SB 1477: School accountability: independent study, educational enrichment activities, oversight, and audit requirements.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-16
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-06-26: June 26 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Under existing law, once the Controller or county superintendent of schools makes a final determination that specified audits performed by a certified public accountant or public accountant were not performed in substantial conformity with provisions of an audit guide, or that the audit reports do not conform to the provisions of an audit guide, the certified public accountant or public accountant is ineligible to conduct specified audits for 3 years. Existing law requires the Controller to notify each school district and county office of education of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible pursuant to these provisions.
This bill would extend the above-described rules related to the ineligibility of the certified public accountant or public accountant to audits of a nonclassroom-based charter school, as provided, and would additionally require the Controller to notify charter schools of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible to conduct these audits, as provided.
(2)The Charter Schools Act of 1992 specifies the procedures for the submission, review, and approval or denial of a petition to establish a charter school. The act requires a petition for the establishment of a charter school to contain specified information, including a reasonably comprehensive description of the manner in which annual, independent financial audits will be conducted. Existing law, by not later than May 1 of each fiscal year, requires the governing board of each local educational agency to provide for an audit of the books and accounts of the local educational agency, as specified, or make arrangements with the county superintendent of schools to provide for that auditing.
By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 of each year thereafter, this bill would require the governing body of a charter school to review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. By imposing additional requirements on charter schools, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an auditor of a nonclassroom-based charter school, when performing certain audits, to take certain actions, including the sampling of certain financial documents, the identification of transfers of funds or assets exceeding prescribed amounts, the identification of transactions that do not meet certain standards, and the preparation of a letter to be included with the audit report, as specified.
(3)Existing law prohibits a school district, county office of education, or charter school from being eligible to receive apportionments for independent study by pupils unless the local educational agency has adopted written policies, and implemented those policies, in accordance with rules and regulations adopted by the Superintendent of Public Instruction, as specified, including a requirement that a current written agreement with specified content for each independent study pupil is maintained on file.Commencing July 1, 2025, this bill would authorize the State Department of Education to assess an administrative penalty of $10,000 on a local educational agency if an employee of the local educational agency, as part of the independent study written agreement, willfully states as true any material fact that the employee knows to be false.(4)(3)Commencing July 1, 2025, this bill would require a school district, county office of education, or charter school to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to the bill. The bill would authorize a local educational agency to expend public funds for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities, provided that all educational enrichment activities, materials, and programs are nonsectarian.
The bill would require the governing board or body of a local educational agency, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and would further require that these policies ensure that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria. The bill would require auditing of approval of, and compliance with, policies and procedures established under the bill to be included in designated annual audit reports. The bill would require a vendor contract that will exceed $100,000 in a fiscal year to be approved by the governing board or body of the local educational agency in an open public meeting. The bill would also require any educational enrichment activity provided by a school to be approved and verified by the pupils assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate for that pupil.
(5)(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, once the Controller or county superintendent of schools makes a final determination that specified audits performed by a certified public accountant or public accountant were not performed in substantial conformity with provisions of an audit guide, or that the audit reports do not conform to the provisions of an audit guide, the certified public accountant or public accountant is ineligible to conduct specified audits for 3 years. Existing law requires the Controller to notify each school district and county office of education of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible pursuant to these provisions.
This bill would extend the above-described rules related to the ineligibility of the certified public accountant or public accountant to audits of a nonclassroom-based charter school, as provided, and would additionally require the Controller to notify charter schools of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible to conduct these audits, as provided.
(2)The Charter Schools Act of 1992 specifies the procedures for the submission, review, and approval or denial of a petition to establish a charter school. The act requires a petition for the establishment of a charter school to contain specified information, including a reasonably comprehensive description of the manner in which annual, independent financial audits will be conducted. Existing law, by not later than May 1 of each fiscal year, requires the governing board of each local educational agency to provide for an audit of the books and accounts of the local educational agency, as specified, or make arrangements with the county superintendent of schools to provide for that auditing.
By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 of each year thereafter, this bill would require the governing body of a charter school to review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. By imposing additional requirements on charter schools, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an auditor of a nonclassroom-based charter school, when performing certain audits, to take certain actions, including the sampling of certain financial documents, the identification of transfers of funds or assets exceeding prescribed amounts, the identification of transactions that do not meet certain standards, and the preparation of a letter to be included with the audit report, as specified.
(3)Existing law prohibits a school district, county office of education, or charter school from being eligible to receive apportionments for independent study by pupils unless the local educational agency has adopted written policies, and implemented those policies, in accordance with rules and regulations adopted by the Superintendent, Superintendent of Public Instruction, as specified, including a requirement that a current written agreement with specified content for each independent study pupil is maintained on file.
Commencing July 1, 2025, this bill would require an independent study written agreement to be signed under penalty of perjury. This provision would impose a state-mandated local program by imposing new duties on local educational agencies and by creating a new crime. authorize the State Department of Education to assess an administrative penalty of $10,000 on a local educational agency if an employee of the local educational agency, as part of the independent study written agreement, willfully states as true any material fact that the employee knows to be false.
(4)Commencing July 1, 2025, this bill would require a school district, county office of education, or charter school to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to this the bill. The bill would authorize a local educational agency to expend public funds for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities, provided that all educational enrichment activities, materials, and programs are nonsectarian.
The bill would require the governing board or body of a local educational agency, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and would further require that these policies ensure that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria. The bill would require auditing of approval of, and compliance with, policies and procedures established under the bill to be included in designated annual audit reports. The bill would require a vendor contract that will exceed $100,000 in a fiscal year to be approved by the governing board or body of the local educational agency in an open public meeting. The bill would also require any educational enrichment activity provided by a school to be approved and verified by the pupils assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate for that pupil.
(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, once the Controller or county superintendent of schools makes a final determination that specified audits performed by a certified public accountant or public accountant were not performed in substantial conformity with provisions of an audit guide, or that the audit reports do not conform to the provisions of an audit guide, the certified public accountant or public accountant is ineligible to conduct specified audits for 3 years. Existing law requires the Controller to notify each school district and county office of education of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible pursuant to these provisions.
This bill would extend the above-described rules related to the ineligibility of the certified public accountant or public accountant to audits of a nonclassroom-based charter school, as provided, and would additionally require the Controller to notify charter schools of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible to conduct these audits, as provided.
(2)The Charter Schools Act of 1992 specifies the procedures for the submission, review, and approval or denial of a petition to establish a charter school. The act requires a petition for the establishment of a charter school to contain specified information, including a reasonably comprehensive description of the manner in which annual, independent financial audits will be conducted. Existing law, by not later than May 1 of each fiscal year, requires the governing board of each local educational agency to provide for an audit of the books and accounts of the local educational agency, as specified, or make arrangements with the county superintendent of schools to provide for that auditing.
By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 of each year thereafter, this bill would require the governing body of a charter school to review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. By imposing additional requirements on charter schools, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would require an auditor of a nonclassroom-based charter school, when performing certain audits, to take certain actions, including the sampling of certain financial documents, the identification of transfers of funds or assets exceeding prescribed amounts, the identification of transactions that do not meet certain standards, and the preparation of a letter to be included with the audit report, as specified.
(3)Existing law prohibits a school district, county office of education, or charter school from being eligible to receive apportionments for independent study by pupils unless the local educational agency has adopted written policies, and implemented those policies, in accordance with rules and regulations adopted by the Superintendent, as specified, including a requirement that a current written agreement with specified content for each independent study pupil is maintained on file.
Commencing July 1, 2025, this bill would require an independent study written agreement to be signed under penalty of perjury. This provision would impose a state-mandated local program by imposing new duties on local educational agencies and by creating a new crime.
(4)Commencing July 1, 2025, this bill would require a school district, county office of education, or charter school to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to this bill. The bill would authorize a local educational agency to expend public funds for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities, provided that all educational enrichment activities, materials, and programs are nonsectarian.
The bill would require the governing board or body of a local educational agency, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and would further require that these policies ensure that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria. The bill would require auditing of approval of, and compliance with, policies and procedures established under the bill to be included in designated annual audit reports. The bill would require a vendor contract that will exceed $100,000 in a fiscal year to be approved by the governing board or body of the local educational agency in an open public meeting. The bill would also require any educational enrichment activity provided by a school to be approved and verified by the pupils assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate for that pupil.
(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Charter Schools Act of 1992 authorizes the establishment, operation, and governance of charter schools.This bill would declare the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to charter schools.The Charter Schools Act of 1992 authorizes the establishment, operation, and governance of charter schools.
This bill would declare the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to charter schools.
(a)(1)If the Controller determines by two consecutive quality control reviews pursuant to Section 14504.2, or if a county superintendent of schools determines, that audits performed by a certified public accountant or public accountant under Section 41020 and subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 were not performed in substantial conformity with provisions of the audit guide, or that the audit reports, including amended reports, submitted by February 15 following the close of the fiscal year audited, for two consecutive years do not conform to provisions of the audit guide as required by Section 14504, the Controller or the county superintendent of schools, as appropriate, shall notify in writing the certified public accountant or public accountant and the California Board of Accountancy.
(2)If the certified public accountant or public accountant does not file an appeal in writing with the California Board of Accountancy within 30 calendar days after receipt of the notification from the Controller or county superintendent of schools, the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools pursuant to this section shall be final.
(b)If an appeal is filed with the California Board of Accountancy, the board shall complete an investigation of the appeal within 90 days of the filing date. On the basis of the investigation, the board may do either of the following:
(1)Find that the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools should not be upheld and has no effect.
(2)Schedule the appeal for a hearing, in which case, the final action on the appeal shall be completed by the board within one year from the date of filing the appeal.
(c)If the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools under subdivision (a) becomes final, the certified public accountant or public accountant shall be ineligible to conduct audits under Section 41020 and subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a period of three years, or, in the event of an appeal, for any period, and subject to the conditions, that may be ordered by the California Board of Accountancy. Not later than the first day of March of each year, the Controller shall notify each school district, charter school, and county office of education of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible under this section. School districts, charter schools, and county offices of education shall not use the audit services of a certified public accountant or public accountant ineligible under this section.
(d)For purposes of this section, certified public accountant or public accountant includes any person or firm entering into a contract to conduct an audit under Section 41020 or subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8.
(e)This section shall not preclude the California Board of Accountancy from taking any disciplinary action it deems appropriate under other laws.
SEC. 2.Section 47605 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.(a)(1)Except as set forth in paragraph (2), a petition for the establishment of a charter school within a school district may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. A petition for the establishment of a charter school shall identify a single charter school that will operate within the geographic boundaries of that school district. A charter school may propose to operate at multiple sites within the school district if each location is identified in the charter school petition. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or legal guardians of pupils that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the charter school for its first year of operation.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the charter school during its first year of operation.
(2)A petition that proposes to convert an existing public school to a charter school that would not be eligible for a loan pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41365 may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after the petition is signed by not less than 50 percent of the permanent status teachers currently employed at the public school to be converted.
(3)A petition shall include a prominent statement that a signature on the petition means that the parent or legal guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(4)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to expand operations to one or more additional sites or grade levels shall request a material revision to its charter and shall notify the chartering authority of those additional locations or grade levels. The chartering authority shall consider whether to approve those additional locations or grade levels at an open, public meeting. If the additional locations or grade levels are approved pursuant to the standards and criteria described in subdivision (c), they shall be a material revision to the charter schools charter.
(5)(A)A charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county in which that school district is located before January 1, 2020, may continue to operate that site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the site, the charter school shall do either of the following:
(i)First, before submitting the request for the renewal of the charter petition, obtain approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
(ii)Submit a request for the renewal of the charter petition pursuant to Section 47607 to the school district in which the charter school is located.
(B)If a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency is issued in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.) for an area in which a charter schoolsite is located and operating, the charter school, for not more than five years, may relocate that site outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration if the charter school first obtains the written approval of the school district where the site is being relocated to.
(C)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.), that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
(D)(i)A charter school in operation and providing educational services to pupils before October 1, 2019, located on a federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria or operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe shall be exempt from the geographic restrictions of paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A) of this paragraph and the geographic restrictions of subdivision (a) of Section 47605.1.
(ii)The exemption to the geographic restrictions of subdivision (a) of Section 47605.1 in clause (i) does not apply to nonclassroom-based charter schools operating pursuant to Section 47612.5.
(E)The department shall regard as a continuing charter school for all purposes a charter school that was granted approval of its petition, that was providing educational services to pupils before October 1, 2019, and is authorized by a different chartering authority due to changes to this paragraph that took effect January 1, 2020. This paragraph shall be implemented only to the extent it does not conflict with federal law. In order to prevent any potential conflict with federal law, this paragraph does not apply to covered programs as identified in Section 8101(11) of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 7801) to the extent the affected charter school is the restructured portion of a divided charter school pursuant to Section 47654.
(6)Commencing January 1, 2003, a petition to establish a charter school shall not be approved to serve pupils in a grade level that is not served by the school district of the governing board considering the petition, unless the petition proposes to serve pupils in all of the grade levels served by that school district.
(b)No later than 60 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the governing board of the school district shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the governing board of the school district shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers employed by the school district, other employees of the school district, and parents. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the governing board of the school district shall either grant or deny the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition, provided, however, that the date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. A petition is deemed received by the governing board of the school district for purposes of commencing the timelines described in this subdivision on the day the petitioner submits a petition to the district office, along with a signed certification that the petitioner deems the petition to be complete. The governing board of the school district shall publish all staff recommendations, including the recommended findings and, if applicable, the certification from the county superintendent of schools prepared pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c), regarding the petition at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district will either grant or deny the charter. At the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district will either grant or deny the charter, petitioners shall have equivalent time and procedures to present evidence and testimony to respond to the staff recommendations and findings.
(c)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools pursuant to this section, the chartering authority shall be guided by the intent of the Legislature that charter schools are and should become an integral part of the California educational system and that the establishment of charter schools should be encouraged. The governing board of the school district shall grant a charter for the operation of a school under this part if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice and with the interests of the community in which the school is proposing to locate. The governing board of the school district shall consider the academic needs of the pupils the school proposes to serve. The governing board of the school district shall not deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school unless it makes written factual findings, specific to the particular petition, setting forth specific facts to support one or more of the following findings:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (e).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will serve high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents about the transferability of courses to other public high schools and the eligibility of courses to meet college entrance requirements. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered transferable and courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the A to G admissions criteria may be considered to meet college entrance requirements.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and attitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all pupil subgroups served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subdivision (a) of Section 52052. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(E)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(F)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)For all schools, the development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282. For schools serving pupils in any of grades 7 to 12, inclusive, the development of a school safety plan shall also include the safety topic listed in subparagraph (L) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(G)The means by which the charter school will achieve a balance of racial and ethnic pupils, special education pupils, and English learner pupils, including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils, as defined by the evaluation rubrics in Section 52064.5, that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the school district to which the charter petition is submitted. Upon renewal, for a charter school not deemed to be a local educational agency for purposes of special education pursuant to Section 47641, the chartering authority may consider the effect of school placements made by the chartering authority in providing a free and appropriate public education as required by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 101-476), on the balance of pupils with disabilities at the charter school.
(H)Admission policies and procedures, consistent with subdivision (e).
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, which shall employ generally accepted accounting principles, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved to the satisfaction of the chartering authority.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that are consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian, or, if the pupil is a homeless child or youth, or a foster child or youth, in the native language of the homeless or foster childs educational rights holder. In the case of a foster child or youth, the written notice shall also be provided to the foster childs attorney and county social worker. If the pupil is an Indian child, as defined in Section 224.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the written notice shall also be provided to the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker. The written notice shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, or county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker or, if applicable, county social worker initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(iv)A foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker and an Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker shall have the same rights a parent or guardian of a child has to receive a suspension notice, expulsion notice, manifestation determination notice, involuntary transfer notice, and other documents and related information.
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter schools will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the school district who choose not to attend charter schools.
(M)The rights of an employee of the school district upon leaving the employment of the school district to work in a charter school, and of any rights of return to the school district after employment at a charter school.
(N)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the chartering authority to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(O)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of pupil records.
(6)The petition does not contain a declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(7)The charter school is demonstrably unlikely to serve the interests of the entire community in which the school is proposing to locate. Analysis of this finding shall include consideration of the fiscal impact of the proposed charter school. A written factual finding under this paragraph shall detail specific facts and circumstances that analyze and consider the following factors:
(A)The extent to which the proposed charter school would substantially undermine existing services, academic offerings, or programmatic offerings.
(B)Whether the proposed charter school would duplicate a program currently offered within the school district and the existing program has sufficient capacity for the pupils proposed to be served within reasonable proximity to where the charter school intends to locate.
(8)The school district is not positioned to absorb the fiscal impact of the proposed charter school. A school district satisfies this paragraph if it has a qualified interim certification pursuant to Section 42131 and the county superintendent of schools, in consultation with the County Office Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team, certifies that approving the charter school would result in the school district having a negative interim certification pursuant to Section 42131, has a negative interim certification pursuant to Section 42131, or is under state receivership. Charter schools proposed in a school district satisfying one of these conditions shall be subject to a rebuttable presumption of denial.
(d)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall, on a regular basis, consult with their parents, legal guardians, and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(e)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against a pupil on the basis of the characteristics listed in Section 220. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of that pupils parent or legal guardian, within this state, except that an existing public school converting partially or entirely to a charter school under this part shall adopt and maintain a policy giving admission preference to pupils who reside within the former attendance area of that public school.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the school district except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the chartering authority shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and shall not take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days, and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(f)The governing board of a school district shall not require an employee of the school district to be employed in a charter school.
(g)The governing board of a school district shall not require a pupil enrolled in the school district to attend a charter school.
(h)The governing board of a school district shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school and upon the school district. The description of the facilities to be used by the charter school shall specify where the charter school intends to locate. The petitioner or petitioners also shall be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation. If the school is to be operated by, or as, a nonprofit public benefit corporation, the petitioner shall provide the names and relevant qualifications of all persons whom the petitioner nominates to serve on the governing body of the charter school.
(i)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the school district, the governing board of the school district shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(j)Upon the approval of the petition by the governing board of the school district, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the applicable county superintendent of schools, the department, and the state board.
(k)(1)(A)(i)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education. The petitioner shall submit the petition to the county board of education within 30 days of a denial by the governing board of the school district. At the same time the petition is submitted to the county board of education, the petitioner shall also provide a copy of the petition to the school district. The county board of education shall review the petition pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c). If the petition submitted on appeal contains new or different material terms, the county board of education shall immediately remand the petition to the governing board of the school district for reconsideration, which shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days. If the governing board of the school district denies a petition after reconsideration, the petitioner may elect to resubmit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education.
(ii)The county board of education shall review the appeal petition pursuant to subdivision (c). If the denial of the petition was made pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c), the county board of education shall also review the school districts findings pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c).
(iii)As used in this subdivision, material terms of the petition means the signatures, affirmations, disclosures, documents, and descriptions described in subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (h), but shall not include minor administrative updates to the petition or related documents due to changes in circumstances based on the passage of time related to fiscal affairs, facilities arrangements, or state law, or to reflect the county board of education as the chartering authority.
(B)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition and the county board of education has jurisdiction over a single school district, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the state board. The state board shall review a petition submitted pursuant to this subparagraph pursuant to subdivision (c). If the denial of a charter petition is reversed by the state board pursuant to this subparagraph, the state board shall designate the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located as the chartering authority.
(2)If the county board of education denies a petition, the petitioner may appeal that denial to the state board.
(A)The petitioner shall submit the petition to the state board within 30 days of a denial by the county board of education. The petitioner shall include the findings and documentary record from the governing board of the school district and the county board of education and a written submission detailing, with specific citations to the documentary record, how the governing board of the school district and the county board of education abused their discretion. The governing board of the school district and county board of education shall prepare the documentary record, including transcripts of the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district and county board of education denied the charter, at the request of the petitioner. The documentary record shall be prepared by the governing board of the school district and county board of education no later than 10 business days after the request of the petitioner is made. At the same time the petition and supporting documentation is submitted to the state board, the petitioner shall also provide a copy of the petition and supporting documentation to the school district and the county board of education.
(B)If the appeal contains new or different material terms, as defined in clause (iii) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the state board shall immediately remand the petition to the governing board of the school district to which the petition was submitted for reconsideration. The governing board of the school district shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days. If the governing board of the school district denies a petition after reconsideration, the petitioner may elect to resubmit the petition to the state board.
(C)Within 30 days of receipt of the appeal submitted to the state board, the governing board of the school district or county board of education may submit a written opposition to the state board detailing, with specific citations to the documentary record, how the governing board of the school district or the county board of education did not abuse its discretion in denying the petition. The governing board of the school district or the county board of education may submit supporting documentation or evidence from the documentary record that was considered by the governing board of the school district or the county board of education.
(D)The state boards Advisory Commission on Charter Schools shall hold a public hearing to review the appeal and documentary record. Based on its review, the Advisory Commission on Charter Schools shall submit a recommendation to the state board whether there is sufficient evidence to hear the appeal or to summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record. If the Advisory Commission on Charter Schools does not submit a recommendation to the state board, the state board shall consider the appeal, and shall either hear the appeal or summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record at a regular public meeting of the state board.
(E)The state board shall either hear the appeal or summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record. If the state board hears the appeal, the state board may affirm the determination of the governing board of the school district or the county board of education, or both of those determinations, or may reverse only upon a determination that there was an abuse of discretion by each of the governing board of the school district and the county board of education. Abuse of discretion is the most deferential standard of review, under which the state board must give deference to the decisions of the governing board of the school district and the county board of education to deny the petition. If the denial of a charter petition is reversed by the state board, the state board shall designate, in consultation with the petitioner, either the governing board of the school district or the county board of education in which the charter school is located as the chartering authority.
(3)A charter school for which a charter is granted by either the county board of education or the state board based on an appeal pursuant to this subdivision shall qualify fully as a charter school for all funding and other purposes of this part.
(4)A charter school that receives approval of its petition from a county board of education or from the state board on appeal shall be subject to the same requirements concerning geographic location to which it would otherwise be subject if it received approval from the chartering authority to which it originally submitted its petition. A charter petition that is submitted to either a county board of education or to the state board shall meet all otherwise applicable petition requirements, including the identification of the proposed site or sites where the charter school will operate.
(5)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petition or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located, the department, and the state board.
(6)If either the county board of education or the state board fails to act on a petition within 180 days of receipt, the decision of the governing board of the school district to deny the petition shall be subject to judicial review.
(l)(1)Teachers in charter schools shall hold the Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document required for the teachers certificated assignment. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and are subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. A governing body of a direct-funded charter school may use local assignment options authorized in statute and regulations for the purpose of legally assigning certificated teachers, in accordance with all of the requirements of the applicable statutes or regulations in the same manner as a governing board of a school district. A charter school shall have authority to request an emergency permit or a waiver from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing for individuals in the same manner as a school district.
(2)By July 1, 2020, all teachers in charter schools shall obtain a certificate of clearance and satisfy the requirements for professional fitness pursuant to Sections 44339, 44340, and 44341.
(3)The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall include in the bulletins it issues pursuant to subdivision (k) of Section 44237 to provide notification to local educational agencies of any adverse actions taken against the holders of any commission documents, notice of any adverse actions taken against teachers employed by charter schools, and shall make this bulletin available to all chartering authorities and charter schools in the same manner in which it is made available to local educational agencies.
(m)(1)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c), to its chartering authority, the Controller, the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering authority, and the department by December 15 of each year. This paragraph does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(2)By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 each year thereafter, the governing body of a charter school shall review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, including any factors identified pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a nonclassroom-based charter school, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. The review shall be placed on the agenda of the meeting pursuant to the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement, but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
(o)The requirements of this section shall not be waived by the state board pursuant to Section 33050 or any other law.
SEC. 3.Section 47605.6 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.6.(a)(1)In addition to the authority provided by Section 47605.5, a county board of education may also approve a petition for the operation of a charter school that operates at one or more sites within the geographic boundaries of the county and that provides instructional services that are not generally provided by a county office of education. A county board of education may approve a countywide charter only if it finds, in addition to the other requirements of this section, that the educational services to be provided by the charter school will offer services to a pupil population that will benefit from those services and that cannot be served as well by a charter school that operates in only one school district in the county. A petition for the establishment of a countywide charter school pursuant to this subdivision may be circulated throughout the county by any one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the county board of education for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or guardians of pupils residing within the county that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the school for its first year of operation and each of the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to operate a facility has received at least 30 days notice of the petitioners intent to operate a charter school pursuant to this section.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the school during its first year of operation and each of the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to operate a facility has received at least 30 days notice of the petitioners intent to operate a charter school pursuant to this section.
(2)An existing public school shall not be converted to a charter school in accordance with this section.
(3)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to establish operations at additional sites within the geographic boundaries of the county board of education shall notify the school districts where those sites will be located. The charter school shall also request a material revision of its charter by the county board of education that approved its charter and the county board of education shall consider whether to approve those additional locations at an open, public meeting, held no sooner than 30 days following notification of the school districts where the sites will be located. If approved, the location of the approved sites shall be a material revision of the charter schools approved charter.
(4)A petition shall include a prominent statement indicating that a signature on the petition means that the parent or guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(b)No later than 60 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the county board of education shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the county board of education shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers, parents or guardians, and the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to place school facilities. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the county board of education shall either grant or deny the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition. However, this date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. A petition is deemed received by the county board of education for purposes of commencing the timelines described in this subdivision when the petitioner submits a petition, in accordance with subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), to the county office of education. The county board of education shall publish all staff recommendations, including the recommended findings, regarding the petition at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the county board of education will either grant or deny the charter. At the public hearing at which the county board of education will either grant or deny the charter, petitioners shall have equivalent time and procedures to present evidence and testimony to respond to the staff recommendations and findings. A county board of education may impose any additional requirements beyond those required by this section that it considers necessary for the sound operation of a countywide charter school. A county board of education may grant a charter for the operation of a charter school under this part only if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice and that the charter school has reasonable justification for why it could not be established by petition to a school district pursuant to Section 47605. The county board of education shall deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school if it finds one or more of the following:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (e).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those pupils whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will enroll high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents regarding the transferability of courses to other public high schools. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered to be transferable to other public high schools.
(iv)If the proposed charter school will enroll high school pupils, information as to the manner in which the charter school will inform parents as to whether each individual course offered by the charter school meets college entrance requirements. Courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as satisfying their prerequisites for admission may be considered as meeting college entrance requirements for purposes of this clause.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and aptitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all pupil subgroups served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subdivision (a) of Section 52052. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The location of each charter school facility that the petitioner proposes to operate.
(E)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(F)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(G)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)For all schools, the development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282. For schools serving pupils in any of grades 7 to 12, inclusive, the development of a school safety plan shall also include the safety topic listed in subparagraph (L) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(H)The means by which the charter school will achieve a balance of racial and ethnic pupils, special education pupils, and English learner pupils, including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils as defined by the evaluation rubrics in Section 52064.5, that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the county board of education to which the charter petition is submitted. Upon renewal, for a charter school not deemed to be a local educational agency for purposes of special education pursuant to Section 47641, the chartering authority may consider the effect of school placements made by the chartering authority in providing a free and appropriate public education as required by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 101-476), on the balance of pupils with disabilities at the charter school.
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, in accordance with regulations established by the state board, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that is consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian, or, if the pupil is a homeless child or youth, or a foster child or youth, in the native language of the homeless or foster childs educational rights holder. In the case of a foster child or youth, the written notice shall also be provided to the foster childs attorney and county social worker. If the pupil is an Indian child, as defined in Section 224.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the written notice shall also be provided to the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker. The written notice shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, or county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker or, if applicable, county social worker initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(iv)A foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker and an Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker shall have the same rights a parent or guardian of a child has to receive a suspension notice, expulsion notice, manifestation determination notice, involuntary transfer notice, and other documents and related information.
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter school will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the county board of education to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(M)Admission policy and procedures, consistent with subdivision (e).
(N)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the county who choose not to attend the charter school.
(O)The rights of an employee of the county office of education, upon leaving the employment of the county office of education, to be employed by the charter school, and any rights of return to the county office of education that an employee may have upon leaving the employment of the charter school.
(P)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of public records.
(6)A declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public school employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of the Educational Employment Relations Act (Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(7)Any other basis that the county board of education finds justifies the denial of the petition.
(c)A county board of education that approves a petition for the operation of a countywide charter may, as a condition of charter approval, enter into an agreement with a third party, at the expense of the charter school, to oversee, monitor, and report to the county board of education on the operations of the charter school. The county board of education may prescribe the aspects of the charter schools operations to be monitored by the third party and may prescribe appropriate requirements regarding the reporting of information concerning the operations of the charter school to the county board of education.
(d)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall on a regular basis consult with their parents and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(e)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against any pupil on the basis of ethnicity, national origin, gender, gender identity, gender expression, or disability. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of the pupils parent or guardian, within this state.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the county except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the county board of education shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and in no event shall take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(f)The county board of education shall not require an employee of the county or a school district to be employed in a charter school.
(g)The county board of education shall not require a pupil enrolled in a county program to attend a charter school.
(h)The county board of education shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school, any school district where the charter school may operate, and upon the county board of education. The petitioner or petitioners shall also be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation. If the charter school is to be operated by, or as, a nonprofit public benefit corporation, the petitioner shall provide the names and relevant qualifications of all persons whom the petitioner nominates to serve on the governing body of the charter school.
(i)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the county, the county board of education shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(j)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the school districts within the county, the Superintendent, and the state board.
(k)If a county board of education denies a petition, the petitioner shall not elect to submit the petition for the establishment of the charter school to the state board.
(l)(1)Teachers in charter schools shall be required to hold the Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document required for the teachers certificated assignment. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and shall be subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. A governing body of a direct-funded charter school may use local assignment options authorized in statute and regulations for the purpose of legally assigning certificated teachers, in accordance with all of the requirements of the applicable statutes or regulations in the same manner as a governing board of a school district. A charter school shall have authority to request an emergency permit or a waiver from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing for individuals in the same manner as a school district.
(2)The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall include in the bulletins it issues pursuant to subdivision (k) of Section 44237 to provide notification to local educational agencies of any adverse actions taken against the holders of any commission documents, notice of any adverse actions taken against teachers employed by charter schools. The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall make this bulletin available to all chartering authorities and charter schools in the same manner in which it is made available to local educational agencies.
(m)(1)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent, financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b), to the county office of education, the Controller, and the department by December 15 of each year. This paragraph does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(2)By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 each year thereafter, the governing body of a charter school shall review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, including any factors identified pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a nonclassroom-based charter school, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. The review shall be placed on the agenda of the meeting pursuant to the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
(o)The requirements of this section shall not be waived by the state board pursuant to Section 33050 or any other law.
SEC. 4.Section 47612.8 is added to the Education Code, to read:47612.8.(a)An auditor of a nonclassroom-based charter school, when performing an audit described in Section 41020, subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c) of Section 47605, or subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 47605.6, shall do all of the following:
(1)(A)Ensure that all sampling of documents or records necessary for the audit are independently selected by the auditor.
(B)Contact a random sample of parents or guardians of pupils, emancipated pupils, or other custodians of pupils, or in the case of a pupil over 18 years of age, the pupil, enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment.
(C)Select a sample and review credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school pursuant to the process described in Section 14502.1.
(2)Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars ($1,000,000) or 10 percent of the charter schools budget, whichever is less, together with a written explanation from the school regarding the school purpose for each such expenditure.
(3)Identify any other transaction that does not meet the standards identified in Section 14502.1.
(4)Review compliance by the charter school with any policy adopted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 51820.
(5)Include a letter with the audit report discussing any findings of the auditor relating to factors arising from the auditors activities under this subdivision, or arising from the lack of those factors, together with a response by the charter school if the charter school chooses to make a response.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Auditor of a nonclassroom-based school means any certified public accountant or public accountant assigned to a nonclassroom-based charter school audit, as described in Section 41020, subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c) of Section 47605, or subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 47605.6.
(2)Nonclassroom-based charter school means a charter school that offers nonclassroom-based instruction pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 47612.5 for more than 20 percent of the instructional time reported by the charter school at the second principal apportionment.
SEC. 5.Section 51747 of the Education Code is amended to read:51747.A local educational agency shall not be eligible to receive apportionments for independent study by pupils, regardless of age, unless it has adopted written policies, and has implemented those policies, pursuant to rules and regulations adopted by the Superintendent, that include, but are not limited to, all of the following:(a)The maximum length of time, by grade level and type of program, that may elapse between the time an independent study assignment is made and the date by which the pupil must complete the assigned work.(b)(1)The level of satisfactory educational progress and the number of missed assignments that will be allowed before an evaluation is conducted to determine whether it is in the best interests of the pupil to remain in independent study, or whether the pupil should return to the regular school program. A written record of the findings of any evaluation made pursuant to this subdivision shall be treated as a mandatory interim pupil record. The record shall be maintained for a period of three years from the date of the evaluation and, if the pupil transfers to another California public school, the record shall be forwarded to that school.(2)Satisfactory educational progress shall be determined based on all of the following indicators:(A)The pupils achievement and engagement in the independent study program, as indicated by the pupils performance on applicable pupil-level measures of pupil achievement and pupil engagement set forth in paragraphs (4) and (5) of subdivision (d) of Section 52060.(B)The completion of assignments, assessments, or other indicators that evidence that the pupil is working on assignments.(C)Learning required concepts, as determined by the supervising teacher.(D)Progressing toward successful completion of the course of study or individual course, as determined by the supervising teacher.(c)The provision of content aligned to grade level standards that is substantially equivalent to in-person instruction. For high schools, this shall include access to all courses offered by the local educational agency for graduation and approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the AG admissions criteria.(d)Procedures for tiered reengagement strategies for all pupils who are not generating attendance for more than 10 percent of required minimum instructional time over four continuous weeks of a local educational agencys approved instructional calendar, pupils found not participatory in synchronous instructional offerings pursuant to Section 51747.5 for more than 50 percent of the scheduled times of synchronous instruction in a school month as applicable by grade span, or pupils who are in violation of the written agreement pursuant to subdivision (g). These procedures shall include local programs intended to address chronic absenteeism, as applicable, with at least all of the following:(1)Verification of current contact information for each enrolled pupil.(2)Notification to parents or guardians of lack of participation within one school day of the recording of a nonattendance day or lack of participation.(3)A plan for outreach from the school to determine pupil needs, including connection with health and social services as necessary.(4)A clear standard for requiring a pupil-parent-educator conference to review a pupils written agreement, and reconsider the independent study programs impact on the pupils achievement and well-being, consistent with the policies adopted pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (g).(e)(1)For pupils in transitional kindergarten and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for daily synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.(2)For pupils in grades 4 to 8, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for both daily live interaction and at least weekly synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.(3)For pupils in grades 9 to 12, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for at least weekly synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.(f)A plan to transition pupils whose families wish to return to in-person instruction from independent study expeditiously, and, in no case, later than five instructional days.(g)A requirement that a current written agreement for each independent study pupil shall be maintained on file, including, but not limited to, all of the following:(1)The manner, time, frequency, and place for submitting a pupils assignments, for reporting the pupils academic progress, and for communicating with a pupils parent or guardian regarding a pupils academic progress.(2)The objectives and methods of study for the pupils work, and the methods used to evaluate that work.(3)The specific resources, including materials and personnel, that will be made available to the pupil. These resources shall include confirming or providing access to all pupils to the connectivity and devices adequate to participate in the educational program and complete assigned work.(4)A statement of the policies adopted pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) regarding the maximum length of time allowed between the assignment and the completion of a pupils assigned work, the level of satisfactory educational progress, and the number of missed assignments allowed before an evaluation of whether or not the pupil should be allowed to continue in independent study.(5)The duration of the independent study agreement, including the beginning and ending dates for the pupils participation in independent study under the agreement. No independent study agreement shall be valid for any period longer than one school year.(6)A statement of the number of course credits or, for the elementary grades, other measures of academic accomplishment appropriate to the agreement, to be earned by the pupil upon completion.(7)A statement detailing the academic and other supports that will be provided to address the needs of pupils who are not performing at grade level, or need support in other areas, such as English learners, individuals with exceptional needs in order to be consistent with the pupils individualized education program or plan pursuant to Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794), pupils in foster care or experiencing homelessness, and pupils requiring mental health supports.(8)The inclusion of a statement in each independent study agreement that independent study is an optional educational alternative in which no pupil may be required to participate. In the case of a pupil who is referred or assigned to any school, class, or program pursuant to Section 48915 or 48917, the agreement also shall include the statement that instruction may be provided to the pupil through independent study only if the pupil is offered the alternative of classroom instruction.(9)(A)For a pupil participating in an independent study program that is scheduled for more than 14 school days, each written agreement shall be signed, before the commencement of independent study, by the pupil, the pupils parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable. Beginning in the 202223 school year, for a pupil participating in an independent study program that is scheduled for less than 15 school days, each written agreement shall be signed within 10 school days of the commencement of the first day of the pupils enrollment in independent study, by the pupil, the pupils parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable. For purposes of this paragraph caregiver means a person who has met the requirements of Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 6550) of Division 11 of the Family Code.(B)Signed written agreements, supplemental agreements, assignment records, work samples, and attendance records assessing time value of work or evidence that an instructional activity occurred may be maintained as an electronic file.(C)For purposes of this section, an electronic file includes a computer or electronic stored image of an original document, including, but not limited to, portable document format (PDF), JPEG, or other digital image file type, that may be sent via fax machine, email, or other electronic means.(D)Either an original document or an electronic file of the original document is allowable documentation for auditing purposes.(E)Written agreements may be signed using an electronic signature that complies with state and federal standards, as determined by the department, that may be a marking that is either computer generated or produced by electronic means and is intended by the signatory to have the same effect as a handwritten signature. The use of an electronic signature shall have the same force and effect as the use of a manual signature if the requirements for digital signatures and their acceptable technology, as provided in Section 16.5 of the Government Code and in Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 22000) of Division 7 of Title 2 of the California Code of Regulations, are satisfied.(F)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), for the 202122 school year only, a local educational agency shall obtain a signed written agreement for an independent study program of any length of time from the pupil, or the pupils parent or legal guardian if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable, no later than 30 days after the first day of instruction in an independent study program or October 15, whichever date comes later. This subparagraph does not relieve a local educational agency from the obligation to comply with the requirements of this article, as amended by the act adding this subparagraph, upon commencement of instruction for a participating pupil in the 202122 school year.(h)(1)For the 202122 school year only, school districts and county offices of education shall notify the parents and guardians of all enrolled pupils of their options to enroll their child in in-person instruction or independent study during the 202122 school year. This notice shall include written information on the local educational agencys internet website, including, but not limited to, the right to request a pupil-parent-educator conference meeting before enrollment pursuant to this section, pupil rights regarding procedures for enrolling, disenrolling, and reenrolling in independent study, and the synchronous and asynchronous instructional time that a pupil will have access to as part of independent study. If 15 percent or more of the pupils enrolled in a local educational agency that provides instruction in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, speak a single primary language other than English, as determined from the census data submitted to the department pursuant to Section 52164 in the preceding year, the written information shall, in addition to being written in English, be written in the primary language.(2)Before signing a written agreement pursuant to this section, the parent or guardian of a pupil may request that the local educational agency conduct a telephone, videoconference, or in-person pupil-parent-educator conference or other school meeting during which the pupil, parent or guardian, and, if requested by the pupil or parent, an education advocate, may ask questions about the educational options, including which curriculum offerings and nonacademic supports will be available to the pupil in independent study, before making the decision about enrollment or disenrollment in the various options for learning.(i)Subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) shall not apply to pupils that participate in an independent study program for fewer than 15 schooldays in a school year and pupils enrolled in a comprehensive school for classroom-based instruction who, under the care of appropriately licensed professionals, participate in independent study due to necessary medical treatments or inpatient treatment for mental health care or substance abuse. Local educational agencies shall obtain evidence from appropriately licensed professionals of the need for pupils to participate in independent study pursuant to this subdivision.(j)(1)Notwithstanding paragraph (8) of subdivision (g) of this section, paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 46300, and subdivision (d) of Section 51745, for the 202122 school year only, a local educational agency shall be eligible to receive apportionments for independent study for pupils that are subject to quarantine for exposure to, or infection with, COVID-19 pursuant to local or state health guidance, and the pupil cannot participate in classroom-based instruction due to the quarantine, and for school closures due to COVID-19 pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41422. Local educational agencies shall receive apportionment for these pupils for all schooldays that they participate in and meet all other apportionment requirements of independent study while in quarantine or during a school closure.(2)Notwithstanding Section 47612.5, for the 202122 fiscal year, a classroom-based charter school that provides an independent study program pursuant to this article for pupils that are subject to quarantine for exposure to, or infection with, COVID-19 pursuant to local or state health guidance, and the pupil cannot participate in classroom-based instruction due to the quarantine, shall not attribute quarantine-based independent study average daily attendance required pursuant to law for a nonclassroom-based charter school pursuant to Section 47612.5 and shall not be required to submit a request for a funding determination as a result of providing independent study to quarantined pupils.(3)This subdivision shall apply only to pupils participating in independent study due to quarantine who do not have the option of in-person instruction, and only for the period of quarantine mandated pursuant to state or local health guidance or order. This subdivision shall not apply to classroom-based charter schools offering independent study to pupils whose parents or guardians have requested independent study pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 51745.(k)Commencing with the 202122 fiscal year Guide for Annual Audits of K12 Local Education Agencies and State Compliance Reporting, the Controller shall incorporate verification of the adoption of the policies required pursuant to this section, including loss of apportionment for independent study for local educational agencies found to be noncompliant, unless compliance verification for those policies is already included in the audit guide.(l)Commencing July 1, 2025, if, as part of the written agreement required pursuant to this section, a local educational agency employee willfully states as true any material fact that the employee knows to be false, the department may assess an administrative penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) on the local educational agency.(m)The provisions of this section are not subject to waiver by the state board, by the Superintendent, or under any provision of Part 26.8 (commencing with Section 47600).SEC. 6.SEC. 5.Article 10.5 (commencing with Section 51820) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 28 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Education Code, to read:10.5.Educational Enrichment Activities51820.(a)A local educational agency may only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c). A local educational agency may expend public funds for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities, provided that all educational enrichment activities, materials, and programs shall be nonsectarian.
(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, the governing board or body of the local educational agency shall establish policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness that, at a minimum, do all of the following:
(1)Ensure a reasonable market value for the service provided.
(2)Require all vendors to provide proof of valid and appropriate insurance, business licenses, or other certification.
(3)Require all vendor personnel interacting with pupils, unsupervised by a parent or school employee, to have a valid criminal records summary as described in Section 45125.1, and require that if the vendor performs the criminal background check, it shall immediately provide subsequent arrest and conviction information it receives to the local educational agency pursuant to the subsequent arrest service.
(4)Require all vendors to have policies and procedures related to pupil and site safety, including in virtual settings, emergency response, and accident reporting that are reasonable for the instruction or activity.
(5)Require all vendors to provide evidence of qualification and expertise for the activities or instruction to be provided.
(6)Prohibit the local educational agency from paying any vendor for educational enrichment activities before approval.
(c)Any vendor contract that will exceed one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) in a fiscal year shall be approved by the governing board or body of the local educational agency in an open public meeting.
(d)Auditing of the approval of, and compliance with, policies enacted in accordance with subdivisions (b) and (c) shall be included in the audit guide, Standards and Procedures for Audits of California K12 Local Educational Agencies, described in Section 14502.1.
(e)Any educational enrichment activity provided by a school shall be approved and verified by the pupils assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate for the pupil.
(f)Notwithstanding any other law, a vendor providing services pursuant to this article shall provide the initial criminal background check report before commencing services and immediately provide any subsequent arrest and conviction information to the local educational agency upon receipt.
(g)For purposes of this section, local educational agency means a county office of education, school district, or charter school.
(h)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2025.
SEC. 7.SEC. 6.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)If the Controller determines by two consecutive quality control reviews pursuant to Section 14504.2, or if a county superintendent of schools determines, that audits performed by a certified public accountant or public accountant under Section 41020 and subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 were not performed in substantial conformity with provisions of the audit guide, or that the audit reports, including amended reports, submitted by February 15 following the close of the fiscal year audited, for two consecutive years do not conform to provisions of the audit guide as required by Section 14504, the Controller or the county superintendent of schools, as appropriate, shall notify in writing the certified public accountant or public accountant and the California Board of Accountancy.
(2)If the certified public accountant or public accountant does not file an appeal in writing with the California Board of Accountancy within 30 calendar days after receipt of the notification from the Controller or county superintendent of schools, the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools pursuant to this section shall be final.
(b)If an appeal is filed with the California Board of Accountancy, the board shall complete an investigation of the appeal within 90 days of the filing date. On the basis of the investigation, the board may do either of the following:
(1)Find that the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools should not be upheld and has no effect.
(2)Schedule the appeal for a hearing, in which case, the final action on the appeal shall be completed by the board within one year from the date of filing the appeal.
(c)If the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools under subdivision (a) becomes final, the certified public accountant or public accountant shall be ineligible to conduct audits under Section 41020 and subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a period of three years, or, in the event of an appeal, for any period, and subject to the conditions, that may be ordered by the California Board of Accountancy. Not later than the first day of March of each year, the Controller shall notify each school district, charter school, and county office of education of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible under this section. School districts, charter schools, and county offices of education shall not use the audit services of a certified public accountant or public accountant ineligible under this section.
(d)For purposes of this section, certified public accountant or public accountant includes any person or firm entering into a contract to conduct an audit under Section 41020 or subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8.
(e)This section shall not preclude the California Board of Accountancy from taking any disciplinary action it deems appropriate under other laws.
SEC. 2.Section 47605 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.(a)(1)Except as set forth in paragraph (2), a petition for the establishment of a charter school within a school district may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. A petition for the establishment of a charter school shall identify a single charter school that will operate within the geographic boundaries of that school district. A charter school may propose to operate at multiple sites within the school district if each location is identified in the charter school petition. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or legal guardians of pupils that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the charter school for its first year of operation.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the charter school during its first year of operation.
(2)A petition that proposes to convert an existing public school to a charter school that would not be eligible for a loan pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41365 may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after the petition is signed by not less than 50 percent of the permanent status teachers currently employed at the public school to be converted.
(3)A petition shall include a prominent statement that a signature on the petition means that the parent or legal guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(4)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to expand operations to one or more additional sites or grade levels shall request a material revision to its charter and shall notify the chartering authority of those additional locations or grade levels. The chartering authority shall consider whether to approve those additional locations or grade levels at an open, public meeting. If the additional locations or grade levels are approved pursuant to the standards and criteria described in subdivision (c), they shall be a material revision to the charter schools charter.
(5)(A)A charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county in which that school district is located before January 1, 2020, may continue to operate that site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the site, the charter school shall do either of the following:
(i)First, before submitting the request for the renewal of the charter petition, obtain approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
(ii)Submit a request for the renewal of the charter petition pursuant to Section 47607 to the school district in which the charter school is located.
(B)If a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency is issued in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.) for an area in which a charter schoolsite is located and operating, the charter school, for not more than five years, may relocate that site outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration if the charter school first obtains the written approval of the school district where the site is being relocated to.
(C)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.), that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
(D)(i)A charter school in operation and providing educational services to pupils before October 1, 2019, located on a federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria or operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe shall be exempt from the geographic restrictions of paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A) of this paragraph and the geographic restrictions of subdivision (a) of Section 47605.1.
(ii)The exemption to the geographic restrictions of subdivision (a) of Section 47605.1 in clause (i) does not apply to nonclassroom-based charter schools operating pursuant to Section 47612.5.
(E)The department shall regard as a continuing charter school for all purposes a charter school that was granted approval of its petition, that was providing educational services to pupils before October 1, 2019, and is authorized by a different chartering authority due to changes to this paragraph that took effect January 1, 2020. This paragraph shall be implemented only to the extent it does not conflict with federal law. In order to prevent any potential conflict with federal law, this paragraph does not apply to covered programs as identified in Section 8101(11) of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 7801) to the extent the affected charter school is the restructured portion of a divided charter school pursuant to Section 47654.
(6)Commencing January 1, 2003, a petition to establish a charter school shall not be approved to serve pupils in a grade level that is not served by the school district of the governing board considering the petition, unless the petition proposes to serve pupils in all of the grade levels served by that school district.
(b)No later than 60 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the governing board of the school district shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the governing board of the school district shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers employed by the school district, other employees of the school district, and parents. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the governing board of the school district shall either grant or deny the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition, provided, however, that the date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. A petition is deemed received by the governing board of the school district for purposes of commencing the timelines described in this subdivision on the day the petitioner submits a petition to the district office, along with a signed certification that the petitioner deems the petition to be complete. The governing board of the school district shall publish all staff recommendations, including the recommended findings and, if applicable, the certification from the county superintendent of schools prepared pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c), regarding the petition at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district will either grant or deny the charter. At the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district will either grant or deny the charter, petitioners shall have equivalent time and procedures to present evidence and testimony to respond to the staff recommendations and findings.
(c)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools pursuant to this section, the chartering authority shall be guided by the intent of the Legislature that charter schools are and should become an integral part of the California educational system and that the establishment of charter schools should be encouraged. The governing board of the school district shall grant a charter for the operation of a school under this part if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice and with the interests of the community in which the school is proposing to locate. The governing board of the school district shall consider the academic needs of the pupils the school proposes to serve. The governing board of the school district shall not deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school unless it makes written factual findings, specific to the particular petition, setting forth specific facts to support one or more of the following findings:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (e).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will serve high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents about the transferability of courses to other public high schools and the eligibility of courses to meet college entrance requirements. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered transferable and courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the A to G admissions criteria may be considered to meet college entrance requirements.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and attitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all pupil subgroups served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subdivision (a) of Section 52052. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(E)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(F)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)For all schools, the development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282. For schools serving pupils in any of grades 7 to 12, inclusive, the development of a school safety plan shall also include the safety topic listed in subparagraph (L) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(G)The means by which the charter school will achieve a balance of racial and ethnic pupils, special education pupils, and English learner pupils, including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils, as defined by the evaluation rubrics in Section 52064.5, that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the school district to which the charter petition is submitted. Upon renewal, for a charter school not deemed to be a local educational agency for purposes of special education pursuant to Section 47641, the chartering authority may consider the effect of school placements made by the chartering authority in providing a free and appropriate public education as required by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 101-476), on the balance of pupils with disabilities at the charter school.
(H)Admission policies and procedures, consistent with subdivision (e).
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, which shall employ generally accepted accounting principles, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved to the satisfaction of the chartering authority.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that are consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian, or, if the pupil is a homeless child or youth, or a foster child or youth, in the native language of the homeless or foster childs educational rights holder. In the case of a foster child or youth, the written notice shall also be provided to the foster childs attorney and county social worker. If the pupil is an Indian child, as defined in Section 224.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the written notice shall also be provided to the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker. The written notice shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, or county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker or, if applicable, county social worker initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(iv)A foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker and an Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker shall have the same rights a parent or guardian of a child has to receive a suspension notice, expulsion notice, manifestation determination notice, involuntary transfer notice, and other documents and related information.
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter schools will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the school district who choose not to attend charter schools.
(M)The rights of an employee of the school district upon leaving the employment of the school district to work in a charter school, and of any rights of return to the school district after employment at a charter school.
(N)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the chartering authority to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(O)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of pupil records.
(6)The petition does not contain a declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(7)The charter school is demonstrably unlikely to serve the interests of the entire community in which the school is proposing to locate. Analysis of this finding shall include consideration of the fiscal impact of the proposed charter school. A written factual finding under this paragraph shall detail specific facts and circumstances that analyze and consider the following factors:
(A)The extent to which the proposed charter school would substantially undermine existing services, academic offerings, or programmatic offerings.
(B)Whether the proposed charter school would duplicate a program currently offered within the school district and the existing program has sufficient capacity for the pupils proposed to be served within reasonable proximity to where the charter school intends to locate.
(8)The school district is not positioned to absorb the fiscal impact of the proposed charter school. A school district satisfies this paragraph if it has a qualified interim certification pursuant to Section 42131 and the county superintendent of schools, in consultation with the County Office Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team, certifies that approving the charter school would result in the school district having a negative interim certification pursuant to Section 42131, has a negative interim certification pursuant to Section 42131, or is under state receivership. Charter schools proposed in a school district satisfying one of these conditions shall be subject to a rebuttable presumption of denial.
(d)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall, on a regular basis, consult with their parents, legal guardians, and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(e)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against a pupil on the basis of the characteristics listed in Section 220. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of that pupils parent or legal guardian, within this state, except that an existing public school converting partially or entirely to a charter school under this part shall adopt and maintain a policy giving admission preference to pupils who reside within the former attendance area of that public school.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the school district except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the chartering authority shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and shall not take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days, and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(f)The governing board of a school district shall not require an employee of the school district to be employed in a charter school.
(g)The governing board of a school district shall not require a pupil enrolled in the school district to attend a charter school.
(h)The governing board of a school district shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school and upon the school district. The description of the facilities to be used by the charter school shall specify where the charter school intends to locate. The petitioner or petitioners also shall be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation. If the school is to be operated by, or as, a nonprofit public benefit corporation, the petitioner shall provide the names and relevant qualifications of all persons whom the petitioner nominates to serve on the governing body of the charter school.
(i)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the school district, the governing board of the school district shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(j)Upon the approval of the petition by the governing board of the school district, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the applicable county superintendent of schools, the department, and the state board.
(k)(1)(A)(i)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education. The petitioner shall submit the petition to the county board of education within 30 days of a denial by the governing board of the school district. At the same time the petition is submitted to the county board of education, the petitioner shall also provide a copy of the petition to the school district. The county board of education shall review the petition pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c). If the petition submitted on appeal contains new or different material terms, the county board of education shall immediately remand the petition to the governing board of the school district for reconsideration, which shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days. If the governing board of the school district denies a petition after reconsideration, the petitioner may elect to resubmit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education.
(ii)The county board of education shall review the appeal petition pursuant to subdivision (c). If the denial of the petition was made pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c), the county board of education shall also review the school districts findings pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c).
(iii)As used in this subdivision, material terms of the petition means the signatures, affirmations, disclosures, documents, and descriptions described in subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (h), but shall not include minor administrative updates to the petition or related documents due to changes in circumstances based on the passage of time related to fiscal affairs, facilities arrangements, or state law, or to reflect the county board of education as the chartering authority.
(B)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition and the county board of education has jurisdiction over a single school district, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the state board. The state board shall review a petition submitted pursuant to this subparagraph pursuant to subdivision (c). If the denial of a charter petition is reversed by the state board pursuant to this subparagraph, the state board shall designate the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located as the chartering authority.
(2)If the county board of education denies a petition, the petitioner may appeal that denial to the state board.
(A)The petitioner shall submit the petition to the state board within 30 days of a denial by the county board of education. The petitioner shall include the findings and documentary record from the governing board of the school district and the county board of education and a written submission detailing, with specific citations to the documentary record, how the governing board of the school district and the county board of education abused their discretion. The governing board of the school district and county board of education shall prepare the documentary record, including transcripts of the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district and county board of education denied the charter, at the request of the petitioner. The documentary record shall be prepared by the governing board of the school district and county board of education no later than 10 business days after the request of the petitioner is made. At the same time the petition and supporting documentation is submitted to the state board, the petitioner shall also provide a copy of the petition and supporting documentation to the school district and the county board of education.
(B)If the appeal contains new or different material terms, as defined in clause (iii) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the state board shall immediately remand the petition to the governing board of the school district to which the petition was submitted for reconsideration. The governing board of the school district shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days. If the governing board of the school district denies a petition after reconsideration, the petitioner may elect to resubmit the petition to the state board.
(C)Within 30 days of receipt of the appeal submitted to the state board, the governing board of the school district or county board of education may submit a written opposition to the state board detailing, with specific citations to the documentary record, how the governing board of the school district or the county board of education did not abuse its discretion in denying the petition. The governing board of the school district or the county board of education may submit supporting documentation or evidence from the documentary record that was considered by the governing board of the school district or the county board of education.
(D)The state boards Advisory Commission on Charter Schools shall hold a public hearing to review the appeal and documentary record. Based on its review, the Advisory Commission on Charter Schools shall submit a recommendation to the state board whether there is sufficient evidence to hear the appeal or to summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record. If the Advisory Commission on Charter Schools does not submit a recommendation to the state board, the state board shall consider the appeal, and shall either hear the appeal or summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record at a regular public meeting of the state board.
(E)The state board shall either hear the appeal or summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record. If the state board hears the appeal, the state board may affirm the determination of the governing board of the school district or the county board of education, or both of those determinations, or may reverse only upon a determination that there was an abuse of discretion by each of the governing board of the school district and the county board of education. Abuse of discretion is the most deferential standard of review, under which the state board must give deference to the decisions of the governing board of the school district and the county board of education to deny the petition. If the denial of a charter petition is reversed by the state board, the state board shall designate, in consultation with the petitioner, either the governing board of the school district or the county board of education in which the charter school is located as the chartering authority.
(3)A charter school for which a charter is granted by either the county board of education or the state board based on an appeal pursuant to this subdivision shall qualify fully as a charter school for all funding and other purposes of this part.
(4)A charter school that receives approval of its petition from a county board of education or from the state board on appeal shall be subject to the same requirements concerning geographic location to which it would otherwise be subject if it received approval from the chartering authority to which it originally submitted its petition. A charter petition that is submitted to either a county board of education or to the state board shall meet all otherwise applicable petition requirements, including the identification of the proposed site or sites where the charter school will operate.
(5)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petition or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located, the department, and the state board.
(6)If either the county board of education or the state board fails to act on a petition within 180 days of receipt, the decision of the governing board of the school district to deny the petition shall be subject to judicial review.
(l)(1)Teachers in charter schools shall hold the Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document required for the teachers certificated assignment. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and are subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. A governing body of a direct-funded charter school may use local assignment options authorized in statute and regulations for the purpose of legally assigning certificated teachers, in accordance with all of the requirements of the applicable statutes or regulations in the same manner as a governing board of a school district. A charter school shall have authority to request an emergency permit or a waiver from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing for individuals in the same manner as a school district.
(2)By July 1, 2020, all teachers in charter schools shall obtain a certificate of clearance and satisfy the requirements for professional fitness pursuant to Sections 44339, 44340, and 44341.
(3)The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall include in the bulletins it issues pursuant to subdivision (k) of Section 44237 to provide notification to local educational agencies of any adverse actions taken against the holders of any commission documents, notice of any adverse actions taken against teachers employed by charter schools, and shall make this bulletin available to all chartering authorities and charter schools in the same manner in which it is made available to local educational agencies.
(m)(1)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c), to its chartering authority, the Controller, the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering authority, and the department by December 15 of each year. This paragraph does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(2)By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 each year thereafter, the governing body of a charter school shall review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, including any factors identified pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a nonclassroom-based charter school, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. The review shall be placed on the agenda of the meeting pursuant to the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement, but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
(o)The requirements of this section shall not be waived by the state board pursuant to Section 33050 or any other law.
SEC. 3.Section 47605.6 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.6.(a)(1)In addition to the authority provided by Section 47605.5, a county board of education may also approve a petition for the operation of a charter school that operates at one or more sites within the geographic boundaries of the county and that provides instructional services that are not generally provided by a county office of education. A county board of education may approve a countywide charter only if it finds, in addition to the other requirements of this section, that the educational services to be provided by the charter school will offer services to a pupil population that will benefit from those services and that cannot be served as well by a charter school that operates in only one school district in the county. A petition for the establishment of a countywide charter school pursuant to this subdivision may be circulated throughout the county by any one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the county board of education for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or guardians of pupils residing within the county that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the school for its first year of operation and each of the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to operate a facility has received at least 30 days notice of the petitioners intent to operate a charter school pursuant to this section.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the school during its first year of operation and each of the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to operate a facility has received at least 30 days notice of the petitioners intent to operate a charter school pursuant to this section.
(2)An existing public school shall not be converted to a charter school in accordance with this section.
(3)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to establish operations at additional sites within the geographic boundaries of the county board of education shall notify the school districts where those sites will be located. The charter school shall also request a material revision of its charter by the county board of education that approved its charter and the county board of education shall consider whether to approve those additional locations at an open, public meeting, held no sooner than 30 days following notification of the school districts where the sites will be located. If approved, the location of the approved sites shall be a material revision of the charter schools approved charter.
(4)A petition shall include a prominent statement indicating that a signature on the petition means that the parent or guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(b)No later than 60 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the county board of education shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the county board of education shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers, parents or guardians, and the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to place school facilities. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the county board of education shall either grant or deny the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition. However, this date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. A petition is deemed received by the county board of education for purposes of commencing the timelines described in this subdivision when the petitioner submits a petition, in accordance with subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), to the county office of education. The county board of education shall publish all staff recommendations, including the recommended findings, regarding the petition at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the county board of education will either grant or deny the charter. At the public hearing at which the county board of education will either grant or deny the charter, petitioners shall have equivalent time and procedures to present evidence and testimony to respond to the staff recommendations and findings. A county board of education may impose any additional requirements beyond those required by this section that it considers necessary for the sound operation of a countywide charter school. A county board of education may grant a charter for the operation of a charter school under this part only if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice and that the charter school has reasonable justification for why it could not be established by petition to a school district pursuant to Section 47605. The county board of education shall deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school if it finds one or more of the following:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (e).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those pupils whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will enroll high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents regarding the transferability of courses to other public high schools. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered to be transferable to other public high schools.
(iv)If the proposed charter school will enroll high school pupils, information as to the manner in which the charter school will inform parents as to whether each individual course offered by the charter school meets college entrance requirements. Courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as satisfying their prerequisites for admission may be considered as meeting college entrance requirements for purposes of this clause.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and aptitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all pupil subgroups served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subdivision (a) of Section 52052. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The location of each charter school facility that the petitioner proposes to operate.
(E)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(F)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(G)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)For all schools, the development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282. For schools serving pupils in any of grades 7 to 12, inclusive, the development of a school safety plan shall also include the safety topic listed in subparagraph (L) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(H)The means by which the charter school will achieve a balance of racial and ethnic pupils, special education pupils, and English learner pupils, including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils as defined by the evaluation rubrics in Section 52064.5, that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the county board of education to which the charter petition is submitted. Upon renewal, for a charter school not deemed to be a local educational agency for purposes of special education pursuant to Section 47641, the chartering authority may consider the effect of school placements made by the chartering authority in providing a free and appropriate public education as required by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 101-476), on the balance of pupils with disabilities at the charter school.
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, in accordance with regulations established by the state board, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that is consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian, or, if the pupil is a homeless child or youth, or a foster child or youth, in the native language of the homeless or foster childs educational rights holder. In the case of a foster child or youth, the written notice shall also be provided to the foster childs attorney and county social worker. If the pupil is an Indian child, as defined in Section 224.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the written notice shall also be provided to the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker. The written notice shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, or county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker or, if applicable, county social worker initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(iv)A foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker and an Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker shall have the same rights a parent or guardian of a child has to receive a suspension notice, expulsion notice, manifestation determination notice, involuntary transfer notice, and other documents and related information.
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter school will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the county board of education to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(M)Admission policy and procedures, consistent with subdivision (e).
(N)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the county who choose not to attend the charter school.
(O)The rights of an employee of the county office of education, upon leaving the employment of the county office of education, to be employed by the charter school, and any rights of return to the county office of education that an employee may have upon leaving the employment of the charter school.
(P)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of public records.
(6)A declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public school employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of the Educational Employment Relations Act (Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(7)Any other basis that the county board of education finds justifies the denial of the petition.
(c)A county board of education that approves a petition for the operation of a countywide charter may, as a condition of charter approval, enter into an agreement with a third party, at the expense of the charter school, to oversee, monitor, and report to the county board of education on the operations of the charter school. The county board of education may prescribe the aspects of the charter schools operations to be monitored by the third party and may prescribe appropriate requirements regarding the reporting of information concerning the operations of the charter school to the county board of education.
(d)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall on a regular basis consult with their parents and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(e)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against any pupil on the basis of ethnicity, national origin, gender, gender identity, gender expression, or disability. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of the pupils parent or guardian, within this state.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the county except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the county board of education shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and in no event shall take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(f)The county board of education shall not require an employee of the county or a school district to be employed in a charter school.
(g)The county board of education shall not require a pupil enrolled in a county program to attend a charter school.
(h)The county board of education shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school, any school district where the charter school may operate, and upon the county board of education. The petitioner or petitioners shall also be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation. If the charter school is to be operated by, or as, a nonprofit public benefit corporation, the petitioner shall provide the names and relevant qualifications of all persons whom the petitioner nominates to serve on the governing body of the charter school.
(i)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the county, the county board of education shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(j)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the school districts within the county, the Superintendent, and the state board.
(k)If a county board of education denies a petition, the petitioner shall not elect to submit the petition for the establishment of the charter school to the state board.
(l)(1)Teachers in charter schools shall be required to hold the Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document required for the teachers certificated assignment. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and shall be subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. A governing body of a direct-funded charter school may use local assignment options authorized in statute and regulations for the purpose of legally assigning certificated teachers, in accordance with all of the requirements of the applicable statutes or regulations in the same manner as a governing board of a school district. A charter school shall have authority to request an emergency permit or a waiver from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing for individuals in the same manner as a school district.
(2)The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall include in the bulletins it issues pursuant to subdivision (k) of Section 44237 to provide notification to local educational agencies of any adverse actions taken against the holders of any commission documents, notice of any adverse actions taken against teachers employed by charter schools. The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall make this bulletin available to all chartering authorities and charter schools in the same manner in which it is made available to local educational agencies.
(m)(1)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent, financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b), to the county office of education, the Controller, and the department by December 15 of each year. This paragraph does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(2)By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 each year thereafter, the governing body of a charter school shall review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, including any factors identified pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a nonclassroom-based charter school, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. The review shall be placed on the agenda of the meeting pursuant to the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
(o)The requirements of this section shall not be waived by the state board pursuant to Section 33050 or any other law.
SEC. 4.Section 47612.8 is added to the Education Code, to read:47612.8.(a)An auditor of a nonclassroom-based charter school, when performing an audit described in Section 41020, subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c) of Section 47605, or subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 47605.6, shall do all of the following:
(1)(A)Ensure that all sampling of documents or records necessary for the audit are independently selected by the auditor.
(B)Contact a random sample of parents or guardians of pupils, emancipated pupils, or other custodians of pupils, or in the case of a pupil over 18 years of age, the pupil, enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment.
(C)Select a sample and review credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school pursuant to the process described in Section 14502.1.
(2)Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars ($1,000,000) or 10 percent of the charter schools budget, whichever is less, together with a written explanation from the school regarding the school purpose for each such expenditure.
(3)Identify any other transaction that does not meet the standards identified in Section 14502.1.
(4)Review compliance by the charter school with any policy adopted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 51820.
(5)Include a letter with the audit report discussing any findings of the auditor relating to factors arising from the auditors activities under this subdivision, or arising from the lack of those factors, together with a response by the charter school if the charter school chooses to make a response.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Auditor of a nonclassroom-based school means any certified public accountant or public accountant assigned to a nonclassroom-based charter school audit, as described in Section 41020, subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c) of Section 47605, or subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 47605.6.
(2)Nonclassroom-based charter school means a charter school that offers nonclassroom-based instruction pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 47612.5 for more than 20 percent of the instructional time reported by the charter school at the second principal apportionment.
SEC. 5.Section 51747 of the Education Code is amended to read:51747.A local educational agency shall not be eligible to receive apportionments for independent study by pupils, regardless of age, unless it has adopted written policies, and has implemented those policies, pursuant to rules and regulations adopted by the Superintendent, that include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(a)The maximum length of time, by grade level and type of program, that may elapse between the time an independent study assignment is made and the date by which the pupil must complete the assigned work.
(b)(1)The level of satisfactory educational progress and the number of missed assignments that will be allowed before an evaluation is conducted to determine whether it is in the best interests of the pupil to remain in independent study, or whether the pupil should return to the regular school program. A written record of the findings of any evaluation made pursuant to this subdivision shall be treated as a mandatory interim pupil record. The record shall be maintained for a period of three years from the date of the evaluation and, if the pupil transfers to another California public school, the record shall be forwarded to that school.
(2)Satisfactory educational progress shall be determined based on all of the following indicators:
(A)The pupils achievement and engagement in the independent study program, as indicated by the pupils performance on applicable pupil-level measures of pupil achievement and pupil engagement set forth in paragraphs (4) and (5) of subdivision (d) of Section 52060.
(B)The completion of assignments, assessments, or other indicators that evidence that the pupil is working on assignments.
(C)Learning required concepts, as determined by the supervising teacher.
(D)Progressing toward successful completion of the course of study or individual course, as determined by the supervising teacher.
(c)The provision of content aligned to grade level standards that is substantially equivalent to in-person instruction. For high schools, this shall include access to all courses offered by the local educational agency for graduation and approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the AG admissions criteria.
(d)Procedures for tiered reengagement strategies for all pupils who are not generating attendance for more than 10 percent of required minimum instructional time over four continuous weeks of a local educational agencys approved instructional calendar, pupils found not participatory in synchronous instructional offerings pursuant to Section 51747.5 for more than 50 percent of the scheduled times of synchronous instruction in a school month as applicable by grade span, or pupils who are in violation of the written agreement pursuant to subdivision (g). These procedures shall include local programs intended to address chronic absenteeism, as applicable, with at least all of the following:
(1)Verification of current contact information for each enrolled pupil.
(2)Notification to parents or guardians of lack of participation within one school day of the recording of a nonattendance day or lack of participation.
(3)A plan for outreach from the school to determine pupil needs, including connection with health and social services as necessary.
(4)A clear standard for requiring a pupil-parent-educator conference to review a pupils written agreement, and reconsider the independent study programs impact on the pupils achievement and well-being, consistent with the policies adopted pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (g).
(e)(1)For pupils in transitional kindergarten and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for daily synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.
(2)For pupils in grades 4 to 8, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for both daily live interaction and at least weekly synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.
(3)For pupils in grades 9 to 12, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for at least weekly synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.
(f)A plan to transition pupils whose families wish to return to in-person instruction from independent study expeditiously, and, in no case, later than five instructional days.
(g)A requirement that a current written agreement for each independent study pupil shall be maintained on file, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The manner, time, frequency, and place for submitting a pupils assignments, for reporting the pupils academic progress, and for communicating with a pupils parent or guardian regarding a pupils academic progress.
(2)The objectives and methods of study for the pupils work, and the methods used to evaluate that work.
(3)The specific resources, including materials and personnel, that will be made available to the pupil. These resources shall include confirming or providing access to all pupils to the connectivity and devices adequate to participate in the educational program and complete assigned work.
(4)A statement of the policies adopted pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) regarding the maximum length of time allowed between the assignment and the completion of a pupils assigned work, the level of satisfactory educational progress, and the number of missed assignments allowed before an evaluation of whether or not the pupil should be allowed to continue in independent study.
(5)The duration of the independent study agreement, including the beginning and ending dates for the pupils participation in independent study under the agreement. No independent study agreement shall be valid for any period longer than one school year.
(6)A statement of the number of course credits or, for the elementary grades, other measures of academic accomplishment appropriate to the agreement, to be earned by the pupil upon completion.
(7)A statement detailing the academic and other supports that will be provided to address the needs of pupils who are not performing at grade level, or need support in other areas, such as English learners, individuals with exceptional needs in order to be consistent with the pupils individualized education program or plan pursuant to Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794), pupils in foster care or experiencing homelessness, and pupils requiring mental health supports.
(8)The inclusion of a statement in each independent study agreement that independent study is an optional educational alternative in which no pupil may be required to participate. In the case of a pupil who is referred or assigned to any school, class, or program pursuant to Section 48915 or 48917, the agreement also shall include the statement that instruction may be provided to the pupil through independent study only if the pupil is offered the alternative of classroom instruction.
(9)(A)For a pupil participating in an independent study program that is scheduled for more than 14 school days, each written agreement shall be signed, before the commencement of independent study, by the pupil, the pupils parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable. Beginning in the 202223 school year, for a pupil participating in an independent study program that is scheduled for less than 15 school days, each written agreement shall be signed within 10 school days of the commencement of the first day of the pupils enrollment in independent study, by the pupil, the pupils parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable. For purposes of this paragraph caregiver means a person who has met the requirements of Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 6550) of Division 11 of the Family Code.
(B)Signed written agreements, supplemental agreements, assignment records, work samples, and attendance records assessing time value of work or evidence that an instructional activity occurred may be maintained as an electronic file.
(C)For purposes of this section, an electronic file includes a computer or electronic stored image of an original document, including, but not limited to, portable document format (PDF), JPEG, or other digital image file type, that may be sent via fax machine, email, or other electronic means.
(D)Either an original document or an electronic file of the original document is allowable documentation for auditing purposes.
(E)Written agreements may be signed using an electronic signature that complies with state and federal standards, as determined by the department, that may be a marking that is either computer generated or produced by electronic means and is intended by the signatory to have the same effect as a handwritten signature. The use of an electronic signature shall have the same force and effect as the use of a manual signature if the requirements for digital signatures and their acceptable technology, as provided in Section 16.5 of the Government Code and in Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 22000) of Division 7 of Title 2 of the California Code of Regulations, are satisfied.
(F)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), for the 202122 school year only, a local educational agency shall obtain a signed written agreement for an independent study program of any length of time from the pupil, or the pupils parent or legal guardian if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable, no later than 30 days after the first day of instruction in an independent study program or October 15, whichever date comes later. This subparagraph does not relieve a local educational agency from the obligation to comply with the requirements of this article, as amended by the act adding this subparagraph, upon commencement of instruction for a participating pupil in the 202122 school year.
(h)(1)For the 202122 school year only, school districts and county offices of education shall notify the parents and guardians of all enrolled pupils of their options to enroll their child in in-person instruction or independent study during the 202122 school year. This notice shall include written information on the local educational agencys internet website, including, but not limited to, the right to request a pupil-parent-educator conference meeting before enrollment pursuant to this section, pupil rights regarding procedures for enrolling, disenrolling, and reenrolling in independent study, and the synchronous and asynchronous instructional time that a pupil will have access to as part of independent study. If 15 percent or more of the pupils enrolled in a local educational agency that provides instruction in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, speak a single primary language other than English, as determined from the census data submitted to the department pursuant to Section 52164 in the preceding year, the written information shall, in addition to being written in English, be written in the primary language.
(2)Before signing a written agreement pursuant to this section, the parent or guardian of a pupil may request that the local educational agency conduct a telephone, videoconference, or in-person pupil-parent-educator conference or other school meeting during which the pupil, parent or guardian, and, if requested by the pupil or parent, an education advocate, may ask questions about the educational options, including which curriculum offerings and nonacademic supports will be available to the pupil in independent study, before making the decision about enrollment or disenrollment in the various options for learning.
(i)Subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) shall not apply to pupils that participate in an independent study program for fewer than 15 schooldays in a school year and pupils enrolled in a comprehensive school for classroom-based instruction who, under the care of appropriately licensed professionals, participate in independent study due to necessary medical treatments or inpatient treatment for mental health care or substance abuse. Local educational agencies shall obtain evidence from appropriately licensed professionals of the need for pupils to participate in independent study pursuant to this subdivision.
(j)(1)Notwithstanding paragraph (8) of subdivision (g) of this section, paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 46300, and subdivision (d) of Section 51745, for the 202122 school year only, a local educational agency shall be eligible to receive apportionments for independent study for pupils that are subject to quarantine for exposure to, or infection with, COVID-19 pursuant to local or state health guidance, and the pupil cannot participate in classroom-based instruction due to the quarantine, and for school closures due to COVID-19 pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41422. Local educational agencies shall receive apportionment for these pupils for all schooldays that they participate in and meet all other apportionment requirements of independent study while in quarantine or during a school closure.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 47612.5, for the 202122 fiscal year, a classroom-based charter school that provides an independent study program pursuant to this article for pupils that are subject to quarantine for exposure to, or infection with, COVID-19 pursuant to local or state health guidance, and the pupil cannot participate in classroom-based instruction due to the quarantine, shall not attribute quarantine-based independent study average daily attendance required pursuant to law for a nonclassroom-based charter school pursuant to Section 47612.5 and shall not be required to submit a request for a funding determination as a result of providing independent study to quarantined pupils.
(3)This subdivision shall apply only to pupils participating in independent study due to quarantine who do not have the option of in-person instruction, and only for the period of quarantine mandated pursuant to state or local health guidance or order. This subdivision shall not apply to classroom-based charter schools offering independent study to pupils whose parents or guardians have requested independent study pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 51745.
(k)Commencing with the 202122 fiscal year Guide for Annual Audits of K12 Local Education Agencies and State Compliance Reporting, the Controller shall incorporate verification of the adoption of the policies required pursuant to this section, including loss of apportionment for independent study for local educational agencies found to be noncompliant, unless compliance verification for those policies is already included in the audit guide.
(l)Commencing July 1, 2025, if, as part of the written agreement under required pursuant to this section shall be signed under penalty of perjury. section, a local educational agency employee willfully states as true any material fact that the employee knows to be false, the department may assess an administrative penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) on the local educational agency.
(m)The provisions of this section are not subject to waiver by the state board, by the Superintendent, or under any provision of Part 26.8 (commencing with Section 47600).
SEC. 6.Article 10.5 (commencing with Section 51820) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 28 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Education Code, to read:10.5.Educational Enrichment Activities51820.(a)A local educational agency may only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c). A local educational agency may expend public funds for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities, provided that all educational enrichment activities, materials, and programs shall be nonsectarian.
(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, the governing board or body of the local educational agency shall establish policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness that, at a minimum, do all of the following:
(1)Ensure a reasonable market value for the service provided.
(2)Require all vendors to provide proof of valid and appropriate insurance, business licenses, or other certification.
(3)Require all vendor personnel interacting with pupils, unsupervised by a parent or school employee, to have a valid criminal records summary as described in Section 45125.1, and require that if the vendor performs the criminal background check, it shall immediately provide subsequent arrest and conviction information it receives to the local educational agency pursuant to the subsequent arrest service.
(4)Require all vendors to have policies and procedures related to pupil and site safety, including in virtual settings, emergency response, and accident reporting that are reasonable for the instruction or activity.
(5)Require all vendors to provide evidence of qualification and expertise for the activities or instruction to be provided.
(6)Prohibit the local educational agency from paying any vendor for educational enrichment activities before approval.
(c)Any vendor contract that will exceed one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) in a fiscal year shall be approved by the governing board or body of the local educational agency in an open public meeting.
(d)Auditing of the approval of, and compliance with, policies enacted in accordance with subdivisions (b) and (c) shall be included in the audit guide, Standards and Procedures for Audits of California K12 Local Educational Agencies, described in Section 14502.1.
(e)Any educational enrichment activity provided by a school shall be approved and verified by the pupils assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate for the pupil.
(f)Notwithstanding any other law, a vendor providing services pursuant to this article shall provide the initial criminal background check report before commencing services and immediately provide any subsequent arrest and conviction information to the local educational agency upon receipt.
(g)For purposes of this section, local educational agency means a county office of education, school district, or charter school.
(h)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2025.
SEC. 7.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district because, in that regard, this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.SEC. 7.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)If the Controller determines by two consecutive quality control reviews pursuant to Section 14504.2, or if a county superintendent of schools determines, that audits performed by a certified public accountant or public accountant under Section 41020 and subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 were not performed in substantial conformity with provisions of the audit guide, or that the audit reports, including amended reports, submitted by February 15 following the close of the fiscal year audited, for two consecutive years do not conform to provisions of the audit guide as required by Section 14504, the Controller or the county superintendent of schools, as appropriate, shall notify in writing the certified public accountant or public accountant and the California Board of Accountancy.
If(2)If the certified public accountant or public accountant does not file an appeal in writing with the California Board of Accountancy within 30 calendar days after receipt of the notification from the Controller or county superintendent of schools, the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools pursuant to this section shall be final.
(b)If an appeal is filed with the California Board of Accountancy, the board shall complete an investigation of the appeal within 90 days of the filing date. On the basis of the investigation, the board may do either of the following:
(1)Find that the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools should not be upheld and has no effect.
(2)Schedule the appeal for a hearing, in which case, the final action on the appeal shall be completed by the board within one year from the date of filing the appeal.
(c)If the determination of the Controller or county superintendent of schools under subdivision (a) becomes final, the certified public accountant or public accountant shall be ineligible to conduct audits under Section 41020 and subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a period of three years, or, in the event of an appeal, for any period, and subject to the conditions, that may be ordered by the California Board of Accountancy. Not later than the first day of March of each year, the Controller shall notify each school district district, charter school, and county office of education of those certified public accountants or public accountants determined to be ineligible under this section. School districts districts, charter schools, and county offices of education shall not use the audit services of a certified public accountant or public accountant ineligible under this section.
(d)For the purposes of this section, certified public accountant or public accountant includes any person or firm entering into a contract to conduct an audit under Section 41020. 41020 or subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8.
(e)This section shall not preclude the California Board of Accountancy from taking any disciplinary action it deems appropriate under other provisions of law. laws.
SEC. 2.Section 47605 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.(a)(1)Except as set forth in paragraph (2), a petition for the establishment of a charter school within a school district may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. A petition for the establishment of a charter school shall identify a single charter school that will operate within the geographic boundaries of that school district. A charter school may propose to operate at multiple sites within the school district if each location is identified in the charter school petition. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or legal guardians of pupils that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the charter school for its first year of operation.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the charter school during its first year of operation.
(2)A petition that proposes to convert an existing public school to a charter school that would not be eligible for a loan pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41365 may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after the petition is signed by not less than 50 percent of the permanent status teachers currently employed at the public school to be converted.
(3)A petition shall include a prominent statement that a signature on the petition means that the parent or legal guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(4)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to expand operations to one or more additional sites or grade levels shall request a material revision to its charter and shall notify the chartering authority of those additional locations or grade levels. The chartering authority shall consider whether to approve those additional locations or grade levels at an open, public meeting. If the additional locations or grade levels are approved pursuant to the standards and criteria described in subdivision (c), they shall be a material revision to the charter schools charter.
(5)(A)A charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county in which that school district is located before January 1, 2020, may continue to operate that site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the site, the charter school shall do either of the following:
(i)First, before submitting the request for the renewal of the charter petition, obtain approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
(ii)Submit a request for the renewal of the charter petition pursuant to Section 47607 to the school district in which the charter school is located.
(B)If a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency is issued in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.) for an area in which a charter schoolsite is located and operating, the charter school, for not more than five years, may relocate that site outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration if the charter school first obtains the written approval of the school district where the site is being relocated to.
(C)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.), that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
(D)(i)A charter school in operation and providing educational services to pupils before October 1, 2019, located on a federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria or operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe shall be exempt from the geographic restrictions of paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A) of this paragraph and the geographic restrictions of subdivision (a) of Section 47605.1.
(ii)The exemption to the geographic restrictions of subdivision (a) of Section 47605.1 in clause (i) does not apply to nonclassroom-based charter schools operating pursuant to Section 47612.5.
(E)The department shall regard as a continuing charter school for all purposes a charter school that was granted approval of its petition, that was providing educational services to pupils before October 1, 2019, and is authorized by a different chartering authority due to changes to this paragraph that took effect January 1, 2020. This paragraph shall be implemented only to the extent it does not conflict with federal law. In order to prevent any potential conflict with federal law, this paragraph does not apply to covered programs as identified in Section 8101(11) of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 7801) to the extent the affected charter school is the restructured portion of a divided charter school pursuant to Section 47654.
(6)Commencing January 1, 2003, a petition to establish a charter school shall not be approved to serve pupils in a grade level that is not served by the school district of the governing board considering the petition, unless the petition proposes to serve pupils in all of the grade levels served by that school district.
(b)No later than 60 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the governing board of the school district shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the governing board of the school district shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers employed by the school district, other employees of the school district, and parents. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the governing board of the school district shall either grant or deny the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition, provided, however, that the date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. A petition is deemed received by the governing board of the school district for purposes of commencing the timelines described in this subdivision on the day the petitioner submits a petition to the district office, along with a signed certification that the petitioner deems the petition to be complete. The governing board of the school district shall publish all staff recommendations, including the recommended findings and, if applicable, the certification from the county superintendent of schools prepared pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c), regarding the petition at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district will either grant or deny the charter. At the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district will either grant or deny the charter, petitioners shall have equivalent time and procedures to present evidence and testimony to respond to the staff recommendations and findings.
(c)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools pursuant to this section, the chartering authority shall be guided by the intent of the Legislature that charter schools are and should become an integral part of the California educational system and that the establishment of charter schools should be encouraged. The governing board of the school district shall grant a charter for the operation of a school under this part if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice and with the interests of the community in which the school is proposing to locate. The governing board of the school district shall consider the academic needs of the pupils the school proposes to serve. The governing board of the school district shall not deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school unless it makes written factual findings, specific to the particular petition, setting forth specific facts to support one or more of the following findings:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (e).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will serve high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents about the transferability of courses to other public high schools and the eligibility of courses to meet college entrance requirements. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered transferable and courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the A to G admissions criteria may be considered to meet college entrance requirements.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and attitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all pupil subgroups served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subdivision (a) of Section 52052. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(E)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(F)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)For all schools, the development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282. For schools serving pupils in any of grades 7 to 12, inclusive, the development of a school safety plan shall also include the safety topic listed in subparagraph (L) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(G)The means by which the charter school will achieve a balance of racial and ethnic pupils, special education pupils, and English learner pupils, including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils, as defined by the evaluation rubrics in Section 52064.5, that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the school district to which the charter petition is submitted. Upon renewal, for a charter school not deemed to be a local educational agency for purposes of special education pursuant to Section 47641, the chartering authority may consider the effect of school placements made by the chartering authority in providing a free and appropriate public education as required by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 101-476), on the balance of pupils with disabilities at the charter school.
(H)Admission policies and procedures, consistent with subdivision (e).
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, which shall employ generally accepted accounting principles, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved to the satisfaction of the chartering authority.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that are consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian, or, if the pupil is a homeless child or youth, or a foster child or youth, in the native language of the homeless or foster childs educational rights holder. In the case of a foster child or youth, the written notice shall also be provided to the foster childs attorney and county social worker. If the pupil is an Indian child, as defined in Section 224.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the written notice shall also be provided to the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker. The written notice shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, or county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker or, if applicable, county social worker initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(iv)A foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker and an Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker shall have the same rights a parent or guardian of a child has to receive a suspension notice, expulsion notice, manifestation determination notice, involuntary transfer notice, and other documents and related information.
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter schools will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the school district who choose not to attend charter schools.
(M)The rights of an employee of the school district upon leaving the employment of the school district to work in a charter school, and of any rights of return to the school district after employment at a charter school.
(N)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the chartering authority to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(O)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of pupil records.
(6)The petition does not contain a declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(7)The charter school is demonstrably unlikely to serve the interests of the entire community in which the school is proposing to locate. Analysis of this finding shall include consideration of the fiscal impact of the proposed charter school. A written factual finding under this paragraph shall detail specific facts and circumstances that analyze and consider the following factors:
(A)The extent to which the proposed charter school would substantially undermine existing services, academic offerings, or programmatic offerings.
(B)Whether the proposed charter school would duplicate a program currently offered within the school district and the existing program has sufficient capacity for the pupils proposed to be served within reasonable proximity to where the charter school intends to locate.
(8)The school district is not positioned to absorb the fiscal impact of the proposed charter school. A school district satisfies this paragraph if it has a qualified interim certification pursuant to Section 42131 and the county superintendent of schools, in consultation with the County Office Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team, certifies that approving the charter school would result in the school district having a negative interim certification pursuant to Section 42131, has a negative interim certification pursuant to Section 42131, or is under state receivership. Charter schools proposed in a school district satisfying one of these conditions shall be subject to a rebuttable presumption of denial.
(d)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall, on a regular basis, consult with their parents, legal guardians, and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(e)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against a pupil on the basis of the characteristics listed in Section 220. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of that pupils parent or legal guardian, within this state, except that an existing public school converting partially or entirely to a charter school under this part shall adopt and maintain a policy giving admission preference to pupils who reside within the former attendance area of that public school.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the school district except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the chartering authority shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and shall not take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days, and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(f)The governing board of a school district shall not require an employee of the school district to be employed in a charter school.
(g)The governing board of a school district shall not require a pupil enrolled in the school district to attend a charter school.
(h)The governing board of a school district shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school and upon the school district. The description of the facilities to be used by the charter school shall specify where the charter school intends to locate. The petitioner or petitioners also shall be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation. If the school is to be operated by, or as, a nonprofit public benefit corporation, the petitioner shall provide the names and relevant qualifications of all persons whom the petitioner nominates to serve on the governing body of the charter school.
(i)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the school district, the governing board of the school district shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(j)Upon the approval of the petition by the governing board of the school district, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the applicable county superintendent of schools, the department, and the state board.
(k)(1)(A)(i)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education. The petitioner shall submit the petition to the county board of education within 30 days of a denial by the governing board of the school district. At the same time the petition is submitted to the county board of education, the petitioner shall also provide a copy of the petition to the school district. The county board of education shall review the petition pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c). If the petition submitted on appeal contains new or different material terms, the county board of education shall immediately remand the petition to the governing board of the school district for reconsideration, which shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days. If the governing board of the school district denies a petition after reconsideration, the petitioner may elect to resubmit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education.
(ii)The county board of education shall review the appeal petition pursuant to subdivision (c). If the denial of the petition was made pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c), the county board of education shall also review the school districts findings pursuant to paragraph (8) of subdivision (c).
(iii)As used in this subdivision, material terms of the petition means the signatures, affirmations, disclosures, documents, and descriptions described in subdivisions (a), (b), (c), and (h), but shall not include minor administrative updates to the petition or related documents due to changes in circumstances based on the passage of time related to fiscal affairs, facilities arrangements, or state law, or to reflect the county board of education as the chartering authority.
(B)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition and the county board of education has jurisdiction over a single school district, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the state board. The state board shall review a petition submitted pursuant to this subparagraph pursuant to subdivision (c). If the denial of a charter petition is reversed by the state board pursuant to this subparagraph, the state board shall designate the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located as the chartering authority.
(2)If the county board of education denies a petition, the petitioner may appeal that denial to the state board.
(A)The petitioner shall submit the petition to the state board within 30 days of a denial by the county board of education. The petitioner shall include the findings and documentary record from the governing board of the school district and the county board of education and a written submission detailing, with specific citations to the documentary record, how the governing board of the school district and the county board of education abused their discretion. The governing board of the school district and county board of education shall prepare the documentary record, including transcripts of the public hearing at which the governing board of the school district and county board of education denied the charter, at the request of the petitioner. The documentary record shall be prepared by the governing board of the school district and county board of education no later than 10 business days after the request of the petitioner is made. At the same time the petition and supporting documentation is submitted to the state board, the petitioner shall also provide a copy of the petition and supporting documentation to the school district and the county board of education.
(B)If the appeal contains new or different material terms, as defined in clause (iii) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1), the state board shall immediately remand the petition to the governing board of the school district to which the petition was submitted for reconsideration. The governing board of the school district shall grant or deny the petition within 30 days. If the governing board of the school district denies a petition after reconsideration, the petitioner may elect to resubmit the petition to the state board.
(C)Within 30 days of receipt of the appeal submitted to the state board, the governing board of the school district or county board of education may submit a written opposition to the state board detailing, with specific citations to the documentary record, how the governing board of the school district or the county board of education did not abuse its discretion in denying the petition. The governing board of the school district or the county board of education may submit supporting documentation or evidence from the documentary record that was considered by the governing board of the school district or the county board of education.
(D)The state boards Advisory Commission on Charter Schools shall hold a public hearing to review the appeal and documentary record. Based on its review, the Advisory Commission on Charter Schools shall submit a recommendation to the state board whether there is sufficient evidence to hear the appeal or to summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record. If the Advisory Commission on Charter Schools does not submit a recommendation to the state board, the state board shall consider the appeal, and shall either hear the appeal or summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record at a regular public meeting of the state board.
(E)The state board shall either hear the appeal or summarily deny review of the appeal based on the documentary record. If the state board hears the appeal, the state board may affirm the determination of the governing board of the school district or the county board of education, or both of those determinations, or may reverse only upon a determination that there was an abuse of discretion by each of the governing board of the school district and the county board of education. Abuse of discretion is the most deferential standard of review, under which the state board must give deference to the decisions of the governing board of the school district and the county board of education to deny the petition. If the denial of a charter petition is reversed by the state board, the state board shall designate, in consultation with the petitioner, either the governing board of the school district or the county board of education in which the charter school is located as the chartering authority.
(3)A charter school for which a charter is granted by either the county board of education or the state board based on an appeal pursuant to this subdivision shall qualify fully as a charter school for all funding and other purposes of this part.
(4)A charter school that receives approval of its petition from a county board of education or from the state board on appeal shall be subject to the same requirements concerning geographic location to which it would otherwise be subject if it received approval from the chartering authority to which it originally submitted its petition. A charter petition that is submitted to either a county board of education or to the state board shall meet all otherwise applicable petition requirements, including the identification of the proposed site or sites where the charter school will operate.
(5)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petition or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located, the department, and the state board.
(6)If either the county board of education or the state board fails to act on a petition within 180 days of receipt, the decision of the governing board of the school district to deny the petition shall be subject to judicial review.
(l)(1)Teachers in charter schools shall hold the Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document required for the teachers certificated assignment. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and are subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. A governing body of a direct-funded charter school may use local assignment options authorized in statute and regulations for the purpose of legally assigning certificated teachers, in accordance with all of the requirements of the applicable statutes or regulations in the same manner as a governing board of a school district. A charter school shall have authority to request an emergency permit or a waiver from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing for individuals in the same manner as a school district.
(2)By July 1, 2020, all teachers in charter schools shall obtain a certificate of clearance and satisfy the requirements for professional fitness pursuant to Sections 44339, 44340, and 44341.
(3)The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall include in the bulletins it issues pursuant to subdivision (k) of Section 44237 to provide notification to local educational agencies of any adverse actions taken against the holders of any commission documents, notice of any adverse actions taken against teachers employed by charter schools, and shall make this bulletin available to all chartering authorities and charter schools in the same manner in which it is made available to local educational agencies.
(m)(1)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c), to its chartering authority, the Controller, the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering authority, and the department by December 15 of each year. This subdivision paragraph does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(2)By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 each year thereafter, the governing body of a charter school shall review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, including any factors identified pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a nonclassroom-based charter school, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. The review shall be placed on the agenda of the meeting pursuant to the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement, but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
(o)The requirements of this section shall not be waived by the state board pursuant to Section 33050 or any other law.
SEC. 3.Section 47605.6 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.6.(a)(1)In addition to the authority provided by Section 47605.5, a county board of education may also approve a petition for the operation of a charter school that operates at one or more sites within the geographic boundaries of the county and that provides instructional services that are not generally provided by a county office of education. A county board of education may approve a countywide charter only if it finds, in addition to the other requirements of this section, that the educational services to be provided by the charter school will offer services to a pupil population that will benefit from those services and that cannot be served as well by a charter school that operates in only one school district in the county. A petition for the establishment of a countywide charter school pursuant to this subdivision may be circulated throughout the county by any one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the county board of education for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or guardians of pupils residing within the county that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the school for its first year of operation and each of the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to operate a facility has received at least 30 days notice of the petitioners intent to operate a charter school pursuant to this section.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the school during its first year of operation and each of the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to operate a facility has received at least 30 days notice of the petitioners intent to operate a charter school pursuant to this section.
(2)An existing public school shall not be converted to a charter school in accordance with this section.
(3)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to establish operations at additional sites within the geographic boundaries of the county board of education shall notify the school districts where those sites will be located. The charter school shall also request a material revision of its charter by the county board of education that approved its charter and the county board of education shall consider whether to approve those additional locations at an open, public meeting, held no sooner than 30 days following notification of the school districts where the sites will be located. If approved, the location of the approved sites shall be a material revision of the charter schools approved charter.
(4)A petition shall include a prominent statement indicating that a signature on the petition means that the parent or guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(b)No later than 60 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the county board of education shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the county board of education shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers, parents or guardians, and the school districts where the charter school petitioner proposes to place school facilities. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the county board of education shall either grant or deny the charter within 90 days of receipt of the petition. However, this date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. A petition is deemed received by the county board of education for purposes of commencing the timelines described in this subdivision when the petitioner submits a petition, in accordance with subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), to the county office of education. The county board of education shall publish all staff recommendations, including the recommended findings, regarding the petition at least 15 days before the public hearing at which the county board of education will either grant or deny the charter. At the public hearing at which the county board of education will either grant or deny the charter, petitioners shall have equivalent time and procedures to present evidence and testimony to respond to the staff recommendations and findings. A county board of education may impose any additional requirements beyond those required by this section that it considers necessary for the sound operation of a countywide charter school. A county board of education may grant a charter for the operation of a charter school under this part only if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice and that the charter school has reasonable justification for why it could not be established by petition to a school district pursuant to Section 47605. The county board of education shall deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school if it finds one or more of the following:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (e).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those pupils whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will enroll high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents regarding the transferability of courses to other public high schools. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered to be transferable to other public high schools.
(iv)If the proposed charter school will enroll high school pupils, information as to the manner in which the charter school will inform parents as to whether each individual course offered by the charter school meets college entrance requirements. Courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as satisfying their prerequisites for admission may be considered as meeting college entrance requirements for purposes of this clause.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and aptitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all pupil subgroups served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subdivision (a) of Section 52052. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The location of each charter school facility that the petitioner proposes to operate.
(E)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(F)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(G)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)For all schools, the development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (K), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282. For schools serving pupils in any of grades 7 to 12, inclusive, the development of a school safety plan shall also include the safety topic listed in subparagraph (L) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(H)The means by which the charter school will achieve a balance of racial and ethnic pupils, special education pupils, and English learner pupils, including redesignated fluent English proficient pupils as defined by the evaluation rubrics in Section 52064.5, that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the county board of education to which the charter petition is submitted. Upon renewal, for a charter school not deemed to be a local educational agency for purposes of special education pursuant to Section 47641, the chartering authority may consider the effect of school placements made by the chartering authority in providing a free and appropriate public education as required by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Public Law 101-476), on the balance of pupils with disabilities at the charter school.
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, in accordance with regulations established by the state board, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that is consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian, or, if the pupil is a homeless child or youth, or a foster child or youth, in the native language of the homeless or foster childs educational rights holder. In the case of a foster child or youth, the written notice shall also be provided to the foster childs attorney and county social worker. If the pupil is an Indian child, as defined in Section 224.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the written notice shall also be provided to the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker. The written notice shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent or guardian, the homeless childs educational rights holder, the foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, or county social worker, or the Indian childs tribal social worker or, if applicable, county social worker initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(iv)A foster childs educational rights holder, attorney, and county social worker and an Indian childs tribal social worker and, if applicable, county social worker shall have the same rights a parent or guardian of a child has to receive a suspension notice, expulsion notice, manifestation determination notice, involuntary transfer notice, and other documents and related information.
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter school will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the county board of education to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(M)Admission policy and procedures, consistent with subdivision (e).
(N)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the county who choose not to attend the charter school.
(O)The rights of an employee of the county office of education, upon leaving the employment of the county office of education, to be employed by the charter school, and any rights of return to the county office of education that an employee may have upon leaving the employment of the charter school.
(P)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of public records.
(6)A declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public school employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of the Educational Employment Relations Act (Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(7)Any other basis that the county board of education finds justifies the denial of the petition.
(c)A county board of education that approves a petition for the operation of a countywide charter may, as a condition of charter approval, enter into an agreement with a third party, at the expense of the charter school, to oversee, monitor, and report to the county board of education on the operations of the charter school. The county board of education may prescribe the aspects of the charter schools operations to be monitored by the third party and may prescribe appropriate requirements regarding the reporting of information concerning the operations of the charter school to the county board of education.
(d)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall on a regular basis consult with their parents and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(e)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against any pupil on the basis of ethnicity, national origin, gender, gender identity, gender expression, or disability. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of the pupils parent or guardian, within this state.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the county except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the county board of education shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and in no event shall take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(f)The county board of education shall not require an employee of the county or a school district to be employed in a charter school.
(g)The county board of education shall not require a pupil enrolled in a county program to attend a charter school.
(h)The county board of education shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school, any school district where the charter school may operate, and upon the county board of education. The petitioner or petitioners shall also be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation. If the charter school is to be operated by, or as, a nonprofit public benefit corporation, the petitioner shall provide the names and relevant qualifications of all persons whom the petitioner nominates to serve on the governing body of the charter school.
(i)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the county, the county board of education shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(j)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the school districts within the county, the Superintendent, and the state board.
(k)If a county board of education denies a petition, the petitioner shall not elect to submit the petition for the establishment of the charter school to the state board.
(l)(1)Teachers in charter schools shall be required to hold the Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document required for the teachers certificated assignment. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and shall be subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. A governing body of a direct-funded charter school may use local assignment options authorized in statute and regulations for the purpose of legally assigning certificated teachers, in accordance with all of the requirements of the applicable statutes or regulations in the same manner as a governing board of a school district. A charter school shall have authority to request an emergency permit or a waiver from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing for individuals in the same manner as a school district.
(2)The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall include in the bulletins it issues pursuant to subdivision (k) of Section 44237 to provide notification to local educational agencies of any adverse actions taken against the holders of any commission documents, notice of any adverse actions taken against teachers employed by charter schools. The Commission on Teacher Credentialing shall make this bulletin available to all chartering authorities and charter schools in the same manner in which it is made available to local educational agencies.
(m)(1)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent, financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b), to the county office of education, the Controller, and the department by December 15 of each year. This subdivision paragraph does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(2)By January 31, 2025, and by January 31 each year thereafter, the governing body of a charter school shall review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, including any factors identified pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 47612.8 for a nonclassroom-based charter school, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue. The review shall be placed on the agenda of the meeting pursuant to the Ralph M. Brown Act (Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 54950) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code).
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
(o)The requirements of this section shall not be waived by the state board pursuant to Section 33050 or any other law.
SEC. 4.Section 47612.8 is added to the Education Code, to read:47612.8.(a)An auditor of a nonclassroom-based charter school, when performing an audit described in Section 41020, subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c) of Section 47605, or subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 47605.6, shall do all of the following:
(1)(A)Ensure that all sampling of documents or records necessary for the audit are independently selected by the auditor.
(B)Contact a random sample of parents or guardians of pupils, emancipated pupils, or other custodians of pupils, or in the case of a pupil over 18 years of age, the pupil, enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment.
(C)Select a sample and review credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school pursuant to the process described in Section 14502.1.
(2)Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars ($1,000,000) or 10 percent of the charter schools budget, whichever is less, together with a written explanation from the school regarding the school purpose for each such expenditure.
(3)Identify any other transaction that does not meet the standards identified in Section 14502.1.
(4)Review compliance by the charter school with any policy adopted pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 51820.
(5)Include a letter with the audit report discussing any findings of the auditor relating to factors arising from the auditors activities under this subdivision, or arising from the lack of those factors, together with a response by the charter school if the charter school chooses to make a response.
(b)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Auditor of a nonclassroom-based school means any certified public accountant or public accountant assigned to a nonclassroom-based charter school audit, as described in Section 41020, subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (c) of Section 47605, or subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b) of Section 47605.6.
(2)Nonclassroom-based charter school means a charter school that offers nonclassroom-based instruction pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 47612.5 for more than 20 percent of the instructional time reported by the charter school at the second principal apportionment.
SEC. 5.Section 51747 of the Education Code is amended to read:51747.A local educational agency shall not be eligible to receive apportionments for independent study by pupils, regardless of age, unless it has adopted written policies, and has implemented those policies, pursuant to rules and regulations adopted by the Superintendent, that include, but are not limited to, all of the following:
(a)The maximum length of time, by grade level and type of program, that may elapse between the time an independent study assignment is made and the date by which the pupil must complete the assigned work.
(b)(1)The level of satisfactory educational progress and the number of missed assignments that will be allowed before an evaluation is conducted to determine whether it is in the best interests of the pupil to remain in independent study, or whether the pupil should return to the regular school program. A written record of the findings of any evaluation made pursuant to this subdivision shall be treated as a mandatory interim pupil record. The record shall be maintained for a period of three years from the date of the evaluation and, if the pupil transfers to another California public school, the record shall be forwarded to that school.
(2)Satisfactory educational progress shall be determined based on all of the following indicators:
(A)The pupils achievement and engagement in the independent study program, as indicated by the pupils performance on applicable pupil-level measures of pupil achievement and pupil engagement set forth in paragraphs (4) and (5) of subdivision (d) of Section 52060.
(B)The completion of assignments, assessments, or other indicators that evidence that the pupil is working on assignments.
(C)Learning required concepts, as determined by the supervising teacher.
(D)Progressing toward successful completion of the course of study or individual course, as determined by the supervising teacher.
(c)The provision of content aligned to grade level standards that is substantially equivalent to in-person instruction. For high schools, this shall include access to all courses offered by the local educational agency for graduation and approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the AG admissions criteria.
(d)Procedures for tiered reengagement strategies for all pupils who are not generating attendance for more than 10 percent of required minimum instructional time over four continuous weeks of a local educational agencys approved instructional calendar, pupils found not participatory in synchronous instructional offerings pursuant to Section 51747.5 for more than 50 percent of the scheduled times of synchronous instruction in a school month as applicable by grade span, or pupils who are in violation of the written agreement pursuant to subdivision (g). These procedures shall include local programs intended to address chronic absenteeism, as applicable, with at least all of the following:
(1)Verification of current contact information for each enrolled pupil.
(2)Notification to parents or guardians of lack of participation within one school day of the recording of a nonattendance day or lack of participation.
(3)A plan for outreach from the school to determine pupil needs, including connection with health and social services as necessary.
(4)A clear standard for requiring a pupil-parent-educator conference to review a pupils written agreement, and reconsider the independent study programs impact on the pupils achievement and well-being, consistent with the policies adopted pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (g).
(e)(1)For pupils in transitional kindergarten and grades 1 to 3, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for daily synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.
(2)For pupils in grades 4 to 8, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for both daily live interaction and at least weekly synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.
(3)For pupils in grades 9 to 12, inclusive, a plan to provide opportunities for at least weekly synchronous instruction for all pupils throughout the school year.
(f)A plan to transition pupils whose families wish to return to in-person instruction from independent study expeditiously, and, in no case, later than five instructional days.
(g)A requirement that a current written agreement for each independent study pupil shall be maintained on file, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)The manner, time, frequency, and place for submitting a pupils assignments, for reporting the pupils academic progress, and for communicating with a pupils parent or guardian regarding a pupils academic progress.
(2)The objectives and methods of study for the pupils work, and the methods used to evaluate that work.
(3)The specific resources, including materials and personnel, that will be made available to the pupil. These resources shall include confirming or providing access to all pupils to the connectivity and devices adequate to participate in the educational program and complete assigned work.
(4)A statement of the policies adopted pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) regarding the maximum length of time allowed between the assignment and the completion of a pupils assigned work, the level of satisfactory educational progress, and the number of missed assignments allowed before an evaluation of whether or not the pupil should be allowed to continue in independent study.
(5)The duration of the independent study agreement, including the beginning and ending dates for the pupils participation in independent study under the agreement. No independent study agreement shall be valid for any period longer than one school year.
(6)A statement of the number of course credits or, for the elementary grades, other measures of academic accomplishment appropriate to the agreement, to be earned by the pupil upon completion.
(7)A statement detailing the academic and other supports that will be provided to address the needs of pupils who are not performing at grade level, or need support in other areas, such as English learners, individuals with exceptional needs in order to be consistent with the pupils individualized education program or plan pursuant to Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794), pupils in foster care or experiencing homelessness, and pupils requiring mental health supports.
(8)The inclusion of a statement in each independent study agreement that independent study is an optional educational alternative in which no pupil may be required to participate. In the case of a pupil who is referred or assigned to any school, class, or program pursuant to Section 48915 or 48917, the agreement also shall include the statement that instruction may be provided to the pupil through independent study only if the pupil is offered the alternative of classroom instruction.
(9)(A)For a pupil participating in an independent study program that is scheduled for more than 14 school days, each written agreement shall be signed, before the commencement of independent study, by the pupil, the pupils parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable. Beginning in the 202223 school year, for a pupil participating in an independent study program that is scheduled for less than 15 school days, each written agreement shall be signed within 10 school days of the commencement of the first day of the pupils enrollment in independent study, by the pupil, the pupils parent, legal guardian, or caregiver, if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable. For purposes of this paragraph caregiver means a person who has met the requirements of Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 6550) of Division 11 of the Family Code.
(B)Signed written agreements, supplemental agreements, assignment records, work samples, and attendance records assessing time value of work or evidence that an instructional activity occurred may be maintained as an electronic file.
(C)For purposes of this section, an electronic file includes a computer or electronic stored image of an original document, including, but not limited to, portable document format (PDF), JPEG, or other digital image file type, that may be sent via fax machine, email, or other electronic means.
(D)Either an original document or an electronic file of the original document is allowable documentation for auditing purposes.
(E)Written agreements may be signed using an electronic signature that complies with state and federal standards, as determined by the department, that may be a marking that is either computer generated or produced by electronic means and is intended by the signatory to have the same effect as a handwritten signature. The use of an electronic signature shall have the same force and effect as the use of a manual signature if the requirements for digital signatures and their acceptable technology, as provided in Section 16.5 of the Government Code and in Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 22000) of Division 7 of Title 2 of the California Code of Regulations, are satisfied.
(F)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), for the 202122 school year only, a local educational agency shall obtain a signed written agreement for an independent study program of any length of time from the pupil, or the pupils parent or legal guardian if the pupil is less than 18 years of age, the certificated employee who has been designated as having responsibility for the general supervision of independent study, and the certificated employee designated as having responsibility for the special education programming of the pupil, as applicable, no later than 30 days after the first day of instruction in an independent study program or October 15, whichever date comes later. This subparagraph does not relieve a local educational agency from the obligation to comply with the requirements of this article, as amended by the act adding this subparagraph, upon commencement of instruction for a participating pupil in the 202122 school year.
(h)(1)For the 202122 school year only, school districts and county offices of education shall notify the parents and guardians of all enrolled pupils of their options to enroll their child in in-person instruction or independent study during the 202122 school year. This notice shall include written information on the local educational agencys internet website, including, but not limited to, the right to request a pupil-parent-educator conference meeting before enrollment pursuant to this section, pupil rights regarding procedures for enrolling, disenrolling, and reenrolling in independent study, and the synchronous and asynchronous instructional time that a pupil will have access to as part of independent study. If 15 percent or more of the pupils enrolled in a local educational agency that provides instruction in transitional kindergarten, kindergarten, or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, speak a single primary language other than English, as determined from the census data submitted to the department pursuant to Section 52164 in the preceding year, the written information shall, in addition to being written in English, be written in the primary language.
(2)Before signing a written agreement pursuant to this section, the parent or guardian of a pupil may request that the local educational agency conduct a telephone, videoconference, or in-person pupil-parent-educator conference or other school meeting during which the pupil, parent or guardian, and, if requested by the pupil or parent, an education advocate, may ask questions about the educational options, including which curriculum offerings and nonacademic supports will be available to the pupil in independent study, before making the decision about enrollment or disenrollment in the various options for learning.
(i)Subdivisions (d), (e), and (f) shall not apply to pupils that participate in an independent study program for fewer than 15 schooldays in a school year and pupils enrolled in a comprehensive school for classroom-based instruction who, under the care of appropriately licensed professionals, participate in independent study due to necessary medical treatments or inpatient treatment for mental health care or substance abuse. Local educational agencies shall obtain evidence from appropriately licensed professionals of the need for pupils to participate in independent study pursuant to this subdivision.
(j)(1)Notwithstanding paragraph (8) of subdivision (g) of this section, paragraph (1) of subdivision (e) of Section 46300, and subdivision (d) of Section 51745, for the 202122 school year only, a local educational agency shall be eligible to receive apportionments for independent study for pupils that are subject to quarantine for exposure to, or infection with, COVID-19 pursuant to local or state health guidance, and the pupil cannot participate in classroom-based instruction due to the quarantine, and for school closures due to COVID-19 pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41422. Local educational agencies shall receive apportionment for these pupils for all schooldays that they participate in and meet all other apportionment requirements of independent study while in quarantine or during a school closure.
(2)Notwithstanding Section 47612.5, for the 202122 fiscal year, a classroom-based charter school that provides an independent study program pursuant to this article for pupils that are subject to quarantine for exposure to, or infection with, COVID-19 pursuant to local or state health guidance, and the pupil cannot participate in classroom-based instruction due to the quarantine, shall not attribute quarantine-based independent study average daily attendance required pursuant to law for a nonclassroom-based charter school pursuant to Section 47612.5 and shall not be required to submit a request for a funding determination as a result of providing independent study to quarantined pupils.
(3)This subdivision shall apply only to pupils participating in independent study due to quarantine who do not have the option of in-person instruction, and only for the period of quarantine mandated pursuant to state or local health guidance or order. This subdivision shall not apply to classroom-based charter schools offering independent study to pupils whose parents or guardians have requested independent study pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 51745.
(k)Commencing with the 202122 fiscal year Guide for Annual Audits of K12 Local Education Agencies and State Compliance Reporting, the Controller shall incorporate verification of the adoption of the policies required pursuant to this section, including loss of apportionment for independent study for local educational agencies found to be noncompliant, unless compliance verification for those policies is already included in the audit guide.
(l)Commencing July 1, 2025, the written agreement under this section shall be signed under penalty of perjury.
(l)(m)The provisions of this section are not subject to waiver by the state board, by the Superintendent, or under any provision of Part 26.8 (commencing with Section 47600).
SEC. 6.Article 10.5 (commencing with Section 51820) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 28 of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Education Code, to read:10.5.Educational Enrichment Activities51820.(a)A local educational agency may only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c). A local educational agency may expend public funds for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities, provided that all educational enrichment activities, materials, and programs shall be nonsectarian.
(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, the governing board or body of the local educational agency shall establish policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness that, at a minimum, do all of the following:
(1)Ensure a reasonable market value for the service provided.
(2)Require all vendors to provide proof of valid and appropriate insurance, business licenses, or other certification.
(3)Require all vendor personnel interacting with pupils, unsupervised by a parent or school employee, to have a valid criminal records summary as described in Section 45125.1, and require that if the vendor performs the criminal background check, it shall immediately provide subsequent arrest and conviction information it receives to the local educational agency pursuant to the subsequent arrest service.
(4)Require all vendors to have policies and procedures related to pupil and site safety, including in virtual settings, emergency response, and accident reporting that are reasonable for the instruction or activity.
(5)Require all vendors to provide evidence of qualification and expertise for the activities or instruction to be provided.
(6)Prohibit the local educational agency from paying any vendor for educational enrichment activities before approval.
(c)Any vendor contract that will exceed one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) in a fiscal year shall be approved by the governing board or body of the local educational agency in an open public meeting.
(d)Auditing of the approval of, and compliance with, policies enacted in accordance with subdivisions (b) and (c) shall be included in the audit guide, Standards and Procedures for Audits of California K12 Local Educational Agencies, described in Section 14502.1.
(e)Any educational enrichment activity provided by a school shall be approved and verified by the pupils assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate for the pupil.
(f)Notwithstanding any other law, a vendor providing services pursuant to this article shall provide the initial criminal background check report before commencing services and immediately provide any subsequent arrest and conviction information to the local educational agency upon receipt.
(g)For purposes of this section, local educational agency means a county office of education, school district, or charter school.
(h)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2025.
SEC. 7.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district because, in that regard, this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to charter schools.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to charter schools.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 26, 2024 | June 26 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 24, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 24, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 4212.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2024 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3985.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2024 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on PUB S. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3752.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Apr 15, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Apr 11, 2024 | April 17 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | Re-referred to Coms. on ED. and PUB S. |
| Mar 20, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 24, 2024 | Special Consent SB1477 Ashby | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Public Safety] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Allegiance Steam Academy Thrive | ** Support | |
| Asa Charter School | ** Support | |
| Excelsior Charter Schools | ** Support | |
| Fenton Charter Public Schools | ** Support | |
| JCS Family Charter Schools | ** Support | |
| Julia Lee Performing Arts Academy | ** Support | |
| LA Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy | ** Support | |
| Liberty Charter High School | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Leadership Academy | ** Support | |
| Public Safety Academy Of San Bernardino | ** Support | |
| Real Journey Academies | ** Support | |
| Santa Rosa Academy | ** Support | |
| Soar Charter Academy | ** Support | |
| Springs Charter Schools | ** Support | |
| Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts | ** Support | |
| Temecula International Academy | ** Support | |
| Visions in Education | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: June 26, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Al Muratsuchi, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1477
Author:(Ashby) – As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: School accountability: independent study, educational enrichment activities, oversight, and audit requirements
SUMMARY: Requires the governing board of a charter school to review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year; requires auditors of nonclassroom-based (NCB) charter schools to perform specified activities; and requires all local educational agencies (LEAs) to only enter into an agreement for educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to specified criteria. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, beginning on January 31, 2025, the governing body of a charter school to annually review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issues.
- Requires an auditor of a NCB charter school, when performing an independent financial audit, to do the following:
- Ensure that all documents necessary for the audit are independently selected by the auditor;
- Contact a random sample, to be selected by the auditor, of parents or guardians of pupils enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment;
- As part of the random sample of documents selected and reviewed, sample credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school are subject to an enhanced materiality standard, as specified;
- Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars or 10% of the charter school’s budget, with a written explanation from the school regarding the purpose of the expenditures;
- Identify any other transactions out of compliance with the audit guide;
- Review compliance by the charter school with any policy adopted regarding educational enrichment activities; and
- Include a letter with the audit report discussing any concerns or findings, along with a response by the school, if the school elects.
- Defines a “nonclassroom-based charter school” as a charter school that offers NCB instruction for more than 20% of the instructional time offered.
- Requires all LEAs to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of nonsectarian educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to prescribed criteria, beginning July 1, 2025.
- Requires the governing board of any LEA, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, evidence of instructor qualification, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and requires the LEA to certify that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Charter Schools Act of 1992, which authorizes a school district governing board or county board of education to approve or deny a petition for a charter school to operate independently from the existing school district structure as a method of accomplishing, among other things, improved pupil learning, increased learning opportunities for all pupils, with special emphasis on expanded learning experiences for pupils who are identified as academically low achieving, holding charter schools accountable for meeting measurable pupil outcomes, and providing the schools with a method to change from rule-based to performance-based accountability systems. (Education Code (EC) 47605)
- Establishes a process for the submission of a petition for the establishment of a charter school. Authorizes a petition identifying a single charter school to operate within the geographical boundaries of the school district to be submitted to the school district. Authorizes, if the governing board of a school district denies a petition for the establishment of a charter school, the petitioner to elect to submit the petition to the county board of education. Authorizes, if the county board of education denies the charter, the petitioner to submit the petition to the State Board of Education (SBE) only if the petitioner demonstrates that the school district governing board or county board of education abused its discretion in denying the charter school. Authorizes a school that serves a countywide purpose to submit the charter petition directly to the county office of education (COE).
- Requires, upon renewal, a charter school to be identified as either low performing, middle performing or high performing based on CA School Dashboard accountability data. Requires that low performing charter schools be denied, however, the school may be renewed for a two year period if the authorizer is presented with verified data that meets specified criteria and the authorizer finds it compelling. Authorizes middle performing charter schools to be renewed for 5 years. Authorizes high performing charter schools to be renewed for 5-7 years.
- Prohibits the authorization and establishment of new NCB charter schools between January 1, 2020, and January 1, 2026.
- Prohibits a charter school from receiving any public funds for a pupil if the pupil also attends a private school that charges the pupil's family for tuition. Prohibits a charter from being granted that authorizes the conversion of any private school to a charter school. (EC 47602)
- Prohibits, notwithstanding any other law, a LEA, including, but not limited to, a charter school, from claiming state funding for the independent study of a pupil, whether characterized as home study or otherwise, if the LEA has provided any funds or other thing of value to the pupil or his or her parent or guardian that the LEA does not provide to pupils who attend regular classes or to their parents or guardians. (EC 51747.3)
- Authorizes a charter school to receive funding for NCB instruction only if a determination for funding is made by the SBE. Requires the determination for funding to be subject to any conditions or limitations the SBE may prescribe. Requires the SBE to adopt regulations that define and establish general rules governing NCB instruction that apply to all charter schools and to the process for determining funding of NCB instruction by charter schools offering NCB instruction. Defines NCB instruction to include, but not be limited to, independent study, home study, work study, and distance and computer-based education. (EC 47612.5)
- Requires the SBE to adopt regulations setting forth criteria for the determination of funding for NCB instruction, at a minimum the regulation to specify that the NCB instruction is conducted for the instructional benefit of the pupil and is substantially dedicated to that function. Requires the SBE to consider, among other factors it deems appropriate, the amount of the charter school’s total budget expended on certificated employee salaries and benefits and on schoolsites, and the teacher-to-pupil ratio in the school. Requires, for the 2003–04 fiscal year and each fiscal year thereafter, the amount of funding determined by the SBE to not be more than 70% of the unadjusted amount to which a charter school would otherwise be entitled unless the SBE determines that a greater or lesser amount is appropriate. (EC 47634.2)
- Requires a charter school to transmit a copy of its annual independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year to its chartering entity, the State Controller’s Office (SCO), the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, (unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering entity) and the CDE, by December 15 of each year. (EC 47605)
- Requires a charter school that operates a multitrack year round calendar to comply with all of the following:
- Calculate attendance separately for each track. The divisor in the calculation must be the calendar days in which school was taught for pupils in each track;
- Operate no more than five tracks;
- Operate each track for a minimum of 175 days. If the charter school is a conversion school, the charter school may continue its previous schedule as long as it provides no fewer than 163 days of instruction in each track;
- For each track, provide the total number of instructional minutes, as specified in Section 47612.5; and
- No track may have less than 55% of its schooldays before April 15. (EC 47612)
- Authorizes a school district to operate a program of multitrack year-round scheduling at one or more schools within the district. Authorizes a program of multitrack year-round scheduling to operate at a schoolsite for as few as 163 days in each fiscal year if the governing board of the school district adopts a resolution at a regularly scheduled board meeting certifying that both of the following criteria are met at the schoolsite:
- The number of annual instructional minutes is not less than that of schools of the same grade levels utilizing the traditional school calendar; and
- It is not possible for the school to maintain a multitrack schedule containing the same number of instructional days as are provided in schools of the district utilizing the traditional school calendar, given the facilities, program, class sizes, and projected number of pupils enrolled at the schoolsite. (EC 37670)
- Requires financial and compliance audits to be performed in accordance with General Accounting Office standards for financial and compliance audits. Requires that the audit guide prepared by the SCO be used in the performance of these audits until an audit guide is adopted by the Education Audits Appeal Panel. When an audit guide is adopted by that panel, the adopted audit guide be used in the performance of these audits, and every audit report specifically and separately address each of the state program compliance requirements included in the audit guide, stating whether or not the district is in compliance with those requirements. (EC 14503)
- Authorizes the independent study (IS) program for school districts, COEs, and charter schools. Requires LEAs that offer IS to adopt written policies that include the length of time that may elapse between the time an independent study assignment is made and the date the pupil must complete the assigned work, missed work assignments, and there be a written agreement between the pupil and the IS program. Requires that the written agreement include processes for submitting pupil work, objectives and methods of study for the pupil’s work, resources that will be made available to the pupil, duration of the agreement, and number of credits to be earned upon completion. A pupil with an Individualized Education Program (IEP) is not authorized to participate in an IS program unless their IEP specifically provides for that participation. Requires that the IS of each pupil be coordinated, and evaluated under the general supervision of an employee of the LEA who possesses a valid certification document or an emergency credential. Establishes certificated employee-to-pupil ratios as specified. (EC 51745–51749.3)
- Requires each chartering authority to do all of the following with respect to each charter school under its authority:
- Identify at least one staff member as a contact person for the charter school;
- Visit each charter school at least annually;
- Ensure that each charter school under its authority complies with all reports required of charter schools by law, including the local control and accountability plan (LCAP) and annual update to the LCAP required, pursuant to Section 47606.5;
- Monitor the fiscal condition of each charter school under its authority; and
- Provide timely notification to the CDE if any of the following circumstances occur or will occur with regard to a charter school for which it is the chartering authority:
- A renewal of the charter is granted or denied;
- The charter is revoked; or
- The charter school will cease operation for any reason. (EC 47604.32)
- Authorizes a chartering authority to charge for the actual costs of supervisorial oversight of a charter school, not to exceed 1% of the revenue of the charter school. Authorizes a chartering authority to charge for the actual costs of supervisorial oversight of a charter school, not to exceed 3% of the revenue of the charter school, if the charter school is able to obtain substantially rent free facilities from the chartering authority. Authorizes an LEA that is given the responsibility for supervisorial oversight of a charter school by the SBE to charge for the actual costs of supervisorial oversight and administrative costs necessary to secure charter school funding. (EC 47613)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill would likely result in increased local costs for NCB charter schools to comply with the expanded audit requirements. This increase could be in the thousands of dollars for each audit and would be charged by auditors as part of the charter’s annual audit. Any administrative costs to the California Department of Education (CDE) are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill. According to the author, “A recent joint report by the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) and the Fiscal Crisis Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) identified concerns with the independent audits and other issues relating to charter school oversight. Many of these concerns center on the actions of bad actors. SB 1477 would implement a number of recommendations by strengthening auditing, contracting, and enrollment policies for charter schools to prevent fraud, improve charter school governance and transparency, and hold bad actors accountable.”
Concerns with this bill. There are several concerns with the requirements established by this bill, and many concerns with the lack of alignment between this bill and the recommendations made by the LAO and FCMAT in their 2024 report on NCB charters.
- This bill requires all vendors providing educational enrichment activities to provide evidence of their qualification for the instruction they are providing. Under existing law, all teachers providing instruction to public school students in California are required to hold a credential from the Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CTC). The bill does not specify what kind of evidence is necessary to demonstrate their qualifications, or whether that includes a teaching credential. This bill sets up a lower secondary standard for people providing instruction to pupils deemed educational enrichment activities. The Committee may wish to consider whether it’s appropriate to establish a lower standard for teacher qualifications in these programs.
- This bill establishes procedures for educational enrichment vendors. Many concerns have been raised about NCB charters giving parents up to $3,000 to spend on vendors for Disneyland tickets, horseback riding lessons, tie-dying, religious theater camps, etc. This bill prohibits religious vendors but does not prohibit any of the other types of vendors. The Committee may wish to consider whether establishing a process to validate these vendors, also legitimizes the practice as a whole.
- This bill establishes a fingerprinting requirement for vendor personnel who provide educational enrichment activities that is similar, but not identical to, the existing fingerprint requirement in Section 45125.1. Because the fingerprinting requirement in this bill is not identical or as detailed as that in existing law, it could cause confusion in the field. The Committee may wish to consider whether this language would adequately protect students.
- This bill requires all educational enrichment activities to be approved and verified by the pupil’s assigned teacher as relevant to specific educational assignments and educationally appropriate. Existing law requires teachers in independent study programs at districts, COEs, and charters to assign all coursework and grade all coursework. This bill makes this a requirement on teachers in classroom-based instruction as well as independent study. It appears that only NCB charter schools provide parents with money to spend on educational enrichment activities, therefore requiring this of all classroom-based instruction programs is confusing. The Committee may wish to consider whether such a requirement should only apply to independent study programs, and more specifically, NCB charter schools.
- This bill creates a new definition of NCB charters to include schools that provide more than 20% of their instruction through NCB instruction. Existing law specifies that NCB instruction occurs when less than 80% of instruction is in person. While these definitions are similar, it is unclear why it is necessary to create a new definition that is different from existing law. The Committee may wish to consider what unintended consequences this change could have and whether this may be confusing to the field.
LAO and FCMAT Report. The 2024 report from the LAO and FCMAT, as required by the Budget Act, makes the following recommendations regarding NCB charter schools:
- Increase Minimum Requirements for Authorizers. We recommend the Legislature require authorizers to conduct certain activities to review and monitor their charter schools. For example, the Legislature could require authorizers to conduct regular reviews throughout the school year of expenditures, enrollment, and attendance data. It could also require that the authorizer investigate and notify its COE of any significant changes in enrollment or attendance, or discrepancies between enrollment and attendance. We also recommend authorizers be required to attend regular trainings on these topics. Authorizers could confirm their compliance using regular reports they file as part of the typical budget adoption and interim reporting. If authorizers do not comply with the requirements, the state could require that authorization be shifted to the COE (or, if the COE is the current authorizer, a neighboring COE).
This bill does not increase the oversight requirements for charter school authorizers consistent with this recommendation.
- Set Limits on District Authorizers Based on District Size and Grade. We recommend setting a cap on the nonclassroom-based charter school attendance that a school district can authorize by using the ratio of total nonclassroom-based charter school attendance to the authorizing district’s attendance. For example, the Legislature could specify that the total nonclassroom-based charter school attendance of a district authorizer cannot exceed the school district’s attendance. (The Legislature could choose to set a different threshold. The Legislature may also need to make exceptions for rural counties that have few if any, large school districts.) In cases where a school district exceeds its cap, authorization and oversight could be transferred to the COE or a neighboring COE.
This bill does not limit small school districts from authorizing NCB charter schools consistent with this recommendation.
- Allow Higher Spending for Authorizing. We recommend allowing authorizers to charge actual costs up to 3 percent for authorizing and oversight activities, as long as they are meeting new requirements. Failure to adequately oversee a charter school, however, should result in the authorizer remitting the oversight fee collected to the COE or state.
This bill does not propose to increase the percentage charged for charter school oversight and authorization consistent with this recommendation.
- Consider Alternative Authorizing Structure for Virtual Schools. Given recent issues that have arisen with virtual charter schools, the Legislature could consider establishing a specific authorizing structure for these programs. For example, the Legislature could establish a separate authorizing agency for all virtual charter schools. Assigning oversight responsibilities to one agency would improve the expertise and quality of oversight provided to virtual charter schools and virtual charter school networks. This approach, however, is at odds with recent state changes to eliminate statewide benefit charter schools. Another option would be to continue to have school districts authorize these schools, but require that they conduct their oversight with a newly established agency that has expertise related to virtual programs.
This bill does not propose an alternative authorizing structure for virtual charter schools consistent with this recommendation.
- Enhance the Audit Process for Charter Schools. We recommend the Legislature make several changes to improve the audit process for charter schools. These changes would reduce the likelihood that issues of fraud or misappropriation of funds would occur and would bring issues to the attention of other agencies more quickly.
- Ensure Conformity of Audit Process to That of School Districts. Explicitly require all charter schools to be subject to the same audit process as school districts. This should include the timing of auditor selection, disclosure of an auditor’s termination or replacement, the granting of extensions for charter school audits, and other matters of parity to school districts.
This bill does not propose ensuring conformity between charter school and school district audit processes consistent with this recommendation.
- Ensure the Audit Guide Addresses Compliance Sampling. Direct that the audit guide be specific as to sampling techniques and that the selection of samples be performed personally by the auditor.
This bill implements this recommendation.
- Develop Materiality Levels for Charter Schools. Explicitly require that the audit guide include average daily attendance (ADA) materiality levels for compliance testing at charter schools.
This bill does not propose materiality levels for charter schools in the audit guide consistent with this recommendation.
- Require Supplemental Schedules of Enrollment and ADA by Track. Direct that the audit guide require supplemental information and schedules be included in an audit of a charter school, such as a schedule of student enrollment and attendance that includes student enrollment and attendance by month and track (if applicable). This should include reconciliation of enrollment/attendance changes from the beginning of the year to the end of the year, including details on additions, subtractions, and transfers. In addition, this information should be separated by category of attendance (classroom-based, nonclassroom-based, summer schedule, enrichment, and others).
This bill does not propose supplemental schedules of enrollment and ADA in the audit guide consistent with this recommendation.
- Require Disclosure of Changes Related to Enrollment and ADA. Direct that the audit guide require auditors to specifically disclose in the audit of a charter school, and separately to CDE, any instance where either or both enrollment and attendance increase or decrease by more than 5 percent during any month as compared to the prior month.
This bill does not propose disclosure of changes related to enrollment and ADA in the audit guide consistent with this recommendation.
- Improve the Quality of Audits Through Specific Auditor Training. To improve auditors’ knowledge of issues related to K-12 education, we recommend the Legislature require certified public accountants or public accountants licensed in California to complete additional training to remain on the State Controller’s directory of qualified auditors. The Legislature could consider requiring an additional 24 hours of training every two years in topics specific to financial reporting and compliance testing related to schools, charter schools, and nonclassroom-based charter schools.
This bill does not propose training for K-12 school auditors consistent with this recommendation.
- Require Charter School Audits to Publicly Disclose Similar Information Collected on Funding Determination Form. Including this information in the audit would provide greater awareness to authorizers and the public. Specifically, we recommend requiring charter school audits to include the following supplemental information:
- A schedule of payments or transfers of (1) the largest 25 payments or transfers of assets to organizations, determined by value accumulated over the fiscal year, including to individuals, corporations, partnerships, nonprofit organizations, and other organizations, but excluding governmental entities; and (2) all payments and transfers of assets of $50,000 or more to organizations, determined by value accumulated over the fiscal year, including to individuals, corporations, partnerships, nonprofit organizations, and other organizations, but excluding governmental entities.
- For nonclassroom-based charter schools, include a schedule denoting the computation of the 40 percent threshold for certificated staff, 80 percent threshold for instruction and related services, and student-to-teacher ratio as required in the funding determination. (These components would need to be modified if the Legislature enacted changes to the funding determination process.)
- Composition of the charter school’s governing board.
This bill implements a requirement for NCB charter school auditors to look at payment transfers greater than $1 million, or 10% of the charter school budget.
This bill does not propose requiring charter schools to disclose the largest 25 payments or transfers and all payments or transfers over $50,000 or the school’s funding determination calculations consistent with this recommendation.
- Require Disclosure of Related Organizations. We recommend the audit guide include a procedure to determine if the charter school has a relationship with a related entity, such as an entity managing a charter school or a similar third party with financial, economic, or controlling membership interests. If such a relationship exists, the auditor should evaluate the level of the relationship to determine if it is material. For material relationships, the audit guide should ensure compliance of the related party disclosure rules of the Financial Accounting Standards Board Accounting Standards Codification and other generally accepted accounting principles. The audit guide should also ensure the charter school complies with constraints regarding when financial statement consolidation is required, permitted, and prohibited.”
This bill does not propose disclosure of related organizations consistent with this recommendation.
Background on charter schools. According to the CDE, as of May 2024, there are 1,283 charter schools in California, with an enrollment of over 700,000 pupils. Some charter schools are new, while others are conversions from existing public schools. Charter schools are part of the state's public education system and are funded by public dollars. A charter school is usually created or organized by a group of teachers, parents, community leaders, a community-based organization, or an education management organization. Charter schools are authorized by school district boards and county boards of education. A charter school is generally exempt from most laws governing school districts, except where specifically noted in the law. Specific goals and operating procedures for the charter school are detailed in an agreement (or "charter") between the authorizing board and charter organizers.
What is nonclassroom-based instruction? NCB instruction includes computer-based instruction using software modules, teacher-directed independent study, and traditional home school parents who enroll their children in independent study charter school programs.
A NCB charter school is defined as a school that provides less than 80% of its total ADA in a classroom setting. As of April 2021, there were 304 charter schools considered to be NCB. Of that number, 105 charter schools self-identified as providing exclusively virtual or primarily virtual instruction.
Existing law defines charter school NCB instruction as instruction that does not meet the requirements of classroom-based instruction. Those requirements are:
- Charter school pupils are engaged in required educational activities and are under the immediate supervision and control of a certificated teacher;
- At least 80% of the instructional time offered by the charter school is at the schoolsite (defined as a facility that is used primarily for classroom instruction); and
- Pupil attendance at the schoolsite is required for at least 80% of the minimum instructional time.
Pupil academic achievement at NCB charter schools and virtual schools is alarming. Research indicates that students at NCB charters and virtual schools achieve lower rates of academic achievement compared to students at classroom-based schools. One report notes, “By any measure, online charter schools perform significantly worse than traditional public schools, and this negative impact carries across every demographic of pupils. So while online schools are indeed needed for pupils whose requirements cannot be met by brick-and-mortar schools, it’s clear that the quality of education offered by online charter schools is significantly below the state average. As public policy, legislators should be looking to limit the number of students in online charter schools and should resist calls to expand this sector.” (Lafer, 2021)
A 2015 national analysis of NCB charter schools found, “The differences were much larger between classroom-based and nonclassroom-based charter schools, with the nonclassroom-based charter schools having lower achievement. This result is consistent with a study of Ohio charter schools that found virtual schools performing poorly relative to traditional public schools (TPSs) and other charter schools (Zimmer, et al., 2009). It is consistent with findings for Pennsylvania, which has among the highest proportion of online charter pupils. The CREDO (2011) report on Pennsylvania charter schools found that all eight cyber schools then operating performed significantly and substantially worse on both mathematics and reading than TPSs.” (Epple, et al., 2015)
The following chart shows the California statewide average student achievement at traditional classroom-based schools versus the average pupil performance at online charter schools. This data excludes all schools that mainly serve pupils who are credit deficient (known as DASS alternative schools) however, when DASS schools are included, the difference in pupil performance between classroom-based schools and online charter schools is even more significant.
(Source: In the Public Interest (Lafer, 2021))
Numerous studies indicate online instruction is not as effective as regular classroom instruction:
- A 2011 study of charter school performance in Pennsylvania by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) at Stanford University found that each of that state's 8 online charter schools ("cyber schools") significantly underperformed brick and mortar schools and regular (non-virtual) charter schools in reading and math.
- A CREDO study in 2015 concluded that the learning deficit of virtual schools is equivalent to receiving 180 fewer days of math instruction and 72 fewer days of reading instruction. The study's author said that the learning in math was so small that it was "literally as though the student did not go to school for the entire year."
- A year review of virtual schools in Wisconsin by the Gannett Wisconsin Media Investigative Team found that pupils receiving online instruction "often struggle to complete their degrees and repeat grades four times as often as their brick-and-mortar counterparts," and they "trail traditional students in every subject but reading."
- A 2011 report from the Office of the Legislative Auditor in Minnesota reported that full-time online pupils were more likely to completely drop out of school and made less progress on state standardized math tests than pupils in traditional schools.
- A 2011 report from the Ohio Department of Education rated only three of Ohio's 27 virtual schools as "effective" or "excellent."
- A 2006 performance audit by the Colorado Department of Education of that state's virtual schools found that "in the aggregate, online students performed poorly on the CSAP (Colorado State Assessment Program) exams and had higher repeater, attrition, and dropout rates."
A report by In the Public Interest (Virtual Public Education in California, 2015) focused specifically on California Virtual Academy (CAVA) schools, and concluded that "students at CAVA are at risk of low quality educational outcomes, and some are falling through the cracks entirely, in a poorly resourced and troubled educational environment." Among the concerns identified by the report are the following:
- In every year since it began graduating pupils, except in 2013, CAVA has had more dropouts than graduates.
- Pupils are eligible to be counted as having attended with as little as one minute of log-in time each day.
- K12 California (the California subsidiary of K-12, Inc.) pays itself for services out of the CAVA school bank accounts that it (K12 California) manages.
- Competitive bidding is prohibited: K12 California contractually prohibits CAVA schools from seeking another vendor for services that K12 California is willing and able to perform.
- CAVA teachers report that the "vast majority" of the work they do is clerical, preventing them from spending sufficient time teaching.
- Limited local control: individual CAVA location governing boards operate under contract to K12 California and do not "have much leeway in terms of budget, program and contracting decisions independent from K12 California."
- K12, Inc. charges CAVA schools more than they can reasonably pay for administrative and technology services. The shortfall is covered by "budget credits" that are extended by K12, Inc., which results in a "perpetual debt" relationship between CAVA schools and K12, Inc.
- CAVA pupils have lower academic achievement, higher dropout rates, and higher turnover than pupils enrolled in brick-and-mortar schools.
Virtual schools have consistently been shown to underperform brick-and-mortar schools by wide margins. At the same time, California has invested heavily in policies to improve pupil outcomes, including the adoption of rigorous academic content standards, assessments aligned to those standards, and the use of the California School Dashboard to monitor school and district performance and identify districts for targeted assistance.
A3 Charter Schools fraud case reveals significant weaknesses in NCB charter school law. In People v. McManus, the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office indicted 11 defendants in a fraud scheme involving nineteen charter schools (A3 Charter Schools). The case revealed many weaknesses in state public charter school law in the areas of pupil data tracking, auditing, school finance, and oversight, which resulted in A3 schools repaying more than $210 million, 13 houses, and numerous shares in third-party companies.
- Lack of pupil data tracking. Currently, charter schools submit aggregate attendance data for each school without any information about individual pupils. Oversight agencies do not maintain individual pupil data about enrollments in charter schools they oversee for state funding purposes. One A3 charter school was found to be paying a private company to recruit and collect personal information from student athletes. The school then enrolled the athletes in the charter school without their knowledge—thereby fraudulently generating ADA—and paid the recruiting company a portion of the public funds generated as a finder’s fee.
- Multi-track calendar abuses. The A3 schools were found to have deceived the state into paying them significantly more funds by manipulating the “multi-track year-round calendar,” which charter schools are currently authorized to use. The A3 schools would (1) run a fake summer school to collect funding for pupils that never knowingly enrolled, (2) inflate their fraudulent summer school attendance numbers—to the tune of about 60%—by offering fewer days of fake summer school instruction, and (3) transfer pupils between different A3 schools, increasing attendance fraudulently by another roughly 40%.
- Lack of meaningful audit requirements. The annual audits required by law found little to no malpractice by A3 schools. First, auditors are not required to complete any specialized up-front or ongoing training in school finance or law to audit a charter school. Second, charter schools can choose their auditors—A3 schools were shown to have fired their auditing firms and hired less experienced firms in the rare event that audit findings were made. Third, NCB charter schools are allowed to pick their own samples of pupil documentation showing compliance with independent study laws—enabling A3 to hide the fraudulent aspects of their operation from auditors. Fourth, auditors are not required to audit the education program received by pupils, only compliance with documentation. In the A3 schools, many children were enrolled from sports teams believing they were participating in a fundraiser and had no knowledge they were enrolled in a charter school at all.
- Flawed funding determination process. While existing law requires that NCB charter schools only receive full funding in exceptional circumstances—when at least 80% of funding is spent directly serving pupils—the current funding determination process essentially funds all schools at 100%. This is because existing regulations define “instructional and related services” very broadly, and charter schools can meet these spending benchmarks without necessarily spending money on pupils. Further, NCB charter schools are only required to request a funding determination and provide compliance documentation to the SBE, every five years.
- Perverse financial incentives for charter school authorizers. Existing law allows charter authorizers to collect oversight fees from charter schools under their authority but does not require authorizers to demonstrate that the fees are spent on meaningful school oversight. Small school districts that approve NCB charter schools serving pupils not located in the district can earn significant oversight fees—creating a built-in incentive to overlook poor charter school practices. For example, Dehesa Elementary School District approved over ten charter schools all providing NCB programs. The district’s oversight fees for the 2017-2018 school year, were more than its entire expenditures for all employees hired by the district. When the district learned of improprieties in their charter schools, it took no meaningful action. Ultimately, the district collected the oversight fees and only acted to revoke the A3 Charter Schools under its authority once law enforcement was involved.
The chart below illustrates a sampling of current small school districts that have authorized large numbers of NCB charter schools.
School District Name | School District ADA | Authorized Charter School ADA |
New Jerusalem Elementary | 22 | 4,500 |
Oro Grande | 109 | 3,738 |
Dehesa Elementary | 145 | 8,532 |
Maricopa Unified | 300 | 6,067 |
Julian Union Elementary | 311 | 3,502 |
Campbell Union | 876 | 6,417 |
Acton-Agua Dulce Unified | 1,080 | 13,775 |
(Source: California School Board Association)
Some homeschool charter schools give education dollars to parents. The term homeschool has traditionally been used to describe private homeschool instruction. Some homeschool parents choose to enroll their children in NCB charter schools. When a pupil enrolls in any public charter school, that pupil becomes a public school pupil and is no longer a private school homeschool pupil. Some NCB charter schools cater to these families and offer to share state funding with parents or allow parents to direct how their children’s homeschool funds are spent.
The Horizon Charter Schools website advertises that they offer “More Student Funds for Educational Needs” and states, “Since we’re a public charter school, there are never any tuition fees and most classes, study trips and educational materials can be paid for with your state-provided student funds. To help families get even more from their homeschooling experience, this year we raised the amount of funds you have to spend -- $2,600 per K-8th grade student and $2,800 for high school students. That’s $1,000 more per student than in previous years and more than most other area charter schools provide. In addition, funds can be shared between family members, providing even greater flexibility and choices for parents.”
Feather River Charter School, which is part of the Inspire Public Schools, provides the following description of the instructional funds available to pupils on their website:
Enrollment Date | Total Fund Amount | Funds upon Enrollment | Funds available December 1, 2019 | |
TK-8th grade | July 1-October 9, 2019 | $2,600 | $1,500 | $1,100 |
High School | July 1-October 9, 2019 | $2,800 | $1,700 | $1,100 |
Inspire describes the appropriate use of these funds to include, but not be limited to, the following:
Product
| Service
|
Examples of inappropriate use of public school funds through vendor contracts. A 2019 investigation by the San Diego Union Tribune found:
- Trips to Disneyland and SeaWorld. “In California, there’s a way parents can use money from the government to buy multi-day Disneyland Park Hopper passes, San Diego Zoo family memberships, tickets to Medieval Times, and dolphin encounters at SeaWorld. There are a handful of charter schools that give pupils’ families as much as $2,800 to $3,200 — tax dollars sent to the charter schools — every year to spend on anything they want from a list of thousands of home-school vendors approved by the charters, according to the schools’ websites. AdvertisementIf you live in California and you’re not taking advantage of this, I don’t know what to say, said Karen Akpan, a home school charter parent of four who lives in Beaumont. She wrote a recent blog article describing how she used the educational funds to pay for a family trip to Disneyland, Chicago CityPASSes, and Legoland tickets, as well as computer coding kits, educational toys, books, and subscription cooking kits for her kids.”
- California is the only state paying for these types of services. “I don’t know of any states where they’re paying for the kinds of things they’re paying for in California,’ said Mike Smith, president of the Home School Legal Defense Association, a national group that advocates for home-schooling families. ‘Those schools don’t have as many fixed costs as a school that would have a large campus, paying for heat and custodians and all of that. But yet, they get the same amount of money per student from the state,’ said Stephanie Hood, a charter school adviser with the Homeschool Association of California. It is relatively easy for home-school charters to recruit pupils, because enrollment happens online and families can request vendors near where they live. Valiant advertised enrollment to families in 34 counties on its website, even though its schools were authorized to operate in only three counties. ‘As you know, that’s why some of the problems have occurred, because there’s so much money in it,’ Smith said. ‘It’s very easy to do. ... It’s just ripe for the kind of things that are going on.”
- Public education dollars spent at private schools. Some charter school vendors are businesses or nonprofits that cater to homeschoolers and operate like private schools in that they charge tuition and employ their own teachers, who often are not credentialed by the state. Some vendors provide a wide variety of classes, ranging from electives such as sewing and cooking, to core classes such as traditional English, math and science. Many of these vendors do not call themselves schools, but rather enrichment centers, learning centers, home school co-ops, or tutoring academies. Some larger vendors, such as Homeschool Campus and Discovery of Learning, have several campuses, often at churches. Enrolling in a home school charter can allow the pupil to use the charter school’s funds to pay the tuition for these schools if their assigned charter schoolteacher approves it.
- Public education dollars spent at religious schools. AdvertisementThere also are religiously affiliated vendors, like the Christian-owned Eden Learning Academy, which until recently said on its website that it is based on a Christian Worldview, or the Christian Youth Theater, which says on its website that part of its objective is to share the love of Christ in word and deed.
Independent Study. According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO):
“Independent Study Independent study programs provide students an alternative to traditional classroom-based instruction. Rather than generating funding solely based on attendance, independent study programs also generate funding based on the work completed by students. Independent study programs range from fully online virtual academies to hybrid programs that combine on-site and off-site instruction. State law allows local education agencies (LEAs)—school districts, charter schools, and county offices of education (COEs)—to decide whether to provide these programs.
Basic Requirements of Independent Study Programs. Below are some of the basic requirements for all independent study programs.
• Certificated Teachers. Students must work under the general supervision of certificated teachers. State law also specifies that only certificated teachers may evaluate the seat-time equivalent of an independent study student’s work for the purposes of generating ADA.
• Individual Written Agreement. LEAs must maintain a written agreement with each student (and parent or guardian) that specifies the dates of participation, methods of study and evaluation, and other resources to be made available to the student.
• Synchronous Instruction. LEAs must offer synchronous instruction—instruction that involves real-time interaction between students and teachers—to independent study students throughout the school year, with frequency varying by grade level. These requirements range from daily instruction for transitional kindergarten through grade three to weekly instruction for high school students.
• Student Reengagement Strategies. LEAs must establish procedures for reengaging with independent study students who do not meet certain requirements, such as students who have completed less than 60 percent of their assigned work in one week, participated in less than 60 percent of scheduled synchronous instruction in one month, or violated their independent study agreement. These procedures are to include several elements, such as notification to parents or guardians regarding lack of participation and a standard for when a student’s enrollment in independent study should be reevaluated.
• Student-to-Teacher Ratios. Current law limits the average number of students each independent study teacher may supervise, unless an alternative ratio is collectively bargained. These limits vary by LEA. For school districts, the student-to-teacher ratio for independent study programs may not exceed the overall student-to-teacher ratio in the district. For charter schools, the ratio cannot exceed 25 to 1. The limit for COEs is based on the overall student-to-teacher ratio in the high school or unified school district with the largest ADA in the county.
• Educational Standards. State law prohibits independent study from using an “alternative curriculum.” This restriction implies that independent study students must be held to the same standards as other district students. Current law, however, does not clarify what an alternative curriculum means or provide a means of enforcing the prohibition.
Charter Schools and School Districts Have Different Flexibilities. Unlike school districts, charter schools do not have a daily minimum instructional minute requirement for school days. (The daily minimum instructional minute requirement for school districts varies by grade span, from 180 minutes for kindergarten to 240 minutes for grades 9-12.) Therefore, to claim attendance for funding purposes, charter schools only need to show that a student completed some work during each school day. (However, charter schools must follow the same minimum number of instructional minutes for the school year as school districts.) School districts must show that the work completed by a student satisfies the minimum amount of instruction for the day. However, school districts may have agreements in place where students submit work weekly, and the work submitted does not need to be attributed to specific days to generate funding.”
Arguments in support. Visions in Education states, “Over the past several years, California’s charter school community has been embarrassed by news of schools whose financial mismanagement has led to closures, criminal investigations, and even jail time for some of those involved. Here are just a few of the most concerning and egregious examples of how bad actors have abused their authority over charter school funds meant to benefit our students:
• A3 charter school network administrators were prosecuted for over $400 million in fraud by the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office.
• A self-described former porn star was hired as a consultant by a charter school.
• Two Ford F-150 Raptors were purchased for the use of a charter school Executive Director’s children.
• Weapon parts and tactical gear were purchased by a Northern California charter school.
We would encourage members of the committee to read the entirety of these reports so that you can get a sense of the breadth and depth of the financial issues not being caught through the current auditing process. These highlights only scratch the surface. None of these expenditures were identified by independent auditors during the independent audit process. While the vast majority of charter schools operate in accordance with high levels of fiscal integrity, the actions of bad actors shake the confidence of authorizing school boards and members of the public – making it harder for high quality schools like ours to operate and be renewed.”
Arguments in opposition. The California Teachers Association states, “The charter school employers who sponsored SB 1477 continue to nibble around the edges and fight any real reforms in the NCB charter school space. They distance themselves from bad actors like A3 and Inspire, and the 8,000 charter school educators in the classrooms that we represent are fed up. In 2022, we saw one of the largest charter school scams in history, and no one served any jail time as a result. A3 was a network of 19 online charter schools that enrolled thousands of students who never took any classes, raking in $400 million from the state over four years. They asked private schools to give them their attendance lists and submitted those names to the state, giving the private school a cut of the ADA they received. A3 hired workers to go into public parks and get names from little league players and submit their names to the state as if those students were taking classes. They were not.
Stopping fraud in a learning environment where there is not a brick-and-mortar school that you can walk into and see teachers teaching and students learning, where much of the accountability is based on easily manipulated paperwork and computer files, has been ineffective. As part of the budget last year, the Governor and the Legislature enacted an effort to develop some third-party recommendations about how to fix what is broken. They called on the LAO and FCMAT to produce a report that would address the problems we see over and over at NCB charter schools. Those recommendations were made public in March and should serve as a starting point for conversations. If we want to get serious about improving this area of law, it will need to be a comprehensive approach.”
Related legislation. AB 1316 (O’Donnell) of the 2021-22 Session would have established new requirements for NCB charter schools in the areas of auditing and accounting standards, IS program requirements, the funding determination process, adding requirements to the contracting process, required teacher-to-pupil ratios, limiting authorization of NCB charters by small districts, and adding specificity to the authorizer oversight process, as specified. This bill was placed on the Assembly Floor inactive file.
SB 593 (Glazer) of the 2021-22 Session would have required the FCMAT to offer auditors of NCB charter schools training on the review of charter school financial documents to better identify irregular practices; required the governing body of a charter school to annually review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year; required all independent study by pupils to be coordinated, evaluated, and under the general supervision of an employee of the LEA who possesses a valid certificate, permit, or other document required by law; and required all LEAs to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved, as specified. This bill was held in the Assembly Education Committee.
AB 2990 (C. Garcia) of the 2019-20 Session would have prohibited a charter school from providing financial incentives to a pupil or a parent of a pupil for educational enrichment activities; required a NCB charter school to enter into an agreement for the provision of an educational enrichment activity only with a vendor that has been properly vetted and approved; required the governing body of a NCB charter school to establish policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness before approving any contract for educational enrichment activities; and prohibited educational enrichment activity funds from being used for tuition at a private school or for activities, materials, and programs that are religious in nature. This bill was held on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1505 (O’Donnell), Chapter 486, Statutes of 2019, established a two year moratorium on the establishment of NCB charter schools until January 1, 2022.
AB 1507 (Smith), Chapter 487, Statutes of 2019, prohibits charter schools from being located outside the boundaries of their authorizer and authorizes NCB charter schools to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located.
SB 1362 (Beall) of the 2017-18 Session would have expanded the existing oversight requirements of, and increased the oversight fees that can be charged by charter school authorizers; changed the charter petition review process for school district and COEs governing boards; added special education and fiscal and business operations content to the information that must be included in a charter petition; expanded the authority of a governing board to deny charter petitions; and required the LAO to submit a report to the Legislature on special education services by charter schools. This bill was held in the Senate Education Committee.
SB 329 (Mendoza) of the 2015-16 Session would have required a school district or COE, as part of its review of a charter petition, to consider 1) a report assessing its capacity to conduct oversight of the charter school and 2) a report of the anticipated financial and educational impact on the other schools for which the school district has oversight obligations. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 8 X5 (Brownley) of the 2009-10 Session proposed comprehensive changes to the Education Code consistent with the federal Race to the Top (RTTT) program. This bill would have addressed the four RTTT policy reform areas of standards and assessments, data systems to support instruction, great teachers and leaders, and turning around the lowest-achieving schools. This bill would have deleted the statewide charter school cap and proposed enhanced charter school fiscal and academic accountability standards. This bill was held in the Senate Education Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Allegiance Steam Academy Thrive
Asa Charter School
Excelsior Charter Schools
Fenton Charter Public Schools
Jcs Family Charter Schools
Julia Lee Performing Arts Academy
LA Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy
Liberty Charter High School
Los Angeles Leadership Academy
Public Safety Academy of San Bernardino
Real Journey Academies
Santa Rosa Academy
Soar Charter Academy
Springs Charter Schools
Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts
Temecula International Academy
Visions in Education
Oppose
California Federation of Teachers
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1477 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1477
Author: Ashby (D)
Amended: 5/16/24
Vote: 21
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/24/24
AYES: Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Cortese, Glazer, Gonzalez, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Jones, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab
SUBJECT: School accountability: independent study, educational enrichment activities, oversight, and audit requirements
SOURCE: Real Journey Academies
Visions in Education
DIGEST:
This bill requires: (1) the governing board of a charter school to review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, (2) auditors of non-classroom based (NCB) charter schools to perform specified actions, and (3) all local educational agencies (LEAs) to only enter into an agreement for educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to prescribed criteria.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Charter Schools Act of 1992 which authorizes a school district governing board or county board of education to approve or deny a petition for a charter school to operate independently from the existing school district structure as a method of accomplishing, among other things, improved pupil learning, increased learning opportunities for all pupils, with special emphasis on expanded learning experiences for pupils who are identified as academically low achieving, holding charter schools accountable for meeting measurable pupil outcomes, and providing the schools with a method to change from rule-based to performance-based accountability systems.
- Prohibits the authorization and establishment of new NCB charter schools between January 1, 2020 and January 1, 2026.
- Requires, not later than October 1, 2023, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) and the County Office Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) to study the processes used to determine funding for NCB charter schools. Requires the study to identify and make recommendations on potential improvements to the processes, including recommendations for enhancing oversight and reducing fraud, waste, and abuse.
- Requires a charter school to transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year to its chartering entity, the State Controller’s Office (SCO), the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, (unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering entity) and the California Department of Education (CDE), by December 15 of each year.
- Requires financial and compliance audits to be performed in accordance with General Accounting Office standards for financial and compliance audits. Requires that the audit guide prepared by the SCO be used in the performance of these audits until an audit guide is adopted by the Education Audits Appeal Panel. When an audit guide is adopted by that panel, the adopted audit guide be used in the performance of these audits, and that every audit report specifically and separately address each of the state program compliance requirements included in the audit guide, stating whether or not the district is in compliance with those requirements.
This bill:
- Requires, beginning on January 31, 2025, the governing board of a charter school to annually review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue.
- Requires an auditor of a NCB charter school, when performing an independent, financial audit, to do the following:
- Contact a random sample, to be selected by the auditor, of parents or guardians of pupils enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment.
- As part of the random sample of documents selected and reviewed, sampling of credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school shall be subject to an enhanced materiality standard, as specified.
- Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars or ten percent of the charter school’s budget, with a written explanation from the school regarding the purpose of the expenditures.
- Identify any other irregular transfers, as defined in the mandatory training developed and provided by FCMAT.
- Include a letter with the audit report discussing any concerns or findings, along with a response by the school if the school elects.
- Defines a “nonclassroom-based charter school” as a charter school that offers NCB instruction for more than 20 percent of the instructional time offered.
- Requires all LEAs to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to prescribed criteria, beginning July 1, 2025.
- Requires the governing board of any LEA, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and requires the LEA to certify that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria.
Comments
Need for the bill. According to the author, “A recent joint report by the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) and the Fiscal Crisis Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) identified concerns with the independent audits and other issues relating to charter school oversight. Many of these concerns center on the actions of bad actors.
This bill would implement a number of recommendations by strengthening auditing, contracting, and enrollment policies for charter schools to prevent fraud, improve charter school governance and transparency, and hold bad actors accountable.”
Charter school overview. Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encouraged local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Over the last decade, charter school enrollment has grown steadily. In 2006, 560 charter schools served about 200,000 students (3.5 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). By 2016, over 1,200 charter schools served about 580,000 students (almost 10 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). Most charter schools are small, compared to traditional public schools, and located in urban areas. The median charter school enrolls about 250 students, whereas the median traditional public school enrolls about 525 students. Together, nine Bay Area counties, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County account for more than 60 percent of all charter schools and charter school enrollment in the state.
Charter schools can be conversions of existing public schools or new startup schools. About 15 percent of charter schools are conversions, with the remaining 85 percent being startups. Of these, about 80 percent offer traditional, classroom-based instruction and 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
What are nonclassroom-based charter schools? By law, any charter school in which less than 80 percent of student learning occurs in a physical classroom is classified as NCB. Within this category, schools offer several different teaching models. The majority of NCB charter school students are enrolled in schools whose education is delivered primarily online, whether under the direction of a teacher or through self-guided programs. Others rely on more traditional forms of instruction, including local arts or enrichment classes, paper packets, textbooks, and parental instruction at home. An NCB charter school must submit a funding determination request to the CDE and receive approval of its funding determination request from the State Board of Education (SBE) to be eligible to receive state funding for its NCB average daily attendance (ADA).
Moratorium on establishing new nonclassroom-based charter schools. Based on recommendations from the California Charter School Policy Task Force Report, existing law establishes a moratorium on the establishment of new NCB charter schools from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2026. In the report, the task force noted, “There has been growing concern that virtual charter schools are operated without appropriate academic rigor and oversight, providing a sub-par education for their students.”
Notwithstanding the benefit that NCB charter schools can have for certain students, there are clear examples of misuse of public funds by these schools due to the nature of the instruction they provide. For example, the California Virtual Academies and three Insight Schools were found to be improperly accounting for Common Core education funds, to the tune of $2 million.
Staff notes that this bill does not propose to change the date by which the moratorium on NCB charter schools is currently set to expire.
Recent A3 Charter Schools fraud case reveals significant weaknesses in nonclassroom-based charter school law. In People v. McManus, the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office indicted 11 defendants in a fraud scheme involving nineteen charter schools (“A3 Charter Schools”). The case revealed many weaknesses in state public charter school law in the areas of student data tracking, auditing, school finance, and oversight, which resulted in A3 schools repaying more than $210 million, 13 houses, and numerous shares in third-party companies.
Lack of student data tracking. Currently, charter schools submit aggregate attendance numbers for the school without any information about individual students. Oversight agencies do not maintain individual student data about enrollments in charter schools they oversee for state funding purposes. One A3 charter school was found to be paying a private company to recruit and collect personal information from student athletes. The school then enrolled the athletes in the charter school without their knowledge—thereby fraudulently generating ADA—and paid the recruiting company a portion of the public funds generated as a finder’s fee.
Multi-track calendar abuses. The A3 schools were found to have tricked the state into paying them significantly more funds by manipulating the “multi-track calendar,” which charter schools are currently authorized to use. The A3 schools would (1) run a fake summer school to collect funding for students that never knowingly enrolled, (2) inflate their fraudulent summer school attendance numbers—to the tune of about 60 percent—by offering fewer days of fake summer school instruction, and (3) transfer students between different A3 schools, increasing attendance fraudulently by another roughly 40 percent.
Lack of meaningful audit requirements. The annual audits required by law found little to no malpractice by A3 schools. First, auditors are not required to complete any specialized up-front or ongoing training in school finance or law to audit a charter school. Second, charter schools can choose their auditors—A3 schools were shown to have fired their auditing firms and hire less experienced firms in the rare event that audit findings were made. Third, NCB charter schools are allowed to pick their own samples of student documentation showing compliance with independent study laws—enabling A3 to hide the fraudulent aspects of their operation from auditors. Fourth, auditors are not required to audit the education program received by students, only compliance with documentation. In the A3 schools, many children became enrolled from sports teams believing they were participating in a fundraiser and had no knowledge they were enrolled in a charter school at all.
No meaningful funding determination process. While existing law proposes that NCB charter schools only receive full funding in exceptional circumstances—when at least 80 percent of funding is spent directly serving students—the current funding determination process essentially funds all schools at 100 percent. This is because existing regulations define “instructional and related services” very broadly and charter schools can meet these spending benchmarks without necessarily spending money on students. Further, NCB charter schools are only required to request a funding determination, and provide compliance documentation to the SBE, every five years.
Perverse financial incentives for charter school authorizers. Existing law allows charter authorizers to collect oversight fees from charter schools under their authority but does not require authorizers to demonstrate that the fees are spent on meaningful school oversight. Small school districts that approve NCB charter schools serving students not located in the district can earn significant oversight fees—creating a built-in incentive to overlook poor charter school practices. For example, Dehesa Elementary School District approved over ten charter schools all providing NCB programs. The district’s oversight fees for the 2017-2018 school year were more than its entire expenditures for all employees hired by the district. When the district learned of improprieties from their charter schools it took no meaningful action. Ultimately, the district collected the oversight fees and only acted to revoke the A3 Charter Schools under its authority once law enforcement was involved.
State law requires evaluation of nonclassroom-based charter schools. SB 114 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 48, Statutes of 2023) required the LAO and FCMAT to study the processes used to determine funding for NCB charter schools and report their findings. The statute specifies that this study shall “identify and make recommendations on potential improvements to the [funding determination] processes, including recommendations for enhancing oversight and reducing fraud, waste,andabuse.”
The LAO and FCMAT report include far more expansive reform recommendations related to NCB charter school funding determinations and oversight, which are not included in this bill as currently drafted.
This bill makes improvements to existing auditing requirements, but future legislation including far more substantial reforms is needed before the nonclassroom-based charter school moratorium expires. As currently drafted, this bill would improve the auditing of NCB charter schools by (1) requiring auditors to perform a check on the validity of the school’s enrollment records, (2) requiring bank statements and fund transfers to individuals or corporations to be reviewed with further scrutiny, and (3) requiring auditors to look for any other irregular practices.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- This bill would likely result in increased local costs for NCB charter schools to comply with the expanded audit requirements. This increase could be in the thousands of dollars for each audit and would be charged by auditors as part of the charter’s annual audit.
- Any administrative costs to the California Department of Education (CDE) are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/16/24)
Real Journey Academies (co-source)
Visions in Education (co-source)
Allegiance Steam Academy Thrive
ASA Charter School
Excelsior Charter Schools
Fenton Charter Public Schools
JCS Family Charter Schools
Julia Lee Performing Arts Academy
LA Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy
Liberty Charter High School
Los Angeles Leadership Academy
Public Safety Academy of San Bernardino
Santa Rosa Academy
SOAR Charter Academy
Springs Charter Schools
Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts
Temecula International Academy
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/24)
None received
Prepared by: Ian Johnson / ED. / (916) 651-4105
5/18/24 14:06:52
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1477 (Ashby) - School accountability: independent study, educational enrichment activities, oversight, and audit requirements
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the governing board of a charter school to review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year and for auditors of non-classroom based (NCB) charter schools to perform specified actions as part of their independent financial audits.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2024
Fiscal Impact:
- This bill would likely result in increased local costs for NCB charter schools to comply with the expanded audit requirements. This increase could be in the thousands of dollars for each audit and would be charged by auditors as part of the charter’s annual audit.
- Any administrative costs to the California Department of Education (CDE) are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources.
Author Amendments:
Remove the provision allowing CDE to assess administrative penalties to local educational agencies for providing false materials.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1477 (Ashby) - School accountability: independent study, educational enrichment activities, oversight, and audit requirements
Version: April 15, 2024 | Policy Vote: ED. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2024 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the governing board of a charter school to review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year and for auditors of non-classroom based (NCB) charter schools to perform specified actions as part of their independent financial audits.
Fiscal Impact:
- This bill would likely result in increased local costs for NCB charter schools to comply with the expanded audit requirements. This increase could be in the thousands of dollars for each audit and would be charged by auditors as part of the charter’s annual audit.
- This bill allows the California Department of Education (CDE) to assess administrative penalties of $10,000 each to local educational agencies (LEAs), beginning July 1, 2025, for providing false materials as part of independent study written agreements. The extent of these costs to LEAs statewide would depend on the number of penalties that are assessed by CDE each year.
- Any administrative costs to the CDE are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources.
Background:
Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encouraged local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Any charter school in which less than 80 percent of student learning occurs in a physical classroom is classified as “nonclassroom-based” (NCB). Within this category, schools offer several different teaching models. The majority of NCB charter school students are enrolled in schools whose education is delivered primarily online, whether under the direction of a teacher or through self-guided programs. Others rely on more traditional forms of instruction, including local arts or enrichment classes, paper packets, textbooks, and parental instruction at home. A NCB charter school must submit a funding determination request to the California Department of Education and receive approval of its funding determination request from the State Board of Education to be eligible to receive state funding for its NCB average daily attendance (ADA).
Existing law requires a charter school to transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year to its chartering entity, the State Controller’s Office (SCO), the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, (unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering entity) and the California Department of Education (CDE), by December 15 of each year.
Existing law requires financial and compliance audits to be performed in accordance with General Accounting Office standards for financial and compliance audits. Requires that the audit guide prepared by the SCO be used in the performance of these audits until an audit guide is adopted by the Education Audits Appeal Panel. When an audit guide is adopted by that panel, the adopted audit guide be used in the performance of these audits, and that every audit report specifically and separately address each of the state program compliance requirements included in the audit guide, stating whether or not the district is in compliance with those requirements.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires, beginning on January 31, 2025, the governing board of a charter school to annually review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue.
This bill requires an auditor of a NCB charter school, when performing an independent, financial audit, to do the following:
- Contact a random sample, to be selected by the auditor, of parents or guardians of pupils enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment.
- As part of the random sample of documents selected and reviewed, sampling of credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school shall be subject to an enhanced materiality standard, as specified.
- Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars or ten percent of the charter school’s budget, with a written explanation from the school regarding the purpose of the expenditures.
- Identify any other irregular transfers, as defined in the mandatory training developed and provided by FCMAT.
- Include a letter with the audit report discussing any concerns or findings, along with a response by the school if the school elects.
This bill defines a “nonclassroom-based charter school” as a charter school that offers NCB instruction for more than 20 percent of the instructional time offered.
This bill provides that if, as part of the independent study written agreements for each independent study pupil, an LEA employee willfully states as true any material fact that the employee knows to be false, the CDE may assess an administrative penalty of $10,000 beginning July 1, 2025.
This bill requires all LEAs to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to prescribed criteria, beginning July 1, 2025.
This bill requires the governing board of any LEA, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and requires the LEA to certify that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria.
Related Legislation:
SB 593 (Glazer, 2021) would have required the County Office Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) to offer auditors of non-classroom based (NCB) charter schools training on the review of charter school financial documents. This bill was held in the Assembly Education Committee.
Staff Comments:
Any charter school in which less than 80 percent of student learning occurs in a physical classroom is classified as NCB. The majority of NCB charter school students are enrolled in schools whose education is delivered primarily online, whether under the direction of a teacher or through self-guided programs.
SB 114 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 48, Statutes of 2023) requires the LAO and FCMAT to study the processes used to determine funding for NCB charter schools and report their findings. The statute specifies that this study shall “identify and make recommendations on potential improvements to the [funding determination] processes, including recommendations for enhancing oversight and reducing fraud, waste, and abuse.” Released in February 2024, the report recommends the following with respect to charter school oversight:
“Current audit requirements often do not address the complexities and unique flexibilities of charter school finances. We recommend the Legislature align the audit process for charter schools to that of school districts and add audit requirements that would address issues specific to charter schools.”
While the LAO and FCMAT report includes more expansive reform recommendations related to NCB charter school funding determinations and oversight, this bill would improve the auditing of NCB charter schools by requiring auditors to perform a check on the validity of the school’s enrollment records; requiring bank statements and fund transfers to individuals or corporations to be reviewed with further scrutiny; and requiring auditors to look for any other irregular practices.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1477 Hearing Date: April 24, 2024
Author: | |||
Version: | April 15, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Ian Johnson | ||
Subject: School accountability: independent study, educational enrichment activities, oversight, and audit requirements.
Note: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Public Safety. A “do pass” motion should include referral to the Committee on Public Safety.
SUMMARY
This bill requires: (1) the governing board of a charter school to review, at a public meeting, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, (2) auditors of non-classroom based (NCB) charter schools to perform specified actions, and (3) all local educational agencies (LEAs) to only enter into an agreement for educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to prescribed criteria.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Establishes the Charter Schools Act of 1992 which authorizes a school district governing board or county board of education to approve or deny a petition for a charter school to operate independently from the existing school district structure as a method of accomplishing, among other things, improved pupil learning, increased learning opportunities for all pupils, with special emphasis on expanded learning experiences for pupils who are identified as academically low achieving, holding charter schools accountable for meeting measurable pupil outcomes, and providing the schools with a method to change from rule-based to performance-based accountability systems.
- Prohibits the authorization and establishment of new NCB charter schools between January 1, 2020 and January 1, 2026.
- Requires, not later than October 1, 2023, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) and the County Office Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) to study the processes used to determine funding for NCB charter schools. Requires the study to identify and make recommendations on potential improvements to the processes, including recommendations for enhancing oversight and reducing fraud, waste, and abuse.
- Requires a charter school to transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year to its chartering entity, the State Controller’s Office (SCO), the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, (unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering entity) and the California Department of Education (CDE), by December 15 of each year.
- Requires financial and compliance audits to be performed in accordance with General Accounting Office standards for financial and compliance audits. Requires that the audit guide prepared by the SCO be used in the performance of these audits until an audit guide is adopted by the Education Audits Appeal Panel. When an audit guide is adopted by that panel, the adopted audit guide be used in the performance of these audits, and that every audit report specifically and separately address each of the state program compliance requirements included in the audit guide, stating whether or not the district is in compliance with those requirements.
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Requires, beginning on January 31, 2025, the governing board of a charter school to annually review, at a public meeting as an item on the agenda, the annual audit of the charter school for the prior fiscal year, any audit exceptions identified in that audit, the recommendations or findings of any management letter issued by the auditor, and any description of correction or plans to correct any exceptions or management letter issue.
- Requires an auditor of a NCB charter school, when performing an independent, financial audit, to do the following:
- Contact a random sample, to be selected by the auditor, of parents or guardians of pupils enrolled in the charter school to verify their enrollment.
- As part of the random sample of documents selected and reviewed, sampling of credit card statements, debit card statements, other electronic payment methods and media, and bank statements of the charter school shall be subject to an enhanced materiality standard, as specified.
- Identify in the audit report any transfers of funds or assets to other individuals or organizations that exceed one million dollars or ten percent of the charter school’s budget, with a written explanation from the school regarding the purpose of the expenditures.
- Identify any other irregular transfers, as defined in the mandatory training developed and provided by FCMAT.
- Include a letter with the audit report discussing any concerns or findings, along with a response by the school if the school elects.
- Defines a “nonclassroom-based charter school” as a charter school that offers NCB instruction for more than 20 percent of the instructional time offered.
- States that if, as part of the independent study written agreements for each independent study pupil, an LEA employee willfully states as true any material fact that the employee knows to be false, the CDE may assess an administrative penalty of $10,000 beginning July 1, 2025.
- Requires all LEAs to only enter into an agreement for the provision or arrangement of educational enrichment activities with a vendor that is vetted and approved pursuant to prescribed criteria, beginning July 1, 2025.
- Requires the governing board of any LEA, in approving any contract for vendor services for educational enrichment activities, to establish specified policies and procedures to ensure educational value, pupil safety, and fiscal reasonableness, and requires the LEA to certify that vendor services for educational enrichment activities meet designated criteria.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “A recent joint report by the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) and the Fiscal Crisis Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) identified concerns with the independent audits and other issues relating to charter school oversight. Many of these concerns center on the actions of bad actors.
SB 1477 would implement a number of recommendations by strengthening auditing, contracting, and enrollment policies for charter schools to prevent fraud, improve charter school governance and transparency, and hold bad actors accountable.”
- Charter school overview. Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encouraged local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Over the last decade, charter school enrollment has grown steadily. In 2006, 560 charter schools served about 200,000 students (3.5 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). By 2016, over 1,200 charter schools served about 580,000 students (almost 10 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). Most charter schools are small, compared to traditional public schools, and located in urban areas. The median charter school enrolls about 250 students, whereas the median traditional public school enrolls about 525 students. Together, nine Bay Area counties, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County account for more than 60 percent of all charter schools and charter school enrollment in the state.
Charter schools can be conversions of existing public schools or new startup schools. About 15 percent of charter schools are conversions, with the remaining 85 percent being startups. Of these, about 80 percent offer traditional, classroom-based instruction and 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
- What are nonclassroom-based charter schools? By law, any charter school in which less than 80 percent of student learning occurs in a physical classroom is classified as NCB. Within this category, schools offer several different teaching models. The majority of NCB charter school students are enrolled in schools whose education is delivered primarily online, whether under the direction of a teacher or through self-guided programs. Others rely on more traditional forms of instruction, including local arts or enrichment classes, paper packets, textbooks, and parental instruction at home. An NCB charter school must submit a funding determination request to the CDE and receive approval of its funding determination request from the State Board of Education (SBE) to be eligible to receive state funding for its NCB average daily attendance (ADA).
- Moratorium on establishing new nonclassroom-based charter schools. Based on recommendations from the California Charter School Policy Task Force Report, existing law establishes a moratorium on the establishment of new NCB charter schools from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2026. In the report, the task force noted, “There has been growing concern that virtual charter schools are operated without appropriate academic rigor and oversight, providing a sub-par education for their students.”
Notwithstanding the benefit that NCB charter schools can have for certain students, there are clear examples of misuse of public funds by these schools due to the nature of the instruction they provide. For example, the California Virtual Academies and three Insight Schools were found to be improperly accounting for Common Core education funds, to the tune of $2 million.
Staff notes that this bill does not propose to change the date by which the moratorium on NCB charter schools is currently set to expire.
- Recent A3 Charter Schools fraud case reveals significant weaknesses in nonclassroom-based charter school law. In People v. McManus, the San Diego County District Attorney’s Office indicted 11 defendants in a fraud scheme involving nineteen charter schools (“A3 Charter Schools”). The case revealed many weaknesses in state public charter school law in the areas of student data tracking, auditing, school finance, and oversight, which resulted in A3 schools repaying more than $210 million, 13 houses, and numerous shares in third-party companies.
- Lack of student data tracking. Currently, charter schools submit aggregate attendance numbers for the school without any information about individual students. Oversight agencies do not maintain individual student data about enrollments in charter schools they oversee for state funding purposes. One A3 charter school was found to be paying a private company to recruit and collect personal information from student athletes. The school then enrolled the athletes in the charter school without their knowledge—thereby fraudulently generating ADA—and paid the recruiting company a portion of the public funds generated as a finder’s fee.
- Multi-track calendar abuses. The A3 schools were found to have tricked the state into paying them significantly more funds by manipulating the “multi-track calendar”, which charter schools are currently authorized to use. The A3 schools would (1) run a fake summer school to collect funding for students that never knowingly enrolled, (2) inflate their fraudulent summer school attendance numbers—to the tune of about 60 percent—by offering fewer days of fake summer school instruction, and (3) transfer students between different A3 schools, increasing attendance fraudulently by another roughly 40 percent.
- Lack of meaningful audit requirements. The annual audits required by law found little to no malpractice by A3 schools. First, auditors are not required to complete any specialized up-front or ongoing training in school finance or law to audit a charter school. Second, charter schools can choose their auditors—A3 schools were shown to have fired their auditing firms and hire less experienced firms in the rare event that audit findings were made. Third, NCB charter schools are allowed to pick their own samples of student documentation showing compliance with independent study laws—enabling A3 to hide the fraudulent aspects of their operation from auditors. Fourth, auditors are not required to audit the education program received by students, only compliance with documentation. In the A3 schools, many children became enrolled from sports teams believing they were participating in a fundraiser and had no knowledge they were enrolled in a charter school at all.
- No meaningful funding determination process. While existing law proposes that NCB charter schools only receive full funding in exceptional circumstances—when at least 80 percent of funding is spent directly serving students—the current funding determination process essentially funds all schools at 100 percent. This is because existing regulations define “instructional and related services” very broadly and charter schools can meet these spending benchmarks without necessarily spending money on students. Further, NCB charter schools are only required to request a funding determination, and provide compliance documentation to the SBE, every five years.
- Perverse financial incentives for charter school authorizers. Existing law allows charter authorizers to collect oversight fees from charter schools under their authority but does not require authorizers to demonstrate that the fees are spent on meaningful school oversight. Small school districts that approve NCB charter schools serving students not located in the district can earn significant oversight fees—creating a built-in incentive to overlook poor charter school practices. For example, Dehesa Elementary School District approved over ten charter schools all providing NCB programs. The district’s oversight fees for the 2017-2018 school year were more than its entire expenditures for all employees hired by the district. When the district learned of improprieties from their charter schools it took no meaningful action. Ultimately, the district collected the oversight fees and only acted to revoke the A3 Charter Schools under its authority once law enforcement was involved.
- State law requires evaluation of nonclassroom-based charter schools. SB 114, Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 48, Statutes of 2023) requires the LAO and FCMAT to study the processes used to determine funding for NCB charter schools and report their findings. The statute specifies that this study shall “identify and make recommendations on potential improvements to the [funding determination] processes, including recommendations for enhancing oversight and reducing fraud, waste, and abuse.”
Released in February 2024, the report found, among other things, the following:
“The funding determination process can be a helpful tool to monitor the overall cost structure of a nonclassroom-based charter school and to ensure funding is being spent on staffing and other services that benefit students. The process, however, is not an effective approach for ensuring that charter schools are complying with other state laws. Given the funding determination process is based on the review of audited expenditures and attendance data, it relies on other aspects of the system to be working effectively. These other aspects of oversight—such as annual audit requirements and oversight from authorizers, county superintendents, and the state—are more appropriate ways to monitor these issues.”
Specific to charter school oversight, the report recommends the following:
“We recommend the Legislature consider several changes to improve the quality of authorizer oversight. Specifically, we recommend the Legislature set limits on district authorizers by district size and grade, increase minimum requirements for authorizers, and consider an alternative authorizing structure for virtual schools.
“Current audit requirements often do not address the complexities and unique flexibilities of charter school finances. We recommend the Legislature align the audit process for charter schools to that of school districts and add audit requirements that would address issues specific to charter schools.”
The LAO and FCMAT report include far more expansive reform recommendations related to NCB charter school funding determinations and oversight, which are not included in this bill as currently drafted.
- This bill makes improvements to existing auditing requirements, but future legislation including far more substantial reforms is needed before the nonclassroom-based charter school moratorium expires. As currently drafted, this bill would improve the auditing of NCB charter schools by (1) requiring auditors to perform a check on the validity of the school’s enrollment records, (2) requiring bank statements and fund transfers to individuals or corporations to be reviewed with further scrutiny, and (3) requiring auditors to look for any other irregular practices.
Examples such as the A3 Charter Schools case demonstrate that the need for NCB charter school reforms go far beyond the contents of this bill. For example, it is unclear whether this bill would reveal abuses made possible by utilizing the multi-track calendar. Further, the bill does not prevent NCB charter schools from picking their own auditors. But perhaps most importantly, the contents of this bill only pertain to financial audits, which can only make findings after nefarious behavior has already occurred and public funds have been apportioned. Given that the moratorium on establishing new NCB charter schools will expire on January 1, 2026, reforms that are designed to prevent “bad actors” from engaging in fraudulent behavior on the front end must be considered—and in a way that preserves the ability for “good actors” to continue to serve students effectively.
For example, would prohibiting schools from utilizing a multi-track calendar unless there is a demonstrated programmatic or facilities need help curb enrollment abuses? Would reforming the NCB charter school funding determination process in a way that incentivizes more in-person instruction lead to better outcomes for students? Are charter school authorizers better positioned to identify and prevent fraudulent practices than independent financial auditors? If so, would providing more professional development for authorizers to identify irregular practices also make sense? Further, would a cap on the amount of NCB charter school ADA small school districts can oversee improve authorizer quality and address existing perverse incentives for districts collecting large amounts of oversight fees?
SUPPORT
Real Journey Academies (co-sponsor)
Visions in Education (co-sponsor)
Excelsior Charter Schools
Fenton Charter Public Schools
JCS Family Charter Schools
LA Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy
Los Angeles Leadership Academy
Santa Rosa Academy
SOAR Charter Academy
Springs Charter Schools
Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):