SB 1447: Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-28
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-28: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 896, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983, establishes a program of seismic safety building standards for certain hospitals. Existing law requires, by January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals to either seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospitals, or demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with regulations and standards developed by the department in accordance with the act, as specified.
This bill would authorize the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles to seek approval from the Department of Health Care Access and Information for an extension to the January 1, 2030, compliance deadline described above by up to 3 years. The bill would authorize the hospital to submit a seismic compliance plan, as specified, and, if necessary, a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report in order to seek an extension. The bill would also require the hospital and department to identify least 2 major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether a hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospitals seismic compliance deadline. The bill would subject the submitted seismic compliance plan to departmental review for reasonableness and require the hospital seeking the extension to submit any documentation requested by the department to assist its review. The bill would require the department to approve or deny a seismic compliance plan and any extension to the seismic compliance deadline within 120 days. The bill would also authorize the department to adjust the approved extension of time, the milestones agreed upon, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, acts of God, governmental entitlements, or other circumstances beyond the hospitals control.
The bill would impose a fine of $5,000 per calendar day for the hospitals failure to comply with a revised construction schedule or to meet any major milestone established by the department until the requirements or milestones, respectively, are met. The bill would also generally prohibit these hospitals from being issued a building permit for any building in the facility except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward meeting the hospitals seismic compliance, as determined by the department. The bill would require the department to implement the above-described provisions by regulation, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the County of Los Angeles.
Existing law, the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983, establishes a program of seismic safety building standards for certain hospitals. Existing law requires, by January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals to either seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospitals, or demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with regulations and standards developed by the department in accordance with the act, as specified.
This bill would authorize the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles to seek approval from the Department of Health Care Access and Information for an extension to the January 1, 2030, compliance deadline described above by up to 3 years. The bill would authorize the hospital to submit a seismic compliance plan, as specified, and, if necessary, a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report in order to seek an extension. The bill would also require the hospital and department to identify least 2 major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether a hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospitals seismic compliance deadline. The bill would subject the submitted seismic compliance plan to departmental review for reasonableness and require the hospital seeking the extension to submit any documentation requested by the department to assist its review. The bill would require the department to approve or deny a seismic compliance plan and any extension to the seismic compliance deadline within 120 days. The bill would also authorize the department to adjust the approved extension of time, the milestones agreed upon, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, acts of God, governmental entitlements, or other circumstances beyond the hospitals control.
The bill would impose a fine of $5,000 per calendar day for the hospitals failure to comply with a revised construction schedule or to meet any major milestone established by the department until the requirements or milestones, respectively, are met. The bill would also generally prohibit these hospitals from being issued a building permit for any building in the facility except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward meeting the hospitals seismic compliance, as determined by the department. The bill would require the department to implement the above-described provisions by regulation, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the County of Los Angeles.
Existing law, the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983, establishes a program of seismic safety building standards for certain hospitals. Existing law requires, by January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals to either seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospitals, or demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with regulations and standards developed by the department in accordance with the act, as specified.
This bill would extend the deadline to January 1, 2033, and would create a specified extension process, to no later than January 1, 2038, for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.This bill would authorize the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles to seek approval from the Department of Health Care Access and Information for a delay to the January 1, 2030, compliance deadline described above by up to 3 years. The bill would authorize the hospital to submit a seismic compliance plan, as specified, and, if necessary, a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report in order to seek an extension. The bill would also require the hospital and department to identify least 2 major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether a hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospitals seismic compliance deadline. The bill would subject the submitted seismic compliance plans to departmental review for reasonableness and require the hospital seeking the extension to submit any documentation requested by the department to assist its review. The bill would require the department to approve or deny a seismic compliance plan and any extension to the seismic compliance deadline within 120 days. The bill would also authorize the department to adjust the approved extension of time, the milestones agreed upon, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, acts of God, governmental entitlements, or other circumstances beyond the hospitals control.
The bill would impose a fine of $5,000 per calendar day for the hospitals failure to comply with a revised construction schedule or to meet any major milestone established by the department until the requirements or milestones, respectively, are met. The bill would also prohibit these hospitals from being issued a building permit for any building in the facility except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward meeting the hospitals seismic compliance, as determined by the department. The bill would require the department to implement the above-described provisions by regulation, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the County of Los Angeles.
Existing law, the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983, establishes a program of seismic safety building standards for certain hospitals. Existing law requires, by January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals to either seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospitals, or demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with regulations and standards developed by the department in accordance with the act, as specified.
This bill would extend the deadline to January 1, 2040, 2033, and would create a specified extension process, to no later than January 1, 2038, for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the County of Los Angeles.
Existing law, the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983, establishes a program of seismic safety building standards for certain hospitals. Existing law requires, by January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals to either seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospitals, or demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with regulations and standards developed by the department in accordance with the act, as specified.
This bill would extend the deadline to January 1, 2040, for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the County of Los Angeles.
Existing law, the California Nutrition Monitoring Development Act of 1986, requires the State Department of Public Health to assess the availability and adequacy of state and local nutrition data systems.This bill would make technical, nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.Existing law, the California Nutrition Monitoring Development Act of 1986, requires the State Department of Public Health to assess the availability and adequacy of state and local nutrition data systems.
This bill would make technical, nonsubstantive changes to these provisions.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is an integral part of providing health care to the children of the County of Los Angeles, including the City of Los Angeles.
(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important in providing health care services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, with more than 60 percent of the hospitals inpatient days provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
(c)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is the states largest provider of services to California Childrens Services Program patients. More than 50 percent of the hospitals inpatient days are provided to children who are eligible for the California Childrens Services Program and who are the most severely ill and highly complex clinical patients.
(d)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles provides care for the most medically complex patients from throughout the City of Los Angeles and the State of California.
(e)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is also a primary teaching facility with the third largest Childrens Hospitals Graduate Medical Education program nationally that trains pediatric physicians, pediatric nurses, and other critical health care professionals.
(f)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is one of the largest pediatric research institutions nationally with more than 350 funded scientists who have dedicated their professional careers to the development of new treatments and new cures for pediatric illnesses.
(g)The hospital faces low reimbursement levels and the cost of compliance by the deadline of 2030 would present substantial hardship to the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
(h)An extension is needed from the current seismic standard deadline of 2030 to avoid putting at risk over 400 critically needed hospital beds in Los Angeles for treating children at risk. This represents a significant percentage of the total number of beds available in Los Angeles and, without an extension, would greatly reduce the availability of inpatient care for children in the County of Los Angeles.
(i)An extension of the seismic safety standard deadline for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important to the provision of health care for children in the City of Los Angeles, the County of Los Angeles, and beyond.
SEC. 2.Section 130065 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:130065.(a)In accordance with the compliance schedule approved by the department, but in any case no later than January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals shall either:
(1)Demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act and this act.
(2)Seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospital buildings so that they are in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act and this act.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), if a hospitals seismic compliance plan, developed pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (d) of Section 130065.1, or pursuant to Section 130069.1, and approved by the department, substantiates the need for a delay of up to three years or, at most, five years beyond January 1, 2030, the owner of that general acute care hospital shall, by the deadline authorized in the approved extension, do either of the following:
(1)Demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 and this act.
(2)Seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospital buildings so that they are in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 and this act.
(c)Upon compliance with this section, the hospital shall be issued a written notice of compliance by the department. The department shall send a written notice of violation to hospital owners that fail to comply with this section.
SEC. 3.Section 130069.1 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:130069.1.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, referenced in subdivision (c) of Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, may seek an extension to the January 1, 2030, seismic compliance deadline outlined in Section 130065, of up to three years, to no later than January 1, 2033, with the submission and department approval of a seismic compliance plan, and a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report, if necessary. The department may authorize this extension as necessary if the hospital experiences issues with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or with other circumstances beyond the hospitals control that prevent it from meeting the January 1, 2030, deadline.
(b)If the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles includes a building that is not anticipated to be in full compliance with the seismic safety regulations or standards described in Section 130065 on the date this section becomes effective, the hospital may submit both of the following items to the Department of Health Care Access and Information by the dates specified to seek an extension:
(1)A Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report for each noncompliant building, if necessary, as outlined in Article 11 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations, by no later than January 1, 2025.
(2)The hospitals seismic compliance plan, as outlined in Section 1.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations and related regulations, by no later than January 1, 2026. The seismic compliance plan shall outline steps, including milestones, to achieve compliance with seismic safety standards at the earliest reasonable date, but no later than January 1, 2033. The hospital and the department shall identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospitals seismic compliance deadline. The seismic compliance plan is subject to department review.
(c)The department shall approve or deny the hospitals seismic compliance plan and any extension to the seismic compliance deadline within 120 days.
(d)If the seismic compliance plan includes a compliance schedule that is extended beyond the January 1, 2030, seismic compliance deadline established in Section 130065, the hospital shall submit any documentation requested by the department to assist the department in its review of the compliance schedule.
(e)If the department determines the compliance schedule is unreasonable based on the information submitted, the department shall notify the hospital and provide the departments rationale for its determination. The hospital shall be given the opportunity to address the identified concerns or to provide additional information to substantiate the compliance schedule.
(f)The duration of an extension granted by the department pursuant to this section shall not exceed the maximums permitted by this section and the department shall not grant an extension that exceeds the amount of time needed by the hospital to come into compliance. The department may grant an adjustment to an extension of time approved pursuant to this section, the milestones agreed upon pursuant to this section, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or other external forces beyond the hospitals control.
(g)If the hospital fails to meet any milestone or the seismic compliance deadline approved in the compliance plan approved pursuant to this section, it shall not be issued a building permit for any building in the facility except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward meeting the hospitals seismic compliance, as determined by the department. On a case-by-case basis, the department may determine if a building permit unrelated to seismic compliance may be considered for approval.
(h)Failure to comply with the revised construction schedule or meet any major milestones established by the department and the hospital shall result in the assessment of a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per calendar day until the requirements or milestones, respectively, are met.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, the hospital shall comply with requirements for a seismic compliance plan in accordance with Section 1.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations and related regulations.
(j)This section does not extend any deadlines for Structural Performance Category-1 buildings to achieve the structural integrity to no longer pose a potential risk of collapse or pose a significant risk of loss of life.
(k)Pursuant to Section 130065.15, the department shall include the name and location of the hospital and the projected final compliance date approved by the department.
(l)The department shall adopt regulations and standards, or revise existing regulations and standards, or both, to extend the deadlines for meeting the structural performance and nonstructural performance requirements pursuant to Section 130065 and this section. Regulatory submissions made by the department to the California Building Standards Commission pursuant to this section shall be deemed to be emergency regulations and shall be adopted as such. The adoption of these regulations shall be deemed to be an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health and safety, and general welfare.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique circumstances facing the City of Los Angeles and the County of Los Angeles with regard to the availability of hospital beds designated for children and the high demand for services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries and children eligible for the California Childrens Services Program, as described in Section 1 of this act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is an integral part of providing health care to the children of the County of Los Angeles, including the City of Los Angeles.
(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important in providing health care services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, with more than 60 percent of the hospitals inpatient days provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
(c)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is the states largest provider of services to California Childrens Services Program patients. More than 50 percent of the hospitals inpatient days are provided to children who are eligible for the California Childrens Services Program and who are the most severely ill and highly complex clinical patients.
(d)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles provides care for the most medically complex patients from throughout the City of Los Angeles and the State of California.
(e)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is also a primary teaching facility with the third largest Childrens Hospitals Graduate Medical Education program nationally that trains pediatric physicians, pediatric nurses, and other critical health care professionals.
(f)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is one of the largest pediatric research institutions nationally with more than 350 funded scientists who have dedicated their professional careers to the development of new treatments and new cures for pediatric illnesses.
(g)The hospital faces low reimbursement levels and the cost of compliance by the deadline of 2030 would present substantial hardship to the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
(h)An extension is needed from the current seismic standard deadline of 2030 to avoid putting at risk over 400 critically needed hospital beds in Los Angeles for treating children at risk. This represents a significant percentage of the total number of beds available in Los Angeles and, without an extension, would greatly reduce the availability of inpatient care for children in the County of Los Angeles.
(i)An extension of the seismic safety standard deadline for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important to the provision of health care for children in the City of Los Angeles, the County of Los Angeles, and beyond.
SEC. 2.Section 130065 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:130065.(a)In accordance with the compliance schedule approved by the department, but in any case no later than January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals shall either:
(1)Demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act and this act.
(2)Seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospital buildings so that they are in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act and this act.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), if a hospitals seismic compliance plan, developed pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (d) of Section 130065.1, or pursuant to Section 130069.1, and approved by the department, substantiates the need for a delay of up to three years or, at most, five years beyond January 1, 2030, the owner of that general acute care hospital shall, by the deadline authorized in the approved extension, do either of the following:
(1)Demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 and this act.
(2)Seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospital buildings so that they are in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 and this act.
(c)Upon compliance with this section, the hospital shall be issued a written notice of compliance by the department. The department shall send a written notice of violation to hospital owners that fail to comply with this section.
SEC. 3.Section 130069.1 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:130069.1.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, referenced in subdivision (c) of Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, may seek an extension to the January 1, 2030, seismic compliance deadline outlined in Section 130065, of up to three years, to no later than January 1, 2033, with the submission and department approval of a seismic compliance plan, and a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report, if necessary. The department may authorize this extension as necessary if the hospital experiences issues with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or with other circumstances beyond the hospitals control that prevent it from meeting the January 1, 2030, deadline.
(b)If the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles includes a building that is not anticipated to be in full compliance with the seismic safety regulations or standards described in Section 130065 on the date this section becomes effective, the hospital may submit both of the following items to the Department of Health Care Access and Information by the dates specified to seek an extension:
(1)A Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report for each noncompliant building, if necessary, as outlined in Article 11 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations, by no later than January 1, 2025.
(2)The hospitals seismic compliance plan, as outlined in Section 1.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations and related regulations, by no later than January 1, 2026. The seismic compliance plan shall outline steps, including milestones, to achieve compliance with seismic safety standards at the earliest reasonable date, but no later than January 1, 2033. The hospital and the department shall identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospitals seismic compliance deadline. The seismic compliance plan is subject to department review.
(c)The department shall approve or deny the hospitals seismic compliance plan and any extension to the seismic compliance deadline within 120 days.
(d)If the seismic compliance plan includes a compliance schedule that is extended beyond the January 1, 2030, seismic compliance deadline established in Section 130065, the hospital shall submit any documentation requested by the department to assist the department in its review of the compliance schedule.
(e)If the department determines the compliance schedule is unreasonable based on the information submitted, the department shall notify the hospital and provide the departments rationale for its determination. The hospital shall be given the opportunity to address the identified concerns or to provide additional information to substantiate the compliance schedule.
(f)The duration of an extension granted by the department pursuant to this section shall not exceed the maximums permitted by this section and the department shall not grant an extension that exceeds the amount of time needed by the hospital to come into compliance. The department may grant an adjustment to an extension of time approved pursuant to this section, the milestones agreed upon pursuant to this section, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or other external forces beyond the hospitals control.
(g)If the hospital fails to meet any milestone or the seismic compliance deadline approved in the compliance plan approved pursuant to this section, it shall not be issued a building permit for any building in the facility except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward meeting the hospitals seismic compliance, as determined by the department. On a case-by-case basis, the department may determine if a building permit unrelated to seismic compliance may be considered for approval.
(h)Failure to comply with the revised construction schedule or meet any major milestones established by the department and the hospital shall result in the assessment of a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per calendar day until the requirements or milestones, respectively, are met.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, the hospital shall comply with requirements for a seismic compliance plan in accordance with Section 1.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations and related regulations.
(j)This section does not extend any deadlines for Structural Performance Category-1 buildings to achieve the structural integrity to no longer pose a potential risk of collapse or pose a significant risk of loss of life.
(k)Pursuant to Section 130065.15, the department shall include the name and location of the hospital and the projected final compliance date approved by the department.
(l)The department shall adopt regulations and standards, or revise existing regulations and standards, or both, to extend the deadlines for meeting the structural performance and nonstructural performance requirements pursuant to Section 130065 and this section. Regulatory submissions made by the department to the California Building Standards Commission pursuant to this section shall be deemed to be emergency regulations and shall be adopted as such. The adoption of these regulations shall be deemed to be an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health and safety, and general welfare.
SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique circumstances facing the City of Los Angeles and the County of Los Angeles with regard to the availability of hospital beds designated for children and the high demand for services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries and children eligible for the California Childrens Services Program, as described in Section 1 of this act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is an integral part of providing health care to the children of the County of Los Angeles, including the City of Los Angeles.
(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important in providing health care services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, with more than 60 percent of the hospitals inpatient days provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
(c)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is the states largest provider of services to California Childrens Services Program patients. More than 50 percent of the hospitals inpatient days are provided to children who are eligible for the California Childrens Services Program and who are the most severely ill and highly complex clinical patients.
(d)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles provides care for the most medically complex patients from throughout the City of Los Angeles and the State of California.
(e)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is also a primary teaching facility with the third largest Childrens Hospitals Graduate Medical Education program nationally that trains pediatric physicians, pediatric nurses, and other critical health care professionals.
(f)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is one of the largest pediatric research institutions nationally with more than 350 funded scientists who have dedicated their professional careers to the development of new treatments and new cures for pediatric illnesses.
(g)The hospital faces low reimbursement levels and the cost of compliance by the deadline of 2030 would present substantial hardship to the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
(h)An extension is needed from the current seismic standard deadline of 2030 to avoid putting at risk over 400 critically needed hospital beds in Los Angeles for treating children at risk. This represents a significant percentage of the total number of beds available in Los Angeles and, without an extension, would greatly reduce the availability of inpatient care for children in the County of Los Angeles.
(i)An extension of the seismic safety standard deadline for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important to the provision of health care for children in the City of Los Angeles, the County of Los Angeles, and beyond.
SEC. 2.Section 130069.1 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:130069.1.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, referenced in subdivision (c) of Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, shall comply with the requirements of Section 130065 no later than January 1, 2033, or a later date as approved by the department pursuant to subdivision (b).(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles may apply to the department for an extension of up to five additional years, to no later than January 1, 2038, upon the submission of a seismic compliance plan no later than January 1, 2026, and a demonstration by the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles of one or more of the following:(1)The complexity of the hospitals seismic compliance plan detailing why the requested extension is necessary, and specifically how the hospital intends to meet the requested deadline.(2)Demonstration that compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity that may not be provided by other general acute care hospitals within a reasonable proximity.(3)The hospital owner demonstrates lack of financial capacity to substantially comply with the seismic safety regulations or standards described in Section 130065 by the January 1, 2033, deadline as described in subdivision (a).(4)The department determines by means of a health impact assessment that removal of the building or buildings from service may significantly diminish the availability or accessibility of health care services in the community.(c)As a condition of approval of an extension pursuant to subdivision (b), the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles shall, as applicable, submit to the department both of the following:(1)The hospital building plans and extension schedule that includes building permitting, construction commencement, and completion.(2)A construction timeline for the building demonstrating the hospitals intent and ability to meet the applicable deadline. The timeline shall include all of the following:(A)The projected construction start date.(B)The projected construction completion date.(C)Identification of the contractor.(d)Using the projected construction start and completion date, the subject hospital and the department shall identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the subject hospitals seismic compliance deadline.(e)The department may grant an adjustment to the extensions of time approved pursuant to subdivision (c) or the milestones pursuant to subdivision (d), or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, with acts of God, or with governmental entitlements, experienced by the hospital, up to the final compliance date of January 1, 2038. If one or more adjustments is granted, the hospital shall submit a revised seismic compliance plan, including, but not limited to, a revised construction schedule.SEC. 2.Section 130065 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:130065.(a)In accordance with the compliance schedule approved by the department, but in any case no later than January 1, 2030, owners of all acute care inpatient hospitals shall either:
(a)(1)Demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act and this act.
(b)(2)Seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospital buildings so that they are in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act and this act.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), if a hospitals seismic compliance plan, developed pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (d) of Section 130065.1, or pursuant to Section 130069.1, and approved by the department, substantiates the need for a delay of up to three years or, at most, five years beyond January 1, 2030, the owner of that general acute care hospital shall, by the deadline authorized in the approved extension, do either of the following:
(1)Demolish, replace, or change to nonacute care use all hospital buildings not in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 and this act.
(2)Seismically retrofit all acute care inpatient hospital buildings so that they are in substantial compliance with the regulations and standards developed by the department pursuant to the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 and this act.
Upon(c)Upon compliance with this section, the hospital shall be issued a written notice of compliance by the department. The department shall send a written notice of violation to hospital owners that fail to comply with this section.
SEC. 3.Section 130069.1 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:130069.1.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, referenced in subdivision (c) of Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, may seek an extension to the January 1, 2030, seismic compliance deadline outlined in Section 130065, of up to three years, to no later than January 1, 2033, with the submission and department approval of a seismic compliance plan, and a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report, if necessary. The department may authorize this extension as necessary if the hospital experiences issues with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or with other circumstances beyond the hospitals control that prevent it from meeting the January 1, 2030, deadline.
(b)If the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles includes a building that is not anticipated to be in full compliance with the seismic safety regulations or standards described in Section 130065 on the date this section becomes effective, the hospital may submit both of the following items to the Department of Health Care Access and Information by the dates specified to seek an extension:
(1)A Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report for each noncompliant building, if necessary, as outlined in Article 11 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations, by no later than January 1, 2025.
(2)The hospitals seismic compliance plan, as outlined in Section 1.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations and related regulations, by no later than January 1, 2026. The seismic compliance plan shall outline steps, including milestones, to achieve compliance with seismic safety standards at the earliest reasonable date, but no later than January 1, 2033. The hospital and the department shall identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospitals seismic compliance deadline. The seismic compliance plan is subject to department review.
(c)The department shall approve or deny the hospitals seismic compliance plan and any extension to the seismic compliance deadline within 120 days.
(d)If the seismic compliance plan includes a compliance schedule that is extended beyond the January 1, 2030, seismic compliance deadline established in Section 130065, the hospital shall submit any documentation requested by the department to assist the department in its review of the compliance schedule.
(e)If the department determines the compliance schedule is unreasonable based on the information submitted, the department shall notify the hospital and provide the departments rationale for its determination. The hospital shall be given the opportunity to address the identified concerns or to provide additional information to substantiate the compliance schedule.
(f)The duration of an extension granted by the department pursuant to this section shall not exceed the maximums permitted by this section and the department shall not grant an extension that exceeds the amount of time needed by the hospital to come into compliance. The department may grant an adjustment to an extension of time approved pursuant to this section, the milestones agreed upon pursuant to this section, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or other external forces beyond the hospitals control.
(g)If the hospital fails to meet any milestone or the seismic compliance deadline approved in the compliance plan approved pursuant to this section, it shall not be issued a building permit for any building in the facility except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward meeting the hospitals seismic compliance, as determined by the department. On a case-by-case basis, the department may determine if a building permit unrelated to seismic compliance may be considered for approval.
(h)Failure to comply with the revised construction schedule or meet any major milestones established by the department and the hospital shall result in the assessment of a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000) per calendar day until the requirements or milestones, respectively, are met.
(i)Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, the hospital shall comply with requirements for a seismic compliance plan in accordance with Section 1.4 of Article 1 of Chapter 6 of Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations and related regulations.
(j)This section does not extend any deadlines for Structural Performance Category-1 buildings to achieve the structural integrity to no longer pose a potential risk of collapse or pose a significant risk of loss of life.
(k)Pursuant to Section 130065.15, the department shall include the name and location of the hospital and the projected final compliance date approved by the department.
(l)The department shall adopt regulations and standards, or revise existing regulations and standards, or both, to extend the deadlines for meeting the structural performance and nonstructural performance requirements pursuant to Section 130065 and this section. Regulatory submissions made by the department to the California Building Standards Commission pursuant to this section shall be deemed to be emergency regulations and shall be adopted as such. The adoption of these regulations shall be deemed to be an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health and safety, and general welfare.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique circumstances facing the City of Los Angeles and the County of Los Angeles with regard to the availability of hospital beds designated for children and the high demand for services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries and children eligible for the California Childrens Services Program, as described in Section 1 of this act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is an integral part of providing health care to the children of the County of Los Angeles, including the City of Los Angeles.
(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important in providing health care services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, with more than 60 percent of the hospitals inpatient days provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
(c)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is the states largest provider of services to California Childrens Services Program patients. More than 50 percent of the hospitals inpatient days are provided to children who are eligible for the California Childrens Services Program and who are the most severely ill and highly complex clinical patients.
(d)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles provides care for the most medically complex patients from throughout the City of Los Angeles and the State of California.
(e)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is also a primary teaching facility with the third largest Childrens Hospitals Graduate Medical Education program nationally that trains pediatric physicians, pediatric nurses, and other critical health care professionals.
(f)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is one of the largest pediatric research institutions nationally with more than 350 funded scientists who have dedicated their professional careers to the development of new treatments and new cures for pediatric illnesses.
(g)The hospital faces low reimbursement levels and the cost of compliance by the deadline of 2030 would present substantial hardship to the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
(h)An extension is needed from the current seismic standard deadline of 2030 to avoid putting at risk over 400 critically needed hospital beds in Los Angeles for treating children at risk. This represents a significant percentage of the total number of beds available in Los Angeles and, without an extension, would greatly reduce the availability of inpatient care for children in the County of Los Angeles.
(i)An extension of the seismic safety standard deadline for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important to the provision of health care for children in the City of Los Angeles, the County of Los Angeles, and beyond.
SEC. 2.Section 130069.1 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:130069.1.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, referenced in subdivision (c) of Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, shall comply with the requirements of Section 130065 no later than January 1, 2040. 2033, or a later date as approved by the department pursuant to subdivision (b).
(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles may apply to the department for an extension of up to five additional years, to no later than January 1, 2038, upon the submission of a seismic compliance plan no later than January 1, 2026, and a demonstration by the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles of one or more of the following:
(1)The complexity of the hospitals seismic compliance plan detailing why the requested extension is necessary, and specifically how the hospital intends to meet the requested deadline.
(2)Demonstration that compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity that may not be provided by other general acute care hospitals within a reasonable proximity.
(3)The hospital owner demonstrates lack of financial capacity to substantially comply with the seismic safety regulations or standards described in Section 130065 by the January 1, 2033, deadline as described in subdivision (a).
(4)The department determines by means of a health impact assessment that removal of the building or buildings from service may significantly diminish the availability or accessibility of health care services in the community.
(c)As a condition of approval of an extension pursuant to subdivision (b), the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles shall, as applicable, submit to the department both of the following:
(1)The hospital building plans and extension schedule that includes building permitting, construction commencement, and completion.
(2)A construction timeline for the building demonstrating the hospitals intent and ability to meet the applicable deadline. The timeline shall include all of the following:
(A)The projected construction start date.
(B)The projected construction completion date.
(C)Identification of the contractor.
(d)Using the projected construction start and completion date, the subject hospital and the department shall identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the subject hospitals seismic compliance deadline.
(e)The department may grant an adjustment to the extensions of time approved pursuant to subdivision (c) or the milestones pursuant to subdivision (d), or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, with acts of God, or with governmental entitlements, experienced by the hospital, up to the final compliance date of January 1, 2038. If one or more adjustments is granted, the hospital shall submit a revised seismic compliance plan, including, but not limited to, a revised construction schedule.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique circumstances facing the City of Los Angeles and the County of Los Angeles with regard to the availability of hospital beds designated for children and the high demand for services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries and children eligible for the California Childrens Services Program, as described in Section 1 of this act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is an integral part of providing health care to the children of the County of Los Angeles, including the City of Los Angeles.
(b)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important in providing health care services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, with more than 60 percent of the hospitals inpatient days provided to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.
(c)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is the states largest provider of services to California Childrens Services Program patients. More than 50 percent of the hospitals inpatient days are provided to children who are eligible for the California Childrens Services Program and who are the most severely ill and highly complex clinical patients.
(d)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles provides care for the most medically complex patients from throughout the City of Los Angeles and the State of California.
(e)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is also a primary teaching facility with the third largest Childrens Hospitals Graduate Medical Education program nationally that trains pediatric physicians, pediatric nurses, and other critical health care professionals.
(f)The Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is one of the largest pediatric research institutions nationally with more than 350 funded scientists who have dedicated their professional careers to the development of new treatments and new cures for pediatric illnesses.
(g)The hospital faces low reimbursement levels and the cost of compliance by the deadline of 2030 would present substantial hardship to the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles.
(h)An extension is needed from the current seismic standard deadline of 2030 to avoid putting at risk over 400 critically needed hospital beds in Los Angeles for treating children at risk. This represents a significant percentage of the total number of beds available in Los Angeles and, without an extension, would greatly reduce the availability of inpatient care for children in the County of Los Angeles.
(i)An extension of the seismic safety standard deadline for the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles is critically important to the provision of health care for children in the City of Los Angeles, the County of Los Angeles, and beyond.
SEC. 2.Section 130069.1 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:130069.1.Notwithstanding any other law, the Childrens Hospital Los Angeles, referenced in subdivision (c) of Section 10727 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, shall comply with the requirements of Section 130065 no later than January 1, 2040.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique circumstances facing the City of Los Angeles and the County of Los Angeles with regard to the availability of hospital beds designated for children and the high demand for services to children who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries and children eligible for the California Childrens Services Program, as described in Section 1 of this act.
SECTION 1.Section 104575 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:104575.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Nutrition Monitoring Development Act of 1986.This article shall be known known, and may be cited cited, as the California Nutrition Monitoring Development Act of 1986.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 28, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 896, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 28, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2024 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 5747.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 29, 2024 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 69. Noes 0. Page 6730.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (August 15). |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 19, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 4140.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3984.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2024 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 30, 2024 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 29, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0. Page 3756.) (April 24). |
| Apr 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 19, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2024 | Special Consent SB1447 Durazo et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2024 | SB 1447 Durazo Senate Third Reading By Calderon | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1447 Durazo et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AltaMed Health Services | ** Support | |
| Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| California ChildrenS Hospital Association | ** Support | |
| California Fire Chiefs Association | ** Against | |
| California Labor Federation | ** Against | |
| California Nurses Association | ** Against | |
| California Professional Firefighters | ** Against | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Against | |
| Childrens Hospital Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Community Health Systems | ** Support | |
| Fire Districts Association Of California | ** Against | |
| First Day Foundation | ** Support | |
| Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Area Chamber Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Business Federation | ** Support | |
| Professional Engineers In California Government | ** Against | |
| Saban Community Clinic | ** Support | |
| Valley Industrial and Commerce Association | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1447 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1447
Author: Durazo (D), et al.
Amended: 8/22/24
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/24/24
AYES: Roth, Nguyen, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/22/24
AYES: Alvarado-Gil, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Allen, Archuleta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-0, 8/28/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
SOURCE: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
DIGEST:
This bill permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to request an extension of up to three years of the January 1, 2030 seismic compliance deadline, to a maximum of January 1, 2033, based on factors outside of the hospital’s control.
Assembly Amendments
delete provisions that would have granted Children’s Hospital Los Angeles an automatic three year extension of seismic compliance requirement, with the ability to request a further extension up to a maximum of January 1, 2038, and instead establish a process for Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to request an extension of the seismic compliance deadline of up to three years.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 (Seismic Safety Act), to ensure that hospital buildings are designed and constructed to resist the forces generated by earthquakes. Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) to propose building standards for earthquake resistance and to provide independent review of the design and construction of hospital buildings. [HSC §129675, et seq.]
- Establishes timelines for hospital compliance with seismic safety standards, including a requirement that buildings posing a significant risk of collapse and a danger to the public (referred to as SPC-1 buildings) be rebuilt or retrofitted to be capable of withstanding an earthquake, or removed from acute care service, by January 1, 2008 (which has since been extended for various hospitals to various dates), and a requirement that hospitals must also be capable of continued operation by January 1, 2030. [HSC §130060, §130065]
- Permits HCAI to grant an extension of up to five years to the 2008 deadline (January 1, 2013) for hospitals for which compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity, as defined. Allows HCAI to grant various further extensions beyond this, including up to seven years (January 1, 2020), in part based on the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship. [HSC §130060, §130061.5]
- Permits HCAI, under legislation enacted in 2018, to provide for an extension of the January 1, 2020 deadline in 4) above, for up to 30 months (July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to meet the 2020 standard, and up to five years (January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to a standard that meets the 2030 requirement. [HSC §130062]
- Requires the owner of a hospital whose building does not substantially comply with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement described in 3) above, to submit to HCAI, by January 1, 2020, an attestation that the board of directors of that hospital is aware that the hospital building is required to meet this requirement. [HSC §130066]
This bill:
- Permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to seek an extension to comply with the requirements for a hospital to remain capable of continued operation following a major earthquake of up to three years to January 1, 2033, with the submission and HCAI approval of a seismic compliance plan, an a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report, if necessary.
- Permits HCAI to authorize the extension requested in 1) above as necessary if the hospital experiences issues with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or with other circumstances beyond the hospital’s control that prevent it from meeting the January 1, 2030 deadline.
- Permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, if it includes a building that is not anticipated to be in full compliance with the seismic safety requirements on the date this bill becomes effective, to submit both of the following items to HCAI to seek an extension:
- A Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report for each noncompliant building, if necessary, by January 1, 2025; and,
- The hospital’s seismic compliance plan, as specified, by January 1, 2026. Requires the seismic compliance plan to outline steps, including milestones, to achieve compliance with seismic safety standards at the earliest reasonable date, but no later than January 1, 2033. Requires the hospital and HCAI to identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan to be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospital’s seismic compliance deadline. Requires the seismic compliance plan to be subject to HCAI review.
- Requires HCAI to approve or deny the hospital’s seismic compliance plan and any extension within 120 days.
- Requires Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, if the seismic compliance plan includes a schedule that is extended beyond January 1, 2030, to submit any documentation requested by HCAI as part of its review.
- Requires HCAI, if it determines the compliance schedule is unreasonable, to notify the hospital and provide HCAI’s rationale for its determination. Requires the hospital to have the opportunity to address the identified concerns or to provide additional information to substantiate the compliance schedule.
- Prohibits the during of an extension granted by HCAI from exceeding January 1, 2033, and prohibits HCAI from granting an extension that exceeds the amount of time needed by the hospital to come into compliance. Permits HCAI to grant an adjustment to an extension of time, or the milestones, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, acts of God, governmental entitlements, or other external forces beyond the hospital’s control.
- Prohibits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles from being issued a building permit except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs, if the hospital fails to meet any milestone or the approved seismic compliance deadline, until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward compliance. Permits HCAI, on a case-by-case basis, to determine if a building permit unrelated to seismic compliance may be considered for approval.
- Specifies that failure to comply with the revised construction schedule or meet any major milestone to result in a fine of $5,000 per calendar day until the milestones are met.
- Requires HCAI to adopt regulations, or revise existing regulations, to extend the deadlines for Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, and deems these emergency regulations.
Comments:
- Author’s statement. According to the author:
Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
- Background on hospital seismic safety requirements. The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations. Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist, Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994), which required HCAI (at that time OSHPD) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create structural performance categories (SPCs), as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services.
- Background on seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various “infrastructure” improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region’s children, regardless of the family’s ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children’s Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care. CHLA states that it has a plan for feasibility, permitting, construction, and financing to reach the seismic goal, and the extension in this bill will allow for both the financing plan and the completion of the required seismic infrastructure projects.
- Children’s Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children’s Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children’s hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new MRI machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA’s radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two NM gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
- Oppose unless amended. The California Professional Firefighters (CPF), SEIU California, and the Professional Engineers in California Government (PECG) all oppose this bill unless amended to be an extension for a maximum of two years. CPF states California hospitals have had 30 years to plan for this deadline, and indeed have another six years in which to complete the work needed to come into compliance. CPF states that firefighters and public safety personnel cannot properly perform their duties to preserve life during an earthquake if they have to also worry about the local hospital failing to care for patients in a time of emergency. SEIU California and PECG make similar arguments.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
The most recent fiscal analysis by the Assembly Appropriations Committee was for a prior version of the bill that permitted an extension of as much as 8 years. The total cost identified by Assembly Appropriations Committee for that version of the bill was $1,689,000 to HCAI (Hospital Building Fund) for the automatic three-year extension, and an additional cost pressure of $1,650,000 (Hospital Building Fund) for the additional years up through January 1, 2038. It is unclear what the revised fiscal effect would be to the current version of the bill, which only permits an extension up to January 1, 2033.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/28/24)
Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (source)
Altamed Health Services
Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles
California Children’s Hospital Association
Community Health System
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Saban Community Clinic
Valley Industrial and Commerce Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/28/24)
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
Fire Districts Association of California
Professional Engineers in California Government
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) (source) states:
Complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million for CHLA. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA states that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shutter in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County. Furthermore, an additional 317 licensed beds in seismically compliant buildings would also be at risk due to the $100+ million investment required to relocate acute care supporting services into them and the upgrades to nonstructural elements that this necessitates. This impact to pediatric acute care capacity underscores the urgency of this request. Supporters, including the Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, state that CHLA is a beacon of hope and healing for children and families, and the financial strain of seismic compliance threatens not just the hospital’s stability, but directly impacts the availability of essential pediatric beds for our community’s children.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Labor Federation state that it is opposed to any extension longer than two years. The potential of having to evacuate patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. Other nearby hospitals in California may not have the appropriate supplies to quickly accommodate an influx of young patients, which underscore the importance of quickly coming into compliance with the 2030 standard. Additionally, the California Labor Federation states that bond funds have been made available to this hospital to be able to come into compliance, which at this time they have not utilized. The California Nurses Association (CNA) also opposes this bill, making similar arguments, stating that in 1994 after the Northridge earthquake, hospital workers were forced to evacuate patients, including newborn babies, down dark staircases to parking lots. CNA states that CHLA plays a critical role in providing pediatric care and the Los Angeles community should expect that CHLA will be able to care for them in the event of a seismic disaster.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-0, 8/28/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Low, Lowenthal, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Davies, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Maienschein, Muratsuchi, Ortega, Rodriguez, Schiavo
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
8/29/24 11:37:40
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1447 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1447
Author: Durazo (D), et al.
Amended: 8/22/24
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/24/24
AYES: Roth, Nguyen, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/22/24
AYES: Alvarado-Gil, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Allen, Archuleta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-0, 8/28/24
(Roll call not available)
SUBJECT: Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
SOURCE: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
DIGEST:
This bill permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to request an extension of up to three years of the January 1, 2030 seismic compliance deadline, to a maximum of January 1, 2033, based on factors outside of the hospital’s control.
Assembly Amendments
delete provisions that would have granted Children’s Hospital Los Angeles an automatic three year extension of seismic compliance requirement, with the ability to request a further extension up to a maximum of January 1, 2038, and instead establish a process for Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to request an extension of the seismic compliance deadline of up to three years.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 (Seismic Safety Act), to ensure that hospital buildings are designed and constructed to resist the forces generated by earthquakes. Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) to propose building standards for earthquake resistance and to provide independent review of the design and construction of hospital buildings. [HSC §129675, et seq.]
- Establishes timelines for hospital compliance with seismic safety standards, including a requirement that buildings posing a significant risk of collapse and a danger to the public (referred to as SPC-1 buildings) be rebuilt or retrofitted to be capable of withstanding an earthquake, or removed from acute care service, by January 1, 2008 (which has since been extended for various hospitals to various dates), and a requirement that hospitals must also be capable of continued operation by January 1, 2030. [HSC §130060, §130065]
- Permits HCAI to grant an extension of up to five years to the 2008 deadline (January 1, 2013) for hospitals for which compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity, as defined. Allows HCAI to grant various further extensions beyond this, including up to seven years (January 1, 2020), in part based on the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship. [HSC §130060, §130061.5]
- Permits HCAI, under legislation enacted in 2018, to provide for an extension of the January 1, 2020 deadline in 4) above, for up to 30 months (July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to meet the 2020 standard, and up to five years (January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to a standard that meets the 2030 requirement. [HSC §130062]
- Requires the owner of a hospital whose building does not substantially comply with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement described in 3) above, to submit to HCAI, by January 1, 2020, an attestation that the board of directors of that hospital is aware that the hospital building is required to meet this requirement. [HSC §130066]
This bill:
- Permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to seek an extension to comply with the requirements for a hospital to remain capable of continued operation following a major earthquake of up to three years to January 1, 2033, with the submission and HCAI approval of a seismic compliance plan, an a Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report, if necessary.
- Permits HCAI to authorize the extension requested in 1) above as necessary if the hospital experiences issues with contractor, labor, or material delays; acts of God; governmental entitlements; or with other circumstances beyond the hospital’s control that prevent it from meeting the January 1, 2030 deadline.
- Permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, if it includes a building that is not anticipated to be in full compliance with the seismic safety requirements on the date this bill becomes effective, to submit both of the following items to HCAI to seek an extension:
- A Nonstructural Performance Category-5 evaluation report for each noncompliant building, if necessary, by January 1, 2025; and,
- The hospital’s seismic compliance plan, as specified, by January 1, 2026. Requires the seismic compliance plan to outline steps, including milestones, to achieve compliance with seismic safety standards at the earliest reasonable date, but no later than January 1, 2033. Requires the hospital and HCAI to identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan to be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress towards meeting the hospital’s seismic compliance deadline. Requires the seismic compliance plan to be subject to HCAI review.
- Requires HCAI to approve or deny the hospital’s seismic compliance plan and any extension within 120 days.
- Requires Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, if the seismic compliance plan includes a schedule that is extended beyond January 1, 2030, to submit any documentation requested by HCAI as part of its review.
- Requires HCAI, if it determines the compliance schedule is unreasonable, to notify the hospital and provide HCAI’s rationale for its determination. Requires the hospital to have the opportunity to address the identified concerns or to provide additional information to substantiate the compliance schedule.
- Prohibits the during of an extension granted by HCAI from exceeding January 1, 2033, and prohibits HCAI from granting an extension that exceeds the amount of time needed by the hospital to come into compliance. Permits HCAI to grant an adjustment to an extension of time, or the milestones, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, acts of God, governmental entitlements, or other external forces beyond the hospital’s control.
- Prohibits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles from being issued a building permit except those required for seismic compliance, maintenance, and emergency repairs, if the hospital fails to meet any milestone or the approved seismic compliance deadline, until the milestone is met and the hospital is adequately progressing toward compliance. Permits HCAI, on a case-by-case basis, to determine if a building permit unrelated to seismic compliance may be considered for approval.
- Specifies that failure to comply with the revised construction schedule or meet any major milestone to result in a fine of $5,000 per calendar day until the milestones are met.
- Requires HCAI to adopt regulations, or revise existing regulations, to extend the deadlines for Children’s Hospital Los Angeles, and deems these emergency regulations.
Comments:
- Author’s statement. According to the author:
Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
- Background on hospital seismic safety requirements. The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations. Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist, Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994), which required HCAI (at that time OSHPD) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create structural performance categories (SPCs), as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services.
- Background on seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various “infrastructure” improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region’s children, regardless of the family’s ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children’s Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care. CHLA states that it has a plan for feasibility, permitting, construction, and financing to reach the seismic goal, and the extension in this bill will allow for both the financing plan and the completion of the required seismic infrastructure projects.
- Children’s Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children’s Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children’s hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new MRI machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA’s radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two NM gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
Oppose unless amended. The California Professional Firefighters (CPF), SEIU California, and the Professional Engineers in California Government (PECG) all oppose this bill unless amended to be an extension for a maximum of two years. CPF states California hospitals have had 30 years to plan for this deadline, and indeed have another six years in which to complete the work needed to come into compliance. CPF states that firefighters and public safety personnel cannot properly perform their duties to preserve life during an earthquake if they have to also worry about the local hospital failing to care for patients in a time of emergency. SEIU California and PECG make similar arguments. Click or tap here to enter text.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
The most recent fiscal analysis by the Assembly Appropriations Committee was for a prior version of the bill that permitted an extension of as much as 8 years. The total cost identified by Assembly Appropriations Committee for that version of the bill was $1,689,000 to HCAI (Hospital Building Fund) for the automatic three-year extension, and an additional cost pressure of $1,650,000 (Hospital Building Fund) for the additional years up through January 1, 2038. It is unclear what the revised fiscal effect would be to the current version of the bill, which only permits an extension up to January 1, 2033.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/28/24)
Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (source)
Altamed Health Services
Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles
California Children’s Hospital Association
Community Health System
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Saban Community Clinic
Valley Industrial and Commerce Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/28/24)
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
Fire Districts Association of California
Professional Engineers in California Government
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) (source) states:
Complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million for CHLA. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA states that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shutter in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County. Furthermore, an additional 317 licensed beds in seismically compliant buildings would also be at risk due to the $100+ million investment required to relocate acute care supporting services into them and the upgrades to nonstructural elements that this necessitates. This impact to pediatric acute care capacity underscores the urgency of this request. Supporters, including the Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, state that CHLA is a beacon of hope and healing for children and families, and the financial strain of seismic compliance threatens not just the hospital’s stability, but directly impacts the availability of essential pediatric beds for our community’s children.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Labor Federation state that it is opposed to any extension longer than two years. The potential of having to evacuate patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. Other nearby hospitals in California may not have the appropriate supplies to quickly accommodate an influx of young patients, which underscore the importance of quickly coming into compliance with the 2030 standard. Additionally, the California Labor Federation states that bond funds have been made available to this hospital to be able to come into compliance, which at this time they have not utilized. The California Nurses Association (CNA) also opposes this bill, making similar arguments, stating that in 1994 after the Northridge earthquake, hospital workers were forced to evacuate patients, including newborn babies, down dark staircases to parking lots. CNA states that CHLA plays a critical role in providing pediatric care and the Los Angeles community should expect that CHLA will be able to care for them in the event of a seismic disaster.
Click here to enter text.
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
8/28/24 23:34:37
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1447
Author:(Durazo)
As Amended Ver:August 22, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Authorizes Children's Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) to seek approval from the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) for a delay of up to three years of the January 1, 2030 seismic safety compliance standard. Authorizes CHLA to submit a compliance plan, and, if necessary, a Nonstructural Performance Category (SPC)-5 evaluation. Requires CHLA and HCAI to identify at least two major milestones relating to the compliance plan to be used to determine if CHLA is making adequate progress toward meeting the seismic deadline. Requires HCAI to approve or deny the compliance plan and any extension within 120 days. Authorizes HCAI to adjust the extension or milestones in order to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, acts of God, governmental entitlements, or other circumstances beyond the hospitals control. Imposes a fine of $5,000 per calendar day for the hospital's failure to comply with a revised construction schedule or to meet a milestone.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations.
Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist), Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994, which required the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) (at that time Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals (GACHs) must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create SPCs, as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for "nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster." Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services.
An in-depth description of SPC and NPC rating requirements may be found in the Assembly Health Committee analysis.
Seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA's plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various "infrastructure" improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region's children, regardless of the family's ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children's Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care.
Children's Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children's Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children's hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA's radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two nuclear medicine gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
According to the Author
CHLA serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund, and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
Arguments in Support
CHLA is the sponsor of this bill and states that complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA notes that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shuttered in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Labor Federation (CLF) opposes the previous version of this bill and states that any longer extension is an unacceptable delay to the requirement that CHLA be functional and not at risk of evacuation after a major earthquake. CLF points out that the requirement to be operational after a major quake has been delayed and modified numerous times in the decades since. The existing requirements for hospitals to be operational after a major earthquake include such basic safety protections as electricity, elevators, water, sewage, oxygen, and other requirements for a functional modern hospital. The potential of having to evacuate their patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. The California Nurses Association/National Nurses United (CNA) opposes this bill and states that California must continue to hold CHLA accountable to our state's high seismic safety standards with no extension of the 2030 compliance deadline.
Arguments in Opposition Unless Amended
Service Employees International Union California State Council and Professional Engineers in California Government also oppose unless the bill is amended to limit the extension to two years and note that California hospitals have known for 30 years that they face the requirement to be fully operational after a major seismic event.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, HCAI will require the technical expertise of supervisors, architects, engineers (structural, mechanical, electrical), compliance officers, fire/life safety officers, regional compliance field staff, and administrative support personnel in the Seismic Compliance Unit, Building Standards Unit, and regions, with total costs of $1,689,000 (Hospital Building Fund), as follows:
- $309,400 for fiscal year (FY) 2029-30.
- $322,400 for FY 2030-31.
- $337,400 for FY 2031-32.
- $351,400 for FY 2032-33.
- $368,400 for FY 2033-34.
Because this bill also allows CHLA to request an additional extension, HCAI estimates additional cost pressures of $1,650,000 (Hospital Building Fund), as follows:
- $384,400 for FY 2034-35.
- $403,400 for FY 2035-36.
- $421,400 for FY 2036-37.
- $440,400 for FY 2037-38.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-2
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Archuleta
ASM HEALTH: 13-0-3
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Jackson, Flora, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Maienschein, Rodriguez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-1
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jim Patterson
UPDATED
VERSION: August 22, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004547
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1447
Author:(Durazo)
As Amended Ver:April 29, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Grants Children's Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) with a three-year extension, to January 1, 2033, of the seismic safety requirement that hospitals be capable of continued operation following a major earthquake. Permits CHLA to request an additional extension, up to January 1, 2038, if it meets certain specified criteria.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations.
Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist), Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994, which required the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) (at that time Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals (GACHs) must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create structural performance categories (SPCs), as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for "nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster." Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services.
An in-depth description of SPC and NPC rating requirements may be found in the Assembly Health Committee analysis.
Seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA's plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various "infrastructure" improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region's children, regardless of the family's ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children's Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care. CHLA states that it has a plan for feasibility, permitting, construction, and financing to reach the seismic goal, and the extension in this bill will allow for both the financing plan and the completion of the required seismic infrastructure projects.
Children's Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children's Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children's hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA's radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two nuclear medicine gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
According to the Author
CHLA serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund, and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
Arguments in Support
CHLA is the sponsor of this bill and states that complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA notes that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shuttered in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County. Furthermore, an additional 317 licensed beds in seismically compliant buildings would also be at risk due to the $100+ million investment required to relocate acute care supporting services into them and the upgrades to nonstructural elements that this necessitates. This impact to pediatric acute care capacity underscores the urgency of this request. Supporters, including the Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, state that CHLA is a beacon of hope and healing for children and families, and the financial strain of seismic compliance threatens not just the hospital's stability, but directly impacts the availability of essential pediatric beds for our community's children.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Labor Federation (CLF) opposes this bill and states that any longer extension is an unacceptable delay to the requirement that CHLA be functional and not at risk of evacuation after a major earthquake. CLF notes that in 1994, the California Legislature passed, and Republican Governor Pete Wilson signed, the law requiring that California hospitals be operational after an earthquake. This legislation was a compromise between those who sought immediate protection in the wake of an earthquake that closed numerous hospitals, with hospital workers evacuating patients, including newborn babies, in the dark down staircases to parking lots. CLF points out that the requirement to be operational after a major quake has been delayed and modified numerous times in the decades since. For example, the standards for small and rural hospitals were modified to reflect their risk. Other modifications have also been made. Similarly, hospitals that rebuilt to this higher standard were not required to retrofit to meet the lower standard of "collapse-hazard," but subject to evacuation post-quake. The existing requirements for hospitals to be operational after a major earthquake include such basic safety protections as electricity, elevators, water, sewage, oxygen, and other requirements for a functional modern hospital. As of October 2023, almost 80% of hospital buildings comply with the structural requirements that must be met by the year 2030. The potential of having to evacuate their patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. Other nearby hospitals in California may not have the appropriate supplies to quickly accommodate an influx of young patients. CLF also highlights the fact that bond funds have been made available to this hospital to be able to come into compliance, which as of this time have not been utilized. CLF encourages the Legislature to take steps to ensure that the hospital takes steps to come into compliance.
The California Nurses Association/National Nurses United (CNA) opposes this bill and states that California must continue to hold CHLA accountable to our state's high seismic safety standards with no extension of the 2030 compliance deadline. CHLA has had over 30 years to implement seismic safety requirements that would ensure the hospital can stay open and functional in the event of a major earthquake. Circumventing these seismic safety requirements now with yet another delay in deadlines endangers patients, nurses, and other health care workers. CNA concludes that nurses and other health care workers who care for patients know first-hand that in the event of an earthquake, hospitals must stand ready to not only treat patients injured during the course of an earthquake, but also to ensure that no serious interruption to patient care occurs.
Arguments in Opposition Unless Amended
The California Professional Firefighters (CPF) are opposed to this bill unless the seismic safety compliance extension is shortened to two years or less. CPF notes that evacuating any hospital that has lost the basic functions necessary for patient care poses a significant challenge, but evacuating the patients of Los Angeles Children's Hospital to a similarly equipped facility is additionally difficult given profile of the patients they serve. Firefighters and other emergency responders tasked with saving lives in the wake of a disaster would be diverted to instead rescuing the youngest and most vulnerable patients from a hospital and transporting them to another children's facility. Given the risks posed to these young patients it is even more important that Los Angeles Children's meet the 2030 deadline for the hospital seismic standard, not less.
Service Employees International Union California State Council and Professional Engineers in California Government also oppose unless the bill is amended to limit the extension to two years and note that California hospitals have known for 30 years that they face the requirement to be fully operational after a major seismic event.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, HCAI will require the technical expertise of supervisors, architects, engineers (structural, mechanical, electrical), compliance officers, fire/life safety officers, regional compliance field staff, and administrative support personnel in the Seismic Compliance Unit, Building Standards Unit, and regions, with total costs of $1,689,000 (Hospital Building Fund), as follows:
- $309,400 for fiscal year (FY) 2029-30.
- $322,400 for FY 2030-31.
- $337,400 for FY 2031-32.
- $351,400 for FY 2032-33.
- $368,400 for FY 2033-34.
Because this bill also allows CHLA to request an additional extension, HCAI estimates additional cost pressures of $1,650,000 (Hospital Building Fund), as follows:
- $384,400 for FY 2034-35.
- $403,400 for FY 2035-36.
- $421,400 for FY 2036-37.
- $440,400 for FY 2037-38.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-2
YES: Alvarado-Gil, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Archuleta
ASM HEALTH: 13-0-3
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Jackson, Flora, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, McCarty, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Maienschein, Rodriguez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-1
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Ta, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jim Patterson
UPDATED
VERSION: April 29, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004052
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1447
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2024
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 13 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends, from January 1, 2030, to January 1, 2033, the date by which Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) must meet the seismic safety requirement that the hospital be capable of continued operation following a major earthquake. The bill also allows CHLA to request an additional extension, up to January 1, 2038, if it meets specified criteria.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires CHLA to comply, no later than January 1, 2033, or a later date as approved by the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), with existing seismic safety requirements.
- Authorizes CHLA to apply to HCAI for an extension of up to five additional years, to January 1, 2038, upon the submission of a seismic compliance plan no later than January 1, 2026, and demonstration of necessity, as specified.
- Requires CHLA, as a condition of approval of an extension pursuant to 2 above, as applicable, to submit to HCAI: (a) the hospital building plans and extension schedule, as specified, and (b) a construction timeline that meets specified requirements.
- Requires CHLA and HCAI to identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether CHLA is making adequate progress towards meeting the seismic compliance deadline.
- Authorizes HCAI to grant an adjustment to the extensions of time approved pursuant to the construction timeline described in 3, above, or the milestones pursuant to 4, above, or both, as necessary to deal with delays, up to the final compliance date of January 1, 2038. Requires CHLA, if one or more adjustments is granted, to submit a revised seismic compliance plan, including, but not limited to, a revised construction schedule.
FISCAL EFFECT:
HCAI will require the technical expertise of supervisors, architects, engineers (structural, mechanical, electrical), compliance officers, fire/life safety officers, regional compliance field staff, and administrative support personnel in the Seismic Compliance Unit, Building Standards Unit, and regions, with total costs of $1,689,000 (Hospital Building Fund), as follows:
- $309,400 for fiscal year (FY) 2029-30.
- $322,400 for FY 2030-31.
- $337,400 for FY 2031-32.
- $351,400 for FY 2032-33.
- $368,400 for FY 2033-34.
Because this bill also allows CHLA to request an additional extension, HCAI estimates additional cost pressures of $1,650,000 (Hospital Building Fund), as follows:
- $384,400 for FY 2034-35.
- $403,400 for FY 2035-36.
- $421,400 for FY 2036-37.
- $440,400 for FY 2037-38.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
CHLA serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund, and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
- Background. HCAI proposes building standards for earthquake resistance and reviews the design and construction of hospital buildings. State law establishes a January 1, 2008 deadline by which a GACH must be retrofitted or replaced so it does not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake, and a January 1, 2030 deadline by which the hospital must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake. Subsequent legislation has allowed most hospitals to qualify for various extensions of the January 1, 2008 deadline. HCAI created Structural Performance Categories (SPCs) and Nonstructural Performance Categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” HCAI assigns each hospital building both an SPC and an NPC rating.
According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA must submit to HCAI its plan for removing and relocating acute care services from six buildings that it intends to remove from service. CHLA must then address the NPC requirements by making various infrastructure improvements to ensure the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other systems to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours.
- Opposition. Advocates oppose this bill or oppose it unless amended to reduce the extension to two years or less, citing safety risks to hospital and other emergency personnel, risks posed by the need to evacuate in a disaster, risks to particularly vulnerable patients, the fact that the requirements have been known for a long time and have already been delayed multiple times, among other concerns.
- Related Legislation.
- SB 1432 (Caballero) extends, to January 1, 2033, the date by which a hospital must be capable of continued operations for a hospital building whose hospital owner submits to HCAI, by specified dates, its seismic compliance plan and Nonstructural Performance Category (NPC)-5 Evaluation Report. The bill also authorizes a hospital to propose a final compliance date that extends up to five years beyond January 1, 2033, but no later than January 1, 2038. SB 1432 is pending in this committee.
- SB 1119 (Newman) extends the dates by which four hospitals owned by Providence must comply with seismic safety standards. SB 1119 is pending in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 18, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Mia Bonta, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1447
Author:(Durazo) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles.
SUMMARY: Grants Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) with a three-year extension, to January 1, 2033, of the seismic safety requirement that hospitals be capable of continued operation following a major earthquake. Permits CHLA to request an additional extension, up to January 1, 2038, if it meets certain specified criteria. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires CHLA to comply with seismic safety requirements as described in 3) of existing law, below, no later than January 1, 2033, or a later date as approved by the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), pursuant to 2) below.
- Authorizes CHLA to apply to HCAI for an extension of up to five additional years, to no later than January 1, 2038, upon the submission of a seismic compliance plan no later than January 1, 2026, and a demonstration by CHLA of one or more of the following:
- The complexity of the hospital’s seismic compliance plan detailing why the requested extension is necessary, and specifically how the hospital intends to meet the requested deadline;
- Demonstration that compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity that may not be provided by other general acute care hospitals (GACHs) within a reasonable proximity;
- The hospital owner demonstrates lack of financial capacity to substantially comply with the seismic safety regulations or standards described in 3) of existing law below, by the January 1, 2033, deadline; or,
- HCAI determines by means of a health impact assessment that removal of the building or buildings from service may significantly diminish the availability or accessibility of health care services in the community.
- Requires CHLA, as a condition of approval of an extension pursuant to 2) above, as applicable, to submit to HCAI both of the following:
- The hospital building plans and extension schedule that includes building permitting, construction commencement, and completion; and,
- A construction timeline for the building demonstrating the hospital’s intent and ability to meet the applicable deadline. Requires the timeline to include all of the following:
- The projected construction start date;
- The projected construction completion date; and,
- Identification of the contractor.
- Requires CHLA and HCAI, using the projected construction start and completion date, to identify at least two major milestones relating to the seismic compliance plan that will be used as the basis for determining whether CHLA is making adequate progress towards meeting the seismic compliance deadline.
- Authorizes HCAI to grant an adjustment to the extensions of time approved pursuant to 3) above, or the milestones pursuant to 4) above, or both, as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, with acts of God, or with governmental entitlements, experienced by CHLA, up to the final compliance date of January 1, 2038. Requires CHLA, if one or more adjustments is granted, to submit a revised seismic compliance plan, including, but not limited to, a revised construction schedule.
EXISTING LAW:
- Licenses and regulates health facilities, including GACHs, by the Department of Public Health (DPH). [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1250, et seq.]
- Establishes the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 (Seismic Safety Act), to ensure that hospital buildings are designed and constructed to resist the forces generated by earthquakes. Requires HCAI to propose building standards for earthquake resistance and to provide independent review of the design and construction of hospital buildings. [HSC §129675, et seq.]
- Establishes timelines for hospital compliance with seismic safety standards, including a requirement that buildings posing a significant risk of collapse and a danger to the public (referred to as structural performance category (SPC)-1 buildings) be rebuilt or retrofitted to be capable of withstanding an earthquake, or removed from acute care service, by January 1, 2008 (which has since been extended for various hospitals to various dates), and a requirement that hospitals must also be capable of continued operation by January 1, 2030. [HSC §130060, §130065]
- Permits HCAI to grant an extension of up to five years to the 2008 deadline (to January 1, 2013) for hospitals for which compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity, as defined. Allows HCAI to grant various further extensions beyond this, including up to seven years (to January 1, 2020), in part based on the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship. [HSC §130060, §130061.5]
- Permits HCAI, under legislation enacted in 2018, to provide for an extension of the January 1, 2020 deadline in 4) above, for up to 30 months (to July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to meet the 2020 standard, and up to five years (to January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to a standard that meets the 2030 requirement. [HSC §130062]
- Requires the owner of a hospital whose building does not substantially comply with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement described in 3) above, to submit to HCAI, by January 1, 2020, an attestation that the board of directors of that hospital is aware that the hospital building is required to meet this requirement. [HSC §130066]
- Establishes the Small and Rural Hospital Relief Program within HCAI for the purpose of funding seismic safety compliance with respect to small hospitals, rural hospitals, and critical access hospitals. Requires HCAI to provide grants to small, rural, and critical access hospital applicants that meet certain criteria, including that seismic safety compliance, as defined, imposes a financial burden on the applicant that may result in hospital closure. [HSC §130075, §130076, §130078]
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown costs for the HCAI for state administration (Hospital Building Fund).
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, CHLA serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund, and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
- BACKGROUND. The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations.
Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist), Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994, which required HCAI (at that time Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which GACH must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create SPCs, as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services.- Description of SPC ratings. Following the enactment of SB 1953, HCAI adopted regulations that initially created five SPC ratings, with a sixth category (SPC-4D) added more recently. The SPC ratings are as follows:
- SPC-1 – These are pre-1973 buildings (built prior to the adoption of the Seismic Safety Act standards) that are at significant risk of collapse and that represent a danger to the public. These buildings were originally required to be brought up to SPC-2 level or removed from service by 2008, but there have been a number of extensions. Most recently, AB 2190 (Reyes), Chapter 673, Statutes of 2018, provided for an extension until July 1, 2022 for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit to SPC-2, and up to January 1, 2025 for hospitals that plan to retrofit to SPC 4D or replace with a new SPC-5 building.
- SPC 2 – These are also pre-1973 buildings, but were in substantial compliance with pre-1973 California Building Standards Codes, and while they may not be repairable or functional following an earthquake, they will not significantly jeopardize life. These buildings are permitted to remain in service only until January 1, 2030, at which point they need to have been replaced by an SPC-5 building, have the acute care services relocated to a conforming building (SPC-3, 4, or 5), or be retrofitted to SPC-4D.
- Description of SPC ratings. Following the enactment of SB 1953, HCAI adopted regulations that initially created five SPC ratings, with a sixth category (SPC-4D) added more recently. The SPC ratings are as follows:
The following categories are 2030 compliant, and can continue operating indefinitely:
iii) SPC-3 – These buildings are in compliance with the original 1973 Seismic Safety Act, but were constructed under a permit issued prior to October 25, 1994, and utilized steel movement-resisting frames. These buildings may experience structural damage during an earthquake, which does not significantly jeopardize life, but may not be repairable or functional following strong ground motion.
iv) SPC-4 – These are buildings constructed in compliance with the Seismic Safety Act under building permits issued between 1973 and 1989, but may experience structural damage, which may inhibit the ability to provide services to the public following strong ground motion.
v) SPC-4D – This is a new category created to allow SPC 2 buildings to be retrofitted to a standard that is 2030 compliant. Because SPC 2 buildings were constructed prior to 1973, they can never reach SPC 3, 4 or 5, since these categories required construction to have started after the adoption of the 1973 standards. SPC 4D became effective on January 1, 2017.
vi) SPC-5 – These are buildings constructed after 1989, and are considered reasonably capable of providing services to the public following strong ground motion.
- Description of NPC ratings. The NPC requirements, unlike SPC requirements, are cumulative, and not different options. For example, a hospital is first required to achieve NPC-2, which ensures that the nonstructural components that are necessary for a safe evacuation are braced and anchored. Next, a hospital is required to achieve NPC-3 status, which ensures that at a minimum the critical care areas are able to continue to function following an earthquake, and so on. The NPC standards are as follows:
- NPC-1 – The building does not meet any bracing and anchorage requirements.
- NPC-2 – The following systems in the building are braced or anchored according to the California Building Standards Code: communications systems, emergency power supply, bulk medical gas systems, fire alarm systems, and emergency lighting equipment and signs in the means of egress. Hospitals had to meet at least the NPC-2 standard by January 1, 2002.
- NPC-3 – This standard requires NPC-2 compliance, plus specified additional bracing and anchorage requirements in critical care areas, clinical laboratory services spaces, pharmaceutical service spaces, radiological service spaces, and central and sterile supply areas. Hospitals had to meet this standard by January 1, 2008, unless an extension or exemption was approved. Extensions generally tracked the extensions given to SPC 1 buildings, so some buildings are not required to achieve NPC-3 until January 1, 2024.
- NPC-4 – This standard requires NPC-3 compliance, plus all architectural, mechanical, electrical systems, components and equipment, and hospital equipment to meet bracing and anchorage requirements. Hospitals are required to meet this standard by January 1, 2024 or 2030 depending on the building’s seismic risk category and extension request requirements.
- NPC-4D – This is a new category assigned to existing hospital buildings that are in compliance with NPC-3 requirements, and have additionally achieved one of three levels with regards to emergency preparedness. NPC-4D became effective on January 1, 2017. Hospitals are required to meet this standard by January 1, 2030.
- NPC-5 – This final standard requires the hospital building to meet NPC-4 or NPC-4D, plus have onsite supplies of water and holding tanks for sewage and liquid waste, sufficient to support 72 hours of emergency operations, which are required to be integrated into the plumbing systems. Additionally, an onsite emergency system, as defined in the California Electrical Code, must be incorporated in the building electrical system for critical care areas, and the system is required to provide for radiological service and onsite fuel supply for 72 hours of acute care operation. Hospitals are required to meet this standard by January 1, 2030.
- NPC-1 – The building does not meet any bracing and anchorage requirements.
- Description of NPC ratings. The NPC requirements, unlike SPC requirements, are cumulative, and not different options. For example, a hospital is first required to achieve NPC-2, which ensures that the nonstructural components that are necessary for a safe evacuation are braced and anchored. Next, a hospital is required to achieve NPC-3 status, which ensures that at a minimum the critical care areas are able to continue to function following an earthquake, and so on. The NPC standards are as follows:
c) Seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various “infrastructure” improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region’s children, regardless of the family’s ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children’s Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care. CHLA states that it has a plan for feasibility, permitting, construction, and financing to reach the seismic goal, and the extension in this bill will allow for both the financing plan and the completion of the required seismic infrastructure projects.
d) Children’s Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children’s Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children’s hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA’s radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two nuclear medicine gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
e) Building code requirements account for regional variation of seismic risk. According to HCAI, compared to rest of the nation, California, in general, has high seismicity throughout the state. Parts of the state have very high seismicity in areas of close proximity to the major earthquake faults. Other areas of the state still have high seismicity. Additionally, each facility has a seismicity value based on their location. This location-specific seismic value is used to evaluate and design buildings at that site. Therefore, the evaluation for a building located in an area with a very high seismicity value will require a stronger building that can resist stronger earthquakes when compared to the evaluation for a building in a high seismicity value area. The evaluation based on location-specific seismicity values addresses the narrow differences in seismicity levels in California. Therefore, an SPC-2 building near a fault will need to be stronger to be life-safe than an SPC-2 building located significantly farther away from a fault line.
f) Status of hospital seismic safety compliance. According to HCAI, as of February of 2024, there are a total of 3,340 buildings at 410 licensed hospital facilities that are subject to the seismic safety standards. All have achieved at least the SPC-2 standard that allows them to remain in service until 2030 except for 41 buildings spread across 20 hospital facilities. In some cases, there are no plans to retrofit or rebuild, and the hospital has either already taken them out of service but it is not reflected in the data yet, or there are plans to take them out of service prior to the January 1, 2025 deadline. It is unclear how many of the remaining out-of-compliance buildings are expected to remain in service, but are in jeopardy of missing the January 1, 2025 deadline for retrofit or replacement projects.
Regarding the 2030 deadline for buildings to achieve SPC-3, 4, 4D or 5, there are still 658 buildings, spread across 251 licensed hospitals, that have an SPC-2 rating and will need to either be retrofitted to SPC-4D, replaced with an SPC-5 building, or removed from acute care service. Of the 658 SPC-2 buildings, 151 have SPC-4D upgrade projects submitted. It is unclear how many of these 151 SPC-2 building upgrade projects will be in construction. The SPC-4D option has only been available since 2017; it is not known whether that will be utilized for the remaining buildings, or whether hospitals will choose to construct new replacement buildings.
Regarding NPC compliance, the vast majority of buildings have not yet met 2030 standards. More than half of all hospital buildings are still NPC-2. Only about 6% of all hospital buildings have achieved NPC-5 and are fully 2030 compliant. Another 34% have met NPC-4 requirements. The deadline to submit NPC construction projects is January 1, 2026, followed by an NPC construction permit deadline of January 1, 2028.
g) RAND report on estimated costs of seismic compliance. The California Hospital Association commissioned the RAND Corporation to update a prior estimate of the cost of future seismic safety compliance with a particular focus on the 2030 deadline. RAND published its report in 2019, and estimated that collectively, California hospitals faced (at that time) a range of $34 billion to $143 billion in compliance costs, depending on assumptions regarding retrofit versus new construction and future cost escalation. RAND stated that a significant proportion of hospitals were already experiencing some degree of financial distress, and the burden of future compliance is likely to exacerbate this stress.
- SUPPORT. CHLA is the sponsor of this bill and states that complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA notes that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shuttered in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County. Furthermore, an additional 317 licensed beds in seismically compliant buildings would also be at risk due to the $100+ million investment required to relocate acute care supporting services into them and the upgrades to nonstructural elements that this necessitates. This impact to pediatric acute care capacity underscores the urgency of this request. Supporters, including the Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, state that CHLA is a beacon of hope and healing for children and families, and the financial strain of seismic compliance threatens not just the hospital’s stability, but directly impacts the availability of essential pediatric beds for our community’s children
- OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. The California Professional Firefighters are opposed to this bill unless the seismic safety compliance extension is shortened to two years or less. CPF notes that evacuating any hospital that has lost the basic functions necessary for patient care poses a significant challenge, but evacuating the patients of Los Angeles Children’s Hospital to a similarly equipped facility is additionally difficult given profile of the patients they serve. Firefighters and other emergency responders tasked with saving lives in the wake of a disaster would be diverted to instead rescuing the youngest and most vulnerable patients from a hospital and transporting them to another children’s facility. Given the risks posed to these young patients it is even more important that Los Angeles Children’s meet the 2030 deadline for the hospital seismic standard, not less.
Service Employees International Union California State Council and Professional Engineers in California Government also oppose unless the bill is amended to limit the extension to two years and note that California hospitals have known for 30 years that they face the requirement to be fully operational after a major seismic event. - OPPOSITION. The California Labor Federation (CLF) opposes this bill and states that any longer extension is an unacceptable delay to the requirement that CHLA be functional and not at risk of evacuation after a major earthquake. CLF notes that in 1994, the California Legislature passed, and Republican Governor Pete Wilson signed, the law requiring that California hospitals be operational after an earthquake. This legislation was a compromise between those who sought immediate protection in the wake of an earthquake that closed numerous hospitals, with hospital workers evacuating patients, including newborn babies, in the dark down staircases to parking lots. CLF points out that the requirement to be operational after a major quake has been delayed and modified numerous times in the decades since. For example, the standards for small and rural hospitals were modified to reflect their risk. Other modifications have also been made. Similarly, hospitals that rebuilt to this higher standard were not required to retrofit to meet the lower standard of “collapse-hazard,” but subject to evacuation post-quake. The existing requirements for hospitals to be operational after a major earthquake include such basic safety protections as electricity, elevators, water, sewage, oxygen, and other requirements for a functional modern hospital. As of October 2023, almost 80% of hospital buildings comply with the structural requirements that must be met by the year 2030. The potential of having to evacuate their patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. Other nearby hospitals in California may not have the appropriate supplies to quickly accommodate an influx of young patients. CLF also highlights the fact that bond funds have been made available to this hospital to be able to come into compliance, which as of this time have not been utilized. CLF encourages the Legislature to take steps to ensure that the hospital takes steps to come into compliance.
The California Nurses Association/National Nurses United (CNA) opposes this bill and states that California must continue to hold CHLA accountable to our state’s high seismic safety standards with no extension of the 2030 compliance deadline. CHLA has had over 30 years to implement seismic safety requirements that would ensure the hospital can stay open and functional in the event of a major earthquake. Circumventing these seismic safety requirements now with yet another delay in deadlines endangers patients, nurses, and other health care workers. CNA concludes that nurses and other health care workers who care for patients know first-hand that in the event of an earthquake, hospitals must stand ready to not only treat patients injured during the course of an earthquake, but also to ensure that no serious interruption to patient care occurs. - RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 869 (Wood) creates a grant program for small and rural hospitals to fund assessments for complying with 2030 seismic safety requirements, including estimating the costs of compliance. Additionally permits qualifying small and rural, as well as financially distressed district hospitals, as defined, to apply for grants for complying with the 2030 seismic safety deadline. AB 869 extends the January 1, 2030 deadline for seismic compliance to January 1, 2035, for hospitals that apply, and qualify for, seismic compliance grants under this bill. AB 869 exempts eligible small and rural and financially distressed district hospitals from the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirements if the estimated cost of compliance is more than $1 million or 2% of the hospital’s revenue, whichever is greater, if HCAI determines that the cost of compliance results in a financial hardship for the hospital, and state or grant funding is not available to assist with the cost of compliance. AB 869 is pending in Senate Health Committee.
- SB 1432 (Caballero) extends the seismic compliance deadline for hospitals to be capable of continued operations from January 1, 2030, to January 1, 2038, creates an abeyance by which a rural hospital or critical access hospital will not be required to meet these requirements until adequate funding is made available to the hospital, and requires the hospital to submit a seismic compliance master plan by January 1, 2027, among other provisions. SB 1432 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- SB 759 (Grove) of 2023 would have extended the seismic safety deadline for hospitals to be capable of continued operations following an earthquake, from January 1, 2030 to January 1, 2040. SB 759 was never heard in Senate Health Committee.
- AB 869 (Wood) creates a grant program for small and rural hospitals to fund assessments for complying with 2030 seismic safety requirements, including estimating the costs of compliance. Additionally permits qualifying small and rural, as well as financially distressed district hospitals, as defined, to apply for grants for complying with the 2030 seismic safety deadline. AB 869 extends the January 1, 2030 deadline for seismic compliance to January 1, 2035, for hospitals that apply, and qualify for, seismic compliance grants under this bill. AB 869 exempts eligible small and rural and financially distressed district hospitals from the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirements if the estimated cost of compliance is more than $1 million or 2% of the hospital’s revenue, whichever is greater, if HCAI determines that the cost of compliance results in a financial hardship for the hospital, and state or grant funding is not available to assist with the cost of compliance. AB 869 is pending in Senate Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 1471 (Pellerin), Chapter 304, Statutes of 2023, extended the dates for compliance with seismic safety requirements for three buildings on the campus of Santa Clara Valley Medical Center, with the latest deadline being July 1, 2026.
- AB 1882 (Robert Rivas), Chapter 584, Statutes of 2022, requires owners GACH buildings that are not compliant with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement to remain operational following a major earthquake, to submit annual status updates to various entities, including the county board of supervisors, any labor union that represents workers in a building that is not January 1, 2030 compliant, the local office of emergency services, and the medical health operational area coordinator; and, requires hospitals to post in any lobby or waiting area of a hospital building that is not compliant with the January 1, 2030 seismic requirement a notice that the hospital is not in compliance.
- AB 2404 (Luz Rivas), Chapter 592, Statutes of 2022, permits HCAI to waive the requirements of the Seismic Safety Act for Pacifica Hospital of the Valley in Los Angeles County if the hospital submits a plan that proposes compliance by January 1, 2025, HCAI accepts the plan based on it being feasible, and the hospital reports to HCAI on a quarterly basis on its progress to timely complete the plan.
- AB 2904 (Bonta) of 2022 would have extended the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement for Alameda Hospital until January 1, 2032. AB 2904 was vetoed by the Governor, who stated that any consideration of an extension must be contemplated across all communities and across all types of facilities in a holistic manner.
- SB 564 (Cortese), Chapter 388, Statutes of 2021, permits HCAI to grant an extension of the seismic safety requirement that hospitals be capable of remaining standing following a major earthquake, until a maximum of December 31, 2024, for two hospitals owned by the County of Santa Clara.
- AB 1527 (Ting), Chapter 1527, Statutes of 2021, permits HCAI to extend the seismic requirements for Seton Medical Center in Daly City until July 1, 2023.
- SB 758 (Portantino) of 2020, among other provisions, would have extended the 2030 hospital seismic compliance deadline to January 1, 2037. SB 758 was amended in the Assembly Appropriations Committee when it came off the Suspense File, to reduce the extension to January 1, 2032. SB 758 was not taken up on the Assembly Floor.
- AB 2190 (Reyes), Chapter 673, Statutes of 2018, provided for an extension of the January 1, 2020, hospital seismic safety deadline of up to 30 months (until July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to at least the 2020 standard of SPC-2, and up to five years (January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to SPC-4D or SPC-5 standards that meet 2030 standards.
- AB 908 (Dababneh), Chapter 350, Statutes of 2017, permitted Providence Tarzana Medical Center in Los Angeles to request an additional extension, until October 1, 2022, of the seismic safety requirement that hospital buildings be rebuilt or retrofitted in order to be capable of withstanding an earthquake.
- AB 81 (Wood), Chapter 63, Statutes of 2015 permitted a hospital in the City of Willits to request an eight-month deadline extension of a seismic safety requirement that hospitals be rebuilt or retrofitted to be capable of withstanding an earthquake, which it was required to meet by January 1, 2015, so that this hospital could have until September 1, 2015.
- AB 2557 (Pan), Chapter 821, Statutes of 2014, permitted a hospital located in the Counties of Sacramento, San Mateo, or Santa Barbara or the City of San Jose, that had received an additional extension of the January 1, 2008, seismic safety requirements under specified provisions of existing law to January 1, 2015, to request an additional extension until September 1, 2015, in order to obtain either a certificate of occupancy or a construction final from the HCAI.
- SB 90 (Steinberg), Chapter 19, Statutes of 2011, allowed a hospital to seek an extension for seismic compliance for its SPC-1 buildings of up to seven years based on the following elements: the structural integrity of the building, the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship.
- SB 499 (Ducheny), Chapter 601, Statutes of 2009, required all GACHs that have SPC-1 buildings to report to HCAI by November 1, 2010, and annually thereafter, on the status of their compliance with the seismic safety deadlines.
- SB 306 (Ducheny), Chapter 642, Statutes of 2007, amended the Seismic Safety Act to permit hospitals to delay compliance with the July 1, 2008 seismic retrofit deadline, and the 2013 extension, to the year 2020, by filing a declaration with HCAI that the owner lacks financial capacity to comply with the law.
- SB 1661 (Cox), Chapter 679, Statutes of 2006, authorized an extension of up to an additional two years for hospitals that had already received extensions of the January 1, 2008 seismic safety compliance deadline if specified criteria were met, and required specified hospital reports to be posted on the HCAI website.
7) POLICY COMMENT. As noted above, AB 869 (Wood) and SB 1432 (Caballero) seek to create statewide standards for hospitals to come into compliance with 2030 seismic safety requirements. The Legislature may wish to consider whether a separate exemption for one hospital is appropriate.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Children's Hospital Los Angeles (sponsor)
AltaMed Health Services
Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles
California Children's Hospital Association
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZFED)
Saban Community Clinic
Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA)
Opposition
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California Nurses Association
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1447 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1447
Author: Durazo (D), et al.
Amended: 4/29/24
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/24/24
AYES: Roth, Nguyen, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SUBJECT: Hospitals: seismic compliance
SOURCE: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
DIGEST:
Provides Children’s Hospital Los Angeles with a three-year extension, to January 1, 2033, of the seismic safety requirement that hospitals be capable of continued operation following a major earthquake. Additionally, permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to request a further extension, up to a maximum of January 1, 2038, if it meets certain specified criteria.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Licenses and regulates health facilities, including general acute care hospitals, by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). [HSC §1250, et seq.]
- Establishes the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 (Seismic Safety Act), to ensure that hospital buildings are designed and constructed to resist the forces generated by earthquakes. Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) to propose building standards for earthquake resistance and to provide independent review of the design and construction of hospital buildings. [HSC §129675, et seq.]
- Establishes timelines for hospital compliance with seismic safety standards, including a requirement that buildings posing a significant risk of collapse and a danger to the public (referred to as SPC-1 buildings) be rebuilt or retrofitted to be capable of withstanding an earthquake, or removed from acute care service, by January 1, 2008 (which has since been extended for various hospitals to various dates), and a requirement that hospitals must also be capable of continued operation by January 1, 2030. [HSC §130060, §130065]
- Permits HCAI to grant an extension of up to five years to the 2008 deadline (January 1, 2013) for hospitals for which compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity, as defined. Allows HCAI to grant various further extensions beyond this, including up to seven years (January 1, 2020), in part based on the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship. [HSC §130060, §130061.5]
- Permits HCAI, under legislation enacted in 2018, to provide for an extension of the January 1, 2020 deadline in 4) above, for up to 30 months (July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to meet the 2020 standard, and up to five years (January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to a standard that meets the 2030 requirement. [HSC §130062]
- Requires the owner of a hospital whose building does not substantially comply with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement described in 3) above, to submit to HCAI, by January 1, 2020, an attestation that the board of directors of that hospital is aware that the hospital building is required to meet this requirement. [HSC §130066]
- Establishes the Small and Rural Hospital Relief Program within HCAI for the purpose of funding seismic safety compliance with respect to small hospitals, rural hospitals, and critical access hospitals. Requires HCAI to provide grants to small, rural, and critical access hospital applicants that meet certain criteria, including that seismic safety compliance, as defined, imposes a financial burden on the applicant that may result in hospital closure. [HSC §130075, §130076, §130078]
This bill:
- Extends the deadline for Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to comply with the requirements for a hospital to remain capable of continued operation following a major earthquake by three years to January 1, 2033.
- Permits Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to apply for an additional extension of up to five years past the January 1, 2033 extension granted pursuant to 1) above, upon the submission of a seismic compliance plan no later than January 1, 2026, and a demonstration by the hospital of one or more of the following:
- The complexity of the hospital’s seismic compliance plan;
- Compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity that may not be provided by other hospitals within a reasonable proximity;
- Lack of financial capacity to comply; or,
- Based on a health impact assessment, removal of the building or buildings from service may significantly diminish the availability or accessibility of health care services in the community.
- Requires, as a condition of an approval by HCAI of any extension past January 1, 2033, Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to do the following: submit building plans and an extension schedule that includes permitting, construction commencement and completion; a construction timeline; and, together with HCAI, identify at least two major milestones to be used as the basis for determining whether the hospital is making adequate progress toward meeting the compliance deadline.
- Permits HCAI to grant an adjustment to the extensions of time approved or to the milestones as necessary to deal with contractor, labor, or material delays, with acts of God, or with governmental entitlements, experienced by the hospital, up to the final compliance date of January 1, 2038. Requires Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to submit a revised seismic compliance plan if one or more adjustments are granted.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author:
Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
- Background on hospital seismic safety requirements. The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations. Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist, Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994), which required HCAI (at that time OSHPD) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create structural performance categories (SPCs), as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services.
- Background on seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various “infrastructure” improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region’s children, regardless of the family’s ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children’s Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care. CHLA states that it has a plan for feasibility, permitting, construction, and financing to reach the seismic goal, and the extension in this bill will allow for both the financing plan and the completion of the required seismic infrastructure projects.
- Children’s Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children’s Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children’s hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new MRI machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA’s radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two NM gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
- Status of hospital seismic safety compliance. According to HCAI, as of February of 2024, there are a total of 3,340 buildings at 410 licensed hospital facilities that are subject to the seismic safety standards. All have achieved at least the SPC-2 standard that allows them to remain in service until 2030 except for 41 buildings spread across 20 hospital facilities. In some cases, there are no plans to retrofit or rebuild, and the hospital has either already taken them out of service but it is not reflected in the data yet, or there are plans to take them out of service prior to the January 1, 2025 deadline. It is unclear how many of the remaining out-of-compliance buildings are expected to remain in service, but are in jeopardy of missing the January 1, 2025 deadline for retrofit or replacement projects.
Regarding the 2030 deadline for buildings to achieve SPC-3, 4, 4D or 5, there are still 658 buildings, spread across 251 licensed hospitals, that have an SPC-2 rating and will need to either be retrofitted to SPC-4D, replaced with an SPC-5 building, or removed from acute care service. Of the 658 SPC-2 buildings, 151 have SPC-4D upgrade projects submitted. It is unclear how many of these 151 SPC-2 building upgrade projects will be in construction. The SPC-4D option has only been available since 2017; it is not known whether that will be utilized for the remaining buildings, or whether hospitals will choose to construct new replacement buildings.
Regarding NPC compliance, the vast majority of buildings have not yet met 2030 standards. More than half of all hospital buildings are still NPC-2. Only about 6% of all hospital buildings have achieved NPC-5 and are fully 2030 compliant. Another 34% have met NPC-4 requirements. The deadline to submit NPC construction projects is January 1, 2026, followed by an NPC construction permit deadline of January 1, 2028.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
Unknown costs for the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) for state administration (Hospital Building Fund).
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/1/24)
Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (source)
Altamed Health Services
Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles
California Children’s Hospital Association
Community Health System
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Saban Community Clinic
Valley Industrial and Commerce Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/1/24)
California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters (unless amended)
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (unless amended)
Professional Engineers in California Government (unless amended)
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) (source) states:
Complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million for CHLA. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA states that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shutter in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County. Furthermore, an additional 317 licensed beds in seismically compliant buildings would also be at risk due to the $100+ million investment required to relocate acute care supporting services into them and the upgrades to nonstructural elements that this necessitates. This impact to pediatric acute care capacity underscores the urgency of this request. Supporters, including the Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, state that CHLA is a beacon of hope and healing for children and families, and the financial strain of seismic compliance threatens not just the hospital’s stability, but directly impacts the availability of essential pediatric beds for our community’s children.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Labor Federation states:
It is opposed to any extension longer than two years. The potential of having to evacuate patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. Other nearby hospitals in California may not have the appropriate supplies to quickly accommodate an influx of young patients, which underscore the importance of quickly coming into compliance with the 2030 standard. Additionally, the California Labor Federation states that bond funds have been made available to this hospital to be able to come into compliance, which at this time they have not utilized. The California Nurses Association (CNA) also opposes this bill, making similar arguments, stating that in 1994 after the Northridge earthquake, hospital workers were forced to evacuate patients, including newborn babies, down dark staircases to parking lots. CNA states that CHLA plays a critical role in providing pediatric care and the Los Angeles community should expect that CHLA will be able to care for them in the event of a seismic disaster.
Oppose unless amended. The California Professional Firefighters (CPF), SEIU California, and the Professional Engineers in California Government (PECG) all oppose this bill unless amended to be an extension for a maximum of two years. CPF states California hospitals have had 30 years to plan for this deadline, and indeed have another six years in which to complete the work needed to come into compliance. CPF states that firefighters and public safety personnel cannot properly perform their duties to preserve life during an earthquake if they have to also worry about the local hospital failing to care for patients in a time of emergency. SEIU California and PECG make similar arguments.
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
5/17/24 15:29:01
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1447 (Durazo) - Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
Version: April 29, 2024 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 11 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2024 | Consultant: Agnes Lee |
Bill Summary:
SB 1447 would provide, for the Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA), extensions of the January 1, 2030 deadline by which hospitals are required to be capable of continued operations following a major earthquake, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
Unknown costs for the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) for state administration (Hospital Building Fund).
Background:
Current law requires the HCAI to propose building standards for earthquake resistance and to provide independent review of the design and construction of hospital buildings. State law established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake, and a January 1, 2030 deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake. Subsequent legislation has allowed most hospitals to qualify for various extensions of the January 1, 2008 deadline.
Current law requires HCAI to create Structural Performance Categories (SPCs), as well as Nonstructural Performance Categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various “infrastructure” improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (the NPC requirements).
Proposed Law:
SB 1447 would extend, for the CHLA, the January 1, 2030 deadline for seismic compliance to no later than January 1, 2033; or to a later date as approved by the HCAI for an extension of up to five additional years, to no later than January 1, 2038, upon the submission of a seismic compliance plan, as specified, and a demonstration by the CHLA of specified items.
Related Legislation:
SB 1119 (Newman) would extend the dates by which four hospitals owned by Providence are required to comply with seismic safety standards. The bill is currently on the suspense file in this committee.
SB 1432 (Caballero) would provide for extensions of the January 1, 2030 seismic compliance deadline for hospitals. The bill is scheduled to be heard on May 6, 2024 in this committee.
AB 869 (Wood, 2023) would provide for an abeyance of the January 1, 2030 seismic compliance deadline for certain small and rural hospitals, as specified. The bill is currently in the Senate Health Committee.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
BILL NO: SB 1447
AUTHOR: | Durazo | ||
VERSION: | March 19, 2024 | ||
HEARING DATE: | April 24, 2024 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles
SUMMARY:
Provides Children’s Hospital Los Angeles with a ten-year extension, to January 1, 2040, of the seismic safety requirement that hospitals be capable of continued operation following a major earthquake.
Existing law:
- Licenses and regulates health facilities, including general acute care hospitals, by the California Department of Public Health (CDPH). [HSC §1250, et seq.]
- Establishes the Alfred E. Alquist Hospital Facilities Seismic Safety Act of 1983 (Seismic Safety Act), to ensure that hospital buildings are designed and constructed to resist the forces generated by earthquakes. Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) to propose building standards for earthquake resistance and to provide independent review of the design and construction of hospital buildings. [HSC §129675, et seq.]
- Establishes timelines for hospital compliance with seismic safety standards, including a requirement that buildings posing a significant risk of collapse and a danger to the public (referred to as SPC-1 buildings) be rebuilt or retrofitted to be capable of withstanding an earthquake, or removed from acute care service, by January 1, 2008 (which has since been extended for various hospitals to various dates), and a requirement that hospitals must also be capable of continued operation by January 1, 2030. [HSC §130060, §130065]
- Permits HCAI to grant an extension of up to five years to the 2008 deadline (January 1, 2013) for hospitals for which compliance will result in a loss of health care capacity, as defined. Allows HCAI to grant various further extensions beyond this, including up to seven years (January 1, 2020), in part based on the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship. [HSC §130060, §130061.5]
- Permits HCAI, under legislation enacted in 2018, to provide for an extension of the January 1, 2020 deadline in 4) above, for up to 30 months (July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to meet the 2020 standard, and up to five years (January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to a standard that meets the 2030 requirement. [HSC §130062]
- Requires the owner of a hospital whose building does not substantially comply with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement described in 3) above, to submit to HCAI, by January 1, 2020, an attestation that the board of directors of that hospital is aware that the hospital building is required to meet this requirement. [HSC §130066]
- Establishes the Small and Rural Hospital Relief Program within HCAI for the purpose of funding seismic safety compliance with respect to small hospitals, rural hospitals, and critical access hospitals. Requires HCAI to provide grants to small, rural, and critical access hospital applicants that meet certain criteria, including that seismic safety compliance, as defined, imposes a financial burden on the applicant that may result in hospital closure. [HSC §130075, §130076, §130078]
This bill: Requires the Children’s Hospital Los Angeles to comply with the requirements for a hospital to remain capable of continued operation following a major earthquake no later than January 1, 2040.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (CHLA) serves as a critical element of the availability of pediatric hospital beds for treating children in the Los Angeles region and beyond, including at least 60% of Medi-Cal patients occupying those beds on a daily basis, while also serving as a key primary teaching hospital for the Los Angeles region. An extension to meet seismic safety retrofit standards will allow CHLA to continue serving the critical pediatric healthcare needs of the region and also allow sufficient time for CHLA to plan for, fund and become compliant with the necessary seismic retrofit upgrades.
- Background on hospital seismic safety requirements. The original Seismic Safety Act was passed in 1973, following the 1971 San Fernando Valley (also known as Sylmar) earthquake, and required all new hospital construction to meet seismic safety standards. The Seismic Safety Act did not apply to existing buildings with the expectation that older buildings would be replaced with conforming buildings over time. By the time of the Northridge earthquake in 1994, however, 80% of hospital beds were still in pre-1973 non-conforming buildings. The Northridge earthquake caused significant structural damage to a number of hospitals, with at least two hospitals needing to be evacuated. What also became apparent in the Northridge earthquake was that nonstructural damage was also a threat to patient safety, with damage to heating and ventilation systems and sprinklers, forcing evacuations. Following the Northridge earthquake, the Legislature updated the Seismic Safety Act with SB 1953 (Alquist, Chapter 740, Statutes of 1994), which required HCAI (at that time OSHPD) to establish earthquake performance categories for hospitals. SB 1953 also established a January 1, 2008 deadline by which general acute care hospitals must be retrofitted or replaced so that they do not pose a risk of collapse in the event of an earthquake (which has been repeatedly extended by subsequent legislation for most hospitals), and a January 1, 2030, deadline by which they must be capable of remaining operational following an earthquake.
Specifically, SB 1953 required HCAI to create structural performance categories (SPCs), as well as nonstructural performance categories (NPCs) for “nonstructural systems that are critical to providing basic services to hospital inpatients and the public after a disaster.” Each hospital building receives both an SPC and an NPC rating. According to HCAI, the SPC requirements can be thought of as protecting the skeleton, while NPC requirements ensure the organs and other tissues that are necessary for a human body to function will remain safely attached to the skeleton. It is important to note that a licensed facility, or hospital, is often made up of several buildings on its campus. Many hospitals may have one or more buildings that are 2030 compliant, while other buildings still need to be retrofitted, replaced, or changed to a use that is not associated with acute care services. - Description of SPC ratings. Following the enactment of SB 1953, HCAI adopted regulations that initially created five SPC ratings, with a sixth category (SPC-4D) added more recently. The SPC ratings are as follows:
- SPC-1 – These are pre-1973 buildings (built prior to the adoption of the Seismic Safety Act standards) that are at significant risk of collapse and that represent a danger to the public. These buildings were originally required to be brought up to SPC-2 level or removed from service by 2008, but there have been a number of extensions. Most recently, AB 2190 (Reyes, Chapter 673, Statutes of 2018), provided for an extension until July 1, 2022 for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit to SPC-2, and up to January 1, 2025 for hospitals that plan to retrofit to SPC 4D or replace with a new SPC-5 building.
- SPC 2 – These are also pre-1973 buildings, but were in substantial compliance with pre-1973 California Building Standards Codes, and while they may not be repairable or functional following an earthquake, they will not significantly jeopardize life. These buildings are permitted to remain in service only until January 1, 2030, at which point they need to have been replaced by an SPC-5 building, have the acute care services relocated to a conforming building (SPC-3, 4, or 5), or be retrofitted to SPC-4D.
The following categories are 2030 compliant, and can continue operating indefinitely:
- SPC-3 – These buildings are in compliance with the original 1973 Seismic Safety Act, but were constructed under a permit issued prior to October 25, 1994, and utilized steel movement-resisting frames. These buildings may experience structural damage during an earthquake, which does not significantly jeopardize life, but may not be repairable or functional following strong ground motion.
- SPC-4 – These are buildings constructed in compliance with the Seismic Safety Act under building permits issued between 1973 and 1989, but may experience structural damage, which may inhibit the ability to provide services to the public following strong ground motion.
- SPC-4D – This is a new category created to allow SPC 2 buildings to be retrofitted to a standard that is 2030 compliant. Because SPC 2 buildings were constructed prior to 1973, they can never reach SPC 3, 4 or 5, since these categories required construction to have started after the adoption of the 1973 standards. SPC 4D became effective on January 1, 2017.
- SPC-5 – These are buildings constructed after 1989, and are considered reasonably capable of providing services to the public following strong ground motion.
- Description of NPC ratings. The NPC requirements, unlike SPC requirements, are cumulative, and not different options. For example, a hospital is first required to achieve NPC-2, which ensures that the nonstructural components that are necessary for a safe evacuation are braced and anchored. Next, a hospital is required to achieve NPC-3 status, which ensures that at a minimum the critical care areas are able to continue to function following an earthquake, and so on. The NPC standards are as follows:
- NPC-1 – The building does not meet any bracing and anchorage requirements.
- NPC-2 – The following systems in the building are braced or anchored according to the California Building Standards Code: communications systems, emergency power supply, bulk medical gas systems, fire alarm systems, and emergency lighting equipment and signs in the means of egress. Hospitals had to meet at least the NPC-2 standard by January 1, 2002.
- NPC-3 – This standard requires NPC-2 compliance, plus specified additional bracing and anchorage requirements in critical care areas, clinical laboratory services spaces, pharmaceutical service spaces, radiological service spaces, and central and sterile supply areas. Hospitals had to meet this standard by January 1, 2008, unless an extension or exemption was approved. Extensions generally tracked the extensions given to SPC 1 buildings, so some buildings are not required to achieve NPC-3 until January 1, 2024.
- NPC-4 – This standard requires NPC-3 compliance, plus all architectural, mechanical, electrical systems, components and equipment, and hospital equipment to meet bracing and anchorage requirements. Hospitals are required to meet this standard by January 1, 2024 or 2030 depending on the building’s seismic risk category and extension request requirements.
- NPC-4D – This is a new category assigned to existing hospital buildings that are in compliance with NPC-3 requirements, and have additionally achieved one of three levels with regards to emergency preparedness. NPC-4D became effective on January 1, 2017. Hospitals are required to meet this standard by January 1, 2030.
- NPC-5 – This final standard requires the hospital building to meet NPC-4 or NPC-4D, plus have onsite supplies of water and holding tanks for sewage and liquid waste, sufficient to support 72 hours of emergency operations, which are required to be integrated into the plumbing systems. Additionally, an onsite emergency system, as defined in the California Electrical Code, must be incorporated in the building electrical system for critical care areas, and the system is required to provide for radiological service and onsite fuel supply for 72 hours of acute care operation. Hospitals are required to meet this standard by January 1, 2030.
- Background on seismic status of CHLA. According to information provided by HCAI, CHLA is comprised of 13 buildings in use for general acute care services at their main campus on Sunset Boulevard. The hospital relies on all buildings for ongoing care delivery or support functions. Four of the buildings provide the bulk of direct care services, including Duque, McAllister, Anderson, and Surgery Center. While Anderson and Surgery Center are both SPC-5 and NPC-4, Duque and McAllister are SPC-2 and must retrofit or be removed from acute care use starting by 2030. According to HCAI, in December 2022 and again in December 2023, the facility informed HCAI that six general acute care buildings in one contiguous grouping will be converted to non-acute functions by 2030, including Duque and McAllister. HCAI states that they have received NPC-4 and NPC-5 evaluations for the buildings that will remain in service beyond 2030, no NPC evaluations were required for the six buildings that CHLA intends to remove from acute care services. According to HCAI, based on CHLA’s plans, CHLA will be compliant with seismic safety requirements related to structural integrity by 2030. By January 1, 2026, to comply with regulatory requirements, CHLA is required to submit to HCAI their plan for removing and relocating acute care services from the six buildings that they have stated they intend to remove from service.
According to CHLA, it has actually met the primary earthquake retrofit structural standards required for 2030. The next set of retrofit standards applicable to CHLA are aimed at the various “infrastructure” improvements to assure that the hospital and its campus have adequate water, sewer, power generation, and other infrastructure to independently support operation of the hospital and its campus for a minimum of 72 hours (these are the NPC requirements). CHLA states that while it has been working to both plan for and achieve compliance with these updates, CHLA also has a primary role to provide acute healthcare for the region’s children, regardless of the family’s ability to pay. CHLA services a minimum of 70% or more Medi-Cal recipients and nearly 60% of their inpatient population are children eligible for the California Children’s Services (CCS) program. CHLA states that providing this high level of patient care requires significant investments, and CHLA experienced an annual $80 million reduction of CCS funding, which required a prioritization of focus to day-to-day patient care. CHLA states that it has a plan for feasibility, permitting, construction, and financing to reach the seismic goal, and the extension in this bill will allow for both the financing plan and the completion of the required seismic infrastructure projects. - Children’s Hospital Bond funding. There have been three voter-approved Children’s Hospital Bond acts over the past 20 years, providing general obligation bonds to fund specified children’s hospitals. In 2004, California voters passed Proposition 61 to issue $750 million in general obligations bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $72 million. In 2008, Proposition 3 enabled the issuance of an additional $980 million in bonds, of which CHLA was awarded $97.4 million. In 2018, voters passed Proposition 4 to issue $1.5 billion in bonds, of which the initiative allocated $135 million to CHLA. From this most recent 2018 bond program, CHLA has already been awarded nearly $90 million in grant funding, spread across four projects. CHLA has approximately $45 million in grant fund eligibility remaining for future awards. Of the $90 million grant funds already awarded from the 2018 bond program, the two largest are: $22 million to fund the renovation, furnishing, and equipping of a vacated space in the Duque building to create a dedicated space for pediatric cardiac imaging services, including two new MRI machines; and, a $44.5 million project to fund the renovation, equipping, and furnishing of an existing space in CHLA’s radiology department in the Duque building, to expand its Post Anesthesia Care Unit and to relocate and expand its Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography (PET/CT), Nuclear Medicine, and MRI departments, including one PET/CT machine, two NM gamma cameras, and one MRI machine.
- Building code requirements account for regional variation of seismic risk. According to HCAI, compared to rest of the nation, California, in general, has high seismicity throughout the state. Parts of the state have very high seismicity in areas of close proximity to the major earthquake faults. Other areas of the state still have high seismicity. Additionally, each facility has a seismicity value based on their location. This location-specific seismic value is used to evaluate and design buildings at that site. Therefore, the evaluation for a building located in an area with a very high seismicity value will require a stronger building that can resist stronger earthquakes when compared to the evaluation for a building in a high seismicity value area. The evaluation based on location-specific seismicity values addresses the narrow differences in seismicity levels in California. Therefore, an SPC-2 building near a fault will need to be stronger to be life-safe than an SPC-2 building located significantly farther away from a fault line.
- Status of hospital seismic safety compliance. According to HCAI, as of February of 2024, there are a total of 3,340 buildings at 410 licensed hospital facilities that are subject to the seismic safety standards. All have achieved at least the SPC-2 standard that allows them to remain in service until 2030 except for 41 buildings spread across 20 hospital facilities. In some cases, there are no plans to retrofit or rebuild, and the hospital has either already taken them out of service but it is not reflected in the data yet, or there are plans to take them out of service prior to the January 1, 2025 deadline. It is unclear how many of the remaining out-of-compliance buildings are expected to remain in service, but are in jeopardy of missing the January 1, 2025 deadline for retrofit or replacement projects.
Regarding the 2030 deadline for buildings to achieve SPC-3, 4, 4D or 5, there are still 658 buildings, spread across 251 licensed hospitals, that have an SPC-2 rating and will need to either be retrofitted to SPC-4D, replaced with an SPC-5 building, or removed from acute care service. Of the 658 SPC-2 buildings, 151 have SPC-4D upgrade projects submitted. It is unclear how many of these 151 SPC-2 building upgrade projects will be in construction. The SPC-4D option has only been available since 2017; it is not known whether that will be utilized for the remaining buildings, or whether hospitals will choose to construct new replacement buildings.
Regarding NPC compliance, the vast majority of buildings have not yet met 2030 standards. More than half of all hospital buildings are still NPC-2. Only about 6% of all hospital buildings have achieved NPC-5 and are fully 2030 compliant. Another 34% have met NPC-4 requirements. The deadline to submit NPC construction projects is January 1, 2026, followed by an NPC construction permit deadline of January 1, 2028. - RAND report on costs of seismic compliance. The California Hospital Association (which supports this bill) commissioned the RAND Corporation to update a prior estimate of the cost of future seismic safety compliance with a particular focus on the 2030 deadline. RAND published its report in 2019, and estimated that collectively, California hospitals faced (at that time) a range of $34 billion to $143 billion in compliance costs, depending on assumptions regarding retrofit versus new construction and future cost escalation. RAND stated that a significant proportion of hospitals were already experiencing some degree of financial distress, and the burden of future compliance is likely to exacerbate this stress. RAND suggested that there are a variety of options to provide regulatory relief or flexibility to hospitals, including providing public subsidies, offering additional flexibility in the timing of compliance, rethinking what it means for hospitals to remain operational after an earthquake, and streamlining the administrative processes associated with seismic compliance projects.
- Related legislation. SB 1432 (Caballero) extends the January 1, 2030 deadline by which hospitals are required to be capable of continued operations following a major earthquake, until January 1, 2038. Gives rural hospitals and critical access hospitals an “abeyance” from this same seismic compliance deadline until such time that adequate funding is made available these hospitals. Requires hospitals to submit a seismic compliance plan by January 1, 2027, which includes, among other elements, the cost of compliance using criteria developed by HCAI. Requires HCAI to provide a report to the Legislature with an analysis of each hospital’s estimated cost of compliance and an estimate of the total statewide cost. Requires HCAI, in consultation with the California Health Facilities Financing Authority, to provide a Hospital Construction Financing Overview report to the Legislature. Requires a hospital with one or more buildings that are not fully compliant with the seismic safety requirements to submit a Patient Alternate Care Sites and Transfer Plan to HCAI by January 1, 2026. SB 1432 is set for hearing on April 24, 2024 in this Committee.
SB 1119 (Newman) extends the dates by which four hospitals owned by Providence are required to comply with seismic safety standards, including two hospitals on a consolidated license in Eureka, one hospital in Fullerton, and one hospital in Tarzana. SB 1119 is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committeee.
AB 869 (Wood) creates a grant program for small and rural hospitals to fund assessments for complying with 2030 seismic safety requirements, including estimating the costs of compliance. Permits qualifying small and rural, as well as financially distressed district hospitals, as defined, to apply for grants for complying with the 2030 seismic safety deadline. Extends the January 1, 2030 deadline for seismic compliance to January 1, 2035, for hospitals that apply, and qualify for, seismic compliance grants under this bill. Exempts eligible small and rural and financially distressed district hospitals from the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirements if the estimated cost of compliance is more than $1 million or 2% of the hospital’s revenue, whichever is greater, if HCAI determines that the cost of compliance results in a financial hardship for the hospital, and state or grant funding is not available to assist with the cost of compliance. AB 869 is pending in this Committee. - Prior legislation. SB 1339 (Pan of 2022) would have required general acute care hospital buildings with specific seismic ratings to submit estimated costs to comply with the 2030 seismic requirements to HCAI. SB 1339 would have required HCAI to provide a report to the Legislature with an assessment of the projected costs to retrofit each hospital building to meet the 2030 seismic requirements. SB 1339 was held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
AB 1882 (Robert Rivas, Chapter 584, Statutes of 2022) requires owners of general acute care hospital buildings that are not compliant with the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement to remain operational following a major earthquake, to submit annual status updates to various entities, including the county board of supervisors, any labor union that represents workers in a building that is not January 1, 2030 compliant, the local office of emergency services, and the medical health operational area coordinator; and, requires hospitals to post in any lobby or waiting area of a hospital building that is not compliant with the January 1, 2030 seismic requirement a notice that the hospital is not in compliance.
AB 2904 (Bonta of 2022) would have extended the January 1, 2030 seismic safety requirement for Alameda Hospital until January 1, 2032. AB 2904 was vetoed by the Governor, who stated that any consideration of an extension must be contemplated across all communities and across all types of facilities in a holistic manner.
SB 758 (Portantino of 2020), among other provisions, would have extended the 2030 hospital seismic compliance deadline to January 1, 2032. SB 758 was not taken up on the Assembly Floor.
AB 2190 (Reyes, Chapter 673, Statutes of 2018) provides for an extension of the January 1, 2020 hospital seismic safety deadline of up to 30 months (until July 1, 2022) for hospitals that plan to replace or retrofit a building to at least the 2020 standard of SPC-2, and up to five years (January 1, 2025) for hospitals that plan to rebuild to SPC-4D or SPC-5 standards that meet 2030 standards. Additionally, required OSHPD to provide the Legislature with an inventory of the SPC category of each hospital building before June 1, 2019, and required hospitals that do not comply with the January 1, 2030 deadline to submit an attestation to OSHPD that it is aware of the deadline.
SB 90 (Steinberg, Chapter 19, Statutes of 2011) allows a hospital to seek an extension for seismic compliance for its SPC-1 buildings of up to seven years based on the following elements: the structural integrity of the building, the loss of essential hospital services to the community if the hospital closed, and financial hardship.
SB 499 (Ducheny, Chapter 601, Statutes of 2009) required all general acute care hospitals that have SPC-1 buildings to report to OSHPD by November 1, 2010, and annually thereafter, on the status of their compliance with the seismic safety deadlines.
SB 306 (Ducheny, Chapter 642, Statutes of 2007) amends the Alquist Act to permit hospitals to delay compliance with the July 1, 2008 seismic retro deadline, and the 2013 extension, to the year 2020, by filing a declaration with OSHPD that the owner lacks financial capacity to comply with the law. - Support. This bill is sponsored by CHLA, which states that complying with the seismic safety retrofit standards will require a significantly burdensome capital outlay expenditure of at least $230 million for CHLA. The extension provided in this bill will allow CHLA to achieve a comprehensive plan for both funding and construction of the seismic upgrades, while also ensuring the hospital beds that are so critical to serving the children of the Los Angeles region and beyond are maintained. CHLA states that it has 121 licensed beds that would be shutter in 2030 because they are located in buildings that will be excluded from housing acute care, and that this number represents 10% of pediatric beds in Los Angeles County. Furthermore, an additional 317 licensed beds in seismically compliant buildings would also be at risk due to the $100+ million investment required to relocate acute care supporting services into them and the upgrades to nonstructural elements that this necessitates. This impact to pediatric acute care capacity underscores the urgency of this request. Supporters, including the Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles and the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce, state that CHLA is a beacon of hope and healing for children and families, and the financial strain of seismic compliance threatens not just the hospital’s stability, but directly impacts the availability of essential pediatric beds for our community’s children.
- Opposition. The California Labor Federation states that it is opposed to any extension longer than two years. The potential of having to evacuate patients at CHLA presents unique challenges due to the types of patients they serve. Other nearby hospitals in California may not have the appropriate supplies to quickly accommodate an influx of young patients, which underscore the importance of quickly coming into compliance with the 2030 standard. Additionally, the California Labor Federation states that bond funds have been made available to this hospital to be able to come into compliance, which at this time they have not utilized. The California Nurses Association (CNA) also opposes this bill, making similar arguments, stating that in 1994 after the Northridge earthquake, hospital workers were forced to evacuate patients, including newborn babies, down dark staircases to parking lots. CNA states that CHLA plays a critical role in providing pediatric care and the Los Angeles community should expect that CHLA will be able to care for them in the event of a seismic disaster.
- Oppose unless amended. The California Professional Firefighters (CPF), SEIU California, and the Professional Engineers in California Government (PECG) all oppose this bill unless amended to be an extension for a maximum of two years. CPF states California hospitals have had 30 years to plan for this deadline, and indeed have another six years in which to complete the work needed to come into compliance. CPF states that firefighters and public safety personnel cannot properly perform their duties to preserve life during an earthquake if they have to also worry about the local hospital failing to care for patients in a time of emergency. SEIU California and PECG make similar arguments.
- Policy comments.
- CHLA extension appears entirely for meeting NPC requirements. According to information from both CHLA and HCAI, CHLA does not have plans to do any further retrofit or new construction projects to meet the structural requirements of the 2030 deadline. Instead, they still plan to remove a group of hospital buildings, including two of their main buildings that are still SPC-2, from acute care service and use them for outpatient services, such as imaging. In fact, as noted above, CHLA is currently using grants from the Children’s Hospital Bond program to expand their imaging capacity in Duque, one of the buildings that they plan to remove from acute care service. CHLA states that they need the extension due to the extensive, and expensive, nature of their planned NPC upgrade projects, including water and sewer infrastructure projects and other utility-related upgrades. In the meantime, under this bill’s proposed 10-year extension, CHLA will be able to continue using the McAllister and Duque buildings for acute care service while completing their planned NPC compliance projects across the hospital campus.
- No hospital has yet had an extension of the 2030 deadline. While there have been several legislative attempts to extend the 2030 deadline for hospitals as a group, none of those bills have made it to the Governor’s desk. The only legislation to be approved by the Legislature that would have extended the 2030 deadline was AB 2904 (Bonta of 2022), which would have given Alameda Hospital an extra two years, and it was vetoed by the Governor. This session, there are several bills seeking to extend the 2030 deadline for hospitals as a group, including SB 1432 (Caballero) that is being heard at the same hearing as this bill and is proposing an 8-year extension for all hospitals. The committee may wish to consider whether it would be sending mixed messages to advance bills that, on the one hand, would grant all hospitals 8 years subject to certain conditions, and on the other hand, grant a single hospital an unconditional 10 year extension.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles (sponsor)
Altamed Health Services
Boys & Girls Club Metro Los Angeles
California Children’s Hospital Association
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Saban Community Clinic
Oppose: California Labor Federation
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters (unless amended)
SEIU California (unless amended)
Professional Engineers in California Government (unless amended)
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):