SB 1062: Conversion of electrical generation facilities using biomass.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the Agricultural Biomass Utilization Account in the Department of Food and Agricultural Fund, which is administered by the Department of Food and Agriculture, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board and the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, for purposes of providing grants to persons that use agricultural biomass as a means for avoiding landfill use, preventing air pollution, and enhancing environmental quality.
This bill would require the Department of Conservation, on or before December 1, 2025, to establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities, as defined. The bill would require the department, Department of Conservation, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste, waste or agricultural biomass waste, as defined, and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department Department of Conservation their intent to convert the facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities. The bill would require the department Department of Conservation to request the relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided. The bill would require the department, Department of Conservation, on or before January 1, 2030, to establish a grant program to support the conversion of the generation facilities identified pursuant to the above-described provisions to advanced bioenergy technology facilities and would require an operator of a generation facility, in order to receive a grant, to develop and submit to the department Department of Conservation business plans meeting specified guidelines. The bill would prohibit actions taken by the department Department of Conservation and by operators of generation facilities pursuant to the above-described provisions from being funded by ratepayers.
Existing law establishes the Agricultural Biomass Utilization Account in the Department of Food and Agricultural Fund, which is administered by the Department of Food and Agriculture, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board and the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, for purposes of providing grants to persons that use agricultural biomass as a means for avoiding landfill use, preventing air pollution, and enhancing environmental quality.
This bill would require the Department of Conservation Conservation, on or before December 1, 2025, to develop establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. facilities, as defined. The bill would require the department, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that uses, use, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste, as defined, and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting intent to convert the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. technology facilities. The bill would require the department to request the relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided. The bill would require the department, on or before January 1, 2032, 2030, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements. conversion of the generation facilities identified pursuant to the above-described provisions to advanced bioenergy technology facilities and would require an operator of a generation facility, in order to receive a grant, to develop and submit to the department business plans meeting specified guidelines. The bill would prohibit actions taken by the department and by operators of generation facilities pursuant to the above-described provisions from being funded by ratepayers.
Existing law establishes the Agricultural Biomass Utilization Account in the Department of Food and Agricultural Fund, which is administered by the Department of Food and Agriculture, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board and the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, for purposes of providing grants to persons that use agricultural biomass as a means for avoiding landfill use, preventing air pollution, and enhancing environmental quality.
This bill would require the Department of Conservation to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of energy biomass generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. The bill would require the department, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, any type of clean woody biomass forest biomass waste, as defined, and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. The bill would require the department to request the relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, technologies applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided. The bill would require the department, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
The bill would require electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities identified by the department that receive applicable air permits from the relevant air district, develop business plans, and commit to the conversion of the generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities, as provided. By imposing additional requirements on local publicly owned electric utilities, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would prohibit the financial commitments from extending beyond January 1, 2041, and authorize a financial commitment to be terminated early if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity, as provided.Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.Because certain provisions of the bill would be a part of the act and a violation of a commission action implementing requirements of the bill would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.Existing law requires the Public Utilities Commission to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or before after June 1, 2013, as provided.
This bill would require the Department of Conservation to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. The bill would require the department, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, forest any type of clean woody biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. The bill would require a the department to request the relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to review and consider specific advanced air emission control technologies that are appropriate for the identified generation facilities, provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided. By imposing additional requirements on air districts, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the department, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
The bill would require electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities identified by the department that use or adopt the advanced air emission control technologies recommended by receive applicable air permits from the relevant air district, develop business plans, and commit to the conversion of the generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities, as provided. By imposing additional requirements on local publicly owned electric utilities, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would provide that prohibit the financial commitments terminate, at the latest, on from extending beyond January 1, 2041, and may authorize a financial commitment to be terminated earlier, early if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity, as provided.
Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because certain provisions of the bill would be a part of the act and a violation of a commission action implementing requirements of the bill would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.
Existing law requires the Public Utilities Commission to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or before June 1, 2013, as provided.
This bill would require the Department of Conservation to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. The bill would require the department, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, forest biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. The bill would require a relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to review and consider specific advanced air emission control technologies that are appropriate for the identified generation facilities, as provided. By imposing additional requirements on air districts, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the department, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
The bill would require electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities identified by the department that use or adopt the advanced air emission control technologies recommended by the relevant air district, develop business plans, and commit to the conversion of the generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities, as provided. By imposing additional requirements on local publicly owned electric utilities, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would provide that the financial commitments terminate, at the latest, on January 1, 2041, and may be terminated earlier, as provided.
Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or an order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because certain provisions of the bill would be a part of the act and a violation of a commission action implementing requirements of the bill would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for specified reasons.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law imposes various limitations on emissions of air contaminants for the control of air pollution from vehicular and nonvehicular sources. Existing law generally designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution, and air pollution control districts and air quality management districts with the primary responsibility for the control of air pollution from all sources other than vehicular sources.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to idled biomass facilities that are in need of new emissions technology in order to meet current air quality standards.Existing law imposes various limitations on emissions of air contaminants for the control of air pollution from vehicular and nonvehicular sources. Existing law generally designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution, and air pollution control districts and air quality management districts with the primary responsibility for the control of air pollution from all sources other than vehicular sources.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to idled biomass facilities that are in need of new emissions technology in order to meet current air quality standards.
Unless the context requires otherwise, for purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Advanced bioenergy technology facility means a noncombustion bioenergy facility that results in significant reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases relative to traditional technologies, and may include, but is not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuel production, or renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen.
(b)Agricultural biomass waste means agricultural crop residue, including woody debris and pruning, associated leaves and silvicultural residue, and orchard or vineyard removals, and the wood, wood chips, and wood waste that results from orchard or vineyard removals.
(b)(c)Department means the Department of Conservation.
(c)(d)District has the same meaning as set forth in Section 39025 of the Health and Safety Code.
(d)(e)Forest biomass waste means forest biomass that is removed to reduce or mitigate the risk of wildfire, reduce the risk to public safety or infrastructure from falling trees or tree limbs, or create defensible space, or for forest restoration projects.
(e)(f)Generation facility means an electrical generation facility using biomass.
(f)(g)Program means the Biomass Technology Transition Program established pursuant to Section 25994.10.
2.Biomass Technology Transition Program25994.10.On or before December 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the commission, the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and districts, shall establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program with relevant program terms to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities.
25994.11.(a)On or before December 1, 2025, the department shall identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste or agricultural biomass waste, and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their intent to convert their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities.
(b)The department shall request the relevant district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, as applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit. As part of the evaluation of the generation facilitys grant application pursuant to Section 25994.14, the department shall consider the upgrades needed by the generation facility to meet the emission limits equivalent to, or more stringent than, the applicable best available control technology, as determined by the district.
25994.12.(a)On or before January 1, 2026, for purposes of Section 25994.13, the department, in consultation with the commission, the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, districts, and relevant federal agencies, shall assess market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities, including, but not limited to, by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness.
(b)Beginning January 1, 2030, and every two years thereafter, the department shall update the assessment of market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy production technology facilities, including, but not limited to, by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness.
25994.13.(a)To receive a grant pursuant to Section 25994.14, the operator of a generation facility shall, on or before January 1, 2027, develop and submit to the department business plans pursuant to guidelines established by the department. The business plans may include a carbon sequestration component.
(b)The department shall establish guidelines that, at minimum, incorporate all of the following criteria:
(1)(A)On or before January 1, 2030, if the department estimates feasible market demand and technology readiness, as determined pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25994.12, for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities, the operator of the generation facility shall, within two years of the departments estimation, begin converting the existing generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility.
(B)The department may provide assistance through the grant program established pursuant to Section 25994.14 to those converted generation facilities to obtain offtake agreements for new products.
(2)After January 1, 2030, if the department determines that feasible market demand and technology readiness is estimated in the updated assessment required pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 25994.12, the operator of the generation facility shall, within two years of the departments estimation, begin converting the facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility.
(3)Ensure the business plans described in this subdivision are consistent, as applicable, with the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protections Joint Institute Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California approved on November 4, 2020.
25994.14.On or before January 1, 2030, the department shall establish a grant program to support the conversion of generation facilities identified pursuant to Section 25994.11 and in compliance with Section 25994.13 to advanced bioenergy technology facilities. Actions taken by the department and by operators of generation facilities pursuant to this chapter shall not be funded by ratepayers.
Unless the context requires otherwise, for purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Advanced bioenergy technology facility means a noncombustion bioenergy facility that results in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases relative to traditional technologies, and may include, but is not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuel production, or renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen.
(a)(b)Department means the Department of Conservation.
(b)(c)District has the same meaning as set forth in Section 39025 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)(d)Forest biomass waste means forest biomass that is removed to reduce or mitigate the risk of wildfire, reduce the risk to public safety or infrastructure from falling trees or tree limbs, or create defensible space, or for forest restoration projects.
(d)(e)Generation facility means an electrical generation facility using biomass.
(e)(f)Program means the Biomass Technology Transition Program established pursuant to Section 25994.10.
2.Biomass Technology Transition Program25994.10.(a)The On or before December 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the commission, the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and districts, shall establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program with relevant program terms to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. facilities.
(b)On or before December 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the commission, the State Air Resources Board, and the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, shall establish relevant program terms for purposes of the program.25994.11.(a)On or before December 1, 2025, the department shall identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting intent to convert their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. facilities.
(b)The department shall request the relevant district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, as applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, which shall be a factor in the consideration of the facilitys participation in the program. permit. As part of the evaluation of the generation facilitys grant application pursuant to Section 25994.14, the department shall consider the upgrades needed by the generation facility to meet the emission limits equivalent to, or more stringent than, the applicable best available control technology, as determined by the district.
25994.12.(a)On or before January 1, 2026, for purposes of Section 25994.13, the department, in consultation with the commission, the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, districts, and relevant federal agencies, shall assess market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities, including, but not limited to, by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness.
(b)Beginning January 1, 2030, and every two years thereafter, the department shall update the assessment of market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy production facilities, including, but not limited to, by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness.
25994.12.25994.13.(a)To receive a grant pursuant to Section 25994.13, 25994.14, the operator of a generation facility shall shall, on or before January 1, 2027, develop and submit to the department business plans pursuant to guidelines established by the department. The business plans may include a carbon sequestration component.
(b)The department shall establish guidelines that, at minimum, incorporate all of the following criteria:
(1)(A)On or before January 1, 2030, if the initial market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, for advanced bioenergy technologies, such as renewable natural gas, hydrogen, or other advanced energy technology development, the operator begins development of business plans to convert to those technologies. Those business plans shall also include a carbon sequestration component. The development of the business plans shall be completed on or before January 1, 2032.(1)(A)On or before January 1, 2030, if the department estimates feasible market demand and technology readiness, as determined pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 25994.12, for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities, the operator of the generation facility shall, within two years of the departments estimation, begin converting the existing generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility.
(B)On or before January 1, 2033, if the advanced market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility. The department shall may provide assistance through the grant program established pursuant to Section 25994.14 to those converted generation facilities to obtain offtake agreements for new products through the grant program established pursuant to Section 25994.13. products.
(2)(A)If the department determines, on or before January 1, 2030, that the initial benchmarks are not met, the department shall, on or before January 1, 2032, and every two years thereafter, determine if the initial benchmarks are met.(B)If the department determines that the initial benchmarks are met in a determination required pursuant to subparagraph (A), the operator of the generation facility shall adopt the business plans specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) within two years of the departments determination and the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility upon a determination by the department that the advanced market benchmarks are met.(2)After January 1, 2030, if the department determines that feasible market demand and technology readiness is estimated in the updated assessment required pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 25994.12, the operator of the generation facility shall, within two years of the departments estimation, begin converting the facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility.
(3)Ensure the business plans described in this subdivision are consistent, as applicable, with the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protections Joint Institute Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California approved on November 4, 2020.
(c)For purposes of this section, the department, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and relevant federal agencies, shall establish market benchmarks for advanced bioenergy technologies.25994.13.25994.14.On or before January 1, 2032, 2030, the department shall establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies, including, but not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuels, linear generators, renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen, as determined appropriate by the department, from the conversion of generation facilities identified pursuant to Section 25994.11 and in compliance with Section 25994.12 that result in substantially lower emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases. 25994.13 to advanced bioenergy technology facilities. Actions taken by the department and by operators of generation facilities pursuant to this chapter shall not be funded by ratepayers.
Unless the context requires otherwise, for purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Department means the Department of Conservation.
(b)District has the same meaning as set forth in Section 39025 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)Forest biomass waste means forest biomass that is removed to reduce or mitigate the risk of wildfire, reduce the risk to public safety or infrastructure from falling trees or tree limbs, or create defensible space, or for forest restoration projects.
(c)(d)Generation facility means an electrical generation facility using biomass.
(d)(e)Program means the Biomass Technology Transition Program established pursuant to Section 25993.10. 25994.10.
2.Biomass Technology Transition Program25993.10.25994.10.(a)The department, in consultation with the commission, the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and districts, shall establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program with relevant program terms to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
(b)On or before December 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the commission, the State Air Resources Board Board, and the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, shall establish relevant program terms for purposes of the program.
25993.11.25994.11.(a)On or before December 1, 2025, the department shall identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, any type of clean woody biomass forest biomass waste and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
(b)The department shall request the relevant district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, technologies, as applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, which shall be a factor in the consideration of the facilitys participation in the program.
25993.12.A generation facility identified pursuant to Section 25993.11 is an eligible facility for purposes of Section 399.20.4 of the Public Utilities Code if the operator of the facility does both of the following:(a)Receives any applicable air permit from the relevant district.(b)Develops business plans and commits to the conversion of the generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility as provided in Section 25993.13.25993.13.25994.12.(a)To receive a grant pursuant to Section 25993.14, 25994.13, the operator of a generation facility shall develop business plans pursuant to guidelines established by the department. The guidelines shall, at minimum, include both of the following metrics:
(b)The department shall establish guidelines that, at minimum, incorporate all of the following criteria:
(1)(A)On or before January 1, 2030, if the initial market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, for advanced bioenergy technologies, such as renewable natural gas, hydrogen, or other advanced energy technology development, the operator begins development of business plans to convert to those technologies. Those business plans shall also include a carbon sequestration component. The development of the business plans shall be completed on or before January 1, 2032.
(B)On or before January 1, 2033, if the advanced market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility. The department shall provide assistance to those converted generation facilities to obtain offtake agreements for new products through the grant program established pursuant to Section 25993.14. 25994.13.
(2)(A)If the department determines, on or before January 1, 2030, that the initial benchmarks are not met, the department shall, on or before January 1, 2032, and every two years thereafter, determine if the initial benchmarks are met.
(B)If the department determines that the initial benchmarks are met in a determination required pursuant to subparagraph (A), the operator of the generation facility shall adopt the business plans specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) within two years of the departments determination and the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility upon a determination by the department that the advanced market benchmarks are met.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 399.20.4 of the Public Utilities Code, financial commitments made to the generation facility pursuant to that section shall terminate upon the occurrence of any of the following:(1)The completion of the conversion by the generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity. (2)The operator of the generation facility fails to prepare a business plan required by paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).(3)The operator of the generation facility fails to convert the generation facility as required by paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).(3)Ensure the business plans described in this subdivision are consistent, as applicable, with the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protections Joint Institute Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California approved on November 4, 2020.
(c)For purposes of this section, the department, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and relevant federal agencies, shall establish market benchmarks for advanced bioenergy technologies.
25993.14.25994.13.On or before January 1, 2032, the department shall establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies, including, but not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuels, linear generators, renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen, as determined appropriate by the department, from generation facilities identified pursuant to Section 25993.11 25994.11 and in compliance with Section 25993.13 25994.12 that result in substantially lower emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
SEC. 2.Section 399.20.4 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:399.20.4.(a)In addition to subdivision (f) of Section 399.20 and subdivision (b) of Section 399.30, on or before December 1, 2026, electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities with 100,000 or more connections shall collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from generation facilities that comply with Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code. The commission shall allocate the proportionate share, as determined pursuant to subdivision (c), of the 125 megawatts to each electrical corporation and local publicly owned electric utility.(b)A community choice aggregator may participate in the procurement pursuant to subdivision (a) if the commission, in consultation with the Department of Conservation, on or before December 1, 2025, determines that a process described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (f) of Section 399.20 is appropriate for purposes of this section and Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 25993) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code.(c)On or before December 1, 2025, the commission, in consultation with the Department of Conservation, shall determine the proportionate share for purposes of subdivision (a).(d)An early termination of the financial commitment described in subdivision (a) shall occur if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity. The commission shall establish and require standard contractual language to reflect the potential early termination without penalty to either party for contracts made to effectuate the financial commitment described in subdivision (a). The commission shall also provide the standard contractual language to the local publicly owned electric utilities for inclusion in contracts made by the local publicly owned electric utilities for the financial commitments made pursuant to subdivision (a). (e)(1)For electrical corporations, before approving a financial commitment made pursuant to this section, the commission shall ensure that any applicable air permits, as required by Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code, are obtained for the generation facility.(2)Before entering into a financial commitment, a local publicly owned electric utility shall ensure that any applicable air permits, as required by Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code, are obtained for the generation facility.(f)(1)Financial commitments made pursuant to this section shall not extend beyond January 1, 2041.(2)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2041, and as of that date is repealed.SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act or because costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.Unless the context requires otherwise, for purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Department means the Department of Conservation.
(b)District has the same meaning as set forth in Section 39025 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)Generation facility means an electrical generation facility using biomass.
(d)Program means the Biomass Technology Transition Program developed established pursuant to Section 25993.10.
2.Biomass Technology Transition Program25993.10.(a)The department, in consultation with the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and districts, shall establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program with relevant program terms to support the conversion of generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
(b)On or before December 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board and the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, shall establish relevant program terms for purposes of the program.
25993.11.(a)On or before December 1, 2025, the department shall identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, forest any type of clean woody biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
(b)The relevant district shall review and recommend to the department specific advanced air emission control technologies, such as ceramic filtration and other criteria pollution control technologies, that are appropriate for each identified generation facility considering the attainment status of the air basin in which the facility is located, proximity to sensitive receptors, and other factors determined appropriated by the district.(b)The department shall request the relevant district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, which shall be a factor in the consideration of the facilitys participation in the program.
25993.12.A generation facility identified pursuant to Section 25993.11 is an eligible facility for purposes of Section 399.20.4 of the Public Utilities Code if the operator of the facility does both of the following:
(a)Uses or adopts advanced air emission control technologies recommended by the relevant local air district pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 25993.11.(a)Receives any applicable air permit from the relevant district.
(b)Develops business plans and commits to the conversion of the generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility as provided in Section 25993.13.
25993.13.(a)To receive a grant pursuant to Section 25993.14, the operator of a generation facility shall develop business plans pursuant to guidelines established by the department. The guidelines shall, at minimum, include both of the following metrics:
(1)(A)On or before January 1, 2030, if the initial market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, for advanced bioenergy technologies, such as renewable natural gas, hydrogen, or other advanced energy technology development, the operator begins development of business plans to convert to those technologies. Those business plans shall also include a carbon sequestration component. The development of the business plans shall be completed on or before January 1, 2032.
(B)On or before January 1, 2033, if the advanced market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility. The department shall provide assistance to those converted generation facilities to obtain offtake agreements for new products through the grant program established pursuant to Section 25993.14.
(2)(A)If the department determines, on or before January 1, 2030, that the initial benchmarks are not met, the department shall, on or before January 1, 2032, and every two years thereafter, determine if the initial benchmarks are met.
(B)If the department determines that the initial benchmarks are met in a determination required pursuant to subparagraph (A), the operator of the generation facility shall adopt the business plans specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) within two years of the departments determination and the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility upon a determination by the department that the advanced market benchmarks are met.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 399.20.4 of the Public Utilities Code, financial commitments made to the generation facility pursuant to that section shall terminate upon the occurrence of any of the following:
(1)The completion of the conversion by the generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity.
(2)The operator of the generation facility fails to prepare a business plan required by paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).
(3)The operator of the generation facility fails to convert the generation facility as required by paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).
(c)For purposes of this section, the department, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and relevant federal agencies, shall establish market benchmarks for advanced bioenergy technologies.
25993.14.On or before January 1, 2032, the department shall establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies, including, but not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuels, linear generators, renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen, as determined appropriate by the department, from generation facilities identified pursuant to Section 25993.11 and in compliance with Section 25993.13 that result in substantially lower emissions of criteria pollutant, pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
SEC. 2.Section 399.20.4 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:399.20.4.(a)In addition to subdivision (f) of Section 399.20 and subdivision (b) of Section 399.30, on or before December 1, 2026, electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities with 100,000 or more connections shall collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from generation facilities that comply with Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code. The commission shall allocate the proportionate share, as determined pursuant to subdivision (c), of the 125 megawatts to each electrical corporation and local publicly owned electric utility.
(b)A community choice aggregator may participate in the procurement pursuant to subdivision (a) if the commission, in consultation with the Department of Conservation, on or before December 1, 2025, determines that a process described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (f) of Section 399.20 is appropriate for purposes of this section and Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 25993) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code.
(c)On or before December 1, 2025, the commission, in consultation with the Department of Conservation, shall determine the proportionate share for purposes of subdivision (a).
(d)An early termination of the financial commitment described in subdivision (a) shall occur if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity. The commission shall establish and require standard contractual language to reflect the potential early termination without penalty to either party for contracts made to effectuate the financial commitment described in subdivision (a). The commission shall also provide the standard contractual language to the local publicly owned electric utilities for inclusion in contracts made by the local publicly owned electric utilities for the financial commitments made pursuant to subdivision (a).
(e)(1)For electrical corporations, before approving a financial commitment made pursuant to this section, the commission shall ensure that any advanced air emissions control technologies, applicable air permits, as required by Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code, are installed at obtained for the generation facility.
(2)Before entering into a financial commitment, a local publicly owned electric utility shall ensure that any advanced air emissions control technologies, applicable air permits, as required by Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code, are installed at obtained for the generation facility.
(f)(1)Financial commitments made pursuant to this section shall not extend beyond January 1, 2041.
(2)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2041, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.As to certain provisions of this act, no No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act or because costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As to other provisions of this act, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.Unless the context requires otherwise, for purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Department means the Department of Conservation.
(b)District has the same meaning as set forth in Section 39025 of the Health and Safety Code.
(c)Generation facility means an electrical generation facility using biomass.
(d)Program means the Biomass Technology Transition Program developed pursuant to Section 25993.10.
2.Biomass Technology Transition Program25993.10.(a)The department, in consultation with the Public Utilities Commission, the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and districts, shall establish and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program with relevant program terms to support the conversion of generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
(b)On or before December 1, 2025, the department, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board and the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, shall establish relevant program terms for purposes of the program.
25993.11.(a)On or before December 1, 2025, the department shall identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, forest biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
(b)The relevant district shall review and recommend to the department specific advanced air emission control technologies, such as ceramic filtration and other criteria pollution control technologies, that are appropriate for each identified generation facility considering the attainment status of the air basin in which the facility is located, proximity to sensitive receptors, and other factors determined appropriated by the district.
25993.12.A generation facility identified pursuant to Section 25993.11 is an eligible facility for purposes of Section 399.20.4 of the Public Utilities Code if the operator of the facility does both of the following:
(a)Uses or adopts advanced air emission control technologies recommended by the relevant local air district pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 25993.11.
(b)Develops business plans and commits to the conversion of the generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility as provided in Section 25993.13.
25993.13.(a)To receive a grant pursuant to Section 25993.14, the operator of a generation facility shall develop business plans pursuant to guidelines established by the department. The guidelines shall, at minimum, include both of the following metrics:
(1)(A)On or before January 1, 2030, if the initial market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, for advanced bioenergy technologies, such as renewable natural gas, hydrogen, or other advanced energy technology development, the operator begins development of business plans to convert to those technologies. Those business plans shall also include a carbon sequestration component. The development of the business plans shall be completed on or before January 1, 2032.
(B)On or before January 1, 2033, if the advanced market benchmarks are met, as determined by the department, the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility. The department shall provide assistance to those converted generation facilities to obtain offtake agreements for new products through the grant program established pursuant to Section 25993.14.
(2)(A)If the department determines, on or before January 1, 2030, that the initial benchmarks are not met, the department shall, on or before January 1, 2032, and every two years thereafter, determine if the initial benchmarks are met.
(B)If the department determines that the initial benchmarks are met in a determination required pursuant to subparagraph (A), the operator of the generation facility shall adopt the business plans specified in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) within two years of the departments determination and the generation facility shall convert to an advanced bioenergy technology facility upon a determination by the department that the advanced market benchmarks are met.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 399.20.4 of the Public Utilities Code, financial commitments made to the generation facility pursuant to that section shall terminate upon the occurrence of any of the following:
(1)The completion of the conversion by the generation facility to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity.
(2)The operator of the generation facility fails to prepare a business plan required by paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).
(3)The operator of the generation facility fails to convert the generation facility as required by paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a).
(c)For purposes of this section, the department, in consultation with the State Air Resources Board, the Governors Office of Business and Economic Development, the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank, and relevant federal agencies, shall establish market benchmarks for advanced bioenergy technologies.
25993.14.On or before January 1, 2032, the department shall establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies, including, but not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuels, linear generators, renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen, as determined appropriate by the department, from generation facilities identified pursuant to Section 25993.11 and in compliance with Section 25993.13 that result in substantially lower emissions of criteria pollutant, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
SEC. 2.Section 399.20.4 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:399.20.4.(a)In addition to subdivision (f) of Section 399.20 and subdivision (b) of Section 399.30, on or before December 1, 2026, electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities with 100,000 or more connections shall collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts of cumulative rated generation capacity from generation facilities that comply with Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code. The commission shall allocate the proportionate share, as determined pursuant to subdivision (c), of the 125 megawatts to each electrical corporation and local publicly owned electric utility.
(b)A community choice aggregator may participate in the procurement pursuant to subdivision (a) if the commission, in consultation with the Department of Conservation, on or before December 1, 2025, determines that a process described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (f) of Section 399.20 is appropriate for purposes of this section and Chapter 16 (commencing with 25993) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code.
(c)On or before December 1, 2025, the commission, in consultation with the Department of Conservation, shall determine the proportionate share for purposes of subdivision (a).
(d)An early termination of the financial commitment described in subdivision (a) shall occur if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity. The commission shall establish and require standard contractual language to reflect the potential early termination without penalty to either party for contracts made to effectuate the financial commitment described in subdivision (a). The commission shall also provide the standard contractual language to the local publicly owned electric utilities for inclusion in contracts made by the local publicly owned electric utilities for the financial commitments made pursuant to subdivision (a).
(e)(1)For electrical corporations, before approving a financial commitment made pursuant to this section, the commission shall ensure that any advanced air emissions control technologies, as required by Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code, are installed at the generation facility.
(2)Before entering into a financial commitment, a local publicly owned electric utility shall ensure that any advanced air emissions control technologies, as required by Section 25993.12 of the Public Resources Code, are installed at the generation facility.
(f)(1)Financial commitments made pursuant to this section shall not extend beyond January 1, 2041.
(2)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2041, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 3.As to certain provisions of this act, no reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act or because costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
As to other provisions of this act, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to idled biomass facilities that are in need of new emissions technology in order to meet current air quality standards.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to idled biomass facilities that are in need of new emissions technology in order to meet current air quality standards.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 1). |
| Jun 24, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 20, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (June 19). |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on U. & E. and NAT. RES. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 4140.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3970.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2024 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 29, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 3753.) (April 24). |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. (Ayes 17. Noes 0. Page 3632.) (April 16). Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Set for hearing April 16. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Re-referred to Coms. on E., U. & C. and E.Q. |
| Mar 20, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 21, 2024 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 9, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 10. |
| Feb 8, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1062 Dahle | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Against | |
| Golden State Power Cooperative | ** Support | |
| Natural Resources Defense Council | ** Against | |
| Natural Resources Defense Council and NRDC Action Fund | ** Against | |
| Placer County Air Pollution Control District | ** Support | |
| Southern California Public Power Authority | ** Against |
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1062
Author:(Dahle) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Energy | Vote: | 13 - 0 |
Natural Resources | 8 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill creates the Biomass Technology Transition Program (program) to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities.
Specifically, this bill:
- Defines an advanced bioenergy technology facility as a noncombustion bioenergy facility that results in significant reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases relative to traditional technologies, and may include, but is not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuel production, or renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen.
- By December 1, 2025, requires the Department of Conservation (Conservation)—in consultation with the California Energy Commission (CEC), the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), the Air Resources Board (ARB), the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz), the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank (IBank), and local air districts—to establish and administer the program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities.
- By December 1, 2025, directs Conservation to (a) identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 megawatts or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste or agricultural biomass waste, and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to Conservation their intent to convert their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities, and (b) request the relevant air district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit.
- By January 1, 2026, requires Conservation—in consultation with the CEC, the CPUC, ARB, GO-Biz, the IBank, the air districts and relevant federal agencies—to assess market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness and, beginning January 1, 2030, and every two years thereafter, to update the assessment.
- By January 1, 2030, requires Conservation to establish a grant program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities.
- Explicitly prohibits the requirements of this bill from being funded by utility ratepayers.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Cost pressure of an unknown, but significant amount, likely in the millions of dollars to tens of millions of dollars, to provide funding for the grant program created by this bill (General Fund, bond funds or other source of funds).
- Conservation contends it does not know how much it will cost it to implement this bill because the cost “depends on how much funding might be appropriated for grant planning, administration and awards.” As an example of potential costs, Conservation notes if $50 million were appropriated for grants, it could cover associated staff and contracts with a 5% administrative cost allocation.
Conservation notes it would need to conduct a bioenergy market assessment, and undertake related work, at a first-year cost of between $775,000 to $1 million and an ongoing annual cost of $486,000 (General Fund or special fund). The bill does not condition this work upon appropriation of funding for the grant program.
- The CEC estimates needing one new staff member at an ongoing annual cost of $201,000 to conduct the market assessment and to help implement and administer the grant program. The CEC acknowledges the Energy Resources Programs Account (ERPA) is its primary operating account; however, the CEC cautions ERPA may not be able to support these costs because of an ongoing structural deficit.
- ARB contends it will need one air pollution control specialist, at an ongoing annual cost of $220,000, to fulfill the consultation duties required by this bill (Agricultural Biomass Utilization Account).
- Costs to CPUC, the IBank and GO-Biz likely will range from the tens of thousands of dollars to low hundreds of thousands of dollars annually ongoing (special fund for CPUC, General Fund for GO-Biz and the IBank).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author intends this bill to provide funding to aging biomass facilities to help them modernize and remain in operation. According to the author:
California has experienced some of the worst wildfires in state history in recent years. The millions of tons of dry wood waste that have been building up in our forests is one of the many reasons why recent fires have gotten out of control. I have supported the recent efforts to expand the use of biomass energy so we can ensure this harmful waste is removed and wildfire risk is reduced. However, there is more to be done. Biomass facilities across the state are struggling to keep up with emissions regulations and many simply cannot afford to acquire new technologies. This bill will help biomass facilities acquire new emissions reducing technology while also providing them with the financial security needed to allow them to continue clearing our forests of the excess woody debris.
- Background. Much of the state in covered in forests. Much of this forestland is prone to wildfire.
Following particularly devastating wildfires over the first decades of this century, the state committed to improving forest health and, thereby, decreasing the risk of wildfire. Notable in regards to this commitment was passage of SB 901 (Dodd), Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018, which requires California to double forest “fuel” removal to reduce the risks of catastrophic wildfires.
Prescribed burns are one way to remove forest fuel. Another is mechanical thinning, in which woody biomass is physically removed from the forest.
An ongoing challenge for forest managers, and policy makers, is deciding what to do with the millions of tons of biomass that is removed from forests. One option is to ignite the biomass in what are known as “burn piles.” This open burning disposes of the biomass. Yet, it also creates air pollution, increases wildfire risk and secures no additional benefits from the forest “waste.”
One way to dispose of biomass removed from the forest is to combust it to produce heat that, in turn, is used to generate electricity. The state has long subsidized the costs of operating facilities that combust biomass for this purpose. For example, statute requires the state’s large investor-owned utilities each to purchase electric generating capacity from existing bioenergy projects. Similarly, the Budget Act of 2022 allocated $50 million to Conservation to support creation of carbon-negative hydrogen and liquid fuel from forest biomass coming from forest vegetation management within the Sierra Nevada. In 2023, Conservation awarded grants of $500,000 each to eight projects in the Sierra Nevada for technology demonstration and planning activities that simultaneously manage catastrophic wildfire risks, address rural economic development and develop carbon-negative fuels resulting from forest vegetation management. (Subsequently, the Budget Act of 2023 reverted $45.5 million of the $50 million appropriation.)
As evidenced by the $50 million appropriation described in the preceding paragraph, there is hope in the potential for forest biomass to produce carbon-negative fuels, such as hydrogen. So, too, is there hope, among some, that the state’s existing biomass combustion facilities—most of them aging, cost-ineffective and utilizing combustion technology—could be converted to produce carbon-negative fuels using forest biomass.
This bill establishes a framework to fund such a conversion. However, neither this bill nor this year’s budget act provide funding for this purpose.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1062
Author:(Dahle) – As Amended Ver:June 24, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Energy: conversion of biomass energy generation facilities.
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Conservation (DOC) to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program (Program) to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities by December 1, 2025. Requires DOC to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies by January 1, 2032.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 megawatts (MW) of cumulative rated generation capacity from bioenergy derived from organic waste diversion, dairy and agricultural resources, and byproducts of forest management. Requires the CPUC to encourage investor-owned utilities (IOUs) to develop programs and services that facilitate development of bioenergy and biogas. This program is known as the Bioenergy Market Adjusting Tariff (BioMAT). (Public Utilities Code (PUC) 399.20)
- Requires CPUC to establish a renewables portfolio standard (RPS) that requires retail sellers of electricity to procure 60% from eligible renewable energy resources by 2030. (PUC 399.15)
- Includes biomass in the definition of “renewable electrical generation facility” for purposes of the state’s RPS. (Public Resources Code (PRC) 25741)
- Defines “biomass conversion” as the production of heat, fuels, or electricity by the controlled combustion of, or the use of other noncombustion thermal conversion technologies on specified materials when separated from other solid waste. (PRC 40106)
- Establishes the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) to represent the state's interest in the acquisition and management of state forests, protect the state's interests in forest resources on private lands, and determine, establish, and maintain an adequate forest policy. (PRC 730 and 740)
- Requires an electrical corporation, local publicly owned electric utility, or community choice aggregator with a contract to procure electricity generated from biomass that expires or expired on or before December 31, 2028, to seek to amend the contract to include, or seek approval for a new contract that includes, an expiration date five years later than the expiration date in the contract that was operative in 2022, except as specified. (PUC 8388)
THIS BILL:
- Requires DOC, in consultation with the California Energy Commission (CEC), the Air resources Board (ARB), the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz), the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank (I-Bank), and air pollution control districts or air quality management districts (air districts), to establish the Program with relevant program terms to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities by December 1, 2025.
- Requires DOC to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 MW or greater that use, or are in the process of recommissioning or redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to DOC their intent to convert their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities.
- Requires DOC to request the relevant air district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, as applicable to the air district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit. As part of the evaluation of a grant application, requires DOC to consider the upgrades needed by the generation facility to meet the emission limits equivalent to, or more stringent than, the applicable best available control technology, as determined by the air district.
- Requires DOC, in consultation with CEC, CPUC, ARB, GO-Biz, I-Bank, air districts, and relevant federal agencies, to assess market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities, including, but not limited to, by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness, by January 1, 2026.
- Requires DOC to update the assessment of market conditions for products from “advanced bioenergy production facilities,” including, but not limited to, by estimating feasible market demand and technology readiness, by January 1, 2030.
- Requires an operator of a generation facility to develop and submit business plans to DOC by January 1, 2027. Authorizes the business plans to include a carbon sequestration component. Requires DOC to develop guidelines that, at a minimum, incorporate:
- On or before January 1, 2030, if DOC estimates feasible market demand and technology readiness for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities pursuant to the assessment, require the operator to begin converting the existing generation facility within two years. Authorizes DOC to provide assistance to those converted generation facilities to obtain offtake agreements for new products.
- After January 1, 2030, if DOC determines that feasible market demand and technology readiness pursuant to an updated assessment, require the operator to begin converting the existing generation facility within two years.
- Ensure that the business plans are consistent, as applicable, with the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection’s Joint Institute for Wood Products Innovation (Institute) Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California.
- Requires DOC to establish a grant program to support the conversion of generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities by January 1, 2030. Specifies that actions taken by DOC and operators of generation facilities pursuant to the bill shall not be funded by ratepayers.
- Defines terms used in the bill, including:
- “Advanced bioenergy technology facility” as a noncombustion bioenergy facility that results in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases relative to traditional technologies, and may include, but is not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuel production, or renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen.
- “Forest biomass waste” as forest biomass that is removed to reduce or mitigate the risk of wildfire, reduce the risk to public safety or infrastructure from falling trees or tree limbs, create defensible space, or for forest restoration projects; and,
- “Generation facility” as an electrical generation facility using biomass.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations:
- DOC notes that any costs estimates ultimately would be dependent on the amount of funding allocated to the grant program, but estimates, if the Legislature were to appropriate $50 million in funding, one-time costs of $250,000 (special fund) for a contract to develop bioenergy market benchmarks, and ongoing costs of $486,000 annually (special fund) for grant planning, administration, and oversight.
- ARB estimates ongoing costs of about $220,000 annually (special fund) to meet the consultation requirements of the bill.
- Unknown but likely significant cost pressure (various funds) to provide funding for the grant program established by this bill.
COMMENTS:
- Biomass. Biomass includes agricultural and forest residue. There are a variety of bioenergy technologies that use biomass as feedstock, including direct combustion (biomass conversion) and combustion of biomass derived gases (biogas), which are generated from digesters and landfills or through technologies like gasification and pyrolysis.
Forest operations such as logging, thinning, fuels reduction programs, and ecosystem restoration create huge amounts of woody biomass, and as much as half of that biomass is left in the forest. According to CEC, there are approximately 47 million bone dry tons (BDT) of biomass resource potential in California. According to the Board, state requirements to remove forest fuels on one million acres per year to reduce wildfire risk will generate 10 to 15 million BDT of forest biomass annually. Biomass materials are often piled and burned, creating air pollutants like black carbon, or left to decay, creating methane, which has a global warming potential 28 times more powerful than carbon dioxide (CO₂) over a 100-year time horizon. Identifying uses for this material, including energy generation, has the potential to reduce the overall emissions and reduce the fire risk of this material.
- California Joint Institute for Wood Products Innovation. The Institute was established by Executive Order B-52-18 to facilitate innovation to develop and expand a robust and sustainable forest products market. The Institute’s goal is to identify market and workforce gaps and opportunities for innovation, as well as supporting research to develop new uses for forest products. The Institute includes representatives from academia and the state, and reports to the Board. In November of 2020, the Institute released its Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California, which identifies goals and recommendations for the state to expand wood and biomass products markets with the intent of supporting “carbon-beneficial, sustainable forest management.” In addition to extensive specific initial actions, the recommendations include the following activities:
- Provide financial incentives, leveraging public dollars to attract private capital to support demand for innovate wood and biomass products markets.
- Identify priority wood products manufacturing centers in or near forested communities throughout the state, based on the New Markets Tax Credit, Opportunity Zones, locations that reduce hauling costs, proximity to solid infrastructure (roads, highways, ports, etc.), and brownfields incentives.
- Provide grants to support workforce development.
- Develop science and technology-based regional strategies that prioritize achievable solutions.
- Encourage coordination among agencies delivering funding or conducting procurement or relevant regulatory activities to enhance overall outcomes of state investments.
- Facilitate information flow between state, federal, tribal, and local governments; utilities; and, other non-governmental organizations.
- Identify and harmonize cross-jurisdictional regulatory and permitting requirements for wood and biomass infrastructure.
- Leverage agency expertise in forest management, funding, or regulation.
- Provide consistent and coordinated messaging to stakeholders and the public.
- Measure progress and monitor outcomes to inform future activities.
- Biomass energy. In 2019, California increased its aggressive renewable energy goals to require that renewable sources provide 60% of electricity by 2030, and renewable and carbon-free sources must provide 100% of electricity by 2045. Unlike variable renewable energy resources (i.e., solar and wind), bioenergy technologies can provide reliable and renewable baseload generation, or firm power, meaning that electricity can be generated consistently during scheduled times and at predetermined power levels.
The technical electricity potential of biomass feedstock products is 35,000 gigawatt hours (GWh) or enough to support 4,650 MW of capacity. CEC’s report, Utility-Scale Renewable Energy Generation Technology Roadmap, estimates that the resulting electricity generation possible from bioenergy if the entire technical capacity is captured is 21,500 GWh, which would be enough electricity to provide 6.6% of the state’s 2045 goal.
Currently, there are currently about 30 direct-combustion biomass facilities in operation with a capacity of 640 MW. These biomass plants use about five million BDT of biomass per year – or about 10% of the total BDT biomass resource potential.
Last session, the Legislature approved SB 1109 (Caballero), Chapter 364, Statutes of 2022, to extend requirements on electric IOUs and community choice aggregators to procure energy from biomass generating electric facilities by five years and requires extension of existing contracts by five years. The bill also extended electrical corporations’ obligation to collectively procure their proportionate share of 125 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from existing bioenergy projects commencing operation before June 1, 2013, through financial commitments of 5 to 15 years.
- Challenges to biomass energy. CEC’s Estimated Cost of New Utility-Scale Generation in California: 2018 Update states that some of California’s biomass plants that began operation in the 1980s and 1990s have either shut down or been idled as their production contracts expired. Meanwhile, California’s forestry waste has increased as drought, heat, and tree die-off have resulted in large amounts of fuel for forest fires. As a result, some idled biomass generation has come back into operation, though not necessarily at full capacity, and new projects are being developed. There are limitations to utility scale biomass combustion, including cost of feedstock, which is highly variable due to the transportation from rural, mountainous areas to biomass facilities. Air quality standards presents another challenge, as biomass conversion produces air emissions.
While these facilities play an important role in mitigating wildfire risk, many facilities are decades-old and still rely on combustion technology. Remaining biomass facilities may have opportunities for technological improvements to reduce emissions and increase forest waste processing capabilities.
- DOC funding. In Fiscal Year 21-22, the Legislature appropriated $50 million to DOC to create carbon-negative fuels from materials resulting from forest vegetation management. DOC established the Forest Biomass to Carbon-Negative Biofuels Pilot Program, which has awarded six $500,000 awards to applicants within the Sierra Nevada region for projects that demonstrate technologies and plan for the creation of energy from Sierra Nevada-sourced forest biomass to offset the use of fossil fuel, improve forest and community resilience, and create regional economic opportunities. If successfully constructed and operated, the biofuels facilities proposed by the grantees have the potential to use more than 800,000 BDT of forest waste woody biomass annually, which would help facilitate the management of 80,000 acres for environmental health and wildfire resilience. Proposed future grant selections will offer funding for facility construction, and will include financial commitments to up to four individual projects of up to $20 million. DOC administers the grant program in coordination with CEC, ARB, CPUC, GO-Biz, the I-Bank, and other entities.
- This bill. SB 1062 is intended to build on the existing coordinating between DOC and the other state entities listed in the bill to further biomass energy generation by providing grants to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 MW or more using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gas emissions.
- Jurisdiction. Both Senate policy committees that heard this bill proposed moving the Program from DOC to CEC. This amendment was rejected by the author, who wished to keep the Program at DOC.
DOC was allocated $50 million in the 2022 Budget to focus on creating carbon-negative hydrogen and/or liquid fuel from forest biomass coming from forest vegetation management within California's Sierra Nevada. This aligns with the focus of SB 1062, but it was also DOC’s entrance into the biomass-into-biofuels arena. A draft of program solicitation guidelines was released in November of last year, but no grants have been awarded.
CEC, on the other hand, has been active in this space since the passage of SB 771 (Kehoe), Chapter 598, Statutes of 2011, which created the Biomass Development Program. That program was intended to accelerate the development of sustainable emerging biomass energy technologies in California by addressing the technical issues and providing long-term support, funding, or seed money in order to achieve prompt commercial readiness and maximize benefits to the state. CEC has also previously administered the Energy Technology Advancement Program and currently runs the Public Interest Energy Research Program, both of which touch upon these technologies.
This array of programs suggests CEC has considerable expertise in the biomass facilities targeted by the Program created by SB 1062. CEC could further have other important technical knowledge that could be helpful in administering the Program, including the future grants available under it. The committee and the author may wish to consider whether DOC is the appropriate entity to administer the Program.
- Author’s statement:
California has experienced some of the worst wildfires in state history in recent years. The millions of tons of dry wood waste that have been building up in our forests is one of the many reasons why recent fires have gotten out of control. I have supported the recent efforts to expand the use of biomass energy so we can ensure this harmful waste is removed and wildfire risk is reduced. However, there is more to be done. Biomass facilities across the state are struggling to keep up with emissions regulations and many simply cannot afford to acquire new technologies. This bill will help biomass facilities acquire new emissions reducing technology while also providing them with the financial security needed to allow them to continue clearing our forests of the excess woody debris.
- Double referral. This bill was passed by the Assembly Utility and Energy Committee on June 19th, with a vote of 13-0.
- Suggested amendments. This bill requires DOC to develop the Program to support emissions reductions by encouraging the conversion of biomass generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities. However, the definition of advanced bioenergy technology facility applies to a facility or upgrade that results in any amount of emission reductions, no matter how small those reductions may be. The committee may wish to amend the bill to require that the advanced bioenergy technology facility must result in significant emissions reductions.
The committee may also wish to amend the bill to correct a drafting error by replacing the word “production” with “technology” on page 5, line 3.
In addition to the committee amendments, the committee may wish to adopt author’s amendments to the bill that the author was unable to submit due to the timing of the double referral. The author’s amendments establish a definition of “agricultural biomass waste” and add agricultural biomass waste as eligible feedstock under the bill.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
Center for Biological Diversity
Natural Resources Defense Council
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: June 19, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Cottie Petrie-Norris, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1062
Author:(Dahle) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Energy: conversion of biomass energy generation facilities
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Conservation (DOC) to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities and proposes related requirements and an additional future grant program.
Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “forest biomass waste” as forest biomass that is removed to reduce or mitigate the risk of wildfire, reduce the risk to public safety or infrastructure from falling trees or tree limbs, or create defensible space, or for forest restoration projects.
- Requires the DOC, in consultation with the California Energy Commission (CEC), California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), the California Air Resources Board (CARB), the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz), the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank (I-Bank), and air pollution control/air quality management districts, to develop and administer the Biomass Technology Transition Program, on or before December 1, 2025, to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria air pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases (GHGs).
- Requires the DOC to establish benchmarks and guidelines, as specified and consistent where applicable with the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection’s (BOF’s) Joint Institute Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California, on business plans for the conversion of facilities within the Biomass Technology Transition Program.
- Requires the DOC, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities that meet all of the following requirements:
- The facility has a generation capacity of 10 megawatts (MW) or greater that uses, or is in the process of recommissioning or redeveloping those facilities to use, forest biomass waste;
- The operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the DOC their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting their facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria air pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and GHGs.
- Requires a relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies (BACTs), and other potential advanced emission control technologies that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided.
- Requires the operator of a generation facility, on or before January 1, 2032, to develop business plans, which must include a carbon sequestration component, pursuant to guidelines established by the department for the conversion of a facility to an advanced bioenergy facility.
- Requires the DOC, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the CPUC to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 MW of cumulative rated generation capacity from bioenergy derived from organic waste diversion, dairy and agricultural resources, and byproducts of forest management. Requires the CPUC to encourage investor-owned utilities (IOUs) to develop programs and services that facilitate development of bioenergy and biogas. This program is known as BioMAT. (Public Utilities Code § 399.20)
- Establishes the BOF within the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFire) to represent the state’s interest in the acquisition and management of state forests, protect the state’s interests in forest resources on private lands, and determine, establish, and maintain an adequate forest policy. (Public Resources Code §§ 730 and 740)
- Establishes the Joint Institute for Wood Products Innovation (Joint Institute) under BOF to perform wood products research, development, and testing; and to accelerate research, development, and adoption of advanced forest management and wood products manufacturing. (Executive Order B-52-18)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, this bill would incur unknown but likely significant cost pressure (various funds) to provide funding for the grant program established by this bill. The DOC notes that any cost estimates would ultimately be dependent upon the amount of funding allocated to the grant program, but estimates, if the Legislature were to appropriate $50 million in funding, one-time costs of $250,000 (special fund) for a contract to develop bioenergy market benchmarks, and ongoing costs of $486,000 annually (special fund) for grant planning, administration, and oversight. The CARB estimates ongoing costs of about $220,000 annually (special fund) to meet the consultation requirements of the bill.
BACKGROUND:
Biomass to energy – Biomass is renewable organic material that can include wood and wood processing wastes, yard and food waste, agricultural crops, animal manure, and human sewage (municipal solid waste). Biomass can be used as feedstock to generate heat and electricity out of what would otherwise be waste material. There are a number of options available to make use of biomass as a feedstock to generate fuels and electricity, rather than treating them strictly as a waste stream to be disposed of. Biomass can be converted to energy through four main processes: direct combustion, and thermochemical, chemical, and biological conversion.
Direct combustion, or simply burning the biomass, is the most common method for converting biomass to useful energy. From about 1990 to 1993, California’s biomass power generation was at its highest.[1] But by 1996, the energy production from biomass combustion decreased to about 590 MW.[2] As of 2019, there were 23 – compared to 66 at the industry’s peak – operating biomass facilities, which represented approximately 3% of the state’s electrical generation capacity.[3] Despite the declining number of power plants, the generation capacity of biomass facilities in sum has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
Non-combustion thermochemical conversion – such as pyrolysis and gasification – breaks down biomass material with heat, usually with little to no oxygen so there is no burning, into fuels which can be then used in conventional equipment (e.g. boilers, engines, and turbines) or advanced equipment (e.g. fuel cells) for the generation of electricity. Chemical conversion breaks down the biomass material through chemical reactions; whereas biological conversion – including fermentation and bacterial decay – breaks down the biomass material through the use of enzymes, bacteria, or other microbes. Scalable non-combustion processes are more nascent pathways, and as a result best practices and emissions profiles are yet to be established.
More pathways, more products, but only if there’s a government subsidy for them – Recognizing the need to better understand the current state of the market for woody feedstock, and the potential to scale up a more sustainable and innovative wood products market to meet the state’s climate goals, the state budget in 2022 also made allocations for several programs, including: $10 million to CalFire for the Woody Biomass Transportation Subsidy Program to encourage post-fire cleanup and expanded capacity at wood processing facilities; resources to GO-Biz to hire at least one full-time position to lead the development of the Sustainable Wood-Based Product Market Development Roadmap; and $50 million to the DOC to focus on creating carbon-negative hydrogen and/or liquid fuel from forest biomass coming from forest vegetation management within California’s Sierra Nevada.[4]
One possible end-use for advanced bioenergy technology facilities is hydrogen. Several grant programs have been financed recently to propel hydrogen projects. The CEC is currently administering a Clean Hydrogen Program incentive program, established by AB 209 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 251, Statutes of 2022) to incentivize hydrogen projects that produce, process, deliver, store, or use hydrogen derived from water using eligible renewable energy resources, or produced from these eligible renewable energy resources. While initially appropriated at $100 million, the Governor’s budget proposes to reduce the amount to $65 million. The federal government is also providing significant incentives for hydrogen development. Specifically, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) included $8 billion to the Department of Energy (DOE) to establish hydrogen research and pilots across the country, known as the Regional Clean Hydrogen Hubs Program. California has been awarded $1.2 billion which is being managed by the Alliance for Renewable Clean Hydrogen Energy Systems (ARCHES). Under the Inflation Reduction Act, the Treasury Department was tasked with developing a federal tax credit to incentivize the production of clean hydrogen, otherwise known as the 45V production tax credit. The tax credit is structured to provide up to a $3 tax credit per kilogram of hydrogen produced, with higher credits granted to lower-carbon-intensive hydrogen.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. “California has experienced some of the worst wildfires in state history in recent years. The millions of tons of dry wood waste that have been building up in our forests is one of the many reasons why recent fires have gotten out of control. I have supported the recent efforts to expand the use of biomass energy so we can ensure this harmful waste is removed and wildfire risk is reduced. However, there is more to be done. Biomass facilities across the state are struggling to keep up with emissions regulations and many simply cannot afford to acquire new technologies. This bill will help biomass facilities acquire new emissions reducing technology while also providing them with the financial security needed to allow them to continue clearing our forests of the excess woody debris.”
- Need for biomass energy. Wildfires have been growing in duration and ferocity over the past 20 years. Their growing risk is due to a number of factors, from accumulating forest fuels to a warming climate to expanding development in the wildland-urban interface. In response, recent initiatives at the state and federal levels have been established to increase wildfire fuel management, including increased mechanical thinning and timber harvest in federal, state, and private forests and wildlands.[5],[6] All of these efforts produce forest waste. Sometimes that waste is left in piles, contributing to wildfire risk; whereas at others times the waste is burned on-site, contributing to air pollution. The need to better manage California’s forest waste is apparent. Having a robust biomass market spurring forest management can help drive down the cost of forest waste removal activities.
- Hindsight is 20/20, maybe. To a large extent, biomass energy facilities have lived and died on mandates and intervention. The federal Public Utility Regulatory Policy Act passed in 1978, which required utilities to purchase electricity at an avoided cost – the price the utility would have paid to generate or contract for that power – from independent power sources that used renewable resources or alternative technologies, encouraged utilities to purchase power from qualifying biomass facilities, leading to their boom in the 1980s.[7] As energy prices dropped in the early 1990s and the costs of feedstock soared, utilities began to scale back from biomass contracts. Subsequent policies have followed, requiring the continued procurement of biomass electricity over the last decade, with the costs of those contracts passed onto ratepayers. According to the CPUC, the average contract price of existing BioRAM contracts in 2023 was 12.2 cents/kWh;[8] whereas the average price of all other contracts was 5.8 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh).[9] The CPUC has cited a number of challenges with accessing fuel for biomass facilities, including insufficient supply chain capacity, long hauling distances, and high transportation costs, which contribute to biomass electricity’s high price.[10] These costs are absorbed by ratepayers. As a consequence, the state must weigh the statewide benefits of forest waste management provided by biomass facilities with the costs to ratepayers, both in real dollars and opportunity costs of not investing in more affordable and carbon-free renewable energy sources.
The retrofitting of existing carbon-emitting energy facilities to cleaner energy facilities, rather than the construction of brand new facilities, has possible merits, such as the continued use of existing transmission lines and the facilitated greening of a skilled energy workforce. However, scalable advanced bioenergy technologies have yet to be commercially demonstrated, so this bill might be putting the cart before the horse. Additionally, as mentioned above, the CPUC has cited a number of challenges with accessing fuel for biomass facilities which contribute to the high cost of bioenergy relative to other renewable resources. Although the Governor has infused some funding from the 2022 state budget into programs that aim to find solutions to alleviate these fuel issues, they remain a cost constraint, which casts doubt on the longevity of the new industry that this bill would stand up without continued procurement mandates and subsidies.
This bill establishes a grant program for biomass facility conversion, along with required market benchmarks and offtake agreements for advanced bioenergy fuels, but is silent as to how such programs or agreements will be paid for or achieved. The author has indicated the intention is to use state dollars, if made available, to help support the DOC in implementing this measure. However, this is not explicit. Given the history of using ratepayer dollars to support biomass production, the committee recommends an amendment prohibiting ratepayer funds from being used to implement this bill.
- Appropriate agencies. Notably, this bill calls for the creation of a biomass transition program at the DOC. While the DOC works on land management issues, the department’s experience in biomass energy production and associated power plants is unclear to the committee. In 2022, the DOC was allocated funding for a new Forest Biomass to Carbon-Negative Biofuels Pilot Program, in alignment with the focus of this bill.[11] However, it was seemingly DOC’s first and very recent entrance into the biomass-into-biofuels arena. The DOC has used $6.5 million of the $50 million allocated for administrative costs and planning grants for eight projects.[12],[13] But these efforts will be short-lived; the program’s budget will be reduced by $43.5 million, effectively eliminating funding for the program.[14] In contrast, the CEC has been active in the biomass space since at least 2012 with the passage of SB 771 (Kehoe, Chapter 598, Statutes of 2011), which created the Biomass Development Program. That program was intended to accelerate the development of sustainable emerging biomass energy technologies in California by addressing the technical issues and providing long-term support, funding, or seed money in order to achieve prompt commercial readiness and maximize benefits to the state. The CEC has also previously administered the Energy Technology Advancement Program and currently runs the Public Interest Energy Research Program, both of which touch upon biomass facility-related technologies. This bill has been amended to include the CEC in a consulting capacity for developing the Program and market benchmarks, but that role is limited compared to what is required of the DOC in establishing and managing the Program. As such, it may be prudent to consider the best location for the Program’s home agency.
- Entering foreign territory. The Program created by this bill is intended to convert existing biomass combustion facilities into “advanced bioenergy technology facilities,” which it broadly defines as noncombustion facilities with reduced emissions relative to today’s biomass facilities. This seemingly leaves the door open for an exceedingly wide range of possible end-uses. The bill mentions sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuels in addition to renewable natural gas and hydrogen as examples of advanced bioenergy technologies, indicating a focus on conversion of these facilities for fuel production, rather than conversion to cleaner combustion for electricity generation. As a result, the intended outcome of this conversion program is unclear. It may be prudent, should the Legislature choose to appropriate funds to support this Program, to consider which conversions would be the most cost-effective or best able to achieve favorable outcomes, and narrow the Program’s scope accordingly.
This bill also requires converted facilities to include a carbon capture and storage (CCS) component in their business plan, indicating the addition of CCS in the converted facility as a requisite for Program eligibility. Given how nascent the advanced bioenergy industry is, it is unclear if CCS will be necessary in all cases to aid in achieving emissions reductions. Additionally, CCS technologies remain nascent as well; no CCS projects operate in California today. As such, requiring CCS may pose a barrier to the conversion of existing biomass combustion facilities into advanced bioenergy technology facilities, which seems to be counter to the author’s intent. The committee thereby recommends adjusting this requirement of including CCS in a project’s business plan to be optional.
- Need for amendments. As put forth by this measure, the Program will be established by the DOC on or before December 1, 2025 – 11 months after enactment of this bill. Certain market benchmarks would be evaluated on or before January 1, 2030 – five years after enactment. The grant program envisioned by SB 1062 would be established by DOC on or before January 1, 2032 – seven years after enactment. The intervening time had previously been when the procurement mandate would take effect, but amendments in the Senate removed those provisions, leaving a notable gap between the Program’s establishment and when grants are issued. The timelines and operations of this bill, therefore, do not seem operational, and may have the unintended consequence of stifling development. As such, the committee recommends amendments to adjust and clarify the timelines in the bill, per below. It deserves reiterating, however, that this bill may be putting the cart before the horse since scalable advanced bioenergy technologies have yet to be commercially demonstrated.
The committee recommends the following adjustments to the timelines in this bill: requiring the DOC and relevant agencies to assess market conditions for products from advanced bioenergy technology facilities on or before January 1, 2026; requiring the operator of a generation facility to develop and submit to the department business plans on or before January 1, 2027; requiring the DOC to establish a grant program on or before January 1, 2030; requiring operators to begin conversion of a facility on or before January 1, 2030 should the DOC estimate feasible market demand and technology readiness from its initial assessment on market conditions; requiring the DOC to update the assessment of market conditions on January 1, 2030 and every two years after; and requiring operators to begin conversion of a facility within two years of the department’s determination of feasible market demand and technology readiness after January 1, 2030.
- Prior legislation.
SB 740 (Cortese) required that the labor contracts an owner or operator of a stationary source that is engaged in manufacturing hydrogen, biofuels, or certain specified chemicals, or in capturing, sequestering, or using carbon dioxide in specified conditions awards, extends, or renews on or after January 1, 2024, must use a skilled and trained workforce. Status: Chapter 293, Statutes of 2023.
AB 834 (Aguiar-Curry) authorized community choice aggregators (CCAs) to submit eligible bioenergy projects for cost recovery from electric utility ratepayers, pursuant to the BioMAT program, if open capacity exists within the 250 MW program limit, as specified. Status: Chapter 234, Statutes of 2022.
SB 1109 (Caballero) extended by 5 years both the requirement in existing law that an IOU or a CCA purchase generating capacity from eligible bioenergy projects, to December 31, 2023, and the expiration date of contracts with biomass projects that were operative in 2022. Status: Chapter 364, Statutes of 2022.
SB 515 (Caballero, 2019) would have required the CPUC to submit a report on the amount of high hazard zone (HHZ) vegetation eligible for removal, the overall market potential for HHZ fuel in California, and the potential HHZ fuel supply for each current BioRAM contract to the Legislature. Status: Died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 901 (Dodd) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response, and recovery, including provisions related to biomass operations and electricity procurement. Status: Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018.
SB 840 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review) expedited transmission interconnections for specified bioenergy or biomass projects in order to give them first priority to commence operations over other renewable energy resources. Status: Chapter 341, Statutes of 2016.
SB 859 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review) required retail sellers of electricity to purchase a total of 125 MW of power from biomass facilities that generate electricity from forest materials removed from specific high fire hazard zones, as designated by CalFire in the Governor’s Proclamation of a State of Emergency issued October 30, 2015. Status: Chapter 368, Statutes of 2016.
- Double referral. This bill is double referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Natural Resources.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file.
Opposition
Center for Biological Diversity
Analysis Prepared by: Kathleen Chen / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
CEC; “Biomass Energy in California; https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/california-power-generation-and-power-sources/biomass/biomass-energy-california. ↑
The expiration of governmental subsidies was a main driver for the reduction in biomass power generation during this time. ↑
University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources; “Woody Biomass Utilization”; https://ucanr.edu/sites/WoodyBiomass/Woody_Biomass_Library/Energy/. ↑
An additional $49 million was authorized for GO-Biz to capitalize the Climate Catalyst Fund within the I-Bank to support projects and businesses advancing sustainable forestry practices – though conversion of combustion biomass facilities are specifically excluded from this program due to separate funding for the previously mentioned DOC program. ↑
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) ↑
Memorandum of Understanding, “Agreement for Shared Stewardship of California’s Forest and Rangelands between the State of California and the USDA, Forest Service Pacific Southwest Region”; August 2020. ↑
Union of Concerned Scientists; “Public Utility Regulatory Policy Act (PURPA); October 2002; https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/public-utility-regulatory-policy-act. ↑
CPUC; Page 23; 2024 Padilla Report: Costs and Cost Savings for the RPS Program; May 2024. ↑
CPUC; Page 22; 2024 Padilla Report: Costs and Cost Savings for the RPS Program; May 2024. ↑
CPUC; 2021 Padilla Report: Costs and Cost Savings for the RPS Program; May 2021. ↑
SB 154 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 43, Statutes of 2022); https://www.conservation.ca.gov/cgs/fbp. ↑
Per data request from the Legislative Analyst’s Office on June 11th, 2024. ↑
DOC; “Forest Biomass to Carbon-Negative Biofuels Pilot Program Phase 1 Awards List”; https://www.conservation.ca.gov/cgs/documents/forestbiofuels/FBBPP-Phase1-Awards-List-a11y.pdf. ↑
AB 107 (Gabriel, 2024) passed through the Legislature on June 13th, 2024, but has not been signed by the Governor as of this analysis’ publication date ↑
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1062 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1062
Author: Dahle (R)
Amended: 4/29/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 17-0, 4/16/24
AYES: Bradford, Dahle, Ashby, Becker, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Grove, Limón, Min, Newman, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Stern, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gonzalez
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 6-0, 4/24/24
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gonzalez
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SUBJECT: Energy: conversion of biomass energy generation facilities
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires the Department of Conservation (DOC) to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass energy generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities and proposes related requirements and a future grant program.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 megawatts (MW) of cumulative rated generation capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or after June 1, 2013, as provided. (Public Utilities Code §399.20)
- Establishes the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (BOF) in CalFire to represent the state’s interest in the acquisition and management of state forests, protect the state’s interests in forest resources on private lands, and determine, establish, and maintain an adequate forest policy. (Public Resources Code §§ 730 and 740)
- Establishes the Joint Institute for Wood Products Innovation (Joint Institute) under BOF to perform wood products research, development, and testing; and to accelerate research, development, and adoption of advanced forest management and wood products manufacturing. (Executive Order B-52-18)
This bill:
- Requires the DOC, in consultation with the California Energy Commission (CEC), CPUC, California Air Resources Board (CARB), GO-Biz, I-Bank, and air pollution control/air quality management districts, to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass energy generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
- Requires DOC, in consultation with the CEC, CARB, and GO-Biz, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 MW or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, any type of clean woody biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases (GHG).
- Requires a relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided.
- Requires the DOC, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
Background
(NOTE: Includes analysis from the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality)
- Biomass. Biomass consists of organic residues from plants and animals obtained from harvesting and processing agricultural and forestry crops. Waste biomass is widely available across California, with an estimated 56 million bone dry tons per year available from trash, agricultural waste, sewage and manure, logging, and fire prevention activities in 2045. Today, this biomass returns its carbon to the atmosphere when it decays or burns in prescribed fires or wildfires, or it is used to produce energy at a power plant that vents its carbon emissions.
- Where can biomass go? There are a number of options available to make use of biomass resources, rather than treating them strictly as a waste stream to be disposed of:
- Combustion. Today, most biomass used for energy in the state is combusted. Biomass power plant is the general term for waste-to-energy power plants that burn organic material, including wood waste. According to the CEC website, in 2020, biomass electric facilities produced 5,628 gigawatt-hours or roughly three percent of the state’s in-state electricity generation portfolio. The CEC notes there are just under 90 operating biomass power plants in California, with installed capacity of about 1,259 MW. The number of power plants and generation capacity has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
- Non-combustion thermochemical processes. There are two main approaches to converting woody biomass into usable fuels: gasification and pyrolysis. Gasification is the conversion of biomass feedstocks to a gaseous fuel, while pyrolysis is the thermal decomposition of biomass in the absence of oxygen (that prevents combustion) to produce liquid fuels. These gas and liquid fuels can be used in conventional equipment (for example, boilers, engines, and turbines) or advanced equipment (such as fuel cells) for the generation of heat and electricity.
These are more nascent pathways, and as a result best practices and emissions profiles are yet to be established. - Advanced conversion. Biomass is composed of cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin, water, minerals, and other compounds. Cellulose and hemicellulose are polymers made up of sugars. Breaking the polymers into sugars could produce a feedstock from which many microbial products could be made. Using ionic liquids and subsequent microbial conversion to break down woody biomass and turn it into valuable chemicals is an active field of research. A recent Berkeley National Labs study funded by the CEC was able to turn waste woody biomass into advanced automotive and aviation biofuels at nearly 80 percent efficiency in an industrial-scale fermenter using an engineered strain of yeast.
- Bioenergy with carbon capture & storage. As opposed to the carbon in fossil fuels (which has been buried underground, out of the climate system for millennia), the carbon molecules that comprise plant matter were in the atmosphere as CO2 much more recently. Because of this, carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) applied to biomass processing and combustion is accounted for much differently than when it is applied to fossil fuels.
Under a theoretical ideal condition with perfect CCS, fossil fuel combustion with CCS could at best be neutral: it did not add any new carbon atoms to the climate system. When that same theoretical perfect CCS system is applied to biomass-based energy systems, the resulting carbon balance can be significantly negative: carbon atoms that were recently in the climate system (and even more recently tied up in plant matter) end up buried deep underground. It should be noted that these accounting practices are not universal, and indeed the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has released guidelines that do not consider biomass used for energy to be carbon neutral.
Bioenergy with carbon capture & storage (BECCS) plays a significant role in some visions of California’s carbon neutral future. For instance, the 2020 Getting to Neutral report from Lawrence Livermore National Labs suggested more than two-thirds of all negative emissions needed in the state by 2045 to account for residual emissions would come from BECCS.
Though not described at length in the 2022 Scoping Plan Update itself, BECCS does figure substantially into CARB’s best efforts to chart a path to carbon neutrality by 2045. BECCS would be expected to play a notable-but-unclear role in the 75 million tons of carbon removal CARB expects to be required in 2045. Moreover, the modeling data underpinning the Scoping Plan’s hydrogen production projections assumes BECCS will play a major role in producing hydrogen in the state. Data from E3 used for the Scoping Plan envisions hydrogen from BECCS surpassing the amount from electrolysis until 2038 and still supplying more than a third of the total volume in 2045.
- Combustion. Today, most biomass used for energy in the state is combusted. Biomass power plant is the general term for waste-to-energy power plants that burn organic material, including wood waste. According to the CEC website, in 2020, biomass electric facilities produced 5,628 gigawatt-hours or roughly three percent of the state’s in-state electricity generation portfolio. The CEC notes there are just under 90 operating biomass power plants in California, with installed capacity of about 1,259 MW. The number of power plants and generation capacity has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
- Combustion biomass energy has waned in California. From about 1990 to 1993, California's biomass power generation was at its highest (more than 800 MW of installed capacity). In 1996, the energy production from biomass dwindled to about 590 MW. The expiration of price support to the biomass industry from the government is the main reason for the reduction in biomass power generation in California. Currently, there are about 30 direct-combustion biomass facility in operation with a capacity of 640 MW. This is less than half of the facilities in operation (66) during the industries' peak, and provides approximately 2% of the state’s electricity.
- The jury’s still out on non-combustion thermal conversion technologies. Federally, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) categorizes pyrolysis as small waste combustion units and institutional waste incinerators under the Clean Air Act. The U.S. EPA considered removing the technology from Clean Air Act rules in 2020 in response to pressure from the plastics, oil, and waste industries. According to a Plastics Industry Association comment, regulating pyrolysis and gasification under the Clean Air Act would discourage the use of the technologies, which they argue are necessary to meet the country’s recycling needs.
The U.S. EPA reversed course in 2023 after receiving public comments (and a change in Administration). In response to the proposal, Earthjustice submitted a public comment noting that Clean Air Act rules should apply to all combustion associated with waste processing, including the various forms of pyrolysis and gasification.
The U.S. EPA has issued an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Pyrolysis and Gasification Units, in hopes that doing so will provide an opportunity for a large and diverse group of stakeholders, including potentially impacted facilities, small businesses, and state, local, and tribal governments, to participate in the data and information gathering process and provide information on the details of pyrolysis and gasification units and processes. At this time, no formal rulemaking appears to have been initiated. - CARB Resolution 22-21. In finalizing and adopting the 2022 Scoping Plan Update, CARB issued resolution 22-21, which found (among other things) that implementation of the Scoping Plan would result in carbon neutrality by 2045. Touching briefly upon biomass, the resolution stated, “Be it further resolved that the Board hereby determines that expansion of biomass combustion for energy production should not be pursued and opportunities for non-combustion biomass solutions should be prioritized.”
The 2022 Scoping Plan Update itself was more specific than the resolution. In the scenario described to achieve carbon neutrality by 2045, the Plan stated that in 2045 the state’s biomass supply would be used to produce conventional and advanced biofuels, as well as hydrogen. The Plan placed a particular emphasis—as did the Getting to Neutral report described above—on BECCS. - Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California. The Institute and BOF released this 2020 report, which provides recommendations to expand innovative wood and biomass products markets in California to help meet the state’s forest health and carbon neutrality goals. Some of the recommendations include:
- Leveraging public dollars to attract private capital to support demand for innovative wood and biomass products markets.
- Identifying priority wood products manufacturing centers in or near forested communities, as specified.
- Providing grants to support workforce development.
- Developing science and technology-based regional strategies that prioritize achievable solutions.
- Measuring progress and monitor outcomes to inform future activities.
- Other incentive programs. The CEC is currently administering a Clean Hydrogen Program incentive program, established by AB 209 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 251, Statutes of 2022) to demonstrate or scale-up hydrogen projects that produce, process, deliver, store, or use hydrogen derived from water using eligible renewable energy resources, or produced from these eligible renewable energy resources. While initially appropriated at $100 million, the Governor’s budget proposes to reduce the amount to $65 million. The federal government is also providing significant incentives for hydrogen development. Specifically, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA), included $8 billion to the Department of Energy (DOE) to establish hydrogen research and pilots across the country, known as the Regional Clean Hydrogen Hubs Program (H2Hubs). California has been awarded $1.2 billion which is being managed by the Alliance for Renewable Clean Hydrogen Energy Systems (ARCHES). Under the Inflation Reduction Act the Treasury Department was tasked with developing a federal tax credit to incentivize the production of clean hydrogen, otherwise known as the 45V production tax credit (45V PTC). The tax credit is structured to provide up to a $3 tax credit per kilogram of hydrogen produced, with higher credits granted to lower-carbon-intensive hydrogen.
Comments
- Need for this bill. The supporters of this bill note that CARB Resolution 22-21 in December 2022 stated that non-combustion biomass energy production should be prioritized. They raise concerns that California is moving away from combustion technologies which leaves biomass facilities still using traditional technology unable to continue operations. Many facilities are idled or in need of new contracts to continue utilizing woody biomass to create electricity but they are left struggling to meet air quality standards or acquire new technologies. The supporters further state that California’s forests are tinder boxes that, if left untreated, exacerbate the catastrophic wildfires that have happened throughout the state. Clearing the excess woody biomass that builds up in the forests is one way to reduce the risk of wildfires while also contributing much needed power to the grid. California needs to ensure that it is utilizing all of the woody biomass that it can to protect our forests and our grid. In this regard, the proposed technology transition grant program could help these idled plants resume activity.
- Costs to hurry up and wait. The Program itself will be established by DOC on or before December 1, 2025—11 months after enactment of the bill. Certain market benchmarks would be evaluated on or before January 1, 2030—five years after enactment. The grant program envisioned by SB 1062 would be established by DOC on or before January 1, 2032—seven years after the bill’s enactment. The intervening time had previously been when the procurement mandate would take effect, but now that that has been removed, there is a notable gap between the Program’s establishment and grants being issued. The author should consider if the timelines in the bill should be adjusted accordingly to provide a more clear and timely path towards action being taken.
- DOC or CEC? Notably, the SEUC analysis also proposed moving the Program from DOC to CEC. This amendment was rejected by the author, who wished to keep the Program at DOC due to budget and electric ratepayer impacts of CEC administration. On one hand, DOC was recently given $50 million in the 2022 Budget to focus on creating carbon-negative hydrogen and/or liquid fuel from forest biomass coming from forest vegetation management within California's Sierra Nevada. This is aligned with the focus of SB 1062, but it was seemingly DOC’s first entrance into the biomass-into-biofuels arena. A draft of program solicitation guidelines was released in November of last year, but no grants have yet been awarded.
- Extreme makeover: biomass edition. The Program created by this bill is intended to convert existing biomass combustion facilities into “advanced bioenergy technology facilities,” which may include renewable natural gas, hydrogen, or other advanced energy technologies. This is an exceedingly wide range of fuels, which would rely on a similarly wide array of technologies.
It is not readily apparent, for any given technology, how easy it would be to convert the existing biomass combustion plant to the new technology.
Related/Prior Legislation
(Note: See Environmental Quality Committee analysis)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations:
- DOC notes that any costs estimates ultimately would be dependent on the amount of funding allocated to the grant program, but estimates, if the Legislature were to appropriate $50 million in funding, one-time costs of $250,000 (special fund) for a contract to develop bioenergy market benchmarks, and ongoing costs of $486,000 annually (special fund) for grant planning, administration, and oversight.
- The California Air Resources Board (ARB) estimates ongoing costs of about $220,000 annually (special fund) to meet the consultation requirements of the bill.
- Unknown but likely significant cost pressure (various funds) to provide funding for the grant program established by this bill.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/15/24)
Golden State Power Cooperative
Placer County Air Pollution Control District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/15/24)
Center for Biological Diversity
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and NRDC Action Fund
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
California has experienced some of the worst wildfires in state history in recent years. The millions of tons of dry wood waste that have been building up in our forests is one of the many reasons why recent fires have gotten out of control. I have supported the recent efforts to expand the use of biomass energy so we can ensure this harmful waste is removed and wildfire risk is reduced. However, there is more to be done. Biomass facilities across the state are struggling to keep up with emissions regulations and many simply cannot get the contracts needed to continue operations. This bill will help biomass facilities acquire new emissions reducing technology while also providing them with the financial security needed to allow them to continue clearing our forests of the excess woody debris.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The NRDC opposes the bill stating:
While SB 1062 rightly calls for increased emissions controls, it unfortunately also calls for incentivization via a grant program “to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies, including, but not limited to, sustainable aviation fuel or other biofuels, linear generators, renewable natural gas or biomass conversion to hydrogen, as determined appropriate by the department” which would perversely allow this industry to grow. As we will continue to discuss, “advanced bioenergy technologies” carry significant environmental, climate, and public health burdens that make them incompatible for achieving a pollution-free and carbon-free future. Subsidizing forest-based biomass in energy applications does more harm than good for the climate and the industry has failed to mitigate climate risks while spurring unintended consequences and market distortions. Burning wood for energy is a failed climate solution and scientists the world over have called for its end-use.
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U. & C. / (916) 651-4107
5/17/24 14:39:22
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1062 (Dahle) - Energy: conversion of biomass energy generation facilities
Version: April 29, 2024 | Policy Vote: E., U. & C. 17 - 0, E.Q. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2024 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require the Department of Conservation (DOC) to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities and proposes related requirements and an additional future grant program.
Fiscal Impact:
- DOC notes that any costs estimates ultimately would be dependent on the amount of funding allocated to the grant program, but estimates, if the Legislature were to appropriate $50 million in funding, one-time costs of $250,000 (special fund) for a contract to develop bioenergy market benchmarks, and ongoing costs of $486,000 annually (special fund) for grant planning, administration, and oversight.
- The California Air Resources Board (ARB) estimates ongoing costs of about $220,000 annually (special fund) to meet the consultation requirements of the bill.
- Unknown but likely significant cost pressure (various funds) to provide funding for the grant program established by this bill.
Background:
Biomass consists of organic residues from plants and animals obtained from harvesting and processing agricultural and forestry crops. Waste biomass is widely available across California, with an estimated 56 million bone dry tons per year available from trash, agricultural waste, sewage and manure, logging, and fire prevention activities in 2045. Today, this biomass returns its carbon to the atmosphere when it decays or burns in prescribed fires or wildfires, or it is used to produce energy at a power plant that vents its carbon emissions.
There are a number of options available to make use of biomass resources, rather than treating them strictly as a waste stream to be disposed of.
- Combustion. Today, most biomass used for energy in the state is combusted. Biomass power plant is the general term for waste-to-energy power plants that burn organic material, including wood waste. According to the California Energy Commission (CEC) website, in 2020, biomass electric facilities produced 5,628 gigawatt-hours or roughly three percent of the state’s in-state electricity generation portfolio. The CEC notes there are just under 90 operating biomass power plants in California, with installed capacity of about 1,259 MW. The number of power plants and generation capacity has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
- Non-combustion thermochemical processes. There are two main approaches to converting woody biomass into usable fuels: gasification and pyrolysis. Gasification is the conversion of biomass feedstocks to a gaseous fuel, while pyrolysis is the thermal decomposition of biomass in the absence of oxygen (that prevents combustion) to produce liquid fuels. These gas and liquid fuels can be used in conventional equipment (for example, boilers, engines, and turbines) or advanced equipment (such as fuel cells) for the generation of heat and electricity.
These are more nascent pathways, and as a result best practices and emissions profiles are yet to be established. - Advanced conversion. Biomass is composed of cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin, water, minerals, and other compounds. Cellulose and hemicellulose are polymers made up of sugars. Breaking the polymers into sugars could produce a feedstock from which many microbial products could be made. Using ionic liquids and subsequent microbial conversion to break down woody biomass and turn it into valuable chemicals is an active field of research. A recent Berkeley National Labs study funded by the CEC was able to turn waste woody biomass into advanced automotive and aviation biofuels at nearly 80% efficiency in an industrial-scale fermenter using an engineered strain of yeast.
- Bioenergy with carbon capture & storage. As opposed to the carbon in fossil fuels (which has been buried underground, out of the climate system for millennia), the carbon molecules that comprise plant matter were in the atmosphere as CO2 much more recently. Because of this, carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) applied to biomass processing and combustion is accounted for much differently than when it is applied to fossil fuels.
Under a theoretical ideal condition with perfect CCS, fossil fuel combustion with CCS could at best be neutral: it did not add any new carbon atoms to the climate system. When that same theoretical perfect CCS system is applied to biomass-based energy systems, the resulting carbon balance can be significantly negative: carbon atoms that were recently in the climate system (and even more recently tied up in plant matter) end up buried deep underground. It should be noted that these accounting practices are not universal, and indeed the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has released guidelines that do not consider biomass used for energy to be carbon neutral.
Bioenergy with carbon capture & storage (BECCS) plays a significant role in some visions of California’s carbon neutral future. For instance, the 2020 Getting to Neutral report from Lawrence Livermore National Labs suggested more than two-thirds of all negative emissions needed in the state by 2045 to account for residual emissions would come from BECCS.
Though not described at length in the 2022 Scoping Plan Update itself, BECCS does figure substantially into CARB’s best efforts to chart a path to carbon neutrality by 2045. BECCS would be expected to play a notable-but-unclear role in the 75 million tons of carbon removal CARB expects to be required in 2045. Moreover, the modeling data underpinning the Scoping Plan’s hydrogen production projections assumes BECCS will play a major role in producing hydrogen in the state. Data from E3 used for the Scoping Plan envisions hydrogen from BECCS surpassing the amount from electrolysis until 2038 and still supplying more than a third of the total volume in 2045.
CARB Resolution 22-21. In finalizing and adopting the 2022 Scoping Plan Update, CARB issued resolution 22-21, which found (among other things) that implementation of the Scoping Plan would result in carbon neutrality by 2045. Touching briefly upon biomass, the resolution stated, “Be it further resolved that the Board hereby determines that expansion of biomass combustion for energy production should not be pursued and opportunities for non-combustion biomass solutions should be prioritized.”
The 2022 Scoping Plan Update itself was more specific than the resolution. In the scenario described to achieve carbon neutrality by 2045, the Plan stated that in 2045 the state’s biomass supply would be used to produce conventional and advanced biofuels, as well as hydrogen. The Plan placed a particular emphasis—as did the Getting to Neutral report described above—on BECCS.
Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California. The Institute and BOF released this 2020 report, which provides recommendations to expand innovative wood and biomass products markets in California to help meet the state’s forest health and carbon neutrality goals. Some of the recommendations include:
- Leveraging public dollars to attract private capital to support demand for innovative wood and biomass products markets.
- Identifying priority wood products manufacturing centers in or near forested communities, as specified.
- Providing grants to support workforce development.
- Developing science and technology-based regional strategies that prioritize achievable solutions.
- Measuring progress and monitor outcomes to inform future activities.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require the DOC to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities and proposes related requirements and an additional future grant program. Specifically, this bill would:
- Require the DOC, in consultation with the CPUC, ARB, GO-Biz, I-Bank, and air pollution control/air quality management districts, to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program (“Program”) to support the conversion of biomass generation facilities using traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases (GHGs), and which must include a carbon sequestration component.
- Require DOC, in consultation with CARB, and GO-Biz, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 MW or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, forest biomass waste and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
- Requires a relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, as applicable to the district, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided.
- Require DOC, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
Related Legislation:
AB 843 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 234, Statutes of 2022) authorized CCAs to submit eligible bioenergy projects for cost recovery from electric utility ratepayers, pursuant to the BioMAT program, if open capacity exists within the 250 MW program limit, as specified.
SB 1109 (Caballero, Chapter 364, Statutes of 2022) extended requirements on electric IOUs and CCAs to procure energy from biomass generating electric facilities by five years and required extension of existing contracts by five years.
SB 515 (Caballero, 2019) would have expanded the fuels and feedstocks that are eligible to satisfy requirements related to specified contracts for mandated electricity generation from biomass facilities. The bill was further amended to require a report on available fuel feedstocks. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including provisions related to biomass operations and electricity procurement.
SB 840 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2016) expedited transmission interconnections for specified bioenergy or biomass projects in order to give them first priority to commence operations over other renewable energy resources.
SB 859 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 368, Statutes of 2016) required retail sellers of electricity to purchase a total of 125 MW of power from biomass facilities that generate electricity from forest materials removed from specific high fire hazard zones, as designated by CalFire in the Governor's Proclamation of a State of Emergency issued October 30, 2015.
Staff Comments:
DOC notes that the fiscal impact of this bill would be dependent on the amount of funding allocated to the program for grant planning, administration, and awards. If the Legislature were to appropriate $50 million in funding, DOC estimates that implementing this bill would require three positions, and $250,000 in one-time contracting funds to develop bioenergy market benchmarks, at a cost of $775,000 in the first year and $486,000 per year thereafter. The new positions would develop program guidelines in collaboration with other state agencies on permitting requirements and potential emission control technologies, develop business plan guidelines, and evaluate business plans. No funding source is identified in the bill, but these costs could be covered by an administrative allocation in a to-be-determined funding source for the grant program.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No. | SB 1062 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/2024 |
Author: | Dahle | ||
Version: | 4/3/2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eric Walters | ||
SUBJECT: Energy: conversion of biomass energy generation facilities
DIGEST: This bill contains two related proposals: (1) requires the Department of Conservation (DOC) to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities and proposes related requirements and additional future grant program; and (2) requires electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities (POUs) with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts (MW) of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities.
ANALYSIS:
- Establishes and vests the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Article XII of the California Constitution and Public Utilities Code §451)
- Requires the CPUC to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 MW of cumulative rated generation capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or after June 1, 2013, as provided. (Public Utilities Code §399.20)
- Requires, under the California Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) Program, every electrical corporation to file with the CPUC a standard tariff for electricity generated by an electric generation facility, as defined, that qualifies for the tariff, is owned and operated by a retail customer of the electrical corporation, and is located within the service territory of, and developed to sell electricity to, the electrical corporation. The CPUC refers to this requirement as the renewable feed-in tariff (FIT). Requires the CPUC to direct the electrical corporations, collectively, to procure at least 250 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or after June 1, 2013. Pursuant to this requirement, the CPUC has established and revised the Bioenergy Market Adjusting Tariff (BioMAT) program. (Public Utilities Code §399.20)
- Requires electrical corporations, by December 1, 2016, to collectively procure, through financial commitments of five years, their proportionate share of 125 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from bioenergy projects commencing operation before June 1, 2013. Requires local electric POU serving more than 100,000 customers to procure their proportionate shares of 125 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from those kinds of bioenergy projects subject to terms of at least five years. Exempts local electric POUs from their proportionate share if on June 1, 2022, the facility operator was in bankruptcy or the contract does not deliver energy to the utility. (Public Utilities Code §399.20.3)
- Requires an electrical corporation, local electric POU, or community choice aggregator (CCA) with a contract to procure electricity generated from biomass that is operative and expires or expired on or before December 31, 2028, to seek to amend the contract to include, or seek approval for a new contract that includes, an expiration date five years later than the expiration date in the contract that was operative in 2018, so long as the contract extension follows the feedstock requirement described above. Prohibits this requirement from applying to facilities located in federal severe or extreme nonattainment areas for particulate matter or ozone. (Public Utilities Code §8388)
- Establishes the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (BOF) in CalFire to represent the state’s interest in the acquisition and management of state forests, protect the state’s interests in forest resources on private lands, and determine, establish, and maintain an adequate forest policy. (PRC § 730 and 740)
- Establishes, pursuant to Executive Order B-52-18, the Joint Institute for Wood Products Innovation (Joint Institute) under BOF to perform wood products research, development, and testing; and to accelerate research, development, and adoption of advanced forest management and wood products manufacturing.
This bill:
- Requires the DOC, in consultation with the CPUC, California Air Resources Board (CARB), GO-Biz, I-Bank, and air pollution control/air quality management districts, to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program (“Program”) to support the conversion of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases (GHGs), and which must include a carbon sequestration component.
- Requires DOC, in consultation with CARB, and GO-Biz, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 MW or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, any type of clean woody biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
- Requires a relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided.
- Requires the DOC, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
- Requires electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local electric POUs with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 MW of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities identified by the DOC that receive applicable air permits from the relevant air district, develop business plans, and commit to the conversion of the generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities, as provided.
- Prohibits the financial commitments from extending beyond January 1, 2041, and authorizes a financial commitment to be terminated early if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity, as provided.
Background
- What is biomass? Biomass consists of organic residues from plants and animals obtained from harvesting and processing agricultural and forestry crops. Waste biomass is widely available across California, with an estimated 56 million bone dry tons per year available from trash, agricultural waste, sewage and manure, logging, and fire prevention activities in 2045. Today, this biomass returns its carbon to the atmosphere when it decays or burns in prescribed fires or wildfires, or it is used to produce energy at a power plant that vents its carbon emissions.
- Where can biomass go? There are a number of options available to make use of biomass resources, rather than treating them strictly as a waste stream to be disposed of.
- Combustion. Today, most biomass used for energy in the state is combusted. Biomass power plant is the general term for waste-to-energy power plants that burn organic material, including wood waste. According to the California Energy Commission (CEC) website, in 2020, biomass electric facilities produced 5,628 gigawatt-hours or roughly three percent of the state’s in-state electricity generation portfolio. The CEC notes there are just under 90 operating biomass power plants in California, with installed capacity of about 1,259 MW. The number of power plants and generation capacity has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
- Non-combustion thermochemical processes. There are two main approaches to converting woody biomass into usable fuels: gasification and pyrolysis. Gasification is the conversion of biomass feedstocks to a gaseous fuel, while pyrolysis is the thermal decomposition of biomass in the absence of oxygen (that prevents combustion) to produce liquid fuels. These gas and liquid fuels can be used in conventional equipment (for example, boilers, engines, and turbines) or advanced equipment (such as fuel cells) for the generation of heat and electricity.
These are more nascent pathways, and as a result best practices and emissions profiles are yet to be established. - Advanced conversion. Biomass is composed of cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin, water, minerals, and other compounds. Cellulose and hemicellulose are polymers made up of sugars. Breaking the polymers into sugars could produce a feedstock from which many microbial products could be made. Using ionic liquids and subsequent microbial conversion to break down woody biomass and turn it into valuable chemicals is an active field of research. A recent Berkeley National Labs study funded by the CEC was able to turn waste woody biomass into advanced automotive and aviation biofuels at nearly 80% efficiency in an industrial-scale fermenter using an engineered strain of yeast.
- Bioenergy with carbon capture & storage. As opposed to the carbon in fossil fuels (which has been buried underground, out of the climate system for millennia), the carbon molecules that comprise plant matter were in the atmosphere as CO2 much more recently. Because of this, carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) applied to biomass processing and combustion is accounted for much differently than when it is applied to fossil fuels.
Under a theoretical ideal condition with perfect CCS, fossil fuel combustion with CCS could at best be neutral: it did not add any new carbon atoms to the climate system. When that same theoretical perfect CCS system is applied to biomass-based energy systems, the resulting carbon balance can be significantly negative: carbon atoms that were recently in the climate system (and even more recently tied up in plant matter) end up buried deep underground. It should be noted that these accounting practices are not universal, and indeed the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has released guidelines that do not consider biomass used for energy to be carbon neutral.
Bioenergy with carbon capture & storage (BECCS) plays a significant role in some visions of California’s carbon neutral future. For instance, the 2020 Getting to Neutral report from Lawrence Livermore National Labs suggested more than two-thirds of all negative emissions needed in the state by 2045 to account for residual emissions would come from BECCS.
Though not described at length in the 2022 Scoping Plan Update itself, BECCS does figure substantially into CARB’s best efforts to chart a path to carbon neutrality by 2045. BECCS would be expected to play a notable-but-unclear role in the 75 million tons of carbon removal CARB expects to be required in 2045. Moreover, the modeling data underpinning the Scoping Plan’s hydrogen production projections assumes BECCS will play a major role in producing hydrogen in the state. Data from E3 used for the Scoping Plan envisions hydrogen from BECCS surpassing the amount from electrolysis until 2038 and still supplying more than a third of the total volume in 2045.
- Combustion. Today, most biomass used for energy in the state is combusted. Biomass power plant is the general term for waste-to-energy power plants that burn organic material, including wood waste. According to the California Energy Commission (CEC) website, in 2020, biomass electric facilities produced 5,628 gigawatt-hours or roughly three percent of the state’s in-state electricity generation portfolio. The CEC notes there are just under 90 operating biomass power plants in California, with installed capacity of about 1,259 MW. The number of power plants and generation capacity has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
- Combustion biomass energy has waned in California. From about 1990 to 1993, California's biomass power generation was at its highest (more than 800 MW of installed capacity). In 1996, the energy production from biomass dwindled to about 590 MW. The expiration of price support to the biomass industry from the government is the main reason for the reduction in biomass power generation in California. Currently, there are about 30 direct-combustion biomass facility in operation with a capacity of 640 MW. This is less than half of the facilities in operation (66) during the industries' peak, and provides approximately 2% of the state’s electricity.
- The jury’s still out on non-combustion thermal conversion technologies. Federally, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) categorizes pyrolysis as small waste combustion units and institutional waste incinerators under the Clean Air Act. The U.S. EPA considered removing the technology from Clean Air Act rules in 2020 in response to pressure from the plastics, oil, and waste industries. According to a Plastics Industry Association comment, regulating pyrolysis and gasification under the Clean Air Act would discourage the use of the technologies, which they argue are necessary to meet the country’s recycling needs.
The U.S. EPA reversed course in 2023 after receiving public comments (and a change in Administration). In response to the proposal, Earthjustice submitted a public comment noting that Clean Air Act rules should apply to all combustion associated with waste processing, including the various forms of pyrolysis and gasification.
The U.S. EPA has issued an Advanced Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on Pyrolysis and Gasification Units, in hopes that doing so will provide an opportunity for a large and diverse group of stakeholders, including potentially impacted facilities, small businesses, and state, local, and tribal governments, to participate in the data and information gathering process and provide information on the details of pyrolysis and gasification units and processes. At this time, no formal rulemaking appears to have been initiated. - CARB Resolution 22-21. In finalizing and adopting the 2022 Scoping Plan Update, CARB issued resolution 22-21, which found (among other things) that implementation of the Scoping Plan would result in carbon neutrality by 2045. Touching briefly upon biomass, the resolution stated, “Be it further resolved that the Board hereby determines that expansion of biomass combustion for energy production should not be pursued and opportunities for non-combustion biomass solutions should be prioritized.”
The 2022 Scoping Plan Update itself was more specific than the resolution. In the scenario described to achieve carbon neutrality by 2045, the Plan stated that in 2045 the state’s biomass supply would be used to produce conventional and advanced biofuels, as well as hydrogen. The Plan placed a particular emphasis—as did the Getting to Neutral report described above—on BECCS. - Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California. The Institute and BOF released this 2020 report, which provides recommendations to expand innovative wood and biomass products markets in California to help meet the state’s forest health and carbon neutrality goals. Some of the recommendations include:
- Leveraging public dollars to attract private capital to support demand for innovative wood and biomass products markets.
- Identifying priority wood products manufacturing centers in or near forested communities, as specified.
- Providing grants to support workforce development.
- Developing science and technology-based regional strategies that prioritize achievable solutions.
- Measuring progress and monitor outcomes to inform future activities.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “California has experienced some of the worst wildfires in state history in recent years. The millions of tons of dry wood waste that have been building up in our forests is one of the many reasons why recent fires have gotten out of control. I have supported the recent efforts to expand the use of biomass energy so we can ensure this harmful waste is removed and wildfire risk is reduced. However, there is more to be done. Biomass facilities across the state are struggling to keep up with emissions regulations and many simply cannot get the contracts needed to continue operations. This bill will help biomass facilities acquire new emissions reducing technology while also providing them with the financial security needed to allow them to continue clearing our forests of the excess woody debris.”
- Previously proposed committee amendments. This bill was heard in the Senate Energy, Utilities, and Communications (SEUC) Committee on April 16, 2024, and passed out on a 17-0 vote with amendments to strike the procurement requirement (i.e. Section 2 and conforming amendments) from the bill. Due to timing constraints between the two policy committee hearings, those amendments have not yet been put in print.
Notably, the SEUC analysis also proposed moving the Program from DOC to CEC. This amendment was rejected by the author, who wished to keep the Program at DOC. Nevertheless, the matter may deserve further consideration.
On one hand, DOC was recently given $50 million in the 2022 Budget to focus on creating carbon-negative hydrogen and/or liquid fuel from forest biomass coming from forest vegetation management within California's Sierra Nevada. This is aligned with the focus of SB 1062, but it was seemingly DOC’s first entrance into the biomass-into-biofuels arena. A draft of program solicitation guidelines was released in November of last year, but no grants have yet been awarded.
On the other hand, CEC has been active in this space since at least 2012 with the passage of SB 771 (Kehoe, 2011), which created the Biomass Development Program. That program was intended to accelerate the development of sustainable emerging biomass energy technologies in California by addressing the technical issues and providing long-term support, funding, or seed money in order to achieve prompt commercial readiness and maximize benefits to the state. CEC has also previously administered the Energy Technology Advancement Program and currently runs the Public Interest Energy Research Program, both of which touch upon these technologies.
This array of programs suggests CEC may have considerable expertise in the biomass facilities targeted by the Program created by SB 1062. Indeed, CEC could have other important technical knowledge that could be helpful in administering the Program, including the future grants available under it.
The committee may wish to consider including the CEC in a consulting role in developing the Program and market benchmarks. - What are we going to do with all this waste? There is no question that woody biomass waste is not the best way to produce energy. It is costly to transport, produces at least some air pollution under virtually any pathway, and cannot compete dollar-for-dollar with clean, renewable electricity. Nevertheless, certain types of bioenergy could indeed be desirable uses for woody biomass waste. This deserves further discussion.
In stewarding California’s forests, it has become clear that they must be managed differently than they have in the past. Aggressive fire suppression and other management regimes have led to forests containing an overabundance of dead, dry, flammable wood. As the state takes steps to prevent catastrophic wildfire, keep Californians safe, and promote forest restoration, it seems woody biomass will necessarily be generated.
The intent of this bill appears to be making that waste stream into a valuable use – advanced bioenergy. This is undoubtedly better than open-air pile burning, and seems significantly better than traditional energy from biomass combustion operations as well. Care must be taken that entities are not incentivized to increase their waste production strictly so that they can sell more woody biomass to bioenergy operations. But incentives to have that extant woody biomass waste be used for energy production may help support ongoing forest restoration and fire mitigation efforts.
However, the bill as written today applies to all clean woody biomass. The committee may wish to consider amending the bill to require the Program only pertain to forest waste biomass: forest biomass that is removed to reduce or mitigate the risk of wildfire, reduce the risks to public safety or infrastructure from falling trees or tree limbs, or create defensible space, or for forest restoration projects.
Moreover, and to align the Program with existing efforts and recommendations, the committee may wish to ensure that the guidelines developed by DOC are in line with the Joint Institute Recommendations to Expand Wood and Biomass Utilization in California. - Hurry up and wait. The Program itself will be established by DOC on or before December 1, 2025—11 months after enactment of the bill. Certain market benchmarks would be evaluated on or before January 1, 2030—five years after enactment. The grant program envisioned by SB 1062 would be established by DOC on or before January 1, 2032—seven years after the bill’s enactment. The intervening time had previously been when the procurement mandate would take effect, but now that that has been removed, there is a notable gap between the Program’s establishment and grants being issued. The author should consider if the timelines in the bill should be adjusted accordingly to provide a more clear and timely path towards action being taken.
- Extreme makeover: biomass edition. The Program created by SB 1062 is intended to convert existing biomass combustion facilities into “advanced bioenergy technology facilities,” which may include renewable natural gas, hydrogen, or other advanced energy technologies. This is an exceedingly wide range of fuels, which would rely on a similarly wide array of technologies.
It is not readily apparent, for any given technology, how easy it would be to convert the existing biomass combustion plant to the new technology. We can consider one extreme, where minimal retrofits are needed to produce the advanced energy technology. In that case, the facility likely does not need a grant to change, and would indeed be expected to do so on its own volition to follow the market. On the other hand, some facilities may need a near-complete overhaul to provide the new technology. In such a situation, a question arises as to whether the new advanced bioenergy facility, like the proverbial Ship of Theseus, is still the same as the original facility in any meaningful way. In that case, it would be unclear what benefits or savings could be expected from converting an old facility rather than building a new one.
The ideal Program applicant then would likely fall somewhere in between those two extremes: one that requires a substantial-but-not-complete overhaul to provide the advanced technology. While assessing which plants may fit that standard for which technologies is beyond the scope of this analysis, it would presumably be an important part of the business plans submitted to the Program pursuant to this bill. - Clearing the air. The bill requires the relevant air district to, “provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit…” (Emphasis added).
Indeed, air districts and their specific permitting processes for stationary sources can have different requirements about control technologies on new facilities. These requirements can differ depending on the federal Clean Air Act (CAA), and specifically whether an air district is in an attainment or non-attainment area for certain criteria air pollutants.
Three such requirements are reasonably available control technology (RACT), best available control technology (BACT), and lowest achievable emission rate (LAER). Specifically, these requirements may be applicable under the following circumstances:- RACT is required on existing sources in areas that are not meeting national ambient air quality standards (i.e., non-attainment areas)
- BACT is required on major new or modified sources in clean areas (i.e., attainment areas)
- LAER is required on major new or modified sources in non-attainment areas.
Each of these requirements will not apply to every facility under the Program in the state; it will depend on the CAA attainment of the air basin. However, the language emphasized above in the bill—“other potential advanced emission control technologies”—may not be entirely clear. The committee may wish to clarify that the information about potential advanced emission control technologies shared by air districts should incorporate what additional pollution control requirements may be applicable to that air district.
- Thou shalt sequester. For the operator of an existing biomass generation facility to apply to the Program, they must submit business plans to describe the transition to advanced technologies. For any business plan submitted to the Program, this bill requires it to include a carbon sequestration component. While this is a clear nod to the drive towards BECCS in the state (advocated for in both Getting to Neutral and the 2022 Scoping Plan Update), it does increase the economic and technical complexity of eligible projects.
Although no CCS projects operate in California today, insights can be gleaned from other cases around the world. CCS is an energy-intensive process, and so care must be taken to avoid a situation where, say, a given bioenergy facility could have CCS installed and be considered carbon neutral, but that CCS system requires significant additional carbon-intensive electricity to run. Moreover, CO2 is not the only emission from these processes, and so capturing that alone through a CCS system would not solve all concerns about facility emissions.
In short, this bill succeeding at converting biomass combustion plants to advanced bioenergy technologies presupposes that there will be cost-effective, emissions-reducing, deployable carbon sequestration methods available. Given the challenges that have been faced in permitting and building CCS projects in California to date, this may be a daunting proposition for Program applicants. However, as California accelerates its deployment of CCS (notably through the implementation of SB 905 (Caballero, 2022)) this will presumably become easier. - Government grants for upcycled dead plants. This bill requires DOC (or CEC, as amended in the SEUC committee) to, on or before January 1, 2032, establish a grant program to support these combustion-to-advanced-bioenergy conversions. While the state’s budget situation will likely change in the intervening seven years between this bill’s enactment date and then, doing so could still be a considerable speculative investment.
There is undoubtedly an abundance of waste biomass in California (56 tons annually in 2045, as projected in the Getting to Neutral report), and there are undoubtable benefits that could come from handling that waste differently. Slash piles can contribute to catastrophic wildfires. Agricultural residues can decompose and release methane to the atmosphere. Municipal solid waste can end up in landfills. Surely we can do something better with these materials.
What remains a consternating challenge is making waste streams valuable without incentivizing sources to maximize their waste. Moreover, even with the volume of waste biomass existing in the state, that is likely not enough to solve every problem that could be addressed with bioenergy. What happens when California’s future production of hydrogen, energy, and advanced liquid fuels are all competing for the same limited resource?
Ultimately, biomass-based facilities have lived and died on their profitability. With abundant government support, biomass combustion grew in the early 1990’s to become a significant source of electricity. When those subsidies went away, so too did much of the biomass energy. Under SB 1062, state support for converting generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies (and eventually grants to do so) could help stand up a new industry within California. But at what cost?
It seems to be in clear furtherance of the state’s emissions reduction road map (i.e. the Scoping Plan) that California should move its biomass resources away from combustion and towards advanced bioenergy, as this bill proposes to do. It is less clear if using state resources and grants to attempt to make these operations profitable is a winning strategy in the long-term. If the state truly needs advanced bioenergy projects to meet its goals, should we pin our hopes on narrow-margin, nascent technology-reliant, potentially polluting businesses maintaining their profitability to keep them running? - Committee amendments. Staff recommends the committee adopt the bolded amendments contained in comments 2, 3, and 6 above.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in Senate Energy, Utilities, and Communications Committee on April 16, 2024, and passed out of committee with a vote of 17-0.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 843 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 234, Statutes of 2022) authorized CCAs to submit eligible bioenergy projects for cost recovery from electric utility ratepayers, pursuant to the BioMAT program, if open capacity exists within the 250 MW program limit, as specified.
SB 1109 (Caballero, Chapter 364, Statutes of 2022) extended requirements on electric IOUs and CCAs to procure energy from biomass generating electric facilities by five years and required extension of existing contracts by five years.
SB 515 (Caballero, 2019) would have expanded the fuels and feedstocks that are eligible to satisfy requirements related to specified contracts for mandated electricity generation from biomass facilities. The bill was further amended to require a report on available fuel feedstocks. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including provisions related to biomass operations and electricity procurement.
SB 840 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2016) expedited transmission interconnections for specified bioenergy or biomass projects in order to give them first priority to commence operations over other renewable energy resources.
SB 859 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 368, Statutes of 2016) required retail sellers of electricity to purchase a total of 125 MW of power from biomass facilities that generate electricity from forest materials removed from specific high fire hazard zones, as designated by CalFire in the Governor's Proclamation of a State of Emergency issued October 30, 2015.
SOURCE:
California Law Empowering Renewable Energy
SUPPORT:
Golden State Power Cooperative
OPPOSITION:
Center for Biological Diversity
Natural Resources Defense Council
Southern California Public Power Authority (SCPPA)
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the Golden State Power Cooperative, “Golden State Power Cooperative supports SB 1062 and the development of a Biomass Technology Transition Program. We appreciate your efforts to highlight the potential for woody biomass to provide firm, renewable power. All of the members of Golden State Power Cooperative serve rural communities in forested areas. We support the use of forest biomass waste to restore healthy forests, prevent catastrophic wildfires, boost rural economies, and generate renewable energy.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the Center for Biological Diversity, “The bill proposes a ‘Biomass Technology Transition Program’ which, on its surface, is meant to reduce the emissions burden—from criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases—of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies. What the bill does instead, however, is provide monetary grants for problematic alternatives like bioenergy with carbon capture and storage (BECCS) and renewable natural gas, while also incentivizing the production of biomass-derived hydrogen and biofuels. … These supposed ‘advanced bioenergy technologies’ carry their own environmental, climate, and public health burdens that should disqualify them from consideration in efforts to achieve a pollution-free and carbon-free future.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 4/16/2024
Author: | |||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill contains two related proposals: (1) requires the Department of Conservation (DOC) to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities and proposes related requirements and additional future grant program; and (2) requires electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local publicly owned electric utilities (POUs) with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 megawatts (MW) of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes and vests the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Article XII of the California Constitution and Public Utilities Code §451)
- Requires the CPUC to direct electrical corporations to collectively procure at least 250 MW of cumulative rated generation capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or after June 1, 2013, as provided. (Public Utilities Code §399.20)
- Requires, under the California Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS) Program, every electrical corporation to file with the CPUC a standard tariff for electricity generated by an electric generation facility, as defined, that qualifies for the tariff, is owned and operated by a retail customer of the electrical corporation, and is located within the service territory of, and developed to sell electricity to, the electrical corporation. The CPUC refers to this requirement as the renewable feed-in tariff (FIT). Requires the CPUC to direct the electrical corporations, collectively, to procure at least 250 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from developers of bioenergy projects that commence operation on or after June 1, 2013. Pursuant to this requirement, the CPUC has established and revised the Bioenergy Market Adjusting Tariff (BioMAT) program. (Public Utilities Code §399.20)
- Requires electrical corporations, by December 1, 2016, to collectively procure, through financial commitments of five years, their proportionate share of 125 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from bioenergy projects commencing operation before June 1, 2013. Requires local electric POU serving more than 100,000 customers to procure their proportionate shares of 125 MW of cumulative rated generating capacity from those kinds of bioenergy projects subject to terms of at least five years. Exempts local electric POUs from their proportionate share if on June 1, 2022 the facility operator was in bankruptcy or the contract does not deliver energy to the utility. (Public Utilities Code §399.20.3)
- Requires an electrical corporation, local electric POU, or community choice aggregator (CCA) with a contract to procure electricity generated from biomass that is operative and expires or expired on or before December 31, 2028, to seek to amend the contract to include, or seek approval for a new contract that includes, an expiration date five years later than the expiration date in the contract that was operative in 2018, so long as the contract extension follows the feedstock requirement described above. Prohibits this requirement from applying to facilities located in federal severe or extreme nonattainment areas for particulate matter or ozone. (Public Utilities Code §8388)
This bill:
- Requires the DOC, in consultation with the CPUC, California Air Resources Board (CARB), GO-Biz, I-Bank, and air pollution control/air quality management districts, to develop the Biomass Technology Transition Program to support the conversion of energy generation facilities using biomass and traditional combustion technologies to newer advanced bioenergy technology facilities that result in reductions in the emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases.
- Requires DOC, in consultation with CARB, and GO-Biz, on or before December 1, 2025, to identify generation facilities with a generation capacity of 10 MW or greater that uses, or are in the process of recommissioning or the redevelopment of those facilities to use, any type of clean woody biomass and the operators of those facilities have demonstrated to the department their sincere interest, to the satisfaction of the department, in converting the facilities to advanced bioenergy technologies that result in a reduction in emissions of criteria pollutants, toxic air contaminants, and greenhouse gases (GHG).
- Requires a relevant local air pollution control district or air quality management district to provide information for each identified generation facility about best available control technologies, and other potential advanced emission control technologies, that would be required if the generation facility requests a permit, as provided.
- Requires the DOC, on or before January 1, 2032, to establish a grant program to support the distribution of advanced bioenergy technologies from those identified generation facilities that meet certain requirements.
- Requires electrical corporations with 100,000 or more connections and local electric POUs with 100,000 or more connections to collectively procure, through financial commitments of 15 years, 125 MW of cumulative rated generation capacity from those facilities identified by the DOC that receive applicable air permits from the relevant air district, develop business plans, and commit to the conversion of the generation facilities to advanced bioenergy technology facilities, as provided.
- By imposing additional requirements on local electric POUs, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
- Prohibits the financial commitments from extending beyond January 1, 2041, and authorizes a financial commitment to be terminated early if the facility has converted to an advanced bioenergy technology facility that does not produce electricity, as provided.
Background
Biomass. Biomass power plant is the general term for waste-to-energy power plants that burn organic material, including wood waste. According to the California Energy Commission (CEC) website, in 2020, biomass electric facilities produced 5,628 gigawatt-hours or roughly three percent of the state’s in-state electricity generation portfolio. The CEC notes there are just under 90 operating biomass power plants in California, with installed capacity of about 1,259 MW. The number of power plants and generation capacity has largely remained unchanged since 2001, per the CEC Energy Almanac data.
2015 Executive Order. Over 100 million trees have died and more continue to die due to many years of drought that have weakened the trees and left millions of acres of forestland highly susceptible to insect attacks. In 2015, then-Governor Brown issued an Emergency Proclamation to protect public safety and property from falling dead and dying trees and wildfire. The proclamation directed the California Department of Forestry and Fire (CalFire), the Natural Resources Agency, the Department of Transportation, and the CEC to identify the state’s high hazard zone (HHZ) as a high priority for tree removal to prevent wildfire and falling trees. The proclamation also directed the CPUC to use its authority to extend contracts for bioenergy facilities receiving feedstock from HHZs.
BioRAM 1 Contracts. On March 17, 2016, the CPUC issued Resolution E-4770 requiring each of the electric investor-owned utilities (IOUs) to enter into contracts to purchase their share of at least 50 MW of collective generating capacity from biomass generation facilities that use progressively higher annual minimum prescribed levels of HHZ material as feedstock. Specifically, the biomass facilities were required to use a minimum of 40 percent feedstock from the HHZ in 2016 and grow to 80 percent in 2018 and all subsequent years. The electric IOUs were required to provide five-year contracts to facilities, with the right to extend the five-year contract term for one year at a time, up to a cumulative total of 10 years so long as HHZ fuel is available at the minimum fuel requirement (80 percent). The CPUC utilized a renewable auction mechanism (RAM) as a streamlined procurement process.
SB 859 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 368, Statutes of 2016). SB 859 included a new requirement for electric IOUs and POUs to procure their respective share of 125 MW from existing biomass facilities using prescribed amounts of dead and dying trees located in HHZs as feedstock, with the IOU assigned portion at 96 MW. Specifically, the legislation required that at least 80 percent of the feedstock of an eligible biomass facility, on an annual basis, must be a byproduct of sustainable forestry management. SB 859 required that at least 60 percent of the feedstock must come from HHZs. SB 859 required that the procurement costs would be recovered from all customers on a non-bypassable basis.
CPUC Resolution E-4805. In October 2016, the CPUC issued Resolution E-4805 to implement the electric IOU procurement requirements of SB 859. Resolution E-4805 provided that the IOUs could meet their proportionate shares of the 125 MW goal using any combination of: (a) the BioRAM ordered by Resolution E-4770; (b) a subsequent RAM (BioRAM 2) authorized in the Resolution; and (c) bilateral procurement. However, in order to allow procurement under option (b), Resolution E-4805 required the IOUs to create an updated BioRAM 2 standard contract rider. Specifically, BioRAM2 contracts must contain the feedstock requirements established in SB 859, specify that the contract length is five years, required that the contracted facility is an existing bioenergy project that commenced operation prior to June 1, 2013, and update administrative details such as dates, deadlines, and process requirements.
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018). SB 901 required a number of actions to reduce and prevent the risk of wildfires and to address issues associated with electric IOU cost recovery of wildfire damages. SB 901 also included specific provisions related to biomass facilities, including provisions to loosen the requirements on the facilities, such as: revising the HHZ fuel definitions, require BioRAM contracts to include a monthly compliance option with updated reporting and payment. SB 901 also prohibits biomass facilities for the BioRAM to operate in areas of the state with severe or extreme federal air quality designations, and revise default terms.
CPUC Resolution E-4977. In its efforts to implement the changes noted in SB 901, the CPUC adopted resolution E-4977 in January 2019. The resolution notes, collectively, the BioRAM program requires the IOUs to procure 146 MW of qualifying biomass electricity and that 153 MW is currently under contract – 119 MW under BioRAM 1 contracts and 34 MW under BioRAM2.
State Budget allocated $10 million for Biomass Transportation Subsidy. Transporting fuel and feedstocks to biomass electric generating facilities is one of the main cost drivers that contributes to biomass much higher costs as compared to other generating resources. To help address transportation fuel costs, the state budget in 2022 allocated $10 million for a Biomass Transportation Subsidy targeted at post-fire cleanup and new processing capacity.
SB 1109 (Caballero, Chapter 364, Statutes of 2022) extended requirements on electric IOUs and CCAs to procure energy from biomass generating electric facilities by five years and requires extension of existing contracts by five years.
BioRAM Contracts. Pursuant to the Governor’s Emergency Order Addressing Tree Mortality, SB 859 and SB 901, the BioRAM program required the large IOUs to procure 146 MW of bioenergy from HHZs to aid in mitigating the threat of wildfires. Since 2016, the IOUs have executed contracts with seven biomass facilities to meet their BioRAM procurement requirements. There are six biomass facilities on contracts for a combined total capacity of 154 MW and an average contract price of 11.3 ¢/kWh, respectively, according to the CPUC’s most recent Renewable Portfolio Standard report.
Integrated Resources Plan (IRP) process. SB 350 (De León, Chapter 547, Statutes of 2015) required each load-serving entity (LSE) to file a biennial IRP for approval or certification by the CPUC. The CPUC combines all LSEs’ IRPs to ensure the state is on its path to meet its clean energy procurement goals. POUs are required to file their own IRPs with the CEC. The goal of the IRP is a two-year planning process to ensure that LSEs are meeting targets that allow the electricity sector to contribute to California’s economy-wide GHG emissions reductions goals and that helps to reduce overall costs. The effort is intended to forecast needs on a 10-year horizon. As part of the IRP process, the CPUC has issued several procurement orders on LSEs to address near-term and mid-term procurement needs. Within the procurement orders, the CPUC has directed electric IOUs to serve central procurement entities for local RA and mid-term reliability to serve load to customers, including those of other LSEs. Last year, AB 1373 (Garcia, Chapter 367, Statutes of 2023) authorized the CPUC to request the Department of Water Resources to procure resources identified in the IRP that meet specific requirements, including that they are new long-lead time resources.
Other incentive programs. The CEC is currently administering a Clean Hydrogen Program incentive program, established by AB 209 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 251, Statutes of 2022) to demonstrate or scale-up hydrogen projects that produce, process, deliver, store, or use hydrogen derived from water using eligible renewable energy resources, or produced from these eligible renewable energy resources. While initially appropriated at $100 million, the Governor’s most recent budget proposal proposes to reduce the amount to $65 million. The federal government is also providing significant incentives for hydrogen development. Specifically, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA), included $8 billion to the Department of Energy (DOE) to establish hydrogen research and pilots across the country, known as the Regional Clean Hydrogen Hubs Program (H2Hubs). California has been awarded $1.2 billion which is being managed by the Alliance for Renewable Clean Hydrogen Energy Systems (ARCHES). Under the Inflation Reduction Act the Treasury Department was tasked with developing a federal tax credit to incentivize the production of clean hydrogen, otherwise known as the 45V production tax credit (45V PTC). The tax credit is structured to provide up to a $3 tax credit per kilogram of hydrogen produced, with higher credits granted to lower-carbon-intensive hydrogen.
Comments
Need for this bill. The supports of this bill note that CARB Resolution 22-21 in December 2022 stated that non-combustion biomass energy production should be prioritized. They raise concerns that California is moving away from combustion technologies which leaves biomass facilities still using traditional technology unable to continue operations. Many facilities are idled or in need of new contracts to continue utilizing woody biomass to create electricity but they are left struggling to meet air quality standards or acquire new technologies. The supporters further state that California’s forests are tinder boxes that, if left untreated, exacerbate the catastrophic wildfires that have happened throughout the state. Clearing the excess woody biomass that builds up in the forests is one way to reduce the risk of wildfires while also contributing much needed power to the grid. California needs to ensure that it is utilizing all of the woody biomass that it can to protect our forests and our grid. In this regard, the proposed technology transition grant program could help these idled plants resume activity.
Costs to ratepayers. Energy procurement is general administered via the Integrated Resources Plan. In general, biomass procurement costs are recovered from electric ratepayers via charges on their utility bills. According to the CPUC’s 2021 Padilla Report, Costs and Cost Savings for the RPS Program, the average price of contracts executed in 2019 that were greater than three MW was 2.8 ¢/kWh compared to 3.5 ¢/kWh in 2020, compared to average contract price of existing BioRAM contracts of about 12.0 ¢/kWh. In the CPUC RPS November 2021 report, the CPUC notes a number of challenges with accessing fuel for biomass facilities, including insufficient supply chain capacity, long hauling distances, and high transportation costs, as well as, the need for retrofits of existing facilities. The analysis notes: “Overcoming these barriers would require further, possibly substantial, investment and subsidies.”
The Southern California Public Power Authority (SCPPA) reports that the BioRAM procurement requirements resulted in procuring resources strictly for the capacity, because the electricity could not be delivered to the procuring electric POUs given the interconnections are out of state and wheeling charges to transmit these resources to their utility service territories are not cost-effective. As a result, electric ratepayers of Southern California POU who entered into these contracts were strictly paying for the capacity on the system to satisfy BioRAM requirements without a direct benefit to serving their load. POUs have argued that the biomass contract was priced 20-30 percent more than other renewable baseload energy contracts for geothermal and landfill gas. Moreover, SCPPA notes on another contract for biomass energy the facility provider went bankrupt.
Need for amendments. In order to minimize impacts on electric ratepayers, the committee may wish to delete the provisions of this bill that require an additional biomass procurement requirement. The author and committee may wish to amend this bill to delete Section 2 of the bill which would require the biomass generation procurement mandate and the reference to this procurement in Section 1 (including in Public Resources Code §25993.13(b) as proposed in this bill). The author and committee may also wish to amend the bill to transfer the administration of the incentive program to the California Energy Commission where such programs may be better housed and to clarify that the program is to support conversion of “biomass” generation facilities.
Dual Referral. Should this bill be approved by this committee, it will be re-referred to the Senate Committee on Environmental Quality.
Prior/Related Legislation
AB 843 (Aguiar-Curry, Chapter 234, Statutes of 2022) authorized CCAs to submit eligible bioenergy projects for cost recovery from electric utility ratepayers, pursuant to the BioMAT program, if open capacity exists within the 250 MW program limit, as specified.
SB 1109 (Caballero, Chapter 364, Statutes of 2022) extended requirements on electric IOUs and CCAs to procure energy from biomass generating electric facilities by five years and required extension of existing contracts by five years.
SB 515 (Caballero, 2019) would have expanded the fuels and feedstocks that are eligible to satisfy requirements related to specified contracts for mandated electricity generation from biomass facilities. The bill was further amended to require a report on available fuel feedstocks. The bill died in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including provisions related to biomass operations and electricity procurement.
SB 840 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 341, Statutes of 2016) expedited transmission interconnections for specified bioenergy or biomass projects in order to give them first priority to commence operations over other renewable energy resources.
SB 859 (Senate Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 368, Statutes of 2016) required retail sellers of electricity to purchase a total of 125 MW of power from biomass facilities that generate electricity from forest materials removed from specific high fire hazard zones, as designated by CalFire in the Governor's Proclamation of a State of Emergency issued October 30, 2015.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT:
None received
OPPOSITION:
Southern California Public Power Authority
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
California has experienced some of the worst wildfires in state history in recent years. The millions of tons of dry wood waste that have been building up in our forests is one of the many reasons why recent fires have gotten out of control. I have supported the recent efforts to expand the use of biomass energy so we can ensure this harmful waste is removed and wildfire risk is reduced. However, there is more to be done. Biomass facilities across the state are struggling to keep up with emissions regulations and many simply cannot get the contracts needed to continue operations. This bill will help biomass facilities acquire new emissions reducing technology while also providing them with the financial security needed to allow them to continue clearing our forests of the excess woody debris.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, the Southern California Public Power Authority (SCPPA) states:
This bill would substantially expand the state’s current bioenergy procurement mandate and force several utilities, including four of SCPPA’s Members – Anaheim, Imperial Irrigation District, Los Angeles, and Riverside – to procure additional capacity from costly bioenergy projects that may provide minimal – if any – benefits to their electricity customers…As recent history has shown, the state’s biomass procurement mandates have been costly with little or no benefits to POU customers.
SB 1062 comes at a time when California electric utility customers have seen increases in rates that far exceed the national average.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):