SB 1203: Education expenses: Education Flex Account Act of 2024.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-02-15
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-24: April 24 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 5. Page 3751.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Existing law establishes a system of elementary and secondary education in this state. This system consists of the public and private schools that provide instruction in kindergarten and in grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
This bill would enact the Education Flex Account Act of 2024 and establish the Education Flex Account (EFA) Trust, to be known as the EFA Trust, as a fund within the State Treasury to be administered by the EFA Trust Board. During the first 4 school years following the operative date of the act, the bill would authorize certain children eligible to be enrolled in kindergarten, or in an elementary or secondary school, in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to establish an EFA or Special Education Flex Account (SEFA), based on parent or guardian income. The bill would remove these income eligibility limits after 4 school years following the operative date of the act, thereby entitling every child eligible to be enrolled in kindergarten, or in an elementary or secondary school, in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to establish an EFA or SEFA. The bill would specify that every child enrolled in an eligible school shall be entitled, pursuant to this act, to a credit to the childs account for tuition and elementary and secondary eligible education expenses, as defined. Commencing with the first fiscal year following the operative date of the act, the bill would require the Department of Finance to determine, on July 1 of each year, the annual EFA and SEFA deposit amounts for the upcoming school year. The bill would specify the procedure for calculating the EFA and SEFA deposit amounts and would require the Controller to transfer an amount of money from the General Fund to the EFA Trust equal to the sum of (1) the EFA deposit amount multiplied by the number of EFAs established, and (2) the SEFA deposit amount multiplied by the number of SEFAs established, as provided. The bill would require any unused funds remaining in an EFA or SEFA account on June 30 to be returned to the state for the benefit of elementary and secondary education, upon appropriation by the Legislature.
The bill would require the EFA Trust Board to be composed of specified members and would vest the EFA Trust Board with certain powers and duties. The bill would establish 2 accounts within the EFA Trust, the EFA Trust Program Account and the EFA Trust Administrative Account, and would continuously appropriate the moneys in the program account to the EFA Trust Board for purposes of the bill, thereby making an appropriation.
The bill would require the Superintendent of Public Instruction to establish a procedure for the parents and legal guardians of eligible students to apply to establish an EFA or SEFA and submit an executed participation agreement. The bill would authorize the EFA Trust Board to disburse funds from EFAs or SEFAs to eligible schools, defined as full-time private schools. The bill would specify the procedures for participating eligible schools to receive funds disbursed by the EFA Trust Board.
(2)The Classroom Instructional Improvement and Accountability Act, an initiative approved by the voters as Proposition 98 at the November 8, 1988, statewide general election, amended the California Constitution to, among other things, set forth a formula for computing the minimum amount of revenues that the state is required to appropriate for the support of school districts and community college districts based on one of 3 tests in any given fiscal year, one of which is based on the percentage of General Fund revenues appropriated for school districts and community college districts, respectively, in the 198687 fiscal year, and 2 of which are based on, among other things, changes in enrollment.
This bill would require the Legislature to recalculate that minimum education funding guarantee by including eligible students not enrolled in a public elementary or secondary school before the operative date of the act in those minimum funding guarantee calculations based on average daily attendance, as provided. The bill would also require the costs of providing EFA and SEFA deposit amounts for eligible students to be apportioned between the General Fund and the public school district in which those eligible students reside in the same ratio of General Fund and local property tax revenue that would have been used to educate those eligible students in their public school district.
(3)The Personal Income Tax Law, in modified conformity with federal law, generally defines gross income as income from whatever source derived, except as specifically excluded, and provides various exclusions from gross income for purposes of computing tax liability.
This bill would, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, exclude from gross income any amounts received as distribution from an EFA or SEFA, as defined, as part of a participation agreement.
Existing law requires a bill authorizing a new tax expenditure to contain, among other things, specific goals, purposes, and objectives the tax expenditure will achieve, detailed performance indicators, and data collection requirements.
This bill would include additional information required for any bill authorizing a new tax expenditure.
(4)These provisions would become operative on January 1, 2025, only if Senate Constitutional Amendment ____ of the 202324 Regular Session is approved by the voters at the statewide general election on November 5, 2024.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Californias civic, economic, and cultural future requires educational options that prepare every pupil and student for a worthwhile role in our vibrant state.
(b)For years, opponents have tried to undermine efforts to help struggling California pupils and students by stating that adjusting public funds to give pupils and students the best educational chance was wrong. Instead of lifting families out of poverty and inspiring the next generation of entrepreneurs, scientists, and leaders, we have trapped children into a one-size-fits-all system that encourages failure rather than success. Parents watch their children struggle, and our democratically governed public schools have stopped investing in our childrens futures and are leaving the most marginalized pupils and students behind.
(c)Educators are forced to teach to the test for the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), also known as the Nations Report Card, instead of identifying and cultivating their pupils and students potential. And yet California has been ranked significantly lower than the national average at least since 2000 and the latest reports show this state once again is not meeting the minimal education standards.
(d)Throughout the years, research has consistently shown that private school students tend to perform better on standardized tests. For example, grade 8 private school students averaged about 20 points higher than public school pupils on the reading assessment in 2022, and grade 4 students had nearly the same advantage in average scores. The most recent NAEP data shows that private school students score better in almost all subjects as well.
(e)Pupils, students, parents, and educators increasingly want a learning environment where each pupil and student is uniquely known and valued, with customized learning experiences focused on childrens interests and aptitudes, and trust and respect for the parents role in developing and educating their children.
(f)For special education in California, school districts must work with private schools and parents to create the most inclusive and thoughtful services for pupils in special education programs. School districts must spend a proportionate share of federal dollars for these programs, but there are no laws prohibiting school districts from spending additional state funds to help these pupils and parents.
(g)Even though private schools are not obligated to create an individualized education program (IEP), once a student with a disability is enrolled in a religious or other private school, the school district must conduct meetings to develop, review, and revise services that will benefit the child and the plan must go through the same process for procedures required in the development of an IEP.
(h)Yet financial barriers have many parents feeling that they have no options but to send their children to neighborhood schools. Private schools, charter schools, and home schools are achieving better educational results, but these options are unaffordable or unavailable for most pupils and students. ZIP Codes and lotteries determine the educational options available for most low- and middle-income pupils and students.
(i)Before the COVID-19 pandemic, around 10 percent of pupils and students in California were using alternative education options, but the pandemic required families to try alternatives. In 2023, a survey of 3,820 parents of schoolage children showed that more than half of them either considered or are considering a new school. In it, a majority of Hispanic, Latino, and Black parents, about 65 percent, said they were looking into or thinking about a new learning environment for their kids.
(j)California now spends around $23,000 per year for each child in public school, including around $17,000 from state funds. Spending more on the current and outdated system has not created better results, and many low- to middle-class taxpaying families are not given a choice but to send their pupils to one. Allowing parents to decide the school that offers the best options and learning experiences for their pupil or student is a better use of education funds. The increasing demand for alternatives will create a range of exciting educational opportunities that all pupils and students can enjoy.
(k)California is the fifth largest economy in the world, and needs to offer a world-class, individualized, and customized education to every K12 pupil or student in our state in order to continue providing for a sustainable and vibrant economy. As such, the state needs to innovate its education system to encourage our children to discover their unique talents, turn those talents into skills, and use those skills to create value for themselves and for others.
(l)Therefore, the people hereby enact the Education Flex Account Act of 2024. The act includes the following provisions:
(1)During the first year after the act is operative, $8,000 will be available to each pupil and each student, and $16,000 will be available to each pupil and each student with special needs, to be used toward tuition and education expenses at an accredited private school of their choice. The annual amount shall be adjusted each year. An Education Flex Account or Special Education Flex Account will be established at the request of the pupils or students parent or legal guardian.
(2)The Education Flex Account and Special Education Flex Account will be available to the lowest income families the first two years after the act is operative, middle income families the next two years after the act is operative, and all families four years after the act is operative.
(3)All of this will be achieved at no additional cost to taxpayers.
SEC. 2.Article 19.1 (commencing with Section 69995) is added to Chapter 2 of Part 42 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code, to read:19.1.Education Flex Account Act of 202469995.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Education Flex Account Act of 2024.
69995.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Account beneficiary means the eligible student for whom an EFA or SEFA was established by the EFA Trust Board.
(b)Administrative account means the account established within the EFA Trust pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 69995.2 from which the costs of administering the EFA Trust shall be paid.
(c)Costs of administration means the actual costs of the EFA Trust Board to administer EFAs and SEFAs, subject to the limit established in subdivision (d) of Section 69995.3.
(d)EFA means Education Flex Account, an account comprised of funds that may be used for elementary and secondary eligible education expenses for the applicable school year. Any funds deposited in an EFA that are unused, as of June 30, shall be returned to the state for the benefit of elementary and secondary education, upon appropriation by the Legislature.
(e)EFA deposit amount means the amount calculated pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 69995.2.
(f)EFA Trust means the Education Flex Account Trust established by subdivision (a) of Section 69995.2.
(g)EFA Trust Board means the Education Flex Account Trust Board established by subdivision (a) of Section 69995.3.
(h)Elementary and secondary eligible education expenses means the expenses typically associated with the education of an eligible student enrolled in a public elementary or secondary school or enrolled in an eligible school, other than tuition, including, but not limited to, books, school supplies and equipment, academic tutoring, academic testing fees, special needs services of a special needs account beneficiary, transportation to and from school, and school functions. Expenses incurred by an eligible student to attend a community college before high school graduation, including tuition, shall be elementary and secondary eligible education expenses.
(i)Eligible school means a full-time private school, as described in Section 48222, operating in the state and accredited by a regional accrediting agency recognized by the state or the United States Department of Education, or a school that has applied for accreditation, but such application is pending, and the school has not been denied accreditation in the prior two years by the same accrediting agency.
(j)Eligible student means every child eligible to enroll in a public elementary or secondary school and enrolled in an eligible school, except as follows:
(1)During the first two school years following the operative date of this article, an eligible student is a child whose parent or guardians taxable income is less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) per year for a single filer and one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) per year for dual filers.
(2)During the two school years following the period described in paragraph (1), an eligible student is a child whose parent or guardians taxable income is less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) per year for a single filer and two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000) per year for dual filers.
(3)After the periods described in paragraphs (1) and (2), there shall be no income limitation on eligibility.
(k)Individualized education program has the same meaning as that term is described in Section 56345.
(l)Participation agreement means the uniform contract created by the EFA Trust Board that must be executed by the EFA Trust Board and the parent or legal guardian of an eligible student that directs the EFA Trust Board to disburse funds to an eligible school on behalf of the account beneficiary.
(m)Program account means the account created in the EFA Trust pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 69995.2 from which moneys transferred from the General Fund, investment earnings, and other grants, gifts, or appropriations are maintained and segregated into EFAs and SEFAs for eligible students.
(n)SEFA means a Special Education Flex Account, an Education Flex Account for students with special needs, including students with an individualized education program (IEP) or any physical or mental disability. A student for whom funds are expended pursuant to an SEFA shall not also receive funds pursuant to an EFA. Any funds deposited in an SEFA that are unused, as of June 30, shall be returned to the state for the benefit of elementary and secondary education, upon appropriation by the Legislature.
(o)SEFA deposit amount means the amount calculated pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 69995.2.
(p)Tuition means the amount charged by an eligible school to enroll a pupil or student at the school for a particular grade level and registration fees associated with application and enrollment.
(q)Unclaimed funds means funds remaining in an EFA or SEFA at the end of the applicable school year.
69995.2.(a)There is hereby established an instrumentality of the State of California to be known as the Education Flex Account Trust.
(b)Every child eligible to be enrolled in kindergarten, or in an elementary or secondary school, in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, and whose parent or guardian desires to enroll their child in an eligible school, may establish an EFA, or, if applicable, an SEFA, pursuant to this article.
(c)Every child enrolled in an eligible school shall be entitled, pursuant to this article, to a credit to the childs EFA or SEFA for tuition and elementary and secondary eligible education expenses.
(d)Commencing with the first fiscal year following the operative date of this article, on July 1 of each year, the Department of Finance shall determine the annual EFA and SEFA deposit amount for the upcoming school year. The EFA deposit amount for the 202526 school year shall be eight thousand dollars ($8,000). The SEFA deposit amount for the 202526 school year shall be sixteen thousand dollars ($16,000). For subsequent school years, the Department of Finance shall adjust the annual EFA and SEFA deposit amount by the same percentage increase or decrease in the total amount required to be applied by the state for the support of school districts in the current fiscal year, as required by Section 8 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
(e)(1)Each school year the Controller shall transfer an amount of moneys from the General Fund to the EFA Trust equal to the sum of the following:
(A)The EFA deposit amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) multiplied by the number of EFAs established pursuant to subdivision (b).
(B)The SEFA deposit amount determined pursuant to subdivision (d) multiplied by the number of SEFAs established pursuant to subdivision (b).
(2)The EFA or SEFA deposit amount may be adjusted for an EFA or SEFA established after the start of the applicable school year and for a partial school year pursuant to an application submitted under subdivision (b) of Section 69995.4. The Controller shall make at least three transfers to the EFA Trust in each fiscal year, with the first transfer occurring on August 1 and the last transfer occurring on or before June 15. The Controller shall adjust the amount of moneys transferred from the General Fund to the EFA Trust to ensure that the total amount of moneys transferred in a school year equals exactly the amount required to be transferred pursuant to this article. The Controller shall report to the Department of Finance and the Legislature the total amount of moneys transferred from the General Fund to the EFA Trust pursuant to this article on or before June 15 of each year. This article does not prohibit the Legislature from appropriating additional funds to the EFA Trust.
(f)The EFA Trust is hereby established as a fund in the State Treasury. The EFA Trust Program Account and the EFA Trust Administrative Account are hereby established as accounts within the EFA Trust. Notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, the program account is hereby continuously appropriated, without regard to fiscal years, to the EFA Trust Board for purposes of this article. Moneys in the administrative account shall be available for expenditure, upon appropriation, for the purposes specified in this article. Moneys in the EFA Trust shall only be used for purposes of this article and shall not be taken, used, borrowed, or collateralized for any other purpose.
(g)Any unit of federal, state, or local government, or any other person, firm, partnership, or corporation, may make a grant, gift, or other appropriation for deposit into the administrative account or the program account.
69995.3.(a)The purposes, powers, and duties of the EFA Trust are vested in, and shall be exercised by, the Education Flex Account Trust Board, which is hereby established.
(b)The EFA Trust Board shall consist of the following members:
(1)The members of the Scholarshare Investment Board as provided in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 69984.
(2)The Superintendent.
(3)One member representing private elementary and secondary schools, appointed by the Governor.
(4)One member representing parochial and religious elementary and secondary schools, appointed by the Governor.
(c)The EFA Trust Board shall have all the necessary powers and duties provided to the Scholarshare Investment Board under Article 19 (commencing with Section 69980), including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The power to invest moneys in the EFA Trust for the benefit of the EFA Trust and account beneficiaries.
(2)The duty to report publicly investments and investment performance.
(3)The duty to distribute funds from EFAs and SEFAs and audit the EFAs and SEFAs to ensure that all funds disbursed to eligible schools are used by and for the account beneficiary and in furtherance of the act.
(4)The power to accept any grants, gifts, appropriations, and other moneys from any unit of federal, state, or local government or any other person, firm, partnership, or corporation for deposit into the administrative account or the program account.
(5)The duty to return unclaimed funds to the state for the benefit of elementary and secondary education, upon appropriation by the Legislature.
(6)The power to adopt regulations to implement this article.
(d)Moneys transferred by the Controller pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 69995.2 shall be allocated by the EFA Trust Board to the program account and administrative account. All moneys allocated to the program account shall be promptly invested and accounted for separately for each individual EFA and SEFA. All costs of administration, including investment management fees, of the EFA Trust shall be paid out of the administrative account, which shall not exceed, on an annual basis, 1 percent of the total amount of moneys in the program account.
69995.4.(a)The Superintendent shall create an online application for a parent or legal guardian to request that an EFA or SEFA be established for an eligible student and submit an executed participation agreement pursuant to this article. The Superintendent shall also accept applications and executed participation agreements submitted by mail.
(b)The deadline for submitting an application and executed participation agreement for the next succeeding school year shall be April 1. The Superintendent shall establish at least one additional opportunity and deadline for a parent or legal guardian to submit an application and executed participation agreement during the school year. The EFA and SEFA deposit amounts for EFAs or SEFAs established during a school year shall be less than the full EFA or SEFA deposit amount established pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 69995.2.
(c)The parent or legal guardian of an eligible student shall identify the eligible student as the account beneficiary of the EFA or SEFA and execute the participation agreement.
(d)Once an application and participation agreement have been submitted, the Superintendent shall confirm that the child is enrolled in an eligible school and the participation agreement shall be transmitted to the eligible school.
(e)So long as the account beneficiary remains eligible to receive the EFA or SEFA deposit amount and to direct the expenditure of funds pursuant to this article, no additional application or participation agreement shall be required. However, an application and participation agreement shall be amended by the parent or legal guardian if the account beneficiary enrolls in a different eligible school.
(f)The Superintendent shall create an online process for a parent or legal guardian, public school district, eligible school, or any other person to report that a child is no longer eligible or no longer enrolled in an eligible school. Upon receipt of a report, the Superintendent shall inquire and confirm the eligibility status of the child by providing adequate notice to the parent or legal guardian of the child and the school and an opportunity for both to be heard. If the Superintendent determines that a child is no longer eligible, that determination may be appealed by the parent or legal guardian on behalf of the child pursuant to the administrative adjudication procedures described in Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
69995.5.The Superintendent shall do all of the following:
(a)Create an online application for a school to become eligible to receive funds from an EFA or SEFA established pursuant to this article.
(b)Publish on its internet website, and periodically update, a list of eligible schools by name and address.
(c)Provide contact information for each eligible school on its internet website.
(d)Post the tuition and other eligible education expenses charged for each grade level at an eligible school on its internet website.
69995.6.(a)The EFA Trust Board shall establish an EFA or SEFA within the program account for each eligible student who has requested an account from the Superintendent, shall enter into participation agreements pursuant to this article, shall credit each EFA or SEFA with the appropriate EFA or SEFA deposit amount for that eligible student, and shall credit investment earnings of the program account to each EFA or SEFA, as appropriate.
(b)The EFA Trust Board shall provide parents and legal guardians of account beneficiaries with the ability to securely review online EFA or SEFA activity, including EFA or SEFA deposits or credits, EFA or SEFA investment earnings, and EFA or SEFA disbursements to an eligible school on behalf of the account beneficiary. The EFA Trust Board shall protect the privacy of parents, legal guardians, and account beneficiaries.
(c)(1)Pursuant to the terms of an executed participation agreement, and except as provided in paragraph (2), the EFA Trust Board shall disburse funds on behalf of an account beneficiary to an eligible school on a monthly basis.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), the EFA Trust Board may enter into an agreement with an eligible school to provide for a different disbursement schedule.
(d)The EFA Trust Board shall randomly audit funds disbursed from EFAs and SEFAs to ensure student eligibility, student enrollment, student attendance, and school eligibility.
(e)The EFA Trust Board shall withhold any ineligible disbursement made to an eligible school from any future disbursements.
(f)The EFA Trust Board shall create a uniform participation agreement for use by the Superintendent, the EFA Trust Board, and the parents and legal guardians of eligible students. An eligible school identified in a participation agreement shall be a third-party beneficiary of an executed participation agreement.
69995.65.The EFA Trust Board shall adopt regulations to implement this article.
69995.7.(a)The EFA Trust Board shall only disburse funds from an EFA or SEFA to an eligible school.
(b)The state shall not limit the number of eligible schools or the number of students enrolled in an eligible school. The state shall not impose conditions on the eligibility of a private school to receive funds, other than conditions based on any of the following:
(1)Periodic certification that an eligible student is enrolled and attending the eligible school.
(2)Periodic certification that the amount disbursed from an EFA or SEFA is only used for tuition and eligible education expenses.
(3)Accreditation required to obtain status as an eligible school pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 69995.1.
(4)Public disclosure of the receipt and expenditure of EFA or SEFA funds as required by the EFA Trust Board.
(5)The general health and safety standards applicable to the facilities of all private schools operating in the state.
69995.8.A full-time private school may become an eligible school by filing an application with the Superintendent. A full-time private school that becomes an eligible school may accept funds from an EFA or SEFA for the tuition and eligible educational expenses of an account beneficiary who is admitted to the eligible school.
69995.9.(a)Notwithstanding Section 69995.2, and except as provided in subdivision (b), the child of a parent or legal guardian who chooses to educate their child at home pursuant to an affidavit filed pursuant to Section 33190 and in lieu of enrolling in an eligible school shall not be entitled to establish an EFA or SEFA pursuant to this article. This article does not prohibit the state from offering financial aid for education-related expenses to the parents or legal guardians of homeschooled children ineligible for an EFA or SEFA.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the parent or legal guardian of a child enrolled in an eligible school to facilitate homeschooling may establish an EFA or SEFA pursuant to this article.
69995.10.(a)An eligible school shall not share, refund, or rebate any funds received from an EFA or SEFA with or to the parent, legal guardian, or eligible student in any manner.
(b)The EFA Trust Board may terminate and suspend an EFA or SEFA, as applicable, and participation agreement if the parent, legal guardian, or eligible student fails to comply with the terms of the participation agreement with the intent to defraud or misuse the funds distributed on behalf of an account beneficiary upon notice to the parent or legal guardian and an opportunity to be heard. If the EFA Trust Board terminates or suspends an EFA or SEFA, that determination may be appealed by the parent, legal guardian, or eligible student pursuant to the administrative adjudication procedures described in Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 11400) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
69995.11.The Legislature shall provide for the allocation of costs associated with this article as follows:
(a)For the cost of providing an EFA or SEFA deposit amount for an eligible student not enrolled in a public elementary or secondary school before the operative date of this article, the Legislature shall rebase, as necessary, the minimum funding guarantee for school districts, as provided in Section 8 of Article XVI of the California Constitution, to include such eligible students in the definition of average daily attendance as defined in Section 8.1 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
(b)For the costs of providing an EFA or SEFA deposit amount for an eligible student, the cost for that EFA or SEFA deposit amount shall be apportioned between the General Fund and the public school district in which the eligible student resides, in the same ratio of General Fund and local property tax revenue that would have been used to educate that eligible student in the students public school district. The Legislature shall provide for the transfer of funds from a school district to the state as necessary to carry out this provision.
69995.12.This article shall become operative on January 1, 2025, only if Senate Constitutional Amendment ____ of the 202324 Regular Session is approved by the voters at the statewide general election on November 5, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 17132.2 is added to the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:17132.2.(a)For taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, gross income shall not include distributions from an Education Flex Account or Special Education Flex Account pursuant to a participation agreement.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Education Flex Account means an Education Flex Account established under the Education Flex Account Act of 2024 (Article 19.1 (commencing with Section 69995) of Chapter 2 of Part 42 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code).
(2)Participation agreement has the same meaning as that term is defined in subdivision (l) of Section 69995.1 of the Education Code.
(3)Special Education Flex Account means a Special Education Flex Account established under the Education Flex Account Act of 2024 (Article 19.1 (commencing with Section 69995) of Chapter 2 of Part 42 of Division 5 of Title 3 of the Education Code).
(c)(1)For purposes of complying with Section 41, as it pertains to the exclusions from income provided by this section, the Legislature finds and declares the following:
(A)The goal, purpose, and objective of the exclusion from income is to encourage parents and legal guardians to participate in the Education Flex Account or Special Education Flex Account and to maximize the value of the Education Flex Account or Special Education Flex Account.
(B)The performance indicators used to determine whether the exclusion from income is achieving its stated purpose shall be the number of taxpayers receiving distributions from an Education Flex Account or Special Education Flex Account that, but for this section, would have been included in income, and the average dollar value of income so excluded.
(2)(A)No later than July 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the Franchise Tax Board shall submit a report to the Legislature, in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code, that details the number of taxpayers that received distributions from an Education Flex Account or Special Education Flex Account that, but for this section, would have been included in income, and the average dollar value of income so excluded.
(B)The disclosure provisions of this paragraph shall be treated as an exception to Section 19542.
(d)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2025, only if Senate Constitutional Amendment ____ of the 202324 Regular Session is approved by the voters at the statewide general election on November 5, 2024.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2024 | April 24 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 5. Page 3751.) |
| Apr 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Revenue and Taxation] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Catholic Conference | ** Support | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Against | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Against | |
| California Policy Center | ** Support | |
| California School Employees Association | ** Against | |
| California State PTA | ** Against | |
| California Teachers Association | ** Against | |
| Olive Knolls Christian School | ** Support | |
| Protection of The Educational Rights of Kids | ** Support | |
| Save Glendora Schools | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley Association of Conservative Republicans | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: April 24, 2024
Author: | Grove | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Revenue and Taxation. A "do pass" motion should include referral to the Committee on Revenue and Taxation.
SUMMARY
This bill would establish the Education Flex Account (EFA) Act of 2024 only if a Senate Constitutional Amendment (SCA 9, Grove) is approved as part of the November 2024 election.
BACKGROUND
Subdivision (b) of Section 8 of Article XVI of the California Constitution requires the state to spend a minimum amount of funding on school districts and community colleges every fiscal year, based on specific calculations built on a percentage of General Fund revenues or prior-year education appropriations, enrollment, and economic growth.
In 2013, the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) was enacted. The LCFF establishes per-pupil funding targets, with adjustments for different student grade levels, and includes supplemental funding for local educational agencies (LEA) serving students who are low-income, English learners, or foster youth. The LCFF replaced almost all sources of state funding for LEAs, including most categorical programs, with general purpose funding including few spending restrictions.
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Establishes the EFA Act of 2024 and establishes the EFA Trust as a fund within the State Treasury to be administered by the EFA Trust Board.
- Specifies that during the first four school years following the operative date of the act, certain school-aged children are eligible to establish an EFA or a Special Education Flex Account (SEFA), based on their parent’s or guardian’s income. After the first four years, every school-aged child would become EFA-eligible.
- Specifies that every child enrolled in an eligible school shall be entitled to a credit to the child’s account for tuition, elementary and secondary eligible education expenses.
- Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to establish a procedure for the parents and legal guardians of eligible students to apply to establish an EFA and submit an executed participation agreement.
- Authorizes EFA or SEFA fund disbursements to full-time private schools operating in the state that are either accredited or have a pending accreditation.
- Specifies that the child of a parent or legal guardian who chooses to educate their child at home pursuant to an affidavit and in lieu of enrolling in an eligible school shall not be entitled to establish an EFA or SEFA. However, the parent or legal guardian of a child enrolled in a private school to facilitate homeschooling may establish an EFA or SEFA.
- Requires the Legislature to recalculate minimum education funding guarantee (Proposition 98 Guarantee) by including school-aged children not enrolled in a public school in those minimum funding guarantee calculations based on their average daily attendance, as provided.
- Requires the costs of providing EFA deposit amounts to be apportioned between the General Fund and school districts in the same ratio of General Fund and local property tax revenue that would have been used to educate students in their school district.
- Excludes, for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2025, from gross income any amounts received as distribution from an EFA or SEFA.
- Becomes operative on January 1, 2025 only if SCA 9 (Grove, 2024) is approved by the voters at the statewide general election on November 5, 2024.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Many parents believe the current system has created an environment where California public schools are failing and that many K-12 students who graduate are not college ready. Despite spending $1,000 more per student than the national average, California has consistently ranked below the nation in academic achievement among 4th and 8th graders.
“Graduation requirements have been weakened, and the state’s high school exit exam was eliminated to mask the underperformance of public schools. Big disparities in academic performance exist, especially among students of color with African American and Latino students performing below the standards for English Language Arts and Mathematics exams.
“Although school districts work with private schools and parents to create the most inclusive and thoughtful services for students in special education programs, unfortunately, religious families with children in special education programs who want to send their child to a religious private school are excluded from receiving funding.”
- Is this similar to a voucher program? Voucher programs generally allow public funds to be used for private school tuition. EFAs are a type of voucher program, but they are structured differently in that, in addition to private school tuition, EFA funds can be used to purchase other educational services, such as tutoring, textbooks, or online course fees. Under this bill, the state would “rebase” the amount of funding currently apportioned to LEAs as required by the Proposition 98 Guarantee to include private school students and award vouchers to parents who could then use the funding to cover tuition and other services at an eligible public or private school. The policy changes and state and local mechanisms required to implement this bill and its companion constitutional amendment are very complex and would profoundly change how public (and private) education is currently funded. Given that no one knows how many parents and schools would apply for vouchers or move their children from public to private schools, it is difficult to assess the impact of this bill with any meaningful precision.
- Voucher programs in other states. The first publicly-funded voucher program in the country was started in Milwaukee in 1990—the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program. Currently, there are 25 voucher programs in 14 states, including the District of Columbia. The number of voucher programs has grown steadily since 2010, as has the scope of existing programs.
Almost all states have eligibility requirements for their voucher programs, with the most common being students with a documented disability or meeting household income requirements. Other eligibility requirements include attending a low-performing school or district, living in certain geographic regions, or some combination therein. There are two states, Arizona and Nevada, which have EFA programs that do not include eligibility requirements. Arizona expanded their already existing EFA program to be universal in 2017, which will phase in over a few years and be capped at 30,000 student participants. Nevada created its universal program in 2013, but the program is on hold following a 2015 court decision declaring the funding mechanism unconstitutional and program funding has not been restored.
Since the passage of Proposition 98, the voters of California have had two opportunities to vote for tax-funded school vouchers—Proposition 174 in 1993 and Proposition 38 in 2000. Both propositions received about 30 percent voter support.
- Many existing school choice options for California parents. There are two main groups of parents in California already exercising alternative school choice—those that send their children to private school and those that access public school options such as charter schools, magnet schools, or cross-town transfer programs. While the author states that this measure would give parents the option of moving their children from their assigned school to any other accredited school that best meets their needs, state law already provides the following public school options:
- Charter Schools. There are over 1,000 public charter schools in the state that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through grade 12. Parents, teachers, or community members may initiate charter petitions, which include the specific goals and operating procedures for the charter school. While most charter schools offer traditional, classroom-based instruction, about 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
- Magnet Schools. Magnet schools are designed by local authorities to attract parents, guardians, and students who are free to choose the school in which they enroll. These programs and schools are established by district governing boards that can make a wide range of choices depending on their local needs and resources. Magnet schools and programs include those that provide unique instruction in the arts, in various sciences, and in career education. Others reflect a district strategy to achieve racial and ethnic balance. When one or more magnets are established at a particular school, students from across the district may select a magnet with available space.
- District of Choice (DOC) Program. This program allows a student to transfer to any district that has deemed itself a DOC and agreed to accept a specified number of transfers. DOC may not use a selective admissions process. Transfer students generally do not need the consent of their home districts.
- Interdistrict Permits. These allow a student to transfer from one district to another district provided both districts consent to the transfer and the student meets any locally determined conditions. Districts receiving these transfer students may require students to meet certain attendance and/or academic standards.
- Parental employment transfers. These allow a student to transfer into a district if at least one parent is employed within the boundaries of that district and that district has chosen to accept parental employment transfers. Transfer students generally do not need the consent of their home districts.
- The Open Enrollment Act. This option, for low-performing schools, allows a student attending a school with low performance on state tests to transfer to another school inside or outside the district that has a higher level of performance and space available. Transfer students generally do not need the consent of their home districts.
Beyond the public school options, about 7.5 percent of California students are enrolled in private schools, a proportion that has gradually dropped over the past two decades from about 10 percent. Interestingly, these are the families that would immediately benefit from this bill because, even though they have already chosen to send their kids to private school, they would be eligible for the same voucher as all other parents.
- How would low-income families be affected? Based on existing research, low-income families may likely participate in a voucher program, especially given recent polls that show growing parental support for school choice in disadvantaged communities. However, among these families, it is the better- educated parents, who express strong commitments to education, that most often take advantage of voucher programs. While this bill includes a four-year phase in based on income, would it be the most disadvantaged children in the state—those from low-income families with minimally educated parents—that would be left behind in struggling public schools with even fewer resources upon full implementation? How does the creation of an unregulated voucher program square with the principles of the LCFF, which targets additional resources to the communities with the highest proportions of English-learning, low-income, and foster youth students?
- Available research on the impact of voucher programs on student achievement is mixed at best. Research on existing voucher programs is relatively limited because prior to 2010, there were a very small number of programs in the country. Additionally, it is difficult to measure the effects of voucher programs on student performance because there are oftentimes other factors, such as class size, school safety issues, or peer effects, that affect academic progress. Finally, the research tends to lack any analysis on the quality of the private schools that students choose to attend. Contrary to popular belief, while many private schools may produce better student outcomes than public schools, the reverse can also be true.
Despite these challenges, existing research on voucher programs shows mixed results. Generally, students attending private school through a voucher program tend to have similar academic outcomes to their peers in traditional public schools, with some studies finding that voucher students performed worse academically than their peers in traditional public schools. However, other research suggests that student performance in voucher programs may improve over time. Specifically, a multi-year study of Milwaukee’s voucher program, the oldest in the country, found that private school-attending students in lower grades tended to have lower academic performance in reading and science than their peers in public schools, while students in upper grades had better academic outcomes in reading and science than their peers. In addition, some students participating in the voucher program were one to two years behind academically when first enrolling in a private school, and study results suggest that attending private school through the voucher program helped these students catch up to their grade level.
Based on the limited research, it appears that children with parents who eagerly pursue vouchers and move their children to private schools can potentially perform better than children who remain in struggling public schools. Would these achievement results continue under a program that is applied statewide? Is this a likely way to raise achievement for students who would remain in urban and suburban public schools?
- Voucher programs face legal challenges. Several state or local voucher programs across the country have faced legal challenges, often centered on the separation of church and state debate. Specifically, whether sending public funds to sectarian private schools contradicts the Establishment Clause of the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment and a series of approximately 36 state constitutional amendments prohibiting the states from providing public funds to religious schools—collectively known as the Blaine Amendments. The outcomes of these challenges have been a mix of upholding the programs and finding them unconstitutional.
- Other policy considerations. When considering the creation of a state-funded EFA system, many more factors must be considered beyond what is described above. The funding impact of this bill is difficult to assess—the Proposition 98 Guarantee would be “rebased” to include private school student average daily attendance (ADA) but public funding would then be diverted away from traditional public schools to parents that currently enroll their children in private schools. It is unclear whether including private school student attendance in the calculation of the Proposition 98 Guarantee would cover the costs of funding these students’ EFAs. If not, the result would be less per-pupil state aid available to public school districts and charter schools.
Other policy considerations include, but are not limited to, the way in which the rights of students with disabilities would continue to be protected, whether low-income parents would receive a voucher amount that could cover private school tuition (the cost of which would likely rise as a result of this bill), whether private schools should be required to administer state testing for student outcome comparison purposes, what level of accountability private schools would be subjected to by state taxpayers, and whether parents would face admissions discrimination within an unregulated voucher system.
- This bill would create costs between $4 and $6 billion, paid by cuts to public education or other areas in the state budget. This bill is substantially similar to a recent proposed constitutional and statutory initiative related to funding for students attending private schools (A.G. File No. 21-0011, Amendment #1). In its analysis of that initiative, the Legislative Analyst’s Office states the following:
“This measure would affect the state budget and the budgets of public schools. The magnitude of these effects largely depends on (1) the number of participating students, and (2) how public and private schools respond to the measure.
“The 471,000 students who already attend private schools likely would be the first students to register for this program. In addition, some of the 84,000 students currently attending homeschool probably would switch to participating private schools. Since these students currently receive no state funding, their participation represents an additional cost to the state. Participation probably would be less than 100 percent, however, on the lower end, if 308,000 students participated (representing 60 percent of current private school students and 30 percent of homeschool students switching to private schools), the annual state cost at full implementation would be about $4 billion. On the high end, if 462,000 students participated (representing 90 percent of current private school students and 45 percent of homeschool students switching), the annual state cost would be about $6 billion. The state generally would pay for these costs through reductions to funding for public schools (as the measure allows) and/or reductions to other state programs supported by the state General Fund.”
- Arguments in support. Proponents argue that these programs empower parents by providing them with choices about where and how to educate their children, and provide students, particularly at-risk or underserved students, with better education options. They also argue that free-market competition among public and private schools improves overall school quality through competition. Interestingly, some note that arguments in favor of school vouchers shifted over the years, with less discussion about the effects of vouchers on student achievement and more discussion about both the value of choice as a right in itself and the beneficial competitive effect of voucher programs on public schools.
- Arguments in opposition. Opponents argue that voucher programs divert public dollars to private schools, but without the same accountability or special education requirements as public schools. They express concerns that voucher programs divert motivated parents and students from underfunded public schools, leaving behind a larger number of disadvantaged students with fewer resources. Opponents also point out that it may be difficult for lower-income families to benefit from voucher programs, as the amount of money available through a voucher may not always cover the full costs of private school. Some raise concerns about public dollars funding religiously-affiliated private schools as a potential violation of the constitutional separation of church and state, as well as the potential for religious discrimination. Finally, some argue that these programs may potentially benefit only a small number of children without providing the comprehensive reforms needed to strengthen the entire public education system.
- Related Legislation
SCA 9 (Grove, 2024) proposes to amend Article IX of the State Constitution to: (1) allow the state to disburse funds and other public benefits to educational institutions irrespective of their religious affiliation, and (2) include the ADA of all children who are otherwise eligible to enroll in public kindergarten schools, elementary schools, and secondary schools but have chosen to fund their kindergarten, elementary, or secondary education with an EFA.
SUPPORT
California Policy Center (sponsor)
California Catholic Conference
De La Salle High School
Olive Knolls Christian School
Protection of the Educational Rights of Kids
Save Glendora Schools
Silicon Valley Association of Conservative Republicans
15 individuals
OPPOSITION
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California School Employees Association
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):