SB 1159: California Environmental Quality Act: roadside wildfire risk reduction projects.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-24
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
CEQA requires the Office of Planning and Research to prepare and develop, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. CEQA requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions.
This bill, on or before January 1, 2026, would require the office to evaluate, and the secretary to consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than 5 road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects subject to a categorical exemption. The bill would require the office to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects, as specified.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
CEQA requires the Office of Planning and Research to prepare and develop, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. CEQA requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions.
This bill, on or before January 1, 2026, would require the office to evaluate, and the secretary to consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than 5 road miles from a municipality or census designated census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects subject to a categorical exemption. The bill would require the office to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects, as specified.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
CEQA requires the Office of Planning and Research to prepare and develop, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. CEQA requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions.
This bill would require the secretary to consider including roadside projects undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects subject to a categorical exemption if specified requirements are met.This bill, on or before January 1, 2026, would require the office to evaluate, and the secretary to consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than 5 road miles from a municipality or census designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects subject to a categorical exemption. The bill would require the office to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects, as specified.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
CEQA requires the Office of Planning and Research to prepare and develop, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. CEQA requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions.
This bill would require the secretary to consider including roadside projects undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects subject to a categorical exemption if specified requirements are met.
(a)(1)On or before January 1, 2026, the Office of Planning and Research, in consultation with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, the State Water Resources Control Board, and other relevant state agencies, shall evaluate, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21084.
(2)The Office of Planning and Research, in consultation with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, the State Water Resources Control Board, and other relevant state agencies, shall consider appropriate eligibility criteria for a roadside project subject to paragraph (1), including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, public or private road or driveway, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees and sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, potential impacts to wildlife, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan pursuant to the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code), habitat conservation plan pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), or other adopted natural resource protection plan.
(b)(1)An exemption for projects pursuant to the class that may be adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
(2)A project that is exempt from the this division pursuant to the class that may be adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall comply with all requirements otherwise imposed by law, including, but not limited to, the California Endangered Species Act (Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code), the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), the Native Plant Protection Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1900) of Division 2 of the Fish and Game Code), and any other applicable state and federal laws.
(a)(1)On or before January 1, 2026, the Office of Planning and Research Research, in consultation with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, the State Water Resources Control Board, and other relevant state agencies, shall evaluate, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21084.
(2)The Office of Planning and Research Research, in consultation with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, the State Water Resources Control Board, and other relevant state agencies, shall consider appropriate eligibility criteria for a roadside project subject to paragraph (1), including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees, and trees and sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, potential impacts to wildlife. wildlife, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan pursuant to the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code), habitat conservation plan pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), or other adopted natural resource protection plan.
(b)(1)An exemption for projects described in this section pursuant to the class that may be adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
(2)A project that is exempt from the division pursuant to the class that may be adopted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall comply with all requirements otherwise imposed by law, including, but not limited to, the California Endangered Species Act (Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code), the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), the Native Plant Protection Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1900) of Division 2 of the Fish and Game Code), and any other applicable state and federal laws.
(a)(1)On or before January 1, 2026, the Office of Planning and Research shall evaluate, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21084.
(2)The Office of Planning and Research shall consider appropriate eligibility criteria for a roadside project subject to paragraph (1), including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees, and potential impacts to wildlife.
(b)An exemption for projects described in this section shall not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
SECTION 1.Section 21084.4 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:21084.4.The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall consider including roadside projects undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21084 if all of the following requirements are met:(a)The project does not result in the removal of healthy trees with a diameter at breast height that is greater than 12 inches.(b)The project does not result in soil disturbance that could lead to sedimentation of surface waters.(c)The project is within 30 feet of the edge of an improved surface road.(d)The project is no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place.The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall consider including roadside projects undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 21084 if all of the following requirements are met:
(a)The project does not result in the removal of healthy trees with a diameter at breast height that is greater than 12 inches.
(b)The project does not result in soil disturbance that could lead to sedimentation of surface waters.
(c)The project is within 30 feet of the edge of an improved surface road.
(d)The project is no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | July 2 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 17). |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| May 24, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 4180.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2024 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3973.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2024 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0. Page 3728.) (April 23). |
| Apr 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on N.R. & W. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3467.) (April 3). Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Mar 20, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Mar 8, 2024 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Feb 21, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E.Q. and N.R. & W. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 17, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2024 | Special Consent SB1159 Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources and Water] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Associated General Contractors | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Farm Bureau Federation | ** Support | |
| California Fire Chiefs Association | ** Support | |
| California State Council Of Laborers | ** Support | |
| Contra Costa County | ** Support | |
| Contra Costa County Fire Chiefs | ** Support | |
| County of Sonoma | ** Support | |
| County of Yolo | ** Support | |
| Humboldt Redwood Company LLC | ** Support | |
| Mendocino Redwood Company LLC | ** Support | |
| Mountain Counties Water Resources Association | ** Support | |
| Napa County | ** Support | |
| New Livable California Dba Livable California | ** Against | |
| Pacific Forest Trust | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | |
| San Diego Gas and Electric Company | ** Support | |
| Solano County Board of Supervisors | ** Support | |
| Wine Institute | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1159
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:June 24, 2024
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Office of Planning and Research (OPR), by January 1, 2026, to evaluate, and the secretary of the Natural Resources Agency (NRA) to consider, creating a categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place if the project is solely for wildfire risk reduction.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires OPR to consult with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, State Water Resources Control Board and “other relevant state agencies.”
- Requires OPR, in consultation with the same agencies, to consider criteria for a roadside project to be eligible for the categorical exemption.
- Provides that a project eligible for a categorical exemption under this bill is not relieved from compliance with all other applicable state and federal laws such as endangered species statutes.
FISCAL EFFECT:
OPR reports estimated General Fund costs of $450,000 for two full-time positions for three years – one Attorney III to adopt, or at least to evaluate adopting, an additional CEQA exemption within the guidelines and go through the regulatory process, and one senior level Environmental Planner to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for the specified projects.
NRA reports $1 million for staff ongoing and $1 million one-time, both General Fund, for coordination, workshops, consulting and assessment to implement this bill.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Many fires are caused by sparks and burning debris from cars that ignite dry brush near our roads. We must make it easier for firefighters to clear this vulnerable land and remove these flammable materials. It will help keep the public safe and defend our exposed forests. This legislation aims to streamline the process for roadside vegetation management projects, crucial for wildfire risk reduction. By considering these projects for categorical exemption from CEQA, we seek to expedite essential preventative measures while minimizing bureaucratic hurdles.
- Background. CEQA requires a lead agency to evaluate environmental impacts of a proposed project and issue a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report, unless a project is exempt from CEQA. OPR is required to issue CEQA guidelines for public agencies to follow in evaluating projects. CEQA review is not required for a specific project if a statutory exemption applies or if the project falls within a categorical exemption. OPR develops categorical exemptions as part of the CEQA guidelines process, and they become part of the CEQA guidelines when certified and adopted by the NRA secretary.
A CEQA exemption can greatly reduce the timeline for project deployment. This bill seeks to expedite projects only if they are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk mitigation, in recognition of the urgent need for government action to prevent wildfires that have plagued California in recent years. However, unlike a statutory exemption, this bill does not guarantee that outcome. It merely requires OPR and NRA to evaluate and consider whether to adopt a categorical exemption for these roadside wildfire risk mitigation projects.
- Prior Legislation.
AB 211 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 574, Statutes of 2022, extended the sunset from January 1, 2023, to January 1, 2028, for the CEQA exemption for prescribed fire, thinning, or fuel reduction projects undertaken on federal lands that have been reviewed under the National Environmental Policy Act, as specified, and expanded this exemption for reforestation and habitat restoration projects undertaken on federal lands that have been reviewed under the National Environmental Policy Act, as specified.
Analysis Prepared by: Jacqueline Kinney / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1159
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:April 24, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: roadside wildfire risk reduction projects.
SUMMARY: Requires the Office of Planning and Research (OPR), in consultation with other relevant state agencies, to evaluate, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency (NRA) to consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines.
EXISTING LAW:
Pursuant to CEQA (Public Resources Code (PRC) 21000-21189.70.10):
- Requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report (EIR) on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect.
- Requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
- Defines “project” as an activity that may cause either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and that is any of the following:
- An activity directly undertaken by any public agency;
- An activity undertaken by a person that is supported, in whole or in part, through contracts, grants, subsidies, loans, or other forms of assistance from one or more public agencies; and,
- An activity that involves the issuance to a person of a lease, permit, license, certificate, or other entitlement for use by one or more public agencies.
- Requires OPR to prepare and develop proposed guidelines for the implementation of CEQA by public agencies. Requires the guidelines to include objectives and criteria for the orderly evaluation of projects and the preparation of EIRs and negative declarations in a manner consistent with CEQA statutes.
- Requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and that shall be exempt from CEQA.
THIS BILL:
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2026, OPR, in consultation with the California Department of Fish & Wildlife (CDFW), the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE), the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board), and other relevant state agencies, to evaluate, and the Secretary of NRA to consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects determined not to have a significant effect on the environment.
- Requires OPR, in consultation with CDFW, CAL FIRE, the State Water Board, and other relevant state agencies, to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for a roadside project, including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees and sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, potential impacts to wildlife, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan pursuant to the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act, habitat conservation plan, or other adopted natural resource protection plan.
- Provides that an exemption for projects pursuant to the class that may be adopted shall not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
- Requires a project that is exempt from the division pursuant to the class that may be adopted to comply with all requirements otherwise imposed by law, including, but not limited to, the California Endangered Species Act, the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973, the Native Plant Protection Act, and any other applicable state and federal laws.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- OPR estimates ongoing costs of about $450,000 annually (General Fund) for two positions to evaluate adopting an additional CEQA exemption within the Guidelines and to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects, as specified.
- NRA estimates ongoing costs of an unknown amount, likely $1 million or more (General Fund), to implement the provisions of this bill.
- To the extent this bill increases the number or ease of completing roadside projects, unknown ongoing cost pressure (various funds) to provide funds for CAL FIRE to implement the additional projects.
- To the extent the bill encourages activities that reduce the occurrence or severity of catastrophic wildfires from what otherwise would have occurred, this bill would result in potentially significant savings due to avoided fire suppression costs (General Fund). CAL FIRE spends roughly $1 billion annually (General Fund) on “emergency fire suppression”
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
Many fires are caused by sparks and burning debris from cars that ignite dry brush near our roads. We must make it easier for firefighters to clear this vulnerable land and remove these flammable materials. It will help keep the public safe and defend our exposed forests. This legislation aims to streamline the process for roadside vegetation management projects, crucial for wildfire risk reduction. By considering these projects for categorical exemption from CEQA, we seek to expedite essential preventative measures while minimizing bureaucratic hurdles.
- Wildfire prevention. In recent years, California has experienced a growing number of highly destructive wildfires. Of the 20 most destructive wildfires in California’s recorded history, 13 have occurred since 2017. Together, these 13 fires caused tremendous damage, destroying nearly 40,000 structures, taking 148 lives, and charring millions of acres. California’s Fourth Climate Change Assessment projects that by 2100, if climate change continues on this trajectory, the frequency of extreme wildfires will increase, and the average area burned statewide are expected to increase by 77%.
To address the threats posed by climate change, it is estimated that as many as 15 million acres of California forests need some form of treatment to maintain or restore forest health and prevent risk of wildfires. The state and United States Forest Service (USFS) have a collective goal to treat one million acres of land annually to reduce fire risk by 2025. CAL FIRE completed about 105,000 acres of fuel treatment, including 36,000 acres of prescribed burns during the 2023 fiscal year, according to state data. The USFS conducted about 312,000 acres of combined treatment and burns.
Implementing vegetation management along roadsides, in addition to prescribed burns, strategic fuel breaks, and home hardening, is essential for reducing the spread of wildfires and protecting both built and natural environments. Many fires are caused by sparks and burning debris from cars that ignite dry brushes near roads, and these roadside ignitions pose a significant threat to communities and are made worse by the presence of dry vegetation capable of carrying fast moving fires. Despite the broad consensus around the disproportionate importance of roadside vegetation management, some stakeholders feel the existing mechanisms for environmental compliance are less than clear.
- CEQA Guidelines. The CEQA statutes require OPR to develop CEQA Guidelines for implementation by public agencies, which include criteria for public agencies to follow in determining whether or not a proposed project may have a “significant effect on the environment.” The Guidelines (Title 14, Division 6, Chapter 3 of the California Code of Regulations (CCR)) reflect the requirements set forth in the PRC, as well as court decisions interpreting the statute and practical planning considerations. Among other things, the CEQA Guidelines explain how to determine whether an activity is subject to environmental review, what steps are involved in the environmental review process, and the required content of environmental documents. The CEQA Guidelines apply to public agencies throughout the state, including local governments, special districts, and state agencies. Further, PRC 21083 requires OPR and NRA to periodically update the CEQA Guidelines.
Existing CEQA Guideline categorical exemptions for vegetation management include the Class 1 exemption that covers the repair, maintenance, or minor alteration of existing public or private facilities, or topographical features, such as maintenance of existing landscaping, and involving negligible or no expansion of existing or former use. (CCR 15301) This exemption has been used by local agencies to perform strategic fuels reduction work to remove dead, dying, or hazardous trees along roads and around structures to provide defensible space and a wildfire calming zone, and clear vegetation that encroaches into the roadway prism.
The Class 4 exemption is for minor public or private alterations which do not involve removal of healthy, mature, scenic trees except for forestry or agricultural purposes. This includes, but is not limited to, fuel management activities within 30 feet of structures to reduce the volume of flammable vegetation, provided that the activities will not result in the taking of endangered, rare, or threatened plant or animal species or significant erosion and sedimentation of surface waters. (CCR 15304) This exemption has been used by state and local agencies to reduce roadside fuels along well-used public roads, improve fuel break function, and vegetation removal on private roads.
In addition, the California Vegetation Treatment Program (CalVTP) was developed and approved by the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) in 2019 and includes the use of prescribed burning, mechanical treatments, manual treatments, herbicides, and prescribed herbivory as tools to reduce hazardous vegetation around communities in the wildland-urban interface, to construct fuel breaks, and to restore healthy ecological fire regimes. The Board certified a VTP-related Final Program Environmental Impact Report (FPEIR) prepared pursuant to CEQA that can be used by more than 200 agencies with land ownership or land management responsibilities in the treatable landscape. The FPEIR is a tool to expedite the implementation of vegetation treatments and is intended to provide broad CEQA coverage for individual projects consistent with the analysis and mitigation strategies set forth in the
The sponsor of this bill expressed concern that the existing categorical exemptions are too vague, and there is a lack of specificity around vegetation management for wildfire risk reduction along roadsides under the existing CEQA exemptions.
- This bill. SB 1159 requires OPR to evaluate, and the secretary of NRA to consider, the inclusion of roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction in the classes of projects subject to a categorical exemption.
- Committee amendments. The term “improved road or surface” is imprecise in that it makes no distinction between public or private roadways. The Committee may wish to consider a technical amendment to clarify what roads would be covered under the bill, as follows:
(2) … including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved public or private road or driveway or surface, …
- Related legislation:
AB 2639 (Patterson) expands the definition of “timber operations” to include the maintenance of timberlands for fuels reduction, and provides that timber operations for the maintenance of timberland, paid in part or in whole with public funds, may comply with the requirements of CEQA in lieu of preparing a timber harvesting plan. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1951 (Fong) provides that CEQA does not apply to a project for wildfire prevention, including, but not limited to, the removal of trees and brush, within 50 feet of either side of a roadway. This bill was pulled by the author from the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 1554 (J. Patterson, 2023) expressly exempts from CEQA a project for the reduction of fuels in areas within moderate, high, and very high fire hazard severity zones, as provided. The bill was presented by the author for presentation-only in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Associated General Contractors of California
Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA)
CalChamber
California Building Industry Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California State Association of Counties
California State Council of Laborers
Contra Costa County
County of Napa
County of Solano
County of Sonoma
Mountain Counties Water Resources Association
San Bernardino County
San Diego Gas and Electric Company
Tri County Chamber Alliance
Wine Institute
Opposition
Livable California
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / NAT. RES. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1159 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1159
Author: Dodd (D)
Amended: 4/24/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/3/24
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/23/24
AYES: Min, Seyarto, Allen, Dahle, Eggman, Grove, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, Menjivar, Padilla
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: roadside wildfire risk reduction projects
SOURCE: California Fire Chiefs Association
DIGEST:
This bill directs the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research (OPR), in consultation with relevant departments, to evaluate, and the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) secretary to consider, creating a categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- CEQA requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for the project, unless the project is exempt from CEQA. (Public Resources Code (PRC) § 21000 et seq.)
- CEQA requires the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) to prepare and develop, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. CEQA requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions. (PRC § 21083)
- Establishes a categorical exemption for Existing Facilities which may apply to the operation, repair, maintenance, permitting, leasing, licensing, or minor alteration of existing public or private structures, facilities, mechanical equipment, or topographical features, involving negligible or no expansion of existing or former use. (California Code of Regulations Title 14 (C.C.R. Tit. 14) Article 19 §15301)
- Establishes a categorical exemption for minor alterations to land which may apply to minor public or private alterations in the condition of land, water, and/or vegetation which do not involve removal of healthy, mature, scenic trees except for forestry or agricultural purposes. (C.C.R. Tit. 14 Article 19 § 15304)
- Specifies that fire thinning or fuel reduction projects on federal lands, subject to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), are exempt from CEQA. (PRC § 4799.05)
This bill:
- Requires that OPR and the Secretary of the Natural Resources agency in consultation Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, and the State Water Resources Control Board to consider creating a categorical CEQA exemption for wildfire risk reduction near roadside projects.
- Specifies that OPR shall consider appropriate eligibility criteria for roadside projects eligible for this exemption, including: distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees and sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, potential impacts to wildlife, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan, habitat conservation plan, or other adopted natural resource protection plan.
Background
- The A, B, C’s of CEQA. CEQA is designed to (a) make government agencies and the public aware of the environmental impacts of a proposed project, (b) ensure the public can take part in the review process, and (c) identify and implement measures to mitigate or eliminate any negative impact the project may have on the environment. CEQA is enforced by civil lawsuits that can challenge any project’s environmental review. Nonprofits, private individuals, public agencies, advocacy groups, and other organizations can all file lawsuits under CEQA.
Under CEQA, projects (unless they have a specific exemption) must undergo environmental analysis. This process starts with an initial study which determines what level of further environmental review is needed for a given project. If a project has no significant effects on the environment, or if those effects can be fully mitigated, the project can move forward with a negative declaration (ND) or mitigated negative declaration (MND). If the initial study finds that the project has potentially significant effects on the environment, then a full EIR is conducted.
- CEQA exemptions: statutory vs. categorical. A project is exempt from CEQA if it is ministerial (i.e., it does not involve discretionary decisions), or if there is a specific statutory or categorical exemption that applies to the project. Statutory exemptions are created by the Legislature and apply even if a project has the potential to significantly affect the environment. In contrast, categorical exemptions, which are listed in the CEQA guidelines, generally do not apply if there are significant environmental impacts associated with the project. Categorical exemptions are developed by the Office of Planning and Research as part of the CEQA guideline process and become part of the CEQA guidelines when they are certified and adopted by the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency.
- Wildfire risk. Wildfires have always shaped life in California, but as they have grown in size, severity, and overlap with the built environment, wildfires have become increasingly harmful to Californians. According to a study in 2023 by researchers at the University of Montana, the number of homes and structures destroyed by wildfires increased by 246% over the past two decades in the contiguous Western U.S. Since 2005, wildfires have destroyed more than 97,000 structures in California, requiring mass evacuations, and exacerbating the state’s housing crisis. A study on the costs of wildfires to the State of California, conducted by the California Council of Science and Technology, found that the cost of wildfires averaged $117.4 billion annually. This includes both direct costs of fighting and recovering from wildfires (an estimated $5.0 billion annually was attributable to reduced tax revenues and increased wildfire response costs) and indirect costs such as the strain on healthcare systems for illnesses associated with wildfire smoke. Wildfires can also be deadly. Between 2000-2017, 84 civilians were killed in wildfires. In 2018, the Camp Fire in Paradise, the deadliest wildfire in California, killed 85 civilians.
- The impacts of wildfires are inequitable. A study from 2010 finds that low income households are more likely to lose all of their assets in a wildfire and less likely to have adequate insurance to cover the cost of losses as compared to higher income households. Furthermore, numerous studies have identified that wildfire smoke can be more harmful to the elderly, children, people with pre-existing medical conditions, and people in disadvantaged communities where more systemic exposure to pollution and more limited access to healthcare increase risk of respiratory illnesses that can be exacerbated by wildfire smoke.
- Roads and wildfires. Roads are one way that humans get access to wild lands. As such, roads increase the chance of human-caused fire ignition in those wild lands: this can be a significant wildfire risk since the majority of wildfires are started by human activity (about 86% of wildfires in California between 1992 and 2020 according to the U.S. Forest Service).
A 2019 study in Scientific Reports found that proximity to roads, alongside other variables like grass cover, were significant predictors of wildfire risk in California. Another study in the eastern cascade mountains of Washington State found that human-caused ignitions were concentrated close to roads, in high road density areas.
While roads pose a fire risk, they can also act as fuel breaks that slow fires and allow fire suppression crews quick access to fires. Roads are most effective at controlling fire when they are cleared of vegetation. However, a Caltrans Wildfire Vulnerability Analysis prepared in 2019 and repeated in 2020 confirmed that a significant portion of the state highway network is vulnerable to wildfire.
- Wildfire mitigation through CalVTP. In California, the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) regulates forestry activities throughout the state and develops policies to prevent fires. In December 2019, CAL FIRE developed and approved a program, the California Vegetative Treatment Program (CalVTP) to reduce hazardous vegetation around communities in the Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI), to construct fuel breaks, and to restore healthy ecological fire regimes. Vegetative treatment involves removing plants that can act as a fuel for wildfires. In forested areas, underbrush can also act as a ladder leading up into the tree canopy, leading to larger, more devastating fires. There are numerous methods of vegetative treatment, including applying herbicides, prescribed herbivory (like goats), prescribed burns, and mechanical fuel thinning.
CalVTP stitches together a series of individual vegetation treatment projects to prevent wildfires over larger areas. Projects are sited in State Responsibility Areas, which represent a small fraction of forested areas in the state. To streamline CalVTP projects, CAL FIRE simultaneously created a Program EIR (PEIR) for CalVTP projects. A PEIR is an umbrella EIR that provides environmental analysis that can be used for multiple related projects.
According CAL FIRE, as of 2021, approximately 750,000 acres of California's forests are treated with mechanical or prescribed burns annually. The state has coordinated with federal official to expand these efforts: in August 2020, California and the U.S. Forest Service committed to vegetation treatment and maintenance on a million acres of federal, state, and private forest and wildlands annually by 2025.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Many fires are caused by sparks and burning debris from cars that ignite dry brush near our roads. We must make it easier for firefighters to clear this vulnerable land and remove these flammable materials. It will help keep the public safe and defend our exposed forests. This legislation aims to streamline the process for roadside vegetation management projects, crucial for wildfire risk reduction. By considering these projects for categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), we seek to expedite essential preventative measures while minimizing bureaucratic hurdles.”
- Are these projects already exempt? Roadside vegetation treatment projects to mitigate wildfires may by-and-large already be exempt from CEQA. A search of the term “fuels reduction and roadside” on CEQAnet, the State’s database of filed notices for certain CEQA projects, finds dozens of examples of fuel thinning projects along roadsides since 2020. The majority of these projects use either an “existing facilities” or a “minor alternations to land” categorical exemptions currently established in the CEQA guidelines.
If fuel thinning projects near roadways are already eligible for existing categorical exemptions, then adding a new, more specific categorical exemption could cause confusion rather than clarity. Stop-back language in the bill specifies that if CNRA adopts a new exemption in the CEQA guidelines pursuant to this legislation, that new exemption would not prevent the use of existing exemptions. This keeps the door open for lead agencies to use whatever exemption works best for them as they manage vegetation along roads for fire prevention.
- Pulling in the experts. Because categorical exemptions are developed by OPR and adopted by CNRA, categorical exemptions provide an opportunity to bring in OPR’s expertise and stakeholder input in crafting the guardrails needed to ensure that this proposed CEQA exemption does not result in unintended harm to the environment. The bill also considers expertise beyond CEQA and that housed at OPR by specifically including consultation with relevant state entities: the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, and the State Water Resources Control Board. In asking OPR and CNRA to consider creating a new categorical exemption, SB 1159 proposes a new approach to creating CEQA exemptions to take advantage of state agencies’ expertise.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee,
• OPR estimates ongoing costs of about $450,000 annually (General Fund) for two positions to evaluate adopting an additional CEQA exemption within the Guidelines and to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects, as specified.
• CNRA estimates ongoing costs of an unknown amount, likely $1 million or more (General Fund), to implement the provisions of this bill
• To the extent this bill increases the number or ease of completing roadside projects, unknown ongoing cost pressure (various funds) to provide funds for CalFire to implement the additional projects.
• To the extent the bill encourages activities that reduce the occurrence or severity of catastrophic wildfires from what otherwise would have occurred, this bill would result in potentially significant savings due to avoided fire suppression costs (General Fund). CalFire spends roughly $1 billion annually (General Fund) on “emergency fire suppression”
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/16/24)
Associated General Contractors
California Building Industry Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fire Chiefs Association
California State Council of Laborers
Contra Costa County
Contra Costa County Fire Chiefs
County of Sonoma
County of Yolo
Humboldt Redwood Company LLC
Mountain Counties Water Resources Association
Napa County
Pacific Forest Trust
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Diego Gas and Electric Company
Solano County Board of Supervisors
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/24)
New Livable California Dba Livable California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT. The California Fire Chiefs write in support: “By streamlining the environmental review process for these projects, SB 1159 will enable more efficient and cost-effective implementation of crucial wildfire prevention measures. Roadside ignitions pose a significant threat to our communities and are made worse by the presence of dry vegetation capable of carrying fast moving fire. Implementing vegetation management along roadsides, in addition to prescribed burns, strategic fuel breaks, and home hardening, is essential for reducing the spread of wildfires and protecting both built and natural environments.
“Current CEQA requirements for roadside vegetation management projects are time-consuming and expensive, limiting the scale of necessary wildfire risk reduction efforts. SB 1159 addresses this challenge by recognizing roadside vegetation management as a legislative priority and advocating for its inclusion on the list of categorically exempt projects under CEQA guidelines.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Livable California writes in opposition “LC understands the need to reduce the risks from wildfire in California, particularly near urban areas. LC also acknowledges that areas near roadways can be conducive to wildfire ignition or spread, especially when that involves careless actions by drivers or passengers of motor vehicles. Therefore, projects that reduce wildfire risk in roadside areas, such as by tree removal or brush clearance, can be beneficial. However, roadside areas within forests or areas of chaparral may also be important as wildlife habitat. For example, the Alameda whipsnake, a federally listed endangered species, uses chaparral, and particularly rock outcroppings and flat, sunny rock surfaces, as part of its preferred habitat. While the bill includes potential impacts to wildlife in factors to be considered, more is required.
“Any CEQA exemption for wildfire prevention projects along roadways should explicitly exclude areas that have been identified as habitat or potential habitat for sensitive wildlife species – either plant or animal. The exemption should also not apply to fire roads, which often go through sensitive habitat areas and can have an important function as wildlife migration corridors.”
Prepared by: Brynn Cook / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
5/17/24 17:19:22
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1159 (Dodd) - California Environmental Quality Act: roadside wildfire risk reduction projects
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would direct the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research (OPR), in consultation with relevant departments, to evaluate, and the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) secretary to consider, creating a categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census-designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction.
Fiscal Impact:
- OPR estimates ongoing costs of about $450,000 annually (General Fund) for two positions to evaluate adopting an additional CEQA exemption within the Guidelines and to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects, as specified.
- CNRA estimates ongoing costs of an unknown amount, likely $1 million or more (General Fund), to implement the provisions of this bill.
- To the extent this bill increases the number or ease of completing roadside projects, unknown ongoing cost pressure (various funds) to provide funds for CalFire to implement the additional projects.
- To the extent the bill encourages activities that reduce the occurrence or severity of catastrophic wildfires from what otherwise would have occurred, this bill would result in potentially significant savings due to avoided fire suppression costs (General Fund). CalFire spends roughly $1 billion annually (General Fund) on “emergency fire suppression” – additional fire suppression resources needed when a fire continues to spread after the “initial attack” or about the first 24 hours. Fires in treated forests are more likely to be contained during the initial attack, and are much less likely to become catastrophic wildfires that require emergency fire suppression resources.
Background:
The A, B, C’s of CEQA. CEQA is designed to (a) make government agencies and the public aware of the environmental impacts of a proposed project, (b) ensure the public can take part in the review process, and (c) identify and implement measures to mitigate or eliminate any negative impact the project may have on the environment. CEQA is enforced by civil lawsuits that can challenge any project’s environmental review. Nonprofits, private individuals, public agencies, advocacy groups, and other organizations can all file lawsuits under CEQA.
Under CEQA, a project must undergo an environmental analysis unless it qualifies for a specific exemption. This process starts with an initial study, which determines what level of further environmental review is needed for a given project. If a project has no significant effects on the environment, or if those effects can be fully mitigated, the project can move forward with a negative declaration or mitigated negative declaration. If the initial study finds that the project has potential significant effects on the environment, then a full environmental impact report (EIR) is conducted.
CEQA exemptions: statutory vs. categorical. A project is exempt from CEQA if it is ministerial (i.e., it does not involve a discretionary decision), or if there is a specific statutory or categorical exemption that applies to the project. Statutory exemptions are created by the Legislature and apply even if a project has the potential to significantly affect the environment. In contrast, categorical exemptions, which are listed in the CEQA guidelines, generally do not apply if there are significant environmental impacts associated with the project. Categorical exemptions are developed by OPR as part of the CEQA guideline process, and become part of the CEQA guidelines when they are certified and adopted by the CNRA secretary.
Wildfires and roads. Catastrophic and devastating wildfires have occurred repeatedly in the state in recent years. Nine of the 20 largest and seven of the 20 most destructive wildland fires in state history occurred in 2020 and 2021 when almost seven million acres burned. The 2020 August Complex Fire in northern California – the largest fire in California’s modern history – burned over one million acres while the 2021 Dixie Fire burned almost one million acres. Two wildland fires in recent years burned over the crest of the Sierras, which had not been previously observed. In the last several years, tens of thousands of structures – mostly homes – have been destroyed from wildland fire, insured losses incurred are in the billions of dollars, prime habitat has been destroyed or damaged, and, tragically, hundreds of lives have been lost. In addition, millions of Californians have been exposed to unhealthy air quality due to the wildfires.
Wildfires can originate from both natural sources such as lightning, and human ignitions such as those started by accident or set intentionally by arsonists. The majority of wildfires are started by human activity: about 86% of wildfires in California between 1992 and 2020 according to the U.S. Forest Service. The Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFire) estimates 95% of wildfires are human caused. Roadways can increase the chance of human-caused fire ignition, particularly in the Wildland-Urban Interface. A 2021 study in Scientific Reports notes that proximity to roads, alongside other variables like grass cover, temperature, and vapor pressure deficit, were significant predictors of wildfire risk in California. According to CalFire, at least seven large fires (300 acres or greater) were started by vehicles in 2022 in the state.
The deadly Carr Fire in 2018 started along a highway. The fire ignited near the Carr Powerhouse Road along Highway 299 in the Whiskeytown National Recreation Area. The official cause of the fire was a flat tire of a vehicle trailer in 100-degree weather. The wheel is thought to have contacted the pavement sending sparks into the highway median and forest habitat gradient. The fire burned almost 230,000 acres, resulted in eight fatalities, four of whom were first responders, destroyed 1,079 residences, and devastated a widespread area in the Redding, California region. According to a ProPublica article, the California Department of Transportation (CalTrans), which owns and manages Highway 299, spent a week in 2016 pruning trees and clearing vegetation along the narrow state right of way. Once the highway crossed over national forest and parkland, CalTrans reached out to Whiskeytown officials to continue the work on federal land outside of CalTrans’ right-of-way. For a variety of reasons, the work did not happen, leaving the risk unaddressed.
The California’s Wildfire and Forest Resilience Action Plan (Action Plan) released by the Wildfire and Forest Resilience Task Force (Task Force) in 2021 notes that a fire-safe state highway system is vital to reducing wildfire ignitions and ensuring emergency evacuation routes. Over 5,000 centerline miles of state highways are built in rural settings, including forestland, chaparral, and grasslands. CalTrans estimates 2,600 centerline miles of California’s highway system need fuel reduction treatment within and alongside the CalTrans-owned right of way. Hazardous fuels reduction along roadways can reduce fire hazards and risks by creating a break in horizontal and vertical fuel continuity that can modify future wildfire behavior and improve community protection efforts.
In many cases, the thinning of vegetation along road corridors will cross federal, state, or local boundaries. For example, 3,000 miles of road cross federal lands. According to the Action Plan, CalTrans is establishing a framework for collaborative fuels reduction projects to protect roadway travelers, communities along highways, and to reduce roadside ignitions along primary and secondary emergency evacuation routes. CalTrans also commits in the Action Plan to partnering with adjacent landowners to treat priority areas along its 2,600 miles of high-risk roadways and to develop a statewide Good Neighbor Agreement with the U.S. Forest Service to treat adjacent federal lands.
California Vegetation Treatment Program (CalVTP). In response to concerns raised by communities that the CEQA process was slowing down their ability to launch critical wildfire fuel reduction projects, the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) adopted the CalVTP. The CalVTP provides a CEQA compliance tool to expedite the implementation of wildfire resilience projects. The CalVTP EIR covers 20.3 million acres of fire-prone land in the state responsibility area. Under the CalVTP, a project proponent could implement prescribed burning, mechanical treatments, manual treatments, herbicide application, and prescribed herbivory to reduce hazardous vegetation around communities in the Wildland-Urban Interface, to construct fuel breaks, and to promote ecological restoration. To utilize the CalVTP, a project proponent must complete a site-specific environmental analysis. Once approved, it is valid for up to 10 years, allowing multiple rounds of vegetation treatment and maintenance using the same environmental document.
The scale of the fuel management problem. Prior to colonization and associated fire suppression activities, as many as 4.5 million acres burned annually in the state. Estimates suggest that on the order of 10 – 30 million acres of the state may benefit from treatment by low-intensity fire, such as cultural burning.
In August 2020, California and the US Forest Service agreed to increase vegetation treatment and maintenance to one million acres annually – 500,000 acres treated each – by 2025. Recent progress suggests that the state is on the order of half-way to its 2025 goal. The Strategic Plan establishes annual targets of 50,000 acres treated by CalFire, and an additional 25,000 acres for state public lands. Cultural fire practitioners and tribes are in the “other lands managers” category with private landowners, nongovernmental organizations, Prescribed Burn Association, and local jurisdictions with a goal of 25,000 acres. CalFire has reached about half of the target acres to be burned annually in the last few years.
Proposed Law:
This bill would direct OPR to evaluate, and CNRA to consider, creating a categorical exemption from the CEQA for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction. Specifically, this bill would:
- By January 1, 2026, direct OPR, in consultation with DFW, CalFire, the State Water Board, and other relevant agencies, to evaluate, and the CNRA secretary to consider, creating a categorical exemption under CEQA for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction.
- Direct OPR, in consultation with the same agencies, to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for this type of categorical exemption, including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees and sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, potential impacts to wildlife, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan, habitat conservation plan, or other adopted natural resource protection plan, as specified
- Provide that an exemption for this type of project does not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
- Specify that a project that is exempt shall comply with all requirements otherwise imposed by law, including, but not limited to, the California Endangered Species Act, the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, and any other applicable state and federal laws.
Related Legislation:
AB 1951 (Vince Fong, 2024) would exempt a project for wildfire prevention, including the removal of trees and brush, within 50 feet of either side of a roadway, from CEQA.
AB 2643 (Wood, 2024), among other things, would make the CEQA exemption permanent for projects to conserve, restore, protect, or enhance, and assist in the recovery of California native fish and wildlife, and the habitat upon which they depend; and to restore or provide habitat for California native fish and wildlife.
AB 211 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 574, Statutes of 2022) extended the sunset from January 1, 2023, to January 1, 2028 for the CEQA exemption for prescribed fire, thinning, or fuel reduction projects undertaken on federal lands that have been reviewed under the National Environmental Policy Act, as specified; and expanded this exemption for reforestation and habitat restoration projects undertaken on federal lands that have been reviewed under the National Environmental Policy Act, as specified.
AB 297 (Gallagher, 2021) would have exempted from CEQA projects or activities related to forest health and fuel reduction, including, but not limited to, projects undertaken pursuant to the federal Good Neighbor Authority, that involve thinning overgrown brushes or trees 10 inches or less in diameter by mechanical thinning, pile burning, prescribed fire, and grazing. This bill was not heard in the first policy committee.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Dave Min, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1159 Hearing Date: April 23, 2024
Author: | Dodd | ||
Version: | March 20, 2024 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Catherine Baxter | ||
Subject: California Environmental Quality Act: roadside wildfire risk reduction projects
SUMMARY
This bill would direct the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research (OPR) to evaluate, and the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) secretary to consider, creating a categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction.
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Background
The A, B, C’s of CEQA. CEQA is designed to (a) make government agencies and the public aware of the environmental impacts of a proposed project, (b) ensure the public can take part in the review process, and (c) identify and implement measures to mitigate or eliminate any negative impact the project may have on the environment. CEQA is enforced by civil lawsuits that can challenge any project’s environmental review. Nonprofits, private individuals, public agencies, advocacy groups, and other organizations can all file lawsuits under CEQA.
Under CEQA, a project must undergo an environmental analysis unless it qualifies for a specific exemption. This process starts with an initial study, which determines what level of further environmental review is needed for a given project. If a project has no significant effects on the environment, or if those effects can be fully mitigated, the project can move forward with a negative declaration or mitigated negative declaration. If the initial study finds that the project has potential significant effects on the environment, then a full environmental impact report (EIR) is conducted.
CEQA exemptions: statutory vs. categorical. A project is exempt from CEQA if it is ministerial (i.e., it does not involve a discretionary decision), or if there is a specific statutory or categorical exemption that applies to the project. Statutory exemptions are created by the Legislature and apply even if a project has the potential to significantly affect the environment. In contrast, categorical exemptions, which are listed in the CEQA guidelines, generally do not apply if there are significant environmental impacts associated with the project. Categorical exemptions are developed by OPR as part of the CEQA guideline process, and become part of the CEQA guidelines when they are certified and adopted by the CNRA secretary.
Wildfires and roads. Catastrophic and devastating wildfires have occurred repeatedly in the state in recent years. Nine of the 20 largest and seven of the 20 most destructive wildland fires in state history occurred in 2020 and 2021 when almost seven million acres burned. The 2020 August Complex Fire in northern California – the largest fire in California’s modern history – burned over one million acres while the 2021 Dixie Fire burned almost one million acres. Two wildland fires in recent years burned over the crest of the Sierras, which had not been previously observed. In the last several years, tens of thousands of structures – mostly homes – have been destroyed from wildland fire, insured losses incurred are in the billions of dollars, prime habitat has been destroyed or damaged, and, tragically, hundreds of lives have been lost. In addition, millions of Californians have been exposed to unhealthy air quality due to the wildfires.
Wildfires can originate from both natural sources such as lightning, and human ignitions such as those started by accident or set intentionally by arsonists. The majority of wildfires are started by human activity: about 86% of wildfires in California between 1992 and 2020 according to the U.S. Forest Service. The Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFire) estimates 95% of wildfires are human caused. Roadways can increase the chance of human-caused fire ignition, particularly in the Wildland-Urban Interface. A 2021 study in Scientific Reports notes that proximity to roads, alongside other variables like grass cover, temperature, and vapor pressure deficit, were significant predictors of wildfire risk in California. According to CalFire, at least seven large fires (300 acres or greater) were started by vehicles[1] in 2022 in the state.
The deadly Carr Fire in 2018 started along a highway. The fire ignited near the Carr Powerhouse Road along Highway 299 in the Whiskeytown National Recreation Area. The official cause of the fire was a flat tire of a vehicle trailer in 100-degree weather. The wheel is thought to have contacted the pavement sending sparks into the highway median and forest habitat gradient. The fire burned almost 230,000 acres, resulted in eight fatalities, four of whom were first responders, destroyed 1,079 residences, and devastated a widespread area in the Redding, California region. According to a ProPublica article, the California Department of Transportation (CalTrans), which owns and manages Highway 299, spent a week in 2016 pruning trees and clearing vegetation along the narrow state right of way. Once the highway crossed over national forest and parkland, CalTrans reached out to Whiskeytown officials to continue the work on federal land outside of CalTrans’ right-of-way. For a variety of reasons, the work did not happen, leaving the risk unaddressed.
The California’s Wildfire and Forest Resilience Action Plan (Action Plan) released by the Wildfire and Forest Resilience Task Force (Task Force) in 2021 notes that a fire-safe state highway system is vital to reducing wildfire ignitions and ensuring emergency evacuation routes. Over 5,000 centerline miles of state highways are built in rural settings, including forestland, chaparral, and grasslands. CalTrans estimates 2,600 centerline miles of California’s highway system need fuel reduction treatment within and alongside the CalTrans-owned right of way. Hazardous fuels reduction along roadways can reduce fire hazards and risks by creating a break in horizontal and vertical fuel continuity that can modify future wildfire behavior and improve community protection efforts.
In many cases, the thinning of vegetation along road corridors will cross federal, state, or local boundaries. For example, 3,000 miles of road cross federal lands. According to the Action Plan, CalTrans is establishing a framework for collaborative fuels reduction projects to protect roadway travelers, communities along highways, and to reduce roadside ignitions along primary and secondary emergency evacuation routes. CalTrans also commits in the Action Plan to partnering with adjacent landowners to treat priority areas along its 2,600 miles of high-risk roadways and to develop a statewide Good Neighbor Agreement with the U.S. Forest Service to treat adjacent federal lands.
California Vegetation Treatment Program (CalVTP). In response to concerns raised by communities that the CEQA process was slowing down their ability to launch critical wildfire fuel reduction projects, the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) adopted the CalVTP. The CalVTP provides a CEQA compliance tool to expedite the implementation of wildfire resilience projects. The CalVTP EIR covers 20.3 million acres of fire-prone land in the state responsibility area. Under the CalVTP, a project proponent could implement prescribed burning, mechanical treatments, manual treatments, herbicide application, and prescribed herbivory to reduce hazardous vegetation around communities in the Wildland-Urban Interface, to construct fuel breaks, and to promote ecological restoration. To utilize the CalVTP, a project proponent must complete a site-specific environmental analysis. Once approved, it is valid for up to 10 years, allowing multiple rounds of vegetation treatment and maintenance using the same environmental document.
Existing federal law:
- Establishes the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (FESA) which prohibits, without a permit, the take or possession of any endangered species of fish and wildlife and prohibits the removal of any endangered species of plants. 16 USC §§1531 et seq.
Existing state law:
- Establishes the California Endangered Species Act (CESA), which generally prohibits, without a permit, a person or public agency from importing, exporting, or taking, possessing, purchasing, or selling any endangered or threatened species, or any part or product thereof, or attempting any of those acts. Fish and Game Code §2080.
- Establishes the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research (OPR) under the control of the director of OPR. OPR serves the Governor and the Governor’s Cabinet as staff for long-range planning and research, and constitutes the comprehensive state planning agency. Government Code (GOV) §65037 and §65040, respectively.
- Establishes CNRA under the control of the CNRA secretary, with oversight of natural resources-related departments, boards, and conservancies. GOV §12805.
- Establishes a local assistance grant program for fire prevention and home hardening education activities in California. This program, known as the Fire Prevention Grant Program, is administered by CalFire and funds vegetation management along roadways and driveways to reduce fire risk, among other fire prevention activities. Public Resources Code (PRC) §4124.5.
- Establishes the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), which requires a lead agency with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or EIR for the project, unless the project is exempt from CEQA. PRC §§21000 et seq.
- Requires OPR to prepare and develop, and the CNRA secretary to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. PRC §21083.
- Requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions. PRC §21084.
- Establishes statutory exemptions from CEQA, including the following:
- Prescribed fire, reforestation, habitat restoration, thinning, or fuel reduction projects on federal lands that have been reviewed under National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) if certain conditions are met. PRC §4799.05.
- Until January 1, 2025, a project to conserve, restore, protect, or enhance, and assist in the recovery of California native fish and wildlife, and the habitat upon which they depend. PRC §21080.56.
- Until January 1, 2025, a project to restore or provide habitat for California native fish and wildlife. PRC §21080.56.
Existing regulation:
- Establishes categorical exemptions from CEQA, including the following:
- Class 1 exemption: Operation, repair, maintenance, permitting, leasing, licensing, or minor alteration of existing public or private structures, facilities, mechanical equipment, or topographical features, involving negligible or no expansion of existing or former use. This includes existing highways and streets, including road grading for the purpose of public safety. California Code of Regulations Title 14 (14 CCR) §15301.
- Class 4 exemption: Minor public or private alterations in the condition of land, water, and/or vegetation which do not involve removal of healthy, mature, scenic trees except for forestry and agricultural purposes. This includes fuel management activities within 30 feet of structures to reduce the volume of flammable vegetation, provided that the activities will not result in the taking of endangered, rare, or threatened plant or animal species or significant erosion and sedimentation of surface waters. 14 CCR §15304.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill would:
- By January 1, 2026, direct OPR to evaluate, and the CNRA secretary to consider, creating a categorical exemption under CEQA for roadside projects no more than five road miles from a municipality or census designated place that are undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction.
- Direct OPR to consider appropriate eligibility criteria for this type of categorical exemption, including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees, and potential impacts to wildlife.
- Provide that an exemption for this type of project does not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “Many fires are caused by sparks and burning debris from cars that ignite dry brush near our roads. We must make it easier for firefighters to clear this vulnerable land and remove these flammable materials. It will help keep the public safe and defend our exposed forests. This legislation aims to streamline the process for roadside vegetation management projects, crucial for wildfire risk reduction. By considering these projects for categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), we seek to expedite essential preventative measures while minimizing bureaucratic hurdles.”
According to the sponsor, “Roadside ignitions pose a significant threat to our communities and are made worse by the presence of dry vegetation capable of carrying fast moving fire. Implementing vegetation management along roadsides, in addition to prescribed burns, strategic fuel breaks, and home hardening, is essential for reducing the spread of wildfires and protecting both built and natural environments.”
“Current CEQA requirements for roadside vegetation management projects are time-consuming and expensive, limiting the scale of necessary wildfire risk reduction efforts. SB 1159 addresses this challenge by recognizing roadside vegetation management as a legislative priority and advocating for its inclusion on the list of categorically exempt projects under CEQA guidelines.”
According to the Pacific Forest Trust, “Roads are a very common place for wildfires to start and are a logical place to focus fire risk reduction projects. Despite the broad consensus around this need the existing mechanisms for environmental compliance are less than clear. SB 1159 offers a responsible pathway for streamlining priority projects with de minimis impacts.”
According to Contra Costa County, “Roadside wildfire risk reduction projects contribute to creating safer working conditions for firefighters by reducing fuel loads and improving access for firefighters to reach and respond to wildfires more effectively.”
According to Napa County, this bill “may have a positive impact on our ability to improve fire breaks and evacuation routes. Effective fire breaks and evacuation routes are critical to the process of mitigating the risk a wildfire poses to a community: residents need to have confidence that main roads will act effectively as fire breaks and that they can be efficiently evacuated from danger.”
According to San Diego Gas & Electric, “Roadside wildfire risk reduction projects are a critical component of our work as they help to reduce the spread of wildfires and property damage. Roadways are used for ingress and egress during emergencies and the longer an ingress/egress route can be free of fire, the longer it can be used for evacuation purposes and to facilitate assistance by emergency personnel.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
According to Livable California (LC), “Projects that reduce wildfire risk in roadside areas, such as by tree removal or brush clearance, can be beneficial. However, roadside areas within forests or areas of chaparral may also be important as wildlife habitat. For example, the Alameda whipsnake, a federally listed endangered species, uses chaparral, and particularly rock outcroppings and flat, sunny rock surfaces, as part of its preferred habitat. While the bill includes potential impacts to wildlife in factors to be considered, more is required.”
“Any CEQA exemption for wildfire prevention projects along roadways should explicitly exclude areas that have been identified as habitat or potential habitat for sensitive wildlife species – either plant or animal. The exemption should also not apply to fire roads, which often go through sensitive habitat areas and can have an important function as wildlife migration corridors.”
COMMENTS
Dual referral. This bill was referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee and this Committee. The former Committee passed the bill unanimously on April 3, 2024, without amendments. Elements of the bill under that Committee’s jurisdiction were discussed before that Committee and are included here for completeness and context only.
The need for the bill. According to the author, sponsor, and supporters, CEQA compliance can be costly and time consuming, delaying important vegetation management projects along roadsides. The CalVTP, however, offers one route to achieve CEQA compliance in a less costly and time-consuming manner. Based on a quick search of the CalVTP database, it appears that some entities are using the CalVTP process to support roadside fuel reduction work. Further, according to the Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC), which writes in support of the bill, “CalFire, the Department of Parks and Recreation, and many counties, cities, and special districts have used existing categorical exemptions for roadside fuel reduction work. These exemptions include the Class 1 (Existing Facility) and Class 4 (Minor Alterations to Land) categorical exemptions.”
Given these options, a key question for the Committee is: Why is this new categorical exemption needed? According to sponsor, the Class 1 and Class 4 categorical exemptions are less than clear regarding their applicability to vegetation management work alongside roadways to reduce wildfire risk. Some project proponents may be hesitant to use these exemptions given concerns over potential CEQA challenges. To clear up any ambiguity, this bill would direct OPR to evaluate, and the CNRA secretary to consider adopting, a new categorical exemption for roadside projects undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction within five road miles of a municipality or census designated place.
It is worth noting that RCRC supports the bill, although it has some requests for amendments discussed further bill, in part because the bill states that the proposed categorical exemption, if adopted, would not limit the use of any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk. Without that provision of the bill, RCRC was concerned the proposed categorical exemption would have supplanted the authority of state and local governments to use the existing categorical exemptions.
FESA and CESA concerns. These two laws provide a framework to list threatened and endangered species and to conserve and protect these species and their habitats. Both laws generally prohibit the “taking” of any listed species without a permit from the appropriate agency. The lead agencies for implementing FESA are the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the U.S. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries. The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) is the state’s lead agency for granting permits under CESA when necessary for the take of CESA listed species.
The EIR prepared under CEQA provides the necessary information and analysis to determine whether a project will significantly impact a listed species and what measures might be adopted to avoid or mitigate those impacts. CDFW uses the EIR to inform its decision-making regarding the necessity for and conditions of a CESA permit. If, pursuant to this bill, the CNRA secretary adopted a new categorical exemption for roadside projects undertaken solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction within five road miles of a municipality or census designated place, it would make it more difficult to assess a project’s potential impact on listed species and to enforce CESA and FESA prohibitions on the take of listed species.
It is worth noting that this bill does not exempt a project from CESA rules and requirements. It also does not (and could not) exempt a project from FESA. If a project proponent secured the proposed categorical exemption for a roadside fuel reduction project, and then, in the course of work discovered listed species within the project site or nearby that would be impacted by the project, existing law would require the project proponent to stop work and start the CEQA process. In other words, the categorical exemption would no longer apply. However, it would be exceedingly difficult for CDFW to enforce this.
Livable California raises similar concerns in an oppose letter regarding the bill’s potential impacts to listed species, arguing that “any CEQA exemption for wildfire prevention projects along roadways should explicitly exclude areas that have been identified as habitat or potential habitat for sensitive wildlife species – either plant or animal.”
A key consideration for this Committee is how to balance the need to quickly implement fuel reductions projects along roadways to protect communities and ecosystems from catastrophic wildfires with the need to protect threatened and endangered species from the potential impacts of these projects.
Committee amendments. Should the bill move forward, the Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to seek to address these concerns. In particular, this would include amendments to:
- Require OPR to evaluate a categorical exemption for roadside fuel reduction projects and consider appropriate eligibility criteria for these projects in consultation with CDFW and any other relevant state agencies, as specified. (See Amendment 1)
- Expand the list of eligibility criteria that OPR must consider when evaluating the proposed categorical exemption to include protection of sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan, habitat conservation plan, or other adopted natural resource protection plan, as specified. (See Amendment 2)
- Clarify that a project must comply with all requirements otherwise imposed by law, including CESA and FESA, among others. (See Amendment 3)
Further, the Committee may wish to consider adopting a technical amendment to refer to the potential categorical exemption as a class of an exemption, which is how categorical exemptions are generally named and discussed. (See Amendment 4)
Other issues for consideration. Multiple letters identified other issues that the author may wish to consider as the bill moves forward. This includes identifying the scope of roads to which the proposed categorical exemption would apply. The bill calls out “roadside projects” and, in the eligibility criteria, uses the term “improved road or surface.” It is unclear what types of roads this might include and the issue generally falls outside of the jurisdiction of this Committee. However, to make clear the author’s intent for the bill, the author may wish to clarify which roads would be eligible for the proposed categorical exemption.
Further, multiple letters requested allowing the proposed categorical exemption to apply to projects that have multiple purposes, rather than “solely for the purpose of wildfire risk reduction” and to eliminate the five road mile limitation on where the proposed categorical exemption could be used. Both suggestions would dramatically expand the scope of the proposed categorical exemption and require careful consideration of how the Legislature intends to balance the need for fuels management to protect communities and ecosystems from catastrophic wildfires with the need to protect threatened and endangered species.
Related/Prior legislation.
AB 1951 (Vince Fong, 2024) would exempt a project for wildfire prevention, including the removal of trees and brush, within 50 feet of either side of a roadway, from CEQA. This bill is pending review in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2643 (Wood, 2024), among other things, would make the CEQA exemption permanent for projects to conserve, restore, protect, or enhance, and assist in the recovery of California native fish and wildlife, and the habitat upon which they depend; and to restore or provide habitat for California native fish and wildlife. This bill is pending review in the Assembly Water, Parks and Wildlife Committee.
AB 211 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 574, Statutes of 2022) extended the sunset from January 1, 2023, to January 1, 2028 for the CEQA exemption for prescribed fire, thinning, or fuel reduction projects undertaken on federal lands that have been reviewed under the National Environmental Policy Act, as specified; and expanded this exemption for reforestation and habitat restoration projects undertaken on federal lands that have been reviewed under the National Environmental Policy Act, as specified.
AB 297 (Gallagher, 2021) would have exempted from CEQA projects or activities related to forest health and fuel reduction, including, but not limited to, projects undertaken pursuant to the federal Good Neighbor Authority, that involve thinning overgrown brushes or trees 10 inches or less in diameter by mechanical thinning, pile burning, prescribed fire, and grazing. This bill was not heard in the first policy committee.
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
AMENDMENT 1
In proposed PRC 21084.4(a)(1) and (2), amend as follows:
(a) (1) On or before January 1, 2026, the Office of Planning and Research, in consultation with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, the State Water Resources Control Board, and any other relevant state agencies, shall evaluate, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall consider …
(2) The Office of Planning and Research, in consultation with the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, the State Water Resources Control Board, and any other relevant state agencies, shall consider appropriate eligibility criteria …
AMENDMENT 2
In proposed PRC 21084.4(a)(2), amend as follows:
(2) … shall consider appropriate eligibility criteria for a roadside project subject to paragraph (1), including, among others, the distance from the edge of an improved road or surface, any disturbance to soil and resultant impacts on sedimentation, protection of natural resources such as trees, and sensitive, rare, threatened, or endangered plants, and potential impacts to wildlife, and considerations for lands under conservation easement or identified for conservation in an adopted natural community conservation plan pursuant to the Natural Community Conservation Planning Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 2800) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code), habitat conservation plan pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), or other adopted natural resource protection plan.
AMENDMENT 3
In proposed PRC 21084.4, add new paragraph (3) under subdivision (a), as follows:
(3) A project shall comply with all requirements otherwise imposed by law, including, but not limited to, the California Endangered Species Act (Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code), the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), the Native Plant Protection Act (Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 1900) of Division 2 of the Fish and Game Code), and any other applicable state and federal laws.
AMENDMENT 4
In proposed PRC 21084.4, amend subdivision (b), as follows:
(b) An exemption for projects described in this section class shall not limit any other statutory or categorical exemption that may otherwise apply to roadside projects undertaken to reduce wildfire risk.
SUPPORT
California Fire Chiefs Association (sponsor)
Associated General Contractors
California Building Industry Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California State Council of Laborers
Contra Costa County Fire Chiefs
County of Contra Costa
County of Napa
County of Sonoma
County of Yolo
Humboldt Redwood Company LLC
Mendocino Redwood Company LLC
Pacific Forest Trust
Rural County Representatives of California
San Diego Gas and Electric Company
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION
Livable California
-- END --
This category includes multiple vehicle-related sources, including from exhaust, chaff, or mechanical sources. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1159
Author: | Dodd | ||
Version: | 3/20/2024 | Hearing Date: | 4/3/2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brynn Cook | ||
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: roadside wildfire risk reduction projects
DIGEST: This bill would require the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to consider creating a California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) categorical exemption in the CEQA guidelines for roadside fire mitigation projects meeting certain criteria.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- CEQA requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for the project, unless the project is exempt from CEQA. (Public Resources Code (PRC) § 21000 et seq.)
- CEQA requires the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) to prepare and develop, and the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to certify and adopt, guidelines for the implementation of CEQA. CEQA requires the guidelines to include a list of classes of projects that have been determined not to have a significant effect on the environment and are exempt from the requirements of CEQA, commonly known as categorical exemptions. (PRC § 21083)
- Requires the Office of Planning and Research and the Natural Resources Agency to periodically update the CEQA Guidelines. (PRC § 21083(f))
- Establishes a categorical exemption for Existing Facilities which may apply to the operation, repair, maintenance, permitting, leasing, licensing, or minor alteration of existing public or private structures, facilities, mechanical equipment, or topographical features, involving negligible or no expansion of existing or former use. (California Code of Regulations Title 14 (C.C.R. Tit. 14) Article 19 §15301)
- Establishes a categorical exemption for minor alterations to land which may apply to minor public or private alterations in the condition of land, water, and/or vegetation which do not involve removal of healthy, mature, scenic trees except for forestry or agricultural purposes. (C.C.R. Tit. 14 Article 19 § 15304)
- Specifies that fire thinning or fuel reduction projects on federal lands, subject to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), are exempt from CEQA. (PRC § 4799.05)
This bill:
- Requires the Secretary of the Natural Resources agency to consider creating a categorical CEQA exemption for wildfire risk reduction near roadside projects. To be eligible for this potential exemption, projects cannot remove trees, lead to sedimentation, be located within 30 feet of a road, or be more than five miles from a municipality of census designated place.
Background
- The A, B, C’s of CEQA. CEQA is designed to (a) make government agencies and the public aware of the environmental impacts of a proposed project, (b) ensure the public can take part in the review process, and (c) identify and implement measures to mitigate or eliminate any negative impact the project may have on the environment. CEQA is enforced by civil lawsuits that can challenge any project’s environmental review. Nonprofits, private individuals, public agencies, advocacy groups, and other organizations can all file lawsuits under CEQA.
Under CEQA, projects (unless they have a specific exemption) must undergo environmental analysis. This process starts with an initial study which determines what level of further environmental review is needed for a given project. If a project has no significant effects on the environment, or if those effects can be fully mitigated, the project can move forward with a negative declaration (ND) or mitigated negative declaration (MND). If the initial study finds that the project has potential significant effects on the environment, then a full EIR is conducted.
- CEQA exemptions: statutory vs. categorical. A project is exempt from CEQA if it is ministerial (i.e., it does not involve discretionary decisions), or if there is a specific statutory or categorical exemption that applies to the project. Statutory exemptions are created by the Legislature and apply even if a project has the potential to significantly affect the environment. In contrast, categorical exemptions, which are listed in the CEQA guidelines, generally do not apply if there are significant environmental impacts associated with the project. Categorical exemptions are developed by the Office of Planning and Research as part of the CEQA guideline process, and become part of the CEQA guidelines when they are certified and adopted by the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency.
- Wildfire risk. Wildfires have always shaped life in California, but as they have grown in size, severity, and overlap with the built environment, wildfires have become increasingly harmful to Californians. According to a study in 2023 by researchers at the University of Montana, the number of homes and structures destroyed by wildfires increased by 246% over the past two decades in the contiguous Western U.S. Since 2005, wildfires have destroyed more than 97,000 structures in California, requiring mass evacuations, and exacerbating the state’s housing crisis. A study on the costs of wildfires to the State of California, conducted by the California Council of Science and Technology, found that the cost of wildfires averaged $117.4 billion annually. This includes both direct costs of fighting and recovering from wildfires (an estimated $5.0 billion annually was attributable to reduced tax revenues and increased wildfire response costs) and indirect costs such as the strain on healthcare systems for illnesses associated with wildfire smoke. Wildfires can also be deadly. Between 2000-2017, 84 civilians were killed in wildfires. In 2018, the Camp Fire in Paradise, the deadliest wildfire in California, killed 85 civilians.
- The impacts of wildfires are inequitable. A study from 2010 finds that
low income households are more likely to lose all of their assets in a wildfire and less likely to have adequate insurance to cover the cost of losses as compared to higher income households. Furthermore, numerous studies have identified that wildfire smoke can be more harmful to the elderly, children, people with pre-existing medical conditions, and people in disadvantaged communities where more systemic exposure to pollution and more limited access to healthcare increase risk of respiratory illnesses that can be exacerbated by wildfire smoke.
- Roads and wildfires. Roads are one way that humans get access to wild lands. As such, roads increase the chance of human-caused fire ignition in those wild lands: this can be a significant wildfire risk since the majority of wildfires are started by human activity (about 86% of wildfires in California between 1992 and 2020 according to the U.S. Forest Service).
A 2019 study in Scientific Reports found that proximity to roads, alongside other variables like grass cover, were significant predictors of wildfire risk in California. Another study in the eastern cascade mountains of Washington State found that human-caused ignitions were concentrated close to roads, in high road density areas.
While roads pose a fire risk, they can also act as fuel breaks that slow fires and allow fire suppression crews quick access to fires. Roads are most effective at controlling fire when they are cleared of vegetation. However, a Caltrans Wildfire Vulnerability Analysis prepared in 2019 and repeated in 2020 confirmed that a significant portion of the state highway network is vulnerable to wildfire.
- Wildfire mitigation through CalVTP. In California, the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) regulates forestry activities throughout the state and develops policies to prevent fires. In December 2019, CAL FIRE developed and approved a program, the California Vegetative Treatment Program (CalVTP) to reduce hazardous vegetation around communities in the Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI), to construct fuel breaks, and to restore healthy ecological fire regimes. Vegetative treatment involves removing plants that can act as a fuel for wildfires. In forested areas, underbrush can also act as a ladder leading up into the tree canopy, leading to larger, more devastating fires. There are numerous methods of vegetative treatment, including applying herbicides, prescribed herbivory (like goats), prescribed burns, and mechanical fuel thinning.
CalVTP stitches together a series of individual vegetation treatment projects to prevent wildfires over larger areas. Projects are sited in State Responsibility Areas, which represent a small fraction of forested areas in the state. To streamline CalVTP projects, CAL FIRE simultaneously created a Program EIR (PEIR) for CalVTP projects. A PEIR is an umbrella EIR that provides environmental analysis that can be used for multiple related projects.
According CAL FIRE, as of 2021, approximately 750,000 acres of California's forests are treated with mechanical or prescribed burns annually. The state has coordinated with federal official to expand these efforts: in August 2020, California and the U.S. Forest Service committed to vegetation treatment and maintenance on a million acres of federal, state, and private forest and wildlands annually by 2025.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Many fires are caused by sparks and burning debris from cars that ignite dry brush near our roads. We must make it easier for firefighters to clear this vulnerable land and remove these flammable materials. It will help keep the public safe and defend our exposed forests. This legislation aims to streamline the process for roadside vegetation management projects, crucial for wildfire risk reduction. By considering these projects for categorical exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), we seek to expedite essential preventative measures while minimizing bureaucratic hurdles.”
- Are these projects already exempt? Roadside vegetation treatment projects to mitigate wildfires may by-and-large already be exempt from CEQA. A search of the term “fuels reduction and roadside” on CEQAnet, the State’s database of filed notices for certain CEQA projects, finds dozens of examples of fuel thinning projects along roadsides since 2020. The majority of these projects use either an “existing facilities” or a “minor alternations to land” categorical exemptions currently established in the CEQA guidelines.
If fuel thinning projects near roadways are already eligible for existing categorical exemptions, then adding a new, more specific categorical exemption could cause confusion rather than clarity. Stop-back language in the bill specifies that if CNRA adopts a new exemption in the CEQA guidelines pursuant to this legislation, that new exemption would not prevent the use of existing exemptions. This keeps the door open for lead agencies to use whatever exemption works best for them as they manage vegetation along roads for fire prevention.
- Pulling in the experts. Because categorical exemptions are developed by OPR and adopted by CNRA, categorical exemptions provide an opportunity to bring in OPR’s expertise and stakeholder input in crafting the guardrails needed to ensure that this proposed CEQA exemption does not result in unintended harm to the environment. In asking OPR and CNRA to consider creating a new categorical exemption, SB 1159 proposes a new approach to creating CEQA exemptions to take advantage of state agencies’ expertise.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1554 (Patterson, 2023) would have expressly exempts from CEQA a project for the reduction of fuels in areas within moderate, high, and very high fire hazard severity zones. This bill died in the Assembly Committee on Natural Resources.
AB 1951 (Fong, 2024) would exempt from CEQA a project for wildfire prevention within 50 feet of either side of a roadway. The bill is awaiting hearing in the Assembly Committee on Natural Resources.
AB 267 (Valladares, 2022) would have extended the sunset from January 1, 2023, to January 1, 2026, for a CEQA exemption for prescribed fire, thinning, or fuel reduction projects undertaken on federal lands to reduce the risk of high-severity wildfire that have been reviewed under NEPA. This bill died on the Senate inactive file.
SB 632 (Galgiani Chapter 411, Statutes of 2019) requires the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection, as soon as practicably feasible, but no later February 1, 2020, to complete its environmental review under CEQA and certify a specific final PEIR for a vegetation treatment program.
SOURCE:
Fire Chief Dave Winnacker
SUPPORT:
Associated General Contractors
California Building Industry Association
California Fire Chiefs Association
Contra Costa County
Contra Costa County Fire Chiefs
County of Sonoma
Humboldt Redwood Company LLC
Pacific Forest Trust
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Diego Gas and Electric Company
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):