SB 791: Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-07
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-07: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 415, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
(1)Under existing law, the segments of postsecondary education in this state include the University of California, the California State University, and the California Community Colleges. Existing law authorizes the governing board of each community college district and the Trustees of the California State University to employ persons in academic and administrative positions in order to carry out the functions of their respective institutions. The California Constitution provides that the University of California constitutes a public trust administered by the Regents of the University of California, a corporation in the form of a board, with full powers of organization and government, subject to legislative control only for specified purposes.
This bill would request the Regents of the University of California, and would require the Trustees of the California State University and the governing boards of community college districts, to require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision, as defined, or final judicial decision, as defined, issued within the last 7 years, as provided, determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment, as defined. The bill would request the University of California to not ask, and would prohibit the California State University or a community college district from asking, an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until it has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
To the extent that this bill would impose new requirements on community college districts, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, the segments of postsecondary education in this state include the University of California, the California State University, and the California Community Colleges. Existing law authorizes the governing board of each community college district and the Trustees of the California State University to employ persons in academic and administrative positions in order to carry out the functions of their respective institutions. The California Constitution provides that the University of California constitutes a public trust administered by the Regents of the University of California, a corporation in the form of a board, with full powers of organization and government, subject to legislative control only for specified purposes.
This bill would request the Regents of the University of California, and would require the Trustees of the California State University and the governing boards of community college districts, to require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision, as defined, or final judicial decision, as defined, issued within the last 7 years, as provided, determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment, as defined. The bill would request the University of California to not ask, and would prohibit the California State University or a community college district from asking, an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until it has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
To the extent that this bill would impose new requirements on community college districts, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, the segments of postsecondary education in this state include the University of California, the California State University, and the California Community Colleges. Existing law authorizes the governing board of each community college district and the Trustees of the California State University to employ persons in academic and administrative positions in order to carry out the functions of their respective institutions. The California Constitution provides that the University of California constitutes a public trust administered by the Regents of the University of California, a corporation in the form of a board, with full powers of organization and government, subject to legislative control only for specified purposes.
This bill would request the Regents of the University of California, and would require the Trustees of the California State University and the governing boards of community college districts, to require require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position position, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision, as defined, or final judicial decision, as defined, issued within the last 7 years, as provided, determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment. harassment, as defined. The bill would request the University of California to not ask, and would prohibit the California State University or a community college district from asking, an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until it has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
To the extent that this bill would impose new requirements on community college districts, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, the segments of postsecondary education in this state include the University of California, the California State University, and the California Community Colleges. Existing law authorizes the governing board of each community college district and the Trustees of the California State University to employ persons in academic and administrative positions in order to carry out the functions of their respective institutions. The California Constitution provides that the University of California constitutes a public trust administered by the Regents of the University of California, a corporation in the form of a board, with full powers of organization and government, subject to legislative control only for specified purposes.
This bill would request the Regents of the University of California, and would require the Trustees of the California State University and the governing boards of community college districts, to require as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision, as defined, or final judicial decision, as defined, determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment. The bill would request the University of California to not ask, and would prohibit the California State University or a community college district from asking, an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until it has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
To the extent that this bill would impose new requirements on community college districts, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law establishes the University of California, under the administration of the Regents of the University of California, the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, the California Community Colleges, under the administration of the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges, independent institutions of higher education, as defined, and private postsecondary educational institutions, as defined, as the segments of postsecondary education in this state.This bill would express the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to higher education.Existing law establishes the University of California, under the administration of the Regents of the University of California, the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, the California Community Colleges, under the administration of the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges, independent institutions of higher education, as defined, and private postsecondary educational institutions, as defined, as the segments of postsecondary education in this state.
This bill would express the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to higher education.
(a)(1)The governing board of a community college district shall require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with that district, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)A community college district shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 2.Section 89521 is added to the Education Code, to read:89521.(a)(1)The trustees shall require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the California State University, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)The California State University shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the California State University has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 3.Section 92612.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:92612.1.(a)(1)The regents are requested to require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the University of California, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)The University of California is requested to not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the University of California has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)The governing board of a community college district shall require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with that district, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)A community college district shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 2.Section 89521 is added to the Education Code, to read:89521.(a)(1)The trustees shall require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the California State University, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)The California State University shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the California State University has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 3.Section 92612.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:92612.1.(a)(1)The regents are requested to require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the University of California, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)The University of California is requested to not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the University of California has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)The governing board of a community college district shall require require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with that district district, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)A community college district shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment. the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 2.Section 89521 is added to the Education Code, to read:89521.(a)(1)The trustees shall require require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the California State University University, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)The California State University shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the California State University has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment. the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 3.Section 92612.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:92612.1.(a)(1)The regents are requested to require require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the University of California California, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(2)Applicants shall be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
(b)The University of California is requested to not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the University of California has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment. the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or, if applicable, as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)The governing board of a community college district shall require as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with that district that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(b)A community college district shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
SEC. 2.Section 89521 is added to the Education Code, to read:89521.(a)The trustees shall require as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the California State University that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(b)The California State University shall not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the California State University has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
SEC. 3.Section 92612.1 is added to the Education Code, to read:92612.1.(a)The regents are requested to require as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the University of California that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
(b)The University of California is requested to not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in subdivision (a), including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the University of California has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Final administrative decision means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment.
(2)Final judicial decision means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
SEC. 4.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to higher education.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact subsequent legislation relating to higher education.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 7, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 415, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 7, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 21, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 2818.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 3385.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (September 1). |
| Aug 16, 2023 | August 16 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jun 28, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Jun 8, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| May 31, 2023 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 40. Noes 0. Page 1361.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 18, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 1184.) (May 18). |
| May 12, 2023 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 1, 2023 | May 1 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 21, 2023 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Apr 19, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0. Page 801.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Set for hearing April 18. |
| Apr 12, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 683.) (April 12). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 3, 2023 | Set for hearing April 12. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | Re-referred to Coms. on ED. and JUD. |
| Mar 22, 2023 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 1, 2023 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 21, 2023 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 20. |
| Feb 17, 2023 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2023 | Unfinished Business SB791 McGuire Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2023 | SB 791 McGuire Senate Third Reading By Weber | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2023 | Senate 3rd Reading SB791 McGuire | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2023 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 18, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| California Faculty Association | ** Support | |
| California State University Employees Union | ** Support | |
| Stop Abuse for Everyone | ** Against | |
| University of California, Davis Associated Students | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 791 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 791
Author: McGuire (D)
Amended: 6/15/23
Vote: 21
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/12/23
AYES: Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Cortese, Glazer, McGuire, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wilk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/18/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, McGuire, Min, Niello, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0, 5/30/23
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 9/13/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the Trustees of the California State University (CSU), and requests the Regents of the University of California (UC), to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision issued within the last seven years determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
Assembly Amendments
(1) limit the required disclosure of any final administrative decision or final judicial decision to the seven years prior to applying to an academic or administrative position; (2) require applicants to be allowed to disclose if they have filed an appeal; and, (3) modify the definition of “final administrative decision” and adds a definition of “sexual harassment.”
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Title IX
- Provides that, in part, "no person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program of activity receiving Federal financial assistance." Enforcement of compliance is initiated upon the filing of a complaint alleging a violation of Title IX. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the 1964 Civil Rights Act)
- Requires each school district and county office of education, or a local public or private agency that receives funding from the state or federal government, to designate a person to serve as the Title IX compliance coordinator to enforce compliance at the local level, including coordinating any complaints of non-compliance. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the 1964 Civil Rights Act)
- Requires each educational institution in California (K-12 and postsecondary education) to have a written policy on sexual harassment, and requires schools to display the policy in a prominent location in the main administrative building or other area of the campus or schoolsite, be provided as part of any orientation program for new students, provided to each faculty member, administrative staff and support staff, and appear in any publication of the school that sets forth the rules, regulations, procedures and standards of conduct. (Education Code (EC) § 231.5 and § 66281.5)
Appointees and employees
- Requires the Trustees of the CSU to provide for, by rule, for the government of their appointees and employees, including but not limited to: appointment; classification; terms; duties; pay and overtime pay; uniform and equipment allowances; travel expenses and allowances; rates for housing and lodging; moving expenses; leave of absence; tenure; vacation; holidays; layoff; dismissal; demotion; suspension; sick leave; reinstatement; and employer’s contribution to employees’, annuitants’, and survivors’ health benefits plans. (EC § 89500)
- Requires a community college district, prior to making a decision relating to the continued employment of a contract employee, to meet certain requirements including an evaluation of the employee and the governing board’s receipt of recommendations of the superintendent or president of the district or community college. (EC § 87607)
Existing reporting related to campus crime statistics
- Requires, pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act, all higher education institutions that participate in federal student aid programs to prepare, publish, and distribute annual security reports disclosing specified campus crime statistics and campus security policies. Reportable crimes include homicides, sex offenses, robberies, aggravated assaults, domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, and stalking. (Unites States Code, Title 20, § 1092)
- Requires the State Auditor to conduct an audit of a sample of at least six institutions of postsecondary education in California that receive federal student aid to do both of the following:
- Evaluate the accuracy of the institutions’ statistics and the procedures used by the institutions to identify, gather, and track data for publishing, disseminating, and reporting accurate crime statistics in compliance with the requirements of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics; and,
- Evaluate the institutions’ compliance with state law governing crime reporting and the development and implementation of related policies and procedures. (EC § 67382)
- Evaluate the accuracy of the institutions’ statistics and the procedures used by the institutions to identify, gather, and track data for publishing, disseminating, and reporting accurate crime statistics in compliance with the requirements of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics; and,
This bill:
- Requires the governing board of a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision issued within the last seven years from the date of submission of the application determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
- Requires that applicants be permitted to disclose if they have filed an appeal with the previous employer, or, if applicable, with the United States Department of Education.
- Prohibits a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, from asking an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district, Trustees, or Regents have determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
- Defines the following terms:
- “Final administrative decision” the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decision-maker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
- “Final judicial decision” means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
- “Sexual harassment” has the same meaning as the existing definition in the Education Code or, if applicable, as the existing definition in federal regulations.
- “Final administrative decision” the written determination of whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decision-maker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
Comments
Need for the bill. According to the author, “Recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students and faculty across our college campuses. While title IX protections exist to protect our public institutions, bad actors escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. Hiring committees also may not have access to a full scope of complaints at the time of their hiring process. This bill will ensure campuses have access to history of misconduct to ensure they are fully informed when making their hiring decisions to foster an environment of safety and trust across all our state campuses.”
Recent State Audit. On July 18, 2023, the State Auditor released an audit related to the CSU system’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving executives, faculty, and staff at the Chancellor’s Office and three campuses (Fresno, San Jose, and Sonoma). The audit made several findings, including that without sufficient guidance, campuses did not appropriately investigate some allegations of sexual harassment; campuses have not always provided adequate discipline or corrective actions; and, the Chancellor’s Office must take a more active approach to overseeing campuses. The audit made several recommendations for actions that the CSU should take, including standardizing how campuses make and document their decisions about whether sexual harassment allegations warrant a formal investigation. [http://www.auditor.ca.gov/reports/2022-109/index.html]
Assessment of CSU’s practices. The CSU hired a private firm (Cozen O’Connor) in March 2022 to conduct a systemwide assessment of its Title IX and Discrimination, Harassment and Retaliation (DHR) programs. The stated goal is to “strengthen CSU’s institutional culture by assessing current practices and providing insights, recommendations, and resources to advance CSU's Title IX and DHR training, awareness, prevention, intervention, compliance, and support systems.” The Cozen O’Connor report was released on July 17, 2023; this report recommends that the Chancellor’s Office shift from the current consultative model to an active oversight model to introduce tiered accountability and ensure effective collaboration, leadership and advice. Recommendations are focused at both the system and campus level and fall into six general categories: strengthen the Chancellor’s Office oversight and supervision; address infrastructure challenges; prevention, education, training and awareness; recommendations to address other conduct of concern; address the trust gap; and enhanced accountability.
[https://www.calstate.edu/titleix/Documents/california-state-university_systemwide-report_july-17-2023.pdf]
Prior State Audits. The State Auditor released a report in June 2018 regarding the UC’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving faculty and staff harassers and student victims. This report concludes that “although the university has been aware of issues with its responses to sexual harassment complaints and has taken steps to address them, it must do more to stop, prevent, and remedy sexual harassment at its campuses. Notably, we found that the three campuses we visited—Berkeley, Davis, and Los Angeles—took much longer to discipline faculty in the Academic Senate than they did to discipline staff. On average, the three campuses disciplined staff within 43 days after the conclusion of an investigation compared to 220 days for faculty in the Academic Senate. In addition, the three campuses disciplined faculty inconsistently, especially those faculty who were the subjects of multiple sexual harassment complaints. We also found that the three campuses inconsistently followed Title IX guidance in their informal and formal processes to address sexual harassment complaints. The three campuses frequently exceeded investigation time frames without obtaining approved time extensions and they often did not send all required information to the complainants and respondents. Finally, the university’s Office of the President established a systemwide Title IX office (systemwide office) in February 2017 with a goal to implement a consistent and coordinated response systemwide to complaints of sexual harassment. However, to make the systemwide office more effective, the Office of the President needs to define how much consistency it desires and provide the systemwide office the necessary authority to achieve it. We identified three areas in which the systemwide office should play a central role in the university’s efforts to prevent and respond to sexual harassment: setting policy, analyzing applicable data, and overseeing the campuses. Based on feedback from external entities and internal groups, the university has taken steps to improve its response to complaints of sexual harassment, but our audit found that the university needs to take additional steps to fully resolve the concerns that reviewers have raised.” [https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2017-125.pdf]
Updated policies of the CSU. The CSU Board of Trustees approved new policies in July 2022, to bolster and clarify employment practices.
- The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing administrator employees’ option to retreat. The policy applies to all administrator appointments made at a CSU campus or the Chancellor’s Office which include the option to retreat to a faculty position. The policy is intended to be prospective and does not impact retreats granted prior to its effective dates except on a case-by-case basis in the event of a serious policy violation.
The opportunity to “retreat” to a faculty position is frequently offered to faculty who are required to relinquish tenure in order to become a university administrator. The opportunity to retreat gives the new administrator the option to return to a faculty position when their administrative role at the university comes to an end. New or continuing administrators often negotiate the opportunity to retreat as a term of their employment as an administrator because university administrators, unlike tenured faculty, are at-will employees who have no assurance of permanent employment.
The new policy includes the following guidance:- An administrator will be ineligible to exercise the option if there is a finding of misconduct or the administrator is under investigation for misconduct.
- Memorialization of terms of the retreat will be placed in the administrative appointment letter.
- There must be consultation with the tenured faculty in the respective department to which the individual would potentially return. [Viewing Employment Policy Governing Administrator Employees' Option to Retreat (policystat.com)]
- An administrator will be ineligible to exercise the option if there is a finding of misconduct or the administrator is under investigation for misconduct.
The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing the provision of employee references. The Employment Policy Governing the Provision of Employee References outlines the principles and procedures guiding the provision of references. Under the policy, the CSU will not provide positive letters of reference, verbal or written, for any current or former employee who has engaged in significant misconduct that resulted in non-retention, is currently under investigation for misconduct or violation of university policy, or has had their retirement benefits rescinded under the Public Employees' Pension Reform Act due to criminal misconduct associated with their official duties. The policy further provides guidance on references requested by third parties, employment verification for current or former employees, personal references and references within the CSU. [https://calstate.policystat.com/policy/12142918/latest/]
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill would impose the following costs:
- One-time General Fund costs of about $100,000 for UC to update hiring manuals and update procedures. Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to UC for administrative costs related to adding an extra step to each hiring process.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to CSU for administrative workload related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. In addition, CSU anticipates potential liability costs.
- One-time General Fund costs to the CCC Chancellor's Office of between $74,654 and $116,941 to update regulations and policies. One-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs to CCC campuses of about $2,900 per CCC to update existing policies, procedures, or memorandums of understanding, resulting in statewide costs of up to $332,000. Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to CCC campuses related to adding an extra step to each hiring process
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/13/23)
California Faculty Association
California State University Employees Union
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/13/23)
Stop Abuse for Everyone
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students and faculty across our college campuses. While Title IX protections exist to protect our public institutions, bad actors escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. Hiring committees also may not have access to a full scope of complaints at the time of their hiring process. This bill will ensure campuses have access to history of misconduct to ensure they are fully informed when making their hiring decisions to foster an environment of safety and trust across all our state campuses.
“Opposition alleges that the required disclosure of final administrative decisions in this bill should be removed because the administrative decision finding process at higher education institutions does not provide due process for the accused, but this is simply not the case. Title IX coordinators work with campus officials and system wide specialists to guarantee Title IX policy. They are required to conduct a full investigation into any claims of harassment, and give all parties an opportunity to present their sides. Parties also have the right to appeal final determinations. It is also unrealistic to expect all cases of sexual harassment would go to court as not everyone has the financial means to file a lawsuit, not to mention it is an extremely difficult process for survivors of sexual harassment.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to Stop Abuse for Everyone, “Final decisions based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university are fraught with biases driven by ideological beliefs. Rarely are the due process rights of alleged offenders upheld. Adjudications at the college campus level resulting in final administrative decisions should never be conflated with final judicial decisions recorded in a judgment or order of a court.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 80-0, 9/13/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
Prepared by: Lynn Lorber / ED. / (916) 651-4105
9/14/23 10:04:08
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 791
Author:(McGuire)
As Amended Ver:June 15, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the California Community Colleges (CCC) and the California State University (CSU), and requests the University of California (UC) to require potential employees to disclose whether they have been found to have committed sexual harassment in seven years prior to their application of employment at the given intuition.
Major Provisions
- Requires a community college district and campuses of the CSU; and requests the UC to require applicants, as part of the hiring process for an academic or administrative position, to disclose whether a final administrative decision or a final judicial decision where the applicant was found to have committed sexual harassment within the seven years.
- Clarifies an applicant is permitted to provide the potential employer with information regarding whether the applicant has filed an appeal either with the previous employer or with the United States Department of Education.
- Clarifies the hiring institution is not required to ask the applicant to disclose the information in 1), above, until after the institution has determined whether the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications as stated in the notice for the position.
- Defines "final administrative decision", "final judicial decision", and "sexual harassment."
COMMENTS
What this measure will accomplish. This bill would a requirement for applicants for academic and administrative positions at the CCC and the CSU to disclose whether they have been determined to have committed sexual harassment within the last seven years either through the Title IX process or by a judicial decision. Furthermore, the measure permits the applicant to explain whether they are appealing the decision to either their previous employer or the United States Department of Education.
The measure requests the above of the UC system as the UC is a constitutional independent system and the procedure of disclosure must be adopted by the UC Board of Regents before being implemented by UC campuses.
The measure does not require the campus to verify the information disclosed by the applicant nor does the measure require the postsecondary education institution to act on the information received by the employee.
Concerns about liability. One could suggest the disclosure of the information by the applicant could subject the institution to liability if they hire the applicant and the applicant has a repeat Title IX offense. In such a case, under Title IX, the institution could be seen as having prior knowledge of a potential risk of repeat sexual harassment.
The issue of when a university is considered liable for sexual harassment that occur on campus has been debated within the court system in the last few years. Multiple Circuit Courts have provided differing opinions as to when a campus is considered liable for damages for having not intervened to prevent sexual harassment. The current Title IX regulations have actual knowledge of when a campus is required to act upon knowledge of sexual harassment is defined as when a complaint is provided to the Title IX coordinator or to an official who has the authority to issue corrective action. Since the sexual harassment has already transpired and the applicant is just disclosing, it would not constitute as "actual knowledge" and therefore, would not require the institution to do anything with the knowledge or create a circumstance of liability even if the applicant was hired and committed sexual harassment. The institution would only be liable if it did not act to resolve the subsequent sexual harassment incident. This topic of
Title IX and sexual harassment grievance procedures. Established in 1972, Title IX Education Amendments of 1972 (Title IX) protects students who elect to participate in education programs from experiencing discrimination based on their sex. The U.S. Department of Education confirmed in June 2021, that Title IX protections extend to protect students from discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity.
Under Title IX each postsecondary education institution that receives federal funding must have a Title IX coordinator and have a procedure in place for handling complaints of sex-based harassment. According to the Office for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, sex-based harassment or gender-based harassment which can be reported under Title IX reporting requirements include:
- Sexual Harassment – unwelcomed conduct of a sexual nature; including, unwelcomed sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal, nonverbal, or physical conduct of a sexual nature; and,
- Sexual Violence – physical sexual acts perpetrated against a person's will or where a person is incapable of giving consent; including, rape, sexual assault, sexual battery, sexual abuse, and sexual coercion.
This bill would only require an applicant to disclose information to the CCC, CSU, or the UC if the Title IX complaint reached a final administrative decision or it was determined after an investigation and a hearing that the subject of the complaint (respondent) did commit sexual harassment or sexual violence. SB 791 (McGuire) would also require if a civil or criminal lawsuit found the applicant to have committed sexual harassment as defined by the Education Code and the Title IX regulations.
Background checks for postsecondary education institutions. Each of the CCC, CSU, and the UC conduct background checks for potential applicants for academic and administrative positions. Based on the Fair Chance Act of 2018, postsecondary education institutions do not conduct the background check until after a condition of employment is provided and the check is limited to the last seven years and is limited to crimes related to the duties of the job. For example, the CCC conducts a Department of Justice background check for academic instructional staff as CCC districts are not permitted to hire someone with convicted sex offenses or controlled substance offenses according to Education Code Section 87405(a). The background check is provided to the applicant who is given the opportunity to explain the findings.
This bill mirrors the requirements of a background check, in that it permits the applicant a chance to disclose the sexual harassment final administrative determination or judicial final determination and provides the applicant a chance to disclose their appeal of the determination. Furthermore, this bill does not require the institution to request the applicant disclose the information until after the institution has determined they are qualified for the position. With the inclusion of "final judicial decision" it is possible, the applicant could be disclosing information from a criminal or civil court decision prior to the job offer which could be interpreted as violating the Fair Chance Act of 2018; however, the measure is not specific as to when the institution must request the information of the applicant and therefore, it is possible for the institution to wait until an offer of employment has been made before asking for the disclosure.
Will this measure be impacted by the changes in Title IX regulations at the Federal level? In June 2022, the Biden Administration announced changes to the Title IX regulations which would undo the Betsy DeVos regulations from 2020. Originally the final ruling was scheduled for release in the Spring of 2023; however, an unprecedented number of comments from the public have delayed the release date of the final ruling to October 2023.
According to the Author
As enumerated by the author, "recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct across our college campuses. While Title IX protections exist to protect students, faculty and staff, bad actors have been able to escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. SB 791 is all about shining the light on dark and dangerous behavior, holding perpetrators accountable and ensuring the cycle of harassment and abuse on California's college campuses is stopped in its tracks. This bill will require applicants for administrative or academic positions to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining they committed sexual harassment. That information would then be turned over to the hiring committee at the college campus to put an end to the cycle of abuse."
Arguments in Support
As proponents of the measure, the California State University Employee Union, expresses support for SB 791 (McGuire), as "Title IX policies at educational institutions exist to protect students, educators, and school employees against all forms of sex or gender discrimination, including sexual harassment, dating and domestic violence, and other forms of sexual misconduct. Despite this, recent audits and media outlets have shed light on serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students, faculty, and staff across our public colleges and universities, and how the individuals committing said harassment have escaped the consequences of their actions by moving from one campus to another. SB 791 (McGuire) will ensure campuses are fully informed of any history of sexual misconduct when making hiring decisions."
Arguments in Opposition
Stop Abuse For Everyone, a Human Rights Agency, is opposed unless amended, as "SAFE opposes the disclosure of final administrative decisions as part of the hiring process. Sexual harassment is illegal, both at the federal level and under California law. A civil lawsuit may be filed, after a completed report to the employer and submission of a formal complaint with a government agency, against any person who allegedly conducts sexual harassment in the workplace. A civil lawsuit would result in a final judicial decision. It would be appropriate to request an applicant disclose any final judicial decision because one can be assured the applicant received his or her procedural due process rights afforded under law. Final decisions based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university are fraught with biases driven by ideological beliefs. Rarely are the due process rights of alleged offenders upheld. Adjudications at the college campus level resulting in final administrative decisions should never be conflated with final judicial decisions recorded in a judgment or order of a court.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time General Fund costs of about $100,000 for UC to update hiring manuals and update procedures. Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to UC for administrative costs related to adding an extra step to each hiring process.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to CSU for administrative workload related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. In addition, CSU anticipates potential liability costs.
- One-time General Fund costs to the CCC Chancellor's Office of between $74,654 and $116,941 to update regulations and policies. One-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs to CCC campuses of about $2,900 per CCC to update existing policies, procedures, or memorandums of understanding, resulting in statewide costs of up to $332,000. Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to CCC campuses related to adding an extra step to each hiring process.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: 11-0-1
YES: Mike Fong, Ta, Addis, Arambula, Gabriel, Irwin, Ortega, Sanchez, Santiago, Wallis, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: Low
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 16-0-0
YES: Holden, Megan Dahle, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Dixon, Mike Fong, Hart, Lowenthal, Mathis, Papan, Pellerin, Sanchez, Soria, Weber, Wilson
UPDATED
VERSION: June 15, 2023
CONSULTANT: Ellen Cesaretti-Monroy / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0001585
Date of Hearing: August 16, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 791
Author:(McGuire) – As Amended Ver:June 15, 2023
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Trustees of the California State University (CSU) and the governing boards of community college districts (CCC), and requests the Regents of the University of California (UC), as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position, to require an applicant to disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision issued within the last seven years determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment. The bill prohibits an institution from asking about these decisions until it has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
FISCAL EFFECT:
UC
- One-time General Fund costs of about $100,000 for UC to update hiring manuals and update procedures.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to UC for administrative costs related to adding an extra step to each hiring process.
UC estimates these costs could be $2 million annually for staff on campuses to manage this new workload. (If each staff person were paid $150,000, about 13 staff would be hired, using UC’s estimate.)
CSU
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to CSU for administrative workload related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. In addition, CSU anticipates potential liability costs. CSU typically hires about 16,000 employees each year.
CCC
- One-time General Fund costs to the CCC Chancellor’s Office of between $74,654 and $116,941 to update regulations and policies.
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs to CCC campuses of about $2,900 per CCC to update existing policies, procedures, or memorandums of understanding, resulting in statewide costs of up to $332,000.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount to CCC campuses related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. There are 116 CCCs in California serving over 1 million students.
To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines this requirement to be a reimbursable state-mandated activity, there would be pressure to increase the mandate block grant for CCCs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
While Title IX protections exist to protect students, faculty and staff, bad actors have been able to escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. SB 791 is all about shining the light on dark and dangerous behavior, holding perpetrators accountable and ensuring the cycle of harassment and abuse on California’s college campuses is stopped in its tracks.
- Background. UC, CSU, and CCC conduct background checks of applicants for academic and administrative positions. Current law requires the background check a) be limited to crimes related to the duties of the prospective job and b) have been committed up to seven years prior. Once the background check is conducted, the employer provides the results to the applicant, who is then given the opportunity to explain the findings and any appeals of the findings.
This bill mirrors the requirements on an employer when conducting a background check on an applicant and applies these requirements to disclosures of certain sexual harassment violations that may be excluded from a background check. While this bill seeks to make intuitions aware of whether an applicant has past sexual harassment violations, it does not require an institution to disqualify an applicant based on this information.
- CSU Comments. CSU raises the concern that, under this bill, applicants coming from private employers may have confidential settlements and could be hired over an employee whose prior public employer is not allowed to have confidential agreements.
- Related Legislation. SB 808 (Dodd) requires CSU to annually submit to the Legislature and post on its website a report on sexual harassment on CSU campuses. The bill is pending a hearing in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Mike Fong, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 791
Author:(McGuire) – As Amended Ver:June 15, 2023
SENATE VOTE: 40-0
SUBJECT: Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment
SUMMARY: Requires the California Community Colleges (CCC) and the California State University (CSU), and requests the University of California (UC) to require potential employees to disclose whether they have been found to have committed sexual harassment in seven years prior to their application of employment at the given intuition. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a community college district and a CSU campus to require applicants, as part of the hiring process for an academic or administrative position, to disclose whether a final administrative decision or a final judicial decision where the applicant was found to have committed sexual harassment within the seven years.
- Clarifies an applicant is permitted to provide the potential employer with information regarding whether the applicant has filed an appeal either with the previous employer or with the United States Department of Education.
- Clarifies the hiring institution is not required to ask the applicant to disclose the information in (1) until after the institution has determined whether the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications as stated in the notice for the position.
- Requests the UC to require applicants, as part of the hiring process for an academic or administrative position, to disclose whether a final administrative decision or a final judicial decision where the applicant was found to have committed sexual harassment within the seven years.
- Clarifies an applicant is permitted to provide the potential employer with information regarding whether the applicant has filed an appeal either with the previous employer or with the United States Department of Education.
- Clarifies the hiring institution is not required to ask the applicant to disclose the information in (2) until after the institution has determined whether the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications as stated in the notice for the position.
- Defines the following:
- “Final administrative decision” means the written determination as to whether or not sexual harassment occurred as determined by the decisionmaker following the final investigative report and the subsequent hearing.
- “Final judicial decision” means the final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or by order of the court.
- “Sexual harassment” has the same meaning as described in subdivision (a) of Section 66262.5 or if applicable as defined in Section 106.30 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.
- Authorizes that if the Commission on State Mandates determines this act contains a cost mandated by the state, the state is required to reimburse local agencies and districts for those identified costs in accordance with Part 7 of Division 4 of Title 3 of the Government Code.
EXISTING LAW: Federal law.
- No person in the United States will, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance except for specified circumstances including membership of fraternities and sororities (United States Code Title 20, Chapter 38, Section 1681… colloquially known as Title IX).
- Outlines the required response pursuant to Title IX, of a postsecondary higher education institution when the institution is made aware of an alleged sexual harassment incident on campus. The regulations include a requirement for a formal complaint, a grievance procedure for an investigation into whether the incident based on a standard of evidence occurred, and a method of appealing the outcome of the grievance process (Federal Code of Regulations Title 34, Subtitle B, Chapter 1, Subpart D, Section 106.45).
- Defines sexual harassment as conduct on the basis of sex that satisfies at least one of the following:
- An employee of the postsecondary education institution conditions aid, benefit, or services to a recipient on the individual’s participation in unwelcome sexual conduct;
- Unwelcome conduct determined by a reasonable person to be so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive that it effectively denies a person equal access to the recipient’s education program or activity; an
- Sexual assault, dating violence, domestic violence, and stalking, as defined in the United States Code (Federal Code of Regulations, Title 34, Subpart D, Section 106.30).
State law.
- Establishes the UC as a public trust to be administered by the Regents and grants the Regents full powers of organization and governance subject only to legislative control as necessary to ensure the security of funds, compliance with terms of its endowments, and the statutory requirements around competitive bidding and contracts, sales of property, and the purchase of materials, goods, and services (Article IX, Section (9) (a) of the California Constitution).
- Defines “Sexual Harassment” as unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal, visual, or physical conduct of a sexual nature, made by someone from or in the work or educational setting under the following conditions: quid pro quo, as defined, and hostile workplace, as defined. Further defines “Sexual Harassment” as sexual violence, sexual battery, and sexual exploitation, as defined (Education Code (EDC) Section 66262.5 and 212.5).
- Establishes the CSU system, made of 23 campuses, and bestows upon the CSU Trustees, through the Board of Trustees, the powers, duties, and functions with respect to the management, administration, and control of the CSU system (EDC Section 66606 and 89030, et seq).
- Establishes the CCC under the administration of the Board of Governors of the CCC, as one of the segments of public postsecondary education in this state. The CCC shall be comprised of community college districts (Education Code (EDC) Section 70900).
- Establishes that CCC districts are under the control of a board of trustees, known as the governing board, who has the authority to establish, maintain, operate, and govern one or more community colleges, within its district as specified (EDC Section 70902).
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations:
- The UC estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $2.3 million for each campus to dedicate one disclosure analyst position to manage changes to the application processes. The UC also estimates $105,000 in one-time General Fund costs to update its “Recruit Program” which would be needed to track and manage the applicants’ responses.
- The Chancellor’s office of the Community Colleges (CCCCO) estimates costs of approximately $2,900 per community college to update existing policies, procedures or memorandums of understanding (MOUs), resulting in statewide costs of up to $332,000. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines this requirement to be a reimbursable state-mandated activity, there would be pressure to increase the mandate block grant for community colleges. The CCCCO also estimates one-time General Fund costs of about $117,000 to implement Title 5 changes and update existing policies and procedures.
- The CSU indicates there could be additional, unknown administrative costs related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. The CSU typically hires approximately 16,000 employees across the system each year. Further, there could be potentially significant liability costs since the bill requires the “final administrative decisions” to be shared, even though these decisions may be appealed and may not be final.
- Though not explicitly required, this bill could create cost pressure for the segments to investigate the disclosures on applications. It is unknown how many investigations would occur as a result of these disclosures or how many applicants will actually self-report this information, but an investigation could cost up to $30,000. There could also be unknown, potentially significant costs related to liability resulting from potential lawsuits pursued by applicants who disclosed the required information.
COMMENTS: Purpose of the measure. As enumerated by the author, “recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct across our college campuses. While Title IX protections exist to protect students, faculty and staff, bad actors have been able to escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. SB 791 is all about shining the light on dark and dangerous behavior, holding perpetrators accountable and ensuring the cycle of harassment and abuse on California’s college campuses is stopped in its tracks. This bill will require applicants for administrative or academic positions to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining they committed sexual harassment. That information would then be turned over to the hiring committee at the college campus to put an end to the cycle of abuse.”
What this measure will accomplish. SB 791 (McGuire) would a requirement for applicants for academic and administrative positions at the CCC and the CSU to disclose whether they have been determined to have committed sexual harassment within the last seven years either through the Title IX process or by a judicial decision. Furthermore, the measure permits the applicant to explain whether they are appealing the decision to either their previous employer or the United States Department of Education.
The measure requests the above of the UC system as the UC is a constitutional independent system and the procedure of disclosure must be adopted by the UC Board of Regents before being implemented by UC campuses.
The measure does not require the campus to verify the information disclosed by the applicant nor does the measure require the postsecondary education institution to act on the information received by the employee.
Concerns about liability. One could suggest the disclosure of the information by the applicant could subject the institution to liability if they hire the applicant and the applicant has a repeat Title IX offense. In such a case, under Title IX, the institution could be seen as having prior knowledge of a potential risk of repeat sexual harassment.
The issue of when a university is considered liable for sexual harassment that occur on campus has been debated within the court system in the last few years. Multiple Circuit Courts have provided differing opinions as to when a campus is considered liable for damages for having not intervened to prevent sexual harassment. The current Title IX regulations have actual knowledge of when a campus is required to act upon knowledge of sexual harassment is defined as when a complaint is provided to the Title IX coordinator or to an official who has the authority to issue corrective action. Since the sexual harassment has already transpired and the applicant is just disclosing, it would not constitute as “actual knowledge” and therefore, would not require the institution to do anything with the knowledge or create a circumstance of liability even if the applicant was hired and committed sexual harassment. The institution would only be liable if it did not act to resolve the subsequent sexual harassment incident.
Committee Staff note this is a topic that is heavily debated before Circuit Courts throughout the United States and the issue of liability created by SB 791 (McGuire) could create lawsuits for the institutions as to whether they were liable for the actions of an employee they knew to have committed sexual harassment.
Title IX and sexual harassment grievance procedures. Established in 1972, Title IX Education Amendments of 1972 (Title IX) protects students who elect to participate in education programs from experiencing discrimination based on their sex. The U.S. Department of Education confirmed in June 2021, that Title IX protections extend to protect students from discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity.
On September 22, 1980, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, heard Alexander v. Yale (1980), 631 F.2nd 178 (2nd Cir.). The court ruled sexual harassment of female students was considered sex discrimination and, therefore, under Title IX was rendered illegal. The case found that a group of female students who had attended Yale College had been sexually harassed by their flute teacher and hockey coach, and Yale College had not provided adequate due process under the law for these students to have their complaints addressed. This case became the impetus for the grievance procedures found within subsequent regulations for Title IX.
Under Title IX each postsecondary education institution that receives federal funding must have a Title IX coordinator and have a procedure in place for handling complaints of sex-based harassment. According to the Office for Civil Rights at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, sex-based harassment or gender-based harassment which can be reported under Title IX reporting requirements include:
- Sexual Harassment – unwelcomed conduct of a sexual nature; including, unwelcomed sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal, nonverbal, or physical conduct of a sexual nature; and,
- Sexual Violence – physical sexual acts perpetrated against a person's will or where a person is incapable of giving consent; including, rape, sexual assault, sexual battery, sexual abuse, and sexual coercion.
Should a campus Title IX coordinator receive a report of sexual harassment, the Title IX regulations dictate the following procedures should occur:
SB 791 (McGuire) would only require an applicant to disclose information to the CCC, CSU, or the UC if the Title IX complaint reached a final administrative decision, or as provided in the chart, after a hearing occurred and a decision was rendered. Technically, there are two pathways by which a Title IX complaint can be resolved, either through the formal process or through an informal resolution.
The informal resolution process or alternative resolution occurs when the complainant (the survivor), the respondent (the accused), and the Title IX coordinator agree to the informal process. According to the UC Sexual Violence and Sexual Harassment Interim Policy published on January 1, 2022, informal resolutions are only used when an investigation is not likely to lead to a resolution, both parties prefer an informal process, or a case involves less serious allegations. The policy includes examples of plausible outcomes of an informal resolution process including, but not limited to, separating of the parties, referring the parties to counseling, or the complainant electing to drop the complaint.
SB 791 (McGuire) does not include disclosure of informal resolutions or alternative resolutions as a final determination is not founded through this process as to whether or not the sexual harassment occurred. The Committee should consider in future years, whether the disclosure of previous informal resolutions is a data point the institutions should consider when hiring a potential employee.
Background checks for postsecondary education institutions. Each of the CCC, CSU, and the UC conduct background checks for potential applicants for academic and administrative positions. Based on the Fair Chance Act of 2018, postsecondary education institutions do not conduct the background check until after a condition of employment is provided and the check is limited to the last seven years and is limited to crimes related to the duties of the job. For example, the CCC conducts a Department of Justice background check for academic instructional staff as CCC districts are not permitted to hire someone with convicted sex offenses or controlled substance offenses according to Education Code Section 87405 subdivision (a). The background check is provided to the applicant who is given the opportunity to explain the findings.
SB 791 (McGuire) mirrors the requirements of a background check, in that it permits the applicant a chance to disclose the sexual harassment final administrative determination or judicial final determination and provides the applicant a chance to disclose their appeal of the determination. Furthermore, SB 791 (McGuire) does not require the institution to request the applicant disclose the information until after the institution has determined they are qualified for the position. With the inclusion of “final judicial decision” it is possible, the applicant could be disclosing information from a criminal or civil court decision prior to the job offer which could be interpreted as violating the Fair Chance Act of 2018; however, the measure is not specific as to when the institution must request the information of the applicant and therefore, it is possible for the institution to wait until an offer of employment has been made before asking for the disclosure.
The author may wish to remove the “final judicial decision” in future committees as this could be seen as potentially undermining work completed by the Fair Chance Act and could have the unintended consequence of capturing criminal convictions of sexual harassment, as defined.
Will this measure be impacted by the changes in Title IX regulations at the Federal level? In June 2022, the Biden Administration announced changes to the Title IX regulations which would undo the Betsy DeVos regulations from 2020. Originally the final ruling was scheduled for release in the Spring of 2023; however, an unprecedented number of comments from the public have delayed the release date of the final ruling to October 2023.
Committee Staff have closely monitored the new proposed regulations and have informed the author that the language of this measure will need to be amended should the bill be signed as the federal definition of sexual harassment could change based on the proposed regulations.
Arguments in support. As proponents of the measure, California State University Employee Union, expresses support for SB 791 (McGuire), as “Title IX policies at educational institutions exist to protect students, educators, and school employees against all forms of sex or gender discrimination, including sexual harassment, dating and domestic violence, and other forms of sexual misconduct. Despite this, recent audits and media outlets have shed light on serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students, faculty, and staff across our public colleges and universities, and how the individuals committing said harassment have escaped the consequences of their actions by moving from one campus to another.
SB 791 (McGuire) will ensure campuses are fully informed of any history of sexual misconduct when making hiring decisions.”
Committee comments. Since March 2022 with the first exposé of Title IX practices at CSU Fresno, there has been a multitude of articles into the handlings and mishandlings of sexual harassment complaints at the CSU. In August 2022, EdSource published an article on disclosed Title IX records which showed faculty who had been disciplined for sexual harassment had been re-hired in administrative or academic positions at other campuses in the California public postsecondary education system. Other states, including New York, Texas, and Oregon, have systems in place to prevent the hiring of professors and staff who have been disciplined for sexual harassment. In past years, California has grappled with how to provide opportunities for rehabilitation while also ensuring campuses are not hiring professors and staff who have previously harmed students.
SB 791 (McGuire) provides a step in the direction of providing transparency in the hiring process while also providing an opportunity for rehabilitation. The measure does not require the institutions to act upon the information received from applicants but does require the institutions to be made aware of past sexual harassment violations that are excluded from a criminal background check.
Previous legislation. AB 1844 (Medina) of 2022, held in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, would have provided a mechanism by which public postsecondary institutions are required to inquire whether an applicant for employment, as defined, is the subject of a sexual misconduct investigation and to disclose to future employers whether an employee was the subject of a sexual misconduct investigation while they were employed. Requires campuses to establish positions on campus to provide survivor and respondent support, as defined
SB 493 (Jackson), Chapter 303, Statues of 2020, requires postsecondary educational institutions to, among other things, adopt rules and procedures for the prevention of sexual harassment, and adopt and post on their Web sites the grievance procedures to resolve complaints of sexual harassment.
SB 1439 (Block), of 2016, provides that the UC, the CSU, and the CCC shall require applicants for employment, as specified, to disclose information regarding final administrative findings of sexual harassment. This bill had bipartisan support and was vetoed by Governor Brown who in his veto message stated: “while I understand the desire to mitigate risk, governing boards-who are the fiduciaries of these institutions-should be responsible for setting hiring standards, including the disclosure of prior bad conduct.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California State University Employees Union
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Ellen Cesaretti-Monroy / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 791 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 791
Author: McGuire (D)
Amended: 3/22/23
Vote: 21
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/12/23
AYES: Newman, Ochoa Bogh, Cortese, Glazer, McGuire, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wilk
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/18/23
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, McGuire, Min, Niello, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/18/23
AYES: Portantino, Jones, Ashby, Bradford, Seyarto, Wahab, Wiener
SUBJECT: Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the Trustees of the California State University (CSU), and requests the Regents of the University of California (UC), to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Title IX
- Provides that, in part, "no person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program of activity receiving Federal financial assistance." Enforcement of compliance is initiated upon the filing of a complaint alleging a violation of Title IX. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the 1964 Civil Rights Act)
- Requires each school district and county office of education, or a local public or private agency that receives funding from the state or federal government, to designate a person to serve as the Title IX compliance coordinator to enforce compliance at the local level, including coordinating any complaints of non-compliance. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the 1964 Civil Rights Act)
- Requires each educational institution in California (K-12 and postsecondary education) to have a written policy on sexual harassment, and requires schools to display the policy in a prominent location in the main administrative building or other area of the campus or schoolsite, be provided as part of any orientation program for new students, provided to each faculty member, administrative staff and support staff, and appear in any publication of the school that sets forth the rules, regulations, procedures and standards of conduct. (Education Code (EC) § 231.5 and § 66281.5)
Appointees and employees
- Requires the Trustees of the CSU to provide for, by rule, for the government of their appointees and employees, including but not limited to: appointment; classification; terms; duties; pay and overtime pay; uniform and equipment allowances; travel expenses and allowances; rates for housing and lodging; moving expenses; leave of absence; tenure; vacation; holidays; layoff; dismissal; demotion; suspension; sick leave; reinstatement; and employer’s contribution to employees’, annuitants’, and survivors’ health benefits plans. (EC § 89500)
- Requires a community college district, prior to making a decision relating to the continued employment of a contract employee, to meet certain requirements including an evaluation of the employee and the governing board’s receipt of recommendations of the superintendent or president of the district or community college. (EC § 87607)
Existing reporting related to campus crime statistics
- Requires, pursuant to the federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act, all higher education institutions that participate in federal student aid programs to prepare, publish, and distribute annual security reports disclosing specified campus crime statistics and campus security policies. Reportable crimes include homicides, sex offenses, robberies, aggravated assaults, domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, and stalking. (Unites States Code, Title 20, § 1092)
- Requires the State Auditor to conduct an audit of a sample of at least six institutions of postsecondary education in California that receive federal student aid to do both of the following:
- Evaluate the accuracy of the institutions’ statistics and the procedures used by the institutions to identify, gather, and track data for publishing, disseminating, and reporting accurate crime statistics in compliance with the requirements of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics; and,
- Evaluate the institutions’ compliance with state law governing crime reporting and the development and implementation of related policies and procedures. (EC § 67382)
- Evaluate the accuracy of the institutions’ statistics and the procedures used by the institutions to identify, gather, and track data for publishing, disseminating, and reporting accurate crime statistics in compliance with the requirements of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics; and,
This bill:
- Requires the governing board of a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
- Prohibits a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, from asking an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district, Trustees, or Regents have determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
- Defines the following terms:
- “Final administrative decision” means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment.
- “Final judicial decision” means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
Comments
Need for the bill. According to the author, “Recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students and faculty across our college campuses. While title IX protections exist to protect our public institutions, bad actors escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. Hiring committees also may not have access to a full scope of complaints at the time of their hiring process. This bill will ensure campuses have access to history of misconduct to ensure they are fully informed when making their hiring decisions to foster an environment of safety and trust across all our state campuses.”
Context. Colleges and universities that receive public funds, or whose students receive federal or state financial aid, must adhere to the requirements of Title IX and follow specific procedures to protect students and employees. Audits conducted by the State Auditor, internal investigations, and news reports have shown long-standing weaknesses in how public postsecondary educational institutions, and individual campuses, prevent sexual harassment and handle Title IX complaints.
Pending State Audit. The State Auditor is currently preparing an audit related to the CSU system’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving executives, faculty, and staff at the Chancellor’s Office and three campuses (Fresno, San Jose, and Sonoma). The scope of the audit will include a determination of whether CSU has adequate systemwide policies and procedures, a review of CSU’s process for investigating alleged sexual harassment, review of systemwide policies on return rights, assessment of policies related to letters of recommendation, and identification of the total number of sexual harassment complaints against employees of the CSU system during the past five years. This audit is expected to be released in June 2023. [https://www.auditor.ca.gov/reports/scope/2022-109]
Prior State Audits. The State Auditor released a report in June 2018 regarding the UC’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving faculty and staff harassers and student victims. This report concludes that “although the university has been aware of issues with its responses to sexual harassment complaints and has taken steps to address them, it must do more to stop, prevent, and remedy sexual harassment at its campuses. Notably, we found that the three campuses we visited—Berkeley, Davis, and Los Angeles—took much longer to discipline faculty in the Academic Senate than they did to discipline staff. On average, the three campuses disciplined staff within 43 days after the conclusion of an investigation compared to 220 days for faculty in the Academic Senate. In addition, the three campuses disciplined faculty inconsistently, especially those faculty who were the subjects of multiple sexual harassment complaints. We also found that the three campuses inconsistently followed Title IX guidance in their informal and formal processes to address sexual harassment complaints. The three campuses frequently exceeded investigation time frames without obtaining approved time extensions and they often did not send all required information to the complainants and respondents. Finally, the university’s Office of the President established a systemwide Title IX office (systemwide office) in February 2017 with a goal to implement a consistent and coordinated response systemwide to complaints of sexual harassment. However, to make the systemwide office more effective, the Office of the President needs to define how much consistency it desires and provide the systemwide office the necessary authority to achieve it. We identified three areas in which the systemwide office should play a central role in the university’s efforts to prevent and respond to sexual harassment: setting policy, analyzing applicable data, and overseeing the campuses. Based on feedback from external entities and internal groups, the university has taken steps to improve its response to complaints of sexual harassment, but our audit found that the university needs to take additional steps to fully resolve the concerns that reviewers have raised.” [https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2017-125.pdf]
The State Auditor released a report in June 2014 regarding the handling of sexual harassment and sexual violence incidents at the state’s public postsecondary institutions. As part of this audit, the State Auditor reviewed the sexual assault policies and procedures at UC Berkeley and UC Los Angeles, CSU Chico, and San Diego State University. The report noted that “staff in key roles of the incident-reporting process receive adequate training on responding to and reporting student incidents of sexual harassment and sexual violence, but other employees including resident advisors and athletic coaches, who may be the first point of contact, do not.” The report also noted that “none of the universities provides its sexual harassment policy to all employees at the start of each academic year, nor do they post the policies in certain places where a large number of students can see them such as in residence halls or athletic facilities.” As part of the report, the State Auditor included several recommendations, including the recommendation for the universities to review and modify educational programs and provide more training and education to both university employees and incoming students, and the recommendation for the universities to properly distribute and post their policy on sexual harassment. [https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2013-124.pdf]
Updated policies of the CSU. The CSU Board of Trustees approved new policies in July 2022, to bolster and clarify employment practices.
- The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing administrator employees’ option to retreat. The policy applies to all administrator appointments made at a CSU campus or the Chancellor’s Office which include the option to retreat to a faculty position. The policy is intended to be prospective and does not impact retreats granted prior to its effective dates except on a case-by-case basis in the event of a serious policy violation.
The opportunity to “retreat” to a faculty position is frequently offered to faculty who are required to relinquish tenure in order to become a university administrator. The opportunity to retreat gives the new administrator the option to return to a faculty position when their administrative role at the university comes to an end. New or continuing administrators often negotiate the opportunity to retreat as a term of their employment as an administrator because university administrators, unlike tenured faculty, are at-will employees who have no assurance of permanent employment.
The new policy includes the following guidance:- An administrator will be ineligible to exercise the option if there is a finding of misconduct or the administrator is under investigation for misconduct.
- Memorialization of terms of the retreat will be placed in the administrative appointment letter.
- There must be consultation with the tenured faculty in the respective department to which the individual would potentially return. [Viewing Employment Policy Governing Administrator Employees' Option to Retreat (policystat.com)]
- An administrator will be ineligible to exercise the option if there is a finding of misconduct or the administrator is under investigation for misconduct.
- The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing the provision of employee references. The Employment Policy Governing the Provision of Employee References outlines the principles and procedures guiding the provision of references. Under the policy, the CSU will not provide positive letters of reference, verbal or written, for any current or former employee who has engaged in significant misconduct that resulted in non-retention, is currently under investigation for misconduct or violation of university policy, or has had their retirement benefits rescinded under the Public Employees' Pension Reform Act due to criminal misconduct associated with their official duties. The policy further provides guidance on references requested by third parties, employment verification for current or former employees, personal references and references within the CSU. [https://calstate.policystat.com/policy/12142918/latest/]
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The UC estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $2.3 million for each campus to dedicate one disclosure analyst position to manage changes to the application processes. The UC also estimates $105,000 in one-time General Fund costs to update its “Recruit Program” which would be needed to track and manage the applicants’ responses.
- The Chancellor’s Office (CCCCO) estimates costs of approximately $2,900 per community college to update existing policies, procedures or memorandums of understanding (MOUs), resulting in statewide costs of up to $332,000. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines this requirement to be a reimbursable state-mandated activity, there would be pressure to increase the mandate block grant for community colleges. The Chancellor’s Office also estimates one-time General Fund costs of about $117,000 to implement Title 5 changes and update existing policies and procedures.
- The CSU indicates there could be additional, unknown administrative costs related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. The CSU typically hires approximately 16,000 employees across the system each year. Further, there could be potentially significant liability costs since the bill requires the “final administrative decisions” to be shared, even though these decisions may be appealed and may not be final.
- Though not explicitly required, this bill could create cost pressure for the segments to investigate the disclosures on applications. It is unknown how many investigations would occur as a result of these disclosures or how many applicants will actually self-report this information, but an investigation could cost up to $30,000. There could also be unknown, potentially significant costs related to liability resulting from potential lawsuits pursued by applicants who disclosed the required information.
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/18/23)
California State University Employees Union
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/18/23)
Stop Abuse for Everyone
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students and faculty across our college campuses. While Title IX protections exist to protect our public institutions, bad actors escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. Hiring committees also may not have access to a full scope of complaints at the time of their hiring process. This bill will ensure campuses have access to history of misconduct to ensure they are fully informed when making their hiring decisions to foster an environment of safety and trust across all our state campuses.
“Opposition alleges that the required disclosure of final administrative decisions in this bill should be removed because the administrative decision finding process at higher education institutions does not provide due process for the accused, but this is simply not the case. Title IX coordinators work with campus officials and system wide specialists to guarantee Title IX policy. They are required to conduct a full investigation into any claims of harassment, and give all parties an opportunity to present their sides. Parties also have the right to appeal final determinations. It is also unrealistic to expect all cases of sexual harassment would go to court as not everyone has the financial means to file a lawsuit, not to mention it is an extremely difficult process for survivors of sexual harassment.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to Stop Abuse for Everyone, “Final decisions based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university are fraught with biases driven by ideological beliefs. Rarely are the due process rights of alleged offenders upheld. Adjudications at the college campus level resulting in
final administrative decisions should never be conflated with final judicial decisions recorded in a judgment or order of a court.”
Prepared by: Lynn Lorber / ED. / (916) 651-4105
5/20/23 13:09:34
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 791 (McGuire) - Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the Trustees of the California State University (CSU), and requests the Regents of the University of California (UC), to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
Fiscal Impact:
- The UC estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $2.3 million for each campus to dedicate one disclosure analyst position to manage changes to the application processes. The UC also estimates $105,000 in one-time General Fund costs to update its “Recruit Program” which would be needed to track and manage the applicants’ responses.
- The Chancellor’s Office (CCCCO) estimates costs of approximately $2,900 per community college to update existing policies, procedures or memorandums of understanding (MOUs), resulting in statewide costs of up to $332,000. To the extent the Commission on State Mandates determines this requirement to be a reimbursable state-mandated activity, there would be pressure to increase the mandate block grant for community colleges. The Chancellor’s Office also estimates one-time General Fund costs of about $117,000 to implement Title 5 changes and update existing policies and procedures.
- The CSU indicates there could be additional, unknown administrative costs related to adding an extra step to each hiring process. The CSU typically hires approximately 16,000 employees across the system each year. Further, there could be potentially significant liability costs since the bill requires the “final administrative decisions” to be shared, even though these decisions may be appealed and may not be final.
- Though not explicitly required, this bill could create cost pressure for the segments to investigate the disclosures on applications. It is unknown how many investigations would occur as a result of these disclosures or how many applicants will actually self-report this information, but an investigation could cost up to $30,000. There could also be unknown, potentially significant costs related to liability resulting from potential lawsuits pursued by applicants who disclosed the required information.
Background:
Federal statutes addressing sexual assault on or around institutions of higher education include Title IX and the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act (Clery Act). The Clery Act requires public and private postsecondary educational institutions that receive federal financial aid to disclose information about crimes on and around campuses as well as establish certain rights for victims of sexual assault. Those rights include notification to victims of the right to file criminal charges, available counseling services, the results of disciplinary proceedings, and the option for victims to change their academic schedule or living arrangements.
Existing law requires each educational institution in California (K-12 and postsecondary education) to have a written policy on sexual harassment, and requires schools to display the policy in a prominent location in the main administrative building or other area of the campus or schoolsite, be provided as part of any orientation program for new students, provided to each faculty member, administrative staff and support staff, and appear in any publication of the school that sets forth the rules, regulations, procedures and standards of conduct.
Existing law requires the Trustees of the CSU to provide for, by rule, for the government of their appointees and employees, including but not limited to: appointment; classification; terms; duties; pay and overtime pay; uniform and equipment allowances; travel expenses and allowances; rates for housing and lodging; moving expenses; leave of absence; tenure; vacation; holidays; layoff; dismissal; demotion; suspension; sick leave; reinstatement; and employer’s contribution to employees’, annuitants’, and survivors’ health benefits plans.
Existing law requires a community college district, prior to making a decision relating to the continued employment of a contract employee, to meet certain requirements including an evaluation of the employee and the governing board’s receipt of recommendations of the superintendent or president of the district or community college.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
This bill prohibits a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, from asking an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district, Trustees, or Regents have determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
This bill defines “final administrative decision” to mean a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment. “Final judicial decision” means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
Related Legislation:
SB 1439 (Block, 2016) was nearly identical to this bill. SB 1439 was vetoed by Governor Brown, whose veto message read:
While I understand the desire to mitigate risk, governing boards-who are the fiduciaries of these institutions-should be responsible for setting hiring standards, including the disclosure of prior bad conduct.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 791 (Author:McGuire)
Version: March 22, 2023
Hearing Date: April 18, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ME
SUBJECT
Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment
DIGEST
This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the trustees of the CSU to require, as part of the hiring process, for an appointment to an academic or administrative position, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment, as specified. The bill requests the UC Regents to require as part of the hiring process, for an appointment to an academic or administrative position, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Committee has noted in several analyses that sexual harassment and abuse are systemic issues across our higher education system. Recent reports again show how despite Title IX and other sexual harassment protections and requirements in the law, perpetrators who have been found guilty of abuse escape consequences by moving from one college to the next.
In 2016, the California State Senate passed a bill nearly identical to this one with a 38 to 1 vote. (SB 1439 (Block, 2016)) Indeed, the author of SB 1439 (Block, 2016) introduced the bill because of reports of sexual harassment at public universities. Professors and instructors could “avoid the consequences of their actions by moving from one university to the next since their history does not follow them.” The author argued that “the information as to their misconduct should be considered when hiring decisions are being made.” SB 1439 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stressed in his veto message that “governing boards-who are the fiduciaries of these institutions-should be responsible for setting hiring standards, including the disclosure of prior bad conduct.”
The problems SB 1439 attempted to address still exist today. The author introduced this bill in response to more reports of sexual harassment occurring at public colleges and universities and the revelations that professors who had been found to have perpetrated sexual harassment at one California State University (CSU) campus were subsequently employed at other CSU campuses. This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the trustees of the CSU to require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment. The bill also requests the UC Regents to require, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the University of California, that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
This bill is author sponsored and supported by the University of California, Davis Associated Students. The bill passed the Senate Education Committee with a 7 to 0 vote.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- States that no person in the U.S. shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program or activity receiving federal financial assistance. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the Civil Rights Act of 1964; 20 U.S.C. § 1681 et seq.)
- Specifies that it is the policy of the State of California, pursuant to education code section 66251 that all persons regardless of their sex should enjoy freedom from discrimination of any kind in the postsecondary educational institution of the state. (Educ. Code § 66281.5.)
- Provides that is the policy of the State of California to afford all persons, regardless of disability, gender, gender identity, gender expression, nationality, race or ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, or any other basis that is contained in the prohibition of hate crimes set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 422.6 of the Penal Code, including immigration status, equal rights and opportunities in the postsecondary educational institutions of the state. (Educ. Code § 66251.)
- Defines sexual harassment as having the same meaning as defined in Section code section 212.5 and specifies that sexual harassment includes sexual battery, sexual violence, and sexual exploitation. (Ed Code § 66262.5.)
- Defines sexual harassment as unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal, visual or physical conduct of a sexual nature, made by someone from or in the work or educational setting, as specified. (Educ. Code § 212.5.)
This bill:
- Requires the governing board of a community college district to require as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with that district that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
- Prohibits a community college district from asking an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in (1) above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
- Requires the trustees of CSU, as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the CSU, to require that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
- Prohibits the CSU from asking an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in (3) above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the CSU has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
- Requests the UC Regents to require as part of the hiring process for an appointment to an academic or administrative position with the University of California that the applicant disclose any final administrative decision or final judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
- Requests the UC to not ask an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision described in (5) above, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the UC has determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
- Defines “final administrative decision” as a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment.
- Defines “final judicial decision” as a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
- Provides that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the above provisions contain costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made, as specified.
COMMENTS
- The continued practice of moving sexual harassers from one college campus to another
There have been recent media revelations about the mishandling of sexual harassment complaints in the CSU system.[1] The Joint Legislative Audit Committee directed the California State Auditor to engage in an audit to “provide independently developed and verified information related to the California State University (CSU) system’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving executives, faculty, and staff at the Chancellor’s Office, Fresno State, San Jose State, and Sonoma State.[2]” The scope of the audit will include a determination of whether CSU has adequate systemwide policies and procedures on sexual harassment, a review of CSU’s process for investigating alleged sexual harassment, a review of systemwide policies on return rights, assessment of policies related to letters of recommendation, and identification of the total number of sexual harassment complaints against employees of the CSU system during the past five years. The audit is expected to be released this summer.
As detailed in an EdSource article, a summary of information by California State University officials detailed how professors who had been found to have committed violations of sexual harassment policies at California State University campuses ended up employed at other CSU campuses.[3]
CSU policy[4] specifies that the “CSU will not provide any official positive letters of recommendation or reference, either verbally or in writing, for a current or former CSU employee who: (i) is subject to a finding that the CSU employee has engaged in misconduct that resulted in the employee being non-retained, terminated, or is separated through mutually agreed upon settlement terms; (ii) is currently under investigation for misconduct or violation of university policy (in abeyance until the completion of the investigation and any appeals); or (iii) has had their retirement benefits rescinded under The Public Employees’ Pension Reform Act due to criminal misconduct associated with their official duties. In such cases, Human Resources/Faculty Affairs shall inform the third party requesting the reference of CSU's employee reference policy and provide an employment verification only, as set forth below, for the current or former CSU employee.”[5]
2. Ensuring full information regarding previous sexual harassment decisions when making hiring decisions at public colleges and universities
In 2016 the California State Senate passed SB 1439 (Block) which was nearly identical to the bill currently before this Committee. SB 1439 was introduced after reports shed light on professors and instructors who avoided the consequences of their sexual harassment by moving from one campus to another without needing to disclose their misconduct. The author wanted the information regarding their sexual harassment to be considered when hiring decisions were made. The bill was vetoed by Governor Brown, yet the problem persists. SB 791 attempts to address public college and university’s continued practice of moving sexual harassers from one campus to another.
According to the author:
Recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students and faculty across our college campuses. While Title IX protections exist to protect our public institutions, bad actors escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. Hiring committees also may not have access to a full scope of complaints at the time of their hiring process. This bill will ensure campuses have access to history of misconduct to ensure they are fully informed when making their hiring decisions to foster an environment of safety and trust across all our state campuses.
Opponents of the bill, Stop Abuse for Everyone, write:
Final decisions based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university are fraught with biases driven by ideological beliefs. Rarely are the due process rights of alleged offenders upheld. Adjudications at the college campus level resulting in final administrative decisions should never be conflated with final judicial decisions recorded in a judgment or order of a court.
The author explains the following in response to opposition:
Opposition alleges that the required disclosure of final administrative decisions in this bill should be removed because the administrative decision finding process at higher education institutions does not provide due process for the accused, but this is simply not the case.
Title IX coordinators work with campus officials and system wide specialists to guarantee Title IX policy. They are required to conduct a full investigation into any claims of harassment, and give all parties an opportunity to present their sides. Parties also have the right to appeal final determinations.
It is also unrealistic to expect all cases of sexual harassment would go to court as not everyone has the financial means to file a lawsuit, not to mention it is an extremely difficult process for survivors of sexual harassment.
Title IX coordinators at our college campuses are tasked with guaranteeing Title IX policy and protecting students and staff. If after a thorough investigation, they determine someone committed sexual harassment, it is appropriate for that finding to be disclosed in an application or an academic or administrative institutions.
SUPPORT
University of California, Davis Associated Students
OPPOSITION
Stop Abuse for Everyone
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 808 (Dodd, 2023) requires the CSU to require each campus president and a vice president or chancellor to approve all sexual harassment settlements. This bill also provides more transparency regarding sexual harassment complaints and the investigative process and requires the posting of specified information on the CSU’s website. The bill also places retreat right prohibitions for any campus president, provost, or other senior administrator who has violated any California State University or campus Title IX policy, as specified. SB 808 is currently pending before this Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1439 (Block, 2016) was nearly identical to this bill and vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message, Governor Brown wrote that while he understood “the desire to mitigate risk, governing boards-who are the fiduciaries of these institutions-should be responsible for setting hiring standards, including the disclosure of prior bad conduct.”
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Education Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
See: “Fresno State president mishandled sexual harassment complaints. Now he leads all 23 Cal State colleges” by Kenny Jacoby, USA Today, Published Feb. 3, 2022 and updated Jan. 25, 2023. Available at Cal State chancellor Joseph Castro mishandled sexual harassment claims (usatoday.com) (as of 4/1/23.]. ↑
For information about the scope of this audit’s scope and objectives see 2022-109 Audit Scope and Objectives, available at: California State Auditor - 2022-109 Audit Scope and Objectives [as of 4/1/23.]. ↑
New batch of CSU records shows professors disciplined for sexual harassment: Records show students suffered sexual advances from professors; EdSource (August 2, 2022) by Thomas Peele, Ashley A. Smith, and Daniel J. Willis; available at: New batch of CSU records shows professors disciplined for sexual harassment | EdSource [as of April 9, 2023]. ↑
California State University Active Policy no. 12142918, Last revised Aug. 3, 2022, adopted July 13, 2022 by Resolution of the California State University Board of Trustees RUFP 07-22-11; Available at: Viewing Employment Policy Governing the Provision of Employee References (policystat.com) [as of April 9, 2023] ↑
A finding includes, but is not limited to,(a) a final internal report, following any appeals, resulting from an investigation conducted by the university; (b) an internal or external audit; (c) an administrative decision by a state body having such jurisdiction, such as the Department of Labor, etc.; (d) a civil or criminal judgment, following any appeals; (e) a finding of improper governmental activity, which is defined by the State of California as any action that violates state or federal law or regulation; that is economically wasteful; or that involves gross misconduct, incompetence, or inefficiency; or (f) admission of any of the above-referenced misconduct by the employee. (Id.) ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Josh Newman, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 791 Hearing Date: April 12, 2023
Author: | |||
Version: | March 22, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Lynn Lorber | ||
Subject: Postsecondary education: academic and administrative employees: disclosure of sexual harassment.
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Judiciary. A “do pass” motion should include referral to the Committee on Judiciary.
SUMMARY
This bill requires the governing board of a community college district and the Trustees of the California State University (CSU), and requests the Regents of the University of California (UC), to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
Title IX
- Provides that, in part, "no person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program of activity receiving Federal financial assistance." Enforcement of compliance is initiated upon the filing of a complaint alleging a violation of Title IX. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the 1964 Civil Rights Act)
- Requires each school district and county office of education, or a local public or private agency that receives funding from the state or federal government, to designate a person to serve as the Title IX compliance coordinator to enforce compliance at the local level, including coordinating any complaints of non-compliance. (Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 to the 1964 Civil Rights Act)
- Requires each educational institution in California (K-12 and postsecondary education) to have a written policy on sexual harassment, and requires schools to display the policy in a prominent location in the main administrative building or other area of the campus or schoolsite, be provided as part of any orientation program for new students, provided to each faculty member, administrative staff and support staff, and appear in any publication of the school that sets forth the rules, regulations, procedures and standards of conduct. (Education Code (EC) § 231.5 and § 66281.5)
Appointees and employees
- Requires the Trustees of the CSU to provide for, by rule, for the government of their appointees and employees, including but not limited to: appointment; classification; terms; duties; pay and overtime pay; uniform and equipment allowances; travel expenses and allowances; rates for housing and lodging; moving expenses; leave of absence; tenure; vacation; holidays; layoff; dismissal; demotion; suspension; sick leave; reinstatement; and employer’s contribution to employees’, annuitants’, and survivors’ health benefits plans. (EC § 89500)
- Requires a community college district, prior to making a decision relating to the continued employment of a contract employee, to meet certain requirements including an evaluation of the employee and the governing board’s receipt of recommendations of the superintendent or president of the district or community college. (EC § 87607)
Existing reporting related to campus crime statistics
- The federal Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act requires all higher education institutions that participate in federal student aid programs to prepare, publish, and distribute annual security reports disclosing specified campus crime statistics and campus security policies. Reportable crimes include homicides, sex offenses, robberies, aggravated assaults, domestic violence, dating violence, sexual assault, and stalking. (Unites States Code, Title 20, § 1092)
- Requires the State Auditor to conduct an audit of a sample of at least six institutions of postsecondary education in California that receive federal student aid to do both of the following:
- Evaluate the accuracy of the institutions’ statistics and the procedures used by the institutions to identify, gather, and track data for publishing, disseminating, and reporting accurate crime statistics in compliance with the requirements of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics; and,
- Evaluate the institutions’ compliance with state law governing crime reporting and the development and implementation of related policies and procedures. (EC § 67382)
- Evaluate the accuracy of the institutions’ statistics and the procedures used by the institutions to identify, gather, and track data for publishing, disseminating, and reporting accurate crime statistics in compliance with the requirements of the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics; and,
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Requires the governing board of a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, to require an application for appointment to an academic or administrative position to disclose any final administrative or judicial decision determining that the applicant committed sexual harassment.
- Prohibits a community college district and the CSU Trustees, and requests the UC Regents, from asking an applicant to disclose, orally or in writing, information concerning any final administrative decision or final judicial decision, including any inquiry about an applicable decision on any employment application, until the community college district, Trustees, or Regents have determined that the applicant meets the minimum employment qualifications stated in the notice issued for the position.
- Defines the following terms:
- “Final administrative decision” means a final determination based on the investigative findings of a Title IX compliance coordinator, or other designated investigator, at a college or university on a complaint of sexual harassment.
- “Final judicial decision” means a final determination of a matter submitted to a court that is recorded in a judgment or order of that court.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Recent reports and news have exposed serious incidents of sexual harassment and misconduct against students and faculty across our college campuses. While title IX protections exist to protect our public institutions, bad actors escape the consequences of their egregious actions by moving from one campus to the next. Hiring committees also may not have access to a full scope of complaints at the time of their hiring process. This bill will ensure campuses have access to history of misconduct to ensure they are fully informed when making their hiring decisions to foster an environment of safety and trust across all our state campuses.”
- Context. Colleges and universities that receive public funds, or whose students receive federal or state financial aid, must adhere to the requirements of Title IX and follow specific procedures to protect students and employees. Audits conducted by the State Auditor, internal investigations, and news reports have shown long-standing weaknesses in how public postsecondary educational institutions, and individual campuses, prevent sexual harassment and handle Title IX complaints. Most notably:
- The most recent Chancellor of CSU, Joseph Castro, was found to have mishandled issues related to a pattern of sexual harassment complaints while serving as President of Fresno State, against a professor who Dr. Castro knew personally. Ultimately, Fresno State reached a settlement agreement with the professor to pay him $260,000 plus full retirement benefits, with a promise of a letter of recommendation for employment at a university other than CSU. Three weeks after the settlement agreement was finalized, Mr. Castro became Chancellor of the CSU system and its 23 campuses. Mr. Castro subsequently resigned in February 2022, and received a $400,000 settlement and has retreat rights to be a tenured professor at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. https://edsource.org/2022/csu-chancellor-joseph-castro-resigns-in-fallout-over-his-handling-of-sexual-misconduct-claims/667865cal
- The Academic Senate and UCLA administration found a range of discrepancies in university offices’ handling of student, faculty and administrative incident reports of discrimination and harassment following a lengthy investigation. The report is authored by the Joint Task Force on Investigatory and Judiciary Processes, which is a committee formed by the Academic Senate and administration to ensure anti-discriminatory investigative conduct at UCLA. The committee was tasked with assessing investigative processes throughout university compliance and non-compliance offices, finding discrepancies in compliance processes and recommending where resources should be allocated for investigations. The investigation was prompted by campuswide dissatisfaction with investigative services, https://dailybruin.com/2023/01/29/ucla-task-force-finds-inadequate-discrimination-harassment-report-systems
- A professor at UC Davis was placed on leave in January 2021, and ultimately terminated, after UC Davis' Title IX office, which handles sexual assault reports, learned of a civil lawsuit filed in relation to a 2018 police report made with the UC Davis Police Department. The lawsuit alleged that the professor, on multiple occasions beginning in 2010, sexually assaulted a high school student who worked in his laboratory as part of a mentorship program. Meanwhile, an outside investigator, at the request of UC Davis’ chancellor, is looking into whether the university handled the sexual assault accusations properly. The university said the external investigation will determine if the sexual assault report was handled properly. https://www.kcra.com/article/uc-davis-professor-ting-guo-sexual-assault-dismissed/42580553
- Riverside City College’s women’s basketball coach alleges she has been harassed by members of the football and men’s basketball team since filing a lawsuit against the college for Title IX discrimination. https://www.latimes.com/sports/story/2023-01-16/riverside-city-college-coach-alicia-berber-title-ix-dispute
- In November 2021, students at the California Maritime Academy confronted campus President Thomas Cropper about Long-standing claims of sexual harassment and misconduct, homophobia, transphobia and racism on campus and during training cruises. Independent investigative reports revealed that cadets were reluctant to make formal complaints about misconduct out of fear of retaliation, and females expressed an understanding that it is not a matter of “if” they will experience sexual harassment or assault, but “when” and “how often.” A report detailed misconduct on two training cruises on the Golden Bear in summer 2021, including sexual harassment, and cited a “more systemic problem that should be carefully assessed.” President Cropper has announced that he plans to retire in August 2023. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-12-13/csu-maritime-academy-women-trans-nonbinary-harassment
- In 2020, a Chico State professor was found to have had a prohibited relationship with a graduate student whom he supervised, yet was allowed to enter a settlement agreement. The professor was subsequently awarded tenure and in 2021, allegedly made threats against two colleagues who cooperated in the investigation in 2020. https://edsource.org/2022/chico-state-professor-disciplined-for-student-affair-allegedly-threatened-colleagues-who-complained/682154
- A different professor at Chico State resigned before he could be disciplined while facing charges of sexual harassment of a student and having a prohibited relationship with a student. The professor was then hired to teach at Cal State East Bay in Hayward. https://edsource.org/2022/new-batch-of-csu-records-show-professors-disciplined-for-sexual-harassment/676217
- Seven violations of the UC Policy on Sexual Violence and Sexual Harassment have been reported at UC Santa Cruz between 2016 and 2019. All of the cases investigated found that a faculty or staff member had violated the Sexual Violence and Sexual Harassment policy, which was updated in 2016. https://www.dailycal.org/2019/02/11/an-institutional-and-pervasive-problem-title-ix-documents-reveal-wave-of-sexual-misconduct-cases-at-uc-santa-cruz
- The most recent Chancellor of CSU, Joseph Castro, was found to have mishandled issues related to a pattern of sexual harassment complaints while serving as President of Fresno State, against a professor who Dr. Castro knew personally. Ultimately, Fresno State reached a settlement agreement with the professor to pay him $260,000 plus full retirement benefits, with a promise of a letter of recommendation for employment at a university other than CSU. Three weeks after the settlement agreement was finalized, Mr. Castro became Chancellor of the CSU system and its 23 campuses. Mr. Castro subsequently resigned in February 2022, and received a $400,000 settlement and has retreat rights to be a tenured professor at Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. https://edsource.org/2022/csu-chancellor-joseph-castro-resigns-in-fallout-over-his-handling-of-sexual-misconduct-claims/667865cal
- Pending State Audit. The State Auditor is currently preparing an audit related to the CSU system’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving executives, faculty, and staff at the Chancellor’s Office and three campuses (Fresno, San Jose, and Sonoma). The scope of the audit will include a determination of whether CSU has adequate systemwide policies and procedures, a review of CSU’s process for investigating alleged sexual harassment, review of systemwide policies on return rights, assessment of policies related to letters of recommendation, and identification of the total number of sexual harassment complaints against employees of the CSU system during the past five years. This audit is expected to be released in June 2023. https://www.auditor.ca.gov/reports/scope/2022-109
- Prior State Audits. The State Auditor released a report in June 2018 regarding the UC’s handling of sexual harassment complaints involving faculty and staff harassers and student victims. This report concludes that “although the university has been aware of issues with its responses to sexual harassment complaints and has taken steps to address them, it must do more to stop, prevent, and remedy sexual harassment at its campuses. Notably, we found that the three campuses we visited—Berkeley, Davis, and Los Angeles—took much longer to discipline faculty in the Academic Senate than they did to discipline staff. On average, the three campuses disciplined staff within 43 days after the conclusion of an investigation
compared to 220 days for faculty in the Academic Senate. In addition, the three campuses disciplined faculty inconsistently, especially those faculty who were the subjects of multiple sexual harassment complaints. We also found that the three campuses inconsistently followed Title IX guidance in their informal and formal processes to address sexual harassment complaints. The three campuses frequently exceeded investigation time frames without obtaining approved time extensions and they often did not send all required information to the complainants and respondents. Finally, the university’s Office of the President established a systemwide Title IX office (systemwide office) in February 2017 with a goal to implement a consistent and coordinated response systemwide to complaints of sexual harassment. However, to make the systemwide office more effective, the Office of the President needs to define how much consistency it desires and provide the systemwide office the necessary authority to achieve it. We identified three areas in which the systemwide office should play a central role in the university’s efforts to prevent and respond to sexual harassment: setting policy, analyzing applicable data, and overseeing the campuses. Based on feedback from external entities and internal groups, the university has taken steps to improve its response to complaints of sexual harassment, but our audit found that the university needs to take additional steps to fully resolve the concerns that reviewers have raised.” https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2017-125.pdf
The State Auditor released a report in June 2014 regarding the handling of sexual harassment and sexual violence incidents at the state’s public postsecondary institutions. As part of this audit, the State Auditor reviewed the sexual assault policies and procedures at UC Berkeley and UC Los Angeles, CSU Chico, and San Diego State University. The report noted that “staff in key roles of the incident-reporting process receive adequate training on responding to and reporting student incidents of sexual harassment and sexual violence, but other employees including resident advisors and athletic coaches, who may be the first point of contact, do not.” The report also noted that “none of the universities provides its sexual harassment policy to all employees at the start of each academic year, nor do they post the policies in certain places where a large number of students can see them such as in residence halls or athletic facilities.” As part of the report, the State Auditor included several recommendations, including the recommendation for the universities to review and modify educational programs and provide more training and education to both university employees and incoming students, and the recommendation for the universities to properly distribute and post their policy on sexual harassment.
https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2013-124.pdf - Updated policies of the CSU. The CSU Board of Trustees approved new policies in July 2022, to bolster and clarify employment practices.
- The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing administrator employees’ option to retreat. The policy applies to all administrator appointments made at a CSU campus or the Chancellor’s Office which include the option to retreat to a faculty position. The policy is intended to be prospective and does not impact retreats granted prior to its effective dates except on a case-by-case basis in the event of a serious policy violation.
The opportunity to “retreat” to a faculty position is frequently offered to faculty who are required to relinquish tenure in order to become a university administrator. The opportunity to retreat gives the new administrator the option to return to a faculty position when their administrative role at the university comes to an end. New or continuing administrators often negotiate the opportunity to retreat as a term of their employment as an administrator because university administrators, unlike tenured faculty, are at-will employees who have no assurance of permanent employment.
The new policy includes the following guidance:- An administrator will be ineligible to exercise the option if there is a finding of misconduct or the administrator is under investigation for misconduct.
- Memorialization of terms of the retreat will be placed in the administrative appointment letter.
- There must be consultation with the tenured faculty in the respective department to which the individual would potentially return. Viewing Employment Policy Governing Administrator Employees' Option to Retreat (policystat.com)
- An administrator will be ineligible to exercise the option if there is a finding of misconduct or the administrator is under investigation for misconduct.
- The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing the provision of employee references. The Employment Policy Governing the Provision of Employee References outlines the principles and procedures guiding the provision of references. Under the policy, the CSU will not provide positive letters of reference, verbal or written, for any current or former employee who has engaged in significant misconduct that resulted in non-retention, is currently under investigation for misconduct or violation of university policy, or has had their retirement benefits rescinded under the Public Employees' Pension Reform Act due to criminal misconduct associated with their official duties. The policy further provides guidance on references requested by third parties, employment verification for current or former employees, personal references and references within the CSU. https://calstate.policystat.com/policy/12142918/latest/
- The CSU now has a systemwide policy governing administrator employees’ option to retreat. The policy applies to all administrator appointments made at a CSU campus or the Chancellor’s Office which include the option to retreat to a faculty position. The policy is intended to be prospective and does not impact retreats granted prior to its effective dates except on a case-by-case basis in the event of a serious policy violation.
- How will it work? While the bill requires an applicant to disclose any previous allegations of sexual harassment that have been substantiated, it does not specify how this would be accomplished. Should a standardized form be created by community college districts and the CSU and UC systems, or could the existing applications for employment be amended to include a disclosure section? Would this be left to the local district or campus discretion?
- Double-referral. The extent or level of detail of the allegations that would have to be disclosed on an application is unclear. It is also unclear if this information would be used solely as a background check for hiring purposes or if it could somehow result in the public release of the information. The bill has been double-referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee, which typically covers, among other policy issues, privacy, confidentiality and consumer protection. The author may wish to consider addressing these issues as the bill moves forward.
- Related legislation.
SB 808 (Dodd, 2023) requires the rules adopted by the CSU Board of Trustees relating to tenure, layoff, dismissal, demotion, suspension, and reinstatement of academic and administrative employees to a) require specific personnel to approve sexual harassment settlements; b) require a report on the number of sexual harassment complaints and disposition of those cases; and, c) prohibit retreat rights for specified personnel who violate CSU or campus Title IX policies. SB 808 is pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 942 (M. Fong, 2023) states legislative intent to amend state law to align with the impending updates to federal regulations relative to Title IX. AB 942 is pending in the Assembly Higher Education Committee. - Prior legislation.
SB 1439 (Block, 2016) was nearly identical to this bill. SB 1439 was vetoed by Governor Brown, whose veto message read:
While I understand the desire to mitigate risk, governing boards-who are the fiduciaries of these institutions-should be responsible for setting hiring standards, including the disclosure of prior bad conduct.
SUPPORT
None received
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Education
Senate Budget and Fiscal Review Subcommittee No. 1 on Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):