SB 1413: Year-round standard time: State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission: report.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-16
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-27: Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 97.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing state law, Proposition 7, an initiative measure approved by the voters at the November 6, 2018, statewide general election, sets the standard time for California and sets daylight saving time to begin each March and end each November. Proposition 7 authorizes the Legislature to amend these provisions by a 2/3 vote to change the dates and times of the daylight saving time period, consistent with federal law, and authorizes the Legislature to amend these provisions by a 2/3 vote to provide for the application of year-round daylight saving time when authorized by federal law.
Existing law requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to continuously carry out studies, research projects, data collection, and other activities required to assess the nature, extent, and distribution of energy resources to meet the needs of the state.
This bill would repeal daylight saving time in the state and the provisions regarding the Legislatures authority to amend the above-described provisions by a 2/3 vote. The bill would instead require the state and all political subdivisions of the state to observe year-round standard time. The bill would exempt the state and all political subdivisions of the state from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time. The bill would require the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to to, on or before February 1, 2027, prepare and submit a report to the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply, as specified. The bill would make the operation of its provisions contingent upon an appropriation by the Legislature for its purpose.
Existing state law, Proposition 7, an initiative measure approved by the voters at the November 6, 2018, statewide general election, sets the standard time for California and sets daylight saving time to begin each March and end each November. Proposition 7 authorizes the Legislature to amend these provisions by a 2/3 vote to change the dates and times of the daylight saving time period, consistent with federal law, and authorizes the Legislature to amend these provisions by a 2/3 vote to provide for the application of year-round daylight saving time when authorized by federal law.
This bill would repeal daylight saving time in the state and the provisions regarding the Legislatures authority to amend the above-described provisions by a 2/3 vote. The bill would instead require the state and all political subdivisions of the state to observe year-round standard time. The bill would exempt the state and all political subdivisions of the state from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time. The bill would require the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply, as specified.
Existing state law, Proposition 7, an initiative measure approved by the voters at the November 6, 2018, statewide general election, sets the standard time for California and sets daylight saving time to begin each March and end each November. Proposition 7 authorizes the Legislature to amend these provisions by a 2/3 vote to change the dates and times of the daylight saving time period, consistent with federal law, and authorizes the Legislature to amend these provisions by a 2/3 vote to provide for the application of year-round daylight saving time when authorized by federal law.
This bill would repeal daylight saving time in the state and the provisions regarding the Legislatures authority to amend the above-described provisions by a 2/3 vote. The bill would instead require the state and all political subdivisions of the state to observe year-round standard time. The bill would exempt the state and all political subdivisions of the state from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time.
(a)By February 1, 2025, On or before February 1, 2027, the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission shall prepare and submit a report to the relevant policy committees of the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts of year-round standard time on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
(b)(1)A report to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5, this section is repealed on February 1, 2029.
(c)This section shall become operative only upon an appropriation by the Legislature for its purpose.
(a)(1)The standard time within the state is that of the fifth zone designated by federal law as Pacific standard time (15 U.S.C. Secs. 261 and 263).
(2)The state and all political subdivisions of the state shall observe the standard time pursuant to paragraph (1).
(b)The state and all political subdivisions of the state shall be exempt from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time (15 U.S.C. Sec. 260a).
SEC. 2.Section 6809 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 6808, to read:6809.(a)By February 1, 2025, the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission shall prepare and submit a report to the relevant policy committees of the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply. The report shall include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts of year-round standard time on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
(b)(1)A report to be submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(2)Pursuant to Section 10231.5, this section is repealed on February 1, 2029.
(a)(1)The standard time within the state is that of the fifth zone designated by federal law as Pacific standard time (15 U.S.C. Secs. 261 and 263).
(b)The standard time within the state shall advance by one hour during the daylight saving time period commencing at 2 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and ending at 2 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year.(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Legislature may amend this section by a two-thirds vote to change the dates and times of the daylight saving time period, consistent with federal law, and, if federal law authorizes the state to provide for the year-round application of daylight saving time, the Legislature may amend this section by a two-thirds vote to provide for that application.(2)The state and all political subdivisions of the state shall observe the standard time pursuant to paragraph (1).
(b)The state and all political subdivisions of the state shall be exempt from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time (15 U.S.C. Sec. 260a).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 27, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 97. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | From inactive file. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | Notice of intention to remove from inactive file given by Assembly Member Flora. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Santiago. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (August 15). |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (July 1). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| May 24, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 33. Noes 1. Page 4176.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3982.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2024 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2024 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 23, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 18, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 0. Page 3632.) (April 16). |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Set for hearing April 16. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | April 2 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 19, 2024 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1413 Niello et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine | ** Support | |
| american academy of sleep medicine | ** Support | |
| California Alliance For Golf | ** Against | |
| California Medical Association | ** Support | |
| California Sleep Society | ** Support | |
| Coalition for Permanent Standard Time | ** Support | |
| national sleep foundation | ** Support | |
| Northwest Noggin Neuroscience | ** Support | |
| Save Standard Time | ** Support | |
| Sleep Research Society | ** Support | |
| Society for Research on Biological Rhythms | ** Support |
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1413
Author:(Niello)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the California Energy Commission (CEC), on or before February 1, 2027, and upon appropriation by the Legislature, to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
Major Provisions
- Requires the CEC, on or before February 1, 2027, to prepare and submit a report to the relevant policy committees of the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
- Requires the report to include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
- Makes the operation of its provisions contingent upon an appropriation by the Legislature for its purpose.
- Repeals the section on February 1, 2029.
COMMENTS
In California, Daylight Saving Time (DST) is observed during the time of year when clocks "spring forward," between the second Sunday of March and first Sunday of November, consistent with federal law. Pacific Standard Time (PST) in California is observed during the time of year when clocks "fall back," between the first Sunday of November and second Sunday of March. DST is often referred to as "summer time" and PST is often referred to as "winter time."
Within the Legislature, many attempts have been made to do away with the biannual changing of the clocks, with some efforts advocating for year-long PST and others championing for year-long DST. States remain prohibited from establishing year-long DST without federal authorization; as such, year-long PST may be more achievable within the confines of California's authority. Contemporary arguments for permanent standard time (and permanent DST) are not related to energy and instead center on health and safety considerations. Previous studies by the CEC and the U.S. Department of Energy have found the effects of permanent DST on energy savings to be nominal. However, these studies are more than 10 years old, and did not consider the energy implications of PST. With California's increased reliance on intermittent renewable resources, particularly solar energy, it is unclear whether a move to permanent PST might challenge grid conditions since the sun would set earlier in the summer as a result of this change. This bill would require the CEC, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to assess the implications of moving to year-long PST on energy reliability.
According to the Author
"SB 1413 is a bipartisan, multistate effort to "ditch the switch" and end Daylight Saving Time (DST). There have been federal efforts to establish permanent DST but those have failed (Congressional action is needed for permanent DST). There is no act of Congress or federal permission needed to be successful in switching, however, to Permanent Standard Time (PST). This measure is a simple study bill to be sure that there are no major energy implications for California before we contemplate the greater policy decision of moving to PST."
Arguments in Support
The American Academy of Sleep Medicine writes, "The long, dark mornings caused by permanent daylight saving time would make it difficult to wake and commute to school and work during the winter. The safety of children waiting at the bus stop, walking, or driving to school would be jeopardized in the darkness… permanent standard time is the most efficient way to eliminate the twice-yearly change, while protecting public health and safety."
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, this bill would incur costs amounting to $600,000 (Energy Resources Program Account (ERPA)) at the CEC to contract with an outside consultant to conduct the study required by this bill. However, according to the Legislative Analyst's Office, the ERPA is in a structural deficit, and the administration estimates that its balances will be exhausted by fiscal year 2027-28.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 33-1-6
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Rubio
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Archuleta, Blakespear, Newman, Nguyen, Seyarto
ASM UTILITIES AND ENERGY: 15-0-1
YES: Petrie-Norris, Bauer-Kahan, Calderon, Chen, Friedman, Hart, Holden, Joe Patterson, Reyes, Santiago, Schiavo, Ting, Wallis, Wood, Zbur
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jim Patterson
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-2
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Jim Patterson
UPDATED
VERSION: May 16, 2024
CONSULTANT: Kathleen Chen / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0004017
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1413
Author:(Niello) – As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Energy | Vote: | 15 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Energy Commission (CEC), upon appropriation, to prepare a report that assesses the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply, including the potential impacts of year-round standard time on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
The bill requires the CEC to submit the report to the Legislature by February 1, 2027.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The CEC will likely need to contract with an outside consultant to conduct the study required by this bill. The CEC estimates the costs of such a contract to be $600,000 (Energy Resources Program Account (ERPA)).
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the ERPA is in a structural deficit, with its ongoing revenues failing to keep pace with its increasing expenditures, and the administration estimates these balances will be exhausted by fiscal year 2027‑28.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose.
Permanent Standard Time Forever. The author describes this bill as part of an effort to “ditch the switch,” that is, to end Daylight Saving Time (DST). The author intends this bill to further that effort by ensuring there are no major energy implications for California before the state decides to move to permanent standard time (PST).
- Background.
Daylight Saving Time Forever, Maybe. In 1918, the United States established in law DST and created a standard time. That law defined standard time zones and set summer DST to begin on March 31, 1918. The nation observed DST for seven months in 1918 and 1919 but ceased to do so when congress repealed the DST law. Nonetheless, from February 9, 1942, to September 30, 1945, President Franklin Roosevelt instituted year-round DST, or “War Time.”
From 1945 to 1966, there was no federal law regarding DST, leaving it to states and localities to choose whether to observe DST and when. In the middle of the last century, California made just such a choice.
In 1949, California voters established DST in the state through the passage of Proposition 12. Known as The Daylight Savings Time Act, the proposition established standard time within California as the time which the federal government describes and designates as United States Standard Pacific Time. The initiative also required that the state advance time one hour during the period from the last Sunday in April until the last Sunday in September, in effect, creating a California DST. Later, in 1962, California voters approved an amendment to the act that extended California DST until the last Sunday in October. This extension conformed California DST to DSTs as practiced in the rest of the major states.
In 2018, voters passed Proposition 7, which repealed Proposition 12 and permitted the Legislature to change DST by a two-thirds vote and establish permanent year-round DST, pending federal authorization. To date, California has received no such federal authorization.
Energy Implication of PST Likely Minor. As the author notes, federal law allows California to institute PST. The likely effects of doing do on energy consumption and use patterns are likely minor.
The CEC has considered the effects of DST, as currently practiced in the state. Regarding energy usage, the CEC found the effects to be few. In 2007, the CEC released a study in response to the expansion of DST by the Energy Policy Act of 2005. This study, titled “The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis,” revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California, according to a statistical analysis. The most likely approximation is a 0.2 percent decrease during these three weeks.” The CEC’s findings are consistent with those of the U.S. Department of Energy (“Impact of Extended Daylight Saving Time on National Energy Consumption,” October 2008) and the National Bureau of Economic Research (“Does Daylight Saving Time Save Energy? Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Indiana,” October 2008.)
While none of these studies considered the energy implications of PST, presumably, such implications—or lack thereof—closely mirror those of switching to DST. However, the state’s energy resource mix has changed in recent years, and will continue to do so. More specifically, the state is now often reliant on solar energy resources that trail off as the sun begins to set. A study commissioned by CEC would help determine whether a switch to PST has an impact on energy resources that is as unremarkable as that of DST…or not.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Cottie Petrie-Norris, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1413
Author:(Niello) – As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 33-1
SUBJECT: Year-round standard time: State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission: report
SUMMARY: Requires the California Energy Commission (CEC) to, on or before February 1, 2027, and upon appropriation by the Legislature, prepare and submit a report to the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the CEC to, on or before February 1, 2027, prepare and submit a report to the relevant policy committees of the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
- Requires the report to include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
- Makes the operation of its provisions contingent upon an appropriation by the Legislature for its purpose.
- Repeals the section on February 1, 2029.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes, under federal law, the standard time of the United States for each of nine zones and advances for the standard time of each zone by one hour during the period commencing at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and ending at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Establishes the standard time within California as that of the fifth zone designated by federal law as Pacific Standard Time (PST). Prohibits a state from setting its standard time to year-round daylight saving time (DST) without the approval of the federal government. (15 U.S. Code § 261-263)
- Mandates that standard time within the state shall advance by one hour during the DST period commencing at 2 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and ending at 2 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Authorizes the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote, to change the dates and times of the DST period, consistent with federal law, and if federal law authorizes the state to provide for the year-round application of DST. (Government Code § 6808)
- Requires the CEC to continuously carry out studies, research projects, data collection, and other activities required to assess the nature, extent, and distribution of energy resources to meet the needs of the state. (Public Resources Code § 25401)
- Requires the CEC and the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), on or before December 15, 2022, and quarterly thereafter, to submit to the Legislature a joint Reliability Planning Assessment that, among other things, includes prospective information on existing and expected resources, including updates on the interconnection status for renewable projects and any delays in interconnection, and expected retirements for both system and local resources. Requires the CEC to continue to report on California energy resources that serve load in California in the energy almanac. (Public Resources Code § 25233)
- Requires the CEC, on a biennial basis, to adopt an integrated energy policy report (IEPR) containing an overview of major trends and issues facing the state. Requires the report to include an assessment and forecast of system reliability and the need for resource additions, efficiency, and conservation that considers all aspects of energy industries and markets that are essential for the state economy, general welfare, public health and safety, energy diversity, and protection of the environment. (Public Resources Code § 25302)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, this bill would incur unknown one-time costs, likely in the low to mid hundreds of thousands of dollars (General Fund, Energy Resources Program Account, or other special fund), for the CEC to complete the proposed assessment. Senate Appropriations Committee amendments delayed the report deadline, which could reduce costs.
BACKGROUND:
Standard Time vs. Daylight Saving Time – In California, DST is observed during the time of year when clocks “spring forward,” between the second Sunday of March and first Sunday of November, consistent with federal law. PST in California is observed during the time of year when clocks “fall back,” between the first Sunday of November and second Sunday of March. DST is often referred to as “summer time” and PST is often referred to as “winter time.”
History of DST in the U.S. – DST has been used in the United States since World War I (WWI). On April 30, 1916, in an effort to conserve fuel needed to produce electric power, Germany and Austria advanced the hands of the clock one hour until the following October. Many other nations – mostly in Europe – followed suit. Two years later, the U.S. formally established DST in law and created a standard time, including defining standard time zones. The nation observed DST for seven months in 1918 and 1919, but the law proved so unpopular in the U.S. that it was repealed after WWI ended with a Congressional override of President Wilson’s veto. DST became a local option and was continued in only a few states and cities. During World War II, President Franklin Roosevelt re-instituted year-round DST, called “War Time,” from February 9, 1942 to September 30, 1945.
From 1945 to 1966, there was no federal law regarding DST, so states and localities were free to choose whether or not to observe DST and could choose when it began and ended. This understandably caused confusion, especially for the broadcasting industry, as well as for railways, airlines, and bus companies. Because of the different local customs and laws, radio stations, TV stations, and transportation companies had to publish new schedules every time a state or town began or ended DST. In response, Congress passed the Uniform Time Act of 1966 (15 U.S. Code Section 260a), which established DST to begin on the last Sunday of April and end on the last Sunday of October. Any state that wanted to be exempt from DST could do so by passing a state law – only Arizona and Hawaii have done so. Federal law does not, however, give states the option to observe DST year-round.
Proposition 12 (1949) and Proposition 7 (2018) – California was one of the states that adopted DST at a time when there were no federal laws on the subject. In 1949, voters adopted Proposition 12, known as The Daylight Saving Time Act, which established standard time within California as the time which the federal government describes and designates as U.S. PST. The initiative required that the state advance time one hour during the period from the last Sunday in April until the last Sunday in September. It also prohibited the Legislature from making changes to the initiative measure unless those changes were submitted to the voters for their approval. Later, in 1962, California voters approved an amendment to the act that extended California DST until the last Sunday in October; this change conformed California DST to DSTs as practiced in the rest of the major states.
In an effort to save energy, Congress passed The Energy Policy Act in 2005 (EPAct 2005) to extend DST in the U.S. by three weeks in the spring and one week in the fall starting in 2007. This change created a conflict between California’s DST law and the federal DST law. However, since federal law provides states only two options, which are to either observe standard time year-round or observe DST on federally mandated dates, California has observed the dates consistent with the adjusted federal dates.
More recently, in 2018, voters passed Proposition 7, which repealed Proposition 12 and permitted the Legislature to change DST by a two-thirds vote and establish permanent year-round DST, pending federal authorization.
DST and energy savings – Claims of energy savings underlie observance of DST during the spring and summer. The argument is simple: by springing the clock forward when there is more sunlight we can take advantage of natural light and use less energy or fuel. Yet, there is no clear evidence that DST results in energy savings, and some evidence suggests the contrary. In a 2008 report on the impacts of extended DST as enacted by EPAct 2005, the U.S. Department of Energy found that the total electricity savings in 2007 were about 0.03% of electricity consumption over the year.[1]
In 2007, the CEC released a study in response to the expansion of DST, providing a more detailed view into its impacts in California, specifically.[2] Using data from the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) to compare daily total electricity use in the early DST weeks of March 2007 to usage in comparable days of preceding years, the study revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California... The most likely approximation is a 0.2% decrease during these three weeks.” The findings of the study in relation to energy savings of the changes to DST were largely inconclusive, as the 95% confidence interval could result in a range of 1.5% energy savings to 1.4% greater energy consumption.
Another 2008 study by the National Bureau of Economic Research sought to provide empirical estimates of DST effects on electricity consumption in the U.S. by focusing on residential electricity demand from as far back as the mid-1970s.[3] The bureau’s main finding was that contrary to the intent of the policy, DST increases residential electricity demand by approximately one percent. The study estimated that DST increased the cost of electricity to Indiana households by about $9 million a year, or $3.29 per household. The authors hypothesized that DST may have yielded savings to energy consumers decades ago when a larger share of energy consumption went toward lighting homes; however, advances in lighting technology have made lighting costs negligible next to the expense of heating and cooling. The study acknowledges that the impact is likely to vary by region, with regions where demand for heating and cooling is greater experiencing a higher increase in electricity use.
Sounding the alarm – In recent years, California has experienced significant challenges ensuring electricity reliability during extreme weather events when demand peaks and generation has been reduced or constrained. In the August 2020 heat wave, electric generation and transmission capacity strained to keep up with the increased electricity demand – this event set a peak demand record of 162,017 megawatts (MW) in the Western Interconnection on August 18, 2020.[4] For the first time in nearly 20 years within the CAISO territory, utilities were forced to shed load – via rotating outages – to help balance the electrical grid. The following year, in the midst of a heat wave, a wildfire in Oregon compromised an electric transmission line, dramatically reducing a critical source of energy imports for the state. As a result, the Governor signed an emergency proclamation that suspended certain permitting requirements and allowed for the use of back-up power generation to alleviate demands on the state’s energy grid. In 2022, a 10-day heat wave resulted in the CAISO setting an all-time record for electricity demand of over 52,000 MW on September 6.[5] The combination of an increased demand and variability with a constrained electricity supply resulted in the state issuing its first ever wireless emergency alert calling on Californians to conserve energy.
Taking lessons from these recent heat waves, the CPUC has created new programs and modified existing programs to reduce energy demand and increase energy supply during critical hours of the day and is working alongside the CEC, CAISO, and the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to carefully and cohesively plan for future electricity needs. However, the frequency, intensity, and length of heat waves are expected to increase in the future across the state,[6] which may continue to challenge the resiliency and reliability of California’s electrical grid.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, “SB 1413 is a bipartisan, multistate effort to “ditch the switch” and end Daylight Saving Time (DST). There have been federal efforts to establish permanent DST but those have failed (Congressional action is needed for permanent DST). There is no act of Congress or federal permission needed to be successful in switching, however, to Permanent Standard Time (PST). This measure is a simple study bill to be sure that there are no major energy implications for California before we contemplate the greater policy decision of moving to PST.”
- Are we talking about energy? Within the Legislature, many attempts have been made to do away with the biannual changing of the clocks, with some efforts advocating for year-long standard time and others championing for year-long DST. States remain prohibited from establishing year-long DST without federal authorization; as such, year-long PST may be more achievable within the confines of California’s authority. The data regarding energy savings potentially granted by either of these measures, however, are more than 10 years old and inconclusive. Contemporary arguments for permanent standard time (and permanent DST) are not related to energy and instead center on health and safety considerations. The main benefits cited by the author and supporters are the avoidance of public health impacts associated with switching the time by an hour twice a year, including increased heart attacks and strokes, traffic accidents, and workplace injuries as residents adjust to the time differences.
- We might be talking about energy. Since the 2007 CEC study, California has increased its use of intermittent renewable resources, particularly solar energy which can only be harnessed when the sun is shining. In recent years, the CAISO has experienced challenges maintaining electric grid reliability in the evening hours of the late summer when solar generation plummets. These challenges were worsened by the increasing number of retired resources across the western U.S. and the drop in hydroelectric power generation due to prolonged drought in the state. As a result, the state has invested billions from the general fund and utility ratepayers to help shore up resources. It is unclear whether a move to permanent PST might exacerbate the conditions that have challenged summer reliability since the sun would set earlier on these days as a result of this change. This bill would require the CEC, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to assess the implications of moving to year-long PST on energy reliability. The bill analysis by the Senate Committee on Appropriations recognizes that the CEC may seek contract support to complete the proposed assessment. The author has indicated that their intention is to contract out this assessment to a University of California entity with relevant expertise in energy.
- Related legislation.
AB 1776 (Ta) would have repealed DST in the state and the Legislature’s authority to amend Proposition 7 by a two-thirds vote and would have required California to observe year-round PST. Status: Held in Assembly Committee on Governmental Organization.
- Prior legislation.
AB 2868 (Choi, 2022) would have established year-round DST effective immediately once the federal government authorizes such a change. Status: Failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
AJR 33 (Chu, 2020) would have urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow a state to adopt DST year-round. Status: Never heard. Died at the Assembly Desk.
AB 7 (Chu, 2019) would have established year-round DST effectively immediately once the federal government authorized such a change. Status: Died – held in Senate Committee on Energy, Utilities, and Communications.
Proposition 7 (2018) made numerous changes to the state’s statute concerning DST, including: conform the dates of DST observance with those in the federal statute; authorize the state, by a two-thirds vote of the Legislature, to adopt a year-round DST if allowed by the federal government; and repeal numerous sections of the 1949 California DST Act.
AB 807 (Chu) directed the Secretary of State to place an initiative on the ballot to allow voters to decide whether to authorize the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote of the members, to make changes to the state’s observance of DST consistent with and to the extent authorized by federal law. Status: Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018.
AB 385 (Chu, 2016) would have repealed the DST Act and authorized the Legislature by majority vote to amend the law for the application of permanent (year-round) DST. Status: Failed passage on the Senate Floor.
AB 2496 (Chu, 2016) would have declared it the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to establish PST as the standard time within the state during the entire year. Status: Never heard. Died at the Assembly Desk.
AJR 28 (Obernolte) urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow states to adopt permanent (year-round) DST. Status: Chapter 167, Statutes of 2016.
SJRX2 1 (Karnette) memorialized Congress to approve legislation that allows a state to uniformly apply DST year-round. Status: Chapter 1, Statutes of 2001.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Academy of Sleep Medicine |
California Medical Association |
California Sleep Society |
Coalition for Permanent Standard Time |
National Sleep Foundation |
Northwest Noggin Neuroscience |
Save Standard Time (501c4 Nonprofit) |
Sleep Research Society |
Opposition
None on file.
Other
California Alliance for Golf
Analysis Prepared by: Kathleen Chen / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083
DOE; Impact of Extended Daylight Saving Time on National Energy Consumption, Report to Congress; October 2008. ↑
CEC; The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis; May 2007. ↑
Grant, Laura and Kotchen, Matthew; “Does Daylight Saving Time Save Energy? A Natural Experiment in Indiana”; National Bureau of Economic Research; October 2008. ↑
Western Electricity Coordinating Council; “August 2020 Heatwave Event Analysis Report”; March 2021. ↑
CAISO; “California ISO posts analysis of September heat wave”; November 2022. ↑
Southwest Climate Science Center; “California Heat Waves”; July 2015. ↑
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1413 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1413
Author: Niello (R), et al.
Amended: 5/16/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 13-0, 4/16/24
AYES: Bradford, Dahle, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Gonzalez, Grove, Limón, Min, Newman, Seyarto, Skinner, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Rubio, Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SUBJECT: Year-round standard time: State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission: report
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission (known as the California Energy Commission (CEC)) to, on or before February 1, 2027, prepare and submit a report to the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply. This bill would make the operation of its provisions contingent upon an appropriation by the Legislature for its purpose.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes, under federal law, the standard time of the United States for each of nine zones and advances the standard time of each zone by one hour during the period commencing at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and ending at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Establishes the standard time within California is that of the fifth zone designated by federal law as Pacific Standard Time (PST). Prohibits a state from setting its standard time to year-round daylight saving time (DST). (15 U.S. Code §260 et seq.)
- Establishes, via Proposition 7, an initiative measure approved by the voters at the November 6, 2018, statewide general election, the standard time for California, consistent with federal law, is PST, and sets DST to begin at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and end at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Authorizes the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote, to change the dates and times of the DST period, consistent with federal law, and if federal law authorizes the state to provide for the year-round application of DST. (Government Code §6808)
- Requires the CEC to continuously carry out studies, research projects, data collection, and other activities required to assess the nature, extent, and distribution of energy resources to meet the needs of the state. (Public Resources Code §25401)
- Requires the CEC and California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), on or before December 15, 2022, and quarterly thereafter, to submit to the Legislature a joint Reliability Planning Assessment that, among other things, includes prospective information on existing and expected resources, including updates on the interconnection status for renewable projects and any delays in interconnection, and expected retirements for both system and local resources. Requires the CEC to report in the energy almanac on California energy resources that serve load in California. (Public Resources Code §25233)
- Requires the CEC, on a biennial basis, to adopt an integrated energy policy report (IEPR) containing an overview of major trends and issues facing the state. Requires the report to include an assessment and forecast of system reliability and the need for resource additions, efficiency, and conservation that considers all aspects of energy industries and markets that are essential for the state economy, general welfare, public health and safety, energy diversity, and protection of the environment. Requires the report to include an assessment and forecast of system reliability and the need for resource additions, efficiency, and conservation that considers all aspects of energy industries and markets that are essential for the state economy, general welfare, public health and safety, energy diversity, and protection of the environment. (Public Resources Code §25302)
This bill:
- Requires the CEC to, on or before February 1, 2027, prepare and submit a report to the Legislature assessing the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
- Requires the report to include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts of year-round standard time on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
- Makes the operation of its provisions contingent upon an appropriation by the Legislature for its purpose.
- Repeals the section on February 1, 2029.
Background
- Daylight savings time v. standard time. DST is often referred to as “summer time” and standard time is often referred to as “winter time.” In California, DST, summer time, is observed during the time of year when clocks “spring forward,” between the second Sunday of March and first Sunday of November, consistent with federal law. Standard time, or winter time, in California is observed during the time of year when clocks “fall back,” between the first Sunday of November and second Sunday of March.
- History of DST. The first modern DST was established during WWI as an effort to save energy and conserve fuel. In April of 1916, Germany and Austria advanced the hands of their clocks one hour and kept them that way until the following October. Many other nations – mostly in Europe – followed suit. Two years later, the United States also established in law DST and created a standard time, including defining standard time zones, and setting summer DST to begin March 31, 1918. The nation observed DST for seven months in 1918 and 1919 but ceased to do so when Congress repealed the DST law. From February 9, 1942, to September 30, 1945, President Franklin Roosevelt instituted year-round DST, or “War Time.” From 1945 to 1966, there was no federal law regarding DST, leaving it to states and localities to choose whether and when to observe DST.
- California Daylight Saving Time Act. California voters, in 1949, established The California Daylight Saving Time Act through the passage of Proposition 12. The proposition established standard time within California as the time which the federal government describes and designates as United States PST. The initiative also required that the state advance time one hour during the period from the last Sunday in April until the last Sunday in October. In the mid-1960s, Congress enacted The Uniform Act of 1966 to establish a uniform standard DST within each time zone. The act set DST to begin on the last Sunday of April and to end on the last Sunday of October. This act exempted any state from observing DST if the state passed a law that results in year-round observance of standard time. Two states—Arizona and Hawaii—have done so. Federal law does not, however, give states the option to observe DST year-round. In an effort to save energy, Congress passed The Energy Policy Act in 2005 to extend DST in the U.S. by three weeks in the spring and one week in the fall. This change created a conflict between California’s DST law and the federal law on DST. However, since federal law provides states only two options: 1) observe standard time throughout the year, or 2) observe DST on federally mandated dates, California has observed the dates consistent with the adjusted federal dates.
- California passes Proposition 7 in 2018. In 2018, AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) placed a ballot measure before voters to make changes to the state’s observance of DST. Specifically, Proposition 7 (November 2018) which passed by 59.75 percent - 40.25 percent margin, allows the Legislature by two-thirds vote to make future changes to California’s DST period, including applying year-round application of DST, if changes are consistent with federal law. Proposition 7 also conformed California DST to current federal law. To enact Proposition 7 the measure also repealed Proposition 12 of 1949, a ballot initiative that established DST in California.
- Energy savings? Claims of energy savings underlie observance of DST during the spring and summer. The argument is simple: by springing the clock forward during the summer when there is more sunlight we can take advantage of natural light and use less energy or fuel. Yet, there is no clear evidence that DST results in energy saving and some evidence suggests the contrary. In 2008, the National Bureau of Economic Research released a study on the effectiveness of DST. The study sought to provide the first empirical estimates of DST effects on electricity consumption in the United States by focusing on residential electricity demand as far back as the mid-1970s. The bureau’s main finding was that, contrary to the intent of the policy, DST increases residential electricity demand by approximately one percent. According to the study, during DST, there is a tradeoff between the demand for electricity and the demand for heating and cooling. That is, as the demand for electricity is reduced, the demand for heating and cooling is increased. These findings estimate that DST increased cost of electricity to Indiana households by about $9 million per year. The study further speculates that this impact is likely to vary by region, with regions where demand for heating and cooling is greater experiencing a higher increase in electricity use. [Grant, Laura and Kotchen, Matthew. “Does Daylight Saving Time Save Energy? Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Indiana.” October 2008. [http://www.nber.org/papers/ w14429.pdf]
- CEC studies impacts of expanded DST. In 2007, the CEC released a study in response to the expansion of DST by the Energy Policy Act of 2005. This study, titled “The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis,” revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California, according to a statistical analysis. The most likely approximation is a 0.2 percent decrease during these three weeks.” [California Energy Commission. The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California. May 2007. http://www.energy.ca.gov/2007publications/CEC-200-2007-004/CEC-200-2007-004.PDF] The findings of the study in relation to energy savings of the changes to DST were largely inconclusive as the 95 percent confidence interval could result in a range of 1.5 percent energy savings to 1.4 percent increase in energy consumption.
- Recent challenges with electricity reliability. In recent years, California has experienced challenges ensuring adequate electricity supply reliability during extreme heat events when demand peaks and generation has been reduced or constrained. In August 2020, electric generation and transmission capacity was strained to keep up with the increased electricity demand – setting a peak demand record in the Western Interconnection of just over 162,000 megawatts (MW) on August 18, 2020. During this heat wave, many balancing authorities were forced to declare energy emergencies as they were unable to meet their load obligations, including the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) and five balancing authorities outside California. Within the CAISO, for the first time in about 20 years, utilities were forced to shed load – via rotating outages – to help balance the electrical grid. The outages ranged from eight minutes to 2.5 hour durations, depending on the utility, while affected customers experienced between eight minutes to 20 minute outages, generally. The following year, in the midst of a heat wave, a wildfire in Oregon compromised an electric transmission line, dramatically reducing a critical source of energy imports for the state. In 2022, a 10-day heat wave resulted in the CAISO setting an all-time record for electricity demand of over 52,000 MW on September 6th. The combination of increased demand and variability and constrained electricity supply, resulted in the state for the first-time issuing a wireless emergency alert calling on Californians to conserve energy.
- CEC and CPUC joint Reliability Planning Assessment. As part of SB 846 (Dodd, Chapter 239, Statutes of 2022) authorized the extension of the Diablo Canyon Power Plant (DCPP)—which was scheduled to retire by 2025—through 2030. SB 846 also included legislative intent to provide a total of $1 billion from the General Fund from 2023-24 through 2025-26—$100 million in 2023-24, $400 million in 2024-25, and $500 million in 2025-26—to support the Clean Energy Reliability Investment Plan. Adjustments to these amounts and dates are subject to annual state budget decisions. The legislation required the plan to support investments that address near- and mid-term reliability needs and the state’s greenhouse gas (GHG) and clean energy goals. The plan adopted by the CEC incorporates a combination of planning and enabling structures to support clean energy deployment and augmenting for extreme events for the first year $100 million funding. Additionally, the legislation requires the CEC and CPUC to quarterly publish a reliability planning assessment to include estimates of supply and demand for the next 10 years under different risk scenarios, information on existing and new resources and delays, and a description of barriers to timely deployment of resources. The agencies have issued their third quarterly report since the passage of SB 846.
- Integrated Energy Policy Report (IEPR). The IEPR provides a cohesive approach to identifying and solving the state’s pressing energy needs and issues. The report, which is crafted in collaboration with a range of stakeholders, develops and implements energy plans and policies. SB 1389 (Bowen, Chapter 568, Statutes of 2002) required the CEC to conduct assessments and forecasts of all 10 aspects of energy industry supply, production, transportation, delivery and distribution, demand, and prices. The CEC is then required to use these assessments and forecasts to “develop energy policies that conserve resources, protect the environment, ensure energy reliability, enhance the state's economy, and protect public health and safety.” The CEC adopts an IEPR every two years and an update every other year.
Comments
- Bill requires assessment of year-round standard time on energy reliability. Many seek to do away with the biannual changing of the clocks, and establish year-long standard time, with some also advocating for year-long DST. In support of year-long standard time, the author and supporters, cite various studies as to the benefits of having year-round standard time. The main benefits cited are the avoidance of public health impacts associated with switching the time by an hour twice a year, including increased heart attacks and strokes, traffic accidents, and workplace injuries as residents adjust to the time differences.
- Changing electricity generation sources. Since the 2007 CEC study, the state has increased its use of intermittent renewable resources, particularly solar generation which can only be used during the time the sun is shining. It is unclear how changes to DST could affect demand of energy resources and the particular effects on the electrical grid when solar generation is increasingly relied upon. In recent years, the state’s largest electrical grid operator, the CAISO has experienced challenges maintaining electric grid reliability in the evening hours of the late summer when solar generation has plummeted and hydroelectric resources have been reduced. As a result, the state has invested billions from the general fund and utility ratepayers to help shore up resources. It is unclear whether a move to permanent standard time might exacerbate these conditions, as the sun would set earlier on these days. This bill would require the CEC, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to assess the implications on energy reliability of moving to year-long standard time.
Related/Prior Legislation
AJR 33 (Chu, 2020) would have urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow a state to adopt DST year-round. The measure was never heard.
AB 7 (Chu, 2018) would have established year-round DST (otherwise understood as summer time) effective immediately once the federal government authorizes such a change. The bill was held in this committee.
Proposition 7 (2018) made numerous changes to the state’s statute concerning DST, including: conform the dates of DST observance with those in the federal statute; authorizes the state, by a two-thirds votes of the Legislature, to adopt a year-round DST if allowed by the federal government; and repealed numerous sections of the 1949 California DST Act.
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) directed the Secretary of State to place an initiative on the ballot to allow voters to decide whether to authorize the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote of the members, to make changes to the state’s observance of DST consistent with, and to the extent authorized by, federal law.
AB 385 (Chu, 2016) would have repealed the DST Act and authorized the Legislature by majority vote to amend the law for the application of permanent (year-round) DST, if authorized by federal law. The bill failed passage on the Senate Floor.
AB 2496 (Chu, 2016) would have declared the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to establish United States Standard Pacific Time as the standard time within the state during the entire year. The bill died at the Assembly Desk.
AJR 28 (Obernolte, Chapter 167, Statutes of 2016) urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow states to adopt permanent (year-round) DST.
SJRX2 1 (Karnette, Chapter 1, Statutes of 2001) memorialized Congress to approve legislation that allows a state to uniformly apply DST year-round.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, unknown one-time costs, likely in the low to mid hundreds of thousands of dollars (General Fund), for the CEC to complete the proposed assessment. Committee amendments delay the report deadline, which could reduce costs.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/15/24)
American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine
American Academy of Sleep Medicine
California Medical Association
California Sleep Society
Coalition for Permanent Standard Time
National Sleep Foundation
Northwest Noggin Neuroscience
Save Standard Time
Sleep Research Society
Society for Research on Biological Rhythms
10 Individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/15/24)
California Alliance for Golf
4 Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the National Sleep Foundation argues that “the human circadian system does not adjust to annual clock changes… The link between our biological clock and the sun clock has been crucial to human health and well-being for millennia.” NSF advocates “for the adoption of permanent standard time as the appropriate option for public health.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As this bill was amended in the Senate Committee on Appropriations to remove the provisions that required a permanent move to year-long standard time, it is unclear whether the opposition remains opposed to the current provisions of the bill which only require an energy assessment of such a change.
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U. & C. / (916) 651-4107
5/18/24 14:05:19
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1413 (Niello) - Year-round standard time
Version: April 22, 2024 | Policy Vote: E., U. & C. 13 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2024 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would repeal daylight savings time (DST) in California and adopt year-round standard time, and would also require the California Energy Commission (CEC) to report on the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2024
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown one-time costs, likely in the low to mid hundreds of thousands of dollars (General Fund, Energy Resources Program Account, or other special fund), for the CEC to complete the proposed assessment. Committee amendments would delay the report deadline, which could reduce costs.
Committee Amendments:
Committee amendments would narrow the scope of the bill to just the CEC study, make it contingent upon an appropriation, and delay the dates for the report and sunset. Specifically, they would:
- Strike the provisions that would repeal DST.
- Make the CEC report contingent upon an appropriation.
- Require the CEC to submit the required report on or before February 1, 2027.
- Sunset the bill’s provisions on February 1, 2029.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1413 (Niello) - Year-round standard time
Version: April 22, 2024 | Policy Vote: E., U. & C. 13 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2024 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would repeal daylight savings time (DST) in California and adopt year-round standard time, and would also require the California Energy Commission (CEC) to report on the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
Fiscal Impact:
- The CEC estimates one-time costs of about $600,000 (General Fund, Energy Resources Program Account [ERPA], or other special fund) for contract support to complete the proposed assessment.
Background:
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) placed a ballot measure before voters to make changes to the state’s observance of DST. Specifically, Proposition 7 (November 2018) which passed by 59.75 percent - 40.25 percent margin, allows the Legislature by two-thirds vote to make future changes to California’s DST period, including applying year-round application of DST, if changes are consistent with federal law. Proposition 7 also conformed California DST to current federal law. To enact Proposition 7 the measure also repealed Proposition 12 of 1949, a ballot initiative that established DST in California.
Claims of energy savings underlie observance of DST during the spring and summer. The argument is simple: by springing the clock forward during the summer when there is more sunlight we can take advantage of natural light and use less energy or fuel. Yet, there is no clear evidence that DST results in energy saving and some evidence suggests the contrary. In 2008, the National Bureau of Economic Research released a study on the effectiveness of DST. The study sought to provide the first empirical estimates of DST effects on electricity consumption in the United States by focusing on residential electricity demand as far back as the mid-1970s. The bureau’s main finding was that, contrary to the intent of the policy, DST increases residential electricity demand by approximately one percent. According to the study, during DST, there is a tradeoff between the demand for electricity and the demand for heating and cooling. That is, as the demand for electricity is reduced, the demand for heating and cooling is increased. These findings estimate that DST increased cost of electricity to Indiana households by about $9 million per year. The study further speculates that this impact is likely to vary by region, with regions where demand for heating and cooling is greater experiencing a higher increase in electricity use.1
In 2007, the California Energy Commission (CEC) released a study in response to the expansion of DST by the Energy Policy Act of 2005. This study, titled “The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis,” revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California, according to a statistical analysis. The most likely approximation is a 0.2 percent decrease during these three weeks.”2 The findings of the study in relation to energy savings of the changes to DST were largely inconclusive as the 95 percent confidence interval could result in a range of 1.5 percent energy savings to 1.4 percent increase in energy consumption.
Proposed Law:
This bill would repeal daylight savings time in California and adopt year-round standard time, and would require the CEC to report on the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply. It would specify that the report shall include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts of year-round standard time on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
Related Legislation:
AJR 33 (Chu, 2020) was a measure to urge Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow a state to adopt DST year-round. The measure was never heard.
AB 7 (Chu, 2018) was an urgency measure that would have established year-round DST (otherwise understood as summer time) effective immediately once the federal government authorizes such a change. The bill was held in policy committee.
Proposition 7 (2018) made numerous changes to the state’s statute concerning DST, including: conform the dates of DST observance with those in the federal statute; authorizes the state, by a two-thirds votes of the Legislature, to adopt a year-round DST if allowed by the federal government; and repealed numerous sections of the 1949 California DST Act.
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) directed the Secretary of State to place an initiative on the ballot to allow voters to decide whether to authorize the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote of the members, to make changes to the state’s observance of DST consistent with, and to the extent authorized by, federal law.
AB 385 (Chu, 2016) would have repealed the DST Act and authorized the Legislature by majority vote to amend the law for the application of permanent (year-round) DST, if authorized by federal law. The bill failed passage on the Senate Floor.
AB 2496 (Chu, 2016) would have declared the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to establish United States Standard Pacific Time as the standard time within the state during the entire year. The bill died at the Assembly Desk.
AJR 28 (Obernolte, Chapter 167, Statutes of 2016) urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow states to adopt permanent (year-round) DST.
SJRX2 1 (Karnette, Chapter 1, Statutes of 2001) memorialized Congress to approve legislation that allows a state to uniformly apply DST year-round.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1413 (Niello) - Year-round standard time
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would repeal daylight savings time (DST) in California and adopt year-round standard time, and would also require the California Energy Commission (CEC) to report on the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2024
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown one-time costs, likely in the low to mid hundreds of thousands of dollars (General Fund), for the CEC to complete the proposed assessment. Committee amendments delay the report deadline, which could reduce costs.
Committee Amendments:
Committee amendments would narrow the scope of the bill to just the CEC study, make it contingent upon an appropriation, and delay the dates for the report and sunset. Specifically, they would:
- Strike the provisions that would repeal DST.
- Make the CEC report contingent upon an appropriation.
- Require the CEC to submit the required report on or before February 1, 2027.
- Sunset the bill’s provisions on February 1, 2029.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 4/16/2024
Author: | |||
Version: | Introduced | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill repeals daylight savings time in California, and adopts year-round standard time.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes, under federal law, the standard time of the United States for each of nine zones and advances the standard time of each zone by one hour during the period commencing at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and ending at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Establishes the standard time within California is that of the fifth zone designated by federal law as Pacific Standard Time (PST). Prohibits a state from setting its standard time to year-round daylight saving time (DST). (15 U.S. Code §260 et seq.)
- Establishes the standard time for California, consistent with federal law, is PST, and sets DST to begin at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and end at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Authorizes the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote, to change the dates and times of the DST period, consistent with federal law, and if federal law authorizes the state to provide for the year-round application of DST. (Government Code §6808)
This bill:
- Repeals DST in the state and the provisions regarding the Legislature’s authority to amend observance of DST provisions by a two-thirds vote.
- Requires the state and all political subdivisions of the state to observe year-round standard time.
- Exempts the state and all political subdivisions of the state from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time.
Background
Daylight savings time v. standard time. DST is often referred to as “summer time” and standard time is often referred to as “winter time.” In California, DST, summer time, is observed during the time of year when clocks “spring forward,” between the second Sunday of March and first Sunday of November, consistent with federal law. Standard time, or winter time, in California is observed during the time of year when clocks “fall back,” between the first Sunday of November and second Sunday of March.
History of DST. The first modern DST was established during WWI as an effort to save energy and conserve fuel. In April of 1916, at 11:00 p.m., Germany and Austria advanced the hands of their clocks one hour and kept them that way until the following October. Many other nations—mostly in Europe, but including Tasmania and some Canadian provinces as well—followed suit. Two years later, the United States, too, established in law DST and created a standard time. That law defined standard time zones and set summer DST to begin on March 31, 1918. The nation observed DST for seven months in 1918 and 1919 but ceased to do so when congress repealed the DST law. Nonetheless, from February 9, 1942, to September 30, 1945, President Franklin Roosevelt instituted year-round DST, or “War Time.” From 1945 to 1966, there was no federal law regarding DST, leaving it to states and localities to choose whether and when to observe DST.
California Daylight Saving Time Act. California voters, in 1949, established The California Daylight Saving Time Act through the passage of Proposition 12. The proposition established standard time within California as the time which the federal government describes and designates as United States PST. The initiative also required that the state advance time one hour during the period from the last Sunday in April until the last Sunday in October. In the mid-1960s, Congress enacted The Uniform Act of 1966 to establish a uniform standard DST within each time zone. The act set DST to begin on the last Sunday of April and to end on the last Sunday of October. This act exempted any state from observing DST if the state passed a law that results in year-round observance of standard time. Two states—Arizona and Hawaii—have done so. Federal law does not, however, give states the option to observe DST year-round. In an effort to save energy, Congress passed The Energy Policy Act in 2005 to extend DST in the U.S. by three weeks in the spring and one week in the fall. This change created a conflict between California’s DST law and the federal law on DST. However, since federal law provides states only two options: 1) observe standard time throughout the year, or 2) observe DST on federally mandated dates, California has observed the dates consistent with the adjusted federal dates.
California passes Proposition 7 in 2018. In 2018, AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) placed a ballot measure before voters to make changes to the state’s observance of DST. Specifically, Proposition 7 (November 2018) which passed by 59.75 percent - 40.25 percent margin, allows the Legislature by two-thirds vote to make future changes to California’s DST period, including applying year-round application of DST, if changes are consistent with federal law. Proposition 7 also conformed California DST to current federal law. To enact Proposition 7 the measure also repealed Proposition 12 of 1949, a ballot initiative that established DST in California.
Energy savings? Claims of energy savings underlie observance of DST during the spring and summer. The argument is simple: by springing the clock forward during the summer when there is more sunlight we can take advantage of natural light and use less energy or fuel. Yet, there is no clear evidence that DST results in energy saving and some evidence suggests the contrary. In 2008, the National Bureau of Economic Research released a study on the effectiveness of DST. The study sought to provide the first empirical estimates of DST effects on electricity consumption in the United States by focusing on residential electricity demand as far back as the mid-1970s. The bureau’s main finding was that, contrary to the intent of the policy, DST increases residential electricity demand by approximately one percent. According to the study, during DST, there is a tradeoff between the demand for electricity and the demand for heating and cooling. That is, as the demand for electricity is reduced, the demand for heating and cooling is increased. These findings estimate that DST increased cost of electricity to Indiana households by about $9 million per year. The study further speculates that this impact is likely to vary by region, with regions where demand for heating and cooling is greater experiencing a higher increase in electricity use.[1]
In 2007, the California Energy Commission (CEC) released a study in response to the expansion of DST by the Energy Policy Act of 2005. This study, titled “The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis,” revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California, according to a statistical analysis. The most likely approximation is a 0.2 percent decrease during these three weeks.”[2] The findings of the study in relation to energy savings of the changes to DST were largely inconclusive as the 95 percent confidence interval could result in a range of 1.5 percent energy savings to 1.4 percent increase in energy consumption.
Comments
Bill seeks year-round standard time. The author is seeking to do away with the biannual changing of the clocks, and establish year-long standard time. In support of this goal, the author and supporters, cite various studies as to the benefits of having year-round standard time. The main benefits cited are the avoidance of public health impacts associated with switching the time by an hour twice a year, including increased heart attacks and strokes, traffic accidents, and workplace injuries as residents adjust to the time differences.
Changing electricity generation sources. Since the 2007 CEC study, the state has increased its use of intermittent renewable resources, particularly solar generation which can only be used during the time the sun is shining. It is unclear how changes to DST could affect demand of energy resources and the particular effects on the electrical grid when solar generation is increasingly relied upon. In recent years, the state’s largest electrical grid operator, the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) has experienced challenges maintaining electric grid reliability in the evening hours of the late summer when solar generation has plummeted and hydroelectric resources have been reduced. As a result, the state has invested billions from the general fund and utility ratepayers to help shore up resources. It is unclear whether a move to permanent standard time might exacerbate these conditions, as the sun would set earlier on these days.
Legislature empowered? Act of Congress not needed to establish standard time. Existing federal law does not allow states to establish year-round DST, but does allow year-round standard time. A previous author abandoned a previous attempt to establish year-round standard time due to opposition against such a change, including concerns that standard time would limit daylight activities and other impacts. If the Legislature passes this measure by the required two-thirds and the Governor signs this bill into law, the bill would take effect on January 1, 2025. As such, the clocks would NOT spring forward on March 2025 in California and the state would remain on Pacific Standard Time.
What did voters support? Voters supported the passage of Proposition 7 in 2018. However, it seems a valid question as to whether voters supported doing away with the biannual clock changes or if they support permanent year-long DST or permanent year-long standard time. Lacking any more recent data and analysis, this bill would go into effect on January 2025 and immediately adopt year-long standard time. It is unclear whether the state is prepared for doing away with the time change and the full ramifications of this policy to a myriad of operations, including: schools, logistics industry, communications, transportation, and many others, as well as, the effects on individuals adjusting to the new sunrise and sunset hours during the summer time (DST). The reality for most individuals is they may not fully appreciate the changes being proposed until they are clearly explained and potentially experienced.
In 1974, as a response to the global energy crisis, the federal government under President Nixon attempted a year-long DST which, according to some news reports, was abandoned by the fall due to the political backlash, public outcry, and concerns about safety due to the later sunrises (and darker mornings as a result). It is unclear whether a change to yearlong standard time would engender a similar response.
Impacts to communities along the state’s borders. California shares borders with three states and the country of Mexico. The constant movement of people and goods across those borders requires coordination. The economies and societies of the border communities are interdependent. Currently, Arizona does not observe DST. Mexico recently did away with observing DST, however, the border areas maintain alignment with U.S. states. Changes to DST in California have the potential for considerable disruption. For example, when Congress passed the Energy Policy Act of 2005, which amended the dates of DST in the United States, it resulted in a time difference, for a period of a couple of weeks, between communities in the U.S. and communities in Mexico. This had a huge effect on border communities. In order to address this effect, the Congress of Mexico passed a law to allow border communities to adopt a DST pattern consistent with the United States. However, given Mexico has moved to year-long standard time, it is unclear whether a similar move by California would have a similar effect.
Caution! According to the Office of Legislative Counsel, SB 1413 may not be allowable as it may need to go before the voters before year-long standard time could be adopted. Legislative Counsel cautions that Section 2 of Article 2 of the California Constitution may require the voters to approve the change proposed in this bill. The Office of Legislative Counsel cautions that a change to yearlong standard time may not be consistent with the passage of Proposition 7 which authorized the Legislature to make changes to the dates of DST. The supporters of this bill contend that when AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) was being debated the authors expressed that the language would still allow the state to adopt year-long standard time. They suggest that this may strictly be an issue of divergent interpretations. Should this bill proceed, the author and members may wish to further assess whether to require the bill go before the voters, as suggested by the Office of Legislative Counsel.
Timing. The question for the Legislature is whether immediate action is necessary. It seems there may be some benefit to waiting and assessing implications of a year-long standard time before authorizing its change. The state could assess the implications and the interests of residents, communities, schools, businesses, neighboring states and others to coordinate and conform to a year-long standard time all with a more informed analysis. Such an analysis should also include more current consideration of changes to energy systems in the near-term and long-term of moving to yearlong standard time, as well as, the impacts during the different time of the year in different regions of the state, as the amount of daily sunrise/sunset is not static and changes depending on the time of year and location.
In this regard, the author and committee may wish to at a minimum amend this bill to require the CEC to develop and publish an assessment, by February 1 of next year, regarding the implications of moving to yearlong standard time with a focus on near-term and long-term energy reliability. By requiring this assessment by February 1, the assessment can inform whether the Legislature may need to act to prevent a permanent move to standard time.
Prior/Related Legislation
AJR 33 (Chu, 2020) was a measure to urge Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow a state to adopt DST year-round. The measure was never heard.
AB 7 (Chu, 2018) was an urgency measure that would have established year-round DST (otherwise understood as summer time) effective immediately once the federal government authorizes such a change. The bill was held in this committee.
Proposition 7 (2018) made numerous changes to the state’s statute concerning DST, including: conform the dates of DST observance with those in the federal statute; authorizes the state, by a two-thirds votes of the Legislature, to adopt a year-round DST if allowed by the federal government; and repealed numerous sections of the 1949 California DST Act.
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) directed the Secretary of State to place an initiative on the ballot to allow voters to decide whether to authorize the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote of the members, to make changes to the state’s observance of DST consistent with, and to the extent authorized by, federal law.
AB 385 (Chu, 2016) would have repealed the DST Act and authorized the Legislature by majority vote to amend the law for the application of permanent (year-round) DST, if authorized by federal law. The bill failed passage on the Senate Floor.
AB 2496 (Chu, 2016) would have declared the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to establish United States Standard Pacific Time as the standard time within the state during the entire year. The bill died at the Assembly Desk.
AJR 28 (Obernolte, Chapter 167, Statutes of 2016) urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow states to adopt permanent (year-round) DST.
SJRX2 1 (Karnette, Chapter 1, Statutes of 2001) memorialized Congress to approve legislation that allows a state to uniformly apply DST year-round.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT:
American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine
American Academy of Sleep Medicine
California Sleep Society
Coalition for Permanent Standard Time
National Sleep Foundation
Northwest Noggin Neuroscience
Save Standard Time
Sleep Research Society
Society for Research on Biological Rhythms
10 Individuals
OPPOSITION:
California Alliance for Golf
4 Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the National Sleep Foundation argues that “the human circadian system does not adjust to annual clock changes… The link between our biological clock and the sun clock has been crucial to human health and well-being for millennia.” NSF advocates “for the adoption of permanent standard time as the appropriate option for public health.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, the California Alliance for Golf contends that the golf community would suffer significant harm by a year-round standard time schedule. They argue that the loss of playable daylight hours in the afternoon/evenings would limit playing opportunities and reduce golf facility utilization, and reduce income for those who derive their livelihoods from the game and lessen recreational opportunities for those who play the game.
-- END --
Grant, Laura and Kotchen, Matthew. “Does Daylight Saving Time Save Energy? Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Indiana.” October 2008. http://www.nber.org/papers/ w14429.pdf ↑
California Energy Commission. The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California. May 2007.< http://www.energy.ca.gov/2007publications/CEC-200-2007-004/CEC-200-2007-004.PDF>. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1413 (Niello) - Year-round standard time
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would repeal daylight savings time (DST) in California and adopt year-round standard time, and would also require the California Energy Commission (CEC) to report on the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply.
Fiscal Impact:
- The CEC estimates one-time costs of about $600,000 (General Fund) for contract support to complete the proposed assessment.
Background:
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) placed a ballot measure before voters to make changes to the state’s observance of DST. Specifically, Proposition 7 (November 2018) which passed by 59.75 percent - 40.25 percent margin, allows the Legislature by two-thirds vote to make future changes to California’s DST period, including applying year-round application of DST, if changes are consistent with federal law. Proposition 7 also conformed California DST to current federal law. To enact Proposition 7 the measure also repealed Proposition 12 of 1949, a ballot initiative that established DST in California.
Claims of energy savings underlie observance of DST during the spring and summer. The argument is simple: by springing the clock forward during the summer when there is more sunlight we can take advantage of natural light and use less energy or fuel. Yet, there is no clear evidence that DST results in energy saving and some evidence suggests the contrary. In 2008, the National Bureau of Economic Research released a study on the effectiveness of DST. The study sought to provide the first empirical estimates of DST effects on electricity consumption in the United States by focusing on residential electricity demand as far back as the mid-1970s. The bureau’s main finding was that, contrary to the intent of the policy, DST increases residential electricity demand by approximately one percent. According to the study, during DST, there is a tradeoff between the demand for electricity and the demand for heating and cooling. That is, as the demand for electricity is reduced, the demand for heating and cooling is increased. These findings estimate that DST increased cost of electricity to Indiana households by about $9 million per year. The study further speculates that this impact is likely to vary by region, with regions where demand for heating and cooling is greater experiencing a higher increase in electricity use.1
In 2007, the California Energy Commission (CEC) released a study in response to the expansion of DST by the Energy Policy Act of 2005. This study, titled “The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis,” revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California, according to a statistical analysis. The most likely approximation is a 0.2 percent decrease during these three weeks.”2 The findings of the study in relation to energy savings of the changes to DST were largely inconclusive as the 95 percent confidence interval could result in a range of 1.5 percent energy savings to 1.4 percent increase in energy consumption.
Proposed Law:
This bill would repeal daylight savings time in California and adopt year-round standard time, and would require the CEC to report on the near-term and long-term impacts of observing year-round standard time on energy demand and supply. It would specify that the report shall include, but not be limited to, the potential impacts of year-round standard time on electricity reliability in the late summer and early fall.
Related Legislation:
AJR 33 (Chu, 2020) was a measure to urge Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow a state to adopt DST year-round. The measure was never heard.
AB 7 (Chu, 2018) was an urgency measure that would have established year-round DST (otherwise understood as summer time) effective immediately once the federal government authorizes such a change. The bill was held in policy committee.
Proposition 7 (2018) made numerous changes to the state’s statute concerning DST, including: conform the dates of DST observance with those in the federal statute; authorizes the state, by a two-thirds votes of the Legislature, to adopt a year-round DST if allowed by the federal government; and repealed numerous sections of the 1949 California DST Act.
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) directed the Secretary of State to place an initiative on the ballot to allow voters to decide whether to authorize the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote of the members, to make changes to the state’s observance of DST consistent with, and to the extent authorized by, federal law.
AB 385 (Chu, 2016) would have repealed the DST Act and authorized the Legislature by majority vote to amend the law for the application of permanent (year-round) DST, if authorized by federal law. The bill failed passage on the Senate Floor.
AB 2496 (Chu, 2016) would have declared the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to establish United States Standard Pacific Time as the standard time within the state during the entire year. The bill died at the Assembly Desk.
AJR 28 (Obernolte, Chapter 167, Statutes of 2016) urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow states to adopt permanent (year-round) DST.
SJRX2 1 (Karnette, Chapter 1, Statutes of 2001) memorialized Congress to approve legislation that allows a state to uniformly apply DST year-round.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1413 Hearing Date: 4/2/2024
Author: | Niello | ||
Version: | 2/16/2024 Introduced | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Year-round standard time
DIGEST: This bill repeals daylight savings time in California, and adopts year-round standard time.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes, under federal law, the standard time of the United States for each of nine zones and advances the standard time of each zone by one hour during the period commencing at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and ending at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Establishes the standard time within California is that of the fifth zone designated by federal law as Pacific Standard Time (PST). Prohibits a state from setting its standard time to year-round daylight saving time (DST). (15 U.S. Code §260 et seq.)
- Establishes the standard time for California, consistent with federal law, is PST, and sets DST to begin at 2:00 a.m. on the second Sunday of March of each year and end at 2:00 a.m. on the first Sunday of November of each year. Authorizes the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote, to change the dates and times of the DST period, consistent with federal law, and if federal law authorizes the state to provide for the year-round application of DST. (Government Code §6808)
This bill:
- Repeals DST in the state and the provisions regarding the Legislature’s authority to amend observance of DST provisions by a two-thirds vote.
- Requires the state and all political subdivisions of the state to observe year-round standard time.
- Exempts the state and all political subdivisions of the state from the provisions of federal law that establish the advancement of time.
Background
Daylight savings time v. standard time. DST is often referred to as “summer time” and standard time is often referred to as “winter time.” In California, DST, summer time, is observed during the time of year when clocks “spring forward,” between the second Sunday of March and first Sunday of November, consistent with federal law. Standard time, or winter time, in California is observed during the time of year when clocks “fall back,” between the first Sunday of November and second Sunday of March.
History of DST. The first modern DST was established during WWI as an effort to save energy and conserve fuel. In April of 1916, at 11:00 p.m., Germany and Austria advanced the hands of their clocks one hour and kept them that way until the following October. Many other nations—mostly in Europe, but including Tasmania and some Canadian provinces as well—followed suit. Two years later, the United States, too, established in law DST and created a standard time. That law defined standard time zones and set summer DST to begin on March 31, 1918. The nation observed DST for seven months in 1918 and 1919 but ceased to do so when congress repealed the DST law. Nonetheless, from February 9, 1942, to September 30, 1945, President Franklin Roosevelt instituted year-round DST, or “War Time.” From 1945 to 1966, there was no federal law regarding DST, leaving it to states and localities to choose whether and when to observe DST.
California Daylight Saving Time Act. California voters, in 1949, established The California Daylight Saving Time Act through the passage of Proposition 12. The proposition established standard time within California as the time which the federal government describes and designates as United States PST. The initiative also required that the state advance time one hour during the period from the last Sunday in April until the last Sunday in October. In the mid-1960s, Congress enacted The Uniform Act of 1966 to establish a uniform standard DST within each time zone. The act set DST to begin on the last Sunday of April and to end on the last Sunday of October. This act exempted any state from observing DST if the state passed a law that results in year-round observance of standard time. Two states—Arizona and Hawaii—have done so. Federal law does not, however, give states the option to observe DST year-round. In an effort to save energy, Congress passed The Energy Policy Act in 2005 to extend DST in the U.S. by three weeks in the spring and one week in the fall. This change created a conflict between California’s DST law and the federal law on DST. However, since federal law provides states only two options: 1) observe standard time throughout the year, or 2) observe DST on federally mandated dates, California has observed the dates consistent with the adjusted federal dates.
California passes Proposition 7 in 2018. In 2018, AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) placed a ballot measure before voters to make changes to the state’s observance of DST. Specifically, Proposition 7 (November 2018) which passed by 59.75 percent - 40.25 percent margin, allows the Legislature by two-thirds vote to make future changes to California’s DST period, including applying year-round application of DST, if changes are consistent with federal law. Proposition 7 also conformed California DST to current federal law. To enact Proposition 7 the measure also repealed Proposition 12 of 1949, a ballot initiative that established DST in California.
Energy savings? Claims of energy savings underlie observance of DST during the spring and summer. The argument is simple: by springing the clock forward during the summer when there is more sunlight we can take advantage of natural light and use less energy or fuel. Yet, there is no clear evidence that DST results in energy saving and some evidence suggests the contrary. In 2008, the National Bureau of Economic Research released a study on the effectiveness of DST. The study sought to provide the first empirical estimates of DST effects on electricity consumption in the United States by focusing on residential electricity demand as far back as the mid-1970s. The bureau’s main finding was that, contrary to the intent of the policy, DST increases residential electricity demand by approximately one percent. According to the study, during DST, there is a tradeoff between the demand for electricity and the demand for heating and cooling. That is, as the demand for electricity is reduced, the demand for heating and cooling is increased. These findings estimate that DST increased cost of electricity to Indiana households by about $9 million per year. The study further speculates that this impact is likely to vary by region, with regions where demand for heating and cooling is greater experiencing a higher increase in electricity use.[1]
In 2007, the California Energy Commission (CEC) released a study in response to the expansion of DST by the Energy Policy Act of 2005. This study, titled “The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California Electricity Consumption: A Statistical Analysis,” revealed that the “extension of DST to March 2007 had little or no effect on energy consumption in California, according to a statistical analysis. The most likely approximation is a 0.2 percent decrease during these three weeks.”[2] The findings of the study in relation to energy savings of the changes to DST were largely inconclusive as the 95 percent confidence interval could result in a range of 1.5 percent energy savings to 1.4 percent increase in energy consumption.
Comments
Bill seeks year-round standard time. The author has sought to do away with the biannual changing of the clocks, and establish one year-long time. In support of this goal, the author and supporters, cite various studies as to the benefits of having year-round standard time. The main benefits cited are the avoidance of public health impacts associated with switching the time by an hour twice a year, including increased heart attacks and strokes, traffic accidents, and workplace injuries as residents adjust to the time differences. Existing federal law does not allow states to establish year-round DST, but does allow year-round standard time. A previous author abandoned a previous attempt to establish year-round standard time due to opposition against such a change, including concerns that standard time would limit daylight activities and other impacts.
Changing electricity generation sources. Since the over a decade old CEC study, the state has increased its use of intermittent renewable resources, particularly solar generation which can only be used during the time the sun is shining. It is unclear how changes to DST could affect demand of energy resources and the particular effects on the electrical grid when solar generation is increasingly relied upon. In recent years, the state’s largest electrical grid operator, the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) has experienced challenges in the evening hours of the late summer when solar generation has plummeted and hydroelectric resources have been reduced. As a result, the state has invested billions from the general fund and utility ratepayers to help shore up resources. It is unclear whether a move to permanent standard time might exacerbate these conditions, as the sun would set earlier on these days.
Legislature empowered, Act of Congress not needed to establish standard time. If the Legislature passes this measure by the required two-thirds and the Governor signs this bill into law, this bill would take effect immediately. An act of Congress may seem unlikely but the issue of DST is not likely to be hampered by partisan politics, as is the case with many other issues before Congress today. There are currently some proposed Congressional measures that have been introduced to make changes to DST.
What did voters support? Voters supported the passage of Proposition 7 in 2018. However, it seems a valid question as to whether voters supported doing away with the biannual clock changes or if they support permanent year-long DST or permanent year-long standard time. Lacking any more recent data and analysis, this bill would immediately go into effect and immediately adopt year-long standard time. California residents and businesses would need to adjust immediately. It is unclear whether the state is prepared for doing away with the time change and the full ramifications of this policy to a myriad of operations, including: schools, logistics industry, communications, transportation, and many others, as well as, the effects on individuals adjusting to the new sunrise and sunset hours during the summer time (DST). The reality for most individuals is they may not fully appreciate the changes being proposed until they are clearly explained and potentially experienced. In 1974, as a response to the global energy crisis, the federal government under President Nixon attempted a year-long DST which, according to some news reports, was abandoned by the fall due to the political backlash, public outcry, and concerns about safety due to the later sunrises (and darker mornings as a result). It is unclear whether a change to yearlong standard time would engender a similar response.
Impacts to communities along the state’s borders. California shares borders with three states and the country of Mexico. The constant movement of people and goods across those borders requires coordination. The economies and societies of the border communities are interdependent. Currently, Arizona does not observe DST. Mexico recently did away with observing DST, however, the border areas maintain alignment with U.S. states. Changes to DST in California have the potential for considerable disruption. For example, when Congress passed the Energy Policy Act of 2005, which amended the dates of DST in the United States, it resulted in a time difference, for a period of a couple of weeks, between communities in the U.S. and communities in Mexico. This had a huge effect on border communities. In order to address this effect, the Congress of Mexico passed a law to allow border communities to adopt a DST pattern consistent with the United States. However, given Mexico has moved to year-long standard time, it is unclear whether a similar move by California would have a similar effect.
Timing. The question for the Legislature is whether immediate action is necessary. It seems there may be some benefit to waiting and assessing implications of a year-long standard time before authorizing its change. The state could assess the implications and the interests of residents, communities, schools, businesses, neighboring states and others to coordinate and conform to a year-long standard time all with a more informed analysis. Such an analysis should also include more current consideration of changes to energy systems in the near-term and long-term of moving to yearlong standard time, as well as, the impacts during the different time of the year in different regions of the state, as the amount of daily sunrise/sunset is not static and changes depending on the time of year and location.
In this regard, the author and committee may wish to amend this bill to require the CEC work with relevant agencies to develop an analysis regarding the implications for moving to yearlong standard time by February 1 of next year before authorizing a move to permanent standard time.
Prior/Related Legislation
AJR 33 (Chu, 2020) was a measure to urge Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow a state to adopt DST year-round. The measure was never heard.
AB 7 (Chu, 2018) was an urgency measure that would have established year-round DST (otherwise understood as summer time) effective immediately once the federal government authorizes such a change. The bill was held in this committee.
Proposition 7 (2018) made numerous changes to the state’s statute concerning DST, including: conform the dates of DST observance with those in the federal statute; authorizes the state, by a two-thirds votes of the Legislature, to adopt a year-round DST if allowed by the federal government; and repealed numerous sections of the 1949 California DST Act.
AB 807 (Chu, Chapter 60, Statutes of 2018) directed the Secretary of State to place an initiative on the ballot to allow voters to decide whether to authorize the Legislature, by a two-thirds vote of the members, to make changes to the state’s observance of DST consistent with, and to the extent authorized by, federal law.
AB 385 (Chu, 2016) would have repealed the DST Act and authorized the Legislature by majority vote to amend the law for the application of permanent (year-round) DST, if authorized by federal law. The bill failed passage on the Senate Floor.
AB 2496 (Chu, 2016) would have declared the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to establish United States Standard Pacific Time as the standard time within the state during the entire year. The bill died at the Assembly Desk.
AJR 28 (Obernolte, Chapter 167, Statutes of 2016) urged Congress and the President to enact legislation that would allow states to adopt permanent (year-round) DST.
SJRX2 1 (Karnette, Chapter 1, Statutes of 2001) memorialized Congress to approve legislation that allows a state to uniformly apply DST year-round.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT:
American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine
American Academy of Sleep Medicine
California Sleep Society
Coalition for Permanent Standard Time
National Sleep Foundation
Northwest Noggin Neuroscience
Save Standard Time
Sleep Research Society
Society for Research on Biological Rhythms
9 Individuals
OPPOSITION:
California Alliance for Golf
3 Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the National Sleep Foundation argues that “the human circadian system does not adjust to annual clock changes… The link between our biological clock and the sun clock has been crucial to human health and well-being for millennia.” NSF advocates “for the adoption of permanent standard time as the appropriate option for public health.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, the California Alliance for Golf contends that the golf community would suffer significant harm by a year-round standard time schedule. They argue that the loss of playable daylight hours in the afternoon/evenings would limit playing opportunities and reduce golf facility utilization, and reduce income for those who derive their livelihoods from the game and lessen recreational opportunities for those who play the game.
-- END --
Grant, Laura and Kotchen, Matthew. “Does Daylight Saving Time Save Energy? Evidence from a Natural Experiment in Indiana.” October 2008. http://www.nber.org/papers/ w14429.pdf ↑
California Energy Commission. The Effect of Early Daylight Saving Time on California. May 2007.< http://www.energy.ca.gov/2007publications/CEC-200-2007-004/CEC-200-2007-004.PDF>. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):