AB 818: Criminal procedure: evidence.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-16
Existing law allows an incarcerated person who has been convicted of a felony to make a written motion for the performance of forensic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing according to a specified procedure. Existing law allows the court to order a hearing on the motion if the court determines the convicted person has met specified requirements and that the hearing is necessary. Existing law requires the motion to be granted if certain facts have been established, including, among others, that the identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
This bill would authorize a party in a criminal action to make a written motion for the comparison of DNA evidence, evidence or latent fingerprint evidence, or firearms-related evidence with information contained in relevant databases. The bill would require the party seeking the comparison to provide written notice, as specified, 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion. The bill would require authorize the court to grant the motion if, in the case of a DNA comparison, if the source of the DNA profile or the latent fingerprint comparison is material to guilt or innocence, in the case of latent print comparison, the comparison may identify the putative perpetrator of the crime, or, in the case of firearms-related evidence comparison, the comparison may provide evidence that is material to guilt or innocence. innocence. The bill would require that the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and provide the results of any comparison to the court. The bill would require the court, if the results are material, to disclose the results to the parties. court for distribution to the parties. By imposing additional duties on local law enforcement agencies with regard to evidence comparison, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law allows an incarcerated person who has been convicted of a felony to make a written motion for the performance of forensic deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing according to a specified procedure. Existing law allows the court to order a hearing on the motion if the court determines the convicted person has met specified requirements and that the hearing is necessary. Existing law requires the motion to be granted if certain facts have been established, including, among others, that the identity of the perpetrator of the crime was, or should have been, a significant issue in the case.
This bill would authorize a party in a criminal action to make a written motion for the comparison of DNA evidence, latent fingerprint evidence, or firearms-related evidence with information contained in relevant databases. The bill would require the party seeking the comparison to provide written notice, as specified, 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion. The bill would require the court to grant the motion if, in the case of a DNA comparison, the source of the DNA profile is material to guilt or innocence, in the case of latent print comparison, the comparison may identify the putative perpetrator of the crime, or, in the case of firearms-related evidence comparison, the comparison may provide evidence that is material to guilt or innocence. The bill would require that the local law enforcement agency conduct the comparison and provide the results of any comparison to the court. The bill would require the court, if the results are material, to disclose the results to the parties. By imposing additional duties on local law enforcement agencies with regard to evidence comparison, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares both of the following:
(1)One of the purposes of a criminal trial is the ascertainment of the truth of the charges against the accused person. Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) profile comparisons, latent fingerprint comparison, and firearms comparison evidence are commonly used in criminal proceedings to help identify the perpetrator of the crime. With these techniques, the evidence from a crime scene is compared with information stored in a database to determine whether the DNA profile or fingerprint matches a previously convicted person, who may then be identified as a suspect, or whether firearms-related evidence appears to match firearms-related evidence used in another crime, thereby potentially identifying a suspect. suspect. The systems commonly used are known as the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), (CODIS) and the Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS), and the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network (NIBIN). (IAFIS). There are also local databases, including the Los Angeles Automated Fingerprint Identification System (LAFIS) and other databases that utilize an Integrated Ballistics Identification System (IBIS). (LAFIS).
(2)Currently, a law enforcement agency on its own or at the request of the prosecuting attorney has the sole discretion to determine if evidence recovered from a crime scene is searched against any of these databases. A court does not have the power on its own to order a search of these databases even if a search will lead to relevant exculpatory evidence, helping prove that the person accused of a crime is being wrongfully prosecuted, or helping identify the actual perpetrator of the crime.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that the act that added this section grant a court the authority to make a pretrial order to compare relevant evidence with information contained in these databases. It is further the intent of the Legislature that the act that added this section will promote fairness and justice, will prevent wrongful convictions, and will ensure that the guilty are prosecuted and the innocent exonerated.
SEC. 2.Section 1405.2 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1405.2.(a)(1)A party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) obtained from biological evidence in the case with DNA profiles contained in the State DNA Index System (SDIS) and, if appropriate, the National DNA Index System (NDIS).
(2)This subdivision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion described in paragraph (1) prior to comparing DNA obtained from biological evidence in a case with DNA profiles contained in SDIS or NDIS.
(b)The party seeking the comparison shall provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion.
(c)The court shall may grant the motion for DNA comparison if it determines that the source of the DNA profile is material to guilt or innocence.
(d)(1)If the court grants the motion for DNA comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individuals whose DNA profile matched the DNA submitted for comparison, if available, and a description of DNA profiles that matched the DNA submitted for comparison, if no identity is associated with the matching DNA profile, be provided to the court. court for distribution to the parties.
(2)The court shall review any results submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) and determine if the results are material. Upon a finding of materiality, the court shall disclose the results to the parties.
SEC. 3.Section 1405.3 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1405.3.(a)(1)A party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of latent print evidence in the case with fingerprints contained in the Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS) and in local fingerprint databases, including, but not limited to, the Los Angeles Automated Fingerprint Identification Systems (LAFIS).
(2)This subdivision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion described in paragraph (1) prior to comparing latent print evidence in a case with fingerprints contained in IAFIS or local fingerprint databases.
(b)The party seeking the comparison shall provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion.
(c)The court shall grant the motion for latent print comparison if it determines that the comparison may identify the putative perpetrator of the crime.
(c)The court may grant the motion for latent print comparison if it determines that the comparison is material to guilt or innocence.
(d)(1)If the court grants the motion for latent print comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individuals whose fingerprints match the latent prints submitted for comparison be provided to the court. court for distribution to the parties.
(2)The court shall review any results submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) and determine if the results are material. Upon a finding of materiality, the court shall disclose the results to the parties.
SEC. 4.Section 1405.4 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1405.4.(a)(1)A party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of firearms-related evidence, including, but not limited to, cartridge casings, bullets, or firearms, in the case with firearms-related data contained in an Integrated Ballistics Identification System (IBIS), the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network (NIBIN), or both.
(2)This subdivision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion described in paragraph (1) prior to comparing firearms-related evidence in a case with firearms-related data contained in an IBIS or the NIBIN.
(b)The party seeking the comparison shall provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion.
(c)The court shall grant the motion for firearms-related evidence comparison if it determines that the comparison may provide evidence that is material to guilt or innocence.
(d)(1)If the court grants the motion for firearms-related evidence comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individual associated with firearms-related data that matched the firearms-related evidence submitted for comparison be provided to the court.
(2)The court shall review any results submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) and determine if the results are material. Upon a finding of materiality, the court shall disclose the results to the parties.
SEC. 5.SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares both of the following:
(1)One of the purposes of a criminal trial is the ascertainment of the truth of the charges against the accused person. Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) profile comparisons, latent fingerprint comparison, and firearms comparison evidence are commonly used in criminal proceedings to help identify the perpetrator of the crime. With these techniques, the evidence from a crime scene is compared with information stored in a database to determine whether the DNA profile or fingerprint matches a previously convicted person, who may then be identified as a suspect, or whether firearms-related evidence appears to match firearms-related evidence used in another crime, thereby potentially identifying a suspect. The systems commonly used are known as the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS), the Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS), and the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network (NIBIN). There are also local databases, including the Los Angeles Automated Fingerprint Identification System (LAFIS) and other databases that utilize an Integrated Ballistics Identification System (IBIS).
(2)Currently, a law enforcement agency on its own or at the request of the prosecuting attorney has the sole discretion to determine if evidence recovered from a crime scene is searched against any of these databases. A court does not have the power on its own to order a search of these databases even if a search will lead to relevant exculpatory evidence, helping prove that the person accused of a crime is being wrongfully prosecuted, or helping identify the actual perpetrator of the crime.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that the act that added this section grant a court the authority to make a pretrial order to compare relevant evidence with information contained in these databases. It is further the intent of the Legislature that the act that added this section will promote fairness and justice, will prevent wrongful convictions, and will ensure that the guilty are prosecuted and the innocent exonerated.
SEC. 2.Section 1405.2 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1405.2.(a)(1)A party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) obtained from biological evidence in the case with DNA profiles contained in the State DNA Index System (SDIS) and, if appropriate, the National DNA Index System (NDIS).
(2)This subdivision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion described in paragraph (1) prior to comparing DNA obtained from biological evidence in a case with DNA profiles contained in SDIS or NDIS.
(b)The party seeking the comparison shall provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion.
(c)The court shall grant the motion for DNA comparison if it determines that the source of the DNA profile is material to guilt or innocence.
(d)(1)If the court grants the motion for DNA comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individuals whose DNA profile matched the DNA submitted for comparison, if available, and a description of DNA profiles that matched the DNA submitted for comparison, if no identity is associated with the matching DNA profile, be provided to the court.
(2)The court shall review any results submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) and determine if the results are material. Upon a finding of materiality, the court shall disclose the results to the parties.
SEC. 3.Section 1405.3 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1405.3.(a)(1)A party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of latent print evidence in the case with fingerprints contained in the Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS) and in local fingerprint databases, including, but not limited to, the Los Angeles Automated Fingerprint Identification Systems (LAFIS).
(2)This subdivision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion described in paragraph (1) prior to comparing latent print evidence in a case with fingerprints contained in IAFIS or local fingerprint databases.
(b)The party seeking the comparison shall provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion.
(c)The court shall grant the motion for latent print comparison if it determines that the comparison may identify the putative perpetrator of the crime.
(d)(1)If the court grants the motion for latent print comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individuals whose fingerprints match the latent prints submitted for comparison be provided to the court.
(2)The court shall review any results submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) and determine if the results are material. Upon a finding of materiality, the court shall disclose the results to the parties.
SEC. 4.Section 1405.4 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1405.4.(a)(1)A party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of firearms-related evidence, including, but not limited to, cartridge casings, bullets, or firearms, in the case with firearms-related data contained in an Integrated Ballistics Identification System (IBIS), the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network (NIBIN), or both.
(2)This subdivision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion described in paragraph (1) prior to comparing firearms-related evidence in a case with firearms-related data contained in an IBIS or the NIBIN.
(b)The party seeking the comparison shall provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 court days prior to a hearing on the motion.
(c)The court shall grant the motion for firearms-related evidence comparison if it determines that the comparison may provide evidence that is material to guilt or innocence.
(d)(1)If the court grants the motion for firearms-related evidence comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individual associated with firearms-related data that matched the firearms-related evidence submitted for comparison be provided to the court.
(2)The court shall review any results submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) and determine if the results are material. Upon a finding of materiality, the court shall disclose the results to the parties.
SEC. 5.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2016 | Died pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 28, 2015 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Apr 29, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 20, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 16, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 15, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 14). |
| Apr 7, 2015 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 12, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 29. |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 14, 2015 | Do pass as amended, and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 818
Page 2
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 818
(Quirk) – As Amended April 16, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Public Safety |
Vote: |
7 - 0 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill authorizes a party in a criminal action to make a written motion for the comparison of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) evidence or latent fingerprint evidence. Specifically, this bill:
States that a party in a criminal action may make a motion for the comparison of DNA obtained from biological evidence in the case with DNA profiles contained in the State DNA Index System (SDIS) and, if appropriate the National DNA Index System (NDIS).
Provides that a party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of latent fingerprint evidence in the case with fingerprints contained in the Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS) and in local fingerprint databases, including, but not limited to, the Los Angeles Automated Fingerprint Identification Systems (LAFIS).
Provides, if the court grants the motion for the comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison, and shall order that the identity of any individuals who are a match to be submitted for comparison, if available.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Significant cost to the Department of Justice (DOJ) in the $10 million range, $5 million for the DNA comparisons and $5 million for the latent fingerprint comparison. Both cases assume the existing workload would triple.
Potential significant reimbursable state mandated cost (GF) to local law enforcement agencies for the additional comparisons the court may order in the event of DNA or finger- print matches with other parties, other than the accused. Some of these costs would be offset by avoiding post-conviction requests for the same tests, and by avoiding the prosecution and/or incarceration of innocent persons.
Unknown fiscal impact (GF) to the courts for additional hearings to process the motions and potentially prolonged criminal trials.
Unknown GF savings to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) by avoiding the incarceration of innocent persons.
Unknown GF savings to the California Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board by avoiding paying an individual $100 per day of incarceration, served in a state prison, as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment, if a claim were made.
COMMENTS:
Purpose/Background. According to the author, "Currently, prosecutors alone decide (1) whether or not an item of physical evidence should be examined and/or tested, and (2) decide whether or not the results of that examination or analysis should be searched against existing law enforcement controlled databases such as CODIS [Combined DNA Index System], IAFIS and IBIS.
"DNA databases such as CODIS, NDIS, and SDIS contain DNA
profiles uploaded by law enforcement agencies from biological
materials collected from crimes scenes, and from arrestees and
convicted offenders. IAFIS and local fingerprint identification
systems are databases that contain biometric information and criminal
histories of offenders. A search of these databases allow criminal
justice agencies to compare DNA or fingerprints in a case that is
being investigated with data in these systems to find a match or
connect the suspect with other criminal cases.
"These databases are powerful crime fighting tools but are presently only available to law enforcement and prosecution. They alone decide what evidence to collect and test. The ends of justice are not met when law enforcement has exclusive control over the decision of whether or not to test and upload evidence that may prove the accused is actually innocent of the crime charged and may provide evidence that someone else is actually guilty. [Current law] allows defense counsel to make a motion to have additional evidence tested, there is no explicit authority to compel the prosecution to test the evidence or have it searched against one of the databases when directed by a judge. "
Argument in Support. According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of California, a co-sponsor of this bill, "ACLU has long advocated reforms to prevent wrongful convictions. When the innocent go to prison, the guilty go free. Wrongful convictions continue to occur and typically take many years, even decades, to rectify. An innocent person who has been wrongfully convicted may one day regain his or her freedom, but that person's life will never be restored. Meanwhile, the true perpetrator remains free to commit additional crimes.
Prior Legislation:
SB 980 (Lieu), Chapter 554, Statutes of 2014, revised the process for obtaining a court order authorizing post-conviction forensic DNA testing.
SB 83 (Burton), Chapter 943, Statutes of 2001, established a procedure for the court to appoint counsel for an indigent person in order to investigate and file a motion for post-conviction DNA testing.
SB 1342 (Burton), Chapter 821, Statutes of 2000, established the procedure for the post-conviction testing of DNA evidence.
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro R. Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 818
Page 7
Date of Hearing: April 14, 2015
Counsel: Stella Choe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Bill Quirk, Chair
AB 818
(Quirk) – As Introduced February 26, 2015
As Proposed to be Amended in Committee
SUMMARY:
Authorizes a party in a criminal action to make a written motion for the comparison of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) evidence or latent fingerprint evidence. Specifically, this bill:
States that a party in a criminal action may make a motion for the comparison of DNA obtained from biological evidence in the case with DNA profiles contained in the State DNA Index System (SDIS) and, if appropriate the National DNA Index System (NDIS).
Specifies that this provision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion prior to comparing DNA obtained from biological evidence in a case with DNA profiles contained in SDIS or NDIS.
Requires the party seeking the comparison to provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 days prior to a hearing on the motion.
States that the court may grant the motion for DNA comparison if it determines that the course of the DNA profile is material to guilt or innocence.
Provides if the court grants the motion for DNA comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individuals whose DNA profile matched the DNA submitted for comparison, if available, and a description of DNA profiles that matched the DNA submitted for comparison, if no identity is associated with the matching DNA profile, be provided to the court for distribution to the parties.
Provides that a party in a criminal action may make a written motion for the comparison of latent fingerprint evidence in the case with fingerprints contained in the Integrated Automated Fingerprint Identification System (IAFIS) and in local fingerprint databases, including, but not limited to, the Los Angeles Automated Fingerprint Identification Systems (LAFIS).
Specifies that this provision does not require a prosecuting attorney to file the motion prior to comparing latent print evidence in a case with fingerprints contained in IAFIS or local fingerprint databases.
Requires the party seeking the comparison to provide written notice to the local law enforcement agency and opposing counsel 30 days prior to a hearing on the motion.
Provides that the court may grant the motion for latent print comparison if it determines that the comparison is material to guilt or innocence.
States if the court grants the motion for latent print comparison, the court shall order the local law enforcement agency to conduct the comparison and order that the identity of any individuals whose fingerprints match the latent prints submitted for comparison be provided to the court for distribution to the parties.
EXISTING LAW:
Allows a person who was convicted of a felony and is currently serving a term of imprisonment to make a written motion before the trial court that entered the judgment of conviction in his or her case, for performance of forensic DNA testing. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (a).)
Allows a person to request appointment of counsel by sending a written request to the court stating that he or she was not the perpetrator of the crime and explaining how the DNA testing is relevant to his or her assertion of innocence. Allows the court, if it finds the person indigent, to appoint counsel to investigate and, if appropriate, file a motion for DNA testing, and to represent the person solely for the purpose of obtaining DNA testing. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (b).)
Authorizes the court, upon request of the convicted person or convicted person's counsel, to order the prosecutor to make all reasonable efforts to obtain, and police agencies and law enforcement laboratories to make all reasonable efforts to provide, the following documents that are in their possession or control, if the documents exist:
Copies of DNA lab reports, with underlying notes, prepared in connection with the laboratory testing of biological evidence from the case, as specified.
Copies of evidence logs, chain of custody logs and reports, including but not limited to, documentation of current location of biological evidence, and evidence destruction logs and reports.
If evidence has been lost or destroyed, a custodian of records shall submit a report to the prosecutor and the convicted person or convicted person's counsel that sets forth the efforts that were made in an attempt to locate the evidence, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (c).)
Requires a motion for DNA testing to be verified by the convicted person under penalty of perjury stating that he or she is innocent and not the perpetrator of the crime and make every reasonable attempt to identify both the evidence that should be tested and the specific type of DNA testing sought. Among other things, the motion shall explain in light of all evidence how DNA testing would raise a reasonable probability that the convicted person’s verdict or sentence would be more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction. (Pen. Code § 1405, subd. (d).)
Requires the court to grant the motion for DNA testing if it determines all of the following have been established:
The evidence to be tested is available and in a condition that would permit DNA testing requested in the motion;
The evidence to be tested has been subject to a chain of custody sufficient to establish it has not be substituted, tampered with, replaced, or altered in any material aspect;
The identity of the perpetrator of the crime was or should have been, a significant issue in the case;
The convicted person has made a prima facie showing that the evidence sought to be tested is material to the issue of the convicted person’s identity as the perpetrator of, or accomplice to, the crime, special circumstance, or enhancement allegation that resulted in the conviction or sentence. The convicted person is only required to demonstrate that the DNA testing he or she seeks would be relevant to, rather than dispositive of, the issue of identity. The convicted person is not required to show a favorable result would conclusively establish his or her innocence;
The requested DNA testing results would raise a reasonable probability that, in light of all the evidence, the convicted person’s verdict or sentence would have been more favorable if the results of DNA testing had been available at the time of conviction. The court in its discretion may consider any evidence whether or not it was introduced at trial. In determining whether the convicted person is entitled to develop potentially exculpatory evidence, the court shall not decide whether, assuming a DNA test result favorable to the convicted person, he or she is entitled to some form of relief;
The evidence to be tested was not tested previously or the evidence was tested previously, but the requested DNA test would provide results that are reasonably more discriminating and probative of the identity of the perpetrator or accomplice or have a reasonable probability of contradicting prior test results;
The testing requested employs a method generally accepted within the relevant scientific community; and
The motion is not made solely for the purpose of delay. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (g).)
Requires the court order to identify the specific evidence to be tested and the DNA technology to be used if it grants the motion for DNA testing. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (h)(1).)
Allows the laboratory to communicate with either party, upon request and in accordance with the court's order, during the testing process. The result of any DNA testing ordered, as applicable here, shall be fully disclosed to the person filing the motion, the district attorney, and the Attorney General. Requires the court to order production of the underlying laboratory data and notes if requested by any party. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (i).)
Provides that the cost of DNA testing is to be borne by the state or the applicant, as the court may order in the interests of justice, if it is shown that the applicant is not indigent and possesses the ability to pay, except that the cost of any additional testing to be conducted by the district attorney or Attorney General shall not be borne by the convicted person. (Pen. Code, § 1405, subd. (i)(1).)
Requires the appropriate governmental entity to retain all biological material that is secured in connection with a criminal case for the period of time that any person is incarcerated. Allows the destruction of the biological evidence if notice is sent to the person and the notifying entity does not receive within 180 days of the notice any of the following:
A motion filed under Penal Code section 1405;
A request under penalty of perjury that the evidence not be destroyed because the person is going to file a motion under Penal Code section 1405 within one year; or,
A declaration of innocence under penalty of perjury that has been filed within one year of the judgment of conviction. (Pen. Code, § 1417.9.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
Author's Statement: According to the author, "Over the last few years, California has taken great steps to prevent the wrongful conviction and imprisonment of innocent people. Most recently, SB 980 (Lieu, 2014) updated the process by which convicted individuals could request post-conviction DNA testing to prove their innocence. However, California has not done enough to prevent wrongful convictions from occurring in the first place.
"Currently, prosecutors alone decide (1) whether or not an item of physical evidence should be examined and/or tested and (2) decide whether or not the results of that examination or analysis should be searched against existing law enforcement controlled databases such as CODIS, IAFIS and IBIS.
"While Penal Code §1054 allows defense counsel to make a motion to have additional evidence tested, there is no explicit authority to compel the prosecution to test the evidence or have it searched against one of the databases when directed by a judge.
"These databases are powerful crime fighting tools but are presently only available to law enforcement and prosecution. They alone decide what evidence to collect and test. The ends of justice are not met when law enforcement has exclusive control over the decision of whether or not to test and upload evidence that may prove the accused is actually innocent of the crime charged and may provide evidence that someone else is actually guilty. Furthermore, the previous president of the National District Attorneys Association has publicly stated that defense attorneys should have access to these databases.
"AB 818 will promote fairness and justice in the criminal
justice system."
The Need for this Bill: DNA databases such as CODIS, NDIS, and SDIS contain DNA profiles uploaded by law enforcement agencies from biological materials collected from crimes scenes, and from arrestees and convicted offenders. IAFIS and local fingerprint identification systems are databases that contain biometric information and criminal histories of offenders. A search of these databases allow criminal justice agencies to compare DNA or fingerprints in a case that is being investigated with data in these systems to find a match or connect the suspect with other criminal cases.
Criminal justice agencies, such as prosecutors and law enforcement, and qualified laboratories, are the only ones allowed access to these databases to upload data and search for matches. Several states also allow defense attorneys to have access to these databases, including Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, Maryland, Mississippi, New York, North Carolina, Ohio and Texas. (Bronner, Lawyers, Saying DNA Cleared Inmate, Pursue Access to Data, The New York Times (Jan. 3, 2013) <http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/04/us/lawyers-saying-dna-cleared-inmate-pursue-access-to-data.html?_r=0> [as of Apr. 8, 2015].) In California, defense attorneys do not have access to these databases, nor is there a statutory mechanism in place to request a comparison of DNA or fingerprint evidence.
While prosecutors have the duty to disclose all exculpatory evidence to the defense, they may not know that DNA or fingerprints were found and not tested, or that testing of the samples were not done correctly.
A recent news article provides examples of why defendants should be able to request comparison of DNA. The first incident involved a case in December where a police officer assigned to the San Francisco Police Department crime lab, confronted with low-quality, incomplete DNA from the assailant, allegedly made assumptions about missing data and, with her supervisor's agreement, submitted two apparently complete genetic profiles to be compared with those of known offenders listed in a state database. The defense attorney learned late in trial that one of the profiles did not match the defendant. The defendant was convicted however, based on his confession to the crime.
Another incident illustrated in the article involved another police officer assigned to the same crime lab. The officer is alleged to have done an incomplete DNA analysis in the 2007 killing of a reputed gang leader by two men on bicycles. Two suspects had been arrested in the case, but a third person's DNA was found on one of the bicycles, which the officer did not enter into the state and federal database. When asked about the third DNA profile by defendants' attorneys, the officer stated she did not enter the third DNA profile because the material could have belonged to an innocent person. The defendants were acquitted in that case. (Van Derbeken, Technician Boss in SFPD Lab Scandal Flunked DNA Skills Exam, S.F. Gate (Mar. 31, 2015) <http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Technician-boss-in-S-F-police-lab-scandal-6169230.php> [as of April 6, 2015].)
These examples show that during the investigation and pre-trial phase, prosecutors may not be aware of improper analyses of DNA or why decisions were made by the laboratory or law enforcement not to test or upload to databases certain DNA or fingerprints. While it is unknown how common these types of problems occur, when they do occur, they can result in a miscarriage of justice. Allowing the defense to request comparison of DNA and fingerprint evidence testing will place an additional check against these kinds of problems. This bill allows a court to decide when to order a comparison of DNA, and provides guidance of that decision by requiring the court to determine in each case where the comparison is requested that the comparison is material to guilt or innocence.
American Bar Association Standards on DNA Evidence: The American Bar Association (ABA) has endorsed providing access to these databases to defendants in certain cases. Rule 8.3 of the Criminal Justice Standards on DNA Evidence, approved by the ABA House of Delegates in August 2006, provides that information in a database should be provided only to criminal justice agencies and only for purposes of criminal identification, except:
A defendant should have access to:
the results of all database searches and analyses performed in connection with the case;
the search procedures used to identify profiles relevant to the case; and
upon a showing of good cause, any other information related to the database that is relevant to the defense.
Upon a showing of good cause, a court should grant a defendant’s request to order a comparison of profiles in the database with an unknown profile;
A prosecutor should have access to the same information provided to the defense pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) of this standard;
The agency maintaining a database should be permitted to disclose information about the database for the purpose of seeking advice on quality control and assurance;
Persons conducting scientific research on population genetics or related issues may be granted access to genetic profiles in a database for the purposes of that research, provided that the profiles are anonymous, privacy concerns are resolved, and the security of the information is assured; and
As allowed under another rule specifying use restrictions and destruction of DNA evidence.
Argument in Support: According to the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of California, a co-sponsor of this bill, "ACLU has long advocated reforms to prevent wrongful convictions. When the innocent go to prison, the guilty go free. Wrongful convictions continue to occur and typically take many years, even decades, to rectify. An innocent person who has been wrongfully convicted may one day regain his or her freedom, but that person's life will never be restored. Meanwhile, the true perpetrator remains free to commit additional crimes.
"Thanks to the leadership of Senator Lieu, individuals who have been convicted of a crime in California are now permitted to request that a court order a search of the DNA database if such a search will help prove that the person was wrongfully convicted. (Lieu SB 980). Yet, people accused of a crime do not have the same right. Nor is there a means to ask a court to search the state's fingerprint and gun databases, even when evidence has been collected from the scene of the crime that does not match the person accused. No matter how compelling a case may be made that a search of one of those databases will demonstrate that the wrong person is being prosecuted, only law enforcement may cause such a search to occur.
"AB 818 will fix this problem. AB 818 will permit the court on its own motion or at the request of a party to order such a search if the results of the search would be material to guilt or innocence. This bill will affect the small number of cases in which the prosecution has charged someone with a crime but there is untested physical evidence – DNA, a fingerprint or a bullet or cartridge casing – that may help prove that person accused is actually innocent and at the same time help identify the true perpetrator. A number of states including Maryland and Illinois permit a judge to order search of the DNA database at the request of a defendant who is facing trial."
Prior Legislation:
SB 980 (Lieu), Chapter 554, Statutes of 2014, revised the process for obtaining a court order authorizing post-conviction forensic DNA testing.
SB 83 (Burton), Chapter 943, Statutes of 2001, established a procedure for the court to appoint counsel for an indigent person in order to investigate and file a motion for post-conviction DNA testing.
SB 1342 (Burton), Chapter 821, Statutes of 2000, established the procedure for the post-conviction testing of DNA evidence.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Civil Liberties Union of California (Co-sponsor)
California
Public Defenders Association (Co-Sponsor)
California Attorneys
for Criminal Justice
Taxpayers for Improving Public Safety
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by:
Stella Choe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):