SB 389: State Water Resources Control Board: investigation of water right.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-08
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-08: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 486, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board within the California Environmental Protection Agency. Existing law provides generally for the appropriation of water. Existing law authorizes the board to investigate bodies of water, to take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water, and to ascertain whether or not water is appropriated lawfully, as provided. Under existing law, the diversion or use of water other than as authorized by specified provisions of law is a trespass, subject to specified civil liability.
This bill would instead authorize the board to investigate and ascertain whether or not a water right is valid. The bill would authorize the board to issue an information order in furtherance of an investigation, as executed by the executive director of the board, as specified. The bill would authorize a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized to be enforced as a trespass, as specified.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board within the California Environmental Protection Agency. Existing law provides generally for the appropriation of water. Existing law authorizes the board to investigate bodies of water, to take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water, and to ascertain whether or not water is appropriated lawfully, as provided. Under existing law, the diversion or use of water other than as authorized by specified provisions of law is a trespass, subject to specified civil liability.
This bill would instead authorize the board to investigate and ascertain whether or not a water right is valid. The bill would authorize the board to issue an information order in furtherance of an investigation, as executed by the executive director of the board, as specified. The bill would authorize a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized to be enforced as a trespass, as specified.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board within the California Environmental Protection Agency. Existing law provides generally for the appropriation of water. Existing law authorizes the board to investigate bodies of water, to take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water, and to ascertain whether or not water is appropriated lawfully, as provided. Under existing law, the diversion or use of water other than as authorized by specified provisions of law is a trespass, subject to specified civil liability.
This bill would instead authorize the board to investigate and ascertain whether or not a water right is valid. The bill would authorize the board to issue an information order in furtherance of an investigation, as executed by the executive director of the board, to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or user to provide the information related to a diversion and use of water, board, as specified. The bill would authorize a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized pursuant to this provision to be enforced as a trespass. trespass, as specified.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board within the California Environmental Protection Agency. Existing law provides generally for the appropriation of water. Existing law provides that it is the intent of the Legislature that the state take vigorous action to enforce the terms and conditions of permits, licenses, certifications, and registrations to appropriate water, to enforce state board orders and decisions, and to prevent the unlawful diversion of water. Existing law authorizes the board to investigate bodies of water, to take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water, and to ascertain whether or not water is appropriated lawfully, as provided. Under existing law, the diversion or use of water other than as authorized by specified provisions of law is a trespass, subject to specified civil liability.
This bill would, upon specified findings, authorize the State Water Resources Control Board to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right, as specified. The bill would authorize the state board to adopt regulations to implement these provisions.This bill would instead authorize the board to investigate and ascertain whether or not a water right is valid. The bill would authorize the board to issue an information order in furtherance of an investigation, as executed by the executive director of the board, to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or user to provide the information related to a diversion and use of water, as specified. The bill would authorize a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized pursuant to this provision to be enforced as a trespass.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board within the California Environmental Protection Agency. Existing law provides generally for the appropriation of water. Existing law provides that it is the intent of the Legislature that the state take vigorous action to enforce the terms and conditions of permits, licenses, certifications, and registrations to appropriate water, to enforce state board orders and decisions, and to prevent the unlawful diversion of water.
This bill would would, upon specified findings, authorize the State Water Resources Control Board to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right, as specified. The bill would authorize the state board to adopt regulations to implement these provisions.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board within the California Environmental Protection Agency. Existing law provides generally for the appropriation of water. Existing law provides that it is the intent of the Legislature that the state take vigorous action to enforce the terms and conditions of permits, licenses, certifications, and registrations to appropriate water, to enforce state board orders and decisions, and to prevent the unlawful diversion of water.
This bill would authorize the State Water Resources Control Board to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right, as specified.
(a)The board for the purpose of this division may:
(1)Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
(2)Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water thereon or therein.
(3)Investigate and ascertain whether or not water heretofore filed upon or any claimed riparian or appropriative right is valid under the laws of this state.
(b)(1)In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to this section, the board may issue an information order, as executed by the executive director of the board.
(2)The information order may be issued to a water right holder or claimant to provide the following information related to a diversion and use of water:
(A)Information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).
(B)Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed.
(C)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use, if the claimed right is a riparian right.
(D)Information concerning the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
(E)Information concerning prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
(3)(A)The information order may be issued to a diverter or user of water to provide information concerning that diverters prior diversion or use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage, or identification of the person or holder claiming the right under which the water was diverted or used.
(B)Information obtained under this paragraph from a diverter or user who is not the water right holder or claimant shall not be binding on, or treated as an admission by, the water right holder or claimant.
(c)The burden of any order issued under subdivision (b), including costs, shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained from the board receiving that information. In making a request, the board shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the person to whom the request is directed with a written explanation with regard to the need for the information.
(2)Identify the evidence that supports requiring that person to provide the information.
(d)A diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized may be enforced as a trespass under Section 1052, following notice and opportunity for hearing as required under Section 1052, Section 1055, or Article 2 (commencing with Section 1831) of Chapter 12 of Part 2.
(e)Nothing in this section shall limit any authority held by the board under this code or any other provision of law.
(a)The board for the purpose of this division may:
(1)Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
(2)Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water thereon or therein.
(3)Investigate and ascertain whether or not water heretofore filed upon or any claimed riparian or appropriative right is valid under the laws of this state.
(b)(1)In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to this section, the board may issue an information order, as executed by the executive director of the board.
(2)The information order may be issued to a water right holder or claimant to provide the following information related to a diversion and use of water:
(A)Information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).
(B)Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed.
(C)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use, if the claimed right is a riparian right.
(D)Information concerning the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
(E)Information concerning prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
(3)(A)The information order may be issued to a diverter or user of water to provide information concerning that diverters prior diversion or use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage, or identification of the person or holder claiming the right under which the water was diverted or used.
(B)Information obtained under this paragraph from a diverter or user who is not the water right holder or claimant shall not be binding on, or treated as an admission by, the water right holder or claimant.
(c)The burden of any order issued under subdivision (b), including costs, shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained from the board receiving that information. In making a request, the board shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the person to whom the request is directed with a written explanation with regard to the need for the information.
(2)Identify the evidence that supports requiring that person to provide the information.
(d)A diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized may be enforced as a trespass under Section 1052, following notice and opportunity for hearing as required under Section 1052, Section 1055, or Article 2 (commencing with Section 1831) of Chapter 12 of Part 2.
(e)Nothing in this section shall limit any authority held by the board under this code or any other provision of law.
(a)The board for the purpose of this division may:
(1)Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
(2)Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water thereon or therein.
(3)Investigate and ascertain whether or not water heretofore filed upon or any claimed riparian or appropriative right is valid under the laws of this state.
(b)(1)In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to this section, the board may issue an information order, as executed by the executive director of the board, to board.
(2)The information order may be issued to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or user claimant to provide the following information related to a diversion and use of water:
(1)(A)Information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).
(2)(B)Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed.
(3)(C)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use, if the claimed right is a riparian right.
(4)(D)Information concerning the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
(5)(E)Information concerning the prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
(3)(A)The information order may be issued to a diverter or user of water to provide information concerning that diverters prior diversion or use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage, or identification of the person or holder claiming the right under which the water was diverted or used.
(B)Information obtained under this paragraph from a diverter or user who is not the water right holder or claimant shall not be binding on, or treated as an admission by, the water right holder or claimant.
(c)The burden of any order issued under subdivision (b), including costs, shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained from the board receiving that information. In making a request, the board shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the person to whom the request is directed with a written explanation with regard to the need for the information.
(2)Identify the evidence that supports requiring that person to provide the information.
(d)A diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized under this section may be enforced as a trespass under Section 1052. 1052, following notice and opportunity for hearing as required under Section 1052, Section 1055, or Article 2 (commencing with Section 1831) of Chapter 12 of Part 2.
(e)Nothing in this section shall limit any authority held by the board under this code or any other provision of law.
(a)The board for the purpose of this division may:
(a)(1)Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
(b)(2)Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water thereon or therein.
(c)Ascertain(3)Investigate and ascertain whether or not water heretofore filed upon or attempted to be appropriated is appropriated any claimed riparian or appropriative right is valid under the laws of this State. state.
(b)In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to this section, the board may issue an information order, as executed by the executive director of the board, to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or user to provide the following information related to a diversion and use of water:
(1)Information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).
(2)Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed.
(3)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use, if the claimed right is a riparian right.
(4)Information concerning the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
(5)Information concerning the prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
(c)The burden of any order issued under subdivision (b), including costs, shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained from the board receiving that information. In making a request, the board shall do both of the following:
(1)Provide the person to whom the request is directed with a written explanation with regard to the need for the information.
(2)Identify the evidence that supports requiring that person to provide the information.
(d)A diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized under this section may be enforced as a trespass under Section 1052.
(e)Nothing in this section shall limit any authority held by the board under this code or any other provision of law.
SECTION 1.Article 6 (commencing with Section 1860) is added to Chapter 12 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Water Code, to read:6.Determination of Basis of Right1860.Upon a finding that there is reason to believe that the information would protect the public interest or further the state boards responsibilities under Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine, the state board may investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.1861.In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to Section 1860, the state board may issue an information order to a water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide technical reports or other information related to a diversion and use of water, including, but not limited to, all of the following:(a)Information in addition to any information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).(b)Information related to the basis of the water right claimed.(c)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use.(d)Information related to the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.(e)Information related to prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.(f)Information related to the diversions and use of transferred water.1862.After notice and opportunity for hearing, the state board may issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right, including the authorized scope of the diversion and use, or may issue a decision or order determining that the diversion and use is not authorized under any basis of right.1863.In determining under this article whether a holder of an appropriative water right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right pursuant to Sections 1240 and 1241, the state board is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim by any water right holder within the stream system during the period of forfeiture.1864.In any state board proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right under this article, the water right claimant, diverter, or user shall have the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right.1865.Nothing in this article shall limit the authority of the state board to issue any decision or order, or to take any other action authorized by law.1866.The state board may adopt regulations to implement this article.The Upon a finding that there is reason to believe that the information would protect the public interest or further the state boards responsibilities under Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine, the state board may investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
1861.In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to Section 1860, the state board may issue an information order to a water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide technical reports or other information related to a diversion and use of water, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(a)Information in addition to any information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).
(b)Information related to the basis of the water right claimed.
(c)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use.
(d)Information related to the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
(e)Information related to prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
(f)Information related to the diversions and use of transferred water.
1862.After notice and opportunity for hearing, the state board may issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right, including the authorized scope of the diversion and use, or may issue a decision or order determining that the diversion and use is not authorized under any basis of right.
1863.In determining under this article whether a holder of an appropriative water right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right pursuant to Sections 1240 and 1241, the state board is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim by any water right holder within the stream system during the period of forfeiture.
1864.In any state board proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right under this article, the water right claimant, diverter, or user shall have the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right.
1865.Nothing in this article shall limit the authority of the state board to issue any decision or order, or to take any other action authorized by law.
1866.The state board may adopt regulations to implement this article.
The state board may investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
1861.In furtherance of an investigation authorized pursuant to Section 1860, the state board may issue an information order to a water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide technical reports or other information related to a diversion and use of water, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(a)Information in addition to any information required to be reported pursuant to Part 5.1 (commencing with Section 5100).
(b)Information related to the basis of the water right claimed.
(c)Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use.
(d)Information related to the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
(e)Information related to prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
(f)Information related to the diversions and use of transferred water.
1862.After notice and opportunity for hearing, the state board may issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right, including the authorized scope of the diversion and use, or may issue a decision or order determining that the diversion and use is not authorized under any basis of right.
1863.In determining under this article whether a holder of an appropriative water right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right pursuant to Sections 1240 and 1241, the state board is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim by any water right holder within the stream system during the period of forfeiture.
1864.In any state board proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right under this article, the water right claimant, diverter, or user shall have the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right.
1865.Nothing in this article shall limit the authority of the state board to issue any decision or order, or to take any other action authorized by law.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 486, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 8, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Sep 12, 2023 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 30. Noes 8. Page 2632.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 58. Noes 17. Page 2930.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 31, 2023 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 31, 2023 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 17, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 16, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (August 16). |
| Jul 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (July 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 6, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on W., P., & W. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | Referred to Com. on W., P., & W. |
| May 31, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 23. Noes 11. Page 1359.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 1168.) (May 18). |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 8, 2023 | May 8 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 2, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 3. Page 899.) (April 25). |
| Apr 11, 2023 | Set for hearing April 25. |
| Feb 22, 2023 | Referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Feb 10, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 12. |
| Feb 9, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 12, 2023 | Unfinished Business SB389 Allen et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 5, 2023 | SB 389 Allen Senate Third Reading By Bauer-Kahan | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Water, Parks, and Wildlife |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB389 Allen | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| African American Farmers of California | ** Against | |
| Agricultural Council Of California | ** Against | |
| Antelope Valley EastKern Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Association Of California Water Agencies | ** Against | |
| Bella Vista Water District | ** Against | |
| Bellflower Somerset Mutual Water Company | ** Against | |
| Byron-Bethany Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| California Alliance for Jobs | ** Against | |
| California Association Of Winegrape Growers | ** Against | |
| California Builders Alliance | ** Against | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Against | |
| California Cattlemen'S Association | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Climate Reality Coalition | ** Support | |
| California Coastkeeper Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association | ** Against | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| California Farm Bureau Federation | ** Against | |
| California Fresh Fruit Association | ** Against | |
| California Manufacturers And Technology Association | ** Against | |
| California Municipal Utilities Association | ** Against | |
| California Outdoors | ** Support | |
| California Sportfishing Protection Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Walnut Commission | ** Against | |
| California Water Research | ** Support | |
| Carmichael Water District | ** Against | |
| City of Corona | ** Against | |
| City of Fairfield | ** Against | |
| City of Foster City | ** Against | |
| City of Mountain View | ** Against | |
| City of Roseville | ** Against | |
| Clean Water Action | ** Support | |
| Climate Action California | ** Support | |
| Climate Reality Project, Los Angeles Chapter | ** Support | |
| Climate Reality Project: San Fernando Valley Chapter | ** Support | |
| Coachella Valley Water District | ** Against | |
| Coast Action Group | ** Support | |
| Coastside County Water District | ** Against | |
| Contra Costa Water District | ** Against | |
| County of Fresno | ** Against | |
| County of San Joaquin | ** Against | |
| County Of Stanislaus | ** Against | |
| County of Tulare | ** Against | |
| Cucamonga Valley Water District | ** Against | |
| Defenders Of Wildlife | ** Support | |
| Desert Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Dunnigan Water District | ** Against | |
| East Turlock Subbasin Groundwater Sustainability Agency | ** Against | |
| El Dorado Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Elk Grove Water District | ** Against | |
| Elsinore Valley Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| Florin Resource Conservation District | ** Against | |
| Florin Resource Conservation District/elk Grove Water District | ** Against | |
| Friant Water Authority | ** Against | |
| Friends of the River | ** Support | |
| Humboldt Bay Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| Imperial Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Jerry Dyer, Mayor of City of Fresno | ** Against | |
| Karuk Tribe | ** Support | |
| Kern County Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Kings River Conservation District | ** Against | |
| Kings River Water Association | ** Against | |
| Lake Arrowhead Community Services District | ** Against | |
| London Breed, Mayor Of San Francisco | ** Against | |
| Manteca Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| McKinleyville Community Services District | ** Against | |
| Mesa Water District | ** Against | |
| Modesto Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Mojave Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Mono Lake Committee | ** Support | |
| montecito water district | ** Against | |
| Mountain Counties Water Resources Association | ** Against | |
| Napa County Flood Control And Water Conservation District | ** Against | |
| Natural Heritage Institute | ** Support | |
| Nisei Farmers League | ** Against | |
| Nisei Farmers League Inc. | ** Against | |
| Northern California Council Fly Fishers International | ** Support | |
| Northern California Water Association | ** Against | |
| Oakdale Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Orange County Water District | ** Against | |
| Pacific Coast Federation Of Fishermen'S Associations | ** Support | |
| Palmdale Water District | ** Against | |
| Pinedale County Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Placer County Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Planning And Conservation League | ** Support | |
| Rancho California Water District | ** Against | |
| Restore the Delta | ** Support | |
| Rosedale-Rio Bravo Water Storage District | ** Against | |
| Rowland Water District | ** Against | |
| Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange | ** Against | |
| Sacramento River Council | ** Support | |
| San Diego County Water Authority | ** Against | |
| San Francisco Baykeeper | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Public Utilities Commission | ** Against | |
| San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| San Gorgonio Pass Water Agency | ** Against | |
| San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority | ** Against | |
| San Juan Water District | ** Against | |
| San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority | ** Against | |
| San Mateo County Democracy for America | ** Support | |
| Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Santa Margarita Water District | ** Against | |
| Sierra Club California | ** Support | |
| Solano County Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| Solano County Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Solano Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Southern California Water Coalition | ** Against | |
| South San Joaquin Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| State Water Contractors, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Stockton East Water District | ** Against | |
| Sweetwater Authority | ** Against | |
| Tehachapi-cummings County Water District | ** Against | |
| The Wine Institute | ** Against | |
| Three Valleys Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| Tranquillity Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Tri-County Water Authority | ** Against | |
| Trout Unlimited | ** Support | |
| Tulare Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Tuolumne County Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Tuolumne River Trust | ** Support | |
| Tuolumne Utilities District | ** Against | |
| Turlock Irrigation District | ** Against | |
| Union Of Concerned Scientists | ** Support | |
| United Water Conservation District | ** Against | |
| Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| Valley Ag Water Coalition | ** Against | |
| Valley Center Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| Walnut Valley Water District | ** Against | |
| Water Foundation | ** Support | |
| Water Replenishment District | ** Support | |
| Western Agricultural Processors Association | ** Against | |
| Western Canal Water District | ** Against | |
| Western Growers Association | ** Against | |
| Western Municipal Water District | ** Against | |
| Wholly H2O | ** Support | |
| Yuba Water Agency | ** Against |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 389 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 389
Author: Allen (D), et al.
Amended: 8/31/23
Vote: 21
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 6-3, 4/25/23
AYES: Min, Allen, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, Padilla
NOES: Seyarto, Dahle, Eggman
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove, Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SENATE FLOOR: 23-11, 5/30/23
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Durazo, Gonzalez, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Alvarado-Gil, Cortese, Dahle, Eggman, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Glazer, Hurtado, Rubio
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-17, 9/5/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: State Water Resources Control Board: determination of water right
SOURCE: Planning and Conservation League
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to investigate and ascertain whether or not a water right is valid, authorizes SWRCB to issue an information order in furtherance of the investigation, and authorizes a diversion of use of water ascertained to be unauthorized to be enforced as a trespass. .
Assembly Amendments
revise and recast the bill to instead authorize SWRCB to investigate and ascertain the validity of a water right, rather than authorizing SWRCB to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use is based on appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right; require that the burden of any information order issued bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information; provides that an unauthorized diversion or use or water may be enforced as a trespass, following notice and opportunity for hearing, as specified; and remove SWRCB's authority to adopt regulations.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Declares that the general welfare requires that the water resources of the State be put to beneficial use to the fullest extent of which they are capable, and that waste or unreasonable use or unreasonable method of use of water be prevented, and that the conservation of such waters is to be exercised with a view to the reasonable and beneficial use therefore in the interest of the people and for the public welfare. (Section 2, Article X, California Constitution)
- Authorizes SWRCB to:
- Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
- Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water.
- Ascertain whether or not water filed upon or attempted to be appropriated is appropriated under the laws of the state. (Water Code (Wat. C.) §1051)
- Authorizes SWRCB to determine all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right upon petition by a claimant to water of the steam system requesting the determination of the rights of the various claimants to the water of that stream system. Requires SWRCB to comply with specific notice, proceeding, and investigation processes and requires claimants to notify SWRCB of their intention to file proof of claim and to submit proof of their respective claims. (Wat. C. §§2500 et seq.)
- Requires each person who diverts water to file with SWRCB a statement of their diversion and use except that a statement is not required in specific circumstances. (Wat. C. §5101)
This bill:
- Authorizes SWRCB to investigate and ascertain whether or not wter filed upon or any claimed riparian or appropriative right is valid
- Authorizes SWRCB, in furtherance of this investigation, to issue an information order, as executed by SWRCB’s executive director, to a water right holder, claimant, diverter of water, or user of water, as specified.
- Requires the burden of any information order to bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained from receiving that information.
- Authorizes a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized to be enforced as a trespass, as specified, following notice and opportunity for hearing, as specified.
Background
- California’s water rights system. A February 3, 2022, paper entitled, “Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change” (paper), which was drafted by water law experts convened by the Planning & Conservation League, proposes various recommendations on how the state’s water laws can be updated to address the impacts of drought and climate change. The paper also provides an overview of the state’s water rights system:
“Unlike other western states, California has a patchwork system for allocating surface water that divides the right to water between statutory water rights issued and regulated by the State Water Resources Control Board [SWRCB] or its predecessors under the Water Commission Act of 1913 and water rights recognized prior to the act’s 1914 effective date. With some exceptions, surface water rights recognized prior to 1914 are limited to riparian rights, rights derived from ownership of land adjacent to a watercourse, and pre-1914 appropriative rights, rights unrelated to land ownership secured through application of the Gold Rush mining customs of water diversion and delivery to beneficial use.
In times of shortage, the priority principle of first in time, first in right generally determines the allocation of pre-1914 and post-1914 appropriative rights. In contrast, riparians mutually share shortages with other riparians. (Millview County Water District v. State Water Resources Control Board, 229 CalApp.4th 879, 888-889 (2014).) The priority of riparian rights over other rights depends upon the date of the land patent for the riparian land. (McKinley Brothers v. McCauley, 215 Cal. 229, 230-231 (1922).) Neither holders of riparian nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from [SWRCB].
Due to these historical circumstances, riparian rights and pre-1914 appropriative rights typically hold a senior priority to post-1914 appropriative rights and are entitled to satisfaction in times of shortage over the claims of post-1914 rights. … Because [SWRCB] does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood.”
[NOTE: See the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee policy analysis for additional background information.]
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed’s diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, SB 389 provides information-gathering and enforcement tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed’s reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 460 (Bauer-Kahan, 2023), among other things, authorizes SWRCB the authority to issue an interim relief order to apply or enforce specified provisions of law related to water rights and quality. AB 460 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
AB 1337 (Wicks, 2023) SWRCB to issue a curtailment order for any diversion when water is not available under the diverter’s priority of right. AB 1337 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According the Assembly Appropriations Committee,
“The [SWRCB] estimates costs to be minor and absorbable (Water Rights Fund) and notes that while there would likely be some increase in workload when conducting the new investigative and enforcement activities, the work would be incorporated into the [SWRCB’s] existing processes and would potentially streamline other enforcement actions.”
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/11/23)
Planning and Conservation League (source)
California Climate Reality Coalition
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Voters
California Outdoors
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
California Water Research
Clean Water Action
Climate Action California
Climate Reality Project, Los Angeles Chapter
Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley Chapter
Coast Action Group
Defenders of Wildlife
Friends of The River
Karuk Tribe
Mono Lake Committee
Natural Heritage Institute
Northern California Council, Fly Fishers International
Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations
Restore the Delta
Sacramento River Council
San Francisco Baykeeper
San Mateo County Democracy for America
Sierra Club California
Trout Unlimited
Tuolumne River Trust
Union of Concerned Scientists
Water Foundation
Water Replenishment District
Wholly H2O
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/23)
Agricultural Council of California
Antelope Valley East-Kern Water Agency
Bella Vista Water District
California Alliance for Jobs
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Builders Alliance
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
Carmichael Water District
City of Fairfield
Coachella Valley Water District
Coastside County Water District
County of Fresno
County of San Joaquin
County of Tulare
Cucamonga Valley Water District
East Turlock Subbasin Groundwater Sustainability Agency
Elk Grove Water District
Florin Resource Conservation District
Friant Water Authority
Humboldt Bay Municipal Water District
Jerry Dyer, Mayor of City of Fresno
Kern County Water Agency
Kings River Conservation District
Kings River Water Association
Lake Arrowhead Community Services District
McKinleyville Community Services District
Modesto Irrigation District
Mojave Water Agency
Montecito Water District
Mountain Counties Water Resources Association
Napa County Flood Control and Water Conservation District
Orange County Water District
Pinedale County Water Agency
Placer County Water Agency
Rosedale-Rio Bravo Water Storage District
Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange
San Diego County Water Authority
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Gorgonio PASS Water Agency
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Juan Water District
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Margarita Water District
Solano County Board of Supervisors
Solano Irrigation District
State Water Contractors, Inc.
Stockton East Water District
Sweetwater Authority
Tehachapi-Cummings County Water District
Tranquillity Irrigation District
Tri-County Water Authority
Tulare Irrigation District
Tuolumne County Water Agency
Tuolumne Utilities District
United Water Conservation District
Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
Valley Center Municipal Water District
Western Canal Water District
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to a coalition letter including, among others, Planning and Conservation League (sponsor), Wholly H2O, California Environmental Voters, Defenders of Wildlife, and Sierra Club California, “The Water Board presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Reforms allowing the Water Board to verify these claimed water rights could make water available for more junior water rights holders and for fishery or other beneficial uses of water in times of scarcity.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the Contra Costa Water District, “Substantive changes to the state’s water rights will have ripple effects with unintended consequences to what is a complex system. CCWD encourages legislators to consider holding additional hearings and forming working groups to bring water agency leaders operating under the existing water rights system together to discuss modifications that will achieve shared goals to protect water users and the environment.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-17, 9/5/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Alanis, Bains, Chen, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Mathis, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron, Wallis
NO VOTE RECORDED: Davies, McCarty, Papan, Jim Patterson, Villapudua
Prepared by: Genevieve Wong / N.R. & W. / (916) 651-4116
9/12/23 10:22:15
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 389
Author:(Allen)
As Amended Ver:August 31, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) to issue an information order to ascertain whether any claimed water right is valid, including pre-1914 appropriative or riparian rights.
Major Provisions
- Provides that the State Water Board may investigate whether any claimed water right is valid under the laws of California, which includes riparian and pre-1914 rights.
- Authorizes the State Water Board to issue an information order to a water right holder or claimant requesting the following:
- Information required to be reported in a statement of water diversion and use;
- Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed;
- Information related to the patent date claimed for place of use, in the case of a riparian right;
- Information concerning the notice and date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use; and
- Information concerning the prior diversion and use.
- Authorizes the State Water Board to issue an information order to a diverter or water user to obtain information regarding the diverter's prior water use or to identify the water right holder or claimant of the water being used by the diverter. Provides that information obtained by a diverter or water user shall not be binding on a water right holder or claimant.
- Provides that a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized may be enforced as a trespass.
COMMENTS
Some scholars have dubbed California's legal framework for surface water rights the "California doctrine" (Worster, 1985) and it is unique among all other states in that it recognizes both riparian and appropriative rights. The coexistence of the two types of surface water rights dates to the very beginning of California's statehood and was affirmed by the California Supreme Court in the 1886 landmark case Lux v. Haggin that recognized the legitimacy of both types of rights but determined "that riparian rights have priority over appropriative rights in most instances" (Littleworth and Garner, 2019).
In 1913, the Legislature passed the Water Commission Act that established today's framework for obtaining a permit and license for the appropriation of surface water resources. Under the Water Commission Act, the Water Commission (the predecessor to the State Water Board) had sole jurisdiction to issue a right to use unappropriated surface waters. The Act recognized that water rights obtained prior to its passage were still valid. This established another important distinction in appropriative surface water rights: those obtain before 1914 ("pre-1914 rights") and those obtained thereafter. There is limited information regarding pre-1914 surface water rights, as rights holders did not obtain a permit or license from the State Water Board, and until recently, did not report volume of use to the State Water Board (Grantham and Viers, 2014).
Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change (February 2022). This report asserts that "California's current system of water laws is ill-equipped to respond to modern water shortages. California's water laws need to be reassessed to address today's challenges, safeguard the health, safety, and livelihoods of California's 40 million residents, support its economy, and protect California's imperiled ecosystems." This bill is based on the report's recommendation (#6) to provide the State Water Board with authority to verify the validity of pre-1914 appropriative and riparian water rights.
Regarding its recommendation #6, the Updating California Water Laws report states: "The State Board presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Section 1051 of the Water Code grants the State Board the general authority to investigate stream systems but does not explicitly grant the power to verify the water rights of users claiming rights outside of the Water Commission Act [Water Code Section 1051]. Sections 2500 through 2900 of the Water Code allow the State Board to 'determine…all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian rights, or other basis of rights,' proceedings commonly known as statutory adjudications [Water Code Section 2501]. However, these sections do not allow the State Board to initiate an adjudication of rights to a stream system. Only claimants to water from the stream may initiate a statutory adjudication [Water Code Section 2525]. Furthermore, the sections do not allow the State Board to determine the rights of individual diverters or a narrow set of diverters."
According to the Author
This bill is intended to provide the State Water Board with more tools to determine whether senior water right claimants who assert riparian or pre-1914 appropriative rights have defensible ground for their diversion and use of water. According to the author, "In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed's diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, [this bill] provides information-gathering tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed's reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses."
Arguments in Support
The Planning and Conservation League (PCL) is the sponsor of this bill and argues that this bill gives the State Water Board an important tool to verify water rights and ensure that water is used judiciously in an era of increasing scarcity. PCL points out that "neither holders of riparian rights nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from the Water Board…. Because the Water Board does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood." PCL cites one study that suggests holders of these senior water rights account for the diversion of at least 2.3 million AF of water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed. PCL maintains that this bill addresses this gap in the State Water Board's authority and will allow it "to better manage the system for the benefit of all users, and the ecology of California's many beautiful streams."
Arguments in Opposition
The South San Joaquin Irrigation District (SSJID) has an "oppose unless amended" position on this bill and seeks a language change regarding how this bill refers to existing enforcement authority held by the State Water Board.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, "the State Water Board estimates costs to be minor and absorbable (Water Rights Fund) and notes that while there would likely be some increase in workload when conducting the new investigative and enforcement activities, the work would be incorporated into the State Water Board's existing processes and would potentially streamline other enforcement actions."
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 23-11-6
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Durazo, Gonzalez, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Cortese, Dahle, Eggman, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Glazer, Hurtado, Rubio
ASM WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE: 9-3-3
YES: Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Friedman, Hart, Kalra, Pellerin, Schiavo, Ward, Weber
NO: Mathis, Alanis, Megan Dahle
ABS, ABST OR NV: Davies, Blanca Rubio, Villapudua
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Soria
UPDATED
VERSION: August 31, 2023
CONSULTANT: Pablo Garza / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096 FN: 0001417
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 389
Author:(Allen)
As Amended Ver:July 6, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) to issue an information order to ascertain whether any claimed water right is valid, including pre-1914 appropriative or riparian rights.
Major Provisions
- Provides that the State Water Board may investigate whether any claimed water right is valid under the laws of California, which includes riparian and pre-1914 rights.
- Authorizes the State Water Board to issue an information order, executed by the Executive Director, to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or water user requesting the following:
- Information required to be reported in a statement of water diversion and use;
- Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed;
- Information related to the patent date claimed for place of use, in the case of a riparian right;
- Information concerning the notice and date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use; and
- Information concerning the prior diversion and use.
- Provides that the burden, including costs, of any information order issued shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained by the State Water Board in receiving the requested information.
- Provides that a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized may be enforced as a trespass.
COMMENTS
Some scholars have dubbed California's legal framework for surface water rights the "California doctrine" (Worster, 1985) and it is unique among all other states in that it recognizes both riparian and appropriative rights. The coexistence of the two types of surface water rights dates to the very beginning of California's statehood and was affirmed by the California Supreme Court in the 1886 landmark case Lux v. Haggin that recognized the legitimacy of both types of rights but determined "that riparian rights have priority over appropriative rights in most instances" (Littleworth and Garner, 2019).
In 1913, the Legislature passed the Water Commission Act that established today's framework for obtaining a permit and license for the appropriation of surface water resources. Under the Water Commission Act, the Water Commission (the predecessor to the State Water Board) had sole jurisdiction to issue a right to use unappropriated surface waters. The Act recognized that water rights obtained prior to its passage were still valid. This established another important distinction in appropriative surface water rights: those obtain before 1914 ("pre-1914 rights") and those obtained thereafter. There is limited information regarding pre-1914 surface water rights, as rights holders did not obtain a permit or license from the State Water Board, and until recently, did not report volume of use to the State Water Board (Grantham and Viers, 2014).
Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change (February 2022). A group of legal scholars and individuals with decades of experience in California's water sector released a series of recommendations to update California's water rights laws in response to drought and climate change. The authors note that nearly 1 million Californians lack access to safe drinking water, domestic wells have been going dry at an unprecedented rate, and more than 100 freshwater-dependent species of plants and wildlife are listed as threatened or endangered under state and federal protection laws, including 18 native fish species that are "highly vulnerable to extinction." The report asserts that "California's current system of water laws is ill-equipped to respond to modern water shortages. California's water laws need to be reassessed to address today's challenges, safeguard the health, safety, and livelihoods of California's 40 million residents, support its economy, and protect California's imperiled ecosystems." This bill is based on the report's recommendation (#6) to provide the State Water Board with authority to verify the validity of pre-1914 appropriative and riparian water rights.
Regarding its recommendation #6, the Updating California Water Laws report states: "The State Board presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Section 1051 of the Water Code grants the State Board the general authority to investigate stream systems but does not explicitly grant the power to verify the water rights of users claiming rights outside of the Water Commission Act [Water Code § 1051]. Sections 2500 through 2900 of the Water Code allow the State Board to 'determine…all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian rights, or other basis of rights,' proceedings commonly known as statutory adjudications [Water Code § 2501]. However, these sections do not allow the State Board to initiate an adjudication of rights to a stream system. Only claimants to water from the stream may initiate a statutory adjudication [Water Code § 2525]. Furthermore, the sections do not allow the State Board to determine the rights of individual diverters or a narrow set of diverters."
According to the Author
This bill is intended to provide the State Water Board with more tools to determine whether senior water right claimants who assert riparian or pre-1914 appropriative rights have defensible ground for their diversion and use of water. According to the author, "In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed's diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, [this bill] provides information-gathering tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed's reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses."
Arguments in Support
The Planning and Conservation League (PCL) is the sponsor of this bill and argues that this bill gives the State Water Board an important tool to verify water rights and ensure that water is used judiciously in an era of increasing scarcity. PCL points out that "neither holders of riparian rights nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from the Water Board…. Because the Water Board does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood." PCL cites one study that suggests holders of these senior water rights account for the diversion of at least 2.3 million AF of water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed. PCL maintains that this bill addresses this gap in the State Water Board's authority and will allow it "to better manage the system for the benefit of all users, and the ecology of California's many beautiful streams."
Arguments in Opposition
Several letters of opposition have been submitted on the previous version of this bill. These letters specifically mention the forfeiture and burden of proof provisions that were removed by the July 6, 2023 amendments. It is not clear if these parties still have concerns with this bill.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, "the State Water Board estimates costs to be minor and absorbable (Water Rights Fund) and notes that while there would likely be some increase in workload when conducting the new investigative and enforcement activities, the work would be incorporated into the State Water Board's existing processes and would potentially streamline other enforcement actions."
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 23-11-6
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Durazo, Gonzalez, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Cortese, Dahle, Eggman, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Glazer, Hurtado, Rubio
ASM WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE: 9-3-3
YES: Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Friedman, Hart, Kalra, Pellerin, Schiavo, Ward, Weber
NO: Mathis, Alanis, Megan Dahle
ABS, ABST OR NV: Davies, Blanca Rubio, Villapudua
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-1
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Dixon, Mathis, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Soria
UPDATED
VERSION: July 6, 2023
CONSULTANT: Pablo Garza / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096 FN: 0001264
Date of Hearing: August 16, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 389
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:July 6, 2023
Policy Committee: | Water, Parks and Wildlife | Vote: | 9 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) to issue an information order to ascertain whether any claimed water right is valid, including pre-1914 appropriative or riparian rights.
Specifically, this bill, among other things:
- Authorizes the State Water Board to investigate and ascertain whether any claimed riparian or appropriative water right is valid under state law.
- Authorizes the State Water Board, in furtherance of an investigation authorized by this bill, to issue an information order, executed by the executive director of the State Water Board, to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or user, that requests the following:
- Information required to be reported in a statement of water diversion and use.
- Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed.
- Information related to the patent date claimed for place of use, in the case of a riparian right.
- Information concerning the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
- Information concerning the prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
- Provides that the burden, including costs, of any information order issued (as described in 2, above), shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained from the State Water Board in receiving the requested information.
- Requires the State Water Board to do the following when issuing an information order pursuant to this bill: (a) provide the person to whom the request is directed with a written explanation regarding the need for the information, and (b) identify the evidence that supports requiring the person to provide the requested information.
- Provides that a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized under this bill may be enforced as a trespass.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The State Water Board estimates costs to be minor and absorbable (Water Rights Fund) and notes that while there would likely be some increase in workload when conducting the new investigative and enforcement activities, the work would be incorporated into the State Water Board’s existing processes and would potentially streamline other enforcement actions.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. According to the author:
In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed’s diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, [this bill] provides information-gathering tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed’s reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses.
2) Background.
California’s Water Rights System. As detailed in the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee analysis of this bill, California’s legal framework for surface water rights recognizes both riparian and appropriative rights. Riparian rights – which have priority over appropriative rights in most instances – are attached to land that is contiguous to a river, stream, or other natural water course and permit a landowner to put the water to beneficial use on their land. Appropriative rights, in contrast, are not tied to land ownership and do not require the holder to use the water on land adjacent to the body of water. The doctrine of prior appropriation (also known as “first in time, first in right”) applies to appropriative rights and is a seniority system that still applies today. Under prior appropriation, a junior water right holder (one that claimed a right at a date after a senior water right claimant) will have their right curtailed, or cut back, in times of shortage before the next claimant has their right curtailed.
In 1913, the Legislature passed the Water Commission Act that established today’s framework for obtaining a permit and license for the appropriation of surface water resources. Under the Water Commission Act, the Water Commission (the predecessor to the State Water Board) had sole jurisdiction to issue a right to use unappropriated surface waters. The Act recognized that water rights obtained prior to its passage were still valid. This established another important distinction in appropriative surface water rights: those obtained before 1914 (“pre-1914 rights”) and those obtained thereafter. There is limited information regarding pre-1914 surface water rights, as rights holders did not obtain a permit or license from the State Water Board, and until recently, did not report volume of use to the State Water Board.
2022 Report. A group of legal scholars and individuals released a series of recommendations in a February 2022 report titled “Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change” to update California’s water rights laws in response to drought and climate change. This bill is based on the report’s recommendation (#6) to provide the State Water Board with authority to verify the validity of pre-1914 appropriative and riparian water rights.
Recent amendments. The most recent amendments removed what would have been a new authority for the State Water Board to “determine” the validity of water rights. Instead, the bill expands the State Water Board’s existing authority to investigate and “ascertain” whether water has a valid claim or appropriative water right for its use. This change has the effect of slightly expanding the State Water Board’s existing authority to ascertain water availability, by allowing investigation of claims of riparian as well as appropriative rights.
3) Related Legislation. AB 460 (Bauer-Kahan), among other things, grants the State Water Board the authority to issue an interim relief order to apply or enforce specified provisions of law related to water rights and quality. AB 460 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
AB 1337 (Wicks) authorizes the State Water Board to issue a curtailment order for any diversion, regardless of basis of right, when water is not available under the diverter’s priority of right. AB 1337 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Nikita Koraddi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 389
Author:(Allen) – As Amended Ver:July 6, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 23-11
SUBJECT: State Water Resources Control Board: investigation of water right
SUMMARY: Authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) to issue an information order to ascertain whether any claimed water right is valid, including pre-1914 appropriative or riparian rights. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that the State Water Board may investigate whether any claimed water rightis valid under the laws of California, which includes riparian and pre-1914 rights.
- Authorizes the State Water Board to issue an information order, executed by the Executive Director, to a water right holder or claimant, diverter, or water user requesting the following:
- Information required to be reported in a statement of water diversion and use;
- Information concerning the basis of the water right claimed;
- Information related to the patent date claimed for place of use, in the case of a riparian right;
- Information concerning the notice and date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use; and
- Information concerning the prior diversion and use.
- Provides that the burden, including costs, of any information order issued (as described in #2, above), shall bear a reasonable relationship to the need for the requested information and the benefits to be obtained by the State Water Board in receiving the requested information. The State Water Board shall do the following when issuing an information order pursuant to this bill:
- Provide the person to whom the request is directed with a written explanation regarding the need for the information; and
- Identify the evidence that supports requiring the person to provide the requested information.
- Provides that a diversion or use of water ascertained to be unauthorized may be enforced as a trespass.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill limits any authority held under any other provision of law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the State Water Board to investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water and ascertain whether or not water filed upon or attempted to be appropriated is appropriated under the laws of the state (Water Code § 1051).
- Provides that the diversion or use of water other than as authorized is a trespass and a person committing trespass may be civilly liable, as specified (Water Code § 1052).
- Requires that an appropriation of water must be for some useful or beneficial purpose, and when the appropriator or their successor in interest ceases to use it for such purposes the right ceases (Water Code § 1240).
- Provides that if a person entitled to the use of water fails to beneficially use all or any part of the water claimed by them, for which a right of use has vested, for the purpose for which it was appropriated or adjudicated, for a period of five years, that unused water may revert to the public and shall, if reverted, be regarded as unappropriated public water (Water Code § 1241).
- Authorizes the State Water Board to determine all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right upon petition by a claimant to water of the stream system requesting the determination of the rights of the various claimants to the water of that stream system (i.e., statutory adjudication). Requires the State Water Board to comply with specific notice, proceeding, and investigation processes and requires claimants to notify the State Water Board of their intention to file proof of claim and to submit proof of their respective claims (Water Code § 2500 et seq.).
- Requires each person who diverts water to file a statement of their diversion and use (“statement of water use and diversion") with the State Water Board unless exempted, for example small domestic or small irrigation use registrations (Water Code § 5101).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill. This bill is intended to provide the State Water Board with more tools to determine whether senior water right claimants who assert riparian or pre-1914 appropriative rights have defensible ground for their diversion and use of water. According to the author, “In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed’s diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, [this bill] provides information-gathering tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed’s reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses.”
- Background. Some scholars have dubbed California’s legal framework for surface water rights the “California doctrine”[1] and it is unique among all other states in that it recognizes both riparian and appropriative rights. The coexistence of the two types of surface water rights dates to the very beginning of California’s statehood and was affirmed by the California Supreme Court in the 1886 landmark case Lux v. Haggin that recognized the legitimacy of both types of rights but determined “that riparian rights have priority over appropriative rights in most instances.”[2]
Riparian rights are attached to land that is contiguous to a river, stream, or other natural water course and permit a landowner to put the water to beneficial use on their land. Riparian rights derive from English common law which the California Legislature adopted in 1850.[3] Appropriative rights, in contrast, are not tied to land ownership and do not require the holder to use the water on land adjacent to the body of water. Appropriative rights “arose in mining camps on public lands where no one could own the land and thus no one could get a riparian right.”[4]
The doctrine of prior appropriation (also known as “first in time, first in right”) applies to appropriative rights and is a seniority system that still applies today. Under prior appropriation, a junior water right holder (i.e., one that claimed a right at a date after a senior water right claimant) will have their right curtailed, or cut back, in times of shortage before the next claimant has their right curtailed. Like riparian rights, appropriative rights were recognized shortly after California became a state: first in the 1855 California Supreme Court case Irwin v. Phillips and later by an act of the Legislature in 1872.[5]
In 1913, the Legislature passed the Water Commission Act that established today’s framework for obtaining a permit and license for the appropriation of surface water resources. Under the Water Commission Act, the Water Commission (the predecessor to the State Water Board) had sole jurisdiction to issue a right to use unappropriated surface waters. The Act recognized that water rights obtained prior to its passage were still valid. This established another important distinction in appropriative surface water rights: those obtain before 1914 (“pre-1914 rights”) and those obtained thereafter. There is limited information regarding pre-1914 surface water rights, as rights holders did not obtain a permit or license from the State Water Board, and until recently, did not report volume of use to the State Water Board.[6]
Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change (February 2022). A group of legal scholars and individuals with decades of experience in California’s water sector released a series of recommendations to update California’s water rights laws in response to drought and climate change. The authors note that nearly 1 million Californians lack access to safe drinking water, domestic wells have been going dry at an unprecedented rate, and more than 100 freshwater-dependent species of plants and wildlife are listed as threatened or endangered under state and federal protection laws, including 18 native fish species that are “highly vulnerable to extinction.” The report asserts that “California’s current system of water laws is ill-equipped to respond to modern water shortages. California’s water laws need to be reassessed to address today’s challenges, safeguard the health, safety, and livelihoods of California’s 40 million residents, support its economy, and protect California’s imperiled ecosystems.” This bill is based on the report’s recommendation (#6) to provide the State Water Board with authority to verify the validity of pre-1914 appropriative and riparian water rights.
Regarding its recommendation #6, the Updating California Water Laws report states: “The State Board presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Section 1051 of the Water Code grants the State Board the general authority to investigate stream systems but does not explicitly grant the power to verify the water rights of users claiming rights outside of the Water Commission Act [Water Code § 1051). Sections 2500 through 2900 of the Water Code allow the State Board to ‘determine…all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian rights, or other basis of rights,’ proceedings commonly known as statutory adjudications [Water Code § 2501]. However, these sections do not allow the State Board to initiate an adjudication of rights to a stream system. Only claimants to water from the stream may initiate a statutory adjudication [Water Code § 2525]. Furthermore, the sections do not allow the State Board to determine the rights of individual diverters or a narrow set of diverters.” - Recent amendments. The most recent amendments removed what would have been a new authority for the State Water Board to “determine” the validity of water rights. Instead, the bill expands the State Water Board’s existing authority to investigate and “ascertain” whether water has a valid claim or appropriative water right for its use. This change has the effect of slightly expanding the State Water Board’s existing authority to ascertain water availability, by allowing investigation of claims of riparian as well as appropriative rights. It deletes this bill’s previous language on allowing legal determinations of water rights, shifting to a lesser authority to ascertain, factually, whether the water itself has a legal claim on it.
Established Burden of Proof. The recent amendments also delete a provision that would have statutorily imposed the burden of proof on the water right claimant. Due to these amendments, courts will instead rely on common law if any disputes arise from State Water Board investigations into a given party’s basis of right pursuant to this bill. Presumably, courts will apply the long-standing legal principle that the water right claimant “has the burden of proving every element of the right that he claims. The burden is upon him ‘to establish by sufficient evidence the fact of appropriation by him to beneficial use upon his land.’” W.A. Hutchins, The California Law of Water Rights, p. 282 (1956), quoting Crane v. Stevenson, 5 Cal 2d 387, 398 (1936). - Arguments in support. The Planning and Conservation League (PCL) is the sponsor of this bill and argues that this bill gives the State Water Board an important tool to verify water rights and ensure that water is used judiciously in an era of increasing scarcity. PCL points out that “neither holders of riparian rights nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from the Water Board…. Because the Water Board does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood.” PCL cites one study that suggests holders of these senior water rights account for the diversion of at least 2.3 million AF of water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed. PCL maintains that this bill addresses this gap in the State Water Board’s authority and will allow it “to better manage the system for the benefit of all users, and the ecology of California’s many beautiful streams.”
- Arguments in opposition. The Committee has received several letters of opposition to the previous version of this bill. These letters specifically mention the forfeiture and burden of proof provisions that the recent amendments have removed. It is not clear if these parties still have concerns with this bill.
- Oppose unless amended. The Contra Costa Water District has taken an “oppose unless amended” position on this bill noting “significant concerns about language in the bill that places the burden of proof solely on the water rights holder.” Recent amendments may have addressed this concern.
- Related legislation. AB 1337 (Wicks) of the current legislative session authorizes the State Water Board to issues a curtailment order for any diversion, regardless of basis of right, when water is not available under the diverter’s priority of right. AB 1337 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
AB 460 (Bauer-Kahan) of the current legislative session grants the State Water board authority to issue an interim relief order to enforce the reasonable use doctrine, water rights, water quality standards, and other provisions of law. AB 460 is pending in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
SB 1205 (Allen), Chapter 369, Statutes of 2022, requires the State Water Board to adopt regulations that specify methodology for, and incorporate consideration of climate change effects into, water availability analyses required for the issuance and administration of water right permits.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Planning and Conservation League (sponsor)
California Climate Reality Coalition
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Voters
California Outdoors
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
California Water Research
Clean Water Action
Climate Action California
Climate Reality Project, Los Angeles Chapter
Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley Chapter
Coast Action Group
Defenders of Wildlife
Friends of The River
Mono Lake Committee
Natural Heritage Institute
Northern California Council, Fly Fishers International
Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations
Restore the Delta
Sacramento River Council
San Francisco Baykeeper
Sierra Club California
Trout Unlimited
Tuolumne River Trust
Union of Concerned Scientists
Water Foundation
Wholly H2o
Oppose Unless Amended
Contra Costa Water District
Opposition
California Cattlemen's Association
City of Corona
City of Foster City
City of Mountain View
County of Fresno
County of San Joaquin
County of Solano
County of Stanislaus
County of Tulare
Modesto Irrigation District
Mountain Counties Water Resources Association
Analysis Prepared by: Pablo Garza / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096
Donald Worster, Rivers of Empire, (New York: Oxford University Press, 1985), 107. ↑
Arthur Littleworth and Eric Garner, California Water Law, 3rd Edition, (Point Arena: Solano Press Books, 2019), 41. ↑
Ibid., 40. ↑
Ibid., 50. ↑
Ibid., 51. ↑
Theodore Grantham and Joshua Viers, “100 years of California’s water rights system: patterns, trends and uncertainty,” Environmental Research Letters, 9 (2014): 3, https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/9/8/084012. ↑
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 389 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 389
Author: Allen (D)
Amended: 4/27/23
Vote: 21
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 6-3, 4/25/23
AYES: Min, Allen, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, Padilla
NOES: Seyarto, Dahle, Eggman
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove, Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: State Water Resources Control Board: determination of water right
SOURCE: Planning and Conservation League
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB), upon making a certain finding, to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based on upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Declares that the general welfare requires that the water resources of the State be put to beneficial use to the fullest extent of which they are capable, and that waste or unreasonable use or unreasonable method of use of water be prevented, and that the conservation of such waters is to be exercised with a view to the reasonable and beneficial use therefore in the interest of the people and for the public welfare. (Section 2, Article X, California Constitution)
- Authorizes SWRCB to:
- Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
- Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water.
- Ascertain whether or not water filed upon or attempted to be appropriated is appropriated under the laws of the state. (Water Code (Wat. C.) §1051)
- Authorizes SWRCB to determine all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right upon petition by a claimant to water of the steam system requesting the determination of the rights of the various claimants to the water of that stream system. Requires SWRCB to comply with specific notice, proceeding, and investigation processes and requires claimants to notify SWRCB of their intention to file proof of claim and to submit proof of their respective claims. (Wat. C. §§2500 et seq.)
- Requires each person who diverts water to file with SWRCB a statement of their diversion and use except that a statement is not required in specific circumstances. (Wat. C. §5101)
This bill:
- Authorizes SWRCB, upon a finding that there is reason to believe that the information would protect the public interest or further state board’s responsibilities under Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine, to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
- Authorizes SWRCB, in furtherance of this investigation, to issue an information order to a water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide technical reports or other information related to a diversion and use of water, as specified.
- Authorizes, after notice and opportunity for hearing, SWRCB to issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right.
- Provides that, in determining whether a holder of an appropriative water right has forfeited the right, SWRCB is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim within the stream system during the period of forfeiture.
- Puts the burden of proving the elements of the basis of right on the water right claimant, diverter, or user in any SWRCB proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right.
- Authorizes SWRCB to adopt regulations to implement these provisions.
Background
- California’s water rights system. A February 3, 2022, paper entitled, “Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change” (paper), which was drafted by water law experts convened by the Planning & Conservation League, proposes various recommendations on how the state’s water laws can be updated to address the impacts of drought and climate change. The paper also provides an overview of the state’s water rights system:
“Unlike other western states, California has a patchwork system for allocating surface water that divides the right to water between statutory water rights issued and regulated by the State Water Resources Control Board [SWRCB] or its predecessors under the Water Commission Act of 1913 and water rights recognized prior to the act’s 1914 effective date. With some exceptions, surface water rights recognized prior to 1914 are limited to riparian rights, rights derived from ownership of land adjacent to a watercourse, and pre-1914 appropriative rights, rights unrelated to land ownership secured through application of the Gold Rush mining customs of water diversion and delivery to beneficial use.
“In times of shortage, the priority principle of first in time, first in right generally determines the allocation of pre-1914 and post-1914 appropriative rights. In contrast, riparians mutually share shortages with other riparians. (Millview County Water District v. State Water Resources Control Board, 229 CalApp.4th 879, 888-889 (2014).) The priority of riparian rights over other rights depends upon the date of the land patent for the riparian land. (McKinley Brothers v. McCauley, 215 Cal. 229, 230-231 (1922).) Neither holders of riparian nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from [SWRCB].
“Due to these historical circumstances, riparian rights and pre-1914 appropriative rights typically hold a senior priority to post-1914 appropriative rights and are entitled to satisfaction in times of shortage over the claims of post-1914 rights. … Because [SWRCB] does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood.”
[NOTE: See the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee policy analysis for additional background information.]
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed’s diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, SB 389 provides information-gathering and enforcement tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed’s reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses.”
- Authority to investigate and request information. SB 389 authorizes SWRCB, upon a finding that the information would protect the public interest or further SWRCB’s responsibilities under Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine, to investigate the diversion and use of water from a steam system.
Opponents of this bill argue that “it is hard to imagine a scenario where [SWRCB] would not make this finding, meaning it provides little in the way of guardrails to ensure investigations only target questionable claims of right.”
However, this finding is similar to the finding SWRCB must make before determining the rights to water of a stream system upon petition of a claimant to the water of a stream system. Existing law authorizes SWRCB to determine the water rights of a stream system upon petition of a claimant to the water, in accordance with specified proceedings, and upon a finding that facts and conditions are in the public interest and necessity will be served by the determination (Wat. C. §§ 2501, 2525).
- More details requested. Opponents of SB 389 also argue that this bill would “stack the deck against all right holders forced into these proceedings by providing minimal due process protections and placing the burden of proof on the right holder.” Opponents of the bill do not feel that the bill is “designed to create a fair and transparent process … .”
As an example, the opponents point to the lack of details in what constitutes “notice and opportunity for a hearing.”
Although SB 389 was amended to authorize SWRCB to adopt regulations to implement its provisions, opponents of this bill argue that SWRCB “would not be required to adopt regulations, and it’s unknown whether regulations would adequately bolster the due process protections … .”
SWRCB has adopted regulations governing various types of investigations, including notice and hearing. (Title 23, California Code of Regulations.) It is unclear if there have been due process concerns with these prior regulations adopted by SWRCB.
- Forfeiture provisions. Under SB 389, SWRCB is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim within the stream system when determining whether a holder of an appropriative right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right. According to the paper, this proposed amendment is in response to two recent California Court of Appeal decisions.
Existing law requires an appropriation be for a useful or beneficial purpose; when an appropriator or successor in interest ceases to use it for the purpose, the right ceases. (Wat. C. §1240.) Further, existing law reverts the water back to the public to be regarded as unappropriated public water, if the person entitled to the use of water, for a period of five years, fails to use beneficially all or any part of the water claimed for the purpose for which it was appropriated or adjudicated and upon SWRCB making a finding following notice and a public hearing, if requested by the water right holder. (Wat. C. §1241.)
As noted by the paper, neither of these sections requires that the party claiming the forfeiture of an appropriative right due to non-use prove the presence of a conflicting diverter who has relied upon the unused water during the forfeiture period. However, as discussed by the paper, two recent Court of Appeal decisions have held that “what is required for forfeiture is not merely nonuse by the rights holder of its full appropriation, but also ‘the presence of a competing claim’ to the unused water by a rival diverter who is prepared to use, or is using, the surplus.” (Millview County Water Dist. V. State Water Resources Control Board, 229 Cal.App.4th 879, 900 (2014); North Kern Water Storage District v. Kern Delta Water District, 147 Cal.App.4th 555, 586-587, 594-595 (2007).) The Millview court conceded that “the [conflicting claim] principal appears not to be announced explicitly by earlier decisions, but upheld the principal because all earlier forfeiture cases had involved conflicting claims and “there is no policy reason for finding a forfeiture until an alternative use has been asserted.” (Millview, supra, 229 Cal. App. 4th at pp. 900-901).
According to the opposition coalition letter, “Courts in the state have long recognized there is no policy justification for finding a forfeiture until an alternative use has been asserted, as the purpose of the forfeiture doctrine is to free unused water for beneficial use. If no other beneficial use has been asserted, there is no reason to find a forfeiture.”
Supporters of this bill argue that the Millview court failed to consider that keeping forfeited water in-stream will benefit fishery and other public trust values. Since Millview and North Kern do not expressly treat public trust users as conflicting claimants, it is argued, then the public trust use of the unused water would not appear to trigger the forfeiture period under these cases.
Although proposed Wat. C. Section 1863 would not be consistent with the Court of Appeal cases, the Separation of Powers Doctrine vests in the Legislature the authority to write and pass bills. The courts interpret the laws that passed by the Legislature and are signed by the Governor. Thus, if the Legislature does not agree with a court’s interpretation of statute, it can amend the statute.
- Who should have the burden of proof? Proposed Wat. C. Section 1864 provides that, in any SWRCB proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right, the water right claimant, diverter, or user has the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right.
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) writes that putting the burden of proof on the water right holder means “[SWRCB]’s investigation essentially commences with the assumption that the water right, which has supplied that community with reliable supply of water for decades, is invalid.” SFPUC has concern that, “unless the water right holder is able to prove the validity of the right with a ‘preponderance of the evidence,’ meaning to [SWRCB]’s satisfaction, [SWRCB] can eliminate that right … .”
According to the sponsors, the burden of proof responsibility is similar to the one used by SWRCB when conducting a statutory adjudication of a stream system to determine the basis of right of claimants to a stream. Under the statutory adjudication provisions, it is the duty of the claimants, upon notice of the proceeding, to notify SWRCB of their intention to file a proof of claim and to submit proof of their claims. (Wat. C. §2528.) A water right claimant is also required to submit a proof of claim that includes all “facts as the board requires to show the extent and nature of the right and compliance with the law in acquiring it.” (Wat. C. §2575.)
If SWRCB can require water right claimants to prove their water rights during the adjudication of an entire stream system, the sponsors argue that there is no policy justification to impose a lesser burden when SWRCB investigates and initiates a proceeding as to individual water rights.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 460 (Bauer-Kahan, 2023), among other things, authorizes SWRCB to commence an interim relief proceeding on its own motion or upon the petition of an interested party, to issue an interim relief order to a diverter or user of water in adjudicative proceedings to apply or enforce specified water provisions, and provides that a person who violates an interim relief order may be liable for a civil penalty. AB 460 is pending on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1337 (Wicks, 2023) authorizes SWRCB to issue a curtailment order for any diversion when water is not available under the diverter’s priority of right. AB 1337 is pending on the Assembly Floor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs and cost pressures (General Fund or special fund) for the SWRCB to investigate the diversion and use of water as well as adopt regulations in order to implement the provisions of this bill.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/18/23)
Planning and Conservation League (source)
California Climate Reality Coalition
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Voters
California Outdoors
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
California Water Research
Climate Action California
Defenders of Wildlife
Friends of The River
Karuk Tribe
Mono Lake Committee
Natural Heritage Institute
Northern California Council, Fly Fishers International
Sierra Club California
Wholly H2O
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/18/23)
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Antelope Valley East-kern Water Agency
Association of California Water Agencies
Bella Vista Water District
Bellflower Somerset Mutual Water Company
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
California Alliance for Jobs
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Builders Alliance
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Cattlemen's Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Walnut Commission
Carmichael Water District
City of Corona
City of Fairfield
City of Mountain View
City of Roseville
Coachella Valley Water District
Coastside County Water District
County of San Joaquin
County of Stanislaus
Cucamonga Valley Water District
Desert Water Agency
Dunnigan Water District
East Turlock Subbasin Groundwater Sustainability Agency
El Dorado Irrigation District
Elsinore Valley Municipal Water District
Florin Resource Conservation District/Elk Grove Water District
Friant Water Authority
Humboldt Bay Municipal Water District
Imperial Irrigation District
Jerry Dyer, Mayor of City of Fresno
Kern County Water Agency
Kings River Conservation District
Kings River Water Association
Lake Arrowhead Community Services District
London Breed, Mayor of San Francisco
Manteca Chamber of Commerce
Mckinleyville Community Services District
Mesa Water District
Modesto Irrigation District
Mojave Water Agency
Montecito Water District
Mountain Counties Water Resources Association
Municipal Water District of Orange County
Napa County Flood Control and Water Conservation District
Nisei Farmers League Inc.
Northern California Water Association
Oakdale Irrigation District
Orange County Water District
Palmdale Water District
Pinedale County Water Agency
Placer County Water Agency
Rancho California Water District
Rosedale-Rio Bravo Water Storage District
Rowland Water District
Sacramento Regional Builders Exchange
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Gorgonio PASS Water Agency
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Juan Water District
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Margarita Water District
Solano County Board of Supervisors
Solano County Water Agency
Solano Irrigation District
South San Joaquin Irrigation District
Southern California Water Coalition
State Water Contractors, Inc.
Stockton East Water District
Sweetwater Authority
Tehachapi-Cummings County Water District
The Wine Institute
Three Valleys Municipal Water District
Tranquillity Irrigation District
Tri-County Water Authority
Tulare Irrigation District
Tuolumne County Water Agency
Tuolumne Utilities District
Turlock Irrigation District
United Water Conservation District
Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Center Municipal Water District
Walnut Valley Water District
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Canal Water District
Western Growers Association
Western Municipal Water District
Yuba Water Agency
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to a coalition letter submitted by Planning and Conservation League, sponsor of this bill, and other environmental groups such as California Environmental Voters, Climate Action California, Sierra Club California, and Wholly H2O, “[a]ccording to one study, self-reported riparian and pre-1914 water claims account for the diversion of over 2.3 million acre-feet of water a year from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed. Because [SWRCB] does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood. …
“[SWRCB] presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Reforms allowing [SWRCB] to verify these claimed water rights could make water available for more junior water rights holders and for fishery and other beneficial uses of water in times of scarcity.
“The Water Code amendment proposed by SB 389 would address this gap in [SWRCB] authority by allowing [SWRCB] to selectively investigate and determine whether a water right claimant, diverter, or user is diverting or using water under a defensible claim of right. With this authority, [SWRCB] will have the ability to better manage the system for the benefit of all users, and the ecology of California’s many beautiful streams.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to a coalition letter of various water districts, water agencies, and agricultural groups, among others, SB 389 “could undermine the reliability of any water right, and, in turn, interests that depend on these rights. The bill would authorize [SWRCB] to drag any water rights holder before the Board to defend its claim of right. Once [SWRCB] begins adjudicating a claim, the bill would stack the deck against all right holders forced into these proceedings by providing minimal due process protections and placing the burden of proof on the right holder. [SB 389] is not designated to create a fair and transparent process, nor is it narrowly tailored to investigate dubious claims to right. The risk with this bill is its potential to strip public agencies of water rights that have been used to sustain communities for decades. …
“Unfortunately, SB 389 provides none of the safeguards that existing law recognizes as essential to making informed and defensible decisions on the validity and scope of water rights. Instead, SB 389 is designed to insulate [SWRCB] and would enable arbitrary outcomes.”
Prepared by: Genevieve Wong / N.R. & W. / (916) 651-4116
5/26/23 14:46:26
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 389 (Allen) - State Water Resources Control Board: determination of water right
Version: April 27, 2023 | Policy Vote: N.R. & W. 6 - 3 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 8, 2023 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would, upon specified findings, authorize the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to investigate the diversion and use of water from a steam system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially significant ongoing costs and cost pressures (General Fund or special fund) for the SWRCB to investigate the diversion and use of water as well as adopt regulations in order to implement the provisions of this bill.
Background:
California’s water rights system. A February 3, 2022, paper entitled, “Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change” (paper), which was drafted by water law experts convened by the Planning & Conservation League, proposes various recommendations on how the state’s water laws can be updated to address the impacts of drought and climate change. The paper also provides a good overview of the state’s water rights system:
“Unlike other western states, California has a patchwork system for allocating surface water that divides the right to water between statutory water rights issued and regulated by the State Water Resources Control Board [SWRCB] or its predecessors under the Water Commission Act of 1913 and water rights recognized prior to the act’s 1914 effective date. With some exceptions, surface water rights recognized prior to 1914 are limited to riparian rights, rights derived from ownership of land adjacent to a watercourse, and pre-1914 appropriative rights, rights unrelated to land ownership secured through application of the Gold Rush mining customs of water diversion and delivery to beneficial use.
In times of shortage, the priority principle of first in time, first in right generally determines the allocation of pre-1914 and post-1914 appropriative rights. In contrast, riparians mutually share shortages with other riparians. (Millview County Water District v. State Water Resources Control Board, 229 CalApp.4th 879, 888-889 (2014).) The priority of riparian rights over other rights depends upon the date of the land patent for the riparian land. (McKinley Brothers v. McCauley, 215 Cal. 229, 230-231 (1922).) Neither holders of riparian nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from [SWRCB].
Due to these historical circumstances, riparian rights and pre-1914 appropriative rights typically hold a senior priority to post-1914 appropriative rights and are entitled to satisfaction in times of shortage over the claims of post-1914 rights. … Because [SWRCB] does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood.”
The paper’s recommendations. The recommendations include more SWRCB and CDFW funding, ensuring environmental justice expertise on the Water Boards, updating SWRCB’s statutory adjudication process, among others. The recommendations also include “Improving Surface Rights Verification,” which proposed amending the Water Code (Wat. C.) to:
- Allow SWRCB to investigate individual water right claimants to verify their basis of right;
- Allow SWRCB to require information from the claimants relevant to the investigation;
- Allow SWRCB to rule upon the water right claim after notice and opportunity for hearing;
- Impose the burden upon the water right claimant to prove the elements of the claimant’s right; and
- Clarify that any determination of forfeiture of an appropriative right held in these proceedings would not require a showing of a competing claim or clash of rights from other rights holders as has been required by recent court decisions.
According to the paper,
“The intent of the proposed Water Code amendment is to provide [SWRCB] with more flexible tools to determine whether senior water rights claimants who assert riparian or pre-1914 appropriative water right claims have defensible grounds for their diversion and use of water. Presently, self-reported data are [SWRCB]’s primary information source about the extent and scope of these senior water rights. According to [SWRCB], this self-reported ‘[d]iverison data contained within the annual reports forms the basis for estimates of water demand used in [SWRCB’s] Water Unavailability Methodology. In times of shortage, [SWRCB] uses these water demand estimates, coupled with supply estimates, to determine the extent that [SWRCB] may curtail junior water right users. To the extent that these demand data inflate the amount of water that senior water right claimants have a right to divert, then less water is available for junior water right holders and for fishery and other beneficial uses of water.
[SWRCB] presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Section 1051 of the Water Code grants [SWRCB] the general authority to investigate stream systems but does not explicitly grant the power to verify the water rights of users claiming rights outside of the Water Commission Act. (Wat. C. §1051.) Sections 2500 through 2900 of the Water Code allow [SWRCB] to ‘determine … all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian rights, or other basis of rights,’ proceedings commonly known as statutory adjudications. (Wat. C. §2501.) However, these sections do not allow [SWRCB] to initiate an adjudication of rights to a stream system. Only claimants to water from the stream may initiate a statutory adjudication. (Wat. C. §2525.) Further, the sections do not allow [SWRCB] to determine the rights of individual diverters or a narrow set of diverters.”
Proposed Law:
This bill would, upon specified findings, authorize the SWRCB to investigate the diversion and use of water from a steam system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right. Specifically, this bill would:
- Authorize SWRCB, upon making a finding that there is reason to believe that the information would protect the public interest or further the SWRCB’s responsibilities under Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine, to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
- Authorize SWRCB, in furtherance of this investigation, to issue an information order to a water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide technical reports or other information related to a diversion and use of water, including but not limited to, all of the following:
- Information in addition to any information required to be reported for water diversions and use, as specified.
- Information related to the basis of the water right claimed.
- Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use.
- Information related to the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
- Information related to prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
- Information related to the diversions and use of transferred water.
- After notice and opportunity for hearing, authorizes SWRCB to issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right, including the authorized scope of the diversion and use, or may issue a decision or order determining that the diversion and use is not authorized under any basis of right.
- Provides that, in determining whether a holder of an appropriative water right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right, SWRCB is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim by any water right holder within the stream system during the period of forfeiture.
- Puts the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right on the water right claimant, diverter, or user in any SWRCB proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right.
- Provides that nothing in these provisions limits the authority of SWRCB to issue any decision or order, or to take any other action authorized by law.
Related Legislation:
AB 460 (Bauer-Kahan, 2023) would authorize the SWRCB to commence an interim relief proceeding on its own motion or upon the petition of an interested party, to issue an interim relief order to a diverter or user of water in adjudicative proceedings to apply or enforce specified water provisions, among others, and provides that a person who violates an interim relief order may be liable for a civil penalty.
AB 1337 (Wicks, 2023) would authorize SWRCB to adopt regulations to ensure water is used in the public’s interest and to implement regulations through orders curtailing water use under any claim of right.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Dave Min, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 389 Hearing Date: April 25, 2023
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | February 9, 2023 Introduced | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Genevieve Wong | ||
Subject: State Water Resources Control Board: determination of water right
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
California’s water rights system. A February 3, 2022, paper entitled, “Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change” (paper), which was drafted by water law experts convened by the Planning & Conservation League, proposes various recommendations on how the state’s water laws can be updated to address the impacts of drought and climate change. The paper also provides a good overview of the state’s water rights system:
“Unlike other western states, California has a patchwork system for allocating surface water that divides the right to water between statutory water rights issued and regulated by the State Water Resources Control Board [SWRCB] or its predecessors under the Water Commission Act of 1913 and water rights recognized prior to the act’s 1914 effective date. With some exceptions, surface water rights recognized prior to 1914 are limited to riparian rights, rights derived from ownership of land adjacent to a watercourse, and pre-1914 appropriative rights, rights unrelated to land ownership secured through application of the Gold Rush mining customs of water diversion and delivery to beneficial use.
In times of shortage, the priority principle of first in time, first in right generally determines the allocation of pre-1914 and post-1914 appropriative rights. In contrast, riparians mutually share shortages with other riparians. (Millview County Water District v. State Water Resources Control Board, 229 CalApp.4th 879, 888-889 (2014).) The priority of riparian rights over other rights depends upon the date of the land patent for the riparian land. (McKinley Brothers v. McCauley, 215 Cal. 229, 230-231 (1922).) Neither holders of riparian nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from [SWRCB].
Due to these historical circumstances, riparian rights and pre-1914 appropriative rights typically hold a senior priority to post-1914 appropriative rights and are entitled to satisfaction in times of shortage over the claims of post-1914 rights. … Because [SWRCB] does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood.”
The paper’s recommendations. The recommendations include more SWRCB and CDFW funding, ensuring environmental justice expertise on the Water Boards, updating SWRCB’s statutory adjudication process, among others. The recommendations also include “Improving Surface Rights Verification,” which proposed amending the Water Code (Wat. C.) to:
- Allow SWRCB to investigate individual water right claimants to verify their basis of right;
- Allow SWRCB to require information from the claimants relevant to the investigation;
- Allow SWRCB to rule upon the water right claim after notice and opportunity for hearing;
- Impose the burden upon the water right claimant to prove the elements of the claimant’s right; and
- Clarify that any determination of forfeiture of an appropriative right held in these proceedings would not require a showing of a competing claim or clash of rights from other rights holders as has been required by recent court decisions.
According to the paper,
“The intent of the proposed Water Code amendment is to provide [SWRCB] with more flexible tools to determine whether senior water rights claimants who assert riparian or pre-1914 appropriative water right claims have defensible grounds for their diversion and use of water. Presently, self-reported data are [SWRCB]’s primary information source about the extent and scope of these senior water rights. According to [SWRCB], this self-reported ‘[d]iverison data contained within the annual reports forms the basis for estimates of water demand used in [SWRCB’s] Water Unavailability Methodology. In times of shortage, [SWRCB] uses these water demand estimates, coupled with supply estimates, to determine the extent that [SWRCB] may curtail junior water right users. To the extent that these demand data inflate the amount of water that senior water right claimants have a right to divert, then less water is available for junior water right holders and for fishery and other beneficial uses of water.
[SWRCB] presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Section 1051 of the Water Code grants [SWRCB] the general authority to investigate stream systems but does not explicitly grant the power to verify the water rights of users claiming rights outside of the Water Commission Act. (Wat. C. §1051.) Sections 2500 through 2900 of the Water Code allow [SWRCB] to ‘determine … all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian rights, or other basis of rights,’ proceedings commonly known as statutory adjudications. (Wat. C. §2501.) However, these sections do not allow [SWRCB] to initiate an adjudication of rights to a stream system. Only claimants to water from the stream may initiate a statutory adjudication. (Wat. C. §2525.) Further, the sections do not allow [SWRCB] to determine the rights of individual diverters or a narrow set of diverters.”
Existing law:
- Authorizes SWRCB to:
- Investigate all streams, stream systems, portions of stream systems, lakes, or other bodies of water.
- Take testimony in regard to the rights to water or the use of water.
- Ascertain whether or not water filed upon or attempted to be appropriated is appropriated under the laws of the state. (Wat. C. §1051)
- Provides that the diversion or use of water other than as authorized is a trespass and a person committing trespass may be civilly liable, as specified. (Wat. C. §1052)
- Authorizes the SWRCB executive director to issue a complaint by personal notice or certified mail to any person or entity on which an administrative civil liability may be imposed, as specified, and requires the complaint to inform the party served that the party may request a hearing not later than 20 days from the date the party was served and that the board may adopt an order setting administrative civil liability based on the allegations set forth in the complaint without a hearing if the party does not sign a written request for a hearing, as specified. (Wat. C. §1055)
- Authorizes the SWRCB executive director to issue a complaint by personal notice or certified mail to any person or entity on which an administrative civil liability may be imposed, as specified, and requires the complaint to inform the party served that the party may request a hearing not later than 20 days from the date the party was served and that the board may adopt an order setting administrative civil liability based on the allegations set forth in the complaint without a hearing if the party does not sign a written request for a hearing, as specified. (Wat. C. §1055)
- Requires the appropriation must be for some useful or beneficial purpose, and when the appropriator or their successor in interest ceases to use it for such purposes the right ceases. (Wat. C. §1240)
- Provides that if a person entitled to the use of water fails to use beneficially all or any part of the water claimed by them, for which a right of use has vested, for the purpose for which it was appropriated or adjudicated, for a period of five years, that unused water may revert to the public and shall, if reverted, be regarded as unappropriated public water. (Wat. C. §1241)
- Authorizes SWRCB to determine all rights to water of a stream system whether based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right upon petition by a claimant to water of the steam system requesting the determination of the rights of the various claimants to the water of that stream system. Requires SWRCB to comply with specific notice, proceeding, and investigation processes and requires claimants to notify SWRCB of their intention to file proof of claim and to submit proof of their respective claims. (Wat. C. §§2500 et seq.)
- Requires each person who diverts water to file with SWRCB a statement of their diversion and use except that a statement is not required in specific circumstances. (Wat. C. §5101)
PROPOSED LAW
This bill:
- Authorizes SWRCB to investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
- Authorizes SWRCB, in furtherance of this investigation, to issue an information order to a water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide technical reports or other information related to a diversion and use of water, including but not limited to, all of the following:
- Information in addition to any information required to be reported for water diversions and use, as specified.
- Information related to the basis of the water right claimed.
- Information related to the patent date claimed for the place of use.
- Information related to the notice date of the appropriation and the date of actual delivery of water to beneficial use.
- Information related to prior diversions and use, including direct diversions and diversions to storage.
- Information related to the diversions and use of transferred water.
- After notice and opportunity for hearing, authorizes SWRCB to issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right, including the authorized scope of the diversion and use, or may issue a decision or order determining that the diversion and use is not authorized under any basis of right.
- Provides that, in determining whether a holder of an appropriative water right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right, SWRCB is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim by any water right holder within the stream system during the period of forfeiture.
- Puts the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right on the water right claimant, diverter, or user in any SWRCB proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right.
- Provides that nothing in these provisions limits the authority of SWRCB to issue any decision or order, or to take any other action authorized by law.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “In the face of climate change and the increasing prevalence of drought, it is critical that the State of California has thorough and up-to-date data for assessing water availability for all holders in a watershed. An accurate determination of water rights requires verification of a watershed’s diversions or use, including those of senior water right holders not governed by the permitting system of the California Water Commission Act of 1913. To address critical gaps in authority, SB 389 provides information-gathering and enforcement tools that allow the State Water Board to align a watershed’s reported demand with the diversions and use authorized under California law, thus more accurately determining water availability for all beneficial uses.”
According to a coalition letter submitted by Planning and Conservation League, sponsor of the bill, and other environmental groups such as California Environmental Voters, Climate Action California, Sierra Club California, and Wholly H2O, “[n]either holders of riparian rights nor pre-1914 appropriative rights require a permit or license from [SWRCB]. According to one study, self-reported riparian and pre-1914 water claims account for the diversion of over 2.3 million acre-feet of water a year from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed. Because [SWRCB] does not issue permits or licenses for riparian and pre-1914 appropriative rights, the extent and scope of these rights are poorly understood. …
[SWRCB] presently lacks the tools for promptly investigating and determining whether senior water right claims are inflated or represent the amounts that the claimants have the right to divert and use. Reforms allowing [SWRCB] to verify these claimed water rights could make water available for more junior water rights holders and for fishery and other beneficial uses of water in times of scarcity.
The Water Code amendment proposed by SB 389 would address this gap in [SWRCB] authority by allowing [SWRCB] to selectively investigate and determine whether a water right claimant, diverter, or user is diverting or using water under a defensible claim of right. With this authority, [SWRCB] will have the ability to better manage the system for the benefit of all users, and the ecology of California’s many beautiful streams.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
According to a coalition letter of various water districts, water agencies, and agricultural groups, among others (opposition coalition letter), SB 389 provides “minimal due process protections” and “places the burden of proof on the right holder.” Opponents of SB 389 feel that the bill “is not designed to create a fair and transparent process,” and is not “narrowly tailored to investigate dubious claims to right.” The letter points out that the “bill would not require [SWRCB] to provide a basis for initiating an investigation of a water right claim” and argues that, although there is a notice and opportunity for hearing, “SB 389 provides no further details about the hearing process … [and] [t]he claimant may have no opportunity to present evidence and testimony, to cross examine witnesses, and to test evidence against them.” The letter compares this to the existing requirements that SWRCB must comply with during statutory adjudications, where SWRCB is “authorized to initiate a statutory adjudication of all water rights to a stream system upon petition of a water rights claimant,” and includes a “robust opportunity for involvement in the investigative process.”
According to California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA), “Water agencies rely on their water rights to conduct water supply and demand assessments and ensure there will be sufficient water to meet the needs of their customers,” and has concern that “materially altering the water rights system in California could result in the inability of water agencies to meet existing needs and to plan for the future because there is not certainty of receiving the full extent of their water rights.” According to CMUA, “SB 389 may effectuate the regulatory taking of a right crucial to water agencies, could impair many aspects of California’s economy, and may lead to an increased risk of communities not having enough water.”
COMMENTS
Authority to investigate and request information. SB 389 authorizes SWRCB to investigate the diversion and use of water from a steam system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right, and authorizes SWRCB to require the water right claimant, diverter, or user to provide information related to the diversion and use of water. This authorization appears to be open-ended, and, according to the sponsors, is intended to provide SWRCB with the ability to gather information and better understand water usage by water right claimants.
Because of this open-ended authorization, opponents of the bill worry, as expressed in a coalition letter, that SWRCB would not be required “to provide a basis for initiating an investigation of a water right claim, meaning any claimant could be subject to an investigation at any time.”
Sponsors of the bill argue that requiring SWRCB to justify the investigation with specific facts assumes that the action of requesting information is punitive, when it is “information-gathering.”
Currently, SWRCB may determine the rights to water of a stream system upon petition of a claimant to water of the stream system and upon a finding that facts and conditions are in the public interest and necessity will be served by the determination (Wat. C. §§ 2501, 2525).
The committee may wish to amend the bill to require SWRCB to make a finding that there is reason to believe that the information would protect the public interest or further the SWRCB’s responsibilities under section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine. (See Amendment 1)
More details requested. Opponents of the bill have expressed concern that SB 389 would “stack the deck against all right holders forced into these proceedings by providing minimal due process protections and placing the burden of proof on the right holder.” Opponents of the bill do not feel that the bill is “designed to create a fair and transparent process, nor is it narrowly tailored to investigate dubious claims of right.”
As an example, the opponents point to the lack of details in what constitutes “notice and opportunity for a hearing.” SB 389 authorizes SWRCB to issue a decision or order determining the diversion and use basis of right or a decision or order determining that the diversion and use is not authorized under any basis of right, after notice and opportunity for hearing.
It is unclear what processes SWRCB would be subject to, if any, when providing notice and opportunity to hearing. However, examples of similar authority exist in statute. For example, the SWRCB executive director is authorized to issue a complaint to any person or entity on which an administrative civil liability may be imposed and requires the complaint to inform the party served that the party may request a hearing not later than 20 days from the date the party was served and that SWRCB may adopt an order setting an administrative civil liability based on the allegations in the complaint without a hearing if the party does not sign a written request for a hearing. (Wat. C. §1055.) Additionally, SWRCB is authorized to issue cease and desist orders in certain circumstances but only after SWRCB gives notice by personal notice or certified mail, pursuant to which the party is required to be informed that they may request a hearing not later than 20 days after the notice is received. (Wat. C. §§1831, 1834.)
Further, SWRCB has adopted regulations governing various types of investigations, including notice and hearing. (Title 23, California Code of Regulations.)
The committee may wish to amend the bill to give SWRCB authority to adopt regulations to implement the bill’s provisions. This will help provide opponents of the bill with transparency to SWRCB’s processes while also giving SWRCB flexibility to set its own processes. (See Amendment 2)
Forfeiture provisions. Under SB 389, SWRCB is not required to find the existence of a conflicting claim within the stream system when determining whether a holder of an appropriative right has forfeited the right or any portion of the right. According to the paper, this proposed amendment is in response to two recent California Court of Appeal decisions.
Existing law requires that an appropriation must be for some useful or beneficial purpose, and when the appropriator or his successor in interest ceases to use it for such a purpose, the right ceases. (Wat. C. §1240.) Further, existing law reverts the water back to the public to be regarded as unappropriated public water, if the person entitled to the use of water, for a period of five years, fails to use beneficially all or any part of the water claimed for the purpose for which it was appropriated or adjudicated and upon SWRCB making a finding following notice and a public hearing, if requested by the water right holder. (Wat. C. §1241.)
As noted by the paper, neither of these sections requires that the party claiming the forfeiture of an appropriative right due to non-use prove the presence of a conflicting diverter who has relied upon the unused water during the forfeiture period. However, as discussed by the paper, two recent Court of Appeal decisions have held that “what is required for forfeiture is not merely nonuse by the rights holder of its full appropriation, but also ‘the presence of a competing claim’ to the unused water by a rival diverter who is prepared to use, or is using, the surplus.” (Millview County Water Dist. V. State Water Resources Control Board, 229 Cal.App.4th 879, 900 (2014); North Kern Water Storage District v. Kern Delta Water District, 147 Cal.App.4th 555, 586-587, 594-595 (2007).) The Millview court conceded that “the [conflicting claim] principal appears not to be announced explicitly by earlier decisions, but upheld the principal because all earlier forfeiture cases had involved conflicting claims and “there is no policy reason for finding a forfeiture until an alternative use has been asserted.” (Millview, supra, 229 Cal. App. 4th at pp. 900-901).
According to the opposition coalition letter, “Courts in the state have long recognized there is no policy justification for finding a forfeiture until an alternative use has been asserted, as the purpose of the forfeiture doctrine is to free unused water for beneficial use. If no other beneficial use has been asserted, there is no reason to find a forfeiture.”
However, the policy paper argues that the Millview court failed to consider one policy reason for not requiring proof of a conflicting claim as an element of forfeiture; keeping forfeited water in-stream will frequently benefit fishery and other public trust values. Since Millview and North Kern do not expressly treat public trust users as conflicting claimants, the paper argues, then the public trust use of the unused water would not appear to trigger the forfeiture period under these cases.
Although proposed Wat. C. §1863 would not be consistent with the Court of Appeal cases, the Separation of Powers Doctrine vests in the Legislature the authority to write and pass bills. The courts interpret the laws that are signed by the Governor. Thus, if the Legislature does not agree with a court’s interpretation of statute, it can amend the statute.
Who should have the burden of proof? Proposed Wat. C. §1864 provides that, in any SWRCB proceeding to determine a diversion and use basis of right, the water right claimant, diverter, or user has the burden of proving by the preponderance of evidence the elements of the basis of right.
CMUA writes that “shifting the burden of proof may place undue hardship on water rights holders that are brought before [SWRCB] to show historical use in a process that is similar to statutory adjudications but without any due process protections present in statutory adjudications.”
Given the committee amendments which authorize SWRCB to adopt regulations to implement the bill’s provisions, including notice and opportunity for hearing, this concern may be addressed.
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) writes that putting the burden of proof on the water right holder means “the [SWRCB]’s investigation essentially commences with the assumption that the water right, which has supplied that community with reliable supply of water for decades, is invalid.” SFPUC has concern that, “unless the water right holder is able to prove the validity of the right with a ‘preponderance of the evidence,’ meaning to [SWRCB]’s satisfaction, [SWRCB] can eliminate that right in whole or in part.”
According to the sponsors, this principal is similar to the one used by SWRCB when it conducts a statutory adjudication of a stream system to determine the basis of right of claimants to a stream. Under the statutory adjudication provisions, whenever proceedings are instituted for the determination of water rights, it is the duty of the claimants, upon notice of the proceeding, to notify SWRCB of their intention to file a proof of claim and to submit proof of their claims. (Wat. C. §2528.) A water right claimant is also required to submit a proof of claim that includes all “facts as the board requires to show the extent and nature of the right and compliance with the law in acquiring it.” (Wat. C. §2575.)
If SWRCB can require water right claimants to prove their water rights during the adjudication of an entire stream system, the sponsors argue that there is no policy justification to impose a lesser burden when SWRCB investigates and initiates a proceeding as to individual water rights.
Related legislation
AB 460 (Bauer-Kahan) of this legislative session authorizes SWRCB to commence an interim relief proceeding on its own motion or upon the petition of an interested party, to issue an interim relief order to a diverter or user of water in adjudicative proceedings to apply or enforce specified water provisions, among others, and provides that a person who violates an interim relief order may be liable for a civil penalty. AB 460 was heard in the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee (9-4-2) and is pending before the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1337 (Wicks) of this legislative session authorizes SWRCB to adopt regulations to ensure water is used in the public’s interest and to implement regulations through orders curtailing water use under any claim of right. AB 1337 was heard in the Assembly Water, Parks and Wildlife Committee (9-4-2) and is pending before the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
AMENDMENT 1
Amend proposed Section 1860 to read:
Upon a finding that there is reason to believe that the information would protect the public interest or further the state board’s responsibilities under section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution or the public trust doctrine, the state board may investigate the diversion and use of water from a stream system to determine whether the diversion and use are based upon appropriation, riparian right, or other basis of right.
AMENDMENT 2
Add a new Section 1866 that reads:
1866. The state board may adopt regulations to implement this article.
SUPPORT
Planning and Conservation League (sponsor)
California Climate Reality Coalition
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Voters (formerly CLCV)
California Outdoors
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
California Water Research
Climate Action California
Defenders of Wildlife
Friends of the River
Mono Lake Committee
Natural Heritage Institute
Northern California Council, Fly Fishers International
Sierra Club California
Wholly H2O
OPPOSITION
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Antelope Valley East-kern Water Agency
Association of California Water Agencies
Bella Vista Water District
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
Cal Chamber
California Alliance for Jobs
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Cattlemen's Association
California Cotton Ginners & Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Walnut Commission
Carmichael Water District
City of Corona
City of Roseville
Coachella Valley Water District
Coastside County Water District
County of San Joaquin
County of Stanislaus
Cucamonga Valley Water District
Desert Water Agency
Dunnigan Water District
East Turlock Subbasin Groundwater Sustainability Agency
El Dorado Irrigation District
Elk Grove Water District
Elsinore Valley Municipal Water District
Friant Water Authority
Imperial Irrigation District
Kern County Water Agency
Kings River Conservation District
Kings River Water Association
Lake Arrowhead Community Services District
Manteca Chamber of Commerce
McKinleyville Community Services District
Mesa Water District
Modesto Irrigation District
Mojave Water Agency
Montecito Water District
Municipal Water District of Orange County
Napa County Flood Control and Water Conservation District
Nisei Farmers League
Northern California Water Association
Oakdale Irrigation District
Palmdale Water District
Placer County Water Agency
Rosedale-Rio Bravo Water Storage District
Rowland Water District
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Gorgonio PASS Water Agency
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Juan Water District
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Margarita Water District
Solano County Water Agency
Solano Irrigation District
South San Joaquin Irrigation District
Southern California Water Coalition
Stockton East Water District
Tehachapi-Cummings County Water District
The Wine Institute
Three Valleys Municipal Water District
Tranquility Irrigation District
Tri-County Water Authority
Tuolumne County Water Agency
Tuolumne Utilities District
Turlock Irrigation District
United Water Conservation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Center Municipal Water District
Walnut Valley Water District
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Municipal Water District
Yuba Water Agency
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Water, Parks, and Wildlife
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):