AB 954: Dependency: court-ordered services.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-08
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-08: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 552, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge children to be dependents of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer serious physical harm, or a parent fails to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. Existing law authorizes a court to make reasonable orders for the care, supervision, and support of a dependent child, as specified. Existing law establishes the grounds for removal of a dependent child from the custody of the childs parents or guardian, and requires the court to order the social worker to provide designated child welfare services, including family reunification services, as prescribed. Existing law also requires family maintenance services to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to maintain a child in their own home, and requires the services to be available without regard to income to specified families, including families in which the child is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court.
This bill would require a court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders for a dependent child. The bill would prohibit a court from declaring at specified review hearings that a parent or guardian is noncompliant with a court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for them, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to them, as specified.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge children to be dependents of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer serious physical harm, or a parent fails to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. Existing law authorizes a court to make reasonable orders for the care, supervision, and support of a dependent child, as specified. Existing law establishes the grounds for removal of a dependent child from the custody of the childs parents or guardian, and requires the court to order the social worker to provide designated child welfare services, including family reunification services, as prescribed. Existing law also requires family maintenance services to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to maintain a child in their own home, and requires the services to be available without regard to income to specified families, including families in which the child is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court.
This bill would require a court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders for a dependent child. The bill would prohibit a court from declaring at specified review hearings that a parent or guardian is noncompliant with a court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for them, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to them, as specified.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge children to be dependents of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer serious physical harm, or a parent fails to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. Existing law authorizes a court to make reasonable orders for the care, supervision, and support of a dependent child, as specified. Existing law establishes the grounds for removal of a dependent child from the custody of the childs parents or guardian, and requires the court to order the social worker to provide designated child welfare services, including family reunification services, as prescribed. Existing law also requires family maintenance services to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to maintain a child in their own home, and requires the services to be available without regard to income to specified families, including families in which the child is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court.
This bill would require a court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders for a dependent child. The bill would prohibit a court from declaring at specified review hearings that a parent or guardian is noncompliant with a court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for them, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to them, as specified.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge children to be dependents of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer serious physical harm, or a parent fails to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. Existing law authorizes a court to make reasonable orders for the care, supervision, and support of a dependent child, as specified. Existing law establishes the grounds for removal of a dependent child from the custody of the childs parents or guardian, and requires the court to order the social worker to provide designated child welfare services, including family reunification services, as prescribed. Existing law also requires family maintenance services to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to maintain a child in their own home, and requires the services to be available without regard to income to specified families, including families in which the child is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court.
This bill would require a court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders for a dependent child. The bill would prohibit a court from declaring at specified review hearings that a parent or guardian is noncompliant with a court-ordered case plan when there is evidence the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for them, at specified review hearings. and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to them, as specified.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge children to be dependents of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer serious physical harm, or a parent fails to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. Existing law authorizes a court to make reasonable orders for the care, supervision, and support of a dependent child, as specified. Existing law establishes the grounds for removal of a dependent child from the custody of the childs parents or guardian, and requires the court to order the social worker to provide designated child welfare services, including family reunification services, as prescribed. Existing law also requires family maintenance services to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to maintain a child in their own home, and requires the services to be available without regard to income to specified families, including families in which the child is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court.
This bill would prohibit a parents inability to pay for any court-ordered services from being a barrier to reunification or a basis for removal. To the extent the bill would impose additional duties on county child welfare departments, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.This bill would require a court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders for a dependent child. The bill would prohibit a court from declaring a parent or guardian noncompliant with a court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for them, at specified review hearings.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge children to be dependents of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer serious physical harm, or a parent fails to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. Existing law establishes the grounds for removal of a dependent child from the custody of the childs parents or guardian, and requires the court to order the social worker to provide designated child welfare services, including family reunification services, as prescribed. Existing law also requires family maintenance services to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to maintain a child in their own home, and requires the services to be available without regard to income to specified families, including families in which the child is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court.
This bill would prohibit a parents inability to pay for any court-ordered services from being a barrier to reunification or a basis for removal. To the extent the bill would impose additional duties on county child welfare departments, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
It is the intent of the Legislature that termination of reunification services shall not be based solely on a parents or guardians inability to pay for a court-ordered service.
SEC. 2.Section 362 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:362.(a)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, the court may make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court.
(b)(1)To facilitate coordination and cooperation among agencies, the court may, at any time after a petition has been filed, after giving notice and an opportunity to be heard, join in the juvenile court proceedings any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under Section 300, to a nonminor, as described in Section 303, or to a nonminor dependent, as defined in subdivision (v) of Section 11400, regardless of the status of the adjudication. In any proceeding in which an agency is joined, the court shall not impose duties upon the agency beyond those mandated by law. Nothing in this section shall prohibit agencies that have received notice of the hearing on joinder from meeting prior to the hearing to coordinate services.
(2)The court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined through the administrative process of an agency that has been joined as a party, that the child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent is eligible for those services. With respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services pursuant to Chapter 26.5 (commencing with Section 7570) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code, the courts determination shall be limited to whether the agency has complied with that chapter.
(3)For the purposes of this subdivision, agency means any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent.
(c)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians shall be required to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court.
(d)The juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter as the court deems necessary and proper to carry out this section, including orders to appear before a county financial evaluation officer. That order may include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. A foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed may be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the childs best interest. The program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate shall be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the courts finding that the child is a person described by Section 300.
(e)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, the juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter to ensure the childs regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child.
(f)When making reasonable orders under this section, the court shall inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
SEC. 3.Section 362.8 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:362.8.(a)At a review hearing where a parent or guardians participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, including, but not limited to, hearings pursuant to Sections 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, and 388, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the courts review.
(b)For purposes of this section, a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of court-appointed counsel pursuant to Section 317 is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
It is the intent of the Legislature that termination of reunification services shall not be based solely on a parents or guardians inability to pay for a court-ordered service.
SEC. 2.Section 362 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:362.(a)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, the court may make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court.
(b)(1)To facilitate coordination and cooperation among agencies, the court may, at any time after a petition has been filed, after giving notice and an opportunity to be heard, join in the juvenile court proceedings any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under Section 300, to a nonminor, as described in Section 303, or to a nonminor dependent, as defined in subdivision (v) of Section 11400, regardless of the status of the adjudication. In any proceeding in which an agency is joined, the court shall not impose duties upon the agency beyond those mandated by law. Nothing in this section shall prohibit agencies that have received notice of the hearing on joinder from meeting prior to the hearing to coordinate services.
(2)The court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined through the administrative process of an agency that has been joined as a party, that the child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent is eligible for those services. With respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services pursuant to Chapter 26.5 (commencing with Section 7570) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code, the courts determination shall be limited to whether the agency has complied with that chapter.
(3)For the purposes of this subdivision, agency means any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent.
(c)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians shall be required to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court.
(d)The juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter as the court deems necessary and proper to carry out this section, including orders to appear before a county financial evaluation officer. That order may include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. A foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed may be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the childs best interest. The program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate shall be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the courts finding that the child is a person described by Section 300.
(e)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, the juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter to ensure the childs regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child.
(f)When making reasonable orders under this section, the court shall inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
SEC. 3.Section 362.8 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:362.8.(a)At a review hearing where a parent or guardians participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, including, but not limited to, hearings pursuant to Sections 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, and 388, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the courts review.
(b)For purposes of this section, a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of court-appointed counsel pursuant to Section 317 is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
It is the intent of the Legislature that termination of reunification services shall not be based solely on a parents or guardians inability to pay for a court-ordered service.
SEC. 2.Section 362 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:362.(a)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, the court may make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court.
(b)(1)To facilitate coordination and cooperation among agencies, the court may, at any time after a petition has been filed, after giving notice and an opportunity to be heard, join in the juvenile court proceedings any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under Section 300, to a nonminor, as described in Section 303, or to a nonminor dependent, as defined in subdivision (v) of Section 11400, regardless of the status of the adjudication. In any proceeding in which an agency is joined, the court shall not impose duties upon the agency beyond those mandated by law. Nothing in this section shall prohibit agencies that have received notice of the hearing on joinder from meeting prior to the hearing to coordinate services.
(2)The court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined through the administrative process of an agency that has been joined as a party, that the child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent is eligible for those services. With respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services pursuant to Chapter 26.5 (commencing with Section 7570) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code, the courts determination shall be limited to whether the agency has complied with that chapter.
(3)For the purposes of this subdivision, agency means any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent.
(c)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians shall be required to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court.
(d)The juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter as the court deems necessary and proper to carry out this section, including orders to appear before a county financial evaluation officer. That order may include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. A foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed may be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the childs best interest. The program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate shall be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the courts finding that the child is a person described by Section 300.
(e)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, the juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter to ensure the childs regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child.
(f)When making reasonable orders under this section, the court shall inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
SEC. 3.Section 362.8 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:362.8.(a)At a review hearing where a parent or guardians participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, including, but not limited to, hearings pursuant to Sections 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, and 388, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the courts review.
(b)For purposes of this section, a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender court-appointed counsel pursuant to Section 317 is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
It is the intent of the Legislature that termination of reunification services shall not be based solely on a parents or guardians inability to pay for a court-ordered service.
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 362 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:362.(a)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, the court may make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court.
(b)(1)To facilitate coordination and cooperation among agencies, the court may, at any time after a petition has been filed, after giving notice and an opportunity to be heard, join in the juvenile court proceedings any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under Section 300, to a nonminor, as described in Section 303, or to a nonminor dependent, as defined in subdivision (v) of Section 11400, regardless of the status of the adjudication. In any proceeding in which an agency is joined, the court shall not impose duties upon the agency beyond those mandated by law. Nothing in this section shall prohibit agencies that have received notice of the hearing on joinder from meeting prior to the hearing to coordinate services.
(2)The court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined through the administrative process of an agency that has been joined as a party, that the child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent is eligible for those services. With respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services pursuant to Chapter 26.5 (commencing with Section 7570) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code, the courts determination shall be limited to whether the agency has complied with that chapter.
(3)For the purposes of this subdivision, agency means any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent.
(c)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians shall be required to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court.
(d)The juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter as the court deems necessary and proper to carry out this section, including orders to appear before a county financial evaluation officer. That order may include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. A foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed may be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the childs best interest. The program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate shall be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the courts finding that the child is a person described by Section 300.
(e)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, the juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter to ensure the childs regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child.
(f)When making reasonable orders under this section, the court shall inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 362.8 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:362.8.(a)At a review hearing where a parent or guardians participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, including, but not limited to, hearings pursuant to Sections 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, and 388, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian. guardian, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the courts review.
(b)For purposes of this section, a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender pursuant to Section 317 is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
(a)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, the court may make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court.
(b)(1)To facilitate coordination and cooperation among agencies, the court may, at any time after a petition has been filed, after giving notice and an opportunity to be heard, join in the juvenile court proceedings any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under Section 300, to a nonminor, as described in Section 303, or to a nonminor dependent, as defined in subdivision (v) of Section 11400, regardless of the status of the adjudication. In any proceeding in which an agency is joined, the court shall not impose duties upon the agency beyond those mandated by law. Nothing in this section shall prohibit agencies that have received notice of the hearing on joinder from meeting prior to the hearing to coordinate services.
(2)The court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined through the administrative process of an agency that has been joined as a party, that the child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent is eligible for those services. With respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services pursuant to Chapter 26.5 (commencing with Section 7570) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code, the courts determination shall be limited to whether the agency has complied with that chapter.
(3)For the purposes of this subdivision, agency means any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or nonminor dependent.
(c)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians shall be required to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court.
(d)The juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter as the court deems necessary and proper to carry out this section, including orders to appear before a county financial evaluation officer. That order may include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. A foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed may be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the childs best interest. The program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate shall be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the courts finding that the child is a person described by Section 300.
(e)If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, the juvenile court may direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings under this chapter to ensure the childs regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child.
(f)When making reasonable orders under this section, the court shall inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
SEC. 2.Section 362.8 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:362.8.(a)At a review hearing where a parent or guardians participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, including, but not limited to, hearings pursuant to Sections 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25, and 388, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian.
(b)For purposes of this section, a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender pursuant to Section 317 is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
SECTION 1.Section 372 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:372.A parents inability to pay for any court-ordered services shall not be a barrier to reunification or a basis for removal.SEC. 2.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state or otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.A parents inability to pay for any court-ordered services shall not be a barrier to reunification or a basis for removal.
SEC. 2.To the extent that this act has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation within the meaning of Section 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, it shall apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. Any new program or higher level of service provided by a local agency pursuant to this act above the level for which funding has been provided shall not require a subvention of funds by the state or otherwise be subject to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 552, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 8, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 63. Noes 0. Page 3077.). |
| Sep 5, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 7 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 34. Noes 0. Page 2356.). |
| Jul 6, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 5, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (July 3). |
| Jun 22, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Jun 21, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on HUMAN S. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 20). |
| Jun 12, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 6, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 3, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and HUMAN S. |
| Apr 24, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 24, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 63. Noes 2. Page 1298.) |
| Apr 20, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 18). |
| Mar 23, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Mar 22, 2023 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on HUM. S. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (March 21). |
| Mar 2, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and HUM. S. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2023 | AB 954 Bryan Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 5, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB954 Bryan By Menjivar | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Human Services] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2023 | AB 954 Bryan Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Mar 21, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Human Services] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Alliance for Childrens Rights | ** Support | |
| A New Way of Life Reentry Project | ** Support | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Support | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Support | |
| ChildrenS Law Center Of California | ** Support | |
| East Bay Family Defenders | ** Support | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Movement for Family Power | ** Support | |
| National Association of Social Workers California Chapter | ** Support | |
| Public Counsel | ** Support | |
| Seneca Family of Agencies | ** Support | |
| Starting Over, Inc. | ** Support | |
| The Children's Partnership | ** Support | |
| The Law Offices of Dale Wilson | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 954
Author:(Bryan)
As Amended Ver:June 22, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Clarifies that a parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian.
Major Provisions
- Requires a court, when making reasonable orders related to dependency proceedings, to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
- Provides that at any review hearing where a parent or guardian's participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the court's review.
- Establishes a presumption, for purposes of 2), above, that a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the court-appointed counsel to represent them in a dependency matter is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
Senate Amendments
- Clarify intent that termination of reunification services shall not be based solely on a parent's or guardian's inability to pay for a court-ordered service.
- Specify that the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the court's review.
- Make technical amendments.
COMMENTS
This bill, sponsored by Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, seeks to require a court to consider the parent's financial circumstances when ordering the parent to participate in fee-based court services. It also prohibits a court, for purposes of court decisions related to the reunification of a parent with a child who has been removed from their home, from considering a parent to be non-compliant with a court order to participate in reunification services when there is evidence that the parent was not able to pay for such a service. Finally, it creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court appointed counsel because they cannot afford to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service.
Overview of child welfare services and juvenile dependency court. Children who are at risk of abuse, neglect, or abandonment may be deemed dependents of the juvenile court and provided services, supports and interventions aimed at protecting them and their health and safety. The system aims to preserve and strengthen families by maintaining or reuniting children with their parents whenever appropriate.
The dependency process begins when child abuse, neglect, or abandonment is reported to the local child welfare agency. A social worker with the child welfare agency investigates the allegation to determine if the child requires protection in order to ensure their safety. If so, the child welfare agency files a petition with the juvenile court to make the child a dependent of the court. If necessary, the social worker will remove the child from their home and take the child into protective custody.
At the subsequent court hearing, the court may elect to keep the child in, or return the child to, their home or remove the child from the home. Removal may either result in eventual reunification with the family, or the court may determine that an alternate permanent placement – including the options of guardianship or adoption – is more fitting. When reunification is not possible or appropriate, children are placed in the setting deemed least restrictive and most suitable; the court must give preference to potential placements with relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Throughout this system, there are multiple court hearings – including the detention hearing, the jurisdictional hearing and the dispositional hearing, followed by ongoing review hearings and the permanency hearing – where the custody of a child or their placement is evaluated, reviewed, and determined by the court, in consultation with the child's social worker appointed by the county and the child's attorney, to help provide the best possible support and services to the child.
A child cannot be found to be a dependent child simply because of indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare, cannot, by themselves, establish jurisdiction over a child. Instead, there must be harm or a substantial risk of harm to the child and a nexus between the parent's action, or failure to act, and the harm to the child.
Simply being poor or unhoused, in and of itself, does not allow a juvenile court to take dependency jurisdiction over the child. The courts have further held that "poverty alone, even abject poverty resulting in homelessness, is not a valid basis for assertion of juvenile court jurisdiction." (In re G.S.R. (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1212.) "Put differently, indigency, by itself, does not make one an unfit parent and "'judges [and] social workers … have an obligation to guard against the influence of class and life style biases.'" (Ibid. [citations omitted].) However, if there are additional reasons, being homeless could be part of the reason that a child is made a dependent of the juvenile court.
Therefore, under current law, it is expected that when the child welfare agency discovers a family struggling with poverty that they will work to connect the family with supports and services to help the family better support their children, rather than bringing the family into the dependency system or even removing the children simply because the family is poor.
Reunification services. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family, and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child's parents. If the child is under the age of three, these reunification services are offered for a period of six months. If the child is over the age of three, the services are offered for twelve months. In some circumstances, the time period for reunification services can be extended up to 24 months.
However not all children can safely be reunited with their families. The Welfare & Institutions Code allows judges to forgo reunification services when the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that one of 17 specific situations that involve danger to the child exist. Generally, in these cases, the parent's or guardian's behavior is such that denial of services is necessary in order to protect children from further harm. These instances include when the parent is suffering from a mental disability that renders the parent incapable of using the reunification services; the parent caused the death of another child through abuse or neglect; the child was conceived as the result of rape or incest with a minor and the parent seeking services committed the rape or incest; the child or a sibling had previously been adjudicated a dependent as the result of physical or sexual abuse and the child is now being removed due to additional physical or sexual abuse; and the parent has been convicted of a violent felony.
Despite the significant progress on these issues of economic justice in the child dependency system as the result of last year's SB 1085 (Kamlager), Chapter 832, Statutes of 2022, among other measures, more reforms are necessary to remove financial barriers facing low-income parents, particularly in the area of reunification services. According to the author:
The majority of parents whose kids are in the foster care system are Black or Brown and extremely poor. Data shows that a third of parents whose children are in foster care have an annual income of less than $10,000. When the court denies parents reunification services or terminates their parental rights purely because the parents haven't completed a class that they cannot afford, the court is punishing poverty.
This bill seeks to make a similar clarification in the law in relation to reunification services similar to the clarification made pursuant to last year's SB 1085 concerning removal of a child from the custody of their parent or guardian. It clarifies that a parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian. Finally, the bill creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court appointed counsel because they cannot afford to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service. These provisions should advance access to justice and help facilitate the ability of low-income families to participate in court-ordered services and ultimately to be reunited. As the author astutely observes, "This bill will reduce barriers to reunifying families and give poor parents the opportunity to say that they cannot complete court-ordered programs because they cannot afford it, or have completed the programs but cannot afford to pay for the certificate of completion."
According to the Author
Today, families are being separated or kept separated based solely on the parent's inability to pay for court-ordered services – even if the parent is complying with all other aspects of their case plan. This practice punishes poor families, the majority of whom are Black or Brown. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases costs of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families. This bill will ensure that a parent's inability to pay for court-ordered services is not a barrier to reunifying with their children and will no longer unnecessarily extend the time children remain away from their families.
Arguments in Support
Sponsor Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. write the following about why the bill is necessary and important:
When a child is removed from a parent's care, in most cases, the court orders the parent into a variety of programs to assist in rehabilitation before the child can be returned. The overwhelming majority of parents in this system are indigent, without access to reliable transportation, and without funds to pay for court-ordered services. Yet, the Welfare and Institution Code (WIC) does not have safeguards to ensure that these families are able to participate in services without footing the bill.
. . . [P]arents must pay for their court-ordered programs, even if they do not have the financial means to afford the services ordered. While health insurance covers some services, many parents are uninsured, and even for those who are, classes still require exorbitant out-of-pocket fees. Inability to pay limits a parent's ability to follow the court's orders and get into a class that does not interfere with their work, school and childcare or visitation. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases the cost of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families.
AB 954 seeks to amend WIC to ensure that a parent's inability to pay for court-ordered services no longer remains a barrier to participating in services in order to reunify with their children or keep their children in their care.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-0-3
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 5-0-3
YES: Jackson, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Garcia
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Alanis, Bonta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-2-15
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Gallagher, Mathis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Holden, Hoover, Lackey, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta
SENATE FLOOR: 35-0-5
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood‑Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dahle, Nguyen, Niello, Padilla, Seyarto
UPDATED
VERSION: June 22, 2023
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001232
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 954 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 954
Author: Bryan (D)
Amended: 6/22/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/20/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Stern, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wilk, Niello
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 5-0, 7/3/23
AYES: Alvarado-Gil, Ochoa Bogh, Hurtado, Menjivar, Wahab
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-2, 4/24/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Dependency: court-ordered services
SOURCE: Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
DIGEST:
This bill requires a juvenile court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders relating to a dependent child, and prohibits a court from declaring a parent or guardian noncompliant with the order if it finds that the parent or guardian could not afford the services, or that paying for the service would create an undue financial hardship, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the juvenile court, which is intended to provide for the protection and safety of the public and minors falling under its jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 202, 245.)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from the custody of their parent or guardian[1] on the basis of enumerated forms of abuse or neglect. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 300(a)-(j).)
- Provides that the purpose of the juvenile court and the dependency system is to provide the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of that harm. This safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being may include provision of a full array of social and health services to help the child and family and to prevent the re-abuse of children. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 300.2.)
- Requires, following the removal of a child from their parent’s custody, the juvenile court to hold an initial hearing at which the court determines whether custody may be resumed or what services should be offered to the parent that could facilitate the child’s return in the future.
- The court must make a determination on the record as to whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal of the child from their home, and whether there are available services that would prevent the need for further detention.
- In determining whether to return a child to the parent’s custody at this stage, the fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of substantial danger. (Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 311, 319.)
- Permits, in lieu of keeping a child out of their parent’s custody, a child to remain in the physical custody of their parent while still a dependent of the juvenile court and under the supervision of a social worker. If the court determines that the child can be returned to their parent’s custody through the provision of remedial services and rehabilitation programs, the court shall order those services or programs to be provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 319.)
- Authorizes a court, where a child has been adjudged a dependent of the court, to make any reasonable orders to the child’s parent directing them to participate in services or programs, such as child welfare services, counseling, parenting programs, or a financial evaluation. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 362.)
- Provides that, when a child has determined to be a dependent of the juvenile court, the court must hold periodic review hearings no less frequently than six months, starting six months after the initial dispositional hearing.
- For children three years of age and older and out of their parent’s custody, the court must return the child to their parent’s custody unless it finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.
- If the child was under three years of age at the date of removal is a member of a sibling group as specified, and the court determines the parent has not been participating and making progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a permanency hearing within 120 days. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 366, 366.21(e).)
- If a child is a dependent of the juvenile court but remains in their parent’s custody, the court must hold six-months hearings to determine whether the family has made progress in eliminating the conditions or factors requiring court supervision. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 364.)
- Provides that, for a child who remains out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 7), the court may hold a permanency hearing no later than 12 months after the initial removal; the court may also continue the permanency hearing for up to two more six-month periods, so that the permanency hearing may be held, at a maximum, 24 months after the child was initially removed. (Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 366.21(f), (g), 366.22, 366.25.)
- Requires a court, at review and permanency hearings, to consider a parent’s efforts or progress in overcoming the factors that led to dependency jurisdiction, including whether and to what extent the parent availed themselves of services provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25.)
This bill:
- Requires a juvenile court, when ordering a parent to participate in services or programs to eliminate the conditions that led to the juvenile court’s jurisdiction, to inquire whether the parent can afford the court-ordered services or programs.
- Provides that, at a hearing where a parent’s participation in court-ordered services or programs is at issue (e.g., a reunification hearing or parental rights termination hearing), a juvenile court shall not deem a parent noncompliant with the order to seek services or programs if the court finds that:
- The parent is unable to pay for a service or payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent, and
- The social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the court’s review.
- Establishes that a parent who qualifies for the services of court-appointed counsel in the juvenile court is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services for purposes of the court’s review under 2).
Comments
When a child is found to be under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, the court is determined to be a dependent of that court and the court may begin proceedings to remove the child from the custody of their parent(s); if, after a series of hearings, a parent is found to be unfit, the court can terminate the parent’s parental rights.[2] The overarching inquiry is whether the child would suffer, or is likely to suffer, harm if they remain with their parent. Alternatively, a court may return a child to their parent’s custody but retain jurisdiction and place the parent under the supervision of a social worker; in such cases, the court holds hearings at six-month intervals to determine whether the parent has improved enough to terminate jurisdiction, but may remove the child from their parent’s custody if circumstances deteriorate.[3]
In both circumstances—when a child is a dependent of the juvenile court in their parent’s custody or out of it—the juvenile court is authorized to make any reasonable orders to the child’s parent directing them to participate in services or programs that may help the parent improve the circumstances that led to juvenile court jurisdiction.[4] Court-ordered services and programs can include an array of subject matters, including child welfare services, counseling, parenting programs, or financial evaluations.[5] A parent’s failure to participate, or make progress, in the court-ordered services and programs will be considered by the court in its review hearings determining whether to return or remove a child from their parent’s custody or to terminate parental rights.[6]
This bill requires a juvenile court to inquire about a parent’s financial circumstances when ordering that a parent participate in services or programs as part of a dependency case plan, and then prohibits a court from deeming a parent noncompliant if the parent could not, without creating financial hardship, afford the ordered classes and services. This bill makes clear that a parent can be deemed noncompliant if the social worker provided the parent with a comparable, available free service and the parent failed to take advantage of the free service, which will allow the court to distinguish between parents who are truly noncompliant and those for whom compliance was not feasible. Finally, this bill creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court-appointed attorney in the juvenile court proceedings due to their inability to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 7/6/23)
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. (source)
A New Way of Life Reentry Project
Alliance for Children’s Rights
Children’s Law Center of California
East Bay Family Defenders
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
Public Counsel
Seneca Family of Agencies
Starting Over, Inc.
OPPOSITION: (Verified 7/6/23)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Alliance for Children’s Rights:
The overwhelming majority of parents in this system are indigent, without access to reliable transportation, and without funds to pay for court-ordered services. Yet, the Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC) does not have safeguards to ensure that these families are able to participate in services without footing the bill.
In Los Angeles County, for instance, parents must pay for their court-ordered programs, even if they do not have the financial means to afford the services ordered. While health insurance covers some services, many parents are uninsured, and even for those who are, classes still require exorbitant out-of-pocket fees. Inability to pay limits a parent’s ability to follow the court’s order and get into a class that does not interfere with their work, school and childcare or visitation. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases the cost of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families.
AB 954 would amend the WIC to ensure that a parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services is no longer a barrier to participating in services in order to reunify their children or keep their children in their care.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-2, 4/24/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Gallagher, Mathis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Holden, Hoover, Lackey, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta
Prepared by: Allison Whitt Meredith / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
7/7/23 9:12:09
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Alvarado-Gil, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | AB 954 | ||
Author: | Bryan | ||
Version: | June 22, 2023 | Hearing Date: | July 3, 2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Heather Hopkins | ||
Subject: Dependency: court-ordered services
SUMMARY
This bill requires the dependency court when making reunification orders to ask if a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services. This bill provides that the parent or guardian will not be considered noncompliant with the case plan if they cannot afford the services or paying for the services would create an undue financial hardship.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Establishes the juvenile court with jurisdiction over children who are subject to abuse or neglect. (WIC 300 et seq.)
- States that the purpose of juvenile dependency law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected, or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional wellbeing of children who are at risk of harm. Provides that the focus must be on the preservation of the family as well as the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of the child. (WIC 300.2)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from their parent or guardian if the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted non-accidentally upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian. (WIC 300(a))
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from their parent or guardian if the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of the failure or inability of the child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child, or the willful or negligent failure of the child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child from the conduct of the custodian with whom the child has been left, or by the willful or negligent failure of the parent or guardian to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment, or by the inability of the parent or guardian to provide regular care for the child due to the parent’s or guardian’s mental illness, developmental disability, or substance abuse. Provides that, notwithstanding these factors, a child does not become a dependent of the juvenile court solely due to the lack of emergency shelter for the family or the failure of the child’s parent or alleged parent to seek court orders for custody of the child. (WIC 300(b))
- Provides for additional conditions that would lead to jurisdiction over a dependent child, including for a child who is suffering serious emotional damage, or is at substantial risk of suffering serious emotional damage, as a result of the conduct of the parent or guardian or who has no parent or guardian capable of providing appropriate care; and has been sexually abused, or there is a substantial risk that the child will be sexually abused, by the child’s parent or guardian or a member of the child’s household, or the parent or guardian has failed to adequately protect the child from sexual abuse when the parent or guardian knew or reasonably should have known that the child was in danger of sexual abuse. (WIC 300(c)-(j))
- Requires the court, if at the initial hearing, the juvenile court orders a child removed from their parent due to abuse or neglect, to order that child welfare reunification services be provided to the family as soon as possible in order to reunify the child with their family, if appropriate. (WIC 319(e))
- Requires a social worker, whenever the social worker has cause to believe that there was or is within the county a person described in WIC 300, to immediately make any investigation they deem necessary to determine whether child welfare services should be offered to the family and whether proceedings in the juvenile court should be commenced. Further, requires the social worker, if they determine that it is appropriate to offer child welfare services to the family, to make a referral to those services. (WIC 328(a))
- Requires the court, at the dispositional hearing, to order a social worker to provide child welfare services to a child who has been removed from their parents' custody and to the parents in order to support the goal of reunification, for a specified time period, except under certain circumstances. Provides that children and families in the child welfare system should typically receive a full six months of reunification services if the child is under three years of age, and twelve months if the child is over three years of age, but that may be extended up to 18 or 24 months, as provided. (WIC 361.5(a))
- Authorizes the court, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by WIC 300, to make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court. (WIC 362(a))
- Authorizes the court, when it appears to the court that a parent or guardian of the child desires counsel but is presently financially unable to afford and cannot for that reason employ counsel, the court to appoint counsel, as provided. (WIC 317(a))
- Authorizes the court, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by WIC 300, to make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court. (WIC 362(a))
- Authorizes the court, at any time after a petition has been filed, to join in the juvenile court proceedings, any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under WIC 300, regardless of the status of the adjudication. (WIC 362(b)(1))
- Defines “nonminor dependent” or NMD, to mean, a foster child who is a current dependent or ward of the juvenile court, or who is a nonminor under the transition jurisdiction of the juvenile court, and who satisfies all of the following criteria:
- The youth has turned 18 years old while under an order of foster care placement by the juvenile court, and is not more than 21 years old;
- The youth is in foster care under the placement and care responsibility of the county welfare department, county probation department, Indian tribe, consortium of tribes, or tribal organization that entered into an agreement as described; and,
- The youth has a transitional independent living case plan. (WIC 11400(v))
- The youth has turned 18 years old while under an order of foster care placement by the juvenile court, and is not more than 21 years old;
- Defines “agency” to mean any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or NMD. (WIC 362(b)(3))
- Provides that the court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined that the child, nonminor, or NMD is eligible for those services. Limits, with respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services, as defined, the court’s determination to whether the agency has complied with these provisions. (WIC 362(b)(2))
- Requires, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court. (WIC 362(c))
- Permits the juvenile court to direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings as the court deems necessary and proper. Permits that order to include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. Authorizes a foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed to be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the child’s best interest. Requires the program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate to be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the court’s finding that the child is a person described by WIC 300. (WIC 362(d))
- Authorizes the juvenile court, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, to direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings to ensure the child’s regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child. (WIC 362(e))
- Requires every hearing in which an order is made placing a child under the supervision of the juvenile court pursuant to WIC 300, and in which the child is not removed from the physical custody of their parent or guardian, to be continued to a specific future date not to exceed six months after the date of the original dispositional hearing. (WIC 364(a))
- Requires a permanency hearing to be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care and requires the court, at the permanency hearing, to determine the permanent plan for the child, which shall include a determination of whether the child will be returned to the child’s home and, if so, when, within specified time limits. Requires the court, after considering the relevant and admissible evidence, to order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. Requires the social worker to have the burden of establishing that detriment. (WIC 366.21(f))
- Requires the juvenile court, excepting certain specified conditions, if a child is not returned to the parent or guardian at the permanency review hearing, to hold a hearing to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. Requires the court to determine whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. Sets forth examples of circumstances that would not, in or of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide reasonable services. (WIC 366.22(a))
- Requires a court to establish, by clear and convincing evidence, that reasonable reunification services have been provided to the parent prior to ordering a hearing to terminate parental rights. (WIC 366.22(b)(3)(C))
- Authorizes any parent or other person having an interest in a dependent child or NMD who is a dependent child of the juvenile court or an NMD, or the child or the NMD through a properly appointed guardian to, upon grounds of change of circumstance or new evidence, petition the court in the same action in which the child was found to be a dependent child of the juvenile court or in which a guardianship was ordered for a hearing to change, modify, or set aside any order of court previously made or to terminate the jurisdiction of the court. Requires The petition to be verified and, if made by a person other than the child or the NMD, to state the petitioner’s relationship to or interest in the child or NMD and shall set forth in concise language any change of circumstance or new evidence that is alleged to require the change of order or termination of jurisdiction. (WIC 388(a))
This Bill:
- Provides it is the intent of the Legislature that termination of reunification services are not to be based solely on the parent’s or guardian’s inability to pay for court-ordered service.
- Provides that when the court orders reunification services, the court is required to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford those services.
- Provides that at review hearings where a parent or guardian’s participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when the court finds that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent or guardian to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the court’s review.
- Provides that if a parent or guardian qualifies for court-ordered counsel they will be presumed unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
FISCAL IMPACT
This bill was keyed non fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, “Today, families are being separated or kept separated based solely on the parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services—even if the parent is complying with all other aspects of their case plan. This practice punishes poor families, the majority of whom are Black or Brown. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases costs of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families. This bill will ensure that a parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services is not a barrier to reunifying with their children and will no longer unnecessarily extend the time children remain away from their families.”
Low Income and Families of Color Are Disproportionately Impacted by Child Welfare System
Human Rights Watch published a report in 2022 “If I Wasn’t Poor, I Wouldn’t Be Unfit” The Family Separation Crisis in the US Child Welfare System. The report notes that federal and state data of child welfare systems show racial and ethnic disparities at every stage of involvement, with Black families being impacted the most. When families access social services, they are more exposed to mandated reports. “This creates a dynamic where families living in poverty are surveilled, scrutinized, and reported more than those with greater resources.” The report ends with a number of recommendations for all levels and layers of the child welfare system. With respect to the dependency court system it recommends:
Consider poverty-related barriers to accessing services and its effect on child welfare reunification plan compliance prior to every child welfare decision. Assess and establish the necessity, adequacy, and appropriateness of recommended services and inquire into a parent’s ability to access and pay for them prior to inclusion in a child welfare service plan.
The Legislative Analyst’s Office published a report earlier this year discussing the racial and ethnic disproportionalities and disparities in California’ child welfare system.[1] The report found that foster youth are disproportionately low income, black and Native American. Black and Native American youth in foster care are represented at four times their proportion of the population. Children who have the public insurance Medi-Cal are involved in the child welfare at more than twice the rate of those with private insurance.
Related/Prior Legislation:
SB 578 (Ashby, 2023) requires a social worker to report on, and a juvenile court to consider, the potential harms to a child when considering whether to remove a child from their parent or guardian’s custody. SB 578 is pending before the Assembly Human Services Committee.
SB 463 (Wahab, 2023) eliminates the evidentiary presumption in juvenile court that a parent or guardian’s lack of participation or progress in a treatment program endangers the child, for purposes of determining whether the child should be returned to the parent or guardian’s custody. SB 463 is pending before the Assembly Human Services Committee.
AB 937 (McKinnor, 2023) clarifies that the court must specify its factual basis for its conclusion that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian if the court extends reunification services on that basis. The bill also requires the court to extend reunification services for an additional 6 months if the court determines at the 18-month permanency hearing that reasonable services have not been provided. The bill is pending before this Committee and set to be heard the same day as this bill.
SB 1085 (Kamlager, Chapter 832, Statutes 2022) prohibited a child from being found to be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court on that basis solely due to indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty.
COMMENTS
Studies show low income families are overrepresented in the child welfare system. This bill attempts to address this by ensuring courts are not punishing families for not having the resources to pay for court ordered services.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Judiciary Committee: | 9 - 0 |
Assembly Floor: | 63 - 2 |
Assembly Human Services Committee: | 5 - 0 |
Assembly Judiciary Committee: | 8 - 0 |
POSITIONS
Support:
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, INC. (Sponsor)
A New Way of Life Re-entry Project
Children's Law Center of California
East Bay Family Defenders
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Public Counsel
The Alliance for Children's Rights
Oppose:
None received
-- END --
https://lao.ca.gov/handouts/socservices/2023/Disproportionalities-in-CWS-032223.pdf ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 954 (Author:Bryan)
Version: June 12, 2023
Hearing Date: June 20, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: AWM
SUBJECT
Dependency: court-ordered services
DIGEST
This bill requires a juvenile court to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services when making reasonable orders relating to a dependent child, and prohibits a court from declaring a parent or guardian noncompliant with the order if it finds that the parent or guardian could not afford the services, or that paying for the service would create an undue financial hardship, and the social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Children who are at risk of abuse, neglect, or abandonment may be deemed dependents of the juvenile court and provided services, supports, and interventions aimed at protecting them and their health and safety. The system aims to preserve and strengthen families by maintaining or reuniting children with their parents whenever appropriate; in some cases, in order to bolster the possibility of reunification, the court will order the parent or guardian to participate in services or programs intended to help them overcome the conditions that led to the child being declared a dependent of the juvenile court. Existing law also states that a child cannot be found to be a dependent child simply because of indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare. Instead, there must be harm or a substantial risk of harm to the child and a nexus between the parent’s action, or failure to act, and the harm to the child. Poverty, by itself, is not a reason to make a child a dependent of the juvenile court.
Current law does not specifically address whether the court needs to inquire about the parent’s ability to pay for a court-ordered services or programs. The law also does not clarify whether a parent can be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for the service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian.
This bill is intended to fill that gap, by clarifying that a court must inquire about a parent or guardian’s ability to pay for court-ordered programs or services in the first instance, and that a court may not, at review hearings, deem a parent noncompliant with the case plan if the parent failed to participate in services and programs that they could not afford or would cause an undue financial hardship. The bill also establishes that a parent is presumed to be unable to pay for a court-ordered service if they qualify for the services of a court-appointed attorney on financial grounds. Recent amendments to the bill clarify that a parent or guardian may be deemed noncompliant if the social worker provided a parent or guardian with a comparable free service that was accessible and available to them and they nevertheless failed to participate. The author has agreed to a minor amendment to clarify the reference to court-appointed counsel.
This bill is sponsored by Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., and is supported by A New Way of Life Reentry Project, the Alliance for Children’s Rights, the National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter, Public Counsel, and the Seneca Family of Agencies. There is no known opposition. If this Committee passes this bill, it will be heard by the Senate Human Services Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the juvenile court, which is intended to provide for the protection and safety of the public and minors falling under its jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 202, 245.)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from the custody of their parent or guardian[1] on the basis of enumerated forms of abuse or neglect. (Welf. Inst. Code, § 300(a)-(j).)
- Provides that the purpose of the juvenile court and the dependency system is to provide the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of that harm. This safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being may include provision of a full array of social and health services to help the child and family and to prevent the reabuse of children. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 300.2.)
- Requires, following the removal of a child from their parent’s custody, the juvenile court to hold an initial hearing at which the court determines whether custody may be resumed or what services should be offered to the parent that could facilitate the child’s return in the future.
- The court must make a determination on the record as to whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal of the child from their home, and whether there are available services that would prevent the need for further detention.
- In determining whether to return a child to the parent’s custody at this stage, the fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of substantial danger. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 311, 319.)
- Permits, in lieu of keeping a child out of their parent’s custody, a child to remain in the physical custody of their parent while still a dependent of the juvenile court and under the supervision of a social worker. If the court determines that the child can be returned to their parent’s custody through the provision of remedial services and rehabilitation programs, the court shall order those services or programs to be provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 319.)
- Authorizes a court, where a child has been adjudged a dependent of the court, to make any reasonable orders to the child’s parent directing them to participate in services or programs, such as child welfare services, counseling, parenting programs, or a financial evaluation. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 362.)
- Provides that, when a child has determined to be a dependent of the juvenile court, the court must hold periodic review hearings no less frequently than six months, starting six months after the initial dispositional hearing.
- For children three years of age and older and out of their parent’s custody, the court must return the child to their parent’s custody unless it finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.
- If the child was under three years of age at the date of removal is a member of a sibling group as specified, and the court determines the parent has not been participating and making progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a permanency hearing within 120 days. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366, 366.21(e).)
- If a child is a dependent of the juvenile court but remains in their parent’s custody, the court must hold six-months hearings to determine whether the family has made progress in eliminating the conditions or factors requiring court supervision. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 364.)
- Provides that, for a child who remains out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 7), the court may hold a permanency hearing no later than 12 months after the initial removal; the court may also continue the permanency hearing for up to two more six-month periods, so that the permanency hearing may be held, at a maximum, 24 months after the child was initially removed. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(f), (g), 366.22, 366.25.)
- Requires a court, at review and permanency hearings, to consider a parent’s efforts or progress in overcoming the factors that led to dependency jurisdiction, including whether and to what extent the parent availed themselves of services provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25.)
This bill:
- Requires a juvenile court, when ordering a parent to participate in services or programs to eliminate the conditions that led to the juvenile court’s jurisdiction, to inquire whether the parent can afford the court-ordered services or programs.
- Provides that, at a hearing where a parent’s participation in court-ordered services or programs is at issue (e.g., a reunification hearing or parental rights termination hearing), a juvenile court shall not deem a parent noncompliant with the order to seek services or programs if the court finds that:
- The parent is unable to pay for a service or payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent, and
- The social worker did not provide a comparable free service that was accessible and available to the parent to comply with the case plan during the period subject to the court’s review.
- Establishes that a parent who qualifies for the services of court-appointed counsel in the juvenile court is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services for purposes of the court’s review under 2).
COMMENTS
- Author’s comment
According to the author:
Today, families are being separated or kept separated based solely on the parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services—even if the parent is complying with all other aspects of their case plan. This practice punishes poor families, the majority of whom are Black or Brown. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases costs of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families. This bill will ensure that a parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services is not a barrier to reunifying with their children and will no longer unnecessarily extend the time children remain away from their families.
2. Background on the child welfare process and the effect of a parent’s failure to participate in court-ordered services or programs
The overarching goal of dependency proceedings is to safeguard the welfare of California’s children.[2] Welfare and Institutions Code section 300 sets forth the circumstances that can bring a child within the jurisdiction of the juvenile dependency court. “ ‘Although the harm or risk of harm to the child [for jurisdictional purposes] must generally be the result of an act, omission or inability of one of the parents or guardians, the central focus of dependency jurisdiction is clearly on the child rather than the parent.’ ”[3]
When a child is found to be under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, the court is determined to be a dependent of that court and the court may begin proceedings to remove the child from the custody of their parent(s); if, after a series of hearings, a parent is found to be unfit, the court can terminate the parent’s parental rights.[4] The overarching inquiry is whether the child would suffer, or is likely to suffer, harm if they remain with their parent. Alternatively, a court may return a child to their parent’s custody but retain jurisdiction and place the parent under the supervision of a social worker; in such cases, the court holds hearings at six-month intervals to determine whether the parent has improved enough to terminate jurisdiction, but may remove the child from their parent’s custody if circumstances deteriorate.[5]
In both circumstances—when a child is a dependent of the juvenile court in their parent’s custody or out of it—the juvenile court is authorized to make any reasonable orders to the child’s parent directing them to participate in services or programs that may help the parent improve the circumstances that led to juvenile court jurisdiction.[6] Court-ordered services and programs can include an array of subject matters, including child welfare services, counseling, parenting programs, or financial evaluations.[7] A parent’s failure to participate, or make progress, in the court-ordered services and programs will be considered by the court in its review hearings determining whether to return or remove a child from their parent’s custody or to terminate parental rights.[8]
Unfortunately, as the author and sponsors report, parents are not always able to participate in the court-ordered services due to cost barriers. Current law does not require the court, as part of its order for a parent to participate in programs or services, to determine if the parent can actually afford those programs or services. As the Alliance for Children’s Rights, writing in support, explains:
The overwhelming majority of parents in this system are indigent, without access to reliable transportation, and without funds to pay for court-ordered services. Yet, the Welfare and Institutions Code does not have safeguards to ensure that these families are able to participate in services without footing the bill.
In Los Angeles County, for instance, parents must pay for their court-ordered programs, even if they do not have the financial means to afford the services ordered. While health insurance covers some services, many parents are uninsured, and even for those who are, classes still require exorbitant out-of-pocket fees. Inability to pay limits a parent’s ability to follow the court’s order and get into a class that does not interfere with their work, school and childcare or visitation. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases the cost of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families.
3. This bill prohibits a court from determining that a parent was noncompliant with a court order to obtain services or participate in programs if there were no affordable services or programs available to the parent
This bill is another entry in a series of bills intended to prevent the dependency system from penalizing parents for their economic conditions and conflating poverty with neglect.[9] Specifically, this bill requires a juvenile court to inquire about a parent’s financial circumstances when ordering that a parent participate in services or programs as part of a dependency case plan, and then prohibits a court from deeming a parent noncompliant if the parent could not, without creating financial hardship, afford the ordered classes and services.
Recent amendments to the bill, in response to stakeholder concerns, make clear that a parent can be deemed noncompliant if the social worker provided the parent with a comparable, available free service and the parent failed to take advantage of the free service. This will allow the court to distinguish between parents who are truly noncompliant and those for whom compliance was not feasible. Finally, the bill creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court-appointed attorney in the juvenile court proceedings due to their inability to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service. The author has agreed to amend the bill to replace the reference to “the services of the public defender” with “the services of court-appointed counsel” to conform the bill more precisely with the provision for court-appointed counsel in dependency cases.
SUPPORT
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. (sponsor)
A New Way of Life Reentry Project
Alliance for Children’s Rights
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
Public Counsel
Seneca Family of Agencies
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 578 (Ashby, 2023) requires a social worker to report on, and a juvenile court to consider, the potential harms to a child when considering whether to remove a child from their parent or guardian’s custody. SB 578 is pending before the Assembly Judiciary Committee and is set to be heard on the same date as this bill.
SB 463 (Wahab, 2023) eliminates the evidentiary presumption in juvenile court that a parent or guardian’s lack of participation or progress in a treatment program endangers the child, for purposes of determining whether the child should be returned to the parent or guardian’s custody. SB 463 is pending before the Assembly Human Services Committee.
AB 937 (McKinnor, 2023) clarifies that the court must specify its factual basis for its conclusion that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian if the court extends reunification services on that basis. The bill also requires the court to extend reunification services for an additional 6 months if the court determines at the 18-month permanency hearing that reasonable services have not been provided. The bill is pending before this Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1085 (Kamlager, Ch. 832, Stats. 2022) prohibited a child from being found to be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court on that basis solely due to indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty.
AB 2866 (Cunningham, Ch. 165, Stats. 2022) modified the standard of proof for establishing at a review hearing that a parent or guardian whose child has been removed from their physical custody was offered reasonable reunification services, by raising the standard to the clear and convincing evidence standard, in order to make the standard of proof consistent with the clear and convincing evidence standard already in place for permanent placement hearings.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 63, Noes 2)
Assembly Human Services Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 0)
**************
Going forward, this analysis uses “parent” to include “guardian.” ↑
In re Josiah Z. (2005) 36 Cal.4th 664, 673. ↑
In re R.T., 3 Cal.5th 622, 626. ↑
See Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 360, 361.3, 366.26. ↑
Id., §§ 319, 364. ↑
Id., § 362. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Id., §§ 364, 366.21, 366.22, 366.25. ↑
See the “Prior legislation” section of this analysis. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 954
Author:(Bryan)
As Amended Ver:March 22, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Clarifies that a parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian.
Major Provisions
- Requires a court, when making reasonable orders related to dependency proceedings, to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services ordered by the court.
- Provides that at any review hearing where a parent or guardian's participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian.
- Establishes a presumption, for purposes of 2), above, that a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender to represent them in a dependency matter is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
- Makes findings regarding costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation.
COMMENTS
This bill, sponsored by Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, seeks to require a court to consider the parent's financial circumstances when ordering the parent to participate in fee-based court services. It also prohibits a court, for purposes of court decisions related to the reunification of a parent with a child who has been removed from their home, from considering a parent to be non-compliant with a court order to participate in reunification services when there is evidence that the parent was not able to pay for such a service. Finally, it creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court appointed public defender because they cannot afford to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service.
Overview of child welfare services and juvenile dependency court. Children who are at risk of abuse, neglect, or abandonment may be deemed dependents of the juvenile court and provided services, supports and interventions aimed at protecting them and their health and safety. The system aims to preserve and strengthen families by maintaining or reuniting children with their parents whenever appropriate.
The dependency process begins when child abuse, neglect, or abandonment is reported to the local child welfare agency. A social worker with the child welfare agency investigates the allegation to determine if the child requires protection in order to ensure their safety. If so, the child welfare agency files a petition with the juvenile court to make the child a dependent of the court. If necessary, the social worker will remove the child from their home and take the child into protective custody.
At the subsequent court hearing, the court may elect to keep the child in, or return the child to, their home or remove the child from the home. Removal may either result in eventual reunification with the family, or the court may determine that an alternate permanent placement –including the options of guardianship or adoption – is more fitting. When reunification is not possible or appropriate, children are placed in the setting deemed least restrictive and most suitable; the court must give preference to potential placements with relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Throughout this system, there are multiple court hearings – including the detention hearing, the jurisdictional hearing and the dispositional hearing, followed by ongoing review hearings and the permanency hearing – where the custody of a child or their placement is evaluated, reviewed, and determined by the court, in consultation with the child's social worker appointed by the county and the child's attorney, to help provide the best possible support and services to the child.
A child cannot be found to be a dependent child simply because of indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare, cannot, by themselves, establish jurisdiction over a child. Instead, there must be harm or a substantial risk of harm to the child and a nexus between the parent's action, or failure to act, and the harm to the child.
Simply being poor or unhoused, in and of itself, does not allow a juvenile court to take dependency jurisdiction over the child. The courts have further held that "poverty alone, even abject poverty resulting in homelessness, is not a valid basis for assertion of juvenile court jurisdiction." (In re G.S.R. (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1212.) "Put differently, indigency, by itself, does not make one an unfit parent and "'judges [and] social workers … have an obligation to guard against the influence of class and life style biases.'" (Ibid. [citations omitted].) However, if there are additional reasons, being homeless could be part of the reason that a child is made a dependent of the juvenile court.
Therefore, under current law, it is expected that when the child welfare agency discovers a family struggling with poverty that they will work to connect the family with supports and services to help the family better support their children, rather than bringing the family into the dependency system or even removing the children simply because the family is poor.
Reunification services. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family, and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child's parents. If the child is under the age of three, these reunification services are offered for a period of six months. If the child is over the age of three, the services are offered for twelve months. In some circumstances, the time period for reunification services can be extended up to 24 months.
However not all children can safely be reunited with their families. The Welfare & Institutions Code allows judges to forgo reunification services when the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that one of 17 specific situations that involve danger to the child exist. Generally, in these cases, the parent's or guardian's behavior is such that denial of services is necessary in order to protect children from further harm. These instances include when the parent is suffering from a mental disability that renders the parent incapable of using the reunification services; the parent caused the death of another child through abuse or neglect; the child was conceived as the result of rape or incest with a minor and the parent seeking services committed the rape or incest; the child or a sibling had previously been adjudicated a dependent as the result of physical or sexual abuse and the child is now being removed due to additional physical or sexual abuse; and the parent has been convicted of a violent felony.
Despite the significant progress on these issues of economic justice in the child dependency system as the result of SB 1085, among other measures, more reforms are necessary to remove financial barriers facing low-income parents, particularly in the area of reunification services. According to the author:
The majority of parents whose kids are in the foster care system are Black or Brown and extremely poor. Data shows that a third of parents whose children are in foster care have an annual income of less than $10,000. When the court denies parents reunification services or terminates their parental rights purely because the parents haven't completed a class that they cannot afford, the court is punishing poverty.
This bill seeks to make a similar clarification in the law in relation to reunification services similar to the clarification made pursuant to last year's SB 1085 concerning removal of a child from the custody of their parent or guardian. It clarifies that a parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian. Finally, the bill creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court appointed public defender because they cannot afford to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service. These provisions should advance access to justice and help facilitate the ability of low-income families to participate in court-ordered services and ultimately to be reunited. As the author astutely observes, "This bill will reduce barriers to reunifying families and give poor parents the opportunity to say that they cannot complete court-ordered programs because they cannot afford it, or have completed the programs but cannot afford to pay for the certificate of completion."
According to the Author
Today, families are being separated or kept separated based solely on the parent's inability to pay for court-ordered services – even if the parent is complying with all other aspects of their case plan. This practice punishes poor families, the majority of whom are Black or Brown. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases costs of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families. This bill will ensure that a parent's inability to pay for court-ordered services is not a barrier to reunifying with their children and will no longer unnecessarily extend the time children remain away from their families.
Arguments in Support
Sponsor Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. write the following about why the bill is necessary and important:
When a child is removed from a parent's care, in most cases, the court orders the parent into a variety of programs to assist in rehabilitation before the child can be returned. The overwhelming majority of parents in this system are indigent, without access to reliable transportation, and without funds to pay for court-ordered services. Yet, the Welfare and Institution Code (WIC) does not have safeguards to ensure that these families are able to participate in services without footing the bill.
. . . [P]arents must pay for their court-ordered programs, even if they do not have the financial means to afford the services ordered. While health insurance covers some services, many parents are uninsured, and even for those who are, classes still require exorbitant out-of-pocket fees. Inability to pay limits a parent's ability to follow the court's orders and get into a class that does not interfere with their work, school and childcare or visitation. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases the cost of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families.
AB 954 seeks to amend WIC to ensure that a parent's inability to pay for court-ordered services no longer remains a barrier to participating in services in order to reunify with their children or keep their children in their care.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-0-3
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 5-0-3
YES: Jackson, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Garcia
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Alanis, Bonta
UPDATED
VERSION: March 22, 2023
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000210
Date of Hearing: April 18, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Corey A. Jackson, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 954 (
Author:Bryan) – As Amended Ver:March 22, 2023
SUBJECT: Dependency: court-ordered services
SUMMARY: Prohibits a parent or guardian’s participation in court-ordered child welfare services from being considered to be noncompliant when there is evidence they are unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the court, when making reasonable orders to parents or guardians to participate in court-ordered child welfare services, to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
- Prohibits, at a review hearing where the court is considering the parent or guardian’s participation in reunification or family maintenance, the parent or guardian from being considered to be noncompliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence they are unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for the parent or guardian.
- Specifies, for purposes of these provisions, that a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender is to be presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the juvenile court with jurisdiction over children who are subject to abuse or neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section [WIC] 300 et seq)
- States that the purpose of juvenile dependency law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected, or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. Provides that the focus must be on the preservation of the family as well as the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of the child. (WIC 300.2)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from their parent or guardian if the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted non-accidentally upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian. (WIC 300(a))
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from their parent or guardian if the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of the failure or inability of the child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child, or the willful or negligent failure of the child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child from the conduct of the custodian with whom the child has been left, or by the willful or negligent failure of the parent or guardian to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment, or by the inability of the parent or guardian to provide regular care for the child due to the parent’s or guardian’s mental illness, developmental disability, or substance abuse. Provides that, notwithstanding these factors, a child does not become a dependent of the juvenile court solely due to the lack of emergency shelter for the family or the failure of the child’s parent or alleged parent to seek court orders for custody of the child. (WIC 300(b))
- Provides for additional conditions that would lead to jurisdiction over a dependent child, including for a child who is suffering serious emotional damage, or is at substantial risk of suffering serious emotional damage, as a result of the conduct of the parent or guardian or who has no parent or guardian capable of providing appropriate care; and has been sexually abused, or there is a substantial risk that the child will be sexually abused, by the child’s parent or guardian or a member of the child’s household, or the parent or guardian has failed to adequately protect the child from sexual abuse when the parent or guardian knew or reasonably should have known that the child was in danger of sexual abuse. (WIC 300(c)-(j))
- Requires the court, if at the initial hearing, the juvenile court orders a child removed from their parent due to abuse or neglect, to order that child welfare reunification services be provided to the family as soon as possible in order to reunify the child with their family, if appropriate. (WIC 319(e))
- Requires a social worker, whenever the social worker has cause to believe that there was or is within the county a person described in WIC 300, to immediately make any investigation they deem necessary to determine whether child welfare services should be offered to the family and whether proceedings in the juvenile court should be commenced. Further, requires the social worker, if they determine that it is appropriate to offer child welfare services to the family, to make a referral to those services. (WIC 328(a))
- Requires the court, at the dispositional hearing, to order a social worker to provide child welfare services to a child who has been removed from their parents' custody and to the parents in order to support the goal of reunification, for a specified time period, except under certain circumstances. Provides that children and families in the child welfare system should typically receive a full six months of reunification services if the child is under three years of age, and twelve months if the child is over three years of age, but that may be extended up to 18 or 24 months, as provided. (WIC 361.5(a))
- Authorizes the court, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by WIC 300, to make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court. (WIC 362(a))
- Authorizes the court, when it appears to the court that a parent or guardian of the child desires counsel but is presently financially unable to afford and cannot for that reason employ counsel, the court to appoint counsel, as provided. (WIC 317(a))
- Authorizes the court, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court on the ground that the child is a person described by WIC 300, to make any and all reasonable orders for the care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the child, including medical treatment, subject to further order of the court. (WIC 362(a))
- Authorizes the court, at any time after a petition has been filed, to join in the juvenile court proceedings, any agency that the court determines has failed to meet a legal obligation to provide services to a child for whom a petition has been filed under WIC 300, regardless of the status of the adjudication. (WIC 362(b)(1))
- Defines “nonminor dependent” or NMD, to mean, a foster child who is a current dependent or ward of the juvenile court, or who is a nonminor under the transition jurisdiction of the juvenile court, and who satisfies all of the following criteria:
- The youth has turned 18 years old while under an order of foster care placement by the juvenile court, and is not more than 21 years old;
- The youth is in foster care under the placement and care responsibility of the county welfare department, county probation department, Indian tribe, consortium of tribes, or tribal organization that entered into an agreement as described; and,
- The youth has a transitional independent living case plan. (WIC 11400(v))
- Defines “agency” to mean any governmental agency or any private service provider or individual that receives federal, state, or local governmental funding or reimbursement for providing services directly to a child, nonminor, or NMD. (WIC 362(b)(3))
- Provides that the court has no authority to order services unless it has been determined that the child, nonminor, or NMD is eligible for those services. Limits, with respect to mental health assessment, treatment, and case management services, as defined, the court’s determination to whether the agency has complied with these provisions. (WIC 362(b)(2))
- Requires, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, on the ground that the child is a person described by Section 300, and the court orders that a parent or guardian shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents or guardians to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court. (WIC 362(c))
- Permits the juvenile court to direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings as the court deems necessary and proper. Permits that order to include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. Authorizes a foster parent or relative with whom the child is placed to be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the child’s best interest. Requires the program in which a parent or guardian is required to participate to be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the court’s finding that the child is a person described by WIC 300. (WIC 362(d))
- Authorizes the juvenile court, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, to direct any reasonable orders to the parents or guardians of the child who is the subject of any proceedings to ensure the child’s regular school attendance and to make reasonable efforts to obtain educational services necessary to meet the specific needs of the child. (WIC 362(e))
- Requires every hearing in which an order is made placing a child under the supervision of the juvenile court pursuant to WIC 300, and in which the child is not removed from the physical custody of their parent or guardian, to be continued to a specific future date not to exceed six months after the date of the original dispositional hearing. (WIC 364(a))
- Requires a permanency hearing to be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care and requires the court, at the permanency hearing, to determine the permanent plan for the child, which shall include a determination of whether the child will be returned to the child’s home and, if so, when, within specified time limits. Requires the court, after considering the relevant and admissible evidence, to order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. Requires the social worker to have the burden of establishing that detriment. (WIC 366.21(f))
- Requires the juvenile court, excepting certain specified conditions, if a child is not returned to the parent or guardian at the permanency review hearing, to hold a hearing to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. Requires the court to determine whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. Sets forth examples of circumstances that would not, in or of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide reasonable services. (WIC 366.22(a))
- Requires a court to establish, by clear and convincing evidence, that reasonable reunification services have been provided to the parent prior to ordering a hearing to terminate parental rights. (WIC 366.22(b)(3)(C))
- Authorizes any parent or other person having an interest in a dependent child or NMD who is a dependent child of the juvenile court or an NMD, or the child or the NMD through a properly appointed guardian to, upon grounds of change of circumstance or new evidence, petition the court in the same action in which the child was found to be a dependent child of the juvenile court or in which a guardianship was ordered for a hearing to change, modify, or set aside any order of court previously made or to terminate the jurisdiction of the court. Requires The petition to be verified and, if made by a person other than the child or the NMD, to state the petitioner’s relationship to or interest in the child or NMD and shall set forth in concise language any change of circumstance or new evidence that is alleged to require the change of order or termination of jurisdiction. (WIC 388(a))
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill was keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Background: Child Welfare Services. California’s child welfare services system was established with the goal of protecting youth from abuse and neglect and is designed to provide safety, health, and overall well-being of children. When a child is identified as being at risk of abuse or neglect, reports can be made to either law enforcement or a county child welfare agency. Often, these reports are submitted by mandated reporters who are legally required to report suspicion of child abuse or neglect due to their profession, such as a teacher or healthcare provider. When a mandated reporter submits a report to either law enforcement or the county child welfare agency, a social worker determines whether the allegation is of suspected abuse, neglect, or exploitation, and creates a case plan which includes the provision of relevant services. The child's social worker and the court collaborate to evaluate and review the circumstances of each case, seeking either reunification or placement outside of the home as a way for the child to achieve permanency.
The court will then determine whether the allegations are true and if the child can remain at home. If the court orders a child to be placed outside of the home, the parent usually receives court-ordered family reunification services. Upon completion of the services, in addition to making any changes or improvements described in the case plan, the court may dismiss the child’s court case and the county welfare department case will also be closed. This bill would prohibit the court from deeming a parent noncompliant with the case plan if the reason they did not participate in any court-ordered child welfare services was due to an inability to pay.
California's child welfare services programs are administered by the 58 individual counties with each county organizing and operating its own program of child protection based on local needs while adhering to state and federal regulations. When a child welfare case is open, counties are the primary governmental entity interacting with children and families when addressing issues of child abuse and neglect and are responsible, either directly or through providers, for obtaining or providing the interventions and relevant services to protect children and assist families with issues related to child abuse and neglect.
The California Department of Social Services secures federal funding to support child welfare services programs, provides statewide best practices training for social workers, and conducts program regulatory oversight and administration, and is responsible for the development of policy while also providing direct services such as adoption placements.
As of October 1, 2022, there are 53,371 youth between birth and up to 21 years of age in foster care.
Dependency court procedure. When a child is removed from the custody of their parent, they are temporarily placed within the jurisdiction of the child welfare system until a determination about the child’s welfare is made. Within 48 hours after a child is taken into temporary custody, the county social worker must file a petition with the court requesting that a detention hearing take place in order to determine if further detention of the child is necessary. If a petition to declare the child a dependent of the court is filed by the county social worker, then the detention hearing must be held within 48 hours of the petition being filed. At the detention hearing, the social worker outlines the allegations of abuse or neglect made against the parent and why it is necessary to remove the child from the custody of their parent. If the court determines that removing the child from their parents’ custody is in the best interests of the child, the child is then removed. Permanent placement of the child is determined at a later date.
Once a child has been removed from the custody of their parents, a jurisdictional hearing must take place within 15 days. It is at the jurisdictional hearing that the court determines whether the allegations outlined in the social worker’s petition are true. If the allegations are deemed to be true, then the child is determined to be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court and a dispositional hearing must be held within 60 days of the initial detention hearing in order to determine the permanent placement of the child.
At the dispositional hearing the court determines the parameters of the family reunification plan, which includes where and with whom the child will live, be it with relatives or in a foster family home. The reunification plan also can entail recommendations for parents such as parenting classes, anger management, counseling, substance abuse counseling and testing, sexual abuse counseling, parenting training, and anger management.
Reunification services. When a child is removed from their parents’ custody and it is determined by the courts and in speaking with the child’s social worker that the child would ultimately benefit from being returned or reunited with the family, the court may order reunification services in order to address the underlying issues or needs of the family that led to the child’s removal in the first place. Reunification services include, but are not limited to: family therapy, parenting classes, substance use disorder treatment, respite care, parent support groups, home visiting programs, and services deemed necessary in order to facilitate a child’s reunification with their parents. For children under three years old, current law allows six months of reunification services; and for children over three years old, twelve months of reunification services are to be offered. Extensions of services are available if the court determines that there is substantial probability that a child will return to their parents’ custody within the extended time period.
According to research conducted by The Fines and Fees Justice Center (FFJC), the median cost for a year-long batterers’ intervention program showed that the median cost per class was $25 per week, or $1,300 year. The FFJC study presented data from 83 of the programs in Los Angeles County, including program fees, the presence of sliding scale payment options, and fee waivers, and found that 23% of the programs do not offer a sliding scale options and per class costs range from $15 to $150. Some family preservation and reunification services in Los Angeles County offer classes that charge fees set on a sliding scale that ranges from $30 to $150 per session for individual counseling, and $25 to $60 for group sessions. Research has indicated that the majority of families involved with the child welfare system have incomes below the federal poverty line, are overrepresented by certain racial and ethnic groups, and are often single-parent households living in low-income neighborhoods.
Author’s statement: According to the Author, “Today, families are being separated or kept separated based solely on the parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services—even if the parent is complying with all other aspects of their case plan. This practice punishes poor families, the majority of whom are Black or Brown. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases costs of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families. This bill will ensure that a parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services is not a barrier to reunifying with their children and will no longer unnecessarily extend the time children remain away from their families.”
Need for this bill: The provisions of this bill seek to prohibit the court from deeming parents noncompliant with their case plans solely because they could not afford to pay for the court-ordered child welfare services. This bill would not require counties to pay for court-ordered services, but rather would prohibit a court at a review hearing from finding that a parent or guardian was noncompliant simply due to their inability to pay for a class.
The bill also creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for public defender services is unable to pay for these court-mandated classes. While most counties already pay for court-ordered family maintenance or reunification services, Los Angeles County remains an outlier in requiring parents to foot the bill. According to the author, the cost burden of these services vary by county to county and that San Diego County uses discretionary funds to pay for all court-ordered services.
By denying continued reunification services or terminating parental rights simply for not completing a class they couldn’t afford, parents are being punished for existing in poverty. This bill seeks to reduce barriers to family reunification by giving all parents involved in the child welfare system the same opportunity to complete court-ordered services. While this bill does not provide for a metric to determine a parent’s inability to pay for a service, it does ensure that a parent’s ability to pay for a service will not be a factor in determining reunification.
Equity Impact: According to a March 2023 report published by the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) entitled, “Update on Analysis and Key Questions: Racial and Ethnic Disproportionalities and Disparities in California’s Child Welfare System”, the majority of California families involved with the child welfare system are experiencing poverty. The LAO estimates that in 2022-23, 54% of child welfare-involved families in California have earnings of under $1,000 per month. When the court orders a parent to attend classes to assist in rehabilitation before returning the child to their home, most parents are not be able to pay, in addition to a large number of these parents not having access to reliable transportation. While some of these court-ordered services can be covered through health insurance, for those parents who are uninsured, an additional barrier to reunification has been erected.
The LAO further reports that in California, the populations reflected in foster care are predominantly youth of color, as 21% are Black and 50% are Latino. Further highlighting the disproportionality comprising the foster youth population, the number of Black and Native American youth in foster care is four times larger than the number of the general population of Black and Native American youth in California. The LAO also states that racial disproportionalities and disparities are present within initial allegations and persist at all levels of the system—becoming the most pronounced for youth in care. While the families involved in the child welfare system skew disproportionally toward low-income people of color, this bill would attempt to reduce the devastating effects that poverty has on families who are involved in the child welfare system and trying to reunify their family.
Double referral: This bill passed out of the Assembly Judiciary Committee on March 21, 2023, with an 8-0 vote.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
SB 1085 (Kamlager), Chapter 832, Statutes of 2022, prohibited a child from being found to be a dependent of the juvenile court solely due to: homelessness; indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare. SB 1085 also stated legislative intent that families not be subject to the jurisdiction of the juvenile court nor should children be separated from their parents based on conditions of financial difficulty, including but not limited to a lack of food, clothing, shelter or childcare.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, INC. (Sponsor)
Seneca Family of Agencies
The Alliance for Children's Rights
The Children's Partnership
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Jessica Langtry / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Date of Hearing: March 21, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 954
Author:(Bryan) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2023
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Dependency: court-ordered services
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD A COURT BE REQUIRED TO INQUIRE ABOUT A PARENT OR GUARDIAN’S ABILITY TO PAY FOR A FEE-BASED FAMILY MAINTENANCE OR REUNIFICATION SERVICE PRIOR TO ORDERING THE PARENT OR GUARDIAN TO PARTICIPATE IN SUCH A SERVICE?
- SHOULD A COURT BE PRECLUDED FROM CONSIDERING A PARENT OR GUARDIAN NON-COMPLIANT WITH A COURT ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN A FEE-BASED FAMILY MAINTENANCE OR REUNIFICATION SERVICE WHEN THERE IS EVIDENCE THAT THE PARENT OR GUARDIAN MAY NOT BE ABLE TO PAY FOR THE SERVICE?
SYNOPSIS
Children who are at risk of abuse, neglect, or abandonment may be deemed dependents of the juvenile court and provided services, supports and interventions aimed at protecting them and their health and safety. The system aims to preserve and strengthen families by maintaining or reuniting children with their parents whenever appropriate. There are a number of reasons that a child may be found to be a dependent of the juvenile court, including that the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm as a result of the failure or inability of the parent to adequately supervise or protect the child, or by the willful or negligent failure of the parent to provide the child with adequate food, clothing, shelter, or medical treatment. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 300 (b)(1).) Existing law also states that a child cannot be found to be a dependent child simply because of indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare. Instead, there must be harm or a substantial risk of harm to the child and a nexus between the parent’s action, or failure to act, and the harm to the child. Poverty, by itself, is not a reason to make a child a dependent of the juvenile court.
Existing law does not specifically address whether the court needs to inquire about the parent’s ability to pay for a court-ordered family maintenance or reunification service. The law also does not clarify whether a parent can be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for the service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian. This bill, as proposed to be amended, would make such helpful clarifications to the law. The bill is sponsored by Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers and supported by a number of child advocacy, social justice, religious, and legal organizations. It has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Clarifies that a parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a court, when making reasonable orders related to dependency proceedings, to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services ordered by the court.
- Provides that at any review hearing where a parent or guardian’s participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian.
- Establishes a presumption, for purposes of 2), above, that a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender to represent them in a dependency matter is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
- Makes findings regarding costs already borne by a local agency for programs or levels of service mandated by the 2011 Realignment Legislation.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the juvenile court with jurisdiction over children who are subject to abuse or neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 300 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to the Welfare & Institutions Code.)
- States that the purpose of the juvenile dependency law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected, or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. Provides that the focus must be on the preservation of the family as well as the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of the child. (Section 300.2.)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from their parent or guardian if the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally upon the child by the child’s parent or guardian. (Section 300 (a).)
- Provides that a child shall not be found to be a person described by this subdivision solely due to any of the following:
- Homelessness or the lack of an emergency shelter for the family.
- The failure of the child’s parent or alleged parent to seek court orders for custody of the child.
- Indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty, the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare. (Section 300 (b)(2).)
- Provides other bases for jurisdiction over a dependent child, including for a child who (a) is suffering serious emotional damage, or is at substantial risk of suffering serious emotional damage, as a result of the conduct of the parent or guardian or who has no parent or guardian capable of providing appropriate care; and (b) has been sexually abused, or there is a substantial risk that the child will be sexually abused, by the child’s parent or guardian or a member of the child’s household, or the parent or guardian has failed to adequately protect the child from sexual abuse when the parent or guardian knew or reasonably should have known that the child was in danger of sexual abuse. (Section 300 (c)-(j).)
- Holds, according to case law, that “poverty alone, even abject poverty resulting in homelessness, is not a valid basis for assertion of juvenile court jurisdiction.” (In re G.S.R. (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1212.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, sponsored by Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, seeks to require a court to consider the parent’s financial circumstances when ordering the parent to participate in fee-based court services. It also prohibits a court, for purposes of court decisions related to the reunification of a parent with a child who has been removed from their home, from considering a parent to be non-compliant with a court order to participate in reunification services when there is evidence that the parent was not able to pay for such a service. Finally, it creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court appointed public defender because they cannot afford to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service. According to the author:
Today, families are being separated or kept separated based solely on the parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services—even if the parent is complying with all other aspects of their case plan. This practice punishes poor families, the majority of whom are Black or Brown. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases costs of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families. This bill will ensure that a parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services is not a barrier to reunifying with their children and will no longer unnecessarily extend the time children remain away from their families.
Overview of child welfare services and juvenile dependency court: Children who are at risk of abuse, neglect, or abandonment may be deemed dependents of the juvenile court and provided services, supports and interventions aimed at protecting them and their health and safety. The system aims to preserve and strengthen families by maintaining or reuniting children with their parents whenever appropriate.
The dependency process begins when child abuse, neglect, or abandonment is reported to the local child welfare agency. A social worker with the child welfare agency investigates the allegation to determine if the child requires protection in order to ensure their safety. If so, the child welfare agency files a petition with the juvenile court to make the child a dependent of the court. If necessary, the social worker will remove the child from their home and take the child into protective custody.
At the subsequent court hearing, the court may elect to keep the child in, or return the child to, their home or remove the child from the home. Removal may either result in eventual reunification with the family, or the court may determine that an alternate permanent placement –including the options of guardianship or adoption – is more fitting. When reunification is not possible or appropriate, children are placed in the setting deemed least restrictive and most suitable; the court must give preference to potential placements with relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Throughout this system, there are multiple court hearings – including the detention hearing, the jurisdictional hearing and the dispositional hearing, followed by ongoing review hearings and the permanency hearing – where the custody of a child or their placement is evaluated, reviewed, and determined by the court, in consultation with the child’s social worker appointed by the county and the child's attorney, to help provide the best possible support and services to the child.
As of October 1, 2022, more than 74,500 children were receiving services from county child welfare agencies in California. As of that date (the most recent available), 11,512 children were placed in foster homes. (California Child Welfare Indicators Project, Pont in Time/In Care, available at https://ccwip.berkeley.edu/childwelfare/index/r.)
Specifics on when children are subject to juvenile dependency court jurisdiction. Welfare & Institutions Code Section 300 lists the instances when a juvenile court may determine that a child is a dependent of the court. These instances include that the child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm inflicted non-accidentally by the child’s parent or guardian; the child is suffering serious emotional damage, or is at substantial risk of suffering serious emotional damage, evidenced by severe anxiety, depression, withdrawal, or untoward aggressive behavior toward self or others, as a result of the conduct of the parent or guardian or who has no parent or guardian capable of providing appropriate care; and the child has been sexually abused, or there is a substantial risk that the child will be sexually abused by the parent or guardian or a member of their household, or the parent or guardian has failed to adequately protect the child from sexual abuse when the parent or guardian knew or reasonably should have known that the child was in danger of sexual abuse.
There are specific exceptions to the above provisions. Of particular relevance for this bill, a child cannot be found to be a dependent child simply because of indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare, cannot, by themselves, establish jurisdiction over a child. Instead, there must be harm or a substantial risk of harm to the child and a nexus between the parent’s action, or failure to act, and the harm to the child.
Simply being poor or unhoused, in and of itself, does not allow a juvenile court to take dependency jurisdiction over the child. The courts have further held that “poverty alone, even abject poverty resulting in homelessness, is not a valid basis for assertion of juvenile court jurisdiction.” (In re G.S.R. (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 1202, 1212.) “Put differently, indigency, by itself, does not make one an unfit parent and “’judges [and] social workers … have an obligation to guard against the influence of class and life style biases.’” (Ibid. [citations omitted].) However, if there are additional reasons, being homeless could be part of the reason that a child is made a dependent of the juvenile court.
Therefore, under current law, it is expected that when the child welfare agency discovers a family struggling with poverty that they will work to connect the family with supports and services to help the family better support their children, rather than bringing the family into the dependency system or even removing the children simply because the family is poor.
Last year’s SB 1085 further clarified this point that poverty alone is not a basis for dependency court jurisdiction. Prior to January 1st of this year, Section 300 (b) stated a child cannot be found to be a dependent child simply because the child’s family lacks emergency shelter. SB 1085 added additional conditions related to financial stress which also cannot be the sole basis for dependency jurisdiction. Therefore, subdivision (b) of Section 300 now specifies that a child shall not be found to be a person described by this subdivision solely due to any of the following:
- Homelessness or the lack of an emergency shelter for the family.
- The failure of the child’s parent or alleged parent to seek court orders for custody of the child.
- Indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty, the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare.
SB 1085 also set forth legislative intent to clarify that it is harm to the child, not poverty, that can result in dependency court jurisdiction. The bill stated the intent of the Legislature that:
- Families should not be subject to the jurisdiction of the juvenile court nor should children be separated from their parents based on conditions of financial difficulty, including but not limited to a lack of food, clothing, shelter or childcare.
- Instead, reasonable services to prevent juvenile court intervention or children being separated from their parents should be attempted, which must include services to alleviate a potential risk to a child based on conditions of financial difficulty, including but not limited to referrals to community-based organizations.
- Consistent with existing law, no family should be subject to the jurisdiction of the juvenile court nor should children be separated from their parents based on conditions of financial difficulty unless there is willful or negligent action or failure to act and a nexus to harm such that the child has suffered or there is a substantial risk the child will suffer serious physical harm or illness.
These statements make clear the Legislature’s intent that it is the harm to the child – or the risk of the harm – that implicated dependency court jurisdiction, not lack of resources. This legislative intent language should help inform courts and social workers about the need to support families struggling with poverty, and not rush to juvenile court jurisdiction and potential removal of children when children are not being harmed or at risk of serious harm.
Reunification services. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family, and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child’s parents. If the child is under the age of three, these reunification services are offered for a period of six months. If the child is over the age of three, the services are offered for twelve months. In some circumstances, the time period for reunification services can be extended up to 24 months.
However not all children can safely be reunited with their families. The Welfare & Institutions Code allows judges to forgo reunification services when the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that one of 17 specific situations that involve danger to the child exist. Generally, in these cases, the parent's or guardian's behavior is such that denial of services is necessary in order to protect children from further harm. (Section 361.5 (b).) These instances include when the parent is suffering from a mental disability that renders the parent incapable of using the reunification services; the parent caused the death of another child through abuse or neglect; the child was conceived as the result of rape or incest with a minor and the parent seeking services committed the rape or incest; the child or a sibling had previously been adjudicated a dependent as the result of physical or sexual abuse and the child is now being removed due to additional physical or sexual abuse; and the parent has been convicted of a violent felony.
Despite the significant progress on these issues of economic justice in the child dependency system as the result of SB 1085, among other measures, more reforms are necessary to remove financial barriers facing low-income parents, particularly in the area of reunification services. According to the author:
The majority of parents whose kids are in the foster care system are Black or Brown and extremely poor. Data shows that a third of parents whose children are in foster care have an annual income of less than $10,000. When the court denies parents reunification services or terminates their parental rights purely because the parents haven’t completed a class that they cannot afford, the court is punishing poverty.
This bill seeks to make a similar clarification in the law in relation to reunification services similar to the clarification made pursuant to last year’s SB 1085 concerning removal of a child from the custody of their parent or guardian. It clarifies that a parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a court-ordered service, or when payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian. Finally, the bill creates a presumption that a parent who qualifies for the services of a court appointed public defender because they cannot afford to pay for a private attorney also cannot afford to pay for a fee-based family maintenance or reunification service. These provisions should advance access to justice and help facilitate the ability of low-income families to participate in court-ordered services and ultimately to be reunited. As the author astutely observes, “This bill will reduce barriers to reunifying families and give poor parents the opportunity to say that they cannot complete court-ordered programs because they cannot afford it, or have completed the programs but cannot afford to pay for the certificate of completion.”
Author’s amendments. The bill in print seeks to address the impact of poverty on both the removal of a child from the home of their parent our guardian, as well as the ability to participate in fee-based court-ordered services, succinctly stating that, “A parent’s inability to pay for any court-ordered services shall not be a barrier to reunification or a basis for removal.” However, the bill’s current language may not be as specific as it needs to be.
First, it is unclear, under the wording of the bill in print, what a “barrier” is. When that term is used in the current law, it generally describes a personal hardship of an individual being able to access public services (See Section 11325.95 [“... multiple barriers to employment, and integrating service delivery ...”].) Second, in terms of being a “basis for removal” of a child from a parent’s home, the law is already fairly clear that poverty cannot be the sole basis for removing a child from a home (see discussion of SB 1085, above).
However, current law could and should be far more clear that a parent or guardian’s poverty cannot be the basis for finding them non-compliant with court orders to complete family maintenance or reunification services when those services require payment of a fee that the parent or guardian cannot afford. In order to further clarify this point, the author proposes the following amendments:
- Strike out Section 1 of the bill.
- Amend Section 362 to add a new subdivision (f):
(f) When making reasonable orders under this Section, the court shall inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford the court-ordered services.
- Add Section 362.8 to the Welfare and Institutions Code to read as follows:
- 362.8.
- At any review hearing where a parent or guardian’s participation in reunification or family maintenance services is considered by the court, including but not limited to hearings pursuant to Sections 364, 366.21(e), 366.21(f), 266.22, 366.25, and 388, the parent or guardian shall not be considered to be non-compliant with the court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent or guardian is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship to the parent or guardian.
- For purposes of this section, a parent or guardian who qualifies for the services of the public defender pursuant to WIC 317 is presumed to be unable to pay the cost of court-ordered services.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Sponsor Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. write the following about why the bill is necessary and important:
When a child is removed from a parent’s care, in most cases, the court orders the parent into a variety of programs to assist in rehabilitation before the child can be returned. The overwhelming majority of parents in this system are indigent, without access to reliable transportation, and without funds to pay for court-ordered services. Yet, the Welfare and Institution Code (WIC) does not have safeguards to ensure that these families are able to participate in services without footing the bill.
. . . [P]arents must pay for their court-ordered programs, even if they do not have the financial means to afford the services ordered. While health insurance covers some services, many parents are uninsured, and even for those who are, classes still require exorbitant out-of-pocket fees. Inability to pay limits a parent’s ability to follow the court’s orders and get into a class that does not interfere with their work, school and childcare or visitation. Delayed reunification traumatizes children, increases the cost of foster care and supervision, and adds further financial and emotional stress on families.
AB 954 seeks to amend WIC to ensure that a parent’s inability to pay for court-ordered services no longer remains a barrier to participating in services in order to reunify with their children or keep their children in their care.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
All of Us or None of Us, Orange County
California Catholic Conference
California Public Defenders Association
East Bay Family Defenders
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
Movement for Family Power
Public Counsel
The Alliance for Children's Rights
The Law Offices of Dale Wilson
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Human Services
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):