SB 463: Dependent children.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-10
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-10: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 714, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge a child to be a dependent of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness as a result of the failure or inability of their parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child. Existing law requires the court to make a determination, throughout various hearings in the juvenile dependency process, including at the 6-month review hearing, the 12-month permanency hearing, and subsequent permanency review hearings, as to whether the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. Under existing law, the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is considered prima facie evidence at these hearings that return would be detrimental.
This bill would delete these provisions requiring the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be considered prima facie evidence at specified review hearings.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code proposed by AB 937 to be operative only if this bill and AB 937 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge a child to be a dependent of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness as a result of the failure or inability of their parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child. Existing law requires the court to make a determination, throughout various hearings in the juvenile dependency process, including at the 6-month review hearing, the 12-month permanency hearing, and subsequent permanency review hearings, as to whether the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. Under existing law, the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is considered prima facie evidence at these hearings that return would be detrimental.
This bill would delete these provisions requiring the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be considered prima facie evidence at specified review hearings.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code proposed by AB 937 to be operative only if this bill and AB 937 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge a child to be a dependent of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness as a result of the failure or inability of their parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child. Existing law requires the court to make a determination, throughout various hearings in the juvenile dependency process, including at the 6-month review hearing, the 12-month permanency hearing, and subsequent permanency review hearings, as to whether the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. Under existing law, the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is considered prima facie evidence at these hearings that return would be detrimental.
This bill would delete these provisions requiring the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be considered prima facie evidence at specified review hearings.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code proposed by AB 937 to be operative only if this bill and AB 937 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
Existing law establishes the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge a child to be a dependent of the court under certain circumstances, including when the child suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness as a result of the failure or inability of their parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child. Existing law requires the court to make a determination, throughout various hearings in the juvenile dependency process, including at the 6-month review hearing, the 12-month permanency hearing, and subsequent permanency review hearings, as to whether the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. Under existing law, the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is considered prima facie evidence at these hearings that return would be detrimental.
This bill would delete these provisions requiring the failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be considered prima facie evidence at specified review hearings.
Existing law prescribes, in accordance with federal law, the powers of the protection and advocacy agency, which is a private, nonprofit corporation, charged with protecting and advocating for the rights of persons with developmental disabilities and mental disorders. Existing law defines various terms for those purposes. This bill would make a technical, nonsubstantive change to these provisions.Existing law prescribes, in accordance with federal law, the powers of the protection and advocacy agency, which is a private, nonprofit corporation, charged with protecting and advocating for the rights of persons with developmental disabilities and mental disorders. Existing law defines various terms for those purposes.
This bill would make a technical, nonsubstantive change to these provisions.
(a)Every hearing conducted by the juvenile court reviewing the status of a dependent child shall be placed on the appearance calendar. The court shall advise all persons present at the hearing of the date of the future hearing and of their right to be present and represented by counsel.
(b)Except as provided in Sections 294 and 295, notice of the hearing shall be provided pursuant to Section 293.
(c)At least 10 calendar days before the hearing, the social worker shall file a supplemental report with the court regarding the services provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian to enable them to assume custody and the efforts made to achieve legal permanence for the child if efforts to reunify fail, including, but not limited to, efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests; the progress made; and, where relevant, the prognosis for return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian; and shall make their recommendation for disposition. If the child is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, the report and recommendation may also take into account those factors described in subdivision (e) relating to the childs sibling group. If the recommendation is not to return the child to a parent or legal guardian, the report shall specify why the return of the child would be detrimental to the child. The social worker shall provide the parent or legal guardian, counsel for the child, and any court-appointed child advocate with a copy of the report, including their recommendation for disposition, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing. The report may be served pursuant to Section 212.5. In the case of a child removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, the social worker shall, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing, provide a summary of their recommendation for disposition to any foster parents, relative caregivers, and certified foster parents who have been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, community care facility, or foster family agency having the physical custody of the child. The social worker shall include a copy of the Judicial Councils Caregiver Information Form (JV-290) with the summary of their recommendation to the childs foster parents, relative caregivers, or foster parents approved for adoption, in the caregivers primary language when available, along with information on how to file the form with the court. The form and summary of the recommendation may be served electronically pursuant to Section 212.5.
(d)Prior to any hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a community care facility or a foster family agency that may result in the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, or in adoption or the creation of a legal guardianship, or in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, the facility or agency shall file with the court a report, or a Judicial Councils Caregiver Information Form (JV-290), containing its recommendation for disposition. Prior to the hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a foster parent, a relative caregiver, or a certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, the foster parent, relative caregiver, or the certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, may file with the court a report containing their recommendation for disposition. The court shall consider the report and recommendation filed pursuant to this subdivision prior to determining any disposition.
(e)(1)At the review hearing held 6 months after the initial dispositional hearing, but no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care as determined in Section 361.49, whichever occurs earlier, after considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental or would not be detrimental. The court also shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366; and, when relevant, shall order any additional services reasonably believed to facilitate the return of the child to the custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall also inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the 12-month permanency hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. This section does not apply in a case in which, pursuant to Section 361.5, the court has ordered that reunification services shall not be provided.
(3)If the child was under three years of age on the date of the initial removal, or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent failed to participate regularly and make substantive progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. If, however, the court finds there is a substantial probability that the child, who was under three years of age on the date of initial removal or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, may be returned to their parent or legal guardian within six months or that reasonable services have not been provided, the court shall continue the case to the 12-month permanency hearing.
(4)For the purpose of placing and maintaining a sibling group together in a permanent home, the court, in making its determination to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 for some or all members of a sibling group, as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations. Factors the report shall address, and the court shall consider, may include, but need not be limited to, whether the sibling group was removed from parental care as a group, the closeness and strength of the sibling bond, the ages of the siblings, the appropriateness of maintaining the sibling group together, the detriment to the child if sibling ties are not maintained, the likelihood of finding a permanent home for the sibling group, whether the sibling group is currently placed together in a preadoptive home or has a concurrent plan goal of legal permanency in the same home, the wishes of each child whose age and physical and emotional condition permits a meaningful response, and the best interests of each child in the sibling group. The court shall specify the factual basis for its finding that it is in the best interests of each child to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days for some or all of the members of the sibling group.
(5)If the child was removed initially under subdivision (g) of Section 300 and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the whereabouts of the parent are still unknown, or the parent has failed to contact and visit the child, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. The court shall take into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents incarceration, institutionalization, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation. If the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent has been convicted of a felony indicating parental unfitness, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days.
(6)If the child had been placed under court supervision with a previously noncustodial parent pursuant to Section 361.2, the court shall determine whether supervision is still necessary. The court may terminate supervision and transfer permanent custody to that parent, as provided for by paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 361.2.
(7)In all other cases, the court shall direct that any reunification services previously ordered shall continue to be offered to the parent or legal guardian pursuant to the time periods set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, provided that the court may modify the terms and conditions of those services.
(8)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian in overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and the continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall order that those services be initiated, continued, or terminated.
(f)(1)The permanency hearing shall be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care, as that date is determined pursuant to Section 361.49. At the permanency hearing, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the child, which shall include a determination of whether the child will be returned to the childs home and, if so, when, within the time limits of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment.
(A)At the permanency hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian to overcome the problems that led to the initial removal and continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(B)The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment.
(C)In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5, shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child, and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(D)For each youth 16 years of age and older, the court shall also determine whether services have been made available to assist them in making the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental. The court also shall make a finding pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state placement options. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(g)If the time period in which the court-ordered services were provided has met or exceeded the time period set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, as appropriate, and a child is not returned to the custody of a parent or legal guardian at the permanency hearing held pursuant to subdivision (f), the court shall do one of the following:
(1)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(i)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(ii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the next permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(2)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, if the parent has been arrested and issued an immigration hold, detained by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deported to their country of origin, and the court determines either that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian.
(3)For purposes of paragraph (2), in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall find all of the following:
(A)The parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child, taking into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents arrest and receipt of an immigration hold, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation.
(B)The parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving the problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity or ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(4)Order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to Section 366.26, but only if the court does not continue the case to the permanency planning review hearing and there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents or legal guardians. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan.
(5)Order that the child remain in foster care, but only if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. For purposes of this section, a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency that adoption is not in the best interests of the child shall constitute a compelling reason for the courts determination. That recommendation shall be based on the present circumstances of the child and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the childs circumstances change. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement.
(A)The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. When the child is under 16 years of age, the court shall order a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. When the child is 16 years of age or older, or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501.
(B)If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained.
(C)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(h)In any case in which the court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall also order the termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child pending the hearing unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall make any other appropriate orders to enable the child to maintain relationships with individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests. When the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall also order that the childs caregiver receive the childs birth certificate in accordance with Sections 16010.4 and 16010.5. Additionally, when the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall order, when appropriate, that a child who is 16 years of age or older receive their birth certificate.
(i)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents or legal guardians.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents or legal guardians and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purpose of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including the prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)A description of efforts to be made to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment and listing on an adoption exchange within the state or out of the state.
(G)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(H)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (G), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(j)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(k)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
(l)For purposes of this section, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of itself, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(1)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(2)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(3)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
SEC. 2.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(1)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(2)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(3)(A)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(B)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(C)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 2.5.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian.
(2)(A)Except as provided in paragraph (1) and subject to subparagraph (B), if the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court finds that reasonable services have not been provided, or, in the case of an Indian child, active efforts as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 224.1 have not been made, the court shall extend reunification services for an additional six months.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence based on competent evidence from a mental health professional that extending the time period for reunification services would be detrimental to the child, the court is not required to extend reunification services for an additional six months. The court shall state, either on the record or in writing, the reasons for its finding. Neither the passage of time nor the childs relationship with the caregiver shall be grounds, in and of themselves, for the denial of further reunification services.
(3)The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian, or, in the case of an Indian child, that active efforts as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 224.1 have not been made. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)(i)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(ii)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(iii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 3.Section 366.25 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.25.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 366.22, the subsequent permanency review hearing shall occur within 24 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of a parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or, in the case of a child 16 years of age or older when no other permanent plan is appropriate, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, then the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the subsequent permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this paragraph, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of, and nature of, any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this paragraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(c)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(d)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 4.Section 2.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code proposed by both this bill and Assembly Bill 937. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2024, (2) each bill amends Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 937, in which case Section 2 of this bill shall not become operative.
(a)Every hearing conducted by the juvenile court reviewing the status of a dependent child shall be placed on the appearance calendar. The court shall advise all persons present at the hearing of the date of the future hearing and of their right to be present and represented by counsel.
(b)Except as provided in Sections 294 and 295, notice of the hearing shall be provided pursuant to Section 293.
(c)At least 10 calendar days before the hearing, the social worker shall file a supplemental report with the court regarding the services provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian to enable them to assume custody and the efforts made to achieve legal permanence for the child if efforts to reunify fail, including, but not limited to, efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests; the progress made; and, where relevant, the prognosis for return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian; and shall make their recommendation for disposition. If the child is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, the report and recommendation may also take into account those factors described in subdivision (e) relating to the childs sibling group. If the recommendation is not to return the child to a parent or legal guardian, the report shall specify why the return of the child would be detrimental to the child. The social worker shall provide the parent or legal guardian, counsel for the child, and any court-appointed child advocate with a copy of the report, including their recommendation for disposition, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing. The report may be served pursuant to Section 212.5. In the case of a child removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, the social worker shall, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing, provide a summary of their recommendation for disposition to any foster parents, relative caregivers, and certified foster parents who have been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, community care facility, or foster family agency having the physical custody of the child. The social worker shall include a copy of the Judicial Councils Caregiver Information Form (JV-290) with the summary of their recommendation to the childs foster parents, relative caregivers, or foster parents approved for adoption, in the caregivers primary language when available, along with information on how to file the form with the court. The form and summary of the recommendation may be served electronically pursuant to Section 212.5.
(d)Prior to any hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a community care facility or a foster family agency that may result in the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, or in adoption or the creation of a legal guardianship, or in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, the facility or agency shall file with the court a report, or a Judicial Councils Caregiver Information Form (JV-290), containing its recommendation for disposition. Prior to the hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a foster parent, a relative caregiver, or a certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, the foster parent, relative caregiver, or the certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, may file with the court a report containing their recommendation for disposition. The court shall consider the report and recommendation filed pursuant to this subdivision prior to determining any disposition.
(e)(1)At the review hearing held 6 months after the initial dispositional hearing, but no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care as determined in Section 361.49, whichever occurs earlier, after considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental or would not be detrimental. The court also shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366; and, when relevant, shall order any additional services reasonably believed to facilitate the return of the child to the custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall also inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the 12-month permanency hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. This section does not apply in a case in which, pursuant to Section 361.5, the court has ordered that reunification services shall not be provided.
(3)If the child was under three years of age on the date of the initial removal, or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent failed to participate regularly and make substantive progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. If, however, the court finds there is a substantial probability that the child, who was under three years of age on the date of initial removal or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, may be returned to their parent or legal guardian within six months or that reasonable services have not been provided, the court shall continue the case to the 12-month permanency hearing.
(4)For the purpose of placing and maintaining a sibling group together in a permanent home, the court, in making its determination to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 for some or all members of a sibling group, as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations. Factors the report shall address, and the court shall consider, may include, but need not be limited to, whether the sibling group was removed from parental care as a group, the closeness and strength of the sibling bond, the ages of the siblings, the appropriateness of maintaining the sibling group together, the detriment to the child if sibling ties are not maintained, the likelihood of finding a permanent home for the sibling group, whether the sibling group is currently placed together in a preadoptive home or has a concurrent plan goal of legal permanency in the same home, the wishes of each child whose age and physical and emotional condition permits a meaningful response, and the best interests of each child in the sibling group. The court shall specify the factual basis for its finding that it is in the best interests of each child to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days for some or all of the members of the sibling group.
(5)If the child was removed initially under subdivision (g) of Section 300 and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the whereabouts of the parent are still unknown, or the parent has failed to contact and visit the child, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. The court shall take into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents incarceration, institutionalization, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation. If the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent has been convicted of a felony indicating parental unfitness, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days.
(6)If the child had been placed under court supervision with a previously noncustodial parent pursuant to Section 361.2, the court shall determine whether supervision is still necessary. The court may terminate supervision and transfer permanent custody to that parent, as provided for by paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 361.2.
(7)In all other cases, the court shall direct that any reunification services previously ordered shall continue to be offered to the parent or legal guardian pursuant to the time periods set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, provided that the court may modify the terms and conditions of those services.
(8)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian in overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and the continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall order that those services be initiated, continued, or terminated.
(f)(1)The permanency hearing shall be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care, as that date is determined pursuant to Section 361.49. At the permanency hearing, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the child, which shall include a determination of whether the child will be returned to the childs home and, if so, when, within the time limits of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment.
(A)At the permanency hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian to overcome the problems that led to the initial removal and continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(B)The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment.
(C)In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5, shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child, and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(D)For each youth 16 years of age and older, the court shall also determine whether services have been made available to assist them in making the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental. The court also shall make a finding pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state placement options. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(g)If the time period in which the court-ordered services were provided has met or exceeded the time period set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, as appropriate, and a child is not returned to the custody of a parent or legal guardian at the permanency hearing held pursuant to subdivision (f), the court shall do one of the following:
(1)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(i)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(ii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the next permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(2)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, if the parent has been arrested and issued an immigration hold, detained by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deported to their country of origin, and the court determines either that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian.
(3)For purposes of paragraph (2), in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall find all of the following:
(A)The parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child, taking into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents arrest and receipt of an immigration hold, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation.
(B)The parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving the problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity or ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(4)Order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to Section 366.26, but only if the court does not continue the case to the permanency planning review hearing and there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents or legal guardians. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan.
(5)Order that the child remain in foster care, but only if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. For purposes of this section, a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency that adoption is not in the best interests of the child shall constitute a compelling reason for the courts determination. That recommendation shall be based on the present circumstances of the child and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the childs circumstances change. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement.
(A)The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. When the child is under 16 years of age, the court shall order a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. When the child is 16 years of age or older, or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501.
(B)If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained.
(C)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(h)In any case in which the court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall also order the termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child pending the hearing unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall make any other appropriate orders to enable the child to maintain relationships with individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests. When the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall also order that the childs caregiver receive the childs birth certificate in accordance with Sections 16010.4 and 16010.5. Additionally, when the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall order, when appropriate, that a child who is 16 years of age or older receive their birth certificate.
(i)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents or legal guardians.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents or legal guardians and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purpose of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including the prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)A description of efforts to be made to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment and listing on an adoption exchange within the state or out of the state.
(G)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(H)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (G), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(j)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(k)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
(l)For purposes of this section, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of itself, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(1)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(2)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(3)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
SEC. 2.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(1)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(2)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(3)(A)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(B)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(C)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 2.5.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian.
(2)(A)Except as provided in paragraph (1) and subject to subparagraph (B), if the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court finds that reasonable services have not been provided, or, in the case of an Indian child, active efforts as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 224.1 have not been made, the court shall extend reunification services for an additional six months.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence based on competent evidence from a mental health professional that extending the time period for reunification services would be detrimental to the child, the court is not required to extend reunification services for an additional six months. The court shall state, either on the record or in writing, the reasons for its finding. Neither the passage of time nor the childs relationship with the caregiver shall be grounds, in and of themselves, for the denial of further reunification services.
(3)The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian, or, in the case of an Indian child, that active efforts as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 224.1 have not been made. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)(i)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(ii)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(iii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 3.Section 366.25 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.25.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 366.22, the subsequent permanency review hearing shall occur within 24 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of a parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or, in the case of a child 16 years of age or older when no other permanent plan is appropriate, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, then the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the subsequent permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this paragraph, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of, and nature of, any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this paragraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(c)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(d)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 4.Section 2.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code proposed by both this bill and Assembly Bill 937. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2024, (2) each bill amends Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 937, in which case Section 2 of this bill shall not become operative.
(a)Every hearing conducted by the juvenile court reviewing the status of a dependent child shall be placed on the appearance calendar. The court shall advise all persons present at the hearing of the date of the future hearing and of their right to be present and represented by counsel.
(b)Except as provided in Sections 294 and 295, notice of the hearing shall be provided pursuant to Section 293.
(c)At least 10 calendar days before the hearing, the social worker shall file a supplemental report with the court regarding the services provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian to enable them to assume custody and the efforts made to achieve legal permanence for the child if efforts to reunify fail, including, but not limited to, efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests; the progress made; and, where relevant, the prognosis for return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian; and shall make their recommendation for disposition. If the child is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, the report and recommendation may also take into account those factors described in subdivision (e) relating to the childs sibling group. If the recommendation is not to return the child to a parent or legal guardian, the report shall specify why the return of the child would be detrimental to the child. The social worker shall provide the parent or legal guardian, counsel for the child, and any court-appointed child advocate with a copy of the report, including their recommendation for disposition, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing. The report may be served pursuant to Section 212.5. In the case of a child removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, the social worker shall, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing, provide a summary of their recommendation for disposition to any foster parents, relative caregivers, and certified foster parents who have been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, community care facility, or foster family agency having the physical custody of the child. The social worker shall include a copy of the Judicial Council Councils Caregiver Information Form (JV-290) with the summary of their recommendation to the childs foster parents, relative caregivers, or foster parents approved for adoption, in the caregivers primary language when available, along with information on how to file the form with the court. The form and summary of the recommendation may be served electronically pursuant to Section 212.5.
(d)Prior to any hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a community care facility or a foster family agency that may result in the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, or in adoption or the creation of a legal guardianship, or in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, the facility or agency shall file with the court a report, or a Judicial Council Councils Caregiver Information Form (JV-290), containing its recommendation for disposition. Prior to the hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a foster parent, a relative caregiver, or a certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, the foster parent, relative caregiver, or the certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, may file with the court a report containing their recommendation for disposition. The court shall consider the report and recommendation filed pursuant to this subdivision prior to determining any disposition.
(e)(1)At the review hearing held 6 months after the initial dispositional hearing, but no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care as determined in Section 361.49, whichever occurs earlier, after considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental or would not be detrimental. The court also shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366; and, when relevant, shall order any additional services reasonably believed to facilitate the return of the child to the custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall also inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the 12-month permanency hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. This section does not apply in a case in which, pursuant to Section 361.5, the court has ordered that reunification services shall not be provided.
(3)If the child was under three years of age on the date of the initial removal, or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent failed to participate regularly and make substantive progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. If, however, the court finds there is a substantial probability that the child, who was under three years of age on the date of initial removal or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, may be returned to their parent or legal guardian within six months or that reasonable services have not been provided, the court shall continue the case to the 12-month permanency hearing.
(4)For the purpose of placing and maintaining a sibling group together in a permanent home, the court, in making its determination to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 for some or all members of a sibling group, as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations. Factors the report shall address, and the court shall consider, may include, but need not be limited to, whether the sibling group was removed from parental care as a group, the closeness and strength of the sibling bond, the ages of the siblings, the appropriateness of maintaining the sibling group together, the detriment to the child if sibling ties are not maintained, the likelihood of finding a permanent home for the sibling group, whether the sibling group is currently placed together in a preadoptive home or has a concurrent plan goal of legal permanency in the same home, the wishes of each child whose age and physical and emotional condition permits a meaningful response, and the best interests of each child in the sibling group. The court shall specify the factual basis for its finding that it is in the best interests of each child to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days for some or all of the members of the sibling group.
(5)If the child was removed initially under subdivision (g) of Section 300 and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the whereabouts of the parent are still unknown, or the parent has failed to contact and visit the child, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. The court shall take into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents incarceration, institutionalization, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation. If the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent has been convicted of a felony indicating parental unfitness, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days.
(6)If the child had been placed under court supervision with a previously noncustodial parent pursuant to Section 361.2, the court shall determine whether supervision is still necessary. The court may terminate supervision and transfer permanent custody to that parent, as provided for by paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 361.2.
(7)In all other cases, the court shall direct that any reunification services previously ordered shall continue to be offered to the parent or legal guardian pursuant to the time periods set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, provided that the court may modify the terms and conditions of those services.
(8)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian in overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and the continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall order that those services be initiated, continued, or terminated.
(f)(1)The permanency hearing shall be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care, as that date is determined pursuant to Section 361.49. At the permanency hearing, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the child, which shall include a determination of whether the child will be returned to the childs home and, if so, when, within the time limits of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment.
(A)At the permanency hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian to overcome the problems that led to the initial removal and continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(B)The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment.
(C)In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5, shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child, and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(D)For each youth 16 years of age and older, the court shall also determine whether services have been made available to assist them in making the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental. The court also shall make a finding pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state placement options. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(g)If the time period in which the court-ordered services were provided has met or exceeded the time period set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, as appropriate, and a child is not returned to the custody of a parent or legal guardian at the permanency hearing held pursuant to subdivision (f), the court shall do one of the following:
(1)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(i)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(ii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the next permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(2)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, if the parent has been arrested and issued an immigration hold, detained by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deported to their country of origin, and the court determines either that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian.
(3)For purposes of paragraph (2), in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall find all of the following:
(A)The parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child, taking into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents arrest and receipt of an immigration hold, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation.
(B)The parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving the problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity or ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(4)Order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to Section 366.26, but only if the court does not continue the case to the permanency planning review hearing and there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents or legal guardians. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan.
(5)Order that the child remain in foster care, but only if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. For purposes of this section, a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency that adoption is not in the best interests of the child shall constitute a compelling reason for the courts determination. That recommendation shall be based on the present circumstances of the child and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the childs circumstances change. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement.
(A)The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. When the child is under 16 years of age, the court shall order a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. When the child is 16 years of age or older, or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501.
(B)If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained.
(C)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(h)In any case in which the court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall also order the termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child pending the hearing unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall make any other appropriate orders to enable the child to maintain relationships with individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests. When the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall also order that the childs caregiver receive the childs birth certificate in accordance with Sections 16010.4 and 16010.5. Additionally, when the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall order, when appropriate, that a child who is 16 years of age or older receive their birth certificate.
(i)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents or legal guardians.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents or legal guardians and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purpose of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including the prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)A description of efforts to be made to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment and listing on an adoption exchange within the state or out of the state.
(G)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(H)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (G), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(j)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(k)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
(l)For purposes of this section, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of itself, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(1)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(2)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(3)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
SEC. 2.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(1)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(2)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(3)(A)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(B)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(C)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 2.5.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(2)(A)Except as provided in paragraph (1) and subject to subparagraph (B), if the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court finds that reasonable services have not been provided, or, in the case of an Indian child, active efforts as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 224.1 have not been made, the court shall extend reunification services for an additional six months.
(B)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence based on competent evidence from a mental health professional that extending the time period for reunification services would be detrimental to the child, the court is not required to extend reunification services for an additional six months. The court shall state, either on the record or in writing, the reasons for its finding. Neither the passage of time nor the childs relationship with the caregiver shall be grounds, in and of themselves, for the denial of further reunification services.
(3)The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian, or, in the case of an Indian child, that active efforts as defined in subdivision (f) of Section 224.1 have not been made. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(1)(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(2)(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(3)(A)(C)(i)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(B)(ii)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(C)(iii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 3.Section 366.25 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.25.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 366.22, the subsequent permanency review hearing shall occur within 24 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of a parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or, in the case of a child 16 years of age or older when no other permanent plan is appropriate, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, then the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the subsequent permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this paragraph, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of, and nature of, any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this paragraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(c)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(d)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 4.Section 2.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code proposed by both this bill and Assembly Bill 937. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2024, (2) each bill amends Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 937, in which case Section 2 of this bill shall not become operative.
(a)Every hearing conducted by the juvenile court reviewing the status of a dependent child shall be placed on the appearance calendar. The court shall advise all persons present at the hearing of the date of the future hearing and of their right to be present and represented by counsel.
(b)Except as provided in Sections 294 and 295, notice of the hearing shall be provided pursuant to Section 293.
(c)At least 10 calendar days before the hearing, the social worker shall file a supplemental report with the court regarding the services provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian to enable them to assume custody and the efforts made to achieve legal permanence for the child if efforts to reunify fail, including, but not limited to, efforts to maintain relationships between a child who is 10 years of age or older and has been in out-of-home placement for six months or longer and individuals who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests; the progress made; and, where relevant, the prognosis for return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian; and shall make their recommendation for disposition. If the child is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, the report and recommendation may also take into account those factors described in subdivision (e) relating to the childs sibling group. If the recommendation is not to return the child to a parent or legal guardian, the report shall specify why the return of the child would be detrimental to the child. The social worker shall provide the parent or legal guardian, counsel for the child, and any court-appointed child advocate with a copy of the report, including their recommendation for disposition, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing. The report may be served pursuant to Section 212.5. In the case of a child removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, the social worker shall, at least 10 calendar days before the hearing, provide a summary of their recommendation for disposition to any foster parents, relative caregivers, and certified foster parents who have been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, community care facility, or foster family agency having the physical custody of the child. The social worker shall include a copy of the Judicial Council Caregiver Information Form (JV-290) with the summary of their recommendation to the childs foster parents, relative caregivers, or foster parents approved for adoption, in the caregivers primary language when available, along with information on how to file the form with the court. The form and summary of the recommendation may be served electronically pursuant to Section 212.5.
(d)Prior to any hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a community care facility or a foster family agency that may result in the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, or in adoption or the creation of a legal guardianship, or in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, the facility or agency shall file with the court a report, or a Judicial Council Caregiver Information Form (JV-290), containing its recommendation for disposition. Prior to the hearing involving a child in the physical custody of a foster parent, a relative caregiver, or a certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, the foster parent, relative caregiver, or the certified foster parent who has been approved for adoption by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, may file with the court a report containing their recommendation for disposition. The court shall consider the report and recommendation filed pursuant to this subdivision prior to determining any disposition.
(e)(1)At the review hearing held 6 months after the initial dispositional hearing, but no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care as determined in Section 361.49, whichever occurs earlier, after considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; and shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental or would not be detrimental. The court also shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366; and, when relevant, shall order any additional services reasonably believed to facilitate the return of the child to the custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall also inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the 12-month permanency hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. This section does not apply in a case in which, pursuant to Section 361.5, the court has ordered that reunification services shall not be provided.
(3)If the child was under three years of age on the date of the initial removal, or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent failed to participate regularly and make substantive progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. If, however, the court finds there is a substantial probability that the child, who was under three years of age on the date of initial removal or is a member of a sibling group described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, may be returned to their parent or legal guardian within six months or that reasonable services have not been provided, the court shall continue the case to the 12-month permanency hearing.
(4)For the purpose of placing and maintaining a sibling group together in a permanent home, the court, in making its determination to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 for some or all members of a sibling group, as described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations. Factors the report shall address, and the court shall consider, may include, but need not be limited to, whether the sibling group was removed from parental care as a group, the closeness and strength of the sibling bond, the ages of the siblings, the appropriateness of maintaining the sibling group together, the detriment to the child if sibling ties are not maintained, the likelihood of finding a permanent home for the sibling group, whether the sibling group is currently placed together in a preadoptive home or has a concurrent plan goal of legal permanency in the same home, the wishes of each child whose age and physical and emotional condition permits a meaningful response, and the best interests of each child in the sibling group. The court shall specify the factual basis for its finding that it is in the best interests of each child to schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days for some or all of the members of the sibling group.
(5)If the child was removed initially under subdivision (g) of Section 300 and the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the whereabouts of the parent are still unknown, or the parent has failed to contact and visit the child, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days. The court shall take into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents incarceration, institutionalization, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation. If the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the parent has been convicted of a felony indicating parental unfitness, the court may schedule a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 within 120 days.
(6)If the child had been placed under court supervision with a previously noncustodial parent pursuant to Section 361.2, the court shall determine whether supervision is still necessary. The court may terminate supervision and transfer permanent custody to that parent, as provided for by paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 361.2.
(7)In all other cases, the court shall direct that any reunification services previously ordered shall continue to be offered to the parent or legal guardian pursuant to the time periods set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, provided that the court may modify the terms and conditions of those services.
(8)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian in overcoming the problems that led to the initial removal and the continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall order that those services be initiated, continued, or terminated.
(f)(1)The permanency hearing shall be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care, as that date is determined pursuant to Section 361.49. At the permanency hearing, the court shall determine the permanent plan for the child, which shall include a determination of whether the child will be returned to the childs home and, if so, when, within the time limits of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment.
(A)At the permanency hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent or legal guardian to overcome the problems that led to the initial removal and continued custody of the child have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(B)The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental.
(C)In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5, shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers to a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child, and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(D)For each youth 16 years of age and older, the court shall also determine whether services have been made available to assist them in making the transition from foster care to successful adulthood.
(2)Regardless of whether the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that the return would be detrimental. The court also shall make a finding pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state placement options. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(g)If the time period in which the court-ordered services were provided has met or exceeded the time period set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 361.5, as appropriate, and a child is not returned to the custody of a parent or legal guardian at the permanency hearing held pursuant to subdivision (f), the court shall do one of the following:
(1)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(A)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(B)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(i)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(ii)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the next permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(2)Continue the case for up to six months for a permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 18 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian, if the parent has been arrested and issued an immigration hold, detained by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deported to their country of origin, and the court determines either that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian.
(3)For purposes of paragraph (2), in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall find all of the following:
(A)The parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child, taking into account any particular barriers to a parents ability to maintain contact with their child due to the parents arrest and receipt of an immigration hold, detention by the United States Department of Homeland Security, or deportation.
(B)The parent or legal guardian has made significant progress in resolving the problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(C)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity or ability both to complete the objectives of their treatment plan and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(4)Order that a hearing be held within 120 days, pursuant to Section 366.26, but only if the court does not continue the case to the permanency planning review hearing and there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents or legal guardians. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan.
(5)Order that the child remain in foster care, but only if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based upon the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date. For purposes of this section, a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency that adoption is not in the best interests of the child shall constitute a compelling reason for the courts determination. That recommendation shall be based on the present circumstances of the child and shall not preclude a different recommendation at a later date if the childs circumstances change. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement.
(A)The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. When the child is under 16 years of age, the court shall order a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. When the child is 16 years of age or older, or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501.
(B)If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained.
(C)If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(h)In any case in which the court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall also order the termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child pending the hearing unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall make any other appropriate orders to enable the child to maintain relationships with individuals, other than the childs siblings, who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests. When the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall also order that the childs caregiver receive the childs birth certificate in accordance with Sections 16010.4 and 16010.5. Additionally, when the court orders a termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian, it shall order, when appropriate, that a child who is 16 years of age or older receive their birth certificate.
(i)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents or legal guardians.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents or legal guardians and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purpose of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including the prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)A description of efforts to be made to identify a prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including, but not limited to, child-specific recruitment and listing on an adoption exchange within the state or out of the state.
(G)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(H)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (G), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(j)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(k)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
(l)For purposes of this section, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of itself, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(1)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(2)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(3)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
SEC. 2.Section 366.22 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.22.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, the permanency review hearing shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. After considering the admissible and relevant evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal, to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or the parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding their child, provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided, taking into account the particular barriers of a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent, or an incarcerated or institutionalized parents or legal guardians access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with their child; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider, and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)Unless the conditions in subdivision (b) are met and the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, in consultation with the childs tribe, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or continued placement in foster care is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child, and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this subdivision, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing and the court determines by clear and convincing evidence that the best interests of the child would be met by the provision of additional reunification services to a parent or legal guardian who is making significant and consistent progress in a court-ordered residential substance abuse treatment program, a parent who was either a minor parent or a nonminor dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, or a parent recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, or the custody of the United States Department of Homeland Security and making significant and consistent progress in establishing a safe home for the childs return, the court may continue the case for up to six months for a subsequent permanency review hearing, provided that the hearing shall occur within 24 months of the date the child was originally taken from the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue the case only if it finds that there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time or that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or legal guardian. For the purposes of this section, in order to find a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian and safely maintained in the home within the extended period of time, the court shall be required to find all of the following:
(1)That the parent or legal guardian has consistently and regularly contacted and visited with the child.
(2)That the parent or legal guardian has made significant and consistent progress in the prior 18 months in resolving problems that led to the childs removal from the home.
(3)(A)The parent or legal guardian has demonstrated the capacity and ability both to complete the objectives of their substance abuse treatment plan as evidenced by reports from a substance abuse provider as applicable, or complete a treatment plan postdischarge from incarceration, institutionalization, or detention, or following deportation to their country of origin and their return to the United States, and to provide for the childs safety, protection, physical and emotional well-being, and special needs.
(B)For purposes of this subdivision, the courts decision to continue the case based on a finding or substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of their parent or legal guardian is a compelling reason for determining that a hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26 is not in the best interests of the child.
(C)The court shall inform the parent or legal guardian that if the child cannot be returned home by the subsequent permanency review hearing, a proceeding pursuant to Section 366.26 may be instituted. The court shall not order that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 be held unless there is clear and convincing evidence that reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parent or legal guardian.
(c)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26, including when a tribal customary adoption is recommended, shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of and nature of any contact between the child and their parents and other members of their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this subparagraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)(i)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(ii)The evaluation pursuant to clause (i) shall include, but is not limited to, providing a copy of the complete health and education summary as required under Section 16010, including the name and contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child.
(iii)In instances where it is determined that disclosure pursuant to clause (ii) of the contact information of the person or persons currently holding the right to make educational decisions for the child poses a threat to the health and safety of that individual or those individuals, that contact information shall be redacted or withheld from the evaluation.
(D) A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 1999. If at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a legal guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(e)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the child by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
SEC. 3.Section 366.25 of the Welfare and Institutions Code is amended to read:366.25.(a)(1)When a case has been continued pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 366.22, the subsequent permanency review hearing shall occur within 24 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of his or her their parent or legal guardian. After considering the relevant and admissible evidence, the court shall order the return of the child to the physical custody of his or her their parent or legal guardian unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child to his or her their parent or legal guardian would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child. The social worker shall have the burden of establishing that detriment. At the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall consider the criminal history, obtained pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 16504.5, of the parent or legal guardian subsequent to the childs removal to the extent that the criminal record is substantially related to the welfare of the child or parents or legal guardians ability to exercise custody and control regarding his or her their child provided that the parent or legal guardian agreed to submit fingerprint images to obtain criminal history information as part of the case plan. The court shall also consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of a parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with his or her their parent. The fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. In making its determination, the court shall review and consider the social workers report and recommendations and the report and recommendations of any child advocate appointed pursuant to Section 356.5; shall consider the efforts or progress, or both, demonstrated by the parent or legal guardian and the extent to which he or she availed himself or herself they availed themselves of services provided; and shall make appropriate findings pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 366.
(2)Whether or not the child is returned to his or her their parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its decision. If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian, the court shall specify the factual basis for its conclusion that return would be detrimental. If the child is not returned to his or her their parent or legal guardian, the court shall consider and state for the record, in-state and out-of-state options for the childs permanent placement. If the child is placed out of the state, the court shall make a determination whether the out-of-state placement continues to be appropriate and in the best interests of the child.
(3)If the child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the subsequent permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26 in order to determine whether adoption, or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, guardianship, or, in the case of a child 16 years of age or older when no other permanent plan is appropriate, another planned permanent living arrangement is the most appropriate plan for the child. On and after January 1, 2012, a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall not be ordered if the child is a nonminor dependent, unless the nonminor dependent is an Indian child and tribal customary adoption is recommended as the permanent plan. However, if the court finds by clear and convincing evidence, based on the evidence already presented to it, including a recommendation by the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency or by a county adoption agency, that there is a compelling reason, as described in paragraph (5) of subdivision (g) of Section 366.21, for determining that a hearing held under Section 366.26 is not in the best interest of the child because the child is not a proper subject for adoption or, in the case of an Indian child, tribal customary adoption, and has no one willing to accept legal guardianship as of the hearing date, then the court may, only under these circumstances, order that the child remain in foster care with a permanent plan of return home, adoption, tribal customary adoption in the case of an Indian child, legal guardianship, or placement with a fit and willing relative, as appropriate. If the child is 16 years of age or older or is a nonminor dependent, and no other permanent plan is appropriate at the time of the hearing, the court may order another planned permanent living arrangement, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (i) of Section 16501. The court shall make factual findings identifying any barriers to achieving the permanent plan as of the hearing date. On and after January 1, 2012, the nonminor dependents legal status as an adult is in and of itself a compelling reason not to hold a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26. The court may order that a nonminor dependent who otherwise is eligible pursuant to Section 11403 remain in a planned, permanent living arrangement. If the court orders that a child who is 10 years of age or older remain in foster care, the court shall determine whether the agency has made reasonable efforts to maintain the childs relationships with individuals other than the childs siblings who are important to the child, consistent with the childs best interests, and may make any appropriate order to ensure that those relationships are maintained. The hearing shall be held no later than 120 days from the date of the subsequent permanency review hearing. The court shall also order termination of reunification services to the parent or legal guardian. The court shall continue to permit the parent or legal guardian to visit the child unless it finds that visitation would be detrimental to the child. The court shall determine whether reasonable services have been offered or provided to the parent or legal guardian. For purposes of this paragraph, evidence of any of the following circumstances shall not, in and of themselves, be deemed a failure to provide or offer reasonable services:
(A)The child has been placed with a foster family that is eligible to adopt a child, or has been placed in a preadoptive home.
(B)The case plan includes services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child if efforts to reunify fail.
(C)Services to make and finalize a permanent placement for the child, if efforts to reunify fail, are provided concurrently with services to reunify the family.
(b)(1)Whenever a court orders that a hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 shall be held, it shall direct the agency supervising the child and the county adoption agency, or the State Department of Social Services when it is acting as an adoption agency, to prepare an assessment that shall include:
(A)Current search efforts for an absent parent or parents.
(B)A review of the amount of, and nature of, any contact between the child and his or her their parents and other members of his or her their extended family since the time of placement. Although the extended family of each child shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, extended family for the purposes of this paragraph shall include, but not be limited to, the childs siblings, grandparents, aunts, and uncles.
(C)An evaluation of the childs medical, developmental, scholastic, mental, and emotional status.
(D)A preliminary assessment of the eligibility and commitment of any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, particularly the caretaker, to include a social history including screening for criminal records and prior referrals for child abuse or neglect, the capability to meet the childs needs, and the understanding of the legal and financial rights and responsibilities of adoption and guardianship. If a proposed legal guardian is a relative of the minor, the assessment shall also consider, but need not be limited to, all of the factors specified in subdivision (a) of Section 361.3 and in Section 361.4.
(E)The relationship of the child to any identified prospective adoptive parent or legal guardian, including a prospective tribal customary adoptive parent, the duration and character of the relationship, the degree of attachment of the child to the prospective relative guardian or adoptive parent, the relatives or adoptive parents strong commitment to caring permanently for the child, the motivation for seeking adoption or legal guardianship, a statement from the child concerning placement and the adoption or legal guardianship, and whether the child, if over 12 years of age, has been consulted about the proposed relative guardianship arrangements, unless the childs age or physical, emotional, or other condition precludes his or her their meaningful response, and if so, a description of the condition.
(F)An analysis of the likelihood that the child will be adopted if parental rights are terminated.
(G)In the case of an Indian child, in addition to subparagraphs (A) to (F), inclusive, an assessment of the likelihood that the child will be adopted, when, in consultation with the childs tribe, a tribal customary adoption, as defined in Section 366.24, is recommended. If tribal customary adoption is recommended, the assessment shall include an analysis of both of the following:
(i)Whether tribal customary adoption would or would not be detrimental to the Indian child and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(ii)Whether the Indian child cannot or should not be returned to the home of the Indian parent or Indian custodian and the reasons for reaching that conclusion.
(2)(A)A relative caregivers preference for legal guardianship over adoption, if it is due to circumstances that do not include an unwillingness to accept legal or financial responsibility for the child, shall not constitute the sole basis for recommending removal of the child from the relative caregiver for purposes of adoptive placement.
(B)Regardless of his or her their immigration status, a relative caregiver shall be given information regarding the permanency options of guardianship and adoption, including the long-term benefits and consequences of each option, prior to establishing legal guardianship or pursuing adoption. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, the relative caregiver shall be informed about the terms and conditions of the negotiated agreement pursuant to Section 11387 and shall agree to its execution prior to the hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26. A copy of the executed negotiated agreement shall be attached to the assessment.
(c)If, at any hearing held pursuant to Section 366.26, a guardianship is established for the minor with an approved relative caregiver, and juvenile court dependency is subsequently dismissed, the minor shall be eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided for in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11360) or Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385), as applicable, of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9.
(d)As used in this section, relative means an adult who is related to the minor by blood, adoption, or affinity within the fifth degree of kinship, including stepparents, stepsiblings, and all relatives whose status is preceded by the words great, great-great, or grand, or the spouse of any of those persons even if the marriage was terminated by death or dissolution. If the proposed permanent plan is guardianship with an approved relative caregiver for a minor eligible for aid under the Kin-GAP Program, as provided in Article 4.7 (commencing with Section 11385) of Chapter 2 of Part 3 of Division 9, relative as used in this section has the same meaning as relative as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 11391.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as introduced in the Senate, February 13, 2023. (JR11) REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.(a)The definitions Definitions contained in this section govern the construction of this division, unless the context requires otherwise. These definitions do not alter or impact the definitions or other provisions of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 15600)), or Chapter 13 (commencing with Section 15750), of Part 3 of Division 9.
(b)Abuse means any of the following:
(1)An act, or failure to act, that would constitute abuse as that term is defined in federal regulations pertaining to the authority of protection and advocacy agencies, including Section 51.2 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations or Section 1326.19 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(2)An act, or failure to act, that would constitute abuse as that term is defined in Section 15610.07 of this code or Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(3)An act, or failure to act, that was performed, or not performed, knowingly, recklessly, or intentionally, and that caused, or may have caused, injury or death to an individual with disabilities, which includes, but is not limited to, verbal, nonverbal, mental, and emotional harassment; rape or sexual assault; striking; the use of excessive force when placing the individual in bodily restraints; the use of bodily or chemical restraints that is not in compliance with federal and state laws and regulations, or any other practice that is likely to cause immediate physical or psychological harm or result in long-term harm if the practice continues.
(4)Any other violation of an individuals legal rights determined, in its discretion, by the protection and advocacy agency to be abuse, including, but not limited to, subjecting an individual to significant financial exploitation.
(c)Complaint has the same meaning as complaint as defined in federal statutes and regulations pertaining to the authority of protection and advocacy agencies, including Section 10802(1) of Title 42 of the United States Code, Section 51.2 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or Section 1386.19 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations. A complaint includes, but is not limited to, any report or communication, whether formal or informal, or written or oral, received by the protection and advocacy agency, including, but not limited to, media accounts, newspaper articles, electronic communications, and telephone calls, including anonymous telephone calls, from any source alleging abuse or neglect of an individual with a disability.
(d)Disability means a developmental disability, as defined in Section 15002(8) of Title 42 of the United States Code, a mental illness, as defined in Section 10802(4) of Title 42 of the United States Code, a disability within the meaning of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.), as defined in Section 12102(2) of Title 42 of the United States Code, or a disability within the meaning of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (Part 2.8 (commencing with Section 12900) of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), as defined in subdivision (j) or (l) of Section 12926 of the Government Code.
(e)Facility or program means a public or private facility, program, or service provider providing services, support, care, or treatment to persons with disabilities, even if only on an as-needed basis or under contractual arrangement. Facility, program, or service provider includes, but is not limited to, a hospital, a long-term health care facility, a community living arrangement for people with disabilities, including a group home, a board and care home, an individual residence or apartment of a person with a disability where services are provided, a day program, a juvenile detention facility, a homeless shelter, a facility used to house or detain persons for the purpose of civil immigration proceedings, a jail, or a prison, including all general areas, as well as special, mental health, or forensic units. The term includes any facility licensed under Division 2 (commencing with Section 1200) of the Health and Safety Code and any facility that is unlicensed but is not exempt from licensure as provided in subdivision (a) of Section 1503.5 of the Health and Safety Code. The term also includes, but is not limited to, a public or private school or other institution or program providing education, training, habilitation, recreation, therapeutic, or residential services to persons with disabilities.
(f)(1)(A)Guardian, conservator, limited conservator, or legal representative means a person, including the parent of a disabled minor who has legal custody of the minor, appointed by a state court or an authorized agency, as appropriate, or otherwise authorized by law, and regularly reviewed by the appointing court or agency, if required by law, to represent and advocate for the legal rights and interests of a person with a disability.
(B)These terms do not include a person acting solely as a representative payee, a person acting solely to handle financial matters, an executor or administrator of an estate, an attorney or other person acting on behalf of an individual with a disability solely in individual legal matters, or an official or the officials designee who is responsible for the provision of treatment, services, supports, or other assistance to an individual with a disability.
(2)With respect to an individual described under paragraph (2) of subdivision (i), the guardian, conservator, limited conservator, or legal representative is the person with the legal authority to consent to health or mental health care or treatment on behalf of the individual.
(3)With respect to an individual described under paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (i), the guardian, conservator, limited conservator, or legal representative is the person with the legal authority to make all decisions on behalf of the individual.
(g)Neglect means any of the following:
(1)A negligent act, or omission to act, that would constitute neglect as that term is defined in federal statutes and regulations pertaining to the authority of protection and advocacy agencies, including Section 10802(5) of Title 42 of the United States Code, Section 51.2 of Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or Section 1326.19 of Title 45 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
(2)A negligent act, or omission to act, that would constitute neglect as that term is defined in subdivision (b) of Section 15610.07 of this code or Section 11165.2 of the Penal Code.
(3)A negligent act, or omission to act, by an individual responsible for providing services, supports, or other assistance that caused, or may have caused, injury or death to an individual with a disability or that placed an individual with a disability at risk of injury or death, and includes, but is not limited to, the failure to establish or carry out an appropriate individual program plan or treatment plan, which includes a discharge plan; provide adequate nutrition, clothing, or health care to an individual with a disability; or provide a safe environment, which may include failing to maintain an adequate number of trained staff or failing to take appropriate steps to prevent self-abuse, harassment, or assault by a peer.
(h)Probable cause to believe that an individual has been or may be subject to abuse or neglect or that the health or safety of the individual is in serious and immediate jeopardy, exists when the protection and advocacy agency determines that it is objectively reasonable for a person to entertain that belief. The individual making a probable cause determination may base the decision on reasonable inferences drawn from their experience or training regarding similar incidents, conditions, or problems that are usually associated with abuse or neglect. Information supporting a probable cause determination may result from monitoring or other activities, including, but not limited to, media reports and newspaper articles.
(i)Protection and advocacy agency means the private nonprofit corporation designated by the Governor in this state pursuant to federal law for the protection and advocacy of the rights of persons with disabilities, including the following:
(1)People with developmental disabilities, as authorized under the federal Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act of 2000, contained in Chapter 144 (commencing with Section 15001) of Title 42 of the United States Code.
(2)People with mental illness, as authorized under the federal Protection and Advocacy for Mentally Ill Individuals Amendments Act of 1991, contained in Chapter 114 (commencing with Section 10801) of Title 42 of the United States Code.
(3)People with disabilities within the meaning of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) as defined in Section 12102(2) of Title 42 of the United States Code, who do not have a developmental disability as defined in Section 15002(8) of Title 42 of the United States Code, people with a mental illness as defined in Section 10802(4) of Title 42 of the United States Code, and who are receiving services under the federal Protection and Advocacy of Individual Rights Act as defined in Section 794e of Title 29 of the United States Code, or people with a disability within the meaning of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (Part 2.8 (commencing with Section 12900) of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code), as defined in subdivision (j) or (l) of Section 12926 of the Government Code.
(j)Reasonable unaccompanied access means access that permits the protection and advocacy agency, without undue interference, to monitor, inspect, and observe conditions in facilities and programs, to meet and communicate with residents and service recipients privately and confidentially on a regular basis, formally or informally, including, but not limited to, by telephone, mail, electronic mail, and in person, and to review records privately and confidentially, in a manner that minimizes interference with the activities of the facility, program, or service provider that respects privacy interests and honors requests to terminate an interview, and that does not jeopardize the physical health or safety of facility, program, or service provider staff, individuals with disabilities, service recipients, or protection and advocacy agency staff. Except as otherwise required by law, the protection and advocacy agency shall not be required to provide the name or other identifying information regarding the individual with a disability or staff with whom it plans to meet or justify or explain its interactions with those persons. Upon request of facility staff, the protection and advocacy agency shall provide the specific location or locations at a facility where it intends to monitor, inspect, or observe conditions and meet and communicate with residents or staff.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 10, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 714, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 10, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Sep 6, 2023 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 2422.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 60. Noes 12. Page 2933.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 28, 2023 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 28, 2023 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 17, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 16, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 3.) (August 16). |
| Jul 12, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (July 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 12, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jun 6, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on HUM. S. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (June 6). Re-referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| May 11, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and HUM. S. |
| May 1, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 1, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 961.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 25, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Apr 24, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to consent calendar. |
| Apr 14, 2023 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0. Page 686.) (April 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | Set for hearing April 11. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 22, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 6, 2023 | Unfinished Business SB463 Wahab et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 5, 2023 | SB 463 Wahab Senate Third Reading By Gipson | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Jun 6, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Human Services] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2023 | Consent Calendar SB463 Wahab et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| All Of Us Or None Orange County | ** Support | |
| A New Way of Life Reentry Project | ** Support | |
| Aouon Orange County | ** Support | |
| California Lawyers Association, Family Law Section Executive Committee | ** Support | |
| ChildrenS Law Center Of California | ** Support | |
| City Of Santa Clara | ** Support | |
| County of Santa Clara | ** Support | |
| Dependency Advocacy Center | ** Support | |
| Dependency Legal Services | ** Support | |
| Drug Policy Alliance | ** Support | |
| East Bay Family Defenders | ** Support | |
| Family Reunification, Equity, and Empowerment Project | ** Support | |
| Family Reunification Equity & Empowerment | ** Support | |
| First 5 Alameda County | ** Support | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. | ** Support | |
| National Center for Youth Law | ** Support | |
| Public Counsel | ** Support | |
| Starting Over, Inc. | ** Support | |
| western center on law and poverty | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 463 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 463
Author: Wahab (D), et al.
Amended: 8/28/23
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-0, 4/11/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Durazo, Laird, McGuire, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0, 5/1/23 (Consent)
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Blakespear, Glazer, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-12, 9/5/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Dependent children
SOURCE: County of Santa Clara
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
DIGEST:
This bill eliminates the evidentiary presumption in juvenile court that a parent or guardian’s lack of participation or progress in a treatment program endangers the child, for purposes of determining whether the child should be returned to the parent or guardian’s custody.
Assembly Amendments
add chaptering-out amendments to avoid a conflict with AB 937 (McKinnor, 2023).
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the juvenile court, which is intended to provide for the protection and safety of the public and minors falling under its jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 202, 245.)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from the custody of their parent or guardian[1] on the basis of enumerated forms of abuse or neglect. (Welf. Inst. Code, § 300(a)-(j).)
- Provides that the purpose of the juvenile court and the dependency system is to provide the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of that harm. This safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being may include provision of a full array of social and health services to help the child and family and to prevent the reabuse of children. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 300.2.)
- Requires, following the removal of a child from their parent’s custody, the juvenile court to hold an initial hearing at which the court determines whether custody may be resumed or what services should be offered to the parent that could facilitate the child’s return in the future.
- The court must make a determination on the record as to whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal of the child from their home, and whether there are available services that would prevent the need for further detention.
- In determining whether to return a child to the parent’s custody at this stage, the fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of substantial danger. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 311, 319.)
- Requires, in a case where a child remains out of their parent’s custody after the initial hearing in 4) and the long-term plan is to return the child to the parent’s custody, the court to order the social worker to provide child welfare services and family reunification services that will benefit the child, which can include court-ordered treatment programs for the parent. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 361.5.)
- Provides that, when a child has been kept out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 4), the court must hold periodic review hearings no less frequently than six months, starting six months after the initial dispositional hearing.
- For children three years of age and older, the court must return the child to their parent’s custody unless it finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.
- If the child was under three years of age at the date of removal is a member of a sibling group as specified, and the court determines the parent has not been participating and making progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a permanency hearing within 120 days. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366, 366.21(e).)
- Provides that, for a child who remains out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 6), the court may hold a permanency hearing no later than 12 months after the initial removal; the court may also continue the permanency hearing for up to two more six-month periods, so that the permanency hearing may be held, at a maximum, 24 months after the child was initially removed. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(f), (g), 366.22, 366.25.)
- Establishes that, at both review and permanency hearings, a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that returning the child to the parent’s custody would be detrimental. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22(a)(1), 366.25(a)(1).)
This bill:
- Eliminates, for purposes of status and permanency hearings conducted by the juvenile court, the provision making the failure of a parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to the parent.
- Makes nonsubstantive conforming changes.
- Includes chaptering-out amendments to avoid a conflict with AB 937 (McKinnor, 2023).
Comments
According to the author,
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. Under child welfare laws, a child who has been removed from the home must be returned to their parents at review hearings absent a showing that the return causes a risk of detriment to the child. However, those provisions are significantly diluted by a statement that failure of a parent to participate or make substantive progress in the court-ordered services is prima facie evidence of detriment.
While a parent’s lack of compliance is a red flag, there may be valid explanations, including illness, inability to get time off, or inability to pay. Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent’s level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be “compliant” or “cooperative.” This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.
SB 463 simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent’s lack of compliance.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill presents no significant state costs.
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/5/23)
County of Santa Clara (co-source)
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. (co-source)
A New Way of Life Reentry Project
All of Us or None Orange County
California Lawyers Association, Family Law Section Executive Committee
Children’s Law Center of California
Dependency Advocacy Center
Dependency Legal Services
Drug Policy Alliance
East Bay Family Defenders
Family Reunification, Equity, and Empowerment Project
First 5 Alameda County
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
National Center for Youth Law
Public Counsel
Starting Over, Inc.
Western Center on Law and Poverty
One individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/5/23)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.:
[I]f this bill is enacted, the court would still be statutorily required to consider the social worker’s report, the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian, and the extent to which they availed themselves of the services provided. SB 463 simply enables courts to make this holistic determination without being required to equate the parent’s level of compliance with the current risk posed to the child.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-12, 9/5/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alvarez, Arambula, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Alanis, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Lackey, Mathis, Joe Patterson, Sanchez
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Gallagher, Hoover, Jim Patterson, Quirk-Silva, Ta
Prepared by: Allison Whitt Meredith / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/5/23 15:51:21
**** END ****
Going forward, this analysis uses “parent” to include “guardian.” ↑
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 463
Author:(Wahab)
As Amended Ver:August 28, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Eliminates from current law a presumption that a parent's failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that return of the child to their parent's custody would be detrimental.
Major Provisions
- Eliminates, for purposes of status and permanency hearings conducted by the juvenile court, the provision making the failure of a parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to the parent.
- Makes nonsubstantive conforming changes.
COMMENTS
This bill, co-sponsored by the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., eliminates, at several points in existing law regarding the juvenile dependency court review process, a requirement that the juvenile court consider a parent's failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return of the child to the parent's custody would be detrimental.
Overview of child welfare services and juvenile dependency court. The dependency process begins when child abuse, neglect, or abandonment is reported to the local child welfare agency. A social worker with the child welfare agency investigates the allegation to determine if the child requires protection in order to ensure their safety. If so, the child welfare agency files a petition with the juvenile court to make the child a dependent of the court. If necessary, the social worker will remove the child from their home and take the child into protective custody.
At the subsequent court hearing, the court may elect to keep the child in, or return the child to, their home or remove the child from the home. Removal may either result in eventual reunification with the family, or the court may determine that an alternate permanent placement –including the options of guardianship or adoption – is more fitting. When reunification is not possible or appropriate, children are placed in the setting deemed least restrictive and most suitable; the court must give preference to potential placements with relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Throughout this system, there are multiple court hearings – including the detention hearing, the jurisdictional hearing and the dispositional hearing, followed by ongoing review hearings and the permanency hearing – where the custody of a child or their placement is evaluated, reviewed, and determined by the court, in consultation with the child's social worker appointed by the county and the child's attorney, to help provide the best possible support and services to the child.
As of October 1, 2022, more than 74,500 children were receiving services from county child welfare agencies in California. As of that date (the most recent available), 11,512 children were placed in foster homes. (California Child Welfare Indicators Project, Pont in Time/In Care, available at https://ccwip.berkeley.edu/childwelfare/index/r.)
Reunification services. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child's parents. If the child is under the age of three, these reunification services are only offered for a period of six months. If the child is over the age of three, the services are offered for twelve months. In some circumstances, the time period for reunification services can be extended up to 24 months.
During the dependency proceedings, a court must hold periodical review hearings at least every six months, including at six and 12 months after the dispositional hearing. (Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC) Section 366.21(e)(1).) At each hearing, except for the permanency and permanency review hearings, the court must find by clear and convincing evidence that the parent was adequately provided reunification services. At a permanency hearing, a judge must find, also by clear and convincing evidence, that reunification services were provided. (WIC Section 366.26.)
Assuming that reunification services are provided (as required for most parents), these review hearings allow the court to make sure that the family is receiving the services that the court has ordered and to see how they are progressing with the services, all with the hope that the family can be reunited. These services provide parents an opportunity to remedy the factors that prompted their child's removal in the first place and provide them every opportunity possible to successfully reunite with their child. At any point during these hearings, a court may initiate, terminate, or continue those services. (WIC Section 366.21(e)(8).) Thus, parents' access to reunification services is pivotal to the goal of dependency courts in maintaining family unity.
Court-ordered services may be extended up to a maximum time period not to exceed 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from physical custody of the child's parent or guardian. (WIC Section 361.5 (a)(3)(A).) But the extension may only occur if and when it can be shown, at the permanency planning hearing that (1) there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of the child's parent or guardian within the extended time period, or (2) that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. (Ibid.)
Finally, a permanency planning hearing "shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of his or her parent." (WIC Section 366.22(a)(1).) If the "child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26" to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or foster care is the best plan for the child. (WIC Section 366.22(a)(3).) Existing law requires – at review and permanency hearings conducted during the juvenile dependency court process – to make an adverse inference about the parent's fitness to be reunified with their child if the parent has not participated in or made adequate progress in court-ordered treatment program. Several provisions provide that, "The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental." (WIC Sections 366.21(e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22(a)(1), 366.25(a)(1).)
This bill merely removes this simplistic and outdated presumption from the law. While the bill eliminates the presumption, it does not prohibit a court from considering a parent's participation in rehabilitation services when evaluating the parent's fitness to be reunified with their child. The bill simply requires the court to make the determination of a parent's ability to reunify with their child based on the totality of the circumstances, rather than requiring the court to begin with the assumption that the parent is unfit based upon their failure to participate in treatment programs (and requiring the parent to overcome the presumption against their ability to reunify with their children).
According to the Author
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. . . . Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent's level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be "compliant" or "cooperative." This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s when probation departments not child welfare departments managed the dependency system, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.
SB 463 simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent's lack of compliance.
Arguments in Support
Santa Clara County and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., co-sponsors of the bill, explain why the change in law proposed by the bill will help keep families intact while increasing equity and protecting the welfare of children in the child dependency system:
While a parent or guardian's inadequate participation in treatment is a red flag, it does not automatically mean they cannot safely care for the child. There are valid reasons for a parent or guardian's failure to participate regularly, including illness, inability to pay for the treatment, inability to get time off from work, or treatment programs having significant waitlists. Likewise, the determination whether the parent or guardian has made "substantive progress" in a program is subjective, and families of color are more likely to be characterized as "uncooperative" or to have fear of the government that leads to lack of cooperation. By placing the burden on parents and guardians to rebut the presumption, this provision compounds disadvantages and reinforces systemic inequalities.
. . .
Importantly, if this bill is enacted, the court would still be statutorily required to consider the social worker's report, the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian, and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided. SB 463 simply enables courts to make this holistic determination without being required to equivocate the parent's level of compliance with the current risk posed to the child.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, no significant state costs.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-3
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Blakespear, Glazer, Wilk
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-2-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Sanchez
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 5-2-1
YES: Jackson, Arambula, Bonta, Bryan, Garcia
NO: Sanchez, Alanis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-3-0
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Soria, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Mathis, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: August 28, 2023
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001350
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 463
Author:(Wahab)
As Amended Ver:March 20, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Eliminates from current law a presumption that a parent's failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that return of the child to their parent's custody would be detrimental.
Major Provisions
- Eliminates, for purposes of status and permanency hearings conducted by the juvenile court, the provision making the failure of a parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to the parent.
- Makes nonsubstantive conforming changes.
COMMENTS
This bill, co-sponsored by the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., eliminates, at several points in existing law regarding the juvenile dependency court review process, a requirement that the juvenile court consider a parent's failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return of the child to the parent's custody would be detrimental.
Overview of child welfare services and juvenile dependency court. The dependency process begins when child abuse, neglect, or abandonment is reported to the local child welfare agency. A social worker with the child welfare agency investigates the allegation to determine if the child requires protection in order to ensure their safety. If so, the child welfare agency files a petition with the juvenile court to make the child a dependent of the court. If necessary, the social worker will remove the child from their home and take the child into protective custody.
At the subsequent court hearing, the court may elect to keep the child in, or return the child to, their home or remove the child from the home. Removal may either result in eventual reunification with the family, or the court may determine that an alternate permanent placement –including the options of guardianship or adoption – is more fitting. When reunification is not possible or appropriate, children are placed in the setting deemed least restrictive and most suitable; the court must give preference to potential placements with relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Throughout this system, there are multiple court hearings – including the detention hearing, the jurisdictional hearing and the dispositional hearing, followed by ongoing review hearings and the permanency hearing – where the custody of a child or their placement is evaluated, reviewed, and determined by the court, in consultation with the child's social worker appointed by the county and the child's attorney, to help provide the best possible support and services to the child.
As of October 1, 2022, more than 74,500 children were receiving services from county child welfare agencies in California. As of that date (the most recent available), 11,512 children were placed in foster homes. (California Child Welfare Indicators Project, Pont in Time/In Care, available at https://ccwip.berkeley.edu/childwelfare/index/r.)
Reunification services. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child's parents. If the child is under the age of three, these reunification services are only offered for a period of six months. If the child is over the age of three, the services are offered for twelve months. In some circumstances, the time period for reunification services can be extended up to 24 months.
During the dependency proceedings, a court must hold periodical review hearings at least every six months, including at six and 12 months after the dispositional hearing. (Welfare and Institutions Code (WIC) Section 366.21(e)(1).) At each hearing, except for the permanency and permanency review hearings, the court must find by clear and convincing evidence that the parent was adequately provided reunification services. At a permanency hearing, a judge must find, also by clear and convincing evidence, that reunification services were provided. (WIC Section 366.26.)
Assuming that reunification services are provided (as required for most parents), these review hearings allow the court to make sure that the family is receiving the services that the court has ordered and to see how they are progressing with the services, all with the hope that the family can be reunited. These services provide parents an opportunity to remedy the factors that prompted their child's removal in the first place and provide them every opportunity possible to successfully reunite with their child. At any point during these hearings, a court may initiate, terminate, or continue those services. (WIC Section 366.21(e)(8).) Thus, parents' access to reunification services is pivotal to the goal of dependency courts in maintaining family unity.
Court-ordered services may be extended up to a maximum time period not to exceed 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from physical custody of the child's parent or guardian. (WIC Section 361.5 (a)(3)(A).) But the extension may only occur if and when it can be shown, at the permanency planning hearing that (1) there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of the child's parent or guardian within the extended time period, or (2) that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. (Ibid.)
Finally, a permanency planning hearing "shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of his or her parent." (WIC Section 366.22(a)(1).) If the "child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26" to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or foster care is the best plan for the child. (WIC Section 366.22(a)(3).) Existing law requires—at review and permanency hearings conducted during the juvenile dependency court process--to make an adverse inference about the parent's fitness to be reunified with their child if the parent has not participated in or made adequate progress in court-ordered treatment program. Several provisions provide that, "The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental." (WIC Sections 366.21(e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22(a)(1), 366.25(a)(1).)
This bill merely removes this simplistic and outdated presumption from the law. While the bill eliminates the presumption, it does not prohibit a court from considering a parent's participation in rehabilitation services when evaluating the parent's fitness to be reunified with their child. The bill simply requires the court to make the determination of a parent's ability to reunify with their child based on the totality of the circumstances, rather than requiring the court to begin with the assumption that the parent is unfit based upon their failure to participate in treatment programs (and requiring the parent to overcome the presumption against their ability to reunify with their children).
According to the Author
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. . . . Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent's level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be "compliant" or "cooperative." This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s when probation departments not child welfare departments managed the dependency system, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.
SB 463 simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent's lack of compliance.
Arguments in Support
Santa Clara County and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., co-sponsors of the bill, explain why the change in law proposed by the bill will help keep families intact while increasing equity and protecting the welfare of children in the child dependency system:
While a parent or guardian's inadequate participation in treatment is a red flag, it does not automatically mean they cannot safely care for the child. There are valid reasons for a parent or guardian's failure to participate regularly, including illness, inability to pay for the treatment, inability to get time off from work, or treatment programs having significant waitlists. Likewise, the determination whether the parent or guardian has made "substantive progress" in a program is subjective, and families of color are more likely to be characterized as "uncooperative" or to have fear of the government that leads to lack of cooperation. By placing the burden on parents and guardians to rebut the presumption, this provision compounds disadvantages and reinforces systemic inequalities.
. . .
Importantly, if this bill is enacted, the court would still be statutorily required to consider the social worker's report, the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian, and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided. SB 463 simply enables courts to make this holistic determination without being required to equivocate the parent's level of compliance with the current risk posed to the child.
Arguments in Opposition
No opposition on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, no significant state costs.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-3
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Blakespear, Glazer, Wilk
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-2-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Dixon, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Sanchez
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 5-2-1
YES: Jackson, Arambula, Bonta, Bryan, Garcia
NO: Sanchez, Alanis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Calderon
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-3-0
YES: Holden, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Papan, Pellerin, Soria, Weber, Wilson
NO: Megan Dahle, Mathis, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: March 20, 2023
CONSULTANT: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001263
Date of Hearing: August 16, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 463
Author:(Wahab) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2023
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 2 |
Human Services | 5 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill eliminates an evidentiary presumption during juvenile dependency proceedings so a court can no longer assume that, if a child’s parent has not participated in a court-ordered treatment program, returning the child to the parent’s custody would be detrimental to the child.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No significant state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. . . . Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent’s level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be ‘compliant’ or ‘cooperative.’ This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s when probation departments not child welfare departments managed the dependency system, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.”
[This bill] simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent’s lack of compliance.
- Background. If the state must remove a child from their parent’s home, the goal of the child welfare system is to safely reunite the child with their parent whenever possible. To that end, under existing law, if a child is removed from the custody of their parent, the court conducts a dispositional hearing to set a family reunification plan. The plan often includes court-ordered family reunification services, including counseling, substance abuse treatment, parenting classes, or other services for the parent to complete. After a reunification plan is in place, the court typically conducts status review hearings every six months to see how the parent is progressing with the services ordered by the court. The stakes at these hearings are high – the court must ultimately determine whether the child can be safely reunited with their parent, or whether the court should order permanent family separation and termination of parental rights.
Under existing law, if a parent has not participated regularly and made substantive progress in court-ordered reunification services, the court must make an assumption that returning the child to the parent’s home would be detrimental to the child. At that point in the proceedings, the burden shifts to the parent to present evidence that contradicts this assumption. However, many parents are unable to access services due to their work schedules, illness, lack of availability of programs, or other factors that are largely outside their control. Under current law, the court doesn’t necessarily care why a parent has not participated in services – the fact of their nonparticipation creates the assumption that the child should not be returned to their custody, and then the parent and their court-appointed counsel must attempt to disprove the assumption.
This bill eliminates this required assumption and instead allows the court to weigh a parent’s participation or nonparticipation in reunification services along with all the other information about the case.
- Statement of Support. The County of Santa Clara and the Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, co-sponsors of the bill, write:
While a parent or guardian’s inadequate participation in treatment is a red flag, it does not automatically mean they cannot safely care for the child. There are valid reasons for a parent or guardian’s failure to participate regularly, including illness, inability to pay for the treatment, inability to get time off from work, or treatment programs having significant waitlists. Likewise, the determination whether the parent or guardian has made “substantive progress” in a program is subjective, and families of color are more likely to be characterized as “uncooperative” or to have fear of the government that leads to lack of cooperation. By placing the burden on parents and guardians to rebut the presumption, this provision compounds disadvantages and reinforces systemic inequalities.
Importantly, if this bill is enacted, the court would still be statutorily required to consider the social worker’s report, the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian, and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided. SB 463 simply enables courts to make this holistic determination without being required to equivocate the parent’s level of compliance with the current risk posed to the child.
There is no opposition on file for this bill.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Corey A. Jackson, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 463
Author:(Wahab) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Dependent children
SUMMARY: Eliminates the juvenile court standard, for purposes of foster youth status review hearings, that considers failure of the parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return of a foster child would be detrimental.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the juvenile court with jurisdiction over children who are subject to abuse or neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section [WIC] 300 et seq.)
- States that the purpose of the juvenile court dependency system is the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being abused, neglected, or exploited. Provides that the focus is on the preservation of the family, as well as the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of the child. (WIC 300.2)
- Requires the court, if at the initial hearing, the juvenile court orders a child removed from their parent due to abuse or neglect, to order that child welfare reunification services be provided to the family as soon as possible in order to reunify the child with their family, if appropriate. (WIC 319(e))
- Requires a social worker, whenever the social worker has cause to believe that there was or is abuse or neglect of a child, to immediately make any investigation they deem necessary to determine whether child welfare services should be offered to the family and whether proceedings in the juvenile court should be commenced. Further requires the social worker, if they determine that it is appropriate to offer child welfare services to the family, to make a referral to those services. (WIC 328(a))
- Requires the court, at the dispositional hearing, to order a social worker to provide child welfare services to a child who has been removed from their parents' custody and to the parents in order to support the goal of reunification, for a specified time period, except under certain circumstances. Provides that children and families in the child welfare system should typically receive a full six months of reunification services if the child is under three years of age, and twelve months if the child is over three years of age, but that may be extended up to 18 or 24 months, as provided. (WIC 361.5(a))
- Provides that reunification services need not be provided if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that specified conditions exist, including:
- The parent is suffering from a mental disability that renders the parent incapable of using the reunification services;
- The parent has caused the death of another child through abuse or neglect;
- The child or a sibling has been adjudicated a dependent of the court as the result of physical or sexual abuse;
- The parent has been convicted of a violent felony; or,
- The parent has a history of drug or alcohol abuse and has failed to comply with treatment programs, as provided. (WIC 361.5(b))
- Prevents a court from ordering reunification services for a parent in specified situations, unless the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that reunification is in the child's best interest. (WIC 361.5(c))
- Requires, if a child is adjudged a dependent child of the court, and the court orders that a parent shall retain custody of the child subject to the supervision of the social worker, the parents to participate in child welfare services or services provided by an appropriate agency designated by the court. (WIC 362(c))
- Permits the juvenile court to direct any reasonable orders to the parents of the child who is the subject of any proceedings as the court deems necessary and proper. Permits that order to include a direction to participate in a counseling or education program, including, but not limited to, a parent education and parenting program operated by a community college, school district, or other appropriate agency designated by the court. Authorizes a foster parent with whom the child is placed to be directed to participate in such a program in cases in which the court deems participation is appropriate and in the child’s best interest. Requires the program in which a parent is required to participate to be designed to eliminate those conditions that led to the court’s finding that the child is a person described by WIC 300. (WIC 362(d))
- Requires every hearing in which an order is made placing a child under the supervision of the juvenile court pursuant to WIC 300, and in which the child is not removed from the physical custody of their parent, to be continued to a specific future date not to exceed six months after the date of the original dispositional hearing. (WIC 364(a))
- Establishes requirements for hearings conducted by the juvenile court reviewing the status of a dependent child, including the hearing held six months after the initial dispositional hearing, but no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care. Requires the court to consider, among other factors, whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. Prohibits the fact the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility from being, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. Declares that the failure of the parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. (WIC 366.21(e)(1))
- Requires the court, at the permanency hearing to be held no later than 12 months after the date the child entered foster care, to determine the permanent plan for the child, which includes a determination of whether the child will be returned to the child’s home and, if so, when, within specified time limits. Requires the court to consider the criminal history of the parent subsequent to the child’s removal and to determine by clear and convincing evidence whether reasonable services that were designed to aid the parent to overcome the problems that led to the removal have been provided or offered to the parent. Declares that the failure of the parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. (WIC 366.21(f)(1)(B))
- Requires, when a case has been continued, the permanency review hearing to occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of their parent. Further requires the court to order the return of the child to the physical custody of their parent unless the court finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child would create a substantial risk of detriment to the stafey, protection, or emotional well-being of the child. The court is required to consider whether the child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allos a dependent child to reside with their parent. Prohibits the fact the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility from being, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of detriment. Declares that the failure of the parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental. (WIC 366.22(a)(1))
- Provides that if the child is not returned to a parent at the permanency review hearing, the court is required to order a hearing to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or foster care is the best plan for the child. (WIC 366.22(a)(3))
- Allows the court to postpone the permanency review hearing for up to six months when it is in the child's best interests to have additional services provided to any of the following: a parent making significant progress in a substance abuse treatment program; a parent who was either a minor parent or a dependent parent at the time of the initial hearing and is making significant progress in establishing a safe home for the child's return; or a parent who was recently discharged from incarceration, institutionalization, and is making significant progress in establishing a safe home for the child's return. (WIC 366.22(b))
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, the March 20, 2023, version of this bill would result in negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
Background: Child Welfare Services (CWS). California’s CWS system was established with the goal of protecting youth from abuse and neglect and is designed to provide safety, health, and overall well-being of children. When a child is identified as being at risk of abuse or neglect, reports can be made to either law enforcement or a county child welfare agency. Often, these reports are submitted by mandated reporters who are legally required to report suspicion of child abuse or neglect due to their profession, such as a teacher or healthcare provider.
When a mandated reporter submits a report to either law enforcement or the county child welfare agency, a social worker determines whether the allegation is of suspected abuse, neglect, or exploitation, and creates a case plan which includes the provision of relevant services. The child's social worker and the court collaborate to evaluate and review the circumstances of each case, seeking either reunification or placement outside of the home as a way for the child to achieve permanency.
If the court orders a child to be placed outside of the home, the parent is typically ordered by the court to receive family reunification services. Upon completion of the services, in addition to making any changes or improvements described in the case plan, the court may dismiss the child’s court case and the county welfare department case will also be closed. If a parent does not participate in the services set forth in the reunification plan, the court can terminate the services, and therefore change the reunification goal to one of finding a permanent home with a caring adult.
When a child is removed from the custody of their parent, they are temporarily placed within the jurisdiction of the child welfare system until a determination about the child’s welfare is made. Within 48 hours after a child is taken into temporary custody, the county social worker must file a petition with the court requesting that a detention hearing take place in order to determine if further detention of the child is necessary. If a petition to declare the child a dependent of the court is filed by the county social worker, then the detention hearing must be held within 48 hours of the petition being filed. At the detention hearing, the social worker outlines the allegations of abuse or neglect made against the parent and why it is necessary to remove the child from the custody of their parent. If the court determines that removing the child from their parents’ custody is in the best interests of the child, the child is then removed. Permanent placement of the child is determined at a later date.
Once a child has been removed from the custody of their parents, a jurisdictional hearing is required to take place within 15 days. It is at the jurisdictional hearing that the court determines whether the allegations outlined in the social worker’s petition are true. If the allegations are deemed to be true, then the child is determined to be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court and a dispositional hearing is required to be held within 60 days of the initial detention hearing in order to determine the permanent placement of the child.
At the dispositional hearing, the court determines the parameters of the family reunification plan, which includes where and with whom the child will live, be it with relatives or in a foster family home. The reunification plan also can entail recommendations for parents such as parenting classes, anger management, counseling, substance use disorder counseling and testing, sexual abuse counseling, parenting training, and anger management.
Except for limited circumstances, if the child is not returned to the parent’s custody at the 18-month permanency reviewing hearing, the juvenile court is required to terminate reunification services and set a hearing to terminate parental rights. This bill would eliminate the current standard during dispositional hearings that requires the court to find the failure of the parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental.
California's CWS programs are administered by the 58 individual counties with each county organizing and operating its own program of child protection based on local needs while adhering to state and federal regulations. When a child welfare case is open, counties are the primary governmental entity interacting with children and families when addressing issues of child abuse and neglect and are responsible, either directly or through providers, for obtaining or providing the interventions and relevant services to protect children and assist families with issues related to child abuse and neglect.
The California Department of Social Services secures federal funding to support child welfare services programs, provides statewide best practices training for social workers, and conducts program regulatory oversight and administration, and is responsible for the development of policy while also providing direct services such as adoption placements.
As of April 1, 2023, there are 51,339 youth between birth and 20 years old in foster care.
Court-Ordered Services and the Reunification Plan. Existing law requires the court, in determining the content of reasonable services, to consider the particular barriers to an incarcerated, institutionalized, detained, or deported parent’s access to those court-mandated services and ability to maintain contact with the child, and to document this information in the child’s case plan. Every case plan is different and may include requirements for that parent to seek counseling, attend parent education classes, or receive substance use disorder treatment and testing services.
Case plans are updated once every six months. The effective date of the case plan is the date the social worker’s supervisor approves and signs it. The social worker meets with the parents at least monthly if not more frequently and discusses the case progress, problems encountered and that status of the parent’s cooperation.
In addition to the intent to consider substance use disorder treatment in determining reunification services, successful engagement in treatment is considered throughout the CWS process. Current law includes a process of investigation that examines all circumstances contributing to a youth's well-being to ensure substance use is not the sole factor in bringing a child into the court's custody.
Once ordered, family reunification services are required to be provided or arranged for by county welfare department staff in order to reunite the child separated from their parent because of abuse, neglect, or exploitation. These services are available without regard to income to families whose child has been adjudicated or is in the process of being adjudicated a dependent child of the court. Family reunification services are only required to be provided when a child has been placed in out-of-home care, or is in the care of a previously noncustodial parent under the supervision of the juvenile court. When a minor has been placed in foster care with a nonparent, family reunification services may be provided to one or both parents.
Family reunification services include, but are not limited to: case management; out-of-home placements; transportation, visitation between child, family and siblings; and referrals to court-ordered services (may include counseling, substance use disorder counseling and testing, sexual abuse counseling, parenting training, and anger management).
Social workers are required to assist parents with their court-ordered case plan by making referrals to programs in the community that will alleviate further risk of abuse or neglect of their child. Dependency courts generally try to preserve parental rights, and in cases in which a parent is estranged from a child, they may order reunification services to help repair the parent-child relationship and assist the parent in regaining physical custody of their child. Family reunification services are meant to alleviate the circumstances that led to the removal of their child.
If family reunification services are granted of a child that is under the age of three, the law restricts these services to six months from the date of disposition but no longer than twelve months from the date the child entered foster care, unless the court makes findings of substantive parental progress and substantial probability of a safe return home within the next review period. In limiting these services, existing law recognizes that very young children are especially vulnerable to lack of permanency.
Reunification services are not required to be provided to a parent when the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that the parent has a history of extensive, abusive, and chronic use of drugs or alcohol and has resisted prior court-ordered treatment for this problem during a three-year period immediately prior to the filing of the petition that brought that child to the court’s attention, or has failed or refused to comply with a program of drug or alcohol treatment described in the case plan on at least two prior occasions, even though the programs identified were available and accessible. For purposes of this paragraph, “resisted” means the parent refused to participate meaningfully in a prior court-ordered drug or alcohol treatment program and does not include “passive resistance,” as described in a 2020 California appellate court decision (46 Cal.App.5th 932), which determined that relapsing was not the same as resisting treatment. This finding is consistent with other provisions regarding rehabilitation and its importance in repairing family bonds for those in the CWS system.
This bill would remove the standard that failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that returning a foster youth to their home would be detrimental.
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. . . . Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent’s level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be ‘compliant’ or ‘cooperative.’ This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s when probation departments not child welfare departments managed the dependency system, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.”
“[This bill] simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent’s lack of compliance.”
Need for this bill: The provisions of this bill seek to eliminate the requirement for juvenile courts at status review hearings, which treats a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs as an automatic presumption that reunifying the family would be detrimental to the youth. Because there could be many factors affecting a parent’s ability to participate in court-ordered treatment programs, such as an inability to pay, transportation issues, or work conflicts, this bill would allow the court to consider all of the relevant circumstances during a dispositional hearing, rather than being directed to bar reunification based only on one element. Additionally, it is unclear how “substantive progress” is measured and by whom.
By eliminating this standard, the court can consider additional factors beyond participation in court-ordered treatment programs in furtherance the goals of the CWS system that aim to preserve and strengthen families.
Equity Implications: According to a March 2023 report published by the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) entitled, “Update on Analysis and Key Questions: Racial and Ethnic Disproportionalities and Disparities in California’s Child Welfare System,” the majority of California families involved with the child welfare system are experiencing poverty. The LAO estimates that in 2022-23, 54% of child welfare-involved families in California have earnings of under $1,000 per month. When the court orders a parent to attend classes to assist in rehabilitation before returning the child to their home, most parents are not be able to pay, in addition to a large number of these parents not having access to reliable transportation. While some of these court-ordered services can be covered through health insurance, for those parents who are uninsured, an additional barrier to reunification has been erected.
The LAO further reports that in California, the populations reflected in foster care are predominantly youth of color, as 21% are Black and 50% are Latino. Further highlighting the disproportionality comprising the foster youth population, the number of Black and Native American youth in foster care is four times larger than the number of the general population of Black and Native American youth in California. The LAO also states that racial disproportionalities and disparities are present within initial allegations and persist at all levels of the system—becoming the most pronounced for youth in care. While the families involved in the child welfare system skew disproportionally toward low-income people of color, this bill would attempt to reduce the effects has on families who are involved in the child welfare system and trying to reunify their family by allowing the juvenile court to properly consider all factors that determine parental fitness.
Double referral: This bill passed out of the Assembly Judiciary Committee on June 6, 2023, with a 9-2 vote.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 937 (McKinnor) of the current legislative session, requires, if the juvenile court finds that reasonable family reunification services have not been provided to a parent, the court to extend reunification services for an additional six months, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that extending the time period for reunification services would be detrimental to the child. AB 937 is currently pending before the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 954 (Bryan) of the current legislative session, prohibits a parent or guardian’s participation in court-ordered child welfare services from being considered to be noncompliant when there is evidence they are unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship. AB 954 is currently pending before on the Senate Floor.
SB 578 (Ashby) of the current legislative session, requires a juvenile court to make a trauma-informed analysis of the negative consequences that a child likely will experience as a result of removal from their home, prior to ordering removal. SB 578 is set for hearing in the Assembly Human Services Committee on July 11, 2023.
AB 2159 (Bryan), Chapter 691, Statutes of 2022, prohibited a court from denying reunification services to parents and guardians in custody prior to conviction and sentencing.
SB 1085 (Kamlager), Chapter 832, Statutes of 2022, prohibited a child from being found to be a dependent of the juvenile court solely due to: homelessness; indigence or other conditions of financial difficulty, including, but not limited to, poverty or the inability to provide or obtain clothing, home or property repair, or childcare. SB 1085 also stated legislative intent that families not be subject to the jurisdiction of the juvenile court nor should children be separated from their parents based on conditions of financial difficulty, including but not limited to, a lack of food, clothing, shelter or childcare.
AB 788 (Calderon), Chapter 201, Statutes of 2021, clarified the meaning of "resisted" within current provisions that enable a juvenile dependency court to deny reunification services for a parent with a history of drug or alcohol abuse.
AB 841 (Cunningham), Chapter 98, Statutes of 2021, prohibited a child from being found to be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court solely due to the failure of the child's parent or alleged parent to pursue court orders seeking custody of the child.
SB 977 (Liu), Chapter, 219, Statutes of 2014, imposed additional duties on social workers to include in each social study, evaluation, and supplemental report to the courts, a factual discussion of whether a child can be returned to the custody of their parent who is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent. Further required courts to consider whether a child can be returned to the custody of their parent in these situations, as specified.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
County of Santa Clara (Co-Sponsor)
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, INC. (Co-Sponsor)
A New Way of Life Re-entry Project
AOUON Orange County
California Lawyers Association - Family Law Section
Children's Law Center of California
Dependency Advocacy Center
Dependency Legal Services
East Bay Family Defenders
Family Reunification Equity & Empowerment (F.R.E.E.)
First 5 Alameda County
LA Dependency Lawyers
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
National Center for Youth Law
Public Counsel
Starting Over, INC.
Western Center on Law & Poverty
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Jessica Langtry / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Date of Hearing: June 6, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 463
Author:(Wahab) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: DEPENDENT CHILDREN
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD the evidentiary presumption in JUVENILE DEPENDENCY PROCEEDINGS, that for purposes of determining whether the child should be returned to the parent or guardian’s custody, a parent or guardian’s lack of participation or progress in a treatment program endangers the child, BE ELIMINATED?
SYNOPSIS
Children who are at risk of abuse, neglect, or abandonment may be deemed dependents of the juvenile court and provided services, supports and interventions aimed at protecting them and their health and safety. The system aims to preserve and strengthen families by maintaining or reuniting children with their parents whenever appropriate. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child’s parents. Existing law requires—at review and permanency hearings conducted during the juvenile dependency court process--to make an adverse inference about the parent’s fitness to be reunified with their child when the parent does not participate in or make adequate progress in a court-ordered treatment program. It provides that, “The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental.”
This bill merely removes this simplistic and outdated presumption from the law. While the bill eliminates the presumption, it does not prohibit a court from considering a parent’s participation in rehabilitation services when evaluating the parent’s fitness to be reunified with their child. The bill simply requires the court to make the determination of a parent’s ability to reunify with their child based on the totality of the circumstances, rather than requiring the court to begin with the assumption that the parent is unfit based upon their non-participation (thus requiring the parent to overcome this presumption in order to reunify with their child). A number of social justice, legal, and youth advocacy organizations support this bill, co-sponsored by the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. The bill has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Eliminates from current law a presumption that a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that return of the child to their parent’s custody would be detrimental. Specifically, this bill:
- Eliminates, for purposes of status and permanency hearings conducted by the juvenile court, the provision making the failure of a parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to the parent.
- Makes nonsubstantive conforming changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the juvenile court with jurisdiction over children who are subject to abuse or neglect. (Welfare & Institutions Code Section 300. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to the Welfare & Institutions Code.)
- Establishes that the purpose of the juvenile court dependency system is the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being abused, neglected, or exploited. Provides that the focus is on the preservation of the family, as well as the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of the child. (Section 300.2.)
- Requires that if, at the initial hearing, the juvenile court orders a child removed from their parent or guardian due to abuse or neglect, the court to order that child welfare reunification services be provided to the family as soon as possible in order to reunify the child with their family, if appropriate. (Section 319 (e).)
- Requires the court, at the dispositional hearing, to order a social worker to provide child welfare services to a child who has been removed from their parents' custody and to the parents in order to support the goal of reunification, for a specified time period, except under certain circumstances. Provides that children and families in the child welfare system should typically receive a full six months of reunification services if the child is under three years of age, and twelve months if the child is over three years of age, but that may be extended up to 18 or 24 months, as provided. (Section 361.5 (a).)
- Provides that reunification services under 4) above, need not be provided if the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that specified conditions exist, including:
- The parent is suffering from a mental disability that renders the parent incapable of using the reunification services;
- The parent has caused the death of another child through abuse or neglect;
- The child or a sibling has been adjudicated a dependent as the result of several physical or sexual abuse;
- The parent has been convicted of a violent felony; or
- The parent has a history of drug or alcohol abuse and has failed to comply with treatment programs as provided. (Section 361.5 (b).)
- Prevents a court from ordering reunification services for a parent in specified situations, including the situations set forth in 5) above, unless the court finds, by clear and convincing evidence, that reunification is in the child's best interest. (Section 361.5 (c)(2) - (4).)
- Requires that a permanency planning hearing “shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of his or her parent.” (Section 366.22 (a)(1).)
- Provides that if the “child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26” to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or foster care is the best plan for the child. (Section 366.22 (a)(3).)
- Establishes, at both review and permanency hearings, a presumption that a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be considered prima facie evidence that returning the child to the parent’s custody would be detrimental. (Sections 366.21 (e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22 (a)(1), 366.25 (a)(1).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, co-sponsored by the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., eliminates, at several points in existing law regarding the juvenile dependency court review process, a requirement that the juvenile court consider a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs to be prima facie evidence that return of the child to the parent’s custody would be detrimental. According to the author:
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. . . . Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent’s level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be “compliant” or “cooperative.” This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s when probation departments not child welfare departments managed the dependency system, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.
SB 463 simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent’s lack of compliance.
Overview of child welfare services and juvenile dependency court. The dependency process begins when child abuse, neglect, or abandonment is reported to the local child welfare agency. A social worker with the child welfare agency investigates the allegation to determine if the child requires protection in order to ensure their safety. If so, the child welfare agency files a petition with the juvenile court to make the child a dependent of the court. If necessary, the social worker will remove the child from their home and take the child into protective custody.
At the subsequent court hearing, the court may elect to keep the child in, or return the child to, their home or remove the child from the home. Removal may either result in eventual reunification with the family, or the court may determine that an alternate permanent placement –including the options of guardianship or adoption – is more fitting. When reunification is not possible or appropriate, children are placed in the setting deemed least restrictive and most suitable; the court must give preference to potential placements with relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Throughout this system, there are multiple court hearings – including the detention hearing, the jurisdictional hearing and the dispositional hearing, followed by ongoing review hearings and the permanency hearing – where the custody of a child or their placement is evaluated, reviewed, and determined by the court, in consultation with the child’s social worker appointed by the county and the child's attorney, to help provide the best possible support and services to the child.
As of October 1, 2022, more than 74,500 children were receiving services from county child welfare agencies in California. As of that date (the most recent available), 11,512 children were placed in foster homes. (California Child Welfare Indicators Project, Pont in Time/In Care, available at https://ccwip.berkeley.edu/childwelfare/index/r.)
Reunification services. When it is necessary for the state to remove a child from his or her parents, the primary objective of the child welfare system is to safely reunify the child with their family. To support that objective, in most cases the juvenile court orders reunification services, such as counseling for the family and parenting classes and drug or alcohol treatment for the child’s parents. If the child is under the age of three, these reunification services are only offered for a period of six months. If the child is over the age of three, the services are offered for twelve months. In some circumstances, the time period for reunification services can be extended up to 24 months.
During the dependency proceedings, a court must hold periodical review hearings at least every six months, including at six and 12 months after the dispositional hearing. (Section 366.21 (e)(1).) At each hearing, except for the permanency and permanency review hearings, the court must find by clear and convincing evidence that the parent was adequately provided reunification services. At a permanency hearing, a judge must find, also by clear and convincing evidence, that reunification services were provided. (Section 366.26.)
Assuming that reunification services are provided (as required for most parents), these review hearings allow the court to make sure that the family is receiving the services that the court has ordered and to see how they are progressing with the services, all with the hope that the family can be reunited. These services provide parents an opportunity to remedy the factors that prompted their child’s removal in the first place and provide them every opportunity possible to successfully reunite with their child. At any point during these hearings, a court may initiate, terminate, or continue those services. (Section 366.21 (e)(8).) Thus, parents’ access to reunification services is pivotal to the goal of dependency courts in maintaining family unity.
Court-ordered services may be extended up to a maximum time period not to exceed 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from physical custody of the child’s parent or guardian. (Section 361.5 (a)(3)(A).) But the extension may only occur if and when it can be shown, at the permanency planning hearing that (1) there is a substantial probability that the child will be returned to the physical custody of the child’s parent or guardian within the extended time period, or (2) that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian. (Ibid.)
Finally, a permanency planning hearing “shall occur within 18 months after the date the child was originally removed from the physical custody of his or her parent.” (Section 366.22 (a)(1).) If the “child is not returned to a parent or legal guardian at the permanency review hearing, the court shall order that a hearing be held pursuant to Section 366.26” to determine whether adoption, guardianship, or foster care is the best plan for the child. (Section 366.22 (a)(3).) Existing law requires—at review and permanency hearings conducted during the juvenile dependency court process--to make an adverse inference about the parent’s fitness to be reunified with their child if the parent has not participated in or made adequate progress in court-ordered treatment program. Several provisions provide that, “The failure of the parent or legal guardian to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs shall be prima facie evidence that return would be detrimental.” (Sections 366.21 (e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22 (a)(1), 366.25 (a)(1).)
This bill merely removes this simplistic and outdated presumption from the law. While the bill eliminates the presumption, it does not prohibit a court from considering a parent’s participation in rehabilitation services when evaluating the parent’s fitness to be reunified with their child. The bill simply requires the court to make the determination of a parent’s ability to reunify with their child based on the totality of the circumstances, rather than requiring the court to begin with the assumption that the parent is unfit based upon their failure to participate in treatment programs (and requiring the parent to overcome the presumption against their ability to reunify with their children).
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Santa Clara County and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., co-sponsors of the bill, explain why the change in law proposed by the bill will help keep families intact while increasing equity and protecting the welfare of children in the child dependency system:
While a parent or guardian’s inadequate participation in treatment is a red flag, it does not automatically mean they cannot safely care for the child. There are valid reasons for a parent or guardian’s failure to participate regularly, including illness, inability to pay for the treatment, inability to get time off from work, or treatment programs having significant waitlists. Likewise, the determination whether the parent or guardian has made “substantive progress” in a program is subjective, and families of color are more likely to be characterized as “uncooperative” or to have fear of the government that leads to lack of cooperation. By placing the burden on parents and guardians to rebut the presumption, this provision compounds disadvantages and reinforces systemic inequalities.
. . .
Importantly, if this bill is enacted, the court would still be statutorily required to consider the social worker’s report, the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian, and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided. SB 463 simply enables courts to make this holistic determination without being required to equivocate the parent’s level of compliance with the current risk posed to the child.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
County of Santa Clara (co-sponsor)
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. (co-sponsor)
A New Way of Life Re-entry Project
Aouon Orange County
California Lawyers Association - Family Law Section
Children's Law Center of California
Dependency Advocacy Center
Dependency Legal Services
East Bay Family Defenders
Family Reunification Equity & Empowerment (F.R.E.E.)
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
Public Counsel
Starting Over, Inc.
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 463 |
CONSENT
Bill No: SB 463
Author: Wahab (D), et al.
Amended: 3/20/23
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 10-0, 4/11/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Durazo, Laird, McGuire, Min, Niello, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Dependent children
SOURCE: County of Santa Clara
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
DIGEST:
This bill eliminates the evidentiary presumption in juvenile court that a parent or guardian’s lack of participation or progress in a treatment program endangers the child, for purposes of determining whether the child should be returned to the parent or guardian’s custody.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the juvenile court, which is intended to provide for the protection and safety of the public and minors falling under its jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 202, 245.)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from the custody of their parent or guardian[1] on the basis of enumerated forms of abuse or neglect. (Welf. Inst. Code, § 300(a)-(j).)
- Provides that the purpose of the juvenile court and the dependency system is to provide the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of that harm. This safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being may include provision of a full array of social and health services to help the child and family and to prevent the reabuse of children. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 300.2.)
- Requires, following the removal of a child from their parent’s custody, the juvenile court to hold an initial hearing at which the court determines whether custody may be resumed or what services should be offered to the parent that could facilitate the child’s return in the future.
- The court must make a determination on the record as to whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal of the child from their home, and whether there are available services that would prevent the need for further detention.
- In determining whether to return a child to the parent’s custody at this stage, the fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of substantial danger. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 311, 319.)
- Requires, in a case where a child remains out of their parent’s custody after the initial hearing in 4) and the long-term plan is to return the child to the parent’s custody, the court to order the social worker to provide child welfare services and family reunification services that will benefit the child, which can include court-ordered treatment programs for the parent. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 361.5.)
- Provides that, when a child has been kept out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 4), the court must hold periodic review hearings no less frequently than six months, starting six months after the initial dispositional hearing.
- For children three years of age and older, the court must return the child to their parent’s custody unless it finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.
- If the child was under three years of age at the date of removal is a member of a sibling group as specified, and the court determines the parent has not been participating and making progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a permanency hearing within 120 days. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366, 366.21(e).)
- Provides that, for a child who remains out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 6), the court may hold a permanency hearing no later than 12 months after the initial removal; the court may also continue the permanency hearing for up to two more six-month periods, so that the permanency hearing may be held, at a maximum, 24 months after the child was initially removed. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(f), (g), 366.22, 366.25.)
- Establishes that, at both review and permanency hearings, a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that returning the child to the parent’s custody would be detrimental. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22(a)(1), 366.25(a)(1).)
This bill:
- Eliminates, for purposes of status and permanency hearings conducted by the juvenile court, the provision making the failure of a parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to the parent.
- Makes nonsubstantive conforming changes.
Comments
According to the author,
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. Under child welfare laws, a child who has been removed from the home must be returned to their parents at review hearings absent a showing that the return causes a risk of detriment to the child. However, those provisions are significantly diluted by a statement that failure of a parent to participate or make substantive progress in the court-ordered services is prima facie evidence of detriment.
While a parent’s lack of compliance is a red flag, there may be valid explanations, including illness, inability to get time off, or inability to pay. Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent’s level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be “compliant” or “cooperative.” This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.
SB 463 simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent’s lack of compliance.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 4/24/23)
County of Santa Clara (co-source)
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. (co-source)
All of Us or None Orange County
Dependency Advocacy Center
Dependency Legal Services
East Bay Family Defenders
Family Reunification, Equity, and Empowerment Project
Public Counsel
Starting Over, Inc.
One individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/24/23)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.:
[I]f this bill is enacted, the court would still be statutorily required to consider the social worker’s report, the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian, and the extent to which they availed themselves of the services provided. SB 463 simply enables courts to
make this holistic determination without being required to equate the parent’s level of compliance with the current risk posed to the child.
Prepared by: Allison Whitt Meredith / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
4/26/23 15:11:46
**** END ****
Going forward, this analysis uses “parent” to include “guardian.” ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 463 (Author:Wahab)
Version: March 20, 2023
Hearing Date: April 11, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AWM
SUBJECT
Protection and advocacy agency
DIGEST
This bill eliminates the evidentiary presumption in juvenile court that a parent or guardian’s lack of participation or progress in a treatment program endangers the child, for purposes of determining whether the child should be returned to the parent or guardian’s custody.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The child welfare system is intended to achieve a delicate balance of values, including “protecting children from harm, preserving family ties, and avoiding unnecessary intrusion into family life.” (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 638.) A child may be brought into the system if the child is subjected to serious physical harm or a substantial risk thereof by a parent’s willful or negligent failure to properly provide for the child; the juvenile court and child welfare agency are required to provide the parent, whenever feasible, with services and resources that will help resolve the issues that led to juvenile court jurisdiction. These services can include court-ordered treatment programs for substance use issues if a court determines that a parent’s substance use has contributed to the harm or risk of harm.
When a child has been removed from a parent’s custody, the juvenile court conducts review hearings at six-month intervals to determine whether the child can be returned to the parent’s home. One factor the court considers as part of this analysis is whether the parent has taken advantage of resources or services provided. Under current law, if the court finds that a parent has failed to participate regularly and make substantive progress, that failure is prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to their parent’s custody. As the stakeholders note, there are reasons why a parent might not be able to participate in treatment programs that do not reflect on their willingness to regain custody of their child, such as a waiting list or the inability to take time off of work. And while the presumption of detriment is rebuttable, stakeholders report that this evidentiary default weighs too heavily in favor of removal and hampers the court’s discretion in the matter.
This bill eliminates the presumption regarding a parent’s failure to participate or make progress in a treatment program, allowing the court to consider all of the facts to determine whether returning the child to their parent’s custody would be harmful to the child.
This bill is sponsored by the County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., and is supported by Dependency Advocacy Center, Dependency Legal Services, East Bay Family Defenders, the Family Reunification, Equity, and Empowerment (FREE) Project, Public Counsel, Starting Over, Inc., and one individual. There is no known opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the juvenile court, which is intended to provide for the protection and safety of the public and minors falling under its jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 202, 245.)
- Provides that a child may become a dependent of the juvenile court and be removed from the custody of their parent or guardian[1] on the basis of enumerated forms of abuse or neglect. (Welf. Inst. Code, § 300(a)-(j).)
- Provides that the purpose of the juvenile court and the dependency system is to provide the maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of that harm. This safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being may include provision of a full array of social and health services to help the child and family and to prevent the reabuse of children. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 300.2.)
- Requires, following the removal of a child from their parent’s custody, the juvenile court to hold an initial hearing at which the court determines whether custody may be resumed or what services should be offered to the parent that could facilitate the child’s return in the future.
- The court must make a determination on the record as to whether reasonable efforts were made to prevent or eliminate the need for removal of the child from their home, and whether there are available services that would prevent the need for further detention.
- In determining whether to return a child to the parent’s custody at this stage, the fact that the parent is enrolled in a certified substance abuse treatment facility that allows a dependent child to reside with their parent shall not be, for that reason alone, prima facie evidence of substantial danger. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 311, 319.)
- Requires, in a case where a child remains out of their parent’s custody after the initial hearing in 4) and the long-term plan is to return the child to the parent’s custody, the court to order the social worker to provide child welfare services and family reunification services that will benefit the child, which can include court-ordered treatment programs for the parent. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 361.5.)
- Provides that, when a child has been kept out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 4), the court must hold periodic review hearings no less frequently than six months, starting six months after the initial dispositional hearing.
- For children three years of age and older, the court must return the child to their parent’s custody unless it finds, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the return of the child would create a substantial risk of detriment to the safety, protection, or physical or emotional well-being of the child.
- If the child was under three years of age at the date of removal is a member of a sibling group as specified, and the court determines the parent has not been participating and making progress in a court-ordered treatment plan, the court may schedule a permanency hearing within 120 days. (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 366, 366.21(e).)
- Provides that, for a child who remains out of their parent’s custody after the hearing in 6), the court may hold a permanency hearing no later than 12 months after the initial removal; the court may also continue the permanency hearing for up to two more six-month periods, so that the permanency hearing may be held, at a maximum, 24 months after the child was initially removed. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(f), (g), 366.22, 366.25.)
- Establishes that, at both review and permanency hearings, a parent’s failure to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that returning the child to the parent’s custody would be detrimental. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.21(e)(1), (f)(1)(B), 366.22(a)(1), 366.25(a)(1).)
This bill:
- Eliminates, for purposes of status and permanency hearings conducted by the juvenile court, the provision making the failure of a parent to participate regularly and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs prima facie evidence that it would be detrimental to return the child to the parent.
- Makes nonsubstantive conforming changes.
COMMENTS
- Author’s comment
According to the author:
The purpose of dependency law is to protect children, not to punish or regulate their parents. Under child welfare laws, a child who has been removed from the home must be returned to their parents at review hearings absent a showing that the return causes a risk of detriment to the child. However, those provisions are significantly diluted by a statement that failure of a parent to participate or make substantive progress in the court-ordered services is prima facie evidence of detriment.
While a parent’s lack of compliance is a red flag, there may be valid explanations, including illness, inability to get time off, or inability to pay. Moreover, research in child welfare and recent legislative trends suggests that current danger to the child should always be the analysis, not the parent’s level of compliance. This is particularly important because many marginalized groups have fear and generational trauma around the child welfare system, making them less likely to be “compliant” or “cooperative.” This legal presumption, which traces back to the late 1980s, puts a thumb on the scale against disadvantaged parents and reinforces racial inequity in the system.
SB 463 simply proposes to delete this presumption. Doing so enhances judicial discretion to make an appropriate, holistic determination about the current risk posed to the child. Such decisions may continue to properly factor in the parent’s lack of compliance.
2. Background on the child welfare process and the effect of a parent’s failure to regularly participate and make substantive process in court-ordered treatment programs
The County of Santa Clara and Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc., the bill’s sponsors, neatly summarizes the procedures at issue and the problem addressed by this bill:
The status of every child in the child welfare system is reviewed at least every six months.[2] The goal is to establish a permanent plan for the child 12 months after removal, but in some circumstances the permanency review hearing may be extended to 18 months or 24 months after removal.[3] In these review hearings, the court must return the child to the parent or guardian unless the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the return would create a substantial risk of detriment to the child. The social worker has the burden of establishing that detriment. The court must consider the report and recommendation of the social worker and the child advocate, as well as the efforts or progress demonstrated by the parent or guardian and the extent to which they availed themselves of services provided. Relevant to [this] bill, the failure of the parent or guardian to participate regularly and make substantive process in court-ordered treatment programs is prima facie evidence that the return would be detrimental.[4]
By classifying the parent or guardian’s lack of compliance as prima facie evidence, this provision creates a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence.[5] “The effect of a presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence is to require the trier of fact to assume the existence of the presumed fact unless and until evidence is introduced which would support a finding of its nonexistence…”[6] Consequently, unless a parent or guardian produces admissible contrary evidence, a social worker can meet their burden to establish detriment simply by showing the parent or guardian failed to participate regularly or did not make substantive progress in the program. In such cases, the court must assume the parent or guardian is unfit.
According to the author and sponsors, a parent or guardian’s inadequate participation in substance abuse treatment is a red flag that bears further investigation, but should not automatically result in a presumption that the parent is unfit. As they note, there are many reasons unrelated to parental fitness that a parent might not be able to meaningfully participate in a treatment program, such as the inability to take time off of work, the unavailability of treatment programs or significant waitlists, and the inability to afford the program. Moreover, the subjective nature of the assessment—whether a parent has made “substantive” progress—leaves room for unconscious bias to slip into the calculation. As the sponsor notes, families of color are more likely to be characterized as “uncooperative” than white families, which might extend to the assessment of whether meaningful progress has been made in treatment.
3. This bill removes the presumption that, if a parent fails to regularly participate and make substantive progress in court-ordered treatment programs, it would be detrimental to the child to return them to their parent’s custody
This bill removes the automatic assumption that a parent’s failure to regularly participate in and make substantive progress in a court-ordered treatment program means the parent is unfit and the child should not be returned to their custody. Without this presumption, the court will still have to consider whether the parent’s failure means it would be detrimental to the child to return them to the parent’s custody; but rather than defaulting to a conclusion of unfitness, the court will have to look at the specific facts of the case and the reasons the parent failed to participate and/or make progress, the parent’s progress and utilization of services in other areas, and whether the overall circumstances warrant keeping the child out of the parent’s custody.
To be clear, the removal of the prima facie provision only eliminates a presumption against the parent; it does not establish a presumption the other way. This bill simply requires the court to make the determination of a parent’s failure to participate and make progress in court-ordered treatment is detrimental to the child based on the totality of the circumstances, rather than requiring the court to begin with the assumption that the parent is unfit. This bill is thus consistent with other recent legislation that requires the child welfare agencies to provide specific evidence showing that a child is at risk instead of relying on inferences based on a parent’s circumstances.[7]
SUPPORT
City of Santa Clara (co-sponsor)
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc. (co-sponsor)
Dependency Advocacy Center
Dependency Legal Services
East Bay Family Defenders
Family Reunification, Equity, and Empowerment (FREE) Project
Public Counsel
Starting Over, Inc.
One individual
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 578 (Ashby, 2023) requires a social worker to report on, and a juvenile court to consider, the potential harms to a child when considering whether to remove a child from their parent or guardian’s custody. SB 578 is pending before this Committee and is scheduled to be heard on the same date as this bill.
AB 954 (Bryan, 2023) would require a juvenile court, when ordering services for a dependent child or their parent, to inquire whether a parent or guardian can afford court-ordered services; and would prohibit a court from declaring a parent noncompliant with a court-ordered case plan when there is evidence that the parent is unable to pay for a service, or that payment for a service would create an undue financial hardship for them, at specified review hearings. AB 954 is pending before the Assembly Human Services Committee.
AB 937 (McKinnor, 2023) would clarify that the court must specify its factual basis for its conclusion that reasonable services have not been provided to the parent or guardian if the court extends reunification services on that basis. The bill would also require the court to extend reunification services for an additional 6 months if the court determines at the 18-month permanency hearing that reasonable services have not been provided. The bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2866 (Cunningham, Ch. 165, Stats. 2022) modified the standard of proof for establishing at a review hearing that a parent or guardian whose child has been removed from their physical custody was offered reasonable reunification services, by raising the standard to the clear and convincing evidence standard, in order to make the standard of proof consistent with the clear and convincing evidence standard already in place for permanent placement hearings.
AB 788 (Calderon, Ch. 201, Stats. 2021) clarified, for purposes of the exemption to the requirement to provide reunification services for a parent who has a history of extensive substance abuse and previously “resisted” court-ordered substance abuse treatment, that “resisted” does not include “passive resistance,” i.e., when the parent meaningfully participates in the program but nonetheless continues to abuse drugs or alcohol.
**************
Going forward, this analysis uses “parent” to include “guardian.” ↑
Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 361.21, 366(b). ↑
See id., §§ 366.21(e) (six-month review), 366.21(f) (12-month review), 366.22(a) (18-month review), 366.25 (24-month review). ↑
Id., §§ 366.21(e)(1), (f)(1), 366.22(a)(1), 366.25(a)(1). ↑
In re Heather B. (1992) 9 Cal.App.4th 535, 561. ↑
Evid. Code, § 604 (ellipses in original). ↑
See SB 1085 (Kamlager, Ch. 832, Stats. 2022); AB 788 (Calderon, Ch. 201, Stats. 2021); SB 977 (Liu, Ch. 219, Stats. 241). ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):