SB 385: Physician Assistant Practice Act: abortion by aspiration: training.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-09-08
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-09-08: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 178, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Physician Assistant Practice Act establishes the Physician Assistant Board to license and regulate physician assistants. Existing law makes it a crime to perform an abortion without holding a license to practice as a physician and surgeon or without holding a specified license or certificate under the Physician Assistant Practice Act that authorizes the holder to perform specified functions necessary for an abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy. The act requires a physician assistant to complete training and comply with certain protocols, as specified, to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
This bill would revise the training requirements to instead require a physician assistant to achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training, as described, in performing an abortion by aspiration techniques. The bill would set forth what types of training qualify. The bill would remove the requirement that a physician assistant follow certain protocols to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
This bill would authorize a physician assistant who has completed the training and achieved clinical competency, as described, to perform abortions by aspirations techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, except as provided. The bill would require a physician assistant to practice abortion by aspiration techniques consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement. The bill would provide that specified persons authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a physician assistant, as described. The bill would make other technical changes.
The Physician Assistant Practice Act establishes the Physician Assistant Board to license and regulate physician assistants. Existing law makes it a crime to perform an abortion without holding a license to practice as a physician and surgeon or without holding a specified license or certificate under the Physician Assistant Practice Act that authorizes the holder to perform specified functions necessary for an abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy. The act requires a physician assistant to complete training and comply with certain protocols, as specified, to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
This bill would revise the training requirements to instead require a physician assistant to achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training, as described, in performing an abortion by aspiration techniques. The bill would set forth what types of training qualify. The bill would remove the requirement that a physician assistant follow certain protocols to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
This bill would authorize a physician assistant who has completed the training and achieved clinical competency, as described, to perform abortions by aspirations techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, except as provided. The bill would require a physician assistant to practice abortion by aspiration techniques consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement. The bill would provide that specified persons authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a physician assistant, as described. The bill would make other technical changes.
The Physician Assistant Practice Act establishes the Physician Assistant Board to license and regulate physician assistants. Existing law makes it a crime to perform an abortion without holding a license to practice as a physician and surgeon or holding a specified license or certificate under the Physician Assistant Practice Act that authorizes the holder to perform specified functions necessary for an abortion. The act requires a physician assistant to complete training and comply with certain protocols, as specified, to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
This bill would revise the training requirements to instead require a physician assistant to achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training, as described, in performing an abortion by aspiration techniques. The bill would set forth what types of training qualify. The bill would remove the requirement that a physician assistant follow certain protocols to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
This bill would authorize a physician assistant who has completed the training and achieved clinical competency, as described, to perform abortions by aspirations techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, except as provided. The bill would require a physician assistant to practice abortion by aspiration techniques consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement. The bill would provide that specified persons authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a physician assistant, as described. The bill would make other technical changes.
(a)In order to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253, a physician assistant shall achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training in performing these procedures. The requisite training shall include a clinical and didactic component and be provided by any of the following:
(1)Training programs approved by the board pursuant to Section 3513.
(2)Training to perform medical services that augment the physician assistants current areas of competency pursuant to Section 1399.543 of Title 16 of the California Code of Regulations.
(3)A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
(4)Training based on the competency-based training protocols established by the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the Department of Health Care Access and Information.
(5)Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortion by aspiration techniques that is provided by any of the following who have performed the procedure themselves:
(A)A physician and surgeon.
(B)A nurse practitioner or certified nurse midwife authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2725.4.
(C)A physician assistant authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to this section.
(b)A physician assistant who has completed training and achieved clinical competency, as required by this section, and is functioning pursuant to Section 3502 shall be authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon unless specified by their practice agreement.
(c)A physician assistant shall practice abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
(d)It is unprofessional conduct for any physician assistant to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 without prior completion of training and validation of clinical competency.
(e)A person authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a physician assistant pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a).
(f)This section shall not be interpreted to authorize a person with a license or certificate to practice as a physician assistant to perform abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
(g)For purposes of this section, exclusively online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care shall not meet the clinical training requirements in subdivision (a).
SEC. 2.Section 3527.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:3527.5.(a)The board shall not suspend or revoke the license of a physician assistant solely for performing an abortion if the licensee performed the abortion in accordance with the provisions of this chapter and the Reproductive Privacy Act (Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 123460) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 106 of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 141, 480, 490, and 3527, the board shall not deny an application for licensure as a physician assistant, or suspend, revoke, or otherwise impose discipline upon a person licensed in this state as a physician assistant under either of the following circumstances:
(1)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was disciplined in that state solely for performing an abortion in that state.
(2)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was convicted in that state for an offense related solely to the performance of an abortion in that state.
(a)In order to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253, a physician assistant shall achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training in performing these procedures. The requisite training shall include a clinical and didactic component and be provided by any of the following:
(1)Training programs approved by the board pursuant to Section 3513.
(2)Training to perform medical services that augment the physician assistants current areas of competency pursuant to Section 1399.543 of Title 16 of the California Code of Regulations.
(3)A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
(4)Training based on the competency-based training protocols established by the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the Department of Health Care Access and Information.
(5)Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortion by aspiration techniques that is provided by any of the following who have performed the procedure themselves:
(A)A physician and surgeon.
(B)A nurse practitioner or certified nurse midwife authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2725.4.
(C)A physician assistant authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to this section.
(b)A physician assistant who has completed training and achieved clinical competency, as required by this section, and is functioning pursuant to Section 3502 shall be authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon unless specified by their practice agreement.
(c)A physician assistant shall practice abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
(d)It is unprofessional conduct for any physician assistant to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 without prior completion of training and validation of clinical competency.
(e)A person authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a physician assistant pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a).
(f)This section shall not be interpreted to authorize a person with a license or certificate to practice as a physician assistant to perform abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
(g)For purposes of this section, exclusively online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care shall not meet the clinical training requirements in subdivision (a).
SEC. 2.Section 3527.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:3527.5.(a)The board shall not suspend or revoke the license of a physician assistant solely for performing an abortion if the licensee performed the abortion in accordance with the provisions of this chapter and the Reproductive Privacy Act (Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 123460) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 106 of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 141, 480, 490, and 3527, the board shall not deny an application for licensure as a physician assistant, or suspend, revoke, or otherwise impose discipline upon a person licensed in this state as a physician assistant under either of the following circumstances:
(1)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was disciplined in that state solely for performing an abortion in that state.
(2)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was convicted in that state for an offense related solely to the performance of an abortion in that state.
(a)In order to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253, a physician assistant shall complete training either through training achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training in performing these procedures. The requisite training shall include a clinical and didactic component and be provided by any of the following:
(1)Training programs approved by the board pursuant to Section 3513 or by training 3513.
(2)Training to perform medical services that augment the physician assistants current areas of competency pursuant to Section 1399.543 of Title 16 of the California Code of Regulations. Beginning January 1, 2014, and until January 1, 2016, the training and clinical competency protocols established by Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Department of Health Care Access and Information shall be used as training and clinical competency guidelines to meet this requirement.
(b)In order to receive authority from the physician assistants supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253, a physician assistant shall comply with protocols developed in compliance with Section 3502 that specify:(1)The extent of supervision by a physician and surgeon with relevant training and expertise.(2)Procedures for transferring patients to the care of the physician and surgeon or a hospital.(3)Procedures for obtaining assistance and consultation from a physician and surgeon.(4)Procedures for providing emergency care until physician assistance and consultation are available.(5)The method of periodic review of the provisions of the protocols.(3)A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
(4)Training based on the competency-based training protocols established by the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the Department of Health Care Access and Information.
(5)Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortion by aspiration techniques that is provided by any of the following who have performed the procedure themselves:
(A)A physician and surgeon.
(B)A nurse practitioner or certified nurse midwife authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2725.4.
(C)A physician assistant authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to this section.
(c)The training protocols established by HWPP No. 171 shall be deemed to meet the standards of the board. A(b)A physician assistant who has completed training and achieved clinical competency through HWPP No. 171 competency, as required by this section, and is functioning pursuant to Section 3502 shall be authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253, in adherence to protocols described in subdivision (b). 2253 without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon unless specified by their practice agreement.
(c)A physician assistant shall practice abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
(d)It is unprofessional conduct for any physician assistant to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques pursuant to Section 2253 without prior completion of training and validation of clinical competency.
(e)The board shall not suspend or revoke the license of a physician assistant solely for performing an abortion if the licensee performed the abortion in accordance with the provisions of this chapter and the Reproductive Privacy Act (Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 123460) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 106 of the Health and Safety Code).(f)Notwithstanding any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 141, 480, 490, and 3527, the board shall not deny an application for licensure as a physician assistant, or suspend, revoke, or otherwise impose discipline upon a person licensed in this state as a physician assistant under either of the following circumstances:(1)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was disciplined in that state solely for performing an abortion in that state.(2)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was convicted in that state for an offense related solely to the performance of an abortion in that state.(e)A person authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a physician assistant pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a).
(f)This section shall not be interpreted to authorize a person with a license or certificate to practice as a physician assistant to perform abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
(g)For purposes of this section, exclusively online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care shall not meet the clinical training requirements in subdivision (a).
SEC. 2.Section 3527.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:3527.5.(a)The board shall not suspend or revoke the license of a physician assistant solely for performing an abortion if the licensee performed the abortion in accordance with the provisions of this chapter and the Reproductive Privacy Act (Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 123460) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 106 of the Health and Safety Code).
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, including, but not limited to, Sections 141, 480, 490, and 3527, the board shall not deny an application for licensure as a physician assistant, or suspend, revoke, or otherwise impose discipline upon a person licensed in this state as a physician assistant under either of the following circumstances:
(1)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was disciplined in that state solely for performing an abortion in that state.
(2)The person is licensed or certified to practice as a physician assistant in another state and was convicted in that state for an offense related solely to the performance of an abortion in that state.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 8, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 178, Statutes of 2023. |
| Sep 8, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 30, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 24, 2023 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 24, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 58. Noes 15. Page 2798.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 17, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 16, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (August 16). |
| Jun 27, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (June 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 13. Noes 4.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 18, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on B. & P. and JUD. |
| May 8, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 8, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 28. Noes 8. Page 1023.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 2, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 1, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Apr 21, 2023 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 2. Page 799.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | Set for hearing April 18. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 10. Noes 3. Page 636.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 6, 2023 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Feb 22, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on B., P. & E. D. and JUD. |
| Feb 10, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 12. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 24, 2023 | SB 385 Atkins Senate Third Reading By Stephanie Nguyen | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB385 Atkins | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| American Association Of University Women - California | ** Support | |
| American College Of Obstetricians And Gynecologists District Ix | ** Support | |
| Attorney General Rob Bonta | ** Support | |
| California Academy Of Family Physicians | ** Support | |
| California Academy of PAs | ** Support | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Against | |
| California Family Council | ** Against | |
| California Legislative Women's Caucus | ** Support | |
| California Nurse Midwives Association | ** Support | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Support | |
| Indivisible Ca Statestrong | ** Support | |
| NARAL Pro-Choice California | ** Support | |
| Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis | ** Support | |
| Physician Assistant Board | ** Against | |
| The Physician’s Assistant Board | ** Against | |
| The Right to Life League | ** Against | |
| University of California | ** Support |
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 385
Author:(Atkins)
As Introduced Ver:February 9, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the training options for physician assistants (PAs) seeking to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
Major Provisions
- Clarifies that training for PAs to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques must include a didactic and clinical component.
- Expands the abortion by aspiration technique training options for PAs to include:
- A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
- Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortions by aspiration techniques provided by any of the following who have performed the procedure themselves:
- A nurse practitioner or certified nurse-midwife authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- A PA authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- Clarifies that a trained PA may perform an abortion by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician unless specified in their practice agreement.
- Clarifies that a PA performing an abortion by aspiration must do so consistent with the standard of care and within the scope of their practice agreement.
- Clarifies that a person authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques may not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege, for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA.
- Clarifies that the provisions of this bill do not authorize a PA to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
- Specifies that online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care do not meet the clinical training requirements.
- Makes other technical changes.
COMMENTS
Background. PAs are healthcare providers that can provide a wide range of medical services under the supervision of a physician when authorized by a supervising physician under a document known as a practice agreement. The practice agreement outlines what a PA may or may not do based on the PA's competence and the level of physician supervision required.
Abortion by Aspiration Techniques. Abortion by aspiration techniques, or vacuum aspiration, is a common method for first-trimester abortions. It involves inserting a flexible tube into the cervical opening of the uterus and using suction to remove fetal tissue. The risk of complications, particularly those requiring medical intervention, is very low (depending on the study, around <5% for minor complications and <0.6% for more serious complications). Where complications requiring interventions do occur, the patient is referred out for appropriate care.
PA Training Options. Existing law authorizes PAs to perform abortions by aspiration technique if they meet specified training and supervision requirements. Some of those training requirements were established as part of the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 under the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the California Department of Health Care Access and Information.
As part of the HWPP No. 171 study (2007-2013), University of California, San Francisco, Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health researchers utilized a standardized, competency-based curriculum and training plan for the education of primary care clinicians in early abortion care. That curriculum is one option for PAs to obtain training to perform an abortion by aspiration and was adopted as the training method for nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives by the BRN.
However, the California Future of Abortion Council, which was established in 2021 and comprised of reproductive freedom and sexual and reproductive health care allies, partners, and leaders, recently reviewed the curriculum and found that it may be overly rigid. The council released a blueprint outlining several policy recommendations to protect, strengthen, and expand access to abortion care. Among those recommendations was that policymakers should review competency requirements for abortion training for nurse practitioners, certified nurse-midwives, and PAs under the HWPP No. 171 and ensure requirements are aligned with other medical procedures with a similar safety record.
This bill seeks to incorporate that recommendation by providing two additional training options for PAs, training offered by healthcare organizations and direct training by a nurse practitioner, certified nurse-midwife, or another PA. The changes are consistent with recent updates to the training options available to nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives.
According to the Author
"[This bill] would expand and modernize reproductive care training options for physician assistants. This bill builds off the success of AB 154[(Atkins), Chapter 662, Statutes of 2013], which authorized advanced practice clinicians to provide abortion care, and SB 1375 [(Atkins), Chapter 631, Statutes of 2022] which streamlined abortion training standards for nurse practitioners and certified nurse midwives. Current abortion training requirements have presented barriers to providers seeking to provide reproductive care due to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. [This bill] will address these barriers by better aligning abortion training to physician assistant scope of practice and provide multiple options for physician assistants to get trained in abortion care, including Physician Assistant Board approved courses and programs, courses offered by state or national health care professional or accreditation organizations, or training in clinics and hospitals."
Arguments in Support
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecology (ACOG) District IX writes in support:
In the months since the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. The decision has opened the door for states to ban and criminalize abortion services – impacting patients and providers across the U.S. Currently, 18 states have enacted a ban on abortion services or have severely restricted access to abortion.
In California, ACOG District IX is committed to mitigating the fallout of the Dobb's decision, working with our partners to find ways to accommodate patients seeking care from outside our borders to the best of our ability and capacity. As California prepares for more patients seeking abortion services and reproductive health care in our state, we must ensure the state has an ample supply of appropriately trained abortion providers qualified to provide that care. [This bill] helps in this effort by building on existing law, expanding the trained pool of qualified non-physician providers to meet this demand during the first trimester.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Catholic Conference and the Right to Life League oppose this bill because they generally oppose decreased physician oversight of abortions and increased access to abortions.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, no costs to the Physician Assistant Board.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 28-8-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alvarado-Gil, Hurtado, Min, Roth
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 13-4-2
YES: Berman, Alvarez, Bains, Bonta, Grayson, Irwin, Jackson, Lee, Lowenthal, McCarty, McKinnor, Stephanie Nguyen, Ting
NO: Flora, Chen, Dixon, Joe Patterson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Gipson
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-1
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Lee
NO: Dixon, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Essayli
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-4-0
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Soria, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: February 9, 2023
CONSULTANT: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0001256
Date of Hearing: August 16, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 385
Author:(Atkins) – As Introduced Ver:February 9, 2023
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 13 - 4 |
Judiciary | 8 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill revises the training requirements for a physician assistant (PA) to achieve clinical competence for performing an abortion by aspiration and authorizes a PA to perform such an abortion without the presence of a supervising physician.
Specifically, this bill:
- Expands training options for a PA to learn how to perform an abortion by aspiration to include:
- A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
- Training and evaluation of clinical competency provided by any of the following, if they have performed the procedure themselves:
- A nurse practitioner or certified nurse-midwife authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- A PA authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- Specifies that online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care do not meet the clinical training requirements.
- Clarifies that a trained PA may perform an abortion by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician unless specified in their practice agreement.
- Clarifies that the bill does not authorize a PA to perform an aspiration abortion after the first trimester of pregnancy.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No costs to the Physician Assistant Board.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
SB 385 would expand and modernize reproductive care training options for physician assistants… Current abortion training requirements have presented barriers to providers seeking to provide reproductive care due to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. SB 385 will address these barriers by better aligning abortion training to physician assistant scope of practice and provide multiple options for physician assistants to get trained in abortion care, including Physician Assistant Board approved courses and programs, courses offered by state or national health care professional or accreditation organizations, or training in clinics and hospitals.
- Background.
PAs. PAs provide a wide range of medical services when authorized by a supervising physician under a document known as a practice agreement. The practice agreement outlines what a PA may or may not do based on the PA’s competence and the level of physician supervision required.
Abortion by Aspiration Techniques. Abortion by aspiration techniques, or vacuum aspiration, is a common method for first-trimester abortions. It involves inserting a flexible tube into the cervical opening of the uterus and using suction to remove fetal tissue. The risk of complications, particularly those requiring medical intervention, is very low: depending on the study, less than 5% for minor complications and less than 0.6% for more serious complications. Where complications requiring interventions do occur, the patient is referred out for appropriate care.
- Opposition. The Physician Assistant Board opposes this bill, stating this bill “would require additional specified training requirements and clarifies physician assistant scope of practice in relation to abortion by aspiration techniques, which are determinations that should remain at the practice level between a physician assistant and their supervising physician.”
- Prior Legislation. SB 1375 (Atkins), Chapter 631, Statutes of 2022, expanded the training options for nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives seeking to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 385
Author:(Atkins) – As Introduced Ver:February 9, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 28-8
SUBJECT: Physician Assistant Practice Act: abortion by aspiration: training
KEY ISSUE: should trained and clinically competent physician assistantS be permitted to perform abortions by the aspiration technique without THE personal presence of a supervising physician or surgeon, except as provided?
SYNOPSIS
In last year’s Dobbs decision, the United States Supreme Court overturned a half-century of legal precedent. Dobbs held that the right to terminate a pregnancy is not a fundamental right protected by the 14th Amendment. One year after the decision, according to a New York Times tracker, 14 states have banned nearly all abortions, seven have “gestational” bans ranging from six to 20 weeks, and five have passed laws banning or severely restricting abortions that have been temporarily stayed by the courts. In other words, just over half of the states (26) have laws that would be unconstitutional under Roe v. Wade, while only 24 states and the District of Columbia continue to protect a person’s right to terminate a pregnancy. While California is among the states that have maintained or expanded reproductive freedom, other state bans and restrictions will be felt here if, as anticipated, people from states where abortion is banned or severely restricted come to California to obtain abortions.
This bill would expand access to abortion by expanding the category of licensed professionals who can perform abortions, specifically abortions by aspiration, which are quite safe when performed in the first trimester of a pregnancy. Physicians Assistants, Nurse Practitioners, and Licensed Nurse Midwives in California first obtained the right to perform abortions under the supervision of a doctor or surgeon in 2013, but the supervision requirements effectively reduced the number of skilled and knowledgeable health care professionals who could otherwise safely perform abortions with or without direct supervision. Therefore, last year’s AB 1375 (Atkins) authorized licensed Nurse Practitioners to perform abortions by aspiration techniques, without direct supervision, during the first trimester of pregnancy if they had appropriate training and practical experience. This bill would do the same for Physicians Assistants (PAs). The bill requires PAs who wish to perform abortion by aspiration to undergo specified training and a clinical competency evaluation, and provides that the professional who provides the clinical evaluation will not be liable for harms caused by the PA.
The bill is supported by several medical professional associations and pro-choice advocates; it is opposed by the California Catholic Conference and the Right to Life League on moral and health safety grounds. It is opposed by the Physician’s Assistant Board, which argues that existing law requires the PAs scope of practice to be determined by the “practice agreement” between the supervising physician and the PA. The bill previously passed the Committee on Business & Professions by a vote of 13-4.
SUMMARY: Revises training requirements that determine when a physician assistant achieves clinical competency to perform abortion by aspiration and clarifies that the physician assistant may perform the procedure without the physical presence of a supervising physician, and makes other corresponding changes. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a physician assistant (PA) to achieve clinical competency by successfully completing requisite training, as described, in performing an abortion by aspiration techniques. The bill removes the requirement that a PA follow certain protocols to receive authority from the PA’s supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques.
- Authorizes a PA who has completed the required training and achieved clinical competency, as described, to perform abortions by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, except as provided.
- Requires a PA to use abortion by aspiration techniques that are consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
- Provides that specified persons authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA.
EXISTING LAW:
- Makes it a crime to perform an abortion without holding a license to practice as a physician and surgeon, or holding another specified license or certificate that authorizes the holder to perform specified functions necessary for an abortion. (Health & Safety Code Sections 123460 to 123468.)
- Regulates and licenses PAs under the Physician Assistant Practice Act and establishes the Physician Assistant Board to enforce the Act. Provides that a PA is only authorized to perform medical services pursuant to a practice agreement with a supervising physician or surgeon and only if the PA has obtained requisite training, education, and experience to establish clinical competency. Specifies that the supervision does not require the physical presence of the physician if the PA adheres to the practice agreement and the physician or surgeon can be contacted, as described. (Business & Professions Code Sections 3501-3502; subsequent references refer to this code unless indicated otherwise.)
- Authorizes a PA to perform abortion by aspiration techniques under a practice agreement if the PA has completed specified training programs approved by the Physician Assistant Board or through training and clinical competency protocols and clinical competency protocols. (Section 3502.4.)
- Authorizes a nurse practitioner (NP) or a certified nurse midwife (CNM) to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques if the NP or CNM has received specified training and achieved clinical competency through an approved educational program or by supervised training in a clinic or hospital. Specifies that persons authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a NP or CNM. (Section 2725.4.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, this bill will expand and modernize reproductive care training options for physician assistants. The author contends that current abortion training requirements have led to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. “SB 385,” the author argues, “will address these barriers by better aligning abortion training to physician assistant scope of practice and provide multiple options for physician assistants to get trained in abortion care, including Physician Assistant Board approved courses and programs, courses offered by state or national health care professional or accreditation organizations, or training in clinics and hospitals.”
This bill builds upon the author’s previous efforts to allow adequately trained medical professionals – including physician assistants (PAs), nurse practitioners (NPs), and certified nurse mid-wives (CNMs) to perform abortions during the first trimester of a pregnancy. AB 154 (Chap. 662, Stats. 2013) permitted PAs, NPs, and CNMS who completed rigorous training and followed prescribed protocols, to perform abortion by aspiration techniques during the first trimester of pregnancy. The author believed that the limited number of physicians who performed abortions meant that too many women were denied access to abortion. However, some of the protocols and supervision requirements apparently proved too limiting and, with the looming prospect that the U.S. Supreme Court would overturn Roe v Wade, the author achieved enactment of SB 1375 (Chap. 631, Stats. 2022), which allowed qualified and clinically competent NPs to provide abortion by aspiration without having to work under the then-existing protocols and procedures. Most notably, SB 1375 tried to expand access to abortions by allowing NPs who were already authorized to practice independently in other areas to perform an abortion without direct physician supervision.
This bill now before the Committee effectively does for PAs what AB 1375 did for NPs. It does this in two ways. First, it expands the training options for PAs, including by allowing training and evaluation at a clinic or hospital and under the supervision of an NP or PA authorized to perform abortion by aspiration. Second, the bill clarifies some ambiguous aspects in existing law, most notably that a trained PA may perform an abortion by aspiration without the physical presence of a supervising physician in most cases. In short, the bill makes it clear that the supervising physician need not be physically present, but at the same time requires rigorous clinical training requirements. In line with this, the bill specifies that online or simulation-based programs that do not include mandatory clinical requirements (that is, direct patient care) do not meet clinical training requirements.
Immunity Provision. Of particular note to this Committee, the bill contains an immunity provision for those who conduct the clinical competency evaluations of PAs, providing that they are not liable for harm caused by the PA. Specifically, the bill provides that “a person authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques may not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege, for any action that relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA.” While this Committee is wary of providing broad immunities in the medical context, there are two aspects of this particular immunity provision that assuage this concern. First, while medical professionals are appropriately liable for the harms caused by the care they personally provide and by the care they “direct,” there is not a strong rationale to hold them liable for making an evaluation of clinical competency of a PA if the PA then negligently harms someone. In short, the trained PA is liable for their own conduct and negligence. Second, as a policy matter, granting immunity to the person who evaluates a PA’s clinical competency does not deny legal recourse to a person injured by the PA’s negligence. The injured party may still bring an action against and recover damages from the PA and the PA’s employer.
The need for the bill at the present moment. Last year the United States Supreme Court overturned a half-century of precedent in holding that the right to terminate a pregnancy is not a fundamental right protected by the 14th Amendment. (Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022) US LEXIS 3057.) One year after the decision, according to a New York Times tracker, 14 states have banned nearly all abortions, seven have “gestational” bans ranging from six to 20 weeks, and five have passed laws banning or restricting abortions that have been temporarily stayed by the courts. In other words, just over half the states have laws that would be unconstitutional under Roe v. Wade, while only 24 states and the District of Columbia continue to protect the right to terminate a pregnancy. (https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/us/abortion-laws-roe-v-wade.html, last visited June 22, 2023.)
While California is among the states that have maintained or expanded reproductive freedom, bans and restrictions in other states will be felt here if, as anticipated, people from those other states come to California to obtain reproductive care. As the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecology put in their letter of support: “As California prepares for more patients seeking abortion services and reproductive health care in our state, we must ensure the state has an ample supply of appropriately trained abortion providers qualified to provide that care.” This bill, by allowing well-trained medical professionals (PAs, NPs, and CNMs) to perform abortion by aspiration – a relatively safe procedure during the first trimester – will allow the state to dramatically increase the number of qualified professionals who can safely provide the procedure should the state see an increase in the number of persons coming from outside of the state to obtain an abortion. It will, of course, also provide greater access to reproductive health care for women who are already in the state.
Opposition Concerns. Opponents, especially those representing religious-based opposition, object to any change in the law that will increase a practice that, in their view, is a morally objectionable practice that results in the death of a living being. The California Catholic Conference (CCC), for example, argues that pregnant women should be provided with “non-violent solutions” to the challenges they face, including the “lack of prenatal and postpartum care, housing, childcare, intimate partner violence, and unemployment.” No doubt the author and supporters of this bill would agree that women – indeed all people – deserve these things, but meeting people’s material needs and giving them greater reproductive freedom are not mutually exclusive. Nonetheless, the CCC usefully reminds us that these other human needs also deserve attention.
The Physician Assistant Board (PAB), within the California Department of Consumer Affairs, raises a different concern. PAB contends that the bill conflicts with existing provisions of the Physician Assistant Practice Act that authorize a PA to perform medical services that are described in the “practice agreement” between the PA and the supervising physician. However, it is not clear to the Committee that the bill overrides such practice agreements; indeed, proposed subdivision (c) of Section 3502.4 expressly states that the PA must perform the abortion by aspiration technique “consistent with applicable standards of care, within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.” [Emphasis added.] This bill would seemingly make it clear that performing abortion by aspiration during the first trimester could but is not required to be part of a PA’s practice agreement. Perhaps PAB’s broader point is that a PA’s scope of practice should be determined in the practice agreement between the PA and the supervising physician and not determined by statute.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecology (ACOG) supports SB 385 because it “aligns the training requirements of a physician assistant, under the supervision of a physician, to perform a first trimester aspiration abortion with the same requirements as a certified nurse midwife and a nurse practitioner.” ACOG writes that it is “committed to mitigating the fallout of the Dobb’s decision, working with our partners to find ways to accommodate patients seeking care from outside our borders to the best of our ability and capacity. As California prepares for more patients seeking abortion services and reproductive health care in our state, we must ensure the state has an ample supply of appropriately trained abortion providers qualified to provide that care. SB 385 helps in this effort by building on existing law, expanding the trained pool of qualified non-physician providers to meet this demand during the first trimester.”
The American Association of University Women California (AAUW-CA), supports SB 385 because it “will expand and modernize reproductive care training” for physician assistants and “apply the same training standards . . . established for nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives.” AAUW-CA contends that this bill is an appropriate follow up to the author’s AB 154 of 2013, which “expanded California’s abortion-providing workforce” by allowing Nurse Practitioners (NP), certified nurse midwives (CNM), and Physician Assistants (PA) that complete appropriate training to perform aspiration abortions. AAUW-CA points out that AB 154 required training to be based on the standards developed in Health Workforce Pilot Project Number 171. AAUW-CA argues that “these training standards have presented barriers to NPs, CNMs, and PAs seeking to provide reproductive care due to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. As such, SB 1375 (Atkins, 2022) updated training and workforce barriers for NPs and CNMs, but statutes relating to PAs have yet to be updated.”
Indivisible California/Statestrong (ICS) supports SB 385, noting that while previous legislation recognized the need to expand the range of trained providers who could perform early term abortions, “subsequent experience found that the needed training was not widely enough available to augment the workforce as intended.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Physician’s Assistant Board (Board) opposes this bill because it believes that it “conflicts with the provisions of SB 697 (Chapter 707, Statutes of 2018) which determined that a physician assistant’s scope of practice is determined at the practice level.” According to the Board, “a physician assistant is authorized to perform those medical services described in the practice agreement, agreed upon by a physician assistant and their supervising physician. This bill would require additional specified training requirements and clarifies physician assistant scope of practice in relation to abortion by aspiration techniques, which are determinations that should remain at the practice level between a physician assistant and their supervising physician.”
The Right to Life League (RTLL) opposes this bill, claiming that it is an example of “capitalistic greed” that greatly “endangers women’s health by further lowering current medical standards to appease a voracious abortion industry.” RTLL claims that “SB 385 is the next generation of abortion deregulation designed to eliminate medical doctors’ supervision entirely, leaving physician assistants completely in charge. This is an existential threat to women’s health and an insult to the years of education and training required of medical doctors.” RTLL concludes that the “abortion industry wants to perform more abortions with fewer obstacles in its way. In its increasingly desperate push to protect its shrinking market for abortion service, the abortion industry is pushing this legislative body to sacrifice long-standing health care standards and physician oversight to boost lucrative profits.”
The California Catholic Conference (CCC) begins its letter of opposition by noting that it is “as always, opposed to abortion since it always takes the life of an innocent human being. Women deserve to be empowered with non-violent solutions to the challenges they face during pregnancy.” However, CCC argues that “this bill should also be rejected because it reduces the oversight of healthcare in abortion. Removing physician oversight of abortion and training,” CCC observes, “does not serve the goal of women’s health and safety.” Finally, CCC questions whether there is a “lack of access to abortion in California,” pointing out that the state “already funds abortions through tax dollars, with over 400 facilities performing abortions, and abortions are already offered by physician assistants, nurse practitioners, nurse midwives, via telehealth, on college campuses, and through a dozen sources by mail.” What California needs, CCC concludes, “is equity for the choices of pregnant and parenting women . . . California women face critical issues including maternal mortality, infant mortality, lack of prenatal and postpartum care, housing, childcare, intimate partner violence, and unemployment. Rather than reducing the oversight of abortion procedures, we encourage the members to provide equitable responses to the real and unmet needs of California families.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Association of University Women - California
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
Attorney General Rob Bonta
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Academy of PA's (CAPA)
California Legislative Women's Caucus
California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA)
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (SEIU California)
Indivisible CA Statestrong
NARAL Pro-choice California
Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
University of California
Opposition
California Catholic Conference
California Family Council
The Physician’s Assistant Board
The Right to Life League
Analysis Prepared by: Tom Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Marc Berman, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 385
Author:(Atkins) – As Introduced Ver:February 9, 2023
NOTE: This bill is double referred and if passed by this Committee will be re-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SENATE VOTE: 28-8
SUBJECT: Physician Assistant Practice Act: abortion by aspiration: training
SUMMARY: Expands the training options for physician assistants (PAs) seeking to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
EXISTING LAW:
- Guarantees, under the Reproductive Privacy Act, an individual’s right to choose or obtain an abortion before the viability of the fetus, or when the abortion is necessary to protect the life or health of the individual. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §§ 123460-123468)
- Defines “abortion” as any medical treatment intended to induce the termination of a pregnancy except to produce a live birth. (HSC § 123464(a)).
- Regulates and licenses PAs under the Physician Assistant Practice Act and establishes the Physician Assistant Board (PAB) to administer and enforce the act. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 3500-3545)
- Defines “supervising physician” or “supervising physician and surgeon” as a physician and surgeon who supervises one or more physician assistants and who is not currently on disciplinary probation prohibiting the employment or supervision of a PA. (BPC § 3501(e))
- Defines “supervision” as physician and surgeon oversight and accepted responsibility over the activities of the medical services rendered by a PA. (BPC § 3501(f)(1))
- Defines “practice agreement” as the writing, developed through collaboration among one or more physicians and surgeons and one or more PAs, that defines the medical services the PA is authorized to perform and that grants approval for physicians and surgeons on the staff of an organized health care system to supervise one or more PAs in the organized health care system. (BPC § 3501(k))
- Specifies that supervision does not require the physical presence of the physician and surgeon, but does require the following:
- Adherence to adequate supervision as agreed to in the practice agreement. (BPC § 3501(f)(1)(A))
- The physician and surgeon is available by telephone or other electronic communication methods at the time the PA examines the patient. (BPC § 3501(f)(1)(B))
- Authorizes a PA to perform medical services if the following requirements are met:
- The PA renders the services under the supervision of a physician and surgeon who is not subject to a disciplinary condition prohibiting that supervision or prohibiting the employment of a PA. (BPC § 3502(a)(1))
- The PA renders the services under a practice agreement. (BPC § 3502(a)(2))
- The PA is competent to perform the services. (BPC § 3502(a)(3))
- The PA’s education, training, and experience have prepared the PA to render the services. (BPC § 3502(a)(4))
- Requires a practice agreement to include provisions that address the following:
- The types of medical services a PA is authorized to perform. (BPC § 3502.3(a)(1)(A))
- Policies and procedures to ensure adequate supervision of the PA, including, but not limited to, appropriate communication, availability, consultations, and referrals between a physician and surgeon and the PA in the provision of medical services. (BPC § 3502.3(a)(1)(B))
- The methods for the continuing evaluation of the competency and qualifications of the PA. (BPC § 3502.3(a)(1)(C))
- The furnishing or ordering of drugs or devices by a PA. (BPC § 3502.3(a)(1)(D))
- Any additional provisions agreed to by the PA and physician and surgeon. (BPC § 3502.3(a)(1)(E))
- Requires a PA, to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques under a practice agreement, to complete training through: (1) training programs approved by the PAB, (2) training to perform medical services authorized under specified PAB regulations, or (3) through the training and clinical competency protocols established by Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Department of Health Care Access and Information. (BPC § 3502.4)
THIS BILL:
- Clarifies that training for PAs to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques must include a didactic and clinical component.
- Expands the abortion by aspiration technique training options for PAs to include:
- A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
- Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortions by aspiration techniques provided by any of the following who have performed the procedure themselves:
- A nurse practitioner or certified nurse-midwife authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- A PA authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- Clarifies that a trained PA may perform an abortion by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician unless specified in their practice agreement.
- Clarifies that a PA performing an abortion by aspiration must do so consistent with the standard of care and within the scope of their practice agreement.
- Clarifies that a person authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques may not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege, for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA.
- Clarifies that the provisions of this bill do not authorize a PA to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
- Specifies that online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care do not meet the clinical training requirements.
- Makes other technical changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, no significant state costs anticipated.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the author. According to the author, “[This bill] would expand and modernize reproductive care training options for physician assistants. This bill builds off the success of AB 154 (Atkins, 2013), which authorized advanced practice clinicians to provide abortion care, and SB 1375 (Atkins, 2022) which streamlined abortion training standards for nurse practitioners and certified nurse midwives. Current abortion training requirements have presented barriers to providers seeking to provide reproductive care due to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. [This bill] will address these barriers by better aligning abortion training to physician assistant scope of practice and provide multiple options for physician assistants to get trained in abortion care, including Physician Assistant Board approved courses and programs, courses offered by state or national health care professional or accreditation organizations, or training in clinics and hospitals.”
Background. PAs are healthcare providers that can provide a wide range of medical services under the supervision of a physician when authorized by a supervising physician under a document known as a practice agreement. The practice agreement outlines what a PA may or may not do based on the PA’s competence and the level of physician supervision required.
Abortion by Aspiration Techniques. Abortion by aspiration techniques, or vacuum aspiration, is a common method for first-trimester abortions. It involves inserting a flexible tube into the cervical opening of the uterus and using suction to remove fetal tissue. The risk of complications, particularly those requiring medical intervention, is very low (depending on the study, around <5% for minor complications and <0.6% for more serious complications). Where complications requiring interventions do occur, the patient is referred out for appropriate care.
PA Training Options. Existing law authorizes PAs to perform abortions by aspiration technique if they meet specified training and supervision requirements. Some of those training requirements were established as part of the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 under the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the California Department of Health Care Access and Information.
As part of the HWPP No. 171 study (2007-2013), UCSF’s Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health researchers utilized a standardized, competency-based curriculum and training plan for the education of primary care clinicians in early abortion care. That curriculum is one option for PAs to obtain training to perform an abortion by aspiration and was adopted as the training method for nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives by the BRN.
However, the California Future of Abortion Council, which was established in 2021 and comprised of reproductive freedom and sexual and reproductive health care allies, partners, and leaders, recently reviewed the curriculum and found that it may be overly rigid. The council released a blueprint outlining several policy recommendations to protect, strengthen, and expand access to abortion care. Among those recommendations was that policymakers should review competency requirements for abortion training for nurse practitioners, certified nurse-midwives, and PAs under the HWPP No. 171 and ensure requirements are aligned with other medical procedures with a similar safety record.
This bill seeks to incorporate that recommendation by providing two additional training options for PAs, training offered by healthcare organizations and direct training by a nurse practitioner, certified nurse-midwife, or another PA. The changes are consistent with recent updates to the training options available to nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives.
Prior Related Legislation. SB 1375 (Atkins), Chapter 631, Statutes of 2022, expanded the training options for nurse practitioners and certified nurse-midwives seeking to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
AB 154 (Atkins), Chapter 662, Statutes of 2013, authorized a nurse practitioner, certified nurse-midwife, or physician assistant to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques during the first trimester of pregnancy if they complete training under HWPP No. 171 or approved by the relevant licensing board.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecology (ACOG) District IX writes in support:
In the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. The decision has opened the door for states to ban and criminalize abortion services – impacting patients and providers across the U.S. Currently, 18 states have enacted a ban on abortion services or have severely restricted access to abortion.
In California, ACOG District IX is committed to mitigating the fallout of the Dobb’s decision, working with our partners to find ways to accommodate patients seeking care from outside our borders to the best of our ability and capacity. As California prepares for more patients seeking abortion services and reproductive health care in our state, we must ensure the state has an ample supply of appropriately trained abortion providers qualified to provide that care. [This bill] helps in this effort by building on existing law, expanding the trained pool of qualified non-physician providers to meet this demand during the first trimester.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The California Catholic Conference and the Right to Life League oppose this bill because they oppose decreased physician oversight of abortions and increased access to abortions.
The Physician Assistant Board is opposed to this bill because it believes this bill “would require additional specified training requirements and clarifies physician assistant scope of practice in relation to abortion by aspiration techniques, which are determinations that should remain at the practice level between a physician assistant and their supervising physician.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
American Association of University Women - California
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
Attorney General Rob Bonta
California Legislative Women's Caucus
California Nurse Midwives Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
Indivisible CA StateStrong
NARAL Pro-Choice California
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
California Catholic Conference
Physician Assistant Board
Right to Life League
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 385 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 385
Author: Atkins (D)
Introduced: 2/9/23
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 10-3, 4/10/23
AYES: Roth, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wahab
NOES: Nguyen, Niello, Wilk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-2, 4/18/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, McGuire, Min, Wiener
NOES: Wilk, Niello
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Physician Assistant Practice Act: abortion by aspiration: training
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies pathways for physician assistants (PAs) to meet necessary training requirements to perform abortion by aspiration techniques. Makes other various technical and conforming changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Specifies that, in order to receive authority from the supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques, a PA must complete training either through PAB approved training programs or through training to perform medical services that augment the PA’s current areas of competency.
- States that beginning January 1, 2014, and until January 1, 2016, the training and clinical competency protocols established by Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 shall be used as training and clinical competency guidelines to meet training requirements.
- Specifies that, in order to receive authority from the supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques, a PA must comply with protocols that specify the extent of supervision, the procedures for transferring a patient to physician and surgeon care or a hospital, the procedures for obtaining physician and surgeon assistance and consultation, and the procedures for providing emergency care until physician and surgeon assistance and consultation is available. (BPC § 3502.4)
This bill:
- Specifies that the required training, necessary for a PA to receive authority from their supervising physician and surgeon to perform abortion by aspiration techniques, must include a clinical and didactic component and be provided by either: a PAB-approved training program; training to perform medical services that augment the PA’s current areas of competency; a course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization; training based on the competency-based training protocols established by HWPP No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the Department of Health Care Access and Information or: training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortion by aspiration techniques that is provided by a physician and surgeon, nurse practitioner (NP), certified nurse midwife (CNM), or PA authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques. Specifies that exclusively online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care do not meet these clinical training requirements.
- Clarifies that a PA who completes requisite training and achieves clinical competency is authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, unless specified by their practice agreement, and that the procedure must be practiced consistent with applicable standards of care, within the PA’s clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
- Provides that a physician and surgeon, NP, or CNM, authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques who provides PA training and evaluates clinical competency at a clinic or hospital, shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of the PA.
- Specifies that nothing shall be interpreted as authorizing a PA to perform abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
Background
As a result of AB 154 (Atkins, Chapter 662, Statutes of 2013), since January 1, 2014, CNMs, NPs, and PAs in California have been providing aspiration abortion care as part of their clinical practice. The bill specified, among other provisions, that “beginning January 1, 2014, and until January 1, 2016, the training and clinical competency protocols established by Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development shall be used as training and clinical competency guidelines to meet the training requirement”.
HWPP is a program that was originally established as The Health Manpower Pilot Project in 1972 within the California Department of Public Health. It was renamed the Health Workforce Pilots Program in 2007, and is currently administered by the California Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI). HWPP allows for the evaluation of various professions authorized scope of practice and where additional practice authority may be appropriate. A pilot project may be requested by non-profit education institutions, community hospitals, clinics, and governmental agencies engaged in health or education activities, and may involve teaching new skills to existing categories of health care personnel, developing new categories of health care personnel, accelerating the training of existing categories of health care personnel, and teaching new health care roles to previously untrained persons.
HWPP No. 171 was conducted from 2007-2013, during which time researchers with Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health, based at the University of California San Francisco, evaluated a variety of factors to determine the role CNMs, NPs, and PAs could play in safely and competently providing early abortion care. The project collected data from almost 20,000 patients and trained nearly 50 CNMs, NPs, and PAs to competency in aspiration abortion care. Study results showed that CNMs, NPs, and PAs can be successfully trained to competence in aspiration abortion care; outpatient abortion is very safe, whether performed by a CNM, NP, PA or a physician and; patients reported high satisfaction during their abortion experience whether they are seen by a CNM, NP, PA or a physician.
This bill does not change the abortion services a PA is authorized to provide but instead conforms updated pathways through which a PA can receive training and demonstrate competent care to provide care currently authorized in the PA Act.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/1/23)
American Association of University Women California
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
California Nurse Midwives Association
NARAL Pro-Choice California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/1/23)
California Catholic Conference
Right to Life League
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters write that this bill applies the same training standards to PAs that SB 1375 established for NPs and CNMs, allowing PAs to provide first trimester aspiration abortions within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training. Supporters note that this bill also better aligns abortion training to physician assistants’ scope of practice and provide multiple options for clinicians to get trained in abortion care.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Catholic Conference writes that “What California needs is equity for the choices of pregnant and parenting women as they pursue motherhood. California women face critical issues including maternal mortality, infant mortality, lack of prenatal and postpartum care, housing, childcare, intimate partner violence, and unemployment. Rather than reducing the oversight of abortion procedures, we encourage the members to provide equitable responses to the real and unmet needs of California families.” According to the Right to Life League, “Last year, the legislature enacted a similar bill, AB 1375, to allow Nurse Practitioners to perform abortions without standardized procedures…SB 385 picks up where AB 1375 left off by allowing physician assistants to perform abortions without direct medical health care supervision, all in the name of increasing “abortion access.”
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
5/3/23 15:01:45
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 385 (Author:Atkins)
Version: February 9, 2023
Hearing Date: April 18, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Physician Assistant Practice Act: abortion by aspiration: training
DIGEST
This bill revises existing training requirements for a physician assistant (PA) to achieve clinical competency to perform abortion by aspiration techniques. The bill provides that a health care professional who is authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques is not to be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA on performing abortion by aspiration techniques.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Since the 1973 holding in Roe v. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court has continuously held that it is a constitutional right to access abortion before fetal viability. However, on June 24, 2022 in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, the Court voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe and found that there is no federal constitutional right to an abortion. As a result of the Dobbs decision, people in roughly half the country may lose access to abortion services or have them severely restricted. This bill seeks to expand and modernize reproductive care training options for PAs in a similar manner that SB 1375 (Atkins, Ch. 631, Stats. 2022) did for nurse practitioners (NPs).
The bill is author sponsored. The bill is supported by the American Association of University Women – California, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX, the California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA), and
NARAL Pro-Choice California. The bill is opposed by the Right to Life League. The bill passed the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee on a vote of 10 to 3.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Prohibits the state from denying or interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives. Specifies that this provision is intended to further the constitutional right to privacy guaranteed by Section 1 of Article I of the California Constitution, and the constitutional right to not be denied equal protection guaranteed by Section 7 of Article I of the California Constitution, and that nothing herein narrows or limits the right to privacy or equal protection. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.1.)
- Provides that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights including, among others, the right to privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.)
- Provides that a person may not be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law or denied equal protection of the laws. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 7.)
- Prohibits the state from denying or interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives. Specifies that this provision is intended to further the constitutional right to privacy guaranteed by Section 1 of Article I of the California Constitution, and the constitutional right to not be denied equal protection guaranteed by Section 7 of Article I of the California Constitution, and that nothing herein narrows or limits the right to privacy or equal protection. (Cal. Const., art. I, § 1.1.)
- Establishes the Reproductive Privacy Act and provides that the Legislature finds and declares that every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy, including prenatal care, childbirth, postpartum care, contraception, sterilization, abortion care, miscarriage management, and infertility care. (Health & Saf. Code § 123460 et. seq., § 123462.)
- Establishes the Physician Assistant Practice Act, administered by the Physician Assistant Board (PAB), which provides for the licensing and regulation of PAs and authorizes a PA to perform medical services under the Act if they do so under the supervision of a licensed physician and surgeon who is not subject to discipline; if the PA renders services pursuant to a practice agreement that meets specified requirements; if the PA is competent to perform the services and; if the PA’s education, training, and experience have prepared the PA to render the services. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 3500 et seq., § 3502)
- Specifies that, in order to receive authority from the supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques, a PA must complete training either through PAB approved training programs or through training to perform medical services that augment the PA’s current areas of competency.
- Specifies that, in order to receive authority from the supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques, a PA must comply with protocols that specify the extent of supervision, the procedures for transferring a patient to physician and surgeon care or a hospital, the procedures for obtaining physician and surgeon assistance and consultation, and the procedures for providing emergency care until physician and surgeon assistance and consultation is available. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 3502.4)
- Specifies that the training protocols established by HWPP No. 171 shall be deemed to meet the PAB standards and that a PA who has completed training and achieved clinical competency through HWPP No. 171 is authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques.
- Makes it unprofessional conduct for a PA to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques without prior completion of training and validation of clinical competency. (Ibid.)
This bill:
- Specifies that the required training, necessary for a PA to receive authority from their supervising physician and surgeon to perform abortion by aspiration techniques, must include a clinical and didactic component and be provided by either:
- A PAB-approved training program.
- Training to perform medical services that augment the PA’s current areas of competency.
- A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
- Training based on the competency-based training protocols established by the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the Department of Health Care Access and Information.
- Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortion by aspiration techniques that is provided by a physician and surgeon, NP, CNM, or PA authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques.
- Clarifies that a PA who completes requisite training and achieves clinical competency is authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, unless specified by their practice agreement, and that the procedure must be practiced consistent with applicable standards of care, within the PA’s clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
- Specifies that nothing in these provisions is to be interpreted as authorizing a PA to perform abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
- Provides that a physician and surgeon, nurse practitioner (NP), or certified-nurse midwife (CNM) authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques is not to be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
SB 385 would expand and modernize reproductive care training options for physician assistants. This bill builds off the success of AB 154 (Atkins, 2013), which authorized advanced practice clinicians to provide abortion care, and SB 1375 (Atkins, 2022) which streamlined abortion training standards for nurse practitioners and certified nurse midwifes. Current abortion training requirements have presented barriers to providers seeking to provide reproductive care due to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. SB 385 will address these barriers by better aligning abortion training to physician assistant scope of practice and provide multiple options for physician assistants to get trained in abortion care, including Physician Assistant Board approved courses and programs, courses offered by state or national health care professional or accreditation organizations, or training in clinics and hospitals.
- Until June 2022, access to abortion was held to be a federal constitutional right since 1973
Roe v. Wade was the landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that held the implied constitutional right to privacy extended to a person’s decision whether to terminate a pregnancy, while allowing that some state regulation of abortion access could be permissible. ((1973) 410 U.S. 113.) The plaintiff in the case was “Jane Roe,” an unmarried woman who wanted to end her pregnancy under safe and clinical conditions but was unable to obtain a legal abortion in Texas because her life was not threatened by the continuation of the pregnancy. Unable to afford travel to another state to obtain an abortion, she challenged the statute making it a crime to perform an abortion unless a woman’s life was at stake. She also claimed that the Texas law abridged her right of personal privacy.
The Court struck down the Texas law, finding for the first time that the constitutional right to privacy under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment is “broad enough to encompass a woman’s decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy.” At the same time, the high court also defined two compelling state interests that would satisfy restrictions on a person’s right to choose to terminate a pregnancy: 1) states may regulate the abortion procedure after the first trimester of pregnancy in ways necessary to promote a woman’s health; and 2) after the point of fetal viability outside of the womb, a state may, to protect the potential life of the fetus, prohibit abortions that are not necessary to preserve a person’s life or health. In Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey (1992) 505 U.S. 833, the Court reaffirmed the basic holding of Roe, yet also permitted states to impose restrictions on abortion as long as those restrictions do not create an undue burden on a person’s right to choose to terminate a pregnancy.
Roe has been one of the most debated U.S. Supreme Court decisions and its application and validity have been challenged numerous times, but its fundamental holding had continuously been upheld by the Court until June 2022. On June 24, 2022 the Court published its official opinion in Dobbs and voted 6-3 to overturn the holding in Roe. The case involved a Mississippi law enacted in 2018 that banned most abortions after the first 15 weeks of pregnancy, which is before what is generally accepted as the period of viability. (See Miss. Code Ann. §41-41-191.) The majority opinion upholds the Mississippi law finding that, contrary to almost 50 years of precedent, there is no fundamental constitutional right to have an abortion. The opinion further provides that states should be allowed to decide how to regulate abortion and that a strong presumption of validity should be afforded to those state laws.
In the wake of the Dobbs decision it is very probable that abortion will be banned or severely restricted in 24 states,[1] with 13 states already having total abortion bans in effect.[2] Almost one-third of women and people who can become pregnant of reproductive age in the United States live in a state where abortion is not legal or is severely restricted.[3] If all the states expected to enact a total ban on abortion actually do, the number of patients who would find that their nearest clinic is in California could increase to 1.4 million an almost 3,000 percent increase.[4]
- California is a Reproductive Freedom State
- California law protects an individual’s right to access abortion
The California Supreme Court held in 1969 that the state constitution’s implied right to privacy extends to an individual’s decision about whether or not to have an abortion. (People v. Belous (1969) 71 Cal.2d 954.) This was the first time an individual’s right to abortion was upheld in a court. In 1972 the California voters passed a constitutional amendment that explicitly provided for the right to privacy in the state constitution. (Prop. 11, Nov. 7, 1972 gen. elec.) California statutory law provides, under the Reproductive Privacy Act, that the Legislature finds and declares every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, which entails the right to make and effectuate decisions about all matters relating to pregnancy; therefore, it is the public policy of the State of California that every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control, and every individual has the fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion. (Health & Saf. Code § 123462.) In 2019 Governor Newsom issued a proclamation reaffirming California’s commitment to making reproductive freedom a fundamental right in response to the numerous attacks on reproductive rights across the nation.[5]
In September 2021, more than 40 organizations came together to form the California Future Abortion Council (CA FAB) to identify barriers to accessing abortion services and to recommend policy proposals to support equitable and affordable access for not only Californians, but all who seek care in this state. CA FAB issued its first report in December 2021, which included 45 policy recommendations to protect, strengthen, and expand abortion access in California.[6] In response to the Dobbs decision and CA FAB’s report, California enacted a comprehensive package of legislation that protects the rights of patients seeking abortion in the state and those supporting them.[7] Additionally, the voters overwhelmingly approved Proposition 1 (Nov. 8, 2022 gen. elec.), and enacted an express constitutional right in the state constitution that prohibits the state from interfering with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions.
- This bill provides updated training standards for PAs
SB 1375 (Atkins, Ch. 631, Stats. 2022) authorized nurse practitioners (NPs) who are qualified to independently practice to provide abortion services by aspiration techniques in the first trimester, and updated training standards for NPs and CNMs. Additionally, it provided that a person authorized to perform abortion services by aspiration techniques is not to be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a NP. This bill seeks to expand on SB 1375 by applying recently updated training standards for NPs and CNMs to PAs, aligning abortion training to a PA’s scope of practice, and providing multiple options for PAs to get trained in abortion care. The author notes that this bill is intended to address one CA FAB’s recommendations to address training and workforce barriers health care professionals face when providing reproductive care in order to provide timely care to Californians and absorb projected increases in out-of-state patients seeking reproductive care. According to the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee analysis, this bill “does not change the abortion services a PA is authorized to provide but instead conforms updated pathways through which a PA can receive training and demonstrate competent care to provide care currently authorized in the PA Act.[8]”
- This bill provides immunity for an act related to the evaluation of a PA for clinical competency
This bill provides that a physician and surgeon, NP, CNM, or PA who is authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques is not to be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of clinical competency of a PA. The PA would still remain liable for their own actions under existing law.
Liability has the primary effect of ensuring that some measure of recourse exists for those persons injured by the negligent or willful acts of others; the risk of that liability has the primary effect of ensuring parties act reasonably to avoid harm to those to whom they owe a duty. As a general rule, California law provides that everyone is responsible, not only for the result of their willful acts, but also for an injury occasioned to another by their want of ordinary care or skill in the management of their property or person, except so far as the latter has, willfully or by lack of ordinary care, caused their own injury. (Civ. Code § 1714(a).)
Blanket immunity provisions are generally disfavored as a matter of public policy because they, by their nature, prevent an injured party from seeking a particular type of recovery. However, the Legislature has in limited circumstances allowed for measured immunity from liability to promote other policy goals that could benefit the public. Immunity provisions are sometimes allowed when necessary to ensure the willingness of individuals to continue taking on certain roles that may involve some risk. SB 1375 from the 2022 legislative session provided immunity to a physician and surgeon, nurse practitioner (NP), or certified-nurse midwife (CNM) who is authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques for any action relating to their evaluation of a NP for clinical competency. This bill seeks to do the same thing for those authorized to evaluate PAs for clinical competency. This limited immunity only applies to the context of an act taken in evaluating a PA for clinical competency to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques. The PA themselves would remain liable for any of their own actions leaving a remedy available to an injured party.
- Statements in support
The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecology (ACOG) District IX writes in support stating:
In the months since the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade, approximately one in three women in this country has lost abortion access. The decision has opened the door for states to ban and criminalize abortion services – impacting patients and providers across the U.S. Currently, 18 states have enacted a ban on abortion services or have severely restricted access to abortion.
In California, ACOG District IX is committed to mitigating the fallout of the Dobb’s decision, working with our partners to find ways to accommodate patients seeking care from outside our borders to the best of our ability and capacity. As California prepares for more patients seeking abortion services and reproductive health care in our state, we must ensure the state has an ample supply of appropriately trained abortion providers qualified to provide that care. SB 385 helps in this effort by building on existing law, expanding the trained pool of qualified non-physician providers to meet this demand during the first trimester.
- Statements in opposition
The Right to Life League writes in opposition stating:
The bill endangers women’s health by further lowering current medical standards to appease a voracious abortion industry. The bill will allow physician assistants to perform abortions by aspirations techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon. […] SB 385 is the next generation of abortion deregulation designed to eliminate medical doctors’ supervision entirely, leaving physician assistants completely in charge. This is an existential threat to women’s health and an insult to the years of education and training required of medical doctors.
SUPPORT
American Association of University Women - California
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA)
NARAL Pro-Choice California
OPPOSITION
Right to Life League
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1375 (Atkins, Ch. 631, Stats. 2022) expanded training options for Nurse Practitioners (NPs) and Certified Nurse-Midwives (CNMs) for purposes of performing abortion by aspiration techniques (AAT), as specified.
AB 154 (Atkins, Ch. 662, Stats. 2013) authorized NPs, certified nurse midwives, and physician assistants to perform abortions during the first trimester if they completed training, as provided, and adhere to standardized procedures and protocols.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 3)
**************
Elizabeth Nash and Isabel Guarnieri, Six Months Post-Roe, 24 US States Have Banned Abortion or Are Likely to Do So: A Roundup, Guttmacher Institute (Jan. 10, 2023), available at https://www.guttmacher.org/2023/01/six-months-post-roe-24-us-states-have-banned-abortion-or-are-likely-do-so-roundup. ↑
Sharon Bernstein, Factbox: US. abortion restrictions mount after overturn of Roe v. Wade, Reuters, (Oct. 4, 2022), available at https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/us-abortion-restrictions-mount-after-overturn-roe-v-wade-2022-10-04/#:~:text=ACTIVE%20BANS,an%20abortion%20rights%20research%20group. ↑
Katie Shepherd, Rachel Roubein, and Caroline Kitchner, 1 in 3 American women have already lost abortion access. More restrictive laws are coming, The Washington Post, (Aug. 22, 2022). ↑
April Dembosky, As states ban abortion, Californians open their arms and wallets, NPR (June 27, 2022), available at https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2022/06/27/1103479722/as-states-ban-abortion-californians-open-their-arms-and-wallets. ↑
California Proclamation on Reproductive Freedom (May 31, 2019) available at https://www.gov.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Proclamation-on-Reproductive-Freedom.pdf. ↑
Recommendations to Protect, Strengthen, and Expand Abortion Care in California, California Future of Abortion Council (Dec. 2021), available at https://www.cafabcouncil.org/_files/ugd/ddc900_0beac0c75cb54445a230168863566b55.pdf. ↑
Kristen Hwang, Newsom signs abortion protections into law, CalMatters (Sept. 27, 2022), available at https://calmatters.org/health/2022/09/california-abortion-bills/. ↑
Sen. Bus., Prof.& Econ. Development Comm. analysis of SB 386 (2023-24 reg. sess.) as introduced Feb. 9, 2023 at p. 5. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 385 Hearing Date: April 10, 2023
Author: | Atkins | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: Physician Assistant Practice Act: abortion by aspiration: training
SUMMARY:
Clarifies pathways for physician assistants (PAs) to meet necessary training requirements to perform abortion by aspiration techniques. Makes other various technical and conforming changes.
NOTE:
This measure is double-referred to the Senate Committee on Judiciary, second.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Reproductive Privacy Act which finds and declares that every individual possesses a fundamental right of privacy with respect to personal reproductive decisions, and states that it is the public policy of the State of California that:
- Every individual has the fundamental right to choose or refuse birth control;
- Every woman has the fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose and to obtain an abortion, except as specifically limited by law; and,
- The state cannot deny or interfere with a woman’s fundamental right to choose to bear a child or to choose to obtain an abortion, except as specifically permitted by law. (Health and Safety Code (Health and Safety Code (HSC)) § 123462)
- Provides that the State may not deny or interfere with a woman's right to choose or obtain an abortion prior to viability of the fetus, or when the abortion is necessary to protect the life or health of the woman. (HSC § 123466)
- Prohibits a person from being subject to certain disciplinary action and penalties if they perform an abortion by medication or aspiration techniques in the first trimester of pregnancy, and at the time of so doing, have a valid, unrevoked, and unsuspended license or certificate obtained in accordance with the Medical Practice Act, Osteopathic Act, Nursing Practice Act, or the Physician Assistant Practice Act (PA Act) that authorizes the person to perform the functions necessary for an abortion by medication or aspiration techniques. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2253)
- Establishes the PA Act, administered by the Physician Assistant Board (PAB), which provides for the licensing and regulation of PAs and authorizes a PA to perform medical services under the Act if they do so under the supervision of a licensed physician and surgeon who is not subject to discipline; if the PA renders services pursuant to a practice agreement that meets specified requirements; if they PA is competent to perform the services and; if the PA’s education, training, and experience have prepared the PA to render the services. (BPC § 3500 et seq., § 3502)
- Specifies that, in order to receive authority from the supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques, a PA must complete training either through PAB approved training programs or through training to perform medical services that augment the PA’s current areas of competency. States that beginning January 1, 2014, and until January 1, 2016, the training and clinical competency protocols established by Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 shall be used as training and clinical competency guidelines to meet training requirements. Specifies that, in order to receive authority from the supervising physician and surgeon to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques, a PA must comply with protocols that specify the extent of supervision, the procedures for transferring a patient to physician and surgeon care or a hospital, the procedures for obtaining physician and surgeon assistance and consultation, and the procedures for providing emergency care until physician and surgeon assistance and consultation is available. (BPC § 3502.4)
- Specifies that the training protocols established by HWPP No. 171 shall be deemed to meet the PAB standards and that a PA who has completed training and achieved clinical competency through HWPP No. 171 is authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques. Makes it unprofessional conduct for a PA to perform an abortion by aspiration techniques without prior completion of training and validation of clinical competency. (Id)
- Prohibits PAB from suspending or revoking PA’s license solely for performing an abortion, if the licensee performed the abortion in accordance with the PA Act and Reproductive Privacy Act. Prohibits PAB from denying a PA application for licensure, or suspending, revoking, or otherwise imposing discipline upon a licensed California PA if they are licensed or certified to practice as a PA in another state and were disciplined in that state solely for performing an abortion in that state, or if the person is licensed or certified to practice as a PA in another state and was convicted in that state for an offense related solely to the performance of an abortion in that state. (Id)
- Requires PAB, The Medical Board of California, Osteopathic Medical Board of California, and Board of Registered Nursing to expedite the licensure process for an applicant who demonstrates that they intend to provide abortions within the scope of practice of their license. (BPC § 870)
This bill:
- Specifies that the required training, necessary for a PA to receive authority from their supervising physician and surgeon to perform abortion by aspiration techniques, must include a clinical and didactic component and be provided by either:
- A PAB-approved training program
- Training to perform medical services that augment the PA’s current areas of competency.
- A course offered by a state or national health care professional or accreditation organization.
- Training based on the competency-based training protocols established by the Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now known as the Department of Health Care Access and Information.
- Training and evaluation of clinical competency, performed at a clinic or hospital, on performing abortion by aspiration techniques that is provided by a physician and surgeon, NP, CNM, or PA authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques.
- Specifies that exclusively online or simulation-based training programs that do not include mandatory clinical hours involving direct patient care do not meet these clinical training requirements.
- Clarifies that a PA who completes requisite training and achieves clinical competency is authorized to perform abortions by aspiration techniques without the personal presence of a supervising physician and surgeon, unless specified by their practice agreement, and that the procedure must be practiced consistent with applicable standards of care, within the PA’s clinical and professional education and training, and pursuant to their practice agreement.
- Provides that a physician and surgeon, NP, or CNM, authorized to perform abortion by aspiration techniques who provides PA training and evaluates clinical competency at a clinic or hospital, shall not be punished, held liable for damages in a civil action, or denied any right or privilege for any action relating to the evaluation of the PA.
- Specifies that nothing shall be interpreted as authorizing a PA to perform abortion by aspiration techniques after the first trimester of pregnancy.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “HWPP No. 171 training standards have presented barriers to PAs, nurse practitioners (NPs), and certified nurse midwives (CNMs) who seek to provide reproductive care, due to a lack of available trainers and training opportunities. Last year, the Author introduced SB 1375 (Atkins, Chapter 631, Statutes of 2022) which updated training and workforce development options for NPs and CNMs but the same clarifications and pathways have not yet been updated in the PA Act.”
According to the Author, “The California Future of Abortion Council – comprised of reproductive freedom and sexual and reproductive health care allies, partners, and leaders – outlined several policy recommendations to protect, strengthen, and expand access to abortion care. The Council’s recommendations include addressing training and workforce barriers health professionals face when providing reproductive care. In order to provide timely care to Californians and absorb projected increases in out-of-state patients seeking reproductive care, the Council suggests that California take steps to ensure the growth of a network of clinicians trained in abortion and sexual and reproductive health care.”
The Author notes that SB 385 will expand aspiration abortion training opportunities for PAs by applying the same, recently updated, training standards for NPs and CNMs to PAs, better aligning abortion training to PA scope of practice and providing multiple options for clinicians to get trained and achieve clinical competency in abortion care.
- Background.
PAs and PAB. PAB licenses and regulates approximately 13,000 PAs who provide health care services with the direction and responsible supervision of a doctor of medicine or osteopathy. Within the physician-PA relationship, PAs make clinical decisions and provide a broad range of diagnostic, therapeutic, preventive, and health maintenance services. A PA must attend and graduate from an accredited PA program associated with a medical school that includes classroom studies and clinical experience. The professional curriculum for PA education includes basic medical, behavioral, and social sciences; introduction to clinical medicine and patient assessment; supervised clinical practice; and health policy and professional practice issues.
PAs predominantly practice in primary care service settings such as private practice physician offices and hospitals; however, PAs also provide services in community health clinics and rural health clinics. As reported by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, nationally, the majority of PAs work in physicians’ offices (55%) and in hospital settings (26%).
The PA Act was updated in 2019, SB 697 (Caballero, Chapter 707, Statutes of 2019), changed the way PAs and physician and surgeons arrange and handle supervision. Among numerous other provisions, the bill allowed multiple physicians and surgeons to supervise a PA and redefined the supervision agreement. What was once referred to as a delegation of services agreement, is now referred to as a practice agreement. A practice agreement is written between a supervising physician and surgeon and a PA (which could be one or more supervisors/supervisees). The agreement defines the medical services that a PA is authorized to perform, along with policies and procedures to ensure adequate supervision, methods for evaluating competency, the specific authorizations for furnishing or ordering drugs or devices, and any other provisions agreed to by the supervising physician and surgeon and the PA.
Effective, January 1, 2020, a physician and surgeon who supervises a PA does not need to be physically present when a PA is treating a patient, but must have the specifications of the supervision agreed to in the practice agreement and the physician and surgeon must be available by telephone or other electronic communication methods at the time the PA is examining a patient.
AB 154 and Abortion by Aspiration Techniques. As a result of AB 154 (Atkins, Chapter 662, Statutes of 2013), since January 1, 2014, CNMs, NPs, and PAs in California have been providing aspiration abortion care as part of their clinical practice. The bill specified, among other provisions, that “beginning January 1, 2014, and until January 1, 2016, the training and clinical competency protocols established by Health Workforce Pilot Project (HWPP) No. 171 through the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development shall be used as training and clinical competency guidelines to meet the training requirement”.
HWPP is a program that was originally established as The Health Manpower Pilot Project in 1972 within the California Department of Public Health. It was renamed the Health Workforce Pilots Program in 2007, and is currently administered by the California Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI). HWPP allows for the evaluation of various professions authorized scope of practice and where additional practice authority may be appropriate. A pilot project may be requested by non-profit education institutions, community hospitals, clinics, and governmental agencies engaged in health or education activities, and may involve teaching new skills to existing categories of health care personnel, developing new categories of health care personnel, accelerating the training of existing categories of health care personnel, and teaching new health care roles to previously untrained persons.
HWPP No. 171 was conducted from 2007-2013, during which time researchers with Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health, based at the University of California San Francisco, evaluated a variety of factors to determine the role CNMs, NPs, and PAs could play in safely and competently providing early abortion care. The project collected data from almost 20,000 patients and trained nearly 50 CNMs, NPs, and PAs to competency in aspiration abortion care. Study results showed that CNMs, NPs, and PAs can be successfully trained to competence in aspiration abortion care; outpatient abortion is very safe, whether performed by a CNM, NP, PA or a physician and; patients reported high satisfaction during their abortion experience whether they are seen by a CNM, NP, PA or a physician.
This bill does not change the abortion services a PA is authorized to provide but instead conforms updated pathways through which a PA can receive training and demonstrate competent care to provide care currently authorized in the PA Act.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters write that this bill would apply the same training standards to PAs that SB 1375 established for NPs and CNMs, allowing PAs to provide first trimester aspiration abortions within the scope of their clinical and professional education and training. Supporters note that this bill would also better align abortion training to physician assistants’ scope of practice and provide multiple options for clinicians to get trained in abortion care.
- Arguments in Opposition. The California Catholic Conference writes that “What California needs is equity for the choices of pregnant and parenting women as they pursue motherhood. California women face critical issues including maternal mortality, infant mortality, lack of prenatal and postpartum care, housing, childcare, intimate partner violence, and unemployment. Rather than reducing the oversight of abortion procedures, we encourage the members to provide equitable responses to the real and unmet needs of California families.”
According to the Right to Life League, “Last year, the legislature enacted a similar bill, AB 1375, to allow Nurse Practitioners to perform abortions without standardized procedures…SB 385 picks up where AB 1375 left off by allowing physician assistants to perform abortions without direct medical health care supervision, all in the name of increasing “abortion access.”
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
American Association of University Women California
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
California Nurse Midwives Association v
NARAL Pro-Choice California
Opposition:
California Catholic Conference
Right to Life League
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):