SB 42: Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Court Program: process and proceedings.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-27
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-27: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 640, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require, commencing July 1, 2025, that unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require the court, in the notice, to provide a general reason for the continuance if a continuance is granted, and specified reasons if the court grants dismissal. The bill would prohibit the court from disclosing certain health or medical information in the notice without the respondents consent.
This bill would authorize a facility, as defined, to refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold to the county behavioral health agency of the county where the individual resides or the county where the individual is receiving involuntary treatment if they believe the individual meets or is likely to meet CARE Act criteria. The bill would require the referral to include certain information, including the contact information for the referred individual, and other information as specified by the State Department of Health Care Services.
Existing law requires the State Department of Health Care Services, in consultation with certain entities, to develop an annual CARE Act report and post the annual report to its internet website.
The bill would additionally require the department to report certain data regarding the above-described referrals in its annual CARE Act report.
Existing law authorizes the court to dismiss a case without prejudice when the court finds that a petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that they qualify for the CARE process. Existing law requires the court to, if the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing, and the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency or their designee, order a county agency or their designee to investigate and file a written report within 14 court days.
This bill would authorize the petitioner to, subject to exception, amend the petition that was dismissed without prejudice, without refiling. The bill would require the county agency or designee to file the report as soon as practicable, or within 30 court days. The bill would also make conforming changes.
(2)Existing law requires the Judicial Council to develop a mandatory form for the CARE process that includes, among other information, the name of the respondent and the respondents address if known, and certain evidence.
This bill would specify that the evidence may include documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner has personal knowledge of the detentions. By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law authorizes a court to refer an individual from assisted outpatient treatment, misdemeanor proceedings, or specified conservatorship proceedings to CARE Act proceedings.
This bill would authorize the CARE Act court and the referring court to communicate regarding the respondents cases, while the cases are pending in both courts. The bill would, except as provided, require a record, as defined, of communications between the courts be maintained and be accessible to the parties. The bill would additionally require all communications about the disposition of a respondents case to be conducted in court and on the record.
(4)Existing law authorizes a court to establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator under specified circumstances.
This bill would require, if a petition for a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit from a certain professional, that an affidavit include an attestation by the professional that all available alternatives to conservatorship have been investigated, as specified, and appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(6)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
(1)Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require, commencing July 1, 2025, that unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require the court, in the notice, to provide a general reason for the continuance if a continuance is granted, and specified reasons if the court grants dismissal. The bill would prohibit the court from disclosing certain health or medical information in the notice without the respondents consent.
This bill would authorize a facility, as defined, to refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold to the county behavioral health agency of the county where the individual resides or the county where the individual is receiving involuntary treatment if they believe the individual meets or is likely to meet CARE Act criteria. The bill would require the referral to include certain information, including the contact information for the referred individual, and other information as specified by the State Department of Health Care Services.
Existing law requires the State Department of Health Care Services, in consultation with certain entities, to develop an annual CARE Act report and post the annual report to its internet website.
The bill would additionally require the department to report certain data regarding the above-described referrals in its annual CARE Act report.
Existing law authorizes the court to dismiss a case without prejudice when the court finds that a petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that they qualify for the CARE process. Existing law requires the court to, if the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing, and the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency or their designee, order a county agency or their designee to investigate and file a written report within 14 court days.
This bill would authorize the petitioner to, subject to exception, amend the petition that was dismissed without prejudice, without refiling. The bill would require the county agency or designee to file the report as soon as practicable, or within 30 court days. The bill would also make conforming changes.
(2)Existing law requires the Judicial Council to develop a mandatory form for the CARE process that includes, among other information, the name of the respondent and the respondents address if known, and certain evidence.
This bill would specify that the evidence may include documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner has personal knowledge of the detentions. By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law authorizes a court to refer an individual from assisted outpatient treatment, misdemeanor proceedings, or specified conservatorship proceedings to CARE Act proceedings.
This bill would authorize the CARE Act court and the referring court to communicate regarding the respondents cases, while the cases are pending in both courts. The bill would, except as provided, require a record, as defined, of communications between the courts be maintained and be accessible to the parties. The bill would additionally require all communications about the disposition of a respondents case to be conducted in court and on the record.
(4)Existing law authorizes a court to establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator under specified circumstances.
This bill would require, if a petition for a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit from a certain professional, that an affidavit include an attestation by the professional that all available alternatives to conservatorship have been investigated, as specified, and appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(6)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
(1)Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require, commencing July 1, 2025, that unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, that the court provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require the court, in the notice, to provide a general reason for the continuance if a continuance is granted, and specified reasons if the court grants dismissal. The bill would prohibit the court from disclosing certain health or medical information in the notice without the respondents consent.
This bill would authorize a facility, as defined, to refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold to the county behavioral health agency of the county where the individual resides or the county where the individual is receiving involuntary treatment if they believe the individual meets or is likely to meet CARE Act criteria. The bill would require the referral to include certain information, including the contact information for the referred individual, and other information as specified by the State Department of Health Care Services.
Existing law requires the State Department of Health Care Services, in consultation with certain entities, to develop an annual CARE Act report and post the annual report to its internet website.
The bill would additionally require the department to report certain data regarding the above-described referrals in its annual CARE Act report.
Existing law authorizes the court to dismiss a case without prejudice when the court finds that a petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that they qualify for the CARE process. Existing law requires the court to, if the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing, and the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency or their designee, order a county agency or their designee to investigate and file a written report within 14 court days.
This bill would authorize the petitioner to, subject to exception, amend the petition that was dismissed without prejudice, without refiling. The bill would require the county agency or designee to file the report as soon as practicable, or within 30 court days. The bill would also make conforming changes.
(2)Existing law requires the Judicial Council to develop a mandatory form for the CARE process that includes, among other information, the name of the respondent and the respondents address if known, and certain evidence.
This bill would specify that the evidence may include documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner has personal knowledge of the detentions. By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law authorizes a court to refer an individual from assisted outpatient treatment, misdemeanor proceedings, or specified conservatorship proceedings to CARE Act proceedings.
This bill would authorize the CARE Act court and the referring court to communicate regarding the respondents cases, while the cases are pending in both courts. The bill would, except as provided, require a record, as defined, of communications between the courts be maintained and be accessible to the parties. The bill would additionally require all communications about the disposition of a respondents case to be conducted in court and on the record.
(4)Existing law authorizes a court to establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator under specified circumstances.
This bill would require, if a petition for a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit from a certain professional, that an affidavit include an attestation by the professional that all available alternatives to conservatorship have been investigated, as specified, and appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(6)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
(1)Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, that the court provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require the court, in the notice, to provide a general reason for the continuance if a continuance is granted, and specified reasons if the court grants dismissal. The bill would prohibit the court from disclosing certain health or medical information in the notice without the respondents consent.
This bill would authorize a facility, as defined, to refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold to the county behavioral health agency of the county where the individual resides or the county where the individual is receiving involuntary treatment if they believe the individual meets or is likely to meet CARE Act criteria. The bill would require the referral to include certain information, including the contact information for the referred individual, and other information as specified by the State Department of Health Care Services.
Existing law requires the State Department of Health Care Services, in consultation with certain entities, to develop an annual CARE Act report and post the annual report to its internet website.
The bill would additionally require the department to report certain data regarding the above-described referrals in its annual CARE Act report.
Existing law authorizes the court to dismiss a case without prejudice when the court finds that a petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that they qualify for the CARE process. Existing law requires the court to, if the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing, and the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency or their designee, order a county agency or their designee to investigate and file a written report within 14 court days.
This bill would authorize the petitioner to, subject to exception, amend the petition that was dismissed without prejudice, without refiling. The bill would require the county agency or designee to file the report as soon as practicable, or within 30 court days. The bill would also make conforming changes.
(2)Existing law requires the Judicial Council to develop a mandatory form for the CARE process that includes, among other information, the name of the respondent and the respondents address if known, and certain evidence.
This bill would specify that the evidence may include documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner has personal knowledge of the detentions. By expanding the scope of the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law authorizes a court to refer an individual from assisted outpatient treatment, misdemeanor proceedings, or specified conservatorship proceedings to CARE Act proceedings.
This bill would authorize the CARE Act court and the referring court to communicate regarding the respondents cases, while the cases are pending in both courts. The bill would, except as provided, require a record, as defined, of communications between the courts be maintained and be accessible to the parties. The bill would additionally require all communications about the disposition of a respondents case to be conducted in court and on the record.
(4)Existing law authorizes a court to establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator under specified circumstances.
This bill would require, if a petition for a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit from a certain professional, that an affidavit include an attestation by the professional that all available alternatives to conservatorship have been investigated, as specified, and appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(6)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, that the court provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice to provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal. require the court, in the notice, to provide a general reason for the continuance if a continuance is granted, and specified reasons if the court grants dismissal. The bill would prohibit the court from disclosing certain health or medical information in the notice without the respondents consent.
Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require require, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, that the court to provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice to provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal.
Existing law, the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, authorizes specified adult persons to petition a civil court to create a voluntary CARE agreement or a court-ordered CARE plan and implement services, to be provided by county behavioral health agencies, to provide behavioral health care, including stabilization medication, housing, and other enumerated services, to adults who are currently experiencing a qualifying severe mental illness and who meet other specified criteria. Existing law authorizes specified individuals to file a petition to commence the CARE process, including, but not limited to, a person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. Existing law authorizes the court to assign ongoing notification rights if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
This bill would require the court to provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, if the original petitioner is a person with whom the respondent resides, or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The bill would require, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice to provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek certain agreements, including agreements that misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported or that a complainant shall withdraw a disciplinary complaint or shall not cooperate with the investigation or prosecution conducted by the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.This bill, except as specified, would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows, as defined, that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, to inform the State Bar. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would also require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement the bill.Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing law authorizes the board, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. Under existing law, it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek certain agreements, including agreements that misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported or that a complainant shall withdraw a disciplinary complaint or shall not cooperate with the investigation or prosecution conducted by the State Bar. Under existing law, a person who reports to the State Bar or causes a complaint to be filed with the State Bar that an attorney has engaged in professional misconduct, knowing the report or complaint to be false and malicious, is guilty of a misdemeanor. Existing law authorizes the State Bar to notify the appropriate district attorney or city attorney that a person has filed what the State Bar believes to be a false and malicious report or complaint against an attorney and recommend prosecution of that person.
This bill, except as specified, would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows knows, as defined, that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, ability to perform legal services with competence, to inform the State Bar. The bill would deem to have committed professional misconduct any licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to this reporting provision with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law. The bill would also require a licensee to inform the State Bar if the licensee knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. The bill would authorize the board to amend the rules of professional conduct, and require the board to propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement the bill.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California (State Bar), a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Under existing law, it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline for any licensee, whether acting on their own behalf or on behalf of someone else, whether or not in the context of litigation, to solicit, agree, or seek certain agreements, including agreements that misconduct or the terms of a settlement of a claim for misconduct shall not be reported or that a complainant shall withdraw a disciplinary complaint or shall not cooperate with the investigation or prosecution conducted by the State Bar.
This bill, except as specified, would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar.
(a)The court may establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator, on the basis of the comprehensive report of the officer providing conservatorship investigation filed pursuant to Section 5354, or on the basis of an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship stating the reasons for their recommendation, if the court is satisfied that the comprehensive report or affidavit shows the necessity for a temporary conservatorship.
(b)If the petition for establishment of a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship, the affidavit shall include an attestation by the professional person that all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act proceedings pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, have been considered by the professional person or have been investigated pursuant to Section 5354, and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(c)Except as provided in this section, a temporary conservatorship shall expire automatically after 30 days, unless prior to that date the court conducts a hearing on the issue of whether or not the proposed conservatee is gravely disabled, as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 5008.
(d)If the proposed conservatee demands a court or jury trial on the issue of whether they are gravely disabled, the court may extend the temporary conservatorship until the date of the disposition of the issue by the court or jury trial, provided that the extension does not exceed 180 days.
SEC. 2.Section 5361 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5361.(a)Conservatorship initiated pursuant to this chapter shall automatically terminate one year after the appointment of the conservator by the superior court. The period of service of a temporary conservator shall not be included in the one-year period. When the conservator has been appointed as conservator of the estate, the conservator shall, for a reasonable time, continue to have the authority over the estate that the superior court, on petition by the conservator, deems necessary for (1) the collection of assets or income that accrued during the period of conservatorship, but were uncollected before the date of termination, (2) the payment of expenses that accrued during period of conservatorship and of which the conservator was notified prior to termination, but were unpaid before the date of termination, and (3) the completion of sales of real property when the only act remaining at the date of termination is the actual transfer of title.
(b)If, upon the termination of an initial or a succeeding period of conservatorship, the conservator determines that conservatorship is still required, the conservator may petition the superior court for reappointment as conservator for a succeeding one-year period. The petition shall include the opinion of two physicians or licensed psychologists who have a doctoral degree in psychology and at least five years of postgraduate experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders that the conservatee is still gravely disabled as a result of mental disorder or impairment by chronic alcoholism. If the conservator is unable to obtain the opinion of two physicians or psychologists, the conservator shall request that the court appoint them. The petition shall also include an attestation by the conservator that they have considered all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act program pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, and that reappointment of a conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives are available.
(c)(1)A facility in which a conservatee is placed shall release the conservatee at the conservatees request when the conservatorship terminates. A petition for reappointment filed by the conservator or a petition for appointment filed by a public guardian shall be transmitted to the facility at least 30 days before the automatic termination date. The facility may detain the conservatee after the end of the termination date only if the conservatorship proceedings have not been completed and the court orders the conservatee to be held until the proceedings have been completed.
(2)A care coordination plan shall be developed by, at a minimum, the individual, the facility, the county behavioral health department, the health care payer, if different from the county, and other individuals designated by the individual as appropriate, and shall be provided to the conservatee prior to their release. The care coordination plan shall include a first followup appointment with an appropriate behavioral health professional. The appointment information shall be provided to the individual before the individual is released. In no event may the individual be involuntarily held based on the requirements of this paragraph beyond when they would otherwise qualify for release. All care and treatment after release shall be voluntary.
(3)For purposes of care coordination and to schedule a followup appointment, the health plan, mental health plan, primary care provider, or other appropriate provider to whom an individual leaving a facility has been referred pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) shall make a good faith effort to contact the referred individual no less than three times, either by email, telephone, mail, or in-person outreach, whichever method or methods are most likely to reach the individual.
(4)The requirement to develop a care coordination plan under this subdivision shall take effect immediately, without waiting for the department to create a model care coordination plan, as required pursuant to Section 5402.5.
SEC. 3.Section 5975 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5975.The Judicial Council shall develop a mandatory form for use to file a CARE process petition with the court and any other forms necessary for the CARE process. The petition shall be signed under the penalty of perjury and contain all of the following:
(a)The name of the respondent and, if known, the respondents address.
(b)The petitioners relationship to the respondent.
(c)Facts that support the petitioners assertion that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972.
(d)Either of the following:
(1)An affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional, stating that the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee has examined the respondent within 60 days of the submission of the petition, or has made multiple attempts to examine, but has not been successful in eliciting the cooperation of the respondent to submit to an examination, within 60 days of the petition, and that the licensed behavioral health professional had determined that the respondent meets, or has reason to believe, explained with specificity in the affidavit, that the respondent meets the diagnostic criteria for CARE proceedings.
(2)Evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Part 1, the most recent one within the previous 60 days. Evidence may include, but is not limited to, documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner had personal knowledge of the detentions.
SEC. 4.Section 5976.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5976.5.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, and except as otherwise provided in this section, a hearing held under this part is presumptively closed to the public.
(b)The respondent may demand that the hearing be public and be held in a place suitable for attendance by the public.
(c)The respondent may request the presence of any family member or friend without waiving the right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public.
(d)A request by any other party to the proceeding to make the hearing public may be granted if the judicial officer conducting the hearing finds that the public interest in an open hearing clearly outweighs the respondents interest in privacy.
(e)All reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information filed with the court related to the respondents health shall be confidential. The respondent may at any time petition the court for an order sealing these records or any other court records in a proceeding held under this part. Notwithstanding any rule of court prohibiting records kept confidential by law from consideration for sealing, if such a petition is filed, there shall exist a presumption in favor of sealing.
(f)The fact that evidence is admitted at a proceeding held under this part shall not be the basis for admission of that evidence in any subsequent legal proceeding.
(g)Photographs, recordings, transcripts, other records of proceedings held under this part, and testimony regarding proceedings held under this part shall not be admissible in any subsequent legal proceeding except upon motion by one of the following in that subsequent legal proceeding:
(1)The respondent.
(2)The county behavioral health agency, the public guardian, or the public conservator.
(h)In a proceeding held under this part, this section shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for that opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
(i)Before commencing a hearing at the respondents first court appearance, the judicial officer shall inform the respondent of their rights under this section. At subsequent hearings, the court is not required to advise the respondent of their rights under this section upon finding that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement of their rights.
SEC. 5.Section 5977 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case and, if the court does so, it shall order that the dismissal is without prejudice, unless Section 5975.1 applies. Nothing other than Section 5975.1 prevents a petitioner whose petition was dismissed without prejudice from refiling the petition with amended information.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, file a written report with the court as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days, and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. Parties shall complete the investigation with appropriate urgency. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines, based on the county agencys report, that the evidence does not support a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines, based on the county agencys report, that the evidence does support a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)(I)Until July 1, 2025, the court may, in its discretion, assign ongoing rights of notice to the original petitioner.
(II)Commencing July 1, 2025, unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondents consent.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner. A licensed behavioral health professional may testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 provided that the court finds that the professional has special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education sufficient to qualify as an expert under Section 720 of the Evidence Code.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
SEC. 6.Section 5977.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.1.(a)(1)At the case management hearing, the court shall hear evidence as to whether the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement.
(2)If the court finds that the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)Approve the terms of the CARE agreement or modify the terms of the CARE agreement and approve the agreement as modified by the court, and continue the matter and set a progress hearing for 60 days.
(B)Continue the matter for 14 days to allow the parties additional time to enter into a CARE agreement, upon stipulation of the parties.
(3)Nothing in this subdivision shall prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE agreement.
(b)If the court finds that the parties have not entered into a CARE agreement, and are not likely to enter into a CARE agreement, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, through a licensed behavioral health professional, to conduct a clinical evaluation of the respondent, unless there is an existing clinical evaluation of the respondent completed within the last 30 days and the parties stipulate to the use of that evaluation. The evaluation shall address, at a minimum, the following:
(1)A clinical diagnosis of the respondent.
(2)Whether the respondent has the legal capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication.
(3)Any other information as ordered by the court or that the licensed behavioral health professional conducting the evaluation determines would help the court make future informed decisions about the appropriate care and services the respondent should receive.
(4)An analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(c)(1)The court shall set a clinical evaluation hearing to review the evaluation within 21 days. The court shall order the county to file the evaluation with the court and provide the evaluation to the respondents counsel no later than five days prior to the scheduled clinical evaluation hearing. The clinical evaluation hearing may be continued for a maximum of 14 days upon stipulation of the respondent and the county behavioral health agency, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(2)At the clinical evaluation review hearing, the court shall review the evaluation and other evidence from the county behavioral health agency and the respondent. The county behavioral health agency and the respondent may present evidence and call witnesses, including the person who conducted the evaluation. Only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
(3)At the conclusion of the hearing, the court shall determine whether the respondent, by clear and convincing evidence, meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 and make orders as follows:
(A)If the court finds that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, the respondent, and the respondents counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan within 14 days.
(B)If the court does not find that clear and convincing evidence establishes that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall dismiss the petition.
(4)If the respondent is a self-identified American Indian or Alaska Native individual, as defined in Sections 1603(13), 1603(28), and 1679(a) of Title 25 of the United States Code, has been determined eligible as an Indian under Section 136.12 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or is currently receiving services from an Indian health care provider or tribal court, the county behavioral health agency shall use its best efforts to meaningfully consult with and incorporate the Indian health care provider or tribal court available to the respondent to develop the CARE plan.
(5)The evaluation and all reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court shall be confidential.
(6)The date for the hearing to review and consider approval of the proposed CARE plan shall be set not more than 14 days from the date of the order to develop a CARE plan, unless the court finds good cause for an extension. The party requesting an extension of time for the CARE plan review hearing shall provide notice to the opposing party and their counsel of the request for extension of time, and the courts order if the request is granted.
(d)(1)At the CARE plan review hearing, the parties shall present their plan or plans to the court. The county behavioral health agency or the respondent, or both, may present a proposed CARE plan.
(2)After consideration of the plans proposed by the parties, the court shall adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent. The court may issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding pursuant to Section 5982. These orders shall constitute the CARE plan and may be amended.
(3)A court may order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties, that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent the court orders medically necessary stabilization medication, the medication shall not be forcibly administered and the respondents failure to comply with a medication order shall not result in a penalty, including, but not limited to, contempt or termination of the CARE plan pursuant to Section 5979.
(4)If the proposed CARE plan includes services and supports, such as housing, provided directly or indirectly through another local governmental entity, that local entity may agree to provide the service or support, or the court may consider a motion by either of the parties to add the local entity as a party to the CARE proceeding. If the local entity agrees to provide the service or support, it may request to be added as a party by the court.
(5)If, after presentation of the CARE plan or plans, the court determines that additional information is needed, including from a licensed behavioral health professional, the court shall order a supplemental report to be filed by the county behavioral health agency for which the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(6)If there is no CARE plan because the parties have not had sufficient time to complete it, the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(7)This subdivision does not prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE plan. The court may also approve amendments to the CARE plan upon the finding that those amendments are necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, following a hearing on the issue.
(e)The issuance of an order approving a CARE plan pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) begins the CARE process timeline, which shall not exceed one year.
SEC. 7.Section 5977.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.4.(a)In all CARE Act proceedings, the judicial officer shall control the proceedings during the hearings with a view to the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future welfare of the respondent. Except when there is a contested issue of fact or law, the proceedings shall be conducted in an informal nonadversarial atmosphere with a view to obtaining the maximum cooperation of the respondent, all persons interested in the respondents welfare, and all other parties, with any provisions that the court may make for the disposition and care of the respondent. The court and relevant local public agencies shall cooperate to develop a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve performance of the CARE system in a vigorous and ongoing manner. The court is authorized to coordinate and participate in meetings to improve system performance. All evaluations and reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court pursuant to CARE Act proceedings shall be confidential.
(b)The hearings described in this chapter shall occur in person unless the court, in its discretion, allows a party or witness to appear remotely through the use of remote technology. The respondent shall have the right to be in person for all hearings.
(c)Consistent with its constitutional rulemaking authority, the Judicial Council shall adopt rules to implement the policies and provisions in this section and in Sections 5977 to 5977.4, inclusive, to promote statewide consistency, including, but not limited to, what is included in the petition form packet, communications between the CARE Act court and the juvenile court, if applicable, the role of the judiciary to improve system performance, and the process by which counsel will be appointed.
(d)(1)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, the county behavioral health agency shall include in any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court, the information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the filing. The county behavioral health agency shall not, unless ordered to do so by the court, submit to the court original or photocopied records underlying the information in a report evaluation or other document required or ordered under this subdivision. The county behavioral health agency shall serve an unredacted copy of any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court on the respondent and the respondents counsel and, with the consent of the respondent, on the supporter in a manner authorized by law. Neither a county nor an employee or agent thereof shall be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this paragraph.
(2)(A)Consistent with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, may disclose to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that is relevant to the county behavioral health agencys provision, coordination, or management of services and supports under this part, including, but not limited to, the preparation of any required investigations, evaluations, or reports. Such a disclosure is a disclosure for treatment purposes, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.506 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(B)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, that filed a CARE Act petition or executed an affidavit included with a CARE Act petition pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 5975 shall provide to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under subdivision (a) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed shall include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(C)The county behavioral health agency may apply to the court ex parte for an order requiring any provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or any covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, to provide to the county behavioral health agency, to the court, or both, any information, including, but not limited to, protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information ordered to be disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(D)A provider of health care or covered entity shall not be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this section.
(E)The county behavioral health agency shall notify the respondent of a disclosure under this paragraph as follows:
(i)By mail at the respondents last known address, if any.
(ii)To the respondents counsel.
(iii)By including a copy of the notification under clause (i) or (ii) with the next notice of hearing served upon the respondent, if any.
(F)All information, including the facts and records, or summary thereof, shared under this subdivision shall further be disclosed to the respondent and the respondents counsel, and with the consent of the respondent, to the supporter.
(3)(A)Except as expressly provided, further disclosure or redisclosure of information is not authorized by this subdivision.
(B)Information disclosed to a county behavioral health agency by a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(C)Disclosure of information under this part shall not be deemed to in any way alter the duties or responsibilities of a county behavioral health agency, of a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or of a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, with respect to the disclosed information under the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191).
SEC. 8.Section 5978.1 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.1.(a)For purposes of this section, facility means a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 5150, or a designated facility as defined in subdivision (n) of Section 5008.
(b)A facility may refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold pursuant to Articles 1 to 4.7, inclusive, and Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of this Division to the county behavioral health agency of the county in which the individual resides, or the county in which the individual is receiving involuntary treatment, if they believe that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria to qualify for the CARE process, as described in Section 5972.
(1)Referrals pursuant to this section shall be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional, employed, by or contracted by the facility, who has knowledge of the individuals case and has been involved in the individuals treatment during their involuntary hold. Documentation of the authority for a referral pursuant to this paragraph shall be signed by the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee.
(2)If the facility chooses to make a referral pursuant to subdivision (b), the facility shall make the referral pursuant to this section as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individuals discharge planning process.
(3)The facility referral shall include contact information for the referred individual, including a telephone number and address, if available, and other information as specified by the department.
(c)Within 14 business days of the referral by the facility, the county behavioral health agency shall complete assessment of the individual referred pursuant to this section and shall file a petition pursuant to Section 5975 if the county behavioral health agency determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria for the CARE process and the individual does not engage in voluntary treatment.
(d)In accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 5984, the department shall develop a referral form to be used by the facility and issue guidance regarding the following:
(1)The procedure for a facility to refer an individual to a county behavioral health agency pursuant to this section.
(2)County behavioral health agency data reporting requirements regarding referrals made pursuant to this section include, but are not limited to, total referrals, outcomes of referrals, reason for not filing a petition, length of time from referral to outcome, and services provided for those engaged voluntarily.
(e)The department shall include data regarding referrals made pursuant to this section as part of the annual CARE Act report required by Section 5985.
(f)This section does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred individual who no longer meets the criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete its assessment pursuant to subdivision (b).
(g)This section does not affect the ability of a facility to make a referral for assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346.
SEC. 9.Section 5978.2 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.2.(a)(1)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed based on a referral pursuant to Section 5978, the CARE Act court and the referring court may communicate with each other regarding the status of respondents cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(2)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed for a respondent within a juvenile courts dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction, the CARE Act court and the juvenile court may communicate with each other regarding the status of respondents cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(b)The court may allow the parties to participate in the communication. All communications about the disposition of a respondents case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
(c)Communication between courts on schedules, calendars, court records, and similar matters may occur without informing the parties. A record need not be made of the communication.
(d)Except as otherwise provided in subdivision (c), a record must be made of a communication pursuant to this section. The parties shall be informed promptly of the communication and granted access to the record.
(e)For the purposes of this section, record means information that is inscribed on a tangible medium or that is stored in an electronic or other medium and is retrievable in perceivable form.
SEC. 10.Section 5982 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5982.(a)The CARE plan may include only the following:
(1)Behavioral health services funded through the 1991 and 2011 Realignment, Medi-Cal behavioral health, health care plans and insurers, and services supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800).
(2)Medically necessary stabilization medications, to the extent not described in paragraph (1).
(3)Housing resources funded through the No Place Like Home Program (Part 3.9 (commencing with Section 5849.1) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); California Housing Accelerator (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 50672) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Multifamily Housing Program (Chapter 6.7 (commencing with Section 50675) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Homeless Housing, Assistance, and Prevention Program (Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 50216) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Encampment Resolution Funding Program (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 50250) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Project Roomkey and Rehousing Program pursuant to Provision 22 of Item 5180-151-0001 of the Budget Act of 2021 (Ch. 21, Stats. 2021); the Community Care Expansion Program (Chapter 20 (commencing with Section 18999.97) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Housing Support Program (Article 3.3 (commencing with Section 11330) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Homeless Assistance pursuant to clause (i) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (f) of Section 11450 of Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Housing and Disability Advocacy Program (Chapter 17 (commencing with Section 18999) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Home Safe Program (Chapter 14 (commencing with Section 15770) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Bringing Families Home Program (Article 6 (commencing with Section 16523) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Placement program for nonminor dependents (Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Program-Plus pursuant to subdivision (s) of Section 11400 and paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 11403.2 of Article 5 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code and Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Behavioral Health Continuum Infrastructure Program (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 5960) of Part 7 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing Program; HUD-Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing Program (Section 8(o)(19) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Section 1437f(o)(19)]); Supportive Services for Veteran Families (Section 604 of the Veterans Mental Health and Other Care Improvements Act of 2008 [38 U.S.C. Sec. 2044]); HUD Continuum of Care program (Section 103 of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 11302]); the Emergency Solutions Grant (Subtitle B of Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Secs. 11371-11378]); HUD Housing Choice Voucher program (Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f]); the Emergency Housing Vouchers (Section 3202 of the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 [Public Law 117-2]; Section 8(o) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f(o)]); HOME Investment Partnerships Program (Title II of the Cranston-Gonzalez National Affordable Housing Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 12721 et seq.]); the Community Development Block Grant Program (Title 1 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 5301 et seq.]); housing supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800); community development block grants; and other state and federal housing resources.
(4)Social services funded through Supplemental Security Income/State Supplementary Payment (SSI/SSP), Cash Assistance Program for Immigrants (CAPI), CalWORKs, California Food Assistance Program, In-Home Supportive Services program, and CalFresh.
(5)Services provided pursuant to Part 5 (commencing with Section 17000) of Division 9.
(6)Upon the consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services, additional services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(b)Individuals who are CARE process participants shall be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program.
(c)If the county behavioral health agency elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined in Section 3620 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations, the court may request information on the reasons for this and any barriers to enrollment.
(d)All CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes and regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance governing initial and ongoing program eligibility. In addition to the resources funded through programs listed in subdivision (a), the State Department of Health Care Services may identify other adjacent covered Medi-Cal services, including, but not limited to, enhanced care management and available community supports, which may be suggested, although not ordered, by the court, subject to all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance.
(e)This section does not prevent a county or other local governmental entity from recommending their own services that are their own responsibility not listed in subdivision (a) or (c). Any such recommendation is not required by this section and shall be made at the request of the county for the purposes of Section 6 of Article XIIIB, and Sections 6 and 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)For respondents who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, the county in which the respondent resides is the county of responsibility as defined in Section 1810.228 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)If a proceeding commences in a county where the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings that is different than the county in which the respondent resides, the county in which the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings shall not delay proceedings under this part and is the responsible county behavioral health agency for providing or coordinating all components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan.
(3)The county in which the respondent resides, as defined in paragraph (1), shall be responsible for the costs of providing all CARE agreement or CARE plan behavioral health services, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(4)In the event of a dispute over responsibility for any costs of providing components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan, the impacted counties shall resolve the dispute in accordance with the arbitration process established in Section 1850.405 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations for county mental health plans, including for respondents who are not Medi-Cal beneficiaries, and pursuant to any related guidance issued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
SEC. 11.Section 5985 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5985.(a)The department shall develop, in consultation with county behavioral health agencies, other relevant state or local government entities, disability rights groups, individuals with lived experience, families, counsel, racial justice experts, and other appropriate stakeholders, an annual CARE Act report. The department shall post the annual report on its internet website.
(b)County behavioral health agencies and any other state or local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide data related to the CARE Act participants, services, and supports to the department. The department shall determine the data measures and specifications, and shall publish them via guidance issues pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
(c)Each county behavioral health department and any other state and local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide the required data to the department, in a format and frequency as directed by the department.
(d)(1)In consultation with the Judicial Council, the department shall develop an annual reporting schedule for the submission of CARE Act data from the trial courts.
(2)Data from the trial courts shall be submitted to the Judicial Council, which shall aggregate the data and submit it to the department consistent with the reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)On an annual basis to be determined by the Judicial Council and consistent with the annual reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1), the trial courts shall report to the Judicial Council the following data related to CARE Act petitions:
(A)The number of petitions submitted pursuant to Section 5975.
(B)The number of initial appearances on the petition set pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 5977.
(C)The total number of hearings held pursuant to this part.
(e)The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation. The report shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)The demographics of participants, including, but not limited to, the age, sex, race, ethnicity, disability, languages spoken, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage status, including Medi-Cal enrollment status, and county of residence, to the extent statistically relevant data is available.
(2)The services and supports ordered, the services and supports provided, and the services and supports ordered but not provided.
(3)The housing placements of all participants during the program and at least one year following the termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter. Placements include, but are not limited to, transition to a higher level of care, independent living in the persons own house or apartment, community-based housing, community-based housing with services, shelter, and no housing.
(4)Treatments continued and terminated at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available.
(5)Substance use disorder rates and rates of treatment among active CARE plan participants and former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(6)Detentions and other Lanterman-Petris-Short Act involvement for participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(7)Criminal justice involvement of participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(8)Deaths among active participants and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, along with causes of death, to the extent administrative data are available.
(9)The number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings.
(10)The number, rates, and trends of supporters.
(11)The number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements.
(12)The number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans.
(13)Statistics on the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications.
(14)The rates of adherence to medication.
(15)The number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives created for participants with active CARE plans.
(16)The number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans.
(17)Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing, reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations, reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration, reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship, and reductions in substance use.
(18)A health equity assessment of the CARE Act to identify demographic disparities based on demographic data in paragraph (1), and to inform disparity reduction efforts.
(19)Data regarding referrals made pursuant to Section 5978.1, as part of the CARE Act.
(f)(1)The report shall include, at a minimum, information on the effectiveness of the CARE Act model in improving outcomes and reducing disparities, homelessness, criminal justice involvement, conservatorships, and hospitalization of participants. The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation, such as the number and source of petitions filed for CARE Court; the number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings; the number, rates, and trends of supporters; the number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements; the number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans; the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications; the rates of adherence to medication; the number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives; and the number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans. The report shall include outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing; reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations; reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration; reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship; and reductions in substance use. The annual report shall examine these data through the lens of health equity to identify racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities and inform disparity reduction efforts.
(2)Data shall be stratified by age, sex, race, ethnicity, languages spoken, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage source, and county, to the extent statistically relevant data is available. Information released or published pursuant to this section shall not contain data that may lead to the identification of respondents or information that would otherwise allow an individual to link the published information to a specific person. Data published by the department shall be deidentified in compliance with Section 164.514(a) and (b) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(g)The outcomes shall be presented to relevant state oversight bodies, including, but not limited to, the California Interagency Council on Homelessness.
SEC. 12.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 13.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
To protect the health and safety of the states most vulnerable individuals by providing additional housing and treatment services within this state, and to avoid a waste of resources, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)The court may establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator, on the basis of the comprehensive report of the officer providing conservatorship investigation filed pursuant to Section 5354, or on the basis of an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship stating the reasons for their recommendation, if the court is satisfied that the comprehensive report or affidavit shows the necessity for a temporary conservatorship.
(b)If the petition for establishment of a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship, the affidavit shall include an attestation by the professional person that all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act proceedings pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, have been considered by the professional person or have been investigated pursuant to Section 5354, and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(c)Except as provided in this section, a temporary conservatorship shall expire automatically after 30 days, unless prior to that date the court conducts a hearing on the issue of whether or not the proposed conservatee is gravely disabled, as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 5008.
(d)If the proposed conservatee demands a court or jury trial on the issue of whether they are gravely disabled, the court may extend the temporary conservatorship until the date of the disposition of the issue by the court or jury trial, provided that the extension does not exceed 180 days.
SEC. 2.Section 5361 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5361.(a)Conservatorship initiated pursuant to this chapter shall automatically terminate one year after the appointment of the conservator by the superior court. The period of service of a temporary conservator shall not be included in the one-year period. When the conservator has been appointed as conservator of the estate, the conservator shall, for a reasonable time, continue to have the authority over the estate that the superior court, on petition by the conservator, deems necessary for (1) the collection of assets or income that accrued during the period of conservatorship, but were uncollected before the date of termination, (2) the payment of expenses that accrued during period of conservatorship and of which the conservator was notified prior to termination, but were unpaid before the date of termination, and (3) the completion of sales of real property when the only act remaining at the date of termination is the actual transfer of title.
(b)If, upon the termination of an initial or a succeeding period of conservatorship, the conservator determines that conservatorship is still required, the conservator may petition the superior court for reappointment as conservator for a succeeding one-year period. The petition shall include the opinion of two physicians or licensed psychologists who have a doctoral degree in psychology and at least five years of postgraduate experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders that the conservatee is still gravely disabled as a result of mental disorder or impairment by chronic alcoholism. If the conservator is unable to obtain the opinion of two physicians or psychologists, the conservator shall request that the court appoint them. The petition shall also include an attestation by the conservator that they have considered all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act program pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, and that reappointment of a conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives are available.
(c)(1)A facility in which a conservatee is placed shall release the conservatee at the conservatees request when the conservatorship terminates. A petition for reappointment filed by the conservator or a petition for appointment filed by a public guardian shall be transmitted to the facility at least 30 days before the automatic termination date. The facility may detain the conservatee after the end of the termination date only if the conservatorship proceedings have not been completed and the court orders the conservatee to be held until the proceedings have been completed.
(2)A care coordination plan shall be developed by, at a minimum, the individual, the facility, the county behavioral health department, the health care payer, if different from the county, and other individuals designated by the individual as appropriate, and shall be provided to the conservatee prior to their release. The care coordination plan shall include a first followup appointment with an appropriate behavioral health professional. The appointment information shall be provided to the individual before the individual is released. In no event may the individual be involuntarily held based on the requirements of this paragraph beyond when they would otherwise qualify for release. All care and treatment after release shall be voluntary.
(3)For purposes of care coordination and to schedule a followup appointment, the health plan, mental health plan, primary care provider, or other appropriate provider to whom an individual leaving a facility has been referred pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) shall make a good faith effort to contact the referred individual no less than three times, either by email, telephone, mail, or in-person outreach, whichever method or methods are most likely to reach the individual.
(4)The requirement to develop a care coordination plan under this subdivision shall take effect immediately, without waiting for the department to create a model care coordination plan, as required pursuant to Section 5402.5.
SEC. 3.Section 5975 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5975.The Judicial Council shall develop a mandatory form for use to file a CARE process petition with the court and any other forms necessary for the CARE process. The petition shall be signed under the penalty of perjury and contain all of the following:
(a)The name of the respondent and, if known, the respondents address.
(b)The petitioners relationship to the respondent.
(c)Facts that support the petitioners assertion that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972.
(d)Either of the following:
(1)An affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional, stating that the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee has examined the respondent within 60 days of the submission of the petition, or has made multiple attempts to examine, but has not been successful in eliciting the cooperation of the respondent to submit to an examination, within 60 days of the petition, and that the licensed behavioral health professional had determined that the respondent meets, or has reason to believe, explained with specificity in the affidavit, that the respondent meets the diagnostic criteria for CARE proceedings.
(2)Evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Part 1, the most recent one within the previous 60 days. Evidence may include, but is not limited to, documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner had personal knowledge of the detentions.
SEC. 4.Section 5976.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5976.5.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, and except as otherwise provided in this section, a hearing held under this part is presumptively closed to the public.
(b)The respondent may demand that the hearing be public and be held in a place suitable for attendance by the public.
(c)The respondent may request the presence of any family member or friend without waiving the right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public.
(d)A request by any other party to the proceeding to make the hearing public may be granted if the judicial officer conducting the hearing finds that the public interest in an open hearing clearly outweighs the respondents interest in privacy.
(e)All reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information filed with the court related to the respondents health shall be confidential. The respondent may at any time petition the court for an order sealing these records or any other court records in a proceeding held under this part. Notwithstanding any rule of court prohibiting records kept confidential by law from consideration for sealing, if such a petition is filed, there shall exist a presumption in favor of sealing.
(f)The fact that evidence is admitted at a proceeding held under this part shall not be the basis for admission of that evidence in any subsequent legal proceeding.
(g)Photographs, recordings, transcripts, other records of proceedings held under this part, and testimony regarding proceedings held under this part shall not be admissible in any subsequent legal proceeding except upon motion by one of the following in that subsequent legal proceeding:
(1)The respondent.
(2)The county behavioral health agency, the public guardian, or the public conservator.
(h)In a proceeding held under this part, this section shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for that opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
(i)Before commencing a hearing at the respondents first court appearance, the judicial officer shall inform the respondent of their rights under this section. At subsequent hearings, the court is not required to advise the respondent of their rights under this section upon finding that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement of their rights.
SEC. 5.Section 5977 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case and, if the court does so, it shall order that the dismissal is without prejudice, unless Section 5975.1 applies. Nothing other than Section 5975.1 prevents a petitioner whose petition was dismissed without prejudice from refiling the petition with amended information.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, file a written report with the court as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days, and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. Parties shall complete the investigation with appropriate urgency. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines, based on the county agencys report, that the evidence does not support a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines, based on the county agencys report, that the evidence does support a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)(I)Until July 1, 2025, the court may, in its discretion, assign ongoing rights of notice to the original petitioner.
(II)Commencing July 1, 2025, unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondents consent.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner. A licensed behavioral health professional may testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 provided that the court finds that the professional has special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education sufficient to qualify as an expert under Section 720 of the Evidence Code.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
SEC. 6.Section 5977.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.1.(a)(1)At the case management hearing, the court shall hear evidence as to whether the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement.
(2)If the court finds that the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)Approve the terms of the CARE agreement or modify the terms of the CARE agreement and approve the agreement as modified by the court, and continue the matter and set a progress hearing for 60 days.
(B)Continue the matter for 14 days to allow the parties additional time to enter into a CARE agreement, upon stipulation of the parties.
(3)Nothing in this subdivision shall prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE agreement.
(b)If the court finds that the parties have not entered into a CARE agreement, and are not likely to enter into a CARE agreement, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, through a licensed behavioral health professional, to conduct a clinical evaluation of the respondent, unless there is an existing clinical evaluation of the respondent completed within the last 30 days and the parties stipulate to the use of that evaluation. The evaluation shall address, at a minimum, the following:
(1)A clinical diagnosis of the respondent.
(2)Whether the respondent has the legal capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication.
(3)Any other information as ordered by the court or that the licensed behavioral health professional conducting the evaluation determines would help the court make future informed decisions about the appropriate care and services the respondent should receive.
(4)An analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(c)(1)The court shall set a clinical evaluation hearing to review the evaluation within 21 days. The court shall order the county to file the evaluation with the court and provide the evaluation to the respondents counsel no later than five days prior to the scheduled clinical evaluation hearing. The clinical evaluation hearing may be continued for a maximum of 14 days upon stipulation of the respondent and the county behavioral health agency, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(2)At the clinical evaluation review hearing, the court shall review the evaluation and other evidence from the county behavioral health agency and the respondent. The county behavioral health agency and the respondent may present evidence and call witnesses, including the person who conducted the evaluation. Only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
(3)At the conclusion of the hearing, the court shall determine whether the respondent, by clear and convincing evidence, meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 and make orders as follows:
(A)If the court finds that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, the respondent, and the respondents counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan within 14 days.
(B)If the court does not find that clear and convincing evidence establishes that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall dismiss the petition.
(4)If the respondent is a self-identified American Indian or Alaska Native individual, as defined in Sections 1603(13), 1603(28), and 1679(a) of Title 25 of the United States Code, has been determined eligible as an Indian under Section 136.12 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or is currently receiving services from an Indian health care provider or tribal court, the county behavioral health agency shall use its best efforts to meaningfully consult with and incorporate the Indian health care provider or tribal court available to the respondent to develop the CARE plan.
(5)The evaluation and all reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court shall be confidential.
(6)The date for the hearing to review and consider approval of the proposed CARE plan shall be set not more than 14 days from the date of the order to develop a CARE plan, unless the court finds good cause for an extension. The party requesting an extension of time for the CARE plan review hearing shall provide notice to the opposing party and their counsel of the request for extension of time, and the courts order if the request is granted.
(d)(1)At the CARE plan review hearing, the parties shall present their plan or plans to the court. The county behavioral health agency or the respondent, or both, may present a proposed CARE plan.
(2)After consideration of the plans proposed by the parties, the court shall adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent. The court may issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding pursuant to Section 5982. These orders shall constitute the CARE plan and may be amended.
(3)A court may order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties, that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent the court orders medically necessary stabilization medication, the medication shall not be forcibly administered and the respondents failure to comply with a medication order shall not result in a penalty, including, but not limited to, contempt or termination of the CARE plan pursuant to Section 5979.
(4)If the proposed CARE plan includes services and supports, such as housing, provided directly or indirectly through another local governmental entity, that local entity may agree to provide the service or support, or the court may consider a motion by either of the parties to add the local entity as a party to the CARE proceeding. If the local entity agrees to provide the service or support, it may request to be added as a party by the court.
(5)If, after presentation of the CARE plan or plans, the court determines that additional information is needed, including from a licensed behavioral health professional, the court shall order a supplemental report to be filed by the county behavioral health agency for which the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(6)If there is no CARE plan because the parties have not had sufficient time to complete it, the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(7)This subdivision does not prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE plan. The court may also approve amendments to the CARE plan upon the finding that those amendments are necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, following a hearing on the issue.
(e)The issuance of an order approving a CARE plan pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) begins the CARE process timeline, which shall not exceed one year.
SEC. 7.Section 5977.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.4.(a)In all CARE Act proceedings, the judicial officer shall control the proceedings during the hearings with a view to the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future welfare of the respondent. Except when there is a contested issue of fact or law, the proceedings shall be conducted in an informal nonadversarial atmosphere with a view to obtaining the maximum cooperation of the respondent, all persons interested in the respondents welfare, and all other parties, with any provisions that the court may make for the disposition and care of the respondent. The court and relevant local public agencies shall cooperate to develop a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve performance of the CARE system in a vigorous and ongoing manner. The court is authorized to coordinate and participate in meetings to improve system performance. All evaluations and reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court pursuant to CARE Act proceedings shall be confidential.
(b)The hearings described in this chapter shall occur in person unless the court, in its discretion, allows a party or witness to appear remotely through the use of remote technology. The respondent shall have the right to be in person for all hearings.
(c)Consistent with its constitutional rulemaking authority, the Judicial Council shall adopt rules to implement the policies and provisions in this section and in Sections 5977 to 5977.4, inclusive, to promote statewide consistency, including, but not limited to, what is included in the petition form packet, communications between the CARE Act court and the juvenile court, if applicable, the role of the judiciary to improve system performance, and the process by which counsel will be appointed.
(d)(1)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, the county behavioral health agency shall include in any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court, the information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the filing. The county behavioral health agency shall not, unless ordered to do so by the court, submit to the court original or photocopied records underlying the information in a report evaluation or other document required or ordered under this subdivision. The county behavioral health agency shall serve an unredacted copy of any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court on the respondent and the respondents counsel and, with the consent of the respondent, on the supporter in a manner authorized by law. Neither a county nor an employee or agent thereof shall be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this paragraph.
(2)(A)Consistent with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, may disclose to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that is relevant to the county behavioral health agencys provision, coordination, or management of services and supports under this part, including, but not limited to, the preparation of any required investigations, evaluations, or reports. Such a disclosure is a disclosure for treatment purposes, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.506 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(B)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, that filed a CARE Act petition or executed an affidavit included with a CARE Act petition pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 5975 shall provide to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under subdivision (a) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed shall include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(C)The county behavioral health agency may apply to the court ex parte for an order requiring any provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or any covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, to provide to the county behavioral health agency, to the court, or both, any information, including, but not limited to, protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information ordered to be disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(D)A provider of health care or covered entity shall not be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this section.
(E)The county behavioral health agency shall notify the respondent of a disclosure under this paragraph as follows:
(i)By mail at the respondents last known address, if any.
(ii)To the respondents counsel.
(iii)By including a copy of the notification under clause (i) or (ii) with the next notice of hearing served upon the respondent, if any.
(F)All information, including the facts and records, or summary thereof, shared under this subdivision shall further be disclosed to the respondent and the respondents counsel, and with the consent of the respondent, to the supporter.
(3)(A)Except as expressly provided, further disclosure or redisclosure of information is not authorized by this subdivision.
(B)Information disclosed to a county behavioral health agency by a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(C)Disclosure of information under this part shall not be deemed to in any way alter the duties or responsibilities of a county behavioral health agency, of a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or of a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, with respect to the disclosed information under the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191).
SEC. 8.Section 5978.1 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.1.(a)For purposes of this section, facility means a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 5150, or a designated facility as defined in subdivision (n) of Section 5008.
(b)A facility may refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold pursuant to Articles 1 to 4.7, inclusive, and Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of this Division to the county behavioral health agency of the county in which the individual resides, or the county in which the individual is receiving involuntary treatment, if they believe that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria to qualify for the CARE process, as described in Section 5972.
(1)Referrals pursuant to this section shall be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional, employed, by or contracted by the facility, who has knowledge of the individuals case and has been involved in the individuals treatment during their involuntary hold. Documentation of the authority for a referral pursuant to this paragraph shall be signed by the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee.
(2)If the facility chooses to make a referral pursuant to subdivision (b), the facility shall make the referral pursuant to this section as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individuals discharge planning process.
(3)The facility referral shall include contact information for the referred individual, including a telephone number and address, if available, and other information as specified by the department.
(c)Within 14 business days of the referral by the facility, the county behavioral health agency shall complete assessment of the individual referred pursuant to this section and shall file a petition pursuant to Section 5975 if the county behavioral health agency determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria for the CARE process and the individual does not engage in voluntary treatment.
(d)In accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 5984, the department shall develop a referral form to be used by the facility and issue guidance regarding the following:
(1)The procedure for a facility to refer an individual to a county behavioral health agency pursuant to this section.
(2)County behavioral health agency data reporting requirements regarding referrals made pursuant to this section include, but are not limited to, total referrals, outcomes of referrals, reason for not filing a petition, length of time from referral to outcome, and services provided for those engaged voluntarily.
(e)The department shall include data regarding referrals made pursuant to this section as part of the annual CARE Act report required by Section 5985.
(f)This section does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred individual who no longer meets the criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete its assessment pursuant to subdivision (b).
(g)This section does not affect the ability of a facility to make a referral for assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346.
SEC. 9.Section 5978.2 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.2.(a)(1)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed based on a referral pursuant to Section 5978, the CARE Act court and the referring court may communicate with each other regarding the status of respondents cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(2)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed for a respondent within a juvenile courts dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction, the CARE Act court and the juvenile court may communicate with each other regarding the status of respondents cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(b)The court may allow the parties to participate in the communication. All communications about the disposition of a respondents case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
(c)Communication between courts on schedules, calendars, court records, and similar matters may occur without informing the parties. A record need not be made of the communication.
(d)Except as otherwise provided in subdivision (c), a record must be made of a communication pursuant to this section. The parties shall be informed promptly of the communication and granted access to the record.
(e)For the purposes of this section, record means information that is inscribed on a tangible medium or that is stored in an electronic or other medium and is retrievable in perceivable form.
SEC. 10.Section 5982 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5982.(a)The CARE plan may include only the following:
(1)Behavioral health services funded through the 1991 and 2011 Realignment, Medi-Cal behavioral health, health care plans and insurers, and services supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800).
(2)Medically necessary stabilization medications, to the extent not described in paragraph (1).
(3)Housing resources funded through the No Place Like Home Program (Part 3.9 (commencing with Section 5849.1) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); California Housing Accelerator (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 50672) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Multifamily Housing Program (Chapter 6.7 (commencing with Section 50675) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Homeless Housing, Assistance, and Prevention Program (Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 50216) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Encampment Resolution Funding Program (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 50250) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Project Roomkey and Rehousing Program pursuant to Provision 22 of Item 5180-151-0001 of the Budget Act of 2021 (Ch. 21, Stats. 2021); the Community Care Expansion Program (Chapter 20 (commencing with Section 18999.97) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Housing Support Program (Article 3.3 (commencing with Section 11330) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Homeless Assistance pursuant to clause (i) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (f) of Section 11450 of Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Housing and Disability Advocacy Program (Chapter 17 (commencing with Section 18999) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Home Safe Program (Chapter 14 (commencing with Section 15770) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Bringing Families Home Program (Article 6 (commencing with Section 16523) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Placement program for nonminor dependents (Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Program-Plus pursuant to subdivision (s) of Section 11400 and paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 11403.2 of Article 5 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code and Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Behavioral Health Continuum Infrastructure Program (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 5960) of Part 7 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing Program; HUD-Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing Program (Section 8(o)(19) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Section 1437f(o)(19)]); Supportive Services for Veteran Families (Section 604 of the Veterans Mental Health and Other Care Improvements Act of 2008 [38 U.S.C. Sec. 2044]); HUD Continuum of Care program (Section 103 of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 11302]); the Emergency Solutions Grant (Subtitle B of Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Secs. 11371-11378]); HUD Housing Choice Voucher program (Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f]); the Emergency Housing Vouchers (Section 3202 of the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 [Public Law 117-2]; Section 8(o) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f(o)]); HOME Investment Partnerships Program (Title II of the Cranston-Gonzalez National Affordable Housing Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 12721 et seq.]); the Community Development Block Grant Program (Title 1 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 5301 et seq.]); housing supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800); community development block grants; and other state and federal housing resources.
(4)Social services funded through Supplemental Security Income/State Supplementary Payment (SSI/SSP), Cash Assistance Program for Immigrants (CAPI), CalWORKs, California Food Assistance Program, In-Home Supportive Services program, and CalFresh.
(5)Services provided pursuant to Part 5 (commencing with Section 17000) of Division 9.
(6)Upon the consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services, additional services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(b)Individuals who are CARE process participants shall be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program.
(c)If the county behavioral health agency elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined in Section 3620 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations, the court may request information on the reasons for this and any barriers to enrollment.
(d)All CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes and regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance governing initial and ongoing program eligibility. In addition to the resources funded through programs listed in subdivision (a), the State Department of Health Care Services may identify other adjacent covered Medi-Cal services, including, but not limited to, enhanced care management and available community supports, which may be suggested, although not ordered, by the court, subject to all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance.
(e)This section does not prevent a county or other local governmental entity from recommending their own services that are their own responsibility not listed in subdivision (a) or (c). Any such recommendation is not required by this section and shall be made at the request of the county for the purposes of Section 6 of Article XIIIB, and Sections 6 and 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)For respondents who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, the county in which the respondent resides is the county of responsibility as defined in Section 1810.228 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)If a proceeding commences in a county where the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings that is different than the county in which the respondent resides, the county in which the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings shall not delay proceedings under this part and is the responsible county behavioral health agency for providing or coordinating all components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan.
(3)The county in which the respondent resides, as defined in paragraph (1), shall be responsible for the costs of providing all CARE agreement or CARE plan behavioral health services, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(4)In the event of a dispute over responsibility for any costs of providing components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan, the impacted counties shall resolve the dispute in accordance with the arbitration process established in Section 1850.405 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations for county mental health plans, including for respondents who are not Medi-Cal beneficiaries, and pursuant to any related guidance issued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
SEC. 11.Section 5985 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5985.(a)The department shall develop, in consultation with county behavioral health agencies, other relevant state or local government entities, disability rights groups, individuals with lived experience, families, counsel, racial justice experts, and other appropriate stakeholders, an annual CARE Act report. The department shall post the annual report on its internet website.
(b)County behavioral health agencies and any other state or local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide data related to the CARE Act participants, services, and supports to the department. The department shall determine the data measures and specifications, and shall publish them via guidance issues pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
(c)Each county behavioral health department and any other state and local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide the required data to the department, in a format and frequency as directed by the department.
(d)(1)In consultation with the Judicial Council, the department shall develop an annual reporting schedule for the submission of CARE Act data from the trial courts.
(2)Data from the trial courts shall be submitted to the Judicial Council, which shall aggregate the data and submit it to the department consistent with the reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)On an annual basis to be determined by the Judicial Council and consistent with the annual reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1), the trial courts shall report to the Judicial Council the following data related to CARE Act petitions:
(A)The number of petitions submitted pursuant to Section 5975.
(B)The number of initial appearances on the petition set pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 5977.
(C)The total number of hearings held pursuant to this part.
(e)The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation. The report shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)The demographics of participants, including, but not limited to, the age, sex, race, ethnicity, disability, languages spoken, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage status, including Medi-Cal enrollment status, and county of residence, to the extent statistically relevant data is available.
(2)The services and supports ordered, the services and supports provided, and the services and supports ordered but not provided.
(3)The housing placements of all participants during the program and at least one year following the termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter. Placements include, but are not limited to, transition to a higher level of care, independent living in the persons own house or apartment, community-based housing, community-based housing with services, shelter, and no housing.
(4)Treatments continued and terminated at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available.
(5)Substance use disorder rates and rates of treatment among active CARE plan participants and former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(6)Detentions and other Lanterman-Petris-Short Act involvement for participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(7)Criminal justice involvement of participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(8)Deaths among active participants and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, along with causes of death, to the extent administrative data are available.
(9)The number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings.
(10)The number, rates, and trends of supporters.
(11)The number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements.
(12)The number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans.
(13)Statistics on the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications.
(14)The rates of adherence to medication.
(15)The number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives created for participants with active CARE plans.
(16)The number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans.
(17)Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing, reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations, reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration, reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship, and reductions in substance use.
(18)A health equity assessment of the CARE Act to identify demographic disparities based on demographic data in paragraph (1), and to inform disparity reduction efforts.
(19)Data regarding referrals made pursuant to Section 5978.1, as part of the CARE Act.
(f)(1)The report shall include, at a minimum, information on the effectiveness of the CARE Act model in improving outcomes and reducing disparities, homelessness, criminal justice involvement, conservatorships, and hospitalization of participants. The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation, such as the number and source of petitions filed for CARE Court; the number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings; the number, rates, and trends of supporters; the number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements; the number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans; the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications; the rates of adherence to medication; the number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives; and the number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans. The report shall include outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing; reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations; reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration; reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship; and reductions in substance use. The annual report shall examine these data through the lens of health equity to identify racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities and inform disparity reduction efforts.
(2)Data shall be stratified by age, sex, race, ethnicity, languages spoken, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage source, and county, to the extent statistically relevant data is available. Information released or published pursuant to this section shall not contain data that may lead to the identification of respondents or information that would otherwise allow an individual to link the published information to a specific person. Data published by the department shall be deidentified in compliance with Section 164.514(a) and (b) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(g)The outcomes shall be presented to relevant state oversight bodies, including, but not limited to, the California Interagency Council on Homelessness.
SEC. 12.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 13.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
To protect the health and safety of the states most vulnerable individuals by providing additional housing and treatment services within this state, and to avoid a waste of resources, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)The court may establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator, on the basis of the comprehensive report of the officer providing conservatorship investigation filed pursuant to Section 5354, or on the basis of an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship stating the reasons for their recommendation, if the court is satisfied that the comprehensive report or affidavit shows the necessity for a temporary conservatorship.
(b)If the petition for establishment of a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship, the affidavit shall include an attestation by the professional person that all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act proceedings pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, have been considered by the professional person or have been investigated pursuant to Section 5354, and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(c)Except as provided in this section, a temporary conservatorship shall expire automatically after 30 days, unless prior to that date the court conducts a hearing on the issue of whether or not the proposed conservatee is gravely disabled, as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 5008.
(d)If the proposed conservatee demands a court or jury trial on the issue of whether they are gravely disabled, the court may extend the temporary conservatorship until the date of the disposition of the issue by the court or jury trial, provided that the extension does not exceed 180 days.
SEC. 2.Section 5361 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5361.(a)Conservatorship initiated pursuant to this chapter shall automatically terminate one year after the appointment of the conservator by the superior court. The period of service of a temporary conservator shall not be included in the one-year period. When the conservator has been appointed as conservator of the estate, the conservator shall, for a reasonable time, continue to have the authority over the estate that the superior court, on petition by the conservator, deems necessary for (1) the collection of assets or income that accrued during the period of conservatorship, but were uncollected before the date of termination, (2) the payment of expenses that accrued during period of conservatorship and of which the conservator was notified prior to termination, but were unpaid before the date of termination, and (3) the completion of sales of real property when the only act remaining at the date of termination is the actual transfer of title.
(b)If, upon the termination of an initial or a succeeding period of conservatorship, the conservator determines that conservatorship is still required, the conservator may petition the superior court for reappointment as conservator for a succeeding one-year period. The petition shall include the opinion of two physicians or licensed psychologists who have a doctoral degree in psychology and at least five years of postgraduate experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders that the conservatee is still gravely disabled as a result of mental disorder or impairment by chronic alcoholism. If the conservator is unable to obtain the opinion of two physicians or psychologists, the conservator shall request that the court appoint them. The petition shall also include an attestation by the conservator that they have considered all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act program pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, and that appointment of a temporary reappointment of a conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives are available.
(c)(1)A facility in which a conservatee is placed shall release the conservatee at the conservatees request when the conservatorship terminates. A petition for reappointment filed by the conservator or a petition for appointment filed by a public guardian shall be transmitted to the facility at least 30 days before the automatic termination date. The facility may detain the conservatee after the end of the termination date only if the conservatorship proceedings have not been completed and the court orders the conservatee to be held until the proceedings have been completed.
(2)A care coordination plan shall be developed by, at a minimum, the individual, the facility, the county behavioral health department, the health care payer, if different from the county, and other individuals designated by the individual as appropriate, and shall be provided to the conservatee prior to their release. The care coordination plan shall include a first followup appointment with an appropriate behavioral health professional. The appointment information shall be provided to the individual before the individual is released. In no event may the individual be involuntarily held based on the requirements of this paragraph beyond when they would otherwise qualify for release. All care and treatment after release shall be voluntary.
(3)For purposes of care coordination and to schedule a followup appointment, the health plan, mental health plan, primary care provider, or other appropriate provider to whom an individual leaving a facility has been referred pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) shall make a good faith effort to contact the referred individual no less than three times, either by email, telephone, mail, or in-person outreach, whichever method or methods are most likely to reach the individual.
(4)The requirement to develop a care coordination plan under this subdivision shall take effect immediately, without waiting for the department to create a model care coordination plan, as required pursuant to Section 5402.5.
SEC. 3.Section 5975 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5975.The Judicial Council shall develop a mandatory form for use to file a CARE process petition with the court and any other forms necessary for the CARE process. The petition shall be signed under the penalty of perjury and contain all of the following:
(a)The name of the respondent and, if known, the respondents address.
(b)The petitioners relationship to the respondent.
(c)Facts that support the petitioners assertion that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972.
(d)Either of the following:
(1)An affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional, stating that the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee has examined the respondent within 60 days of the submission of the petition, or has made multiple attempts to examine, but has not been successful in eliciting the cooperation of the respondent to submit to an examination, within 60 days of the petition, and that the licensed behavioral health professional had determined that the respondent meets, or has reason to believe, explained with specificity in the affidavit, that the respondent meets the diagnostic criteria for CARE proceedings.
(2)Evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Part 1, the most recent one within the previous 60 days. Evidence may include, but is not limited to, documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner had personal knowledge of the detentions.
SEC. 4.Section 5976.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5976.5.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, and except as otherwise provided in this section, a hearing held under this part is presumptively closed to the public.
(b)The respondent may demand that the hearing be public and be held in a place suitable for attendance by the public.
(c)The respondent may request the presence of any family member or friend without waiving the right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public.
(d)A request by any other party to the proceeding to make the hearing public may be granted if the judicial officer conducting the hearing finds that the public interest in an open hearing clearly outweighs the respondents interest in privacy.
(e)All reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information filed with the court related to the respondents health shall be confidential. The respondent may at any time petition the court for an order sealing these records or any other court records in a proceeding held under this part. Notwithstanding any rule of court prohibiting records kept confidential by law from consideration for sealing, if such a petition is filed, there shall exist a presumption in favor of sealing.
(f)The fact that evidence is admitted at a proceeding held under this part shall not be the basis for admission of that evidence in any subsequent legal proceeding.
(g)Photographs, recordings, transcripts, other records of proceedings held under this part, and testimony regarding proceedings held under this part shall not be admissible in any subsequent legal proceeding except upon motion by one of the following in that subsequent legal proceeding:
(1)The respondent.
(2)The county behavioral health agency, the public guardian, or the public conservator.
(h)In a proceeding held under this part, this section shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for that opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
(i)Before commencing a hearing at the respondents first court appearance, the judicial officer shall inform the respondent of their rights under this section. At subsequent hearings, the court is not required to advise the respondent of their rights under this section upon finding that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement of their rights.
SEC. 5.Section 5977 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case and, if the court does so, it shall order that the dismissal is without prejudice, unless Section 5975.1 applies. Nothing other than Section 5975.1 prevents a petitioner whose petition was dismissed without prejudice from refiling the petition with amended information.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, file a written report with the court as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days, and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. Parties shall complete the investigation with appropriate urgency. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines, based on the county agencys report, that the evidence does not support a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines, based on the county agencys report, that the evidence does support a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)Unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondents consent.(ii)(I)Until July 1, 2025, the court may, in its discretion, assign ongoing rights of notice to the original petitioner.
(II)Commencing July 1, 2025, unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondents consent.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner. A licensed behavioral health professional may testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 provided that the court finds that the professional qualifies as an expert. has special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education sufficient to qualify as an expert under Section 720 of the Evidence Code.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
SEC. 6.Section 5977.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.1.(a)(1)At the case management hearing, the court shall hear evidence as to whether the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement.
(2)If the court finds that the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)Approve the terms of the CARE agreement or modify the terms of the CARE agreement and approve the agreement as modified by the court, and continue the matter and set a progress hearing for 60 days.
(B)Continue the matter for 14 days to allow the parties additional time to enter into a CARE agreement, upon stipulation of the parties.
(3)Nothing in this subdivision shall prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE agreement.
(b)If the court finds that the parties have not entered into a CARE agreement, and are not likely to enter into a CARE agreement, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, through a licensed behavioral health professional, to conduct a clinical evaluation of the respondent, unless there is an existing clinical evaluation of the respondent completed within the last 30 days and the parties stipulate to the use of that evaluation. The evaluation shall address, at a minimum, the following:
(1)A clinical diagnosis of the respondent.
(2)Whether the respondent has the legal capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication.
(3)Any other information as ordered by the court or that the licensed behavioral health professional conducting the evaluation determines would help the court make future informed decisions about the appropriate care and services the respondent should receive.
(4)An analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(c)(1)The court shall set a clinical evaluation hearing to review the evaluation within 21 days. The court shall order the county to file the evaluation with the court and provide the evaluation to the respondents counsel no later than five days prior to the scheduled clinical evaluation hearing. The clinical evaluation hearing may be continued for a maximum of 14 days upon stipulation of the respondent and the county behavioral health agency, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(2)At the clinical evaluation review hearing, the court shall review the evaluation and other evidence from the county behavioral health agency and the respondent. The county behavioral health agency and the respondent may present evidence and call witnesses, including the person who conducted the evaluation. Only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
(3)At the conclusion of the hearing, the court shall determine whether the respondent, by clear and convincing evidence, meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 and make orders as follows:
(A)If the court finds that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, the respondent, and the respondents counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan within 14 days.
(B)If the court does not find that clear and convincing evidence establishes that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall dismiss the petition.
(4)If the respondent is a self-identified American Indian or Alaska Native individual, as defined in Sections 1603(13), 1603(28), and 1679(a) of Title 25 of the United States Code, has been determined eligible as an Indian under Section 136.12 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or is currently receiving services from an Indian health care provider or tribal court, the county behavioral health agency shall use its best efforts to meaningfully consult with and incorporate the Indian health care provider or tribal court available to the respondent to develop the CARE plan.
(5)The evaluation and all reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court shall be confidential.
(6)The date for the hearing to review and consider approval of the proposed CARE plan shall be set not more than 14 days from the date of the order to develop a CARE plan, unless the court finds good cause for an extension. The party requesting an extension of time for the CARE plan review hearing shall provide notice to the opposing party and their counsel of the request for extension of time, and the courts order if the request is granted.
(d)(1)At the CARE plan review hearing, the parties shall present their plan or plans to the court. The county behavioral health agency or the respondent, or both, may present a proposed CARE plan.
(2)After consideration of the plans proposed by the parties, the court shall adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent. The court may issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding pursuant to Section 5982. These orders shall constitute the CARE plan and may be amended.
(3)A court may order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties, that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent the court orders medically necessary stabilization medication, the medication shall not be forcibly administered and the respondents failure to comply with a medication order shall not result in a penalty, including, but not limited to, contempt or termination of the CARE plan pursuant to Section 5979.
(4)If the proposed CARE plan includes services and supports, such as housing, provided directly or indirectly through another local governmental entity, that local entity may agree to provide the service or support, or the court may consider a motion by either of the parties to add the local entity as a party to the CARE proceeding. If the local entity agrees to provide the service or support, it may request to be added as a party by the court.
(5)If, after presentation of the CARE plan or plans, the court determines that additional information is needed, including from a licensed behavioral health professional, the court shall order a supplemental report to be filed by the county behavioral health agency for which the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(6)If there is no CARE plan because the parties have not had sufficient time to complete it, the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(7)The CARE plan described in paragraph (2) may be amended because of changed circumstances upon agreement of the parties, or approval of the court pursuant to the procedures described in this subdivision.(7)This subdivision does not prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE plan. The court may also approve amendments to the CARE plan upon the finding that those amendments are necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, following a hearing on the issue.
(e)The issuance of an order approving a CARE plan pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) begins the CARE process timeline, which shall not exceed one year.
SEC. 7.Section 5977.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.4.(a)In all CARE Act proceedings, the judicial officer shall control the proceedings during the hearings with a view to the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future welfare of the respondent. Except when there is a contested issue of fact or law, the proceedings shall be conducted in an informal nonadversarial atmosphere with a view to obtaining the maximum cooperation of the respondent, all persons interested in the respondents welfare, and all other parties, with any provisions that the court may make for the disposition and care of the respondent. The court and relevant local public agencies shall act in conformity with cooperate to develop a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve system performance performance of the CARE system in a vigorous and ongoing manner. The court is authorized to initiate coordinate and participate in meetings to improve system performance. All evaluations and reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court pursuant to CARE Act proceedings shall be confidential.
(b)The hearings described in this chapter shall occur in person unless the court, in its discretion, allows a party or witness to appear remotely through the use of remote technology. The respondent shall have the right to be in person for all hearings.
(c)Consistent with its constitutional rulemaking authority, the Judicial Council shall adopt rules to implement the policies and provisions in this section and in Sections 5977 to 5977.4, inclusive, to promote statewide consistency, including, but not limited to, what is included in the petition form packet, communications between the CARE Act court and the juvenile court, if applicable, the role of the judiciary to improve system performance, and the process by which counsel will be appointed.
(d)(1)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, the county behavioral health agency shall include in any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court, the information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the filing. The county behavioral health agency shall not, unless ordered to do so by the court, submit to the court original or photocopied records underlying the information in a report evaluation or other document required or ordered under this subdivision. The county behavioral health agency shall serve an unredacted copy of any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court on the respondent and the respondents counsel and, with the consent of the respondent, on the supporter in a manner authorized by law. Neither a county nor an employee or agent thereof shall be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this paragraph.
(2)(A)Consistent with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, may disclose to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that is relevant to the county behavioral health agencys provision, coordination, or management of services and supports under this part, including, but not limited to, the preparation of any required investigations, evaluations, or reports. Such a disclosure is a disclosure for treatment purposes, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.506 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(B)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, that filed a CARE Act petition or executed an affidavit included with a CARE Act petition pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 5975 shall provide to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under subdivision (a) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed shall include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(C)The county behavioral health agency may apply to the court ex parte for an order requiring any provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or any covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, to provide to the county behavioral health agency, to the court, or both, any information, including, but not limited to, protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information ordered to be disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(D)A provider of health care or covered entity shall not be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this section.
(E)The county behavioral health agency shall notify the respondent of a disclosure under this paragraph as follows:
(i)By mail at the respondents last known address, if any.
(ii)To the respondents counsel.
(iii)By including a copy of the notification under clause (i) or (ii) with the next notice of hearing served upon the respondent, if any.
(F)All information, including the facts and records, or summary thereof, shared under this subdivision shall further be disclosed to the respondent and the respondents counsel, and with the consent of the respondent, to the supporter.
(3)(A)Except as expressly provided, further disclosure or redisclosure of information is not authorized by this subdivision.
(B)Information disclosed to a county behavioral health agency by a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(C)Disclosure of information under this part shall not be deemed to in any way alter the duties or responsibilities of a county behavioral health agency, of a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or of a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, with respect to the disclosed information under the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191).
SEC. 8.Section 5978.1 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.1.(a)For purposes of this section, facility means a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 5150, or a designated facility as defined in subdivision (n) of Section 5008.
(b)A facility may refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold pursuant to Articles 1 to 4.7, inclusive, and Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of this Division to the county behavioral health agency of the county in which the individual resides, or the county in which the individual is receiving involuntary treatment, if they believe that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria to qualify for the CARE process, as described in Section 5972.
(1)Referrals pursuant to this section shall be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional, employed, by or contracted by the facility, who has knowledge of the individuals case and has been involved in the individuals treatment during their involuntary hold. Documentation of the authority for a referral pursuant to this paragraph shall be signed by the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee.
(2)The If the facility chooses to make a referral pursuant to subdivision (b), the facility shall make a the referral pursuant to this section as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individuals discharge planning process.
(3)The facility referral shall include contact information for the referred individual, including a telephone number and address, if available, and other information as specified by the department.
(c)Within 14 business days of the referral by the facility, the county behavioral health agency shall complete assessment of the individual referred pursuant to this section and shall file a petition pursuant to Section 5975 if the county behavioral health agency determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria for the CARE process and the individual does not engage in voluntary treatment.
(d)In accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 5984, the department shall develop a referral form to be used by the facility and issue guidance regarding the following:
(1)The procedure for a facility to refer an individual to a county behavioral health agency pursuant to this section.
(2)County behavioral health agency data reporting requirements regarding referrals made pursuant to this section include, but are not limited to, total referrals, outcomes of referrals, reason for not filing a petition, length of time from referral to outcome, and services provided for those engaged voluntarily.
(e)The department shall include data regarding referrals made pursuant to this section as part of the annual CARE Act report required by Section 5985.
(f)This section does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred individual who no longer meets the criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete its assessment pursuant to subdivision (b).
(g)This section does not affect the ability of a facility to make a referral for assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346.
SEC. 9.Section 5978.2 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.2.(a)(1)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed based on a referral pursuant to Section 5978, the CARE Act court and the referring court may communicate with each other regarding the respondents cases the status of respondents cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(2)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed for a respondent within a juvenile courts dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction, the CARE Act court and the juvenile court may communicate with each other regarding the respondents case status of respondents cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(b)The court may allow the parties to participate in the communication. All communications about the disposition of a respondents case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
(c)Communication between courts on schedules, calendars, court records, and similar matters may occur without informing the parties. A record need not be made of the communication.
(d)Except as otherwise provided in subdivision (c), a record must be made of a communication pursuant to this section. The parties shall be informed promptly of the communication and granted access to the record.
(e)For the purposes of this section, record means information that is inscribed on a tangible medium or that is stored in an electronic or other medium and is retrievable in perceivable form.
SEC. 10.Section 5982 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5982.(a)The CARE plan may include only the following:
(1)Behavioral health services funded through the 1991 and 2011 Realignment, Medi-Cal behavioral health, health care plans and insurers, and services supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800).
(2)Medically necessary stabilization medications, to the extent not described in paragraph (1).
(3)Housing resources funded through the No Place Like Home Program (Part 3.9 (commencing with Section 5849.1) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); California Housing Accelerator (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 50672) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Multifamily Housing Program (Chapter 6.7 (commencing with Section 50675) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Homeless Housing, Assistance, and Prevention Program (Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 50216) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Encampment Resolution Funding Program (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 50250) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Project Roomkey and Rehousing Program pursuant to Provision 22 of Item 5180-151-0001 of the Budget Act of 2021 (Ch. 21, Stats. 2021); the Community Care Expansion Program (Chapter 20 (commencing with Section 18999.97) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Housing Support Program (Article 3.3 (commencing with Section 11330) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Homeless Assistance pursuant to clause (i) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (f) of Section 11450 of Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Housing and Disability Advocacy Program (Chapter 17 (commencing with Section 18999) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Home Safe Program (Chapter 14 (commencing with Section 15770) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Bringing Families Home Program (Article 6 (commencing with Section 16523) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Placement program for nonminor dependents (Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Program-Plus pursuant to subdivision (s) of Section 11400 and paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 11403.2 of Article 5 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code and Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Behavioral Health Continuum Infrastructure Program (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 5960) of Part 7 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing Program; HUD-Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing Program (Section 8(o)(19) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Section 1437f(o)(19)]); Supportive Services for Veteran Families (Section 604 of the Veterans Mental Health and Other Care Improvements Act of 2008 [38 U.S.C. Sec. 2044]); HUD Continuum of Care program (Section 103 of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 11302]); the Emergency Solutions Grant (Subtitle B of Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Secs. 11371-11378]); HUD Housing Choice Voucher program (Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f]); the Emergency Housing Vouchers (Section 3202 of the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 [Public Law 117-2]; Section 8(o) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f(o)]); HOME Investment Partnerships Program (Title II of the Cranston-Gonzalez National Affordable Housing Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 12721 et seq.]); the Community Development Block Grant Program (Title 1 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 5301 et seq.]); housing supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800); community development block grants; and other state and federal housing resources.
(4)Social services funded through Supplemental Security Income/State Supplementary Payment (SSI/SSP), Cash Assistance Program for Immigrants (CAPI), CalWORKs, California Food Assistance Program, In-Home Supportive Services program, and CalFresh.
(5)Services provided pursuant to Part 5 (commencing with Section 17000) of Division 9.
(6)Upon the consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services, additional services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(b)Individuals who are CARE process participants shall be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program.
(c)If the county behavioral health agency elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined in Section 3620 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations, the court may request information on the reasons for this and any barriers to enrollment.
(d)All CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes and regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance governing initial and ongoing program eligibility. In addition to the resources funded through programs listed in subdivision (a), the State Department of Health Care Services may identify other adjacent covered Medi-Cal services, including, but not limited to, enhanced care management and available community supports, which may be suggested, although not ordered, by the court, subject to all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance.
(e)This section does not prevent a county or other local governmental entity from recommending their own services that are their own responsibility not listed in subdivision (a) or (c). Any such recommendation is not required by this section and shall be made at the request of the county for the purposes of Section 6 of Article XIIIB, and Sections 6 and 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)For respondents who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, the county in which the respondent resides is the county of responsibility as defined in Section 1810.228 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)If a proceeding commences in a county where the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings that is different than the county in which the respondent resides, the county in which the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings shall not delay proceedings under this part and is the responsible county behavioral health agency for providing or coordinating all components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan.
(3)The county in which the respondent resides, as defined in paragraph (1), shall be responsible for the costs of providing all CARE agreement or CARE plan behavioral health services, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(4)In the event of a dispute over responsibility for any costs of providing components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan, the impacted counties shall resolve the dispute in accordance with the arbitration process established in Section 1850.405 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations for county mental health plans, including for respondents who are not Medi-Cal beneficiaries, and pursuant to any related guidance issued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
SEC. 11.Section 5985 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5985.(a)The department shall develop, in consultation with county behavioral health agencies, other relevant state or local government entities, disability rights groups, individuals with lived experience, families, counsel, racial justice experts, and other appropriate stakeholders, an annual CARE Act report. The department shall post the annual report on its internet website.
(b)County behavioral health agencies and any other state or local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide data related to the CARE Act participants, services, and supports to the department. The department shall determine the data measures and specifications, and shall publish them via guidance issues pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
(c)Each county behavioral health department and any other state and local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide the required data to the department, in a format and frequency as directed by the department.
(d)(1)In consultation with the Judicial Council, the department shall develop an annual reporting schedule for the submission of CARE Act data from the trial courts.
(2)Data from the trial courts shall be submitted to the Judicial Council, which shall aggregate the data and submit it to the department consistent with the reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)On an annual basis to be determined by the Judicial Council and consistent with the annual reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1), the trial courts shall report to the Judicial Council the following data related to CARE Act petitions:
(A)The number of petitions submitted pursuant to Section 5975.
(B)The number of initial appearances on the petition set pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 5977.
(C)The total number of hearings held pursuant to this part.
(e)The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation. The report shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)The demographics of participants, including, but not limited to, the age, sex, race, ethnicity, disability, languages spoken, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage status, including Medi-Cal enrollment status, and county of residence, to the extent statistically relevant data is available.
(2)The services and supports ordered, the services and supports provided, and the services and supports ordered but not provided.
(3)The housing placements of all participants during the program and at least one year following the termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter. Placements include, but are not limited to, transition to a higher level of care, independent living in the persons own house or apartment, community-based housing, community-based housing with services, shelter, and no housing.
(4)Treatments continued and terminated at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available.
(5)Substance use disorder rates and rates of treatment among active CARE plan participants and former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(6)Detentions and other Lanterman-Petris-Short Act involvement for participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(7)Criminal justice involvement of participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(8)Deaths among active participants and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, along with causes of death, to the extent administrative data are available.
(9)The number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings.
(10)The number, rates, and trends of supporters.
(11)The number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements.
(12)The number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans.
(13)Statistics on the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications.
(14)The rates of adherence to medication.
(15)The number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives created for participants with active CARE plans.
(16)The number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans.
(17)Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing, reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations, reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration, reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship, and reductions in substance use.
(18)A health equity assessment of the CARE Act to identify demographic disparities based on demographic data in paragraph (1), and to inform disparity reduction efforts.
(19)Data regarding referrals made pursuant to Section 5978.1, as part of the CARE Act.
(f)(1)The report shall include, at a minimum, information on the effectiveness of the CARE Act model in improving outcomes and reducing disparities, homelessness, criminal justice involvement, conservatorships, and hospitalization of participants. The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation, such as the number and source of petitions filed for CARE Court; the number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings; the number, rates, and trends of supporters; the number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements; the number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans; the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications; the rates of adherence to medication; the number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives; and the number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans. The report shall include outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing; reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations; reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration; reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship; and reductions in substance use. The annual report shall examine these data through the lens of health equity to identify racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities and inform disparity reduction efforts.
(2)Data shall be stratified by age, sex, race, ethnicity, languages spoken, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage source, and county, to the extent statistically relevant data is available. Information released or published pursuant to this section shall not contain data that may lead to the identification of respondents or information that would otherwise allow an individual to link the published information to a specific person. Data published by the department shall be deidentified in compliance with Section 164.514(a) and (b) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(g)The outcomes shall be presented to relevant state oversight bodies, including, but not limited to, the California Interagency Council on Homelessness.
SEC. 12.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 13.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
To protect the health and safety of the states most vulnerable individuals by providing additional housing and treatment services within this state, and to avoid a waste of resources, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)The court may establish a temporary conservatorship for a period not to exceed 30 days and appoint a temporary conservator, on the basis of the comprehensive report of the officer providing conservatorship investigation filed pursuant to Section 5354, or on the basis of an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship stating the reasons for their recommendation, if the court is satisfied that the comprehensive report or affidavit shows the necessity for a temporary conservatorship.
(b)If the petition for establishment of a temporary conservatorship is based on an affidavit of the professional person who recommended conservatorship, the affidavit shall include an attestation by the professional person that all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act proceedings pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, have been investigated pursuant to Section 5354, and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
(b)(c)Except as provided in this section, a temporary conservatorship shall expire automatically after 30 days, unless prior to that date the court conducts a hearing on the issue of whether or not the proposed conservatee is gravely disabled, as defined in subdivision (h) of Section 5008.
(c)(d)If the proposed conservatee demands a court or jury trial on the issue of whether they are gravely disabled, the court may extend the temporary conservatorship until the date of the disposition of the issue by the court or jury trial, provided that the extension does not exceed 180 days.
SEC. 2.Section 5361 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5361.(a)Conservatorship initiated pursuant to this chapter shall automatically terminate one year after the appointment of the conservator by the superior court. The period of service of a temporary conservator shall not be included in the one-year period. When the conservator has been appointed as conservator of the estate, the conservator shall, for a reasonable time, continue to have the authority over the estate that the superior court, on petition by the conservator, deems necessary for (1) the collection of assets or income that accrued during the period of conservatorship, but were uncollected before the date of termination, (2) the payment of expenses that accrued during period of conservatorship and of which the conservator was notified prior to termination, but were unpaid before the date of termination, and (3) the completion of sales of real property when the only act remaining at the date of termination is the actual transfer of title.
(b)If, upon the termination of an initial or a succeeding period of conservatorship, the conservator determines that conservatorship is still required, the conservator may petition the superior court for reappointment as conservator for a succeeding one-year period. The petition shall include the opinion of two physicians or licensed psychologists who have a doctoral degree in psychology and at least five years of postgraduate experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders that the conservatee is still gravely disabled as a result of mental disorder or impairment by chronic alcoholism. If the conservator is unable to obtain the opinion of two physicians or psychologists, the conservator shall request that the court appoint them. The petition shall also include an attestation by the conservator that they have considered all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346 and the CARE Act program pursuant to Section 5978, as applicable, and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives are available.
(c)(1)A facility in which a conservatee is placed shall release the conservatee at the conservatees request when the conservatorship terminates. A petition for reappointment filed by the conservator or a petition for appointment filed by a public guardian shall be transmitted to the facility at least 30 days before the automatic termination date. The facility may detain the conservatee after the end of the termination date only if the conservatorship proceedings have not been completed and the court orders the conservatee to be held until the proceedings have been completed.
(2)A care coordination plan shall be developed by, at a minimum, the individual, the facility, the county behavioral health department, the health care payer, if different from the county, and other individuals designated by the individual as appropriate, and shall be provided to the conservatee prior to their release. The care coordination plan shall include a first followup appointment with an appropriate behavioral health professional. The appointment information shall be provided to the individual before the individual is released. In no event may the individual be involuntarily held based on the requirements of this paragraph beyond when they would otherwise qualify for release. All care and treatment after release shall be voluntary.
(3)For purposes of care coordination and to schedule a followup appointment, the health plan, mental health plan, primary care provider, or other appropriate provider to whom an individual leaving a facility has been referred pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) shall make a good faith effort to contact the referred individual no less than three times, either by email, telephone, mail, or in-person outreach, whichever method or methods are most likely to reach the individual.
(4)The requirement to develop a care coordination plan under this subdivision shall take effect immediately, without waiting for the department to create a model care coordination plan, as required pursuant to Section 5402.5.
SEC. 3.Section 5975 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5975.The Judicial Council shall develop a mandatory form for use to file a CARE process petition with the court and any other forms necessary for the CARE process. The petition shall be signed under the penalty of perjury and contain all of the following:
(a)The name of the respondent and, if known, the respondents address.
(b)The petitioners relationship to the respondent.
(c)Facts that support the petitioners assertion that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972.
(d)Either of the following:
(1)An affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional, stating that the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee has examined the respondent within 60 days of the submission of the petition, or has made multiple attempts to examine, but has not been successful in eliciting the cooperation of the respondent to submit to an examination, within 60 days of the petition, and that the licensed behavioral health professional had determined that the respondent meets, or has reason to believe, explained with specificity in the affidavit, that the respondent meets the diagnostic criteria for CARE proceedings.
(2)Evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to Article 4 (commencing with Section 5250) of Chapter 2 of Part 1, the most recent one within the previous 60 days. Evidence may include, but is not limited to, documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner had personal knowledge of the detentions.
SEC. 4.Section 5976.5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5976.5.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, and except as otherwise provided in this section, a hearing held under this part is presumptively closed to the public.
(b)The respondent may demand that the hearing be public and be held in a place suitable for attendance by the public.
(c)The respondent may request the presence of any family member or friend without waiving the right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public.
(d)A request by any other party to the proceeding to make the hearing public may be granted if the judicial officer conducting the hearing finds that the public interest in an open hearing clearly outweighs the respondents interest in privacy.
(e)All reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information filed with the court related to the respondents health shall be confidential. The respondent may at any time petition the court for an order sealing these records or any other court records in a proceeding held under this part. Notwithstanding any rule of court prohibiting records kept confidential by law from consideration for sealing, if such a petition is filed, there shall exist a presumption in favor of sealing.
(f)The fact that evidence is admitted at a proceeding held under this part shall not be the basis for admission of that evidence in any subsequent legal proceeding.
(g)Photographs, recordings, transcripts, other records of proceedings held under this part, and testimony regarding proceedings held under this part shall not be admissible in any subsequent legal proceeding except upon motion by one of the following in that subsequent legal proceeding:
(1)The respondent.
(2)The county behavioral health agency, the public guardian, or the public conservator.
(h)In a proceeding held under this part, this section shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for that opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
(i)Before commencing a hearing, hearing at the respondents first court appearance, the judicial officer shall inform the respondent of their rights under this section. At subsequent hearings, the court is not required to advise the respondent of their rights under this section upon finding that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement of their rights.
SECTION 1.SEC. 5.Section 5977 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case without prejudice subject to consideration of Section 5975.1. and, if the court does so, it shall order that the dismissal is without prejudice, unless Section 5975.1 applies. Nothing other than Section 5975.1 prevents a petitioner whose petition was dismissed without prejudice from refiling the petition with amended information.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, and file a written report with the court within 14 as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days days, and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. Parties shall complete the investigation with appropriate urgency. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the 14-day report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines that determines, based on the county agencys report report, that the evidence does not support the petitions a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines that determines, based on the county agencys report report, that the evidence does support the petitions a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)Unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify whether the dismissal was granted pursuant to a reason specified in Section 5977.1, 5977.3, or 5979. the statutory basis for the dismissal. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondents consent.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner. A licensed behavioral health professional may testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 provided that the court finds that the professional qualifies as an expert.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
SEC. 6.Section 5977.1 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.1.(a)(1)At the case management hearing, the court shall hear evidence as to whether the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement.
(2)If the court finds that the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)Approve the terms of the CARE agreement or modify the terms of the CARE agreement and approve the agreement as modified by the court, and continue the matter and set a progress hearing for 60 days.
(B)Continue the matter for 14 days to allow the parties additional time to enter into a CARE agreement, upon stipulation of the parties.
(3)Nothing in this subdivision shall prohibit the parties from agreeing to, and the court from approving, amendments to the CARE agreement.
(b)If the court finds that the parties have not entered into a CARE agreement, and are not likely to enter into a CARE agreement, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, through a licensed behavioral health professional, to conduct a clinical evaluation of the respondent, unless there is an existing clinical evaluation of the respondent completed within the last 30 days and the parties stipulate to the use of that evaluation. The evaluation shall address, at a minimum, the following:
(1)A clinical diagnosis of the respondent.
(2)Whether the respondent has the legal capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication.
(3)Any other information as ordered by the court or that the licensed behavioral health professional conducting the evaluation determines would help the court make future informed decisions about the appropriate care and services the respondent should receive.
(4)An analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(c)(1)The court shall set a clinical evaluation hearing to review the evaluation within 21 days. The court shall order the county to file the evaluation with the court and provide the evaluation to the respondents counsel no later than five days prior to the scheduled clinical evaluation hearing. The clinical evaluation hearing may be continued for a maximum of 14 days upon stipulation of the respondent and the county behavioral health agency, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(2)At the clinical evaluation review hearing, the court shall review the evaluation and other evidence from the county behavioral health agency and the respondent. The county behavioral health agency and the respondent may present evidence and call witnesses, including the person who conducted the evaluation. Only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
(3)At the conclusion of the hearing, the court shall determine whether the respondent, by clear and convincing evidence, meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972 and make orders as follows:
(A)If the court finds that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency, the respondent, and the respondents counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan within 14 days.
(B)If the court does not find that clear and convincing evidence establishes that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court shall dismiss the petition.
(4)If the respondent is a self-identified American Indian or Alaska Native individual, as defined in Sections 1603(13), 1603(28), and 1679(a) of Title 25 of the United States Code, has been determined eligible as an Indian under Section 136.12 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or is currently receiving services from an Indian health care provider or tribal court, the county behavioral health agency shall use its best efforts to meaningfully consult with and incorporate the Indian health care provider or tribal court available to the respondent to develop the CARE plan.
(5)The evaluation and all reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court shall be confidential.
(6)The date for the hearing to review and consider approval of the proposed CARE plan shall be set not more than 14 days from the date of the order to develop a CARE plan, unless the court finds good cause for an extension. The party requesting an extension of time for the CARE plan review hearing shall provide notice to the opposing party and their counsel of the request for extension of time, and the courts order if the request is granted.
(d)(1)At the CARE plan review hearing, the parties shall present their plan or plans to the court. The county behavioral health agency or the respondent, or both, may present a proposed CARE plan.
(2)After consideration of the plans proposed by the parties, the court shall adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent. The court may issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding pursuant to Section 5982. These orders shall constitute the CARE plan. plan and may be amended.
(3)A court may order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties, that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent the court orders medically necessary stabilization medication, the medication shall not be forcibly administered and the respondents failure to comply with a medication order shall not result in a penalty, including, but not limited to, contempt or termination of the CARE plan pursuant to Section 5979.
(4)If the proposed CARE plan includes services and supports, such as housing, provided directly or indirectly through another local governmental entity, that local entity may agree to provide the service or support, or the court may consider a motion by either of the parties to add the local entity as a party to the CARE proceeding. If the local entity agrees to provide the service or support, it may request to be added as a party by the court.
(5)If, after presentation of the CARE plan or plans, the court determines that additional information is needed, including from a licensed behavioral health professional, the court shall order a supplemental report to be filed by the county behavioral health agency for which the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(6)If there is no CARE plan because the parties have not had sufficient time to complete it, the court may grant a continuance of no more than 14 days, unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
(7)The CARE plan described in paragraph (2) may be amended because of changed circumstances upon agreement of the parties, or approval of the court pursuant to the procedures described in this subdivision.
(e)The issuance of an order approving a CARE plan pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) begins the CARE process timeline, which shall not exceed one year.
SEC. 7.Section 5977.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5977.4.(a)In all CARE Act proceedings, the judicial officer shall control the proceedings during the hearings with a view to the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future welfare of the respondent. Except when there is a contested issue of fact or law, the proceedings shall be conducted in an informal nonadversarial atmosphere with a view to obtaining the maximum cooperation of the respondent, all persons interested in the respondents welfare, and all other parties, with any provisions that the court may make for the disposition and care of the respondent. The court and relevant local public agencies shall act in conformity with a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve system performance in a vigorous and ongoing manner. The court is authorized to initiate meetings to improve system performance. All evaluations and reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court pursuant to CARE Act proceedings shall be confidential.
(b)The hearings described in this chapter shall occur in person unless the court, in its discretion, allows a party or witness to appear remotely through the use of remote technology. The respondent shall have the right to be in person for all hearings.
(c)Consistent with its constitutional rulemaking authority, the Judicial Council shall adopt rules to implement the policies and provisions in this section and in Sections 5977, 5977.1, 5977.2, and 5977.3 5977 to 5977.4, inclusive, to promote statewide consistency, including, but not limited to, what is included in the petition form packet, communications between the CARE Act court and the juvenile court, if applicable, the role of the judiciary to improve system performance, and the process by which counsel will be appointed.
(d)(1)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, the county behavioral health agency shall include in any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court, the information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the filing. The county behavioral health agency shall not, unless ordered to do so by the court, submit to the court original or photocopied records underlying the information in a report evaluation or other document required or ordered under this subdivision. The county behavioral health agency shall serve an unredacted copy of any report evaluation, or other document filed with the court on the respondent and the respondents counsel and, with the consent of the respondent, on the supporter in a manner authorized by law. Neither a county nor an employee or agent thereof shall be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this paragraph.
(2)(A)Consistent with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, may disclose to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that is relevant to the county behavioral health agencys provision, coordination, or management of services and supports under this part, including, but not limited to, the preparation of any required investigations, evaluations, or reports. Such a disclosure is a disclosure for treatment purposes, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.506 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(B)Consistent with paragraph (9) of subdivision (b) of Section 56.10 of the Civil Code, a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, that filed a CARE Act petition or executed an affidavit included with a CARE Act petition pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 5975 shall provide to the county behavioral health agency any information, including protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under subdivision (a) of Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information disclosed shall include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(C)The county behavioral health agency may apply to the court ex parte for an order requiring any provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or any covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, to provide to the county behavioral health agency, to the court, or both, any information, including, but not limited to, protected health information, and mental health records excluding psychotherapy notes, in its possession about the respondent that may be relevant in connection with an investigation, evaluation, or other report or hearing under this part, or with the provision of services and supports under this part. The provision of information under this paragraph is a disclosure required by law, which may be made only to the extent permitted under Section 164.512 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. The information ordered to be disclosed may include substance use disorder patient records only to the extent permitted by Part 2 (commencing with Section 2.1) of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(D)A provider of health care or covered entity shall not be held civilly or criminally liable for any disclosure authorized or required by this section.
(E)The county behavioral health agency shall notify the respondent of a disclosure under this paragraph as follows:
(i)By mail at the respondents last known address, if any.
(ii)To the respondents counsel.
(iii)By including a copy of the notification under clause (i) or (ii) with the next notice of hearing served upon the respondent, if any.
(F)All information, including the facts and records, or summary thereof, shared under this subdivision shall further be disclosed to the respondent and the respondents counsel, and with the consent of the respondent, to the supporter.
(3)(A)Except as expressly provided, further disclosure or redisclosure of information is not authorized by this subdivision.
(B)Information disclosed to a county behavioral health agency by a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(C)Disclosure of information under this part shall not be deemed to in any way alter the duties or responsibilities of a county behavioral health agency, of a provider of health care, as defined in Section 56.05 of the Civil Code, or of a covered entity, as defined in Section 160.103 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations, with respect to the disclosed information under the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191).
SEC. 8.Section 5978.1 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.1.(a)For purposes of this section, facility means a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 5150, or a designated facility as defined in subdivision (n) of Section 5008.
(b)A facility may refer an individual treated under an involuntary hold pursuant to Articles 1 to 4.7, inclusive, and Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 1 of this Division to the county behavioral health agency of the county in which the individual resides, or the county in which the individual is receiving involuntary treatment, if they believe that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria to qualify for the CARE process, as described in Section 5972.
(1)Referrals pursuant to this section shall be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional, employed, by or contracted by the facility, who has knowledge of the individuals case and has been involved in the individuals treatment during their involuntary hold. Documentation of the authority for a referral pursuant to this paragraph shall be signed by the licensed behavioral health professional or their designee.
(2)The facility shall make a referral pursuant to this section as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individuals discharge planning process.
(3)The facility referral shall include contact information for the referred individual, including a telephone number and address, if available, and other information as specified by the department.
(c)Within 14 business days of the referral by the facility, the county behavioral health agency shall complete assessment of the individual referred pursuant to this section and shall file a petition pursuant to Section 5975 if the county behavioral health agency determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria for the CARE process and the individual does not engage in voluntary treatment.
(d)In accordance with subdivision (b) of Section 5984, the department shall develop a referral form to be used by the facility and issue guidance regarding the following:
(1)The procedure for a facility to refer an individual to a county behavioral health agency pursuant to this section.
(2)County behavioral health agency data reporting requirements regarding referrals made pursuant to this section include, but are not limited to, total referrals, outcomes of referrals, reason for not filing a petition, length of time from referral to outcome, and services provided for those engaged voluntarily.
(e)The department shall include data regarding referrals made pursuant to this section as part of the annual CARE Act report required by Section 5985.
(f)This section does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred individual who no longer meets the criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete its assessment pursuant to subdivision (b).
(g)This section does not affect the ability of a facility to make a referral for assisted outpatient treatment pursuant to Section 5346.
SEC. 9.Section 5978.2 is added to the Welfare and Institutions Code, to read:5978.2.(a)(1)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed based on a referral pursuant to Section 5978, the CARE Act court and the referring court may communicate with each other regarding the respondents cases while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(2)If a petition to initiate CARE Act proceedings has been filed for a respondent within a juvenile courts dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction, the CARE Act court and the juvenile court may communicate with each other regarding the respondents case while the cases are still pending in both courts.
(b)The court may allow the parties to participate in the communication. All communications about the disposition of a respondents case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
(c)Communication between courts on schedules, calendars, court records, and similar matters may occur without informing the parties. A record need not be made of the communication.
(d)Except as otherwise provided in subdivision (c), a record must be made of a communication pursuant to this section. The parties shall be informed promptly of the communication and granted access to the record.
(e)For the purposes of this section, record means information that is inscribed on a tangible medium or that is stored in an electronic or other medium and is retrievable in perceivable form.
SEC. 10.Section 5982 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5982.(a)The CARE plan may include only the following:
(1)Behavioral health services funded through the 1991 and 2011 Realignment, Medi-Cal behavioral health, health care plans and insurers, and services supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800).
(2)Medically necessary stabilization medications, to the extent not described in paragraph (1).
(3)Housing resources funded through the No Place Like Home Program (Part 3.9 (commencing with Section 5849.1) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); California Housing Accelerator (Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 50672) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Multifamily Housing Program (Chapter 6.7 (commencing with Section 50675) of Part 2 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Homeless Housing, Assistance, and Prevention Program (Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 50216) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Encampment Resolution Funding Program (Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 50250) of Part 1 of Division 31 of the Health and Safety Code); the Project Roomkey and Rehousing Program pursuant to Provision 22 of Item 5180-151-0001 of the Budget Act of 2021 (Ch. 21, Stats. 2021); the Community Care Expansion Program (Chapter 20 (commencing with Section 18999.97) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Housing Support Program (Article 3.3 (commencing with Section 11330) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the CalWORKs Homeless Assistance pursuant to clause (i) of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (f) of Section 11450 of Article 6 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Housing and Disability Advocacy Program (Chapter 17 (commencing with Section 18999) of Part 6 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Home Safe Program (Chapter 14 (commencing with Section 15770) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Bringing Families Home Program (Article 6 (commencing with Section 16523) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Placement program for nonminor dependents (Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Transitional Housing Program-Plus pursuant to subdivision (s) of Section 11400 and paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 11403.2 of Article 5 of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code and Article 4 (commencing with Section 16522) of Chapter 5 of Part 4 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code; the Behavioral Health Continuum Infrastructure Program (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 5960) of Part 7 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code); the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing Program; HUD-Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing Program (Section 8(o)(19) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Section 1437f(o)(19)]); Supportive Services for Veteran Families (Section 604 of the Veterans Mental Health and Other Care Improvements Act of 2008 [38 U.S.C. Sec. 2044]); HUD Continuum of Care program (Section 103 of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 11302]); the Emergency Solutions Grant (Subtitle B of Title IV of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act [42 U.S.C. Secs. 11371-11378]); HUD Housing Choice Voucher program (Section 8 of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f]); the Emergency Housing Vouchers (Section 3202 of the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021 [Public Law 117-2]; Section 8(o) of the United States Housing Act of 1937 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 1437f(o)]); HOME Investment Partnerships Program (Title II of the Cranston-Gonzalez National Affordable Housing Act [42 U.S.C. Sec. 12721 et seq.]); the Community Development Block Grant Program (Title 1 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974 [42 U.S.C. Sec. 5301 et seq.]); housing supported by the Mental Health Services Act pursuant to Part 3 (commencing with Section 5800); community development block grants; and other state and federal housing resources.
(4)Social services funded through Supplemental Security Income/State Supplementary Payment (SSI/SSP), Cash Assistance Program for Immigrants (CAPI), CalWORKs, California Food Assistance Program, In-Home Supportive Services program, and CalFresh.
(5)Services provided pursuant to Part 5 (commencing with Section 17000) of Division 9.
(6)Upon the consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services, additional services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
(b)Individuals who are CARE process participants shall be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program.
(c)If the county behavioral health agency elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined in Section 3620 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations, the court may request information on the reasons for this and any barriers to enrollment.
(d)All CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes and regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance governing initial and ongoing program eligibility. In addition to the resources funded through programs listed in subdivision (a), the State Department of Health Care Services may identify other adjacent covered Medi-Cal services, including, but not limited to, enhanced care management and available community supports, which may be suggested, although not ordered, by the court, subject to all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions, and policy guidance.
(e)This section does not prevent a county or other local governmental entity from recommending their own services that are their own responsibility not listed in subdivision (a) or (c). Any such recommendation is not required by this section and shall be made at the request of the county for the purposes of Section 6 of Article XIIIB, and Sections 6 and 36 of Article XIII of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)For respondents who are Medi-Cal beneficiaries, the county in which the respondent resides is the county of responsibility as defined in Section 1810.228 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)If a proceeding commences in a county where the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings that is different than the county in which the respondent resides, the county in which the respondent is found or is facing criminal or civil proceedings shall not delay proceedings under this part and is the responsible county behavioral health agency for providing or coordinating all components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan.
(3)The county in which the respondent resides, as defined in paragraph (1), shall be responsible for the costs of providing all CARE agreement or CARE plan behavioral health services, as defined in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a).
(4)In the event of a dispute over responsibility for any costs of providing components of the CARE agreement or CARE plan, the impacted counties shall resolve the dispute in accordance with the arbitration process established in Section 1850.405 of Title 9 of the California Code of Regulations for county mental health plans, including for respondents who are not Medi-Cal beneficiaries, and pursuant to any related guidance issued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
SEC. 11.Section 5985 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:5985.(a)The department shall develop, in consultation with county behavioral health agencies, other relevant state or local government entities, disability rights groups, individuals with lived experience, families, counsel, racial justice experts, and other appropriate stakeholders, an annual CARE Act report. The department shall post the annual report on its internet website.
(b)County behavioral health agencies and any other state or local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide data related to the CARE Act participants, services, and supports to the department. The department shall determine the data measures and specifications, and shall publish them via guidance issues pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 5984.
(c)Each county behavioral health department and any other state and local governmental entity, as identified by the department, shall provide the required data to the department, in a format and frequency as directed by the department.
(d)(1)In consultation with the Judicial Council, the department shall develop an annual reporting schedule for the submission of CARE Act data from the trial courts.
(2)Data from the trial courts shall be submitted to the Judicial Council, which shall aggregate the data and submit it to the department consistent with the reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)On an annual basis to be determined by the Judicial Council and consistent with the annual reporting schedule developed pursuant to paragraph (1), the trial courts shall report to the Judicial Council the following data related to CARE Act petitions:
(A)The number of petitions submitted pursuant to Section 5975.
(B)The number of initial appearances on the petition set pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 5977.
(C)The total number of hearings held pursuant to this part.
(e)The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation. The report shall include, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1)The demographics of participants, including, but not limited to, the age, sex, race, ethnicity, disability, languages spoken, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage status, including Medi-Cal enrollment status, and county of residence, to the extent statistically relevant data is available.
(2)The services and supports ordered, the services and supports provided, and the services and supports ordered but not provided.
(3)The housing placements of all participants during the program and at least one year following the termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter. Placements include, but are not limited to, transition to a higher level of care, independent living in the persons own house or apartment, community-based housing, community-based housing with services, shelter, and no housing.
(4)Treatments continued and terminated at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available.
(5)Substance use disorder rates and rates of treatment among active CARE plan participants and former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(6)Detentions and other Lanterman-Petris-Short Act involvement for participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(7)Criminal justice involvement of participants with an active CARE plan and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, to the extent administrative data are available to report the latter.
(8)Deaths among active participants and for former participants at least one year following termination of the CARE plan, along with causes of death, to the extent administrative data are available.
(9)The number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings.
(10)The number, rates, and trends of supporters.
(11)The number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements.
(12)The number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans.
(13)Statistics on the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications.
(14)The rates of adherence to medication.
(15)The number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives created for participants with active CARE plans.
(16)The number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans.
(17)Outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing, reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations, reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration, reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship, and reductions in substance use.
(18)A health equity assessment of the CARE Act to identify demographic disparities based on demographic data in paragraph (1), and to inform disparity reduction efforts.
(19)Data regarding referrals made pursuant to Section 5978.1, as part of the CARE Act.
(f)(1)The report shall include, at a minimum, information on the effectiveness of the CARE Act model in improving outcomes and reducing disparities, homelessness, criminal justice involvement, conservatorships, and hospitalization of participants. The annual report shall include process measures to examine the scope of impact and monitor the performance of CARE Act model implementation, such as the number and source of petitions filed for CARE Court; the number, rates, and trends of petitions resulting in dismissal and hearings; the number, rates, and trends of supporters; the number, rates, and trends of voluntary CARE agreements; the number, rates, and trends of ordered and completed CARE plans; the services and supports included in CARE plans, including court orders for stabilizing medications; the rates of adherence to medication; the number, rates, and trends of psychiatric advance directives; and the number, rates, and trends of developed graduation plans. The report shall include outcome measures to assess the effectiveness of the CARE Act model, such as improvement in housing status, including gaining and maintaining housing; reductions in emergency department visits and inpatient hospitalizations; reductions in law enforcement encounters and incarceration; reductions in involuntary treatment and conservatorship; and reductions in substance use. The annual report shall examine these data through the lens of health equity to identify racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities and inform disparity reduction efforts.
(2)Data shall be stratified by age, sex, race, ethnicity, languages spoken, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, housing status, veteran status, immigration status, health coverage source, and county, to the extent statistically relevant data is available. Information released or published pursuant to this section shall not contain data that may lead to the identification of respondents or information that would otherwise allow an individual to link the published information to a specific person. Data published by the department shall be deidentified in compliance with Section 164.514(a) and (b) of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(g)The outcomes shall be presented to relevant state oversight bodies, including, but not limited to, the California Interagency Council on Homelessness.
SEC. 12.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 13.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
To protect the health and safety of the states most vulnerable individuals by providing additional housing and treatment services within this state, and to avoid a waste of resources, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case without prejudice subject to consideration of Section 5975.1.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, and file a written report with the court within 14 court days and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the 14-day report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines that the county agencys report does not support the petitions prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines that the county agencys report does support the petitions prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)Unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed. If including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance or dismissal. continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify whether the dismissal was granted pursuant to a reason specified in Section 5977.1, 5977.3, or 5979. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondents consent.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case without prejudice subject to consideration of Section 5975.1.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, and file a written report with the court within 14 court days and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the 14-day report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines that the county agencys report does not support the petitions prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines that the county agencys report does support the petitions prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)The Unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
(a)(1)The court shall promptly review the petition to determine if the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972.
(2)If the court finds that the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court may dismiss the case without prejudice subject to consideration of Section 5975.1.
(3)If the court finds that the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall do one of the following:
(A)If the petitioner is the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall do the following:
(i)Set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code, to represent the respondent. If no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity shall be appointed to represent the respondent.
(iii)Determine whether the petition includes all of the following information and, if it does not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report with the court within 14 court days that includes all of the following:
(I)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(II)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent prior to the filing of the petition.
(III)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)Order the county behavioral health agency to provide notice to the respondent, the appointed counsel, and the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, if different from the county where the CARE process has commenced.
(B)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall order a county agency, or their designee, as determined by the court, to investigate, as necessary, and file a written report with the court within 14 court days and provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that a report has been ordered. The written report shall include all of the following:
(i)A determination as to whether the respondent meets, or is likely to meet, the criteria for the CARE process.
(ii)The outcome of efforts made to voluntarily engage the respondent during the 14-day report period.
(iii)Conclusions and recommendations about the respondents ability to voluntarily engage in services.
(iv)The information, including protected health information, necessary to support the determinations, conclusions, and recommendations in the report.
(4)If, upon a request by the county agency ordered to investigate and file a report under subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court finds that the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, the court may, in its discretion, grant the county agency no more than 30 additional days to continue to work with, engage, and enroll the individual in voluntary treatment and services. The county agency shall provide notice to the respondent and petitioner that an extension for filing a report has been granted.
(5)Upon receipt of the report described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3), the court shall, within five days, take one of the following actions:
(A)If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, and that the individual has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, the court shall dismiss the matter.
(B)If the court determines that the county agencys report does not support the petitions prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the matter. This section shall not prevent a county behavioral health agency from continuing to voluntarily engage with a person not described in Section 5972 but who is in need of services and supports.
(C)If the court determines that the county agencys report does support the petitions prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, a person described in Section 5972, and engagement with the county agency was not effective, the court shall do all of the following:
(i)Set an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days.
(ii)Appoint a qualified legal services project, as defined in Sections 6213 to 6214.5, inclusive, of the Business and Professions Code or, if no legal services project has agreed to accept these appointments, a public defender or other counsel working in that capacity to represent the respondent.
(iii)Order the county agency to provide notice of the initial appearance to the petitioner, the respondent, the appointed counsel, the county behavioral health agency in the county where the respondent resides, and, if different, the county where the CARE court proceedings have commenced.
(b)At the initial appearance on the petition, all of the following shall apply:
(1)The court shall permit the respondent to substitute their own counsel.
(2)Petitioner shall be present. If the petitioner is not present, the matter may be dismissed.
(3)Respondent may waive personal appearance and appear through counsel. If the respondent does not waive personal appearance and does not appear at the hearing, and the court makes a finding in open court that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondents absence if the court makes a finding in open court that conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondents best interest.
(4)A representative from the county behavioral health agency shall be present.
(5)If the respondent asserts that they are enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe or are receiving services from an Indian health care provider, a tribal court, or a tribal organization, a representative from the program, the tribe, or the tribal court shall be allowed to be present, subject to the consent of the respondent. The tribal representative shall be entitled to notice by the county of the initial appearance.
(6)(A)If the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency, or their designee, the court shall issue an order relieving the original petitioner and appointing the director of the county behavioral health agency or their designee as the successor petitioner.
(B)If the original petitioner is described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, all of the following apply:
(i)The original petitioner shall have the right to be present and make a statement at the initial hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(ii)The court may, in its discretion, assign ongoing rights of notice to the original petitioner. shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal.
(iii)To the extent that the respondent consents, the court may allow the original petitioner to participate in the respondents CARE proceedings.
(iv)The original petitioner may file a new petition with the court, pursuant to Section 5974, if the matter is dismissed and there is a change in circumstances.
(C)If the original petitioner is not described in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 5974, the court shall not assign ongoing rights to the original petitioner, other than the right to be present and make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition held pursuant to paragraph (7).
(7)(A)The court shall set a hearing on the merits of the petition within 10 days, at which time the court shall determine whether, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972. In making this determination, the court shall consider all evidence properly before it, including any report from the county behavioral health agency ordered pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) and any additional admissible evidence presented by the parties, including the petition submitted and any statement given by the original petitioner.
(B)The hearing on the merits of the petition may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance upon stipulation of the successor petitioner and the respondent, subject to the approval by the court.
(c)(1)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds there is not clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, in open court, that the original petitioners filing was not in good faith, in which case the dismissal shall be with prejudice.
(2)If, at the hearing on the merits of the petition, the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria in Section 5972, the court shall order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondents counsel, and the supporter to engage the respondent in behavioral health treatment and attempt to enter into a CARE agreement. The court shall set a case management hearing within 14 days.
(3)If the respondent is enrolled in a federally recognized Indian tribe, the respondent shall provide notice of the case management hearing to the tribe, subject to the consent of the respondent.
(d)The following shall apply to any written report submitted by a county behavioral health agency to the court pursuant to this section:
(1)The report is confidential and not subject to disclosure or inspection under the California Public Records Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(2)The report is inadmissible in any subsequent legal proceeding, except upon motion of the respondent in that subsequent legal proceeding.
(3)The report shall be confidential pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 5976.5.
(4)This subdivision shall not affect the applicability of paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 5977.1, make admissible any evidence that is not otherwise admissible, or permit a witness to base an opinion on any matter that is not a proper basis for such an opinion. The admission or exclusion of evidence shall be pursuant to the rules of evidence established by the Evidence Code, including, but not limited to, Section 352 of the Evidence Code, and by judicial decision.
SECTION 1.Section 6090.8 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6090.8.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, shall inform the State Bar.(2)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, shall inform the State Bar.(3)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.(a)(1)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, ability to perform legal services with competence, shall inform the State Bar.
(2)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, shall inform the State Bar.
(3)For the purpose of this subdivision, knows means actual knowledge of the fact in question. A licensees knowledge may be inferred from circumstances.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
(c)A licensee of the State Bar who makes a complaint to the State Bar pursuant to subdivision (a) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law shall be deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
(d)The board may amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and shall propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, to implement this section.
(a)A licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensees honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, shall inform the State Bar.
(b)This section does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 27, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 640, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 27, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2024 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 5767.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 31, 2024 | Urgency clause adopted. |
| Aug 30, 2024 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 29, 2024 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 6894.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (August 15). |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 25, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 25, 2024 | June 25 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 11, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 20, 2023 | June 20 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 9, 2023 | June 13 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 26, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 15, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 15, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 1076.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 4, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 3, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 10. Noes 0. Page 1011.) (May 2). |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 2. |
| Jan 18, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Dec 6, 2022 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 5. |
| Dec 5, 2022 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2024 | Unfinished Business SB42 Umberg Urgency Clause Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 29, 2024 | SB 42 Umberg Third Reading Urgency By Gipson | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB42 Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| California Dispute Resolution Council | ** Against | |
| California Lawyers Association | ** Against | |
| California Professional Firefighters | ** Support | |
| California Youth Empowerment Network | ** Against | |
| Cal Voices | ** Against | |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Against | |
| Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Mental Health America of California | ** Against | |
| Peace Officers Research Association Of California | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 42 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 42
Author: Umberg (D)
Amended: 8/22/24
Vote: 27 - Urgency
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 8/29/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Court Program: process and proceedings
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill makes various changes to the Community, Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, which has been implemented in at least eight counties and will be implemented by the remaining counties on or before December 1, 2024.
Assembly Amendments
gutted and amended the bill as passed by the Senate.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the CARE Act. (Welf. & Inst. Code, div. 5, pt. 8, §§ 5970 et seq.)
- Provides that the CARE Act shall be implemented by a first cohort of counties, including Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, Stanislaus, Tuolumne, and the City and County of San Francisco, no later than October 1, 2023; and by a second cohort of counties, representing the remaining counties in the state, no later than December 1, 2024. The Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) may grant a county additional time in which to implement the CARE Act, up to December 1, 2025. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5970.5.)
- Establishes criteria for a person to qualify for the CARE process, including that the person is 18 years of age or older; the person is experiencing a serious mental disorder, as defined, and has a diagnosis in the disorder class of schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders; the person is not clinically stabilized in ongoing voluntary treatment; and participation in a CARE plan or agreement would be the least restrictive alternative necessary to ensure the person’s recovery and stability. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5972.)
- Establishes the CARE process, which includes:
- The filing of a petition by a qualified person or entity. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5974.)
- Requiring a CBHA to investigate the case and file a report with the court if the petition makes a prima facie case of the respondent’s eligibility. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5977(a)(3).)
- Requiring, if the court determines that the respondent meets the CARE Act criteria, the court to order the CBHA and respondent to work out a CARE agreement. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 5977, 5977.1.)
- Requiring, if the parties reach a CARE agreement, the court to order the implementation of the agreement; if the parties do not reach an agreement, then both parties may propose a CARE plan and the court may order that one of the proposed plans, as proposed or as modified, be entered. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.1)
- Establishes the components of a CARE plan, which may include specified social services and housing assistance, and lasts for one year. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 5977.1, 5982(a).)
- Requires the court to hold a status review hearing during the duration of the CARE plan at least every 60 days, with the parties submitting information prior to the hearing as provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.2.)
- Requires the court, in the 11th month of the CARE plan, to hold a one-year status hearing, which is an evidentiary hearing, to determine if the respondent graduates from the CARE plan or should be reappointed for another year; a respondent may be reappointed to the care process only once, for up to one additional year. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.3.)
- Establishes certain protections for the CARE process, including:
- The rights retained by a respondent, including the right to receive notice of the hearings and the court-ordered evaluation; the right to be represented by counsel at all stages of a CARE proceeding, regardless of ability to pay; the right to present evidence and call witnesses; and the right to an interpreter in all proceedings if necessary for the respondent to fully participate. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5976.)
- Hearings that are presumptively closed to the public, as specified, and the requirement that a court inform the respondent of their rights at a CARE hearing. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5976.5.)
- Allows the court, at any point during CARE proceedings, if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent, after receiving notice, is not participating in the CARE process or is not adhering to their CARE plan, to terminate respondent’s participation. The court is then permitted to make a referral under the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act, as provided, and the LPS Act court may take the respondent’s failure to complete the CARE plan if an LPS Act case is brought within six months. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5979.)
- Provides for sanctions against a person who wrongfully files a CARE Act petition that is without merit or is intended to harass or gain an advantage over the respondent in another legal proceeding. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5975.1.)
- Allows a court, if a criminal defendant is found to be mentally incompetent and ineligible for a diversion, to refer the defendant to the CARE program, as provided. (Pen. Code, § 1370.1(b)(1)(D)(iv).)
- Permits a court to refer an individual from assisted outpatient treatment (AOT), LPS Act conservatorship, or misdemeanor proceedings to CARE Act proceedings; the CBHA shall be designated as the petitioner in such a referral. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5978.)
- Requires DHCS to collect data relating to the CARE Act implementation from CBHAs and other entities, and to coordinate with the Judicial Council to develop an annual reporting schedule for the submission of CARE Act data from the trial courts on an annual basis; and requires an independent evaluation of the effective ness of the CARE Act to be provided five years after its implementation. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5985, 5986.)
This bill:
- Requires an affidavit submitted by a professional person in support of the establishment of a temporary conservatorship under the LPS Act, or by a conservator in support of the reappointment of a conservatorship under the LPS Act, to include an attestation that all available alternatives to the conservatorship have been considered, including AOT and CARE Act proceedings, and that the appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternative is available.
- Clarifies that, in connection with a CARE Act petition, evidence that a respondent has met the minimum intensive treatment requirement may include, but is not limited to, documentary evidence from the facility in which the facility was detained or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner has personal knowledge of the detentions.
- Provides that, in a CARE Act proceeding, a court must inform a respondent of their rights at the first hearing at which the respondent makes an appearance, and that the court need not inform the respondent of their rights at subsequent hearings if the court finds that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement of rights.
- Clarifies that, if the court finds that a CARE Act petition fails to make a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, eligible for CARE Act proceedings, the court may dismiss the case and that the dismissal shall be without prejudice unless the court finds that the petition was filed for an improper purpose, as specified.
- Extends the time in which a county agency must investigate the circumstances surrounding a petition filed by a person other than the county behavioral health agency and file a report with the court, from 14 court days to as soon as practicable but within 30 court days; and requires the parties to complete the investigation with appropriate urgency.
- Provides that, beginning July 1, 2025, unless a court determines, on its own motion or on the motion of a respondent, that it would likely be detrimental to the treatment or wellbeing of the respondent, that the court shall provide ongoing notice of CARE Act proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE Act proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed and certain information about the reason for the continuance or dismissal; however, the notice shall not provide any patient information protected by specified state or federal laws unless the respondent consents.
- Provides that, at a hearing on the merits of a CARE Act petition, a licensed behavioral health professional may testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the CARE Act criteria, provided that the court finds that the professional qualifies as an expert under Evidence Code section 720.
- Clarifies that the parties may agree to, and the court may approve, amendments to a CARE agreement; and that a court may, after a hearing, approve amendments to a CARE plan upon the finding that the amendments are necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports.
- Requires a court and all relevant local public agencies to cooperate to develop a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve performance of the CARE system in a vigorous and ongoing manner, and authorizes the court to coordinate and participate in meetings to improve systems performance.
- Clarifies the scope of rules which the Judicial Council may adopt to implement the CARE Act.
- Permits a facility, as defined, to refer an individual being involuntarily treated under the LPS Act to a county behavioral health agency if they believe the individual meets or is likely to meet the criteria for the CARE process, as specified.
- Provides that, if a CARE Act petition has been filed pursuant to a referral from an AOT court, LPS Act conservatorship proceeding, misdemeanor proceeding, or for a respondent within a juvenile court’s dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction, the CARE Act court and the referring or juvenile court may communicate with each other regarding the status of the respondent’s cases and any relevant court orders while both cases are pending.
- The courts may allow the parties to participate in the communication; all communications about the disposition of a respondent’s case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
- Communication between courts regarding schedules, calendars, court records, and similar matters may be conducted without informing the parties and off the record; a record must be made of all other communications between the courts, and the parties must be promptly notified of the communications and given access to the record.
- Permits a CARE plan to include, with the consent or the respondent and the entity or facility responsible for the services, additional services not otherwise specified in statute to support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
- Requires DHCS to include, in its annual report to the Legislature regarding the implementation of the CARE Act, data regarding inter-court referrals made pursuant to 12).
- Includes an urgency clause.
Comments
In 2022, the Legislature enacted, and the Governor signed, SB 1338 (Umberg, Ch. 319, Stats. 2022), known as the CARE Act, which is intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder services for persons with certain severe mental illness diagnoses as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility or to being subjected to a conservatorship under the LPS Act. The CARE Act provides for CARE agreements and court-ordered CARE plans for qualified persons suffering from a mental health or substance abuse disorder crisis for up to 12 months, with the potential for an extension. CARE agreements and plans are supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services.
A first cohort of seven counties implemented the CARE Act on October 1, 2023, and the County of Los Angeles elected to implement the CARE Act in December 2023. The remaining counties must implement the CARE Act by December 1, 2024.
This bill amends the CARE Act and addresses concerns raised by some stakeholders in advance of the statewide implementation date. Among other things, the bill clarifies what evidence may establish a respondent’s eligibility for CARE proceedings; reduces a CARE court’s obligation to inform the respondent of their rights; requires a CARE petition’s dismissal to be without prejudice unless specific criteria are met; and gives original petitioners the right to notice of ongoing CARE proceedings unless the court specifically finds that notice would be detrimental to the respondent.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill presents:
Costs (Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount to the courts to send the required notices. Judicial Council projects an “unknown, potentially significant impact” to the judicial branch to comply with this bill’s requirements. As Judicial Council notes, only a few CARE courts are currently operational, but costs associated with administering the CARE courts, including providing the notices required by this bill, may grow as more courts begin operating and more CARE petitions are filed in coming years. Judicial Council reports that costs are likely absorbable if the courts have the petitioner contact information needed to provide notice to qualifying petitioners electronically, rather than via mail service.
The fiscal year 2024-25 budget provides $47.4 million to the courts to implement the CARE courts.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/30/24)
California Professional Firefighters
Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/24)
ACLU California Action
Cal Voices
California Youth Empowerment Network
Disability Rights California
Mental Health America of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to California Professional Firefighters:
CARE Court as established by SB 1338 (Umberg, 2022) presents an important new method for providing behavioral health treatment to the Californians who most need it but are least able to access services. Once enrolled in a CARE plan, an individual is connected with much-needed services such as behavioral health care, medication, and supportive housing services in order to assist them with recovery and achieving stability. These services are intended for those with severe schizophrenia spectrum and psychotic disorders who are unable to care for themselves or make the complex decisions needed to direct their own care.
Oftentimes, the individual petitioners who began the process of having someone enrolled in CARE Court are a close friend or family member with close relationships with that person. That relationship, along with the fact that the petitioner has a legal tie to the individual in CARE, means that it is important for them to be aware of every step of the Court process and understand when a continuance is ordered or a case is dismissed. SB 42 provides clarity regarding when and to whom notifications are issued on those steps in the process, and ensures transparency and full understanding for all involved.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to a coalition of the bill’s opponents: Disability Rights California (DRC), Mental Health America of California (MHAC), Cal Voices, ACLU California Action (ACLU) and the California Youth Empowerment Network (CAYEN) regretfully oppose SB 42 because it makes numerous changes to CARE Court that water down due process, reinforce coercive aspects of the program and threaten to harm the very people CARE Court is supposed to help. In addition, this bill was unnecessarily rushed through the Legislature with no opportunity for meaningful feedback…
We have not yet fully analyzed this measure, but our objections include the following:
- The bill provides ongoing notice rights to nonparties, even when the respondent objects. We support a family member’s involvement if the respondent consents. Forcing continued involvement of family members on respondents violates their privacy and is not conducive to recovery.
- CARE Court requires a petition to include evidence of a person’s prior mental health history. SB 42 permits evidence of prior hospitalizations to consist of a petitioner’s declaration from personal knowledge, with no regard for the meaning of personal knowledge in the Evidence Code, and in case law.
- SB 42 eliminates, after the first hearing, the requirement that a court advise the respondent of their rights, if the court finds the respondent understands and waives additional advisement. This provision applies even when the respondent is not assisted by counsel.
- This bill permits a facility to refer a detained individual to CARE Court and allows a county 14 business days to evaluate the individual. This clearly incentivizes referring physicians to hold the person involuntarily in a hospital in order for the county to be able to find and assess this individual. Persons may not be held involuntarily in a mental hospital unless they meet criteria set out in the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act and also in the United States Supreme Court decision in O’Connor v. Donaldson. Nothing in the bill protects involuntary patients from being detained illegally.
- SB 42 permits courts to communicate about a respondent’s case when there are proceedings in more than one court, e.g., Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT) and CARE Court simultaneously. Respondents should not be subject to multiple and duplicative civil commitment proceedings at one time. Communication between courts regarding multiple and duplicative proceedings seems calculated to ensure unfairness in the process.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 8/29/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bryan, Cervantes, Ortega, Zbur
Prepared by: Allison Whitt Meredith / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/30/24 17:27:03
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 42 (Author:Umberg)
Version: August 22, 2024
Hearing Date: August 30, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: Yes
Consultant: AWM
PURSUANT TO SENATE RULE 29.10(d)
SUBJECT
Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Court Program: process and proceedings
DIGEST
This bill makes various changes to the Community, Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act, which has been implemented in at least eight counties and will be implemented by the remaining counties on or before December 1, 2024.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In 2022, the Legislature enacted, and the Governor signed, SB 1338 (Umberg, Ch. 319, Stats. 2022), known as the CARE Act, which is intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder services for persons with certain severe mental illness diagnoses as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility or to being subjected to a conservatorship under the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act (Welf. & Inst. Code, div. 5, pt. 1, §§ 5000 et seq.). The CARE Act provides for CARE agreements and court-ordered CARE plans for qualified persons suffering from a mental health or substance abuse disorder crisis for up to 12 months, with the potential for an extension. CARE agreements and plans are supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services.
A first cohort of seven counties implemented the CARE Act on October 1, 2023, and the County of Los Angeles elected to implement the CARE Act in December 2023. The remaining counties must implement the CARE Act by December 1, 2024.
This bill amends the CARE Act and addresses concerns raised by some stakeholders in advance of the statewide implementation date. Among other things, the bill clarifies what evidence may establish a respondent’s eligibility for CARE proceedings; reduces a CARE court’s obligation to inform the respondent of their rights; requires a CARE petition’s dismissal to be without prejudice unless specific criteria are met; and gives original petitioners the right to notice of ongoing CARE proceedings unless the court specifically finds that notice would be detrimental to the respondent. This bill was gutted and amended into its current form in the Assembly, so this Committee has not yet heard the provisions in this bill. Accordingly, this bill was referred to this Committee pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d) when it returned to the Senate.
This bill is sponsored by the author and is supported by California Professional Firefighters and Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill. This bill is opposed by ACLU California Action, Cal Voices, the California Youth Empowerment Network, Disability Rights California, and Mental Health America of California.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the LPS Act, which provides for the involuntary detention for treatment and evaluation of people who are gravely disabled, as defined, or a danger to self or others. (Welf. & Inst. Code, div. 5, pt. 1, §§ 5000 et seq.)
- Establishes the Assisted Outpatient Treatment Demonstration Project of 2002, which provides for court-ordered assisted outpatient treatment (AOT) under specified circumstances. (Welf. & Inst. Code, div. 5, pt. 1, ch. 2, art. 9.)
- Establishes the CARE Act. (Welf. & Inst. Code, div. 5, pt. 8, §§ 5970 et seq.)
- Defines the following relevant terms:
- “Care agreement” is a voluntary settlement agreement entered into by the parties, and includes the same elements as a CARE plan to support the respondent in accessing community-based services and supports.
- “Care plan” is an individualized, appropriate range of community-based services and supports, which include clinically appropriate behavioral health care and stabilization medications, housing, and other supportive services, as appropriate.
- “CARE process” is the court and related proceedings to implement the CARE Act.
- “Court-ordered evaluation” means an evaluation ordered by the court in connection with a CARE Act petition, as specified.
- “Department” is the State Department of Health Care Services (DHCS).
- “Petitioner” is the entity who files a CARE Act petition with the court; if the petitioner is a person other than the director of a county behavioral health agency (CBHA), or their designee, the court shall substitute the director or their designee for the county in which the proceedings are filed as the petitioner at the first hearing.
- “Respondent” is the person who is subject to the petition for the CARE process. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5971.)
- Provides that the CARE Act shall be implemented as follows:
- A first cohort of counties, including Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, Stanislaus, Tuolumne, and the City and County of San Francisco, shall begin no later than October 1, 2023.
- A second cohort of counties, representing the remaining counties in the state, shall begin no later than December 1, 2024.
- DHCS shall issue guidelines under which counties can apply for, and be provided, additional time in which to implement the CARE Act, subject to certain conditions and restrictions; DHCS may grant only one extension per county, and the latest a county may implement the CARE Act is December 1, 2025. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5970.5.)
- Establishes criteria for a person to qualify for the CARE process, including that the person is 18 years of age or older; the person is experiencing a serious mental disorder, as defined, and has a diagnosis in the disorder class of schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders; the person is not clinically stabilized in ongoing voluntary treatment; and participation in a CARE plan or agreement would be the least restrictive alternative necessary to ensure the person’s recovery and stability. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5972.)
- Provides that the following adult persons may file a petition to commence the CARE process:
- A person with whom the respondent resides.
- A spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent of, or individual who stands in loco parentis to, the respondent.
- The director of a hospital in which the respondent is hospitalized, including pursuant to certain temporary holds under the LPS Act, or their designee.
- The director of a public or charitable home, or a licensed behavioral health professional, or their designee, who has had a specified interaction with the respondent within the previous 30 days.
- A first responder, as specified, who has had repeated interactions with the respondent in the form of multiple arrests, multiple detentions and transportations pursuant to the LPS Act, multiple attempts to engage the respondent in the form of voluntary treatment, or other repeated efforts to aid the respondent in obtaining professional assistance.
- The public guardian or public conservator, or their designee, of the county in which the respondent resides or is found.
- The director of a CBHA or county adult protective services, or their designee, of the county in which the respondent resides or is found.
- The director of a California Indian health services program, California tribal behavioral health department, or their designee, who has, within the previous 30 days, provided or is providing behavioral health services to the respondent.
- The judge of a tribal court that is located in California, or their designee, who has, within the previous 30 days, provided or is providing behavioral health services to the respondent.
- The respondent. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5974.)
- Allows a court, if a criminal defendant is found to be mentally incompetent and ineligible for a diversion, to refer the defendant to the CARE program, as provided. (Pen. Code, § 1370.1(b)(1)(D)(iv).)
- Requires the Judicial Council to create a mandatory court form to file a CARE process petition, together with any other forms necessary during the CARE process. The petition must be signed under penalty of perjury and set forth specified information, including either an affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional setting forth specified information about the respondent, or evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to the LPS Act, the most recent of which was no more than 60 days prior to the date of the petition. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5975.)
- Provides for sanctions for a person who wrongfully files a CARE Act petition, as follows:
- If a person other than the respondent files a petition for CARE Act proceedings that is without merit or is intended to harass or annoy the respondent, and the person has previously filed such a CARE Act pleading, the petition shall be grounds for the court to determine that the person is a vexatious litigant, as provided.
- If a person other than the respondent files a petition for CARE Act proceedings in order to gain advantage over the respondent in another legal proceeding, it is cause for suspension, disbarment, or other discipline if a member of the State Bar is found to have filed the petition or assisted in the filing with the knowledge that the filing was made in order to gain that advantage. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5975.1.)
- Establishes the rights of the respondent, including the right to receive notice of the hearings and the court-ordered evaluation; the right to be represented by counsel at all stages of a CARE proceeding, regardless of ability to pay; the right to present evidence and call witnesses; and the right to an interpreter in all proceedings if necessary for the respondent to fully participate. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5976.)
- Establishes the following with respect to CARE Act hearings:
- Hearings are presumptively closed to the public, but the respondent may demand that the hearings be public.
- The respondent may request the presence of a family member or friend without waiving the right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public.
- The court may grant a request by another party to make a hearing public if the judge conducting the hearing finds that the public interest clearly outweighs the respondent’s interest in privacy.
- All reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information related to the respondent’s health are confidential, and the respondent may petition the court for an order sealing those records.
- The fact that evidence is admitted under a CARE Act proceeding is not the basis for the admission of that evidence in any subsequent legal proceeding, and records of the proceeding shall not be admitted in a subsequent legal proceeding except by a motion by the respondent or by the county behavioral health agency, public guardian, or public conservator.
- The judicial officer, before commencing a hearing, must inform the respondent of their rights under this section. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5976.5.)
- Requires the court, upon receipt of a CARE Act petition, to promptly review it to determine whether a prima facie showing has been made that the respondent is or may be a person described in 6), and then do one of the following:
- If the court finds the petitioner has not made the required prima facie showing, then dismiss the case without prejudice. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5977(a)(2).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has made the required prima facie showing, and the petitioner is the director of a CBHA, then the court must do all of the following:
- Set the matter for initial hearing within 14 court days.
- Appoint counsel.
- Determine if the petition includes a determination as to whether the respondent meets the criteria for the CARE process and is willing to engage voluntarily with services, and, if not, order the county behavioral health agency to submit a written report containing specified information within 14 court days.
- Require the CBHA to provide notice to the respondent, respondent’s counsel, and the CBHA where the respondent resides. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5977(a)(3)(A).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has made the required prima facie showing, but the petitioner is not a CBHA, then the court must do all of the following:
- Order a county agency to investigate whether the respondent meets the criteria for the CARE process and is willing to engage voluntarily with services; the CBHA must a written report with the court within 14 court days.
- Provide notice to the respondent and the petitioner that a report has been ordered.
- Upon receipt of the report, within 5 days, do one of the following:
- If the county’s report does not support a prima facie showing under 6), or if the county determines that the respondent has enrolled or is likely to enroll in voluntary behavioral health treatment, dismiss the matter.
- If the county’s report does support a prima facie showing under 6), set the matter for initial hearing within 14 court days, appoint counsel, and order the county to provide notice of the hearing as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5977(a)(3)(B).)
- Provides that, if a CBHA is making progress with a respondent named in a petition, the CBHA may request up to 30 additional days to continue to engage and enroll the respondent in treatment and services. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977(a)(4).)
- Requires a court, within five days of receipt of a report from the CBHA pursuant to 13), to review the report and do one of the following:
- To dismiss the matter, if the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, as provided.
- If the court determines that the county's report supports the petition's prima facie showing that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, and engagement is not effective, to:
- Set an initial hearing within 14 days;
- Appoint counsel, unless the respondent has their own counsel; and
- Provide notice of the hearing, as provided.
- If the court determines that the county's report does not support the petition's prima facie showing that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, to dismiss the matter. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977(a)(5).)
- Provides the following with respect to initial CARE Act hearing:
- If the petitioner is not present, the court may dismiss the matter.
- If the respondent elects not to waive their appearance and is not present, the court may conduct the hearing in the respondent's absence if the court makes a finding on the record that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, and conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondent's best interest.
- A CBHA representative must be present, a supporter may be appointed, and a tribal representative may attend for a respondent who is a tribal member, as provided, and subject to the respondent's consent.
- If the court finds that there is no reason to believe that the facts stated in the petition are true, the court must dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding on the record that the petitioner's filing was not in good faith.
- If the court finds that there is reason to believe that the facts stated in the petition appear to be true, the court must order the CBHA to work with the respondent, respondent’s counsel, and respondent’s CARE supporter to engage in behavioral health treatment; the court must to set a case management hearing within 14 days.
- If the petitioner is other than the county behavioral health director, the court must substitute the county behavioral health director or their designee for the petitioner, as specified.
- If the court does not dismiss the petition, the court must set a hearing on the merits of the petition, which may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance on the petition upon stipulation of the petitioner and respondent and agreement by the court. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977(b).)
- Provides the following with respect to a CARE Act hearing on the merits:
- If the court finds that the petitioner has not shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court must dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, on the record, that the petitioner's filing was not in good faith.
- If the court finds that the petitioner has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court must order the CBHA to work with the respondent, respondent's counsel, and the supporter to engage in behavioral health treatment and determine if the parties will be able to enter into a CARE agreement; in this case, the court must set a case management hearing, and notice of must be provided to the respondent’s tribe, as applicable. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977(c).)
- Provides the following with respect to a CARE Act case management hearing:
- If the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, a CARE agreement, the court must approve, or modify and approve, the CARE agreement, stay the matter, and set a progress hearing for 60 days; the court may continue the matter for 14 days to allow the parties additional time to enter into a CARE agreement.
- If the court finds that the parties have not entered, and are not likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, the court must order a clinical evaluation of the respondent, as provided; the evaluation must address, at a minimum, a clinical diagnosis, whether the respondent has capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication, other information, as provided, and an analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the respondent's recovery and stability.
- If the court orders an evaluation, it must also set a clinical evaluation review hearing to review the evaluation within 21 days, and the county must file the evaluation with the court and provide the evaluation to respondent’s counsel no later than 5 days prior to the hearing. This hearing may be continued for a maximum of 14 days upon stipulation of the respondent and CBHA, unless there is good cause for a longer extension. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.1)
- Provides the following with respect to a CARE Act clinical evaluation review hearing:
- The court must consider the evaluation, and other evidence, including calling witnesses; but only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
- If the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, after review of the evaluation and other evidence, that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court must order the CBHA, the respondent, and the respondent's counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan.
- If the court finds, in reviewing the evaluation, that clear and convincing evidence does not support that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, the court must dismiss the petition. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.1(c).)
- Provides the following with respect to a hearing to review a proposed CARE plan:
- Either or both parties may present a CARE plan.
- The court must adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent, and may issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding, as provided. These orders are the CARE plan.
- A court may to order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent that the court orders medically necessary stabilization medications, prohibits the medication from being forcibly administered and the respondent's failure to comply with a medication order may not result in a penalty, including but not limited to contempt or the accountability measures in 26)-28).
- If the court determines that additional information is needed, the court must order a supplemental report to be filed by the CBHA, which must be filed within 14 days unless there is good cause for a longer extension.
- If there is no CARE plan because the parties have not had time to complete it, the court may grant a continuance of up to 14 days unless there is good cause to grant a longer extension. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.1(d).)
- Provides that an issuance of an order adopted by the court adopting a CARE plan begins the one-year CARE program timeline. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.1(e).)
- Requires the court to hold a status review hearing during the duration of the CARE plan at least every 60 days, with the parties submitting information prior to the hearing as provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.2.)
- Requires the court, in the 11th month of the CARE plan, to hold a one-year status hearing, which is an evidentiary hearing, to determine if the respondent graduates from the CARE plan or should be reappointed for another year.
- The CBHA must file a report and provide it to the respondent, respondent’s counsel, and supporter no fewer than five days before the hearing; the report must address specified information, including the respondent’s progress in the CARE plan, their stability, what services were provided or not provided, and recommendations for the next steps.
- At the hearing, the respondent shall be provided the opportunity to respond to the report and present evidence, including witnesses.
- Following the hearing, the court must issue an order either graduating the respondent, if they elect to leave the program, and ordering the respondent and CBHA to work on a voluntary graduation plan; or permitting the respondent to remain in the program for up to an additional year, if the respondent elects to remain in the program and specified conditions are met.
- The court may involuntarily reappoint the respondent to the CARE program only if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent did not successfully complete the care process; that all services and supports required through the CARE process were provided; the respondent would benefit from the CARE process; and the respondent meets all the CARE Act criteria.
- A respondent may be reappointed to the care process only once, for up to one additional year. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.3.)
- Requires hearings to occur in person unless the court allows a party or a witness to appear remotely; the respondent has the right to be in-person for all hearings. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.4(b).)
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules to implement the CARE Act provisions. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5977.4(c).)
- Allows the court, at any point during CARE proceedings, if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent, after receiving notice, is not participating in the CARE process or is not adhering to their CARE plan, to terminate respondent’s participation. The court is then permitted to make a referral under the LPS Act, as provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5979(a).)
- Provides that, if a respondent was provided timely with all of the services and supports required by the CARE plan, the fact that the respondent failed to successfully complete their CARE plan, including the reasons for their failure:
- May be considered by a court in a subsequent hearing under the LPS Act, provided that hearing occurs within six months of termination of the CARE plan; and
- Creates a presumption at a hearing under the LPS Act that the respondent needs additional interventions beyond the supports and services provided by the CARE plan. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5979(a)(3).)
- Prohibits a respondent's failure to comply with any order from resulting in any penalty outside of 27), including, but not limited to contempt or failure to appear; and prohibits a respondent’s failure to comply with a medication order from resulting any penalty, including under 27). (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5979(a)(4), (5).)
- Creates a process for penalizing counties or other local government entities that do not comply with CARE court orders. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 5979(b).)
- Provides that either a respondent or a CBHA may appeal an adverse court determination. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5979(c).)
- Permits a court to refer an individual from AOT, LPS Act conservatorship, or misdemeanor proceedings to CARE Act proceedings; the CBHA shall be designated as the petitioner in such a referral. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5978.)
- Requires DHCA, in consultation with specified groups, to provide optional training and resources for supporters, and establishes requirements for CARE supporters, as specified. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 5980, 5981.)
- Establishes the components of a CARE plan, which may include only:
- Behavioral health services, funded through specified sources.
- Medically necessary stabilization medications.
- Housing resources, funded through specified state and federal sources.
- Social services funded through specified county, state, and federal sources. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5982(a).)
- Requires CARE participants to be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program; if the CBHA elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined, the court may review the reason for that election. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5982(b), (c).)
- Provides that all CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions and policy guidance governing program eligibility, as provided; and sets forth rules by which a county is responsible for the costs of providing services to CARE participants. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5982(d)-(f).)
- Requires the Health and Human Services Agency (CalHHS), DHCS, and the Judicial Council to engage in data-gathering, and to provide technical assistance and training for entities participating in the CARE process, as provided. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5983.)
- Requires DHCS to collect data relating to the CARE Act implementation from CBHAs and other entities, and to coordinate with the Judicial Council to develop an annual reporting schedule for the submission of CARE Act data from the trial courts on an annual basis. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5985.)
- Requires an independent, research-based entity retained by DHCS, in consultation with others, to develop an independent evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act; the independent evaluation must employ statistical research methodology and include a logic model, hypotheses, comparative or quasi-experimental analyses, and conclusions regarding the extent to which the CARE Act model is associated, correlated, and causally related with the performance of the outcome measures included in the annual reports, highlighting racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities, and including causal inference or descriptive analyses regarding the impact of the CARE Act on disparity reduction efforts. DHCS must also provide a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act to the Legislature three years after its implementation and a final report five years after implementation. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5986.)
- Provides immunity to a county, or an employee or agent of a county, for any action by a respondent in the CARE process, except when the act or omission of a county, or the employee or agent of a county, constitutes gross negligence, recklessness, or willful misconduct. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5987.)
This bill:
- Requires an affidavit submitted by a professional person in support of the establishment of a temporary conservatorship under the LPS Act to include an attestation that the professional person has considered all available alternatives to the conservatorship, including AOT and CARE Act proceedings, and that the appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternative is available.
- Requires a petition for the reappointment of a conservator under the LPS Act to include an attestation by the conservator stating that they have considered all available alternatives to conservatorship, including AOT and CARE Act proceedings, and that reappointment of a conservator is recommended because no suitable alternative is available.
- Clarifies that, in connection with a CARE Act petition, evidence that a respondent has met the minimum intensive treatment requirement may include, but is not limited to, documentary evidence from the facility in which the facility was detained or a signed declaration from the petitioner if the petitioner has personal knowledge of the detentions.
- Provides that, in a CARE Act proceeding, a court must inform a respondent of their rights at the first hearing at which the respondent makes an appearance, and that the court need not inform the respondent of their rights at subsequent hearings if the court finds that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement of rights.
- Clarifies that, if the court finds that a CARE Act petition fails to make a prima facie showing that the respondent is, or may be, eligible for CARE Act proceedings, the court may dismiss the case and that the dismissal shall be without prejudice unless the court finds that the petition was filed under circumstances addressed in Welfare and Institutions Code section 5975.1; and provides that nothing other than Welfare and Institutions Code section 5975.1 prevents a petitioner whose petition was dismissed without prejudice from refiling the petition with amended information.
- Extends the time in which a county agency must investigate the circumstances surrounding a petition filed by a person other than the county behavioral health agency and file a report with the court, from 14 court days to as soon as practicable but within 30 court days; and requires the parties to complete the investigation with appropriate urgency.
- Provides that, beginning July 1, 2025, unless a court determines, on its own motion or on the motion of a respondent, that it would likely be detrimental to the treatment or wellbeing of the respondent, that the court shall provide ongoing notice of CARE Act proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE Act proceedings, including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed.
- If a continuance is granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, i.e., the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds listed in California Rule of Court Rule 3.1332.
- If the case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal.
- The notice of continuance or dismissal shall not provide any patient information protected by specified state or federal laws unless the respondent consents.
- Provides that, at a hearing on the merits of a CARE Act petition, a licensed behavioral health professional may testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the criteria for CARE Act eligibility, provided that the court finds that the professional has special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education sufficient to qualify as an expert under Evidence Code section 720.
- Clarifies that the parties may agree to, and the court may approve, amendments to a CARE agreement; and that a court may, after a hearing, approve amendments to a CARE plan upon the finding that the amendments are necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports.
- Requires a court and all relevant local public agencies to cooperate to develop a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve performance of the CARE system in a vigorous and ongoing manner, and authorizes the court to coordinate and participate in meetings to improve systems performance.
- Clarifies the scope of rules which the Judicial Council may adopt to implement the CARE Act.
- Permits a facility, as defined, to refer an individual being involuntarily treated under the LPS Act to a county behavioral health agency if they believe the individual meets or is likely to meet the criteria for the CARE process.
- Such a referral must be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional employed by or contracted by the facility, who has knowledge of the individual’s case, and who has been involved in the individual’s treatment during their involuntary hold.
- The referral must be made as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individual’s discharge planning process, and the referral must include specified contact information for the referred individual.
- The county behavioral health agency must complete an assessment of the referred individual within 14 business days of the referral and file a CARE Act petition if it determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet the criteria for the CARE Act and does not engage in voluntary treatment.
- DHCS must develop a referral form to be used by a facility, issue guidance relating to the referral process, and include data relating to this referral process in its annual CARE Act report.
- This provision does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred person who no longer meets the criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete the referral assessment; and does not affect a facility’s ability to make an AOT referral.
- Provides that, if a CARE Act petition has been filed pursuant to a referral from an AOT court, LPS Act conservatorship proceeding, misdemeanor proceeding, or for a respondent within a juvenile court’s dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction, the CARE Act court and the referring or juvenile court may communicate with each other regarding the status of the respondent’s cases and any relevant court orders while both cases are pending.
- The courts may allow the parties to participate in the communication; all communications about the disposition of a respondent’s case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
- Communication between courts regarding schedules, calendars, court records, and similar matters may be conducted without informing the parties and off the record; a record must be made of all other communications between the courts, and the parties must be promptly notified of the communications and given access to the record.
- “Record” means information that is inscribed on a tangible medium or that is stored in an electronic or other medium and is retrievable in perceivable form.
- Permits a CARE plan to include, with the consent or the respondent and the entity or facility responsible for the services, additional services not otherwise specified in statute to support the recovery and stability of the respondent.
- Requires DHCS to include, in its annual report to the Legislature regarding the implementation of the CARE Act, data regarding inter-court referrals made pursuant to 12).
- Makes technical and nonsubstantive clarifying changes to the CARE Act.
- Includes an urgency clause.
COMMENTS
- Author’s comment
SB 42 is a CARE Court clean-up bill that is urgently needed to assist in the implementation of California’s CARE Court program before the program starts in all counties on December 1st of this year. The bill contains several CARE Court process changes requested by governmental entities in charge of CARE Court’s implementation. Specifically this bill: ensures health professionals consider other alternatives before recommending the patient's conservatorship; updates the process by allowing the utilization of documents from past treatments, such as records and personal statements, as evidence; updates the rights advisement process; requires an investigatory report by the county agency regarding a CARE petition to be completed as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days rather than 14 court days; allows mental healthcare professionals to testify as experts ; allows additional services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent; and lastly, the bill gives the court will the discretion to provide ongoing notice throughout the CARE proceedings, thereby enhancing transparency.
2. Background on the CARE Act
In 2022, the Legislature passed SB 1338 (Umberg, Ch. 319, Stats. 2022), which established the CARE Act. The CARE Act is intended to provide essential mental health and substance use disorder services to severely mentally ill Californians—many of whom are homeless or incarcerated—while also preserving these individuals’ self-determination to the greatest extent possible. The CARE Act was subsequently modified by SB 35 (Umberg, Ch. 283, Stats. 2023), which made a number of clean-up changes to the CARE process and related changes before the first cohort of counties implemented the CARE Act.
The CARE Act is currently in the middle of a two-stage implementation rollout. The first cohort of counties—comprised of the Counties of Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne, and the City and County of San Francisco—implemented the CARE Act on October 1, 2023.[1] The remaining counties must implement the CARE Act no later than December 1, 2024.[2] Some counties in the second cohort have already implemented the CARE Act ahead of schedule: the County of Los Angeles began accepting CARE Act petitions in December of 2023, and the County of San Mateo began accepting CARE Act petitions in July of this year.[3] DHCS may approve an implementation delay if a county experiences a state or local emergency and the implementation is necessary as a result of that emergency; an extension may be granted only once per county, and to no later than December 1, 2025.[4]
DHCS’s first report to the Legislature regarding the implementation of the CARE Act from October 1, 2023, to June 30, 2024, is not due until December 1, 2024, so there is no comprehensive data regarding how many individuals are currently participating in the CARE Act process.[5] Reports suggest, however, that fewer CARE petitions have been filed, and fewer respondents have received CARE agreements or plans, than anticipated. For example, Los Angeles expected to receive 4,000 CARE petitions in its first year, but as of July 2024, only 203 petitions had been filed, of which at least 14 petitions resulted in agreements with the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health and at least 4 resulted in court-ordered care plans.[6] Similarly, San Mateo reported only two CARE petitions were filed in the first six weeks of implementation.[7] As of the end of May 2024, an estimated 502 petitions had been filed statewide.[8]
3. The CARE Act process
The CARE process is largely overseen by the courts, which are trusted with ensuring that eligible individuals—termed “respondents”—are delivered mental health and substance use disorder services, as an alternative to involuntary conservatorship or imprisonment. CalHHS describes the CARE process as “an upstream diversion to prevent more restrictive conservatorship or incarceration.”[9]
The CARE process is unique within the state insofar as the court process can be initiated by a person who has a relationship with the potential respondent; other mental health procedures that go through the courts, such as AOT, require a county actor to initiate the process.[10] Eligible petitioners include the CBHA; a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent of the respondent; a treating behavioral health professional; the county public guardian or public conservator; and other enumerated persons and entities.[11]
There are strict criteria for CARE Act eligibility, including that the respondent suffer from a serious mental disorder, as defined; not be currently clinically stabilized in on-going voluntary treatment; and either be unlikely to survive safely in the community, or need services and supports to avoid grave disability or the risk of serious harm to themselves or others.[12] The CARE Act also imposes strict, and short, deadlines for the CARE process; for example, after a petition is filed, the court must set the matter for an initial appearance on the petition within 14 court days if the petition establishes a prima facie case for CARE eligibility;[13] and if the court orders a clinical evaluation of the respondent, the hearing to review the evaluation must be held within 21 days, and the evaluation must be provided to the respondent’s counsel no later than five days before that hearing.[14]
The CARE Act provides for two avenues to a court-ordered set of services. If the respondent and the CBHA are able to agree on a plan, it is known as a “CARE agreement”; the court may approve that agreement and set further hearings to monitor the respondent’s progress under the agreement.[15] If parties are unable to reach an agreement, one or both parties may present a proposed “CARE plan” to the court; the court may accept a proposed plan or adopt a modified plan, which becomes a court order that lasts for up to one year.[16] The CARE Plan may provide for behavioral health services and housing supports, as well as other services.[17] The court may order medication only if it finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication; to the extent such medication is administered, the medication may not be forcibly administered, and the respondent’s failure to comply with a medication order shall not result in a penalty, such as terminating the CARE process.[18]
Eleven months after the CARE Plan was put in place, the court shall hold a hearing to determine whether to graduate the respondent from the CARE Plan or whether, with or without the consent of the respondent, as specified, to keep the respondent in the CARE program.[19] A respondent may be appointed to the CARE process only once, for up to one additional year.[20]
4. This bill makes a number of changes to the CARE Act process in advance of the statewide CARE Act implementation
This bill is intended to modify the CARE Act in advance of the December 1, 2024, deadline for the second cohort of counties to implement the CARE Act. The bill includes an urgency clause, so that the changes take effect prior to the implementation deadline.
The bill’s changes to the CARE Act include:
- Clarifying that evidence of a respondent’s past involuntary treatment under the LPS Act may be presented in a CARE Act petition through documentary evidence or a declaration from a petitioner with personal knowledge of the detentions.
- Eliminating a CARE court’s ongoing obligation to inform a respondent of their rights if, after informing the respondent of their rights at the first hearing at which the respondent makes an appearance, the court finds that the respondent understands and waives the additional advisement.
- Requiring that a dismissal of a CARE petition be without prejudice unless a petition was specifically found to violate the CARE Act’s prohibition on vexatious petitions and filing petitions for purposes of gaining advantage in a lawsuit.
- Extending the time window in which a CBHA must investigate a respondent and file a report in cases where the initial petition was filed by a person other than the CBHA, from 14 court days to “as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days.”
- Clarifying that parties may agree to amendments to a CARE agreement or plan, with the court’s approval.
- Requiring the courts and relevant local public agencies to cooperate develop a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve performance of the CARE system in a vigorous and ongoing manner; and providing that a court may coordinate and participate in meetings to improve system performance.
- Clarifying that a CARE plan may include services to support the recovery and stability of a respondent not listed specifically in statute, with the consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services.
Additionally, modifies, beginning July 1, 2025, when an original CARE Act petitioner who is not a CBHA—for example, a family member or roommate of the respondent—may receive ongoing notices of the proceedings. Current law permits the CARE court judge to determine, in its discretion, whether to provide ongoing notice to an original petitioner after the CBHA has been substituted in as the petitioner. This bill instead establishes, beginning July 1, 2025, a presumption that an original petitioner will receive ongoing notice of the proceedings, unless the court determines on its own motion or on a motion from the respondent that notice to the original petitioner would be detrimental to the treatment or wellbeing of the respondent. The notice relating to continuances and the dismissal of a case must include specified information regarding the reason for the continuance or dismissal; however, the bill is clear that the notice may not include patient information protected by specified state or federal laws without the respondent’s consent. Opponents of the bill have expressed concern that this provision permits notice over the objection of the respondent, which may hurt their recovery.
5. This bill establishes more connections between the CARE Act, the LPS Act, and other courts
In addition to the changes listed above, this bill adds provisions to the CARE Act and the wider Welfare and Institutions Code to create more connectivity between CARE courts, the courts and professionals involved in LPS Act and misdemeanor cases, and other courts which may refer individuals to CARE proceedings. These provisions will also be implemented on an urgency basis.
First, the bill requires a petition for the establishment of an LPS Act conservatorship and a petition to reappoint an LPS Act conservator to include an attestation from the relevant professional person or conservator that they have considered all alternatives to the conservatorship, including AOT and CARE Act proceedings, and that no suitable alternatives to the conservatorship are available.
Second, this bill authorizes a facility that is treating a person involuntarily under the LPS Act to refer that person to CARE Act proceedings if, in their professional opinion, the individual meets or is likely to meet the CARE Act criteria. A CBHA must complete an assessment of the referred person within 14 business days of the referral. The bill explicitly states that this law does not permit a facility to detain a person who no longer meets the criteria for an involuntary hold for purposes of determining whether they may meet the CARE Act criteria. Opponents of the bill have expressed concern that facilities will nevertheless hold individuals longer than permitted under the LPS Act for purposes of completing CARE Act assessments. The bill also requires the DHCS to report on referrals made through this provision, giving the Legislature the opportunity to review whether LPS Act detentions are being illegally extended.
Third, this bill authorizes a CARE court judge to communicate with a judge who referred the respondent from an AOT, LPS Act, or misdemeanor proceeding, or with a judge of the juvenile court who referred the respondent under the court’s dependency, delinquency, or transition jurisdiction. The bill permits the judges to communicate off the record and without notice to the parties on ministerial matters—schedules, calendars, and court records—but requires any substantive communication to be on the record, with the parties notified and given access to the record promptly. The bill also permits the judges to allow the parties to participate in the communication, and specifies that all communications about the disposition of a respondent’s case must be conducted in court and on the record.
6. Arguments in support
According to California Professional Firefighters:
CARE Court as established by SB 1338 (Umberg, 2022) presents an important new method for providing behavioral health treatment to the Californians who most need it but are least able to access services. Once enrolled in a CARE plan, an individual is connected with much-needed services such as behavioral health care, medication, and supportive housing services in order to assist them with recovery and achieving stability. These services are intended for those with severe schizophrenia spectrum and psychotic disorders who are unable to care for themselves or make the complex decisions needed to direct their own care.
Oftentimes, the individual petitioners who began the process of having someone enrolled in CARE Court are a close friend or family member with close relationships with that person. That relationship, along with the fact that the petitioner has a legal tie to the individual in CARE, means that it is important for them to be aware of every step of the Court process and understand when a continuance is ordered or a case is dismissed. SB 42 provides clarity regarding when and to whom notifications are issued on those steps in the process, and ensures transparency and full understanding for all involved.
7. Arguments in opposition
According to ACLU California Action, Cal Voices, the California Youth Empowerment Network, Disability Rights California, and Mental Health America of California:
Disability Rights California (DRC), Mental Health America of California (MHAC), Cal Voices, ACLU California Action (ACLU) and the California Youth Empowerment Network (CAYEN) regretfully oppose SB 42 because it makes numerous changes to CARE Court that water down due process, reinforce coercive aspects of the program and threaten to harm the very people CARE Court is supposed to help. In addition, this bill was unnecessarily rushed through the Legislature with no opportunity for meaningful feedback…
We have not yet fully analyzed this measure, but our objections include the following:
- The bill provides ongoing notice rights to nonparties, even when the respondent objects. We support a family member’s involvement if the respondent consents. Forcing continued involvement of family members on respondents violates their privacy and is not conducive to recovery.
- CARE Court requires a petition to include evidence of a person’s prior mental health history. SB 42 permits evidence of prior hospitalizations to consist of a petitioner’s declaration from personal knowledge, with no regard for the meaning of personal knowledge in the Evidence Code, and in case law.
- SB 42 eliminates, after the first hearing, the requirement that a court advise the respondent of their rights, if the court finds the respondent understands and waives additional advisement. This provision applies even when the respondent is not assisted by counsel.
- This bill permits a facility to refer a detained individual to CARE Court and allows a county 14 business days to evaluate the individual. This clearly incentivizes referring physicians to hold the person involuntarily in a hospital in order for the county to be able to find and assess this individual. Persons may not be held involuntarily in a mental hospital unless they meet criteria set out in the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act and also in the United States Supreme Court decision in O’Connor v. Donaldson. Nothing in the bill protects involuntary patients from being detained illegally.
- SB 42 permits courts to communicate about a respondent’s case when there are proceedings in more than one court, e.g., Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT) and CARE Court simultaneously. Respondents should not be subject to multiple and duplicative civil commitment proceedings at one time. Communication between courts regarding multiple and duplicative proceedings seems calculated to ensure unfairness in the process.
SUPPORT
California Professional Firefighters
Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill
OPPOSITION
ACLU California Action
Cal Voices
California Youth Empowerment Network
Disability Rights California
Mental Health America of California
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: SB 1400 (Stern, 2024) among other things, modifies how a respondent must participate in the CARE Act process in order to have pending criminal charges dismissed. SB 1400 is pending before on Assembly Floor.
Prior Legislation:
SB 35 (Umberg, Ch. 283, Stats. 2023) made various modifications to the CARE Act in advance of the first cohort’s implementation of the CARE Act in 2024.
SB 1338 (Umberg, Ch. 319, Stats. 2022) enacted the CARE Act and implements the CARE Court framework in a two-phased rollout, with the first cohort of counties to commence implementation on October 1, 2023, and the second cohort of counties to commence implementation on December 1, 2024.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (the official vote count was not available at the time this analysis was released)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
[Because this bill was gutted and amended in the Assembly, the votes preceding the Assembly Judiciary Committee’s vote are not relevant.]
**************
Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5970.5(a). ↑
Id., § 5970.5(b). ↑
See County of Los Angeles Homeless Initiative, Care Court in LA County (Dec. 1, 2023), available at https://homeless.lacounty.gov/news/care-court-in-la-county/; San Mateo County Health, Care Court in San Mateo County, https://www.smchealth.org/care. All links in this analysis are current as of August 29, 2024. ↑
Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5970.5(c). ↑
See AB 102 (Ting, Ch. 38, Stats. 2023) § 133(24)(b). ↑
Khairzada, About 200 petitions filed for LA County CARE Court so far, Spectrum News 1 (Jul. 29, 2024), https://spectrumnews1.com/ca/la-west/health/2024/07/29/about-200-petitions-have-been-filed-for-la-county-care-court-so-far. ↑
Mata, CARE Court links residents to resources, San Mateo Daily Journal (Aug. 19, 2024), available at https://www.smdailyjournal.com/news/local/care-court-links-residents-to-resources/article_6f0c463e-5e0b-11ef-8a51-538eff8c3a7d.html. ↑
Garrova, California’s Big Plan To Get Help For People With Serious Mental Illness Is Off To A Slow Start, LAist (Jun. 5, 2024), https://laist.com/news/health/6-months-in-la-county-is-far-behind-projections-for-care-court-program-leader-says-the-work-takes-time. ↑
See CalHHS, Community Assistance, Recovery & Empowerment Act, https://www.chhs.ca.gov/care-act/. ↑
E.g., Welf. & Inst. Code, § 5346 (AOT petition must be filed by a county behavioral health director or their designee; specified family members or other persons may request that a petition be filed, but may not file the petition themselves). ↑
Id., § 5974. ↑
Id., § 5972. ↑
Id., § 5977. ↑
Id., § 5977.1(b). The court may continue the evaluation hearing for a maximum of 14 days upon stipulation of the respondent and the CBHA, unless there is good cause for a longer extension. ↑
Id., § 5977.1(a)(2). ↑
Id., § 5977.1(d). ↑
Id., § 5982. ↑
Id., § 5977.1(d)(3). ↑
Id., § 5977.3. ↑
Ibid. ↑
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 42
Author:(Umberg)
As Amended Ver:August 22, 2024
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY
Requires, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent in a Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) proceeding, the court to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings, including notice of a continuance or dismissal of the proceedings, to specified family members of the respondent without the respondent's consent and prohibits the disclosure of confidential patient information in any such notice without the respondent's consent; and makes a number of other clarifications and modifications to existing law regarding conservatorship and CARE proceedings.
Major Provisions
- Requires as of July 1, 2025, that, if an original petitioner lives with the respondent or is a parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent to provide or continue such notice. Prohibits the notice from disclosing confidential medical or mental health information, without the respondent's consent.
- Requires that, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court; and if a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal.
- Clarifies or modifies the following provisions of existing law regarding LPS conservatorships:
- Requires the professional person who recommends a conservatorship to attest that all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment and CARE Act proceedings have been considered or investigated and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
- Allows a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act to refer a person to the CARE process after assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention of the person; requires a referral to be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional employed by or contracted by the facility who has knowledge of the individual's case and has been involved in the individual's treatment during their involuntary hold; and requires documentation of the authority for a referral pursuant to this paragraph to be signed by the licensed behavioral health professional, or their designee.
- Requires the facility to make a referral to CARE as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individual's discharge planning process; and include contact information for the referred individual.
- Requires the county behavioral health agency, within 14 business days of the referral by the facility, to complete assessment of the individual referred pursuant to this section and file a petition if the county behavioral health agency determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria for the CARE process and the individual does not engage in voluntary treatment.
- Clarifies that the bill does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred individual who no longer meets criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete its assessment, or affect the ability of a facility to make a referral for assisted outpatient treatment.
- Clarifies or modifies the following provisions of existing law regarding CARE proceedings:
- Allows required evidence that the respondent was detained in the past for a minimum of two intensive treatments to include documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration of the petitioner if the petitioner had personal knowledge of the detentions.
- Allows a respondent to waive the advisement of their rights at subsequent court hearings if they were fully advised of their rights at their initial appearance.
- Clarifies, if a court dismisses a petition for its failure to make a prima facie case, the dismissal shall be without prejudice, unless the petitioner has intended to harass or annoy the respondent. In all other circumstances the petitioner is allowed to refile the petition with amended information.
- Requires an investigatory report by the county agency regarding a CARE petition to be completed as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days, rather than within 14 court days.
- Allows a licensed behavioral health professional to testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the criteria for CARE proceedings, provided that the court finds that the professional qualifies as an expert.
- Clarifies that parties may agree to, and the court from approving, amendments to a CARE agreement and a CARE plan.
- Requires the court and relevant local public agencies shall act in conformity with a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve system performance in a vigorous and ongoing manner; authorizes the court to initiate meetings to improve system performance.
- Allows a CARE Act court and a referring court to communicate with each other regarding the status of the respondent's cases and any relevant court orders while the cases are still pending in both courts, but clarifies, among other things, that all communications about the disposition of a respondent's case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
- Allows, upon consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services, services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent to be provided in addition to the services currently authorized to be provided to a respondent.
- Requires the annual report shall regarding the CARE Act model implementation to include data regarding referrals by a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to the LPS Act as part of the individual's discharge planning process.
- Because of an urgency clause, makes the above changes to the law effective immediately.
COMMENTS
Background – CARE Proceedings. SB 1338 (Umberg) Chapter 319, Statutes of 2022 enacted the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act. The Act was intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services.
The CARE Act is not yet fully implemented in the state. The CARE Act was required to be implemented by Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, San Francisco, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties by October 1, 2023, but not in the remaining counties until December 1, 2024. (Furthermore, under certain circumstances the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) can issue a one-time delay implementation to a specific county until December 1, 2025.) Finally the CARE Act only becomes operative upon DHCS, in consultation with county stakeholders, developing a CARE Act allocation to provide state financial assistance to counties to implement the CARE process. DHCS is required to issue a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act by due by December 31, 2026; and to issue a final report by December 31, 2028.
How a CARE proceeding is designed to work. A central feature of the CARE Act are "CARE Courts," intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services. These might include court-ordered stabilization medications, wellness and recovery support, help with finding social services and housing. "Court-ordered stabilization medication" is distinct from involuntary medication in that it cannot be forcibly administered. However, failure of a person to voluntarily participate in the medication treatment could lead to their referral to an LPS conservatorship.
CARE court focuses on the most severely mentally ill, including those with schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders. As noted, while the overall purpose of the CARE Act is to provide essential services to the most severely ill, it also is supposed to preserve self-determination to the greatest extent possible. The California Health and Human Services Agency describes CARE Court as "an upstream diversion to prevent more restrictive conservatorships or incarceration." ("CARE Court FAQ," at chhs.ca.gov.) CARE Court could be an "appropriate next step" after someone has been placed on a 72-hour hold ("5150") or a 14-day hold ("5250"), an arrest, or those who can otherwise be safely diverted from a criminal proceeding.
The Process: The first step in the CARE Court process is a "referral" – that is, a petition to the court by a family member, mental health provider, or first responder, among others. The Court then orders a clinical evaluation and appoints both a Public Defender and a "CARE Supporter," the person assigned to help the individual understand the process so as to provide the individual with as much autonomy as is feasible. If the Court finds that the person meets the criteria for the program, then the Court orders the individual, CARE Supporter, and county behavioral health agency to develop a CARE Plan. If approved, the Plan becomes a court order lasting up to 12 months. Eventually, the individual "graduates" from the CARE Court, although they may be provided with ongoing services, including assistance with finding housing.
This bill is yet another modification to the CARE Act during its initial stage of implementation, but prior to its full implementation and evaluation. The bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide, as of July 1, 2025, ongoing notice about the proceedings to specified associates and family members, namely 1) a person with whom the respondent resides; 2) a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent; or 3) an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
The bill requires that the court must provide "ongoing notice" to these persons of all CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or a case is dismissed. As recently amended, the bill allows a court to deny notice to a petitioner if the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. The bill also prohibits the notice from disclosing confidential medical or mental health information, without the respondent's consent.
As recently amended, the bill also makes a number of other clarifications and modifications to existing law regarding conservatorship and CARE proceedings in an effort to integrate the CARE Act into the LPS Act (as a "step-down" from an LPS conservatorship) and clarify a number of procedures.
According to the Author
SB 42 aims to improve communication and openness by streamlining the notification procedures during CARE proceedings. In order for all parties to stay informed, this entails providing thorough justifications for the CARE court procedures' continuances and dismissals. This bill is required because it has been recognized that there is a need for better organized communication between the courts and the parties involved in CARE actions, particularly when there is a close personal relationship between the original petitioner and the respondent. The measure promotes unambiguous, continuous notices and explanations for court proceedings to guarantee that individuals who start the CARE procedure are kept informed at all times.
Arguments in Support
Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill (FASMI) writes the following to explain the need for, and their support of, the bill:
My group FASMI includes many family members of seriously mentally ill people. We want them to get help and need to be involved in their care because they often aren't even aware that they are ill. We know their history and love them. Nevertheless we are often shut out of legal proceedings that have a chance of getting help for our loved ones. This has happened to me: county officials tried to prevent me from seeing my late loved one or getting her medical information, and rarely was I notified of hearings even when my loved one wanted me to know. We supported the CARE Court bill because we hoped it would be more effective than Assisted Outpatient Treatment. A big reason CARE Court is better is that it has a role for families. This bill is a step towards making that role meaningful.
Arguments in Opposition
Disability Rights California wrote that a prior version of the bill likely violated privacy laws:
SB 42 violates state and federal medical privacy laws by requiring courts to provide to third parties, without the respondent's consent, ongoing notice of CARE proceedings and the reason for continuance or dismissal. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) defines protected health information as "individually identifiable health information." . . . Ongoing notice and reasons for continuance or dismissal of CARE proceedings are individually identifiable health information pertaining to mental health assessment and treatment and qualify as "protected health information" under HIPAA. Under state and federal medical privacy laws, this information can only be provided with the patient's consent. . . . SB 42 violates state and federal medical privacy laws by requiring courts provide protected health information to specified third parties without the respondent's consent.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, costs (Trial Court Trust Fund) to the courts of an unknown but potentially significant amount to make required notifications, process refiled petitions, and ensure all communications about the disposition of a respondent's case are conducted in court and documented on the record. The bill also states a CARE plan may be amended upon agreement of the parties or approval of the court, which may lead to additional court workload to process amendment requests and to amend existing plans. The fiscal year 2024-25 budget provides $47.4 million General Fund to the courts to implement the CARE courts.
Costs (General Fund) to DHCS of an unknown amount to include in its annual CARE Act report data about people subject to involuntary mental health holds who are referred to the CARE process.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-2
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Seyarto, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Joe Patterson, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-0-4
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: August 22, 2024
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004459
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 42
Author:(Umberg)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2024
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY
Requires, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent in a Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) proceeding, the court to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings, including notice of a continuance or dismissal of the proceedings, to specified family members of the respondent without the respondent's consent and prohibits the disclosure of confidential patient information in any such notice without the respondent's consent; and makes a number of other clarifications and modifications to existing law regarding conservatorship and CARE proceedings.
Major Provisions
- Requires that, if an original petitioner lives with the respondent or is a parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent to provide or continue such notice. Prohibits the notice from disclosing confidential medical or mental health information, without the respondent's consent.
- Requires that, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court; and if a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify the statutory basis for the dismissal.
- Clarifies or modifies the following provisions of existing law regarding LPS conservatorships:
- Requires the professional person who recommends a conservatorship to attest that all available alternatives to conservatorship, including, but not limited to, assisted outpatient treatment and CARE Act proceedings have been investigated and that appointment of a temporary conservator is recommended because no suitable alternatives to conservatorship are available.
- Allows a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act to refer a person to the CARE process after assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention of the person; requires a referral to be authorized by a licensed behavioral health professional employed by or contracted by the facility who has knowledge of the individual's case and has been involved in the individual's treatment during their involuntary hold; and requires documentation of the authority for a referral pursuant to this paragraph to be signed by the licensed behavioral health professional, or their designee.
- Requires the facility to make a referral to CARE as soon as clinically indicated as part of the individual's discharge planning process; and include contact information for the referred individual.
- Requires the county behavioral health agency, within 14 business days of the referral by the facility, to complete assessment of the individual referred pursuant to this section and file a petition if the county behavioral health agency determines that the individual meets or is likely to meet criteria for the CARE process and the individual does not engage in voluntary treatment.
- Clarifies that the bill does not authorize a facility to continue an involuntary hold on a referred individual who no longer meets criteria for involuntary treatment solely for the purpose of allowing the county behavioral health agency to complete its assessment, or affect the ability of a facility to make a referral for assisted outpatient treatment.
- Clarifies or modifies the following provisions of existing law regarding CARE proceedings:
- Allows required evidence that the respondent was detained in the past for a minimum of two intensive treatments to include documentary evidence from the facility where the respondent was detained, or a signed declaration of the petitioner if the petitioner had personal knowledge of the detentions.
- Allows a respondent to waive the advisement of their rights at subsequent court hearings if they were fully advised of their rights at their initial appearance.
- Clarifies, if a court dismisses a petition for its failure to make a prima facie case, the dismissal shall be without prejudice, unless the petitioner has intended to harass or annoy the respondent. In all other circumstances the petitioner is allowed to refile the petition with amended information.
- Requires an investigatory report by the county agency regarding a CARE petition to be completed as soon as practicable, but within 30 court days, rather than within 14 court days.
- Allows a licensed behavioral health professional to testify as an expert concerning whether the respondent meets the criteria for CARE proceedings, provided that the court finds that the professional qualifies as an expert.
- Clarifies that parties may agree to, and the court from approving, amendments to a CARE agreement and a CARE plan.
- Requires the court and relevant local public agencies shall act in conformity with a comprehensive set of objectives established to improve system performance in a vigorous and ongoing manner; authorizes the court to initiate meetings to improve system performance.
- Allows a CARE Act court and a referring court to communicate with each other regarding the respondent's cases while the cases are still pending in both courts, but clarifies, among other things, that all communications about the disposition of a respondent's case shall be conducted in court and on the record.
- Allows, upon consent of the respondent and the entity or individual financially responsible for the services, services to support the recovery and stability of the respondent to be provided in addition to the services currently authorized to be provided to a respondent.
- Requires the annual report shall regarding the CARE Act model implementation to include data regarding referrals by a facility that provides assessment, evaluation, and crisis intervention pursuant to the LPS Act as part of the individual's discharge planning process.
- Because of an urgency clause, makes the above changes to the law effective immediately.
COMMENTS
Background – CARE Proceedings. SB 1338 (Umberg) Chapter 319, Statutes of 2022 enacted the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act. The Act was intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services.
The CARE Act is not yet fully implemented in the state. The CARE Act was required to be implemented by Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, San Francisco, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties by October 1, 2023, but not in the remaining counties until December 1, 2024. (Furthermore, under certain circumstances the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) can issue a one-time delay implementation to a specific county until December 1, 2025.) Finally the CARE Act only becomes operative upon DHCS, in consultation with county stakeholders, developing a CARE Act allocation to provide state financial assistance to counties to implement the CARE process. DHCS is required to issue a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act by due by December 31, 2026; and to issue a final report by December 31, 2028.
How a CARE proceeding is designed to work. A central feature of the CARE Act are "CARE Courts," intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services. These might include court-ordered stabilization medications, wellness and recovery support, help with finding social services and housing. "Court-ordered stabilization medication" is distinct from involuntary medication in that it cannot be forcibly administered. However, failure of a person to voluntarily participate in the medication treatment could lead to their referral to an LPS conservatorship.
CARE court focuses on the most severely mentally ill, including those with schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders. As noted, while the overall purpose of the CARE Act is to provide essential services to the most severely ill, it also is supposed to preserve self-determination to the greatest extent possible. The California Health and Human Services Agency describes CARE Court as "an upstream diversion to prevent more restrictive conservatorships or incarceration." ("CARE Court FAQ," at chhs.ca.gov.) CARE Court could be an "appropriate next step" after someone has been placed on a 72-hour hold ("5150") or a 14-day hold ("5250"), an arrest, or those who can otherwise be safely diverted from a criminal proceeding.
The Process: The first step in the CARE Court process is a "referral" – that is, a petition to the court by a family member, mental health provider, or first responder, among others. The Court then orders a clinical evaluation and appoints both a Public Defender and a "CARE Supporter," the person assigned to help the individual understand the process so as to provide the individual with as much autonomy as is feasible. If the Court finds that the person meets the criteria for the program, then the Court orders the individual, CARE Supporter, and county behavioral health agency to develop a CARE Plan. If approved, the Plan becomes a court order lasting up to 12 months. Eventually, the individual "graduates" from the CARE Court, although they may be provided with ongoing services, including assistance with finding housing.
This bill is yet another modification to the CARE Act during its initial stage of implementation, but prior to its full implementation and evaluation. The bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings to specified associates and family members, namely 1) a person with whom the respondent resides; 2) a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent; or 3) an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
The bill requires that the court must provide "ongoing notice" to these persons of all CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or a case is dismissed. As recently amended, the bill allows a court to deny notice to a petitioner if the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. The bill also prohibits the notice from disclosing confidential medical or mental health information, without the respondent's consent.
As recently amended, the bill also makes a number of other clarifications and modifications to existing law regarding conservatorship and CARE proceedings in an effort to integrate the CARE Act into the LPS Act (as a "step-down" from an LPS conservatorship) and clarify a number of procedures.
According to the Author
SB 42 aims to improve communication and openness by streamlining the notification procedures during CARE proceedings. In order for all parties to stay informed, this entails providing thorough justifications for the CARE court procedures' continuances and dismissals. This bill is required because it has been recognized that there is a need for better organized communication between the courts and the parties involved in CARE actions, particularly when there is a close personal relationship between the original petitioner and the respondent. The measure promotes unambiguous, continuous notices and explanations for court proceedings to guarantee that individuals who start the CARE procedure are kept informed at all times.
Arguments in Support
Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill (FASMI) writes the following to explain the need for, and their support of, the bill:
My group FASMI includes many family members of seriously mentally ill people. We want them to get help and need to be involved in their care because they often aren't even aware that they are ill. We know their history and love them. Nevertheless we are often shut out of legal proceedings that have a chance of getting help for our loved ones. This has happened to me: county officials tried to prevent me from seeing my late loved one or getting her medical information, and rarely was I notified of hearings even when my loved one wanted me to know. We supported the CARE Court bill because we hoped it would be more effective than Assisted Outpatient Treatment. A big reason CARE Court is better is that it has a role for families. This bill is a step towards making that role meaningful.
Arguments in Opposition
Disability Rights California wrote that a prior version of the bill likely violated privacy laws:
SB 42 violates state and federal medical privacy laws by requiring courts to provide to third parties, without the respondent's consent, ongoing notice of CARE proceedings and the reason for continuance or dismissal. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) defines protected health information as "individually identifiable health information." . . . Ongoing notice and reasons for continuance or dismissal of CARE proceedings are individually identifiable health information pertaining to mental health assessment and treatment and qualify as "protected health information" under HIPAA. Under state and federal medical privacy laws, this information can only be provided with the patient's consent. . . . SB 42 violates state and federal medical privacy laws by requiring courts provide protected health information to specified third parties without the respondent's consent.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, costs (Trial Court Trust Fund) to the courts of an unknown but potentially significant amount to make required notifications, process refiled petitions, and ensure all communications about the disposition of a respondent's case are conducted in court and documented on the record. The bill also states a CARE plan may be amended upon agreement of the parties or approval of the court, which may lead to additional court workload to process amendment requests and to amend existing plans. The fiscal year 2024-25 budget provides $47.4 million General Fund to the courts to implement the CARE courts.
Costs (General Fund) to DHCS of an unknown amount to include in its annual CARE Act report data about people subject to involuntary mental health holds who are referred to the CARE process.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-2
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Seyarto, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Kalra, Dixon, Bauer-Kahan, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Joe Patterson, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-0-4
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: August 19, 2024
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004132
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 42
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires a court to provide notices about ongoing Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) court proceedings to qualifying petitioners.
Specifically, this bill:
- Specifies a qualifying petitioner for the purposes of the bill is an original CARE petitioner who resides with the respondent, or is the spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent of the respondent, or stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
- Requires the court to provide ongoing notice to a qualifying petitioner throughout CARE proceedings, including when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed, unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent to provide or continue such notice.
- Specifies information to be included in a notice to a qualifying petitioner that a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed.
- Prohibits any notice from disclosing patient information protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, or the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, without the respondent’s consent.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs (Trial Court Trust Fund) of an unknown amount to the courts to send the required notices. Judicial Council projects an “unknown, potentially significant impact” to the judicial branch to comply with this bill’s requirements. As Judicial Council notes, only a few CARE courts are currently operational, but costs associated with administering the CARE courts, including providing the notices required by this bill, may grow as more courts begin operating and more CARE petitions are filed in coming years. Judicial Council reports that costs are likely absorbable if the courts have the petitioner contact information needed to provide notice to qualifying petitioners electronically, rather than via mail service.
The fiscal year 2024-25 budget provides $47.4 million to the courts to implement the CARE courts.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
SB 42 aims to improve communication and openness by streamlining the notification procedures during CARE proceedings. In order for all parties to stay informed, this entails providing thorough justifications for the CARE court procedures’ continuances and dismissals. This bill is required because it has been recognized that there is a need for better organized communication between the courts and the parties involved in CARE actions, particularly when there is a close personal relationship between the original petitioner and the respondent.
- Background. In 2022, the Legislature passed SB 1338 (Umberg), Chapter 319, Statutes of 2022, known as the CARE Act. SB 1338 established the CARE court program, which seeks to provide mental health and substance abuse disorder services to qualifying individuals through court-ordered CARE plans. The goal of the CARE court program is to provide these services without requiring incarceration in jail, detention in a psychiatric facility, or a Lanterman-Petris-Short Act conservatorship. The CARE Act required seven counties to begin implementation by October 1, 2023, and requires the remaining counties to begin implementation by December 1, 2024.
The CARE court process begins when a person (“petitioner”) files a petition with the court seeking services for a qualifying person with a serious mental disorder (“respondent”). The court orders a clinical evaluation and appoints a public defender and a support person to represent the respondent in legal proceedings and help the respondent navigate the CARE court process. If the court finds that the respondent meets the statutory criteria, the court orders the parties and the county behavioral health agency to develop a proposed CARE treatment plan for the respondent. Once the court approves the plan, it becomes a court-ordered treatment plan that requires the respondent to participate in specified clinically-appropriate, community-based services for a set period of time.
This bill requires the court to provide a qualifying petitioner with ongoing notices about the status of the CARE court proceedings resulting from the CARE petition the petitioner filed. Generally, a qualifying petitioner is a person who filed a petition seeking CARE court services for their family member.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 42
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:June 25, 2024
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: NOT RELEVANT
SUBJECT: COMMUNITY ASSISTANCE, RECOVERY, AND EMPOWERMENT (CARE) COURT PROGRAM: NOTICE TO ORIGINAL PETITIONER
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD A COURT, IN A CARE PROCEEDING BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE ONGOING NOTICE ABOUT THE PROCEEDINGS, INCLUDING THE REASON FOR A CONTINUANCE OR DISMISSAL, TO SPECIFIED FAMILY MEMBERS OF THE RESPONDENT, UNLESS THE COURT DETERMINES THAT IT WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO THE RESPONDENT TO DO SO?
- SHOULD ALL SUCH NOTICES BE PROHIBITED FROM DISCLOSING PROTECTED PATIENT INFORMATION, UNLESS THE RESPONDENT CONSENTS?
SYNOPSIS
SB 1338 (Umberg) Chap. 319, Stats. 2022 enacted the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act. The CARE Act was intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services. The CARE Act is not yet fully implemented in the state. DHCS is required to issue a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act by due by December 31, 2026; and to issue a final report by December 31, 2028.
Like a number of other recent bills, this bill modifies the CARE Act during its initial stage of implementation, but prior to its full implementation and evaluation. The bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings to specified associates and family members, namely (1) a person with whom the respondent resides; (2) a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent; or (3) an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The respondent is not required to consent to such notice being provided. The bill in print requires notice to be provided unless the court—on its own motion, or upon motion of the respondent—disapproves or discontinues notice of CARE proceedings to the original petitioner when it finds that such notice likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. The author proposes to further amend the bill to clarify, among other things, that a notice to the original petitioner, shall not include protected patient information, unless the respondent consents. The amendments are included in the SUMMARY of the bill, below, and explained in the analysis. This author-sponsored bill is supported by Alameda County Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill, California Professional Firefighters, and one individual. It is opposed by a number of organizations that advocate for civil and disability rights. It is unclear whether the proposed amendments fully address the concerns of the opposition.
SUMMARY: Requires, unless the court determines that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent in a CARE proceeding, the court to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings, including notice of a continuance or dismissal of the proceedings, to specified family members of the respondent without the respondent’s consent; specifies the information that may be provided in a notice of a continuance or dismissal; and prohibits disclosure of confidential patient information in any notice, without the respondent’s consent. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that, if an original petitioner meets the criteria of 4), the court shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed.
- As an exception to 1), authorizes the court, when it determines, either upon its own motion, or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent to provide or continue such notice.
- Requires that, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court; and if a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify whether the dismissal was granted pursuant to a reason specified in Section 5977.1, 5977.3, or 5979.
- Prohibits any notice from disclosing any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or the LPS Act, without the respondent’s consent.
- Limits the notification mandates above to an original petitioner who is one the following:
- A person with whom the respondent resides.
- A spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the LPS Act to end inappropriate, indefinite, and involuntary commitment of mentally disordered persons, developmentally disabled persons, and persons impaired by chronic alcoholism, and to provide prompt evaluation and treatment of those with mental health disorders or impaired by chronic alcoholism. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 5000 et seq. All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Defines, as a basis for involuntary commitment under the LPS Act, “grave disability” as a condition in which a person, as a result of a mental disorder, or impairment by chronic alcoholism, is unable to provide for their basic personal needs for food, clothing, or shelter, or is found to be mentally incompetent under the Penal Code. Excludes from that definition persons with intellectual disabilities by reason of that disability alone. (Section 5008 (h).)
- Provides that if a person is gravely disabled as a result of mental illness, or a danger to self or others, then a peace officer, staff of a designated treatment facility or crisis team, or other professional person designated by the county, may, upon probable cause, take that person into custody for a period of up to 72 hours for assessment, evaluation, crisis intervention, or placement in a designated treatment facility. (Section 5150.)
- Allows a person who has been detained for 72 hours to be detained for up to 14 days of intensive treatment if the person continues to pose a danger to self or others, or to be gravely disabled, and the person has been unwilling or unable to accept voluntary treatment. (Section 5250.)
- Allows a person to be held at the expiration of a 14-day period of intensive treatment for further intensive treatment of up to 14 days if, during the detention period, a person threatened or attempted to take their own life or was detained because they threatened or attempted to their own life and continues to present an imminent threat of taking their own life and other specified conditions. (Section 5260.)
- Allows a person who has been detained for 14 days of intensive treatment to be detained for up to 30 additional days of intensive treatment if the person remains gravely disabled and is unwilling or unable to voluntarily accept treatment. (Section 5270.15.)
- Requires a certification review hearing to be held within four days of the date on which a person is certified for a 14-day period of intensive treatment or 30 additional days of intensive treatment unless judicial review has been requested or a postponement is requested by a person or their attorney or advocate. (Section 5256.)
- Provides every person detained by certification for intensive treatment with a right to a hearing by writ of habeas corpus for their release. Enumerates specified requirements and procedures for judicial review. (Sections 5275, 5276.)
- Allows the professional person in charge of a facility providing 72-hour, 14-day, or 30-day treatment to recommend an LPS conservatorship to the county conservatorship investigator for a person who is gravely disabled and is unwilling or unable to voluntarily accept treatment; and requires the conservatorship investigator, if they concur with the recommendation, to petition the superior court to establish an LPS conservatorship. Provides that a person for whom an LPS conservatorship is sought has the right to demand a court or jury trial on the issue of whether they are gravely disabled. (Section 5350, et seq.)
- Establishes the CARE Act, which must be implemented by Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, San Francisco, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties by October 1, 2023, and the remaining counties by December 1, 2024, subject to delays based on a state or local emergency, or discretionary approval by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), up until December 1, 2025. Provides that the CARE Act only becomes operative upon DHCS, in consultation with county stakeholders, developing a CARE Act allocation to provide state financial assistance to counties to implement the CARE process. (Section 5970, et seq.)
- Defines, for purposes of the CARE Act, certain terms, including:
- "CARE agreement" is a voluntary settlement agreement, which includes the same elements as a CARE plan.
- "CARE plan" is an individualized, appropriate range of services and supports consisting of behavioral health care, stabilization medications, housing, and other supportive services, as provided.
- "Graduation plan" is a voluntary agreement entered into by the parties at the end of the CARE program that includes a strategy to support a successful transition out of court jurisdiction and may include a psychiatric advance directive. A graduation plan includes the same elements as a CARE plan to support the respondent in accessing services and supports. A graduation plan may not place additional requirements on the local government entities and is not enforceable by the court.
- "Parties" are the person who file the petition, respondent and the county behavioral health agency, along with other parties that the court may add if they are providing services to the respondent.
- "Petitioner" is the entity who files the CARE Act petition, but if other than the county behavioral health agency, the court is required, at the initial hearing, to substitute the director of county behavioral health agency or their designee as the petitioner, limiting the initial petitioner's rights to potentially receiving ongoing notice of the proceedings, and the right to make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition, with broader participation rights only if the respondent consents.
- "Respondent" is the person who is subject to the petition for the CARE process.
- "Supporter" is an adult who assists the respondent, which may include supporting the person to understand, make, communicate, implement, or act on their own life decisions during the CARE process, including a CARE agreement, a CARE plan, and developing a graduation plan. (Section 5971.)
- Provides that a respondent may qualify for the CARE process only if all of the following criteria are met:
- The person is 18 years of age or older.
- The person is currently experiencing a severe mental illness, as defined, and has a diagnosis identified in the disorder class: schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders, as defined in the most current version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Specifically exempts specified other conditions or disorders.
- The person is not clinically stabilized in on-going voluntary treatment.
- At least one of the following is true:
- The person is unlikely to survive safely in the community without supervision and the person's condition is substantially deteriorating.
- The person is in need of services and supports in order to prevent a relapse or deterioration that would be likely to result in grave disability or serious harm to the person or to others.
- Participation in a CARE plan or agreement would be the least restrictive alternative necessary to ensure the person's recovery and stability.
- It is likely that the person will benefit from participation in a CARE plan or agreement. (Section 5972.)
- Provides venue provisions for where CARE Act proceedings may be brought. (Section 5973.)
- Allows a petition to initiate a CARE proceeding to be brought by one of the following adults:
- A person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent of the respondent, or another individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
- The director of a hospital, or their designee, in which the respondent is hospitalized, or the director of a public or charitable organization, agency, or home, or their designee, that is currently, or within the previous 30 days, providing behavioral health services to the respondent or in whose institution the respondent resides.
- A licensed behavioral health professional, or their designee, who is treating, or has been treating within the last 30 days, the respondent for a mental illness.
- A first responder, including a peace officer, firefighter, paramedic, emergency medical technician, mobile crisis response worker, or homeless outreach worker who has had repeated interactions with the respondent in the form of multiple arrests, multiple detentions, as provided, multiple attempts to engage the respondent in voluntary treatment or other repeated efforts to aid the respondent in obtaining professional assistance.
- The public guardian or public conservator, or their designee (and a respondent may be referred from conservatorship proceedings).
- The director of a county behavioral health agency of the county in which the respondent reside or is present (and a respondent may be referred from assisted outpatient treatment proceedings).
- The director of the county Adult Protective Services or their designee.
- The director of a California Indian health services program, California tribal behavioral health department, or their designee.
- The judge of a tribal court that is located in California, or their designee.
- The respondent. (Section 5974.)
- Allows a court, if a criminal defendant is found to be mentally incompetent and ineligible for a diversion, to refer the defendant to the CARE program, as provided. (Penal Code Section 1370.1 (b)(1)(D)(iv).)
- Requires the CARE petition, which must be developed as a mandatory form by the Judicial Council (along with other forms necessary for the CARE process) and must be signed under penalty of perjury, to include, among other things:
- The name of the respondent, their address, if known, and the petitioner's relationship with the respondent.
- Facts that support petitioner's allegation that the respondent meets the criteria in 12).
- Either of the following:
- An affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional stating that the health professional or their designee has examined the respondent within 60 days of the submission of the petition, or has made multiple attempts to examine, but has not been successful in eliciting the cooperation of the respondent to submit to an examination, within 60 days of submission of the petition, and that the licensed behavioral health professional had determined that the respondent meets, or has reason to believe, explained with specificity in the affidavit, that the respondent meets, the diagnostic criteria for CARE proceedings.
- Evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act, the most recent of which must be no longer ago than 60 days from the date of the petition. (Section 5975.)
- Provides that if a person other than the respondent files a petition for CARE Act proceedings that is unmeritorious or intended to harass or annoy the respondent, and that person had previously filed a petition for CARE Act proceedings that was unmeritorious or intended to harass or annoy the respondent, the petition is grounds to declare the person a vexatious litigant, as provided. (Section 5975.1.)
- Sets out the respondent's rights, including the right to be represented by counsel at all stages of a CARE proceeding, and requires the court to appoint specified counsel if the respondent does not have their own attorney. (Section 5976.)
- Provides that all CARE Act hearings are presumptively closed to the public. Allows the respondent to demand that the hearings be public or allows them to request the presence of a family member or friend without waiving their right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public. A request by another party to make a hearing public may be granted if the court finds that the public interest clearly outweighs the respondent's privacy interest. (Section 5976.5.)
- Requires, for all CARE Act proceedings, that the judge control all hearings with a view to the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future welfare of the respondent. Except where there is a contested issue of fact or law, requires the proceedings to be conducted in an informal, non-adversarial atmosphere with a view to obtaining the maximum cooperation of the respondent, all persons interested in respondent's welfare, and all other parties, with any provisions that the court may make for the disposition and care of the respondent. (Section 5977.4 (a).)
- Requires that all reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information related to the respondent's health are confidential. Requires that all evaluations and reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court pursuant to CARE Act proceedings are confidential. (Section 5976.5 (e), 5977.4 (a).)
- Upon receipt of a CARE Act petition, requires that the court shall promptly review the petition to see if it makes a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12). (Section 5977 (a)(1).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12), the court shall dismiss without prejudice, subject to 8). (Section 5977 (a)(2).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12), and the petitioner is the county behavioral health agency, the court shall do all of the following: (i) set the matter for an initial appearance; (ii) appoint counsel; (iii) determine if the petition includes all the required information and, if not, order the county to submit a report with the information; and (iv) require notice be provided. (Section 5977 (a)(3)(A).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12), and the petitioner is not the county behavioral health agency, the court shall order the county agency to investigate whether the respondent meets the CARE proceedings criteria and is willing to engage voluntarily with the county, file a written report with the court, and provide notice, as required. (Section 5977 (a)(3)(B).)
- If the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, allows the agency to request up to an additional 30 days to continue to engage and enroll the individual in treatment and services. (Section 5977 (a)(4).)
- Within five days of the receipt of the report in 22c), requires the court to review the report and do one of the following:
- If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, as provided, requires the court to dismiss the matter.
- If the court determines that the county's report supports the petition's prima facie showing that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, and engagement is not effective, requires the court to: (i) set an initial hearing within 14 days; (ii) appoint counsel, unless the respondent has their own counsel; and (iii) provide notice of the hearing, as provided.
- If the court determines that the county's report does not support the petition's prima facie showing that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to dismiss the matter. (Section 5977 (a)(5).)
- At the initial hearing:
- If the petitioner is not present, allows the court to dismiss the matter.
- If the respondent elects not to waive their appearance and is not present, allows the court to conduct the hearing in the respondent's absence if the court makes a finding on the record that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, and conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondent's best interest.
- Requires a county behavioral health agency representative to be present, allows a supporter to be appointed, and allows a tribal representative to attend for a respondent who is a tribal member, as provided, and subject to the respondent's consent.
- If the court finds that there is no reason to believe that the facts stated in the petition are true, requires the court to dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding on the record that the petitioner's filing was not in good faith.
- If the court finds that there is reason to believe that the facts stated in the petition appear to be true, requires the court to order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent and the respondent's counsel and CARE supporter to engage in behavioral health treatment. Requires the court to set a case management hearing within 14 days.
- If the petitioner is other than the county behavioral health director, substitutes the county behavioral health director or their designee for the petitioner, as specified.
- Requires the court to set a hearing on the merits of the petition, which may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance on the petition upon stipulation of the petitioner and respondent and agreement by the court. (Section 5977 (b).)
- At the hearing on the merits:
- If the court finds that the petitioner has not shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, on the record, that the petitioner's filing was not in good faith.
- If the court finds that the petitioner has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondent's counsel, and the supporter to engage in behavioral health treatment and determine if the parties will be able to enter into a CARE agreement. Requires the court to set a case management hearing. Requires notice to the tribe, if applicable. (Section 5977 (c).)
- At the case management hearing:
- If the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, a CARE agreement, requires the court to approve or modify and approve the CARE agreement, stay the matter, and set a progress hearing for 60 days.
- If the court finds that the parties have not entered, and are not likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, requires the court to order a clinical evaluation of the respondent, as provided. Requires the evaluation to address, at a minimum, a clinical diagnosis, whether the respondent has capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication, other information, as provided, and an analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the respondent's recovery and stability. (Section 5977.1 (a).)
- Requires the court to set a clinical evaluation hearing. (Section 5977.1 (c)(1).)
- At the clinical evaluation review hearing:
- Requires the court to consider the evaluation, and other evidence, including calling witnesses, but only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
- If the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, after review of the evaluation and other evidence, that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to order the county behavioral health agency, the respondent, and the respondent's counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan.
- If the court finds, in reviewing the evaluation, that clear and convincing evidence does not support that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to dismiss the petition. (Section 5977.1 (c).)
- At the hearing to review the proposed CARE plan:
- Either or both parties may present a CARE plan.
- Requires the court to adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent. Allows the court to issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding, as provided. These orders are the CARE plan.
- Allows a court to order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent that the court orders medically necessary stabilization medications, prohibits the medication from being forcibly administered and the respondent's failure to comply with a medication order may not result in a penalty, including but not limited to contempt or the accountability measures in 37) – 38).
- Allows for supplemental information to be provided to the court, as provided. (Section 5977.1 (d).)
- The issuance of any orders in 29b) begins the up to one-year CARE program timeline. (Section 5977.1 (e).)
- Requires that a status review hearing occur at least every 60 days during the CARE plan implementation. (Section 5977.2 (a)(1).)
- Requires the petitioner to file with the court, and serve on the respondent and the respondent's counsel and supporter, a report not less than five court days prior to the hearing, with specified information, including progress the respondent has made on the CARE plan, what services and supports in the CARE plan were provided, and what services and supports were not provided, and any recommendations for changes to the services and supports to make the CARE plan more successful.
- Allows the respondent to respond to the report and introduce their own information and recommendations.
- Allows the petitioner, the respondent, or the court to request more frequent reviews as necessary to address changed circumstances. (Section 5977.2 (a)(1)(A) – (b).)
- Requires the court, in the 11th month, to hold a one-year status hearing, which is an evidentiary hearing, to determine if the respondent graduates from the CARE plan or should be reappointed for another year.
- Requires a report by the petitioner before the status conference, as provided. Allows respondent to call witnesses and present evidence.
- Provides that the respondent may be graduated from the CARE program and may be allowed to enter into a voluntary graduation plan with the county. However, such plan may not place additional requirements on the county and is not enforceable, other than a psychiatric advance directive if included.
- If the respondent elects to accept voluntary reappointment to the program, the respondent may request to be re-appointed to the CARE program for up to one additional year, subject to meeting certain criteria and court approval.
- Allows the court to involuntarily reappoint the respondent to the CARE program for up to one year if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that (i) the respondent did not successfully complete the CARE process; (ii) all of the required services and supports were provided to the respondent; (ii) the respondent would benefit from continuation of the CARE process; and (iv) the respondent currently meets the requirements for initial enrollment in the CARE program.
- Provides that a respondent may only be reappointed to the CARE program for up to one additional year. (Section 5977.3.)
- Provides mandatory timeframes, as well as continuances for good cause, throughout the CARE court proceedings. (Section 5977.1.)
- Requires hearings to occur in person unless the court allows a party or a witness to appear remotely. Provides the respondent with the right to be in-person for all hearings. (Section 5977.4 (b).)
- Allows the respondent and the county behavioral health agency to appeal an adverse court determination. (Section 5979 (c).)
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules to implement the CARE court provisions. (Section 5977.4 (c).)
- Allows the court, at any point in the proceedings, if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent, after receiving notice, is not participating in the CARE proceedings, to terminate respondent's participation in the CARE process. Allows the court to make a referral under the LPS Act, as provided. (Section 5979 (a).)
- Requires that, if a respondent was provided timely with all of the services and supports required by the CARE plan, the fact that the respondent failed to successfully complete their CARE plan, including the reasons for that failure: a) is a fact considered by a court in a subsequent hearing under the LPS Act, provided that hearing occurs within six months of termination of the CARE plan; and b) creates a presumption at that hearing that the respondent needs additional interventions beyond the supports and services provided by the CARE plan. Prohibits a respondent's failure to comply with any order from resulting in any penalty outside of this paragraph, including, but not limited to contempt or failure to appear. Prohibits a respondent's failure to comply with a medication order from resulting in any penalty, including under this paragraph. (Section 5979 (a)(3) – (5).)
- Creates a process for penalizing counties or other local government entities that do not comply with CARE court orders. If the presiding judge or designee of the county finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that a local government entity has substantially failed to comply with an order, the presiding judge or designee may impose a fine of up to $1,000 per day for noncompliance, not to exceed $25,000 for each violation. Requires that any fines be deposited in the CARE Act Accountability Fund and used, upon appropriation, by DHCS to support that local government's efforts that will serve individuals who have schizophrenia or other psychotic disorders and who experience, or are at risk of, homelessness, criminal justice involvement, hospitalization, or conservatorship. Allows the presiding judge or designee, if a county is found to be persistently noncompliant, to appoint a special master to secure court-ordered care for the respondent at the county's cost. In determining the application of the remedies available, requires the court to consider whether there are any mitigating circumstances impairing the ability of the county agency or local government entity to fully comply with the CARE Act requirements. (Section 5979 (b).)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with specified groups, to provide optional training and technical resources for volunteer supporters. Requires that a CARE supporter do the following:
- Offer the respondent a flexible and culturally responsive way to maintain autonomy and decisionmaking authority over their own life by developing and maintaining voluntary supports to assist them in understanding, making, communicating, and implementing their own informed choices;
- Strengthen the respondent's capacity to engage in and exercise autonomous decision making and prevent or remove the need to use more restrictive protective mechanisms, such as conservatorship; and
- Assist the respondent with understanding, making, and communicating decisions and expressing preferences throughout the CARE court process. (Section 5980.)
- Allows a respondent to have their supporter be in any meeting, judicial proceedings, status hearing, or communication related to an evaluation; creation of the CARE plan; establishing a psychiatric advance directive; and development of a graduation plan. (Section 5981 (a).)
- Sets forth the duties and limitations of the supporter. Bounds a supporter by all existing obligations and prohibitions otherwise applicable by law that protect people with disabilities and the elderly from fraud, abuse, neglect, coercion, or mistreatment. Prohibits a supporter from being subpoenaed or called to testify against the respondent in any CARE Act proceeding, and provides that the supporter's presence at any meeting, proceeding, or communication does not waive confidentiality or any privilege. (Section 5981 (c) – (e).)
- Requires the Legal Services Trust Fund Commission to provide funding to qualified legal services projects to provide appointed legal counsel in CARE proceedings. Allows the Legal Services Trust Fund Commission to enter into no bid contracts. (Section 5981.5.)
- Sets forth the provisions of the CARE plan, which may only include:
- Specified behavioral health services;
- Medically necessary stabilization medications;
- Housing resources, as provided;
- Social services, as provided; and
- General assistance, as provided. (Section 5982 (a).)
- Requires that CARE participants be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program. If the county behavioral health agency elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined, allows the court to review why not. (Section 5982 (b), (c).)
- Provides that all CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions and policy guidance governing program eligibility, as provided. (Section 5982 (d).)
- Sets forth rules by which a county is responsible for the costs of providing services to CARE participants. (Section 5982 (d) – (f).)
- Requires the Health and Human Services Agency, as provided, to (a) engage an independent, research-based entity to advise on the development of data-driven process and outcome measures to guide the planning, collaboration, reporting, and evaluation of the CARE Act; (b) convene a working group to provide coordination and on-going engagement with, and support collaboration among, relevant state and local partners and other stakeholders throughout the phases of county implementation to support the successful implementation of the CARE Act, including during implementation. (Section 5983 (a).)
- Requires DHCS to provide training and technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies to support the implementation of the CARE Act, including trainings regarding the CARE statutes, CARE plan services and supports, supported decisionmaking, the supporter role, trauma-informed care, elimination of bias, psychiatric advance directives, and data collection. (Section 5983 (b).)
- Requires the Judicial Council, in consultation with others, to provide training and technical assistance to judges to support the implementation of the CARE Act. (Section 5983 (c).)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with others, to provide training to counsel on the CARE statutes, and CARE plan services and supports. (Section 5983 (d).)
- Allows the Health and Human Services Agency and DHCS to enter into exclusive or nonexclusive contracts, or amend existing contracts, on a bid or negotiated basis. (Section 5984 (a).)
- Allows the Health and Human Services Agency and DHCS to implement, interpret, or make specific the CARE Act by means of plan letters, information notices, provider bulletins, or other similar instructions, without taking any further regulatory action. (Section 5984 (b).)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with specified others, to prepare an annual CARE Act report. Requires state or local governmental entities to provide data required by DHCS. Requires DHCS to provide information on the populations served and demographic data, stratified as specified. Requires that the report include, at a minimum, information on the effectiveness of the CARE Act model in improving outcomes and reducing homelessness, criminal justice involvement, conservatorships, and hospitalization of participants. Requires the annual report to examine data through the lens of health equity to identify racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities and inform disparity reduction efforts. (Section 5985.)
- Requires DHCS to report on court data, as specified. (Section 5985 (d).)
- Requires an independent, research-based entity retained by DHCS, in consultation with others, to develop an independent evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act. Requires the independent evaluation to employ statistical research methodology and include a logic model, hypotheses, comparative or quasi-experimental analyses, and conclusions regarding the extent to which the CARE Act model is associated, correlated, and causally related with the performance of the outcome measures included in the annual reports, highlighting racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities, and including causal inference or descriptive analyses regarding the impact of the CARE Act on disparity reduction efforts. Requires DHCS to provide a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act to the Legislature three years after its implementation and a final report five years after implementation. (Section 5986.)
- Requires a health care service plan and an insurance policy, after July 1, 2023, to cover various costs under the CARE program. Sets out requirements for health care services plans and insurance policies, effective July 1, 2023, to cover CARE plans, as provided. (Section 1374.723.)
- Provides immunity to a county, or an employee or agent of a county, for any action by a respondent in the CARE process, except when the act or omission of a county, or the employee or agent of a county, constitutes gross negligence, recklessness, or willful misconduct. (Section 5987.)
- Sets forth that it is the duty of an attorney to do a number of things, including: To maintain inviolate the confidence, and at every peril to himself or herself to preserve the secrets, of his or her client. An attorney may, but is not required to, reveal confidential information relating to the representation of a client to the extent that the attorney reasonably believes the disclosure is necessary to prevent a criminal act that the attorney reasonably believes is likely to result in death of, or substantial bodily harm to, an individual. (Business and Professions Code Section 6068 (e).)
- Provides the following grounds for which a court may grant a continuance upon an affirmative showing of good cause requiring the continuance. Circumstances that may indicate good cause include:
- The unavailability of an essential lay or expert witness because of death, illness, or other excusable circumstances;
- The unavailability of a party because of death, illness, or other excusable circumstances;
- The unavailability of trial counsel because of death, illness, or other excusable circumstances;
- The substitution of trial counsel, but only where there is an affirmative showing that the substitution is required in the interests of justice;
- The addition of a new party if:
- The new party has not had a reasonable opportunity to conduct discovery and prepare for trial; or
- The other parties have not had a reasonable opportunity to conduct discovery and prepare for trial in regard to the new party's involvement in the case;
- A party's excused inability to obtain essential testimony, documents, or other material evidence despite diligent efforts; or
- A significant, unanticipated change in the status of the case as a result of which the case is not ready for trial. (Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This author-sponsored bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings, including the reason for any continuance or dismissal, to specified friends and family members of the respondent without that person’s consent. The bill provides an exception to the notice requirement when the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings that providing notice likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. As proposed to be amended, the bill also prohibits a notice from including protected patient information and specifies what information can be provided about a continuance or dismissal. According to the author:
SB 42 aims to improve communication and openness by streamlining the notification procedures during CARE proceedings. In order for all parties to stay informed, this entails providing thorough justifications for the CARE court procedures' continuances and dismissals. This bill is required because it has been recognized that there is a need for better organized communication between the courts and the parties involved in CARE actions, particularly when there is a close personal relationship between the original petitioner and the respondent. The measure promotes unambiguous, continuous notices and explanations for court proceedings to guarantee that individuals who start the CARE procedure are kept informed at all times.
Background – CARE Proceedings. SB 1338 (Umberg) Chap. 319, Stats. 2022 enacted the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act. The Act was intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services.
The CARE Act is not yet fully implemented in the state. The CARE Act was required to be implemented by Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, San Francisco, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties by October 1, 2023, but not in the remaining counties by December 1, 2024. (Furthermore, under certain circumstances the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) can issue a one-time delay implementation to a specific county until December 1, 2025.) Finally the CARE Act only becomes operative upon DHCS, in consultation with county stakeholders, developing a CARE Act allocation to provide state financial assistance to counties to implement the CARE process. DHCS is required to issue a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act by due by December 31, 2026; and to issue a final report by December 31, 2028.
How a CARE proceeding is designed to work. A central feature of the CARE Act are “CARE Courts,” intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services. These might include court-ordered stabilization medications, wellness and recovery support, help with finding social services and housing. “Court-ordered stabilization medication” is distinct from involuntary medication in that it cannot be forcibly administered. However, failure of a person to voluntarily participate in the medication treatment could lead to their referral to an LPS conservatorship. (Section 5979 (a)(3) – (5).)
CARE Court focuses on the most severely mentally ill, including those with schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders. As noted, while the overall purpose of the CARE Act is to provide essential services to the most severely ill, it also is supposed to preserve self-determination to the greatest extent possible. The California Health and Human Services Agency describes CARE Court as “an upstream diversion to prevent more restrictive conservatorships or incarceration.” (“CARE Court FAQ,” at chhs.ca.gov.) CARE Court could be an “appropriate next step” after someone has been placed on a 72-hour hold (“5150”) or a 14-day hold (“5250”), an arrest, or those who can otherwise be safely diverted from a criminal proceeding.
The Process: The first step in the CARE Court process is a “referral” – that is, a petition to the court by a family member, mental health provider, or first responder, among others. The Court then orders a clinical evaluation and appoints both a Public Defender and a “CARE Supporter,” the person assigned to help the individual understand the process so as to provide the individual with as much autonomy as is feasible. If the Court finds that the person meets the criteria for the program, then the Court orders the individual, CARE Supporter, and county behavioral health agency to develop a CARE Plan. The Court then reviews the Plan, and if it approves it, the Plan becomes a court order lasting up to 12 months. In addition to the county behavioral care team, CARE Supporter, and individual participating in the prescribed treatment plan, the CARE team also will develop a Psychiatric Advance Directive which can be used for future crisis, by providing necessary background information by the individual’s history. Eventually, the individual “graduates” from the CARE Court, although they may be provided with ongoing services, including assistance with finding housing. “Graduation” from CARE is designed to occur with a person in need of CARE services, including those who are mentally ill and unhoused, obtaining housing of some sort. Housing is a critical component of CARE Court– i.e. stable housing that allows the person to stay connected with treatment, if needed.
Criticism of the CARE Act. While CARE Court and the CARE Act was championed by Governor Newsom and largely popular among the Legislature, many civil liberties groups expressed serious concerns about the model, its cost, and its impact on vulnerable communities. ACLU California Action summarizes some of those concerns in its letter of opposition to last year’s bill by the author of this bill, SB 35 (Chap. 283, Stats. 2023) that, among other things, relaxed the criteria for who can be appointed as counsel for the subject of the proceeding and authorized a “court-appointed commissioner or other subordinate judicial officer” to preside over proceedings in lieu of a superior court judge:
Proponents of CARE Court rely on false premises – that people are rejecting offers of housing; that access to behavioral health services based on one evaluation will solve a person’s mental health, disabilities; and, that a civil court is the least restrictive setting. In reality, low-cost housing stock is at a near record low and affordable housing options have years-long waitlists of people desperate for a home. Moreover, recovery is primarily found to be successful when accessible, affordable housing is combined with community-based treatment settings, surrounded by peers, and provided through voluntary, accessible means. When a person is faced with defending their case before a judge without agency over their own care, the least restrictive setting is not court.
CARE Court is also a costly mistake. Once implemented, this court system is likely to cost in excess of billions of dollars, as estimated by the Assembly Appropriations Committee. This state mandate will fail to deliver on what it promises to accomplish and will divert resources from other urgently needed programs. SB 35 will increase this cost further by increasing the amount of petitions, even though counties already report they do not have enough resources to implement the CARE Court program.
. . . By targeting people with schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders, studies show Black, Indigenous and People of Color will disproportionately experience the harms that CARE Court poses.234 SB 35 will increase CARE Court’s exploitation of poor people who need mental health care. It is those people with low incomes and/or from communities of color who will be most victim to the chilling effects CARE Court will have in preventing people from seeking treatment and care.
Instead of expanding access to CARE Court, the Legislature should fund more community-based mental health care treatment centers, increase housing funds for extremely low-income Californians, and decrease the presence of law enforcement and court involvement in mental health crises.
This bill is yet another modification to the CARE Act during its initial stage of implementation, but prior to its full implementation and evaluation. The bill in print requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings to specified associates and family members, namely (1) a person with whom the respondent resides; (2) a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent; or (3) an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. It is unclear whether there could be more than one “original petitioner” in one CARE proceeding (if multiple family members submitted a petition, for example). If so, the bill would seem to require that all of them be notified. Under current law, a person who “stands in loco parentis to the respondent” may file a petition to initiate CARE proceedings. The bill provides that such a person is entitled to ongoing notice. Neither the bill in print, nor current law (Section 5974 (b) of the CARE Act, the place the term “loco parentis” refers to a relationship between adults) defines what it means to be “in loco parentis” with a person who is the respondent in a CARE Act proceeding and who, by definition, must be over the age of 18 years. (See Section 5972 (a).)
The bill requires that the court must provide “ongoing notice” to these persons throughout the CARE proceedings if they are an “original petitioner.” Any individual who meets the definition of “original petitioner” is entitled to notice of all CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or a case is dismissed. The bill in print has an exception to the notification requirement in a case where the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent to do so. If that were the case, it understandably could be distressing to the respondent for the original petitioner to have access to their sensitive mental health information and information about their CARE proceedings.
Newly registered opposition to the bill points out that, even with this exception, the bill could lead to the inappropriate and unlawful disclosure of confidential medical information, among other things if that information were disclosed in a notice without the respondent’s consent.
Author’s amendments. In response to these concerns, the author wisely proposes to amend the bill to specify that any ongoing notice that is provided cannot disclose any patient information that is protected under HIPAA, state confidentiality laws, or the LPS Act, without the respondent’s consent. The amendments also specify what information can be provided in the notices. Specifically, a notice of a continuance can only provide general information about the dismissal, such as the absence of the respondent or another grounds for a continuance that is specified in rules of court that govern grounds for a continuance of a court hearing. Notice of a dismissal can provide one of the bases for dismissal that is found in existing law, including the failure to establish at the initial hearing that the person meets the program’s criteria (Section 5977.1); that the person refuses to participate (Section 5979); or that the person graduates (Section 5977.3). In order to address these issues, the bill will be amended to read as follows:
(ii) Unless the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice of proceedings to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings,including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed. including notice of when a continuance is granted or when a case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, granted, the notice shall provide a general reason for the continuance or dismissal. continuance, including the absence of the respondent or one of the grounds pursuant to Rule 3.1332 of the California Rules of Court. If a case is dismissed, the notice shall specify whether the dismissal was granted pursuant to a reason specified in Section 5977.1, 5977.3, or 5979. A notice pursuant to this clause shall not disclose any patient information that is protected under the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-191), the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (Part 2.6 (commencing with Section 56) of Division 1 of the Civil Code), or this act, without the respondent’s consent.
Future amendments? Given the history of this Committee’s involvement in, and concerns about, the CARE Act, the author is strongly encouraged to keep the Committee informed of any future amendments to the bill.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill (FASMI) writes the following to explain the need for, and their support of, the bill:
My group FASMI includes many family members of seriously mentally ill people. We want them to get help and need to be involved in their care because they often aren’t even aware that they are ill. We know their history and love them. Nevertheless we are often shut out of legal proceedings that have a chance of getting help for our loved ones. This has happened to me: county officials tried to prevent me from seeing my late loved one or getting her medical information, and rarely was I notified of hearings even when my loved one wanted me to know. We supported the CARE Court bill because we hoped it would be more effective than Assisted Outpatient Treatment. A big reason CARE Court is better is that it has a role for families. This bill is a step towards making that role meaningful.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Disability Rights California writes that the bill in print may violate privacy laws:
SB 42 violates state and federal medical privacy laws by requiring courts to provide to third parties, without the respondent’s consent, ongoing notice of CARE proceedings and the reason for continuance or dismissal. The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) defines protected health information as “individually identifiable health information.” . . . Ongoing notice and reasons for continuance or dismissal of CARE proceedings are individually identifiable health information pertaining to mental health assessment and treatment and qualify as “protected health information” under HIPAA. Under state and federal medical privacy laws, this information can only be provided with the patient’s consent. . . . SB 42 violates state and federal medical privacy laws by requiring courts provide protected health information to specified third parties without the respondent’s consent.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Alameda County Families Advocating for the Seriously Mentally Ill
California Professional Firefighters
One individual
Opposition
Cal Voices
California Youth Empowerment Network
Disability Rights California
Mental Health America of California
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 42
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2024
PROPOSED CONSENT (As Proposed to be Amended)
SENATE VOTE: NOT RELEVANT
SUBJECT: COMMUNITY ASSISTANCE, RECOVERY, AND EMPOWERMENT (CARE) COURT PROGRAM: NOTICE TO ORIGINAL PETITIONER
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD A COURT IN A CARE PROCEEDING BE REQUIRED, AS A GENERAL RULE, TO PROVIDE ONGOING NOTICE ABOUT THE PROCEEDINGS, INCLUDING THE REASON FOR A CONTINUANCE OR DISMISSAL, TO SPECIFIED FAMILY MEMBERS OF THE RESPONDENT WITHOUT THE RESPONDENT’S CONSENT?
- SHOULD THERE BE AN EXCEPTION TO THE RULE WHEN THE COURT DETERMINES, AT ANY POINT IN THE PROCEEDINGS, THAT PROVIDING SUCH NOTICE LIKELY WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO THE TREATMENT OR WELL-BEING OF THE RESPONDENT?
SYNOPSIS
SB 1338 (Umberg) Chap. 319, Stats. 2022 enacted the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act. The CARE Act was intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services. The CARE Act is not yet fully implemented in the state. DHCS is required to issue a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act by due by December 31, 2026; and to issue a final report by December 31, 2028.
Like a number of other recent bills, this bill modifies the CARE Act during its initial stage of implementation, but prior to its full implementation and evaluation. The bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings to specified associates and family members, namely (1) a person with whom the respondent resides; (2) a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent; or (3) an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. The respondent is not required to consent to such notice being provided. In fact, the bill in print requires notice to be provided over the objection of the respondent. The author wisely proposes to amend the bill to provide a mechanism for the court—on its own motion, or upon motion of the respondent—to disapprove or discontinue notice of CARE proceedings to the original petitioner when it finds that such notice likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. The amendments are included in the SUMMARY of the bill, below, and explained in the analysis. Gutted and amended just recently, this author-sponsored bill has no support or opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings, including the reason for a continuance or dismissal, to specified family members of the respondent without that person’s consent, unless the court determines, either upon its own motion, or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that, if an original petitioner meets the criteria of 4), the court shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed.
- As an exception to 1), authorizes the court, when it determines, either upon its own motion, or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent to continue such notice.
- Requires that, if a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal in a CARE proceeding.
- Limits the mandates above to an original petitioner who is one the following:
- A person with whom the respondent resides.
- A spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent or an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the LPS Act to end inappropriate, indefinite, and involuntary commitment of mentally disordered persons, developmentally disabled persons, and persons impaired by chronic alcoholism, and to provide prompt evaluation and treatment of those with mental health disorders or impaired by chronic alcoholism. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 5000 et seq. All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Defines, as a basis for involuntary commitment under the LPS Act, “grave disability” as a condition in which a person, as a result of a mental disorder, or impairment by chronic alcoholism, is unable to provide for their basic personal needs for food, clothing, or shelter, or is found to be mentally incompetent under the Penal Code. Excludes from that definition persons with intellectual disabilities by reason of that disability alone. (Section 5008 (h).)
- Provides that if a person is gravely disabled as a result of mental illness, or a danger to self or others, then a peace officer, staff of a designated treatment facility or crisis team, or other professional person designated by the county, may, upon probable cause, take that person into custody for a period of up to 72 hours for assessment, evaluation, crisis intervention, or placement in a designated treatment facility. (Section 5150.)
- Allows a person who has been detained for 72 hours to be detained for up to 14 days of intensive treatment if the person continues to pose a danger to self or others, or to be gravely disabled, and the person has been unwilling or unable to accept voluntary treatment. (Section 5250.)
- Allows a person to be held at the expiration of a 14-day period of intensive treatment for further intensive treatment of up to 14 days if, during the detention period, a person threatened or attempted to take their own life or was detained because they threatened or attempted to their own life and continues to present an imminent threat of taking their own life and other specified conditions. (Section 5260.)
- Allows a person who has been detained for 14 days of intensive treatment to be detained for up to 30 additional days of intensive treatment if the person remains gravely disabled and is unwilling or unable to voluntarily accept treatment. (Section 5270.15.)
- Requires a certification review hearing to be held within four days of the date on which a person is certified for a 14-day period of intensive treatment or 30 additional days of intensive treatment unless judicial review has been requested or a postponement is requested by a person or their attorney or advocate. (Section 5256.)
- Provides every person detained by certification for intensive treatment with a right to a hearing by writ of habeas corpus for their release. Enumerates specified requirements and procedures for judicial review. (Sections 5275, 5276.)
- Allows the professional person in charge of a facility providing 72-hour, 14-day, or 30-day treatment to recommend an LPS conservatorship to the county conservatorship investigator for a person who is gravely disabled and is unwilling or unable to voluntarily accept treatment; and requires the conservatorship investigator, if they concur with the recommendation, to petition the superior court to establish an LPS conservatorship. Provides that a person for whom an LPS conservatorship is sought has the right to demand a court or jury trial on the issue of whether they are gravely disabled. (Section 5350, et seq.)
- Establishes the CARE Act, which must be implemented by Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, San Francisco, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties by October 1, 2023, and the remaining counties by December 1, 2024, subject to delays based on a state or local emergency, or discretionary approval by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), up until December 1, 2025. Provides that the CARE Act only becomes operative upon DHCS, in consultation with county stakeholders, developing a CARE Act allocation to provide state financial assistance to counties to implement the CARE process. (Section 5970, et seq.)
- Defines, for purposes of the CARE Act, certain terms, including:
- "CARE agreement" is a voluntary settlement agreement, which includes the same elements as a CARE plan.
- "CARE plan" is an individualized, appropriate range of services and supports consisting of behavioral health care, stabilization medications, housing, and other supportive services, as provided.
- "Graduation plan" is a voluntary agreement entered into by the parties at the end of the CARE program that includes a strategy to support a successful transition out of court jurisdiction and may include a psychiatric advance directive. A graduation plan includes the same elements as a CARE plan to support the respondent in accessing services and supports. A graduation plan may not place additional requirements on the local government entities and is not enforceable by the court.
- "Parties" are the person who file the petition, respondent and the county behavioral health agency, along with other parties that the court may add if they are providing services to the respondent.
- "Petitioner" is the entity who files the CARE Act petition, but if other than the county behavioral health agency, the court is required, at the initial hearing, to substitute the director of county behavioral health agency or their designee as the petitioner, limiting the initial petitioner's rights to potentially receiving ongoing notice of the proceedings, and the right to make a statement at the hearing on the merits of the petition, with broader participation rights only if the respondent consents.
- "Respondent" is the person who is subject to the petition for the CARE process.
- "Supporter" is an adult who assists the respondent, which may include supporting the person to understand, make, communicate, implement, or act on their own life decisions during the CARE process, including a CARE agreement, a CARE plan, and developing a graduation plan. (Section 5971.)
- Provides that a respondent may qualify for the CARE process only if all of the following criteria are met:
- The person is 18 years of age or older.
- The person is currently experiencing a severe mental illness, as defined, and has a diagnosis identified in the disorder class: schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorders, as defined in the most current version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Specifically exempts specified other conditions or disorders.
- The person is not clinically stabilized in on-going voluntary treatment.
- At least one of the following is true:
- The person is unlikely to survive safely in the community without supervision and the person's condition is substantially deteriorating.
- The person is in need of services and supports in order to prevent a relapse or deterioration that would be likely to result in grave disability or serious harm to the person or to others.
- Participation in a CARE plan or agreement would be the least restrictive alternative necessary to ensure the person's recovery and stability.
- It is likely that the person will benefit from participation in a CARE plan or agreement. (Section 5972.)
- Provides venue provisions for where CARE Act proceedings may be brought. (Section 5973.)
- Allows a petition to initiate a CARE proceeding to be brought by one of the following adults:
- A person with whom the respondent resides or a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent of the respondent, or another individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent.
- The director of a hospital, or their designee, in which the respondent is hospitalized, or the director of a public or charitable organization, agency, or home, or their designee, that is currently, or within the previous 30 days, providing behavioral health services to the respondent or in whose institution the respondent resides.
- A licensed behavioral health professional, or their designee, who is treating, or has been treating within the last 30 days, the respondent for a mental illness.
- A first responder, including a peace officer, firefighter, paramedic, emergency medical technician, mobile crisis response worker, or homeless outreach worker who has had repeated interactions with the respondent in the form of multiple arrests, multiple detentions, as provided, multiple attempts to engage the respondent in voluntary treatment or other repeated efforts to aid the respondent in obtaining professional assistance.
- The public guardian or public conservator, or their designee (and a respondent may be referred from conservatorship proceedings).
- The director of a county behavioral health agency of the county in which the respondent reside or is present (and a respondent may be referred from assisted outpatient treatment proceedings).
- The director of the county Adult Protective Services or their designee.
- The director of a California Indian health services program, California tribal behavioral health department, or their designee.
- The judge of a tribal court that is located in California, or their designee.
- The respondent. (Section 5974.)
- Allows a court, if a criminal defendant is found to be mentally incompetent and ineligible for a diversion, to refer the defendant to the CARE program, as provided. (Penal Code Section 1370.1 (b)(1)(D)(iv).)
- Requires the CARE petition, which must be developed as a mandatory form by the Judicial Council (along with other forms necessary for the CARE process) and must be signed under penalty of perjury, to include, among other things:
- The name of the respondent, their address, if known, and the petitioner's relationship with the respondent.
- Facts that support petitioner's allegation that the respondent meets the criteria in 12).
- Either of the following:
- An affidavit of a licensed behavioral health professional stating that the health professional or their designee has examined the respondent within 60 days of the submission of the petition, or has made multiple attempts to examine, but has not been successful in eliciting the cooperation of the respondent to submit to an examination, within 60 days of submission of the petition, and that the licensed behavioral health professional had determined that the respondent meets, or has reason to believe, explained with specificity in the affidavit, that the respondent meets, the diagnostic criteria for CARE proceedings.
- Evidence that the respondent was detained for a minimum of two intensive treatments pursuant to the Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) Act, the most recent of which must be no longer ago than 60 days from the date of the petition. (Section 5975.)
- Provides that if a person other than the respondent files a petition for CARE Act proceedings that is unmeritorious or intended to harass or annoy the respondent, and that person had previously filed a petition for CARE Act proceedings that was unmeritorious or intended to harass or annoy the respondent, the petition is grounds to declare the person a vexatious litigant, as provided. (Section 5975.1.)
- Sets out the respondent's rights, including the right to be represented by counsel at all stages of a CARE proceeding, and requires the court to appoint specified counsel if the respondent does not have their own attorney. (Section 5976.)
- Provides that all CARE Act hearings are presumptively closed to the public. Allows the respondent to demand that the hearings be public or allows them to request the presence of a family member or friend without waiving their right to keep the hearing closed to the rest of the public. A request by another party to make a hearing public may be granted if the court finds that the public interest clearly outweighs the respondent's privacy interest. (Section 5976.5.)
- Requires, for all CARE Act proceedings, that the judge control all hearings with a view to the expeditious and effective ascertainment of the jurisdictional facts and the ascertainment of all information relative to the present condition and future welfare of the respondent. Except where there is a contested issue of fact or law, requires the proceedings to be conducted in an informal, non-adversarial atmosphere with a view to obtaining the maximum cooperation of the respondent, all persons interested in respondent's welfare, and all other parties, with any provisions that the court may make for the disposition and care of the respondent. (Section 5977.4 (a).)
- Requires that all reports, evaluations, diagnoses, or other information related to the respondent's health are confidential. Requires that all evaluations and reports, documents, and filings submitted to the court pursuant to CARE Act proceedings are confidential. (Section 5976.5 (e), 5977.4 (a).)
- Upon receipt of a CARE Act petition, requires that the court shall promptly review the petition to see if it makes a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12). (Section 5977 (a)(1).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has not made a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12), the court shall dismiss without prejudice, subject to 8). (Section 5977 (a)(2).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12), and the petitioner is the county behavioral health agency, the court shall do all of the following: (i) set the matter for an initial appearance; (ii) appoint counsel; (iii) determine if the petition includes all the required information and, if not, order the county to submit a report with the information; and (iv) require notice be provided. (Section 5977 (a)(3)(A).)
- If the court finds the petitioner has made a prima facie showing that the respondent is or may be a person described in 12), and the petitioner is not the county behavioral health agency, the court shall order the county agency to investigate whether the respondent meets the CARE proceedings criteria and is willing to engage voluntarily with the county, file a written report with the court, and provide notice, as required. (Section 5977 (a)(3)(B).)
- If the county agency is making progress to engage the respondent, allows the agency to request up to an additional 30 days to continue to engage and enroll the individual in treatment and services. (Section 5977 (a)(4).)
- Within five days of the receipt of the report in 22c), requires the court to review the report and do one of the following:
- If the court determines that voluntary engagement with the respondent is effective, as provided, requires the court to dismiss the matter.
- If the court determines that the county's report supports the petition's prima facie showing that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, and engagement is not effective, requires the court to: (i) set an initial hearing within 14 days; (ii) appoint counsel, unless the respondent has their own counsel; and (iii) provide notice of the hearing, as provided.
- If the court determines that the county's report does not support the petition's prima facie showing that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to dismiss the matter. (Section 5977 (a)(5).)
- At the initial hearing:
- If the petitioner is not present, allows the court to dismiss the matter.
- If the respondent elects not to waive their appearance and is not present, allows the court to conduct the hearing in the respondent's absence if the court makes a finding on the record that reasonable attempts to elicit the attendance of the respondent have failed, and conducting the hearing without the participation or presence of the respondent would be in the respondent's best interest.
- Requires a county behavioral health agency representative to be present, allows a supporter to be appointed, and allows a tribal representative to attend for a respondent who is a tribal member, as provided, and subject to the respondent's consent.
- If the court finds that there is no reason to believe that the facts stated in the petition are true, requires the court to dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding on the record that the petitioner's filing was not in good faith.
- If the court finds that there is reason to believe that the facts stated in the petition appear to be true, requires the court to order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent and the respondent's counsel and CARE supporter to engage in behavioral health treatment. Requires the court to set a case management hearing within 14 days.
- If the petitioner is other than the county behavioral health director, substitutes the county behavioral health director or their designee for the petitioner, as specified.
- Requires the court to set a hearing on the merits of the petition, which may be conducted concurrently with the initial appearance on the petition upon stipulation of the petitioner and respondent and agreement by the court. (Section 5977 (b).)
- At the hearing on the merits:
- If the court finds that the petitioner has not shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to dismiss the case without prejudice, unless the court makes a finding, on the record, that the petitioner's filing was not in good faith.
- If the court finds that the petitioner has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to order the county behavioral health agency to work with the respondent, the respondent's counsel, and the supporter to engage in behavioral health treatment and determine if the parties will be able to enter into a CARE agreement. Requires the court to set a case management hearing. Requires notice to the tribe, if applicable. (Section 5977 (c).)
- At the case management hearing:
- If the parties have entered, or are likely to enter, a CARE agreement, requires the court to approve or modify and approve the CARE agreement, stay the matter, and set a progress hearing for 60 days.
- If the court finds that the parties have not entered, and are not likely to enter, into a CARE agreement, requires the court to order a clinical evaluation of the respondent, as provided. Requires the evaluation to address, at a minimum, a clinical diagnosis, whether the respondent has capacity to give informed consent regarding psychotropic medication, other information, as provided, and an analysis of recommended services, programs, housing, medications, and interventions that support the respondent's recovery and stability. (Section 5977.1 (a).)
- Requires the court to set a clinical evaluation hearing. (Section 5977.1 (c)(1).)
- At the clinical evaluation review hearing:
- Requires the court to consider the evaluation, and other evidence, including calling witnesses, but only relevant and admissible evidence that fully complies with the rules of evidence may be considered by the court.
- If the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, after review of the evaluation and other evidence, that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to order the county behavioral health agency, the respondent, and the respondent's counsel and supporter to jointly develop a CARE plan.
- If the court finds, in reviewing the evaluation, that clear and convincing evidence does not support that the respondent meets the CARE criteria, requires the court to dismiss the petition. (Section 5977.1 (c).)
- At the hearing to review the proposed CARE plan:
- Either or both parties may present a CARE plan.
- Requires the court to adopt the elements of a CARE plan that support the recovery and stability of the respondent. Allows the court to issue any orders necessary to support the respondent in accessing appropriate services and supports, including prioritization for those services and supports, subject to applicable laws and available funding, as provided. These orders are the CARE plan.
- Allows a court to order medication if it finds, upon review of the court-ordered evaluation and hearing from the parties that, by clear and convincing evidence, the respondent lacks the capacity to give informed consent to the administration of medically necessary stabilization medication. To the extent that the court orders medically necessary stabilization medications, prohibits the medication from being forcibly administered and the respondent's failure to comply with a medication order may not result in a penalty, including but not limited to contempt or the accountability measures in 37) – 38).
- Allows for supplemental information to be provided to the court, as provided. (Section 5977.1 (d).)
- The issuance of any orders in 29b) begins the up to one-year CARE program timeline. (Section 5977.1 (e).)
- Requires that a status review hearing occur at least every 60 days during the CARE plan implementation. (Section 5977.2 (a)(1).)
- Requires the petitioner to file with the court, and serve on the respondent and the respondent's counsel and supporter, a report not less than five court days prior to the hearing, with specified information, including progress the respondent has made on the CARE plan, what services and supports in the CARE plan were provided, and what services and supports were not provided, and any recommendations for changes to the services and supports to make the CARE plan more successful.
- Allows the respondent to respond to the report and introduce their own information and recommendations.
- Allows the petitioner, the respondent, or the court to request more frequent reviews as necessary to address changed circumstances. (Section 5977.2 (a)(1)(A) – (b).)
- Requires the court, in the 11th month, to hold a one-year status hearing, which is an evidentiary hearing, to determine if the respondent graduates from the CARE plan or should be reappointed for another year.
- Requires a report by the petitioner before the status conference, as provided. Allows respondent to call witnesses and present evidence.
- Provides that the respondent may be graduated from the CARE program and may be allowed to enter into a voluntary graduation plan with the county. However, such plan may not place additional requirements on the county and is not enforceable, other than a psychiatric advance directive if included.
- If the respondent elects to accept voluntary reappointment to the program, the respondent may request to be re-appointed to the CARE program for up to one additional year, subject to meeting certain criteria and court approval.
- Allows the court to involuntarily reappoint the respondent to the CARE program for up to one year if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that (i) the respondent did not successfully complete the CARE process; (ii) all of the required services and supports were provided to the respondent; (ii) the respondent would benefit from continuation of the CARE process; and (iv) the respondent currently meets the requirements for initial enrollment in the CARE program.
- Provides that a respondent may only be reappointed to the CARE program for up to one additional year. (Section 5977.3.)
- Provides mandatory timeframes, as well as continuances for good cause, throughout the CARE court proceedings. (Section 5977.1.)
- Requires hearings to occur in person unless the court allows a party or a witness to appear remotely. Provides the respondent with the right to be in-person for all hearings. (Section 5977.4 (b).)
- Allows the respondent and the county behavioral health agency to appeal an adverse court determination. (Section 5979 (c).)
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules to implement the CARE court provisions. (Section 5977.4 (c).)
- Allows the court, at any point in the proceedings, if it determines, by clear and convincing evidence, that the respondent, after receiving notice, is not participating in the CARE proceedings, to terminate respondent's participation in the CARE process. Allows the court to make a referral under the LPS Act, as provided. (Section 5979 (a).)
- Requires that, if a respondent was provided timely with all of the services and supports required by the CARE plan, the fact that the respondent failed to successfully complete their CARE plan, including the reasons for that failure: a) is a fact considered by a court in a subsequent hearing under the LPS Act, provided that hearing occurs within six months of termination of the CARE plan; and b) creates a presumption at that hearing that the respondent needs additional interventions beyond the supports and services provided by the CARE plan. Prohibits a respondent's failure to comply with any order from resulting in any penalty outside of this paragraph, including, but not limited to contempt or failure to appear. Prohibits a respondent's failure to comply with a medication order from resulting in any penalty, including under this paragraph. (Section 5979 (a)(3) – (5).)
- Creates a process for penalizing counties or other local government entities that do not comply with CARE court orders. If the presiding judge or designee of the county finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that a local government entity has substantially failed to comply with an order, the presiding judge or designee may impose a fine of up to $1,000 per day for noncompliance, not to exceed $25,000 for each violation. Requires that any fines be deposited in the CARE Act Accountability Fund and used, upon appropriation, by DHCS to support that local government's efforts that will serve individuals who have schizophrenia or other psychotic disorders and who experience, or are at risk of, homelessness, criminal justice involvement, hospitalization, or conservatorship. Allows the presiding judge or designee, if a county is found to be persistently noncompliant, to appoint a special master to secure court-ordered care for the respondent at the county's cost. In determining the application of the remedies available, requires the court to consider whether there are any mitigating circumstances impairing the ability of the county agency or local government entity to fully comply with the CARE Act requirements. (Section 5979 (b).)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with specified groups, to provide optional training and technical resources for volunteer supporters. Requires that a CARE supporter do the following:
- Offer the respondent a flexible and culturally responsive way to maintain autonomy and decisionmaking authority over their own life by developing and maintaining voluntary supports to assist them in understanding, making, communicating, and implementing their own informed choices;
- Strengthen the respondent's capacity to engage in and exercise autonomous decision making and prevent or remove the need to use more restrictive protective mechanisms, such as conservatorship; and
- Assist the respondent with understanding, making, and communicating decisions and expressing preferences throughout the CARE court process. (Section 5980.)
- Allows a respondent to have their supporter be in any meeting, judicial proceedings, status hearing, or communication related to an evaluation; creation of the CARE plan; establishing a psychiatric advance directive; and development of a graduation plan. (Section 5981 (a).)
- Sets forth the duties and limitations of the supporter. Bounds a supporter by all existing obligations and prohibitions otherwise applicable by law that protect people with disabilities and the elderly from fraud, abuse, neglect, coercion, or mistreatment. Prohibits a supporter from being subpoenaed or called to testify against the respondent in any CARE Act proceeding, and provides that the supporter's presence at any meeting, proceeding, or communication does not waive confidentiality or any privilege. (Section 5981 (c) – (e).)
- Requires the Legal Services Trust Fund Commission to provide funding to qualified legal services projects to provide appointed legal counsel in CARE proceedings. Allows the Legal Services Trust Fund Commission to enter into no bid contracts. (Section 5981.5.)
- Sets forth the provisions of the CARE plan, which may only include:
- Specified behavioral health services;
- Medically necessary stabilization medications;
- Housing resources, as provided;
- Social services, as provided; and
- General assistance, as provided. (Section 5982 (a).)
- Requires that CARE participants be prioritized for any appropriate bridge housing funded by the Behavioral Health Bridge Housing program. If the county behavioral health agency elects not to enroll the respondent into a full service partnership, as defined, allows the court to review why not. (Section 5982 (b), (c).)
- Provides that all CARE plan services and supports ordered by the court are subject to available funding and all applicable federal and state statutes, regulations, contractual provisions and policy guidance governing program eligibility, as provided. (Section 5982 (d).)
- Sets forth rules by which a county is responsible for the costs of providing services to CARE participants. (Section 5982 (d) – (f).)
- Requires the Health and Human Services Agency, as provided, to (a) engage an independent, research-based entity to advise on the development of data-driven process and outcome measures to guide the planning, collaboration, reporting, and evaluation of the CARE Act; (b) convene a working group to provide coordination and on-going engagement with, and support collaboration among, relevant state and local partners and other stakeholders throughout the phases of county implementation to support the successful implementation of the CARE Act, including during implementation. (Section 5983 (a).)
- Requires DHCS to provide training and technical assistance to county behavioral health agencies to support the implementation of the CARE Act, including trainings regarding the CARE statutes, CARE plan services and supports, supported decisionmaking, the supporter role, trauma-informed care, elimination of bias, psychiatric advance directives, and data collection. (Section 5983 (b).)
- Requires the Judicial Council, in consultation with others, to provide training and technical assistance to judges to support the implementation of the CARE Act. (Section 5983 (c).)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with others, to provide training to counsel on the CARE statutes, and CARE plan services and supports. (Section 5983 (d).)
- Allows the Health and Human Services Agency and DHCS to enter into exclusive or nonexclusive contracts, or amend existing contracts, on a bid or negotiated basis. (Section 5984 (a).)
- Allows the Health and Human Services Agency and DHCS to implement, interpret, or make specific the CARE Act by means of plan letters, information notices, provider bulletins, or other similar instructions, without taking any further regulatory action. (Section 5984 (b).)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with specified others, to prepare an annual CARE Act report. Requires state or local governmental entities to provide data required by DHCS. Requires DHCS to provide information on the populations served and demographic data, stratified as specified. Requires that the report include, at a minimum, information on the effectiveness of the CARE Act model in improving outcomes and reducing homelessness, criminal justice involvement, conservatorships, and hospitalization of participants. Requires the annual report to examine data through the lens of health equity to identify racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities and inform disparity reduction efforts. (Section 5985.)
- Requires DHCS to report on court data, as specified. (Section 5985 (d).)
- Requires an independent, research-based entity retained by DHCS, in consultation with others, to develop an independent evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act. Requires the independent evaluation to employ statistical research methodology and include a logic model, hypotheses, comparative or quasi-experimental analyses, and conclusions regarding the extent to which the CARE Act model is associated, correlated, and causally related with the performance of the outcome measures included in the annual reports, highlighting racial, ethnic, and other demographic disparities, and including causal inference or descriptive analyses regarding the impact of the CARE Act on disparity reduction efforts. Requires DHCS to provide a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act to the Legislature three years after its implementation and a final report five years after implementation. (Section 5986.)
- Requires a health care service plan and an insurance policy, after July 1, 2023, to cover various costs under the CARE program. Sets out requirements for health care services plans and insurance policies, effective July 1, 2023, to cover CARE plans, as provided. (Section 1374.723.)
- Provides immunity to a county, or an employee or agent of a county, for any action by a respondent in the CARE process, except when the act or omission of a county, or the employee or agent of a county, constitutes gross negligence, recklessness, or willful misconduct. (Section 5987.)
- Sets forth that it is the duty of an attorney to do a number of things, including: To maintain inviolate the confidence, and at every peril to himself or herself to preserve the secrets, of his or her client. An attorney may, but is not required to, reveal confidential information relating to the representation of a client to the extent that the attorney reasonably believes the disclosure is necessary to prevent a criminal act that the attorney reasonably believes is likely to result in death of, or substantial bodily harm to, an individual. (Business and Professions Code Section 6068 (e).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This author-sponsored bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings, including the reason for any continuance or dismissal, to specified friends and family members of the respondent without that person’s consent. As proposed to be amended, the bill provides an exception to the notice requirement when the court determines, either upon its own motion or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings that providing notice likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent. According to the author:
SB 42 aims to improve communication and openness by streamlining the notification procedures during CARE proceedings. In order for all parties to stay informed, this entails providing thorough justifications for the CARE court procedures' continuances and dismissals. This bill is required because it has been recognized that there is a need for better organized communication between the courts and the parties involved in CARE actions, particularly when there is a close personal relationship between the original petitioner and the respondent. The measure promotes unambiguous, continuous notices and explanations for court proceedings to guarantee that individuals who start the CARE procedure are kept informed at all times.
Background – CARE Proceedings. SB 1338 (Umberg) Chap. 319, Stats. 2022 enacted the Community Assistance, Recovery, and Empowerment (CARE) Act. The Act was intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services.
The CARE Act is not yet fully implemented in the state. The CARE Act was required to be implemented by Glenn, Orange, Riverside, San Diego, San Francisco, Stanislaus, and Tuolumne Counties by October 1, 2023, but not in the remaining counties by December 1, 2024. (Furthermore, under certain circumstances the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) can issue a one-time delay implementation to a specific county until December 1, 2025.) Finally the CARE Act only becomes operative upon DHCS, in consultation with county stakeholders, developing a CARE Act allocation to provide state financial assistance to counties to implement the CARE process. DHCS is required to issue a preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the CARE Act by due by December 31, 2026; and to issue a final report by December 31, 2028.
How a CARE proceeding is designed to work. A central feature of the CARE Act are “CARE Courts,” intended to deliver mental health and substance use disorder (SUD) services as an alternative to incarceration in a jail or psychiatric facility of a person with schizophrenia or another psychotic disorder, or that person becoming subject to an LPS conservatorship. The CARE Act provides for court-ordered CARE Plans for a person suffering from a mental health or SUD crisis for up to 12 months, with possible extensions. The plan is supposed to provide individuals with clinically appropriate, community-based services. These might include court-ordered stabilization medications, wellness and recovery support, help with finding social services and housing. “Court-ordered stabilization medication” is distinct from involuntary medication in that it cannot be forcibly administered. However, failure of a person to voluntarily participate in the medication treatment could lead to their referral to an LPS conservatorship. (Section 5979 (a)(3) – (5).)
CARE Court focuses on the most severely mentally ill, including those with schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders. As noted, while the overall purpose of the CARE Act is to provide essential services to the most severely ill, it also is supposed to preserve self-determination to the greatest extent possible. The California Health and Human Services Agency describes CARE Court as “an upstream diversion to prevent more restrictive conservatorships or incarceration.” (“CARE Court FAQ,” at chhs.ca.gov.) CARE Court could be an “appropriate next step” after someone has been placed on a 72-hour hold (“5150”) or a 14-day hold (“5250”), an arrest, or those who can otherwise be safely diverted from a criminal proceeding.
The Process: The first step in the CARE Court process is a “referral” – that is, a petition to the court by a family member, mental health provider, or first responder, among others. The Court then orders a clinical evaluation and appoints both a Public Defender and a “CARE Supporter,” the person assigned to help the individual understand the process so as to provide the individual with as much autonomy as is feasible. If the Court finds that the person meets the criteria for the program, then the Court orders the individual, CARE Supporter, and county behavioral health agency to develop a CARE Plan. The Court then reviews the Plan, and if it approves it, the Plan becomes a court order lasting up to 12 months. In addition to the county behavioral care team, CARE Supporter, and individual participating in the prescribed treatment plan, the CARE team also will develop a Psychiatric Advance Directive which can be used for future crisis, by providing necessary background information by the individual’s history. Eventually, the individual “graduates” from the CARE Court, although they may be provided with ongoing services, including assistance with finding housing. “Graduation” from CARE is designed to occur with a person in need of CARE services, including those who are mentally ill and unhoused, obtaining housing of some sort. Housing is a critical component of CARE Court– i.e. stable housing that allows the person to stay connected with treatment, if needed.
Criticism of the CARE Act. While CARE Court and the CARE Act was championed by Governor Newsom and largely popular among the Legislature, many civil liberties groups expressed serious concerns about the model, its cost, and its impact on vulnerable communities. ACLU California Action summarizes some of those concerns in its letter of opposition to last year’s bill by the author of this bill, SB 35 (Chap. 283, Stats. 2023) that, among other things, relaxed the criteria for who can be appointed as counsel for the subject of the proceeding and authorized a “court-appointed commissioner or other subordinate judicial officer” to preside over proceedings in lieu of a superior court judge:
Proponents of CARE Court rely on false premises – that people are rejecting offers of housing; that access to behavioral health services based on one evaluation will solve a person’s mental health, disabilities; and, that a civil court is the least restrictive setting. In reality, low-cost housing stock is at a near record low and affordable housing options have years-long waitlists of people desperate for a home. Moreover, recovery is primarily found to be successful when accessible, affordable housing is combined with community-based treatment settings, surrounded by peers, and provided through voluntary, accessible means. When a person is faced with defending their case before a judge without agency over their own care, the least restrictive setting is not court.
CARE Court is also a costly mistake. Once implemented, this court system is likely to cost in excess of billions of dollars, as estimated by the Assembly Appropriations Committee. This state mandate will fail to deliver on what it promises to accomplish and will divert resources from other urgently needed programs. SB 35 will increase this cost further by increasing the amount of petitions, even though counties already report they do not have enough resources to implement the CARE Court program.
. . . By targeting people with schizophrenia and other psychotic disorders, studies show Black, Indigenous and People of Color will disproportionately experience the harms that CARE Court poses.234 SB 35 will increase CARE Court’s exploitation of poor people who need mental health care. It is those people with low incomes and/or from communities of color who will be most victim to the chilling effects CARE Court will have in preventing people from seeking treatment and care.
Instead of expanding access to CARE Court, the Legislature should fund more community-based mental health care treatment centers, increase housing funds for extremely low-income Californians, and decrease the presence of law enforcement and court involvement in mental health crises.
This bill is yet another modification to the CARE Act during its initial stage of implementation, but prior to its full implementation and evaluation. The bill requires the court in a CARE proceeding to provide ongoing notice about the proceedings to specified associates and family members, namely (1) a person with whom the respondent resides; (2) a spouse, parent, sibling, child, or grandparent; or (3) an individual who stands in loco parentis to the respondent. It is unclear whether there could be more than one “original petitioner” in one CARE proceeding (if multiple family members submitted a petition, for example). If so, the bill would seem to require that all of them be notified.
Under current law, a person who “stands in loco parentis to the respondent” may file a petition to initiate CARE proceedings. The bill provides that such a person is entitled to ongoing notice. Neither the bill in print, nor current law (Section 5974 (b) of the CARE Act, the place the term “loco parentis” refers to a relationship between adults) defines what it means to be “in loco parentis” with a person who is the respondent in a CARE Act proceeding and who, by definition, must be over the age of 18 years. (See Section 5972 (a).)
The bill requires that the court must provide “ongoing notice” to these persons throughout the CARE proceedings if they are an “original petitioner.” Any individual who meets the definition of “original petitioner” is entitled to notice of all CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or a case is dismissed. The bill also specifically requires that if a continuance is granted, or the case is dismissed, the notice must provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal.
Most importantly, the bill in print does not require the respondent to consent to such notice, or even allow them to object to these individuals being notified about their CARE proceeding. Nor does the bill allow a court to make an exception to the mandatory notification, notwithstanding the fact that the respondent could be estranged from one or all of these individuals (i.e., by estrangement from parents, separation from a spouse, or conflict with a housemate, for example) or the relationship with that person could be harmful to the respondent’s mental or physical well-being. If that were the case, it understandably could be distressing to the respondent for the original petitioner to have access to their sensitive mental health information and information about their CARE proceedings.
Author’s amendments. The author wisely proposes to amend the bill to provide a mechanism for the court—on its own motion, or upon motion of the respondent—to disapprove or discontinue notice of CARE proceedings to the original petitioner when it finds that such notice likely would be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent:
(ii) The Unless the court determines, either upon its own motion, or upon the motion of the respondent, at any point in the proceedings, that it likely would be to be detrimental to the treatment or well-being of the respondent, the court shall provide ongoing notice to the original petitioner throughout the CARE proceedings, including, but not limited to, when a continuance is granted or if the case is dismissed. If a continuance is granted or the case is dismissed, the notice shall provide a reason for the continuance or dismissal.
Future amendments? Given the history of this Committee’s involvement in, and concerns about, the CARE Act, the author is strongly encouraged to keep the Committee informed any future amendments to the bill.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 42
Author:(Umberg) – As Amended Ver:June 15, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Attorneys: reporting professional misconduct
KEY ISSUE: should attorneys licensed in California be required to notify the state bar when they know of serious ethical misconduct committed by another attorney?
SYNOPSIS
In recent years, the State Bar of California has been forced to manage several high profile disciplinary cases against prominent California attorneys accused of significant misconduct. Beginning in 2020, a series of allegations against prominent plaintiffs’ attorney Thomas Girardi revealed a decades-long effort by Mr. Girardi to defraud his clients and use connection within the State Bar to cover up his misconduct. Indeed, this Committee held a lengthy oversight hearing on the Girardi-related failures at the State Bar in May 2023. Despite the State Bar’s failing, the Girardi case highlights the fact that other attorneys almost certainly knew of his misconduct but said nothing to regulators. Following on the heels of the Girardi scandal, the State Bar announced formal charges against attorney and law professor John Eastman for his role in advocating for the overturn of the 2020 Presidential Election, and generating the legal theory that underpinned the January 6th Insurrection at the United States Capitol. The incidents involving both attorneys highlighted that California is the only state in the country that has not adopted some form of the American Bar Association’s Model Rule 8.3, requiring attorneys to notify their regulator when they know of specified types of misconduct on the part of another attorney.
This bill would bring California into alignment with the other 49 states by adopting a mandatory misconduct disclosure requirement for licensed attorneys. The bill would require attorneys to inform the State Bar anytime they know a fellow attorney is engaged in treasonous or seditious conduct. Additionally, this bill requires attorneys to report any misconduct that is detrimental to a client that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence. The bill clarifies how the reporting requirement interacts with various privileged communications and clarifies that abuse of the reporting mandate is itself an act of professional misconduct.
This measure is supported by law enforcement and is supported, in concept, by the Consumer Attorneys of California who highlight the need to rehabilitate the image of the legal profession in the wake of recent scandals. The measure is opposed by several attorney organizations, including the California Lawyers Association, and mediation service providers. The opposition contends that the reporting requirements in this bill are too broad and do not adequately protect privileged communications. While recent amendments should address many of the opposition’s concerns, it appears that some consternation remains regarding this bill. This measure was previously, and unanimously, approved by the Senate by a vote of 38 to 0.
SUMMARY: Establishes an affirmative burden on licensed attorneys to report to the State Bar about known misconduct on the part of another licensed attorney. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence, to inform the State Bar of such conduct.
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States, to inform the State Bar of such conduct.
- Defines for the purpose of 1) and 2) “knows” to mean actual knowledge of the fact in question, which may be inferred from circumstances.
- Provides that a licensee who makes a complaint pursuant to 1) or 2) with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter a fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law is deemed to have committed professional misconduct.
- Provides that nothing in the bill requires disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
- Authorizes the State Bar to amend the Rules of Professional Conduct, and propose those amendments to the Supreme Court for approval, as needed to implement this bill.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, is the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. (Business & Professions Code Section 6001.1.)
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Business & Professions Code Section 6000 et seq.)
- Authorizes the Board of Trustees of the State Bar, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. (Business & Professions Code Section 6076.)
- Authorizes the State Bar Court the power to discipline licensees by reproval, public or private, or to recommend to the Supreme Court the suspension from practice for a period not exceeding three years for a willful breach of any of the rules of professional conduct. (Ibid.)
- Authorizes a client, whether or not a party, the privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing, a confidential communication between client and lawyer if the privilege is claimed, as specified. (Evidence Code Section 954.)
- Establishes the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with an impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety, as provided. (Business & Professions Code Section 6230 et seq.)
- Provides that the State Bar’s Chief Trial Counsel, with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to the discipline of the licensees of the State Bar, as specified. (Business & Professions Code Section 6044.)
- Requires, as a part of the self-regulation of the legal profession, that a lawyer who knows that another lawyer has committed a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct that raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness or fitness as a lawyer in other respects, to inform the appropriate professional authority. (American Bar Association Model Rule of Professional Conduct Number 8.3.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: The licensure and regulation of attorneys across the country is the responsibility of the individual regulator in each of the fifty states. In this state, the State Bar of California is the primary regulator of attorney conduct. Like many other states, the State Bar of California utilizes the suggestions of the American Bar Association’s Model Rules of Professional Conduct to help craft the state-specific ethical rules governing the legal profession. However, unlike all 49 other American states, California has never adopted Model Rule 8.3, which essentially requires attorneys to inform their regulator when the attorney knows of misconduct committed by a fellow licensee. In the wake of recent scandals involving the State Bar’s willingness to turn a blind eye to clear cases of attorney misconduct, this measure seeks to statutorily adopt a mandated attorney misconduct reporting framework. In support of this important new tool for protecting the public from unethical legal practitioners, the author states:
SB 42 requires attorney to inform the State Bar if they know of another attorney that has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that attorney’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness. Each state has its own rules that govern ethical standards for attorneys. For example, the California Rules of Professional Conduct regulate the professional conduct of attorneys licensed by the State Bar through discipline. However, these rules have no requirement that attorney’s report the misconduct of their colleagues. Many state rules have either been copied or influenced by the standards created by the American Bar Association (ABA). In fact, 49 states have some sort form of requirement that attorneys report their colleague’s misconduct. California only requires attorneys to report their own professional misconduct and not the misconduct of others.
SB 42 aims to prevent some of the most egregious examples of attorney misconduct. Specifically, the type of corruption and unethical behavior seen in the Thomas Girardi Scandals. Thomas Girardi was a nationally renowned trial attorney who misappropriated millions of dollars’ worth of settlement money for clients and cheated fellow attorneys out of fees. Hundreds of former clients sued Girardi when money damages were never transferred to them. These monies included the misappropriation of at least two million dollars due to crash victims’ widows and orphans for those killed in a Boeing 737 MAX crash and dozens of cancer survivors who were awarded $17 million from a pharmaceutical company.
Many attorneys noticed Girardi’s egregious ethical violations, including those in his own law firm. However, these attorneys had no duty to report his misconduct. The lack of a mandatory reporting statute resulted in a substantial delay in justice to the victims. Thankfully, in 2022, a court ordered Girardi to pay $2,300,000 in restitution and he was finally was disbarred.
In order to prevent future abuses to vulnerable clients, SB 42 would require attorneys to report the professional miscount of other attorneys to the State Bar. Changing these reporting requirements will ensure that California’s attorneys are held the same standard as other attorneys from the other 49 states.
The Tom Girardi scandal highlights that the existing system for attorney discipline in California is woefully inadequate. The State Bar is embroiled in scandal over its handling, or lack thereof, of misconduct by once-prominent trial attorney Thomas Girardi. In 2021, Girardi was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. A federal court found that he had misappropriated $2 million that had been awarded to the families of those killed in the Lion Air Flight 610 plane crash of 2018, and referred the matter to federal prosecutors for further investigation. This incident triggered numerous further accusations against Girardi for stealing client funds; as a result, the true scope of his malfeasance finally began to materialize. Eventually, Girardi and his law firm, Girardi Keese, were forced into bankruptcy. This year, Girardi was indicted by federal grand juries in Los Angeles and Chicago on charges that he embezzled more than $18 million from his clients.
Once this scandal broke, the State Bar commissioned Los Angeles attorney Aaron May and his firm to investigate how the State Bar handled complaints against Girardi. After numerous interviews and a lengthy document review, the report (known as the May Report) found that Girardi sought to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and that “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.” (Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP, Independent Investigation for the State bar of California: Report of Investigation (February 4, 2023).)
As a result of the scandal, this Committee conducted an oversight hearing of the State Bar in coordination with the Senate Committee on Judiciary. In preparing for that hearing, this Committee interviewed several former clients of Girardi Keese. Throughout those interviews, it became fairly clear that other attorneys at the firm either participated in misconduct or certainly were aware of Girardi’s violations of the Rules of Professional Conduct. However, given that California does not impose any affirmative duty on licensed attorneys to inform the State Bar about the known malfeasance of other licensees, Tom Girardi’s conduct was able to continue, unabated, for years.
California lawyers played a prominent role in the January 6th Insurrection. The attack on the United States Capitol on January 6, 2021, was the culmination of a months-long effort to utilize spurious legal theories and misguided political strategies to overturn the results of the November 2020 Presidential Election. One of the leading legal advocates behind the effort was prominent former attorney and law professor John Charles Eastman. Eastman advocated the theory that then-Vice President Mike Pence could singlehandedly reject the counting of electors from states in which President Trump claimed votes were “stolen” from him. When Vice President Pence refused to go along with Eastman’s theory, he sparked the now infamous chants of “hang Mike Pence” by angry Capitol insurrectionists. Eastman’s legal theory was largely derided by other experts as far-fetched. Indeed, in light of the harm that resulted from Eastman’s ill-conceived legal plan, in January the State Bar moved to initiate formal disciplinary actions against Eastman as a result of his, “false and misleading statements regarding purported election fraud,” and his advocacy for legal theories that were, “unsupported by law, based on false and misleading assertions of fact, and designed for the purpose of keeping Trump in office.” (State Bar of California-Office of Communications, Attorney John Eastman Charged with Multiple Disciplinary Counts by the State Bar of California, Jan. 26, 2023, available at: https://www.calbar.ca.gov/About-Us/News/News-Releases/attorney-john-eastman-charged-with-multiple-disciplinary-counts-by-the-state-bar-of-california.) Under existing law, none of Eastman’s colleagues would have been required to take any action to deter Eastman’s conduct or to inform the State Bar of his efforts to advance the dangerous and suspect legal theories that underpinned the January 6th Insurrection.
California is the only state that does not require attorneys to assist in upholding the integrity of the profession. In addition to serving as a national trade association for attorneys, the American Bar Association (ABA) also provides guidance to attorneys and regulators on how to conduct oneself as an ethical legal practitioner. This guidance is contained in the ABA’s Model Rules for Professional Conduct. However, because the ABA is not a regulatory entity, the degree to which its Model Rules actually apply to licensed attorneys in any given state is solely at the discretion of the state’s legal regulator. Of note to this bill, Model Rule 8.3 states in part, “that lawyer who knows that another lawyer has committed a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct that raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness or fitness as a lawyer in other respects, to inform the appropriate professional authority.”
The comment to ABA Model Rule 8.3 states that, “self-regulation of the legal profession requires that members of the profession initiate disciplinary investigation when they know of a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct. This rule is based on the notion that an apparently isolated violation may indicate a pattern of misconduct that only a disciplinary investigation can uncover. In recognition that a rule that would require all violation of the rules of professional conduct to be reported would be unworkable, the ABA model rule limits the conduct the type of which a “self-regulating profession must vigorously endeavor to prevent.” For this reason, the conduct that must be reported pursuant to ABA Model Rule 8.3 is conduct that raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects. This high bar seeks to ensure that mandatory misconduct reporting does not encompass either minor errors that do not meaningful impact clients, or mistakes made by young lawyers that can be corrected by more senior supervisors. Most importantly, this high bar ensures that mandatory reporting cannot be utilized as a tool to gain an advantage against an otherwise ethical opposing counsel in litigation.
This bill. As a result of the Girardi and Eastman scandals, California’s status as the only state to not impose some version of Model Rule 8.3 on licensed attorneys came under scrutiny. Seeking to address the issue, this bill adopts several mandatory reporting requirements for licensed attorneys. First, in order to address the Eastman issue, this bill requires a licensed attorney to report to the State Bar anytime they know a fellow licensee has conspired to engage in, or has engaged in, treason, sedition, or insurrection against the State of California or the United States. Seeking to address the Girardi issues and finally ensure that California adopts a Model Rule 8.3-like requirement in this state, this bill requires a licensee to inform the State Bar of any time an attorney knows a fellow licensee has engaged in professional misconduct to the detriment of a client and that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence.
This bill adopts a definition of “knows” to clarify that an attorney must have actual factual knowledge of misconduct or that such knowledge can be inferred from circumstances. Seeking to ensure that this measure is not used as a tool for retaliation between attorneys, or as a means of gaining an advantage in litigation, this bill would make the filing of a complaint regarding misconduct of another attorney with the intent to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter the fellow licensee from engaging in the lawful practice of law a violation of the Rule of Professional Conduct in its own right. Finally, this measure authorizes the State Bar to propose changes to the Rules of Professional Conduct in order to implement this bill.
Recent amendments seek to establish clear reporting guidelines to address opposition concerns. This bill was recently amended by the author to address concerns raised by opposition to the bill as it was introduced. To the prior version of the bill, the California Lawyers Association noted, “SB 42 is concerning, given the breadth and scope of potential ‘professional misconduct.’” As now in print, this bill essentially adopts a three-part test for reporting, non-treason related attorney misconduct. In order to trigger a mandatory report to the State Bar a licensee must meet the following:
- First, the licensee must know that the conduct exists. There is no duty to speculate about or investigate suspected misconduct that the attorney does not have actual knowledge of.
- Secondly, the known professional misconduct to the detriment of a client. This standard does not mean that an attorney must report about the conduct of another attorney that while unsavory does not impact a client. For example, this would not require an attorney to report another attorneys speeding as was suggested by one opponent of the bill.
- Finally, the known professional misconduct much be of the nature as to raise a substantial question about a fellow attorney’s honesty, trustworthiness, or ability to perform legal services with competence.
This three-part standard is designed to avoid unnecessary reporting. The high standard for triggering a mandatory report is designed to provide attorneys with clarity and prevent the development of a “snitching” culture within the ranks of the legal profession. Additionally, the provisions of the bill prohibiting reporting to the State Bar from being used as a litigation tool should mollify many of the concerns about the bill that have been expressed to this Committee.
The State Bar and California Supreme Court’s existing efforts to adopt a California version of Model Rule 8.3. This bill is advancing on a parallel track with the State Bar and California Supreme Court’s own efforts to adopt some version of Model Rule 8.3. The State Bar provided two suggested versions of Rule 8.3 to the California Supreme Court for adoption. However, those versions differ from this measure in that criminal conduct is a key trigger for both reporting requirements. When compared with the State Bar’s proposals, this measure would certainly capture a larger segment of attorney misconduct. However, unethical conduct or incompetence on the part of an attorney may significantly impact a client, even if such conduct is not criminal. Indeed, it appears the State Bar’s proposal is a narrower standard that would fit within the confines of the broader requirements of this bill. Accordingly, the standard adopted by this bill is appropriate. Nonetheless, the author may wish to monitor the ongoing developments with the State Bar’s proposed rule and modify this bill, if necessary, to ensure that there is not conflicting reporting standards imposed upon attorneys.
Opposition claims that this measure would eliminate attorney mentorship or result in meritless claims to gain an advantage in litigation are greatly overstated. It should be noted that several organizations representing the legal community have written to this Committee supporting this measure, at least in concept. However, several other legal organizations have written to oppose this bill, claiming that is it overbroad, may result in frivolous or malicious complaints, and would upend the existing system of attorney mentorship. Recent amendments should address the most pressing of these concerns. Remaining concerns appear to be largely fear-driven conjecture.
First, recent amendments should address the fears that the bill is overbroad. As discussed above, this bill is now limited to conduct that actually harms a client and raises issue of trust, honesty, or competency. All three of these standards are found elsewhere in the Rules of Professional Conduct, thus enabling licensees to understand what types of conduct should trigger reporting.
Secondly, as to concerns that mandatory reporting would be used as a tool in litigation, recent amendments should ameliorate these concerns by clarifying that reports intended to intimidate, harass, or otherwise deter lawful conduct are themselves a violation of professional ethics. One would surmise that most attorneys would not risk their own professional discipline just to gain an advantage over opposing counsel.
Finally, as to a concern raised by the Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., this bill should not impede mentorship and oversight of new attorneys. The opposition worries this bill would require a senior attorney to report a new attorney for, “correctable errors [made] in the course of learning their job.” However, when looking at the text of the bill, such a situation seems extremely unlikely. Minor and correctable errors do not appear to raise any concerns about a young attorney’s trustworthiness or honesty. Additionally, correctable errors should not raise to the level of creating a substantial question of competency as all lawyers; the State Bar, as well as practicing attorneys, recognize that those learning the profession make innocent mistakes and learn from them. Accordingly, in light of recent amendments, the Committee sees no additional need to modify this relatively narrow measure designed to ensure that the legal profession has a stake in protecting the public from bad actors within the profession.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is supported, in concept, by the Consumer Attorneys of California. They write:
All other states except California have adopted some version of this rule. A bit of history is relevant--the State Bar voted to reject adopting a possible revised version of the ABA’s Model Rule 8.3 (“MR 8.3”) for California, most recently in 2016. It is past time for California to act and SB 42 is a step in the right direction.
CAOC stands for justice, advocating for those whose rights have been violated by powerful individuals and interests. That’s why it is repulsive to see Californians – already the victims of wrongdoing – harmed once again by people they’ve entrusted to represent them in the pursuit of justice. New information has come to light exposing numerous opportunities presented to the California State Bar – whose core mission is to protect the public – to hold Tom Girardi accountable. It is an abject failure of the State Bar leadership and a fundamental dereliction of duty that after 150 complaints against one of its former members over four decades, the State Bar did nothing. The Bar’s failure to act is a scandal that threatens to undermine the public trust in California’s legal system.
Additionally, the Peace Officers’ Research Association states:
PORAC supports the passage of SB 42 because it will keep attorneys accountable for their actions. This will help ensure that all licensees of the State Bar are trustworthy and fit to be attorneys.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As noted this measure is opposed by several attorney and dispute resolution organizations. In opposition to the measure the California Lawyers’ Association states:
The State Bar’s Alternative 1 provides that a lawyer shall, without undue delay, inform the State Bar when the lawyer knows of credible evidence that another lawyer has committed a criminal act, engaged in fraud, or misappropriated funds or property in violation of rule 1.15 (Safekeeping Funds and Property of Clients and Other Persons) when that conduct raises a substantial question as to a lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects.
The State Bar’s Alternative 2 would provide that a lawyer shall, without undue delay, inform the State Bar when the lawyer knows of credible evidence that another lawyer has (1) committed a criminal act that reflects adversely on that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects; or (2) engaged in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or reckless or intentional misrepresentation or misappropriation of funds or property.
SB 42, in marked contrast, would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar.
The reporting obligation under SB 42 is concerning, given the breadth and scope of potential “professional misconduct” along with all the facts, circumstances, and related interpretational issues involved in determining whether an attorney would be required to report to the State Bar, based on their own conclusion that another attorney has in fact engaged in professional misconduct. In addition, although a substantial question as to an attorney’s honesty or trustworthiness may be self-evident with certain misconduct, determining whether particular misconduct raises a substantial question as to an attorney’s “fitness as an attorney in other respects” would involve application of a much more amorphous and subjective standard. Significantly, SB 42 is not limited to reporting situations where the attorney’s misconduct occurs in connection with the practice of law or causes direct harm to a client.
Additionally, the California Dispute Resolution Council states:
SB 42 currently contains two exceptions, to wit, information otherwise protected by the attorney client privilege and information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program. By specifically including two exceptions, it would appear that no other exception was considered by the Legislature. Hence, the bill would supersede the doctrine of mediation confidentiality set forth in Evidence Code Section 1119.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Attorneys of California (in concept)
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Oppose
California Dispute Resolution Council (unless amended)
California Lawyers Association
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 42 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 42
Author: Umberg (D)
Introduced: 12/5/22
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-0, 5/2/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SUBJECT: Attorneys: reporting professional misconduct
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires a licensee of the State Bar of California who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar, except as provided.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Cal. const. sec. 9, art. VI.; Bus. & Prof. Code § 6000 et seq.)
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, shall be the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Provides that the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC), with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to: the discipline of the licensees of the State Bar; the acts or practices of a person whom the CTC has reason to believe has violated or is about to violate any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of the State Bar Act; and any other matter within the jurisdiction of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6044.)
- Authorizes the Board of Trustees, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6076.)
- The rules of professional conduct adopted by the board, when approved by the Supreme Court, are binding upon all licensees of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6076.)
- the State Bar Court has power to discipline licensees by reproval, public or private, or to recommend to the Supreme Court the suspension from practice for a period not exceeding three years for a willful breach of any of the rules of professional conduct. (Ibid.)
- Establishes the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with an impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety, as provided. (Bus. & Prov. Code § 6230 et seq.)
- Establishes an attorney-client privilege under the Evidence Code that provides the client, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing, a confidential communication between client and lawyer, as provided.
This bill:
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar.
- Provides that this provision does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
Comments
The State Bar of California (State Bar) is a public corporation that functions as the administrative arm of the California Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions (licensing) and discipline. The State Bar’s highest priority is the protection of the public, which includes quickly finding and disciplining dishonest or incompetent attorneys. Attorneys are subject to the Rules of Professional Conduct and can be disciplined by the State Bar for violating them. The American Bar Association (ABA), a national professional association, has promulgated Model Rules of Professional Conduct for the legal profession. California is the only state that has not enacted some version of ABA Model Rule 8.3, which requires attorneys to report the conduct of another attorney who they know violated the rules of professional conduct. This bill seeks to remedy this by enacting a version of that ABA model rule on mandatory reporting. By requiring attorneys to report the misconduct of other attorneys of which they have knowledge, this bill will bring California in line with the other 49 states and hopefully help preserve and potentially increase the integrity of the legal profession.
The comment to the ABA Model Rule 8.3 states that “self-regulation of the legal profession requires that members of the profession initiate disciplinary investigation when they know of a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct. Lawyers have a similar obligation with respect to judicial misconduct. An apparently isolated violation may indicate a pattern of misconduct that only a disciplinary investigation can uncover. Reporting a violation is especially important where the victim is unlikely to discover the offense.”[1] In recognition that a rule that would require any violation of the rules of professional conduct to be reported would be unworkable, the ABA model rule limits the conduct the type of which a “self-regulating profession must vigorously endeavor to prevent.” For this reason the conduct that must be reported is conduct that raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects.
This bill follows the guidance provided in the Comment to ABA Model Rule 8.3, and only requires a licensed attorney who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney, in other respects, to inform the State Bar of such conduct. The bill provides exceptions for disclosing knowledge gained by a licensee via the participation in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program or information that is protected by the attorney-client privilege.
Girardi, a prominent trial attorney, was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. Serious and repeated allegations of misconduct against him were reported to the State Bar over several decades, but the State Bar did not take action against him until 2021, when he was disbarred. This year, he was indicted by federal grand juries in two states. As noted by the author, it is almost certain that other attorneys knew about his unethical violations, but under current law there is no duty on attorneys to report such unethical conduct to the State Bar. By enacting this bill, attorneys would have a duty to report misconduct of other attorneys, which they have knowledge about, that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney. Maintaining the integrity of the legal profession is not a weight that should fall solely on the public. This bill remedies this and brings California in line with every other state regarding mandatory reporting for attorney misconduct.
At the November 17, 2022 Board of Trustees Meeting of the State Bar, the Chair of the Board of Trustees asked the State Bar Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (COPRAC) to prepare a proposal for a new rule of professional conduct on a lawyer’s duty to report the misconduct of another lawyer, pointing to the fact that California was the only state in the nation without such a rule. This will be the third time the State Bar has considered some form of a mandatory reporting rule for attorneys. It did so in 2010 and 2016 as part of the work of the Rules Revision Commission. In 2010, the then Board of the State Bar rejected the proposal to adopt a mandatory reporting rule that would have required a lawyer to report another lawyer who committed a felonious criminal act that raised a substantial question as to that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness. In 2016 the Rules Revision Commission voted 10 to 4 against recommending the adoption of a version of rule 8.3 and a proposed rule was never brought to the Board for a vote.
COPRAC submitted its proposal to the Board at their March 16, 2023 meeting.[2] The proposal included two options and recommended the Board put forth both options for a 45-day public comment period that is to end on May 4, 2023. The first provided that a lawyer must, without undue delay, inform the State Bar when the lawyer knows of credible evidence that another lawyer has committed a criminal act, engaged in fraud, or misappropriated funds or property in violation of rule 1.15 of the Rules of Professional Conduct when that conduct raises a substantial question as to that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects. Rule 1.15 of the Rules of Professional Conduct specifically governs how an attorney is to safeguard client funds and property in the possession of the attorney.
The second proposed rule provided that a lawyer must, without undue delay, inform the State Bar when the lawyer has: (1) committed a criminal act that reflects adversely on that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects; or (2) engaged in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or reckless or intentional misrepresentation or misappropriation of funds or property. Both proposed rules provide more expansive exceptions than the bill does, such as mediation confidentiality and other applicable privileges. And both proposed rules also specifically authorize, but do not require, a lawyer to report violations of the rules of professional conduct or other rules of the State Bar.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/2/23)
Consumer Attorneys of California
Peace Officers’ Research Association of California
1 individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/2/23)
California Dispute Resolution Council
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
SB 42 requires attorneys to inform the State Bar if they know of another attorney that has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that attorney’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness. Each state has its own rules that govern ethical standards for attorneys. For example, the California Rules of Professional Conduct regulate the professional conduct of attorneys licensed by the State Bar through discipline. However, these rules have no requirement that attorneys report the misconduct of their colleagues. Many state rules have either been copied or influenced by the standards created by the American Bar Association (ABA). In fact, 49 states have some sort of requirement that attorneys report their colleague’s misconduct. California only requires attorneys to report their own professional misconduct and not the misconduct of others.
SB 42 aims to prevent some of the most egregious examples of attorney misconduct. Specifically, the type of corruption and unethical behavior seen in the Girardi scandal. Girardi was a nationally renowned trial attorney who misappropriated millions of dollars’ worth of settlement money for clients and cheated fellow attorneys out of fees. Hundreds of former clients sued Girardi when money damages were never transferred to them. These monies included the misappropriation of at least two million dollars due to crash victims’ widows and orphans for those killed in a Boeing 737 MAX, crash and dozens of cancer survivors who were awarded $17 million from a pharmaceutical company.
Many attorneys noticed Girardi’s egregious ethical violations, including those in his own law firm. However, these attorneys had no duty to report his misconduct. The lack of a mandatory reporting statute resulted in a substantial delay in justice to the victims. Thankfully, in 2022, a court ordered Girardi to pay $2,300,000 in restitution and he was finally was disbarred.
In order to prevent future abuses to vulnerable clients, SB 42 would require attorneys to report the professional miscount of other attorneys to the State Bar. Changing these reporting requirements will ensure that California’s attorneys are held to an equivalent standard as other attorneys from the other 49 states.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Dispute Resolution Council writes that they are opposed unless amended, stating:
SB 42 currently contains two exceptions, to wit, information otherwise protected by the attorney client privilege and information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program. By specifically including two exceptions, it would appear that no other exception was considered by the Legislature. Hence, the bill would supersede the doctrine of confidentiality set forth in Evidence Code Sections 1115 et. seq.
CDRC believes that mediation confidentiality should be an exception to the reporting requirement set forth in SB 42. The ability of parties in a mediation to speak to each other and to the mediator candidly is the key to a successful mediation. If a mediator-attorney files a report to the State Bar about the conduct of another attorney who is participating in the mediation, the mediator will likely be breaching mediation confidentiality and that breach not only will affect the attorney who is acting inappropriately, but all the other mediation participants, who may have had nothing to do with the attorney’s misconduct. This prospect may deter individuals from participating in a mediation and will substantially reduce the number of California mediations, causing many of the lawsuits which otherwise would have been resolved in a mediation to be added to the court docket.
Please bear in mind that the doctrine of confidentiality does not apply to any information that was known before the mediation commenced. A party thus cannot convert non-confidential information to confidential information through the device of discussing it during the mediation.
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/5/23 13:17:50
**** END ****
Comment to Rule 8.3 Reporting Professional Misconduct, ABA available at https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_8_3_reporting_professional_misconduct/comment_on_rule_8_3/. ↑
Agenda Item 60-1, Mar. 16, 2023 Open Session, State Bar Board of Trustees Meeting, available at https://board.calbar.ca.gov/docs/agendaItem/Public/agendaitem1000030459.pdf. ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 42 (Author:Umberg)
Version: December 5, 2022
Hearing Date: May 2, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Attorneys: reporting professional misconduct
DIGEST
This bill requires a licensee of the State Bar of California who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar, except as provided.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The State Bar of California (State Bar) is a public corporation that functions as the administrative arm of the California Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions (licensing) and discipline. The State Bar’s highest priority is the protection of the public, which includes quickly finding and disciplining dishonest or incompetent attorneys. Attorneys are subject to the Rules of Professional Conduct and can be disciplined by the State Bar for violating them. The American Bar Association (ABA), a national professional association, has promulgated Model Rules of Professional Conduct for the legal profession. California is the only state that has not enacted some version of ABA Model Rule 8.3, which requires attorneys to report the conduct of another attorney who they know violated the rules of professional conduct. This bill seeks to remedy this by enacting a version of that ABA model rule on mandatory reporting. By requiring attorneys to report the misconduct of other attorneys of which they have knowledge, this bill will bring California in line with the other 49 states and hopefully help preserve and potentially increase the integrity of the legal profession.
The bill is author sponsored. The bill is supported by the Consumer Attorneys of California and the Peace Officers’ Research Association of California. The bill is opposed by the California Dispute Resolution Council and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Cal. const. sec. 9, art. VI.; Bus. & Prof. Code § 6000 et seq.)
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, shall be the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Provides that the Chief Trial Counsel (CTC), with or without the filing or presentation of any complaint, may initiate and conduct investigations of all matters affecting or relating to: the discipline of the licensees of the State Bar; the acts or practices of a person whom the CTC has reason to believe has violated or is about to violate any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of the State Bar Act; and any other matter within the jurisdiction of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6044.)
- Authorizes the Board of Trustees, with the approval of the Supreme Court, to formulate and enforce rules of professional conduct for all licensees of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6076.)
- The rules of professional conduct adopted by the board, when approved by the Supreme Court, are binding upon all licensees of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6076.)
- the State Bar Court has power to discipline licensees by reproval, public or private, or to recommend to the Supreme Court the suspension from practice for a period not exceeding three years for a willful breach of any of the rules of professional conduct. (Ibid.)
- Establishes the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program to identify and rehabilitate attorneys with an impairment due to substance use or a mental health disorder affecting competency so that attorneys so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of law in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety, as provided. (Bus. & Prov. Code § 6230 et seq.)
- Establishes an attorney-client privilege under the Evidence Code that provides the client, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing, a confidential communication between client and lawyer, as provided.
This bill:
- Requires a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar.
- Provides that this provision does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by the attorney-client privilege or information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
SB 42 requires attorneys to inform the State Bar if they know of another attorney that has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that attorney’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness. Each state has its own rules that govern ethical standards for attorneys. For example, the California Rules of Professional Conduct regulate the professional conduct of attorneys licensed by the State Bar through discipline. However, these rules have no requirement that attorneys report the misconduct of their colleagues. Many state rules have either been copied or influenced by the standards created by the American Bar Association (ABA). In fact, 49 states have some sort of requirement that attorneys report their colleague’s misconduct. California only requires attorneys to report their own professional misconduct and not the misconduct of others.
SB 42 aims to prevent some of the most egregious examples of attorney misconduct. Specifically, the type of corruption and unethical behavior seen in the Girardi scandal. Girardi was a nationally renowned trial attorney who misappropriated millions of dollars’ worth of settlement money for clients and cheated fellow attorneys out of fees. Hundreds of former clients sued Girardi when money damages were never transferred to them. These monies included the misappropriation of at least two million dollars due to crash victims’ widows and orphans for those killed in a Boeing 737 MAX, crash and dozens of cancer survivors who were awarded $17 million from a pharmaceutical company.
Many attorneys noticed Girardi’s egregious ethical violations, including those in his own law firm. However, these attorneys had no duty to report his misconduct. The lack of a mandatory reporting statute resulted in a substantial delay in justice to the victims. Thankfully, in 2022, a court ordered Girardi to pay $2,300,000 in restitution and he was finally was disbarred.
In order to prevent future abuses to vulnerable clients, SB 42 would require attorneys to report the professional miscount of other attorneys to the State Bar. Changing these reporting requirements will ensure that California’s attorneys are held to an equivalent standard as other attorneys from the other 49 states.
- California is the only state in the nation that has not enacted some version of the ABA Model Rule for Professional Conduct regarding mandatory reporting of attorney misconduct
The comment to the ABA Model Rule 8.3 states that “self-regulation of the legal profession requires that members of the profession initiate disciplinary investigation when they know of a violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct. Lawyers have a similar obligation with respect to judicial misconduct. An apparently isolated violation may indicate a pattern of misconduct that only a disciplinary investigation can uncover. Reporting a violation is especially important where the victim is unlikely to discover the offense.”[1] In recognition that a rule that would require any violation of the rules of professional conduct to be reported would be unworkable, the ABA model rule limits the conduct the type of which a “self-regulating profession must vigorously endeavor to prevent.” For this reason the conduct that must be reported is conduct that raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects.
This bill follows the guidance provided in the Comment to ABA Model Rule 8.3, and only requires a licensed attorney who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney, in other respects, to inform the State Bar of such conduct. The bill provides exceptions for disclosing knowledge gained by a licensee via the participation in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program or information that is protected by the attorney-client privilege.
Girardi, a prominent trial attorney, was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. Serious and repeated allegations of misconduct against him were reported to the State Bar over several decades, but the State Bar did not take action against him until 2021, when he was disbarred. This year, he was indicted by federal grand juries in two states. As noted by the author, it is almost certain that other attorneys knew about his unethical violations, but under current law there is no duty on attorneys to report such unethical conduct to the State Bar. By enacting this bill, attorneys would have a duty to report misconduct of other attorneys, which they have knowledge about, that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney. Maintaining the integrity of the legal profession is not a weight that should fall solely on the public. This bill remedies this and brings California in line with every other state regarding mandatory reporting for attorney misconduct.
- The State Bar is, once again, contemplating adopting a mandatory reporting rule to the Rules of Professional Conduct
At the November 17, 2022 Board of Trustees Meeting of the State Bar, the Chair of the Board of Trustees asked the State Bar Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility and Conduct (COPRAC) to prepare a proposal for a new rule of professional conduct on a lawyer’s duty to report the misconduct of another lawyer, pointing to the fact that California was the only state in the nation without such a rule. This will be the third time the State Bar has considered some form of a mandatory reporting rule for attorneys. It did so in 2010 and 2016 as part of the work of the Rules Revision Commission. In 2010, the then Board of the State Bar rejected the proposal to adopt a mandatory reporting rule that would have required a lawyer to report another lawyer who committed a felonious criminal act that raised a substantial question as to that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness. In 2016 the Rules Revision Commission voted 10 to 4 against recommending the adoption of a version of rule 8.3 and a proposed rule was never brought to the Board for a vote.
COPRAC submitted its proposal to the Board at their March 16, 2023 meeting.[2] The proposal included two options and recommended the Board put forth both options for a 45-day public comment period that is to end on May 4, 2023. The first provided that a lawyer must, without undue delay, inform the State Bar when the lawyer knows of credible evidence that another lawyer has committed a criminal act, engaged in fraud, or misappropriated funds or property in violation of rule 1.15 of the Rules of Professional Conduct when that conduct raises a substantial question as to that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects. Rule 1.15 of the Rules of Professional Conduct specifically governs how an attorney is to safeguard client funds and property in the possession of the attorney.
The second proposed rule provided that a lawyer must, without undue delay, inform the State Bar when the lawyer has: (1) committed a criminal act that reflects adversely on that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer in other respects; or (2) engaged in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or reckless or intentional misrepresentation or misappropriation of funds or property. Both proposed rules provide more expansive exceptions than the bill does, such as mediation confidentiality and other applicable privileges. And both proposed rules also specifically authorize, but do not require, a lawyer to report violations of the rules of professional conduct or other rules of the State Bar.
- Statements in support
The Peace Officers Research Association Committee writes in support stating:
SB 42 would require a licensee of the State Bar who knows that another licensee has engaged in professional misconduct that raises a substantial question as to that licensee’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as an attorney in other respects, to inform the State Bar.
PORAC supports the passage of SB 42 because it will keep attorneys accountable for their actions. This will help ensure that all licensees of the State Bar are trustworthy and fit to be attorneys.
- Statements in opposition
The California Dispute Resolution Council writes that they are opposed unless amended, stating:
SB 42 currently contains two exceptions, to wit, information otherwise protected by the attorney client privilege and information gained by a licensee while participating in the Attorney Diversion and Assistance Program. By specifically including two exceptions, it would appear that no other exception was considered by the Legislature. Hence, the bill would supersede the doctrine of confidentiality set forth in Evidence Code Sections 1115 et. seq.
CDRC believes that mediation confidentiality should be an exception to the reporting requirement set forth in SB 42. The ability of parties in a mediation to speak to each other and to the mediator candidly is the key to a successful mediation. If a mediator-attorney files a report to the State Bar about the conduct of another attorney who is participating in the mediation, the mediator will likely be breaching mediation confidentiality and that breach not only will affect the attorney who is acting inappropriately, but all the other mediation participants, who may have had nothing to do with the attorney’s misconduct. This prospect may deter individuals from participating in a mediation and will substantially reduce the number of California mediations, causing many of the lawsuits which otherwise would have been resolved in a mediation to be added to the court docket.
Please bear in mind that the doctrine of confidentiality does not apply to any information that was known before the mediation commenced. A party thus cannot convert non-confidential information to confidential information through the device of discussing it during the mediation.
SUPPORT
Consumer Attorneys of California
Peace Officers’ Research Association of California
1 individual
OPPOSITION
California Dispute Resolution Council
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: See Comment 3, above.
Prior Legislation: None known.
**************
Comment to Rule 8.3 Reporting Professional Misconduct, ABA available at https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_rules_of_professional_conduct/rule_8_3_reporting_professional_misconduct/comment_on_rule_8_3/. ↑
Agenda Item 60-1, Mar. 16, 2023 Open Session, State Bar Board of Trustees Meeting, available at https://board.calbar.ca.gov/docs/agendaItem/Public/agendaitem1000030459.pdf. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):