SB 1035: Criminal procedure: fines, fees, and restitution.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-25
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Constitution entitles the victim of a crime to restitution. Existing law requires the court in each criminal case to order a convicted defendant to pay full restitution to the victim and a separate restitution fine, as specified. Existing law requires the order of restitution to include interest at the annual rate of 10%. Under existing law, certain delinquent payments, including payments for fines, fees, and restitution, may be referred to the Franchise Tax Board for collection. Existing law imposes interest on these delinquent payments.
This bill would change the annual interest rate on restitution orders and to the adjusted annual rate, as specified, and not to exceed 10%. The bill would cap the annual interest rate charged by the Franchise Tax Board on certain delinquent payments, including fines, fees, and restitution, to no more than 1%. The bill would additionally require the Franchise Tax Board, when issuing a withholding order for the purpose of fulfilling a restitution order, to use a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld. The bill would also require an entity collecting money for restitution orders and fines to first use the money to fulfill any restitution order before using it to fulfill any restitution fine or any administrative costs of the agency.
The California Constitution entitles the victim of a crime to restitution. Existing law requires the court in each criminal case to order a convicted defendant to pay full restitution to the victim and a separate restitution fine, as specified. Existing law requires the order of restitution to include interest at the annual rate of 10%. Under existing law, certain delinquent payments, including payments for fines, fees, and restitution, may be referred to the Franchise Tax Board for collection. Existing law imposes interest on these delinquent payments.
This bill would change the annual interest rate on restitution orders and the annual interest rate charged by the Franchise Tax Board on certain delinquent payments, including fines, fees, and restitution, to no more than 1%. The bill would additionally require the Franchise Tax Board, when issuing a withholding order for the purpose of fulfilling a restitution order, to use a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld. The bill would also require an entity collecting money for restitution orders and fines to first use the money to fulfill any restitution order before using it to fulfill any restitution fine or any administrative costs of the agency.
(a)Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, the maximum amount of disposable earnings of an individual judgment debtor for any workweek that is subject to levy under an earnings withholding order shall not exceed the lesser of the following:
(1)Twenty percent of the individuals disposable earnings for that week.
(2)Forty percent of the amount by which the individuals disposable earnings for that week exceed 48 times the state minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable. If a judgment debtor works in a location where the local minimum hourly wage is greater than the state minimum hourly wage, the local minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable shall be used for the calculation made pursuant to this paragraph.
(b)For any pay period other than weekly, the following multipliers shall be used to determine the maximum amount of disposable earnings subject to levy under an earnings withholding order that is proportional in effect to the calculation described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), except as specified in paragraph (1):
(1)For a daily pay period, the amounts shall be identical to the amounts described in subdivision (a).
(2)For a biweekly pay period, multiply the applicable hourly minimum wage by 96 work hours.
(3)For a semimonthly pay period, multiply the applicable hourly minimum wage by 104 work hours.
(4)For a monthly pay period, multiply the applicable hourly minimum wage by 208 work hours.
(c)When the withholding order is an order issued by the Franchise Tax Board for the purpose of fulfilling a restitution order, the board shall use a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld.
SEC. 2.Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1202.4.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature that a victim of crime who incurs an economic loss as a result of the commission of a crime shall receive restitution directly from a defendant convicted of that crime.
(2)Upon a person being convicted of a crime in the State of California, the court shall order the defendant to pay a fine in the form of a penalty assessment in accordance with Section 1464.
(3)The court, in addition to any other penalty provided or imposed under the law, shall order the defendant to pay both of the following:
(A)A restitution fine in accordance with subdivision (b).
(B)Restitution to the victim or victims, if any, in accordance with subdivision (f), which shall be enforceable as if the order were a civil judgment.
(b)In every case where a person is convicted of a crime, the court shall impose a separate and additional restitution fine, unless it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons for not doing so and states those reasons on the record.
(1)The restitution fine shall be set at the discretion of the court and commensurate with the seriousness of the offense. If the person is convicted of a felony, the fine shall not be less than three hundred dollars ($300) and not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000). If the person is convicted of a misdemeanor, the fine shall not be less than one hundred fifty dollars ($150) and not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(2)In setting a felony restitution fine, the court may determine the amount of the fine as the product of the minimum fine pursuant to paragraph (1) multiplied by the number of years of imprisonment the defendant is ordered to serve, multiplied by the number of felony counts of which the defendant is convicted.
(c)The court shall impose the restitution fine unless it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons for not doing so and states those reasons on the record. A defendants inability to pay shall not be considered a compelling and extraordinary reason not to impose a restitution fine. Inability to pay may be considered only in increasing the amount of the restitution fine in excess of the minimum fine pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b). The court may specify that funds confiscated at the time of the defendants arrest, except for funds confiscated pursuant to Chapter 8 (commencing with Section 11469) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, be applied to the restitution fine if the funds are not exempt for spousal or child support or subject to any other legal exemption.
(d)In setting the amount of the fine pursuant to subdivision (b) in excess of the minimum fine pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), the court shall consider any relevant factors, including, but not limited to, the defendants inability to pay, the seriousness and gravity of the offense and the circumstances of its commission, any economic gain derived by the defendant as a result of the crime, the extent to which any other person suffered losses as a result of the crime, and the number of victims involved in the crime. Those losses may include pecuniary losses to the victim or the victims dependents as well as intangible losses, such as psychological harm caused by the crime. Consideration of a defendants inability to pay may include the defendants future earning capacity. A defendant shall bear the burden of demonstrating the defendants inability to pay. Express findings by the court as to the factors bearing on the amount of the fine shall not be required. A separate hearing for the fine shall not be required.
(e)The restitution fine shall not be subject to penalty assessments authorized in Section 1464 or Chapter 12 (commencing with Section 76000) of Title 8 of the Government Code, or the state surcharge authorized in Section 1465.7, and shall be deposited in the Restitution Fund in the State Treasury.
(f)Except as provided in subdivisions (p) and (q), in every case in which a victim has suffered economic loss as a result of the defendants conduct, the court shall require that the defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount established by court order, based on the amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims or any other showing to the court. If the amount of loss cannot be ascertained at the time of sentencing, the restitution order shall include a provision that the amount shall be determined at the direction of the court. The court shall order full restitution. The court may specify that funds confiscated at the time of the defendants arrest, except for funds confiscated pursuant to Chapter 8 (commencing with Section 11469) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, be applied to the restitution order if the funds are not exempt for spousal or child support or subject to any other legal exemption.
(1)The defendant has the right to a hearing before a judge to dispute the determination of the amount of restitution. The court may modify the amount, on its own motion or on the motion of the district attorney, the victim or victims, or the defendant. If a motion is made for modification of a restitution order, the victim shall be notified of that motion at least 10 days prior to the proceeding held to decide the motion. A victim at a restitution hearing or modification hearing described in this paragraph may testify by live, two-way audio and video transmission, if testimony by live, two-way audio and video transmission is available at the court.
(2)Determination of the amount of restitution ordered pursuant to this subdivision shall not be affected by the indemnification or subrogation rights of a third party. Restitution ordered pursuant to this subdivision shall be ordered to be deposited in the Restitution Fund to the extent that the victim, as defined in subdivision (k), has received assistance from the California Victim Compensation Board pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 13950) of Part 4 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(3)To the extent possible, the restitution order shall be prepared by the sentencing court, shall identify each victim and each loss to which it pertains, and shall be of a dollar amount that is sufficient to fully reimburse the victim or victims for every determined economic loss incurred as the result of the defendants criminal conduct, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(A)Full or partial payment for the value of stolen or damaged property. The value of stolen or damaged property shall be the replacement cost of like property, or the actual cost of repairing the property when repair is possible.
(B)Medical expenses.
(C)Mental health counseling expenses.
(D)Wages or profits lost due to injury incurred by the victim, and if the victim is a minor, wages or profits lost by the minors parent, parents, guardian, or guardians, while caring for the injured minor. Lost wages shall include commission income as well as base wages. Commission income shall be established by evidence of commission income during the 12-month period prior to the date of the crime for which restitution is being ordered, unless good cause for a shorter time period is shown.
(E)Wages or profits lost by the victim, and if the victim is a minor, wages or profits lost by the minors parent, parents, guardian, or guardians, due to time spent as a witness or in assisting the police or prosecution. Lost wages shall include commission income as well as base wages. Commission income shall be established by evidence of commission income during the 12-month period prior to the date of the crime for which restitution is being ordered, unless good cause for a shorter time period is shown.
(F)Noneconomic losses, including, but not limited to, psychological harm, for felony violations of Section 288, 288.5, or 288.7.
(G)Interest, at a rate not exceeding 1 percent per annum, that the adjusted annual rate, determined pursuant to Section 19521 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, for the year in which the loss occurred or the year of sentencing, as determined by the court, and not to exceed 10 percent per annum. The court shall determine whether interest accrues as of the date of sentencing or loss, as determined by the court. loss.
(H)Actual and reasonable attorneys fees and other costs of collection accrued by a private entity on behalf of the victim.
(I)Expenses incurred by an adult victim in relocating away from the defendant, including, but not limited to, deposits for utilities and telephone service, deposits for rental housing, temporary lodging and food expenses, clothing, and personal items. Expenses incurred pursuant to this section shall be verified by law enforcement to be necessary for the personal safety of the victim or by a mental health treatment provider to be necessary for the emotional well-being of the victim.
(J)Expenses to install or increase residential security incurred related to a violation of Section 273.5, or a violent felony as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 667.5, including, but not limited to, a home security device or system, or replacing or increasing the number of locks.
(K)Expenses to retrofit a residence or vehicle, or both, to make the residence accessible to or the vehicle operational by the victim, if the victim is permanently disabled, whether the disability is partial or total, as a direct result of the crime.
(L)Expenses for a period of time reasonably necessary to make the victim whole, for the costs to monitor the credit report of, and for the costs to repair the credit of, a victim of identity theft, as defined in Section 530.5.
(4)(A)If, as a result of the defendants conduct, the Restitution Fund has provided assistance to or on behalf of a victim or derivative victim pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 13950) of Part 4 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the amount of assistance provided shall be presumed to be a direct result of the defendants criminal conduct and shall be included in the amount of the restitution ordered.
(B)The amount of assistance provided by the Restitution Fund shall be established by copies of bills submitted to the California Victim Compensation Board reflecting the amount paid by the board and whether the services for which payment was made were for medical or dental expenses, funeral or burial expenses, mental health counseling, wage or support losses, or rehabilitation. Certified copies of these bills provided by the board and redacted to protect the privacy and safety of the victim or any legal privilege, together with a statement made under penalty of perjury by the custodian of records that those bills were submitted to and were paid by the board, shall be sufficient to meet this requirement.
(C)If the defendant offers evidence to rebut the presumption established by this paragraph, the court may release additional information contained in the records of the board to the defendant only after reviewing that information in camera and finding that the information is necessary for the defendant to dispute the amount of the restitution order.
(5)Except as provided in paragraph (6), in any case in which an order may be entered pursuant to this subdivision, the defendant shall prepare and file a disclosure identifying all assets, income, and liabilities in which the defendant held or controlled a present or future interest as of the date of the defendants arrest for the crime for which restitution may be ordered. The financial disclosure statements shall be made available to the victim and the board pursuant to Section 1214. The disclosure shall be signed by the defendant upon a form approved or adopted by the Judicial Council for the purpose of facilitating the disclosure. A defendant who willfully states as true a material matter that the defendant knows to be false on the disclosure required by this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor, unless this conduct is punishable as perjury or another provision of law provides for a greater penalty.
(6)A defendant who fails to file the financial disclosure required in paragraph (5), but who has filed a financial affidavit or financial information pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 987, shall be deemed to have waived the confidentiality of that affidavit or financial information as to a victim in whose favor the order of restitution is entered pursuant to subdivision (f). The affidavit or information shall serve in lieu of the financial disclosure required in paragraph (5), and paragraphs (7) to (10), inclusive, shall not apply.
(7)Except as provided in paragraph (6), the defendant shall file the disclosure with the clerk of the court no later than the date set for the defendants sentencing, unless otherwise directed by the court. The disclosure may be inspected or copied as provided by subdivision (b), (c), or (d) of Section 1203.05.
(8)In its discretion, the court may relieve the defendant of the duty under paragraph (7) of filing with the clerk by requiring that the defendants disclosure be submitted as an attachment to, and be available to, those authorized to receive the following:
(A)A report submitted pursuant to subparagraph (D) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 1203 or subdivision (g) of Section 1203.
(B)A stipulation submitted pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) of Section 1203.
(C)A report by the probation officer, or information submitted by the defendant applying for a conditional sentence pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 1203.
(9)The court may consider a defendants unreasonable failure to make a complete disclosure pursuant to paragraph (5) as any of the following:
(A)A circumstance in aggravation of the crime in imposing a term under subdivision (b) of Section 1170.
(B)A factor indicating that the interests of justice would not be served by admitting the defendant to probation under Section 1203.
(C)A factor indicating that the interests of justice would not be served by conditionally sentencing the defendant under Section 1203.
(D)A factor indicating that the interests of justice would not be served by imposing less than the maximum fine and sentence fixed by law for the case.
(10)A defendants failure or refusal to make the required disclosure pursuant to paragraph (5) shall not delay entry of an order of restitution or pronouncement of sentence. In appropriate cases, the court may do any of the following:
(A)Require the defendant to be examined by the district attorney pursuant to subdivision (h).
(B)If sentencing the defendant under Section 1170, provide that the victim shall receive a copy of the portion of the probation report filed pursuant to Section 1203.10 concerning the defendants employment, occupation, finances, and liabilities.
(C)If sentencing the defendant under Section 1203, set a date and place for submission of the disclosure required by paragraph (5) as a condition of probation or suspended sentence.
(11)If a defendant has any remaining unpaid balance on a restitution order or fine 120 days prior to the defendants scheduled release from probation or 120 days prior to the defendants completion of a conditional sentence, the defendant shall prepare and file a new and updated financial disclosure identifying all assets, income, and liabilities in which the defendant holds or controls or has held or controlled a present or future interest during the defendants period of probation or conditional sentence. The financial disclosure shall be made available to the victim and the board pursuant to Section 1214. The disclosure shall be signed and prepared by the defendant on the same form as described in paragraph (5). A defendant who willfully states as true a material matter that the defendant knows to be false on the disclosure required by this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor, unless this conduct is punishable as perjury or another provision of law provides for a greater penalty. The financial disclosure required by this paragraph shall be filed with the clerk of the court no later than 90 days prior to the defendants scheduled release from probation or completion of the defendants conditional sentence.
(12)In cases where an employer is convicted of a crime against an employee, a payment to the employee or the employees dependent that is made by the employers workers compensation insurance carrier shall not be used to offset the amount of the restitution order unless the court finds that the defendant substantially met the obligation to pay premiums for that insurance coverage.
(g)A defendants inability to pay shall not be a consideration in determining the amount of a restitution order.
(h)The district attorney may request an order of examination pursuant to the procedures specified in Article 2 (commencing with Section 708.110) of Chapter 6 of Division 2 of Title 9 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in order to determine the defendants financial assets for purposes of collecting on the restitution order.
(i)A restitution order imposed pursuant to subdivision (f) shall be enforceable as if the order were a civil judgment.
(j)The making of a restitution order pursuant to subdivision (f) shall not affect the right of a victim to recovery from the Restitution Fund as otherwise provided by law, except to the extent that restitution is actually collected pursuant to the order. Restitution collected pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited to any other judgments for the same losses obtained against the defendant arising out of the crime for which the defendant was convicted.
(k)For purposes of this section, victim shall include all of the following:
(1)The immediate surviving family of the actual victim.
(2)A corporation, business trust, estate, trust, partnership, association, joint venture, government, governmental subdivision, agency, or instrumentality, or any other legal or commercial entity when that entity is a direct victim of a crime.
(3)A person who has sustained economic loss as the result of a crime and who satisfies any of the following conditions:
(A)At the time of the crime was the parent, grandparent, sibling, spouse, child, or grandchild of the victim.
(B)At the time of the crime was living in the household of the victim.
(C)At the time of the crime was a person who had previously lived in the household of the victim for a period of not less than two years in a relationship substantially similar to a relationship listed in subparagraph (A).
(D)Is another family member of the victim, including, but not limited to, the victims fiance, and who witnessed the crime.
(E)Is the primary caretaker of a minor victim.
(4)A person who is eligible to receive assistance from the Restitution Fund pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 13950) of Part 4 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(5)A governmental entity that is responsible for repairing, replacing, or restoring public or privately owned property that has been defaced with graffiti or other inscribed material, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 594, and that has sustained an economic loss as the result of a violation of Section 594, 594.3, 594.4, 640.5, 640.6, or 640.7.
(l)In every case in which the defendant is granted probation, the court shall make the payment of restitution fines and orders imposed pursuant to this section a condition of probation. Any portion of a restitution order that remains unsatisfied after a defendant is no longer on probation shall continue to be enforceable by a victim pursuant to Section 1214 until the obligation is satisfied.
(m)If the court finds and states on the record compelling and extraordinary reasons why a restitution fine should not be required, the court shall order, as a condition of probation, that the defendant perform specified community service, unless it finds and states on the record compelling and extraordinary reasons not to require community service in addition to the finding that a restitution fine should not be required. Upon revocation of probation, the court shall impose the restitution fine pursuant to this section.
(n)The provisions of Section 13963 of the Government Code shall apply to restitution imposed pursuant to this section.
(o)The court clerk shall notify the California Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board within 90 days of an order of restitution being imposed if the defendant is ordered to pay restitution to the board due to the victim receiving compensation from the Restitution Fund. Notification shall be accomplished by mailing a copy of the court order to the board, which may be done periodically by bulk mail or email.
(p)Upon conviction for a violation of Section 236.1, the court shall, in addition to any other penalty or restitution, order the defendant to pay restitution to the victim in a case in which a victim has suffered economic loss as a result of the defendants conduct. The court shall require that the defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount established by court order, based on the amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims or another showing to the court. In determining restitution pursuant to this section, the court shall base its order upon the greater of the following: the gross value of the victims labor or services based upon the comparable value of similar services in the labor market in which the offense occurred, or the value of the victims labor as guaranteed under California law, or the actual income derived by the defendant from the victims labor or services or any other appropriate means to provide reparations to the victim.
(q)(1)In addition to any other penalty or fine, the court shall order a person who has been convicted of a violation of Section 350, 653h, 653s, 653u, 653w, or 653aa that involves a recording or audiovisual work to make restitution to an owner or lawful producer, or trade association acting on behalf of the owner or lawful producer, of a phonograph record, disc, wire, tape, film, or other device or article from which sounds or visual images are derived that suffered economic loss resulting from the violation. The order of restitution shall be based on the aggregate wholesale value of lawfully manufactured and authorized devices or articles from which sounds or visual images are devised corresponding to the number of nonconforming devices or articles involved in the offense, unless a higher value can be proved in the case of (A) an unreleased audio work, or (B) an audiovisual work that, at the time of unauthorized distribution, has not been made available in copies for sale to the general public in the United States on a digital versatile disc. For purposes of this subdivision, possession of nonconforming devices or articles intended for sale constitutes actual economic loss to an owner or lawful producer in the form of displaced legitimate wholesale purchases. The order of restitution shall also include reasonable costs incurred as a result of an investigation of the violation undertaken by the owner, lawful producer, or trade association acting on behalf of the owner or lawful producer. Aggregate wholesale value means the average wholesale value of lawfully manufactured and authorized sound or audiovisual recordings. Proof of the specific wholesale value of each nonconforming device or article is not required.
(2)As used in this subdivision, audiovisual work and recording shall have the same meaning as in Section 653w.
(r)When collecting restitution ordered pursuant to this section, the collecting entity shall use the money to fulfill any restitution order imposed pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) before using it to fulfill any restitution fine or any administrative costs of the agency.
SEC. 3.Section 19280 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:19280.(a)(1)(A)Fines, monetary sanctions, state or local penalties, bail, forfeitures, restitution fines, restitution orders, or any other amounts imposed by a juvenile or superior court of the State of California or the Supreme Court of the State of California upon a person or any other entity, or any payment from the State Bar of Californias Client Security Fund that is part of a final determination from the Client Security Fund, that are due and payable in an amount totaling no less than one hundred dollars ($100), in the aggregate, for criminal offenses, including all offenses involving a violation of the Vehicle Code, any amounts due pursuant to Section 903.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and any amounts due pursuant to Section 6086.10, 6086.13, or 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code may, no sooner than 90 days after payment of that amount becomes delinquent, be referred by the juvenile or superior court, the county, the state, or the State Bar to the Franchise Tax Board for collection under guidelines prescribed by the Franchise Tax Board. Except as specified in subparagraph (B), the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county may refer a restitution order to the Franchise Tax Board, in accordance with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), for any person subject to the restitution order who is or has been under the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county.
(B)The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county shall not refer a restitution order to the Franchise Tax Board if a county agency has been designated by the county board of supervisors to collect restitution from individuals who (i) are serving a sentence in a county jail pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, (ii) are on mandatory supervision pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or (iii) are on postrelease community supervision pursuant to Title 2.05 (commencing with Section 3450) of Part 3 of the Penal Code, the designated county agency has an existing collection system and objects to collection by the Franchise Tax Board, and the designated county agency informs the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county that it will collect the restitution order.
(C)If the crime victim entitled to restitution in the order notifies either the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the designated county agency with regard to their preference of a collecting agency, that preference shall be honored and the collection shall be performed in accordance with the preference of the victim.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision:
(A)The amounts referred by the juvenile or superior court, the county, the state, or the State Bar under this section may include an administrative fee and any amounts that a government entity may add to the court-imposed obligation as a result of the underlying offense, trial, or conviction. For purposes of this article, those amounts shall be deemed to be imposed by the court.
(B)Restitution orders may be referred to the Franchise Tax Board only by a government entity, as agreed upon by the Franchise Tax Board, provided that all of the following apply:
(i)The government entity has the authority to collect on behalf of the state or the victim.
(ii)The government entity shall be responsible for distributing the restitution order collections, as appropriate.
(iii)The government entity shall ensure, in making the referrals and distributions, that it coordinates with any other related collection activities that may occur by superior courts, counties, or other state agencies.
(iv)The government entity shall ensure compliance with laws relating to the reimbursement of the Restitution Fund.
(C)The Franchise Tax Board shall establish criteria for referral that shall include setting forth a minimum dollar amount subject to referral and collection.
(b)The Franchise Tax Board, in conjunction with the Judicial Council, shall seek whatever additional resources are needed to accept referrals from all 58 counties or superior courts.
(c)Upon written notice to the debtor from the Franchise Tax Board, any amount referred to the Franchise Tax Board under subdivision (a) and any interest thereon, including any interest on the amount referred under subdivision (a) that accrued prior to the date of referral, shall be treated as final and due and payable to the State of California, and shall be collected from the debtor by the Franchise Tax Board in any manner authorized under the law for collection of a delinquent personal income tax liability, including, but not limited to, issuance of an order and levy under Article 4 (commencing with Section 706.070) of Chapter 5 of Division 2 of Title 9 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the manner provided for earnings withholding orders for taxes.
(d)(1)Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001), this part, Part 10.7 (commencing with Section 21001), and Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001) shall apply to amounts referred under this article in the same manner and with the same force and effect and to the full extent as if the language of those laws had been incorporated in full into this article, except to the extent that any provision is either inconsistent with this article or is not relevant to this article.
(2)Any information, information sources, or enforcement remedies and capabilities available to the court or the state referring to the amount due described in subdivision (a) shall be available to the Franchise Tax Board to be used in conjunction with, or independent of, the information, information sources, or remedies and capabilities available to the Franchise Tax Board for purposes of administering Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001), this part, Part 10.7 (commencing with Section 21001), or Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001).
(e)The activities required to implement and administer this part shall not interfere with the primary mission of the Franchise Tax Board to administer Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001) and Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001).
(f)For amounts referred for collection under subdivision (a), interest shall accrue at a rate not exceeding 1 percent per annum. When notice of the amount due includes interest and is mailed to the debtor and the amount is paid within 15 days after the date of notice, interest shall not be imposed for the period after the date of notice.
(g)A collection under this article is not a payment of income taxes imposed under Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001) or Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001).
(h)(1)Both of the following shall apply to any levy or order issued on or after January 1, 2022, under subdivision (c):
(A)The maximum amount of disposable earnings of a debtor for any workweek that is subject to collection shall not exceed the amount specified in Section 706.050 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)The minimum basic standard of care amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 704.220 of the Code of Civil Procedure shall not be subject to collection.
(2)This subdivision shall not apply to restitution orders or restitution fines.
(a)Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, the maximum amount of disposable earnings of an individual judgment debtor for any workweek that is subject to levy under an earnings withholding order shall not exceed the lesser of the following:
(1)Twenty percent of the individuals disposable earnings for that week.
(2)Forty percent of the amount by which the individuals disposable earnings for that week exceed 48 times the state minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable. If a judgment debtor works in a location where the local minimum hourly wage is greater than the state minimum hourly wage, the local minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable shall be used for the calculation made pursuant to this paragraph.
(b)For any pay period other than weekly, the following multipliers shall be used to determine the maximum amount of disposable earnings subject to levy under an earnings withholding order that is proportional in effect to the calculation described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), except as specified in paragraph (1):
(1)For a daily pay period, the amounts shall be identical to the amounts described in subdivision (a).
(2)For a biweekly pay period, multiply the applicable hourly minimum wage by 96 work hours.
(3)For a semimonthly pay period, multiply the applicable hourly minimum wage by 104 work hours.
(4)For a monthly pay period, multiply the applicable hourly minimum wage by 208 work hours.
(c)This section shall become operative on September 1, 2023.(c)When the withholding order is an order issued by the Franchise Tax Board for the purpose of fulfilling a restitution order, the board shall use a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld.
SEC. 2.Section 1202.4 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1202.4.(a)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature that a victim of crime who incurs an economic loss as a result of the commission of a crime shall receive restitution directly from a defendant convicted of that crime.
(2)Upon a person being convicted of a crime in the State of California, the court shall order the defendant to pay a fine in the form of a penalty assessment in accordance with Section 1464.
(3)The court, in addition to any other penalty provided or imposed under the law, shall order the defendant to pay both of the following:
(A)A restitution fine in accordance with subdivision (b).
(B)Restitution to the victim or victims, if any, in accordance with subdivision (f), which shall be enforceable as if the order were a civil judgment.
(b)In every case where a person is convicted of a crime, the court shall impose a separate and additional restitution fine, unless it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons for not doing so and states those reasons on the record.
(1)The restitution fine shall be set at the discretion of the court and commensurate with the seriousness of the offense. If the person is convicted of a felony, the fine shall not be less than three hundred dollars ($300) and not more than ten thousand dollars ($10,000). If the person is convicted of a misdemeanor, the fine shall not be less than one hundred fifty dollars ($150) and not more than one thousand dollars ($1,000).
(2)In setting a felony restitution fine, the court may determine the amount of the fine as the product of the minimum fine pursuant to paragraph (1) multiplied by the number of years of imprisonment the defendant is ordered to serve, multiplied by the number of felony counts of which the defendant is convicted.
(c)The court shall impose the restitution fine unless it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons for not doing so and states those reasons on the record. A defendants inability to pay shall not be considered a compelling and extraordinary reason not to impose a restitution fine. Inability to pay may be considered only in increasing the amount of the restitution fine in excess of the minimum fine pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b). The court may specify that funds confiscated at the time of the defendants arrest, except for funds confiscated pursuant to Chapter 8 (commencing with Section 11469) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, be applied to the restitution fine if the funds are not exempt for spousal or child support or subject to any other legal exemption.
(d)In setting the amount of the fine pursuant to subdivision (b) in excess of the minimum fine pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), the court shall consider any relevant factors, including, but not limited to, the defendants inability to pay, the seriousness and gravity of the offense and the circumstances of its commission, any economic gain derived by the defendant as a result of the crime, the extent to which any other person suffered losses as a result of the crime, and the number of victims involved in the crime. Those losses may include pecuniary losses to the victim or the victims dependents as well as intangible losses, such as psychological harm caused by the crime. Consideration of a defendants inability to pay may include the defendants future earning capacity. A defendant shall bear the burden of demonstrating the defendants inability to pay. Express findings by the court as to the factors bearing on the amount of the fine shall not be required. A separate hearing for the fine shall not be required.
(e)The restitution fine shall not be subject to penalty assessments authorized in Section 1464 or Chapter 12 (commencing with Section 76000) of Title 8 of the Government Code, or the state surcharge authorized in Section 1465.7, and shall be deposited in the Restitution Fund in the State Treasury.
(f)Except as provided in subdivisions (p) and (q), in every case in which a victim has suffered economic loss as a result of the defendants conduct, the court shall require that the defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount established by court order, based on the amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims or any other showing to the court. If the amount of loss cannot be ascertained at the time of sentencing, the restitution order shall include a provision that the amount shall be determined at the direction of the court. The court shall order full restitution. The court may specify that funds confiscated at the time of the defendants arrest, except for funds confiscated pursuant to Chapter 8 (commencing with Section 11469) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, be applied to the restitution order if the funds are not exempt for spousal or child support or subject to any other legal exemption.
(1)The defendant has the right to a hearing before a judge to dispute the determination of the amount of restitution. The court may modify the amount, on its own motion or on the motion of the district attorney, the victim or victims, or the defendant. If a motion is made for modification of a restitution order, the victim shall be notified of that motion at least 10 days prior to the proceeding held to decide the motion. A victim at a restitution hearing or modification hearing described in this paragraph may testify by live, two-way audio and video transmission, if testimony by live, two-way audio and video transmission is available at the court.
(2)Determination of the amount of restitution ordered pursuant to this subdivision shall not be affected by the indemnification or subrogation rights of a third party. Restitution ordered pursuant to this subdivision shall be ordered to be deposited in the Restitution Fund to the extent that the victim, as defined in subdivision (k), has received assistance from the California Victim Compensation Board pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 13950) of Part 4 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(3)To the extent possible, the restitution order shall be prepared by the sentencing court, shall identify each victim and each loss to which it pertains, and shall be of a dollar amount that is sufficient to fully reimburse the victim or victims for every determined economic loss incurred as the result of the defendants criminal conduct, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(A)Full or partial payment for the value of stolen or damaged property. The value of stolen or damaged property shall be the replacement cost of like property, or the actual cost of repairing the property when repair is possible.
(B)Medical expenses.
(C)Mental health counseling expenses.
(D)Wages or profits lost due to injury incurred by the victim, and if the victim is a minor, wages or profits lost by the minors parent, parents, guardian, or guardians, while caring for the injured minor. Lost wages shall include commission income as well as base wages. Commission income shall be established by evidence of commission income during the 12-month period prior to the date of the crime for which restitution is being ordered, unless good cause for a shorter time period is shown.
(E)Wages or profits lost by the victim, and if the victim is a minor, wages or profits lost by the minors parent, parents, guardian, or guardians, due to time spent as a witness or in assisting the police or prosecution. Lost wages shall include commission income as well as base wages. Commission income shall be established by evidence of commission income during the 12-month period prior to the date of the crime for which restitution is being ordered, unless good cause for a shorter time period is shown.
(F)Noneconomic losses, including, but not limited to, psychological harm, for felony violations of Section 288, 288.5, or 288.7.
(G)Interest, at the a rate of 10 not exceeding 1 percent per annum, that accrues as of the date of sentencing or loss, as determined by the court.
(H)Actual and reasonable attorneys fees and other costs of collection accrued by a private entity on behalf of the victim.
(I)Expenses incurred by an adult victim in relocating away from the defendant, including, but not limited to, deposits for utilities and telephone service, deposits for rental housing, temporary lodging and food expenses, clothing, and personal items. Expenses incurred pursuant to this section shall be verified by law enforcement to be necessary for the personal safety of the victim or by a mental health treatment provider to be necessary for the emotional well-being of the victim.
(J)Expenses to install or increase residential security incurred related to a violation of Section 273.5, or a violent felony as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 667.5, including, but not limited to, a home security device or system, or replacing or increasing the number of locks.
(K)Expenses to retrofit a residence or vehicle, or both, to make the residence accessible to or the vehicle operational by the victim, if the victim is permanently disabled, whether the disability is partial or total, as a direct result of the crime.
(L)Expenses for a period of time reasonably necessary to make the victim whole, for the costs to monitor the credit report of, and for the costs to repair the credit of, a victim of identity theft, as defined in Section 530.5.
(4)(A)If, as a result of the defendants conduct, the Restitution Fund has provided assistance to or on behalf of a victim or derivative victim pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 13950) of Part 4 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, the amount of assistance provided shall be presumed to be a direct result of the defendants criminal conduct and shall be included in the amount of the restitution ordered.
(B)The amount of assistance provided by the Restitution Fund shall be established by copies of bills submitted to the California Victim Compensation Board reflecting the amount paid by the board and whether the services for which payment was made were for medical or dental expenses, funeral or burial expenses, mental health counseling, wage or support losses, or rehabilitation. Certified copies of these bills provided by the board and redacted to protect the privacy and safety of the victim or any legal privilege, together with a statement made under penalty of perjury by the custodian of records that those bills were submitted to and were paid by the board, shall be sufficient to meet this requirement.
(C)If the defendant offers evidence to rebut the presumption established by this paragraph, the court may release additional information contained in the records of the board to the defendant only after reviewing that information in camera and finding that the information is necessary for the defendant to dispute the amount of the restitution order.
(5)Except as provided in paragraph (6), in any case in which an order may be entered pursuant to this subdivision, the defendant shall prepare and file a disclosure identifying all assets, income, and liabilities in which the defendant held or controlled a present or future interest as of the date of the defendants arrest for the crime for which restitution may be ordered. The financial disclosure statements shall be made available to the victim and the board pursuant to Section 1214. The disclosure shall be signed by the defendant upon a form approved or adopted by the Judicial Council for the purpose of facilitating the disclosure. A defendant who willfully states as true a material matter that the defendant knows to be false on the disclosure required by this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor, unless this conduct is punishable as perjury or another provision of law provides for a greater penalty.
(6)A defendant who fails to file the financial disclosure required in paragraph (5), but who has filed a financial affidavit or financial information pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 987, shall be deemed to have waived the confidentiality of that affidavit or financial information as to a victim in whose favor the order of restitution is entered pursuant to subdivision (f). The affidavit or information shall serve in lieu of the financial disclosure required in paragraph (5), and paragraphs (7) to (10), inclusive, shall not apply.
(7)Except as provided in paragraph (6), the defendant shall file the disclosure with the clerk of the court no later than the date set for the defendants sentencing, unless otherwise directed by the court. The disclosure may be inspected or copied as provided by subdivision (b), (c), or (d) of Section 1203.05.
(8)In its discretion, the court may relieve the defendant of the duty under paragraph (7) of filing with the clerk by requiring that the defendants disclosure be submitted as an attachment to, and be available to, those authorized to receive the following:
(A)A report submitted pursuant to subparagraph (D) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) of Section 1203 or subdivision (g) of Section 1203.
(B)A stipulation submitted pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b) of Section 1203.
(C)A report by the probation officer, or information submitted by the defendant applying for a conditional sentence pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 1203.
(9)The court may consider a defendants unreasonable failure to make a complete disclosure pursuant to paragraph (5) as any of the following:
(A)A circumstance in aggravation of the crime in imposing a term under subdivision (b) of Section 1170.
(B)A factor indicating that the interests of justice would not be served by admitting the defendant to probation under Section 1203.
(C)A factor indicating that the interests of justice would not be served by conditionally sentencing the defendant under Section 1203.
(D)A factor indicating that the interests of justice would not be served by imposing less than the maximum fine and sentence fixed by law for the case.
(10)A defendants failure or refusal to make the required disclosure pursuant to paragraph (5) shall not delay entry of an order of restitution or pronouncement of sentence. In appropriate cases, the court may do any of the following:
(A)Require the defendant to be examined by the district attorney pursuant to subdivision (h).
(B)If sentencing the defendant under Section 1170, provide that the victim shall receive a copy of the portion of the probation report filed pursuant to Section 1203.10 concerning the defendants employment, occupation, finances, and liabilities.
(C)If sentencing the defendant under Section 1203, set a date and place for submission of the disclosure required by paragraph (5) as a condition of probation or suspended sentence.
(11)If a defendant has any remaining unpaid balance on a restitution order or fine 120 days prior to the defendants scheduled release from probation or 120 days prior to the defendants completion of a conditional sentence, the defendant shall prepare and file a new and updated financial disclosure identifying all assets, income, and liabilities in which the defendant holds or controls or has held or controlled a present or future interest during the defendants period of probation or conditional sentence. The financial disclosure shall be made available to the victim and the board pursuant to Section 1214. The disclosure shall be signed and prepared by the defendant on the same form as described in paragraph (5). A defendant who willfully states as true a material matter that the defendant knows to be false on the disclosure required by this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor, unless this conduct is punishable as perjury or another provision of law provides for a greater penalty. The financial disclosure required by this paragraph shall be filed with the clerk of the court no later than 90 days prior to the defendants scheduled release from probation or completion of the defendants conditional sentence.
(12)In cases where an employer is convicted of a crime against an employee, a payment to the employee or the employees dependent that is made by the employers workers compensation insurance carrier shall not be used to offset the amount of the restitution order unless the court finds that the defendant substantially met the obligation to pay premiums for that insurance coverage.
(g)A defendants inability to pay shall not be a consideration in determining the amount of a restitution order.
(h)The district attorney may request an order of examination pursuant to the procedures specified in Article 2 (commencing with Section 708.110) of Chapter 6 of Division 2 of Title 9 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in order to determine the defendants financial assets for purposes of collecting on the restitution order.
(i)A restitution order imposed pursuant to subdivision (f) shall be enforceable as if the order were a civil judgment.
(j)The making of a restitution order pursuant to subdivision (f) shall not affect the right of a victim to recovery from the Restitution Fund as otherwise provided by law, except to the extent that restitution is actually collected pursuant to the order. Restitution collected pursuant to this subdivision shall be credited to any other judgments for the same losses obtained against the defendant arising out of the crime for which the defendant was convicted.
(k)For purposes of this section, victim shall include all of the following:
(1)The immediate surviving family of the actual victim.
(2)A corporation, business trust, estate, trust, partnership, association, joint venture, government, governmental subdivision, agency, or instrumentality, or any other legal or commercial entity when that entity is a direct victim of a crime.
(3)A person who has sustained economic loss as the result of a crime and who satisfies any of the following conditions:
(A)At the time of the crime was the parent, grandparent, sibling, spouse, child, or grandchild of the victim.
(B)At the time of the crime was living in the household of the victim.
(C)At the time of the crime was a person who had previously lived in the household of the victim for a period of not less than two years in a relationship substantially similar to a relationship listed in subparagraph (A).
(D)Is another family member of the victim, including, but not limited to, the victims fiance or fiancee, fiance, and who witnessed the crime.
(E)Is the primary caretaker of a minor victim.
(4)A person who is eligible to receive assistance from the Restitution Fund pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 13950) of Part 4 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(5)A governmental entity that is responsible for repairing, replacing, or restoring public or privately owned property that has been defaced with graffiti or other inscribed material, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 594, and that has sustained an economic loss as the result of a violation of Section 594, 594.3, 594.4, 640.5, 640.6, or 640.7.
(l)In every case in which the defendant is granted probation, the court shall make the payment of restitution fines and orders imposed pursuant to this section a condition of probation. Any portion of a restitution order that remains unsatisfied after a defendant is no longer on probation shall continue to be enforceable by a victim pursuant to Section 1214 until the obligation is satisfied.
(m)If the court finds and states on the record compelling and extraordinary reasons why a restitution fine should not be required, the court shall order, as a condition of probation, that the defendant perform specified community service, unless it finds and states on the record compelling and extraordinary reasons not to require community service in addition to the finding that a restitution fine should not be required. Upon revocation of probation, the court shall impose the restitution fine pursuant to this section.
(n)The provisions of Section 13963 of the Government Code shall apply to restitution imposed pursuant to this section.
(o)The court clerk shall notify the California Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board within 90 days of an order of restitution being imposed if the defendant is ordered to pay restitution to the board due to the victim receiving compensation from the Restitution Fund. Notification shall be accomplished by mailing a copy of the court order to the board, which may be done periodically by bulk mail or email.
(p)Upon conviction for a violation of Section 236.1, the court shall, in addition to any other penalty or restitution, order the defendant to pay restitution to the victim in a case in which a victim has suffered economic loss as a result of the defendants conduct. The court shall require that the defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount established by court order, based on the amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims or another showing to the court. In determining restitution pursuant to this section, the court shall base its order upon the greater of the following: the gross value of the victims labor or services based upon the comparable value of similar services in the labor market in which the offense occurred, or the value of the victims labor as guaranteed under California law, or the actual income derived by the defendant from the victims labor or services or any other appropriate means to provide reparations to the victim.
(q)(1)In addition to any other penalty or fine, the court shall order a person who has been convicted of a violation of Section 350, 653h, 653s, 653u, 653w, or 653aa that involves a recording or audiovisual work to make restitution to an owner or lawful producer, or trade association acting on behalf of the owner or lawful producer, of a phonograph record, disc, wire, tape, film, or other device or article from which sounds or visual images are derived that suffered economic loss resulting from the violation. The order of restitution shall be based on the aggregate wholesale value of lawfully manufactured and authorized devices or articles from which sounds or visual images are devised corresponding to the number of nonconforming devices or articles involved in the offense, unless a higher value can be proved in the case of (A) an unreleased audio work, or (B) an audiovisual work that, at the time of unauthorized distribution, has not been made available in copies for sale to the general public in the United States on a digital versatile disc. For purposes of this subdivision, possession of nonconforming devices or articles intended for sale constitutes actual economic loss to an owner or lawful producer in the form of displaced legitimate wholesale purchases. The order of restitution shall also include reasonable costs incurred as a result of an investigation of the violation undertaken by the owner, lawful producer, or trade association acting on behalf of the owner or lawful producer. Aggregate wholesale value means the average wholesale value of lawfully manufactured and authorized sound or audiovisual recordings. Proof of the specific wholesale value of each nonconforming device or article is not required.
(2)As used in this subdivision, audiovisual work and recording shall have the same meaning as in Section 653w.
(r)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2022.(r)When collecting restitution ordered pursuant to this section, the collecting entity shall use the money to fulfill any restitution order imposed pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) before using it to fulfill any restitution fine or any administrative costs of the agency.
SEC. 3.Section 19280 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:19280.(a)(1)(A)Fines, monetary sanctions, state or local penalties, bail, forfeitures, restitution fines, restitution orders, or any other amounts imposed by a juvenile or superior court of the State of California or the Supreme Court of the State of California upon a person or any other entity, or any payment from the State Bar of Californias Client Security Fund that is part of a final determination from the Client Security Fund, that are due and payable in an amount totaling no less than one hundred dollars ($100), in the aggregate, for criminal offenses, including all offenses involving a violation of the Vehicle Code, any amounts due pursuant to Section 903.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and any amounts due pursuant to Section 6086.10, 6086.13, or 6140.5 of the Business and Professions Code may, no sooner than 90 days after payment of that amount becomes delinquent, be referred by the juvenile or superior court, the county, the state, or the State Bar to the Franchise Tax Board for collection under guidelines prescribed by the Franchise Tax Board. Except as specified in subparagraph (B), the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county may refer a restitution order to the Franchise Tax Board, in accordance with subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), for any person subject to the restitution order who is or has been under the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county.
(B)The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county shall not refer a restitution order to the Franchise Tax Board if a county agency has been designated by the county board of supervisors to collect restitution from individuals who (i) are serving a sentence in a county jail pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, (ii) are on mandatory supervision pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or (iii) are on postrelease community supervision pursuant to Title 2.05 (commencing with Section 3450) of Part 3 of the Penal Code, the designated county agency has an existing collection system and objects to collection by the Franchise Tax Board, and the designated county agency informs the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county that it will collect the restitution order.
(C)If the crime victim entitled to restitution in the order notifies either the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the designated county agency with regard to their preference of a collecting agency, that preference shall be honored and the collection shall be performed in accordance with the preference of the victim.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision:
(A)The amounts referred by the juvenile or superior court, the county, the state, or the State Bar under this section may include an administrative fee and any amounts that a government entity may add to the court-imposed obligation as a result of the underlying offense, trial, or conviction. For purposes of this article, those amounts shall be deemed to be imposed by the court.
(B)Restitution orders may be referred to the Franchise Tax Board only by a government entity, as agreed upon by the Franchise Tax Board, provided that all of the following apply:
(i)The government entity has the authority to collect on behalf of the state or the victim.
(ii)The government entity shall be responsible for distributing the restitution order collections, as appropriate.
(iii)The government entity shall ensure, in making the referrals and distributions, that it coordinates with any other related collection activities that may occur by superior courts, counties, or other state agencies.
(iv)The government entity shall ensure compliance with laws relating to the reimbursement of the Restitution Fund.
(C)The Franchise Tax Board shall establish criteria for referral that shall include setting forth a minimum dollar amount subject to referral and collection.
(b)The Franchise Tax Board, in conjunction with the Judicial Council, shall seek whatever additional resources are needed to accept referrals from all 58 counties or superior courts.
(c)Upon written notice to the debtor from the Franchise Tax Board, any amount referred to the Franchise Tax Board under subdivision (a) and any interest thereon, including any interest on the amount referred under subdivision (a) that accrued prior to the date of referral, shall be treated as final and due and payable to the State of California, and shall be collected from the debtor by the Franchise Tax Board in any manner authorized under the law for collection of a delinquent personal income tax liability, including, but not limited to, issuance of an order and levy under Article 4 (commencing with Section 706.070) of Chapter 5 of Division 2 of Title 9 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure in the manner provided for earnings withholding orders for taxes.
(d)(1)Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001), this part, Part 10.7 (commencing with Section 21001), and Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001) shall apply to amounts referred under this article in the same manner and with the same force and effect and to the full extent as if the language of those laws had been incorporated in full into this article, except to the extent that any provision is either inconsistent with this article or is not relevant to this article.
(2)Any information, information sources, or enforcement remedies and capabilities available to the court or the state referring to the amount due described in subdivision (a) shall be available to the Franchise Tax Board to be used in conjunction with, or independent of, the information, information sources, or remedies and capabilities available to the Franchise Tax Board for purposes of administering Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001), this part, Part 10.7 (commencing with Section 21001), or Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001).
(e)The activities required to implement and administer this part shall not interfere with the primary mission of the Franchise Tax Board to administer Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001) and Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001).
(f)For amounts referred for collection under subdivision (a), interest shall accrue at the greater of the rate applicable to the amount due being collected or the rate provided under Section 19521. a rate not exceeding 1 percent per annum. When notice of the amount due includes interest and is mailed to the debtor and the amount is paid within 15 days after the date of notice, interest shall not be imposed for the period after the date of notice.
(g)A collection under this article is not a payment of income taxes imposed under Part 10 (commencing with Section 17001) or Part 11 (commencing with Section 23001).
(h)(1)Both of the following shall apply to any levy or order issued on or after January 1, 2022, under subdivision (c):
(A)The maximum amount of disposable earnings of a debtor for any workweek that is subject to collection shall not exceed the amount specified in Section 706.050 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(B)The minimum basic standard of care amount specified in subdivision (a) of Section 704.220 of the Code of Civil Procedure shall not be subject to collection.
(2)This subdivision shall not apply to restitution orders or restitution fines.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 14, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2024 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 3759.) (April 24). |
| Apr 12, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. (Ayes 4. Noes 1. Page 3449.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 8, 2024 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Feb 21, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on PUB S. and REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 7, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 8. |
| Feb 6, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 13, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Revenue and Taxation] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Association of Judgment Professionals | ** Against | |
| California Attorneys For Criminal Justice | ** Support | |
| California District Attorneys Association | ** Against | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Support | |
| Fiona Ma, California State Treasurer | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership | ** Support | |
| Secure Justice | ** Support | |
| Smart Justice California, a project of Tides Advocacy | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1035 (Ashby) - Criminal procedure: fines, fees, and restitution
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary: SB 1035 lowers the interest rate on restitution orders, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially significant one-time and ongoing costs (General Fund) to the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) to establish and implement a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine amounts to be withheld from earnings to satisfy outstanding restitution orders, as required by this bill.
- Unknown, potentially significant cost pressures to the Restitution Fund and General Fund by requiring collections on outstanding restitution orders to be used to satisfy restitution orders before any restitution fine. The Restitution Fund has operated at a structural deficient for years. This bill may increase cost pressures on the General Fund by potentially exacerbating the Restitution Fund’s structural deficit. (See Staff Comments.)
Background: Existing law provides that “in every case in which a victim has suffered economic loss as a result of the defendant’s conduct, the court shall require that the defendant make restitution to the victim or victims in an amount established by court order.” The statute further provides that a “defendant’s inability to pay shall not be consideration in determining the amount of a restitution order.” Rather, victim restitution orders must be of a dollar amount that is sufficient to fully reimburse the victim, which can include an assortment of expenses such as medical expenses, mental health counseling expenses, wages or lost profits, noneconomic losses like psychological harm, actual and reasonable attorney’s fees, and relocation fees. The victim restitution order must also include interest at the rate of 10% per annum.
Payment of victim restitution goes directly to the victim and compensates them for economic losses they have suffered because of the defendant’s crime, i.e., to make the victim reasonably whole. A victim restitution order is an enforceable civil money judgment, and typical post-judgment enforcement tools are available to the victim. Victims have access to all available resources to enforce the order, including wage garnishment and lien procedures, even if the defendant is no longer in custody or on supervision.
Victim restitution can easily exceed amounts in the tens of thousands of dollars, on top of which is added accruing interest. Most people can never afford to pay off the restitution order. Instead, they live with debt. This has had serious consequences for people of color, deepening the racial wealth gap of Black persons in particular. In Los Angeles County, though Black people make up 8% of the population, they were charged with 20% of all dollars owed in restitution.[1] Victim restitution orders can be referred to the FTB for collection and crime victims are entitled to their preference of collection agencies. Interest may be imposed on delinquent amounts.
Proposed Law: SB 1035 lowers the interest rate on restitution orders from 10% to an adjusted annual rate, as specified, not to exceed 10% per annum; directs FTB to use a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld under a criminal restitution order; and, provides that money collected must be used first to satisfy a restitution order before being applied against restitution fines or administrative costs.
Related Legislation:
- AB 855 (Jackson, 2023) was substantially similar to this bill. AB 855 failed passage in Assembly Revenue and Tax Committee.
- AB 1530 (Skinner, Chapter 359, Statutes of 2010) provided express authority for the FTB to collect orders of restitution awarded to the FTB in criminal proceedings in the same manner and with the same priority as tax liabilities.
Staff Comments: Criminal defendants are ordered to pay direct restitution orders to the victims and restitution fines and fees. Restitution fines and fees are deposited in the Restitution Fund in the State Treasury. The Restitution Fund receives revenue from criminal fines and penalties and distributes those funds to a number of recipients, including the California Victim Compensation Board (CalVCB). The Restitution Fund has been operating under a structural imbalance for years and faces a potential operating deficit in coming years. Despite steady revenues and federal funding, expenditures have exceeded available funds. The 2021 budget act added $33 million to the Restitution Fund in fiscal year 2021-22 and $39.5 million annually thereafter to restore the fund to operational levels. Additionally, although the 2023-24 budget included $39.5 million General Fund to backfill the Restitution Fund, General Fund backfill for 2024-25 is expected to be reduced to $14.5 million.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | SB 1035 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/24 |
Author: | Ashby | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 2/6/24 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Criminal procedure: fines, fees, and restitution
Makes three changes to provisions of law guiding criminal restitution orders and the manner in which the state collects restitution.
Background
Criminal restitution. Section 28 of Article I of the California Constitution provides people the right to seek restitution when they suffer a loss from the convicted party guilty of the criminal activity causing the loss (Proposition 8, 1982). Proposition 8 added that restitution must be ordered from the convicted wrongdoer in every case, regardless of the sentence or disposition imposed in which a crime victim suffers a loss, and funds collected must first be applied to pay the amounts ordered as restitution to the victim.
Convicted criminal defendants must pay a restitution fine, which a court can only waive it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons. State law sets forth several criteria for a court to apply when determining the restitution fine, but the court has discretion to set the fine commensurate with the seriousness of the offense as follows:
- If the person is convicted of a felony, the fine shall not be less than $300, and not more than $10,000.
- If the person is convicted of a misdemeanor, the fine shall not be less than $150 and not more than $1,000.
Courts cannot consider a person’s inability to pay when deciding whether to impose a restitution fine, but may consider it when increasing the amount of the restitution fine in excess of the minimum set above. A restitution fine is not paid by the defendant directly to the victim. Instead, the fine is deposited in the Restitution Fund from which crime victims may obtain compensation.
Additionally, if a victim incurs an economic loss as a result of a crime, they must receive restitution directly from a convicted defendant, based on the amount of loss claimed by the victim or victims or any other showing to the court. If the court does not determine the amount of loss at the time of sentencing, the restitution order must include a provision that the amount shall be determined at the direction of the court. Courts must order full restitution, meaning a dollar amount that fully reimburses the victim or victims for every economic losses incurred as a result of the defendant’s criminal action. Courts cannot consider a defendant’s inability to pay in determining the amount of a restitution order, but defendants have the right to a hearing before a judge to dispute this restitution amount.
Once a court orders restitution, it’s enforceable by the victim as a civil judgment in the same manner as any other money judgment. Upon the victim’s request, the court must provide the victim a certified copy of the order and a copy of the defendant’s financial disclosure. Interest on an unpaid restitution order accrues at 10% per year as of the day of sentencing or loss.
Earnings withholding order of taxes. Tax agencies will issue an earnings withholding order of taxes (EWOT), where employers garnish a portion of delinquent tax or fee payer’s wages and send them to the tax agency to satisfy the delinquent liability. Employers must withhold the amounts required by an EWOT from the earnings of the employee during the designated withholding period. Interest accrues after the issuance of an EWOT. The California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) or a county can refer restitution orders to the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), which then issues an EWOT to collect the amount owed in restitution, among other tools such as bank levies, tax refund intercepts, and property liens,
State law sets a maximum amount of disposable earnings that is subject to levy under an EWOT at:
- 20% of the individual’s weekly disposable income; or,
- 40% of the amount by which the individual’s disposable earnings for that week exceed 48 times the state or local minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable. The Legislature recently reduced this amount from 50% to 40%, among other changes (SB 1477, Wieckowski, 2022).
Except for current inmates, CDCR submits all unpaid victim direct orders of restitution owed by persons, under CDCR’s jurisdiction to the FTB for collection, from whom restitution is collected only through wage and deposit garnishment process. For parolees and discharged offenders, the FTB works as a collection agent for CDCR. FTB first sends a notice letter advising the debtor to contact FTB and set up a payment plan. Debtors who do not contact FTB are then subject to EWOTs, and other forms of collection.
FTB collects the restitution and sends the money to CDCR, which then sends the money and victim information to the California Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board’s Victim Compensation Program, the agency responsible for sending the money to the victim. The FTB collection process continues until the victim is paid in full. FTB will pursue collection no matter how long it takes until the restitution is paid. Further, those in bankruptcy cannot discharge their victim restitution obligation.
Currently, many restitution orders either go entirely unfulfilled or are only partially fulfilled. The author wants to make changes to criminal restitution to increase the likelihood that they will be satisfied.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 1035 makes three changes to criminal restitution:
- Lowers the interest rate on restitution orders from 10% to 1% for a restitution order, and from the interest rate that applies generally to late tax payments to 1% for EWOTs.
- Directs FTB to use a sliding scale model that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld under a criminal restitution order, instead of the 20% of disposable income or 40% of the state or local minimum wage requirement in current law.
- Provides that money collected from restitution must be used first to satisfy a restitution order before being applied against restitution fines or administrative costs.
The measure also makes a technical change.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “restitution is intended to compensate crime survivors for economic loss and harm done, while also holding offenders accountable for their actions. However, for a variety of reasons, less than 1% of survivors actually receive restitution as ordered. 80% of people who owe restitution live in poverty. An additional 10% interest rate required by the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) further exasperates an already dire situation. Inability to pay restitution often results in two things: the formerly incarcerated people living with debt — which can range from thousands to sometimes millions of dollars — for the rest of their lives, and the survivors receiving little to no compensation. This not only wreaks havoc on the lives of people ordered to pay, but also leaves many survivors without restitution. SB 1035 will better ensure victims are properly compensated and receive their payments in a timely manner by reforming the current structure of restitution payments, while also easing the burden for people trying to reintegrate back into their communities, pay off their debt, and move forward with productive lives.”
2. Taking interest. Governments charge interest to compensate for the time value of money when delinquent taxpayers or others possess funds that lawfully belong to the government or others. To reduce criminal recidivism, SB 1035 would reduce two different interest rates. First, the bill would reduce the current interest rate that applies to criminal restitution orders from 10% to an unspecified rate that cannot exceed 1%. Because this interest rate accrues on unpaid criminal restitution, crime victims would receive less than they otherwise would due to the bill. Second, the bill would reduce the interest rate FTB applies when a wage garnishment does not fully satisfy the withholding order to 1%, which is the lesser of 5% or one based on the federal short term rate. As a result, FTB would have to apply a different interest rate for withholding orders for restitution than for other payments. Additionally, it’s unclear whether interest charges would apply to restitution fines, and to whom that interest is paid. The Committee may wish to consider removing the bill’s provisions relating to interest rates. Alternatively, it may wish to consider reducing the interest rate on restitution orders to one that more closely approximates the rate of inflation.
3. Reducing recidivism. When formerly incarcerated individuals exit criminal justice facilities and attempt to rejoin society, they face a myriad of challenges: difficulty obtaining employment that generates sufficient income to pay for housing and transportation; rising costs of living; and a potential lack of family support, among others. Even after a formerly incarcerated individual obtains employment, wage garnishment for restitution leaves less funds to meet necessities. The Senate Public Safety Committee cites two recent studies detailing these difficulties:
- According to the Berkeley Law’s Policy Advocacy Clinic, in California, less than 1% of victims actually receive the amount as ordered, and 67% of victims receive no restitution or victim compensation at all. The clinic also found the average restitution amount in California is about $10,000 and the average total of restitution fines were about $2,000. People assessed with restitution will often live with this debt and victims in these cases receive little to no restitution at all. The large percent of unfulfilled restitution payments can possibly be attributed to the ability of the defendant to pay the court-ordered amounts.
- A study conducted by the Brookings Institute found that nationally individuals who were incarcerated at some point during 2009-2013, in the first full year after their release, about 49% of formerly incarcerated individuals earn less than $500, 32% earn between $500 and $15,000, and only 20% earn more than $15,000.
SB 1035’s supporters argue a formerly incarcerated individual’s inability to pay restitution combined with other pressures facing them will result in more of these individuals recidivating. The measure’s provisions allowing FTB to instead base wage garnishments on a sliding scale model instead of up to 20% of their earnings could lead to more restitution orders being fulfilled and less recidivism.
4. Double-referred. The Senate Public Safety Committee approved SB 1035 by a vote of 4 to 1 on April 2, 2024. The Revenue and Taxation Committee is hearing the measure as the committee of second reference.
5. Related legislation. Last year, the Senate approved SB 516 (Skinner), which enacted the Franchise Tax Board Debtor Bill of Rights, which makes several changes to the way the Controller and the Franchise Tax Board collect outstanding debts. The author removed those provisions and inserted others relating to health care coverage,
Support and Opposition
(4/19/24)
Support: Fiona Ma, California State Treasurer (Co-Sponsor)
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership (LARRP)
Secure Justice
Smart Justice California, a Project of Tides Advocacy
Opposition: California Association of Judgment Professionals
California District Attorneys Association
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1035 Hearing Date: April 2, 2024
Author: | Ashby | ||
Version: | February 6, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | JD | ||
Subject: Criminal procedure: fines, fees, and restitution
HISTORY
Source: Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Prior Legislation: AB 855 (Jackson, 2023) – Died Asm. Rev. & Tax
AB 1803 (Jones-Sawyer), Chapter 494, Statutes of 2022
SB 1106 (Wiener), Chapter 734, Statutes of 2022
AB 1530 (Skinner), Chapter 359, Statutes of 2010
Support: California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Public Defenders Association; California State Treasurer; Secure Justice
Opposition: California Association of Judgment Professionals
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to change the maximum annual interest assessed on restitution orders from 10% to no more than 1% and to establish a sliding scale model for the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) to “consider income and ability to pay” when determining its withholding amount for restitution payments.
Existing law provides people the right to seek restitution when they suffer loss as a result of criminal activity, from the convicted party guilty of the criminal activity causing the loss (California Constitution Art. I Sec. 28 (13)(A)).
Existing law states that restitution shall be ordered from the convicted wrongdoer in every case, regardless of the sentence or disposition imposed, in which a crime victim suffers a loss (California Constitution Art. I Sec. 28 (13)(B)).
Existing law states that restitution collected shall be first applied to pay the amounts ordered as restitution to the victim (California Constitution Art. I Sec. 28 (13)(C)).
Existing law provides that if a victim incurs an economic loss as a result of the commission of a crime, they shall receive restitution directly from the defendant convicted of the crime (Penal Code § 1202.4, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law states that, in addition to any other penalty provided or imposed under the law, the court shall order the defendant to pay both a restitution fine to the state and restitution to the victim or victims, if any. (Penal Code § 1202.4, subd. (a)(3).)
Existing law requires the courts to consider all relevant factors when setting the restitution fine amount, including the:
- Defendants inability to pay, including future earning capacity – defendant bears the burden to prove their inability to pay;
- Seriousness and gravity of the convicted offense;
- Circumstances that contributed to the commission of the crime;
- Defendants economic gain as a result of the crime, if any;
- Victim’s monetary losses as well as intangible losses like psychological harm; and,
- Number of victims. (Penal Code § 1202.4, subd. (d)(1).)
Existing law clarifies that if the amount of loss cannot be determined at the time of sentencing, the restitution order shall include a provision declaring that the responsibility of setting the amount shall fall to the direction of the court (Penal Code § 1202.4, subd. (f))
Existing law provides a defendant ordered to pay restitution the right to dispute the determination of the restitution order before a judge (Penal Code § 1202.4, subd. (f)(1))
Existing law prohibits an unfulfilled order of restitution or restitution fine from being considered as grounds for a defendant not fulfilling the conditions of their probation (Penal Code § 1203.4 subd. (c)(3)).
Existing law specifies that a restitution order is enforceable by the victim as a civil judgment, and enforceable in the same manner as is provided for the enforcement of any other money judgment. Upon the victim’s request, the court shall provide the victim in whose favor the order of restitution is entered with a certified copy of that order and a copy of the defendant’s financial disclosure. (Penal Code, §§ 1202.4, subd. (i), & 1214, subd. (b).)
Existing law states that any portion of a restitution fine or restitution fee that remains unsatisfied after a defendant is no longer on probation, parole, post release community supervision or mandatory supervision, after a term in custody, or after completing diversion is enforceable by the California Victim Compensation Board. (Penal Code, § 1214, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires a restitution order to be a dollar amount that fully reimburses the victim(s) for every one of their economic losses incurred as a result of the defendants criminal action (Penal Code, § 1214, subd. (f)(3).)
Existing law assesses a 10 percent annual interest rate on restitution orders beginning on either the sentencing date or the date that the loss occurred, as determined by the court. (Penal Code § 1202.4 subd. (f)(3)(A).)
Existing law defines a withholding period as the time period beginning 10 days after an employer receives an earnings withholding order until the earliest of one of these occurrences:
- The date when the entire amount designated by the withholding order has been withheld
- A court serves an order to the employer forcing them to terminate the withholding period
- The levying officer serves a notice of termination to the employer
- The date of termination of a dormant or suspended earnings withholding order as determined pursuant to Section 706.032 (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.022 subd. (a)).
Existing law states that an employer must withhold the amounts required by an earnings withholding order from the earnings of the employee during the designated withholding period (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.022 subd. (b)).
Existing law clarifies that an employer is not liable for any amounts withheld and paid to the levying officer prior to the service of the withholding order (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.022 subd. (c)).
Existing law includes the addition of daily interest accrued after the issuance of a withholding order in the total amount required to satisfy an earnings withholding order (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.024).
Existing law requires the withholding order be paid monthly no later than the 15th of each month, the monthly payment shall include all the amounts required to be withheld from the pay period that ends closest to the end of the month. Employers have the option to pay more frequently than monthly (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.025).
Existing law provides that the maximum amount of disposable earnings subject to levy under an earnings withholding shall not exceed the lesser of the following:
- Twenty percent of the individual’s weekly disposable income; or,
- Forty percent of the amount by which the individual’s disposable earnings for that week exceed 48 times the state minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable. If a judgment debtor works in a location where the local minimum hourly wage is greater than the state minimum hourly wage, the local minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable shall be used for the calculation made (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.050 subd. (a)).
Existing law establishes multipliers for determining the maximum amount of disposable earnings subject to levy under an earnings withholding (Code of Civil Procedure § 706.050 subd. (b)).
Existing law allows for restitution fines and restitution orders be referred to the FTB for collection no sooner than 90 days after the payment becomes delinquent (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (a) and (b))
Existing law allows the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) or county to refer restitution orders to the FTB for any person who is or has been under the jurisdiction of CDCR or the county (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (a)).
Existing law prohibits a restitution order from being referred to the FTB if a county agency has already been designated by the county board of supervisors to collect restitutions from individuals who are serving a sentence in a county jail, are on mandatory supervision, or are on post release community supervision (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (a)(1)(B)).
Existing law allows for a crime victim entitled to restitution to choose a preferred collecting agency, if they notify the county agency or CDCR, depending on the agency that is already responsible for restitution order (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (a)(1)(C)).
Existing law allows the withholding amount referred to the FTB to include an administrative fee and any amounts that a government entity may add to the court-imposed obligation (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (a)(2)(A)).
Existing law requires the FTB to treat the entire remaining withholding amount combined with any accrued to that date as final and due payable to the State of California (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (c)).
Existing law allows the FTB to collect the withholding amount from the debtor using any means authorized under the law for collection of a delinquent personal income tax liability (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (c)).
Existing law prohibits restitution payments collected by the FTB from being considered as a form of income tax payments (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19280 subd. (g)).
This bill establishes a sliding scale model for when withholding orders are issued by the FTB; this model will used when determining the amounts collected for restitution payments.
This bill changes the maximum annual interest rate for restitution orders from 10% to no more than 1%, with the rate accruing beginning on the date of sentencing or loss as determined by the court.
This bill would require the collecting entity to use the money to completely pay off the restitution ordered to the victim before using any money to fulfill court ordered restitution fine or any administrative fees.
This bill changes the gendered distinction between fiancé and fiancée to the non-gendered term “fiance” in the California Penal Code § 1202.4.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author of this bill:
Restitution is intended to compensate crime survivors for economic loss and harm done, while also holding offenders accountable for their actions. However, for a variety of reasons, less than 1% of survivors actually receive restitution as ordered.
80% of people who owe restitution live in poverty. An additional 10% interest rate required by the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) further exasperates an already dire situation. Inability to pay restitution often results in two things: the formerly incarcerated people living with debt — which can range from thousands to sometimes millions of dollars — for the rest of their lives, and the survivors receiving little to no compensation. This not only wreaks havoc on the lives of people ordered to pay, but also leaves many survivors without restitution.
SB 1035 will better ensure victims are properly compensated and receive their payments in a timely manner by reforming the current structure of restitution payments, while also easing the burden for people trying to reintegrate back into their communities, pay off their debt, and move forward with productive lives.
- Background: FTB Restitution Involvement
According to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation:
Effective March 1, 2010, the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) began submitting all unpaid victim direct orders of restitution owed by persons who are, or have been, under CDCR’s jurisdiction to the FTB for collection. The exception is persons who are currently inmates at a state prison, from whom restitution is collected only through CDCR’s wage and deposit garnishment process.
For parolees and discharged offenders, the FTB works as a collection agent for CDCR, collecting the restitution through its Court-Ordered Debt Unit. Cities, counties, and other state agencies also use FTB’s Court-Ordered Debt Unit. The procedures used by FTB to collect these debts are identical to those used with ordinary taxpayers who owe a tax debt. FTB sends a notice letter advising the debtor to contact FTB and set up a payment plan. Debtors who do not contact FTB are then subject to wage garnishment, bank account seizures, and other forms of collection.
No victim information is shared with the FTB, only offender information. FTB collects the restitution and sends the money to CDCR. CDCR allocates the collection to the appropriate victim and sends the money and victim information to the California Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board’s Victim Compensation Program, the agency responsible for sending the money to the victim. The FTB collection process continues until the victim is paid in full.
FTB will pursue collection no matter how long it takes until the restitution is paid. There is no time limit. Further, offenders in bankruptcy cannot discharge their victim restitution obligation.
- Restitution Fines
A convicted defendant must pay a restitution fine. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (b).) The fine can only be waived if the court finds compelling and extraordinary reasons not to impose it, and inability to pay does not qualify as a compelling and extraordinary reason to waive the fine. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (c).)
The amount of the fine varies in the trial court’s discretion, ranging from a minimum of $300 up to $10,000 for felony convictions, and $150 to $1,000 for misdemeanor convictions. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (b)(1).) The court may determine the amount of the fine by multiplying the minimum fine by the number of years of imprisonment to which the defendant is sentenced, and then by the number of convictions. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (b)(2).) In this calculation, the court is permitted to consider the defendant’s ability to pay although this factor is only to be considered in determining whether to set the fine in excess of the statutory minimum. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (c).)
A restitution fine is not paid by the defendant directly to the victim. Instead, the fine is deposited in the Restitution Fund from which crime victims may obtain compensation. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (e).) Similar to victim restitution, a defendant’s obligation to pay a restitution fine does not expire once the sentence is completed or probation has ended. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (f); Pen. Code, § 1214.) The California Victim Compensation Board is authorized with collecting any restitution fines that the defendant is ordered to pay. (Pen. Code, § 1214.)
This bill would mandate that restitution ordered to the victim be paid first, before any restitution fine can be collected.
- Constitutional Right to Victim Restitution
In 1982, Proposition 8 was approved by California voters to amend the California Constitution to establish the right of crime victims to receive restitution. The initiative provided that “It is the unequivocal intention of the People of the State of California that all persons who suffer losses as a result of criminal activity shall have the right to restitution from the persons convicted of the crimes for losses they suffer. Restitution shall be ordered from the convicted persons in every case, regardless of the sentence or disposition imposed, in which a crime victim suffers a loss, unless compelling and extraordinary reasons exist to the contrary.” (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 28, subd. (b).)
A trial court is required to order defendant to pay full restitution to victims of a crime “unless it finds compelling and extraordinary reasons for not doing so and states them on the record.” (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (f).) If the amount of restitution cannot be ascertained at the time of sentencing, the court shall include a provision in the restitution order that the restitution amount shall be determined at a future time. (Id.) The trial court must incorporate the restitution order in the defendant's conditions of probation. (Pen. Code, § 1202.4, subd. (m).)
When the court grants probation, payment of restitution must be made a condition of probation. (Pen. Code, 1202.4, subd. (m).) If part of a restitution order has not been paid after a defendant is no longer on probation, it remains enforceable by the victim as though it were a civil judgment. (Pen. Code, 1202.4, subd. (m); Pen. Code, § 1214.) Additionally, if the defendant is unable to pay full restitution within the initial term of probation, the court can modify and extend the period of probation to allow the defendant to pay off all restitution within the probation term. (Pen. Code, §1203.3, subd. (b)(4); People v. Cookson (1991) 54 Cal.3d 1091, 1097.) Generally, the probation term may be extended up to, but not beyond, the maximum probation period allowed for the offense. (People v Medeiros (1994) 25 Cal.App.4th 1260, 1267–1268.)
- Issues with Fulfilling Restitution Orders
This bill modifies how California’s FTB assesses restitution orders upon formerly incarcerated individuals. One of its main provisions establishes a “sliding scale model” for the FTB to use when setting amounts to be withheld from a person’s paycheck on a monthly basis. Currently, the FTB considers the ability of the defendant to pay on a case-by-case basis when determining their withholding orders, which can result in a lack of uniformity across the system. The sole metric that the FTB is bound to when setting a withholding order amount is according to Civil Code of Procedure § 706.050, which states that an order may not exceed twenty percent of an individual’s disposable income for the week, or if their wage exceeds forty percent of the amount by which the individual’s disposable earnings for that week exceed 48 times the state minimum hourly wage in effect at the time the earnings are payable. By mandating the use of a single sliding scale model, this bill would ensure that each defendant’s ability to pay is equally considered.
Currently, many restitution orders either go entirely unfulfilled or are only partially fulfilled. According to the Berkeley Law’s Policy Advocacy Clinic, in California, less than 1 percent of victims actually receive the amount as ordered, and 67 percent of victims receive no restitution or victim compensation at all. The clinic also found that the average restitution amount in California is about $10,000 and the average total of restitution fines were about $2,000.[1] People assessed with restitution will often live with this debt and victims in these cases receive little to no restitution at all.
The large percent of unfulfilled restitution payments can possibly be attributed to the ability of the defendant to pay the court-ordered amounts. A study conducted by the Brookings Institute found that nationally individuals who were incarcerated at some point during 2009-2013, in the first full year after their release, about 49 percent of formerly incarcerated individuals earn less than $500, 32 percent earn between $500 and $15,000, and only 20 percent earn more than $15,000.[2] The sponsor of this bill is concerned that formerly incarcerated individual’s inability to pay restitution combined with other pressures facing them will result in more of these individuals recidivating. And by easing this burden and allowing individuals to enter into payment plans more understanding of their situation could lead to more restitution orders being fulfilled and less recidivism.
- Argument in Support
According to the State Treasurer:
[SB 1035] will reduce the annual interest rates placed on restitution payments, increased payments, increased flexibility by requiring restitution payments be paid before administrative costs, and implementing a sliding scale model for FTB garnishments that considers income and ability to pay to determine the amount to be withheld while leaving the payments made toward victims intact. This step will reduce barriers to make these payments on time, which will ensure more money goes directly to victims and their families.
Current law requires a person who causes harm to pay restitution for any injury or loss caused to the victim. Restitution not only serves to indemnify the victim for a loss, but it also serves as a form of restorative justice for the offender. Interest is charged annually on restitution payments and collected by the Franchise Tax Board and Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. Additional penalties, including wage garnishment, are assessed for delinquent payments. Many formerly incarcerated individuals often struggle to make payments once they fall behind.
Unlike other debt, restitution has no statute of limitations and is not dischargeable in bankruptcy. Consequently, this debt can follow formerly incarcerated people for their entire lives. This can restrain their ability to build savings, support themselves and their families, successfully rehabilitate in their communities, and importantly, limit funds available to make restitution payments to victims since the state collects interest and penalties first. Approximately 80% of Californians owing restitution are living in poverty and unable to pay their debt. Not only does this make it nearly impossible for the victims’ families to receive payments that are owed, but this inability to pay restitution and pay off restitution debt also can lead to higher cases of recidivism.
If enacted, SB 1035 will allow formerly incarcerated individuals to have a real chance in assimilating into society while ensuring their payments go to victims.
- Argument in Opposition
According to the California Association of Judgment Professionals:
[…] A Crime Victim has a right to civil recovery against a criminal defendant for full economic losses he/she sustained as a result of the commission of a crime for which the defendant is found guilty.[3] When a court of law orders monetary restitution from the criminal defendant to the Victim, the resulting Victim Restitution Order is enforced as a civil judgment.[4]
A Victim’s Restitution “[s]hall be of a dollar amount that is sufficient to fully reimburse the victim or victims for every determined economic loss incurred as the result of the defendant’s criminal conduct, including, but not limited to…profits lost by the victim”.[5] A proposed interest rate “not exceeding 1 percent per annum” does not compensate the Victim for the economic loss of use of the funds owed. This proposed interest rate does not fully reimburse the Victim for his/her economic losses, and it rewards the defendant with an abnormally low interest rate. This measure incentivizes the defendant ignore the ordered restitution to the Victim.
[…] What SB 1035 fails to understand is that reducing the interest rate on a restitution order to “less than 1% interest”, would only encourage recidivism for two reasons. First, even if the criminals ever get caught, are convicted, and ordered to return that money or the value of the property to the Victim, the criminals will only have to pay “less than 1% interest” on that stolen money or asset. This is the equivalent of borrowing a low interest loan from a bank that enables the criminal to earn a much higher rate of return whether that return be through legitimate means or through other means that are criminal and less savvy in nature.
[…]The California Constitution Article XV, Section 1 permits judgment interest up to 10 percent per annum. The Legislature had two purposes in setting the interest rate on judgments at the current 10 percent per annum: 1) to compensate Judgment Creditors (ie. Victims) for their loss of use of their money ordered restored to them but unpaid, and 2) to encourage Judgment Debtors (ie. Defendant/Criminal) to pay or settle their judgments (ie. Victim Restitution). This purpose is still applicable today. Interest rates fluctuate year-by-year, but over the long-term, 10 percent interest per annum is not an outlandish rate because properly invested, a Judgment Creditor could earn 10% per annum on money invested.
The second part of this measure affects “restitution fines”, which are separate and distinct from Restitution Orders owed to the Victim. These “restitution fines” are solely punitive in nature and are payable to the State Treasury, not payable to a Victim.
Lowering the interest rate on the “restitution fine” portion of this measure, only affects the income of the State Treasury and that has no effect on the Victims; however, the measure should leave the interest rate at 10 percent for Victim Restitution Orders to assure Victims are not further victimized.
-- END –
Restitution Relief: Policy Advocacy Clinic Spearheads Reform Efforts to Lift a Lifelong Burden ↑
[Penal Code §§1202.4(a)(1), 1202.4(f) and 1202.4(k)] ↑
[Penal Code §§1191.2, 1202.4(a)(3)(B) 1202.4(i)] ↑
[Penal Code §1202.4(f)(3)] ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation
Senate Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):