SB 1124: Deceptive practices: service members and veterans.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-02-13
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-05-16: May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Consumers Legal Remedies Act makes unlawful certain unfair methods of competition and certain unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by a person in a transaction intended to result or that results in the sale or lease of goods or services to a consumer, including charging or receiving an unreasonable fee, as defined, to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services, as defined to include, among other things, veterans pensions.
This bill would expand the definition of public social services to also include other veterans benefits. The bill would also expand the definition of an unreasonable fee to include a fee charged with respect to federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged for those services by an attorney or claims agent accredited by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs.
Existing law prohibits a person from, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, electronically accessing a Common Access Card (CAC) issued to a service member, placing or requiring the placement of such a CAC in a smart card reader, requesting or requesting entry of the personal identification number (PIN) associated with such a CAC, or requiring a service member to log in to any United States Department of Defense or, in the case of a member of the United States Coast Guard, United States Department of Homeland Security computer system. Existing law makes void a transaction or sale entered into in violation of these provisions.
This bill would extend the above-described restrictions to prohibit requiring a former or current service member to log in or share their credentials for accessing, or accessing with another persons credentials, any United States Department of Defense, United States Department of Veterans Affairs, or United States Department of Homeland Security computer system. Except as provided, the bill would prohibit a person from, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, directly or indirectly soliciting, contracting for, charging, or receiving, or attempting to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs. The bill would also make void a contract performed in violation of these provisions. The bill would make violations of these provisions a misdemeanor. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)The unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices listed in this subdivision undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or that results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer are unlawful:
(1)Passing off goods or services as those of another.
(2)Misrepresenting the source, sponsorship, approval, or certification of goods or services.
(3)Misrepresenting the affiliation, connection, or association with, or certification by, another.
(4)Using deceptive representations or designations of geographic origin in connection with goods or services.
(5)Representing that goods or services have sponsorship, approval, characteristics, ingredients, uses, benefits, or quantities that they do not have or that a person has a sponsorship, approval, status, affiliation, or connection that the person does not have.
(6)Representing that goods are original or new if they have deteriorated unreasonably or are altered, reconditioned, reclaimed, used, or secondhand.
(7)Representing that goods or services are of a particular standard, quality, or grade, or that goods are of a particular style or model, if they are of another.
(8)Disparaging the goods, services, or business of another by false or misleading representation of fact.
(9)Advertising goods or services with intent not to sell them as advertised.
(10)Advertising goods or services with intent not to supply reasonably expectable demand, unless the advertisement discloses a limitation of quantity.
(11)Advertising furniture without clearly indicating that it is unassembled if that is the case.
(12)Advertising the price of unassembled furniture without clearly indicating the assembled price of that furniture if the same furniture is available assembled from the seller.
(13)Making false or misleading statements of fact concerning reasons for, existence of, or amounts of, price reductions.
(14)Representing that a transaction confers or involves rights, remedies, or obligations that it does not have or involve, or that are prohibited by law.
(15)Representing that a part, replacement, or repair service is needed when it is not.
(16)Representing that the subject of a transaction has been supplied in accordance with a previous representation when it has not.
(17)Representing that the consumer will receive a rebate, discount, or other economic benefit, if the earning of the benefit is contingent on an event to occur subsequent to the consummation of the transaction.
(18)Misrepresenting the authority of a salesperson, representative, or agent to negotiate the final terms of a transaction with a consumer.
(19)Inserting an unconscionable provision in the contract.
(20)Advertising that a product is being offered at a specific price plus a specific percentage of that price unless (A) the total price is set forth in the advertisement, which may include, but is not limited to, shelf tags, displays, and media advertising, in a size larger than any other price in that advertisement, and (B) the specific price plus a specific percentage of that price represents a markup from the sellers costs or from the wholesale price of the product. This subdivision shall not apply to in-store advertising by businesses that are open only to members or cooperative organizations organized pursuant to Division 3 (commencing with Section 12000) of Title 1 of the Corporations Code if more than 50 percent of purchases are made at the specific price set forth in the advertisement.
(21)Selling or leasing goods in violation of Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1797.8) of Title 1.7.
(22)(A)Disseminating an unsolicited prerecorded message by telephone without an unrecorded, natural voice first informing the person answering the telephone of the name of the caller or the organization being represented, and either the address or the telephone number of the caller, and without obtaining the consent of that person to listen to the prerecorded message.
(B)This subdivision does not apply to a message disseminated to a business associate, customer, or other person having an established relationship with the person or organization making the call, to a call for the purpose of collecting an existing obligation, or to any call generated at the request of the recipient.
(23)(A)The home solicitation, as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 1761, of a consumer who is a senior citizen where a loan or assessment is made encumbering the primary residence of that consumer for purposes of paying for home improvements and where the transaction is part of a pattern or practice in violation any of the following:
(i)Subsection (h) or (i) of Section 1639 of Title 15 of the United States Code.
(ii)Paragraph (1), (2), or (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 226.34 of Title 12 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(iii)Section 22684, 22685, 22686, or 22687 of the Financial Code.
(iv)Section 5898.16, 5898.17, 5913, 5922, 5923, 5924, 5925, 5926, or 5940 of the Streets and Highways Code.
(B)A third party shall not be liable under this subdivision unless (i) there was an agency relationship between the party who engaged in home solicitation and the third party, or (ii) the third party had actual knowledge of, or participated in, the unfair or deceptive transaction. A third party who is a holder in due course under a home solicitation transaction shall not be liable under this subdivision.
(24)(A)Charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph:
(i)Public social services means those activities and functions of state and local government administered or supervised by the State Department of Health Care Services, the State Department of Public Health, or the State Department of Social Services, and involved in providing aid or services, or both, including health care services, and medical assistance, to those persons who, because of their economic circumstances or social condition, are in need of that aid or those services and may benefit from them.
(ii)Public social services also includes activities and functions administered or supervised by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs or the California Department of Veterans Affairs involved in providing aid or services, or both, to veterans, including pension and other veterans benefits.
(iii)Unreasonable fee means a fee that is is either or both of the following:
(I)A fee that is exorbitant and disproportionate to the services performed. Factors to be considered, if appropriate, in determining the reasonableness of a fee, are based on the circumstances existing at the time of the service and shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(I)(ia)The time and effort required.
(II)(ib)The novelty and difficulty of the services.
(III)(ic)The skill required to perform the services.
(IV)(id)The nature and length of the professional relationship.
(V)(ie)The experience, reputation, and ability of the person providing the services.
(II)A fee charged with respect to federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged for those services by an attorney or claims agent accredited by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs.
(C)This paragraph shall not apply to attorneys licensed to practice law in California, who are subject to the California Rules of Professional Conduct and to the mandatory fee arbitration provisions of Article 13 (commencing with Section 6200) of Chapter 4 of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code, when the fees charged or received are for providing representation in administrative agency appeal proceedings or court proceedings for purposes of procuring, maintaining, or securing public social services on behalf of a person or group of persons.
(25)(A)Advertising or promoting any event, presentation, seminar, workshop, or other public gathering regarding veterans benefits or entitlements that does not include the following statement in the same type size and font as the term veteran or any variation of that term:
(i)I am not authorized to file an initial application for Veterans Aid and Attendance benefits on your behalf, or to represent you before the Board of Veterans Appeals within the United States Department of Veterans Affairs in any proceeding on any matter, including an application for those benefits. It would be illegal for me to accept a fee for preparing that application on your behalf. The requirements of this clause do not apply to a person licensed to act as an agent or attorney in proceedings before the Agency of Original Jurisdiction and the Board of Veterans Appeals within the United States Department of Veterans Affairs when that person is offering those services at the advertised event.
(ii)The statement in clause (i) shall also be disseminated, both orally and in writing, at the beginning of any event, presentation, seminar, workshop, or public gathering regarding veterans benefits or entitlements.
(B)Advertising or promoting any event, presentation, seminar, workshop, or other public gathering regarding veterans benefits or entitlements that is not sponsored by, or affiliated with, the United States Department of Veterans Affairs, the California Department of Veterans Affairs, or any other congressionally chartered or recognized organization of honorably discharged members of the Armed Forces of the United States, or any of their auxiliaries that does not include the following statement, in the same type size and font as the term veteran or the variation of that term:
This event is not sponsored by, or affiliated with, the United States Department of Veterans Affairs, the California Department of Veterans Affairs, or any other congressionally chartered or recognized organization of honorably discharged members of the Armed Forces of the United States, or any of their auxiliaries. None of the insurance products promoted at this sales event are endorsed by those organizations, all of which offer free advice to veterans about how to qualify and apply for benefits.
(i)The statement in this subparagraph shall be disseminated, both orally and in writing, at the beginning of any event, presentation, seminar, workshop, or public gathering regarding veterans benefits or entitlements.
(ii)The requirements of this subparagraph shall not apply in a case where the United States Department of Veterans Affairs, the California Department of Veterans Affairs, or other congressionally chartered or recognized organization of honorably discharged members of the Armed Forces of the United States, or any of their auxiliaries have granted written permission to the advertiser or promoter for the use of its name, symbol, or insignia to advertise or promote the event, presentation, seminar, workshop, or other public gathering.
(26)Advertising, offering for sale, or selling a financial product that is illegal under state or federal law, including any cash payment for the assignment to a third party of the consumers right to receive future pension or veterans benefits.
(27)Representing that a product is made in California by using a Made in California label created pursuant to Section 12098.10 of the Government Code, unless the product complies with Section 12098.10 of the Government Code.
(28)(A)Failing to include either of the following in a solicitation by a covered person, or an entity acting on behalf of a covered person, to a consumer for a consumer financial product or service:
(i)The name of the covered person, and, if applicable, the entity acting on behalf of the covered person, and relevant contact information, including a mailing address and telephone number.
(ii)The following disclosure statement in at least 18-point bold type and in the language in which the solicitation is drafted: THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. YOU ARE NOT REQUIRED TO MAKE ANY PAYMENT OR TAKE ANY OTHER ACTION IN RESPONSE TO THIS OFFER.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph:
(i)Consumer financial product or service has the same meaning as defined in Section 90005 of the Financial Code.
(ii)(I)Covered person has the same meaning as defined in Section 90005 of the Financial Code.
(II)Covered person does not mean an entity exempt from Division 24 (commencing with Section 90000) of the Financial Code pursuant to Section 90002 of the Financial Code.
(iii)Solicitation means an advertisement or marketing communication through writing or graphics that is directed to, or likely to give the impression of being directed to, an individually identified person, residence, or business location. Solicitation does not include any of the following:
(I)Communication through a mass advertisement, including in a catalog, on a radio or television broadcast, or on a publicly accessible internet website, if that communication is not directed to, or is not likely to give the impression of being directed to, an individually identified person, residence, or business location.
(II)Communication via a telephone, mail, or electronic communication that was initiated by a consumer.
(III)A written credit or insurance solicitation that is subject to the disclosure requirements of subsection (d) of Section 1681m of Title 15 of the United States Code.
(29)(A)Advertising, displaying, or offering a price for a good or service that does not include all mandatory fees or charges other than either of the following:
(i)Taxes or fees imposed by a government on the transaction.
(ii)Postage or carriage charges that will be reasonably and actually incurred to ship the physical good to the consumer.
(B)Compliance by a person providing broadband internet access service on its own or as part of a bundle, as defined in Section 8.1(b) of Title 47 of the Code of Federal Regulations, with the broadband consumer label requirements adopted by the Federal Communications Commission in FCC 22-86 on November 14, 2022, codified in Section 8.1(a) of Title 47 of the Code of Federal Regulations, shall be deemed compliance with this paragraph.
(C)(i)For purposes of this subparagraph, financial entity means an entity that is exempt from Division 24 (commencing with Section 90000) of the Financial Code pursuant to Section 90002 of the Financial Code.
(ii)A financial entity that is required to provide disclosures in compliance with any of the following federal or state acts or regulations with respect to a financial transaction is exempt from this paragraph for purposes of that financial transaction:
(I)The federal Truth in Savings Act, as amended (12 U.S.C. Sec. 4301 et seq.).
(II)The federal Electronic Fund Transfer Act, as amended (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1693 et seq.).
(III)Section 19 of the Federal Reserve Act, as amended (12 U.S.C. Sec. 461 et seq.).
(IV)The federal Truth in Lending Act, as amended (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1601 et seq.).
(V)The federal Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act, as amended (12 U.S.C. Sec. 2601 et seq.).
(VI)The federal Home Ownership and Equity Protection Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1639).
(VII)Any regulation adopted pursuant to any of the federal acts in subclauses (I) to (VI), inclusive.
(VIII)The California Financing Law (Division 9 (commencing with Section 22000) of the Financial Code).
(IX)The California Residential Mortgage Lending Act (Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000) of the Financial Code).
(X)The Real Estate Law (Part 1 (commencing with Section 10000) of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code).
(XI)Any regulation adopted pursuant to any of the state acts in subclauses (VIII) to (X), inclusive.
(b)(1)It is an unfair or deceptive act or practice for a mortgage broker or lender, directly or indirectly, to use a home improvement contractor to negotiate the terms of any loan that is secured, whether in whole or in part, by the residence of the borrower and that is used to finance a home improvement contract or any portion of a home improvement contract. For purposes of this subdivision, mortgage broker or lender includes a finance lender licensed pursuant to the California Financing Law (Division 9 (commencing with Section 22000) of the Financial Code), a residential mortgage lender licensed pursuant to the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act (Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000) of the Financial Code), or a real estate broker licensed under the Real Estate Law (Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code).
(2)This section shall not be construed to either authorize or prohibit a home improvement contractor from referring a consumer to a mortgage broker or lender by this subdivision. However, a home improvement contractor may refer a consumer to a mortgage lender or broker if that referral does not violate Section 7157 of the Business and Professions Code or any other law. A mortgage lender or broker may purchase an executed home improvement contract if that purchase does not violate Section 7157 of the Business and Professions Code or any other law. Nothing in this paragraph shall have any effect on the application of Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 1801) of Title 2 to a home improvement transaction or the financing of a home improvement transaction.
(c)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2024.
SEC. 2.Section 401 of the Military and Veterans Code is amended to read:401.(a)Application by a service member for, or receipt by a service member of, a stay, postponement, or suspension pursuant to this chapter in the payment of any tax, fine, penalty, insurance premium, or other civil obligation or liability of that person shall not itself, without regard to other considerations, provide the basis for any of the following:
(1)A determination by any lender or other person that the service member is unable to pay any civil obligation or liability in accordance with its terms.
(2)With respect to a credit transaction between a creditor and the service member, any of the following:
(A)A denial or revocation of credit by the creditor.
(B)A change by the creditor in the terms of an existing credit arrangement.
(C)A refusal by the creditor to grant credit to the service member in substantially the amount or on substantially the terms requested.
(3)An adverse report relating to the creditworthiness of the service member by or to any person or entity engaged in the practice of assembling or evaluating consumer credit information.
(4)A refusal by an insurer to insure the service member.
(5)An annotation in a service members record by a creditor or a person engaged in the practice of assembling or evaluating consumer credit information identifying the service member as a member of the active militia, as defined in Section 120, or an active or reserve component of the Armed Forces.
(b)A person shall not, in connection with the collection of any obligation, including any debt or payment, falsely claim to be a member or civilian employee of the Armed Forces, a component of the active militia, as defined in Section 120, the United States Department of Defense, the United States Department of Homeland Security, or the Military Department, or identify themselves through the use of any military rank, rating, or title.
(c)A person shall not, in connection with the collection of any obligation, including any debt or payment, from a member of the active militia, as defined in Section 120, or a member of an active or reserve component of the Armed Forces, contact the members military unit or chain of command without the written consent of the member given after the obligation becomes due and payable.
(d)(1)A person shall not, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, electronically do any of the following:
(A)Electronically access a Common Access Card (CAC) issued to a service member, place or require the placement of such a CAC in a smart card reader, or request or request require entry of the personal identification number (PIN) associated with such a CAC, or require CAC.
(B)Require a current or former service member to log in to or share their credentials for accessing any United States Department of Defense or, in the case of a member of the Coast Guard, Defense, United States Department of Veterans Affairs, or United States Department of Homeland Security computer system. A
(C)Access a United States Department of Defense, United States Department of Veterans Affairs, or United States Department of Homeland Security computer system with another persons credentials.
(2)A transaction or sale entered into or performed in violation of this subdivision is void.
(e)Except as provided in Sections 1984 and 5904 of Title 38 of the United States Code, a person shall not directly or indirectly solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, or attempt to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs.
(e)(f)(1)A person shall not condition the receipt of a military or veteran discount, in any form, on the waiver by a recipient of the discount of any right the person has under state or federal law. Any such waiver is void.
(2)Any other waiver of a right provided to service members, former service members, or their dependents by this code is void.
(f)(g)Any person violating any provision of this section is liable for actual damages, reasonable attorneys fees, and costs incurred by the injured party.
(g)(h)Any person violating any provision of this section is guilty of a misdemeanor, and shall be punishable by imprisonment not to exceed one year or by a fine not to exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000), or both.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2024 | May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 14, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2024 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 3. Noes 0. Page 3703.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2024 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on M. & V.A. (Ayes 10. Noes 1. Page 3531.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on M. & V.A. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | April 2 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Feb 21, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and M. & V.A. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 15. |
| Feb 13, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 13, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Military and Veterans Affairs |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Military and Veterans Affairs] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AARP | ** Support | |
| American Legion, Department Of California | ** Support | |
| Amvets, Department Of California | ** Support | |
| Attorney General Rob Bonta | ** Support | |
| California Association Of County Veterans Service Officers | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Support | |
| California State Commanders Veterans Council | ** Support | |
| California Teamsters Public Affairs Council | ** Support | |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| County Of Kern | ** Support | |
| County Of Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| County of Nevada | ** Support | |
| Military Officers Association Of America, California Council Of Chapters | ** Support | |
| National Association for Veterans Rights | ** Against | |
| San Diego Military Advisory Council | ** Support | |
| Ventura County Chapter of The Military Officers Association of America | ** Support | |
| Veteran Benefits Guide | ** Against | |
| Veterans Guardian VA Claim Consulting, LLC | ** Support | |
| Veterans Of Foreign Wars Department Of California | ** Support | |
| VetFund Foundataion | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1124 (Menjivar) - Deceptive practices: service members and veterans
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary: SB 1124, requires, consistent with federal law, a person to be federally accredited in order to prepare, present, or prosecute a veteran’s claim for benefits under federal law.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates ongoing costs of $500,000 or less (Unfair Competition Law Fund) to enforce the provisions of this bill. Based on an initial assessment, the Consumer Protection Section (CPS) anticipates that the proposed language changes would require 1.0 Special Investigator beginning January 1, 2025 and ongoing to investigate potential violations of this statute. The DOJ notes that Implementation of this bill will be dependent upon the appropriation of funds and that the DOJ will be unable to absorb the costs to comply with or implement the requirements of the bill within existing budgeted resources.
- Unknown, potentially significant workload cost pressures (General Fund, Trial Court Trust Fund) to the courts to adjudicate violations of this bill in civil actions brought to enforce this bill. It generally costs about $8,000 to operate a courtroom for one eight-hour day. It is unknown how many additional civil actions would be brought as a result of the implementation of this bill. Consequently, if additional cases are filed under the provisions of this measure that otherwise would not be available under existing law take 50 or more hours of court involvement, the cost pressures of this measure to the courts would surpass the Suspense File threshold. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to increase the amount appropriated to backfill for trial court operations. For illustrative purposes, the Governor’s 2024-25 state budget proposes $83.1 million ongoing General Fund to continue to backfill the Trial Court Trust Fund for expected revenue declines.
Background: Veterans of the United States armed forces may be eligible for a broad range of programs and services provided by the federal Department of Veteran Affairs (VA). Filing for VA benefits involves a complex, highly technical process. To assist veterans through the claims process, the VA and the State of California both provide resources and services. The VA accredits three types of representatives—Veterans Service Organization (VSO) representatives, attorneys, and agents—to help ensure that claimants have access to responsible and qualified representation on their VA benefits claims. Federal regulations also govern the fees available, providing that only accredited agents and attorneys may receive fees from claimants or appellants for their services provided in connection with representation. Recognized organizations are not permitted to receive fees. Agents and attorneys may only charge claimants or appellants for representation provided after an agency of original jurisdiction has issued notice of an initial decision on the claim or claims, except as provided. Fees are required to be reasonable. The regulations establish a rebuttable presumption that any fee that does not exceed 20 percent of past-due benefits awarded is reasonable and that any fee that exceeds 33 1/3 percent of such benefits is unreasonable.
Proposed Law: This bill would, consistent with federal law, prohibit a person from directly or indirectly soliciting, contracting for, charging, or receiving, or attempting to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the VA except as provided under federal law. This bill also expands the existing Consumer Legal Remedies Act prohibition, including charging or receiving an unreasonable fee, to other veterans benefits and provides that a fee charged with respect to federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged for those services by an attorney or agent accredited by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs is unreasonable. Lastly, this bill prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems; accessing such systems with another person’s credentials; and requiring entry of a veteran’s PIN associated with a Common Access Card.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON MILITARY AND VETERANS AFFAIRS
Senator Bob Archuleta, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1124 Hearing Date: 4/22/24
Author: | Menjivar | ||
Version: | 2/13/24 Introduced | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jenny Callison | ||
Subject: Deceptive practices: service members and veterans
DESCRIPTION
Summary:
Provides additional protections for veterans in California in connection with fees charged for assistance applying for veterans’ benefits and the privacy of their information, and requires persons to be federally accredited before preparing, presenting, or prosecuting a veteran’s claim for benefits under federal law.
Existing law:
Existing federal law:
- Authorizes to Secretary to furnish to discharged members of the armed forces of such government, under agreements requiring reimbursement in cash of expenses so incurred, at such rates and under such regulations as the Secretary may prescribe, medical, surgical, and dental treatment, hospital care, transportation and traveling expenses, prosthetic appliances, education, training, or similar benefits authorized by the laws of such nation for its veterans, and services required in extending such benefits. (38 U.S.C. § 109.)
- Prohibits any individual from acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under laws administered by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) unless such individual has been recognized for such purposes by the Secretary of the VA (Secretary), except as provided. (38 U.S.C. § 5901.)
- Authorizes the Secretary to recognize representatives of the American National Red Cross, the American Legion, the Disabled American Veterans, the United Spanish War Veterans, the Veterans of Foreign Wars, and such other organizations as the Secretary may approve, in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of benefits claims. No fees may be charged in connection with services rendered hereby. (38 U.S.C. § 5902.)
- Authorizes the Secretary to recognize any individual as an agent or attorney for the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of claims under laws administered by the Secretary and provides that the Secretary shall promulgate regulations laying out the necessary qualifications and standards of conduct. (38 U.S.C. § 5904.) Those attendant regulations lay out the accreditation process, continuing legal education requirements, and parameters on reasonable fees. (38 C.F.R. § 14.626 et seq.)
- Prohibits a fee from being charged, allowed, or paid for services of agents and attorneys with respect to services provided before the date on which a claimant is provided notice of the agency of original jurisdiction’s initial decision. (38 U.S.C. § 5904.)
Existing state law:
- Establishes the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), which prohibits unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer. (Civ. Code § 1750 et seq.)
- Designates specified practices as unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices, including charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services, including veterans benefits, as provided. (Civ. Code § 1770.)
- Establishes the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), which provides a statutory cause of action for any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, including over the internet. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 et seq.)
- Prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from electronically accessing a Common Access Card (CAC) issued to a service member, placing or requiring the placement of such a CAC in a smart card reader, requesting or requesting entry of the personal identification number (PIN) associated with such a CAC, or requiring a service member to log in to any Department of Defense or, in the case of a member of the Coast Guard, Department of Homeland Security computer system. A transaction or sale entered into in violation of this subdivision is void. (Mil. & Vets. Code § 401(d).)
- Authorizes the board of supervisors of each county to appoint a county veterans service officer who shall assist every veteran of any war of the United States and every qualified former member, and the dependents of every deceased veteran and every qualified former member, in presenting and pursuing any claim the veteran or the qualified former member may have against the United States and in establishing the veteran’s or qualified former member’s right to any privilege, preference, care, or compensation provided for by the laws of the United States or of this state. (Mil. & Vets. Code § 971(a).)
This bill:
- Prohibits persons from directly or indirectly soliciting, contracting for, charging, or receiving, or attempting to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the VA except as provided in Sections 1984 and 5904 under Title 38 of the US Code.
- Expands the CLRA prohibition, including charging or receiving an unreasonable fee, to other veterans benefits and provides that a fee charged with respect to federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged for those services by an attorney or claims agent accredited by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs is unreasonable.
- Prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems; accessing such systems with another person’s credentials; and requiring entry of a veteran’s PIN associated with a CAC.
BACKGROUND
Since its creation, the United States provided medical care and maintenance for disabled veterans and bonuses for serving soldiers, a practice derived from late 1500s English legislation. A military bonus is payment for the difference between what a soldier earned and what the soldier could have earned elsewhere.
Overview of Veterans Benefits:
Veterans of the United States armed forces may be eligible for a broad range of programs and services provided by the VA. These federal benefits are legislated in Title 38 of the United States Code and generally fall within the following categories:
- Education & Training
- Vocational Rehab & Employment
- Disability Compensation & Pension
- Health Care
- Home Loan Guaranty
- Life Insurance
- Burial
Filing for VA benefits involves a complex, highly technical process. The Code of Federal Regulations Title 38, which governs veterans’ claims, contains more than 1,600 pages of fine print, and the accompanying manual also is over 1,600 pages in length.
The Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA), a component of the Department of Veterans Affairs, processes disability claims and administers all aspects of the VA disability program. Since 1988 VA disability claim decisions have been subject to federal court review. Disability ratings theoretically represent a veteran's "average impairment in earnings capacity", on a scale from 0 to 100 in increments of 10. The amount of compensation provided—both cash payments and VA-sponsored services—is based on the veteran's "average impairment in earnings capacity".
VA disability compensation is a tax-free monetary benefit paid to Veterans with disabilities that are the result of a disease or injury incurred or aggravated during active military service. Compensation may also be paid for post-service disabilities that are considered related or secondary to disabilities occurring in service and for disabilities presumed to be related to circumstances of military service, even though they may arise after service. Generally, the degrees of disability specified are also designed to compensate for considerable loss of working time from exacerbations or illnesses.
The Claims Process:
Only Veterans who have been honorably discharged are eligible for disability benefits and may apply for them by appearing at an in-person meeting, by mail, and electronically via the VA’s secure web portal. The VA’s eBenefits portal provides veterans with information and resources regarding the claims process and permits veterans to securely submit disability claims including claims for increased benefits, supplemental claims, and secondary service-connected claims. Veterans may also upload documents in support of a claim and check on the status of an application. The application process requires veterans to submit sensitive personal information including protected health information.
Disability claims require an analysis and review by the VBA of detailed records and medical information. Generally, the VA takes from 90 to 120 days to decide on a claim. How long a specific claim takes depends on current VA workloads, the complexity of the claim, and the completeness of the application. It is well known that the process can be frustrating for veterans seeking to understand the VA’s procedures, including what evidence may be required to support a claim, disability ratings, and the reconsideration and appeals process. The VA claims process is arduous, cumbersome, extensive, stressful, and time consuming. It often involves paperwork to which the veteran does not have access to other than through the eBenefits portal. The VA recommends supporting a disability claim with the following documents:
- VA medical records and hospital records.
- Private medical records and hospital reports.
- Supporting statements.
- Discharge papers
To assist veterans through the claims process, the VA and the State of California both provide resources and services. The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) accredits three types of representatives—Veterans Service Organization (VSO) representatives, attorneys, and agents—to help ensure that claimants have access to responsible and qualified representation on their VA benefits claims. VA-accredited representatives must have good moral character and be capable of providing competent representation, and VA’s Office of General Counsel is responsible for making those determinations through its accreditation process. The accreditation process differs depending of which type of accreditation is being sought. An accredited VSO representative is someone who has been recommended for accreditation by a VSO that is recognized by VA to assist on VA benefit claims.
To ensure accredited attorneys and claims agents are best suited to assist with claims, the regulations impose a continuing legal education requirement. The regulations also govern the fees available, providing that only accredited agents and attorneys may receive fees from claimants or appellants for their services provided in connection with representation. Recognized organizations are not permitted to receive fees. Agents and attorneys may only charge claimants or appellants for representation provided after an agency of original jurisdiction has issued notice of an initial decision on the claim or claims, except as provided. Fees are required to be reasonable. The regulations establish a rebuttable presumption that any fee that does not exceed 20 percent of past-due benefits awarded is reasonable and that any fee that exceeds 33 1/3 percent of such benefits is unreasonable.
Veterans Claims in California:
To assist veterans and their families in navigating the claims process, 28 states, including California, use the county veterans service officer (CVSO) model. CVSOs are trained, accredited professionals, who can legally represent veterans in the federal claims process, and also help connect veterans with state- and locally-provided benefits. Fifty-six of California’s 58 counties have CVSOs, whose professional interests are represented by the California Association of County Veterans Service Officers (CACVSO).
“ The county veterans service officer shall assist every veteran of any war of the United States and every qualified former member, and the dependents of every deceased veteran and every qualified former member, in presenting and pursuing any claim the veteran or the qualified former member may have against the United States and in establishing the veteran’s or qualified former member’s right to any privilege, preference, care, or compensation provided for by the laws of the United States or of this state” (MVC 971 (a)).
The California model requires a close partnership between state and county governments through the auspices of CalVet the various CVSO offices. Collectively, the CVSO, through claims initiation and development, and CalVet, through claims development and representation, provide assistance to veterans and their dependents in preparing and submitting claims and in representing claimants before the federal, state and local agencies providing veterans benefits. In addition, the CVSOs use the CalVet-sponsored VetPro software program to enhance their claims reporting and tracking. In addition to the 56 CVSOs and their staff, there are 129 VFW offices, 452 American Legion posts, and 464 VA-accredited lawyers to assist veterans in the state.
PACT ACT:
In 2022, Congress passed the Sergeant First Class Heath Robinson Honoring our Promise to Address Comprehensive Toxics Act (PACT Act). The PACT Act allocated $797 billion to significantly improve healthcare access and funding for veterans who were exposed to toxic substances during military service. The PACT Act opened the door to VA benefits to a population of veterans not previously eligible.
COMMENT
Historically, there is a great deal of money involved with claims filings for veterans disability, and henceforth a great deal of bad actors involve themselves. Shortly after the Civil War and the commencement of a system for settling veterans claims, bad actors sought out veterans to persuade to blame their injuries on war with false promises. In the 1930s, in the midst of an environment of ethically questionable business practices and notably excessive fees, Congress chartered VSOs to provide free disability claim assistance.
A subcommittee of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs held a hearing on the VA Accreditation Program in 2022, emphasizing concerns about this unregulated industry. Congressman Chris Pappas, Chair of the Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee of the House Committee on Veterans,’ Affairs squarely addressed the issue:
“For decades, federal law has prohibited anyone from helping a veteran prepare or present a VA benefit claim without accreditation. Despite this black-letter law, there’s been an explosion in the number of unaccredited, for-profit companies who say they’re not preparing or presenting claims . . . However, if you read the fine print, they also charge veterans hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars. . . . there are many other veterans who have complained about exorbitant costs, hidden fees, difficulties canceling a contract, aggressive marketing emails, rampant collection calls, and other predatory practices that many unaccredited companies employ. Some companies even solicit veterans’ eBenefits usernames and passwords, or try to gain direct access to people’s bank accounts…Some veterans may be willing to pay a fee if the services they receive are worthwhile and a company’s business practices are above board. But without adequate oversight through the accreditation process, we cannot be assured that this is case.”
According to the Wounded Warrior Project:
Issues that arose in the past – most notably excessive fees and false promises – have persisted to the present day, where current circumstances have exacerbated problems for some. Veterans who are now working from home or pursing online education or training due to the COVID-19 public health emergency are now less likely to go to a VA regional office (VARO) to speak with a local VSO or VA representative about the disability claims process. Information about the process can be found independently; however, a high degree of circumspection may be required. Searching the internet may help a veteran find a VSO that provides VA-accredited professionals to ensure that benefits claims are filed properly and efficiently – and that he or she will never pay a fee for this expert assistance. However, such results may be scattered within numerous “for-profit” organizations. For those unfamiliar with the distinction, predatory tactics and social media campaigns targeted towards the veteran community can further overshadow more trustworthy options (both non-profit and for-profit).
The decisions that follow can have a steep financial impact. A veteran who chooses to be represented by an agent may be obligated to pay substantial fees during the claims process. In some cases, a veteran may pay an initial fee for a records review and nexus statement, and some fee-based companies also assess a contingency fee based on the total retroactive payment if the claim is successful. Twenty percent is a standard contingency fee that can lead a veteran to owe anywhere from $0 to well over $100,000. If, for example, a 20% contingency fee is applied to a $20,000 retroactive payment, a veteran would be responsible for a $4,000 payment to the claims agent or attorney while keeping $16,000 for his or herself – before considering any upfront fees and additional charges associated with printing, doctors’ appointments, and various costs accrued during their claim process. In the end, the veteran will take home considerably less than their VA award.
The Consumer Legal Remedies Act prohibits charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services. “Public social services” is defined to mean those activities and functions of state and local government administered or supervised by specified state departments, and involved in providing aid or services, or both, including health care services, and medical assistance, to those persons who, because of their economic circumstances or social condition, are in need of that aid or those services and may benefit from them. “Unreasonable fee” is defined to mean a fee that is exorbitant and disproportionate to the services performed. The section lays out a number of factors to be considered in determining reasonableness.
In response to prior concerns about unscrupulous companies preying on veterans, SB 180 (Corbett, Ch. 79, Stats. 2011) expanded the definition of public social services to explicitly include “activities and functions administered or supervised by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs or the California Department of Veterans Affairs involved in providing aid or services, or both, to veterans, including pension benefits.”
This bill expands this prohibition by ensuring that “other veterans benefits” are included within that definition, but more importantly, it deems as unreasonable a fee charged in connection with federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged by an accredited agent or attorney.
The bill also codifies in state law the federal prohibition on preparing, presenting, or prosecuting claims for benefits unless accredited pursuant to federal law. Specifically, the law states that, except “as provided in Sections 1984 and 5904 of Title 38 of the United States Code, a person shall not directly or indirectly solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, or attempt to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs.”
The bill also bolsters existing protections for veterans by prohibiting a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems and from accessing such systems with another person’s credentials.
According to the author:
“Veterans bravely serve and often times sacrifice their wellbeing for our country. Those living with the consequences of their selfless service deserve a smooth process in accessing the benefits they have earned. However, that process can be daunting and leaves veterans vulnerable to bad actors. Therefore, we must ensure we have accredited advocates working on their case to ensure oversight, accountability, and the proper dispersal of funds. That is why I introduced SB 1124, in collaboration with Attorney General Bonta, to tackle this very important but often overlooked issue. SB 1124 specifically prohibits unaccredited caseworkers and lawyers from processing VA disability claims, protects veterans from exorbitant fees, and makes it a crime to obtain unauthorized access to the Veterans Affairs claims system using a veterans’ login information. We must protect the personal information, financial interests, and health of the veterans who have sacrificed to protect us.”
Stakeholder Positions:
Attorney General Rob Bonta, the sponsor of the bill, writes:
The VA accreditation program exists to ensure that veterans receive competent and fair representation on their VA benefits claims. In addition to CVSO and nonprofit VSOs, which provide assistance free of charge, the VA also accredits attorneys and claims agents to represent veterans and assist with benefit claims. Accredited attorneys and claims agents cannot charge money for assistance with an initial claim for veteran’s benefits, but, subject to limits set and enforced by the VA, they can charge for other services.
In 2006, Congress amended federal law in a way that eliminated prohibitions that made it a crime to assist veterans with benefits claims without being accredited. This had the unintentional effect of driving the creation of a cottage industry of businesses that charge veterans for assistance with benefits claims without being accredited. Some of these businesses are well intentioned, but operate without the protections provided by VA accreditation and oversight, including fee caps. Others, often referred to as “claims sharks”, are predators that provide worthless services or get veterans to agree to exorbitant fee agreements, sometimes including contingent fees that would be patently illegal if charged by an accredited attorney or agent.
Because unaccredited claims representatives are not subject to the VA’s rules and oversight, they pose an unacceptable consumer risk to veterans. To address this problem, SB 1124 would strengthen several state law protections for veterans, including by: (1) prohibiting any person not accredited by the VA from charging a veteran for help with a benefits claim; (2) increasing penalties for persons that obtain unauthorized access to veterans’ data on VA computer systems; and (3) prohibiting the charging of fees that exceed what a VA-accredited attorney or claims agent could legally charge to assist a veteran with a benefits claim.
The VFW Department of California, a cosponsor of the bill, writes:
SB 1124 addresses a critical gap in the current legal framework that has allowed unaccredited claims representatives to exploit veterans seeking assistance with their benefits claims. Unaccredited claims representatives are not required to adhere to the well-established professional and ethical standards of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) accreditation, so their advice can often be misleading or even fraudulent. By strengthening state law to prohibit such practices, this bill ensures that only those accredited by the VA can offer these crucial services.
Some of the predatory practices include promising or guaranteeing an increased disability rating, expedited VA claims decisions, and using confusing tactics or ambiguous language to mislead claimants or coerce them into signing a contract. Veterans face numerous challenges upon returning to civilian life, and navigating the complexities of VA benefits process is difficult enough. SB 1124 not only protects veterans from predatory practices, but also honors their service by ensuring they have access to fair and competent representation.
This legislation is crucial in safeguarding veterans from exploitation and ensuring veterans receive the benefits they have earned through their service. . . . This bill will protect those who bear the visible and invisible scars of war.
Veterans Guardian write in opposition unless amended:
We appreciate the intent of this bill, but this bill fails to address any specific predatory or unscrupulous practices. Legislation like this bill, in the state of New Jersey, is currently being litigated in the Third Circuit Federal Court of Appeals, and we share the same Constitutional and legal concerns with SB 1124. I would be happy to discuss this in depth with the Committee. We have been working at the federal level for the last few years in a bipartisan manner to achieve a compromise solution that maintains veterans’ options and freedom of choice while legislating against predatory practices and providing oversight from the VA for all actors in this space. California’s veterans can make good, independent decisions. This body shouldn’t take that right away. We hope to work with this Committee and Leadership to preserve the option for California’s nearly 1,500,000 Veterans to decide for themselves how to pursue their claim.
Bill language like what we have presented as an alternative to the committee has been passed through at least one full chamber in Arizona, Kentucky, Hawaii and has been introduced in Louisiana. We are committed to working with this committee to develop a better alternative than what has been presented. It is our goal to work with the sponsor of SB 1124, to work with this Committee, and improve around the intent of this bill along the lines of other states, as suggested in the draft PLUS language, previously circulated to this committee. If the goal is to protect veterans, then you can legislate around best practices, while preserving their right to use companies like mine. .
National Assocation for Veteran’s Rights write in opposition
While the intention to safeguard veterans is commendable, SB 1124 falls short of its goal. Rather than empowering veterans to choose how they pursue their claims, it restricts their freedom and neglects key issues. The bill fails to provide adequate oversight and protections for Veterans while infringing upon their constitutional rights to peGGon their government as they see fit. AddiGonally, it overlooks the need for diverse opGons and effecGve soluGons for Veterans over the long term.
Veterans Benefits Guide writes in opposition:
In its current form, SB1124 would prohibit California Veterans from hiring honorable for-profit companies like VBG. This would take away Veterans’ choice, make it harder for Veterans to receive accurate disability ratings and benefits in a timely manner and worsen the VA’s claims backlog.
There exists an inaccurate insinuation that organizations such as ours choose not to be accredited. That is false. VBG would welcome the opportunity to become accredited with the VA, but cannot because current Federal law prohibits accredited entities from charging a fee for representation of Veterans on the initial claim. VBG’s personnel, medical service provider network and procedures already meet standards required of VA-accredited agents and would meet any reasonable threshold for accreditation set by the VA.
Sponsor Response to Opposition Arguments:
- A pending lawsuit against the VA alleges institutional racial discrimination in awarding lower compensation to Black veterans dating back to the 1970s. Opponents argue that SB 1124 is forcing vets into a system that perpetuates racial discrimination in the awarding of benefits, perpetuating racial disparities. fVBG in particular argues that their work helps reduce racial disparities, because a large percentage of their clients are awarded benefits increases that they should have been getting.
Neither the opponents’ proposed amendments nor this bill address purported racial discrimination within the VA. VA-accredited actors like the VFW, American Legion, CVSOs, etc. are not employees of or part of the VA itself. Whether a veteran chooses to use an accredited VSO like the VFW, or an unaccredited company like VBG, they are both submitting an initial claim into the same VA system for consideration. SB 1124 simply seeks to ensure that everyone charging fees for assistance in CA is accredited, subject to VA oversight and accountability, and thus observing the same rules of the road.
If allegations that the federal VA has a history of racial disparities prove to be true, that that is not acceptable and federal action should be taken to rectify that, as only federal action can. However, that does not mean that the solution to such a problem is to allow unaccredited for-profit companies to gain a greater foothold in CA and charge people for initial claims work, which is what opponents’ proposed amendments to SB 1124 seek to do. These are different issues; SB 1124 is about oversight and accountability over those charging for helping with initial benefits claims.
- There are claims that this bill takes away a veteran’s right to choose how to pursue their claim. It is said that the current VA system is not working well, and veterans should be free to make an informed decision to pay a private for-profit company to help them file their claim.
The choice to hire an unaccredited company is not the same as the choice to use a VA-accredited entity. To hold them equivalent ignores the fact that federal law restricts providing assistance to veterans to only accredited entities, and prohibits the charging of fees for help with initial benefit claims, which extends even to accredited attorneys and agents. It is also inaccurate to say that veterans have no right to choose under this bill. If a veteran is not happy with the VSO representative he or she initially selected, the veteran can always choose to patronize a different VSO (many options, the Legion, VFW, etc), or use the CVSOs instead, or an accredited claims agent or attorney. All of these options are accredited professionals and they all operate under the VSO rules and system of accountability.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: California Department of Justice
Veterans of Foreign Wars, Department of California
Support
AARP
American Legion, Department of California
AMVETs, Department of California
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California State Association of Counties
California State Commanders Veterans Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Attorneys of California
County of Kern
County of Los Angeles
County of Nevada
Military Officers Association of America, California Council of Chapters
San Diego Military Advisory Council
Ventura County Chapter of the Military Officers Association of America (VCC-MOAA)
VetFund Foundataion
Support If Amended
Veterans Guardian VA Claim Consulting, LLC
Oppose Unless Amended
National Association for Veteran's Rights
Veteran Benefits Guide
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1124 (Author:Menjivar)
Version: February 13, 2024
Hearing Date: April 9, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Deceptive practices: service members and veterans
DIGEST
This bill provides additional protections for veterans in California in connection with fees charged for assistance applying for veterans’ benefits and the privacy of their information. The bill requires persons to be federally accredited before preparing, presenting, or prosecuting a veteran’s claim for benefits under federal law.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Veterans’ benefits are a crucial support system for those who have served this country in the armed forces. As with other government benefits, applicants may need assistance in applying for these critical benefits. To meet this need, federal law establishes a process for organizations, attorneys, and additional claims agents to become accredited to assist veterans in applying for, preparing, presenting, and prosecuting their claims for federal benefits.
Concerns about unaccredited organizations and individuals charging veterans for these services, with sometimes exorbitant rates, has continued to persist despite previous legislation. This bill seeks to ensure that veterans are not charged unreasonable fees and that only federally accredited individuals and organizations are able to carry out this important work.
The bill is co-sponsored by Attorney General Rob Bonta and the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) Department of California. It is supported by a variety of veterans groups. It is opposed by several unaccredited businesses that provide veteran’s benefits services, including Veteran Benefit Guide (VBG). If this bill passes out of Committee, it will next be heard in the Senate Military and Veterans Affairs Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Prohibits any individual from acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under laws administered by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) unless such individual has been recognized for such purposes by the Secretary of the VA (Secretary), except as provided. (38 U.S.C. § 5901.)
- Authorizes the Secretary to recognize representatives of the American National Red Cross, the American Legion, the Disabled American Veterans, the United Spanish War Veterans, the Veterans of Foreign Wars, and such other organizations as the Secretary may approve, in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of benefits claims. No fees may be charged in connection with services rendered hereby. (38 U.S.C. § 5902.)
- Authorizes the Secretary to recognize any individual as an agent or attorney for the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of claims under laws administered by the Secretary and provides that the Secretary shall promulgate regulations laying out the necessary qualifications and standards of conduct. (38 U.S.C. § 5904.) Those attendant regulations lay out the accreditation process, continuing legal education requirements, and parameters on reasonable fees. (38 C.F.R. § 14.626 et seq.)
- Prohibits a fee from being charged, allowed, or paid for services of agents and attorneys with respect to services provided before the date on which a claimant is provided notice of the agency of original jurisdiction’s initial decision. (38 U.S.C. § 5904.)
Existing state law:
- Establishes the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), which prohibits unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer. (Civ. Code § 1750 et seq.)
- Designates specified practices as unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices, including charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services, including veterans benefits, as provided. (Civ. Code § 1770.)
- Provides that any consumer who suffers any damage as a result of the use or employment by any person of a method, act, or practice declared to be unlawful by Section 1770 of the Civil Code may bring an action against that person to recover or obtain any of the following:
- actual damages, but in no case shall the total award of damages in a class action be less than $1,000;
- an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices;
- restitution of property;
- punitive damages;
- court costs and attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff. However, reasonable attorney’s fees may be awarded to a prevailing defendant upon a finding by the court that the plaintiff’s prosecution of the action was not in good faith; and
- any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civ. Code § 1780(a), (e).)
- Establishes the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), which provides a statutory cause of action for any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, including over the internet. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 et seq.)
- Prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from electronically accessing a Common Access Card (CAC) issued to a service member, placing or requiring the placement of such a CAC in a smart card reader, requesting or requesting entry of the personal identification number (PIN) associated with such a CAC, or requiring a service member to log in to any Department of Defense or, in the case of a member of the Coast Guard, Department of Homeland Security computer system. A transaction or sale entered into in violation of this subdivision is void. (Mil. & Vets. Code § 401(d).)
This bill:
- Expands the CLRA prohibition to other veterans benefits and provides that a fee charged with respect to federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged for those services by an attorney or claims agent accredited by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs is unreasonable.
- Prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems; accessing such systems with another person’s credentials; and requiring entry of a veteran’s PIN associated with a CAC.
- Prohibits persons from directly or indirectly soliciting, contracting for, charging, or receiving, or attempting to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the VA except as provided under federal law.
COMMENTS
- Federal law establishes who may prepare, present, or prosecute veterans’ benefits claims
Federal law prohibits anyone from acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under the laws administered by the VA unless such individual has been recognized for such purposes by the VA Secretary, except as provided. The law provides for the recognition of certain organizations for these purposes, such as the VFW, the American Legion, and the American National Red Cross. However, these organizations are restricted from charging fees for these services. The law also authorizes the Secretary to provide for the accreditation of agents and attorneys and directs the Secretary to prescribe in regulations the various requirements and parameters for providing such services.
The VA describes the process on their website:
The VA accreditation program exists to ensure that Veterans and their family members receive appropriate representation on their VA benefits claims. VA accreditation is for the sole and limited purpose of preparing, presenting, and prosecuting claims before VA.
. . .
An individual generally must first be accredited by VA to assist a claimant in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of a claim for VA benefits—even without charge. VA accredits three types of individuals for this purpose: - Representatives of VA-recognized veterans service organizations (VSO) - Attorneys (accredited in their individual capacity, not through a law firm) - Claims agents (accredited in their individual capacity, not through an organization).[1]
Here in California, the California Department of Veterans Affairs (CalVet) has a network of VSOs:
County Veteran Service Offices (CVSO) are the key agencies in providing California’s veterans with assistance and connection to benefits and services in local communities throughout the state. CalVet’s relationship with CVSOs ensures veterans and their families are served and represented by trained and accredited professionals. CVSOs are a critical component in the state’s efforts to work directly with individual veterans and their families to ensure our Veterans receive benefits they earned through their service to our Nation. CVSOs are on the front lines for this important mission and play the key role in ensuring that veterans and their families are aware of their benefits, and in fact apply for and receive them. Together, the CVSOs, through claims initiation and development, and CalVet, through claims development and representation with appeals, provide assistance to veterans and their families in preparing and submitting claims and in representing claimants before the federal, state and local agencies providing veterans benefits.[2]
The CVSOs reported in 2023 that their officers were able to serve over 600,000 veterans and their families and secured $485 million in claims awards.[3]
The federal regulations governing the accreditation program provide: “The purpose of the regulation of representatives, agents, attorneys, and other individuals is to ensure that claimants for Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) benefits have responsible, qualified representation in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of claims for veterans’ benefits.” (38 C.F.R. § 14.626 et seq.) The regulations lay out the application process and detail the necessary qualifications.
To ensure accredited attorneys and claims agents are best suited to assist with claims, the regulations impose a continuing legal education requirement. The regulations also govern the fees available, providing that only accredited agents and attorneys may receive fees from claimants or appellants for their services provided in connection with representation. Recognized organizations are not permitted to receive fees. Agents and attorneys may only charge claimants or appellants for representation provided after an agency of original jurisdiction has issued notice of an initial decision on the claim or claims, except as provided. Fees are required to be reasonable. The regulations establish a rebuttable presumption that any fee that does not exceed 20 percent of past-due benefits awarded is reasonable and that any fee that exceeds 33 1/3 percent of such benefits is unreasonable.
- Concerns with unaccredited organizations
After a softening of the penalties for acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of a claim for veterans benefits without accreditation, the industry for unaccredited claims representatives expanded:
For decades, federal law penalized unaccredited actors who charged veterans for “preparing, presenting, or prosecuting claims before the VA.” While regulations still prohibit such behavior, all criminal penalties were removed from federal statutes in 2006, leaving the VA essentially toothless to go after bad actors. (Accredited representatives, however, remain liable to be investigated and, if appropriate, disbarred when a veteran complains.)[4]
These unaccredited companies and representatives are not subject to the accountability measures laid out in federal law or the oversight of the VA.
A subcommittee of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs held a hearing on the VA Accreditation Program in 2022, emphasizing concerns about this unregulated industry. Congressman Chris Pappas, Chair of the Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee of the House Committee on Veterans,’ Affairs squarely addressed the issue:
For decades, federal law has prohibited anyone from helping a veteran prepare or present a VA benefit claim without accreditation. Despite this black-letter law, there’s been an explosion in the number of unaccredited, for-profit companies who say they’re not preparing or presenting claims . . . However, if you read the fine print, they also charge veterans hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars. . . . there are many other veterans who have complained about exorbitant costs, hidden fees, difficulties canceling a contract, aggressive marketing emails, rampant collection calls, and other predatory practices that many unaccredited companies employ. Some companies even solicit veterans’ eBenefits usernames and passwords, or try to gain direct access to people’s bank accounts…Some veterans may be willing to pay a fee if the services they receive are worthwhile and a company’s business practices are above board. But without adequate oversight through the accreditation process, we cannot be assured that this is case.[5]
- Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA)
The Legislature has long considered consumer protection to be a matter of high importance. State law is replete with statutes aimed at protecting California consumers from unfair, dishonest, or harmful market practices. These consumer-protection laws authorize consumers to enforce their own rights and seek remedies to make them whole.
The CLRA was enacted “to protect the statute’s beneficiaries from deceptive and unfair business practices,” and to provide aggrieved consumers with “strong remedial provisions for violations of the statute.” (Am. Online, Inc. v. Superior Court (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 1, 11.) The CLRA prohibits “unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer,” (Civ. Code § 1770(a)), and prohibits conduct “likely to mislead a reasonable consumer,” (Colgan v. Leatherman Tool Grp., Inc. (2006) 135 Cal. App. 4th 663, 680; internal quotation marks omitted.)
Among other things, the CLRA prohibits merchants from “representing that a transaction confers or involves rights, remedies, or obligations which it does not have or involve, or which are prohibited by law,” or representing that goods “are of a particular standard, quality, or grade” when they are of another. (Civ. Code § 1770.) Consumers who are harmed by specified unlawful practices have a right of action under the CLRA to recover damages and other remedies, including actual damages; an order to enjoin the unlawful act; restitution; punitive damages; or any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civ. Code § 1780.) Additionally, the statute authorizes courts to award attorney’s fees to prevailing plaintiffs and contains mechanisms for securing remedies on a class wide basis. (Civ. Code §§ 1780, 1781.) Consumers who are over the age of 65 are eligible to additionally seek and be awarded, in addition to the above remedies, up to $5,000 where the trier of fact finds certain circumstances are met.
- Protecting veterans by capping fees and requiring accreditation
Relevant here, the CLRA prohibits charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services. “Public social services” is defined to mean those activities and functions of state and local government administered or supervised by specified state departments, and involved in providing aid or services, or both, including health care services, and medical assistance, to those persons who, because of their economic circumstances or social condition, are in need of that aid or those services and may benefit from them. “Unreasonable fee” is defined to mean a fee that is exorbitant and disproportionate to the services performed. The section lays out a number of factors to be considered in determining reasonableness.
In response to prior concerns about unscrupulous companies preying on veterans, SB 180 (Corbett, Ch. 79, Stats. 2011) expanded the definition of public social services to explicitly include “activities and functions administered or supervised by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs or the California Department of Veterans Affairs involved in providing aid or services, or both, to veterans, including pension benefits.”
This bill expands this prohibition by ensuring that “other veterans benefits” are included within that definition, but more importantly, it deems as unreasonable a fee charged in connection with federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged by an accredited agent or attorney.
The bill also codifies in state law the federal prohibition on preparing, presenting, or prosecuting claims for benefits unless accredited pursuant to federal law. Specifically, the law states that, except “as provided in Sections 1984 and 5904 of Title 38 of the United States Code, a person shall not directly or indirectly solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, or attempt to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs.”
It should be noted that federal law does not allow for the charging of fees, even for accredited agents and lawyers, for the preparation of initial claims for benefits.
The bill also bolsters existing protections for veterans by prohibiting a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems and from accessing such systems with another person’s credentials.
According to the author:
Veterans bravely serve and often times sacrifice their wellbeing for our country. Those living with the consequences of their selfless service deserve a smooth process in accessing the benefits they have earned. However, that process can be daunting and leaves veterans vulnerable to bad actors. Therefore, we must ensure we have accredited advocates working on their case to ensure oversight, accountability, and the proper dispersal of funds. That is why I introduced SB 1124, in collaboration with Attorney General Bonta, to tackle this very important but often overlooked issue. SB 1124 specifically prohibits unaccredited caseworkers and lawyers from processing VA disability claims, protects veterans from exorbitant fees, and makes it a crime to obtain unauthorized access to the Veterans Affairs claims system using a veterans’ login information. We must protect the personal information, financial interests, and health of the veterans who have sacrificed to protect us.
- Stakeholder positions
Attorney General Rob Bonta, the sponsor of the bill, writes:
The VA accreditation program exists to ensure that veterans receive competent and fair representation on their VA benefits claims. In addition to CVSO and nonprofit VSOs, which provide assistance free of charge, the VA also accredits attorneys and claims agents to represent veterans and assist with benefit claims. Accredited attorneys and claims agents cannot charge money for assistance with an initial claim for veteran’s benefits, but, subject to limits set and enforced by the VA, they can charge for other services.
In 2006, Congress amended federal law in a way that eliminated prohibitions that made it a crime to assist veterans with benefits claims without being accredited. This had the unintentional effect of driving the creation of a cottage industry of businesses that charge veterans for assistance with benefits claims without being accredited. Some of these businesses are well intentioned, but operate without the protections provided by VA accreditation and oversight, including fee caps. Others, often referred to as “claims sharks”, are predators that provide worthless services or get veterans to agree to exorbitant fee agreements, sometimes including contingent fees that would be patently illegal if charged by an accredited attorney or agent.
Because unaccredited claims representatives are not subject to the VA’s rules and oversight, they pose an unacceptable consumer risk to veterans. To address this problem, SB 1124 would strengthen several state law protections for veterans, including by: (1) prohibiting any person not accredited by the VA from charging a veteran for help with a benefits claim; (2) increasing penalties for persons that obtain unauthorized access to veterans’ data on VA computer systems; and (3) prohibiting the charging of fees that exceed what a VA-accredited attorney or claims agent could legally charge to assist a veteran with a benefits claim.
The VFW Department of California, a cosponsor of the bill, writes:
SB 1124 addresses a critical gap in the current legal framework that has allowed unaccredited claims representatives to exploit veterans seeking assistance with their benefits claims. Unaccredited claims representatives are not required to adhere to the well-established professional and ethical standards of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) accreditation, so their advice can often be misleading or even fraudulent. By strengthening state law to prohibit such practices, this bill ensures that only those accredited by the VA can offer these crucial services.
Some of the predatory practices include promising or guaranteeing an increased disability rating, expedited VA claims decisions, and using confusing tactics or ambiguous language to mislead claimants or coerce them into signing a contract. Veterans face numerous challenges upon returning to civilian life, and navigating the complexities of VA benefits process is difficult enough. SB 1124 not only protects veterans from predatory practices, but also honors their service by ensuring they have access to fair and competent representation.
This legislation is crucial in safeguarding veterans from exploitation and ensuring veterans receive the benefits they have earned through their service. . . . This bill will protect those who bear the visible and invisible scars of war.
Several organizations providing support to veterans in their application for federal benefits outside of the accreditation process are in opposition to the bill. They argue that this bill will eliminate their ability to provide much-needed services to veterans. VBG, one of these organizations, writes in opposition:
In its current form, SB 1124 would prohibit California Veterans from hiring honorable for-profit companies like VBG. This would take away Veterans’ choice, make it harder for Veterans to receive accurate disability ratings and benefits in a timely manner and worsen the VA’s claims backlog.
There exists an inaccurate insinuation that organizations such as ours choose not to be accredited. That is false. VBG would welcome the opportunity to become accredited with the VA, but cannot because current Federal law prohibits accredited entities from charging a fee for representation of Veterans on the initial claim. VBG’s personnel, medical service provider network and procedures already meet standards required of VA-accredited agents and would meet any reasonable threshold for accreditation set by the VA.
It is also claimed that private services like VBG are violating the law. That is also false. Federal law states that “no individual may act as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under laws administered by the Secretary” without first being accredited. I would like to state for the record that:
• We DO NOT practice law
• We DO NOT act as the Veteran’s agent of record
• We DO NOT present before the VA
Veterans Guardian VA Claim Consulting, LLC, another such company, argues that existing services are not enough:
Unfortunately, the VSOs are incapable of meeting the demands of the veterans of this state. According to the VA’s publicly available data on accredited service officers and agents, the entire state of California has only 501 VSO representatives to provide assistance to the over 1,500,000 veterans who currently reside in the state. This equates to each representative being responsible for handling the affairs of 3,063 veterans. Even the hardest working and most efficient volunteer would be pressed to give the best possible service to that many veterans. This further demonstrates how harmful SB 1124 will be by forcing California’s veterans to rely on a system that is already overloaded and ineffective.
SUPPORT
Attorney General Rob Bonta (sponsor)
Veterans of Foreign Wars Department of California (sponsor)
AARP
American Legion, Department of California
AMVETS, Department of California
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California State Commanders Veterans Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Attorneys of California
County of Kern
Military Officers Association of America, California Council of Chapters
OPPOSITION
National Association for Veterans Rights
Veteran Benefits Guide
Veterans Guardian VA Claim Consulting, LLC
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 2736 (Juan Carrillo, 2024) repeals the prohibition on a dependent of a veteran from receiving veterans educational benefits during the time the dependent is entitled to receive specified federal educational benefits or duplicate assistance from any other government source. AB 2736 is currently in the Assembly Military and Veterans Affairs Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 684 (Ta, 2023) would have, upon appropriation by the Legislature, provided a stipend to counties that host an active United States military base for the purposes of maintaining a county veterans service officer, at least part time, at each such base, subject to base approval. This bill died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 180 (Corbett, Ch. 79, Stats. 2011) See Comment 4.
**************
VA Accreditation Program, United States Department of Veterans Affairs, https://www.va.gov/OGC/docs/Accred/HowtoApplyforAccreditation.pdf. All internet citations are current as of March 23, 2024. ↑
County Veterans Service Offices, CalVet, https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/County-Veteran-Service-Organization.aspx. ↑
2023 Annual Report, California Association of County Veterans Service Officers, https://www.cacvso.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Veterans-Annual-Report-2023.pdf. ↑
Jasper Craven, As veteran disability claims soar, unaccredited coaches profit off frustration with VA system (July 5, 2023) Texas Tribune, https://www.texastribune.org/2023/07/05/veterans-disability-benefits-brian-reese-va-claims-insider/. ↑
Press Release, Pappas Chairs Joint Hearing on Predatory Claim Sharks Targeting Veterans’ Benefits, Questions VA Efforts to Protect Veterans (April 28, 2022) website of Congressman Chris Pappas, https://pappas.house.gov/media/press-releases/pappas-chairs-joint-hearing-predatory-claim-sharks-targeting-veterans-benefits. ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1124 (Author:Menjivar)
Version: February 13, 2024
Hearing Date: April 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Deceptive practices: service members and veterans
DIGEST
This bill provides additional protections for veterans in California in connection with fees charged for assistance applying for veterans’ benefits and the privacy of their information. The bill requires persons to be federally accredited before preparing, presenting, or prosecuting a veteran’s claim for benefits under federal law.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Veterans’ benefits are a crucial support system for those who have served this country in the armed forces. As with other government benefits, applicants may need assistance in applying for these critical benefits. To meet this need, federal law establishes a process for organizations, attorneys, and additional claims agents to become accredited to assist veterans in applying for, preparing, presenting, and prosecuting their claims for federal benefits.
Concerns about unaccredited organizations and individuals charging veterans for these services, with sometimes exorbitant rates, has continued to persist despite previous legislation. This bill seeks to ensure that veterans are not charged unreasonable fees and that only federally accredited individuals and organizations are able to carry out this important work.
The bill is co-sponsored by Attorney General Rob Bonta and the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) Department of California. It is supported by a variety of veterans groups. It is opposed by several unaccredited businesses that provide veteran’s benefits services, including Veteran Benefit Guide (VBG). If this bill passes out of Committee, it will next be heard in the Senate Military and Veterans Affairs Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Prohibits any individual from acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under laws administered by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) unless such individual has been recognized for such purposes by the Secretary of the VA (Secretary), except as provided. (38 U.S.C. § 5901.)
- Authorizes the Secretary to recognize representatives of the American National Red Cross, the American Legion, the Disabled American Veterans, the United Spanish War Veterans, the Veterans of Foreign Wars, and such other organizations as the Secretary may approve, in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of benefits claims. No fees may be charged in connection with services rendered hereby. (38 U.S.C. § 5902.)
- Authorizes the Secretary to recognize any individual as an agent or attorney for the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of claims under laws administered by the Secretary and provides that the Secretary shall promulgate regulations laying out the necessary qualifications and standards of conduct. (38 U.S.C. § 5904.) Those attendant regulations lay out the accreditation process, continuing legal education requirements, and parameters on reasonable fees. (38 C.F.R. § 14.626 et seq.)
- Prohibits a fee from being charged, allowed, or paid for services of agents and attorneys with respect to services provided before the date on which a claimant is provided notice of the agency of original jurisdiction’s initial decision. (38 U.S.C. § 5904.)
Existing state law:
- Establishes the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), which prohibits unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer. (Civ. Code § 1750 et seq.)
- Designates specified practices as unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices, including charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services, including veterans benefits, as provided. (Civ. Code § 1770.)
- Provides that any consumer who suffers any damage as a result of the use or employment by any person of a method, act, or practice declared to be unlawful by Section 1770 of the Civil Code may bring an action against that person to recover or obtain any of the following:
- actual damages, but in no case shall the total award of damages in a class action be less than $1,000;
- an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices;
- restitution of property;
- punitive damages;
- court costs and attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff. However, reasonable attorney’s fees may be awarded to a prevailing defendant upon a finding by the court that the plaintiff’s prosecution of the action was not in good faith; and
- any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civ. Code § 1780(a), (e).)
- Establishes the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), which provides a statutory cause of action for any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising, including over the internet. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 et seq.)
- Prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from electronically accessing a Common Access Card (CAC) issued to a service member, placing or requiring the placement of such a CAC in a smart card reader, requesting or requesting entry of the personal identification number (PIN) associated with such a CAC, or requiring a service member to log in to any Department of Defense or, in the case of a member of the Coast Guard, Department of Homeland Security computer system. A transaction or sale entered into in violation of this subdivision is void. (Mil. & Vets. Code § 401(d).)
This bill:
- Expands the CLRA prohibition to other veterans benefits and provides that a fee charged with respect to federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged for those services by an attorney or claims agent accredited by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs is unreasonable.
- Prohibits a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems; accessing such systems with another person’s credentials; and requiring entry of a veteran’s PIN associated with a CAC.
- Prohibits persons from directly or indirectly soliciting, contracting for, charging, or receiving, or attempting to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the VA except as provided under federal law.
COMMENTS
- Federal law establishes who may prepare, present, or prosecute veterans’ benefits claims
Federal law prohibits anyone from acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under the laws administered by the VA unless such individual has been recognized for such purposes by the VA Secretary, except as provided. The law provides for the recognition of certain organizations for these purposes, such as the VFW, the American Legion, and the American National Red Cross. However, these organizations are restricted from charging fees for these services. The law also authorizes the Secretary to provide for the accreditation of agents and attorneys and directs the Secretary to prescribe in regulations the various requirements and parameters for providing such services.
The VA describes the process on their website:
The VA accreditation program exists to ensure that Veterans and their family members receive appropriate representation on their VA benefits claims. VA accreditation is for the sole and limited purpose of preparing, presenting, and prosecuting claims before VA.
. . .
An individual generally must first be accredited by VA to assist a claimant in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of a claim for VA benefits—even without charge. VA accredits three types of individuals for this purpose: - Representatives of VA-recognized veterans service organizations (VSO) - Attorneys (accredited in their individual capacity, not through a law firm) - Claims agents (accredited in their individual capacity, not through an organization).[1]
Here in California, the California Department of Veterans Affairs (CalVet) has a network of VSOs:
County Veteran Service Offices (CVSO) are the key agencies in providing California’s veterans with assistance and connection to benefits and services in local communities throughout the state. CalVet’s relationship with CVSOs ensures veterans and their families are served and represented by trained and accredited professionals. CVSOs are a critical component in the state’s efforts to work directly with individual veterans and their families to ensure our Veterans receive benefits they earned through their service to our Nation. CVSOs are on the front lines for this important mission and play the key role in ensuring that veterans and their families are aware of their benefits, and in fact apply for and receive them. Together, the CVSOs, through claims initiation and development, and CalVet, through claims development and representation with appeals, provide assistance to veterans and their families in preparing and submitting claims and in representing claimants before the federal, state and local agencies providing veterans benefits.[2]
The CVSOs reported in 2023 that their officers were able to serve over 600,000 veterans and their families and secured $485 million in claims awards.[3]
The federal regulations governing the accreditation program provide: “The purpose of the regulation of representatives, agents, attorneys, and other individuals is to ensure that claimants for Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) benefits have responsible, qualified representation in the preparation, presentation, and prosecution of claims for veterans’ benefits.” (38 C.F.R. § 14.626 et seq.) The regulations lay out the application process and detail the necessary qualifications.
To ensure accredited attorneys and claims agents are best suited to assist with claims, the regulations impose a continuing legal education requirement. The regulations also govern the fees available, providing that only accredited agents and attorneys may receive fees from claimants or appellants for their services provided in connection with representation. Recognized organizations are not permitted to receive fees. Agents and attorneys may only charge claimants or appellants for representation provided after an agency of original jurisdiction has issued notice of an initial decision on the claim or claims, except as provided. Fees are required to be reasonable. The regulations establish a rebuttable presumption that any fee that does not exceed 20 percent of past-due benefits awarded is reasonable and that any fee that exceeds 33 1/3 percent of such benefits is unreasonable.
- Concerns with unaccredited organizations
After a softening of the penalties for acting as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of a claim for veterans benefits without accreditation, the industry for unaccredited claims representatives expanded:
For decades, federal law penalized unaccredited actors who charged veterans for “preparing, presenting, or prosecuting claims before the VA.” While regulations still prohibit such behavior, all criminal penalties were removed from federal statutes in 2006, leaving the VA essentially toothless to go after bad actors. (Accredited representatives, however, remain liable to be investigated and, if appropriate, disbarred when a veteran complains.)[4]
These unaccredited companies and representatives are not subject to the accountability measures laid out in federal law or the oversight of the VA.
A subcommittee of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs held a hearing on the VA Accreditation Program in 2022, emphasizing concerns about this unregulated industry. Congressman Chris Pappas, Chair of the Oversight and Investigations Subcommittee of the House Committee on Veterans,’ Affairs squarely addressed the issue:
For decades, federal law has prohibited anyone from helping a veteran prepare or present a VA benefit claim without accreditation. Despite this black-letter law, there’s been an explosion in the number of unaccredited, for-profit companies who say they’re not preparing or presenting claims . . . However, if you read the fine print, they also charge veterans hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars. . . . there are many other veterans who have complained about exorbitant costs, hidden fees, difficulties canceling a contract, aggressive marketing emails, rampant collection calls, and other predatory practices that many unaccredited companies employ. Some companies even solicit veterans’ eBenefits usernames and passwords, or try to gain direct access to people’s bank accounts…Some veterans may be willing to pay a fee if the services they receive are worthwhile and a company’s business practices are above board. But without adequate oversight through the accreditation process, we cannot be assured that this is case.[5]
- Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA)
The Legislature has long considered consumer protection to be a matter of high importance. State law is replete with statutes aimed at protecting California consumers from unfair, dishonest, or harmful market practices. These consumer-protection laws authorize consumers to enforce their own rights and seek remedies to make them whole.
The CLRA was enacted “to protect the statute’s beneficiaries from deceptive and unfair business practices,” and to provide aggrieved consumers with “strong remedial provisions for violations of the statute.” (Am. Online, Inc. v. Superior Court (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 1, 11.) The CLRA prohibits “unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer,” (Civ. Code § 1770(a)), and prohibits conduct “likely to mislead a reasonable consumer,” (Colgan v. Leatherman Tool Grp., Inc. (2006) 135 Cal. App. 4th 663, 680; internal quotation marks omitted.)
Among other things, the CLRA prohibits merchants from “representing that a transaction confers or involves rights, remedies, or obligations which it does not have or involve, or which are prohibited by law,” or representing that goods “are of a particular standard, quality, or grade” when they are of another. (Civ. Code § 1770.) Consumers who are harmed by specified unlawful practices have a right of action under the CLRA to recover damages and other remedies, including actual damages; an order to enjoin the unlawful act; restitution; punitive damages; or any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civ. Code § 1780.) Additionally, the statute authorizes courts to award attorney’s fees to prevailing plaintiffs and contains mechanisms for securing remedies on a class wide basis. (Civ. Code §§ 1780, 1781.) Consumers who are over the age of 65 are eligible to additionally seek and be awarded, in addition to the above remedies, up to $5,000 where the trier of fact finds certain circumstances are met.
- Protecting veterans by capping fees and requiring accreditation
Relevant here, the CLRA prohibits charging or receiving an unreasonable fee to prepare, aid, or advise any prospective applicant, applicant, or recipient in the procurement, maintenance, or securing of public social services. “Public social services” is defined to mean those activities and functions of state and local government administered or supervised by specified state departments, and involved in providing aid or services, or both, including health care services, and medical assistance, to those persons who, because of their economic circumstances or social condition, are in need of that aid or those services and may benefit from them. “Unreasonable fee” is defined to mean a fee that is exorbitant and disproportionate to the services performed. The section lays out a number of factors to be considered in determining reasonableness.
In response to prior concerns about unscrupulous companies preying on veterans, SB 180 (Corbett, Ch. 79, Stats. 2011) expanded the definition of public social services to explicitly include “activities and functions administered or supervised by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs or the California Department of Veterans Affairs involved in providing aid or services, or both, to veterans, including pension benefits.”
This bill expands this prohibition by ensuring that “other veterans benefits” are included within that definition, but more importantly, it deems as unreasonable a fee charged in connection with federal veterans benefits that exceeds the amount that could be charged by an accredited agent or attorney.
The bill also codifies in state law the federal prohibition on preparing, presenting, or prosecuting claims for benefits unless accredited pursuant to federal law. Specifically, the law states that, except “as provided in Sections 1984 and 5904 of Title 38 of the United States Code, a person shall not directly or indirectly solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, or attempt to solicit, contract for, charge, or receive, any fee or compensation with respect to the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim for benefits under the laws administered by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs.”
It should be noted that federal law does not allow for the charging of fees, even for accredited agents and lawyers, for the preparation of initial claims for benefits.
The bill also bolsters existing protections for veterans by prohibiting a person, in connection with any transaction or any sale of goods or services, from requiring a service member to share their credentials for accessing specified government computer systems and from accessing such systems with another person’s credentials.
According to the author:
Veterans bravely serve and often times sacrifice their wellbeing for our country. Those living with the consequences of their selfless service deserve a smooth process in accessing the benefits they have earned. However, that process can be daunting and leaves veterans vulnerable to bad actors. Therefore, we must ensure we have accredited advocates working on their case to ensure oversight, accountability, and the proper dispersal of funds. That is why I introduced SB 1124, in collaboration with Attorney General Bonta, to tackle this very important but often overlooked issue. SB 1124 specifically prohibits unaccredited caseworkers and lawyers from processing VA disability claims, protects veterans from exorbitant fees, and makes it a crime to obtain unauthorized access to the Veterans Affairs claims system using a veterans’ login information. We must protect the personal information, financial interests, and health of the veterans who have sacrificed to protect us.
- Stakeholder positions
Attorney General Rob Bonta, the sponsor of the bill, writes:
The VA accreditation program exists to ensure that veterans receive competent and fair representation on their VA benefits claims. In addition to CVSO and nonprofit VSOs, which provide assistance free of charge, the VA also accredits attorneys and claims agents to represent veterans and assist with benefit claims. Accredited attorneys and claims agents cannot charge money for assistance with an initial claim for veteran’s benefits, but, subject to limits set and enforced by the VA, they can charge for other services.
In 2006, Congress amended federal law in a way that eliminated prohibitions that made it a crime to assist veterans with benefits claims without being accredited. This had the unintentional effect of driving the creation of a cottage industry of businesses that charge veterans for assistance with benefits claims without being accredited. Some of these businesses are well intentioned, but operate without the protections provided by VA accreditation and oversight, including fee caps. Others, often referred to as “claims sharks”, are predators that provide worthless services or get veterans to agree to exorbitant fee agreements, sometimes including contingent fees that would be patently illegal if charged by an accredited attorney or agent.
Because unaccredited claims representatives are not subject to the VA’s rules and oversight, they pose an unacceptable consumer risk to veterans. To address this problem, SB 1124 would strengthen several state law protections for veterans, including by: (1) prohibiting any person not accredited by the VA from charging a veteran for help with a benefits claim; (2) increasing penalties for persons that obtain unauthorized access to veterans’ data on VA computer systems; and (3) prohibiting the charging of fees that exceed what a VA-accredited attorney or claims agent could legally charge to assist a veteran with a benefits claim.
The VFW Department of California, a cosponsor of the bill, writes:
SB 1124 addresses a critical gap in the current legal framework that has allowed unaccredited claims representatives to exploit veterans seeking assistance with their benefits claims. Unaccredited claims representatives are not required to adhere to the well-established professional and ethical standards of the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) accreditation, so their advice can often be misleading or even fraudulent. By strengthening state law to prohibit such practices, this bill ensures that only those accredited by the VA can offer these crucial services.
Some of the predatory practices include promising or guaranteeing an increased disability rating, expedited VA claims decisions, and using confusing tactics or ambiguous language to mislead claimants or coerce them into signing a contract. Veterans face numerous challenges upon returning to civilian life, and navigating the complexities of VA benefits process is difficult enough. SB 1124 not only protects veterans from predatory practices, but also honors their service by ensuring they have access to fair and competent representation.
This legislation is crucial in safeguarding veterans from exploitation and ensuring veterans receive the benefits they have earned through their service. . . . This bill will protect those who bear the visible and invisible scars of war.
Several organizations providing support to veterans in their application for federal benefits outside of the accreditation process are in opposition to the bill. They argue that this bill will eliminate their ability to provide much-needed services to veterans. VBG, one of these organizations, writes in opposition:
In its current form, SB1124 would prohibit California Veterans from hiring honorable for-profit companies like VBG. This would take away Veterans’ choice, make it harder for Veterans to receive accurate disability ratings and benefits in a timely manner and worsen the VA’s claims backlog.
There exists an inaccurate insinuation that organizations such as ours choose not to be accredited. That is false. VBG would welcome the opportunity to become accredited with the VA, but cannot because current Federal law prohibits accredited entities from charging a fee for representation of Veterans on the initial claim. VBG’s personnel, medical service provider network and procedures already meet standards required of VA-accredited agents and would meet any reasonable threshold for accreditation set by the VA.
It is also claimed that private services like VBG are violating the law. That is also false. Federal law states that “no individual may act as an agent or attorney in the preparation, presentation, or prosecution of any claim under laws administered by the Secretary” without first being accredited. I would like to state for the record that:
• We DO NOT practice law
• We DO NOT act as the Veteran’s agent of record
• We DO NOT present before the VA
Veterans Guardian VA Claim Consulting, LLC, another such company, argues that existing services are not enough:
Unfortunately, the VSOs are incapable of meeting the demands of the veterans of this state. According to the VA’s publicly available data on accredited service officers and agents, the entire state of California has only 501 VSO representatives to provide assistance to the over 1,500,000 veterans who currently reside in the state. This equates to each representative being responsible for handling the affairs of 3,063 veterans. Even the hardest working and most efficient volunteer would be pressed to give the best possible service to that many veterans. This further demonstrates how harmful SB 1124 will be by forcing California’s veterans to rely on a system that is already overloaded and ineffective.
SUPPORT
Attorney General Rob Bonta (sponsor)
Veterans of Foreign Wars Department of California (sponsor)
AARP
American Legion, Department of California
AMVETS, Department of California
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California State Commanders Veterans Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Military Officers Association of America, California Council of Chapters
OPPOSITION
National Association for Veterans Rights
Veteran Benefits Guide
Veterans Guardian VA Claim Consulting, LLC
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 2736 (Juan Carrillo, 2024) repeals the prohibition on a dependent of a veteran from receiving veterans educational benefits during the time the dependent is entitled to receive specified federal educational benefits or duplicate assistance from any other government source. AB 2736 is currently in the Assembly Military and Veterans Affairs Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 684 (Ta, 2023) would have, upon appropriation by the Legislature, provided a stipend to counties that host an active United States military base for the purposes of maintaining a county veterans service officer, at least part time, at each such base, subject to base approval. This bill died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 180 (Corbett, Ch. 79, Stats. 2011) See Comment 4.
**************
VA Accreditation Program, United States Department of Veterans Affairs, https://www.va.gov/OGC/docs/Accred/HowtoApplyforAccreditation.pdf. All internet citations are current as of March 23, 2024. ↑
County Veterans Service Offices, CalVet, https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/County-Veteran-Service-Organization.aspx. ↑
2023 Annual Report, California Association of County Veterans Service Officers, https://www.cacvso.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/Veterans-Annual-Report-2023.pdf. ↑
Jasper Craven, As veteran disability claims soar, unaccredited coaches profit off frustration with VA system (July 5, 2023) Texas Tribune, https://www.texastribune.org/2023/07/05/veterans-disability-benefits-brian-reese-va-claims-insider/. ↑
Press Release, Pappas Chairs Joint Hearing on Predatory Claim Sharks Targeting Veterans’ Benefits, Questions VA Efforts to Protect Veterans (April 28, 2022) website of Congressman Chris Pappas, https://pappas.house.gov/media/press-releases/pappas-chairs-joint-hearing-predatory-claim-sharks-targeting-veterans-benefits. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Military and Veterans Affairs
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):