SB 1175: Organic waste: reduction goals: local jurisdictions: waivers.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-13
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires the State Air Resources Board to approve and begin implementing a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy to achieve a certain reduction in statewide emissions of methane, including a goal of a 75% reduction in the level of the statewide disposal of organic waste from the 2014 level by 2025.
Existing law requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, in consultation with the state board, to adopt regulations that achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills that may include, among other things, different levels of requirements for local jurisdictions and phased timelines based upon their progress in meeting the organic waste reduction goals, and penalties to be imposed by the department for noncompliance. The departments regulations authorize low-population and elevation waivers for a local jurisdiction jurisdiction, based on, among other things, a consideration of the jurisdictions census tracts, that exempt the jurisdiction from all or some of the departments organic waste collection requirements.
This bill would require the department to revise the regulations to require the department to consider, in addition to census tracts, alternatives to those census tracts, as provided, when deciding the geographic boundaries of a low-population or elevation waiver. waiver, as specified. The bill would prohibit the department from considering those alternatives when deciding the boundaries for those waivers until it adopts the revised regulations.
Existing law requires the State Air Resources Board to approve and begin implementing a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy to achieve a certain reduction in statewide emissions of methane, including a goal of a 75% reduction in the level of the statewide disposal of organic waste from the 2014 level by 2025.
Existing law requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, in consultation with the state board, to adopt regulations that achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills that may include, among other things, different levels of requirements for local jurisdictions and phased timelines based upon their progress in meeting the organic waste reduction goals, and penalties to be imposed by the department for noncompliance. The departments regulations authorize low-population and elevation waivers for a local jurisdiction based on, among other things, a consideration of the jurisdictions census tracts, that exempt the jurisdiction from all or some of the departments organic waste collection requirements. The departments regulations authorize a low-population waiver issued pursuant to the departments regulations to be valid for a period of up to 5 years, as provided.
This bill would require the department to consider consider, in addition to census tracts, alternatives to those census tracts, as provided, when deciding the boundaries of a low-population or elevation waiver and would require low-population waivers to be valid for a period of 10 years. waiver.
Existing law requires the State Air Resources Board to approve and begin implementing a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy to achieve a certain reduction in statewide emissions of methane, including a goal of a 75% reduction in the level of the statewide disposal of organic waste from the 2014 level by 2025.
Existing law requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, in consultation with the state board, to adopt regulations that achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills that may include, among other things, different levels of requirements for local jurisdictions and phased timelines based upon their progress in meeting the organic waste reduction goals, and penalties to be imposed by the department for noncompliance. The departments regulations authorize low-population and elevation waivers for a local jurisdiction based on, among other things, a consideration of the jurisdictions census tracts, that exempt the jurisdiction from all or some of the departments organic waste collection requirements. The departments regulations authorize a low-population waiver issued pursuant to the departments regulations to be valid for a period of up to 5 years, as provided.
This bill would require the department to consider alternatives to census tracts, as provided, when deciding the boundaries of a low-population or elevation waiver and would require low-population waivers to be valid for a period of 10 years.
When reviewing and evaluating (a)At the time of the first revision after January 1, 2025, to the regulations adopted pursuant to Section 42652.5 for purposes that are unrelated to this section, the department shall also revise those regulations to require the department, when it reviews and evaluates a waiver application that is submitted by a local jurisdiction to the department pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 18984.12 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section read on January 1, 2024, the department shall to consider, in addition to census tracts, the following alternatives to those census tracts when deciding the geographic boundaries of those waivers:
(a)(1)Boundaries submitted by counties, cities, or other public agencies.
(b)(2)Boundaries of incorporated cities.
(c)(3)Boundaries of census-designated places.
(b)The department shall not consider the alternatives to census tracts when it reviews and evaluates a waiver application, as described in subdivision (a), until it adopts revised regulations pursuant to subdivision (a).
(a)When reviewing and evaluating a waiver application that is submitted by a local jurisdiction to the department pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 18984.12 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section read on January 1, 2024, the department shall consider consider, in addition to census tracts, the following alternatives to those census tracts when deciding the boundaries of those waivers:
(1)(a)Boundaries submitted by counties, cities, or other public agencies.
(2)(b)Boundaries of incorporated cities.
(3)(c)Boundaries of census-designated places.
(b)Waivers issued by the department pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 18984.12 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section read on January 1, 2024, shall be valid for a period of 10 years.(a)When reviewing and evaluating a waiver application that is submitted by a local jurisdiction to the department pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) or paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 18984.12 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section read on January 1, 2024, the department shall consider the following alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of those waivers:
(1)Boundaries submitted by counties, cities, or other public agencies.
(2)Boundaries of incorporated cities.
(3)Boundaries of census-designated places.
(b)Waivers issued by the department pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 18984.12 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section read on January 1, 2024, shall be valid for a period of 10 years.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Jun 19, 2024 | June 19 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 11, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (June 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 28, 2024 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| May 21, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 20, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 36. Noes 1. Page 4022.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 14, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 13, 2024 | Ordered to second reading. |
| May 13, 2024 | Read third time and amended. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Apr 12, 2024 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 8, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3467.) (April 3). |
| Mar 8, 2024 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Feb 21, 2024 | Referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 14, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 10, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| May 20, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1175 Ochoa Bogh et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Californians Against Waste | ** Against | |
| League Of California Cities | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | |
| San Bernardino County | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: June 19, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1175
Author:(Ochoa Bogh) – As Amended Ver:May 13, 2024
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to consider alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of low-population and elevation waivers from the state’s organic waste diversion requirements.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires CalRecycle, in its first revision after January 1, 2025, of existing organic waste reduction regulations, to include revisions that require the department to consider alternatives in addition to census tracts for its review of low-population and elevation waiver applications from local jurisdictions. Required alternatives are boundaries submitted by local agencies, boundaries of incorporated cities, and boundaries of census-designated places.
- Prohibits CalRecycle from considering alternatives to census tracts in waiver applications until after it adopts revised regulations.
FISCAL EFFECT:
CalRecycle estimates annual costs of $472,000 for three full-time staff and $16,150 in contracts for fiscal years 2024-25 and ongoing to provide ongoing spatial analysis expertise, facilitate rulemaking, support training needs for locals, and maintain access to mapping software.
COMMENTS:
- Author Statement. According to the author:
Recognizing that parts of SB 1383 (Lara, 2016) were difficult to implement in mountainous, sparsely-populated, and rural areas of the state, CalRecycle began accepting applications for waivers and exemptions to SB 1383 collection requirements. One of three waivers may be granted to exempt areas from SB 1383 collection requirements for varying periods. However, these waivers are awarded based not on well-established boundaries, like city or county lines, but on census tracts, which are geographic regions defined only for census purposes. The result is that the boundaries of areas eligible for a waiver make little sense for the purposes of disposing of organic waste....To provide more flexibility to local governments in their attempts to reach emission reduction goals, SB 1175 will require CalRecycle to consider alternatives in addition to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of a jurisdiction eligible for a waiver of some or all of the collection requirements of SB 1383
- Background. SB 1383 requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to complete, approve, and implement a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (SCLPs) in the state to achieve, among other things, a reduction in the statewide emissions of methane by 40% relative to 2013 levels. To achieve these methane reductions, SB 1383 set a goal of reducing landfill disposal of organic waste 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025, and to rescue at least 20% of currently disposed of surplus food for meals by 2025.
Organic waste accounts for more than a third of California’s waste stream. CalRecycle reports that 2.5 billion meals worth of potentially donatable food is landfilled in a year, and decomposing organic waste in landfills accounts for about 20% of the state’s total methane emissions.
In 2020, CalRecycle adopted SB 1383 regulations, which include requirements on local jurisdictions related to generators and organic waste procurement and recovery targets based, in part, on a jurisdiction’s population. CalRecycle may grant waivers from some or all of the requirements for low population jurisdictions, rural jurisdictions, and jurisdictions above 4,500 elevation. Rural waivers rely on a statutory definition of “rural jurisdiction.” Low-population and elevation waivers are based on census tracts, which can split geographic areas in ways that pose logistical challenges for waste management entities. Waste handling routes are typically based on town or city lines. Thus, waivers based on census tracts can create confusion in planning these routes and cause residents to lose regularly scheduled organic waste pickup.
- Related Legislation. A number of bills relating to organic waste management have been introduced this year. While viewed individually, these bills have modest impacts on the state’s efforts to achieve its SLCP reduction goals; however, added together, they may result in further hindering the state’s ability to reduce these critical GHG emissions. Such bills still under active consideration include AB 2311 (Bennett), AB 2346 (Lee), AB 2514 (Aguiar Curry), AB 2902 (Wood), SB 972 (Min), SB 1045 (Blakespear), and SB 1046 (Laird).
- Prior Legislation. SB 1383 (Lara), Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016, requires CARB to approve and implement a comprehensive SLCP strategy to achieve, from 2013 levels, a 40% reduction in methane, a 40% reduction in hydrofluorocarbon gases, and a 50% reduction in anthropogenic black carbon by 2030. In order to accomplish these goals, the law specifies that the methane emission reduction goals include targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025 from the 2014 level. SB 1383 also requires that by 2025, 20% of edible food that would otherwise be sent to landfills is redirected to feed people.
Analysis Prepared by: Jacqueline Kinney / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 10, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1175
Author:(Ochoa Bogh) – As Amended Ver:May 13, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 36-1
SUBJECT: Organic waste: reduction goals: local jurisdictions: waivers
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to consider alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of low-population and elevation waivers from the state’s organic waste diversion requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to develop a comprehensive strategy to reduce the emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (SLCP) to achieve a 40% reduction in methane emissions, 40% reduction in hydrofluorocarbon gases, and 50% reduction in anthropogenic black carbon below 2013 levels by 2030. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 39730-39730.5)
- Requires the state to reduce the disposal of organic waste by 40% from the 2014 level by 2020 and 75% by 2025 to help achieve the state’s methane reduction goal. (HSC 39730.6)
- Requires that the regulations adopted by CalRecycle include requirements intended to meet the goal that not less than 20% of edible food that is currently disposed is recovered for human consumption by 2025, among other things. (Public Resources Code (PRC) 42652.5)
- Requires CalRecycle, in consultation with ARB, to adopt regulations to achieve the state’s organic waste reduction requirements. Specifies that the regulations, in part:
- May require jurisdictions to impose requirements on generators or other relevant entities within their jurisdiction and may authorize local jurisdictions to impose penalties on generators for noncompliance.
- Include requirements intended to meet the goal that not less than 20% of edible food is recovered for human consumption by 2025.
- May include penalties for noncompliance, as specified.
- Specify that penalties for the organic waste procurement target established by CalRecycle shall be imposed on the following schedule:
- On or after January 1, 2023, each jurisdiction shall procure a quantity of recovered organic waste products that meet or exceed 30% of its recovered organic waste procurement target;
- On or after January 1, 2024, each jurisdiction shall procure a quantity of recovered organic waste products that meet or exceed 65% of its recovered organic waste procurement target; and,
- On and after January 1, 2025, each jurisdiction shall procure a quantity of recovered organic waste products that meet or exceed 100% of its recovered organic waste procurement target. (PRC 42652.5)
- Authorizes CalRecycle to grant waivers to a jurisdiction, and some or all generators located within the jurisdiction, from some or all of the requirements, as specified, from the organic waste recycling requirements for low population census tracts, rural jurisdictions, and jurisdictions above 4,500 feet elevation, as specified. (California Code of Regulations (CCR) 18984.12
- Requires jurisdictions to annually procure a specified quantity of recovered organic waste products that meets or exceeds its annual organic waste procurement target. Specifies that the organic waste procurement target is calculated by multiplying the per capita procurement target (0.8 tons per resident per year) by the jurisdiction’s population. (CCR 18993.1)
THIS BILL:
- Requires CalRecycle, when it revises the regulations adopted pursuant to PRC 42652.5 after January 1, 2025, to consider boundaries submitted by local agencies, boundaries of incorporated cities, and boundaries of census-designated places in addition to census tracts when it reviews and evaluates a waiver application.
- Prohibits CalRecycle from considering alternatives to census tracts until it adopts revised regulations.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, this bill has negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Organic waste management. SB 1383 (Lara), Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016, requires ARB to approve and implement a comprehensive SLCP strategy to achieve, from 2013 levels, a 40% reduction in methane, a 40% reduction in hydrofluorocarbon gases, and a 50% reduction in anthropogenic black carbon by 2030. In order to accomplish these goals, the law specifies that the methane emission reduction goals include targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025 from the 2014 level. SB 1383 also requires that by 2025, 20% of edible food that would otherwise be sent to landfills is redirected to feed people.
To achieve these targets, California’s waste management infrastructure is going to have to process and recycle much higher quantities of organic materials, involving significant investments in additional processing infrastructure. Organic waste is primarily recycled by composting the material, which generates compost that can be used in gardening and agriculture as a soil amendment and engineering purposes for things like slope stabilization. Anaerobic digestion is also widely used to recycle organic wastes. This technology uses bacteria to break down the material in the absence of oxygen and produces biogas, which can be used as fuel, and digestate, which can also be used as a soil amendment.
Though California has made significant progress toward achieving its SLCP reduction goals, more needs to be done. Since the program’s implementation in 2022, 75% of California communities (464 out of 616 jurisdictions) report that they have residential organic waste collection in place. According to CalRecycle, California now has 206 organic waste processing facilities and is building 20 more, and CalRecycle has invested over $220 million in grants and loans for organics processing infrastructure. CalRecycle states that the state needs approximately 50 to 100 new or expanded organics facilities to recycle the additional 20-25 million tons of organic waste that will be collected to meet the SB 1383 organic waste reduction targets.
- Waivers. CalRecycle has recognized that certain local entities face more challenges than others when developing organic waste infrastructure. Specifically, CalRecycle notes that "rural, elevation, and low-population jurisdictions have a small organic waste footprint and face significant challenges to collecting material." In response to these challenges, CalRecycle included waivers for some or all organics collection requirements for jurisdictions if they meet specific criteria:
- Low population waivers: Jurisdictions with a total population less than 7,500 or that disposed less than 5,000 tons of solid waste in 2014 may apply for a waiver from some or all of the regulations for up to five years.
- Rural exemptions: Jurisdictions that meet the statutory definition of a rural jurisdiction are eligible for an exemption from the regulations if the governing body adopts a resolution, as specified. The exemption is valid until December 31, 2026, or until five years after CalRecycle makes a determination that the statewide disposal of organic waste has not been reduced to 50% of the level of disposal during the 2014 calendar year, whichever is later.
- Elevation waivers: A jurisdiction may apply to CalRecycle for a waiver from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper if the entire jurisdiction is, or in census tracts located in unincorporated portions of a county that are, located at or above 4,500 feet elevation.
Unlike rural exemptions, which rely on a statutory definition of “rural jurisdiction,” the low-population and elevation waivers determine eligibility based on census tracts. Census tracts, unlike city or county lines, can split geographic areas in ways that pose logistical challenges for waste management entities. Waste hauling routes are typically based on town or city lines; therefore, waivers based on census tracts can create confusion on the part of collection entities in planning their waste hauling routes and cause residents to lose regularly scheduled organic waste pick up.
Additionally, relying on census tracts to evaluate waiver eligibility sometimes results in sparsely populated rural areas being found ineligible for an exemption because a portion of the census tract is embedded in a densely populated area.
The intent of this bill is to provide local governments with more flexibility to reach SB 1383 targets, and to provide CalRecycle with more flexibility to consider alternative boundaries to census tracts for determining waiver eligibility. While many areas of the state may benefit from this increased flexibility, it could result in more areas being eligible for waivers, which may potentially slow down SB 1383 implementation. This effect may be minimized due to the relatively small quantities of organics that lower population jurisdictions produce.
The author provides the example of Running Springs, an unincorporated jurisdiction in the San Bernardino Mountains. Running Springs is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver, leading to neighbors having to comply with different collection requirements. According to the author, waste management entities have consequently halted regularly scheduled organic waste pickup (such as pine needles, which can pose fire risks). Instead, residents must either drop off their waste at designated sites, or elect for monthly pickup services (6 bags per month at an additional cost, which often times is an insufficient number of bags for the large quantities of pine needles). Allowing CalRecycle to consider other boundaries for elevation waivers, which exempt jurisdictions from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper, may provide more certainty for waste haulers in towns such as Running Springs to plan their routes based on consistent collection requirements.
CalRecycle has issued waivers to 151 jurisdictions from some or all of the organic waste collection requirements, a substantial increase from 54 entities in 2023.
- Author’s statement:
Recognizing that parts of SB 1383 (Lara, 2016) were difficult to implement in mountainous, sparsely-populated, and rural areas of the state, CalRecycle began accepting applications for waivers and exemptions to SB 1383 collection requirements. One of three waivers may be granted to exempt areas from SB 1383 collection requirements for varying periods. However, these waivers are awarded based not on well-established boundaries, like city or county lines, but on census tracts, which are geographic regions defined only for census purposes. The result is that the boundaries of areas eligible for a waiver make little sense for the purposes of disposing of organic waste.
For example, Running Springs, an unincorporated town in the San Bernardino Mountains, is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver. This means that neighbors living across the street from each other have to comply with different collection requirements, which poses logistical challenges for waste management entities.
Due to these challenges, many households in the San Bernardino mountains have lost regularly scheduled organic waste pickup. Given that much of this region is designated as a “Very High Fire Hazard” zone, regular disposal of highly flammable organic waste such as pine needles is of the utmost importance.
To provide more flexibility to local governments in their attempts to reach emission reduction goals, SB 1175 will require CalRecycle to consider alternatives in addition to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of a jurisdiction eligible for a waiver of some or all of the collection requirements of SB 1383.
- Cumulative impacts. A number of bills relating to organic waste management have been introduced this year. While viewed individually, these bills have modest impacts on the state’s efforts to achieve its SLCP reduction goals; however, added together, they may result in further hindering the state’s ability to reduce these critical GHG emissions. As the bills move through the process, the authors should work together and with CalRecycle, stakeholders, and the relevant policy committees to ensure that the bills are complimentary and not duplicative or conflicting and that they do not negatively affect the state’s SLCP reduction efforts. The bills include:
AB 2311 (Bennett) adds edible food recovery activities to the activities eligible for funding from CalRecycle’s grant program that provides financial assistance to promote the development of organic waste infrastructure and waste reduction programs (infrastructure grant program). This bill has been referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 2346 (Lee) authorizes local jurisdictions to be credited for the procurement of recovered organic waste products through contracts with direct service providers, and authorizes jurisdictions to receive procurement credit for investments made in projects that increase organic waste recycling capacity. This bill has been referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 2514 (Aguiar Curry) exempts small counties with a population less than 70,000 from the state’s organic waste reduction requirements. This bill defines pyrolysis as the thermal decomposition of organic material at elevated temperatures in the absence of oxygen. This bill also requires CalRecycle to include hydrogen and pipeline biomethane converted from organic waste as eligible for procurement credit by local jurisdictions and requires CalRecycle to consider life cycle impacts when providing incentives to facilitate progress toward the organic waste reduction targets. This bill has been referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 2902 (Wood) indefinitely extends the exemption for small rural counties with a population below 70,000 from the state’s organic waste reduction requirements, as specified. This bill provides additional compliance flexibility for small counties that produce less than 200,000 tons of solid waste annually. This bill also provides a process by which jurisdictions located at higher altitudes may receive an exemption from CalRecycle where food waste collection bins pose a threat to public health or animal safety due to bears. This bill has been referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
SB 972 (Min) requires CalRecycle, ARB, and the California Environmental Protection Agency to hold at least two joint meetings each calendar year to coordinate the implementation of policies that affect organic waste reduction targets. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 1045 (Blakespear) requires the Office of Planning and Research, in consultation with CalRecycle, to develop a model zoning ordinance that facilitates the siting of compost facilities and requires local jurisdictions, when amending a zoning ordinance to also amend an appropriate zoning ordinance based on the model ordinance. This bill also requires district or regional water boards to act on permits for compost facilities within 30 days. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee and the Assembly Local Government Committee.
SB 1046 (Laird) requires CalRecycle to prepare a program environmental impact report that streamlines the California Environmental Quality Act process for small and medium sized compost facilities. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Riverside County
Rural County Representatives of California
San Bernardino County
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1175 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1175
Author: Ochoa Bogh (R), et al.
Amended: 5/13/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/3/24
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Organic waste: reduction goals: local jurisdictions: waivers
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill directs Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to consider alternatives in addition to census tracts when deciding on the boundaries of low-population and elevation waivers from SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016) organics waste diversion goals.
Senate Floor Amendments of 5/13/24 specify that CalRecycle shall not consider alternatives to census tracts when deciding on the boundaries of low-population and elevation waivers until the department next updates and adopts its organic waste reduction regulations pursuant to SB 1383.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to complete, approve, and implement a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (SLCPs) in the state to achieve, among other things, a reduction in the statewide emissions of methane by 40%. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §39730 et seq.)
- Requires that methane emissions reduction goals include specified targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste by 50% relative to its 2014 level by 2020, and achieve a 75% reduction relative to 2014 by 2025. (HSC §39730.6)
- Requires CalRecycle, in consultation with CARB, to adopt regulations to achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills (SB 1383 regulations). These regulations include:
- Requirements for local jurisdictions to impose requirements on generators and authorize local jurisdictions to impose penalties for noncompliance with those requirements.
- Different levels of requirements and phased timelines for local jurisdictions based on different categorizations for those local jurisdictions.
- A process for local jurisdictions facing penalties for violations of these requirements to obtain relief by submitting a notice of intent to comply that includes an explanation of why they were unable to comply and a description of the proposed actions to come into compliance in a timely manner. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §42652.5)
- Provides waivers for low population, elevation, and rural local jurisdictions. (14.C.C.R. § 18984.12)
- Exempts local jurisdictions in possession of a specified rural exemption from the recovered organic waste product procurement targets until December 31, 2026. Beginning January 1, 2027, CalRecycle may provide these exempted rural jurisdictions an extended recovered organic waste product procurement target schedule. (PRC §42652.5)
- Exempts local jurisdictions from their organic diversion and methane emission reduction targets under SB 1383 if the local jurisdictions (including a city, county, a city and county, or a special district) have fewer than 7,500 people and dispose of less than 5,000 tons of solid waste per year, but did not report their waste tonnage to CalRecycle’s Disposal Reporting System in 2014. (PRC §42652.8)
This bill requires CalRecycle, when it next adopts revised organic waste regulations pursuant to SB 1383, to consider the following alternatives, in addition to census tracts, when deciding the boundaries of submitted low-population and elevation waiver applications for SB 1383 collection requirements: (1) boundaries submitted by counties, cities, or other public agencies; (2) boundaries of incorporated cities; and (3) boundaries of census-designated places.
Background
- Organic Waste and Short-Lived Climate Pollutants. Organic material accounts for more than a third of California’s waste stream: the nearly six million tons of food waste that Californians dispose of alone accounts for approximately 18% of landfilled material, and yard waste accounts for another seven percent of the total waste stream. CalRecycle reports that 2.5 billion meals worth of potentially-donatable food is landfilled in a year. Organic waste is not only a high volume problem in landfills— it also has an oversized impact on climate. According to CalRecycle, methane emissions from decomposing organic waste in landfills account for approximately 20% of the State’s total methane emissions. Methane is a climate “super pollutant” that is 84 times more potent than carbon dioxide over a 20-year timescale.
- Organic waste and methane emission reduction goals (SB 1383 Regulations). In 2016, the Legislature passed SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016), which established emission reduction targets for short-lived climate pollutants including hydrofluorocarbon gasses, anthropogenic black carbon, and methane. SB 1383 required CARB to approve and implement a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy that included a 2030 target of reducing methane emissions by 40% relative to 2014 levels. In order to achieve these reductions in methane emissions, SB 1383 set a goal of reducing landfill disposal of organic waste 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025 from 2014 levels; and to rescue at least 20% of currently disposed of surplus food for meals by 2025.
CalRecycle reports that meeting the goals of SB 1383 would be equivalent to removing 3 million cars worth of climate pollution. CalRecycle was given the authority to adopt regulations that would achieve these organic waste reduction requirements. After significant public engagement and workshopping over the course of several years, in 2020, CalRecycle adopted its regulations for Short-lived Climate Pollutants (SB 1383 Regulations). - Progress towards SB 1383 goals. The ambitious waste diversion goals established in 1383 have necessitated significant changes to California’s organic waste management infrastructure. Though California has made significant progress towards achieving the goals laid out in SB 1383, there is still some way to go; according to a report by the Little Hoover Commission in 2023, the state failed to reach its 2020 targets and is not on track to reach its 2025 goals. However, since its January 2022 implementation, 75% of California communities (464 out of 616 jurisdictions) report that they have residential organic waste collection in place. According to CalRecycle, California now has 206 organic waste processing facilities and is building 20 more. CalRecycle reports having invested over $220 million in grants and loans for SB 1383 infrastructure.
- Existing SB 1383 waivers. In developing SB 1383 regulations, CalRecycle recognized that certain local entities face more significant problems in developing organic waste infrastructure than others and specifically that “rural, elevation, and low-population jurisdictions have a small organic waste footprint and face significant challenges to collecting material.” As a result, CalRecycle developed in regulations a set of SB 1383 waivers for some or all organics collection requirements for jurisdictions if they meet specific criteria:
- Low-population waivers: A jurisdiction is eligible to apply for a low-population waiver if it disposed less than 5,000 tons of solid waste in 2014 and has a total population of less than 7,500 people. A jurisdiction may also be eligible for this waiver if the census tract has a population density of less than 75 people per square mile and are located in unincorporated portions of the county. Under this waiver, jurisdictions are exempted from some or all of organics waste diversion goals of SB 1383 regulations.
- Rural exemptions: A jurisdiction is eligible to apply for a rural exemption if it is located entirely within 1 or more rural counties, defined as less than 70,000 people. The jurisdiction must also show evidence to CalRecycle as to the purpose of and need for the exemption. Under this exemption, a jurisdiction does not have to comply with the organic waste collection requirements of SB 1383 regulations.
- Elevation waivers: A jurisdiction may apply for an elevation waiver if some or all of the jurisdiction is located at or above an elevation of 4,500 feet. Under this waiver, the jurisdiction is only exempt from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper.
- Jurisdictions can also apply for disaster and emergency waivers, and non-local entities and local education agencies that meet specific criteria can also apply.
As of the writing of this analysis, CalRecycle reports that it has issued waivers to 151 jurisdictions from some or all of the organic waste collection requirements, a substantial increase from 54 entities in 2023.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Recognizing that parts of SB 1383 (Lara, 2016) were difficult to implement in mountainous, sparsely-populated, and rural areas of the state, CalRecycle began accepting applications for waivers and exemptions to SB 1383 collection requirements. One of three waivers may be granted to exempt areas from SB 1383 collection requirements for varying periods. However, these waivers are awarded based not on well-established boundaries, like city or county lines, but on census tracts, which are geographic regions defined only for census purposes. The result is that the boundaries of areas eligible for a waiver make little sense for the purposes of disposing of organic waste.
“For example, Running Springs, an unincorporated town in the San Bernardino Mountains, is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver. This means that neighbors living across the street from each other have to comply with different collection requirements, which poses logistical challenges for waste management entities. Due to these challenges, many households in the San Bernardino Mountains have lost regularly scheduled organic waste pickup. Given that much of this region is designated as a “Very High Fire Hazard” zone, regular disposal of highly flammable organic waste such as pine needles is of the utmost importance.
“To provide more flexibility to local governments in their attempts to reach emission reduction goals, SB 1175 will require CalRecycle to consider alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of a jurisdiction eligible for a waiver of some or all of the collection requirements of SB 1383.”
- Specificity of census tracts. Unlike the rural waiver, which relies on a definition of “rural jurisdiction” (defined in statute as a “jurisdiction that is located entirely within 1 or more rural counties [less than 70,000 people]”), the low-population and elevation waivers specify eligibility based solely on census tracts. Census tracts, unlike city or county lines, can split geographic areas in ways that pose logistical challenges for waste management entities. Because waste hauling routes are typically based on town or city lines, waivers based on census tracts can create confusion on the part of collection entities in planning their waste hauling routes and cause residents to lose regularly scheduled organic waste pick up. Having certainty about which residents fall under the same collection requirements could help haulers plan more regular routes.
Additionally, relying solely on census tracts to evaluate waiver eligibility sometimes means that some sparsely populated rural areas are ineligible for an exemption because a portion of the census tract is embedded in a densely populated city or census designated place, such as in the case of areas within Nevada County. The goal of this bill is to provide local governments more flexibility in reaching the SB 1383 targets and CalRecycle more flexibility to consider alternative boundaries in addition to census tracts for determining waiver eligibility.
- The curious case of Running Springs. The criteria for SB 1383 waivers currently defined in regulation are intended to aid local jurisdictions with disproportionate challenges to collecting organic material. However, in the case of Running Springs, an unincorporated jurisdiction in the San Bernardino Mountains, the waivers may have inadvertently created more challenges than they mitigated. Running Springs is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver, leading to neighbors having to comply with different collection requirements. According to information provided by the author, waste management entities have consequently halted regularly scheduled organic waste pickup (such as pine needles, which can pose fire risks). Instead, residents must either drop off their waste at designated sites, or elect for monthly pickup services (six bags per month at an additional cost, which often times is an insufficient number of bags for the large quantities of pine needles). Allowing CalRecycle to consider other boundaries for elevation waivers, which exempt jurisdictions from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper, may provide more certainty for waste haulers in towns such as Running Springs to plan their routes based on a unified collection bin requirement.
- Waivers, delays, extensions, oh my. The ambitious goals of SB 1383 were established as a part of the state’s statewide effort to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants. However, local jurisdictions have since raised concerns about the challenges of implementing various aspects of the bill, and specifically the implementation timelines. Even though the goals under SB 1383 had been known since 2016, the final draft of regulations was not adopted until November 2020. Included in those regulations were waivers for rural, low-population, and high-elevation jurisdictions. In addition to these set of waivers, there have been several legislative actions to delay SB 1383 implementation or waive certain jurisdictions; SB 619 (Laird, Chapter 508, Statutes of 2021) allowed local jurisdictions to submit a notice of intent to comply with CalRecycle in order to be eligible for relief from penalties for the 2022 calendar year; AB 1985 (R. Rivas, Chapter 344, Statutes of 2022) provided an exemption for rural jurisdictions and authorized CalRecycle to create a delayed and ramping enforcement timeline for penalties for rural local jurisdictions to meet their organic waste procurement requirements; and SB 613 (Seyarto, Chapter 878, Statutes of 2023) added more jurisdictions to the low population waiver by including jurisdictions that did not report their waste tonnage to CalRecycle’s Disposal Reporting System.
In the 2024 legislative session, there are currently ten bills (including this bill) seeking to amend, streamline, or extend various requirements of CalRecycle’s regulations for SB 1383. Viewing these bills not in isolation, but as a part of the SB 1383 universe, is critical, as they all present the question of whether the Legislature seeks to legislate additional flexibility into the regulations. SB 1383 was initially passed as an ambitious statement that California was going to take significant steps in tackling its climate goals; it is worth considering how continued legislation impacting (and in some cases, curtailing) its implementation reflects on the strength of that statement.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 613 (Seyarto, Chapter 878, Statutes of 2023) created a waiver for low-population local jurisdictions and exempts those jurisdictions from SB 1383 organics waste diversion goals until December 31, 2028, if they do not already have another waiver.
AB 1985 (R. Rivas, Chapter 344, Statutes of 2022) provided an exemption for rural jurisdictions and authorizes CalRecycle to create a delayed and ramping enforcement timeline for penalties for rural local jurisdictions to meet their organic waste procurement targets.
SB 619 (Laird, Chapter 508, Statutes of 2022) pushed back the timeline for penalties for local jurisdictions that have not complied with SB 1383 requirements.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/14/24)
League of California Cities
Rural County Representatives of California
San Bernardino County
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/14/24)
None Received
Prepared by: Holly Rudel / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
5/14/24 15:06:52
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1175 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1175
Author: Ochoa Bogh (R), et al.
Amended: 4/8/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/3/24
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Organic waste: reduction goals: local jurisdictions: waivers
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill directs Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to consider alternatives in addition to census tracts when deciding on the boundaries of low-population and elevation waivers from SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016) organics waste diversion goals.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to complete, approve, and implement a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (SLCPs) in the state to achieve, among other things, a reduction in the statewide emissions of methane by 40%. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §39730 et seq.)
- Requires that methane emissions reduction goals include specified targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste by 50% relative to its 2014 level by 2020, and achieve a 75% reduction relative to 2014 by 2025. (HSC §39730.6)
- Requires CalRecycle, in consultation with CARB, to adopt regulations to achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills (SB 1383 regulations). These regulations include:
- Requirements for local jurisdictions to impose requirements on generators and authorize local jurisdictions to impose penalties for noncompliance with those requirements.
- Different levels of requirements and phased timelines for local jurisdictions based on different categorizations for those local jurisdictions.
- A process for local jurisdictions facing penalties for violations of these requirements to obtain relief by submitting a notice of intent to comply that includes an explanation of why they were unable to comply and a description of the proposed actions to come into compliance in a timely manner. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §42652.5)
- Provides waivers for low population, elevation, and rural local jurisdictions. (14.C.C.R. § 18984.12)
- Exempts local jurisdictions in possession of a specified rural exemption from the recovered organic waste product procurement targets until December 31, 2026. Beginning January 1, 2027, CalRecycle may provide these exempted rural jurisdictions an extended recovered organic waste product procurement target schedule. (PRC §42652.5)
- Exempts local jurisdictions from their organic diversion and methane emission reduction targets under SB 1383 if the local jurisdictions (including a city, county, a city and county, or a special district) have fewer than 7,500 people and dispose of less than 5,000 tons of solid waste per year, but did not report their waste tonnage to CalRecycle’s Disposal Reporting System in 2014. (PRC §42652.8)
This bill authorizes CalRecycle to consider the following alternatives, in addition to census tracts, when deciding the boundaries of submitted low-population and elevation waiver applications for SB 1383 collection requirements:
- Boundaries submitted by counties, cities, or other public agencies;
- Boundaries of incorporated cities; and
- Boundaries of census-designated places.
Background
- Organic Waste and Short-Lived Climate Pollutants. Organic material accounts for more than a third of California’s waste stream: the nearly six million tons of food waste that Californians dispose of alone accounts for approximately 18% of landfilled material, and yard waste accounts for another seven percent of the total waste stream. CalRecycle reports that 2.5 billion meals worth of potentially-donatable food is landfilled in a year. Organic waste is not only a high volume problem in landfills— it also has an oversized impact on climate. According to CalRecycle, methane emissions from decomposing organic waste in landfills account for approximately 20% of the State’s total methane emissions. Methane is a climate “super pollutant” that is 84 times more potent than carbon dioxide over a 20-year timescale.
- Organic waste and methane emission reduction goals (SB 1383 Regulations). In 2016, the Legislature passed SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016), which established emission reduction targets for short-lived climate pollutants including hydrofluorocarbon gasses, anthropogenic black carbon, and methane. SB 1383 required CARB to approve and implement a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy that included a 2030 target of reducing methane emissions by 40% relative to 2014 levels. In order to achieve these reductions in methane emissions, SB 1383 set a goal of reducing landfill disposal of organic waste 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025 from 2014 levels; and to rescue at least 20% of currently disposed of surplus food for meals by 2025.
CalRecycle reports that meeting the goals of SB 1383 would be equivalent to removing 3 million cars worth of climate pollution. CalRecycle was given the authority to adopt regulations that would achieve these organic waste reduction requirements. After significant public engagement and workshopping over the course of several years, in 2020, CalRecycle adopted its regulations for Short-lived Climate Pollutants (SB 1383 Regulations). - Progress towards SB 1383 goals. The ambitious waste diversion goals established in 1383 have necessitated significant changes to California’s organic waste management infrastructure. Though California has made significant progress towards achieving the goals laid out in SB 1383, there is still some way to go; according to a report by the Little Hoover Commission in 2023, the state failed to reach its 2020 targets and is not on track to reach its 2025 goals. However, since its January 2022 implementation, 75% of California communities (464 out of 616 jurisdictions) report that they have residential organic waste collection in place. According to CalRecycle, California now has 206 organic waste processing facilities and is building 20 more. CalRecycle reports having invested over $220 million in grants and loans for SB 1383 infrastructure.
- Existing SB 1383 waivers. In developing SB 1383 regulations, CalRecycle recognized that certain local entities face more significant problems in developing organic waste infrastructure than others and specifically that “rural, elevation, and low-population jurisdictions have a small organic waste footprint and face significant challenges to collecting material.” As a result, CalRecycle developed in regulations a set of SB 1383 waivers for some or all organics collection requirements for jurisdictions if they meet specific criteria:
- Low-population waivers: A jurisdiction is eligible to apply for a low-population waiver if it disposed less than 5,000 tons of solid waste in 2014 and has a total population of less than 7,500 people. A jurisdiction may also be eligible for this waiver if the census tract has a population density of less than 75 people per square mile and are located in unincorporated portions of the county. Under this waiver, jurisdictions are exempted from some or all of organics waste diversion goals of SB 1383 regulations.
- Rural exemptions: A jurisdiction is eligible to apply for a rural exemption if it is located entirely within 1 or more rural counties, defined as less than 70,000 people. The jurisdiction must also show evidence to CalRecycle as to the purpose of and need for the exemption. Under this exemption, a jurisdiction does not have to comply with the organic waste collection requirements of SB 1383 regulations.
- Elevation waivers: A jurisdiction may apply for an elevation waiver if some or all of the jurisdiction is located at or above an elevation of 4,500 feet. Under this waiver, the jurisdiction is only exempt from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper.
- Jurisdictions can also apply for disaster and emergency waivers, and non-local entities and local education agencies that meet specific criteria can also apply.
As of the writing of this analysis, CalRecycle reports that it has issued waivers to 151 jurisdictions from some or all of the organic waste collection requirements, a substantial increase from 54 entities in 2023.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Recognizing that parts of SB 1383 (Lara, 2016) were difficult to implement in mountainous, sparsely-populated, and rural areas of the state, CalRecycle began accepting applications for waivers and exemptions to SB 1383 collection requirements. One of three waivers may be granted to exempt areas from SB 1383 collection requirements for varying periods. However, these waivers are awarded based not on well-established boundaries, like city or county lines, but on census tracts, which are geographic regions defined only for census purposes. The result is that the boundaries of areas eligible for a waiver make little sense for the purposes of disposing of organic waste.
“For example, Running Springs, an unincorporated town in the San Bernardino Mountains, is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver. This means that neighbors living across the street from each other have to comply with different collection requirements, which poses logistical challenges for waste management entities. Due to these challenges, many households in the San Bernardino Mountains have lost regularly scheduled organic waste pickup. Given that much of this region is designated as a “Very High Fire Hazard” zone, regular disposal of highly flammable organic waste such as pine needles is of the utmost importance.
“To provide more flexibility to local governments in their attempts to reach emission reduction goals, SB 1175 will require CalRecycle to consider alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of a jurisdiction eligible for a waiver of some or all of the collection requirements of SB 1383.”
- Specificity of census tracts. Unlike the rural waiver, which relies on a definition of “rural jurisdiction” (defined in statute as a “jurisdiction that is located entirely within 1 or more rural counties [less than 70,000 people]”), the low-population and elevation waivers specify eligibility based solely on census tracts. Census tracts, unlike city or county lines, can split geographic areas in ways that pose logistical challenges for waste management entities. Because waste hauling routes are typically based on town or city lines, waivers based on census tracts can create confusion on the part of collection entities in planning their waste hauling routes and cause residents to lose regularly scheduled organic waste pick up. Having certainty about which residents fall under the same collection requirements could help haulers plan more regular routes.
Additionally, relying solely on census tracts to evaluate waiver eligibility sometimes means that some sparsely populated rural areas are ineligible for an exemption because a portion of the census tract is embedded in a densely populated city or census designated place, such as in the case of areas within Nevada County. The goal of this bill is to provide local governments more flexibility in reaching the SB 1383 targets and CalRecycle more flexibility to consider alternative boundaries in addition to census tracts for determining waiver eligibility. Of note, this flexibility could result in more areas being eligible for waivers or potentially slow down SB 1383 implementation.
- The curious case of Running Springs. The criteria for SB 1383 waivers currently defined in regulation are intended to aid local jurisdictions with disproportionate challenges to collecting organic material. However, in the case of Running Springs, an unincorporated jurisdiction in the San Bernardino Mountains, the waivers may have inadvertently created more challenges than they mitigated. Running Springs is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver, leading to neighbors having to comply with different collection requirements. According to information provided by the author, waste management entities have consequently halted regularly scheduled organic waste pickup (such as pine needles, which can pose fire risks). Instead, residents must either drop off their waste at designated sites, or elect for monthly pickup services (six bags per month at an additional cost, which often times is an insufficient number of bags for the large quantities of pine needles). Allowing CalRecycle to consider other boundaries for elevation waivers, which exempt jurisdictions from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper, may provide more certainty for waste haulers in towns such as Running Springs to plan their routes based on a unified collection bin requirement.
- Waivers, delays, extensions, oh my. The ambitious goals of SB 1383 were established as a part of the state’s statewide effort to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants. However, local jurisdictions have since raised concerns about the challenges of implementing various aspects of the bill, and specifically the implementation timelines. Even though the goals under SB 1383 had been known since 2016, the final draft of regulations was not adopted until November 2020. Included in those regulations were waivers for rural, low-population, and high-elevation jurisdictions. In addition to these set of waivers, there have been several legislative actions to delay SB 1383 implementation or waive certain jurisdictions; SB 619 (Laird, Chapter 508, Statutes of 2021) allowed local jurisdictions to submit a notice of intent to comply with CalRecycle in order to be eligible for relief from penalties for the 2022 calendar year; AB 1985 (R. Rivas, Chapter 344, Statutes of 2022) provided an exemption for rural jurisdictions and authorized CalRecycle to create a delayed and ramping enforcement timeline for penalties for rural local jurisdictions to meet their organic waste procurement requirements; and SB 613 (Seyarto, Chapter 878, Statutes of 2023) added more jurisdictions to the low population waiver by including jurisdictions that did not report their waste tonnage to CalRecycle’s Disposal Reporting System.
In the 2024 legislative session, there are currently ten bills (including this bill) seeking to amend, streamline, or extend various requirements of CalRecycle’s regulations for SB 1383. Viewing these bills not in isolation, but as a part of the SB 1383 universe, is critical, as they all present the question of whether the Legislature seeks to legislate additional flexibility into the regulations. SB 1383 was initially passed as an ambitious statement that California was going to take significant steps in tackling its climate goals; it is worth considering how continued legislation impacting (and in some cases, curtailing) its implementation reflects on the strength of that statement.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 613 (Seyarto, Chapter 878, Statutes of 2023) created a waiver for low-population local jurisdictions and exempts those jurisdictions from SB 1383 organics waste diversion goals until December 31, 2028, if they do not already have another waiver.
AB 1985 (R. Rivas, Chapter 344, Statutes of 2022) provided an exemption for rural jurisdictions and authorizes CalRecycle to create a delayed and ramping enforcement timeline for penalties for rural local jurisdictions to meet their organic waste procurement targets.
SB 619 (Laird, Chapter 508, Statutes of 2022) pushed back the timeline for penalties for local jurisdictions that have not complied with SB 1383 requirements.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 4/23/24)
League of California Cities
Rural County Representatives of California
San Bernardino County
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/23/24)
Prepared by: Holly Rudel / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
4/24/24 11:16:21
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1175
Author: | Ochoa Bogh | ||
Version: | 2/14/2024 | Hearing Date: | 4/3/2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Holly Rudel | ||
SUBJECT: Organic waste: reduction goals: local jurisdictions: waivers
DIGEST: Directs CalRecycle to consider alternatives in addition to census tracts when deciding on the boundaries of low-population and elevation waivers from SB 1383 organics waste diversion goals. Extends low-population waivers to be valid for 10-years.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to complete, approve, and implement a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (SLCPs) in the state to achieve, among other things, a reduction in the statewide emissions of methane by 40%. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §39730 et seq.)
- Requires that methane emissions reduction goals include specified targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste by 50% relative to its 2014 level by 2020, and achieve a 75% reduction relative to 2014 by 2025. (HSC §39730.6)
- Requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle), in consultation with CARB, to adopt regulations to achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills (SB 1383 regulations). These regulations include:
- Requirements for local jurisdictions to impose requirements on generators and authorize local jurisdictions to impose penalties for noncompliance with those requirements.
- Different levels of requirements and phased timelines for local jurisdictions based on different categorizations for those local jurisdictions.
- A process for local jurisdictions facing penalties for violations of these requirements to obtain relief by submitting a notice of intent to comply that includes an explanation of why they were unable to comply and a description of the proposed actions to come into compliance in a timely manner. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §42652.5)
- Provides waivers for low population, elevation, and rural local jurisdictions. (14.C.C.R. § 18984.12)
- Exempts local jurisdictions in possession of a specified rural exemption from the recovered organic waste product procurement targets until December 31, 2026. Beginning January 1, 2027, CalRecycle may provide these exempted rural jurisdictions an extended recovered organic waste product procurement target schedule. (PRC §42652.5)
- Exempts local jurisdictions from their organic diversion and methane emission reduction targets under SB 1383 if the local jurisdictions (including a city, county, a city and county, or a special district) have fewer than 7,500 people and dispose of less than 5,000 tons of solid waste per year, but did not report their waste tonnage to CalRecycle’s Disposal Reporting System in 2014. (PRC §42652.8)
This bill:
- Authorizes CalRecycle to consider the following alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of submitted low-population and elevation waiver applications for SB 1383 collection requirements:
- Boundaries submitted by counties, cities, or other public agencies;
- Boundaries of incorporated cities; and
- Boundaries of census-designated places.
- Stipulates that low population waivers issued by CalRecycle shall be valid for a period of 10 years.
Background
- Organic Waste and Short-Lived Climate Pollutants. Organic material accounts for more than a third of California’s waste stream: the nearly 6 million tons of food waste that Californians dispose of alone accounts for approximately 18% of landfilled material, and yard waste accounts for another seven percent of the total waste stream. CalRecycle reports that 2.5 billion meals worth of potentially-donatable food is landfilled in a year. Organic waste is not only a high volume problem in landfills— it also has an oversized impact on climate. According to CalRecycle, methane emissions from decomposing organic waste in landfills account for approximately 20% of the State’s total methane emissions. Methane is a climate “super pollutant” that is 84 times more potent than carbon dioxide over a 20-year timescale.
- Organic waste and methane emission reduction goals (SB 1383 Regulations). In 2016, the Legislature passed SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016), which established emission reduction targets for short-lived climate pollutants including hydrofluorocarbon gasses, anthropogenic black carbon, and methane. SB 1383 required CARB to approve and implement a comprehensive short-lived climate pollutant strategy that included a 2030 target of reducing methane emissions by 40% relative to 2014 levels. In order to achieve these reductions in methane emissions, SB 1383 set a goal of reducing landfill disposal of organic waste 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025 from 2014 levels; and to rescue at least 20% of currently disposed of surplus food for meals by 2025.
CalRecycle reports that meeting the goals of SB 1383 would be equivalent to removing 3 million cars worth of climate pollution. CalRecycle was given the authority to adopt regulations that would achieve these organic waste reduction requirements. After significant public engagement and workshopping over the course of several years, in 2020, CalRecycle adopted its regulations for Short-lived Climate Pollutants (SB 1383 Regulations). - Progress towards SB 1383 goals. The ambitious waste diversion goals established in 1383 have necessitated significant changes to California’s organic waste management infrastructure. Though California has made significant progress towards achieving the goals laid out in SB 1383, there is still some way to go; according to a report by the Little Hoover Commission in 2023, the state failed to reach its 2020 targets and is not on track to reach its 2025 goals. However, since its January 2022 implementation, 75% of California communities (464 out of 616 jurisdictions) report that they have residential organic waste collection in place. According to CalRecycle, California now has 206 organic waste processing facilities and is building 20 more. CalRecycle reports having invested over $220 million in grants and loans for SB 1383 infrastructure.
- Existing SB 1383 waivers. In developing SB 1383 regulations, CalRecycle recognized that certain local entities face more significant problems in developing organic waste infrastructure than others and specifically that “rural, elevation, and low-population jurisdictions have a small organic waste footprint and face significant challenges to collecting material.” As a result, CalRecycle developed in regulations a set of SB 1383 waivers for some or all organics collection requirements for jurisdictions if they meet specific criteria:
- Low-population waivers: A jurisdiction is eligible to apply for a low-population waiver if it disposed less than 5,000 tons of solid waste in 2014 and has a total population of less than 7,500 people. A jurisdiction may also be eligible for this waiver if the census tract has a population density of less than 75 people per square mile and are located in unincorporated portions of the county. Under this waiver, jurisdictions are exempted from some or all of organics waste diversion goals of SB 1383 regulations.
- Rural exemptions: A jurisdiction is eligible to apply for a rural exemption if it is located entirely within 1 or more rural counties, defined as less than 70,000 people. The jurisdiction must also show evidence to CalRecycle as to the purpose of and need for the exemption. Under this exemption, a jurisdiction does not have to comply with the organic waste collection requirements of SB 1383 regulations.
- Elevation waivers: A jurisdiction may apply for an elevation waiver if some or all of the jurisdiction is located at or above an elevation of 4,500 feet. Under this waiver, the jurisdiction is only exempt from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper.
- Jurisdictions can also apply for disaster and emergency waivers, and non-local entities and local education agencies that meet specific criteria can also apply.
As of the writing of this analysis, CalRecycle reports that it has issued waivers to 151 jurisdictions from some or all of the organic waste collection requirements, a substantial increase from 54 entities in 2023.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Recognizing that parts of SB 1383 (Lara, 2016) were difficult to implement in mountainous, sparsely-populated, and rural areas of the state, CalRecycle began accepting applications for waivers and exemptions to SB 1383 collection requirements. One of three waivers may be granted to exempt areas from SB 1383 collection requirements for varying periods. However, these waivers are awarded based not on well-established boundaries, like city or county lines, but on census tracts, which are geographic regions defined only for census purposes. The result is that the boundaries of areas eligible for a waiver make little sense for the purposes of disposing of organic waste.
“For example, Running Springs, an unincorporated town in the San Bernardino Mountains, is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver. This means that neighbors living across the street from each other have to comply with different collection requirements, which poses logistical challenges for waste management entities. Due to these challenges, many households in the San Bernardino Mountains have lost regularly scheduled organic waste pickup. Given that much of this region is designated as a “Very High Fire Hazard” zone, regular disposal of highly flammable organic waste such as pine needles is of the utmost importance.
“To provide more flexibility to local governments in their attempts to reach emission reduction goals, SB 1175 will require CalRecycle to consider alternatives to census tracts when deciding the boundaries of a jurisdiction eligible for a waiver of some or all of the collection requirements of SB 1383.”
- Specificity of census tracts. Unlike the rural waiver, which relies on a definition of “rural jurisdiction” (defined in statute as a “jurisdiction that is located entirely within 1 or more rural counties [less than 70,000 people]”), the low-population and elevation waivers specify eligibility based solely on census tracts. Census tracts, unlike city or county lines, can split geographic areas in ways that pose logistical challenges for waste management entities. Because waste hauling routes are typically based on town or city lines, waivers based on census tracts can create confusion on the part of collection entities in planning their waste hauling routes and cause residents to lose regularly scheduled organic waste pick up. Having certainty about which residents fall under the same collection requirements could help haulers plan more regular routes.
Additionally, relying solely on census tracts to evaluate waiver eligibility sometimes means that some sparsely populated rural areas are ineligible for an exemption because a portion of the census tract is embedded in a densely populated city or census designated place, such as in the case of areas within Nevada County. The goal of this bill is to provide local governments more flexibility in reaching the SB 1383 targets and CalRecycle more flexibility to consider alternative boundaries in addition to census tracts for determining waiver eligibility. Of note, this flexibility could result in more areas being eligible for waivers or potentially slow down SB 1383 implementation.
Given that CalRecycle spent significant time developing their regulations and the fact that several waivers have already been issued utilizing census tracts, it may be important to clarify that the department may consider alternative boundaries in addition to, and not instead of, census tracts.
The committee may wish to consider amending the bill to clarify that the alternative boundaries may be considered in addition to census tracts.
- The curious case of Running Springs. The criteria for SB 1383 waivers currently defined in regulation are intended to aid local jurisdictions with disproportionate challenges to collecting organic material. However, in the case of Running Springs, an unincorporated jurisdiction in the San Bernardino Mountains, the waivers may have inadvertently created more challenges than they mitigated. Running Springs is split between two census tracts: one with a low-population waiver and one with an elevation waiver, leading to neighbors having to comply with different collection requirements. According to information provided by the author, waste management entities have consequently halted regularly scheduled organic waste pickup (such as pine needles, which can pose fire risks). Instead, residents must either drop off their waste at designated sites, or elect for monthly pickup services (6 bags per month at an additional cost, which often times is an insufficient number of bags for the large quantities of pine needles). Allowing CalRecycle to consider other boundaries for elevation waivers, which exempt jurisdictions from the requirement to separate and recover food waste and food-soiled paper, may provide more certainty for waste haulers in towns such as Running Springs to plan their routes based on a unified collection bin requirement.
- Waivers, delays, extensions, oh my. The ambitious goals of SB 1383 were established as a part of the state’s statewide effort to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants. However, local jurisdictions have since raised concerns about the challenges of implementing various aspects of the bill, and specifically the implementation timelines. Even though the goals under SB 1383 had been known since 2016, the final draft of regulations was not adopted until November 2020. Included in those regulations were waivers for rural, low-population, and high-elevation jurisdictions (see “Existing Law” section). In addition to these set of waivers, there have been several legislative actions to delay SB 1383 implementation or waive certain jurisdictions; SB 619 (Laird, Chapter 508, Statutes of 2021) allowed local jurisdictions to submit a notice of intent to comply with CalRecycle in order to be eligible for relief from penalties for the 2022 calendar year; AB 1985 (R. Rivas, Chapter 344, Statutes of 2022) provided an exemption for rural jurisdictions and authorized CalRecycle to create a delayed and ramping enforcement timeline for penalties for rural local jurisdictions to meet their organic waste procurement requirements; and SB 613 (Seyarto, Chapter 878, Statutes of 2023) added more jurisdictions to the low population waiver by including jurisdictions that did not report their waste tonnage to CalRecycle’s Disposal Reporting System. In the 2024 legislative session, there are currently eleven bills (including SB 1175) seeking to amend, streamline, or extend various requirements of CalRecycle’s regulations for SB 1383 (see Related Legislation section). Viewing these bills not in isolation, but as a part of the SB 1383 universe, is critical, as they all present the question of whether the Legislature seeks to legislate additional flexibility into the regulations, flexibility that could lead to regulatory uncertainty and potentially hinder implementation of SB 1383 while local agencies wait to see whether they are exempt. SB 1383 was initially passed as an ambitious statement that California was going to take significant steps in tackling its climate goals; it is worth considering how continued legislation impacting (and in some cases, curtailing) its implementation reflects on the strength of that statement.
As described above, there have been several delays to the implementation of SB 1383. This bill would further delay implementation by increasing the low-population waiver exemption from five years to ten, potentially giving some jurisdictions nearly twenty years from when SB 1383 was passed to implement its requirements.
To curtail this pattern of kicking the can down the road, the committee may wish to consider amending the bill to remove the provision extending waiver validity to 10-years.
- Committee amendments: Staff recommends the committee adopt the suggested amendments bolded in (2) and (4) above.
Related Legislation
A number of bills relating to organic waste management have been introduced this year. As the bills move through the process, the authors should work together and with CalRecycle, stakeholders, and the relevant policy committees to ensure that the bills are complimentary and not duplicative or conflicting. The bills include:
AB 2311 (Bennett) adds edible food recovery activities to the activities eligible for funding from the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery’s (CalRecycle) grant program that provides financial assistance to promote the development of organic waste infrastructure and waste reduction programs (infrastructure grant program). This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2346 (Lee) authorizes local jurisdictions to be credited for the procurement of recovered organic waste products through contracts with direct service providers, and authorizes jurisdictions to receive procurement credit for investments made in projects that increase organic waste recycling capacity. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2514 (Aguiar Curry) exempts small counties with a population under 70,000 from the state’s organic waste reduction requirements. This bill defines pyrolysis as the thermal decomposition of organic material at elevated temperatures in the absence of oxygen. This bill also requires CalRecycle to include hydrogen and pipeline biomethane converted from organic waste as eligible for procurement credit by local jurisdictions and requires CalRecycle to consider “life-cycle carbon intensity” when providing incentives to facilitate progress toward the organic waste reduction targets. Finally, this bill requires CalRecycle, in consultation with ARB, to report to the Legislature on the amount of methane emissions leaked from “different recovered organic waste product procurement target compliance pathways” and measures to reduce methane leakage. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2577 (Irwin) requires the regulations adopted by CalRecycle to meet the state’s edible food recovery goal to include product labeling requirements that reduce food waste. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2658 (Bains) exempts food processing establishments that do not “divert organic waste to landfills” from the state’s organic waste diversion targets. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2902 (Wood) indefinitely extends the exemption for small rural counties with a population below 70,000 from the state’s organic waste reduction requirements, as specified. This bill provides additional compliance flexibility for small counties that produce less than 200,000 tons of solid waste annually. This bill also provides a process by which jurisdictions located at higher altitudes may receive an exemption from CalRecycle where food waste collection bins pose a threat to public health or animal safety due to bears. This bill has been referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 1045 (Blakespear) requires the Office of Planning and Research, in consultation with CalRecycle, to develop a model zoning ordinance that facilitates the siting of compost facilities and requires local jurisdictions, when amending a zoning ordinance to also amend an appropriate zoning ordinance based on the model ordinance. This bill also requires district or regional water boards to act on permits for compost facilities within 30 days. This bill has been referred to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
SB 972 (Min) requires CalRecycle, ARB, and the California Environmental Protection Agency to hold at least two joint meetings each calendar year to coordinate the implementation of policies that affect organic waste reduction targets. This bill is scheduled to be heard in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on April 24, 2024.
SB 1046 (Laird) requires CalRecycle to prepare a program environmental impact report that streamlines the California Environmental Quality Act process for small and medium sized compost facilities. This bill passed out of Senate Environmental Quality Committee and has been referred to Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 1232 (Grove) exempts a portion of a county from the prescribed organic waste collection requirements if a county proposed a fee for the collection of organic waste in that portion of the county and, as a result of successful protest vote, did not impose the fee. This bill is scheduled to be heard in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on April 17, 2024.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
San Bernardino County
OPPOSITION:
Californians Against Waste
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the Rural County Representatives of California, “Senate Bill 1175 simply provides CalRecycle and local governments with greater flexibility to tailor SB 1383 low population waivers to meet specific local situations. SB 1383 requires the state to reduce landfill disposal of organic waste 75 percent below 2014 levels by 2025. CalRecycle’s implementing regulations are generally tailored to dovetail within the solid waste collection system that exists in urban areas, but they are sometimes poorly suited to deal with the needs and challenges of lower-population and rural areas and afford very little flexibility for those situations. As a result, the greatest implementation challenges and highest anticipated rate increases will occur in rural and sparsely populated areas of the state.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to Californians Against Waste, “
The success of SB 1383 is crucial to the state’s climate efforts and the bill has already served as a model for other states around the country. In developing the regulations to implement SB 1383, CalRecycle went through an extensive stakeholder process, with over a dozen public meetings around the state and countless meetings with individual stakeholders. In response to stakeholder feedback, this process resulted in a nuanced regulation that thoughtfully established exemptions that went beyond the broad-brush population cutoffs used in previous solid waste legislation. SB 1175 would direct CalRecycle to re-evaluate these criteria based on different geographic criteria.”
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):