AB 572: Common interest developments: imposition of assessments.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-11
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-11: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 745, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would, with certain exceptions, prohibit an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, from imposing an increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 10% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would, with certain exceptions, prohibit an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, from imposing an increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 10% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would, with certain exceptions, prohibit an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, from imposing an increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 10% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or more than the percentage change in the cost of living, whichever is larger, not to exceed 10 percent, as specified. year.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would would, with certain exceptions, prohibit an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, from imposing an increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year, except as provided. year or more than the percentage change in the cost of living, whichever is larger, not to exceed 10 percent, as specified.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would prohibit the increase of an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, from imposing an increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year, except as provided.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would prohibit the increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year. year, except as provided.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates common interest developments, including the establishment and imposition of assessments. Existing law limits increases in regular assessments and the aggregate of special assessments that the board may impose in any fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, as specified.
This bill would prohibit the increase of a regular assessment on the owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)(1)(A)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, percentage change in the cost of living means the percentage change from April 1 of the prior year to April 1 of the current year in the regional Consumer Price Index for the region where the residential real property is located, as published by the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. If a regional index is not available, the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers for all items, as determined by the Department of Industrial Relations, shall apply.
(2)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to any of the following:
(A)A development where the percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing units exceeds the percentage required by an applicable zoning ordinance in effect at the time the development received final approval.
(B)A development that is located within a city, county, or city and county that does not have an applicable zoning ordinance requiring a percentage of deed-restricted affordable housing units and meet either of the following conditions:
(i)The percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 10 percent of the total number of units in the development at the time the development received final approval.
(ii)If the development met the requirements described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 65912.122 of the Government Code and was approved pursuant to Section 65912.124 of the Government Code, the percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 15 percent of the total number of units in the development at the time the development received final approval.
(C)A development of 20 units or fewer.
(d)For the purposes of this section, all of the following definitions apply:
(1)Affordable housing unit means a unit occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)Final approval has the same meaning as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (o) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code.
(3)Quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)(1)(A)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, percentage change in the cost of living means the percentage change from April 1 of the prior year to April 1 of the current year in the regional Consumer Price Index for the region where the residential real property is located, as published by the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. If a regional index is not available, the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers for all items, as determined by the Department of Industrial Relations, shall apply.
(2)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to any of the following:
(A)A development where the percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing units exceeds the percentage required by an applicable zoning ordinance in effect at the time the development received final approval.
(B)A development that is located within a city, county, or city and county that does not have an applicable zoning ordinance requiring a percentage of deed-restricted affordable housing units and meet either of the following conditions:
(i)The percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 10 percent of the total number of units in the development at the time the development received final approval.
(ii)If the development met the requirements described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 65912.122 of the Government Code and was approved pursuant to Section 65912.124 of the Government Code, the percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 15 percent of the total number of units in the development at the time the development received final approval.
(C)A development of 20 units or fewer.
(d)For the purposes of this section, all of the following definitions apply:
(1)Affordable housing unit means a unit occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)Final approval has the same meaning as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (o) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code.
(3)Quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)(1)(A)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment or that is greater than the percentage change in cost of living, whichever is larger. assessment.
(B)When calculating the imposition of a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit under this subdivision, the board shall not impose a regular assessment that exceeds 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.(C)(B)For purposes of this paragraph, percentage change in the cost of living means the percentage change from April 1 of the prior year to April 1 of the current year in the regional Consumer Price Index for the region where the residential real property is located, as published by the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. If a regional index is not available, the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers for all items, as determined by the Department of Industrial Relations, shall apply.
(2)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to a any of the following:
(A)A development where 30 percent or more the percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code. deed-restricted affordable housing units exceeds the percentage required by an applicable zoning ordinance in effect at the time the development received final approval.
(B)A development that is located within a city, county, or city and county that does not have an applicable zoning ordinance requiring a percentage of deed-restricted affordable housing units and meet either of the following conditions:
(i)The percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 10 percent of the total number of units in the development at the time the development received final approval.
(ii)If the development met the requirements described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 65912.122 of the Government Code and was approved pursuant to Section 65912.124 of the Government Code, the percentage of the units, exclusive of a managers unit or units, that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 15 percent of the total number of units in the development at the time the development received final approval.
(C)A development of 20 units or fewer.
(d)For the purposes of this section, quorum all of the following definitions apply:
(1)Affordable housing unit means a unit occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(2)Final approval has the same meaning as defined in clause (ii) of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (o) of Section 65589.5 of the Government Code.
(3)Quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)(1)(A)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment. assessment or that is greater than the percentage change in cost of living, whichever is larger.
(B)When calculating the imposition of a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit under this subdivision, the board shall not impose a regular assessment that exceeds 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
(C)For purposes of this paragraph, percentage change in the cost of living means the percentage change from April 1 of the prior year to April 1 of the current year in the regional Consumer Price Index for the region where the residential real property is located, as published by the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. If a regional index is not available, the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers for all items, as determined by the Department of Industrial Relations, shall apply.
(2)For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to a development where 100 30 percent or more of the units units, exclusive of a managers unit or units units, are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)For the purposes of this section, quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
(2)Notwithstanding For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to a development where 100 percent of the units exclusive of a managers unit or units are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)For the purposes of this section, quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment. Notwithstanding
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments.
(3)This subdivision does not apply to a development where 100 percent of the units exclusive of a managers unit or units are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)For the purposes of this section, quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
(a)Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the associations preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c)Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment. Notwithstanding any other law, the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments.
(c)(d)For the purposes of this section, quorum means more than 50 percent of the members.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 11, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 745, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 11, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 59. Noes 14. Page 3483.). |
| Sep 13, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 29. Noes 8. Page 2720.). |
| Sep 11, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 8, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 10, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 6, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (July 6). |
| Jun 21, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on HOUSING and JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 55. Noes 18. Page 2121.) |
| May 26, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1850.) |
| May 1, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (April 26). |
| Apr 6, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Apr 5, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on H. & C.D. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 11. |
| Feb 8, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2023 | AB 572 Haney Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB572 Haney et al. By Skinner | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 6, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
|
| Jun 1, 2023 | AB 572 Haney Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Alliance For Retired Americans | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Community Managers | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Local Housing Finance Agencies | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Against | |
| California Bankers Association | ** Against | |
| California Building Industry Alliance | ** Against | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Community Banking Network | ** Against | |
| California Credit Union League | ** Against | |
| California Mortgage Bankers Association | ** Against | |
| California Reinvestment Coalition | ** Support | |
| Center for California Homeowner Association Law | ** Against | |
| Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee | ** Against | |
| Council of Community Housing Organizations, San Francisco | ** Support | |
| Devine & Gong, Inc. | ** Support | |
| East Bay YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Generation Housing | ** Support | |
| Grow the Richmond | ** Support | |
| Homeownership San Francisco | ** Support | |
| Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County | ** Support | |
| How to ADU | ** Support | |
| Mission Economic Development Agency | ** Support | |
| Mountain View YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Napa-Solano for Everyone | ** Support | |
| Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California | ** Support | |
| Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California | ** Support | |
| Northern Neighbors | ** Support | |
| Peninsula for Everyone | ** Support | |
| People For Housing Orange County | ** Support | |
| Progress Noe Valley | ** Support | |
| san francisco housing development corporation | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Yimby | ** Support | |
| San Luis Obispo Yimby | ** Support | |
| Santa Cruz Yimby | ** Support | |
| Santa Rosa Yimby | ** Support | |
| South Bay Yimby | ** Support | |
| Southside Forward | ** Support | |
| Ventura County YIMBY | ** Support | |
| Yimby Action | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 572
Author:(Haney)
As Amended Ver:September 08, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in certain homeowners associations (HOAs) at 5% plus the percentage change in cost of living, not to exceed 10% greater than the preceding regular assessment, for certain HOAs that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2025.
Senate Amendments:
- Modify the cap to be 5% plus the percentage change in cost of living, not to exceed 10% greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Define "percentage change in cost of living" to mean the percentage change from April 1 of the prior year to April 1 of the current year in the regional Consumer Price Index (CPI) for the region where the property is located, as published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics. If a regional index is not available, provides that the California CPI for All Urban Consumers for all items shall apply.
- Delay the implementation of the bill to apply to HOAs that record an original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, rather than January 1, 2024.
- Exempt the following types of developments from the bill:
- A development where the percentage of affordable units exceeds the percentage required by an applicable inclusionary zoning ordinance in effect at the time the development received final approval.
- A development located in a city or county without an inclusionary zoning ordinance that meets either of the following conditions:
- The percentage of affordable units in the development exceeds 10% at the time it received final approval.
- If the development conforms to the requirements for streamlined approval in the mixed-income provisions of the Affordable Housing and High Road Jobs Act of 2022 (AB 2011 (Wicks), Chapter 647, Statutes of 2022), and the percentage of affordable units in the development exceeds 15% at the time it received final approval.
- A development of 20 units or fewer.
- Add definitions and cross-references.
COMMENTS
Background on CIDs: CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California's housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35% of the state's total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code Section 4000 et seq.) as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership, which have a number of powers and duties, including determining the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. Many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs: Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100% affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units typically operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are usually protected for 55 years. These units are targeted to lower income and moderate-income households making up to 120% of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e. Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new BMR unit purchasers, they must meet the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new BMR buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner's resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
HOA Budgets and Assessments: HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
Increases in regular assessments and special assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5605. A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20% over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year's assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5610 and do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or that otherwise could not have been anticipated.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations call "unequal access to common services provided by the HOA" (10 CCR Section 2792.16). These are called variable assessments. According to DRE's "Operating Cost Manual for Homeowners Associations" section on variable assessments:
Variable prorations should be employed only when services are provided to units in unequal proportions. DRE regulations allow the use of variable assessments against units only if one unit will derive as much as 10% more than another unit in the value of common goods and services supplied by the association. Examples of services provided in unequal proportions directly to units are insurance, domestic water and gas, if applicable, and exterior and roof maintenance. […] In most instances, however, variable proration is not considered preferable to equal proration if differential in the level of services supplied by the association to the units is less than 20%. Variable assessments should be used when the differential exceeds 20%.
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in certain CIDs created after January 1, 2025 where BMR units are present in the development at specified ratios. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing future boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill's cap.
Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures: Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide a longer time. Failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner's property through foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner's property, which may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, an HOA may not foreclose if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney's fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose. An owner may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment, and the board must meet with that owner to discuss the payment plan, but is not required to accept the payment plan.
Prospective: This bill would impose the 5% plus CPI (up to 10% max) increase cap on regular assessments for certain HOAs with BMR units where the original declaration to DRE is recorded on or after January 1, 2025. The bill would also explicitly authorize the establishment of variable assessment rates in future CIDs based on the presence of BMR units. The effect of making the bill prospective – only applying to newly created CIDs – is that all owners who purchase homes in the development will have the opportunity to review the assessment rate schedule laid out in the governing documents and be informed that there will be more modest rates of increases on the BMR units in the community, or if there will be variable assessments at the outset. The growth in the actual gap between assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the development is completed and units are for sale, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners without a vote of membership (20%).
Civil Code Section 5975 provides that CC&Rs are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA. The statutory presumption of reasonableness requires that CC&Rs be enforced "unless they are wholly arbitrary, violate a fundamental public policy, or impose a burden on the use of affected land that far outweighs any benefit." (Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development (US), LLC (2012) 55 Cal.4th 223, 239; Nahrstedt v. Lakeside Village Condominium Assn. (1994) 8 Cal.4th, 361, 382.) In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing as a matter of public policy that assessments on certain BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in future CIDs.
According to the Author
"The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people's credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes."
Arguments in Support
Supporters, including the Community Reinvestment Coalition, YIMBY Action, and HomeownershipSF, state that increases in HOA dues have outpaced increases in income for many BMR owners, putting them at risk of default or foreclosure. This undermines the promise of financial security and housing stability made to low- and moderate-income homeowners who are able to purchase BMR units. In addition, supporters point out that BMR units with higher HOA dues can sit on the market for long periods of time, undermining the goals of the program during the statewide housing crisis. Income-eligible families are concerned they will not be able to afford large increases in HOA dues year over year.
Arguments in Opposition
According to the Community Associations Institute's California Legislative Action Committee, "While AB 572 has been amended to only impact new associations created after January 1, 202[5], it would still impose disproportionate financial burdens on homeowners who cannot afford to subsidize others and would create inequities and divisions within the community. AB 572 would also undermine the ability for associations to raise the necessary funds to maintain the community."
FISCAL COMMENTS
None.
VOTES:
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 5-1-2
YES: Wicks, Wendy Carrillo, Gabriel, Kalra, Quirk-Silva
NO: Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Joe Patterson, Ward
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 55-18-7
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gabriel, Garcia, Hart, Irwin, Muratsuchi, Soria, Wilson
UPDATED
VERSION: September 08, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0002318
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 572 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 572
Author: Haney (D), et al.
Amended: 9/8/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 7-2, 6/20/23
AYES: Wiener, Blakespear, Cortese, McGuire, Padilla, Skinner, Wahab
NOES: Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Caballero, Umberg
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-2, 7/6/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Stern, Wiener
NOES: Wilk, Niello
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 55-18, 6/1/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Common interest developments: imposition of assessments
SOURCE: Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation
DIGEST:
This bill caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs), as specified, at 5% plus the percentage change in the cost of living—not to exceed 10%—greater than the preceding regular assessment, for HOAs that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2025.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/8/23 make several changes to address opposition and implementation concerns, including: changing the calculation of annual assessment caps to align with existing departmental practices; and further restricting developments that can utilize new provisions, as specified, such as parks with fewer than 20 units or where deed-restricted units exceed local inclusionary requirements.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, which provides rules and regulations governing the operation of residential common interest developments (CIDs) and the rights and responsibilities of HOAs and HOA members.
- Provides that for any conflict between the law and HOA governing documents, the law prevails over the governing documents.
- Requires the owner of a separate interest to provide a prospective purchaser a written statement, as specified, from an authorized HOA representative with the amount of the HOA’s current regular and special assessments and fees, any assessments levied upon the owner’s interest in the CID that are unpaid on the date of the statement, and any monetary fines or penalties levied upon the owner’s interest and unpaid on the date of the statement.
- Requires a HOA to distribute an annual budget report 30 to 90 days before the end of its fiscal year, and requires the annual budget report to include certain specified information, unless the governing documents impose more stringent standards.
- Requires an HOA to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the Davis-Stirling Act, and prohibits a HOA from imposing or collecting an assessment or a fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied.
- Prohibits an HOA board from imposing annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year unless the board has complied with the annual budget requirements in 1) with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members at a member meeting or election.
- Authorizes an HOA board, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, to impose a regular assessment up to 20% greater than the regular assessment for the HOA’s preceding fiscal year. Prohibits a board from imposing regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s regular assessment, or imposing special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without the approval of a majority of a quorum of the members at a member meeting or election.
- Defines “quorum” for purposes of 6) and 7) above to mean more than 50% of the members.
- Requires, via Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations, that governing instruments for CIDs provide for a variety of items, including procedures for calculating and collecting regular assessments from owners, and procedures for establishing and collecting special assessments for capital improvements or for other purposes.
- Requires, via DRE regulations, regular assessments to ordinarily be levied against each owner according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments. In the case of a subdivision offering in which it is reasonable to anticipate that any owner will derive as much as 10% more than any other owner in the value of common services supplied by the HOA, the assessment against each owner may be determined according to a formula or schedule under which the assessments against the various subdivision interests bear a relationship which is equitably proportionate to the value of the common services furnished to the respective interests.
- Provides that regular and special assessments are delinquent 15 days after they become due, unless the declaration provides a longer time period. If an assessment is delinquent, the HOA may recover, as specified, reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, a late charge, and interest on all sums imposed.
- Requires an HOA to notify the owner of record in writing, as specified, by certified mail at least 30 days prior to recording a lien upon the separate interest of the owner of record to collect a past-due debt under 11).
- Allows an owner to submit a written request to meet with the board to discuss a payment plan for past-due debt, and requires the board to meet with the owner pursuant to specified timelines. Requires the HOA to provide owners the standards for payment plans, as specified, if any exist.
- Requires, prior to initiating a foreclosure on an owner’s separate interest, the HOA offer the owner and, if so requested by the owner, participate in dispute resolution, as specified. The board must approve a decision to initiate a foreclosure of a lien for delinquent assessments by a majority vote of the directors in an executive session.
- Prohibits an HOA that seeks to collect delinquent regular or special assessments of an amount less than $1,800 from collecting that debt through judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, but allows the HOA to attempt to collect or secure that debt by a civil action in small claims court, by recording a lien on the owner’s separate interest upon which the HOA can foreclose after the debt reaches or exceeds $1,800 or the debt is more than 12 months delinquent, or any other manner provided by law.
- Provides that the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA.
This bill:
- Prohibits HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2025, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 8%, greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2025 to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts the following developments from 1) and 2) above:
- Where deed-restricted affordable housing units exceeds the percentage required in an applicable zoning ordinance in effect at the time the development received final approval.
- Located within a city, county, or county and city that does not have an applicable zoning ordinance requiring a percentage of deed-restricted affordable housing units and meets either of the following conditions:
- The percentage of units that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 10% of the total units when the development received final approval.; or
- If the development meets specified requirements, the percentage of units that are deed-restricted affordable housing exceeds 15% of the total units when the development received final approval.
- 20 units or fewer.
Background
CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California’s housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of five million housing units, or about 35% of the state’s total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership, which have a number of powers and duties, including determining the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. Many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
Comments
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.”
- Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs. Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100% affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are usually protected for 55 years. Affordable ownership units are targeted to lower income and moderate-income households, making up to 120% of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e., Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new Below Market Rate (BMR) unit purchasers, they must meet the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new BMR buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner’s resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
- HOA Budgets and Assessments. HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20% over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or that otherwise could not have been anticipated.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what DRE regulations call "unequal access to common services provided by the HOA". These are called variable assessments.
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in CIDs created after January 1, 2025 where BMR units are present in the development, as specified. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing future boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill’s cap.
- Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures. Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide a longer time. Failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner’s property through foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner’s property, which may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, an HOA may not foreclose if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney’s fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose. An owner may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment, and the board must meet with that owner to discuss the payment plan, but is not required to accept the payment plan.
- Prospective. This bill imposes a 5% increase cap (plus the percentage change in the cost of living, not to exceed 8%) on regular assessments for any HOA with BMR units where the original declaration to DRE is recorded on or after January 1, 2025. This bill also explicitly authorizes the establishment of variable assessment rates in future CIDs based on the presence of BMR units. The effect of making the bill prospective – only applying to newly created CIDs – is that all owners who purchase homes in the development will have the opportunity to review the assessment rate schedule laid out in the governing documents and be informed that there will be more modest rates of increases on the BMR units in the community, or if there will be variable assessments at the outset. The growth in the actual gap between assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the development is completed and units are for sale, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners without a vote of membership (20%).
CC&Rs are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA.
In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing, as a matter of public policy, that assessments on BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in all future CIDs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/8/23)
Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California (co-source)
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation (co-source)
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Reinvestment Coalition
Council of Community Housing Organizations, San Francisco
Devine & Gong, Inc.
East Bay YIMBY
Generation Housing
Grow the Richmond
Homeownership San Francisco
Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County
How To ADU
Mission Economic Development Agency
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Ventura County YIMBY
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/8/23)
California Building Industry Association
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Building Industry Association (CBIA) writes in opposition stating “…if everyone does not pay their fair share, everyone loses.” The Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee also writes in opposition, stating that the bill would “…impose disproportionate financial burdens on homeowners who cannot afford to subsidize others and would create inequities and division within the community.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 55-18, 6/1/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gabriel, Garcia, Hart, Irwin, Muratsuchi, Soria, Wilson
Prepared by: Mehgie Tabar / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
9/11/23 12:00:21
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 572 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 572
Author: Haney (D)
Amended: 7/10/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 7-2, 6/20/23
AYES: Wiener, Blakespear, Cortese, McGuire, Padilla, Skinner, Wahab
NOES: Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Caballero, Umberg
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-2, 7/6/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Stern, Wiener
NOES: Wilk, Niello
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 55-18, 6/1/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Common interest developments: imposition of assessments
SOURCE: Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation
DIGEST:
This bill caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs) at 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment, for HOAs that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Davis-Stirling CID Act, which provides rules and regulations governing the operation of residential CIDs and the rights and responsibilities of HOAs and HOA members.
- Provides that for any conflict between the law and HOA governing documents, the law prevails over the governing documents.
- Requires the owner of a separate interest to provide a prospective purchaser a written statement, as specified, from an authorized HOA representative with the amount of the HOA’s current regular and special assessments and fees, any assessments levied upon the owner’s interest in the CID that are unpaid on the date of the statement, and any monetary fines or penalties levied upon the owner’s interest and unpaid on the date of the statement.
- Requires a HOA to distribute an annual budget report 30 to 90 days before the end of its fiscal year, and requires the annual budget report to include certain specified information, unless the governing documents impose more stringent standards.
- Requires an HOA to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the Davis-Stirling Act, and prohibits a HOA from imposing or collecting an assessment or a fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied.
- Prohibits an HOA board from imposing annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year unless the board has complied with the annual budget requirements in 1) with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members at a member meeting or election.
- Authorizes an HOA board, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, to impose a regular assessment up to 20% greater than the regular assessment for the HOA’s preceding fiscal year. Prohibits a board from imposing regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s regular assessment, or imposing special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without the approval of a majority of a quorum of the members at a member meeting or election.
- Defines “quorum” for purposes of 6) and 7) above to mean more than 50% of the members.
- Requires, via Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations, that governing instruments for CIDs provide for a variety of items, including procedures for calculating and collecting regular assessments from owners, and procedures for establishing and collecting special assessments for capital improvements or for other purposes.
- Requires, via DRE regulations, regular assessments to ordinarily be levied against each owner according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments. In the case of a subdivision offering in which it is reasonable to anticipate that any owner will derive as much as 10% more than any other owner in the value of common services supplied by the HOA, the assessment against each owner may be determined according to a formula or schedule under which the assessments against the various subdivision interests bear a relationship which is equitably proportionate to the value of the common services furnished to the respective interests.
- Provides that regular and special assessments are delinquent 15 days after they become due, unless the declaration provides a longer time period. If an assessment is delinquent, the HOA may recover, as specified, reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, a late charge, and interest on all sums imposed.
- Requires an HOA to notify the owner of record in writing, as specified, by certified mail at least 30 days prior to recording a lien upon the separate interest of the owner of record to collect a past-due debt under 11).
- Allows an owner to submit a written request to meet with the board to discuss a payment plan for past-due debt, and requires the board to meet with the owner pursuant to specified timelines. Requires the HOA to provide owners the standards for payment plans, as specified, if any exist.
- Requires, prior to initiating a foreclosure on an owner’s separate interest, the HOA offer the owner and, if so requested by the owner, participate in dispute resolution, as specified. The board must approve a decision to initiate a foreclosure of a lien for delinquent assessments by a majority vote of the directors in an executive session.
- Prohibits an HOA that seeks to collect delinquent regular or special assessments of an amount less than $1,800 from collecting that debt through judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, but allows the HOA to attempt to collect or secure that debt by a civil action in small claims court, by recording a lien on the owner’s separate interest upon which the HOA can foreclose after the debt reaches or exceeds $1,800 or the debt is more than 12 months delinquent, or any other manner provided by law.
- Provides that the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA.
This bill:
- Prohibits HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment, or that is greater than the percentage change in cost of living, whichever is larger, but to not exceed 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024 to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts developments with 30% or more of units available to lower income and moderate-income households from 1) and 2) above.
Background
CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California’s housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35% of the state’s total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership, which have a number of powers and duties, including determining the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. Many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
Comments
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.”
- Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs. Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100% affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are usually protected for 55 years. Affordable ownership units are targeted to lower income and moderate-income households, making up to 120% of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e., Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new Below Market Rate (BMR) unit purchasers, they must meet the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new BMR buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner’s resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
- HOA Budgets and Assessments. HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20% over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or that otherwise could not have been anticipated.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what DRE regulations call "unequal access to common services provided by the HOA". These are called variable assessments.
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in CIDs created after January 1, 2024 where BMR units are present in the development. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing future boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill’s cap.
- Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures. Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide a longer time. Failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner’s property through foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner’s property, which may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, an HOA may not foreclose if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney’s fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose. An owner may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment, and the board must meet with that owner to discuss the payment plan, but is not required to accept the payment plan.
- Prospective. This bill imposes the 5% increase cap on regular assessments for any HOA with BMR units where the original declaration to DRE is recorded on or after January 1, 2024. The bill also explicitly authorizes the establishment of variable assessment rates in future CIDs based on the presence of BMR units. The effect of making the bill prospective – only applying to newly created CIDs – is that all owners who purchase homes in the development will have the opportunity to review the assessment rate schedule laid out in the governing documents and be informed that there will be more modest rates of increases on the BMR units in the community, or if there will be variable assessments at the outset. The growth in the actual gap between assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the development is completed and units are for sale, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners without a vote of membership (20%).
CC&Rs are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA.
In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing, as a matter of public policy, that assessments on BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in all future CIDs.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 648 (Valencia, 2023) authorizes an HOA to hold board meetings or member meetings entirely by teleconference without any physical location if certain conditions are met. This bill passed the Senate Housing Committee on a vote of 11-0.
AB 1458 (Ta, 2023) authorizes a lower quorum requirement for HOA elections of directors under specified circumstances. The bill is in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 7/12/23)
Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California (co-source)
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation (co-source)
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Reinvestment Coalition
Council of Community Housing Organizations, San Francisco
Devine & Gong, Inc.
East Bay YIMBY
Generation Housing
Grow the Richmond
Homeownership San Francisco
Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County
How to ADU
Mission Economic Development Agency
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Ventura County YIMBY
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION: (Verified 7/12/23)
California Building Industry Association
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Building Industry Association (CBIA) writes in opposition stating “…if everyone does not pay their fair share, everyone loses.” The Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee also writes in opposition, stating that the bill would “…impose disproportionate financial burdens on homeowners who cannot afford to subsidize others and would create inequities and division within the community.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 55-18, 6/1/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Holden, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gabriel, Garcia, Hart, Irwin, Muratsuchi, Soria, Wilson
Prepared by: Mehgie Tabar / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
7/12/23 16:02:53
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 572 (Author:Haney)
Version: May 26, 2023
Hearing Date: July 6, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Common interest developments: imposition of assessments
DIGEST
This bill caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs) at 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment, for HOAs that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Common interest development (CID) communities are, with rare exceptions, managed by a homeowners association (HOA) which essentially acts as a mini-government. Each property owner within the CID is a member of the HOA and the membership elects the HOA’s board of directors, which is responsible for making key decisions about the CID community on behalf of everyone, including the annual assessments, which are like taxes that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. If members do not pay their assessments in full or on time the board has the power to fine the members and, if necessary, the power to foreclose upon the offending member’s property. According to the proponents, this bill is intended to address an issue that has been repeatedly brought to them as a major problem – high HOA fees for below market rate (BMR) homeowners and how this can leads to a foreclose on their homes as the increases in HOA fees can significantly outpace the income increases for many BMR homeowners.
The bill is sponsored by the Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California and the San Francisco Housing Development Corporation. The bill is supported by various local organizations supporting housing policies. The bill is opposed by organizations representing HOAs, HOA homeowners, retired Californians, and building developers and one individual. The bill passed the Senate Housing Committee on a vote of 7 to 2.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes, within the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential common interest development (CID) and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members. (Civ. Code § 4000 et seq.)
- Requires an HOA to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the Davis-Stirling Act, and prohibits an HOA from imposing or collecting an assessment or a fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied. (Civ. Code §5600)
- Requires the owner of a separate interest to provide a prospective purchaser a written statement from an authorized HOA representative with the amount of the HOA’s current regular and special assessments and fees, any assessments levied upon the owner’s interest in the CID that are unpaid on the date of the statement, and any monetary fines or penalties levied upon the owner’s interest and unpaid on the date of the statement. The statement must also include any change in the HOA’s regular and special assessments and fees that have been approved by the board but have not become due and payable yet. The statement must be provided to the prospective purchaser as soon as practicable before the transfer of title or execution of a sales contract. (Civ. Code §4525(a)(4))
- Prohibits an HOA board from imposing annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year unless the board has complied with the annual budget requirements with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members at a member meeting or election. (Civ. Code § 5605(a); § 5300(a)-(b)).)
- Authorizes an HOA board, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, to impose a regular assessment up to 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the HOA’s preceding fiscal year. (Civ. Code § 5605(b).)
- Prohibits a board from imposing regular assessments over 20 percent higher than the preceding year’s regular assessment, or imposing special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without the approval of a majority of a quorum of the members at a member meeting or election. (Civ. Code § 5605(b).)
- Defines “quorum” for purposes of 5) and 6), above, to mean more than 50 percent of the members. (Civ. Code § 5605(c).)
- Requires, under regulations adopted by the Department of Real Estate (DRE), that governing instruments for CIDs provide for a variety of items, including:
- procedures for calculating and collecting regular assessments from owners to defray expenses attributable to the ownership, operation, or furnishing of common interests or to the enjoyment of mutual and reciprocal rights of use; and
- procedures for establishing and collecting special assessments for capital improvements or for other purposes. (10 Cal. Code Reg. § 2792.8(a)(4)-(5).)
- Requires, under DRE regulations, that regular assessments are ordinarily to be levied against each owner according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments. In the case of a subdivision offering in which it is reasonable to anticipate that any owner will derive as much as 10 percent more than any other owner in the value of common services supplied by the HOA, the assessment against each owner may be determined according to a formula or schedule under which the assessments against the various subdivision interests bear a relationship which is equitably proportionate to the value of the common services furnished to the respective interests. (Id. § 2792.16)
- Provides that regular and special assessments are delinquent 15 days after they become due, unless the declaration provides a longer time period. If an assessment is delinquent, the HOA may recover all of the following:
- reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, including reasonable attorney’s fees;
- a late charge not exceeding 10 percent of the delinquent assessment or $10, whichever is greater, unless the declaration specifies a late charge in a smaller amount; and
- interest on all sums imposed at an annual interest rate not to exceed 12 percent, commencing 30 days after the assessment becomes due, unless the declaration specifies the recovery of interest at a lesser rate. (Civ. Code § 5650(b).)
- Requires an HOA to notify the owner of record in writing by certified mail at least 30 days prior to recording a lien upon the separate interest of the owner of record to collect a past-due debt under 10), above. The notice must include the following information:
- a general description of the collection and lien enforcement procedures of the HOA and the method and calculation of the amount, and other specified notices;
- an itemized statement of the charges owed by the owner, including the amount of any delinquent assessments, the fees and reasonable costs of collection, reasonable attorney’s fees, any late charges, and interest, if any;
- the right to request a meeting with the board to discuss a payment plan for the debt; and
- other statements and rights of the owner. (Civ. Code § 5660.)
- Prior to initiating a foreclosure on an owner’s separate interest, the HOA must offer the owner and, if so requested by the owner, participate in dispute resolution pursuant to the HOA’s meet and confer program or other alternative dispute resolution as required by law. The board must approve a decision to initiate a foreclosure of a lien for delinquent assessments by a majority vote of the directors in an executive session. (Civ. Code § 5705.)
- Prohibits an HOA that seeks to collect delinquent regular or special assessments of an amount less than $1,800 from collecting that debt through judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, but allows the HOA to attempt to collect or secure that debt by a civil action in small claims court, by recording a lien on the owner’s separate interest upon which the HOA can foreclose after the debt reaches or exceeds $1,800 or the debt is more than 12 months delinquent, or any other manner provided by law. (Civ. Code § 5720.)
- Provides that the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA. (Civ. Code § 5975.)
This bill:
- Prohibits HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024 to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts from these provisions a development where 100 percent of the units, exclusive of a manager’s unit or units, are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
The Below Market Rate (BMR) Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.
- Background on HOAs
CIDs are self-governing groups of dwellings that share common spaces and amenities. They come in a wide variety of physical layouts: condominium complexes, apartment buildings, and neighborhoods of detached, single-family residences, for example. Units within common housing developments currently account for approximately a quarter of the state’s overall housing stock, meaning that the laws governing such developments have a large impact on the population. In California, CIDs are governed by the Davis-Stirling Act. (Civ. Code §§ 4000-6150.)
The Davis-Stirling Act sets forth a system for CID self-governance. The owners of the separate properties within the community are the members of the HOA. HOA members vote for the board of directors of the association that oversees operation of the community. An HOA board has a number of duties and powers. The board manages the community, frequently by hiring an individual or entity to do so on its behalf. The board determines the annual assessments – much like taxes – that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. The board enforces the community rules and can propose as well as make changes to those rules. If members do not pay their assessments in full or on time, or if members violate the community rules, the board has the power to fine the members and, if necessary, the power to foreclose upon the offending member’s property. This combination of responsibilities and authority has led multiple courts to observe that HOAs function in many ways almost “as a second municipal government, regulating many aspects of [the homeowners’] daily lives.” (Villa Milano Homeowners Ass’n v. Il Davorge (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 819, 836. Internal citations omitted.)
The Senate Housing Committee analysis notes:
There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California’s housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35% of the state’s total housing stock.[1]
HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, such as maintenance and repair, amenities, shared services, taxes, insurance the HOA is required to purchase, and other general operating expenses. Under existing law there are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
A board must adopt a budget for the year in order to increase a regular assessment, and existing law caps regular assessments at up to 20 percent over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards are prohibited from imposing regular assessments over 20 percent higher than the preceding year’s assessment, or imposing special assessments that, in the aggregate, exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, unless they get approval of a majority of a quorum of the members of the HOA to impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments can only be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, necessary to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or necessary to repair or maintain CID property that could not have been reasonably foreseen by the board in the annual budget preparation. (Civ. Code § 5610.) In the latter circumstance, the board must pass a resolution containing findings as to why the extraordinary expense is necessary and why it was not anticipated during the budgeting process, and must distribute the resolution to members along with the notice of increased assessment.
Assessments can be equally assessed among owners or, in some instances, differently depending on what DRE regulations refer to as “unequal access to common services provided by the HOA.” (10 Cal. Code Reg. § 2792.16.) These types of assessments are called variable assessments. According to DRE’s “Operating Cost Manual for Homeowners Associations” section on variable assessments:
Equal proration involves the simple process of dividing the total costs of a budget item by the number of units in the subdivision. Variable prorations entail the use of a factor or factors that differ from one unit to the next, e.g., square footage of floor space. Equal assessments should be used wherever reasonably equitable, since variable proration can be a complicated and controversial process.
Variable prorations should be employed only when services are provided to units in unequal proportions. DRE regulations allow the use of variable assessments against units only if one unit will derive as much as 10 percent more than another unit in the value of common goods and services supplied by the association. Examples of services provided in unequal proportions directly to units are insurance, domestic water and gas, if applicable, and exterior and roof maintenance. […] In most instances, however, variable proration is not considered preferable to equal proration if differential in the level of services supplied by the association to the units is less than 20 percent. Variable assessments should be used when the differential exceeds 20 percent.[2]
- This bill seeks to address the issue of high HOA fees for below market rate (BMR) homeowners by placing a 5 percent cap on HOA assessments for BMR homeowners
The proponents of the bill note that many cities across the state have created inclusionary housing programs that require private developers to provide a percentage of affordable homes sold at below market rate value due to the importance of homeownership as a means to create intergenerational wealth for low-income and BIPOC families. These BMR homeownership programs are aimed at first-time homebuyers who are low and moderate income, and are usually condos in mixed-income buildings, many with monthly Homeowners Association (HOA) fees. Low-income, first-time buyers must meet various qualifications and then they are entered into a lottery system to purchase a home. The proponents of the bill argue that while BMR ownership programs are specifically designed to make the initial cost of homeownership more affordable, the increases in HOA fees can significantly outpace the income increases for many BMR homeowners. Since current law sets the maximum HOA fee increase at 20percent for all homeowners regardless of income level, after only a few years of large increases, the HOA fees of a BMR homeowners can increase beyond the original mortgage of a house, pushing them toward the risk of foreclosure.
Home foreclosure can have devastating impacts on a person’s credit score. Borrowers with a good credit score can lose 100 points or more on their score if a lender forecloses on their home.[3] After a foreclosure it can take up to seven years to rebuild your credit score. Additionally, credit scores are used for housing applications, auto loans, insurance coverage, and more. The Federal Housing Administration Home Loan program requires a three-year waiting period after a foreclosure before someone can apply for a loan, while Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac can require as much as seven years. A low-income homeowner whose home is foreclosed on may not only lose the opportunity to own a home, but it can send them down a path of decades of debt and other financial hardship.
The proponents of the bill also argue that the potential for large increases of HOA fees also discourages low-income buyers from purchasing BMR units, leading to vacancies and upending the potential positive impact of the BMR homeownership program. This only worsens California’s housing crisis.
In response to this issue, the bill seeks to prohibit HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in their governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a BMR unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment. The bill provides an exception to these provisions for a development where 100 percent of the units, exclusive of a manager’s unit or units, are occupied by, or available at, affordable housing cost to lower income and moderate-income households. The bill’s provisions only apply to regular assessments and does not impact special assessments or emergency assessments. The author amended this bill in the Assembly to makes it provisions only apply prospectively. This change led to several groups that were in opposition, such as the California Association of Realtors and the California Bankers Association, to change their position to neutral.
- Remaining opposition concerns
- The bill shifts burden on HOA assessments to market rate homeowners
The California Alliance for Retired Americans, the Center for California Homeowner Association Law, and the Community Associations Institute’s California Legislative Action Committee write in opposition to the bill all raising the same concern—that the bill shifts the costs of HOA assessments onto market rate homeowners. They state that while sympathetic to the issue the bill is trying to address, the solution is not to place more cost burdens on market rate homeowners. They note that there is no evidence to show that market rate homeowners can afford to subsidize the cost of homeownership for BMR homeowners, and state that all residents in HOAs are currently struggling to afford the increase in HOA fees. They point out that many residents of HOAs are seniors on fixed and reduced incomes who have very little ability to absorb additional costs into their limited budgets. They fear that this bill will lead to more foreclosures for market rate homeowners as HOAs will try and shift the costs they will no longer be able to allocate evenly among all owners onto the market rate owners, exacerbating the already concerning issue of exorbitant HOA fees and housing crisis the sponsors of the bill are trying to address. The opposition additionally argues that the bill will create tension within a community when neighbors realize that they are paying more than some of their neighbors. They posit that this bill will invite litigation from HOA members. They also raise issues that purchasers of a unit will be unaware that they will be required to pay a higher proportion of HOA fees than other owners.
- Concerns from the California Building Industry Association
The California Building Industry Association (CBIA)is opposed unless amend stating in their opposition letter that the cap on an HOA assessment fee in this bill is not adjusted for the cost of living as the 5 percent rent cap is in AB 1482 (Chiu, Ch. 579, Stats. 2019). CBIA writes “we are opposed to AB 572 because the 5% cap does not keep pace with inflation or increases due to changes in law” and that “the limit proposed in AB 572 does not allow for the cost to comply with new laws as they are enacted.”
They also want the effective date pushed back a year to January 1, 2025, claiming it takes a year to get approval of the governing documents by the Department of Real Estate (DRE) and fear the current effective date of January 1, 2024 will “mess up or delay” projects that have already been submitted to DRE. Lastly, they seek an amendment to “limit the number of units in a development whereby a cap would apply to 15% to ensure that the cost shift to the market rate homeowners is not unduly burdensome” as under the bill currently you “could have a situation in which 90% of units in a development are deed-restricted and have a cap, while the other 10% of market rate units would have to subsidize all of those units, raising their costs significantly.”
5. Proposed Amendments
The Committee may wish to amend the cap on the fee assessment in this bill to provide for more flexibility and account for the percentage change in the cost of living. Looking at the provisions of AB 1482 as a guide, the Committee may wish to provide that the assessment cap be amended to be the greater of either: 5 percent or the percentage change in cost of living, whichever is greater, than the prior assessment. However, in no instance would the assessment be higher than 10 percent of the prior assessment for BMR homeowners. “Percentage change in the cost of living” would have the same definition as it does in AB 1482, existing subdivision (g) of Section 1947.12 of the Civil Code.
Additionally, the Committee may wish to amend the bill to provide that the cap on assessments for BMR homeowners does not apply to a development where 30 percent or more of the units, exclusive of a manager’s unit or units, are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households.
The specific amendments are as follows:[4]
Section 5606 of the Civil Code is amended to read:
(a) Annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year shall not be imposed unless the board has complied with paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), (7), and (8) of subdivision (b) of Section 5300 with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(b) Notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, the board may not impose a regular assessment that is more than 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the association’s preceding fiscal year or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the association for that fiscal year without the approval of a majority of a quorum of members, pursuant to Section 4070, at a member meeting or election.
(c) (1) (A) For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations placed on the board by the governing documents, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board shall not impose a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment. assessment or that is greater than the percentage change in cost of living, whichever is larger.
(B) When calculating the imposition of a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit under this subdivision, the board shall not impose a regular assessment that exceeds 10 percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
(C) For purposes of this paragraph, “percentage change in the cost of living” means the percentage change from April 1 of the prior year to April 1 of the current year in the regional Consumer Price Index for the region where the residential real property is located, as published by the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics. If a regional index is not available, the California Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers for all items, as determined by the Department of Industrial Relations, shall apply.
(2) For an association that records its original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding any other law, except as provided in paragraph (3), the board may impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
(3) This subdivision does not apply to a development where 100 30 percent or more of the units units, exclusive of a manager’s unit or units units, are occupied by, or available at affordable housing cost to, lower income and moderate-income households, as defined by Sections 50079.5 and 50052.5, respectively, of the Health and Safety Code.
(d) For the purposes of this section, “quorum” means more than 50 percent of the members.
6. Statements in Support
The San Francisco Housing Development Corporation and the Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California, the sponsors of the bill, write in support stating:
Recently, increases in HOA dues have significantly outpaced the income increases for many BMR homeowners, putting them at risk of foreclosure or HOA fee default. This development is highly troubling for a program that is meant to be a promise of stability and financial security to low- and moderate-income homeowners.
From large urban areas like San Francisco, to smaller suburban centers like San Ramon, and beyond the Bay Area, affordable housing developers and advocates are reporting similar problems wherever these deed-restricted BMR programs exist. This is also not a new issue – BMR programs have struggled with this issue for decades but the recent spikes in HOA fees have highlighted this long standing issue.
In addition to the problem of foreclosures, BMR units with higher HOA dues are harder to sell, which can lead to lengthy vacancies, undermining the goals of this program during a statewide housing crisis. In one especially egregious example, the monthly dues in a San Francisco BMR unit started from $1,500 per month. Fewer buyers applied to the BMR units because HOA dues were a concern, especially when they can increase by a large percentage each year.
This is a small yet important change intended to slow down the fee increases that are forcing many families out of their homes.
7. Statements in Opposition
The Center for California Homeowner Association Law writes in opposition stating:
AB 572 is well-intentioned legislation seeking to solve the problem the very real problem of escalating regular assessments. As noted above: regular assessments can increase by 20% a year, when we can safely say that few working people get salary increases of 20% a year. But shifting the cost burden onto another class of owners doesn’t solve it.
Yes, affordable homeownership units built by public and private developers should be preserved. Public monies and resources – land, for example – are poured into building homes that are to become the key to establishing economic security.
However, AB 572 will not solve the assessment affordability problem but instead will trigger litigation and dissension in the association community. (footnotes omitted)
The California Alliance for Retired Americans writes in opposition stating:
Our reading of AB572 is that it would force seniors who buy homes at market rates to subsidize the assessments of owners who buy homes at reduced prices or with some form of public assistance. Owners who would be required to take on these new costs would include seniors who now live on fixed and reduced incomes. Their main source of income is Social Security – not pensions or investments in the stock market.
Of special concern to us are senior women who were never in the job market or who had part-time or sporadic employment and whose chief financial asset is now their home. Such women have no pensions to speak of and their chief income is miniature Social Security checks. Senior women in particular have a hard time stretching income to cover housing costs, increasing health care costs, and the costs of transportation and utilities.
AB572 would require seniors to take on another cost: not just increased regular assessments but the burden of subsidizing the assessments of their neighbors who own Below-Market-Rate homes.
SUPPORT
Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California (sponsor)
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation (sponsor)
Devine & Gong, Inc.
East Bay YIMBY
Generation Housing
Grow the Richmond
Homeownership San Francisco
Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County
How to ADU
Mission Economic Development Agency (MEDA)
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Ventura County YIMBY
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Building Industry Alliance
Center for California Homeowner Association Law
Community Associations Institute’s California Legislative Action Committee
1 individual
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 1458 (Ta, 2023) would authorize a reduced quorum requirement for homeowner association board elections if the first attempt at holding the election failed to establish a quorum and certain procedural requirements are met, as specified. AB 1458 is currently pending in this Committee.
Prior Legislation: None known.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Housing Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 2)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 55, Noes 18)
Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 1)
**************
Sen. Comm. on Housing analysis of AB 572 (2023-24 Reg. Sess.) as amended May 26, 2023 at p. 4. ↑
Operating Cost Manual, Cal. Dept. or Real Estate at p. 3, available at https://www.dre.ca.gov/files/pdf/re8.pdf. ↑
How Does a Foreclosure Affect Your Credit Score? Consumer Education Services Inc., available at https://www.cesisolutions.org/resources/credit-and-debt-resource-center/consequences-of-foreclosure. ↑
The amendments may also include technical, nonsubstantive changes recommended by the Office of Legislative Counsel. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 572 Hearing Date: 6/20/2023
Author: | Haney | ||
Version: | 5/26/2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Mehgie Tabar | ||
SUBJECT: Common interest developments: imposition of assessments
DIGEST: This bill caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs) at 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment, for HOAs that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Davis-Stirling CID Act, which provides rules and regulations governing the operation of residential CIDs and the rights and responsibilities of HOAs and HOA members.
- Provides that for any conflict between the law and HOA governing documents, the law prevails over the governing documents.
- Requires the owner of a separate interest to provide a prospective purchaser a written statement, as specified, from an authorized HOA representative with the amount of the HOA’s current regular and special assessments and fees, any assessments levied upon the owner’s interest in the CID that are unpaid on the date of the statement, and any monetary fines or penalties levied upon the owner’s interest and unpaid on the date of the statement.
- Requires a HOA to distribute an annual budget report 30 to 90 days before the end of its fiscal year, and requires the annual budget report to include certain specified information, unless the governing documents impose more stringent standards.
- Requires an HOA to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the Davis-Stirling Act, and prohibits a HOA from imposing or collecting an assessment or a fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied.
- Prohibits an HOA board from imposing annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year unless the board has complied with the annual budget requirements in 1) with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members at a member meeting or election.
- Authorizes an HOA board, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, to impose a regular assessment up to 20% greater than the regular assessment for the HOA’s preceding fiscal year. Prohibits a board from imposing regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s regular assessment, or imposing special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without the approval of a majority of a quorum of the members at a member meeting or election.
- Defines “quorum” for purposes of 6) and 7) above to mean more than 50% of the members.
- Requires, via Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations, that governing instruments for CIDs provide for a variety of items, including procedures for calculating and collecting regular assessments from owners, and procedures for establishing and collecting special assessments for capital improvements or for other purposes.
- Requires, via DRE regulations, regular assessments to ordinarily be levied against each owner according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments. In the case of a subdivision offering in which it is reasonable to anticipate that any owner will derive as much as 10% more than any other owner in the value of common services supplied by the HOA, the assessment against each owner may be determined according to a formula or schedule under which the assessments against the various subdivision interests bear a relationship which is equitably proportionate to the value of the common services furnished to the respective interests.
- Provides that regular and special assessments are delinquent 15 days after they become due, unless the declaration provides a longer time period. If an assessment is delinquent, the HOA may recover, as specified, reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, a late charge, and interest on all sums imposed.
- Requires an HOA to notify the owner of record in writing, as specified, by certified mail at least 30 days prior to recording a lien upon the separate interest of the owner of record to collect a past-due debt under 11).
- Allows an owner to submit a written request to meet with the board to discuss a payment plan for past-due debt, and requires the board to meet with the owner pursuant to specified timelines. Requires the HOA to provide owners the standards for payment plans, as specified, if any exist.
- Prior to initiating a foreclosure on an owner’s separate interest, the HOA must offer the owner and, if so requested by the owner, participate in dispute resolution, as specified. The board must approve a decision to initiate a foreclosure of a lien for delinquent assessments by a majority vote of the directors in an executive session.
- Prohibits an HOA that seeks to collect delinquent regular or special assessments of an amount less than $1,800 from collecting that debt through judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, but allows the HOA to attempt to collect or secure that debt by a civil action in small claims court, by recording a lien on the owner’s separate interest upon which the HOA can foreclose after the debt reaches or exceeds $1,800 or the debt is more than 12 months delinquent, or any other manner provided by law.
- Provides that the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA.
This bill:
- Prohibits HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024 to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts developments with 100% of units available to lower income and moderate-income households from 1) and 2) above.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. “The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.”
- Background on CIDs. CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California’s housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35% of the state’s total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership, which have a number of powers and duties, including determining the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. Many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
- Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs. Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100% affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are usually protected for 55 years. Affordable ownership units are targeted to lower income and moderate-income households, making up to 120% of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e., Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new Below Market Rate (BMR) unit purchasers, they must meet the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new BMR buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner’s resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
- HOA Budgets and Assessments. HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20% over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or that otherwise could not have been anticipated.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what DRE regulations call "unequal access to common services provided by the HOA". These are called variable assessments.
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in CIDs created after January 1, 2024 where BMR units are present in the development. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing future boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill’s cap.
- Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures. Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide a longer time. Failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner’s property through foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner’s property, which may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, an HOA may not foreclose if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney’s fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose. An owner may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment, and the board must meet with that owner to discuss the payment plan, but is not required to accept the payment plan.
- Prospective. This bill would impose the 5% increase cap on regular assessments for any HOA with BMR units where the original declaration to DRE is recorded on or after January 1, 2024. The bill would also explicitly authorize the establishment of variable assessment rates in future CIDs based on the presence of BMR units. The effect of making the bill prospective – only applying to newly created CIDs – is that all owners who purchase homes in the development will have the opportunity to review the assessment rate schedule laid out in the governing documents and be informed that there will be more modest rates of increases on the BMR units in the community, or if there will be variable assessments at the outset. The growth in the actual gap between assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the development is completed and units are for sale, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners without a vote of membership (20%).
CC&Rs are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA.
In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing, as a matter of public policy, that assessments on BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in all future CIDs.
Related Legislation:
AB 648 (Valencia, 2023) — authorizes an HOA to hold board meetings or member meetings entirely by teleconference without any physical location if certain conditions are met. This bill recently passed this committee on a vote of 11-0.
AB 1458 (Ta, 2023) — authorizes a lower quorum requirement for HOA elections of directors under specified circumstances. This bill is also being heard at this same hearing.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
June 14, 2023.)
SUPPORT:
Nonprofit Housing Association of Northern California (Co-Sponsor)
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation (Co-Sponsor)
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Reinvestment Coalition
Council of Community Housing Organizations, San Francisco
Devine & Gong, INC.
East Bay YIMBY
Generation Housing
Grow the Richmond
Homeownership San Francisco
Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County
How to ADU
Mission Economic Development Agency (MEDA)
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Ventura County YIMBY
YIMBY Action
OPPOSITION:
None received.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 572
Author:(Haney)
As Amended Ver:May 26, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs) at five percent greater than the preceding regular assessment, for HOAs that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than five percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards that record their original declaration on or after January 1, 2024 to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the proportional ownership of total subdivision interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts developments with 100% of units available to lower income and moderate-income households from 1) and 2) above.
COMMENTS
Background on CIDs: CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California’s housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35% of the state’s total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code Section 4000 et seq.) as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership, which have a number of powers and duties, including determining the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. Many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs: Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100 percent affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are usually protected for 55 years. Affordable ownership units are targeted to lower income and moderate-income households making up to 120% of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e. Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new BMR unit purchasers, they must meet the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new BMR buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner’s resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
HOA Budgets and Assessments: HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
Increases in regular assessments and special assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5605. A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20 % over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year’s assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5610 and do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or that otherwise could not have been anticipated.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations call "unequal access to common services provided by the HOA" (10 Civil Code Section 2792.16). These are called variable assessments. According to DRE’s "Operating Cost Manual for Homeowners Associations" section on variable assessments:
Variable prorations should be employed only when services are provided to units in unequal proportions. DRE regulations allow the use of variable assessments against units only if one unit will derive as much as 10% more than another unit in the value of common goods and services supplied by the association. Examples of services provided in unequal proportions directly to units are insurance, domestic water and gas, if applicable, and exterior and roof maintenance. […] In most instances, however, variable proration is not considered preferable to equal proration if differential in the level of services supplied by the association to the units is less than 20%. Variable assessments should be used when the differential exceeds 20%.
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in CIDs created after January 1, 2024 where BMR units are present in the development. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing future boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill’s cap.
Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures: Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide a longer time. Failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner’s property through foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner’s property, which may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, an HOA may not foreclose if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney’s fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose. An owner may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment, and the board must meet with that owner to discuss the payment plan, but is not required to accept the payment plan.
Prospective: This bill would impose the five percent increase cap on regular assessments for any HOA with BMR units where the original declaration to DRE is recorded on or after January 1, 2024. The bill would also explicitly authorize the establishment of variable assessment rates in future CIDs based on the presence of BMR units. The effect of making the bill prospective – only applying to newly created CIDs – is that all owners who purchase homes in the development will have the opportunity to review the assessment rate schedule laid out in the governing documents and be informed that there will be more modest rates of increases on the BMR units in the community, or if there will be variable assessments at the outset. The growth in the actual gap between assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the development is completed and units are for sale, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners without a vote of membership (20%).
Civil Code Section 5975 provides that CC&Rs are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA. The statutory presumption of reasonableness requires that CC&Rs be enforced "unless they are wholly arbitrary, violate a fundamental public policy, or impose a burden on the use of affected land that far outweighs any benefit." (Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development (US), LLC (2012) 55 Cal.4th 223, 239; Nahrstedt v. Lakeside Village Condominium Assn. (1994) 8 Cal.4th, 361, 382.) In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing as a matter of public policy that assessments on BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in all future CIDs.
According to the Author
"The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes."
Arguments in Support
Supporters, including the Community Reinvestment Coalition, YIMBY Action, and HomeownershipSF, state that increases in HOA dues have outpaced increases in income for many BMR owners, putting them at risk of default or foreclosure. This undermines the promise of financial security and housing stability made to low- and moderate-income homeowners who are able to purchase BMR units. In addition, supporters point out that BMR units with higher HOA dues can sit on the market for long periods of time, undermining the goals of the program during the statewide housing crisis. Income-eligible families are concerned they will not be able to afford large increases in HOA dues year over year.
Arguments in Opposition
Opponents including the Center for California Homeowner Association Law believe this bill will result in an unfair distribution of the responsibility for funding maintenance, safety, and other community services that benefit all owners equally. They contend this will result in litigation and division within communities. Other opponents, including the California Building Industry Association and the California Association of Retired Americans, question whether market-rate homeowners, especially those living on fixed and reduced incomes, have the funds available to take on the burden of unequal assessments.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None.
VOTES
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 5-1-2
YES: Wicks, Wendy Carrillo, Gabriel, Kalra, Quirk-Silva
NO: Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Joe Patterson, Ward
UPDATED
VERSION: May 26, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0001028
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 572
Author:(Haney)
As Amended Ver:April 5, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs) at 5% greater than the preceding regular assessment.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits HOA boards, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than five percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts developments with 100% of units available to lower income and moderate-income households from 1) and 2), above.
COMMENTS
Background on Common Interest Development (CIDs): CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California's housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35% of the state's total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code Section 4000 et seq.) as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership, which have a number of powers and duties, including determining the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. Many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs: Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100 percent affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are usually protected for 55 years. Affordable ownership units are targeted to lower income and moderate-income households generally making up to 120 percent of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e. Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new BMR unit purchasers, they must meet the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new below-market-rate (BMR) buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner's resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
HOA Budgets and Assessments: HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
Increases in regular assessments and special assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5605. A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20% over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20% higher than the preceding year's assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5% of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5610 and do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or that otherwise could not have been anticipated.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations call "unequal access to common services provided by the HOA" (10 CCR Section 2792.16). These are called variable assessments. According to DRE's "Operating Cost Manual for Homeowners Associations" section on variable assessments:
Variable prorations should be employed only when services are provided to units in unequal proportions. DRE regulations allow the use of variable assessments against units only if one unit will derive as much as 10% more than another unit in the value of common goods and services supplied by the association. Examples of services provided in unequal proportions directly to units are insurance, domestic water and gas, if applicable, and exterior and roof maintenance. […] In most instances, however, variable proration is not considered preferable to equal proration if differential in the level of services supplied by the association to the units is less than 20%. Variable assessments should be used when the differential exceeds 20%.
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in CIDs where BMR units are present in the development. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill's cap on BMR unit increases.
Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures: Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide a longer time. Failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner's property through foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner's property, which may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, a HOA may not foreclose if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney's fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose. An owner of a separate interest may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment, and the board must meet with that owner to discuss the payment plan, but is not required to accept the payment plan.
Overriding Governing Documents: This bill would override assessment ratios in existing CC&Rs and governing documents in order to impose the five percent increase cap on BMR units. Thus, this bill will create situations where owners who were previously paying identical assessments will gradually begin to have unequal assessment rates. The growth in the actual gap between these formerly identical assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the bill would go into effect, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners (20%).
Civil Code Section 4205 expressly provides that in any situation where there is a conflict between the law and a set of governing documents, the law shall prevail. And in recent years, the Legislature has approved a number of bills that overrode certain prohibitions in governing documents, including provisions that restricted the construction of accessory dwelling units, the installation of electric vehicle charging stations or time-of-use meters, and the renting or leasing of certain separate interests.
However, Civil Code Section 5975 provides that CC&Rs are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA. The statutory presumption of reasonableness requires that CC&Rs be enforced "unless they are wholly arbitrary, violate a fundamental public policy, or impose a burden on the use of affected land that far outweighs any benefit." (Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development (US), LLC (2012) 55 Cal.4th 223, 239; Nahrstedt v. Lakeside Village Condominium Assn. (1994) 8 Cal.4th, 361, 382.) It would be illegal for any HOA to provide a voluntary discount or lowered assessment rate to homeowners in BMR units – or to any homeowner or class of homeowners in the HOA – without specific, reasonable assessment allocations laid out in the governing documents. A member could sue the board to compel enforcement of the equitable servitude if the board changed assessments without following the rules in the governing documents for changing the overall assessment allocations.
In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing as a matter of public policy that assessments on BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in all existing and future CIDs. The bill would also explicitly authorize the establishment of variable assessment rates in developments based on the presence of BMR units. It should be noted that owners of units in existing CIDs bought into those developments expecting to be governed by CC&Rs and governing documents with assessment rates as they were specified in the declaration, and this bill will conflict with those CC&Rs.
According to the Author
"The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people's credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes."
Arguments in Support
Supporters, including the Community Reinvestment Coalition, YIMBY Action, and HomeownershipSF, state that increases in HOA dues have outpaced increases in income for many BMR owners, putting them at risk of default or foreclosure. This undermines the promise of financial security and housing stability made to low- and moderate-income homeowners who are able to purchase BMR units. In addition, supporters point out that BMR units with higher HOA dues can sit on the market for long periods of time, undermining the goals of the program during the statewide housing crisis. Income-eligible families are concerned they will not be able to afford large increases in HOA dues year over year.
Arguments in Opposition
Opponents, including the California Association of Community Managers, California Association of Realtors, and others, believe this bill will result in an unfair distribution of the responsibility for funding maintenance, safety, and other community services that benefit all owners equally. They contend this will result in litigation and division within communities as market-rate owners seek to enforce the terms of existing CC&Rs. Other opponents, including the California Association of Retired Americans, question whether market-rate homeowners, especially those living on fixed and reduced incomes, have the funds available to take on the burden of unequal assessments.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None.
VOTES
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 5-1-2
YES: Wicks, Wendy Carrillo, Gabriel, Kalra, Quirk-Silva
NO: Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Joe Patterson, Ward
UPDATED
VERSION: April 5, 2023
CONSULTANT: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0000262
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 572 (
Author:Haney) – As Amended Ver:April 5, 2023
SUBJECT: Common interest developments: imposition of assessments
SUMMARY: Caps annual increases in regular assessments on deed-restricted affordable housing units in homeowners associations (HOAs) at five percent greater than the preceding regular assessment. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits HOA boards, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, from imposing a regular assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is more than five percent greater than the preceding regular assessment.
- Authorizes HOA boards to impose an assessment against an owner of a deed-restricted affordable housing unit that is lower than the assessment imposed against other owners according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments.
- Exempts developments with 100 percent of units available to lower income and moderate-income households from 1) and 2) above.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development (CID) Act, which provides rules and regulations governing the operation of residential CIDs and the rights and responsibilities of HOAs and HOA members. (Civil Code (CC) Section 4000 et seq.)
- Provides that for any conflict between the law and HOA governing documents, the law prevails over the governing documents. (CC 4205)
- Requires the owner of a separate interest to provide a prospective purchaser a written statement from an authorized HOA representative with the amount of the HOA’s current regular and special assessments and fees, any assessments levied upon the owner’s interest in the CID that are unpaid on the date of the statement, and any monetary fines or penalties levied upon the owner’s interest and unpaid on the date of the statement. The statement must also include any change in the HOA’s regular and special assessments and fees that have been approved by the board but not become due and payable yet. The statement must be provided to the prospective purchaser as soon as practicable before the transfer of title or execution of a sales contract. (CC 4525(a)(4))
- Requires a HOA to distribute an annual budget report 30 to 90 days before the end of its fiscal year, and requires the annual budget report to include all of the following information, unless the governing documents impose more stringent standards:
- A pro forma operating budget, showing the estimated revenue and expenses on an accrual basis;
- A summary of the HOA’s reserves as required by law;
- A summary of the reserve funding plan adopted by the board with notice to members that the full reserve study plan is available upon request;
- A statement as to whether the board has determined to defer or not undertake repairs or replacement of any major component with a remaining life of 30 years or less, including a justification for the deferral or decision not to undertake the repairs or replacement;
- A statement as to whether the board, consistent with the reserve funding plan, has determined or anticipates that the levy of one or more special assessments will be required to repair, replace, or restore any major component or to provide adequate reserves. If so, the statement must also set out the estimated amount, commencement date, and duration of the assessment;
- A statement as to the mechanism by which the board will fund reserves to repair or replace major components, including assessments, borrowing, use of other assets, deferral of selected replacements or repairs, or alternative mechanisms;
- A general statement addressing the procedures used for the calculation and establishment of those reserves;
- A statement as to whether the HOA has any outstanding loans with an original term of more than one year, including the payee, interest rate, amount outstanding, annual payment, and when the loan is scheduled to be retired; and
- Other specified information relating to insurance policies, condominium-specific notices, and copies of certain document fees. (CC 5300(a)-(b))
- Requires an HOA to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations under the governing documents and the Davis-Stirling Act, and prohibits a HOA from imposing or collecting an assessment or a fee that exceeds the amount necessary to defray the costs for which it is levied. (CC 5600)
- Prohibits an HOA board from imposing annual increases in regular assessments for any fiscal year unless the board has complied with the annual budget requirements in 1) with respect to that fiscal year, or has obtained the approval of a majority of a quorum of members at a member meeting or election. (CC 5605(a))
- Authorizes an HOA board, notwithstanding more restrictive limitations in governing documents, to impose a regular assessment up to 20 percent greater than the regular assessment for the HOA’s preceding fiscal year. Prohibits a board from imposing regular assessments over 20 percent higher than the preceding year’s regular assessment, or imposing special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without the approval of a majority of a quorum of the members at a member meeting or election. (CC 5605(b))
- Defines “quorum” for purposes of 6) and 7) above to mean more than 50 percent of the members.
- Requires, via Department of Real Estate (DRE) regulations, that governing instruments for CIDs provide for a variety of items, including:
- Procedures for calculating and collecting regular assessments from owners to defray expenses attributable to the ownership, operation, or furnishing of common interests or to the enjoyment of mutual and reciprocal rights of use; and
- Procedures for establishing and collecting special assessments for capital improvements or for other purposes. (California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 10, Chapter 6, Article 12, Subdivision 2792.8(a)(4)-(5))
- Requires, via DRE regulations, regular assessments to ordinarily be levied against each owner according to the ratio of the number of subdivision interests owned by the owner assessed to the total number of interests subject to assessments. In the case of a subdivision offering in which it is reasonable to anticipate that any owner will derive as much as 10 percent more than any other owner in the value of common services supplied by the HOA, the assessment against each owner may be determined according to a formula or schedule under which the assessments against the various subdivision interests bear a relationship which is equitably proportionate to the value of the common services furnished to the respective interests. (10 CCR § 2792.16)
- Provides that regular and special assessments are delinquent 15 days after they become due, unless the declaration provides a longer time period. If an assessment is delinquent, the HOA may recover all of the following:
- Reasonable costs incurred in collecting the delinquent assessment, including reasonable attorney’s fees;
- A late charge not exceeding 10 percent of the delinquent assessment or $10, whichever is greater, unless the declaration specifies a late charge in a smaller amount; and
- Interest on all sums imposed at an annual interest rate not to exceed 12 percent, commencing 30 days after the assessment becomes due, unless the declaration specifies the recovery of interest at a lesser rate. (CC 5650(b))
- Requires an HOA to notify the owner of record in writing by certified mail at least 30 days prior to recording a lien upon the separate interest of the owner of record to collect a past-due debt under 11). The notice must include the following information:
- A general description of the collection and lien enforcement procedures of the HOA and the method and calculation of the amount, and other specified notices;
- An itemized statement of the charges owed by the owner, including the amount of any delinquent assessments, the fees and reasonable costs of collection, reasonable attorney’s fees, any late charges, and interest, if any;
- The right to request a meeting with the board to discuss a payment plan for the debt; and
- Other statements and rights of the owner. (CC 5660)
- Allows an owner to submit a written request to meet with the board to discuss a payment plan for past-due debt, and requires the board to meet with the owner pursuant to specified timelines. Requires the HOA to provide owners the standards for payment plans, if any exist. Payment plans may incorporate any assessments that accrue during the payment plan period, but no additional late fees can accrue during the plan period if the owner is in compliance with the terms of the payment plan. (CC 5665)
- Prior to initiating a foreclosure on an owner’s separate interest, the HOA must offer the owner and, if so requested by the owner, participate in dispute resolution pursuant to the HOA’s “meet and confer” program or alternative dispute resolution as required by law. The board must approve a decision to initiate a foreclosure of a lien for delinquent assessments by a majority vote of the directors in an executive session. (CC 5705)
- Prohibits an HOA that seeks to collect delinquent regular or special assessments of an amount less than $1,800 from collecting that debt through judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, but allows the HOA to attempt to collect or secure that debt by a civil action in small claims court, by recording a lien on the owner’s separate interest upon which the HOA can foreclose after the debt reaches or exceeds $1,800 or the debt is more than 12 months delinquent, or any other manner provided by law. (CC 5720)
- Provides that the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA. (CC 5975)
FISCAL EFFECT: None.
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “The Below Market Rate Homeownership programs are one of the best tools we have to provide homeownership opportunities to low-income Californians – but the rapidly increasing HOA fees are defeating the purpose of these programs. BMR homeowners are foreclosing on their homes faster than ever because their HOA fees are becoming more expensive than their mortgage. A foreclosure impacts people’s credit scores for years to come. So instead of helping low-income people build generational wealth through homeownership, the HOA fee increases are pushing them into more debt. AB 572 addresses this issue by capping annual HOA fee increases at 5% for BMR homeowners to make sure that low-income Californians are not forced into foreclosing on their homes.”
Background on CIDs: CIDs are a type of housing with separate ownership of housing units that also share common areas and amenities. There are a variety of different types of CIDs, including condominium complexes, planned unit developments, and resident-owned mobilehome parks. In recent years CIDs have represented a growing share of California’s housing stock. Data from 2019 indicates that there are an estimated 54,065 CIDs in the state that are made up of 5 million housing units, or about 35 percent of the state’s total housing stock.
CIDs are regulated under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code Section 4000 et seq.) as well as the governing documents of the HOA, including the bylaws, declaration, and operating rules. CIDs can also have Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs) that are filed with the county and recorded at the time they are established. Owners in a CID are contractually obligated to abide by the CC&Rs and the governing documents of a CID, which specify rules such as parking policies, allowable modifications to homes, and rental restrictions. Additionally, HOAs are governed by a board of directors elected by the membership in elections that closely resemble California’s vote-by-mail process. In addition, many associations use a managing agent to assist with finances, logistics, and other services provided to homeowners.
HOA boards have a number of duties and powers. The board determines the annual assessments that members must pay in order to cover communal expenses. The board enforces the community rules and can propose as well as make changes to those rules. If members do not pay their assessments in full or on time, or if members violate the community rules, the board has the power to fine the members and, if necessary, the power to foreclose upon the offending member’s property. This combination of responsibilities and authority has led multiple courts to observe that HOAs function in many ways almost “as a second municipal government, regulating many aspects of [the homeowners’] daily lives” (Villa Milano Homeowners Ass’n v. Il Davorge (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 819, 836).
Affordable Ownership Units in CIDs: Affordable ownership units in CIDs generally come about as a result of local inclusionary ordinance requirements, via density bonus projects to create for-sale housing, in 100 percent affordable homeownership projects, or where they were created by redevelopment agencies and have had their initial term of affordability extended or are subject to local statutes that keep the homes deed-restricted in perpetuity. Affordable ownership units generally operate on 45-year deed restriction timeframes, as opposed to affordable rental units, which are generally protected for 55 years.[1] Affordable ownership units are targeted to be affordable for lower income and moderate-income households generally making up to 120 percent of area median income (AMI).
Ownership programs are generally operated by a local government or a nonprofit housing manager (i.e. Habitat for Humanity or a local community land trust network or housing trust). For new BMR unit purchasers, they generally must meet some assortment of the following: requirements to comply with income and asset restrictions, the ability to make a specified down payment and obtain a mortgage on the property, requirements to use the home as their principal place of residence (no renting), and be subject to an equity sharing arrangement or first right of resale to the entity to retake ownership of the property and sell it to a new BMR buyer in the event the owner sells the property before a deed restriction expires. A feature of these arrangements is the BMR owner’s resale proceeds are capped at a below-market price or the equity from the home sale must be split between the BMR owner and the local government or nonprofit with a senior lien or deed of trust on the property.
For example, the San Francisco Mayor’s Office of Housing and Community Development manages three types of below-market-rate (BMR) ownership programs.[2] The programs include:
- Inclusionary Affordable Housing Program: Applies to privately developed projects that choose to construct on-site affordable housing rather than pay in-lieu fees or dedicate land to offsite affordable housing. Subject to San Francisco Planning Code Section 415.6, for projects between 10-25 units, 15 percent of units constructed on-site must be affordable to households earning up to 100 percent of AMI. For projects with 25 or more units, 25 percent of units must be affordable, with a minimum of 12 percent of units affordable to households earning up to 100 percent of AMI, 6.5 percent affordable to households earning up to 120 percent of AMI, and 6.5 percent affordable to households earning up to 150 percent of AMI (minimum occupancy of two persons). Inclusionary rates for 25+ unit projects will rise to 26 percent overall by 2025. Special 27 percent inclusionary rates apply to ownership projects in the Mission, the Tenderloin, and SoMa.[3]
- Limited Equity Program: All LEP homes were created by the former San Francisco Redevelopment Agency and are targeted to help low- and moderate-income first time homebuyers.
- Condo Conversion: Between 1979 and 1988, building owners who converted their properties from apartments to condominiums were required to set aside a percentage of those converted units for sale to low- and moderate-income homebuyers.
Where any of these ownership units are constructed or exist within a condominium, planned unit development, or cooperative, they will also be subject to the Davis-Stirling Act and any CC&Rs and governing documents of the CID.
HOA Budgets and Assessments: HOAs must collect assessments from members to fund a variety of budgeted costs, including reserves for maintenance and repair projects for major components of common areas and shared structures, amenities, shared services, taxes, different types of insurance the HOA is required to maintain, and other general operating expenses like legal fees, accounting fees, and more. There are three types of assessments – sometimes referred to as “dues” – HOAs levy on members in order to fund their obligations: regular assessments, special assessments, and emergency assessments.
Increases in regular assessments and special assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5605. A board must have adopted a budget for the year in order to be able to entertain an increase in regular assessments, and boards can only raise regular assessments up to 20 percent over the regular assessment for the preceding fiscal year. Boards cannot impose regular assessments over 20 percent higher than the preceding year’s assessment, or impose special assessments which in the aggregate exceed 5 percent of the budgeted gross expenses of the HOA for that fiscal year, without taking a vote of the members. Approval of a majority of a quorum of the members is required to legally impose assessments larger than the caps.
Emergency assessments are governed by Civil Code Section 5610 and do not require membership approval. These are only allowed to be levied to cover extraordinary expenses required by a court order, necessary to repair or maintain CID property where there is a threat to personal safety, or necessary to repair or maintain CID property that could not have been reasonably foreseen by the board in the annual budget preparation. In the latter circumstance, the board must pass a resolution containing findings as to why the extraordinary expense is necessary and why it was not anticipated during the budgeting process, and must distribute the resolution to members along with the notice of increased assessment.
Assessments can be equal or, in some instances, might differ depending on what DRE regulations call “unequal access to common services provided by the HOA” (10 CCR § 2792.16). These are called variable assessments. According to DRE’s “Operating Cost Manual for Homeowners Associations” section on variable assessments:
Proration is a procedure to determine the amount to be assessed to each unit in the subdivision to meet budgeted expenses. Prorations may be either equal or variable. Equal proration involves the simple process of dividing the total costs of a budget item by the number of units in the subdivision. Variable prorations entail the use of a factor or factors that differ from one unit to the next, e.g., square footage of floor space. Equal assessments should be used wherever reasonably equitable, since variable proration can be a complicated and controversial process.
Variable prorations should be employed only when services are provided to units in unequal proportions. DRE regulations allow the use of variable assessments against units only if one unit will derive as much as 10 percent more than another unit in the value of common goods and services supplied by the association. Examples of services provided in unequal proportions directly to units are insurance, domestic water and gas, if applicable, and exterior and roof maintenance. […] In most instances, however, variable proration is not considered preferable to equal proration if differential in the level of services supplied by the association to the units is less than 20 percent. Variable assessments should be used when the differential exceeds 20 percent.[4]
This bill affects the process for raising regular assessments in CIDs where BMR units are present in the development. As such, it may have the effect of incentivizing boards to rely more heavily on special assessments, which are not affected by the cap in this bill. Emergency assessments are reserved for court orders and unanticipated safety repairs and would also not be affected by the bill’s cap on BMR unit increases.
Delinquent Assessments and Foreclosure Procedures: Assessments become delinquent 15 days after they are due, unless the governing documents provide for a longer time. The failure to pay assessments may result in the loss of an owner’s property through foreclosure. Foreclosure may occur either as a result of a court action, known as judicial foreclosure, or without court action, often referred to as nonjudicial foreclosure. When using judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure, the HOA records a lien on the owner’s property. The owner’s property may be sold to satisfy the lien if the amounts secured by the lien are not paid. For liens recorded on and after January 1, 2006, a HOA may not use judicial or nonjudicial foreclosure if the amount of the delinquent assessments – not including any accelerated assessments, late charges, fees, attorney’s fees, interest, and costs of collection – is less than $1,800. For delinquent assessments in excess of $1,800 or more than 12 months delinquent, the HOA can foreclose to sell the property and recover costs.
An owner of a separate interest that is not a time-share interest may request the HOA to consider a payment plan to satisfy a delinquent assessment. The HOA must inform owners of the standards for payment plans, if any exist. The board also must meet with an owner who makes a proper written request for a meeting to discuss a payment plan when the owner has received a notice of a delinquent assessment. These payment plans must conform to the payment plan standards of the association, if they exist.
Overriding Governing Documents: This bill would override assessment ratios in existing CC&Rs and governing documents in order to impose the five percent increase cap on BMR units. Thus, this bill will create situations where owners who were previously paying identical assessments will gradually begin to have unequal assessment rates. The growth in the actual gap between these formerly identical assessments will vary depending on a variety of factors, including percentage of BMR units in the CID, assessment rates at the time the bill would go into effect, and percentage of increases boards would seek for BMR and non-BMR owners. Not surprisingly, the gap will be larger in circumstances where actual assessment rates are higher at the inception of the new caps, where there are more BMR units overall in a development, and where boards seek the highest possible increases on non-BMR owners (20 percent).
Civil Code Section 4205 expressly provides that in any situation where there is a conflict between the law and a set of governing documents, the law shall prevail. And in recent years, the Legislature has approved a number of bills that overrode certain prohibitions in governing documents, including provisions that restricted the construction of accessory dwelling units, the installation of electric vehicle charging stations or time-of-use meters, and the renting or leasing of certain separate interests (see AB 670 (Friedman, Chapter 178, Statutes of 2019), SB 1016 (Allen, Chapter 376, Statutes of 2018), and AB 3182 (Ting, Chapter 198, Statutes of 2020)).
However, Civil Code Section 5975 provides that the covenants and restrictions in the declaration are enforceable equitable servitudes, unless unreasonable, and must inure to the benefit of and bind all owners of separate interests in the development. Unless the declaration states otherwise, these servitudes may be enforced by any owner of a separate interest or by the HOA, or both. The statutory presumption of reasonableness requires that recorded covenants and restrictions be enforced “‘unless they are wholly arbitrary, violate a fundamental public policy, or impose a burden on the use of affected land that far outweighs any benefit.’” (Pinnacle Museum Tower Assn. v. Pinnacle Market Development (US), LLC (2012) 55 Cal.4th 223, 239; Nahrstedt v. Lakeside Village Condominium Assn. (1994) 8 Cal.4th, 361, 382.) It would be illegal for any HOA to provide a voluntary discount or lowered assessment rate to individual homeowners in BMR units – or to any homeowner or class of homeowners in the HOA – without specific, reasonable assessment allocations laid out in the governing documents. A member could sue the board to compel enforcement of the equitable servitude in any instance where the board changed assessments without following procedures spelled out in the governing documents for changing the overall assessment allocations.
In passing this bill, the Legislature would be establishing as a matter of public policy that assessments on BMR units should grow more slowly than assessments on market-rate units in all existing and future CIDs. The bill would also explicitly authorize the establishment of variable assessment rates in developments based on the presence of BMR units. Given that owners of market-rate units in existing CIDs bought into those developments expecting to be governed by CC&Rs and governing documents with assessment rates as they were specified in the declaration, the committee may wish to consider whether it would be more appropriate to apply the bill only to future CID developments, so that CC&Rs at the point of purchase will accurately reflect the variable BMR assessment growth model outlined in the bill.
Arguments in Support: Supporters, including the Community Reinvestment Coalition, YIMBY Action, and HomeownershipSF, state that increases in HOA dues have outpaced increases in income for many BMR owners, putting them at risk of default or foreclosure. This undermines the promise of financial security and housing stability made to low- and moderate-income homeowners who are able to purchase BMR units. In addition, supporters point out that BMR units with higher HOA dues can sit on the market for long periods of time, undermining the goals of the program during the statewide housing crisis. Income-eligible families are concerned they will not be able to afford large increases in HOA dues year over year.
Arguments in Opposition: Opponents, including the California Association of Community Managers, California Association of Realtors, and others, believe this bill will result in an unfair distribution of the responsibility for funding maintenance, safety, and other community services that benefit all owners equally. They contend this will result in litigation and division within communities as market-rate owners seek to enforce the terms of existing CC&Rs. Other opponents, including the California Association of Retired Americans, question whether market-rate homeowners, especially those living on fixed and reduced incomes, have the funds available to take on the burden of unequal assessments.
Related Legislation:
AB 648 (Valencia) of the current legislative session authorizes a HOA to hold board meetings or member meetings entirely by teleconference without any physical location if certain conditions are met. This bill recently passed this committee on a vote of 8-0.
AB 1458 (Ta) of the current legislative session authorizes a lower quorum requirement for HOA elections of directors under specified circumstances. This bill recently passed this committee on a vote of 8-0 and is currently pending before the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Non-profit Housing Association of Northern California (Co-Sponsor)
San Francisco Housing Development Corporation (Co-Sponsor)
California Association of Local Housing Finance Agencies
California Reinvestment Coalition
Council of Community Housing Organizations, San Francisco
Devine & Gong
East Bay YIMBY
Generation Housing
Grow the Richmond
Homeownership San Francisco
Housing Leadership Council of San Mateo County
How to ADU
Mission Economic Development Agency
Mountain View YIMBY
Napa-Solano for Everyone
Northern Neighbors
Peninsula for Everyone
People for Housing Orange County
Progress Noe Valley
San Francisco YIMBY
San Luis Obispo YIMBY
Santa Cruz YIMBY
Santa Rosa YIMBY
South Bay YIMBY
Southside Forward
Ventura County YIMBY
YIMBY Action
Opposition
California Alliance for Retired Americans
California Association of Community Managers
California Association of Realtors
California Bankers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Community Banking Network
California Credit Union League
California Mortgage Bankers Association
Center for California Homeowner Association Law
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
Analysis Prepared by: Nicole Restmeyer / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
More on the various deed restrictions that affect affordable housing can be found at: https://www.calcities.org/docs/default-source/annual-conference---session-materials/9.2022-annual-kautz---affordable-housing-covenants-v2.pdf?sfvrsn=445cf601_3 ↑
https://sf.gov/reports/october-2022/below-market-rate-bmr-ownership-programs ↑
https://sfplanning.org/sites/default/files/documents/legis/inclusionary-affordable-requirements/Inclusionary_Code_Change_Summary_MATRIX_FINAL_12.3.17.pdf ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Housing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):