AB 996: Elections: recounts.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Existing law establishes procedures by which a voter may request a recount of the votes cast in an election following completion of the official canvass. Under existing law, the voter or the campaign committee represented by the voter seeking the recount must, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, deposit with the elections official the amount of money required to cover the cost of the recount for that day.
This bill would require any committee that provides a deposit to cover the cost of the recount, including a committee that is registered only with the Federal Election Commission, to identify the source of any contribution to that committee of at least $10,000 that is received during the period of the week before the recount beginning with election day and continuing through a week after the recount ends. The bill would require an elections official, within 24 hours of receipt, to publish this information on the officials internet website, except as specified.
(2)Existing law authorizes the Governor or Secretary of State, as applicable, to, within a specified time frame, order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office if, among other things, the official canvass of returns in a statewide general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.015% of the number of all votes cast for that office.
This bill would require the Governor or Secretary of State, as applicable, Governor, within a specified time frame, to order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for Governor, State Senator, Member of the Assembly, Member of the United States Senate, or Member of the United States House of Representative if either 1) the official canvass of returns for a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.25% of the number of all votes cast for that office, or 2) the official canvass of returns for a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.25% of the number of all votes cast for that office. The bill would require the recount to be conducted by means of the voting system originally used to cast or tabulate the votes subject to recount. The bill would authorize the Secretary of State to request, as part of the recount, an examination of specific categories of relevant materials, as defined, and it would permit specified interested parties to be present during the examination.
By expanding the duties of county elections officials with respect to conducting recounts, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes procedures by which a voter may request a recount of the votes cast in an election following completion of the official canvass. Under existing law, the voter or the campaign committee represented by the voter seeking the recount must, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, deposit with the elections official the amount of money required to cover the cost of the recount for that day.
This bill would require any committee that provides a deposit to cover the cost of the recount, including a committee that is registered only with the Federal Election Commission, to identify the source of any contribution to that committee of at least $10,000 that is received during the period of the week before the recount and continuing through a week after the recount ends.
(2)Existing law authorizes the Governor or Secretary of State, as applicable, to, within a specified time frame, order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office if, among other things, the official canvass of returns in a statewide general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.015% of the number of all votes cast for that office.
This bill would require the Governor or Secretary of State, as applicable, within a specified time frame, to order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for Governor, State Senator, Member of the Assembly, Member of the United States Senate, or Member of the United States House of Representative if either 1) the official canvass of returns for a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the lesser greater of 25 votes or 0.25% of the number of all votes cast for that office, or 2) the official canvass of returns for a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the lesser greater of 25 votes or 0.25% of the number of all votes cast for that office.
By expanding the duties of county elections officials with respect to conducting recounts, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law establishes procedures by which a voter may request a recount of the votes cast in an election following completion of the official canvass. Under existing law, the voter or the campaign committee represented by the voter seeking the recount must, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, deposit with the elections official the amount of money required to cover the cost of the recount for that day.
This bill would require any committee that provides a deposit to cover the cost of the recount, including a committee that is registered only with the Federal Election Commission, to identify the source of any contribution to that committee of at least $10,000 that is received during the period of the week before the recount and continuing through a week after the recount ends.
(2)Existing law authorizes the Governor or Secretary of State, as applicable, to, within a specified time frame, order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office if, among other things, the official canvass of returns in a statewide general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.015% of the number of all votes cast for that office.
This bill would require the Governor or Secretary of State, as applicable, within a specified time frame, to order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for Governor, State Senator, Member of the Assembly, Member of the United States Senate, or Member of the United States House of Representative if either 1) the official canvass of returns for a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the lesser of 25 votes or 0.25% of the number of all votes cast for that office, or 2) the official canvass of returns for a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the lesser of 25 votes or 0.25% of the number of all votes cast for that office.
By expanding the duties of county elections officials with respect to conducting recounts, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of professions and vocations by entities within the Department of Consumer Affairs. Under existing law, several of these entities may require licensees to satisfy continuing education course requirements, including, among others, licensed physicians and surgeons licensed by the Medical Board of California and certified public accountants and public accountants licensed by the California Board of Accountancy.This bill would require those entities to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that, at minimum, discourages the qualification of any continuing education course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course and requires conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each continuing education course.Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of professions and vocations by entities within the Department of Consumer Affairs. Under existing law, several of these entities may require licensees to satisfy continuing education course requirements, including, among others, licensed physicians and surgeons licensed by the Medical Board of California and certified public accountants and public accountants licensed by the California Board of Accountancy.
This bill would require those entities to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that, at minimum, discourages the qualification of any continuing education course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course. course and requires conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each continuing education course.
Existing law provides for the licensure and regulation of professions and vocations by entities within the Department of Consumer Affairs. Under existing law, several of these entities may require licensees to satisfy continuing education course requirements, including, among others, licensed physicians and surgeons licensed by the Medical Board of California and certified public accountants and public accountants licensed by the California Board of Accountancy.
This bill would require those entities to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that, at minimum, discourages the qualification of any continuing education course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course.
(a)(1)This section applies to any committee, including a committee registered only with the Federal Election Commission, that provides the daily deposit or part of the daily deposit for a voter-requested recount.
(2)This section shall apply in either of the following cases:
(A)The committee provides the deposit directly to the elections official.
(B)The committee provides the funds to another person or another committee to pay the deposit.
(b)For any contribution of at least $10,000 ten thousand dollars ($10,000) received by the committee during the period consisting of one week before the recount begins beginning with election day and continuing through one week after the recount ends, the committee shall report the following information to the elections official to whom the deposit was provided:
(1)Contributors name.
(2)Contributors street address.
(3)Contributors occupation, if any.
(4)Contributors employer, if any, or if self-employed, the name of the business.
(5)The date and amount received for each contribution of at least $10,000. ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
(6)Multiple contributions from a single source that total at least $10,000 ten thousand dollars ($10,000) and that are received during the period described in this subdivision. The contributions shall be reported within 24 hours of receipt of the contribution that causes the total amount to equal at least $10,000. ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
(c)The committee shall use reasonable efforts to verify whether the contributor is the true source of the contribution or an intermediary. If the contributor is an intermediary, the committee shall use reasonable efforts to identify and disclose the information described in subdivision (b) for the individual, committee, or other entity that is the true source of the contribution.
(d)Within 24 hours of receipt of the information described in subdivision (b), the elections official shall publish the information on their internet website. website, except the following information shall be omitted or redacted:
(1)Contributors street, building, or unit number.
(2)Contributors street name.
(e)The requirements imposed by this section are in addition to any other requirements imposed on elections officials and committees under applicable federal and state law.
SEC. 2.Section 15645 of the Elections Code is amended to read:15645.(a)(1)Within five days after the Secretary of State files a statement of the vote, as required by subdivision (b) of Section 15501, the Governor may order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office or state ballot measure if any of the following occurs, except as provided in paragraph (4): (3):
(A)The official canvass of returns in a statewide primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates for a statewide office is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office except as provided in paragraph (3). (2).
(B)The official canvass of returns in a statewide general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes for a statewide office is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(C)The official canvass of returns in a statewide election shows that the difference in the number of votes cast for and against a state ballot measure is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast on the measure.
(2)(A)Within five days after the Secretary of State files a statement of the vote, as required by subdivision (b) of Section 15501, the Governor shall order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for State Senator, Member of the Assembly, Member of the United States Senate, or Member of the United States House of Representatives, if either of the following occurs:(i)The official canvass of returns in a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.(ii)The official canvass of returns in a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.(B)If the conditions set forth in subparagraph (A) are satisfied with respect to the number of votes cast for the office of Governor, the Secretary of State, but not the Governor, shall order a state-funded manual recount pursuant to this paragraph.(3)(2)The Governor shall not order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction pursuant to this section unless the official canvass of returns in a statewide primary election shows either of the following:
(A)The number of votes received by the candidate receiving the greatest number of votes was either of the following:
(i)Between 0.49985 and 0.50015, inclusive, of the number of all votes cast.
(ii)Within 1,000 votes of 50 percent of the number of all votes cast.
(B)No candidate for the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction received votes on a majority of all the ballots cast for candidates for that office and the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates for that office was less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(4)(3)If the conditions set forth in paragraph (1) are satisfied with respect to the number of votes cast for the office of Governor, the Secretary of State, but not the Governor, may order a state-funded manual recount pursuant to this section.
(5)(4)For purposes of this subdivision, statewide office means the office of Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Attorney General, Controller, Insurance Commissioner, Secretary of State, Superintendent of Public Instruction, Treasurer, or Member of the United States Senate.
(b)(1)Within five days following the completion of the official canvass, or if an election is conducted in more than one county, within five days beginning on the 31st day after the election, the Governor shall order a state-funded recount of all votes cast for State Senator, Member of the Assembly, or Member of the United States House of Representatives, if either of the following occurs:
(A)The official canvass of returns in a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(B)The official canvass of returns in a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(2)The recount shall be conducted by means of the voting system originally used to cast or tabulate the votes subject to recount. Only one method of recount shall be used for all ballots cast or tabulated by the same type of voting system.
(3)(A)Before the recounting of ballots commences, the Secretary of State may submit a written request to the elections official to examine specific categories of relevant materials as part of the recount.
(B)The elections official shall produce any relevant materials requested.
(C)The elections official shall communicate any request to examine relevant materials to each interested party. Any interested party may be present during the examination of relevant materials.
(D)For purposes of this paragraph, the following terms have the following meanings:
(i)Interested party means any person identified in Section 15628.
(ii)Relevant materials includes unvoted ballots, vote by mail and provisional ballot envelopes, voting system redundant vote data, ballot definition files, language translation files and the central database or other electronic repository of results for the election in which the contest subject to recount occurred, election data media devices, audit logs, system logs, pre- and post-election logic and accuracy testing plans and results, polling place event logs, precinct tally results, central count tally results and consolidated results in a structured, non-proprietary format, surveillance video recordings and chain of custody logs, including logs of security seals and access to election-related storage areas.
(b)(c)If a state-funded recount is conducted pursuant to this section, no other recount shall be conducted.
(c)The State shall reimburse counties for costs resulting from conducting a manual recount pursuant to this section in an expeditious manner upon certification of those costs.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)This section applies to any committee, including a committee registered only with the Federal Election Commission, that provides the daily deposit or part of the daily deposit for a voter-requested recount.
(2)This section shall apply in either of the following cases:
(A)The committee provides the deposit directly to the elections official.
(B)The committee provides the funds to another person or another committee to pay the deposit.
(b)For any contribution of at least $10,000 received by the committee during the period consisting of one week before the recount begins and continuing through one week after the recount ends, the committee shall report the following information to the elections official to whom the deposit was provided:
(1)Contributors name.
(2)Contributors street address.
(3)Contributors occupation, if any.
(4)Contributors employer, if any, or if self-employed, the name of the business.
(5)The date and amount received for each contribution of at least $10,000.
(6)Multiple contributions from a single source that total at least $10,000 and that are received during the period described in this subdivision. The contributions shall be reported within 24 hours of receipt of the contribution that causes the total amount to equal at least $10,000.
(c)The committee shall use reasonable efforts to verify whether the contributor is the true source of the contribution or an intermediary. If the contributor is an intermediary, the committee shall use reasonable efforts to identify and disclose the information described in subdivision (b) for the individual, committee, or other entity that is the true source of the contribution.
(d)Within 24 hours of receipt of the information described in subdivision (b), the elections official shall publish the information on their internet website.
(e)The requirements imposed by this section are in addition to any other requirements imposed on elections officials and committees under applicable federal and state law.
SEC. 2.Section 15645 of the Elections Code is amended to read:15645.(a)(1)Within five days after the Secretary of State files a statement of the vote, as required by subdivision (b) of Section 15501, the Governor may order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office or state ballot measure if any of the following occurs, except as provided in paragraph (4):
(A)The official canvass of returns in a statewide primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates for a statewide office is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office except as provided in paragraph (3).
(B)The official canvass of returns in a statewide general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes for a statewide office is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(C)The official canvass of returns in a statewide election shows that the difference in the number of votes cast for and against a state ballot measure is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast on the measure.
(2)(A)Within five days after the Secretary of State files a statement of the vote, as required by subdivision (b) of Section 15501, the Governor shall order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for State Senator, Member of the Assembly, Member of the United States Senate, or Member of the United States House of Representatives, if either of the following occurs:
(i)The official canvass of returns in a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the lesser greater of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(ii)The official canvass of returns in a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the lesser greater of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(B)If the conditions set forth in subparagraph (A) are satisfied with respect to the number of votes cast for the office of Governor, the Secretary of State, but not the Governor, shall order a state-funded manual recount pursuant to this paragraph.
(3)The Governor shall not order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction pursuant to this section unless the official canvass of returns in a statewide primary election shows either of the following:
(A)The number of votes received by the candidate receiving the greatest number of votes was either of the following:
(i)Between 0.49985 and 0.50015, inclusive, of the number of all votes cast.
(ii)Within 1,000 votes of 50 percent of the number of all votes cast.
(B)No candidate for the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction received votes on a majority of all the ballots cast for candidates for that office and the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates for that office was less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(4)If the conditions set forth in paragraph (1) are satisfied with respect to the number of votes cast for the office of Governor, the Secretary of State, but not the Governor, may order a state-funded manual recount pursuant to this section.
(5)For purposes of this subdivision, statewide office means the office of Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Attorney General, Controller, Insurance Commissioner, Secretary of State, Superintendent of Public Instruction, Treasurer, or Member of the United States Senate.
(b)If a state-funded recount is conducted pursuant to this section, no other recount shall be conducted.
(c)The State shall reimburse counties for costs resulting from conducting a manual recount pursuant to this section in an expeditious manner upon certification of those costs.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)This section applies to any committee, including a committee registered only with the Federal Election Commission, that provides the daily deposit or part of the daily deposit for a voter-requested recount.
(2)This section shall apply in either of the following cases:
(A)The committee provides the deposit directly to the elections official.
(B)The committee provides the funds to another person or another committee to pay the deposit.
(b)For any contribution of at least $10,000 received by the committee during the period consisting of one week before the recount begins and continuing through one week after the recount ends, the committee shall report the following information to the elections official to whom the deposit was provided:
(1)Contributors name.
(2)Contributors street address.
(3)Contributors occupation, if any.
(4)Contributors employer, if any, or if self-employed, the name of the business.
(5)The date and amount received for each contribution of at least $10,000.
(6)Multiple contributions from a single source that total at least $10,000 and that are received during the period described in this subdivision. The contributions shall be reported within 24 hours of receipt of the contribution that causes the total amount to equal at least $10,000.
(c)The committee shall use reasonable efforts to verify whether the contributor is the true source of the contribution or an intermediary. If the contributor is an intermediary, the committee shall use reasonable efforts to identify and disclose the information described in subdivision (b) for the individual, committee, or other entity that is the true source of the contribution.
(d)Within 24 hours of receipt of the information described in subdivision (b), the elections official shall publish the information on their internet website.
(e)The requirements imposed by this section are in addition to any other requirements imposed on elections officials and committees under applicable federal and state law.
SEC. 2.Section 15645 of the Elections Code is amended to read:15645.(a)(1)Within five days after the Secretary of State files a statement of the vote, as required by subdivision (b) of Section 15501, the Governor may order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office or state ballot measure if any of the following occurs, except as provided in paragraph (3): (4):
(A)The official canvass of returns in a statewide primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates for a statewide office is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office except as provided in paragraph (2). (3).
(B)The official canvass of returns in a statewide general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes for a statewide office is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(C)The official canvass of returns in a statewide election shows that the difference in the number of votes cast for and against a state ballot measure is less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast on the measure.
(2)(A)Within five days after the Secretary of State files a statement of the vote, as required by subdivision (b) of Section 15501, the Governor shall order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for State Senator, Member of the Assembly, Member of the United States Senate, or Member of the United States House of Representatives, if either of the following occurs:
(i)The official canvass of returns in a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the lesser of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(ii)The official canvass of returns in a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the lesser of 25 votes or 0.0025 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(B)If the conditions set forth in subparagraph (A) are satisfied with respect to the number of votes cast for the office of Governor, the Secretary of State, but not the Governor, shall order a state-funded manual recount pursuant to this paragraph.
(2)(3)The Governor shall not order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction pursuant to this section unless the official canvass of returns in a statewide primary election shows either of the following:
(A)The number of votes received by the candidate receiving the greatest number of votes was either of the following:
(i)Between 0.49985 and 0.50015, inclusive, of the number of all votes cast.
(ii)Within 1,000 votes of 50 percent of the number of all votes cast.
(B)No candidate for the office of Superintendent of Public Instruction received votes on a majority of all the ballots cast for candidates for that office and the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates for that office was less than or equal to the lesser of 1,000 votes or 0.00015 of the number of all votes cast for that office.
(3)(4)If the conditions set forth in paragraph (1) are satisfied with respect to the number of votes cast for the office of Governor, the Secretary of State, but not the Governor, may order a state-funded manual recount pursuant to this section.
(4)(5)For purposes of this subdivision, statewide office means the office of Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Attorney General, Controller, Insurance Commissioner, Secretary of State, Superintendent of Public Instruction, Treasurer, or Member of the United States Senate.
(b)If a state-funded recount is conducted pursuant to this section, no other recount shall be conducted.
(c)The State shall reimburse counties for costs resulting from conducting a manual recount pursuant to this section in an expeditious manner upon certification of those costs.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.Section 36 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:36.(a)Any entity listed in Section 101 that is responsible for approving continuing education providers or courses shall develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy in accordance with subdivision (b).(b)The conflict-of-interest policy required by this section shall, at a minimum, do both of the following:(1)Discourage the qualification of any continuing education course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course.(2)Require conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each continuing education course.(a)Any entity listed in Section 101 that is responsible for approving continuing education providers or courses shall develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy in accordance with subdivision (b).
(b)The conflict-of-interest policy required by this section shall, at a minimum, discourage do both of the following:
(1)Discourage the qualification of any continuing education course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course.
(2)Require conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each continuing education course.
(a)Any entity listed in Section 101 that is responsible for approving continuing education providers or courses shall develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy in accordance with subdivision (b).
(b)The conflict-of-interest policy required by this section shall, at a minimum, discourage the qualification of any continuing education course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 17, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Jun 13, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Jun 13, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(c). |
| Jun 11, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 10, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 6, 2024 | From inactive file. |
| Jun 6, 2024 | Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 17, 2023 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Roth. |
| Jul 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 3, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 12, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 7, 2023 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E. D. |
| May 26, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 25, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 1742.) |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (May 17). |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (April 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 28, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 28, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 23, 2023 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 18. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2023 | AB 996 Low Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 17, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Board of Psychology | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 996 (Low) - Elections: recounts
Version: July 3, 2024 | Policy Vote: E. & C.A. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 5, 2024 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
AB 996 would (1) require public disclosure of certain contributions made to support a voter-requested recount effort, and (2) create a mandatory state-funded recount for Congressional, State Senate, and State Assembly races.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Secretary of State (SOS) indicates that this bill would not have a fiscal impact.
- By expanding the duties of county elections officials with respect to conducting recounts, this bill creates a state-mandated local program. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines that the provisions of this bill create a new program or impose a higher level of service on local agencies, local agencies could claim reimbursement of those costs. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially in excess of $50,000 annually (General Fund).
- As detailed below, this bill would result in a state-funded recount when specified conditions are met. The frequency of such a recount occurring is likely to be rare. However, recount costs, to the extent they occur, could reach the tens of millions of dollars per episode (General Fund).
Background:
Under current state election law, there is no provision for an automatic recount, but any voter can request one if they are willing to pay for it. The March 2024 Primary Election saw two candidates finish in a tie for second place in Congressional District (CD) 16. A voter requested a recount and paid the estimated $24,000 a day required by elections officials for a machine recount of the ballots cast in the election. According to news reports, the voter’s costs were being financed by a political action committee (PAC), a fact that came to light as a result of federal disclosure requirements. The total spent on the recount reportedly was $360,000.
Proposed Law:
This bill would do the following:
Campaign Contribution Disclosures:
- Require any committee that provides a deposit to cover the cost of the recount, including a committee that is registered only with the Federal Election Commission, to identify the source of any contribution to that committee of at least $10,000 that is received during the period beginning with election day and continuing through a week after the recount ends.
- Require an elections official, within 24 hours of receipt, to publish this information on the official’s internet website, except as specified.
Recounts:
- Require the Governor, within a specified time frame, to order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for State Senator, Member of the Assembly, or Member of the United States House of Representative if either (1) the official canvass of returns for a primary election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the second and third place candidates is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.25 percent of the number of all votes cast for that office, or (2) the official canvass of returns for a general election shows that the difference in the number of votes received by the two candidates receiving the greatest number of votes is less than the greater of 25 votes or 0.25 percent of the number of all votes cast for that office.
- Require the recount to be conducted by means of the voting system originally used to cast or tabulate the votes subject to recount.
- Authorize SOS to request, as part of the recount, an examination of specific categories of relevant materials, as defined, and it would permit specified interested parties to be present during the examination.
Staff Comments:
The cost of a recount will vary based on a number of different factors, including (1) the number of ballots cast, (2) the technology used to conduct the recount, (3) the number of people employed to conduct a hand recount, (4) the amount of other materials a recount requestor may want to examine, (5) how and where the county elections official stores the ballots and the complexity associated with retrieving them, and (6) whether any accommodations – staffing, space, furniture, etc. – need to be made to ensure the recount can be viewed by the interested parties who, by law, have a right to observe the process. Available information indicates that the cost of a hand recount can be two to four times as expensive as a machine recount – and can take significantly longer.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Catherine Blakespear, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: 996 Hearing Date: 7/2/24
Author: | Low | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
DIGEST
This bill requires public disclosure of certain contributions made to support a voter-requested recount effort. Separately, the bill creates a mandatory state-funded recount for United States (U.S.) Senate, Congressional, State Senate, and State Assembly races.
ANALYSIS
Existing law related to campaign contribution disclosures:
- Imposes numerous pre- and post-election campaign finance reporting requirements on candidates, committees supporting candidates, committees supporting and opposing ballot measures, and others.
- Requires, for state offices and ballot measures, contributions totaling $1,000 made within 90 days of an election to be reported to the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) within 24 hours. Requires this information to be posted online for the public to see, though certain information is required to be redacted.
- Does not impose any 24-hour reporting requirements on post-election contributions.
Existing law related to election recounts:
- Allows the Governor – within five days of the Secretary of State (SOS) certifying the election results (which is 38 days after the election) – to order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast for a statewide office (except for Governor and Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI)) or a state ballot measure if:
- In a primary election, the vote difference between the second and third place candidates (or for and against a ballot measure) is 1,000 or fewer votes or less than 0.015% of the number of all votes cast for that office; and
- In a general election, the vote difference between the top two vote getters (or for and against a ballot measure) is 1,000 or fewer votes or less than 0.015% of the number of all votes cast for that office.
- Sets different triggers for allowing the Governor to call a recount for SPI.
- Permits the SOS, instead of the Governor, to order a state-funded manual recount in a race for Governor.
- Allows any voter to request and pay for a recount pursuant to the following rules:
- The request must be made within five days of the elections official certifying their results and in the case of a statewide election, the request must be made of the SOS;
- The requestor can ask to examine “relevant materials,” such as vote-by-mail (VBM) ballots and envelopes, provisional ballots, and other materials prior to any ballots actually being recounted;
- The requestor can specify the precincts they want recounted, the order they want them recounted in, and they can halt the recount at any time;
- The requestor must, each day, pay to the elections official’s office the amount of money the official states is needed to cover the daily cost of the recount; and
- An election result can only be overturned once the entire jurisdiction has been recounted.
This bill, as it relates to campaign contribution disclosures:
- Requires any committee, even one registered solely with the Federal Election Commission, that provides any part of a daily deposit for a voter-requested recount to:
- Disclose any contributions totaling $10,000 or more received during the period of one week before a recount begins and one week after the recount ends. The disclosure must be provided to the elections official where the recount is taking place and must include:
- The contributor’s name;
- The contributor’s street address;
- The contributor’s occupation, if any;
- The contributor’s employer, if any, or if self-employed, the name of the business; and
- The date and amount received for each contribution of at least $10,000.
- Report the contributions to the elections official within 24 hours of receipt.
- Use reasonable efforts to verify whether the contributor is the true source of the contribution or an intermediary. If the contributor is an intermediary, the committee shall use reasonable efforts to identify and disclose the information noted above for the true source of the contribution.
- Requires the elections official to publish the contribution information on their website within 24 hours of receiving it.
This bill, as it relates to recounts:
- Requires the Governor – within five days of the SOS certifying the election results (the SOS has up to 38 days after Election Day to certify the results) – to order a state-funded manual recount of all votes cast in a race for State Senate, State Assembly, U.S. Senate, or U.S. House if:
- In a primary election, the difference in votes between the second and third place candidates is 25 or fewer votes or less than 0.25% of all votes cast for that office; or
- In a general election, the difference in votes between the top two vote getters is 25 or fewer votes or less than 0.25% of all votes cast for that office.
BACKGROUND
Congressional District 16. The March 5, 2024, Primary Election saw two candidates – State Assemblyman Evan Low and Santa Clara County Supervisor Joe Simitian – finish in a tie for second place in the race for Congressional District (CD) 16.
CD 16 covers portions of Santa Clara and San Mateo counties and under California law, while there is no provision for an automatic recount, any voter can request a recount provided they are willing to pay for it. In this case, a voter named Jonathan Padilla requested the recount and paid the estimated $24,000 a day required by elections officials for a machine recount of the ballots cast in the election.
According to news reports, while Mr. Padilla may have been paying elections officials to cover the cost of the recount, his costs were being financed by a political action committee (PAC) called Count The Vote, a fact that came to light due to federal disclosure requirements that apply to PACs. The total spent on the recount was, according to news reports, approximately $360,000.
During the recount, Santa Clara County awarded 11 additional votes to Assemblymember Low and 7 additional votes to Supervisor Simitian, while San Mateo County awarded 1 additional vote to Assemblyman Low and 0 additional votes to Supervisor Simitian. As a result, Assemblymember Low will advance to the November 5, 2024, General Election.
Not Just A Recount – It Could Also Change What Is Actually Counted. The term “election recount” is, in a sense, a bit of a misnomer because it can be inferred to mean a voter can only request a recount – by machine or by hand – of solely those ballots counted on Election Day and during the canvass process.
The reality is, a person requesting a recount can also ask to examine “relevant materials” to the election. This includes VBM ballots that were not included in the final tally for reasons such as:
- The signature on the VBM envelope did not match the voter’s signature on file;
- There was no signature on the envelope;
- The ballot arrived after the deadline; or
- The postmark on the ballot envelope did not clearly indicate it was mailed on or before Election Day.
Other “relevant materials” can include provisional ballots that may have been rejected due to signature-related issues or ballots from first-time voters who may not have provided the required identification.
A recount requestor can challenge an election officials’ decision not to include those ballots in the official tally and if the requestor wins the challenge, the ballot is included in the recount.
Following the recount in CD 16, a press release from San Mateo County noted:
“…the requestor of the recount asked to review relevant materials including ballot envelopes that were not counted due to late arrival, signature mismatch, or missing signatures. [O]f the 586 ballot envelopes reviewed, 28 were challenged by the requestor. Of those 28 challenged ballots, 12 related to signature verification and 16 related to postmark issues. The challenged ballot process resulted in 21 challenges that were rejected and 7 were accepted.”
As a result, 7 ballots that hadn’t been counted during San Mateo County’s canvass process could be counted during the recount.
A press release from Santa Clara County issued following the CD 16 recount noted:
- 45 uncounted ballots were challenged and 7 were accepted for inclusion in the recount;
- 19 uncounted ballots were identified as being erroneously excluded during the canvass, so they were included in the recount; and
- 3 ballots were identified as having been double-counted, so they were subtracted during the recount.
As a result, a net of 23 ballots that hadn’t been counted during Santa Clara County’s canvass process could be counted during the recount.
Machine Counting vs. Hand Counting -- Accuracy. Numerous studies – in voting and in other fields, such as banking and in the retail sector – have concluded that people counting by hand make far more errors counting than machines do, especially when counting larger and larger numbers:
- In one New Hampshire study conducted by MIT, poll workers who counted ballots by hand were off by 8%, while the error rate for machine counted ballots ran at 0.5%;
- Rice University conducted a study in which people were tasked with counting just two races on 120 ballots. The participants accurately counted the results of the two races only 58% of the time; and
- According to the Voting Rights Lab, officials in Nye County, Nevada, hand counted all the ballots in a 2022 election and experienced an error rate as high as 25%.
Stephen Ansolabehere, a professor of government at Harvard University who has conducted research on hand-counts, said that in his studies, “Machine counting is generally twice as accurate as hand-counting and a much simpler and faster process.”
Machine Counting vs. Hand Counting – Cost. The cost of a recount will vary based on a number of different factors, including:
- The number of ballots cast;
- The technology used to conduct the recount (if it’s a machine recount);
- The number of people employed to conduct a hand recount;
- The amount of other materials a recount requestor may want to examine;
- How and where the county elections official stores the ballots and the complexity associated with retrieving them; and
- Whether any accommodations – staffing, space, furniture, etc. – need to be made to ensure the recount can be viewed by the interested parties who, by law, have a right to observe the process.
Based on a number of published reports and some information provided by California county elections officials, the cost of a hand recount can be two to four times as expensive as a machine recount – and can take significantly longer.
As noted earlier, media reports put the total cost of the machine recount in CD 16 at approximately $360,000. Each of the two counties (San Mateo and Santa Clara) involved in the recount charged the requestor $12,000 per day to conduct the recount.
COMMENTS
- According to the Author: “AB 996 will enhance election integrity and transparency in California by mandating recounts in close elections and disclosing significant contributions to recounts. Our goal is to ensure full public transparency of the recount process and improve political processes and laws to foster transparency and confidence in our elections.”
- Privacy Concerns. This bill requires that when anyone makes contributions totaling $10,000 or more, the committee receiving the contribution must report to the elections official the contributor’s name, street address, occupation (if any), employer (if any), and if self-employed, the name of the business. The elections official is then required to post this information on their website
This same information must be reported now when people make contributions of $1,000 or more to candidates or committees 90 days before an election – however, the law requires the SOS to redact the person’s street address and building number (if applicable) before posting this information online. The Committee may wish to consider requiring the elections official to redact the filings mandated by this measure in the same manner.
- Seven Days, Before & After. The bill requires the disclosure of contributions over $10,000 to be made beginning seven days before a voter-requested recount begins, during the recount period, and for seven days after a recount has concluded. It also ties the start of a recount to within five days of when the SOS certifies the vote – which is generally 38 days after Election Day. As such, it is possible to envision a scenario where someone could decide 30 days after an election, but 8 days before a recount could be requested, to donate $10,000 or more toward a potential recount without triggering the disclosure requirements under this bill.
As such, the Committee may wish to consider whether the trigger for this type of disclosure should be earlier in the process, perhaps as early as Election Day.
- Avoiding Disclosure. When it comes to drawing a line of demarcation – especially in the world of campaign contribution disclosures – it’s virtually impossible to draw a line that can’t be avoided.
For example, under current law, contributions made to candidates and committees of $1,000 or more within 90 days of an election must be reported within 24 hours. Anyone wanting to avoid having to make such a report would simply ask people to donate $999 to their campaigns.
The same issue exists here – someone wanting to skirt disclosure would simply have to ensure they don’t donate more than $9,999 in the aggregate.
It should be pointed out though that given the high cost of a recount – approximately $360,000 in the case of the CD 16 recount – it would take 36 different people donating $9,999 each to avoid disclosure.
Also worthy of note is under the law, a candidate may accept contributions after the election to pay for net debts outstanding, which is defined in FPPC regulations to include “Legal fees and expenses incurred directly in connection with monitoring the count of absentee or provisional ballots for the election, or with a ballot recount conducted for the election.”
Put another way, a candidate can accept contributions to their existing campaign account following an election to pay for a recount, among other things, but that information would not be disclosed until the candidate files a post-election spending report, which could be several months after the election and recount are concluded.
- Hand Count vs. Machine Count. As noted in the “Background” section, numerous studies show machines, not humans, are more reliable when it comes to completing repetitive tasks such as counting. Furthermore, based on data provided by some of California’s county elections officials, counting ballots by hand is exponentially more expensive.
As such, the Committee may wish to consider whether the bill should mandate a state-funded machine recount, not a hand recount.
Furthermore, the Committee may wish to consider whether in a state-funded recount mandated by this bill, someone should be permitted to examine any of the “relevant materials,” such as VBM ballots envelopes, to see if any ballots that were not included in the original count should be included in any recount. As the bill is drafted now, those relevant materials could not be examined as part of a state-mandated recount – only the ballots that were counted originally could be recounted.
- Calling Off A Recount. Under current law, when a voter requests and pays for a recount, they can call it off at any time and simply accept the results of the election. It’s not uncommon for a voter to, for example, test the waters by paying just to examine the “relevant materials” to see if they believe any ballots that were rejected should have been counted. Or to count a handful of precincts to see if any votes do change, which may lead them to pay to count more precincts.
This bill does not have any provision to allow for a state-mandated manual recount to be called off, regardless of how it may be proceeding. On the other hand, it’s not clear who should be given that authority and if provisions need to be included to prevent that power from being mis-used.
- Is The 0.25% Trigger Too High? The bill triggers an automatic state-funded manual recount in cases where the top two vote getters (in a general election) or second and third place finishers (in a primary election) are within 25 votes or 0.25% of the votes cast for that office, whichever is greater. Here are some examples where, had this measure been law at the time, a state-funded recount would have been required:
- March 2024, CD 16. There were 182,188 votes cast for the office. Given 0.25% of 182,188 is just over 455, if this bill were law, an automatic recount would have been triggered if the second and third place finishers were within up to 455 votes of one another. As noted in the background, the second and third place finishers were tied and following an examination of relevant materials (VBM envelopes, etc.) and a machine recount, 19 votes were awarded between the two candidates (12 to Assemblyman Low and 7 to Supervisor Simitian).
- November 2022, Senate District 16. There were 136,898 votes cast in this two-person general election contest between Senator Melissa Hurtado and challenger David Shepard. Given 0.25% of 136,898 is just over 342, if this bill were law, an automatic recount would have been triggered if the difference between the two candidates was 342 or fewer votes,. Candidate Shepard, who was trailing by 31 votes after the election was certified, did file and pay for a recount. The final margin of victory for Senator Hurtado was officially 22 votes, though it’s not clear from news reports whether any of those numbers changed solely due to the ballots being recounted or from the inclusion of ballots that were not included in the original tally.
- March 2020, Senate District 25. There were 187,168 votes cast in this primary election race, meaning if this bill were law, an automatic recount would have been triggered if the second and third place finishers were 467 or fewer votes apart. The second and third place finishers – two write-in candidates – were 141 votes apart.
- March 2020, Assembly District 21. There were 55,543 votes cast in this primary election race, meaning if this bill were law, an automatic recount would have been triggered if the second and third place finishers were 138 or fewer votes apart. The second and third place finishers – two write-in candidates – were 44 votes apart, so an automatic recount would have been triggered had this bill been law in 2020.
- March 2020, Assembly District 13. There were 75,438 votes cast in this primary election race, meaning if this bill were law, an automatic recount would have been triggered if the second and third place finishers were 188 or fewer votes apart. The second and third place finishers were 30 votes apart.
There is certainly no obvious or “magic” number when it comes to deciding when a mandatory recount should be triggered. Current law sets the trigger for when the Governor (or the SOS, if the race in question is for Governor) may (but is not required to) call for a recount for a statewide race at 0.015%. For comparison purposes, in the 2022 General Election race for California Governor, there were 10,933,018 votes cast, meaning had the top two vote getters been within 1,639 of each other, the SOS would have had the option to call for a state-mandated hand recount.
The 0.25% number in this bill is modeled on an ordinance in Santa Clara County, which since 2018, has had a mandatory manual recount requirement for all contests (excluding state and federal races) contained solely within the county. For countywide races or citywide races in San Jose, a machine or a manual recount must be conducted. In a November 2022 general election for County Supervisor District 1, 109,506 ballots were cast, meaning an automatic manual recount would have been triggered it the top two vote getters were within 273 votes of each other. There was no recount in this race.
- Technically – And More – Speaking. There are a number of amendments that aren’t exactly “technical,” yet fall short of being truly “substantive” the Committee may wish to ask the author to adopt. They are:
- Page 4, Line 22, applies the bill’s automatic recount provisions – and higher triggering percentage – to the state’s U.S. Senate seats. This U.S. Senate seat is already covered in current law by the optional recount – and lower triggering percentage – rules that apply to all statewide races (except the race for SPI). The Committee may wish to delete this bill’s application to the state’s U.S. Senate seats.
- Page 4, Lines 18-23, trigger a mandatory, state-funded recount if a race for State Senate, State Assembly, U.S. Senate, and U.S. House is within a certain margin. However, that recount couldn’t be triggered until up to five days after the SOS certifies the statewide vote – something the SOS has 38 days after Election Day to do.
This mirrors the provision in current law that refers to statewide races, which makes sense because the SOS must receive and review the canvass reports from 58 counties before certifying a statewide election. However, given this new section applies only to district races, it may be more logical – and timely – to use a trigger similar to the one in Elections Code section 15620, which allows a voter to request a recount five days after a county (in a race contained in a single county) has finished its official canvass. As such, the Committee may wish to consider replacing the language in the bill with language similar to what is found in Elections Code section 15620.
- Page 4, Lines 33-36, require the SOS to order a statewide recount in a race for Governor in certain cases. This is somewhat duplicative of current law (found on Page 5, Lines 15-18 of the bill) and refers to a code section to which it could never apply. The Committee may wish to delete the section added by this bill.
- Move Page 4, Lines 18-32, to Page 5, Line 32, so the new district-related recount provisions added by this bill are placed below all of the provisions of existing law related solely to statewide recounts and re-letter the remaining provisions in this section accordingly.
PRIOR ACTIONS
The prior Assembly votes on this measure are not relevant to the current version of the bill.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: None received
Oppose: None received
-- END --
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 996 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 996
Author: Low (D)
Amended: 3/27/23 in Assembly
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 11-0, 6/19/23
AYES: Roth, Nguyen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Dodd, Glazer, Niello, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wahab, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Becker, Eggman
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/25/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Department of Consumer Affairs: continuing education: conflict-of-interest policy
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires any entity responsible for approving continuing education (CE) providers or courses to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that discourages the qualification of a CE course if the course provider has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in the course and requires conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each CE course.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the DCA within the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 100)
- Defines “board” as also inclusive of “bureau,” “commission,” “committee,” “department,” “division,” “examining committee,” “program,” and “agency.” (BPC § 22)
- Provides that all boards, bureaus, and commissions within the DCA are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities which have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. (BPC § 101.6)
This bill requires any entity responsible for approving CE providers or courses to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that discourages the qualification of a CE course if the course provider has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in the course and requires conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each CE course.
Background
Numerous practice acts governing the licensing, regulation, and oversight of professionals within the jurisdiction of the DCA require licensees to continue their education and training as a condition of continuing their licensure. Statutes and regulations dictate how many hours of CE a licensee must complete over a certain number of years. While CE requirements can often be fulfilled through a wide variety of courses, some professionals must fulfill more complete more specific course content in order to renew a license.
CE providers and courses are approved to count toward professional requirements different ways depending on the practice act. For example, the Professional Fiduciaries Bureau is responsible for approving CE providers for its licensees, and the Bureau also reviews and approves specific CE courses. The Dental Board of California (DBC) is tasked with approving providers of CE for dental professionals; however, excluding mandatory courses, the DBC does not individually approve specific courses offered by approved registered providers. The California State Board of Pharmacy (BOP) is not responsible for approving CE providers or courses, and relies entirely on two accreditation agencies.
Over the past several years, questions have been raised during the review of various boards under the DCA through the sunset process relating to the potential for conflicts-of-interest in CE courses. This type of conflict would typically occur when the provider or author of a CE course has a pecuniary interest in its topic. For example, a company that manufactures and sells a specific medical device would arguably have a conflict of interest if they are sponsoring a CE course that teaches health professionals about the availability and merit of that device. While perhaps there is some value to licensees learning about the device, there should be some basic awareness as to whether the content of the CE course is motivated in part by the company’s concern for profitability.
While this bill would not expressly prohibit any particular CE course or content, it would require each entity under the DCA that plays a role in approving CE to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy. A number of private accrediting associations and organizations already maintain a similar policy. Each policy would, at a minimum, be required to discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course. Any conflicts would also be required to be disclosed at the beginning of each course.
Comments
The Respiratory Care Board of California states that “While the intent of AB 996 is understood, members of the Board felt the bill sends an unfair message that a provider with a financial interest in a particular product is somehow less ethical. Members agreed that so long as a provider’s interest is disclosed, licensees should not be deterred from CE opportunities due to a perception it is unscrupulous. This is especially significant considering in the healthcare arena representatives of medical device and pharmaceutical companies are often the most qualified experts to educate practitioners regarding their products.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 7/5/23)
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 7/5/23)
Board of Psychology
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Board of Psychology opposes this bill, noting that “the organizations which approve continuing education providers and courses in psychology operate independently of the Board other than their regulatory specification as qualified to approve providers and offerings. As the Board does not approve the course offerings, it could not effectively monitor individual courses or offerings for any such conflict of interest. Thankfully, the primary organizations upon which we rely, including the American Psychological Association and the California Psychological Association, have established their own standards as to, among other things, conflicts of interest of continuing education speakers or providers and the required disclosure to attendees.” According to the Board, “unlike other disciplines, the continuing education courses most useful to licensees are often provided by the authors or publishers of the relevant materials. For example, when a new or revised assessment instrument or test is released to the market, the person or persons most capable of speaking to the validity and reliability of the test, the appropriate method for administration, scoring, and interpretation, or its use with historically underrepresented groups are those who authored or developed the assessment instrument or test. Similarly, when a theorist, scientist, or researcher is one of the primary presenters in a continuing education course, they will often offer for sale a published work which further illuminates or explains the subject under discussion, offerings that the Board’s licensees have submitted help them to better understand and implement the subject of the course. Unlike some other healthcare disciplines, psychology does not find itself unnecessarily influenced by the types of conflicts of interest that arise when major industrial concerns, such as pharmaceutical companies or medical device makers, exert undue influence over the continuing education available to licensees.” The Board advises that “the proposed language would be difficult to implement given that it does not approve continuing education offerings. Further, it does not provide adequate guidance as to how the policy could be developed or enforced given the nature of continuing education in psychology. Licensees have expressed their concern that were all of the continuing education courses vetted based on the complete absence of any economic interest on the part of presenters or providers, the remaining course offerings might be insufficient to allow them to effectively satisfy the requirements for Continuing Professional Development, without taking courses not relevant to their practices.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/25/23
AYES: Addis, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Aguiar-Curry, Mathis
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
7/5/23 14:55:42
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 19, 2023
Author: | |||
Version: | March 27, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY:
Requires any entity responsible for approving CE providers or courses to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that discourages the qualification of a CE course if the course provider has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in the course and requires conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each continuing education course.
Existing law:
- Establishes the DCA within the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 100)
- Defines “board” as also inclusive of “bureau,” “commission,” “committee,” “department,” “division,” “examining committee,” “program,” and “agency.” (BPC § 22)
- Provides that all boards, bureaus, and commissions within the DCA are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities which have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. (BPC § 101.6)
This bill requires any entity responsible for approving CE providers or courses to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy that discourages the qualification of a CE course if the course provider has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in the course and requires conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each continuing education course.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, the bill will result in minor and absorbable costs to the impacted DCA boards and bureaus.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “While continuing education can be a valuable tool to help ensure that California's licensed professionals continue to provide high-quality services to their patients and clients that reflect the current standards of their profession, there may be times where that education has an ulterior financial motive for the course provider. AB 996 will require regulatory boards to take steps to prevent sales pitches from masquerading as education courses by requiring each board to have a conflict-of-interest policy in place and requiring any potential conflicts to be disclosed to licensees.”
- Background. Numerous practice acts governing the licensing, regulation, and oversight of professionals within the jurisdiction of the DCA require licensees to continue their education and training as a condition of continuing their licensure. Statutes and regulations dictate how many hours of CE a licensee must complete over a certain number of years. While CE requirements can often be fulfilled through a wide variety of courses, some professionals must fulfill more complete more specific course content in order to renew a license.
CE providers and courses are approved to count toward professional requirements different ways depending on the practice act. For example, the Professional Fiduciaries Bureau is responsible for approving CE providers for its licensees, and the Bureau also reviews and approves specific CE courses. The Dental Board of California (DBC) is tasked with approving providers of CE for dental professionals; however, excluding mandatory courses, the DBC does not individually approve specific courses offered by approved registered providers. The California State Board of Pharmacy (BOP) is not responsible for approving CE providers or courses, and relies entirely on two accreditation agencies.
Over the past several years, questions have been raised during the review of various boards under the DCA through the sunset process relating to the potential for conflicts-of-interest in CE courses. This type of conflict would typically occur when the provider or author of a CE course has a pecuniary interest in its topic. For example, a company that manufactures and sells a specific medical device would arguably have a conflict of interest if they are sponsoring a CE course that teaches health professionals about the availability and merit of that device. While perhaps there is some value to licensees learning about the device, there should be some basic awareness as to whether the content of the CE course is motivated in part by the company’s concern for profitability.
While this bill would not expressly prohibit any particular CE course or content, it would require each entity under the DCA that plays a role in approving CE to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy. A number of private accrediting associations and organizations already maintain a similar policy. Each policy would, at a minimum, be required to discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course. Any conflicts would also be required to be disclosed at the beginning of each course.
- Comments. The Respiratory Care Board of California states that “While the intent of AB 996 is understood, members of the Board felt the bill sends an unfair message that a provider with a financial interest in a particular product is somehow less ethical. Members agreed that so long as a provider’s interest is disclosed, licensees should not be deterred from CE opportunities due to a perception it is unscrupulous. This is especially significant considering in the healthcare arena representatives of medical device and pharmaceutical companies are often the most qualified experts to educate practitioners regarding their products.”
- Arguments in Opposition. The Board of Psychology opposes this bill, noting that “the organizations which approve continuing education providers and courses in psychology operate independently of the Board other than their regulatory specification as qualified to approve providers and offerings. As the Board does not approve the course offerings, it could not effectively monitor individual courses or offerings for any such conflict of interest. Thankfully, the primary organizations upon which we rely, including the American Psychological Association and the California Psychological Association, have established their own standards as to, among other things, conflicts of interest of continuing education speakers or providers and the required disclosure to attendees.” According to the Board, “unlike other disciplines, the continuing education courses most useful to licensees are often provided by the authors or publishers of the relevant materials. For example, when a new or revised assessment instrument or test is released to the market, the person or persons most capable of speaking to the validity and reliability of the test, the appropriate method for administration, scoring, and interpretation, or its use with historically underrepresented groups are those who authored or developed the assessment instrument or test. Similarly, when a theorist, scientist, or researcher is one of the primary presenters in a continuing education course, they will often offer for sale a published work which further illuminates or explains the subject under discussion, offerings that the Board’s licensees have submitted help them to better understand and implement the subject of the course. Unlike some other healthcare disciplines, psychology does not find itself unnecessarily influenced by the types of conflicts of interest that arise when major industrial concerns, such as pharmaceutical companies or medical device makers, exert undue influence over the continuing education available to licensees.” The Board advises that “the proposed language would be difficult to implement given that it does not approve continuing education offerings. Further, it does not provide adequate guidance as to how the policy could be developed or enforced given the nature of continuing education in psychology. Licensees have expressed their concern that were all of the continuing education courses vetted based on the complete absence of any economic interest on the part of presenters or providers, the remaining course offerings might be insufficient to allow them to effectively satisfy the requirements for Continuing Professional Development, without taking courses not relevant to their practices.”
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
None received
Opposition:
Board of Psychology
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 996
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:March 27, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires each board under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) that approves continuing education (CE) providers or courses to have a conflict-of-interest policy that discourages the qualification of courses that promote a product or enterprise in which the provider has a financial interest, and requires those conflicts to be disclosed before each course.
Major Provisions
- Requires any entity under the DCA that is responsible for approving CE providers or courses shall develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy.
- Provides that each conflict-of-interest policy shall, at a minimum, do both of the following:
- Discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course; and
- Require conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each CE course.
COMMENTS
Numerous practice acts governing the licensing, regulation, and oversight of professionals within the jurisdiction of the DCA require licensees to continue their education and training as a condition of continuing their licensure. Statutes and regulations dictate how many hours of CE a licensee must complete over a certain number of years. While CE requirements can often be fulfilled through a wide variety of courses, some professionals must fulfill more complete more specific course content in order to renew a license.
CE providers and courses are approved different ways depending on the practice act. For example, the Professional Fiduciaries Bureau is responsible for approving CE providers for its licensees, and the Bureau also reviews and approves specific CE courses. The Dental Board of California is tasked with approving providers of CE for dental professionals; however, excluding mandatory courses, the Dental Board of California (DBC) does not individually approve specific courses offered by approved registered providers. The California State Board of Pharmacy is not responsible for approving CE providers or courses, and relies entirely on two accreditation agencies.
Over the past several years, questions have been raised during the review of various boards under the DCA through the sunset process relating to the potential for conflicts-of-interest in CE courses. This type of conflict would typically occur when the provider or author of a CE course has a pecuniary interest in its topic. For example, a company that manufactures and sells a specific medical device would arguably have a conflict of interest if they are sponsoring a CE course that teaches health professionals about the availability and merit of that device. While perhaps there is some value to licensees learning about the device, there should be some basic awareness as to whether the content of the CE course is motivated in part by the company's concern for profitability.
While this bill would not expressly prohibit any particular CE course or content, it would require each entity under the DCA that plays a role in approving CE to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy. A number of private accrediting associations and organizations already maintain a similar policy. Each policy would, at a minimum, be required to discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course. Any conflicts would also be required to be disclosed at the beginning of each course.
According to the Author
"While continuing education can be a valuable tool to help ensure that California's licensed professionals continue to provide high-quality services to their patients and clients that reflect the current standards of their profession, there may be times where that education has an ulterior financial motive for the course provider. AB 996 will require regulatory boards to take steps to prevent sales pitches from masquerading as education courses by requiring each board to have a conflict-of-interest policy in place and requiring any potential conflicts to be disclosed to licensees."
Arguments in Support
The Board of Registered Nursing supports this bill, arguing that a support position is consistent with its mission "to protect the health, safety, and wellbeing of the public through fair and consistent application of the statutes and regulations governing nursing practice and education in California."
Arguments in Opposition
The California Board of Psychology opposes this bill, writing that "the organizations which approve continuing education providers and courses in psychology operate independently of the Board" and that "unlike other disciplines, the continuing education courses most useful to licensees are often provided by the authors or publishers of the relevant materials."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, minor and absorbable costs to the impacted DCA boards and bureaus.
VOTES
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 16-0-2
YES: Berman, Flora, Alanis, Alvarez, Bonta, Dixon, Gipson, Grayson, Irwin, Jackson, Lee, Lowenthal, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Joe Patterson, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 16-0-0
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Robert Rivas, Sanchez, Weber, Ortega
UPDATED
VERSION: March 27, 2023
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0000418
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 996
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:March 27, 2023
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 16 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires each board under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) responsible for approving continuing education (CE) providers or courses to have a conflict-of-interest policy.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires any entity under the DCA that is responsible for approving CE providers or courses to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy.
- Provides that each conflict-of-interest policy must, at a minimum, do both of the following:
- Discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course.
- Require conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each CE course.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable costs to the impacted DCA boards and bureaus.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
While continuing education can be a valuable tool to help ensure that California’s licensed professionals continue to provide high-quality services to their patients and clients that reflect the current standards of their profession, there may be times where that education has an ulterior financial motive for the course provider. [This bill] will require regulatory boards to take steps to prevent sales pitches from masquerading as education courses by requiring each board to have a conflict-of-interest policy in place and requiring any potential conflicts to be disclosed to licensees.
- Background. Numerous practice acts governing the licensing, regulation, and oversight of professionals under the jurisdiction of DCA require licensees to continue their education and training as a condition of continuing their licensure. Statutes and regulations dictate how many hours of CE a licensee must complete over a certain number of years. While CE requirements can often be fulfilled through a wide variety of courses, some professionals must complete more specific course content in order to renew a license.
CE providers and courses are approved to count toward professional requirements in different ways depending on the practice act. Some boards approve both CE course providers and specific courses, some approve only the CE course providers, while others rely entirely on outside accreditation agencies. Over the past several years, questions have been raised during the sunset review of various boards under the DCA relating to the potential for conflicts-of-interest in CE courses. This type of conflict would typically occur when the provider or author of a CE course has a financial or commercial interest in its topic.
This bill does not expressly prohibit any particular CE course or content. Instead, it requires each entity under the DCA that plays a role in approving CE to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy. A number of private accrediting associations and organizations already maintain a similar policy. Each policy must, at a minimum, discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course. Any conflicts must also be disclosed at the beginning of each course.
- Arguments in Support. The Board of Registered Nursing has a position of support on the bill. The Board’s mission is to protect the health, safety, and wellbeing of the public through fair and consistent application of the statutes and regulations governing nursing practice and education in California.
- Arguments in Opposition. The Board of Psychology writes in opposition:
Unlike other disciplines, the continuing education courses most useful to licensees are often provided by the authors or publishers of the relevant materials. [Also] unlike some other healthcare disciplines, psychology does not find itself unnecessarily influenced by the types of conflicts of interest that arise when major industrial concerns, such as pharmaceutical companies or medical device makers, exert undue influence over the continuing education available to licensees.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Marc Berman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 996
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:March 27, 2023
SUBJECT: Department of Consumer Affairs: continuing education: conflict-of-interest policy.
SUMMARY: Requires each board under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) that approves continuing education (CE) providers or courses to have a conflict-of-interest policy that discourages the qualification of courses that promote a product or enterprise in which the provider has a financial interest, and requires those conflicts to be disclosed before each course.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the DCA within the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 100)
- Defines “board” as also inclusive of “bureau,” “commission,” “committee,” “department,” “division,” “examining committee,” “program,” and “agency.” (BPC § 22)
- Enumerates various regulatory boards, bureaus, committees, and commissions under the DCA’s jurisdiction. (BPC § 101)
- Provides that all boards, bureaus, and commissions within the DCA are established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities which have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. (BPC § 101.6)
THIS BILL:
- Requires any entity under the DCA that is responsible for approving CE providers or courses shall develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy.
- Provides that each conflict-of-interest policy shall, at a minimum, do both of the following:
- Discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course; and
- Require conflicts to be disclosed at the beginning of each CE course.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the author. According to the author:
“While continuing education can be a valuable tool to help ensure that California’s licensed professionals continue to provide high-quality services to their patients and clients that reflect the current standards of their profession, there may be times where that education has an ulterior financial motive for the course provider. AB 996 will require regulatory boards to take steps to prevent sales pitches from masquerading as education courses by requiring each board to have a conflict-of-interest policy in place and requiring any potential conflicts to be disclosed to licensees.”
Background.
Numerous practice acts governing the licensing, regulation, and oversight of professionals within the jurisdiction of the DCA require licensees to continue their education and training as a condition of continuing their licensure. Statutes and regulations dictate how many hours of CE a licensee must complete over a certain number of years. While CE requirements can often be fulfilled through a wide variety of courses, some professionals must fulfill more complete more specific course content in order to renew a license.
CE providers and courses are approved to count toward professional requirements different ways depending on the practice act. For example, the Professional Fiduciaries Bureau is responsible for approving CE providers for its licensees, and the Bureau also reviews and approves specific CE courses. The Dental Board of California (DBC) is tasked with approving providers of CE for dental professionals; however, excluding mandatory courses, the DBC does not individually approve specific courses offered by approved registered providers. The California State Board of Pharmacy (BOP) is not responsible for approving CE providers or courses, and relies entirely on two accreditation agencies.
Over the past several years, questions have been raised during the review of various boards under the DCA through the sunset process relating to the potential for conflicts-of-interest in CE courses. This type of conflict would typically occur when the provider or author of a CE course has a pecuniary interest in its topic. For example, a company that manufactures and sells a specific medical device would arguably have a conflict of interest if they are sponsoring a CE course that teaches health professionals about the availability and merit of that device. While perhaps there is some value to licensees learning about the device, there should be some basic awareness as to whether the content of the CE course is motivated in part by the company’s concern for profitability.
While this bill would not expressly prohibit any particular CE course or content, it would require each entity under the DCA that plays a role in approving CE to develop and maintain a conflict-of-interest policy. A number of private accrediting associations and organizations already maintain a similar policy. Each policy would, at a minimum, be required to discourage the qualification of any CE course if the provider of that course has an economic interest in a commercial product or enterprise directly or indirectly promoted in that course. Any conflicts would also be required to be disclosed at the beginning of each course.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
None on file.
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):