SB 1426: Waste reduction: undiverted materials.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-04-10
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-24: April 24 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 3. Noes 2. Page 3754.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989, administered by the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, generally regulates the disposal, management, and recycling of solid waste, as defined. Existing law authorizes each county, city, district, or other local governmental agency to determine aspects of solid waste handling that are of local concern and whether the services are to be provided by means of nonexclusive franchise, contract, license, permit, or otherwise.
This bill would define diversion services to mean the collection, transportation, and diversion of materials that would otherwise become solid waste, including through reuse, recycling, manufacturing, anaerobic digestion, or other similar services. The bill would prohibit a city or county ordinance from precluding the collection, transportation, or diversion of materials not diverted by, or the provision of diversion services using a method or process not offered by, a local governing bodys solid waste handling services, as specified.The act requires a city, county, or city and county, or regional agency formed under the act, to develop a source reduction and recycling element of an integrated waste management plan containing specified components. The act requires those jurisdictions to divert 50% of the solid waste subject to the element, except as specified, through source reduction, recycling, and composting activities.
This bill would prohibit an exclusive franchise, contract, license, or permit to provide services for diversion from exceeding the services required to be performed and actually performed under the exclusive authorization. The bill would require a person who provides services for diversion by means other than a franchise, contract, license, or permit, to comply with applicable law, as specified. The bill would, if certain programs are not offered through a local ordinance or a local jurisdictions franchise agreement, authorize other persons to collect, transport, and process undiscarded organic material from nonresidential customers, as specified.
The bill would include findings that changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern rather than a municipal affair and, therefore, apply to all cities, including charter cities.
The California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989, administered by the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery, generally regulates the disposal, management, and recycling of solid waste, as defined. Existing law authorizes each county, city, district, or other local governmental agency to determine aspects of solid waste handling that are of local concern and whether the services are to be provided by means of nonexclusive franchise, contract, license, permit, or otherwise.
This bill would define diversion services to mean the collection, transportation, and diversion of materials that would otherwise become solid waste, including through reuse, recycling, manufacturing, anaerobic digestion, or other similar services. The bill would prohibit a city or county ordinance from precluding the collection, transportation, or diversion of materials not diverted by, or the provision of diversion services using a method or process not offered by, a local governing bodys solid waste handling services, as specified.
The bill would include findings that changes proposed by this bill address a matter of statewide concern rather than a municipal affair and, therefore, apply to all cities, including charter cities.
Existing law requires the State Oil and Gas Supervisor, in cooperation with appropriate state and local agencies, to develop a strategy for extracting existing accumulations of methane gas and other hazardous gas from abandoned oil and gas wells in high-risk areas identified by the supervisor to protect the health and safety of the public.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that provision.Existing law requires the State Oil and Gas Supervisor, in cooperation with appropriate state and local agencies, to develop a strategy for extracting existing accumulations of methane gas and other hazardous gas from abandoned oil and gas wells in high-risk areas identified by the supervisor to protect the health and safety of the public.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that provision.
It is the intent of the Legislature that this act do all of the following:
(a)Clarifies that a contract, permit, or ordinance for solid waste handling services does not grant exclusivity for a service that is not actually provided.
(b)Affirms that, where a service for diversion is not being offered by the franchisee under an exclusive franchise, someone other than the franchisee cannot be prohibited from offering that service for diversion, and that, if and when an exclusive franchise is amended to include that service for diversion and the franchisee is providing that service, then that service would no longer be allowed to be offered by someone other than the franchisee.
(c)Clarifies that, since organic waste is required to be recycled statewide, there are specific scenarios in which the existing services provided under an exclusive franchise may be unsuitable to achieve the desired diversion results of the generator and the state, and therefore, if organic waste depackaging, contaminant removal, edible food recovery, food donation improvement, or source reduction, are not offered and actually performed through a local ordinance or a local jurisdictions franchise agreement, then undiscarded organic materials may be collected from nonresidential customers, transported, and processed by other persons providing these services if all other applicable state and local requirements are met.
(d)Clarifies that, if a service for diversion is not being provided by the contracted franchise hauler, then a supplemental servicer can operate and provide a service for diversion within that jurisdiction to collect and manage a material that is not currently being diverted through an existing curbside program.
SEC. 2.Section 40059 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:40059.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, each county, city, district, or other local governmental agency may determine all of the following:
(1)Aspects of solid waste handling which are of local concern, including, but not limited to, frequency of collection, means of collection and transportation, level of services, charges and fees, and nature, location, and extent of providing solid waste handling services.
(2)Whether the services are to be provided by means of nonexclusive franchise, contract, license, permit, or otherwise, either with or without competitive bidding, or if, in the opinion of its governing body, the public health, safety, and well-being so require, by partially exclusive or wholly exclusive franchise, contract, license, permit, or otherwise, either with or without competitive bidding. The authority to provide solid waste handling services may be granted under terms and conditions prescribed by the governing body of the local governmental agency by resolution or ordinance.
(b)In accordance with the requirements specified in Section 40051 and the purposes specified in Section 40052, an exclusive franchise, contract, license, or permit to provide services for diversion shall not exceed the services required to be performed and actually performed under the exclusive authorization.
(b)(c)Nothing in this division modifies or abrogates in any manner either of the following:
(1)Any franchise previously granted or extended by any county or other local governmental agency.
(2)Any contract, license, or any permit to collect solid waste previously granted or extended by a city, county, or a city and county.
(d)A person who provides services for diversion by means other than a franchise, contract, license, or permit, shall comply with all applicable federal, state, regional, and local laws, rules, and regulations, including, but not limited to, regulations related to labor and worker safety, land use, vehicles, and responsible end-use or disposal of materials.
SEC. 3.Section 42649.81 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:42649.81.(a)(1)A business that generates four cubic yards or more of commercial solid waste, as defined in Section 42649.1, per week, shall arrange for recycling services specifically for organic waste in the manner specified in subdivision (b).
(2)On or after January 1, 2020, if the department determines that statewide disposal of organic waste has not been reduced to 50 percent of the level of disposal during 2014, a business that generates two cubic yards or more per week of commercial solid waste shall arrange for the organic waste recycling services specified in paragraph (1), unless the department determines that this requirement will not result in significant additional reductions of organics disposal.
(3)A business located in a rural jurisdiction that is exempted pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 42649.82 is not subject to this chapter.
(b)A business subject to subdivision (a) shall take at least one of the following actions:
(1)Source separate organic waste from other waste and subscribe to a basic level of organic waste recycling service that includes collection and recycling of organic waste.
(2)Recycle its organic waste onsite or self-haul its own organic waste for recycling.
(3)Subscribe to an organic waste recycling service that may include mixed waste processing that specifically recycles organic waste.
(4)Make other arrangements consistent with paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 42649.84.
(c)A business that is a property owner may require a lessee or tenant of that property to source separate their organic waste to aid in compliance with this section.
(d)(1)A business subject to subdivision (a) and that provides customers access to the business shall provide customers with an organic waste recycling bin or container to collect material purchased on the premises for immediate consumption and that fulfills all of the following requirements:
(A)Is in the same area as a bin or container for trash other than recyclable organic waste, except in restrooms.
(B)Is visible and easily accessible.
(C)Is clearly marked with educational signage indicating what is appropriate to place in the organic waste recycling bin or container in accordance with state law and the local jurisdictions solid waste ordinances and practices.
(2)Full-service restaurants are exempt from the requirements of this subdivision if the full-service restaurant provides its employees an organic waste recycling bin or container to collect material purchased on the premises for immediate consumption and implements a program to collect recyclable organic waste.
(3)With respect to a park that is subject to subdivision (a), both of the following apply:
(A)This subdivision only applies to permanent, nonmobile food service facilities with dedicated seating areas that are not full-service restaurants.
(B)In lieu of providing an organic waste recycling bin or container as required by paragraph (1), a facility identified in this paragraph may implement a process for recycling organic waste from customers that yields results comparable to or greater in volume and quality to results attained by providing an organic waste recycling bin or container.
(4)The department shall develop model signage that businesses may use in implementing paragraph (1).
(5)For a park that is subject to subdivision (a), this subdivision shall apply on and after January 1, 2022.
(e)A business generating organic waste shall arrange for the recycling services required by this section in a manner that is consistent with state and local laws and requirements, including a local ordinance or local jurisdictions franchise agreement, applicable to the collection, handling, or recycling of solid and organic waste.
(f)When arranging for gardening or landscaping services, the contract or work agreement between a business subject to this section and a gardening or landscaping service shall require that the organic waste generated by those services be managed in compliance with this chapter.
(g)(1)A multifamily residential dwelling that consists of fewer than five units is not a business for purposes of this chapter.
(2)A business that is a multifamily dwelling is not required to arrange for the organic waste recycling services specified in subdivision (b) for food waste that is generated by the business.
(h)If separate organic waste collection and recycling services are not offered through a local ordinance or local jurisdictions franchise agreement, a business generating organic waste may arrange for separate organic waste collection and recycling services, until the local ordinance or local jurisdictions franchise agreement includes organic waste recycling services.
(i)(1)Subject to paragraphs (2) and (3), if organic waste depackaging, contaminant removal, edible food recovery, food donation improvement, source reduction, or another service otherwise intended to meet the goals of this part is not offered through a local ordinance or a local jurisdictions franchise agreement, then an undiscarded organic material may be collected from nonresidential customers, transported, and processed by other persons providing that service if all other applicable state and local regulations and requirements are met.
(2)Paragraph (1) does not apply to byproducts used for livestock feed donations to an organization described in subsection (c) of Section 501 of the Internal Revenue Code of the United States (26 U.S.C. 501(c)).
(3)Paragraph (1) shall not be interpreted to do either of the following:
(A)Negate, impact, or otherwise affect activities conducted under Section 40059.4.
(B)Authorize the disposal of covered material, as defined in Section 42041, in a manner inconsistent with the producer responsibility plan, as defined in Section 42041.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that the collection, transportation, and diversion from the solid waste stream of undiscarded materials that are not diverted by local waste handling services the ability of Californians to divert waste from landfills where services for diversion are not provided by local solid waste handling services under exclusive authorization is a matter of statewide concern and is not a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution. Therefore, Section 1 Sections 2 and 3 of this act adding Section 40059.5 to amending Sections 40059 and 42649.81 of the Public Resources Code applies to all cities, including charter cities.
An ordinance adopted by a local governing body, or an ordinance enacted by initiative of the voters of a city or county, shall not preclude the collection, transportation, or diversion of materials not diverted by, or the provision of diversion services using a method or process not offered by, a local governing bodys solid waste handling services.
SEC. 2.Section 40128 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:40128.Diversion services means the collection, transportation, and diversion of materials that would otherwise become solid waste, including through reuse, recycling, manufacturing, anaerobic digestion, or other similar services.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that the collection, transportation, and diversion from the solid waste stream of undiscarded materials that are not diverted by local waste handling services is a matter of statewide concern and is not a municipal affair as that term is used in Section 5 of Article XI of the California Constitution. Therefore, Section 1 of this act adding Section 40059.5 to the Public Resources Code applies to all cities, including charter cities.
SECTION 1.Section 3241 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:3241.The supervisor, in cooperation with appropriate state and local agencies, shall develop a strategy for extracting existing accumulations of methane gas and other hazardous gas from abandoned oil and gas wells in high-risk areas identified by the supervisor to protect the health and safety of the public. The strategy shall also provide plans for the management of methane gas and other hazardous gas from wells in high-risk areas where no accumulations are discovered to prevent future accumulations of methane gas and other hazardous gas.The supervisor, in cooperation with appropriate state and local agencies, shall develop a strategy for extracting existing accumulations of methane gas and other hazardous gas from abandoned oil and gas wells in high-risk areas identified by the supervisor in order to protect the health and safety of the public. The strategy shall also provide plans for the management of methane gas and other hazardous gas from wells in high-risk areas where no accumulations are discovered in order to prevent future accumulations of methane gas and other hazardous gas.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2024 | April 24 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 3. Noes 2. Page 3754.) |
| Apr 17, 2024 | Set for hearing May 1 in L. GOV. pending receipt. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Re-referred to Coms. on E.Q. and L. GOV. |
| Mar 18, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Local Government] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Athens Services | ** Against | |
| California Council For Environmental & Economic Balance | ** Against | |
| California State Treasurer | ** Support | |
| California Teamsters Public Affairs Council | ** Against | |
| California Waste Haulers Council | ** Against | |
| Child Creativity Lab | ** Support | |
| Circular Fashion LA | ** Support | |
| City of Napa | ** Against | |
| Cleanearth | ** Support | |
| Cr&R, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Desert Valley Disposal, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Divert INC. | ** Support | |
| Human and Pet Initiative | ** Support | |
| Imperial Western Products Inc | ** Support | |
| Inland Empire Disposal Association | ** Against | |
| LA Family Housing | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Waste Management Association | ** Against | |
| Merlin Plastics | ** Support | |
| Mid Valley Disposal | ** Against | |
| National Diversity Coalition | ** Support | |
| Palm Springs Disposal Services | ** Against | |
| Project Ropa | ** Support | |
| Recology | ** Against | |
| Re-cork | ** Support | |
| Recycle Right Coalition | ** Support | |
| Republic Services - Western Region | ** Against | |
| Resource Recovery Coalition Of California | ** Against | |
| Ridwell, INC. | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Against | |
| Solid Waste Association Of Orange County | ** Against | |
| Waste Connections, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Waste Management | ** Against | |
| Wastexperts, INC. | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No. | SB 1426 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/2024 |
Author: | Blakespear | ||
Version: | 4/10/2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Brynn Cook | ||
SUBJECT: Waste reduction: undiverted materials
DIGEST: This bill prohibits exclusive waste diversion franchises and contracts from exceeding the services under their exclusive authorization. This bill also specifies that entities can collect undiscarded organic material from nonresidential customers if that material is diverted from the landfill in a manner not offered by a local jurisdiction’s ordinance or franchise agreement.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes within the California Environmental Protection Agency the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to administer and oversee the Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 (IWMA) and related laws pertaining to solid waste management. (Public Resources Code (PRC) §40400)
- Under the IWMA:
- Establishes a state recycling goal of 75% of solid waste generated to be diverted from landfill disposal through source reduction, recycling, and composting by 2020. (PRC §41780.01)
- Requires each local jurisdiction to divert 50% of solid waste from landfill disposal through source reduction, recycling, and composting. (PRC §41780)
- Requires commercial waste generators, including multi-family dwellings, to arrange for recycling services and requires local governments to implement commercial solid waste recycling programs designed to divert solid waste from businesses. (PRC §42649)
- Requires that solid waste handling services be provided by the local agency, another local agency, or a solid waste enterprise. (PRC §42649)
- Authorizes local jurisdictions to determine: (PRC §40059)
- Aspects of solid waste handling that are of local concern, including frequency of collection, means of collection and transportation, level of services, charges and fees, and the nature, location, and extent of providing the services; and
- Whether the services are provided by nonexclusive franchise, contract, license, permit, or otherwise, with or without competitive bidding. If the governing body determines that public health, safety, and well-being require, services may be provided by partially exclusive or wholly exclusive franchise, contract, license, permit, or otherwise, with or without competitive bidding.
- Prohibits the theft of recyclable materials, including those that are placed at curbside for pickup by an authorized recycling agent and sets limits for civil penalties for theft of recyclable materials. (PRC § 41950)
- Establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act (SB 54), which imposes minimum recycled content requirements and source reduction requirements for single-use packaging and plastic food service ware, to be achieved through an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program. (PRC § §42040 et seq.)
- Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to complete, approve, and implement a comprehensive strategy to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants (SLCPs) in the state to achieve, among other things, a reduction in the statewide emissions of methane by 40%. (SB 1383, Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016 (SB 1383); Health and Safety Code (HSC) §39730 et seq.)
- Requires that methane emissions reduction goals include specified targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste by 50% relative to its 2014 level by 2020, and achieve a 75% reduction relative to 2014 by 2025. (HSC §39730.6)
- Requires CalRecycle, in consultation with CARB, to adopt regulations to achieve those targets for reducing organic waste in landfills (SB 1383 regulations).
This bill:
- Specifies that an exclusive franchise, contract, license or permit to provide services for diversion shall not exceed the services obligated and performed under the exclusive authorization.
- Specifies that a person who provides solid waste handling services by means other than those in an existing franchise agreement or local ordinance shall comply with all applicable federal, state, regional, and local laws, rules, and regulations.
- Authorizes an entity that is outside a local ordinance or local jurisdictions franchise agreement to transport or process undiscarded organic materials collected from non-residential customers for diversion services not offered in the local ordinance or local jurisdiction’s franchise agreement.
- Specifies that this does not does not apply to byproducts used for livestock feed donations to a 501(c) organization.
- Specifies that materials that are part of SB 54 must be disposed of in a manner consistent with the producer responsibility plan developed in SB 54.
- Makes related findings and declarations.
Background
- Solid waste in California. For three decades, CalRecycle has been tasked with reducing disposal of municipal solid waste and promoting recycling in California through the IWMA. Under IWMA, the state has established a statewide 75% reduction, recycling, and composting goal by 2020. Additionally, the state has established a target of a 75% reduction in the level of disposal of organic waste from the 2014 level by 2025. Local governments have been required to divert 50% of the solid waste generated within their jurisdictions from landfill disposal since 2000. However, according to CalRecycle’s 2022 State of Disposal and Recycling, the State’s 2021 recycling rate was just 41%. The single largest contributor to this recycling rate was recyclables that were exported out of the state.
- State programs to reach landfill diversion goals. California has introduced numerous policies to divert material from the landfill and prioritizing source reduction, reuse, and recycling for those materials instead. Two of the most significant policies to drive diversion are SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016) and SB 54 (Allen Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022).
- SB 1383 sets a goal of reducing landfill disposal of organic waste by 50% by 2020 and 75% by 2025 relative to 2014 levels in order to reduce methane emissions from landfills. The organic waste diverted from landfills will instead go to organics recovery facilities to make useful products, including compost, fertilizer, fuel, or energy. In addition, at least 20 percent of the edible food in the organic waste stream must be recovered to feed people by 2025.
To achieve these targets, CalRecycle, in consultant with CARB, set requirements for organic waste collection and consumption:
- Jurisdictions must provide organic waste collection services to all residents and businesses; and
- Jurisdictions must procure 0.08 tons of organic waste per resident per year. The recovered organic waste products that can be procured to comply with this requirement compost that is produced at a permitted compostable material handling operation or facility or a permitted large volume in-vessel digestion facility; renewable gas used for fuel for transportation, electricity, or heating applications; electricity from biomass conversion; or mulch.
- SB 54 uses an EPR approach to reach ambitious targets to reduce single-use serviceware and packaging through source reduction and postconsumer recycled content. EPR require producers to factor in costs associated with disposal and, working through a product stewardship organization (PRO), develop and implement approaches to create a circular economy with oversight and enforcement provided by the government. SB 54 sets specific waste reduction targets for producers including:
- Requiring all covered material sold in the state to be recyclable or compostable by January 1, 2032;
- Requiring that all plastic-covered material sold in the state meet a recycling rate of 65% by Jan 1, 2032, with interim goals beginning in 2028;
- Prohibiting producers of expanded polystyrene (EPS) from selling EPS food serviceware unless they meet a 65% recycling rate by January 1, 2032; and
- Requiring the PRO to pay $500 million per year from January 1, 2027, through January 1, 2037 to fund the program, and authorizes the PRO to collect up to $150 million from plastic manufacturers.
- Trash or treasure? Material that ends up in the trash can still have value. In January 2023, aluminum had a scrap value of $1,458per ton. Even plastics can have significant scrap value: PET plastic had a scrap value of $250 per ton and HDEP had a scrap value of $408 per ton (the cost of recycling these plastics, however, is higher than the cost of their scrap value). In addition to the intrinsic value of material as scrap or in a resell market, state policy aimed at keeping waste out of landfills can also add direct and indirect pressures that increase the value of ‘trash.’ A simple example (on paper) is the California Beverage Container Recycling Program, or bottle bill: by adding a 5-25cents CRV per beverage container, the bottle bill adds a monetary incentive for consumers to return bottles to recycling centers and claim their CRV, which keeps those same out of landfills. Another example is SB 1383’s organic material collection and procurement requirements for local jurisdictions: these state requirements have driven the deployment of organic waste collection and recycling infrastructure and markets.
- Taking out the trash. Most jurisdictions in the state operate with some form of "franchise," or contract, that limits solid waste hauling within the jurisdiction to one or more specified companies. Local agencies have authority under the IWMA to set the terms of solid waste handling, including the frequency and means of collection, level of service, charges and fees, nature, location, and extent of providing service, and whether to provide services through franchise agreements, contracts, licenses, permits, other approvals, or a combination of any of the above. Jurisdictions have the authority to enter into franchises with waste haulers, with or without competitive bidding. Exclusive franchises authorize a single hauler to operate within a jurisdiction. Non-exclusive franchises allow for more than one hauler, but establish specific requirements for hauling within the jurisdiction. Some communities in California do not have franchise agreements, which allows solid waste businesses to compete within the jurisdiction for service contracts with individual waste generators.
Franchise exclusivity prevents competing services from undercutting the planned revenue the franchised structure is based on. Franchises generally include a "franchise fee," which is a payment made by the franchise hauler to the local government that holds the franchise. Franchise fees vary, but are often in the millions to tens of millions of dollars.
Franchise waste hauling agreements only apply to material once it has been discarded: individuals or businesses are free to sell recyclable materials to non-franchise companies. This was crystalized in a 1994 California Supreme Court ruling in the City of Rancho Mirage and Waste Management of the Desert v. Palm Springs Recycling Center, Inc., which determined that a city's authority to grant exclusive franchise rights for waste management does not prohibit people in the franchise area from selling their recyclable materials to other companies. The argument behind this decision is that recyclables are not waste until their owner discards them. If recyclables are being sold, this indicates that they are not discarded and therefore do not fall under city waste management authority.
This ruling, commonly referred to as the “Rancho Mirage” decision, still governs how recycled materials are treated in solid waste franchise agreements. Additionally, state law specifies that individuals have the right to donate or sell recyclable materials.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author: “Today, Californians that want to divert more waste from landfills and reduce their climate emissions do not have the option to do so. This is due to a lack of clarity around who may provide additional waste diversion services that waste haulers currently are not providing. My intention with SB 1426 is to allow for materials that are not being diverted under an exclusive franchise contract to be diverted by a third-party service so that we can meet our waste diversion goals more quickly.
“This policy solution is critical as the journal ‘Science’ published findings recently that found investor-owned landfills are spewing 40% more methane gas than previously thought. California landfills are combusting. Currently, the Chiquita Valley Landfill and Sunshine Canyon Landfills are emitting fumes so toxic residents have been relocated. In addition, studies have shown that 79% of materials that could be recycled are currently being lost to the landfill.
“The status quo is failing our state and our environment, and it’s time for innovation in the industry that SB 1426 helps usher in.”
- Reinforcing or overturning a mirage? Under existing law in Rancho Mirage, a local jurisdiction’s authority to grant exclusive franchise rights for waste management does not prohibit people in the franchise area from selling their recyclable materials to other companies. However, the reality of determining what is and is not discarded can be complex. The author and sponsors of SB 1426 point to numerous cases where non-franchise recycling companies have been discouraged or failed to get authority to operate in a jurisdiction because of uncertainty on the legality of providing recycling services in an area with an existing exclusive waste-hauling service.
SB 1426 tries to address this ambiguity and give more legal certainty to third party recyclers to operate. However, it does so by delineating what services a non-franchised recycler could offer in an area that already has an incumbent exclusive waste hauler contract, while at the same time specifying that the material in question is “undiscarded” and thus outside the purview of exclusive waste-hauling services. By accepting two conflicting premises –specifying that the material is undiscarded, but also outlining a process for providing services for it as if it were waste—the bill may add confusion rather than clarity to this issue.
- Are we talking about services, or material? SB 1426 would allow a business that isn’t a local jurisdiction or their franchise waste hauler to offer diversion services for undiscarded material so long as those services are not already offered in the franchise agreement. The intent of SB 1426, as stated in material provided by the author, is to only capture and divert material that is going to landfills under existing contracts. However, in its current form, the bill doesn’t accomplish that goal. SB 1426 would allow non-franchise entities to capture and divert organic material that may already be diverted in existing franchise contracts, so long as the recyclers are offering a different service from the one offered in the franchise. For example, a non-franchise recycler could divert organic material for composting even if that material would otherwise be diverted for edible food recovery in the incumbent franchise agreement. In this case, allowing non-franchise agreements to provide new diversion services opens the door to more types of diversion services, but does not increase the overall amount of material being diverted from landfills. Even more worrisome, the diversion service offered by the non-franchise recycler may in some cases be lower on the reduce, reuse, recycle hierarchy than the diversion service offered by the franchise waste hauling service.
By focusing on services instead of the actual material that is being diverted, SB 1426 could also open the door to loopholes. Waste-haulers would be incentivized to offer many types of diversion services in their exclusive franchise agreements in order to maintain jurisdiction of that material. However, there could be no requirement in those agreements that these services divert substantial amounts of materials. Without considering the volume of the material being diverted to various services, it is unclear if SB 1426 will increase diversion from landfills.
The author and committee may wish to specify that entities may collect categories of material that are not currently being accepted by facilities for recycling or composting from curbside or as part of an exclusive franchise agreement.
- Curbside recycling is a real problem. SB 1426 seeks to address a very real problem: a significant amount of compostable or recyclable material that ends up in curbside does not get composted or recycled. According to a report by The Recycling Partnership (TRP), on average that 20% of materials delivered to California MRFs were not accepted by local curbside recycling programs and even materials listed as acceptable was often not functionally recyclable. Curbside is often a very contaminated source of recyclable or compostable materials (e.g., some but not all materials in a curbside recycle bin are actually recyclable at facilities). According to TRP, more than half of Californians think plastic bags are accepted in their curbside recycling program, even though according to CalRecycle, plastic bags, alongside film and wrap is the largest type of contamination in curbside recycling bins at 12% by weight. Given that commonly recycled items comprised 22.8% of the State’s 2018 single-family residential disposal, according to TRP, the amount of recyclable material that is being put in curbside and not actually being diverted from landfills is significant.
- Intersection with SB 54 and SB 1383. As discussed in the background, the value of organic material and single-use plastics and packaging has shifted with the passage of SB 1383 and SB 54 respectively, which are creating new markets and pressures to recycle covered material in these programs.
- SB 1383. Opening up more channels for diverting waste through out-of-franchise recycling could support local jurisdictions in their efforts to reach SB 1383 targets. At the same time, diversion services that are not part of franchise agreements or that are pre-empted from local control could limit the information, predictability, and control of that material that enables locals to strategically deploy organic waste infrastructure. If a significant amount of organic waste is diverted without using the local jurisdiction’s infrastructure, local jurisdictions may find that the scale and type of the infrastructure they have built to accommodate organic waste under SB 1383 does not align with the volume or type organic waste actually through existing franchise and contracts. Because SB 1426 pre-empts local control regarding non-franchise contracts, it could tie the hands of locals to effectively deploy their SB 1383 strategies.
The author and committee may wish to take amendments that authorize third party collection of material that is not currently accepted at facilities for recycling and composting or accepted at facilities as part of a franchise agreement, removing the need for the declaration that diverting materials from landfills is a matter of statewide concern and is not a municipal affair.
- SB 54. Under SB 54, producers for single use plastics and packaging are required to meet specific source reduction and recycling goals. It is the responsibility of the PRO to develop a plan to achieve these outcomes. This plan could include contracting with third-party recycling companies to ensure that their materials are not entering landfills. Moreover, in developing its product stewardship plan, the PRO is required to ensure that products are being recycled at responsible end markets. This criteria is not currently integrated into SB 1426.
Given that materials covered under SB 54 will already be covered under the PRO’s plan to reach source reduction, recycling, and composting goals, it may be most efficient to remove these materials from the requirements of SB 1426. Recyclers would still be able to coordinate directly with the PRO to collect materials through ‘alternative recycling’ measures authorized in SB 54. While SB 1426 does specify that covered material under SB 54 should not be disposed of in a manner inconsistent with the producer responsibility plan, this language does not preclude covered material under SB 54 from being collected by recyclers independent of the PRO.
The author and committee may wish to specify that material covered under SB 54 is not under the purview of SB 1426. The author and committee may also wish to require that all recyclable material collected by entities under SB 1426 must go to a responsible end market.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Local Governance Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 71 (Wiener, 2017) would have prohibited any entity other than a solid waste enterprise authorized by a local government from collecting, transporting, or hauling solid waste. The bill also would have expanded civil enforcement provisions associated with the theft of recycled materials. The bill died on the assembly suspense file.
SB 54 (Allen Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022) establishes the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which imposes minimum content and source reduction requirements for plastic single-use packaging and food service ware through an EPR program.
SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016) requires the state to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants, including reducing methane emissions 40% by 2030, as specified, reducing hydrofluorocarbon gas emissions 40% by 2030, and reducing anthropogenic black carbon emissions 50% by 2030.
SOURCE:
Recycle Right Coalition
SUPPORT:
California State Treasurer
Child Creativity Lab
Circular Fashion LA
Cleanearth
Divert INC.
Human and Pet Initiative
Imperial Western Products, INC
LA Family Housing
Merlin Plastics
National Diversity Coalition
Project Ropa
Re-cork
Recycle Right Coalition
Ridwell, INC.
Wastexperts, INC.
OPPOSITION:
Athens Services
California Council for Environmental & Economic Balance (CCEEB)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Waste Haulers Council
City of Napa
Cr&r, INC.
Desert Valley Disposal, INC.
Inland Empire Disposal Association
Los Angeles County Waste Management Association
Mid Valley Disposal
Palm Springs Disposal Services
Recology
Republic Services - Western Region
Resource Recovery Coalition of California
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
Solid Waste Association of Orange County
Waste Connections, INC.
Waste Management
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Recycle Right Coalition writes in support: “This bill is critical in clarifying existing legal ambiguities to ensure that no Californian desiring to divert waste from landfills is prohibited from doing so. Across California, many residents and businesses are currently restricted from accessing innovative waste diversion services due to overly broad interpretations of franchise hauling agreements. These agreements are mistakenly believed to confer exclusivity over all waste management services, including those not provided under the franchise system. SB 1426 seeks to rectify this by explicitly stating that exclusivity does not extend to unoffered services, thereby fostering an environment where supplemental waste diversion can thrive alongside existing services. This clarification is urgently needed as many Californians that want to divert more materials are required under ambiguity in current law to send materials that could
be recycled to landfills instead. SB 1426 not only supports our environmental goals but also aids in job creation and the stimulation of a circular economy by enabling private investments in waste diversion infrastructure.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
Republic Services writes in opposition: “SB 1426 (Blakespear) Preempts and Undermines Local Control. Franchise agreements between a local agency and a solid waste service provider, in addition to the services provided and the fees paid, often also specify the number of vehicles used in providing these services, the types of vehicles used (low-emission or zero-emission vehicles) and whether the solid waste service provider’s employees are unionized. SB 1426 in essence provides that any organization may bypass the franchise agreement between a local agency and a franchised solid waste service provider with no approval from that local agency if that organizations believes they provide the same solid waste diversion services, but do so in a different fashion.
“SB 1426 (Blakespear) will Cause the Investments made by Local Agencies and Franchised Solid Waste Services Providers in Organics Recycling Required by SB 1383 to be Stranded. SB 1383 (Lara) Short-lived climate pollutants: methane emissions: dairy and livestock: organic waste: landfills [Ch. 395, Stat. 2016] requires among other things that methane emission reduction goals shall include targets to reduce the landfill disposal of organic waste 75% by 2025. Republic Services was an early supporter of SB 1383. The sponsors of SB 1426 were not involved in any way in the passage of SB 1383 Responding to the requirements in SB 1383, to date, Republic Services has invested over $100 million in organics collections, processing and recycling infrastructure. The Standardized Regulatory Impact Assessment (SRIA) prepared by CalRecycle estimated that the direct costs of SB 1383 will be $20.9 Billion. SB 1426 is designed to provide other organizations, not a franchised solid waste service provider, the opportunity to “cherry pick” the organics waste stream. This will cause much of the investments made by local agencies and franchised solid waste services providers in organics recycling required under SB 1383 to be left stranded.”
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):