SB 687: Water Quality Control Plan: Delta Conveyance Project.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-05-02
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-02-01: Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law authorizes the state board to adopt water quality control plans for waters that require water quality standards pursuant to the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, and provides that those plans supersede any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict.
This bill would require the board to adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, as provided, before the board may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project. The bill would also, if, after completing the update of the plan and in compliance with existing law, the board approves a change in point of diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, prohibit the operation of the Delta Conveyance Project unless and until the updated plan is fully implemented. The bill would specify that these provisions do not constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance Project or any other isolated Delta conveyance project that includes isolated Delta conveyance facilities, and do not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance conveyance projects.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law authorizes the state board to adopt water quality control plans for waters that require water quality standards pursuant to the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, and provides that those plans supersede any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict.
This bill would require the board to adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, as provided, before the board may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with for the Delta Conveyance Project. The bill would also, if, after completing the update of the plan and in compliance with existing law, the board approves a change in point of diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, prohibit the operation of the Delta Conveyance Project unless and until the updated plan is fully implemented. The bill would specify that these provisions do not constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance or any other isolated Delta conveyance project and do not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance projects.
Existing law establishes the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards as the principal state agencies with authority over matters relating to water quality. Existing law requires the state board to formulate and adopt state policy for water quality control. Existing law authorizes the state board to adopt water quality control plans for waters that require water quality standards pursuant to the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, and provides that those plans supersede any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict.
This bill would require the board to adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, as provided, before the board may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project. The bill would also, if, after completing the update of the plan and in compliance with existing law, the board approves a change in point of diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, prohibit the operation of the Delta Conveyance Project unless and until the updated plan is fully implemented. The bill would specify that these provisions do not constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance or any other isolated Delta conveyance project and do not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance projects.
Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards regulate water quality in accordance with the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act and the federal Clean Water Act. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region, as provided.Existing law authorizes the board to adopt water quality control plans for waters for which quality standards are required by the federal act, as specified, and that in the event of conflict, those plans supersede regional water quality control plans for the same waters.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that provision.Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards regulate water quality in accordance with the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act and the federal Clean Water Act. Existing law requires each regional board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region, as provided.
Existing law authorizes the board to adopt water quality control plans for waters for which quality standards are required by the federal act, as specified, and that in the event of conflict, those plans supersede regional water quality control plans for the same waters.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to that provision.
(a)Before the board may consider a change in point diversion or other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project, or any other isolated Delta conveyance project, the board shall first adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary adopted by the board in Resolution No. 95-24 on May 22, 1995, as amended by the 2006 amendment adopted by the board in Resolution No. 2006-0098 on December 13, 2006, and as amended by the 2018 amendment adopted by the board in Resolution No. 2018-0059 on December 12, 2018, including its update of water quality objectives for the Sacramento River, Delta, and tributaries.
(b)If, after completing the update of the water quality control plan required in subdivision (a) and in compliance with existing law, the board approves a change in point of diversion or other water rights permit or order approving for the Delta Conveyance Project, the Delta Conveyance Project shall not be operated unless and until the updated water quality control plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, including the update required by subdivision (a) and the amendments referenced or amendments thereto, is fully implemented.
(c)Nothing in this section shall constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance Project or any other isolated Delta conveyance project that includes isolated Delta conveyance facilities, and shall not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance conveyance projects.
(d)This section shall not be construed as creating any authority for the department to build any isolated Delta conveyance facilities.
(a)Before the board may consider a change in point diversion or other water rights permit or order associated with for the Delta Conveyance Project, or any other isolated Delta conveyance project, the board shall first adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary adopted by the board in Resolution No. 95-24 on May 22, 1995, as amended by the 2006 amendment adopted by the board in Resolution No. 2006-0098 on December 13, 2006, and as amended by the 2018 amendment adopted by the board in Resolution No. 2018-0059 on December 12, 2018, including its update of water quality objectives for the Sacramento River, Delta, and tributaries.
(b)If, after completing the update of the water quality control plan required in subdivision (a) and in compliance with existing law, the board approves a change in point of diversion or other water rights permit or order approving for the Delta Conveyance Project, the Delta Conveyance Project shall not be operated unless and until the updated water quality control plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, including the update required by subdivision (a) and the amendments referenced or amendments thereto, is fully implemented.
(c)Nothing in this section shall constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance or any other isolated Delta conveyance project and shall not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance projects.
(d)This section shall not be construed as creating any authority for the department to build any isolated Delta conveyance facilities.
(a)Before the board may consider a change in point diversion or other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, or any other isolated Delta conveyance project, the board shall first adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary adopted by the board in Resolution No. 95-24 on May 22, 1995, as amended by the 2006 amendment adopted by the board in Resolution No. 2006-0098 on December 13, 2006, and as amended by the 2018 amendment adopted by the board in Resolution No. 2018-0059 on December 12, 2018, including its update of water quality objectives for the Sacramento River, Delta, and tributaries.
(b)If, after completing the update of the water quality control plan required in subdivision (a) and in compliance with existing law, the board approves a change in point of diversion or other water rights permit or order approving for the Delta Conveyance Project, the Delta Conveyance Project shall not be operated unless and until the updated water quality control plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, including the update required by subdivision (a) and the amendments referenced or amendments thereto, is fully implemented.
(c)Nothing in this section shall constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance or any other isolated Delta conveyance project and shall not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance projects.
(d)This section shall not be construed as creating any authority for the department to build any isolated Delta conveyance facilities.
SECTION 1.Section 13170 of the Water Code is amended to read:13170.The state board may adopt water quality control plans in accordance with the provisions of Sections 13240 to 13244, inclusive, insofar as they are applicable, for waters for which water quality standards are required by the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, acts amendatory thereof, or acts supplementary thereto. Those plans, when adopted, supersede any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict.The state board may adopt water quality control plans in accordance with the provisions of Sections 13240 to 13244, inclusive, insofar as they are applicable, for waters for which water quality standards are required by the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and Act, acts amendatory thereof thereof, or acts supplementary thereto. Such Those plans, when adopted, supersede any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2024 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 18, 2023 | May 18 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 8, 2023 | May 8 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 2, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2023 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Apr 26, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1. Page 937.) (April 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | Set for hearing April 26. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on E.Q. (Ayes 8. Noes 1. Page 658.) (April 11). |
| Mar 30, 2023 | Set for hearing April 11. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Re-referred to Coms. on N.R. & W. and E.Q. |
| Mar 20, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 1, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 8, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Environmental Quality] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Black Urban Farmers Association | ** Support | |
| Business Council San Joaquin | ** Support | |
| California Hispanic Chambers Of Commerce | ** Support | |
| California Sportfishing Protection Alliance | ** Support | |
| Defenders Of Wildlife | ** Support | |
| Delta Counties Coalition | ** Support | |
| Desert Water Agency | ** Against | |
| Friends of the River | ** Support | |
| Golden State Salmon Association | ** Support | |
| Greater Stockton Chamber of Commerce | ** Support | |
| Little Manila Rising | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Waterkeeper | ** Support | |
| Natural Resources Defense Council | ** Support | |
| Nopal | ** Support | |
| Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Association | ** Support | |
| Public Health Advocates | ** Support | |
| Reinvent South Stockton Coalition | ** Support | |
| Reinvent Stockton Foundation | ** Support | |
| Restore the Delta | ** Support | |
| San Francisco Baykeeper | ** Support | |
| San Joaquin County Historical Museum | ** Support | |
| san joaquin partnership | ** Support | |
| Santa Maria Peregrina Lutheran Church | ** Support | |
| State Water Contractors | ** Against | |
| Valley Ag Water Coalition | ** Against | |
| With Our Words | ** Support |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 687 (Eggman) - Water Quality Control Plan: Delta Conveyance Project
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would require the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) to adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP) for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary (Bay-Delta) before the State Water Board may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Water Resources (DWR) estimates costs of at least $1 billion (various funds) due to delays in Delta Conveyance Project (DCP) construction and operation.
Background:
Water Quality Control Plans. A WQCP is the State or Regional Water Board's master water quality control planning document and typically begins by listing the various water uses (beneficial uses). Then, it describes the water quality that must be maintained to allow for those uses (water quality objectives). Together, the beneficial uses and the water quality objectives established to reasonably protect the beneficial uses are called water quality standards under the terminology of the federal Clean Water Act (CWA). Next, the water quality control plan outlines the implementation plan and describes the programs, projects, and other actions necessary to achieve the standards established in the water quality control plan.
The objective of WQCPs is to determine how the quality of surface water and groundwater in the region should be managed to provide the highest water quality reasonably possible. Water uses and water benefits vary, and water quality is an important factor in determining use and benefit. For example, drinking water has to be of higher quality than the water used to irrigate pastures. Both are legitimate uses, but the quality requirements for irrigation are different from those for domestic use. The WQCP recognizes such variations.
Bay-Delta Estuary. The Bay-Delta Estuary is where the Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers, California's two major river systems, converge to flow westward through the San Francisco Bay. The Bay-Delta is also the hub of the state's water system as the State Water Project (SWP) and Central Valley Project (CVP) use it to export water to the Central Valley, Central Coast, and Southern California. Water flowing through the Delta is used for municipal, industrial, agricultural, and environmental purposes and provides drinking water to more than 30 million Californians and water to irrigate approximately 6 million acres of farmland. The Delta is also one of the most valuable estuary and wetland ecosystems on the West Coast, providing critical habitat to 700 native plant and animal species. Finally, the Delta is home to more than 500,000 people, with 14 cities and towns, has its own $5.2 billion agricultural economy, and a vibrant fishing, boating, and recreation economy.
Challenges facing the Bay-Delta. The Bay-Delta has been in ecological decline for several decades. Historic and current human activities (e.g., water development, land use, wastewater discharges, introduced species, and harvesting) have degraded the beneficial uses of the Bay-Delta. Additionally, the long-term sustainability of the Bay-Delta system is threatened by floods, rising sea levels, and earthquake damage. The Delta ecosystem is facing threats that impact native plants, animals, migratory waterfowl, and fish. Iconic Delta smelt, indicators of the estuary's health, are on state and federal agencies threatened and endangered lists. Chinook salmon and other native fish species are also in trouble as a result of engineered stream flows and disturbances caused by the water pumps in the system.
Bay-Delta WQCP. The State Water Board is responsible for adopting and updating the Bay-Delta WQCP, which establishes water quality control measures and flow requirements needed to provide reasonable protection of beneficial uses in the watershed. The State Water Board first adopted a WQCP for the Bay-Delta in 1978. Subsequently, the State Water Board adopted minor revisions to the Bay-Delta WQCP in 1991, a significant update in 1995, and minor revisions in 2006. The 2006 Bay-Delta WQCP identified emerging issues requiring additional action, including San Joaquin River flows and Delta salinity, signaling a need for a more comprehensive update of the WQCP.
Current Bay-Delta WQCP Update. The process for the current update commenced in 2009. Though state law requires that a WQCP be "periodically reviewed" and the CWA requires that a WQCP be reviewed every three years, the State Water Board has been unable to comply with these requirements for periodic or triennial review of the Bay-Delta WQCP for various reasons.
The State Water Board has divided the current update of the Bay-Delta WQCP into two phases, the Lower San Joaquin River and Southern Delta (LSJR/SD) phase and the Sacramento River and its tributaries, Delta eastside tributaries, Delta outflows, and interior Delta flows (Sacramento/Delta) phase. The State Water Board adopted an update for the LSJR/SD phase in December 2018. Since then, the State Water Board has not taken subsequent action to implement the LSJR/SD update due to negotiations over a "Voluntary Agreement."
The State Water Board initiated the update to the Sacramento/Delta phase in 2012 and later released the "July 2018 Framework for the Sacramento/Delta Update to the Bay-Delta Plan" (July 2018 Framework) that outlined the background and need for an update, comprehensive objectives (e.g., water flow and temperature), and possible pathways to ultimately implement the update. The July 2018 Framework indicates the next step in the process would be for the State Water Board to draft proposed changes to the Bay-Delta WQCP and a supporting draft staff report by the end of 2018. Neither the proposed changes or draft staff report have been produced to date, primarily to allow for parties to negotiate a "voluntary agreement (VA)."
At its December 2021 hearing, State Water Board staff presented an informational item on the Bay-Delta WQCP update. The staff presentation indicated implementation of the LSJR/SD update could begin by fall 2023 if the chosen path to implementation was via a regulation (as opposed to a water rights proceeding) by the State Water Board. The presentation further estimated an update to the Sacramento/Delta phase of the WQCP could be considered by the State Water Board as soon as fall 2023.
Voluntary Agreements. In 2022, State Water Board received a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) signed by state and federal agencies and water users proposing VAs for updating and implementing the Bay-Delta Plan. In response to the MOU, a coalition of environmental groups published a white paper entitled, “Back Room Bay-Delta Voluntary Agreement Scheme is Inequitable, Exclusionary, Inadequate, and Lacks Scientific Foundations.” According to the white paper, “The VA proposal is incomplete, unenforceable, inequitable, inadequate and lacks a scientific foundation. That process has excluded most of the parties affected by declining Bay-Delta conditions. It is not a scientifically credible effort to respond to the crisis in the vast Bay-Delta ecosystem or California’s long history of inequitable water policies.”
On January 5, 2023, the State Water Board released a Draft Scientific Basis Report Supplement in Support of Proposed Voluntary Agreement for the Sacramento River, Delta, and Tributaries Update to the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Water Quality Control Plan for public comment.
Delta Conveyance Project. The conveyance of water through and around the Delta has a long and controversial history. The Delta Conveyance Project, in some form or another, has been debated since the 1960s. Most recently, Governor Newsom announced in 2019 he favored a single tunnel plan and began a new planning and environmental review process for Delta conveyance. In July 2022, DWR released its draft EIR, proposing a 6,000 cubic feet per second (cfs) tunnel to convey water under the Delta. The comment period for the draft EIR closed on December 16, 2022. The draft EIS was released on December 16, 2022, and was available for public review and comment until March 16, 2023.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require the State Water Board to adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP) for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary (Bay-Delta) before the State Water Board may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project. Specifically, this bill would:
- Require the State Water Board to adopt a final update of the Bay Delta WCQP, as provided, before it may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project.
- Specify, if, after completing the update of the Bay Delta WQCP and in compliance with existing law, the State Water Board approves a change in point of diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, operation of the Delta Conveyance Project is prohibited unless and until the updated plan is fully implemented.
- Stipulate that these provisions do not constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance Project or any other project that includes isolated Delta conveyance facilities and do not reduce any statutory, or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta conveyance projects.
Related Legislation:
AB 2639 (Quirk, 2022) would have required the State Water Board to complete an update of the Bay-Delta Plan by December 31, 2023, and placed a moratorium on new water right permits resulting in increased diversions in the Bay-Delta watershed if the update was not completed by January 1, 2024. AB 2639 died on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1242 (Gray, 2015) would have required the State Water Board to consider any groundwater sustainability plan in formulating state policy for water quality control or adopting or approving a water quality control plan. AB 1242 died in the Senate Rules Committee.
SBx7 1 (Simitian, Chapter 5, Statutes of 2009-10 Seventh Extraordinary Session) requires, among other provisions, the State Water Board to develop new flow criteria for the Delta ecosystem necessary to protect public trust resources within nine months (i.e., by fall 2010), to inform planning decisions in the Delta Plan (developed by the Delta Stewardship Council) and the Bay Delta Conservation Plan.
Staff Comments:
According to DWR, the current estimated annual cost increase from delays to the DCP approaches $500 million. Delaying the ability of the DCP to proceed to construction and operation would result in significant cost to water users. Additionally, tens of millions of dollars have been invested in studies and analyses as part of the DCP planning and permitting efforts. If delayed, it is likely that studies, documents, and analyses would need to be reinitiated to avoid “staling” of the information.
At present, completion of the Bay-Delta Plan is likely to occur in late 2024 at the earliest. This currently is running neck and neck with projected hearings of the DCP’s water rights hearings, and “full implementation” of the Bay-Delta Plan could be years off. As such, DWR estimates at least $1 billion in impacts to the DCP from enactment of this bill.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 687
Author: | Eggman | ||
Version: | 4/12/2023 | Hearing Date: | 4/26/23 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Water Quality Control Plan: Delta Conveyance Project
DIGEST: Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) to adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan (WQCP) for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary (Bay-Delta) before the State Water Board may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes as Legislative intent that the State Water Board and each regional water quality control board (Regional Water Board) shall be the principal state agencies with primary responsibility for the coordination and control of water quality. (Water Code (Water) § 13001)
- Defines "beneficial uses" of the waters of the state that may be protected against quality degradation to include, but not be limited to, domestic, municipal, agricultural, and industrial supply; power generation; recreation; aesthetic enjoyment; navigation; and preservation and enhancement of fish, wildlife, and other aquatic resources or preserves. (Water § 13050 (f))
- Provides that a "water quality control plan" consists of a designation or establishment for the waters within a specified area of all of the following: beneficial uses to be protected; water quality objectives; and, a program of implementation needed for achieving water quality objectives. (Water §13050 (j))
- Authorizes the State Water Board to adopt WQCPs for waters for which water quality standards are required by the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. Provides such plans, when adopted, supersede any regional WQCPs for the same waters to the extent of any conflict. (Water § 13170)
- Requires each Regional Water Board to formulate and adopt WQCPs for all areas within the region, as specified. Requires the WQCPs are periodically reviewed and authorizes revision. (Water § 13240)
- Requires each Regional Water Board to establish water quality objectives in the WQCP that, in its judgment, will ensure the reasonable protection of beneficial uses and the prevention of nuisance, as specified. (Water § 13241)
- Requires the State Water Board to act, as specified, upon any WQCP not later than 60 days from the date the Regional Water Board submitted the plan to the State Water Board, or 90 days from the date of resubmission of the plan. (Water § 13246)
This bill:
- Requires the State Water Board to adopt a final update of the Bay Delta WCQP, as provided, before it may consider a change in point diversion or any other water rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project.
- Specifies, if, after completing the update of the Bay Delta WQCP and in compliance with existing law, the State Water Board approves a change in point of diversion or any other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, operation of the Delta Conveyance Project is prohibited unless and until the updated plan is fully implemented.
- Stipulates that these provisions do not constitute an authorization for or approval of funding for the Delta Conveyance or any other isolated Delta conveyance project and do not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance projects.
Background
- Water Quality Control Plans. A WQCP is the State or Regional Water Board's master water quality control planning document and typically begins by listing the various water uses (beneficial uses). Then, it describes the water quality that must be maintained to allow for those uses (water quality objectives). Together, the beneficial uses and the water quality objectives established to reasonably protect the beneficial uses are called water quality standards under the terminology of the federal Clean Water Act (CWA). Next, the water quality control plan outlines the implementation plan and describes the programs, projects, and other actions necessary to achieve the standards established in the water quality control plan.
The objective of WQCPs is to determine how the quality of surface water and groundwater in the region should be managed to provide the highest water quality reasonably possible. Water uses and water benefits vary, and water quality is an important factor in determining use and benefit. For example, drinking water has to be of higher quality than the water used to irrigate pastures. Both are legitimate uses, but the quality requirements for irrigation are different from those for domestic use. The WQCP recognizes such variations.
- Bay-Delta Estuary. The Bay-Delta Estuary is where the Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers, California's two major river systems, converge to flow westward through the San Francisco Bay. The Bay-Delta is also the hub of the state's water system as the State Water Project (SWP) and Central Valley Project (CVP) use it to export water to the Central Valley, Central Coast, and Southern California. Water flowing through the Delta is used for municipal, industrial, agricultural, and environmental purposes and provides drinking water to more than 30 million Californians and water to irrigate approximately 6 million acres of farmland. The Delta is also one of the most valuable estuary and wetland ecosystems on the West Coast, providing critical habitat to 700 native plant and animal species. Finally, the Delta is home to more than 500,000 people, with 14 cities and towns, has its own $5.2 billion agricultural economy, and a vibrant fishing, boating, and recreation economy.
- Challenges facing the Bay-Delta. The Bay-Delta has been in ecological decline for several decades. Historic and current human activities (e.g., water development, land use, wastewater discharges, introduced species, and harvesting) have degraded the beneficial uses of the Bay-Delta. Additionally, the long-term sustainability of the Bay-Delta system is threatened by floods, rising sea levels, and earthquake damage. The Delta ecosystem is facing threats that impact native plants, animals, migratory waterfowl, and fish. Iconic Delta smelt, indicators of the estuary's health, are on state and federal agencies threatened and endangered lists. Chinook salmon and other native fish species are also in trouble as a result of engineered stream flows and disturbances caused by the water pumps in the system.
- Bay-Delta WQCP. The State Water Board is responsible for adopting and updating the Bay-Delta WQCP, which establishes water quality control measures and flow requirements needed to provide reasonable protection of beneficial uses in the watershed. The State Water Board first adopted a WQCP for the Bay-Delta in 1978. Subsequently, the State Water Board adopted minor revisions to the Bay-Delta WQCP in 1991, a significant update in 1995, and minor revisions in 2006. The 2006 Bay-Delta WQCP identified emerging issues requiring additional action, including San Joaquin River flows and Delta salinity, signaling a need for a more comprehensive update of the WQCP.
- Current Bay-Delta WQCP Update. The process for the current update commenced in 2009. Though state law requires that a WQCP be "periodically reviewed" and the CWA requires that a WQCP be reviewed every three years, the State Water Board has been unable to comply with these requirements for periodic or triennial review of the Bay-Delta WQCP for various reasons.
The State Water Board has divided the current update of the Bay-Delta WQCP into two phases, the Lower San Joaquin River and Southern Delta (LSJR/SD) phase and the Sacramento River and its tributaries, Delta eastside tributaries, Delta outflows, and interior Delta flows (Sacramento/Delta) phase. The State Water Board adopted an update for the LSJR/SD phase in December 2018. Since then, the State Water Board has not taken subsequent action to implement the LSJR/SD update due to negotiations over a "Voluntary Agreement."
The State Water Board initiated the update to the Sacramento/Delta phase in 2012 and later released the "July 2018 Framework for the Sacramento/Delta Update to the Bay-Delta Plan" (July 2018 Framework) that outlined the background and need for an update, comprehensive objectives (e.g., water flow and temperature), and possible pathways to ultimately implement the update. The July 2018 Framework indicates the next step in the process would be for the State Water Board to draft proposed changes to the Bay-Delta WQCP and a supporting draft staff report by the end of 2018. Neither the proposed changes or draft staff report have been produced to date, primarily to allow for parties to negotiate a "voluntary agreement (VA)."
At its December 2021 hearing, State Water Board staff presented an informational item on the Bay-Delta WQCP update. The staff presentation indicated implementation of the LSJR/SD update could begin by fall 2023 if the chosen path to implementation was via a regulation (as opposed to a water rights proceeding) by the State Water Board. The presentation further estimated an update to the Sacramento/Delta phase of the WQCP could be considered by the State Water Board as soon as fall 2023.
- Voluntary Agreements. In 2022, State Water Board received a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) signed by state and federal agencies and water users proposing VAs for updating and implementing the Bay-Delta Plan. In response to the MOU, a coalition of environmental groups published a white paper entitled, “Back Room Bay-Delta Voluntary Agreement Scheme is Inequitable, Exclusionary, Inadequate, and Lacks Scientific Foundations.” According to the white paper, “The VA proposal is incomplete, unenforceable, inequitable, inadequate and lacks a scientific foundation. That process has excluded most of the parties affected by declining Bay-Delta conditions. It is not a scientifically credible effort to respond to the crisis in the vast Bay-Delta ecosystem or California’s long history of inequitable water policies.”
On January 5, 2023, the State Water Board released a Draft Scientific Basis Report Supplement in Support of Proposed Voluntary Agreement for the Sacramento River, Delta, and Tributaries Update to the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Water Quality Control Plan for public comment.
- Delta Conveyance Project. The conveyance of water through and around the Delta has a long and controversial history. The Delta Conveyance Project, in some form or another, has been debated since the 1960s. Most recently, Governor Newsom announced in 2019 he favored a single tunnel plan and began a new planning and environmental review process for Delta conveyance. In July 2022, DWR released its draft EIR, proposing a 6,000 cubic feet per second (cfs) tunnel to convey water under the Delta. The comment period for the draft EIR closed on December 16, 2022. The draft EIS was released on December 16, 2022, and was available for public review and comment until March 16, 2023.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Water quality control plans, like the Bay-Delta Plan, identify beneficial uses that must be protected, establish water quality objectives to protect those uses and establish a program of implementation to achieve those objectives. The Bay-Delta Plan includes water quality objectives to maintain water quality in the Delta for farms, cities, and the environment.
“Most of the water quality objectives in the Bay-Delta Plan have not been updated in nearly 30 years. In those 30 years, our understanding of the impacts of climate change and the growing ecological crisis in the Bay-Delta has become increasingly worrying. The coupling of climate change with the repeated violations and waivers of the existing Bay-Delta plan requirements over the last several years has exacerbated the problem of harmful algal blooms, which threaten human health, degrade water quality for cities and farms, and further damages salmon populations and other endangered species. The completion of the updated Bay-Delta Plan was originally intended to be completed a decade ago and is long overdue.
“The ultimate goal of SB 687 is to ensure that any Delta Conveyance Project does not degrade water quality in the Delta. The only real way this can be accomplished is for the Board to establish a scientific baseline for the health of the estuary through a fully updated and implemented Bay-Delta Plan before it considers permitting the Delta Conveyance Project.”
- Makes sense. An update to the Bay-Delta Plan is long overdue. Given the current state of the Bay-Delta, moving forward to construct a Delta conveyance project that proposes to divert significant amounts of water from the Bay-Delta without an updated Plan doesn’t make sense. SB 687 simply requires the Bay-Delta Plan to be updated before the State Water Board considers whether to issue permits for the Delta Conveyance Project and that the Plan be implemented if the Project is operated. This should help ensure that any diversions taken through such a project adhere to the applicable water quality and flow standards, thus avoiding further harm to the Bay-Delta.
DOUBLE REFERRAL:
This measure was heard in Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee on April 11, 2023, and passed out of committee on an 8-1 vote.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2639 (Quirk, 2022) would have required the State Water Board to complete an update of the Bay-Delta Plan by December 31, 2023, and placed a moratorium on new water right permits resulting in increased diversions in the Bay-Delta watershed if the update was not completed by January 1, 2024. AB 2639 died on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1242 (Gray, 2015) would have required the State Water Board to consider any groundwater sustainability plan in formulating state policy for water quality control or adopting or approving a water quality control plan. AB 1242 died in the Senate Rules Committee.
SBx7 1 (Simitian, Chapter 5, Statutes of 2009-10 Seventh Extraordinary Session) requires, among other provisions, the State Water Board to develop new flow criteria for the Delta ecosystem necessary to protect public trust resources within nine months (i.e., by fall 2010), to inform planning decisions in the Delta Plan (developed by the Delta Stewardship Council) and the Bay Delta Conservation Plan.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Black Urban Farmers Association
Business Council San Joaquin
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
Defenders of Wildlife
Delta Counties Coalition
Friends of The River
Golden State Salmon Association
Greater Stockton Chamber of Commerce
Little Manila Rising
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Association
Reinvent South Stockton Coalition
Restore the Delta
San Francisco Baykeeper
San Joaquin County Historical Museum
With Our Words
OPPOSITION:
Desert Water Agency
State Water Contractors
Valley Ag Water Coalition
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to a coalition letter from numerous environmental organizations, “This legislation helps to ensure that the Delta Conveyance Project does not degrade water quality in the Bay-Delta estuary by requiring that the State Water Board complete its update of the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan (“Bay-Delta Plan”) before considering whether to issue permits for the Delta Conveyance Project, and it helps to protect ratepayers who are considering whether to pay tens of billions of dollars for the Delta Conveyance Project.
“California’s rivers and fisheries are in a state of crisis because of unsustainable water diversions from our rivers and streams in the Bay-Delta watershed. This crisis is resulting in the complete closure of the State’s salmon fishery in 2023 and the loss of thousands of jobs, increased frequency of harmful algal blooms in the Delta that threaten human health and safety, and many native fish species heading towards extinction. The State Water Board has repeatedly found, based on the best available science, that requirements in the existing Bay-Delta Plan (much of which has not been substantively updated since 1995) fails to protect the environment– and the thousands of fishing jobs, Native American Tribes, and communities that depend on its health. In 2008, the Board began the process of updating the Bay-Delta Plan, but that process remains incomplete. Moreover, in recent years the requirements in the Bay-Delta Plan have been repeatedly waived and violated, further degrading water quality conditions in the Bay-Delta.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to Reed Government Relations, on behalf of Desert Water Agency and Valley Ag Water Coalition, “Our clients oppose SB 687 for several reasons. Their principal concern is that the effect of the legislation would be to further delay the timeline for completing this critical infrastructure project. Further delay will inevitably increase the costs of the project. In addition, among the purposes of the project is to lessen the impacts of State Water Project diversions from the Delta on threatened and endangered fisheries and water quality… the Board believes that voluntary agreements can provide a faster, more durable solution to reasonably protect beneficial uses in the Sacramento and San Joaquin watersheds. Our clients believe strongly that SB 687, should it become law, would threaten the voluntary agreements approach as they support completion and operation of the Delta Conveyance Project an essential component to improving water supply reliability and recovery of threatened and endangered fisheries.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Dave Min, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 687 Hearing Date: April 11, 2023
Author: | Eggman | ||
Version: | March 20, 2023 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Genevieve Wong | ||
Subject: Water Quality Control Plan: Delta Conveyance Project
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Water quality management in California: California's Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act (Porter-Cologne) establishes the responsibilities and authorities of the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) and the nine regional water quality control boards (regional water boards), naming them "... the principal State agencies with primary responsibility for the coordination and control of water quality" (Water Code (Wat. C.) §13001). Under this authority, SWRCB establishes statewide water quality control policy and regulation, coordinates regional water board efforts, and reviews regional water board actions for consistency with statewide policy and regulation. The regional water boards are semi-autonomous and make critical water quality decisions for their region. All duties and responsibilities of the regional water boards center on providing reasonable protection and enhancement of the quality of both surface and ground waters in the region.
Water quality control plans: Pursuant to Porter-Cologne, each regional water board is directed to, "...formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region" (Wat. C. §13240). A water quality control plan is defined as having three components: beneficial uses to be protected, water quality objectives that protect those uses, and a program of implementation needed to achieve the water quality objectives (Wat. C. §13050). Water quality control plans are required to be periodically reviewed and may be revised (Wat. C §13240). SWRCB is also authorized to adopt water quality control plans on its own initiative (Wat. C. §13170). When SWRCB adopts a water quality control plan, that plan supersedes any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict (Wat. C. §13170).
A water quality control plan is the State or regional water board’s master water quality control planning document and typically begins by listing the various water uses (beneficial uses). Then, it describes the water quality that must be maintained to allow for those uses (water quality objectives). Together, the beneficial uses and the water quality objectives established to reasonably protect the beneficial uses are called water quality standards. Next, the water quality control plan outlines the implementation plan and describes the programs, projects, and other actions necessary to achieve the standards established in the water quality control plan.
The objective of a water quality control plan is to determine how the quality of surface water and groundwater in the region should be managed to provide the highest water quality reasonably possible. Water uses and water benefits vary, and water quality is an important factor in determining use and benefit. For example, drinking water has to be of higher quality than the water used to irrigate pastures. Both are legitimate uses, but the quality requirements for irrigation are different from those for domestic use. The water quality control plan recognizes such variations.
The Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta. The Delta is formed by the confluence of the Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers and covers about 1,150 square miles in Sacramento, San Joaquin, Contra Costa, Solano, and Yolo counties. The Delta comprises about 70 islands that have been created from what was historically tidal marshland through the construction of over 1,100 miles of levees. About three-fourths of the water flowing into the Delta comes from the Sacramento River. In addition, the Suisun Marsh, the San Francisco Bay, and the Pacific Ocean affect the Delta through the tides and the flow of saltwater.
Although the Delta is geographically located in one part of the state, it affects the rest of the state in four important ways. The Delta is (1) a biologically diverse ecosystem, (2) essential to the state’s water system, (3) a place with economic and cultural value to the state, and (4) an important infrastructure corridor. The Delta is the largest estuary on the west coast and contains a variety of habitat types for over 700 species of fish and wildlife. In addition, many of the state’s native fish species migrate through the Delta. As a result, the Delta is important for maintaining biodiversity in California and the United States and essential to state’s water system.
Water supply in California does not naturally occur where demand is highest. Much of the state’s precipitation occurs in the northern and eastern parts of the state, while much of the demand occurs in the south and on the coast because of the locations of population centers and agricultural lands. As a result, two large water projects—the State Water Project (SWP) and the federal Central Valley Project (CVP) — were built to store and transport water throughout the state. These projects store water in dams upstream of the Delta and use rivers to transport it to the Delta. The water then moves through the Delta’s waterways to pumps in the southern part of the Delta, where the SWP and the CVP then pump, or “export,” that water to the Central Valley, Southern California, and parts of the San Francisco Bay Area.
Bay-Delta system: According to the United States Geological Survey, the San Francisco Bay and the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, which together are referred to as the "Bay-Delta," covers more than 1,600 square miles and forms the largest estuary on the west coast of the Americas. The Bay-Delta is home to nearly 10 million people and is valued for its beauty, Mediterranean climate, and recreational opportunities. The estuary is also home to a diverse community of plants and animals, serving as a habitat to more than 750 animal and plant species, including more than 40 aquatic species. It is the hub of California’s freshwater-delivery system to move water from the northern to the southern part of the State. It drains a watershed of more than 75,000 square miles that covers more than 40 percent of California. This system is a source of drinking water for more than 25 million Californians and irrigation for more than 4 million acres of farmland in the Central Valley. The health of the Bay-Delta Estuary is important to the natural environment and economy of California.
Challenges facing the Bay-Delta: Historic and current human activities (e.g., water development, land use, wastewater discharges, introduced species, and harvesting), amplified by variations in natural conditions, have degraded the beneficial uses of the Bay-Delta, as evidenced by the declines in populations of many biological resources of the Bay-Delta. The long-term sustainability of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta system is threatened by floods, rising sea levels, earthquake damage, aging levees, invasive species, and contaminants. The Delta ecosystem is facing threats that impact native plants, animals, migratory waterfowl, and fish. Iconic Delta smelt, indicators of the estuary’s health, are on state and federal agencies’ threatened and endangered lists. Equally, iconic Chinook salmon and other native fish species also are in trouble as a result of engineered stream flows and disturbances caused by the water pumps in the system.
Bay-Delta Plan: According to SWRCB, "protecting the Bay-Delta watershed and its many beneficial uses is one of [its] primary responsibilities and top priorities." The SWRCB is responsible for adopting and updating the Bay-Delta Plan, which establishes water quality control measures and flow requirements needed to provide reasonable protection of beneficial uses in the watershed. The SWRCB states that it is “now engaged in urgent efforts to address prolonged and precipitous declines of native aquatic species in the Bay-Delta and the ecosystem they depend upon.”
Updates to the Bay-Delta Plan: A February 3, 2022 paper entitled, “Updating California Water Laws to Address Drought and Climate Change” (paper), which was drafted by water law experts convened by the Planning & Conservation League, helps lay out the following background and timelines of the Bay-Delta Plan development and updates.
SWRCB has twice adopted water quality control plans for the Bay-Delta watershed (the Bay-Delta Plan) that have superseded the Central Valley and San Francisco Bay Regional Water Boards’ planning authority, where the plans conflict – in 1978 and 1995. In both cases, SWRCB adopted water quality control plans for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed that superseded regional water quality control plans and set flow objectives to protect fishery beneficial uses. The paper states that SWRCB has not comprehensively revised these objectives since 1995.
According to the paper, over the decades, SWRCB has held numerous public meetings and workshops, released multiple technical reports for public comment, and revised the Bay-Delta Plan, but no new water quality objectives have been adopted in subsequent revisions. In 2018, SWRCB issued a document entitled “July 2018 Framework for the Sacramento/Delta Update to the Bay-Delta Plan” that recognized the need for “urgent efforts in the [Bay-Delta] to address prolonged and precipitous declines of native aquatic species and the ecosystem they depend upon.” The document then described the two separate processes “that are critically important to the health and survival of the Bay-Delta ecosystem” and are being used to update the Bay-Delta Plan. The first is to update the water quality objectives for the Lower San Joaquin River and the Southern Delta (San Joaquin River/Southern Delta update). The second is to update the objectives for the Sacramento River and its tributaries, Delta eastside tributaries, Delta outflows, and interior Delta flows (Sacramento River/Delta update).
On December 12, 2018, through Resolution No. 2018-0059, SWRCB adopted the San Joaquin River/Southern Delta update, materially revising the fishery flow objectives for the Lower San Joaquin River and imposing new agricultural salinity objectives for the Southern Delta. In 2019, the Newsom administration moved forward with talks among Bay-Delta stakeholders aimed at voluntary stakeholder agreements that proponents argued would offer legally and scientifically defensible alternatives to the new objectives. After almost three years of talks, the Newsom administration, in an October 20, 2021 letter, acknowledged the talks had not produced defensible objectives for the San Joaquin River and its tributaries and directed SWRCB to resume all activities necessary to implement the flow objectives established by the 2018 Bay-Delta Plan for the Lower San Joaquin River and its three major tributaries, the Stanislaus, Tuolumne, and Merced rivers. According to the SWRCB website, SWRCB is in the process of developing regulations to implement the Lower San Joaquin River Flows and Southern Delta Salinity Objectives, including consideration of voluntary agreements (VAs).
Changes proposed for the Sacramento River/Delta update include new inflow requirements for the Sacramento River, its tributaries, and eastside tributaries to the Delta; new and modified Delta outflow requirements; new requirements for cold-water habitat; new and modified interior Delta flow requirements; recommendations for complementary ecosystem protection actions; and adaptive management, monitoring, evaluation, special study, and reporting provisions.
Voluntary agreements. In 2022, SWRCB received a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) signed by state and federal agencies and water users proposing VAs for updating and implementing the Bay-Delta Plan. In response to the MOU, a coalition of environmental groups which included the Golden State Salmon Association, Defenders of Wildlife, Winnemem Wintu Tribe, Save California Salmon, Sierra Club California, Tuolumne River Trust, San Francisco Baykeeper, Friends of the River, and Tuolumne River Conservancy, published a white paper entitled, “Back Room Bay-Delta Voluntary Agreement Scheme is Inequitable, Exclusionary, Inadequate and Lacks Scientific Foundations.” According to the white paper, “The VA proposal is incomplete, unenforceable, inequitable, inadequate and lacks a scientific foundation. That process has excluded most of the parties affected by declining Bay-Delta conditions. It is not a scientifically credible effort to respond to the crisis in the vast Bay-Delta ecosystem or California’s long history of inequitable water policies.”
On January 5, 2023, SWRCB released a Draft Scientific Basis Report Supplement in Support of Proposed Voluntary Agreement for the Sacramento River, Delta, and Tributaries Update to the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Water Quality Control Plan for public comment.
Delta Conveyance Project.
Peripheral canal. Conveyance of water through and around the Delta has a long and controversial history. A “peripheral canal” to take water around the Delta was contemplated as part of the SWP that voters authorized in 1960. After the major components (Oroville Dam, Delta pumping facilities, and the California Aqueduct) of the SWP were completed, the Legislature authorized a peripheral canal with the passage of SB 200 (Chapter 632, Statutes of 1980) and ACA 90 during the 1979-80 Legislative Session. The peripheral canal was intended to improve water quality in the Delta, protect fisheries, and make more water available for southern California by moving water around, rather than through, the Delta, thus avoiding the adverse impacts resulting from massive pumping plants in the southern Delta. Due to significant opposition to the peripheral canal, SB 200 and ACA 90 were subject to a referendum initiative (Proposition 9) on the June 1982 primary ballot and voters overwhelmingly rejected the authorization of the peripheral canal: 37.3% in favor to 62.7% against.
CALFED Bay-Delta Program. Conflicts over the Delta and water exports did not end with the rejection of the peripheral canal and conditions in the Delta deteriorated. In 1994, state and federal agencies signed the Bay-Delta Accord, which initiated the CALFED Bay-Delta program that intended to develop a long-term, consensus solution to issues in the Delta. CALFED released a Programmatic Record of Decision (ROD) in August 2000 that outlined a long-term plan for the Delta; however, conditions continued to deteriorate in the Delta, fish species declined, and state and federal agencies did not follow through on funding commitments to implement the ROD. CALFED unraveled by the mid-2000s.
Bay-Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP). In CALFED’s place, state and federal agencies, water agencies, and conservation groups initiated the BDCP process in 2006. BDCP envisioned new water intake facilities in the northern Delta and conveyance facilities that would move water around (or under via tunnels) the Delta to avoid the adverse impacts of pumping and allow for continued export of water in the event of an earthquake and sea-level rise resulting from climate change. BDCP was also intended to be a habitat conservation plan that would restore as much as 100,000 acres of habitat to improve conditions in the Delta and bring certainty to Delta operations for as long as 50 years. The state finalized the BDCP joint Environmental Impact Statement/Environmental Impact Report (EIS/EIR) in December 2013.
WaterFix. After voluminous comments on the BDCP EIS/EIR, and the filing of dozens of lawsuits over it, the state reformulated BDCP as “WaterFix,” a proposal for twin tunnels to move water under the Delta, and “EcoRestore,” a proposal to restore approximately 30,000 acres of habitat in the Delta.
Delta Conveyance Project. After Governor Newsom announced he favored a single tunnel plan in early 2019, the state withdrew its proposed permits for WaterFix to begin a new planning and environmental review process for Delta conveyance. In July 2022, DWR released its draft EIR, proposing a 6,000 cubic feet per second (cfs) tunnel to convey water under the Delta. The comment period for the draft EIR closed on December 16, 2022. The draft EIS was released December 16, 2022, and was available for public review and comment until March 16, 2023.
Existing law
- Establishes as legislative intent that the health, safety, and welfare of the people of the state requires that there be a statewide program for the control of the quality of all the waters of the state; that the state must be prepared to exercise its full power and jurisdiction to protect the quality of waters in the state from degradation originating inside or outside the boundaries of the state; … and that the statewide program for water quality control can be most effectively administered regionally, within a framework of statewide coordination and policy. (Water Code (Wat. C.) §13000)
- Establishes as legislative intent that SWRCB and each regional water board shall be the principal state agencies with primary responsibility for the coordination and control of water quality. (Wat. C. §13001)
- Defines "beneficial uses" of the waters of the state that may be protected against quality degradation to include, but not be limited to, domestic, municipal, agricultural, and industrial supply; power generation; recreation; aesthetic enjoyment; navigation; and preservation and enhancement of fish, wildlife, and other aquatic resources or preserves. (Wat. C. §13050 (f))
- Provides that a "water quality control plan" consists of a designation or establishment for the waters within a specified area of all of the following: beneficial uses to be protected, water quality objectives, and a program of implementation needed for achieving water quality objectives. (Wat. C. §13050 (j))
- Authorizes SWRCB to adopt water quality control plans for waters for which water quality standards are required by the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. Provides that such plans, when adopted, supersede any regional water quality control plans for the same waters to the extent of any conflict. (Wat. C. §13170)
- Requires each regional water board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region, as specified. Requires that the plans are periodically reviewed and authorizes revision. (Wat. C. §§13143, 13240)
- Requires each regional water board to establish water quality objectives in water quality control plans that, in its judgement, will ensure the reasonable protection of beneficial uses and the prevention of nuisance, as specified. (Wat. .C §13241)
- Prohibits a water quality control plan, or a revision thereof adopted by a regional water board, from becoming effective unless and until it is approved by SWRCB. (Wat. C. §13245)
- Requires the Governor of a State or the State water pollution control agency of such State to, from time to time (but at least once each three year period beginning October 18, 1972), hold public hearings for the purpose of reviewing applicable water quality standards and, as appropriate, modifying and adopting standards. (33 United States Code (U.S.C.) § 1313 (c)(1))
- Vests in the SWRCB the responsibility to administer a water rights program whereby SWRCB grants permits and licenses to appropriate water. (Wat. C. §§1200 et. seq.)
- Authorizes a permittee or licensee to change the point of diversion, place of use, or purpose of use on a temporary or long-term basis if certain conditions are met. (Wat. C. §§1725 et seq.)
- Until SWRCB issues an order approving a change in the point of diversion of the SWP or CVP from the southern Delta to a point on the Sacramento River, as specified, prohibits DWR from commencing construction on any diversion, conveyance, or other facility necessary to divert and convey water pursuant to the change until SWRCB issues the order. (Wat. C. §85088)
PROPOSED LAW
This bill:
- Requires SWRCB, before considering a change in point of diversion or other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project, or any other isolated Delta conveyance project, to first adopt a final update of the 1995 Water Quality Control Plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary, including its update of water quality objectives for the Sacramento River, Delta, and tributaries.
- If, after completing the above-described water quality control plan update, SWRCB approves a change in point of diversion or other water rights permit or order approving for the Delta Conveyance Project, prohibits the Delta Conveyance Project from being operated unless the updated water quality control plan for the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary is fully implemented.
- Provides that nothing in the bill constitutes an authorization for or approval for funding for the Delta Conveyance or any other isolated Delta conveyance project and does not reduce any statutory or other regulatory conditions or permit requirements for Delta Conveyance projects.
- Prohibits the bill from being construed as creating authority for DWR to build any isolated Delta conveyance facilities.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “Water quality control plans, like the Bay-Delta Plan, identify beneficial uses that must be protected, establish water quality objectives to protect those uses, and establish a program of implementation to achieve those objectives. The Bay-Delta Plan includes water quality objectives to maintain water quality in the Delta for farms, cities, and the environment.
Most of the water quality objectives in the Bay-Delta Plan have not been updated in nearly 30 years. In those 30 years, our understanding of the impacts of climate change and the growing ecological crisis in the Bay-Delta have become increasingly worrying. The coupling of climate change with the repeated violations and waivers of the existing Bay-Delta plan requirements over the last several years has exacerbated the problem of harmful algal blooms, which threatens human health, degrades water quality for cities and farms, and further damages salmon populations and other endangered species. The completion of the updated Bay-Delta Plan was originally intended to be completed a decade ago, and is long overdue.
Updating the Bay-Delta Plan is critical to protecting Delta communities, Tribes, and fishermen who depend on the Delta. An updated Bay-Delta Plan is an important tool to protect the water quality of the Delta for farms and cities who rely on these vital resources. An updated Bay-Delta Plan is also important to ratepayers who are considering whether to pay to construct the Delta Conveyance Project. Updating the Bay-Delta Plan allows ratepayers to understand how much water the project is likely to deliver, as well as the cost-effectiveness of the multi-billion dollar investment.
Additionally, an updated Bay-Delta Plan should also speed up permitting of other water infrastructure projects in the Bay-Delta, as the lack of updated flow and water quality requirements currently results in a more prolonged process to permit new infrastructure projects. It is also important to recognize that this bill would not delay or affect any other water projects, as it does not affect the Board’s permitting of any other water projects—just the Delta Conveyance Project.
The ultimate goal of SB 687 is to ensure that any Delta Conveyance Project does not degrade water quality in the Delta. The only real way this can be accomplished is for the Board to establish a scientific baseline for the health of the estuary through a fully updated and implemented Bay-Delta Plan before it considers permitting the Delta Conveyance Project.”
Additionally, a coalition letter which includes, among others Black Urban Farmers Association, Little Manila Rising, Public Health Advocates, and Restore the Delta, writes that “An updated Bay-Delta Plan is an important tool to protect the water quality of the Delta for farms and cities who rely on these vital resources, which is threatened by the proliferation of harmful algal blooms, saltwater intrusion, and other sources of pollution.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
None received.
COMMENTS
Look before you leap. The Delta is a unique resource. It supplies a significant portion of drinking water for more than 29 million Californians, serves a $50 billion agricultural industry, and is home to native animal and plant species. An estimated 25 percent of all warm water and anadromous sport fishing species live in or migrate through the Delta. It is home to more than half-a-million people. Delta communities, tribes, and fisherman rely on the Delta and its delicate ecosystem for recreation, livelihood, or both.
The Delta Conveyance Project is a major water conveyance system that would transport water from the Delta to areas south. This, likely, would have substantial impacts on the water quality and ecosystem of the Delta. The objective of water quality control plans is to provide a plan on how to best manage a region’s water resources to provide the highest water quality reasonably possible. It makes sense that an updated Bay-Delta Plan, including updated water quality objectives, should be in place before any diversions for a major project such as the Delta Conveyance Project begin. An updated plan helps ensure that the Delta, and all of the benefits it provides, are preserved as much as reasonably possible. Degradation of water quality in the Delta does not just impact fish and wildlife, it impacts the Native American tribes and their way of life, the fishing industry, Delta communities, water supply, levee integrity, and more. It is a delicate system that must be thoughtfully managed.
Unintended consequences. While the purposes of the bill are to ensure that a proper water quality control plan is in place and implemented before water rights permits for the Delta Conveyance Project are considered and before the Delta Conveyance Project begins operation, linking the two projects together could have the unintended consequences. Both the Delta Conveyance Project, and its various iterations, and updates to the Bay-Delta Plan have been surrounded by controversy. The Delta Conveyance Project, in some form or another, has been debated since the 1960s. The Bay-Delta Plan has not been updated since 1995. As discussions regarding the Delta Conveyance Project continue, could stakeholder groups put pressure on SWRCB to update the Bay-Delta Plan more expeditiously? If pressured to update the Bay-Delta Plan, could SWRCB be forced to rush the process and not consider certain factors as thoroughly or even at all?
Guilty by association? There has been some concern that the restriction on SWRCB in proposed Section 85090(a) is too broad, covering “a change in point diversion or other water rights permit or order associated with the Delta Conveyance Project…” (emphasis added). “Associated with” could be interpreted broadly to capture projects that are distinctly separate from, but maybe indirectly related to, the Delta Conveyance Project. The committee may wish to narrow the scope of the bill to provide that the restriction applies to a change in point or diversion or other rights permit or order for the Delta Conveyance Project. (See Amendment 1)
Double referral. This bill is double referred with the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, with this committee being the committee of first referral. Elements of this bill under the jurisdiction of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee are included here for context and completeness only and will be discussed before that committee.
Related legislation
SB 231 (Hurtado) requires SWRCB, in collaboration with DWR, the California Bay-Delta Authority, and the California Department of Public Health, to update a 2009 report that evaluates the feasibility, estimated costs, and potential means for financing a coordinated water measurement database. SB 231 has been referred to this committee.
SB 651 (Grove) exempts from CEQA, among other things, actions taken by a state agency, or local agency as specified, and permits necessary to carry out those actions, to accelerate approvals for projects that enhance the ability to capture high precipitation events for local storage or recharge and would exempt these actions and permits from the requirement to prepare a written certification of consistency as to whether the action or permit is consistent with the Delta Plan. SB 651 has been referred to this committee.
AB 1613 (Bains) enacts the Salinity Intrusion in the Delta Act, which would require DWR to identify strategic locations in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta where barriers could be constructed to combat salinity intrusion that would reduce the need to contaminate fresh water and would require DWR, upon appropriation, to construct, operate, and maintain barriers at the identified strategic locations. AB 1613 is pending in the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee.
Previous legislation
AB 2639 (Quirk, 2022) would have required SWRCB to complete the update of the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary Water Quality Control Plan by December 31, 2023, and would have placed a moratorium on new water right permits resulting in increased diversions from the Sacramento River/San Joaquin River watershed if the update was not completed by January 1, 2024. AB 2639 failed on the Assembly Floor.
AB 979 (Frazier, 2021) would have required any individual or entity that undertakes a project within the Delta to complete a report analyzing the impact of sea level rise on the project. AB 979 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee on suspense.
AB 791 (Frazier, 2017) would have required the disclosure of specified financial information related to the proposed Delta Conveyance Project. AB 791 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee on suspense
AB 1490 (Gray, 2017) would have required SWRCB, by July 1, 2028, to prepare and submit a report evaluating potential adverse impacts resulting from the implementation of the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan on the quality and supply of drinking water provided to schools in disadvantaged communities and would have required SWRCB, to the extent funds are available, to provide financial assistance to schools in disadvantaged communities to address any adverse impacts on the supply and quality of drinking water provided to schools identified in the report. AB 1490 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee on suspense.
AB 1713 (Eggman, 2016) would have prohibited construction of a peripheral canal, defined as a facility or structure that conveys water directly from a diversion point in the Sacramento River to pumping facilities of the State Water Project or the federal Central Valley Project south of the Delta, in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta unless expressly authorized by an initiative voted on by the voters of California, and would have required the Legislative Analyst’s Office to complete an economic feasibility analysis before the initiative vote. AB 1713 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee on suspense.
AB 1242 (Gray, 2015) would have required, among other things, SWRCB to take into consideration, when adopting or approving a water quality control plan for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, any applicable groundwater sustainability plan or alternative and available information and data regarding the impacts of groundwater use and management on beneficial uses of surface waters. AB 1242 was held in the Senate Rules Committee.
AB 550 (Huber, 2011)/AB 1594 (Huber, 2010) would have prohibited the construction of a peripheral canal that conveys water from a diversion point in the Sacramento River to a location south of the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, unless expressly authorized by the Legislature; would have required the Legislative Analyst’s Office to complete an economic feasibility analysis before legislative authorization; and would have prohibited the construction and operation of the canal from diminishing or negatively affecting the water supplies, water rights, or quality of water for water users within the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed. AB 550 and AB 1594 were both held in the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee.
SBX7 1 (Simitian, Chapter 5, Statutes of 2009-10 Seventh Extraordinary Session) requires, among other provisions, SWRCB to develop new flow criteria for the Delta ecosystem necessary to protect public trust resources within nine months (i.e. by fall 2010), to inform planning decisions in the Delta Plan (developed by the Delta Stewardship Council) and the Bay Delta Conservation Plan.
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS:
AMENDMENT 1
Amend Water Code §85090(a) to read:
“(a) Before the board may consider a change in point diversion or other water rights permit or order associated with for the Delta Conveyance Project, or any other isolated Delta Conveyance project, … .”
SUPPORT
Black Urban Farmers Association
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance
Defenders of Wildlife
Friends of The River
Golden State Salmon Association
Little Manila Rising
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nopal
Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations
Public Health Advocates
Reinvent Stockton Foundation
Restore the Delta
San Francisco Baykeeper
San Joaquin County Historical Museum
San Joaquin Partnership
Santa Maria Peregrina Lutheran Church
With Our Words
OPPOSITION
None Received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):