SB 499: School facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-05-18
Current Status:
Failed
(2023-09-01: September 1 hearing: Held in committee and under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the California Child Day Care Facilities Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes by the State Department of Social Services. The act exempts from its provisions certain types of these facilities and certain programs, including, among others, a California state preschool program operated by a local educational agency under contract with the State Department of Education and that meets specified conditions and operates in a school building. Existing law requires the governing board of any school district to, among other things, repair its school property.
This bill, the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023, would, among other things, require all schoolsites, as defined, the next time outdoor surfaces are resurfaced or replaced at the schoolsite, to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution, as provided. The bill would require all schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the State Department of Education, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites, and to make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation. The bill would require the State Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, as defined, for these purposes.
This bill would, on or before January 1, 2025, require all schoolsites, as defined, to develop an extreme heat action plan, as specified, and, by January 1, 2027, to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. specified. The bill would require the plan to include installing address the installation or planting of (1) shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance, (2) school garden infrastructure and plantings, and (3) green barriers between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the State Department of Education, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites, and to make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation. The bill would require the State Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, as defined, for these purposes.This bill would also require, on or before January 1, 2027, schoolsites to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. The bill would make implementation of the plan contingent upon appropriation by the Legislature. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the California Child Day Care Facilities Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes by the State Department of Social Services. The act exempts from its provisions certain types of these facilities and certain programs, including, among others, a California state preschool program operated by a local educational agency under contract with the State Department of Education and that meets specified conditions and operates in a school building. Existing law requires the governing board of any school district to, among other things, repair its school property.
This bill, the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023, would, among other things, require all schoolsites, as defined, at the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces is required, outdoor surfaces are resurfaced or replaced at the schoolsite, to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution, as provided. The bill would require all schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would, on or before January 1, 2025, require all schoolsites, as defined, to develop an extreme heat action plan, as specified, and, by January 1, 2027, to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. The bill would require the plan to include installing or planting (1) shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance, (2) school garden infrastructure and plantings, and (3) coniferous tree green barriers between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the State Department of Education, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites, and to make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation. The bill would require the State Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes facilities, as defined, for these purposes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the California Child Day Care Facilities Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes by the State Department of Social Services. The act exempts from its provisions certain types of these facilities and certain programs, including, among others, a California state preschool program operated by a local educational agency under contract with the State Department of Education and that meets specified conditions and operates in a school building. Existing law authorizes requires the governing board of any school district to, among other things, repair its school property.
This bill, the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023, would, among other things, require all schoolsites, as defined, at the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces is required, to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution, as provided. The bill would require all schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would, on or before January 1, 2025, require all schoolsites, as defined, to develop an extreme heat action plan, as specified, and, by January 1, 2027, to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. The bill would require the plan to include installing or planting (1) shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them during the school day, when in attendance, (2) school garden infrastructure and plantings, and (3) coniferous tree barriers between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the State Department of Education, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites, and to make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation. The bill would require the State Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes for these purposes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law, the California Child Day Care Facilities Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes by the State Department of Social Services. The act exempts from its provisions certain types of these facilities and certain programs, including, among others, a California state preschool program operated by a local educational agency under contract with the State Department of Education and that meets specified conditions and operates in a school building. Existing law authorizes the governing board of any school district to, among other things, repair its school property.
This bill, the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023, would, among other things, require all schoolsites, as defined, at the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces is required, to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution, as provided. The bill would require all schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would, on or before January 1, 2025, require all schoolsites, as defined, to develop an extreme heat action plan, as specified, and, by January 1, 2027, to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. The bill would require the plan to include installing or planting (1) shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them during the school day, (2) school garden infrastructure and plantings, and (3) coniferous tree barriers between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects. By imposing additional duties on local educational entities, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require the State Department of Education, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites, and to make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation. The bill would require the State Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes for these purposes.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Schools are largely characterized by impervious surfaces where water cannot easily percolate into the soil, including streets, sidewalks, playgrounds, and parking lots. These surfaces are generally composed of cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, aggregates, rubber, or synthetic turf, which absorb and store radiation throughout the day and slowly release heat throughout the night. They are nonporous and therefore do not allow water to flow through them. Air that is close to, and water runoff from, these surfaces are polluted with toxic chemicals used in the creation of these surfaces.
(b)School planning often disconnects construction and renovation from natural systems, such as forests, waterways, and wildlife habitats. The presence of nature-rich school grounds are strongly correlated with income in most cities across California. This means that schools with the fewest resources usually also have the least access to nature, increasing extreme heat and environmental pollution.
(c)Children spend a significant portion of their day at their schoolsite. Adding green spaces to schoolyards has been linked to persistent changes in recess behavior, including increased physical activity and social collaboration. The choices schools and school districts make about how they manage their land directly impacts pupils daily experiences, their mental and physical health, and their learning outcomes.
(d)The removal of surfaces that absorb heat, and the increase of natural systems on school grounds, directly protects children from high temperatures and reduces urban heat islands in the surrounding community, while also making school grounds more comfortable for both children and adults.
(e)An ecological schoolyard with trees and other plantings provides a peaceful, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasant environment for pupils, particularly for those pupils who lack the desire or ability to engage in competitive, fast-paced, or more structured activities. This has been shown to improve mental health and the ability to pay attention for both children and adults. The presence of trees on school grounds is associated with higher academic achievement for pupils.
(f)Ecological schoolyards provide a diverse, engaging, and multifaceted play and social environment that encourages collaborative and cooperative play and social interaction, reducing the aggression and bullying that occurs on traditional playgrounds.
SEC. 2.Article 5 (commencing with Section 17615) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 10.5 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:5.School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 202317615.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
17615.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Child daycare facility means a facility, owned or operated by a local educational agency, that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. The term child daycare facilities includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
(b)Local educational agency means a school district or charter school.
(c)Outdoor surfaces means any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property.
(d)School designee means a schoolsite or local educational agency employee identified by the schoolsite or local educational agency to carry out and ensure that the requirements of this article are met.
(e)Schoolsite means any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a local educational agency for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils. Schoolsite does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(f)Specific heat means the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
17615.2.(a)It is the policy of this state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and that the state, in order to reduce childrens exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites pursuant to this article.
(b)The next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, the schoolsite shall replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
(c)The school designee shall make every effort to meet the requirements of this section in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
(d)All schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite shall be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
17615.3.(a)The department, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, shall do both of the following:
(1)Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites.
(2)Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
(b)The State Department of Social Services shall identify a liaison for child daycare facilities for purposes of this article.
17615.4.(a)On or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites shall develop an extreme heat action plan and, by January 1, 2027, shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, to do addressing all of the following:
(a)Install or plant shade(1)The installation or planting of shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
(1)(A)Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat.
(2)(B)Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
(b)Install or plant school(2)The installation or planting of school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
(c)Install or plant a(3)The installation or planting of a green barrier, such as a hedgegrow hedgerow of native plants, fruit trees, or conifers, between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
(b)(1)On or before January 1, 2027, all schoolsites shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan developed pursuant to subdivision (a).
(2)The implementation of this subdivision shall be contingent upon an appropriation for this purpose in the annual Budget Act or another statute.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 3.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Schools are largely characterized by impervious surfaces where water cannot easily percolate into the soil, including streets, sidewalks, playgrounds, and parking lots. These surfaces are generally composed of cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, aggregates, rubber, or synthetic turf, which absorb and store radiation throughout the day and slowly release heat throughout the night. They are nonporous and therefore do not allow water to flow through them. Air that is close to, and water runoff from, these surfaces are polluted with toxic chemicals used in the creation of these surfaces.
(b)School planning often disconnects construction and renovation from natural systems, such as forests, waterways, and wildlife habitats. The presence of nature-rich school grounds are strongly correlated with income in most cities across California. This means that schools with the fewest resources usually also have the least access to nature, increasing extreme heat and environmental pollution.
(c)Children spend a significant portion of their day at their schoolsite. Adding green spaces to school yards schoolyards has been linked to persistent changes in recess behavior, including increased physical activity and social collaboration. The choices schools and school districts make about how they manage their land directly impacts pupils daily experiences, their mental and physical health, and their learning outcomes.
(d)The removal of surfaces that absorb heat, and the increase of natural systems on school grounds, directly protects children from high temperatures and reduces urban heat islands in the surrounding community, while also making school grounds more comfortable for both children and adults.
(e)An ecological schoolyard with trees and other plantings provides a peaceful, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasant environment for pupils, particularly for those pupils who lack the desire or ability to engage in competitive, fast-paced, or more structured activities. This has been shown to improve mental health and the ability to pay attention for both children and adults. The presence of trees on school grounds is associated with higher academic achievement for pupils.
(f)Ecological schoolyards provide a diverse, engaging, and multifaceted play and social environment that encourages collaborative and cooperative play and social interaction, reducing the aggression and bullying that occurs on traditional playgrounds.
SEC. 2.Article 5 (commencing with Section 17615) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 10.5 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:5.School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 202317615.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
17615.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Child daycare facility means a facility facility, owned or operated by a local educational agency, that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. Child The term child daycare facilities facilities includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, and family daycare homes. infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
(b)Daycare center means any child daycare facility, other than a family daycare home, and includes infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.(c)Earliest possible time means the next time an outdoor surface of a schoolsite is planned to be replaced or resurfaced.(d)Family daycare home means a home that regularly provides care, protection, and supervision for 14 or fewer children, in the providers own home, for periods of less than 24 hours per day, while the parents or guardians are away, and is either a large family daycare home or a small family daycare home, as those terms are defined in Section 1596.78 of the Health and Safety Code.(b)Local educational agency means a school district or charter school.
(e)(c)Outdoor surfaces means any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property.
(f)(d)School designee means a schoolsite or school district local educational agency employee identified by a the schoolsite or school district local educational agency to carry out and ensure that the requirements of this article are met.
(g)(e)Schoolsite means any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a school district, county office of education, or charter school local educational agency for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils. Schoolsite does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(h)(f)Specific heat means the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
17615.2.(a)It is the policy of this state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and that the state, in order to reduce childrens exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites pursuant to this article.
(b)At the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite is required, all schoolsites The next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, the schoolsite shall replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
(c)The school designee shall make every effort to meet the requirements of this section in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
(d)All schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite shall be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
17615.3.(a)The department, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, shall do both of the following:
(1)Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites.
(2)Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
(b)The State Department of Social Services shall identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes facilities for purposes of this article.
17615.4.On or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites shall develop an extreme heat action plan and, by January 1, 2027, shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, to do all of the following:
(a)Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
(1)Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat.
(2)Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
(b)Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
(c)Install or plant a coniferous tree barrier green barrier, such as a hedgegrow of native plants, fruit trees, or conifers, between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Schools are largely characterized by impervious surfaces where water cannot easily percolate into the soil, including streets, sidewalks, playgrounds, and parking lots. These surfaces are generally composed of cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, aggregates, rubber, or synthetic turf, which absorb and store radiation throughout the day and slowly release heat throughout the night. They are nonporous and therefore do not allow water to flow through them. Air that is close to, and water runoff from, these surfaces are polluted with toxic chemicals used in the creation of these surfaces.
(b)School planning often disconnects construction and renovation from natural systems, such as forests, waterways, and wildlife habitats. The presence of nature-rich school grounds are strongly correlated with income in most cities across California. This means that schools with the fewest resources usually also have the least access to nature, increasing extreme heat and environmental pollution.
(c)Children spend a significant portion of their day at their schoolsite. Adding green spaces to school yards has been linked to persistent changes in recess behavior, including increased physical activity and social collaboration. The choices schools and school districts make about how they manage their land directly impacts pupils daily experiences, their mental and physical health, and their learning outcomes.
(d)The removal of surfaces that absorb heat, and the increase of natural systems on school grounds, directly protects children from high temperatures and reduces urban heat islands in the surrounding community, while also making school grounds more comfortable for both children and adults.
(e)An ecological schoolyard with trees and other plantings provides a peaceful, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasant environment for pupils, particularly for those pupils who lack the desire or ability to engage in competitive, fast-paced, or more structured activities. This has been shown to improve mental health and the ability to pay attention for both children and adults. The presence of trees on school grounds is associated with higher academic achievement for pupils.
(f)Ecological schoolyards provide a diverse, engaging, and multifaceted play and social environment that encourages collaborative and cooperative play and social interaction, reducing the aggression and bullying that occurs on traditional playgrounds.
SEC. 2.Article 5 (commencing with Section 17615) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 10.5 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:5.School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 202317615.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
17615.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Child daycare facility means a facility that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. Child daycare facilities includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, and family daycare homes.
(b)Daycare center means any child daycare facility, other than a family daycare home, and includes infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
(c)Earliest possible time means the next time an outdoor surface of a schoolsite is planned to be replaced or resurfaced.
(d)Family daycare home means a home that regularly provides care, protection, and supervision for 14 or fewer children, in the providers own home, for periods of less than 24 hours per day, while the parents or guardians are away, and is either a large family daycare home or a small family daycare home, as those terms are defined in Section 1596.78 of the Health and Safety Code.
(e)Outdoor surfaces means any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property.
(f)School designee means a schoolsite or school district employee identified by a schoolsite or school district to carry out and ensure that the requirements of this article are met.
(g)Schoolsite means any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a school district, county office of education, or charter school for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils. Schoolsite does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(h)Specific heat means the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
17615.2.(a)It is the policy of this state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and that the state, in order to reduce childrens exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites pursuant to this article.
(b)At the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite is required, all schoolsites shall replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
(c)The school designee shall make every effort to meet the requirements of this section in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
(d)All schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite shall be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
17615.3.(a)The department, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, shall do both of the following:
(1)Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites.
(2)Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
(b)The State Department of Social Services shall identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes for purposes of this article.
17615.4.On or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites shall develop an extreme heat action plan and, by January 1, 2027, shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, to do all of the following:
(a)Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them during the schoolday. when in attendance. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
(1)Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat.
(2)Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the school year.
(b)Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
(c)Install or plant a coniferous tree barrier between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Schools are largely characterized by impervious surfaces where water cannot easily percolate into the soil, including streets, sidewalks, playgrounds, and parking lots. These surfaces are generally composed of cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, aggregates, rubber, or synthetic turf, which absorb and store radiation throughout the day and slowly release heat throughout the night. They are nonporous and therefore do not allow water to flow through them. Air that is close to, and water runoff from, these surfaces are polluted with toxic chemicals used in the creation of these surfaces.
(b)School planning often disconnects construction and renovation from natural systems, such as forests, waterways, and wildlife habitats. The presence of nature-rich school grounds are strongly correlated with income in most cities across California. This means that schools with the fewest resources usually also have the least access to nature, increasing extreme heat and environmental pollution.
(c)Children spend a significant portion of their day at their schoolsite. Adding green spaces to school yards has been linked to persistent changes in recess behavior, including increased physical activity and social collaboration. The choices schools and school districts make about how they manage their land directly impacts pupils daily experiences, their mental and physical health, and their learning outcomes.
(d)The removal of surfaces that absorb heat, and the increase of natural systems on school grounds, directly protects children from high temperatures and reduces urban heat islands in the surrounding community, while also making school grounds more comfortable for both children and adults.
(e)An ecological schoolyard with trees and other plantings provides a peaceful, comfortable, and aesthetically pleasant environment for pupils, particularly for those pupils who lack the desire or ability to engage in competitive, fast-paced, or more structured activities. This has been shown to improve mental health and the ability to pay attention for both children and adults. The presence of trees on school grounds is associated with higher academic achievement for pupils.
(f)Ecological schoolyards provide a diverse, engaging, and multifaceted play and social environment that encourages collaborative and cooperative play and social interaction, reducing the aggression and bullying that occurs on traditional playgrounds.
SEC. 2.Article 5 (commencing with Section 17615) is added to Chapter 5 of Part 10.5 of Division 1 of Title 1 of the Education Code, to read:5.School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 202317615.This article shall be known, and may be cited, as the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
17615.1.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Child daycare facility means a facility that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. Child daycare facilities includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, and family daycare homes.
(b)Daycare center means any child daycare facility, other than a family daycare home, and includes infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
(c)Earliest possible time means the next time an outdoor surface of a schoolsite is planned to be replaced or resurfaced.
(d)Family daycare home means a home that regularly provides care, protection, and supervision for 14 or fewer children, in the providers own home, for periods of less than 24 hours per day, while the parents or guardians are away, and is either a large family daycare home or a small family daycare home, as those terms are defined in Section 1596.78 of the Health and Safety Code.
(e)Outdoor surfaces means any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property.
(f)School designee means a schoolsite or school district employee identified by a schoolsite or school district to carry out and ensure that the requirements of this article are met.
(g)Schoolsite means any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a school district, county office of education, or charter school for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils. Schoolsite does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
(h)Specific heat means the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
17615.2.(a)It is the policy of this state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and that the state, in order to reduce childrens exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites pursuant to this article.
(b)At the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite is required, all schoolsites shall replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
(c)The school designee shall make every effort to meet the requirements of this section in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
(d)All schoolsite decisionmaking personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite shall be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
17615.3.(a)The department, in consultation with the State Department of Social Services, as appropriate, shall do both of the following:
(1)Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites.
(2)Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
(b)The State Department of Social Services shall identify a liaison for child daycare facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes for purposes of this article.
17615.4.On or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites shall develop an extreme heat action plan and, by January 1, 2027, shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, to do all of the following:
(a)Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them during the schoolday. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
(1)Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat.
(2)Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the school year.
(b)Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
(c)Install or plant a coniferous tree barrier between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2023 | September 1 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 16, 2023 | August 16 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (July 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jul 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on ED. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (July 11). Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jul 6, 2023 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Jul 6, 2023 | Re-referred to Coms. on HUM. S. and ED. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and HUM. S. |
| Jun 1, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 31, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 4. Page 1392.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 1172.) (May 18). |
| May 16, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 15, 2023 | May 15 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 5, 2023 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| May 2, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0. Page 876.) (April 24). |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Mar 27, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Mar 23, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on HUMAN S. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 451.) (March 22). |
| Mar 2, 2023 | Set for hearing March 22. |
| Feb 22, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and HUMAN S. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 12, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Education] | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB499 Menjivar et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Mar 22, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Human Services] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 350 Sacramento | ** Support | |
| Amigos de los Rios | ** Support | |
| Angelenos for Trees | ** Support | |
| Arts District Community Council LA | ** Support | |
| Association Of California School Administrators | ** Against | |
| A Voice for Choice Advocacy | ** Support | |
| Bay Area JEA | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Jewish Earth Alliance | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Urban Forest Ecosystem Council | ** Support | |
| Baycats | ** Support | |
| Beyond Pesticides | ** Support | |
| California Environmental Voters | ** Support | |
| California Health Coalition Advocacy | ** Support | |
| California Parents Union | ** Support | |
| California Releaf | ** Support | |
| California School Boards Association | ** Against | |
| California Urban Forests Council | ** Support | |
| Canopy | ** Support | |
| Central Coast Urban Forests Council | ** Support | |
| Clean Earth 4 Kids | ** Support | |
| cleanearth4kids.org | ** Support | |
| Clean & Green Pomona | ** Support | |
| Climate Action California | ** Support | |
| Climate Action Now | ** Support | |
| Climate Reality Project, Los Angeles Chapter | ** Support | |
| Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley | ** Support | |
| Coalition For Adequate School Housing | ** Against | |
| Community Forest Advisory Committee | ** Support | |
| County School Facilities Consortium | ** Against | |
| Early Edge California | ** Support | |
| Educate. Advocate. | ** Support | |
| Glendale Environmental Coalition | ** Support | |
| Green Schoolyards America | ** Support | |
| Growing Together | ** Support | |
| Hills for Everyone | ** Support | |
| Industrial District Green | ** Support | |
| Inland Urban Forest Council | ** Support | |
| International Society of Arboriculture, Western Chapter | ** Support | |
| Koreatown Youth and Community Center INC. | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Beautification Team | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Conservation Corps | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust | ** Support | |
| Lumber Cycle | ** Support | |
| Madera Coalition for Community Justice | ** Support | |
| Non Toxic Communities | ** Support | |
| Nontoxic Schools | ** Support | |
| North East Trees | ** Support | |
| Numerous individuals | ** Support | |
| Office of the Riverside County Superintendent of Schools | ** Against | |
| Pesticide Free Zone | ** Support | |
| Riverside County Office Of Education | ** Against | |
| Sacramento Tree Foundation | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Urban Forest Council | ** Support | |
| Safe Healthy Playing Fields, Inc. | ** Support | |
| San Diegans for Sustainable, Equitable, & Quiet Equipment in Landscaping | ** Support | |
| San Diego Regional Urban Forests Council | ** Support | |
| San Joaquin Urban Forest Council | ** Support | |
| Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action | ** Support | |
| Solano County Democratic Central Committee | ** Support | |
| Stand Up California | ** Support | |
| Stand Up For California | ** Support | |
| Street Tree Seminar | ** Support | |
| Sustainable Claremont | ** Support | |
| The Climate Center | ** Support | |
| The Field Fund | ** Support | |
| Tree Fresno | ** Support | |
| Treepeople | ** Support | |
| Urban Ecos | ** Support | |
| Watsonville Wetlands Watch | ** Support | |
| Your Children's Trees | ** Support |
Date of Hearing: August 16, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 499
Author:(Menjivar) – As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
Policy Committee: | Human Services | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
Education | 4 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires every school in the state, contingent on appropriation, to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan. The bill also requires every school to replace outdoor surfaces with more heat resistant materials the next time the school replaces an outdoor surface.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, contingent on appropriation, every school site to develop an extreme heat action plan by January 1, 2025. The plan is to include the installation or planting of (a) shade trees or mini-forests, (b) schools gardens, and (c) a green barrier between the school site and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
- Requires, contingent on appropriation, every school to begin implementation of the plan by January 1, 2027.
- Requires the California Department of Education (CDE), in consultation with the Department of Social Services (DSS), as appropriate, to (a) develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schools, (b) make a model program guidebook available to schools, and (c) establish a process for updating the guidebook. The bill further requires DSS to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities with regard to extreme heat action plans.
- Requires, the next time the outdoor surfaces of a school site are resurfaced or replaced, the school site to replace outdoor surfaces with a “low specific heat surface,” such as concrete and asphalt, with a material qualifying as a “high specific hear surface,” such as cool pavement technologies, grass, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs to schools of an unknown amount, but potentially in the tens of millions of dollars to hundreds of millions of dollars, to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan.
The state has over 10,000 schools. Assuming a planning and implementation grant of $10,000 per school site, costs would be $100 million. Costs would be somewhat lower to the extent schools have already received Green Schoolyard grants, described below, or implemented elements of extreme heat action plan requirements prior, as anecdotal evidence suggests some have done.
- One-time and ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs of an unknown, but potentially significant amount, to local educational agencies to replace or resurface outdoor low specific heat surfaces with high specific heat surfaces.
California does not maintain a statewide database for tracking information about school facilities or grounds. Without information about the types, sizes and useful lifes of schools’ outdoor surfaces, estimating the cost to replace those surfaces with surfaces more appropriate for extreme heat is difficult. While certain technologies are in development and the cost of high specific heat surfaces may be decreasing as time goes on, according to DGS, these materials may be more expensive and may need to be replaced more frequently than other surfaces such as concrete or asphalt.
If the Commission on State Mandates determines the bill’s requirements to be a reimbursable state mandate, the state would need to reimburse these costs to local educational agencies or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
- Minor and absorbable General Fund costs to CDE to support the work required by this bill. A template that may fulfill this bill’s requirement exists already as part of the Green Schoolyards grant program.
- One-time and ongoing General Fund costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars for DSS to hire staff to support the work required in the bill.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Extreme heat events are expected to increase in frequency, severity, and duration…Current measures to combat the impacts on our children are not stringent enough or moving at a pace comparable to the effects of climate change. Every year that passes without implementing robust mitigation strategies, our young people on school sites endure increasing discomfort, physical harm, and mental and emotional exasperation. These high heat emitting surfaces affect their academic performance, sense of well-being, and future. SB 499 will implement clear, actionable directives to protect our students and support their prosperity.
- Background. The Natural Resources Agency released the state’s first Extreme Heat Action Plan in April 2022. Multiple state entities and stakeholders developed the plan. The plan provides a comprehensive set of state actions that will help the state adapt to and strengthen resilience to extreme heat. The plan includes actions related to supporting climate-smart planning in heat-vulnerable schools, promoting climate-appropriate shade tree cover at schools, and promoting increased use of green barriers.
The Budget Act of 2022 included $465 million over two years to address extreme heat. Included in that funding was $150 million to CAL Fire to administer the Green Schoolyards grant program. The program awards grants to cities, counties, qualifying districts (including schools and eligible child care facilities), and nonprofit organizations to assist with planning and implementing projects to plant trees that will provide significant amounts of shade when mature. The request for applications for round one of the Green Schoolyard planning grants and implementation grants went out earlier this year, and applications were due April 28, 2023. The grant guidelines state planning grants can range from $75,000 to $3 million awarded per applicant, with a maximum of $200,000 per school campus included in the project. The grant guidelines state implementation grants can range from $500,000 to $30 million, with a maximum of $2.5 million per school campus included in the project. On July 12, 2023, Cal Fire announced the selection of nine recipients of a planning grant and six recipients of an implementation grant but did not publish the amounts awarded. The selected entities typically represented either a school district or a coalition working with school districts.
- Opposition. The Association of California School Administrators (ACSA) and others oppose this bill. With regard to cost concerns, ACSA writes:
We are also deeply concerned about the costs created by this proposal, made worse by the fact existing facility needs for public schools statewide exceeds $8 billion and the State Facilities Program is exhausted. There is no dedicated funding for schools to carry out the requirements in the bill.
- Related Legislation. SB 394 (Gonzalez) requires, contingent on appropriation, the California Energy Commission, in consultation with CDE, the Division of the State Architect, Office of Public School Construction, and Natural Resources Agency, to facilitate an interagency process and stakeholder engagement to develop a Master Plan for Healthy, Sustainable, and Climate-Resilient Schools. The bill is pending in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 12, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Al Muratsuchi, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 499
Author:(Menjivar) – As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
[Note: This bill is double referred to the Assembly Human Services Committee and was heard by that Committee as it relates to issues under its jurisdiction.]
SENATE VOTE: 32-4
SUBJECT: School facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023
SUMMARY: Requires: 1) all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan to plant shade trees, install a school garden, and plant a coniferous tree barrier; 2) the next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, the schoolsite to replace low specific heat surfaces; 3) the California Department of Education (CDE), in consultation with the California Department of Social Services (CDSS), to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan, and to make available a model program guidebook; and, 4) the CDSS to identify a liaison for child care facilities. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
- States that it is the policy of the state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and that the state, in order to reduce children’s exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites.
- Requires, the next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, the schoolsite to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution. Requires the school designee to make every effort to meet these requirements in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
- Requires all schoolsite decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
- Requires, or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites to develop an extreme heat action plan addressing all of the following:
- The installation or planting of shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees to be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat; and
- Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
- The installation or planting of school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade; and
- The installation or planting of a green barrier, such as a hedgerow of native plants, fruit trees, or conifers, between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
- The installation or planting of shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees to be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2027, all schoolsites to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. Requires the implementation of the extreme heat action plan to be contingent upon an appropriation for this purpose in the annual Budget Act or another statute.
- Requires the CDE, in consultation with the CDSS, as appropriate, to do both of the following:
- Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites; and
- Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
- Requires the CDSS to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities for purposes of this act.
- Defines the following:
- “Child daycare facility” to mean a facility, owned or operated by a local educational agency (LEA), that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. The term “child daycare facilities” includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
- “Local educational agency” to mean a school district or charter school.
- “Outdoor surfaces” to mean any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property.
- “School designee” to mean a schoolsite or LEA employee identified by the schoolsite or LEA to carry out and ensure that the specified requirements are met.
- “Schoolsite” to mean any facility used as a child daycare facility or by an LEA for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils. “Schoolsite” does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
- “Specific heat” to mean the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes a goal of doubling energy efficiency savings from existing building end uses by January 1, 2030. Existing law requires the CEC to establish annual targets for statewide energy efficiency savings and demand reduction to achieve this goal.
- Establishes the School Energy Efficiency Stimulus Program (also known as the California Schools Healthy Air, Plumbing, and Efficiency Program – CalSHAPE), which provides grants to LEAs to fund appliance, plumbing, and HVAC upgrades at schools using ratepayer energy efficiency incentives. Existing law designates the CEC as the third-party administrator of CalSHAPE grants and sunsets the program on January 1, 2027.
- Established the Clean Energy Job Creation Program and allocates Proposition 39 revenues to fund energy efficient retrofits and clean energy installations as well as related improvements and repairs that contribute to reduced operating costs and provide certain non-energy benefits, including improved health and safety conditions in public schools. The program also allocated funds to the State Energy Conservation Assistance Account Education Subaccount (ECAA-Ed) to provide LEAs with no-interest revolving loans to fund energy efficiency and renewable energy projects.
- Establishes the School Facility Program (SFP) under which the state provides general obligation bond funding for various school construction projects, including new construction, modernization, joint-use facilities, and programs to specifically address the construction needs of charter schools, career technical education facilities, and seismic mitigation.
- Defines “good repair” to mean a school facility that is maintained in a manner that assures that it is clean, safe, and functional as determined pursuant to a school facility inspection and evaluation instrument developed by the Office of Public School Construction (OPSC) and approved by the State Board of Education (SBE) or a local evaluation instrument that meets the same criteria, and requires the evaluation instrument to include mechanical systems, including heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning systems, that are functional and unobstructed, appear to supply adequate amount of air to all classrooms, work spaces, and facilities, and maintain interior temperatures within normally acceptable ranges. (Education Code (EC) 17002(d))
- Requires the CDE to establish standards for use by school districts to ensure that the design and construction of school facilities is educationally appropriate, promotes school safety, and provides school districts with flexibility in designing instructional facilities. (EC 17251(c))
- Requires, the Department of General Services (DGS), under the police power of the state, to supervise the design and construction of any school building or the reconstruction or alteration of or addition to any school building to ensure that plans and specifications comply with the specified rules and regulations, and to ensure that the work of construction has been performed in accordance with the approved plans and specifications, for the protection of life and property. (EC 17280)
- Requires the governing board of any school district to meet with appropriate local government recreation and park authorities to review all possible methods of coordinating planning, design, and construction of new school facilities and schoolsites or major additions to existing school facilities and recreation and park facilities in the community. (EC 35275)
- Makes findings and declarations that school gardens provide an interactive, hands-on learning environment in which pupils learn composting and waste management techniques, fundamental concepts about nutrition and obesity prevention, and the cultural and historical aspects of our food supply. States that school gardens also foster a better understanding and appreciation of where food comes from, how food travels from the farm to the table, and the important role of agriculture in the state, national, and global economy. (EC 51795)
- Establishes the Instructional School Gardens Program, administered by the CDE for the promotion, creation, and support of instructional school gardens through the allocation of grants, and through technical assistance provided, to school districts, charter schools, or county offices of education (COEs). (EC 51796)
- Prohibits a local governing board from siting a school located on land that was previously a hazardous waste disposal site, that contains pipelines that carry hazardous substances, or that is near an airport runway or freeway, other busy traffic corridors and railyards that have the potential to expose students and school staff to hazardous air emissions. (EC 17213 and 17215)
- Requires the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to identify disadvantaged communities for investment opportunities. Requires these communities to be identified based on geographic, socioeconomic, public health, and environmental hazard criteria, and may include, but are not limited to, either of the following:
- Areas disproportionately affected by environmental pollution and other hazards that can lead to negative public health effects, exposure, or environmental degradation; or
- Areas with concentrations of people that are of low income, high unemployment, low levels of homeownership, high rent burden, sensitive populations, or low levels of educational attainment. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) 39711)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- While the bill’s requirement for schools to implement an extreme heat action plan would be contingent upon an appropriation, it could lead to one-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure in the low to mid hundreds of millions of dollars. This estimate assumes a minimum cost of $10,000 for each schoolsite in the state and is based on the amount that is currently provided for the existing Green Schoolyards grant program. Further, by requiring all schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces and develop extreme heat action plans, this bill could result in a reimbursable state mandate. The extent of these costs is unknown but could be significant, and would create additional cost pressure on the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
- The Department of Social Services estimates ongoing administrative costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to comply with the bill’s requirements, including the development of guidance, future updates, and providing technical assistance.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill. According to the author, “Extreme heat events are expected to increase in frequency, severity, and duration. Extreme heat and climate change disproportionately impacts Black, Indigenous, and People of Color and low-income communities. One example of this has been seen in my district as on a 93-degree day, it was recorded that the school asphalt reached 145 degrees. Research supports that communities with the fewest resources usually have the least access to nature within and surrounding their school grounds, coupled with the highest heat, pollution, and environmental toxicology levels.
Current measures to combat the impacts on our children are not stringent enough or moving at a pace comparable to the effects of climate change. Every year that passes without implementing robust mitigation strategies, our young people on school sites endure increasing discomfort, physical harm, and mental and emotional exasperation. These high heat emitting surfaces affect their academic performance, sense of well-being, and future. SB 499 will implement clear, actionable directives to protect our students and support their prosperity.”
LEAs have diverse and unique energy and climate challenges. Public K-12 facilities in California include approximately 12,800 schools with more than 714 million square feet of space, making LEAs the largest category of building in the public building sector. Unlike other commercial end users, government buildings generally are not able to use energy savings to reinvest in more capital improvements, which leads public buildings to require regular cycles of investment to update facilities and replace less efficient appliances. While some school districts may seek local and state bond or tax funding to make these updates, other school districts may seek monies and tax incentives from the recently enacted federal Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and Inflation Reduction Act (IRA).
This bill seeks to require all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan to plant shade trees, install a school garden, and plant a green barrier between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects, and to require, the next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, the schoolsite to replace low specific heat surfaces. The Committee may wish to consider that the diversity of size, condition, and location of California’s LEAs creates significant challenges for unilaterally requiring specific methods to reduce the impact of heat on students and schools. Local building ordinances may discourage or prohibit the use of specific interventions required by the bill, such as tree barriers, due to concerns related to water conservation and defensible space for wildfire prevention.
Most, if not all LEAs make decisions regarding infrastructure changes or improvements at the LEA, rather than schoolsite level. The Committee may wish to consider if requiring each of the approximately 12,800 schoolsites, and applicable childcare sites, to each develop their own extreme heat action plan, and associated training related to ground surface materials, is appropriate at the schoolsite level, or is even necessary. Existing law requires schoolsites to complete a school safety plan, which may include many of the components that would be required by this bill. LEAs have numerous reports which must be developed regularly, such as the Local Control and Accountability Plan (LCAP), and feedback from LEA leaders has been clear – in their totality, the reports have become overly burdensome and hinder, rather than improve, their ability to manage the associated programs and funds to improve student outcomes.
LEAs have a number of climate change-related improvements they could make to their schoolsites, including fuel switching, electric vehicle (EV) charging, on-site clean energy generation, and replacing HVAC systems and water filtration with more efficient equipment. LEAs with sufficient resources may have little difficulties in taking advantage of new funding opportunities as they arise; however, smaller LEAs and LEAs with limited support resources may experience tremendous challenges meeting these requirements without additional funding and technical assistance.
Finally, the Committee may wish to consider that the definition of LEA in the bill is limited to school districts and charter schools. County offices of education (COEs) also include schoolsites.
Climate change impacts in California. California’s climate is generally expected to become hotter, drier, and more variable over the coming decades, increasing the risk of catastrophic wildfires, droughts, floods, extreme weather, biodiversity loss, and sea level rise. California’s Fourth Climate Assessment estimates the economic cost to California for these losses by 2050 will be over $100 billion annually. Average global temperatures have increased since 1895, with the fastest relative increase beginning in the 1980s. Nine of the ten hottest years recorded have occurred in the last decade. In California, the statewide average temperature is predicted to increase 1.9°F by 2025 and 4.6°F by 2050. Populations in cooler parts of the state, particularly along the coast, are generally at a greater risk for health-related illness because they are less acclimatized to heat, people may be less aware of behaviors to reduce exposure, and the built environment is not designed for warmer temperatures.
Urban areas have higher temperatures than in surrounding areas due to pavement and building materials that absorb sunlight and heat. This phenomenon is referred to as the urban heat island effect. Average daytime temperatures in urban areas are 1-6°F warmer than surrounding areas, but at night that increases to as much as 22°F as the heat is gradually released from buildings and paved surfaces. The urban heat island effect increases the health risks associated with extreme heat for populations living in those areas. A number of strategies can be used to mitigate the urban heat island effect, such as shading, green spaces, and the use of cool building and paving materials.
Greener schools. The majority of the state’s urban schools are covered in hard surfaces, particularly in neighborhoods that are already suffering from park scarcity. Play spaces are covered in asphalt and concrete, which contribute to the urban heat island effect. Green space, such as grass, trees, and shrubs, which have been shown to lower temperatures is linked to improved child development outcomes. In addition to reducing heat, spending time in green spaces has been shown to improve student’s academic achievement, improve concentration, and reduce stress. Greenery near schools has also been shown to improve air quality.
School garden programs. Existing law encourages schools to establish school garden programs. The Green Schoolyards grant program, a component of CalFire’s Urban and Community Forestry Program, is designed to assist with planning and implementing projects to plant trees that, when mature, will cover at least 30% of each school property, shading areas used most often by students during the school day. Priority for these grants is being given to districts and schools in under-served communities with the highest poverty levels, hottest climates, and least existing tree cover. Non-profit child care facilities that receive state or federal funding are also eligible for these grant funds. The 2022-23 Budget included $150 million over two years for Green Schoolyard grants ($117 million in 2022-23 and $33 million in 2023-24).
In 1995, the CDE launched the Garden in Every School initiative and collaborates with entities that support school gardens, including public and private agricultural agencies, waste management agencies, health agencies and others.
In 2006, AB 1535 (Nunez), Chapter 427, Statutes of 2006, provided $15 million via grants to LEAs to develop and maintain an instructional school garden program, administered by the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI). Kindergarten through grade 8 schoolsites were eligible to receive a maximum of $2,500 and high schools were eligible to receive a maximum of $5,000. Funds were used for instructional school garden equipment or supplies and professional development for teachers, garden volunteers and food service staff. According to the CDE, approximately 3,500 schoolsites received grants.
Existing law also requires a local governing board to evaluate methods for coordinating and planning new schoolsites and parks in the community. Many new schools are now constructed adjacent to city parks.
The impact of heat on students and their academic performance. As climate change intensifies, students are increasingly burdened by worsening heat waves, wildfires, drought, and other extreme weather-related events that hinder their well-being and academic development, according to a 2023 report from the Sean N. Parker Center for Allergy and Asthma Research at Stanford University and other partners, Climate Resilient California Schools: Safeguarding Children’s Health and Opportunity to Learn in TK-12. Children are particularly vulnerable to extreme weather conditions because their bodies are more sensitive and less capable of self-regulating temperature.
According to a 2022 Legislative Analyst Office report, Climate Change Impacts Across California K-12 Education, climate change has led to students experiencing greater learning loss, poorer academic outcomes, food insecurity, and traumatic mental health problems. Moreover, minority children who live in high-poverty neighborhoods are often exposed to more heat, which contributes to racial disparities in health outcomes. School facilities located in low-income neighborhoods have historically had fewer financial resources to invest in efficient HVAC systems, thereby compounding student health risks from worsening climate change.
Indoor temperatures in California public schools are not currently subject to any upper limits in existing law, and schools are not required to have air conditioning or other cooling systems. Indoor classrooms that cannot maintain healthy temperatures exacerbate existing inequities in student and health outcomes (Patel, 2023). According to a 2020 Journal of Human Resources article, Hot Temperature and High Stakes Performance, hot temperature reduces performance by up to 13% of a standard deviation and leads to persistent impacts on high school graduation status, despite compensatory responses by teachers who selectively upward manipulate grades after hotter exams. According to a 2020 American Economic Journal: Economic Policy article, Heat and Learning, students of color and students in lower-income areas are the most affected by heat-driven learning losses, exacerbating racial and income-based achievement gaps. It is estimated that 5% of the nationwide gap in academic achievement between white and Black students is due to heat and air conditioning disparities.
California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan. Existing law requires the Natural Resources Agency to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy every three years. In updating the strategy, the need for an interagency approach to extreme heat was identified, and therefore the state updated its extreme heat guidance and recommendations to create California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan.
California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan was released by the Natural Resources Agency in April, 2022. The plan provides a strategic and comprehensive set of state actions to adapt and build resilience to extreme heat, including supporting climate-smart planning in heat-vulnerable schools, promoting climate-appropriate shade tree cover and schools, and promoting increased use of green barriers between agricultural fields and schools.
California lacks an inventory of public school facilities, including heating and cooling devices. While the state has general information on the number of K-12 schools (10,521 schools, including alternative schools), there is not an inventory on the number of school buildings within a schoolsite, the types of facilities in those buildings (e.g., gymnasiums, multipurpose rooms, etc.), or the size, and status of their outdoor areas (e.g., gardens, play structures, and other surfaces). Beginning in 2008, school districts applying for state bond funds must complete an informational worksheet on the project. Data on the number of new facilities and the types of facilities constructed since 2008 is available, but is not comprehensive. California does not maintain a statewide database for tracking which schools have air conditioning, appropriately shaded schoolyards, and other heat interventions, according to the 2019 American Society of Civil Engineers Report Card for California’s Infrastructure. According to a 2020 Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC) report, Improving K-12 School Facilities in California, not every California school has adequate access to indoor cooling, making it impossible to universally maintain temperatures ideal for teachers to educate and students to learn. And with limited statewide school facility data, the Committee may wish to consider it is difficult to know how widespread the problem is, or what the cost of interventions will be.
Arguments in support. A Voice for Choice Advocacy writes, “Children spend a significant portion of their day on their school campuses. Removing synthetic surfaces that absorb heat and adding shade trees in places that are accessible to children and youth during the school day will directly protect children from high temperatures and reduces urban heat islands in the surrounding community, while also reducing air pollution and toxic chemical exposure. Adding green spaces, including trees, shrubs, and natural grasses to schoolyards has also been linked to persistent changes in recess and classroom behavior, including increased physical activity, attention and social collaboration, higher academic achievement, decrease in stress, anxiety, and disruptive behavior. The choices schools and districts make about how they manage their land directly impacts students’ daily experiences, mental and physical health, and learning outcomes.”
Arguments in opposition. The Association of California School Administrators writes, “As you may know, school districts in California are currently taking steps to mitigate the impacts of extreme heat at their school sites. For example, the Desert Sands Unified School District in Riverside County has made heat mitigation a priority. The district’s governing board recently allocated $30 million in available facilities funding to construct shade structures at all of the district’s campuses. The district is also requiring all school sites to complete a heat mitigation plan, and has issued heat prevention guidelines for students and employees. These are locally driven efforts responding directly to the conditions created by the local environment.
Our concerns with SB 499 result from the bill’s statewide mandates that are simply not appropriate for all school sites. We believe a more prudent approach would allow time for state and local stakeholders to develop guidelines and best practices that speak to the great diversity of California’s climates and geographies. In doing so, it will create more resilient schools given the myriad environmental disasters schools endure, including fires, floods, landslides, mudslides, snowstorms and windstorms. We are also concerned that the implementation steps set forth in SB 499 fail to recognize the roles of other state and local agencies that are relevant to the discussion. For example, decisions regarding the installation of artificial turf fields at schools are often in response to concerns, if not restrictions, from water agencies during drought conditions.
We are also deeply concerned about the costs created by this proposal, made worse by the fact existing facility needs for public schools statewide exceeds $8 billion and the State Facilities Program is exhausted. There is no dedicated funding for schools to carryout the requirements in the bill.”
Related legislation. SB 394 (Gonzalez) of the 2023-24 Session would require, upon an appropriation by the Legislature for this purpose, the California Energy Commission (CEC), in consultation with the CDE, Division of the State Architect (DSA), OPSC, and NRA, to facilitate an interagency process and stakeholder engagement to develop a Master Plan for Healthy, Sustainable, and Climate-Resilient Schools.
AB 247 (Muratsuchi) of the 2023-24 Session would place the Kindergarten-Community Colleges Public Education Facilities Bond Act of 2024 on the 2024 statewide ballot, to be operative only if approved by voters at that election.
AB 384 (Calderon) of the 2023-24 Session would require the CDE to conduct a research study on recommended indoor air temperature ranges and temperature control standards for public schools, to compile a statewide inventory of heating and cooling systems and interventions in all public schools, and to develop policy recommendations for safe indoor air temperature standards for public school facilities.
AB 527 (Calderon) of the 2023-24 Session would require the CAL FIRE to provide grants to qualified entities to support school greening.
AB 1642 (Gipson) of the 2023-24 Session would require the CDE and the NRA, in consultation with the DSA, the OPSC, and any other appropriate state entities to facilitate an interagency and stakeholder engagement process to develop, on or before December 1, 2024, recommendations for a master plan for green schoolyards. Requires a report of the recommendations for a master plan for green schoolyards to be sent to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature on or before December 1, 2024.
SB 28 (Glazer) of the 2023-24 Session would place the Public Preschool, K-12, and College Health and Safety Bond Act on the ballot for the March 2024 statewide primary election.
SB 515 (Stern) of the 2023-24 Session exempt the installation of shade structures on the DSA’s approved pre-check design list from requiring school districts, COEs, charter schools, or community colleges to provide an accessible path of travel, as required by the California Building Standards Code.
AB 544 (O’Donnell) of the 2021-22 Session would have required LEAs to provide the CDE information related to each school facility, schoolsite, or school property owned or leased by the LEA. This bill was held in the Senate Education Committee.
AB 2232 (McCarty), Chapter 777, Statutes of 2022, requires a covered school (school district, COE, charter school, private school, the California Community Colleges, the California State University, and requests the University of California (UC), to ensure that facilities, including classrooms for students, have HVAC systems that meet minimum ventilation rate requirements, as specified, and to install filtration that achieves minimum efficiency reporting values (MERV) levels of 13 or higher. Requires the California Building Standards Commission and the DSA to propose for adoption mandatory standards for carbon dioxide monitors in classrooms of a covered school and the UC.
AB 2597 (Bloom) of the 2021-22 Session would have required the Department of Housing and Community Development to develop, propose, and submit to the California Building Standards Commission standards for adequate residential cooling for both new and existing units. This bill was held in the Senate Housing Committee.
SB 1167 (Mendoza), Chapter 839, Statutes of 2016, requires the Division of Occupational Safety and Health to propose to the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board for review and adoption, a standard that minimizes heat-related illness and injury among workers working in indoor places of employment by January 1, 2019.
AB 1292 (Evans) of the 2005-06 Session would have required school districts to ensure that facilities, including, but not limited to, classrooms, have HVAC systems that meet minimum requirements of indoor air quality, as adopted by the California Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2863 (Pavley) of the 2003-04 Session would have required a school district applying for state school facilities funds to include in its plans for new construction and modernization of a school building an indoor air quality management plan, and authorizes the use of certain funds to prevent indoor air problems in school facilities. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
350 Sacramento
A Voice for Choice Advocacy
Amigos De Los Rios
Angelenos for Trees
Arts District Community Council LA
Bay Area Jea
Bay Area Urban Forest Ecosystem Council
Baycats
California Environmental Voters (formerly Clcv)
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Parents Union
California Releaf
California Urban Forests Council
Canopy
Central Coast Urban Forests Council
Clean & Green Pomona
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Cleanearth4kids.org
Climate Action California
Climate Action Now
Climate Reality Project, Los Angeles Chapter
Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley
Coalition Letter
Community Forest Advisory Committee
Early Edge California
Educate. Advocate.
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Green Schoolyards America
Growing Together
Hills for Everyone
Industrial District Green
Inland Urban Forest Council
International Society of Arboriculture Western Chapter
Koreatown Youth and Community Center INC.
Los Angeles Beautification Team
Los Angeles Conservation Corps
Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust
Lumber Cycle
Madera Coalition for Community Justice
Non Toxic Communities
Nontoxic Schools
North East Trees
Pesticide Free Zone
Sacramento Urban Forest Council
Safe Healthy Playing Fields, INC.
San Diegans for Sustainable, Equitable, & Quite Equipment in Landscaping
San Diego Regional Urban Forests Council
San Joaquin Urban Forest Council
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Solano County Democratic Central Committee
Stand Up California
Stand Up for California
Street Tree Seminar
Sustainable Claremont
The Climate Center
The Field Fund
Tree Fresno
Treepeople
Urban Ecos
Watsonville Wetlands Watch
Your Children's Trees
Opposition
Association of California School Administrators
California School Boards Association
Coalition for Adequate School Housing (CASH)
County School Facilities Consortium
Office of The Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Riverside County Office of Education
Analysis Prepared by: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Date of Hearing: July 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Corey A. Jackson, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 499
Author:(Menjivar) – As Amended Ver:May 18, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 32-4
SUBJECT: School facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023
SUMMARY: Requires all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan to plant shade trees, install a school garden, and plant a coniferous tree barrier; requires the California Department of Education (CDE), in consultation with the California Department of Social Services (CDSS), to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan, make available a model program guidebook; and, requires CDSS to identify a liaison for child care facilities. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the “School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023”.
- Establishes it is the state’s policy that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and that the state, in order to reduce children’s exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites.
- Requires, the next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, the schoolsite to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution. Requires the school designee to make every effort to meet the specified requirements in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
- Requires all schoolsite decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites to develop an extreme heat action plan addressing all of the following:
- The installation or planting of shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees to be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat; and,
- Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
- The installation or planting of school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade; and,
- The installation or planting of a green barrier, such as a hedgerow of native plants, fruit trees, or conifers, between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
- The installation or planting of shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees to be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2027, all schoolsites to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan. Requires the implementation of the extreme heat action plan to be contingent upon an appropriation for this purpose in the annual Budget Act or another statute.
- Requires CDE, in consultation with CDSS, as appropriate, to do both of the following:
- Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites; and,
- Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
- Requires CDSS to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities for purposes of this act.
- Defines the following:
- “Child daycare facility” to mean a facility, owned or operated by a local educational agency, that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. The term “child daycare facilities” includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
- “Local educational agency” or “LEA” to mean a school district or charter school.
- “Outdoor surfaces” to mean any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property.
- “School designee” to mean a schoolsite or LEA employee identified by the schoolsite or LEA to carry out and ensure that the specified requirements are met.
- “Schoolsite” to mean any facility used as a child daycare facility or by an LEA for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils. “Schoolsite” does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
- “Specific heat” to mean the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires child care centers’ outdoor activity space to be situated to provide a shaded rest area for children. (Title 22, California Code of Regulations [CCR] 101238.2)
- Defines “child day care facility” to mean a facility that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. Child daycare facilities include day care centers, employer-sponsored child care centers, and family daycare homes. (Health and Safety Code Section [HSC] 1596.750)
- Defines “family child care home” to mean a facility that regularly provides care, protection, and supervision for 14 or fewer children, in the provider’s own home, for periods of less than 24 hours per day, while the parents or guardians are away, and is either a large family daycare home or a small family daycare home. (HSC 1596.78(a))
- Defines “day care center” to mean a child day care facility other than a family day care home, and includes infant centers, preschools, extended day care facilities, and schoolage child care centers and including licensed child care centers, as provided. (HSC 1596.76)
- Requires each licensee to have and keep on file a current written, definitive plan of operation and provide a copy of the plan to CDSS with the license application. Further requires the plan and related materials to contain a sketch of the building(s) to be occupied, including a floor plan that describes the capacities of the buildings and the uses intended, the room dimensions, and the rooms to be used for nonambulatory children; and, a sketch of the grounds that shows buildings, driveways, fences, storage areas, pools, gardens, recreation areas and other space used by the children, as provided. (Title 22, CCR 101173)
- States legislative intent that all families have access to childcare and development services, through resource and referral where appropriate, and regardless of demographic background or special needs, and that families are provided the opportunity to attain financial stability through employment, while maximizing growth and development of their children and enhancing their parenting skills through participation in childcare and development programs. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section [WIC] 10207.5)
- Defines “childcare and development services” to mean services designed to meet a wide variety of children’s and families’ needs while parents and guardians are working, in training, seeking employment, incapacitated, or in need of respite and states that these services may include direct care supervision, instructional activities, resource and referral programs, and alternative payment arrangements. (WIC 10213.5(j))
- Designates CDSS as the single state agency responsible for the promotion, development, and provision of care of children in the absence of their parents during the workday or while engaged in other activities which require assistance of a third party or parties, and, further, requires CDSS to administer the federal Child Care Development Fund as defined in current federal law. (WIC 10211, 45 Code of Federal Regulations 98.2)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee on May 18, 2023:
- “While the bill’s requirement for schools to implement an extreme heat action plan would be contingent upon an appropriation, it could lead to one-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure in the low to mid hundreds of millions of dollars. This estimate assumes a minimum cost of $10,000 for each schoolsite in the state and is based on the amount that is currently provided for the existing Green Schoolyards grant program. Further, by requiring all schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces and develop extreme heat action plans, this bill could result in a reimbursable state mandate. The extent of these costs is unknown but could be significant, and would create additional cost pressure on the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
- CDSS estimates ongoing administrative costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to comply with the bill’s requirements, including the development of guidance, future updates, and providing technical assistance.”
COMMENTS: This Committee has jurisdiction over childcare and CDSS. As such, this analysis is narrowly focused on these issues.
Background: Childcare in California. California’s childcare system has undergone a number of changes in recent years. In 2019, Governor Newsom signed AB 378 (Limon), Chapter 385, Statutes of 2019, which gave approximately 40,000 childcare providers the right to join a union and collectively bargain with the State of California. In 2021, AB 131 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 116, Statutes of 2021, transferred administration of certain childcare programs from CDE to CDSS, including, among others: General Child Care and Development Program (CCTR); Migrant Child Care and Development Program; Alternative Payment Program (APP); California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids stages 2 and 3; Resource and Referral agencies; Local Child Care and Development Planning Councils; and, Head Start and Early Head Start. However, California State Preschool Program (CSPP) remains under the purview of CDE.
Community-based programs are often located in commercial-type buildings and many are private centers that rely on family tuition and fees as well as public funding. In a 2023 report by First 5, “Early care education in community-based settings can positively impact child development outcomes. Publicly funded high-quality preschool programs have proven to prepare children academically for school with lasting benefits into adulthood. In addition to academic preparation, many community-based settings facilitate parental access to social services and support parent engagement.” The following are considered community-based programs: APPs, CSPPs, and CCTRs.
Home-based settings are found in neighbors’, families’, and loved ones’ homes or a babysitter. This type of setting benefits the need for flexible hours, language and cultural needs, and children with a disability. Home-based settings include APPs, CSPPs and CCTRs that participate in a Family Child Care Home Education Network (FCCHEN), Family Childcare (FCCs), a Family, Friend, or Neighbor (FFN), and nannies/babysitters. The most common home-based early care education program is an FCC.
School-based programs are set in an LEA. A school site can typically use Proposition 98 funding. These programs follow Title 5 regulations and require teachers to be credentialed. School-based programs also typically have a focus on school readiness. When a family has an older sibling, school-based programs allow for a “one-stop shop” for family engagement. The following are the different types of school-based programs: CSPPs, CCTR, Head Start, and Transitional Kindergarten (TK).
This bill would only apply to childcare sites owned and operated by an LEA such as CSPPs or before and after school daycares. This bill would not apply to community or home-based programs.
California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan. Existing law requires the California Natural Resources Agency (CNRA) to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy every three years. California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan was released by CNRA in April 2022. The need for an interagency approach to extreme heat was identified. The plan provides a strategic set of state actions to adapt and build resilience to extreme heat, including supporting climate-smart planning in heat-vulnerable schools, promoting climate-appropriate shade tree cover and schools, and promoting increased use of green barriers between agricultural fields and schools.
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “Extreme heat events are expected to increase in frequency, severity, and duration. Extreme heat and climate change disproportionately impacts Black, Indigenous, and People of Color and low-income communities. One example of this has been seen in my district as on a 93- degree day, it was recorded that the school asphalt reached 145 degrees. Research supports that communities with the fewest resources usually have the least access to nature within and surrounding their school grounds, coupled with the highest heat, pollution, and environmental toxicology levels.
“Current measures to combat the impacts on our children are not stringent enough or moving at a pace comparable to the effects of climate change. Every year that passes without implementing robust mitigation strategies, our young people on school sites endure increasing discomfort, physical harm, and mental and emotional exasperation. These high heat emitting surfaces affect their academic performance, sense of well-being, and future. [This bill] will implement clear, actionable directives to protect our students and support their prosperity.”
Need for this bill: This bill seeks to help protect children from the impacts of extreme heat. Extreme heat can negatively impact a person’s cardiovascular, kidney, and respiratory health, It is not uncommon for extreme heat waves to cause health problems and those without shelter or protection from heat are left vulnerable.
Equity Implications: According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency, children are more susceptible to extreme heat. This is because:
“Physical characteristics – Children have a smaller body mass to surface area ratio than adults, making them more vulnerable to heat-related morbidity and mortality. Children are more likely to become dehydrated than adults because they can lose more fluid quickly.
“Behaviors – Children play outside more than adults, and they may be at greater risk of heat stroke and exhaustion because they may lack the judgment to limit exertion during hot weather and to rehydrate themselves after long periods of time in the heat. There are also regular reports of infants dying when left in unattended vehicles, which suggests a low awareness of the dangers of heat events.”
A study conducted by Harvard Kennedy School Associate Professor Joshua Goodman entitled Heat and Learning found that higher temperatures directly correlated with lower test scores. The study concluded, “Student fixed effects models using 10 million PSAT-takers show that hotter school days in the year prior to the test reduce learning, with extreme heat being particularly damaging and larger effects for low income and minority students.” Implementing a heat plan could help alleviate inequities in student outcome and child development.
Policy Considerations: This bill requires CDE to consult with CDSS to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites, and make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation. This bill also requires CDSS to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities. However, this bill only applies to child daycare facilities that are operated by LEAs which falls under CDE, not CDSS. It not clear if CDSS is the ideal department to consult with, or if CDSS should identify a liaison for childcare facilities.
Double referral: This bill will be referred to the Assembly Education Committee should it pass out of this committee.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 527 (Calderon) of the current legislative session, requires Cal Fire to develop a competitive grant process to support school greening, as defined, by providing grants to eligible LEAs (excluding child care facilities), nonprofit organizations, cities, counties, and districts. AB 527 is set to be heard by the Senate Appropriations Committee on July 10, 2023.
SB 394 (Gonzalez) of the current session, requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission, upon an appropriation, to facilitate an interagency process and stakeholder engagement to develop a Master Plan for Healthy, Sustainable, and Climate-Resilient Schools in consultation with CDE, the Division of the State Architect, Office of Public School Construction, and Natural Resources Agency. SB 394 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
A Voice for Choice Advocacy (Sponsor)
Amigos de los Rios
Angelenos for Trees
Arts District Community Council LA
Bay Area Urban Forest Ecosystem Council
Beyond Pesticides
California Environmental Voters (formerly CLCV)
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Parents Union
California Releaf
California Urban Forests Council
Canopy
Central Coast Urban Forests Council
Clean & Green Pomona
Climate Action Now
Climate Reality Project, Los Angeles Chapter
Climate Reality Project, San Fernando Valley
Community Forest Advisory Committee
Early Edge California
Educate. Advocate.
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Growing Together
Hills for Everyone
Industrial District Green
Inland Urban Forest Council
International Society of Arboriculture Western Chapter
Koreatown Youth and Community Center INC.
Los Angeles Beautification Team
Los Angeles Conservation Corps
Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust
Lumber Cycle
Madera Coalition for Community Justice
Non-Toxic Schools
North East Trees
Sacramento Tree Foundation
Sacramento Urban Forest Council
Safe Healthy Playing Fields, INC.
San Diego Regional Urban Forests Council
San Joaquin Urban Forest Council
Solano County Democratic Central Committee
Stand Up California
Street Tree Seminar
Sustainable Claremont
The Climate Center
Tree Fresno
TreePeople
Urban Ecos
Watsonville Wetlands Watch
Your Children’s Trees
Opposition
County School Facilities Consortium
Analysis Prepared by: Alexandria Smith / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 499 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 499
Author: Menjivar (D), et al.
Amended: 5/18/23
Vote: 21
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 3/22/23
AYES: Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Cortese, Glazer, McGuire, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wilk
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 5-0, 4/24/23
AYES: Alvarado-Gil, Ochoa Bogh, Hurtado, Menjivar, Wahab
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Ashby, Bradford, Wahab, Wiener
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: School facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023
SOURCE: A Voice for Choice Advocacy
DIGEST:
This bill requires (1) all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop an extreme heat action plan addressing the planting of shade trees, installation or planting of a school garden, and installation or planting of a green barrier; (2) the California Department of Education (CDE), in consultation with the Department of Social Services, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan, make available a model program guidebook; and, (3) the Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child care facilities. This also bill requires all schoolsites to being implementation of their extreme heat action plans by January 1, 2027, contingent upon an appropriation for this purpose.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires the governing board of any school district to meet with appropriate local government recreation and park authorities to review all possible methods of coordinating planning, design, and construction of new school facilities and schoolsites or major additions to existing school facilities and recreation and park facilities in the community. (Education Code § 35275)
- Establishes the Instructional School Gardens Program, administered by the CDE for the promotion, creation, and support of instructional school gardens through the allocation of grants, and through technical assistance provided, to school districts, charter schools, or county offices of education. (EC § 9000 et seq, and § 51795 et seq)
- Requires the State Allocation Board to obtain construction plans for school buildings appropriate for school districts in various climates and geographical conditions of the state, and requires the plans to be composed of plans designed to meet the needs of school districts requiring school buildings of various sizes. Existing law authorizes the plans to include landscape suggestions and designs that promote the efficient use of energy and water, the maximum use of natural lighting and indoor air quality, the use of recycled materials and materials that emit a minimum of toxic substances, the use of acoustics conducive to teaching and learning, and other characteristics of high performance schools. (EC § 17261)
- Requires child care centers’ outdoor activity space to be situated to provide a shaded rest area for children. (California Code of Regulations, Title 22 § 101238.2)
This bill:
Schoolsite extreme heat action plans
- Requires, by January 1, 2025, all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop an extreme heat action plan addressing all of the following:
- The installation or planting shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites and child care facilities where children can access them when in attendance. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Directly protecting children from the effects of extreme heat.
- Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings and child care facilities to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
- The installation or planting of school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
- The installation or planting of a green barrier, such as a hedgerow of native plants, fruit trees, or conifers, between the schoolsite or child care facility and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
- The installation or planting shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites and child care facilities where children can access them when in attendance. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Requires, by January 1, 2027, all schoolsites to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, and provides that implementation is contingent upon an appropriation for this purpose.
Template, guidebook, and liaison for child care facilities
- Requires the CDE, in consultation with the Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to do both of the following:
- Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites and child care facilities.
- Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and child care facilities, and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
- Requires the Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child care facilities.
Resurfacing or replacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities
- Establishes that it is the policy of this state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities and that the state, in order to reduce children’s exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities pursuant to this bill.
- Requires a schoolsite, the next time the outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite are resurfaced or replaced, to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
- Requires the school designee (see # 9c) to make every effort to meet the requirements of this bill in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
- Requires all schoolsite and child care facilities decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite and child care facilities to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
- Defines various terms:
- “Local educational agency” (LEA) means a school district or charter school.
- “Outdoor surfaces” means any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property or and child care facility.
- “School designee” means a schoolsite or LEA employee identified by the schoolsite or LEA to carry out and ensure that the requirements of this bill are met.
- “Schoolsite” means any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a LEA for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by children. “Schoolsite” does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by students or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
- “Child daycare facility” means a facility owned or operated by a LEA that provides non-medical care to children under 18 years of age in need or personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour bases. The term “child daycare facilities” includes daycare centers, employer-sponsored childcare centers, infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and schoolage childcare centers.
- “Specific heat” means the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
- States findings and declarations relative to the benefits of an ecological schoolyard.
Comments
Existing plans and reports that support the use of shade trees to address heat issues.
- California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan. Existing law requires the Natural Resources Agency to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy every three years. In updating the strategy, the need for an interagency approach to extreme heat was identified, and therefore the state updated its extreme heat guidance and recommendations to create California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan.
- California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan was released by the Natural Resources Agency in April 2022. The plan provides a strategic and comprehensive set of state actions to adapt and build resilience to extreme heat, including supporting climate-smart planning in heat-vulnerable schools, promoting climate-appropriate shade tree cover and schools, and promoting increased use of green barriers between agricultural fields and schools. [Protecting Californians From Extreme Heat: A State Action Plan to Build Community Resilience]
- Climate Resilient California Schools. A report titled “Climate-Resilient California Schools” was released in March 2023, and includes several recommendations for schools to achieve sustainability through extreme weather, wildfire smoke/air pollution, high temperatures, and other environmental concerns. Specifically, this report includes recommendations relative to creating green schoolyards. [https://static1.squarespace.com/static/635dbc6808cab54e82a25127/t/6400991808b825694c042579/1677760795596/Climate-Resilient+California+Schools.
pdf]
- Possible sources of funding.
- Green Schoolyards. The Green Schoolyards grant program, a component of CalFire’s Urban and Community Forestry Program, is designed to assist with planning and implementing projects to plant trees that, when mature, will cover at least 30% of each school property, shading areas used most often by students during the school day. Priority for these grants is being given to districts and schools in under-served communities with the highest poverty levels, hottest climates, and least existing tree cover. Non-profit child care facilities that receive state or federal funding are also eligible for these grant funds. The 2022-23 Budget included $150 million over two years for Green Schoolyard grants ($117 million in 2022-23 and $33 million in 2023-24).
- Proposition 98. As noted in the Legislative Analyst’s February 2023 report “The 2023-24 Budget: Crafting Climate, Resources, and Environmental Budget Solutions,” the Green Schoolyards program could potentially be funded through Proposition 98, but would use school funds that would otherwise be available for other education priorities. Shifting funding to Proposition 98 would free up non-Proposition 98 General Fund resources.
- Bond funds. School greening projects are an eligible expenditure under the School Facility Program’s modernization program; however, there will be no money left in that program unless a school facilities bond is passed (see # 7 below).
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- While the bill’s requirement for schools to implement an extreme heat action plan would be contingent upon an appropriation, it could lead to one-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure in the low to mid hundreds of millions of dollars. This estimate assumes a minimum cost of $10,000 for each schoolsite in the state and is based on the amount that is currently provided for the existing Green Schoolyards grant program. Further, by requiring all schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces and develop extreme heat action plans, this bill could result in a reimbursable state mandate. The extent of these costs is unknown but could be significant, and would create additional cost pressure on the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
- The Department of Social Services estimates ongoing administrative costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to comply with the bill’s requirements, including the development of guidance, future updates, and providing technical assistance.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/19/23)
A Voice for Choice Advocacy (source)
350 Sacramento
Amigos De Los Rios
Angelenos for Trees
Arts District Community Council LA
Bay Area JEA
Bay Area Urban Forest Ecosystem Council
Baycats
California Environmental Voters
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Parents Union
California Releaf
California Urban Forests Council
Canopy
Central Coast Urban Forests Council
Clean & Green Pomona
Clean Earth 4 Kids
CleanEarth4Kids.org
Climate Action California
Climate Action Now
Coalition Letter
Community Forest Advisory Committee
Early Edge California
Educate. Advocate.
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Green Schoolyards America
Growing Together
Hills for Everyone
Industrial District Green
Inland Urban Forest Council
International Society of Arboriculture Western Chapter
Koreatown Youth and Community Center Inc.
Los Angeles Beautification Team
Los Angeles Conservation Corps
Los Angeles Neighborhood Land Trust
Lumber Cycle
Madera Coalition for Community Justice
Non Toxic Communities
Nontoxic Schools
North East Trees
Pesticide Free Zone
Sacramento Urban Forest Council
Safe Healthy Playing Fields, Inc.
San Diegans for Sustainable, Equitable, & Quite Equipment in Landscaping
San Diego Regional Urban Forests Council
San Joaquin Urban Forest Council
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Stand Up California
Stand Up for California
Street Tree Seminar
Sustainable Claremont
The Climate Center
The Field Fund
Tree Fresno
Treepeople
Urban Ecos
Watsonville Wetlands Watch
Your Children's Trees
Numerous individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/19/23)
Association of California School Administrators
California School Boards Association
California’s Coalition for Adequate School Housing
County School Facilities Consortium
Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Prepared by: Lynn Lorber / ED. / (916) 651-4105
5/23/23 13:10:22
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 499 (Menjivar) - School facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require schoolsites to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan for planting shade trees, installing a school garden, and planting green barriers. This bill would also require schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 18, 2023
Fiscal Impact:
- While the bill’s requirement for schools to implement an extreme heat action plan would be contingent upon an appropriation, it could lead to one-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure in the low to mid hundreds of millions of dollars. This estimate assumes a minimum cost of $10,000 for each schoolsite in the state and is based on the amount that is currently provided for the existing Green Schoolyards grant program. Further, by requiring all schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces and develop extreme heat action plans, this bill could result in a reimbursable state mandate. The extent of these costs is unknown but could be significant, and would create additional cost pressure on the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
- The Department of Social Services estimates ongoing administrative costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to comply with the bill’s requirements, including the development of guidance, future updates, and providing technical assistance.
Author Amendments:
Provide that schools shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plans on or before January 1, 2027, contingent upon an appropriation.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 499 (Menjivar) - School facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023
Version: May 2, 2023 | Policy Vote: ED. 7 - 0, HUMAN S. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 15, 2023 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require schoolsites to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan for planting shade trees, installing a school garden, and planting green barriers. This bill would also require schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
By requiring all schoolsites to replace low specific heat surfaces and implement extreme heat action plans, this bill could result in a costly reimbursable state mandate. Based on the amount that is currently provided for the existing Green Schoolyards grant program, the one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs could potentially be in the low to mid hundreds of millions of dollars. This estimate assumes a minimum cost of $10,000 for each schoolsite in the state.
Background:
Existing law requires the governing board of any school district to meet with appropriate local government recreation and park authorities to review all possible methods of coordinating planning, design, and construction of new school facilities and schoolsites or major additions to existing school facilities and recreation and park facilities in the community.
Existing law establishes the Instructional School Gardens Program, administered by the CDE for the promotion, creation, and support of instructional school gardens through the allocation of grants, and through technical assistance provided, to school districts, charter schools, or county offices of education.
Existing law requires the State Allocation Board to obtain construction plans for school buildings appropriate for school districts in various climates and geographical conditions of the state, and requires the plans to be composed of plans designed to meet the needs of school districts requiring school buildings of various sizes. Existing law authorizes the plans to include landscape suggestions and designs that promote the efficient use of energy and water, the maximum use of natural lighting and indoor air quality, the use of recycled materials and materials that emit a minimum of toxic substances, the use of acoustics conducive to teaching and learning, and other characteristics of high performance schools.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires schoolsites, at the next time the outdoor surfaces are resurfaced or replaced, to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution. School designees shall make every effort to meet these requirements in the least costly manner. This bill also requires schoolsites’ and child care facilities’ decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite and child care facilities to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
This bill requires CDSS to identify a liaison for child daycare facilities for the bill’s purposes. This bill also requires CDE to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites; and make a model program guidebook that is available to schoolsites, and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
This bill requires, by January 1, 2025, all schoolsites to develop an extreme heat action plan, and by January 1, 2027, to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, to do all of the following:
- Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where children can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees to be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, as specified.
- Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
- Install or plant a green barrier between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
Related Legislation:
SB 515 (Stern, 2023) exempts the installation of shade structures on the Division of the State Architect’s approved pre-check design list from requiring local educational agencies to also provide an accessible path of travel under the California Building Standards Code. SB 515 is pending in the Assembly.
AB 527 (Calderon, 2023) requires Cal Fire to develop a competitive grant process to support school greening, as defined, by providing grants to eligible local educational agencies (not including child care facilities), nonprofit organizations, cities, counties, and districts. AB 527 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2566 (Calderon, 2022), was substantially similar to AB 527 and vetoed by the Governor with the following message:
I share the author's commitment to school greening projects and my Administration is proud that the 2022-23 Budget included $150 million over two years for this purpose ($117 million in 2022-23 and $33 million in 2023-24). This funding will be administered through the existing Urban and Community Forestry Program. Additionally, Cal FIRE is able to update program guidelines to support implementation of this program and can incorporate program implementation elements outlined in this bill, as appropriate. Accordingly, neither the program nor the fund that would be established by this bill are necessary to administer the funding authorized in the Budget. Moreover, the budget agreement allocated one-time funds for this purpose, but this bill codifies an ongoing commitment not provided for in the budget.
Staff Comments:
The 2022 Budget Act includes $150 million (School Greening and Resiliency Fund) for a Green Schoolyards grant program, which is housed within Cal Fire’s Urban Forestry Program. The 2023-24 Governor’s Budget proposes the same amount for the program. The program’s guidelines were released in February 2023 with a grant application deadline of April 28, 2023. Implementation grants range from $500,000 to $30 million per applicant, with a maximum of $2.5 million per school campus. Planning grants range from $75,000 to $3 million per applicant, with a maximum of $200,000 per school campus.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Alvarado-Gil, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: | SB 499 | ||
Author: | Menjivar | ||
Version: | March 27, 2023 | Hearing Date: | April 24, 2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Bridgett Hankerson | ||
Subject: Early childhood education facilities: school facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023
SUMMARY
This bill establishes the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023, which requires all child daycare facilities and all schoolsites to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan, to install or plant shade trees, gardens, or mini-forests, as provided. This bill also requires California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to identify a liaison for child care facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes, and to consult with the California Department of Education (CDE) to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites and child care facilities, make and update as necessary, a model program guidebook for schoolsites and child care facilities, as specified.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Requires child care centers’ outdoor activity space to be situated to provide a shaded rest area for children. (Title 22, California Code of Regulations (CCR) (101238.2))
- Defines “child daycare facility” to mean a facility that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis. Child daycare facilities include day care centers, employer-sponsored child care centers, and family daycare homes. (HSC 1596.750)
- Defines “Family child care home” to mean a facility that regularly provides care, protection, and supervision for 14 or fewer children, in the provider’s own home, for periods of less than 24 hours per day, while the parents or guardians are away, and is either a large family daycare home or a small family daycare home. (HSC 1596.78(a))
- Defines “Daycare center” to mean a child day care facility other than a family day care home, and includes infant centers, preschools, extended day care facilities, and schoolage child care centers) and including licensed child care centers, as provided. (HSC 1596.76)
- Provides that it is the intent of the Legislature to create a childcare license that has individual program components that serve infant, toddler, preschool, and schoolage children and for the department consider flexibility for childcare providers and maximizing administrative efficiency while supporting a continuum of services in a manner consistent with all respective health and safety requirements. Further requires the department to adopt regulations to create a childcare center license to serve infant, toddler, preschool, and schoolage children with all respective health and safety requirements, as provided. Before January 1, 2024, all daycare centers shall be licensed as childcare centers. (HSC 1596.951)
- Requires each licensee to have and keep on file a current written, definitive plan of operation and provide a copy of the plan to CDSS with the license application. Further requires the plan and related materials to contain, a sketch of the building(s) to be occupied, including a floor plan that describes the capacities of the buildings and the uses intended, the room dimensions, and the rooms to be used for nonambulatory children; and a sketch of the grounds that shows buildings, driveways, fences, storage areas, pools, gardens, recreation areas and other space used by the children, as provided. (Title 22, CCR 101173)
- Requires the governing board of any school district to meet with appropriate local government recreation and park authorities to review all possible methods of coordinating planning, design, and construction of new school facilities and schoolsites or major additions to existing school facilities and recreation and park facilities in the community. (EDC 35275)
- Establishes the Instructional School Gardens Program, administered by the CDE for the promotion, creation, and support of instructional school gardens through the allocation of grants, and through technical assistance provided, to school districts, charter schools, or county offices of education. (EDC 9000 et seq. and 51795 et seq.)
- Requires the State Allocation Board to obtain construction plans for school buildings appropriate for school districts in various climates and geographical conditions of the state, and requires the plans to be composed of plans designed to meet the needs of school districts requiring school buildings of various sizes. Further, authorizes the plans to include landscape suggestions and designs that promote the efficient use of energy and water, the maximum use of natural lighting and indoor air quality, the use of recycled materials and materials that emit a minimum of toxic substances, the use of acoustics conducive to teaching and learning, and other characteristics of high performance schools. (EDC 17261)
This Bill:
- Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding schoolsites and child care facilities.
- Establishes the School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
- Defines “daycare center” to mean any child daycare facility, other than a family daycare home, and includes infant centers, preschools, extended daycare facilities, and school age childcare centers.
- Includes definitions of outdoor surfaces, child daycare facilities, day care center, and family child care homes, among others.
- Defines “schoolsite” to mean any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a school district, county office of education, or charter school for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by pupils.
- Excludes any institution of higher education facility attended by pupils or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, from the definition of a schoolsite.
- Defines “specific heat” as the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
- Defines “earliest possible time” to mean the next time an outdoor surface of a schoolsite and child care facility is planned to be replaced or resurfaced.
- Establishes that it is state policy that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities and that the state, in order to reduce children’s exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities, as specified.
- Requires, at the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite and child care facilities is required, all schoolsites and child care facilities to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
- Requires all schoolsites’ and child care facilities’ decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite and child care facilities to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
- Requires CDSS to identify a liaison for child care facilities, daycare centers, and family daycare homes, and to consult with CDE as appropriate to:
- Develop a template for an Extreme Heat Action Plan (EHAP) to be used by schoolsites and child care facilities.
- Make a model program guidebook that is available to schoolsites and child care facilities, and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
- Requires, by January 1, 2025, all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop an EHAP to do all of the following:
- Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites and child care facilities where children can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees are selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Directly protecting children from the effects of extreme heat, and
- Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings and child care facilities to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
- Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
- Install or plant a coniferous tree barrier between the schoolsite or child care facility and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
- Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites and child care facilities where children can access them when in attendance. Requires planting locations for shade trees are selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Requires, by January 1, 2027, all schoolsites and child care facilities to begin implementation of their EHAP.
FISCAL IMPACT
This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, extreme heat events are expected to increase in frequency, severity, and duration, and along with climate change, disproportionately impacts Black, indigenous, people of color, and low-income communities. For instance, on a 93-degree day a school in my district, it was recorded that the school’s asphalt reached 145 degrees. Research shows that resource poor communities usually have the least access to nature within and surrounding their schoolsites, and have the highest heat, pollution, and environmental toxicology levels.
The author states, “current measures to combat the climate and environmental impacts on our children are not stringent enough or moving at a pace comparable to the effects of climate change. Every year that passes without implementing robust mitigation strategies, our young people on schoolsites endure increasing discomfort, physical harm, and mental and emotional exasperation. These high heat emitting surfaces affect their academic performance, sense of well-being, and future. The School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act will implement clear, actionable directives to protect our students and support their prosperity.”
Background:
California’s Child Care and Development Programs
On July 1, 2021, as authorized by SB 89 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 24, Statutes of 2020), child care and development programs were transferred from CDE to CDSS. The transfer of these programs included: Stages 2 and 3 of the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs); the Emergency Child Care Bridge Program for Foster Children; Alternative Payment Programs; Migrant Child Care; General Child Care and Development Programs; Child Care for Children with Disabilities; and a variety of local supports for these programs, such as Resource and Referral and Local Child Care Planning Councils, in addition to quality improvement projects. The change in department oversight was meant to, among other things, reduce administrative and other barriers to program access so that providers can focus on positive outcomes for children and families. However, SB 98 did not transfer the California State Preschool Program from CDE to CDSS.
Under current law, care of children can be provided by center-based or family “home-based” daycare providers. Center-based daycare is usually located in a commercial building, where they provide “non-medical care” and supervision for infant to school age children in a group setting for periods of less than 24 hours. There are two types of family daycare homes—licensed and family, friend or neighbor (FFN) care. Family daycare is child care offered in a provider’s home. Families may choose family daycare for their children because it is a home-based setting and offers lower adult-to-child ratios. FFN care, also known as license-exempt child care, is care provided in the child’s or child care provider’s home by a person who is a relative, friend, neighbor, or other license-exempt provider. Families who choose this type of care may know and trust the caregiver, choose them for linguistic or cultural reasons, or for flexibility in scheduling, and transportation. While license-exempt child care providers are not required to be licensed in the State of California, they may be required to complete a background check in order to be reimbursed for their care through a voucher-based program.
Title 22, Division 12 of the California Code of regulation require licensed child care facilities to provide an outdoor space with a shaded rest area for children. Child care facilities must also maintain indoor rooms within a specified minimum and maximum temperature range. Schoolsites, including preschools that operate on a schoolsite, are not required to meet the same shade requirements. This bill would instead require all child care facilities and schoolsites to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan to install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned where children can access them when in attendance, install or plant a coniferous tree barrier and install or plant a school garden infrastructure and plantings.
Protecting Californians from Extreme Heat
Trees and other plant life are beneficial in many ways for a person’s physical and mental health. Trees can provide shade and cool environments, reduce overall stress, and promote health, wellness and physical activity.[1] Due to climate change, Californians are facing higher than normal weather temperatures, which can lead to extreme heat events. Extreme heat relates to “temperatures that are well above normal conditions, and extreme heat events are consecutive unusually hot days and nights for a given area.” High temperatures place vulnerable populations at a higher risk for heat-related illnesses, including seniors, children, pregnant women, the unhoused, those who work outside and those without air conditioning. Federal guidelines consider extreme heat to be 90 degrees and above. In 2022, California had a statewide extreme heat even that lasted 10 days and broke nearly 1,000 temperature records in localities across the state.
To address Californian’s needs related to heat, the state began producing a state Extreme Heat Action Plan (Action Plan).[2] The state’s Natural Resources Agency is required to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy every three years. Released in April 2022, the Action Plan delineates California’s “all-of-government approach to mitigating the health, economic, cultural, ecological, and social impacts of increasing average temperatures and heat waves.” The Action Plan also constitutes California’s response to ‘extreme heat’ and extreme heat events. The plan also includes a strategic and comprehensive set of state actions to adapt and build resilience to extreme heat, including supporting climate-smart planning in heat-vulnerable schools, promoting climate-appropriate shade tree cover and schools, and promoting increased use of green barriers between agricultural fields and school.
In addition to the Action Plan, another report called “Climate Resilient California Schools”[3] was released in March 2023 that includes several recommendations for schools to achieve sustainability through extreme weather, wildfire smoke/air pollution, high temperatures, and other environmental concerns.
Lastly, research outlined in a report by the Los Angeles Cooling Collaborative states that “Reducing urban heat exposure is an equity issue, as low-income communities and communities of color are more likely to live in neighborhoods with older buildings, low tree cover, more heat-retaining surfaces, and limited access to coping strategies such as air conditioning.”[4] To address the equity issues, the report provided recommendations for policy makers such as, increasing heat data collection and mapping to establish where hot spots currently exist within the city and demonstrations of urban cooling strategies to help gather important performance data for policymaking and serve as a tangible example to raise public awareness.
California Urban and Community Forestry Program
California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection’s (CAL FIRE) Urban & Community Forestry (UCF) Program was established to improve the management of trees and related vegetation in California communities. The UCF Program advances the development of sustainable urban and community forests to improve the quality of life in urban environments and provides grants throughout California communities to advance these urban forestry efforts.
One component of CAL FIRE’s UCF Program is the Green Schoolyards Grant Program (Grant Program). The Grant Program is designed to assist with planning and implementing projects to plant trees that, when mature, will cover at least 30 percent of each school’s property, shading areas used often by students during the school day. The Grant Program prioritizes school districts and schools in under-served communities with the highest poverty levels, hottest climates, and least existing tree cover. These grants are also open to non-profit child care facilities that receive state or federal funding. Grant Program funds may be used to support project costs including, but not limited to: planning, design, permitting, environmental assessment, soil testing, pavement removal, remediation of hazardous materials from pavement removal, water-efficient irrigation, and project maintenance. The 2022-23 Budget included $150 million in one-time funding for the Grant Program over two years for school greening projects ($117 million in FY 2022-23 and $33 million in FY 2023-24). Child care providers are eligible to apply for the Grant Program funds.
This bill would require all schoolsites, including preschools and child care facilities, by January 1, 2027 to begin implementing their EHAP.
Related/Prior Legislation:
SB 515 (Stern, 2023) exempts the installation of shade structures on the Division of the State Architect’s approved pre-check design list from requiring local educational agencies to also provide an accessible path of travel under the California Building Standards Code. SB 515 passed out of the Senate on consent and was transferred to the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 28 (Glazer, 2023) makes changes to the existing School Facility Program and places the Public Preschool, K-12, and College Health and Safety Bond Act on the ballot for the March, 2024 statewide primary election, which authorizes $15 billion in bonds. SB 28 is scheduled to be heard by the Senate Governance and Finance on April 26.
AB 57 (Kalra, 2023) establishes the California Pocket Forest Initiative under the administration of CAL FIRE to provide grants to cities, counties, districts, nonprofit organizations, and public schools to establish pocket forests on public lands in order to test and demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of the Miyawaki method in California. AB 57 is scheduled to be heard by the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 527 (Calderon, 2023) requires CAL FIRE to develop a competitive grant process to support school greening, as defined, by providing grants to eligible local educational agencies (not including child care facilities), nonprofit organizations, cities, counties, and districts. AB 527 is scheduled to be heard by the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 247 (Muratsuchi, 2023) places the “Kindergarten Through Community College Public Education Facilities Bond Act”, which authorizes an unspecified amount of bonds, on an unspecified 2024 statewide election. AB 247 has been referred to the Assembly Education Committee.
AB 2238 (Luz Rivas, Chapter 264, Statutes of 2022) requires the California Environmental Protection Agency to develop by January 1, 2025, a statewide extreme heat ranking system in coordination with the Integrated Climate Adaptation and Resiliency Program, the Department of Public Health, and the Department of Insurance, as provided.
AB 2566 (Calderon, 2022) would have required on or before July 1, 2023, CAL FIRE to develop a competitive grant program to support school greening projects, as provided. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 2114 (Kalra, 2022) would have established the California Pocket Forest Initiative under the administration of Cal FIRE to provide grants to cities, counties, districts, nonprofit organizations, and public schools to establish pocket forests on public lands in order to test and demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of the Miyawaki method in California. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 585 (Luz Rivas, 2021) would have established the Extreme Heat and Community Resilience Program through the Integrated Climate Adaptation and Resiliency Program to coordinate the state’s efforts to address extreme heat and the urban heat island effect and to provide financial and technical assistance to local or regional entities for improving resilience to extreme heat and urban heat island effects. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 89 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 24, Statutes of 2020) authorized the transfer of child care and development programs currently administered by CDE to CDSS effective July 1, 2021, except for the CSPP.
AB 1578 (Luz Rivas, 2019) would have established the School Pavement to Parks Grant Program within CDE to assist schools located in disadvantaged communities to convert existing pavement to greenspace. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
COMMENTS
High temperatures place vulnerable populations at a higher risk for heat-related illnesses or death, including seniors, children, pregnant women, the unhoused, those who work outside and those without air conditioning. Research shows there are equity issues as low-income communities and communities of color are more likely to live in neighborhoods with older buildings, minimal tree cover, more heat-retaining surfaces, and limited access to ways to cope with heat, such as air conditioning.[5] Research also shows that “investments in increased tree canopies can provide critical benefits to urban communities, such as reducing heat island effects, reducing energy demand, carbon sequestration, and improving air quality.”[6]
The state currently has a 2022 Extreme Heat Plan (Plan), which was produced by the California Natural Resources Agency Resources. According to the bill’s sponsors, the bill is aligned with the state Extreme Heat Plan’s Action Track D-Nature Based Solutions to resolve the impact of heat disenfranchised and lower-income communities. The author may wish to have the departments consult with the Natural Resources Agency regarding schoolsites’ and child care facilities’ EHAPs, so that there is some congruency between the plans.
This bill was double referred to the Senate Education Committee and heard on March 22nd. The March 20, 2023 analysis by the Senate Education Committee points to two areas that the author’s office may wish to address as the bill moves forward. These include training and implementation capacity issues of the providers. First, the bill as currently written requires all schoolsites’ and child care facilities’ decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures. However, this bill does not specify who will provide the training or any training criteria that should be met. Secondly, it still is unclear if child care facilities will have the capacity to meet the current requirements of the bill as some schoolsites (like charter schools) and child care facilities are not owned by the school or provider of child care. It may be difficult for those schoolsites and child care facilities to implement plans to plant shade trees or create mini-forests.
The author’s office is also working with opposition to address concerns raised. The author’s office has worked with the committee to clarify the provisions and purpose of this bill, and is committed to continue to do so as the bill works its way through the legislative process.
This Committee recommends the below amendment to provide some additional clarification that will enhance the goals of the bill.
Please note the italicized text represents what is currently in the bill, and the bold, underlined text represents the Committee’s proposed changes.
Amendment 1
17615.4. On or before January 1, 2025, all schoolsites shall develop an extreme heat action plan and, by January 1, 2027, shall begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan, to do all of the following:
(a) Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites where pupils can access them when in attendance. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
(1) Directly protecting pupils from the effects of extreme heat.
(2) Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the year.
(b) Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
(c) Install or plant a coniferous tree green barrier between the schoolsite and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects such as a hedgerow of native plants, fruit trees, or conifers.
SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Arguments in Support:
A Voice for Choice Advocacy writes, “SB 499 will make strides in mitigating both extreme heat and air pollution in California, which have been priorities in our state, and specifically Governor Newsom, in recent years. SB 499 will align school environments with greater greening, nature-based solutions of schools/communities under the Governor’s Extreme Heat Action Plan, and CAL FIRE Urban & Community Forestry Program. Utilizing nature-based solutions as part of cooling and air pollution reduction strategies, including through planting trees, expanding greenspace, restoring urban streams, and increasing public awareness of best practices to green urban residential areas will benefit students, school staff and their greater community. Current unhealthy landscapes reflect the opposite, releasing more greenhouse gasses and air contaminants than they store and increase health risks to people and nature. Amid growing public concern about economic inequality and environmental injustice, unraveling the link between poverty and pollution, and designing effective means to spare children the deleterious impacts, is essential. This bill will ensure that all California schools, not just those in affluent neighborhoods, prioritize natural systems on their school sites leading to heat and pollution mitigation.”
Arguments in Opposition:
The Association of California School Administrators writes, “As you may know, school districts in California are currently taking steps to mitigate the impacts of extreme heat at their school sites. Our concerns with SB 499 result from the bill’s statewide mandates that are simply not appropriate for all school sites. We believe a more prudent approach would allow time for state and local stakeholders to develop guidelines and best practices that speak to the great diversity of California’s climates and geographies. In doing so, it will create more resilient schools given the myriad environmental disasters schools endure, including fires, floods, landslides, mudslides, snowstorms and windstorms. We are also concerned that the implementation steps set forth in SB 499 fail to recognize the roles of other state and local agencies that are relevant to the discussion. For example, decisions regarding the installation of artificial turf fields at schools are often in response to concerns, if not restrictions, from water agencies during drought conditions. We are also deeply concerned about the costs created by this proposal, made worse by the fact existing facility needs for public schools statewide exceeds $8 billion and the State Facilities Program is exhausted. There is no dedicated funding for schools to carry out the requirements in the bill.”
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Education Committee: | 7-0 |
|
POSITIONS
Support:
A Voice for Choice Advocacy (Sponsor)
350 Sacramento
Baycats
California Environmental Voters
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Parents Union
Cleanearth4kids.org
Climate Action California
Early Edge California
Educate. Advocate.
Glendale Environmental Coalition
Nontoxic Schools
Pesticide Free Zone
Silicon Valley Youth Climate Action
Stand Up California
Stand Up for California
Oppose:
Association of California School Administrators
California School Boards Association
Coalition for Adequate School Housing
County School Facilities Consortium
Office of the Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
-- END --
Kardan, O. et al, “Neighborhood Greenspace and Health in a Large Urban Center”, Sci. Rep. 5, 11610; doi: 10.1038/srep11610 (2015). ↑
https://resources.ca.gov/-/media/CNRA-Website/Files/Initiatives/Climate-Resilience/2022-Final-Extreme-Heat-Action-Plan.pdf ↑
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/635dbc6808cab54e82a25127/t/6400991808b825694c042579/1677760795596/Climate-Resilient+California+Schools.pdf ↑
ttps://www.treepeople.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/RX-for-hot-cities-report.pdf ↑
https://www.treepeople.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/RX-for-hot-cities-report.pdf ↑
https://www.epa.gov/heatislands/using-trees-and-vegetation-reduce-heat-islands ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 499 Hearing Date: March 22, 2023
Author: | |||
Version: | February 14, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Lynn Lorber | ||
Subject: Early childhood education facilities: school facilities: School Extreme Heat Action Plan Act of 2023.
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Human Services. A "do pass" motion should include referral to the Committee on Human Services.
SUMMARY
This bill requires a) all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan to planting shade trees, install a school garden, and plant a coniferous tree barrier; b) the California Department of Education (CDE), in consultation with the Department of Social Services, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan, make available a model program guidebook; and, c) the Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child care facilities.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Requires the governing board of any school district to meet with appropriate local government recreation and park authorities to review all possible methods of coordinating planning, design, and construction of new school facilities and schoolsites or major additions to existing school facilities and recreation and park facilities in the community. (Education Code § 35275)
- Establishes the Instructional School Gardens Program, administered by the CDE for the promotion, creation, and support of instructional school gardens through the allocation of grants, and through technical assistance provided, to school districts, charter schools, or county offices of education. (EC § 9000 et seq, and § 51795 et seq)
- Requires the State Allocation Board to obtain construction plans for school buildings appropriate for school districts in various climates and geographical conditions of the state, and requires the plans to be composed of plans designed to meet the needs of school districts requiring school buildings of various sizes. Existing law authorizes the plans to include landscape suggestions and designs that promote the efficient use of energy and water, the maximum use of natural lighting and indoor air quality, the use of recycled materials and materials that emit a minimum of toxic substances, the use of acoustics conducive to teaching and learning, and other characteristics of high performance schools. (EC § 17261)
- Requires child care centers’ outdoor activity space to be situated to provide a shaded rest area for children. (California Code of Regulations, Title 22 § 101238.2)
ANALYSIS
This bill requires a) all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop and implement an extreme heat action plan to planting shade trees, install a school garden, and plant a coniferous tree barrier; b) the CDE, in consultation with the Department of Social Services, to develop a template for an extreme heat action plan, make available a model program guidebook; and, c) requires the Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child care facilities. Specifically, this bill:
Schoolsite extreme heat action plans
- Requires, by January 1, 2025, all schoolsites and child care facilities to develop an extreme heat action plan to do all of the following:
- Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites and child care facilities where children can access them during the schoolday. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Directly protecting children from the effects of extreme heat.
- Casting shade on adjacent classroom windows in schoolsite buildings and child care facilities to help reduce temperatures indoors and save cooling costs during the warmest parts of the school year.
- Directly protecting children from the effects of extreme heat.
- Install or plant school garden infrastructure and plantings, such as raised garden beds, potting soil, hoses, and installation of native, low-water, and food-producing plants that may help block the wind or provide shade.
- Install or plant a coniferous tree barrier between the schoolsite or child care facility and any adjacent high-polluting streets or commercial projects.
- Install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, positioned on schoolsites and child care facilities where children can access them during the schoolday. Planting locations for shade trees shall be selected to improve the thermal comfort of outdoor surfaces, including:
- Requires, by January 1, 2027, all schoolsites and child care facilities to begin implementation of their extreme heat action plan.
Template, guidebook, and liaison for child care facilities
- Requires the CDE, in consultation with the Department of Social Services, as appropriate, to do both of the following:
- Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites and child care facilities.
- Make a model program guidebook available to schoolsites and child care facilities, and establish a process for systematically updating the guidebook and supporting documentation.
- Develop a template for an extreme heat action plan to be used by schoolsites and child care facilities.
- Requires the Department of Social Services to identify a liaison for child care facilities.
Resurfacing or replacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities
- Establishes that it is the policy of this state that outdoor surfaces with high specific heat should be the preferred method of resurfacing outdoor surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities and that the state, in order to reduce children’s exposure to extreme heat, should take the necessary steps to facilitate the adoption of effective high specific heat surfaces at schoolsites and child care facilities pursuant to this bill.
- Requires, at the earliest possible time or, at the latest, the next time resurfacing or replacement of outdoor surfaces of a schoolsite and child care facilities is required, all schoolsites and child care facilities to replace low specific heat surfaces, such as cement, asphalt, brick, pebbles, sand, aggregates, rubber, and synthetic turf, with high specific heat surfaces, such as cool pavement technologies, natural grass, shrubs, trees, wood chips, or other natural systems that mitigate heat and pollution.
- Requires the school designee (see # 9c) to make every effort to meet the requirements of this bill in the least costly manner, to the extent permissible under state law.
- Requires all schoolsite and child care facilities decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces at a schoolsite and child care facilities to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures.
- Defines various terms, including but not limited to:
- Earliest possible time” means the next time an outdoor surface of a schoolsite and child care facility is planned to be replaced or resurfaced.
- “Outdoor surfaces” means any ground surface within the boundaries of the school property or and child care facility.
- “School designee” means a schoolsite or school district employee identified by a schoolsite or school district to carry out and ensure that the requirements of this bill are met.
- “Schoolsite” means any facility used as a child daycare facility or by a school district, county office of education, or charter school for purposes of providing kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive, including buildings, structures, playgrounds, athletic fields, areas for vehicles, or any other area of property visited or used by children. “Schoolsite” does not include any institution of higher education facility attended by students or any private school offering kindergarten or any of grades 1 to 12, inclusive.
- “Specific heat” means the heat necessary to raise the temperature of a substance by 1 degree Celsius, taking into account the mass of the substance and the amount of temperature change in Celsius.
- Earliest possible time” means the next time an outdoor surface of a schoolsite and child care facility is planned to be replaced or resurfaced.
- States findings and declarations relative to the benefits of an ecological schoolyard.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Extreme heat events are expected to increase in frequency, severity, and duration. Extreme heat and climate change disproportionately impacts Black, Indigenous, and People of Color and low-income communities. One example of this has been seen in my district as on a 93-degree day, it was recorded that the school asphalt reached 145 degrees. Research supports that communities with the fewest resources usually have the least access to nature within and surrounding their school grounds, coupled with the highest heat, pollution, and environmental toxicology levels.
“Current measures to combat the impacts on our children are not stringent enough or moving at a pace comparable to the effects of climate change. Every year that passes without implementing robust mitigation strategies, our young people on school sites endure increasing discomfort, physical harm, and mental and emotional exasperation. These high heat emitting surfaces affect their academic performance, sense of well-being, and future. The Cool Schools Act will implement clear, actionable directives to protect our students and support their prosperity.” - Existing plans and reports that support the use of shade trees to address heat issues.
- California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan. Existing law requires the Natural Resources Agency to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy every three years. In updating the strategy, the need for an interagency approach to extreme heat was identified, and therefore the state updated its extreme heat guidance and recommendations to create California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan.
California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan was released by the Natural Resources Agency in April 2022. The plan provides a strategic and comprehensive set of state actions to adapt and build resilience to extreme heat, including supporting climate-smart planning in heat-vulnerable schools, promoting climate-appropriate shade tree cover and schools, and promoting increased use of green barriers between agricultural fields and schools. Protecting Californians From Extreme Heat: A State Action Plan to Build Community Resilience - Climate Resilient California Schools. A report titled “Climate-Resilient California Schools” was released in March 2023, and includes several recommendations for schools to achieve sustainability through extreme weather, wildfire smoke/air pollution, high temperatures, and other environmental concerns. Specifically, this report includes recommendations relative to creating green schoolyards. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/635dbc6808cab54e82a25127/t/6400991808b825694c042579/1677760795596/Climate-Resilient+California+Schools.pdf
- California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan. Existing law requires the Natural Resources Agency to update the state’s climate adaptation strategy every three years. In updating the strategy, the need for an interagency approach to extreme heat was identified, and therefore the state updated its extreme heat guidance and recommendations to create California’s Extreme Heat Action Plan.
- Capacity at each schoolsite and child care facility. Child care facilities are currently required to provide shade for children pursuant to provisions in Title 22 of the California Code of Regulations; schoolsites are not required to meet these shade requirements, even for preschools that operate on a schoolsite.
It is unclear that the capacity to meet these requirements currently exists at each schoolsite and child care facility; the type of child care facility varies significantly, from large urban centers to individual private homes. It may be more efficient for planning to be at the school district level.
While this bill requires all schoolsite and child care facility decision-making personnel involved in the replacement or resurfacing of outdoor surfaces to be trained in extreme heat mitigation measures, this bill does not specify who will provide the training or any training criteria that should be met.
Some schoolsites and child care facilities are not owned by the school or provider of child care. It may be difficult for those schoolsites and child care facilities to implement plans to plant shade trees or mini-forests.
The author may wish to consider addressing these issues moving forward. - Elements of the extreme heat action plan. This bill requires schoolsites and child care facilities to develop and implement plans to install or plant shade trees or mini-forests, school gardens, and coniferous barriers. Shade trees and conifers do not thrive in every environment. Some facilities may be directly adjacent to a city-owned sidewalk without space to plant trees, or may have below-ground plumbing or other infrastructure that could be affected by tree roots.
Should schoolsites and child care facilities have the flexibility to develop plans that consider the appropriate landscape, sufficient water sources, and if other sources of shade (such as shade structures) are more feasible? - Technical amendments. This bill references the school year and schoolday. This bill affects child care programs that do not operate according to a schoolday or school year. Therefore, staff recommends amendments to change terms to instead reference times when students or children are in attendance.
- Possible sources of funding.
- Green Schoolyards. The Green Schoolyards grant program, a component of CalFire’s Urban and Community Forestry Program, is designed to assist with planning and implementing projects to plant trees that, when mature, will cover at least 30% of each school property, shading areas used most often by students during the school day. Priority for these grants is being given to districts and schools in under-served communities with the highest poverty levels, hottest climates, and least existing tree cover. Non-profit child care facilities that receive state or federal funding are also eligible for these grant funds. The 2022-23 Budget included $150 million over two years for Green Schoolyard grants ($117 million in 2022-23 and $33 million in 2023-24).
- Proposition 98. As noted in the Legislative Analyst’s February 2023 report “The 2023-24 Budget: Crafting Climate, Resources, and Environmental Budget Solutions,” the Green Schoolyards program could potentially be funded through Proposition 98, but would use school funds that would otherwise be available for other education priorities. Shifting funding to Proposition 98 would free up non-Proposition 98 General Fund resources.
- Bond funds. School greening projects are an eligible expenditure under the School Facility Program’s modernization program; however, there will be no money left in that program unless a school facilities bond is passed (see # 7 below).
- Green Schoolyards. The Green Schoolyards grant program, a component of CalFire’s Urban and Community Forestry Program, is designed to assist with planning and implementing projects to plant trees that, when mature, will cover at least 30% of each school property, shading areas used most often by students during the school day. Priority for these grants is being given to districts and schools in under-served communities with the highest poverty levels, hottest climates, and least existing tree cover. Non-profit child care facilities that receive state or federal funding are also eligible for these grant funds. The 2022-23 Budget included $150 million over two years for Green Schoolyard grants ($117 million in 2022-23 and $33 million in 2023-24).
- Related legislation.
AB 527 (Calderon, 2023) requires Cal Fire to develop a competitive grant process to support school greening, as defined, by providing grants to eligible local educational agencies (not including child care facilities), nonprofit organizations, cities, counties, and districts. AB 527 passed the Assembly Natural Resources Committee on March 13 on an 11-0 vote, and is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee
SB 394 (Gonzalez, 2023) requires the State Energy Resources Conservation and Development Commission, upon an appropriation, to facilitate an interagency process and stakeholder engagement to develop a Master Plan for Healthy, Sustainable, and Climate-Resilient Schools in consultation with CDE, the Division of the State Architect, Office of Public School Construction, and natural Resources Agency.
AB 57 (Kalra, 2023) establishes the California Pocket Forest Initiative under the administration of Cal Fire to provide grants to cities, counties, districts, nonprofit organizations, and public schools to establish pocket forests on public lands in order to test and demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of the Miyawaki method in California. AB 57 passed the Assembly Natural Resources Committee on March 13 on a 10-0 vote, and is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 515 (Stern, 2023) exempts the installation of shade structures on the Division of the State Architect’s approved pre-check design list from requiring local educational agencies to also provide an accessible path of travel under the California Building Standards Code. SB 515 is scheduled to be heard by this committee on March 22.
SB 28 (Glazer, 2023) makes changes to the existing School Facility Program and places the Public Preschool, K-12, and College Health and Safety Bond Act on the ballot for the March, 2024 statewide primary election, which authorizes $15 billion in bonds. SB 28 is scheduled to be heard by this committee on March 22.
AB 247 (Muratsuchi, 2023) places the Kindergarten Through Community College Public Education Facilities Bond Act, authorizing an unspecified amount of bonds, on an unspecified 2024 statewide election. AB 247 is pending in the Assembly Education Committee.
- Prior legislation.
AB 2566 (Calderon, 2022) would have required Cal Fire to develop a competitive grant program to support school greening projects. AB 2566 was vetoed by the Governor, whose veto message read:
I share the author's commitment to school greening projects and my Administration is proud that the 2022-23 Budget included $150 million over two years for this purpose ($117 million in 2022-23 and $33 million in 2023-24). This funding will be administered through the existing Urban and Community Forestry Program. Additionally, Cal FIRE is able to update program guidelines to support implementation of this program and can incorporate program implementation elements outlined in this bill, as appropriate. Accordingly, neither the program nor the fund that would be established by this bill are necessary to administer the funding authorized in the Budget. Moreover, the budget agreement allocated one-time funds for this purpose, but this bill codifies an ongoing commitment not provided for in the budget.
With our state facing lower-than-expected revenues over the first few months of this fiscal year, it is important to remain disciplined when it comes to spending. We must prioritize existing obligations and priorities, including education, health care, public safety and safety-net programs.
The Legislature sent measures with potential costs of well over $20 billion in one-time spending commitments and more than $10 billion in ongoing commitments not accounted for in the state budget. Bills with cost pressure, such as this measure, should be considered and accounted for in the annual budget process.
AB 2114 (Kalra, 2022) would have established the California Pocket Forest Initiative under the administration of Cal Fire to provide grants to cities, counties, districts, nonprofit organizations, and public schools to establish pocket forests on public lands in order to test and demonstrate the applicability and effectiveness of the Miyawaki method in California. AB 2114 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 585 (Luz Rivas, 2021) would have established the Extreme Heat and Community Resilience Program through the Integrated Climate Adaptation and Resiliency Program to coordinate the state’s efforts to address extreme heat and the urban heat island effect and to provide financial and technical assistance to local or regional entities for improving resilience to extreme heat and urban heat island effects. AB 585 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1578 (Luz Rivas, 2019) would have established the School Pavement to Parks Grant Program with the CDE to assist schools located in disadvantaged communities to convert existing pavement to greenspace. AB 1578 was vetoed by the Governor, whose veto message read:
While I support an integrated and cohesive effort to make parks and greenspaces accessible to all throughout our State, and to that end signed Assembly Bill 209, I cannot support the creation of these stand-alone grant programs.
SUPPORT
A Voice for Choice Advocacy (sponsor)
Bay Area Jewish Earth Alliance
California Environmental Voters
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Educate. Advocate.
Non Toxic Communities
Pesticide Free Zone
Safe Healthy Playing Fields
San Diegans for Sustainable, Equitable, & Quiet Equipment in Landscaping
The Field Fund
13 individuals
OPPOSITION
Association of California School Administrators
California’s Coalition for Adequate School Housing
Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Education
Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Human Services
Senate Standing Committee on Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):