SB 670: State Air Resources Board: vehicle miles traveled: maps.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-04-27
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution and the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of emissions of greenhouse gases. Existing law imposes various requirements related to transportation planning, including a requirement that certain transportation planning agencies prepare and adopt regional transportation plans directed at achieving a coordinated and balanced regional transportation system. Existing law requires each regional transportation plan to include, among other things, a sustainable communities strategy prepared by each metropolitan planning organization, as specified, which is designed to achieve certain targets for 2020 and 2035 established by the state board for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions from automobiles and light trucks in the region.
This bill would require the state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research and the Department of Transportation, to develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing light-duty vehicle miles traveled and to develop maps accordingly to display average light-duty vehicle miles traveled per capita in the state at the local, regional, and statewide level, as provided. The bill would require the state board to adopt the methodology no later than January 1, 2025, and to publish the maps no later than 6 months after the methodology is adopted. The bill would require the state board to update the methodology and maps at least once every 4 years. The bill would require the state board to make the methodology and the maps publicly available on its internet website. Under certain circumstances, the bill would require the state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research, to provide technical assistance with regard to the usage and interpretation of the statewide map to a local agency requesting assistance.
Existing law establishes a policy for expenditure of certain state and federal funds available to the state for transportation purposes. designates the State Air Resources Board as the state agency with the primary responsibility for the control of vehicular air pollution and the state agency charged with monitoring and regulating sources of emissions of greenhouse gases. Existing law imposes various requirements related to transportation planning, including a requirement that certain transportation planning agencies prepare and adopt regional transportation plans directed at achieving a coordinated and balanced regional transportation system. Existing law requires certain transportation planning programs and processes to, among other things, identify opportunities to reduce vehicle miles traveled or measure the impact of certain policies on vehicle miles traveled. each regional transportation plan to include, among other things, a sustainable communities strategy prepared by each metropolitan planning organization, as specified, which is designed to achieve certain targets for 2020 and 2035 established by the state board for the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions from automobiles and light trucks in the region.
This bill would require the state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research and the Department of Transportation, to develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing vehicle miles traveled and to develop maps accordingly to display average vehicle miles traveled per capita in the state at the local, regional, and statewide level, as provided. The bill would require the state board to adopt the methodology no later than January 1, 2025, and to publish the maps no later than 6 months after the methodology is adopted. The bill would require the state board to update the methodology and maps at least once every 4 years. The bill would require the state board to make the methodology and the maps publicly available on its internet website. Under certain circumstances, the bill would require the state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research, to provide technical assistance with regard to the usage and interpretation of the statewide map to a local agency requesting assistance.
This bill would require state and local transportation agencies to create a single model for vehicle miles traveled mapping to be used for transportation planning and funding. By imposing additional duties on local transportation agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.Existing law establishes a policy for expenditure of certain state and federal funds available to the state for transportation purposes. Existing law imposes various requirements related to transportation planning, including a requirement that certain transportation planning agencies prepare and adopt regional transportation plans directed at achieving a coordinated and balanced regional transportation system. Existing law requires certain transportation planning programs and processes to, among other things, identify opportunities to reduce vehicle miles traveled or measure the impact of certain policies on vehicle miles traveled.
This bill would require state and local transportation agencies to create a single model for vehicle miles traveled mapping to be used for transportation planning and funding. By imposing additional duties on local transportation agencies, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Without a reduction in total vehicle miles traveled (VMT), it is unlikely that the state will achieve its climate and equity goals.
(b)In order to reduce VMT sufficiently to meet those goals, it is important to know how much VMT a project will generate.
(c)Accurate mapping of household generated household-generated light-duty VMT provides for the opportunity to inform efforts to mitigate those effects to enable the state to grow while balancing the pressures imposed by climate change.
(d)Additionally, in an effort to assist local governments with implementing Senate Bill 743 (Chapter 386 of the Statutes of 2013) and to keep in line with the goals of Senate Bill 375 (Chapter 728 of the Statutes of 2008), VMT mapping of light-duty vehicles conducted by the state would serve as a potential source of substantial evidence when determining the significance of transportation impacts for new developments.
(e)The availability of statewide VMT will also inform state and local planning decisions for where best to target housing and infrastructure investments.
(f)The availability of maps published pursuant to this act will also help to achieve the objective set forth in the 2022 scoping plan adopted by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code of reducing per capita VMT by at least 25 percent below 2019 levels by 2030.SEC. 2.Section 39611 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:39611.(a)(1)(A)The state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research and the Department of Transportation, shall develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing light-duty vehicle miles traveled and shall develop maps accordingly to display light-duty average vehicle miles traveled per capita in the state at the local, regional, and statewide level.
(B)For the purposes of displaying regional light-duty vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to this paragraph, a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(2)The maps developed pursuant to paragraph (1) shall use the best available information, including, but not limited to, the technical advisory relating to vehicle miles traveled adopted by the Office of Planning and Research.
(3)(A)In developing maps pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall work with local agencies to assess whether regional maps created by local agencies that show average vehicle miles traveled can be incorporated into the maps developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(B)If the state board determines that a regional map assessed pursuant to subparagraph (A) is consistent with the methodology for accounting vehicle miles traveled developed pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall incorporate that map into the maps developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(b)(1)The state board shall adopt the methodology for assessing and spatially representing vehicle miles traveled resulting from the development of a project no later than January 1, 2025.
(2)The state board shall publish the maps developed pursuant to subdivision (a) no later than six months after it adopts the methodology pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)The state board shall update the methodology and maps at least once every four years.
(c)The state board shall make both the methodology and the maps publicly available on its internet website.
(d)If a local agency wishes to use the statewide map published pursuant to this section to help determine transportation impacts resulting from a project, the state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research, shall provide technical assistance with regard to the usage and interpretation of the map, upon request of the local agency.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Without a reduction in total vehicle miles traveled (VMT), it is unlikely that the state will achieve its climate and equity goals.
(b)In order to reduce VMT sufficiently to meet those goals, it is important to know how much VMT a project will generate.
(c)Accurate mapping of household generated VMT provides for the opportunity to inform efforts to mitigate those effects to enable the state to grow while balancing the pressures imposed by climate change.
(d)Additionally, in an effort to assist local governments with implementing Senate Bill 743 (Chapter 386 of the Statutes of 2013) and to keep in line with the goals of Senate Bill 375 (Chapter 728 of the Statutes of 2008), mapping conducted by the state would serve as a potential source of substantial evidence when determining the significance of transportation impacts for new developments.
(e)The availability of statewide VMT will also inform state and local planning decisions for where best to target housing and infrastructure investments.
(f)The availability of maps published pursuant to this act will also help to achieve the objective set forth in the 2022 scoping plan adopted by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to Section 38561 of the Health and Safety Code of reducing per capita VMT by at least 25 percent below 2019 levels by 2030.
SEC. 2.Section 39611 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:39611.(a)(1)(A)The state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research and the Department of Transportation, shall develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing vehicle miles traveled and shall develop maps accordingly to display average vehicle miles traveled per capita in the state at the local, regional, and statewide level.
(B)For the purposes of displaying regional vehicle miles traveled per capita pursuant to this paragraph, a region is the entirety of incorporated and unincorporated areas governed by a multicounty or single-county metropolitan planning organization, or the entirety of the incorporated and unincorporated areas of an individual county that is not part of a metropolitan planning organization.
(2)The maps developed pursuant to paragraph (1) shall use the best available information, including, but not limited to, the technical advisory relating to vehicle miles traveled adopted by the Office of Planning and Research.
(3)(A)In developing maps pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall work with local agencies to assess whether regional maps created by local agencies that show average vehicle miles traveled can be incorporated into the maps developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(B)If the state board determines that a regional map assessed pursuant to subparagraph (A) is consistent with the methodology for accounting vehicle miles traveled developed pursuant to paragraph (1), the state board shall incorporate that map into the maps developed pursuant to paragraph (1).
(b)(1)The state board shall adopt the methodology for assessing and spatially representing vehicle miles traveled resulting from the development of a project no later than January 1, 2025.
(2)The state board shall publish the maps developed pursuant to subdivision (a) no later than six months after it adopts the methodology pursuant to paragraph (1).
(3)The state board shall update the methodology and maps at least once every four years.
(c)The state board shall make both the methodology and the maps publicly available on its internet website.
(d)If a local agency wishes to use the statewide map published pursuant to this section to help determine transportation impacts resulting from a project, the state board, in consultation with the Office of Planning and Research, shall provide technical assistance with regard to the usage and interpretation of the map, upon request of the local agency.
SECTION 1.Section 164.57 is added to the Streets and Highways Code, immediately following Section 164.56, to read:164.57.State and local transportation agencies shall create a single model for vehicle miles traveled mapping to be used for transportation planning and funding.SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.State and local transportation agencies shall create a single model for vehicle miles traveled mapping to be used for transportation planning and funding.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 18, 2023 | May 18 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 8, 2023 | May 8 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 2, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Apr 27, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 937.) (April 26). |
| Apr 14, 2023 | Set for hearing April 26. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Mar 1, 2023 | Referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 8, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| CA Coalition for Clean Air | ** Support | |
| California Building Industry Association | ** Against | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Against | |
| ClimatePlan | ** Support | |
| Mogavero Architects | ** Support | |
| Planning And Conservation League | ** Support | |
| Streets for All | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 670 (Allen) - State Air Resources Board: vehicle miles traveled: maps
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would direct the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to develop maps of average light-duty vehicle miles traveled (VMT) at the local, regional, and statewide levels, and provides direction to how those maps should be reconciled with existing ones.
Fiscal Impact:
- ARB estimates ongoing costs of $1.9 million annually (Motor Vehicle Account) to develop and adopt the light-duty VMT estimation methodology, among other things.
- The Office of Planning and Research (OPR) estimates ongoing costs of about $200,000 annually (General Fund or special fund) and one position to assist on GIS issues as it relates to coordinating with ARB. This position would additionally support the initial technical assistance in developing the methodology and subsequent ongoing technical assistance to local governments in data development.
- Unknown but potentially significant ongoing costs (General Fund or special fund) for the Department of Transportation (CalTrans) to consult with ARB and OPR.
Background:
Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT). The transportation sector is directly responsible for 41% of the state’s GHG emissions, and when fuel production is figured in, roughly half of the state’s total emissions are the result of our existing transportation system. Simply put, reaching the state’s 2030 and 2045 climate goals will require a major retooling of the transportation sector.
Transforming the transportation sector goes beyond phasing out combustion technology and producing cleaner fuels. Managing total demand for transportation energy by reducing the miles people need to drive on a daily basis is also critical as the state aims for a sustainable transportation sector in a carbon-neutral economy. Though GHG emissions are declining due to cleaner vehicles and fuels, rising VMT can offset the effective benefits of adopted regulations.
Even with 100 percent zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) sales in the light-duty vehicle sector by 2035, a significant portion of passenger vehicles will still rely on combustion technology. Accordingly, VMT reductions will play an indispensable role in reducing overall transportation energy demand and achieving the state’s climate, air quality, and equity goals. After a significant pandemic-induced reduction in VMT during 2020, passenger VMT has steadily climbed back up and is now closing in on pre-pandemic levels. Driving alone with no passengers remains the primary mode of travel in California, amounting to 75 percent of the mode share for daily commute trips.
Reducing VMT. Sustained VMT reductions have been difficult to achieve for much of the past decade, in large part due to entrenched transportation, land use, and housing policies and practices. Specifically, historic decision-making favoring single-occupancy vehicle travel has shaped development patterns and transportation policy, generating further growth in driving (and making transit, biking, and walking less viable alternatives). These policies have also reinforced long-standing racial and economic injustices that leave people with little choice but to spend significant time and money commuting long distances, placing a disproportionate burden on low-income Californians, who pay the highest proportion of their wages on housing and transportation.
How is California doing on this front? To quote ARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan Update: “we also know we are not on track to achieve the VMT reduction called for in the 2017 Scoping Plan and will need to double down to achieve the even more ambitious target called for in the Scoping Plan Scenario.” Even the aggressive scenario developed by the UC Davis Institute of Transportation Studies for a carbon neutral transportation sector in 2045 envisioned the goal being met almost entirely by fuel switching, with only a modest VMT reduction from present levels.
SB 743 and the threshold of significance for VMT. Then-Senator Steinberg’s SB 743 of 2013 changed the way many projects evaluate transportation impacts under CEQA. These changes were intended to “better promote the state’s goals of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and traffic-related air pollution, promoting the development of a multimodal transportation system, and providing clean, efficient access to destinations.” These changes included the replacement of level of service with VMT as the measure for determining significant impacts for land use projects, plans, transit projects, and active transportation projects. They also generally allow for streamlined analysis of land use projects that are located near high-quality transit and in low-VMT areas.
On November 27, 2017, OPR released comprehensive updates to the CEQA Guidelines, including revisions for the analysis of transportation impacts called for by SB 743. One of the most impactful determinations made in the Technical Advisory was for a “threshold of significance” for VMT impacts.
The CEQA Guidelines define a “threshold of significance” to mean “an identifiable quantitative, qualitative or performance level of a particular environmental effect, non-compliance with which means the effect will normally be determined to be significant by the agency and compliance with which means the effect normally will be determined to be less than significant.” Lead agencies have the discretion to develop and adopt their own, or rely on thresholds recommended by other agencies, “provided the decision of the lead agency to adopt such thresholds is supported by substantial evidence.” Substantial evidence means “enough relevant information and reasonable inferences from this information that a fair argument can be made to support a conclusion, even though other conclusions might also be reached.”
After considering a range of targets, OPR ultimately settled on a reasonable threshold of significance for VMT impacts being 15% below the current reality. Put another way, if a project were going to have 15% lower VMT than existing development, it would not need to have its VMT impacts assessed under CEQA. If a project were going to have a VMT equivalent to an existing development’s VMT, it would need to have its VMT impacts assessed. OPR stated that “achieving 15 percent lower per capita (residential) … VMT than existing development is both generally achievable and is supported by evidence that connects this level of reduction to the State’s emissions goals.” It should be noted this is only guidance, and lead agencies are free to set the threshold at a different level, if they have substantial evidence to do so.
Proposed Law:
This bill would direct ARB to develop maps of average light-duty VMT at the local, regional, and statewide levels, and provides direction to how those maps should be reconciled with existing ones. Specifically, this bill would:
- Make several findings and declarations regarding the importance and intent of the bill.
- Require ARB, in consultation with OPR and the Department of Transportation (CalTrans), to develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing light-duty VMT, and to develop maps to display average light-duty VMT at the local, regional, and statewide levels.
- Require ARB to adopt the methodology for assessing and representing the maps, and to publish and update those maps, as specified.
- Direct ARB, in consultation with OPR, to provide technical assistance upon request to local agencies regarding the maps.
Related Legislation:
AB 2443 (Wicks, Chapter 653, Statutes of 2022) allows a housing development project to receive added height and unlimited density if the project, among other criteria, is located in an urbanized very low vehicle travel area.
SB 1217 (Allen, 2022) would have created the State-Regional Collaborative for Climate, Equity, and Resilience to, among other things, address the lack of progress the state is making in achieving its climate goals, by updating the sustainable communities strategies program guidelines. SB 1217 died in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 670
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | 3/20/2023 | Hearing Date: | 4/26/2023 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eric Walters | ||
SUBJECT: State Air Resources Board: vehicle miles traveled: maps
DIGEST: This bill directs the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to develop maps of average vehicle miles traveled (VMT) at the local, regional, and statewide levels, and provides direction to how those maps should be reconciled with existing ones.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Requires any urbanized area with a population greater than 50,000 to establish a metropolitan planning organization (MPO) that, among other things, is responsible to ensure that regional transportation planning is cohesive across local jurisdictions. (23 U.S.C. §134–135)
Existing state law:
- Establishes the California Air Resources Board (CARB) as the air pollution control agency in California and requires CARB, among other things, to control emissions from a wide array of mobile sources and coordinate, encourage, and review the efforts of all levels of government as they affect air quality. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §39500 et seq.)
- Requires CARB to determine the 1990 statewide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions level and achieve that same level by 2020 (AB 32, Nunez, Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006), and achieve a 40% reduction from that level by 2030 (SB 32, Pavley, Chapter 249, Statutes of 2016). (HSC §38500 et seq.)
- Requires transportation planning agencies to prepare and adopt regional plans that, with specifications, achieve a coordinated and balanced regional transportation system. (Government Code (GOV) §65080 et seq.)
- Requires, as a part of the regional transportation plan, a Sustainable Communities Strategy (SCS) with specifications, to be prepared by each MPO. (GOV §65080)
- Establishes a process for, and requires, CARB to provide regional transportation planning agencies with GHG emissions reduction targets that must be included in their SCS. (GOV §65080)
- Requires, by September 1, 2018, and every four years thereafter, CARB to report to the Legislature on MPOs’ progress towards meeting their GHG emission reduction targets in their SCS, including changes to emissions, metrics that support the strategies being used, a discussion of best practices, and identification of challenges. (SB 150, Allen, Chapter 646, Statutes of 2017)
- Directs the Governor’s Office of Planning & Research (OPR) to prepare revisions to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines for determining the significance of transportation impacts of projects within transit priority areas, including but not limited to VMT. (SB 743 Steinberg, Chapter 386, Statutes of 2013)
This bill:
- Makes several findings and declarations regarding the importance and intent of the bill, including, but not limited to:
- The importance of—and difficulties associated with—VMT reduction in meeting the state’s climate and equity goals;
- That mapping conducted by the state would serve as a potential source of substantial evidence when determining the threshold of significance of transportation impacts for new developments; and
- That the maps generated under this bill can inform land use decisions and help the state reach the 25% by 2030 VMT reduction goal described in CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan Update.
- Requires CARB, in consultation with OPR and the Department of Transportation (CalTrans), to develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing VMT, and to develop maps to display average VMT at the local, regional, and statewide levels.
- Requires CARB to adopt the methodology for assessing and representing the maps, and to publish and update those maps, as specified.
- Directs CARB, in consultation with OPR, to provide technical assistance upon request to local agencies regarding the maps.
Background
- Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT). The transportation sector is directly responsible for 41% of the state’s GHG emissions, and when fuel production is figured in, roughly half of the state’s total emissions are the result of our existing transportation system. Simply put, reaching the state’s 2030 and 2045 climate goals will require a major retooling of the transportation sector.
Transforming the transportation sector goes beyond phasing out combustion technology and producing cleaner fuels. Managing total demand for transportation energy by reducing the miles people need to drive on a daily basis is also critical as the state aims for a sustainable transportation sector in a carbon-neutral economy. Though GHG emissions are declining due to cleaner vehicles and fuels, rising VMT can offset the effective benefits of adopted regulations.
Even with 100 percent zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) sales in the light-duty vehicle sector by 2035, a significant portion of passenger vehicles will still rely on combustion technology. Accordingly, VMT reductions will play an indispensable role in reducing overall transportation energy demand and achieving the state’s climate, air quality, and equity goals. After a significant pandemic-induced reduction in VMT during 2020, passenger VMT has steadily climbed back up and is now closing in on pre-pandemic levels. Driving alone with no passengers remains the primary mode of travel in California, amounting to 75 percent of the mode share for daily commute trips. - Reducing VMT. Sustained VMT reductions have been difficult to achieve for much of the past decade, in large part due to entrenched transportation, land use, and housing policies and practices. Specifically, historic decision-making favoring single-occupancy vehicle travel has shaped development patterns and transportation policy, generating further growth in driving (and making transit, biking, and walking less viable alternatives). These policies have also reinforced long-standing racial and economic injustices that leave people with little choice but to spend significant time and money commuting long distances, placing a disproportionate burden on low-income Californians, who pay the highest proportion of their wages on housing and transportation.
How is California doing on this front? To quote CARB’s 2022 Scoping Plan Update: “we also know we are not on track to achieve the VMT reduction called for in the 2017 Scoping Plan and will need to double down to achieve the even more ambitious target called for in the Scoping Plan Scenario.” Even the aggressive scenario developed by the UC Davis Institute of Transportation Studies for a carbon neutral transportation sector in 2045 envisioned the goal being met almost entirely by fuel switching, with only a modest VMT reduction from present levels. - SB 743 and the threshold of significance for VMT. Then-Senator Steinberg’s SB 743 of 2013 changed the way many projects evaluate transportation impacts under CEQA. These changes were intended to “better promote the state’s goals of reducing greenhouse gas emissions and traffic-related air pollution, promoting the development of a multimodal transportation system, and providing clean, efficient access to destinations.” These changes included the replacement of level of service with VMT as the measure for determining significant impacts for land use projects, plans, transit projects, and active transportation projects. They also generally allow for streamlined analysis of land use projects that are located near high-quality transit and in low-VMT areas.
On November 27, 2017, OPR released comprehensive updates to the CEQA Guidelines, including revisions for the analysis of transportation impacts called for by SB 743. One of the most impactful determinations made in the Technical Advisory was for a “threshold of significance” for VMT impacts.
The CEQA Guidelines define a “threshold of significance” to mean “an identifiable quantitative, qualitative or performance level of a particular environmental effect, non-compliance with which means the effect will normally be determined to be significant by the agency and compliance with which means the effect normally will be determined to be less than significant.” Lead agencies have the discretion to develop and adopt their own, or rely on thresholds recommended by other agencies, “provided the decision of the lead agency to adopt such thresholds is supported by substantial evidence.” Substantial evidence means “enough relevant information and reasonable inferences from this information that a fair argument can be made to support a conclusion, even though other conclusions might also be reached.”
After considering a range of targets, OPR ultimately settled on a reasonable threshold of significance for VMT impacts being 15% below the current reality. Put another way, if a project were going to have 15% lower VMT than existing development, it would not need to have its VMT impacts assessed under CEQA. If a project were going to have a VMT equivalent to an existing development’s VMT, it would need to have its VMT impacts assessed. OPR stated that “achieving 15 percent lower per capita (residential) … VMT than existing development is both generally achievable and is supported by evidence that connects this level of reduction to the State’s emissions goals.” It should be noted this is only guidance, and lead agencies are free to set the threshold at a different level, if they have substantial evidence to do so.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “While some local governments have found success in implementing SB 375 (Steinberg, 2008) and developing frameworks that accommodate SB 743 (Steinberg, 2013), many continue to struggle with resourcing, conflicting data, methods for data collection, and more. In fact, many parts of the state lack adequate Vehicle Miles Traveled mapping or have no VMT mapping at all. To assist with this, SB 670 requires that the California Air Resources Board establish a consistent methodology for the assessment of VMT and develop maps based on this methodology. CARB will consider existing methodologies, data, and mapping already done, but the usage of CARB mapping or methodology is not a necessity for local governments. Those that have been successful in compiling their own data and mapping would prove valuable by sharing their findings with CARB. Ultimately, this helpful tool could be utilized for a project’s transportation impact analysis and aid in implementing climate laws.”
- A picture is worth a thousand words. SB 670 describes the process and stipulations for developing regional average VMT maps, but ultimately an example is most helpful for understanding what this looks like. Fortunately, the Sacramento Area Council of Governments (SACOG) has already developed one such map:
Notably, the lowest category of residential VMT (shown in green) appears across a wide geographic range, not just in high-density downtown settings.
- What good is a map? These maps can be useful for more than just data visualization; they can delineate areas that would be exempt from VMT analysis under CEQA. The green regions—being more than 15% below the regional average for VMT—surpass the suggested threshold from OPR’s Technical Advisory on evaluating transportation impacts in CEQA.
Those are only guidelines, and a lead agency can choose a different threshold of significance, but this is still impactful. A project developer looking at a map like this could choose to pursue a project specifically within the green area (or whatever the suitable threshold set by the appropriate lead agency may be). This would allow them to sidestep the time and money associated with VMT assessments for a project. It is not hard to imagine, over the course of many projects over many years, these nudges leading to more development in the kinds of dense, transit-accessible communities that are better aligned with our climate and equity goals. - A long way to go. As noted in the 2022 Scoping Plan Update and the findings and declarations of this bill, CARB’s best projections for a 2045 where California achieves its climate goals depend on a 2030 where state VMT is reduced by 25%. The 25% VMT reduction target in the final Scoping Plan Update is double what was initially suggested in the draft Update, and despite its audacious ambition, the Update lacks detailed strategies for achieving it.
That being said, the Scoping Plan Update did not envision that 25% reduction being binding. The Plan states, “While CARB has included VMT reduction targets and strategies in the Scoping Plan and appendices, these targets are not regulatory requirements, but would inform future planning processes. CARB is not setting regulatory limits on VMT in the 2022 Scoping Plan; the authority to reduce VMT largely lies with state, regional, and local transportation, land use, and housing agencies, along with the Legislature and its budgeting choices.”
Subdivision (f) of the findings and declarations of SB 670 states in part, “The availability of maps published pursuant to this act will also help to achieve the [25% VMT reduction by 2030] objective set forth in the 2022 scoping plan,” and while this is likely true, it could be misconstrued. It does not appear to be the author’s intent to supplant the 15% threshold of significance for VMT reductions with the 25% target discussed in the Scoping Plan Update. Nevertheless, the opposition to the bill contends that could be one plausible interpretation of this finding.
The committee may wish to consider simply striking finding and declaration (f) to clarify the bill does not intend to require localities to adopt a 25% below average threshold of significance for VMT impacts. - Multiple mismatched map methodologies may make motivation murky. To return to the example of the map produced by SACOG, a clearly delineated area within a region that will have VMT below the threshold of significance should help promote development there. However, pursuant to this bill, CARB will create similar maps as well. For regions that have not undertaken the same kind of mapmaking exercise SACOG has, the CARB maps will help provide helpful resources. But what happens if CARB’s maps for a region do not match the map that a region has already produced?
As written, SB 670 directs CARB to “work with local agencies to assess whether regional maps created by local agencies… can be incorporated into [CARB’s] maps. Moreover, the bill directs CARB to determine if the region’s existing map is “consistent with” the methodology CARB develops and incorporate the region’s map into their own if so.
Consider two extreme scenarios of how reconciling regions’ and CARB’s maps could go. If CARB were given complete discretion to develop and deploy a mapmaking methodology, the resulting maps would provide information that is consistent statewide, but the existing work done by regions would be rendered moot. Moreover, developers of any projects that are already underway based on an outdated map may be wary of changes. On the other hand, if CARB were required to simply use a region’s existing maps wherever they may exist, this bill would result in a confusing patchwork of methodologies and make apple-to-apples comparisons difficult. Indeed, SB 670’s current approach (having CARB assess consistency and integrate where appropriate) seems to be a plausible—albeit potentially time-consuming—solution. Still, it is not perfect either and may still result in maps that vary in their construction region-by-region.
Going forward, the author should continue engaging with CARB and stakeholders to arrive at a solution that minimizes conflicting maps applying to a single region, and maximizes the usefulness of the resulting maps. - The right VMT for the job. As written, SB 670 directs CARB to “develop a methodology for assessing and spatially representing vehicle miles traveled,” and while it is clear from the bill and author’s provided materials that the intent is to capture residential VMT, the text of the bill could be construed to require a broader analysis. VMT of heavy-duty and off-road vehicles is an important consideration in the state’s broader climate goals, but for the purposes of directing land use changes involving housing, transportation, job centers, and other such matters, “light-duty VMT” may be more appropriate.
The committee may wish to consider amending SB 670 to refer to “light-duty VMT” rather than just VMT. - Doing the work. Under SB 670, CARB will be required to undertake a considerable amount of work, both upfront (for map development and assessing and integrating existing maps) and ongoing (for technical assistance upon request). While the premise of the bill ultimately seems to be that it would be more efficient and beneficial for a single state agency to carry out this work rather than each region in its own silo, it is noteworthy that the state’s current budget situation makes this somewhat difficult. The author should consider any changes that could allow similar policy outcomes to be achieved at a lower cost to the state (such as delaying implementation or changing how technical assistance may be provided), but ultimately these considerations are more appropriately the purview of the Senate Appropriations Committee, where this bill will go next should it be approved today.
- Committee amendments. Staff recommends the committee adopt the bolded amendments contained in comments 4 and 6 above.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2443 (Wicks, Chapter 653, Statutes of 2022) allows a housing development project to receive added height and unlimited density if the project, among other criteria, is located in an urbanized very low vehicle travel area.
SB 1217 (Allen, 2022) would have created the State-Regional Collaborative for Climate, Equity, and Resilience to, among other things, address the lack of progress the state is making in achieving its climate goals, by updating the sustainable communities strategies program guidelines. SB 1217 died in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SOURCE:
Planning & Conservation League
SUPPORT:
CA Coalition for Clean Air
Climateplan
Mogavero Architects
Planning and Conservation League
Streets for All
OPPOSITION:
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to a coalition of the sponsors and other groups, “The reduction of VMT is a critical component of California’s ability to achieve its climate and equity goals. VMT reduction is integral to successful implementation of landmark smart-growth legislation, including SB 375 (2008) and SB 743 (2013), and, as such, has become a primary metric through which we assess transportation impacts in project planning analyses.
“Yet, many jurisdictions of the State lack adequate, up to date mapping of VMT performance, and some still have none at all. Some jurisdictions simply lack the resources and technical capacity to develop such spatial analyses.
“SB 670 provides that CARB develop a standard methodology for spatial analysis of VMT, and develop and maintain a statewide inventory of VMT performance mapping, in coordination with relevant state, regional, and local agencies. These maps will not supersede any existing mapping that has been developed by regional or local agencies, but will offer an important planning reference for areas of the state where adequate mapping is lacking.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the California Building Industry Association, “We are opposed to SB 670 for the following reasons: [It is a] solution in search of a problem… [it] risks removal of lead agencies’ ability to set thresholds of significance… [it has equity impacts]… and [it may lead to] increasing CEQA litigation.
“It will make the implementation of VMT in CEQA much more litigious and give a definite advantage to one side only – project opponents. SB 670 purports to provide “a potential source of substantial evidence when determining the significance of transportation impacts for new developments.” This substantial evidence developed by the state agencies may conflict with the substantial evidence proffered by the lead agency, virtually guaranteeing more topics to litigate within CEQA. This plays into the hands of NIMBYs and continues the trend of excluding more people from obtaining shelter while exacerbating the housing crisis.”
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):