AB 747: Business: unlawful employee contracts and requirements.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-01-25
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: Died on third reading file.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Existing law provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void, except as provided. Existing law authorizes any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or ownership interests to agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. Existing law defines ownership interest as a partnership interest, membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as described.
This bill would modify the definition of ownership interest to require the partnership interest, membership interest, or capital stock to be more than a 10% interest of the total partnership interest, more than a 10% interest of the total membership interest, or more than 10% of the total shares of ownership of the entity, respectively.
This bill would prohibit an employer from entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, except as specified.This bill would prohibit an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, as specified.This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from entering into, presenting an employee, as defined, or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade, as defined, that is void, as described. The bill would provide that an employer, as defined, that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of these provisions violates that provision is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of up to $5,000 per employee, as defined, or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee. The bill would authorize an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and penalties and would provide that a prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees. The bill would require the Attorney General to receive and investigate allegations of a violation of this provision and would authorize the Attorney General to bring an action enforcing this provision.
(2)ExistingExisting law provides for a system of labor standards enforcement administered by the Labor Commissioner.
This bill would require the Labor Commissioner to enforce the above-described prohibition against entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, according to specified existing law, and would require the Attorney General and the Labor Commissioner to coordinate responsibility with respect to enforcement of those provisions, as specified, and would make a contract entered into in violation of that prohibition void. to, in coordination with the Attorney General, receive and investigate complaints related to the above-described provisions of this bill.
(3)(2)Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek agreement that, among other things, misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported to the State Bar.
This bill would provide that it may be is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement on the licensees behalf, or on behalf of their client, that violates the above-described prohibition against entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated. in restraint of trade, as provided.
(4)(3)Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Existing law provides that this prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
This bill would provide that, for a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, 2025, the above-described prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel, excluding when the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer, in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
(1)Existing law provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void, except as provided. Existing law authorizes any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or ownership interests to agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. Existing law defines ownership interest as a partnership interest, membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as described.
This bill would modify the definition of ownership interest to require the partnership interest, membership interest, or capital stock to be more than a 10% interest of the total partnership interest, more than a 10% interest of the total membership interest, or more than 10% of the total shares of ownership of the entity, respectively.
This bill would prohibit an employer from entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, except as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, as specified.
This bill would provide that an employer, as defined, that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of these provisions is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of up to $5,000 per employee, as defined, or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee. The bill would authorize an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and would provide that a prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees. The bill would require the Attorney General to receive and investigate allegations of a violation of this provision and would authorize the Attorney General to bring an action enforcing this provision.
(2)Existing law provides for a system of labor standards enforcement administered by the Labor Commissioner.
This bill would require the Labor Commissioner to enforce the above-described prohibition against entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, according to specified existing law law, and in coordination with the Attorney General, would require the Attorney General and the Labor Commissioner to coordinate responsibility with respect to enforcement of those provisions, as specified, and would make a contract entered into in violation of that prohibition void.
(3)Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek agreement that, among other things, misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported to the State Bar.
This bill would provide that it may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement on the licensees behalf, or on behalf of their client, that violates the above-described prohibition against entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated.
(4)Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Existing law provides that this prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
This bill would provide that, for a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, the above-described prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel, excluding when the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer, in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
(1)Existing law provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void, except as provided. Existing law authorizes any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or ownership interests to agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. Existing law defines ownership interest as a partnership interest, membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as described.
This bill would modify the definition of ownership interest to require the partnership interest, membership interest, or capital stock to be more than a 10% interest of the total partnership interest, more than a 10% interest of the total membership interest, or more than 10% of the total shares of ownership of the entity, respectively.
This bill would declare prohibit an employer from entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with a specific the employer is terminated to be a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business and void as contrary to public policy, terminated, except as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from entering into, presenting an employee, as defined, or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade, as defined, that is void, as described. The bill would provide that an employer that violates that provision employer, as defined, that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of these provisions is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee or prospective employee. employee, as defined, or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee. The bill would authorize an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and penalties and would provide that a prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees. The bill would require the Attorney General to receive and investigate allegations of a violation of this provision and would authorize the Attorney General to bring an action enforcing this provision.
(2)Existing law provides for a system of labor standards enforcement administered by the Labor Commissioner.
This bill would require the Labor Commissioner to enforce the above-described prohibition against entering into or enforcing a contract in restraint of trade a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, according to specified existing law and in coordination with the Attorney General, as specified. specified, and would make a contract entered into in violation of that prohibition void.
(3)Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek agreement that, among other things, misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported to the State Bar.
This bill would provide that it is may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates the above-described prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade. against entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated.
(4)Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Existing law provides that this prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
This bill would provide that, for a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, the above-described prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel, excluding when the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer, in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
(1)Existing law provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void, except as provided. Existing law authorizes any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or ownership interests to agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. Existing law defines ownership interest as a partnership interest, membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as described.
This bill would modify the definition of ownership interest to require the partnership interest, membership interest, or capital stock to be more than a 10% interest of the total partnership interest, more than a 10% interest of the total membership interest, or more than 10% of the total shares of ownership of the entity, respectively.
This bill would declare a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated to be a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business and void as contrary to public policy, except as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from entering into, presenting an employee, as defined, or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade, as defined, that is void, as described. The bill would provide that an employer that violates that provision is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee or prospective employee. The bill would authorize an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and penalties and would provide that a prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees. The bill would require the Attorney General to receive and investigate allegations of a violation of this provision and would authorize the Attorney General to bring an action enforcing this provision.
(2)Existing law provides for a system of labor standards enforcement administered by the Labor Commissioner.
This bill would require the Labor Commissioner to enforce the above-described prohibition against entering into or enforcing a contract in restraint of trade according to specified existing law and in coordination with the Attorney General, as specified.
(3)Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek agreement that, among other things, misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported to the State Bar.
This bill would provide that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee or employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee or employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates the above-described prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade.
(4)Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Existing law provides that this prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
This bill would provide that, for a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the above-described prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel, excluding when the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer. employer, in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
(1)Existing law provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void, except as provided. Existing law authorizes any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or ownership interests to agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. Existing law defines ownership interest as a partnership interest, membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as described.
This bill would modify the definition of ownership interest to require the partnership interest, membership interest, or capital stock to be more than a 10% interest of the total partnership interest, more than a 10% interest of the total membership interest, or more than 10% of the total shares of ownership of the entity, respectively.
This bill would declare a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated to be a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business and void as contrary to public policy, except as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, as specified.
This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from entering into, presenting an employee, as defined, or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any covenant not to compete, contract in restraint of trade, as defined, that is void, as described. The bill would provide that an employer that violates that provision is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee or prospective employee who is harmed by the violation. employee. The bill would authorize an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and penalties and would provide that a prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees. The bill would require the Attorney General to receive and investigate allegations of a violation of this provision and would authorize the Attorney General to bring an action enforcing this provision.
(2)Existing law provides for a system of labor standards enforcement administered by the Labor Commissioner.
This bill would require the Labor Commissioner to enforce the above-described prohibition against entering into or enforcing a contract in restraint of trade according to specified existing law and in coordination with the Attorney General, as specified.
(2)(3)Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek agreement that, among other things, misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported to the State Bar.
This bill would provide that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee or prospective employee, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates the above-described prohibition on covenants not to compete. contracts in restraint of trade.
(3)Existing law regulates various aspects of employment, including the payment of wages to specified provisions in employment contracts. Existing law creates the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, which is under the direction of the Labor Commissioner, and generally commits to the commissioner the authority and responsibility for the enforcement of employment laws.Existing(4)Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Existing law provides that this prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
This bill would provide that, for a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from requiring an employee, as defined, to reimburse, pay, or repay, including upon termination of employment, costs for trainings, as defined, related to the employees responsibilities and duties related to their employment.(1)Existing law provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is, to that extent, void, except as provided. Existing law authorizes any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or ownership interests to agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. Existing law defines ownership interest as a partnership interest, membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as described.
This bill would modify the definition of ownership interest to require the partnership interest, membership interest, or capital stock to be more than a 10% interest of the total partnership interest, more than a 10% interest of the total membership interest, or more than 10% of the total shares of ownership of the entity, respectively.
This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from entering into, presenting an employee, as defined, or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any covenant not to compete, as defined, that is void, as described. The bill would provide that an employer that violates that provision is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee or prospective employee who is harmed by the violation. The bill would authorize an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and penalties and would provide that a prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(2)Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation. Existing law provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek agreement that, among other things, misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported to the State Bar.
This bill would provide that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee or prospective employee, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates the above-described prohibition on covenants not to compete.
(3)Existing law regulates various aspects of employment, including the payment of wages to specified provisions in employment contracts. Existing law creates the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, which is under the direction of the Labor Commissioner, and generally commits to the commissioner the authority and responsibility for the enforcement of employment laws.
Existing law prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Existing law provides that this prohibition does not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied.
This bill would provide that, for a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
This bill would prohibit an employer, as defined, from requiring an employee, as defined, to reimburse, pay, or repay, including upon termination of employment, costs for trainings, as defined, related to the employees responsibilities and duties related to their employment.
(a)It may be is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement on the licensees behalf, or on behalf of their client, that violates Section 16608. Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 16600) of Part 2 of Division 7.
(b)For purposes of this section, employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
SEC. 2.Section 16601 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:16601.(a)Any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells (a) all or substantially all of its operating assets together with the goodwill of the business entity, (b) all or substantially all of the operating assets of a division or a subsidiary of the business entity together with the goodwill of that division or subsidiary, or (c) all of the ownership interest of any subsidiary, may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or corporation.
(2)Owner of a business entity means any partner, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), or any member, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or any owner of capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation.
(3)Ownership interest means any of the following:
(A)A partnership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership, including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total partnership interest of the entity.
(B)A membership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company, including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total membership interest of the entity.
(C)A capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation, that is more than 10-percent of the total shares of ownership of the corporation.
(4)Subsidiary means any business entity over which the selling business entity has voting control or from which the selling business entity has a right to receive a majority share of distributions upon dissolution or other liquidation of the business entity (or has both voting control and a right to receive these distributions.)
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:(1)Contract includes a promise, undertaking, contract, or agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied.(2)Consumer financial product or service has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 90005 of the Financial Code.(3)Debt means money, property, or their equivalent that is due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person to another person, including, but not limited to, for employment-related costs, education-related costs, or a consumer financial product or service.(4)Debtor means a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.(5)Education-related cost means a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.(6)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees or independent contractors or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, contractor, or third-party agent of an employer.(7)Employment-related cost means a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.(8)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.(b)Beginning January 1, 2024, except as provided in subdivision (c), an employer shall not enter into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated.(c)(1)An employer may require an employee to pay for training-related costs if they are incurred pursuant to a union-affiliated apprenticeship program.(2)An employer may require an employee to pay for the cost of maintaining professional licensure required by the state.(d)(1)This section applies to a contract or contractual term regardless of whether the debt is certain, contingent, or incurred voluntarily.(2)This section applies to a contract or contractual term in which a person promises to pay or forgive a debt, defers liability of a debt, or holds a debt in forbearance.(3)This section does not prevent a person or governmental entity from paying or forgiving a debt or from providing other benefits to a debtor or other natural person after the debtor or natural person completes a specified time period of employment or work relationship with an employer or other business entity.(4)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit or prohibit any loan repayment assistance program or loan forgiveness program provided by a federal, state, or local governmental agency, other than an individual agreement between an agency and its employee.(5)This section does not limit or alter the obligation of employers under Section 2802 of the Labor Code.SEC. 4.Section 16609 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16608, to read:16609.An employer shall not impose any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, a replacement hire fee, a retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, bondage fees, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.SEC. 5.Section 16610 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16609, to read:16610.(a)SEC. 3.Section 16610 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16610.(a)An employer shall not enter into, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under this chapter.
(b)(1)An employer that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of this chapter violates this section is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee.
(2)An employee or prospective employee may also bring an action for injunctive relief. relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties pursuant to this section. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(3)(A)The Attorney General shall receive and investigate complaints from persons alleging a violation of this section. section in coordination with the Labor Commissioner. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the Attorney General believes a violation has occurred, the Attorney General may bring an action to enforce this section pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200).
(B)The Labor Commissioner shall receive and investigate complaints alleging a violation of this section pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 926 of the Labor Code. section.
(b)The Attorney General and the Labor Commissioner shall coordinate responsibility with respect to enforcement of this section, according to the following:(1)The Attorney General and Labor Commissioner may enter into an agreement with respect to civil actions by each agency.(2)Any regulation or order made under the authority of this subdivision or any agreement under this subdivision shall not do any of the following:(A)Limit the powers or authorities of the Attorney General or Labor Commissioner, including, but not limited to, the Attorney Generals ability to prosecute violations of civil or criminal law and the Labor Commissioners ability to prosecute violations of the Labor Code.(B)Limit the rights of any person, or the obligations of any covered person, under this chapter, the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, or a consumer financial law.(C)Limit the rights of any employee under the Labor Code.(3)The Attorney General shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any complaint regarding a contract or contract term that may constitute a violation of this section.(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Consumer financial law means a federal or state law that directly and specifically regulates the manner, content, or terms and conditions of any financial transaction, or any account, product, or service related thereto, with respect to a consumer.(1) Contract in restraint of trade means any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind, including a contract described in this chapter.
(2)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(3)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
SEC. 6.SEC. 4.Section 925 of the Labor Code is amended to read:925.(a)An employer shall not require an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would do either of the following:
(1)Require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California.
(2)Deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
(b)Any provision of a contract that violates subdivision (a) is voidable by the employee, and if a provision is rendered void at the request of the employee, the matter shall be adjudicated in California and California law shall govern the dispute.
(c)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award an employee who is enforcing their rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)For purposes of this section, adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
(e)(1)This section shall not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied. For purposes of this subdivision, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
(2)The amendments made by the act adding this paragraph shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024. 2025.
(f)This section shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 7.Section 926 is added to the Labor Code, immediately following Section 925, to read:926.(a)A contract or contract term that violates subdivision (a) of Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code is void as contrary to public policy.(b)The Labor Commissioner shall enforce this section and subdivision (a) of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code, including receiving and investigating complaints of an alleged violation and ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation or to maintain the status quo pending the completion of a full investigation or hearing through the procedures set forth in Section 98, 98.3, or 1197.1, including by issuance of a citation against an employer who violates this article and by filing a civil action. If a citation is issued, the procedures for issuing, contesting, and enforcing judgments for citations and civil penalties issued by the Labor Commissioner shall be the same as those set out in Section 1197.1, as appropriate. If the Labor Commissioner issues a citation or files a civil action under this subdivision, the Labor Commissioner may, in addition to any other penalties or remedies available, seek penalties pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code.(c)The Labor Commissioner and the Attorney General shall coordinate responsibility with respect to enforcement of this section, according to the following:(1)The Labor Commissioner and the Attorney General may enter into an agreement with respect to civil actions by each agency.(2)Any regulation or order made under the authority of this section or any agreement under this section shall not do any of the following:(A)Limit the powers or authorities of the Attorney General or Labor Commissioner, including, but not limited to, the Attorney Generals ability to prosecute violations of civil or criminal law and the Labor Commissioners ability to prosecute violations of the Labor Code.(B)Limit the rights of any person, or the obligations of any covered person, under the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, or a federal or state law that directly and specifically regulates the manner, content, or terms and conditions of any financial transaction, or any account, product, or service related thereto, with respect to a consumer.(C)Limit the rights of any employee under the Labor Code.(3)The Labor Commissioner shall notify the Attorney General of any complaint regarding a contract or contract term that may constitute a violation of this section. (d)A person, including a local government or an employee representative, seeking to establish liability against an employer may bring a civil action on behalf of the person, other persons similarly situated, or both, in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable costs, including reasonable attorneys fees, as part of the costs, to any plaintiff who prevails in a civil action brought under this section.(e)This section does not limit the remedies available to a debtor or other natural person specified in Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code.(a)It may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement on the licensees behalf, or on behalf of their client, that violates Section 16608.
(b)For purposes of this section, employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
SEC. 2.Section 16601 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:16601.(a)Any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells (a) all or substantially all of its operating assets together with the goodwill of the business entity, (b) all or substantially all of the operating assets of a division or a subsidiary of the business entity together with the goodwill of that division or subsidiary, or (c) all of the ownership interest of any subsidiary, may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or corporation.
(2)Owner of a business entity means any partner, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), or any member, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or any owner of capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation.
(3)Ownership interest means any of the following:
(A)A partnership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership, including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total partnership interest of the entity.
(B)A membership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company, including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total membership interest of the entity.
(C)A capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation, that is more than 10-percent of the total shares of ownership of the corporation.
(4)Subsidiary means any business entity over which the selling business entity has voting control or from which the selling business entity has a right to receive a majority share of distributions upon dissolution or other liquidation of the business entity (or has both voting control and a right to receive these distributions.)
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Contract includes a promise, undertaking, contract, or agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied.
(2)Consumer financial product or service has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 90005 of the Financial Code.
(3)Debt means money, property, or their equivalent that is due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person to another person, including, but not limited to, for employment-related costs, education-related costs, or a consumer financial product or service.
(4)Debtor means a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
(5)Education-related cost means a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
(6)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees or independent contractors or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, contractor, or third-party agent of an employer.
(7)Employment-related cost means a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
(8)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(b)Except Beginning January 1, 2024, except as provided in subdivision (c), an employer shall not enter into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated.
(c)(1)An employer may require an employee to pay for training-related costs if they are incurred pursuant to a union-affiliated apprenticeship program.
(2)An employer may require an employee to pay for the cost of maintaining professional licensure required by the state.
(d)(1)This section applies to a contract or contractual term regardless of whether the debt is certain, contingent, or incurred voluntarily.
(2)This section applies to a contract or contractual term in which a person promises to pay or forgive a debt, defers liability of a debt, or holds a debt in forbearance.
(3)This section does not prevent a person or governmental entity from paying or forgiving a debt or from providing other benefits to a debtor or other natural person after the debtor or natural person completes a specified time period of employment or work relationship with an employer or other business entity.
(4)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit or prohibit any loan repayment assistance program or loan forgiveness program provided by a federal, state, or local governmental agency. agency, other than an individual agreement between an agency and its employee.
(5)This section does not limit or alter the obligation of employers under Section 2802 of the Labor Code.
SEC. 4.Section 16609 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16608, to read:16609.An employer shall not impose any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, a replacement hire fee, a retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, bondage fees, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
SEC. 5.Section 16610 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16609, to read:16610.(a)(1)An employer that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of this chapter is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee.
(2)An employee or prospective employee may also bring an action for injunctive relief. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(3)(A)The Attorney General shall receive and investigate complaints from persons alleging a violation of this section in coordination with the Labor Commissioner pursuant to Section 926 of the Labor Code. section. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the Attorney General believes a violation has occurred, the Attorney General may bring an action to enforce this section pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200).
(B)The Labor Commissioner shall receive and investigate complaints alleging a violation of this section pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 926 of the Labor Code.
(b)The Attorney General and the Labor Commissioner shall coordinate responsibility with respect to enforcement of this section, according to the following:
(1)The Attorney General and Labor Commissioner may enter into an agreement with respect to civil actions by each agency.
(2)Any regulation or order made under the authority of this subdivision or any agreement under this subdivision shall not do any of the following:
(A)Limit the powers or authorities of the Attorney General or Labor Commissioner, including, but not limited to, the Attorney Generals ability to prosecute violations of civil or criminal law and the Labor Commissioners ability to prosecute violations of the Labor Code.
(B)Limit the rights of any person, or the obligations of any covered person, under this chapter, the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, or a consumer financial law.
(C)Limit the rights of any employee under the Labor Code.
(3)The Attorney General shall notify the Labor Commissioner of any complaint regarding a contract or contract term that may constitute a violation of this section.
(b)(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Consumer financial law means a federal or state law that directly and specifically regulates the manner, content, or terms and conditions of any financial transaction, or any account, product, or service related thereto, with respect to a consumer.
(1)(2)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(2)(3)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
SEC. 6.Section 925 of the Labor Code is amended to read:925.(a)An employer shall not require an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would do either of the following:
(1)Require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California.
(2)Deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
(b)Any provision of a contract that violates subdivision (a) is voidable by the employee, and if a provision is rendered void at the request of the employee, the matter shall be adjudicated in California and California law shall govern the dispute.
(c)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award an employee who is enforcing their rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)For purposes of this section, adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
(e)(1)This section shall not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied. For purposes of this subdivision, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
(2)The amendments made by the act adding this paragraph shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024.
(f)This section shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 7.Section 926 is added to the Labor Code, immediately following Section 925, to read:926.(a)A contract or contract term that violates subdivision (a) of Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code is void as contrary to public policy.
(b)The Labor Commissioner shall enforce this section, section and subdivision (a) of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code, including receiving and investigating complaints of an alleged violation and ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation or to maintain the status quo pending the completion of a full investigation or hearing through the procedures set forth in Section 98, 98.3, or 1197.1, including by issuance of a citation against an employer who violates this article and by filing a civil action. If a citation is issued, the procedures for issuing, contesting, and enforcing judgments for citations and civil penalties issued by the Labor Commissioner shall be the same as those set out in Section 1197.1, as appropriate. If the Labor Commissioner issues a citation or files a civil action under this subdivision, the Labor Commissioner may, in addition to any other penalties or remedies available, seek penalties pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)The Labor Commissioner and the Attorney General shall coordinate responsibility with respect to enforcement of this section, according to the following:
(1)The Labor Commissioner and the Attorney General may enter into an agreement with respect to civil actions by each agency.
(2)Any regulation or order made under the authority of this section or any agreement under this section shall not do any of the following:
(A)Limit the powers or authorities of the Attorney General or Labor Commissioner, including, but not limited to, the Attorney Generals ability to prosecute violations of civil or criminal law and the Labor Commissioners ability to prosecute violations of the Labor Code.
(B)Limit the rights of any person, or the obligations of any covered person, under the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, or a federal or state law that directly and specifically regulates the manner, content, or terms and conditions of any financial transaction, or any account, product, or service related thereto, with respect to a consumer.
(C)Limit the rights of any employee under the Labor Code.
(3)The Labor Commissioner shall notify the Attorney General of any complaint regarding a contract or contract term that may constitute a violation of this section.
(c)(d)A person, including a local government or an employee representative, seeking to establish liability against an employer may bring a civil action on behalf of the person, other persons similarly situated, or both, in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable costs, including reasonable attorneys fees, as part of the costs, to any plaintiff who prevails in a civil action brought under this section.
(d)(e)This section does not limit the remedies available to a debtor or other natural person specified in Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)In carrying out their duties under this section, the Labor Commissioner shall coordinate with the Attorney General on the enforcement of a violation of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code.(a)It is may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates Section 16610. 16608.
(b)For purposes of this section, employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
SEC. 2.Section 16601 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:16601.(a)Any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells (a) all or substantially all of its operating assets together with the goodwill of the business entity, (b) all or substantially all of the operating assets of a division or a subsidiary of the business entity together with the goodwill of that division or subsidiary, or (c) all of the ownership interest of any subsidiary, may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or corporation.
(2)Owner of a business entity means any partner, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), or any member, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or any owner of capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation.
(3)Ownership interest means any of the following:
(A)A partnership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership, including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total partnership interest of the entity.
(B)A membership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company, including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total membership interest of the entity.
(C)A capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation, that is more than 10-percent of the total shares of ownership of the corporation.
(4)Subsidiary means any business entity over which the selling business entity has voting control or from which the selling business entity has a right to receive a majority share of distributions upon dissolution or other liquidation of the business entity (or has both voting control and a right to receive these distributions.)
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Contract includes a promise, undertaking, contract, or agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied.
(2)Consumer financial product or service has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 90005 of the Financial Code.
(3)Debt means money, property, or their equivalent that is due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person to another person, including, but not limited to, for employment-related costs, education-related costs, or a consumer financial product or service.
(4)Debtor means a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
(5)Education-related cost means a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
(6)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees or independent contractors or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, contractor, or third-party agent of an employer.
(7)Employment-related cost means a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
(8)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), an employer shall not enter into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with a specific the employer is terminated is a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business under this chapter. terminated.
(c)(1)An employer may require an employee to pay for training-related costs if they are incurred pursuant to a union-affiliated apprenticeship program.
(2)An employer may require an employee to pay for the cost of maintaining professional licensure required by the state.
(d)(1)This section applies to a contract or contractual term regardless of whether the debt is certain, contingent, or incurred voluntarily.
(2)This section applies to a contract or contractual term in which a person promises to pay or forgive a debt, defers liability of a debt, or holds a debt in forbearance.
(3)This section does not prevent a person or governmental entity from paying or forgiving a debt or from providing other benefits to a debtor or other natural person after the debtor or natural person completes a specified time period of employment or work relationship with an employer or other business entity.
(4)Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit or prohibit any loan repayment assistance program or loan forgiveness program provided by a federal, state, or local governmental agency.
(4)(5)This section does not limit or alter the obligation of employers under Section 2802 of the Labor Code.
SEC. 4.Section 16609 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16608, to read:16609.An employer shall not impose any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, replacement hire fee, retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
SEC. 5.Section 16610 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16609, to read:16610.(a)An employer shall not enter into, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under this chapter.(b)16610.(a)(1)An employer that violates this section enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of this chapter is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee. employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee.
(2)An employee or prospective employee may also bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties pursuant to this section. relief. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(3)The Attorney General shall receive and investigate complaints from debtors persons alleging a violation of this section in coordination with the Labor Commissioner pursuant to Section 926 of the Labor Code. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the Attorney General believes a violation has occurred, the Attorney General may bring an action to enforce this section pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200).
(c)(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Contract in restraint of trade means any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind, including a contract described in this chapter.(2)(1)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(3)(2)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
SEC. 6.Section 925 of the Labor Code is amended to read:925.(a)An employer shall not require an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would do either of the following:
(1)Require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California.
(2)Deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
(b)Any provision of a contract that violates subdivision (a) is voidable by the employee, and if a provision is rendered void at the request of the employee, the matter shall be adjudicated in California and California law shall govern the dispute.
(c)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award an employee who is enforcing their rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)For purposes of this section, adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
(e)(1)This section shall not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied. For purposes of this subdivision, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
(2)The amendments made by the act adding this paragraph shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024.
(f)This section shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 7.Section 926 is added to the Labor Code, immediately following Section 925, to read:926.(a)A contract or contract term that violates Section 16610 16608 of the Business and Professions Code is void as contrary to public policy.
(b)The Labor Commissioner shall enforce this section, including investigating an alleged violation and ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation or to maintain the status quo pending the completion of a full investigation or hearing through the procedures set forth in Section 98, 98.3, or 1197.1, including by issuance of a citation against an employer who violates this article and by filing a civil action. If a citation is issued, the procedures for issuing, contesting, and enforcing judgments for citations and civil penalties issued by the Labor Commissioner shall be the same as those set out in Section 1197.1, as appropriate.
(c)A person, including a local government or an employee representative, seeking to establish liability against an employer may bring a civil action on behalf of the person, other persons similarly situated, or both, in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable costs, including reasonable attorneys fees, as part of the costs, to any plaintiff who prevails in a civil action brought under this section.
(d)This section does not limit the remedies available to a debtor or other natural person specified in Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)In carrying out their duties under this section, the Labor Commissioner shall coordinate with the Attorney General on the enforcement of a violation of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code.
(a)It is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee or employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee or employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates Section 16610.
(b)For purposes of this section, employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
SEC. 2.Section 16601 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:16601.(a)Any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells (a) all or substantially all of its operating assets together with the goodwill of the business entity, (b) all or substantially all of the operating assets of a division or a subsidiary of the business entity together with the goodwill of that division or subsidiary, or (c) all of the ownership interest of any subsidiary, may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or corporation.
(2)Owner of a business entity means any partner, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), or any member, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or any owner of capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation.
(3)Ownership interest means any of the following:
(A)A partnership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership, including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total partnership interest of the entity.
(B)A membership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company, including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total membership interest of the entity.
(C)A capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation, that is more than 10-percent of the total shares of ownership of the corporation.
(4)Subsidiary means any business entity over which the selling business entity has voting control or from which the selling business entity has a right to receive a majority share of distributions upon dissolution or other liquidation of the business entity (or has both voting control and a right to receive these distributions.)
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Contract includes a promise, undertaking, contract, or agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied.
(2)Consumer financial product or service has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 90005 of the Financial Code.
(3)Debt means money, property, or their equivalent that is due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person to another person, including, but not limited to, for employment-related costs, education-related costs, or a consumer financial product or service.
(4)Debtor means a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
(5)Education-related cost means a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
(6)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees or independent contractors or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, contractor, or third-party agent of an employer.. employer.
(7)Employment-related cost means a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
(8)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated is a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business under this chapter.
(c)(1)An employer may require an employee to pay for training-related costs if they are incurred pursuant to a union-affiliated apprenticeship program.
(2)An employer may require an employee to pay for the cost of maintaining professional licensure required by the state.
(d)(1)This section applies to a contract or contractual term regardless of whether the debt is certain, contingent, or incurred voluntarily.
(2)This section applies to a contract or contractual term in which a person promises to pay or forgive a debt, defers liability of a debt, or holds a debt in forbearance.
(3)This section does not prevent a person or governmental entity from paying or forgiving a debt or from providing other benefits to a debtor or other natural person after the debtor or natural person completes a specified time period of employment or work relationship with an employer or other business entity.
(4)This section does not limit or alter the obligation of employers under Section 2802 of the Labor Code.
SEC. 4.Section 16609 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16608, to read:16609.An employer shall not impose any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, replacement hire fee, retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
SEC. 5.Section 16610 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16609, to read:16610.(a)An employer shall not enter into, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under this chapter.
(b)(1)An employer that violates this section is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee.
(2)An employee or prospective employee may bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties pursuant to this section. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(3)The Attorney General shall receive and investigate complaints from debtors alleging a violation of this section in coordination with the Labor Commissioner pursuant to Section 926 of the Labor Code. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the Attorney General believes a violation has occurred, the Attorney General may bring an action to enforce this section pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200).
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Contract in restraint of trade means any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind, including a contract described in this chapter.
(2)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(3)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
SEC. 6.Section 925 of the Labor Code is amended to read:925.(a)An employer shall not require an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would do either of the following:
(1)Require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California.
(2)Deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
(b)Any provision of a contract that violates subdivision (a) is voidable by the employee, and if a provision is rendered void at the request of the employee, the matter shall be adjudicated in California and California law shall govern the dispute.
(c)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award an employee who is enforcing their rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)For purposes of this section, adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
(e)(1)This section shall not apply to a contract with an employee who is individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate and, at the option of the employee, designates either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied. For purposes of this subdivision, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
(2)The amendments made by the act adding this paragraph shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024.
(f)This section shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 7.Section 926 is added to the Labor Code, immediately following Section 925, to read:926.(a)A contract or contract term that violates Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code is void as contrary to public policy.
(b)The Labor Commissioner shall enforce this section, including investigating an alleged violation and ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation or to maintain the status quo pending the completion of a full investigation or hearing through the procedures set forth in Section 98, 98.3, or 1197.1, including by issuance of a citation against an employer who violates this article and by filing a civil action. If a citation is issued, the procedures for issuing, contesting, and enforcing judgments for citations and civil penalties issued by the Labor Commissioner shall be the same as those set out in Section 1197.1, as appropriate.
(c)A person, including a local government or an employee representative, seeking to establish liability against an employer may bring a civil action on behalf of the person, other persons similarly situated, or both, in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable costs, including reasonable attorneys fees, as part of the costs, to any plaintiff who prevails in a civil action brought under this section.
(d)This section does not limit the remedies available to a debtor or other natural person specified in Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)In carrying out their duties under this section, the Labor Commissioner shall coordinate with the Attorney General on the enforcement of a violation of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.(a)It is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee or prospective employee, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates Section 16608. 16610.
(b)For purposes of this section, employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
SEC. 2.Section 16601 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:16601.(a)Any person who sells the goodwill of a business, any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells (a) all or substantially all of its operating assets together with the goodwill of the business entity, (b) all or substantially all of the operating assets of a division or a subsidiary of the business entity together with the goodwill of that division or subsidiary, or (c) all of the ownership interest of any subsidiary, may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or corporation.
(2)Owner of a business entity means any partner, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), or any member, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or any owner of capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation.
(3)Ownership interest means any of the following:
(A)A partnership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership, including a limited partnership a limited liability partnership, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total partnership interest of the entity.
(B)A membership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company, including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total membership interest of the entity.
(C)A capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation, that is more than 10-percent of the total shares of ownership of the corporation.
(4)Subsidiary means any business entity over which the selling business entity has voting control or from which the selling business entity has a right to receive a majority share of distributions upon dissolution or other liquidation of the business entity (or has both voting control and a right to receive these distributions.)
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.(a)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Contract includes a promise, undertaking, contract, or agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied.
(2)Consumer financial product or service has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 90005 of the Financial Code.
(3)Debt means money, property, or their equivalent that is due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person to another person, including, but not limited to, for employment-related costs, education-related costs, or a consumer financial product or service.
(4)Debtor means a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
(5)Education-related cost means a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
(6)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees or independent contractors or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, contractor, or third-party agent of an employer..
(7)Employment-related cost means a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
(8)Person means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
(b)Except as provided in subdivision (c), a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtors employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated is a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business under this chapter.
(c)(1)An employer may require an employee to pay for training-related costs if they are incurred pursuant to a union-affiliated apprenticeship program.
(2)An employer may require an employee to pay for the cost of maintaining professional licensure required by the state.
(d)(1)This section applies to a contract or contractual term regardless of whether the debt is certain, contingent, or incurred voluntarily.
(2)This section applies to a contract or contractual term in which a person promises to pay or forgive a debt, defers liability of a debt, or holds a debt in forbearance.
(3)This section does not prevent a person or governmental entity from paying or forgiving a debt or from providing other benefits to a debtor or other natural person after the debtor or natural person completes a specified time period of employment or work relationship with an employer or other business entity.
(4)This section does not limit or alter the obligation of employers under Section 2802 of the Labor Code.
SEC. 4.Section 16609 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16608, to read:16609.An employer shall not impose any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, replacement hire fee, retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.SEC. 5.Section 16610 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16609, to read:16610.(a)An employer shall not enter into, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any covenant not to compete contract in restraint of trade that is void under this chapter.
(b)(1)An employer that violates this section is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee who is harmed by the violation. employee.
(2)An employee or prospective employee may bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties pursuant to this section. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(3)The Attorney General shall receive and investigate complaints from debtors alleging a violation of this section in coordination with the Labor Commissioner pursuant to Section 926 of the Labor Code. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the Attorney General believes a violation has occurred, the Attorney General may bring an action to enforce this section pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200).
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Covenant not to compete Contract in restraint of trade means any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind. kind, including a contract described in this chapter.
(2)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(3)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
SEC. 4.SEC. 6.Section 925 of the Labor Code is amended to read:925.(a)An employer shall not require an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would do either of the following:
(1)Require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California.
(2)Deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
(b)Any provision of a contract that violates subdivision (a) is voidable by the employee, and if a provision is rendered void at the request of the employee, the matter shall be adjudicated in California and California law shall govern the dispute.
(c)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award an employee who is enforcing their rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)For purposes of this section, adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
(e)(1)This section shall not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied. For purposes of this subdivision, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
(2)The amendments made by the act adding this paragraph shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024.
(f)This section shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 5.Chapter 4.1 (commencing with Section 1058) is added to Part 3 of Division 2 of the Labor Code, to read:4.1.Training Costs and Debt1058.(a)An employer shall not require an employee to reimburse, pay, or repay, including upon termination of employment, costs for any training related to the employees responsibilities and duties related to their employment.(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:(1)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.(2)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.(3)(A)Training means any instruction or course the employer requires the employee to complete as a prerequisite to the employee fulfilling their responsibilities and duties related to their employment.(B)Training does not mean or include any required training to obtain or maintain necessary professional licenses and excludes required coursework, apprenticeship programs, work experience education programs, or other similar coursework and programs required before employment of the employee.SEC. 7.Section 926 is added to the Labor Code, immediately following Section 925, to read:926.(a)A contract or contract term that violates Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code is void as contrary to public policy.
(b)The Labor Commissioner shall enforce this section, including investigating an alleged violation and ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation or to maintain the status quo pending the completion of a full investigation or hearing through the procedures set forth in Section 98, 98.3, or 1197.1, including by issuance of a citation against an employer who violates this article and by filing a civil action. If a citation is issued, the procedures for issuing, contesting, and enforcing judgments for citations and civil penalties issued by the Labor Commissioner shall be the same as those set out in Section 1197.1, as appropriate.
(c)A person, including a local government or an employee representative, seeking to establish liability against an employer may bring a civil action on behalf of the person, other persons similarly situated, or both, in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable costs, including reasonable attorneys fees, as part of the costs, to any plaintiff who prevails in a civil action brought under this section.
(d)This section does not limit the remedies available to a debtor or other natural person specified in Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)In carrying out their duties under this section, the Labor Commissioner shall coordinate with the Attorney General on the enforcement of a violation of Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code.
(a)It is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee or prospective employee, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates Section 16608.
(b)For purposes of this section, employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
SEC. 2.Section 16601 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:16601.(a)Any person who sells the goodwill of a business, or any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of his or her their ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells (a) all or substantially all of its operating assets together with the goodwill of the business entity, (b) all or substantially all of the operating assets of a division or a subsidiary of the business entity together with the goodwill of that division or subsidiary, or (c) all of the ownership interest of any subsidiary, may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, so long as if the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein.
For(b)For the purposes of this section, business the following definitions apply:
(1)Business entity means any partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or corporation.
For the purposes of this section, owner(2)Owner of a business entity means any partner, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including a limited partnership or a limited liability partnership), or any member, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or any owner of capital stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation.
For the purposes of this section, ownership(3)Ownership interest means a any of the following:
(A)A partnership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a partnership (including partnership, including a limited partnership a limited liability partnership), a partnership, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total partnership interest of the entity.
(B)A membership interest, in the case of a business entity that is a limited liability company (including company, including a series of a limited liability company formed under the laws of a jurisdiction that recognizes such a series), or a series, that is more than a 10-percent interest of the total membership interest of the entity.
(C)A capital stockholder, stock, in the case of a business entity that is a corporation. corporation, that is more than 10-percent of the total shares of ownership of the corporation.
For the purposes of this section, subsidiary(4)Subsidiary means any business entity over which the selling business entity has voting control or from which the selling business entity has a right to receive a majority share of distributions upon dissolution or other liquidation of the business entity (or has both voting control and a right to receive these distributions.)
SEC. 3.Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:16608.(a)An employer shall not enter into, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any covenant not to compete that is void under this chapter.
(b)(1)An employer that violates this section is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee who is harmed by the violation.
(2)An employee or prospective employee may bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties pursuant to this section. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorneys fees.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Covenant not to compete means any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind.
(2)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(3)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
SEC. 4.Section 925 of the Labor Code is amended to read:925.(a)An employer shall not require an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would do either of the following:
(1)Require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California.
(2)Deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
(b)Any provision of a contract that violates subdivision (a) is voidable by the employee, and if a provision is rendered void at the request of the employee, the matter shall be adjudicated in California and California law shall govern the dispute.
(c)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award an employee who is enforcing his or her their rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(d)For purposes of this section, adjudication adjudication includes litigation and arbitration.
(e)(1)This section shall not apply to a contract with an employee who is in fact individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of an agreement to designate either the venue or forum in which a controversy arising from the employment contract may be adjudicated or the choice of law to be applied. For purposes of this subdivision, an employee is not considered individually represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employees employer.
(2)The amendments made by the act adding this paragraph shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024.
(f)This section shall apply to a contract entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2017.
SEC. 5.Chapter 4.1 (commencing with Section 1058) is added to Part 3 of Division 2 of the Labor Code, to read:4.1.Training Costs and Debt1058.(a)An employer shall not require an employee to reimburse, pay, or repay, including upon termination of employment, costs for any training related to the employees responsibilities and duties related to their employment.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Employee includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(2)Employer means any person or entity that employs employees.
(3)(A)Training means any instruction or course the employer requires the employee to complete as a prerequisite to the employee fulfilling their responsibilities and duties related to their employment.
(B)Training does not mean or include any required training to obtain or maintain necessary professional licenses and excludes required coursework, apprenticeship programs, work experience education programs, or other similar coursework and programs required before employment of the employee.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Died on third reading file. |
| Jan 25, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 3933.) |
| Jan 22, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 22, 2024 | From inactive file. |
| Jan 18, 2024 | Notice of intention to remove from inactive file given by Assembly Member McCarty. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Assembly Member McCarty. |
| May 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (May 18). |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 10, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (April 25). |
| Apr 13, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 12). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 4, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 4, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Apr 3, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 9, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Acclamation Insurance Management Services | ** Against | |
| Allied Managed Care | ** Against | |
| American Economic Liberties Project | ** Support | |
| Board of Registered Nursing | ** Support | |
| California Association For Health Services At Home | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Health Facilities | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Sheet Metal Air Conditioning Contractors National Association | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Winegrape Growers | ** Against | |
| California Attractions And Parks Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Roundtable | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Employment Law Council | ** Against | |
| California Employment Lawyers Association | ** Support | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Support | |
| California League of Food Producers | ** Against | |
| California Lodging Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Manufactures & Technology Association | ** Against | |
| California New Car Dealers Association | ** Against | |
| California Nurses Association | ** Support | |
| California Restaurant Association | ** Against | |
| California Retailers Association | ** Against | |
| California Trucking Association | ** Against | |
| Coalition of Small & Disabled Veteran Businesses | ** Against | |
| Construction Employers' Association | ** Against | |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| Democracy Policy Network | ** Support | |
| Family Business Association of California | ** Against | |
| Flasher Barricade Association | ** Against | |
| hollywood chamber of commerce | ** Against | |
| Independent Lodging Industry Association. | ** Against | |
| Official Police Garage Association Of Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| People’s Parity Project, UCLA Law | ** Support | |
| Small Business Majority | ** Support | |
| Student Borrower Protection Center | ** Support | |
| TechEquity Collaborative | ** Support | |
| Western Electrical Contractors Association | ** Against |
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 747
Author:(McCarty)
As Amended Ver:January 25, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits an employer from entering into, presenting an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void, as specified. An employer that violates this prohibition is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty per employee.
Major Provisions
- Provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee of the State Bar to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement in restraint of trade.
- Modifies, in the context of contracts in restraint of trade, the definition of "ownership interest" to require that a partnership interest, a membership interest, or capital stock, be more than 10% of the total partnership interest, total membership interest, or total shares.
- Prohibits an employer from entering into, presenting an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under the bill.
- Defines a "contract in restraint of trade" to mean any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind, as specified.
- Provides that an employer that violates the prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee.
- Authorizes an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties, as specified. A prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney's fees.
- Requires the Attorney General (AG) to receive and investigate complaints from persons alleging a violation in coordination with the Labor Commissioner. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the AG believes a violation has occurred, the AG may bring an action to enforce this section.
- Provides that, for a contract with an out of state adjudication clause that is entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2025, an employee is not considered represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employee's employer.
COMMENTS
In January 2023, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) made headlines when it announced a proposed rule to ban noncompete clauses in contracts for employment. In its press release, the FTC noted that "companies use noncompetes for workers across industries and job levels, from hairstylists and warehouse workers to doctors and business executives. In many cases, employers use their outsized bargaining power to coerce workers into signing these contracts. Noncompetes harm competition in U.S. labor markers by blocking workers from pursuing better opportunities and by preventing employers from hiring the best available talent.[1]"
Similar to AB 747, the FTC proposed rule would ban noncompetes covering both employees and independent contractors. It would also ban "de-facto" noncompetes, so that clauses with the effect of prohibiting a worker from seeking or obtaining other employment or opening up a business would be illegal. Finally, it would require employers to notify current and former employees who we were previously subject to a noncompete that it is no longer in effect.
According to the Author
"Noncompetes, while unenforceable in California, are still being included in 1 of 5 worker contracts. They reduce worker wages, hurt consumer choices, and stunt innovation and new business creation. In fact, economists estimate that noncompetes lower U.S. workers' collective income by more than $250 billion per year. AB 747 prevents employers and attorneys from including these exploitative and deceptive agreements in worker contracts.”
The author further contends that the bill will assist underserved and marginalized communities because "low wage workers are especially vulnerable if they are unaware that the noncompete is unenforceable. This traps the low wage worker, more often a BIPOC, in a job even if they have identified either 1) a career with a higher wage with a new employer, or 2) the desire to create a small business. All workers and consumers will immediately benefit."
Arguments in Support
The Democracy Policy Network, co-sponsor of the bill, states, "California courts will not enforce non-compete agreements, yet an estimated 45% of businesses continue to require workers to sign them as a condition of employment. This is an inherently deceptive business practice. AB 747 would hold those who engage in this deceptive practice accountable and provide relief to workers who have been harmed by invalid agreements.
The cost of invalid non-compete agreements is enormous. Using the Federal Trade Commission's estimate that non-compete agreements cost workers $300 billion nationally, we can infer that void non-competes likely cost Californians tens of billions of dollars every year. Non-compete agreements have also been shown to harm innovation and prevent workers from starting their own businesses.
Non-compete agreements can also cause artificial labor shortages that make it harder to respond to crises like pandemics."
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, are opposed and state, "We have concerns about the consequences of the proposed amendment to Business and Professions Code section 16601. Company ownership hinges substantially on how the company is financed. It is not uncommon in a company for one entity or individual to own a substantial amount of the entity and others who are intimately involved in the creation and operations to own far less. Despite the unequal ownership interest, the remaining individuals with less than 10% of interest are not unequal in their knowledge and participation in the business or their ability to subsequently directly compete with that business.
Under the proposed language, one or more of those individuals could sell all of their interest in the entity to a third party, receive payment in exchange for that interest, and then immediately compete with the entity. Further, it is arbitrary that most partners could go compete while the one who owns the more substantial interest over 10% could not."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Annual cost pressures (General Fund (GF) or Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount, potentially in the mid-hundreds of thousands of dollars or more, to the courts in additional workload. This bill authorizes a cause of action, brought by an employee, the AG, or LC, against an employer that enters into or seeks to enforce specified contracts. It is unclear how many actions may be filed statewide, but the estimated workload cost of one hour of court time is $1,000. If 10 cases are filed statewide resulting in 20 hours of court time for each case, costs would be approximately $200,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on staff and the TCTF may create a need for increased court funding from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. The Governor's 2023-24 state budget already proposes $109.3 million in ongoing GF revenue to continue backfilling the TCTF for expected revenue declines.
- Costs of approximately $841,000 in fiscal year 2023-24 and $1.5 million annually thereafter to the AG to receive, process, investigate, and potentially litigate an increase in complaints regarding prohibited contracts. The AG anticipates needing eight new positions to accommodate this increased workload (GF).
- Annual costs of an unknown, but likely significant amount, in excess of $150,000, to the LC to investigate complaints, issue citations, and bring enforcement actions
VOTES
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-2-0
YES: Kalra, Haney, Ortega, Reyes, Ward
NO: Flora, Chen
ASM JUDICIARY: 7-3-1
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Pacheco
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: January 25, 2024
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002621
Federal Trade Commission, Press Release, "FTC Proposes Rule to Ban Noncompete Clauses, Which Hurt Workers and Harm Competition," January 5, 2023. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 747
Author:(McCarty)
As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Provides for coordinated enforcement between the Attorney General (AG) and the Labor Commissioner (LC) for violations of the prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade in employment. Additionally prohibits an employer from entering into a contract or a contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor's employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, with limited exceptions.
Major Provisions
- Modifies, in the context of contracts in restraint of trade, the definition of "ownership interest" to require that a partnership interest, a membership interest, or capital stock, be more than 10% of the total partnership interest, total membership interest, or total shares.
- Prohibits an employer from entering into a contract or a contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor's employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated, with limited exceptions.
- Defines "debtor" to mean a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
- Defines "education-related cost" to mean a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
- Defines "employment-related cost" to mean a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
- Prohibits an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, a replacement hire fee, a retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, bondage fees, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
- Provides that it may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee of the State Bar to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement on the licensee's behalf, or on behalf of their client, that violates the prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade.
- Provides that an employer that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in restraint of trade is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of up to $5,000 per employee or prospective employee.
- Authorizes an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief. A prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney's fees.
- Requires the AG to receive and investigate complaints from persons alleging a violation of the prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade in coordination with the LC in her capacity to investigate alleged violations, hold hearings, issue citations, and file a civil action. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the AG believes a violation has occurred, the AG may bring an action to enforce this section.
- Provides that the AG and LC shall coordinate enforcement as described in 10) above according to the following:
- The AG and the LC may enter into an agreement with respect to civil actions by each agency.
- Any regulation or order made under this authority or any agreement entered into shall not do any of the following:
- Limit the powers or authorities of the AG or LC, including, but not limited to, the AG's ability to prosecute violations of civil or criminal law and the LC's ability to prosecute violations of the Labor Code.
- Limit the rights of any person, or the obligations of any covered person, under this chapter, the Unfair Competition Law, the False Advertising Law, or a consumer financial law, as defined.
- Limit the rights of any employee under the Labor Code.
- The AG shall notify the LC of any complaint regarding a contract or contract term that may constitute a violation of these provisions.
- Provides that, for a contract with an out of state adjudication clause that is entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, an employee is not considered represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employee's employer.
COMMENTS
In January 2023, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) made headlines when it announced a proposed rule to ban noncompete clauses in contracts for employment. In its press release, the FTC noted that "companies use noncompetes for workers across industries and job levels, from hairstylists and warehouse workers to doctors and business executives. In many cases, employers use their outsized bargaining power to coerce workers into signing these contracts. Noncompetes harm competition in United States (U.S.) labor markers by blocking workers from pursuing better opportunities and by preventing employers from hiring the best available talent.[1]"
Similar to AB 747, the FTC proposed rule would ban noncompetes covering both employees and independent contractors. It would also ban "de-facto" noncompetes, so that clauses with the effect of prohibiting a worker from seeking or obtaining other employment or opening up a business would be illegal. Finally, it would require employers to notify current and former employees who we were previously subject to a noncompete that it is no longer in effect.
According to the Author
"Noncompetes, while unenforceable in California, are still being included in 1 of 5 worker contracts. They reduce worker wages, hurt consumer choices, and stunt innovation and new business creation. In fact, economists estimate that noncompetes lower U.S. workers' collective income by more than $250 billion per year. AB 747 prevents employers and attorneys from including these exploitative and deceptive agreements in worker contracts."
The author further contends that the bill will assist underserved and marginalized communities because "low wage workers are especially vulnerable if they are unaware that the noncompete is unenforceable. This traps the low wage worker, more often a BIPOC, in a job even if they have identified either 1) a career with a higher wage with a new employer, or 2) the desire to create a small business. All workers and consumers will immediately benefit. Finally, doing away with noncompetes and employer driven debt would likely lower consumer prices in the healthcare sector, to the tune of $150 billion a year."
Arguments in Support
The Democracy Policy Network, co-sponsor of this bill, states, "California courts will not enforce non-compete agreements, yet an estimated 45% of businesses continue to require workers to sign them as a condition of employment. This is an inherently deceptive business practice. AB 747 would hold those who engage in this deceptive practice accountable and provide relief to workers who have been harmed by invalid agreements.
The cost of invalid non-compete agreements is enormous. Using the Federal Trade Commission's estimate that non-compete agreements cost workers $300 billion nationally, we can infer that void non-competes likely cost Californians tens of billions of dollars every year. Non-compete agreements have also been shown to harm innovation and prevent workers from starting their own businesses.
Non-compete agreements can also cause artificial labor shortages that make it harder to respond to crises like pandemics."
The California Nurses Association/National Nurses United, co-sponsor of the bill, also argues in support that "Employer-driven debt is often mandated as a condition of employment for nurses and other workers required to enter a profession. Employers force nurses and other workers to repay work-related expenses by requiring the worker to work minimum periods of time as a form of repayment towards the alleged debt. If the worker quits or is terminated for any reason before the end of the labor contract period, they are required to repay the costs of the alleged debt or pay a high financial penalty. Employers use the threat of financial ruin to keep workers out of unions, silence whistleblowers, and lock them into low-wage positions. In other words, the kind of employer-driven debt that many nurses and other workers face today is a modern-day form of indentured servitude.
For nurses, employer debt traps prevent them from acting collectively to improve hospital working conditions for themselves, their coworkers, and their patients. Importantly, when employers hold workers hostage as debtors, it makes it difficult for nurses to speak out about unsafe working conditions and to advocate for their patients to ensure they receive safe and effective nursing care. Ultimately, patients and other consumers suffer as a result of employer-driven debt."
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, are opposed and state, "…AB 747 would prohibit an employer from requiring that the worker remain at the company for a certain amount of time after receiving a benefit. Any requirement that the worker pay back the signing bonus would be considered a "contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business," subjecting the employer to penalties, including penalties under PAGA. The unintended consequence of this bill is that it removes the incentive for employers to offer these benefits programs. In effect, AB 747 does not help workers – it hurts them.
The intent behind Sections 3 and 4 of AB 747 appears to be aimed at prohibiting employers from requiring specific training and then saddling employees with a bill for that training upon termination of employment. That scenario is already addressed under Labor Code section 2802. Under section 2802, employers must reimburse employees for all necessary expenses and/or losses incurred in the course and scope of their employment. Courts have interpreted this provision quite broadly in favor of the employee. For example, if an employee makes a mistake at work that costs the employer money – such as damaging valuable equipment – the employee cannot be required to reimburse the employer. Or if the employer requires the employee to use their cell phone to conduct work, the employer must provide reimbursement, even if the employee is not incurring any additional cost because they have an unlimited data plan."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Annual cost pressures (General Fund (GF) or Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount, potentially in the mid-hundreds of thousands of dollars or more, to the courts in additional workload. This bill authorizes a cause of action, brought by an employee, the AG, or LC, against an employer that enters into or seeks to enforce specified contracts. It is unclear how many actions may be filed statewide, but the estimated workload cost of one hour of court time is $1,000. If 10 cases are filed statewide resulting in 20 hours of court time for each case, costs would be approximately $200,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on staff and the TCTF may create a need for increased court funding from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. The Governor's 2023-24 state budget already proposes $109.3 million in ongoing GF revenue to continue backfilling the TCTF for expected revenue declines.
- Costs of approximately $841,000 in fiscal year 2023-24 and $1.5 million annually thereafter to the AG to receive, process, investigate, and potentially litigate an increase in complaints regarding prohibited contracts. The AG anticipates needing eight new positions to accommodate this increased workload (GF).
- Annual costs of an unknown, but likely significant amount, in excess of $150,000, to the LC to investigate complaints, issue citations, and bring enforcement actions.
VOTES
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-2-0
YES: Kalra, Haney, Ortega, Reyes, Ward
NO: Flora, Chen
ASM JUDICIARY: 7-3-1
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Pacheco
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: May 18, 2023
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000579
Federal Trade Commission, Press Release, "FTC Proposes Rule to Ban Noncompete Clauses, Which Hurt Workers and Harm Competition," January 5, 2023. ↑
Date of Hearing: May 10, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 747
Author:(McCarty) – As Amended Ver:April 26, 2023
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
Judiciary | 7 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits an employer from entering into a contract that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated.
Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that an employer that enters into or seeks to enforce a contract requiring a debtor to pay for a debt upon termination of the debtor’s employment or work relationship with the employer is liable in a civil action for actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee. The employee or prospective employee may bring an action for injunctive relief and is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney’s fees. Another entity, including a local government or an employee representative, may also bring a civil action on behalf of the employee or other persons similarly situated. Entering into such a prohibited contract may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline if the employer is a licensee of the State Bar of California. A contract entered into in violation of this prohibition is void.
- Requires the Attorney General (AG), in coordination with the Labor Commissioner (LC), to receive and investigate allegations of such prohibited contracts and authorizes the AG to bring an enforcement action in court if the AG believes a violation occurred.
- Requires the LC, in coordination with the AG, to provide enforcement against such prohibited contracts, including investigating an alleged violation, ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation, issuing a citation, and filing a civil action.
- Prohibits an employer from imposing a penalty, fee, or cost on an employee for terminating the employment relationship.
- Modifies the definition of “ownership interest” in the context of noncompete agreements.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual cost pressures (General Fund (GF) or Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount, potentially in the mid-hundreds of thousands of dollars or more, to the courts in additional workload. This bill authorizes a cause of action, brought by an employee, the AG, or LC, against an employer that enters into or seeks to enforce specified contracts. It is unclear how many actions may be filed statewide, but the estimated workload cost of one hour of court time is $1,000. If 10 cases are filed statewide resulting in 20 hours of court time for each case, costs would be approximately $200,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on staff and the TCTF may create a need for increased court funding from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. The Governor’s 2023-24 state budget already proposes $109.3 million in ongoing GF revenue to continue backfilling the TCTF for expected revenue declines.
- Costs of approximately $841,000 in fiscal year 2023-24 and $1.5 million annually thereafter to the AG to receive, process, investigate, and potentially litigate an increase in complaints regarding prohibited contracts. The AG anticipates needing eight new positions to accommodate this increased workload (GF).
- Annual costs of an unknown, but likely significant amount, in excess of $150,000, to the LC to investigate complaints, issue citations, and bring enforcement actions.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Noncompetes, while unenforceable in California, are still being included in 1 of 5 worker contracts. They reduce worker wages, hurt consumer choices, and stunt innovation and new business creation. In fact, economists estimate that Noncompetes lower U.S. workers’ collective income by more than $250 billion per year. AB 747 prevents employers and attorneys from including these exploitative and deceptive agreements in worker contracts.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is co-sponsored by the American Economic Liberties Project, California Nurses Association (CNA), and Democracy Policy Network. For its part, CNA argues “Employers use the threat of financial ruin to keep workers out of unions, silence whistleblowers, and lock them into low-wage positions…the kind of employer-driven debt that many nurses and other workers face today is a modern-day form of indentured servitude.” This bill is also supported by attorneys associations, the California Labor Federation, and Small Business Majority.
This bill is opposed by a coalition of employer organizations led by the California Chamber of Commerce, which argues this bill will “disincentivize voluntary benefits programs for employees and is duplicative of existing law regarding mandatory trainings. It imposes significant penalties for any good faith error, including potential disbarment for an attorney, and improperly sweeps in independent contractors.”
- Background.
Noncompete Agreements. Noncompete agreements are contracts that prohibit an employee of or partner to a business from engaging in competition against the employer. Noncompete agreements arising after an employee has left the employer have largely been held unenforceable under California law, recognizing the inherent power dynamic between an employee and their employer and that an employer should not be authorized to restrict an individual from engaging in what would otherwise be lawful economic activity.
Training Repayment Agreements. Training repayment agreements, also referred to as training repayment agreement provisions (TRAPs), are similar contracts between an employer and employee requiring the employee to pay for various training programs if the employee elects to leave their job before a set date. While these programs are often well-intentioned opportunities for professional growth, TRAPs can also lead to poor working conditions. For example, an employment contract may provide the employee job-related training, but require the employee to work a minimum specified term or else shoulder the financial burden of the training. In the event the employee begins to experience workplace harassment or abuse, the employee would be faced with the decision to stay, despite the negative conditions, or leave, but assume potentially significant debt. Proponents of such programs argue the requirement for an employee to stay a certain period of time is necessary to stave off economic loss and lessen the burden of costly turnover.
This bill expands existing limitations on noncompete agreements by prohibiting contracts that require a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with the employer is terminated. This prohibition can be enforced by an employee subject to such a contract or either the AG or LC in collaboration with each other. However, as highlighted in the Assembly Judiciary Committee’s analysis of this bill:
[T]here is arguably a distinction between the types of trainings often included in TRAP agreements – such as trainings directly related to the type of job helped by the employee and those necessary to complete the job requirements – and programs offered by an employer that are distinct and in addition to the type of work considered by the employee’s position. Moreover, it is not unreasonable to conclude that prohibiting employers from even requiring that their employee remain in the position for the duration of the program in order to receive the full financial benefit could risk disincentivizing employers from providing these programs to begin with. To the extent this bill invalidates all such contracts, the author may wish to consider narrowing its application to exempt programs which, for example, offer financial assistance for secondary degree programs that are not a necessary qualification for the employee’s position.
The analysis also notes the author may wish to consider amending the bill to apply prospectively to any new contracts beginning January 1, 2024, and specifying a lead agency between the AG and LC so a claimant has a clear first point of contact.
- Related Legislation. AB 1076 (Bauer-Kahan) codifies the case of Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP (2008) 44 Cal.4th 937, which provides that noncompete agreements in an employment context and noncompete clauses within employment contracts are void, even if the agreements are narrowly tailored. AB 1076 is pending in this committee.
SB 699 (Caballero) provides that a noncompete contract is unenforceable regardless of where and when the contract was signed and subjects an employer who enters into such a contract to liability in an action brought by the AG or an employee. SB 699 is pending on the Senate Committee on Appropriations’ suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 25, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 747
Author:McCarty – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2023
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Business: unlawful employee contracts and requirements
KEY ISSUES:
- should employers be prohibited from entering into a contract or contract term that requires an employee to assume a debt if the employment is terminated?
- should an employer be liable to an employee for entering into, attempting to enter into, or attempting to enforce a contract that IS an unlawful contract or contract term?
SYNOPSIS
Noncompete agreements, or contracts that prohibit an employee or partner to a business from engaging in competition against the employer, affect nearly 20% of workers nationwide, with somewhere between 30 – 46% of workers in the private sector being subject to such an agreement. Noncompete agreements arising after an employee has left the employer seeking to enforce the agreement have largely been held to be unenforceable under California law. Akin to the issue of noncompete agreements, training repayment agreements (TRAs), also called training repayment agreement provisions (TRAPs), refer to contracts between an employer and employee requiring the employee to pay for various training programs if the employee elects to leave their job before a set date. While the programs are often presented as well-intentioned opportunities for professional growth, they can often create a breeding ground for poor working conditions.
This bill aims to expand on existing limitations on noncompete agreements. First, as currently written, the bill defines “a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated” as a “contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful, profession, trade, or business.” Further, the bill creates an enforcement mechanism that exposes employers who enter into or attempt to enforce invalid contracts to liability, including actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee or prospective employee. Finally, in an attempt to ensure robust enforcement, the bill also authorizes collaborative enforcement between the Office of the Attorney General and the Labor Commissioner’s office. As currently written, this bill suffers from an unfitting conflation of noncompete clauses and contractual agreements to assume debt upon termination of employment. In order to disengage the two distinct issues, the author proposes to amend the bill as discussed in the COMMENTS section of this analysis. The author also proposes various clarifying amendments.
This bill is sponsored by the American Economic Liberties Project, the California Nurses Association (CNA), and the Democracy Policy Network. It is further supported by several business and labor organizations including the Board of Registered Nursing, the California Labor Federation, the Student Borrower Protection Center, the Consumer Attorneys of California, and the Small Business Majority. It is opposed by a significant coalition of business advocates including the California Chamber of Commerce and Allied Managed Care. This bill was previously heard by the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment and passed on a vote of 5-2.
SUMMARY: Prohibits an employer from entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated, and imposes civil liability on an employer who enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of the chapter. Specifically, this bill:
- Modifies, in the context of contracts in restraint of trade, the definition of “ownership interest” to require that a partnership interest, a membership interest, or capital stock, be more than 10% of the total partnership interest, total membership interest, or total shares.
- Prohibits an employer from entering into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with an employer is terminated, subject to specified exceptions.
- Defines the following for purposes of 2):
- “Contract” includes a promise, undertaking, contract, or agreement, whether written or oral, express or implied.
- “Consumer financial product or service” has the same meaning as existing law.
- “Debt” means money, property, or their equivalent that is due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person to another natural person, including, but not limited to, for employment-related costs, education-related costs, or a consumer financial product or service.
- “Debtor” means a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
- “Education-related cost” means a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
- “Employer” means any person or entity that employs employees or independent contractors or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, contractor, or third-party agent of an employer.
- “Employment-related cost” means a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
- “Person” means a natural person or an entity, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, association, trust, limited liability company, cooperative, or other organization.
- Prohibits an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, a replacement hire fee, retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
- Provides that it may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee of the State Bar to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates the prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade.
- Provides that an employer that enters into a contract in violation of the chapter, including 2) is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee.
- Further authorizes an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties, as provided. A prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney’s fees.
- Requires the Attorney General (AG) to receive and investigate complaints submitted pursuant to 6) and requires the AG to coordinate with the Labor Commissioner (LC) in her capacity to investigate alleged violations, hold hearings, issue citations, and file a civil action. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the AG believes a violation has occurred, the AG may bring an action to enforce this section.
- Provides that, for a contract with an out of state adjudication clause that is entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, an employee is not considered represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employee’s employer.
- Makes a contract or contract term that violates 2) void as contrary to public policy for purposes of the Labor Code.
- Authorizes the LC to enforce 10) including investigating an alleged violation and ordering appropriate temporary relief to mitigate the violation.
- Authorizes a person, including a local government or an employee representative, to bring a civil action on behalf of the person, other persons similarly situated, or both, in any court of competent jurisdiction. Authorizes recovery of reasonable costs, including reasonable attorney’s fees.
- Requires the LC to coordinate with the AG for enforcement pursuant to 10).
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is void, subject to limited exceptions. (Business & Professions Code Section 16600.)
- Provides that any person who sells the goodwill of a business, or any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of his or her ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or interests may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business is sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, so long as the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. (Business and Professions Code section 16601.)
- Defines “ownership interest” to mean a partnership interest, a membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as specified. (Business and Professions Code section 16601.)
- Establishes the State Bar Act that provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California. (Business and Professions Code section 6000 et seq.)
- Establishes the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement, of which the state Labor Commissioner is chief, to ensure that minimum labor standards are adequately enforced. (Labor Code Sections 82 and 90.5.)
- Prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. (Labor Code Section 925.)
- Provides an exception to the prohibition described in 6) if the employee is individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of the agreement to designate either the venue or forum for claim adjudication. (Labor Code Section 925.)
- Requires an employer to indemnify an employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of the employee’s duties. (Labor Code Section 2802.)
- Provides that the expense or cost of any employer-provided or employer-required educational program or training, as defined, for an employee providing direct patient care or an applicant for direct patient care employment constitutes a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of the employee’s duties. (Labor Code Section 2802.1.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Noncompete agreements, or contracts that prohibit someone from engaging in competition against the employer, affect nearly 20% of workers nationwide, with somewhere between 30 – 46% of workers in the private sector being subject to such an agreement. (Alexander J.S. Colvin and Heidi Shierholz, Noncompete agreements: Ubiquitous, harmful to wages and to competition, and part of a growing trend of employers requiring workers to sign away their rights, Economic Policy Institute, December 10, 2019 available at: https://www.epi.org/publication/noncompete-agreements/.) Critics of noncompete agreements argue that they not only harm workers by limiting their employment options or mobility, but also harm businesses by contributing to “brain drain” and forcing talent to relocate to jurisdictions where noncompete agreements are unenforceable. (https://hbswk.hbs.edu/item/non-competes-push-talent-away.) Noncompete agreements arising after an employee has left the employer seeking to enforce the agreement have largely been held to be contrary to public policy and therefore unenforceable under California law. The approach has recognized the inherent power dynamic between workers and their employers, and that employers should not be authorized to restrict an individual from engaging in what would otherwise be lawful economic activity.
Akin to the issue of noncompete agreements, training repayment agreements (TRAs), also called training repayment agreement provisions (TRAPs), refer to contracts between an employer and employee requiring the employee to pay for training programs if the employee elects to leave their job before a set date. While the programs are often presented as well-intentioned opportunities for professional growth, they can often create a breeding ground for poor working conditions. For example, a worker who is desperate for any job due to mounting debt may seize an opportunity to work in a position that also offers them job-related training. On its face, this offer would seem ideal – the job provides economic stability and potential for professional growth. However, a TRA includes a clause in the employment contract that requires the worker to stay for a specified period of time or otherwise shoulder the financial burden of the training. In the event the worker begins to experience workplace harassment or abuse, they would ultimately be faced with the decision of staying despite the negative conditions or leaving but having to assume potentially significant debt.
Proponents of these programs argue that the requirement for employees to stay for a certain period of time is necessary in order to stave off economic loss and lessen the burden of costly turnover. Opponents, on the other hand, compare such programs to indentured servitude. (Karla L. Miller, Work Advice: training debt can keep employees trapped at jobs, The Washington Post February 9, 2023 available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/02/09/training-repayment-agreement-worker-debt/.)
According to the author:
Noncompetes, while unenforceable in California, are still being included in 1 of 5 worker contracts. They reduce worker wages, hurt consumer choices, and stunt innovation and new business creation. In fact, economists estimate that noncompetes lower U.S. workers’ collective income by more than $250 billion per year. AB 747 prevents employers and attorneys from including these exploitative and deceptive agreements in worker contracts.
This bill aims to expand on existing limitations on noncompete agreements. First, as currently written, the bill defines “a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated” as a “contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful, profession, trade, or business.” Further, the bill creates an enforcement mechanism that exposes employers who enter into or attempt to enforce invalid contracts to liability, include actual damages and an additional penalty of $5,000 per employee or prospective employee. Finally, in an attempt to ensure robust enforcement, the bill also authorizes collaborative enforcement between the Office of the Attorney General and the Labor Commissioner’s office. Additionally, the bill adds a provision to the Labor Code establishing that contracts or contract terms in violation of the bill’s provision are void as contrary to public policy. The bill authorizes enforcement of this new section by the Labor Commissioner as well as through a civil claim brought by a person, including a local government or an employee representative on behalf of the person harmed, or other persons similarly situated.
While well-intentioned, the bill as currently written appears to improperly conflate TRAP agreements with noncompete clauses. Original common law allowed contractual restraints on lawful business practices, so long as they were reasonable. (Bosley Medical Group v. Abramson (1984) 161 Cal.App.3d 284.) However, in 1872, California opted to impose stricter limitations on such contractual restraints, instead opting to favor policy that would support competition in trade. This decision resulted in the enactment of Civil Code Section 1673, subsequently renumbered and moved to Business and Professions Code Section 16600. Section 16600 states “Except as provided in this chapter, every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void.” Subject to various statutory exceptions, the impact of this section is to invalidate any attempt at a noncompete agreement (or a contract in restraint of trade) that would improperly prohibit individuals from engaging in a lawful business. There is extensive case law on this matter, but one case in particular has cemented the prohibition on noncompete clauses in California. In Edwards v. Arthur Andersen LLP, the California Supreme Court held that “[n]oncompetition agreements are invalid under section 16600 in California, even if narrowly drawn, unless they fall within the applicable statutory exceptions[.]” (Edwards v. Arthur Anderson LLP, 44 Cal. 4th 937, 955 (2008).)
While Edwards v. Arthur Andersen has largely been viewed as the final determination regarding the invalidity of noncompete clauses imposing restrictions on employees after leaving the employer, case law has also determined that noncompete clauses imposing restrictions on employees during their time with the employer are not as undeniably void. The court in Techno Lite, Inc. v. Emcod, LLC addressed just this issue – whether an agreement by an employee to refrain from interfering with their current employer’s business was void as an unreasonable interference pursuant to Business and Professions Code 16600. In Techno Lite, a business sued its employees on various grounds, including breach of fiduciary duty, misappropriation of trade secrets, and interference with contractual relationships, after the employees began their own business selling similar products as their employer. The employees argued that they began their business in response to, and in preparation for, their employer going out of business. In their response, the employees argued that any agreement not to compete with their employer was void under Section 16600, and cited Edwards v. Arthur Andersen. (Techno Lite, Inc. v. Emcode, LLC, 44 Cal. App. 5th 462, 466 – 468 (2020).) The court ultimately determined, however, “Edwards did not address – much less invalidate – agreements by employees not to undermine their employer’s business by surreptitiously competing with it while being paid by the employer.” (Techno Lite v. Emcod, LLC, supra 44 Cal. App.5th at p. 472). Further, the court wrote:
[T]he public policy behind Section 16600 is to ensure ‘that every citizen shall retain the right to pursue any lawful employment and enterprise of their choice’ […] and to encourage ‘open competition and employee mobility’ […]; it is not to immunize employees who undermine their employer by competing with it while still employed. […] ‘We state the obvious in observing that no ‘firmly established principle of public policy’ authorizes an employee to assist his employer’s competitors.’ […] It should be even more obvious that no firmly established principle of public policy authorizes an employee to become his employer’s competitor while still employed. Section 16600 is not an invitation to employees to bite the hand that feeds them. (Ibid. at p. 653. Internal citations omitted.)
In sum, while the Legislature and courts have reliably established that noncompete agreements limiting employees’ opportunities after leaving their employer are void as a matter of public policy and therefore unenforceable, they have not said the same regarding such agreements affecting an employee’s limitations during employment.
As currently written, the bill proposes to expand the definition of an unlawful contract in restraint of trade to include any contract or contract provision which would require a worker to pay for a debt incurred through an employer-provided training program if the worker elects to leave the employer before a specified period of time. In essence, the bill presents noncompete clauses and TRAPs as two sides of the same coin. To the extent that employer-driven debt can function as a barrier to employees who would otherwise wish to move on to new opportunities, the approach makes some sense. However, these two issues are fundamentally distinct. While post-employment noncompetes exclusively address behavior following an employment relationship, TRAs and TRAPs necessarily relate to a portion of the employer-employee relationship during employment. Looping TRAPs into the existing, well-litigated, definition of “contracts in restraint of trade” would risk complicating decades of established case law.
In order to address these concerns, the author proposes to amend the bill in a manner that would create a prohibition against contracts that would obligate an employee for the cost of employer-provided training separate and apart from the prohibition found at Section 16600. By maintaining the language in the same section of the Business and Professions Code, the bill would arguably connect the issues of such programs with unlawful noncompete agreements without improperly conflating the two distinct issues. In order to achieve this goal, the author proposes to strike the definition of “contract in restraint of trade” found at subdivision (c)(1) of Section 16610 and to amend Section 3 as follows:
SEC. 3. Section 16608 is added to the Business and Professions Code, immediately following Section 16607, to read:
[…]
(b) Except as provided in subdivision (c), an employer shall not enter into a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer the employer is terminated is a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business under this chapter.
Additionally, this bill authorizes an employee or prospective employee to bring a civil lawsuit against an employer that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of the chapter. In conjunction with the amendments identified above, this language authorizes a civil lawsuit for either a contract requiring a debtor-employee to pay a debt, or an invalid noncompete clause. The bill also authorizes the employee or prospective employee to seek injunctive relief, in addition to reasonable costs and attorney’s fees. Notably, as currently written, the Attorney General is directed to receive and investigate complaints only from debtors alleging a violation of this section, arguably excluding individuals claiming a violation of Section 16600 due to an invalid noncompete clause. In order to clarify this intent, the author proposes to amend the language to authorize the AG to receive and investigate complaints from “persons” alleging any violation of the section.
Finally, concerns have been raised regarding the bill’s effect on government programs such as public service loan forgiveness. Arguably the language of the existing bill would not capture these situations, as they necessarily function regardless of who the debtor works for. In other words, the employer is not forcing a contract on an employee for payment of a debt incurred through a program offered by the employer. However, in order to avoid any potential confusion, the author proposes the following amendment:
16608. (a) For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
[…]
(4) Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit or prohibit any loan repayment assistance program or loan forgiveness program provided by a federal, state, or local governmental agency.
Opponents argue this bill may have the unintended consequence of deterring well-meaning employer-provided programs. The opposition argues that by prohibiting any contract between an employer and employee that would ultimately leave the employee with the burden of repaying any incurred debt could serve as a deterrent to well-meaning employers who would like to help subsidize their employees’ educational aspirations. Specifically, they write:
[E]mployers may pay a worker’s tuition to get an advanced degree or additional certification or pay a signing bonus at the outset of employment. These mutually beneficial programs give the worker an opportunity to improve their resume/skills, or receive additional money up front while the employer simultaneously makes an investment in its workforce. Understandably, employers are more motivated to invest in these types of voluntary benefits if they know the worker will be at the company for a longer period of time. It is therefore common for employers to offer more benefits if the worker agrees to remain at the company for a certain amount of time afterwards.
To some extent, an employer is arguably repaid for footing the bill for their employees’ education in the increase in quality or type of services those employees are likely to provide to the employer. Additionally, it is possible that employers will continue to offer such programs to their employees as a hiring incentive in a competitive job market. With that said, there is arguably a distinction between the types of trainings often included in TRAP agreements – such as trainings directly related to the type of job held by the employee and those necessary to complete the job requirements – and programs offered by an employer that are distinct and in addition to the type of work considered by the employee’s position. Moreover, it is not unreasonable to conclude that prohibiting employers from even requiring that their employee remain in the position for the duration of the program in order to receive the full financial benefit could risk disincentivizing employers from providing these programs to begin with. To the extent this bill invalidates all such contracts, the author may wish to consider narrowing its application to exempt programs which, for example, offer financial assistance for secondary degree programs that are not a necessary qualification for the employee’s position.
Moreover, as currently written and as proposed to be amended, this bill would void all existing contracts with clauses requiring an employee to pay for a debt upon leaving their position with their employer. The resulting impact is that every employer in California who currently has such an agreement with an employee would experience a significant shift in their contractual expectations. While acknowledging that this approach would undoubtedly invalidate nefarious TRAP agreements, it would also impact well-intentioned programs as previously discussed. Given the expansive nature of the bill’s application and the existing contractual expectations of many employers, the author may wish to consider amending the bill to apply prospectively to any new contracts beginning January 1, 2024.
Finally, the bill currently creates an obligation for the Labor Commissioner to enforce violations of its provisions alongside the Office of the Attorney General. As currently written, it is not entirely clear which agency has priority in enforcement, nor how the “coordination,” would unfold. The language appears to be responsive to the fact that the Labor Commissioner’s office is currently overwhelmed by claims that have yet to be adjudicated and claimants often face months’ long wait times. However, the author may wish to clarify which agency should be the first point of contact for any claimant, or whether either agency has a right of first refusal for claims brought before them, and what the obligation to “coordinate” ultimately means.
Clarifying amendments. The author also proposes various clarifying amendments to ensure the intent of the bill is effectuated.
First, the author proposes to amend Section 1 of the bill to grant greater discretion than currently proposed to the State Bar in their determination of whether a licensed attorney’s engagement in a contract deemed unlawful by this bill is cause for any degree of discipline. The amendment would be as follows:
6090.5.5. (a) It is may be cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates Section 16610.
Second, the author proposes the following clarifying amendments to Section 5 of the bill in order to avoid redundancy and promote clarity:
16610. (a) An employer shall not enter into, present an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under this chapter.
(b) (1) An employer that enters into, attempts to enter into, or seeks to enforce a contract in violation of this chapter is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee in a civil action brought by the employee or prospective employee.
(2) An employee or prospective employee may also bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties pursuant to this section. In addition to these remedies, a prevailing employee or prospective employee in any action based on a violation of this section is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney’s fees.
(3) The Attorney General shall receive and investigate complaints from debtors persons alleging a violation of this section in coordination with the Labor Commissioner pursuant to Section 926 of the Labor Code. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the Attorney General believes a violation has occurred, the Attorney General may bring an action to enforce this section pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200).
(c) For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1) “Contract in restraint of trade” means any provision of any contract or other agreement that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind, including a contract described in this chapter.
(2) “Employee” includes, but is not limited to, a full-time or part-time employee and independent contractor.
(3) “Employer” means any person or entity that employs employees.
Finally, the author proposes to amend two references to Section 16610 of the Business and Professions Code to appropriately refer to Section 16608 of the Business and Professions Code.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is co-sponsored by the American Economic Liberties Project, the California Nurses Association (CNA), and the Democracy Policy Network. It is supported by a coalition of labor organizations and workers’ rights advocates. In support of the bill CNA writes:
Employer-driven debt is often mandated as a condition of employment for nurses and other workers required to enter a profession. Employers force nurses and other workers to repay work-related expenses by requiring the worker to work minimum periods of time as a form of repayment towards the alleged debt. If the worker quits or is terminated for any reason before the end of the labor contract period, they are required to repay the costs of the alleged debt or pay a high financial penalty. Employers use the threat of financial ruin to keep workers out of unions, silence whistleblowers, and lock them into low-wage positions. In other words, the kind of employer-driven debt that many nurses and other workers face today is a modern-day form of indentured servitude.
For nurses, employer debt traps prevent them from acting collectively to improve hospital working conditions for themselves, their coworkers, and their patients. Importantly, when employers hold workers hostage as debtors, it makes it difficult for nurses to speak out about unsafe working conditions and to advocate for their patients to ensure they receive safe and effective nursing care. Ultimately, patients and other consumers suffer as a result of employer-driven debt.
The California Labor Federation writes the following in support:
According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), an estimated 18 percent of U.S. workers are bound by a noncompete clause. These clauses impede job mobility, lower overall wages, and undermine fair competition. Employers are also increasingly turning to training repayment agreements to trap workers in a job. Debt-trap agreements require workers to stay at a job for a certain amount of time or they will be hit with a bill for “training” costs, often in the tens of thousands of dollars.
The trainings required by repayment schemes are unlike professional licenses that are required by the state and portable from job to job. Employers put provisions in job contracts that the employee will work a minimum amount of time for the employer or will owe the employer for the stated cost of training. Recent high-profile cases include a PetSmart dog groomer and an Ameriflight pilot who were hit with huge training bills when they tried to leave their jobs.
Debt-trap agreements are used across industries, but increasingly in health care, retail, construction, and the service sector—industries with low-wages and high turnover. Low-paid workers are the least likely to be able to afford training debt-traps. Workers are locked into often unsafe, exploitative jobs where the fear of debt prevents advocacy for better conditions. Employers have no incentive to raise wages or improve conditions when workers cannot leave to find a better job. Workers lose the power to negotiate when employers hold the debt card.
The Small Business Majority writes the following:
By restricting where workers can seek employment, noncompete agreements also remove the incentive for employers to retain workers by offering better pay and working conditions. As a result, wages and working conditions are both diminished. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) recently estimated that noncompete clauses deprive American workers of between $250-296 billion per year in income.
Even without an explicit noncompete agreement, some employers use employer driven debt, “stay-or-pay contracts,” or Training Repayment Agreement Provisions (“TRAPs”), to deter workers from leaving jobs with substandard pay or working conditions.
TRAPs require employees to repay the cost of training received on the job, even if that training was of little use in or outside of a given workplace. TRAPs are particularly common in the healthcare sector, where nurses during the pandemic found themselves working unreasonable hours, often without sufficient protective equipment, and unable to leave their jobs without triggering tens of thousands of dollars in debt to their employer. For all workers seeking better pay and working conditions, TRAPs quite literally trap workers, disproportionately low- to middle-wage workers and people of color, in substandard working conditions.
AB 747 solves for this problem by prohibiting contracts that require an employee to pay for a debt to their employer at the termination of employment. AB 747 includes limited exemptions only for situations where the debt was incurred due to the maintenance of a State-mandated licensure program, or for training-related costs associated with the repayment of union-affiliated apprenticeship program.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by a wide coalition of business advocates. In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce writes:
AB 747’s Application to Independent Contractors is At Odds with the Concept of an Independent Contractor and Likely Violates the Contracts Clauses
None of AB 747’s provisions should apply to independent contractors. For example, Labor Code 2802’s requirements apply to employees, not independent contractors. This makes sense given the concept of an independent contractor – someone who performs work outside of the company’s usual course of business, is free from control of the company regarding the performance of the work, and is customarily engaged in an independent trade or business. Independent contractors often work for many different companies. Anything specific to the needs of a specific company would be negotiated for in the terms and price of the contract between the contractor and that company. Further, consider proposed Business and Professions Code section 16609, which provides that a company would be prohibited from imposing a penalty if the contractor terminated the arrangement prior to the agreed upon date. Contracts regularly consider damages in the event of early termination, and such early termination may constitute a breach for which damages are owed. However, any attorney who drafted such a normal contract term would be subject to disbarment under Section 1 of the bill. For that reason, all of the provisions of this bill that include independent contractors are likely to violate the contracts clauses of the California and federal constitutions because they substantially impair pre-existing contractual obligations.
AB 747 Significantly Increases Penalties on Businesses of All Sizes
Presently, an Unfair Competition Law (UCL) claim is the common method of challenging the enforceability of a non-compete agreement. AB 747 creates two new enforcement mechanisms with steep penalties for businesses of any size. First, proposed Business and Professions Code section 16610 allows for actual damages and a $5,000 per employee penalty. Based on the language, the $5,000 is mandatory, not up to the discretion of the court, and would apply to businesses of every size. Second, proposed Labor Code section 925 creates a new private right of action as well as PAGA exposure given that it creates a new labor code section. 2 Again, this provision also applies to businesses of every size.
AB 747 therefore creates tremendous liability exposure for small businesses, who often do not have the resources for legal counsel. Consider a small business that accidently includes a policy in their handbook that violates the bill or a business that thinks their agreement is lawful under one of the recognized exceptions for non-competes or under Labor Code 925. Unintentional errors will result in mandatory thousands of dollars in exposure.
In summary, AB 747 will disincentivize employers investing in their own workforce by paying for additional certifications or degrees, and will make routine practices such as signing bonuses impossible to offer. Moreover, it will create significant liability for contract terms that are presently routine and non-controversial contractual terms.
Implementing a 10% Threshold for the Sale of Business Exception Is Problematic
We have concerns about the consequences of the proposed amendment to Business and Professions Code section 16601. It is not uncommon in a partnership for one partner to own a substantial amount of the entity and other partners to own far less. Division of ownership interests are often dictated by how the business entity is financed. Despite the unequal ownership interest, the remaining partners are not unequal in their knowledge and participation in the business or their ability to subsequently directly compete with that business. Under the proposed language, one or more of those partners could sell all of their interest in the entity to a third party, receive payment in exchange for that interest, and then immediately compete with the entity. Further, it is arbitrary that most partners could go compete while the one who owns the more substantial interest over 10% could not.
AltaMed Health Services writes in opposition of the measure, unless amended to include an exemption for healthcare organizations that include programs designed to support workforce development. In support of their position they write:
Specifically, we are concerned about Section 16608 (b) of the bill, which would declare an employment contract that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment is terminated as void and the associated $5,000 penalty per employee for employers. While we understand the intentions behind this provision, we believe it may inadvertently affect our workforce development and career advancement programs, which are bona fide programs with transferable benefits across employers. This would be to the detriment of the communities we serve–California’s medically underserved. We respectfully request that you consider amending AB 747 to include an exemption for safety net healthcare organizations like AltaMed that have programs specifically designed to support workforce development in service to underserved and under-resourced populations.
[…]
Today, AltaMed employees participate in health workforce federal programs such as the National Health Service Corps1 , the Nurse Corps Loan Repayment Program2 , and the Indian Health Service Loan Repayment Program3 . These programs require participants who receive an award to commit to serving an underserved area known as a Health Professional Shortage Area (HPSA), population or critical shortage facility such as an FQHC for a specified length of time. AltaMed also established and currently operates a number of career development and workforce programs modeled after these programs. By doing so, we are able to attract and retain qualified health professionals who are dedicated to improving the health outcomes of underserved communities, and fill critical FQHC workforce positions, assuring critical healthcare services are available to those in need.
Pending related legislation. AB 1076 (Bauer-Kahan) would codify existing case law by specifying that the statutory provision voiding noncompete contracts is to be broadly construed to void the application of any noncompete agreement in an employment context, or any noncompete clause in an employment contract, no matter how narrowly tailored, that does not satisfy specified exceptions. This bill is currently pending before the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment.
SB 699 (Caballero) would strengthen the law that voids contracts which restrain anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind, regardless of where the contract was signed. This bill is pending hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Economic Liberties Project (co-sponsor)
California Nurses Association (co-sponsor)
Democracy Policy Network (co-sponsor)
Board of Registered Nursing
Consumer Attorneys of California
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Labor Federation
People’s Parity Project, UCLA Law
Student Borrower Protection Center
Small Business Majority
TechEquity Collaborative
Opposition
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
Allied Managed Care
California Association for Health Services At Home
California Association of Health Facilities
California Association of Sheet Metal & Air Conditioning Contractors National Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California League of Food Producers
California Lodging Industry Association
California Manufactures & Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
Coalition of Small & Disabled Veteran Business
Construction Employers' Association
Family Business Association of California
Flasher Barricade Association
Hollywood Chamber of Commerce
Independent Lodging Industry Association.
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Analysis Prepared by: Manuela Boucher-de la Cadena/ JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 12, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 747 (
Author:McCarty) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2023
SUBJECT: Business: unlawful employee contracts and requirements
SUMMARY: Prohibits an employer from entering into, presenting an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under the law. Additionally provides that a contract that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated constitutes a contract in restraint of trade. Specifically, this bill:
- Modifies, in the context of contracts in restraint of trade, the definition of “ownership interest” to require that a partnership interest, a membership interest, or capital stock, be more than 10% of the total partnership interest, total membership interest, or total shares.
- Declares a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated to be a contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business and void as contrary to public policy, with limited exceptions.
- Defines “debtor” to mean a natural person who is or may become liable to pay an employer, a prospective employer, a third-party entity, or other business entity for all or part of an employment-related cost, education-related cost, or other debt.
- Defines “education-related cost” to mean a cost associated with enrollment or attendance at an educational program and related expenses, including, but not limited to, tuition, fees, books, supplies, student loans, examinations, and equipment required for enrollment or attendance in an educational, training, or residency program.
- Defines “employment-related cost” to mean a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by a person in direct consequence of the discharge of their duties at work or of their obedience to a direction of their employer, including, but not limited to, equipment or a training, residency, orientation, or competency validation required either by an employer or to practice in a specific employee classification.
- Prohibits an employer from imposing any penalty, fee, or cost on an employee or independent contractor for terminating the employment relationship, including, but not limited to, a replacement hire fee, retraining fee, reimbursement for immigration or visa-related costs, liquidated damages, lost goodwill, or lost profit.
- Prohibits an employer from entering into, presenting an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract in restraint of trade that is void under the law.
- Provides that it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee of the State Bar to enter into with an employee, prospective employee, or former employee, present an employee, prospective employee, or former employee as a term of employment, or attempt to enforce any employee contract or other agreement that violates the prohibition on contracts in restraint of trade.
- Provides that an employer that violates 7) above is liable for actual damages and an additional penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per employee or prospective employee.
- Authorizes an employee or prospective employee to bring an action for injunctive relief and for the recovery of actual damages and additional penalties, as provided. A prevailing employee or prospective employee is entitled to recover reasonable costs and attorney’s fees.
- Requires the Attorney General (AG) to receive and investigate complaints from debtors alleging a violation of 7) above in coordination with the Labor Commissioner (LC) in her capacity to investigate alleged violations, hold hearings, issue citations, and file a civil action. If, after examining a complaint and the evidence, the AG believes a violation has occurred, the AG may bring an action to enforce this section.
- Provides that, for a contract with an out of state adjudication clause that is entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2024, an employee is not considered represented by legal counsel if the counsel is paid for by, or was selected based upon the suggestion of, the employee’s employer.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that every contract that restrains anyone from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is void, subject to limited exceptions. B&P Code § 16600.
- Provides that any person who sells the goodwill of a business, or any owner of a business entity selling or otherwise disposing of all of his or her ownership interest in the business entity, or any owner of a business entity that sells specified assets or interests may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business within a specified geographic area in which the business so sold, or that of the business entity, division, or subsidiary has been carried on, so long as the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill or ownership interest from the buyer, carries on a like business therein. B&P Code § 16601.
- Defines “ownership interest” to mean a partnership interest, a membership interest, or a capital stockholder, as specified. B&P Code § 16601.
- Establishes the Division of Labor Standards and Enforcement, of which the state Labor Commissioner is chief, to ensure that minimum labor standards are adequately enforced. Labor Code § 82, §90.5.
- Establishes the State Bar Act that provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California. B&P Code §6000 et seq.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in the state to agree, as a condition of employment, to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of the state a claim arising in the state or would deprive the employee of the substantive protection of state law with respect to a controversy arising in the state. Labor Code §925.
- Provides an exception to the prohibition described in 6) if the employee is individually represented by legal counsel in negotiating the terms of the agreement to designate either the venue or forum for claim adjudication. Labor Code §925.
- Requires an employer to indemnify an employee for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of the employee’s duties. Labor Code §2802.
- Provides that the expense or cost of any employer-provided or employer-required educational program or training, as defined, for an employee providing direct patient care or an applicant for direct patient care employment constitutes a necessary expenditure or loss incurred by the employee in direct consequence of the discharge of the employee’s duties. Labor Code §2802.1.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Note: This bill is double referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee upon passage out of this Committee.
In January 2023, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) made headlines when it announced a proposed rule to ban noncompete clauses in contracts for employment. In its press release, the FTC noted that “companies use noncompetes for workers across industries and job levels, from hairstylists and warehouse workers to doctors and business executives. In many cases, employers use their outsized bargaining power to coerce workers into signing these contracts. Noncompetes harm competition in U.S. labor markers by blocking workers from pursuing better opportunities and by preventing employers from hiring the best available talent.[1]”
Similar to AB 747, the FTC proposed rule would ban noncompetes covering both employees and independent contractors. It would also ban “de-facto” noncompetes, so that clauses with the effect of prohibiting a worker from seeking or obtaining other employment or opening up a business would be illegal. Finally, it would require employers to notify current and former employees who we were previously subject to a noncompete that it is no longer in effect.
According to the author, “Noncompetes, while unenforceable in California, are still being included in 1 of 5 worker contracts. They reduce worker wages, hurt consumer choices, and stunt innovation and new business creation. In fact, economists estimate that noncompetes lower U.S. workers’ collective income by more than $250 billion per year. AB 747 prevents employers and attorneys from including these exploitative and deceptive agreements in worker contracts.”
The author further contends that the bill will assist underserved and marginalized communities because “low wage workers are especially vulnerable if they are unaware that the noncompete is unenforceable. This traps the low wage worker, more often a BIPOC, in a job even if they have identified either 1) a career with a higher wage with a new employer, or 2) the desire to create a small business. All workers and consumers will immediately benefit. Finally, doing away with noncompetes and employer driven debt would likely lower consumer prices in the healthcare sector, to the tune of $150 billion a year.”
Committee Comments
Committee staff recommends the author consider in the future clarifying the following provisions:
- B&P Section 16610 (b)(3) proposes coordination between the AG and the LC to receive, investigate, and prosecute complaints from debtors alleging a violation of the prohibition on a contract in restraint of trade.
As currently written, both entities could accept and investigate complaints but their processes are not the same. Similarly, both entities have enforcement tools. It is unclear how these various enforcement tools would be employed on a given complaint.
This section as written only applies to debtors who bring complaints. The author may want to expand this to also allow any person alleging a violation of the prohibition on a contract in restraint of trade to bring a complaint.
- B&P Section 16608 revises the definition of a “contract in restraint of trade” to include a contract or contract term that requires a debtor to pay for a debt if the debtor’s employment or work relationship with a specific employer is terminated.
As written, this section would take effect January 1, 2024, and thus, could impair existing contracts that require a debtor-employee to repay work-related costs.
Arguments in Support
The Democracy Policy Network, co-sponsor of the bill, states, “California courts will not enforce non-compete agreements, yet an estimated 45% of businesses continue to require workers to sign them as a condition of employment. This is an inherently deceptive business practice. AB 747 would hold those who engage in this deceptive practice accountable and provide relief to workers who have been harmed by invalid agreements.
The cost of invalid non-compete agreements is enormous. Using the Federal Trade Commission’s estimate that non-compete agreements cost workers $300 billion nationally, we can infer that void non-competes likely cost Californians tens of billions of dollars every year. Non-compete agreements have also been shown to harm innovation and prevent workers from starting their own businesses.
Non-compete agreements can also cause artificial labor shortages that make it harder to respond to crises like pandemics.”
The California Nurses Association/National Nurses United, co-sponsor of the bill, also argues in support that “Employer-driven debt is often mandated as a condition of employment for nurses and other workers required to enter a profession. Employers force nurses and other workers to repay work-related expenses by requiring the worker to work minimum periods of time as a form of repayment towards the alleged debt. If the worker quits or is terminated for any reason before the end of the labor contract period, they are required to repay the costs of the alleged debt or pay a high financial penalty. Employers use the threat of financial ruin to keep workers out of unions, silence whistleblowers, and lock them into low-wage positions. In other words, the kind of employer-driven debt that many nurses and other workers face today is a modern-day form of indentured servitude.
For nurses, employer debt traps prevent them from acting collectively to improve hospital working conditions for themselves, their coworkers, and their patients. Importantly, when employers hold workers hostage as debtors, it makes it difficult for nurses to speak out about unsafe working conditions and to advocate for their patients to ensure they receive safe and effective nursing care. Ultimately, patients and other consumers suffer as a result of employer-driven debt.”
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, are opposed and state, “…AB 747 would prohibit an employer from requiring that the worker remain at the company for a certain amount of time after receiving a benefit. Any requirement that the worker pay back the signing bonus would be considered a “contract restraining a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business,” subjecting the employer to penalties, including penalties under PAGA. The unintended consequence of this bill is that it removes the incentive for employers to offer these benefits programs. In effect, AB 747 does not help workers – it hurts them.
The intent behind Sections 3 and 4 of AB 747 appears to be aimed at prohibiting employers from requiring specific training and then saddling employees with a bill for that training upon termination of employment. That scenario is already addressed under Labor Code section 2802. Under section 2802, employers must reimburse employees for all necessary expenses and/or losses incurred in the course and scope of their employment. Courts have interpreted this provision quite broadly in favor of the employee. For example, if an employee makes a mistake at work that costs the employer money – such as damaging valuable equipment – the employee cannot be required to reimburse the employer. Or if the employer requires the employee to use their cell phone to conduct work, the employer must provide reimbursement, even if the employee is not incurring any additional cost because they have an unlimited data plan.”
Related and Prior Legislation
AB 1076 (Bauer-Kahan) of 2023 would codify existing case law by specifying that the statutory provision voiding noncompete contracts is to be broadly construed to void the application of any noncompete agreement in an employment context, or any noncompete clause in an employment contract, no matter how narrowly tailored, that does not satisfy specified exceptions. This bill is pending a hearing in this committee.
SB 699 (Caballero) of 2023 would prohibit an employer from entering into a contract that presents an employee or prospective employee as a term of employment, or attempting to enforce any contract that is void, as specified. The bill would establish that an employer who violates that provision commits a civil violation. This bill is pending a hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 1241 (Wieckowski) Chapter 632, Statutes of 2016, prohibits an employer from requiring an employee who primarily resides and works in California, as a condition of employment, to agree to a provision that would require the employee to adjudicate outside of California a claim arising in California or deprive the employee of the substantive protection of California law with respect to a controversy arising in California.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Economic Liberties Project (Co-Sponsor)
California Nurses Association (Co-Sponsor)
Democracy Policy Network (Co-Sponsor)
Board of Registered Nursing
California Employment Lawyers Association
Techequity Collaborative
Oppose
Acclamation Insurance Management Services
Allied Managed Care
California Association for Health Services At Home
California Association of Health Facilities
California Association of Sheet Metal & Air Conditioning Contractors National Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California League of Food Producers
California Lodging Industry Association
California Manufactures & Technology Association
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
Coalition of Small & Disabled Veteran Business
Construction Employers' Association
Family Business Association of California
Flasher Barricade Association
Hollywood Chamber of Commerce
Independent Lodging Industry Association.
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Western Electrical Contractors Association
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
Federal Trade Commission, Press Release, “FTC Proposes Rule to Ban Noncompete Clauses, Which Hurt Workers and Harm Competition,” January 5, 2023. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):