SB 36: Out-of-state criminal charges: prosecution related to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-04-10
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law authorizes a magistrate to issue a warrant, upon application by a bail bondsman, as described, for an individual fleeing bail in another state and found in this state upon a finding of probable cause for believing that the person is a fugitive. Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to take a person who is a fugitive admitted to bail in another state into custody, except pursuant to a magistrates order.
This bill would prohibit a magistrate from issuing a warrant for the arrest of an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. The bill would make a bail bondsman who takes such an individual into custody without a warrant guilty of a misdemeanor and ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of specified licenses. The bill would create a civil cause of action for an individual taken into custody in violation of this provision. By creating a new crime, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons Act, prohibits a person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless the person is a licensed a bail fugitive recovery agent, or both a bail licensee and private investigator who are also bail fugitive recovery agents. Existing law makes a violation of the Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons Act a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit a person authorized under the act from apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive who has been admitted to bail in another state and whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care, if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. The bill would make a violation of this provision a misdemeanor and make the authorized individual ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of specified licenses. The bill would create a civil cause of action for an individual taken into custody in violation of this provision. By expanding the application of a crime, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
This bill would additionally prohibit an officer or employee of a state or local law enforcement agency from providing information or assistance to specified entities regarding services constituting legally protected health care activity, including including, but not limited to, abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, if those services would be lawful if they were provided entirely within this state.
Existing law establishes a process by which a material witness in this state may be ordered to attend and testify in a pending prosecution or grand jury in another state.
This bill would prohibit a judge from ordering a witness to appear pursuant to these provisions if the criminal prosecution is based on the laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state.
Existing law provides for the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program, under which each county provides cash assistance and other benefits to qualified low-income families and individuals. Existing federal law establishes the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), known in California as CalFresh, under which supplemental nutrition assistance benefits allocated to the state by the federal government are distributed to eligible individuals by each county. Existing federal regulations disqualify a fleeing felon, as defined, from receiving benefits under the CalFresh program.
This bill would require that the determination of whether a person is fleeing to avoid prosecution for purposes of eligibility in the Calworks CalWORKS program be made pursuant to a specified federal regulation. The bill would also make a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care, if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the location of the patient, eligible for benefits under these programs. Because this bill would expand the eligibility requirements for these programs, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law authorizes a magistrate to issue a warrant, upon application by a bail bondsman, as described, for an individual fleeing bail in another state and found in this state upon a finding of probable cause for believing that the person is a fugitive. Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to take a person who is a fugitive admitted to bail in another state into custody, except pursuant to a magistrates order.
This bill would prohibit a magistrate from issuing a warrant for the arrest of an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. The bill would make a bail bondsman who takes such an individual into custody without a warrant guilty of a misdemeanor and ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of specified licenses. The bill would create a civil cause of action for an individual taken into custody in violation of this provision. By creating a new crime, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons Act, prohibits a person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless the person is a licensed a bail fugitive recovery agent, or both a bail licensee and private investigator who are also bail fugitive recovery agents. Existing law makes a violation of the Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons Act a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit a person authorized under the act from apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive who has been admitted to bail in another state and whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care, if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. The bill would make a violation of this provision a misdemeanor and make the authorized individual ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of specified licenses. The bill would create a civil cause of action for an individual taken into custody in violation of this provision. By expanding the application of a crime, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
This bill would additionally prohibit an officer or employee of a state or local law enforcement agency from providing information or assistance to specified entities regarding services constituting legally protected health care activity, including but not limited to, abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, if those services would be lawful if they were provided entirely within this state.
Existing law provides for the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program, under which each county provides cash assistance and other benefits to qualified low-income families and individuals. Existing federal law establishes the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), known in California as CalFresh, under which supplemental nutrition assistance benefits allocated to the state by the federal government are distributed to eligible individuals by each county. Existing federal regulations disqualify a fleeing felon, as defined, from receiving benefits under the CalFresh program.
This bill would require that the determination of whether a person is fleeing to avoid prosecution for purposes of eligibility in the Calworks program be made pursuant to a specified federal regulation. The bill would also make a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care, if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the location of the patient, eligible for benefits under these programs. Because this would expand the eligibility requirements for these programs, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law authorizes a magistrate to issue a warrant, upon application by a bail bondsman, as described, for an individual fleeing bail in another state and found in this state upon a finding of probable cause for believing that the person is a fugitive. Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to take a person who is a fugitive admitted to bail in another state into custody, except pursuant to a magistrates order.
This bill would prohibit a magistrate from issuing a warrant for the arrest of an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. The bill would make a bail bondsman who takes such an individual into custody without a warrant guilty of a misdemeanor and ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of specified licenses. The bill would create a civil cause of action for an individual taken into custody in violation of this provision. By creating a new crime, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons Act, prohibits a person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless the person is a licensed a bail fugitive recovery agent, or both a bail licensee and private investigator who are also bail fugitive recovery agents. Existing law makes a violation of the Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons Act a misdemeanor.
This bill would prohibit a person authorized under the act from apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive who has been admitted to bail in another state and whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care, if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. The bill would make a violation of this provision a misdemeanor and make the authorized individual ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of specified licenses. The bill would create a civil cause of action for an individual taken into custody in violation of this provision. By expanding the application of a crime, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
Existing law provides for the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program, under which each county provides cash assistance and other benefits to qualified low-income families and individuals. Existing federal law establishes the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), known in California as CalFresh, under which supplemental nutrition assistance benefits allocated to the state by the federal government are distributed to eligible individuals by each county. Existing federal regulations disqualify a fleeing felon, as defined, from receiving benefits under the CalFresh program.
This bill would require that the determination of whether a person is fleeing to avoid prosecution for purposes of eligibility in the Calworks program be made pursuant to a specified federal regulation. The bill would also make a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care, if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the location of the patient, eligible for benefits under these programs. Because this would expand the eligibility requirements for these programs, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In 2022, following the United States Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, Californias legislature passed and Governor Gavin Newsom signed a package of bills, led by members of the Legislative Womens Caucus, and complimentary budget actions that established the state as a haven for those fleeing prosecution for seeking abortion and gender-affirming care in other states.
(b)Many states have now passed laws that make seeking or providing an abortion a felony offense.
(c)Many states have also enacted laws or regulations banning gender-affirming care and 15 additional states are considering legislation to do so.
(d)It is the intent of the legislature Legislature to pass legislation to provide protections and supports to any person fleeing a prosecution, conviction, or sentence in another state for seeking an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or seeking gender-affirming care and to any person assisting the person seeking that care.
SEC. 2.Section 847.5 of the Penal Code is amended to read:847.5.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), if a person has been admitted to bail in another state, escapes bail, and is present in this State, state, the bail bondsman or other person who is bail for such fugitive, may file with a magistrate in the county where the fugitive is present an affidavit stating the name and whereabouts of the fugitive, the offense with which the alleged fugitive was charged or of which they were convicted, the time and place of same, and the particulars in which the fugitive has violated the terms of their bail, and may request the issuance of a warrant for arrest of the fugitive, and the issuance, after hearing, of an order authorizing the affiant to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which they escaped bail. The magistrate may require such additional evidence under oath as they deem necessary to decide the issue. If the magistrate concludes that there is probable cause for believing that the person alleged to be a fugitive is such, the magistrate may issue a warrant for the persons arrest. The magistrate shall notify the district attorney of such action and shall direct the district attorney to investigate the case and determine the facts of the matter. When the fugitive is brought before the magistrate pursuant to the warrant, the magistrate shall set a time and place for hearing, and shall advise the fugitive of their right to counsel and to produce evidence at the hearing. The magistrate may admit the fugitive to bail pending the hearing. The district attorney shall appear at the hearing. If, after hearing, the magistrate is satisfied from the evidence that the person is a fugitive the magistrate may issue an order authorizing affiant to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which they escaped bail.
(b)A magistrate shall not issue a warrant for the arrest of an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
(c)A bondsman or person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1299.02, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes into custody a fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location, without a magistrates order, is ineligible for a license issued pursuant to Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or Section 1800 of the Insurance Code, and shall forfeit any license already obtained pursuant to those laws.
(d)A person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of subdivision (b) may institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bondsman and bond company within three years after the cause of action accrues.
(e)A bondsman or other person who is bail for a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes the fugitive into custody, except pursuant to an order issued under this section, is guilty of a misdemeanor.
SEC. 3.Section 1299.02 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 21 of Chapter 768 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1299.02.(a)No person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, shall be authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless that person meets one of the following conditions:
(1)Is a bail as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01 who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(2)Is a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(3)Is a licensed private investigator as provided in Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(b)This article shall not prohibit an arrest pursuant to Sections 837, 838, and 839, provided that no consideration is paid or allowed, directly or indirectly, to any person effecting an arrest pursuant to Sections 837, 838, and 839.
(c)Individuals who hold a bail license, bail fugitive recovery license, bail enforcer license, bail runner license, or private investigator license issued by another state shall not apprehend, detain, or arrest bail fugitives in California, unless that individual obtains a bail fugitive recovery agent license issued in this state and complies with California law.
(d)A person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a), to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive shall not apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction was for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. A person who violates this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000) or by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by both that imprisonment and fine, is ineligible for a license issued pursuant to Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or Section 1800 of the Insurance Code, and shall forfeit any license already obtained pursuant to those laws. A person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of this subdivision may institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bail fugitive recovery agent within three years after the cause of action accrues.
(e)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2023.
SEC. 4.Section 1334.2 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1334.2.If (a) Except as provided in subdivision (f), if a judge of a court of record in any state, which by its laws provides for commanding persons within that state to attend and testify in this state, issues a certificate under the seal of the court that there is a criminal prosecution pending in the court, or that there is a grand jury investigation, that a person within this state is a material witness in that prosecution or grand jury investigation, and that his or her their presence will be required for a specified number of days, then, upon presentation of the certificate to a judge of a court of record in the county in which the person is, a time and place for a hearing shall be fixed by the judge and he or she the judge shall make an order directing the witness to appear at the hearing.
If,(b)If at the hearing, the judge determines that the witness is material and necessary, that it will not cause undue hardship to the witness to be compelled to attend and testify in the prosecution or grand jury investigation in the other state, and that the laws of the state in which the prosecution is pending or in which there is a grand jury investigation will give to the witness protection from arrest and service of civil and criminal process and will furnish in advance to the witness the sum of ten cents ($0.10) for each mile necessarily traveled if the witness elects surface travel or the minimum round trip scheduled airline fare plus twenty cents ($0.20) a mile for necessary surface travel at either end of the flight if the witness elects air travel, and, except as provided in subdivision (b) of Section 1334.3, a per diem of twenty dollars ($20) for each day that he or she is they are required to travel and attend as a witness and that the judge of the court in which the witness is ordered to appear will order the payment of witness fees authorized by law for each day the witness is required to attend the court plus reimbursement for any additional expenses of the witness which the judge of the court in which the witness is ordered to appear shall find reasonable and necessary, he or she the judge shall issue a subpoena, with a copy of the certificate attached, directing the witness to attend and testify in the court where the prosecution is pending, or where the grand jury investigation is, at a time and place specified in the subpoena. In any of these hearings the certificate shall be prima facie evidence of all the facts stated therein.
If(c)If the certificate recommends that the witness be taken into immediate custody and delivered to an officer of the requesting state to assure his or her the witness attendance therein, the judge may, in lieu of notification of the hearing, direct that the witness be forthwith brought before him or her the judge for the hearing.
If(d)If the judge at the hearing is satisfied of the desirability of the custody and delivery, for which determination the certificate shall be prima facie proof of this desirability, he or she the judge may, in lieu of issuing a subpoena, order that the witness be forthwith taken into custody and delivered to an officer of the requesting state.
If(e)If the witness, who is subpoenaed as provided in this section, after being paid or tendered by some properly authorized person the sum or fare, and per diem set forth in this section, fails without good cause to attend and testify as directed in the subpoena, he or she the witness shall be punished in the manner provided for the punishment of any witness who disobeys a subpoena issued from a court of record in this state.
(f)A judge shall not issue an order directing a witness to appear pursuant to this section if the criminal prosecution is based on the laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Title 5.8 (commencing with Section 13790) is added to Part 4 of the Penal Code, to read:5.8.Legally Protected Health Care Activity 13790.Notwithstanding any other law and except as required by federal law, an officer or employee of a law enforcement agency of a state or local law enforcement agency, shall not, while acting in their official capacity, provide information or assistance relating to an investigation or inquiry into services constituting legally protected health care activity, including including, but not limited to, abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, if such services would be lawful if they were provided entirely in this state to any of the following:
(a)A federal law enforcement agency.
(b)A state law enforcement agency.
(c)A private citizen.
(d)A bondsman or person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1299.02, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state.
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.Section 11486.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:11486.5.(a)An individual shall not be eligible for aid under this chapter if the individual is either:
(1)Fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, for a crime or an attempt to commit a crime that is a felony under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, or which, in the case of the State of New Jersey, is a high misdemeanor under the laws of that state. For the purposes of this section, except as provided in subdivision (c), an individual shall be determined to be fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, pursuant to Sections 273.11(n)(1)(ii) and 273.11(n)(2) of Title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(2)Violating a condition of probation or parole imposed under federal law or the law of any state.
(b)Subdivision (a) shall not apply with respect to conduct of an individual for any month beginning after the President of the United States grants a pardon with respect to the conduct.
(c)For the purposes of this section, an individual is not considered fleeing to avoid prosecution if the felony offense with which the person is charged or convicted is as a result of performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
SEC. 6.SEC. 7.Section 18901.33 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:18901.33.A person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is eligible for benefits pursuant to this chapter, if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
SEC. 7.SEC. 8.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district because, in that regard, this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In 2022, following the United States Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, Californias legislature passed and Governor Gavin Newsom signed a package of bills, led by members of the Legislative Womens Caucus, and complimentary budget actions that established the state as a haven for those fleeing prosecution for seeking abortion and gender-affirming care in other states.
(b)At least 13 states have Many states have now passed laws that make seeking or providing an abortion a felony offense.
(c)Four states have Many states have also enacted laws or regulations banning gender-affirming care and 15 additional states are considering legislation to do so.
(d)It is the intent of the legislature to pass legislation to provide protections and supports to any person fleeing a felony prosecution, conviction, or sentence in another state for seeking an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or seeking gender-affirming care and to any person assisting the person seeking that care.
SEC. 2.Section 847.5 of the Penal Code is amended to read:847.5.(a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), if a person has been admitted to bail in another state, escapes bail, and is present in this State, the bail bondsman or other person who is bail for such fugitive, may file with a magistrate in the county where the fugitive is present an affidavit stating the name and whereabouts of the fugitive, the offense with which the alleged fugitive was charged or of which they were convicted, the time and place of same, and the particulars in which the fugitive has violated the terms of their bail, and may request the issuance of a warrant for arrest of the fugitive, and the issuance, after hearing, of an order authorizing the affiant to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which they escaped bail. The magistrate may require such additional evidence under oath as they deem necessary to decide the issue. If the magistrate concludes that there is probable cause for believing that the person alleged to be a fugitive is such, the magistrate may issue a warrant for the persons arrest. The magistrate shall notify the district attorney of such action and shall direct the district attorney to investigate the case and determine the facts of the matter. When the fugitive is brought before the magistrate pursuant to the warrant, the magistrate shall set a time and place for hearing, and shall advise the fugitive of their right to counsel and to produce evidence at the hearing. The magistrate may admit the fugitive to bail pending the hearing. The district attorney shall appear at the hearing. If, after hearing, the magistrate is satisfied from the evidence that the person is a fugitive the magistrate may issue an order authorizing affiant to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which they escaped bail.
(b)A magistrate shall not issue a warrant for the arrest of an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
(c)A bondsman or person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1299.02, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes into custody a fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location, without a magistrates order, is ineligible for a license issued pursuant to Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or Section 1800 of the Insurance Code, and shall forfeit any license already obtained pursuant to those laws.
(d)A person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of subdivision (b) may institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bondsman and bond company within three years after the cause of action accrues.
(e)A bondsman or other person who is bail for a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes the fugitive into custody, except pursuant to an order issued under this section, is guilty of a misdemeanor.
SEC. 3.Section 1299.02 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 21 of Chapter 768 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1299.02.(a)No person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, shall be authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless that person meets one of the following conditions:
(1)Is a bail as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01 who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(2)Is a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(3)Is a licensed private investigator as provided in Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(b)This article shall not prohibit an arrest pursuant to Sections 837, 838, and 839, provided that no consideration is paid or allowed, directly or indirectly, to any person effecting an arrest pursuant to Sections 837, 838, and 839.
(c)Individuals who hold a bail license, bail fugitive recovery license, bail enforcer license, bail runner license, or private investigator license issued by another state shall not apprehend, detain, or arrest bail fugitives in California, unless that individual obtains a bail fugitive recovery agent license issued in this state and complies with California law.
(d)A person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a), to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive shall not apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction was for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. A person who violates this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000) or by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by both that imprisonment and fine, is ineligible for a license issued pursuant to Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or Section 1800 of the Insurance Code, and shall forfeit any license already obtained pursuant to those laws. A person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of this subdivision may institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bail fugitive recovery agent within three years after the cause of action accrues.
(e)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2023.
SEC. 4.Title 5.8 (commencing with Section 13790) is added to Part 4 of the Penal Code, to read:5.8.Legally Protected Health Care Activity 13790.Notwithstanding any other law and except as required by federal law, an officer or employee of a law enforcement agency of a state or local law enforcement agency, shall not, while acting in their official capacity, provide information or assistance relating to an investigation or inquiry into services constituting legally protected health care activity, including but not limited to, abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, if such services would be lawful if they were provided entirely in this state to any of the following:
(a)A federal law enforcement agency.
(b)A state law enforcement agency.
(c)A private citizen.
(d)A bondsman or person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1299.02, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 11486.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:11486.5.(a)An individual shall not be eligible for aid under this chapter if the individual is either:
(1)Fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, for a crime or an attempt to commit a crime that is a felony under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, or which, in the case of the State of New Jersey, is a high misdemeanor under the laws of that state. For the purposes of this section, except as provided in subdivision (c), an individual shall be determined to be fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, pursuant to Sections 273.11(n)(1)(ii) and 273.11(n)(2) of Title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(2)Violating a condition of probation or parole imposed under federal law or the law of any state.
(b)Subdivision (a) shall not apply with respect to conduct of an individual for any month beginning after the President of the United States grants a pardon with respect to the conduct.
(c)For the purposes of this section, an individual is not considered fleeing to avoid prosecution if the felony offense with which the person is charged or convicted is as a result of performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.Section 18901.33 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:18901.33.A person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is eligible for benefits pursuant to this chapter, if the abortion or care abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
SEC. 6.SEC. 7.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district because, in that regard, this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)In 2022, following the United States Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, Californias legislature passed and Governor Gavin Newsom signed a package of bills, led by members of the Legislative Womens Caucus, and complimentary budget actions that established the state as a haven for those fleeing prosecution for seeking abortion and gender-affirming care in other states.
(b)At least 13 states have passed laws that make seeking or providing an abortion a felony offense.
(c)Four states have enacted laws or regulations banning gender-affirming care and 15 additional states are considering legislation to do so.
(d)It is the intent of the legislature to pass legislation to provide protections and supports to any person fleeing a felony prosecution, conviction, or sentence in another state for seeking an abortion or seeking gender-affirming care and to any person assisting the person seeking that care.
SEC. 2.Section 847.5 of the Penal Code is amended to read:847.5.If (a)Except as provided in subdivision (b), if a person has been admitted to bail in another state, escapes bail, and is present in this State, the bail bondsman or other person who is bail for such fugitive, may file with a magistrate in the county where the fugitive is present an affidavit stating the name and whereabouts of the fugitive, the offense with which the alleged fugitive was charged or of which he was they were convicted, the time and place of same, and the particulars in which the fugitive has violated the terms of his their bail, and may request the issuance of a warrant for arrest of the fugitive, and the issuance, after hearing, of an order authorizing the affiant to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which he they escaped bail. The magistrate may require such additional evidence under oath as he deems they deem necessary to decide the issue. If he the magistrate concludes that there is probable cause for believing that the person alleged to be a fugitive is such, he the magistrate may issue a warrant for his the persons arrest. The magistrate shall notify the district attorney of such action and shall direct him the district attorney to investigate the case and determine the facts of the matter. When the fugitive is brought before him the magistrate pursuant to the warrant, the magistrate shall set a time and place for hearing, and shall advise the fugitive of his their right to counsel and to produce evidence at the hearing. He The magistrate may admit the fugitive to bail pending the hearing. The district attorney shall appear at the hearing. If, after hearing, the magistrate is satisfied from the evidence that the person is a fugitive he the magistrate may issue an order authorizing affiant to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which he they escaped bail.
(b)A magistrate shall not issue a warrant for the arrest of an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
(c)A bondsman or person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1299.02, to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes into custody a fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location, without a magistrates order, is ineligible for a license issued pursuant to Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or Section 1800 of the Insurance Code, and shall forfeit any license already obtained pursuant to those laws.
(d)A person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of subdivision (b) may institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bondsman and bond company within three years after the cause of action accrues.
A(e)A bondsman or other person who is bail for a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes the fugitive into custody, except pursuant to an order issued under this section, is guilty of a misdemeanor.
SEC. 3.Section 1299.02 of the Penal Code, as added by Section 21 of Chapter 768 of the Statutes of 2022, is amended to read:1299.02.(a)No person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, shall be authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless that person meets one of the following conditions:
(1)Is a bail as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01 who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(2)Is a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(3)Is a licensed private investigator as provided in Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01.
(b)This article shall not prohibit an arrest pursuant to Sections 837, 838, and 839, provided that no consideration is paid or allowed, directly or indirectly, to any person effecting an arrest pursuant to Sections 837, 838, and 839.
(c)Individuals who hold a bail license, bail fugitive recovery license, bail enforcer license, bail runner license, or private investigator license issued by another state shall not apprehend, detain, or arrest bail fugitives in California, unless that individual obtains a bail fugitive recovery agent license issued in this state and complies with California law.
(d)A person authorized, pursuant to subdivision (a), to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive shall not apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction was for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location. A person who violates this subdivision is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000) or by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by both that imprisonment and fine, is ineligible for a license issued pursuant to Chapter 11.3 (commencing with Section 7512) of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code or Section 1800 of the Insurance Code, and shall forfeit any license already obtained pursuant to those laws. A person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of this subdivision may institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bail fugitive recovery agent within three years after the cause of action accrues.
(d)(e)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2023.
SEC. 4.Section 11486.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:11486.5.(a)An individual shall not be eligible for aid under this chapter if he or she is the individual is either:
(1)Fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, for a crime or an attempt to commit a crime that is a felony under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, or which, in the case of the State of New Jersey, is a high misdemeanor under the laws of that state. For the purposes of this section, except as provided in subdivision (c), an individual shall be determined to be fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, pursuant to Sections 273.11(n)(1)(ii) and 273.11(n)(2) of Title 7 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(2)Violating a condition of probation or parole imposed under federal law or the law of any state.
(b)Subdivision (a) shall not apply with respect to conduct of an individual for any month beginning after the President of the United States grants a pardon with respect to the conduct.
(c)For the purposes of this section, an individual is not considered fleeing to avoid prosecution if the felony offense with which the person is charged or convicted is as a result of performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
SEC. 5.Section 18901.33 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:18901.33.A person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion or gender-affirming care is eligible for benefits pursuant to this chapter, if the abortion or care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipients location.
SEC. 6.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district because, in that regard, this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 18, 2023 | May 18 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 1, 2023 | May 1 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 21, 2023 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2. Page 798.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 10, 2023 | Set for hearing April 18. |
| Mar 14, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 0. Page 340.) (March 14). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Set for hearing March 14. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Jan 25, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on PUB S. and JUD. |
| Dec 6, 2022 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 5. |
| Dec 5, 2022 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 1, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 14, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Access Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| American Atheists | ** Support | |
| Anti-Recidivism Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Academy Of Family Physicians | ** Support | |
| California Attorneys For Criminal Justice | ** Support | |
| California LGBTQ Health and Human Services Network | ** Support | |
| City of Berkeley | ** Support | |
| Coalition of California Welfare Rights Organizations | ** Support | |
| Concerned Women for America | ** Against | |
| Desert Aids Project D/b/a Dap Health | ** Support | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Support | |
| End Child Poverty California | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| Essential Access Health | ** Support | |
| John Burton Advocates for Youth | ** Support | |
| NARAL Pro-Choice California | ** Support | |
| National Council of Jewish Women, CA | ** Support | |
| National Health Law Program | ** Support | |
| Oakland Privacy | ** Support | |
| Plan C | ** Support | |
| Right to Life League | ** Against | |
| Sacramento LGBT Community Center | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group | ** Support | |
| The Translatin@ Coalition | ** Support | |
| Training In Early Abortion For Comprehensive Healthcare | ** Support | |
| western center on law and poverty | ** Support | |
| Young Women’s Freedom Center | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 36 (Skinner) - Out-of-state criminal charges: prosecution related to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
SB 36 would prohibit the issuance of warrants for persons who have violated the laws of another state relating to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, that are legally protected in California. The bill would also prohibit apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive based on such offenses, and impose criminal and civil liability for doing so. In addition, the bill would restrict the sharing of information by law enforcement related to such protected activity and provide that convictions in other states would not result in ineligibility for state benefits.
Fiscal Impact:
- Judicial Branch: Unknown court workload cost pressures to adjudicate prosecutions and civil actions brought against persons who violate the prohibitions of SB 36 (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund).*
- CDSS: Unknown, potentially significant costs for the Department of Social Services (CDSS) to pay CalWORKS benefits to persons who would be ineligible to receive federal funds due to their status as fleeing felon under federal law (General Fund).*
*See Staff Comments for additional detail.
Background:
In the 1973 holding, Roe v. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court held that it is a constitutional right to access abortion before fetal viability. However, on June 24, 2022 in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the Court voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe and found that there is no federal constitutional right to an abortion. As a result of the Dobbs decision, people in roughly half the country may lose access to abortion services or have them severely restricted. In addition, a growing number of states have been passing laws putting residents who seek essential gender-affirming care at risk of being prosecuted. States are attempting to classify the provision and seeking of gender-affirming health care as a crime warranting prison time and are threatening parents with criminal penalties if they attempt to travel to another state in order to secure gender-affirming care for their child.
Although California has enacted numerous laws to protect the right to gender-affirming care and the fundamental right to reproductive freedom, without federal protections there is nothing prohibiting those providing or seeking abortion or gender-affirming health care from being criminalized or held liable in other states. This bill seeks to address this issue in myriad ways, including restrictions on and penalties for issuing or executing a warrant on a bail fugitive where the underlying offense imposes a criminal penalty on an individual for performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care that is legal in this state. This includes criminal penalties for, and a civil cause of action against, a bail bondsman who takes the individual into custody in violation of this bill. Law enforcement are also restricted from providing information to specified entities regarding these protected activities. Finally, the bill provides greater access to state benefits for those otherwise ineligible as “fleeing felons.”
California’s safety net operates through a complex network of programs, including public health insurance, cash and food assistance, and tax credits. CalFresh food assistance, and CalWORKs cash assistance are two of the largest programs in the safety net. Combined with Medi-Cal, these three programs together serve about 13.6 million Californians.
CalWORKs is a public assistance program that offers temporary cash aid assistance, nutrition benefits, employment services and health insurance to eligible families who have children under the age of 18. The program is operated locally by county welfare departments. If a person is eligible for CalWORKs, they are eligible for Medi-Cal and may also qualify for CalFresh food benefits. The amount of a family's monthly assistance payment depends on a number of factors, including the number of people who are eligible and the special needs of any of those family members. The income of the family is considered in calculating the amount of cash aid the family receives.
CalFresh provides monthly food benefits for individuals and families with low-income. CalFresh benefits can help buy nutritious foods for a better diet. CalFresh benefits stretch food budgets, allowing individuals and families to afford nutritious food, including more fruit, vegetables and other healthy foods. The amount of benefits a household receives is dependent on household size countable income, and monthly expenses, such as housing and utilities. The program issues monthly benefits on an Electronic Benefit Transfer (EBT) card. Food may be purchased at any grocery store or farmers market that accepts EBT cards.
The Federal Government provides most of the funding for CalWORKS and CalFresh. Under Federal law, a person who is considered to be a fleeing felon is ineligible to receive CalWORKS and CalFRESH benefits.
Proposed Law:
- Prohibits a magistrate from issuing an arrest warrant for an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that criminalizes an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state (“protected health care activities”), regardless of the recipient’s location.
- Provides that a bondsman or person authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes into custody a fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual for protected health care activities, without a magistrate’s order, is ineligible for a license to be a bail fugitive recovery agent and shall forfeit any license already obtained. Imposes criminal penalties against a bail fugitive recovery agent for apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction was for the violation of laws of another state that criminalizes protected health care.
- Authorizes a person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of this bill’s provisions to bring a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bondsman and bond company within three years.
- Prohibits, except as required by federal law, an officer or employee of a law enforcement agency from providing information or assistance relating to an investigation or inquiry into services constituting legally protected health care activity to any of the following:
- a federal law enforcement agency;
- a state law enforcement agency;
- a private citizen; or
- a bondsman or person authorized as a bail fugitive recovery agent to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state.
- Prohibits a judge from issuing an order directing a witness to appear as specified, if the criminal prosecution is based on the laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual for protected health care.
- Provides that an individual is not considered fleeing to avoid prosecution for purposes of CalWORKs eligibility if the felony offense with which the person is charged or convicted is as a result of protected health care.
- Provides that a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for protected health care, is eligible for CalFresh benefits.
Related Legislation:
- SB 345 (Skinner, 2023), among other things, prohibits a licensing board from denying an application for licensure or suspending, revoking, or otherwise imposing discipline on a licensed person because they were disciplined or convicted of an offense in another state, if that disciplinary action was the result of providing a legally protected health care activity. SB 345 is currently pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- SCA 10 (Atkins and Rendon, Ch. 87, Stats. 2022) expressly provided that the state shall not deny or interfere with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives, and states the measure is intended to further the right to privacy and the right to not be denied equal protection, as guaranteed by the California Constitution and that it does not narrow or limit the right to privacy or equal protection.
- AB 1242 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 627, Stats. 2022) prohibited law enforcement from knowingly arresting a person for performing or aiding in the performance of a lawful abortion or for obtaining an abortion and prohibits specified entities from providing information to another state or political subdivision thereof regarding an abortion that is lawful under California law, except as provided.
- AB 1666 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 42, Stats. 2022) prohibited the enforcement in this state of out-of-state laws authorizing a civil action against a person or entity that receives or seeks, performs or induces, or aids or abets the performance of an abortion, or who attempts or intends to engage in those actions and declares those out-of-state laws to be contrary to the public policy of this state.
- AB 2091 (Mia Bonta, Ch. 628, Stats. 2022), among other things, prohibited compelling a person to identify or provide information that would identify an individual who has sought or obtained an abortion in a state, county, city, or other local criminal, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding if the information is being requested based on another state’s laws that interfere with a person’s right to choose or obtain an abortion or a foreign penal civil action.
- AB 2223 (Wicks, Ch. 629, Stats. 2022), among other things, authorized a party aggrieved by a violation of the Reproductive Privacy Act to bring a civil action against an offending state actor, as specified, and provides that every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care.
Staff Comments:
It is unknown how many additional prosecutions and civil actions would be brought as a result of the implementation of this bill. Misdemeanor charges carry the potential for incarceration, therefore certain defendants’ rights are attached to the proceedings. These include the right to a jury trial and the right to counsel (at public expense if the defendants are unable to afford the costs of representation) which could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings. It generally costs about $1,000 to operate a courtroom for one hour. Consequently, if prosecutors filed charges proposed by this bill that take 50 or more hours of court involvement, the cost pressures of this measure to the courts would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure court staff time and resources may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund (GF) to perform existing duties. Numerous trial court operations are funded through the imposition and collection of fines and fees. However, the Legislature has reduced and eliminated fines and fees over the past decade. As a result, the 2023-24 proposed budget anticipates an ongoing annual allocation of $109.3 million from the GF to the Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF) in order to address the decline in revenue.
It is unknown how many persons would be eligible to receive CalWORKS benefits under the provisions of SB 36 who would otherwise be prohibited due to their status as a fleeing felon under existing law. Because such persons would be prohibited from receiving federal funding, their benefits would have to be paid out of the state General Fund. According to the most recent CalWORKS report, the average monthly payment per Assistance Unit (AU) was $717. Therefore if this bill resulted in the equivalent of 6 new AUs who received the average benefit, it would qualify for suspense in one fiscal year.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 36 (Author:Skinner)
Version: April 10, 2023
Hearing Date: April 18, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Out-of-state criminal charges: prosecution related to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care
DIGEST
This bill prohibits the issuance of warrants for those whose offense pursuant to the laws of another state is related to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care legally protected in California. The bill restricts and imposes criminal and civil penalties for those apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive based on such offenses. The bill restricts the sharing of information by law enforcement related to such protected activity and ensures convictions in other states of such offenses does not result in ineligibility for state benefits.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Since the 1973 holding in Roe v. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court has continuously held that it is a constitutional right to access abortion before fetal viability. However, on June 24, 2022 in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the Court voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe and found that there is no federal constitutional right to an abortion. As a result of the Dobbs decision, people in roughly half the country may lose access to abortion services or have them severely restricted.
In addition, a growing number of states have been passing laws putting residents who seek essential gender-affirming care at risk of being prosecuted. States are attempting to classify the provision and seeking of gender-affirming health care as a crime warranting prison time and are threatening parents with criminal penalties if they attempt to travel to another state in order to secure life-saving gender-affirming care for their child.
Though California has enacted numerous laws to protect the right to gender-affirming care and the fundamental right to reproductive freedom, without federal protections there is nothing prohibiting those providing or seeking abortion or gender-affirming health care from being criminalized or held liable in other states.
This bill seeks to address this issue in myriad ways, including restrictions on and penalties for issuing or executing a warrant on a bail fugitive where the underlying offense imposes a criminal penalty on an individual for performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care that is legal in this state. This includes a civil cause of action against a bail bondsman who takes the individual into custody in violation of this law. Law enforcement are also restricted from providing information to specified entities regarding these protected health care activities. Finally, the bill provides greater access to state benefits for those otherwise ineligible as “fleeing felons.”
The bill is co-sponsored by Equality California, NARAL Pro-Choice California, Western Center on Law and Poverty, and the Coalition of California Welfare Rights Organizations. It is supported by an array of organizations. The bill is opposed by Concerned Women for America and the Right to Life League. It passed out of the Senate Public Safety Committee on a vote of 4 to 0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Provides that each state shall give full faith and credit to the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state, and that Congress may prescribe the manner in which such acts, records, and proceedings shall be proved and the effect thereof. (U.S. Const., art. IV, § 1.)
- Provides that a person charged in any state with treason, felony, or other crime who fled from that state and is found in another state shall, on demand from the executive authority of the state from which the person fled, be delivered to the state having jurisdiction of the crime. (U.S. Const., art. IV, § 2; 18 U.S.C. § 3182.)
- Provides that persons in the United States may travel freely throughout the United States. (E.g., U.S. v. Guest (1966) 383 U.S. 745, 758 (“freedom to travel throughout the United States has long been recognized as a basic right under the Constitution”).)[1]
- Provides that records and judicial proceedings of any court of any state, territory or possession, or copies thereof, must be proved or admitted in other courts within the United States and its territories and possessions by the attestation of the clerk and seal of the court annexed, if a seal exists, together with a certificate of a judge of the court that the said attestation is in proper form; and that such acts, records, and judicial proceedings, or copies thereof, once authenticated, have the same full faith and credit in every court within the United States and its territories and possessions as they have by law or usage in the courts of such State, territory or possession from which they are taken. (28 U.S.C. § 1738.)
Existing law:
- Provides, under the state constitution, that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights, including, among others, the right to privacy. (Cal. Const. art. I, § 1.)
- Prohibits the state from denying or interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives. Specifies that this provision is intended to further the constitutional right to privacy guaranteed by Section 1 of Article I of the California Constitution, and the constitutional right to not be denied equal protection guaranteed by Section 7 of Article I of the California Constitution, and that nothing herein narrows or limits the right to privacy or equal protection. (Cal. Const. art. I, § 1.1.)
- Establishes the Reproductive Privacy Act and provides that the Legislature finds and declares that every individual possesses a fundamental right to privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care. (Health & Saf. Code §§ 123460 et. seq., § 123462.)
- Prohibits the state from denying or interfering with a person’s right to choose or obtain an abortion prior to viability of the fetus or when the abortion is necessary to protect the life or health of the person. (Health & Saf. Code § 123466.)
- Prohibits a person from being compelled in a state, county, city, or other local criminal, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding to identify or provide information that would identify or that is related to an individual who has sought or obtained an abortion if the information is being requested based on either another state’s laws that interfere with a person’s rights to choose or obtain an abortion or a foreign penal civil action. (Health & Saf. Code § 123466.)
- Provides that a law of another state that authorizes a person to bring a civil action against a person or entity who does any of the following is contrary to the public policy of this state:
- receives or seeks an abortion;
- performs or induces an abortion;
- knowingly engages in conduct that aids or abets the performance or inducement of an abortion; or
- attempts or intends to engage in the conduct described above. (Health & Saf. Code § 123467.5(a).)
- Prohibits the application of an out-of-state law described in the preceding paragraph from being applied to a case or controversy heard in state court and prohibits the enforcement or satisfaction of a civil judgment received through an adjudication under such an out-of-state law. (Health & Saf. Code § 123467.5(b).)
- Prohibits a clerk of a superior court in the county in which discovery in a foreign action is sought, or an attorney licensed in this state and retained by a party in a foreign action, from issuing a subpoena for discovery in this state based on a foreign subpoena if the foreign subpoena is based on an anti-gender-affirming care action. (Code Civ. Proc. § 2029.300(e).)
- Authorizes a magistrate to issue an arrest warrant, upon application by a bail bondsman, for a person who has been admitted to bail in another state, escapes bail, and is present in this State and after a hearing, issue an order to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which they escaped. (Pen. Code § 847.5.)
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a bail bondsman to take a fugitive into custody without a warrant from a magistrate. (Pen. Code § 847.5.)
- Provides, starting July 1, 2023, that no person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, shall be authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless that person is one of the following:
- a bail as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01 who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined;
- a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined; or
- a licensed private investigator who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined. (Pen. Code 1299.02.)
- Defines a “bail fugitive” as a defendant in a pending criminal case who has been released from custody under a financially secured appearance, cash, or other bond and has had that bond declared forfeited, or a defendant in a pending criminal case who has violated a bond condition whereby apprehension and reincarceration are permitted. (Pen. Code § 1299.01.)
- Defines a “bail fugitive recovery person” as a person provided written authorization by the bail or depositor of bail, and is contracted to investigate, surveil, locate, and arrest a bail fugitive for surrender to the appropriate court, jail, or police department, and any person who is employed to assist a bail or depositor of bail to investigate, surveil, locate, and arrest a bail fugitive for surrender to the appropriate court, jail, or police department. (Pen. Code § 1299.01.)
- Establishes the CalWORKs program under which each county provides cash assistance and other benefits to qualified low-income families and individuals. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 11200 et seq.)
- Makes certain individuals ineligible for the CalWORKs program including a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, for a crime or an attempt to commit a crime that is a felony under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, or which, in the case of the State of New Jersey, is a high misdemeanor under the laws of that state. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 11486.5.)
- Establishes CalFresh whereby recipients of aid and other low-income households receive benefits under the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). (Welf. & Inst. Code § 18900 et seq.)
This bill:
- Prohibits a magistrate from issuing an arrest warrant for an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that criminalizes an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state (collectively “protected health care”), regardless of the recipient’s location.
- Provides that a bondsman or person authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes into custody a fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual for protected health care, without a magistrate’s order, is ineligible for a license to be a bail fugitive recovery agent and shall forfeit any license already obtained. Imposes criminal penalties against a bail fugitive recovery agent for apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction was for the violation of laws of another state that criminalizes protected health care.
- Authorizes a person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of this bill’s provisions to bring a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bondsman and bond company within three years.
- Prohibits, except as required by federal law, an officer or employee of a law enforcement agency from providing information or assistance relating to an investigation or inquiry into services constituting legally protected health care activity to any of the following:
- a federal law enforcement agency;
- a state law enforcement agency;
- a private citizen; or
- a bondsman or person authorized as a bail fugitive recovery agent to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state.
- Prohibits a judge from issuing an order directing a witness to appear pursuant to Penal Code Section 1334.2 if the criminal prosecution is based on the laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual for protected health care.
- Provides that an individual is not considered fleeing to avoid prosecution for purposes of CalWORKs eligibility if the felony offense with which the person is charged or convicted is as a result of protected health care.
- Provides that a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for protected health care, is eligible for CalFresh benefits.
- States specified legislative findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
- Post-Dobbs access to reproductive healthcare is being restricted across the nation
Roe v. Wade (1973) 410 U.S. 113, was the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that held the implied constitutional right to privacy extended to a person’s decision whether to terminate a pregnancy, while allowing that some state regulation of abortion access could be permissible. Roe has been one of the most debated U.S. Supreme Court decisions and its application and validity have been challenged numerous times, but its fundamental holding had continuously been upheld by the Court until June 2022. On June 24, 2022, the Court published its official opinion in Dobbs and voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe.[2] The case involved a Mississippi law enacted in 2018 that banned most abortions after the first 15 weeks of pregnancy, which is before what is generally accepted as the period of viability.[3] The majority opinion upholds the Mississippi law finding that, contrary to almost 50 years of precedent, there is no fundamental constitutional right to have an abortion. The opinion further provides that states should be allowed to decide how to regulate abortion and that a strong presumption of validity should be afforded to those state laws.[4]
The Roe decision was the foundation for allowing people the ability to control their reproductive lives because it established a federal constitutional right for anyone who could become pregnant in the United States to decide when and if to have children and prevented the criminalization of having an abortion or providing an abortion. Prior to Roe, legal abortion did exist in some states, but the choices available to those seeking to terminate an unwanted pregnancy were limited and disproportionately affected those who were younger, lower income, and members of communities of color.[5] In the wake of the Dobbs decision, it is very probable that abortion will be banned or severely restricted in dozens of states,[6] with 13 states already having total abortion bans in effect.[7] Almost one-third of women and people who can become pregnant of reproductive age in the United States live in a state where abortion is not legal or is severely restricted.[8] If all the states expected to enact a total ban on abortion actually do, the number of patients who would find that their nearest clinic is in California could increase to 1.4 million, an almost 3,000 percent increase.[9]
- Healthcare providers are often the targets of abortion bans
Many abortion bans target providers of abortions through criminal, civil, and administrative penalties. For example, in Texas it is a felony to perform an abortion, unless it is needed to save the life of the patient, and provides for civil liability and licensure revocation. (Tex. Health & Safety Code § 171.201 et. seq.) Texas law also prohibits a physician from knowingly performing or inducing an abortion on a pregnant woman if the physician detected a fetal heartbeat for the unborn child, as specified, or failed to perform a test to detect a fetal heartbeat. (Tex. Health & Safety Code § 171.201 et seq. (enacted through Texas Senate Bill 8).) SB 8 provides that any person, other than an officer or employee of a state or local governmental entity in Texas, and regardless if they suffered any actual harm, may bring a civil action to enforce its provisions, which includes liability of $10,000 plus costs and fees if a plaintiff prevails while a defendant is prohibited from recovering their own costs and fees if they prevail. (Id. at § 171.201(b) & (i).) Idaho enacted a similar law via Idaho Senate Bill 1309, which provides for liability of $20,000 plus costs and fees if a plaintiff prevails. (Idaho Code § 18-8701 et. seq.) Oklahoma also enacted a similar law to Texas and enacted criminal penalties for the performance of an abortion, except when performed to save the life of a pregnant person, with punishment of up to 10 years in prison or fines of up to $100,000.[10] Similar legislation to SB 8 has also been introduced in Arizona, Florida, Minnesota, and Wisconsin.[11] In six states with abortion bans—Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Missouri, North Dakota, and Tennessee—prosecutors can criminally prosecute health care professionals for performing abortions and providers are only allowed to offer evidence that the procedure was necessary to save the patient until after they are charged.[12] These laws put providers in extremely difficult positions where they have to make legal and ethical judgments about treating a patient whose health or life may be in jeopardy while facing the very real potential of being held criminally or civilly liable or having their medical license threatened.
- California is a Reproductive Freedom State
The California Supreme Court held in 1969 that the state constitution’s implied right to privacy extends to an individual’s decision about whether or not to have an abortion. (People v. Belous (1969) 71 Cal.2d 954.) This was the first time an individual’s right to abortion was upheld in a court and came before the Roe decision. In 1972 the California voters passed a constitutional amendment that explicitly provided for the right to privacy in the state constitution. (Prop. 11, Nov. 7, 1927 gen. elec.) California statutory law provides, under the Reproductive Privacy Act, that the Legislature finds and declares every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy; therefore, it is the public policy of the State of California that every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control, and every individual has the fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion. (Health & Saf. Code § 123462.) In 2019, Governor Newsom issued a proclamation reaffirming California’s commitment to making reproductive freedom a fundamental right in response to the numerous attacks on reproductive rights across the nation.[13]
In September 2021, more than 40 organizations came together to form the California Future Abortion Council (CA FAB) to identify barriers to accessing abortion services and to recommend policy proposals to support equitable and affordable access for not only Californians, but all who seek care in this state. CA FAB issued its first report in December 2021, which included 45 policy recommendations to protect, strengthen, and expand abortion access in California.[14] In response to the Dobbs decision and CA FAB’s report, California enacted a comprehensive package of legislation that protects the rights of patients seeking abortion in the state and those supporting them.[15] Additionally, the voters overwhelmingly approved Proposition 1 (Nov. 8, 2022 gen. elec.), and enacted an express constitutional right in the state constitution that prohibits the state from interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions.
Though California has enacted numerous laws to protect the fundamental right to reproductive freedom, without federal protections there is nothing prohibiting providers or recipients of protected health care from being criminalized in other states. In December 2022, CA FAB issued an addendum to its original report and identified additional policy recommendations, including protecting abortion providers “against adverse actions related to their participation in public benefit programs, health plan and insurance contracts, and credentialing due to enforcement of another state’s hostile abortion law.[16]“
- Out of state bans on gender-affirming care and California policies to protect patients receiving such care
As California and other states have implemented policies to ensure that transgender individuals are not discriminated against and can obtain gender-affirming care, other states have targeted transgender individuals and providers of gender-affirming care. According to Human Rights Watch, as of March 2022, legislatures nationwide had introduced over 300 anti-LGBTQ+ bills, over 130 of which specifically targeted transgender people.[17] Many states have been enacting statutes that potentially impose civil and criminal liability for providing to a minor, or helping a minor obtain, gender-affirming care. For example, Alabama recently enacted a bill that makes it a felony to provide, or help to provide, certain types of gender-affirming care.[18] Arkansas prohibits a physician or other healthcare provider from providing or referring certain types of gender-affirming care for a minor; a violation or “threatened violation” can be punished through a professional board or a civil action.[19] On September 29, 2022, Governor Newsom issued a signing statement for SB 107 (Wiener, Ch. 810, Stats. 2022) that said “[i]n California we believe in equality and acceptance. We believe that no one should be prosecuted or persecuted for getting care they need – including gender-affirming care.[20]“ That bill enacts various safeguards against the enforcement of other states’ laws that purport to penalize individuals from obtaining gender-affirming care that is legal in California.
- Bolstering California as a sanctuary for the right to abortion and gender-affirming care
According to the author:
Last year the Legislature, Governor Newsom, and California voters took bold action, guaranteeing the right to an abortion and gender-affirming care. But a growing number of states have done the opposite, putting residents who seek essential health care at risk of being prosecuted. My ‘Safe Haven’ bill will ensure that those who come to California fleeing persecution by other states will be free from the worry that a bounty hunter could snatch them up and send them back.
This bill approaches this onslaught of criminal penalties for protected health care in other states from several angles.
First, the bill prohibits a magistrate from issuing a warrant for the arrest of an individual where the underlying offense is for engaging in protected health care, performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location.
Relatedly, the bill restricts a bondsman or other person authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state from taking into custody a person who is a fugitive based on criminal offenses related to protected health care. Such a person is ineligible for specified licenses and must forfeit any already held. A person in violation can be subject to criminal penalties and, most relevant to this Committee’s jurisdiction, is subject to a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief brought by an individual unlawfully taken into custody.
In addition, the bill prohibits law enforcement personnel from sharing information or providing assistance relating to investigations or inquiries into protected health care to specified entities, including federal and state law enforcement and bondsman and other bail agents.
Finally, the bill amends existing law to ensure that those charged with criminal penalties in other states for engaging in protected health care are not thereby made ineligible for specified state benefits, namely CalWORKs and CalFresh.
Writing in support, the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights states:
Following the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June 2022, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed a package of bills making California a sanctuary state for abortion services and gender-affirming care. In addition, in the November election, California voters enacted a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to abortion and contraception. Meanwhile, a growing number of states have been passing laws putting residents who seek essential health care at risk of being prosecuted.
SB 36 builds on California landmark protections further protecting people who have been charged or convicted in another state as a result of the criminalization of abortion or gender-affirming health care that is fully legal in California.
- Legal Concerns: Full Faith and Credit Clause
Article IV, section 1 of the U. S. Constitution, known as the Full Faith and Credit Clause, requires every state to give full faith and credit to the public acts (statutes), records, and judicial proceedings of every other state. As the bill requires certain laws and judgments of other states to not be enforced in California, it potentially implicates the Full Faith and Credit Clause. Current legal scholarship regarding the Full Faith and Credit Clause posits that the clause applies differently to public acts (statutes), records, and judicial proceedings.[21] Public acts or statutes and state records may not need to be as strictly enforced. (see Alaska Packers Association v. Industrial Accident Comm. (1935) 294 U.S. 532; Adar v. Smith (5th Cir. 2011) 639 F.3d 146.) However, the current jurisprudence seems to provide that determinative judicial proceedings should be enforced in another jurisdiction. The U.S. Supreme Court provides some guidance:
Our precedent differentiates the credit owed to laws (legislative measures and common law) and to judgments. “In numerous cases this Court has held that credit must be given to the judgment of another state although the forum would not be required to entertain the suit on which the judgment was founded.” The Full Faith and Credit Clause does not compel “a state to substitute the statutes of other states for its own statutes dealing with a subject matter concerning which it is competent to legislate.” Regarding judgments, however, the full faith and credit obligation is exacting. A final judgment in one State, if rendered by a court with adjudicatory authority over the subject matter and persons governed by the judgment, qualifies for recognition throughout the land. For claim and issue preclusion (res judicata) purposes, in other words, the judgment of the rendering State gains nationwide force.[22]
Writing in opposition, the Right to Life League argues:
On its face, the bill’s subsections (b), (c) and (d) impermissibly violate the U.S. Constitution. Subsection (b) unlawfully forbids magistrates from complying with valid court orders issued in foreign states. Subsection (c) strips state licensing of bail agents and bondsmen complying with valid court orders issued in foreign states. Subsection (d) creates a private cause of action designed to chill the enforcement of foreign states’ laws.
Like other unconstitutional laws AB 1666 and AB 2091, SB 36 usurps valid judicial power to unlawfully ignore other states’ laws. SB 36 blatantly violates the Full Faith and Credit Clause in Article 4 of the U.S. Constitution by instructing those tasked with enforcing foreign state law not to comply. SB 36 will thwart enforcement of foreign laws against abusers and human traffickers who flee to California to escape prosecution in other states, denying justice to their victims.
Passage of SB 36 will subject taxpayers to a lengthy and expensive judicial battle which California will ultimately lose.
However, case law calls into question whether the clause would require California to respect the criminal laws of another state in this way. In 1892, the Supreme Court was asked to evaluate whether a Maryland court’s refusal to uphold a New York judgment was correct when the Maryland court found that the New York cause of action was “intended as a punishment for doing any acts forbidden, and was, therefore…a penalty which could not be enforced.”[23] The Huntington court opted to examine the definition of “penal” in the “international sense” and harkened back to Chief Justice Marshall’s maxim, “the courts of no country execute the penal laws of another.” (The Antelope 10 Wheat 66, 123.) The Huntington court further explained that whether or not a law were considered penal, and thus could not be enforced in the court of another jurisdiction, “depends on the question whether its purpose is to punish an offense against the public justice of the state, or to afford a private remedy to a person injured by the wrongful act.”
The Supreme Court has continued to examine Full Faith and Credit Clause claims using the penal exception standard.[24] In one slightly more recent case, the Supreme Court was faced with whether California was required by the clause to enforce a North Carolina criminal judgment, it found: “Since the Full Faith and Credit Clause does not require that sister States enforce a foreign penal judgment, Huntington v. Attrill, 146 U.S. 657 (1892); cf. Milwaukee County v. M. E. White Co., 296 U.S. 268, 279 (1935), California is free to consider what effect, if any, it will give to the North Carolina detainer in terms of George’s present “custody.”[25]
It should be noted that in certain circumstances the Extradition Clause of the United States Constitution may be implicated: “A person charged in any State with Treason, Felony, or other Crime, who shall flee from Justice, and be found in another State, shall on Demand of the Executive Authority of the State from which he fled, be delivered up, to be removed to the State having Jurisdiction of the Crime.” [26]
SUPPORT
Coalition of California Welfare Rights Organizations (co-sponsor)
Equality California (co-sponsor)
NARAL Pro-Choice California (co-sponsor)
Western Center on Law and Poverty (co-sponsor)
Access Reproductive Justice
American Atheists
Anti-Recidivism Coalition
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California LGBTQ Health and Human Services Network
City of Berkeley
Desert Aids Project d/b/a Dap Health
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
End Child Poverty California
Essential Access Health
John Burton Advocates for Youth
National Council of Jewish Women CA
National Health Law Program
Oakland Privacy
Plan C
Sacramento LGBT Community Center
San Francisco Black, Jewish and Unity Group
The Translatin@ Coalition
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Health Care
Young Women’s Freedom Center
One individual
OPPOSITION
Concerned Women for America
Right to Life League
Two individuals
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 385 (Atkins, 2023) authorizes a physician assistant who has completed specified training and achieved clinical competency, as described, to perform abortions by aspirations techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, except as provided. SB 385 is currently pending in the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development.
SB 345 (Skinner, 2023), among other things, prohibits a licensing board from denying an application for licensure or suspending, revoking, or otherwise imposing discipline on a licensed person because they were disciplined or convicted of an offense in another state, if that disciplinary action was the result of providing a legally protected health care activity. SB 345 is currently pending in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
SB 487 (Atkins, 2023) providing protections for providers from other states’ laws that seek to restrict access to, or punish the provision of, health care services that are legal in California. SB 487 is currently in the Senate Rules Committee.
AB 571 (Petrie-Norris, 2023) prohibits an insurer from refusing to issue or renew or terminate professional liability insurance for health care providers and from imposing a surcharge or increasing the premium or deductible solely based on any prohibited bases for discrimination, including a health care provider offering or performing abortion, and prohibits an insurer from denying coverage for liability for damages arising from offering, performing, or rendering specified health care services. AB 571 is currently pending in the Assembly Committee on Insurance.
Prior Legislation:
SCA 10 (Atkins and Rendon, Ch. 87, Stats. 2022) expressly provided that the state shall not deny or interfere with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives, and states the measure is intended to further the right to privacy and the right to not be denied equal protection, as guaranteed by the California Constitution and that it does not narrow or limit the right to privacy or equal protection.
SB 107 (Wiener, Ch. 810, Stats. 2022) See Comment 4.
AB 1242 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 627, Stats. 2022) prohibits law enforcement from knowingly arresting a person for performing or aiding in the performance of a lawful abortion or for obtaining an abortion and prohibits specified entities from providing information to another state or political subdivision thereof regarding an abortion that is lawful under California law, except as provided.
AB 1666 (Bauer-Kahan, Ch. 42, Stats. 2022) prohibited the enforcement in this state of out-of-state laws authorizing a civil action against a person or entity that receives or seeks, performs or induces, or aids or abets the performance of an abortion, or who attempts or intends to engage in those actions and declares those out-of-state laws to be contrary to the public policy of this state.
AB 2091 (Mia Bonta, Ch. 628, Stats. 2022), among other things, prohibited compelling a person to identify or provide information that would identify an individual who has sought or obtained an abortion in a state, county, city, or other local criminal, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding if the information is being requested based on another state’s laws that interfere with a person’s right to choose or obtain an abortion or a foreign penal civil action.
AB 2223 (Wicks, Ch. 629, Stats. 2022), among other things, authorized a party aggrieved by a violation of the Reproductive Privacy Act to bring a civil action against an offending state actor, as specified, and provides that every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Public Safety Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 0)
**************
Although the right to travel is not expressly set forth in the Constitution, it has been recognized as emanating from both the Interstate Commerce Clause (e.g., Edwards v. People of State of California (1941) 314 U.S. 160, 174) and the Privileges and Immunities Clause (e.g., Saenz v. Roe (1999) 526 U.S. 501-502). ↑
Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health (2022) 597 U.S. _ (142 S.Ct. 2228) at p. 5, available at https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/21pdf/19-1392_6j37.pdf. ↑
See Miss. Code Ann. §41-41-191. ↑
Id. at 77. ↑
Rachel Benson Gold, Lessons from Before Roe: Will Past be Prologue, Guttmacher Institute (Mar. 1, 2003), available at https://www.guttmacher.org/gpr/2003/03/lessons-roe-will-past-be-prologue. ↑
Elizabeth Nash and Isabel Guarnieri, Six Months Post-Roe, 24 US States Have Banned Abortion or Are Likely to Do So: A Roundup, Guttmacher Institute (Jan. 10, 2023), available at https://www.guttmacher.org/2023/01/six-months-post-roe-24-us-states-have-banned-abortion-or-are-likely-do-so-roundup. ↑
Sharon Bernstein, Factbox: US. abortion restrictions mount after overturn of Roe v. Wade, Reuters, (Oct. 4, 2022), available at https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/us-abortion-restrictions-mount-after-overturn-roe-v-wade-2022-10-04/#:~:text=ACTIVE%20BANS,an%20abortion%20rights%20research%20group. ↑
Katie Shepherd, Rachel Roubein, and Caroline Kitchner, 1 in 3 American women have already lost abortion access. More restrictive laws are coming, The Washington Post, (Aug. 22, 2022), https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/08/22/more-trigger-bans-loom-1-3-women-lose-most-abortion-access-post-roe/. ↑
April Dembosky, As states ban abortion, Californians open their arms and wallets, NPR (June 27, 2022), available at https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/06/27/1103479722/as-states-ban-abortion-californians-open-their-arms-and-wallets. ↑
Dana Branham and Chris Casteel, Another anti-abortion law goes into effect in Oklahoma. Here’s what’s changing, The Oklahoman (Aud, 26, 2022), available at https://www.oklahoman.com/story/news/2022/08/26/oklahoma-senate-bill-612-another-anti-abortion-law-goes-into-effect/65419612007/. ↑
Alison Durkee, Idaho Enacts Law Copying Texas’ Abortion Ban – And These States Might Be Next, Forbes (Mar. 23, 2022) available at https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2022/03/23/idaho-enacts-law-copying-texas-abortion-ban---and-these-states-might-be-next/?sh=340dc49425c0. ↑
Christine Vestal, Some Abortion Bans Put Patients, Doctors at Risk in Emergencies, Pew Trusts (Sept. 1, 2022), available at https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/blogs/stateline/2022/09/01/some-abortion-bans-put-patients-doctors-at-risk-in-emergencies. ↑
California Proclamation on Reproductive Freedom (May 31, 2019) available at https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Proclamation-on-Reproductive-Freedom.pdf. ↑
Recommendations to Protect, Strengthen, and Expand Abortion Care in California, California Future of Abortion Council (Dec. 2021), available at https://www.cafabcouncil.org/_files/ugd/ddc900_0beac0c75cb54445a230168863566b55.pdf. ↑
Kristen Hwang, Newsom signs abortion protections into law, CalMatters (Sept. 27, 2022), available at https://calmatters.org/health/2022/09/california-abortion-bills/. ↑
December 2022 Addendum, California Future of Abortion Council (Dec. 2022), available at https://www.cafabcouncil.org/_files/ugd/ddc900_cb34dfb0c1154013a43642b9a95adfd6.pdf?index=true. ↑
Human Rights Watch, Press Release, ICYMI: As Lawmakers Escalate Attacks on Transgender Youth Across the Country, Some GOP Leaders Stand Up for Transgender Youth (Mar. 24, 2022), https://www.hrc.org/press-releases/icymi-as-lawmakers-escalate-attacks-on-transgender-youth-across-the-country-some-gop-leaders-stand-up-for-transgender-youth (all links current as of August 29, 2022). ↑
See Al. Code, § 26-26-4. ↑
Ark. Stats. §§ 20-9-1502 & 20-9-1504. ↑
Governor’s singing statement on Sen. Bill 107 (2021-22 Reg. Sess.), available at https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/SB-107-SIGNING.pdf?emrc=1a80c5. ↑
Redpath, Between Judgment and Law: Full Faith and Credit, Public Policy, and State Records (2013) 62 Emory L.J. 639. ↑
Baker v. GMC (1998) 522 U.S. 222, 232-33 (internal citations omitted). ↑
Huntington v Attrill (1892) 146 U.S. 657. ↑
See Milwaukee County v. M. E. White Company (1935) 296 U.S. 268. ↑
Nelson v. George (1970) 399 U.S. 224, 229. ↑
U.S. Const., art. IV, § 2, cl. 2. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 36 Hearing Date: March 14, 2023
Author: | Skinner | ||
Version: | February 14, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Out-of-state criminal charges: prosecution related to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care
HISTORY
Source: Black Women for Wellness
Coalition of California Welfare Rights Organizations
Equality CA
NARAL Pro-Choice California
VALOR
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Prior Legislation: SB 107 (Wiener), Ch. 810, Stats. 2022
AB 1242 (Bauer-Kahan), Ch. 627, Stats. 2022
AB 2043 (Jones-Sawyer), Ch. 768, Stats. 2022
AB 2029 (Ammiano), Ch. 747, Stats. 2012
Support: Access Reproductive Justice; American Atheists; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Public Defenders Association; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; John Burton Advocates for Youth; Oakland Privacy; Young Women’s Freedom Center
Opposition: Concerned Women for America; Right to Life League
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to:
- Prohibit a magistrate from issuing a warrant for the arrest of a bail fugitive whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of another state’s laws that criminalize abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care that is otherwise lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the individual’s location;
- State that it is a misdemeanor for a bail fugitive recovery agent or bail bondsman to take into custody a bail fugitive whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of another state’s laws that criminalize abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care that is otherwise lawful under the laws of this state and makes them ineligible for a license to operate in California;
- Prohibit a state or local law enforcement agency from providing information or assistance to specified entities regarding legally protected health care activity, which includes abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care that is otherwise lawful under the laws of this state; and,
- State that a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, for the above-described acts, is not ineligible for the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) program, regardless of the recipient’s location.
Existing law establishes the Reproductive Privacy Act which provides that the Legislature finds and declares that every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care. Accordingly, it is the public policy of the State of California that:
- Every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control;
- Every individual has the fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion, with specified limited exceptions; and,
- The state shall not deny or interfere with a person’s fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion, except as specifically permitted. (Health & Saf. Code § 123462.)
Existing law provides that the state may not deny or interfere with a person’s right to choose or obtain an abortion prior to viability of the fetus or when the abortion is necessary to protect the life or health of the person. (Health & Safe. Code § 123466, subd. (a).)
Existing law states that a person shall not be compelled in a state, county, city, or other local criminal, administrative, legislative, or other proceeding to identify or provide information that would identify or that is related to an individual who has sought or obtained an abortion if the information is being requested based on either another state’s laws that interfere with a person’s rights under subdivision (a) or a foreign penal civil action. (Health & Saf. Code, §123466, subd. (b).)
Existing law prohibits, under the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA), providers of health care, health care service plans, or contractors, as defined, from sharing medical information without the patient’s written authorization, subject to certain exceptions. (Civ. Code § 56 et seq.)
Existing law authorizes a magistrate to issue an arrest warrant, upon application by a bail bondsman, for a person who has been admitted to bail in another state, escapes bail, and is present in this State and after a hearing, issue an order to return the fugitive to the jurisdiction from which they escaped. (Pen. Code, § 847.5.)
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor for a bail bondsman to take a fugitive into custody without a warrant from a magistrate. (Pen. Code, § 847.5.)
This bill prohibits a magistrate from issuing an arrest warrant for an individual whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that criminalizes an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location.
This bill states that a bondsman or person authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state who takes into custody a fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location, without a magistrate’s order, is ineligible for a license to be a bail fugitive recovery agent and shall forfeit any license already obtained.
This bill authorizes a person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of this bill’s provisions to institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bondman and bond company within three years after the cause of action accrues.
Existing law, starting July 1, 2023, states that no person, other than a certified law enforcement officer, shall be authorized to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive unless that person meets one of the following conditions:
- Is a bail as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1299.01 who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined;
- Is a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined; or,
- Is a licensed private investigator who is also a bail fugitive recovery agent as defined. (Pen. Code 1299.02, subd. (a).)
Existing law defines a “bail fugitive” as a defendant in a pending criminal case who has been released from custody under a financially secured appearance, cash, or other bond and has had than bond declared forfeited, or a defendant in a pending criminal case who has violated a bond condition whereby apprehension and reincarceration are permitted. (Pen. Code, § 1299.01, subd. (a).)
Existing law defines a “bail fugitive recovery person” as a person provided written authorization by the bail or depositor of bail, and is contracted to investigate, surveil, locate, and arrest a bail fugitive for surrender to the appropriate court, jail, or police department, and any person who is employed to assist a bail or depositor of bail to investigate, surveil, locate, and arrest a bail fugitive for surrender to the appropriate court, jail, or police department. (Pen. Code, § 1299.01, subd. (d).)
This bill makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of $5000 and imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, for a bail fugitive recovery agent to apprehend, detain, or arrest a bail fugitive admitted to bail in another state whose alleged offense or conviction was for the violation of laws of another state that criminalizes an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care that is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location.
This bill provides that a person who violates the above provision is ineligible for a bail fugitive recovery agent license and shall forfeit any license already obtained.
This bill authorizes a person who is taken into custody by a bail agent in violation of the above provision to institute and prosecute a civil action for injunctive, monetary, or other appropriate relief against the bail fugitive recovery agent within three years after the cause of action accrues.
This bill states that notwithstanding any other law and except as required by federal law, an officer or employee of a law enforcement agency of a state or local law enforcement agency, shall not, while acting in their official capacity, provide information or assistance relating to an investigation or inquiry into services constituting legally protected health care activity, including but not limited to, abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, if such services would be lawful if they were provided entirely in this state to any of the following:
- A federal law enforcement agency;
- A state law enforcement agency;
- A private citizen; or.
- A bondsman or person authorized as a bail fugitive recovery agent to apprehend, detain, or arrest a fugitive admitted to bail in another state.
Existing law establishes the CalWORKs program under which each county provides cash assistance and other benefits to qualified low-income families and individuals. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 11200 et seq.)
Existing law makes certain individuals ineligible for the CalWORKs program including a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, for a crime or an attempt to commit a crime that is a felony under the laws of the place from which the individual is fleeing, or which, in the case of the State of New Jersey, is a high misdemeanor under the laws of that state. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 11486.5, subd. (a).)
This bill specifies that for purposes of the above provision on CalWORKs ineligibility, an individual is not considered fleeing to avoid prosecution if the felony offense with which the person is charged or convicted is as a result of performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location.
Existing law establishes CalFresh whereby recipients of aid and other low-income households to receive benefits under the federal Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP). (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 18900 et seq.)
This bill provides that a person who is fleeing to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of laws of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is eligible for CalFresh benefits, if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location.
This bill contains the following Legislative findings and declarations:
- In 2022, following the United States Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, California’s legislature passed and Governor Gavin Newsom signed a package of bills, led by members of the Legislative Women’s Caucus, and complimentary budget actions that established the state as a haven for those fleeing prosecution for seeking abortion and gender-affirming care in other states.
- Many states have now passed laws that make seeking or providing an abortion a felony offense.
- Many states have also enacted laws or regulations banning gender-affirming care and 15 additional states are considering legislation to do so.
- It is the intent of the legislature to pass legislation to provide protections and supports to any person fleeing a prosecution, conviction, or sentence in another state for seeking an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or seeking gender-affirming care and to any person assisting the person seeking that care.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author of this bill:
Last year the Legislature, Governor Newsom, and California voters took bold action, guaranteeing the right to an abortion and gender-affirming care. But a growing number of states have done the opposite, putting residents who seek essential health care at risk of being prosecuted. My ‘Safe Haven’ bill will ensure that those who come to California fleeing persecution by other states will be free from the worry that a bounty hunter could snatch them up and send them back.
- Reproductive Rights in California
Roe v. Wade, (1973) 410 U.S. 113 (overruled by Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health (2022) 142 S. Ct. 2228), was the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that held that the implied constitutional right to privacy extends to a person’s decision whether to terminate a pregnancy. Specifically, the Court found for the first time that the constitutional right to privacy is “broad enough to encompass a woman’s decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy.” Roe had been one of the most debated Supreme Court decisions, and its application and validity continued to be challenged time and again. For example, in Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey (1992) 505 U.S. 833, the Court reaffirmed the basic holding of Roe, yet also permitted states to impose restrictions on abortion as long as those restrictions do not create an undue burden on a person’s right to choose to terminate a pregnancy.
Last year, in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health, supra, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade holding that, contrary to 50 years of precedent, there is no fundamental constitutional right to have an abortion. (Dobbs, 142 S. Ct. at 2242.) The majority opinion further provided that states should be allowed to decide how to regulate abortion and that a strong presumption of validity should be afforded to those state laws. (Id. at 2283-2284.)
In California, before Roe v. Wade was decided by the U.S. Supreme Court, the California Supreme Court held in 1969 that the state constitution’s express right to privacy extends to an individual’s decision about whether or not to have an abortion. (People v. Belous (1969) 71 Cal.2d 954.) Existing California statutory law provides, under the Reproductive Privacy Act, that the Legislature finds and declares every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions; therefore, it is the public policy of the State of California that every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control and the right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion. (Health & Safe. Code § 123462, subds. (a)-(b).) The Act further provides that it is the public policy of the state that the state shall not deny or interfere with a person’s fundamental right to choose or obtain an abortion prior to viability of the fetus or when the abortion is necessary to protect the life or health of the pregnant person. (Health & Saf. Code, § 123466.)
In the 2022 general election, California voters approved Proposition 1 to amend the state constitution to guarantee the right to abortion and contraception. This ballot measure was approved by 66.9 percent of voters. (Secretary of State, November 8, 2022 General Election State Ballot Measures by County <https://elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/sov/2022-general/sov/props.pdf> [as of Mar. 6, 2023].)
Last year, several bills were enacted to further protect reproductive rights in California. AB 1242 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 627, Statutes of 2022, protects reproductive digital information handled by companies incorporated or headquartered in California and prevents the arrest of individuals or the disclosure by law enforcement of information in an investigation related to any abortion that is legal in California. AB 1666 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 42, Statutes of 2022, declares that a law of another state that authorizes a person to bring a civil action against a person or entity that receives or seeks, performs or induces, or aids or abets the performance of an abortion, or who attempts or intends to engage in those actions, is contrary to the public policy of this state. AB 2091 (Bonta), Chapter 628, Statutes of 2022, prohibits a provider of health care, health care service plan, or contractor from releasing medical information related to an individual seeking or obtaining an abortion in response to a subpoena or request if that subpoena or request is based on either another state's laws that interfere with a person's rights set forth in the Reproductive Privacy Act and prohibits the issuance of a subpoena, from the Superior Court or an attorney licensed in California, based on a civil action authorized by the law of a state other than this state in which the sole purpose is to punish an offense against the public justice of that state. AB 2223 (Wicks), Chapter 629, Statutes of 2022 prohibits a person from being criminally or civilly liable for miscarriage, stillbirth, abortion, or perinatal death due to causes that occurred in utero.
This bill builds upon California’s existing protections for reproductive rights by prohibiting law enforcement from providing information or assistance to specified entities regarding services constituting legally protected health care activity, including but not limited to, abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care, if those services would be lawful if they were provided within this state. This bill also prohibits the issuance of an arrest warrant for an individual admitted to bail in another state and escapes bail if the alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of another state’s law that criminalizes an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if such care is lawful in California. The bill also prohibits a bail bondsman or bounty hunter from arresting and taking into custody a bail fugitive whose violation or conviction is for one of these acts. A violation of this prohibition would be punishable as a misdemeanor and the person violating the law would not be eligible for a license to operate in California. Additionally, the individual who is taken into custody in violation of this law would be able to pursue a civil action against the bail bondsman or bounty hunter.
This bill would also remove potential barriers to receive public benefits under CalWORKs and CalFresh based on the individual fleeing prosecution or confinement after conviction for an offense related to performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if that care is lawful under California’s laws.
- Gender-Affirming Health Care Protections in California
Last year, in response to a series of laws and executive orders adopted in other states that impose civil and/or criminal liability on transgender youth, their parents and medical providers who assist them in obtaining gender-affirming care, California enacted protections for such individuals obtaining care in this state. The new law, among other things, prohibits the sharing of medical records regarding the receipt of gender-affirming care; the enforcement of out-of-state subpoenas seeking information regarding the receipt of gender-affirming medical care in California; and the enforcement of laws of another state that authorize the removal of a child from their parent or guardian and enforcement of out-of-state criminal laws related to gender-affirming health care. (SB 107 (Wiener), Chapter 810, Statutes of 2022.)
This bill provides additional protections for individuals receiving gender-affirming health care in California by prohibiting a judge from issuing a warrant to arrest a bail fugitive whose offense is based on another state’s laws that criminalize gender-affirming health care and prohibiting a bail fugitive recovery person and bail bondsman from taking such individuals into custody. This bill also prohibits local law enforcement agencies from sharing information about such individuals with specified entities, including federal law enforcement and bail bondsmen.
- Bail Fugitive Recovery Persons
Bail fugitive recovery persons, also known as bounty hunters, are persons who are hired to locate and apprehend bail fugitives for surrender to the appropriate court, jail, or police department. Existing law places specified requirements on bail fugitive recovery agents, including that the person must be at least 18 years of age, complete 20 hours of classroom education pertinent to the duties and responsibilities of a bail licensee, complete a 40-hour power of arrest course certified by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, and not have been convicted of a felony, except as specified. Bail fugitive recovery persons are also required to carry certificates of completion of the mandatory training programs with them at all times in the course of performing their duties.
Starting July 1, 2023, bail fugitive recovery persons must obtain a license through the Department of Insurance in order to operate in California and will be required to maintain a policy of liability insurance that provides minimum limits of insurance of $1,000,000 for any one loss or occurrence due to either bodily injury or death, or property damage, or both.
This bill would prohibit a bail fugitive recovery person from apprehending, detaining, or arresting a bail fugitive who has been admitted to bail in another state and whose alleged offense or conviction is for the violation of a law of another state that authorizes a criminal penalty to an individual performing, receiving, supporting, or aiding in the performance or receipt of abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care, if the abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care is lawful under the laws of this state, regardless of the recipient’s location. The bill would make a violation of this provision a misdemeanor and make the individual ineligible for and subject to forfeiture of a license received through Department of Insurance. Furthermore, an individual taken into custody in violation of these provisions would be able to pursue a civil action against the bail fugitive recovery agent within three years after the cause of action accrues.
- CalWORKs and CalFresh
CalWORKs is a public assistance program that offers temporary cash aid assistance, nutrition benefits, employment services and health insurance to eligible families who have children under the age of 18. The program is operated locally by county welfare departments. If a person is eligible for CalWORKs, they are eligible for Medi-Cal and may also qualify for CalFresh food benefits. The amount of a family's monthly assistance payment depends on a number of factors, including the number of people who are eligible and the special needs of any of those family members. The income of the family is considered in calculating the amount of cash aid the family receives.
CalFresh provides monthly food benefits for individuals and families with low-income. According to the CalFresh Program website:
CalFresh benefits can help buy nutritious foods for a better diet. CalFresh benefits stretch food budgets, allowing individuals and families to afford nutritious food, including more fruit, vegetables and other healthy foods. The amount of benefits a household receives is dependent on household size countable income, and monthly expenses, such as housing and utilities. The program issues monthly benefits on an Electronic Benefit Transfer (EBT) card. Food may be purchased at any grocery store or farmers market that accepts EBT cards.
(See CalFresh Program, California Department of Social Services Programs <https://www.cdss.ca.gov/inforesources/calfresh> [as of Mar. 6, 2023].)
Existing law makes ineligible for CalWORKs benefits an individual who is fleeing another state to avoid prosecution, or custody and confinement after conviction, for a crime that is a felony under the laws of that state. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §11486.5.)
This bill states that for purposes of this exclusion, an individual is not considered feeling to avoid prosecution if the felony offense is the result of performing or receiving an abortion, contraception, reproductive care, or gender-affirming care if the care is lawful under the laws of California, regardless of the recipient’s location. This bill also specifies that the person is eligible for CalFresh benefits, regardless of the recipient’s location.
The addition of the words, “…regardless of the recipient’s location” would seem to mean that a person may receive these benefits regardless of where they currently reside, i.e. a location outside of California. The author has indicated that this is not the intent of this provision, thus, this language should either be clarified or deleted.
- Full Faith and Credit Clause
Generally, the laws of the state regulate conduct that occurs within that state. However, situations may arise where more than one state’s laws may apply such as collection of previously-owed income taxes or child support obligations from another state. Or one state has jurisdiction to criminally prosecute an offense because someone has fled the state or committed part of the crime in the prosecuting state. Under the United States Constitution, states are required to provide full faith and credit to “to the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state. (U.S. Const. art. IV, sec. 1.)”
The Full Faith and Credit Clause may be implicated when there is a conflict between the laws of the different states. At least one court has held that any effort by a state to apply its criminal laws beyond its state borders to criminalize activity that is otherwise lawful in the other state. (Bigelow v. Virginia (1975) 421 U.S. 809.) However, the Supreme Court has also held that even when criminal conduct takes place outside of the state, extraterritorial jurisdiction may be proper when the conduct was intended to produce or did produce harmful effects within the state. (Strassheim v. Daily (1911) 221 U.S. 280.)
The Supreme Court has also made a distinction between the strength of the Full Faith and Credit Clause’s applications to judgements versus state law. “The Full Faith and Credit Clause does not compel ‘a state to substitute the statutes of other states for its own statutes dealing with a subject matter concerning which it is competent to legislate. Regarding judgments, however, the full faith and credit obligation is exacting. A final judgment in one State, if rendered by a court with adjudicatory authority over the subject matter and persons governed by the judgment, qualifies for recognition throughout the land.’” (Baker v. General Motors Co., supra, 522 U.S. at 232-233.) This concept is often referred to as the “public policy exception” meaning statutes in on states is given effect only if they do not contravene the public policy of the other state.
By refusing to recognize the laws of another state, this bill appears to implicate the Full Faith and Credit Clause. California has declared that such laws that criminalize abortion, contraceptives and gender-affirming health care are against the public policy of this state and shall not be enforced in a court in this state. Thus, a challenge based on a violation of the Full Faith and Credit Clause would likely be met with a response that the public policy exception applies. Whether such exception applies is ultimately up to the courts.
- Argument in Support
According to Equality California, a co-sponsor of this bill:
Following the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Dobbs v. Jackson, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed a package of bills making California a sanctuary state for abortion services and gender-affirming care. In addition, in the November election, California voters enacted a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to abortion and contraception. Meanwhile, a growing number of states have been passing laws putting residents who seek essential gender-affirming care and reproductive health care services at risk of being prosecuted. States are attempting to classify the provision of gender-affirming health care as a crime warranting prison time and are threatening parents with criminal penalties if they attempt to travel to another state in order to secure life-saving gender-affirming care for their child. While attacks on the transgender community are not new, we are experiencing alarmingly blatant attempts to use legislation, policy, and political rhetoric to restrict or eliminate the autonomy, freedom, and existence of transgender people across the country.
SB 36 builds on California landmark protections further protecting people who have been charged or convicted in another state as a result of the criminalization of abortion or gender-affirming health care that is fully legal in California.
- Argument in Opposition
According to the Right to Life League:
The U.S. Constitution is the supreme law of our land. Thanks to the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in Dobbs, states regulate abortion. Dobbs did not change the applicability of the Full Faith and Credit Clause in Article 4. California may proclaim itself an “Abortion Sanctuary”; however, California may not thwart the laws of other states to suit its radical pro-abortion agenda.
. . . .
On its face, the bill’s subsections (b), (c) and (d) impermissibly violate the U.S. Constitution. Subsection (b) unlawfully forbids magistrates from complying with valid court orders issued in foreign states. Subsection (c) strips state licensing of bail agents and bondsmen complying with valid court orders issued in foreign states. Subsection (d) creates a private cause of action designed to chill the enforcement of foreign states’ laws. Like other unconstitutional laws AB 1666 and AB 2091, SB 36 usurps valid judicial power to unlawfully ignore other states’ laws. SB 36 blatantly violates the Full Faith and Credit Clause in Article 4 of the U.S. Constitution by instructing those tasked with enforcing foreign state law not to comply. SB 36 will thwart enforcement of foreign laws against abusers and human traffickers who flee to California to escape prosecution in other states, denying justice to their victims.
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):