AB 506: California State University: graduation requirement: ethnic studies.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-07-13
Current Status:
Failed
(2023-09-01: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the California State University and its various campuses under the administration of the Board of Trustees of the California State University. Existing law requires the California State University to provide for courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses. Existing law, commencing with students graduating in the 202425 academic year, requires the California State University to require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one 3-unit course in ethnic studies.
This bill would require the California State University to collaborate with the Academic Senate of the California State University, the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to ensure the development of a process, on or before December 31, 2024, for eligible community college ethnic studies courses to meet the requirements of a California State University ethnic studies course provided pursuant to these provisions for students who transfer to the California State University from California Community Colleges. The bill would require the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to make the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies the California State University requirements for ethnic studies. The bill would provide that a community college course which that has been approved for the California State University ethnic studies requirements as of December 1, 2023, no longer satisfies those requirements on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to this bill. bill, except that the bill, notwithstanding that provision, would prohibit requiring students who have successfully completed an approved community college ethnic studies course before August 1, 2025, from taking another course to meet the California State University requirements for ethnic studies.
Existing law establishes the California State University and its various campuses under the administration of the Board of Trustees of the California State University. Existing law requires the California State University to provide for courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses. Existing law, commencing with students graduating in the 202425 academic year, requires the California State University to require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one 3-unit course in ethnic studies.
This bill would delay the requirement for the California State University to require one 3-unit ethnic studies course as an undergraduate graduation requirement by one year to instead commence with students graduating in the 202526 academic year. The bill would require the California State University to collaborate with the office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the Academic Senate of the California State University, the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for the California State University to approve community college ethnic studies courses, as meeting ensure the development of a process, on or before December 31, 2024, for eligible community college ethnic studies courses to meet the requirements of a California State University ethnic studies course provided pursuant to these provisions, provisions for students who transfer to the California State University from California Community Colleges. The bill would require the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to make the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies the California State University requirements for ethnic studies. The bill would provide that a community college course which has been approved for the California State University ethnic studies requirements as of December 1, 2023, no longer satisfies those requirements on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to this bill.
Existing law establishes the California State University and its various campuses under the administration of the Board of Trustees of the California State University. Existing law requires the California State University to provide for courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses. Existing law, commencing with students graduating in the 202425 academic year, requires the California State University to require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one 3-unit course in ethnic studies.
This bill would delay the requirement for the California State University to require one 3-unit ethnic studies course as an undergraduate graduation requirement by one year to instead commence with students graduating in the 202526 academic year. The bill would require the California State University to collaborate with the office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the Academic Senate of the California State University, the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for the California State University to approve community college ethnic studies courses, as meeting the requirements of a California State University ethnic studies course provided pursuant to these provisions, for students who transfer to the California State University from California Community Colleges.
Existing law establishes the California State University and its various campuses under the administration of the Board of Trustees of the California State University. Existing law requires the California State University to provide for courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses. Existing law, commencing with students graduating in the 202425 academic year, requires the California State University to require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one 3-unit course in ethnic studies.
This bill would require the California State University to collaborate with the office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for the California State University to approve community college ethnic studies courses, as meeting the requirements of a California State University ethnic studies course provided pursuant to these provisions, for students who transfer to the California State University from California Community Colleges.
(a)The California State University shall collaborate with the Academic Senate of the California State University, the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to ensure the development of a process, on or before December 31, 2024, for eligible community college ethnic studies courses to meet the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032, for students who transfer to the California State University from the California Community Colleges.
(b)For purposes of the process developed pursuant to subdivision (a), all of the following apply:
(1)Faculty of the California State University shall be duly represented by an equal number of members from each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies, to develop the process for approving Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies.
(2)The California State University Council on Ethnic Studies shall make the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies the California State University Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies.
(3)The California State University shall collaborate with the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, the Academic Senate of the California State University, and the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges to facilitate training for ethnic studies Area F reviewers to ensure that the appropriate laws, policies, and procedures governing the curriculum for the California Community Colleges are adhered to during the California State University General Education Breadth ethnic studies Area F review process.
(4)The review process shall be well-structured with appropriate guidelines, timelines, and qualified reviewers in each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies and the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council.
(c)(1)For purposes of the California State University General Education Breadth submission cycle for the 202425 academic year, the review of proposed community college courses for Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies that is scheduled to take place in December 2023 shall be suspended. The review shall recommence once the new process is developed pursuant to subdivision (a) on or before December 31, 2024.
(2)A community college course which that has been approved for the California State University Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies as of December 1, 2023, shall no longer satisfy the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032 on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to subdivision (a).
(3)Notwithstanding paragraph (2), students who have successfully completed an approved community college ethnic studies course before August 1, 2025, shall not be required to take another course to meet the Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies.
(a)The California State University shall collaborate with the office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the Academic Senate of the California State University, the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for the California State University to approve eligible community college ethnic studies courses, as meeting ensure the development of a process, on or before December 31, 2024, for eligible community college ethnic studies courses to meet the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032, for students who transfer to the California State University from the California Community Colleges.
(b)For purposes of the process developed pursuant to subdivision (a), all of the following apply:
(1)Faculty of the California State University shall be duly represented by an equal number of members from each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies, to develop the process for approving Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies.
(2)The California State University Council on Ethnic Studies shall make the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies the California State University Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies.
(3)The California State University shall collaborate with the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, the Academic Senate of the California State University, and the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges to facilitate training for ethnic studies Area F reviewers to ensure that the appropriate laws, policies, and procedures governing the curriculum for the California Community Colleges are adhered to during the California State University General Education Breadth ethnic studies Area F review process.
(4)The review process shall be well-structured with appropriate guidelines, timelines, and qualified reviewers in each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies and the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council.
(c)(1)For purposes of the California State University General Education Breadth submission cycle for the 202425 academic year, the review of proposed community college courses for Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies that is scheduled to take place in December 2023 shall be suspended. The review shall recommence once the new process is developed pursuant to subdivision (a) on or before December 31, 2024.
(2)A community college course which has been approved for the California State University Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies as of December 1, 2023, shall no longer satisfy the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032 on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to subdivision (a).
(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that students of the California State University acquire the knowledge and skills that will help them comprehend the diversity and social justice history of the United States and of the society in which they live to enable them to contribute to that society as responsible and constructive citizens.
(b)Commencing with the 202122 academic year, the California State University shall provide for courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses.
(c)The California State University shall collaborate with the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies and the Academic Senate of the California State University to develop core competencies to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course pursuant to implementation of this section. The council and the academic senate shall approve the core competencies before commencement of the 202122 academic year.
(d)Commencing with students graduating in the 202425 202526 academic year, the California State University shall require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one three-unit course in ethnic studies. The university shall not increase the number of units required to graduate from the university with a baccalaureate degree by the enforcement of this requirement. This graduation requirement shall not apply to a postbaccalaureate student who is enrolled in a baccalaureate degree program at the university if the student has satisfied either of the following:
(1)The student has earned a baccalaureate degree from an institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency.
(2)The student has completed an ethnic studies course at a postsecondary educational institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 89032.5 is added to the Education Code, to read:89032.5.The California State University shall collaborate with the office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the Academic Senate of the California State University, the Academic Senate for California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for the California State University to approve eligible community college ethnic studies courses, as meeting the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032, for students who transfer to the California State University from the California Community Colleges.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 1.The California State University shall collaborate with the office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for the California State University to approve eligible community college ethnic studies courses, as meeting the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032, for students who transfer to the California State University from the California Community Colleges.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2023 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 14, 2023 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (July 12). |
| Jul 3, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 1986.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (May 18). |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HIGHER ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Feb 8, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 10. |
| Feb 7, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 14, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 506 Mike Fong Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| American Jewish Committee | ** Against | |
| California Association For Bilingual Education | ** Support | |
| California Community College Ethnic Studies Faculty Council | ** Support | |
| California Faculty Association | ** Support | |
| California State University, Office Of The Chancellor | ** Against | |
| Campaign For College Opportunity | ** Support | |
| Hispanas Organized for Political Equality | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles College Faculty Guild, Local 1521 | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Community College District | ** Support | |
| Pasadena Area Community College District | ** Support | |
| San Diego Community College District | ** Support | |
| StandWithUs | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 506 (Mike Fong) - California State University: graduation requirement: ethnic studies
Version: July 13, 2023 | Policy Vote: ED. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 14, 2023 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the California State University (CSU) to collaborate with the CSU and California Community College (CCC) Academic Senates and the CCC and CSU Council on Ethnic Studies to develop a process for CSU to approve community college ethnic studies course requirements for meeting CSU’s ethnic studies graduation requirement for CCC students transferring to CSU. This bill also requires the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies to make the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies the CSU requirements for ethnic studies.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Chancellor’s Office estimates one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs of $31.3 million to $42.8 million for community colleges to resubmit ethnic studies courses to the CSU Ethnic Studies Faculty Council for approval. This estimate assumes that each course resubmission would cost between $33,319 and $45,542 for colleges to provide stipends and/or release time to faculty, curriculum chairs, and deans to develop the curriculum, course standards, and student learning outcomes consistent with the review process required by this bill. There could be additional one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs of $135,000 to $329,000 statewide for colleges to update course catalogs and student advising practices and procedures. Further, the Chancellor’s Office estimates additional unknown costs, likely in the low millions to tens of millions of dollars, for colleges to also resubmit approved courses to the UC under Cal-GETC, the singular general education transfer pathway, and potential workload for their Academic Senate to revise the general education pathway and for colleges to update student advising practices and procedures.
- The CSU estimates one-time General Fund costs of approximately $1.9 million to comply with the bill’s requirements. This estimate includes an average of $75,000 for various administrative functions such as notifying, advising, and assisting students with changes in approved courses and modifying the degree audit systems. The CSU also estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $410,000 each year to develop the new process, including expanded faculty collaboration, consultation, courser-approval and annual training.
- The UC estimates one-time General Fund costs of $200,000 to $300,000 for additional administrative and faculty workload to consult with stakeholders and re-approve community college courses. This estimate would also cover any new workload that would be required to collaborate with the CSU and CCC systems and change the IGETC and Cal-GETC Ethnic Studies criteria to the extent that it is necessary.
Background:
Existing law requires the CSU to collaborate with the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies and the Academic Senate of the CSU in order to develop core competencies to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course, as specified. It further requires the Council and the CSU Academic Senate to approve the core competencies before commencement of the 2021–2022 academic year.
Existing law requires that beginning with students graduating in the 2024–2025 academic year, the CSU must require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one three-unit course in ethnic studies. It also provides that the CSU is prohibited from increasing the number of units required to graduate from the CSU with a baccalaureate degree by the enforcement of this requirement.
Existing law provides that this graduation requirement must not apply to a post-baccalaureate student who is enrolled in a baccalaureate degree program at the university if the student has satisfied either of the following: the student has earned a baccalaureate degree from an institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency; or the student has completed an ethnic studies course at a postsecondary educational institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires the CSU to collaborate with the CSU and CCC Academic Senate, the CCC Academic Senate, and the CSU and CCC Councils on Ethnic Studies to ensure the development of a process on or before December 31, 2024, for eligible CCC ethnic studies courses to meet the requirements of an ethnic studies course, prescribed in current law for CSU, for students who transfer from the CCC to the CSU.
This bill provides that, for purposes of the process developed, all of the following apply:
- CSU faculty shall be represented by an equal number of members from each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies, to develop the process for approving Area F general education (GE) requirements for ethnic studies.
- The CSU Council on Ethnic Studies shall make the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies the CSU Area F GE requirement for ethnic studies.
- The CSU shall collaborate with the CSU and CCC Council on Ethnic Studies, and the CSU and CCC the Academic Senates to facilitate training for ethnic studies Area F reviewers to ensure that the appropriate laws, policies, and procedures governing the curriculum for the CCC are adhered to during the CSU General Education Breadth ethnic studies Area F review process.
- The review process shall be well-structured with appropriate guidelines, timelines, and qualified reviews in each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the CSU and CCC Council on Ethnic Studies.
This bill suspends the review of proposed community college courses for Area F GE requirements for ethnic studies that is scheduled to take place in December 2023 for purposes of the CSU General Education Breadth submission cycle for the 2024-25 academic year.
This bill provides that a community college course that has been approved for the CSU ethnic studies requirements as of December 1, 2023, no longer satisfies those requirements on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to the bill.
This bill provides that students who have successfully completed an approved community college ethnic studies course before August 1, 2025 shall not be required to take another course to meet the Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies.
Related Legislation:
AB 928 (Berman, Chapter 566, Statutes of 2021), required, among other things, that the CSU and UC jointly establish a singular lower division GE pathway for transfer admission into both segments at CCCs.
AB 1460 (Weber, Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020) requires the CSU, commencing with the 2021-22 academic year, to (1) provide courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses; and (2) require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement commencing with students graduating in the 2024-25 academic year, the completion of, at minimum, one three-unit course in ethnic studies.
Staff Comments:
AB 1460 required the CSU Ethnic Studies Council and the CSU Academic Senate to develop “core competencies” for CSU’s ethnic studies courses, which reflect the knowledge expected to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course. The CCCs also require students to complete an ethnic studies course as a general education requirement in order to transfer to CSU. After the CSU developed its ethnic studies course core competencies, CSU reviewed many of the CCC ethnic studies courses to determine if they could be transferred to fulfill the CSU’s ethnic studies requirement. This bill requires the CSU to collaborate with the CCC Chancellor’s Office, the CCC Academic Senate, and the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty Council to develop a new approval process for approving CCC ethnic studies courses.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: July 12, 2023
Author: | Mike Fong | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: .
SUMMARY
This bill requires, by December 31, 2024, the California State University (CSU) to collaborate with the CSU and California Community College (CCC) Academic Senates, and the CCC and CSU Council on Ethnic Studies to ensure the development of a process for eligible CCC ethnic studies courses to satisfy the CSU ethnic studies requirements for CCC students transferring to CSU. The bill requires the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies to make the final determination regarding whether a community college course satisfies the CSU requirements for ethnic studies. It further suspends the current approval process for one year and provides that a community college course approved for the CSU ethnic studies requirement through December 1, 2023, no longer satisfy the requirements commencing on August 1, 2025.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
1) Confers upon the CSU Trustees the powers, duties, and functions with respect to
the management, administration, control of the CSU system and provides that the Trustees are responsible for the rule of government of their appointees and employees. (Education Code (EC) § 66606 and 89500, et seq.)
2) Requires that the CSU must collaborate with the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies (Council) and the Academic Senate of the CSU in order to develop core competencies to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course, as specified. It further requires the Council and the CSU Academic Senate to approve the core competencies before commencement of the 2021–2022 academic year.
3) Requires that beginning with students graduating in the 2024–2025 AY, the CSU must require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one three-unit course in ethnic studies.
4) Provides that the CSU is prohibited from increasing the number of units required to graduate from the CSU with a baccalaureate degree by the enforcement of this requirement.
5) Stipulates that this graduation requirement must not apply to a post-baccalaureate student who is enrolled in a baccalaureate degree program at the university if the student has satisfied either of the following:
a) The student has earned a baccalaureate degree from an institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency; and,
b) The student has completed an ethnic studies course at a postsecondary educational institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency. (EC § 89032)
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Requires the CSU to collaborate with the CSU and CCC Academic Senate, the CCC Academic Senate, and the CSU and CCC Councils on Ethnic Studies to ensure the development of a process on or before December 31, 2024, for eligible CCC ethnic studies courses to meet the requirements of an ethnic studies course, prescribed in current law for CSU, for students who transfer from the CCC to the CSU.
- Provides that, for purposes of the process developed, all of the following apply:
- Representation from CSU faculty by an equal number of members from
each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies, to develop the process for approving Area F general education (GE) requirements for ethnic studies.
- That the final decision on whether a community college course satisfies
the CSU Area F GE requirement for ethnic studies be made by the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies.
- CSU collaboration with the CSU and CCC Council on Ethnic Studies, and
the CSU and CCC the Academic Senates to facilitate training for ethnic studies Area F reviewers to ensure that the appropriate laws, policies, and procedures governing the curriculum for the CCC are adhered to during the CSU General Education Breadth ethnic studies Area F review process.
- That the review process be well-structured with appropriate guidelines,
timelines, and qualified reviews in each of the four ethnic studies disciplines, as determined by the CSU and CCC Council on Ethnic Studies.
- Suspends the review of proposed community college courses for Area F GE requirements for ethnic studies that is scheduled to take place in December 2023 for purposes of the CSU General Education Breadth submission cycle for the 2024-25 academic year.
- Provides that a community college course that has been approved for the CSU ethnic studies requirements as of December 1, 2023, no longer satisfies those requirements on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to the bill.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “AB 1460 (Weber), signed by the Governor in 2020, requires California State University (CSU) students to complete an ethnic studies course as a requirement for graduation beginning with the Class of 2024-25. With over 90% of students who transfer to the CSU coming from the California Community Colleges (CCC), it is important for CCC courses to have transferability to the CSU. If CCC students are not able to take an approved course, their plan to transfer to a CSU will be delayed. According to the CSU, the approval rate of CCC ethnic studies courses as of September 2022 is 47%. Community College Districts have expressed concerns regarding the lack of clarity in the criteria for approval as well as the high rejection rate. This bill requires the CSU Chancellor’s office to consult with CSU and CCC academic senates and CSU and CCC ethnic studies councils regarding the Area F approval process to increase.”
- Impact on CCC students. Since the enactment of AB 1460 (Weber, Chapter 32, Statutes 2020), CSU has granted transfer approval to approximately 675 community college courses for the CSU ethnic studies requirements. A CCC student who has successfully completed one of the approved courses can apply those credits toward the requirement upon transferring to the CSU. Transferability of credits aims to facilitate a smoother transition into CSU and upper-division coursework. This bill attempts to disqualify the already approved courses, meaning those credits can no longer be applied toward the graduation requirement at CSU. As drafted, this bill would apply to students who are currently enrolled as well as students who have successfully completed an approved course. Implementation of this bill’s provisions could result in the loss of applicable credits for graduation.
Is it appropriate to disqualify courses from fulfilling graduation requirements for students who have already completed those courses?
To ensure students who have already earned credits in the approved courses are held harmless from the implementation of EC§ 89032.5 (c)(2) in the bill, staff recommends that the bill be amended as follows:
89032.5 (c) (1) For purposes of the California State University General Education Breadth submission cycle for the 2024–25 academic year, the review of proposed community college courses for Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies that is scheduled to take place in December 2023 shall be suspended. The review shall recommence once the new process is developed pursuant to subdivision (a) on or before December 31, 2024.
(2) A community college course which has been approved for the California State University Area F general education requirements for ethnic studies as of December 1, 2023, shall no longer satisfy the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided pursuant to Section 89032 on and after August 1, 2025, unless the course is approved under the process developed pursuant to subdivision (a).
(i) Students who have successfully completed an ethnic studies course prior to August 1, 2025 shall not be required to take another course to meet the Area F general education requirement.
- Impact on singular transfer pathway agreement. Current law, enacted by AB 928 (Berman, Chapter 566, Statutes of 2021), required, by May 31, 2023, the Intersegmental Committee of the Academic Senates of the University of California (UC), the CSU, and the CCCs to establish a singular lower division GE pathway that meets the academic eligibility requirements necessary for transfer admission to the CSU and UC (one single set of lower-division GE certification and transfer admission). In order to satisfy these requirements, the Academic Senates of the CCC, the CSU, and the UC endorsed the creation of the California General Education Transfer Curriculum (Cal-GETC), a modified version of the Intersegmental General Education Transfer Curriculum (IGETC). The intersegmental council of academic senates developed the Cal-GETC in 2022 and approved an initial structure in the spring of 2023. The use of the Cal-GETC transfer pathway is intended to begin in the fall of 2025 for the 2025-26 academic year. Under Cal-GETC, every student will be designated simply as having achieved, or not having achieved, Cal-GETC, certification irrespective of their transfer destination. Current law requires that the agreed-upon singular GE pathway (i.e., Cal-GETC) be the only lower division GE pathway used to determine academic eligibility and sufficient academic preparation for transfer admission to CSU and UC. As it relates to this bill, the Cal-GETC course pattern includes satisfaction of Area 6 Ethnic Studies. Under the agreement, a course meeting the CSU Ethnic Studies Core Competencies requirement will be deemed to have met the UC Ethnic Studies Course Competencies requirement. Similarly, a course meeting the UC Ethnic Studies Core Competencies requirement will be deemed to have met the CSU Ethnic Studies Core Competencies requirement. It is unclear whether the implementation of this bill’s provisions to reopen the ethnic studies course approval process without UC involvement would trigger a re-evaluation of the Cal-GETC agreement on ethnic studies.
- CSU’s Ethnic Studies requirement. Current law enacted by AB 1460 (Weber, Chapter 32, Statutes of 2021 ) requires the CSU to require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement commencing with students graduating in the 2024-25 academic year, the completion of a course in ethnic studies. It further required that the CSU collaborate with the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies and the CSU Academic Senate in order to develop core competencies to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course. The CSU Academic Senate adopted those core competencies in November 2020.
- CCC course approval rate. As noted in the Assembly Higher Education Committee analysis, in late 2020, the CSU Chancellor’s Office started the first round of review of courses submitted by CCCs for approval for the 2021-2022 academic year. The submitted CCC courses must include three of the five core competencies adopted by the CSU Academic Senate. Core competencies reflect the knowledge expected to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course.
According to the CSU Chancellor’s Office, the table below shows the final numbers on Area F (of which ethnic studies falls) course approvals. These courses are referred to as Area F in GE. The summary chart below shows the total CCC course approval numbers for the GE cycle ending on September 30, 2022. The data shows that 47% of the courses were deemed to meet the requirements needed for approval, pursuant to existing law established by AB 1460 (Weber, Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020), and 53 percent were rejected.
All Area F Proposals for 2022-2023 AY | ||
Area F Courses | Count | % |
Approved | 323 | 47% |
Denied | 370 | 53% |
Grand Total | 693 | 100% |
- Demand for a more inclusive process. Although CSU faculty have been involved in the decision-making process in the review and approval of CCC ethnic studies courses, concerns have been raised that faculty who have expertise in the area of ethnic studies were excluded from the process and believe that the end result falls short of AB 1460 requirements. According to the author, CCCs throughout the state have expressed many concerns, including high rejection rates, a lack of clarity on what needs to be in the courses in order to gain approval, a lack of clarity on whether the proposed courses must include core competencies word for word, and inconsistencies in approvals by reviewers. This bill requires that reviewers undergo training to ensure that the appropriate laws, policies, and procedures governing the curriculum for the CCCs are adhered to during the review process; which laws, policies, or governing procedures are to be included within the training is not specified in the bill. The committee may wish to consider whether issues related to course review and approval can be effectively addressed without requiring legislative intervention.
- Need for an intersegmental coordinating body. The Master Plan for Higher Education outlines the missions of the CCC, CSU, and UC. However, in recent years, the Legislature has pushed those boundaries by allowing CCCs to offer baccalaureate programs and several doctoral programs at CSU. At the same time, in an effort to streamline transfer pathways for students, legislation has forced collaboration between the segments. Additionally, there has been an influx of legislation to address workforce shortages in creative ways within higher education. It seems likely that the Legislature will see other proposals in future years to expand the institutional mission, mandate the offering of specific programs of study, or intervene in matters to resolve intersegmental conflict resulting from overlapping missions or consolidating transfer pathways. These types of programmatic changes are being taken up in a piecemeal way with no comprehensive plan for future growth for, or expectations of, higher education in California; if this trend persists, it could result in an uncoordinated and fragmented system of higher education. Prior to its demise, the role of the California Postsecondary Education Commission (CPEC) included program review to coordinate the long-range planning of the state’s public higher education systems as a means to ensure that the segments were working together to carry out their individual missions while serving the state’s long-range workforce and economic needs. In the wake of CPEC’s closure, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) cautioned in its 2012 higher education oversight report that no office or committee has the resources to devote to reviewing degree programs to identify long-term costs, alignment with state needs and institutional missions, duplication, and priority relative to other demands. The committee may wish to consider whether establishing a higher education coordinating entity is necessary to coordinate successful collaboration and guide the state’s higher education agenda. A CPEC-like entity could facilitate the review of new degree programs, make recommendations on proposals that push mission boundaries, monitor student access, improve coordination among the public segments, and ensure alignment of degrees and credentials with economic and workforce development needs.
- Arguments in opposition. The CSU argues, in part, in their opposition letter, “In 2020 Assembly Member Shirley Weber authored AB 1460, which requires all CSU students who graduate beginning in the 2024-25 academic year to complete an ethnic studies course. The statute directed the CSU to work with the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies and the CSU Academic Senate to develop core competencies to ensure that courses include academic content and substance. As a general education (GE) requirement, all ethnic studies courses which seek to meet this requirement must undergo a GE review process and meet the competencies required in AB 1460. This includes community college courses offered to students who plan to transfer and wish to fulfill this GE requirement at their community college.
Since AB 1460 was signed into law, the CSU has worked collaboratively to approve nearly 650 community college ethnic studies courses which satisfy this requirement. All reviewers are Ethnic Studies faculty. Students have been taking approved courses since the fall of 2021, and CSU is on target to ensure that our graduates fulfill this requirement by 2024-25. The University of California recently implemented its own ethnic studies GE requirement and has worked successfully with CSU to ensure alignment in community college course transfer approval.
Despite the collective progress achieved by community colleges, CSU, and University of California (UC), AB 506 seeks to create a new approval process between community colleges and CSU for ethnic studies courses only three years after CSU’s requirement was signed into law. In doing so, it proposes to suspend the current approval process for one year and states that courses approved through 2023 no longer satisfy the requirement. This will be disruptive to students, faculty, and staff at public postsecondary segments.”
- Arguments in support. According to the letter of support submitted to the committee from the sponsors of the bill, California Community Colleges Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, “The initial goal of AB1460 is to ensure that all students complete an Ethnic Studies course in preparation for their holistic development, sense of belonging and full participation in all aspects of humanity and its global communities. Ethnic Studies disciplines provide an alternative intellectual approach grounded in holistic and culturally centered worldviews where students gain emancipatory and liberatory learning experiences that empower them to become agents of their own learning. This provides an understanding of the origin and persistence of knowledge gaps that cultivate the agency students need to transcend these gaps.
The courses fulfilling this Ethnic Studies requirement must include introductory or integrative baccalaureate-level courses in the Ethnic Studies autonomous disciplines of Black/African American/Africana Studies, American Indian/Native American Studies, Chicano/a/x and Latino/a/x Studies, and Asian American Studies.
It is therefore essential that the review process include Ethnic Studies discipline faculty to ensure appropriate courses are available for students to complete the CSU Area F general education, graduation and transfer requirement. This will correct and eliminate fifty plus years of Institutional Centered Compromise and Colonization (ICCC) within American higher education.”
- Prior legislation
AB 928 (Berman, Chapter 566, Statutes of 2021), required, among other things,
that the CSU and UC jointly establish a singular lower division GE pathway for transfer admission into both segments at CCCs.
AB 1460 (Weber, Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020) requires the CSU, commencing with the 2021-22 academic year, to (1) provide courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses; and (2) require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement commencing with students graduating in the 2024-25 academic year, the completion of, at minimum, one three-unit course in ethnic studies.
SUPPORT
California Association for Bilingual Education
California Community College Ethnic Studies Faculty Council
California Faculty Association
Campaign for College Opportunity
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality
Los Angeles College Faculty Guild, Local 1521
Pasadena Area Community College District
San Diego Community College District
OPPOSITION
American Jewish Committee
California State University, Office of the Chancellor
StandWithUS
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 506
Author:(Mike Fong and Weber)
As Amended Ver:April 17, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Delays implementation of the California State University's (CSU) ethnic studies graduation requirement by one year.
Major Provisions
- Requires that the CSU must collaborate with the California Community College (CCC) Chancellor's Office, the Academic Senate of the CSU, the Academic Senate for CCC, the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies in order to develop a process for the CSU to approve eligible CCC ethnic studies courses, as meeting the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided, as specified, for students who transfer to the CSU from the CCC.
- Delays implementation of the CSU ethnic studies graduation requirement by one year; from the 2024-2025 academic year (AY) to the 2025-2026 AY.
COMMENTS
Background. AB 1460 (Shirley Weber), Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020, requires CSU students graduating in 2024-2025 to complete a course in ethnic studies. As a general education requirement, community college students must complete an ethnic studies course in order to transfer to the CSU. Pursuant to the requirement in AB 1460 (Shirley Weber), core competencies were adopted by the CSU Ethnic Studies Council and the CSU Academic Senate.
Ethnic studies courses at the CSU. Commencing in 1968, CSU campuses responded to student demands and struggles and developed Ethnic Studies units in different forms. Some institutions like San Francisco State created a school, which later became a College of Ethnic Studies. Other institutions' separate and autonomous Ethnic Studies units became departments or programs, while others like Sacramento State and CSU, Fullerton formed a department constituted by different Ethnic Studies programs. These varied distinct and combined Ethnic Studies departments and programs focused on and fostered interdisciplinary scholarship, discourse and projects of national and international scope and import.
Status of the ethnics studies graduation requirement at the CSU. In late 2020, the CSU Office of the Chancellor started the first round of review of courses submitted by CCC campuses under the CSU Area F approval for the 2021-2022 AY. The submitted CCC courses must include three of the five core competencies. [Core competencies reflect the knowledge expected to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course.]
According to the CSU Office of the Chancellor, the tables below show the final numbers on Area F (of which ethnic studies falls) course approvals. These courses are referred to as Area F in General Education (GE). Committee Staff understands that the CSU extended the Area F resubmission deadline in order to allow additional time for CCC to undertake course revisions. The summary chart below (from the CSU Office of the Chancellor) shows the total CCC course approval numbers for the GE cycle ending on September 30, 2022. The data shows that 47% of the courses meet the requirements needed for approval, pursuant to existing law (AB 1460, Shirley Weber).
All Area F Proposals for 2022-2023 AY | ||
Area F Courses | Count | % |
Approved | 323 | 47% |
Denied | 370 | 53% |
Grand Total | 693 | 100% |
Many community college districts throughout the state have expressed concerns, including high rejection rates, lack of clarity on what needs to be in the courses in order to gain approval, lack of clarity on whether the proposed courses must include core competencies word for word, and inconsistencies of approvals by reviewers.
According to the CSU Office of the Chancellor, the chart below shows the approval rate of a subgroup of courses which were resubmitted. That is to say, the 188 courses in the chart below are also accounted for in the chart above.
Area F Resubmission (June to September 2022) | ||
Area F Courses | Count | % |
Approved | 162 | 86% |
Denied | 26 | 14% |
Total | 188 | 100% |
According to the CSU Office of the Chancellor, every CCC now as at least one Ethnic Studies course with Area F approval.
According to the Author
The author states that, "with over 90% of students who transfer to the CSU coming from the CCC, it is important for CCC courses to have transferability to the CSU. If CCC students are not able to take an approved course, their plan to transfer to a CSU could be delayed."
According to the author, "underrepresented students make up a substantial portion of the student body at CCCs. The racial/ethnic breakdown of CCC students is as follows: 46% Hispanic/Latinx, 24% White, 11% Asian, 6% Black, 4% Multi-ethnic, 3% Filipino, less than 1% American Indian and Alaskan Native, less than 1% Pacific Islander, and 6% unknown. About half of California Community College [CCC] students are traditional aged (24 or younger) and half are adult students (25 or older). Sixty-four percent of students across the system are classified as Perkins Economically Disadvantaged."[1]
The author states that, "in order to increase the number of underrepresented students transferring to the CSU, the number of CCC approved ethnic studies courses must increase."
Lastly, the author states that, "requiring the CSU Office of the Chancellor to consult with relevant entities, including both CCC and CSU ethnic studies councils, will help improve the process for approving CCC courses, increase approval rates, and make CCC ethnic studies courses more available."
Arguments in Support
According to the Los Angeles Community College District, "the California State University graduation requirement for Ethnic Studies is currently set to take effect beginning in the 2024-2025 academic year. However, there has been significant confusion surrounding the approval process for California Community College courses that would satisfy the graduation requirement for transfer students. AB 506 would delay the implementation of the graduation requirement until the 2025-2026 academic year to provide additional time for the aforementioned groups to develop a comprehensive course approval process. This would ensure that only courses that fit the four original, autonomous disciplines of Ethnic Studies are approved."
Arguments in Opposition
According to the Academic Senate of the California State University (ASCSU), which represents more than 28,000 faculty of the CSU on academic matters of systemwide concern, "we write in opposition to AB 506, because the Office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges (CCC) should not be involved in setting California State University (CSU) graduation requirements. That is a direct violation of AB 1460 which sets in place the ASCSU and the California State University Council on Ethnic Studies alone as determining CSU Ethnic Studies graduation requirements. Furthermore, the intersegmental curricular work necessary for articulation of coursework between segments has not been funded. We believe that providing state support for the smooth implementation of AB 1460 would better meet the goals of AB 506."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- Ongoing Proposition 98 costs, likely not exceeding $80,000, for workload associated with collaborating with CSU. This assumes that each of the 10 members of the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty would spend 55 hours collaborating with the CSU annually, at $8,000 per member.
The CCC Chancellor's Office indicates the CCC Academic Senate and the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty Council are in communication with the CSU regarding the CSU ethnic studies requirement.
- One-time General Fund costs of $200,000 to CSU academic program staff for additional administrative workload and faculty buy-out time to consult with additional groups.
VOTES
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: 12-0-0
YES: Mike Fong, Ta, Addis, Arambula, Gabriel, Irwin, Low, Ortega, Sanchez, Santiago, Wallis, Weber
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-0-1
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: April 17, 2023
CONSULTANT: Jeanice Warden / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0000690
Student Enrollment and Demographics. The CCC Chancellor's Office. Retrieved March 29, 2023, from https://www.cccco.edu/About-Us/Chancellors-Office/Divisions/Digital-Innovation-and-Infrastructure/research-data-analytics/data-snapshot/student-demographics ↑
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 506
Author:(Mike Fong) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2023
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill delays the requirement for the California State University (CSU) to require one three unit ethnic studies course as an undergraduate graduation requirement for CSU, from the 2024-25 academic year to the 2025-26 academic year.
In addition, the bill requires CSU to collaborate with the California Community College (CCC) Chancellor’s Office, the Academic Senates of the CSU and CCC, and the Ethnic Studies Faculty Councils of the CSU and CCC to develop a process for CSU to approve CCC ethnic studies courses as meeting CSU’s graduation requirement of an ethnic studies course for students who transfer from CCC to CSU.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Ongoing Proposition 98 costs, likely not exceeding $80,000, for workload associated with collaborating with CSU. This assumes that each of the 10 members of the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty would spend 55 hours collaborating with the CSU annually, at $8,000 per member.
The CCC Chancellor’s Office indicates the CCC Academic Senate and the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty Council are in communication with the CSU regarding the CSU ethnic studies requirement.
- One-time General Fund costs of $200,000 to CSU academic program staff for additional administrative workload and faculty buy-out time to consult with additional groups.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
With over 90% of students who transfer to the CSU coming from the CCC, it is important for CCC courses to have transferability to the CSU. If CCC students are not able to take an approved course, their plan to transfer to a CSU could be delayed…in order to increase the number of underrepresented students transferring to the CSU, the number of CCC approved ethnic studies courses must increase.
- Background. AB 1460 (Shirley Weber), Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020, required CSU students graduating in the 2024-2025 academic year to complete a course in ethnic studies. AB 1460 required the CSU Ethnic Studies Council and the CSU Academic Senate to develop “core competencies” for CSU’s ethnic studies courses. Core competencies reflect the knowledge expected to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course.
CCC also requires students to complete an ethnic studies course as a general education requirement in order to transfer to CSU. After CSU developed its ethnic studies course core competencies, CSU reviewed hundreds of CCC ethnic studies courses to determine if the CCC ethnic studies courses could be transferred to fulfill the CSU’s ethnic studies requirement. As of September 30, 2022, of 693 courses submitted, 47% were approved.
This bill requires the CSU to consult with CCC entities and others to develop a new approval process for CCC ethnic studies courses for fulfillment of the CSU ethnic studies graduation requirement.
- CSU Concerns. According to the CSU Chancellor’s office, this bill would add several additional layers of academic consultation for ethnic studies course approvals and delay by one year implementation of AB 1460, which mandates an ethnic studies graduation requirement for CSU students by the 2024-25 academic year.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 25, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Mike Fong, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 506 (
Author:Mike Fong) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2023
SUBJECT: California State University: graduation requirement: ethnic studies.
SUMMARY: Delays implementation of the California State University’s (CSU) ethnic studies graduation requirement by one year. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that the CSU must collaborate with the California Community College (CCC) Chancellor’s Office, the Academic Senate of the CSU, the Academic Senate for CCC, the CCC Ethnic Studies Faculty Council, and the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies in order to develop a process for the CSU to approve eligible CCC ethnic studies courses, as meeting the requirements of an ethnic studies course provided, as specified, for students who transfer to the CSU from the CCC.
- Delays implementation of the CSU ethnic studies graduation requirement by one year; from the 2024-2025 academic year (AY) to the 2025-2026 AY.
EXISTING LAW:
- Confers upon the CSU Trustees the powers, duties, and functions with respect to the management, administration, control of the CSU system and provides that the Trustees are responsible for the rule of government of their appointees and employees (Education Code Sections 66606 and 89500, et seq.).
- Requires that the CSU must collaborate with the CSU Council on Ethnic Studies (Council) and the Academic Senate of the CSU in order to develop core competencies to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course, as specified. Requires the Council and the CSU Academic Senate to approve the core competencies before commencement of the 2021–2022 AY.
Requires that beginning with students graduating in the 2024–2025 AY, the CSU must require, as an undergraduate graduation requirement, the completion of, at minimum, one three-unit course in ethnic studies.
Stipulates that the CSU is prohibited from increasing the number of units required to graduate from the CSU with a baccalaureate degree by the enforcement of this requirement.
Stipulates that this graduation requirement must not apply to a postbaccalaureate student who is enrolled in a baccalaureate degree program at the university if the student has satisfied either of the following:
- The student has earned a baccalaureate degree from an institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency; and,
- The student has completed an ethnic studies course at a postsecondary educational institution accredited by a regional accrediting agency (EC 89032).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Background. AB 1460 (Shirley Weber), Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020, requires CSU students graduating in 2024-2025 to complete a course in ethnic studies. As a general education requirement, community college students must complete an ethnic studies course in order to transfer to the CSU. Pursuant to the requirement in AB 1460 (Shirley Weber), core competencies were adopted by the CSU Ethnic Studies Council and the CSU Academic Senate.
Purpose of this measure. The author states that, “with over 90% of students who transfer to the CSU coming from the CCC, it is important for CCC courses to have transferability to the CSU. If CCC students are not able to take an approved course, their plan to transfer to a CSU could be delayed.”
According to the author, “underrepresented students make up a substantial portion of the student body at CCCs. The racial/ethnic breakdown of CCC students is as follows: 46% Hispanic/Latinx, 24% White, 11% Asian, 6% Black, 4% Multi-ethnic, 3% Filipino, less than 1% American Indian and Alaskan Native, less than 1% Pacific Islander, and 6% unknown. About half of California Community College [CCC] students are traditional aged (24 or younger) and half are adult students (25 or older). Sixty-four percent of students across the system are classified as Perkins Economically Disadvantaged.”[1]
The author states that, “in order to increase the number of underrepresented students transferring to the CSU, the number of CCC approved ethnic studies courses must increase.”
Ethnic studies courses at the CSU. Commencing in 1968, CSU campuses responded to student demands and struggles and developed Ethnic Studies units in different forms. Some institutions like San Francisco State created a school, which later became a College of Ethnic Studies. Other institutions' separate and autonomous Ethnic Studies units became departments or programs, while others like Sacramento State and CSU, Fullerton formed a department constituted by different Ethnic Studies programs. These varied distinct and combined Ethnic Studies departments and programs focused on and fostered interdisciplinary scholarship, discourse and projects of national and international scope and import.
Status of the ethnics studies graduation requirement at the CSU. In late 2020, the CSU Office of the Chancellor started the first round of review of courses submitted by CCC campuses under the CSU Area F approval for the 2021-2022 AY. The submitted CCC courses must include three of the five core competencies. [Core competencies reflect the knowledge expected to be achieved by students who complete an ethnic studies course.]
According to the CSU Office of the Chancellor, the tables below show the final numbers on Area F (of which ethnic studies falls) course approvals. These courses are referred to as Area F in General Education (GE). Committee Staff understands that the CSU extended the Area F resubmission deadline in order to allow additional time for CCC to undertake course revisions. The summary chart below (from the CSU Office of the Chancellor) shows the total CCC course approval numbers for the GE cycle ending on September 30, 2022. The data shows that 47% of the courses meet the requirements needed for approval, pursuant to existing law (AB 1460, Shirley Weber).
All Area F Proposals for 2022-2023 AY | ||
Area F Courses | Count | % |
Approved | 323 | 47% |
Denied | 370 | 53% |
Grand Total | 693 | 100% |
Committee Staff understands that many community college districts throughout the state have expressed many concerns, including high rejection rates, lack of clarity on what needs to be in the courses in order to gain approval, lack of clarity on whether the proposed courses must include core competencies word for word, and inconsistencies of approvals by reviewers.
According to the CSU Office of the Chancellor, the chart below shows the approval rate of a subgroup of courses which were resubmitted. That is to say, the 188 courses in the chart below are also accounted for in the chart above.
Area F Resubmission (June to September 2022) | ||
Area F Courses | Count | % |
Approved | 162 | 86% |
Denied | 26 | 14% |
Total | 188 | 100% |
According to the CSU Office of the Chancellor, every CCC now as at least one Ethnic Studies course with Area F approval.
The author states that, “requiring the CSU Office of the Chancellor to consult with relevant entities, including both CCC and CSU ethnic studies councils, will help improve the process for approving CCC courses, increase approval rates, and make CCC ethnic studies courses more available.”
Committee comments. This measure, in part, delays the implementation date for meeting the ethnic studies graduation requirement by one year [from 2024-2025 AY to 2025-2026 AY] in order to provide additional time for more CCC course approvals.
Further, this measure will also require the CSU Office of the Chancellor to consult with CSU and CCC Academic Senates and the CSU and CCC ethnic studies councils regarding the approval process of ethnic studies courses for transfer. Committee Staff understands the University of California (UC) is in the process of considering an ethnic studies course as a graduation requirement.
Moving forward, the author may wish to consider requesting the UC Academic Senate and the UC Ethnic Studies Council be a part of the collaborative process.
Arguments in support. According to the Los Angeles Community College District, “the California State University graduation requirement for Ethnic Studies is currently set to take effect beginning in the 2024-2025 academic year. However, there has been significant confusion surrounding the approval process for California Community College courses that would satisfy the graduation requirement for transfer students. AB 506 would delay the implementation of the graduation requirement until the 2025-2026 academic year to provide additional time for the aforementioned groups to develop a comprehensive course approval process. This would ensure that only courses that fit the four original, autonomous disciplines of Ethnic Studies are approved.”
Related legislation. AB 654 (Cervantes) of 2023, which, per the request of the author, is a two-year bill, requests the University of California to establish an ethnic studies undergraduate graduation requirement at the UC.
AB 1255 (Wendy Carrillo) of 2023, which, per the request of the author, is a two-year bill, requires the California Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CTC) to convene a statewide task force, composed of relevant stakeholders, and requires the task force, by September 1, 2024, to provide a report to the CTC and the Legislature with recommendations for the criteria that should be required in order to obtain a single-subject credential in ethnic studies. The measure requires the CTC, by January 1, 2025, to use the task force’s recommendations to begin developing the criteria that will be required in order to obtain a single-subject credential in ethnic studies.
Prior legislation. AB 1964 (Mike Fong) of 2022, which was held in this Committee, in part, would require the Chancellor of the CCC and the Chancellor of the CSU to ensure that at least one course identification (C-ID) descriptor number in certain ethnic studies areas is issued, as provided. Additionally, this measure would require each CSU campus to accept any community college course articulated or approved, as specified, as meeting the campus’ lower division ethnic studies course graduation requirement. Further, this measure would prohibit a CSU campus from revoking the approval of any community college course previously accepted as meeting the campus’ lower division ethnic studies course graduation requirement, except as provided.
AB 1040 (Muratsuchi) of 2021, which was held in the Senate Committee on Education, would, in part, require, commencing with the 2022-2023 AY, each community college district to offer courses in ethnic studies at each of its campuses; and, would require, beginning with the 2024-2025 AY, each CCD to require the completion of at least one course in ethnic studies of at least three-units as a requirement for a student to obtain an associate degree.
AB 3310 (Muratsuchi) of 2020, which died for a lack of hearing by this Committee, was substantially similar AB 1040 (as described above).
AB 1460 (Shirley Weber), Chapter 32, Statutes of 2020, in part, enacted the ethnics studies graduation requirement for CSU students (see (2) in the Existing law section of this analysis for further details).
AB 2408 (Shirley Weber) of 2018, which was held by this Committee, per the request of the author, was very similar in nature to AB 1460 (as described above).
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association for Bilingual Education (CABE)
Los Angeles Community College District
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Jeanice Warden / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Student Enrollment and Demographics. The CCC Chancellor's Office. Retrieved March 29, 2023, from https://www.cccco.edu/About-Us/Chancellors-Office/Divisions/Digital-Innovation-and-Infrastructure/research-data-analytics/data-snapshot/student-demographics ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Education
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):