AB 817: Open meetings: teleconferencing: subsidiary body.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-29
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-05: In committee: Set, second hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Ralph M. Brown Act, requires, with specified exceptions, each legislative body of a local agency to provide notice of the time and place for its regular meetings and an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted. The act also requires that all meetings of a legislative body be open and public, and that all persons be permitted to attend unless a closed session is authorized. The act generally requires for teleconferencing that the legislative body of a local agency that elects to use teleconferencing post agendas at all teleconference locations, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting or proceeding, and have each teleconference location be accessible to the public. Existing law also requires that, during the teleconference, at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
Existing law authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use alternate teleconferencing provisions during a proclaimed state of emergency (emergency provisions) and, until January 1, 2026, in certain circumstances related to the particular member if at least a quorum of its members participate from a singular physical location that is open to the public and situated within the agencys jurisdiction and other requirements are met (nonemergency provisions). Existing law imposes different requirements for notice, agenda, and public participation, as prescribed, when a legislative body is using alternate teleconferencing provisions. The nonemergency provisions impose restrictions on remote participation by a member of the legislative body and require the legislative body to provide specific means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting.
This bill, until January 1, 2026, would authorize a subsidiary body, as defined, to use similar alternative teleconferencing provisions and would impose requirements for notice, agenda, and public participation, as prescribed. The bill would require at least one staff member of the local agency to be present at a designated primary physical meeting location during the meeting. The bill would require the local agency to post the agenda at the primary physical meeting location. The bill would require the members of the subsidiary body to visibly appear on camera during the open portion of a meeting that is publicly accessible via the internet or other online platform, as specified. The bill would also require the subsidiary body to list a member of the subsidiary body who participates in a teleconference meeting from a remote location in the minutes of the meeting. In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this act, the bill would require the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action to make specified findings by majority vote, before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing for the first time and every 12 months thereafter.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the Ralph M. Brown Act, requires, with specified exceptions, each legislative body of a local agency to provide notice of the time and place for its regular meetings and an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted. The act also requires that all meetings of a legislative body be open and public, and that all persons be permitted to attend unless a closed session is authorized. The act generally requires for teleconferencing that the legislative body of a local agency that elects to use teleconferencing post agendas at all teleconference locations, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting or proceeding, and have each teleconference location be accessible to the public. Existing law also requires that, during the teleconference, at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, law authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use alternate teleconferencing provisions during a proclaimed state of emergency or in other situations related to public health that exempt a legislative body from the general requirements (emergency provisions) and impose and, until January 1, 2026, in certain circumstances related to the particular member if at least a quorum of its members participate from a singular physical location that is open to the public and situated within the agencys jurisdiction and other requirements are met (nonemergency provisions). Existing law imposes different requirements for notice, agenda, and public participation, as prescribed. The emergency provisions specify that they do not require a legislative body to provide a physical location from which the public may attend or comment. prescribed, when a legislative body is using alternate teleconferencing provisions. The nonemergency provisions impose restrictions on remote participation by a member of the legislative body and require the legislative body to specific means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting.
Existing law, until January 1, 2026, authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use alternative teleconferencing in certain circumstances related to the particular member if at least a quorum of its members participate from a singular physical location that is open to the public and situated within the agencys jurisdiction and other requirements are met, including restrictions on remote participation by a member of the legislative body.This bill bill, until January 1, 2026, would authorize a subsidiary body, as defined, to use similar alternative teleconferencing provisions similar to the emergency provisions indefinitely and without regard to a state of emergency. and would impose requirements for notice, agenda, and public participation, as prescribed. In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this act, the bill would require the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action to make specified findings by majority vote, before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing for the first time and every 12 months thereafter.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing law, the Ralph M. Brown Act, requires requires, with specified exceptions, each legislative body of a local agency to provide notice of the time and place for its regular meetings and an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted. The act also requires that all meetings of a legislative body be open and public, and that all persons be permitted to attend unless a closed session is authorized. The act generally requires for teleconferencing that the legislative body of a local agency that elects to use teleconferencing post agendas at all teleconference locations, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting or proceeding, and have each teleconference location be accessible to the public. Existing law also requires that, during the teleconference, at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
Existing law, until January 1, 2024, authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use alternate teleconferencing provisions during a proclaimed state of emergency or in other situations related to public health that exempt a legislative body from the general requirements (emergency provisions) and impose different requirements for notice, agenda, and public participation, as prescribed. The emergency provisions specify that they do not require a legislative body to provide a physical location from which the public may attend or comment.
Existing law, until January 1, 2026, authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use alternative teleconferencing in certain circumstances related to the particular member if at least a quorum of its members participate from a singular physical location that is open to the public and situated within the agencys jurisdiction and other requirements are met, including restrictions on remote participation by a member of the legislative body.
This bill would authorize a subsidiary body, as defined, to use alternative teleconferencing provisions similar to the emergency provisions indefinitely and without regard to a state of emergency. In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this act, the bill would require the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action to make specified findings by majority vote, before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing for the first time and every 12 months thereafter.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to a provision of the Ralph M. Brown Act.Existing law, the Ralph M. Brown Act, requires each legislative body of a local agency to provide notice of the time and place for its regular meetings and an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted. The act also requires that all meetings of a legislative body be open and public, and that all persons be permitted to attend unless a closed session is authorized.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to a provision of the Ralph M. Brown Act.
(a)(1)The definitions in Section 54953, as that section may be amended from time to time, apply for purposes of this section.
(2)For purposes of this section, subsidiary body means a legislative body that meets all of the following:
(A)Is described in subdivision (b) of Section 54952.
(B)Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
(C)Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
(b)A subsidiary body may use teleconferencing without complying with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 54953, if the subsidiary body complies with all of the following:
(1)The teleconferenced meetings shall be conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the subsidiary body.
(2)Each member of the subsidiary body shall participate through both audio and visual technology.
(3)The subsidiary body shall provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
(A)A two-way audiovisual platform.
(B)A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
(4)The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by this chapter.
(5)The subsidiary body shall designate a primary physical meeting location where members of the public may physically attend, observe, hear, and participate in the meeting. At least one staff member of the local agency shall be present at the primary physical meeting location during the meeting. The local agency shall post the agenda at the primary physical meeting location, but need not post the agenda at a remote location.
(5)(6)In each instance in which notice of the time of the teleconferenced meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted, the subsidiary body shall also give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment.
(6)(7)The agenda shall identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly pursuant to Section 54954.3 via a call-in option or via an internet-based service option.
(7)(8)In the event of a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting to members of the public using the call-in option or internet-based service option, or in the event of a disruption within the subsidiary bodys control that prevents members of the public from offering public comments using the call-in option or internet-based service option, the subsidiary body shall take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until public access to the meeting via the call-in option or internet-based service option is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting may be challenged pursuant to Section 54960.1.
(8)(9)Notwithstanding Section 54953.3, an individual desiring to provide public comment through the use of an internet website, or other online platform, not under the control of the subsidiary body, that requires registration to log in to a teleconference may be required to register as required by the third-party internet website or online platform to participate.
(10)The members of the subsidiary body shall visibly appear on camera during the open portion of a meeting that is publicly accessible via the internet or other online platform.
(A)The visual appearance of a member of the subsidiary body on camera may cease only when the appearance would be technologically impracticable, including, but not limited to, when the member experiences a lack of reliable broadband or internet connectivity that would be remedied by joining without video, or when the visual display of meeting materials, information, or speakers on the internet or other online platform requires the visual appearance of a member of a subsidiary body on camera to cease.
(B)If a member of the advisory body does not appear on camera due to challenges with internet connectivity, the member shall announce the reason for their nonappearance when they turn off their camera.
(9)(11)The subsidiary body shall not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting and must provide an opportunity for the public to address the subsidiary body and offer comment in real time.
(A)A subsidiary body that provides a timed public comment period for each agenda item shall not close the public comment period for the agenda item, or the opportunity to register, pursuant to paragraph (8), (9), to provide public comment until that timed public comment period has elapsed.
(B)A subsidiary body that does not provide a timed public comment period, but takes public comment separately on each agenda item, shall allow a reasonable amount of time per agenda item to allow public members the opportunity to provide public comment, including time for members of the public to register pursuant to paragraph (8), (9), or otherwise be recognized for the purpose of providing public comment.
(C)A subsidiary body that provides a timed general public comment period that does not correspond to a specific agenda item shall not close the public comment period or the opportunity to register, pursuant to paragraph (8), (9), until the timed general public comment period has elapsed.
(12)A member of the subsidiary body who participates in a teleconference meeting from a remote location shall be listed in the minutes of the meeting.
(c)In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this section, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action shall make the following findings by majority vote before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing pursuant to this section for the first time, and every 12 months thereafter:
(1)The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
(2)Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
(3)Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds and repeals Section 54953.05 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
By removing the requirement for agendas to be placed at the location of each public official participating in a public meeting remotely, this act protects the personal, private information of public officials and their families while preserving the publics right to access information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 54953.05 to the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
This act is necessary to provide opportunities for public participation in meetings of specified public agencies and to promote the attraction and retention of members of those agencies.
(a)(1)The definitions in Section 54953, as that section may be amended from time to time, apply for purposes of this section.
(2)For purposes of this section, subsidiary body means a legislative body that meets all of the following:
(A)Is described in subdivision (b) of Section 54952.
(B)Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
(C)Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
(b)A subsidiary body may use teleconferencing without complying with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 54953, if the subsidiary body complies with all of the following:
(1)The teleconferenced meetings shall be conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the subsidiary body.
(2)Each member of the subsidiary body shall participate through both audio and visual technology.
(3)The subsidiary body shall provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
(A)A two-way audiovisual platform.
(B)A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
(4)The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by this chapter.
(5)In each instance in which notice of the time of the teleconferenced meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted, the subsidiary body shall also give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment.
(6)The agenda shall identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly pursuant to Section 54954.3 via a call-in option or via an internet-based service option.
(7)In the event of a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting to members of the public using the call-in option or internet-based service option, or in the event of a disruption within the subsidiary bodys control that prevents members of the public from offering public comments using the call-in option or internet-based service option, the subsidiary body shall take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until public access to the meeting via the call-in option or internet-based service option is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting may be challenged pursuant to Section 54960.1.
(8)Notwithstanding Section 54953.3, an individual desiring to provide public comment through the use of an internet website, or other online platform, not under the control of the subsidiary body, that requires registration to log in to a teleconference may be required to register as required by the third-party internet website or online platform to participate.
(9)The subsidiary body shall not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting and must provide an opportunity for the public to address the subsidiary body and offer comment in real time.
(A)A subsidiary body that provides a timed public comment period for each agenda item shall not close the public comment period for the agenda item, or the opportunity to register, pursuant to paragraph (8), to provide public comment until that timed public comment period has elapsed.
(B)A subsidiary body that does not provide a timed public comment period, but takes public comment separately on each agenda item, shall allow a reasonable amount of time per agenda item to allow public members the opportunity to provide public comment, including time for members of the public to register pursuant to paragraph (8), or otherwise be recognized for the purpose of providing public comment.
(C)A subsidiary body that provides a timed general public comment period that does not correspond to a specific agenda item shall not close the public comment period or the opportunity to register, pursuant to paragraph (8), until the timed general public comment period has elapsed.
(c)In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this section, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action shall make the following findings by majority vote before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing pursuant to this section for the first time, and every 12 months thereafter:
(1)The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
(2)Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
(3)Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2026, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds and repeals Section 54953.05 to of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
By removing the requirement for agendas to be placed at the location of each public official participating in a public meeting remotely, this act protects the personal, private information of public officials and their families while preserving the publics right to access information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 54953.05 to the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
This act is necessary to provide opportunities for public participation in meetings of specified public agencies and to promote the attraction and retention of members of those agencies.
(a)(1)The definitions in Section 54953, as that section may be amended from time to time, apply for purposes of this section.
(2)For purposes of this section, subsidiary body means a legislative body that meets all of the following:
(A)Is described in subdivision (b) of Section 54952.
(B)Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
(C)Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
(b)A subsidiary body may use teleconferencing without complying with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 54953, if the subsidiary body complies with all of the following:
(1)The teleconferenced meetings shall be conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the subsidiary body.
(2)Each member of the subsidiary body shall participate through both audio and visual technology.
(3)The subsidiary body shall provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
(A)A two-way audiovisual platform.
(B)A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
(4)The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by this chapter.
(5)In each instance in which notice of the time of the teleconferenced meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted, the subsidiary body shall also give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment.
(6)The agenda shall identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly pursuant to Section 54954.3 via a call-in option or via an internet-based service option.
(7)In the event of a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting to members of the public using the call-in option or internet-based service option, or in the event of a disruption within the subsidiary bodys control that prevents members of the public from offering public comments using the call-in option or internet-based service option, the subsidiary body shall take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until public access to the meeting via the call-in option or internet-based service option is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting may be challenged pursuant to Section 54960.1.
(8)Notwithstanding Section 54953.3, an individual desiring to provide public comment through the use of an internet website, or other online platform, not under the control of the subsidiary body, that requires registration to log in to a teleconference may be required to register as required by the third-party internet website or online platform to participate.
(9)The subsidiary body shall not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting and must provide an opportunity for the public to address the subsidiary body and offer comment in real time.
(A)A subsidiary body that provides a timed public comment period for each agenda item shall not close the public comment period for the agenda item, or the opportunity to register, pursuant to paragraph (8), to provide public comment until that timed public comment period has elapsed.
(B)A subsidiary body that does not provide a timed public comment period, but takes public comment separately on each agenda item, shall allow a reasonable amount of time per agenda item to allow public members the opportunity to provide public comment, including time for members of the public to register pursuant to paragraph (8), or otherwise be recognized for the purpose of providing public comment.
(C)A subsidiary body that provides a timed general public comment period that does not correspond to a specific agenda item shall not close the public comment period or the opportunity to register, pursuant to paragraph (8), until the timed general public comment period has elapsed.
(c)In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this section, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action shall make the following findings by majority vote before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing pursuant to this section for the first time, and every 12 months thereafter:
(1)The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
(2)Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
(3)Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 54953.05 to the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
By removing the requirement for agendas to be placed at the location of each public official participating in a public meeting remotely, this act protects the personal, private information of public officials and their families while preserving the publics right to access information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which adds Section 54953.05 to the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
This act is necessary to provide opportunities for public participation in meetings of specified public agencies and to promote the attraction and retention of members of those agencies.
SECTION 1.Section 54950 of the Government Code is amended to read:54950.(a)In enacting this chapter, the Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards, councils, and the other public agencies in this state exist to aid in the conduct of the peoples business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly.(b)The people of this state do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies that serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed, so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.(a)In enacting this chapter, the Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils boards, councils, and the other public agencies in this State state exist to aid in the conduct of the peoples business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly.
The(b)The people of this State state do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies which that serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed informed, so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 5, 2024 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| May 29, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| May 21, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 1, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and JUD. |
| Jan 25, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 25, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 54. Noes 8. Page 3930.) |
| Jan 18, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 17, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Jan 16, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (January 10). |
| Apr 25, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. GOV. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 16, 2023 | Referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 5, 2024 | [Second] hearing set for [06-05-2024]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| Jun 5, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Local Government |
Failed |
|
| Jan 25, 2024 | AB 817 Pacheco Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 10, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AARP | ** Support | |
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| Agency on Aging \ Area 4 | ** Support | |
| Alameda County Transportation Commission | ** Support | |
| Association of California Healthcare Districts | ** Support | |
| Association Of California School Administrators | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Air Quality Management District | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Digital Inclusion Coalition | ** Support | |
| Bet Tzedek | ** Support | |
| CA In-home Supportive Services Consumer Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Air Pollution Control Officers Association | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Clerks & Election Officials | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Councils Of Governments | ** Support | |
| California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Public Authorities For Ihss | ** Support | |
| California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts | ** Support | |
| California Broadcasters Association | ** Against | |
| California Commission on Aging | ** Support | |
| California Common Cause | ** Against | |
| California Municipal Utilities Association | ** Support | |
| California News Publishers Association | ** Against | |
| Californians Aware | ** Against | |
| California Senior Legislature | ** Support | |
| California Special Districts Association | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Support | |
| Carmichael Recreation and Park District | ** Support | |
| City and County Association of Governments of San Mateo County | ** Support | |
| City Clerks Association of California | ** Support | |
| City of Alameda | ** Support | |
| City Of Bell | ** Support | |
| City of Bell Gardens | ** Support | |
| City of Belmont | ** Support | |
| city of carlsbad | ** Support | |
| City of Downey | ** Support | |
| City of Emeryville | ** Support | |
| City of Goleta | ** Support | |
| City of Lafayette | ** Support | |
| City Of Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| City of Mountain View | ** Support | |
| City of Norwalk | ** Support | |
| City of Redwood City | ** Support | |
| City Of San Carlos | ** Support | |
| City of San Marcos | ** Support | |
| City of Santa Rosa | ** Support | |
| City of Thousand Oaks | ** Support | |
| City of West Hollywood | ** Support | |
| City of Winters | ** Support | |
| City of Woodland | ** Support | |
| CivicWell | ** Support | |
| Conejo Recreation and Park District | ** Support | |
| Contra Costa County | ** Support | |
| Contra Costa County Advisory Council on Aging | ** Support | |
| County of Humboldt | ** Support | |
| County of Inyo | ** Support | |
| County Of Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| County of Mendocino | ** Support | |
| County of Monterey | ** Support | |
| County of San Bernardino | ** Support | |
| County Of San Diego | ** Support | |
| County of San Joaquin | ** Support | |
| County of Santa Barbara | ** Support | |
| County of Santa Cruz | ** Support | |
| County of Sonoma | ** Support | |
| County of Ventura | ** Support | |
| County of Yolo | ** Support | |
| Democracy Winters | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund | ** Support | |
| Fair Oaks Recreation & Park District | ** Support | |
| First Amendment Coalition | ** Against | |
| Hand in Hand: The Domestic Employers Network | ** Support | |
| Homebridge | ** Support | |
| Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Justice in Aging | ** Support | |
| Lake Cuyamaca | ** Support | |
| Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability | ** Against | |
| League Of California Cities | ** Support | |
| Livermore Area Recreation And Park District | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Division, League of California Cities | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts | ** Support | |
| Marin County Council of Mayors and Council Members | ** Support | |
| Napa County | ** Support | |
| Napa Valley Transportation Authority | ** Support | |
| National Press Photographers Association | ** Against | |
| Nlgja: Association of Lgbtq+ Journalists | ** Against | |
| Northern California Society of Professional Journalists | ** Against | |
| Orange County Transportation Authority | ** Support | |
| Peninsula Traffic Congestion Relief Alliance | ** Support | |
| Placer Independent Resource Services | ** Support | |
| Radio Television Digital News Association | ** Against | |
| Regional Climate Protection Authority | ** Support | |
| Rim of The World Recreation and Park District | ** Support | |
| Rio Linda Elverta Recreation and Park District | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Area Council Of Governments | ** Support | |
| San Diego County Of | ** Support | |
| San Diego Pro Chapter of The Society of Professional Journalists | ** Against | |
| San Gabriel Valley Council Of Governments | ** Support | |
| San Mateo County Board of Supervisors | ** Support | |
| San Mateo County-City/County Association Of Governments | ** Support | |
| San Mateo County Transit District | ** Support | |
| Santa Barbara County Association Of Governments | ** Support | |
| Society of Professional Journalists, Greater Los Angeles Chapter | ** Against | |
| Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter | ** Against | |
| Sonoma Clean Power | ** Support | |
| Sonoma County Transportation Authority | ** Support | |
| Tuolumne County Board of Supervisors | ** Support | |
| Urban Counties of California | ** Support | |
| Village Movement California | ** Support | |
| Water Replenishment District Of Southern California | ** Support | |
| Yolo County In-home Supportive Services Advisory Committee | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Senator María Elena Durazo, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | AB 817 | Hearing Date: | 6/5/24 |
Author: | Pacheco | Fiscal: | No |
Version: | 5/29/24 | Consultant: | Peterson |
Open meetings: teleconferencing: subsidiary body
Allows subsidiary bodies of a local agency to teleconference meetings without having to notice and make publicly accessible each teleconference location, or have at least a quorum participate from locations within the boundaries of the agency.
Background
Public access. Article I, Section Three of the California Constitution guarantees “the people have the right to instruct their representatives, petition government for redress of grievances, and assemble freely to consult for the common good.” This includes a right to access information concerning the meetings and writings of public officials. To ensure the right to openly scrutinize public agencies is maintained, the Constitution requires local agencies to comply with certain state laws that outline the basic requirements for public access to meetings and public records. If a subsequent bill modifies these laws, it must include findings demonstrating how it furthers the public’s access to local agencies and their officials.
Brown Act. The Ralph M. Brown Act provides guidelines for how local agencies must hold public meetings. Among other provisions, the Act requires meetings of the legislative body of a local agency be open and public. The Legislature originally enacted the Brown Act in 1953 and has since amended it numerous times. The Legislature expressly declared the intent of the Brown Act in its original statute, which remains unchanged today:
The Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils and other public agencies in this State exist to aid in the conduct of the people’s business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly. The people of this State do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies which serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.
The Brown Act generally requires local agencies to notice meetings in advance, including the posting of an agenda, and requires these meetings to be open and accessible to the public. The Brown Act defines a “meeting” as “any congregation of a majority of the member of a legislative body at the same time and location, including teleconference locations, to hear, discuss, deliberate, or take action on any item that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body.” The Brown Act only allows local agencies to take actions, meaning a majority vote of the legislative body unless otherwise specified, on items that appear on the posted agenda.
The Brown Act lays out certain requirements for public participation. The local agency cannot require members of the public to register or provide information as a condition of participation. The Brown Act also generally requires every agenda for meetings to provide an opportunity for the public to directly address the legislative body on any item of public interest, before or during its consideration of the item, within its jurisdiction. While the Brown Act requires local agencies to provide opportunities for public comment, it also allows local agencies to adopt reasonable regulations to carry out public participation requirements, such as limiting the amount of time for public testimony on each item and for each speaker. These restrictions must be content-neutral; for example, the local agency cannot restrict public criticism of its actions.
If a member of the public, including the respective district attorney, believes a local agency violated the Brown Act, it must first send an order to the local agency to correct the violation. If the local agency disagrees with the complaint and does not correct it, the submitter can pursue the complaint through the courts. If the court agrees with the complaint, outcomes range from invalidating certain actions of the local agency to a misdemeanor criminal conviction.
Legislative bodies subject to the Brown Act. The Brown Act applies not just to governing bodies of local agency like a city council or county board of supervisors. It also applies to these other legislative bodies of a local agency:
- Bodies of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, decisionmaking or advisory, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body;
- Standing committees of a legislative body, regardless of their composition, that have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction, or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body; and
- Boards, commissions, committees, or other multimember bodies that govern a private corporation, limited liability company, or other entity that either is created by an elected legislative body to exercise authority delegated to it, or receives funds from a local agency and the membership includes a full voting member from that legislative body.
Advisory committees composed of less than a quorum of the legislative body are not subject to the Brown Act unless they meet one of the above categories.
Teleconferencing and the Brown Act. The Brown Act first allowed teleconference meetings in 1988. At the time, San Diego County was considering the use of video teleconferencing for meetings and hearings of the board of supervisors due to concerns about the long distances some of their constituents travelled to participate, and were concerned these distances prohibited some people from attending at all. AB 3191 (Frazee, 1988) responded to these concerns by authorizing the legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing. Since that time, a number of bills have made modifications to this original authorization.
The Brown Act allows the legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing for the benefit of the public and the legislative body in connection with any meeting or proceeding authorized by law. The teleconferenced meeting or proceeding must comply with all requirements of the Brown Act and all otherwise applicable provisions of law relating to a specific type of meeting or proceeding. Teleconferencing may be used for all purposes in connection with any meeting within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body. All votes taken during a teleconferenced meeting must be taken by roll call. The agenda must provide an opportunity for members of the public at each teleconference location to address the legislative body directly pursuant to the Brown Act’s provisions governing public comment.
In addition to the above, if a legislative body of a local agency elects to use teleconferencing, it must follow four requirements:
- The legislative body must post agendas at all teleconference locations;
- Each teleconference location must be identified in the notice and agenda of the meeting or proceeding;
- Each teleconference location must be accessible to the public; and
- During the teleconference, at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body must participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction, with specified exceptions.
Public meetings during the COVID-19 pandemic. In response to the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, including mandatory “stay-at-home” orders, public agencies had to find new ways of conducting business because of the public safety risk associated with meeting in person. In March 2020, the Governor issued Executive Order N-29-20, which provided local agencies with more flexibility to use teleconferencing without making those teleconference locations accessible to the public. In June 2020, the Governor issued Executive Order N-08-21 notifying local agencies and the public that previous executive orders concerning the conduct of public meetings would apply through September 30, 2021.
Despite the executive order, both local and state governing bodies wanted to ensure they would have the ongoing ability to teleconference without having to disclose the location of teleconferencing members or make that location accessible to the public. The Legislature enacted AB 361 (Robert Rivas, 2021) which allowed, until January 1, 2024, local agencies to use teleconferencing without complying with specified Brown Act restrictions in certain state-declared emergencies.
A local agency availing itself of the provisions of AB 361 is subject to various requirements, including:
- In each instance where notice of the time of the teleconferenced meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted, the legislative body must also give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment;
- The agenda must identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend via a call-in option or an internet-based service option. The legislative body need not provide a physical location from which the public may attend or comment;
- In the event of a disruption that prevents the public agency from publicly broadcasting the meeting using the call-in or internet-based service options, or in the event of a disruption within the local agency’s control that prevents members of the public from offering public comments using the call-in or internet-based service options, the legislative body must take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until public access to the meeting is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption preventing the broadcast of the meeting may be challenged as provided in the Brown Act;
- The legislative body may not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting, and it must provide an opportunity for the public to address the legislative body and offer comment in real time; and
- The legislative body may use an online third-party system for individuals to provide public comment that requires an individual to register with the system prior to providing comment.
If a state of emergency remains active, or state or local officials have imposed measures to promote social distancing, the legislative body must make findings to continue using the exemptions AB 361 provides every 30 days.
AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio, 2022). AB 2449 gave members of legislative bodies more teleconferencing flexibility in non-emergency circumstances. It allowed members of legislative bodies to participate remotely for “just cause” and “emergency circumstances” without noticing their teleconference location or making that location public. Under the measure, just cause includes:
- Childcare or caregiving need that requires a member to participate remotely;
- A contagious illness that prevents a member from attending in person;
- A need related to a physical or mental disability not otherwise accommodated; and
- Travel while on official business of the legislative body or another state or local agency.
Emergency circumstances are a physical or family medical emergency that prevents a member from attending in person.
To use this flexibility, at least a quorum of the legislative body must participate in person at one physical location, which must be identified on the agenda, open to the public, and within the boundaries of the local agency’s jurisdiction. The bill also placed additional requirements on local agencies using provisions modeled after AB 361.
A member of a legislative body can participate in a meeting remotely using these provisions only if one of the following circumstances apply:
- The member notifies the legislative body at the earliest opportunity possible, including at the start of a regular meeting, of their need to participate remotely for just cause, including a general description of the circumstances relating to their need to appear remotely at the given meeting. These provisions cannot be used by any member of the legislative body for more than two meetings per calendar year; or
- The member requests the legislative body to allow them to participate in the meeting remotely due to emergency circumstances and the legislative body approves the request.
When a member uses this flexibility, they must participate through both audio and visual technology, and publicly disclose whether any other individuals 18 years of age or older are present in the same room at the teleconference location and the member’s relationship with any such individuals. Additionally, a member of a legislative body cannot participate in meetings of the legislative body solely by teleconference from a remote location for more than three consecutive months or 20 percent of the regular meetings for the local agency within a calendar year, or more than two meetings if the legislative body regularly meets fewer than 10 times per calendar year.
AB 2449 sunsets on January 1, 2026.
The California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts, the League of California Cities, Urban Counties of California, the Rural County Representative of California, the California State Association of Counties, and the California Association of Public Authorities for In-Home Supportive Services want to create teleconferencing flexibility for local subsidiary bodies.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 817 allows a subsidiary body of a local agency to teleconference their meetings without having to notice and make publicly accessible each teleconference location, or have at least a quorum participate from locations within the boundaries of the agency.
The measure defines “subsidiary body” to mean:
- An advisory body that meets the Brown Act’s definition of a legislative body;
- Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity; and
- Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
To use this flexibility, the legislative body that created the subsidiary body must make findings on the need for this flexibility by majority vote before the subsidiary body can use AB 817’s teleconferencing provisions, which it must do every 12 months thereafter. These findings must include that:
- The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body;
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body; and
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
To use this flexibility, subsidiary bodies must:
- Designate a primary physical meeting location in the notice of the meeting where the public can physically attend, observe, hear, and participate. At least one staff member of the local agency must be present at the location during the meeting;
- When posting notices of the time of the meeting or the agenda, the subsidiary body must also give notice as to how members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment. The agenda must identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend via a call-in option or an internet-based service option;
- In the event of a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting to the public, or in the event of a disruption within the local agency’s control that prevents the public from offering comments remotely, the local agency cannot take further action until it can restore public access. The public can challenge actions taken on agenda items during such disruptions;
- The legislative body must not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting and must provide an opportunity for the public to address the legislative body and offer comments in real time;
- Provide an opportunity for the public to address the legislative body and offer comments in real time. A third-party internet website or online platform not under the control of the legislative body may require members of public to login or register to provide public comment; and
- List each member of the subsidiary body participating remotely in the minutes of the meeting.
Members participating remotely must visibly appear on camera during the open portion of the meeting that is publicly accessible via the internet or other online platform. The visual appearance of a member on camera can cease only when the appearance would be technologically impracticable, including when a member experiences a lack of reliable broadband or internet connectivity that they could remedy by joining without video, or when the visual display of meeting materials, information, or speakers requires the visual appearance of a member of the subsidiary body to cease. If the member does not appear for internet connectivity reasons, they must announce the reason for their nonappearance when they turn off their cameras.
AB 817 provides that its provisions do not limit a subsidiary body from using other teleconferencing flexibility provisions in the Brown Act.
AB 817 makes findings and declarations to further its intent.
The measure sunsets its provisions on January 1, 2026.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “The Legislature has previously declared, ‘A vast and largely untapped reservoir of talent exists among the citizenry of the State of California, and that rich and varied segments of this great human resource are, all too frequently, not aware of the many opportunities which exist to participate in and serve on local regulatory and advisory boards, commissions, and committees.’ Under the Local Appointments List, also known as Maddy’s Act, this information must be publicly noticed and published.
“However, merely informing the public of the opportunity to engage is not enough: we can and must address barriers to entry to achieve diverse participation and representation in civic leadership. Diversification in civic participation at all levels requires careful consideration of different protected characteristics as well as socio-economic status. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
“AB 817 promotes equity and inclusion for many protected classes in local communities statewide by removing a barrier to entry into leadership opportunities. Allowing non-decision-making legislative bodies to participate virtually as long as they do not have the ability to take final action is a step forward in seeking to remedy injustices resulting from underrepresentation in leadership positions. This approach takes into consideration the public’s direct access to locally elected decision making bodies while opening the pathway to serve on advisory boards, commissions, and committees.”
2. Public access. AB 817 includes a finding that its provisions impose a limitation on the public’s constitutional right of access to public meetings. In such a case, the Constitution requires the legislation to demonstrate the interest this limitation protects and the need for protecting that interest. AB 817 states:
During the COVID-19 public health emergency, audio and video teleconference were widely used to conduct public meetings in lieu of physical location meetings, and those public meetings have been productive, increased public participation by all members of the public regardless of their location and ability to travel to physical meeting locations, increased the pool of people who are able to serve on these bodies, and protected the health and safety of civil servants and the public. Extending the operation of teleconference as conducted during the COVID-19 public health emergency for bodies of local agencies with appointed membership will continue these benefits.
In other words, AB 817 argues the purported benefits of increased public participation and diversity of the members that serve on these boards outweigh the loss of additional public scrutiny that noticing teleconference locations and making them publicly accessible provides. Does AB 817 adequately balance public access with the ability for members of subsidiary bodies to participate remotely more easily?
3. Live within the limits. Teleconferencing has been part of the Brown Act since 1988. Legislative bodies could use teleconferencing so long as they did so in a way that provides the public notice of the locations they were teleconferencing from and made them publicly accessible. Due to the social distancing requirements of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Legislature enacted AB 361 to allow local agencies to use teleconferencing without noticing each teleconference location or making these locations publicly accessible during state-declared emergencies, provided they meet specified requirements. AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio, 2022) provided another layer of flexibility for members of legislative bodies to participate remotely for “just cause” and “emergency circumstances.” These previous measures tailor their flexibility to specific events, or provide flexibility to members for a limited set of accommodations. This ensures the public can directly address members of a legislative body in person, except when a member needs a particular accommodation, or to ensure public health and safety. These limits also ensure that a member of a legislative body does not routinely participate remotely to avoid public scrutiny. AB 817 applies to any subsidiary body, and does not require members to have a specific reason or any limits on how often they can participate remotely.
4. Right time? While legislative bodies have had a little over a year to test AB 2449’s provisions, AB 817 seeks to add even more flexibility. AB 817 sunsets its provisions on January 1, 2026, meaning the supporters of the measure will have to return to the Legislature next year to ask to extend the sunset. That gives the Legislature very little time to assess whether changes to AB 817’s provisions are necessary. Given that recent efforts to expands Brown Act teleconferencing have only been in place for a year and a half, and the provisions of AB 2449 and some other teleconferencing provisions sunset on January 1, 2026, AB 817 may be premature. An alternative approach would be to allow local agencies to continue to use AB 2449’s flexibility, and then the Legislature can assess whether additional flexibility is needed.
4. Slippery slope. Exempting subsidiary bodies from the Brown Act, or providing them with additional flexibility, limits public access to organizations that serve an important role advising local agencies. Providing subsidiary bodies with more flexibility sets a precedent for other legislative bodies subject to the Brown Act to ask for similar flexibility.
5. Zoom in. Supporters of AB 817 argue subsidiary bodies warrant more flexibility than other local agencies because they can include individuals with physical or economic limitations, including seniors, individuals with disabilities, those with caretaking responsibilities, economically marginalized groups, and those who live in rural areas that face prohibitive driving distances. They say increasing teleconferencing opportunities could make it easier for these individuals to serve on these subsidiary bodies. They also argue that when these individuals participate remotely, they often participate from home, and under current law, these individuals would have to publish their home address and make it publicly accessible in most cases, which creates security concerns. However, AB 817’s definition of subsidiary bodies includes standing committees of legislative bodies. For example, if a city created a committee to develop recommendations for the city’s annual budget with just city council members, they could move that meeting online, despite not having any public members this bill claims to benefit, which eliminates the opportunity for the public to question its elected officials in-person on issues of great public concern.
To ensure legislative bodies do not take advantage of AB 817’s teleconferencing flexibility to conduct meetings remotely without the public present, the Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to:
- Prohibit subsidiary bodies with half or more of their members are members of the legislative body that created it, or their staff, from using this flexibility; and
- Provide members of a legislative body or their staff cannot exclusively establish a quorum of a subsidiary body when using this flexibility.
6. Power to the people. Supporters of this measure also argue that subsidiary bodies do not take final actions. While the measure states that subsidiary bodies must serve in an advisory capacity only, and cannot make final decisions, that does mean they do not serve important roles in developing recommendations for the legislative body that created them. The measure does not limit the membership composition or subject matter jurisdiction that subsidiary bodies can cover. This means subsidiary bodies that cover sensitive subjects like police oversight, elections, budgets, and access to public materials and facilities could move their meetings from a meeting room to a computer screen more easily. Even if subsidiary bodies only make recommendations and do not take final actions, these recommendations inform what items end up on future agendas of the legislative body. Moving meetings online means the public has less opportunity to raise issues with recommendations in person before the item ends up on a future agenda. Also, legislative bodies could place items on consent, meaning an in-person meeting on the item may never occur. To ensure adequate safeguards are in place when a subsidiary body uses AB 817’s authority, the Committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- Prohibit subsidiary bodies that have subject matter jurisdiction over police oversight, elections, budgets, or removing materials or restricting public access from facilities of the legislative body from using this flexibility.
- Require subsidiary body to present recommendations at a regular meeting of the legislative body, which could not be presented as a consent item;
- Add grants and other funding decisions to list of decisions that subsidiary bodies must not be authorized to make to use flexibility;
- In addition to requiring legislative bodies to authorize subsidiary bodies to use this flexibility, the subsidiary body must then vote to use the flexibility with a 2/3 vote. The legislative body could subsequently remove the subsidiary body’s use of the flexibility; and
- Include an in-person quorum requirement, but allow groups with specific needs to count towards the quorum requirement even if they are participating remotely.
7. Show me the money. Some subsidiary bodies compensate their members. Others pay for expenses incurred to make their participation possible. AB 817 allows all members of subsidiary bodies to participate remotely regardless of whether they are paid for the service on the subsidiary body. Should members paid for their service on subsidiary bodies be allowed to participate remotely without complying with existing teleconferencing requirements? The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to prohibit compensated members from using AB 817’s flexibility.
8. Parade isn’t over. The Legislature is considering numerous proposals to amend the Brown Act:
- AB 1852 (Pacheco), which the Committee approved on a 7-0 vote at its May 29th meeting, extends until January 1, 2030, the existing sunset date on provisions of law authorizing the Clean Power Alliance of Southern California to allow specified alternate members of its legislative body to attend closed sessions of the agency.
- AB 1855 (Arambula), which the Committee approved on a 5-2 vote at its May 29th meeting, allows community college student body associations to teleconference meetings without having to notice and make publicly accessible each teleconference location.
- AB 2302 (Addis) recasts existing limits on the number of times members of a legislative body can participate remotely in meetings for just cause or emergency circumstances. The measure is also scheduled for the Committee’s June 5th meeting.
- AB 2350 (Hoover) allows notifications for emergency meetings required by Brown Act to be sent via email, instead of given by telephone, for an emergency meeting held by a school board. The measure is also scheduled for the Committee’s June 5th meeting.
- AB 2715 (Boerner) allows the legislative body of a local agency to hold closed sessions pursuant to the Brown Act on matters pertaining to a threat to cybersecurity. The measure is also scheduled for the Committee’s June 5th meeting.
- AB 2748 (Flora) , which the Committee approved on a 7-0 vote at its May 29th meeting, allows the Board of Directors of the Tri-Dam Project to hold no more than four regular meetings annually at a Tri-Dam Project office that is located in Sonora, California, or Strawberry, California, or within 30 miles of either city.
9. Coming and going. The Senate Rules Committee has ordered a double referral of AB 817: first to the Senate Local Government Committee to hear issues related to local government, and second to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Local Government Committee: 8-0
Assembly Floor: 54-8
Support and Opposition
(5/31/24)
Support: California Association of Public Authorities for IHSS (Sponsor)
California Association of Recreation & Park Districts (Sponsor)
California State Association of Counties (CSAC) (Sponsor)
League of California Cities (Sponsor)
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC) (Sponsor)
Urban Counties of California (UCC) (Sponsor)
Alameda County Transportation Commission
Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District (AC Transit)
All Voting Members of The North Westwood Neighborhood Council
Associaiton of California School Administrators
Association of Bay Area Governments
Association of California Healthcare Districts (ACHD)
Ava Community Energy Authority
Bet Tzedek
California Air Pollution Control Officers Association
California Airports Council
California Association of Clerks & Election Officials
California Association of Councils of Governments
California Community Choice Association
California In-home Supportive Services Consumer Alliance
California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA)
California Park & Recreation Society
California Special Districts Association
California Transit Association
City Clerks Association of California
City of Alameda
City of Carlsbad
City of Downey
City of Emeryville
City of Foster City
City of Lafayette
City of Los Angeles
City of Moorpark
City of Mountain View
City of Norwalk
City of Redwood City
City of San Diego
City of Santa Rosa
City of Thousand Oaks
City/County Association of Governments of San Mateo County
Clean Power Alliance of Southern California
County of Los Angeles
County of Monterey
County of San Bernardino
County of San Diego
County of San Mateo
County of Yolo
Democracy Winters
Disability Rights California
Hand in Hand: the Domestic Employers Network
Homebridge
Justice in Aging
Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Mendocino Council of Governments
Merced County Association of Governments
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
Monterey-Salinas Transit (MST)
Napa County Transportation and Planning Agency/Napa Valley Transportation Authority
Nevada County Transportation Commission
Orange County Transportation Authority
Orange County Water District
Peninsula Clean Energy
Peninsula Corridor Joint Powers Board (CALTRAIN)
Placer Independent Resource Services
Sacramento Area Council of Governments
San Diego Community Forest Advisory Board
San Diego Community Power
San Diego County Regional Airport Authority
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District (BART)
San Mateo County Transit District (SAMTRANS)
San Mateo County Transportation Authority
Santa Barbara County Association of Governments
Santa Cruz County Regional Transportation Commission
Sonoma County Transportation Authority/Regional Climate Protection Authority
Town of Hillsborough
Tulare County Association of Governments
Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA)
Village Movement California
Western Riverside Council of Governments (WRCOG)
Yolo County In-home Supportive Services Advisory Committee
1 Individual
Opposition: ACLU California Action
California Broadcasters Association
California Common CAUSE
California News Publishers Association
Californians Aware: the Center for Public Forum Rights
First Amendment Coalition
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association (HJTA)
Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability
League of Women Voters of California
Media Alliance
National Press Photographers Association
Nlgja: Association of Lgbtq+ Journalists
Oakland Privacy
Orange County Press Club
Radio Television Digital News Association
San Diego Pro Chapter of The Society of Professional Journalists
Society of Professional Journalists, Greater Los Angeles Chapter
Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter
Student Press Law Center
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 817
Author:(Pacheco)
As Amended Ver:January 17, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Allows, until January 1, 2026, a subsidiary body of a local agency to teleconference without meeting all of the teleconferencing requirements of the Ralph M. Brown Act (Brown Act).
Major Provisions
- Defines, for the purposes of this bill, "subsidiary body" to mean a legislative body that meets all of the following:
- Is a commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, decision-making or advisory, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body. However, advisory committees, composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies, except that standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, which have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction, or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
- Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
- Allows a subsidiary body to use teleconferencing without complying with the following teleconference requirements of the Brown Act:
- Posting agendas at each teleconference location.
- Identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding.
- Making each teleconference location accessible to the public.
- Requiring at least a quorum of the members of the subsidiary body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
- Requires, in order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, a subsidiary body to comply with a number of requirements, including the following:
- The teleconferenced meetings shall be conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the subsidiary body.
- Each member of the subsidiary body shall participate through both audio and visual technology.
- The subsidiary body shall provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
- A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
- The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act.
- The subsidiary body meets a number of requirements related to public comment and meeting disruptions, as specified
- Requires, in order for a subsidiary body to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body to make the following findings by majority vote before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing pursuant to this bill for the first time, and every 12 months thereafter:
- The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
- Provides a sunset date of January 1, 2026.
COMMENTS
The Brown Act. The Brown Act was enacted in 1953 and has been amended numerous times since its enactment. The legislative intent of the Brown Act was expressly declared in its original statute, which remains unchanged:
The Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils and other public agencies in this State exist to aid in the conduct of the people's business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly. The people of this State do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies which serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.
The Brown Act generally requires meetings to be noticed in advance, including the posting of an agenda, and generally requires meetings to be open and accessible to the public. The Brown Act also generally requires members of the public to have an opportunity to comment on agenda items, and generally prohibits deliberation or action on items not listed on the agenda.
Please see the policy analysis from the Assembly Committee on Local Government for a full discussion of the Brown Act and other provisions of this bill.
Executive Order N-29-20. In March of 2020, the Governor issued Executive Order N-29-20, which stated that, "Notwithstanding any other provision of state or local law (including, but not limited to, the Bagley-Keene Act or the Brown Act), and subject to the notice and accessibility requirements set forth below, a local legislative body or state body is authorized to hold public meetings via teleconferencing and to make public meetings accessible telephonically or otherwise electronically to all members of the public seeking to observe and to address the local legislative body or state body. All requirements in both the Bagley-Keene Act and the Brown Act expressly or impliedly requiring the physical presence of members, the clerk or other personnel of the body, or of the public as a condition of participation in or quorum for a public meeting are hereby waived. All of the foregoing provisions concerning the conduct of public meetings shall apply only during the period in which state or local public health officials have imposed or recommended social distancing measures."
According to the Author
The Legislature has previously declared, 'A vast and largely untapped reservoir of talent exists among the citizenry of the State of California, and that rich and varied segments of this great human resource are, all too frequently, not aware of the many opportunities which exist to participate in and serve on local regulatory and advisory boards, commissions, and committees.' Under the Local Appointments List, also known as Maddy's Act, this information must be publicly noticed and published.
However, merely informing the public of the opportunity to engage is not enough: we can and must address barriers to entry to achieve diverse participation and representation in civic leadership. Diversification in civic participation at all levels requires careful consideration of different protected characteristics as well as socio-economic status. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
AB 817 promotes equity and inclusion for many protected classes in local communities statewide by removing a barrier to entry into leadership opportunities. Allowing non-decision-making legislative bodies to participate virtually as long as they do not have the ability to take final action is a step forward in seeking to remedy injustices resulting from underrepresentation in leadership positions. This approach takes into consideration the public's direct access to locally elected decision making bodies while opening the pathway to serve on advisory boards, commissions, and committees.
Arguments in Support
The California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts, the League of California Cities, Urban Counties of California, the Rural County Representative of California, and the California State Association of Counties, sponsors of this measure, write, "Local governments across the state have faced an ongoing challenge to recruit and retain members of the public on advisory bodies, boards, and commissions. Challenges associated with recruitment have been attributed to participation time commitments; time and location of meetings; physical limitation, conflicts with childcare, and work obligations.
"The COVID-19 global pandemic drove both hyper-awareness and concerns about the spread of infectious diseases, as well as removed barriers to local civic participation by allowing this same remote participation. This enabled individuals who could not otherwise accommodate the time, distance, or mandatory physical participation requirements to engage locally, providing access to leadership opportunities and providing communities with greater diversified input on critical community proposals…
"The in-person requirement to participate in local governance bodies presents a disproportionate challenge for those with physical or economic limitations, including seniors, persons with disability, single parents and/or caretakers, economically marginalized groups, and those who live in rural areas and face prohibitive driving distances. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
"AB 817 would help address these issues by providing a narrow exemption under the Ralph M. Brown Act for non-decision-making legislative bodies that do not take final action on any legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or other entitlements, so that equity in opportunity to serve locally and representative diversity in leadership can be achieved. For these reasons, we are collectively pleased to support AB 817…"
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of opponents, including the California News Publishers Association, ACLU California Action, Californians Aware, the California Broadcasters Association, the First Amendment Coalition, Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability, National Press Photographers Association, NLGJA: Association of LGBTQ+ Journalists, Radio Television Digital News Association, San Diego Pro Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, Society of Professional Journalists, Los Angeles Chapter, Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter, and the Freedom of Information Committee, write, "Last year, lawmakers passed AB 2449, amending the Brown Act to give further flexibility to individual members of local legislative bodies to participate in public meetings remotely when certain requirements are met…Importantly, the bill required the body to maintain a quorum of members in one physical location accessible to the public inside the jurisdiction. Whenever some members might elect to use teleconferencing to participate remotely, the legislation specifies that the public must also have the ability to access and participate through remote technology as well. The bill also contained many other guardrails that were important to this coalition, the sponsors of the bills and the numerous policy committees that invested time considering the bill.
"AB 2449 by Assemblymember Blanca Rubio was the result of careful negotiations by members of the undersigned coalition. After thoughtful conversations, the resulting legislation, in effect now for mere months, rigorously balanced open-government protections with the desire for members of local bodies to have increased flexibility for their own remote participation following the COVID-19 era of virtual meetings. The hard work that was done last year must be given an opportunity to play out before making additional, and in some cases, drastic and permanent changes to the Brown Act….
"AB 817's rewriting of the Brown Act would fundamentally undermine one of the law's key protections for public access and participation — the guarantee that the press and public can be physically present in the same room as those sitting on the dais and making decisions. Such physical presence has been a constant hallmark of democratic institutions…For journalists who do the important work of informing their communities, AB 817 would make newsgathering even more challenging. A primary newsgathering tool is being able to approach officials, see how decision-makers engage with the public, and observe how officials interact with one another on the dais. By allowing bodies to meet remotely indefinitely, AB 817 would significantly hamper the ability of reporters and photographers to provide valuable information to their readers, leaving Californians less informed.
"For advocates and other concerned Californians who do community organizing for social change, AB 817 would make this work more challenging. A primary organizing tool of impacted communities is to show up to public meetings in person, face the public officials who are making decisions that affect us all, and at times raise awareness about important public policy among members of the observing press…
"The undersigned organizations advocate for or increase awareness about ways to achieve the goal of greater diversity and equity within government bodies and among the members of the public who attend public meetings. Allowing members to participate remotely and never have to face the public in person is not an effective way to diversify bodies governed by our state's open-meeting laws. Diversifying our state and local legislative bodies instead requires public officials to commit to robust outreach to potential members, provide stipends for unpaid positions, implement an open and transparent selection and appointment process, and exercise the political will to appoint members from diverse backgrounds and identities to public bodies, among other things."
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM LOCAL GOVERNMENT: 8-0-1
YES: Juan Carrillo, Waldron, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Ramos, Ward, Wilson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Essayli
UPDATED
VERSION: January 17, 2024
CONSULTANT: Angela Mapp / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0002593
Date of Hearing: January 10, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Juan Carrillo, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 817 (
Author:Pacheco) – As Amended Ver:March 16, 2023
SUBJECT: Open meetings: teleconferencing: subsidiary body
SUMMARY: Allows a subsidiary body of a local agency to use teleconferencing for its meetings without posting agendas at each teleconference location, identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, making each teleconference location accessible to the public, and requiring at least a quorum of the subsidiary body to participate from within the local agency’s jurisdiction, subject to certain conditions. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines, for the purposes of this bill, “subsidiary body” to mean a legislative body that meets all of the following:
- Is a commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, decision-making or advisory, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body. However, advisory committees, composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies, except that standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, which have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction, or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
- Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
- Allows a subsidiary body to use teleconferencing without complying with the following teleconference requirements of the Ralph M. Brown Act (Brown Act):
- Posting agendas at each teleconference location.
- Identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding.
- Making each teleconference location accessible to the public.
- Requiring at least a quorum of the members of the subsidiary body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
- Requires, in order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, a subsidiary body to comply with all of the following:
- The teleconferenced meetings shall be conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the subsidiary body.
- Each member of the subsidiary body shall participate through both audio and visual technology.
- The subsidiary body shall provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
- A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
- The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act.
- In each instance in which notice of the time of the teleconferenced meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted, the subsidiary body shall also give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment.
- The agenda shall identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly, pursuant to the Brown Act’s provisions governing public comment, via a call-in option or via an internet-based service option.
- In the event of a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting to members of the public using the call-in option or internet-based service option, or in the event of a disruption within the subsidiary body’s control that prevents members of the public from offering public comments using the call-in option or internet-based service option, the subsidiary body shall take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until public access to the meeting via the call-in option or internet-based service option is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting may be challenged pursuant to specified provisions of the Brown Act that govern the ability of a district attorney or interested person to seek a judicial determination that an action violates specified provisions of the Brown Act and is, therefore, null and void.
- An individual desiring to provide public comment through the use of an internet website, or other online platform, not under the control of the subsidiary body, that requires registration to log in to a teleconference may be required to register as required by the third-party internet website or online platform to participate, notwithstanding provisions of the Brown Act that prohibit a member of the public from being required to register or fulfill any condition before attending a meeting of a legislative body of a local agency.
- The subsidiary body shall not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting and must provide an opportunity for the public to address the subsidiary body and offer comment in real time.
- A subsidiary body that provides a timed public comment period for each agenda item shall not close the public comment period for the agenda item, or the opportunity to register, pursuant to h), above, to provide public comment until that timed public comment period has elapsed.
- A subsidiary body that does not provide a timed public comment period, but takes public comment separately on each agenda item, shall allow a reasonable amount of time per agenda item to allow public members the opportunity to provide public comment, including time for members of the public to register, pursuant to h), above, or otherwise be recognized for the purpose of providing public comment.
- A subsidiary body that provides a timed general public comment period that does not correspond to a specific agenda item shall not close the public comment period or the opportunity to register, pursuant to h), above, until the timed general public comment period has elapsed.
- Requires, in order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action to make the following findings by majority vote before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing pursuant to this bill for the first time, and every 12 months thereafter:
- The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
- Provides that the definitions in specified existing provisions of the Brown Act, including teleconferencing provisions, apply for the purposes of this bill.
- Finds and declares that Section 1 of this bill imposes a limitation on the public’s right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
By removing the requirement for agendas to be placed at the location of each public official participating in a public meeting remotely, this act protects the personal, private information of public officials and their families while preserving the public’s right to access information concerning the conduct of the people’s business.
- Finds and declares that Section 1 of this bill furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to that Constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings:
This act is necessary to provide opportunities for public participation in meetings of specified public agencies and to promote the attraction and retention of members of those agencies.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, pursuant to Article I, Section 3 of the California Constitution, the following:
- The people have the right to instruct their representatives, petition government for redress of grievances, and assemble freely to consult for the common good.
- The people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny.
- In order to ensure public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, as specified in b), above, each local agency is required to comply with the California Public Records Act, the Brown Act, and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, enacting a successor act, or amending any successor act that contains findings demonstrating that the statutory enactment furthers the purposes of these constitutional provisions.
- Provides, pursuant to the Brown Act, requirements for local agency meetings. (GOV §§ 54950 – 54963)
- Authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing, subject to a number of requirements that include posting agendas at all teleconference locations, identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding, making each teleconference location accessible to the public, and requiring at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction, as specified. [GOV § 54953(b)(3)]
- Defines “teleconference” to mean a meeting of a legislative body, the members of which are in different locations, connected by electronic means, through either audio or video, or both. [GOV § 54953(j)(6)]
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2024, pursuant to provisions of law enacted via AB 361 (Robert Rivas), Chapter 165, Statutes of 2021, a local agency to use teleconferencing without complying with the requirements of 3), above, during a proclaimed state of emergency, as specified. [GOV § 54953(e)]
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2026, pursuant to provisions of law enacted via AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 285, Statutes of 2022, a legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing without complying with the requirements of 3), above, subject to multiple conditions and requirements and limited to “just cause” or for emergency circumstances, as specified. [GOV § 54953(f)]
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “The Legislature has previously declared, ‘A vast and largely untapped reservoir of talent exists among the citizenry of the State of California, and that rich and varied segments of this great human resource are, all too frequently, not aware of the many opportunities which exist to participate in and serve on local regulatory and advisory boards, commissions, and committees.’ Under the Local Appointments List, also known as Maddy’s Act, this information must be publicly noticed and published.
“However, merely informing the public of the opportunity to engage is not enough: we can and must address barriers to entry to achieve diverse participation and representation in civic leadership. Diversification in civic participation at all levels requires careful consideration of different protected characteristics as well as socio-economic status. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
“AB 817 promotes equity and inclusion for many protected classes in local communities statewide by removing a barrier to entry into leadership opportunities. Allowing non-decision-making legislative bodies to participate virtually as long as they do not have the ability to take final action is a step forward in seeking to remedy injustices resulting from underrepresentation in leadership positions. This approach takes into consideration the public’s direct access to locally elected decision making bodies while opening the pathway to serve on advisory boards, commissions, and committees.”
- Background. The Brown Act was enacted in 1953 and has been amended numerous times since then. The legislative intent of the Brown Act was expressly declared in its original statute, which remains unchanged:
“The Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils and other public agencies in this State exist to aid in the conduct of the people’s business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly. The people of this State do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies which serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.”
The Brown Act generally requires meetings to be noticed in advance, including the posting of an agenda, and generally requires meetings to be open and accessible to the public. The Brown Act also generally requires members of the public to have an opportunity to comment on agenda items, and generally prohibits deliberation or action on items not listed on the agenda.
- Agencies and Legislative Bodies. The Brown Act defines “local agency” to mean a county, city, whether general law or chartered, city and county, town, school district, municipal corporation, district, political subdivision, or any board, commission or agency thereof, or other local public agency.
The Brown Act defines “legislative body” to mean:
- The governing body of a local agency or any other local body created by state or federal statute.
- A commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, decision-making or advisory, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body. Advisory committees composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies. Standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, that have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- A board, commission, committee, or other multimember body that governs a private corporation, limited liability company, or other entity that either:
- Is created by the elected legislative body in order to exercise authority that may lawfully be delegated by the elected governing body to a private corporation, limited liability company, or other entity.
- Receives funds from a local agency and the membership of whose governing body includes a member of the legislative body of the local agency appointed to that governing body as a full voting member by the legislative body of the local agency.
- Meetings. The Brown Act defines a “meeting” as “any congregation of a majority of the member of a legislative body at the same time and location, including teleconference locations, to hear, discuss, deliberate, or take action on any item that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body.”
- Registering. The Brown Act specifies that a member of the public shall not be required, as a condition of attending a meeting, to register a name, provide other information, complete a questionnaire, or otherwise fulfill any condition precedent to attendance. If an attendance list, register, questionnaire, or other similar document is posted at or near the entrance to the room where the meeting is to be held, or is circulated during the meeting, it must state clearly that signing, registering, or completing the document is voluntary, and that all persons may attend the meeting regardless of whether a person signs, registers, or completes the document.
- Remedies for Violations. The Brown Act allows a district attorney or any interested person to seek a judicial determination that an action taken by a local agency’s legislative body violates specified provisions of the Brown Act – including the provisions governing open meeting requirements, teleconferencing, and agendas – and is therefore null and void.
- Agendas. The Brown Act requires local agencies to post, at least 72 hours before a regular meeting, an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted or discussed at the meeting, including items to be discussed in closed session. The agenda must specify the time and location of the regular meeting and must be posted in a location that is freely accessible to members of the public and on the local agency website, if the local agency has one. No action or discussion may be undertaken on any item not appearing on the posted agenda, with specified exceptions.
If requested, the agenda must be made available in appropriate alternative formats to persons with a disability, as required by Section 202 of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), and the federal rules and regulations adopted to implement the ADA. The agenda must include information regarding how, to whom, and when a request for disability-related modification or accommodation, including auxiliary aids or services, may be made by a person with a disability who requires a modification or accommodation in order to participate in the public meeting.
- Comment Periods. The Brown Act generally requires every agenda for regular meetings to provide an opportunity for members of the public to directly address the legislative body on any item of interest to the public, before or during the legislative body’s consideration of the item, that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body. The legislative body of a local agency may adopt reasonable regulations to ensure that this intent is carried out, including, but not limited to, regulations limiting the total amount of time allocated for public testimony on particular issues and for each individual speaker.
- Teleconferencing and the Brown Act. The Brown Act first allowed meetings to be conducted via video teleconference in 1988. At the time, San Diego County was considering the use of video teleconferencing for meetings and hearings of the board of supervisors due to concerns about the long distances that some of their constituents were having to travel to participate in board meetings. They were especially concerned that these distances were so great that they prohibited some people from attending meetings at all. AB 3191 (Frazee), Chapter 399, Statutes of 1988, responded to these concerns by authorizing the legislative body of a local agency to use video teleconferencing. Since that time, a number of bills have made modifications to this original authorization.
The Brown Act generally allows the legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing for the benefit of the public and the legislative body in connection with any meeting or proceeding authorized by law. The teleconferenced meeting or proceeding must comply with all requirements of the Brown Act and all otherwise applicable provisions of law relating to a specific type of meeting or proceeding. Teleconferencing may be used for all purposes in connection with any meeting within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body.
If the legislative body of a local agency elects to use teleconferencing, the legislative body must comply with a number of requirements. It must conduct teleconference meetings in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the legislative body of a local agency. The legislative body must give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act, and must allow members of the public to access the meeting. The agenda for the meeting must provide an opportunity for members of the public to address the legislative body directly pursuant to the Brown Act’s provisions governing public comment. All votes taken during a teleconferenced meeting must be taken by roll call.
“Teleconference” is defined as a meeting of a legislative body, the members of which are in different locations, connected by electronic means, through either audio or video, or both. Teleconferencing has never been required. It has always been permissive.
- The Four Teleconferencing Rules of GOV § 54953(b)(3). The Brown Act contains four additional specific requirements for teleconferenced meetings in GOV § 54953(b)(3). Specifically, this paragraph requires all of the following:
- The legislative body shall post agendas at all teleconference locations.
- Each teleconference location shall be identified in the notice and agenda of the meeting or proceeding.
- Each teleconference location shall be accessible to the public.
- During the teleconference, at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body shall participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction, with specified exceptions.
- Executive Order N-29-20. In March of 2020, the Governor issued Executive Order N-29-20, which stated that, “Notwithstanding any other provision of state or local law (including, but not limited to, the Bagley-Keene Act or the Brown Act), and subject to the notice and accessibility requirements set forth below, a local legislative body or state body is authorized to hold public meetings via teleconferencing and to make public meetings accessible telephonically or otherwise electronically to all members of the public seeking to observe and to address the local legislative body or state body. All requirements in both the Bagley-Keene Act and the Brown Act expressly or impliedly requiring the physical presence of members, the clerk or other personnel of the body, or of the public as a condition of participation in or quorum for a public meeting are hereby waived.”
“All of the foregoing provisions concerning the conduct of public meetings shall apply only during the period in which state or local public health officials have imposed or recommended social distancing measures.”
- AB 361 of 2021. Despite the Governor’s executive order, both local and state governing bodies were concerned about their ongoing ability to teleconference without having to disclose the locations of teleconferencing members or make those locations accessible to the public. In response, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 361 (Robert Rivas) Chapter 165, Statutes of 2021. In addition to provisions affecting state governing bodies, AB 361 allowed exemptions to the Brown Act’s teleconferencing requirements during a proclaimed state of emergency.
Specifically, AB 361 authorized a local agency’s legislative body to use teleconferencing for a public meeting without having to post agendas at each teleconference location, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, make each teleconference location accessible to the public, and require at least a quorum of the legislative body to participate from within the local agency’s jurisdiction [the requirements of GOV § 54953(b)(3)]. This flexibility was limited to the following circumstances:
- A legislative body holds a meeting during a proclaimed state of emergency, and state or local officials have imposed or recommended measures to promote social distancing.
- A legislative body holds a meeting during a proclaimed state of emergency for purposes of determining, by majority vote, whether as a result of the emergency, meeting in person would present imminent risks to the health and safety of attendees.
- A legislative body holds a meeting during a proclaimed state of emergency and has determined by majority vote pursuant to b), above, that, as a result of the emergency, meeting in person would present imminent risks to the health or safety of attendees.
AB 361 required a legislative body that chooses to use its provisions to meet the following requirements:
- Notice and Agenda. A legislative body must give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act.
- Public Access. A legislative body must allow members of the public to access the meeting, and the agenda must provide an opportunity for members of the public to address the legislative body directly. The legislative body must give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment. The agenda must identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend via call-in option or an internet-based service option. The legislative body need not provide a physical location from which the public may attend or comment.
- Meeting Disruptions. In the event of a disruption that prevents the agency from broadcasting the meeting to the public using the call-in or internet-based service options, or in the event of a disruption within the local agency’s control that prevents the public from offering public comments using the call-in or internet-based service options, the legislative body must take no further action until public access is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption may be challenged as provided in the Brown Act.
- Public Comment. The legislative body may not require public comments to be submitted in advance, and it must provide an opportunity for the public to address the legislative body and offer comment in real time. The legislative body may use an online third-party system for individuals to provide public comment that requires registration with the system before providing comment. If a legislative body provides a timed public comment period, it may not close the comment period or the time to register until the timed period has elapsed. If the legislative body does not provide a time-limited comment period, it must allow a reasonable time for the public to comment on each agenda item and to register as necessary.
If a state of emergency remains active, or state or local officials have imposed measures to promote social distancing, the legislative body must make specified findings every 30 days in order to continue using the exemptions provided by AB 361. As an urgency measure, AB 361 went into effect on September 16, 2021. It originally contained a sunset date of January 1, 2024. Legislation from last year [AB 557 (Hart) Chapter 534, Statutes of 2023] eliminated the sunset date, changed the required findings to be made every 45 days, and eliminated the ability of local agencies to continue to hold meetings pursuant to its provisions if a state of emergency ends, but state or local officials continue to impose or recommend measures to promote social distancing.
- AB 2449 of 2022. Responding to calls from local governments to provide even further flexibility to use teleconferencing, AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 285, Statutes of 2022, again relieved a legislative body of a local agency from the requirements of GOV § 54953(b)(3) while teleconferencing, but this time outside of a declared state of emergency. However, in order to enjoy this flexibility, AB 2449 requires at least a quorum of the legislative body to participate in person from a singular physical location. This location must be:
- Clearly identified on the agenda.
- Open to the public.
- Situated within the boundaries of the local agency’s jurisdiction.
The legislative body must provide one of the following so that the public can hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the legislative body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
- A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
The legislative body must give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment, and the agenda must allow all persons to attend and address the legislative body directly via a call-in option, an internet-based service option, and at the in-person location of the meeting. AB 2449 contained identical provisions as AB 361 concerning meeting disruptions and public comment.
AB 2449 allows members of a legislative body to use these alternative teleconferencing rules in two distinct situations: for “just cause” and for emergency circumstances.
- Just Cause. Under the “just cause” circumstance, a member must notify the legislative body as early as possible of their need to participate remotely for just cause. A just cause circumstance cannot be used by any member of the legislative body for more than two meetings per calendar year. “Just cause” means any of the following:
- Childcare or a caregiving need that requires them to participate remotely.
- A contagious illness that prevents a member from attending in person.
- A need related to a physical or mental disability not otherwise accommodated.
- Travel while on official business of the legislative body or another state or local agency.
- Emergency Circumstances. Under emergency circumstances, a member requests the legislative body to allow them to participate in the meeting remotely due to emergency circumstances and the legislative body takes action to approve the request. “Emergency circumstances” means a physical or family medical emergency that prevents a member from attending in person. The legislative body must request a general description of the emergency circumstances, which shall not require the member to disclose any medical diagnosis or disability or any personal medical information. For the purposes of emergency circumstances, the following requirements apply:
- A member shall make a request to participate remotely as soon as possible, and shall make a separate request for each meeting in which they seek to participate remotely.
- The legislative body may take action on a request to participate remotely at the earliest opportunity. If the request does not allow sufficient time to place proposed action on such a request on the agenda for the meeting for which the request is made, the legislative body may take action at the beginning of the meeting, in accordance with specified provisions of the Brown Act.
- The member who is participating remotely must publicly disclose at the meeting before any action is taken whether any other individuals 18 years of age or older are present in the room at the remote location with the member, and the general nature of the member’s relationship with any such individuals.
- The member must participate through both audio and visual technology.
- Just Cause. Under the “just cause” circumstance, a member must notify the legislative body as early as possible of their need to participate remotely for just cause. A just cause circumstance cannot be used by any member of the legislative body for more than two meetings per calendar year. “Just cause” means any of the following:
AB 2449 specified that its provisions shall not serve as a means for any member of a legislative body to participate in meetings of the legislative body solely by teleconference from a remote location for a period of more than three consecutive months or 20% of the regular meetings for the local agency within a calendar year, or more than two meetings if the legislative body regularly meets fewer than 10 times per calendar year.
AB 2449 remains in effect until January 1, 2026.
- Bill Summary. This bill creates a new definition – a “subsidiary body” – for the purposes of the Brown Act’s teleconferencing requirements and allows a subsidiary body to use teleconferencing without complying with the four rules of GOV § 54953(b)(3), which include the following:
- Posting agendas at each teleconference location.
- Identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding.
- Making each teleconference location accessible to the public.
- Requiring at least a quorum of the members of the subsidiary body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
The bill defines “subsidiary body” to mean a legislative body that meets all of the following:
- Is a commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body. Advisory committees, composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies. However, standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, which have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction, or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
- Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, a subsidiary body to must comply with a number of requirements, including:
- Audio and Visual Technology. Each member of the subsidiary body must participate through both audio and visual technology.
- Public Access. The subsidiary body must provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
ii) A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
- Notice and Agendas. The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act, including information regarding the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment. The agenda must identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly via a call-in option or an internet-based service option.
This bill contains identical provisions as AB 361 and AB 2449 concerning meeting disruptions and additional public comment requirements.
Before a subsidiary body can use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, and every 12 months thereafter, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body must make the following findings:
- The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
This bill is sponsored by the California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts, the League of California Cities, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representative of California, and California State Association of Counties.
- Policy Considerations. The Committee may wish to consider the following:
- Sunset Provision. When the Legislature approved AB 361 and AB 2449, both measures contained sunset provisions. AB 361 originally contained a sunset date of January 1, 2024, which has now been extended to January 1, 2026. AB 2449 contains a sunset date of January 1, 2026. This bill contains no sunset date. The Committee may wish to consider if it wishes to ensure the automatic legislative review of the provisions of this bill that a sunset date would provide.
- Protecting Public Access and Participation. AB 2449 provided local governing board members with enhanced flexibility for teleconferencing while maintaining some of the protections for public access and participation, by requiring the following:
- At least a quorum of the legislative body must participate in person.
- In-person participation must be from a singular physical location.
- The singular physical location must be:
- Clearly identified on the agenda.
- Open to the public.
- Situated within the boundaries of the local agency’s jurisdiction.
- The singular physical location must be:
The Committee may wish to consider if these protections for the public should be added to this bill.
- Committee Amendments. To address the policy considerations above, the Committee may wish to amend this bill as follows:
- Add a sunset date of January 1, 2026.
- Require a quorum of members of the subsidiary body to participate from a single, physical location within the jurisdiction of the subsidiary body’s local agency that is accessible to the public. To meet this quorum requirement, a person with a disability that requires accommodation pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act may count towards the quorum, whether that person participates in-person or via teleconference.
- Related Legislation. AB 557 (Hart), Chapter 534, Statutes of 2023, eliminated the January 1, 2024, sunset date on AB 361; changed the requirement for a legislative body, in order to continue using AB 361 teleconferencing provisions, to make specified findings every 45 days instead of every 30 days; and, eliminated the ability of local agencies to continue to hold meetings pursuant to AB 361 if a state of emergency ends, but state or local officials continue to impose or recommend measures to promote social distancing.
AB 1275 (Arambula) would have expanded teleconferencing flexibility under the Brown Act for community college student organizations. This bill was subsequently amended to address a different subject matter.
AB 1379 (Papan) would have eliminated the Brown Act’s teleconferencing requirements to post agendas at all teleconferencing locations, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, make each teleconference location accessible to the public, and require a quorum of the legislative body to participate from locations within the local agency’s jurisdiction, and allowed legislative bodies to participate remotely from any location for all but two meetings per year. AB 1379 is pending in this Committee.
SB 411 (Portantino), Chapter 605, Statutes of 2023, allows a neighborhood council in the City of Los Angeles to teleconference without meeting all of the teleconferencing requirements of the Brown Act.
SB 537 (Becker) would have allowed multi-jurisdictional, cross-county local agencies with appointed members to teleconference without meeting all of the teleconferencing requirements of the Brown Act. SB 537 was ordered to the Assembly inactive file.
- Previous Legislation. AB 1944 (Lee) would have allowed, until January 1, 2030, members of a legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing without identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting, and without making each teleconference location accessible to the public, under specified conditions. AB 1944 was held in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 285, Statutes of 2022, allows, until January 1, 2026, members of a legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing without identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting, and without making each teleconference location accessible to the public, under specified conditions.
SB 1100 (Cortese), Chapter 171, Statutes of 2022, allows the presiding member of a local legislative body to remove an individual for disrupting a local agency’s meeting, defines “disrupting” for this purpose, and outlines the procedure that must be followed before an individual may be removed.
AB 339 (Lee) of 2021 would have required, until December 31, 2023, city councils and boards of supervisors in jurisdictions over 250,000 residents provide both in-person and teleconference options for the public to attend their meetings. This bill was vetoed with the following message:
“While I appreciate the author's intent to increase transparency and public participation in certain local government meetings, this bill would set a precedent of tying public access requirements to the population of jurisdictions. This patchwork approach may lead to public confusion. Further, AB 339 limits flexibility and increases costs for the affected local jurisdictions trying to manage their meetings.
“Additionally, this bill requires in-person participation during a declared state of emergency unless there is a law prohibiting in-person meetings in those situations. This could put the health and safety of the public and employees at risk depending on the nature of the declared emergency.
“I recently signed urgency legislation that provides the authority and procedures for local entities to meet remotely during a declared state of emergency. I remain open to revisions to the Brown Act to modernize and increase public access, while protecting public health and safety. Unfortunately, the approach in this bill may have unintended consequences.”
AB 361 (Robert Rivas) Chapter 165, Statutes of 2021, allows, until January 1, 2024, local agencies to use teleconferencing without complying with specified Ralph. M Brown Act restrictions in certain state emergencies, and provides similar authorizations, until January 31, 2022, for state agencies subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and legislative bodies subject to the Gloria Romero Open Meetings Act of 2000.
AB 703 (Rubio) of 2021 would have allowed teleconferencing with only a quorum of the members of a local legislative body participating from a singular location that is clearly identified on an agenda, open to the public, and situated within the boundaries of the local agency. AB 703 was held in this Committee.
- Arguments in Support. The California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts, the League of California Cities, Urban Counties of California, the Rural County Representative of California, and the California State Association of Counties, sponsors of this measure, write, “Local governments across the state have faced an ongoing challenge to recruit and retain members of the public on advisory bodies, boards, and commissions. Challenges associated with recruitment have been attributed to participation time commitments; time and location of meetings; physical limitation, conflicts with childcare, and work obligations.
“The COVID-19 global pandemic drove both hyper-awareness and concerns about the spread of infectious diseases, as well as removed barriers to local civic participation by allowing this same remote participation. This enabled individuals who could not otherwise accommodate the time, distance, or mandatory physical participation requirements to engage locally, providing access to leadership opportunities and providing communities with greater diversified input on critical community proposals…
“The in-person requirement to participate in local governance bodies presents a disproportionate challenge for those with physical or economic limitations, including seniors, persons with disability, single parents and/or caretakers, economically marginalized groups, and those who live in rural areas and face prohibitive driving distances. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
“AB 817 would help address these issues by providing a narrow exemption under the Ralph M. Brown Act for non-decision-making legislative bodies that do not take final action on any legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or other entitlements, so that equity in opportunity to serve locally and representative diversity in leadership can be achieved. For these reasons, we are collectively pleased to support AB 817…”
- Arguments in Opposition. A coalition of opponents, including the California News Publishers Association, ACLU California Action, Californians Aware, the California Broadcasters Association, the First Amendment Coalition, Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability, National Press Photographers Association, NLGJA: Association of LGBTQ+ Journalists, Radio Television Digital News Association, San Diego Pro Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, Society of Professional Journalists, Los Angeles Chapter, Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter, and the Freedom of Information Committee, write, “Last year, lawmakers passed AB 2449, amending the Brown Act to give further flexibility to individual members of local legislative bodies to participate in public meetings remotely when certain requirements are met…Importantly, the bill required the body to maintain a quorum of members in one physical location accessible to the public inside the jurisdiction. Whenever some members might elect to use teleconferencing to participate remotely, the legislation specifies that the public must also have the ability to access and participate through remote technology as well. The bill also contained many other guardrails that were important to this coalition, the sponsors of the bills and the numerous policy committees that invested time considering the bill.
“AB 2449 by Assemblymember Blanca Rubio was the result of careful negotiations by members of the undersigned coalition. After thoughtful conversations, the resulting legislation, in effect now for mere months, rigorously balanced open-government protections with the desire for members of local bodies to have increased flexibility for their own remote participation following the COVID-19 era of virtual meetings. The hard work that was done last year must be given an opportunity to play out before making additional, and in some cases, drastic and permanent changes to the Brown Act….
“AB 817’s rewriting of the Brown Act would fundamentally undermine one of the law’s key protections for public access and participation — the guarantee that the press and public can be physically present in the same room as those sitting on the dais and making decisions. Such physical presence has been a constant hallmark of democratic institutions…For journalists who do the important work of informing their communities, AB 817 would make newsgathering even more challenging. A primary newsgathering tool is being able to approach officials, see how decision-makers engage with the public, and observe how officials interact with one another on the dais. By allowing bodies to meet remotely indefinitely, AB 817 would significantly hamper the ability of reporters and photographers to provide valuable information to their readers, leaving Californians less informed.
“For advocates and other concerned Californians who do community organizing for social change, AB 817 would make this work more challenging. A primary organizing tool of impacted communities is to show up to public meetings in person, face the public officials who are making decisions that affect us all, and at times raise awareness about important public policy among members of the observing press…
“The undersigned organizations advocate for or increase awareness about ways to achieve the goal of greater diversity and equity within government bodies and among the members of the public who attend public meetings. Allowing members to participate remotely and never have to face the public in person is not an effective way to diversify bodies governed by our state’s open-meeting laws. Diversifying our state and local legislative bodies instead requires public officials to commit to robust outreach to potential members, provide stipends for unpaid positions, implement an open and transparent selection and appointment process, and exercise the political will to appoint members from diverse backgrounds and identities to public bodies, among other things.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts [CO-SPONSOR]
California State Association of Counties [CO-SPONSOR]
League of California Cities [CO-SPONSOR]
Rural County Representatives of California [CO-SPONSOR]
Urban Counties of California [CO-SPONSOR]
AARP
Agency on Aging \ Area 4
Alameda County Transportation Commission
Associaiton of California School Administrators
Association of California Healthcare Districts (ACHD)
Bay Area Air Quality Management District
Bay Area Digital Inclusion Coalition
Bet Tzedek
CA In-home Supportive Services Consumer Alliance
California Air Pollution Control Officers Association
California Association of Clerks & Election Officials
California Association of Councils of Governments
California Association of Public Authorities for IHSS
California Commission on Aging
California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA)
California Senior Legislature
California Special Districts Association
Carmichael Recreation and Park District
City and County Association of Governments of San Mateo County
City Clerks Association of California
City of Alameda
City of Bell
City of Bell Gardens
City of Belmont
City of Carlsbad
City of Downey
City of Emeryville
City of Goleta
City of Lafayette
City of Los Angeles
City of Mountain View
City of Norwalk
City of Redwood City
City of San Carlos
City of San Marcos
City of Santa Rosa
City of Thousand Oaks
City of West Holloywood
City of West Hollywood
City of Winters
City of Woodland
Civicwell (formally the Local Government Commission)
Conejo Recreation and Park District
Contra Costa County
Contra Costa County Advisory Council on Aging
County of Humboldt
County of Inyo
County of Los Angeles
County of Mendocino
County of Monterey
County of San Bernardino
County of San Diego
County of San Joaquin
County of Santa Barbara
County of Santa Cruz
County of Sonoma
County of Ventura
County of Yolo
Democracy Winters
Disability Rights California
Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund
Fair Oaks Recreation & Park District
Hand in Hand: the Domestic Employers Network
Homebridge
Justice in Aging
Lake Cuyamaca
Livermore Area Recreation and Park District
Los Angeles County Division, League of California Cities
Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority
Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts
Marin County Council of Mayors and Council members (MCCMC)
Napa County
Napa Valley Transportation Authority
Orange County Transportation Authority
Peninsula Traffic Congestion Relief Alliance (COMMUTE.ORG)
Placer Independent Resource Services
Regional Climate Protection Authority
Rim of The World Recreation and Park District
Rio Linda Elverta Recreation and Park District
Sacramento Area Council of Governments
San Gabriel Valley Council of Governments
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
San Mateo County Transit District
San Mateo County Transit District (SAMTRANS)
San Mateo County-city/county Association of Governments
Santa Barbara County Association of Governments
Sonoma Clean Power
Sonoma County Transportation Authority
Tuolumne County Board of Supervisors
Village Movement California
Water Replenishment District of Southern California
Yolo County In-home Supportive Services Advisory Committee
Support If Amended
The California Association of Local Behavioral Health Boards and Commissions
Opposition
ACLU California Action
California Broadcasters Association
California Common Cause
California News Publishers Association
Californians Aware
First Amendment Coalition
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability
National Press Photographers Association
Nlgja: Association of Lgbtq+ Journalists
Northern California Society of Professional Journalists
Radio Television Digital News Association
San Diego Pro Chapter of The Society of Professional Journalists
Society of Professional Journalists, Greater Los Angeles Chapter
Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter
Analysis Prepared by: Angela Mapp / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 817 (
Author:Pacheco) – As Amended Ver:March 16, 2023
SUBJECT: Open meetings: teleconferencing: subsidiary body.
SUMMARY: Allows a subsidiary body of a local agency to use teleconferencing for its meetings without posting agendas at each teleconference location, identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, making each teleconference location accessible to the public, and requiring at least a quorum of the subsidiary body to participate from within the local agency’s jurisdiction, subject to certain conditions. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines, for the purposes of this bill, “subsidiary body” to mean a legislative body that meets all of the following:
- Is a commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, decision-making or advisory, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body. However, advisory committees, composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies, except that standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, which have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction, or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
- Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
- Allows a subsidiary body to use teleconferencing without complying with the following teleconference requirements of the Brown Act:
- Posting agendas at each teleconference location.
- Identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding.
- Making each teleconference location accessible to the public.
- Requiring at least a quorum of the members of the subsidiary body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
- Requires, in order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, a subsidiary body to comply with all of the following:
- The teleconferenced meetings shall be conducted in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the subsidiary body.
- Each member of the subsidiary body shall participate through both audio and visual technology.
- The subsidiary body shall provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
- A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
- The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act.
- In each instance in which notice of the time of the teleconferenced meeting is otherwise given or the agenda for the meeting is otherwise posted, the subsidiary body shall also give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment.
- The agenda shall identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly, pursuant to the Brown Act’s provisions governing public comment, via a call-in option or via an internet-based service option.
- In the event of a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting to members of the public using the call-in option or internet-based service option, or in the event of a disruption within the subsidiary body’s control that prevents members of the public from offering public comments using the call-in option or internet-based service option, the subsidiary body shall take no further action on items appearing on the meeting agenda until public access to the meeting via the call-in option or internet-based service option is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption that prevents the subsidiary body from broadcasting the meeting may be challenged pursuant to specified provisions of the Brown Act that govern the ability of a district attorney or interested person to seek a judicial determination that an action violates specified provisions of the Brown Act and is, therefore, null and void.
- An individual desiring to provide public comment through the use of an internet website, or other online platform, not under the control of the subsidiary body, that requires registration to log in to a teleconference may be required to register as required by the third-party internet website or online platform to participate, notwithstanding provisions of the Brown Act that prohibit a member of the public from being required to register or fulfill any condition before attending a meeting of a legislative body of a local agency.
- The subsidiary body shall not require public comments to be submitted in advance of the meeting and must provide an opportunity for the public to address the subsidiary body and offer comment in real time.
- A subsidiary body that provides a timed public comment period for each agenda item shall not close the public comment period for the agenda item, or the opportunity to register, pursuant to h), above, to provide public comment until that timed public comment period has elapsed.
- A subsidiary body that does not provide a timed public comment period, but takes public comment separately on each agenda item, shall allow a reasonable amount of time per agenda item to allow public members the opportunity to provide public comment, including time for members of the public to register, pursuant to h), above, or otherwise be recognized for the purpose of providing public comment.
- A subsidiary body that provides a timed general public comment period that does not correspond to a specific agenda item shall not close the public comment period or the opportunity to register, pursuant to h), above, until the timed general public comment period has elapsed.
- Requires, in order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body by charter, ordinance, resolution, or other formal action to make the following findings by majority vote before the subsidiary body uses teleconferencing pursuant to this bill for the first time, and every 12 months thereafter:
- The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
- Provides that the definitions in specified existing provisions of the Brown Act, including teleconferencing provisions, apply for the purposes of this bill.
- Finds and declares that Section 1 of this bill imposes a limitation on the public’s right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
By removing the requirement for agendas to be placed at the location of each public official participating in a public meeting remotely, this act protects the personal, private information of public officials and their families while preserving the public’s right to access information concerning the conduct of the people’s business.
- Finds and declares that Section 1 of this bill furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to that Constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings:
This act is necessary to provide opportunities for public participation in meetings of specified public agencies and to promote the attraction and retention of members of those agencies.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, pursuant to Article I, Section 3 of the California Constitution, the following:
- The people have the right to instruct their representatives, petition government for redress of grievances, and assemble freely to consult for the common good.
- The people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny.
- In order to ensure public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, as specified in b), above, each local agency is required to comply with the California Public Records Act, the Brown Act, and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, enacting a successor act, or amending any successor act that contains findings demonstrating that the statutory enactment furthers the purposes of these constitutional provisions.
- Provides, pursuant to the Brown Act, requirements for local agency meetings. (GOV §§ 54950 – 54963)
- Authorizes the legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing, subject to a number of requirements that include posting agendas at all teleconference locations, identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding, making each teleconference location accessible to the public, and requiring at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction, as specified. [GOV § 54953(b)(3)]
- Defines “teleconference” to mean a meeting of a legislative body, the members of which are in different locations, connected by electronic means, through either audio or video, or both. [GOV § 54953(j)(6)]
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2024, pursuant to provisions of law enacted via AB 361 (Robert Rivas), Chapter 165, Statutes of 2021, a local agency to use teleconferencing without complying with the requirements of 3), above, during a proclaimed state of emergency, as specified. [GOV § 54953(e)]
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2026, pursuant to provisions of law enacted via AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 285, Statutes of 2022, a legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing without complying with the requirements of 3), above, subject to multiple conditions and requirements and limited to “just cause” or for emergency circumstances, as specified. [GOV § 54953(f)]
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “The Legislature has previously declared, ‘A vast and largely untapped reservoir of talent exists among the citizenry of the State of California, and that rich and varied segments of this great human resource are, all too frequently, not aware of the many opportunities which exist to participate in and serve on local regulatory and advisory boards, commissions, and committees.’ Under the Local Appointments List, also known as Maddy’s Act, this information must be publicly noticed and published.
“However, merely informing the public of the opportunity to engage is not enough: we can and must address barriers to entry to achieve diverse participation and representation in civic leadership. Diversification in civic participation at all levels requires careful consideration of different protected characteristics as well as socio-economic status. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
“AB 817 promotes equity and inclusion for many protected classes in local communities statewide by removing a barrier to entry into leadership opportunities. Allowing non-decision-making legislative bodies to participate virtually as long as they do not have the ability to take final action is a step forward in seeking to remedy injustices resulting from underrepresentation in leadership positions. This approach takes into consideration the public’s direct access to locally elected decision making bodies while opening the pathway to serve on advisory boards, commissions, and committees.”
- Background. The Brown Act was enacted in 1953 and has been amended numerous times since then. The legislative intent of the Brown Act was expressly declared in its original statute, which remains unchanged:
“The Legislature finds and declares that the public commissions, boards and councils and other public agencies in this State exist to aid in the conduct of the people’s business. It is the intent of the law that their actions be taken openly and that their deliberations be conducted openly. The people of this State do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies which serve them. The people, in delegating authority, do not give their public servants the right to decide what is good for the people to know and what is not good for them to know. The people insist on remaining informed so that they may retain control over the instruments they have created.”
The Brown Act generally requires meetings to be noticed in advance, including the posting of an agenda, and generally requires meetings to be open and accessible to the public. The Brown Act also generally requires members of the public to have an opportunity to comment on agenda items, and generally prohibits deliberation or action on items not listed on the agenda.
The Brown Act defines “local agency” to mean a county, city, whether general law or chartered, city and county, town, school district, municipal corporation, district, political subdivision, or any board, commission or agency thereof, or other local public agency.
The Brown Act defines “legislative body” to mean:
- The governing body of a local agency or any other local body created by state or federal statute.
- A commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, decision-making or advisory, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body. Advisory committees composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies. Standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, that have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- A board, commission, committee, or other multimember body that governs a private corporation, limited liability company, or other entity that either:
- Is created by the elected legislative body in order to exercise authority that may lawfully be delegated by the elected governing body to a private corporation, limited liability company, or other entity.
- Receives funds from a local agency and the membership of whose governing body includes a member of the legislative body of the local agency appointed to that governing body as a full voting member by the legislative body of the local agency.
The Brown Act defines a “meeting” as “any congregation of a majority of the member of a legislative body at the same time and location, including teleconference locations, to hear, discuss, deliberate, or take action on any item that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body.”
The Brown Act specifies that a member of the public shall not be required, as a condition of attending a meeting, to register a name, provide other information, complete a questionnaire, or otherwise fulfill any condition precedent to attendance. If an attendance list, register, questionnaire, or other similar document is posted at or near the entrance to the room where the meeting is to be held, or is circulated during the meeting, it must state clearly that signing, registering, or completing the document is voluntary, and that all persons may attend the meeting regardless of whether a person signs, registers, or completes the document.
The Brown Act allows a district attorney or any interested person to seek a judicial determination that an action taken by a local agency’s legislative body violates specified provisions of the Brown Act – including the provisions governing open meeting requirements, teleconferencing, and agendas – and is therefore null and void.
- Agendas. The Brown Act requires local agencies to post, at least 72 hours before a regular meeting, an agenda containing a brief general description of each item of business to be transacted or discussed at the meeting, including items to be discussed in closed session. The agenda must specify the time and location of the regular meeting and must be posted in a location that is freely accessible to members of the public and on the local agency website, if the local agency has one. No action or discussion may be undertaken on any item not appearing on the posted agenda, with specified exceptions.
If requested, the agenda must be made available in appropriate alternative formats to persons with a disability, as required by Section 202 of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA), and the federal rules and regulations adopted to implement the ADA. The agenda must include information regarding how, to whom, and when a request for disability-related modification or accommodation, including auxiliary aids or services, may be made by a person with a disability who requires a modification or accommodation in order to participate in the public meeting.
- Comment Periods. The Brown Act generally requires every agenda for regular meetings to provide an opportunity for members of the public to directly address the legislative body on any item of interest to the public, before or during the legislative body’s consideration of the item, that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body. The legislative body of a local agency may adopt reasonable regulations to ensure that this intent is carried out, including, but not limited to, regulations limiting the total amount of time allocated for public testimony on particular issues and for each individual speaker.
- Teleconferencing and the Brown Act. The Brown Act first allowed meetings to be conducted via video teleconference in 1988. At the time, San Diego County was considering the use of video teleconferencing for meetings and hearings of the board of supervisors due to concerns about the long distances that some of their constituents were having to travel to participate in board meetings. They were especially concerned that these distances were so great that they prohibited some people from attending meetings at all. AB 3191 (Frazee), Chapter 399, Statutes of 1988, responded to these concerns by authorizing the legislative body of a local agency to use video teleconferencing. Since that time, a number of bills have made modifications to this original authorization.
The Brown Act generally allows the legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing for the benefit of the public and the legislative body in connection with any meeting or proceeding authorized by law. The teleconferenced meeting or proceeding must comply with all requirements of the Brown Act and all otherwise applicable provisions of law relating to a specific type of meeting or proceeding. Teleconferencing may be used for all purposes in connection with any meeting within the subject matter jurisdiction of the legislative body.
If the legislative body of a local agency elects to use teleconferencing, the legislative body must comply with a number of requirements. It must conduct teleconference meetings in a manner that protects the statutory and constitutional rights of the parties or the public appearing before the legislative body of a local agency. The legislative body must give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act, and must allow members of the public to access the meeting. The agenda for the meeting must provide an opportunity for members of the public to address the legislative body directly pursuant to the Brown Act’s provisions governing public comment. All votes taken during a teleconferenced meeting must be taken by roll call.
“Teleconference” is defined as a meeting of a legislative body, the members of which are in different locations, connected by electronic means, through either audio or video, or both. Teleconferencing has never been required. It has always been permissive.
- The Four Teleconferencing Rules of GOV § 54953(b)(3). The Brown Act contains four additional specific requirements for teleconferenced meetings in GOV § 54953(b)(3). Specifically, this paragraph requires all of the following:
- The legislative body shall post agendas at all teleconference locations.
- Each teleconference location shall be identified in the notice and agenda of the meeting or proceeding.
- Each teleconference location shall be accessible to the public.
- During the teleconference, at least a quorum of the members of the legislative body shall participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction, with specified exceptions.
- Executive Order N-29-20. In March of 2020, the Governor issued Executive Order N-29-20, which stated that, “Notwithstanding any other provision of state or local law (including, but not limited to, the Bagley-Keene Act or the Brown Act), and subject to the notice and accessibility requirements set forth below, a local legislative body or state body is authorized to hold public meetings via teleconferencing and to make public meetings accessible telephonically or otherwise electronically to all members of the public seeking to observe and to address the local legislative body or state body. All requirements in both the Bagley-Keene Act and the Brown Act expressly or impliedly requiring the physical presence of members, the clerk or other personnel of the body, or of the public as a condition of participation in or quorum for a public meeting are hereby waived.”
“All of the foregoing provisions concerning the conduct of public meetings shall apply only during the period in which state or local public health officials have imposed or recommended social distancing measures.”
- AB 361 of 2021. Despite the Governor’s executive order, both local and state governing bodies were concerned about their ongoing ability to teleconference without having to disclose the locations of teleconferencing members or make those locations accessible to the public. In response, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 361 (Robert Rivas) Chapter 165, Statutes of 2021. In addition to provisions affecting state governing bodies, AB 361 allowed exemptions to the Brown Act’s teleconferencing requirements during a proclaimed state of emergency.
Specifically, AB 361 authorized a local agency’s legislative body to use teleconferencing for a public meeting without having to post agendas at each teleconference location, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, make each teleconference location accessible to the public, and require at least a quorum of the legislative body to participate from within the local agency’s jurisdiction [the requirements of GOV § 54953(b)(3)]. This flexibility was limited to the following circumstances:
- A legislative body holds a meeting during a proclaimed state of emergency, and state or local officials have imposed or recommended measures to promote social distancing.
- A legislative body holds a meeting during a proclaimed state of emergency for purposes of determining, by majority vote, whether as a result of the emergency, meeting in person would present imminent risks to the health and safety of attendees.
- A legislative body holds a meeting during a proclaimed state of emergency and has determined by majority vote pursuant to b), above, that, as a result of the emergency, meeting in person would present imminent risks to the health or safety of attendees.
AB 361 required a legislative body that chooses to use its provisions to meet the following requirements:
- Notice and Agenda. A legislative body must give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act.
- Public Access. A legislative body must allow members of the public to access the meeting, and the agenda must provide an opportunity for members of the public to address the legislative body directly. The legislative body must give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment. The agenda must identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend via call-in option or an internet-based service option. The legislative body need not provide a physical location from which the public may attend or comment.
- Meeting Disruptions. In the event of a disruption that prevents the agency from broadcasting the meeting to the public using the call-in or internet-based service options, or in the event of a disruption within the local agency’s control that prevents the public from offering public comments using the call-in or internet-based service options, the legislative body must take no further action until public access is restored. Actions taken on agenda items during a disruption may be challenged as provided in the Brown Act.
- Public Comment. The legislative body may not require public comments to be submitted in advance, and it must provide an opportunity for the public to address the legislative body and offer comment in real time. The legislative body may use an online third-party system for individuals to provide public comment that requires registration with the system before providing comment. If a legislative body provides a timed public comment period, it may not close the comment period or the time to register until the timed period has elapsed. If the legislative body does not provide a time-limited comment period, it must allow a reasonable time for the public to comment on each agenda item and to register as necessary.
If a state of emergency remains active, or state or local officials have imposed measures to promote social distancing, the legislative body must make specified findings every 30 days in order to continue using the exemptions provided by AB 361. As an urgency measure, AB 361 went into effect on September 16, 2021. It remains in effect until January 1, 2024.
- AB 2449 of 2022. Responding to calls from local governments to provide even further flexibility to use teleconferencing, AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 285, Statutes of 2022, again relieved a legislative body of a local agency from the requirements of GOV § 54953(b)(3) while teleconferencing, but this time outside of a declared state of emergency. However, in order to enjoy this flexibility, AB 2449 requires at least a quorum of the legislative body to participate in person from a singular physical location. This location must be:
- Clearly identified on the agenda.
- Open to the public.
- Situated within the boundaries of the local agency’s jurisdiction.
The legislative body must provide one of the following so that the public can hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the legislative body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
- A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
The legislative body must give notice of the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment, and the agenda must allow all persons to attend and address the legislative body directly via a call-in option, an internet-based service option, and at the in-person location of the meeting. AB 2449 contained identical provisions as AB 361 concerning meeting disruptions and public comment.
AB 2449 allows members of a legislative body to use these alternative teleconferencing rules in two distinct situations: for “just cause” and for emergency circumstances.
- Just Cause. Under the “just cause” circumstance, a member must notify the legislative body as early as possible of their need to participate remotely for just cause. A just cause circumstance cannot be used by any member of the legislative body for more than two meetings per calendar year. “Just cause” means any of the following:
- Childcare or a caregiving need that requires them to participate remotely.
- A contagious illness that prevents a member from attending in person.
- A need related to a physical or mental disability not otherwise accommodated.
- Travel while on official business of the legislative body or another state or local agency.
- Emergency Circumstances. Under emergency circumstances, a member requests the legislative body to allow them to participate in the meeting remotely due to emergency circumstances and the legislative body takes action to approve the request. “Emergency circumstances” means a physical or family medical emergency that prevents a member from attending in person. The legislative body must request a general description of the emergency circumstances, which shall not require the member to disclose any medical diagnosis or disability or any personal medical information. For the purposes of emergency circumstances, the following requirements apply:
- A member shall make a request to participate remotely as soon as possible, and shall make a separate request for each meeting in which they seek to participate remotely.
- The legislative body may take action on a request to participate remotely at the earliest opportunity. If the request does not allow sufficient time to place proposed action on such a request on the agenda for the meeting for which the request is made, the legislative body may take action at the beginning of the meeting, in accordance with specified provisions of the Brown Act.
- The member who is participating remotely must publicly disclose at the meeting before any action is taken whether any other individuals 18 years of age or older are present in the room at the remote location with the member, and the general nature of the member’s relationship with any such individuals.
- The member must participate through both audio and visual technology.
- Just Cause. Under the “just cause” circumstance, a member must notify the legislative body as early as possible of their need to participate remotely for just cause. A just cause circumstance cannot be used by any member of the legislative body for more than two meetings per calendar year. “Just cause” means any of the following:
AB 2449 specified that its provisions shall not serve as a means for any member of a legislative body to participate in meetings of the legislative body solely by teleconference from a remote location for a period of more than three consecutive months or 20% of the regular meetings for the local agency within a calendar year, or more than two meetings if the legislative body regularly meets fewer than 10 times per calendar year.
AB 2449 remains in effect until January 1, 2026.
- Bill Summary. This bill creates a new definition – a “subsidiary body” – for the purposes of the Brown Act’s teleconferencing requirements and allows a subsidiary body to use teleconferencing without complying with the four rules of GOV § 54953(b)(3), which include the following:
- Posting agendas at each teleconference location.
- Identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda for the meeting or proceeding.
- Making each teleconference location accessible to the public.
- Requiring at least a quorum of the members of the subsidiary body to participate from locations within the boundaries of the territory over which the local agency exercises jurisdiction.
The bill defines “subsidiary body” to mean a legislative body that meets all of the following:
- Is a commission, committee, board, or other body of a local agency, whether permanent or temporary, created by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body? Advisory committees, composed solely of the members of the legislative body that are less than a quorum of the legislative body are not legislative bodies. However, standing committees of a legislative body, irrespective of their composition, which have a continuing subject matter jurisdiction, or a meeting schedule fixed by charter, ordinance, resolution, or formal action of a legislative body are legislative bodies.
- Serves exclusively in an advisory capacity.
- Is not authorized to take final action on legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or any other entitlements.
In order to use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, a subsidiary body to must comply with a number of requirements, including:
- Audio and Visual Technology. Each member of the subsidiary body must participate through both audio and visual technology.
- Public Access. The subsidiary body must provide at least one of the following as a means by which the public may remotely hear and visually observe the meeting, and remotely address the subsidiary body:
- A two-way audiovisual platform.
ii) A two-way telephonic service and a live webcasting of the meeting.
- Notice and Agendas. The subsidiary body shall give notice of the meeting and post agendas as otherwise required by the Brown Act, including information regarding the means by which members of the public may access the meeting and offer public comment. The agenda must identify and include an opportunity for all persons to attend and address the subsidiary body directly via a call-in option or an internet-based service option.
This bill contains identical provisions as AB 361 and AB 2449 concerning meeting disruptions and additional public comment requirements.
Before a subsidiary body can use teleconferencing pursuant to this bill, and every 12 months thereafter, the legislative body that established the subsidiary body must make the following findings:
- The legislative body has considered the circumstances of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would enhance public access to meetings of the subsidiary body.
- Teleconference meetings of the subsidiary body would promote the attraction, retention, and diversity of subsidiary body members.
This bill is sponsored by the California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts, the League of California Cities, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representative of California, and California State Association of Counties.
- Policy Considerations. The Committee may wish to consider the following:
- Sunset Provision. When the Legislature approved AB 361 and AB 2449, both measures contained sunset provisions. AB 361 contains a sunset date of January 1, 2024. AB 2449 contains a sunset date of January 1, 2026. This bill contains no sunset date. The Committee may wish to consider if it wishes to ensure the automatic legislative review of the provisions of this bill that a sunset date would provide.
- Protecting Public Access and Participation. AB 2449 provided local governing board members with enhanced flexibility for teleconferencing while maintaining some of the protections for public access and participation, by requiring the following:
- At least a quorum of the legislative body must participate in person.
- In-person participation must be from a singular physical location.
- The singular physical location must be:
- Clearly identified on the agenda.
- Open to the public.
- Situated within the boundaries of the local agency’s jurisdiction.
- The singular physical location must be:
The Committee may wish to consider if these protections for the public should be added to this bill.
- Compensated Members. The Committee may wish to consider if a member of a subsidiary body should enjoy the flexibility to teleconference that this bill provides if that person is receiving compensation for serving on the subsidiary body. According to the author’s office, members of a subsidiary body are not compensated for their service on a subsidiary body. Nonetheless, the Committee may wish to consider if language should be added to this bill to ensure that paid members attend meetings in person.
- Committee Amendments. To address the policy considerations above, the Committee may wish to amend this bill as follows:
- Add a sunset date of January 1, 2026.
- Require a quorum of members of the subsidiary body to participate from a single, physical location within the jurisdiction of the subsidiary body’s local agency that is accessible to the public. To meet this quorum requirement, a person with a disability that requires accommodation pursuant to the Americans with Disabilities Act may count towards the quorum, whether that person participates in-person or via teleconference.
- Require any person who receives compensation for their service on the subsidiary body (other than reimbursement for actual and necessary expenses) to participate in person.
- Related Legislation. AB 557 (Hart) eliminates the January 1, 2024, sunset date on AB 361 and changes the requirement for a legislative body, in order to continue using the bill’s teleconferencing provisions, to make specified findings every 30 days to every 45 days. This bill is pending in this Committee.
AB 1275 (Arambula) authorizes the recognized statewide community college student organization and other student-run community college organizations to use teleconferencing for their meetings without having to post agendas at all teleconferencing locations, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, make each teleconference location accessible to the public, and require a quorum of the student organization’s members participate from a singular physical location. This bill is pending in this Committee.
AB 1379 (Papan) eliminates the Brown Act’s teleconferencing requirements to post agendas at all teleconferencing locations, identify each teleconference location in the notice and agenda, make each teleconference location accessible to the public, and require a quorum of the legislative body to participate from locations within the local agency’s jurisdiction, allows legislative bodies to participate remotely from any location for all but two meetings per year, and makes several changes to the provisions of AB 2449. AB 1379 is pending in this Committee.
SB 411 (Portantino) allows appointed bodies of a local agency to teleconference meetings without having to notice and make publicly accessible each teleconference location, or have at least a quorum participate from locations within the boundaries of the agency. SB 411 is pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 537 (Becker) allows appointed bodies of a multijurisdictional local agency to teleconference meetings without having to notice and make publicly accessible each teleconference location, or have at least a quorum participate from locations within the boundaries of the agency. SB 537 is pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Previous Legislation. AB 1944 (Lee) would have allowed, until January 1, 2030, members of a legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing without identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting, and without making each teleconference location accessible to the public, under specified conditions. AB 1944 was held in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
AB 2449 (Blanca Rubio), Chapter 285, Statutes of 2022, allows, until January 1, 2026, members of a legislative body of a local agency to use teleconferencing without identifying each teleconference location in the notice and agenda of the meeting, and without making each teleconference location accessible to the public, under specified conditions.
SB 1100 (Cortese), Chapter 171, Statutes of 2022, allows the presiding member of a local legislative body to remove an individual for disrupting a local agency’s meeting, defines “disrupting” for this purpose, and outlines the procedure that must be followed before an individual may be removed.
AB 339 (Lee) of 2021 would have required, until December 31, 2023, city councils and boards of supervisors in jurisdictions over 250,000 residents provide both in-person and teleconference options for the public to attend their meetings. This bill was vetoed with the following message:
“While I appreciate the author's intent to increase transparency and public participation in certain local government meetings, this bill would set a precedent of tying public access requirements to the population of jurisdictions. This patchwork approach may lead to public confusion. Further, AB 339 limits flexibility and increases costs for the affected local jurisdictions trying to manage their meetings.
“Additionally, this bill requires in-person participation during a declared state of emergency unless there is a law prohibiting in-person meetings in those situations. This could put the health and safety of the public and employees at risk depending on the nature of the declared emergency.
“I recently signed urgency legislation that provides the authority and procedures for local entities to meet remotely during a declared state of emergency. I remain open to revisions to the Brown Act to modernize and increase public access, while protecting public health and safety. Unfortunately, the approach in this bill may have unintended consequences.”
AB 361 (Robert Rivas) Chapter 165, Statutes of 2021, allows, until January 1, 2024, local agencies to use teleconferencing without complying with specified Ralph. M Brown Act restrictions in certain state emergencies, and provides similar authorizations, until January 31, 2022, for state agencies subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act and legislative bodies subject to the Gloria Romero Open Meetings Act of 2000.
AB 703 (Rubio) of 2021 would have allowed teleconferencing with only a quorum of the members of a local legislative body participating from a singular location that is clearly identified on an agenda, open to the public, and situated within the boundaries of the local agency. AB 703 was held in this Committee.
- Arguments in Support. The California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts, the League of California Cities, Urban Counties of California, the Rural County Representative of California, and the California State Association of Counties, sponsors of this measure, write, “Local governments across the state have faced an ongoing challenge to recruit and retain members of the public on advisory bodies, boards, and commissions. Challenges associated with recruitment have been attributed to participation time commitments; time and location of meetings; physical limitation, conflicts with childcare, and work obligations.
“The COVID-19 global pandemic drove both hyper-awareness and concerns about the spread of infectious diseases, as well as removed barriers to local civic participation by allowing this same remote participation. This enabled individuals who could not otherwise accommodate the time, distance, or mandatory physical participation requirements to engage locally, providing access to leadership opportunities and providing communities with greater diversified input on critical community proposals…
“The in-person requirement to participate in local governance bodies presents a disproportionate challenge for those with physical or economic limitations, including seniors, persons with disability, single parents and/or caretakers, economically marginalized groups, and those who live in rural areas and face prohibitive driving distances. Participation in local advisory bodies and appointed boards and commissions often serves as a pipeline to local elected office and opportunities for state and federal leadership positions.
“AB 817 would help address these issues by providing a narrow exemption under the Ralph M. Brown Act for non-decision-making legislative bodies that do not take final action on any legislation, regulations, contracts, licenses, permits, or other entitlements, so that equity in opportunity to serve locally and representative diversity in leadership can be achieved. For these reasons, we are collectively pleased to support AB 817…”
- Arguments in Opposition. A coalition of opponents, including the California News Publishers Association, ACLU California Action, Californians Aware, the California Broadcasters Association, the First Amendment Coalition, Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association, Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability, National Press Photographers Association, NLGJA: Association of LGBTQ+ Journalists, Radio Television Digital News Association, San Diego Pro Chapter of the Society of Professional Journalists, Society of Professional Journalists, Los Angeles Chapter, Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter, and the Freedom of Information Committee, write, “Last year, lawmakers passed AB 2449, amending the Brown Act to give further flexibility to individual members of local legislative bodies to participate in public meetings remotely when certain requirements are met…Importantly, the bill required the body to maintain a quorum of members in one physical location accessible to the public inside the jurisdiction. Whenever some members might elect to use teleconferencing to participate remotely, the legislation specifies that the public must also have the ability to access and participate through remote technology as well. The bill also contained many other guardrails that were important to this coalition, the sponsors of the bills and the numerous policy committees that invested time considering the bill.
“AB 2449 by Assemblymember Blanca Rubio was the result of careful negotiations by members of the undersigned coalition. After thoughtful conversations, the resulting legislation, in effect now for mere months, rigorously balanced open-government protections with the desire for members of local bodies to have increased flexibility for their own remote participation following the COVID-19 era of virtual meetings. The hard work that was done last year must be given an opportunity to play out before making additional, and in some cases, drastic and permanent changes to the Brown Act….
“AB 817’s rewriting of the Brown Act would fundamentally undermine one of the law’s key protections for public access and participation — the guarantee that the press and public can be physically present in the same room as those sitting on the dais and making decisions. Such physical presence has been a constant hallmark of democratic institutions…For journalists who do the important work of informing their communities, AB 817 would make newsgathering even more challenging. A primary newsgathering tool is being able to approach officials, see how decision-makers engage with the public, and observe how officials interact with one another on the dais. By allowing bodies to meet remotely indefinitely, AB 817 would significantly hamper the ability of reporters and photographers to provide valuable information to their readers, leaving Californians less informed.
“For advocates and other concerned Californians who do community organizing for social change, AB 817 would make this work more challenging. A primary organizing tool of impacted communities is to show up to public meetings in person, face the public officials who are making decisions that affect us all, and at times raise awareness about important public policy among members of the observing press…
“The undersigned organizations advocate for or increase awareness about ways to achieve the goal of greater diversity and equity within government bodies and among the members of the public who attend public meetings. Allowing members to participate remotely and never have to face the public in person is not an effective way to diversify bodies governed by our state’s open-meeting laws. Diversifying our state and local legislative bodies instead requires public officials to commit to robust outreach to potential members, provide stipends for unpaid positions, implement an open and transparent selection and appointment process, and exercise the political will to appoint members from diverse backgrounds and identities to public bodies, among other things.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Recreation and Parks Districts [CO-SPONSOR]
California State Association of Counties [CO-SPONSOR]
League of California Cities [CO-SPONSOR]
Rural County Representatives of California [CO-SPONSOR]
Urban Counties of California [CO-SPONSOR]
AARP
Association of California School Administrators
Association of California Healthcare Districts (ACHD)
Bay Area Air Quality Management District
Bet Tzedek
CA In-home Supportive Services Consumer Alliance
California Air Pollution Control Officers Association
California Association of Councils of Governments
California Association of Public Authorities for Ihss
California Commission on Aging
California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA)
City and County Association of Governments of San Mateo County
City Clerks Association of California
City of Bell
City of Belmont
City of Carlsbad
City of Downey
City of Mountain View
City of Norwalk
City of Redwood City
City of San Marcos
City of Thousand Oaks
City of West Hollywood
City of Winters
City of Woodland
Civicwell (formally the Local Government Commission)
Conejo Recreation and Park District
Contra Costa County
Contra Costa County Advisory Council on Aging
County of Monterey
County of Santa Barbara
County of Santa Cruz
County of Yolo
Democracy Winters
Disability Rights California
Fair Oaks Recreation & Park District
Hand in Hand: the Domestic Employers Network
Homebridge
Justice in Aging
Lake Cuyamaca
Livermore Area Recreation and Park District
Los Angeles County Division, League of California Cities
Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts
Peninsula Traffic Congestion Relief Alliance (COMMUTE.ORG)
Placer Independent Resource Services
Regional Climate Protection Authority
Rim of The World Recreation and Park District
Sacramento Area Council of Governments
San Carlos; City of
San Diego; County of
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
Santa Barbara County Association of Governments
Santa Cruz County Board of Supervisors
Sonoma Clean Power
Sonoma County Transportation Authority
Thousand Oaks; City of
Village Movement California
Yolo County In-home Supportive Services Advisory Committee
Opposition
ACLU California Action
Cal Aware
California Broadcasters Association
California News Publishers Association
First Amendment Coalition
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association (HJTA)
Leadership Council for Justice and Accountability
National Press Photographers Association
Nlgja: Association of Lgbtq+ Journalists
Northern California Society of Professional Journalists
Radio Television Digital News Association
San Diego Pro Chapter of The Society of Professional Journalists
Society of Professional Journalists, Greater Los Angeles Chapter
Society of Professional Journalists, Northern California Chapter
Analysis Prepared by: Angela Mapp / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Local Government
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):