AB 542: Self-service storage facilities: lien sales.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-08
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-08: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 531, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges, including through enforcement of a lien by the sale of the stored property. These procedures require an advertisement of the sale to be published once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. Existing law requires the advertisement to include, among other things, a general description of the goods. Existing law requires, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in at least 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
This bill would instead require publication once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, or publication once in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on an internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales for at least 7 days before the sale, as specified. The bill would require that, in either case, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The bill would remove the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods.
Existing law, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges, including through enforcement of a lien by the sale of the stored property. These procedures require an advertisement of the sale to be published once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. Existing law requires the advertisement to include, among other things, a general description of the goods. Existing law requires, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in at least 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
This bill would instead require publication once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, or publication once in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on an internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales for at least 7 days before the sale, as specified. The bill would require that, in either case, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The bill would remove the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods.
Existing law, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges, including through enforcement of a lien by the sale of the stored property. These procedures require an advertisement of the sale to be published once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. Existing law requires the advertisement to include, among other things, a general description of the goods. Existing law requires, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in at least 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
This bill would instead require publication once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, or publication once in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on an internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales for at least 7 days before the sale, as specified. The bill would require that, in either case, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The bill would remove the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods.
Existing law, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges, including through enforcement of a lien by the sale of the stored property. These procedures require an advertisement of the sale to be published once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. Existing law requires the advertisement to include, among other things, a general description of the goods. Existing law requires, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in at least 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
This bill would instead require a single publication once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in either the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located. The bill would delete the above-described alternative that the advertisement be posted in at least 6 conspicuous places and would alternatively authorize an owner to satisfy these notice requirements by publishing an advertisement for the sale located, or publication once in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on an internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill would require the online advertisement to remain online for 7 days before the sale. sales for at least 7 days before the sale, as specified. The bill would require that, in either case, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The bill would remove the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods.
Existing law, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges, including through enforcement of a lien by the sale of the stored property. These procedures require an advertisement of the sale to be published once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. Existing law requires, if there is no newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in at least 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
This bill would instead require a single publication in a newspaper of general circulation in either the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located. The bill would delete the above-described alternative that the advertisement be posted in at least 6 conspicuous places and would alternatively authorize an owner to satisfy these notice requirements by publishing an advertisement for the sale on an internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill would require the online advertisement to remain online for 7 days before the sale.
Existing law, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges, including through enforcement of a lien by the sale of the stored property. These procedures require an advertisement of the sale to be published once per week for 2 consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held.
This bill would instead require a single publication in a newspaper of general circulation in either the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service facility is located. The bill would alternatively authorize an owner to satisfy these notice requirements by publishing an advertisement for the sale on an internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
(a)(1)After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published before the sale in either of the following ways:
(A)Once per week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located.
(B)Once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale.
(2)If, pursuant to either subparagraph (A) or (B), there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
(3)The advertisement shall include the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility.
(4)For the purposes of this subdivision, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(b)(1)The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupants behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
(2)For the purposes of this subdivision, a commercially reasonable manner of sale includes, but is not limited to, an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales.
(a)(1)After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published before the sale in either of the following ways:
(A)Once per week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located.
(B)Once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale.
(2)If, pursuant to either subparagraph (A) or (B), there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
(3)The advertisement shall include the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility.
(4)For the purposes of this subdivision, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(b)(1)The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupants behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
(2)For the purposes of this subdivision, a commercially reasonable manner of sale includes, but is not limited to, an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales.
(a)(1)After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published before the sale in either of the following ways:
(A)Once per week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located.
(B)Once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale.
(2)If, pursuant to either subparagraph (A) or (B), there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The advertisement shall include the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility.
(3)The advertisement shall include the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility.
(4)For the purposes of this subdivision, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(3)(b)(1)The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupants behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
(b) For the purposes of this section, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code.(2)For the purposes of this section, subdivision, a commercially reasonable manner of sale includes, but is not limited to, an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales.
(a)(1)After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published before the sale once in either of the following ways:
(A)Once per week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, instead of publishing an advertisement for the sale in a newspaper of general circulation, an advertisement for the sale may be published on
(B)Once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale. The
(2)If, pursuant to either subparagraph (A) or (B), there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The advertisement shall include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility. The
(3)The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupants behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
(b)For the purposes of this section, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code. For the purposes of this section, a commercially reasonable manner of sale includes, but is not limited to, an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales.
(a)After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published before the sale once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, instead of publishing an advertisement for the sale in a newspaper of general circulation, an advertisement for the sale may be published on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale. The advertisement shall include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. If there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupants behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
(b)For the purposes of this section, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code. For the purposes of this section, a commercially reasonable manner of sale includes, but is not limited to, an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales.
(a)After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. held or in the county where the self-service facility is located. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, instead of publishing an advertisement for the sale in a newspaper of general circulation, an advertisement for the sale may be published on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The advertisement shall include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. If there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupants behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
(b)For the purposes of this section, publication of notice in a public notice district is governed by Chapter 1.1 (commencing with Section 6080) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code. For the purposes of this section, a commercially reasonable manner of sale includes, but is not limited to, an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible Internet Web site internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 531, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 8, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 15, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 3178.). |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Page 3011.) |
| Sep 6, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 8 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 6, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 2417.). |
| Jun 15, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 13). |
| May 10, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 2, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 1, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 1406.) |
| Apr 27, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1357.) |
| Mar 16, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 15, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Mar 14, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (March 14). |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 11. |
| Feb 8, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2023 | AB 542 Juan Carrillo Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB542 Juan Carrillo By Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 13, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2023 | AB 542 Juan Carrillo Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 14, 2023 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Black Media | ** Against | |
| California News Publishers Association | ** Against | |
| California Self Storage Association | ** Support | |
| Ethnic Media Services | ** Against | |
| Self Storage Association | ** Support | |
| Self-Storage Association | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 542
Author:(Juan Carrillo)
As Amended Ver:June 15, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Revises the advertising requirement of lien sales in the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act. Existing law requires publication of a lien sale for two consecutive weeks in a print newspaper. This bill provides an alternative: it permits an operator to advertise a lien sale once in a print newspaper and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
Major Provisions
- Requires a self-service storage facility operator to advertise a lien sale in one of two ways:
- Once per week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation; or
- Once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-storage facility is located and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
- Requires an operator who elects option b), above, to post the online advertisement for seven days before the sale.
- Requires an advertisement to include the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility.
- Establishes that in the event there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement must be posted at least 10 days before the sale in no fewer than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
- Expands the location of permitted advertisement of lien in newspaper also to include the county where the self-service facility is located.
Senate Amendments
Clarify organization of the bill's provisions through minor technical amendments.
COMMENTS
In the event a person renting a unit within a self-storage facility fails to pay the required rent, existing law enables a facility operator to place a lien on the property stored within the unit and subsequently sell the property if adequate rent is not paid. In the event of a lien sale, existing law requires the facility owner to publicize the sale of the unit's contents in a newspaper of general circulation for two weeks. This bill expands the method of advertising for lien sales to include once in a print newspaper and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. Proponents of this measure contend that this bill will modernize the existing law to enable more Californians to become aware of property they may wish to purchase.
Existing law protects persons who use self-storage facilities with robust notices prior to any lien sale. The California Self-Storage Facility Act (the Act), set forth in Business and Professions Code Sections 21700 - 21716, is the principal law regulating the relationship between the owners of self-storage facilities and the occupants of self-storage units within those facilities. One of the Act's most important aspects is its specification of the owner's rights to dispose of an occupant's stored personal property if the occupant fails to timely pay storage fees, including rent. Under the Act, the owner has a right to place a lien on the occupant's personal property as security for unpaid storage fees. However, the lien does not attach (become legally enforceable) unless the owner follows statutory procedures meant to ensure that the occupant has notice of the lien, any lien sale, and an opportunity to oppose the lien sale.
The rental agreement in place between the self-storage operator and the occupant is required to contain a statement that the occupant's property is subject to the storage owner's lien and may be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid. In the event of unpaid storage fees, prior to placing a lien, the operator must do the following:
- No earlier than 14 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a preliminary lien notice informing the occupant that if the overdue fees are not paid, then the occupant's right to access their stored personal property may terminate and a lien may then attach to their property.
- No earlier than 28 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a notice of lien sale (which sets forth the amount due and informs the occupant that their property may be sold within 14 days from the date of mailing) and a blank declaration in opposition to lien sale which the occupant may complete and return. Having sent these documents, the owner can legally bar the occupant from the storage space and remove any personal property therein for safekeeping.
- If the occupant signs and returns the declaration in opposition before the date of sale in the notice, then the owner cannot conduct a lien sale and must instead sue the occupant to enforce the lien.
- Otherwise, no earlier than 42 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner may proceed with the lien sale and sell the occupant's stored personal property.
These notice requirements – which inform occupants of the itemized fees that are due, their rights to redeem their property under the law, and the procedures and options available to them to protect their property rights and avoid a lien sale – are crucial to safeguarding occupants' property rights.
As an additional safeguard, the owner must send these notices to both the occupant's last known address and one alternate address provided by the occupant. In 2018, the Act was modernized to allow the occupant to elect to receive notices by electronic mail. In 2020, when the electronic mail provision was set to sunset, this Committee received no comments indicating that emailed notices had caused harm to self-storage unit occupants. In sum, under the statutory scheme, the occupant receives multiple direct notices alerting them to the impending sale. All of these direct notices to the occupant must occur before the sale is advertised in a newspaper of general circulation. Nothing in the bill alters or lessens the existing law's requirements that the owner of property that is subject to a potential lien sale must be notified of their rights to reclaim their property, or how those notices must occur.
The purpose of the sale advertisement is to bring bidders to the sale. In recognition of the changing reality of how auctions and sales actually take place, the Act was amended in 2017 to clarify that a lien sale may be conducted through an online auction or sale on a publicly accessible website. These online websites permit a potential bidder to search by location or keywords, and perhaps most importantly, include color photographs of the storage unit's contents that are to be sold. In fact, by utilizing online sites, as opposed to print descriptions, many potential buyers are better able to understand exactly what property is being sold and to determine whether they may wish to purchase it. Online auction sites are free to search, but charge a percentage fee per auction sale.
A higher sale price benefits the former tenant, as any proceeds realized from the sale are applied to pay down their debts. In fact, in the rare instance in which auction proceeds are greater than the debt, the excess must be returned to the former tenant or escheat to the County. (Business and Professions Code Section 21707(a).)
This measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. Recognizing that most Californians use internet-based resources when searching for items to purchase, this measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. Under existing law, an operator is required to publish the advertisement in a print newspaper for two consecutive weeks. This measure provides an operator an alternative: it permits an operator to advertise a lien sale once in a print newspaper and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
Opponents argue that this bill may harm property owner's rights and limit the public's access to information about lien sales. Opponents raise concerns about reducing the required number of times an advertisement must be published in a print newspaper, which is an independent forum in general circulation. Specifically, the opponents argue that this measure overestimates Californians access to broadband. Additionally, the opposition appears to argue that newspaper publication is the most transparent means of alerting a person of the impending sale of their property, despite the existing law's comprehensive notice requirements. Given that the owner of the property subject to a lien sale is already provided several notices of the impending action, the existing law's newspaper notice appears primarily aimed at boosting public interest in the auction as a means of increasing revenue, rather than alerting the impacted party of the impending sale. Accordingly, some consideration should be given to the arguments of those conducting the sale that online notices are more effective than print notices in newspapers. Nonetheless, print notices remain an important means of communication and this measure retains – an albeit reduced – print publication requirement.
According to the Author
Assembly Bill 542 seeks to remove an unnecessary burden on many small California storage owners by allowing them to advertise upcoming lien sales on a publicly accessible website, providing a commonsense alternative to outdated advertising requirements….This bill updates the California Self Service Storage Facility Act by providing storage operators with the flexibility and additional options to advertise lien sales, while still retaining the ability to advertise in the newspaper.
Arguments in Support
This bill is supported by the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, who write in support:
By way of background, in self storage the operator and occupants have a commercial landlord-tenant relationship. A broad swath of consumers use self storage for a variety of reasons. Once a unit size is selected, a consumer signs the rental agreement, the contract that governs the relationship between the operator and the occupant. All rental agreements are month-to-month tenancies that renew only upon the mutual desire of both parties. In other words, occupants can simply vacate if they are unable or unwilling to pay for the leased space. Most tenancies are successful for both parties; goods are stored, and rent is timely paid…
National data from the SSA indicate that storage operators sell approximately 1% to 3% of leased spaces annually. Anecdotally, many of the lien sales involve occupants who have abandoned the space after removing their valuable property and are not interested in what is remaining in the space. Stated differently, 97-99% of tenants will use the space per the rental agreement and never have their belongings subject to a lien sale. The lien process is an infrequently used procedure, but it is necessary for the successful operation of a storage facility. Operators' primary goal is to recover the space, which can then be rented by a paying customer...
It has been suggested that the advertisement may provide some form of constructive notice to the tenant. However, the suggestion that a tenant or a friend may happen upon an advertisement (in a legal notice listing), which prompts the tenant to pay the debt to avoid the sale is questionable, at best. In that hypothetical, an occupant would have been unresponsive to all direct notices. All notices to the alternative contact (if any) would similarly have been ignored. There is an extremely low or no probability an occupant, the alternative contact, friend, or family member would then purchase the one newspaper where the notice was published or scour capublicnotice.com, read all the ads, see the specific advertisement, alert that tenant who then immediately pays the debt owed. That simply does not happen.
The California Moving and Storage Associate made a late-submission in support if amended to provide parity in the advertisement requirements for warehouse owners.
Arguments in Opposition
The California News Publishers Association, along with Ethnic Media Services and California Black Media, write the following in opposition to this bill:
AB 542 contemplates reliance on niche websites as a resort for public information. Information consumption in the State contradicts this belief. More than 10 million Californians rely on home-delivered print newspapers or their e-editions for news. The weekly circulation, unique web visitor counts, and social media following of newspapers is a thousand-fold of websites that conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill also propose that an advertisement of the sale shall be published once instead of once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation. The fact is, with AB 542, most people won't get notices at all.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-0
YES: Maienschein, Essayli, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas, Sanchez
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0-2
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones‑Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Lackey, McKinnor
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED
VERSION: June 15, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke and Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001084
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 542 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 542
Author: Juan Carrillo (D)
Amended: 6/15/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/13/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Allen, Stern
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/1/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Self-service storage facilities: lien sales
SOURCE: California Self Storage Association
Self Storage Association
DIGEST:
This bill amends the publication notice requirements regarding lien sales of property within self-service storage facilities.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act (Act). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21700 et seq.)
- Provides that the owner of a self-service storage facility has a lien upon all personal property located at a self-service storage facility for rent, labor, late payment fees, or other charges, present or future, incurred pursuant to the rental agreement and for expenses necessary for the preservation, sale, or disposition of personal property subject to the provisions of the Act. The lien may be enforced consistent with the provisions of the Act. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21702.)
- Authorizes an owner, if any part of the rent or other charges due from an occupant remain unpaid for 14 consecutive days, to terminate the right of the occupant to the use of the storage space at a self-service storage facility by sending a notice to the occupant’s last known address and to the specified alternative address. The notice shall be sent by certified mail, postage prepaid, by regular first-class mail if the owner obtains a certificate of mailing indicating the date the notice was mailed, or by email, as provided. The notice must contain specified information. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21703.)
- Provides that if an owner sends an occupant a preliminary lien notice, the owner may, upon the effective date of the lien, deny the occupant access to the space, enter the space, and remove property for safe-keeping. Upon taking such actions, the owner must send to the occupant, by certified mail, or by first-class mail if the owner obtains a certificate of mailing, postage prepaid, addressed to the occupant’s last known address, and to the alternative address or by email, as specified, a notice of lien sale with specified information and a blank declaration in opposition to the lien sale. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21705.)
- Authorizes the owner to conduct the lien sale in the absence of a valid declaration in opposition. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21706.) However, the lien sale must first be advertised in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held for two consecutive weeks. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(a).)
- Requires the above advertisement to include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(a).)
- Requires the above advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(a).)
- Permits lien sale of the property at an in-person auction or on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(b).)
- Mandates that all notices required by law to be published in a newspaper, must be published in a newspaper of general circulation and that it must be published at least once a week before the event the notice concerns takes place. (Government Code Section 6061.)
This bill:
- Authorizes an alternative publication notice requiring advertisement once in a newspaper of general circulation and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement must remain online for seven days before the sale.
- Eliminates the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods.
- Authorizes the advertisements to be published in either the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located.
Background
The California Self-Service Storage Facility Act specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges. Owners of such facilities have a lien upon all personal property located at a self-service storage facility for rent, labor, late payment fees, or other charges, present or future, incurred pursuant to the rental agreement and for expenses necessary for the preservation, sale, or disposition of personal property subject to the provisions of the Act. The Act lays out the process by which such liens may be established and executed upon.
This includes notice to the occupant through specified methods pursuant to the provisions of the Act that includes various information about the occupant’s obligations and rights and other information about the lien process. After complying with these steps the owner has the right to sell the property at a lien sale. However, the owner must advertise the sale once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation that includes specified information about the occupant, the facility, and the sale.
This bill, sponsored by the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, updates this latter public notice requirement by providing an option for lien sales to be published only once in a newspaper and once on a website that conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. This bill is opposed by the California News Publishers Association and other media organizations.
Comments
California Self-Service Storage Facility Act
The Act specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges. Owners of such facilities have a lien upon all personal property located at a self-service storage facility for rent, labor, late payment fees, or other charges, present or future, incurred pursuant to the rental agreement and for expenses necessary for the preservation, sale, or disposition of personal property subject to the provisions of the Act. The Act lays out the process by which such liens may be established and executed upon.
At the outset, each contract for the rental or lease of individual storage space in a self-service storage facility must be in writing and contain, in addition to the provisions otherwise required or permitted, a statement that the occupant’s property will be subject to a claim of lien and may even be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid
If the customer becomes 14 days overdue in paying the fees for the unit, the self storage company may mail a preliminary lien notice to inform the occupant that if the overdue fees are not paid within another two weeks, the self storage company can place a lien on the contents of the unit, and the customer’s right to use the unit will forfeit. The notice must be sent to the occupant’s last known address or to a specified alternative address. The notice shall be sent by certified mail, postage prepaid, by regular first-class mail if the owner obtains a certificate of mailing indicating the date the notice was mailed. The owner may also send the notice by email, if certain conditions are met and actual delivery and receipt are demonstrated. The notice must contain detailed information, including:
- An itemized statement of the owner’s claim showing the sums due at the time of the notice and the date when the sums became due;
- A statement that the occupant’s right to use the storage space will terminate on a specified date (not less than 14 days after the mailing of the notice) unless all sums due are paid by the occupant before the specified date;
- A notice that the occupant may be denied access to the storage space after the termination date if the sums are not paid and that an owner’s lien may be imposed thereafter; and
- The name, street address, and telephone number of the owner or their designated agent whom the occupant may contact to respond to the notice.
If the customer still does not pay the bill, the lien attaches on the 28th day. At that point, the self-storage company can begin denying the customer access to the unit, may enter the unit, and can remove property for safekeeping, unless the customer pays the bill in full. The company must then mail another notice to the customer, a notice of lien sale, using the same methods as specified above, that states all of the following:
- That the occupant’s right to use the storage space has terminated and that the occupant no longer has access to the stored property;
- That the stored property is subject to a lien, the current amount of the lien, and that the lien will continue to increase if rent is not paid;
- That the property will be sold to satisfy the lien after a specified date that is not less than 14 days from the date of mailing the notice, unless the occupant executes and returns by certified mail a declaration in opposition to lien sale;
- A statement that the occupant may regain full use of the space by paying the full lien amount before the specified date; and
- That any excess proceeds of the sale over the lien amount and costs of sale will be retained by the owner and may be reclaimed by the occupant or claimed by another person at any time for a period of one year from the sale and that thereafter the proceeds will escheat to the county in which the sale is to take place.
A blank declaration in opposition to the lien sale must accompany the notice. The customer can fill out the form to contest the process and return it. If the customer does so before the date of the auction, then the owner must file suit against the occupant to enforce the lien. Otherwise, the self-storage company may conduct a public auction sale of the content of the unit and can use the proceeds as payment against the outstanding balance.
The sale must be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner, which may take the form of an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupant’s behalf. The occupant may claim the excess proceeds at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
However, relevant here, the owner must first advertise the lien sale according to statute. The advertisement of the sale must be published once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. The advertisement must include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. If there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
Modernizing the publication notice requirement
This bill updates this publication notice requirement in several material ways. First, the advertisement can either be accomplished through the existing method or by publishing the notice once in a newspaper of general circulation and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale.
Second, this bill allows for the advertisements, in either iteration, to be published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, as under existing law, or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located. The stated goal of this change is to make compliance easier for owners who may not know the relevant public notice district.
Third, this bill eliminates the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods. The advertisement will still need to list the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility
Given the thorough requirements regarding notification of the occupant, the main purpose of the publication notice is to ensure that the public has fair warning about the impending lien sale and an opportunity to bid on the property. This notice prevents facility owners from improperly disposing of the underlying property by, for instance, selling below market value in a transaction that is not at arm’s length. This bill brings the notice to a place where potential buyers are more likely to be searching for such sales. In addition, such sales are still required to be published in newspapers and ensure that potential buyers can continue to rely on searches of such papers for notice of all such sales.
According to the author:
Assembly Bill 542 seeks to reduce an unnecessary burden on many small California storage owners while also expanding the access and visibility to lien sale advertisements. The bill provides storage owners with the option to advertise upcoming lien sales on a publicly accessible website, provided the sale is also advertised once in a newspaper of general circulation.
AB 542 updates The California Self Service Storage Facility Act by providing storage operators with flexibility and additional options to advertise lien sales, while still requiring at least one advertisement in the newspaper.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/15/23)
California Self Storage Association (co-source)
Self Storage Association (co-source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/15/23)
California Black Media
California News Publishers Association
Ethnic Media Services
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Self Storage Association writes:
[T]he newspaper advertising requirement is outdated. Since the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act was passed in 1981 newspaper readership is down significantly and many newspapers have shuttered resulting in operators’ inability to properly advertise within the specific public notice district. The purpose of the newspaper advertisement is to bring bidders to the sale. Simply, advertising in a local newspaper within a specific public notice district is no longer the most effective method to drive traffic to self storage lien sales. Thirty-two states permit advertisements via another mechanism other than newspapers preceding the sale or have no advertising requirement at all, including Washington. California is only one of a dozen states that requires two newspaper advertisements before a sale.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California News Publishers Association asserts:
Newspaper public notices unlike the use of a website alone, constitute a forum that is independent of the government and self-storage facility owners and it is in the best of interest of newspapers to have the widest possible circulation There are no standards for the maintenance, appearance, effectiveness or usage of web sites. A person who visits websites that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales will not have any idea where to look or what to look for other than that information they are seeking. As a result, this new notice scheme is fundamentally flawed.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/1/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Lackey, McKinnor
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
6/16/23 13:16:51
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 542 (Author:Juan Carrillo)
Version: April 27, 2023
Hearing Date: June 13, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Self-service storage facilities: lien sales
DIGEST
This bill amends the publication notice requirements regarding lien sales of property within self-service storage facilities.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The California Self-Service Storage Facility Act (the Act) specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges. Owners of such facilities have a lien upon all personal property located at a self-service storage facility for rent, labor, late payment fees, or other charges, present or future, incurred pursuant to the rental agreement and for expenses necessary for the preservation, sale, or disposition of personal property subject to the provisions of the Act. The Act lays out the process by which such liens may be established and executed upon.
This includes notice to the occupant through specified methods pursuant to the provisions of the Act that includes various information about the occupant’s obligations and rights and other information about the lien process. After complying with these steps the owner has the right to sell the property at a lien sale. However, the owner must advertise the sale once a week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation that includes specified information about the occupant, the facility, and the sale.
This bill, sponsored by the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, updates this latter public notice requirement by providing an option for lien sales to be published only once in a newspaper and once on a website that conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill is opposed by the California News Publishers Association and other media organizations.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act (the Act). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21700 et seq.)
- Provides that the owner of a self-service storage facility has a lien upon all personal property located at a self-service storage facility for rent, labor, late payment fees, or other charges, present or future, incurred pursuant to the rental agreement and for expenses necessary for the preservation, sale, or disposition of personal property subject to the provisions of the Act. The lien may be enforced consistent with the provisions of the Act. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21702.)
- Authorizes an owner, if any part of the rent or other charges due from an occupant remain unpaid for 14 consecutive days, to terminate the right of the occupant to the use of the storage space at a self-service storage facility by sending a notice to the occupant’s last known address and to the specified alternative address. The notice shall be sent by certified mail, postage prepaid, by regular first-class mail if the owner obtains a certificate of mailing indicating the date the notice was mailed, or by email, as provided. The notice must contain specified information. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21703.)
- Provides that if an owner sends an occupant a preliminary lien notice, the owner may, upon the effective date of the lien, deny the occupant access to the space, enter the space, and remove property for safe-keeping. Upon taking such actions, the owner must send to the occupant, by certified mail, or by first-class mail if the owner obtains a certificate of mailing, postage prepaid, addressed to the occupant’s last known address, and to the alternative address or by email, as specified, a notice of lien sale with specified information and a blank declaration in opposition to the lien sale. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21705.)
- Authorizes the owner to conduct the lien sale in the absence of a valid declaration in opposition. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21706.) However, the lien sale must first be advertised in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held for two consecutive weeks. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(a).)
- Requires the above advertisement to include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(a).)
- Requires the above advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(a).)
- Permits lien sale of the property at an in-person auction or on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 21707(b).)
- Mandates that all notices required by law to be published in a newspaper, must be published in a newspaper of general circulation and that it must be published at least once a week before the event the notice concerns takes place. (Government Code Section 6061.)
This bill:
- Authorizes an alternative publication notice requiring advertisement once in a newspaper of general circulation and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement must remain online for seven days before the sale.
- Eliminates the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods.
- Authorizes the advertisements to be published in either the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located.
COMMENTS
- California Self-Service Storage Facility Act
- The regulated process for enforcing liens
The Act specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges. Owners of such facilities have a lien upon all personal property located at a self-service storage facility for rent, labor, late payment fees, or other charges, present or future, incurred pursuant to the rental agreement and for expenses necessary for the preservation, sale, or disposition of personal property subject to the provisions of the Act. The Act lays out the process by which such liens may be established and executed upon.
At the outset, each contract for the rental or lease of individual storage space in a self-service storage facility must be in writing and contain, in addition to the provisions otherwise required or permitted, a statement that the occupant’s property will be subject to a claim of lien and may even be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid
If the customer becomes 14 days overdue in paying the fees for the unit, the self storage company may mail a preliminary lien notice to inform the occupant that if the overdue fees are not paid within another two weeks, the self storage company can place a lien on the contents of the unit, and the customer’s right to use the unit will forfeit. The notice must be sent to the occupant’s last known address or to a specified alternative address. The notice shall be sent by certified mail, postage prepaid, by regular first-class mail if the owner obtains a certificate of mailing indicating the date the notice was mailed. The owner may also send the notice by email, if certain conditions are met and actual delivery and receipt are demonstrated. The notice must contain detailed information, including:
- an itemized statement of the owner’s claim showing the sums due at the time of the notice and the date when the sums became due;
- a statement that the occupant’s right to use the storage space will terminate on a specified date (not less than 14 days after the mailing of the notice) unless all sums due are paid by the occupant before the specified date;
- a notice that the occupant may be denied access to the storage space after the termination date if the sums are not paid and that an owner’s lien may be imposed thereafter; and
- the name, street address, and telephone number of the owner or their designated agent whom the occupant may contact to respond to the notice.
If the customer still does not pay the bill, the lien attaches on the 28th day. At that point, the self-storage company can begin denying the customer access to the unit, may enter the unit, and can remove property for safekeeping, unless the customer pays the bill in full. The company must then mail another notice to the customer, a notice of lien sale, using the same methods as specified above, that states all of the following:
- that the occupant’s right to use the storage space has terminated and that the occupant no longer has access to the stored property;
- that the stored property is subject to a lien, the current amount of the lien, and that the lien will continue to increase if rent is not paid;
- that the property will be sold to satisfy the lien after a specified date that is not less than 14 days from the date of mailing the notice, unless the occupant executes and returns by certified mail a declaration in opposition to lien sale;
- a statement that the occupant may regain full use of the space by paying the full lien amount before the specified date; and
- that any excess proceeds of the sale over the lien amount and costs of sale will be retained by the owner and may be reclaimed by the occupant or claimed by another person at any time for a period of one year from the sale and that thereafter the proceeds will escheat to the county in which the sale is to take place.
A blank declaration in opposition to the lien sale must accompany the notice. The customer can fill out the form to contest the process and return it. If the customer does so before the date of the auction, then the owner must file suit against the occupant to enforce the lien. Otherwise, the self-storage company may conduct a public auction sale of the content of the unit and can use the proceeds as payment against the outstanding balance.
The sale must be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner, which may take the form of an in-person auction or a sale on a publicly accessible website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupant’s behalf. The occupant may claim the excess proceeds at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
However, relevant here, the owner must first advertise the lien sale according to statute. The advertisement of the sale must be published once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. The advertisement must include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. If there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
- Modernizing the publication notice requirement
This bill updates this publication notice requirement in several material ways. First, the advertisement can either be accomplished through the existing method or by publishing the notice once in a newspaper of general circulation and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for seven days before the sale.
Second, the bill allows for the advertisements, in either iteration, to be published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, as under existing law, or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located. The stated goal of this change is to make compliance easier for owners who may not know the relevant public notice district.
Third, the bill eliminates the requirement that the advertisement include a general description of the goods. The advertisement will still need to list the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility. However, the location of this provision may make it unclear that this requirement applies to the various advertising options. The author has agreed to amendments that clearly organize the provisions of the bill.
Given the thorough requirements regarding notification of the occupant, the main purpose of the publication notice is to ensure that the public has fair warning about the impending lien sale and an opportunity to bid on the property. This notice prevents facility owners from improperly disposing of the underlying property by, for instance, selling below market value in a transaction that is not at arm’s length. This bill brings the notice to a place where potential buyers are more likely to be searching for such sales. In addition, such sales are still required to be published in newspapers and ensure that potential buyers can continue to rely on searches of such papers for notice of all such sales.
According to the author:
Assembly Bill 542 seeks to reduce an unnecessary burden on many small California storage owners while also expanding the access and visibility to lien sale advertisements. The bill provides storage owners with the option to advertise upcoming lien sales on a publicly accessible website, provided the sale is also advertised once in a newspaper of general circulation.
AB 542 updates The California Self Service Storage Facility Act by providing storage operators with flexibility and additional options to advertise lien sales, while still requiring at least one advertisement in the newspaper.
- Stakeholder positions
The bill’s sponsors, the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, write:
[T]he newspaper advertising requirement is outdated. Since the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act was passed in 1981 newspaper readership is down significantly and many newspapers have shuttered resulting in operators’ inability to properly advertise within the specific public notice district. The purpose of the newspaper advertisement is to bring bidders to the sale. Simply, advertising in a local newspaper within a specific public notice district is no longer the most effective method to drive traffic to self storage lien sales. Thirty-two states permit advertisements via another mechanism other than newspapers preceding the sale or have no advertising requirement at all, including Washington. California is only one of a dozen states that requires two newspaper advertisements before a sale.
Historically, self storage lien sales occurred on-site at the facility where the tenant default occurred. In the last several years, that has changed. Many self storage owners nationally, including in California, have shifted to online auction platforms to conduct these sales. California law permits online auctions. Online sales can expand the audience of potential bidders by allowing bidders to submit bids over several days without attending a one-day sale in person.
As online auctions have increased significantly in popularity, it is logical that the sales would also be advertised on the platform where the sale is conducted. Interested bidders seek out these upcoming auctions on these platforms, which may be accessed free of charge. Further, self storage auction websites are optimized to easily search and provide access to thousands of individuals who are specifically interested in upcoming sales.
The bill is opposed by a coalition of media organizations, including the California News Publishers Association, that asserts:
Newspaper public notices unlike the use of a website alone, constitute a forum that is independent of the government and self-storage facility owners and it is in the best of interest of newspapers to have the widest possible circulation There are no standards for the maintenance, appearance, effectiveness or usage of web sites. A person who visits websites that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales will not have any idea where to look or what to look for other than that information they are seeking. As a result, this new notice scheme is fundamentally flawed.
SUPPORT
California Self Storage Association (sponsor)
Self Storage Association (sponsor)
OPPOSITION
California Black Media
California News Publishers Association
Ethnic Media Services
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: SB 458 (Gonzalez, 2023) expands current requirements for local agencies to publish public contract information in physical newspapers, to require local agencies to post this information online as well. This bill is currently in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
Prior Legislation: AB 1108 (Daly, Ch. 227, Stats. 2017) updated two aspects of the Act to better fit the internet age. It allowed self-storage businesses to provide legal notices to customers by email, with the consent of the customer. It also clarified that self-storage companies may use online auction sites when conducting public sale of storage unit contents.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 78, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
**************
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 542
Author:(Juan Carrillo)
As Amended Ver:April 27, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Revises the advertising requirement of lien sales in the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act. Existing law requires publication of a lien sale for two consecutive weeks in a print newspaper. This bill provides an alternative: it permits an operator to advertise a lien sale once in a print newspaper and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
Major Provisions
- Requires a self-service storage facility operator to advertise a lien sale in one of two ways:
- Once per week for two consecutive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation; or
- Once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-storage facility is located and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
- Requires an operator who elects option b), above, to post the online advertisement for seven days before the sale.
- Requires an advertisement to include the name of the person on whose account the goods are being stored and the name and location of the storage facility.
- Establishes that in the event there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service storage facility is located, the advertisement must be posted at least 10 days before the sale in no fewer than 6 conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale.
- Expands the location of permitted advertisement of lien in newspaper also to include the county where the self-service facility is located.
COMMENTS
In the event a person renting a unit within a self-storage facility fails to pay the required rent, existing law enables a facility operator to place a lien on the property stored within the unit and subsequently sell the property if adequate rent is not paid. In the event of a lien sale, existing law requires the facility owner to publicize the sale of the unit's contents in a newspaper of general circulation for two weeks. This bill expands the method of advertising for lien sales to include once in a print newspaper and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. Proponents of this measure contend that this bill will modernize the existing law to enable more Californians to become aware of property they may wish to purchase.
Existing law protects persons who use self-storage facilities with robust notices prior to any lien sale. The California Self-Storage Facility Act (the Act), set forth in Business and Professions Code Sections 21700 - 21716, is the principal law regulating the relationship between the owners of self-storage facilities and the occupants of self-storage units within those facilities. One of the Act's most important aspects is its specification of the owner's rights to dispose of an occupant's stored personal property if the occupant fails to timely pay storage fees, including rent. Under the Act, the owner has a right to place a lien on the occupant's personal property as security for unpaid storage fees. However, the lien does not attach (become legally enforceable) unless the owner follows statutory procedures meant to ensure that the occupant has notice of the lien, any lien sale, and an opportunity to oppose the lien sale.
The rental agreement in place between the self-storage operator and the occupant is required to contain a statement that the occupant's property is subject to the storage owner's lien and may be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid. In the event of unpaid storage fees, prior to placing a lien, the operator must do the following:
- No earlier than 14 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a preliminary lien notice informing the occupant that if the overdue fees are not paid, then the occupant's right to access their stored personal property may terminate and a lien may then attach to their property.
- No earlier than 28 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a notice of lien sale (which sets forth the amount due and informs the occupant that their property may be sold within 14 days from the date of mailing) and a blank declaration in opposition to lien sale which the occupant may complete and return. Having sent these documents, the owner can legally bar the occupant from the storage space and remove any personal property therein for safekeeping.
- If the occupant signs and returns the declaration in opposition before the date of sale in the notice, then the owner cannot conduct a lien sale and must instead sue the occupant to enforce the lien.
- Otherwise, no earlier than 42 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner may proceed with the lien sale and sell the occupant's stored personal property.
These notice requirements – which inform occupants of the itemized fees that are due, their rights to redeem their property under the law, and the procedures and options available to them to protect their property rights and avoid a lien sale – are crucial to safeguarding occupants' property rights.
As an additional safeguard, the owner must send these notices to both the occupant's last known address and one alternate address provided by the occupant. In 2018, the Act was modernized to allow the occupant to elect to receive notices by electronic mail. In 2020, when the electronic mail provision was set to sunset, this Committee received no comments indicating that emailed notices had caused harm to self-storage unit occupants. In sum, under the statutory scheme, the occupant receives multiple direct notices alerting them to the impending sale. All of these direct notices to the occupant must occur before the sale is advertised in a newspaper of general circulation. Nothing in the bill alters or lessens the existing law's requirements that the owner of property that is subject to a potential lien sale must be notified of their rights to reclaim their property, or how those notices must occur.
The purpose of the sale advertisement is to bring bidders to the sale. In recognition of the changing reality of how auctions and sales actually take place, the Act was amended in 2017 to clarify that a lien sale may be conducted through an online auction or sale on a publicly accessible website. These online websites permit a potential bidder to search by location or keywords, and perhaps most importantly, include color photographs of the storage unit's contents that are to be sold. In fact, by utilizing online sites, as opposed to print descriptions, many potential buyers are better able to understand exactly what property is being sold and to determine whether they may wish to purchase it. Online auction sites are free to search, but charge a percentage fee per auction sale.
A higher sale price benefits the former tenant, as any proceeds realized from the sale are applied to pay down their debts. In fact, in the rare instance in which auction proceeds are greater than the debt, the excess must be returned to the former tenant or escheat to the County. (Business and Professions Code Section 21707(a).)
This measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. Recognizing that most Californians use internet-based resources when searching for items to purchase, this measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. Under existing law, an operator is required to publish the advertisement in a print newspaper for two consecutive weeks. This measure provides an operator an alternative: it permits an operator to advertise a lien sale once in a print newspaper and once on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales.
Opponents argue that this bill may harm property owner's rights and limit the public's access to information about lien sales. Opponents raise concerns about reducing the required number of times an advertisement must be published in a print newspaper, which is an independent forum in general circulation. Specifically, the opponents argue that this measure overestimates Californians access to broadband. Additionally, the opposition appears to argue that newspaper publication is the most transparent means of alerting a person of the impending sale of their property, despite the existing law's comprehensive notice requirements. Given that the owner of the property subject to a lien sale is already provided several notices of the impending action, the existing law's newspaper notice appears primarily aimed at boosting public interest in the auction as a means of increasing revenue, rather than alerting the impacted party of the impending sale. Accordingly, some consideration should be given to the arguments of those conducting the sale that online notices are more effective than print notices in newspapers. Nonetheless, print notices remain an important means of communication and this measure retains – an albeit reduced – print publication requirement.
According to the Author
Assembly Bill 542 seeks to remove an unnecessary burden on many small California storage owners by allowing them to advertise upcoming lien sales on a publicly accessible website, providing a commonsense alternative to outdated advertising requirements….This bill updates the California Self Service Storage Facility Act by providing storage operators with the flexibility and additional options to advertise lien sales, while still retaining the ability to advertise in the newspaper.
Arguments in Support
This bill is supported by the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, who write in support:
By way of background, in self storage the operator and occupants have a commercial landlord-tenant relationship. A broad swath of consumers use self storage for a variety of reasons. Once a unit size is selected, a consumer signs the rental agreement, the contract that governs the relationship between the operator and the occupant. All rental agreements are month-to-month tenancies that renew only upon the mutual desire of both parties. In other words, occupants can simply vacate if they are unable or unwilling to pay for the leased space. Most tenancies are successful for both parties; goods are stored, and rent is timely paid…
National data from the SSA indicate that storage operators sell approximately 1% to 3% of leased spaces annually. Anecdotally, many of the lien sales involve occupants who have abandoned the space after removing their valuable property and are not interested in what is remaining in the space. Stated differently, 97-99% of tenants will use the space per the rental agreement and never have their belongings subject to a lien sale. The lien process is an infrequently used procedure, but it is necessary for the successful operation of a storage facility. Operators' primary goal is to recover the space, which can then be rented by a paying customer...
It has been suggested that the advertisement may provide some form of constructive notice to the tenant. However, the suggestion that a tenant or a friend may happen upon an advertisement (in a legal notice listing), which prompts the tenant to pay the debt to avoid the sale is questionable, at best. In that hypothetical, an occupant would have been unresponsive to all direct notices. All notices to the alternative contact (if any) would similarly have been ignored. There is an extremely low or no probability an occupant, the alternative contact, friend, or family member would then purchase the one newspaper where the notice was published or scour capublicnotice.com, read all the ads, see the specific advertisement, alert that tenant who then immediately pays the debt owed. That simply does not happen.
The California Moving and Storage Associate made a late-submission in support if amended to provide parity in the advertisement requirements for warehouse owners.
Arguments in Opposition
The California News Publishers Association, along with Ethnic Media Services and California Black Media, write the following in opposition to this bill:
AB 542 contemplates reliance on niche websites as a resort for public information. Information consumption in the State contradicts this belief. More than 10 million Californians rely on home-delivered print newspapers or their e-editions for news. The weekly circulation, unique web visitor counts, and social media following of newspapers is a thousand-fold of websites that conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill also propose that an advertisement of the sale shall be published once instead of once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation. The fact is, with AB 542, most people won't get notices at all.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-0
YES: Maienschein, Essayli, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: April 27, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke and Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000196
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 542
Author:(Juan Carrillo)
As Amended Ver:February 15, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Revises the advertising requirement of lien sales in the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act by permitting storage facility operators to advertise sales on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales in lieu of two consecutive weeks of print newspaper advertisement.
Major Provisions
- Permits a self-service storage facility operator to advertise the lien sale on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales or to advertise in a newspaper of general circulation.
- Requires a self-service storage facility operator electing to advertise online to maintain that online advertisement for no fewer than seven days before the sale is set to occur.
- Requires a self-service storage facility operator electing to advertise in a print newspaper to publish that advertisement before the sale is set to occur.
- Provides that, if a self-service storage facility operator opts for newspaper publication of a lien sale, the notice of the sale is reduced to a single publication date.
- Expands the location of permitted advertisement of lien in newspaper also to include the county where the self-service facility is located.
COMMENTS
In the event a person renting a unit within a self-storage facility fails to pay the required rent, existing law enables a facility operator to place a lien on the property stored within the unit and subsequently sell the property if adequate rent is not paid. In the event of a lien sale, existing law requires the facility owner to publicize the sale of the unit’s contents in a newspaper of general circulation for two weeks. This bill eliminates the exclusive print publication requirement, and expands the method of advertising for lien sales to include any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. Proponents of this measure contend that this bill will modernize the existing law to enable more Californians to become aware of property they may wish to purchase.
Existing law protects persons who use self-storage facilities with robust notices prior to any lien sale. The California Self-Storage Facility Act (the Act), set forth in Business and Professions Code Sections 21700 - 21716, is the principal law regulating the relationship between the owners of self-storage facilities and the occupants of self-storage units within those facilities. One of the Act's most important aspects is its specification of the owner's rights to dispose of an occupant's stored personal property if the occupant fails to timely pay storage fees, including rent. Under the Act, the owner has a right to place a lien on the occupant's personal property as security for unpaid storage fees. However, the lien does not attach (become legally enforceable) unless the owner follows statutory procedures meant to ensure that the occupant has notice of the lien, any lien sale, and an opportunity to oppose the lien sale.
The rental agreement in place between the self-storage operator and the occupant is required to contain a statement that the occupant's property is subject to the storage owner's lien and may be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid. In the event of unpaid storage fees, prior to placing a lien, the operator must do the following:
- No earlier than 14 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a preliminary lien notice informing the occupant that if the overdue fees are not paid, then the occupant's right to access their stored personal property may terminate and a lien may then attach to their property.
- No earlier than 28 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a notice of lien sale (which sets forth the amount due and informs the occupant that their property may be sold within 14 days from the date of mailing) and a blank declaration in opposition to lien sale which the occupant may complete and return. Having sent these documents, the owner can legally bar the occupant from the storage space and remove any personal property therein for safekeeping.
- If the occupant signs and returns the declaration in opposition before the date of sale in the notice, then the owner cannot conduct a lien sale and must instead sue the occupant to enforce the lien.
- Otherwise, no earlier than 42 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner may proceed with the lien sale and sell the occupant's stored personal property.
These notice requirements—which inform occupants of the itemized fees that are due, their rights to redeem their property under the law, and the procedures and options available to them to protect their property rights and avoid a lien sale—are crucial to safeguarding occupants’ property rights.
As an additional safeguard, the owner must send these notices to both the occupant's last known address and one alternate address provided by the occupant. In 2018, the Act was modernized to allow the occupant to elect to receive notices by electronic mail. In 2020, when the electronic mail provision was set to sunset, this Committee received no comments indicating that emailed notices had caused harm to self-storage unit occupants. In sum, under the statutory scheme, the occupant receives multiple direct notices alerting them to the impending sale. All of these direct notices to the occupant must occur before the sale is advertised in a newspaper of general circulation. Nothing in the bill alters or lessens the existing law's requirements that the owner of property that is subject to a potential lien sale must be notified of their rights to reclaim their property, or how those notices must occur.
The purpose of the sale advertisement is to bring bidders to the sale. In recognition of the changing reality of how auctions and sales actually take place, the Act was amended in 2017 to clarify that a lien sale may be conducted through an online auction or sale on a publicly accessible website. These online websites permit a potential bidder to search by location or keywords, and perhaps most importantly, include color photographs of the storage unit's contents that are to be sold. In fact, by utilizing online sites, as opposed to print descriptions, many potential buyers are better able to understand exactly what property is being sold and to determine whether they may wish to purchase it. Online auction sites are free to search, but charge a percentage fee per auction sale.
A higher sale price benefits the former tenant, as any proceeds realized from the sale are applied to pay down their debts. In fact, in the rare instance in which auction proceeds are greater than the debt, the excess must be returned to the former tenant or escheat to the County. (Business and Professions Code Section 21707(a).)
This measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. Recognizing that most Californians use internet-based resources when searching for items to purchase, this measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. First, this measure eliminates the requirement that all lien sales of property left at self-storage facilities must be advertised in newspapers. Secondly, this bill clarifies the timelines for sale postings to ensure the public is adequately informed about potentially lien sales, whether they are advertised in print or online publications. Finally, this measure makes several technical changes to implement the above described reforms to existing law.
Opponents argue that this bill may harm property owner's rights and limit the public's access to information about lien sales. Opponents raise concerns about not requiring publication in a print newspaper, which is an independent forum in general circulation. Specifically, the opponents argue that this measure overestimates Californians access to broadband. Additionally, the opposition appears to argue that newspaper publication is the most transparent means of alerting a person of the impending sale of their property, despite the existing law's comprehensive notice requirements. Given that the owner of the property subject to a lien sale is already provided several notices of the impending action, the existing law's newspaper notice appears primarily aimed at boosting public interest in the auction as a means of increasing revenue, rather than alerting the impacted party of the impending sale. Accordingly, some consideration should be given to the arguments of those conducting the sale that online notices are more effective than print notices in newspapers. Nonetheless, print notices remain an important means of communication.
According to the Author
Assembly Bill 542 seeks to remove an unnecessary burden on many small California storage owners by allowing them to advertise upcoming lien sales on a publicly accessible website, providing a commonsense alternative to outdated advertising requirements….This bill updates the California Self Service Storage Facility Act by providing storage operators with the flexibility and additional options to advertise lien sales, while still retaining the ability to advertise in the newspaper.
Arguments in Support
This bill is supported by the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, who write in support:
By way of background, in self storage the operator and occupants have a commercial landlord-tenant relationship. A broad swath of consumers use self storage for a variety of reasons. Once a unit size is selected, a consumer signs the rental agreement, the contract that governs the relationship between the operator and the occupant. All rental agreements are month-to-month tenancies that renew only upon the mutual desire of both parties. In other words, occupants can simply vacate if they are unable or unwilling to pay for the leased space. Most tenancies are successful for both parties; goods are stored, and rent is timely paid…
National data from the SSA indicate that storage operators sell approximately 1% to 3% of leased spaces annually. Anecdotally, many of the lien sales involve occupants who have abandoned the space after removing their valuable property and are not interested in what is remaining in the space. Stated differently, 97-99% of tenants will use the space per the rental agreement and never have their belongings subject to a lien sale. The lien process is an infrequently used procedure, but it is necessary for the successful operation of a storage facility. Operators' primary goal is to recover the space, which can then be rented by a paying customer...
It has been suggested that the advertisement may provide some form of constructive notice to the tenant. However, the suggestion that a tenant or a friend may happen upon an advertisement (in a legal notice listing), which prompts the tenant to pay the debt to avoid the sale is questionable, at best. In that hypothetical, an occupant would have been unresponsive to all direct notices. All notices to the alternative contact (if any) would similarly have been ignored. There is an extremely low or no probability an occupant, the alternative contact, friend, or family member would then purchase the one newspaper where the notice was published or scour capublicnotice.com, read all the ads, see the specific advertisement, alert that tenant who then immediately pays the debt owed. That simply does not happen.
The California Moving and Storage Associate made a late-submission in support if amended to provide parity in the advertisement requirements for warehouse owners.
Arguments in Opposition
The California News Publishers Association, along with Ethnic Media Services and California Black Media, write the following in opposition to this bill:
AB 542 contemplates reliance on niche websites as a resort for public information. Information consumption in the State contradicts this belief. More than 10 million Californians rely on home-delivered print newspapers or their e-editions for news. The weekly circulation, unique web visitor counts, and social media following of newspapers is a thousand-fold of websites that conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill also propose that an advertisement of the sale shall be published once instead of once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation. The fact is, with AB 542, most people won't get notices at all.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None.
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-0
YES: Maienschein, Essayli, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: February 15, 2023
CONSULTANT: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000023
Date of Hearing: March 14, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 542
Author:(Juan Carrillo) – As Introduced Ver:February 8, 2023
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Self-service storage facilities: lien sales
KEY ISSUE: should the publication requirement for lien sales of PROPERTY IN self-storage spaceS be revised to permit advertisEment on internet auction and sale sites in lieu of traditional print notifications?
SYNOPSIS
Under existing law, in the event a renter of a self-service storage unit ceases paying the required rent on the unit, the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act enables the owner of the storage facility to place a lien on the property within the unit. If no payment is tendered after a lien is placed on the contents of the unit, and after the proper notices are transmitted to the owner of the property stored in the unit, the facility owner is legally entitled to sell the contents of the storage unit to recoup their losses. Currently, pursuant to the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act, a self-storage facility owner must publicize potential lien sales in newspapers when delinquent occupants' property is slated to be sold.
This bill expands the legally permissible methods of advertising lien sales to include any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. Additionally, should a storage facility opt to publish a notice of sale in a newspaper, this bill reduces the length of time that such sales must be printed in newspapers from two-consecutive weeks prior to the sale of the property to one. The bill, also, expands the geographic territory of newspapers in which a storage facility may publish a traditional notice.
This measure is sponsored by the California Self-Storage Association who contends that advertising lien sales in traditional print media is outdated and limits the scope of persons notified regarding the sale of items that have been legally forfeited and offered for public sale. The proponents argue that the current print notices were originally designed to increase the interest of potential buyers, and that in the modern age of online commerce, print notices are unnecessary. This measure is strongly opposed by the California News Publishers Association and a coalition of smaller news publishing organizations, who contend that online notices may inadvertently overlook Californians without broadband access and those in more rural areas of the state. Notably, the proponents of this measure argue that due to contractions within the newspaper industry many rural Californians rely on internet-based publications for information as print media has largely retreated from these areas. Proposed amendments to this bill are largely technical and are unlikely to ameliorate the concerns of the opposition.
SUMMARY: Revises the advertising requirement of lien sales in the California Self-Service Storage Facility Act by permitting storage facility operators to advertise sales on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales in lieu of two consecutive weeks of print newspaper advertisement. Specifically, this bill:
- Permits a self-service storage facility operator to advertise the lien sale on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales or to advertise in a newspaper of general circulation.
- Requires a self-service storage facility operator electing to advertise online to maintain that online advertisement for no fewer than seven days before the sale is set to occur.
- Requires a self-service storage facility operator electing to advertise in a print newspaper to publish that advertisement before the sale is set to occur.
- Provides that, if a self-service storage facility operator opts for newspaper publication of a lien sale, the notice of the sale is reduced to a single publication date.
- Expands the location of permitted advertisement of lien in newspaper also to include the county where the self-service facility is located.
EXISTING LAW:
- Specifies remedies and procedures for self-service storage facility owners when occupants are delinquent in paying rent or other charges. (Business and Professions Code Section 21700 et seq. All further references are to this code unless noted otherwise.)
- Provides that if an owner sends an occupant a preliminary lien notice, the owner may, upon the effective date of the lien, deny the occupant access to the space, enter the space, and remove property for safe-keeping. (Section 21705.)
- Each contract for the rental or lease of individual storage space requires a statement that the occupant’s property will be subject to a claim of lien and may even be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid for 14 consecutive days. (Section 21712 (a).)
- Once the occupant is in default for fourteen (14) consecutive days, an owner must send a preliminary lien notice to the occupant and to the alternative contact, if any. (Section 21703, 21712 (b).)
- Requires owners to send occupants a notice of lien sale that states the property will be sold to satisfy the lien after a specified date that is not less than 14 days from the date of mailing unless: (1) the amount of the lien is paid; or (2) the occupant returns a declaration in opposition to lien sale. (Section 21705 (c).)
- Notice of lien must be sent to the occupant via certified or first-class mail and via alternative address or electronic mail notifying of sale of property to satisfy the lien not less than 14 days from the date of the lien notice. (Sections 21705, 21712 (c).)
- Requires the lien sale to be advertised in a newspaper of general circulation in the public notice district where the sale is to be held for two consecutive weeks. (Section 21707 (a).)
- Requires the advertisement to be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale, if there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held. (Section 21707 (a).)
- Permits lien sale of the property on a publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts online auctions or sales. (Section 21707 (b).)
- Mandates that all notices required by law to be published in a newspaper, must be published in a newspaper of general circulation and that it must be published at least once a week before the event the notice concerns takes place. (Government Code Section 6061.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: In the event a person renting a unit within a self-storage facility fails to pay the required rent, existing law enables a facility operator to place a lien on the property stored within the unit and subsequently sell the property if adequate rent is not paid. In the event of a lien sale, existing law requires the facility owner to publicize the sale of the unit’s contents in a newspaper of general circulation for two weeks. This bill eliminates the exclusive print publication requirement, and expands the method of advertising for lien sales to include any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. Proponents of this measure contend that this bill will modernize the existing law to enable more Californians to become aware of property they may wish to purchase. In support of this measure, the author notes:
Assembly Bill 542 seeks to remove an unnecessary burden on many small California storage owners by allowing them to advertise upcoming lien sales on a publicly accessible website, providing a commonsense alternative to outdated advertising requirements….This bill updates the California Self Service Storage Facility Act by providing storage operators with the flexibility and additional options to advertise lien sales, while still retaining the ability to advertise in the newspaper.
Existing law protects persons who use self-storage facilities with robust notices prior to any lien sale. The California Self-Storage Facility Act (the Act), set forth in Business and Professions Code Sections 21700 - 21716, is the principal law regulating the relationship between the owners of self-storage facilities and the occupants of self-storage units within those facilities. One of the Act’s most important aspects is its specification of the owner’s rights to dispose of an occupant’s stored personal property if the occupant fails to timely pay storage fees, including rent. Under the Act, the owner has a right to place a lien on the occupant’s personal property as security for unpaid storage fees. However, the lien does not attach (become legally enforceable) unless the owner follows statutory procedures meant to ensure that the occupant has notice of the lien, any lien sale, and an opportunity to oppose the lien sale.
The rental agreement in place between the self-storage operator and the occupant is required to contain a statement that the occupant’s property is subject to the storage owner’s lien and may be sold to satisfy the lien if the rent or other charges due remain unpaid. In the event of unpaid storage fees, prior to placing a lien, the operator must do the following:
- No earlier than 14 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a preliminary lien notice informing the occupant that if the overdue fees are not paid, then the occupant’s right to access their stored personal property may terminate and a lien may then attach to their property.
- No earlier than 28 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner must send a notice of lien sale (which sets forth the amount due and informs the occupant that their property may be sold within 14 days from the date of mailing) and a blank declaration in opposition to lien sale which the occupant may complete and return. Having sent these documents, the owner can legally bar the occupant from the storage space and remove any personal property therein for safekeeping.
- If the occupant signs and returns the declaration in opposition before the date of sale in the notice, then the owner cannot conduct a lien sale and must instead sue the occupant to enforce the lien.
- Otherwise, no earlier than 42 days after the storage fees become unpaid, the owner may proceed with the lien sale and sell the occupant’s stored personal property.
These notice requirements—which inform occupants of the itemized fees that are due, their rights to redeem their property under the law, and the procedures and options available to them to protect their property rights and avoid a lien sale—are crucial to safeguarding occupants’ property rights.
As an additional safeguard, the owner must send these notices to both the occupant’s last known address and one alternate address provided by the occupant. In 2018, the Act was modernized to allow the occupant to elect to receive notices by electronic mail. In 2020, when the electronic mail provision was set to sunset, this Committee received no comments indicating that emailed notices had caused harm to self-storage unit occupants. In sum, under the statutory scheme, the occupant receives multiple direct notices alerting them to the impending sale. All of these direct notices to the occupant must occur before the sale is advertised in a newspaper of general circulation. Nothing in the bill alters or lessens the existing law’s requirements that the owner of property that is subject to a potential lien sale must be notified of their rights to reclaim their property, or how those notices must occur.
The purpose of the sale advertisement is to bring bidders to the sale. In recognition of the changing reality of how auctions and sales actually take place, the Act was amended in 2017 to clarify that a lien sale may be conducted through an online auction or sale on a publicly accessible website. These online websites permit a potential bidder to search by location or keywords, and perhaps most importantly, include color photographs of the storage unit’s contents that are to be sold. In fact, by utilizing online sites, as opposed to print descriptions, many potential buyers are better able to understand exactly what property is being sold and to determine whether they may wish to purchase it. Online auction sites are free to search, but charge a percentage fee per auction sale.
A higher sale price benefits the former tenant, as any proceeds realized from the sale are applied to pay down their debts. In fact, in the rare instance in which auction proceeds are greater than the debt, the excess must be returned to the former tenant or escheat to the County. (Section 21707 (a).)
This measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. Recognizing that most Californians use internet-based resources when searching for items to purchase, this measure modernizes the California Self-Storage Facility Act. First, this measure eliminates the requirement that all lien sales of property left at self-storage facilities must be advertised in newspapers. Secondly, this bill clarifies the timelines for sale postings to ensure the public is adequately informed about potentially lien sales, whether they are advertised in print or online publications. Finally, this measure makes several technical changes to implement the above described reforms to existing law.
Opponents argue that this bill may harm property owner’s rights and limit the public’s access to information about lien sales. Opponents raise concerns about not requiring publication in a print newspaper, which is an independent forum in general circulation. Specifically, the opponents argue that this measure overestimates Californians access to broadband. Additionally, the opposition appears to argue that newspaper publication is the most transparent means of alerting a person of the impending sale of their property, despite the existing law’s comprehensive notice requirements. Given that the owner of the property subject to a lien sale is already provided several notices of the impending action, the existing law’s newspaper notice appears primarily aimed at boosting public interest in the auction as a means of increasing revenue, rather than alerting the impacted party of the impending sale. Accordingly, some consideration should be given to the arguments of those conducting the sale that online notices are more effective than print notices in newspapers. Nonetheless, print notices remain an important means of communication. Accordingly, the Committee encourages the stakeholders interested in this measure to continue conversations in order to strike the best balance between modernizing the notice requirements related to self-storage unit lien sales and ensuring the broadest segment of the public are informed of these transactions.
Author’s Amendments. The author proposes several amendments to clarify the time period when an advertisement is required to be published in the newspaper or online. The amendments also remove the requirement to post the advertisement in the neighborhood of the proposed sale in the event there is no newspaper of general circulation available. Because the bill creates an online alternative to the print publication requirement, this provision becomes superfluous and confusing. Accordingly, as proposed to be amended, the bill will now read:
Business and Professions Code Section 21707
(a) After the expiration of the time given in the notice of lien sale, pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 21705, or following the failure of a claimant to pay rent or obtain a court order pursuant to Section 21709, an advertisement of the sale shall be published before the sale once in a newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held or in the county where the self-service facility is located. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, instead of publishing an advertisement for the sale in a newspaper of general circulation, an advertisement for the sale may be published on any publicly accessible internet website that customarily conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The online advertisement shall remain online for 7 days before the sale. The advertisement shall include a general description of the goods, the name of the person on whose account they are being stored, and the name and location of the storage facility. If there is no newspaper of general circulation published in the public notice district where the sale is to be held, the advertisement shall be posted at least 10 days before the sale in not less than six conspicuous places in the neighborhood of the proposed sale. The sale shall be conducted in a commercially reasonable manner. After deducting the amount of the lien and costs of sale, the owner shall retain any excess proceeds of the sale on the occupant’s behalf. The occupant, or any other person having a court order or other judicial process against the property, may claim the excess proceeds, or a portion thereof sufficient to satisfy the particular claim, at any time within one year of the date of sale. Thereafter, the owner shall pay any remaining excess proceeds to the treasury of the county in which the sale was held.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by the Self Storage Association and the California Self Storage Association, who write in support:
By way of background, in self storage the operator and occupants have a commercial landlord-tenant relationship. A broad swath of consumers use self storage for a variety of reasons. Once a unit size is selected, a consumer signs the rental agreement, the contract that governs the relationship between the operator and the occupant. All rental agreements are month-to-month tenancies that renew only upon the mutual desire of both parties. In other words, occupants can simply vacate if they are unable or unwilling to pay for the leased space. Most tenancies are successful for both parties; goods are stored, and rent is timely paid…
National data from the SSA indicate that storage operators sell approximately 1% to 3% of leased spaces annually. Anecdotally, many of the lien sales involve occupants who have abandoned the space after removing their valuable property and are not interested in what is remaining in the space. Stated differently, 97-99% of tenants will use the space per the rental agreement and never have their belongings subject to a lien sale. The lien process is an infrequently used procedure, but it is necessary for the successful operation of a storage facility. Operators’ primary goal is to recover the space, which can then be rented by a paying customer...
It has been suggested that the advertisement may provide some form of constructive notice to the tenant. However, the suggestion that a tenant or a friend may happen upon an advertisement (in a legal notice listing), which prompts the tenant to pay the debt to avoid the sale is questionable, at best. In that hypothetical, an occupant would have been unresponsive to all direct notices. All notices to the alternative contact (if any) would similarly have been ignored. There is an extremely low or no probability an occupant, the alternative contact, friend, or family member would then purchase the one newspaper where the notice was published or scour capublicnotice.com, read all the ads, see the specific advertisement, alert that tenant who then immediately pays the debt owed. That simply does not happen.
The California Moving and Storage Associate made a late-submission in support if amended to provide parity in the advertisement requirements for warehouse owners.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California News Publishers Association, along with Ethnic Media Services and California Black Media, write the following in opposition to the bill:
AB 542 contemplates reliance on niche websites as a resort for public information. Information consumption in the State contradicts this belief. More than 10 million Californians rely on home-delivered print newspapers or their e-editions for news. The weekly circulation, unique web visitor counts, and social media following of newspapers is a thousand-fold of websites that conducts or advertises online auctions or sales. The bill also propose that an advertisement of the sale shall be published once instead of once a week for two weeks consecutively in a newspaper of general circulation. The fact is, with AB 542, most people won’t get notices at all.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Self Storage Association (sponsor)
Self-Storage Association (sponsor)
Opposition
California News Publishers Association
California Black Media
Ethnic Media Services
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):