SB 1441: Examination of petitions: time limitations and reimbursement of costs.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-22
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-22: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 479, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection, except as provided. Existing law generally includes in the meaning of public records any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the publics business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics.
Under existing law, certain election petitions are not public records and are not open to inspection except by certain persons. Specifically, existing law authorizes, among other persons, the proponents of a petition found to be insufficient or their designated representative to examine the petition no later than 21 days after certification of the insufficiency.
This bill would require the examination to conclude no later than 60 days after it commenced. If the examination does not conclude within 5 business days, the bill would require that the proponents of the examination reimburse the county for any costs incurred to continue the examination, as provided. When an examination continues beyond 5 business days, the bill would require the elections official to estimate at the beginning of each day and the proponent to deposit with the elections official a sum required by the elections official to support the examination for that day. The bill would authorize the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination and provide that money not required to be refunded be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
By imposing new duties on county elections officials related to examination of petitions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, with regard to certain mandates, no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection, except as provided. Existing law generally includes in the meaning of public records any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the publics business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics.
Under existing law, certain election petitions are not public records and are not open to inspection except by certain persons. Specifically, existing law authorizes, among other persons, the proponents of a petition found to be insufficient or their designated representative to examine the petition no later than 21 days after certification of the insufficiency.
This bill would require the examination to conclude no later than 60 days after it commenced. If the examination does not conclude within 5 business days, the bill would require that the proponents of the examination reimburse the county for any costs incurred to continue the examination, as provided. When an examination continues beyond 5 business days, the bill would require the elections official to estimate at the beginning of each day and the proponent to deposit with the elections official a sum required by the elections official to support the examination for that day. The bill would authorize the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination and provide that money not required to be refunded be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
By imposing new duties on county elections officials related to examination of petitions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, with regard to certain mandates, no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection, except as provided. Existing law generally includes in the meaning of public records any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the publics business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics.
Under existing law, certain election petitions are not public records and are not open to inspection except by certain persons. Specifically, existing law authorizes, among other persons, the proponents of a petition found to be insufficient or their designated representative to examine the petition no later than 21 days after certification of the insufficiency.
This bill would require the examination to conclude no later than 60 days after it commenced. The bill would also require the proponent to reimburse all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination within 30 days after the examination concludes. The If the examination does not conclude within 5 business days, the bill would require that the proponents of the examination reimburse the county for any costs incurred to continue the examination, as provided. When an examination continues beyond 5 business days, the bill would, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, would require the elections official to estimate at the beginning of each day and the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum required by the elections official to cover the cost of support the examination for that day. The bill would authorize the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination and provide that money not required to be refunded be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
By imposing new duties on county elections officials related to examination of petitions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, with regard to certain mandates, no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection, except as provided. Existing law generally includes in the meaning of public records any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the publics business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics.
Under existing law, certain election petitions are not public records and are not open to inspection except by certain persons. Specifically, existing law authorizes, among other persons, the proponents of a petition found to be insufficient or their designated representative to examine the petition no later than 21 days after certification of the insufficiency.
This bill would require the examination to conclude no later than 60 days after it commenced. The bill would also require the proponent to reimburse all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination within 30 days after the examination concludes. The bill would, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, require the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The bill would authorize the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination and provide that money not required to be refunded be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
By imposing new duties on county elections officials related to examination of petitions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the California Public Records Act, requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection, except as provided. Existing law generally includes in the meaning of public records any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the publics business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics.
Under existing law, certain election petitions are not public records and are not open to inspection except by certain persons. Specifically, existing law authorizes, among other persons, the proponents of a petition found to be insufficient or their designated representative to examine the petition no later than 21 days after certification of the insufficiency.
This bill would require the examination to conclude no later than 60 days after it commenced. The bill would also require the proponent to reimburse all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination within 30 days after the examination concludes. The bill would, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, require the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The bill would authorize the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination and provide that money not required to be refunded be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
By imposing new duties on county elections officials related to examination of petitions, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Constitution requires local agencies, for the purpose of ensuring public access to the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies, to comply with a statutory enactment that amends or enacts laws relating to public records or open meetings and contains findings demonstrating that the enactment furthers the constitutional requirements relating to this purpose.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
(a)Notwithstanding Sections 7920.510, 7920.515, 7920.520, 7920.530, 7920.540, 7920.545, 7922.545, subdivision (a) of Section 7920.525, subdivision (b) of Section 7922.540, and Sections 7922.500 to 7922.535, inclusive, the following are not public records:
(1)A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
(2)A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
(3)A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
(4)A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code.
(5)A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
(b)The materials described in subdivision (a) shall not be open to inspection except by the following persons:
(1)A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
(2)If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), the Attorney General, the Secretary of State, the Fair Political Practices Commission, a district attorney, a city attorney, a school district attorney, and a community college district attorney shall be permitted to examine the materials described in subdivision (a) upon approval of the appropriate superior court.
(d)If the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to subdivision (b), all of the following shall apply:
(1)The examination shall commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency and shall conclude no later than 60 days from the date that the examination commenced, and the county elections official shall retain the documents as prescribed in Section 17200 of the Elections Code.
(2)The elections official may establish reasonable guidelines for the examination and shall provide reasonable resources as necessary for the examination to proceed in a timely manner.
(3)If the examination is not concluded within 5 business days from the date that the examination begins, any costs incurred by the county elections official to continue the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponents. Nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to permit a county elections official to delay or obstruct the examination.
(4)Before the examination may continue pursuant to paragraph (3), the elections official shall estimate the costs necessary to support the examination. A new estimate of costs shall take place at the beginning of each day of examination following the fifth day. The proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum shall deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official necessary to support the examination for that day. The proponent shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Money not required to be refunded shall be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
(5)Cost for purposes of this subdivision means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
It is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state to have access to information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is the intent of this act to continue the existing balance between the publics right of access to information concerning the conduct of public business and other interests, including the constitutional guarantee of privacy of persons signing initiative, referendum, and recall petitions, which are not public records under Section 7924.110 of the Government Code.
It is the intent of this act to further the interest of petition proponents to examine initiative, referendum, and recall petitions without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to allow for any examination of the petition to proceed and conclude in a timely manner. It is also the intent of this act to further the interest of elections officials to provide support to proponents in the petition examination process without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to avoid any interference with the elections officials ability to complete all statutory and ongoing election support activities in the administration of elections.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding Sections 7920.510, 7920.515, 7920.520, 7920.530, 7920.540, 7920.545, 7922.545, subdivision (a) of Section 7920.525, subdivision (b) of Section 7922.540, and Sections 7922.500 to 7922.535, inclusive, the following are not public records:
(1)A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
(2)A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
(3)A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
(4)A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code.
(5)A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
(b)The materials described in subdivision (a) shall not be open to inspection except by the following persons:
(1)A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
(2)If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), the Attorney General, the Secretary of State, the Fair Political Practices Commission, a district attorney, a city attorney, a school district attorney, and a community college district attorney shall be permitted to examine the materials described in subdivision (a) upon approval of the appropriate superior court.
(d)If the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to subdivision (b), all of the following shall apply:
(1)The examination shall commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency and shall conclude no later than 60 days from the date that the examination commenced, and the county elections official shall retain the documents as prescribed in Section 17200 of the Elections Code.
(2)The elections official may establish reasonable guidelines for the examination and shall provide reasonable resources as necessary for the examination to proceed in a timely manner.
(3)If the examination is not concluded within 5 business days from the date that the examination begins, any costs incurred by the county elections official to continue the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponents. Nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to permit a county elections official to delay or obstruct the examination.
(4)Before the examination may continue pursuant to paragraph (3), the elections official shall estimate the costs necessary to support the examination. A new estimate of costs shall take place at the beginning of each day of examination following the fifth day. The proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum shall deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official necessary to support the examination for that day. The proponent shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Money not required to be refunded shall be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
(5)Cost for purposes of this subdivision means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
It is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state to have access to information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is the intent of this act to continue the existing balance between the publics right of access to information concerning the conduct of public business and other interests, including the constitutional guarantee of privacy of persons signing initiative, referendum, and recall petitions, which are not public records under Section 7924.110 of the Government Code.
It is the intent of this act to further the interest of petition proponents to examine initiative, referendum, and recall petitions without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to allow for any examination of the petition to proceed and conclude in a timely manner. It is also the intent of this act to further the interest of elections officials to provide support to proponents in the petition examination process without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to avoid any interference with the elections officials ability to complete all statutory and ongoing election support activities in the administration of elections.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding Sections 7920.510, 7920.515, 7920.520, 7920.530, 7920.540, 7920.545, 7922.545, subdivision (a) of Section 7920.525, subdivision (b) of Section 7922.540, and Sections 7922.500 to 7922.535, inclusive, the following are not public records:
(1)A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
(2)A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
(3)A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
(4)A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code.
(5)A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
(b)The materials described in subdivision (a) shall not be open to inspection except by the following persons:
(1)A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
(2)If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), the Attorney General, the Secretary of State, the Fair Political Practices Commission, a district attorney, a city attorney, a school district attorney, and a community college district attorney shall be permitted to examine the materials described in subdivision (a) upon approval of the appropriate superior court.
(d)(1)If the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to subdivision (b), the all of the following shall apply:
(1)The examination shall commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency and shall conclude no later than 60 days from the date that the examination commenced, and the county elections official shall retain the documents as prescribed in Section 17200 of the Elections Code. All costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes.
(2)The elections official may establish reasonable guidelines for the examination and shall provide reasonable resources as necessary for the examination to proceed in a timely manner.
(3)If the examination is not concluded within 5 business days from the date that the examination begins, any costs incurred by the county elections official to continue the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponents. Nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to permit a county elections official to delay or obstruct the examination.
(2)(4)Before an the examination is conducted may continue pursuant to subdivision (b) and at the beginning of each day following, the paragraph (3), the elections official shall estimate the costs necessary to support the examination. A new estimate of costs shall take place at the beginning of each day of examination following the fifth day. The proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum shall deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of necessary to support the examination for that day. The proponent shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Money not required to be refunded shall be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
(3)(5)Cost for purposes of this subdivision means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
It is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state to have access to information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is the intent of this act to continue the existing balance between the publics right of access to information concerning the conduct of public business and other interests, including the constitutional guarantee of privacy of persons signing initiative, referendum, and recall petitions, which are not public records under Section 7924.110 of the Government Code.
It is the intent of this act to further the interest of petition proponents to examine initiative, referendum, and recall petitions without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to allow for any examination of the petition to proceed and conclude in a timely manner. It is also the intent of this act to further the interest of elections officials to provide support to proponents in the petition examination process without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to avoid any interference with the elections officials ability to complete all statutory and ongoing election support activities in the administration of elections.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding Sections 7920.510, 7920.515, 7920.520, 7920.530, 7920.540, 7920.545, 7922.545, subdivision (a) of Section 7920.525, subdivision (b) of Section 7922.540, and Sections 7922.500 to 7922.535, inclusive, the following are not public records:
(1)A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
(2)A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
(3)A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
(4)A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code.
(5)A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
(b)The materials described in subdivision (a) shall not be open to inspection except by the following persons:
(1)A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
(2)If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), the Attorney General, the Secretary of State, the Fair Political Practices Commission, a district attorney, a city attorney, a school district attorney, and a community college district attorney shall be permitted to examine the materials described in subdivision (a) upon approval of the appropriate superior court.
(d)(1)If the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to subdivision (b), the examination shall commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency and shall conclude no later than 60 days from the date that the examination commenced, and the county elections official shall retain the documents as prescribed in Section 17200 of the Elections Code. All costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes.
(2)Before an examination is conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum shall deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The proponent shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Money not required to be refunded shall be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
(3)Cost for purposes of this subdivision means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.SEC. 3.SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
It is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state to have access to information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is the intent of this act to continue the existing balance between the publics right of access to information concerning the conduct of public business and other interests, including the constitutional guarantee of privacy of persons signing initiative, referendum, and recall petitions, which are not public records under Section 7924.110 of the Government Code.
It is the intent of this act to further the interest of petition proponents to examine initiative, referendum, and recall petitions without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to allow for any examination of the petition to proceed and conclude in a timely manner. It is also the intent of this act to further the interest of elections officials to provide support to proponents in the petition examination process without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to avoid any interference with the elections officials ability to complete all statutory and ongoing election support activities in the administration of elections.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
(a)Notwithstanding Sections 7920.510, 7920.515, 7920.520, 7920.530, 7920.540, 7920.545, 7922.545, subdivision (a) of Section 7920.525, subdivision (b) of Section 7922.540, and Sections 7922.500 to 7922.535, inclusive, the following are not public records:
(1)A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
(2)A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
(3)A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
(4)A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code.
(5)A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
(b)The materials described in subdivision (a) shall not be open to inspection except by the following persons:
(1)A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
(2)If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) and (b), the Attorney General, the Secretary of State, the Fair Political Practices Commission, a district attorney, a city attorney, a school district attorney, and a community college district attorney shall be permitted to examine the materials described in subdivision (a) upon approval of the appropriate superior court.
(d)(1)If the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to subdivision (b), the examination shall commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency, insufficiency and shall conclude no later than 60 days from the date that the examination commenced, and the county elections official shall retain the documents as prescribed in Section 17200 of the Elections Code. All costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes.
(2)Before an examination is conducted pursuant to subdivision (b) and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum shall deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The proponent shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Money not required to be refunded shall be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, furthers, within the meaning of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the purposes of that constitutional section as it relates to the right of public access to the meetings of local public bodies or the writings of local public officials and local agencies. Pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b) of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution, the Legislature makes the following findings:
It is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state to have access to information concerning the conduct of the peoples business.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that Section 1 of this act, which amends Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, imposes a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
It is the intent of this act to continue the existing balance between the publics right of access to information concerning the conduct of public business and other interests, including the constitutional guarantee of privacy of persons signing initiative, referendum, and recall petitions, which are not public records under Section 7924.110 of the Government Code.
It is the intent of this act to further the interest of petition proponents to examine initiative, referendum, and recall petitions without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to allow for any examination of the petition to proceed and conclude in a timely manner. It is also the intent of this act to further the interest of elections officials to provide support to proponents in the petition examination process without undue delay or excessive expenditure of time, money, and resources, to avoid any interference with the elections officials ability to complete all statutory and ongoing election support activities in the administration of elections.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 22, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 479, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 22, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 4, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 31. Noes 8. Page 5592.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 26, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 60. Noes 17. Page 6508.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 8, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 7, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 10. Noes 4.) (August 7). |
| Jun 26, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (June 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 11, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on ELECTIONS. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (June 11). Re-referred to Com. on ELECTIONS. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and ELECTIONS. |
| May 22, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 31. Noes 8. Page 4097.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 14, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 13, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1. Page 3631.) (April 16). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 16. |
| Apr 4, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on E. & C.A. (Ayes 9. Noes 2. Page 3449.) (April 2). |
| Mar 20, 2024 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and E. & C.A. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2024 | Unfinished Business SB1441 Allen Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 26, 2024 | SB 1441 Allen Senate Third Reading By Berman | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 7, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections |
Passed |
|
| Jun 11, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Elections] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1441 Allen By Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Elections and Constitutional Amendments] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Association of Clerks and Election Officials | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Support | |
| County Of Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Election Integrity Project | ** Against | |
| Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association | ** Against | |
| Marian M.J. Thompson, former Deputy District Attorney in Los Angeles County | ** Against | |
| Steve Cooley, former District Attorney of Los Angeles County | ** Against |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1441 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1441
Author: Allen (D)
Amended: 8/22/24
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-2, 4/2/24
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Stern, Wahab
NOES: Wilk, Niello
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/16/24
AYES: Blakespear, Allen, Menjivar, Newman, Portantino, Umberg
NOES: Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 31-8, 5/21/24
AYES: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Allen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-17, 8/26/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Examination of petitions: time limitations and reimbursement of costs
SOURCE: County of Los Angeles
DIGEST:
This bill requires a proponent to conclude an examination of an election petition for insufficiency no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced. This bill also requires costs, as defined, incurred by the county elections official past the fifth business day of the examination to be paid by the proponent, as specified.
Assembly Amendments, specify that an elections official may establish reasonable guidelines and provide reasonable resources for the examination to proceed in a timely manner, provides that if the examination is not concluded within 5 business days from date the examination begins then costs incurred by the county to continue the examination are to be reimbursed, and requires an estimate of the costs of examination are to be provided, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Public Records Act (CPRA), that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure. (Gov. Code § 7922.525.)
- Provides that the following are not public records:
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition;
- A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code; and
- A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition. (Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).)
- Provides that materials in 2), above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum; or,
- If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id. at subd. (b).)
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 3) b), above, the examination must commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency. (Id. at subd. (d).)
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day. (Elec. Code § 15624.)
This bill:
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced.
- Authorizes an election official to establish reasonable guidelines for the examination and to provide reasonable resources as necessary to proceed in a timely manners. If the examination is not concluded within five business days from the date it begins, any costs incurred by the county elections official due to continuing the examination are to be reimbursed. “Cost” means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
- Provides that, before an examination may continue, the elections official must estimate the cost to support the examination and provide a new estimate at the beginning of each day of examination following the fifth day.
- Provides that the proponent is required to deposit a sum required by the elections official necessary to support the continuation of the examination, and s proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination.
- Provides that money not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
Comments
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. (Gov. Code § 7922.525-7922.530.) A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code § 7920.530.) Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable. (Gov. Code § 7920.530(a).) The California Supreme Court has held that this is generally understood to include costs like running a copy machine and “conceivably also the expense of the person operating it, but excludes any supplemental tasks associated with the retrieval, inspection, or handling of the record. (National Lawyers Guild v. City of Hayward (2020) 9 Cal.5th 488 at 493.) For copies of records in an electronic format, a requester must also pay the direct duplication costs including, the cost of producing a copy of the record, the cost to construct the record, and the cost of programming and computer services necessary to produce a copy of the record when either: (1) an agency would be required to produce a copy of a record that is produced only at regularly scheduled intervals; or (2) the request would require data compilation, extraction, or programming to produce the record. (Gov. Code § 7922.575.) In 2020, the Court held that the term “extraction” of electronic records does not encompass every process that “might be colloquially described as ‘taking information out’ and cited specific examples of things that could not be charged for such as, searching an e-mail in box or computer’s documents folder or redacting exempt data from otherwise disclosable records. (National Lawyers Guild supra at 506.)
The CPRA expressly provides that certain election petitions are not public records. (Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).) Additionally, they are not open to inspection except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id. at (b).) Existing law provides that the examination of a petition must commence within 21 days of certification of insufficiency, but there is no time prescribed for when the examination must end. (Id. at (d)).
The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352 at 359.) On August 15, 2022 the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the petition to recall DA Gascón, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. (Ibid.) The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures as 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: “Not Registered” (88,464); “Duplicate” (43,593); “Different Address” (32,187); “Mismatch Signature” (9,490); “Canceled” (7,344); “Out of County Address” (5,374); and “Other” (9,331). (Ibid at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with “no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room.” (Id. at 360.)
The proponents were provided several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: “(1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; (2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and (3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures.” (Ibid. at fn. 3.) The Registrar also provided “a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated.” (Ibid. at fn. 4). The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, including “training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address. (Ibid.) The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. (Id. at 360-61.) Proponents also sought an order to allow 25 representatives of the proponents to be able to participate in the examination five days a week, access to computer stations for each representative, and the ability to use their own devices. (Ibid.)
The trial court issued several orders that, among other things, (1) authorized the proponents and their representatives to use electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room subject to a protective order, and (2) ordered disclosure of current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures to proponents. (Id. at 374.) The Registrar appealed the trial court’s decision on multiple grounds, including that the use of electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room and access to current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures would violate confidentiality statutes and was outside the scope of Section 7924.110 of the Government Code. The Appeals Court ultimately agreed with the Registrar regarding the disclosure issue, dismissed other issues raised on appeal by the Registrar on procedural grounds, and remanded the case back to the trial court on certain outstanding issues that remained in the case.
The Appeals Court pointed to the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy as the main reason for its finding on the disclosure issues stating: (Id. at 376):
In view of the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy, however, it is unlikely the Legislature intended to broaden a petition examination by permitting the proponent to copy petition and memoranda data for use beyond the control of county election officials. In Bilofsky v. Deukmejian (1981) 124 Cal.App.3d 825, 831, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621 (Bilofsky), this court narrowly construed a provision in the Elections Code to prohibit any circulator of a petition (initiative, referendum, or recall) from using the list of signatures “‘for any purpose other than qualification of the ... question for the ballot.’” (Id. at pp. 827-828, fn. 1, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621, quoting former Elec. Code, § 2770.) Guided by “the California constitutional guarantee of privacy by insuring the least interference with that right of persons signing ... recall petitions,” we narrowly construed the provision as “designed in order to protect the signer from any use of his identity other than that integral to the [petition] process.” (Id. at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621; see Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.)
We agree with the Registrar that the same privacy concerns exist for voters who participate in recall petitions. (See [Government Code] §§ 7924.000, subds. (a)-(c).) Use of voter information in this case outside the Registrar's walls would undoubtedly give the Committee greater control over how they use the information. In turn, this level of control could expedite its petition examination. But the Committee already has access to this information for use inside the examination room. And as a practical matter, we are mindful of the risks of unlawful dissemination of voter data in this case, even if that risk is mitigated by a protective order.[] Under these circumstances, we do not believe that use of electronic voter data outside the Registrar's walls is “integral” to the Committee's petition examination. (Bilofsky, supra, at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621.)
The Appeals Court also concluded that Section 7924.110 of the Government Code “does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case.” (Ibid.)
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The Court of Appeal decision does not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case. The petition examination ultimately concluded because the trial court ordered the examination to conclude by November 21, 2023, which was 14 months after the petition review commenced. The County fears that had the trial court not issued this order the review could still be ongoing today. According to the County, plaintiffs in the litigation demanded increased staffing and resources be allocated during the petition examination effort, which the County did provide at a significant cost. The County believes that these extra costs should have been borne by the proponents instead of being ultimately absorbed by the County.
In light of the above described situation, this bill seeks to provide a specific time frame in which an examination must be completed—60 days from the commencement of the examination. The sponsors of the bill state that the 60 day time frame was chosen because it is the same amount of time in which a county must examine the signatures of a petition to determine if it is sufficient (i.e. verify the signatures). (see Elec. Code § 9031.) The bill also requires that costs incurred by the county elections official as a result of the examination continuing beyond five business days be reimbursed by the proponent. Under the bill an estimate of the cost is to be provided to the proponent of the petition and the proponent will be required to deposit with the elections official that sum before an examination is continued past the fifth business day and at the beginning of each subsequent day. The author and sponsor of the bill point to the fact that a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount is required to cover the costs of the recount as to why the costs to examine insufficient petitions should be passed on to the petitioner. (see Elec. Code § 15624.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, “No significant state costs. Possible cost savings to county elections officials to the extent they are reimbursed for future petition examinations under the bill, rather than bearing examination costs under existing law.”
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/23/24)
County of Los Angeles (source)
California Association of Clerks and Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/23/24)
Steve Cooley, former District Attorney of Los Angeles County
Election Integrity Project
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
3 individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review. SB 1441 establishes a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures and authorizes a county to recover costs for resources expended accommodating the proponent’s access to election records.
The County of Los Angeles, the sponsor of the bill, writes in support stating:
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, Ch. 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. County elections officials have a duty to ensure elections are conducted in a fairly, transparently, and lawfully, which is true of all aspects of the election process. It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county’s costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
SB 1441 creates a finite period – 60 days – for the proponents to examine a failed petition and establishes a mechanism for county elections officials to recover the costs associated with the personnel and resources associated with those examinations. In this way, county elections officials throughout the state can better determine the impact petition reviews have on their operations and allocate resources accordingly. It’s important to note that requiring proponents to reimburse the county for the costs of conducting this review aligns with provisions currently found in Elections Code section 15624 for cost recovery of voter-initiated recount efforts.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Election Integrity Project (EIPCa) writes in opposition stating:
In reality, the length of time and the resources consumed during that petition signature review were the direct and sole result of the L.A. Registrar’s denial of the people’s statutory rights. If the citizen oversight process had been facilitated in good faith, as mandated in current law, results of the public inquiry would have been accomplished in a reasonable amount of time and with reasonable expense. SB 1441 is a clear effort to subvert Direct Democracy in California using a spurious argument.
Former District Attorney of Los Angeles County, Steve Cooley and former Deputy District Attorney in Los Angeles County, Marian M.J. Thompson—both of whom were involved in the recall effort of DA Gascón— write in opposition stating they are concerned that the bill will impact “direct democracy and the constitutional right of voters to recall their elective officers.” They are majorly concerned with the 60-day time constraint, especially without any requirements on what kind of access should be given to proponents during an examination. They point to their own experience described above and believe that the Registrar did not provide them adequate access or time for examination.
Additionally they are concerned with shifting the cost of examination to proponents stating:
In summary, while SB 1441 purports to streamline the process, proponents legitimately worry about the potential impact on their ability to participate in the democratic process if this bill passes. The ability of proponents to participate in the petition review process really functions as a fundamental check on an otherwise secretive government review process relating to electing our leaders. Moreover, the bill’s provisions not only affect larger petitions that may not be adequately funded, but also disproportionately affects smaller initiatives and grassroots efforts.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-17, 8/26/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Ortega
Click here to enter text.
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/27/24 12:11:25
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1441
Author:(Allen)
As Amended Ver:August 22, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and are not a financial burden to county election offices.
Major Provisions
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced.
- Provides that if the examination is not concluded within 5 business days from the date that the examination begins, any costs incurred by the county elections official to continue the examination shall be reimbursed by the proponents. Nothing in this paragraph shall be construed to permit a county elections official to delay or obstruct the examination.
- Requires, before an examination may continue after five business days and at the beginning of each day following, the local elections official to estimate the costs necessary to support the examination before the examination may continue. A new estimate of costs shall take place at the beginning of each day of examination following the fifth day.
- Requires the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official necessary to support the examination for that day.
- Provides that the proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination.
- Provides that funds not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
- Provides that the elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
- Allows elections officials to establish reasonable guidelines for the examination and shall provide reasonable resources as necessary for the examination to proceed in a timely manner.
- Defines "cost" to mean any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
- Makes findings to justify the bill's restriction on access to records related to a petition.
COMMENTS
This bill, sponsored by the County of Los Angeles, revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and are not a financial burden to county election offices.
A recall petition in Los Angeles County—and its aftermath-- is the genesis for this bill. The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more signatures than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352, 359.) But on August 15, 2022, the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the recall petition, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. (Ibid.) The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures was 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: "Not Registered" (88,464); "Duplicate" (43,593); "Different Address" (32,187); "Mismatch Signature" (9,490); "Canceled" (7,344); "Out of County Address" (5,374); and "Other" (9,331). (Ibid., at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with "no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room." (Id. at p. 360.)
The proponents were provided with several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: "1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; 2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and 3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures." (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon, supra, at p. 360, fn. 3.) The Registrar also provided "a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated." (Ibid., at fn. 4). The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, including "training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address." (Ibid.) The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. (Id. at pp. 360-61.) The Appeals Court agreed with the county, finding that Section 7924.110 of the Government Code "does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case." (Ibid.) The Court of Appeal decision did not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case.
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. According to the County, plaintiffs in the litigation demanded increased staffing and resources. The County believes that these extra costs should have been borne by the proponents instead of being absorbed by the County.
The bill seeks to provide a specific period in which an examination must be completed—60 days from the commencement of the examination. The author and sponsor argue that the 60 day time frame was chosen because it is the same amount of time in which a county must examine the signatures of a petition to determine whether it is sufficient (i.e. verify the signatures). (Elections Code Section 9031.) The bill also requires that costs incurred by the county elections official as a result of the examination must be reimbursed to the county by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. Under the bill, before an examination is conducted, and at the beginning of each subsequent day, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition is required to deposit with the elections official a sum as determined by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The author and sponsor of the bill point to the fact that a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount is required to cover the costs of the recount as to why the costs to examine insufficient petitions should be passed on to the petitioner. (See Elections Code Section 15624.)
According to the Author
SB 1441 establishes clear timelines and processes for review of petitions to ensure petition proponents do not abuse the review process while also preserving a critical transparency tool. The bill would institute a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition's signatures, and authorizes a county to recover costs for the additional resources expended in accommodating the proponent's access to election records. These proposed guardrails are consistent with timelines that exist for counties to verify petition signatures and cost recovery models for voter-initiated recounts, ensuring that all parties utilize resources efficiently.
Arguments in Support
Sponsor County of Los Angeles writes the following to explain the need for the bill:
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter's Choice Act (SB 450, chapter 832, Statutes of 2016). . . . It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county's costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
Arguments in Opposition
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association writes the following to explain its opposition to the bill:
The bill eviscerates a critically important tool for voters to ensure accurate verification of signatures on recall, initiative, and referendum petitions. It does this by placing a 60-day limit on the proponents' review of rejected signatures and the reason for that rejection, and by adding a new requirement for proponents to pay the costs of the review, which could run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
SB 1441 requires proponents to deposit a sum covering the daily cost determined by the elections official before the examination even commences, and daily thereafter, with any costs above those amounts paid in full within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. This bars all but the wealthiest Californians and well-funded special interest groups from verifying the accuracy of a county's determination that insufficient signatures were submitted to qualify a measure for the ballot.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, no significant state costs. Possible cost savings to county elections officials to the extent they are reimbursed for future petition examinations under the bill, rather than bearing examination costs under existing law.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 31-8-1
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Reyes
NO: Dixon, Joe Patterson, Sanchez
ASM ELECTIONS: 6-2-0
YES: Pellerin, Bennett, Berman, Cervantes, Low, Weber
NO: Lackey, Essayli
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 10-4-1
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
ABS, ABST OR NV: Villapudua
UPDATED
VERSION: August 22, 2024
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004320
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1441
Author:(Allen)
As Amended Ver:April 4, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and are not a financial burden to county election offices.
Major Provisions
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced.
- Requires that all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination to be reimbursed to the officials by the proponents within 30 days from the date the examination concludes.
- Requires, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day.
- Provides that the proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination.
- Provides that funds not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
- Provides that the elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
- Defines "cost" to mean any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
- Makes findings to justify the bill's restriction on access to records related to a petition.
COMMENTS
This bill, sponsored by the County of Los Angeles, revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and are not a financial burden to county election offices.
A recall petition in Los Angeles County—and its aftermath-- is the genesis for this bill. The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more signatures than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352, 359.) But on August 15, 2022, the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the recall petition, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. (Ibid.) The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures was 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: "Not Registered" (88,464); "Duplicate" (43,593); "Different Address" (32,187); "Mismatch Signature" (9,490); "Canceled" (7,344); "Out of County Address" (5,374); and "Other" (9,331). (Ibid., at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with "no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room." (Id. at p. 360.)
The proponents were provided with several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: "1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; 2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and 3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures." (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon, supra, at p. 360, fn. 3.) The Registrar also provided "a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated." (Ibid., at fn. 4). The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, including "training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address." (Ibid.) The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. (Id. at pp. 360-61.) The Appeals Court agreed with the county, finding that Section 7924.110 of the Government Code "does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case." (Ibid.) The Court of Appeal decision did not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case.
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. According to the County, plaintiffs in the litigation demanded increased staffing and resources be allocated during the petition examination effort, which the County did provide at a significant cost. The County believes that these extra costs should have been borne by the proponents instead of being absorbed by the County.
The bill seeks to provide a specific period in which an examination must be completed—60 days from the commencement of the examination. The author and sponsor argue that the 60 day time frame was chosen because it is the same amount of time in which a county must examine the signatures of a petition to determine whether it is sufficient (i.e. verify the signatures). (Elections Code Section 9031.) The bill also requires that costs incurred by the county elections official as a result of the examination must be reimbursed to the county by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. Under the bill, before an examination is conducted, and at the beginning of each subsequent day, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition is required to deposit with the elections official a sum as determined by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The author and sponsor of the bill point to the fact that a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount is required to cover the costs of the recount as to why the costs to examine insufficient petitions should be passed on to the petitioner. (See Elections Code Section 15624.)
According to the Author
SB 1441 establishes clear timelines and processes for review of petitions to ensure petition proponents do not abuse the review process while also preserving a critical transparency tool. The bill would institute a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition's signatures, and authorizes a county to recover costs for the additional resources expended in accommodating the proponent's access to election records. These proposed guardrails are consistent with timelines that exist for counties to verify petition signatures and cost recovery models for voter-initiated recounts, ensuring that all parties utilize resources efficiently.
Arguments in Support
Sponsor County of Los Angeles writes the following to explain the need for the bill:
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter's Choice Act (SB 450, chapter 832, Statutes of 2016). . . . It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county's costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
Arguments in Opposition
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association writes the following to explain its opposition to the bill:
The bill eviscerates a critically important tool for voters to ensure accurate verification of signatures on recall, initiative, and referendum petitions. It does this by placing a 60-day limit on the proponents' review of rejected signatures and the reason for that rejection, and by adding a new requirement for proponents to pay the costs of the review, which could run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
SB 1441 requires proponents to deposit a sum covering the daily cost determined by the elections official before the examination even commences, and daily thereafter, with any costs above those amounts paid in full within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. This bars all but the wealthiest Californians and well-funded special interest groups from verifying the accuracy of a county's determination that insufficient signatures were submitted to qualify a measure for the ballot.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, no significant state costs. Possible cost savings to county elections officials to the extent they are reimbursed for future petition examinations under the bill, rather than bearing examination costs under existing law.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 31-8-1
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Reyes
NO: Dixon, Joe Patterson, Sanchez
ASM ELECTIONS: 6-2-0
YES: Pellerin, Bennett, Berman, Cervantes, Low, Weber
NO: Lackey, Essayli
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 10-4-1
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
ABS, ABST OR NV: Villapudua
UPDATED
VERSION: April 4, 2024
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003787
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1441
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2024
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 3 |
Elections | 6 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes a timeline for examination of an election petition that failed due to insufficient signatures and requires a proponent who conducts such an examination to reimburse county officials for costs incurred in the examination.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, when the proponent of a petition that failed due to insufficient signatures is permitted to examine the petition, the proponent to conclude their examination of the petition no later than 60 days from when the examination began.
- Requires a proponent who conducts such an examination to, within 30 days of the conclusion of the examination, reimburse the county elections official for all costs incurred due to the examination.
- Requires a proponent of a petition who requests to examine a failed petition to provide the county elections official with a deposit, and establishes procedures for return of the deposit.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No significant state costs. Possible cost savings to county elections officials to the extent they are reimbursed for future petition examinations under the bill, rather than bearing examination costs under existing law.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the County of Los Angeles. According to the author:
When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review.
- Background. Under the California Public Records Act, election petitions are not deemed public records that are subject to disclosure to or inspection by members of the public. This includes any statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition, and a memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition indicating which registered voters signed the petition. However, these petitions are open to inspection by certain public officials. Additionally, if a county election official deems a petition insufficient, the proponent of the petition may examine the petition and related memoranda prepared by the county elections official to determine which signatures were disqualified and why.
Existing law requires a petition proponent to begin their examination of the petition within 21 days of when the petition is certified as insufficient, but the law is silent about how long the proponent’s examination may be. This bill requires a petition proponent to complete their examination within 60 days, and requires the proponent to pay for any costs incurred by county elections officials as a result of the examination.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 26, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
Gail Pellerin, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1441
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 31-8
SUBJECT: Examination of petitions: time limitations and reimbursement of costs.
SUMMARY: Requires proponents of a petition that failed due to insufficient signatures to conclude their examination of the petition’s insufficiency within 60 days, as specified. Requires all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination to be paid by the petition proponents, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a proponent of a petition who is permitted to examine a petition that failed due to insufficient signatures to conclude their examination of insufficiency no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced.
- Requires all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination to be reimbursed by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes.
- Requires a proponent of a petition who requests to examine a failed petition and the memorandum of the reasons for the signature rejections, before the examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, to deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. Requires the proponent to be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination, and requires money not required to be refunded to be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. Provides that an elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
- Defines the term “cost” for the purposes of this bill to mean any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
- Makes various findings and declarations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies are required to be open to public scrutiny. (California Constitution Article I, §3(b)(1))
- Requires a statute to be broadly construed if it furthers the people’s right of access, and narrowly construed if it limits the right of access. (California Constitution Article I, §3(b)(1))
- Requires a statute that limits the public’s right of access to be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest. (California Constitution Article I §3(b)(1))
- Governs the disclosure of information collected and maintained by public agencies pursuant to the California Public Records Act (CPRA). (Government Code §§7920.000 et seq.)
- States that the Legislature, mindful of the right of individuals to privacy, finds and declares that access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Government Code §7921.000)
- Defines “public records” to mean any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Government Code §7920.530)
- Defines “public agency” to mean any state or local agency. (Government Code §7920.525(a))
- Requires all public records to be accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure, as specified. (Government Code §7922.525)
- Provides that some records are prohibited from being disclosed and other records are permissively exempted from being disclosed. (Government Code §§7920.505 & 7922.200)
- Provides, among others, that the following are not public records:
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition;
- A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to the Education Code;
- A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition. (Government Code §7924.110(a))
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition;
- Provides that materials in 10) above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum; or,
- If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Government Code §7924.110 (b))
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum; or,
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 10) (e) above, the examination must commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency. (Government Code §7924.110 (d))
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day. Requires the money deposited to be returned to the depositor if, upon completion of the recount, the results of the recount show a different outcome, as specified. (Elections Code §15624.)
- Requires a recount to be conducted publicly. (Elections Code §15629)
- Requires the Secretary of State, if the random statistical sampling of the number of qualified voters who signed a petition shows that the number of valid signatures is within 95 to 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to declare the state petition sufficient, to order the examination and verification of the signatures filed. This process is referred to as a “full check.” Requires an elections official, within 60 working days after receipt of the order, to determine what number of qualified voters have signed the state petition. (Elections Code §9031(a)-(b))
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review. SB 1441 establishes a reasonable 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures and authorizes a county to recover costs for the additional resources expended accommodating the proponent’s access to election records.
- California Public Records Act and Petitions: Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable. As an exception to the general rule, the CPRA expressly provides that certain records related to election petitions are not public records. For example, current law specifies that a statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition is not a public record. Additionally, the CPRA provides that those same election petition records are not open to inspection, except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons for the rejections. The CPRA provides that an examination of petition records by a petitioner must commence within 21 days of their certification of insufficiency. However, existing law does not specify when such an examination must be completed.
This bill specifies that the petition proponent’s examination of the failed petition and the reasons for the signature rejections must conclude within 60 days. - Los Angeles County Local Recall: According to the author and sponsor, the need for this bill is due to a petition review that occurred in Los Angeles County that resulted in litigation with recall proponents from a failed recall petition effort to recall Los Angeles County’s District Attorney, George Gascón. In 2022, the Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more signatures than required to trigger a recall election. The Los Angeles County elections official later concluded that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed for the recall petition to qualify for the November 2022 general election ballot because 195,783 signatures were rejected.
According to the author and sponsor, due to the ongoing litigation the petition review lasted 14 months, costing the county approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The author and sponsor contend that because there currently is no time limit for the petition review process to conclude, petition proponents can exploit this access to public resources through indefinite reviews, creating uncertainty for election officials in how to allocate resources at significant taxpayer expense.
Despite the petition review incident that occurred in Los Angeles County, the author and sponsor have not provided the committee with other examples demonstrating that similar incidents are occurring in other parts of the state. - New Reimbursement Requirement: This bill requires costs incurred by a county elections official for a petition proponent’s review of a petition that failed to qualify to be reimbursed by the proponent. Additionally, this bill requires a petition proponent to deposit a sum of money determined by the elections officials before the examination may begin, and each day after in which the examination continues.
According to the author and sponsor, most petition reviews conclude within two to three days, while others may require one to two weeks. However, because current law does not specify a time limit for the petition review process to conclude and even though not all petition reviews incur costs, the cost recovery mechanism in this bill will ensure that the petition examination proceeds in an efficient manner, without undue delay and excessive expenditure of time and resources. Additionally, this bill would only allow for cost recovery of expenses in excess of and in addition to general ongoing operational expenses of the election official.
The author and sponsor note that there is precedent in existing law for elections officials to recover costs associated with a review of elections-related materials that is requested by a member of the public. Specifically, existing law requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount to cover the costs of the recount, and requires, before a recount may begin, a requester to provide money requested by the county elections official to pay for the cost of the first day’s recount work, as specified.
On the other hand, there are notable differences between a voter-requested recount and a proponent-requested review of a failed petition. Notably, the counting of votes as part of the official canvass is a process that is required to be open to the public. Accordingly, when a voter requests a recount, that request requires that public resources be used to conduct a secondary review of ballots that were counted as part of a process that was already open for public observation. By contrast, the verification of signatures on petitions is not required by law to be open for public observation. As a result, a proponent-requested review of a failed petition may provide an opportunity for external scrutiny of a process that was not otherwise subject to public observation.
Furthermore, state law governing recounts provides for the requester to be refunded the cost of the recount if it changes the outcome of the election in a specified manner. Unlike a recount, however, an examination of a failed petition by the proponents does not have the ability to alter the original determinations made by the elections official that the petition failed to qualify. The only remedy a proponent has if they believe mistakes occurred during the petition signature review process is to file a lawsuit in court. As a result, a review of a failed petition by the proponents serves a different purpose than a recount.
Because the recount process is fundamentally different than the process for allowing a petition proponent to examine a failed petition, the committee may wish to consider whether requiring the proponents to pay the costs of that review is appropriate.
- Arguments in Support: The sponsor of this bill, the County of Los Angeles, writes:
The law is silent regarding the amount of time proponents can take to review failed petitions, and protracted reviews, although rare, are costly. Government Code section 7924.110 states that a petition proponent has up to 21 days after certification of insufficiency to commence an examination of disqualified petition signatures. However, the statute does not provide proponents of a failed petition with a time limit for their review of the insufficient signatures. Also, the law is silent about cost recovery by the county for staff time and other public resources utilized during the examination process.
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, ch. 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. County elections officials have a duty to ensure elections are conducted in a fairly, transparently, and lawfully, which is true of all aspects of the election process. It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county’s costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
SB 1441 creates a finite period – 60 days – for the proponents to examine a failed petition and establishes a mechanism for county elections officials to recover the costs associated with the personnel and resources associated with those examinations. In this way, county elections officials throughout the state can better determine the impact petition reviews have on their operations and allocate resources accordingly. It’s important to note that requiring proponents to reimburse the county for the costs of conducting this review aligns with provisions currently found in Elections Code section 15624 for cost recovery of voter-initiated recount efforts.
- Arguments in Opposition: In opposition to this bill, former District Attorney of Los Angeles County Steve Cooley, writes:
In July 2022, I became intensely involved in a review of an effort to validate the work by the Los Angeles County Registrar of Voters [] related to the examination of a petition to recall District Attorney George Gascón under Elections Code section 11301 and Government Code section 7924.110. …[We] felt that it was very important to bring to your attention our deep concerns about and opposition to SB 1441 in its current form to preserve direct democracy and the constitutional right of voters to recall their elective officers, and/or to fully participate in the initiative and referendum process…
Here are some of the major concerns that we have about Senate Bill 1441:
1. Time Constraints: The bill mandates that the examination of a petition must conclude within 60 days after it commences. For proponents, this tight timeline may limit their ability to thoroughly review and address any issues with the petition. This is especially true for large petitions, such as the Recall Petition. It took the Committee, consisting entirely of volunteers, 13 months (with limited access by the Registrar) to review only half of the 195,758 rejected signatures.
Despite creating a statutory limit on the length of a petition review, the bill doesn’t place any requirements at all and the kind of access election officials must provide during that review process…
2. Cost Reimbursement: Proponents whose petitions are found to be insufficient must reimburse all costs incurred by the county election official due to the examination. While public accountability of election officials is essential, this financial burden could disproportionately affect grassroots campaigns or individuals with limited resources. This is particularly so because fundraising efforts almost always dry up after a failed petition. This was the experience of the Committee…
Proponents may find it challenging to cover these costs promptly.
Undue restrictions on the review process such as this could potentially feed a public perception that election officials are trying to escape accountability for their errors, or even their malfeasance, by essentially taking away the ability for proponents to participate in the examination process through the cost prohibitions of this bill.
3. Deposit Requirement: Before an examination begins and at the start of each subsequent day, the proponent requesting to examine a petition must deposit a sum with the election official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. This upfront deposit requirement adds an additional financial hurdle for proponents. It may also discourage some individuals from pursuing petitions, especially if they lack the necessary funds. The Committee could not have met this daily deposit requirement.
4. Lack of Reimbursement: Although the California Constitution generally requires the state to reimburse local agencies for certain mandated costs, SB 1441 specifies that no reimbursement is required for a specified reason. This bill places the entire financial burden of the petition process upon proponents, and threatens the ability of the People to participate in a functioning democracy.
- Previous Legislation: SB 386 (Newman), Chapter 870, Statutes of 2023, extends the signature verification period for an elections official to complete a full check of the number of qualified voters that have signed a state initiative, referendum, or recall petition from 30 working days to 60 working days, among other provisions.
- Double Referral: This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee, where it was heard on June 11, 2024, and approved by a 9-3 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
County of Los Angeles (Sponsor)
California Association of Clerks and Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
Opposition
Election Integrity Project California, Inc. (unless amended)
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
Two Individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Becker / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094
Date of Hearing: June 11, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1441
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 31-8
SUBJECT: EXAMINATION OF PETITIONS: TIME LIMITATIONS AND REIMBURSEMENT OF COSTS
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE LAW REQUIRE THAT (1) A COUNTY’S EXAMINATION OF AN ELECTION PETITION FOR INSUFFICIENCY BE COMPLETED NO LATER THAN 60 DAYS FROM THE DATE WHEN THE EXAMINATION IS COMMENCED; AND (2) ALL COSTS INCURRED BY THE COUNTY ELECTIONS OFFICIAL DUE TO THE EXAMINATION MUST BE PAID BY THE PROPONENT OF THE EXAMINATION?
SYNOPSIS
As an exception to the general rule of the California Public Records Act (CPRA) that all records in the possession of a public agency are open to public inspection, certain records related to election petitions are not public. For example, current law specifies that a statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition is not a public record. Additionally, the CPRA provides that those same election petition records are not open to inspection, except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. The CPRA provides that an examination of a petition records by a petitioner must commence within 21 days of their certification of insufficiency, but does not specify when such an examination must be completed.
A recall petition in Los Angeles County—and its aftermath-- is the genesis for this bill. The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more signatures than required to trigger a recall election, but county election officials later concluded that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot because 195,783 signatures were rejected. Over the next 14+ months, county elections staff facilitated the process of reviewing the basis for the county’s determination. According to the County, the petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election.
This bill, sponsored by the County of Los Angeles, revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and that they are not a financial burden to county election offices. Specifically, it requires that an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced. It also requires a petitioner to pay the costs of a petition review. It is supported by counties and election officials and opposed by the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association and Election Integrity Project California. Should the bill pass this Committee, it would be referred next to the Assembly Elections Committee.
SUMMARY: Revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and that they are not a financial burden to county election offices. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced.
- Requires that all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination to be reimbursed to the officials by the proponents within 30 days from the date the examination concludes.
- Requires, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day.
- Provides that the proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination.
- Provides that funds not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
- Provides that the elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
- Defines “cost” to mean any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
- Makes findings to justify the bill’s restriction on access to records related to a petition.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure. (Government Code Section 7922.525. All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Prohibits some records from being disclosed and other records are permissively exempted from being disclosed. (See e.g. Sections 7920.505, 7922.200.)
- Specifies that several general categories of documents or information that are permissively exempt from disclosure under the CPRA essentially due to the character of the information. The exempt information can be withheld by the public agency with custody of the information, but it also may be disclosed if it is shown that the public’s interest in disclosure outweighs the public’s interest in non-disclosure of the information. (CBS, Inc. v. Block (1986) 42 Cal.3d 646, at 652.).
- Provides that the following are not public records:
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition;
- A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code.
- A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition. (Section 7924.110 (a).)
- Provides that materials in 2), above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum; or
- In the event that a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id., at (b).)
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 3b), above, the examination must commence no later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency. (Id., at (d).)
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day. (Elections Code Section 15624.)
- Provides that the money deposited must be returned to the depositor if, upon completion of the recount, the candidate, slate of presidential electors, or the position on the measure (affirmative or negative) for which the declaration is filed is found to have received the plurality of votes cast which it had not received according to the official canvass or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount results in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff election or general election who would not have so appeared in the absence of the recount. (Ibid.)
- Provides that the depositor shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the recount if the candidate, slate, or position on the measure has not received the plurality of the votes cast or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount does not result in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff or general election as a result of the recount. (Ibid.)
- Provides that, if the random sampling of the number of qualified voters who signed a petition shows that the number of valid signatures is within 95 to 110 percent of the requisite number of qualified voters, the Secretary of State must order the examination and verification of the signatures filed, and within 60 days of this order, as specified, the elections official must determine the number of qualified voters who signed the petition. (Elections Code Section 9031 (a), (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, sponsored by the County of Los Angeles, revises rules relating to the process for a county to examine an election petition for insufficiency to help ensure that examinations are completed in a timely manner and that they are not a financial burden to county election offices. According to the author:
SB 1441 establishes clear timelines and processes for review of petitions to ensure petition proponents do not abuse the review process while also preserving a critical transparency tool. The bill would institute a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures, and authorizes a county to recover costs for the additional resources expended in accommodating the proponent’s access to election records. These proposed guardrails are consistent with timelines that exist for counties to verify petition signatures and cost recovery models for voter-initiated recounts, ensuring that all parties utilize resources efficiently.
Records in the possession of a public agency presumptively are open to the public for examination and copying, but there are exceptions to the rule. Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. (Sections 7922.525-7922.530.) A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Section 7920.530.) Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable. (Section 7920.530 (a).) The California Supreme Court has held that this is generally understood to include costs like running a copy machine and “conceivably also the expense of the person operating it, but excludes any supplemental tasks associated with the retrieval, inspection, or handling of the record. (National Lawyers Guild v. City of Hayward (2020) 9 Cal.5th 488, 493.) For copies of records in an electronic format, a requester must also pay the direct duplication costs including, the cost of producing a copy of the record, the cost to construct the record, and the cost of programming and computer services necessary to produce a copy of the record when either: (1) an agency would be required to produce a copy of a record that is produced only at regularly scheduled intervals; or (2) the request would require data compilation, extraction, or programming to produce the record. (Section 7922.575.) In 2020, the Court held that the term “extraction” of electronic records does not encompass every process that “might be colloquially described as ‘taking information out’ and cited specific examples of things that could not be charged for such as, searching an e-mail in box or computer’s documents folder or redacting exempt data from otherwise disclosable records.” (National Lawyers Guild, supra, at p. 506.)
As an exception to the general rule, the CPRA expressly provides that certain records related to election petitions are not public records. (Section 7924.110 (a).) For example, current law specifies that a statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition is not a public record. (Ibid.) Additionally, the CPRA provides that those same election petition records are not open to inspection, except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id., at (b).) The CPRA provides that an examination of a petition records by a petitioner must commence within 21 days of their certification of insufficiency, but does not specify when such an examination must be completed. (Id., at (d).)
A recall petition in Los Angeles County—and its aftermath-- is the genesis for this bill. The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more signatures than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352, 359.) But on August 15, 2022, the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the recall petition, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. (Ibid.) The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures was 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: “Not Registered” (88,464); “Duplicate” (43,593); “Different Address” (32,187); “Mismatch Signature” (9,490); “Canceled” (7,344); “Out of County Address” (5,374); and “Other” (9,331). (Ibid., at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with “no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room.” (Id. at p. 360.)
The proponents were provided with several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: “(1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; (2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and (3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures.” (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon, supra, at p. 360, fn. 3.) The Registrar also provided “a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated.” (Ibid., at fn. 4). The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, including “training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address.” (Ibid.) The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. (Id. at pp. 360-61.) Proponents also sought an order to allow 25 representatives of the proponents to be able to participate in the examination five days a week, access to computer stations for each representative, and the ability to use their own devices. (Ibid.)
The trial court issued several orders that, among other things, (1) authorized the proponents and their representatives to use electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room subject to a protective order, and (2) ordered disclosure of current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures to proponents. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon, supra, at p. 374.) The Registrar appealed the trial court’s decision on multiple grounds, including that the use of electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room and access to current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures would violate confidentiality statutes and was outside the scope of Section 7924.110 of the Government Code. The Appeals Court ultimately agreed with the Registrar regarding the disclosure issue, dismissed other issues raised on appeal by the Registrar on procedural grounds, and remanded the case back to the trial court on certain outstanding issues that remained in the case.
The Appeals Court pointed to the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy as the main reason for its finding on the disclosure issues stating:
In view of the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy, however, it is unlikely the Legislature intended to broaden a petition examination by permitting the proponent to copy petition and memoranda data for use beyond the control of county election officials. In Bilofsky v. Deukmejian (1981) 124 Cal.App.3d 825, 831, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621 (Bilofsky), this court narrowly construed a provision in the Elections Code to prohibit any circulator of a petition (initiative, referendum, or recall) from using the list of signatures “‘for any purpose other than qualification of the ... question for the ballot.’” (Id. at pp. 827-828, fn. 1, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621, quoting former Elec. Code, § 2770.) Guided by “the California constitutional guarantee of privacy by insuring the least interference with that right of persons signing ... recall petitions,” we narrowly construed the provision as “designed in order to protect the signer from any use of his identity other than that integral to the [petition] process.” (Id. at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621; see Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.)
We agree with the Registrar that the same privacy concerns exist for voters who participate in recall petitions. (See [Government Code] §§ 7924.000, subds. (a)-(c).) Use of voter information in this case outside the Registrar's walls would undoubtedly give the Committee greater control over how they use the information. In turn, this level of control could expedite its petition examination. But the Committee already has access to this information for use inside the examination room. And as a practical matter, we are mindful of the risks of unlawful dissemination of voter data in this case, even if that risk is mitigated by a protective order.[] Under these circumstances, we do not believe that use of electronic voter data outside the Registrar's walls is “integral” to the Committee's petition examination. (Bilofsky, supra, at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621.) (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon, supra, at p. 376.)
The Appeals Court also concluded that Section 7924.110 of the Government Code “does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case.” (Ibid.)
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The Court of Appeal decision does not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case. The County fears that had the trial court not issued this order the review could still be ongoing today. According to the County, plaintiffs in the litigation demanded increased staffing and resources be allocated during the petition examination effort, which the County did provide at a significant cost. The County believes that these extra costs should have been borne by the proponents instead of being absorbed by the County.
The bill seeks to provide a specific time frame in which an examination must be completed—60 days from the commencement of the examination. The author and sponsor argue that the 60 day time frame was chosen because it is the same amount of time in which a county must examine the signatures of a petition to determine whether it is sufficient (i.e. verify the signatures). (Elections Code Section 9031.) The bill also requires that costs incurred by the county elections official as a result of the examination must be reimbursed to the county by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. Under the bill, before an examination is conducted, and at the beginning of each subsequent day, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition is required to deposit with the elections official a sum as determined by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The author and sponsor of the bill point to the fact that a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount is required to cover the costs of the recount as to why the costs to examine insufficient petitions should be passed on to the petitioner. (See Elections Code Section 15624.)
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Sponsor County of Los Angeles writes the following to explain the need for the bill:
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, ch. 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. County elections officials have a duty to ensure elections are conducted in a fairly, transparently, and lawfully, which is true of all aspects of the election process. It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county’s costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
. . .
In an effort to ensure that elections officials remain able to conduct their work and allocate resources to the benefit of the people they serve, SB 1441 offers some modest but impactful opportunities that will modernize the local elections process.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association writes the following to explain its opposition to the bill:
The bill eviscerates a critically important tool for voters to ensure accurate verification of signatures on recall, initiative, and referendum petitions. It does this by placing a 60-day limit on the proponents’ review of rejected signatures and the reason for that rejection, and by adding a new requirement for proponents to pay the costs of the review, which could run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
SB 1441 requires proponents to deposit a sum covering the daily cost determined by the elections official before the examination even commences, and daily thereafter, with any costs above those amounts paid in full within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. This bars all but the wealthiest Californians and well-funded special interest groups from verifying the accuracy of a county’s determination that insufficient signatures were submitted to qualify a measure for the ballot.
Further, this bill contains no check on a county’s power to limit access to the resources needed to conduct a complete examination of rejected signatures and the reasons for the rejection. What in this bill prevents a county from completely evading review of invalidated signatures by providing inadequate access or simply setting excessively high fees?
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Clerks & Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
County of Los Angeles Board of Supervisors
Opposition
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
Election Integrity Project California
Two individuals (including former Los Angeles County District Attorney Steve Cooley)
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1441 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1441
Author: Allen (D)
Amended: 4/4/24
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-2, 4/2/24
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Stern, Wahab
NOES: Wilk, Niello
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/16/24
AYES: Blakespear, Allen, Menjivar, Newman, Portantino, Umberg
NOES: Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Examination of petitions: time limitations and reimbursement of costs
SOURCE: County of Los Angeles
DIGEST:
This bill requires a proponent to conclude an examination of an election petition for insufficiency no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced. This bill also requires all costs, as defined, incurred by the county elections official due to the examination to be paid by the proponent, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Public Records Act, that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure. (Gov. Code § 7922.525.)
- Provides that the following are not public records:
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition;
- A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code;
- A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code; and,
- A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition. (Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).)
- Provides that materials in 2), above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum; or,
- If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id. at subd. (b).)
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 3b), above, the examination must commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency. (Id. at subd. (d).)
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day. (Elec. Code § 15624.)
This bill:
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced.
- Requires that all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination must be reimbursed within 30 days from the date the examination concludes. “Cost” means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs:
- Before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum must deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day.
- The proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination.
- Money not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
- The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
Comments
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. (Gov. Code § 7922.525-7922.530.) A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code § 7920.530.) Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable. (Gov. Code § 7920.530(a).) The California Supreme Court has held that this is generally understood to include costs like running a copy machine and “conceivably also the expense of the person operating it, but excludes any supplemental tasks associated with the retrieval, inspection, or handling of the record. (National Lawyers Guild v. City of Hayward (2020) 9 Cal.5th 488 at 493.) For copies of records in an electronic format, a requester must also pay the direct duplication costs including, the cost of producing a copy of the record, the cost to construct the record, and the cost of programming and computer services necessary to produce a copy of the record when either: (1) an agency would be required to produce a copy of a record that is produced only at regularly scheduled intervals; or (2) the request would require data compilation, extraction, or programming to produce the record. (Gov. Code § 7922.575.) In 2020, the Court held that the term “extraction” of electronic records does not encompass every process that “might be colloquially described as ‘taking information out’ and cited specific examples of things that could not be charged for such as, searching an e-mail in box or computer’s documents folder or redacting exempt data from otherwise disclosable records. (National Lawyers Guild supra at 506.)
The CPRA expressly provides that certain election petitions are not public records. (Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).) Additionally, they are not open to inspection except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id. at (b).) Existing law provides that the examination of a petition must commence within 21 days of certification of insufficiency, but there is no time prescribed for when the examination must end. (Id. at (d)).
The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352 at 359.) On August 15, 2022 the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the petition to recall DA Gascón, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. (Ibid.) The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures as 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: “Not Registered” (88,464); “Duplicate” (43,593); “Different Address” (32,187); “Mismatch Signature” (9,490); “Canceled” (7,344); “Out of County Address” (5,374); and “Other” (9,331). (Ibid at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with “no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room.” (Id. at 360.)
The proponents were provided several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: “(1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; (2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and (3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures.” (Ibid. at fn. 3.) The Registrar also provided “a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated.” (Ibid. at fn. 4). The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, including “training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address. (Ibid.) The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. (Id. at 360-61.) Proponents also sought an order to allow 25 representatives of the proponents to be able to participate in the examination five days a week, access to computer stations for each representative, and the ability to use their own devices. (Ibid.)
The trial court issued several orders that, among other things, (1) authorized the proponents and their representatives to use electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room subject to a protective order, and (2) ordered disclosure of current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures to proponents. (Id. at 374.) The Registrar appealed the trial court’s decision on multiple grounds, including that the use of electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room and access to current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures would violate confidentiality statutes and was outside the scope of Section 7924.110 of the Government Code. The Appeals Court ultimately agreed with the Registrar regarding the disclosure issue, dismissed other issues raised on appeal by the Registrar on procedural grounds, and remanded the case back to the trial court on certain outstanding issues that remained in the case.
The Appeals Court pointed to the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy as the main reason for its finding on the disclosure issues stating: (Id. at 376):
In view of the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy, however, it is unlikely the Legislature intended to broaden a petition examination by permitting the proponent to copy petition and memoranda data for use beyond the control of county election officials. In Bilofsky v. Deukmejian (1981) 124 Cal.App.3d 825, 831, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621 (Bilofsky), this court narrowly construed a provision in the Elections Code to prohibit any circulator of a petition (initiative, referendum, or recall) from using the list of signatures “‘for any purpose other than qualification of the ... question for the ballot.’” (Id. at pp. 827-828, fn. 1, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621, quoting former Elec. Code, § 2770.) Guided by “the California constitutional guarantee of privacy by insuring the least interference with that right of persons signing ... recall petitions,” we narrowly construed the provision as “designed in order to protect the signer from any use of his identity other than that integral to the [petition] process.” (Id. at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621; see Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.)
We agree with the Registrar that the same privacy concerns exist for voters who participate in recall petitions. (See [Government Code] §§ 7924.000, subds. (a)-(c).) Use of voter information in this case outside the Registrar's walls would undoubtedly give the Committee greater control over how they use the information. In turn, this level of control could expedite its petition examination. But the Committee already has access to this information for use inside the examination room. And as a practical matter, we are mindful of the risks of unlawful dissemination of voter data in this case, even if that risk is mitigated by a protective order.[] Under these circumstances, we do not believe that use of electronic voter data outside the Registrar's walls is “integral” to the Committee's petition examination. (Bilofsky, supra, at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621.)
The Appeals Court also concluded that Section 7924.110 of the Government Code “does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case.” (Ibid.)
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The Court of Appeal decision does not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case. The petition examination ultimately concluded because the trial court ordered the examination to conclude by November 21, 2023, which was 14 months after the petition review commenced. The County fears that had the trial court not issued this order the review could still be ongoing today. According to the County, plaintiffs in the litigation demanded increased staffing and resources be allocated during the petition examination effort, which the County did provide at a significant cost. The County believes that these extra costs should have been borne by the proponents instead of being ultimately absorbed by the County.
In light of the above described situation, this bill seeks to provide a specific time frame in which an examination must be completed—60 days from the commencement of the examination. The sponsors of the bill state that the 60 day time frame was chosen because it is the same amount of time in which a county must examine the signatures of a petition to determine if it is sufficient (i.e. verify the signatures). (see Elec. Code § 9031.) The bill also requires that costs incurred by the county elections official as a result of the examination be reimbursed by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. Under the bill, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each subsequent day, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition will be required to deposit with the elections official a sum as determined by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The author and sponsor of the bill point to the fact that a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount is required to cover the costs of the recount as to why the costs to examine insufficient petitions should be passed on to the petitioner. (see Elec. Code § 15624.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/13/24)
County of Los Angeles (source)
California Association of Clerks and Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/13/24)
Steve Cooley, former District Attorney of Los Angeles County
Election Integrity Project
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
3 individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review. SB 1441 establishes a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures and authorizes a county to recover costs for resources expended accommodating the proponent’s access to election records.
The County of Los Angeles, the sponsor of the bill, writes in support stating:
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, Ch. 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. County elections officials have a duty to ensure elections are conducted in a fairly, transparently, and lawfully, which is true of all aspects of the election process. It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county’s costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
SB 1441 creates a finite period – 60 days – for the proponents to examine a failed petition and establishes a mechanism for county elections officials to recover the costs associated with the personnel and resources associated with those examinations. In this way, county elections officials throughout the state can better determine the impact petition reviews have on their operations and allocate resources accordingly. It’s important to note that requiring proponents to reimburse the county for the costs of conducting this review aligns with provisions currently found in Elections Code section 15624 for cost recovery of voter-initiated recount efforts.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Election Integrity Project (EIPCa) writes in opposition stating:
In reality, the length of time and the resources consumed during that petition signature review were the direct and sole result of the L.A. Registrar’s denial of the people’s statutory rights. If the citizen oversight process had been facilitated in good faith, as mandated in current law, results of the public inquiry would have been accomplished in a reasonable amount of time and with reasonable expense. SB 1441 is a clear effort to subvert Direct Democracy in California using a spurious argument.
Former District Attorney of Los Angeles County, Steve Cooley and former Deputy District Attorney in Los Angeles County, Marian M.J. Thompson—both of whom were involved in the recall effort of DA Gascón— write in opposition stating they are concerned that the bill will impact “direct democracy and the constitutional right of voters to recall their elective officers.” They are majorly concerned with the 60-day time constraint, especially without any requirements on what kind of access should be given to proponents during an examination. They point to their own experience described above and believe that the Registrar did not provide them adequate access or time for examination.
Additionally they are concerned with shifting the cost of examination to proponents stating:
In summary, while SB 1441 purports to streamline the process, proponents legitimately worry about the potential impact on their ability to participate in the democratic process if this bill passes. The ability of proponents to participate in the petition review process really functions as a fundamental check on an otherwise secretive government review process relating to electing our leaders. Moreover, the bill’s provisions not only affect larger petitions that may not be adequately funded, but also disproportionately affects smaller initiatives and grassroots efforts.
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/14/24 9:37:34
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Catherine Blakespear, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: 1441 Hearing Date: 4/16/24
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
DIGEST
This bill requires a proponent to conclude an examination of an election petition for insufficiency no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies are required to be open to public scrutiny.
- Governs the disclosure of information collected and maintained by public agencies pursuant to the California Public Records Act (CPRA). Provides that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure.
- Provides that the following are not public records:
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
- A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
- A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code; and
- A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
- Provides that materials in 3), above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
- If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 4)b), above, the examination must commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency.
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day.
- Provides that the money deposited must be returned to the depositor if, upon completion of the recount, the candidate, slate of presidential electors, or the position on the measure (affirmative or negative) for which the declaration is filed is found to have received the plurality of votes cast which it had not received according to the official canvass or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount results in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff election or general election who would not have so appeared in the absence of the recount.
- Provides that the depositor shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the recount if the candidate, slate, or position on the measure has not received the plurality of the votes cast or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount does not result in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff or general election as a result of the recount.
- Provides that, if the random sampling of the number of qualified voters who signed a petition shows that the number of valid signatures is within 95 to 110 percent of the requisite number of qualified voters, the Secretary of State must order the examination and verification of the signatures filed, and within 60 days of this order, as specified, the elections official must determine the number of qualified voters who signed the petition.
This bill:
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced.
- Requires that all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination be reimbursed within 30 days from the date the examination concludes.
- Requires, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. Provides that the proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Provides that funds not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. Provides that the elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
- Defines “cost” to mean any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
BACKGROUND
California Public Records Act and Petitions. The CPRA makes all public records of a public agency open to public inspection upon request and grants the public the right to obtain a copy of any public record, unless the records are otherwise exempt from public disclosure. In 2004, the right of public access was enshrined in the California Constitution with the passage of Proposition 59 at the statewide general election held on November 3, 2004. Proposition 59 amended the California Constitution to specifically protect the right of the public to access and obtain government records. Additionally, at the statewide primary election held on June 3, 2014, voters approved Proposition 42 and increased public access to government records by requiring local agencies to comply with the CPRA and the Ralph M. Brown Act, and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, as provided.
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable.
The CPRA expressly provides that certain election petitions are not public records. Additionally, they and are not open to inspection except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. Existing law also provides that the examination of a petition must commence within 21 days of certification of insufficiency, but there is no time prescribed for when the examination must end.
Los Angeles County. The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352 at 359.) On August 15, 2022 the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the petition to recall DA Gascón, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures as 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: “Not Registered” (88,464); “Duplicate” (43,593); “Different Address” (32,187); “Mismatch Signature” (9,490); “Canceled” (7,344); “Out of County Address” (5,374); and “Other” (9,331). (Ibid at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with “no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room.”
The proponents were provided several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: “(1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; (2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and (3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures.” The Registrar also provided “a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated.” The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by existing law, including “training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address. The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. Proponents also sought an order to allow 25 representatives of the proponents to be able to participate in the examination five days a week, access to computer stations for each representative, and the ability to use their own devices.
The trial court issued several orders that, among other things, (1) authorized the proponents and their representatives to use electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room subject to a protective order, and (2) ordered disclosure of current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures to proponents. The Registrar appealed the trial court’s decision on multiple grounds, including that the use of electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room and access to current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures would violate confidentiality statutes and was outside the scope of existing law. The Appeals Court agreed with the Registrar regarding the disclosure issue, dismissed other issues raised on appeal by the Registrar on procedural grounds, and remanded the case back to the trial court on certain outstanding issues that remained in the case.
The Appeals Court pointed to the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy as the main reason for its finding on the disclosure issues stating:
In view of the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy, however, it is unlikely the Legislature intended to broaden a petition examination by permitting the proponent to copy petition and memoranda data for use beyond the control of county election officials. In Bilofsky v. Deukmejian (1981) 124 Cal.App.3d 825, 831, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621 (Bilofsky), this court narrowly construed a provision in the Elections Code to prohibit any circulator of a petition (initiative, referendum, or recall) from using the list of signatures “‘for any purpose other than qualification of the ... question for the ballot.’” Guided by “the California constitutional guarantee of privacy by insuring the least interference with that right of persons signing ... recall petitions,” we narrowly construed the provision as “designed in order to protect the signer from any use of his identity other than that integral to the [petition] process.”
We agree with the Registrar that the same privacy concerns exist for voters who participate in recall petitions. (See [Government Code] §§ 7924.000, subds. (a)-(c).) Use of voter information in this case outside the Registrar’s walls would undoubtedly give the Committee greater control over how they use the information. In turn, this level of control could expedite its petition examination. But the Committee already has access to this information for use inside the examination room. And as a practical matter, we are mindful of the risks of unlawful dissemination of voter data in this case, even if that risk is mitigated by a protective order.[] Under these circumstances, we do not believe that use of electronic voter data outside the Registrar’s walls is “integral” to the Committee’s petition examination. (Bilofsky, supra, at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621.)
The Appeals Court also concluded that existing law “does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case.”
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The Court of Appeal decision does not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case. The petition examination ultimately concluded because the trial court ordered the examination to conclude by November 21, 2023, which was 14 months after the petition review commenced.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review. SB 1441 establishes a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures and authorizes a county to recover costs for resources expended accommodating the proponent’s access to election records.
- Double Referral. Prior to being heard by this committee, SB 1441 was heard in the Committee on Judiciary where it was approved with a 9 – 2 vote.
- Argument in Support. In a letter sponsoring SB 1441, the County of Los Angeles stated, in part, the following:
Current law is silent regarding the amount of time proponents have to review failed petitions. Government Code section 7924.110 states that a petition proponent has up to 21 days after certification of insufficiency to commence an examination of disqualified petition signatures. However, the statute does not inform proponents of a failed petition how long they have to conduct their review of the insufficient signatures.
Likewise, current law is silent about who must bear extraordinary costs incurred by elections offices for a protracted examination. Protracted reviews, although rare, are costly. SB 1441 would permit election officials to recover costs associated with reviewing failed petitions when those costs are not part of the normal operations budget of an elections office. Examples of such costs include hiring additional staff, sacrificing office space, and providing secure computer stations for the proponents to review documents.
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, Chapter 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. In this context, it is important to remember that county election officials have a sworn duty to ensure elections are conducted fairly, transparently, and lawfully. It is critical that county election officials ensure that election activities, like reviewing a failed petition, are managed effectively. As a result of current law’s silence, petition proponents in some jurisdictions have exploited this access and abused public resources through what they may perceive as their right to an infinite amount of time and staff to examine failed petitions without obligation to reimburse the county. One egregious petition examination resulted in proponents using 14 months of election staff office time, office space, and computer terminals at a cost of well over $1.5 million.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing SB 1441, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association stated, in part, the following:
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association must oppose your Senate Bill 1441. The bill eviscerates a critically important tool for voters to ensure accurate verification of signatures on recall, initiative, and referendum petitions. It does this by placing a 60-day limit on the proponents’ review of rejected signatures and the reason for that rejection, and by adding a new requirement for proponents to pay the costs of the review, which could run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
SB 1441 requires proponents to deposit a sum covering the daily cost determined by the elections official before the examination even commences, and daily thereafter, with any costs above those amounts paid in full within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. This bars all but the wealthiest Californians and well-funded special interest groups from verifying the accuracy of a county’s determination that insufficient signatures were submitted to qualify a measure for the ballot.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 286 (Newman), Chapter 870, Statutes of 2023, among other provisions, extended the time in which a county must examine petitions for sufficiency from 30 days to 60 days.
AB 1004 (Ta) of 2023 would have established a process for a voter whose signature on a state, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition is rejected by an elections official to submit a statement to verify the voter’s signature. AB 1004 was held in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: County of Los Angeles
Support: California Association of Clerks and Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
Oppose: Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
3 individuals
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Catherine Blakespear, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB Hearing Date: 4/16/24
Author: | |||
Version: | 4/4/24 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Scott Matsumoto | ||
Subject: Examination of petitions: time limitations and reimbursement of costs
DIGEST
This bill requires a proponent to conclude an examination of an election petition for insufficiency no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies are required to be open to public scrutiny.
- Governs the disclosure of information collected and maintained by public agencies pursuant to the California Public Records Act (CPRA). Provides that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure.
- Provides that the following are not public records:
- A statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- A petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code.
- A petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code.
- A petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code; and
- A memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition.
- Provides that materials in 3), above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- A public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum.
- If a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor.
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 4)b), above, the examination must commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency.
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day.
- Provides that the money deposited must be returned to the depositor if, upon completion of the recount, the candidate, slate of presidential electors, or the position on the measure (affirmative or negative) for which the declaration is filed is found to have received the plurality of votes cast which it had not received according to the official canvass or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount results in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff election or general election who would not have so appeared in the absence of the recount.
- Provides that the depositor shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the recount if the candidate, slate, or position on the measure has not received the plurality of the votes cast or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount does not result in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff or general election as a result of the recount.
- Provides that, if the random sampling of the number of qualified voters who signed a petition shows that the number of valid signatures is within 95 to 110 percent of the requisite number of qualified voters, the Secretary of State must order the examination and verification of the signatures filed, and within 60 days of this order, as specified, the elections official must determine the number of qualified voters who signed the petition.
This bill:
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced.
- Requires that all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination be reimbursed within 30 days from the date the examination concludes.
- Requires, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum to deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. Provides that the proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination. Provides that funds not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury. Provides that the elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
- Defines “cost” to mean any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
BACKGROUND
California Public Records Act and Petitions. The CPRA makes all public records of a public agency open to public inspection upon request and grants the public the right to obtain a copy of any public record, unless the records are otherwise exempt from public disclosure. In 2004, the right of public access was enshrined in the California Constitution with the passage of Proposition 59 at the statewide general election held on November 3, 2004. Proposition 59 amended the California Constitution to specifically protect the right of the public to access and obtain government records. Additionally, at the statewide primary election held on June 3, 2014, voters approved Proposition 42 and increased public access to government records by requiring local agencies to comply with the CPRA and the Ralph M. Brown Act, and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, as provided.
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable.
The CPRA expressly provides that certain election petitions are not public records. Additionally, they and are not open to inspection except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. Existing law also provides that the examination of a petition must commence within 21 days of certification of insufficiency, but there is no time prescribed for when the examination must end.
Los Angeles County. The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352 at 359.) On August 15, 2022 the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the petition to recall DA Gascón, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures as 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: “Not Registered” (88,464); “Duplicate” (43,593); “Different Address” (32,187); “Mismatch Signature” (9,490); “Canceled” (7,344); “Out of County Address” (5,374); and “Other” (9,331). (Ibid at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with “no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room.”
The proponents were provided several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: “(1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; (2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and (3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures.” The Registrar also provided “a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated.” The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by existing law, including “training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address. The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. Proponents also sought an order to allow 25 representatives of the proponents to be able to participate in the examination five days a week, access to computer stations for each representative, and the ability to use their own devices.
The trial court issued several orders that, among other things, (1) authorized the proponents and their representatives to use electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room subject to a protective order, and (2) ordered disclosure of current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures to proponents. The Registrar appealed the trial court’s decision on multiple grounds, including that the use of electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room and access to current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures would violate confidentiality statutes and was outside the scope of existing law. The Appeals Court agreed with the Registrar regarding the disclosure issue, dismissed other issues raised on appeal by the Registrar on procedural grounds, and remanded the case back to the trial court on certain outstanding issues that remained in the case.
The Appeals Court pointed to the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy as the main reason for its finding on the disclosure issues stating:
In view of the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy, however, it is unlikely the Legislature intended to broaden a petition examination by permitting the proponent to copy petition and memoranda data for use beyond the control of county election officials. In Bilofsky v. Deukmejian (1981) 124 Cal.App.3d 825, 831, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621 (Bilofsky), this court narrowly construed a provision in the Elections Code to prohibit any circulator of a petition (initiative, referendum, or recall) from using the list of signatures “‘for any purpose other than qualification of the ... question for the ballot.’” Guided by “the California constitutional guarantee of privacy by insuring the least interference with that right of persons signing ... recall petitions,” we narrowly construed the provision as “designed in order to protect the signer from any use of his identity other than that integral to the [petition] process.”
We agree with the Registrar that the same privacy concerns exist for voters who participate in recall petitions. (See [Government Code] §§ 7924.000, subds. (a)-(c).) Use of voter information in this case outside the Registrar’s walls would undoubtedly give the Committee greater control over how they use the information. In turn, this level of control could expedite its petition examination. But the Committee already has access to this information for use inside the examination room. And as a practical matter, we are mindful of the risks of unlawful dissemination of voter data in this case, even if that risk is mitigated by a protective order.[] Under these circumstances, we do not believe that use of electronic voter data outside the Registrar’s walls is “integral” to the Committee’s petition examination. (Bilofsky, supra, at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621.)
The Appeals Court also concluded that existing law “does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case.”
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The Court of Appeal decision does not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case. The petition examination ultimately concluded because the trial court ordered the examination to conclude by November 21, 2023, which was 14 months after the petition review commenced.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review. SB 1441 establishes a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures and authorizes a county to recover costs for resources expended accommodating the proponent’s access to election records.
- Double Referral. Prior to being heard by this committee, SB 1441 was heard in the Committee on Judiciary where it was approved with a 9 – 2 vote.
- Argument in Support. In a letter sponsoring SB 1441, the County of Los Angeles stated, in part, the following:
Current law is silent regarding the amount of time proponents have to review failed petitions. Government Code section 7924.110 states that a petition proponent has up to 21 days after certification of insufficiency to commence an examination of disqualified petition signatures. However, the statute does not inform proponents of a failed petition how long they have to conduct their review of the insufficient signatures.
Likewise, current law is silent about who must bear extraordinary costs incurred by elections offices for a protracted examination. Protracted reviews, although rare, are costly. SB 1441 would permit election officials to recover costs associated with reviewing failed petitions when those costs are not part of the normal operations budget of an elections office. Examples of such costs include hiring additional staff, sacrificing office space, and providing secure computer stations for the proponents to review documents.
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, Chapter 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. In this context, it is important to remember that county election officials have a sworn duty to ensure elections are conducted fairly, transparently, and lawfully. It is critical that county election officials ensure that election activities, like reviewing a failed petition, are managed effectively. As a result of current law’s silence, petition proponents in some jurisdictions have exploited this access and abused public resources through what they may perceive as their right to an infinite amount of time and staff to examine failed petitions without obligation to reimburse the county. One egregious petition examination resulted in proponents using 14 months of election staff office time, office space, and computer terminals at a cost of well over $1.5 million.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing SB 1441, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association stated, in part, the following:
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association must oppose your Senate Bill 1441. The bill eviscerates a critically important tool for voters to ensure accurate verification of signatures on recall, initiative, and referendum petitions. It does this by placing a 60-day limit on the proponents’ review of rejected signatures and the reason for that rejection, and by adding a new requirement for proponents to pay the costs of the review, which could run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
SB 1441 requires proponents to deposit a sum covering the daily cost determined by the elections official before the examination even commences, and daily thereafter, with any costs above those amounts paid in full within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. This bars all but the wealthiest Californians and well-funded special interest groups from verifying the accuracy of a county’s determination that insufficient signatures were submitted to qualify a measure for the ballot.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 286 (Newman), Chapter 870, Statutes of 2023, among other provisions, extended the time in which a county must examine petitions for sufficiency from 30 days to 60 days.
AB 1004 (Ta) of 2023 would have established a process for a voter whose signature on a state, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition is rejected by an elections official to submit a statement to verify the voter’s signature. AB 1004 was held in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: County of Los Angeles
Support: California Association of Clerks and Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
One Individual Support
Oppose: Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1441 (Author:Allen)
Version: February 16, 2024
Hearing Date: April 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Examination of petitions: time limitations and reimbursement of costs
DIGEST
This bill requires a proponent to conclude an examination of an election petition for insufficiency no later than 60 days from the date the examination commenced. The bill also requires all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination to be paid by the proponent, as specified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The California Public Records Act (CPRA) makes all public records of a public agency open to public inspection upon request and grants the public the right to obtain a copy of any public record, unless the records are otherwise exempt from public disclosure. The CPRA expressly provides that certain election petitions are not public records and are not to be disclosed except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. The examination must commence within 21 days of certification of insufficiency, but no date is specified for when the examination must be completed. This bill seeks to provide a definitive end date to which an examination of an insufficient petition must be completed and seeks to shift the burden of paying the costs of the examination from the counties to the proponent seeking examination. The reason for these changes stems from a situation that occurred in the County of Los Angeles where an examination of a petition continued for 14 months and, according to the County, cost them $1.5 million. The bill is sponsored by the County of Los Angeles and supported by the California State Association of Counties and California Association of Clerks and Election Officials. The bill is opposed by two individuals, one of whom is the former District Attorney of Los Angeles County, Steve Cooley. Should this bill pass this Committee, it will next be heard in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and, therefore, the meetings of public bodies and the writings of public officials and agencies are required to be open to public scrutiny. (Cal. const. art. I, § 3(b)(1).)
- Requires a statute to be broadly construed if it furthers the people’s right of access, and narrowly construed if it limits the right of access. (Cal. const. art. I, § 3(b)(1).)
- Requires a statute that limits the public’s right of access to be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest. (Cal. const. art. I, § 3(b)(1).)
- Governs the disclosure of information collected and maintained by public agencies pursuant to the CPRA. (Gov. Code §§ 792.000 et seq.)
- States that, the Legislature, mindful of the right of individuals to privacy, finds and declares that access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Gov. Code § 7921.000.)
- Defines “public records” as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any state or local agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code § 7920.530.)
- Defines “public agency” as any state or local agency. (Gov. Code § 7920.525(a).)
- Provides that all public records are accessible to the public upon request, unless the record requested is exempt from public disclosure. (Gov. Code § 7922.525.)
- Some records are prohibited from being disclosed and other records are permissively exempted from being disclosed. (See e.g. Gov. Code §§ 7920.505 & 7922.200.)
- There are several general categories of documents or information that are permissively exempt from disclosure under the CPRA essentially due to the character of the information. The exempt information can be withheld by the public agency with custody of the information, but it also may be disclosed if it is shown that the public’s interest in disclosure outweighs the public’s interest in non-disclosure of the information. (CBS, Inc. v. Block (1986) 42 Cal.3d 646, at 652.).
- Provides that the following are not public records:
- a statewide, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition;
- a petition circulated pursuant to Section 5091 of the Education Code;
- a petition for reorganization of school districts submitted pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with Section 35700) of Chapter 4 of Part 21 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Education Code;
- a petition for reorganization of community college districts submitted pursuant to Part 46 (commencing with Section 74000) of Division 7 of Title 3 of the Education Code; and
- a memorandum prepared by a county elections official in the examination of a petition, indicating which registered voters signed that particular petition. (Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).)
- Provides that materials in 4), above, are not open to inspection except to the following persons:
- a public officer or public employee who has the duty of receiving, examining, or preserving the petition, or who is responsible for preparation of the memorandum; or
- if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition and a representative of the proponent as may be designated by the proponent in writing, in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id. at subd. (b).)
- Provides that if the proponent of a petition is permitted to examine a petition and a memorandum pursuant to 5)b), above, the examination must commence not later than 21 days after certification of insufficiency. (Id. at subd. (d).)
- Requires a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount, before the recount is commenced and at the beginning of each subsequent day, to deposit with the elections official the amount of money required by the elections official to cover the cost of the recount for that day.
- The money deposited must be returned to the depositor if, upon completion of the recount, the candidate, slate of presidential electors, or the position on the measure (affirmative or negative) for which the declaration is filed is found to have received the plurality of votes cast which it had not received according to the official canvass or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount results in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff election or general election who would not have so appeared in the absence of the recount.
- The depositor shall be entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the recount if the candidate, slate, or position on the measure has not received the plurality of the votes cast or, in an election where there are two or more candidates, the recount does not result in the candidate for whom the recount was requested appearing on the ballot in a subsequent runoff or general election as a result of the recount. (Elec. Code § 15624.)
- Provides that, if the random sampling of the number of qualified voters who signed a petition shows that the number of valid signatures is within 95 to 110 percent of the requisite number of qualified voters, the Secretary of State must order the examination and verification of the signatures filed, and within 60 days of this order, as specified, the elections official must determine the number of qualified voters who signed the petition. (Elec. Code § 9031(a)-(b).)
This bill:
- Requires an examination of a petition for insufficiency to conclude no later than 60 days from the date examination commenced.
- Requires that all costs incurred by the county elections official due to the examination must be reimbursed within 30 days from the date the examination concludes.
- Before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each day following, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition and a memorandum must deposit with the elections official a sum as required by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day.
- The proponent is entitled to the return of any money deposited in excess of the cost of the examination.
- Money not required to be refunded must be deposited in the appropriate public treasury.
- The elections official is not bound by any estimate of cost provided to the proponent or required to be deposited by the proponent and may, on a pro rata basis, bill the proponent for additional actual expense or refund any excess paid depending on the final actual cost.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
When a petition receives insufficient signatures to qualify for the ballot, state law affords proponents the opportunity to examine the petition and reasons for signature rejections. However, there is no time limit for this review process which increases demand on county elections department staff time and resources. Some petition proponents have exploited this access to public resources through indefinite time for a review. SB 1441 establishes a 60-day time limit for the proponents to complete their review of the failed petition’s signatures and authorizes a county to recover costs for resources expended accommodating the proponent’s access to election records.
- Election petitions and the CPRA
- Access to public records is a fundamental right
Access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business is a fundamental and necessary right of every person in this state. (Gov. Cod § 7921.000.) In 2004, the right of public access was enshrined in the California Constitution with the passage of Proposition 59 (Nov. 3, 2004, statewide general election),[1] which amended the California Constitution to specifically protect the right of the public to access and obtain government records: “The people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people’s business, and therefore . . . the writings of public officials and agencies shall be open to public scrutiny.” (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 3 (b)(1).) In 2014, voters approved Proposition 42 (Jun. 3, 2014, statewide direct primary election)[2] to further increase public access to government records by requiring local agencies to comply with the CPRA and the Ralph M. Brown Act[3], and with any subsequent statutory enactment amending either act, as provided. (Cal. Const., art. I, sec. 3 (b)(7).)
Under the CPRA, public records are open to inspection by the public at all times during the office hours of the agency, unless exempted from disclosure. (Gov. Cod § 7922.525-7922.530.) A public record is defined as any writing containing information relating to the conduct of the public’s business prepared, owned, used, or retained by any public agency regardless of physical form or characteristics. (Gov. Code § 7920.530.) Additionally, the CPRA only allows an agency to charge a fee to cover the direct costs of duplication of a public record in a non-electronic format or statutory fee if applicable. (Gov. Code § 7920.530(a).) The California Supreme Court has held that this is generally understood to include costs like running a copy machine and “conceivably also the expense of the person operating it, but excludes any supplemental tasks associated with the retrieval, inspection, or handling of the record. (National Lawyers Guild v. City of Hayward (2020) 9 Cal.5th 488 at 493.) For copies of records in an electronic format, a requester must also pay the direct duplication costs including, the cost of producing a copy of the record, the cost to construct the record, and the cost of programming and computer services necessary to produce a copy of the record when either: (1) an agency would be required to produce a copy of a record that is produced only at regularly scheduled intervals; or (2) the request would require data compilation, extraction, or programming to produce the record. (Gov. Code § 7922.575.) In 2020, the Court held that the term “extraction” of electronic records does not encompass every process that “might be colloquially described as ‘taking information out’ and cited specific examples of things that could not be charged for such as, searching an e-mail in box or computer’s documents folder or redacting exempt data from otherwise disclosable records. (National Lawyers Guild supra at 506.)
- Election petitions are not public records pursuant to the CPRA and can only be disclosed in limited circumstances
The CPRA expressly provides that certain election petitions are not public records. (Gov. Code § 7924.110(a).) Additionally, they and are not open to inspection except to specified public officials or, if a petition is found to be insufficient, by the proponent of the petition in order to determine which signatures were disqualified and the reasons therefor. (Id. at (b).) Existing law provides that the examination of a petition must commence within 21 days of certification of insufficiency, but there is no time prescribed for when the examination must end. (Id. at (d)).
- A situation in Los Angeles County is the genesis for this bill
- Background
The Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascón (proponents) submitted a recall petition containing 715,833 signatures on July 6, 2022, which was 148,976 more than required to trigger a recall election. (Committee to Support the Recall of District Attorney George Gascon v. Dean C. Logan et al. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 352 at 359.) On August 15, 2022 the County issued a press release after a full count examination of the signatures on the petition to recall DA Gascón, stating that the proponents were 46,000 signatures short of those needed to qualify for the ballot. (Ibid.) The press release noted the number of invalidated signatures as 195,783 and provided categories for why the signatures were rejected: “Not Registered” (88,464); “Duplicate” (43,593); “Different Address” (32,187); “Mismatch Signature” (9,490); “Canceled” (7,344); “Out of County Address” (5,374); and “Other” (9,331). (Ibid at fn. 2.) The proponents began an examination of the signatures on September 6, 2022 and were permitted by the Registrar to examine the signatures three days a week from 9:00 am until 4:00 pm with “no more than 14 representatives working at seven computer workstations under the control of Registrar staff. The Registrar prohibited the Committee from using any personal electronic devices inside its examination room.” (Id. at 360.)
The proponents were provided several reports by the Registrar in the examination room including: “(1) a report of signatures challenged as due to death with a date of death; (2) a report of signatures challenged as fatal pending with a fatal pending reason code; and (3) a report of signatures challenged as duplicates with all other signatures for the voter, including accepted signatures.” (Ibid. at fn. 3.) The Registrar also provided “a hardcopy list and report of invalided signatures, hardcopy list of signatures invalidated for death or fatal pending, and a hardcopy report showing when a voter changed or updated an address during the time the petition was circulated.” (Ibid. at fn. 4). The Registrar declined to provide the proponents with information it deemed were not authorized by Section 7924.110 of the Government Code, including “training materials for the software program it used to store voter registration records […], all signatures on file for each voter, various lists and/or reports for signatures deemed valid and accepted, and signatures invalidated as duplicates, death, fatal pending, or different address. (Ibid.) The proponents brought suit seeking several things, including access to training materials for staff to interpret its own data, electronic copies of lists of all voters who submitted a valid signature, whose signatures were invalidated, and original affidavits of registration and re-registration for voters whose recall signatures were rejected. (Id. at 360-61.) Proponents also sought an order to allow 25 representatives of the proponents to be able to participate in the examination five days a week, access to computer stations for each representative, and the ability to use their own devices. (Ibid.)
The trial court issued several orders that, among other things, (1) authorized the proponents and their representatives to use electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room subject to a protective order, and (2) ordered disclosure of current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures to proponents. (Id. at 374.) The Registrar appealed the trial court’s decision on multiple grounds, including that the use of electronic lists of voter data outside the examination room and access to current and former affidavits of registration for rejected signatures would violate confidentiality statutes and was outside the scope of Section 7924.110 of the Government Code. The Appeals Court ultimately agreed with the Registrar regarding the disclosure issue, dismissed other issues raised on appeal by the Registrar on procedural grounds, and remanded the case back to the trial court on certain outstanding issues that remained in the case.
The Appeals Court pointed to the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy as the main reason for its finding on the disclosure issues stating: (Id. at 376):
In view of the constitutional guarantee of voter privacy, however, it is unlikely the Legislature intended to broaden a petition examination by permitting the proponent to copy petition and memoranda data for use beyond the control of county election officials. In Bilofsky v. Deukmejian (1981) 124 Cal.App.3d 825, 831, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621 (Bilofsky), this court narrowly construed a provision in the Elections Code to prohibit any circulator of a petition (initiative, referendum, or recall) from using the list of signatures “‘for any purpose other than qualification of the ... question for the ballot.’” (Id. at pp. 827-828, fn. 1, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621, quoting former Elec. Code, § 2770.) Guided by “the California constitutional guarantee of privacy by insuring the least interference with that right of persons signing ... recall petitions,” we narrowly construed the provision as “designed in order to protect the signer from any use of his identity other than that integral to the [petition] process.” (Id. at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621; see Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.)
We agree with the Registrar that the same privacy concerns exist for voters who participate in recall petitions. (See [Government Code] §§ 7924.000, subds. (a)-(c).) Use of voter information in this case outside the Registrar's walls would undoubtedly give the Committee greater control over how they use the information. In turn, this level of control could expedite its petition examination. But the Committee already has access to this information for use inside the examination room. And as a practical matter, we are mindful of the risks of unlawful dissemination of voter data in this case, even if that risk is mitigated by a protective order.[] Under these circumstances, we do not believe that use of electronic voter data outside the Registrar's walls is “integral” to the Committee's petition examination. (Bilofsky, supra, at pp. 831, 833, 177 Cal.Rptr. 621.)
The Appeals Court also concluded that Section 7924.110 of the Government Code “does not authorize disclosure of affidavits of registration to proponents of recall petitions, the trial court erred by ordering disclosure of them in this case.” (Ibid.)
- This bill seeks to provide an end date for reviewing an insufficient petition and seeks to require the proponent to bear costs of the review
According to the County, the above described petition review lasted 14 months, cost the County approximately $1.5 million in additional staffing and resources, and diverted substantial resources and staffing away from existing election support activities; such as, examination of other initiative and referendum petitions at the state and local levels, updating of voter records, and preparing for the November 2022 General Election. The Court of Appeal decision does not address the duration of the failed petition examination or cost recovery as these were not issues in the case. The petition examination ultimately concluded because the trial court ordered the examination to conclude by November 21, 2023, which was 14 months after the petition review commenced. The County fears that had the trial court not issued this order the review could still be ongoing today. According to the County, plaintiffs in the litigation demanded increased staffing and resources be allocated during the petition examination effort, which the County did provide at a significant cost. The County believes that these extra costs should have been borne by the proponents instead of being ultimately absorbed by the County.
In light of the above described situation, this bill seeks to provide a specific time frame in which an examination must be completed—60 days from the commencement of the examination. The sponsors of the bill state that the 60 day time frame was chosen because it is the same amount of time in which a county must examine the signatures of a petition to determine if it is sufficient (i.e. verify the signatures). (see Elec. Code § 9031.) The bill also requires that costs incurred by the county elections official as a result of the examination be reimbursed by the proponent within 30 days from the date that the examination concludes. Under the bill, before an examination is conducted and at the beginning of each subsequent day, the proponent of a petition who requests to examine a petition will be required to deposit with the elections official a sum as determined by the elections official to cover the cost of the examination for that day. The author and sponsor of the bill point to the fact that a voter or campaign committee seeking a recount is required to cover the costs of the recount as to why the costs to examine insufficient petitions should be passed on to the petitioner. (see Elec. Code § 15624.)
- Proposed amendment
In discussions with Committee staff, the author and sponsor indicated it was their intent that “costs” was meant to apply to costs above general operating costs—such as additional staffing, additional equipment, and loss of resources towards other necessary duties of election officials and staff. In light of this stated intent, the Committee may wish to amend the bill to make it clear that the costs a proponent requesting examination of a petition would be required to pay are not any costs to county elections officials but those costs that are above and beyond the ordinary operating costs of running the county elections office. The specific amendment is as follows:
Amendment[4]
On page 4, between lines 7 and 8, insert:
(3) “Cost” for purposes of this subdivision means any cost incurred by a county elections official that is in addition to or greater than general operating costs.
- Statements in support
The County of Los Angeles, the sponsor of the bill, writes in support stating:
Elections have become increasingly complex, particularly following the enactment of the California Voter’s Choice Act (SB 450, Ch. 832, Statutes of 2016). This complexity is creating greater demand for existing staff time and office resources. County elections officials have a duty to ensure elections are conducted in a fairly, transparently, and lawfully, which is true of all aspects of the election process. It is then critical that county elections officials ensure that election activities, including review of failed petitions, are managed effectively. Through its silence on this issue, current law has enabled petition proponents in some jurisdictions to exploit this access to public resources through indefinite time for examination of failed petitions and no obligation to reimburse the county’s costs. Some examinations by proponents of failed petitions have resulted in millions of taxpayer dollars being expended to support these efforts.
SB 1441 creates a finite period – 60 days – for the proponents to examine a failed petition and establishes a mechanism for county elections officials to recover the costs associated with the personnel and resources associated with those examinations. In this way, county elections officials throughout the state can better determine the impact petition reviews have on their operations and allocate resources accordingly. It’s important to note that requiring proponents to reimburse the county for the costs of conducting this review aligns with provisions currently found in Elections Code section 15624 for cost recovery of voter-initiated recount efforts.
In an effort to ensure that elections officials remain able to conduct their work and allocate resources to the benefit of the people they serve, SB 1441 offers some modest but impactful opportunities that will modernize the local elections process.
- Statements in opposition
Two individuals have submitted opposition to the bill, former District Attorney of Los Angeles County, Steve Cooley, and former Deputy District Attorney in Los Angeles County, Marian M.J. Thompson—both of whom were involved in the recall effort of DA Gascón. They are concerned that the bill will impact “direct democracy and the constitutional right of voters to recall their elective officers.” They are majorly concerned with the 60-day time constraint, especially without any requirements on what kind of access should be given to proponents during an examination. They point to their own experience described above and believe that the Registrar did not provide them adequate access or time for examination. Additionally they are concerned that shifting the cost of examination to proponents and requiring an upfront deposit will discourage proponents from conducting examinations and will disproportionately affect grassroots campaigns or individuals with limited resources.
The opposition believes this bill could lead to corruption in the petition review process and offers other ideas to make the review process better, such as allowing observation of the signature verification process by proponents, allowing a signature cure process as provided for in AB 1004 (Ta, 2023), which died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee, and third party monitoring of an examination process by a neutral party, such as the Secretary of State or California State Auditor.
SUPPORT
County of Los Angeles (sponsor)
California Association of Clerks and Election Officials
California State Association of Counties
OPPOSITION
Steve Cooley, former District Attorney of Los Angeles County
Marian M.J. Thompson, former Deputy District Attorney in Los Angeles County
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 286 (Newman, Ch. 870, Stats. 2023), among other things, extended the time in which a county must examine petitions for sufficiency from 30 days to 60 days.
AB 1004 (Ta, 2023), would have established a process for a voter whose signature on a state, county, city, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition is rejected by an elections official to submit a statement to verify the voter’s signature. AB 1004 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
**************
Prop. 59 was placed on the ballot by a unanimous vote of both houses of the Legislature. (SCA 1 (Burton, Ch. 1, Stats. 2004). ↑
Prop. 42 was placed on the ballot by a unanimous vote of both houses of the Legislature. (SCA 3 (Leno, Ch. 123, Stats. 2013). ↑
The Ralph M. Brown Act is the open meetings laws that apply to local agencies. (Gov. Code §§ 59450 et. seq.) ↑
The amendments may also include technical, nonsubstantive changes recommended by the Office of Legislative Counsel. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Elections
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):