SB 12: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: emissions limit.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2022-12-05
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of emissions of greenhouse gases. Under the act, the state board is required to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by no later than December 31, 2030. Under the act, a violation of a rule, regulation, order, emission limitation, emission reduction measure, or other measure adopted by the state board under the act is a crime.
This bill instead would require the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 55% below the 1990 level by no later than December 31, 2030. By expanding the scope of a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
In adopting rules and regulations to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective greenhouse gas emissions reductions authorized by this division, the state board shall ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40 55 percent below the statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit no later than December 31, 2030.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 18, 2023 | May 18 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 16, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 15, 2023 | May 15 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 5, 2023 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| May 2, 2023 | May 8 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 1, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | April 10 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 28, 2023 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Mar 15, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 352.) (March 15). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 10, 2023 | Set for hearing March 15. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Dec 6, 2022 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 5. |
| Dec 5, 2022 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 15, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 15, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 350 Bay Area Action | ** Support | |
| 350 Conejo - San Fernando Valley | ** Support | |
| 350 Humboldt | ** Support | |
| 350 Sacramento | ** Support | |
| 350 South Bay Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| 350 Southland Legislative Alliance | ** Support | |
| 350 Ventura County Climate Hub | ** Support | |
| Breast Cancer Action | ** Support | |
| California Business Roundtable | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Climate Action | ** Support | |
| California Climate Voters | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| California Independent Petroleum Association | ** Against | |
| California Interfaith Power and Light | ** Support | |
| California Manufacturers & Technology Association | ** Against | |
| California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice | ** Support | |
| California Restaurant Association | ** Against | |
| California Trucking Association | ** Against | |
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Support | |
| Center for Climate Change and Health | ** Support | |
| Ceres | ** Support | |
| Clean Coalition | ** Support | |
| Climate Action California | ** Support | |
| Climate Action Campaign | ** Support | |
| Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas | ** Support | |
| Climate Hawks Vote | ** Support | |
| Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley | ** Support | |
| Climate Resolve | ** Support | |
| Community Environmental Council | ** Support | |
| Elders Climate Action, Norcal and Socal Chapters | ** Support | |
| El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Elk Grove Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Endangered Habitats League | ** Support | |
| Environmental Working Group | ** Support | |
| Environment California | ** Support | |
| Family Business Association of California | ** Against | |
| Folsom Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Fossil Free California | ** Support | |
| Glendale Environmental Coalition | ** Support | |
| Greenbelt Alliance | ** Support | |
| Hammond Climate Solutions | ** Support | |
| Human Impact Partners | ** Support | |
| Indivisible California Green Team | ** Support | |
| indivisible ventura | ** Support | |
| Joint Venture Silicon Valley | ** Support | |
| Let's Green Ca! | ** Support | |
| lincoln area chamber of commerce | ** Against | |
| Physicians for Social Responsibility-San Francisco Bay Area Chapter | ** Support | |
| Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Rocklin Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Roseville Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Shingle Springs/cameron Park Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| SoCal 350 Climate Action | ** Support | |
| State Building And Construction Trades Council Of Ca | ** Against | |
| Sunflower Alliance | ** Support | |
| The Climate Center | ** Support | |
| The Nature Conservancy | ** Support | |
| Treepeople | ** Support | |
| Western Growers Association | ** Against | |
| Western States Petroleum Association | ** Against | |
| Wine Institute | ** Against | |
| Yuba Sutter Chamber of Commerce | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 12 (Stern) - California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: emissions limit
Version: December 5, 2022 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 15, 2023 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would increase California’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emission
reduction target for 2030 from 40 percent below the 1990 level to 55 percent below that
level.
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Air Resources Board (ARB) estimates one-time costs of $600,000 (Cost of Implementation Account [COIA]) for a contract for scenario modeling.
- Unknown potential ongoing costs, possibly in the millions of dollars annually until the 2030 deadline (Cost of Implementation Account [COIA]), for ARB to identify strategies and recommend measures to achieve a 55% target by 2030, and to incorporate these into existing plans and strategies. Expeditious publication of a document with a 55% target would maximize California’s ability to act on the plan and be the most likely to produce a cost-effective path forward. ARB would likely incur significant costs to develop an additional update to reflect the 55% target. (See staff comments.)
- Unknown costs, likely in the billions of dollars total over several years until 2030 (Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund [GGRF], COI, other special funds, and General Fund), for additional state spending on California Climate Investments (CCI) and other state programs that reduce GHGs to meet a more ambitious target. (See staff comments.)
- Potential ongoing savings of an unknown amount (General Fund and other funds) due to mitigated or avoided state costs associated with carbon emissions and air pollution. For example, the state’s health coverage program, Medi-Cal, could realize savings if additional GHG reductions lower its treatment costs of adverse health impacts linked to emissions. (See staff comments.)
- To the extent that actions to meet the 55% target in this bill result in higher cap-and-trade allowance prices, both state costs and revenues could increase. How heavily ARB would rely on cap-and-trade versus other policies to achieve this target is unknown. However, should ARB utilize the cap-and-trade program, more ambitious reductions could decrease the number of allowances sold relative to sales under the existing target. Consequently, allowance prices might go up. This would have two fiscal effects:
- Unknown potential revenue impacts (GGRF) from both increases and decreases in state auction proceeds. Fewer allowances sold would decrease revenue, but higher allowance prices would increase it. Any changes in actual revenues would depend on the net effect of these countervailing forces.
- Unknown costs (various funds) to the state as an energy ratepayer. An increase in allowance prices would likely raise statewide energy prices and could lead to rate increases in the medium-term until 2030. The State of California is a natural gas and electrical customer, purchasing roughly one percent of the state’s electricity and four percent of its natural gas. As such, the state incurs costs when rates increase. However, identifying an amount attributable to this bill is not feasible given the number and scale of overlapping climate efforts within the energy sector.
Background:
California is particularly susceptible to the harmful effects of climate change, including an increase in extreme heat events, drought, wildfire, sea level rise, and more. According to the Fourth California Climate Change Assessment, by 2100, the average annual maximum daily temperature is projected to increase by 5.6-8.8 °F, water supply from snowpack is projected to decline by two-thirds, the average area burned in wildfires could increase by 77%, and 31-67% of Southern California beaches may completely erode without large-scale human intervention, all under business as usual and moderate GHG reduction pathways.
California is already experiencing the effects of climate change now. For example, eight out of the past ten years have had significantly below average precipitation. As of September 2020, the state has experienced a degree of wildfire activity that California’s Fourth Climate Change Assessment initially forecasted to not occur until 2050.
Establishment of GHG emission reduction targets. In 2006, the Legislature passed the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Health and Safety Code §38500 et seq.), which is frequently referred to as AB 32. The act required ARB to determine the 1990 statewide GHG emission level and approve a statewide GHG emissions limit that is equivalent to that level, to be achieved by 2020, and to adopt GHG emissions reductions measures by regulation. ARB was also authorized to adopt a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emission limits for sources or categories of sources that emit GHGs. This program is known as the cap-and-trade program.
ARB Scoping Plan. AB 32 required ARB to develop a Scoping Plan that describes the approach California will take to reduce GHGs to achieve the goal of reducing emissions to 1990 levels by 2020. Serving as an important roadmap towards the 2020 and 2030 goals, ARB’s AB/SB 32 Scoping Plan is updated every five years. This document charted a path to the 2020 goals, and the first post-2020 Scoping Plan Update is currently nearing completion. This Update focuses primarily on achieving carbon neutrality by 2045, a goal established by Executive Order B-55-18, though it does briefly mention complying with SB 32 and achieving a 40% reduction by 2030 as well.
ARB recently finalized and approved the 2022 Scoping Plan Update, which plans for a 48% reduction in statewide GHGs by 2030.
Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) assessment of the 2022 Scoping Plan Update. The LAO found that the most recent plan lacks a clear strategy for meeting 2030 GHG goals. Their report states:
“Without a clear policy approach articulated in the Scoping Plan or elsewhere, how—and whether—the state would meet the 2030 GHG goal is unclear. The lack of specific direction means that state departments will need to spend additional time and effort to identify and evaluate what policy changes will be required to achieve the intended outcomes before they can even begin the process of adopting and implementing those changes. Overall, many of these efforts likely will take years. Such a delay increases the risk that the state will not meet its 2030 goal.
For example, the plan is unclear regarding how much the state will rely on financial incentives, sector-specific regulatory programs, or cap-and-trade. Rather, the plan’s estimated reductions are driven primarily by assumptions developed by CARB, without specifying how those assumed outcomes might be achieved. The lack of focus on policy options is a missed opportunity that has important ramifications for California’s overall GHG reduction efforts, including:
- The lack of specificity likely will lead to delayed action, as it defaults to state departments to identify necessary implementation steps. This increases the risk that the state will not meet its statutory 2030 GHG goal, much less CARB’s more ambitious target.
- If the state needs to adopt policy changes in a relatively short period of time to meet its goal, this could be costlier and/or disruptive for private businesses and households.
- The plan does not provide the Legislature with sufficient information—such as about cost-effectiveness, distributional impacts, or other environmental impacts—to evaluate the merits of new policies that might be needed to meet the 2030 goal.
- Failing to develop a credible plan to meet statewide GHG goals could adversely affect California’s ability to serve as an effective model for other jurisdictions or demonstrate global leadership.”
Cap-and-trade program. AB 32 authorized ARB to implement a market‑based mechanism known as a cap‑and‑trade program. Under cap-and-trade, ARB issues a limited number of “allowances” (essentially, emission permits), which large GHG emitters can purchase at a state‑run auction or on the private market. (ARB also gives some allowances away for free.) From an economic perspective, the primary advantage of a cap‑and‑trade program is that the market sets a price for GHG emissions, which creates a financial incentive for businesses and households to implement the least costly emission reduction activities.
A recent assessment by the LAO found that the Cap-and-Trade program is not currently positioned to ensure meeting the 2030 target under current law, let alone a more ambitious 2030 target. One key reason for this is because there will be more than enough allowances available for covered entities to continue to emit at levels exceeding the 2030 target. “In short,” writes the LAO, “the program is not stringent enough—that is, it will not drive the additional emission reductions needed to close a 2030 emissions gap. One key reason for this is because there will be more than enough allowances available for covered entities to continue to emit at levels exceeding the 2030 target.”
The LAO also notes, “An overall supply of allowances that significantly exceeds demand also results in relatively low allowance prices and affects future state revenue from cap-and-trade auctions—both of which could make it harder for the state to meet its GHG goals in 2030 and future years.”
California Climate Investments (CCI) programs. Proceeds from the cap-and-trade program support a wide range of programs and projects to reduce GHG emissions and deliver economic, environmental, and public health co-benefits, including for the most disadvantaged communities, low-income communities, and low-income households. These programs include supporting incentives for zero-emission vehicles and equipment, increasing mobility through transit projects, diverting organic waste from landfills to composting, and more. CCI has also implemented a variety of nature-based solutions to sequester carbon and prevent GHG emissions through such strategies as protecting forests from catastrophic wildfire, supporting sustainable agricultural lands, and growing urban forests.
There are 73 CCI programs across California that are administered by 22 state agencies. In 2021, CCI programs implemented $2.1 billion in funding, bringing the cumulative total to almost $10.5 billion. According to ARB, investments implemented since the inception of CCI are expected to reduce 76.0 MMTCO2e over project lifetimes. The average cost of GHG reductions under all CCI programs in 2021 was about $125 per MTCO2. Compared to 2019, the average cost-effectiveness of CCI decreased slightly, in part due to increases in programs offering technical assistance, outreach, research, and planning rather than direct emission reductions.
Other state investments for climate resilience. In addition to CCI programs, the Legislature has provided unprecedented funding levels from multiple sources to address climate issues. For example, the 2021-22 budget provided $369 million for climate change related activities from the General Fund. Moreover, this budget agreement included a commitment for $3.7 billion General Fund over three years for climate resilience investments such as cutting carbon emissions and catalyzing innovation.
Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF). A substantial portion of cap-and-trade auction proceeds—about two-thirds for the February 2022 auction—go to the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (GGRF). As of early 2022, about $19.2 billion in cap-and-trade auction proceeds had gone to the fund, and as of November 2021, about $10.5 billion had been used in implemented projects.
As discussed above, the recent LAO assessment found that the Cap-and-Trade Program lacks stringency, resulting in low allowance prices, which in turn makes GGRF revenue lower and more volatile. This makes it more difficult to fund the various programs that typically rely on GGRF monies, including programs intended to help the state meet its GHG reduction goals.
Cost of Implementation Account (COIA). AB 32 authorized ARB to adopt a schedule of fees to be paid by sources of GHG emissions. These fees are used to fund costs directly related to state agencies’ development, administration, and implementation of AB 32 programs that reduce GHG emissions.
The total implementation expenses budgeted for fiscal year 2022-2023 are approximately $99 million. The total emissions subject to the COI Fee Regulation for data year 2020 were approximately 285 million MTCO2e. Thus, 2022 fees were approximately $0.34 per MTCO2e emitted.
Existing emission targets. The state achieved its 2020 GHG emissions reductions target of returning to 1990 levels 4 years earlier than mandated by AB 32. The state is currently implementing strategies in the 2017 Scoping Plan Update to further reduce its GHG emissions by 40% below 1990 levels by 2030.
The pace of emission reductions needed to achieve the 2030 target is much greater than what was needed for 2020. The 2021 California Green Innovation Index, published by the nonpartisan think tank Next 10, found that total GHG emissions dropped 1.6 percent between 2018 and 2019—the second largest percentage decrease since 2010—but far short of what is needed to achieve the SB 32 goals. California must now sustain a 4.3 percent annual decrease through 2030—a reduction that is more than 2.5 times greater than was achieved in 2019.
In short, California achieved its 2020 GHG emissions reduction goals early, but appears to not yet be on pace to achieve its current 2030 goal of a further 40% reduction, let alone an even more ambitious goal.
State costs of carbon. Carbon and GHG emissions are associated with significant and widespread costs on individuals, businesses, economies, governments, and the global community. These costs are driven by things like increases in adverse health impacts, lowered economic productivity, agricultural losses, damages to property and infrastructure, lower standards of living, and climate adaptation efforts, among other things. Many state programs are likely to incur increasing carbon costs in future years if not already. Some of these costs would likely be the result of complex chains of events—such as health declines, heat stress, and other climate-related conditions contributing to lost labor productivity, which in turn would lower economic output and result in a state tax revenue decrease—and these costs are difficult to pin-point and even harder to predict.
Other costs are more clear-cut. For example, carbon emissions can lead to higher healthcare spending through Medi-Cal, California’s Medicaid program that provides health coverage. Air pollution has been linked to increased risk for numerous adverse health impacts, including cardiovascular and respiratory illness, lung disease, cancerous tumors, birth defects, premature births, developmental disorders, central nervous system damage, intellectual disability, persistent memory impairments, epilepsy, dementia, and premature death. The costs to treat and manage these conditions in patients covered by Medi-Cal are largely paid for by the state.
GHGs and the economy. A recent study by Deloitte found that maintaining the status quo would be costlier than taking action to further reduce GHG emissions now. According to Deloitte, unchecked climate change could cost the global economy $178 trillion in net present value terms from 2021-2070. The human costs would be far greater: a lack of food and water, a loss of jobs, worsening health and well-being, and reduced standard of living. On the other hand, acting to achieve net-zero emissions by midcentury could lead to stronger economic growth by 2070, according to Deloitte’s analysis.
Proposed Law:
Existing law, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §38500 et seq.):
- Establishes the State Air Resources Board (ARB) as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases.
- Requires ARB to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 (AB 32, 2006) and to ensure that statewide GHGs are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030 (SB 32, 2016).
- Requires ARB to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
This bill would change the SB 32 emission reduction target for 2030 from a 40% reduction below the 1990 level to a 55% reduction below that level.
Related Legislation:
AB 1395 (Muratsuchi, 2021) would declare that it is the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions and reduce anthropogenic GHG emissions by at least 90 percent below the 1990 level no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative GHG emissions thereafter. AB 1395 is pending on the Senate Floor.
SB 582 (Stern, 2021), in its earlier form, would have updated the statewide GHG emission reduction target to 80% by 2030, among other things. SB 582 died in the Senate due to bill limits enacted in 2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic.
SB 32 (Pavley, 2016) requires ARB to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030.
AB 32 (Nunez, 2006) required ARB to develop regulations and market mechanisms to reduce California's GHG emissions to 1990 levels by the year of 2020, representing approximately a 30% reduction statewide, with mandatory caps beginning in 2012 for significant emissions sources.
Staff Comments:
Costs for an early scoping plan update or additional reporting. The cost estimate of this bill provided by ARB does not include costs related to scoping plan updates or other conforming changes. Without additional funding, ARB would not have the resources to develop updates outside its normal Scoping Plan process, which is scheduled to produce the next update in 2027. Staff are concerned this timeline would significantly increase both the target’s implementation costs as well as its odds of failure.
The impact of implementing a new 2030 target in 2027 would likely be minimal. Establishment of an incredibly ambitious target without including it in the very processes built to ensure robust strategic planning and thoughtful program development would seriously undermine any attempt to meet that target, calling into question the purpose of such a measure. If the Legislature intends to meet the 55% target, publication of an early update to the scoping plan or other timely report would be a critical step for laying necessary groundwork.
Even if state departments were somehow able to quickly take action to identify, evaluate, and adopt new or modified policies in order to try to meet the ambitious 2030 targets, these policies would then need to achieve reductions in a very short time period. Moreover, rushed implementation would reduce avenues available to achieve reductions, increase department costs, and be more disruptive for private businesses and households.
Recently, the LAO recommended directing ARB to submit a report clarifying the plan to meet 2030 goals. Such a report could also incorporate the 55% target. The LAO states:
“We recommend the Legislature direct CARB to submit a report to the Legislature by July 31, 2023 that clarifies its plan for reducing GHG emissions to meet 2030 goals. As part of this report, CARB should identify new or expanded policies that would be used to meet both the statutory goal and the Scoping Plan goal, including the role that it expects cap-and-trade to play. The report should also include additional details about the estimated emission reductions, air pollution reductions, distributional impacts, and cost-effectiveness of each of those policies. Such a report would help the Legislature: (1) evaluate the feasibility of the administration’s new 2030 goal, (2) assess whether it agrees with the administration’s policy approach or whether it would like to pursue a modified approach, (3) identify potential policy or budget actions needed to meet the Legislature’s 2030 benchmark, and (4) ensure there is adequate legislative oversight of the administration’s implementation of the plan. We recognize that specifying the details of every policy and conducting a thorough analysis of each policy might not be feasible by July 2023. However, given the available resources at CARB, we think providing a significant amount of additional detail and analysis is both reasonable to expect and valuable for legislative decision-making.”
Staff agree that such a report would provide much-needed information and be extremely helpful in meeting established state goals. It would also provide an opportunity to incorporate the new 2030 target in a timely manner. Alternatively, the Legislature could direct ARB to develop the next Scoping Plan Update earlier than required. Similarly, the Senate Environmental Quality Committee analysis suggested that, “Going forward, the author should assess how the requirements of this bill would interact with the existing Scoping Plan Update timeline and consider amending the bill accordingly, whether that be an explicit call to update the Plan before 2027, or other direction to CARB for conforming changes.”
While ARB would have costs associated with producing a report or developing scoping plan updates outside of the established process, staff find that the expenditure would have merit. Increasing the state’s 2030 GHG emission reduction goals from 40% to 55% would be a significant and expensive undertaking. Setting this target without also charting a well-reasoned, realistic, and thoughtful approach to reaching it could lead to higher overall state costs and even failure.
The inclusion of other state goals and policies in scoping plan updates can provide a reasonable cost comparison for incorporating the new target in this bill. For example, ARB estimated that implementation of AB 1395 (Muratsuchi) would cost $7.5 million in 2021-22 and $6.7 million annually thereafter to incorporate the bill’s proposed state policies of net zero GHG emissions and reduced anthropogenic GHG emissions into future scoping plan updates. Other examples of scoping plan inclusions have had similar costs or cost estimates. Therefore, staff believe costs for future scoping plan updates would likely be in this range.
Costs to meet new target. CCI has been an important part of meeting the state’s climate goals to-date. As of 2020, CCI programs had implemented $8.3 billion in funding for projects that reduced GHGs by 66.3 MMTCO2e. Subsequently, CCI programs implemented over 75,000 new projects in 2021. To-date, CCI has implemented over 560,000 projects across the state and nearly $10.5 billion.
Should the state, in working toward a 55% target, utilize CCI programs to achieve a similar share of statewide GHG reductions as they have in past years, staff estimate this bill would result in increased costs for additional CCI funding. In addition to CCI, increased state investments consistent with current climate spending would likely be needed to achieve a 55% target.
Based on past funding amounts and corresponding GHG emission reductions achieved, staff estimate that costs for additional state investments to meet a more ambitious 2030 target could possibly be in the billions of dollars for the period until 2030.
State costs of carbon. As discussed above, carbon emissions can result in state costs, such as increased Medi-Cal costs. Carbon dioxide and other air pollution emissions have been linked to increased risk for numerous adverse health impacts. Costs for the treatment and management of these conditions in patients covered by Medi-Cal are largely paid by the state.
Total Medi-Cal program costs are slated to be $98.5 billion in fiscal year 2018–19, with the federal government providing $62.7 billion, the state General Fund $20.7 billion, and other state sources—including funds generated by provider fees and transfers from local governments—another $15.1 billion. It is impossible to calculate just how much of this spending is driven by emissions, but the state clearly bears a significant share of overall healthcare costs, including costs related to emissions. More than 12 million Californians—or about 1 in 3—are enrolled in Medi-Cal, meaning the state funds treatment for a sizeable chunk of emission-related illnesses in California. Moreover, Medi-Cal beneficiaries—who tend to be older adults and children—are more likely than privately insured Californians to experience adverse health impacts and incur healthcare costs related to climate change. This means the state cost share is even higher than the number of Medi-Cal enrollees would predict.
A reduction of harmful emissions could mitigate or avoid some adverse health impacts and related Medi-Cal spending. This is supported by a recent study by UC researchers in Berkeley and San Francisco that reported that for every dollar the state has spent controlling air pollution (between 1990 and 2014), it has generated $38 in benefits attributable to lower rates of illness, premature death and lost productivity attributable to air pollution. Some of the benefits identified could lower Medi-Cal and other state carbon costs.
Impact on the California economy. The 2022 Scoping Plan Update examines a few different scenarios and their potential overall impact on the California economy. ARB finds that the “Scoping Plan Scenario” (carbon neutrality by 2045) would result in a small impact on the Gross State Product (GSP) and employment relative to the “Reference Scenario” (continuing but modest GHG reductions beyond 2030 that level off toward mid-century) as shown in the figure below. Economic growth would be largely unaffected by the Scoping Plan Scenario in 2035 and slowed by 0.1 percent in 2045. Employment growth is also slowed a small amount, 0.4 percent in 2035 and in 2045, and employment still grows. Assuming annual growth rates of 0.7 percent means there would be more than 193,000 additional jobs in 2045.
Source: ARB 2022 Scoping Plan for Achieving Carbon Neutrality
Cap-and-Trade and GGRF revenue. Changes to Cap-and-Trade could make the program a more effective tool and improve consistency with state goals. As discussed above, the LAO recently found that under a wide range of different emissions scenarios—including a scenario where covered emissions decline more slowly (1 percent annually) and a scenario where covered emissions decline more quickly (nearly 4 percent annually)—the state would fail to meet its statutory goal and a significant number of unused allowances would remain at the end of 2030. One reason there are so many unused allowances is the program allows unlimited banking of allowances from earlier years, which can then be used to comply with more strict caps in later years. If a significant number of allowances are “banked” in the earlier years, covered entities can then continue emitting GHGs in 2030 at levels that exceed the state’s targets. Notably, a significant decline in emissions driven by other policies or economic conditions also would result in even more unused allowances—making it even less likely that cap-and-trade could act as a backstop to limit emissions and close any remaining emissions gap in 2030.
Reducing the supply of allowances issued in future years could make Cap-and-Trade a more effective tool in meeting more ambitious targets. It would also put upward pressure on allowance prices. An over-supply of allowances eventually will result in a significant drop in their market price—likely to levels near or below the floor price established by CARB. When prices would drop to these levels is unclear, but they likely would approach the floor as market participants (such as covered entities) become more confident that there will be excess allowances available through 2030. Although reduced allowance prices mean lower direct costs for households and businesses, they also mean the cap-and-trade program would have less of an effect on emissions. As allowance prices decline, so too will the state cap-and-trade auction revenue that goes into the GGRF. These monies fund a wide variety of environmental and transportation programs. As covered entities begin to see that more allowances than they need are available, some of the allowances offered at state auctions likely will go unsold. As a result, the state will have very low and/or volatile GGRF revenue at these auctions—making it more difficult to fund the various programs that typically rely on GGRF funding, including programs intended to help the state meet its GHG reduction goals.
Another option is to limit the use of offsets. Offsets are credits generated by entities undertaking GHG emission reduction projects from sources that are not covered by the state’s cap-and-trade program (uncapped sources), such as forestry projects that increase or maintain carbon in the forests. Covered entities can purchase these offsets and use them (instead of allowances) to cover some of their emissions (up to 4 percent of their emissions through 2025, and 6 percent of emissions from 2026 through 2030). Offsets allow covered entities to emit at higher levels than they otherwise would, in exchange for emission reductions elsewhere, often outside of California. Limiting, eliminating, or modifying the use of offsets in the program could encourage greater emission reductions from covered entities within California. Some changes to the use of offsets would require new legislation.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 12
Author: | Stern, et al. | ||
Version: | 12/5/2022 | Hearing Date: | 3/15/2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eric Walters | ||
SUBJECT: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006: emissions limit
This bill increases California’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emission reduction target from 40% below the 1990 level to 55% below that level.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §38500 et seq.):
- Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to approve a statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions limit equivalent to the statewide GHG emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 (AB 32, 2006) and to ensure that statewide GHGs are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030 (SB 32, 2016).
- Requires CARB to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
- States, under the California Climate Crisis Act—AB 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337, Statutes of 2022), that it is the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions no later than 2045, and to ensure that by 2045 statewide anthropogenic GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 level.
This bill changes the SB 32 emission reduction target for 2030 from a 40% reduction below the 1990 level to a 55% reduction below that level.
Background
- California’s climate reality. California is particularly susceptible to the harmful effects of climate change, including an increase in extreme heat events, drought, wildfire, sea level rise, and more. According to the Fourth California Climate Change Assessment, by 2100, the average annual maximum daily temperature is projected to increase by 5.6-8.8 °F, water supply from snowpack is projected to decline by two-thirds, the average area burned in wildfires could increase by 77%, and 31-67% of Southern California beaches may completely erode without large-scale human intervention, all under business as usual and even moderate GHG reduction pathways.
The effects of climate change to date have been felt the world over, but the most dire consequences have often struck those least able to defend themselves. This is true both in California and worldwide. Should reaching net-zero GHG emissions be delayed and rapid warming allowed to continue, experts predict unprecedented numbers of deaths, ecosystem destruction, and human migration. In a 2019 report on climate change and poverty, the United Nations Human Rights Council states, “Addressing climate change will require a fundamental shift in the global economy, decoupling improvements in economic well-being from fossil fuel emissions.” - Reducing emissions across the economy. The AB 32 Climate Change Scoping Plan is an actionable blueprint for aligning action to achieve California’s ambitious climate goals. The state achieved its 2020 GHG emissions reductions target of returning to 1990 levels 4 years earlier than mandated by AB 32. By law, the next GHG emission reduction target is 40% below the 1990 level by 2030.
The pace of emission reductions needed to achieve the 2030 targets is much greater than what was needed for 2020. The 2021 California Green Innovation Index, published by the nonpartisan think tank Next 10, found that total GHG emissions dropped 1.6 percent between 2018 and 2019 but far short of what is needed to achieve the SB 32 goals. California must now sustain an annual decrease in emissions far greater than the previous average every year between now and 2030.
In short, California achieved its 2020 GHG emissions reduction goals early, but appears to not yet be on pace to achieve its current 2030 goal of a further 40% reduction, let alone an even more ambitious goal. - Increasing ambition across the country. Since 2016, when the Legislature set the SB 32 target of a 40% reduction from 1990 emissions by 2030, other states have followed and even surpassed California. According to the States Climate Action Map maintained by UC Berkeley’s California-China Climate Institute, 12 other states have emission reduction goals for 2030.
Specifically, California, (40%), Maine (45%), Massachusetts (50%), New York (40%), Rhode Island (45%), Vermont (40%) and Washington (45%) all have GHG emission reduction goals for 2030 emissions below a 1990 baseline. No state has a 2030 emission reduction goal higher than 50%, as this bill proposes. - Raising the bar across the world. California’s climate goals have generally been in-line with the scientific consensus at the time, consistent with Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) recommendations to prevent a 1.5 ℃ rise by 2050. No IPCC report has been issued since 2018 when the last target was set, however, the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) 2020 Emissions Gap Assessment indicates that current global GHG targets are insufficient to ensure a safe climate future.
The UNEP warns that, globally, emissions need to be cut by 7.6% every year until 2030 to meet the 1.5 ℃ target. Presently, California will need to cut emissions more than 4% per year to achieve its 2030 goal. Under the proposed 55% by 2030 goal, the state would need to cut emissions over 5.5% per year. The latest California GHG emission inventory data do not show reductions at near that rate, and thus they do not inspire confidence in reaching any of the above annual emission reduction rates without major changes. - The 2022 Scoping Plan Update. The Scoping Plan was initially required by AB 32 and is updated by CARB at least once every five years for the purpose of achieving California’s climate goals with the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions.
The 2022 Scoping Plan Update is primarily focused on achieving the newly statutorily required carbon neutrality by 2045 goal, although it does briefly address the 2030 SB 32 goal as well. The Update stated that in order to be on track for success in reaching net neutrality (and 85% reduction in emissions) by 2045, California should in fact strive for a 48% reduction by 2030, rather than the SB 32 target of 40% below 1990 levels. The Scoping Plan outlines a set of policy assumptions that, taken together, would reach that 48% reduction. These are boldly ambitious assumptions, and they will require massive action and likely significant policy changes to be achieved. - Joint legislative oversight hearing of CARB of 3/1/23. On March 1, 2023, this committee, along with the Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies (JLCCCP) and the Assembly Natural Resources Committee hosted the CARB Chair, Liane Randolph, in a hearing to assess the 2022 Scoping Plan Update.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Last summer, Governor Newsom endorsed a package of climate related measures called the “Climate Pillars”, nearly all of them passed the Legislature and were signed into law. But among them was one pillar that didn’t get to his desk, AB 2133 by former Assemblymember Quirk, that would have raised the state’s greenhouse gas emissions reduction goal from 40% by 2030 to instead 55% by 2030, further proving California’s commitment, leadership and resolve in mitigating the worsening effects on our climate. Additionally, last fall, global leaders convened in Sharm El Sheik, Egypt, for the COP 27 climate conference to find new solutions and make renewed commitments in combating the global effects of climate change. I attended the conference, and the big take away was without accelerated and equitable climate policies to increase renewable energy, move away from fossil fuels and decarbonize our economies, global temperatures will certainly exceed 1.5 degrees Celsius as early as 2030. California can’t afford to simply adapt to a worsening climate, it must also lead with effective climate strategies. We are on target to exceed our own 40% emission reduction goal by 2030, a goal set 7 years ago, well before annual catastrophic wildfires became the norm, before 75% of the state was in severe drought and fire severity zones, before the terms atmospheric river and bomb cyclone entered our vocabulary. It is important that we revisit our climate goals, and aim higher. Increasing our greenhouse gas reduction target remains a very important pillar to challenge ourselves, and show the rest of the world that accelerated emissions reductions are achievable.”
- Is 55% the right number? As discussed above, GHG emission reduction targets vary significantly between states and nations. While a 55% target would set California ahead once more as the state with the most ambitious goal, it is not entirely clear if that is the most appropriate target.
However, there is mounting evidence that existing climate goals worldwide are woefully inadequate to minimize global warming and the associated catastrophes. In a letter published in Environmental Research Letters in 2021, Daniel Kammen and seven other respected experts called for California to raise its climate ambitions. They implored,
“California’s once aggressive climate targets are no longer scientifically defensible. California is banking on outdated targets and policies in the face of an accelerating climate crisis, aspiring yet struggling to reach inadequate goals… it is time for California to establish a new set of targets backed by feasibility studies that take into account the declining cost for clean energy technologies, a social cost of carbon, and the disproportionate health, housing, transportation, and other costs to frontline and other disadvantaged communities.”
The letter ultimately calls for California to move its carbon neutrality goal up fifteen years from 2045 to 2030. While this may seem eye-poppingly ambitious, this recommendation was made by a number of well-informed academics with a keen eye toward the current state of climate science, clean energy technology, and environmental policy.
From that perspective, perhaps even 55% below 1990 levels by 2030 is not nearly ambitious enough to stave off the worst, most devastating impacts of global climate change.
- Is now the right time? Despite this bill being identical to AB 2133 (Quirk, 2022) as it was heard in this committee last August, the circumstances surrounding it are significantly different. Namely, the 2022 Scoping Plan Update was finalized and approved by the CARB board, and it planned for a 48% reduction in statewide GHGs by 2030.
CARB will not be required by existing law to update the Scoping Plan again until 2027. If SB 12 were signed into law, even if the target was updated as of January 1, 2024, it is unclear how much impact that number would have until the Scoping Plan was updated again. Going forward, the author should assess how the requirements of this bill would interact with the existing Scoping Plan Update timeline and consider amending the bill accordingly, whether that be an explicit call to update the Plan before 2027, or other direction to CARB for conforming changes. - Is an emission reduction number the right focus? The climate science could not be clearer: a massive, unprecedented decrease in GHG emissions from virtually all stationary and mobile sources is essential to stop global climate change. However, that is not the whole picture of what is needed to combat the injustices inherent in our present climate catastrophe. While carbon dioxide emissions may have minimal local health impacts, they are often accompanied by a bevy of other gases and particles that harm those breathing nearby. Thus, the approach this bill currently takes—namely, setting an ambitious GHG emission reduction target without accompanying guardrails to center environmental justice—runs the risk of encouraging the most cost-effective emissions reduction measures at the continued expense of vulnerable and historically pollution-burdened communities.
Going forward, the author may wish to consider what guardrails could be included in this measure to prioritize environmental justice in all actions taken to achieve the bill’s goal. One potential idea to consider is the concept of no-trade zones (or facility-level emission limits) raised by the Environmental Justice Advisory Committee and recently uplifted by the Independent Emissions Market Advisory Committee’s annual report. This could, in short, require regulated entities in specified communities to comply with cap-and-trade through direct emission reductions, rather than the purchase and use of flexible compliance instruments. - Is a new statewide GHG target the right goal? Ultimately, an ambitious target is only useful if it is able to drive action. The pace at which California has approached its existing 2030 goals gives some cause for concern.
Over the last decade, statewide GHGs have fallen at roughly 1% per year (with a few notable exceptions). To reach the current statutory 2030 goal, that number will need to be quadrupled. To reach the 2022 Scoping Plan Update’s 48% reduction, it will need to be quintupled. By increasing ambition even further, to a 55% reduction by 2030, success would rely on an even greater still acceleration in emission reductions. A question arises as to whether it is more impactful at this time to litigate exactly which ambitious 2030 goal we are already hurtling towards, or to identify what hurdles impede progress towards even our current goals.
It is the understanding of committee staff that the author of this measure is engaged in discussions with stakeholders about the appropriate 2030 emissions reduction target for this bill. Regardless of whether that agreed-upon number ends up being the 40% in existing law, the 48% called for in the 2022 Scoping Plan Update, the 55% contemplated in this bill currently, or an even higher number entirely, committee staff maintains that achieving the goal is more important than setting the goal.
The author may wish to consider, going forward, whether to include any of the specific considerations raised in the March 1st oversight hearing in this measure. This could include, but need not be limited to:- Programmatic reform to the state’s cap-and-trade program, such as those suggested by the past five annual reports of the Independent Emissions Market Advisory Committee;
- Pursuing the idea of an “Implementation Plan” to address the challenges and shortcomings identified in achieving the policy outcomes identified in the Scoping Plan Update; and
- Directing CARB to quantify the relative contributions of different policy approaches to achieving the state’s emission reduction goals.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2133 (Quirk, 2022) was identical to this bill and was introduced late in the 2022 legislative session in accordance with Governor Newsom’s five climate pillars. AB 2133 died on concurrence on the Assembly floor.
SB 582 (Stern, 2021), in its earlier form heard in this committee, updated the statewide GHG emission reduction target to 80% by 2030, among other things. SB 582 died in the Senate due to bill limits enacted in 2021 during the COVID-19 pandemic.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
350 Bay Area Action
350 Conejo / San Fernando Valley
350 Humboldt
350 Sacramento
350 South Bay Los Angeles
350 Southland Legislative Alliance
350 Ventura County Climate Hub
Breast Cancer Action
California Climate Action
California Climate Voters
California Environmental Voters
California Environmental Voters (formerly Clcv)
California Interfaith Power and Light
California Nurses for Environmental Health and Justice
Center for Biological Diversity
Center for Climate Change and Health
Ceres
Clean Coaliton
Climate Action California
Climate Action Campaign
Climate First: Replacing Oil & Gas (CFROG)
Climate Hawks Vote
Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley
Climate Resolve
Community Environmental Council
Elders Climate Action, Norcal and Socal Chapters
Endangered Habitats League
Environment California
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Greenbelt Alliance
Hammond Climate Solutions
Human Impact Partners
Indivisible California Green Team
Indivisible Ventura
Joint Venture Silicon Valley
Let's Green Ca!
Physicians for Social Responsibility - San Francisco Bay Area Chapter
Socal 350 Climate Action
Sunflower Alliance
The Climate Center
The Nature Conservancy
Treepeople
OPPOSITION:
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Independent Petroleum Association (CIPA)
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Restaurant Association
California Trucking Association
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Lincoln Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce
Rocklin Area Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
Shingle Springs/cameron Park Chamber of Commerce
State Building and Construction Trades Council of Ca
Western Growers Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Wine Institute
Yuba Sutter Chamber of Commerce
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to a coalition of over fifty environmental groups in support, “Recently, in its Scoping Plan, CARB proposed that the state could exceed the ambition of its statutory target of 40% and achieve a 48% reduction in GHGs by 2030. Even with this increase, California is behind many of our closest allies. The European Union’s target for reducing emissions by 2030 is 62% below 2005 levels (EU emissions were slightly lower in 2005 than 1990 making this relatively comparable to California’s baseline of 1990). Denmark has set a more ambitious target of a 70% reduction while the United Kingdom aims for a 68% cut in emissions below 1990 levels by 2030.
“With California expending a projected $48 billion over the next five years for climate change adaptation and mitigation measures, and $374 billion being invested nationally by the federal government through the Inflation Reduction Act over the next decade, it is time for California to step up its leadership in this arena. SB 12 would set California on the path to do just that by establishing a statutory goal for the state to achieve a minimum of 55% emissions reduction by 2030, commensurate with new state funding and positioning the state to leverage significant new federal and private investments.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to a coalition of twenty chambers of commerce and other business groups in opposition, “This proposal undermines the existing public and transparent process that the California Air Resources Board (CARB) recently adopted, where hundreds of stakeholders engaged in a months-long inclusive Scoping Plan review. During that process stakeholders made clear that the transition to a clean energy future will require a deliberate and thoughtful approach to ensure that we are appropriately balancing affordability with reliability. Unfortunately, this proposal does not carry that degree of nuance, but rather sets an ambitious target on top of a target that the LAO suggests lacks a clear strategy to achieve our 2030 goals.
“Increasing the GHG 2030 emissions reduction target from 40% to 55% below the 1990 level, would require the state to remove an additional 17 million gasoline vehicles off the road by 2030, according to data developed by CARB. Additionally, CARB data shows that CARB’s initial modeling of scenarios in this range concluded them to be ‘economically and technically infeasible due to the current lack of low-carbon energy infrastructure, unavailability of technology, large job loss and high implementation costs.’”
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):