SB 1231: Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act: environmental advertising.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)The Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act covers certain single-use packaging and plastic single-use food service ware, as provided. As part of its comprehensive statutory scheme, the act requires producers of those covered materials to reduce and recycle the covered plastic material and to ensure that covered materials that are offered for sale, distributed, or imported in or into the state on or after January 1, 2032, are recyclable or compostable, as provided. The act authorizes the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery to identify materials that are trending toward meeting specified requirements and criteria to be considered recyclable within the state, as provided, and requires those material types and forms to be considered and labeled as recyclable in the state as long as the material types and forms meet certain requirements.
This bill would instead authorize a producer or group of producers of products using covered materials to to, on or before January 1, 2026, petition the department to identify material types and forms that meet those specified requirements and criteria to be considered as recyclable in the state. The bill would require the department to review the petition and approve or deny it within 60 days of receipt, as provided.
(2)Existing law provides that a product or packaging that displays a chasing arrows symbol, among other symbols, statements, or directions, is deemed to be a deceptive or misleading claim unless the product or packaging is considered recyclable pursuant to statewide recyclability criteria and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock used in the production of new products or packaging, except for products or packaging manufactured up to 18 months after the date the department publishes or updates a specified material characterization study, as provided. Existing
This bill would additionally exempt from the above-described provisions any product or packaging that has been manufactured up to 24 months after the date the department publishes its first update to a specified material characterization study and for which a producer or group of producers has submitted a specified petition to the department.
(3)Existing law provides that a product or packaging is not considered recyclable in the state unless the product or packaging meets specified criteria, including that the product or packaging does not contain an intentionally added chemical identified pursuant to specified regulations.
This bill would expand that exemption to up to 24 months after the date the department publishes or updates the specified material characterization study. The bill would exclude chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with a specified regulation governing the disclosure of chemicals on a list produced under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65) from the intentionally added chemicals that would affect whether a product or package is considered recyclable in this state.
(1)The Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act covers certain single-use packaging and plastic single-use food service ware, as provided. As part of its comprehensive statutory scheme, the act requires producers of those covered materials to reduce and recycle the covered plastic material and to ensure that covered materials that are offered for sale, distributed, or imported in or into the state on or after January 1, 2032, are recyclable or compostable, as provided. The act authorizes the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery to identify materials that are trending toward meeting specified requirements and criteria to be considered recyclable within the state, as provided, and requires those material types and forms to be considered and labeled as recyclable in the state as long as the material types and forms meet certain requirements.
This bill would instead authorize a producer or group of producers of products using covered materials to petition the department to identify material types and forms that meet those specified requirements and criteria to be considered as recyclable in the state. The bill would require the department to review the petition and approve or deny it within 60 days of receipt, as provided.
(2)Existing law provides that a product or packaging that displays a chasing arrows symbol, among other symbols, statements, or directions, is deemed to be a deceptive or misleading claim unless the product or packaging is considered recyclable pursuant to statewide recyclability criteria and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock used in the production of new products or packaging, except for products or packaging manufactured up to 18 months after the date the department publishes or updates a specified material characterization study, as provided. Existing law provides that a product or packaging is not considered recyclable in the state unless the product or packaging meets specified criteria, including that the product or packaging does not contain an intentionally added chemical identified pursuant to specified regulations.
This bill would expand that exemption to up to 24 months after the date the department publishes or updates the specified material characterization study. The bill would exclude chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with a specified regulation governing the disclosure of chemicals on a list produced under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65) from the intentionally added chemicals that would affect whether a product or package is considered recyclable in this state.
The department shall do all of the following:
(a)(1)By July 1, 2024, the department shall establish and post on its internet website a list of covered material categories. The department may consider material types and forms referenced in waste characterization studies or material characterization studies for determining the categories.
(2)The department shall conduct and publish on its internet website a characterization study of covered material categories that are disposed of in California landfills. The departments activities pursuant to this paragraph, including the departments determination of the appropriate facilities to include in the study, are exempt from Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(3)(A)For the departments first material characterization study conducted pursuant to paragraph (2), which the department shall complete on or before July 1, 2025, the department shall conduct disposal-based characterization studies to determine the approximate amount of covered material disposed of in California landfills.
(B)A producer or group of producers may petition the department department, on or before January 1, 2026, to identify material types and forms that are trending toward meeting the requirements in subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51 and measurable increase of statewide collection and sorting rates through either statewide recycling programs or alternative programs, such as take-back systems, and for which the continued increase in the collection, sorting, and viable responsible end market development the department determines will be disrupted by a loss of a recyclable designation. The department shall approve or deny a petition within 60 days of receipt of the petition. In reviewing a petition, the department may consider information provided in the petition as well as information received through the departments characterization study. A denial shall be accompanied by a written statement detailing the reasons for the denial and additional information that may be helpful in approving future petitions. Identified material types and forms shall be considered recyclable in the state and may be labeled as recyclable, notwithstanding subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51, so long as the material types and forms satisfy subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51 and until the material types and forms are a part of, and in compliance with, a program described in paragraph (6) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51.
(4)The department shall update the material characterization study required pursuant to this subdivision in 2028, 2030, 2032, and at least every four years thereafter.
(5)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), the department may publish additional information that was not available at the time of the most recent periodic material characterization study regarding the appropriate characterization of material types and forms.
(6)For purposes of studying a representative sample of material types and forms in the state, within 90 calendar days of a department request, a transfer, processing, or recycling facility shall allow for periodic sampling conducted by a designated representative of the department on a mutually agreed upon date and time. The department shall not require a periodic sampling of a transfer, processing, or recycling facility if that facility was sampled during the previous 24 months.
(7)For each material characterization study conducted pursuant to this subdivision, the department shall publish on its internet website the preliminary findings of the study and conduct a public meeting to present the preliminary findings and receive public comments. The public meeting shall occur at least 30 calendar days after the department publishes the preliminary findings. After receiving and considering public comments, and within 60 calendar days of the public meeting, the department shall finalize and publish on its internet website the findings of the study.
(b)(1)By January 1, 2026, the department shall calculate and publish on its internet website the current recycling rates being achieved in the state for each covered material category. These recycling rates shall be deemed to meet the description in subdivision (g) of Section 11340.9 of the Government Code and may be filed by the Office of Administrative Law, at the request of the department, pursuant to Section 11343.8 of the Government Code.
(2)In determining a recycling rate, the department may consider data gathered pursuant to any of the following, including any amendments thereto:
(A)Chapter 746 of the Statutes of 2015.
(B)Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 42370).
(C)Chapter 395 of the Statutes of 2016.
(D)Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 42300).
(E)Division 12.1 (commencing with Section 14500).
(F)Chapter 5.7. 5.7 (commencing with Section 42355).
(G)Data voluntarily provided by local jurisdictions.
(H)Data and information received from producers.
(I)Any other relevant data and information received by the department.
(c)By January 1, 2024, the department shall publish on its internet website a list of covered material categories that are, based on available collection and processing infrastructure and recycling markets, deemed recyclable as of January 1, 2024. Covered material is deemed recyclable if it meets the requirements of Section 17989.2 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section existed on January 1, 2023, and Section 42355.51. The list shall include covered material categories identified by the department and considered recyclable pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51.
(d)By January 1, 2024, the department shall create and post on its internet website a list of covered material categories that are deemed compostable as of January 1, 2024. Covered material is deemed compostable if it meets the requirements to be labeled as compostable pursuant to Chapter 5.7 (commencing with Section 42355).
(e)The department shall determine a process for updating the lists created pursuant to subdivisions (c) and (d) to either add covered material categories that are deemed to meet all of the criteria in either subdivision (c) or (d) or remove covered material categories if they can no longer be deemed recyclable or compostable pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d). As part of the process, the department shall update the list at least annually until January 1, 2032. After January 1, 2032, the department shall regularly, but no less than once every two years, evaluate the list to determine if it is still accurate and update it as needed. Covered material categories deemed to be recyclable or compostable as of January 1, 2032, and listed pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) shall be deemed to be compliant with subdivision (b) of Section 42050 until and unless the department determines that the covered material category no longer meets the requirements of subdivision (c) or (d).
(f)(1)The department shall determine a process for updating the rates published pursuant to subdivision (b). The department shall update the list at least every two years and shall regularly, but no less than once every two years, evaluate the list of rates to determine whether the rates are still accurate. After evaluation, the department may amend the list to remove, add, or change rates. The department shall post any updates to the list on its internet website.
(2)A producer may demonstrate compliance with the rates in subdivision (c) of Section 42050 by submitting to the department evidence that the particular type of covered material meets the applicable recycling rate by reference to a recycling rate on the departments list or through another mechanism approved by the department.
(3)A producer that seeks to have a rate included or changed on the list, or a covered material category added to the list, may be required by the department to submit data for purposes of the departments determination of the rate to include on the list or the appropriateness of adding the category.
(4)Publication of and updates made to the list pursuant to this subdivision are exempt from Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 42355.51 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:42355.51.(a)A person shall not offer for sale, sell, distribute, or import into the state any product or packaging for which a deceptive or misleading claim about the recyclability of the product or packaging is made.
(b)(1)Subject to paragraph (2), a product or packaging that displays a chasing arrows symbol, a chasing arrows symbol surrounding a resin identification code, or any other symbol or statement indicating the product or packaging is recyclable, or otherwise directing the consumer to recycle the product or packaging, is deemed to be a deceptive or misleading claim pursuant to this section and Section 17580.5 of the Business and Professions Code unless the product or packaging is considered recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d) and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock used in the production of new products or packaging.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not apply to either any of the following:
(A)Any product or packaging that is manufactured up to 24 18 months after the date the department publishes the first material characterization study required pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), or before January 1, 2024, whichever is later.
(B)Any product or packaging manufactured up to 24 18 months after the date the department updates the material characterization study pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), if the product or packaging satisfied or, for a new product or packaging, would have satisfied, the requirements to be considered recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d) before the publication of the updated study.
(C)Any product or packaging manufactured up to 24 months after the date the department publishes its first update to the material characterization study pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) and for which a producer or group of producers has submitted a petition to the department pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 42061.
(3)Subject to paragraph (2), for a product or packaging that is not considered to be recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d), all of the following apply:
(A)Displaying a chasing arrows symbol or any other statement indicating the product is recyclable directly on the product shall be deemed to be deceptive or misleading pursuant to this section and Section 17580.5 of the Business and Professions Code.
(B)If a product or packaging has multiple material types, a chasing arrows symbol or statement indicating recyclability may be displayed on the external packaging that is considered to be recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d) if the chasing arrows symbol or statement makes clear in the same or greater font, font size, or symbol size which other components of the product or packaging are not recyclable.
(C)Displaying a chasing arrows symbol or any other statement indicating recyclability on packaging containing a consumable product shall, for purposes of this section, be deemed to refer only to the packaging. For purposes of this subparagraph, consumable product means a commodity that is intended to be used and not disposed of.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following do not constitute a deceptive or misleading claim about the recyclability of the product or packaging pursuant to this section or Section 17580.5 of the Business and Professions Code:
(1)A person using a chasing arrows symbol in combination with a clearly visible line placed at a 45-degree angle over the chasing arrows symbol to convey that an item is not recyclable.
(2)A consumer good that is required by any federal or California law or regulation to display a chasing arrows symbol, including, but not limited to, Section 103(b)(1) of the federal Mercury-Containing and Rechargeable Battery Management Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 14322(b)(1)) and Section 25215.65 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Directing a consumer to compost or properly dispose of a consumer good through an organics recycling program.
(4)A resin identification code placed inside a solid equilateral triangle.
(d)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, in order to provide information to the public sufficient for evaluating whether a product or packaging is recyclable in the state according to the criteria set forth in paragraph (2) and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock used in the production of new products or packaging, the department shall do both of the following:
(A)(i)Update the regulations promulgated pursuant to Section 41821.5 to include both of the following in the information to be submitted to the department pursuant to that section:
(I)How the material collected or processed by the operations and facilities was collected.
(II)What material types and forms are actively recovered, and not considered contaminants, by the operation or facility.
(ii)The department shall publish the information required pursuant to clause (i) in a form the department deems appropriate for achieving the purpose of this section consistent with the requirements of paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 41821.5.
(B)(i)To get a representative sample of recycling programs in the state, the department shall conduct and publish on its internet website a characterization study of material types and forms that are collected, sorted, sold, or transferred by solid waste facilities deemed appropriate by the department for inclusion in the study. The departments activities pursuant to this subparagraph, including the departments determination of the appropriate facilities to include in the study, are exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(ii)The department shall update the material characterization study required pursuant to this subparagraph every five years, with the first update being issued by the department in 2027.
(iii)Notwithstanding clauses (i) and (ii), the department may publish additional information that was not available at the time of the most recent periodic material characterization study regarding the appropriate characterization of material types and forms.
(iv)For purposes of studying a representative sample of material types and forms in the state, within 90 days of a department request, a facility shall allow for periodic sampling conducted by a designated representative of the department on a mutually-agreed upon date and time. The department shall not request a periodic sampling of a facility if that facility was sampled during the previous 24 months.
(v)For each material characterization study conducted pursuant to this subparagraph, the department shall publish on its internet website the preliminary findings of the study and conduct a public meeting to present the preliminary findings and receive public comments. The public meeting shall occur at least 30 days after the department publishes the preliminary findings. After receiving and considering public comments, and within 60 days of the public meeting, the department shall finalize and publish on its internet website the findings of the study.
(2)Subject to paragraph (3), a product or packaging is considered recyclable in the state if, based on information published by the department pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1), the product or packaging is of a material type and form that meets both of the following requirements:
(A)The material type and form is collected for recycling by recycling programs for jurisdictions that collectively encompass at least 60 percent of the population of the state.
(B)(i)The material type and form is sorted into defined streams for recycling processes by large volume transfer or processing facilities, as defined in regulations adopted pursuant to Section 43020, that process materials and collectively serve at least 60 percent of recycling programs statewide, with the defined streams sent to and reclaimed at a reclaiming facility consistent with the requirements of the Basel Convention.
(ii)The department may adopt regulations modifying this requirement to encompass transfer or processing facilities other than large volume transfer or processing facilities, as the department deems appropriate for achieving the purposes of this section.
(3)A product or packaging shall not be considered recyclable in the state unless the product or packaging meets all of the following criteria, as applicable:
(A)For plastic packaging, the plastic packaging is designed to not include any components, inks, adhesives, or labels that prevent the recyclability of the packaging according to the APR Design Guide published by the Association of Plastic Recyclers.
(B)For plastic products and non-plastic nonplastic products and packaging, the product or packaging is designed to ensure recyclability and does not include any components, inks, adhesives, or labels that prevent the recyclability of the product or packaging.
(C)The product or packaging does not contain an intentionally added chemical identified pursuant to the regulations implementing subparagraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 42370.2, excluding chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 17989.2 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(D)The product or packaging is not made from plastic or fiber that contains perfluoroalkyl or polyfluoroalkyl substances or PFAS that meets either of the following criteria:
(i)PFAS that a manufacturer has intentionally added to a product or packaging and that have a functional or technical effect in the product or packaging, including the PFAS components of intentionally added chemicals and PFAS that are intentional breakdown products of an added chemical that also have a functional or technical effect in the product.
(ii)The presence of PFAS in a product or product component or packaging or packaging component at or above 100 parts per million, as measured in total organic flourine.
(4)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging is recyclable in the state if the product or packaging has a demonstrated recycling rate of at least 75 percent, meaning that not less than 75 percent of the product or packaging sorted and aggregated in the state is reprocessed into new products or packaging.
(5)(A)Before January 1, 2030, notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging not collected pursuant to a curbside collection program is recyclable in the state if the non-curbside collection program recovers at least 60 percent of the product or packaging in the program and the material has sufficient commercial value to be marketed for recycling and be transported at the end of its useful life to a transfer, processing, or recycling facility to be sorted and aggregated into defined streams by material type and form.
(B)After January 1, 2030, notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging not collected pursuant to a curbside collection program is recyclable in the state if the non-curbside collection program recovers at least 75 percent of the product or packaging in the program and the material has sufficient commercial value to be marketed for recycling and be transported at the end of its useful life to a transfer, processing, or recycling facility to be sorted and aggregated into defined streams by material type and form.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging is recyclable in the state if the product or packaging is part of, and in compliance with, a program established pursuant to state or federal law on or after January 1, 2022, governing the recyclability or disposal of that product or packaging if the director determines that the product or packaging will not increase contamination of curbside recycling or deceive consumers as to the recyclability of the product or packaging.
(7)The information published by the department pursuant to paragraph (1) shall not limit the discretion of a local agency under existing law to decide whether, and to what extent, a material type or form shall be accepted by a local recycling program.
(e)For purposes of this section, chasing arrows symbol has the meaning set forth in subdivision (f) of Section 17580 of the Business and Professions Code.
(f)Consistent with the waste hierarchy established pursuant to Section 40051, and pursuant to Section 40180, for purposes of this section, recycling, recyclable, and recyclability do not include transformation, as defined in Section 40201, EMSW conversion, or production of fuels.
The department shall do all of the following:
(a)(1)By July 1, 2024, the department shall establish and post on its internet website a list of covered material categories. The department may consider material types and forms referenced in waste characterization studies or material characterization studies for determining the categories.
(2)The department shall conduct and publish on its internet website a characterization study of covered material categories that are disposed of in California landfills. The departments activities pursuant to this paragraph, including the departments determination of the appropriate facilities to include in the study, are exempt from Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(3)(A)For the departments first material characterization study conducted pursuant to paragraph (2), which the department shall complete on or before July 1, 2025, the department shall conduct disposal-based characterization studies to determine the approximate amount of covered material disposed of in California landfills.
(B)The department shall, on or before January 1, 2024, report to the Legislature in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code on the status of material types relative to the requirements in subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51. When updating information pursuant to clause (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51, the department may A producer or group of producers may petition the department to identify materials material types and forms that are trending toward meeting the requirements in subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51 and measurable increase of statewide collection and sorting rates through either statewide recycling programs or alternative programs, such as take-back systems, and for which the continued increase in the collection, sorting, and viable responsible end market development the department determines will be disrupted by a loss of a recyclable designation. Those The department shall approve or deny a petition within 60 days of receipt of the petition. In reviewing a petition, the department may consider information provided in the petition as well as information received through the departments characterization study. A denial shall be accompanied by a written statement detailing the reasons for the denial and additional information that may be helpful in approving future petitions. Identified material types and forms shall be considered recyclable in the state and may be labeled as recyclable, notwithstanding subparagraphs (A) and (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51, so long as the material types and forms satisfy subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51 and until the material types and forms are a part of, and in compliance with, a program described in paragraph (6) of subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51.
(4)The department shall update the material characterization study required pursuant to this subdivision in 2028, 2030, 2032, and at least every four years thereafter.
(5)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), the department may publish additional information that was not available at the time of the most recent periodic material characterization study regarding the appropriate characterization of material types and forms.
(6)For purposes of studying a representative sample of material types and forms in the state, within 90 calendar days of a department request, a transfer, processing, or recycling facility shall allow for periodic sampling conducted by a designated representative of the department on a mutually agreed upon date and time. The department shall not require a periodic sampling of a transfer, processing, or recycling facility if that facility was sampled during the previous 24 months.
(7)For each material characterization study conducted pursuant to this subdivision, the department shall publish on its internet website the preliminary findings of the study and conduct a public meeting to present the preliminary findings and receive public comments. The public meeting shall occur at least 30 calendar days after the department publishes the preliminary findings. After receiving and considering public comments, and within 60 calendar days of the public meeting, the department shall finalize and publish on its internet website the findings of the study.
(b)(1)By January 1, 2026, the department shall calculate and publish on its internet website the current recycling rates being achieved in the state for each covered material category. These recycling rates shall be deemed to meet the description in subdivision (g) of Section 11340.9 of the Government Code and may be filed by the Office of Administrative Law, at the request of the department, pursuant to Section 11343.8 of the Government Code.
(2)In determining a recycling rate, the department may consider data gathered pursuant to any of the following, including any amendments thereto:
(A)Chapter 746 of the Statutes of 2015.
(B)Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 42370).
(C)Chapter 395 of the Statutes of 2016.
(D)Chapter 5.5 (commencing with Section 42300).
(E)Division 12.1 (commencing with Section 14500).
(F)Chapter 5.7. (commencing with Section 42355).
(G)Data voluntarily provided by local jurisdictions.
(H)Data and information received from producers.
(I)Any other relevant data and information received by the department.
(c)By January 1, 2024, the department shall publish on its internet website a list of covered material categories that are, based on available collection and processing infrastructure and recycling markets, deemed recyclable as of January 1, 2024. Covered material is deemed recyclable if it meets the requirements of Section 17989.2 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations, as that section existed on January 1, 2023, and Section 42355.51. The list shall include covered material categories identified by the department and considered recyclable pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 42355.51.
(d)By January 1, 2024, the department shall create and post on its internet website a list of covered material categories that are deemed compostable as of January 1, 2024. Covered material is deemed compostable if it meets the requirements to be labeled as compostable pursuant to Chapter 5.7 (commencing with Section 42355).
(e)The department shall determine a process for updating the lists created pursuant to subdivisions (c) and (d) to either add covered material categories that are deemed to meet all of the criteria in either subdivision (c) or (d) or remove covered material categories if they can no longer be deemed recyclable or compostable pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d). As part of the process, the department shall update the list at least annually until January 1, 2032. After January 1, 2032, the department shall regularly, but no less than once every two years, evaluate the list to determine if it is still accurate and update it as needed. Covered material categories deemed to be recyclable or compostable as of January 1, 2032, and listed pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) shall be deemed to be compliant with subdivision (b) of Section 42050 until and unless the department determines that the covered material category no longer meets the requirements of subdivision (c) or (d).
(f)(1)The department shall determine a process for updating the rates published pursuant to subdivision (b). The department shall update the list at least every two years and shall regularly, but no less than once every two years, evaluate the list of rates to determine whether the rates are still accurate. After evaluation, the department may amend the list to remove, add, or change rates. The department shall post any updates to the list on its internet website.
(2)A producer may demonstrate compliance with the rates in subdivision (c) of Section 42050 by submitting to the department evidence that the particular type of covered material meets the applicable recycling rate by reference to a recycling rate on the departments list or through another mechanism approved by the department.
(3)A producer that seeks to have a rate included or changed on the list, or a covered material category added to the list, may be required by the department to submit data for purposes of the departments determination of the rate to include on the list or the appropriateness of adding the category.
(4)Publication of and updates made to the list pursuant to this subdivision are exempt from Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SEC. 2.Section 42355.51 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:42355.51.(a)A person shall not offer for sale, sell, distribute, or import into the state any product or packaging for which a deceptive or misleading claim about the recyclability of the product or packaging is made.
(b)(1)Subject to paragraph (2), a product or packaging that displays a chasing arrows symbol, a chasing arrows symbol surrounding a resin identification code, or any other symbol or statement indicating the product or packaging is recyclable, or otherwise directing the consumer to recycle the product or packaging, is deemed to be a deceptive or misleading claim pursuant to this section and Section 17580.5 of the Business and Professions Code unless the product or packaging is considered recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d) and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock used in the production of new products or packaging.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not apply to either of the following:
(A)Any product or packaging that is manufactured up to 18 24 months after the date the department publishes the first material characterization study required pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), or before January 1, 2024, whichever is later.
(B)Any product or packaging manufactured up to 18 24 months after the date the department updates the material characterization study pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), if the product or packaging satisfied or, for a new product or packaging, would have satisfied, the requirements to be considered recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d) before the publication of the updated study.
(3)Subject to paragraph (2), for a product or packaging that is not considered to be recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d), all of the following apply:
(A)Displaying a chasing arrows symbol or any other statement indicating the product is recyclable directly on the product shall be deemed to be deceptive or misleading pursuant to this section and Section 17580.5 of the Business and Professions Code.
(B)If a product or packaging has multiple material types, a chasing arrows symbol or statement indicating recyclability may be displayed on the external packaging that is considered to be recyclable in the state pursuant to subdivision (d) if the chasing arrows symbol or statement makes clear in the same or greater font, font size, or symbol size which other components of the product or packaging are not recyclable.
(C)Displaying a chasing arrows symbol or any other statement indicating recyclability on packaging containing a consumable product shall, for purposes of this section, be deemed to refer only to the packaging. For purposes of this subparagraph, consumable product means a commodity that is intended to be used and not disposed of.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following do not constitute a deceptive or misleading claim about the recyclability of the product or packaging pursuant to this section or Section 17580.5 of the Business and Professions Code:
(1)A person using a chasing arrows symbol in combination with a clearly visible line placed at a 45-degree angle over the chasing arrows symbol to convey that an item is not recyclable.
(2)A consumer good that is required by any federal or California law or regulation to display a chasing arrows symbol, including, but not limited to, Section 103(b)(1) of the federal Mercury-Containing and Rechargeable Battery Management Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 14322(b)(1)) and Section 25215.65 of the Health and Safety Code.
(3)Directing a consumer to compost or properly dispose of a consumer good through an organics recycling program.
(4)A resin identification code placed inside a solid equilateral triangle.
(d)(1)On or before January 1, 2024, in order to provide information to the public sufficient for evaluating whether a product or packaging is recyclable in the state according to the criteria set forth in paragraph (2) and is of a material type and form that routinely becomes feedstock used in the production of new products or packaging, the department shall do both of the following:
(A)(i)Update the regulations promulgated pursuant to Section 41821.5 to include both of the following in the information to be submitted to the department pursuant to that section:
(I)How the material collected or processed by the operations and facilities was collected.
(II)What material types and forms are actively recovered, and not considered contaminants, by the operation or facility.
(ii)The department shall publish the information required pursuant to clause (i) in a form the department deems appropriate for achieving the purpose of this section consistent with the requirements of paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 41821.5.
(B)(i)To get a representative sample of recycling programs in the state, the department shall conduct and publish on its internet website a characterization study of material types and forms that are collected, sorted, sold, or transferred by solid waste facilities deemed appropriate by the department for inclusion in the study. The departments activities pursuant to this subparagraph, including the departments determination of the appropriate facilities to include in the study, are exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
(ii)The department shall update the material characterization study required pursuant to this subparagraph every five years, with the first update being issued by the department in 2027.
(iii)Notwithstanding clauses (i) and (ii), the department may publish additional information that was not available at the time of the most recent periodic material characterization study regarding the appropriate characterization of material types and forms.
(iv)For purposes of studying a representative sample of material types and forms in the state, within 90 days of a department request, a facility shall allow for periodic sampling conducted by a designated representative of the department on a mutually-agreed upon date and time. The department shall not request a periodic sampling of a facility if that facility was sampled during the previous 24 months.
(v)For each material characterization study conducted pursuant to this subparagraph, the department shall publish on its internet website the preliminary findings of the study and conduct a public meeting to present the preliminary findings and receive public comments. The public meeting shall occur at least 30 days after the department publishes the preliminary findings. After receiving and considering public comments, and within 60 days of the public meeting, the department shall finalize and publish on its internet website the findings of the study.
(2)Subject to paragraph (3), a product or packaging is considered recyclable in the state if, based on information published by the department pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1), the product or packaging is of a material type and form that meets both of the following requirements:
(A)The material type and form is collected for recycling by recycling programs for jurisdictions that collectively encompass at least 60 percent of the population of the state.
(B)(i)The material type and form is sorted into defined streams for recycling processes by large volume transfer or processing facilities, as defined in regulations adopted pursuant to Section 43020, that process materials and collectively serve at least 60 percent of recycling programs statewide, with the defined streams sent to and reclaimed at a reclaiming facility consistent with the requirements of the Basel Convention.
(ii)The department may adopt regulations modifying this requirement to encompass transfer or processing facilities other than large volume transfer or processing facilities, as the department deems appropriate for achieving the purposes of this section.
(3)A product or packaging shall not be considered recyclable in the state unless the product or packaging meets all of the following criteria, as applicable:
(A)For plastic packaging, the plastic packaging is designed to not include any components, inks, adhesives, or labels that prevent the recyclability of the packaging according to the APR Design Guide published by the Association of Plastic Recyclers.
(B)For plastic products and non-plastic products and packaging, the product or packaging is designed to ensure recyclability and does not include any components, inks, adhesives, or labels that prevent the recyclability of the product or packaging.
(C)The product or packaging does not contain an intentionally added chemical identified pursuant to the regulations implementing subparagraph (4) of subdivision (g) of Section 42370.2. 42370.2, excluding chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 17989.2 of Title 14 of the California Code of Regulations.
(D)The product or packaging is not made from plastic or fiber that contains perfluoroalkyl or polyfluoroalkyl substances or PFAS that meets either of the following criteria:
(i)PFAS that a manufacturer has intentionally added to a product or packaging and that have a functional or technical effect in the product or packaging, including the PFAS components of intentionally added chemicals and PFAS that are intentional breakdown products of an added chemical that also have a functional or technical effect in the product.
(ii)The presence of PFAS in a product or product component or packaging or packaging component at or above 100 parts per million, as measured in total organic flourine.
(4)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging is recyclable in the state if the product or packaging has a demonstrated recycling rate of at least 75 percent, meaning that not less than 75 percent of the product or packaging sorted and aggregated in the state is reprocessed into new products or packaging.
(5)(A)Before January 1, 2030, notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging not collected pursuant to a curbside collection program is recyclable in the state if the non-curbside collection program recovers at least 60 percent of the product or packaging in the program and the material has sufficient commercial value to be marketed for recycling and be transported at the end of its useful life to a transfer, processing, or recycling facility to be sorted and aggregated into defined streams by material type and form.
(B)After January 1, 2030, notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging not collected pursuant to a curbside collection program is recyclable in the state if the non-curbside collection program recovers at least 75 percent of the product or packaging in the program and the material has sufficient commercial value to be marketed for recycling and be transported at the end of its useful life to a transfer, processing, or recycling facility to be sorted and aggregated into defined streams by material type and form.
(6)Notwithstanding paragraphs (2) and (3), a product or packaging is recyclable in the state if the product or packaging is part of, and in compliance with, a program established pursuant to state or federal law on or after January 1, 2022, governing the recyclability or disposal of that product or packaging if the director determines that the product or packaging will not increase contamination of curbside recycling or deceive consumers as to the recyclability of the product or packaging.
(7)The information published by the department pursuant to paragraph (1) shall not limit the discretion of a local agency under existing law to decide whether, and to what extent, a material type or form shall be accepted by a local recycling program.
(e)For purposes of this section, chasing arrows symbol has the meaning set forth in subdivision (f) of Section 17580 of the Business and Professions Code.
(f)Consistent with the waste hierarchy established pursuant to Section 40051, and pursuant to Section 40180, for purposes of this section, recycling, recyclable, and recyclability do not include transformation, as defined in Section 40201, EMSW conversion, or production of fuels.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (July 1). |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| May 24, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 4181.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2024 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3976.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 29, 2024 | April 29 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3661.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 12, 2024 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2024 | Special Consent SB1231 Allen | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 350 Bay Area Action | ** Against | |
| Agricultural Council Of California | ** Support | |
| Air Alliance Houston | ** Against | |
| American Chemistry Council | ** Support | |
| American Cleaning Institute | ** Support | |
| Aquatic Genesis LLC | ** Against | |
| Arms of Andes USA Corp | ** Against | |
| Association for Farmers Rights Defense | ** Against | |
| Association Of Home Appliance Manufacturers | ** Support | |
| Association of Plastic Recyclers | ** Support | |
| Beyond Plastics | ** Against | |
| Breathe Free Detroit | ** Against | |
| Bureo, Inc. | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Farm Bureau | ** Support | |
| California League of Food Producers | ** Support | |
| California Manufacturers & Technology Association | ** Support | |
| California Retailers Association | ** Support | |
| California Safe Schools | ** Against | |
| Clean Earth 4 Kids | ** Against | |
| Climdev-Africa | ** Against | |
| Comite Pro Uno | ** Against | |
| Consumer Brands Association | ** Support | |
| Dairy Institute Of California | ** Support | |
| Danone North America | ** Support | |
| Dr Pepper, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Earth Ethics, INC | ** Against | |
| EJCW | ** Against | |
| Environmental Justice Coalition for Water | ** Against | |
| Environmental & Public Health Consulting | ** Against | |
| Fenceline Watch | ** Against | |
| Flexible Packaging Association | ** Support | |
| FracTracker Alliance | ** Against | |
| Gallifrey Foundation | ** Against | |
| Glendale Environmental Coalition | ** Against | |
| Greenpeace Usa | ** Against | |
| Hamraah Foundation | ** Against | |
| Household and Commercial Products Association | ** Support | |
| International Dairy Foods Association | ** Support | |
| Keurig | ** Support | |
| Kraft Heinz Company | ** Support | |
| My Zero Waste Store | ** Against | |
| National Stewardship Action Council | ** Support | |
| Nestle USA | ** Support | |
| Next Highest Good | ** Against | |
| Non Toxic Communities | ** Against | |
| Pacific Marine Mammal Center | ** Against | |
| Paddle Out Plastic | ** Against | |
| Personal Care Products Council | ** Support | |
| Pet Food Institute | ** Support | |
| Plastic Pollution Coalition | ** Against | |
| Recycling Partnership | ** Support | |
| Recycling Partnership The | ** Support | |
| Santa Cruz Climate Action Network | ** Against | |
| Save The Albatross Coalition | ** Against | |
| Sea Hugger | ** Against | |
| See Turtles | ** Against | |
| Sierra Club California | ** Against | |
| Society of Native Nations | ** Against | |
| Steel Straw | ** Against | |
| Story of Stuff | ** Against | |
| Sustain LA | ** Against | |
| The Descendants Project | ** Against | |
| The Green Room Corporation | ** Against | |
| The Last Beach Cleanup | ** Against | |
| The Last Plastic Straw | ** Against | |
| The Ride Guides | ** Against | |
| The Toy Association | ** Support | |
| Tiny Textiles Wilder Color | ** Against | |
| Turtle Island Restoration Network | ** Against | |
| Unilever | ** Support | |
| Unilever United States | ** Support | |
| Zero Waste Sonoma | ** Against |
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1231
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes a new process by which producers of plastic products under the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act can petition the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of the state’s recyclability labeling law if it is trending towards the recyclability standard set by the state’s truth in labeling law.
Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes producers of covered plastics material to petition CalRecycle, on or before January 1, 2026, to identify material types and forms that are trending toward meeting the requirements of SB 343 and measurable increase of statewide collection and sorting rates, for which continued increase in collection, sorting, and viable responsible end market development will be disrupted by loss of recyclable designation.
- Requires CalRecycle to approve or deny a petition within 60 days, to consider information in the petition and in its waste characterization study, and to include reasons for a denial and additional information that may be helpful in approving future petitions.
- Provides that a product is exempt from the chasing arrows truth in labeling law if manufactured up to 24 months after the date CalRecycle publishes its first update to a specified material characterization study and for which a producer or group of producers has submitted a petition to CalRecycle authorized by this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT:
CalRecycle reports costs of $606,000 in fiscal year 2025-26 for four permanent full-time positions, increasing to $779,000 for five positions in 2026-27 and annually ongoing for drafting regulations, reviewing petitions and applications and compliance activities. This bill will require modification to the ongoing rulemaking to implement SB 54. That bill established the California Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund into which industry will pay fees to cover CalRecycle’s costs to implement the SB 54 program, expected to be funded by 2027. To date, CalRecycle’s costs for the SB 54 rulemaking are being covered by a loan from the Beverage Container Recycling Fund. CalRecycle reports that the start-up costs of implementing this bill also will be from the Beverage Container Recycling Fund, with ongoing costs starting in 2027 from the California Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In 2021, the Legislature passed SB 343, which established a clear definition in California law for recyclability and prohibited producers from making recyclability claims on their products, including using the ubiquitous chasing arrows symbol, unless the product meets the standards in the definition. The measure included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material if that material is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (SB 54) and CalRecycle determines the material will not contaminate the recycling stream. The purpose of this on-ramp clause was to ensure that if producers were investing in recycling infrastructure under SB 54 and could demonstrate that those investments were increasing the recyclability of their material, they could continue encouraging consumers to put the material in the blue recycle bin. Otherwise, when SB 343 is fully implemented next year, consumers will not know how to recycle the material, and producers of that material could not comply with SB 54 despite their efforts.
However, the language in SB 54 inadvertently precludes CalRecycle from identifying which material could qualify for this on-ramp until the deadline for removing the recyclability claim and chasing arrows has passed. SB 1231 addresses this time gap by allowing producers to petition CalRecycle for the continued use of recycling claims for a product if the producer can demonstrate sufficient investments that will allow the material to meet California’s definition. The bill continues to give CalRecycle full discretion to determine which materials meet this high bar.
- Background. Supporters describe this bill as a “fix” or “cleanup” of SB 54 to create a temporary bridge for producers of materials covered by SB 54 to use the on-ramp authorized by SB 343. Opponents describe this bill as “providing a new loophole that the plastics industry and other packaging industries can exploit to continue creating a massive amount of plastic waste.”
- Prior Legislation. SB 54 (Allen), Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022, established the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which, among other things, authorizes CalRecycle to identify covered materials that are trending toward meeting the requirements of SB 343.
SB 343 (Allen), Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021, established a “truth in labeling” requirement for product recyclability, making a product displaying the chasing arrows symbol deceptive or misleading unless at least 60% of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler; required CalRecycle to conduct and publish a material characterization study of the types and forms of material that are collected, sorted, sold, or transferred by solid waste facilities by January 1, 2024, and update the study every five years, beginning Jan 1, 2027.
Analysis Prepared by: Jacqueline Kinney / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1231
Author:(Allen) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act: environmental advertising
SUMMARY: Establishes a new process by which producers of covered materials in the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act can petition the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of the state’s recyclability labeling law if it is trending towards the recyclability standard set by the state’s truth in labeling law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all rigid plastic bottles and containers sold in the state to be labeled with a code that indicates the resin type of their basic material. The code shall be placed inside a triangle, and letters indicating resin abbreviation shall be placed below the triangle. (Public Resources Code (PRC) 18015 et seq.)
- Pursuant to SB 343 (Allen), Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021:
- Establishes a “truth in labeling” requirement for product recyclability. A product that displays the chasing arrows symbol or other statement of recyclability is deemed deceptive or misleading unless at least 60% of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler. (PRC 42355.51)
- Requires CalRecycle to conduct and publish a material characterization study of the types and forms of material that are collected, sorted, sold, or transferred by solid waste facilities by January 1, 2024. Requires the study to be updated every five years, beginning Jan 1, 2027.
- Establishes an “on-ramp” clause allowing materials that are moving toward the standard for recyclability in SB 343 but do not yet reach that standard to continue to use the chasing arrows symbol on material that is both (1) part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material on or after January 1, 2022 (i.e., SB 54); and, (2) has been determined by CalRecycle not to contaminate the recycling stream if placed in a recycling collection bin.
- Specifies that products have 18 months following an initial characterization study and after subsequent updates in which progress towards SB 343 recyclability goals for different material types is evaluated to ensure their labeling aligns with the requirements of SB 343.
- Pursuant to SB 54 (Allen), Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022, establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which:
- Imposes minimum recycled content requirements and source reduction requirements for single-use packaging and plastic food service ware, to be achieved through an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program. (PRC 42040 et seq.)
- Requires CalRecycle to conduct a material characterization study of covered material categories that are disposed of in California landfills before July 1, 2025, and to report to the Legislature the status of materials at solid waste facilities pursuant to SB 343 by January 1, 2024. Requires CalRecycle to update the material characterization study required pursuant in 2028, 2030, 2032, and at least every four years thereafter.
- Authorizes CalRecycle to identify covered materials that are trending toward meeting the requirements of SB 343, and requires those material types and forms to be considered and labeled as recyclable in the state as long as the material types and forms meet specified requirements.
THIS BILL:
- Authorizes a producer or a group of producers of covered material to petition CalRecycle to identify material types and forms that are trending toward meeting the requirements of SB 343 and measurable increase of statewide collection and sorting rates, as specified, for which the continued increase in the collection, sorting, and viable responsible end market development will be disrupted by a loss of a recyclable designation.
- Requires CalRecycle to approve or deny a petition within 60 days, and to consider information provided in the petition as well as information received through the waste characterization study. Specifies that a denial must be accompanied by a statement detailing the reasons for the denial and additional information that may be helpful in approving future petitions.
- Extends, from 18 months to 24 months, the amount of time a covered material has to achieve compliance with SB 343 recyclability criteria following the publication of a waste characterization study.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CalRecycle estimates ongoing costs of about $468,000 annually (California Circular Economy Fund) to revise SB 54 regulations, review petitions, draft determinations, validate accuracy of information submitted in the petition, and evaluate the trend line of subject material types.
COMMENTS:
- Plastic pollution. Plastics pose a threat to the environment from origin to end-of-life. Plastic production is responsible for three and a half percent of all greenhouse gas emissions—more than the entire aviation sector. In 2021, global plastics production was estimated at 390.7 million metric tons, a 4% increase from the previous year. The United Nations Environment Programme reports that only 9% of all plastic ever made has been recycled, 12% has been incinerated, and the remaining 79% has accumulated in landfills or the environment.
Once plastics enter the environment, they remain there for hundreds to thousands of years. Plastics do not break down into their constituent parts, but instead break down into smaller and smaller particles, or microplastics. Because they are so small, microplastics can travel in the air and water, and can be easily absorbed by living things and accumulate up the food chain. Microplastics have been found in the most pristine natural environments on earth, including in the deep ocean, Antarctic sea ice, and in the sand of remote deserts. Laboratory studies have found that microplastics increase the risk of cancer and disrupt hormone pathways in lab rats.
Recycling plastic into new products is one way to reduce plastic pollution, as it keeps the recycled plastic out of the environment and reduces our dependence on virgin resin. However, recycling is currently only feasible for some of the more common, and least toxic, forms of plastic. One of the major factors that intrinsically impacts California’s recycling efforts is the market for recyclable materials. In order for material to be recycled, the cost of processing and using the recycled material must be competitive with the cost of virgin material. Prices for scrap materials can fluctuate wildly over both the short term and the long term, influenced by global factors. While recycling is one important tool to address plastic pollution, the most effective way to tackle the plastic pollution crisis is to use less of it. - SB 54. SB 54 created sweeping new minimum recycling requirements for single-use plastic packaging and food service ware (covered material), source reduction requirements for plastic covered material, and prohibits the sale or distribution of expanded polystyrene unless it meets accelerated recycling rates. SB 54 requires producers to comply with the bill’s requirements through an expanded producer responsibility program. Under SB 54, covered material must meet specified recycling and source reduction requirements by 2027, which ramp up until all covered material must achieve and maintain a 65% recycling rate and a 25% source reduction requirement by 2032. This bill additionally requires producers, through the producer responsibility organization, to pay $500 million per year for ten years (from 2027 to 2037) to be deposited into the California Plastic Pollution Mitigation Fund, which is established to fund various environmental and public health programs.
- What is recyclable? It is frequently unclear to consumers what is and is not recyclable. There have historically been several reasons for this, including:
- In California, rigid plastic bottles and containers are required to display a resin identification code (RIC) inside of a triangle or a chasing arrows symbol. Consumers may assume this code means a package is recyclable, but that is often not the case. According to CalRecycle, only plastics with the code #1 for polyethylene terephthalate (PET), used in beverage bottles, and #2 for high-density polyethylene (HDPE), used in milk jugs and shampoo bottles, are commonly recycled. The rest of the resin types (#3-7) are generally not recycled.
- Recycling varies by jurisdiction. What can be recycled in one area of the state may not be recyclable in another. Recycling varies based on the solid waste infrastructure available within a jurisdiction, and available markets.
- Plastic materials may be technologically recyclable, but the cost to collect, sort, and process the materials and lack of available market make them economically infeasible to actually recycle into new products.
- SB 343. To give consumers clarity and curtail misinformation or “greenwashing” that promotes products as recyclable when they are actually not recycled, the Legislature enacted SB 343. The law prohibits producers from making a false claim of recyclability on their products, such as using a chasing arrow symbol on material that does not meet strict standards for recyclability. Under SB 343, a product is considered “recyclable” if at least 60% of jurisdictions in the state can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler.
SB 343 included an “on-ramp” for materials that do not meet the bill’s recyclability standards, but that are covered by SB 54. This on-ramp allows covered material to be labeled as recyclable if producers demonstrate to CalRecycle an improvement in the material’s recycling rate. - This bill. This bill is intended to address a drafting issue in SB 54 that requires CalRecycle to identify covered material under SB 54 that qualifies for the SB 343 on-ramp before there have been sufficient waste characterization studies to determine whether or not a material is trending toward compliance. This bill replaces the current requirement for CalRecycle to identify covered materials that are “trending toward” meeting the requirements of SB 343 and allow those material types and forms to be considered and labeled as recyclable and instead allows producers to petition CalRecycle to have their materials evaluated by CalRecycle to be eligible for the on-ramp.
It is not clear what metric CalRecycle should use to determine whether or not a covered material is “trending toward” meeting the state’s requirements. Additionally, CalRecycle may need additional clarity in the bill or may need to establish regulations to develop requirements for the petition process. The author may wish to consider incorporating additional authority and guidance for CalRecycle to develop and implement the petition process. Finally, CalRecycle is in the midst of implementing SB 54. Depending on the volume of petitions submitted, implementation of this bill has the potential to impede CalRecycle’s ability to effectively implement SB 54. - Author’s statement:
In 2021, the Legislature passed SB 343, which established a clear definition in California law for recyclability and prohibited producers from making recyclability claims on their products, including using the ubiquitous chasing arrows symbol, unless the product meets the standards in the definition. The measure included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material if that material is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (SB 54) and CalRecycle determines the material will not contaminate the recycling stream. The purpose of this on-ramp clause was to ensure that if producers were investing in recycling infrastructure under SB 54 and could demonstrate that those investments were increasing the recyclability of their material, they could continue encouraging consumers to put the material in the blue recycle bin. Otherwise, when SB 343 is fully implemented next year, consumers will not know how to recycle the material, and producers of that material could not comply with SB 54 despite their efforts.
However, the language in SB 54 inadvertently precludes CalRecycle from identifying which material could qualify for this on-ramp until the deadline for removing the recyclability claim and chasing arrows has passed. SB 1231 addresses this time gap by allowing producers to petition CalRecycle for the continued use of recycling claims for a product if the producer can demonstrate sufficient investments that will allow the material to meet California’s definition. The bill continues to give CalRecycle full discretion to determine which materials meet this high bar.
- Suggested amendments. This bill is intended to create a temporary bridge for producers of materials covered by SB 54 to use the on-ramp authorized by SB 343. The committee may wish to amend the bill to require petitions to be submitted to CalRecycle on or before January 1, 2026.
This bill extends the window from 18 months to 24 months for all covered material after CalRecycle completes required waste characterization studies. The committee may wish to amend the bill to narrow that extension by limiting it to those materials for which a producer has submitted a petition to CalRecycle.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Agricultural Council of California
American Chemistry Council
Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers
Association of Plastic Recyclers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Consumer Brands Association
Dairy Institute of California
Danone North America
Flexible Packaging Association
Household and Commercial Products Association
International Dairy Foods Association
Keurig
Dr Pepper, Inc.
Kraft Heinz Company
National Stewardship Action Council
Nestle USA
Personal Care Products Council
Pet Food Institute
Recycling Partnership
The Toy Association
Unilever United States
Opposition
350 Bay Area Action
Air Alliance Houston
Aquatic Genesis LLC
Arms of Andes USA Corp
Association for Farmers Rights Defense
Beyond Plastics
Breathe Free Detroit
Bureo, Inc.
California Safe Schools
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Climdev-Africa
Comite Pro Uno
Earth Ethics, Inc
EJCW
Environmental & Public Health Consulting
Environmental Justice Coalition for Water
Fenceline Watch
Fractracker Alliance
Gallifrey Foundation
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Greenpeace USA
Hamraah Foundation
My Zero Waste Store
Next Highest Good
Non Toxic Communities
Pacific Marine Mammal Center
Paddle Out Plastic
Plastic Pollution Coalition
Santa Cruz Climate Action Network
Save the Albatross Coalition
Sea Hugger
See Turtles
Sierra Club California
Society of Native Nations
Steel Straw
Story of Stuff
Sustain LA
The Descendants Project
The Green Room Corporation
The Last Beach Cleanup
The Last Plastic Straw
The Ride Guides
Tiny Textiles Wilder Color
Turtle Island Restoration Network
Zero Waste Sonoma
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1231 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1231
Author: Allen (D)
Introduced: 2/15/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/17/24
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Archuleta, Gonzalez, Menjivar, Nguyen, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SUBJECT: Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act: environmental advertising
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill establishes a process by which producers of covered materials in the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act (SB 54) can petition the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. This process replaces the existing process by which CalRecycle identifies those materials based on sequential material characterization studies.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires, under the Integrated Waste Management Act (IWMA), local governments to divert at least 50% of solid waste from landfill disposal and establishes a statewide goal that 75% of solid waste be diverted from landfill disposal by 2020. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §§41780, 41780.01)
- Requires all rigid plastic bottles and containers sold in the state to be labeled with a code that indicates the resin type of their basic material. The code shall be placed inside a triangle, and letters indicating resin abbreviation shall be placed below the triangle. (PRC §18015 et seq.)
- Establishes a “truth in labeling” requirement for product recyclability, established in SB 343 (Allen Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021.) A product that displays the chasing arrows symbol or other statement of recyclability is deemed deceptive or misleading unless at least 60 percent of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler. (PRC § 42355.51)
- Requires CalRecycle to conduct a publish a material characterization study of the types and forms of material that are collected, sorted, sold, or transferred by solid waste facilities. Requires the department to update this study every five years, beginning Jan 1, 2027.
- Establishes an “on-ramp” clause allowing materials that are improving towards the standard for recyclability in SB 343 but do not yet reach that standard to continue to use the chasing arrows symbol on material that is both (1) part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material on or after January 1, 2022 (i.e. SB 54) and (2) has been determined by CalRecycle not to contaminate the recycling stream if placed in a recycle bin. (PRC § 42355.51 (d)(6))
- Specifies that products have 18 months following an initial characterization study and after subsequent updates, in which progress towards SB 343 recyclability goals for different material types is evaluated, to ensure their labeling aligns with the “truth in labeling” requirements of SB 343. (PRC § 42355.51 (b)(2))
- Establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act (SB 54), which imposes minimum recycled content requirements and source reduction requirements for single-use packaging and plastic food service ware, to be achieved through an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program. (PRC § §42040 et seq.)
- Requires CalRecycle to conduct a material characterization study of covered material categories that are disposed of in California landfills before July 1, 2025, and shall report to the Legislature the status of materials at solid waste facilities pursuant to SB 343 by January 1, 2024. CalRecycle shall update the material characterization study required pursuant to this subdivision in 2028, 2030, 2032, and at least every four years thereafter (PRC § 42061(a)(3))
- Under SB54, authorizes CalRecycle to identify materials that are covered in SB 54 that are trending toward meeting the goals of SB 343, and requires those material types and forms to be considered and labeled as recyclable in the state as long as the material types and forms meet certain requirements. (PRC § 42061(a))
This bill:
- Establishes a process by which producers of covered materials in SB 54 can petition CalRecycle to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. This process replaces the existing process by which CalRecycle identifies materials that do not meet the requirements of recyclability in SB 343 but are trending towards meeting the State’s recyclable standard based on updates to an initial material characterization study, which grants those materials permission to use the chasing arrow symbol.
- Requires CalRecycle to review produces’ petitions and approve or deny them within 60 days of receipt, as provided.
- Adds an additional six months to an 18-month extension for products to be compliant with SB 343 recyclability criteria following the publication of CalRecycle’s material characterization study.
- This extension does not include chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with a specified regulation governing the disclosure of chemicals on a list produced under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65) from the intentionally added chemicals that would affect whether a product or package is considered recyclable in this state.
Background
- Plastics Pollution and Policy. Plastic pollution is a persistent problem impacting the environment on a local and global scale. In 2021, global plastics production was estimated at 390.7 million metric tons: only nine percent of all plastic ever made has been recycled, according to a United Nations Environment Programme report. Plastic pollution threatens ecosystems. As litter, plastic threatens wildlife as terrestrial and marine animals alike can become entangled in or ingest plastic debris, causing suffocation or starvation. Moreover, plastic never truly degrades into its chemical components; instead, it physically breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces that become more penetrative and more challenging to clean from the environment. Plastics under five millimeters, or microplastics, have been found in the most pristine environments on earth, including in national parks, in Antarctic sea ice, and in human placentas: microplastics are shown to increase risks of cancer and disrupt hormone pathways in lab rats.
To reduce plastics in the environment, CalRecycle has been tasked with reducing the amount of waste that is landfilled and promoting recycling in California through the IWMA. The IWMA establishes a goal of source reducing, recycling, or composting at least 75% of solid waste generated in the State by 2020. However, according to CalRecycle’s 2022 State of Disposal and Recycling, the State’s 2021 recycling rate was just 41%. The single largest contributor to this recycling rate was recyclables that were exported out of the state. The statewide recycling rate has declined over the last decade, following a peak of 50% in 2014. The recycling rate has been impacted and may continue to be impacted by global policies like China’s National SWORD and the Basel Convention, which restrict the amount of foreign waste these countries will accept.
One of the major factors that intrinsically impacts California’s recycling efforts is the broader market for recyclable materials. Without intervention, in order for material to be recycled and not end up in a landfill, the cost of processing and using the recycled material must be less than cost of the of virgin material. Prices for scrap materials can fluctuate wildly over both the short term and the long term, influenced by global factors such as China’s National Sword in 2017, the global pandemic’s impacts on industry and shipping, and the price of oil.
- What is recyclable? It is often unclear to consumers what is and is not recyclable. There have historically been several reasons for this, including:
- Resin identification codes. In California, rigid plastic bottles and containers are required to display a resin identification code (RIC) inside of a triangle or a chasing arrows symbol. Consumers may assume this code means a package is automatically recyclable, but that is not the case. According to CalRecycle, only plastics with the code #1 for polyethylene terephthalate (PET), used in water and soda bottles, and #2 high-density polyethylene (HDPE), used in milk jugs and shampoo bottles, are commonly recycled currently. The rest of the resin types #3-7 are generally not recycled.
- Regional and temporal variability. The way plastics are recycled varies by jurisdiction. What can be recycled in one area of the state may not be recyclable in another. As of 2015, there were an estimated 161 Materials Recovery Facility (MRF)s statewide. According to a 2020 Recyclability Screening Survey of 76 CA MRFs, plastic items made from resins #3-7 were accepted at a rate of 1-82% depending on the type of item. While all MRFs accepted PET and HDPE bottles and jugs, there was also variability in other #1 and #2 resin items accepted, such as PET clamshells, cups and HDPE rigid containers. What can be recycled within a particular jurisdiction will also vary over time depending on when a waste hauler can sell their collected materials.
To address the consumer confusion on what can and cannot be recycled, and specifically to curtail misinformation or “greenwashing” that promotes products as recyclable when they are not, the Legislature enacted the “truth in labelling” for recyclability in SB 343 (Allen Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021).
- SB 343 prohibits producers from making a false claim of recyclability on their products, such as using a chasing arrow symbol on material that does not meet strict standards for recyclability.
- A product is considered “recyclable” under SB 343 only if at least 60% of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler. In order to determine what materials meet this standard of recyclability, SB 343 directs CalRecycle to publish data about the types of materials that are actually recycled in jurisdictions across California and specifically directs CalRecycle to: Oversee a statewide analysis of material recovery facilities to identify which materials are commonly collected, sorted, sold, or transferred for recycling in California; and
- Oversee a follow-up study in 2027 and every five years thereafter to make updates to the statewide analysis.
(CalRecycle published a draft of its preliminary findings on December 28, 2023, and is currently accepting public feedback on those findings.)
- SB 54 uses an EPR approach to reach ambitious targets to reduce single-use serviceware and packaging through source reduction and postconsumer recycled content. These goals include:
- Requiring all covered material sold in the state to be recyclable or compostable by January 1, 2032;
- Requiring that all plastic-covered material sold in the state meet a recycling rate of 65% by Jan 1, 2032, with interim goals beginning in 2028;
- Prohibiting producers of expanded polystyrene (EPS) from selling EPS food serviceware unless they meet a 65% recycling rate by January 1, 2032; and
- Requiring the PRO to pay $500 million per year from January 1, 2027, through January 1, 2037, to fund the program, and authorizes the PRO to collect up to $150 million from plastic manufacturers.
- SB 343 and SB 54 both regulate many of the same products. To align these two measures, SB 343 specifically included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material that does not meet the “recyclability” standard in SB 343 but is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (i.e. SB 54). This “onramp” provision also includes a guardrail that the material has been determined by CalRecycle not to contaminate the recycling stream if placed in a recycle bin. The onramp provision in SB 343 would allow material covered in SB 54 to be labeled as recyclable if producers can demonstrate an improvement in the material's recycling rate.
However, CalRecycle’s timeline to re-evaluate the material characterization study is Jan 1, 2027. This re-evaluation is necessary to ascertain which materials are increasing towards the recyclability standards in SB 343, and resultantly, which materials would be eligible to continue to use the “chasing arrow” symbol under SB 343. Having a January 1, 2027 timeline to make this evaluation would preclude materials that are meeting the requirements intended to onramp them into SB 343 for the next two years. As a result, these products would need to remove their “chasing arrow” symbol during that timeframe, only to (potentially) add it back on to the same product if the subsequent material characterization study finds that they are advancing towards the goals of SB 343 and eligible to use the chasing arrow symbol.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author:
“ [SB 343] included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material if that material is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (SB 54, California’s plastics pollution law passed the following year in 2022) and CalRecycle determines the material will not contaminate the recycling stream. The purpose of this “on-ramp” clause was to ensure that if producers were investing in recycling infrastructure under SB 54 and could demonstrate that those investments were increasing the recyclability of their material, they could continue encouraging consumers to put the material in the blue recycle bin. Otherwise, when SB 343 is fully implemented next year, consumers will not know how to recycle the material, and producers of that material could not comply with SB 54 despite their efforts.
However, the language in SB 54 inadvertently precludes CalRecycle from identifying which material could qualify for this on-ramp until the deadline for removing the recyclability claim and chasing arrows has passed. SB 1231 addresses this time gap by allowing producers to petition CalRecycle for the continued use of recycling claims for a product if the producer can demonstrate sufficient investments that will allow the material to meet California’s definition. The bill continues to give CalRecycle full discretion to determine which materials meet this high bar.”
- Bridging an onramp across policies. To align the “onramp” in SB 343 with the material characterization study timelines in SB 54, SB 1231 removes the requirement that CalRecycle first evaluate which materials covered by SB 54 are advancing towards the recyclability standard in SB 343, and instead creates a petition process where producers can request that specific materials be authorized by CalRecycle to meet that standard. Tasking producers with making the case that materials are “trending towards recyclability” removes the need for CalRecycle to make this call based on updates to the material characterization study. Removing the reliance on the follow-up material characterization study, published in 2027, would make the on-ramp for products improving in recyclability targets under SB 343 viable before that 2027 timeline.
Who knows best? The method that SB 1231 uses to bridge the “onramp” for materials that are covered in SB 54 and trending towards SB 343 recyclability goals flips the task of identifying what materials are trending towards SB 343 compliance from CalRecycle to the producers. Under SB 1231, CalRecycle still has the final say in whether or not products are “onramped” onto SB 343 and are allowed to continue to use the chasing arrow symbol even if they do not yet meet the recyclability standards of SB 343. However, SB 1231 would put CalRecycle in a responsive position, instead of in the driver’s seat.
Putting the onus on producers to make the case that their product is advancing towards the recyclability goals in SB 343 instead of relying on CalRecycle to make that determination assumes that the producers have better access to information on what is and is not improving on recyclability. Before CalRecycle has data from the follow-up material characterization study, this is likely to be true. However, after CalRecycle has completed its second material characterization study, it will have the evidence needed to evaluate for itself whether or not a given material is increasing in recyclability.
In its current form, SB 1231 does not specify what information producers should provide to CalRecycle to make their case, or establish a process of enforcement should the information provided to CalRecycle be inaccurate.
As the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider whether the petition process for establishing increasing recyclability of materials should be used in perpetuity, or only until the first follow-up material characterization study is released in 2027. The author may wish to further consider what information should be included in the petition from producers to help CalRecycle evaluate whether or not a product or material is eligible for the SB 343 onramp, and consider what remedies might be needed if producers submit information that is not accurate in making a claim towards increasing recyclability.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 343 (Allen, Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021) tightens the requirements around the permissible use of the “chasing arrows” recycling symbol and when claims regarding recyclability can be made and requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to publish the types and forms of recyclable products and packaging.
SB 54 (Allen Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022) establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which imposes minimum content and source reduction requirements for plastic single-use packaging and food service ware through an EPR program.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
CalRecycle estimates ongoing costs of about $468,000 annually (California Circular Economy Fund [CCEF]) to revise SB 54 regulations, review petitions, draft determinations, validate accuracy of information submitted in the petition, and evaluate the trend line of subject material types.
SUPPORT: (Verified 05/16/2024)
American Chemistry Council
American Cleaning Institute
Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers
Calchamber
California Farm Bureau
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
Consumer Brands Association
Dairy Institute of California
Danone North America
Flexible Packaging Association
International Dairy Foods Association
Keurig Dr Pepper INC.
Kraft Heinz Company
National Stewardship Action Council
Nestle USA
Personal Care Products Council
Pet Food Institute
Recycling Partnership; the
The Association of Plastic Recyclers
The Toy Association
Unilever
OPPOSITION: (Verified 05/16/2024)
Prepared by: Brynn Cook / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
5/17/24 18:49:00
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1231 (Allen) - Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act: environmental advertising
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would establish a process by which producers of covered materials in the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act (SB 54) can petition the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 (Allen Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021) if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. This process would replace the existing process by which CalRecycle identifies those materials based on sequential material characterization studies.
Fiscal Impact:
- CalRecycle estimates ongoing costs of about $468,000 annually (California Circular Economy Fund [CCEF]) to revise SB 54 regulations, review petitions, draft determinations, validate accuracy of information submitted in the petition, and evaluate the trend line of subject material types.
Background:
Plastics Pollution and Policy. Plastic pollution is a persistent problem impacting the environment on a local and global scale. In 2021, global plastics production was estimated at 390.7 million metric tons: only nine percent of all plastic ever made has been recycled, according to a United Nations Environment Programme report. Plastic pollution threatens ecosystems. As litter, plastic threatens wildlife as terrestrial and marine animals alike can become entangled in or ingest plastic debris, causing suffocation or starvation. Moreover, plastic never truly degrades into its chemical components; instead, it physically breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces that become more penetrative and more challenging to clean from the environment. Plastics under five millimeters, or microplastics, have been found in the most pristine environments on earth, including in national parks, in Antarctic sea ice, and in human placentas: microplastics are shown to increase risks of cancer and disrupt hormone pathways in lab rats.
To reduce plastics in the environment, CalRecycle has been tasked with reducing the amount of waste that is landfilled and promoting recycling in California through the IWMA. The IWMA establishes a goal of source reducing, recycling, or composting at least 75% of solid waste generated in the State by 2020. However, according to CalRecycle’s 2022 State of Disposal and Recycling, the State’s 2021 recycling rate was just 41%. The single largest contributor to this recycling rate was recyclables that were exported out of the state. The statewide recycling rate has declined over the last decade, following a peak of 50% in 2014. The recycling rate has been impacted and may continue to be impacted by global policies like China’s National SWORD and the Basel Convention, which restrict the amount of foreign waste these countries will accept.
One of the major factors that intrinsically impacts California’s recycling efforts is the broader market for recyclable materials. Without intervention, in order for material to be recycled and not end up in a landfill, the cost of processing and using the recycled material must be less than cost of the of virgin material. Prices for scrap materials can fluctuate wildly over both the short term and the long term, influenced by global factors such as China’s National Sword in 2017, the global pandemic’s impacts on industry and shipping, and the price of oil.
What is recyclable? It is often unclear to consumers what is and is not recyclable. There have historically been several reasons for this, including:
- Resin identification codes. In California, rigid plastic bottles and containers are required to display a resin identification code (RIC) inside of a triangle or a chasing arrows symbol. Consumers may assume this code means a package is automatically recyclable, but that is not the case. According to CalRecycle, only plastics with the code #1 for polyethylene terephthalate (PET), used in water and soda bottles, and #2 high-density polyethylene (HDPE), used in milk jugs and shampoo bottles, are commonly recycled currently. The rest of the resin types #3-7 are generally not recycled.
- Regional and temporal variability. The way plastics are recycled varies by jurisdiction. What can be recycled in one area of the state may not be recyclable in another. As of 2015, there were an estimated 161 Materials Recovery Facility (MRF)s statewide. According to a 2020 Recyclability Screening Survey of 76 CA MRFs, plastic items made from resins #3-7 were accepted at a rate of 1-82% depending on the type of item. While all MRFs accepted PET and HDPE bottles and jugs, there was also variability in other #1 and #2 resin items accepted, such as PET clamshells, cups and HDPE rigid containers. What can be recycled within a particular jurisdiction will also vary over time depending on when a waste hauler can sell their collected materials.
To address the consumer confusion on what can and cannot be recycled, and specifically to curtail misinformation or “greenwashing” that promotes products as recyclable when they are not, the Legislature enacted the “truth in labelling” for recyclability in SB 343 (Allen Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021).
SB 343. SB 343 prohibits producers from making a false claim of recyclability on their products, such as using a chasing arrow symbol on material that does not meet strict standards for recyclability.
- A product is considered “recyclable” under SB 343 only if at least 60% of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler. In order to determine what materials meet this standard of recyclability, SB 343 directs CalRecycle to publish data about the types of materials that are actually recycled in jurisdictions across California and specifically directs CalRecycle to: Oversee a statewide analysis of material recovery facilities to identify which materials are commonly collected, sorted, sold, or transferred for recycling in California; and
- Oversee a follow-up study in 2027 and every five years thereafter to make updates to the statewide analysis.
CalRecycle published a draft of its preliminary findings on December 28, 2023, and is currently accepting public feedback on those findings.
SB 54. SB 54 uses an EPR approach to reach ambitious targets to reduce single-use serviceware and packaging through source reduction and postconsumer recycled content. These goals include:
- Requiring all covered material sold in the state to be recyclable or compostable by January 1, 2032;
- Requiring that all plastic-covered material sold in the state meet a recycling rate of 65% by Jan 1, 2032, with interim goals beginning in 2028;
- Prohibiting producers of expanded polystyrene (EPS) from selling EPS food serviceware unless they meet a 65% recycling rate by January 1, 2032; and
- Requiring the PRO to pay $500 million per year from January 1, 2027, through January 1, 2037 to fund the program, and authorizes the PRO to collect up to $150 million from plastic manufacturers.
SB 343 and SB 54. SB 343 and SB 54 both regulate many of the same products. To align these two measures, SB 343 specifically included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material that does not meet the “recyclability” standard in SB 343 but is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (i.e. SB 54). This “onramp” provision also includes a guardrail that the material has been determined by CalRecycle not to contaminate the recycling stream if placed in a recycle bin. The onramp provision in SB 343 would allow material covered in SB 54 to be labeled as recyclable if producers can demonstrate an improvement in the material's recycling rate.
However, CalRecycle’s timeline to re-evaluate the material characterization study is Jan 1, 2027. This re-evaluation is necessary to ascertain which materials are increasing towards the recyclability standards in SB 343, and resultantly, which materials would be eligible to continue to use the “chasing arrow” symbol under SB 343. Having a January 1, 2027 timeline to make this evaluation would preclude materials that are meeting the requirements intended to onramp them into SB 343 for the next two years. As a result, these products would need to remove their “chasing arrow” symbol during that timeframe, only to (potentially) add it back on to the same product if the subsequent material characterization study finds that they are advancing towards the goals of SB 343 and eligible to use the chasing arrow symbol.
Proposed Law:
This bill would establish a process by which producers of covered under SB 54 can petition CalRecycle to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. Specifically, this bill would:
- Establish a process by which producers of covered materials in SB 54 can petition CalRecycle to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. This process would replace the existing process by which CalRecycle identifies materials that do not meet the requirements of recyclability in SB 343 but are trending towards meeting the State’s recyclable standard based on updates to an initial material characterization study, which grants those materials permission to use the chasing arrow symbol.
- Require CalRecycle to review produces’ petitions and approve or deny them within 60 days of receipt, as provided.
- Add an additional six months to an 18-month extension for products to be compliant with SB 343 recyclability criteria following the publication of CalRecycle’s material characterization study.
- This extension would not include chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with a specified regulation governing the disclosure of chemicals on a list produced under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65) from the intentionally added chemicals that would affect whether a product or package is considered recyclable in this state.
Related Legislation:
SB 343 (Allen, Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021) tightens the requirements around the permissible use of the “chasing arrows” recycling symbol and when claims regarding recyclability can be made and requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to publish the types and forms of recyclable products and packaging
SB 54 (Allen Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022) establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which imposes minimum content and source reduction requirements for plastic single-use packaging and food service ware through an EPR program.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No. | SB 1231 | Hearing Date: | 4/17/2024 |
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | 2/15/2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brynn Cook | ||
SUBJECT: Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act: environmental advertising
DIGEST: This bill establishes a process by which producers of covered materials in the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act (SB 54) can petition the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. This process replaces the existing process by which CalRecycle identifies those materials based on sequential material characterization studies.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires, under the Integrated Waste Management Act (IWMA), local governments to divert at least 50% of solid waste from landfill disposal and establishes a statewide goal that 75% of solid waste be diverted from landfill disposal by 2020. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §§41780, 41780.01)
- Requires all rigid plastic bottles and containers sold in the state to be labeled with a code that indicates the resin type of their basic material. The code shall be placed inside a triangle, and letters indicating resin abbreviation shall be placed below the triangle. (PRC §18015 et seq.)
- Establishes a “truth in labeling” requirement for product recyclability, established in SB 343 (Allen Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021.) A product that displays the chasing arrows symbol or other statement of recyclability is deemed deceptive or misleading unless at least 60 percent of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler. (PRC § 42355.51)
- Requires CalRecycle to conduct a publish a material characterization study of the types and form of material that are collected, sorted, sold, or transferred by solid waste facilities. Requires the department to update this study every five years, beginning Jan 1, 2027.
- Establishes an “on-ramp” clause allowing materials that are improving towards the standard for recyclability in SB 343 but do not yet reach that standard to continue to use the chasing arrows symbol on material that is both (1) part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material on or after January 1, 2022 (i.e. SB 54) and (2) has been determined by CalRecycle not to contaminate the recycling stream if placed in a recycle bin. (PRC § 42355.51 (d)(6))
- Specifies that products have 18 months following an initial characterization study and after subsequent updates, in which progress towards SB 343 recyclability goals for different material types is evaluated, to ensure their labeling aligns with the “truth in labeling” requirements of SB 343. (PRC § 42355.51 (b)(2))
- Establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act (SB 54), which imposes minimum recycled content requirements and source reduction requirements for single-use packaging and plastic food service ware, to be achieved through an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program. (PRC § §42040 et seq.)
- Requires CalRecycle to conduct a material characterization study of covered material categories that are disposed of in California landfills before July 1, 2025, and shall report to the Legislature the status of materials at solid waste facilities pursuant to SB 343 by January 1, 2024. CalRecycle shall update the material characterization study required pursuant to this subdivision in 2028, 2030, 2032, and at least every four years thereafter (PRC § 42061(a)(3))
- Under SB54, authorizes CalRecycle to identify materials that are covered in SB 54 that are trending toward meeting the goals of SB 343, and requires those material types and forms to be considered and labeled as recyclable in the state as long as the material types and forms meet certain requirements. (PRC § 42061(a))
This bill:
- Establishes a process by which producers of covered materials in SB 54 can petition CalRecycle to authorize a material as meeting the requirements of SB 343 if it is trending towards the recyclability standard in SB 343. This process replaces the existing process by which CalRecycle identifies materials that do not meet the requirements of recyclability in SB 343 but are trending towards meeting the State’s recyclable standard based on updates to an initial material characterization study, which grants those materials permission to use the chasing arrow symbol.
- Requires CalRecycle to review produces’ petitions and approve or deny them within 60 days of receipt, as provided.
- Adds an additional six months to an 18-month extension for products to be compliant with SB 343 recyclability criteria following the publication of CalRecycle’s material characterization study.
- This extension does not include chemicals that are disclosed only for purposes of compliance with a specified regulation governing the disclosure of chemicals on a list produced under the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (Proposition 65) from the intentionally added chemicals that would affect whether a product or package is considered recyclable in this state.
Background
- Plastics Pollution and Policy. Plastic pollution is a persistent problem impacting the environment on a local and global scale. In 2021, global plastics production was estimated at 390.7 million metric tons: only nine percent of all plastic ever made has been recycled, according to a United Nations Environment Programme report. Plastic pollution threatens ecosystems. As litter, plastic threatens wildlife as terrestrial and marine animals alike can become entangled in or ingest plastic debris, causing suffocation or starvation. Moreover, plastic never truly degrades into its chemical components; instead, it physically breaks down into smaller and smaller pieces that become more penetrative and more challenging to clean from the environment. Plastics under five millimeters, or microplastics, have been found in the most pristine environments on earth, including in national parks, in Antarctic sea ice, and in human placentas: microplastics are shown to increase risks of cancer and disrupt hormone pathways in lab rats.
To reduce plastics in the environment, CalRecycle has been tasked with reducing the amount of waste that is landfilled and promoting recycling in California through the IWMA. The IWMA establishes a goal of source reducing, recycling, or composting at least 75% of solid waste generated in the State by 2020. However, according to CalRecycle’s 2022 State of Disposal and Recycling, the State’s 2021 recycling rate was just 41%. The single largest contributor to this recycling rate was recyclables that were exported out of the state. The statewide recycling rate has declined over the last decade, following a peak of 50% in 2014. The recycling rate has been impacted and may continue to be impacted by global policies like China’s National SWORD and the Basel Convention, which restrict the amount of foreign waste these countries will accept.
One of the major factors that intrinsically impacts California’s recycling efforts is the broader market for recyclable materials. Without intervention, in order for material to be recycled and not end up in a landfill, the cost of processing and using the recycled material must be less than cost of the of virgin material. Prices for scrap materials can fluctuate wildly over both the short term and the long term, influenced by global factors such as China’s National Sword in 2017, the global pandemic’s impacts on industry and shipping, and the price of oil.
- What is recyclable? It is often unclear to consumers what is and is not recyclable. There have historically been several reasons for this, including:
- Resin identification codes. In California, rigid plastic bottles and containers are required to display a resin identification code (RIC) inside of a triangle or a chasing arrows symbol. Consumers may assume this code means a package is automatically recyclable, but that is not the case. According to CalRecycle, only plastics with the code #1 for polyethylene terephthalate (PET), used in water and soda bottles, and #2 high-density polyethylene (HDPE), used in milk jugs and shampoo bottles, are commonly recycled currently. The rest of the resin types #3-7 are generally not recycled.
- Regional and temporal variability. The way plastics are recycled varies by jurisdiction. What can be recycled in one area of the state may not be recyclable in another. As of 2015, there were an estimated 161 Materials Recovery Facility (MRF)s statewide. According to a 2020 Recyclability Screening Survey of 76 CA MRFs, plastic items made from resins #3-7 were accepted at a rate of 1-82% depending on the type of item. While all MRFs accepted PET and HDPE bottles and jugs, there was also variability in other #1 and #2 resin items accepted, such as PET clamshells, cups and HDPE rigid containers. What can be recycled within a particular jurisdiction will also vary over time depending on when a waste hauler can sell their collected materials.
To address the consumer confusion on what can and cannot be recycled, and specifically to curtail misinformation or “greenwashing” that promotes products as recyclable when they are not, the Legislature enacted the “truth in labelling” for recyclability in SB 343 (Allen Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021).
- SB 343. SB 343 prohibits producers from making a false claim of recyclability on their products, such as using a chasing arrow symbol on material that does not meet strict standards for recyclability.
- A product is considered “recyclable” under SB 343 only if at least 60% of jurisdictions can collect, sort, and bale a material for sale to a recycler. In order to determine what materials meet this standard of recyclability, SB 343 directs CalRecycle to publish data about the types of materials that are actually recycled in jurisdictions across California and specifically directs CalRecycle to: Oversee a statewide analysis of material recovery facilities to identify which materials are commonly collected, sorted, sold, or transferred for recycling in California; and
- Oversee a follow-up study in 2027 and every five years thereafter to make updates to the statewide analysis.
CalRecycle published a draft of its preliminary findings on December 28, 2023, and is currently accepting public feedback on those findings.
- SB 54. SB 54 uses an EPR approach to reach ambitious targets to reduce single-use serviceware and packaging through source reduction and postconsumer recycled content. These goals include:
- Requiring all covered material sold in the state to be recyclable or compostable by January 1, 2032;
- Requiring that all plastic-covered material sold in the state meet a recycling rate of 65% by Jan 1, 2032, with interim goals beginning in 2028;
- Prohibiting producers of expanded polystyrene (EPS) from selling EPS food serviceware unless they meet a 65% recycling rate by January 1, 2032; and
- Requiring the PRO to pay $500 million per year from January 1, 2027, through January 1, 2037 to fund the program, and authorizes the PRO to collect up to $150 million from plastic manufacturers.
5) SB 343 and SB 54. SB 343 and SB 54 both regulate many of the same products.
To align these two measures, SB 343 specifically included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material that does not meet the “recyclability” standard in SB 343 but is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (i.e. SB 54). This “onramp” provision also includes a guardrail that the material has been determined by CalRecycle not to contaminate the recycling stream if placed in a recycle bin. The onramp provision in SB 343 would allow material covered in SB 54 to be labeled as recyclable if producers can demonstrate an improvement in the material's recycling rate.
However, CalRecycle’s timeline to re-evaluate the material characterization study is Jan 1, 2027. This re-evaluation is necessary to ascertain which materials are increasing towards the recyclability standards in SB 343, and resultantly, which materials would be eligible to continue to use the “chasing arrow” symbol under SB 343. Having a January 1, 2027 timeline to make this evaluation would preclude materials that are meeting the requirements intended to onramp them into SB 343 for the next two years. As a result, these products would need to remove their “chasing arrow” symbol during that timeframe, only to (potentially) add it back on to the same product if the subsequent material characterization study finds that they are advancing towards the goals of SB 343 and eligible to use the chasing arrow symbol.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “In 2021, the Legislature passed SB 343, which established a clear definition in California law for recyclability and prohibited producers from making recyclability claims on their products, including using the ubiquitous chasing arrows symbol, unless the product meets the standards in the definition. The measure included an “on-ramp” clause allowing the use of the chasing arrows symbol on material if that material is part of a statewide program aimed at increasing the recycling rate for that material (SB 54, California’s plastics pollution law passed the following year in 2022) and CalRecycle determines the material will not contaminate the recycling stream. The purpose of this “on-ramp” clause was to ensure that if producers were investing in recycling infrastructure under SB 54 and could demonstrate that those investments were increasing the recyclability of their material, they could continue encouraging consumers to put the material in the blue recycle bin. Otherwise, when SB 343 is fully implemented next year, consumers will not know how to recycle the material, and producers of that material could not comply with SB 54 despite their efforts.
However, the language in SB 54 inadvertently precludes CalRecycle from identifying which material could qualify for this on-ramp until the deadline for removing the recyclability claim and chasing arrows has passed. SB 1231 addresses this time gap by allowing producers to petition CalRecycle for the continued use of recycling claims for a product if the producer can demonstrate sufficient investments that will allow the material to meet California’s definition. The bill continues to give CalRecycle full discretion to determine which materials meet this high bar.”
- Bridging an onramp across policies. To align the “onramp” in SB 343 with the material characterization study timelines in SB 54, SB 1231 removes the requirement that CalRecycle first evaluate which materials covered by SB 54 are advancing towards the recyclability standard in SB 343, and instead creates a petition process where producers can request that specific materials be authorized by CalRecycle to meet that standard. Tasking producers with making the case that materials are “trending towards recyclability” removes the need for CalRecycle to make this call based on updates to the material characterization study. Removing the reliance on the follow-up material characterization study, published in 2027, would make the on-ramp for products improving in recyclability targets under SB 343 viable before that 2027 timeline.
Who knows best? The method that SB 1231 uses to bridge the “onramp” for materials that are covered in SB 54 and trending towards SB 343 recyclability goals flips the task of identifying what materials are trending towards SB 343 compliance from CalRecycle to the producers. Under SB 1231, CalRecycle still has the final say in whether or not products are “onramped” onto SB 343 and are allowed to continue to use the chasing arrow symbol even if they do not yet meet the recyclability standards of SB 343. However, SB 1231 would put CalRecycle in a responsive position, instead of in the driver’s seat.
Putting the onus on producers to make the case that their product is advancing towards the recyclability goals in SB 343 instead of relying on CalRecycle to make that determination assumes that the producers have better access to information on what is and is not improving on recyclability. Before CalRecycle has data from the follow-up material characterization study, this is likely to be true. However, after CalRecycle has completed its second material characterization study, it will have the evidence needed to evaluate for itself whether or not a given material is increasing in recyclability.
In its current form, SB 1231 does not specify what information producers should provide to CalRecycle to make their case, or establish a process of enforcement should the information provided to CalRecycle be inaccurate.
As the bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider whether the petition process for establishing increasing recyclability of materials should be used in perpetuity, or only until the first follow-up material characterization study is released in 2027. The author may wish to further consider what information should be included in the petition from producers to help CalRecycle evaluate whether or not a product or material is eligible for the SB 343 onramp, and consider what remedies might be needed if producers submit information that is not accurate in making a claim towards increasing recyclability.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 343 (Allen, Chapter 507, Statutes of 2021) tightens the requirements around the permissible use of the “chasing arrows” recycling symbol and when claims regarding recyclability can be made and requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to publish the types and forms of recyclable products and packaging
SB 54 (Allen Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022) establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which imposes minimum content and source reduction requirements for plastic single-use packaging and food service ware through an EPR program.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
American Chemistry Council
American Cleaning Institute
Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers
Calchamber
California Farm Bureau
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Retailers Association
Consumer Brands Association
Dairy Institute of California
Danone North America
Flexible Packaging Association
International Dairy Foods Association
Keurig Dr Pepper INC.
Kraft Heinz Company
National Stewardship Action Council
Nestle USA
Personal Care Products Council
Pet Food Institute
Recycling Partnership; the
The Association of Plastic Recyclers
The Toy Association
Unilever
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):