SB 1259: California Environmental Quality Act: judicial review.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-02-15
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-03: April 3 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 0. Page 3467.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment, or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA authorizes specified entities to file and maintain with a court an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul an act of a public agency on grounds of noncompliance with the requirements of CEQA.
This bill would authorize a defendant, in an action brought under CEQA, to file a motion requesting the plaintiff or petitioner to identify every person or entity that contributes in excess of $10,000, as specified, toward the plaintiffs or petitioners costs of the action. The bill would authorize the motion to be heard on shortened time at the courts discretion. The bill would authorize a plaintiff or petitioner to request the courts permission to withhold the public disclosure of a person or entity who made a monetary contribution. The bill also would require the plaintiff or petitioner to use reasonable efforts to identify the actual persons or entities that are the true source of the contributions, to include the exact total amount contributed, and to identify any pecuniary or business interest related to the project of any person or entity that contributes in excess of $10,000 to the costs of the action, as specified. The bill would, except as provided, prohibit those disclosures from being admissible into evidence for any purpose. The bill would provide that a failure to comply with these requirements may be grounds for dismissal of the action by the court.
This bill would require an action or proceeding brought to attack, review, set aside, void, or annual acts or decision of a public agency for a commercial, housing, or public works project that helps to address longstanding critical needs in the project area and that results in an investment of at least $25,000,000 in the state on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 365 days of the filing of the certified record of proceedings with the court. The bill would require the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to implement this provision.
This bill would require the courts approval for a settlement agreement reached in an action or proceeding brought under CEQA and would prohibit the court from approving the settlement agreement if the settlement agreement contains a nonenvironmental provision, as defined.
CEQA authorizes a court, in an action or proceeding brought challenging the decision of a public agency on the ground of noncompliance with CEQA, to enter an order to suspend any or all specific project activity or activities if the court finds that the activity or activities will prejudice the consideration or implementation of particular mitigation measures or alternatives to the project. CEQA provides that, except as otherwise specified, it is not intended to limit the equitable powers of the courts.
This bill would instead prohibit the court from staying or enjoining the construction or operation of a project unless it makes certain findings. The bill would delete that intent relating to the equitable powers of the courts.
(a)For purposes of this section, project means a commercial, housing, or public works project that helps to address longstanding critical needs in the project area and that results in an investment of at least twenty-five million dollars ($25,000,000) in the state.
(b)To the extent feasible, an action or proceeding filed pursuant to this division to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul acts or decisions of a public agency for a project on the grounds of noncompliance with this division, including any potential appeals to the court of appeal or the Supreme Court, shall be resolved within 365 days of the filing of the certified record of proceedings prepared pursuant to Section 21167.6 or 21167.6.2 with the court.
(c)The Judicial Council shall adopt a rule of court that establishes procedures to implement subdivision (b).
SEC. 2.Section 21168.9 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:21168.9.(a)If a court finds, as a result of a trial, hearing, or remand from an appellate court, that any determination, finding, or decision of a public agency has been made without compliance with this division, the court shall enter an order that includes one or more of the following:
(1)A mandate that the determination, finding, or decision be voided by the public agency, in whole or in part.
(2)If the court finds that a specific project activity or activities will prejudice the consideration or implementation of particular mitigation measures or alternatives to the project, a mandate that the public agency and any real parties in interest suspend any or all specific project activity or activities, pursuant to the determination, finding, or decision, that could result in an adverse change or alteration to the physical environment, until the public agency has taken any actions that may be necessary to bring the determination, finding, or decision into compliance with this division.(2)Relief as provided in subdivision (c).
(3)A mandate that the public agency take specific action as may be necessary to bring the determination, finding, or decision into compliance with this division.
(b)Any An order pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include only those mandates which that are necessary to achieve compliance with this division and only those specific project activities in noncompliance with this division. The order shall be made by the issuance of a peremptory writ of mandate specifying what action by the public agency is necessary to comply with this division. However, the order shall be limited to that portion of a determination, finding, or decision or the specific project activity or activities found to be in noncompliance only if a court finds that (1) the portion or specific project activity or activities are severable, (2) severance will not prejudice complete and full compliance with this division, and (3) the court has not found the remainder of the project to be in noncompliance with this division. The trial court shall retain jurisdiction over the public agencys proceedings by way of a return to the peremptory writ until the court has determined that the public agency has complied with this division.
(c)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), in granting relief in an action or proceeding brought pursuant to this division, the court shall not stay or enjoin the construction or operation of a project unless the court finds either of the following:
(A)The continued construction or operation of the project presents an imminent threat to the public health and safety.
(B)The project location contains unforeseen important Native American artifacts or unforeseen important historical, archaeological, or ecological values that would be materially, permanently, and adversely affected by the continued construction or operation of the project unless the court stays or enjoins the construction or operation of the project.
(2)If the court finds that subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) is satisfied, the court shall only enjoin those specific activities associated with the project that present an imminent threat to public health and safety or that materially, permanently, and adversely affect unforeseen important Native American artifacts or unforeseen important historical, archaeological, or ecological values.
(c)Nothing in this(d)This section authorizes does not authorize a court to direct any public agency to exercise its discretion in any particular way. Except as expressly provided in this section, nothing in this section is intended to limit the equitable powers of the court.
SEC. 3.Section 21170 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:21170.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature that this division shall not be used for nonenvironmental purposes.
(b)For purposes of this section, nonenvironmental provision means a provision that is unrelated to environmental protection, or a provision providing concessions by a project proponent that is unrelated to the environment. Nonenvironmental provision does not include provisions related to attorneys fees or other costs that are directly attributable to the action or proceeding.
(c)(1)A settlement agreement reached in an action or proceeding brought pursuant to this division shall be approved by the court.
(2)The court shall not approve a settlement agreement if the settlement agreement contains a nonenvironmental provision.
SEC. 4.Section 21176 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:21176.(a)(1)Any defendant in an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul any act or decision of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with this division, may file a motion requesting the plaintiff or petitioner to identify every person or entity who made a monetary contribution of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or more, or committed to contribute ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or more, for the preparation of the petition and subsequent action or proceeding. The motion may be heard on shortened time at the courts discretion.
(2)Upon a motion by the defendant pursuant to paragraph (1), a plaintiff or petitioner shall provide the information specified in this section within seven days.
(3)Any information disclosed to the defendant by the plaintiff or petitioner pursuant to this section shall be kept confidential and shall not be disclosed to anyone for 30 days.
(4)A plaintiff or petitioner may request the courts permission to withhold the public disclosure of a person or entity who made a monetary contribution. The court may grant the request if it finds that the public interest in keeping that information confidential clearly outweighs the public interest in disclosure. If the court grants a request pursuant to this paragraph, the information disclosed to the defendant shall be kept confidential.
(b)If the defendant makes a motion pursuant to subdivision (a), the plaintiff or petitioner shall have a continuing obligation throughout the course of the proceeding to identify any person or entity that has made a single or multiple contributions or commitments, the sum of which is ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or more, and that were intended to fund the action or proceeding within seven days of receiving the contribution. All other provisions of this section shall apply to a disclosure pursuant to this subdivision.
(c)In complying with subdivisions (a) and (b), the plaintiff or petitioner shall use reasonable efforts to identify the actual persons or entities that are the true source of the contributions.
(d)The disclosures required pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) shall include the exact total amount contributed and also include the identity of any pecuniary or business interest that the person or entity has related to the proposed project.
(e)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the information disclosed by a plaintiff or petitioner upon a motion by a defendant pursuant to this section shall not be admissible into evidence for any purpose.
(2)The information disclosed pursuant to this section shall be admissible for purposes of Section 529.2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
(f)A court may, upon its own motion or the motion of any party, take any action necessary to compel compliance with the requirements of this section, up to and including dismissal of the action or proceeding.
(g)An individual contributing funds to file an action or proceeding pursuant to this division in that individuals individual capacity, and not as a representative for an organization or association, has the right to limit disclosure of that individuals personal information to an in-camera review by the court.
(h)This section does not limit or prohibit the independent discovery of funding sources based on any other provision of law, including postjudgment motions related to recovery of attorneys fees.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 3, 2024 | April 3 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 2. Noes 0. Page 3467.) |
| Mar 8, 2024 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E.Q. and JUD. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 3, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| CalChamber | ** Support | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Against | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Against | |
| California Teamsters Public Affairs Council | ** Against | |
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Against | |
| Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment | ** Against | |
| Civil Justice Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Housing Contractors Of California | ** Support | |
| Planning And Conservation League | ** Against | |
| UFCW - Western States Council | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1259
Author: | Niello | ||
Version: | 2/15/2024 | Hearing Date: | 4/3/2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brynn Cook | ||
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: judicial review
DIGEST: This bill makes numerous changes to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), including providing expedited judicial review for projects that lead to $25 million investments or more in the state, requiring disclosures for plaintiffs or petitioners contributing more than $10,000 to a CEQA lawsuit, prohibiting staying a project unless certain criteria are met, and prohibiting approving settlements on non-environmental provisions.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Under CEQA, requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for the project, unless the project is exempt from CEQA. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.)
- Authorizes judicial review of CEQA actions taken by public agencies, following the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR doesn't comply with CEQA, must be filed in the Superior Court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. (PRC §21000 et seq.)
- Authorizes a trial court to order a party, the party’s attorney, or both to pay the reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees, incurred by another party as a result of bad-faith actions or tactics that are frivolous or solely intended to cause unnecessary delay. (Code of Civil Procedures CCP §128.5)
- Authorizes a court, in an action or proceeding brought challenging the decision of a public agency on the ground of noncompliance with CEQA, to enter an order to suspend any or all specific project activity or activities if the court finds that the activity or activities will prejudice the consideration or implementation of particular mitigation measures or alternatives to the project. CEQA provides that, except as otherwise specified, it is not intended to limit the equitable powers of the courts. (PRC § 21168.9)
- Establishes the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (AB 900, Buchanan, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011), which established CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures for an "environmental leadership" project. (PRC §21178 et seq.).
- Establishes a certification process authorizing CEQA administrative and judicial review for certain infrastructure projects meeting certain criteria. (PRC §21189.8)
- Establishes a requirement and procedure for parties in a CEQA lawsuit to meet and attempt to settle the litigation. This includes specifications that the meeting shall be scheduled and held not later than 45 days from the date of service of the petition or complaint upon the public agency, and that:
- The settlement meeting may be continued from time to time without postponing or otherwise delaying other applicable time limits in the litigation. The settlement meeting is intended to be conducted concurrently with any judicial proceedings.
- The trail court is authorized to impose sanctions on any party who was notified of the settlement and failed, without good cause, to participate in the settlement process. (PRC 21167.8)
This bill:
- Establishes an expedited judicial review period of 365 days for projects
that result in an investment of at least $25 million in the state.
- Requires, to the extent feasible, any actions to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul acts or decisions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA regarding one of these projects – including any potential appeals to the court of appeal or the Supreme Court – be resolved within 365 days of filing.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to establish procedures to implement these requirements.
- Requires a plaintiff or petitioner bringing a CEQA action to provide the identity of any person or entity contributing $10,000 or more toward the plaintiff’s or petitioner’s costs of the action within seven days if the defendant makes a motion to receive this information. This information shall be kept confidential and not disclosed to anyone for 30 days.
- Requires the plaintiff or petitioner to identify any pecuniary or business interest related to the project of any person or entity that contributes $10,000 or more to the costs of the action.
- Allows a plaintiff or petitioner to ask the court to withhold the public disclosure of a contributor and the court can grant the request if it finds the public interest in keeping that information confidential clearly outweighs the public interest in disclosure.
- Specifies that the information disclosed pursuant to this section shall not be admissible into evidence for any purpose.
- Allows a court to take any action necessary to compel compliance with this section, including dismissing the action or proceeding.
- Allows a person who contributes funds to file an action in their individual capacity, and not as a representative for an organization or association, to limit disclosure of their personal information to an in-camera review by the court.
- Establishes that a court shall not stay or enjoin a construction or operation of a project challenged under the provisions of CEQA if those actions present an imminent threat to public health and safety or that materially, permanently, and adversely affect unforeseen important Native American artifacts or unforeseen important historical, archaeological, or ecological value.
- Reverses current law to remove authority from a court to direct any public agency to exercise its discretion in any particular way.
- Deletes the specification in current law that nothing in this section is intended to limit the equitable powers of the court.
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature that CEQA shall not be used for nonenvironmetnal purposes.
- Requires that the court shall not approve a settlement agreement if the settlement agreement contains a nonenvironmental provision.
- Defines “nonenvironmental provision” to mean a provision that is unrelated to environmental protection, or a provision providing concessions by a project proponent that is unrelated to the environment.
- “Nonenvironmental provision” does not include provisions related to attorney’s fees or other costs that are directly attributable to the action or proceeding.
Background
- The A, B, C’s of CEQA. CEQA is designed to (a) make government agencies and the public aware of the environmental impacts of a proposed project, (b) ensure the public can take part in the review process, and (c) identify and implement measures to mitigate or eliminate any negative impact the project may have on the environment. CEQA is enforced by civil lawsuits that can challenge any project’s environmental review. Nonprofits, private individuals, public agencies, advocacy groups, and other organizations can all file lawsuits under CEQA.
- CEQA Streamlining. Current law has established numerous processes to reduce the time for projects involved in CEQA lawsuits. These include:
- The Superior Court and the Court of Appeal must give CEQA lawsuits preference over all other civil actions;
- If feasible, the Court of Appeal must hear a CEQA appeal within one year of filing;
- Discovery is generally not allowed, as CEQA cases are generally restricted to review of the record; and
- Counties with a population of over 200,000 must designate one or more judges to develop expertise on CEQA and hear CEQA cases.
In addition to the expediting measures that apply broadly to CEQA cases, the Legislature has also developed CEQA judicial and administrative streamlining for certain projects that meet rigorous environmental and labor criteria. In 2011, the Legislature passed the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act, which created CEQA streamlining for residential, retail, commercial, sports, and recreational use projects that were certified as Environmental Leadership Development Projects (ELDP) (AB 900, Buchanan, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011). The ELDP program was extended and modified in 2021 with (SB 7, Atkins, Chapter 19, Statutes of 2021). In 2023, these same streamlining provisions, with a slightly different certification process and similar eligibility criteria, were made available to certain energy, transportation, and water infrastructure projects (SB 1149, Caballero, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2023).
The streamlining provisions granted under SB 7 and SB 149 include both judicial and administrative streamlining. Judicial streamlining for projects requires that CEQA cases be heard in 270 days, including all appeals, as feasible. Administrative streamlining requires projects to prepare the administrative record, the comprehensive document at the heart of a CEQA case, at the same time they prepare the environmental review documents (i.e. the EIR). These streamlining measures shorten what is potentially the lengthiest portion of the CEQA process--litigation--while retaining the environmental review offered under CEQA.
The Legislature has also offered these same streamlining procedures to specific one-off projects, including:
- SB 292 (Padilla, Chapter 353, Statutes of 2011) which proposed a
downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center that
would achieve specified traffic and air quality mitigations. This
project has not proceeded.
- SB 743 (Steinberg, Chapter 386, Statutes of 2013) established special
CEQA procedures modeled after SB 292 for the Sacramento Kings
arena project and included specified traffic and air quality mitigations.
- AB 734 (Bonta, Chapter 959, Statutes of 2018) authorized the
Governor to certify, and established special CEQA procedures
modeled after AB 900 for, the Oakland Sports and Mixed-Use Project
if the project met specified conditions. Unlike AB 900, AB 734
required that 50% of the GHG emissions reductions necessary to
achieve the zero-net additional GHG emissions requirement be from
on-site and local reduction measures.
- AB 987 (Kamlager-Dove, Chapter 961, Statutes of 2018) was similar
to AB 734 but applied to a proposed basketball arena for the Los
Angeles Clippers in Inglewood. AB 987 required a transportation
demand management plan that achieves 15% reduction in vehicle
trips by 2030 and additional reductions in local criteria pollutants.
In all cases, whether through specific legislation or through the ELDP or SB 149 certification process, projects that are eligible for CEQA streamlining, must meet rigorous environmental and labor criteria. While the specific eligibility requirements vary by process, current law requires actions such as achieving LEED Gold certification and being greenhouse gas neutral. In addition to environmental criteria, SB 149 also includes a specific equity provision which requires that projects both minimize significant environmental impacts in disadvantaged communities and take mitigation measures that directly benefit the affected community
- CEQA Disclosure Laws. CEQA lawsuits can be brought by anyone who has an environmental concern about a project, keeping the barrier to bring a CEQA lawsuit intentionally low. Lawsuits can be brought anonymously, and plaintiff and petitioners in a CEQA case do not have to disclose any person or entities that contribute to fund a given lawsuit. According to a group of developer attorneys forming the organization “CEQA Research Council,” “CEQA lawsuits…are frequently filed on behalf of unincorporated associations or other loosely formed organizations…As a result, it is often difficult, if not impossible, to identify the ‘real’ plaintiff underwriting a CEQA lawsuit.”
- While it is unclear how frequently this assertion may actually be true in CEQA litigation, it has spurred a number of pieces of legislation over the last decade, including, AB 2026, Hadley, 2016; SB 1248 Moorlach, 2016; SB 1341 Glazer 2018; AB 1673 Salas, 2019. None of these measures have successfully passed through the Legislature. Staying Projects. If a lawsuit has been filed to challenge a project under CEQA, that project does not immediately halt while the lawsuit is ongoing. In fact, CEQA requires that responsible agencies assume that the project is in compliance with the law unless ordered by a court to halt project activity.
A petitioner that wants to stop a project while a lawsuit is ongoing must seek a “stay” from the courts following the Code of Civil Procedures. The general rule under this law is that trial court may stay operation of an administrative decision based on its merits, but that the stay cannot be imposed or continued if that stay is against the public interest.
Stay orders operate only to suspend operation of an agency’s decision: it may not be sufficient to prevent a project from proceeding. If a final approval has been issued and the project is underway, it may take an order prohibiting further development to stop work on a project.
While the decision on whether to grant a stay is typically in the purview of the courts, previous legislation (SB 743, Steinberg, 2013) has dictated that in the case of a specific ELDP certified project, the Sacramento Kings Arena, the court should not stay or enjoin construction of arena unless the court found either that:
- The continued construction or operation of the downtown arena presents an imminent threat to the public health and safety.
- The downtown arena site contains unforeseen important Native American artifacts or unforeseen important historical, archaeological, or ecological values that would be materially, permanently, and adversely affected by the continued construction or operation of the downtown arena unless the court stays or enjoins the construction or operation of the downtown arena.
- Nonenvironmental provisions. CEQA currently has jurisdiction over a project that (1) is a discretionary action by a governmental agency and (2) will either have a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect impact on the environment. Actions that do not have a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect impact on the environment are not subject to CEQA.
Under CEQA, an EIR analyzes the significant direct and indirect environmental impacts of a proposed project on water quality, transportation, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions, terrestrial and aquatic biological resources, surface and subsurface hydrology, land use and agricultural resources, aesthetics, geology and soils, recreation, public services and utilities such as water supply and wastewater disposal, and cultural resources, among other factors.
- Mediation in CEQA. CEQA currently requires the litigating parties to engage in a mandatory settlement meeting within 45 days of service of a lawsuit on a public agency. The parties must meet and attempt in good faith to settle the litigation and the underlying dispute, which includes considering anticipated issues to be raised in litigation. Settlements negotiations usually involve requests to reduce objectionable impacts that result from the project by modifying the projects or adding additional mitigation measures. This mediation process happens at the same time as the lawsuit is moving forward under judicial proceedings, and the settlement can go on intermittently throughout the court case.
The trail court is authorized to impose sanctions on any party who fails without good cause to participate in the settlement process. CEQA practitioners and trial courts have interpreted this statue to mean that the parties must make a good faith effort to settle the litigation –merely showing up to the settlement meetings may not be enough to comply with the participation requirement.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “In recent years, CEQA has been seen as a tool to block project developments of any size when entities do not like it, even for non-environmental reasons. If we do not take steps to amend this legacy legislation, California is destined for never-ending litigation, increased costs, and ongoing delays. Some common disruptions include project opponents filing a lawsuit forcing a developer to prepare an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) even if the lead agency has already deemed it unnecessary, challenging a completed EIR, or questioning an exemption. Litigation or even the threat thereof creates delays and uncertainty that leads to increased project timelines and costs.
“SB 1259 would prevent those who seek an unfair business competition advantage or have ulterior motives, from improperly hiding behind CEQA to block a project through litigation. Stated simply, this measure would require full disclosure on all lawsuits filed for all parties involved. Removing the existing anonymity from those who file nameless ensures transparency for all.”
- Great power and great responsibility in CEQA streamlining. In current law, projects must meet strong environmental and labor criteria to be eligible for CEQA judicial and administrative streamlining. While the specific environmental and labor criteria vary depending on which process projects are certified through (ELDP program or SB 149 infrastructure provisions) or through individual legislation, the criteria ensure that only projects that are environmental leaders are eligible for streamlining. In offering CEQA streamlining for projects that meet these high standards, the state can promote projects that align with California’s environmental, climate, and labor goals.
SB 1259 would create streamlining provision for projects based solely on how expensive the project is (i.e., bringing in at least $25 million in investment to the state). This overturns the current policy of the Legislature, which is to grant CEQA streamlining specifically to promote environmentally-aligned development. Moreover, instead of creating a competitive edge for projects that are “environmental leaders,” SB 1259 would offer a competitive edge to “the big guys.” While large projects may in some cases have benefits to the communities in which they are sited, those benefits are dependent on the type of project. Since SB 1259 does not specify what types of projects would be eligible for this exemption, one potential result from this would be giving a competitive edge to bigger projects over smaller projects simply because one is bigger.
Furthermore, granting these large projects CEQA streamlining could jam up courts calendars and resultantly slow down streamlining for other projects that have been granted CEQA streamlining through the ELDP or SB 149 processes in existing law. An expedited judicial review does not guarantee that a challenge to a project will be resolved within 270 days, as demonstrated by: (1) the Sacramento Kings Arena (Adriana Gianturco Saltonstall et al. v. City of Sacramento), (2) the Golden State Warriors Arena (Mission Bay Alliance et al. v. Office of Community Investment and Infrastructure and a separate non-CEQA lawsuit), and (3) 8150 Sunset Boulevard Mixed Use Development which had 4 CEQA challenges to the project (Los Angeles Conservancy v. City of Los Angeles; Fix the City, Inc. v. City of Los Angeles; JDR Crescent v. City of Los Angeles; and Manners v. City of Los Angeles), none of which were resolved within 270 days
Although it is difficult to estimate how many projects could ultimately qualify under this new large investment category, if numerous projects are fast-tracked to the front of judicial calendars, courts may be forced to repeatedly miss the 270 day deadline for ELDP or SB 149 projects, or the 365 deadline for large investment projects authorized under this bill.
An identical proposal to this portion of SB 1259 was introduced by the same author in 2023 and was held in this committee.
- Requiring disclosures in CEQA. SB 1259 requires a plaintiff or petitioner bringing a CEQA action to include an affidavit that discloses the identity of any person or entity contributing $1,000 or more supporting the action. Requiring this disclosure of contributions raises two equity issues. First, the bill only requires plaintiffs, but not respondents or real parties in interest, to disclose when they accept contributions. Second, while the disclosure of large contributions is important, there is no requirement to report an entity’s overall spending on a lawsuit. So, while Plaintiff A who accepts three $1,000 contributions in support of their lawsuit would have to report those to the court, the court and the public would have no idea how much Plaintiff A raised and spent overall to support their lawsuit. Plaintiff B, who may raise money in amounts less than $1,000 contributions, could actually raise more funds overall, but would never have to report anything to the court. Similarly, Plaintiff C who may not accept any contributions and may entirely self-finance a CEQA lawsuit also wouldn’t have to report anything to the court. As a result, the snapshot of money raised in support of a CEQA lawsuit would be incomplete or even misleading.
Moreover, the courts already have authority under current law to sanction parties who pursue claims in bad faith or for improper purposes. If the identity or motives of a plaintiff are in question, a court can not only compel the party to identify itself, but issue sanctions if the court finds that the party's actions or tactics are frivolous.
In 2023, the Senate Environmental Quality Committee passed a bill that had the same disclosure provisions in SB 1259, but narrowly tailored those provisions to apply only to housing projects. That bill (SB 393, Glazer, 2023), is still active in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
- Staying stays. As noted in the background section, projects facing CEQA lawsuits do not automatically halt while the lawsuit is ongoing: plaintiffs must seek a stay from the courts, and then the court must adjudicate whether or not a stay is warranted. Staying or enjoining a project that does not comply with CEQA serves as a crucial mechanism to safeguard both communities and the environment from projects that could cause environmental harm. Imagine a worst-case scenario where a plaintiff brings a case alleging that a development project violates CEQA, but as the case is being decided, the project moves forward and results in significant impacts to the environment. Even if the case was eventually decided in favor of the plaintiff, any impacts to the environment as the court adjudicated the issue may be irreversible.
Requiring a stay to be sought by the plaintiff and authorizing courts to evaluate whether or not a stay is appropriate offers both protection against projects that are found to violate CEQA (and may have significant impacts in the communities in which they are sited) and does not prohibit the project from advancing if the court action results in a final determination that the EIR or negative declaration complies with the provisions of CEQA.
- Where’s the sense in nonenvironment? Because projects are only subject to CEQA if they have either a direct or reasonably foreseeable indirect impact on the environment, any case that meets the criteria of “nonenvironmental” would not be subject to a CEQA (or a CEQA lawsuit). Ultimately, the courts would make the decision on whether or not a lawsuit was based on “nonenvironmental” issues and thus a viable case under CEQA or not.
The cost for bringing a meritless suit can be severe. For example, are recent much-publicized case Save Livermore Downtown v. City of Livermore.(Save Livermore Downtown v. City of Livermore (2023) Cal.App.5th) In this case, the city off Livermore approved a 120 unit affordable housing development in downtown Livermore, and a community group called Save Livermore Downtown filed a lawsuit claiming that the city’s approval violated CEQA. Ultimately, the trial court ruled in favor of the city, stating that the plaintiff's CEQA arguments were “almost utterly without merit.” The court then ordered a $500,000 bond for costs and damages incurred by the project developer by these litigation-related delays, which allows statute allows parties defending low or moderate-income housing development projects to request that the plaintiff post a bond for costs and damages that may result from a bad faith lawsuit or a lawsuit brought to delay a project.
With “direct and indirect environmental impacts” being a requirement for a project to be under the purview of CEQA, and with protections already in place for meritless cases, it is unclear what the “nonenvironmental” provision of SB 1259 seeks to achieve.
SB 1259 also prohibits a court from approving a CEQA settlement agreement if the settlement agreement contains a nonenvironmental provision. A “nonenvironmental provisions” is defined in the bill to mean a provision that is unrelated to environmental protection, or a provision that provides concessions by a project proponent that is unrelated to the environment. It is unclear if this definition is intended to preclude specific impacts that are required to be considered in a full EIR (e.g., water quality, transportation, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions, terrestrial and aquatic biological resources, surface and subsurface hydrology, land use and agricultural resources, aesthetics, geology and soils, recreation, public services and utilities such as water supply and wastewater disposal, and cultural resources, among other factors). Without understanding how the definition of “nonenvironment” maps onto the definition of “direct or indirect environmental impacts” that are considered under CEQA, it is not feasible to determine how this proposed legislation would be interpreted.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 794 (Niello, 2023) would have required CEQA actions challenging a commercial, housing, or public works project that has at least $25 million invested in it to be resolved within 365 days of filing. It also required a CEQA plaintiff to disclose any contributions received of $100 or more to help fund the legal action. This bill was held in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
SB 393 (Glazer, 2023) requires a CEQA plaintiff to disclose any contributions he or she has received of $1,000 or more to help fund the legal action. It also prevents a CEQA action from being filed against a housing project that was included as part of a larger plan or project already approved under CEQA. This bill is awaiting hearing in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 239 (Dahle, 2023) would have required, among other things, any CEQA actions to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul acts or decisions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance CEQA regarding one of these projects – including any potential appeals to the court of appeal or the Supreme Court – to be resolved within 365 days of filing.
SB 7 (Chapter 19, Statutes of 2021. Atkins, 2021) extends and expands expedited CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures in the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act (Leadership Act) for ELDPs. Additionally, this bill expands the Leadership Act to include smaller housing projects.
AB 1673 (Salas,2019) would have required a plaintiff or petitioner to, in a CEQA action, disclose the identity of a person or entity that contributes in excess of $1,000 toward the plaintiff’s or petitioner’s costs of the action. This bill was defeated in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee
SB 1341 (Glazer, 2018) would have required a plaintiff or petitioner, in an CEQA action, to disclose the identity of a person or entity that contributes in excess of $1,000, toward the plaintiff’s or petitioner’s costs of the action. It also sought to prohibit an action or proceeding from being brought in the court to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul an act of a public agency for housing projects on grounds of noncompliance with CEQA. This bill was assigned to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee but was never heard.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Calchamber
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Housing Contractors of California
OPPOSITION:
California Environmental Voters
California Environmental Voters (formerly Clcv)
California Labor Federation
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Center for Biological Diversity
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Planning and Conservation League
Ufcw - Western States Council
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the California Chamber of Commerce “CEQA serves an important goal of preventing public agencies from approving projects with potentially significant impacts if there are feasible mitigation measures that would eliminate or substantially reduce those impacts. Notwithstanding these benefits, CEQA can be used by special interest groups to delay, scale back, or halt projects altogether for reasons unrelated to the environment
“SB 1259 makes four important changes to CEQA that will help prevent the
weaponization of CEQA for non-environmental reasons. First, the timeline for challenges and appellate review will be limited to 365 days for all major commercial, housing, and public works projects over $25 million dollars where it can be shown that these projects will help address longstanding critical needs in the project areas. Second, it would require parties filing CEQA lawsuits to identify individuals/groups providing $10,000 or more for the preparation of the lawsuit to disclose the economic interest(s) of those opposing or seeking to modify an approved project. Third, it would limit the ability of the courts to stop projects from proceeding once they have been approved, except in circumstances where there are clear and direct threats to public health, the environment, and other important benefits. Lastly, it would limit settlements to environmental issues related to the project such as mitigation measures or project alternatives that materially reduce significant physical impacts to the environment.
We support these types of efforts to identify thoughtful ways to preserve the
integrity of CEQA while updating the statute to quash known abuses of the
statute.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to California Environmental Voters “This bill would authorize a defendant, in an action brought under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), to file a motion requesting the plaintiff or petitioner to identify every person or entity that contributes $10,000 or more toward the plaintiff’s or petitioner’s costs of the action and would provide that a failure to comply with these requirements may be grounds for dismissal of the action by the court.
“…SB 1259 will dramatically weaken CEQA protections, leading to increased
unmitigated environmental impacts in California communities.
CEQA provides for public disclosure of environmental impacts of a project and mitigation of these impacts in order to require polluters to clean up for their actions. It helps promote informed decision making and a better environment for all. SB 1259 does not serve any identifiable public purpose. It would impose unnecessary burdens on both plaintiffs and petitioners, decrease judicial efficiency by adding a motion practice and discovery tool that would complicate litigation, and would likely exclude meritorious cases from court, and in particular meritorious cases being brought by plaintiffs with fewer resources with which to litigate–and therefore excluding those most disproportionately impacted by environmentally deleterious development from the courthouse, when it is precisely they who are most in need of protection by CEQA. This bill does not state the rationale for imposing this burden on CEQA plaintiffs and petitioners. It seems to rely primarily on sinister insinuations”
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):