AB 571: Medical malpractice insurance.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-09-27
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-09-27: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 256, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including liability insurance. Existing law defines liability insurance to include, among other things, insurance coverage against the legal liability of the insured, and against loss, damage, or expense incident to a claim arising out of the death or injury of any person as the result of negligence or malpractice in rendering professional services by any person who holds a certificate or license issued pursuant to the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act, or a license as a community clinic or health facility, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers, as specified, and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state.
The bill would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including liability insurance. Existing law defines liability insurance to include, among other things, insurance coverage against the legal liability of the insured, and against loss, damage, or expense incident to a claim arising out of the death or injury of any person as the result of negligence or malpractice in rendering professional services by any person who holds a certificate or license issued pursuant to the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act, or a license as a community clinic or health facility, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers, as specified, and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state.
The bill would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including liability insurance. Existing law defines liability insurance to include, among other things, insurance coverage against the legal liability of the insured, and against loss, damage, or expense incident to a claim arising out of the death or injury of any person as the result of negligence or malpractice in rendering professional services by any person who holds a certificate or license issued pursuant to the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act, or a license as a community clinic or health facility, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers providers, as specified, and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state.
The bill would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including liability insurance. Existing law defines liability insurance to include, among other things, insurance coverage against the legal liability of the insured, and against loss, damage, or expense incident to a claim arising out of the death or injury of any person as the result of negligence or malpractice in rendering professional services by any person who holds a certificate or license issued pursuant to the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act, or a license as a community clinic or health facility, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state.
The bill would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including liability insurance. Existing law defines liability insurance to include, among other things, insurance coverage against the legal liability of the insured, and against loss, damage, or expense incident to a claim arising out of the death or injury of any person as the result of negligence or malpractice in rendering professional services by any person who holds a certificate or license issued pursuant to the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act, or a license as a community clinic or health facility, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state.
The bill would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including professional liability insurance such as medical malpractice insurance. Existing law generally exempts unincorporated interindemnity, reciprocal, or interinsurance contracts between members of a cooperative corporation that indemnify medical malpractice claims against physician and surgeon members from regulation, subject to specified exceptions.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to medical malpractice insurance.Existing law generally regulates classes of insurance, including professional liability insurance such as medical malpractice insurance. Existing law generally exempts unincorporated interindemnity, reciprocal, or interinsurance contracts between members of a cooperative corporation that indemnify medical malpractice claims against physician and surgeon members from regulation, subject to specified exceptions.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to medical malpractice insurance.
(a)(1)An insurer shall not refuse to issue or renew, nor shall terminate, professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d).
(2)With respect to policies issued in this state and that provide professional liability coverage for damages arising from services offered or performed in multiple states, if a health care provider offers or performs the services described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) in a state where those services are unlawful, nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit an insurer from terminating, or refusing to issue or renew, a health care providers professional liability coverage in that state where the unlawful services are offered or performed.
(b)An insurer shall not increase premium, impose a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or institute or increase a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d). Nothing in this section shall be construed to supersede, modify, or otherwise affect in any way the provisions of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 and implementing regulations, as applicable.
(c)An insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers in this state shall not deny coverage for liability for damages arising from offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
(d)For purposes of this section, prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
(1)A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state.
(2)Another states laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state.
(3)Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if those health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
(e)This section applies to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
(f)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Health care provider means a person licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code to perform or render health care services in this state.
(2)Offer or perform means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services.
(3)Professional liability insurance means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
(a)(1)An insurer shall not refuse to issue or renew, nor shall terminate, professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d).
(2)With respect to policies issued in this state and that provide professional liability coverage for damages arising from services offered or performed in multiple states, if a health care provider offers or performs the services described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) in a state where those services are unlawful, nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit an insurer from terminating, or refusing to issue or renew, a health care providers professional liability coverage in that state where the unlawful services are offered or performed.
(b)An insurer shall not increase premium, impose a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or institute or increase a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d). Nothing in this section shall be construed to supersede, modify, or otherwise affect in any way the provisions of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 and implementing regulations, as applicable.
(c)An insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers in this state shall not deny coverage for liability for damages arising from offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insureds license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
(d)For purposes of this section, prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
(1)A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state.
(2)Another states laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state.
(3)Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if those health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
(e)This section applies to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
(f)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Health care provider means a person licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code to perform or render health care services in this state.
(2)Offer or perform means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services.
(3)Professional liability insurance means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
(a)(1)An insurer shall not refuse to issue or renew, nor shall terminate, professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d).
(2)With respect to policies issued in this state and that provide professional liability coverage for damages arising from services offered or performed in multiple states, if a health care provider offers or performs the services described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) in a state where those services are unlawful, nothing in this section shall be construed to prohibit an insurer from terminating, or refusing to issue or renew, a health care providers professional liability coverage in that state where the unlawful services are offered or performed.
(b)An insurer shall not increase premium, impose a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or institute or increase a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d). Nothing in this section shall be construed to supersede, modify, or otherwise affect in any way the provisions of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 and implementing regulations, as applicable.
(c)An insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers in this state shall not deny coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if such those services are within the scope of the insureds license license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
(d)For purposes of this section, prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
(1)A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state.
(2)Another states laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state.
(3)Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such those health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
(e)This section applies to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
(f)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Health care provider means a person licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code to perform or render health care services in this state.
(2)Offer or perform means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services.
(3)Professional liability insurance means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
(a)An insurer shall not refuse to issue or renew, nor shall terminate, professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d).
(b)An insurer shall not increase premium, impose a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or institute or increase a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d). Nothing in this section shall be construed to supersede, modify, or otherwise affect in any way the provisions of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 and implementing regulations, as applicable.
(c)An insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers in this state shall not deny coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if such services are within the scope of the insureds license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
(d)For purposes of this section, prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
(1)A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state.
(2)Another states laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state.
(3)Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
(e)This section applies to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
(f)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Health care provider means a person licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code to perform or render health care services in this state.
(2)Offer or perform means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services.
(3)Professional liability insurance means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
(a)An insurer shall not refuse to issue or renew, nor shall terminate, professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d).
(b)An insurer shall not increase premium, impose a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or institute or increase a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination set forth in subdivision (d).
(c)An insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers in this state shall not deny coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if such services are within the scope of the insureds license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insureds scope of license.
(d)For purposes of this section, prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
(1)A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state.
(2)Another states laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state.
(3)Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
(e)This section applies to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
(f)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Health care provider means a person licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code to perform or render health care services in this state.
(2)Offer or perform means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services.
(3)Professional liability insurance means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to medical malpractice insurance. REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to medical malpractice insurance.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 27, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 256, Statutes of 2023. |
| Sep 27, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 64. Noes 14. Page 3360.). |
| Sep 12, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 12, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 31. Noes 7. Page 2629.). |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (September 1). |
| Aug 21, 2023 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 12, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (July 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 29, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (June 28). |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on INS. and JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 63. Noes 14. Page 2059.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (May 18). |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 10. Noes 2.) (April 12). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 13, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on INS. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on INS. and JUD. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 11. |
| Feb 8, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2023 | AB 571 Petrie-Norris Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 12, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB571 Petrie-Norris et al. By Becker | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 21, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 571 Petrie-Norris Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Access Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| American College Of Obstetricians And Gynecologists District Ix | ** Support | |
| American Nurses Association/California | ** Support | |
| Attorney General Rob Bonta | ** Support | |
| California Academy Of Family Physicians | ** Support | |
| California Academy of Preventive Medicine | ** Support | |
| California Legislative Women's Caucus | ** Support | |
| California Medical Association | ** Support | |
| California Nurse Midwives Association | ** Support | |
| California Women's Law Center | ** Support | |
| Essential Access Health | ** Support | |
| If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| Medical Students for Choice | ** Support | |
| NARAL Pro-Choice California | ** Support | |
| National Health Law Program | ** Support | |
| Nurses for Sexual & Reproductive Health | ** Support | |
| Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis | ** Support | |
| Planned Parenthood Affiliates Of California | ** Support | |
| Reproductive Health Access Project | ** Support | |
| Right to Life League | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group | ** Support | |
| San Francisco City Attorney's Office | ** Support | |
| san francisco marin medical society | ** Support | |
| Training In Early Abortion For Comprehensive Healthcare | ** Support | |
| Women'S Foundation California | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 571
Author:(Petrie-Norris and Wicks)
As Amended Ver:September 1, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits insurers from refusing to provide professional liability coverage to health care providers or from imposing a surcharge on health care providers, because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, as specified.
Senate Amendments
- Add language to clarify that this bill does nothing to change the authority granted to the California Department of Insurance and the California Insurance Commissioner to approve any premium change in accordance with Proposition 103.
- Provide that this bill does not prohibit a medical malpractice carrier from terminating or refusing to issue or renew a health care provider's professional liability coverage in a state where that provider offered or performed specified services if those services are unlawful in that state.
- Make technical and conforming changes.
COMMENTS
Limited research suggests that the cost of liability insurance for health care providers (i.e. medical malpractice insurance) can be a barrier to the ability for family physicians to provide low-risk abortion services like first-trimester aspiration (which is provided in an out-patient setting) and medication abortion.
Additionally, this State has made protecting access to abortion and other reproductive services a priority. Gaps in access to reproductive services disproportionally impact low-income individuals and communities of color. Making it less cost prohibitive for practitioners to provide certain reproductive services could help to increase access.
Although California has become a safe haven for persons seeking medical treatment, the fact that medical professionals are targeted by other states can have implications in California. Seeking to protect health care providers in California who offer care that may be prohibited in other states, this bill places limits on what professional liability insurers can do as a result of the professional's line of work.
The constitutional concerns raised by the opposition appear to be based on a misunderstanding about the scope of this bill. This measure is opposed by the Right to Life League who argues this bill is an unconstitutional violation of California Supreme Court precedent prohibiting unequal financial treatment for those receiving abortions and birthing services. (Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252.) While such a contention regarding the unequal financial treatment may be true under the law, the premise is based on the notion that this bill limits a medical provider's liability should something go wrong during an abortion or childbirth. Such a notion wholly misunderstands the provisions of this bill. This bill simply prevents insurance premiums from increasing because a provider is offering medical care that is lawful in California but has been prohibited in other states. Because nothing in this bill impacts liability or financial treatment of medical services, the opposition's constitutional claims appear to be unfounded and should not be an impediment to this bill advancing through the legislative process.
According to the Author
In the months since the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color.
Ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element to securing access to services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing California's healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care.
AB 571 prohibits insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge to a healthcare provider for offering these services. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services, and will increase the number of licensed healthcare providers who are able to provide abortion and gender-affirming care in California.
Arguments in Support
According to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, the sponsor of this bill, "the current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services. AB 571 addresses this important issue by prohibiting insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge solely based on the offering of these services."
Arguments in Opposition
The Right to Life League opposes this bill, arguing that "AB 571 would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured's license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured's scope of license.
Accordingly, AB 571 creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth in violation of the California Constitution, pursuant to Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252 (1981)."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The California Department of Insurance (CDI) reports costs of $60,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24, $190,000 in FY 2024-25, and $61,000 in FY 2025-26 for staff workload to promulgate a medium-complexity rulemaking to interpret and implement the provisions of this bill (Insurance Fund).
- CDI notes that the bill as currently drafted may result in litigation, as Proposition 103 allows insurers to increase premiums for healthcare providers that perform abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services when those premium increases are related to the risk of loss. CDI notes that the estimated impact includes 20 companies that may file a rate filing to explicitly address the provisions of this bill.
VOTES:
ASM INSURANCE: 10-2-2
YES: Calderon, Berman, Cervantes, Gipson, Grayson, Jones-Sawyer, Ortega, Rodriguez, Valencia, Wood
NO: Essayli, Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Soria
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-14-3
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones -Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Megan Dahle, Davies, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Dixon, Ortega
UPDATED
VERSION: September 1, 2023
CONSULTANT: Claire Wendt / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0001787
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 571 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 571
Author: Petrie-Norris (D) and Wicks (D), et al.
Amended: 9/1/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE INSURANCE COMMITTEE: 4-2, 6/28/23
AYES: Rubio, Ashby, McGuire, Portantino
NOES: Jones, Niello
NO VOTE RECORDED: Nguyen
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-2, 7/11/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Stern, Wiener
NOES: Wilk, Niello
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-14, 5/31/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Medical malpractice insurance
SOURCE: American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers, as specified, and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state. This bill prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured’s license, the services are lawful in the state where they are offered or performed, and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Insurance Commissioner (Commissioner) as a statewide elected official responsible for administering and overseeing the California Department of Insurance (CDI).
- Regulates, generally, classes of insurance, including liability insurance.
- Defines liability insurance to include, but not be limited to, insurance coverage against legal liability arising from the rendering of professional services by an insured licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act. (Insurance (Ins.) Code Section 11580.01)
- Provides that an insurer who provides professional liability insurance for physicians and surgeons shall not increase the premium for such insurance, impose a surcharge with respect to such insurance, or otherwise require additional compensation for such insurance, or institute or increase a deductible amount payable by the insured, because a notice of intention to commence an action for professional negligence has been filed, unless a complaint has been served on the physician or surgeon. (Ins. Code Section 11589)
This bill:
- Prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers solely based on any prohibited basis, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost solely based on any prohibited basis, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health services if the services are within the scope of the insured’s license, as provided.
- Provides that prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
- Offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services that are lawful in this state;
- Where another state’s laws create potential or actual liability for the above mentioned services in this state; or
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services would be lawful in this state.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill shall be construed to prohibit an insurer from terminating, or refusing to issue or renew, a health care provider’s professional liability coverage in that state where the unlawful services are offered or performed.
Background
According to the author, in the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color. A major barrier to expanding access to abortion care is the cost and availability of professional liability insurance. According to recent research, physicians must often purchase costly abortion riders.
Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions.
AB 571 prevents insurers from denying licensed healthcare practitioners professional liability insurance based solely on their provision of abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services. Furthermore, this bill prohibits insurers from imposing fees or surcharges on healthcare providers who offer these services. By removing these obstacles, AB 571 aims to facilitate the provision of reproductive health services by licensed healthcare providers.
Research studies have shown that the cost of professional liability insurance can be prohibitively high for abortion providers. These costs can be a deterrent for healthcare practitioners and clinics to offer abortion services or can result in increased costs for patients. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) has highlighted the challenges related to professional liability insurance as a barrier to abortion provision. In a position statement, ACOG mentions that the high cost and limited availability of insurance coverage for abortion providers contribute to the scarcity of trained providers and the closure of abortion clinics.
The Senate Judiciary Committee wrote in its analysis:
California is a Reproductive Freedom State
The California Supreme Court held in 1969 that the state constitution’s implied right to privacy extends to an individual’s decision about whether or not to have an abortion. (People v. Belous (1969) 71 Cal.2d 954.) This was the first time an individual’s right to abortion was upheld in a court. In 1972 the California voters passed a constitutional amendment that explicitly provided for the right to privacy in the state constitution. (Prop. 11, Nov. 7, 1972 gen. elec.) California statutory law provides, under the Reproductive Privacy Act, that the Legislature finds and declares every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy; therefore, it is the public policy of the State of California that every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control, and every individual has the fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion. (Health & Saf. Code § 123462.) In 2019 Governor Newsom issued a proclamation reaffirming California’s commitment to making reproductive freedom a fundamental right in response to the numerous attacks on reproductive rights across the nation.[1] In September 2021, more than 40 organizations came together to form the California Future Abortion Council (CA FAB) to identify barriers to accessing abortion services and to recommend policy proposals to support equitable and affordable access for not only Californians but all who seek care in the state.
In response to the Dobbs decision, California enacted a comprehensive package of legislation expanding, protecting, and strengthening access to reproductive health care, including abortions, for all Californians and people seeking such care in our state.[2] One such law, AB 1666 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 42, Stats. 2022) provided that a law of another state that authorizes a person to bring a civil action against a person or entity who receives, seeks, performs, or induces an abortion, or knowingly engages in conduct that aids or abets the performance or inducement of an abortion, or attempts or intends to engage in such conduct, is contrary to the public policy of this state (Gov. Code § 123467.5.) Additionally, the voters overwhelmingly approved Proposition 1 (Nov. 8, 2022 gen. elec.), and enacted an express constitutional right in the state constitution that prohibits the state from interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- CDI reports costs of $60,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24, $190,000 in FY 2024-25, and $61,000 in FY 2025-26 for staff workload to promulgate a medium-complexity rulemaking to interpret and implement the provisions of this bill (Insurance Fund).
- CDI notes that this bill as currently drafted may result in litigation, as Proposition 103 allows insurers to increase premiums for healthcare providers that perform abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services when those premium increases are related to the risk of loss. CDI notes that the estimated impact includes 20 companies that may file a rate filing to explicitly address the provisions of this bill.
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/5/23)
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX (source)
Attorney General Rob Bonta
Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Access Reproductive Justice
American Nurses Association/California
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Academy of Preventive Medicine
California Legislative Women's Caucus
California Medical Association
California Nurse Midwives Association
California Women's Law Center
Essential Access Health
If/When/How: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Medical Students for Choice
NARAL Pro-Choice California
National Health Law Program
Nurses for Sexual & Reproductive Health
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Reproductive Health Access Project
San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group
San Francisco City Attorney's Office
San Francisco Marin Medical Society
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Healthcare
Women's Foundation California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/5/23)
Right to Life League
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, states that a major barrier to expanding access to abortion care is the cost and availability of professional liability insurance. According to recent research, physicians must often purchase costly abortion riders. Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions. The current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services. AB 571 addresses this important issue by prohibiting insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge solely based on the offering of these services.
The California Medical Association argues that in the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access resulting in patients being forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions are estimated to affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color. The California constitution protects the legal right to abortion care. But this right is meaningless without real access – and ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element in strengthening access to reproductive services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing the State’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the Right to Life League, AB 571 creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth in violation of the California Constitution, pursuant to Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252 (1981). In CDRR v. Myers, the California Supreme Court struck down the Legislature’s ban on Medi-Cal funding of abortion. The Court emphasized that the state could not intervene in the very intimate decision about whether to give birth or have an abortion, e.g.,: By virtue of the explicit protection afforded an individual's inalienable right of privacy by Article I, Section 1 of the California Constitution, however, the decision whether to bear a child or to have an abortion is so private and so intimate that each woman in this state -- rich or poor -- is guaranteed the constitutional right to make that decision as an individual, un-coerced by governmental intrusion. Because a woman's right to choose whether or not to bear a child is explicitly afforded this constitutional protection, in California the question of whether an individual woman should or should not terminate her pregnancy is not a matter that may be put to a vote of the Legislature.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-14, 5/31/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Megan Dahle, Davies, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chen, Dixon, Ortega
Prepared by: Jill Rice / INS. / (916) 651-4110
9/5/23 12:36:35
**** END ****
California Proclamation on Reproductive Freedom (May 31, 2019) available at https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Proclamation-on-Reproductive-Freedom.pdf. ↑
Kristen Hwang, Newsom signs abortion protections into law, CalMatters (Sept. 27, 2022), available at https://calmatters.org/health/2022/09/california-abortion-bills/. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 571 (Petrie-Norris) - Medical malpractice insurance
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 571 prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited basis for discrimination, as specified. AB 571 also prohibits an insurer authorized in the state from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on September 1, 2023
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Department of Insurance (CDI) reports costs of $60,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24, $190,000 in FY 2024-25, and $61,000 in FY 2025-26 for staff workload to promulgate a medium-complexity rulemaking to interpret and implement the provisions of this bill (Insurance Fund).
- CDI notes that the bill as currently drafted may result in litigation, as Proposition 103 allows insurers to increase premiums for healthcare providers that perform abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services when those premium increases are related to the risk of loss. CDI notes that the estimated impact includes 20 companies that may file a rate filing to explicitly address the provisions of this bill.
Author Amendments:
- Provide that this bill does not prohibit a medical malpractice carrier from terminating or refusing to issue or renew a health care provider’s professional liability coverage in a state where that provider offered or performed specified services if those services are unlawful in that state.
- Make technical and conforming changes.
- Add coauthors.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 571 (Petrie-Norris) - Medical malpractice insurance
Version: July 3, 2023 | Policy Vote: INS. 4 - 2, JUD. 9 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 21, 2023 | Consultant: Janelle Miyashiro |
Bill Summary:
AB 571 prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited basis for discrimination, as specified. AB 571 also prohibits an insurer authorized in the state from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
Fiscal Impact:
The California Department of Insurance (CDI) reports costs of $60,000 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2023-24, $190,000 in FY 2024-25, and $61,000 in FY 2025-26 for staff workload to promulgate a medium-complexity rulemaking to interpret and implement the provisions of this bill (Insurance Fund).
CDI notes that the bill as currently drafted may result in litigation, as Proposition 103 allows insurers to increase premiums for healthcare providers that perform abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services when those premium increases are related to the risk of loss. CDI notes that the estimated impact includes 20 companies that may file a rate filing to explicitly address the provisions of this bill.
Background:
According to CDI’s website, when CDI proposes regulations the Administrative Procedure Act requires that CDI publish a public notice of its proposed regulatory change in the California Regulatory Notice Register at least 45 days prior to the agency's hearing or decision to adopt the change. This includes the adoption of new regulations, an amendment to an existing regulation or the repeal of an existing regulation. The public notice must include the following:
- CDI's legal authority for adopting the regulatory change.
- An informative digest containing a concise and clear summary of what the regulatory change would do.
- The deadline for submission of written comments on the proposed regulatory action.
- The name and telephone number of the contact person and back-up contact person for the proposed action.
- Information on where to find the proposed text of regulations (express terms).
- The notice may also include the date, time, and place of a public hearing to be held by the Department for receipt of oral testimony on the proposed regulatory change.
Public hearings are generally optional; however, an interested member of the public can compel CDI to hold a public hearing on any proposed regulatory changes by requesting a hearing in writing no later than 15 days prior to the close of the written comment period. The public may petition CDI to conduct a rulemaking hearing. Any person may file a written petition requesting the adoption of an amendment, or repeal of a regulation. Within 30 days, the CDI must notify the petitioners in writing indicating whether (and why) it has denied the petition, or granting the petition or scheduling a public hearing on the matter.
Proposed Law:
- Prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers solely based on any prohibited basis.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost solely based on any prohibited basis, as provided.
- Specifies that nothing supersedes, modifies, or otherwise affects in any way the provisions of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 and implementing regulations, as applicable.
- Prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health services if the services are within the scope of the insured’s license, as provided.
- Provides that prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
- Offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services that are lawful in this state;
- Where another state’s laws create potential or actual liability for the above mentioned services in this state; or
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services would be lawful in this state.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 571 (Author:Petrie-Norris)
Version: July 3, 2023
Hearing Date: July 11, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Medical malpractice insurance
DIGEST
This bill prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue, renew, or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on specified bases of discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state. The bill also prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services, if the services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Since the 1973 holding in Roe v. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court has continuously held that it is a constitutional right to access abortion before fetal viability. However, on June 24, 2022 the Court voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe and found that there is no federal constitutional right to an abortion. As a result of the Dobbs decision, people in roughly half the country may lose access to abortion services or have them severely restricted. Some states have even begun criminalizing abortion care. In addition, a growing number of states have been passing laws putting residents who seek essential gender-affirming care at risk of being prosecuted. States are attempting to classify the provision and seeking of gender-affirming health care as a crime warranting prison time and are threatening parents with criminal penalties if they attempt to travel to another state in order to secure life-saving gender-affirming care for their child. This bill seeks to provide additional safeguards for health care providers by prohibiting an insurer from terminating professional liability insurance or refusing to issue or renew insurance as a result of a medical professional based on specified bases of discrimination, including performing abortions or providing gender-affirming health care. The bill also limits premium increases as a result of a medical professional’s provision of care that is legal in California yet banned elsewhere. This bill passed the Senate Insurance Committee on a vote of 4 to 2.
The bill is sponsored by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, the California Nurse Midwives Association, and NARAL Pro-Choice. The bill is supported by various medical and health organizations, Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis, and the San Francisco City Attorney's Office. There is no known opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides for the regulation of insurance by CDI, which is under the control of the Insurance Commissioner (Commissioner). (Ins. Code § 12921.)
- Prohibits an insurer that provides professional liability insurance for physicians and surgeons or dentists from increasing the premium for the insurance, impose a surcharge with respect to such insurance, or otherwise require additional compensation for such insurance, or institute or increase a deductible amount payable by the insured, because a notice of intention to commence an action has been issued unless a complaint has actually been served on the insured. (Ins. Code § 11589(a).)
- Defines liability insurance to include, but not be limited to, insurance coverage against legal liability arising from the rendering of professional services by an insured licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act. (Ins. Code § 11580.01.)
- Provides, pursuant to Proposition 103 (Nov. 8, 1988, gen. elec.), that no insurance rate is to be approved or remain in effect that is excessive, inadequate, unfairly discriminatory, or otherwise in violation of existing provisions of the Insurance Code. (Ins. Code § 1861.05.)
- Provides for the various healing arts professions that are to be regulated and licensed by the boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 500 et seq.)
- Establishes limits for compensation for noneconomic losses related to pain, suffering, inconvenience, physical impairment, disfigurement, and other nonpecuniary damage stemming from an injury that occurred as a result of the professional negligence of a health care provider or health care institution. (Civ. Code § 3333.2(a).)
This bill:
- Prohibits an insurer from terminating professional liability insurance or refusing to issue or renew professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases as specified in 4) below.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or instituting or increasing a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases as specified in 4) below.
- Prohibits an insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if such services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
- Prohibits an insurer from discriminating against a health care provider related to professional liability insurance for any of the following:
- A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state;
- Another state’s laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state; and
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
- Provides that these provisions are limited to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
- Provides that these provisions are not to be construed to supersede, modify, or otherwise affect in any way the provisions related to insurance rates as added by Proposition 103.
- Defines various terms for these purposes.
- “Health care provider” means a person licensed under specified provisions of the Business and Professions Code to be regulated by a healing arts board within the Department of Consumer Affairs;
- “Offer or perform” means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services; and
- “Professional liability insurance” means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
In the time since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color.
Ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element to securing access to services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing California’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care.
AB 571 prohibits insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge to a healthcare provider for offering these services. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services, and will increase the number of licensed healthcare providers who are able to provide abortion and gender-affirming care in California.
- Reproductive rights
Roe v. Wade was the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that held the implied constitutional right to privacy extended to a person’s decision whether to terminate a pregnancy, while allowing that some state regulation of abortion access could be permissible. ((1973) 410 U.S. 113; overruled by Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health (2022) 142 S. Ct. 2228.) Roe has been one of the most debated U.S. Supreme Court decisions and its application and validity have been challenged numerous times, but its fundamental holding had continuously been upheld by the Court until June 2022. On June 24, 2022 the Court published its official opinion in Dobbs and voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe.[1] The case involved a Mississippi law enacted in 2018 that banned most abortions after the first 15 weeks of pregnancy, which is before what is generally accepted as the period of viability. (see Miss. Code Ann. §41-41-191.) The majority opinion upholds the Mississippi law finding that, contrary to almost 50 years of precedent, there is no fundamental constitutional right to have an abortion. The opinion further provides that states should be allowed to decide how to regulate abortion and that a strong presumption of validity should be afforded to those state laws.[2]
- Out-of-state statutes denying or chilling access to reproductive health care
Texas perniciously enacted a law with an enforcement scheme that was designed to avoid judicial scrutiny of the law’s clearly unconstitutional, at the time of enactment, provisions under the holding of Roe and Casey.[3] Texas abortion providers filed a case in an attempt to stop the law before it took effect seeking pre-enforcement review of the law and an injunction barring its enforcement. On certiorari from the Fifth Circuit, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a pre-enforcement challenge to the law under the U.S. Constitution may only proceed against certain defendants but not others.[4] The court did not address whether the law was constitutionally sound. However, the court’s ruling essentially insulated the private enforcement of the law from challenge, allowing the law to remain in effect. The inability to challenge the law pre-enforcement allows it to stand as an ominous threat to all persons seeking or performing an abortion. This Texas law may very well be found to be constitutional under the holding of Dobbs.
The Texas law prohibits a physician from knowingly performing or inducing an abortion on a pregnant woman if the physician detected a fetal heartbeat for the unborn child, as specified, or failed to perform a test to detect a fetal heartbeat. (Tex. Health & Safety Code § 171.201 et seq. (enacted through Texas Senate Bill 8).) This law essentially places a near-categorical ban on abortions beginning six weeks after a person’s last menstrual period, which is before many people even realize they are pregnant and occurs months before fetal viability.[5] The Texas law has far reaching implications, not only for the person receiving an abortion or performing abortion services. This is evidenced in the provisions that prohibit anyone from “aiding and abetting” a person in obtaining an abortion, which could implicate and impose significant civil liability upon a person providing transportation to or from an abortion clinic, a person donating to a fund to assist individuals receiving an abortion, or even a person who simply discusses getting an abortion with someone. (Tex. Health & Safety Code § 171.208.) The Texas law provides that any person, other than an officer or employee of a state or local governmental entity in Texas, may bring a civil action to enforce its provisions, which includes liability of $10,000 plus costs and fees if a plaintiff prevails while a defendant is prohibited from recovering their own costs and fees if they prevail. (Id. at § 171.201(b) & (i).) Other states have already followed suit.
Additionally, many abortion bans attach criminal and administrative penalties in addition to civil liability. For example, in Texas it is a felony to perform an abortion, unless it is needed to save the life of the patient, and provides for civil liability and licensure revocation. (Tex. Health & Safety Code § 171.201 et. seq.) In six states with abortion bans—Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Missouri, North Dakota, and Tennessee—prosecutors can criminally prosecute health care professionals for performing abortions and providers are only allowed to offer evidence that the procedure was necessary to save the patient until after they are charged.[6] Oklahoma made performing an abortion a felony, with a punishment of up to 10 years in prison and a fine of up to $100,000 in August of 2022.[7] This year, the Governor of Idaho signed a bill into law that makes it illegal for an adult to help a minor get an abortion without parental consent. The law essentially bans adults from obtaining abortion pills for a minor or “recruiting, harboring or transporting the pregnant minor” without parental consent.[8] If convicted, a person could face two to five years in prison and may be sued by the minor’s parent.
- California is a Reproductive Freedom State
The California Supreme Court held in 1969 that the state constitution’s implied right to privacy extends to an individual’s decision about whether or not to have an abortion. (People v. Belous (1969) 71 Cal.2d 954.) This was the first time an individual’s right to abortion was upheld in a court. In 1972 the California voters passed a constitutional amendment that explicitly provided for the right to privacy in the state constitution. (Prop. 11, Nov. 7, 1972 gen. elec.) California statutory law provides, under the Reproductive Privacy Act, that the Legislature finds and declares every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy; therefore, it is the public policy of the State of California that every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control, and every individual has the fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion. (Health & Saf. Code § 123462.) In 2019 Governor Newsom issued a proclamation reaffirming California’s commitment to making reproductive freedom a fundamental right in response to the numerous attacks on reproductive rights across the nation.[9] In September 2021, more than 40 organizations came together to form the California Future Abortion Council (CA FAB) to identify barriers to accessing abortion services and to recommend policy proposals to support equitable and affordable access for not only Californians but all who seek care in the state.
In response to the Dobbs decision, California enacted a comprehensive package of legislation expanding, protecting, and strengthening access to reproductive health care, including abortions, for all Californians and people seeking such care in our state.[10] One such law, AB 1666 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 42, Stats. 2022) provided that a law of another state that authorizes a person to bring a civil action against a person or entity who receives, seeks, performs, or induces an abortion, or knowingly engages in conduct that aids or abets the performance or inducement of an abortion, or attempts or intends to engage in such conduct, is contrary to the public policy of this state (Gov. Code § 123467.5.) Additionally, the voters overwhelmingly approved Proposition 1 (Nov. 8, 2022 gen. elec.), and enacted an express constitutional right in the state constitution that prohibits the state from interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions.
- Out of state bans on gender-affirming care and California policies to protect patients receiving such care
As California and other states have implemented policies to ensure that transgender individuals are not discriminated against and can obtain gender-affirming care, other states have targeted transgender individuals and providers of gender affirming care. According to Human Rights Watch, as of March 2022, legislatures nationwide had introduced over 300 anti-LGBTQ+ bills, over 130 of which specifically targeted transgender people.[11] Many states have been enacting statutes that potentially impose civil and criminal liability for providing to a minor, or helping a minor obtain, gender-affirming care. For example, Alabama recently enacted a bill that makes it a felony to provide, or help to provide, certain types of gender-affirming care.[12] Arkansas prohibits a physician or other healthcare provider from providing or referring certain types of gender-affirming care for a minor; a violation or “threatened violation” can be punished through a professional board or a civil action.[13] SB 107 (Wiener, 2022; Ch. 810, Stats. 2022), among other things, prohibits the sharing of medical records regarding the receipt of gender-affirming care, the enforcement of out-of-state subpoenas seeking information regarding the receipt of gender-affirming medical care in California, and the enforcement of laws of another state that authorize the removal of a child from their parent or guardian and enforcement of out-of-state criminal laws related to gender-affirming health care. On September 29, 2022, Governor Newsom issued a signing statement for SB 107 that said “[i]n California we believe in equality and acceptance. We believe that no one should be prosecuted or persecuted for getting care they need – including gender-affirming care.[14]” Just last month, the American Medical Association House of Delegates passed a resolution to protect access to evidence-based gender-affirming care by committing to opposing legislation to enact criminal and legal penalties against patients seeking gender-affirming care, family members or guardians who support them in seeking medical care, and health care facilities and clinicians who provide gender-affirming care.[15]
- This bill seeks to provide additional protections for health care providers in regards to professional liability insurance
According to the Senate Insurance Committee:
Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions. […]
Research studies have shown that the cost of professional liability insurance can be prohibitively high for abortion providers. These costs can be a deterrent for healthcare practitioners and clinics to offer abortion services or can result in increased costs for patients. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) has highlighted the challenges related to professional liability insurance as a barrier to abortion provision. In a position statement, ACOG mentions that the high cost and limited availability of insurance coverage for abortion providers contribute to the scarcity of trained providers and the closure of abortion clinics.[16]
This bill seeks to provide health care providers in California who offer care that may be prohibited in other states protections from having their insurance premiums unduly increased. The bill prohibits an insurer from terminating or refusing to issue or renew insurance, or increasing premiums, simply because a medical professional provides abortions, contraception, or gender-affirming care. The bill also provides that should another state seek to take action against a health care provider for providing those services, California insurers cannot take adverse action against the health care provider as long as the health care services provided are, or would be, lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state. The bill makes it clear that it only applies to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state, and that it does not supersede any of the provision of Proposition 103 (Nov. 8, 1988, gen. elec.), which governs insurance rate and rate increases.
The language in the bill regarding legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider specifically provides that it is limited to actions conducted in a manner that is both, “lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.” Under this limitation, if an action taken in another state would constitute malpractice in this state, then an insurer can increase rates or refuse to renew or terminate a policy. The bill only applies to the narrow circumstances where liability incurred due to other states attempts to limit access to health care that is lawful in this state.
- Statements in support
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, a sponsor of the bill, writes in support:
A major barrier to expanding access to abortion care is the cost and availability of professional liability insurance. According to recent research, physicians must often purchase costly abortion riders. Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions. The current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services.
AB 571 addresses this important issue by prohibiting insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge solely based on the offering of these services.
SUPPORT
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX (sponsor)
California Nurse Midwives Association (sponsor)
NARAL Pro-Choice (sponsor)
California Academy of Family Physicians
Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Medical Students for Choice
National Health Law Program
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group
San Francisco City Attorney's Office
San Francisco Marin Medical Society
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Healthcare
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 254 (Bauer-Kahan, 2023) includes “reproductive or sexual health application information” in the definition of “medical information” and the businesses that offer reproductive or sexual health digital services to consumers in the definition of a provider of health care for purposes of the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA). This bill is currently pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 352 (Bauer-Kahan, 2023), among other things, enacts protections for certain sensitive medical information by requiring businesses that store or maintain that information to develop specified capabilities, policies, and procedures to enable safeguards regarding accessing the information by July 1, 2024. This bill is currently pending in the Senate Health Committee.
AB 793 (Bonta, 2023) prohibits a government entity from seeking or obtaining information from a reverse-location demand or a reverse-keyword demand, and prohibits any person or government entity from complying with a reverse-location demand or a reverse-keyword demand. That bill is currently pending before the Senate Public Safety Committee.
AB 1194 (Carrillo, 2023) provides stronger privacy protections pursuant to the California Consumer Privacy Act where the consumer information relates to specified reproductive health services. This bill is currently pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SR 9 (Skinner, 2023) urged the President of the U.S. and the U.S. Congress to enact federal legislation that guarantees the right to reproductive freedom, including abortion and contraception.
SB 107 (Wiener, Ch. 810, Stats. 2022) enacted various safeguards against the enforcement of other states’ laws that purport to penalize individuals from obtaining gender-affirming care that is legal in California.
AB 1666 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 42, Stats. 2022) prohibited the enforcement in this state of out-of-state laws authorizing a civil action against a person or entity that receives or seeks, performs or induces, or aids or abets the performance of an abortion, or who attempts or intends to engage in those actions and declares those out-of-state laws to be contrary to the public policy of this state.
AB 2091 (Mia Bonta, Ch. 628, Stats. 2022), among other things, prohibited compelling a person to identify or provide information that would identify an individual who has sought or obtained an abortion in a state, county, city, or other local criminal, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding if the information is being requested based on another state’s laws that interfere with a person’s right to choose or obtain an abortion or a foreign penal civil action.
AB 2223 (Wicks, Ch. 629, Stats. 2022), among other things, provides that every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Insurance Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 2)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 63, Noes 14)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 4)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 3)
Assembly Insurance Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 2)
**************
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health (2022) 597 U.S. _ (142 S. Ct. 2228) at p. 5, available at https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/19-1392_6j37.pdf. ↑
Id. at 77. ↑
See Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson (2021) 142 S. Ct. 522, at 543 (conc. opn. Roberts, C.J., Breyer, Sotomayor, & Kagan) that states Texas has passed a law that is contrary to Roe and Casey because it has “the effect of denying the exercise of what we have held is a right protected under the Federal Constitution” and was “designed to shield its unconstitutional law from judicial review.” (footnote omitted). ↑
Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson (2021) 142 S. Ct. 522, 530. ↑
See Whole Woman's Health v. Jackson (2021) 141 S. Ct. 2494, at 2498 (dis. opn. Sotomayor, Breyer, & Kagan). ↑
Christine Vestal, Some Abortion Bans Put Patients, Doctors at Risk in Emergencies, Pew Trusts (Sept. 1, 2022), available at https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2022/09/01/some-abortion-bans-put-patients-doctors-at-risk-in-emergencies. ↑
Associated Press, Oklahoma governor signs bill making it felony to perform an abortion, NBC News (Apr. 12, 2022), available at https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/oklahoma-governor-signs-bill-making-felony-perform-abortion-rcna24071. ↑
Associated Press, Idaho governor signs law banning adults from helping minors get abortions, The Guardian (April 6, 2023), available at https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/apr/06/idaho-abortion-trafficking-law-governor. ↑
California Proclamation on Reproductive Freedom (May 31, 2019) available at https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Proclamation-on-Reproductive-Freedom.pdf. ↑
Kristen Hwang, Newsom signs abortion protections into law, CalMatters (Sept. 27, 2022), available at https://calmatters.org/health/2022/09/california-abortion-bills/. ↑
Human Rights Watch, Press Release, ICYMI: As Lawmakers Escalate Attacks on Transgender Youth Across the Country, Some GOP Leaders Stand Up for Transgender Youth (Mar. 24, 2022), https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/icymi-as-lawmakers-escalate-attacks-on-transgender-youth-across-the-country-some-gop-leaders-stand-up-for-transgender-youth (all links current as of August 29, 2022). ↑
See Al. Code, § 26-26-4. ↑
Ark. Stats. §§ 20-9-1502 & 20-9-1504. ↑
Governor’s singing statement on Sen. Bill 107 (2021-22 Reg. Sess.), available at https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/SB-107-SIGNING.pdf?emrc=1a80c5. ↑
Endocrine Society, AMA strengthens its policy on protecting access to gender-affirming care (Jun. 12, 2023), available at https://www.endocrine.org/news-and-advocacy/news-room/2023/ama-gender-affirming-care. ↑
Sen. Ins. Comm. analysis of AB 571 (2023-24 Reg. Sess.) as amended Mar. 9, 2023 at pp. 3-4. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Senator Susan Rubio, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 571 Hearing Date: June 28, 2023
Author: | Petrie-Norris | ||
Version: | March 9, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jill Rice | ||
SUBJECT: Medical malpractice insurance
DIGEST:
This bill would prohibit an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminating professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited basis for discrimination. These bases include a health care provider offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services that are lawful in this state but unlawful in another state. The bill would prohibit an insurer authorized in the state from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Insurance Commissioner (Commissioner) as a statewide elected official responsible for administering and overseeing the California Department of Insurance (CDI).
- Regulates, generally, classes of insurance, including liability insurance.
- Defines liability insurance to include, but not be limited to, insurance coverage against legal liability arising from the rendering of professional services by an insured licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act. (Insurance (Ins.) Code Section 11580.01)
- Provides that an insurer who provides professional liability insurance for physicians and surgeons shall not increase the premium for such insurance, impose a surcharge with respect to such insurance, or otherwise require additional compensation for such insurance, or institute or increase a deductible amount payable by the insured, because a notice of intention to commence an action for professional negligence has been filed, unless a complaint has been served on the physician or surgeon. (Ins. Code Section 11589)
This bill:
- Prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers solely based on any prohibited basis, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost solely based on any prohibited basis, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health services if the services are within the scope of the insured’s license, as provided.
- Provides that prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
- Offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services that are lawful in this state;
- Where another state’s laws create potential or actual liability for the above mentioned services in this state; or
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services would be lawful in this state.
Background
According to the author, in the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color. A major barrier to expanding access to abortion care is the cost and availability of professional liability insurance. According to recent research, physicians must often purchase costly abortion riders.
Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions.
AB 571 prevents insurers from denying licensed healthcare practitioners professional liability insurance based solely on their provision of abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services. Furthermore, this bill prohibits insurers from imposing fees or surcharges on healthcare providers who offer these services. By removing these obstacles, AB 571 aims to facilitate the provision of reproductive health services by licensed healthcare providers.
Research studies have shown that the cost of professional liability insurance can be prohibitively high for abortion providers. These costs can be a deterrent for healthcare practitioners and clinics to offer abortion services or can result in increased costs for patients. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) has highlighted the challenges related to professional liability insurance as a barrier to abortion provision. In a position statement, ACOG mentions that the high cost and limited availability of insurance coverage for abortion providers contribute to the scarcity of trained providers and the closure of abortion clinics.
Suggested Amendment
In order to clarify that we are not intending to change the authority granted to the Department of Insurance to approve any premium change or anything about the Prop 103 process, want to add the following
Line 11, as a second sentence in (b): “Nothing in this section shall be construed to supersede, modify, or otherwise affect in any way the provisions of Article 10 (commencing with Section 1861.01) of Chapter 9 of Part 2 of Division 1 and implementing regulations, as applicable.”
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, District IX, states that a major barrier to expanding access to abortion care is the cost and availability of professional liability insurance. According to recent research, physicians must often purchase costly abortion riders. Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions. The current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services. AB 571 addresses this important issue by prohibiting insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge solely based on the offering of these services.
The California Medical Association argues that in the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access resulting in patients being forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions are estimated to affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color. The California constitution protects the legal right to abortion care. But this right is meaningless without real access – and ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element in strengthening access to reproductive services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing the State’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the Right to Life League, AB 571 creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth in violation of the California Constitution, pursuant to Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252 (1981). In CDRR v. Myers, the California Supreme Court struck down the legislature’s ban on Medi-Cal funding of abortion. The Court emphasized that the state could not intervene in the very intimate decision about whether to give birth or have an abortion, e.g.,: By virtue of the explicit protection afforded an individual's inalienable right of privacy by article I, section 1 of the California Constitution, however, the decision whether to bear a child or to have an abortion is so private and so intimate that each woman in this state -- rich or poor -- is guaranteed the constitutional right to make that decision as an individual, un-coerced by governmental intrusion. Because a woman's right to choose whether or not to bear a child is explicitly afforded this constitutional protection, in California the question of whether an individual woman should or should not terminate her pregnancy is not a matter that may be put to a vote of the Legislature.
SUPPORT:
Access Reproductive Justice |
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District Ix |
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District Ix (SPONSOR) |
American Nurses Association/California |
CA Legislative Women's Caucus |
California Academy of Family Physicians |
California Academy of Preventive Medicine |
California Medical Association |
California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA) |
California Women's Law Center |
Essential Access Health |
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice |
Naral Pro-choice California |
National Health Law Program |
Nurses for Sexual & Reproductive Health |
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California |
Reproductive Health Access Project (RHAP) |
San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group |
San Francisco Marin Medical Society |
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Health Care |
Women's Foundation California |
OPPOSITION:
Right to Life League
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 571
Author:(Petrie-Norris and Wicks)
As Amended Ver:March 9, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits insurers from refusing to provide professional liability coverage to health care providers or from imposing a surcharge on health care providers, because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers solely based on any prohibited bases, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost solely based on any prohibited bases, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health services if the services are within the scope of the insured's license, as provided.
- Provides that prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
- Offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services that are lawful in this state;
- Where another state's laws create potential or actual liability for the above mentioned services in this state; or
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services would be lawful in this state.
- Limits the provisions of the bill to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
- Defines the following terms:
- "Health care provider" means a person licensed under specified provisions of the Business and Professions Code to be regulated by a healing arts board within the Department of Consumer Affairs;
- "Offer or perform" means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services; and
- "Professional liability insurance" means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
COMMENTS
Limited research suggests that the cost of liability insurance for health care providers (i.e. medical malpractice insurance) can be a barrier to the ability for family physicians to provide low-risk abortion services like first-trimester aspiration (which is provided in an out-patient setting) and medication abortion.
Additionally, this State has made protecting access to abortion and other reproductive services a priority. Gaps in access to reproductive services disproportionally impact low-income individuals and communities of color. Making it less cost prohibitive for practitioners to provide certain reproductive services could help to increase access.
Although California has become a safe haven for persons seeking medical treatment, the fact that medical professionals are targeted by other states can have implications in California. Seeking to protect health care providers in California who offer care that may be prohibited in other states, this bill places limits on what professional liability insurers can do as a result of the professional's line of work.
Concerns Related to Commissioner's Authority and Proposition (Prop.) 103. Prop. 103, passed by the voters in November 1988, requires the "prior approval" of CDI before insurance companies can implement property and casualty insurance rates. Therefore, all insurance rates charged in this state are essentially overseen and approved by CDI and the Commissioner. The limits this bill places on how insurers can charge for medical malpractice insurance does not appear to directly violate Prop. 103.
The constitutional concerns raised by the opposition appear to be based on a misunderstanding about the scope of this bill. This measure is opposed by the Right to Life League who argues this bill is an unconstitutional violation of California Supreme Court precedent prohibiting unequal financial treatment for those receiving abortions and birthing services. (Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252.) While such a contention regarding the unequal financial treatment may be true under the law, the premise is based on the notion that this bill limits a medical provider's liability should something go wrong during an abortion or childbirth. Such a notion wholly misunderstands the provisions of this bill. This bill simply prevents insurance premiums from increasing because a provider is offering medical care that is lawful in California but has been prohibited in other states. Because nothing in this bill impacts liability or financial treatment of medical services, the opposition's constitutional claims appear to be unfounded and should not be an impediment to this bill advancing through the legislative process.
According to the Author
In the months since the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color.
Ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element to securing access to services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing California's healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care.
AB 571 prohibits insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge to a healthcare provider for offering these services. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services, and will increase the number of licensed healthcare providers who are able to provide abortion and gender-affirming care in California.
Arguments in Support
According to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, the sponsor of this bill, "the current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services. AB 571 addresses this important issue by prohibiting insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge solely based on the offering of these services."
Arguments in Opposition
The Right to Life League opposes this bill, arguing that "AB 571 would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured's license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured's scope of license.
Accordingly, AB 571 creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth in violation of the California Constitution, pursuant to Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252 (1981)."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, "Costs of approximately $60,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24, $190,000 in FY 2024-25, and $61,000 in FY 2025-26 to the Department of Insurance (CDI) in staff workload to promulgate a medium-complexity rulemaking to interpret this bill's provisions. CDI notes the bill, as drafted, is unclear and may result in litigation, since Proposition 103 (2018) allows insurers to increase premiums for healthcare providers that perform specified services when such an increase is related to the risk of loss (Insurance Fund)."
VOTES
ASM INSURANCE: 10-2-2
YES: Calderon, Berman, Cervantes, Gipson, Grayson, Jones-Sawyer, Ortega, Rodriguez, Valencia, Wood
NO: Essayli, Vince Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Soria
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: March 9, 2023
CONSULTANT: Claire Wendt / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0000554
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 571
Author:(Petrie-Norris) – As Amended Ver:March 9, 2023
Policy Committee: | Insurance | Vote: | 10 - 2 |
Judiciary | 8 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits an insurer from rescinding or increasing the cost of professional liability insurance for healthcare providers offering legal healthcare services in California that are unlawful in other states, such as abortion, contraception, and gender-affirming care.
Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an insurer from terminating, refusing to issue or renew, imposing a surcharge on, or increasing the premium or deductible of professional liability insurance solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination.
- Defines “prohibited bases for discrimination” to include a healthcare provider offering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming healthcare, or care related to such services lawful in this state, but unlawful in another state, and legal or administrative action resulting in a conviction or disciplinary action taken in another state against a healthcare provider offering such care otherwise lawful in this state.
- Prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from providing such healthcare services, if those services are within the insured’s scope of practice and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from other services provided within the insured’s scope of practice.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs of approximately $60,000 in fiscal year (FY) 2023-24, $190,000 in FY 2024-25, and $61,000 in FY 2025-26 to the Department of Insurance (CDI) in staff workload to promulgate a medium-complexity rulemaking to interpret this bill’s provisions. CDI notes the bill, as drafted, is unclear and may result in litigation, since Proposition 103 (2018) allows insurers to increase premiums for healthcare providers that perform specified services when such an increase is related to the risk of loss (Insurance Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author notes approximately one in three women in this country has lost access to abortion after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, forcing patients to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. According to the author, “The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing California’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care.”
- Support and Opposition. This bill is co-sponsored by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX (ACOG) and California Medical Association. ACOG explains, “The current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services.” This bill is also supported by other healthcare provider groups, reproductive justice organizations, and the California Legislative Women’s Caucus.
This bill is opposed by the Right to Life League, which argues this bill “creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth in violation of the California Constitution.”
- Scope of the Problem. ACOG states:
According to recent research, physicians must often purchase costly abortion riders. Evidence suggests that the large premiums for abortion riders are not proportional to the true liability risk. In extreme cases, some insurance carriers have refused to issue coverage altogether to physicians providing abortions.
However, the Assembly Insurance Committee’s analysis of this bill notes “there is no clear data that was provided to the Committee to suggest that practitioners in California are not providing certain services because of the cost of medical malpractice insurance.” Additionally, CDI does not allow for rates that are excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory. This bill specifically prohibits an insurer from rescinding or increasing the cost of liability insurance for healthcare providers offering services such as abortion and gender-affirming care.
- Proposition 103 (1988). Proposition 103 requires the “prior approval” of CDI before insurance companies may implement property and casualty insurance rates. Thus, all insurance rates charged in this state are essentially overseen and approved by the Insurance Commissioner (IC). According to the Assembly Insurance Committee’s analysis of this bill:
The limits this bill places on how insurers can charge for medical malpractice insurance does not appear to directly violate [Proposition 103], but does closely challenge it. If this bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider amendments that clarify the [IC’s] authority and role to oversee rates, specifically as it relates to the prohibition on insurers from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 571
Author:(Petrie-Norris and Wicks) – As Amended Ver:March 9, 2023
SUBJECT: Medical malpractice insurance
KEY ISSUE: should health care providers be protected from malpractice insurance rate increases, and potential loss of coverage, when the provider’s practice area is no longer legal in other states?
SYNOPSIS
In the wake of the United States Supreme Court’s ruling that eliminated a constitutional right to an abortion, over a dozen states have moved to ban the procedure with nearly a dozen more seeking to enact new restrictions. Simultaneously, many of these same states are seeking to curtail a minor’s ability to receive essential gender-affirming health care. As a result, health care professionals in California are noting that the professional liability insurance premiums for professionals who provide these critical services are facing cost pressures. Additionally, these professionals fear losing their insurance should they face discipline resulting from another state’s laws restricting access to medical care that is legal in California. Accordingly, this measure seeks to prohibit an insurer from terminating professional liability insurance or refusing to issue or renew insurance as a result of a medical professional specified care including abortions and gender-affirming health care. The bill also limits premium increases as a result of a medical professional’s provision of care that is legal in California yet banned elsewhere.
This measure is sponsored by the California Medical Association and is supported by an array of health care professionals. The proponents of this measure note the risk that professionals, even those that only practice within California borders, face from the growing reach of anti-abortion and anti-trans laws appearing across the country. They contend that this measure will provide them with needed security and stability to continue to offer these critical health care services. This measure is opposed by the Right to Life League who somewhat perplexingly contend that this bill is unconstitutional. The opposition appears to believe that this bill would impact liability payments, something that the bill does not actually contemplate. The bill was previously heard and approved by the Assembly Committee on Insurance by a vote of ten to two.
SUMMARY: Prohibits an insurer from terminating professional liability insurance or refusing to issue or renew insurance as a result of a medical professional specified care, including abortion and gender-affirming health care. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an insurer from terminating professional liability insurance or refusing to issue or renew professional liability insurance for a health care provider in this state, solely based on any prohibited bases as specified in 4) below.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or instituting or increasing a deductible amount or other cost sharing payable by an insured, solely based on any prohibited bases as specified in 4) below.
- Prohibits an insurer providing professional liability insurance for health care providers from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if such services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for such damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
- Prohibits an insurer from discriminating against a health care provider related to professional liability insurance for any of the following:
- A health care provider offers or performs abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, that are lawful in this state, including, but not limited to, those that may be unlawful in another state;
- Another state’s laws create potential or actual liability for abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services offered or performed in this state; and
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services, as provided, are or would be lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.
- Limits the provisions of the bill to professional liability insurance marketed, offered, issued, amended, or renewed in this state for health care providers in this state.
- Defines the following terms:
- “Health care provider” means a person licensed under specified provisions of the Business and Professions Code to be regulated by a healing arts board within the Department of Consumer Affairs;
- “Offer or perform” means to offer, perform, provide, prescribe, dispense, furnish, or otherwise render health care items or services, as well as to aid or assist in the rendering of those items or services; and
- “Professional liability insurance” means insurance against liability for damages caused by any act or omission of a person licensed to provide health care services in rendering professional services within this state issued by any insurer, including, but not limited to, a joint underwriting association, cooperative corporation, or reciprocal or interinsurance exchange.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the position of the Insurance Commissioner and vests the Commissioner and the Department of Insurance with the ability to oversee and license entities selling insurance within this state. (Insurance Code Section 12900 et seq.)
- Prohibits an insurer that provides professional liability insurance for physicians and surgeons or dentists from increasing the premium for the insurance, impose a surcharge with respect to such insurance, or otherwise require additional compensation for such insurance, or institute or increase a deductible amount payable by the insured, because a notice of intention to commence an action has been issued unless a complaint has actually been served on the insured. (Insurance Code Section 11589 (a).)
- Defines liability insurance to include, but not be limited to, insurance coverage against legal liability arising from the rendering of professional services by an insured licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act. (Insurance Code Section 11580.01.)
- Provides, pursuant to Proposition 103, that no insurance rate is to be approved or remain in effect which is excessive, inadequate, unfairly discriminatory or otherwise in violation of existing provisions of the Insurance Code. (Insurance Code Section 1861.05.)
- Requires each insurer transacting insurance covering liability for malpractice of any person licensed under the Dental Practice Act, Medical Practice Act, or the State Bar Act to report to the Insurance Commissioner all of the following statistics, by profession and by medical specialty, upon request of the Commissioner:
- The total number of doctors or lawyers written during the immediately preceding calendar year;
- The total amount of premiums received from insureds, both written and earned (as reported in the annual statement), during the immediately preceding calendar year;
- The number of claims reported to the insurer for the first time separately by the year the claim occurred, and the number of claims reported closed during a previous calendar year which were reopened separately by the year the claim occurred;
- The total number of claims outstanding, together with the monetary amount reserved for loss and allocated loss expense, in the annual statement as of December 31 of the calendar year next preceding, separately stated by the year the claim occurred;
- The monetary amount paid on claims during the calendar year next preceding, to be reported separately by the year the claim occurred, with allocated loss expense paid, to be reported separately by the year the claim occurred;
- The number of claims closed without payment to the claimant during the calendar year next preceding, by the year the claim occurred, and the allocated loss expense paid thereon, separately by the year the claim occurred;
- The monetary amount reserved in the annual statement for the calendar year next preceding on claims incurred but not reported to the insurer;
- The number of lawsuits filed against the insurer’s insureds, and the number of doctors, included therein, during the calendar year next preceding, to be separately reported by the year the claim occurred; and
- A distribution by size of payment for those claims closed during the calendar year next preceding, showing the number of claims and total amount paid for each monetary category, as determined by the Commissioner. (Insurance Code Section 11555.2.)
- Prohibits the State of California from denying or interfering with a woman’s right to choose or obtain an abortion prior to viability of the fetus, or when the abortion is necessary to protect the life or health of the woman. (Health & Safety Code Section 123466.)
- Provides for the various healing arts professions that are to be regulated and licensed by the boards within the Department of Consumer Affairs. (Business and Professions Code Section 500 et seq.)
- Establishes various limits for compensation for noneconomic losses related to pain, suffering, inconvenience, physical impairment, disfigurement and other nonpecuniary damage stemming from an injury that occurred as a result of the professional negligence of a health care provider or health care institution. (Civil Code Section 3333.2 (a).)
- Provides that statements, writings, or benevolent gestures expressing sympathy, regret, a general sense of benevolence, or suggesting, reflecting, or accepting fault relating to the pain, suffering, or death of a person, or to an adverse patient safety event or unexpected health care outcome, in relation to an act or omission to act in the provision of or failure to provide health care, and made to that person or the family or representative of that person prior to the filing of a lawsuit or demand for arbitration, is confidential, privileged, protected, not subject to subpoena, discovery, or disclosure, and cannot be used or admitted into evidence in any civil, administrative, regulatory, licensing, or disciplinary board, agency, or body action or proceeding, and cannot be used or admitted in relation to any sanction, penalty, or other liability, as evidence of an admission of liability or for any other purpose, and all such communications, whether verbal, electronic, in writing, or in any other form, are also to be entitled to the privileges and protections specified in the Evidence Code. (Health and Safety Code Section 104340 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: As other states begin to interfere with the relationship between doctors and patients by limiting the availability of certain types of medical care, medical professionals in California are noting that it is becoming more difficult to obtain liability coverage should they perform similar services in this state, even though that medical care remains fully legal here. The author and proponents of this measure suggest that protections are needed so that California medical professionals can continue to perform abortions, provide gender-affirming care, and offer other sensitive health services without fear of significant financial impacts from rising insurance rates, or a complete loss of coverage. In support of the bill the author states:
In the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color.
Ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element to securing access to services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing California’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care.
AB 571 prohibits insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge to a healthcare provider for offering these services. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services, and will increase the number of licensed healthcare providers who are able to provide abortion and gender-affirming care in California.
A series of draconian laws in other states seek to limit medical professional’s ability to provide vital reproductive and gender-affirming healthcare. Since the United States Supreme Court eliminated the constitutional right to an abortion (Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Org. (2022) 141 S. Ct. 2619), 13 states have moved to effectively ban abortion, one state bans the procedure after six weeks, and another four ban the procedure between 15 and 20 weeks. (NY Times, Tracking the States Where Abortion Is Now Banned, (Apr. 2023.) available at: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/us/abortion-laws-roe-v-wade.html.) Another eight states have abortion restrictions or bans currently being evaluated by state courts. Abortion is not the only legitimate form of health care being limited by some state legislatures. Thirteen states have recently enacted restrictions on gender-affirming health care for minors. (Human Rights Campaign Foundation, Map: Attacks on Gender Affirming Care by State, (Apr. 2023) available at: https://www.hrc.org/resources/attacks-on-gender-affirming-care-by-state-map.) In several of these states it is not the person receiving care who “violates” the law but rather the medical professional providing the treatment.
Although California has become a safe haven for persons seeking medical treatment, the fact that medical professionals are targeted by other states can have implications in California. For example, should a California-based doctor perform an abortion for an out-of-state resident and subsequently be sued on the basis of another jurisdiction’s civil statutes that prohibit “aiding and abetting” a person in receiving an abortion, the actuarial tables that underpin most insurance rates would likely deem that doctor a greater financial risk when compared with their peers. Should the adverse decision subsequently cause that doctor’s malpractice insurance rates to increase, the doctor may find it difficult to continue to provide the abortion care that is legal in this state.
California-based doctors are likely to face similar concerns as states move to prohibit gender affirming health care. Last session, the Legislature passed SB 923 (Wiener) Chap. 822, Stats. 2022, which provided some protections for parents who bring their minor child to California to receive gender-affirming healthcare that is banned in their home state. Should another parent, or potentially another state’s government, try and take legal action against a doctor who provided the care in California, their insurance may also increase despite the fact that the care provided was wholly legal and provided in a manner that meets the doctors duty of care under the laws of this state.
This bill. Seeking to protect health care providers in California who offer care that may be prohibited in other states, this bill places limits on what professional liability insurers can do as a result of the professional’s line of work. This bill would prohibit an insurer from terminating or refusing to issue or renew insurance, or increasing premiums, simply because a medical professional provides abortions, contraception, or gender-affirming care. The bill also provides that should another state seek to take action against a health care provider for providing those services, California insurers cannot take adverse action against the health care provider. Finally, this bill defines relevant terms.
Provisions of this bill appear sufficiently narrow as to not interfere with insurance rate increases related to malpractice or other violations of the professional’s standard of care. As briefly noted above, insurance rates are set based on an individual insured’s risk profile. In the medical field this risk profile may include the nature of one’s practice and the associated risks, any prior instances of errors or malfeasance, and the general nature of potential liability facing the medical provider. Accordingly, should a medical provider have had a previous adverse action taken by a state regulator or been found liable for some form of professional malpractice it would be legitimate for an insurer to increase their insurance rates as, presumably, that provider does pose a legitimately greater liability risk to the insurer.
In the portion of this bill outlining what factors an insurer cannot use to deny or alter coverages, the language specifically notes that any protections in this bill are limited to actions conducted in a manner that is both, “lawful and consistent with the applicable standard of care in this state.” This condition appears to note that should an act constitute malpractice in this state then an insurer is free to increase rates. The limits only, and appropriately, apply to liability incurred due to other states attempts to limit medical freedom in a manner inconsistent with the laws of this state. Accordingly, this bill appears wholly appropriate.
The constitutional concerns raised by the opposition appear to be based on a misunderstanding about the scope of this bill. This measure is opposed by the Right to Life League who claim that the bill, “allows insurers to deny coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering prenatal and OB-GYN services, including childbirth and perinatal services.” Based on this contention, the opposition argues this bill is an unconstitutional violation of California Supreme Court precedent prohibiting unequal financial treatment for those receiving abortions and birthing services. (Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252.) While such a contention regarding the unequal financial treatment may be true under the law, the premise is based on the notion that this bill limits a medical provider’s liability should something go wrong during an abortion or childbirth. Such a notion wholly misunderstands the provisions of this bill. As discussed above, this bill does not impact liability or an insurer’s ability to increase rates should a medical professional commit malpractice or be disciplined by a state regulator for a legitimate violation of professional conduct. Indeed, this bill simply prevents insurance premiums from increasing because a provider is offering medical care that is lawful in California but has been prohibited in other states. Because nothing in this bill impacts liability or financial treatment of medical services, the opposition’s constitutional claims appear to be unfounded and should not be an impediment to this bill advancing through the legislative process.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is co-sponsored by the California Medical Association and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX and is supported by a broad array of health care providers from across California and pro-choice advocates. In support of the bill, the California Medical Association writes:
The California constitution protects the legal right to abortion care. But this right is meaningless without real access – and ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element in strengthening access to reproductive services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing the State’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services.
Additionally, Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California writes:
The current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these services. AB 571 prohibits insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge to a healthcare provider for offering these services. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services.
PPAC is committed to making sure that providers can offer critical health care services without being discriminated against for the type of care they provide and support policies that would expand the abortion workforce in California.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by the Right to Life League. In advance of their argument that this treats different classes of medical providers differently they note:
AB 571 would prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health care services, if those services are within the scope of the insured’s license and the policy would otherwise cover liability for damages arising from performing or rendering other professional services within the insured’s scope of license.
Accordingly, AB 571 creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth in violation of the California Constitution, pursuant to Committee to Defend Reproductive Rights v. Myers, 29 Cal.3d 252 (1981). In 1981, conservative forces in the state legislature sought to limit access to abortion services through various budget acts. In CDRR v. Myers, the California Supreme Court struck down the legislature’s ban on Medi-Cal funding of abortion.
To cure this unconstitutional, discriminatory oversight, the “prohibited bases for discrimination” in subsection Section 11589.1 (d) should be amended to prohibit an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering prenatal and
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX (sponsor)
California Medical Association (sponsor)
Access Reproductive Justice
American Nurses Association/California
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA)
California Women's Law Center
Essential Access Health
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Naral Pro-choice California
National Health Law Program
Nurses for Sexual & Reproductive Health
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Reproductive Health Access Project (RHAP)
San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Health Care
Women's Foundation California
Oppose
Right to Life League
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 12, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Lisa Calderon, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 571 (
Author:Petrie-Norris) – As Amended Ver:March 9, 2023
SUBJECT: Medical malpractice insurance
SUMMARY: Prohibits insurers from refusing to provide professional liability coverage to health care providers or from imposing a surcharge on health care providers, because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers solely based on any prohibited bases, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost solely based on any prohibited bases, as provided.
- Prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those health services if the services are within the scope of the insured’s license, as provided.
- Provides that prohibited bases for discrimination include all of the following:
- Offering or performing abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services that are lawful in this state;
- Where another state’s laws create potential or actual liability for the above mentioned services in this state; or
- Legal or administrative action taken in another state against a health care provider concerning abortion, contraception, gender-affirming health care, or care related to those services, results or resulted in a judgment, conviction, or disciplinary action against the provider, if such health care services would be lawful in this state.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Insurance Commissioner (Commissioner) as a statewide elected official responsible for administering and overseeing the California Department of Insurance (CDI).
- Regulates, generally, classes of insurance, including liability insurance.
- Defines liability insurance to include, but not be limited to, insurance coverage against legal liability arising from the rendering of professional services by an insured licensed pursuant to the provisions of the Medical Practice Act or the Osteopathic Initiative Act. (Insurance (Ins.) Code Section 11580.01)
- Provides that an insurer who provides professional liability insurance for physicians and surgeons shall not increase the premium for such insurance, impose a surcharge with respect to such insurance, or otherwise require additional compensation for such insurance, or institute or increase a deductible amount payable by the insured, because a notice of intention to commence an action for professional negligence has been filed, unless a complaint has been served on the physician or surgeon. (Ins. Code Section 11589)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. Patients have been forced to travel to neighboring states to receive reproductive care. With more states attempting to ban abortion, restrictions will likely affect more than 36 million women of reproductive age – disproportionally harming youth, low-income individuals, and communities of color.
Ensuring that providers are able to obtain professional liability insurance is a critical element to securing access to services. The Future of Abortion Council and many reproductive rights champions have identified access to professional liability insurance as one of the major obstacles to increasing California’s healthcare workforce providing abortion care and gender-affirming care.
AB 571 prohibits insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge to a healthcare provider for offering these services. AB 571 will reduce barriers otherwise capable, licensed, and willing healthcare providers face when trying to offer reproductive health services, and will increase the number of licensed healthcare providers who are able to provide abortion and gender-affirming care in California.
- Background and discussion. Limited research suggests that the cost of liability insurance for health care providers (i.e. medical malpractice insurance) can be a barrier to the ability for family physicians to provide low-risk abortion services like first-trimester aspiration (which is provided in an out-patient setting) and medication abortion.[1] However, there is no clear data that was provided to the Committee to suggest that practitioners in California are not providing certain services because of the cost of medical malpractice insurance. Additionally, the CDI does not allow for rates that are excessive, inadequate, or unfairly discriminatory. Therefore, the need for and effect of this bill are unclear.
Nevertheless, this State has made protecting access to abortion and other reproductive services a priority. Gaps in access to reproductive services disproportionally impact low-income individuals and communities of color.[2] Making it less cost prohibitive for practitioners to provide certain reproductive services could help to increase access.
- Concerns Related to Commissioner’s Authority and Proposition (Prop.) 103. Prop. 103, passed by the voters in November 1988, requires the "prior approval" of CDI before insurance companies can implement property and casualty insurance rates. Therefore, all insurance rates charged in this state are essentially overseen and approved by CDI and the Commissioner. The limits this bill places on how insurers can charge for medical malpractice insurance does not appear to directly violate Prop. 103, but does closely challenge it. If this bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider amendments that clarify the Commissioner’s authority and role to oversee rates, specifically as it relates to the prohibition on insurers from increasing premiums, imposing a surcharge or other additional compensation or cost, or increasing a deductible amount or other cost.
- Argument in Support. According to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, the sponsor of this bill:
The current difficulty some licensed providers have in securing professional liability insurance has had an impact on the number of otherwise eligible practitioners who could offer these desperately needed services. AB 571 addresses this important issue by prohibiting insurers from refusing to issue professional liability insurance to licensed healthcare practitioners solely because they offer abortion, contraception, or gender-affirming services, and additionally prohibits an insurer from charging an arbitrary fee or surcharge solely based on the offering of these services.
- Argument in Opposition. The Right to Life League opposes this bill, arguing that “AB 571 favors abortion services over birthing services… [and] creates unequal financial treatment of abortion and childbirth.”
- Double-referral. This bill has also been referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Access Reproductive Justice
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
American Nurses Association/California
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Medical Association
California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA)
Essential Access Health
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
NARAL Pro-choice California
National Health Law Program
Nurses for Sexual & Reproductive Health
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Reproductive Health Access Project (RHAP)
San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Health Care
Women's Foundation California
Opposition
Right to Life League
Analysis Prepared by: Claire Wendt / INS. / (916) 319-2086
“Medical liability insurance as a barrier to the provision of abortion services in family medicine,” Christine E. Dehlendorf and Kevin Grumbach, American Journal of Public Health (October 2008) https://ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/10.2105/AJPH.2008.136325 ↑
“Beyond the Numbers: Access to Reproductive Healthcare for Low-Income Women in Five Communities,” Kaiser Family Foundation (November 14, 2019) https://www.kff.org/report-section/beyond-the-numbers-access-to-reproductive-health-care-for-low-income-women-in-five-communities-executive-summary/ ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Insurance
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):