the appeal process is exhausted. Far too frequently, the state has downgraded and reduced fines for citations involving the death of a resident after the SNF filed an appeal in superior court rather than continue with the burden and expense of ongoing litigation. Under this bill, SNFs would still be able to appeal AA and A citations, but they would be handled like other regulatory citation appeals, by an ALJ with the OAH. This would ensure that SNFs still have due process and the opportunity to challenge a citation, but not at the expense of a procedure which is wasteful of state resources, time consuming, and burdensome to our court system.
California AG Rob Bonta supports this bill and notes that the California Department of Justice provides legal counsel to CDPH in defending Class A and AA citations. The direct-to-superior court system currently in place in California has organizational, fiscal, and practical shortcomings in the adjudication of these citations. It is an outlier in the national landscape, as well as an outlier in the California’s administrative landscape. Many state agencies in California handle administrative decisions internally. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, disputes only rise to superior court as a writ of mandate under the Code of Civil Procedure following an administrative hearing. The AG states that this common practice reflects a basic principle: disputes that can reach resolution more efficiently and effectively through administrative hearings should be resolved in this way. It also allocates the initial decision-making responsibility in a given dispute to the regulatory body with the most expertise in the matters at hand, while the courts are still accessible via the process of judicial review. The administrative model used in the vast majority of states and in other California state agencies will provide a more efficient, effective, and economical method of resolving disputed class A and AA nursing home citations. The accelerated timeline of administrative proceedings will allow for a greatly expedited first level of review, with only the most contested citations proceeding to writ of mandate review in a superior court. This shift will not change the likelihood of settlement or facilitate frivolous litigation; rather, the administrative process will allow meritorious disputes to rise to the level of judicial review, while resolving all other disputes earlier and more economically. The AG concludes that an administrative model for resolving citations will result in cost-savings for the DOJ and lead to the expedited resolution of the majority of contested citations. - Oppose unless amended. The California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) opposes this bill because it would reduce licensee due process rights in appealing citations that could potentially close their facility or result in major financial penalties. CAHF is requesting amendments to remove the requirement that citation appeals only be adjudicated in an administrative hearing process and instead include arbitration as an alternative mechanism for appealing A and AA citations. CAHF states that there is no evidence that the existing appeal process is not function as intended, or that the courts are not reviewing these cases appropriately. Furthermore, CDPH is still implementing AB 323, and the lower burden of proof is likely to increase the number of AA citations issued by CDPH. Before changing state law regarding venues for appeals, the impact of AB 323 should be evaluated to determine whether further changes to the process are necessary. According to CAHF, AA and A citations are highly complex with extensive evidentiary needs, and are often similar to highly issues raised in medical malpractice and civil liability cases. Administrative hearings have more limited discovery and evidentiary rules that would not be sufficient or appropriate for ensuring due process when addressing the issues in AA and A citation cases. CAHF points out that in addition to the significant fines, these citations can also result in:
- Ineligibility for Medi-Cal supplemental payment programs;
- Permanent reductions in Medi-Cal LTC reimbursement rates;
- Negative impacts on the professional license status for physicians, nurses, certified nursing assistants, nursing home administrators, and other licensed professionals working at the facility; and,
- Suspension and revocation of the facility license.
According to CAHF, hearsay evidence is admissible in an administrative hearing, but would not be admissible civil proceedings. The existing appeals process also allows for greater participation in judicial hearings by licensees, witnesses, experts and their legal counsel because cases can be heard in trial court venues across the state. The administrative hearing appeal process required by this bill would limit hearings to be held only in Sacramento.
The City and County of San Francisco (City) also opposes this bill unless amended to exempt Laguna Honda Hospital and Rehabilitation Center. Laguna Honda Hospital is a 769-bed SNF owned and operated by the City. The City states that based on its experience as the owner and operator of this facility, it has strong concerns about the impact this bill would have on this institution. The City states that should Laguna Honda is concerned that, by taking the adjudication process away from the superior courts and placing it before an ALJ, the appeal process would become less impartial and unfairly weighted to the enforcement agency. Under this bill, the City states that CDPH could revoke a facility’s license and the facility’s recourse would be through an administrative appeal process biased in favor of the state agency and without the independence and procedural protections of state superior court. Given the impacts these types of citations can have, facilities appealing those citations deserve full and fair hearings as provided under current law.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Disability Rights California (sponsor)
AARP
Association of Regional Center Agencies
Attorney General Rob Bonta
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Foundation for Independent Living Centers
California Long-term Care Ombudsman Association
Caring Across Generations
Choice in Aging
Family Caregiver Alliance
Hand in Hand: the Domestic Employers Network
Justice in Aging
Placer Independent Resource Services
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Oppose: California Association of Health Facilities (unless amended)
City and County of San Francisco (unless amended)
LeadingAge California (unless amended)
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 486
Author:(Kalra)
As Amended Ver:May 22, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Removes the ability of a long-term care (LTC) facility, as defined, to adjudicate the validity of a citation issued by the Department of Public Health (DPH) in a county superior court, and instead requires all citation appeals to be made through an administrative law judge (ALJ). Authorizes an ALJ to affirm, modify, or dismiss a citation, the class of a citation, or the proposed penalty. Authorizes a licensee to seek judicial review of an ALJ's decision.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
- LTC facility inspections. DPH is responsible for ensuring LTC facilities comply with state laws and regulations. DPH Licensing & Certification staff conducts approximately 1,320 on-site inspections of LTC facilities and responds to approximately 6,650 complaints and 19,300 events reported by facilities each year. Events that facilities are required to report to DPH (reportable events) include interruptions of services essential to the health and safety of residents; alleged or suspected abuse; all fires, disasters, and other risks to resident life or health resulting from accidents or incidents at the facility; and, administrator or director of nursing personnel changes. Investigation of complaints and reportable events also require on-site inspections. These inspections, called surveys, evaluate compliance with both state and federal requirements.
- LTC facility citations. According to DPH, between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2021 facilities appealed 668 Class AA or A citations out of a total of 1474 Class AA or A citations issued. Of the 668 appeals, 292 (44%) had no decrease in fine amount or citation level. In five of the 668 appeals (0.7 %) the facility prevailed and the citation was dismissed. One-hundred and thirty-nine of the 668 appeals (21%) were downgraded and 341 of the 668 appeals (51%) had a reduced penalty amount. These numbers are based on the previous penalty standards, and may change once DPH has had the opportunity to determine the impacts of AB 323 (Kalra), Chapter 458, Statutes of 2021, which changed the standards effective for violations taking place on or after January 1, 2022.
- California Courts backlog. According to a January 2021 Judicial Council of California budget report, half as many cases, both civil and criminal, were resolved, 1.4 million fewer, from March through August of 2020, than during the same period in 2019, due in large part to the COVID-19 pandemic.
- ALJs. ALJs conduct/preside over judicial, quasi-judicial, and adjudicative hearings for various state and other public agencies in connection with the resolution of disputes as authorized or required by statue, regulation, due process, or a contract. ALJs prepare decisions, orders and/or opinions, conclusions of law, and recommended actions. ALJs control the course of the hearing, and secure orderly conduct throughout; administer oaths; rule on motions, objections and the admissibility of evidence; conduct settlement and prehearing conferences; conduct mediations with parties; instruct participants at hearings as to their rights; question witnesses; issue subpoenas; receive and review evidence; prepare reports; advise members of the public on questions regarding their rights under the applicable statutes; and, perform other related work.
- Current ALJ process for Class "B" citations. Class B violations are issued by DPH's Center for Health Care Quality district offices to facilities along with a notification of appeal rights. The district offices determine the appropriate penalty amount based on the conduct and the facility's compliance history. The facility can immediately pay the penalty at a reduced cost (65% of the penalty amount), or, the facility has 15 days to appeal and has the choice of binding arbitration or an administrative hearing. The facility sends their appeal to DPH-Office of Legal Services (OLS). OLS prepares an accusation (similar to a complaint in civil court) that is served on the facility, along with a notice of defense (similar to an answer in civil court). The facility has 20 days to return the notice of defense. If the facility does not return the notice of defense, DPH will take a default judgment. If the notice of defense is returned, OLS communicates with the facility or facility counsel on potential settlement options. If settlement efforts are unsuccessful, OLS will request a hearing date from Office of Administrative Hearings and Appeals (OAHA) (typically within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defense). OAHA assigns an ALJ and sets a hearing date. The parties exchange discovery, which in administrative cases, consists solely of a document exchange, and prepare for hearing.
Most B citation matters are resolved through settlement efforts after discovery is exchanged. If a B citation goes to hearing, the ALJ issues a proposed decision (the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) requires 30 days, but it is usually longer). At hearing, the APA allows for administrative hearsay, which reduces the number of witnesses that need to testify. The ALJ sends the proposed decision to DPH Public Health Programs team, who advises the Director on the review of the proposed decision. DPH has 100 days to review the proposed decision and either accept, reject, or amend the decision.
Under the provisions of this bill, facilities with "A" and "AA" citations dissatisfied with the OAHA process may file a writ in a superior court that will review the factual/evidentiary record from the OAHA hearing to determine if the process was fair. Unlike the OAHA or an initial judicial review, a writ is limited in scope and less time consuming primarily because there is no discovery process. However, the court in a writ case may permit additional evidence if it is new evidence that, "in the exercise of reasonable diligence, could not have been produced or that was improperly excluded at the hearing."
According to the Author
The state of skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) have never been more deadly and under this much scrutiny. The author states that coming off the heels of the deadliest and most difficult years for SNFs during the COVID-19 pandemic, it is imperative that we continue to improve state oversight, accountability, and demand better care to avoid future tragedies. The author concludes that by providing a more consistent and expedient appeals process, this bill will lighten the burden on our superior court system, utilize taxpayer money more effectively, and streamline a critical process to hold negligent LTC facilities accountable.
Arguments in Support
Disability Rights California (DRC) is the sponsor of this bill and states that under current law, SNFs in California accused of the most serious violations are given special treatment in the appeals process. If a facility is cited with a Class AA or A citation because of a violation that has resulted in the death or substantial probability of death of a resident, the facility may appeal the citation to a superior court in the county in which the facility is located, which is a singular privilege not available to other types of licensees. DRC notes that it is expensive and time consuming for the state to defend their citations in superior court. SNFs are not required to pay their fines until the appeal process is exhausted. Far too frequently, the state has downgraded and reduced fines for citations involving the death of a resident after the SNF filed an appeal in superior court rather than continue with the burden and expense of ongoing litigation.
Attorney General Rob Bonta (the AG) supports this bill and notes that the California Department of Justice provides legal counsel to DPH in defending Class A and AA citations. The direct-to-superior court system currently in place in California has organizational, fiscal, and practical shortcomings in the adjudication of these citations. It is an outlier in the national landscape, as well as an outlier in the State's administrative landscape. Many state agencies in California handle administrative decisions internally. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, disputes only rise to superior court as a writ of mandate under Code of Civil Procedure section 1094.5 following an administrative hearing. The AG states that this common practice reflects a basic principle: disputes that can reach resolution more efficiently and effectively through administrative hearings should be resolved in this way. It also allocates the initial decision-making responsibility in a given dispute to the regulatory body with the most expertise in the matters at hand, while the courts are still accessible via the process of judicial review.
Arguments in Opposition
Leading Age California and the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) are opposed to this bill unless it is amended. CAHF states the following concerns:
- There is no evidence that the existing appeal process for Class "AA" and "A" citations is not functioning as intended. Under the current process, the courts have upheld and dismissed "A" citations issued by DPH for 50 years. There is no reason to believe that the courts are not reviewing these cases appropriately. Furthermore, DPH is still implementing the author's previous bill, AB 323 in its citation issuance process. The lower burden of proof is likely to increase the number of "AA" citations issued by DPH. Before changing state law regarding venues for citation appeals, AB 323 should be fully implemented and the impact of the law should be evaluated to determine whether further changes to the process are necessary.
- Changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing process is unlikely to generate significant cost savings to the State. In 2021, DPH issued 15 Class AA citations and 152 Class A citations. Changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing will still result in legal expenses to the state and would likely require the hiring of staff to support the additional hearing workload within OAHA and DPH.
- "AA" and "A" citation cases are highly complex with extensive evidentiary needs and should be heard in an impartial judicial setting experienced in handling complex cases. SNF surveys and the identification of deficiencies is a highly subjective process. Determining whether an AA or A citation was issued appropriately by DPH requires specific judicial skills, experience, and resources to understand and interpret the law and to evaluate extensive amounts of evidence and witness testimony.
CAHF requests that the bill be amended as follows: Restore the judicial review process for appealing Class "AA" and "A" citations and provide licensees with an option to appeal the "AA" and "A" citations in a binding arbitration process. Existing law allows licensees with Class "B" citations to appeal through an administrative hearing or to submit the matter for binding arbitration. Existing law also allows licensees with Class "B" citations who which to contest the ALJ decision to submit the matter for binding arbitration.
While this bill would allow licensees to appeal Class "AA" and "A" appeal decisions made by an ALJ through a binding arbitration process, given the complexity of the cases, it would be more appropriate and efficient to bypass the administrative hearing step for Class "AA" and "A" citations, and add an option for binding arbitration to the existing judicial appeal process.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, DPH estimates the fiscal effect of this bill to range from annual ongoing savings of approximately $500,000 to annual ongoing costs of $1.6 million (Licensing and Certification Fund). On average, DPH issues 141 AA and A citations and handles 64 appeals per year. Of the appeals, 61 settle before trial, three go to full trial, and one results in an appeal of the superior court decision. DPH anticipates an increase in the average annual number of appeals to 85 appeals, of which approximately 67% (57 appeals) would settle during the pre-hearing process, 33% (28 appeals) would go to full hearing before an ALJ, and 16% (14 appeals) would go to judicial review. The cost range reflects costs and savings in relation to the current process, depending on whether the AG or DPH's Office of Legal Services would assume responsibility for litigating AA and A citation appeals in the administrative forum.
If the AG handles the litigation, DPH estimates a total net cost of approximately $1.6 million annually ongoing, including three new positions and external services provided by the AG, an administrative tribunal, and other potential expert contracts. This estimate reflects total new costs of $5.1 million and four positions required to implement this bill, less $3.5 million and one position for activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate. If DPH's attorneys handle the litigation, DPH estimates a total net savings of approximately $500,000 annually ongoing, including seven new positions and external services provided by litigation contractors. This reflects the total new costs of $3.1 million and eight positions required to implement this bill, less $3.6 million and one position from activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 11-4-0
YES: Wood, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Maienschein, McCarty, Rodriguez, Santiago, Villapudua, Weber
NO: Waldron, Flora, Vince Fong, Joe Patterson
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-3-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: May 22, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000950
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 486
Author:(Kalra)
As Amended Ver:March 22, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Removes the ability of a long-term care (LTC) facility, as defined, to adjudicate the validity of a citation issued by the Department of Public Health (DPH) in a county superior court, and instead requires all citation appeals to be made through an administrative law judge (ALJ). Authorizes an ALJ to affirm, modify, or dismiss a citation, the class of a citation, or the proposed penalty. Authorizes a licensee to seek judicial review of an ALJ's decision in the context of a class "AA" or "A" citation and would authorize a licensee to elect to submit the decision of an ALJ to arbitration for a class "B" citation.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
- LTC facility inspections. DPH is responsible for ensuring LTC facilities comply with state laws and regulations. DPH Licensing & Certification staff conducts approximately 1,320 on-site inspections of LTC facilities and responds to approximately 6,650 complaints and 19,300 events reported by facilities each year. Events that facilities are required to report to DPH (reportable events) include interruptions of services essential to the health and safety of residents; alleged or suspected abuse; all fires, disasters, and other risks to resident life or health resulting from accidents or incidents at the facility; and, administrator or director of nursing personnel changes. Investigation of complaints and reportable events also require on-site inspections. These inspections, called surveys, evaluate compliance with both state and federal requirements.
- LTC facility citations. According to DPH, between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2021 facilities appealed 668 Class AA or A citations out of a total of 1474 Class AA or A citations issued. Of the 668 appeals, 292 (44%) had no decrease in fine amount or citation level. In five of the 668 appeals (0.7 %) the facility prevailed and the citation was dismissed. One-hundred and thirty-nine of the 668 appeals (21%) were downgraded and 341 of the 668 appeals (51%) had a reduced penalty amount. These numbers are based on the previous penalty standards, and may change once DPH has had the opportunity to determine the impacts of AB 323 (Kalra), Chapter 458, Statutes of 2021, which changed the standards effective for violations taking place on or after January 1, 2022.
- California Courts backlog. According to a January 2021 Judicial Council of California budget report, half as many cases, both civil and criminal, were resolved, 1.4 million fewer, from March through August of 2020, than during the same period in 2019, due in large part to the COVID-19 pandemic.
- ALJs. ALJs conduct/preside over judicial, quasi-judicial, and adjudicative hearings for various state and other public agencies in connection with the resolution of disputes as authorized or required by statue, regulation, due process, or a contract. ALJs prepare decisions, orders and/or opinions, conclusions of law, and recommended actions. ALJs control the course of the hearing, and secure orderly conduct throughout; administer oaths; rule on motions, objections and the admissibility of evidence; conduct settlement and prehearing conferences; conduct mediations with parties; instruct participants at hearings as to their rights; question witnesses; issue subpoenas; receive and review evidence; prepare reports; advise members of the public on questions regarding their rights under the applicable statutes; and, perform other related work.
- Current ALJ process for Class "B" citations. Class B violations are issued by DPH's Center for Health Care Quality district offices to facilities along with a notification of appeal rights. The district offices determine the appropriate penalty amount based on the conduct and the facility's compliance history. The facility can immediately pay the penalty at a reduced cost (65% of the penalty amount), or, the facility has 15 days to appeal and has the choice of binding arbitration or an administrative hearing. The facility sends their appeal to DPH-Office of Legal Services (OLS). OLS prepares an accusation (similar to a complaint in civil court) that is served on the facility, along with a notice of defense (similar to an answer in civil court). The facility has 20 days to return the notice of defense. If the facility does not return the notice of defense, DPH will take a default judgment. If the notice of defense is returned, OLS communicates with the facility or facility counsel on potential settlement options. If settlement efforts are unsuccessful, OLS will request a hearing date from Office of Administrative Hearings and Appeals (OAHA) (typically within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defense). OAHA assigns an ALJ and sets a hearing date. The parties exchange discovery, which in administrative cases, consists solely of a document exchange, and prepare for hearing.
Most B citation matters are resolved through settlement efforts after discovery is exchanged. If a B citation goes to hearing, the ALJ issues a proposed decision (the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) requires 30 days, but it is usually longer). At hearing, the APA allows for administrative hearsay, which reduces the number of witnesses that need to testify. The ALJ sends the proposed decision to DPH Public Health Programs team, who advises the Director on the review of the proposed decision. DPH has 100 days to review the proposed decision and either accept, reject, or amend the decision.
Under the provisions of this bill, facilities with "A" and "AA" citations dissatisfied with the OAHA process may file a writ in a superior court that will review the factual/evidentiary record from the OAHA hearing to determine if the process was fair. Unlike the OAHA or an initial judicial review, a writ is limited in scope and less time consuming primarily because there is no discovery process. However, the court in a writ case may permit additional evidence if it is new evidence that, "in the exercise of reasonable diligence, could not have been produced or that was improperly excluded at the hearing."
According to the Author
The state of skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) have never been more deadly and under this much scrutiny. The author states that coming off the heels of the deadliest and most difficult years for SNFs during the COVID-19 pandemic, it is imperative that we continue to improve state oversight, accountability, and demand better care to avoid future tragedies. The author concludes that by providing a more consistent and expedient appeals process, this bill will lighten the burden on our superior court system, utilize taxpayer money more effectively, and streamline a critical process to hold negligent LTC facilities accountable.
Arguments in Support
Disability Rights California (DRC) is the sponsor of this bill and states that under current law, SNFs in California accused of the most serious violations are given special treatment in the appeals process. If a facility is cited with a Class AA or A citation because of a violation that has resulted in the death or substantial probability of death of a resident, the facility may appeal the citation to a superior court in the county in which the facility is located, which is a singular privilege not available to other types of licensees. DRC notes that it is expensive and time consuming for the state to defend their citations in superior court. SNFs are not required to pay their fines until the appeal process is exhausted. Far too frequently, the state has downgraded and reduced fines for citations involving the death of a resident after the SNF filed an appeal in superior court rather than continue with the burden and expense of ongoing litigation.
Attorney General Rob Bonta (the AG) supports this bill and notes that the California Department of Justice provides legal counsel to DPH in defending Class A and AA citations. The direct-to-superior court system currently in place in California has organizational, fiscal, and practical shortcomings in the adjudication of these citations. It is an outlier in the national landscape, as well as an outlier in the State's administrative landscape. Many state agencies in California handle administrative decisions internally. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, disputes only rise to superior court as a writ of mandate under Code of Civil Procedure section 1094.5 following an administrative hearing. The AG states that this common practice reflects a basic principle: disputes that can reach resolution more efficiently and effectively through administrative hearings should be resolved in this way. It also allocates the initial decision-making responsibility in a given dispute to the regulatory body with the most expertise in the matters at hand, while the courts are still accessible via the process of judicial review.
Arguments in Opposition Unless Amended
Leading Age California and the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) are opposed to this bill unless it is amended. CAHF states the following concerns:
- There is no evidence that the existing appeal process for Class "AA" and "A" citations is not functioning as intended. Under the current process, the courts have upheld and dismissed "A" citations issued by DPH for 50 years. There is no reason to believe that the courts are not reviewing these cases appropriately. Furthermore, DPH is still implementing the author's previous bill, AB 323 in its citation issuance process. The lower burden of proof is likely to increase the number of "AA" citations issued by DPH. Before changing state law regarding venues for citation appeals, AB 323 should be fully implemented and the impact of the law should be evaluated to determine whether further changes to the process are necessary.
- Changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing process is unlikely to generate significant cost savings to the State. In 2021, DPH issued 15 Class AA citations and 152 Class A citations. Changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing will still result in legal expenses to the state and would likely require the hiring of staff to support the additional hearing workload within OAHA and DPH.
- "AA" and "A" citation cases are highly complex with extensive evidentiary needs and should be heard in an impartial judicial setting experienced in handling complex cases. SNF surveys and the identification of deficiencies is a highly subjective process. Determining whether an AA or A citation was issued appropriately by DPH requires specific judicial skills, experience, and resources to understand and interpret the law and to evaluate extensive amounts of evidence and witness testimony.
CAHF requests that the bill be amended as follows: Restore the judicial review process for appealing Class "AA" and "A" citations and provide licensees with an option to appeal the "AA" and "A" citations in a binding arbitration process. Existing law allows licensees with Class "B" citations to appeal through an administrative hearing or to submit the matter for binding arbitration. Existing law also allows licensees with Class "B" citations who which to contest the ALJ decision to submit the matter for binding arbitration.
While this bill would allow licensees to appeal Class "AA" and "A" appeal decisions made by an ALJ through a binding arbitration process, given the complexity of the cases, it would be more appropriate and efficient to bypass the administrative hearing step for Class "AA" and "A" citations, and add an option for binding arbitration to the existing judicial appeal process.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, DPH estimates the fiscal effect of this bill to range from annual ongoing savings of approximately $500,000 to annual ongoing costs of $1.6 million (Licensing and Certification Fund). On average, DPH issues 141 AA and A citations and handles 64 appeals per year. Of the appeals, 61 settle before trial, three go to full trial, and one results in an appeal of the superior court decision. DPH anticipates an increase in the average annual number of appeals to 85 appeals, of which approximately 67% (57 appeals) would settle during the pre-hearing process, 33% (28 appeals) would go to full hearing before an ALJ, and 16% (14 appeals) would go to judicial review. The cost range reflects costs and savings in relation to the current process, depending on whether the AG or DPH's Office of Legal Services would assume responsibility for litigating AA and A citation appeals in the administrative forum.
If the AG handles the litigation, DPH estimates a total net cost of approximately $1.6 million annually ongoing, including three new positions and external services provided by the AG, an administrative tribunal, and other potential expert contracts. This estimate reflects total new costs of $5.1 million and four positions required to implement this bill, less $3.5 million and one position for activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate. If DPH's attorneys handle the litigation, DPH estimates a total net savings of approximately $500,000 annually ongoing, including seven new positions and external services provided by litigation contractors. This reflects the total new costs of $3.1 million and eight positions required to implement this bill, less $3.6 million and one position from activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate.
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 11-4-0
YES: Wood, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Boerner Horvath, Wendy Carrillo, Maienschein, McCarty, Rodriguez, Santiago, Villapudua, Weber
NO: Waldron, Flora, Vince Fong, Joe Patterson
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-3-2
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mathis, Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: March 22, 2023
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000523
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 486
Author:(Kalra) – As Amended Ver:March 22, 2023
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 11 - 4 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
The California Department of Public Health (CDPH) issues citations to long-term care (LTC) facilities for violations associated with the health and safety of residents. This bill removes the ability of an LTC facility to adjudicate the validity of such a citation in a county superior court, and instead requires an LTC facility to appeal a citation through an administrative law judge (ALJ).
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a LTC facility that wishes to contest a class “AA” or “A” citation to notify CDPH, within 15 working days after service of the citation that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation. (CDPH defines the violations as follows: a “B” violation has a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of LTC facility residents; an “A” violation presents imminent danger or a substantial probability of death or serious harm; and an “AA” violation (the most severe) meets the criteria for an “A” violation and was a substantial factor in the death of a resident of an LTC facility.)
- Authorizes an ALJ to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty.
- Authorizes an LTC facility dissatisfied with the decision of the ALJ to seek judicial review of the decision with respect to a class “AA” or “A” citation, and to submit the decision of an ALJ for a class “B” citation to arbitration.
- Requires actions brought under the provisions of this bill to be set for hearing by an ALJ at the earliest possible date and to take precedence over all other matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. Requires actions for class “AA” and “A” violations to take precedence over actions for class “B” violations.
FISCAL EFFECT:
CDPH estimates the fiscal effect of this bill to range from annual ongoing savings of approximately $500,000 to annual ongoing costs of $1.6 million (Licensing and Certification Fund).
On average, CDPH issues 141 AA and A citations and handles 64 appeals per year. Of the appeals, 61 settle before trial, three go to full trial, and one results in an appeal of the superior court decision. CDPH anticipates an increase in the average annual number of appeals to 85 appeals, of which approximately 67% (57 appeals) would settle during the pre-hearing process, 33% (28 appeals) would go to full hearing before an ALJ, and 16% (14 appeals) would go to judicial review. The cost range reflects costs and savings in relation to the current process, depending on whether the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) or CDPH’s Office of Legal Services would assume responsibility for litigating AA and A citation appeals in the administrative forum.
If the OAG handles the litigation, CDPH estimates a total net cost of approximately $1.6 million annually ongoing, including three new positions and external services provided by the OAG, an administrative tribunal, and other potential expert contracts. This estimate reflects total new costs of $5.1 million and four positions required to implement this bill, less $3.5 million and one position for activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate.
If CDPH’s attorneys handle the litigation, CDPH estimates a total net savings of approximately $500,000 annually ongoing, including seven new positions and external services provided by litigation contractors. This reflects the total new costs of $3.1 million and eight positions required to implement this bill, less $3.6 million and one position from activities under the current process that this bill would eliminate.
COMMENTS:
- This bill is sponsored by Disability Rights California (DRC). According to the author:
Under current law, Long-Term Care (LTC) Facilities, including skilled nursing facilities (nursing homes), intermediate care facilities for people with developmental disabilities, and congregate living health facilities, in California accused of the most serious violations are given special treatment in the appeals process. If a facility is cited with a Class AA or A citation, the facility may appeal the citation to a superior court in the county in which the facility is located...This is a singular privilege that is only provided to nursing homes with Class AA or A citations.
Generally, the regulatory citation appeals process is handled by an [ALJ] or a regulatory appeals board. By providing nursing home facilities unique access to superior court, it clogs an already overburdened judicial system, which wastes resources and results in less expedient resolutions.
DRC contends the state has downgraded and reduced fines for citations involving the death of a resident after a facility filed an appeal in superior court, rather than continue with the burden and expense of ongoing litigation.
- Background. CDPH is responsible for ensuring LTC facilities comply with state laws and regulations. CDPH Licensing and Certification staff conducts approximately 1,320 on-site inspections (“surveys”) of LTC facilities and responds to approximately 6,650 complaints and 19,300 events reported by facilities each year. Facilities are required to report to CDPH “reportable events,” including interruptions of services essential to the health and safety of residents; alleged or suspected abuse; fires, disasters, and other risks to resident health resulting from incidents at the facility; and certain personnel changes. Investigation of complaints and reportable events also require on-site surveys.
LTC Facility Citation Appeals. According to CDPH, between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2021 facilities appealed 668 Class AA or A citations out of a total of 1474 Class AA or A citations issued. Of the 668 appeals:- 292 (44%) resulted in no decrease in fine amount or citation level.
- Five appeals (0.7 %) led to dismissal of the citation because the facility prevailed.
- 139 appeals (21%) downgraded the citation.
- 341 appeals (51%) reduced the penalty amount.
(These numbers are based on penalty standards in effect at the time.)
ALJs. ALJs conduct and preside over judicial, quasi-judicial, and adjudicative hearings for various state and other public agencies in connection with the resolution of disputes as authorized or required by statute, regulation, due process, or a contract. ALJs prepare decisions, orders, opinions, conclusions of law, and recommended actions. ALJs control the course of the hearing; administer oaths; rule on motions, objections, and the admissibility of evidence; conduct settlement and prehearing conferences; conduct mediations with parties; instruct participants at hearings as to their rights; question witnesses; issue subpoenas; receive and review evidence; prepare reports; and advise members of the public on questions regarding their rights under the applicable statutes.
- Opposition. Leading Age California and the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) oppose this bill unless amended. CAHF argues there is no evidence the existing appeal process for Class “AA” and “A” citations is not functioning as intended, and furthermore, CDPH is still implementing the author’s previous bill in its citation issuance process. CAHF adds that changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing process is unlikely to save money for the state. CAHF contends “AA” and “A” citation cases are highly complex with extensive evidentiary needs and should be heard in an impartial judicial setting by a judge experienced in handling complex cases. CAHF concludes it would be more appropriate and efficient to bypass the administrative hearing step for Class “AA” and “A” citations, and add an option for binding arbitration to the existing judicial appeal process.
- Prior Legislation. AB 323 (Kalra), Chapter 458, Statutes of 2021, changed the standard for penalties against LTC facilities for violations that result in the death of a resident from "direct proximate cause" to "substantial factor" and the death was a result of the violation. AB 323 also increased the amount of civil penalties assessed against LTC facilities.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 486
Author:(Kalra) – As Amended Ver:March 22, 2023
SUBJECT: Long-term health facilities: citation appeals.
SUMMARY: Removes the ability of a long-term care (LTC) facility, as defined, to adjudicate the validity of a citation issued by the Department of Public Health (DPH) in a county superior court, and instead requires all citation appeals to be made through an administrative law judge (ALJ). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a LTC facility that desires to contest a class “AA” or “A” citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify DPH that the licensee wishes to appeal the citation.
- Authorizes the ALJ to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, class of the citation, or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty.
- Authorizes a LTC facility dissatisfied with the decision of the ALJ to seek judicial review of the decision with respect to a class “AA” or “A” citation, and to submit the decision of an ALJ to arbitration for a class “B” citation.
- Requires actions brought under the provisions of this bill to be set for hearing by an ALJ at the earliest possible date and to take precedence over all other matters except those to which equal or superior precedence is specifically granted by law. Requires actions for class “AA” and “A” violations to take precedence over actions for class “B” violations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Licenses and regulates LTC facilities by DPH. Includes skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), intermediate care facilities (ICFs), ICF/developmentally disabled (ICF/DD), ICF/DD-habilitative, ICF/DD-nursing, and congregate living health facilities in the definition of LTC facilities. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1250, et seq., and §1418]
- Establishes a civil penalty structure for LTC facilities, categorized into “AA,” “A,” and “B” violations:
- “A” violations are those which DPH determines the violation presents either imminent danger of death or serious harm, or a substantial probability that death or serious harm to residents would result;
- “AA” violations (the most severe) are those that meet the criteria for a class “A” violation that DPH determines was a substantial factor (as defined) in the death of a resident of an LTC facility; and,
- “B” violations are those that DPH determines have a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of LTC facility residents. [HSC §1424]
- Makes a class “AA” citation subject to a civil penalty in an amount not less than thirty thousand dollars ($30,000) and not exceeding one hundred twenty thousand dollars ($120,000) for each citation. Requires DPH, for a second or subsequent class “AA” citation in a SNF or ICF within a 24-month period to commence action to suspend or revoke the facility’s license. [HSC § 1424.5]
- Makes a class “A” citation subject to a civil penalty in an amount not less than three thousand five hundred dollars ($3,500) and not exceeding twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each citation. Makes a class “A” citation that involved the death of a patient or resident subject to a civil penalty in an amount not less than fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) and not exceeding sixty thousand dollars ($60,000). [Id.]
- Makes any “willful material falsification” or “willful material omission,” as defined, in the health record of a resident subject to a civil penalty in an amount not less than three thousand five hundred dollars ($3,500) and not exceeding twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for each citation. [Id.]
- Makes a class “B” citation subject to a civil penalty in an amount not less than one hundred fifty dollars ($150) and not exceeding three thousand dollars ($3,000). Defines class “B” violations as violations that DPH determines have a direct or immediate relationship to the health, safety, or security of long-term health care facility residents, other than class “AA” or “A” violations. [Id.]
- Provides, through regulations, that, unless determined by DPH to be a class “A” violation that will cause, or be likely to cause, significant humiliation, indignity, anxiety, or other emotional trauma to a resident, a violation is a class “B” violation. Requires a class “B” citation to specify the time within which the violation is required to be corrected. Requires the licensee, if DPH establishes that a violation occurred, to have the burden of proving that the licensee did what might reasonably be expected of a LTC facility licensee, acting under similar circumstances, to comply with the regulation, and if the licensee sustains this burden, requires the citation to be dismissed. [Id.]
- Requires a LTC facility licensee, if it intends to contest a class “AA” or a class “A” citation, to inform DPH in writing, within 15 business days of the service of the citation of the licensee’s intent to adjudicate the validity of the citation in the superior court in the county in which the LTC facility is located. Requires a licensee to file a civil action in the superior court in the county in which the LTC facility is located no later than 90 calendar days after a licensee notifies DPH that they intend to contest the citation. Requires a licensee prosecuting a judicial appeal to file and serve a case management statement, as specified, within six months after DPH files its answer in the appeal. Requires the court to dismiss the appeal upon motion of DPH if the case management statement is not filed by the licensee within the period specified. Authorizes the court to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation, the level of the citation, or the amount of the proposed assessment of the civil penalty. [HSC § 1428 (b)]
- Requires a LTC facility licensee that desires to contest a class “B” citation to, within 15 working days after service of the citation, notify DPH that the facility wishes to appeal the citation or elects to submit the matter to binding arbitration. Authorizes the ALJ to affirm, modify, or dismiss the citation or the proposed assessment of a civil penalty. Allows the LTC facility licensee to choose to have their appeal heard by the ALJ or submit the matter to binding arbitration by notifying DPH in writing within 15 business days of the service of the citation. [HSC § 1428 (c) and (d)]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, the state of SNFs have never been more deadly and under this much scrutiny. The author states that coming off the heels of the deadliest and most difficult years for SNFs during the COVID-19 pandemic, it is imperative that we continue to improve state oversight, accountability, and demand better care to avoid future tragedies. The author concludes that by providing a more consistent and expedient appeals process, this bill will lighten the burden on our superior court system, utilize taxpayer money more effectively, and streamline a critical process to hold negligent LTC facilities accountable.
- BACKGROUND.
- LTC facility inspections. DPH is responsible for ensuring LTC facilities comply with state laws and regulations. DPH Licensing & Certification staff conducts approximately 1,320 on-site inspections of LTC facilities and responds to approximately 6,650 complaints and 19,300 events reported by facilities each year. Events that facilities are required to report to DPH (reportable events) include interruptions of services essential to the health and safety of residents; alleged or suspected abuse; all fires, disasters, and other risks to resident life or health resulting from accidents or incidents at the facility; and, administrator or director of nursing personnel changes. Investigation of complaints and reportable events also require on-site inspections. These inspections, called surveys, evaluate compliance with both state and federal requirements.
- LTC facility citations. According to DPH, between January 1, 2011 and June 30, 2021 facilities appealed 668 Class AA or A citations out of a total of 1474 Class AA or A citations issued. Of the 668 appeals, 292 (44%) had no decrease in fine amount or citation level. In five of the 668 appeals (0.7 %) the facility prevailed and the citation was dismissed. One-hundred and thirty-nine of the 668 appeals (21%) were downgraded and 341 of the 668 appeals (51%) had a reduced penalty amount. These numbers are based on the previous penalty standards, and may change once DPH has had the opportunity to determine the impacts of AB 323 (Kalra), Chapter 458, Statutes of 2021, which changed the standards effective for violations taking place on or after January 1, 2022.
- California Courts backlog. According to a January 2021 Judicial Council of California budget report, half as many cases, both civil and criminal, were resolved, 1.4 million fewer, from March through August of 2020, than during the same period in 2019, due in large part to the COVID-19 pandemic.
- ALJs. ALJs conduct/preside over judicial, quasi-judicial, and adjudicative hearings for various state and other public agencies in connection with the resolution of disputes as authorized or required by statue, regulation, due process, or a contract. ALJs prepare decisions, orders and/or opinions, conclusions of law, and recommended actions. ALJs control the course of the hearing, and secure orderly conduct throughout; administer oaths; rule on motions, objections and the admissibility of evidence; conduct settlement and prehearing conferences; conduct mediations with parties; instruct participants at hearings as to their rights; question witnesses; issue subpoenas; receive and review evidence; prepare reports; advise members of the public on questions regarding their rights under the applicable statutes; and, perform other related work.
- Current ALJ process for Class “B” citations. Class B violations are issued by DPH’s Center for Health Care Quality district offices to facilities along with a notification of appeal rights. The district offices determine the appropriate penalty amount based on the conduct and the facility’s compliance history. The facility can immediately pay the penalty at a reduced cost (65% of the penalty amount), or, the facility has 15 days to appeal and has the choice of binding arbitration or an administrative hearing. The facility sends their appeal to DPH-Office of Legal Services (OLS). OLS prepares an accusation (similar to a complaint in civil court) that is served on the facility, along with a notice of defense (similar to an answer in civil court). The facility has 20 days to return the notice of defense. If the facility does not return the notice of defense, DPH will take a default judgment. If the notice of defense is returned, OLS communicates with the facility or facility counsel on potential settlement options. If settlement efforts are unsuccessful, OLS will request a hearing date from Office of Administrative Hearings and Appeals (OAHA) (typically within 30 days of receipt of the notice of defense). OAHA assigns an ALJ and sets a hearing date. The parties exchange discovery, which in administrative cases, consists solely of a document exchange, and prepare for hearing.
Most B citation matters are resolved through settlement efforts after discovery is exchanged. If a B citation goes to hearing, the ALJ issues a proposed decision (the Administrative Procedure Act (APA) requires 30 days, but it is usually longer). At hearing, the APA allows for administrative hearsay, which reduces the number of witnesses that need to testify. The ALJ sends the proposed decision to DPH Public Health Programs team, who advises the Director on the review of the proposed decision. DPH has 100 days to review the proposed decision and either accept, reject, or amend the decision.
Under the provisions of this bill, facilities with “A” and “AA” citations dissatisfied with the OAHA process may file a writ in a superior court that will review the factual/evidentiary record from the OAHA hearing to determine if the process was fair. Unlike the OAHA or an initial judicial review, a writ is limited in scope and less time consuming primarily because there is no discovery process. However, the court in a writ case may permit additional evidence if it is new evidence that, “in the exercise of reasonable diligence, could not have been produced or that was improperly excluded at the hearing.”
- SUPPORT. Disability Rights California (DRC) is the sponsor of this bill and states that under current law, SNFs in California accused of the most serious violations are given special treatment in the appeals process. If a facility is cited with a Class AA or A citation because of a violation that has resulted in the death or substantial probability of death of a resident, the facility may appeal the citation to a superior court in the county in which the facility is located, which is a singular privilege not available to other types of licensees. DRC notes that it is expensive and time consuming for the state to defend their citations in superior court. SNFs are not required to pay their fines until the appeal process is exhausted. Far too frequently, the state has downgraded and reduced fines for citations involving the death of a resident after the SNF filed an appeal in superior court rather than continue with the burden and expense of ongoing litigation. Under this bill, SNFs would still be able to appeal AA and A citations, but they would be handled like other regulatory citation appeals, by an ALJ with the OAHA. This would ensure that SNFs still have due process and the opportunity to challenge a citation, but not at the expense of a procedure which is wasteful of state resources, time consuming, and burdensome to our court system.
Negligent nursing homes that are responsible for caring for some of our most vulnerable residents benefit from the current appeal system that is slow and expensive. DRC concludes that this bill holds poorly performing nursing homes accountable to improve their care and better aligns with the national standard for using administrative proceedings to hear regulatory violations.
Attorney General Rob Bonta (the AG) supports this bill and notes that the California Department of Justice (DOJ) provides legal counsel to DPH in defending Class A and AA citations. The direct-to-superior court system currently in place in California has organizational, fiscal, and practical shortcomings in the adjudication of these citations. It is an outlier in the national landscape, as well as an outlier in the State’s administrative landscape. Many state agencies in California handle administrative decisions internally. Under the Administrative Procedure Act, disputes only rise to superior court as a writ of mandate under Code of Civil Procedure section 1094.5 following an administrative hearing. The AG states that this common practice reflects a basic principle: disputes that can reach resolution more efficiently and effectively through administrative hearings should be resolved in this way. It also allocates the initial decision-making responsibility in a given dispute to the regulatory body with the most expertise in the matters at hand, while the courts are still accessible via the process of judicial review.
The administrative model used in the vast majority of states and in other California state agencies will provide a more efficient, effective, and economical method of resolving disputed class A and AA nursing home citations. The accelerated timeline of administrative proceedings will allow for a greatly expedited first level of review, with only the most contested citations proceeding to writ of mandate review in a superior court. The accelerated timeline and streamlined discovery process of administrative proceedings will shift costs downward. This shift in costs will not change the likelihood of settlement or facilitate frivolous litigation; rather, the administrative process will allow meritorious disputes to rise to the level of judicial review, while resolving all other disputes earlier and more economically. The AG concludes that an administrative model for resolving citations will result in cost-savings for the DOJ and lead to the expedited resolution of the majority of contested citations.
- OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. Leading Age California and the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) are opposed to this bill unless it is amended. CAHF states the following concerns:
- There is no evidence that the existing appeal process for Class “AA” and “A” citations is not functioning as intended. Under the current process, the courts have upheld and dismissed “A” citations issued by DPH for 50 years. There is no reason to believe that the courts are not reviewing these cases appropriately. Furthermore, DPH is still implementing the author’s previous bill, AB 323 in its citation issuance process. The lower burden of proof is likely to increase the number of “AA” citations issued by DPH. Before changing state law regarding venues for citation appeals, AB 323 should be fully implemented and the impact of the law should be evaluated to determine whether further changes to the process are necessary.
- Changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing process is unlikely to generate significant cost savings to the State. In 2021, DPH issued 15 Class AA citations and 152 Class A citations. Changing the venue from the courts to an administrative hearing will still result in legal expenses to the state and would likely require the hiring of staff to support the additional hearing workload within OAHA and DPH.
- “AA” and “A” citation cases are highly complex with extensive evidentiary needs and should be heard in an impartial judicial setting experienced in handling complex cases. SNF surveys and the identification of deficiencies is a highly subjective process. Determining whether an AA or A citation was issued appropriately by DPH requires specific judicial skills, experience, and resources to understand and interpret the law and to evaluate extensive amounts of evidence and witness testimony.
CAHF requests that the bill be amended as follows: Restore the judicial review process for appealing Class “AA” and “A” citations and provide licensees with an option to appeal the “AA” and “A” citations in a binding arbitration process. Existing law allows licensees with Class “B” citations to appeal through an administrative hearing or to submit the matter for binding arbitration. Existing law also allows licensees with Class “B” citations who which to contest the ALJ decision to submit the matter for binding arbitration.
While this bill would allow licensees to appeal Class “AA” and “A” appeal decisions made by an ALJ through a binding arbitration process, given the complexity of the cases, it would be more appropriate and efficient to bypass the administrative hearing step for Class “AA” and “A” citations, and add an option for binding arbitration to the existing judicial appeal process.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 48 (Aguiar-Curry) creates the Nursing Facility Resident Informed Consent Protection Act of 2023 which requires a prescriber, prior to prescribing a psychotherapeutic drug for a resident of a SNF or ICF to personally examine and obtain the informed written consent of the resident or the resident’s representative. AB 48 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1537 (Wood) requires, no later than July 1, 2024, the establishment of a direct patient-related services spending, reporting, and rebate requirement for SNFs, with certain exceptions. Requires that a minimum of 85% of a facility’s total non-Medicare health revenues from all payer sources in each fiscal year be expended on residents’ direct patient-related services, as defined. AB 1537 is pending a hearing in the Assembly Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION. AB 323 changes the standard for DPH when issuing penalties against LTC facilities for violations that result in the death of a resident from "direct proximate cause" to "substantial factor" and the death was a result of the violation. Increases the amount of civil penalties assessed against LTC facilities.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Disability Rights California (sponsor)
Attorney General Rob Bonta
AARP
Association of Regional Center Agencies
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
Caring Across Generations
Choice in Aging
Disability Rights California
Family Caregiver Alliance
Hand in Hand: the Domestic Employers Network
Justice in Aging
Placer Independent Resource Services
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):