AB 1242: Water quality and storage.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-09-01
(1)Existing law establishes the Department of Water Resources in the Natural Resources Agency, and, among other things, empowers the department to conduct investigations of all or any portion of any stream, stream system, lake, or other body of water.
Existing law requires all moneys, except for fines and penalties, collected by the State Air Resources Board from the auction or sale of allowances as part of a market-based compliance mechanism relative to reduction of greenhouse gas emissions to be deposited in the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund.
This bill would require the department to increase statewide water storage capacity by 25% by January 1, 2025, and 50% by January 1, 2050, as specified. The bill would require the department, on or before January 1, 2017, to identify the current statewide water storage capacity and prepare a strategy and implementation plan to achieve those expansions in statewide water storage capacity, and would require the department to update the strategy and implementation plan on January 1, 2018, and every 2 years thereafter, until January 1, 2050. The bill would require the Legislative Analysts Office to report to the Legislature on January 1, 2020, and every 5 years thereafter, until January 1, 2050, on the departments progress on achieving those required increases in statewide water storage capacity, as specified. The bill would, beginning in the 201617 fiscal year, continuously appropriate 25% of the annual proceeds of the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund to the department to comply with these requirements.
Existing
(2)Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region and prohibits a water quality control plan, or a revision of the plan, adopted by a regional board, from becoming effective unless it is approved by the state board.
Existing law, the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, requires all groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins by the Department of Water Resources that are designated as basins subject to critical conditions of overdraft to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2020, and requires all other groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2022, except as specified.
This bill would require the state board, in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, to take into consideration, consistent with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region and prohibits a water quality control plan, or a revision of the plan, adopted by a regional board, from becoming effective unless it is approved by the state board.
Existing law, the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, requires all groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins by the Department of Water Resources that are designated as basins subject to critical conditions of overdraft to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2020, and requires all other groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2022, except as specified.
This bill would require the state board, in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan, plan for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, to take into consideration, consistent with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region and prohibits a water quality control plan, or a revision of the plan, adopted by a regional board, from becoming effective unless it is approved by the state board.
Existing law, the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, requires all groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins by the Department of Water Resources that are designated as basins subject to critical conditions of overdraft to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2020, and requires all other groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2022, except as specified.
This bill would require the state board to take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative board, in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin. This bill would require the state board to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses. plan, to take into consideration, consistent with the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the State Water Resources Control Board state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region and prohibits a water quality control plan, or a revision of the plan, adopted by a regional board, from becoming effective unless it is approved by the state board.
Existing law, the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, requires all groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins by the Department of Water Resources that are designated as basins subject to critical conditions of overdraft to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2020, and requires all other groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2022, except as specified.
This bill would require the state board to take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin. This bill would require the state board to evaluate impacts on groundwater basins, consider alternatives and mitigation measures to avoid or mitigate any adverse impacts on groundwater quality or supply, and avoid or mitigate those adverse impacts to the extent feasible identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses.
Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report (EIR) on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment. CEQA authorizes a public agency to approve a project that would result in significant effects on the environment that are not feasible to mitigate by issuing a statement of overriding consideration making a finding that specific overriding economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits of the project outweigh the significant effect on the environment.
This bill would require the state board to adopt and implement mitigation measures to make any adverse impacts to the groundwater basin that are less than significant. This bill would prohibit the state board from adopting a statement of overriding consideration if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin and would prohibit the state board from adopting or approving a water quality control plan if there is a significant adverse impact to the groundwater basin.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the State Water Resources Control Board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region and prohibits a water quality control plan, or a revision of the plan, adopted by a regional board, from becoming effective unless it is approved by the state board.
Existing law, the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act, requires all groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins by the Department of Water Resources that are designated as basins subject to critical conditions of overdraft to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2020, and requires all other groundwater basins designated as high- or medium-priority basins to be managed under a groundwater sustainability plan or coordinated groundwater sustainability plans by January 31, 2022, except as specified.
This bill would require the state board to take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin. This bill would require the state board to evaluate impacts on groundwater basins, consider alternatives and mitigation measures to avoid or mitigate any adverse impacts on groundwater quality or supply, and avoid or mitigate those adverse impacts to the extent feasible before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses.
Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of an environmental impact report (EIR) on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment. CEQA authorizes a public agency to approve a project that would result in significant effects on the environment that are not feasible to mitigate by issuing a statement of overriding consideration making a finding that specific overriding economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits of the project outweigh the significant effect on the environment.
This bill would require the state board to adopt and implement mitigation measures to make any adverse impacts to the groundwater basin that are less than significant. This bill would prohibit the state board from adopting a statement of overriding consideration if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin and would prohibit the state board from adopting or approving a water quality control plan if there is a significant adverse impact to the groundwater basin.
(a)The Legislature shall appropriate the annual proceeds of the fund for the purpose of reducing greenhouse gas emissions in this state in accordance with the requirements of Section 39712.
(b)To carry out a portion of the requirements of subdivision (a), annual proceeds are continuously appropriated for the following:
(1)Beginning in the 201516 fiscal year, and notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, 35 percent of annual proceeds are continuously appropriated, without regard to fiscal years, for transit, affordable housing, and sustainable communities programs as following:
(A)Ten percent of the annual proceeds of the fund is hereby continuously appropriated to the Transportation Agency for the Transit and Intercity Rail Capital Program created by Part 2 (commencing with Section 75220) of Division 44 of the Public Resources Code.
(B)Five percent of the annual proceeds of the fund is hereby continuously appropriated to the Low Carbon Transit Operations Program created by Part 3 (commencing with Section 75230) of Division 44 of the Public Resources Code. Funds shall be allocated by the Controller, according to requirements of the program, and pursuant to the distribution formula in subdivision (b) or (c) of Section 99312 of, and Sections 99313 and 99314 of, the Public Utilities Code.
(C)Twenty percent of the annual proceeds of the fund is hereby continuously appropriated to the Strategic Growth Council for the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program created by Part 1 (commencing with Section 75200) of Division 44 of the Public Resources Code. Of the amount appropriated in this subparagraph, no less than 10 percent of the annual proceeds, shall be expended for affordable housing, consistent with the provisions of that program.
(2)Beginning in the 201516 fiscal year, notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, 25 percent of the annual proceeds of the fund is hereby continuously appropriated to the High-Speed Rail Authority for the following components of the initial operating segment and Phase I Blended System as described in the 2012 business plan adopted pursuant to Section 185033 of the Public Utilities Code:
(A)Acquisition and construction costs of the project.
(B)Environmental review and design costs of the project.
(C)Other capital costs of the project.
(D)Repayment of any loans made to the authority to fund the project.
(3)Beginning in the 201617 fiscal year, notwithstanding Section 13340 of the Government Code, 25 percent of the annual proceeds of the fund is hereby continuously appropriated to the Department of Water Resources to comply with the requirements of Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 430) of Division 1 of the Water Code.
(c)In determining the amount of annual proceeds of the fund for purposes of the calculation in subdivision (b), the funds subject to Section 39719.1 shall not be included.
SEC. 2.Chapter 4.5 (commencing with Section 430) is added to Division 1 of the Water Code, to read:4.5.Water Storage and Reliability430.(a)On or before January 1, 2017, the Department of Water Resources, after one or more public workshops, shall identify the current statewide water storage capacity, including local, state, and federal projects, and prepare a strategy and implementation plan to achieve an expansion in statewide water storage capacity of 25 percent by January 1, 2025, and 50 percent by January 1, 2050.
(b)The Department of Water Resources shall provide a copy of the strategy and implementation plan to the appropriate policy committees of the Legislature and publish this information on the Department of Water Resources publicly available Internet Web site.
(c)On January 1, 2018, and every two years thereafter, until January 1, 2050, the Department of Water Resources shall update the strategy and implementation plan to reflect any changes made to the strategy and plan.
(d)The Department of Water Resources shall provide a copy of the updated strategy and implementation plans required pursuant to subdivision (c) to the appropriate policy committees of the Legislature and publish this information on the Department of Water Resources publicly available Internet Web site.
431.(a)The Department of Water Resources shall increase the states total water storage capacity by 25 percent by January 1, 2025, and by 50 percent by January 1, 2050.
(b)The increase in water storage capacity required pursuant to subdivision (a) may be accomplished through a mix of both surface water and groundwater storage projects, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
(1)Surface water storage projects identified in the CALFED Bay-Delta Program Record of Decision, dated August 28, 2000, except for projects prohibited by Chapter 1.4 (commencing with Section 5093.50) of Division 5 of the Public Resources Code.
(2)Local and regional surface water storage projects.
(3)Groundwater storage projects and groundwater contamination prevention or remediation projects that provide water storage benefits.
(4)Conjunctive use and reservoir reoperation projects.
432.(a)On January 1, 2020, and every five years thereafter, until January 1, 2050, the Legislative Analysts Office shall report to the Legislature on the Department of Water Resources progress on fulfilling the requirements imposed under Section 431.
(b)The Legislative Analysts Office shall include in the report required pursuant to subdivision (a) whether the Department of Water Resources is expected to achieve the water storage requirements imposed under Section 431 on time.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Section 13145.5 is added to the Water Code, to read:13145.5.In formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, the state board shall take into consideration, consistent with the requirements of Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted or approved under Part 2.74 (commencing with Section 10720) of Division 6 and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
In formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan, plan for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, the state board shall take into consideration, consistent with the requirements of Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted or approved under Part 2.74 (commencing with Section 10720) of Division 6 and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
(a)In formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin, plan, the state board shall take into consideration consideration, consistent with the requirements of Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted or approved under Part 2.74 (commencing with Section 10720) of Division 6. 6 and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
(b)Before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses, the state board shall identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows.
(a)In formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin, the state board shall take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted or approved under Part 2.74 (commencing with Section 10720) of Division 6.
(b)(1)Before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses, the state board shall evaluate impacts on groundwater basins, consider alternatives and mitigation measures to avoid or mitigate any adverse impacts on groundwater quality or supply, and avoid or mitigate those adverse impacts to the extent feasible. identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows.
(2)If the state board finds any adverse impacts to the groundwater basin that are significant, as defined in Section 21068 of the Public Resources Code, the state board shall adopt and implement mitigation measures to make any adverse impact less than significant.
(3)The state board shall not adopt a statement of overriding consideration pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin. The state board shall not adopt or approve a water quality control plan as required pursuant to Section 13245 if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin.
(a)In formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin, the state board shall take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted or approved under Part 2.74 (commencing with Section 10720) of Division 6.
(b)(1)Before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses, the state board shall evaluate impacts on groundwater basins, consider alternatives and mitigation measures to avoid or mitigate any adverse impacts on groundwater quality or supply, and avoid or mitigate those adverse impacts to the extent feasible.
(2)If the state board finds any adverse impacts to the groundwater basin that are significant, as defined in Section 21068 of the Public Resources Code, the state board shall adopt and implement mitigation measures to make any adverse impact less than significant.
(3)The state board shall not adopt a statement of overriding consideration pursuant to Section 21081 of the Public Resources Code if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin. The state board shall not adopt or approve a water quality control plan as required pursuant to Section 13245 if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 2, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(b). |
| Sep 2, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10 (b). |
| Sep 2, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2015 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 19, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 18, 2015 | From committee: Be placed on second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and be amended. |
| Jul 16, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 16, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 15). |
| Jun 24, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (June 23). Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Jun 11, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on N.R. & W. and E.Q. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 2, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 69. Noes 6. Page 1774.) |
| Jun 2, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 28, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 28, 2015 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (May 28). |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| May 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 5, 2015 | Read second time and amended. |
| May 4, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (April 27). |
| Apr 14, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. (Ayes 8. Noes 4.) (April 14). Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Mar 23, 2015 | Referred to Coms. on W., P., & W. and NAT. RES. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 15, 2015 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Jun 23, 2015 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2015 | AB 1242 GRAY Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2015 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 27, 2015 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Apr 14, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Water, Parks, and Wildlife |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 1242
Page 7
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1242
Amended: 8/19/15 in Senate
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/23/15
AYES: Stone, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Vidak, Wolk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Pavley, Allen, Monning
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/15/15
AYES: Wieckowski, Gaines, Bates, Hill, Jackson, Leno, Pavley
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-6, 6/2/15 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Water quality: groundwater impacts
DIGEST: This bill requires the State Water Resources Control Board to consider any groundwater sustainability plan in formulating state policy for water quality control or adopting or approving a water quality control plan
Existing law:
Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Board), under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act (Porter-Cologne), to adopt a state policy for water quality control.
The policy is to consist of any or all of the following:
Water quality principles and guidelines for long-range resource planning, including ground water and surface water management programs and control and use of recycled water.
Water quality objectives at key locations for planning and operation of water resource development projects and for water quality control activities.
Other principles and guidelines deemed essential by the state board for water quality control.
In developing the policy, the State Board is required to consult with and carefully evaluate the recommendations of concerned federal, state, and local agencies.
Requires the Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regional Boards), also under Porter-Cologne, to formulate and adopt water quality control plans (WQCPs) for all areas within each region of the state that protect beneficial uses of water and meet water quality objectives. The State Board is similarly tasked with developing statewide plans (e.g., the California Ocean Plan and the Bay-Delta Plan).
WQCPs are to include objectives that will ensure the reasonable protection of all beneficial uses, protection of water quality, and the prevention of nuisance. Porter-Cologne recognizes that it may be possible for the quality of water to be changed to some degree without unreasonably affecting beneficial uses. Consequently, Regional Boards are required to consider various factors in establishing water quality objectives, including:
Past, present, and probable future beneficial uses of water.
Environmental characteristics of the hydrographic unit under consideration, including the quality of water available thereto.
Water quality conditions that could reasonably be achieved through the coordinated control of all factors which affect water quality in the area.
Economic considerations.
The need for developing housing within the region.
The need to develop and use recycled water.
In developing WQCPs, the Regional Boards are required to consult with and consider recommendations of affected state and local agencies.
WQCPs adopted or amended by Regional Boards must be approved by the State Board.
Requires the development and adoption of state policy for water quality control and WQCPs to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
CEQA requires, for any project or plan subject to CEQA that would potentially have significant environmental impacts, an environmental impact report that, among other things, identifies the following:
All significant effects on the environment of the proposed project.
Mitigation measures proposed to minimize significant effects on the environment, including, but not limited to, measures to reduce the wasteful, inefficient, and unnecessary consumption of energy.
Alternatives to the proposed project.
Requires, under the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), by June 30, 2017, the formation of one or more Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in all high and medium priority basins.
SGMA requires, by January 31, 2020, Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSPs) GSAs in all high and medium priority basins subject to a chronic condition of overdraft develop and adopt that provide for the sustainable management of the groundwater basin, as defined.
SGMA requires GSAs to develop and adopt GSPs in all other high and medium priority basins by January 31, 2022.
SGMA requires GSPs to include, among other things:
Measurable objectives, as well as interim milestones in increments of five years, to achieve the sustainability goal in the basin within 20 years of the implementation of the plan.
A description of how the plan helps meet each objective and how each objective is intended to achieve the sustainability goal for the basin for long-term beneficial uses of groundwater.
This bill requires the State Board, in formulating state policy for water quality control or adopting or approving a water quality control plan, to take into consideration, consistent with the requirements of CEQA, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted or approved under the SGMA and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters.
Comments
Opposition is dropping off – in response to recent amendments, a number of environmental organizations that were previously “opposed” to this bill have moved to a “neutral” position. Such organizations include Natural Resources Defense Council, Golden Gate Salmon Association, Community Water Center, and Clean Water Action. It is not clear if those remaining “oppose” are in fact still opposed or simply haven’t sent a letter removing their opposition
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Hullers & Processors Association
Building and Construction Trades Council of Stanislaus, Merced, Tuolumne, and Mariposa Counties
California Bean Shippers Association
California Diary Campaign
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Grain and Feed Association
California Pear Growers Association
California Seed Association
California State Floral Association
California Women for Agriculture
City of Atwater
City of Ceres
City of Dos Palos, Mayor Jerry Antonetti
City of Gustine
City of Livingston
City of Los Banos
City of Merced
City of Modesto
City of Patterson, Mayor Luis Molina
City of Turlock, Mayor Gary Soiseth
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Congressman Jim Costa
Glen-Colusa Irrigation District
Greater Merced Chamber of Commerce
Harris Farms, Inc.
IBEW – Local 684
IBEW – Local 1245
Latino Community Roundtable
League of California Cities – Central Valley Division
Merced County Board of Supervisors
Merced County Farm Bureau
Merced County Sheriff Vernon Warnke
Merced Irrigation District
Modesto Chamber of Commerce
Modesto Irrigation District
Northern California Water Association
Pacific Egg & Poultry Association
Regional Water Authority
Stanislaus Business Alliance
Stanislaus County Board of Supervisors
Stanislaus County Farm Bureau
Stevinson Water District
Turlock Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Irrigation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Western Growers Association
Yosemite Community College District
Yosemite Farm Credit
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/15)
California League of Conservation Voters
Center for Biological Diversity
Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation
Contra Costa County
Friends of the River
Klamath Riverkeeper
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Sierra Club California
The Nature Conservancy
Union of Concerned Scientists
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Author, “For the past year, the State Water Resources Control Board has considered a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus rivers. The proposed plan would require an additional 350,000 acre feet of water annually to flow out to San Francisco Bay Delta.
“If adopted, the Board’s proposal will devastate the groundwater basins in the Valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminate surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users. The Board recognizes these impacts would have “significant and unavoidable” adverse impacts on the region.
“In 2014, the Legislature passed the Sustainability Groundwater Management Act which promised to empower local communities with the tools to achieve sustainable management goals. The adoption of the Board’s proposal without consideration to local groundwater sustainability plans would jeopardize one of the most important tools to achieving groundwater sustainability – the ability to recharge the depleted groundwater table with surface flows.
“With the difficulties caused by the state’s historic drought, and the mandate that the newly created groundwater sustainability agencies create sustainable groundwater plans, it is more important than ever that the State Water Board consult all stakeholders as they develop a Bay-Delta Plan that balances the needs of all water users.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents essentially argue that the bill is unnecessary. “Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and its regional boards are required, as they develop water quality control plans for the State, to consider all existing and potential future beneficial uses of water, as well as economic considerations …These water quality control plans include pollution standards, instream flows, and other measures to best manage the scarce water resources of the state and to comply with other statutory and common law obligations. In setting these standards, the State and regional boards already consider impacts to groundwater resources, and they are required to mitigate those impacts to less than significant levels when feasible, or to adopt a statement of overriding considerations … In addition, in developing water quality control plans the State Water Resources Control Board already considers both flow and nonflow measures, such as habitat restoration, pollution controls, or improved water use efficiency, in order to protect and restore fisheries and other beneficial uses.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-6, 6/2/15
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Linder, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Perea, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Thurmond, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NOES: Eggman, Levine, Lopez, Quirk, Mark Stone, Ting
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bloom, Chávez, Gordon, Nazarian, Rendon
Prepared by: Dennis O'Connor / N.R. & W. / (916) 651-4116
8/19/15 21:02:21
**** END ****
AB 1242 (Gray) Page 10 of 10
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1242
Author: |
Gray |
||
Version: |
5/5/2015 |
Hearing Date: |
7/15/2015 |
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Rachel Machi Wagoner |
||
SUBJECT: Water quality: impacts on groundwater: instream flows.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act (Porter-Cologne),
Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to adopt a state policy for water quality control. The policy is to consist of any or all of the following:
Water quality principles and guidelines for long-range resource planning, including ground water and surface water management programs and control and use of recycled water.
Water quality objectives at key locations for planning and operation of water resource development projects and for water quality control activities.
Other principles and guidelines deemed essential by the state board for water quality control.
Requires the Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regional Boards) to formulate and adopt water quality control plans (WQCPs) for all areas within each region of the state that protect beneficial uses of water and meet water quality objectives. SWRCB is similarly tasked with developing statewide plans (e.g., the California Ocean Plan and the Bay-Delta Plan).
WQCPs are to include objectives that will ensure the reasonable protection of all beneficial uses, protection of water quality, and the prevention of nuisance. Porter-Cologne recognizes that it may be possible for the quality of water to be changed to some degree without unreasonably affecting beneficial uses. Consequently, regional boards are required to consider various factors in establishing water quality objectives, including:
Past, present, and probable future beneficial uses of water.
Environmental characteristics of the hydrographic unit under consideration, including the quality of water available thereto.
Water quality conditions that could reasonably be achieved through the coordinated control of all factors which affect water quality in the area.
Economic considerations.
The need for developing housing within the region.
The need to develop and use recycled water.
In developing WQCPs, Regional Boards are required to consult with and consider recommendations of affected state and local agencies.
WQCPs adopted or amended by Regional Boards must be approved by the SWRCB.
Under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires, for any project or plan subject to CEQA that would potentially have significant environmental impacts, an environmental impact report that, among other things, identifies the following:
All significant effects on the environment of the proposed project.
Mitigation measures proposed to minimize significant effects on the environment, including, but not limited to, measures to reduce the wasteful, inefficient, and unnecessary consumption of energy.
Alternatives to the proposed project.
The development and adoption of state policy for water quality control and WQCPs are subject to CEQA.
Under the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA), requires, by June 30, 2017, the formation of one or more Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in all high and medium priority basins.
SGMA requires, by January 31, 2020, GSAs in all high and medium priority basins subject to a chronic condition of overdraft to develop and adopt Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSPs) that provide for the sustainable management of the groundwater basin, as defined.
SGMA requires by January 31, 2022, GSAs in all other high and medium priority basins to develop and adopt GSPs.
SGMA requires GSPs to include, among other things:
Measurable objectives, as well as interim milestones in increments of five years, to achieve the sustainability goal in the basin within 20 years of the implementation of the plan.
A description of how the plan helps meet each objective and how each objective is intended to achieve the sustainability goal for the basin for long-term beneficial uses of groundwater.
This bill:
Requires the SWRCB, in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin, to take into consideration any applicable GSP or alternative adopted or approved SGMA.
Requires the SWRCB, before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses, to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows.
Background
SWRCB is responsible for allocating surface water rights and protecting water quality. SWRCB allocates water through an administrative system that is intended to maximize the beneficial uses of water while protecting the public trust, serving the public interest, and preventing the waste and unreasonable use or method of diversion of water.
Porter-Cologne requires the adoption of WQCPs that identify existing and potential beneficial uses of waters of the state and establish water quality objectives to protect these uses. The plans also contain implementation, surveillance and monitoring elements. While most water quality control planning is done by the Regional Boards, SWRCB has authority to adopt statewide Water Quality Control Plans and adopts the Bay-Delta Plan because of its importance as a major source of water supply for the state and the nexus with flow and water rights implementation.
The Bay-Delta Plan protects water quality in the region and includes water quality objectives to protect municipal and industrial, agricultural, and fish and wildlife beneficial uses.
SWRCB’s Bay-Delta Program facilitates the development and review of plans and policies to protect beneficial uses of the water in the Bay-Delta pursuant to the California Water Code and federal Clean Water Act. The Bay-Delta Program also facilitates water right activities related to the Bay-Delta, including implementation of the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan through water right requirements. The Bay-Delta Program resides in the Division of Water Rights because of the critical importance of flow objectives in the Bay-Delta Plan. The Bay-Delta Program also oversees implementation of the State Water Board’s and Central Valley and San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Boards’ 2008 Strategic Workplan for Activities in the Bay-Delta.
SWRCB is currently in the process of developing and implementing updates to the Bay-Delta Plan and flow objectives for priority tributaries to the Delta to protect beneficial uses in the Bay-Delta watershed. Phase 1 of this work involves updating San Joaquin River flow and southern Delta water quality requirements included in the Bay-Delta Plan. Phase 2 involves other comprehensive changes to the Bay-Delta Plan to protect beneficial uses not addressed in Phase 1. Phase 3 involves changes to water rights and other measures to implement changes to the Bay-Delta Plan from Phases 1 and 2. Phase 4 involves developing and implementing flow objectives for priority Delta tributaries outside of the Bay-Delta Plan updates.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “For the past year, SWRCB has considered a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus rivers. The proposed plan would require an additional 350,000 acre feet of water annually to be diverted from the rivers to flow out to San Francisco Bay Delta.
The author believes that “if adopted, SWRCB’s proposal will devastate the groundwater basins in the Valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminating surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users. The Board recognizes these impacts would have significant ‘but unavoidable’ adverse impacts to the region.
The author asserts, “in 2014, the Legislature passed the Sustainability Groundwater Management Act which promised to empower local communities with the tools to achieve sustainable management goals. The adoption of the Board’s proposal without mitigating measures would deny Central Valley basins one of the most important tools in that tool box: the ability to recharge the depleted groundwater table with surface flows. AB 1242 would ensure that the Board considers water neutral projects to help fish populations before diverting water out of the Valley.”
Unintended Consequences and Costs Preventing the Adoption and Implementation of Water Quality Plans? This bill would require SWRCB to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses. This bill also would require the SWRCB, when formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin, to take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative adopted under the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act.
According to the author, this bill would ensure that SWRCB considers and mitigates the adverse impacts of any new water quality control plan.
This bill would likely result in increased litigation and significant delays to the adoption of instream flows for the protection of fish and wildlife, including significant delays in SWRCB’s current efforts to adopt its Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan (Bay-Delta Plan).
The provision of the bill requiring SWRCB to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses could be interpreted to require SWRCB to fully evaluate all possible actions that could be used to increase fish populations.
SWRCB currently identifies alternative actions that could be taken to implement instream flows to protect fish and wildlife in the Bay-Delta Plan, and this information could be used by diverters during the implementation phase of the Bay-Delta plan to investigate, develop and propose projects to increase fish populations and thereby potentially reduce the amount of instream flows necessary for fish and wildlife.
Further, the bill’s language is ambiguous as to what is intended in requiring SWRCB to “identify projects for fish recovery….” Proponents may view this bill to require that SWRCB not simply identify, but comprehensively evaluate and implement, on its own, projects for fish recovery that may be implemented in lieu of in-stream flows under CEQA.
Assembly Member Gray testified in the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee that his intent is for SWRCB to fully evaluate under CEQA all possible alternatives to increasing flows.
As a result, the ambiguity of this bill would likely increase the likelihood and complexity of litigation over SWRCB’s adoption of future water quality control plans. Potential litigation and requirements that SWRCB develop substantial additional analysis could result in significant delays and additional costs for the adoption of instream flows.
Additionally, this bill could result in profound delays in SWRCB’s implementation of the Bay-Delta Plan. Delays in properly addressing the needs of water users downstream of the Delta and the associated environmental impacts could have larger ramifications for state economic activity. Without a plan ensuring fair access to water while preserving environmental resources and the public trust, economic harm is likely, in the forms of uncertainty in the agricultural industry and destruction of fisheries and tourism in the Delta.
The impediments to timely regulatory action caused by this bill would ultimately result in degraded water quality and harm to wildlife and public trust resources.
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee estimates increased contract costs for the SWRCB to perform the duties required in the bill of up to $21 million General or Water Rights Fund (which is supported by water rights fees).
SWRCB estimates increased litigation, significant delays to the adoption of instream flows for the protection of fish and wildlife, including significant delays in the SWRCB’s current efforts to adopt its Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan (Bay-Delta Plan) could result in costs in excess of $36 million to the General Fund or to the Water Rights Fund.
Is This Bill Necessary? Porter-Cologne already requires SWRCB, when developing a state policy for water quality control, to consult with and carefully evaluate the recommendations of concerned federal, state, and local agencies. Local agencies would include groundwater sustainability agencies formed to develop and implement GSPs. There are similar requirements for developing WQCPs.
SWRCB also has to comply with CEQA when adopting a state policy or a WQCP. Such analysis requires identifying and evaluating alternatives to establishing instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses.
It is not clear what benefit this bill would provide beyond that required under current law. Additionally, there is a question as to whether the perceived benefit of this legislation is worth the fiscal cost to the state, the economic cost to the region or the harm to the environment caused by the inevitable delay to adoption of WQCPs.
However, if the concern is that alternatives to instream flows are not currently considered and that the SWRCB and regional board consider water neutral projects to help fish populations before diverting water then the bill should be amended to require, when SWRCB adopts or approves water quality objectives which require instream flows for the protection of instream beneficial uses, SWRCB shall include flexibility for implementation through methods that provide the same level of protection without requiring as much water for instream flows.
Related/Prior Legislation
A number of bills were introduced this year to address one or more aspects of groundwater management in general and SGMA in particular. Bills still under active consideration this year are:
AB 453 (Bigelow) authorizes existing groundwater management plans (aka AB 3030 plans) to be renewed and amended for high and medium priority basins, until a GSP is adopted. Also grants agencies operating under an AB 3030 plan the same powers and authorities of a groundwater management agency the authorities of a groundwater sustainably agency.
AB 617 (Perea) makes numerous changes throughout SGMA: some changes are minor and technical; others are substantive policy changes, such as eliminating the requirement that a groundwater sustainability agency submit its groundwater sustainability plan to the Department of Water Resources as a condition of a groundwater sustainability agency becoming authorized to exercise its powers to implement SGMA.
AB 938 (Salas) makes a minor technical change regarding reprioritization of groundwater basins under SGMA.
AB 939 (Salas) makes a minor technical change regarding making data in support of a proposed fee available to the public.
AB 1390 (Alejo, Gomez, and Perea) streamlines legal processes used to assign water rights in a groundwater basin.
SB 13 (Pavley) makes numerous non-substantive technical changes to SGMA.
SB 226 (Pavley) streamlines legal processes used to assign water rights in a groundwater basin.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee on June 23, 2015, and passed out of committee with a vote of 6-0.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Hullers & Processors Association
Building and Construction Trades Council of Stanislaus, Merced, Tuolumne, and
Mariposa Counties
California Diary Campaign
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Women for Agriculture
City of Atwater
City of Ceres
City of Dos Palos, Mayor Jerry Antonetti
City of Gustine
City of Livingston
City of Los Banos
City of Merced
City of Modesto
City of Patterson, Mayor Luis Molina
City of Turlock, Mayor Gary Soiseth
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Congressman Jim Costa
Glen-Colusa Irrigation District
Greater Merced Chamber of Commerce
Harris Farms, Inc.
IBEW – Local 684
IBEW – Local 1245
Latino Community Roundtable
League of California Cities – Central Valley Division
Merced County Board of Supervisors
Merced County Farm Bureau
Merced County Sheriff Vernon Warnke
Merced Irrigation District
Modesto Chamber of Commerce
Modesto Irrigation District
Northern California Water Association
Regional Water Authority
Stanislaus Business Alliance
Stanislaus County Board of Supervisors
Stanislaus County Farm Bureau
Stevinson Water District
Turlock Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Irrigation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Western Growers Association
Yosemite Community College District
Yosemite Farm Credit
OPPOSITION:
California League of Conservation Voters
Center for Biological Diversity
Clean Water Action
Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation
Community Water Center
Friends of the River
Klamath Riverkeeper
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
The Nature Conservancy
Union of Concerned Scientists
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to Congressman Jim Costa, “Subsidence was a major factor motivating passage of the Sustainability Groundwater Management Act of 2014 and Merced County is significantly impacted by subsidence. However the proposal from SWRCB to require up to an additional 250,000 acre feet to be diverted to the Sacramento San Joaquin Bay-Delta from these rivers would have a catastrophic impact on the rate of subsidence of the Valley. Our agricultural economy and our region’s ability to achieve sustainable management goals laid out by the Sustainability Groundwater Management Act of 2014 are dependent on these headwaters. AB 1242, if enacted, would ensure that SWRCB consider and mitigate the adverse impact of any new water quality control plan.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to a coalition of environmental and environmental justice organizations, “Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and its regional boards are required, as they develop water quality control plans for the State, to consider all existing and potential future beneficial uses of water, as well as economic considerations …These water quality control plans include pollution standards, instream flows, and other measures to best manage the scarce water resources of the state and to comply with other statutory and common law obligations. In setting these standards, the State and regional boards already consider impacts to groundwater resources, and they are required to mitigate those impacts to less than significant levels when feasible, or to adopt a statement of overriding considerations … In addition, in developing water quality control plans the State Water Resources Control Board already considers both flow and nonflow measures, such as habitat restoration, pollution controls, or improved water use efficiency, in order to protect and restore fisheries and other beneficial uses.
Opponents argue, “AB 1242, attempts to undermine more than a century of California law, which requires maintaining adequate instream flows below dams in order to maintain healthy rivers and fisheries. The bill would limit the State Board’s ability to require instream flows in a water quality control plan by requiring the State Water Resources Control Board to identify measures to be taken instead of instream flow, regardless of whether such measures can successfully protect and restore healthy rivers and fish and wildlife populations. The bill could even be read to require the Board to eliminate all instream flow in a river, completely drying up the river.”
-- END --
AB 1242 (Gray) Page 6 of 6
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Fran Pavley, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1242 Hearing Date: June 23, 2015
Author: |
Gray |
|
|
Version: |
May 5, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
Yes |
Consultant: |
Dennis O'Connor |
||
Subject: Water quality: impacts on groundwater: instream flows
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act (Porter-Cologne), the State Water Resources Control Board (State Board) is required to adopt a state policy for water quality control.
The policy is to consist of any or all of the following:
Water quality principles and guidelines for long-range resource planning, including ground water and surface water management programs and control and use of recycled water.
Water quality objectives at key locations for planning and operation of water resource development projects and for water quality control activities.
Other principles and guidelines deemed essential by the state board for water quality control.
In developing the policy, the State Board is required to consult with and carefully evaluate the recommendations of concerned federal, state, and local agencies.
Porter-Cologne also requires the Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regional Boards) to formulate and adopt water quality control plans (WQCPs) for all areas within each region of the state that protect beneficial uses of water and meet water quality objectives. The State Board is similarly tasked with developing statewide plans (e.g., the California Ocean Plan and the Bay-Delta Plan).
WQCPs are to include objectives that will ensure the reasonable protection of all beneficial uses, protection of water quality, and the prevention of nuisance. Porter-Cologne recognizes that it may be possible for the quality of water to be changed to some degree without unreasonably affecting beneficial uses. Consequently, regional boards are required to consider various factors in establishing water quality objectives, including:
Past, present, and probable future beneficial uses of water.
Environmental characteristics of the hydrographic unit under consideration, including the quality of water available thereto.
Water quality conditions that could reasonably be achieved through the coordinated control of all factors which affect water quality in the area.
Economic considerations.
The need for developing housing within the region.
The need to develop and use recycled water.
In developing WQCPs, the Regional Boards are required to consult with and consider recommendations of affected state and local agencies.
WQCPs adopted or amended by Regional Boards must be approved by the State Board.
Development and adoption of state policy for water quality control and WQCPs are subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
CEQA requires, for any project or plan subject to CEQA that would potentially have significant environmental impacts, an environmental impact report that, among other things, identifies the following:
All significant effects on the environment of the proposed project.
Mitigation measures proposed to minimize significant effects on the environment, including, but not limited to, measures to reduce the wasteful, inefficient, and unnecessary consumption of energy.
Alternatives to the proposed project.
The Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA) requires, by June 30, 2017, the formation of one or more Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in all high and medium priority basins.
SGMA requires, by January 31, 2020, Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSPs) GSAs in all high and medium priority basins subject to a chronic condition of overdraft develop and adopt that provide for the sustainable management of the groundwater basin, as defined.
SGMA requires by January 31, 2022, GSPs all other high and medium priority basins to develop and adopt GSPs.
SGMA requires GSPs to include, among other things:
Measurable objectives, as well as interim milestones in increments of five years, to achieve the sustainability goal in the basin within 20 years of the implementation of the plan.
A description of how the plan helps meet each objective and how each objective is intended to achieve the sustainability goal for the basin for long-term beneficial uses of groundwater.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill would do two things:
Require the State Board, in formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a water quality control plan that affects a groundwater basin, to take into consideration any applicable GSP or alternative adopted or approved SGMA.
Require the State Board, before adopting or approving water quality objectives or a program of implementation that requires instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses, to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “For the past year, the State Water Resources Control Board has considered a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus rivers. The proposed plan would require an additional 350,000 acre feet of water annually to be diverted from the rivers to flow out to San Francisco Bay Delta.
“If adopted, the Board’s proposal will devastate the groundwater basins in the Valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminating surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users. The Board recognizes these impacts would have significant ‘but unavoidable’ adverse impacts to the region.
“In 2014, the Legislature passed the Sustainability Groundwater Management Act which promised to empower local communities with the tools to achieve sustainable management goals. The adoption of the Board’s proposal without mitigating measures would deny Central Valley basins one of the most important tools in that tool box: the ability to recharge the depleted groundwater table with surface flows.
“AB 1242 would ensure that the Board considers water neutral projects to help fish populations before diverting water out of the Valley.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
According to a coalition of environmental and environmental justice organizations, “Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and its regional boards are required, as they develop water quality control plans for the State, to consider all existing and potential future beneficial uses of water, as well as economic considerations …These water quality control plans include pollution standards, instream flows, and other measures to best manage the scarce water resources of the state and to comply with other statutory and common law obligations. In setting these standards, the State and regional boards already consider impacts to groundwater resources, and they are required to mitigate those impacts to less than significant levels when feasible, or to adopt a statement of overriding considerations … In addition, in developing water quality control plans the State Water Resources Control Board already considers both flow and nonflow measures, such as habitat restoration, pollution controls, or improved water use efficiency, in order to protect and restore fisheries and other beneficial uses.
“AB 1242, in contrast, attempts to undermine more than a century of California law, which requires maintaining adequate instream flows below dams in order to maintain healthy rivers and fisheries. The bill would limit the State Board’s ability to require instream flows in a water quality control plan by requiring the State Water Resources Control Board to identify measures to be taken instead of instream flow, regardless of whether such measures can successfully protect and restore healthy rivers and fish and wildlife populations. The bill could even be read to require the Board to eliminate all instream flow in a river, completely drying up the river.
“For all of these reasons, we strongly urge the committee to vote NO on AB 1242.”
COMMENTS
Is This Bill Necessary? Porter-Cologne already requires the state board, when developing a state policy for water quality control, to consult with and carefully evaluate the recommendations of concerned federal, state, and local agencies. Local agencies would include groundwater sustainability agencies formed to develop and implement GSPs. There are similar requirements for developing WQCPs.
The state board also has to comply with CEQA when adopting a state policy or a WQCP. Such analysis requires identifying and evaluating alternatives to establishing instream flows for protection of instream beneficial uses.
The author’s staff has stated that they are not looking for an analysis of projects for fish recovery beyond that required of CEQA. If so, it is not clear what this bill would provide beyond that required under current law.
Related Bills. A number of bills were introduced this year to address one or more aspects of groundwater management in general and SGMA in particular. Bills still under active consideration this year are:
AB 453 (Bigelow) Authorizes existing groundwater management plans (aka AB 3030 plans) to be renewed and amended for high and medium priority basins, until a GSP is adopted. Also grants agencies operating under an AB 3030 plan the same powers and authorities of a groundwater management agencies the authorities of a groundwater sustainably agency.
AB 617 (Perea) Makes numerous changes throughout SGMA: Some changes are minor and technical; others are substantive policy changes, such as eliminating the requirement that a groundwater sustainability agency submit its groundwater sustainability plan to DWR as a condition of a groundwater sustainability agency becoming authorized exercise its powers to implement SGMA.
AB 938 (Salas) Makes a minor technical change regarding reprioritization of groundwater basins under SGMA.
AB 939 (Salas) Makes a minor technical change regarding making data in support of a proposed available to the public.
AB 1390 (Alejo) Streamlines legal processes used to assign water rights in a groundwater basin.
SB 13 (Pavley) Makes numerous non-substantive technical changes to SGMA.
SB 226 (Pavley) Streamlines legal processes used to assign water rights in a groundwater basin.
Double-Referral. The Rules Committee referred this bill to both the Committee on Natural Resources and Water and to the Committee on Environmental Quality. Therefore, if this bill passes this committee, it will be referred to the Committee on Environmental Quality, which will consider the issues within their jurisdiction
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS: None
SUPPORT
Agricultural Council of California
Almond Hullers & Processors Association
Building and Construction Trades Council of Stanislaus, Merced, Tuolumne, and Mariposa Counties
California Diary Campaign
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Women for Agriculture
City of Atwater
City of Ceres
City of Dos Palos
City of Gustine
City of Livingston
City of Los Banos
City of Merced
City of Modesto
City of Patterson
City of Turlock
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Congressman Jim Costa
Glen-Colusa Irrigation District
Greater Merced Chamber of Commerce
Harris Farms, Inc.
IBEW – Local 684
IBEW – Local 1245
Latino Community Roundtable
League of California Cities – Central Valley Division
Merced County
Merced County Farm Bureau
Merced County Sheriff Vernon Warnke
Merced Irrigation District
Modesto Chamber of Commerce
Modesto Irrigation District
Northern California Water Association
Regional Water Authority
Stanislaus Business Alliance
Stanislaus County
Stanislaus County Farm Bureau
Stevinson Water District
The Greater Merced Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Irrigation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Western Growers Association
Yosemite Community College District
Yosemite Farm Credit
OPPOSITION
California League of Conservation Voters
Center for Biological Diversity
Clean Water Action
Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation
Community Water Center
Friends of the River
Klamath Riverkeeper
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Natural Resources Defense Counsel
Sierra Club California
The Nature Conservancy
Union of Concerned Scientists
-- END --
AB 1242
Page 3
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 1242
(Gray)
As Amended May 5, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Water |
8-4 |
Bigelow, Dodd, Beth Gaines, Gray, Harper, Mathis, Medina, Ridley-Thomas |
Levine, Cristina Garcia, Lopez, Williams |
Natural Resources |
8-1 |
Williams, Dahle, Cristina Garcia, Hadley, Harper, McCarty, Rendon, Wood |
Mark Stone |
Appropriations |
16-0 |
Gomez, Bigelow, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gordon, Holden, Jones, Quirk, Rendon, Wagner, Weber, Wood |
|
SUMMARY: Requires the State Water Resources Control Board, when setting flow requirements for a Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP), to take into consideration any applicable groundwater sustainability plans if a groundwater basin could be affected and to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows.
EXISTING LAW:
Maintains that the waters of the state are held in trust for the people of California and cannot be privately owned but can only be reasonably and beneficially used.
Tasks the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) with protecting and enforcing water rights and water quality laws, included delegated water quality authorities under the federal Clean Water Act. Places nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regional Water Boards) under the State Water Board.
Requires the Regional Water Boards, or State Water Board under specified circumstances, to formulate and adopt WQCPs for all areas within each region of the state that protect beneficial uses of water and meet water quality objectives.
Defines beneficial uses of the waters of the state to include domestic, municipal, agricultural, and industrial supply; power generation; recreation; aesthetic enjoyment; navigation; and preservation and enhancement of fish, wildlife, and other aquatic resources or preserves.
Requires the WQCP to include objectives that will ensure the reasonable protection of all beneficial uses, protection of water quality, and the prevention of nuisance while considering factors such as past, present and probably future beneficial uses of water, environmental characteristics, regional economics, the need to develop housing, and the need to expand and use recycled water.
Requires the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to prioritize California's groundwater basins in order to focus state resources. The basins are prioritized as either high, medium, low, or very low based on a combination of factors including, but not limited to, overlying population, level of dependence for urban and agricultural water supplies, and impacts on the groundwater from overdraft, subsidence, saline water intrusion, and water quality degradation.
Requires, by June 30, 2017, the formation of one or more Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in all high and medium priority basins subject to the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).
Requires, by January 31, 2020, that GSAs in all high and medium priority basins subject to a chronic condition of overdraft develop and adopt Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSPs) that provide for the sustainable management of the groundwater basin, as defined.
Requires, by January 31, 2022, that GSAs in all other high and medium priority basins subject to SGMA develop and adopt GSPs.
Allows the State Water Board to impose an interim plan for management of a groundwater basin if no GSA is formed by the deadline, no GSP is adopted by the appropriate deadline, or a GSP is adopted which DWR deems insufficient and where the basin is in a chronic condition of overdraft or in a condition where groundwater pumping is causing a significant depletion of interconnected surface waters.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, increased contract costs for the State Water Board to perform the duties required in the bill of up to $21 million (General Fund or special fund).
COMMENTS: This bill would require the State Water Board to consider SGMA GSPs, or any alternatives, when setting instream flow requirements that could "affect" a groundwater basin. This bill is assuming that if the State Water Board requires adequate water to be left instream to meet water quality needs, then locals will pump more groundwater in response.
This bill is also requiring the State Water Board to identify projects for fish recovery that may be undertaken in lieu of instream flows. However, in the Delta, there is significant scientific disagreement as to whether habitat projects or other actions can substitute for flows needed to recovery fisheries.
The Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers meet in the Delta and part of the flow passes through the San Francisco Bay and out to sea under the Golden Gate Bridge. The Delta is important to the natural environment and economy of California. The Delta's flows provide part of the drinking water supply for two-thirds of the State's population and water for a multitude of other urban uses as well as supplying some of the State's most productive agricultural areas both inside and outside of the Delta. The Delta is also one of the largest ecosystems for fish and wildlife habitat production in the United States, including commercial runs of salmon.
This bill is a direct response to the State Water Board's current process of setting in-stream flows sufficient to meet the Delta's WQCP needs. For 30 years parties on the Sacramento River and its tributaries, including the State Water Project and federal Central Valley Project, have been required to help meet flow requirements in accordance with the 1995 Delta WQCP. However, at the time that the 1995 Delta WQCP was developed, the parties on the Merced, Tuolumne and Stanislaus Rivers, which are tributaries to the San Joaquin River, claimed there was insufficient scientific information to establish flow requirements and proposed a multi-year experiment to inform the determination.
The objective of the experiment, called the "Vernalis Adaptive Management Plan" or "VAMP" was to evaluate the relative relationship between flows down the tributaries and export pumping in the Delta on fish survival. VAMP ended in 2011 after more than a decade during which the VAMP participants did not provide the high end of the flow range that was necessary to complete the experiment. Meanwhile, populations of at-risk fish species crashed in the Delta.
The Delta WQCP received a minor update in 2006. As part of that update four "emerging issues" were identified. These included: the decline of pelagic or "open water" fish such as smelt and threadfin shad; climate change impacts; Delta and Central Valley salinity; and, San Joaquin River flows. With regard to San Joaquin River flows, the State Water Board referenced data that showed various fish species within the Delta and San Joaquin River basin had not shown significant signs of recovery since adoption of the VAMP experiment and recommended additional study. Thereafter, in 2009, the State Water Board commenced a triennial update of the WQCP that is ongoing and will include a determination of what responsibility parties on the individual tributaries to the San Joaquin River have for contributing to Delta flows.
The author states this bill is necessary because the State Water Board is considering a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus Rivers. The author maintains that the proposed plan would significantly increase the level of water into the Delta and thus devastate the groundwater basins in the valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminating surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users. The author maintains that the State Board's action will deny Central Valley basins one of the most important tools in the tool box: the ability to recharge the depleted groundwater table with surface flows.
Opponents state that this bill would unreasonably limit the authority of the State Water Board to balance the use of water in the state for all beneficial uses, including fish and wildlife that are held in trust by the state. Opponents state that this bill also threatens vulnerable communities from unsustainable groundwater management by inserting a broad and inappropriate requirement that essentially makes every Basin Plan subservient to any and all GSPs in that basin with the effect of interfering with the State Water Board's ability to protect water quality. Specifically, with regard to the San Joaquin River and its tributaries, opponents note that in some years more than 80% of the natural flow of these rivers is diverted, which has devastating impacts on salmon, steelhead, and other native fisheries as well as the health of the Delta. Opponents add that during the negotiations for SGMA the author attempted to link groundwater management and the State Water Board's potential requirement for the San Joaquin River tributaries to provide adequate water to the Delta, but the approach was rejected.
Analysis Prepared by: Tina Leahy / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096 FN: 0000772
AB 1242
Page 2
Date of Hearing: May 20, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 1242
(Gray) – As Amended May 5, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Water, Parks and Wildlife |
Vote: |
8 - 4 |
|
Natural Resources |
|
8 - 1 |
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to consider any applicable groundwater sustainability plans (GSPs) or alternatives when formulating state policy or adopting a Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP) that affects a groundwater basin. This bill also requires SWRCB to identify in lieu fish recovery projects that may be undertaken before adopting instream flow requirements for beneficial use.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Increased contract costs for the SWRCB to perform the duties required in the bill of up to $21 million (GF or special fund).
This estimate is based on contract costs of a minimum $600,000 (GF or special fund) related to changes in the setting of flow requirements for each project evaluated. This amount is based on contract costs to evaluate flow alternatives in a CEQA analysis to establish San Joaquin River instream flows. Costs may be higher to quantify the trade-off between any project flow and non-flow alternatives.
To evaluate five alternative projects related to SWRCB's current work setting flows for the San Joaquin River, the additional costs would be $3 million in contract costs.
Further, the current Bay-Delta phase 1 San Joaquin River instream flow effort is only one of several instream flow efforts currently underway. Phase 2 (related to the instream flows on the Sacramento River) and Phase 4 (development of flow objectives for priority tributaries) would multiply the fiscal effect by a factor of 7 because instream flows are being developed for six other water bodies, for a total of $21 million.
Unknown, potentially significant, additional staff costs to SWRCB (GF or special fund).
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, the SWRCB is considering a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus Rivers. The proposed plan would require an additional 350,000 acre feet of water annually to be diverted from the rivers to flow out to the San Francisco Bay Delta.
The author states, if adopted, the SWRCB proposal will devastate the groundwater basins in the Valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminating surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users.
This bill requires SWRCB to identify in lieu fish recovery projects that may be undertaken before adopting instream flow requirements for beneficial use. This bill also requires SWRCB to consider applicable groundwater sustainability plans (GSPs) or alternatives when formulating state policy or adopting a Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP) that affects a groundwater basin
Background. The SWRCB and federal Central Valley Project and others are required to help meet flow requirements in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta). Until recently, the tributaries to the San Joaquin River have not had the same requirements.
The Merced, Tuolumne and Stanislaus Rivers are tributaries to the San Joaquin River. The SWRCB is now engaged in a process to determine what level of flows should be required on the tributaries.
The San Joaquin River flows northward to join the Sacramento River in the Delta. The Delta's flow provides part of the drinking water supply for two-thirds of the state's population and water for a multitude of other urban uses as well as supplying some of the state's most productive agricultural areas both inside and outside of the Delta. The Delta is also one of the largest ecosystems for fish and wildlife habitat production in the United States, including commercial runs of salmon.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 1242
Page 5
Date of Hearing: April 27, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Das Williams, Chair
AB 1242
(Gray) – As Introduced February 27, 2015
SUBJECT: Water quality: impacts on groundwater basins: mitigation measures
SUMMARY: Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB), before requiring instream flows, to evaluate impacts on groundwater, consider alternatives, and mitigate any significant adverse impacts to a groundwater basin. Prohibits the SWRCB from adopting a statement of overriding considerations or adopting a water quality control plan (WQCP) if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin.
EXISTING LAW:
Maintains that the waters of the state are held in trust for the people of California and cannot be privately owned but can only be reasonably and beneficially used.
Tasks the SWRCB with protecting and enforcing water rights and water quality laws, included delegated water quality authorities under the federal Clean Water Act. Places nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regional Boards) under the SWRCB.
Requires the Regional Boards, or SWRCB under specified circumstances, to formulate and adopt WQCPs for all areas within each region of the state that protect beneficial uses of water and meet water quality objectives.
Defines beneficial uses of the waters of the state to include domestic, municipal, agricultural, and industrial supply; power generation; recreation; aesthetic enjoyment; navigation; and preservation and enhancement of fish, wildlife, and other aquatic resources or preserves.
Requires the WQCP to include objectives that will ensure the reasonable protection of all beneficial uses, protection of water quality, and the prevention of nuisance while considering factors such as past, present and probably future beneficial uses of water, environmental characteristics, regional economics, the need to develop housing, and the need to expand and use recycled water.
Requires the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to prioritize California's groundwater basins in order to focus state resources. The basins are prioritized as either high, medium, low, or very low based on a combination of factors including, but not limited to, overlying population, level of dependence for urban and agricultural water supplies, and impacts on the groundwater from overdraft, subsidence, saline water intrusion, and water quality degradation.
Requires, by June 30, 2017, the formation of one or more Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in all high and medium priority basins subject to the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).
Requires, by January 31, 2020, that GSAs in all high and medium priority basins subject to a chronic condition of overdraft develop and adopt Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSPs) that provide for the sustainable management of the groundwater basin, as defined.
Requires, by January 31, 2022, that GSAs in all other high and medium priority basins subject to SGMA develop and adopt GSPs.
Allows the SWRCB to impose an interim plan for management of a groundwater basin if no GSA is formed by the deadline, no GSP is adopted by the appropriate deadline, or a GSP is adopted which DWR deems insufficient and where the basin is in a chronic condition of overdraft or in a condition where groundwater pumping is causing a significant depletion of interconnected surface waters.
THIS BILL:
Requires the SWRCB to consider GSPs when formulating state policy for water quality control and adopting or approving a WQCP.
Requires, before adopting instream flows that protect beneficial uses of water, that the SWRCB evaluate impacts on groundwater basins (i.e., from increased groundwater pumping in reaction to increased instream flow requirements) and consider alternatives and mitigation measures to avoid or mitigate any adverse impacts on groundwater quality or supply to the extent feasible.
Requires the SWRCB to adopt and implement mitigation measures for any significant adverse impacts to a groundwater basin caused by increased groundwater pumping.
Prohibits the SWRCB from adopting a WQCP if there is a significant adverse impact to a groundwater basin caused by increased groundwater pumping.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Background. For 30 years the State Water Project and federal Central Valley Project and others have been required to help meet flow requirements in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta), but the tributaries to the San Joaquin River avoided any requirements other than experimental flows. The SWRCB is now engaged in a long-delayed process to determine what level of flows should be provided by the tributaries. This bill would prohibit the SWRCB from imposing in-stream flow requirements on tributaries to the San Joaquin River unless the SWRCB pays for actions to mitigate when local water users pump more groundwater in response to the loss of surface water dedicated to in-stream flows.
The Merced, Tuolumne and Stanislaus Rivers are tributaries to the San Joaquin River. The San Joaquin River flows northward to join the Sacramento River in the Delta. The Delta's flow provides part of the drinking water supply for two-thirds of the state's population and water for a multitude of other urban uses as well as supplying some of the state's most productive agricultural areas both inside and outside of the Delta. The Delta is also one of the largest ecosystems for fish and wildlife habitat production in the United States, including commercial runs of salmon.
The SWRCB is responsible for protecting and managing both water rights and water quality in California. As part of its duties, the SWRCB developed a Delta WQCP in 1995 that included requirements as to how much water must be left in-stream at different times to protect and balance all beneficial uses of water including municipal and industrial, agricultural, recreational, and fish and wildlife. After adopting the Delta WQCP, the SWRCB commenced a water rights proceeding to determine the responsibilities of water rights holders to implement the flow-dependent objectives in the Delta WQCP. The water rights proceeding was massive and included parties with water rights on the Sacramento River and its tributaries, San Joaquin River and its tributaries, and in the Delta. The hearing was divided into 8 regional phases and the SWRCB encouraged parties to reach settlement agreements with other water rights holders and interested parties as a way of proposing allocations of responsibility to meet the flow-dependent objectives.
During Phase 2 of the hearing, parties on the San Joaquin River and its tributaries submitted the San Joaquin River Agreement proposing an allocation of responsibility for releasing "pulse flows" to the Delta during the April-May and October periods, which are most critical to migrating salmon. The parties argued there wasn't sufficient information to determine how much water was needed instream for fish and, therefore, they would also conduct an experiment during the April-May period called the Vernalis Adaptive Management Plan (VAMP). Under VAMP, parties on the tributaries to the San Joaquin River were paid a fixed amount of money by the federal government in return for maintaining low, medium, and high releases during different years that would be tied to low, medium, and high levels of export water by the State Water Project and federal Central Valley Project pumping plants in the Delta. The objective was to evaluate the relative relationship between flows down the San Joaquin and export pumping in the Delta on fish survival. VAMP ended in 2011 after more than a decade during which the full range of flows and export limitations were never provided to complete the experiment and, meanwhile, populations of at-risk fish species crashed in the Delta.
The Delta WQCP received a minor update in 2006 but identified, as part of that update, four "emerging issues" including the decline of pelagic or "open water" fish such as smelt and threadfin shad; climate change impacts; Delta and Central Valley salinity; and, San Joaquin River flows. With regard to San Joaquin River flows, the SWRCB referenced data that showed various fish species within the Delta and San Joaquin River basin that had not shown significant signs of recovery since adoption of the VAMP experiment and recommended additional study. Thereafter, in 2009, the SWRCB commenced a triennial update of the WQCP that is ongoing and will include a determination of what responsibility parties on the individual tributaries to the San Joaquin River have for contributing to Delta flows.
Parties on the tributaries to the San Joaquin River have advised that if they are required to leave more flows in-stream they will simply pump more groundwater. As a result, they maintain, it is the SWRCB's potential action that will be responsible for additional degradation of their groundwater basins. In this bill they seek to have the SWRCB analyze the potentially significant impact of a local increase in groundwater pumping on the basin and then require the SWRCB and not local entities mitigate for any increased degradation.
The most likely mitigation that the SWRCB would require in accordance with this bill is adoption of a GSP pursuant to SGMA. However, all basins on the eastern side of the San Joaquin River are already ranked as high priority and thus are already required to adopt a SGMA plan or submit an alternative plan that meets SGMA's requirements by the appropriate deadlines.
Author's statement:
For the past year, the SWRCB has considered a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus rivers. The proposed plan would require an additional 350,000 acre feet of water annually to be diverted from the rivers to flow out to the San Francisco Bay Delta.
If adopted, the Board’s proposal will devastate the groundwater basins in the Valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminating surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users. The Board recognizes these impacts would have significant “but unavoidable” adverse impacts to the region.
In 2014, the Legislature passed the Sustainability Groundwater Management Act which promised to empower local communities with the tools to achieve sustainable management goals. The adoption of the Board’s proposal without mitigating measures would deny Central Valley basins one of the most important tools in that tool box: the ability to recharge the depleted groundwater table with surface flows.
AB 1242 would ensure that the Board consider and mitigate the adverse impact of any new water quality control plan. It would also require the Board to implement mitigation measures to reduce identified significant adverse impacts, and would prohibit the adoption of plans with adverse impacts that cannot be sufficiently mitigated.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Agricultural Council of California
Building and Construction Trades Council of Stanislaus, Merced, Tuolumne and Mariposa
Counties
California Women for Agriculture
California Farm Bureau Federation
City of Atwater City Council
City of Ceres, Office of the Mayor
City of Dos Palos, Office of the Mayor
City of Gustine City Council
City of Livingston, Office of the Mayor
City of Los Banos, Office of the Mayor
City of Merced, Office of the Mayor
City of Modesto, Office of the Mayor
City of Patterson, Office of the Mayor
City of Turlock, Office of the Mayor
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Electrical Workers of Stanislaus, Merced, Tuolumne and Mariposa Counties
Glenn-Colusa Irrigation District
Greater Merced Chamber of Commerce
Harris Farms
IBEW Local 1245
Latino Community Roundtable
League of California Cities Central Valley Division
Merced County Board of Supervisors
Merced County Farm Bureau Board of Directors
Merced Irrigation District
Modesto Chamber of Commerce
Modesto Irrigation District
Northern California Water Association
Stanislaus Business Alliance
Stanislaus County Board of Supervisors
Stanislaus County Chapter of California Women for Agriculture
Stanislaus County Farm Bureau
Stevinson Water District
Turlock Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Irrigation District
Western Growers Association
Yosemite Community College District
Yosemite Farm Credit Association
One individual
Opposition
California League of Conservation Voters
Center for Biological Diversity
Coastal Environmental Rights Foundation
Clean Water Action
Community Water Center
Friends of the River
Klamath Riverkeeper
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra Club California
The Nature Conservancy
Union of Concerned Scientists
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092
AB 1242
Page 5
Date of Hearing: April 14, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE
Marc Levine, Chair
AB 1242
(Gray) – As Introduced February 27, 2015
SUBJECT: Groundwater: State mitigation for local actions
SUMMARY: Requires the State Water Resources Control Board implement mitigation measures for effects to groundwater basins that occur when local entities opt to pump more groundwater in response to State action. Specifically, this bill:
Requires the State Water Board to consider groundwater plans when adopting or approving a Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP).
Requires, before adopting instream flows that protect beneficial uses of water, that the State Water Board evaluate impacts on groundwater basins from increased groundwater pumping by locals in reaction to increased instream flow requirements and consider alternatives and mitigation measures to avoid or mitigate to less-than-significant any adverse impacts on the groundwater basin from increased groundwater pumping by locals, to the extent feasible.
Requires the State Water Board adopt and implement the measures to mitigate for increased groundwater pumping by locals.
Prohibits the State Water Board from adopting a WQCP if there are significant adverse impacts to a groundwater basin from increased groundwater pumping by locals.
EXISTING LAW:
Maintains that the waters of the state are held in trust for the people of California and cannot be privately owned but can only be reasonably and beneficially used.
Tasks the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) with protecting and enforcing water rights and water quality laws, included delegated water quality authorities under the federal Clean Water Act. Places nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards (Regional Water Boards) under the State Water Board.
Requires the Regional Water Boards, or State Water Board under specified circumstances, formulate and adopt water quality control plans (WQCPs) for all areas within each region of the State that protect beneficial uses of water and meet water quality objectives.
Defines beneficial uses of the waters of the state include domestic, municipal, agricultural, and industrial supply; power generation; recreation; aesthetic enjoyment; navigation; and preservation and enhancement of fish, wildlife, and other aquatic resources or preserves.
Requires the WQCP include objectives that will ensure the reasonable protection of all beneficial uses, protection of water quality, and the prevention of nuisance while considering factors such as past, present and probably future beneficial uses of water, environmental characteristics, regional economics, the need to develop housing, and the need to expand and use recycled water.
Requires the Department of Water Resources (DWR) prioritize California's groundwater basins in order to focus state resources. The basins are prioritized as either high, medium, low, or very low based on a combination of factors including, but not limited to, overlying population, level of dependence for urban and agricultural water supplies, and impacts on the groundwater from overdraft, subsidence, saline water intrusion, and water quality degradation.
Requires, by June 30 2017, the formation of one or more Groundwater Sustainability Agencies (GSAs) in all high and medium priority basins subject to the Sustainable Groundwater Management Act (SGMA).
Requires, by January 31, 2020, that GSAs in all high and medium priority basins subject to a chronic condition of overdraft develop and adopt Groundwater Sustainability Plans (GSPs) that provide for the sustainable management of the groundwater basin, as defined.
Requires, by January 31, 2022, that GSAs in all other high and medium priority basins subject to SGMA develop and adopt GSPs.
Allows the State Water Board to impose an interim plan for management of a groundwater basin if no GSA is formed by the deadline, no GSP is adopted by the appropriate deadline, or a GSP is adopted which DWR deems insufficient and where the basin is in a chronic condition of overdraft or in a condition where groundwater pumping is causing a significant depletion of interconnected surface waters.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: This bill would prohibit the State Water Board from imposing in-stream flow requirements on tributaries to the San Joaquin River unless the State Water Board pays for actions to mitigate when locals water users pump more groundwater in response. For thirty years the State Water Project and federal Central Valley Project and others have been required to help meet flow requirements in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta (Delta) but the tributaries to the San Joaquin River avoided any requirements other than experimental flows. The State Water Board is now engaged in a long-delayed process to determine what level of flows should be provided by the tributaries. This bill would prohibit that action unless it is the State Water Board who mitigates.
1. Who owns a river?
Under State law, no one can own a river. Rivers are a public trust resource, meaning they belong to the public as a whole. An individual or organization can obtain a right to divert a portion of a river's flow. But the right is limited by whether the diversion is reasonable and beneficial. A diversion or cumulative series of diversions that ruin the public trust values of a river for commercial and recreational fishing, wildlife habitat, or boating and other public enjoyment can be considered unreasonable and subject to limitations.
2. Relationship of the San Joaquin River and its tributaries to the Delta
The Merced, Tuolumne and Stanislaus Rivers are tributaries to the San Joaquin River. They originate in the high slopes of the southern Sierra Nevada Mountains and flow westward down the valley to contribute to the San Joaquin River's flow. The San Joaquin River flows northward to join the Sacramento River in the Delta. The point at which the flow of the San Joaquin River is measured to see how much it is contributing to Delta flows is near the town of Vernalis in San Joaquin County and often referred to simply as "Vernalis."
3. The Delta Water Quality Control Plan
The Delta is important to the natural environment and economy of California. The Delta's flows provide part of the drinking water supply for two-thirds of the State's population and water for a multitude of other urban uses as well as supplying some of the State's most productive agricultural areas both inside and outside of the Delta. The Delta is also one of the largest ecosystems for fish and wildlife habitat production in the United States, including commercial runs of salmon.
The State Water Board is responsible for protecting and managing both water rights and water quality in California. As part of its duties, the State Water Board developed a Delta WQCP in 1995 that included requirements as to how much water must be left in-stream at different times to protect and balance all beneficial uses of water including municipal and industrial, agricultural, recreational, and fish and wildlife. After adopting the Delta WQCP the State Water Board entered commenced a water rights proceeding to determine the responsibilities of water rights holders to implement the flow-dependent objectives in the Delta WQCP. The water rights proceeding was massive and included parties with water rights on the Sacramento River and its tributaries, San Joaquin River and its tributaries, and in the Delta. The hearing was divided into 8 regional phases and the State Water Board encouraged parties to reach settlement agreements with other water rights holders and interested parties as a way of proposing allocations of responsibility to meet the flow-dependent objectives.
4. D-1641 and failure of the Vernalis Adaptive Management Plan
During Phase 2 of the hearing, parties on the San Joaquin River and its tributaries submitted the San Joaquin River Agreement proposing an allocation of responsibility for releasing "pulse flows" to the Delta during the April-May and October periods, which are most critical to migrating salmon. The parties argued there wasn't sufficient information to determine how much water was needed instream for fish and, therefore, they would also conduct an experiment during the April-May period called the Vernalis Adaptive Management Plan (VAMP). Under VAMP, parties on the tributaries to the San Joaquin River were paid a fixed amount of money by the federal government in returning for maintaining low, medium, and high releases during different years that would be tied to low, medium, and high levels of export water by the State Water Project and Federal Central Valley Project pumping plants in the Delta. The objective was to evaluate the relative relationship between flows down the San Joaquin and export pumping in the Delta on fish survival. The VAMP flows were measured at Vernalis. VAMP ended in 2011 after more than a decade during which the full range of flows and export limitations were never provided to complete the experiment and, meanwhile, populations of at-risk fish species crashed in the Delta.
5. Current Delta WQCP update
The Delta WQCP received a minor update in 2006 but identified, as part of that update, four "emerging issues" including the decline of pelagic or "open water" fish such as smelt and threadfin shad; climate change impacts; Delta and Central Valley salinity; and, San Joaquin River flows. With regard to San Joaquin River flows, the State Water Board referenced data that showed various fish species within the Delta and San Joaquin River basin had not shown significant signs of recovery since adoption of the VAMP experiment and recommended additional study. Thereafter, in 2009, the State Water Board commenced a triennial update of the WQCP that is ongoing and will include a determination of what responsibility parties on the individual tributaries to the San Joaquin River have for contributing to Delta flows.
6. Relationship of the WQCP update to this bill
Parties on the tributaries to the San Joaquin River have advised that if they are required to leave more flows in-stream they will simply pump more groundwater. As a result, they maintain it is the State Water Board's potential action that will be responsible for additional degradation of their groundwater basins. In this bill they seek to have the State Water Board analyze the potentially significant impact of a local increase in groundwater pumping on the basin and then require the State Water Board and not local entities mitigate for any increased degradation.
7. Relationship to SGMA
The most likely mitigation that the State Water Board would require in accordance with this bill is adoption of a GSP pursuant to SGMA. However, all basins on the eastern side of the San Joaquin River are already ranked as high priority and thus are already required to adopt a SGMA plan or submit an alternative plan that meets SGMA's requirements by the appropriate deadlines.
SGMA provides locals with tools to help manage their groundwater basin over time and under changing circumstances. Under the GSP locals could investigate groundwater storage, conjunctive use programs, stormwater capture, agricultural water use efficiency incentives and other strategies for maintaining adequate supplies of groundwater. If locals are unwilling or unable to adopt a GSP, SGMA then triggers State Water Board involvement but only as a last resort.
The recently-passed Proposition 1, The Water Quality, Supply, Treatment, and Storage Projects Act of 2014, has $100 million that will be available to help locals with sustainable groundwater management planning. The Governor's January 10 budget proposes $21.3 million of those funds be made available for the 2015-2016 fiscal year. Prop. 1 also has $2.7 billion, continuously appropriated to the California Water Commission for surface water and groundwater storage projects.
Supporting argument: The author states this bill is necessary because the State Water Board is considering "a proposal to develop new unimpaired flow requirements on the Tuolumne, Merced, and Stanislaus rivers." The author maintains that the proposed plan would significantly increase the level of water into the Delta and thus "devastate the groundwater basins in the Valley by reducing surface water recharge opportunities and eliminating surface water deliveries to domestic and agricultural water users." The author maintains that the State Board's action will "deny Central Valley basins one of the most important tools in the tool box: the ability to recharge the depleted groundwater table with surface flows."
Opposing arguments: Opponents state that this bill would "unreasonably limit the authority of the State Water Board to balance the use of water in the State for all beneficial uses, including fish and wildlife that are held in trust by the State." Opponents state that this bill also fails to threaten vulnerable communities from unsustainable groundwater management by inserting a "broad and inappropriate requirement that essentially makes every Basin Plan subservient to any and all GSPs in that basin" with the effect of "placing the onus for paying for local problems on the State Water Board," interfering with the Board's ability to protect water quality, and making the Board rather than the polluter the responsible party in case of contamination. Specifically with regard to the San Joaquin River and its tributaries, opponents note that "in some years more than 80% of the natural flow of these rivers is diverted, which has devastating impacts on salmon, steelhead, and other native fisheries as well as the health of the Delta." Opponents add that "during the negotiations for SGMA the author attempted to include the provisions of this bill but they were rejected."
Related Legislation
This is one of 14 bills in the Legislature proposing changes to SGMA and its related statutes. The other bills are: AB 452 (Bigelow) restricting the State Water Board from using Water Rights Fund monies for SGMA enforcement, except funds collected from SGMA enforcement; AB 453 (Bigelow) allowing groundwater management plans that preceded SGMA to be amended and extended; AB 454 (Bigelow) adding one year to each of several SGMA deadlines; AB 455 (Bigelow) requiring the Judicial Council to come up with a 270-day process for completing all California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) legal challenges to SGMA projects; AB 617 (Perea) adding mutual water companies to GSAs; AB 938 (Salas) making minor technical changes to SGMA; AB 939 (Salas) allowing 20 days instead of 10 days to review technical data upon which a fee is based; AB 1243 (Gray) rebating 50% of all SGMA enforcement penalties back to local governments and water districts for groundwater recharge projects; AB 1390 (Alejo) creating a streamlined process for groundwater adjudications and exempting them from SGMA, except minimal reporting requirements; AB 1531 (Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee) making minor technical changes to SGMA; SB 13 (Pavley) making noncontroversial technical cleanup changes to SGMA; SB 226 (Pavley) adding a streamlined groundwater adjudication section to SGMA; and SB 487 (Nielsen) exempting SGMA projects from CEQA.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Agricultural Council of California
California Women for Agriculture
City of Ceres
City of Dos Palos
City of Merced
City of Modesto
City of Turlock
Merced County Board of Supervisors
Modesto Irrigation District
Stanislaus County Board of Supervisors
Stanislaus County Farm Bureau
Stevenson Water District
Turlock Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Irrigation District
three individuals
Opposition
Center for Biological Diversity
Clean Water Action
Community
Water Center
Leadership Counsel for Justice &
Accountability
Natural Resources Defense Council
Sierra
Club California
Union of Concerned Scientists
Analysis Prepared by: Tina Cannon Leahy / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Water, Parks, and Wildlife
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):