AB 868: Political Reform Act of 1974: digital political advertisements.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-08-14
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Political Reform Act of 1974 provides for the comprehensive regulation of campaign financing and activities. Among other things, the act requires specified disclosures in advertisements regarding the source of the advertisement. Existing law requires an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements to maintain, and make available for online public inspection, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements during the preceding 12 months, as specified. Existing law establishes the Fair Political Practices Commission that enforces the Political Reform Act of 1974.
This bill would enact the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act. The bill would, beginning on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the Fair Political Practices Commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining such reports, require a committee that pays for a digital advertisement, as defined, to appear on an online platform to submit to the commission a copy of the digital advertisement and specified information, including, among other things, the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, information relating to the subject of the advertisement, the name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed, and the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement. The bill would require the information to be submitted to the commission in accordance with existing deadline for the submission of semiannual statements and preelection statements, if the committee spends $1,000 or more during the period covered by the statement. The bill would require the commission to make information submitted pursuant to this act available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format, as specified. The bill would, upon certification of the above system, eliminate the existing requirement for an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements and that receives $50,000 or more from digital advertisement sales during a calendar month to maintain and make accessible for public inspection specified records of advertisements. Instead, the bill would require an online platform to transmit to the commission specified information regarding digital advertisements, and to retain the information for no less than four years for specified purposes.
Existing law makes a knowing or willful violation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 a misdemeanor. By creating new requirements in that act, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
The Political Reform Act of 1974 provides for the comprehensive regulation of campaign financing and activities. Among other things, the act requires specified disclosures in advertisements regarding the source of the advertisement. Existing law requires an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements to maintain, and make available for online public inspection, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements during the preceding 12 months, as specified. Existing law establishes the Fair Political Practices Commission that enforces the Political Reform Act of 1974.
This bill would enact the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act. The bill would, beginning on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the Fair Political Practices Commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining such reports, require a committee that pays for a digital advertisement, as defined, to appear on an online platform to submit to the commission a copy of the digital advertisement and specified information, including, among other things, the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, information relating to the subject of the advertisement, the name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed, and the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement. The bill would require the information to be submitted to the commission in accordance with existing deadline for the submission of semiannual statements and preelection statements. statements, if the committee spends $1,000 or more during the period covered by the statement. The bill would require the commission to make information submitted pursuant to this act available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format, as specified. The bill would, upon certification of the above system, eliminate the existing requirement for an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements and that receives $50,000 or more from digital advertisement sales during a calendar month to maintain and make accessible for public inspection specified records of advertisements. Instead, the bill would require an online platform to transmit to the commission specified information regarding digital advertisements, and to retain the information for no less than four years for specified purposes.
Existing law makes a knowing or willful violation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 a misdemeanor. By creating new requirements in that act, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
The Political Reform Act of 1974 provides for the comprehensive regulation of campaign financing and activities. Among other things, the act requires specified disclosures in advertisements regarding the source of the advertisement. Existing law requires an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements to maintain, and make available for online public inspection, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements during the preceding 12 months, as specified. Existing law establishes the Fair Political Practices Commission that enforces the Political Reform Act of 1974.
This bill would enact the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act. The bill would, beginning on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the Fair Political Practices Commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining such reports, require a committee that pays for a digital advertisement, as defined, to appear on an online platform to submit to the commission a copy of the digital advertisement and specified information, including, among other things, the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, information relating to the subject of the advertisement, the name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed, and the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement. The bill would require the information to be submitted to the commission in accordance with existing deadline for the submission of semiannual statements and preelection statements. The bill would require the commission to make information submitted pursuant to this act available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format, as specified. The bill would, upon certification of the above system, eliminate the existing requirement for an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements and that receives $50,000 or more from digital advertisement sales during a calendar month to maintain and make accessible for public inspection specified records of advertisements.
Existing law makes a knowing or willful violation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 a misdemeanor. By creating new requirements in that act, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
The Political Reform Act of 1974 provides for the comprehensive regulation of campaign financing and activities. Among other things, the act requires specified disclosures in advertisements regarding the source of the advertisement. Existing law requires an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements to maintain, and make available for online public inspection, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements during the preceding 12 months, as specified. Existing law establishes the Fair Political Practices Commission that enforces the Political Reform Act of 1974.
This bill would enact the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act. The bill would, 60 days after the Fair Political Practices Commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining such reports, require a committee that pays for a digital advertisement, as defined, to appear on an online platform to submit to the commission a copy of the digital advertisement and specified information, including, among other things, the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, information relating to the subject of the advertisement, the name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed, and the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement. The bill would require the information to be submitted to the commission in accordance with existing deadline for the submission of semiannual statements and preelection statements. The bill would require the commission to make information submitted pursuant to this act available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format, as specified. The bill would, upon certification of the above system, eliminate the existing requirement for an online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements and that receives $50,000 or more from digital advertisement sales during a calendar month to maintain and make accessible for public inspection specified records of advertisements.
Existing law makes a knowing or willful violation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 a misdemeanor. By creating new requirements in that act, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Political campaigns are increasingly using digital media, such as internet websites and social media, as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and persuading voters to support their campaigns.
(b)Digital campaign advertisements present unique challenges to regulators, such as the Fair Political Practices Commission, who are charged with ensuring that voters receive timely and accurate information about who is responsible for the content of the advertisement and the payments associated with producing and distributing the advertisement.
(c)Because of the impermanent nature of these ads, and because these ads are increasingly appearing in new digital spaces, it can be difficult and sometimes impossible for a voter to track down an ad they saw previously or to find other digital ads associated with a campaign or election.
(d)Although current law requires online platforms to maintain and make available a record of some of the campaign advertisements disseminated on the platform, these current requirements do not capture all digital ads run on those platforms and the different ways in which platforms maintain these records has made it difficult for the public, academics, and others to meaningfully utilize this information.
(e)Digital campaign advertisements are also used as vehicles for misinformation and disinformation, and the nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public, media, researchers, government agencies, and watchdog groups to find these ads, correct false statements, and hold speakers accountable.
(f)Creating a public record of digital campaign advertisements will facilitate transparency of those advertisements for the benefit of the public, journalists, academics, watchdog groups, and other persons seeking to better understand who is trying to influence voters and the outcome of elections.
(g)It is therefore the intent of the Legislature to require the Fair Political Practices Commission to collect and make publicly available copies of, and information about, specified digital political advertisements.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.6 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.6.(a)For purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform for purposes of this article to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(2)(A)Online platform disclosed advertisement means either of the following:
(i)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with Section 84504.1. Individual posts, comments, or other similar communications are not considered online-platform-disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
(ii)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of the following:
(I)A graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to hyperlink to an internet website containing required disclosures, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 84504.3.
(II)Video, audio, or email.
(B)Electronic media advertisements that are not online-platform-disclosed advertisements as defined in subparagraph (A) shall follow disclosure requirements for electronic media advertisements under Section 84504.3.
(b)A committee that disseminates an online-platform-disclosed advertisement or a digital advertisement as defined in Section 84551 shall do all of the following:
(1)Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platforms chosen notification method, that the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501.
(2)(A)Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee.
(B)For purposes of this section, disclosure name means the text required by Section 84503, followed by a colon, followed by, surrounded in quotation marks, the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211. If no disclosure text is required by Section 84503, disclosure name means the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211.
(C)If the disclosure name changes due to a change in the top contributors or the name of the committee, the committee shall provide the online platform with an updated disclosure name within five business days.
(3)Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(4)Provide the online platform with the name of the committee that paid for the advertisement and identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101.
(c)An online platform that disseminates a committees online platform disclosed advertisement shall do one of the following:
(1)Display Paid for by or Ad Paid for by followed by the disclosure name provided by the committee, easily readable to the average viewer, located adjacent to any text stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored. The online platform may display only 100 or more characters of the disclosure name if it is followed by a ... that is clearly clickable and that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(2)The online platform may instead display a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab with the text Who funded this ad?, Paid for by, or Ad Paid for by that is clearly clickable in the same or similar font and in at least the same font size as the online platforms text, and easily readable to the average viewer, stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored, that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(3)Hyperlinks, icons, buttons, or tabs used for the purposes described in paragraphs (1) and (2) shall be linked to the profile or landing page of the committee that paid for the advertisement; to another page to which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee containing the disclosure name in a manner that is easily seen and readable by the average viewer; or to an internet website containing the disclosure required by subdivision (d) of Section 84504.3.
(d)(1)An online platform that disseminates committees online-platform-disclosed advertisements shall do both of the following:
(A)Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain all of the following:
(i)A digital copy of the advertisement.
(ii)The approximate number of views generated from the advertisement and the date and time that the advertisement was first displayed and last displayed.
(iii)Information regarding the range charged or the total amount spent on the advertisement.
(iv)The name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(v)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement, and the identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(B)(i)Display a prominent button, icon, tab, or hyperlink with the text View Ads or similar text in one of the following locations: (I) near the top of a profile, landing page, or similar location of a committee that paid for an advertisement in a position that the average viewer will readily see it upon viewing that page; (II) on a page that displays the committees profile information or biographical information; (III) or on a page on which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee.
(ii)The button, icon, tab, or hyperlink shall link to a page clearly showing all of the advertisement records required by subparagraph (A).
(2)(A)The information required by paragraph (1) shall be made available as soon as practicable and shall be retained by the online platform for no less than four years.
(B)Paragraph (1) shall become inoperative on the date that Section 84553 becomes operative, after which time the online platform shall retain the information described in this section for no less than four years or transfer the information to the commission in a form and manner prescribed by the commission.
(3)Beginning on the date that Section 84553 becomes operative, an online platform that disseminates a committees online-platform-disclosed advertisements shall meet all of the following requirements:
(A)Transmit to the commission a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain all of the following:
(i)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(ii)The disclosure name as provided by the committee and the identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(iii)One Either of the following, as applicable:
(I)The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
(II)The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
(III)(iv)The name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
(IV)(v)The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
(V)(vi)The date or date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
(VI)(vii)A copy of the advertisement.
(VII)(viii)The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
(B)An online platform shall retain records of the information required to be sent to the commission pursuant to this subdivision for no less than four years for audit and other legal purposes.
(e)An online platform that creates a mechanism for a committee requesting dissemination of an online-platform-disclosed advertisement to expressly notify the online platform whether the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501 and to provide all information necessary for the online platform to comply with the requirements of this section may rely in good faith on the information provided by the committee to the online platform to satisfy the online platforms obligations under subdivisions (c) and (d).
SEC. 3.Article 6 (commencing with Section 84550) is added to Chapter 4 of Title 9 of the Government Code, to read:6.Public Record of Digital Campaign Advertisements84550.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act.
84551.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Digital advertisement means a paid advertisement, as defined in Section 84501, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, web application, or connected television platform.
(b)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, digital application, or connected television platform, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Online platform does not include a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
84552.(a)This article applies to digital advertisements supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective state office or a state ballot measure or ballot measures.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to expand this article with future legislative action to include other kinds of advertisements or communications, including, but not limited to, advertisements for local candidates and measures and nondigital advertisements.
84553.(a)A committee that pays for a digital advertisement that is not an online-platform-disclosed advertisement as defined in Section 85404.6 shall submit to the commission, in a format specified by the commission, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)The identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(3)One of the following, as applicable:
(A)The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
(B)The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
(4)The name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
(5)The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
(6)The date or date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
(7)A copy of the digital advertisement.
(8)The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
(b)A committee shall submit the information specified in subdivision (a) in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements pursuant to Section 84200 and preelection statements pursuant to Section 84200.8. A committee shall submit the information specified in subdivision (a) if the committee spends one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more on digital advertisements during the period covered by the statement.
(c)A committee may contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information required by subdivision (a) to the commission on behalf of the committee.
(d)This section shall become operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted in accordance with this section as required pursuant to Section 84554.
84554.(a)The commission shall make the information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format.
(b)The commission shall maintain information for a digital advertisement as required pursuant to subdivision (a) for no less than 12 years from the date that information was first submitted to the commission.
(c)The information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 shall be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Search and filter parameter categories shall include, but are not limited to, committee payor payer name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
84555.If a committee submits the information specified in subdivision (a) of Section 84553 after the prescribed deadline, the committee shall be liable in the amount of ten dollars ($10) per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. This penalty shall apply in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by this chapter, but shall be the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a violation of this article that is unintentional, including an inadvertent or negligent violation.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Political campaigns are increasingly using digital media, such as internet websites and social media, as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and persuading voters to support their campaigns.
(b)Digital campaign advertisements present unique challenges to regulators, such as the Fair Political Practices Commission, who are charged with ensuring that voters receive timely and accurate information about who is responsible for the content of the advertisement and the payments associated with producing and distributing the advertisement.
(c)Because of the impermanent nature of these ads, and because these ads are increasingly appearing in new digital spaces, it can be difficult and sometimes impossible for a voter to track down an ad they saw previously or to find other digital ads associated with a campaign or election.
(d)Although current law requires online platforms to maintain and make available a record of some of the campaign advertisements disseminated on the platform, these current requirements do not capture all digital ads run on those platforms and the different ways in which platforms maintain these records has made it difficult for the public, academics, and others to meaningfully utilize this information.
(e)Digital campaign advertisements are also used as vehicles for misinformation and disinformation, and the nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public, media, researchers, government agencies, and watchdog groups to find these ads, correct false statements, and hold speakers accountable.
(f)Creating a public record of digital campaign advertisements will facilitate transparency of those advertisements for the benefit of the public, journalists, academics, watchdog groups, and other persons seeking to better understand who is trying to influence voters and the outcome of elections.
(g)It is therefore the intent of the Legislature to require the Fair Political Practices Commission to collect and make publicly available copies of, and information about, specified digital political advertisements.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.6 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.6.(a)For purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform for purposes of this article to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(2)(A)Online platform disclosed advertisement means either of the following:
(i)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with Section 84504.1. Individual posts, comments, or other similar communications are not considered online-platform-disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
(ii)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of the following:
(I)A graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to hyperlink to an internet website containing required disclosures, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 84504.3.
(II)Video, audio, or email.
(B)Electronic media advertisements that are not online-platform-disclosed advertisements as defined in subparagraph (A) shall follow disclosure requirements for electronic media advertisements under Section 84504.3.
(b)A committee that disseminates an online-platform-disclosed advertisement or a digital advertisement as defined in Section 84551 shall do all of the following:
(1)Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platforms chosen notification method, that the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501.
(2)(A)Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee.
(B)For purposes of this section, disclosure name means the text required by Section 84503, followed by a colon, followed by, surrounded in quotation marks, the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211. If no disclosure text is required by Section 84503, disclosure name means the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211.
(C)If the disclosure name changes due to a change in the top contributors or the name of the committee, the committee shall provide the online platform with an updated disclosure name within five business days.
(3)Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(4)Provide the online platform with the name of the committee that paid for the advertisement and identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101.
(c)An online platform that disseminates a committees online platform disclosed advertisement shall do one of the following:
(1)Display Paid for by or Ad Paid for by followed by the disclosure name provided by the committee, easily readable to the average viewer, located adjacent to any text stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored. The online platform may display only 100 or more characters of the disclosure name if it is followed by a ... that is clearly clickable and that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(2)The online platform may instead display a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab with the text Who funded this ad?, Paid for by, or Ad Paid for by that is clearly clickable in the same or similar font and in at least the same font size as the online platforms text, and easily readable to the average viewer, stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored, that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(3)Hyperlinks, icons, buttons, or tabs used for the purposes described in paragraphs (1) and (2) shall be linked to the profile or landing page of the committee that paid for the advertisement; to another page to which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee containing the disclosure name in a manner that is easily seen and readable by the average viewer; or to an internet website containing the disclosure required by subdivision (d) of Section 84504.3.
(d)(1)An online platform that disseminates committees online-platform-disclosed advertisements shall meet all do both of the following requirements: following:
(A)Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain all of the following:
(i)A digital copy of the advertisement.
(ii)The approximate number of views generated from the advertisement and the date and time that the advertisement was first displayed and last displayed.
(iii)Information regarding the range charged or the total amount spent on the advertisement.
(iv)The name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(v)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement, and the identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(B)The information required under this subdivision shall be made available as soon as practicable and shall be retained by the online platform for no less than four years. (C)(B)(i)Display a prominent button, icon, tab, or hyperlink with the text View Ads or similar text in one of the following locations: (I) near the top of a profile, landing page, or similar location of a committee that paid for an advertisement in a position that the average viewer will readily see it upon viewing that page; (II) on a page that displays the committees profile information or biographical information; (III) or on a page on which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee.
(ii)The button, icon, tab, or hyperlink shall link to a page clearly showing all of the advertisement records required by subparagraph (A).
(2)(A)The information required by paragraph (1) shall be made available as soon as practicable and shall be retained by the online platform for no less than four years.
(2)(B)This section Paragraph (1) shall become inoperative on the date that Section 84533 84553 becomes operative, after which time the online platform shall retain the information described in this section for no less than four years or transfer the information to the commission in a form and manner prescribed by the commission.
(3)Beginning on the date that Section 84553 becomes operative, an online platform that disseminates a committees online-platform-disclosed advertisements shall meet all of the following requirements:
(A)Transmit to the commission a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain all of the following:
(i)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(ii)The disclosure name as provided by the committee and the identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(iii)One of the following, as applicable:
(I)The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
(II)The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
(III)The name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
(IV)The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
(V)The date or date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
(VI)A copy of the advertisement.
(VII)The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
(B)An online platform shall retain records of the information required to be sent to the commission pursuant to this subdivision for no less than four years for audit and other legal purposes.
(e)An online platform that creates a mechanism for a committee requesting dissemination of an online-platform-disclosed advertisement to expressly notify the online platform whether the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501 and to provide all information necessary for the online platform to comply with the requirements of this section may rely in good faith on the information provided by the committee to the online platform to satisfy the online platforms obligations under subdivisions (c) and (d).
SEC. 3.Article 6 (commencing with Section 84550) is added to Chapter 4 of Title 9 of the Government Code, to read:6.Public Record of Digital Campaign Advertisements84550.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act.
84551.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Digital advertisement means a paid advertisement, as defined in Section 84501, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, or web application. application, or connected television platform.
(b)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, application, or connected television platform, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Online platform does not include the following: a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(1)A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.(2)The internet website, web application, or digital application of a newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest.84552.(a)This article applies to digital advertisements supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective state office or a state ballot measure or ballot measures.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to expand this article with future legislative action to include other kinds of advertisements or communications, including, but not limited to, advertisements for local candidates and measures and nondigital advertisements.
84553.(a)A committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform that is not an online-platform-disclosed advertisement as defined in Section 85404.6 shall submit to the commission, in a format specified by the commission, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)The identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(3)One of the following, as applicable:
(A)The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
(B)The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
(4)The name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
(5)The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
(6)The date or date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
(7)A copy of the digital advertisement.
(8)The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
(b)A committee shall submit the information specified in subdivision (a) in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements pursuant to Section 84200 and preelection statements pursuant to Section 84200.8. A committee shall submit the information specified in subdivision (a) if the committee spends one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more on digital advertisements during the period covered by the statement.
(c)A committee may contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information required by subdivision (a) to the commission on behalf of the committee.
(d)This section shall become operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted in accordance with this section as required pursuant to Section 84554.
84554.(a)The commission shall make the information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format.
(b)The commission shall maintain information for a digital advertisement as required pursuant to subdivision (a) for no less than 12 years from the date that information was first submitted to the commission.
(c)The information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 shall be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Search and filter parameter categories shall include, but are not limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
84555.If a committee submits the information specified in subdivision (a) of Section 84553 after the prescribed deadline, the committee shall be liable in the amount of ten dollars ($10) per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. This penalty shall apply in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by this chapter, but shall be the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a violation of this article that is unintentional, including an inadvertent or negligent violation.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Political campaigns are increasingly using digital media, such as internet websites and social media, as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and persuading voters to support their campaigns.
(b)Digital campaign advertisements present unique challenges to regulators, such as the Fair Political Practices Commission, who are charged with ensuring that voters receive timely and accurate information about who is responsible for the content of the advertisement and the payments associated with producing and distributing the advertisement.
(c)Because of the impermanent nature of these ads, and because these ads are increasingly appearing in new digital spaces, it can be difficult and sometimes impossible for a voter to track down an ad they saw previously or to find other digital ads associated with a campaign or election.
(d)Although current law requires online platforms to maintain and make available a record of some of the campaign advertisements disseminated on the platform, these current requirements do not capture all digital ads run on those platforms and the different ways in which platforms maintain these records has made it difficult for the public, academics, and others to meaningfully utilize this information.
(e)Digital campaign advertisements are also used as vehicles for misinformation and disinformation, and the nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public, media, researchers, government agencies, and watchdog groups to find these ads, correct false statements, and hold speakers accountable.
(f)Creating a public record of digital campaign advertisements will facilitate transparency of those advertisements for the benefit of the public, journalists, academics, watchdog groups, and other persons seeking to better understand who is trying to influence voters and the outcome of elections.
(g)It is therefore the intent of the Legislature to require the Fair Political Practices Commission to collect and make publicly available copies of, and information about, specified digital political advertisements.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.6 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.6.(a)For purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform for purposes of this article to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(2)(A)Online platform disclosed advertisement means either of the following:
(i)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with Section 84504.1. Individual posts, comments, or other similar communications are not considered online platform disclosed online-platform-disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
(ii)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of the following:
(I)A graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to hyperlink to an internet website containing required disclosures, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 84504.3.
(II)Video, audio, or email.
(B)Electronic media advertisements that are not online platform disclosed online-platform-disclosed advertisements as defined in subparagraph (A) shall follow disclosure requirements for electronic media advertisements under Section 84504.3.
(b)A committee that disseminates an online platform disclosed online-platform-disclosed advertisement or a digital advertisement as defined in Section 84551 shall do all of the following:
(1)Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platforms chosen notification method, that the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501.
(2)(A)Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee.
(B)For purposes of this section, disclosure name means the text required by Section 84503, followed by a colon, followed by, surrounded in quotation marks, the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211. If no disclosure text is required by Section 84503, disclosure name means the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211.
(C)If the disclosure name changes due to a change in the top contributors or the name of the committee, the committee shall provide the online platform with an updated disclosure name within five business days.
(3)Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(4)Provide the online platform with the name of the committee that paid for the advertisement and identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101.
(c)An online platform that disseminates a committees online platform disclosed advertisement shall do one of the following:
(1)Display Paid for by or Ad Paid for by followed by the disclosure name provided by the committee, easily readable to the average viewer, located adjacent to any text stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored. The online platform may display only 100 or more characters of the disclosure name if it is followed by a ... that is clearly clickable and that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(2)The online platform may instead display a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab with the text Who funded this ad?, Paid for by, or Ad Paid for by that is clearly clickable in the same or similar font and in at least the same font size as the online platforms text, and easily readable to the average viewer, stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored, that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(3)Hyperlinks, icons, buttons, or tabs used for the purposes described in paragraphs (1) and (2) shall be linked to the profile or landing page of the committee that paid for the advertisement; to another page to which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee containing the disclosure name in a manner that is easily seen and readable by the average viewer; or to an internet website containing the disclosure required by subdivision (d) of Section 84504.3.
(d)(1)An online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed online-platform-disclosed advertisements shall meet all of the following requirements:
(A)Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain all of the following:
(i)A digital copy of the advertisement.
(ii)The approximate number of views generated from the advertisement and the date and time that the advertisement was first displayed and last displayed.
(iii)Information regarding the range charged or the total amount spent on the advertisement.
(iv)The name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(v)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement, and the identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(B)The information required under this subdivision shall be made available as soon as practicable and shall be retained by the online platform for no less than four years.
(C)(i)Display a prominent button, icon, tab, or hyperlink with the text View Ads or similar text in one of the following locations: (I) near the top of a profile, landing page, or similar location of a committee that paid for an advertisement in a position that the average viewer will readily see it upon viewing that page; (II) on a page that displays the committees profile information or biographical information; (III) or on a page on which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee.
(ii)The button, icon, tab, or hyperlink shall link to a page clearly showing all of the advertisement records required by subparagraph (A).
(2)This section shall become inoperative on the date that Section 84533 becomes operative, after which time the online platform shall retain the information described in this section for no less than four years or transfer the information to the commission in a form and manner prescribed by the commission.
(e)An online platform that creates a mechanism for a committee requesting dissemination of an online platform disclosed online-platform-disclosed advertisement to expressly notify the online platform whether the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501 and to provide all information necessary for the online platform to comply with the requirements of this section may rely in good faith on the information provided by the committee to the online platform to satisfy the online platforms obligations under subdivisions (c) and (d).
SEC. 3.Article 6 (commencing with Section 84550) is added to Chapter 4 of Title 9 of the Government Code, to read:6.Public Record of Digital Campaign Advertisements84550.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act.
84551.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Digital advertisement means a paid advertisement, as defined in Section 84501, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, or web application.
(b)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Online platform does not include the following:
(1)A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(2)The internet website, web application, or digital application of a newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest.
84552.(a)This article applies to digital advertisements supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective state office or a state ballot measure or ballot measures.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to expand this article with future legislative action to include other kinds of advertisements or communications, including, but not limited to, advertisements for local candidates and measures and nondigital advertisements.
84553.(a)A committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform shall submit to the commission, in a format specified by the commission, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)The identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(3)One of the following, as applicable:
(A)The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
(B)The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
(4)The name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
(5)The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
(6)The date or date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
(7)A copy of the digital advertisement.
(8)The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
(b)A committee shall submit the information specified in subdivision (a) in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements pursuant to Section 84200 and preelection statements pursuant to Section 84200.8.
(c)A committee may contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information required by subdivision (a) to the commission on behalf of the committee.
(d)This section shall become operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted in accordance with this section as required pursuant to Section 84554.
84554.(a)The commission shall make the information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format.
(b)The commission shall maintain information for a digital advertisement as required pursuant to subdivision (a) for no less than 12 years from the date that information was first submitted to the commission.
(c)The information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 shall be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Search and filter parameter categories shall include, but are not limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
84555.If a committee submits the information specified in subdivision (a) of Section 84553 after the prescribed deadline, the committee shall be liable in the amount of ten dollars ($10) per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. This penalty shall apply in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by this chapter, but shall be the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation of this article. article that is unintentional, including an inadvertent or negligent violation.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Political campaigns are increasingly using digital media, such as internet websites and social media, as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and persuading voters to support their campaigns.
(b)Digital campaign advertisements present unique challenges to regulators, such as the Fair Political Practices Commission, who are charged with ensuring that voters receive timely and accurate information about who is responsible for the content of the advertisement and the payments associated with producing and distributing the advertisement.
(c)Because of the impermanent nature of these ads, and because these ads are increasingly appearing in new digital spaces, it can be difficult and sometimes impossible for a voter to track down an ad they saw previously or to find other digital ads associated with a campaign or election.
(d)Although current law requires online platforms to maintain and make available a record of some of the campaign advertisements disseminated on the platform, these current requirements do not capture all digital ads run on those platforms and the different ways in which platforms maintain these records has made it difficult for the public, academics, and others to meaningfully utilize this information.
(e)Digital campaign advertisements are also used as vehicles for misinformation and disinformation, and the nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public, media, researchers, government agencies, and watchdog groups to find these ads, correct false statements, and hold speakers accountable.
(f)Creating a public record of digital campaign advertisements will facilitate transparency of those advertisements for the benefit of the public, journalists, academics, watchdog groups, and other persons seeking to better understand who is trying to influence voters and the outcome of elections.
(g)It is therefore the intent of the Legislature to require the Fair Political Practices Commission to collect and make publicly available copies of, and information about, specified digital political advertisements.
SEC. 2.Section 84504.6 of the Government Code is amended to read:84504.6.(a)For purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform for purposes of this article to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(2)(A)Online platform disclosed advertisement means either of the following:
(i)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with Section 84504.1. Individual posts, comments, or other similar communications are not considered online platform disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
(ii)A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of the following:
(I)A graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to hyperlink to an internet website containing required disclosures, as described in subdivision (b) of Section 84504.3.
(II)Video, audio, or email.
(B)Electronic media advertisements that are not online platform disclosed advertisements as defined in subparagraph (A) shall follow disclosure requirements for electronic media advertisements under Section 84504.3.
(b)A committee that disseminates an online platform disclosed advertisement or a digital advertisement as defined in Section 84551 shall do all of the following:
(1)Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platforms chosen notification method, that the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501.
(2)(A)Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee.
(B)For purposes of this section, disclosure name means the text required by Section 84503, followed by a colon, followed by, surrounded in quotation marks, the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent Statement of Organization statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211. If no disclosure text is required by Section 84503, disclosure name means the name of the committee as it appears on the most recent Statement of Organization statement of organization filed pursuant to Section 84101 or the name that the filer is required to use on campaign statements pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 84211.
(C)If the disclosure name changes due to a change in the top contributors or the name of the committee, the committee shall provide the online platform with an updated disclosure name within five business days.
(3)Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(4)Provide the online platform with the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement. advertisement and identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101.
(c)An online platform that disseminates a committees online platform disclosed advertisement shall do one of the following:
(1)Display Paid for by or Ad Paid for by followed by the disclosure name provided by the committee, easily readable to the average viewer, located adjacent to any text stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored. The online platform may display only one hundred 100 or more characters of the disclosure name if it is followed by a ... that is clearly clickable and that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(2)The online platform may instead display a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab with the text Who funded this ad?, Paid for by, or Ad Paid for by that is clearly clickable in the same or similar font and in at least the same font size as the online platforms text, and easily readable to the average viewer, stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored, that links to a page as described in paragraph (3).
(3)Hyperlinks, icons, buttons, or tabs used for the purposes described in paragraphs (1) and (2) shall be linked to the profile or landing page of the committee that paid for the advertisement; to another page to which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee containing the disclosure name in a manner that is easily seen and readable by the average viewer; or to an internet website containing the disclosure required by subdivision (d) of Section 84504.3.
(d)(1)An online platform that disseminates committees online platform disclosed advertisements shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)(A)Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain all of the following:
(A)(i)A digital copy of the advertisement.
(B)(ii)The approximate number of views generated from the advertisement and the date and time that the advertisement was first displayed and last displayed.
(C)(iii)Information regarding the range charged or the total amount spent on the advertisement.
(D)(iv)The name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
(E)(v)The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, and the identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(2)(B)The information required under this subdivision shall be made available as soon as practicable and shall be retained by the online platform for no less than four years.
(3)(A)(C)(i)Display a prominent button, icon, tab, or hyperlink with the text View Ads or similar text in one of the following locations: (i) (I) near the top of a profile, landing page, or similar location of a committee that paid for an advertisement in a position that the average viewer will readily see it upon viewing that page; (ii) (II) on a page that displays the committees profile information or biographical information; (iii) (III) or on a page on which the average viewer would normally navigate to view additional information about a committee.
(B)(ii)The button, icon, tab, or hyperlink shall link to a page clearly showing all of the advertisement records required by paragraph (1). subparagraph (A).
(2)This section shall become inoperative on the date that Section 84533 becomes operative, after which time the online platform shall retain the information described in this section for no less than four years or transfer the information to the commission in a form and manner prescribed by the commission.
(e)An online platform that creates a mechanism for a committee requesting dissemination of an online platform disclosed advertisement to expressly notify the online platform whether the advertisement is an advertisement as defined in Section 84501 and to provide all information necessary for the online platform to comply with the requirements of this section may rely in good faith on the information provided by the committee to the online platform to satisfy the online platforms obligations under subdivisions (c) and (d).
SEC. 3.Article 6 (commencing with Section 84550) is added to Chapter 4 of Title 9 of the Government Code, to read:6.Public Record of Digital Campaign Advertisements84550.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or DATA Act.
84551.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Digital advertisement means a paid advertisement, as defined in Section 84501, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, or web application.
(b)Online platform means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Online platform does not include the following:
(1)A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
(2)The internet website, web application, or digital application of a newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest.
84552.(a)This article applies to digital advertisements supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective state office or a state ballot measure or ballot measures.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to expand this article with future legislative action to include other kinds of advertisements or communications, including, but not limited to, advertisements for local candidates and measures and nondigital advertisements.
84553.(a)A committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform shall submit to the commission, in a format specified by the commission, all of the following information:
(1)The name of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
(2)The identification number assigned to the committee by the Secretary of State pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 84101, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
(3)One of the following, as applicable:
(A)The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
(B)The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
(4)The name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
(5)The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
(6)The date or date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
(7)A copy of the digital advertisement.
(8)The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
(b)A committee shall submit the information specified in subdivision (a) in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements pursuant to Section 84200 and preelection statements pursuant to Section 84200.8.
(c)A committee may contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information required by subdivision (a) to the commission on behalf of the committee.
(d)This section shall become operative 60 days after the commission certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted in accordance with this section as required pursuant to Section 84554.
84554.(a)The commission shall make the information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format.
(b)The commission shall maintain information for a digital advertisement as required pursuant to subdivision (a) for no less than 12 years from the date that information was first submitted to the commission.
(c)The information submitted pursuant to Section 84553 shall be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Search and filter parameter categories shall include, but are not limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
84555.If a committee submits the information specified in subdivision (a) of Section 84553 after the prescribed deadline, the committee shall be liable in the amount of ten dollars ($10) per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. This penalty shall apply in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by this chapter, but shall be the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation of this article.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 21, 2023 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Aug 14, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 2, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 12, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 1.) (July 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 6, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (July 5). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 27, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Jun 19, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on E. & C.A. and JUD. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 58. Noes 17. Page 2071.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (May 18). |
| Apr 26, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 3, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (March 29). |
| Feb 23, 2023 | Referred to Com. on ELECTIONS. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 21, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jul 5, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | AB 868 Wilson Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 29, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Clean Money Campaign | ** Support | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Against | |
| Fair Political Practices Commission | ** Support | |
| League of California Women Voters | ** Support | |
| Northern California Recycling Association | ** Support | |
| Technet | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 868 (Wilson) - Political Reform Act of 1974: digital political advertisements
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 868 would (1) require an online platform, as defined, to submit information and materials relating to political digital advertisements to the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), as specified, and (2) require FPPC to create an online, centralized, and publicly accessible database using the information collected from online platforms, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
FPPC indicates that it would incur first-year General Fund costs of $732,000, and $1.1 million annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill. FPPC would require two additional information technology positions to carry out its workload. Additionally, the bill could result in increased penalty revenue; the magnitude is unknown, but probably minor.
Background:
In 2019, FPPC authorized and established the Digital Transparency Task Force (DTTF) to examine issues surrounding digital political advertising. DTTF recognized that digital political advertising has risen over time with the advancement of social media and other online platforms, and sought to explore how to balance the rise of digital political advertising with transparency needs.
Following a number of meetings, DTTF published a report in late 2021 that included a series of recommendations, one of which was to create a state-run political advertisement archive, which it DTTF saw as assisting in the facilitation of campaign finance enforcement and allowing for more legal oversight of digital advertisements by FPPC. Additionally, the recommendations also specified that the archive collect and make publicly available copies of digital political advertisements.
The Legislature has passed legislation in recent years to improve transparency in connection with political advertising. In particular, recently enacted legislation has sought to make information more accessible to the public about the identity of committees that are responsible for political advertisements, and of the top campaign contributors to those committees. Five years ago, in response to a growth in political advertisements on social media platforms, the Legislature enacted AB 2188 (Mullin, 2018), which requires online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public, among other provisions. In accordance with the provisions of AB 2188, major online platforms that run political advertising (including Google, Meta, and Snap) maintain online political advertising libraries that include digital copies of political advertisements that ran on the platform, along with specified information about when the ad ran, the approximate number of views that the ad received, the amount charged or spent on the ad, the candidate or ballot measure that the ad supported or opposed, and the identity of the political committee that paid for the ad. Although the information available through these political advertising libraries is similar, there are differences in the way that each platform presents the information. Furthermore, there is no centralized library or archive that contains comprehensive information about political advertisements related to California elections that appeared on different online platforms.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Enact the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act (DATA Act) operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after FPPC certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted by political committees.
- Clarify the definition of "online platform" to mean a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Provides that the term "online platform" does not include a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- Add a definition of "online platform disclosed advertisement" as either of the following:
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with Section 84504.1. Individual communications are not considered online-platform-disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of specified types of digital postings, and are considered electronic media advertisements subject to the disclosure requirements of Section 84504.3.
- Upon certification of the above system, eliminate the existing requirement for an online platform that disseminates committees' online platform disclosed advertisements and that receives $50,000 or more from digital advertisement sales during a calendar month to maintain and make accessible for public inspection specified records of advertisements.
- Require, instead, an online platform to transmit to FPPC a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months specified information regarding digital advertisements and to retain the information for no less than four years for specified purposes, as specified.
- Require a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to submit to the commission a copy of the digital advertisement and specified information, including, among other things, the name, disclosure name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, information relating to the subject of the advertisement, the name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed, and the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement
- Require the information to be submitted to FPPC in accordance with existing deadlines for the submission of semiannual statements and preelection statements, if the committee spends $1,000 or more during the period covered by the statement.
- Require FPPC to make information submitted pursuant to this act available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format, as specified, and.to maintain information for a digital advertisement for no less than 12 years from the date that information is first submitted.
- Require the information submitted related to digital advertisements to be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Require search and filter parameter categories to include, but not be limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
- Permit a committee to contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information specified above to the FPPC on behalf of the committee.
- Make a committee that submits the information related to a digital advertisement after the prescribed deadline liable in the amount of $10 per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. Provides that this penalty applies in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by existing law, but provides that the $10 per day penalty is the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation of the provisions of this bill related to the submission of digital advertisements by a committee.
Related Legislation:
- SB 921 (Newman, 2021) would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather than requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. The bill was held under submission on the Suspense File of this Committee.
- AB 2885 (Eduardo Garcia, 2020) would have required an online platform to maintain and make available for online public inspection a description of the audience requested by the committee and the types of personal information used by the platform to target the advertisement, including use of characteristics that are protected classifications under law; and also would have required the online platform’s officers, to personally certify, under penalty of perjury, that to their knowledge the online platform has correctly disclosed all activity under this law. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting.
- AB 864 (Mullin, Chapter 558, Statutes of 2019), among other things, excluded certain online communications from the Act’s campaign advertisement disclosure requirements, including communications opted into by the recipient, added certain requirements for campaign text messages, and added certain definitions to the provisions imposing requirements for advertisements on online platforms.
- AB 2188 (Mullin, Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018) required, among other provisions, online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public.
Staff Comments:
In addition to two new positions, FPPC anticipates that the bill woulld result in new information technology spending, including (1) interacting with the California Department of Technology, and (2) a contract with a vendor to provide the database, including maintenance and support.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 868 (Author:Wilson)
Version: June 27, 2023
Hearing Date: July 11, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Political Reform Act of 1974: digital political advertisements
DIGEST
This bill requires an online platform, as defined, to submit information and materials relating to political digital advertisements to the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), as specified; and requires the FPPC to create an online, centralized, and publicly accessible database using the information collected from online platforms, as specified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The internet has proven to be a powerful tool for political campaigns. Online platforms’ ability to gather information about their users allow campaigns to purchase ads to be displayed to a precisely targeted audience, and to quickly modify ads and campaign messaging based on online feedback. Unfortunately, the fast-paced and targeted nature of online campaign advertising also makes it more difficult to regulate. Current law requires online platforms, as defined, to obtain certain information from the committees purchasing campaign ads for at least four years. According to the FPPC, however, more is needed to ensure that regulators and voters can review digital campaign ads and the statements in them.
This bill, in response to a report from the FPPC’s Digital Transparency Task Force, establishes the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act (DATA). The bill requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform, if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to provide specified information to the FPPC. The FPPC is required to create a public, searchable database for these ads and retain them for at least 12 years. The bill also requires an online platform to submit specified information to the FPPC regarding these digital advertisements, and retain that information for four years, as provided.
The bill is sponsored by the FPPC and supported by League of Women Voters of
California. The bill is opposed by California Chamber of Commerce, the California
Clean Money Campaign, and TechNet. It passed the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee on a vote of 6 to 1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the Political Reform Act of 1974 (the Act), which governs campaign and lobbying activities related to elections. (Gov. Code, tit. 9, §§ 81000 et seq.)
- Establishes the Fair Political Practices Commission (the FPPC), comprised of three members, no more than three of which may be members of the same political party, to impartially and effectively implement and administer the Act. (Gov. Code, tit. 9, ch. 3, §§ 83100 et seq.)
- Establishes, as part of the Act, requirements relating to campaign advertisements and the disclosures that must be made on or along with those advertisements, including advertisements online. (Gov. Code, tit. 9, ch. 4, §§ 84100 et seq.)
- Provides the following relevant definitions for purposes of the Act:
- An “advertisement” is any general or public communication that is authorized and paid for by a committee for the purpose of supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective office or a ballot measure or ballot measures. An advertisement does not include:
- A communication from an organization, other than a political party, to its members.
- An email communication, text message, or other electronic text message from an organization to persons who have opted in or asked to receive messages from the organization.
- Any communication solicited by the recipient.
- Campaign buttons, bumper stickers, or other promotional items within certain specified parameters.
- Wearing apparel.
- Skywriting.
- Any other type of communication excluded by regulation by the FPPC. (Gov. Code, § 84501(a).)
- A “committee” is any person or combination of persons who directly or indirectly receive or contributions or make expenditures of specified amounts to, or at the behest of, a candidate or committee. (Gov. Code, § 82013.)
- A “person” is an individual, proprietorship, firm, partnership, joint venture, syndicate, business trust, company, corporation, limited liability company, association, committee, and any other organization or group of persons acting in concert. (Gov. Code, § 82047.)
- An “online platform” is a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform for purposes of this article to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform. (Gov. Code, § 84504.6(a)(1).)
- An “online platform disclosed advertisement” is either of the following:
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements are video that comply with separate video disclosure requirements (see Gov. Code, § 84504.1); but individual posts, comments, or similar communications are not online platform disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
- A paid electronic media advertisement that is not an image or graphic with a hyperlink to a website with otherwise-required disclosures, video, audio, or email. (Gov. Code, § 84504.6(a)(2)(A).)
- An “advertisement” is any general or public communication that is authorized and paid for by a committee for the purpose of supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective office or a ballot measure or ballot measures. An advertisement does not include:
- Requires a committee that disseminates an online platform disclosed advertisement to do all of the following:
- Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platform’s chosen notification method, that the advertisement is one governed by the Act.
- Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee, as defined.
- Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
- Provide the online platform with the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement. (Gov. Code, § 84504.6(b).)
- Requires an online platform that disseminates a committee’s online platform disclosed advertisement to do one of the following:
- Display a “Paid for by” or “Ad Paid for by” followed by the disclosure name provided by the committee, easily readable to the average viewer, located adjacent to any text stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored. The online platform may display only one hundred or more characters of the disclosure name if it is followed by an ellipsis that is clearly clickable and that links to a page as described in 6)(c), below.
- Display a hyperlink, icon, button, or tab with the text “Who funded this ad?,” “Paid for by,” or “Ad Paid for by” that is clearly clickable in the same or similar font and in at least the same font size as the online platform’s text, and easily readable to the average viewer, stating that the advertisement is an advertisement or is promoted or sponsored, that links to a page as described in 6)(c), below.
- Hyperlinks, icons, buttons, or tabs used for the purposes described in 6)(a) or (b) above must be linked to the profile or landing page of the committee that paid for the advertisement, to another page to which the average viewer would normally navigate to learn about a committee containing the disclosure name in an easily seen location, or to an internet website containing specified disclosures. (Gov. Code, § 84504.6(c).)
- Requires an online platform that disseminates a committee’s online platform disclosed advertisement to meet all of the following requirements:
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Each record shall contain a digital copy of the advertisement, the approximate number of views, the date and time range during which it was displayed, information relating to the rate charged or total amount spent on the advertisement, the name of the candidate and the office sought or the ballot measure and jurisdiction to which the advertisement relates, and the name and identification number of the committee.
- Make the information available as soon as practicable and retain it for at least four years.
- Display a prominent button, icon, tab, or hyperlink with the text “View Ads” or similar text in either (i) the top of a profile, landing page, or similar location of a committee that paid for an advertisement in a position that the average viewer will readily see upon viewing the page, (ii) on a page that displays the committee’s profile information or biographical information, or (iii) on a page on which the average viewer would normally navigate to view any additional information about a committee. The button, icon, tab, or hyperlink shall link to a page clearly showing all of the advertisement records that the online platform must maintain under 7)(a). (Gov. Code, § 84504.6(d).)
- Provides that an online platform that creates a mechanism for a committee requesting dissemination of an online platform disclosed advertisement to expressly notify the online platform whether the advertisement is an advertisement under the Act and to provide all information necessary for the online platform to comply with the online platform disclosure requirements may rely in good faith on the information provided by the committee to the online platform to satisfy its disclosure and record obligations. (Gov. Code, § 84504.6(e).)
This bill:
- Makes legislative findings relating to campaigns’ increasingly frequent use of digital media as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and the unique challenges associated with regulating online advertisements, and declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to require the FPPC to collect and make publicly available copies of, and information about, specified digital political advertisements.
- Establishes the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act, or the DATA Act.
- Provides the following definitions:
- “Archive” means the centralized collection of information maintained pursuant to 7), below.
- “Digital advertisement” means a paid advertisement, as defined above in 4)(a), that appears in a digital format, including, but not limited to, on an internet website, digital application, web application, or connected television platform.
- “Online platform” means a public-facing internet website, web application, digital application, or connected television platform, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. AN online platform does not include a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- Provides that the DATA Act applies to digital advertisements supporting or opposing a candidate or candidates for elective office or a state ballot measure or measures, and that it is the intent of the Legislature that the archive may be expanded with future legislation to, e.g., advertisements for local candidates and local measures.
- Requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform, if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to submit the following information to the FPPC in a format specified by the FPPC:
- the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, as specified;
- one of the following, as applicable:
- the name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate; or
- the number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure;
- the name of the online platform on which the digital advertisement was displayed;
- the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement;
- the date range during which the advertisement was displayed;
- a copy of the digital advertisement; and
- the name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
- Requires a committee to submit the information submitted pursuant to 5) in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements and preelection statements if the committee spends $1,000 or more during the period covered by the statement.
- Requires the FPPC to make the information submitted related to digital advertisements available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format for no fewer than 12 years from the date the information was submitted.
- Requires the FPPC to make the information submitted related to digital advertisements available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including searching by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. The available search parameters must include, but are not limited to:
- committee payor name;
- the dates the advertisements ran;
- the candidate or ballot measure at issue;
- the platforms used;
- keywords; and
- content.
- Provides that the above described reporting requirements will become operative 60 days after the FPPC certifies a system for accepting and maintaining digital advertisements.
- Makes existing laws that require an online platform to make publicly available information regarding political advertisements that are disseminated through the platform inoperative on the date specified in 9), and instead requires the online platform to retain and transmit certain information to the FPPC regarding any advertisement that was disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months, as specified.
- States that the Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purpose of the Act within the meaning of section 81012(a) of the Government Code.
- Makes nonsubstantive technical and conforming changes.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
AB 868 (Wilson) would create a centralized, searchable, and user-friendly public record of digital campaign advertisements that appear across multiple online platforms.
Access to copies of the campaign ads that voters see on their smartphones, computers, and other devices, and information about who paid for those ads, is crucial to empowering an informed electorate. This information enables the public to understand what interests and groups are funding these ad campaigns, weigh the value and veracity of the ads’ messages, and hold speakers accountable for any false or misleading statements. Additionally, targeting and micro targeting tools create opportunities for political committees to send inconsistent or conflicting messages to appeal to different groups of people. The creation of a centralized public record would enable to the public to discover these inconsistencies and hold speakers accountable.
Tools for effective transparency must keep pace with advancing technology and changing practices. Currently, voters have no ability to search for or access digital campaign ads that appear across multiple online platforms. AB 868 creates a common-sense, forward-thinking public resource that addresses this need and will create crucial improvements to campaign transparency.
- The federal-state framework for regulating election-related advertisements
As a general matter, the federal and state governments have overlapping authority to regulate elections. The United States Constitution (U.S. Constitution) delegates certain matters relating to elections for federal office to Congress and other matters to state legislatures.[1] The Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution also grant Congress the authority to regulate elections as necessary to ensure that persons are provided equal protection under the law and that the right to vote is not denied or abridged on account of race.[2] But the U.S. Constitution generally leaves the regulation of state elections, and many of the details relating to federal elections, to the states.[3]
The states’ authority to regulate elections is also circumscribed by the other U.S. Constitutional amendments, even though they do not directly regulate elections. The most prominent limitation on the ability to regulate election-related communications and advertisements is the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, and specifically the protection of the right to free speech.[4] Laws that impose limitations on political speech based on its subject or viewpoint, or the identity of the speaker, are subject to strict scrutiny review, which places the highest burden on the government seeking to justify the restriction.[5] Government-mandated disclaimer and disclosure requirements, however, are subjected to the less-severe “ ‘exacting scrutiny,’ which requires a ‘substantial relation’ between the disclosure requirement and a ‘sufficiently important’ government interest.”[6]
In 1974, the voters approved an initiative measure to add the Political Reform Act of 1974 (the Act) to the Government Code.[7] The measure was one of the first state political reform measures passed in the aftermath of the Watergate scandal.[8] The Act addressed a range of measures relating to the ethics and conflicts of interest of elected officials, and also added provisions relating to campaign finance and campaign expenditures.[9] The Act has been amended many times since, including to require disclosures in campaign literature.[10]
The rise of the internet—as is the case in many fields—has made it more difficult to effectively regulate campaign ads and statements. “The problem of online political ads pushing disinformation is growing, according to experts, with ongoing and potential threats to campaigns from both within and without the United States.”[11] As of 2021, two platforms—Google and Facebook—made up a majority of the online market for campaign advertisements.[12] Yet, as the author points out, the ephemeral nature of online ads makes it difficult for regulators to monitor and oversee the full extent of campaign advertisements online.
California is one of several states that passed legislation following the 2016 election to more effectively regulate online political advertising.[13] AB 2188 (Mullin, Ch. 754, Stats. 2018) added specific requirements for electronic media campaign ads and communications in the state.[14] The bill added specific disclosure requirements for ads posted online and required the campaign committee behind the ad to provide specified information, including the disclosure name and identification number of the committee and the name of the candidate or ballot measure addressed in the ad.[15] An online platform that accepts campaign ads must maintain, and make available for public inspection, a record of ads purchased from a committee that spent more than $500 on the platform in the last 12 months, which must include:
- A digital copy of the ad.
- The approximate number of views generated from the ad.
- The date and time the ad was first and last displayed.
- Information regarding the rate charged or the total amount spent on the ad.
- The name of the candidate to which the ad refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, or the number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the ad refers.
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the ad, if applicable.[16]
The platform is required to maintain the above information for no fewer than four years.[17] AB 2188 was clarified the next year through AB 864 (Mullin, Ch. 558, Stats. 2019) and became operative on January 1, 2020.[18]
- This bill establishes the DATA Act to create a searchable online database of campaign ads posted online
This bill builds on the Legislature’s efforts to regulate and preserve campaign advertisements posted online. Titled the DATA Act, the bill requires the FPPC to create a centralized, publicly accessible online database of certain digital advertisements in elections for state office and for statewide ballot measures. The database must retain the stored ads for at least 12 years, and the database must be searchable for parameter categories, including the candidate or ballot measure addressed, the committee that paid for the ad, and keywords.
After the FPPC has created the database, the obligation to provide content for it falls on the political committees. This differs from SB 921 (Newman, 2022), which was substantially similar to this bill but placed the reporting requirement on online platforms. SB 921 passed this Committee on a vote of 9 to 1, but was ultimately held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Under this bill, political committees that pay for a digital advertisements to appear on an online platform, if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, must submit the following information to the FPPC in a format specified by the FPPC:
- the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, as specified;
- one of the following, as applicable: the name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate; or the number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure;
- the name of the online platform on which the digital advertisement was displayed;
- the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement;
- the date range during which the advertisement was displayed;
- a copy of the digital advertisement; and
- the name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
A covered political committee is required to submit the above information in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements and preelection statements, if the committee spends $1,000 or more during the period covered by the statement. The obligation to submit records to the FPPC begins 60 days after the FPPC’s platform is certified.
Common Cause writes that they would support the bill if it was amended to revert the bill back to placing the reporting requirement son the online platforms instead of the political committees writing:
AB 868 currently places the obligation for submitting specified advertisement information to the FPPC in order to be included in the archive on campaign committees. While the committees are the ones who create the advertisements, this may unintentionally negatively impact smaller and less politically sophisticated or well-funded campaigns that wish to engage with voters. AB 868 may increase their need to hire outside legal counsel to ensure compliance, or require the devotion of additional staff hours, and indirectly make their political participation harder or more confusing.
In comparison, there are relatively few large online platforms in which most digital advertisements are concentrated, and these platforms already under existing law must collect and save certain digital political advertisements, and make them available to the FPPC. Placing the burden to submit advertisement information instead on the online platforms has potential benefits, including the platforms having more potential capacity and expertise to comply, compared to temporarily existing campaigns. The fact that online platforms already must store some of this information also lends itself to placing additional obligations on the platform.
- Arguments in support
The League of Women Voters of California writes in support stating:
The League of Women Voters supports state campaign finance practices that increase transparency in funding sources in political campaigns so that voters can be more informed when making decisions. The League also supports the effective monitoring and enforcement of campaign finance laws. The methods of financing political campaigns should protect representative democracy from being distorted by big spending in election campaigns and undue influence. Political campaigns are increasingly turning to advertising via digital media, including social media and internet websites. Current law does not address these forms of political advertising. As we have seen during recent election cycles, digital campaign ads have been used as vehicles for misinformation, disinformation, and amplifying "fake news." The nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public to correct and/or to respond to these ads or to understand who is trying to influence the public.
- Arguments in opposition
The California Federation of Teachers writes in opposition unless amended stating:
While we strongly support increased transparency in campaign finance, establishing a new and distinct filing process for digital advertisements is a step in the wrong direction for several reasons. First, it will impose a substantial compliance burden on smaller, less sophisticated campaign committees, putting them at a high risk of inadvertent noncompliance. Second, to the extent that the Legislature wishes to create a digital advertisement archive, this requirement should be harmonized with existing electronic filing requirements and the burden of archiving these advertisements should be placed either on the state or the online platforms where the ads are displayed. Finally, the State has invested significant time and resources into the Cal-Access Replacement System (“CARS), which is expected to be certified within the next several years. Therefore, appropriating additional funds to create a new filing system for digital advertisements in the interim is redundant, fiscally wasteful, and will increase confusion by promoting two separate campaign disclosure filing systems.[…]
AB 868 will significantly burden smaller unions that engage in state campaign activity who have less resources to devote to building familiarity with new campaign disclosure rules. AB 868 not only creates a lengthy new disclosure obligation, but also requires that this disclosure occur through a new, yet-to-be determined submission process over which the FPPC has discretion. Unlike requiring new information to be included on an existing campaign reporting form or requiring a new type of form to be filed through a familiar filing system such a Cal-Access, AB 868 will require committees to learn how to utilize a new and unknown filing process. This will require additional administrative resources and time, which will increase the likelihood of non-compliance and associated financial penalties for less sophisticated committees.
SUPPORT
California Clean Money Campaign
League of California Women Voters
Northern California Recycling Association
OPPOSITION
California Chamber of Commerce
California Federation of Teachers
TechNet
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 921 (Newman, 2022) was substantially similar to this bill, see Comment 3. SB 921 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 1360 (Umberg, Ch. 887, Stats. 2022) changed the disclosure requirements for certain campaign advertisements based on the media in which they appear, including for video advertisements disseminated over the internet and electronic media advertisements.
AB 1798 (Bryan, Ch. 862, Stats. 2022) modified the requirements for electronic media advertisements by allowing an advertisement to state the required disclosures in the ad rather than providing a link to the disclosures.
AB 2885 (Eduardo Garcia, 2020) would have required an online platform to maintain and make available for online public inspection a description of the audience requested by the committee and the types of personal information, as defined, used by the online platform to target the advertisement, including use by the online platform of characteristics such as age, gender, race, or other protected classifications under law; and would have required the online platform’s chief executive officer, chief financial officer, chief operating officer, chief privacy officer, or the equivalent position of any of these officers, to personally certify, under penalty of perjury, that to their knowledge the online platform has correctly disclosed all activity under this law. AB 2885 died in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee (Ayes 6, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 58, Noes 17)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 4)
Assembly Elections Committee (Ayes 6, Noes 2)
**************
E.g., U.S. Const., art. I, § 4 (providing that the time, places, and manner of holding Congressional elections may be decided by each state’s legislature, but Congress may make overriding laws except as to the places for choosing senators), art. II, § 1, cl. 3 (each state may determine its procedure for appointing electors to vote for president), cl. 4 (Congress may determine the time for choosing electors to vote for president). ↑
U.S. Const., 14th & 15th amends. ↑
See, e.g., Congressional Research Service, Congressional Authority to Direct How States Administer Elections (Dec. 14, 2022), at p. 6 (“Although the Constitution is silent on various aspects of the voting process, the Constitution seems to anticipate that states would be primarily responsible for establishing procedures for elections”). ↑
See, e.g., Citizens United v. Federal Election Com’n (2010) 558 U.S. 310, 339 (“The First Amendment ‘ “has its fullest and most urgent application” to speech uttered during a campaign for political office’ ”). ↑
Id. at pp. 340-341. ↑
Id. at pp. 366-367. ↑
See Gov. Code, tit. 9, §§ 81000 et seq., added by initiative measure approved by the electors June 4, 1974, eff. Jan. 7, 1975. ↑
See California Fair Political Practices Commission, History of the Political Reform Act, https://www.fppc.ca.gov/about-fppc/about-the-political-reform-act.html. ↑
Ibid. ↑
See Griset v. Fair Political Practices Commission (1994) 8 Cal.4th 851, 859-860. ↑
Ekstrand & Fox, Regulating the Political Wild West: State Efforts to Disclose Sources of Online Political Advertising, 47 J. Legis. 74, 76 (2021). ↑
Ibid. ↑
Id. at pp. 85-92 (discussing measures enacted by Colorado, Vermont, Wyoming, California, New Jersey, New York, Washington, and Maryland). ↑
See Gov. Code, § 84504.6. ↑
Id., § 84504.6(b). ↑
Id., § 84504.6(d)(1). ↑
Id., § 84504.6(d)(2). ↑
AB 2188 (Mullin, Ch. 754, Stats. 2018), § 7. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 7/5/23
Author: | |||
Version: | 6/27/23 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Karen French | ||
Subject: Political Reform Act of 1974: digital political advertisements.
DIGEST
This bill requires the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to develop an online archive of digital campaign advertisements. This bill also requires a candidate or committee that pays for a digital campaign advertisement related to a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure to submit that advertisement and specified information about it to the FPPC for inclusion in the archive.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Creates the FPPC and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 (PRA).
- Defines a “person” to mean an individual, proprietorship, firm, partnership, joint venture, syndicate, business trust, company, corporation, limited liability company, association, committee, and any other organization or group of persons acting in concert.
- Defines “committee” to mean any person or combination of persons who directly or indirectly does any of the following:
- Receives contributions totaling $2,000 or more in a calendar year (also known as a recipient committee).
- Makes independent expenditures totaling $1,000 or more in a calendar year to or at the behest of candidates or committees (also known as an “Independent Expenditure” committee).
- Makes contributions totaling $10,000 or more in a calendar year to or at the behest of candidates or committees (also known as a “Major Donor” committee).
- Requires a qualified committee to file periodic statements and reports, as specified.
- Defines "advertisement," for the purposes of specified provisions of the PRA, as any general or public communication that is authorized and paid for by a committee for the purpose of supporting or opposing a candidate or a ballot measure, unless certain conditions are met.
- Defines “online platform” to mean a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Provides that a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform to the extent that it displays advertisements sold directly to advertisers through another online platform, as specified.
- Defines “online platform disclosed advertisement” to mean either of the following:
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which a committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with a specific section of existing law. Individual posts, comments, or other similar communications are not considered online platform disclosed advertisements if posted without payment to the online platform.
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of the following:
- A graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to hyperlink to an internet website containing required disclosures, as specified.
- Video, audio, or email.
- Provides that electronic media advertisements that are not online platform disclosed advertisements, as defined, shall follow disclosure requirements for electronic media advertisements under existing law.
- Requires a committee that disseminates an online platform disclosed advertisement to do all of the following:
- Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platform’s chosen notification method, that the advertisement is an advertisement, as specified.
- Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee, as specified.
- Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
- Provide the online platform with the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
- Requires an online platform that disseminates committees’ online platform disclosed advertisements meet all of the following requirements:
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Requires each record contain all of the following:
- A digital copy of the advertisement.
- The approximate number of views generated from the advertisement and the date and time that the advertisement was first displayed and last displayed.
- Information regarding the range charged or the total amount spent on the advertisement.
- The name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
- Requires the information required be made available as soon as practicable and be retained by the online platform for no less than four years.
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Requires each record contain all of the following:
This bill:
- Enacts the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability Act (DATA Act) operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the FPPC certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted by political committees.
- Clarifies the definition of “online platform” to mean a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Provides that the term “online platform” does not include a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- Adds a definition of “online platform disclosed advertisement” as either of the following:
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which the committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with Section 84504.1. Individual communications are not considered online-platform-disclosed advertisements if they are posted without payment to the online platform.
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of specified types of digital postings, and are considered electronic media advertisements subject to the disclosure requirements of Section 84504.3.
- Upon certification of the above system, eliminates the existing requirement for an online platform that disseminates committees’ online platform disclosed advertisements and that receives $50,000 or more from digital advertisement sales during a calendar month to maintain and make accessible for public inspection specified records of advertisements.
- Requires, instead, an online platform to transmit to the commission a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased five hundred dollars ($500) or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months specified information regarding digital advertisements and to retain the information for no less than four years for specified purposes, as specified.
- Requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to submit to to the commission a copy of the digital advertisement and specified information, including, among other things, the name, disclosure name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, information relating to the subject of the advertisement, the name of the online platform or platforms on which the digital advertisement was displayed, and the amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement
- Requires the information to be submitted to the FPPC in accordance with existing deadlines for the submission of semiannual statements and preelection statements, if the committee spends $1,000 or more during the period covered by the statement.
- Requires the FPPC to make information submitted pursuant to this act available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format, as specified, and.to maintain information for a digital advertisement for no less than 12 years from the date that information is first submitted.
- Requires the information submitted related to digital advertisements to be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Requires search and filter parameter categories to include, but not be limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
- Permits a committee to contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information specified above to the FPPC on behalf of the committee.
- Makes a committee that submits the information related to a digital advertisement after the prescribed deadline liable in the amount of $10 per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. Provides that this penalty applies in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by existing law, but provides that the $10 per day penalty is the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation of the provisions of this bill related to the submission of digital advertisements by a committee.
- Makes various findings and declarations, as specified.
- Makes technical, clarifying, and conforming changes.
BACKGROUND
FPPC Digital Transparency Task Force. In 2019, the FPPC authorized and established the Digital Transparency Task Force (DTTF) in an effort to examine issues surrounding digital political advertising. The DTTF recognized that digital political advertising has risen over time with the advancement of social media and other online platforms. The DTTF sought to explore how to balance the rise of digital political advertising with the adequate need for transparency for these types of communication.
Following a number of meetings throughout 2020 and 2021, the DTTF published a report towards the end of 2021 with a summary of their efforts and a number of recommendations. One recommendation was to create a state-run political advertisement archive, which the DTTF saw as assisting in the facilitation of campaign finance enforcement and allowing for more legal oversight of digital advertisements by the FPPC. Additionally, the recommendations also specified that the archive collect and make publicly available copies of digital political advertisements.
Political Advertising Archives in Other Jurisdictions. The cities of Los Angeles, San Jose, and New York have all created online, government-run campaign advertisement archives where the public can access copies of certain political advertisements along with information about the persons or groups responsible for those advertisements. If certain requirements are met for a type of communication, such as when a monetary spending or a distribution threshold is reached, then the campaign is required to send a copy of the advertisement and other specified information to a centralized database where the public can access copies and locate information about the people and/or organizations responsible for the advertisement. For example, in Los Angeles, campaign communications that are distributed to 200 or more persons by a candidate, officeholder, or committee are required to be submitted to the City Ethics Commission, which makes those communications available through an online public data portal. The Los Angeles law applies not only to digital communications, but also to physical mail, emails, telephone calls (candidates and committees must submit a copy of the script for the call), and similar communications. In addition to the city archives, online platforms, such as Facebook and Google, have created their own archives in an effort to be more transparent and comply with existing law.
Existing Regulation of Political Advertising on Online Platforms. In the last several years, the Legislature has taken a number of significant steps to improve transparency in connection with political advertising. In particular, recently enacted legislation has sought to make information more accessible to the public about the identity of committees that are responsible for political advertisements, and of the top campaign contributors to those committees. Five years ago, in response to a growth in political advertisements on social media platforms, the Legislature approved and Governor Brown signed AB 2188 (Mullin), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018, which requires online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public, among other provisions. In accordance with the provisions of AB 2188, major online platforms that run political advertising (including Google, Meta (the parent company of Facebook), and Snap) maintain online political advertising libraries that include digital copies of political advertisements that ran on the platform, along with specified information about when the ad ran, the approximate number of views that the ad received, the amount charged or spent on the ad, the candidate or ballot measure that the ad supported or opposed, and the identity of the political committee that paid for the ad. Although the information available through these political advertising libraries is similar, there are differences in the way that each platform presents the information. Furthermore, there is no centralized library or archive that contains comprehensive information about political advertisements related to California elections that appeared on different online platforms.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: AB 868 (Wilson) would create a centralized, searchable, and user-friendly public record of digital campaign advertisements that appear across multiple online platforms.
Access to copies of the campaign ads that voters see on their smartphones, computers, and other devices, and information about who paid for those ads, is crucial to empowering an informed electorate. This information enables the public to understand what interests and groups are funding these ad campaigns, weigh the value and veracity of the ads’ messages, and hold speakers accountable for any false or misleading statements. Additionally, targeting and microtargeting tools create opportunities for political committees to send inconsistent or conflicting messages to appeal to different groups of people. The creation of a centralized public record would enable to the public to discover these inconsistencies and hold speakers accountable.
Tools for effective transparency must keep pace with advancing technology and changing practices. Currently, voters have no ability to search for or access digital campaign ads that appear across multiple online platforms. AB 868 creates a common-sense, forward-thinking public resource that addresses this need and will create crucial improvements to campaign transparency
- Argument in Support. In a letter supporting AB 868, the League of Women Voters of California states, in part, the following:
The League of Women Voters supports state campaign finance practices that increase transparency in funding sources in political campaigns so that voters can be more informed when making decisions. The League also supports the effective monitoring and enforcement of campaign finance laws. The methods of financing political campaigns should protect representative democracy from being distorted by big spending in election campaigns and undue influence. Political campaigns are increasingly turning to advertising via digital media, including social media and internet websites. Current law does not address these forms of political advertising. As we have seen during recent election cycles, digital campaign ads have been used as vehicles for misinformation, disinformation, and amplifying "fake news." The nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public to correct and/or to respond to these ads or to understand who is trying to influence the public.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing AB 868, the California Chamber of Commerce stated, in part, the following:
While we strongly support additional transparency in our elections process and agree that digital advertisements have increased in use in recent years, we don’t believe that this will improve the state’s current disclosure requirements.
California already has one of the most robust and transparent systems of campaign finance laws in the country…There is information already available through the Secretary of State’s website where anyone in the world can see – in near real time depending on the proximity to an election of the expenditure – which candidate or committee has expended funds on digital ads, who contributed to the candidate or committee, what types of ads were paid for (whether they were digital, television etc.), and to the penny how much money was spent…Additionally, if there is any allegation of impropriety or malfeasance or a formal complaint is filed, the FPPC already has the authority to conduct a thorough investigation…While we appreciate the author’s efforts to narrow the bill from last year, we will note that with the State facing a more than $20 billion budget deficit, this proposal would add material cost to the FPPC budget.
- Who should submit? This bill makes political committees responsible for submitting information about digital advertisements to the FPPC. SB 921 (Newman) of 2022, was similar to this bill, although notably SB 921 would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather that requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. SB 921 was held on the Senate Committee on Appropriations’ suspense file.
Some of the reasoning behind requiring online platforms to submit information about digital advertisements, instead of imposing that obligation on political committees includes: 1) minimizing the number of entities that are submitting information to the FPPC, and 2) improving compliance because many political committees are ad hoc entities that exist only for a limited duration, online platforms may be in a better position to develop familiarity with submitting information about digital advertising to the FPPC, therefore improving compliance. However, this bill implements the recommendations of the DTTF, including that committees paying for digital advertisements have the obligation of submitting copies and inputs regarding such advertisements to the archive, and noting that such a requirement "structurally flows from obligations currently on committees to maintain records and report activity" under the PRA.
- Double Referral. If approved by this committee, AB 868 will be referred to the Committee on Judiciary.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 921 (Newman) of 2021 would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather than requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. SB 921 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
AB 2885 (Eduardo Garcia) of 2020 would have required an online platform to maintain and make available for online public inspection a description of the audience requested by the committee and the types of personal information used by the platform to target the advertisement, including use of characteristics that are protected classifications under law; and also would have required the online platform’s officers, to personally certify, under penalty of perjury, that to their knowledge the online platform has correctly disclosed all activity under this law. SB 2885 died in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting.
AB 864 (Mullin), Chapter 558, Statutes of 2019, among other things, excluded certain online communications from the Act’s campaign advertisement disclosure requirements, including communications opted into by the recipient, added certain requirements for campaign text messages, and added certain definitions to the provisions imposing requirements for advertisements on online platforms.
AB 2188 (Mullin), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018, required, among other provisions, online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public.
SB 1104 (Padilla) of 2014 would have required a candidate for elective state office, a slate mailer organization, or a committee that authorizes an expenditure for a campaign communication to file an electronic copy of the campaign communication with the Secretary of State. This bill would have also required the Secretary of State to maintain an archive of the filed campaign communications and to make the campaign communications available for public inspection on the Secretary of State’s website. This bill was held on the Assembly Suspense File.
PRIOR ACTION
Assembly Floor: | |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | |
Assembly Elections Committee: |
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Fair Political Practices Commission
Support: California Clean Money Campaign
League of Women Voters of California
Northern California Recycling Association
Oppose: California Chamber of Commerce
California Federation of Teachers, AFT, AFL-CIO
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 6/20/23
Author: | |||
Version: | 3/30/23 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Karen French | ||
Subject: Political Reform Act of 1974: digital political advertisements.
DIGEST
This bill requires the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to develop an online archive of digital campaign advertisements. This bill also requires a candidate or committee that pays for a digital campaign advertisement related to a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure to submit that advertisement and specified information about it to the FPPC for inclusion in that archive.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Creates the FPPC and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act of 1974 (PRA).
- Defines a “person” to mean an individual, proprietorship, firm, partnership, joint venture, syndicate, business trust, company, corporation, limited liability company, association, committee, and any other organization or group of persons acting in concert.
- Defines “committee” to mean any person or combination of persons who directly or indirectly does any of the following:
- Receives contributions totaling $2,000 or more in a calendar year (also known as a recipient committee).
- Makes independent expenditures totaling $1,000 or more in a calendar year to or at the behest of candidates or committees (also known as an “Independent Expenditure” committee).
- Makes contributions totaling $10,000 or more in a calendar year to or at the behest of candidates or committees (also known as a “Major Donor” committee).
- Requires a qualified committee to file periodic statements and reports, as specified.
- Defines "advertisement," for the purposes of specified provisions of the PRA, as any general or public communication that is authorized and paid for by a committee for the purpose of supporting or opposing a candidate or a ballot measure, unless certain conditions are met.
- Defines “online platform” to mean a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Provides that a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application is not an online platform to the extent that it displays advertisements sold directly to advertisers through another online platform, as specified.
- Defines “online platform disclosed advertisement” to mean either of the following:
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform made via a form of electronic media that allows users to engage in discourse and post content, or any other type of social media, for which a committee pays the online platform, unless all advertisements on the platform are video advertisements that can comply with a specific section of existing law. Individual posts, comments, or other similar communications are not considered online platform disclosed advertisements if posted without payment to the online platform.
- A paid electronic media advertisement on an online platform that is not any of the following:
- A graphic, image, animated graphic, or animated image that the online platform hosting the advertisement allows to hyperlink to an internet website containing required disclosures, as specified.
- Video, audio, or email.
- Provides that electronic media advertisements that are not online platform disclosed advertisements, as defined, shall follow disclosure requirements for electronic media advertisements under existing law.
- Requires a committee that disseminates an online platform disclosed advertisement to do all of the following:
- Upon requesting the dissemination, expressly notify the online platform through which the advertisement would be disseminated, using the online platform’s chosen notification method, that the advertisement is an advertisement, as specified.
- Provide the online platform with the disclosure name of the committee, as specified.
- Provide the online platform with the name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
- Provide the online platform with the name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement.
- Requires an online platform that disseminates committees’ online platform disclosed advertisements meet all of the following requirements:
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Requires each record contain all of the following:
- A digital copy of the advertisement.
- The approximate number of views generated from the advertisement and the date and time that the advertisement was first displayed and last displayed.
- Information regarding the range charged or the total amount spent on the advertisement.
- The name of the candidate to which the advertisement refers and the office to which the candidate is seeking election, as applicable, or number or letter of the ballot measure and the jurisdiction to which the advertisement refers.
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, if the committee is assigned an identification number.
- Requires the information required be made available as soon as practicable and be retained by the online platform for no less than four years.
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in a machine readable format, a record of any advertisement disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in advertisements on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Requires each record contain all of the following:
This bill:
- Requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform, if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to submit the following information to the FPPC in a format specified by the FPPC:
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, as specified.
- One of the following, as applicable:
- The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
- The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
- The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
- The name of the online platform on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
- The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
- The date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
- A copy of the digital advertisement.
- The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, as specified.
- Requires a committee to submit the information specified above in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements and preelection statements, as specified.
- Permits a committee to contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information specified above to the FPPC on behalf of the committee.
- Provides that the provisions outlined above shall become operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the FPPC certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted by political committees. Makes existing laws that require an online platform to make information publicly available about political advertisements that are disseminated through the platform inoperative on that date. Requires the online platform to retain the information required by those laws for no less than four years, or to transfer the information to the FPPC, as specified.
- Requires the FPPC to make the information specified above related to digital advertisements available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format.
- Requires the FPPC to maintain information for a digital advertisement for no less than 12 years from the date that information is first submitted to the FPPC.
- Requires the information submitted related to digital advertisements to be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Requires search and filter parameter categories to include, but not be limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
- Makes a committee that submits the information related to a digital advertisement after the prescribed deadline liable in the amount of $10 per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. Provides that this penalty applies in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by existing law, but provides that the $10 per day penalty is the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation of the provisions of this bill related to the submission of digital advertisements by a committee.
- Defines the following terms, for the purpose of this bill:
- “Digital advertisement” to mean a paid advertisement, as specified, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, or web application.
- “Online platform” to means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Provides that the term “online platform” does not include the following:
- A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- The internet website, web application, or digital application of a newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest.
- A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- Makes various findings and declarations, as specified.
- Makes technical, clarifying, and conforming changes.
BACKGROUND
FPPC Digital Transparency Task Force. In 2019, the FPPC authorized and established the Digital Transparency Task Force (DTTF) in an effort to examine issues surrounding digital political advertising. The DTTF recognized that digital political advertising has risen over time with the advancement of social media and other online platforms. The DTTF sought to explore how to balance the rise of digital political advertising with the adequate need for transparency for these types of communication.
Following a number of meetings throughout 2020 and 2021, the DTTF published a report towards the end of 2021 with a summary of their efforts and a number of recommendations. One recommendation was to create a state-run political advertisement archive, which the DTTF saw as assisting in the facilitation of campaign finance enforcement and allowing for more legal oversight of digital advertisements by the FPPC. Additionally, the recommendations also specified that the archive collect and make publicly available copies of digital political advertisements.
Political Advertising Archives in Other Jurisdictions. The cities of Los Angeles, San Jose, and New York have all created online, government-run campaign advertisement archives where the public can access copies of certain political advertisements along with information about the persons or groups responsible for those advertisements. If certain requirements are met for a type of communication, such as when a monetary spending or a distribution threshold is reached, then the campaign is required to send a copy of the advertisement and other specified information to a centralized database where the public can access copies and locate information about the people and/or organizations responsible for the advertisement. For example, in Los Angeles, campaign communications that are distributed to 200 or more persons by a candidate, officeholder, or committee are required to be submitted to the City Ethics Commission, which makes those communications available through an online public data portal. The Los Angeles law applies not only to digital communications, but also to physical mail, emails, telephone calls (candidates and committees must submit a copy of the script for the call), and similar communications. In addition to the city archives, online platforms, such as Facebook and Google, have created their own archives in an effort to be more transparent and comply with existing law.
Existing Regulation of Political Advertising on Online Platforms. In the last several years, the Legislature has taken a number of significant steps to improve transparency in connection with political advertising. In particular, recently enacted legislation has sought to make information more accessible to the public about the identity of committees that are responsible for political advertisements, and of the top campaign contributors to those committees. Five years ago, in response to a growth in political advertisements on social media platforms, the Legislature approved and Governor Brown signed AB 2188 (Mullin), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018, which requires online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public, among other provisions. In accordance with the provisions of AB 2188, major online platforms that run political advertising (including Google, Meta (the parent company of Facebook), and Snap) maintain online political advertising libraries that include digital copies of political advertisements that ran on the platform, along with specified information about when the ad ran, the approximate number of views that the ad received, the amount charged or spent on the ad, the candidate or ballot measure that the ad supported or opposed, and the identity of the political committee that paid for the ad. Although the information available through these political advertising libraries is similar, there are differences in the way that each platform presents the information. Furthermore, there is no centralized library or archive that contains comprehensive information about political advertisements related to California elections that appeared on different online platforms.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: AB 868 (Wilson) would create a centralized, searchable, and user-friendly public record of digital campaign advertisements that appear across multiple online platforms.
Access to copies of the campaign ads that voters see on their smartphones, computers, and other devices, and information about who paid for those ads, is crucial to empowering an informed electorate. This information enables the public to understand what interests and groups are funding these ad campaigns, weigh the value and veracity of the ads’ messages, and hold speakers accountable for any false or misleading statements. Additionally, targeting and microtargeting tools create opportunities for political committees to send inconsistent or conflicting messages to appeal to different groups of people. The creation of a centralized public record would enable to the public to discover these inconsistencies and hold speakers accountable.
Tools for effective transparency must keep pace with advancing technology and changing practices. Currently, voters have no ability to search for or access digital campaign ads that appear across multiple online platforms. AB 868 creates a common-sense, forward-thinking public resource that addresses this need and will create crucial improvements to campaign transparency
- Argument in Support. In a letter supporting AB 868, the League of Women Voters of California states, in part, the following:
The League of Women Voters supports state campaign finance practices that increase transparency in funding sources in political campaigns so that voters can be more informed when making decisions. The League also supports the effective monitoring and enforcement of campaign finance laws. The methods of financing political campaigns should protect representative democracy from being distorted by big spending in election campaigns and undue influence. Political campaigns are increasingly turning to advertising via digital media, including social media and internet websites. Current law does not address these forms of political advertising. As we have seen during recent election cycles, digital campaign ads have been used as vehicles for misinformation, disinformation, and amplifying "fake news." The nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public to correct and/or to respond to these ads or to understand who is trying to influence the public.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing AB 868, the California Chamber of Commerce stated, in part, the following:
The California Chamber of Commerce respectfully OPPOSES AB 868 (Wilson), as it would add yet another regulatory cost to political speech by requiring the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to build and implement a new system to accept, process and maintain a database with nearly all of the digital advertisements that are created during a political campaign in the previous 12 months. While we strongly support additional transparency in our elections process and agree that digital advertisements have increased in use in recent years, we don’t believe that this will improve the state’s current disclosure requirements.
California already has one of the most robust and transparent systems of campaign finance laws in the country. There is information already available through the Secretary of State’s website where anyone in the world can see – in near real time depending on the proximity to an election of the expenditure – which candidate or committee has expended funds on digital ads, who contributed to the candidate or committee, what types of ads were paid for (whether they were digital, television etc.), and to the penny how much money was spent. Additionally, if there is any allegation of impropriety or malfeasance or a formal complaint is filed, the FPPC already has the authority to conduct a thorough investigation. While we appreciate the author’s efforts to narrow the bill from last year, we will note that with the State facing a more than $20 billion budget deficit, this proposal would add material cost to the FPPC budget.
- Who should submit? This bill makes political committees responsible for submitting information about digital advertisements to the FPPC. SB 921 (Newman) of 2022, was similar to this bill, although notably SB 921 would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather that requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. SB 921 was held on the Senate Committee on Appropriations’ suspense file.
Some of the reasoning behind requiring online platforms to submit information about digital advertisements, instead of imposing that obligation on political committees includes: 1) Minimizing the number of entities that are submitting information to the FPPC, and 2) Improving compliance because many political committees are ad hoc entities that exist only for a limited duration, online platforms may be in a better position to develop familiarity with submitting information about digital advertising to the FPPC, therefore improving compliance. However, this bill implements the recommendations of the DTTF, including that committees paying for digital advertisements have the obligation of submitting copies and inputs regarding such advertisements to the archive, and noting that such a requirement "structurally flows from obligations currently on committees to maintain records and report activity" under the PRA.
- Double Referral. If approved by this committee, AB 868 will be referred to the Committee on Judiciary.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 921 (Newman) of 2021 would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather than requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. SB 921 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
AB 2885 (Eduardo Garcia) of 2020 would have required an online platform to maintain and make available for online public inspection a description of the audience requested by the committee and the types of personal information used by the platform to target the advertisement, including use of characteristics that are protected classifications under law; and also would have required the online platform’s officers, to personally certify, under penalty of perjury, that to their knowledge the online platform has correctly disclosed all activity under this law. SB 2885 died in the Assembly Committee on Elections and Redistricting.
AB 864 (Mullin), Chapter 558, Statutes of 2019, among other things, excluded certain online communications from the Act’s campaign advertisement disclosure requirements, including communications opted into by the recipient, added certain requirements for campaign text messages, and added certain definitions to the provisions imposing requirements for advertisements on online platforms.
AB 2188 (Mullin), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018, required, among other provisions, online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public.
SB 1104 (Padilla) of 2014 would have required a candidate for elective state office, a slate mailer organization, or a committee that authorizes an expenditure for a campaign communication to file an electronic copy of the campaign communication with the Secretary of State. This bill would have also required the Secretary of State to maintain an archive of the filed campaign communications and to make the campaign communications available for public inspection on the Secretary of State’s website. This bill was held on the Assembly Suspense File.
PRIOR ACTION
Assembly Floor: | |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | |
Assembly Elections Committee: |
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Fair Political Practices Commission
Support: League of Women Voters of California
Oppose: California Chamber of Commerce
California Clean Money Campaign
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 868
Author:(Wilson)
As Amended Ver:March 30, 2023
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Requires the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to develop an online archive of digital campaign advertisements. Requires a candidate or committee that pays for a digital campaign advertisement related to a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure to submit that advertisement and specified information about it to the FPPC for inclusion in that archive.
Major Provisions
- Requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform, if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to submit a copy of the advertisement to the FPPC along with information about the advertisement including an identification of the platform on which the advertisement was displayed, the candidate or ballot measure that was the subject of the advertisement, the amount paid for the advertisement, and the date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
- Provides that the provisions outlined above shall become operative on the first January 1 that is at least 60 days after the FPPC certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted by political committees. Requires the FPPC to maintain information for a digital advertisement for no less than 12 years from the date that information is first submitted to the FPPC.
- Requires the information submitted related to digital advertisements to be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities.
- Makes a committee that submits the information related to a digital advertisement after the prescribed deadline liable in the amount of $10 per day after the deadline until the information is submitted, and provides that this penalty is the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a non-intentional violation of the provisions of this bill related to the submission of digital advertisements.
COMMENTS
In September 2019, the FPPC voted to establish a task force to study best practices for regulating campaign activity on social media and other digital platforms. That task force, known as the Digital Transparency Task Force (DTTF), included members of the FPPC, along with representation from a digital platform, political scientists and academics who study digital political activities, political practitioners experienced using digital technology in advertising and outreach, and groups devoted to political transparency. After holding 10 meetings between April 2020 and July 2021, the DTTF published a report summarizing its findings and making recommendations. One recommendation was the creation of a state-run archive for digital political advertisements. Although state law already requires online platforms to make certain information publicly available about political advertising that they run, the DTTF found that approach lacking, noting that there were discrepancies in how platforms defined "advertisements" and in the types of information that the platforms disclosed. The DTTF noted that a state-run archive would facilitate public review of political advertising and enforcement of the state's campaign finance laws by centralizing and standardizing the information available about digital political advertisements.
As currently drafted, this bill makes political committees responsible for submitting information about digital advertisements to the FPPC. SB 921 (Newman) of 2022, was similar to this bill, though notably SB 921 would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC's archive, rather than requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. SB 921 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
It is possible that this bill's objectives would be better realized by requiring online platforms to submit information about digital advertisements to the FPPC, instead of imposing that obligation on political committees. A substantial majority of digital political advertising is made through a small number of online platforms. Accordingly, making those platforms responsible for submitting information to the FPPC about digital political ads will minimize the number of entities that are submitting information to the FPPC. Furthermore, because many political committees are ad hoc entities that exist only for a limited duration, online platforms may be in a better position to develop familiarity with submitting information about digital advertising to the FPPC, therefore improving compliance with this bill.
On the other hand, because online platforms are not responsible for creating the content of advertisements that political committees run on those platforms, the political committees may be in a better position to know which advertisements must be submitted to the FPPC. Furthermore, the DTTF recommended that committees paying for digital advertisements have the obligation of submitting copies and inputs regarding such advertisements to the archive, noting that such a requirement "structurally flows from obligations currently on committees to maintain records and report activity" under the Political Reform Act (PRA).
California voters passed an initiative, Proposition 9, in 1974 that created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. That initiative is commonly known as the PRA. Amendments to the PRA that are not submitted to the voters, such as those contained in this bill, must further the purposes of the initiative and require a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature
According to the Author
"AB 868 (Wilson) would create a centralized, searchable, and user-friendly public record of digital campaign advertisements that appear across multiple online platforms. Access to copies of the campaign ads that voters see on their smartphones, computers, and other devices, and information about who paid for those ads, is crucial to empowering an informed electorate… Tools for effective transparency must keep pace with advancing technology and changing practices. Currently, voters have no ability to search for or access digital campaign ads that appear across multiple online platforms. AB 868 creates a common-sense, forward-thinking public resource that addresses this need and will create crucial improvements to campaign transparency."
Arguments in Support
The sponsor of this bill, the Fair Political Practices Commission, writes in support, "Political committees are spending more money than ever on digital campaign ads to affect public opinion and voter choices. On many platforms, committees can customize ads to particular groups, increasing the danger that these ads can be used to manipulate or spread misinformation or disinformation. It is currently not possible to view the ads paid for by a particular committee or campaign across multiple platforms. Better public transparency is needed to allow the public to review ads, determine who is funding these ads, and hold speakers accountable. Information about the money behind digital campaign ads helps voters weigh the value and veracity of the ad's message, empowering voters to make informed decisions at the ballot box."
Arguments in Opposition
In opposition to this bill, the California Federation of Teachers writes, "AB 868 not only creates a lengthy new disclosure obligation, but also requires that this disclosure occur through a new, yet-to-be-determined submission process over which the FPPC has discretion. Unlike requiring new information to be included on an existing campaign reporting form or requiring a new type of form to be filed through a familiar filing system such a Cal-Access, AB 868 will require committees to learn how to utilize a new and unknown filing process. This will require additional administrative resources and time, which will increase the likelihood of non-compliance and associated financial penalties for less sophisticated committees…Finally, the State should focus on certifying and implementing the [Cal-Access Replacement System] filing system rather than appropriating funds to create an additional distinct process for filing campaign-related digital advertisements."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs of approximately $360,000 to $391,000 in the first year and $181,000 to $210,000 annually thereafter to the FPPC to develop and maintain the online archive system. FPPC anticipates hiring two additional information technology staff to carry out this workload.
VOTES
ASM ELECTIONS: 6-2-0
YES: Bryan, Bennett, Lee, Low, Pellerin, Blanca Rubio
NO: Lackey, Essayli
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Ortega
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Robert Rivas
UPDATED
VERSION: March 30, 2023
CONSULTANT: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0000662
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 868
Author:(Wilson) – As Amended Ver:March 30, 2023
Policy Committee: | Elections | Vote: | 6 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill enacts the Digital Advertisement Transparency and Accountability (DATA) Act.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to develop an online archive of digital campaign advertisements supporting or opposing state candidates and ballot measures.
- Requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement on an online platform to submit specified information to the FPPC, including the name of the online platform that displayed the advertisement, the amount paid to the platform for the advertisement, and a copy of the advertisement. The committee may contract with the online platform to submit this information to the FPPC on the committee’s behalf.
- Makes the above-described requirements operative on the first January 1 at least 60 days after the FPPC certifies a system to provide such information in a centralized and publicly accessible online format with specified search filter capabilities. The information must remain available in this format for at least 12 years.
- Establishes a penalty of $10 per day for a committee that does not timely submit the information to the FPPC.
- Makes inoperative, when this bill’s requirements become operative, existing law requiring an online platform to make political advertisements disseminated through the platform publicly available. However, the online platform must retain such advertisement information for at least four years after the inoperative date or transfer the information to the FPPC.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs of approximately $360,000 to $391,000 in the first year and $181,000 to $210,000 annually thereafter to the FPPC to develop and maintain the online archive system. FPPC anticipates hiring two additional information technology staff to carry out this workload.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Access to copies of the campaign ads that voters see on their smartphones, computers, and other devices, and information about who paid for those ads, is crucial to empowering an informed electorate. This information enables the public to understand what interests and groups are funding these ad campaigns, weigh the value and veracity of the ads’ messages, and hold speakers accountable for any false or misleading statements. Additionally, targeting and microtargeting tools create opportunities for political committees to send inconsistent or conflicting messages to appeal to different groups of people. The creation of a centralized public record would enable the public to discover these inconsistences and hold speakers accountable.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is sponsored by the FPPC, which argues “Political committees are spending more money than ever on digital campaign ads to affect public opinion and voter choices. On many platforms, committees can customize ads to particular groups, increasing the danger that these ads can be used to manipulate or spread misinformation or disinformation.” This bill is also supported by the League of Women Voters of California.
This bill is opposed by the California Chamber of Commerce, which argues “California already has one of the most robust and transparent systems of campaign finance laws in the country.” Opposition points to the Secretary of State’s (SOS’s) website, “where anyone in the world can see – in near real time depending on the proximity to an election of the expenditure – which candidate or committee has expended funds on digital ads, who contributed to the candidate or committee, what types of ads were paid for (whether they were digital, television etc.), and to the penny how much money was spent.”
- FPPC’s Digital Transparency Task Force (DTTF). In September 2019, the FPPC voted to establish the DTTF to study best practices for regulating campaign activity on social media and other online platforms. After holding 10 meetings between April 2020 and July 2021, the DTTF published its recommendations, which included the creation of a state-run archive for digital political advertisements. Although AB 2188 (Mullin), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018, required online platforms to make specified information regarding political advertisements run on the platform publicly available, the DTTF found this approach lacking, noting there were discrepancies in how platforms defined “advertisements” and disclosed information. The DTTF concluded a state-run archive would facilitate public review of political advertising and enforcement of the state’s campaign finance laws by centralizing and standardizing the information available about digital advertisements. This bill requires the FPPC to create the recommended state-run archive.
- Who Is Responsible? This bill makes political committees responsible for submitting advertisement information to the FPPC. The DTTF opined putting the requirement on committees “structurally flows from obligations currently on committees to maintain records and report activity” under existing law. However, as noted in the Assembly Elections Committee’s analysis of this bill, “It is possible that this bill’s objectives would be better realized by requiring online platforms to submit information about digital advertisements to the FPPC, instead of imposing that obligation on political committees.” Since a substantial majority of digital political advertising is made through a small number of online platforms, making platforms responsible for submission will minimize the number of entities from which the FPPC receives information. Additionally, since many political committees are ad hoc entities that exist only for a limited duration, online platforms may be in a better position to develop familiarity with submitting information, therefore increasing compliance.
- Prior Legislation. SB 921 (Newman), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, was similar to this bill, but would have made an online platform responsible for submitting digital advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather than the political committee. SB 921 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
SB 1104 (Padilla), of the 2013-14 Legislative Session, would have required submission of state campaign communications to the SOS for online publication. SB 1104 was held on this committee’s suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 29, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 868 (
Author:Wilson) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2023
SUBJECT: Political Reform Act of 1974: digital political advertisements.
SUMMARY: Requires the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to develop an online archive of digital campaign advertisements. Requires a candidate or committee that pays for a digital campaign advertisement related to a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure to submit that advertisement and specified information about it to the FPPC for inclusion in that archive. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a political committee that pays for a digital advertisement to appear on an online platform, if that advertisement supports or opposes a candidate for elective state office or a state ballot measure, to submit the following information to the FPPC in a format specified by the FPPC:
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, as specified.
- One of the following, as applicable:
- The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
- The number or letter designation of the ballot measure, and whether the advertisement supported or opposed the measure.
- The name of the candidate identified in the advertisement, whether the advertisement supported or opposed the candidate, and the office sought by the candidate.
- The name of the online platform on which the digital advertisement was displayed.
- The amount paid or agreed to be paid to the online platform for the advertisement.
- The date range during which the advertisement was displayed.
- A copy of the digital advertisement.
- The name, title, and contact information of the person submitting the information.
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the advertisement, as specified.
- Requires a committee to submit the information specified above in accordance with the deadlines for semiannual statements and preelection statements, as specified.
- Permits a committee to contract with an online platform to submit copies of the advertisement and other information specified above to the FPPC on behalf of the committee.
- Provides that the provisions outlined above shall become operative 60 days after the FPPC certifies a system for accepting and maintaining the information submitted by political committees. Makes existing laws that require an online platform to make information publicly available about political advertisements that are disseminated through the platform inoperative on that date. Requires the online platform to retain the information required by those laws for no less than four years, or to transfer the information to the FPPC, as specified.
- Requires the FPPC to make the information specified above related to digital advertisements available in a centralized and publicly accessible online format.
- Requires the FPPC to maintain information for a digital advertisement for no less than 12 years from the date that information is first submitted to the FPPC.
- Requires the information submitted related to digital advertisements to be available to the public in a user-friendly format that includes search capabilities, including filtering by various parameters, and the ability to download raw data. Requires search and filter parameter categories to include, but not be limited to, committee payor name, dates the advertisements ran, the candidate or ballot measure at issue, the platforms used, keywords, and content.
- Makes a committee that submits the information related to a digital advertisement after the prescribed deadline liable in the amount of $10 per day after the deadline until the information is submitted. Provides that this penalty applies in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by existing law, but provides that the $10 per day penalty is the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation of the provisions of this bill related to the submission of digital advertisements by a committee.
- Defines the following terms, for the purpose of this bill:
- “Digital advertisement” to mean a paid advertisement, as specified, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, or web application.
- “Online platform” to means a public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application, including a social network, ad network, or search engine, that sells advertisements directly to advertisers. Provides that the term “online platform” does not include the following:
- A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- The internet website, web application, or digital application of a newspaper, magazine, or other periodical of general circulation that routinely carries news and commentary of general interest.
- A public-facing internet website, web application, or digital application to the extent that it displays advertisements that are sold directly to advertisers through another online platform.
- “Digital advertisement” to mean a paid advertisement, as specified, that appears in a digital format, including on an internet website, digital application, or web application.
- Makes various findings and declarations, including the following:
- Political campaigns are increasingly using digital media as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and persuading voters to support their campaigns.
- Digital campaign advertisements present unique challenges to regulators who are charged with ensuring that voters receive timely and accurate information about who is responsible for the content of the advertisement and the payments associated with producing and distributing the advertisement.
- Because of the impermanent nature of these ads, and because these ads are increasingly appearing in new digital spaces, it can be difficult and sometimes impossible for a voter to track down an ad they saw previously or to find other digital ads associated with a campaign or election.
- Although current law requires online platforms to maintain and make available a record of some of the campaign advertisements disseminated on the platform, these current requirements do not capture all digital ads run on those platforms and the different ways in which platforms maintain these records has made it difficult for the public, academics, and others to meaningfully utilize this information.
- Digital campaign advertisements are also used as vehicles for misinformation and disinformation, and the nature of these ads makes it difficult for the public, media, researchers, government agencies, and watchdog groups to find these ads, correct false statements, and hold speakers accountable.
- Creating a public record of digital campaign advertisements will facilitate transparency of those advertisements for the benefit of the public, journalists, academics, watchdog groups, and other persons seeking to better understand who is trying to influence voters and the outcome of elections.
- Political campaigns are increasingly using digital media as a means of delivering campaign advertisements and persuading voters to support their campaigns.
- Makes technical, clarifying, and conforming changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Creates the FPPC, and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act (PRA). (Government Code §§83100, 83111)
- Defines "advertisement," for the purposes of specified provisions of the PRA, as any general or public communication that is authorized and paid for by a committee for the purpose of supporting or opposing a candidate or a ballot measure, except as specified. (Government Code §84501)
- Requires an online platform, as defined, that disseminates specified political advertisements that are paid for by committees, to do all of the following:
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in machine readable format, a record of any ad that is disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in ads on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Requires each record to contain all of the following:
- A digital copy of the ad;
- The approximate number of views generated from the ad, and the date and time that the ad was first and last displayed;
- Information regarding the amount charged for or spent on the ad;
- Identifying information about the candidate or the ballot measure to which the ad refers; and,
- The name and identification number of the committee that paid for the ad. (Government Code §§84504.6(d)(1))
- Make the information related to campaign ads that are disseminated on the online platform available as soon as possible and retain those records for no less than four years. (Government Code §§84504.6(d)(2))
- Display a prominent link with the text "View Ads" or similar text on a page that contains information about the committee that paid for an ad, as specified. Requires the linked page to show all of the ads purchased by the committee on the platform. (Government Code §§84504.6(d)(3))
- Maintain, and make available for online public inspection in machine readable format, a record of any ad that is disseminated on the online platform by a committee that purchased $500 or more in ads on the online platform during the preceding 12 months. Requires each record to contain all of the following:
- Requires a committee that disseminates an ad on an online platform to provide the platform with the information it needs to comply with the requirements of the PRA, as specified. (Government Code §§84504.6(b))
- Requires elected officers, candidates, and specified committees to file semiannual disclosure statements each year no later than July 31 for the period ending June 30, and no later than January 31 for the period ending December 31, except as specified. (Government Code §84200)
- Requires preelection campaign disclosure statements to be filed by specified elected officers, candidates, and committees as follows:
- For the period ending 45 days before the election, the statement shall be filed no later than 40 days before the election.
- For the period ending 17 days before the election, the statement shall be filed no later than 12 days before the election.
- For runoff elections held within 60 days of the qualifying election, an additional preelection statement for the period ending 17 days before the runoff election shall be filed no later than 12 days before the election. (Government Code §84200.8)
- Permits the FPPC to impose administrative penalties in situations where it determines that a violation of the PRA has occurred. Permits the FPPC, through this administrative enforcement procedure, to require the person who violated the PRA to do any of the following:
- Cease and desist violation of the PRA;
- File any reports, statements, or other documents or information required by the PRA; and,
- Pay a monetary penalty of up to $5,000 per violation. (Government Code §83116)
- Provides civil and criminal penalties for violations of the PRA. (Government Code §§91000, 91004, 91005, 91005.5)
- Provides that any person who files an original statement or report after a deadline imposed by the PRA is liable in the amount of $10 per day after the deadline until the statement or report is filed, as specified, in addition to any other penalties or remedies established by the PRA. (Government Code §91013)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. State-mandated local program; contains a crimes and infractions disclaimer.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
AB 868 (Wilson) would create a centralized, searchable, and user-friendly public record of digital campaign advertisements that appear across multiple online platforms.
Access to copies of the campaign ads that voters see on their smartphones, computers, and other devices, and information about who paid for those ads, is crucial to empowering an informed electorate. This information enables the public to understand what interests and groups are funding these ad campaigns, weigh the value and veracity of the ads’ messages, and hold speakers accountable for any false or misleading statements. Additionally, targeting and microtargeting tools create opportunities for political committees to send inconsistent or conflicting messages to appeal to different groups of people. The creation of a centralized public record would enable to the public to discover these inconsistencies and hold speakers accountable.
Tools for effective transparency must keep pace with advancing technology and changing practices. Currently, voters have no ability to search for or access digital campaign ads that appear across multiple online platforms. AB 868 creates a common-sense, forward-thinking public resource that addresses this need and will create crucial improvements to campaign transparency.
- FPPC Digital Transparency Task Force: In September 2019, the FPPC voted to establish a task force to study best practices for regulating campaign activity on social media and other digital platforms. That task force, known as the Digital Transparency Task Force (DTTF), included members of the FPPC, along with representation from a digital platform, political scientists and academics who study digital political activities, political practitioners experienced using digital technology in advertising and outreach, and groups devoted to political transparency.
The FPPC formed the DTTF in recognition of the fact that an increase in digital political activities created new challenges for ensuring transparency of campaign spending and advertising. After holding 10 meetings between April 2020 and July 2021, the DTTF published a report summarizing its findings and making recommendations. One recommendation was the creation of a state-run archive for digital political advertisements. Although state law already requires online platforms to make certain information publicly available about political advertising that they run, the DTTF found that approach lacking, noting that there were discrepancies in how platforms defined “advertisements” and in the types of information that the platforms disclosed. The DTTF noted that a state-run archive would facilitate public review of political advertising and enforcement of the state’s campaign finance laws by centralizing and standardizing the information available about digital political advertisements. - Existing Regulation of Political Advertising on Online Platforms: In the last several years, the Legislature has taken a number of significant steps to improve transparency in connection with political advertising. In particular, recently enacted legislation has sought to make information more accessible to the public about the identity of committees that are responsible for political advertisements, and of the top campaign contributors to those committees. Five years ago, in response to a growth in political advertisements on social media platforms, the Legislature approved and Governor Brown signed AB 2188 (Mullin), Chapter 754, Statutes of 2018, which requires online platforms that sell political ads to make specified information about those political ads available to the public, among other provisions. In accordance with the provisions of AB 2188, major online platforms that run political advertising (including Google, Meta (the parent company of Facebook), and Snap) maintain online political advertising libraries that include digital copies of political advertisements that ran on the platform, along with information about when the ad ran, the approximate number of views that the ad received, the amount charged or spent on the ad, the candidate or ballot measure that the ad supported or opposed, and the identity of the political committee that paid for the ad. Although the information available through these political advertising libraries is similar, there are differences in the way that each platform presents the information. Furthermore, there is no centralized library or archive that contains comprehensive information about political advertisements related to California elections that appeared on different online platforms.
- Political Advertising Archives in Other Jurisdictions: The cities of Los Angeles, San Jose, and New York have all created online, government-run campaign advertisement archives where the public can access copies of certain political advertisements along with information about the persons or groups responsible for those advertisements. In Los Angeles, campaign communications that are distributed to 200 or more persons by a candidate, officeholder, or committee are required to be submitted to the City Ethics Commission, which makes those communications available through an online public data portal. The Los Angeles law applies not only to digital communications, but also to physical mail, emails, telephone calls (candidates and committees must submit a copy of the script for the call), and similar communications.
The online campaign advertisement archives in San Jose and New York generally include campaign advertisements that were paid for by independent expenditures, but do not include advertisements made by candidates and their committees. Other jurisdictions, including Marin County and the cities of Berkeley and Palmdale, have laws that require copies of certain campaign communications to be submitted to the jurisdiction and make those communications available to the public upon request, but do not generally post those communications online. - Responsibility for Submitting Advertisements: As currently drafted, this bill makes political committees responsible for submitting information about digital advertisements to the FPPC. As discussed in more detail below, a similar bill in the last legislative session proposed requiring the online platforms to submit that information to the FPPC.
It is possible that this bill’s objectives would be better realized by requiring online platforms to submit information about digital advertisements to the FPPC, instead of imposing that obligation on political committees. A substantial majority of digital political advertising is made through a small number of online platforms. Accordingly, making those platforms responsible for submitting information to the FPPC about digital political ads will minimize the number of entities that are submitting information to the FPPC. Furthermore, because many political committees are ad hoc entities that exist only for a limited duration, online platforms may be in a better position to develop familiarity with submitting information about digital advertising to the FPPC, therefore improving compliance with this bill.
On the other hand, because online platforms are not responsible for creating the content of advertisements that political committees run on those platforms, the political committees may be in a better position to know which advertisements must be submitted to the FPPC. Furthermore, the DTTF recommended that committees paying for digital advertisements have the obligation of submitting copies and inputs regarding such advertisements to the archive, noting that such a requirement “structurally flows from obligations currently on committees to maintain records and report activity” under the PRA. - Effective Date and Suggested Amendments: As currently drafted, this bill requires committees to begin submitting information about digital advertisements to the FPPC beginning 60 days after the FPPC certifies that it has a system for accepting and maintaining that information. Depending on when the FPPC makes such a certification, this requirement theoretically could go into effect in the days leading up to a major election. Changing state laws governing the submission of digital political advertisements during the middle of an election could create substantial burdens for the entities that are subject to those laws, thereby complicating compliance. Furthermore, any problems or technical issues with the FPPC’s system when it is first deployed will be considerably more significant if the system is launched in close proximity to an election, when the system must deal with a larger volume of submissions.
To decrease the likelihood that the online archive of digital campaign advertisements may be launched in close proximity to a major election and to provide greater certainty to the regulated community about the date on which those entities will need to submit advertisements to that archive, committee staff recommends that this bill be amended to require submissions to the FPPC’s digital advertisement system beginning the January 1 that is at least 60 days after the FPPC certifies its system for accepting and maintaining that information. - Penalties for Violations and Suggested Amendments: As detailed above, violations of the PRA generally are subject to administrative, civil, or criminal penalties. Civil and criminal proceedings for violations of the PRA are relatively rare, however, and the FPPC deals with a substantial majority of enforcement cases through its administrative enforcement process. In most situations, the FPPC can levy a monetary penalty of up to $5,000 per violation through an administrative enforcement action, though certain types of violations are subject to different penalty amounts. In addition to administrative, civil, or criminal penalties, the PRA also includes a “late filing fee” of $10 for every day after the deadline for filing a statement or report until the date on which that statement or report is filed.
This bill establishes a similar $10 per day late filing fee for information about digital advertisements that is required to be submitted to the FPPC under this bill, and specifies that the penalty shall apply in addition to other penalties or remedies, but the $10 per day fee “shall be the exclusive administrative penalty or remedy for a negligent violation.” As currently drafted, this language appears to allow for more significant penalties to be levied for inadvertent violations than for negligent violations, which does not appear to be consistent with the author or sponsor’s intent. Accordingly, committee staff recommends amendments to this bill on page 9, line 35 by deleting the word “negligent” and inserting “non-intentional.” - Previous Legislation and Technical Issues: SB 921 (Newman) of 2022, was similar to this bill, though notably SB 921 would have made online platforms responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC’s archive, rather than requiring political committees to submit those advertisements as is proposed by this bill. SB 921 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
Because this bill is based off the text of SB 921, it includes various provisions that are tailored for a law that requires online platforms to submit digital political advertisements; those provisions are less appropriate for a law that makes political committees responsible for submitting the advertisements, as proposed in this bill. To the extent that this bill continues to make political committees responsible for submitting digital political advertisements to the FPPC, various technical changes will be necessary to ensure that this bill accomplishes its goals.
SB 1104 (Padilla) of 2014 would have required all campaign communications that support or oppose a candidate for state office or a statewide ballot measure to be submitted to the Secretary of State (SOS) and made available on a campaign communication archive on the SOS’s website, as specified. SB 1104 was approved by the Assembly Elections & Redistricting Committee by a 5-0 vote, but subsequently was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file. - Arguments in Support: The sponsor of this bill, the Fair Political Practices Commission, writes in support:
Political committees are spending more money than ever on digital campaign ads to affect public opinion and voter choices. On many platforms, committees can customize ads to particular groups, increasing the danger that these ads can be used to manipulate or spread misinformation or disinformation. It is currently not possible to view the ads paid for by a particular committee or campaign across multiple platforms. Better public transparency is needed to allow the public to review ads, determine who is funding these ads, and hold speakers accountable. Information about the money behind digital campaign ads helps voters weigh the value and veracity of the ad’s message, empowering voters to make informed decisions at the ballot box.
By creating a publicly accessible and searchable record of digital ads in a centralized location, AB 868 would effectively address these transparency and accountability issues by providing voters with a mechanism to view digital ads associated with a particular campaign or committee across multiple online platforms.
- Arguments in Opposition: In opposition to this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce writes:
The California Chamber of Commerce respectfully OPPOSES AB 868 (Wilson), as it would add yet another regulatory cost to political speech by requiring the [FPPC] to build and implement a new system to accept, process and maintain a database with nearly all of the digital advertisements that are created during a political campaign in the previous 12 months.
While we strongly support additional transparency in our elections process and agree that digital advertisements have increased in use in recent years, we don’t believe that this will improve the state’s current disclosure requirements.
California already has one of the most robust and transparent systems of campaign finance laws in the country. There is information already available through the Secretary of State’s website where anyone in the world can see – in near real time depending on the proximity to an election of the expenditure – which candidate or committee has expended funds on digital ads, who contributed to the candidate or committee, what types of ads were paid for (whether they were digital, television etc.), and to the penny how much money was spent…
While we appreciate the author’s efforts to narrow the bill from last year, we will note that with the State facing a more than $20 billion budget deficit, this proposal would add material cost to the FPPC budget.
- Political Reform Act of 1974: California voters passed an initiative, Proposition 9, in 1974 that created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. That initiative is commonly known as the PRA. Amendments to the PRA that are not submitted to the voters, such as those contained in this bill, must further the purposes of the initiative and require a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Fair Political Practices Commission (Sponsor)
League of Women Voters of California
Opposition
California Chamber of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Assembly Standing Committee on Elections
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):