SB 16: Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-05-18
Current Status:
Failed
(2023-09-01: September 1 hearing postponed by committee.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Unruh Civil Rights Act generally prohibits business establishments from discriminating on specified bases. The California Fair Employment and Housing Act (act) prohibits discrimination in housing and employment on specified bases and provides procedures for enforcement by the Civil Rights Department. Existing law specifies that while it is the intent of the Legislature that the act occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing, nothing in the act shall be construed to limit or restrict the application of the Unruh Civil Rights Act.
This bill would would, commencing on January 1, 2025, also specify that nothing in the act shall be construed to limit or restrict efforts by local entities to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against classes of persons covered by the act in employment and housing, provided that the enforcement complies with regulations governing local enforcement of the act that the bill would require the Civil Rights Department to promulgate by____. The bill would require those regulations, at a minimum, to ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state, protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims, and avoid duplication of investigatory work. work, and minimize any possible loss of federal funding for the Civil Rights Departments work.
The Unruh Civil Rights Act generally prohibits business establishments from discriminating on specified bases. The California Fair Employment and Housing Act (act) prohibits discrimination in housing and employment on specified bases and provides procedures for enforcement by the Civil Rights Department. Existing law specifies that while it is the intent of the Legislature that the California Fair Employment and Housing Act act occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing, nothing in the act shall be construed to limit or restrict the application of the Unruh Civil Rights Act.
This bill would also specify that nothing in the California Fair Employment and Housing Act act shall be construed to limit or restrict efforts by local entities to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against classes of persons covered by the act in employment and housing. housing, provided that the enforcement complies with regulations governing local enforcement of the act that the bill would require the Civil Rights Department to promulgate by____. The bill would require those regulations, at a minimum, to ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state, protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims, and avoid duplication of investigatory work.
The Unruh Civil Rights Act generally prohibits business establishments from discriminating on specified bases. The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits discrimination in housing and employment on specified bases and provides procedures for enforcement by the Civil Rights Department. Existing law specifies that while it is the intent of the Legislature that the California Fair Employment and Housing Act occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing, nothing in the act shall be construed to limit or restrict the application of the Unruh Civil Rights Act.
This bill would also specify that nothing in the California Fair Employment and Housing Act shall be construed to limit or restrict efforts by local entities to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against classes of persons covered by the act in employment and housing.
(a)The provisions of this part shall be construed liberally for the accomplishment of the purposes of this part. This part does not repeal any of the provisions of civil rights law or of any other law of this state relating to discrimination because of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, age, reproductive health decisionmaking, or sexual orientation, unless those provisions provide less protection to the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part.
(b)The provisions in this part relating to discrimination in employment on account of sex or medical condition do not affect the operation of the terms or conditions of any bona fide retirement, pension, employee benefit, or insurance plan, provided the terms or conditions are in accordance with customary and reasonable or actuarially sound underwriting practices.
(c)(1)It is the intention of the Legislature to occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing encompassed by the provisions of this part, exclusive of all other laws banning discrimination in employment and housing by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), this part does not limit or restrict the application of Section 51 of the Civil Code.
(3)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), this part does not limit or restrict efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing, provided that the enforcement complies with the regulations promulgated pursuant to subparagraph (B).
(B)Pursuant to its authority under subdivision (e) of Section 12930, the department shall promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing by____. The regulations shall, at a minimum, do all of the following:
(i)Ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state.
(ii)Protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims.
(iii)Avoid duplication of investigatory work.
(iv)Minimize any possible loss of federal funding for the departments work.
(d)The amendments made by the act adding this subdivision shall become operative on January 1, 2025.
(a)The provisions of this part shall be construed liberally for the accomplishment of the purposes of this part. This part does not repeal any of the provisions of civil rights law or of any other law of this state relating to discrimination because of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, age, reproductive health decisionmaking, or sexual orientation, unless those provisions provide less protection to the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part.
(b)The provisions in this part relating to discrimination in employment on account of sex or medical condition do not affect the operation of the terms or conditions of any bona fide retirement, pension, employee benefit, or insurance plan, provided the terms or conditions are in accordance with customary and reasonable or actuarially sound underwriting practices.
(c)While it (1)It is the intention of the Legislature to occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing encompassed by the provisions of this part, exclusive of all other laws banning discrimination in employment and housing by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state, this state.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), this part does not limit or restrict the application of Section 51 of the Civil Code, or Code.
(3)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), this part does not limit or restrict efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing. housing, provided that the enforcement complies with the regulations promulgated pursuant to subparagraph (B).
(B)Pursuant to its authority under subdivision (e) of Section 12930, the department shall promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing by____. The regulations shall, at a minimum, do all of the following:
(i)Ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state.
(ii)Protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims.
(iii)Avoid duplication of investigatory work.
(a)The provisions of this part shall be construed liberally for the accomplishment of the purposes of this part. This part does not repeal any of the provisions of civil rights law or of any other law of this state relating to discrimination because of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, age, reproductive health decisionmaking, or sexual orientation, unless those provisions provide less protection to the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part.
(b)The provisions in this part relating to discrimination in employment on account of sex or medical condition do not affect the operation of the terms or conditions of any bona fide retirement, pension, employee benefit, or insurance plan, provided the terms or conditions are in accordance with customary and reasonable or actuarially sound underwriting practices.
(c)While it is the intention of the Legislature to occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing encompassed by the provisions of this part, exclusive of all other laws banning discrimination in employment and housing by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state, this part does not limit or restrict the application of Section 51 of the Civil Code. Code, or limit or restrict efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2023 | September 1 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 12, 2023 | July 12 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 20, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 8, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 31, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 7. Page 1357.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 1157.) (May 18). |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | April 17 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 1. Page 575.) (March 28). |
| Mar 7, 2023 | Set for hearing March 28. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Dec 6, 2022 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 5. |
| Dec 5, 2022 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 20, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB16 Smallwood-Cuevas | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 28, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Affordable Housing Management Association Pacific Southwest | ** Against | |
| Apartment Association Of Orange County | ** Against | |
| CA African American Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Faculty Association | ** Support | |
| California Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| California Labor Federation, Afl-Cio | ** Support | |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Support | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Support | |
| California Teachers Association | ** Support | |
| East Bay Rental Housing Association | ** Against | |
| Greater Sacramento Urban League | ** Support | |
| Housing Contractors Of California | ** Against | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Protection of The Educational Rights of Kids | ** Support | |
| Southern California Black Worker Hub for Regional Organizing | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: July 12, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 16
Author:(Smallwood-Cuevas) – As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 8 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows a local government to enforce the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) as long as the local government follows related regulations established by the Civil Rights Department (CRD).
The bill specifies that CRD’s regulations must:
- Ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state.
- Protect complainants against inadvertently losing federal or state legal claims.
- Avoid duplication of investigatory work.
- Minimize possible loss of federal funding for CRD’s work.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs (General Fund) to CRD in the low millions of dollars annually. CRD reports this bill would require additional staffing to promulgate and update regulations, negotiate legal agreements between CRD and local enforcement agencies, and provide ongoing oversight over and technical assistance to local enforcement agencies. CRD may need to create and implement new case management and IT tools, the costs of which are currently unknown. CRD estimates costs of at least $1.2 million for six positions in fiscal year (FY) 2024-25 and $2.75 million for 14 positions in FY 2025-26 and ongoing. As described below, SB 16 may have additional effects on CRD’s federal funding, of an unknown but potentially significant amount.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Any form of discrimination robs people of their human dignity and often also of their financial stability and their health. When discrimination is allowed to ensue unchecked it also robs our communities of valuable opportunities to be better and to be stronger. Lack of enforcement of anti-discrimination laws is a problem that is well documented and if ever there were a time to reverse that pattern, it is now. SB 16 would do this by specifying nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination, and help ensure equity for all Californians.
- Background. FEHA is a state law that prohibits employment and housing discrimination based on protected characteristics including race, color, ancestry, religion, age, disability, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, and medical condition. FEHA is enforced only by CRD (formerly known as the Department of Fair Employment and Housing). CRD receives and investigates complaints of discrimination under FEHA, conducts alternative dispute resolutions, and, if needed, files civil lawsuits to enforce violations of the law. CRD also has contracts and work-sharing agreements with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) through which CRD shares the workload of investigating and resolving discrimination complaints that violate both state and federal law. CRD receives federal funding for handling claims of discrimination that could otherwise be investigated by these federal agencies. Currently, FEHA expressly preempts local anti-discrimination laws and ordinances, and local governments cannot enforce FEHA.
This bill allows a local government to enforce FEHA as long as the local government complies with regulations promulgated by CRD. The bill requires CRD to create the related regulations and prescribes minimum requirements for the regulations, as listed above. These provisions will become operative January 1, 2025. It is unclear how this significant change in enforcement will affect CRD’s workload and fiscal needs. Implementation of this bill will require coordination between local agencies, CRD, and, likely, federal agencies, but the details of how exactly they will share enforcement duties is unknown. CRD’s caseload may decrease if local agencies handle complaints that would normally be filed with CRD. CRD may lose federal funding if other agencies handle cases that CRD would have dual-filed with EEOC and HUD.
- Prior Legislation. SB 218 (Bradford), of the 2019-2020 Legislative Session, would have allowed a local government in Los Angeles County to enact and enforce its own employment discrimination laws, as long as the local laws were at least as protective as FEHA. In 2019, Governor Newsom vetoed the bill, writing:
I don’t support lifting a preemption that has been in place for decades in the manner proposed in this bill. As crafted, this measure could create confusion, inconsistent enforcement of the law and increase costs without a corresponding increase in worker protections. This bill leaves ambiguities about local governments’ ability to enforce both local ordinances and FEHA. I invite the Legislature to come back with a measure that makes it clear that local enforcement measures are exclusively focused on local ordinances.
As discussed in the analysis of SB 16 by the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, this bill does not directly address these concerns. Rather than focusing on enforcement of local antidiscrimination ordinances, as suggested in the Governor’s veto message, SB 16 allows local governments to enforce FEHA, a state law. And rather than resolving the implementation concerns cited in response to SB 218 and related legislation, SB 16 directs CRD to promulgate regulations that address those issues.
SB 491 (Bradford), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required CRD to convene an advisory group to conduct a study about the feasibility of authorizing local government entities to enforce antidiscrimination laws. Governor Brown vetoed the bill, stating that the bill was unclear and too broadly drafted. He directed CRD to create an advisory group to study and report to the Legislature and the Governor’s office about allowing the provisions of FEHA to be enforced by local authorities.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 16
Author:(Smallwood-Cuevas) – As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 32-7
SUBJECT: Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement
KEY ISSUE: should local governments be authorized, as of January 1, 2025, to enforce state anti-discrimination laws; and should the Civil Rights Department be required to develop guidelines for this purpose?
SYNOPSIS
California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) prohibits discrimination in housing and employment on the basis of any of the protected characteristics enumerated in the statute. FEHA expressly declares a legislative intent that the state shall “occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing exclusive of all other laws banning discrimination in employment and housing” by local governments. In short, FEHA preempts local laws prohibiting employment and housing discrimination; it also effectively prohibits local governments from enforcing state law, given that FEHA does not presently provide any mechanism for local governments to do so. According to the author, while FEHA provides strong protections against discrimination, the state lacks adequate capacity and funding to enforce the law. Allowing local agencies to enforce state law, the author contends, will permit more rigorous and robust enforcement.
This bill would declare that nothing in existing law prevents local governments from enforcing FEHA, provided that they do so in compliance with regulations to be promulgated by the Civil Rights Department (CRD). Since no such regulations for local enforcement presently exist, the bill would also require the CRD – which now has exclusive power to enforce FEHA – to promulgate such regulations. The bill also specifies that these regulations shall do all of the following: (1) ensure consistent application of the anti-discrimination laws throughout the state; (2) protect claimants against inadvertent loss of state or federal claims; (3) avoid duplication of investigatory work; and (4) minimize any possible loss of federal funds for CRD’s work. In order to provide time for CRD to do this, the bill’s provision would not become effective until January 1, 2025.
This Committee has previously heard, and passed, bills to permit local enforcement of anti-discrimination laws. SB 491 (Bradford, 2017), as introduced, would have similarly permitted local enforcement of FEHA, but the bill was eventually amended to create an advisory group to consider the feasibility of local enforcement. SB 218 (Bradford, 2019) would have created a pilot project permitting Los Angeles to enact and enforce its own anti-discrimination employment laws, so long as the local laws were at least as protective as state law. Both measures were vetoed. This bill is supported by several labor organizations. Several regional apartment associations opposed a prior version of this bill. It is unclear if they remain opposed.
SUMMARY: Provides that nothing in existing law prevents local governments from enforcing state laws prohibiting housing and employment discrimination and requires the Civil Rights Department (CRD) to promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of these state laws. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a provision in existing law declaring legislative intent that the state occupy the field of regulating housing and employment discrimination does not limit or restrict efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against protected classes, provided that the enforcement complies with the regulations promulgated by the CRD.
- Requires the CRD to promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of state law prohibiting discrimination against protected classes, as described, and specifies that these regulations shall, at a minimum, do all of the following:
- Ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state.
- Protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims.
- Avoid duplication of investigatory work.
- Minimize any possible loss of federal funding for the CRD’s work.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits, under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), discrimination in housing and employment on the bases of specified characteristics and establishes procedures for enforcement by the Civil Rights Department. States legislative intent that FEHA shall occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing. (Government Code Sections 12900 et seq., 12993.)
- Establishes, under federal law, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) for the purpose of receiving, investigating, and resolving complaints of employment discrimination. Permits state or local agencies to accept and investigate complaints alleging a violation of federal employment anti-discrimination laws and to enter into a work-sharing agreement with EEOC. Specifies that filing with a state or local agency constitutes “double-filing” with the EEOC. (42 U.S.C. Sections 2000e et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, any “form of discrimination robs people of their human dignity and often also of their financial stability and their health. When discrimination is allowed to ensue unchecked it also robs our communities of valuable opportunities to be better and to be stronger.” Yet, the author maintains, lack of enforcement “is a problem that is well documented and if ever there were a time to reverse that pattern, it is now.” The author believes that this bill, by allowing local agencies to enforce FEHA’s anti-discrimination provisions, “will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination, and help ensure equity for all Californians.”
Specifically, this bill would declare that nothing in existing law prevents local governments from enforcing FEHA, provided that they do so in compliance with regulations promulgated by CRD. Given that no such regulations for local enforcement presently exist, the bill would also require the CRD – formerly the Department of Fair Employment and Housing – to promulgate such regulations. The bill specifies that these regulations shall do all of the following: (1) ensure consistent application of the anti-discrimination laws throughout the state; (2) protect claimants against inadvertent loss of state or federal claims; (3) avoid duplication of investigatory work; and (4) minimize any possible loss of federal funds for CRD’s work. In order to provide time for CRD to do this, the bill’s provision would not become effective until January 1, 2025.
Background on California’s civil rights and anti-discrimination laws. In 1959, the California Legislature enacted two important civil rights statutes. The Fair Employment Practices Act prohibited discrimination in employment. Initially this statute targeted racial and religious discrimination, but this list of protected characteristics has expanded over the years to also ban discrimination on account of color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. It was also in 1959 that the Legislature enacted the Unruh Civil Rights Act to prohibit any business establishment from denying to any person full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services based on certain protected characteristics. As with the Fair Employment Practices Act, the Unruh Civil Rights originally targeted racial discrimination but has expanded over the years to include sex (which was later defined to include gender, gender identity, and gender expression), ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, and immigration status.
In 1963, the Legislature enacted the Rumford Fair Housing Act in response to widespread and deeply rooted racial discrimination in housing. In 1980, the Fair Employment Practices Act and the Rumford Fair Housing Act were combined to become the present Fair Employment and Housing Act, or FEHA. Enforcement of FEHA fell to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH), which also acquired the power to enforce most of the state’s civil rights statutes, including the Unruh Act. In July of 2022, the DFEH was renamed the Civil Rights Department (CRD) to better reflect its more expansive powers and duties. Additional statutes were added in subsequent years to prohibit, among other things, gender pricing discrimination, harassment or intimidation directed at protected classes of people, and human trafficking. Together, these statutes constitute California's principal civil rights and anti-discrimination statutes.
State and local enforcement of civil rights and antidiscrimination laws. The agencies charged with enforcing California's civil rights and anti-discrimination statutes vary. The Unruh Civil Rights Act, for example, may be investigated and enforced by CRD, the California Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney. In addition, any person injured by a violation of the Unruh Civil Rights Act may bring a civil action for damages, including any attorney's fees. However, the provisions on employment and housing anti-discrimination consolidated under FEHA are regulated and enforced only by the CRD, which is authorized to make all rules and regulations relating to workplace and housing discrimination, as well as to receive complaints of discrimination, investigate those complaints, and take appropriate remedial action. Once a complaint is filed, CRD must take a series of legally required steps. In many cases, CRD investigates the case and encourages the parties to resolve the dispute. If the dispute cannot be resolved in this manner, CRD may conduct hearings and, if it finds that discrimination has occurred, may bring a civil action on behalf of itself and the complainant. In other cases, indeed the majority of cases, CRD may opt not to investigate the case and instead provides the complainant a so-called "right to sue" letter, which allows that person to bring a civil action without having to further exhaust any administrative process. Issuance of the right-to-sue letter relieves CRD of any further obligation to investigate the case.
Most relevant to this bill, FEHA expressly states legislative intent that the state “occupies the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing encompassed by the provisions [of FEHA], exclusive of all other laws banning discrimination in employment and housing by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state.” This statement constitutes a classic assertion of express preemption. That is, just as federal laws may preempt state law, state laws may preempt local laws and ordinances. The California courts have generally analyzed state preemption in the same way that courts analyze federal preemption, recognizing three forms of preemption: (1) “conflict preemption,” where local law conflicts with state law, and thus state law prevails; (2) “implied” or “field” preemption, where the statutory scheme is so comprehensive in a particular field of law that it impliedly preempts local laws; and (3) “express” preemption, in which the Legislature expressly states that it occupies the field of regulation, which the FEHA statute does. In addition, the same section also provides that nothing in FEHA shall be construed to limit the application of Civil Code Section 51, the Unruh Civil Rights Act. In other words, while CRD may enforce the Unruh Act, it does not prohibit local governments from enforcing the Act. (Indeed, the Unruh Act expressly authorizes local public prosecutors to bring actions under the Unruh Act.) In short, while local officials are expressly authorized to bring actions against discrimination under the Unruh Act and related civil rights statutes, they cannot regulate and enforce the provisions of FEHA.
UCLA/Rand Study on DFEH Funding: In 2008, DFEH Director Phyllis Cheng commissioned a study in anticipation of the 50-year anniversary of FEHA (1959-2009), which eventually resulted in a 2010 UCLA/Rand report, entitled California Employment Discrimination Law and its Enforcement: The Fair Employment and Housing Act at 50. Among the many problems identified by the report was the "inadequate funding" that made it more difficult for CRD (then DFEH) to carry out its mission, and especially its capacity to investigate all of the complaints that it received. Three years later, a report prepared by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes also concluded that DFEH investigation and enforcement was hampered by a combination of "dwindling resources and increased demand." (California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes, Department of Fair Employment and Housing: Underfunding and Misguided Policies Compromise Civil Rights Mission, December 18, 2013.) In short, while FEHA is arguably one of the strongest and most progressive anti-discrimination laws in the country, the only entity empowered to enforce the law lacks the capacity, resources, and funding to fully carry out its ambitious mission.
Prior efforts to permit local enforcement: SB 491, the SB 491 Report, and SB 218. The UCLA/Rand and the Senate Office of Oversight and Outcome reports prompted calls to expand enforcement capacity in California by allowing local governments and agencies to enforce FEHA in the same way that local public prosecutors may enforce the Unruh Act. In 2017, Senator Bradford introduced SB 491. Early versions of the bill would have expressly permitted local enforcement of FEHA, notwithstanding the language stating legislative intent to “occupy the field.” Preemption prevents local governments from enacting their own laws and ordinances in the field expressly occupied by the state; it does not, however, prohibit local governments from enforcing state laws. However, as a practical matter, local governments cannot enforce FEHA, not so much because of preemption, but because the FEHA statute developed procedures that assigned the tasks of taking complaints, investigating complaints, and enforcing violations to DFEH or, today, CRD. Presumably, the state could preempt local governments from enacting their own ordinances, but still allow local governments to participate in enforcing state law. At times, the discussion around SB 491 – not unlike some of the discussion around the bill now before the Committee – conflates two distinct issues: the ability of local governments to enact their own housing and employment discrimination ordinances, on the one hand; and their ability to enforce state anti-discrimination laws, on the other hand. In addition to confusion around these issues, SB 491 also raised questions about allowing local governments to enforce a state law drafted with a single state enforcement agency in mind, as well as questions about whether all local governments would be as protective as DFEH in their enforcement of state law, or if local enforcement would diminish uniformity across the state, thus leaving rights to the happenstance of where one lived. In light of these and other questions, SB 491 was eventually amended to require DFEH to appoint an advisory group to study the feasibility of local enforcement of FEHA. Then-Governor Brown vetoed the measure, but nonetheless on his own authority ordered DFEH to study the issue and report back to the Governor and the Legislature.
The DFEH report on SB 491, published in 2018, provided an overview of the FEHA complaint and enforcement process, provided a short history of FEHA’s preemption clause, and laid out the options and prospects for local enforcement. The Report was short on specific recommendations, and instead offered this ambivalent assessment:
An effective mechanism for local enforcement of anti-discrimination laws could further advance the state’s efforts to combat discrimination. If not handled correctly, however, lifting of preemption could have significant negative consequences, including accidental forfeiture of state or federal rights. [DFEH. SB 491 Report (November, 2018), p. 3.]
The SB 491 Report concluded that lifting FEHA’s preemption clause would leave local jurisdictions with four options: “(1) They could do nothing at all; (2) they could enforce only state law; (3) they could promulgate and enforce local law; or (4) they could enforce state and local law.” The report only considered the second and fourth options, as most proposals focused on the feasibility of local enforcement of state law, as opposed to locals doing nothing or passing and enforcing their own laws. While the report conceded that local enforcement of FEHA was “feasible,” it nonetheless raised a number of potential consequences of local enforcement. Many of the concerns raised by the report were similar to those already raised about SB 491 by stakeholders and by various legislative committee analyses. First, some feared that allowing local enforcement could lead complainants (especially workers claiming employment discrimination) to lose state and federal rights if they filed their complaint with a local agency and, because of that, missed the deadline for filing state and federal claims. One solution to this danger was to follow the example of FEHA’s relationship with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), whereby when an employee files a complaint with DFEH, the agency files a complaint on that person’s behalf with EEOC. Conversely, when an employee files a complaint with EEOC, that agency files with DFEH. Presumably, any state law that allowed local enforcement should require filing a simultaneously report with the CRD.
Second, the report noted the possibility of inconsistent enforcement throughout the state. Different jurisdictions might enact very different local laws, and even where local governments enforced a uniform state law, they might adopt different practices and procedures. Third, the report warned that local enforcement, especially where an employee files with both the local agency and the state, could lead to duplicative, and thus inefficient, investigations. Presumably, this problem could be resolved by requiring communication, coordination, and some sort of work-sharing agreement between the state and the local jurisdiction, similar to those developed between the state and the federal EEOC. Finally, the report noted possible negative effects on statistics and reporting, as DFEH acted as a centralized source of information on the types and number of complaints, their demographic dimensions, and their outcomes. The report acknowledged that the Legislature could require local jurisdictions to report the same information that DFEH reports.
The following year, Senator Bradford introduced SB 218. That bill revised FEHA’s preemption language to “authorize the legislative body of a local government, located within the County of Los Angeles [presumably the City of Los Angeles] to enact a local antidiscrimination ordinances relating to employment, including establishing remedies and penalties for violations.” In short, rather than allowing a local government to enforce state law, it authorized Los Angeles to enact and enforce its own ordinance prohibiting employment discrimination. While supporters of SB 218 cited the parts of the SB 491 Report that acknowledged the benefits and feasibility of local enforcement, opponents of SB 218 latched on just as firmly to the report’s enumeration of unintended negative consequences. SB 218 passed out of both houses of the Legislature but was vetoed by Governor Newsom. In his veto message, Governor Newson wrote:
I am committed to combating and eradicating discrimination and have signed several measures this year to address discriminatory practices. However, I don't support lifting a preemption that has been in place for decades in the manner proposed in this bill. As crafted, this measure could create confusion, inconsistent enforcement of the law and increase costs without a corresponding increase in worker protections.
This bill leaves ambiguities about local governments' ability to enforce both local ordinances and FEHA. I invite the Legislature to come back with a measure that makes it clear that local enforcement measures are exclusively focused on local ordinances.
Will this bill avoid the fate of SB 491 and SB 218? The bill now before the Committee is apparently a response to the Governor’s invitation for the Legislature to come back with something better. In this regard, two points deserve attention. First, this bill is much broader than SB 218, which only applied to employment discrimination and only in Los Angeles. The bill under consideration applies statewide to both employment and housing discrimination. It is difficult to see how a broader bill will fare better than a narrowly tailored bill. Second, Governor Newsom’s message asked the Legislature to come back with a measure that “exclusively focused on local ordinances.” The bill under consideration does not do that; it would allow local agencies to enforce state law.
It is unclear how this broader, statewide bill, which allows local governments to enforce state law, instead of focusing exclusively on local ordinances, will garner a more favorable response from the same Governor. To be sure, this bill pays attention to many of the criticisms raised against previous bills by Governors Brown and Newsom in their veto messages. However, it does not resolve the issues so much as it punts to the CRD and hopes that it will resolve them when drafting regulations. As noted above, this bill directs CRD to adopt regulations that will (1) ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state; (2) protect claimants against inadvertent loss of state or federal claims; (3) avoid duplication of investigatory work; and (4) minimize any possible loss of federal funds for CRD’s work. Not surprisingly, this list summarizes the negative and unintended consequences raised in past iterations of this measure, and in the DFEH SB 491 Report. The bill does not resolve these concerns; rather, it directs CRD to adopt regulations that will address them.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Labor Federation (CLF) supports this bill because it will “clarify local governments are not restricted from enforcing California’s fair employment and housing laws to better protect Californians from discrimination.” CLF writes that the “pandemic laid bare the systemic inequities in housing, employment, health care, and other areas. . . The need for enforcement is more urgent than ever in the wake of the pandemic.” CLF contends that the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) receives thousands of complaints, and as such they “need every tool available to ensure robust enforcement of these critical laws.” CLF believes that “SB 16 will clarify this right of local agencies to enforce FEHA employment and housing protections, adding another layer of enforcement to support DFEH’s work. It will give Californians the option to file a claim with a local agency in lieu of filing with the state or federal agency. It also preserves workers’ state claims by creating a dual-filing process so that any charge filed with a local agency that raises a FEHA claim will also be filed with DFEH . . . SB 16 simply clarifies that local entities can enforce the Act, creating more tools to fight the scourge of discrimination in housing and employment-settings.”
The California Faculty Association (CFA) supports this bill because, even though the state has made “strides in securing civil rights for all out residents, yet we understand that gaps remain in enforcement due to capacity constraints. SB 16 provides a timely and potent solution to the ongoing issue of understaffed and overworked state-level enforcement bodies. . . With local authorities involved, not only can we expect faster resolution of discrimination cases, but also an increased sensitivity to local issues and concerns. By empowering local governments to enforce the FEHA's provisions, SB 16 offers an intelligent, efficient, and locally-sensitive approach to promoting fairness and equality in our society.”
Several organizations support this bill for substantially similar reasons.
Arguments in OppositioN. Several regional apartment associations opposed a prior version of this bill for the following reason: “SB 16 is a violation of the FEHA because it conflicts with general law. The Civil Rights Department is the only state department exclusively empowered with enforcement authority to prohibit discriminatory employment and housing practices identified within the California Civil Rights statutory scheme.” [NOTE: The bill in print requires CRD to adopt regulations governing local enforcement; it is unclear if this removes their opposition.]
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CA African American Chamber of Commerce
California Faculty Association
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California State Association of Counties
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
California Teachers Association
Greater Sacramento Urban League
Oakland Privacy
Protection of The Educational Rights for Kids
Southern California Black Worker Hub for Regional Organizing
Opposition (to a previous version of the bill)
Affordable Housing Management Association - Pacific Southwest
Apartment Association of Orange County
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Housing Contractors of California
Analysis Prepared by: Tom Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 16 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 16
Author: Smallwood-Cuevas (D)
Amended: 5/18/23
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-1, 3/28/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Wiener
NOES: Niello
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes local governments to enforce the housing and employment components of California’s state civil rights laws.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Makes it unlawful, pursuant to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, for employers with 15 or more employees to discriminate on the basis of race, color, sex, pregnancy status, religion, or national origin in all aspects of an employment relationship, including hiring, discharge, compensation, assignments, and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment. (42 U.S.C. 2000e et seq.)
- Establishes an administrative agency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), charged with receiving, investigating, and adjudicating allegations of workplace discrimination. (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-4.)
- Requires an aggrieved worker to exhaust the EEOC’s administrative remedies before filing an action for discrimination in court. (42 USCS § 2000e-5(f)(1).)
- Permits state or local agencies to accept and investigate allegations that federal workplace antidiscrimination laws have been violated, provided that the state or local agency has entered into a worksharing agreement with the EEOC that requires specified case-handling procedures and coordination with the EEOC such that filing with the state or local agency also constitutes filing with the EEOC (so-called “dual filing”). (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5(c).)
- Makes it unlawful, pursuant to the Fair Housing Act, for a provider of housing accommodations to discriminate in the sale or rental of housing, including against individuals seeking a mortgage or housing assistance, or in other housing-related activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation), familial status, and disability. (42 U.S.C. § 3604.)
- Provides that a federal administrative agency, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), shall receive and investigate complaints of housing discrimination. (42 U.S.C. § 3610(a).)
- Establishes procedures by which HUD may certify state and local public agencies to accept referrals of housing discrimination complaints for investigation and enforcement. (42 U.S.C. § 3610(f).)
- Does not require an aggrieved person to file an administrative complaint with HUD prior to filing a lawsuit for discrimination in court. (42 U.S.C. § 3613(a)(2).)
Existing state law:
- Prohibits workplace discrimination, as specified, on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status through the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). (Gov. Code § 12940.)
- Prohibits housing providers from discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, veteran or military status, or genetic information through the FEHA. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
- Establishes an administrative agency, the Civil Rights Department (CRD), responsible for receiving, investigating, and adjudicating allegations of housing and workplace discrimination under the FEHA. (Gov. Code § 12930.)
- Requires an aggrieved worker to exhaust CRD’s administrative remedies prior to filing a lawsuit in court for workplace discrimination. (Gov. Code §§ 12960 and 12965.)
- Permits aggrieved parties to petition the court of jurisdiction for review of administrative determinations. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1094.5.)
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to occupy the field of enforcing the FEHA’s prohibition on workplace discrimination to the exclusion of any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state. (Gov. Code § 12993(c)).
This bill:
- Authorizes, commencing on January 1, 2025, efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting housing or employment discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered by the FEHA, provided that the enforcement complies with regulations promulgated by the CRD, as specified.
- Provides that the regulations shall, at a minimum, do all of the following: ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state; protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims; avoid duplication of investigatory work; and minimize any possible loss of federal funding for the CRD’s work.
Comments
The issue this bill is intended to address
California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) is one of the strongest anti-discrimination laws in the nation. Its purpose is to prohibit and punish unequal treatment of any Californian on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin, disability, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, or sexual orientation, among other grounds, in the areas of housing and employment. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
California’s enforcement of the FEHA has sometimes been criticized, however. Existing law restricts the power to enforce the FEHA to the Civil Rights Department (formerly known as the Department of Fair Employment and Housing or DFEH).[1] Local governments are preempted from attempting such enforcement themselves.[2]
Responding to all of the civil rights concerns across one of the nation’s largest and most populous states presents an enormous challenge. According to a 2013 report by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes: “years of tight budgets have whittled away the state’s ability to protect workers and enforce the law.”[3] The report concluded that “[o]ver the long run, DFEH and state leaders must come to grips with the chasm between the broad legal mandate to provide effective remedies – including full investigations into all proper claims alleging discrimination – and the relatively miniscule allotment of resources appropriated for that purpose in the state budget.”[4] CRD has received some additional resources since that time, but its workload remains large and challenging.
In its 2020 Annual Report, CRD stated that it received just under 24,000 intake forms alleging discrimination throughout that year. In over half of these cases, the complainant elected to bypass CRD’s involvement and to proceed directly to court by requesting a right-to-sue letter. CRD went on to investigate the complaints in 5,784 cases. [5] The remaining intake forms involved complaints that CRD determined were outside of its jurisdiction (things like unpaid wages or overtime violations, for example), so CRD conducted no further investigation.
The author wants to see more investigation and enforcement, citing the need for “strong and swift enforcement of anti-discrimination laws.” As evidence of this need, the author points a recent survey of nearly 2,000 of Black workers in Southern California in which a third of respondents reported experiencing discrimination at work during the pandemic, of whom just under half were laid off or terminated and 16 percent were furloughed.[6] Of particular relevance to this bill, the majority of the surveyed workers indicated that they were not aware of what rights and recourses they have for addressing the employment discrimination they faced.[7]
From the perspective of the author and sponsors of this bill, the state’s reliance on CRD as the sole government agency enforcing FEHA raises other concerns as well. Even with offices in a few locations throughout the state, CRD can feel removed and impersonal to civil rights complainants.
According to the author:
Any form of discrimination robs people of their human dignity and often also of their financial stability and their health. When discrimination is allowed to ensue unchecked it also robs our communities of valuable opportunities to be better and to be stronger. Lack of enforcement of anti-discrimination laws is a problem that is well documented and if ever there were a time to reverse that pattern, it is now. SB 16 would do this by specifying nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination, and help ensure equity for all Californians.
In support, the California State Association of Counties writes:
[…] [T]he pervasiveness of discrimination throughout the state makes it difficult for a single state agency to bear the sole responsibility for enforcement. While municipalities and other local agencies could assist in the Act’s enforcement, there is no clear direction on whether local agencies actually have the authority to do so. SB 16 would specify that nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination and will help ensure equity for all.
In opposition to this bill, Housing Contractors of California writes:
[…] enforcement of complex laws requires significant training and experience by the enforcing agents. Having local jurisdictions join enforcement in discrimination claims will not promote enforcement, but cause more confusion. Laws should be enforced by those agencies who have committed the time and resources to train and vet their staff to effectively enforce the laws assigned to them. Agencies should stay in their lane of expertise. Discrimination claims should only be enforced by the California Civil Rights Department.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, staff notes significant one-time costs to the CRD)in addition to annual, ongoing costs in the low millions for numerous PY in 2025-26 and annually thereafter (General Fund).
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/19/23)
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Federation of Teachers, AFL-CIO
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California State Association of Counties
California Teachers Association
Oakland Privacy
Protection of Educational Rights for Kids
Service Employees International Union – California State Council
Southern California Black Worker Hub for Regional Organizing
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/19/23)
Affordable Housing Management Association – Pacific Southwest
Apartment Association of Orange County
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Housing Contractors of California
Prepared by: Margie Estrada / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/23/23 11:04:11
**** END ****
Gov. Code § 12993(c). Given the recent name change, the acronyms DFEH and CRD will be used interchangeably in this analysis based on the entity’s name at the time most relevant to the reference. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Korby & Adkisson. Department of Fair Employment and Housing: Underfunding and Misguided Policies Compromise Civil Rights Mission (Dec. 18, 2013) California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes https://sooo.senate.ca.gov/sites/sooo.senate.ca.gov/files/fair%20employment%20and%20housing%20final.pdf at p. 1 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Id. at pp. 1-2. ↑
2020 Annual Report. California Civil Rights Department https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2022/01/2020-DFEH-Annual-Report.pdf at p. 11 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Thomas et al. Essential Stories: Black Worker COVID-19 Economic Health Impact Survey (Feb. 2022) The UCLA Center for the Advancement of Racial Equity at Work https://www.labor.ucla.edu/publication/essential-stories-black-worker-covid-19-economic-health-impact-survey/ at p. 6 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Ibid. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 16 (Smallwood-Cuevas) - Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement
Version: March 30, 2023 | Policy Vote: JUD. 9 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 18, 2023 | Consultant: Matthew Fleming |
Bill Summary:
SB 16 would authorize local governments to enforce the housing and employment components of California’s state civil rights laws.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 18, 2023
Fiscal Impact:
Staff notes significant one-time costs to the Civil Rights Department (CRD) in addition to annual, ongoing costs in the low millions for numerous PY in 2025-26 and annually thereafter (General Fund).
Committee Amendments:
- Specify that the regulations promulgated by the CRD shall minimize any possible loss of federal funding for the department’s work.
- Delay implementation until January 1, 2025.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 16 (Smallwood-Cuevas) - Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement
Version: March 30, 2023 | Policy Vote: JUD. 9 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 17, 2023 | Consultant: Matthew Fleming |
Bill Summary:
SB 16 would authorize local governments to enforce the housing and employment components of California’s state civil rights laws.
Fiscal Impact:
The Civil Rights Department (CRD) reports significant unknown costs in addition to approximately $1.2 million for 6.0 PY in 2024-25 and $2.75 million for 14.0 PY in 2025-26 and annually thereafter (General Fund). See Staff Comments for additional detail.
Background:
California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) is one of the strongest anti-discrimination laws in the nation. Its purpose is to prohibit and punish unequal treatment of any Californian on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin, disability, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, or sexual orientation, among other grounds, in the areas of housing and employment. Existing law restricts the power to enforce the FEHA to the Civil Rights Department (formerly known as the Department of Fair Employment and Housing or DFEH). Local governments are preempted from attempting such enforcement themselves.
Over the years, CRD’s enforcement of FEHA has been criticized as underwhelming. SB 491 (Bradford, 2018) sought to address that by eliminating FEHA’s provision preempting local enforcement. There were questions, however, about the potential ramifications of making such a move. Those included the potential loss of claims for otherwise eligible complainants, unequal enforcement of the laws across the state with perhaps even weaker protections being afforded to California residents in certain parts of the States, and a loss of federal funding to the already limited resources of the CRD (or, the DFEH as it was known at that time). As a result, SB 491 was ultimately converted into a mandate for a task force to study the matter and return to the Legislature with recommended legislation. While he vetoed SB 491, then Governor Brown embraced its intent and ordered DFEH to convene an advisory group to study the concept of local civil rights enforcement.
After the advisory group concluded its work, DFEH released the resulting report on December 5, 2018. The report concluded that “DFEH and the advisory group find that local enforcement of anti-discrimination laws is feasible.” Indeed the report stated that “[a]n effective mechanism for local enforcement of anti-discrimination employment laws could further advance the state’s efforts to combat discrimination.” At the same time, however, the report warned that “[i]f not handled correctly […], lifting of preemption could have significant negative consequences, including accidental forfeiture of state or federal rights. Similar to the original version of SB 491, this bill would lift the preemption of SB 491 and allow for local enforcement of the FEHA.
Proposed Law:
- Authorizes efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting housing or employment discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered by the FEHA.
- Requires CRD to promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing by an unspecified date.
- Requires the regulations to 1) ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state, 2) protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims, and 3) avoid duplication of investigatory work.
Related Legislation:
- SB 218 (Bradford, 2019) would have authorized local governments within the County of Los Angeles to enact and enforce workplace anti-discrimination laws, including establishing remedies and penalties for violations, subject to specified procedural requirements. SB 218 was vetoed by Governor Newsom.
- SB 491 (Bradford, 2017) would have directed CRD to convene a group of experts and stakeholders to study the ramifications of authorizing local enforcement of FEHA and to report back to the Legislature with findings and draft legislation. Governor Brown vetoed SB 491 but directed CRD to create an advisory group to explore the matter and report back by December 31, 2018.
- AB 2534 (Shelley, 2000) would have provided that local governments are not pre-empted from providing or maintaining greater protections against discrimination than FEHA. AB 2534 died in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Staff Comments:
SB 16 would require the CRD to promulgate regulations that ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state. Such regulations are likely to be complex, as they will require the CRD to address numerous issues pointed out in the 2018 DFEH report. SB 16 will require the coordination of multiple state, local, and federal agencies including the United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Potential complications include the possibility for loss of state and federal discrimination claims for eligible parties, a risk of inconsistent civil rights enforcement across the State, inefficient and conflicting duplication of work that result in result in contradictory outcomes, and a loss of revenue to the CRD for cases that would have been dual filed with the EEOC or HUD, and instead are filed with local agencies.
Implementation of SB 16 will likely require the negotiation of legal agreements between CRD and local enforcement agencies, ongoing oversight of local enforcement agencies, providing ongoing technical assistance to localities, and more. In order to accomplish these tasks and promulgate the regulations described above, CRD anticipates needing a minimum total of 14.0 permanent positions. Those include 9.0 attorney positions of varying classification and 1.0 legal secretary, 1.0 Associate Governmental Program Analyst, 1.0 Human Resources position, and 2.0 IT positions.
-- END --
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 16 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 16
Author: Smallwood-Cuevas (D)
Amended: 3/30/23
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-1, 3/28/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Wiener
NOES: Niello
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SUBJECT: Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes local governments to enforce the housing and employment components of California’s state civil rights laws.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Makes it unlawful, pursuant to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, for employers with 15 or more employees to discriminate on the basis of race, color, sex, pregnancy status, religion, or national origin in all aspects of an employment relationship, including hiring, discharge, compensation, assignments, and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment. (42 U.S.C. 2000e et seq.)
- Establishes an administrative agency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), charged with receiving, investigating, and adjudicating allegations of workplace discrimination. (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-4.)
- Requires an aggrieved worker to exhaust the EEOC’s administrative remedies before filing an action for discrimination in court. (42 USCS § 2000e-5(f)(1).)
- Permits state or local agencies to accept and investigate allegations that federal workplace antidiscrimination laws have been violated, provided that the state or local agency has entered into a worksharing agreement with the EEOC that requires specified case-handling procedures and coordination with the EEOC such that filing with the state or local agency also constitutes filing with the EEOC (so-called “dual filing”). (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5(c).)
- Makes it unlawful, pursuant to the Fair Housing Act, for a provider of housing accommodations to discriminate in the sale or rental of housing, including against individuals seeking a mortgage or housing assistance, or in other housing-related activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation), familial status, and disability. (42 U.S.C. § 3604.)
- Provides that a federal administrative agency, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), shall receive and investigate complaints of housing discrimination. (42 U.S.C. § 3610(a).)
- Establishes procedures by which HUD may certify state and local public agencies to accept referrals of housing discrimination complaints for investigation and enforcement. (42 U.S.C. § 3610(f).)
- Does not require an aggrieved person to file an administrative complaint with HUD prior to filing a lawsuit for discrimination in court. (42 U.S.C. § 3613(a)(2).)
Existing state law:
- Prohibits workplace discrimination, as specified, on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status through the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). (Gov. Code § 12940.)
- Prohibits housing providers from discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, veteran or military status, or genetic information through the FEHA. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
- Establishes an administrative agency, the Civil Rights Department (CRD), responsible for receiving, investigating, and adjudicating allegations of housing and workplace discrimination under the FEHA. (Gov. Code § 12930.)
- Requires an aggrieved worker to exhaust CRD’s administrative remedies prior to filing a lawsuit in court for workplace discrimination. (Gov. Code §§ 12960 and 12965.)
- Permits aggrieved parties to petition the court of jurisdiction for review of administrative determinations. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1094.5.)
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to occupy the field of enforcing the FEHA’s prohibition on workplace discrimination to the exclusion of any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state. (Gov. Code § 12993(c)).
This bill:
- Directs the CRD, by a date to be specified, to promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of FEHA that, at a minimum, do all of the following:
- Ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state;
- Protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims; and
- Void duplication of investigatory work.
- Authorizes efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting housing or employment discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered by the FEHA, provided that such enforcement complies with the regulations issued pursuant to (1), above.
Comments
The issue this bill is intended to address
California’s FEHA is one of the strongest anti-discrimination laws in the nation. Its purpose is to prohibit and punish unequal treatment of any Californian on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin, disability, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, or sexual orientation, among other grounds, in the areas of housing and employment. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
California’s enforcement of the FEHA has sometimes been criticized, however. Existing law restricts the power to enforce the FEHA to the Civil Rights Department (formerly known as the Department of Fair Employment and Housing or DFEH).[1] Local governments are preempted from attempting such enforcement themselves.[2]
Responding to all of the civil rights concerns across one of the nation’s largest and most populous states presents an enormous challenge. According to a 2013 report by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes: “years of tight budgets have whittled away the state’s ability to protect workers and enforce the law.”[3] The report concluded that “[o]ver the long run, DFEH and state leaders must come to grips with the chasm between the broad legal mandate to provide effective remedies – including full investigations into all proper claims alleging discrimination – and the relatively miniscule allotment of resources appropriated for that purpose in the state budget.”[4] CRD has received some additional resources since that time, but its workload remains large and challenging.
In its 2020 Annual Report, CRD stated that it received just under 24,000 intake forms alleging discrimination throughout that year. In over half of these cases, the complainant elected to bypass CRD’s involvement and to proceed directly to court by requesting a right-to-sue letter. CRD went on to investigate the complaints in 5,784 cases. [5] The remaining intake forms involved complaints that CRD determined were outside of its jurisdiction (things like unpaid wages or overtime violations, for example), so CRD conducted no further investigation.
The author wants to see more investigation and enforcement, citing the need for “strong and swift enforcement of anti-discrimination laws.” As evidence of this need, the author points a recent survey of nearly 2,000 of Black workers in Southern California in which a third of respondents reported experiencing discrimination at work during the pandemic, of whom just under half were laid off or terminated and 16 percent were furloughed.[6] Of particular relevance to this bill, the majority of the surveyed workers indicated that they were not aware of what rights and recourses they have for addressing the employment discrimination they faced.[7]
From the perspective of the author and supporters of this bill, the State’s reliance on CRD as the sole government agency enforcing FEHA raises other concerns as well. Even with offices in a few locations throughout the state, CRD can feel removed and impersonal to civil rights complainants.
Primary concerns associated with local enforcement of FEHA and the bill’s proposed method for addressing them
Previous legislative attempts to open up civil rights enforcement to local jurisdictions have surfaced a number of issues that need to be addressed in order to avoid unintended negative consequences. The most significant of those issues are: (1) the danger that people submitting local complaints alleging civil rights violations might inadvertently lose their state and federal discrimination claims; (2) the risk of inconsistent civil rights enforcement across the state; (3) the potential for inefficient or even conflicting duplication of work; and (4) the possibility of partial loss of federal revenue for CRD. Each issue is described in greater detail in the Senate Judiciary Committee analysis of this bill.
This bill addresses at least the first three of these concerns in two steps. First, the bill directs CRD to promulgate regulations to govern any local enforcement of the FEHA and mandates that those regulations are to address the concerns mentioned. Second, this bill requires any local civil rights enforcement regime to adhere to these regulations.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 4/6/23)
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Labor Federation
California State Association of Counties
Oakland Privacy
Service Employees International Union – California State Council
Southern California Black Worker Hub for Regional Organizing
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/6/23)
Affordable Housing Management Association – Pacific Southwest
Apartment Association of Orange County
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Housing Contractors of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
Any form of discrimination robs people of their human dignity and often also of their financial stability and their health. When discrimination is allowed to ensue unchecked it also robs our communities of valuable opportunities to be better and to be stronger. Lack of enforcement of anti-discrimination laws is a problem that is well documented and if ever there were a time to reverse that pattern, it is now. SB 16 would do this by specifying nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination, and help ensure equity for all Californians.
In support, the California State Association of Counties writes:
[…] [T]he pervasiveness of discrimination throughout the state makes it difficult for a single state agency to bear the sole responsibility for enforcement. While municipalities and other local agencies could assist in the Act’s enforcement, there is no clear direction on whether local agencies actually have the authority to do so. SB 16 would specify that nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination and will help ensure equity for all.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, Housing Contractors of California writes:
[…] enforcement of complex laws requires significant training and experience by the enforcing agents. Having local jurisdictions join enforcement in discrimination claims will not promote enforcement, but cause more confusion. Laws should be enforced by those agencies who have committed the time and resources to train and vet their staff to effectively enforce the laws assigned to them. Agencies should stay in their lane of expertise. Discrimination claims should only be enforced by the California Civil Rights Department.
Prepared by: Margie Estrada / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
4/6/23 10:59:31
**** END ****
Gov. Code § 12993(c). Given the recent name change, the acronyms DFEH and CRD will be used interchangeably in this analysis based on the entity’s name at the time most relevant to the reference. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Korby & Adkisson. Department of Fair Employment and Housing: Underfunding and Misguided Policies Compromise Civil Rights Mission (Dec. 18, 2013) California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes https://sooo.senate.ca.gov/sites/sooo.senate.ca.gov/files/fair%20employment%20and%20housing%20final.pdf at p. 1 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Id. at pp. 1-2. ↑
2020 Annual Report. California Civil Rights Department https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2022/01/2020-DFEH-Annual-Report.pdf at p. 11 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Thomas et al. Essential Stories: Black Worker COVID-19 Economic Health Impact Survey (Feb. 2022) The UCLA Center for the Advancement of Racial Equity at Work https://www.labor.ucla.edu/publication/essential-stories-black-worker-covid-19-economic-health-impact-survey/ at p. 6 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Ibid. ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 16 (Author:Smallwood-Cuevas)
Version: December 5, 2022
Hearing Date: March 28, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Civil rights: discrimination: enforcement
DIGEST
This bill authorizes local governments to enforce the housing and employment components of California’s state civil rights laws.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) protects Californians against discrimination in the workplace and with respect to their housing. Under existing law, only the state may enforce the FEHA. Local governments cannot. The State enforces the FEHA through the Civil Rights Department (CRD). With limited resources and a handful of offices throughout the state, CRD must process around 24,000 complaints alleging discrimination annually and investigates about a quarter of them. With the aim of fortifying California’s civil rights enforcement regime and bringing it closer to the people it is designed to protect, this bill would authorize – but not require – local governments to undertake enforcement of the FEHA.
The bill is author-sponsored. Support comes from a variety of organizations who back the possibility of expanding civil rights enforcement locally. Opposition comes from some housing providers who contend that only CRD has the requisite capabilities to enforce state civil rights law well. If the bill passes out of this Committee, it is currently slated to be heard next on the Senate Floor, though amendments that the author proposes to offer in Committee would trigger a referral to the Senate Appropriations Committee first.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Makes it unlawful, pursuant to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, for employers with 15 or more employees to discriminate on the basis of race, color, sex, pregnancy status, religion, or national origin in all aspects of an employment relationship, including hiring, discharge, compensation, assignments, and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment. (42 U.S.C. 2000e et seq.)
- Establishes an administrative agency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), charged with receiving, investigating, and adjudicating allegations of workplace discrimination. (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-4.)
- Requires an aggrieved worker to exhaust the EEOC’s administrative remedies before filing an action for discrimination in court. (42 USCS § 2000e-5(f)(1).)
- Permits state or local agencies to accept and investigate allegations that federal workplace antidiscrimination laws have been violated, provided that the state or local agency has entered into a worksharing agreement with the EEOC that requires specified case-handling procedures and coordination with the EEOC such that filing with the state or local agency also constitutes filing with the EEOC (so-called “dual filing”). (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-5(c).)
5) Makes it unlawful, pursuant to the Fair Housing Act, for a provider of housing accommodations to discriminate in the sale or rental of housing, including against individuals seeking a mortgage or housing assistance, or in other housing-related activities on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation), familial status, and disability. (42 U.S.C. § 3604.)
6) Provides that a federal administrative agency, the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), shall receive and investigate complaints of housing discrimination. (42 U.S.C. § 3610(a).)
7) Establishes procedures by which HUD may certify state and local public agencies to accept referrals of housing discrimination complaints for investigation and enforcement. (42 U.S.C. § 3610(f).)
8) Does not require an aggrieved person to file an administrative complaint with HUD prior to filing a lawsuit for discrimination in court. (42 U.S.C. § 3613(a)(2).)
Existing state law:
- Prohibits workplace discrimination, as specified, on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status through the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). (Gov. Code § 12940.)
- Prohibits housing providers from discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, veteran or military status, or genetic information through the FEHA. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
- Establishes an administrative agency, the Civil Rights Department (CRD), responsible for receiving, investigating, and adjudicating allegations of housing and workplace discrimination under the FEHA. (Gov. Code § 12930.)
- Requires an aggrieved worker to exhaust CRD’s administrative remedies prior to filing a lawsuit in court for workplace discrimination. (Gov. Code §§ 12960 and 12965.)
- Permits aggrieved parties to petition the court of jurisdiction for review of administrative determinations. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1094.5.)
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature to occupy the field of enforcing the FEHA’s prohibition on workplace discrimination to the exclusion of any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state. (Gov. Code § 12993(c)).
This bill:
- Authorizes efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting housing or employment discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered by the FEHA.
COMMENTS
- The issue this bill is intended to address
California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) is one of the strongest anti-discrimination laws in the nation. Its purpose is to prohibit and punish unequal treatment of any Californian on the basis of race, religion, color, national origin, disability, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, or sexual orientation, among other grounds, in the areas of housing and employment. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
California’s enforcement of the FEHA has sometimes been criticized, however. Existing law restricts the power to enforce the FEHA to the Civil Rights Department (formerly known as the Department of Fair Employment and Housing or DFEH).[1] Local governments are preempted from attempting such enforcement themselves.[2]
Responding to all of the civil rights concerns across one of the nation’s largest and most populous states presents an enormous challenge. According to a 2013 report by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes: “years of tight budgets have whittled away the state’s ability to protect workers and enforce the law.”[3] The report concluded that “[o]ver the long run, DFEH and state leaders must come to grips with the chasm between the broad legal mandate to provide effective remedies – including full investigations into all proper claims alleging discrimination – and the relatively miniscule allotment of resources appropriated for that purpose in the state budget.”[4] CRD has received some additional resources since that time, but its workload remains large and challenging.
In its 2020 Annual Report, CRD stated that it received just under 24,000 intake forms alleging discrimination throughout that year. In over half of these cases, the complainant elected to bypass CRD’s involvement and to proceed directly to court by requesting a right-to-sue letter. CRD went on to investigate the complaints in 5,784 cases. [5] The remaining intake forms involved complaints that CRD determined were outside of its jurisdiction (things like unpaid wages or overtime violations, for example), so CRD conducted no further investigation.
The author wants to see more investigation and enforcement, citing the need for “strong and swift enforcement of anti-discrimination laws.” As evidence of this need, the author points a recent survey of nearly 2,000 of Black workers in Southern California in which a third of respondents reported experiencing discrimination at work during the pandemic, of whom just under half were laid off or terminated and 16 percent were furloughed.[6] Of particular relevance to this bill, the majority of the surveyed workers indicated that they were not aware of what rights and recourses they have for addressing the employment discrimination they faced.[7]
From the perspective of the author and sponsors of this bill, the State’s reliance on CRD as the sole government agency enforcing FEHA raises other concerns as well. Even with offices in a few locations throughout the state, CRD can feel removed and impersonal to civil rights complainants.
2. The initial legislative effort to enable local enforcement of civil rights (SB 491, Bradford, 2017) and the resulting advisory group study
Looking for a way to boost California civil rights enforcement and bring civil rights enforcement closer to the people it affects, in 2017 Senator Bradford introduced SB 491. As introduced, SB 491 simply called for eliminating FEHA’s provision preempting local enforcement. There was some question, however, about the potential ramifications of making such a move. Could the blanket removal of the bar on local enforcement inadvertently cause some complainants to lose state or federal causes of action? Could it result in inconsistent enforcement of civil rights laws across the state and even allow for weaker civil rights protections in some parts of the state? Might DFEH lose some of its already limited resources as a result of lifting preemption?[8]
With these and other questions in mind, the author of SB 491 ultimately opted to convert the bill into a mandate for a task force to study the matter and return to the Legislature with recommended legislation. While he vetoed SB 491, then Governor Brown embraced its intent and ordered DFEH to convene an advisory group to study the concept of local civil rights enforcement.
3. The SB 491 advisory group report on local enforcement of FEHA
In response to the orders from Governor Brown, DFEH assembled an advisory group of seven stakeholders and experts to study how local civil rights enforcement could be carried out. In addition to the author of this bill, the advisory group included a law professor, a labor lawyer, an official from the City of Los Angeles, worker advocates, and a representative from the California Chamber of Commerce.
After the advisory group concluded its work, DFEH released the resulting report on December 5, 2018. The report concluded that “DFEH and the advisory group find that local enforcement of anti-discrimination laws is feasible.”[9] Indeed the report stated that “[a]n effective mechanism for local enforcement of anti-discrimination employment laws could further advance the state’s efforts to combat discrimination.” At the same time, however, the report warned that “[i]f not handled correctly […], lifting of preemption could have significant negative consequences, including accidental forfeiture of state or federal rights.[10]
The report went on to list a series of additional technical considerations that should be taken into account in the design of legislation authorizing local enforcement.[11]
4. Primary concerns associated with local enforcement of FEHA
The SB 491 report and analysis of the other previous legislative attempts to open up civil rights enforcement to local jurisdictions have raised a number of issues that need to be addressed in order to avoid unintended negative consequences. The most significant of those issues are briefly described below.
a. Danger of loss of state and federal discrimination claims
Housing and employment discrimination often violates both state and federal law. The aggrieved person therefore has the option of seeking relief from either the state agency tasked with enforcing state civil rights laws, or the corresponding federal agency. To complicate matters, there are different filing deadlines for state and federal complaints.
Under current practices in California, when an aggrieved person files a claim with CRD and the claim alleges a violation of both state and federal civil rights laws, CRD automatically files the claim with the EEOC (employment discrimination) or HUD (housing discrimination) as well. The same thing happens in reverse: if the claim alleges violations of both state and federal laws but the person files the claim with the relevant federal agency, the relevant federal agency automatically files the claim with DFEH as well. This process is known as dual filing.
Dual filing happens because of worksharing agreements that CRD, HUD and the EEOC have with one another. Dual-filing acts to ensure that complainants do not lose state claims when they file federally, and vice versa.
If state preemption were lifted in California and local agencies also began to receive allegations of housing and employment discrimination, that change would add an additional layer of complexity. For example, in a case involving violation of a local ordinance, state law, and federal law, the state and federal agencies might never know about the claim if the aggrieved person filed their complaint with the local agency only. The aggrieved person might lose the opportunity to seek state and federal remedies as a result.
b. Risk of inconsistent civil rights enforcement across the state
Another concern about simply lifting preemption is that it might lead to inconsistent workplace civil rights enforcement across the state. While the language of FEHA would remain the same, a local anti-discrimination agency in Modoc County, for example, might interpret that language differently from an anti-discrimination agency in San Francisco. The resulting inconsistencies could be confusing and might also contribute to the politicization of civil rights enforcement.
Beyond interpreting the FEHA, the quality of investigation of complaints might diverge. Some local jurisdictions might decide to develop and invest in quite robust local anti-discrimination enforcement agencies, while other jurisdictions might not. Indeed, given the cost associated with operating a local civil rights enforcement agency, it seems likely that only the largest cities will have the resources available to consider it.
c. Potential for inefficient or even conflicting duplication of work
Lifting preemption without some formal coordination between local and state workplace civil rights enforcement could leave open the possibility that multiple investigations of the same allegation would take place at various levels of government. In addition to being an efficient use of public resources, simultaneous investigations by multiple agencies would be burdensome for complainants and defendants alike. In some instances, simultaneous investigations might even result in contradictory outcomes, with one agency exonerating the defendant while the other comes to the conclusion that a civil rights violation has indeed taken place.
d. Possibility of partial loss of federal revenue for CRD
Authorizing local enforcement of state civil rights laws has the potential to disrupt some of the funding that CRD relies on for its civil rights enforcement work. CRD receives some federal funds for its work based on the agreements it has with its federal counterparts, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development as well as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Turning some of CRD’s work over to local entities could have impacts on that federal funding. That could, potentially, lead to less enforcement overall.
5. Statutory or regulatory path forward?
Given the conclusions of the SB 491 report and the considerations set forth in Comment 4, above, this much seems clear: if the potential benefits of local enforcement of employment and housing civil rights laws are to be realized without risking harmful unintended consequences, then the local enforcement will need to take place within a legal framework that anticipates and addresses those concerns.
The bill in print does not provide such a framework. That is deliberate but should not be taken as an indication that the author believes no such framework is necessary. Rather, the absence from the bill in print of a legal framework for coordinating the processing of federal, state, and local housing and employment discrimination complaint reflects the author’s openness to considering various approaches to constructing this framework.
One obvious path forward would be to follow the approach taken by Senator Bradford with his bill SB 218 in 2020. SB 218 established a statutory framework allowing for local enforcement of statewide civil rights standards. It accomplished that aim in three steps. First, SB 218 removed language in existing law that preempts local jurisdictions from enforcing workplace civil rights laws. Next, the bill authorized local governments to enact local workplace civil rights ordinances that are at least as strong as FEHA and to establish local government agencies charged with enforcing those ordinances. Finally, in its third step, SB 218 laid out all the ways that a local workplace civil rights agency would interact with CRD and the EEOC when processing allegations of workplace civil rights violations. SB 218’s mechanisms were complex, but in concert, they were intended to address all of the issues set forth in Comment 4, above. (For a detailed description of SB 218’s content, see Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of SB 218 (2019-2020 Reg. Sess.) as amended Apr. 9, 2019, pp. 4-5.) Unlike this bill, SB 218 would only have applied to the employment discrimination side of FEHA and, in its final versions, would only have authorized local enforcement within the County of Los Angeles.
Ultimately, however, Governor Newsom elected to veto SB 218, concluding that “[a]s crafted, this measure could create confusion, inconsistent enforcement of the law and increase costs without a corresponding increase in worker protections.” As a result, any attempt to build a statutory framework for governing local enforcement of the FEHA will presumably either involve revising the framework proposed by SB 218 or starting fresh.
An alternative approach would be to establish clear parameters for what the Legislature wants the legal framework for local civil rights enforcement to achieve, but leave the details to CRD to develop through the regulatory process. There are, arguably, at least two main virtues to this approach. First, it allows the Legislature to ensure that its primary objectives and concerns are addressed while leaving the technicalities in the hands of the administrative agency that is best equipped to understand all of the nuances and that will ultimately be tasked with implementation. Second, proceeding through the regulatory process will enable stakeholders to continue to engage in the realization of this idea through testimony and public comment.
With these considerations in mind, the author proposes to offer amendments in Committee that adopt the regulatory approach for the time being. Should a statutory approach emerge during the legislative process that satisfies both legislators and the Governor alike, then the author has the option of going in that direction with the bill instead.
6. Models of local civil rights enforcement from elsewhere
A “Fair Employment Practice Agency,” or “FEPA,” is a government agency tasked with enforcing workplace civil rights laws through worksharing agreements with the EEOC that include dual filing. Most states have a statewide FEPA. In California, the statewide FEPA is CRD.
Because of the preemption that this bill would lift, there are no local FEPAs in California.[12] Elsewhere in the country however, local FEPAs are common. In its SB 491 report, DFEH’s advisory group identified about 50 local jurisdictions across the country with FEPAs, including major cities like Baltimore, Philadelphia, New York, Miami, and Seattle.[13]
While there is ample precedent for local FEPAs, however, the SB 491 advisory group’s report did not find any examples where local FEPAs enforced state anti-discrimination laws. Instead, the local FEPAs generally enforce ordinances specific to their local jurisdiction.[14] The local civil right enforcement proposed by this bill diverges from that pattern by allowing local governments to enforce the FEHA itself.
7. Proposed amendments
In order to address the issues set forth in the Comments, above, the author proposes to incorporate amendments into the bill that would:
- direct the Civil Rights Department to promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of FEHA by a date to be specified and in accordance with specified guidance; and
- require local jurisdictions that choose to pursue local enforcement of FEHA to proceed according to those regulations.
A mock-up of the amendments in context is attached to this analysis.
8. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
Any form of discrimination robs people of their human dignity and often also of their financial stability and their health. When discrimination is allowed to ensue unchecked it also robs our communities of valuable opportunities to be better and to be stronger. Lack of enforcement of anti-discrimination laws is a problem that is well documented and if ever there were a time to reverse that pattern, it is now. SB 16 would do this by specifying nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination, and help ensure equity for all Californians.
In support, the California State Association of Counties writes:
[…] [T]he pervasiveness of discrimination throughout the state makes it difficult for a single state agency to bear the sole responsibility for enforcement. While municipalities and other local agencies could assist in the Act’s enforcement, there is no clear direction on whether local agencies actually have the authority to do so. SB 16 would specify that nothing in the FEHA restricts the ability of local agencies from enforcing the Act’s provisions. This will expand the number of agencies actively addressing the problem of workplace and housing discrimination and will help ensure equity for all.
9. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, Housing Contractors of California writes:
[…] enforcement of complex laws requires significant training and experience by the enforcing agents. Having local jurisdictions join enforcement in discrimination claims will not promote enforcement, but cause more confusion. Laws should be enforced by those agencies who have committed the time and resources to train and vet their staff to effectively enforce the laws assigned to them. Agencies should stay in their lane of expertise. Discrimination claims should only be enforced by the California Civil Rights Department.
SUPPORT
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California State Association of Counties
Oakland Privacy
Service Employees International Union – California State Council
OPPOSITION
Affordable Housing Management Association – Pacific Southwest
Apartment Association of Orange County
East Bay Rental Housing Association
Housing Contractors of California
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 218 (Bradford, 2019) would have authorized local governments within the County of Los Angeles to enact and enforce workplace anti-discrimination laws, including establishing remedies and penalties for violations, subject to specified procedural requirements. In his message vetoing SB 218, Governor Newsom wrote that: “I am committed to combating and eradicating discrimination […]. However, I don’t support lifting a preemption that has been in place for decades in the manner proposed in this bill. As crafted, this measure could create confusion, inconsistent enforcement of the law and increase costs without a corresponding increase in worker protections. This bill leaves ambiguities about local governments’ ability to enforce both local ordinances and FEHA.” The Governor went on to invite the Legislature to “come back with a measure that makes it clear that local enforcement measures are exclusively focused on local ordinances.”
SB 491 (Bradford, 2017) would have directed CRD to convene a group of experts and stakeholders to study the ramifications of authorizing local enforcement of FEHA and to report back to the Legislature with findings and draft legislation. In his message vetoing SB 491, then Governor Brown wrote that he agreed with the author “that it is time for the state to reassess whether the state should allow local authorities to enforce FEHA,” but that the bill as drafted was too broad. He directed CRD to create
an advisory group to explore the matter and report back by December 31, 2018.
AB 2534 (Shelley, 2000) would have provided that local governments are not pre-empted from providing or maintaining greater protections against discrimination than FEHA. AB 2534 died in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
**************
Amended Mock-up for 2023-2024 SB-16 (Smallwood-Cuevas (S))
Mock-up based on Version Number 99 - Introduced 12/5/22
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 12993 of the Government Code, as amended by Section 9 of Chapter 630 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:
12993. (a) The provisions of this part shall be construed liberally for the accomplishment of the purposes of this part. This part does not repeal any of the provisions of civil rights law or of any other law of this state relating to discrimination because of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, age, reproductive health decisionmaking, or sexual orientation, unless those provisions provide less protection to the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part.
(b) The provisions in this part relating to discrimination in employment on account of sex or medical condition do not affect the operation of the terms or conditions of any bona fide retirement, pension, employee benefit, or insurance plan, provided the terms or conditions are in accordance with customary and reasonable or actuarially sound underwriting practices.
(c)(1) It is the intention of the Legislature to occupy the field of regulation of discrimination in employment and housing encompassed by the provisions of this part, exclusive of all other laws banning discrimination in employment and housing by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state.
(2) Notwithstanding paragraph (1), this part does not limit or restrict the application of Section 51 of the Civil Code.
(3)(A) Notwithstanding paragraph (1), this part does notlimit or restrict efforts by any city, city and county, county, or other political subdivision of the state to enforce state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing, provided that such enforcement complies with the regulations promulgated pursuant to subparagraph (B).
(B) Pursuant to its authority under subdivision (e) of section 12930, the department shall promulgate regulations governing local enforcement of state law prohibiting discrimination against any of the enumerated classes of persons covered under this part in employment and housing by_______. The regulations shall, at a minimum, do all of the following:
(i) Ensure consistent application of employment and housing discrimination laws across the state.
(ii) Protect complainants against inadvertent loss of federal or state legal claims.
(iii) Avoid duplication of investigatory work.
Gov. Code § 12993(c). Given the recent name change, the acronyms DFEH and CRD will be used interchangeably in this analysis based on the entity’s name at the time most relevant to the reference. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Korby & Adkisson. Department of Fair Employment and Housing: Underfunding and Misguided Policies Compromise Civil Rights Mission (Dec. 18, 2013) California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes https://sooo.senate.ca.gov/sites/sooo.senate.ca.gov/files/fair%20employment%20and%20housing%20final.pdf at p. 1 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Id. at pp. 1-2. ↑
2020 Annual Report. California Civil Rights Department https://calcivilrights.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2022/01/2020-DFEH-Annual-Report.pdf at p. 11 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Thomas et al. Essential Stories: Black Worker COVID-19 Economic Health Impact Survey (Feb. 2022) The UCLA Center for the Advancement of Racial Equity at Work https://www.labor.ucla.edu/publication/essential-stories-black-worker-covid-19-economic-health-impact-survey/ at p. 6 (as of Mar. 10, 2023). ↑
Ibid. ↑
Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of SB 491 (2017-2018 Reg. Sess.) as amended May 1, 2017, pp. 4-5. ↑
SB 491 Report (2018) California Department of Fair Employment and Housing https://www.dfeh.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2018/12/SB491Report2018.pdf (as of Apr.14, 2019) at p. 4. ↑
Id. at p. 3. ↑
Id. at pp. 9-18. ↑
The San Francisco Human Rights Commission investigates allegations of discrimination within that city and county. However, its jurisdiction is explicitly limited to “all incidents of discrimination within the scope of this ordinance to the extent such functions are not within the exclusive responsibilities of the
California Fair Employment Practices Commission or any federal or other State agency.” (San Francisco Administrative Code § 12A.5(g).) ↑
SB 491 Report (2018) California Department of Fair Employment and Housing https://www.dfeh.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2018/12/SB491Report2018.pdf (as of Mar. 11, 2023) at p. 9. ↑
Id. at 10. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):