AB 813: Criminal procedure: postconviction relief.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-28
Under existing law, although persons not presently restrained of liberty may seek certain types of relief from the disabilities of a conviction, the writ of habeas corpus is generally not available to them. Existing law creates an explicit right for a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a judgment based on newly obtained evidence of fraud or misconduct by a government official, as specified.
This bill would create an explicit right for a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence based on a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, or based on newly discovered evidence of actual innocence, as specified. The bill would require a court to grant the motion if the moving party establishes a ground for relief, by a preponderance of the evidence. The bill would require a court granting or denying the motion to specify the basis for its conclusion.
Under existing law, although persons not presently restrained of liberty may seek certain types of relief from the disabilities of a conviction, the writ of habeas corpus is generally not available to them. Existing law creates an explicit right for a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a judgment based on newly obtained evidence of fraud or misconduct by a government official, as specified.
This bill would create an explicit right for a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence based on a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, or based on newly discovered evidence of actual innocence, as specified. The bill would require a court to grant the motion if the moving party establishes a ground for relief, by a preponderance of the evidence. The bill would require a court granting or denying the motion to specify the basis for its conclusion.
Under existing law, although persons not presently restrained of liberty may seek certain types of relief from the disabilities of a conviction, the writ of habeas corpus is generally not available to them. Existing law creates an explicit right for a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a judgment based on newly obtained evidence of fraud or misconduct by a government official, as specified.
This bill would create an explicit right for a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence based on a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, or based on newly discovered evidence of actual innocence, as specified. The bill would require a court to grant the motion if the moving party establishes a ground for relief, by a preponderance of the evidence. The bill would require a court granting or denying the motion to specify the basis for its conclusion.
Under existing law, although persons not presently restrained of liberty may seek certain types of relief from the disabilities of a conviction, the writ of habeas corpus is generally not available to them. Existing law creates an explicit right for a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a judgment based on newly obtained evidence of fraud or misconduct by a government official, as specified.
This bill would create an explicit right for a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence based on a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, or based on newly discovered evidence of actual innocence, as specified. The bill would require a court to grant the motion if the moving party establishes a ground for relief, by a preponderance of the evidence.
Under existing law, although persons not presently restrained of liberty may seek certain types of relief from the disabilities of a conviction, the writ of habeas corpus is generally not available to them. Existing law creates an explicit right for a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a judgment based on newly obtained evidence of fraud or misconduct by a government official, as specified.
This bill would create an explicit right for a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence based on error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of the conviction, a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, or based on newly discovered evidence of actual innocence, as specified. The bill would require a court to grant the motion if the moving party establishes a ground for relief, by a preponderance of the evidence.
Under existing law, although persons not presently restrained of liberty may seek certain types of relief from the disabilities of a conviction, the writ of habeas corpus is generally not available to them. Existing law creates an explicit right for a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a judgment based on newly obtained evidence of fraud or misconduct by a government official, as specified.
This bill would create an explicit right for a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence based on error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of the conviction, or based on newly discovered evidence of actual innocence, as specified. The bill would require a court to grant the motion if the moving party establishes a ground for relief, by a preponderance of the evidence.
If an offense is bailable, a judgment of imprisonment has been given, and the defendant will surrender himself or herself in execution of the judgment when, among other things, the judgment is affirmed or modified, existing law authorizes the defendant in a criminal case to be admitted to bail after the conviction and during the appeal of the conviction.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that authorizes judicial review of a conviction in a criminal case even if a person is not in custody.
If an offense is bailable, a judgment of imprisonment has been given, and the defendant will surrender himself or herself in execution of the judgment when, among other things, the judgment is affirmed or modified, existing law authorizes the defendant in a criminal case to be admitted to bail after the conviction and during the appeal of the conviction.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that authorizes judicial review of a conviction in a criminal case even if a person is not in custody.
(a)A person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
(1)The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(2)Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
(b)A motion pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
(1)The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
(2)The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
(c)A motion pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) shall be filed without undue delay from the date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(d)All motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
(e)When ruling on the motion:
(1)The court shall grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief specified in subdivision (a).
(2)In granting or denying the motion, the court shall specify the basis for its conclusion.
(3)If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
(f)An order granting or denying the motion is appealable under subdivision (b) of Section 1237 as an order after judgment affecting the substantial rights of a party.
(a)A person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
(1)The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(2)Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
(b)A motion pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
(1)The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
(2)The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
(c)A motion pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) shall be filed without undue delay from the date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(d)All motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
(e)When ruling on the motion:
(1)The court shall grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief specified in subdivision (a).
(2)In granting or denying the motion, the court shall specify the basis for its conclusion.
(3)If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
(f)An order granting or denying the motion is appealable under subdivision (b) of Section 1237 as an order after judgment affecting the substantial rights of a party.
(a)A person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
(1)The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(2)Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
(b)A motion pursuant to this section paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
(1)The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
(2)The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
(3)The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(4)The effective date of this section.
(c)A motion pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) shall be filed without undue delay from the date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(c)
(d)All motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
(d)
(e)When ruling on the motion:
(1)The court shall grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief specified in subdivision (a).
(2)In granting or denying the motion, the court shall make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented. specify the basis for its conclusion.
(3)If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
(e)
(f)An order granting or denying the motion is appealable under subdivision (b) of Section 1237 as an order after judgment affecting the substantial rights of a party.
(a)A person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
(1)The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(2)Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
(b)A motion pursuant to this section shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
(1)The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
(2)The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
(3)The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(4)The effective date of this section.
(c)All motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
(d)When ruling on the motion:
(1)The court shall grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief specified in subdivision (a).
(2)In granting or denying the motion, the court shall make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
(3)If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
(e)An order granting or denying the motion is appealable under subdivision (b) of Section 1237 as an order after judgment affecting the substantial rights of a party.
(a)A person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for any either of the following reasons:
(1)The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of the conviction. a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
(2)Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
(b)A motion pursuant to this section shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
(1)The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
(2)The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
(3)The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(4)The effective date of this section.
(c)All motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
(d)When ruling on the motion:
(1)The court shall grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief specified in subdivision (a).
(2)In granting or denying the motion, the court shall make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
(3)If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court must shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
(e)An order granting or denying the motion is appealable under subdivision (b) of Section 1237 as an order after judgment affecting the substantial rights of a party.
(a)A person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for any of the following reasons:
(1)The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to error damaging the moving partys ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of the conviction.
(2)Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
(b)A motion pursuant to this section shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
(1)The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
(2)The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
(3)The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
(4)The effective date of this section.
(c)All motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
(d)When ruling on the motion:
(1)The court shall grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief specified in subdivision (a).
(2)In granting or denying the motion, the court shall make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
(3)If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court must allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
(e)An order granting or denying the motion is appealable under subdivision (b) of Section 1237 as an order after judgment affecting the substantial rights of a party.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that authorizes judicial review of a conviction in a criminal case even if a person is not in custody.
It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that authorizes judicial review of a conviction in a criminal case even if a person is not in custody.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 6469.) |
| Aug 30, 2016 | From committee: That the Senate amendments be concurred in. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (August 30). |
| Aug 30, 2016 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| Aug 29, 2016 | Action rescinded whereby the Assembly concurred in Senate amendments. |
| Aug 29, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. |
| Aug 29, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 24, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 26 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 26. Noes 11. Page 5022.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 26. Noes 11.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 11). |
| Jun 20, 2016 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 19, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 10, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (May 10). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jul 7, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 23, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 22, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 10, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 28, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 18, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 18, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 65. Noes 11. Page 1476.) |
| May 18, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 14, 2015 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1429.) |
| May 14, 2015 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 7, 2015 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 1331.) |
| May 7, 2015 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 23, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 22, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 21). |
| Apr 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 29. |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2016 | AB 813 GONZALEZ Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2016 | With recommendation: That Senate amendments be concurred in. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Aug 29, 2016 | AB 813 GONZALEZ Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB813 Gonzalez By Leno | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 10, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2015 | AB 813 GONZALEZ Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 21, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA2 Bill Id:AB 813
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:June 22, 2015
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 65-11 | (May 18, 2015) | SENATE: | 26-11 | (August 16, 2016) |
COMMITTEE VOTE: | 5-1 | (August 30, 2016) | RECOMMENDATION: | concur |
(Pub. S.)
Original Committee Reference: PUB. S.
SUMMARY: Creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction following a guilty plea based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction.
The Senate amendments:
- State that a motion to vacate a guilty-plea conviction based on a misunderstanding of immigration consequences must be filed with reasonable diligence, whereas a motion to vacate a conviction based on newly-discovered evidence of actual innocence must be filed without undue delay from the date of discovery.
- Require the court to specify its basis for granting or denying the motion, rather than make findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States."
- Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea.
- Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea.
- Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint.
- Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery.
AS PASSED BY THE ASSEMBLY:
- Permitted a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
- The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party's ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere; or,
- Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires the conviction or sentence be vacated either as a matter of law, or in the interests of justice.
- Required a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
- The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
- The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
- The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section; or
- The effective date of this section.
- Entitled the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
- Required the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
- Required the court when ruling on the motion to make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
- Required the court to allow the moving party to withdraw the plea if it grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
- Permitted an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, to the extent additional motions to vacate are filed with the courts and evidentiary hearings are conducted as required for all motions filed pursuant to the provisions of this measure, significant additional workload for the trial courts could result. While the fiscal impact cannot be estimated with certainty, costs could potentially exceed the low millions of dollars (General Fund*) annually for additional court workload based on the estimated hourly court cost of $837. To the extent even five to 10 petitions for relief are filed per county could cost in the range of $1.9 million to $3.9 million statewide assuming eight hours of court time per case, which includes locating the historic record, reviewing the case, setting the case for hearing, allowing for discovery, conducting the hearing, and making a final judgment on the record.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
COMMENTS: According to the author, "AB 813 will give hope to those who have been wronged by an unlawful conviction by establishing a way to challenge it after their criminal custody has ended. Even though current law requires defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants of the immigration consequences of convictions, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Failure to understand the true consequences of pleading guilty to certain felonies, for example, has led to the unnecessary separation of families across California. AB 813 does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present their case in front of a judge, a procedure that already exists in most of the country."
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0005003
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 813
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:June 22, 2015
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 65-11 | (May 18, 2015) | SENATE: | 26-11 | (August 16, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: PUB. S.
SUMMARY: Creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction following a guilty plea based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction.
The Senate amendments:
- State that a motion to vacate a guilty-plea conviction based on a misunderstanding of immigration consequences must be filed with reasonable diligence, whereas a motion to vacate a conviction based on newly-discovered evidence of actual innocence must be filed without undue delay from the date of discovery.
- Require the court to specify its basis for granting or denying the motion, rather than make findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States."
- Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea.
- Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea.
- Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint.
- Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery.
AS PASSED BY THE ASSEMBLY:
- Permitted a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
- The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party's ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere; or,
- Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires the conviction or sentence be vacated either as a matter of law, or in the interests of justice.
- Required a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
- The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
- The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
- The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section; or
- The effective date of this section.
- Entitled the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
- Required the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
- Required the court when ruling on the motion to make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
- Required the court to allow the moving party to withdraw the plea if it grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
- Permitted an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, to the extent additional motions to vacate are filed with the courts and evidentiary hearings are conducted as required for all motions filed pursuant to the provisions of this measure, significant additional workload for the trial courts could result. While the fiscal impact cannot be estimated with certainty, costs could potentially exceed the low millions of dollars (General Fund*) annually for additional court workload based on the estimated hourly court cost of $837. To the extent even five to 10 petitions for relief are filed per county could cost in the range of $1.9 million to $3.9 million statewide assuming eight hours of court time per case, which includes locating the historic record, reviewing the case, setting the case for hearing, allowing for discovery, conducting the hearing, and making a final judgement on the record.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
COMMENTS: According to the author, "AB 813 will give hope to those who have been wronged by an unlawful conviction by establishing a way to challenge it after their criminal custody has ended. Even though current law requires defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants of the immigration consequences of convictions, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Failure to understand the true consequences of pleading guilty to certain felonies, for example, has led to the unnecessary separation of families across California. AB 813 does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present their case in front of a judge, a procedure that already exists in most of the country."
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0004167
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 813
:
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/10/16
AYES: Hancock, Glazer, Leno, Liu, Monning
NOES: Anderson, Stone
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-11, 5/18/15 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: American Civil Liberties Union
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
DIGEST: This bill creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction or sentence based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction.
Existing federal law:
- Lists several categories of crimes which render a non-citizen removable from the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; aggravated felony convictions; domestic violence convictions; firearm convictions, and drug convictions. (INA § 237(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2).)
- Lists several categories of crimes which will render a non-citizen inadmissible to the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; drug convictions; and prostitution convictions. (INA § 212(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2).)
Existing state law:
- Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States." (Penal Code § 1016.5 (a).)
- Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea. (Penal Code § 1016.5 (a).)
- Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea. (Penal Code § 1018.)
- Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint. (Penal Code § 1473 (a).)
- Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery. (Penal Code § 1473.6.)
This bill:
- Permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
- The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere; or,
- Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
- Provides that a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
- The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal; or,
- The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
- Provides that the motion shall be filed without undue delay from the date of the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this bill.
- Entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
- Requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
- Requires the court when ruling on the motion to specify the basis for its conclusions.
- Provides that if the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
- Permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
Background
This bill creates a new mechanism for post-conviction relief for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody. Specifically, it allows a person to move to vacate a conviction due to error affecting his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential immigration consequences of the conviction.
In Padilla v. Kentucky (2010) 559 U.S. 356, the United States Supreme court held that the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to provide affirmative and competent advice to noncitizen defendants regarding the potential immigration consequences of their criminal cases. (Id. at p. 360.) Specifically, the United States Supreme Court held that defense counsel is constitutionally deficient if there is a failure to advise a noncitizen client entering a plea to a criminal offense of the risk of deportation. "Deportation as a consequence of a criminal conviction has become an integral part of the penalty for a criminal conviction for noncitizens, sometimes the most important part.” (Id. at p. 364.) The court's holding is not limited to only affirmative mis-advice of the consequence because that would encourage defense counsel to remain silent on a matter of great importance to a noncitizen client, and that would be inconsistent with counsel's duty to provide advice to a client considering the advantages and disadvantages of a plea agreement. (Id. at pp. 370-371.)
A criminal defendant who is no longer in "custody" for purposes of the writ of habeas corpus, can move to withdraw a guilty plea if the trial court accepting the plea, failed to admonish the defendant of the possible immigration consequence of the plea under Penal Code Section 1016.5. There is no time limit within which such a motion must be filed, but there is a due diligence requirement. (People v. Zamudio (2000) 23 Cal.4th 183.) However, the grounds for this basis of relief are quite limited. It is only available where the court fails to give the general admonishment or the record is silent on the matter. (People v. Martinez (2013) 57 Cal.4th 555, 565.)
At this time, under California law, there is no vehicle to for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody to challenge his or her conviction based on a mistake of law regarding immigration consequences or ineffective assistance of counsel in properly advising of these consequences when the person learns of the error post-custody. The Padilla case requiring that a defense counsel properly advise a person on immigration consequences was subsequent to prohibiting the use of corum nobis and so this bill creates a mechanism for post-conviction relief where there is not one currently.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, to the extent additional motions to vacate are filed with the courts and evidentiary hearings are conducted as required for all motions filed pursuant to the provisions of this measure, significant additional workload for the trial courts could result. While the fiscal impact cannot be estimated with certainty, costs could potentially exceed the low millions of dollars (General Fund*) annually for additional court workload based on the estimated hourly court cost of $837. To the extent even five to 10 petitions for relief are filed per county could cost in the range of $1.9 million to $3.9 million statewide assuming eight hours of court time per case, which includes locating the historic record, reviewing the case, setting the case for hearing, allowing for discovery, conducting the hearing, and making a final judgment on the record.
American Civil Liberties Union (co-source)
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice (co-source)
California Public Defenders Association (co-source)
A New Way of Life Re-Entry Project
ACCESS Women’s Health Justice
Alameda County Public Defender
California Immigrant Policy Center
Centro Legal de la Raza
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Equal Justice Society
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Immigrant Defense Project
Immigrant Legal Resource Center
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Northern California Innocence Project
Pangea Legal Services
Post-Conviction Justice Project of the USC Gould School of Law
Public Counsel
Root and Rebound
Rubicon Programs
Santa Clara County Public Defender’s Office
SEIU California
The Immigrant Rights Clinic at the University of California Irvine School of Law Lawyers Committee of Civil Rights of the SF Bay Area
The National Day Laborer Organizing Network
Unite Here Local 30
W. Haywood Burns Institute
One individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/11/16)
Alameda County District Attorney
Judicial Council of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Alameda County Public Defender supports this bill stating:
Currently, only people who are in prison, on parole or on probation may ask a court to review the validity of their conviction. People with old convictions—who long ago completed their sentence and have become productive members of society—have not way to raise a claim of innocence or otherwise challenge the legal validity of the convictions. California is one of the very few states that lacks a vehicle for post-custodial review. In fact, forty-four other states and the federal government all provide individuals with a way of challenging unjust convictions after criminal custody has ended.
This deficiency in current law has a particularly devastating impact on California’s immigrant communities. While the criminal penalty for a conviction is obvious and immediate, the immigration penalty can remain “invisible” until an encounter with the immigration system raises the issue. Since 1987, California law has required defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants about the immigration consequences of convictions. But, despite this requirement, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Immigrants may only find out that their conviction makes them deplorable when, years later, Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiates removal proceedings. By then, however, it is too late. Without any vehicle to challenge their convictions in state court, immigrants are routinely deported on the basis of conviction that never should have existed in the first place.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Alameda County District Attorney opposes this bill stating:
I oppose this bill for many reasons. The first is that existing law already creates a mechanism for a person to seek relief if they did not know their immigration consequences of a conviction. Second, this bill requires all motions shall be entitled to a hearing which removes the discretion from the court to have a hearing because there is not requirement of showing or new evidence. Also this new hearing also doesn’t require the defendant to be present for the hearing so who is going to testify that he or she didn’t understand their immigration consequences.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-11, 5/18/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Olsen, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NOES: Travis Allen, Baker, Brough, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Obernolte, Patterson, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Kim, Mathis, Melendez
8/15/16 20:26:50
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 813 (Gonzalez) - Criminal procedure: post-conviction relief
Version: June 22, 2015 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: June 20, 2016 | Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 813 would establish a process of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons: (1) the conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging a person’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction, or (2) newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
Fiscal Impact:
To the extent additional motions to vacate are filed with the courts and evidentiary hearings are conducted as required for all motions filed pursuant to the provisions of this measure, significant additional workload for the trial courts could result. While the fiscal impact cannot be estimated with certainty, costs could potentially exceed the low millions of dollars (General Fund*) annually for additional court workload based on the estimated hourly court cost of $837. To the extent even five to ten petitions for relief are filed per county could cost in the range of $1.9 million to $3.9 million statewide assuming eight hours of court time per case, which includes locating the historic record, reviewing the case, setting the case for hearing, allowing for discovery, conducting the hearing, and making a final judgement on the record.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
In Padilla v. Kentucky (2010) 559 U.S. 356, the United States (U.S.) Supreme Court held that the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to provide affirmative and competent advice to noncitizen defendants regarding the potential immigration consequences of their criminal cases. Specifically, the U.S. Supreme Court held that defense counsel is constitutionally deficient if there is a failure to advise a noncitizen client entering a plea to a criminal offense of the risk of deportation. "Deportation as a consequence of a criminal conviction has become an integral part of the penalty for a criminal conviction for noncitizens, sometimes the most important part. (Id. at p. 364.) The court's holding is not limited to only affirmative mis-advice of the consequence as that would encourage defense counsel to remain silent on a matter of great importance to a noncitizen client, and that would be inconsistent with counsel's duty to provide advice to a client considering the advantages and disadvantages of a plea agreement. (Id. at pp. 370-371.)
A criminal defendant who is no longer in "custody" for purposes of the writ of habeas corpus, can move to withdraw a guilty plea if the trial court accepting the plea, failed to admonish the defendant of the possible immigration consequence of the plea under Penal Code § 1016.5. There is no time limit within which such a motion must be filed, but there is a due diligence requirement. (People v. Zamudio (2000) 23 Cal.4th 183.) However, the grounds for this basis of relief are quite limited. It is only available where the court fails to give the general admonishment or the record is silent on the matter. (People v. Martinez (2013) 57 Cal.4th 555, 565.)
Under California law, there is currently no means for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody to challenge his or her conviction based on a mistake of law regarding immigration consequences or ineffective assistance of counsel in properly advising of these consequences when the person learns of the error post-custody. The Padilla case requiring defense counsel to properly advise a person of potential immigration consequences was subsequent to the California decision in People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1107, prohibiting the use of a writ of corum nobis. This bill would create a mechanism for post-conviction relief where there is not one currently.
Proposed Law:
This bill would provide that a person no longer imprisoned or restrained may prosecute a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
- The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
- Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists that requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
This bill provides that a motion pursuant to (1) above shall be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
- The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal.
- The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final.
This bill provides that a motion pursuant to (2) above shall be filed without undue delay from the date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
This bill specifies that all motions shall be entitled to a hearing. At the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without the personal presence of the moving party if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
When ruling on the motion, this bill:
- Requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the grounds for relief, as specified.
- In granting or denying the motion, the court shall specify the basis for its conclusion.
- If the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
- Provides that an order granting or denying the motion is appealable, as specified.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1343 (Thurmond) Chapter 705/2015 requires defense counsel to provide accurate advice on the potential immigration consequences of a proposed plea agreement, consistent with the provisions of Padilla. AB 1343 additionally requires the prosecution and defense counsel to contemplate immigration consequences in the plea negotiation process.
AB 267 (Jones-Sawyer) 2015 would have required the court, prior to the acceptance of a guilty plea to a felony offense, to inform the defendant of the various consequences that may result from conviction of a felony offense. This bill allowed the court to provide the required advisement through a form notice presented to the defendant, or a bulletin posted in the courtroom. This bill was vetoed by the Governor with the following message:
I am returning Assembly Bill 267 without my signature. This bill requires the court to provide a criminal defendant with information about a wide array of potential consequences of a guilty plea. I believe ensuring adequate consideration of the various consequences of a criminal conviction prior to a guilty plea is the responsibility of the defendant's counsel, who is best situated to determine which advisements are appropriate and meaningful to the defendant.
Staff Comments:
By establishing a new process for post-conviction relief, this bill could result in a significant number of court filings by persons no longer in custody who are seeking to have their sentences or convictions vacated. The Judicial Council has indicated that while the circumstances upon which a court may vacate a sentence or conviction are limited (lack of understanding about potential adverse immigration consequences, or newly discovered evidence of actual innocence), it is likely that far more individuals will file motions than are eligible for this post-conviction relief.
In addition to the potential increase in filings for post-conviction relief, this bill requires that all motions shall be entitled to a hearing, irrespective of whether or not a petitioner has demonstrated a prima facie case in his or her favor. By prohibiting judicial discretion to deny a motion to vacate based on an insufficient showing of evidence to warrant a hearing, this bill could potentially result in significant court costs to conduct such hearings.
While the fiscal impact of this measure cannot be estimated with certainty, costs to the courts could potentially exceed the low millions of dollars annually for additional court workload based on the estimated hourly court cost of $837. To the extent even five to ten motions are filed in each county per year could cost in the range of $1.9 million to $3.9 million statewide assuming eight hours of court time per case, which includes locating the historic record, reviewing the case, setting the case for hearing, allowing for discovery, conducting the hearing, and making a final judgement on the record. To the extent the number of motions filed is greater or less than noted above, and/or the court time attributable to each case is greater or less than estimated above, the annual costs would be commensurately higher or lower. To the extent motions to vacate are currently being filed in the courts via other approaches (i.e., through coram nobis petitions, PC §1016.5 motions) for this population would serve to potentially offset, only in minor part, the potential costs of this measure.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 813 Hearing Date: May 10, 2016
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | June 22, 2015 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Criminal Procedure: Post-Conviction Relief
HISTORY
Source: American Civil Liberties Union
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Prior Legislation: AB 267 (Jones-Sawyer) – Vetoed 2015
AB 1343 (Thurmond) – Chapter 705, Stats. 2015
AB 1352 (Eggman) – Chapter 646, Stats. 2015
Support: ACCESS Women’s Health Justice; Alameda County Public Defender; California Immigrant Policy Center; Centro Legal de la Raza; Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; Equal Justice Society; Friends Committee on Legislation of California; Immigrant Defense Project; Immigrant Legal Resource Center; The Immigrant Rights Clinic at the University of California Irvine School of Law; Lawyers Committee of Civil Rights of the SF Bay Area; Legal Services for Prisoners with Children; The National Day Laborer Organizing Network; A New Way of Life Re-Entry Project; Northern California Innocence Project; Pangea Legal Services; Post-Conviction Justice Project of the USC Gould School of Law; Public Counsel; Root and Rebound; Rubicon Programs; Santa Clara County Public Defender’s Office; SEIU California; Unite Here Local 30; W. Haywood Burns Institute; one individual
Opposition: Alameda County District Attorney; Judicial Council of California (unless amended)
Assembly Floor Vote: 65 - 11
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to create a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction or sentence based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction.
Existing law requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows:
"If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States." (Penal Code § 1016.5 (a).)
Existing law permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea. (Penal Code, § 1016.5 (a).)
Existing law permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea. (Penal Code § 1018.)
Existing law allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint. (Penal Code § 1473 (a).)
Existing law authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery. (Pen. Code, § 1473.6.)
Existing federal law lists several categories of crimes which render a non-citizen removable from the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; aggravated felony convictions; domestic violence convictions; firearm convictions, and drug convictions. (INA § 237(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2).)
Existing federal law lists several categories of crimes which will render a non-citizen inadmissible to the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; drug convictions; and prostitution convictions. (INA § 212(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2).)
This bill permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
- The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere; or,
- Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
This bill provides that a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
- The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
- The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
This bill provides that the motion shall be filed without undue delay from the date of the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
This bill entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
This bill requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
This bill requires the court when ruling on the motion to specify the basis for its conclusions.
This bill provides that if the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
This bill permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past several years this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
- 143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
- 141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
- 137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In December of 2015 the administration reported that as “of December 9, 2015, 112,510 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.0% of design bed capacity, and 5,264 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. The current population is 1,212 inmates below the final court-ordered population benchmark of 137.5% of design bed capacity, and has been under that benchmark since February 2015.” (Defendants’ December 2015 Status Report in Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).) One year ago, 115,826 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounted to 140.0% of design bed capacity, and 8,864 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. (Defendants’ December 2014 Status Report in Response to February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).)
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
- Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
- Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
- Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
- Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
- Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
California lags far behind the rest of the country in its failure to provide its residents with a means of challenging unlawful convictions after their criminal sentences have been served. Forty-four states and the federal government all provide individuals with a way of challenging unjust convictions after criminal custody has ended. In California, however, individuals who gain access to evidence of actual innocence - or to proof of a defect in the underlying criminal proceeding - have no way to present this evidence before the court after criminal custody has expired.
This omission has a particularly devastating impact on California’s immigrant community. Since 1987, California law has required defense counsel to inform non-citizen defendants about the immigration consequences of convictions. However, many defense attorneys still fail to do so. Many immigrants suffer convictions without having any idea that their criminal record will, at some point in the future, result in mandatory immigration imprisonment and deportation, permanently separating families.
While the criminal penalty for a conviction is clear, the immigration penalty can remain “invisible” until an encounter with the immigration system raises the issue. For many immigrants, the first time they learn of the immigration consequences of a conviction can occur years after they have successfully completed their criminal sentence when Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiates removal proceedings. Challenging the unlawful criminal conviction is often the only remedy available to allow immigrants an opportunity to remain with their families in the United States. Yet, in California, affected individuals have no way of challenging their unjust convictions once probation ends, because they no longer satisfy habeas corpus’ strict custody requirements. Californians are thus routinely deported on the basis of convictions that never should have existed in the first place.
AB 813 will fill a gap in California criminal procedure by providing a means for people to challenge their legally invalid convictions. The proposal does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present a case in front of a judge.
2. People v. Kim (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1078
Kim was a legal resident, but not a citizen of the United States, when he suffered multiple criminal convictions. The federal government sought to deport him based on the convictions, and Kim petitioned for a writ of error coram nobis, seeking to vacate the convictions which triggered the deportation proceedings based on his unawareness of the immigration consequences of his plea. The California Supreme Court granted review to address whether persons in similar situations are entitled to have their guilty pleas vacated by a writ of error coram nobis. (Id. at p. 1084.)
The Supreme Court observed, the writ of coram nobis is granted only when three requirements are met. First, the petitioner must demonstrate that some fact existed which, through no fault or negligence on his part, was not presented to the court at the trial, and which if presented would have prevented the rendition of the judgment. Next, the petitioner must show that the newly discovered evidence does not go to the merits of issues tried because issues of fact, once adjudicated, even if incorrectly, cannot be reopened except on motion for new trial. This requirement applies even though the evidence in question is not discovered until after the deadline for filing a motion for new trial time or after the motion has been denied. Finally, the petitioner must show that the relied-upon facts were not known to him or her and could not in the exercise of due diligence have been discovered at any time substantially earlier than the time of the motion for the writ. (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at pp. 1092-1093, citing People v. Shipman (1965) 62 Cal.2d 226.)
The Court held that Kim was ineligible for a coram nobis relief. Kim was put on notice of the possible immigration consequences pertaining to the plea agreement. The fact that the actual immigration consequences of the plea were unknown to the court and the parties was a mistake of law, not a mistake of fact. Kim's claim amounted to a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, which is not reviewable by way of writ of coram nobis. Here, Kim's contention was not a basic flaw which would have prevented rendition of the judgment, but rather facts which went to the legal effect of the judgment. (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at pp. 1102-1103.) In Kim, the Court concluded by noting, "[T]he Legislature has been active in providing statutory remedies when the existing remedies such as habeas corpus have proven ineffective. Section 1016.5 especially shows the Legislature's concern that those who plead guilty or no contest to criminal charges are aware of the immigration consequences of their pleas. Because the Legislature remains free to enact further statutory remedies for those in defendant's position, we are disinclined to reinterpret the historic writ of error coram nobis to provide the remedy he seeks." (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1107.)
3. Motion for Post-Conviction Relief
This bill creates a new mechanism for post-conviction relief for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody. Specifically, it allows a person to move to vacate a conviction due to error affecting his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential immigration consequences of the conviction.
In Padilla v. Kentucky (2010) 559 U.S. 356, the United States Supreme court held that the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to provide affirmative and competent advice to noncitizen defendants regarding the potential immigration consequences of their criminal cases. (Id. at p. 360.) Specifically, the United States Supreme Court held that defense counsel is constitutionally deficient if there is a failure to advise a noncitizen client entering a plea to a criminal offense of the risk of deportation. "Deportation as a consequence of a criminal conviction has become an integral part of the penalty for a criminal conviction for noncitizens, sometimes the most important part. (Id. at p. 364.) The court's holding is not limited to only affirmative mis-advice of the consequence because that would encourage defense counsel to remain silent on a matter of great importance to a noncitizen client, and that would be inconsistent with counsel's duty to provide advice to a client considering the advantages and disadvantages of a plea agreement. (Id. at pp. 370-371.)
A criminal defendant who is no longer in "custody" for purposes of the writ of habeas corpus, can move to withdraw a guilty plea if the trial court accepting the plea, failed to admonish the defendant of the possible immigration consequence of the plea under Penal Code section 1016.5. There is no time limit within which such a motion must be filed, but there is a due diligence requirement. (People v. Zamudio (2000) 23 Cal.4th 183.) However, the grounds for this basis of relief are quite limited. It is only available where the court fails to give the general admonishment or the record is silent on the matter. (People v. Martinez (2013) 57 Cal.4th 555, 565.)
At this time, under California law, there is no vehicle to for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody to challenge his or her conviction based on a mistake of law regarding immigration consequences or ineffective assistance of counsel in properly advising of these consequences when the person learns of the error post-custody. The Padilla case requiring that a defense counsel properly advise a person on immigration consequences was subsequent to the California decision in Kim prohibiting the use of corum nobis and so this bill would create a mechanism for post-conviction relief where there is not one currently.
4. Support
The Alameda County Public Defender supports this bill stating:
Currently, only people who are in prison, on parole or on probation may ask a court to review the validity of their conviction. People with old convictions—who long ago completed their sentence and have become productive members of society—have not way to raise a claim of innocence or otherwise challenge the legal validity of the convictions. California is one of the very few states that lacks a vehicle for post-custodial review. In fact, forty-four other states and the federal government all provide individuals with a way of challenging unjust convictions after criminal custody has ended.
This deficiency in current law has a particularly devastating impact on California’s immigrant communities. While the criminal penalty for a conviction is obvious and immediate, the immigration penalty can remain “invisible” until an encounter with the immigration system raises the issue. Since 1987, California law has required defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants about the immigration consequences of convictions. But, despite this requirement, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Immigrants may only find out that their conviction makes them deplorable when, years later, Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiates removal proceedings. By then, however, it is too late. Without any vehicle to challenge their convictions in state court, immigrants are routinely deported on the basis of conviction that never should have existed in the first place.
5. Opposition
The Alameda County District Attorney opposes this bill stating:
I oppose this bill for many reasons. The first is that existing law already creates a mechanism for a person to seek relief if they did not know their immigration consequences of a conviction. Second, this bill requires all motions shall be entitled to a hearing which removes the discretion from the court to have a hearing because there is not requirement of showing or new evidence. Also this new hearing also doesn’t require the defendant to be present for the hearing so who is going to testify that he or she didn’t understand their immigration consequences.
-- END –
AB 813 (Gonzalez ) Page 7 of 7
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Loni Hancock, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 813 Hearing Date: July 7, 2015
Author: |
Gonzalez |
||
Version: |
June 22, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
MK |
||
Subject: Criminal Procedure: Post-Conviction Relief
HISTORY
Source: American Civil Liberties Union
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
Prior Legislation: None
Support: Alameda County Public Defender; California Immigrant Policy Center; Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles; Immigrant Defense Project; Immigrant Legal Resource Center; The Immigrant Rights Clinic at the University of California Irvine School of Law; Lawyers Committee of Civil Rights of the SF Bay Area; Legal Services for Prisoners with Children; The National Day Laborer Organizing Network; Pangea Legal Services; Public Counsel; Root and Rebound; Rubicon Programs
Opposition: Alameda County District Attorney; Judicial Council of California (unless amended)
Assembly Floor Vote: 65 - 11
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to create a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction or sentence based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction.
Existing law requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows:
"If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States." (Penal Code § 1016.5 (a).)
Existing law permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea. (Penal Code, § 1016.5 (a).)
Existing law permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea. (Penal Code § 1018.)
Existing law allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint. (Penal Code § 1473 (a).)
Existing law authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery. (Pen. Code, § 1473.6.)
Existing federal law lists several categories of crimes which render a non-citizen removable from the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; aggravated felony convictions; domestic violence convictions; firearm convictions, and drug convictions. (INA § 237(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2).)
Existing federal law lists several categories of crimes which will render a non-citizen inadmissible to the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; drug convictions; and prostitution convictions. (INA § 212(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2).)
This bill permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere; or,
Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires vacation of the conviction or sentence as a matter of law or in the interests of justice.
This bill provides that a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
This bill provides that the motion shall be filed without undue delay from the date of the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section.
This bill entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
This bill requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
This bill requires the court when ruling on the motion to specify the basis for its conclusions.
This bill provides that if the court grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere, the court shall allow the moving party to withdraw the plea.
This bill permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
RECEIVERSHIP/OVERCROWDING CRISIS AGGRAVATION
For the past eight years, this Committee has scrutinized legislation referred to its jurisdiction for any potential impact on prison overcrowding. Mindful of the United States Supreme Court ruling and federal court orders relating to the state’s ability to provide a constitutional level of health care to its inmate population and the related issue of prison overcrowding, this Committee has applied its “ROCA” policy as a content-neutral, provisional measure necessary to ensure that the Legislature does not erode progress in reducing prison overcrowding.
On February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows:
143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014;
141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and,
137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
In February of this year the administration reported that as “of February 11, 2015, 112,993 inmates were housed in the State’s 34 adult institutions, which amounts to 136.6% of design bed capacity, and 8,828 inmates were housed in out-of-state facilities. This current population is now below the court-ordered reduction to 137.5% of design bed capacity.”( Defendants’ February 2015 Status Report In Response To February 10, 2014 Order, 2:90-cv-00520 KJM DAD PC, 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (fn. omitted).
While significant gains have been made in reducing the prison population, the state now must stabilize these advances and demonstrate to the federal court that California has in place the “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14). The Committee’s consideration of bills that may impact the prison population therefore will be informed by the following questions:
Whether a proposal erodes a measure which has contributed to reducing the prison population;
Whether a proposal addresses a major area of public safety or criminal activity for which there is no other reasonable, appropriate remedy;
Whether a proposal addresses a crime which is directly dangerous to the physical safety of others for which there is no other reasonably appropriate sanction;
Whether a proposal corrects a constitutional problem or legislative drafting error; and
Whether a proposal proposes penalties which are proportionate, and cannot be achieved through any other reasonably appropriate remedy.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
California lags far behind the rest of the country in its failure to provide its residents with a means of challenging unlawful convictions after their criminal sentences have been served. Forty-four states and the federal government all provide individuals with a way of challenging unjust convictions after criminal custody has ended. In California, however, individuals who gain access to evidence of actual innocence - or to proof of a defect in the underlying criminal proceeding - have no way to present this evidence before the court after criminal custody has expired.
This omission has a particularly devastating impact on California’s immigrant community. Since 1987, California law has required defense counsel to inform non-citizen defendants about the immigration consequences of convictions. However, many defense attorneys still fail to do so. Many immigrants suffer convictions without having any idea that their criminal record will, at some point in the future, result in mandatory immigration imprisonment and deportation, permanently separating families.
While the criminal penalty for a conviction is clear, the immigration penalty can remain “invisible” until an encounter with the immigration system raises the issue. For many immigrants, the first time they learn of the immigration consequences of a conviction can occur years after they have successfully completed their criminal sentence when Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiates removal proceedings. Challenging the unlawful criminal conviction is often the only remedy available to allow immigrants an opportunity to remain with their families in the United States. Yet, in California, affected individuals have no way of challenging their unjust convictions once probation ends, because they no longer satisfy habeas corpus’ strict custody requirements. Californians are thus routinely deported on the basis of convictions that never should have existed in the first place.
AB 813 will fill a gap in California criminal procedure by providing a means for people to challenge their legally invalid convictions. The proposal does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present a case in front of a judge.
2. People v. Kim (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1078
Kim was a legal resident, but not a citizen of the United States, when he suffered multiple criminal convictions. The federal government sought to deport him based on the convictions, and Kim petitioned for a writ of error coram nobis, seeking to vacate the convictions which triggered the deportation proceedings based on his unawareness of the immigration consequences of his plea. The California Supreme Court granted review to address whether persons in similar situations are entitled to have their guilty pleas vacated by a writ of error coram nobis. (Id. at p. 1084.)
The Supreme Court observed, the writ of coram nobis is granted only when three requirements are met. First, the petitioner must demonstrate that some fact existed which, through no fault or negligence on his part, was not presented to the court at the trial, and which if presented would have prevented the rendition of the judgment. Next, the petitioner must show that the newly discovered evidence does not go to the merits of issues tried because issues of fact, once adjudicated, even if incorrectly, cannot be reopened except on motion for new trial. This requirement applies even though the evidence in question is not discovered until after the deadline for filing a motion for new trial time or after the motion has been denied. Finally, the petitioner must show that the relied-upon facts were not known to him or her and could not in the exercise of due diligence have been discovered at any time substantially earlier than the time of the motion for the writ. (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at pp. 1092-1093, citing People v. Shipman (1965) 62 Cal.2d 226.)
The Court held that Kim was ineligible for a coram nobis relief. Kim was put on notice of the possible immigration consequences pertaining to the plea agreement. The fact that the actual immigration consequences of the plea were unknown to the court and the parties was a mistake of law, not a mistake of fact. Kim's claim amounted to a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, which is not reviewable by way of writ of coram nobis. Here, Kim's contention was not a basic flaw which would have prevented rendition of the judgment, but rather facts which went to the legal effect of the judgment. (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at pp. 1102-1103.) In Kim, the Court concluded by noting, "[T]he Legislature has been active in providing statutory remedies when the existing remedies such as habeas corpus have proven ineffective. Section 1016.5 especially shows the Legislature's concern that those who plead guilty or no contest to criminal charges are aware of the immigration consequences of their pleas. Because the Legislature remains free to enact further statutory remedies for those in defendant's position, we are disinclined to reinterpret the historic writ of error coram nobis to provide the remedy he seeks." (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1107.)
3. Motion for Post-Conviction Relief
This bill creates a new mechanism for post-conviction relief for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody. Specifically, it allows a person to move to vacate a conviction due to error affecting his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential immigration consequences of the conviction.
In Padilla v. Kentucky (2010) 559 U.S. 356, the United States Supreme court held that the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to provide affirmative and competent advice to noncitizen defendants regarding the potential immigration consequences of their criminal cases. (Id. at p. 360.) Specifically, the United States Supreme Court held that defense counsel is constitutionally deficient if there is a failure to advise a noncitizen client entering a plea to a criminal offense of the risk of deportation. "Deportation as a consequence of a criminal conviction has become an integral part of the penalty for a criminal conviction for noncitizens, sometimes the most important part. (Id. at p. 364.) The court's holding is not limited to only affirmative mis-advice of the consequence because that would encourage defense counsel to remain silent on a matter of great importance to a noncitizen client, and that would be inconsistent with counsel's duty to provide advice to a client considering the advantages and disadvantages of a plea agreement. (Id. at pp. 370-371.)
A criminal defendant who is no longer in "custody" for purposes of the writ of habeas corpus, can move to withdraw a guilty plea if the trial court accepting the plea, failed to admonish the defendant of the possible immigration consequence of the plea under Penal Code section 1016.5. There is no time limit within which such a motion must be filed, but there is a due diligence requirement. (People v. Zamudio (2000) 23 Cal.4th 183.) However, the grounds for this basis of relief are quite limited. It is only available where the court fails to give the general admonishment or the record is silent on the matter. (People v. Martinez (2013) 57 Cal.4th 555, 565.)
At this time, under California law, there is no vehicle to for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody to challenge his or her conviction based on a mistake of law regarding immigration consequences or ineffective assistance of counsel in properly advising of these consequences when the person learns of the error post-custody. The Padilla case requiring that a defense counsel properly advise a person on immigration consequences was subsequent to the California decision in Kim prohibiting the use of corum nobis and so this bill would create a mechanism for post-conviction relief where there is not one currently.
4. Support
The Alameda County Public Defender supports this bill stating:
Currently, only people who are in prison, on parole or on probation may ask a court to review the validity of their conviction. People with old convictions—who long ago completed their sentence and have become productive members of society—have not way to raise a claim of innocence or otherwise challenge the legal validity of the convictions. California is one of the very few states that lacks a vehicle for post-custodial review. In fact, forty-four other states and the federal government all provide individuals with a way of challenging unjust convictions after criminal custody has ended.
This deficiency in current law has a particularly devastating impact on California’s immigrant communities. While the criminal penalty for a conviction is obvious and immediate, the immigration penalty can remain “invisible” until an encounter with the immigration system raises the issue. Since 1987, California law has required defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants about the immigration consequences of convictions. But, despite this requirement, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Immigrants may only find out that their conviction makes them deplorable when, years later, Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiates removal proceedings. By then, however, it is too late. Without any vehicle to challenge their convictions in state court, immigrants are routinely deported on the basis of conviction that never should have existed in the first place.
5. Opposition
The Alameda County District Attorney opposes this bill stating:
I oppose this bill for many reasons. The first is that existing law already creates a mechanism for a person to seek relief if they did not know their immigration consequences of a conviction. Second, this bill requires all motions shall be entitled to a hearing which removes the discretion from the court to have a hearing because there is not requirement of showing or new evidence. Also this new hearing also doesn’t require the defendant to be present for the hearing so who is going to testify that he or she didn’t understand their immigration consequences.
6. Related Legislation
AB 267 (Jones-Sawyer) would require the court, prior to the acceptance of a guilty plea to a felony offense, to inform the defendant of the various consequences that may result from conviction of a felony. AB 267 passed this Committee on June 16.
AB 1343 (Thurmond) would require defense counsel to provide accurate and affirmative advice to a defendant regarding the potential immigration consequences of a proposed disposition and attempt to defend against those consequences. AB 1343 will be heard in this Committee today.
AB 1352 (Eggman) would require the court to allow a defendant to withdraw his or her plea in a deferred entry of judgment case in order to avoid specified adverse consequences, including deportation. AB 1352 (Eggman) is set to be heard in this committee on July 14th.
-- END –
AB 813
Page 2
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 813
(Gonzalez)
As Amended May 14, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Public Safety |
5-2 |
Quirk, Jones-Sawyer, Low, Santiago, Thurmond |
Melendez, Lackey |
SUMMARY:
Creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction following a guilty plea based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction. Specifically, this bill:
Permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to a prejudicial error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendere; or,
Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires the conviction or sentence be vacated either as a matter of law, or in the interests of justice.
Requires a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section; or
The effective date of this section.
Entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
Requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
Requires the court when ruling on the motion to make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
Requires the court to allow the moving party to withdraw the plea if it grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
Permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
EXISTING LAW:
Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States."
Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea.
Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea.
Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint.
Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
According to the author, "AB 813 will give hope to those who have been wronged by an unlawful conviction by establishing a way to challenge it after their criminal custody has ended. Even though current law requires defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants of the immigration consequences of convictions, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Failure to understand the true consequences of pleading guilty to certain felonies, for example, has led to the unnecessary separation of families across California. AB 813 does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present their case in front of a judge, a procedure that already exists in most of the country."
Analysis Prepared by: Martin Vindiola / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0000392
AB 813
Page 2
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 813
(Gonzalez)
As Amended May 7, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Public Safety |
5-2 |
Quirk, Jones-Sawyer, Low, Santiago, Thurmond |
Melendez, Lackey |
SUMMARY:
Creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction following a guilty plea based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction. Specifically, this bill:
Permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of a plea of guilty or nolo contendre; or,
Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires the conviction or sentence be vacated either as a matter of law, or in the interests of justice.
Requires a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section; or
The effective date of this section.
Entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
Requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
Requires the court when ruling on the motion to make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
Requires the court to allow the moving party to withdraw the plea if it grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
Permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States."
Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea.
Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea.
Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint.
Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
According to the author, "AB 813 will give hope to those who have been wronged by an unlawful conviction by establishing a way to challenge it after their criminal custody has ended. Even though current law requires defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants of the immigration consequences of convictions, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Failure to understand the true consequences of pleading guilty to certain felonies, for example, has led to the unnecessary separation of families across California. AB 813 does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present their case in front of a judge, a procedure that already exists in most of the country."
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0000309
AB 813
Page 2
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 813
(Gonzalez)
As Amended March 26, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Public Safety |
5-2 |
Quirk, Jones-Sawyer, Low, Santiago, Thurmond |
Melendez, Lackey |
SUMMARY:
Creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate a conviction or sentence based on error damaging his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the immigration consequences of the conviction. Specifically, this bill:
Permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to error damaging the moving party's ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of the conviction; or,
Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires the conviction or sentence be vacated either as a matter of law, or in the interests of justice.
Requires a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section; or
The effective date of this section.
Entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
Requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
Requires the court when ruling on the motion to make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
Requires the court to allow the moving party to withdraw the plea if it grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
Permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States."
Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea.
Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea.
Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint.
Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
According to the author, "AB 813 will give hope to those who have been wronged by an unlawful conviction by establishing a way to challenge it after their criminal custody has ended. Even though current law requires defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants of the immigration consequences of convictions, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Failure to understand the true consequences of pleading guilty to certain felonies, for example, has led to the unnecessary separation of families across California. AB 813 does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present their case in front of a judge, a procedure that already exists in most of the country."
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0000184
AB 813
Page 8
Date of Hearing: April 21, 2015
Counsel: Sandra Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Bill Quirk, Chair
AB 813
(Gonzalez) – As Amended March 26, 2015
SUMMARY:
Creates a mechanism of post-conviction relief for a person to vacate
a conviction or sentence based on error damaging his or her ability
to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the
immigration consequences of the conviction. Specifically, this
bill:
Permits a person no longer imprisoned or restrained to file a motion to vacate a conviction or sentence for either of the following reasons:
The conviction or sentence is legally invalid due to error damaging the moving party’s ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential adverse immigration consequences of the conviction; or,
Newly discovered evidence of actual innocence exists which requires the conviction or sentence be vacated either as a matter of law, or in the interests of justice.
Requires a motion to vacate be filed with reasonable diligence after the later of the following:
The date the moving party receives a notice to appear in immigration court or other notice from immigration authorities that asserts the conviction or sentence as a basis for removal;
The date a removal order against the moving party, based on the existence of the conviction or sentence, becomes final;
The date the moving party discovered, or could have discovered with the exercise of due diligence, the evidence that provides a basis for relief under this section; or
The effective date of this section.
Entitles the moving party to a hearing; however, at the request of the moving party, the court may hold the hearing without his or her personal presence if counsel for the moving party is present and the court finds good cause as to why the moving party cannot be present.
Requires the court to grant the motion to vacate the conviction or sentence if the moving party establishes, by a preponderance of the evidence, the existence of any of the specified grounds for relief.
Requires the court when ruling on the motion to make specific findings of fact and conclusions of law on all issues presented.
Requires the court to allow the moving party to withdraw the plea if it grants the motion to vacate a conviction or sentence obtained through a plea of guilty or nolo contendere.
Permits an appeal from an order granting or denying a motion to vacate the conviction or sentence.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
Requires a court before accepting a plea to advise a criminal defendant as follows: "If you are not a citizen, you are hereby advised that conviction of the offense for which you have been charged may have the consequences of deportation, exclusion from admission to the United States, or denial of naturalization pursuant to the laws of the United States." (Pen. Code, § 1016.5, subd. (a).)
Permits a defendant to make a motion to withdraw his or her plea if the court fails to admonish him or her about the possible immigration consequences of entering the plea. (Pen. Code, § 1016.5, subd. (a).)
Permits a defendant to move to withdraw a plea at any time before judgment, or within six months after an order granting probation when the entry of judgment is suspended, or if the defendant appeared without counsel at the time of the plea. (Pen. Code, § 1018.)
Allows every person unlawfully imprisoned or restrained of his or her liberty to prosecute a writ of habeas corpus to inquire into the cause of his or her restraint. (Pen. Code, § 1473, subd. (a).)
Authorizes a person no longer unlawfully imprisoned or restrained to prosecute a motion to vacate the judgment based on newly discovered evidence, as specified, if the motion is brought within one year of the discovery. (Pen. Code, § 1473.6.)
EXISTING
FEDERAL LAW:
Lists several categories of crimes which render a non-citizen removable from the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; aggravated felony convictions; domestic violence convictions; firearm convictions, and drug convictions. (INA § 237(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2).)
Lists several categories of crimes which will render a non-citizen inadmissible to the United States, including: crimes of moral turpitude; drug convictions; and prostitution convictions. (INA § 212(a)(2), see also 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(2).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
Author's Statement: According to the author, "AB 813 will give hope to those who have been wronged by an unlawful conviction by establishing a way to challenge it after their criminal custody has ended. Even though current law requires defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants of the immigration consequences of convictions, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Failure to understand the true consequences of pleading guilty to certain felonies, for example, has led to the unnecessary separation of families across California. AB 813 does not guarantee an automatic reversal of the conviction, but an opportunity to present their case in front of a judge, a procedure that already exists in most of the country."
People v. Kim (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1078: Kim was a legal resident, but not a citizen of the United States, when he suffered multiple criminal convictions. The federal government sought to deport him based on the convictions, and Kim petitioned for a writ of error coram nobis, seeking to vacate the convictions which triggered the deportation proceedings based on his unawareness of the immigration consequences of his plea. The California Supreme Court granted review to address whether persons in similar situations are entitled to have their guilty pleas vacated by a writ of error coram nobis. (Id. at p. 1084.)
The Supreme Court observed, the writ of coram nobis is granted only when three requirements are met. First, the petitioner must demonstrate that some fact existed which, through no fault or negligence on his part, was not presented to the court at the trial, and which if presented would have prevented the rendition of the judgment. Next, the petitioner must show that the newly discovered evidence does not go to the merits of issues tried because issues of fact, once adjudicated, even if incorrectly, cannot be reopened except on motion for new trial. This requirement applies even though the evidence in question is not discovered until after the deadline for filing a motion for new trial time or after the motion has been denied. Finally, the petitioner must show that the relied-upon facts were not known to him or her and could not in the exercise of due diligence have been discovered at any time substantially earlier than the time of the motion for the writ. (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at pp. 1092-1093, citing People v. Shipman (1965) 62 Cal.2d 226.)
The Court held that Kim was ineligible for a coram nobis relief. Kim was put on notice of the possible immigration consequences pertaining to the plea agreement. The fact that the actual immigration consequences of the plea were unknown to the court and the parties was a mistake of law, not a mistake of fact. Kim's claim amounted to a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, which is not reviewable by way of writ of coram nobis. Here, Kim's contention was not a basic flaw which would have prevented rendition of the judgment, but rather facts which went to the legal effect of the judgment. (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at pp. 1102-1103.)
In Kim, the Court concluded by noting, "[T]he Legislature has been active in providing statutory remedies when the existing remedies such as habeas corpus have proven ineffective. Section 1016.5 especially shows the Legislature's concern that those who plead guilty or no contest to criminal charges are aware of the immigration consequences of their pleas. Because the Legislature remains free to enact further statutory remedies for those in defendant's position, we are disinclined to reinterpret the historic writ of error coram nobis to provide the remedy he seeks." (People v. Kim, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 1107.)
This bill creates a new mechanism for post-conviction relief for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody. Specifically, it allows a person to move to vacate a conviction due to error affecting his or her ability to meaningfully understand, defend against, or knowingly accept the actual or potential immigration consequences of the conviction.
Options for Post-Conviction Relief: In Padilla v. Kentucky (2010) 559 U.S. 356, the United States Supreme court held that the Sixth Amendment requires defense counsel to provide affirmative and competent advice to noncitizen defendants regarding the potential immigration consequences of their criminal cases. (Id. at p. 360.) Specifically, the United States Supreme Court held that defense counsel is constitutionally deficient if there is a failure to advise a noncitizen client entering a plea to a criminal offense of the risk of deportation. "Deportation as a consequence of a criminal conviction has become an integral part of the penalty for a criminal conviction for noncitizens, sometimes the most important part. (Id. at p. 364.) The court's holding is not limited to only affirmative mis-advice of the consequence because that would encourage defense counsel to remain silent on a matter of great importance to a noncitizen client, and that would be inconsistent with counsel's duty to provide advice to a client considering the advantages and disadvantages of a plea agreement. (Id. at pp. 370-371.)
For a defendant who is granted probation, he or she may be able to obtain post-conviction relief based on ineffective assistance of counsel with regard to advice about immigration consequences by moving to vacate the plea under Penal Code section 1018, but only within six months of the granting of probation. (See e.g. People v. Perez (2015) 233 Cal.App.4th 736.)
An appeal is the most common method for most defendants to challenge a judgment of conviction. However, a notice of appeal must be filed within 60 days of the judgment. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 8.308.) Moreover, an appeal is limited to matters that appear on the face of the record. Usually, the record on appeal fails to show why counsel acted or failed to act in the instance asserted to be ineffective. To accept an ineffective assistance of counsel claim on direct appeal the appellate record must make it clear that the challenged omission was "mistake beyond the range of reasonable competence." (People v. Montiel (1993) 5 Cal.4th 877, 911.) "In some cases . . . the record on appeal sheds no light on why counsel acted or failed to act in the manner challenged. In such circumstances, unless counsel was asked for an explanation and failed to provide one or unless there simply could be no satisfactory explanation, these cases are affirmed on appeal." (People v. Lewis (1990) 50 Cal.3d 262, 288; People v. Mendoza Tello (1997) 15 Cal.4th 264, 266.)
Habeas corpus is the main vehicle for review of orders where an appeal is precluded or would be an inadequate remedy. Habeas corpus is also used to bring to the court's attention to matters outside the record which are crucial to the petitioner's claims for relief, and which have resulted in a constitutional violation, thereby rendering the petitioner's restraint unlawful. (In re Bower (1985) 38 Cal.3d 865, 872.) One common example of the use of habeas corpus is ineffective assistance of counsel claims. An individual could allege that his or her attorney was ineffective by failing to advise him or her of the adverse immigration consequences of accepting a plea, or by providing erroneous advice. (See e.g. People v. Soriano (1987) 194 Cal.App.3d 1470.) However, to be eligible for habeas corpus the individually must be considered "unlawful imprisoned or restrained." (Pen. Code, § 1473.) Actual incarceration in prison or jail is not required for a petition for writ of habeas corpus; persons on bail, probation, parole, or committed to a state hospital are considered to be in constructive custody for purposes of habeas corpus writ review. (In re Bandmann (1959) 51 Cal.2d 388, 396-397; In re Petersen (1958) 51 Cal.2d 177, 181.) However, federal immigration custody alone, does not qualify as "custody" for purposes of habeas corpus writ review. (People v. Villa (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1063.) Therefore, a non-citizen who did not learn of an immigration consequence until many years later, such as at a naturalization interview, would be precluded from using the writ of habeas corpus to challenge the conviction based on ineffective assistance of counsel.
A criminal defendant who is no longer in "custody" for purposes of the writ of habeas corpus, can move to withdraw a guilty plea if the trial court accepting the plea, failed to admonish the defendant of the possible immigration consequence of the plea under Penal Code section 1016.5. There is no time limit within which such a motion must be filed, but there is a due diligence requirement. (People v. Zamudio (2000) 23 Cal.4th 183.) However, the grounds for this basis of relief are quite limited. It is only available where the court fails to give the general admonishment or the record is silent on the matter. (People v. Martinez (2013) 57 Cal.4th 555, 565.)
So at this time, under California law, there is no vehicle to for a person who is no longer in actual or constructive custody to challenge his or her conviction based on a mistake of law regarding immigration consequences or ineffective assistance of counsel in properly advising of these consequences when the person learns of the error post-custody. It seems particularly important to create such a vehicle given that it was after the California Supreme Court prohibited the use of a writ of corum nobis in these instances that the United States Supreme Court explicitly held that defense counsel has a duty to properly advise on these matters.
Argument in Support: According to the American Civil Liberties Union of California, a co-sponsor of this bill, "Currently, only people who are in prison, on parole, or on probation may ask a court to review the validity of their conviction. After the opportunity for habeas corpus relief has passed, people with old convictions – who long ago completed their sentence and have become productive members of society – have no way to raise a claim of innocence or otherwise challenge the legal validity of the convictions. California is one of very few states that lacks a vehicle for post-custodial review. In fact, forty-four other states and the federal government all provide individuals with a way of challenging unjust convictions after criminal custody has ended.
"This deficiency in current law has a particularly devastating impact on California's immigrant communities. While the criminal penalty for a conviction is obvious and immediate, the immigration penalty can remain 'invisible' until an encounter with the immigration system raises the issue. Since 1987, California law has required defense counsel to inform noncitizen defendants about the immigration consequences of convictions. But, despite this requirement, some defense attorneys still fail to do so. Immigrants may find out that their conviction makes them deportable only when, years later, Immigration and Customs Enforcement initiates removal proceedings. By then, however, it is too late. Without any vehicle to challenge their convictions in state court, immigrants are routinely deported on the basis of convictions that should never have existed in the first place and would be thrown out if habeas corpus were available.
"Previously, Californians facing deportation for old, legally invalid convictions used a process called corum nobis to challenge these convictions. But in 2009, the California Supreme Court decided People v. Kim, ruling that corum nobis could not be used to raise claims of ineffective assistance of counsel, thereby eliminating the last post-custodial vehicle to vacate legally invalid convictions. (People v. Kim 45 Cal.4th 1078 (Cal. 2009)). However, the Court specifically invited legislative action, noting that, 'when established remedies have proved inadequate, the Legislature has enacted statutory remedies to fill the void.' (People v. Kim)
"AB 813 answers the Supreme Court's call to action and fills a gaping hole in California law."
Argument in Opposition: The California District Attorneys Association writes, "In the context of a conviction obtained by a guilty plea, I can follow the logic that a person who didn't fully understand the immigration consequences of that plea should be given an opportunity to have the conviction vacated and the plea withdrawn because they may not have pled guilty if they understood how that plea may impact their immigration status. It would represent a tremendous failure by defense counsel to meet their constitutional obligation to inform their client, by the court to advise the defendant as required under PC 1016.5, and likely be grounds for an appeal based on ineffective assistance of counsel, but it makes logical sense.
"However, in cases where an individual chose to go to trial, and was found guilty by verdict, this logic falls apart. Would a person have tried harder to not be found guilty if they were concerned about adverse immigration consequences? Would they somehow have been less culpable of the crime for which a jury has found them guilty?
"Consider this example – a person is charged with armed robbery (or forcible rape, or murder, or literally any other crime, as the bill contains no restrictions based on the seriousness of the offense) and enters a plea of not guilty. The evidence against the defendant is overwhelming, and the jury returns a unanimous guilty verdict. After the convicted defendant completes his sentence, he files a motion under this new right given to him by AB 813, contesting his conviction because he didn’t meaningfully understand that there might be adverse immigration consequences as a result of his conviction. The court would then be required to vacate his conviction if they found, by a preponderance of the evidence, that he didn’t understand the potential immigration consequences.
"This makes no sense. At no point is the convicted person alleging that he did not commit the crime for which a jury found him guilty, yet he would be allowed to have that conviction vacated because of what amounts to a failure by defense counsel to meet their constitutional obligation of ensuring that their client was informed about the consequences of a conviction. It’s unclear how a better understanding of those consequences would have changed someone’s trial strategy when they already decided not to enter a guilty plea.
"Even more troubling is the fact that if that person later committed another offense, they would not be eligible for any sort of enhanced sentence that would normally apply to a person who has committed multiple offenses, because their prior conviction has been vacated. Again, in the case of a motion under new PC 1473.7(a)(1), this would be done without any showing of actual innocence.
"The bill also contains no provisions covering whether a person could be retried after a conviction was vacated or plea withdrawn.
"We have additional concerns that AB 813 would be sent directly to the floor if it were to pass out of committee. Certainly there would be a cost attributed to the hearings that would be required for these new motions. Since the bill, as drafted, would apply to literally everyone who has ever been convicted of any crime, as long as they can show that the conviction might negatively impact their immigration status, these potential costs would be substantial. Having the Appropriations Committee estimate and consider these potential costs seems like a good idea."
Related Legislation:
AB 267 (Jones-Sawyer) would require the court, prior to the acceptance of a guilty plea to a felony offense, to inform the defendant of the various consequences that may result from conviction of a felony. AB 267 is pending a vote on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1343 (Thurmond) would require defense counsel to provide accurate and affirmative advice to a defendant regarding the potential immigration consequences of a proposed disposition and attempt to defend against those consequences. AB 1343 will be heard in this Committee today.
AB 1352 (Eggman) would require the court to allow a defendant to withdraw his or her plea in a deferred entry of judgment case in order to avoid specified adverse consequences, including deportation. AB 1352 is will be heard in this Committee today.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1310 (Lara), Chapter 174, Statutes of 2014, reduced the maximum sentence for a misdemeanor from 365 days to 364 days to prevent some offenses from being classified as aggravated felonies for purposes of federal immigration law.
Chapter 1088, Statutes of 1977, required trial courts, prior to acceptance of guilty or nolo contendere pleas from noncitizens, to advise them that conviction might result in deportation or other immigration consequences.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American
Civil Liberties Union of California (Co-Sponsor)
California
Public Defenders Association (Co-Sponsor)
California Attorneys
for Criminal Justice
California Immigrant Policy Center
Centro
Legal de la Raza
Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights of the San
Francisco Bay Area
Legal Services for Prisoners with
Children
National Day Laborer Organizing Network
Pangea
Legal Services
Public Counsel
Root and Rebound
Rubicon
Programs
San Francisco Public Defender
Opposition
California
District Attorneys Association
Analysis Prepared by:
Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):