SB 308: Net zero greenhouse gas emissions goal: carbon dioxide removal: regulations.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-08
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act authorizes the state board to adopt a regulation that establishes a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emissions limits for sources or categories of sources that emit greenhouse gases, applicable from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2030, inclusive, as specified. The act authorizes the state board to include in its regulation of those emissions the use of market-based compliance mechanisms.
The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.
The act also declares the policy of the state both to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 levels.
This bill would require the state board to develop and adopt regulations, or utilize existing programs and regulations, to ensure the state achieves carbon dioxide removals equivalent to at least 100% of statewide greenhouse gas emissions in calendar year 2045, and all subsequent years, in order to achieve the net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions goals. As part of those efforts, the bill would require the state board to establish separate interim targets for greenhouse gas emissions reductions and carbon dioxide removals, to be applicable beginning no later than calendar year 2030, and to report on progress toward achieving those targets. The bill would provide that only carbon dioxide removed by processes certified by the state board as satisfying certain requirements shall be eligible to be counted for the purpose of counterbalancing statewide greenhouse gas emissions when determining the states progress toward achieving net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions. For purposes of those provisions, the bill would require state board to only approve carbon dioxide removal processes that meet certain requirements, as specified.
Existing law requires the state board to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of carbon capture, utilization, or storage technologies and carbon dioxide removal technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from those technologies, where appropriate. Existing law requires the state board to adopt regulations to implement that program. In furtherance of the objectives of that program, existing law authorizes the state board, by January 1, 2024, to adopt protocols to support additional methods of utilization or storage of captured carbon dioxide.
This bill would require the state board to adopt the regulations to implement the program no later than July 1, 2027. The bill would indefinitely authorize the state board to adopt those protocols, and protocols to support methods of utilization or storage of removed carbon dioxide.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act authorizes the state board to adopt a regulation that establishes a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emissions limits for sources or categories of sources that emit greenhouse gases, applicable from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2030, inclusive, as specified. The act authorizes the state board to include in its regulation of those emissions the use of market-based compliance mechanisms.
The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.
The act also declares the policy of the state both to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 levels.
Existing law also requires the state board to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of carbon capture, utilization, or storage technologies and carbon dioxide removal technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from those technologies, where appropriate.This bill would enact the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act that would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to adopt a regulation to require certain emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified amount of their greenhouse gas emissions, as determined by the state board, in each calendar year beginning in the 2028 calendar year in accordance with specified requirements. The bill would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits in accordance with certain criteria. The bill would also require negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits to be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions, as specified.Because a violation of the requirement to purchase negative emissions credits would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.This bill would require the state board to develop and adopt regulations, or utilize existing programs and regulations, to ensure the state achieves carbon dioxide removals equivalent to at least 100% of statewide greenhouse gas emissions in calendar year 2045, and all subsequent years, in order to achieve the net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions goals. As part of those efforts, the bill would require the state board to establish separate interim targets for greenhouse gas emissions reductions and carbon dioxide removals, to be applicable beginning no later than calendar year 2030, and to report on progress toward achieving those targets. The bill would provide that only carbon dioxide removed by processes certified by the state board as satisfying certain requirements shall be eligible to be counted for the purpose of counterbalancing statewide greenhouse gas emissions when determining the states progress toward achieving net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions.
Existing law requires the state board to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of carbon capture, utilization, or storage technologies and carbon dioxide removal technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from those technologies, where appropriate. In furtherance of the objectives of that program, existing law authorizes the state board, by January 1, 2024, to adopt protocols to support additional methods of utilization or storage of captured carbon dioxide.
This bill would indefinitely authorize the state board to adopt those protocols, and protocols to support methods of utilization or storage of removed carbon dioxide.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act authorizes the state board to adopt a regulation that establishes a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emissions limits for sources or categories of sources that emit greenhouse gases, applicable from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2030, inclusive, as specified. The act authorizes the state board to include in its regulation of those emissions the use of market-based compliance mechanisms.
The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.
The act also declares the policy of the state both to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 levels.
Existing law also requires the state board to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of carbon capture, utilization, or storage technologies and carbon dioxide removal technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from those technologies, where appropriate.
This bill would enact the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act that would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to adopt a regulation to require certain emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified amount of their greenhouse gas emissions, as determined by the state board, in each calendar year beginning in the 2028 calendar year in accordance with specified requirements. The bill would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits in accordance with certain criteria. The bill would also require negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits to be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions, as specified.
Because a violation of the requirement to purchase negative emissions credits would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act authorizes the state board to adopt a regulation that establishes a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emissions limits for sources or categories of sources that emit greenhouse gases, applicable from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2030, inclusive, as specified. The act authorizes the state board to include in its regulation of those emissions the use of market-based compliance mechanisms.
The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.
The act also declares the policy of the state both to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 levels.
Existing law also requires the state board to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of carbon capture, utilization, or storage technologies and carbon dioxide removal technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from those technologies, where appropriate.
This bill would enact the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act that would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to adopt a regulation to require certain emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified amount of their greenhouse gas emissions, as determined by the state board, in each calendar year beginning in the 2028 calendar year in accordance with specified requirements. The bill would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits in accordance with certain criteria. The bill would also require negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits to be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions, as specified.
Because a violation of the requirement to purchase negative emissions credits would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. The act requires the state board to approve a statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit equivalent to the statewide greenhouse gas emissions level in 1990 to be achieved by 2020 and to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act authorizes the state board to adopt a regulation that establishes a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emissions limits for sources or categories of sources that emit greenhouse gases, applicable from January 1, 2012, to December 31, 2030, inclusive, as specified. The act authorizes the state board to include in its regulation of those emissions the use of market-based compliance mechanisms.
The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.
The act also declares the policy of the state both to achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter, and to ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 levels.
Existing law also requires the state board to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of carbon capture, utilization, or storage technologies and carbon dioxide removal technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from those technologies, where appropriate.
This bill would enact the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act that would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to adopt a regulation to require certain emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified amount of their greenhouse gas emissions, as determined by the state board, in each calendar year beginning in the 2028 calendar year in accordance with specified requirements. The bill would require the state board, no later than December 31, 2027, to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits in accordance with certain criteria. The bill would also require negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits to be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions, as specified.
Because a violation of the requirement to purchase negative emissions credits would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. Existing law, the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that encourages the development of carbon dioxide removal in order to meet the states carbon dioxide removal targets.Existing law establishes the State Air Resources Board as the state agency responsible for monitoring and regulating sources emitting greenhouse gases. Existing law, the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, requires the state board to ensure that statewide greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. The act requires the state board to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in greenhouse gas emissions. Existing law requires the state board, as part of its scoping plan, to establish specified carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that encourages the development of carbon dioxide removal in order to meet the states carbon dioxide removal targets.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has recognized that limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) over preindustrial times will require not only large reductions in global carbon dioxide emissions from human sources but also carbon dioxide removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, a report by the IPCC released in early 2022, states, [t]he deployment of CDR to counterbalance hard-to-abate residual emissions is unavoidable if net zero CO2 or GHG emissions are to be achieved.
(2)Assembly Bill 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337 of the Statutes of 2022) established a target for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by at least 85 percent from 1990 levels by 2045 as part of achieving net zero GHG emissions. California will need to employ CDR to balance out the remaining up to 15 percent GHG emissions to achieve the net zero target.
(3)The State Air Resources Boards 2022 Scoping Plan for Achieving Carbon Neutrality, dated November 16, 2022, stated, states, [t]he modeling shows that emissions from the AB 32 GHG Inventory sources will continue to persist even if all fossil related combustion emissions are phased out. These residual emissions must be compensated for to achieve carbon neutrality.
(4)The 2022 Scoping Plan estimated that the state would need approximately 75 million metric tons (MMT) of CDR in 2045 in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions. It further identified a target of 7 MMT per year of CDR by 2030 as an ambitious, but achievable, goal that can serve as an important marker for progress in deploying CDR to support Californias carbon neutrality goal.
(5)Therefore, although CDR should not be seen as a reason to prolong the states reliance on fossil fuels or as an excuse for not reducing GHG emissions as quickly as is feasible, CDR is widely predicted to be an important and necessary part of achieving the states net zero target.
(6)A diversity of approaches can be used to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequester it, including natural processes, engineered mechanical and chemical processes, or a combination of these approaches.
(7)Once carbon dioxide is released into the atmosphere from previously inert sources, such as fossil fuels, it causes increases in atmospheric concentrations of CO2 that will last thousands of years, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency.
(8)CDR that is intended to balance out continued emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should therefore result in long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere on a similar time scale to that of the released carbon dioxide.
(9)Very little capacity exists currently to provide CDR that can meet these criteria for long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and this capacity, along with the supporting infrastructure for transporting and sequestering the removed carbon, will need to be scaled up enormously in order to meet the needs estimated for the states target of achieving net zero GHG emissions by 2045.
(10)CDR approaches that can reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide for shorter periods of time can also provide valuable services in reducing climate change, but they eventually must be coupled with more durable sequestration of carbon in order to truly balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases.
(11)In order to be counted for the purpose of balancing continued residual emissions of greenhouse gases, CDR processes must be quantifiable and must include scientifically rigorous approaches to monitor and verify the sequestration of removed carbon in order to ensure that the reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide is maintained over long periods of time.
(12)CDR that is intended to balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should represent true removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and not just the avoidance of emissions that might otherwise have occurred, as is sometimes allowed in carbon offset programs.
(13)The use of carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies to prevent greenhouse gas emissions represents an avoidance or reduction of emissions that would otherwise have occurred, not the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, and should therefore be counted toward the states greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets and not toward the states carbon dioxide removal targets.
(13)(14)Developing and manufacturing the technologies needed to capture and sequester carbon dioxide and building and operating the facilities and supporting infrastructure used for CDR can be a source of jobs, economic development, and tax revenues for the state and can establish the state as a leader in exporting these products to help the rest of the world achieve reductions in net GHG emissions.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature for the State Air Resources Board to implement regulations and programs to attain the states target for net zero greenhouse gas emissions, as set forth in Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code, and to establish and attain interim targets in order to grow over time the CDR capacity and supporting infrastructure that will be necessary to achieve that net zero target.
SEC. 2.Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:38562.2.(a)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Climate Crisis Act.(b)For purposes of this section, net zero greenhouse gas emissions means emissions of greenhouse gases, as defined in subdivision (g) of Section 38505, to the atmosphere are balanced by removals of greenhouse gas emissions over a period of time, as determined by the state board.(c)It is the policy of the state to do both of the following:(1)Achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. This goal is in addition to, and does not replace or supersede, the statewide greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets in Section 38566.(2)Ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85 percent below the statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit established pursuant to Section 38550.(d)Only carbon dioxide removed by processes certified by the state board pursuant to Section 38562.3 shall be eligible to be counted for the purpose of counterbalancing statewide greenhouse gas emissions when determining the states progress toward achieving net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to subdivision (c).(e)The state board shall work with relevant state agencies to do both of the following:(1)Ensure that updates to the scoping plan required pursuant to Section 38561 identify and recommend measures to achieve the policy goals stated in subdivision (c).(2)Identify and implement a variety of policies and strategies that enable carbon dioxide removal solutions and carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies in California to complement emissions reductions and achieve the policy goals stated in subdivision (c).(f)(1)By December 31, 2035, the state board shall evaluate the feasibility and tradeoffs of achieving the policy goal stated in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) relative to alternative scenarios that achieve the policy goals stated in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), and report its findings and recommendations to the Legislature.(2)The state board shall report to the Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies annually on progress toward the goals stated in subdivision (c).(3)As part of its annual reporting requirements pursuant to Section 38592.6, the Legislative Analysts Office, until January 1, 2030, shall conduct independent analyses of the states progress toward the goals stated in subdivision (c) and shall prepare an annual report detailing its review, which may include recommendations for improvements in state actions taken to achieve the goals stated in subdivision (c). When appropriate, these annual reports may incorporate reviews of the state boards evaluation and reporting practices, and may include recommendations for potential changes to advance transparency and accountability. A report prepared pursuant to this paragraph shall be made available to the public.SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 38562.3 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:38562.3.(a)(1)The state board shall develop and adopt regulations, or utilize existing programs and regulations, to ensure the state achieves carbon dioxide removals equivalent to at least 100 percent of statewide greenhouse gas emissions in calendar year 2045, and all subsequent years, in order to achieve the net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions goals established pursuant to Section 38562.2.
(2)Regulations adopted pursuant to this subdivision shall be consistent with, or impose requirements equivalent to, Chapter 4.3 (commencing with Section 39740) of Part 2 of Division 26 of this code and Part 8 (commencing with Section 71460) of Division 34 of the Public Resources Code, as determined by the state board.
(3)Before commencing a formal rulemaking process for regulations adopted pursuant to this subdivision, the state board shall conduct a robust community engagement process that includes outreach that targets residents of communities most likely to be near potential carbon dioxide removal projects. The environmental justice advisory committee established pursuant to Section 38591 shall be invited to participate in planning and implementation of this community engagement process.
(b)(1)As part of its efforts undertaken pursuant to subdivision (a), the state board shall establish separate interim targets for greenhouse gas emissions reductions and carbon dioxide removals, to be applicable beginning no later than calendar year 2030, and report on progress toward achieving those targets. The state board shall post any report prepared pursuant to this subdivision on its internet website.
(2)The interim target for carbon dioxide removals established pursuant to paragraph (1) for calendar year 2030 shall be at least 1 percent of projected total greenhouse gas emissions for that calendar year.
(c)For purposes of subdivision (c) of Section 38562.2, subdivisions (a) and (b), the state board shall only certify approve carbon dioxide removal processes that meet all of the following:
(1)The carbon dioxide removal process results in removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, directly or indirectly, atmosphere and not only the avoidance or reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. emissions or the prevention of greenhouse gas emissions through the use of CCUS technology, as defined in Section 39741. The carbon dioxide process may remove carbon from the atmosphere directly or indirectly, including by direct air capture or using carbon stored in biomass or soil or absorbed in water.
(2)The carbon dioxide removal process results in removals of carbon dioxide that are quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by the state board.
(2)(3)The carbon dioxide removal process is not used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.
(3)(4)If the carbon dioxide removal process requires biomass as a feedstock, it only uses biomass that is produced as a residue or waste product, including, but not limited to, agricultural residues and byproducts of sustainable forest management.
(4)(5)The carbon dioxide removal process is consistent with the requirements of Section 39741.1.
(5)(6)The carbon dioxide removal process uses a form of long-term carbon storage with requirements for financial responsibility and longevity consistent with, or equivalent to, those required under Section 39741.5, as determined by the state board.
(d)For purposes of this section, the state board shall include nature-based carbon dioxide removal strategies pursuant to Section 38561.5 that meet all of the requirements of subdivision (c), either individually or when coupled with carbon dioxide removal processes with sufficiently long-term carbon storage such that carbon dioxide removal credits based on the combined impacts of the coupled processes meet all of the requirements of subdivision (c).
(d)(e)To the extent feasible, the requirements of this section shall apply equivalently to all carbon dioxide removal processes certified approved by the state board whether located inside or outside of the state.
(f)The state board shall not approve a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to subdivision (c) that includes an industrial facility or engineered infrastructure for any portion of the process until the owner or operator of the facility or infrastructure provides a written attestation to the state board that includes both of the following:
(1)The owner or operator has done meaningful community engagement, including conducting at least three community meetings that include explaining the scope and potential impacts of the proposed facility or infrastructure before beginning construction or operation of it.
(2)The owner or operator has a plan for providing meaningful benefits to residents of the surrounding community, such as through an enforceable community benefits agreement or the establishment of a community oversight and advisory body with members representing local residents for the purpose of addressing community concerns and prioritizing community investments.
(g)The state board shall post on its internet website attestations received for carbon dioxide removal processes pursuant to subdivision (f) and provide a process for a third party to report to the state board an allegation that an attestation was untruthful or that a commitment made in the attestation is not being met. The state board may determine appropriate remedies if a violation is found to have been committed, including revoking approval of the carbon dioxide removal process.
(h)No later than July 1, 2026, and annually thereafter, the chair of the state board shall appear before the Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies established pursuant to Section 9147.10 of the Government Code to report on the implementation of this section. The environmental justice advisory committee established pursuant to Section 38591 shall also be invited to appear to provide comments and recommendations on the implementation of this section.
SEC. 3.Section 39741.1 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:39741.1.(a)The state board shall establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program to do all of the following:
(1)Evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of CCUS and CDR technologies and facilitate the capture and sequestration of carbon dioxide from these technologies, where appropriate.
(2)Develop monitoring and reporting schedules to state regulatory agencies for carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects to ensure efficacy, safety, and viability of the projects.
(3)Ensure that all carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects include the following, as appropriate:
(A)Strategies to minimize, to the maximum extent technologically feasible, copollutant emissions from facilities where CCUS or CDR technology is deployed to ensure that the use of carbon dioxide removal technologies and carbon capture and storage technologies does not have an adverse impact on local air quality and public health, particularly in low-income and disadvantaged communities.
(B)Strategies to ensure that carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects minimize, to the maximum extent technologically feasible, local water pollution or air pollution from construction- and transportation-related impacts from the projects in communities adjacent to carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects, including a geologic storage complex.
(C)Strategies to minimize the risk of seismic impacts to, and from, geologic storage projects, including the risk of gas leakage due to seismic activity.
(D)Monitoring and reporting of seismic activity related to geologic sequestration of carbon dioxide, and monitoring of sequestered carbon dioxide, including movement within the geologic storage complex, for a period of time that is sufficiently long enough to demonstrate that the risk of carbon dioxide leakage poses no material threat to public health, safety, and the environment and to achievement of net zero greenhouse gas emissions in California and that terminates no earlier than 100 years after the last date of injection of carbon dioxide into a geologic storage reservoir. In adopting regulations pursuant to subdivision (c) that pertain to this subparagraph, the state board shall consult with the State Geologist.
(E)Monitoring of criteria pollutants and potential toxic air contaminants at the one or more sites within the geologic storage complex and at mobile or fixed sites within the facility, and monitoring of ambient carbon dioxide concentrations over the geologic storage complex to facilitate leak detection. Monitoring required under this section shall continue for a period of time that is sufficiently long enough to demonstrate that the risk of carbon dioxide leakage poses no material threat to public health, safety, and the environment and to achievement of net zero greenhouse gas emissions in California and that terminates no earlier than the completion of the applicable postinjection site care and site closure plan pursuant to Section 146.93 of Title 40 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(F)Projects meet best available control technology requirements as determined by the local air district.
(b)In carrying out the objectives of the program, the state board shall prioritize the following:
(1)Reducing the emissions of greenhouse gases.
(2)Minimizing land use and potential environmental, noise, air quality, water quality, traffic, seismic, and other related impacts, and any potential health and safety risks, to all communities where CCUS and CDR technologies are deployed, and carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects are located to the maximum extent feasible.
(3)Maximizing workforce development and employment opportunities in each community where CCUS and CDR technologies are deployed, and carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects are located, to the extent feasible.
(4)Leveraging private funding sources and public-private partnership structures alongside potential state funding sources.
(5)Reducing fossil fuel production in the state.
(c)The state board shall adopt regulations to implement this section. section no later than July 1, 2027.
(d)In developing the program, the state board shall consult with the Geologic Carbon Sequestration Group established pursuant to Section 2213 of the Public Resources Code.
(e)In tracking progress toward the states climate targets, the state board shall prevent the double counting of emissions reductions associated with utilizing carbon dioxide that is captured or removed from the atmosphere. The state board may use a state board-approved third-party verifier to satisfy this subdivision.
(f)(1)Beginning January 1, 2025, and every two years thereafter, the state board shall report to the Legislature on the progress of the program. The report shall, at a minimum, include an evaluation of potential local environmental impacts and potential long-term leakage impacts as well as recommendations on measures to reduce these impacts of completed carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
SEC. 4.Section 39741.4 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:39741.4.In furtherance of the objectives in Section 39741.1, the state board may adopt protocols to support additional methods of utilization or storage of captured or removed carbon dioxide, including for use in products and in methods of long-term storage as identified by the state board.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has recognized that limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) over preindustrial times will require not only large reductions in global carbon dioxide emissions from human sources but also carbon dioxide removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, a report by the IPCC released in early 2022, states, [t]he deployment of CDR to counterbalance hard-to-abate residual emissions is unavoidable if net zero CO2 or GHG emissions are to be achieved.
(2)Assembly Bill 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337 of the Statutes of 2022) established a target for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by at least 85 percent from 1990 levels by 2045 as part of achieving net zero GHG emissions. California will need to employ CDR to balance out the remaining up to 15 percent GHG emissions to achieve the net zero target.
(3)The State Air Resources Boards 2022 Scoping Plan for Achieving Carbon Neutrality, dated November 16, 2022, stated, [t]he modeling shows that emissions from the AB 32 GHG Inventory sources will continue to persist even if all fossil related combustion emissions are phased out. These residual emissions must be compensated for to achieve carbon neutrality.
(4)The 2022 Scoping Plan estimated that the state would need approximately 75 million metric tons (MMT) of CDR in 2045 in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions. It further identified a target of 7 MMT per year of CDR by 2030 as an ambitious, but achievable, goal that can serve as an important marker for progress in deploying CDR to support Californias carbon neutrality goal.
(5)Therefore, although CDR should not be seen as a reason to prolong the states reliance on fossil fuels or as an excuse for not reducing GHG emissions as quickly as is feasible, CDR is widely predicted to be an important and necessary part of achieving the states net zero target.
(6)A diversity of approaches can be used to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequester it, including natural processes, engineered mechanical and chemical processes, or a combination of these approaches.
(7)Once carbon dioxide is released into the atmosphere from previously inert sources, such as fossil fuels, it causes increases in atmospheric concentrations of CO2 that will last thousands of years, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency.
(8)CDR that is intended to balance out continued emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should therefore result in long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere on a similar time scale to that of the released carbon dioxide.
(9)Very little capacity exists currently to provide CDR that can meet these criteria for long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and this capacity, along with the supporting infrastructure for transporting and sequestering the removed carbon, will need to be scaled up enormously in order to meet the needs estimated for the states target of achieving net zero GHG emissions by 2045.
(10)CDR approaches that can reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide for shorter periods of time can also provide valuable services in reducing climate change, but they eventually must be coupled with more durable sequestration of carbon in order to truly balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases.
(11)In order to be counted for the purpose of balancing continued residual emissions of greenhouse gases, CDR processes must be quantifiable and must include scientifically rigorous approaches to monitor and verify the sequestration of removed carbon in order to ensure that the reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide is maintained over long periods of time.
(12)CDR that is intended to balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should represent true removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and not just the avoidance of emissions that might otherwise have occurred, as is sometimes allowed in carbon offset programs.
(13)Consistent with the polluter pays principle, the entities responsible for GHG emissions should be responsible for paying for CDR sufficient to balance the impact on climate change of those GHG emissions.(14)(13)Developing and manufacturing the technologies needed to capture and sequester carbon dioxide and building and operating the facilities and supporting infrastructure used for CDR can be a source of jobs, economic development, and tax revenues for the state and can establish the state as a leader in exporting these products to help the rest of the world achieve reductions in net GHG emissions.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature for the State Air Resources Board to implement a program to grow the CDR capacity and supporting infrastructure that is necessary to achieve carbon dioxide removal in sufficient volume regulations and programs to attain the states target for net zero greenhouse gas emissions, as set forth in Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code. Code, and to establish and attain interim targets in order to grow over time the CDR capacity and supporting infrastructure that will be necessary to achieve that net zero target.
SEC. 2.Article 3 (commencing with Section 39742) is added to Chapter 4.3 of Part 2 of Division 26 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:3.Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act39742.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act.39742.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:(a)Carbon dioxide equivalent has the same meaning as defined in Section 38505.(b)Carbon dioxide removal process means a process using biological means, chemical means, physical means, or any combination of these means, including the use of CDR technology as defined in Section 39741, that results in a net reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide and puts carbon atoms into a form of carbon sequestration.(c)Carbon sequestration means storing carbon atoms in a geological location or in a stable chemical form so that the geological location or the stable chemical form keeps the carbon atoms from entering the atmosphere as carbon dioxide for a period of time.(d)Direct climate mitigation benefits to the state means a local reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration within the state caused by removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere within or sufficiently close to that area.(e)Durable carbon sequestration method means a method of carbon sequestration that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of the carbon atoms out of the atmosphere for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity provides a guarantee period of at least 100 years.(f)Emitting entity means an entity that is responsible for greenhouse gas emissions included within the states inventory and has an obligation to balance the impact of some or all of those greenhouse gas emissions through the purchase of negative emissions credits pursuant to Section 39742.4.(g)Guarantee period means the period of time during which the responsible entity is required to ensure that the carbon remains sequestered and to replace any carbon that is lost.(h)Negative emissions credit means a tradeable environmental attribute representing one metric ton of net carbon dioxide removed by a carbon dioxide removal process.(i)Negative emissions obligation means the amount of negative emissions credits an emitting entity is required to purchase and retire each year in order to partially or fully balance the impact of the greenhouse gas emissions for which the emitting entity is responsible.(j)Neighboring communities means the local government, residents, and other private entities in areas that are in close proximity to facilities used in a carbon dioxide removal process.(k)Net carbon dioxide removed means the net amount of carbon dioxide, by mass, that is removed by a carbon dioxide removal process per ton of carbon put into carbon sequestration, as measured over the full lifecycle of the process, including any greenhouse gas emissions caused by the use of energy or fuels to drive the process, transport the captured carbon, or sequester the carbon.(l)Responsible entity means a business, organization, or other entity that is responsible for ensuring that sequestered carbon is monitored and verified during the guarantee period and is responsible for replacing any losses to the sequestered carbon during the guarantee period.(m)Temporary carbon sequestration method means any method of carbon sequestration that does not meet the criteria for a durable carbon sequestration method.39742.2.(a)No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits. In establishing these rules and processes, the state board shall consider all of the following:(1)Criteria to ensure that certified carbon dioxide removal processes result in reductions in atmospheric carbon dioxide that are real, quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by the state board and are in addition to any carbon dioxide removals that are otherwise required by law or regulation. Only processes that result in removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, not avoidance of or reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, may be certified for the purpose of creating negative emissions credits.(2)A method to determine the net carbon dioxide removed by each certified carbon dioxide removal process.(3)Criteria to determine whether each certified carbon dioxide removal process qualifies as using a durable carbon sequestration method.(4)Requirements for scientifically rigorous and transparent methods for monitoring, reporting, and verification by responsible entities.(5)Requirements for responsible entities to replace any losses in sequestered carbon during the guarantee period with newly sequestered carbon representing an equal amount of net carbon dioxide removed.(6)Financial responsibility requirements for responsible entities to demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations during the guarantee period, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.(7)A method of tracking the creation, transfer of ownership, and retirement of negative emissions credits based on certified carbon dioxide removal processes so that the environmental attributes of each negative emissions credit will be counted only once for the purpose of meeting any regulatory or voluntary carbon dioxide removal targets or net greenhouse gas emissions targets.(b)(1)The state board may develop rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits that can meet the requirements of subdivision (e) of Section 39742.4 for durable carbon sequestration, such as a combination of the following:(A)A negative emissions credit using a temporary carbon sequestration method.(B)A legally binding commitment to purchase another negative emissions credit using a durable carbon sequestration method at the end of the guarantee period of the original temporary negative emissions credit.(2)For any two-phase negative emissions credits created pursuant to this section, the state board shall do all of the following:(A)Establish a method for tracking compliance with future negative emission credit purchase commitments.(B)Establish financial responsibility requirements to ensure that the responsible entity can demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.39742.3.(a)The state board shall not certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if the process is used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.(b)(1)The state board may elect not to certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if it determines the benefits generated by the carbon dioxide removal process do not outweigh the impacts caused by the carbon dioxide removal process, including, but not limited to, benefits and impacts to neighboring communities.(2)In making the determination pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall consider at least all of the following:(A)Impacts on deforestation or the displacement of agricultural land to grow dedicated biomass for carbon sequestration.(B)Impacts on neighboring communities from increases in criteria air pollutants caused by equipment used to capture, transport, sequester, or monitor the carbon.(C)Benefits to neighboring communities from investment, jobs, and tax revenues associated with carbon dioxide removal processes.39742.4.No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall adopt a regulation to require emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a portion of their greenhouse gas emissions in each calendar year beginning with greenhouse gas emissions for calendar year 2028 in accordance with all of the following:(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), only emitting entities with an obligation to report their greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to the regulation adopted by the state board pursuant to Section 38530 and who report 25,000 metric tons or more of greenhouse gas emissions per year shall be considered emitting entities for the purposes of this article.(b)The state board may include additional entities as emitting entities if the annual greenhouse gas emissions of those entities can be estimated with reasonable accuracy and without an unreasonable measurement burden on those entities.(c)The regulation shall establish a negative emissions obligation that requires emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a percentage of the carbon dioxide equivalent of their greenhouse gas emissions for each calendar year, as determined by the state board pursuant to subdivision (d).(d)The state board shall determine the percentage required pursuant to subdivision (c) for each year, beginning with calendar year 2028, with the goal of increasing the total capacity to provide negative emissions credits over time in order to meet the states net zero greenhouse gas emissions policy set forth in Section 38562.2. Those percentages shall be at least the following percentages in the following years:(1)One percent in 2030.(2)Eight percent in 2035.(3)Thirty-five percent in 2040.(4)One hundred percent in 2045.(e)Only negative emissions credits using a durable carbon sequestration method may be used to meet an emitting entitys negative emissions obligation.(f)If the state board develops rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 39742.2, no more than 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year may be two-phase emissions credits.(g)At least 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year shall be from carbon dioxide removal processes that provide direct climate mitigation benefits to the state.(h)The state board may adjust any of the percentages specified in subdivision (g) or in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (d) to a lower figure if it determines that it would be infeasible for emitting entities to comply with those requirements.(i)The state board may allow an emitting entity to reserve negative emissions credits purchased in excess of its obligation in a calendar year pursuant to subdivision (c) and to use those negative emissions credits to meet its obligation in a future calendar year.(j)Negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits for the purpose of complying with the obligation pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Section 38562.2, even if those negative emissions occurred outside of the state.39742.5.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.SEC. 2.Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:38562.2.(a)This section shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Climate Crisis Act.
(b)For purposes of this section, net zero greenhouse gas emissions means emissions of greenhouse gases, as defined in subdivision (g) of Section 38505, to the atmosphere are balanced by removals of greenhouse gas emissions over a period of time, as determined by the state board.
(c)It is the policy of the state to do both of the following:
(1)Achieve net zero greenhouse gas emissions as soon as possible, but no later than 2045, and to achieve and maintain net negative greenhouse gas emissions thereafter. This goal is in addition to, and does not replace or supersede, the statewide greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets in Section 38566.
(2)Ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions are reduced to at least 85 percent below the statewide greenhouse gas emissions limit established pursuant to Section 38550.
(d)Only carbon dioxide removed by processes certified by the state board pursuant to Section 38562.3 shall be eligible to be counted for the purpose of counterbalancing statewide greenhouse gas emissions when determining the states progress toward achieving net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to subdivision (c).
(d)(e)The state board shall work with relevant state agencies to do both of the following:
(1)Ensure that updates to the scoping plan required pursuant to Section 38561 identify and recommend measures to achieve the policy goals stated in subdivision (c).
(2)Identify and implement a variety of policies and strategies that enable carbon dioxide removal solutions and carbon capture, utilization, and storage technologies in California to complement emissions reductions and achieve the policy goals stated in subdivision (c).
(e)(f)(1)By December 31, 2035, the state board shall evaluate the feasibility and tradeoffs of achieving the policy goal stated in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) relative to alternative scenarios that achieve the policy goals stated in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), and report its findings and recommendations to the Legislature.
(2)The state board shall report to the Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies annually on progress toward the goals stated in subdivision (c).
(3)As part of its annual reporting requirements pursuant to Section 38592.6, the Legislative Analysts Office, until January 1, 2030, shall conduct independent analyses of the states progress toward the goals stated in subdivision (c) and shall prepare an annual report detailing its review, which may include recommendations for improvements in state actions taken to achieve the goals stated in subdivision (c). When appropriate, these annual reports may incorporate reviews of the state boards evaluation and reporting practices, and may include recommendations for potential changes to advance transparency and accountability. A report prepared pursuant to this paragraph shall be made available to the public.
SEC. 3.Section 38562.3 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:38562.3.(a)(1)The state board shall develop and adopt regulations, or utilize existing programs and regulations, to ensure the state achieves carbon dioxide removals equivalent to at least 100 percent of statewide greenhouse gas emissions in calendar year 2045, and all subsequent years, in order to achieve the net zero and net negative greenhouse gas emissions goals established pursuant to Section 38562.2.
(2)Regulations adopted pursuant to this subdivision shall be consistent with, or impose requirements equivalent to, Chapter 4.3 (commencing with Section 39740) of Part 2 of Division 26 of this code and Part 8 (commencing with Section 71460) of Division 34 of the Public Resources Code, as determined by the state board.
(b)(1)As part of its efforts undertaken pursuant to subdivision (a), the state board shall establish separate interim targets for greenhouse gas emissions reductions and carbon dioxide removals, to be applicable beginning no later than calendar year 2030, and report on progress toward achieving those targets. The state board shall post any report prepared pursuant to this subdivision on its internet website.
(2)The interim target for carbon dioxide removals established pursuant to paragraph (1) for calendar year 2030 shall be at least 1 percent of projected total greenhouse gas emissions for that calendar year.
(c)For purposes of subdivision (c) of Section 38562.2, the state board shall only certify carbon dioxide removal processes that meet all of the following:
(1)The carbon dioxide removal process results in removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, directly or indirectly, and not only the avoidance or reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.
(2)The carbon dioxide removal process is not used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.
(3)If the carbon dioxide removal process requires biomass as a feedstock, it only uses biomass that is produced as a residue or waste product, including, but not limited to, agricultural residues and byproducts of sustainable forest management.
(4)The carbon dioxide removal process is consistent with the requirements of Section 39741.1.
(5)The carbon dioxide removal process uses a form of long-term carbon storage with requirements for financial responsibility and longevity consistent with, or equivalent to, those required under Section 39741.5, as determined by the state board.
(d)To the extent feasible, the requirements of this section shall apply equivalently to all carbon dioxide removal processes certified by the state board whether located inside or outside of the state.
SEC. 4.Section 39741.4 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:39741.4.In furtherance of the objectives in Section 39741.1, by January 1, 2024, the state board may adopt protocols to support additional methods of utilization or storage of captured or removed carbon dioxide, including carbon capture for use in products and in methods of long-term storage as identified by the state board.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has recognized that limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) over preindustrial times will require not only large reductions in global carbon dioxide emissions from human sources but also carbon dioxide removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, a report by the IPCC released in early 2022, states, [t]he deployment of CDR to counterbalance hard-to-abate residual emissions is unavoidable if net zero CO2 or GHG emissions are to be achieved.
(2)Assembly Bill 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337 of the Statutes of 2022) established a target for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by at least 85 percent from 1990 levels by 2045 as part of achieving net zero GHG emissions. California will need to employ CDR to balance out the remaining up to 15 percent GHG emissions to achieve the net zero target.
(3)The State Air Resources Boards 2022 Scoping Plan for Achieving Carbon Neutrality, dated November 16, 2022, stated, [t]he modeling shows that emissions from the AB 32 GHG Inventory sources will continue to persist even if all fossil related combustion emissions are phased out. These residual emissions must be compensated for to achieve carbon neutrality.
(4)The 2022 Scoping Plan estimated that the state would need approximately 75 million metric tons (MMT) of CDR in 2045 in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions. It further identified a target of 7 MMT per year of CDR by 2030 as an ambitious, but achievable, goal that can serve as an important marker for progress in deploying CDR to support Californias carbon neutrality goal.
(5)Therefore, although CDR should not be seen as a reason to prolong the states reliance on fossil fuels or as an excuse for not reducing GHG emissions as quickly as is feasible, CDR is widely predicted to be an important and necessary part of achieving the states net zero target.
(6)A diversity of approaches can be used to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequester it, including natural processes, engineered mechanical and chemical processes, or a combination of these approaches.
(7)Once carbon dioxide is released into the atmosphere from previously inert sources, such as fossil fuels, it causes increases in atmospheric concentrations of CO2 that will last thousands of years, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency.
(8)CDR that is intended to balance out continued emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should therefore result in long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere on a similar time scale to that of the released carbon dioxide.
(9)Very little capacity exists currently to provide CDR that can meet these criteria for long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and this capacity, along with the supporting infrastructure for transporting and sequestering the removed carbon, will need to be scaled up enormously in order to meet the needs estimated for the states target of achieving net zero GHG emissions by 2045.
(10)CDR approaches that can reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide for shorter periods of time can also provide valuable services in reducing climate change, but they eventually must be coupled with more durable sequestration of carbon in order to truly balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases.
(11)In order to be counted for the purpose of balancing continued residual emissions of greenhouse gases, CDR processes must be quantifiable and must include scientifically rigorous approaches to monitor and verify the sequestration of removed carbon in order to ensure that the reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide is maintained over long periods of time.
(12)CDR that is intended to balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should represent true removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and not just the avoidance of emissions that might otherwise have occurred, as is sometimes allowed in carbon offset programs.
(13)Consistent with the polluter pays principle, the entities responsible for GHG emissions should be responsible for paying for CDR sufficient to balance the impact on climate change of those GHG emissions.
(14)Developing and manufacturing the technologies needed to capture and sequester carbon dioxide and building and operating the facilities and supporting infrastructure used for CDR can be a source of jobs, economic development, and tax revenues for the state and can establish the state as a leader in exporting these products to help the rest of the world achieve reductions in net GHG emissions.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to implement a program to grow the CDR capacity and supporting infrastructure that is necessary to achieve carbon dioxide removal in sufficient volume to attain the states target for net zero greenhouse gas emissions, as set forth in Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code.
SEC. 2.Article 3 (commencing with Section 39742) is added to Chapter 4.3 of Part 2 of Division 26 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:3.Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act39742.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act.
39742.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Carbon dioxide equivalent has the same meaning as defined in Section 38505.
(b)Carbon dioxide removal process means a process using biological means, chemical means, physical means, or any combination of these means, including the use of CDR technology as defined in Section 39741, that results in a net reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide and puts carbon atoms into a form of carbon sequestration.
(c)Carbon sequestration means storing carbon atoms in a geological location or in a stable chemical form so that the geological location or the stable chemical form keeps the carbon atoms from entering the atmosphere as carbon dioxide for a period of time.
(d)Direct climate mitigation benefits to the state means a local reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration within the state caused by removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere within or sufficiently close to that area.
(e)Durable carbon sequestration method means a method of carbon sequestration that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of the carbon atoms out of the atmosphere for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity provides a guarantee period of at least 100 years.
(f)Emitting entity means an entity that is responsible for greenhouse gas emissions included within the states inventory and has an obligation to balance the impact of some or all of those greenhouse gas emissions through the purchase of negative emissions credits pursuant to Section 39742.4.
(g)Guarantee period means the period of time during which the responsible entity is required to ensure that the carbon remains sequestered and to replace any carbon that is lost.
(h)Negative emissions credit means a tradeable environmental attribute representing one metric ton of net carbon dioxide removed by a carbon dioxide removal process.
(i)Negative emissions obligation means the amount of negative emissions credits an emitting entity is required to purchase and retire each year in order to partially or fully balance the impact of the greenhouse gas emissions for which the emitting entity is responsible.
(j)Neighboring communities means the local government, residents, and other private entities in areas that are in close proximity to facilities used in a carbon dioxide removal process.
(k)Net carbon dioxide removed means the net amount of carbon dioxide, by mass, that is removed by a carbon dioxide removal process per ton of carbon put into carbon sequestration, as measured over the full lifecycle of the process, including any greenhouse gas emissions caused by the use of energy or fuels to drive the process, transport the captured carbon, or sequester the carbon.
(l)Responsible entity means a business, organization, or other entity that is responsible for ensuring that sequestered carbon is monitored and verified during the guarantee period and is responsible for replacing any losses to the sequestered carbon during the guarantee period.
(m)Temporary carbon sequestration method means any method of carbon sequestration that does not meet the criteria for a durable carbon sequestration method.
39742.2.(a)No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits. In establishing these rules and processes, the state board shall consider all of the following:
(1)Criteria to ensure that certified carbon dioxide removal processes result in reductions in atmospheric carbon dioxide that are real, quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by the state board and are in addition to any carbon dioxide removals that are otherwise required by law or regulation. Only processes that result in removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, not avoidance of or reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, may be certified for the purpose of creating negative emissions credits.
(2)A method to determine the net carbon dioxide removed by each certified carbon dioxide removal process.
(3)Criteria to determine whether each certified carbon dioxide removal process qualifies as using a durable carbon sequestration method.
(4)Requirements for scientifically rigorous and transparent methods for monitoring, reporting, and verification by responsible entities.
(5)Requirements for responsible entities to replace any losses in sequestered carbon during the guarantee period with newly sequestered carbon representing an equal amount of net carbon dioxide removed.
(6)Financial responsibility requirements for responsible entities to demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations during the guarantee period, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.
(7)A method of tracking the creation, transfer of ownership, and retirement of negative emissions credits based on certified carbon dioxide removal processes so that the environmental attributes of each negative emissions credit will be counted only once for the purpose of meeting any regulatory or voluntary carbon dioxide removal targets or net greenhouse gas emissions targets.
(b)(1)The state board may develop rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits that can meet the requirements of subdivision (e) of Section 39742.4 for durable carbon sequestration, such as a combination of the following:
(A)A negative emissions credit using a temporary carbon sequestration method.
(B)A legally binding commitment to purchase another negative emissions credit using a durable carbon sequestration method at the end of the guarantee period of the original temporary negative emissions credit.
(2)For any two-phase negative emissions credits created pursuant to this section, the state board shall do all of the following:
(A)Establish a method for tracking compliance with future negative emission credit purchase commitments.
(B)Establish financial responsibility requirements to ensure that the responsible entity can demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.
39742.3.(a)The state board shall not certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if the process is used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.
(b)(1)The state board may elect not to certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if it determines the benefits generated by the carbon dioxide removal process do not outweigh the impacts caused by the carbon dioxide removal process, including, but not limited to, benefits and impacts to neighboring communities.
(2)In making the determination pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall consider at least all of the following:
(A)Impacts on deforestation or the displacement of agricultural land to grow dedicated biomass for carbon sequestration.
(B)Impacts on neighboring communities from increases in criteria air pollutants caused by equipment used to capture, transport, sequester, or monitor the carbon.
(C)Benefits to neighboring communities from investment, jobs, and tax revenues associated with carbon dioxide removal processes.
39742.4.No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall adopt a regulation to require emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a portion of their greenhouse gas emissions in each calendar year beginning with greenhouse gas emissions for calendar year 2028 in accordance with all of the following:
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), only emitting entities with an obligation to report their greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to the regulation adopted by the state board pursuant to Section 38530 and who report 25,000 metric tons or more of greenhouse gas emissions per year shall be considered emitting entities for the purposes of this article.
(b)The state board may include additional entities as emitting entities if the annual greenhouse gas emissions of those entities can be estimated with reasonable accuracy and without an unreasonable measurement burden on those entities.
(c)The regulation shall establish a negative emissions obligation that requires emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a percentage of the carbon dioxide equivalent of their greenhouse gas emissions for each calendar year, as determined by the state board pursuant to subdivision (d).
(d)The state board shall determine the percentage required pursuant to subdivision (c) for each year, beginning with calendar year 2028, with the goal of increasing the total capacity to provide negative emissions credits over time in order to meet the states net zero greenhouse gas emissions policy set forth in Section 38562.2. Those percentages shall be at least the following percentages in the following years:
(1)One percent in 2030.
(2)Eight percent in 2035.
(3)Thirty-five percent in 2040.
(4)One hundred percent in 2045.
(e)Only negative emissions credits using a durable carbon sequestration method may be used to meet an emitting entitys negative emissions obligation.
(f)If the state board develops rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 39742.2, no more than 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year may be two-phase emissions credits.
(g)At least 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year shall be from carbon dioxide removal processes that provide direct climate mitigation benefits to the state.
(h)The state board may adjust any of the percentages specified in subdivision (g) or in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (d) to a lower figure if it determines that it would be infeasible for emitting entities to comply with those requirements.
(i)The state board may allow an emitting entity to reserve negative emissions credits purchased in excess of its obligation in a calendar year pursuant to subdivision (c) and to use those negative emissions credits to meet its obligation in a future calendar year.
(j)Negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits for the purpose of complying with the obligation pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Section 38562.2, even if those negative emissions occurred outside of the state.
39742.5.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has recognized that limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) over preindustrial times will require not only large reductions in global carbon dioxide emissions from human sources but also carbon dioxide removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, a report by the IPCC released in early 2022, states, [t]he deployment of CDR to counterbalance hard-to-abate residual emissions is unavoidable if net zero CO2 or GHG emissions are to be achieved.
(2)Assembly Bill 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337 of the Statutes of 2022) established a target for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by at least 85 percent from 1990 levels by 2045 as part of achieving net zero GHG emissions. California will need to employ CDR to balance out the remaining up to 15 percent GHG emissions to achieve the net zero target.
(3)The State Air Resources Boards 2022 Scoping Plan for Achieving Carbon Neutrality, dated November 16, 2022, stated, [t]he modeling shows that emissions from the AB 32 GHG Inventory sources will continue to persist even if all fossil related combustion emissions are phased out. These residual emissions must be compensated for to achieve carbon neutrality.
(4)The 2022 Scoping Plan estimated that the state would need approximately 75 million metric tons (MMT) of CDR in 2045 in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions. It further identified a target of 7 MMT per year of CDR by 2030 as an ambitious, but achievable, goal that can serve as an important marker for progress in deploying CDR to support Californias carbon neutrality goal.
(5)Therefore, although CDR should not be seen as a reason to prolong the states reliance on fossil fuels or as an excuse for not reducing GHG emissions as quickly as is feasible, CDR is widely predicted to be an important and necessary part of achieving the states net zero target.
(6)A diversity of approaches can be used to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequester it, including natural processes, engineered mechanical and chemical processes, or a combination of these approaches.
(7)Once carbon dioxide is released into the atmosphere from previously inert sources, such as fossil fuels, it causes increases in atmospheric concentrations of CO2 that will last thousands of years, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency.
(8)CDR that is intended to balance out continued emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should therefore result in long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere on a similar time scale to that of the released carbon dioxide.
(9)Very little capacity exists currently to provide CDR that can meet these criteria for long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and this capacity, along with the supporting infrastructure for transporting and sequestering the removed carbon, will need to be scaled up enormously in order to meet the needs estimated for the states target of achieving net zero GHG emissions by 2045.
(10)CDR approaches that can reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide for shorter periods of time can also provide valuable services in reducing climate change, but they eventually must be coupled with more durable sequestration of carbon in order to truly balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases.
(11)In order to be counted for the purpose of balancing continued residual emissions of greenhouse gases, CDR processes must be quantifiable and must include scientifically rigorous approaches to monitor and verify the sequestration of removed carbon in order to ensure that the reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide is maintained over long periods of time.
(12)CDR that is intended to balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should represent true removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and not just the avoidance of emissions that might otherwise have occurred, as is sometimes allowed in carbon offset programs.
(13)Consistent with the polluter pays principle, the entities responsible for GHG emissions should be responsible for paying for CDR sufficient to balance the impact on climate change of those GHG emissions.
(14)Developing and manufacturing the technologies needed to capture and sequester carbon dioxide and building and operating the facilities and supporting infrastructure used for CDR can be a source of jobs, economic development, and tax revenues for the state and can establish the state as a leader in exporting these products to help the rest of the world achieve reductions in net GHG emissions.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to implement a program to grow the CDR capacity and supporting infrastructure that is necessary to achieve carbon dioxide removal in sufficient volume to attain the states target for net zero greenhouse gas emissions, as set forth in Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code.
SEC. 2.Article 3 (commencing with Section 39742) is added to Chapter 4.3 of Part 2 of Division 26 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:3.Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act39742.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act.
39742.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Carbon dioxide equivalent has the same meaning as defined in Section 38505.
(b)Carbon dioxide removal process means a process using biological means, chemical means, physical means, or any combination of these means means, including the use of CDR technology as defined in Section 39741, that results in a net reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide and puts carbon atoms into a form of carbon sequestration.
(c)Carbon sequestration means storing carbon atoms in a geological location or in a stable chemical form so that the geological location or the stable chemical form keeps the carbon atoms from entering the atmosphere as carbon dioxide for a period of time.
(d)Direct climate mitigation benefits to the state means a local reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration within the state caused by removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere within or sufficiently close to that area.
(e)Durable carbon sequestration method means a method of carbon sequestration that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of the carbon atoms out of the atmosphere for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity provides a guarantee period of at least 100 years.
(f)Emitting entity means an entity that is responsible for greenhouse gas emissions included within the states inventory and has an obligation to balance the impact of some or all of those greenhouse gas emissions through the purchase of negative emissions credits pursuant to Section 39742.4.
(g)Guarantee period means the period of time during which the responsible entity is required to ensure that the carbon remains sequestered and to replace any carbon that is lost.
(h)Negative emissions credit means a tradeable environmental attribute representing one metric ton of net carbon dioxide removed by a carbon dioxide removal process.
(i)Negative emissions obligation means the amount of negative emissions credits an emitting entity is required to purchase and retire each year in order to partially or fully balance the impact of the greenhouse gas emissions for which the emitting entity is responsible.
(j)Neighboring communities means the local government, residents, and other private entities in areas that are in close proximity to facilities used in a carbon dioxide removal process.
(k)Net carbon dioxide removed means the net amount of carbon dioxide, by mass, that is removed by a carbon dioxide removal process per ton of carbon put into carbon sequestration, as measured over the full lifecycle of the process, including any greenhouse gas emissions caused by the use of energy or fuels to drive the process, transport the captured carbon, or sequester the carbon.
(l)Responsible entity means a business, organization, or other entity that is responsible for ensuring that sequestered carbon is monitored and verified during the guarantee period and is responsible for replacing any losses to the sequestered carbon during the guarantee period.
(m)Temporary carbon sequestration method means any method of carbon sequestration that does not meet the criteria for a durable carbon sequestration method.
39742.2.(a)No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits. In establishing these rules and processes, the state board shall consider all of the following:
(1)Criteria to ensure that certified carbon dioxide removal processes result in reductions in atmospheric carbon dioxide that are real, quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by the state board and are in addition to any carbon dioxide removals that are otherwise required by law or regulation. Only processes that result in removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, not avoidance of or reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, may be certified for the purpose of creating negative emissions credits.
(2)A method to determine the net carbon dioxide removed by each certified carbon dioxide removal process.
(3)Criteria to determine whether each certified carbon dioxide removal process qualifies as using a durable carbon sequestration method.
(4)Requirements for scientifically rigorous and transparent methods for monitoring, reporting, and verification by responsible entities.
(5)Requirements for responsible entities to replace any losses in sequestered carbon during the guarantee period with newly sequestered carbon representing an equal amount of net carbon dioxide removed.
(6)Requirements Financial responsibility requirements for responsible entities to demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations during the guarantee period, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.
(7)A method of tracking the creation, transfer of ownership, and retirement of negative emissions credits based on certified carbon dioxide removal processes so that the environmental attributes of each negative emissions credit will be counted only once for the purpose of meeting any regulatory or voluntary carbon dioxide removal targets or net greenhouse gas emissions targets.
(b)(1)The state board may develop rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits that can meet the requirements of subdivision (e) of Section 39742.4 for durable carbon sequestration, such as a combination of the following:
(A)A negative emissions credit using a temporary carbon sequestration method.
(B)A legally binding commitment to purchase another negative emissions credit using a durable carbon sequestration method at the end of the guarantee period of the original temporary negative emissions credit.
(2)For any two-phase negative emissions credits created pursuant to this section, the state board shall do all of the following:
(A)Establish a method for tracking compliance with future negative emission credit purchase commitments.
(B)Establish financial responsibility requirements to ensure that the responsible entity can demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.
39742.3.(a)The state board shall not certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if the process is used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery. recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.
(b)(1)The state board may elect not to certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if it determines the benefits generated by the carbon dioxide removal process do not outweigh the impacts caused by the carbon dioxide removal process, including, but not limited to, benefits and impacts to neighboring communities.
(2)In making the determination pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall consider at least all of the following:
(A)Impacts on deforestation or the displacement of agricultural land to grow dedicated biomass for carbon sequestration.
(B)Impacts on neighboring communities from increases in criteria air pollutants caused by equipment used to capture, transport, sequester, or monitor the carbon.
(C)Benefits to neighboring communities from investment, jobs, and tax revenues associated with carbon dioxide removal processes.
39742.4.No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall adopt a regulation to require emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a portion of their greenhouse gas emissions in each calendar year beginning with greenhouse gas emissions for calendar year 2028 in accordance with all of the following:
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), only emitting entities with an obligation to report their greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to the regulation adopted by the state board pursuant to Section 38530 shall be considered emitting entities for the purposes of this article.
(b)The state board may include additional entities as emitting entities if the annual greenhouse gas emissions of those entities can be estimated with reasonable accuracy and without an unreasonable measurement burden on those entities.
(c)The regulation shall establish a negative emissions obligation that requires emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a percentage of the carbon dioxide equivalent of their greenhouse gas emissions for each calendar year, as determined by the state board pursuant to subdivision (d).
(d)The state board shall determine the percentage required pursuant to subdivision (c) for each year, beginning with calendar year 2028, with the goal of increasing the total capacity to provide negative emissions credits over time in order to meet the states net zero greenhouse gas emissions policy set forth in Section 38562.2. Those percentages shall be at least the following percentages in the following years:
(1)One percent in 2030.
(2)Eight percent in 2035.
(3)Thirty-five percent in 2040.
(4)One hundred percent in 2045.
(e)Only negative emissions credits using a durable carbon sequestration method may be used to meet an emitting entitys negative emissions obligation.
(f)If the state board develops rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 39742.2, no more than 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year may be two-phase emissions credits.
(g)At least 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year shall be from carbon dioxide removal processes that provide direct climate mitigation benefits to the state.
(h)The state board may adjust any of the percentages specified in subdivision (g) or in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (d) to a lower figure if it determines that it would be infeasible for emitting entities to comply with those requirements.
(i)The state board may allow an emitting entity to reserve negative emissions credits purchased in excess of its obligation in a calendar year pursuant to subdivision (c) and to use those negative emissions credits to meet its obligation in a future calendar year.
(j)Negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits for the purpose of complying with the obligation pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Section 38562.2, even if those negative emissions occurred outside of the state.
39742.5.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has recognized that limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) over preindustrial times will require not only large reductions in global carbon dioxide emissions from human sources but also carbon dioxide removal (CDR) from the atmosphere. Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, a report by the IPCC released in early 2022, states, [t]he deployment of CDR to counterbalance hard-to-abate residual emissions is unavoidable if net zero CO2 or GHG emissions are to be achieved.
(2)Assembly Bill 1279 (Muratsuchi, Chapter 337 of the Statutes of 2022) established a target for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by at least 85 percent from 1990 levels by 2045 as part of achieving net zero GHG emissions. California will need to employ CDR to balance out the remaining up to 15 percent GHG emissions to achieve the net zero target.
(3)The State Air Resources Boards 2022 Scoping Plan for Achieving Carbon Neutrality, dated November 16, 2022, stated, [t]he modeling shows that emissions from the AB 32 GHG Inventory sources will continue to persist even if all fossil related combustion emissions are phased out. These residual emissions must be compensated for to achieve carbon neutrality.
(4)The 2022 Scoping Plan estimated that the state would need approximately 75 million metric tons (MMT) of CDR in 2045 in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions. It further identified a target of 7 MMT per year of CDR by 2030 as an ambitious, but achievable, goal that can serve as an important marker for progress in deploying CDR to support Californias carbon neutrality goal.
(5)Therefore, although CDR should not be seen as a reason to prolong the states reliance on fossil fuels or as an excuse for not reducing GHG emissions as quickly as is feasible, CDR is widely predicted to be an important and necessary part of achieving the states net zero target.
(6)A diversity of approaches can be used to remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequester it, including natural processes, engineered mechanical and chemical processes, or a combination of these approaches.
(7)Once carbon dioxide is released into the atmosphere from previously inert sources, such as fossil fuels, it causes increases in atmospheric concentrations of CO2 that will last thousands of years, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency.
(8)CDR that is intended to balance out continued emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should therefore result in long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere on a similar time scale to that of the released carbon dioxide.
(9)Very little capacity exists currently to provide CDR that can meet these criteria for long-lasting reductions in carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and this capacity, along with the supporting infrastructure for transporting and sequestering the removed carbon, will need to be scaled up enormously in order to meet the needs estimated for the states target of achieving net zero GHG emissions by 2045.
(10)CDR approaches that can reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide for shorter periods of time can also provide valuable services in reducing climate change, but they eventually must be coupled with more durable sequestration of carbon in order to truly balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases.
(11)In order to be counted for the purpose of balancing continued residual emissions of greenhouse gases, CDR processes must be quantifiable and must include scientifically rigorous approaches to monitor and verify the sequestration of removed carbon in order to ensure that the reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide is maintained over long periods of time.
(12)CDR that is intended to balance the impact of residual emissions of greenhouse gases in order to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045 should represent true removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and not just the avoidance of emissions that might otherwise have occurred, as is sometimes allowed in carbon offset programs.
(13)Consistent with the polluter pays principle, the entities responsible for GHG emissions should be responsible for paying for CDR sufficient to balance the impact on climate change of those GHG emissions.
(14)Developing and manufacturing the technologies needed to capture and sequester carbon dioxide and building and operating the facilities and supporting infrastructure used for CDR can be a source of jobs, economic development, and tax revenues for the state and can establish the state as a leader in exporting these products to help the rest of the world achieve reductions in net GHG emissions.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature to implement a program to grow the CDR capacity and supporting infrastructure that is necessary to achieve carbon dioxide removal in sufficient volume to attain the states target for net zero greenhouse gas emissions, as set forth in Section 38562.2 of the Health and Safety Code.
SEC. 2.Article 3 (commencing with Section 39742) is added to Chapter 4.3 of Part 2 of Division 26 of the Health and Safety Code, to read:3.Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act39742.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act.
39742.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Carbon dioxide equivalent has the same meaning as defined in Section 38505.
(b)Carbon dioxide removal process means a process using biological means, chemical means, physical means, or any combination of these means that results in a net reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide and puts carbon atoms into a form of carbon sequestration.
(c)Carbon sequestration means storing carbon atoms in a geological location or in a stable chemical form so that the geological location or the stable chemical form keeps the carbon atoms from entering the atmosphere as carbon dioxide for a period of time.
(d)Direct climate mitigation benefits to the state means a local reduction in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration within the state caused by removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere within or sufficiently close to that area.
(e)Durable carbon sequestration method means a method of carbon sequestration that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of the carbon atoms out of the atmosphere for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity provides a guarantee period of at least 100 years.
(f)Emitting entity means an entity that is responsible for greenhouse gas emissions included within the states inventory and has an obligation to balance the impact of some or all of those greenhouse gas emissions through the purchase of negative emissions credits pursuant to Section 39742.4.
(g)Guarantee period means the period of time during which the responsible entity is required to ensure that the carbon remains sequestered and to replace any carbon that is lost.
(h)Negative emissions credit means a tradeable environmental attribute representing one metric ton of net carbon dioxide removed by a carbon dioxide removal process.
(i)Negative emissions obligation means the amount of negative emissions credits an emitting entity is required to purchase and retire each year in order to partially or fully balance the impact of the greenhouse gas emissions for which the emitting entity is responsible.
(j)Neighboring communities means the local government, residents, and other private entities in areas that are in close proximity to facilities used in a carbon dioxide removal process.
(k)Net carbon dioxide removed means the net amount of carbon dioxide, by mass, that is removed by a carbon dioxide removal process per ton of carbon put into carbon sequestration, as measured over the full lifecycle of the process, including any greenhouse gas emissions caused by the use of energy or fuels to drive the process, transport the captured carbon, or sequester the carbon.
(l)Responsible entity means a business, organization, or other entity that is responsible for ensuring that sequestered carbon is monitored and verified during the guarantee period and is responsible for replacing any losses to the sequestered carbon during the guarantee period.
(m)Temporary carbon sequestration method means any method of carbon sequestration that does not meet the criteria for a durable carbon sequestration method.
39742.2.(a)No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that may be used to create negative emissions credits and for tracking negative emissions credits. In establishing these rules and processes, the state board shall consider all of the following:
(1)Criteria to ensure that certified carbon dioxide removal processes result in reductions in atmospheric carbon dioxide that are real, quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by the state board and are in addition to any carbon dioxide removals that are otherwise required by law or regulation. Only processes that result in removals of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, not avoidance of or reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, may be certified for the purpose of creating negative emissions credits.
(2)A method to determine the net carbon dioxide removed by each certified carbon dioxide removal process.
(3)Criteria to determine whether each certified carbon dioxide removal process qualifies as using a durable carbon sequestration method.
(4)Requirements for scientifically rigorous and transparent methods for monitoring, reporting, and verification by responsible entities.
(5)Requirements for responsible entities to replace any losses in sequestered carbon during the guarantee period with newly sequestered carbon representing an equal amount of net carbon dioxide removed.
(6)Requirements for responsible entities to demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations during the guarantee period, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.
(7)A method of tracking the creation, transfer of ownership, and retirement of negative emissions credits based on certified carbon dioxide removal processes so that the environmental attributes of each negative emissions credit will be counted only once for the purpose of meeting any regulatory or voluntary carbon dioxide removal targets or net greenhouse gas emissions targets.
(b)(1)The state board may develop rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits that can meet the requirements of subdivision (e) of Section 39742.4 for durable carbon sequestration, such as a combination of the following:
(A)A negative emissions credit using a temporary carbon sequestration method.
(B)A legally binding commitment to purchase another negative emissions credit using a durable carbon sequestration method at the end of the guarantee period of the original temporary negative emissions credit.
(2)For any two-phase negative emissions credits created pursuant to this section, the state board shall do all of the following:
(A)Establish a method for tracking compliance with future negative emission credit purchase commitments.
(B)Establish requirements to ensure that the responsible entity can demonstrate that they, or another entity on their behalf, has the financial ability to meet their obligations, such as through the use of surety bonds or other insurance products.
39742.3.(a)The state board shall not certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if the process is used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery.
(b)(1)The state board may elect not to certify a carbon dioxide removal process pursuant to Section 39742.2 if it determines the benefits generated by the carbon dioxide removal process do not outweigh the impacts caused by the carbon dioxide removal process, including, but not limited to, benefits and impacts to neighboring communities.
(2)In making the determination pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall consider at least all of the following:
(A)Impacts on deforestation or the displacement of agricultural land to grow dedicated biomass for carbon sequestration.
(B)Impacts on neighboring communities from increases in criteria air pollutants caused by equipment used to capture, transport, sequester, or monitor the carbon.
(C)Benefits to neighboring communities from investment, jobs, and tax revenues associated with carbon dioxide removal processes.
39742.4.No later than December 31, 2027, the state board shall adopt a regulation to require emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a portion of their greenhouse gas emissions in each calendar year beginning with greenhouse gas emissions for calendar year 2028 in accordance with all of the following:
(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), only emitting entities with an obligation to report their greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to the regulation adopted by the state board pursuant to Section 38530 shall be considered emitting entities for the purposes of this article.
(b)The state board may include additional entities as emitting entities if the annual greenhouse gas emissions of those entities can be estimated with reasonable accuracy and without an unreasonable measurement burden on those entities.
(c)The regulation shall establish a negative emissions obligation that requires emitting entities to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a percentage of the carbon dioxide equivalent of their greenhouse gas emissions for each calendar year, as determined by the state board pursuant to subdivision (d).
(d)The state board shall determine the percentage required pursuant to subdivision (c) for each year, beginning with calendar year 2028, with the goal of increasing the total capacity to provide negative emissions credits over time in order to meet the states net zero greenhouse gas emissions policy set forth in Section 38562.2. Those percentages shall be at least the following percentages in the following years:
(1)One percent in 2030.
(2)Eight percent in 2035.
(3)Thirty-five percent in 2040.
(4)One hundred percent in 2045.
(e)Only negative emissions credits using a durable carbon sequestration method may be used to meet an emitting entitys negative emissions obligation.
(f)If the state board develops rules to create two-phase negative emissions credits pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 39742.2, no more than 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year may be two-phase emissions credits.
(g)At least 50 percent of the negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity to meet its negative emissions obligation in any calendar year shall be from carbon dioxide removal processes that provide direct climate mitigation benefits to the state.
(h)The state board may adjust any of the percentages specified in subdivision (g) or in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (d) to a lower figure if it determines that it would be infeasible for emitting entities to comply with those requirements.
(i)The state board may allow an emitting entity to reserve negative emissions credits purchased in excess of its obligation in a calendar year pursuant to subdivision (c) and to use those negative emissions credits to meet its obligation in a future calendar year.
(j)Negative emissions resulting from the use of negative emissions credits for the purpose of complying with the obligation pursuant to subdivision (c) shall be included in the calculation of the states net greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Section 38562.2, even if those negative emissions occurred outside of the state.
39742.5.The provisions of this article are severable. If any provision of this article or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that encourages the development of carbon dioxide removal in order to meet the states carbon dioxide removal targets.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact future legislation that encourages the development of carbon dioxide removal in order to meet the states carbon dioxide removal targets.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | August 15 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 8, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 8, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (July 1). |
| Jun 21, 2024 | June 24 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jul 6, 2023 | July 10 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 8, 2023 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| May 25, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 25, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 24. Noes 9. Page 1290.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 1164.) (May 18). |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 1, 2023 | May 1 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 21, 2023 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 793.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Mar 22, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Mar 14, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 3, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 5. |
| Feb 2, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB308 Becker | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 350 Sacramento | ** Support | |
| American Forest & Paper Association | ** Against | |
| Biofuelwatch | ** Against | |
| California Carbon Dioxide Removal Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Carbon Solutions Coalition | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Farm Bureau | ** Against | |
| California Manufacturers & Technology Association | ** Against | |
| Carbon Removal Alliance | ** Support | |
| Center For Biological Diversity | ** Against | |
| Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment | ** Against | |
| Central California Asthma Collaborative | ** Against | |
| Central Valley Air Quality Coalition | ** Against | |
| Clean Air Task Force | ** Support | |
| Climate Action California | ** Support | |
| Climeworks | ** Support | |
| Conservation Strategy Group | ** Support | |
| Ebb Carbon | ** Support | |
| Elders Climate Action, Norcal and Socal Chapters | ** Support | |
| Environmental Defense Fund | ** Support | |
| Generation 2030 | ** Support | |
| Heirloom Carbon | ** Support | |
| Indivisible Ca Statestrong | ** Support | |
| Indivisible Yolo | ** Support | |
| Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability | ** Against | |
| League Of Women Voters Of California | ** Support | |
| Little Manila Rising | ** Against | |
| Menlo Spark | ** Support | |
| Ocean Iron Fertilization Alliance | ** Support | |
| Openair Collective | ** Support | |
| Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| Planetary Technologies | ** Support | |
| Producer Accountability for Carbon Emissions | ** Support | |
| Project 2030 | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility | ** Against | |
| Santa Cruz Climate Action Network | ** Support | |
| US Green Building Council | ** Support | |
| Western States Petroleum Association | ** Against | |
| World Resources Institute | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 308
Author:(Becker) – As Amended Ver:July 8, 2024
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 9 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to adopt specified standards and targets for carbon dioxide (CO2) removal (CDR) to help achieve climate goals.
Specifically, this bill:
1) Requires ARB to adopt regulations to ensure the state achieves CDR equivalent to at least 100% of statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2045, in order to achieve net zero and net negative GHG emissions goals.
2) Requires ARB to conduct a community engagement process before the rulemaking process.
3) Requires ARB to establish separate interim targets for GHG emissions reductions and CDR, to apply no later than 2030, and report on progress toward achieving those targets.
4) Requires ARB to certify only CDR processes that meet all of the following:
a) The CDR process results in removals of CO2 from the atmosphere and not only the avoidance or reduction of GHG emissions, or the prevention of GHG emissions through the use of carbon capture, utilization, and storage.
b) The CDR process results in removals of CO2 that are quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by ARB.
c) The CDR process is not used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.
d) If the CDR process requires biomass as a feedstock, it only uses biomass that is produced as a residue or waste product, including, but not limited to, agricultural residues and byproducts of sustainable forest management.
e) The CDR process is consistent with the requirements of Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program established by ARB pursuant to prior legislation.
f) The CDR process uses a form of long-term carbon storage with specified requirements for financial responsibility and longevity.
5) Requires ARB to include nature-based CDR strategies that meet the requirements above either individually or when coupled with CDR processes with sufficiently long-term carbon storage.
6) To the extent feasible, requires ARB to apply these requirements equivalently to all CDR processes approved by ARB whether located inside or outside of the state.
7) Prohibits ARB approval of a CDR process that includes an industrial facility or engineered infrastructure until the owner or operator provides a written attestation that the owner or operator has done community engagement with at least three community meetings and has a plan for providing meaningful community benefits to residents of the surrounding community.
8) Requires the ARB Chair to appear before the Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies to report on implementation of this bill.
9) Adds a deadline of July 1, 2027, for ARB to implement the Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program enacted by previous legislation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
ARB reports the following costs from the Cost of Implementation Account:
- For fiscal year 2024-25, $8,420,000, including $5,670,000 for 25 full-time positions; and $1,750,000 for contracts for updated GHG projections to establish interim targets and to support the complaint process.
- For fiscal year 2025-26, $5,895,000, including $5,645,000 for the 25 positions and $500,000 for contracts.
- For fiscal year 2026-27 annually ongoing, $5,745,000 for the 25 positions and $100,000 for contracts.
Duties of the 25 positions include adopting regulations to support CDR targets, conducting economic and environmental analysis for the rulemaking, establishing a reporting and accounting framework, setting interim CDR targets and reporting on progress, evaluating existing programs and regulations for feasibility to support CDR targets, determining communities most likely to be near potential carbon dioxide removal projects, developing a community engagement process prior to regulations, collaborating with the Environmental Justice Advisory Committee, managing complaints regarding project self-attestations, providing legal support for regulation development, and providing administrative and fiscal support.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In 2022, California passed landmark legislation committing the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. To achieve the net zero target, the state will need CDR to balance those remaining 15% of emissions. Today, the state has no plan for scaling up that CDR capacity to produce the needed “negative emissions,” and there are no rules for what should count as negative emissions or how to keep track of it. There are a wide variety of approaches to CDR being developed, but they are early-stage, low volume, and expensive.
Since California is going to need large volumes of negative emissions to meet its climate targets, we need a plan for helping those CDR solutions mature, scale up, and reduce costs over time. As the Draft 2022 Scoping Plan Update stated, “Because CDR is critical for achieving carbon neutrality in all alternatives, it is important to begin investment soon to allow demonstration, deployment, and experience to reduce its cost as dependence on it grows toward 2045.
- Background. CDR is an umbrella term to describe strategies to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, without a relationship to where or when the CO2 was emitted. In contrast to carbon capture, CDR is a negative emissions strategy when it involves capturing legacy CO2 directly from the atmosphere. To store the CO2 for long periods, it is generally injected underground into geological formations, such as former oil and gas reservoirs, deep saline formations, and coal beds.
Radical cuts in GHG emissions are critical to climate change mitigation, but in parallel with emissions reductions, most experts agree that CDR is necessary to avert further climate disaster. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) Sixth Assessment asserts that global emissions will need to be cut by almost half by 2030 if warming is to be limited to 1.5°C, the global target in the Paris Agreement. It acknowledged that CDR will be necessary to meet the 1.5℃ target, especially in hard-to-abate sectors.
California also has acknowledged the need for CDR. California has a statutory goal to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. This leaves 15% of emissions that need to be removed, estimated to be about 65 million metric tons (MMT). To balance out those remaining 15% of emissions, ARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projected that the state will need about 75 MMT of CDR by 2045 (65 MMT to balance out the 15% of remaining emissions in the state inventory plus 10 MMT to balance estimated net emissions from natural and working lands).
ARB has raised significant technical and substantive concerns with this bill, stating in summary: “[T]his bill is intended to spur investment in CDR projects, but in reality it sets up new, unique, and difficult hurdles for them, all while precluding nature-based solutions that are needed not just for climate stabilization but ecosystem maintenance and restoration.”
- Prior Legislation. SB 905 (Caballero) Chapter 359, Statutes of 2022, requires ARB to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage (CCRUS) Program.
Analysis Prepared by: Jacqueline Kinney / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 308
Author:(Becker) – As Amended Ver:June 5, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 24-9
SUBJECT: Net zero greenhouse gas emissions goal: carbon dioxide removal: regulations
SUMMARY: Requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to adopt specified standards and targets for carbon dioxide (CO2) removal (CDR).
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires ARB, pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act, to adopt a statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions limit equivalent to 1990 levels by 2020 and to adopt rules and regulations to achieve maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective GHG emission reductions. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 38500 et seq.)
- Requires ARB to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030. (HSC 38566)
- Establishes, pursuant to the California Climate Crisis Act, the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, maintain net negative GHG emissions thereafter, and ensure that by 2045, statewide anthropogenic GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the statewide GHG emissions limit. (HSC 38562.2)
- Requires ARB to prepare and approve a scoping plan, at least once every five years, for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions from sources or categories of sources of GHG emissions. (HSC 38561)
- Requires any direct GHG regulation or market-based compliance mechanism adopted by ARB to achieve GHG emissions reductions that are real, permanent, quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by ARB. (HSC 38562 (d))
- Requires ARB to establish CDR targets for 2030 and beyond, taking into consideration the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy, science-based data, cost-effectiveness, and technological feasibility. (HSC 39740.2)
- Requires ARB to establish a Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program and defines CDR as anthropogenic activities that use technologies or engineered strategies to remove CO2 from the atmosphere and put it into long-term storage, including direct air capture. (HSC 39741 and 39741.1)
THIS BILL:
- Requires ARB to ensure the state achieves CDR equivalent to at least 100% of statewide GHG emissions by 2045, in order to achieve net zero and net negative GHG emissions goals.
- Requires ARB to establish separate interim targets for GHG emissions reductions and CDR, to be applicable beginning no later than 2030, and report on progress toward achieving those targets.
- Requires ARB, for purposes of the net zero GHG target, to only certify CDR processes that meet all of the following:
- The CDR process results in removals of CO2 from the atmosphere, directly or indirectly, and not only the avoidance or reduction of GHG emissions.
- The CDR process is not used for purposes of enhanced oil recovery, including the facilitation of enhanced oil recovery from another well.
- If the CDR process requires biomass as a feedstock, it only uses biomass that is produced as a residue or waste product, including, but not limited to, agricultural residues and byproducts of sustainable forest management.
- The CDR process is consistent with the requirements of Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program established by ARB pursuant to SB 905.
- The CDR process uses a form of long-term carbon storage with specified requirements for financial responsibility and longevity.
- To the extent feasible, requires these requirements to apply equivalently to all CDR processes certified by ARB whether located inside or outside of the state.
- Provides that only CDR certified by ARB is counted for the purpose of counterbalancing statewide GHG emissions when determining the state’s progress toward achieving net zero and net negative GHG emissions.
- Authorizes ARB to adopt protocols for CDR.
- Makes related findings.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Background. CDR is an umbrella term used to describe a range of strategies used to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, without a relationship to where or when the CO2 was emitted. In contrast to carbon capture, CDR is a negative emissions strategy when it involves capturing legacy CO2 directly from the atmosphere. To store the CO2 for long periods, it is generally injected underground into geological formations, such as former oil and gas reservoirs, deep saline formations, and coal beds.
Radical cuts in GHG emissions are critical to climate change mitigation, but in parallel with emissions reductions, most experts agree that CDR is necessary to avert further climate disaster. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) Sixth Assessment asserts that global emissions will need to be cut by almost half by 2030 if warming is to be limited to 1.5°C, the global target in the Paris Agreement. It acknowledged that CDR will be necessary to meet the 1.5℃ target, especially in hard-to-abate sectors.
California too has acknowledged the need for CDR. California has a statutory goal to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. This leaves 15% of emissions that need to be removed, estimated to be about 65 million metric tons (MMT). To balance out those remaining 15% of emissions, ARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projected that the state will need about 75 MMT of CDR by 2045 (65 MMT to balance out the 15% of remaining emissions in the state inventory plus 10 MMT to balance estimated net emissions from natural and working lands).
- Author’s statement:
In 2022, California passed landmark legislation committing the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. To achieve the net zero target, the state will need CDR to balance those remaining 15% of emissions. Today, the state has no plan for scaling up that CDR capacity to produce the needed “negative emissions,” and there are no rules for what should count as negative emissions or how to keep track of it. There are a wide variety of approaches to CDR being developed, but they are early-stage, low volume, and expensive.
Since California is going to need large volumes of negative emissions to meet its climate targets, we need a plan for helping those CDR solutions mature, scale up, and reduce costs over time. As the Draft 2022 Scoping Plan Update stated, “Because CDR is critical for achieving carbon neutrality in all alternatives, it is important to begin investment soon to allow demonstration, deployment, and experience to reduce its cost as dependence on it grows toward 2045.”
SB 308 will create the plan we need for developing the required CDR capacity, with a focus on three issues:
- Putting requirements and guardrails around what CDR pathways will be certified by ARB.
- Ensuring that only that certified, high-quality CDR is counted toward meeting the state’s net zero target.
- Setting interim targets to drive progress in scaling up CDR capacity.
- Proposed author’s amendments. The author has developed several amendments, in consultation with the committee, to address opposition concerns. The proposed amendments:
- Add a finding clarifying the distinction between CDR and carbon capture, utilization and storage (CCUS).
- Clarify that CDR may remove carbon from the atmosphere directly or indirectly, including by direct air capture or using carbon stored in biomass or soil or absorbed in water, and that “nature-based” CDR is included.
- Provide that CDR must be quantifiable, verifiable, and enforceable by ARB.
- Require ARB, prior to rulemaking, to conduct a robust community engagement process that includes outreach that targets residents of communities most likely to be near potential CDR projects.
- Prohibit ARB approval of CDR that includes an industrial facility or engineered infrastructure for any portion of the process until the owner or operator provides a written attestation they have done community engagement and have a plan for providing meaningful benefits to residents of the surrounding community, as specified.
- Require ARB to report on the implementation of this bill to the Joint Legislative Committee on Climate Change Policies.
- Add a deadline of July 1, 2027 for ARB to implement the Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage Program enacted by SB 905.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
350 Sacramento
California Carbon Dioxide Removal Coalition
Clean Air Task Force
Climate Action California
Ebb Carbon
Environmental Defense Fund
Generation 2030
Heirloom Carbon
League of Women Voters of California
Menlo Spark
Ocean Iron Fertilization Alliance
Producer Accountability for Carbon Emissions
Project 2030
Santa Cruz Climate Action Network
US Green Building Council
World Resources Institute
Opposition
American Forest & Paper Association
Biofuelwatch
California Cement Manufacturers Environmental Coalition (unless amended)
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Center for Biological Diversity (unless amended)
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment (unless amended)
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition (unless amended)
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability (unless amended)
Western States Petroleum Association
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 308 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 308
Author: Becker (D)
Amended: 5/18/23
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 4/19/23
AYES: Allen, Gonzalez, Limón, Menjivar, Skinner
NOES: Dahle, Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal (CDR) processes that can be used for negative emissions credits. This bill requires CARB to adopt a regulation requiring certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with that percentage increasing over time.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 and updates thereof (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 38500 et seq.):
- Requires CARB to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030.
- States, under the California Climate Crisis Act, that it is the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions no later than 2045, and to ensure that by 2045 statewide anthropogenic GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 level.
This bill:
- Requires CARB to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal (CDR) processes that can be used for negative emissions credits by December 31, 2027. These rules and processes shall include criteria to ensure CDR processes are real, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional and that sequestration is durable.
- Requires CARB to adopt a regulation by December 31, 2027, to require certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their GHG emissions beginning in 2028, with those percentages increasing in 5-year intervals to reach 100% in 2045.
- Emitting agencies are those subject to CARB’s Mandatory Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting Regulation (MRR) and those who report 25,000 metric tons or more of GHG emissions per year.
- Allows CARB to develop two-phase negative emission credit rules, in which emitting entities may purchase temporary carbon sequestration methods with a legally binding commitment to purchase durable carbon sequestration at the end of the guarantee period of the temporary negative emissions credits.
- Durable carbon sequestration is defined as a process that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of carbon atoms for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity proves a guarantee of at least 100 years.
- Temporary carbon sequestration is defined as any method that does not meet the criteria for durable carbon sequestration.
- Prohibits certification of CDR processes in which carbon dioxide (CO2) is used for enhanced oil recovery (EOR).
- Provides that at least 50% of negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity in any calendar year shall provide direct climate mitigation benefits to California.
- Allows CARB to not certify CDR processes if the carbon removal benefits do not outweigh the impacts to neighboring communities, on deforestation, or of displacement of agricultural land.
Background
- Yes, And: The need for CDR. Radical cuts in GHG emissions are critical to climate change mitigation, but in parallel with emissions reductions, most experts agree that carbon dioxide removal is necessary to avert further climate disaster. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) latest Sixth Assessment, finalized in March 2023, asserts that global emissions will need to be cut by almost half by 2030 if warming is to be limited to 1.5°C, the global target in the Paris Agreement. It acknowledged that CDR will be necessary to meet the 1.5℃ target, especially in hard-to-abate sectors.
California too has acknowledged the need for CDR. California has a statutory goal to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. This leaves 15% of emissions that need to be removed, estimated to be about 65 million metric tons (MMT). To balance out those remaining 15% of emissions, CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projected that the state will need about 75 MMT of CDR by 2045 (65 MMT to balance out the 15% of remaining emissions in the state inventory plus 10 MMT to balance estimated net emissions from natural and working lands).
- CDR vs. CCS. Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) is a process that separates CO2 from a point source, such as the flue of a gas-fired power plant or a cement plant. CCS is generally considered to be a CO2 reduction strategy, not a CO2 removal strategy, since it is only reducing CO2 from anthropogenic sources that would have otherwise entered the atmosphere, rather than removing what was already there. CCS remains controversial because of fears it could prolong the life of fossil fuels and delay the transition to more sustainable fuels, among other concerns.
Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) is an umbrella term used to describe a range of strategies used to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, without a relationship to where or when the CO2 was emitted. In contrast to CCS, CDR is a negative emissions strategy when it involves capturing legacy CO2 directly from the atmosphere. To store the CO2 for long periods, it is generally injected underground into geological formations, such as former oil and gas reservoirs, deep saline formations, and coal beds.
Comments
- Purpose of bill. According to the author, “In 2022, California passed landmark legislation committing the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. To achieve the net zero target, the state will need carbon dioxide removal (CDR) to balance the remaining 15% of emissions. Today, the state has no plan for scaling up that CDR capacity to produce the needed “negative emissions,” and there are no rules for what should count as negative emissions or how to keep track of it. There are a wide variety of approaches to CDR being developed, but they are early-stage, low volume, and expensive. Since California is going to need large volumes of negative emissions to meet its climate targets, we need a plan for helping those CDR solutions – and the supporting transport and storage infrastructure – mature, scale up, and reduce costs over time.”
- How much CDR do we need? First, it is critical to underscore that CDR is no replacement for dramatic emissions reductions. CDR will only feasibly be able to help us reach net-zero CO2 emissions when deployed alongside substantial emissions cuts.
Permanent storage of carbon is a nascent industry. The Global CCS Institute released a report in 2021 that provides a sense of scale. The report found 6 commercial-scale projects worldwide that geologically stored a total of 9 MMT of CO2 per year, with only one in the U.S. that had a capacity of 0.55-1 MMT per year. CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projects a need for 75 MMT of carbon removed and stored annually by 2045 in California alone.
Increasing CDR capacity to the scale projected to meet climate goals will take a massive amount of money. Current CDR prices with durable storage are typically around $200-$700 per ton of carbon, though many available solutions cost upwards of $2,000 per ton. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory’s 2020 “Getting to Neutral” report projects prices for direct air capture (DAC) projects to fall to approximately $200 per ton by 2045, gasification or pyrolysis of biomass to between $30 and $150 per ton, and natural solutions to $10-20 per ton (natural solutions generally do not store carbon as long). Using the $200 per ton projection and CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan scenario of 75 MMT of CDR, $15 billion worth of CDR would be needed a year in California by 2045. For a 7 MMT intermediate goal in 2030 laid out in the Scoping Plan, $1.4 billion will be needed by seven years from now, but this number could feasibly be three times higher or more as prices per ton of carbon are likely to still be high.
- CDR Carrots and Sticks. To get CDR deployed at the scale projected we need, it is important to consider the need for a compliance obligation, such as the one proposed in this bill, alongside other market mechanisms incentivizing CDR: LCFS and federal tax credits. In 2019, certain CCS projects became eligible to generate LCFS credits, including capturing emissions associated with fuel production (examples of CCS, not eligible under this bill) and DAC (a CDR method). LCFS credits were worth on average between $122 and $190 per ton of carbon in 2019 but have recently plummeted to between $60-70. At the federal level, the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) have provisions supporting CDR, including a tax credit of up to $180 per metric ton of carbon removed, commonly referred to as 45Q credits after the section describing them in the U.S. Internal Revenue Code.
Though individual companies’ climate commitments and choices to take advantage of such benefits are helpful, a voluntary market is unlikely to achieve the projected scale of implementation necessary for the state to meet its climate goals. In April 2022, an alliance of prominent Silicon Valley companies, including Google, Meta, Shopify, and Stripe, announced that it is purchasing $925 million in carbon removal over the next eight years. While far larger than any other such commitments to date, that purchase would still buy less over eight years than what just California is projected to need just in the year 2030 (~$1.4 billion, likely higher), with that need per year over ten times higher by 2045 (~$15 billion), even considering the likely reduction in the cost of CDR.
LCFS and 45Q credits are “carrots;” SB 308 would implement a “stick” in that it would require certain GHG emitters to purchase certain volumes of CDR. This bill adopts a “polluter pays” principle. CDR regulations that obligate emitters to purchase negative emissions could stimulate private investment as investors know that there will be growing demand for CDR. As a result, CDR costs should fall as the technology matures.
This bill’s negative emissions purchase obligation is in addition to cap-and-trade but closely related in concept. On February 28, 2023, CARB issued a notice on upcoming topics to inform potential regulatory amendments to the cap-and-trade regulation with workshops to be held this spring and a rulemaking schedule to be put out this summer. This list of topics includes carbon dioxide sequestration and removal projects developed under an SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage (CCRUS) Program. While it is not yet clear what role CDR will play in future cap-and-trade regulations, it is important to note that conversations about this topic are upcoming. Currently, carbon capture, whether through CCS or CDR, does not count towards a covered entity’s cap-and-trade obligation.
- Two-phase credit purchases. This bill allows CARB to develop two-phase negative emission credit rules, in which emitting agencies may purchase temporary carbon sequestration methods with a legally binding commitment to purchase durable carbon sequestration at the end of the guarantee period of the temporary sequestration. This first phase can be a helpful temporary option if durable sequestration methods take time to be scaled up. However, enforcing the second phase purchase could be a challenge. The responsible party to fulfill the purchase of durable sequestration after the temporary sequestration would be a business, and businesses can dissolve, which could leave the second purchase requirement unfulfilled.
- CDR isn’t (yet) happening in California. No large-scale CDR projects yet exist in California. SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) directed CARB to adopt regulations by January 1, 2025, for a unified permit application for carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects to expedite the process. It is worth noting the possibly slow development of CDR in the state in light of this bill’s requirement that at least half of negative emissions credits provide direct climate mitigation benefits to the state, meaning at least half of the CDR must be done in-state or sufficiently close. This bill does, however, include a clause allowing CARB to adjust the 50% requirement if determines it to be infeasible.
- Protecting communities. Emitters purchasing offsets or negative emissions credits to “undo” their emissions may balance out GHG emissions in the big picture but allow pollution to continue in neighboring communities. For this reason, CCS gained significant opposition from environmental justice organizations. While CDR is not linked to point source emissions like CCS and may be less likely to extend the lifetime of an emitting facility, having emitters “undo” their emissions through CDR may not alleviate impacts to communities near the emitters’ operations.
At the very least, ensuring that CDR operations do not further burden neighboring communities is important for an environmentally just implementation. SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) directs CARB, as part of its CCRUS Program, to ensure that all carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects minimize local water or air pollution in adjacent communities as well as monitor criteria pollutants and toxic air contaminants at geological storage sites. SB 308 gives CARB the authority to not certify a CDR process if it determines its benefits do not outweigh the impacts to neighboring communities, considering, among other things, increases in criteria air pollutants. This clause does not have specific thresholds regarding acceptable increases in air pollution and leaves it to CARB to weigh costs and benefits. Moving forward, the author may wish to provide more direction to CARB in the bill if they wish to ensure any specific considerations or protections are included. - Aligning with MRR and cap-and-trade. Author amendments taken in the Senate Appropriations Committee to align with cap-and-trade criteria stated that emitting entities who report 25,000 tons or more of greenhouse gas emissions per year are subject to the requirements in this bill. The threshold for cap-and trade and for CARB’s MRR is 25,000 tons or more of carbon dioxide equivalent. Carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e) is a widely used unit that facilitates comparison between amounts of different GHGs that have different global warming potentials. The author may wish to consider adopting the unit CO2e instead to more closely align with existing regulations.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 905 (Caballero, Chapter 359, Statutes of 2022) directed CARB to establish a CCRUS Program to evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of CDR and CCRUS and facilitate their implementation where appropriate. This bill requires CARB to track the deployment of CCRUS and CDR and adopt regulations for financial responsibility for CO2 capture, removal, or sequestration projects. This bill also directs the California Geological Survey to establish a Geologic Carbon Sequestration Group that identifies injection wells capable of maintaining integrity for at least 1,000 years, identifies appropriate monitoring of injected carbon dioxide and identifies hazards.
SB 1314 (Limón, Chapter 336, Statutes of 2022) prohibited an operator from injecting a concentrated carbon dioxide fluid produced by a carbon dioxide capture project or carbon dioxide capture and sequestration project into a well for the purposes of EOR.
SB 27 (Skinner, Chapter 237, Statues of 2021), among other things, directed CARB to establish carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond as part of its Scoping Plan.
NOTE: See the Senate Environmental Quality Committee analysis for detailed background of this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown ongoing costs, likely in the millions of dollars annually (Cost of Implementation Account [COIA]), for ARB to implement the provisions of this bill.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/18/23)
350 Humboldt
350 Sacramento
Carbon Removal Alliance
Climate Action California
Climeworks
Conservation Strategy Group
Elders Climate Action, NorCal and SoCal Chapters
Environmental Defense Fund
Heirloom Carbon
Indivisible CA Statestrong
Indivisible Yolo
Ocean Iron Fertilization Alliance
Openair Collective
Planetary Technologies
Project 2030
Santa Cruz Climate Action Network
World Resources Institute
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/18/23)
American Forest & Paper Association
Biofuelwatch
California Carbon Solutions Coalition
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
Center for Biological Diversity
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Central California Asthma Collaborative
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Little Manila Rising
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Carbon Removal Alliance, “Just as California has successfully done with other climate solutions, the state will need new policies that help scale carbon removal technologies. This will ensure that our state can take full advantage of the climate and socio-economic benefits of carbon removal technologies. Market creation, in particular, is an important lever to drive capital and resources towards these technologies from the private sector. There are a number of ways to create markets for permanent carbon removal, and SB 308 lays out a clear path for one such mechanism, engaging the private sector to create demand for high quality removals from projects that create local jobs. Importantly, the legislation reflects several core principles that are critical for growing the market for carbon removal at the scale and pace needed to achieve climate goals, including a focus on permanent removals and the need for technology-inclusive solutions.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to a coalition of eight environmental and environmental justice groups, “In addition to our concerns with the efficacy of carbon markets and local externalities from the technologies this bill would advance, we foresee unintended consequences of diminished urgency on proven solutions, a loss of urgency that would prove catastrophic for our communities and our climate. California must focus on direct emissions reductions that decrease both carbon dioxide and co-pollutants that for far too long have been poisoning communities across California, and we cannot allow ourselves to be distracted from this imperative. The state cannot drag its feet on actual climate solutions as it over-relies on the questionable technofix of direct air capture and the blatant climate dead-end of bioenergy with carbon capture and storage.”
Prepared by: Theresa Keates / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
5/23/23 13:07:56
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 308 (Becker) - Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that could be used for negative emissions credits, and to adopt a regulation requiring certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with that percentage increasing over time.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 18, 2023
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown ongoing costs, likely in the millions of dollars annually (Cost of Implementation Account [COIA]), for ARB to implement the provisions of this bill.
Author Amendments:
These amendments would align criteria with existing Cap & Trade market criteria.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 308 (Becker) - Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that could be used for negative emissions credits, and to adopt a regulation requiring certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with that percentage increasing over time.
Fiscal Impact:
- ARB estimates ongoing costs of $6.3 million in FY 2024-25 and $5.8 million annually thereafter (Cost of Implementation Account [COIA]) to implement the provisions of this bill.
Background:
Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) is an umbrella term used to describe a range of strategies used to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, without a relationship to where or when the CO2 was emitted. In contrast to CCS, CDR is a negative emissions strategy when it involves capturing legacy CO2 directly from the atmosphere. To store the CO2 for long periods, it is generally injected underground into geological formations, such as former oil and gas reservoirs, deep saline formations, and coal beds.
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) latest Sixth Assessment, finalized in March 2023, asserts that global emissions will need to be cut by almost half by 2030 if warming is to be limited to 1.5°C, the global target in the Paris Agreement. It acknowledged that CDR will be necessary to meet the 1.5℃ target, especially in hard-to-abate sectors.
California too has acknowledged the need for CDR. California has a statutory goal to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. This leaves 15% of emissions that need to be removed, estimated to be about 65 million metric tons (MMT). To balance out those remaining 15% of emissions, ARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projected that the state will need about 75 MMT of CDR by 2045 (65 MMT to balance out the 15% of remaining emissions in the state inventory plus 10 MMT to balance estimated net emissions from natural and working lands).
Current law requires ARB to establish rules and processes for certifying CDR processes that can be used for negative emissions credits by December 31, 2027. These rules and processes are required to include criteria to ensure CDR processes are real, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional and that sequestration is durable.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require ARB to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that can be used for negative emissions credits, and to adopt a regulation requiring certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their GHG emissions, with that percentage increasing over time. Specifically, this bill would:
- Require ARB to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal (CDR) processes that can be used for negative emissions credits by December 31, 2027. These rules and processes shall include criteria to ensure CDR processes are real, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional and that sequestration is durable.
- Require ARB to adopt a regulation by December 31, 2027, to require certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their GHG emissions beginning in 2028, with those percentages increasing in 5-year intervals to reach 100% in 2045.
- Emitting agencies are those subject to ARB’s Mandatory Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting Regulation (MRR).
- Allow ARB to develop two-phase negative emission credit rules, in which emitting agencies may purchase temporary carbon sequestration methods with a legally binding commitment to purchase durable carbon sequestration at the end of the guarantee period of the temporary negative emissions credits.
- Durable carbon sequestration is defined as a process that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of carbon atoms for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity proves a guarantee of at least 100 years.
- Temporary carbon sequestration is defined as any method that does not meet the criteria for durable carbon sequestration.
- Prohibit certification of CDR processes in which carbon dioxide (CO2) is used for enhanced oil recovery (EOR).
- Provide that at least 50% of negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity in any calendar year shall provide direct climate mitigation benefits to California.
- Allow ARB to not certify CDR processes if the carbon removal benefits do not outweigh the impacts to neighboring communities, on deforestation, or of displacement of agricultural land.
Related Legislation:
SB 905 (Caballero, Chapter 359, Statutes of 2022) directed ARB to establish a CCRUS Program to evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of CDR and CCRUS and facilitate their implementation where appropriate. This bill required ARB to track the deployment of CCRUS and CDR and adopt regulations for financial responsibility for CO2 capture, removal, or sequestration projects. This bill also directed the California Geological Survey to establish a Geologic Carbon Sequestration Group that identifies injection wells capable of maintaining integrity for at least 1,000 years, identifies appropriate monitoring of injected carbon dioxide and identifies hazards.
SB 1314 (Limón, Chapter 336, Statutes of 2022) prohibited an operator from injecting a concentrated carbon dioxide fluid produced by a carbon dioxide capture project or carbon dioxide capture and sequestration project into a well for the purposes of EOR.
SB 27 (Skinner, Chapter 237, Statues of 2021), among other things, directed ARB to establish carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond as part of its Scoping Plan.
Staff Comments:
Possible that ARB costs could be lower. Of the total costs estimated by ARB, about $1.6 million would be for ARB to establish rules and processes for certifying CDR processes and tracking negative emissions credits. Staff note that it is possible some of these costs associated with establishing rules and processes could be incurred as part of any plan for counting CDR toward California’s net zero target. The Scoping Plan calls for 7 MMT of CDR per year by 2030 and 75 MMT by 2045, consistent with the Governor's directive to ARB. This could mean that at least some of these costs might be incurred in order to implement the Scoping Plan and absent this bill.
Current CDR prices. Current CDR prices with durable storage are typically around $200-$700 per ton of carbon, though many available solutions cost upwards of $2,000 per ton. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory’s 2020 “Getting to Neutral” report projects prices for direct air capture (DAC) projects to fall to approximately $200 per ton by 2045, gasification or pyrolysis of biomass to between $30 and $150 per ton, and natural solutions to $10-20 per ton (natural solutions likely do not store carbon as long). Using the $200 per ton projection and ARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan scenario of 75 MMT of CDR, $15 billion worth of CDR would be needed a year in California by 2045. For a 7 MMT intermediate goal in 2030 laid out in the Scoping Plan, $1.4 billion will be needed by seven years from now, but this number could feasibly be three times higher or more as prices per ton of carbon are likely to still be high. CDR will only feasibly be able to help us reach net-zero CO2 emissions when deployed alongside substantial emissions cuts.
CDR in the state budget. Recognizing the need to develop CDR technology, the 2023-2024 state budget allocated $75 million to carbon removal innovation.
State mandate. Because a violation of the requirement to purchase negative emissions credits would be a crime, Legislative Council says that the bill would create a state-mandated local program. The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. This bill states that no reimbursement would be required because the only costs that could be incurred would be because of a crime or infraction, as specified.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 308
Author: | Becker | ||
Version: | 4/10/2023 | Hearing Date: | 4/19/2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Theresa Keates | ||
SUBJECT: Carbon Dioxide Removal Market Development Act
DIGEST: This bill requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal processes that can be used for negative emissions credits. This bill requires CARB to adopt a regulation requiring certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, with that percentage increasing over time.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 and updates thereof (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 38500 et seq.):
- Requires CARB to ensure that statewide GHG emissions are reduced to at least 40% below the 1990 level by 2030 (SB 32, Pavley, 2016).
- Requires CARB to prepare and approve a scoping plan for achieving the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions and to update the scoping plan at least once every 5 years.
- Requires CARB when adopting regulations, to the extent feasible and in furtherance of achieving the statewide GHG emissions goal, to do the following:
- Ensure that activities undertaken to comply with the regulations do not disproportionately impact low-income communities.
- Ensure that activities pursuant to the regulations do not interfere with efforts to achieve and maintain federal and state ambient air quality standards and reduce toxic air contaminant emissions.
- Consider overall societal benefits, including reductions in other air pollutants, diversification of energy sources, and other benefits to the economy, environment, and public health.
- Consider the cost-effectiveness of these regulations.
- Under the California Climate Crisis Act (AB 1279, Muratsuchi, 2022), states that it is the policy of the state to achieve net zero GHG emissions no later than 2045, and to ensure that by 2045 statewide anthropogenic GHG emissions are reduced to at least 85% below the 1990 level.
This bill:
- Requires CARB to establish rules and processes for certifying carbon dioxide removal (CDR) processes that can be used for negative emissions credits by December 31, 2027. These rules and processes shall include criteria to ensure CDR processes are real, quantifiable, verifiable, enforceable, and additional and that sequestration is durable.
- Requires CARB to adopt a regulation by December 31, 2027, to require certain emitting agencies to purchase negative emissions credits equal to a specified percentage of their GHG emissions beginning in 2028, with those percentages increasing in 5-year intervals to reach 100% in 2045.
- Emitting agencies are those subject to CARB’s Mandatory Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reporting Regulation (MRR).
- Allows CARB to develop two-phase negative emission credit rules, in which emitting agencies may purchase temporary carbon sequestration methods with a legally binding commitment to purchase durable carbon sequestration at the end of the guarantee period of the temporary negative emissions credits.
- Durable carbon sequestration is defined as a process that can reasonably be projected to retain a large majority of carbon atoms for 1,000 years and for which the responsible entity proves a guarantee of at least 100 years.
- Temporary carbon sequestration is defined as any method that does not meet the criteria for durable carbon sequestration.
- Prohibits certification of CDR processes in which carbon dioxide (CO2) is used for enhanced oil recovery (EOR).
- Provides that at least 50% of negative emissions credits used by an emitting entity in any calendar year shall provide direct climate mitigation benefits to California.
- Allows CARB to not certify CDR processes if the carbon removal benefits do not outweigh the impacts to neighboring communities, on deforestation, or of displacement of agricultural land.
Background
- Yes, And: The need for CDR. According to United Nations Secretary General António Guterres, what’s needed on climate action is “everything, everywhere, all at once.” Radical cuts in GHG emissions are critical to climate change mitigation, but in parallel with emissions reductions, most experts agree that carbon dioxide removal is necessary to avert further climate disaster. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) latest Sixth Assessment, finalized in March 2023, asserts that global emissions will need to be cut by almost half by 2030 if warming is to be limited to 1.5°C, the global target in the Paris Agreement. It acknowledged that CDR will be necessary to meet the 1.5℃ target, especially in hard-to-abate sectors.
California too has acknowledged the need for CDR. California has a statutory goal to achieve net zero GHG emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. This leaves 15% of emissions that need to be removed, estimated to be about 65 million metric tons (MMT). To balance out those remaining 15% of emissions, CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projected that the state will need about 75 MMT of CDR by 2045 (65 MMT to balance out the 15% of remaining emissions in the state inventory plus 10 MMT to balance estimated net emissions from natural and working lands).
- CDR vs. CCS. Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) is a process that separates CO2 from a point source, such as the flue of a gas-fired power plant or a cement plant. CCS is generally considered by experts to be a CO2 reduction strategy, not a CO2 removal strategy, since it is only reducing CO2 from anthropogenic sources that would have otherwise entered the atmosphere, rather than removing what was already there. CCS remains controversial because of fears it could prolong the life of fossil fuels and delay the transition to more sustainable fuels.
Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) is an umbrella term used to describe a range of strategies used to remove CO2 from the atmosphere, without a relationship to where or when the CO2 was emitted. In contrast to CCS, CDR is a negative emissions strategy when it involves capturing legacy CO2 directly from the atmosphere. To store the CO2 for long periods, it is generally injected underground into geological formations, such as former oil and gas reservoirs, deep saline formations, and coal beds.
- Status of CDR in California, the U.S., and worldwide. An academic study published in 2022 found that 197 MMT of CO2 was removed from the atmosphere and stored underground globally between 1996 and 2020. The Global CCS Institute released a Global Status of CCS Report in 2021. This is a report on CCS, not CDR, so many of the projects included in this report do not meet the criteria for true negative emissions for this bill. However, this report on the current capacity of CCS gives some perspective on how much growth will need to occur in the carbon removal industry. As of the 2021 release of the report, there were 6 commercial-scale CCS projects worldwide that geologically stored a total of 9 MMT of CO2 per year. Twenty other CCS projects were in operation worldwide but used the captured CO2 for EOR, which is a prohibited use for removed CO2 under this bill and previous legislation (SB 1314 and SB 905, both 2022). In the U.S., only one project in Illinois with a capacity of 0.55-1 MMT per year was used for dedicated geological storage as of 2021; 12 other CCS projects operational in the United States were used for EOR. CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan projects a need for 75 MMT of carbon removed and stored annually by 2045 in California alone. As of the 2021 report, 44 CCS projects with the purpose of underground carbon storage (meaning that they may meet the CDR standards outlined in this bill) were in development or construction in the U.S. and expected to come online in the mid-2020s with a capacity of 28.5 – 35.7 MMT per year. While a number of CDR companies are headquartered in California, as of a 2021 report from Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and as of the writing of this analysis, no commercial-scale CDR projects were operational in California.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “In 2022, California passed landmark legislation committing the state to achieve net zero greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2045, with a reduction in emissions of at least 85% from 1990 levels. To achieve the net zero target, the state will need carbon dioxide removal (CDR) to balance the remaining 15% of emissions. Today, the state has no plan for scaling up that CDR capacity to produce the needed “negative emissions,” and there are no rules for what should count as negative emissions or how to keep track of it. There are a wide variety of approaches to CDR being developed, but they are early-stage, low volume, and expensive.
“Since California is going to need large volumes of negative emissions to meet its climate targets, we need a plan for helping those CDR solutions – and the supporting transport and storage infrastructure – mature, scale up, and reduce costs over time. As the Draft 2022 Scoping Plan Update stated, ‘Because CDR is critical for achieving carbon neutrality in all alternatives, it is important to begin investment soon to allow demonstration, deployment, and experience to reduce its cost as dependence on it grows toward 2045.’
“SB 308 creates the plan we need by addressing 4 crucial issues:
- It requires CARB to establish rules for what can be counted as valid negative emissions, with safeguards to make sure that only high-quality, scientifically valid processes are counted.
- It requires CARB to consider the non-climate costs and benefits of CDR processes to avoid certifying approaches that would have harmful side effects.
- It creates a framework in which ‘polluters pay’ for the cost of CDR to clean up at least a portion of their annual emissions.
- It increases the amount of CDR each emitter will need to purchase over time (as a percentage of their emissions), similar to the approach taken for the Renewables Portfolio Standard, to scale up CDR capacity toward the 2045 goal.”
- How much do we need? First, it is critical to underscore that CDR is no replacement for dramatic emissions reductions. CDR will only feasibly be able to help us reach net-zero CO2 emissions when deployed alongside substantial emissions cuts.
Increasing CDR capacity to the scale projected to meet climate goals will take a massive amount of money. Current CDR prices with durable storage are typically around $200-$700 per ton of carbon, though many available solutions cost upwards of $2,000 per ton. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory’s 2020 “Getting to Neutral” report projects prices for direct air capture (DAC) projects to fall to approximately $200 per ton by 2045, gasification or pyrolysis of biomass to between $30 and $150 per ton, and natural solutions to $10-20 per ton (natural solutions likely do not store carbon as long). Using the $200 per ton projection and CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan scenario of 75 MMT of CDR, $15 billion worth of CDR would be needed a year in California by 2045. For a 7 MMT intermediate goal in 2030 laid out in the Scoping Plan, $1.4 billion will be needed by seven years from now, but this number could feasibly be three times higher or more as prices per ton of carbon are likely to still be high.
- CDR Carrots and Sticks. To get CDR deployed at the scale projected we need, it is important to consider the need for a compliance obligation, as proposed in this bill, alongside other market mechanisms incentivizing CDR: LCFS and federal tax credits. California’s LCFS sets transportation fuel carbon intensity targets with the goal of reducing GHG emissions. In 2019, certain CCS projects became eligible to generate LCFS credits, including capturing emissions associated with fuel production (examples of CCS, not eligible under this bill) and DAC (a CDR method). Projects do not have to be located within California to earn LCFS credits and can be used for EOR. LCFS credits were worth on average between $122 and $190 per ton of carbon in 2019 but have recently plummeted to between $60-70.
At the federal level, both the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) have provisions supporting CDR. Under the IRA, DAC projects can earn a tax credit of up to $180 per metric ton of carbon removed, commonly referred to as 45Q credits after the section describing them in the U.S. Internal Revenue Code. The IRA also includes an additional $2 billion for natural CDR alongside tax credits supporting carbon removal technologies expected to be worth several billion more. The IIJA directly funds DAC through grants for certain carbon capture programs and by supporting the creation of four regional DAC hubs, which co-locate DAC technologies with existing or planned infrastructure for transporting and storing the CO2 that has been captured. The IIJA also includes a provision that expands the eligibility of DAC projects to receive private activity bonds with favorable pay-back periods.
Though individual companies’ climate commitments and choices to take advantage of such benefits are helpful, a voluntary market is unlikely to achieve the projected scale of implementation necessary for the state to meet its climate goals. In April 2022, an alliance of prominent Silicon Valley companies, including Google, Meta, Shopify, and Stripe, announced that it is purchasing $925 million in carbon removal over the next eight years. While far larger than any other such commitments to date, that purchase still buys less over eight years than what just California will need just in the year 2030 (~$1.4 billion, likely higher), with that need per year over ten times higher by 2045 (~$15 billion), even considering the likely reduction in the cost of CDR.
LCFS and 45Q credits are “carrots;” SB 308 would implement a “stick” in that it would require certain GHG emitters to purchase certain volumes of CDR. This bill adopts a “polluter pays” principle. Rather than the state funding incentives, it can be more financially effective to establish CDR regulations that obligate emitters to purchase negative emissions, which then stimulates billions of dollars of private investment as investors know that there will be growing demand for CDR. As a result, CDR costs should fall as the technology matures.
This bill’s negative emissions purchase obligation is in addition to cap-and-trade but closely related in concept. On February 28, 2023, CARB issued a notice on upcoming topics to inform potential regulatory amendments to the cap-and-trade regulation with workshops to be held this spring and a rulemaking schedule to be put out this summer. This list of topics includes carbon dioxide sequestration and removal projects developed under an SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) Carbon Capture, Removal, Utilization, and Storage (CCRUS) Program. While it is not yet clear what role CDR will play in future cap-and-trade regulations, it is important to note that conversations about this topic are upcoming. Currently, carbon capture, whether through CCS or CDR, does not count towards a covered entity’s cap-and-trade obligation.
- Stimulating a market. Recognizing the need to develop CDR technology, the 2023-2024 state budget allocates $75 million to carbon removal innovation, but ensuring a future market has the potential to attract significant additional private investment for research and development. Unlike developing a good for sale, bringing CDR technology to market does not create a product with an inherent value. It falls upon governments to create a mechanism by which this service has value and must be utilized.
The mechanism proposed in this bill is similar to other strategies employed in the past to scale up a nascent market. The state’s renewables portfolio standard (RPS) has required utilities to buy renewable energy equal to a percentage of their retail sales of electricity, with those percentages increasing over time as renewable energy technology matures and prices fall. The RPS framework prompted large amounts of private investment capital to build wind and solar, leading to major cost declines as the technology matured. Another market-stimulating strategy is Advance Market Commitments (AMC). An AMC is a binding contract used to guarantee a viable market for a product once it is successfully developed. Generally, AMCs are used in circumstances where the cost of developing a new product is too high to be worthwhile for the private sector without a guarantee of a certain quantity of purchases in advance. The Silicon Valley companies, including Google, Meta, Shopify, and Stripe, announcing a purchase of $925 million in carbon removal, at no specified price per ton, over the next eight years (mentioned in the “CDR Carrots and Sticks” comment) is an example of an AMC.
This bill requires emitting entities to purchase a certain number of negative carbon credits regardless of their price. While this is not completely analogous to an AMC because a CDR company would not have a certain amount of money it has been promised if it delivers its product, this compliance obligation approach could guarantee there will be future purchasers for CDR, encouraging investments and allowing CDR companies to develop diverse carbon dioxide removal and storage methods whose prices should fall with time.
- Interaction with SB 905 (Caballero, 2022). SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) provides a useful framework for CDR development and monitoring that will apply to some in-state CDR projects used to generate negative emissions credits under SB 308. SB 905 directs CARB to establish a CCRUS Program that will, among other things, evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of CDR technologies and develop monitoring and reporting schedules to state regulatory agencies for CDR projects. The only sequestration projects that SB 905 covers are those that store atmospheric carbon dioxide in a geologic formation, while SB 308 takes a more broad definition that includes nature-based solutions, so there is potential for some CDR projects under SB 308 to not be subject to regulation under SB 905.
- Two-phase credit purchases. This bill allows CARB to develop two-phase negative emission credit rules, in which emitting agencies may purchase temporary carbon sequestration methods with a legally binding commitment to purchase durable carbon sequestration at the end of the guarantee period of the temporary sequestration. This first phase can be a helpful temporary option if durable sequestration methods take time to be scaled up. However, enforcing the second phase purchase could be a challenge. The responsible party to fulfill the purchase of durable sequestration after the temporary sequestration would be a business, and businesses can dissolve, which could leave the second purchase requirement unfulfilled. Both SB 905 and SB 308 have requirements for longer-term financial responsibility of at least 100 years, but they are placed on the operators of CDR projects, not the purchasers of CDR. Moving forward, the author may wish to consider a safety mechanism to ensure the purchase of durable storage follows temporary storage in a two-phase option.
- CDR isn’t (yet) happening in California. As stated in the Background section, no commercial-scale CDR projects yet exist in California. One possible slowdown to scaling up CDR in California is permitting, which happens both at the state and federal levels. Permitting and regulations are important to minimize risks to public health, safety, and the environment but can make it hard to predict the timeline of CDR adoption within the state. SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) directed CARB to adopt regulations by January 1, 2025, for a unified permit application for carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects to expedite the process. This bill does not further tackle the regulatory environment in California as it relates to CDR, but it is worth noting the likely slow proliferation of CDR in the state in light of this bill’s requirement that at least half of negative emissions credits provide direct climate mitigation benefits to the state, meaning at least half of the CDR must be done in-state or sufficiently close. This bill does, however, include a clause allowing CARB to adjust the 50% requirement if determines it to be infeasible.
- Protecting communities. Emitters purchasing offsets or negative emissions credits to “undo” their emissions may balance out GHG emissions in the big picture but allow pollution to continue in neighboring communities. For this reason, CCS gained significant opposition from environmental justice organizations. While CDR is not linked to point source emissions like CCS and may be less likely to extend the lifetime of an emitting facility, having emitters “undo” their emissions through CDR may not alleviate impacts to communities near the emitters’ operations.
At the very least, ensuring that CDR operations do not further burden neighboring communities is important for an environmentally just implementation. SB 905 (Caballero, 2022) directs CARB, as part of its CCRUS Program, to ensure that all carbon dioxide capture, removal, or sequestration projects minimize local water or air pollution in adjacent communities as well as monitor criteria pollutants and toxic air contaminants at geological storage sites. SB 308 gives CARB the authority to not certify a CDR process if it determines its benefits do not outweigh the impacts to neighboring communities, considering, among other things, increases in criteria air pollutants. This clause does not have specific thresholds regarding acceptable increases in air pollution and leaves it to CARB to weigh costs and benefits. Moving forward, the author may wish to provide more direction to CARB in the bill if they wish to ensure any specific considerations or protections are included.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 905 (Caballero, Chapter 359, Statutes of 2022) directs CARB to establish a CCRUS Program to evaluate the efficacy, safety, and viability of CDR and CCRUS and facilitate their implementation where appropriate. This bill requires CARB to track the deployment of CCRUS and CDR and adopt regulations for financial responsibility for CO2 capture, removal, or sequestration projects. This bill also directs the California Geological Survey to establish a Geologic Carbon Sequestration Group that identifies injection wells capable of maintaining integrity for at least 1,000 years, identifies appropriate monitoring of injected carbon dioxide and identifies hazards.
SB 1314 (Limón, Chapter 336, Statutes of 2022) prohibits an operator from injecting a concentrated carbon dioxide fluid produced by a carbon dioxide capture project or carbon dioxide capture and sequestration project into a well for the purposes of EOR.
SB 27 (Skinner, Chapter 237, Statues of 2021), among other things, directs CARB to establish carbon dioxide removal targets for 2030 and beyond as part of its Scoping Plan.
SOURCE:
Author.
SUPPORT:
350 Humboldt
350 Sacramento
Carbon Removal Alliance
Climate Action California
Climeworks
Elders Climate Action, Norcal and Socal Chapters
Environmental Defense Fund
Heirloom Carbon
Indivisible CA Statestrong
Indivisible Yolo
Ocean Iron Fertilization Alliance
Santa Cruz Climate Action Network
World Resources Institute
OPPOSITION:
American Forest & Paper Association
Biofuelwatch
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
Center for Biological Diversity
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Central California Asthma Collaborative
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition (CVAQ)
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Little Manila Rising
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the Carbon Removal Alliance, “Just as California has successfully done with other climate solutions, the state will need new policies that help scale carbon removal technologies. This will ensure that our state can take full advantage of the climate and socio-economic benefits of carbon removal technologies. Market creation, in particular, is an important lever to drive capital and resources towards these technologies from the private sector. There are a number of ways to create markets for permanent carbon removal, and SB 308 lays out a clear path for one such mechanism, engaging the private sector to create demand for high quality removals from projects that create local jobs. Importantly, the legislation reflects several core principles that are critical for growing the market for carbon removal at the scale and pace needed to achieve climate goals, including a focus on permanent removals and the need for technology-inclusive solutions.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability, “In addition to our concerns with the efficacy of carbon markets and local externalities from the technologies this bill would advance, we foresee unintended consequences of diminished urgency on proven solutions, a loss of urgency that would prove catastrophic for our communities and our climate. California must focus on direct emissions reductions that decrease both carbon dioxide and co-pollutants that for far too long have been poisoning communities across California, and we cannot allow ourselves to be distracted from this imperative. The state cannot drag its feet on actual climate solutions as it over-relies on the questionable technofix of direct air capture and the blatant climate dead-end of bioenergy with carbon capture and storage.”
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):