SB 274: Suspensions and expulsions: willful defiance: interventions and supports.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-08
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-08: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 597, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Existing law prohibits a pupil from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act from a list of specified acts, including, among other acts, disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law authorizes a teacher to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following.
Existing law prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and recommending the expulsion of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of those school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law, until July 1, 2025, prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for those acts. Existing law applies these same provisions to charter schools.
This bill would extend the prohibition against the suspension of pupils enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, including those pupils enrolled in a charter school, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties to all grades, by 4 years to instead be until July 1, 2029, and, commencing July 1, 2024, would prohibit the suspension of pupils enrolled in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, including those pupils enrolled in a charter school, for those acts until July 1, 2029, but would retain a teachers existing authorization to suspend any pupil in any grade from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following, as provided.
(2)Existing law authorizes suspension to be imposed only when other means of correction, including, among other things, a conference between school personnel, the pupils parent or guardian, and the pupil, or participation in a restorative justice program, fail to bring about proper conduct, except as provided.
This bill would authorize certificated and classified employees, including certificated and noncertificated employees at charter schools, to refer pupils to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports, from the specified list of other means of correction, for willful defiance, and would require school administrators, including charter school administrators, within 5 business days, to document the actions taken and to place that documentation in the pupils record, as specified. The bill would also require the school administrator, by the end of the 5th business day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports. By imposing additional duties on public school administrators, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
This bill would instead prohibit a suspension or expulsion from being imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are otherwise absent from school activities.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law prohibits a pupil from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act from a list of specified acts, including, among other acts, disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law authorizes a teacher to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following.
Existing law prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and recommending the expulsion of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of those school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law, until July 1, 2025, prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for those acts. Existing law applies these same provisions to charter schools.
This bill would extend the prohibition against the suspension of pupils enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, including those pupils enrolled in a charter school, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties to all grades, by 4 years to instead be until July 1, 2029, and, commencing July 1, 2024, would prohibit the suspension of pupils enrolled in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, including those pupils enrolled in a charter school, for those acts until July 1, 2029, but would retain a teachers existing authorization to suspend any pupil in any grade from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following, as provided.
(2)Existing law authorizes suspension to be imposed only when other means of correction, including, among other things, a conference between school personnel, the pupils parent or guardian, and the pupil, or participation in a restorative justice program, fail to bring about proper conduct, except as provided.
This bill would authorize certificated and classified employees, including certificated and noncertificated employees at charter schools, to refer pupils to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports, from the specified list of other means of correction, for willful defiance, and would require school administrators, including charter school administrators, within 5 business days, to document the actions taken and to place that documentation in the pupils record, as specified. The bill would also require the school administrator, by the end of the 5th business day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports. By imposing additional duties on public school administrators, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
This bill would instead prohibit a suspension or expulsion from being imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are otherwise absent from school activities.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law prohibits a pupil from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act from a list of specified acts, including, among other acts, disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law authorizes a teacher to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following.
Existing law prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and recommending the expulsion of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of those school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law, until July 1, 2025, prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for those acts. Existing law applies these same provisions to charter schools.
This bill would extend the prohibition against the suspension of pupils, pupils enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, including those pupils enrolled in a charter school, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties to all grades, indefinitely, by 4 years to instead be until July 1, 2029, and, commencing July 1, 2024, would prohibit the suspension of pupils enrolled in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, including those pupils enrolled in a charter school, for those acts until July 1, 2029, but would retain a teachers existing authorization to suspend any pupil in any grade from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following, as provided.
(2)Existing law authorizes suspension to be imposed only when other means of correction, including, among other things, a conference between school personnel, the pupils parent or guardian, and the pupil, or participation in a restorative justice program, fail to bring about proper conduct, except as provided.
This bill would authorize certificated and classified employees, including certificated and noncertificated employees at charter schools, to refer pupils to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports, from the specified list of other means of correction, for willful defiance, and would require school administrators, including charter school administrators, within 5 business days, to document the actions taken and to place that documentation in the pupils record, as specified. The bill would also require the school administrator, by the end of the 5th business day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports. By imposing additional duties on public school administrators, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
This bill would instead prohibit a suspension or expulsion from being imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are otherwise absent from school activities.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law prohibits a pupil from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act from a list of specified acts, including, among other acts, disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law authorizes a teacher to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following.
Existing law prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and recommending the expulsion of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of those school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law, until July 1, 2025, prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for those acts. Existing law applies these same provisions to charter schools.
This bill would extend the prohibition against the suspension of pupils, including pupils enrolled in a charter school, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties to all grades, indefinitely, but would retain a teachers existing authorization to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following, as provided.
(2)Existing law authorizes suspension to be imposed only when other means of correction, including, among other things, a conference between school personnel, the pupils parent or guardian, and the pupil, or participation in a restorative justice program, fail to bring about proper conduct, except as provided.
This bill would authorize certificated and classified employees, including certificated and noncertificated employees at charter schools, to refer pupils to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports, from the specified list of other means of correction, for willful defiance, and would require school administrators, including charter school administrators, within 5 business days, to document the actions taken and to place that documentation in the pupils record, as specified. The bill would also require the school administrator, by the end of the 5th business day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports. By imposing additional duties on public school administrators, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)(3)Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
This bill would instead prohibit a suspension or expulsion from being imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are otherwise absent from school activities.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Existing law prohibits a pupil from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed a specified act, an act from a list of specified acts, including, among other acts, disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law authorizes a teacher to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following.
Existing law prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and recommending the expulsion of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of those school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law, until July 1, 2025, prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for those acts. Existing law applies these same provisions to charter schools.
This bill would remove extend the prohibition against the suspension of pupils, including pupils enrolled in a charter school, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties from the list of acts for which a pupil, regardless of their grade of enrollment, may be suspended or recommended for expulsion. The bill would extend the prohibition against the suspension of charter school pupils for those acts to all grades, indefinitely. to all grades, indefinitely, but would retain a teachers existing authorization to suspend any pupil from class for any of the listed acts, including willful defiance, for the day of the suspension and the day following, as provided.
(2)Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
This bill would instead prohibit a suspension or expulsion from being imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are otherwise absent from school activities.
(1)Existing law prohibits a pupil from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed a specified act, including, among other acts, disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
Existing law prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and recommending the expulsion of a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of those school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. Existing law, until July 1, 2025, prohibits the suspension of a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for those acts. Existing law applies these same provisions to charter schools.
This bill would remove disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties from the list of acts for which a pupil, regardless of their grade of enrollment, may be suspended or recommended for expulsion. The bill would extend the prohibition against the suspension of charter school pupils for those acts to all grades, indefinitely.
(2)Existing law states the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
This bill would instead prohibit a suspension or expulsion from being imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are otherwise absent from school activities.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For more than a decade, the Supreme Court, in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), and supported by neuroscience research, has recognized that young people are different and, because of the hallmark features of youth, such as immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences, are both not as culpable as older people and capable of remarkable change.
(b)Reflecting this reality and emerging science, California law concerning youth, their development, and punishment for their behaviors has been evolving.
(c)In 2014, Assembly Bill 420 of the 201314 Regular Session, authored by Assembly Member Roger Dickinson, was passed and signed by Governor Jerry Brown, eliminating willful defiance as a reason to suspend or expel pupils enrolled in grades 1 to 3, inclusive.
(d)In 2019, Senate Bill 419 of the 201920 Regular Session, authored by Senator Nancy Skinner, was passed and signed by Governor Gavin Newsom, removing a sunset provision for the prohibition against willful defiance suspensions for 4th and 5th grade pupils and expanding the prohibition to middle school pupils, with a sunset provision for July 1, 2025.
(e)Removing the opportunity for a pupil to be suspended from school for a behavior deemed willfully defiant has a disproportionately beneficial impact on Black pupils. According to a publication from the California School Board Association, Californias Black pupils are suspended at a far higher rate than their peers.
(f)Research confirms that pupils of color, pupils who are homeless, pupils with disabilities, pupils in foster care, and LGBTQIA+ pupils are more likely to be suspended for behavior deemed to be a willfully defiant offense even when harmless.
(g)A 2018 study conducted by professors from the University of California, Los Angeles, and San Diego State University shows willful defiance suspensions represent 15 percent of all suspensions in grades 4 to 12, inclusive, and 21 percent in grades 7 and 8, among Black male pupils.
(h)Suspending pupils can significantly harm children, leading to learning loss, missed school meals, and have countless other harmful social and material consequences.
(i)School suspensions can also result in substantial economic and social costs for families, including other children in the household, their employers, and their communities.
(j)Suspended or expelled pupils are five times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the so-called school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $46,000,000,000 per year.
(k)United States Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona was quoted in an Education Week article stating, All students deserve access to safe, supportive schools and classrooms. Discrimination and use of exclusionary discipline can negatively impact students abilities to learn, grow and thrive... Were seeking information so that the Department can help schools and educators confront disparities and create inclusive school environments that set all students up for success.
(l)Ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color, and supports a school environment where every child has the opportunity to succeed.
SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:
(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.
(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.
(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.
(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
(2)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(3)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(4)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2024, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(5)(A)A certificated or classified employee may refer a pupil to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(B)A school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to subparagraph (A) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or classified employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.
(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.
(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.
(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.
(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.
(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.
(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:
(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.
(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.
(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.
(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.
(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.
(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:
(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).
(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.
(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.
(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.
(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.
(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.
(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.
(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(1)While on school grounds.
(2)While going to or coming from school.
(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.
(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.
(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).
(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.
(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.
(w)(1)A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
(2)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is amended to read:48901.1.Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, the following provisions apply to charter schools:
(a)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(b)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. This subdivision is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(c)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2024, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(d)(1)A certificated or noncertificated employee may refer a pupil to charter school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(2)A charter school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to paragraph (1) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The charter school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or noncertificated employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For more than a decade, the Supreme Court, in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), and supported by neuroscience research, has recognized that young people are different and, because of the hallmark features of youth, such as immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences, are both not as culpable as older people and capable of remarkable change.
(b)Reflecting this reality and emerging science, California law concerning youth, their development, and punishment for their behaviors has been evolving.
(c)In 2014, Assembly Bill 420 of the 201314 Regular Session, authored by Assembly Member Roger Dickinson, was passed and signed by Governor Jerry Brown, eliminating willful defiance as a reason to suspend or expel pupils enrolled in grades 1 to 3, inclusive.
(d)In 2019, Senate Bill 419 of the 201920 Regular Session, authored by Senator Nancy Skinner, was passed and signed by Governor Gavin Newsom, removing a sunset provision for the prohibition against willful defiance suspensions for 4th and 5th grade pupils and expanding the prohibition to middle school pupils, with a sunset provision for July 1, 2025.
(e)Removing the opportunity for a pupil to be suspended from school for a behavior deemed willfully defiant has a disproportionately beneficial impact on Black pupils. According to a publication from the California School Board Association, Californias Black pupils are suspended at a far higher rate than their peers.
(f)Research confirms that pupils of color, pupils who are homeless, pupils with disabilities, pupils in foster care, and LGBTQIA+ pupils are more likely to be suspended for behavior deemed to be a willfully defiant offense even when harmless.
(g)A 2018 study conducted by professors from the University of California, Los Angeles, and San Diego State University shows willful defiance suspensions represent 15 percent of all suspensions in grades 4 to 12, inclusive, and 21 percent in grades 7 and 8, among Black male pupils.
(h)Suspending pupils can significantly harm children, leading to learning loss, missed school meals, and have countless other harmful social and material consequences.
(i)School suspensions can also result in substantial economic and social costs for families, including other children in the household, their employers, and their communities.
(j)Suspended or expelled pupils are five times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the so-called school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $46,000,000,000 per year.
(k)United States Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona was quoted in an Education Week article stating, All students deserve access to safe, supportive schools and classrooms. Discrimination and use of exclusionary discipline can negatively impact students abilities to learn, grow and thrive... Were seeking information so that the Department can help schools and educators confront disparities and create inclusive school environments that set all students up for success.
(l)Ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color, and supports a school environment where every child has the opportunity to succeed.
SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:
(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.
(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.
(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.
(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
(2)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(3)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(4)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2024, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(5)(A)A certificated or classified employee may refer a pupil to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(B)A school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to subparagraph (A) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or classified employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.
(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.
(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.
(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.
(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.
(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.
(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:
(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.
(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.
(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.
(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.
(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.
(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:
(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).
(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.
(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.
(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.
(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.
(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.
(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.
(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(1)While on school grounds.
(2)While going to or coming from school.
(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.
(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.
(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).
(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.
(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.
(w)(1)A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
(2)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is amended to read:48901.1.Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, the following provisions apply to charter schools:
(a)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(b)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. This subdivision is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(c)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2024, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(d)(1)A certificated or noncertificated employee may refer a pupil to charter school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(2)A charter school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to paragraph (1) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The charter school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or noncertificated employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For more than a decade, the Supreme Court, in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), and supported by neuroscience research, has recognized that young people are different and, because of the hallmark features of youth, such as immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences, are both not as culpable as older people and capable of remarkable change.
(b)Reflecting this reality and emerging science, California law concerning youth, their development, and punishment for their behaviors has been evolving.
(c)In 2014, Assembly Bill 420 of the 201314 Regular Session, authored by Assembly Member Roger Dickinson, was passed and signed by Governor Jerry Brown, eliminating willful defiance as a reason to suspend or expel pupils enrolled in grades 1 to 3, inclusive.
(d)In 2019, Senate Bill 419 of the 201920 Regular Session, authored by Senator Nancy Skinner, was passed and signed by Governor Gavin Newsom, removing a sunset provision for the prohibition against willful defiance suspensions for 4th and 5th grade pupils and expanding the prohibition to middle school pupils, with a sunset provision for July 1, 2025.
(e)Removing the opportunity for a pupil to be suspended from school for a behavior deemed willfully defiant has a disproportionately beneficial impact on Black pupils. According to a publication from the California School Board Association, Californias Black pupils are suspended at a far higher rate than their peers.
(f)Research confirms that pupils of color, pupils who are homeless, pupils with disabilities, pupils in foster care, and LGBTQIA+ pupils are more likely to be suspended for behavior deemed to be a willfully defiant offense even when harmless.
(g)A 2018 study conducted by professors from the University of California, Los Angeles, and San Diego State University shows willful defiance suspensions represent 15 percent of all suspensions in grades 4 to 12, inclusive, and 21 percent in grades 7 and 8, among Black male pupils.
(h)Suspending pupils can significantly harm children, leading to learning loss, missed school meals, and have countless other harmful social and material consequences.
(i)School suspensions can also result in substantial economic and social costs for families, including other children in the household, their employers, and their communities.
(j)Suspended or expelled pupils are five times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the so-called school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $46,000,000,000 per year.
(k)United States Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona was quoted in an Education Week article stating, All students deserve access to safe, supportive schools and classrooms. Discrimination and use of exclusionary discipline can negatively impact students abilities to learn, grow and thrive... Were seeking information so that the Department can help schools and educators confront disparities and create inclusive school environments that set all students up for success.
(l)(l)Ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color, and supports a school environment where every child has the opportunity to succeed.
SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.(k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.(2)(A)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.(B)(i)A certificated or classified employee may refer a pupil to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).(ii)A school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to clause (i) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or classified employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:(1)While on school grounds.(2)While going to or coming from school.(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.(w)(1)A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.(2)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 48901.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:48901.1.(a)Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.(b)(1)A certificated or noncertificated employee may refer a pupil to charter school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).(2)A charter school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to paragraph (1) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The charter school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or noncertificated employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:
(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.
(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.
(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.
(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
(2)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 3, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion. This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2020.(3)(2)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2020, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(4)(3)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2020, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2025. 2029.
(4)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2024, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(5)(A)A certificated or classified employee may refer a pupil to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(B)A school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to subparagraph (A) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or classified employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.
(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.
(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.
(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.
(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.
(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.
(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:
(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.
(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.
(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.
(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.
(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.
(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:
(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).
(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.
(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.
(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.
(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.
(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.
(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.
(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(1)While on school grounds.
(2)While going to or coming from school.
(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.
(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.
(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).
(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.
(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.
(w)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil who is based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
(2)It is further the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, may be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is amended to read:48901.1.Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, commencing July 1, 2020, the following provisions apply to charter schools:
(a)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(b)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. This subdivision is inoperative on July 1, 2025. 2029.
(c)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2024, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 9 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2029.
(d)(1)A certificated or noncertificated employee may refer a pupil to charter school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(2)A charter school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to paragraph (1) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The charter school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or noncertificated employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
SEC. 5.SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For more than a decade, the Supreme Court, in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), and supported by neuroscience research, has recognized that young people are different and, because of the hallmark features of youth, such as immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences, are both not as culpable as older people and capable of remarkable change.
(b)Reflecting this reality and emerging science, California law concerning youth, their development, and punishment for their behaviors has been evolving.
(c)In 2014, Assembly Bill 420 of the 201314 Regular Session, authored by Assembly Member Roger Dickinson, was passed and signed by Governor Jerry Brown, eliminating willful defiance as a reason to suspend or expel pupils enrolled in grades 1 to 3, inclusive.
(d)In 2019, Senate Bill 419 of the 201920 Regular Session, authored by Senator Nancy Skinner, was passed and signed by Governor Gavin Newsom, removing a sunset provision for the prohibition against willful defiance suspensions for 4th and 5th grade pupils and expanding the prohibition to middle school pupils, with a sunset provision for July 1, 2025.
(e)Removing the opportunity for a pupil to be suspended from school for a behavior deemed willfully defiant has a disproportionately beneficial impact on Black pupils. According to a publication from the California School Board Association, Californias Black pupils are suspended at a far higher rate than their peers.
(f)Research confirms that pupils of color, pupils who are homeless, pupils with disabilities, pupils in foster care, and LGBTQIA+ pupils are more likely to be suspended for behavior deemed to be a willfully defiant offense even when harmless.
(g)A 2018 study conducted by professors from the University of California, Los Angeles, and San Diego State University shows willful defiance suspensions represent 15 percent of all suspensions in grades 4 to 12, inclusive, and 21 percent in grades 7 and 8, among Black male pupils.
(h)Suspending pupils can significantly harm children, leading to learning loss, missed school meals, and have countless other harmful social and material consequences.
(i)School suspensions can also result in substantial economic and social costs for families, including other children in the household, their employers, and their communities.
(j)Suspended or expelled pupils are five times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the so-called school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $46,000,000,000 per year.
(k)United States Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona was quoted in an Education Week article stating, All students deserve access to safe, supportive schools and classrooms. Discrimination and use of exclusionary discipline can negatively impact students abilities to learn, grow and thrive... Were seeking information so that the Department can help schools and educators confront disparities and create inclusive school environments that set all students up for success.
(l)Ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color, and supports a school environment where every child has the opportunity to succeed.
SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:
(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.
(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.
(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.
(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
(2)(A)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(B)(i)A certificated or classified employee may refer a pupil to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(ii)A school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to clause (i) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or classified employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.
(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.
(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.
(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.
(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.
(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.
(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:
(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.
(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.
(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.
(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.
(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.
(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:
(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).
(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.
(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.
(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.
(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.
(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.
(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.
(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(1)While on school grounds.
(2)While going to or coming from school.
(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.
(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.
(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).
(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.
(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.
(w)(1)A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
(2)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 48901.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:48901.1.(a)Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(b)(1)A certificated or noncertificated employee may refer a pupil to charter school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list specified in subdivision (b) of Section 48900.5 for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1).
(2)A charter school administrator shall, within five business days, document the actions taken pursuant to paragraph (1) and place that documentation in the pupils record to be available for access, to the extent permissible under state and federal law, pursuant to Section 49069.7. The charter school administrator shall, by the end of the fifth business day, also inform the referring certificated or noncertificated employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken and, if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
SEC. 5.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For more than a decade, the Supreme Court, in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), and supported by neuroscience research, has recognized that young people are different and, because of the hallmark features of youth, such as immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences, are both not as culpable as older people and capable of remarkable change.
(b)Reflecting this reality and emerging science, California law concerning youth, their development, and punishment for their behaviors has been evolving.
(c)In 2014, Assembly Bill 420 of the 201314 Regular Session, authored by Assembly Member Roger Dickinson, was passed and signed by Governor Jerry Brown, eliminating willful defiance as a reason to suspend or expel pupils enrolled in grades 1 to 3, inclusive.
(d)In 2019, Senate Bill 419 of the 201920 Regular Session, authored by Senator Nancy Skinner, was passed and signed by Governor Gavin Newsom, removing a sunset provision for the prohibition against willful defiance suspensions for 4th and 5th grade pupils and expanding the prohibition to middle school pupils, with a sunset provision for July 1, 2025.
(e)Removing the opportunity for a pupil to be suspended from school for a behavior deemed willfully defiant has a disproportionately beneficial impact on Black pupils. According to a publication from the California School Board Association, Californias Black pupils are suspended at a far higher rate than their peers.
(f)Research confirms that pupils of color, pupils who are homeless, pupils with disabilities, pupils in foster care, and LGBTQIA+ pupils are more likely to be suspended for behavior deemed to be a willfully defiant offense even when harmless.
(g)A 2018 study conducted by professors from University of California, Los Angeles, and San Diego State University shows willful defiance suspensions represent 15 percent of all suspensions in grades 4 to 12, inclusive, and 21 percent in grades 7 and 8, among Black male pupils.
(h)Suspending pupils can significantly harm children, leading to learning loss, missed school meals, and have countless other harmful social and material consequences.
(i)School suspensions can also result in substantial economic and social costs for families, including other children in the household, their employers, and their communities.
(j)Suspended or expelled pupils are five times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the so-called school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $46,000,000,000 per year.
(k)United States Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona was quoted in an Education Week article stating, All students deserve access to safe, supportive schools and classrooms. Discrimination and use of exclusionary discipline can negatively impact students abilities to learn, grow and thrive... Were seeking information so that the Department can help schools and educators confront disparities and create inclusive school environments that set all students up for success.
(l)Ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color, and supports a school environment where every child has the opportunity to succeed.
SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:
(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.
(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.
(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.
(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(k)[Reserved](k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
(2)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.
(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.
(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.
(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.
(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.
(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.
(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:
(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.
(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.
(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.
(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.
(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.
(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:
(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).
(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.
(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.
(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.
(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.
(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.
(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.
(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(1)While on school grounds.
(2)While going to or coming from school.
(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.
(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.
(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).
(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.
(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.
(w)(1)A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
(2)It is the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 48901.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:48901.1.Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended or recommended for expulsion on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For more than a decade, the Supreme Court, in Miller v. Alabama, 567 U.S. 460 (2012), and supported by neuroscience research, has recognized that young people are different and, because of the hallmark features of youth, such as immaturity, impetuosity, and failure to appreciate risks and consequences, are both not as culpable as older people and capable of remarkable change.
(b)Reflecting this reality and emerging science, California law concerning youth, their development, and punishment for their behaviors has been evolving.
(c)In 2014, Assembly Bill 420 of the 201314 Regular Session, authored by Assembly Member Roger Dickinson, was passed and signed by Governor Jerry Brown, eliminating willful defiance as a reason to suspend or expel pupils enrolled in grades 1 to 3, inclusive.
(d)In 2019, Senate Bill 419 of the 201920 Regular Session, authored by Senator Nancy Skinner, was passed and signed by Governor Gavin Newsom, removing a sunset provision for the prohibition against willful defiance suspensions for 4th and 5th grade pupils and expanding the prohibition to middle school pupils, with a sunset provision for July 1, 2025.
(e)Removing the opportunity for a pupil to be suspended from school for a behavior deemed willfully defiant has a disproportionately beneficial impact on Black pupils. According to a publication from the California School Board Association, Californias Black pupils are suspended at a far higher rate than their peers.
(f)Research confirms that pupils of color, pupils who are homeless, pupils with disabilities, pupils in foster care, and LGBTQIA+ pupils are more likely to be suspended for behavior deemed to be a willfully defiant offense even when harmless.
(g)A 2018 study conducted by professors from University of California, Los Angeles, and San Diego State University shows willful defiance suspensions represent 15 percent of all suspensions in grades 4 to 12, inclusive, and 21 percent in grades 7 and 8, among Black male pupils.
(h)Suspending pupils can significantly harm children, leading to learning loss, missed school meals, and have countless other harmful social and material consequences.
(i)School suspensions can also result in substantial economic and social costs for families, including other children in the household, their employers, and their communities.
(j)Suspended or expelled pupils are five times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the so-called school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $46,000,000,000 per year.
(k)United States Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona was quoted in an Education Week article stating, All students deserve access to safe, supportive schools and classrooms. Discrimination and use of exclusionary discipline can negatively impact students abilities to learn, grow and thrive... Were seeking information so that the Department can help schools and educators confront disparities and create inclusive school environments that set all students up for success.
(l)Ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color, and supports a school environment where every child has the opportunity to succeed.
SEC. 2.Section 48900 of the Education Code is amended to read:48900.A pupil shall not be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has committed an act as defined pursuant to any of subdivisions (a) to (r), inclusive:
(a)(1)Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
(2)Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
(b)Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless, in the case of possession of an object of this type, the pupil had obtained written permission to possess the item from a certificated school employee, which is concurred in by the principal or the designee of the principal.
(c)Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
(d)Unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell a controlled substance listed in Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 11053) of Division 10 of the Health and Safety Code, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind, and either sold, delivered, or otherwise furnished to a person another liquid, substance, or material and represented the liquid, substance, or material as a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or intoxicant.
(e)Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
(f)Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
(g)Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
(h)Possessed or used tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, miniature cigars, clove cigarettes, smokeless tobacco, snuff, chew packets, and betel. However, this section does not prohibit the use or possession by a pupil of the pupils own prescription products.
(i)Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
(j)Unlawfully possessed or unlawfully offered, arranged, or negotiated to sell drug paraphernalia, as defined in Section 11014.5 of the Health and Safety Code.
(k)(1)Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.(2)Except as provided in Section 48910, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 3, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts enumerated in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion. This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2020.(3)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2020, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1), and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.(4)Except as provided in Section 48910, commencing July 1, 2020, a pupil enrolled in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended for any of the acts specified in paragraph (1). This paragraph is inoperative on July 1, 2025.(k)[Reserved]
(l)Knowingly received stolen school property or private property.
(m)Possessed an imitation firearm. As used in this section, imitation firearm means a replica of a firearm that is so substantially similar in physical properties to an existing firearm as to lead a reasonable person to conclude that the replica is a firearm.
(n)Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault as defined in Section 261, 266c, 286, 287, 288, or 289 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code or committed a sexual battery as defined in Section 243.4 of the Penal Code.
(o)Harassed, threatened, or intimidated a pupil who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding for purposes of either preventing that pupil from being a witness or retaliating against that pupil for being a witness, or both.
(p)Unlawfully offered, arranged to sell, negotiated to sell, or sold the prescription drug Soma.
(q)Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing means a method of initiation or preinitiation into a pupil organization or body, whether or not the organization or body is officially recognized by an educational institution, that is likely to cause serious bodily injury or personal degradation or disgrace resulting in physical or mental harm to a former, current, or prospective pupil. For purposes of this subdivision, hazing does not include athletic events or school-sanctioned events.
(r)Engaged in an act of bullying. For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Bullying means any severe or pervasive physical or verbal act or conduct, including communications made in writing or by means of an electronic act, and including one or more acts committed by a pupil or group of pupils as defined in Section 48900.2, 48900.3, or 48900.4, directed toward one or more pupils that has or can be reasonably predicted to have the effect of one or more of the following:
(A)Placing a reasonable pupil or pupils in fear of harm to that pupils or those pupils person or property.
(B)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience a substantially detrimental effect on the pupils physical or mental health.
(C)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils academic performance.
(D)Causing a reasonable pupil to experience substantial interference with the pupils ability to participate in or benefit from the services, activities, or privileges provided by a school.
(2)(A)Electronic act means the creation or transmission originated on or off the schoolsite, by means of an electronic device, including, but not limited to, a telephone, wireless telephone, or other wireless communication device, computer, or pager, of a communication, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(i)A message, text, sound, video, or image.
(ii)A post on a social network internet website, including, but not limited to:
(I)Posting to or creating a burn page. Burn page means an internet website created for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1).
(II)Creating a credible impersonation of another actual pupil for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). Credible impersonation means to knowingly and without consent impersonate a pupil for the purpose of bullying the pupil and such that another pupil would reasonably believe, or has reasonably believed, that the pupil was or is the pupil who was impersonated.
(III)Creating a false profile for the purpose of having one or more of the effects listed in paragraph (1). False profile means a profile of a fictitious pupil or a profile using the likeness or attributes of an actual pupil other than the pupil who created the false profile.
(iii)(I)An act of cyber sexual bullying.
(II)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying means the dissemination of, or the solicitation or incitement to disseminate, a photograph or other visual recording by a pupil to another pupil or to school personnel by means of an electronic act that has or can be reasonably predicted to have one or more of the effects described in subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1). A photograph or other visual recording, as described in this subclause, shall include the depiction of a nude, semi-nude, or sexually explicit photograph or other visual recording of a minor where the minor is identifiable from the photograph, visual recording, or other electronic act.
(III)For purposes of this clause, cyber sexual bullying does not include a depiction, portrayal, or image that has any serious literary, artistic, educational, political, or scientific value or that involves athletic events or school-sanctioned activities.
(B)Notwithstanding paragraph (1) and subparagraph (A), an electronic act shall not constitute pervasive conduct solely on the basis that it has been transmitted on the internet or is currently posted on the internet.
(3)Reasonable pupil means a pupil, including, but not limited to, a pupil with exceptional needs, who exercises average care, skill, and judgment in conduct for a person of that age, or for a person of that age with the pupils exceptional needs.
(s)A pupil shall not be suspended or expelled for any of the acts enumerated in this section unless the act is related to a school activity or school attendance occurring within a school under the jurisdiction of the superintendent of the school district or principal or occurring within any other school district. A pupil may be suspended or expelled for acts that are enumerated in this section and related to a school activity or school attendance that occur at any time, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(1)While on school grounds.
(2)While going to or coming from school.
(3)During the lunch period whether on or off the campus.
(4)During, or while going to or coming from, a school-sponsored activity.
(t)A pupil who aids or abets, as defined in Section 31 of the Penal Code, the infliction or attempted infliction of physical injury to another person may be subject to suspension, but not expulsion, pursuant to this section, except that a pupil who has been adjudged by a juvenile court to have committed, as an aider and abettor, a crime of physical violence in which the victim suffered great bodily injury or serious bodily injury shall be subject to discipline pursuant to subdivision (a).
(u)As used in this section, school property includes, but is not limited to, electronic files and databases.
(v)For a pupil subject to discipline under this section, a superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupils specific misbehavior as specified in Section 48900.5.
(w)(1)It is the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to A suspension or expulsion shall not be imposed against a pupil who is based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
(2)It is further the intent of the Legislature that the Multi-Tiered System of Supports, which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, may be used to help pupils gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
SEC. 3.Section 48901.1 of the Education Code is repealed.48901.1.Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, commencing July 1, 2020, the following provisions apply to charter schools:(a)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties, and those acts shall not constitute grounds for a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, to be recommended for expulsion.(b)A pupil enrolled in a charter school in any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, shall not be suspended on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. This subdivision is inoperative on July 1, 2025.SEC. 4.Section 48901.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:48901.1.Notwithstanding Section 47610 or any other law, a pupil enrolled in a charter school in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, shall not be suspended or recommended for expulsion on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 597, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 8, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 32. Noes 6. Page 2467.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 6, 2023 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 6, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 61. Noes 13. Page 2959.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 3.) (September 1). |
| Sep 1, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 23, 2023 | August 23 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Aug 14, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 17, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (July 12). |
| Jul 3, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 20, 2023 | June 28 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 18, 2023 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 11, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 11, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 36. Noes 3. Page 1049.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 20, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 789.) (April 19). |
| Apr 10, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Apr 5, 2023 | April 12 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | Set for hearing April 12. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 2, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 4. |
| Feb 1, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2023 | Unfinished Business SB274 Skinner et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2023 | SB 274 Skinner Senate Third Reading By Bonta | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2023 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 11, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB274 Skinner | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Alameda County Office Of Education | ** Support | |
| Alliance for Boys and Men of Color | ** Support | |
| Alliance for Children's Rights | ** Support | |
| American Civil Liberties Union California Action | ** Support | |
| Asian Solidarity Collective | ** Support | |
| Association Of California School Administrators | ** Support | |
| Black Parallel School board | ** Support | |
| California Alliance for Youth and Community Justice | ** Support | |
| California County Superintendents | ** Support | |
| California Native Vote Project | ** Support | |
| Californians for Justice | ** Support | |
| Californians for Safety and Justice | ** Support | |
| California Public Defenders Association | ** Support | |
| California Youth Connection | ** Support | |
| California Youth Empowerment Network | ** Support | |
| Cancel the Contract | ** Support | |
| Castro Valley Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice | ** Support | |
| Children Now | ** Support | |
| City and County of San Francisco | ** Support | |
| Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice | ** Support | |
| Community Asset Development Redefining Education | ** Support | |
| Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Support | |
| Dolores Huerta Foundation | ** Support | |
| Dublin Unified School District | ** Support | |
| East Bay Community Law Center | ** Support | |
| Emery Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Equal Justice Society | ** Support | |
| Fresh Lifelines for Youth | ** Support | |
| Genders & Sexualities Alliance Network | ** Support | |
| Generation Up | ** Support | |
| Go Public Schools | ** Support | |
| John Burton Advocates for Youth | ** Support | |
| Law Foundation of Silicon Valley | ** Support | |
| Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles County Office Of Education | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Mental Health America of California | ** Support | |
| Mid-City Community Advocacy Network | ** Support | |
| milpa | ** Support | |
| National Association Of Social Workers, California Chapter | ** Support | |
| National Institute for Criminal Justice Reform | ** Support | |
| Newark Unified School District | ** Support | |
| NextGen California | ** Support | |
| Oakland Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Pacific Juvenile Defender Center | ** Support | |
| Public Advocates | ** Support | |
| Public Counsel | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Unified School District | ** Support | |
| San Leandro Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos | ** Support | |
| Seneca Family of Agencies | ** Support | |
| Sigma Beta Xi, Inc., Youth and Family Services | ** Support | |
| Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition | ** Support | |
| Smart Justice California | ** Support | |
| State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond | ** Support | |
| Sunol Glen Unified School District | ** Support | |
| Teach Plus | ** Support | |
| The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration | ** Support | |
| The Children's Partnership | ** Support | |
| The Education Trust - West | ** Support | |
| Women Democrats of Sacramento County | ** Support | |
| Young Women's Freedom Center | ** Support | |
| Youth Alliance | ** Support | |
| Youth Justice Education Clinic, Center for Juvenile Law and Policy, Loyola Law School | ** Support | |
| Youth United for Community Action | ** Support | |
| Youth Will | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 274 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 274
Author: Skinner (D), et al.
Amended: 8/14/23
Vote: 21
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/19/23
AYES: Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Cortese, Glazer, McGuire, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wilk
SENATE FLOOR: 36-3, 5/11/23
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Jones, Niello, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-13, 9/6/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Suspensions and expulsions: willful defiance: interventions and supports
SOURCE: State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Dolores Huerta Foundation
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student enrolled in 6th through 12th grade in a public school on the basis of willful defiance until July 1, 2029, authorizes employees to refer students to school administrators for in-school interventions or supports, and requires that administrators document the actions taken in the student’s record and inform the referring employee of those actions.
Assembly Amendments
:
- Remove the extension of the prohibition on willful defiance for students enrolled in grades 6-12.
- Extend the current sunset on the prohibition of suspensions for willful defiance for students enrolled in grades 6-8 to July 1, 2030, unless the administrator determines there is a need for a suspension due to an immediate threat to the safety of the pupil, other pupils, or school staff.
- Beginning July 1, 2024, prohibit out-of-school suspensions for students enrolled in grades 9-12 on the basis of willful defiance, unless the administrator determines there is a need for a suspension due to an immediate threat to the safety of the pupil, other pupils or school staff.
- Require that parents, guardians, or other relevant responsible adults be notified when any suspension for willful defiance is imposed.
- Express the intent of the Legislature that any suspension for willful defiance be used only as a last resort when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct.
- Make other technical and clarifying amendments.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Prohibits a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, from being suspended and expelled for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. (Education Code (EC) § 48900(k)(3))
- Prohibits until July 1, 2025, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, from being suspended for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. (EC § 48900(k)(4)
- Prohibits a pupil from being suspended or recommended for expulsion unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school determines that the pupil has committed certain acts, as specified. (EC § 48900)
- Authorizes a pupil enrolled in any of grades 4 to 12, inclusive, to be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion if the superintendent or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has intentionally engaged in harassment, threats, or intimidation, directed against school district personnel or pupils, that is sufficiently severe or pervasive to have the actual and reasonably expected effect of materially disrupting classwork, creating substantial disorder, and invading the rights of either school personnel or pupils by creating an intimidating or hostile educational environment. (EC § 48900.4)
- Authorizes school district superintendents and school principals to use discretion to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupil’s specific misbehavior, as specified. (EC § 48900(v))
- States that suspension, including supervised suspension, shall be imposed only when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct, but authorizes a pupil, including a pupil with exceptional needs, to be suspended upon a first offense for certain acts (not including disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties) or the pupil’s presence causes a danger to persons. (EC § 48900.5)
- Authorizes teachers to suspend pupils from class for the day and the following day. If the pupil is to remain on campus during that suspension, the pupil must be under appropriate supervision. Teachers must ask the parent to attend a parent-teacher conference regarding the suspension. Pupils are prohibited from returning to the class from which he or she was suspended, during the period of the suspension, without the concurrence of the teacher and principal. (EC § 48910)
This bill:
- Extends the ban on suspending a student on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel, from kindergarten through 5th grade, to students in 6th through 12th grade, and retains the prohibition on recommending a student for expulsion based upon willful defiance from kindergarten through 12th grade.
- Extends the sunset on the prohibition on suspending a student in grades 6 to 8 on the basis of willful defiance from July 1, 2025, to July 1, 2029.
- Prohibits the suspension of a student in grades 9 to 12 on the basis of willful defiance between July 1, 2024, and July 1, 2029.
- Authorizes certificated or classified employees to refer a student to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports, as specified, on the basis of willful defiance.
- Requires a school administrator, within five business days, to document the actions taken pursuant to 3), above and place the documentation in the student’s record to be available for access by the parent, as specified. Also requires the school administrator, by the end of the 5th day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken, and if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
- Prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student in a school district based solely on the student being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
- Applies the provisions in 1) through 5), above, to students in charter schools.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, "SB 274 is based on a simple premise: Students belong in school. Suspending youth for low-level behavior issues leads to significant harm, including learning loss and a higher likelihood that affected students will drop out of school completely. SB 274 puts the needs of students first. Instead of kicking them out of school, we owe it to students to figure out what’s causing them to act out and help them fix it. The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school. Students, especially those with behavioral issues, need to be in school where teachers and counselors can help them succeed."
- Zero Tolerance Policies Disproportionate Effects. In 1994, Congress passed the Gun-Free Schools Act (GFSA), which required states to expel students who brought firearms to campus for at least one year. While zero tolerance policies were initially intended to ensure a safe and healthy school environment (e.g., selling drugs or engaging in gang-related fights on school grounds), policies were expanded to include minor offenses that would otherwise be seen as normal behavior. These policies inadvertently created the "School to Prison Pipeline," where youth expelled or suspended for minor offenses are funneled out of public schools and into the juvenile and criminal legal systems. The school-to-prison pipeline causes a disproportionate number of students of color to drop out of school and enter the criminal justice system, which can have life-changing adverse effects.
Although California's suspension rate has decreased recently, students of color are still disproportionately suspended compared to their peers. The California Department of Education (CDE) data shows that while total suspensions dropped from 363,406 in the 2017-18 school year (SY) to 233,753 in 2019-20 SY, black students received 15.6% of all suspensions for defiance-only in the 2017-18 SY and 18.7% in the 2019-20 SY. In recent years there have been other statutory provisions designed to limit the use of suspensions and promote alternatives to suspension.
- Restorative Justice and Other Approaches to Suspension and Expulsion? Several school districts, including some of the largest, have adopted board policies prohibiting willful defiance as the basis for suspension or expulsion and are committing resources to effectively implement alternative correction models, including restorative justice, positive behavior interventions and support, and other evidence-based approaches. For example, Oakland Unified School District has banned the suspension or expulsion of students based solely upon willful defiance. Oakland Unified offers restorative justice programs in their schools. Furthermore, the Legislature has made significant investments to encourage local educational agencies (LEAs) to establish alternatives to suspension and expulsion.
• $100 million in competitive grants to LEAs to increase the number of teachers available to serve California state preschool and transitional kindergarten pupils and to provide teachers with training in inclusive practices, culturally responsive instruction, supporting dual language learners, enhancing social-emotional learning, implementing trauma-informed and restorative practices, and mitigating implicit biases to eliminate exclusionary discipline;
• $50 million to the Orange County Office of Education for support of MTSS efforts, including grants to LEAs to provide ongoing training and support in the use of trauma screening tools and mental health service referrals, and school climate surveys.
• $6 million for training LEAs on interpreting data from their local school climate surveys of pupils, families, and educators to inform continuous improvement efforts and better assess community needs stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic and distance learning; and for the CDE to develop an optional trauma-informed practice module to be used with school climate surveys.
- Discretion. This bill would prohibit school personnel from recommending suspension or expulsion from school for willfully defying school personnel and for being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities. This does not limit the ability of a teacher to suspend a student from class.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According the Assembly Appropriations Committee, “Potential Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures to schools to the extent a school provides interventions and supports to students who are willfully defiant. Should schools provide these services, this bill requires a school to document the support and interventions and take other actions. It is likely a school would provide interventions and supports to a willfully defiant students it can no longer suspend or expel under this bill. Costs would depend on the number of students to which a school provides interventions and supports and would be less to the extent schools already document these supports and interventions. The state has over 10,000 schools. Because this bill does not require schools to document support and interventions and take other actions unless they first provide support and interventions to students who are willfully defiant, this bill is unlikely to be a state-mandated local program. However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines the bill’s requirements to be a reimbursable state mandate, the state would need to reimburse these costs to local educational agencies or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.”
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/6/23)
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond (co-source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color (co-source)
Dolores Huerta Foundation (co-source)
Alameda County Office of Education
Alliance for Children's Rights
American Civil Liberties Union California Action
Asian Solidarity Collective
Association of California School Administrators
Black Parallel School Board
California Alliance for Youth and Community Justice
California County Superintendents
California Native Vote Project
California Public Defenders Association
California Youth Connection
California Youth Empowerment Network
Californians for Justice
Californians for Safety and Justice
Cancel the Contract
Castro Valley Unified School District
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Children Now
City and County of San Francisco
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Asset Development Re-defining Education
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
Disability Rights California
Dublin Unified School District
East Bay Community Law Center
Emery Unified School District
Equal Justice Society
Fresh Lifelines for Youth
Genders & Sexualities Alliance Network
Generation Up
Go Public Schools
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Law Foundation of Silicon Valley
Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles
Livermore Valley Joint Unified School District
Los Angeles County Office of Education
Los Angeles Unified School District
Mental Health America of California
Mid-City Community Advocacy Network
Milpa
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Institute for Criminal Justice Reform
Newark Unified School District
NextGen California
Oakland Unified School District
Pacific Juvenile Defender Center
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
San Francisco Unified School District
San Leandro Unified School District
Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos
Seneca Family of Agencies
Sigma Beta Xi, Inc. Youth and Family Services
Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition
Smart Justice California
Sunol Glen Unified School District
Teach Plus
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
The Children's Partnership
The Education Trust - West
Women Democrats of Sacramento County
Young Women's Freedom Center
Youth Alliance
Youth Justice Education Clinic, Center for Juvenile Law and Policy, Loyola Law School
Youth United for Community Action
Youth Will
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/6/23)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Alliance of Boys and Men of Color, “AB 420 (Dickinson) successfully eliminated defiance expulsions and suspensions for students in grades K-3 (inclusive) and SB 419 (Skinner) successfully eliminated defiance suspensions for students in grades 4-6 (inclusive). Since the 2014-2015 school year, “defiance” suspensions have decreased from 125,419 to 21,465 in the 2021-2022 Academic Year. Despite this significant decrease many schools continue to use this policy and racial disparities persist. The simple act of ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color and youth with disabilities, by creating a school environment where every child has the opportunity to learn, thrive and succeed. It is for these reasons, the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color is pleased to co-sponsor and support SB 274.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-13, 9/6/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Alanis, Megan Dahle, Davies, Essayli, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chen, Dixon, Flora, Grayson, Lackey, Ta
Prepared by: Kordell Hampton / ED. / (916) 651-4105
9/6/23 18:14:28
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 274
Author:(Skinner)
As Amended Ver:August 14, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student enrolled in 6th through 12th grade in a public school, including charter schools, on the basis of willful defiance until July 1, 2029, authorizes employees to refer students to school administrators for in-school interventions or supports, and requires that administrators document the actions taken in the student’s record and inform the referring employee of those actions.
Major Provisions
- Extends the ban on suspending a student on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel, from kindergarten through 5th grade, to students in 6th through 12th grade, and retains the prohibition on recommending a student for expulsion based upon willful defiance from kindergarten through 12th grade.
- Extends the sunset on the prohibition on suspending a student in grades 6 to 8 on the basis of willful defiance from July 1, 2025, to July 1, 2029.
- Prohibits the suspension of a student in grades 9 to 12 on the basis of willful defiance between July 1, 2024, and July 1, 2029.
- Authorizes certificated or classified employees to refer a student to school administrators for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports, as specified, on the basis of willful defiance.
- Requires a school administrator, within five business days, to document the actions taken pursuant to 3), above and place the documentation in the student’s record to be available for access by the parent, as specified. Also requires the school administrator, by the end of the 5th day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken, and if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
- Prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student in a school district based solely on the student being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
- Applies the provisions in 1) through 5), abovce, to students in charter schools.
COMMENTS
Rates of suspension/expulsion have dropped dramatically. According to California Department of Education (CDE) data on discipline in California public schools, over the ten-year period from 2011-12 to 2021-22:
- Total suspensions for all offenses dropped 58%, from 709,702 to 292,423;
- Total expulsions for all offenses dropped 57%, from 9,758 to 4,191;
- Total suspensions for willful defiance dropped 94%, from 335,079 suspensions to 21,465; and
- Total expulsions for willful defiance dropped 98%, from 512 to 8.
However, disproportionality continues to be an issue for suspensions and expulsions on the basis of willful defiance, particularly for African American students and Hispanic students.
High school students continue to be suspended for defiance. In 2011-12 prior to restrictions on suspensions for willful defiance, there were a total of 334,391 suspensions statewide across all grade levels. Of these, 52.7% were imposed on students in grades 9-12. As the restrictions on willful defiance in younger grades were imposed through legislation, beginning in 2013-14, the incidence of suspensions for this offense fell significantly overall, dropping by 76.6% from 2011-12 to 2016-17 and by 72.6% from 2016-17 to 2021-22. As of 2021-22, restrictions on suspensions for willful defiance applied to students in kindergarten through 8th grade, and 65% of total suspensions for willful defiance were for students in grades 9-12.
According to the Author
"SB 274 is based on a simple premise: Students belong in school. Suspending youth for low-level behavior issues leads to significant harm, including learning loss and a higher likelihood that affected students will drop out of school completely. SB 274 puts the needs of students first. Instead of kicking them out of school, we owe it to students to figure out what’s causing them to act out and help them fix it. The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school. Students, especially those with behavioral issues, need to be in school where teachers and counselors can help them succeed."
Arguments in Support
According to the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color, a co-sponsor, "Willful defiance is broadly defined as defying the authority of school staff. Some examples of defiance include: wearing a hat, not having a belt, or falling asleep in class. Defiance suspensions contribute to racial inequality in schools. Students of color, students with disabilities, and LGBTQ students are disproportionately suspended for low-level subjective behavioral disruptions, classified as willful defiance. These suspensions cause students to lose significant instruction time. Suspending students causes significant harm such as learning loss, missed school meals, and lack of access to extracurricular activities. Furthermore, suspended or expelled students are 5 times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $2.7 billion a year. The simple act of ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color and youth with disabilities, by creating a school environment where every child has the opportunity to learn, thrive and succeed."
Arguments in Opposition
One individual writes, "Egregious behavior must have serious consequences. If kids learn in school that there are no serious consequences for willful bad behavior, they will end up as adults who don’t understand consequences and will end up in jail. This bill leaves teachers exposed."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
Potential Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures to schools to the extent a school provides interventions and supports to students who are willfully defiant. Should schools provide these services, this bill requires a school to document the support and interventions and take other actions. It is likely a school would provide interventions and supports to a willfully defiant students it can no longer suspend or expel under this bill. Costs would depend on the number of students to which a school provides interventions and supports and would be less to the extent schools already document these supports and interventions. The state has over 10,000 schools.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 36-3-1
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Jones, Niello, Seyarto
ABS, ABST OR NV: Grove
ASM EDUCATION: 5-0-2
YES: Muratsuchi, Juan Carrillo, Lee, McCarty, Quirk-Silva
ABS, ABST OR NV: Megan Dahle, Hoover
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-3-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Soria, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon
UPDATED
VERSION: August 14, 2023
CONSULTANT: Debbie Look / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0001549
Date of Hearing: August 23, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 274
Author:(Skinner) – As Amended Ver:August 14, 2023
Policy Committee: | Education | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends the current prohibition on suspending students in grades six through eight for willful defiance for four additional years. The bill also prohibits for four years the suspension of students in grades nine through 12 for willful defiance and makes other changes to student discipline.
Specifically, this bill:
- Extends the current prohibition on suspending students in grades six through eight for willful defiance until July 1, 2029.
- Commencing July 1, 2024, prohibits the suspension of student in grades nine through 12 for willful defiance until July 1, 2029.
- Authorizes a certificated or classified school employee to refer a student to school administrators, on the basis of willful defiance, for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction. If an employee refers a student to intervention or supports, the bill requires a school administrator, within five business days, to document the interventions or supports and place the documentation in the student’s record to be available for access by the student’s parent. The bill also requires the school administrator, by the end of the fifth day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken, and if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
- Prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student based solely on the student being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Potential Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures to schools to the extent a school provides interventions and supports to students who are willfully defiant. Should schools provide these services, this bill requires a school to document the support and interventions and take other actions. It is likely a school would provide interventions and supports to a willfully defiant students it can no longer suspend or expel under this bill. Costs would depend on the number of students to which a school provides interventions and supports and would be less to the extent schools already document these supports and interventions. The state has over 10,000 schools.
Because this bill does not require schools to document support and interventions and take other actions unless they first provide support and interventions to students who are willfully defiant, this bill is unlikely to be a state-mandated local program. However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines the bill’s requirements to be a reimbursable state mandate, the state would need to reimburse these costs to local educational agencies or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
SB 274 is based on a simple premise: Students belong in school. Suspending youth for low-level behavior issues leads to significant harm, including learning loss and a higher likelihood that affected students will drop out of school completely. SB 274 puts the needs of students first. Instead of kicking them out of school, we owe it to students to figure out what’s causing them to act out and help them fix it. The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school. Students, especially those with behavioral issues, need to be in school where teachers and counselors can help them succeed.
- Background. Current law prohibits a student from being suspended or expelled from school unless the superintendent of the school district or school’s principal determine the student has committed certain acts. These acts include various serious offenses, including if a student caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person; possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object; among other offenses. In addition, these acts include if a student “disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties,” also known as “willful defiance.”
Current law also prohibits the suspension of a student in grades one through five or the expulsion of a student in grades one through 12 for willful defiance. Current law also prohibits the suspension of a student in grades six through eight for willful defiance until July 1, 2025.
This bill creates new prohibitions on suspension and expulsion related to willful defiance and extends existing prohibitions. The bill does not alter the authority in current law of a teacher to suspend a student of any age from that particular classroom for the current day and the following day.
- Prior Legislation. SB 419 (Skinner), Chapter 279, Statutes of 2019, commencing July 1, 2020, extends the permanent prohibition against suspending a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or grades one through three for willful defiance to include grades four and five permanently; and to include grades six through eight, inclusive, until July 1, 2025; and applies these prohibitions to charter schools.
AB 1808 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 32, Statutes of 2018, removed the sunset on the prohibition on suspending a student in kindergarten through third grade, or recommending a student in kindergarten through 12th grade for expulsion, on the basis of willful defiance, thereby making these prohibitions permanent.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 12, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Al Muratsuchi, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 274
Author:(Skinner) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 36-3
SUBJECT: Suspensions and expulsions: willful defiance
SUMMARY: Extends the current permanent ban on suspending a student, or recommending for expulsion on the basis of willful defiance from kindergarten through 5th grade, to students in 6th through 12th grade, and prohibits a student from being suspended or expelled on the sole basis of being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school. Specifically, this bill:
- Removes the sunset on the prohibition on suspending a student in any of grades 6 to 8 on the basis of willful defiance as of July 1, 2025.
- Extends the permanent ban on suspending a student on the basis of having disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel, from kindergarten through 5th grade, to students in 6th through 12th grade, and retains the prohibition on recommending a student for expulsion based upon willful defiance from kindergarten through 12th grade.
- Extends the prohibition on suspension or a recommendation for expulsion of a student in a charter school on the basis of willful defiance to students in kindergarten through 12th grade.
- Authorizes a certificated or classified employee of a school district or charter school to refer a student to school administrators, on the basis of willful defiance, for appropriate and timely in-school interventions or supports from the list of other means of correction, as specified.
- Requires a school administrator, within 5 business days, to document the actions taken pursuant to (5) and place the documentation in the student’s record to be available for access by the parent, as specified. Also requires the school administrator, by the end of the 5th day, to inform the referring employee, verbally or in writing, what actions were taken, and if none, the rationale used for not providing any appropriate or timely in-school interventions or supports.
- Prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student in a school district based solely on the student being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a student from being suspended from school or recommended for expulsion, unless the superintendent of the school district, or the principal of the school, determines that the student has committed any of the following offenses:
- Causing, attempting to cause, or threatening to cause physical injury to another person, or willfully using force or violence upon another person, except in self-defense;
- Possessing, selling, or otherwise furnishing a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, unless the student had obtained prior written permission to possess the item;
- Unlawfully possessing, using, selling, or otherwise furnishing a controlled substance;
- Unlawfully offering, arranging, or negotiating to sell a controlled substance, alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind;
- Committing or attempting to commit robbery or extortion;
- Causing or attempting to cause damage to school property or private property;
- Stealing or attempting to steal school property or private property;
- Possessing or using tobacco, or products containing tobacco or nicotine products;
- Committing an obscene act or engaging in habitual profanity or vulgarity;
- Unlawfully possessing or unlawfully offering, arranging or negotiating to sell drug paraphernalia;
- Disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. This subdivision does not apply to a student enrolled in kindergarten through grade 5; or to a student enrolled in grades 6 to 8 until July 1, 2025; and does not allow a student enrolled in grades kindergarten through 12th grade to be recommended for expulsion on this basis.
- Knowingly receiving stolen school property or private property;
- Possessing an imitation firearm;
- Committing or attempting to commit a sexual assault or sexual battery;
- Harassing, threatening, or intimidating a student who is a complaining witness or a witness in a school disciplinary proceeding in order to prevent the student from being a witness or retaliating against that student for being a witness, or both;
- Unlawfully offering, arranging to sell, or negotiating to sell the prescription drug Soma;
- Engaging in or attempting to engage in hazing;
- Engaging in the act of bullying, including bullying committed by means of an electronic act;
- Committing sexual harassment (grades 4 through 12 only);
- Causing or attempting to cause, threatening to cause, or participating in, an act of hate violence (grades 4 through 12 only);
- Engaging in harassment, threats, or intimidation against school district personnel or students that have the effect of disrupting classwork, creating substantial disorder, and invading the rights of either school personnel or students by creating an intimidating or hostile educational environment (grades 4 through 12 only); and,
- Making a terroristic threat against school officials, school property, or both. (Education Code (EC) Sections 48900, 48900.2, 48900.3, 48900.4, 48900.7)
- Includes the prohibition on suspension and expulsions on the basis of willful defiance in (1)(k) above to students in charter schools. (EC 48901.1)
- Requires the principal or superintendent of schools to recommend the expulsion of a student for any of the following acts committed at school or at a school activity off school grounds, unless it is determined that the expulsion should not be recommended under the circumstances or that an alternative means of correction would address the conduct:
- Causing serious physical injury to another person, except in self-defense;
- Possession of any knife or other dangerous object of no reasonable use to the student;
- Unlawful possession of any controlled substance, as specified;
- Robbery or extortion; and
- Assault or battery, as defined, upon any school employee. (EC 48915)
- Requires that a suspension only be imposed when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct. Specifies that other means of correction may include, but are not limited to, the following:
- A conference between school personnel, the student's parent or guardian, and the student;
- Referrals to the school counselor, psychologist, social worker, child welfare attendance personnel, or other school support personnel for case management and counseling;
- Study teams, guidance teams, resource panel teams, or other intervention-related teams that assess the behavior, develop and implement individualized plans to address the behavior in partnership with the student and his or her parents;
- Referral for a comprehensive psychosocial or psychoeducational assessment;
- Enrollment in a program for teaching prosocial behavior or anger management;
- Participation in a restorative justice program;
- A positive behavior support approach with tiered interventions that occur during the schoolday on campus; and,
- After school programs that address specific behavioral issues or expose students to positive activities and behaviors. (EC 48900.5)
- Authorizes a teacher to suspend any student from class for specified acts for the day of the suspension and the day following, and send the student to the principal for appropriate action. Prohibits the student being suspended from class from being placed in another regular class during the period of the suspension, if the student is assigned to more than one class per day this provision only applies to other regular classes scheduled at the same time. If the suspension requires the continued presence of the student at the schoolsite, the student must be under appropriate supervision. Requires the teacher, as soon as possible, to ask the parent or guardian of the student to attend a parent-teacher conference regarding the suspension. The conference may include a school counselor or school psychologist and must include a school administrator, if requested by the parent, guardian, or teacher. (EC 48910)
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has been keyed non-fiscal by the Office of Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill. This bill would extend the current permanent prohibition on the suspension of kindergarten through 5th grade students, to 6th through 12th grade students, on the basis of willful defiance, and would retain the ban on recommendations for expulsion on this basis for students from kindergarten through twelfth grade. These provisions would apply to charter schools, as well as to schools operated by school districts.
The bill would not alter the authority of a teacher to suspend a student of any age from that particular classroom for the current day and the following day. Existing law also authorizes the suspension or expulsion of a pupil in grades four through twelve if the pupil has intentionally engaged in harassment, threats, or intimidation directed against school personnel or other pupils, that is sufficiently severe or pervasive to have the effect of materially disrupting classwork, created substantial disorder, or invaded the rights of school personnel or pupils by creating a hostile educational environment.
Need for the bill. According to the author, “SB 274 is based on a simple premise: Students belong in school. Suspending youth for low-level behavior issues leads to significant harm, including learning loss and a higher likelihood that affected students will drop out of school completely. SB 274 puts the needs of students first. Instead of kicking them out of school, we owe it to students to figure out what’s causing them to act out and help them fix it. The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school. Students, especially those with behavioral issues, need to be in school where teachers and counselors can help them succeed.”
Rates of suspension/expulsion have dropped dramatically. According to CDE data on discipline in California public schools, over the ten-year period from 2011-12 to 2021-22:
- Total suspensions for all offenses dropped 58%, from 709,702 to 292,423;
- Total expulsions for all offenses dropped 57%, from 9,758 to 4,191;
- Total suspensions for willful defiance dropped 94%, from 335,079 suspensions to 21,465; and
- Total expulsions for willful defiance dropped 98%, from 512 to 8.
However, disproportionality continues to be an issue for suspensions and expulsions on the basis of willful defiance, particularly for African American students and Hispanic students, as shown in the tables below:
Race/ ethnicity | % of cumulative enrollment in 2011-12 | % of total suspensions for willful defiance 2011-12 | % of total expulsions for willful defiance 2011-12 |
African American | 6.8% | 18.5% | 13.7% |
Hispanic | 50.6% | 55.1% | 59.6% |
White | 25.7% | 18.8% | 18.4% |
Total | 6,285,600 | 335,079 | 512 |
Race/ ethnicity | % of cumulative enrollment in 2021-22 | % of total suspensions for willful defiance 2021-22 | % of total expulsions for willful defiance 2021-22 |
African American | 5.2% | 13.8% | 12.5% |
Hispanic | 55.8% | 59.6% | 50.0% |
White | 21.0% | 18.4% | 25.0% |
Total | 6,064,658 | 21,465 | 8 |
Source: CDE Dataquest
Disparities in the rate of school suspensions. The disproportionate incidence of suspensions and expulsions among certain populations of students, including African American students, has gained nationwide attention in recent years. A 2018 report by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), K-12 Education: Discipline Disparities for Black Students, Boys, and Students with Disabilities, found that black students, boys, and students with disabilities were disproportionately disciplined in K-12 schools, based upon an analysis of Civil Rights Data Collection (CRDC) data.
CRDC data show that there was an overall 2% decline in the use of exclusionary discipline practices in public schools in the U.S. from the 2015-16 school year to the 2017-18 school year. However, there was an increase during this period of school-related arrests, expulsions with educational services, and referrals to law enforcement. The data also shows a continued disproportionality in exclusionary practices during the 2017-18 school year:
- Black students accounted for 15.1% of total student enrollment in the U.S. and received 38.8% of expulsions with educational services and 33.3% of expulsions without educational services;
- Students with disabilities represented 13.2% of enrollment and received 23.3% of expulsions with educational services and 14.8% of expulsions without educational services;
- Boys accounted for 51.4% of enrollment and received 69.5% of in-school suspensions and 70.5% of out-of-school suspensions;
- 31.4% of Black students received 1 or more in-school suspensions and 38.2% received 1 or more out-of-school suspensions;
- 20.5% of students with disabilities received 1 or more in-school suspensions and 24.5% received 1 or more out-of-school suspensions;
- Black students with disabilities represent 2.3% of student enrollment, but 6.2% received 1 or more in-school suspensions and 8.8% received 1 or more out-of-school suspensions; and
- Black students accounted for 28.7% of all students referred to law enforcement and 31.6% of all students arrested at school or during a school-related activity.
A GAO report on the topic of disproportionate disciplinary actions suggest that “implicit bias on the part of teachers and staff may cause them to judge students’ behaviors differently based on the students’ race and sex. Teachers and staff sometimes have discretion to make case-by-case decisions about whether to discipline, and the form of discipline to impose in response to student behaviors, such as disobedience, defiance, and classroom disruption.”
Research on student behavior, race, and discipline has found no evidence that African American over-representation in school suspension is due to higher rates of misbehavior. African American students were referred more often for behaviors that seem to require more subjective judgement on the part of the person making the referral (e.g. disrespect, excessive noise, threatening behavior, and loitering). (Losen, 2011)
High school students continue to be suspended for defiance. In 2011-12 prior to restrictions on suspensions for willful defiance, there were a total of 334,391 suspensions statewide across all grade levels. Of these, 52.7% were imposed on students in grades 9-12. As the restrictions on willful defiance in younger grades were imposed through legislation, beginning in 2013-14, the incidence of suspensions for this offense fell significantly overall, dropping by 76.6% from 2011-12 to 2016-17 and by 72.6% from 2016-17 to 2021-22. As of 2021-22, restrictions on suspensions for willful defiance applied to students in kindergarten through 8th grade, and 65% of total suspensions for willful defiance were for students in grades 9-12.
Impacts of exclusionary discipline policies. Research suggests that harsh discipline practices and the over-policing of students of color that occurs in many schools has undermined the creation of safe and inclusive learning environments. Disproportionalities in suspension and expulsion rates between students of color and their white peers appear as early as preschool and continue through the K-12th grades. Black youth often receive harsher punishments for minor offenses and are more than twice as likely as white students to receive a referral to law enforcement or be subject to a school-related arrest. (Learning Policy Institute (LPI), March 2021).
One study, Educational and Criminal Justice Outcomes 12 Years After School Suspension, (Rosenbaum, 2018) notes that “school suspensions aim to obtain better behavior from the punished student and maintain school norms by removing students. Suspension removes disruptive students from schools temporarily and may improve school climate by reducing peer influences to engage in deviant behavior.” The study goes on to note that a body of research has found that suspended students are more likely to:
- Engage in antisocial behavior;
- Have involvement with the criminal justice system;
- Be arrested both during the month of suspension and within a year of suspension; and
- Use marijuana and tobacco.
The study also cites various longitudinal research findings, including:
- Youth suspended in ninth grade were less likely to graduate high school, graduate on time, and enroll in postsecondary education; and
- Twelve years after suspension, suspended youth were less likely to have earned degrees or high school diplomas, and were more likely to have been arrested or on probation.
Some researchers conclude that “suspensions may act more as a reinforcer than a punisher for inappropriate behavior. Other research raises doubts as to whether harsh school discipline has a deterrent value. Frequent use of suspension alone has no measureable positive deterrent or academic benefit to either the students who are suspended or to non-suspended students.” (Losen, 2011). The American Academy of Pediatrics states, “Without the services of trained professionals, such as pediatricians, mental health professionals, and school counselors, and without a parent at home during the day, students with out-of-school suspensions and expulsions are far more likely to commit crimes.”
Researchers have pointed out that “many suspended students find school to be challenging and experience suspension from school as a reward. Suspensions may be reinforcing and even incentivizing the very behavior they are meant to correct.” (Rumberger, 2017).
According to the U.S. Department of Education: “Teachers and students deserve school environments that are safe, supportive, and conducive to teaching and learning. Creating a supportive school climate—and decreasing suspensions and expulsions—requires close attention to the social, emotional, and behavioral needs of all students. Evidence does not show that discipline practices that remove students from instruction—such as suspensions and expulsions—help to improve either student behavior or school climate.”
Holding schools accountable for suspension and expulsion rates. California’s Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and Local Control and Accountability Plan (LCAP) requirements include school climate as one of the eight state priorities. All California school districts, COEs, and charter schools are required to report and examine student suspension and expulsion rates on their LCAP and annual updates. It has been suggested that this requirement to clearly report disciplinary actions, in the aggregate as well as by subgroup, increases the pressure on schools to employ alternatives to suspension and expulsion.
Alternatives to suspension and expulsion include PBIS. Schoolwide strategies employed by school districts to improve school climate and reduce exclusionary discipline include Positive Behavior Interventions and Support (PBIS), which is a schoolwide approach to discipline that is intended to create safe, predictable, and positive school environments. When PBIS is implemented with fidelity, schools see fewer students with serious behavior problems and an overall improvement in school climate. The key PBIS practices include:
- Clearly defining behavioral expectations of the school community;
- Proactively teaching what those expected behaviors look like in various school settings, on a regular basis;
- Frequently recognizing students who comply with behavioral expectations;
- Administering a clearly defined continuum of consequences for behavioral violations; and
- Continuously collecting and analyzing data to assess students’ responsiveness to the behavioral supports provided.
Restorative justice as alternative approach. Restorative practices in schools are also considered a non-punitive approach as an alternative to harsh zero tolerance policies. The use of restorative justice and restorative practices in schools offers a respectful and equitable approach to discipline, as well as a proactive strategy to create a connected, inclusive school culture. Inspired by indigenous values, restorative justice is a philosophy and a theory of justice that emphasizes bringing together everyone affected by wrongdoing to address needs and responsibilities, and to heal the harm to relationships as much as possible. The term “restorative practices” is used by a number of practitioners to describe how the concepts of restorative justice are utilized to create change in school systems. These practices are an alternative to zero-tolerance policies that mandate suspension or expulsion of students from school for a wide variety of misbehaviors that are not necessarily violent or dangerous. (Fix School Discipline, 2022)
According to the LPI, “Safe, supportive learning environments, where students feel a sense of belonging and where relational trust prevails, are the foundation of a restorative approach to education. Research shows that stable, caring relationships with teachers and other adults are linked to better school performance and engagement. Even one stable relationship with a committed adult can help buffer a child from the effects of serious adversity. Restorative structures, such as advisory systems, support community building and relationships and provide consistent opportunities for teachers to check in on students’ academic, social-emotional, and mental health needs and connect them to appropriate supports.” (LPI, March 2021).
According to the LPI research, restorative practices in schools include:
- Staff and students have a shared vocabulary that enables them to express feelings in a healthy productive way and to criticize the deed, not the doer;
- Impromptu student conferences are used to redirect a student’s behavior in a way that minimizes disruption to instructional time; and
- Restorative circles are structured processes guided by a trained facilitator with a strong emphasis on the importance of listening, facilitated by using a talking piece.
Successful implementation of restorative practices. Research suggests that integrating restorative approaches into school settings is complex and takes time. Studies have suggested that key elements include (LPI, October 2021):
- Incorporating restorative practices as one of many strategies for improving school culture;
- Utilizing a whole school approach;
- Focusing on building staff buy-in and capacity;
- Developing meaningful accountability and data collection systems;
- Establishing district-level infrastructure; and
- Centering student and community voices.
Increasing use of alternatives to suspension and expulsion in California. A number of school districts, including some of the largest in the state, have adopted board policies that prohibit the use of willful defiance as the basis for suspension or expulsion and are committing resources to effectively implement alternative models of correction, including restorative justice, PBIS, and other evidence-based approaches. For example, three large school districts in California, San Francisco Unified School District (SFUSD), Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD), and Oakland Unified School District (OUSD), have banned the suspension or expulsion of students based solely upon willful defiance and all three districts offer restorative justice programs in their schools.
LAUSD, writing in support of this bill, states, “In 2013, the Los Angeles Unified School Board banned willful defiance suspensions outright. We are proud to share that in the past ten years, there has been a significant decline in willful defiance suspensions among students of color. Eliminating willful defiance suspensions for all grade levels can help ensure that proactive approaches that positively address a students’ behavior are deployed rather than preventing the student from attending school.” CDE data shows the following:
- Suspensions for willful defiance in LAUSD declined 98% from 4,458 in 2011-12 to only 54 in 2021-22;
- In 2011-12, African American students made up 9.4% of LAUSD’s enrollment, but accounted for 31.6% of suspensions for willful defiance; and
- In 2021-22, African American students made up 7.9% of LAUSD’s enrollment, but accounted for 33% of suspensions for willful defiance.
OUSD is considered a nationwide model for restorative justice, having successfully operated their program since 2006. According to the district website, “Restorative Justice (RJ) is a set of principles and practices inspired by indigenous values used to build community, respond to harm/conflict and provide individual circles of support for students. By building, maintaining and restoring relationships between members of the entire school community, we help to create an environment where all students can thrive. Our program is implemented through a 3-tier, school-wide model.”
- Tier 1: Community Building, characterized by the use of social emotional skills and practice (classroom circles) to build relationships, create shared values and guidelines, and promote restorative conversations following behavioral disruption. The goal is to build a caring, intentional, and equitable community with conditions conducive to learning;
- Tier 2: Restorative Processes, characterized by the use of non-punitive response to harm/conflict such as harm circles, mediation, or family-group conferencing to respond to disciplinary issues in a restorative manner. This process addresses the root causes of the harm, supports accountability for the offender, and promotes healing for the victim(s), the offender, and the school community; and
- Tier 3: Supported Re-Entry, characterized by 1:1 support and successful re-entry of youth following suspension, truancy, expulsion or incarceration. The goal is to welcome youth to the school community in a manner that provides wraparound support and promotes student accountability and achievement.
The State has invested in alternatives to suspension and expulsion to improve school climate and culture. In recent years, the Legislature has allocated significant resources specifically designed to improve school climate and reduce exclusionary disciplinary practices. These include significant investments in Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS) to encourage LEAs to establish and align schoolwide, data-driven systems of academic and behavioral supports to more effectively meet the needs of California’s diverse learners in the most inclusive environment.
The state has also invested almost $3 billion in one-time funding for the establishment and expansion of community schools in 2021, for encumbrance through 2028. A community school is a public school that serves prekindergarten through grade twelve and has community partnerships that support improved academic outcomes, whole-child engagement, and family development. Community school partnership strategies include integrated supports services, extended learning time, and collaborative leadership and practices for educators and administrators. Community schools can increase equitable student learning outcomes by addressing the conditions for teaching and learning. Community schools support the needs of the whole child by strengthening family and community foundations with approaches that sustain mental and behavioral health through healing-centered practices, social–emotional learning, and restorative justice.
Teacher survey shows concerns with student behavior. A California survey of 4,632 current K-12 teachers, 26 former teachers, and 25 aspiring teachers conducted in the summer of 2022 looked at general job satisfaction and career plans. Burnout from stress was cited as the top reason current teachers are considering leaving the profession. It was noted that student apathy and behavioral issues contribute to the stress felt by teachers. Current and former teachers note that stress would be reduced with stronger discipline policies for students who behave disruptively.
When asked what they like least about their current position, 32% of teachers cited student apathy, discipline, and behavioral problems. The report quotes an aspiring teacher as follows:
“The most challenging aspects of being a teacher right now I’m seeing is a lot of teachers struggle with the behavior management portion of the classroom. Because you can’t teach if you don’t have control of your classroom and your kids aren’t engaged, and I think the pandemic had a lot to do with that.” (Hart Research, 2022)
Survey results found the top two priorities for current teachers who indicate they will definitely leave the profession within three years are better pay (73%), and strengthening discipline for students with disruptive behaviors (66%). Student behavior issues were also a concern that former teachers dealt with during their teaching career. They note that school-mandated solutions were typically ineffective and support from administrators and leadership was minimal. Former teachers suggest that there should be more professional opportunities for teachers to learn relationship-based skillsets to manage interactions with students, other teachers, administrators, and parents.
Another national survey of teachers conducted in 2023 by The Harris Poll, on behalf of the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, found the top challenges cited by teachers were discipline/behavioral issues (74%) and pay (65%).
Concerns raised regarding lack of alternative measures. The California School Boards Association (CSBA) has a support if amended position on SB 274 and writes:
CSBA has long supported finding alternatives for suspending and expelling students. Suspensions and expulsions should be used as an option of last resort, not the reverse. This is why training, resources and funding should be provided on an ongoing basis to assist schools in addressing the root causes that lead to willful defiance and disrupting school activities. Specifically, funding should be provided to support LEAs in addressing positive behavioral interventions, restorative justice and other similar programs to address the leading circumstances as to why willful defiance occurs.
Without this funding, we are concerned about wholly deleting one of the “tools” in the list of actions available to addressing student behavior without providing adequate support to implement developmentally appropriate and effective disciplinary alternatives. Adequate training and funding are needed to properly implement disciplinary alternatives.
We are requesting that specific and adequate funding be provided prior to the implementation of this measure to support LEAs in addressing positive behavioral interventions, restorative justice and other similar programs to address the leading circumstances as to why willful defiance occurs.
The Committee may wish to consider whether teachers, particularly in high schools, would have access to the skills and supports necessary for effective classroom management if the prohibition on suspensions for willful defiance is extended to high school as proposed by this bill, and if not, if it would lead to more teachers leaving the teaching profession, further exacerbating the teacher shortage.
Recommended Committee Amendments. Staff recommend that the bill be amended as follows:
- Remove the extension of the prohibition on willful defiance for students enrolled in grades 6-12.
- Extend the current sunset on the prohibition of suspensions for willful defiance for students enrolled in grades 6-8 to July 1, 2030, unless the administrator determines there is a need for a suspension due to an immediate threat to the safety of the pupil, other pupils, or school staff.
- Beginning July 1, 2024, prohibit out-of-school suspensions for students enrolled in grades 9-12 on the basis of willful defiance, unless the administrator determines there is a need for a suspension due to an immediate threat to the safety of the pupil, other pupils or school staff.
- Requires that parents, guardians, or other relevant responsible adults be notified when any suspension for willful defiance is imposed pursuant to (2) or (3) above.
- Expresses the intent of the Legislature that any suspension for willful defiance be used only as a last resort when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct.
- Other technical and clarifying amendments.
Arguments in support. According to the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color, a co-sponsor, “Willful defiance is broadly defined as defying the authority of school staff. Some examples of defiance include: wearing a hat, not having a belt, or falling asleep in class. Defiance suspensions contribute to racial inequality in schools. Students of color, students with disabilities, and LGBTQ students are disproportionately suspended for low-level subjective behavioral disruptions, classified as willful defiance. These suspensions cause students to lose significant instruction time. Suspending students causes significant harm such as learning loss, missed school meals, and lack of access to extracurricular activities. Furthermore, suspended or expelled students are 5 times more likely to drop out of school and to fall into the school-to-prison pipeline, costing the state an estimated $2.7 billion a year.
Since the 2014-2015 school year, defiance suspensions have decreased from 125,419 to 21,465 in the 2021-2022 academic year. Despite this significant decrease many schools continue to use this policy and racial disparities persist. The simple act of ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color and youth with disabilities, by creating a school environment where every child has the opportunity to learn, thrive and succeed.”
Arguments in opposition. One individual writes, “Egregious behavior must have serious consequences. If kids learn in school that there are no serious consequences for willful bad behavior, they will end up as adults who don’t understand consequences and will end up in jail. This bill leaves teachers exposed.”
Related legislation. SB 419 (Skinner), Chapter 279, Statutes of 2019, commencing July 1, 2020, extends the permanent prohibition against suspending a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 3 for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of school staff to include grades 4 and 5 permanently; and to include grades 6 to 8, inclusive, until July 1, 2025; and applies these prohibitions to charter schools.
AB 1808 (Committee on Budget) Chapter 32, Statutes of 2018, removed the sunset on the prohibition on suspending a student in kindergarten through third grade, or recommending a student in kindergarten through 12th grade for expulsion, on the basis of willful defiance, thereby making these prohibitions permanent.
SB 607 (Skinner) of the 2017-18 of the Session would have required, commencing July 1, 2019, permanently prohibits the suspension any pupil in kindergarten or grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and the expulsion of any pupil in kindergarten or in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, who disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties; prohibits, until July 1, 2023, the suspension of any pupil or grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for that same act; and makes these provisions applicable to charter schools. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown, with the following message:
Teachers and principals are on the front lines educating our children and are in the best position to make decisions about order and discipline in the classroom. That's why I vetoed a similar bill in 2012. In addition, I just approved $15 million in the 2018 Budget Act to help local schools improve their disciplinary practices. Let's give educators a chance to invest that money wisely before issuing any further directives from the state.
AB 420 (Dickerson) Chapter 660, Statutes of 2014, eliminated the option to suspend or recommend for expulsion a pupil who disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the authority of school officials and instead authorizes schools to suspend a pupil in grades 6-12 who has substantially disrupted school activities or substantially prevented instruction from occurring.
AB 1729 (Ammiano) Chapter 425, Statutes of 2012, recasts provisions relative to the suspension of a pupil upon a first offense, and authorizes the use and documentation of other means of correction.
AB 2242 (Dickinson) of the 2011-12 Session would have prohibited pupils who are found to have disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the authority of school officials from being subject to extended suspension, or recommended for expulsion. AB 2242 was vetoed by Governor Brown with the following message:
I cannot support limiting the authority of local school leaders, especially at a time when budget cuts have greatly increased class sizes and reduced the number of school personnel. It is important that teachers and school officials retain broad discretion to manage and set the tone in the classroom. The principle of subsidiarity calls for greater, not less, deference to our elected school boards which are directly accountable to the citizenry.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Alameda County Office of Education
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Alliance for Children's Rights
American Civil Liberties Union California Action
Asian Solidarity Collective
California Alliance for Youth and Community Justice
California County Superintendents
California Native Vote Project
California Public Defenders Association
California Youth Connection
California Youth Empowerment Network
Californians for Justice
Californians for Safety and Justice
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Children Now
City and County of San Francisco
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Asset Development Re-defining Education
Disability Rights California
Dolores Huerta Foundation
Fresh Lifelines for Youth
Genders & Sexualities Alliance Network
Genup
Go Public Schools
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Law Foundation of Silicon Valley
Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles
Los Angeles County Office of Education
Los Angeles Unified School District
Mental Health America of California
Mid-city Community Advocacy Network
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Oakland Unified School District
Pacific Juvenile Defender Center
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos
Seneca Family of Agencies
Sigma Beta Xi, INC. Youth and Family Services
Smart Justice California
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond
Teach Plus
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
The Children's Partnership
The Education Trust - West
Young Women's Freedom Center
Youth Alliance
Youth United for Community Action
Youth Will
Opposition
One individual
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Look / ED. / (916) 319-2087
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 274 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 274
Author: Skinner (D)
Amended: 4/10/23
Vote: 21
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/19/23
AYES: Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Cortese, Glazer, McGuire, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wilk
SUBJECT: Suspensions and expulsions: willful defiance
SOURCE: State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Dolores Huerta Foundation
DIGEST:
This bill extends the prohibition against the suspension and expulsion of students in grades K-8, to K-12, for disrupting school activities or willfully defying the valid authority of school personnel to all grades indefinitely but retains a teacher’s existing authorization to suspend any student from class for willful defiance and prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Prohibits a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, from being suspended and expelled for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. (EDC § 48900(k)(3))
- Prohibits until July 1, 2025, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, from being suspended for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. (EDC § 48900(k)(4)
- Authorizes teachers to suspend pupils from class for the day and the following day. If the pupil is to remain on campus during that suspension, the pupil must be under appropriate supervision. Teachers must ask the parent to attend a parent-teacher conference regarding the suspension. Pupils are prohibited from returning to the class from which he or she was suspended, during the period of the suspension, without the concurrence of the teacher and principal. (EDC § 48910)
- Prohibits a pupil from being suspended or recommended for expulsion unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school determines that the pupil has committed certain acts, including, among other acts, all of the following:
- Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
- Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self-defense.
- Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous objects, except as specified.
- Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of a controlled substance, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
- Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
- Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
- Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
- Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
- Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault or committed sexual battery.
- Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in performing their duties.
- Engaged in or attempted to engage in hazing.
- Engaged in the act of bullying. (EDC § 48900)
- Authorizes a pupil enrolled in any of grades 4 to 12, inclusive, to be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion if the superintendent or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has intentionally engaged in harassment, threats, or intimidation, directed against school district personnel or pupils, that is sufficiently severe or pervasive to have the actual and reasonably expected effect of materially disrupting classwork, creating substantial disorder, and invading the rights of either school personnel or pupils by creating an intimidating or hostile educational environment. (EDC § 48900.4)
- Authorizes school district superintendents and school principals to use discretion to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupil’s specific misbehavior, as specified. (EDC § 48900(v))
- States that suspension, including supervised suspension, shall be imposed only when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct but authorizes a pupil, including a pupil with exceptional needs, to be suspended upon a first offense for certain acts (not including disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties) or the pupil’s presence causes a danger to persons. (EDC § 48900.5)
- Specifies that other means of correction include, but are not limited to:
- A conference between school personnel, the pupil’s parent or guardian, and the pupil.
- Referrals to the school counselor, psychologist, social worker, child welfare attendance personnel, or other school support service personnel for case management and counseling.
- Study teams, guidance teams, resource panel teams, or other intervention-related teams that assess the behavior and develop and implement individualized plans to address the behavior in partnership with the pupil and their parents.
- Referral for a comprehensive psychosocial or psychoeducational assessment, including creating an individualized education program or a 504 plan.
- Enrollment in a program for teaching prosocial behavior or anger management.
- Participation in a restorative justice program.
- A positive behavior support approach with tiered interventions that occur during the school day on campus.
- After-school programs that address specific behavioral issues or expose pupils to positive activities and behaviors, including, but not limited to, those operated in collaboration with local parent and community groups.
- Community service, as specified. (EDC §48900.5)
- States that schools should consider implementing at least one of the following if the number of pupils suspended during the prior school year exceeded 30 percent of the school's enrollment:
- A supervised suspension program.
- A progressive discipline approach during the schoolday on campus (as an alternative to off-campus suspension), using any of the following activities:
- Conferences between the school staff, parents, and pupils.
- Referral to the school counselor, psychologist, child welfare attendance personnel, or other school support service staff.
- Detention.
- Study teams, guidance teams, resource panel teams, or other assessment-related teams. (EDC § 48911.2)
This bill extends the prohibition against the suspension and expulsion of students in grades K-8, to K-12, for disrupting school activities or willfully defying the valid authority of school personnel to all grades indefinitely but retains a teacher’s existing authorization to suspend any student from class for willful defiance and prohibits the suspension or expulsion of a student based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “SB 274 is based on a simple premise: Students belong in school. Suspending youth for low-level behavior issues leads to significant harm, including learning loss and a higher likelihood that affected students will drop out of school completely. The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school. Students, especially those with behavioral issues, must be in school where teachers and counselors can help them succeed. SB 274 puts the needs of students first. Instead of kicking them out of school, we owe it to students to figure out what’s causing them to act out and help them fix it.”
- Zero Tolerance Policies Have Disproportionate Effects. In 1994, Congress passed the Gun-Free Schools Act (GFSA), which required states to expel students who brought firearms to campus for at least one year. While zero tolerance policies were initially intended to ensure a safe and healthy school environment (e.g., selling drugs or engaging in gang-related fights on school grounds), policies were expanded to include minor offenses that would otherwise be seen as normal behavior. These policies inadvertently created the "School to Prison Pipeline," where youth expelled or suspended for minor offenses are funneled out of public schools and into the juvenile and criminal legal systems. The school-to-prison pipeline causes a disproportionate number of students of color to drop out of school and enter the criminal justice system, which can have life-changing adverse effects.
Although California's suspension rate has decreased recently, students of color are still disproportionately suspended compared to their peers. The California Department of Education (CDE) data shows that while total suspensions dropped from 363,406 in the 2017-18 school year (SY) to 233,753 in 2019-20 SY, black students received 15.6% of all suspensions for defiance-only in the 2017-18 SY and 18.7% in the 2019-20 SY. In recent years, other statutory provisions have been designed to limit the use of suspensions and promote alternatives to suspension. These provisions aim to address the root causes of the student’s behavior and to improve academic outcomes:
- Minimize Suspension for Attendance Issues: The Legislature intends that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
- Instead of Suspension, Support: A school district superintendent or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes that are age-appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupil’s misbehavior.
The state has also established a Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS), which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, that may be used to help students gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
- Suspension as a Last Resort: Suspension shall be imposed only when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct and then continues to provide an extensive list of suggested positive, non-exclusionary alternative practices. Other means of correction may include additional academic supports to ensure, for example, that instruction is academically appropriate, culturally relevant, and engaging for students at different educational levels and with diverse backgrounds.
- Restorative Justice and Other Approaches to Suspension and Expulsion? Several school districts, including some of the largest, have adopted board policies prohibiting willful defiance as the basis for suspension or expulsion and are committing resources to effectively implement alternative correction models, including restorative justice, positive behavior interventions and support, and other evidence-based approaches. For example, Oakland Unified School District has banned the suspension or expulsion of students based solely upon willful defiance. Oakland Unified offers restorative justice programs in their schools.
- Discretion. This bill prohibits school personnel from recommending suspension or expulsion from school for willfully defying school personnel and for being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities. This does not limit the ability of a teacher to suspend a student from class.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 4/20/23)
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond (co-source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color (co-source)
Dolores Huerta Foundation (co-source)
Alliance for Children's Rights
American Civil Liberties Union California Action
Asian Solidarity Collective
California Alliance for Youth and Community Justice
California County Superintendents
California Native Vote Project
California Public Defenders Association
California Youth Connection
California Youth Empowerment Network
Californians for Justice
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Children Now
City and County of San Francisco
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Asset Development Re-defining Education
Disability Rights California
Fresh Lifelines for Youth
Genders & Sexualities Alliance Network
Generation Up
Go Public Schools
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Law Foundation of Silicon Valley
Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles
Los Angeles County Office of Education
Los Angeles Unified School District
Mental Health America of California
Mid-City Community Advocacy Network
Pacific Juvenile Defender Center
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos
Seneca Family of Agencies
Sigma Beta Xi, Inc. Youth and Family Services
Teach Plus
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
The Children's Partnership
The Education Trust-West
Young Women's Freedom Center
Youth Alliance
Youth United for Community Action
Youth Will
2 Individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/20/23)
5 Individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Alliance of Boys and Men of Color, a co-sponsor of the measure, “AB 420 (Dickinson) successfully eliminated defiance expulsions and suspensions for students in grades K-3 (inclusive) and SB 419 (Skinner) successfully eliminated defiance suspensions for students in grades 4-6 (inclusive). Since the 2014-2015 school year, “defiance” suspensions have decreased from 125,419 to 21,465 in the 2021-2022 Academic Year. Despite this significant decrease many schools continue to use this policy and racial disparities persist. The simple act of ending willful defiance suspensions for all public school children recognizes the unique developmental vulnerabilities of youth, especially youth of color and youth with disabilities, by creating a school environment where every child has the opportunity to learn, thrive and succeed. It is for these reasons, the Alliance for Boys and Men of Color is pleased to co-sponsor and support SB 274.”
Prepared by: Kordell Hampton / ED. / (916) 651-4105
4/21/23 15:32:03
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: April 19, 2023
Author: | Skinner | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: .
SUMMARY
This bill extends the prohibition against the suspension and expulsion of students in grades K-8, to K-12, for disrupting school activities or willfully defying the valid authority of school personnel to all grades, indefinitely, but would retain a teacher’s existing authorization to suspend any student from class for willful defiance and prohibit the suspension or expulsion of a student based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
BACKGROUND
Existing Law
Education Code (EDC)
- Prohibits a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 5, inclusive, from being suspended and expelled for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. (EDC § 48900(k)(3))
- Prohibits until July 1, 2025, a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 6 to 8, inclusive, from being suspended for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties. (EDC § 48900(k)(4)
- Prohibits a pupil from being suspended or recommended for expulsion unless the superintendent of the school district or the principal of the school determines that the pupil has committed certain acts, including, among other acts, all of the following:
- Caused, attempted to cause, or threatened to cause physical injury to another person.
- Willfully used force or violence upon the person of another, except in self defense.
- Possessed, sold, or otherwise furnished a firearm, knife, explosive, or other dangerous object, except as specified.
- Unlawfully possessed, used, sold, or otherwise furnished, or been under the influence of, a controlled substance, an alcoholic beverage, or an intoxicant of any kind.
- Committed or attempted to commit robbery or extortion.
- Caused or attempted to cause damage to school property or private property.
- Stole or attempted to steal school property or private property.
- Committed an obscene act or engaged in habitual profanity or vulgarity.
- Committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault or committed sexual battery.
- Disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties.
- Engaged in, or attempted to engage in, hazing.
- Engaged in an act of bullying. (EDC § 48900)
- Authorizes a pupil enrolled in any of grades 4 to 12, inclusive, to be suspended from school or recommended for expulsion if the superintendent or the principal of the school in which the pupil is enrolled determines that the pupil has intentionally engaged in harassment, threats, or intimidation, directed against school district personnel or pupils, that is sufficiently severe or pervasive to have the actual and reasonably expected effect of materially disrupting classwork, creating substantial disorder, and invading the rights of either school personnel or pupils by creating an intimidating or hostile educational environment. (EDC § 48900.4)
- Authorizes school district superintendents and school principals to use discretion to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion that are age appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupil’s specific misbehavior, as specified. (EDC § 48900(v))
- States that suspension, including supervised suspension, shall be imposed only when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct, but authorizes a pupil, including a pupil with exceptional needs, to be suspended upon a first offense for certain acts (not including disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties) or the pupil’s presence causes a danger to persons. (EDC § 48900.5)
- Specifies that other means of correction include, but are not limited to:
- A conference between school personnel, the pupil’s parent or guardian, and the pupil.
- Referrals to the school counselor, psychologist, social worker, child welfare attendance personnel, or other school support service personnel for case management and counseling.
- Study teams, guidance teams, resource panel teams, or other intervention-related teams that assess the behavior, and develop and implement individualized plans to address the behavior in partnership with the pupil and his or her parents.
- Referral for a comprehensive psychosocial or psychoeducational assessment, including for purposes of creating an individualized education program, or a 504 plan.
- Enrollment in a program for teaching prosocial behavior or anger management.
- Participation in a restorative justice program.
- A positive behavior support approach with tiered interventions that occur during the schoolday on campus.
- After-school programs that address specific behavioral issues or expose pupils to positive activities and behaviors, including, but not limited to, those operated in collaboration with local parent and community groups.
- Community service, as specified. (EDC §48900.5)
- States that schools should consider implementing at least one of the following if the number of pupils suspended during the prior school year exceeded 30 percent of the school's enrollment:
- A supervised suspension program.
- A progressive discipline approach during the schoolday on campus (as an alternative to off-campus suspension), using any of the following activities:
- Conferences between the school staff, parents and pupils.
- Referral to the school counselor, psychologist, child welfare attendance personnel, or other school support service staff.
- Detention.
- Study teams, guidance teams, resource panel teams, or other assessment-related teams. (EDC § 48911.2)
- Authorizes teachers to suspend pupils from class for the day and the following day. If the pupil is to remain on campus during that suspension, the pupil must be under appropriate supervision. Teachers must ask the parent to attend a parent-teacher conference regarding the suspension. Pupils are prohibited from returning to the class from which he or she was suspended, during the period of the suspension, without the concurrence of the teacher and principal. (EDC § 48910)
ANALYSIS
This bill extends the prohibition against the suspension and expulsion of students in grades K-8, to K-12, for disrupting school activities or willfully defying the valid authority of school personnel to all grades, indefinitely, but would retain a teacher’s existing authorization to suspend any student from class for willful defiance and prohibit the suspension or expulsion of a student based solely on the fact that they are truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author “SB 274 is based on a simple premise: Students belong in school. Suspending youth for low-level behavior issues leads to significant harm, including learning loss and a higher likelihood that affected students will drop out of school completely. The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school. Students, especially those with behavioral issues, need to be in school where teachers and counselors can help them succeed. SB 274 puts the needs of students first. Instead of kicking them out of school, we owe it to students to figure out what’s causing them to act out and help them fix it.”
- Zero Tolerance Policies Disproportionate Effects. In 1994, Congress passed the Gun-Free Schools Act (GFSA), which required states to expel students who brought firearms to campus for at least one year. While zero tolerance policies were initially intended to ensure a safe and healthy school environment (e.g., selling drugs or engaging in gang-related fights on school grounds), policies were expanded to include minor offenses that would otherwise be seen as normal behavior. These policies inadvertently created the "School to Prison Pipeline," where youth expelled or suspended for minor offenses are funneled out of public schools and into the juvenile and criminal legal systems. The school-to-prison pipeline causes a disproportionate number of students of color to drop out of school and enter the criminal justice system, which can have life-changing adverse effects.
Although California's suspension rate has decreased recently, students of color are still disproportionately suspended compared to their peers. The California Department of Education (CDE) data shows that while total suspensions dropped from 363,406 in the 2017-18 school year (SY) to 233,753 in 2019-20 SY, black students received 15.6% of all suspensions for defiance-only in the 2017-18 SY and 18.7% in the 2019-20 SY. In recent years there have been other statutory provisions designed to limit the use of suspensions and promote alternatives to suspension. These provisions aim to address the root causes of the student’s behavior and to improve academic outcomes:
- Minimize Suspension for Attendance Issues: It is the intent of the Legislature that alternatives to suspension or expulsion be imposed against a pupil who is truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities.
- Instead of Suspension, Support: A superintendent of the school district or principal is encouraged to provide alternatives to suspension or expulsion, using a research-based framework with strategies that improve behavioral and academic outcomes, that are age-appropriate and designed to address and correct the pupil’s misbehavior.
The state has also established a Multi-Tiered System of Supports (MTSS), which includes restorative justice practices, trauma-informed practices, social and emotional learning, and schoolwide positive behavior interventions and support, that may be used to help students gain critical social and emotional skills, receive support to help transform trauma-related responses, understand the impact of their actions, and develop meaningful methods for repairing harm to the school community.
- Suspension as a Last Resort: Suspension shall be imposed only when other means of correction fail to bring about proper conduct, and then continues to provide an extensive list of suggested positive, non-exclusionary alternative practices. Other means of correction may include additional academic supports, to ensure, for example, that instruction is academically appropriate, culturally relevant, and engaging for students at different academic levels and with diverse backgrounds.
- Restorative Justice and Other Approaches to Suspension and Expulsion? Several school districts, including some of the largest, have adopted board policies prohibiting willful defiance as the basis for suspension or expulsion and are committing resources to effectively implement alternative correction models, including restorative justice, positive behavior interventions and support, and other evidence-based approaches. For example, Oakland Unified School District has banned the suspension or expulsion of students based solely upon willful defiance. Oakland Unified offers restorative justice programs in their schools. Furthermore, the Legislature has made significant investments to encourage local educational agencies (LEAs) to establish alternatives to suspension and expulsion.
• $100 million in competitive grants to LEAs to increase the number of teachers available to serve California state preschool and transitional kindergarten pupils and to provide teachers with training in inclusive practices, culturally responsive instruction, supporting dual language learners, enhancing social-emotional learning, implementing trauma-informed and restorative practices, and mitigating implicit biases to eliminate exclusionary discipline;
• $50 million to the Orange County Office of Education for support of MTSS efforts, including grants to LEAs to provide ongoing training and support in the use of trauma screening tools and mental health service referrals, and school climate surveys.
• $6 million for training LEAs on interpreting data from their local school climate surveys of pupils, families, and educators to inform continuous improvement efforts and better assess community needs stemming from the COVID-19 pandemic and distance learning; and for the CDE to develop an optional trauma-informed practice module to be used with school climate surveys.
Moreover, Governor Newsom signed AB 2598 (Weber) Chapter 914, Statutes of 2022 which required the CDE to develop and post on its website by June 1, 2024, evidence-based best practices for restorative justice practices for LEAs to implement to improve campus culture and climate.
- Discretion. This bill would prohibit school personnel from recommending suspension or expulsion from school for willfully defying school personnel and for being truant, tardy, or otherwise absent from school activities. This does not limit the ability of a teacher to suspend a student from class.
The committee may wish to consider whether this bill is a reasonable compromise between prohibiting suspension and expulsion from school and allowing teachers to continue to suspend students from class for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defying the authority of school officials.
- Local Control Accountability Plan (LCAP) State Priority: Pupil Engagement. One of the eight state priorities required to be addressed in the LCAP is pupil engagement, measured by suspension and expulsion rates. In their LCAPs, school districts, county offices of education, and charter schools have to explain their actions to achieve their goals for each state priority, including goals for reducing suspension rates. Given that LCAPs were first implemented for the 2014-15 school year, the overall reduction in suspensions and disruption/willful defiance could also be linked to the priority of pupil engagement.
- Related legislation.
SB 419 (Skinner), Chapter 279, Statutes of 2019, commencing July 1, 2020, extends the permanent prohibition against suspending a pupil enrolled in kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 3 for disrupting school activities or otherwise willfully defied the valid authority of school staff to include grades 4 and 5 permanently; and to include grades 6 to 8, inclusive, until July 1, 2025; and applies these prohibitions to charter schools
SB 607 (Skinner, 2017) would have required commencing July 1, 2019, permanently prohibits the suspension any pupil in kindergarten or grades 1 to 5, inclusive, and the expulsion of any pupil in kindergarten or in any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, who disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied valid authority of supervisors, teachers, administrators, school officials, or other school personnel engaged in the performance of their duties; prohibits, until July 1, 2023, the suspension of any pupil or grades 6 to 8, inclusive, for that same act; and makes these provisions applicable to charter schools. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown:
Teachers and principals are on the front lines educating our children and are in the best position to make decisions about order and discipline in the classroom. That's why I vetoed a similar bill in 2012. In addition, I just approved $15 million in the 2018 Budget Act to help local schools improve their disciplinary practices. Let's give educators a chance to invest that money wisely before issuing any further directives from the state.
AB 420 (Dickerson), Chapter 660, Statutes of 2014, eliminated the option to suspend or recommend for expulsion a pupil who disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the authority of school officials and instead authorizes schools to suspend a pupil in grades 6-12 who has substantially disrupted school activities or substantially prevented instruction from occurring.
SB 1111 (Lara), Chapter 837, Statutes of 2014, requires parental consent for referrals to a county community school by a school attendance review board (SARB), school district, or probation department, except for situations where a student is expelled or pursuant to a court order. This bill also establishes the right of a student to reenroll in his/her former school or another school upon completion of the term of involuntary transfer to a county community school.
AB 1729 (Ammiano), Chapter 425, Statutes of 2012, recasts provisions relative to the suspension of a pupil upon a first offense, and authorizes the use and documentation of other means of correction.
AB 2242 (Dickinson, 2012) would have prohibited pupils who are found to have disrupted school activities or otherwise willfully defied the authority of school officials from being subject to extended suspension, or recommended for expulsion. AB 2242 was vetoed by Governor Brown:
I cannot support limiting the authority of local school leaders, especially at a time when budget cuts have greatly increased class sizes and reduced the number of school personnel. It is important that teachers and school officials retain broad discretion to manage and set the tone in the classroom.
The principle of subsidiarity calls for greater, not less, deference to our elected school boards which are directly accountable to the citizenry.
AB 1909 (Ammiano), Chapter 849, Statutes of 2012, requires schools to notify a foster youth’s attorney and representative of the county child welfare agency of pending expulsion or other disciplinary proceedings.
SUPPORT
State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond (Co-Sponsor)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color (Co-Sponsor)
Dolores Huerta Foundation (Co-Sponsor)
Alliance for Children's Rights
American Civil Liberties Union California Action
Asian Solidarity Collective
California Alliance for Youth and Community Justice
California County Superintendents
California Native Vote Project
California Public Defenders Association
California Youth Empowerment Network
Californians for Justice
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Children Now
The Children’s Partnership
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Asset Development Re-defining Education
Disability Rights California
Fresh Lifelines for Youth
Genders & Sexualities Alliance Network
Generation Up
Go Public Schools
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Law Foundation of Silicon Valley
Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles
Los Angeles County Office of Education
Los Angeles Unified School District
Mental Health America of California
Mid-City Community Advocacy Network
Pacific Juvenile Defender Center
Public Advocates INC.
Public Counsel
Santa Cruz Barrios Unidos
Seneca Family of Agencies
Sigma Beta Xi, INC. Youth and Family Services
Teach Plus
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
The Children's Partnership
The Education Trust - West
Young Women's Freedom Center
Youth Alliance
Youth United for Community Action
Youth Will
2 Individuals
OPPOSITION
5 Individuals
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):